Game Detail
Players
Alice (Butler) Bob (Slayer) Charlie (Imp) David (Librarian) Eve (Poisoner) Frank (Virgin) Grace (Empath) Heidi (Monk)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 1,165,251 | 598,509 | $0.5323 |
| Evil | 378,220 | 35,704 | $1.1617 |
Event Transcript
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
You are the Minion. The Demon is Charlie.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Minions are: Eve. Your safe bluffs are: Chef, Drunk, Ravenkeeper
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
🎯
Eve
Eve made a choice.
🧠
Night zero poison should hit a likely information role, ideally near Charlie, to muddy early deductions and keep suspicion off the Demon.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
You chose to poison Bob.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Librarian. Either Alice or Grace is the Butler.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Empath. You sense that 0 of your neighbors is evil!
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Alice
Alice made a choice.
🧠
Night 0 choice locks Day 1 voting. Pick active neighbor Bob to maximize my voting chance tomorrow, nullifying ability drawback early while staying flexible for info gathering.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
You chose Bob to be your master.
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Charlie
Hey Alice and Charlie, I'm Bob, right between you two. Great to meet. What roles do you have? Any starting info? Let's figure out who to nominate first.
🧠
Day 1 start, no info. Whisper neighbors to form quick alliance, share thoughts privately before nominations. Helps coordinate good team without revealing to evil.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
,Heidi
Hey Frank and Heidi, I'm the Empath. Last night I sensed zero evil neighbors, so you both are good. Demon is elsewhere. Let's work together and share what we know.
🧠
Whisper my true info to neighbors to form a trusted good alliance quickly on Day 1. They are mechanically good, so proxy info through them and narrow Demon suspects.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Eve
Hello neighbors. I am David, the Librarian. I start knowing that either Alice or Grace is the Butler. Exactly one of them is that Outsider. What do you know?
🧠
Day 1 start, share my Librarian info privately with neighbors to build trust, gather responses, and start info exchange before nominations. Helps good team by providing mechanical info early.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Charlie
Hey Bob and Charlie, good to meet you too. I am the Butler, an Outsider. Last night I picked you Bob as my master, so today I can only vote if you are. No starting info from me. What roles do you two have? Any info?
🧠
Respond to Bob's whisper, share my role to foster good team alliance with neighbors. My ability ties to Bob, so align early for voting power.
👤
Eve
→
David
,Charlie
Hi David. I can share mine: I am the Washerwoman, and I was told that either Bob or Heidi is the Empath. Your Butler info is interesting; I am happy to compare notes later once those two speak up.
🧠
Answer David with a plausible early-info role to build trust, create claim cross-pressure, and keep attention off Charlie while we evaluate which outsider frame is easiest.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Alice
Hi both. I am the Chef. I got zero, so no adjacent pair of evil players. Alice, your Butler claim is interesting. Have either of you heard anything from David or anyone else yet?
🧠
Build credibility early by matching a plausible Chef 0, encourage town to look elsewhere, and keep Bob and David from suspecting me or Eve.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
,Heidi
Thanks Grace, good to hear. I am the Virgin. You and Heidi both good makes sense. Let's stick together and figure out who the demon is. What is your plan?
🧠
Respond to Grace's claim outing us as good. Share Virgin role (powerful early) to solidify alliance, gather more info before nominations. Virgin safe to claim day 1.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
,Frank
Grace, there was no last night; it's Day 1, so no Empath info yet. What did you mean? Frank, glad you're Virgin. I'm the Monk and can protect someone tonight. Let's figure out the demon together.
🧠
Grace's 'last night' Empath claim impossible on Day 1 (no N0 info). Question tests her; share Monk to build real good block if truthful, expose evil otherwise.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Charlie
Thanks for sharing, guys. I am the Slayer, so once per game I can publicly shoot someone if they are the Demon. Charlie, what did David whisper to you and Eve? Any info from them? Alice, thanks for picking me as Butler master.
🧠
Neighbors shared first, reciprocate with Slayer role to build trust trio. Chef 0 valuable, get David info from Charlie before nomination to narrow suspects.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
,Heidi
Heidi, there was Night 0 info for Empath - I learned 0 evil neighbors then, so you and Frank are both good. Frank, great you're Virgin. Heidi, awesome Monk. Let's ally as confirmed goods. Who do you suspect? I see Bob cliquing with Alice/Charlie.
🧠
Clarify Night 0 was real Empath info (0 evil neighbors) to Heidi's confusion, confirm alliance with Frank/Heidi as good trio. Share plans before nomination.
👤
David
→
Alice
,Grace
Hi Alice and Grace. I am the Librarian. My starting info is that exactly one of you is the Butler. What roles do you have? Let's share what we know.
🧠
Directly sharing my exact info with Alice/Grace gets their claims/reactions early. Consistent good claims build alliances; lies expose evil. Progresses info sharing on Day 1.
👤
Alice
→
David
,Grace
Hi David and Grace. David, you are right, I am the Butler. So Grace, you are not the Butler. What is your role? Charlie told us he is Chef with zero evil pairs adjacent, and Bob claims to be the Slayer.
🧠
David whispered me+Grace with info matching my Butler role. Confirm to him, get Grace's claim, share Chef/Bob info to align goods early day 1 before noms, build info network.
👤
Eve
→
Charlie
Quick sync: David is claiming Librarian, got Alice or Grace is Butler. I am sticking with Washerwoman bluff, Bob or Heidi is Empath. I poisoned Bob night zero, so if he claims info it will be off. Let me know your bluff so we do not clash.
🧠
Coordinate with Charlie to align bluffs and exploit Bob's poison. Reinforce David's Librarian claim publicly later to anchor town on a likely wrong Outsider world.
👤
Charlie
→
Eve
I am sticking with Chef bluff, got zero adjacent evil, which fits our seating. Bob is claiming Slayer and is asking what David said. I will say David claimed Librarian and saw Alice or Grace is Butler. We can push heat onto Grace for a Butler double claim angle. Who do you want dead tonight, David or Bob?
🧠
Sync with Eve on bluffs and a day one push. Keep my Chef claim consistent, use Butler conflict to steer town toward executing a good player and protect us.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
,Heidi
Agreed, Grace, your Empath info confirms us good. Heidi Monk great. Bob Alice Charlie whispering clique screams evil. Charlie also with Eve David. Let's nominate Bob first to test them.
🧠
Strengthen confirmed good trio (Empath verified). Agree on suspects (Bob clique) to coordinate nominations. Progress to execution phase by targeting suspicious group, narrow Demon suspects.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
,Frank
Agreed, Frank. The Bob/Alice/Charlie clique is super suspicious with all their whispers. Let's nominate Bob first to test them. Grace, what did David say when he whispered to you and Alice?
🧠
Confirmed good trio (Empath/Virgin/Monk). Push nomination on most suspicious Bob to test clique and start eliminating evil suspects early.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Charlie
Hey guys, any updates? Charlie, what did David and Eve say in whispers? Alice, David whispered to you too? Let's share what we hear and maybe go public with our roles soon.
🧠
Strengthen neighbor alliance with Alice/Charlie (Chef/Butler claims consistent). Probe for info from other whispers to map suspicions early Day 1, narrow evil locations before nominations.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
,Heidi
Frank and Heidi, David whispered he's Librarian, one of Alice or me is Butler. Alice confirmed she is Butler, so David checks out as good. Charlie claims Chef zero evil pairs, Bob Slayer. But their clique is sus. Let's nominate Bob to test them.
🧠
Update alliance on David/Alcice info to confirm more goods. Coordinate nominating suspicious Bob to progress Day 1 execution and narrow evil.
👤
David
→
Alice
,Grace
Grace, what is your role? Alice claims to be the Butler, which matches my Librarian info perfectly since exactly one of you is. Also, Alice mentioned Charlie is Chef with zero evil pairs and Bob is Slayer. Does that sound right to you? Let's align.
🧠
Alice claims Butler fitting my info; need Grace's role to verify and build good alliance. Comment on Chef claim to cross-check info and progress Day 1 info sharing before nomination.
👤
Alice
→
David
,Grace
David, yes Alice Butler matches your info perfectly. Grace, what is your role? No startinginfo from me beyond that. Charlie is Chef zero evil pairs, so no adjacent evils. Bob claims Slayer. Heard from anyone else? Let's align before nominating.
🧠
Respond to David's whisper, confirm alignment, press Grace for role to verify David and build info chain before nomination. Share with our group to connect info.
👤
Eve
→
Charlie
I think we kill Bob tonight. Even if he is bluffing Slayer, he is loud and could rally votes. I will poison David tonight to muddy his Librarian trail and keep town unsure about Outsider count.
🧠
Coordinate with Charlie to remove Slayer threat and plan next poison target (David) to disrupt town info chain.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Alice
Yeah, quick update: David told me and Eve he is the Librarian and that either Alice or Grace is the Butler. Eve said she is Washerwoman and got that either you Bob or Heidi is the Empath. That puts some pressure on the Alice versus Grace Butler thing.
🧠
Feed Bob a consistent summary, push a Grace Butler double-claim angle, and keep focus off me while setting up mis-executions.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
,Heidi
Agreed Grace, David sounds good with Alice Butler. Charlie Chef 0 pairs but clique sus. Let's nominate Bob first to break them. Heidi, you good to nom him? Any other info?
🧠
Strengthen good trio alliance. Push to nominate Bob as test of sus clique before nomination phase. Gather more on David/Alice whispers.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
,Frank
Yes Frank, I'm good to nominate Bob. His clique with Alice and Charlie is way too tight. Grace, thanks on David - Alice Butler clears him. Eve seems quiet but sus with Charlie whispers. Frank or Grace, will one of you nominate Bob next phase?
🧠
Alliance solid via mechanical info (Empath N0). Clique sus, nom Bob Day1 tests them without risking confirmed goods. Progress to execution info.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
⚖️
Alice
→
Frank
Claims from our group: I'm Butler Out, Bob Slayer TF, Charlie Chef TF with zero adjacent evil pairs, David Lib TF confirming me Butler not Grace, Eve WW TF with Bob/Heidi one Empath so Heidi Empath. That leaves Frank Grace Heidi as last Townsfolk, Minion, Demon. Chef zero means no adj evils, so Frank and Heidi evil (not adj), Grace good Townsfolk. Let's execute Frank.
🧠
Claims consistent, account for all but 1TF+2evils in FGH. Chef 0 pins evils on non-adj Frank&Heidi. Day1 nominate Frank for info/execution to progress good win.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Alice
→
All
Everyone, quick recap: Charlie's Chef zero means no adjacent evil pairs. With claims confirming me Butler, Grace good, Heidi Empath, that leaves Frank as evil. Vote yes on Frank to execute him!
🧠
Voting for Frank in progress, need 4 votes. Publicly rally support with logic recap to ensure execution of suspicious Frank, narrowing evils. Last tick before night.
💬
Frank
→
All
Everyone, I am the Virgin Townsfolk. Alice nominated me, but she was not executed, confirming she is not Townsfolk, which fits her Butler claim or means she is evil. Her logic fails because Grace is the real Empath from Night 0 clearing me and Heidi as good, while Eve claims Heidi Empath - contradiction. Bob Alice Charlie clique is sus. Vote no on me!
🧠
Publicly claim Virgin to confirm good TF, note Alice not TF (Butler or evil), expose claim conflicts (2 Empaths), sway votes no on me to survive Day 1 and nom sus clique later.
💬
Grace
→
All
Everyone, I am the Empath. Night zero I sensed zero evil neighbors, so Frank and Heidi are both good. Eve claiming Heidi Empath is false, and Alice's Chef logic wrongly concludes Frank evil. Frank's Virgin point proves Alice is not Townsfolk. Vote no on Frank!
🧠
Publicly claim Empath & share N0 info to directly contradict Alice/Eve, prove Frank good, rally no votes, expose contradictions in clique claims to progress info vs evils.
💬
Eve
→
All
I do not think we should rush this. Frank being Virgin does not prove Alice is evil since she could be an Outsider, and we have an Empath contradiction between Grace and the Washerwoman info I got. I am not confident Frank is the right kill today.
🧠
Stop an easy D1 execution that could unify town; amplify contradictions (Empath vs WW, Virgin interaction) to keep town divided and protect Charlie.
💬
David
→
All
Everyone, Grace's Empath info shows zero evil neighbors, clearing Frank and Heidi as good. That contradicts Alice assuming Heidi evil. My Librarian confirms one of Alice or Grace is Butler; Alice claims it. Eve's Washer contradicts Grace on Empath. Too risky for day one execution. Vote no on Frank!
🧠
Publicly note Grace clearing Frank/Heidi, Alice logic contradiction, Eve/Grace Empath conflict. Urge no vote on Frank day 1 to avoid killing good, gather more info night 1.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am not voting this. We have a direct Empath contradiction, and the Butler confirmation is not as clean as Alice is saying. I would rather take another day to sort Grace versus Heidi and check what the Undertaker shows tomorrow before we execute.
🧠
Stop a D1 execution and amplify uncertainty between Grace, Eve, and Alice so town fractures and we get a safe night kill.
💬
Bob
→
All
Everyone, hold off on voting yes for Frank. Grace claims Empath zero evil neighbors, clearing Frank and Heidi good. Eve's Washerwoman says one of me or Heidi is Empath, and I'm Slayer so Heidi is, meaning Grace is lying about her role. That makes Grace suspicious, not Frank. David said one of Alice or Grace is Butler, not confirming Alice specifically. Let's not rush a day one execution.
🧠
Day 1 execution risky with Empath contradiction (Grace vs Eve/Heidi). Grace likely lying, sus but not Frank. Prevent good death, gather Undertaker info tomorrow. As Slayer revealed, speak publicly to progress logic.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Everyone, I am the Monk Townsfolk. Eve claims Washerwoman with one of Bob or me as Empath, but I am Monk, not Empath, so Eve is lying. Grace is the real Empath, Frank and I are both good. Vote no on Frank!
🧠
Reveal true role Monk to debunk Eve's claim, confirm Grace Empath/Frank good, rally no votes on Frank. Expose Eve lie, build good alliance, avoid Day 1 good death.
💬
Alice
→
All
Everyone, Grace cannot be the Empath. If she were truthful with zero evil neighbors, then Frank Virgin, Heidi Monk, David Librarian, Charlie Chef, Bob Slayer, and Grace Empath are all six good Townsfolk, plus my Butler Outsider makes seven good players. But there are only six good total. Impossible, so Grace is lying and evil. Vote no on Frank!
🧠
Expose logical impossibility of Grace's claim to prove her evil publicly. Prevent mis-executing Frank (likely good), build case against Grace for tomorrow. Aligns with Bob's suspicion of Grace.
💬
Frank
→
All
Alice, David said one of you or Grace is Butler, not confirming you specifically. If Grace is the Butler, she's not Empath Townsfolk and your count drops to six good. Eve's Washerwoman claim is fully contradicted since Heidi is Monk, not Empath. Vote no on me so we can nominate Bob next.
🧠
Counter Alice's impossible 7-good count: David didn't confirm her Butler specifically; if Grace is, count fixes. Eve WW contradicted. Rally no votes, survive day1 to nom/test sus Bob clique tomorrow.
💬
Grace
→
All
Alice, your count of too many Townsfolk assumes Bob, Charlie, Eve, and others are all real Townsfolk claims, but your sus clique with Bob and Charlie likely hides the lies or Demon. I am the real Empath Townsfolk, Frank and Heidi both good from night zero. Vote no on Frank, then let's nominate Bob to test that clique.
🧠
Counter Alice's impossible count by pointing to clique lies causing extra TF claims. Confirm Frank/Heidi good via my reliable N0 info. Prevent day1 bad exec, build alliance to nom Bob next tick for win.
💬
Eve
→
All
I am not putting my hand up here. We have three direct contradictions on the table, so executing Frank today just locks us into a bad guess. I would rather spend the rest of the day comparing Grace and Heidi, and ask David exactly what his Librarian saw.
🧠
Discourage a D1 execution that could give town mechanical clarity; keep focus on contradictions and delay until we can poison/kill info sources.
💬
David
→
All
Eve asked, so to clarify: my Librarian info is exactly one of Alice or Grace is the Butler, I do not know which one. Alice, your logic calls Heidi Empath good from Eve's Washer but then says Heidi evil from Chef - that is a contradiction. Grace's Empath clears Frank and Heidi. No vote on Frank today.
🧠
Clarify my exact info publicly since Eve asked, expose Alice logic flaw to discredit her, reinforce no on Frank to avoid day1 misexec and build logic for later noms.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
Do not contribute votes to a likely good execution; maintain my earlier stance to look consistent while letting town argue contradictions into next day.
💬
Bob
→
All
Everyone, Alice is right that Grace cannot be the real Empath Townsfolk, because that plus the other claims and her as Butler would be seven good players, which is impossible. Grace is lying. But we still should not execute Frank on day one with all these contradictions. Vote no on Frank, then nominate Grace.
🧠
Prevent day 1 misexec of likely good Frank. Highlight Grace lie proven by overcount, urge no vote on Frank, setup nom Grace or Alice later to narrow suspects.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Alice, your seven goods logic assumes Eve's Washerwoman and Charlie's Chef are true Townsfolk claims, but Eve lied saying I'm Empath when I'm Monk, and Charlie's zero evil pairs hides the adjacent evils in your tight clique with Bob. Grace is the real Empath. Vote no on Frank!
🧠
Counter Alice's '7 goods impossible' by showing her assumed claims (Eve WW, Charlie Chef) are lies, preserving Grace Empath as true. Rally no votes on good Frank to test sus clique next nom.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Frank did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Frank did not receive enough votes (0/4).
💬
Alice
→
All
Everyone, David's Librarian is exact one Butler between me and Grace. Since I am the Butler, that confirms it mechanically. Grace claiming Empath Townsfolk leads to seven good players which is impossible. She is lying and evil. Someone nominate Grace now before night!
🧠
Reinforce Grace impossible good Empath TF (7 goods). David's exact 1 Butler A/G + my claim mechanically confirms me. Urge nominate Grace before night to test.
⚖️
Frank
→
Bob
Bob is in the suspicious Alice-Bob-Charlie clique with tight private whispers and claims that contradict like Eve's false Washerwoman (I'm not Empath, Heidi is Monk) and Charlie's Chef zero ignoring adjacencies. Grace's real Empath clears Frank and Heidi good. My Virgin ability proved Alice is not Townsfolk. Let's execute Bob to test his Slayer claim and break the clique.
🧠
1 tick left pre-night. Pre-planned w/ Grace/Heidi to nom Bob testing sus clique (tight whispers, flawed logic ignoring contradictions). Virgin saved me; focus evil group to narrow Demon suspects.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Alice
→
All
Everyone, vote no on Bob. Grace's Empath claim is impossible because it makes seven good players with the other claims: Frank Virgin, Heidi Monk, David Librarian, Charlie Chef, Bob Slayer, Grace Empath Townsfolk, plus my confirmed Butler Outsider. She is lying and evil. No on Bob, nominate Grace now!
🧠
Bob good (Slayer claim, my master, agrees on Grace impossible). Grace claim mechanically impossible (7 goods). Urge no vote Bob (clique attack), push nominate Grace before night to test her lie and progress to her execution.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Voting yes on my nomination of Bob pressures the suspicious Alice-Bob-Charlie clique with contradictions (Eve false WW, Chef 0 ignoring pairs). Grace Empath clears neighbors good. D1 heavy info; exec tests claims or passes safely to N1 info.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Voting yes on Bob supports good neighbor Frank's nom of sus clique member (tight whispers, false Eve WW). Day 1 execution tests claims/breaks evil trio; aligns with plan to nom Bob.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Push through a Bob execution to remove a potential Slayer and burn town’s day one, keeping suspicion away from Charlie and maintaining confusion.
💬
David
→
All
Everyone, Grace claimed Empath Townsfolk, but the Butler knows they are an Outsider. She can't be Butler. My Librarian says exactly one of Alice or Grace is, so Alice is the real Butler, good. Her Empath claim plus the others makes seven goods, which is impossible. Grace is lying and evil. Vote no on Bob!
🧠
Mechanically proves Alice good Butler via Lib + Grace TF claim. Exposes Grace evil via impossible good count. Vote no Bob to avoid day1 mistake, focus on Grace next.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Get an early mis-execution through at 4 votes, shrinking town and locking in a messy narrative that keeps me safe into Night 1.
💬
Bob
→
All
Everyone, vote no on me please! I am the real Slayer Townsfolk. Grace's Empath claim is impossible, it makes seven good players with Alice's confirmed Butler and the rest. Charlie, why vote yes on me after your Chef claim? Let's not lose a good player day one.
🧠
Prevent my execution as good Slayer on day 1. Highlight Grace's claim impossibility again, question Charlie's betrayal vote to sway Alice/David/Heidi/Eve to no or hesitate, buy time for night info.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Bob highly suspicious in contradicting clique; 4 yes-votes already but I confirm to execute, break clique day 1, gain alignment info via death (Undertaker will check). Allies Frank/Grace voting yes.
💬
Alice
→
All
David and Bob, hold your no votes! Grace's Empath claim is impossible with seven goods including my confirmed Butler. She is evil lying. Charlie, why vote yes on Bob after your Chef claim clears adjacencies? Vote no on Bob, we need him alive!
🧠
Bob likely good Slayer TF. Grace mechanically lying evil. Urge no vote on Bob to save good player day 1, build case vs Grace for later nom.
💬
Frank
→
All
Alice, your seven good players logic assumes all other Townsfolk claims are true, but Eve already lied about Washerwoman since Heidi is Monk not Empath. Charlie's zero evil pairs claim is suspicious for your adjacent Alice-Bob-Charlie clique. Grace's Empath clears me and Heidi. Vote yes on Bob!
🧠
Speak to debunk Alice's '7 goods' argument (ignores Eve lie), rally yes votes on Bob (already 5), execute suspicious Slayer in evil-ish clique D1 to gain info/break strategy.
💬
Grace
→
All
Alice, your seven goods logic assumes Eve's Washerwoman is true, but she lied saying Heidi is Empath when Heidi is Monk. Not all those Townsfolk claims can be real anyway. My Empath is legit, Frank and Heidi good. Bob's clique is sus, vote yes on him!
🧠
Already 5 yes votes on Bob (me included). Reinforce by debunking Alice's bad math (ignores Eve lie), push exec sus Bob from tight clique to break evil team early.
↩️
Eve
Eve lowered their hand
🧠
I already have enough hands up; retract to reduce chance Bob is executed and keep day one unresolved, protecting Charlie and maintaining confusion.
💬
David
→
All
Charlie, your Chef zero evil pairs means no adjacent evils. Alice is confirmed good Butler adjacent to Bob, so Bob good. Why vote yes on him? That's a contradiction, you are evil! Everyone, vote no on Bob, he is good Slayer. Nominate Grace or Charlie next!
🧠
Expose Charlie's contradiction (Chef0 + Alice good adj Bob => Bob good, but votes yes). Prove Charlie evil. Urge no on Bob (likely good Slayer), save for later. Push nom Grace/Charlie evil next day1.
↩️
Charlie
Charlie lowered their hand
🧠
Retract my vote to avoid executing Bob, reduce heat from David, and keep town focused on Grace/contradictions while I survive as Imp.
💬
Bob
→
All
Heidi and Grace, please lower your hands and vote no on me. Grace's Empath Townsfolk claim plus Bob Slayer, Charlie Chef, David Librarian, Eve Washerwoman, Frank Virgin, and Heidi Monk is seven Townsfolk, which is impossible. She is lying and evil. Charlie's Chef zero evil pairs clears me good next to Alice Butler. Vote no!
🧠
Prevent day 1 execution as valuable Slayer. Reinforce Grace impossible Empath TF logic to sway Heidi/Grace/Frank no vote. Charlie contradiction sways him already lowered. Survive to Day 2 info.
↩️
Heidi
Heidi lowered their hand
🧠
Charlie's yes vote on Bob contradicts his Chef 0 (Alice good adj Bob clears Bob). He's evil. Prevent day 1 exec of good Bob, lower hand for no, nom Charlie next.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Bob did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Bob did not receive enough votes (2/4).
💬
Alice
→
All
David's Librarian mechanically confirms I am the real Butler good. Grace's Empath Townsfolk claim makes seven Townsfolk impossible. She is lying evil. Bob, David, Eve, Heidi: one of you nominate Grace right now before night! We must execute her.
🧠
1 tick left Day 1 nom phase. Grace claim mechanically impossible per TF count + Lib confirm. Urge others (Bob/David/Eve/Heidi) to nominate her now or lose to night kill.
💬
Frank
→
All
Alice and David are right. David's Librarian proves Alice is the good Butler since Grace claims Townsfolk Empath. That plus the other claims is too many Townsfolk otherwise. Grace is lying and evil. Someone nominate her now before night! We vote yes.
🧠
Logic proves Grace lying evil: can't be Butler (TF claim), so Alice good Butler; 6 TF claims otherwise impossible. Urge nom/execute Grace before night to remove evil early.
⚖️
Grace
→
Charlie
Charlie is in the tight Alice-Bob-Charlie clique with suspicious whispers. His Chef zero evil pairs claim conveniently ignores adjacent evils there. With seven Townsfolk claims impossible, one liar is evil. He voted oddly on Bob. Vote yes to test him before night!
🧠
1 tick left day1. Nom sus Charlie (clique, Chef hides adj evil?, odd Bob vote) to test before night. Too many TF claims means evil liar in group; progress by executing sus.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Alice
→
All
Vote no on Charlie! He is good. My neighbor Bob is cleared good by his Chef zero evil pairs since we are adjacent. David's Librarian confirms I am the real good Butler, so Grace's Empath Townsfolk claim makes seven Townsfolk claims which is impossible. Grace is lying and evil. Vote no and nominate her tomorrow!
🧠
Charlie cleared good by Chef+my adj Bob. Grace mechanical TF lie evil. Urge vote NO on Charlie to save good player, push Grace exec next day before night1 info loss.
💬
Frank
→
All
Vote no on Charlie! Grace is the obvious liar - David's Librarian proves Alice is the real good Butler, so Grace can't be Empath Townsfolk. That's too many Townsfolk claims. Charlie's Chef claim fits, he's good. We nominate Grace tomorrow!
🧠
Charlie likely good per majority logic, Grace confirmed liar evil by Lib+claim count. Vote no to save him, end day alive with info, target Grace D2. Rally no votes before night.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Charlie sus clique member per good Frank. I nommed him; raise to vote yes, aim for 4 votes execution before night. Reveals info if survives.
💬
Eve
→
All
I am not voting on Charlie. The only hard mechanical point we have is the Townsfolk count problem, and that points at Grace being the liar, not Charlie. If we execute today, it should be Grace tomorrow, not Charlie now.
🧠
Keep my Demon alive by discouraging votes on Charlie and redirecting suspicion toward Grace as the mechanically impossible extra Townsfolk claim.
💬
David
→
All
Vote no on Charlie, he is good! Grace is the liar - her Empath Townsfolk claim plus Bob Slayer, Charlie Chef, me Librarian, Eve Washerwoman, Frank Virgin, Heidi Monk is seven Townsfolk, impossible. Alice is the good Butler. I nominate Grace!
🧠
Grace most mechanically sus per TF overcount her claim causes. Group consensus (Alice/Frank/Eve/Bob/me prior) on her evil. Nominate her now before night to enable execution vote.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Please vote no on me. The only solid mechanical thing today is the seven Townsfolk problem, and that points at Grace, not me. If you want a safe execute tomorrow, do Grace, but do not spend day one killing me on vibes.
🧠
Stay off the block by reinforcing the Townsfolk count argument against Grace and highlighting that executing me now is low value; push vote no and set up Grace as tomorrow's target.
💬
Bob
→
All
Vote no on Charlie, everyone! Grace's Empath claim makes seven Townsfolk which is impossible. David confirms Alice is the good Butler. Charlie's Chef clears my neighbor Alice and me. Grace is the liar and evil. We nominate her tomorrow!
🧠
Speak to rally no votes on Charlie (likely good per Chef+adj Alice), highlight Grace as liar evil via TF overflow. Prevent bad D1 exec, set up Grace for D2 execution. As Slayer, save shot unless certain.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Vote no on Charlie, everyone! Grace's Empath Townsfolk claim makes seven Townsfolk which is impossible with David's Librarian confirming Alice as the good Butler. She is the liar and evil. We nominate and execute her tomorrow!
🧠
Grace creates 7 TF contradiction, strongest lie. Charlie Chef 0 consistent with goods. Vote no on Charlie, push Grace tomorrow. As last tick, speak to sway votes no.
💬
Alice
→
All
Everyone, vote no on Charlie! David's Librarian and the seven Townsfolk count prove Grace is the lying evil. Charlie's Chef clears him and Bob good. We nominate and execute Grace tomorrow. Do not waste day one!
🧠
Push vote no on good Charlie. Grace is proven liar evil via town count + Lib. With 1 tick left, reinforce to save day1, nom Grace day2 to test.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
Voting only Grace yes (1<4), Charlie safe. Wait for close, avoid wasting tick speaking repeat info. Ensures no accidental exec, sets up Grace nom D2 to execute evil.
↩️
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
🧠
Lower hand as only yes voter; Charlie unlikely executed day1 safely. Prevents 'stubborn evil' narrative. Reveals neighbor clears tomorrow to mechanically prove good, redirects sus to David/Alice/Bob clique.
💬
Eve
→
All
Please do not vote on Charlie. The only real mechanical issue today is the too many Townsfolk problem, and that points at Grace, not him. I would rather go to night and come back tomorrow with cleaner info than gamble on this.
🧠
Keep the Demon (Charlie) off the block and redirect suspicion onto Grace or toward no-execution, preserving evil win path.
💬
David
→
All
I nominate Grace. As the real Librarian, exactly one of Alice or Grace is the Butler Outsider. Grace claims Townsfolk Empath, but that plus Bob Slayer, Charlie Chef, my Librarian, Eve Washerwoman, Frank Virgin, Heidi Monk is seven Townsfolk, which is impossible. Alice is the good Butler, Grace is lying evil. Vote yes on her tomorrow!
🧠
Nominate Grace to test her impossible Empath TF claim vs my Lib info & TF count. Day1 execution unlikely but starts process; reveals more info before night. Vote no implied on Charlie.
💬
Charlie
→
All
If you are unsure, please just do not vote today. Day one executions are usually high risk, and the only real mechanical tension points at Grace versus David, not at me. Let us go to night and come back with fresh info.
🧠
Keep myself off the block and steer the town toward delaying or targeting Grace later, preserving misexecution paths and keeping demon alive.
⚔️
Bob
→
All
I am the Slayer! I shoot Grace!
🧠
Grace mechanically can't be good TF Empath (7 TF impossible). She's evil. Slayer shot safe: kills Demon or wastes safely day1 before night kill. Progresses game hugely.
📜
Storyteller
Nothing happens.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Wait to avoid executing Charlie (cleared by Chef + Lib logic). Low yes votes likely close voting safely. Night 1 as Monk, plan protect high-value good like Frank or David.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Charlie did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Charlie did not receive enough votes (0/4).
💬
Alice
→
All
David is correct. I am the real Butler Outsider. Grace claiming Empath Townsfolk makes seven Townsfolk claims, which is impossible. She is the lying evil. Tomorrow, we nominate and execute Grace!
🧠
Phase ending Day1. Reinforce mechanical proof Grace evil liar via Lib/TF count/Chef. Plan exec tomorrow prevents Demon kill+info. As good Butler, organize town.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
Consensus Grace lying evil unbreakable by logic. Day 1 ending (1 tick left), no new nom possible. Wait for night info; D2 exec Grace per plan maximizes good win.
💬
Grace
→
All
Everyone, the seven Townsfolk count can be explained by a Drunk or Spy claiming Townsfolk. Heidi confirms my Empath is real, and my night zero read shows zero evil neighbors, so she is good. David's Librarian claim is what breaks it if he is lying. Bob's shot did nothing because I am not the Demon. Nominate David tomorrow!
🧠
Defend against TF count with logical alternatives (Drunk/Spy/Baron), affirm mechanical confirmation from Heidi and my info, prove not Demon via shot, redirect suspicion to David to avoid my D2 exec.
⚖️
Eve
→
Grace
I am nominating Grace. The seven Townsfolk claims do not fit the setup unless Grace is lying or heavily compromised, and her push to turn it into a Drunk or Spy story feels like backfilling. I would rather execute Grace than gamble on Charlie or David today.
🧠
Push an execution away from Charlie and onto the player town already suspects, ideally removing a good voice and ending Day 1 cleanly.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Alice
→
All
Everyone, vote yes on Grace right now! David's Librarian proves exactly one Butler between us, so I am the real good one and she is lying evil claiming Townsfolk. The seven claims make sense only if she lies. Bob's shot shows she is not Demon, just Minion. Execute her!
🧠
Grace confirmed lying evil Minion by Lib exact Butler1 + TF overcount. Urge yes votes to execute her now, removing only Minion early. Consensus building, my push seals 4 votes before night.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Grace most suspicious per TF count + Lib contradiction. Day1 exec risky but consensus builds 4 votes possible; exec Minion progresses game hugely, aligns good win.
💬
Grace
→
All
Everyone, please vote no on me! The seven Townsfolk count is explained by a Spy or Drunk among the claimants. Heidi confirms my Empath is real, and my night zero read shows zero evil neighbors, so Frank and Heidi are both good. David's Librarian claim is the lie that breaks it. Do not execute on day one—nominate David tomorrow!
🧠
Urge no vote on me Day1. High risk exec. My Empath info reliable (Heidi confirms, N0 good neighbors). TF count via Spy/Drunk. David most sus lying Lib. Survive to give N1 info.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
A day one execution on Grace likely removes a good info role and preserves Charlie. Voting yes also aligns me with current town momentum, building cover for later.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Consensus from my Lib claim IDs Grace as lying evil (Minion post-shot). Day1 exec of Minion huge advantage; if wrong still 7 alive to recover. Must vote yes to push execution.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Secure a day one mis-execution on a likely good player, gain town cred by following the loud mechanical argument, and keep pressure away from me and Eve.
💬
Bob
→
All
Everyone, vote no on Grace! My Slayer shot proves she is not the Demon. The seven Townsfolk claims can be a Spy or Drunk among them. We will get more information tonight from night actions. Do not execute on day one!
🧠
My Slayer shot proves Grace not Demon. TF count explained by Drunk/Spy without her lying. D1 execution too risky—night gives Empath/Chef updates, death info. Urge vote no to avoid killing good.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Mechanical 7 TF impossibility + Lib info point to Grace lying evil Minion. Day 1 exec safe, removes threat, confirms board tomorrow.
💬
Alice
→
All
Everyone, stop! We have solid worlds where either Grace or David is the lying evil. Grace's Empath zero evil neighbors confirmed by Heidi, Bob's Slayer shot proves not Demon. Do not execute day one—vote no, get night information, and execute the real liar tomorrow!
🧠
Equal logic for Grace or David evil. Day1 exec risks killing good player (World 2). Bob good Slayer shot not Demon. Need night info (Empath N1, etc.). Urge no vote, nom sus tomorrow to narrow Demon suspects.
↩️
Frank
Frank lowered their hand
🧠
Lower hand to vote no on Grace D1. Consensus shifting no-exec (Alice/Bob), Bob shot proves not Demon. Risky D1 Minion exec leaves Demon; night info distinguishes Grace vs David for confident D2 exec.
💬
Grace
→
All
Heidi, you are my neighbor and my night zero Empath read shows zero evil neighbors, so you and Frank are both good. Please lower your hand—you confirmed my role earlier! Charlie, you said do not vote today, so please lower too. David's fake Librarian is the contradiction. Vote no, get night info, nominate him tomorrow!
🧠
Already 4 yes votes (Eve/David/Charlie/Heidi). Speak to Heidi (good neighbor) and Charlie (who said no vote) to lower hands. Avoid day1 death for night info as Empath. Progress to nominate David tomorrow.
💬
Eve
→
All
I still think we should execute Grace today. The Townsfolk count problem centers on her Empath claim, and her explanation keeps changing. If you already have your hand up, I would keep it up and let us go to night.
🧠
Keep votes on Grace to secure a day one good execution, protect Charlie, and end the day before town can re-evaluate and pivot onto the Demon.
💬
David
→
All
Bob's Slayer shot proves Grace is not the Demon but a lying Minion. My Librarian pins her as fake Townsfolk claim causing 7 Townsfolk impossible. Alice is good Butler. We have four votes—do not lower your hands! Execute Grace now and win big!
🧠
Grace mechanically proven Minion via Lib+TF count+shot. 4 votes likely (Eve/David/Charlie/Heidi up), urge no lowers to execute day1, major good win.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I know I said day one executions are risky, but this is a clean mechanical fork. I am fine executing Grace to resolve it, then we can reassess tomorrow with night info. If you already have your hand up, I would keep it up.
🧠
Keep the execution on Grace to remove a good player and maintain confusion, while framing it as resolving the mechanical contradiction.
💬
Bob
→
All
Everyone with your hand up, please lower it now. It is day one and we need night information to sort this out properly. My Slayer shot already proved Grace is not the Demon, and a Spy or Drunk explains the Townsfolk count. Let us get more info tonight and execute tomorrow.
🧠
4 votes up but day1 too risky without Demon proof. Urge lower hands for night info (Empath read, Monk protect, Demon kill) to confirm Grace vs David evil safely.
↩️
Heidi
Heidi lowered their hand
🧠
4-4 tie likely no exec (need >4 yes). Day1 w/ Slayer used & Grace/David fork unresolved. Lower to vote no, get night info (my Monk protect, Grace Empath, etc.) to narrow evils safely.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Grace did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (3/4).
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
World A likely: Lib precisely confirmed my role, Grace fake TF Minion. Day1 no exec good for night info (Empath, Monk safe etc). 1 tick left, wait to night no disruption.
💬
Frank
→
All
Grace's night zero Empath read on me and Heidi was correct - I am Virgin Townsfolk. David's Librarian claim doesn't contradict her if Alice is Butler, but he insists 7 Townsfolk is impossible when Spy or Drunk explains it. Charlie or Heidi, please nominate David now before night!
🧠
Grace vote failed 3/4. With 1 tick left, urge Charlie/Heidi/Bob to nom David to test fork & progress before night. Confirm my Virgin claim matching Grace read to build good block.
💬
Grace
→
All
Charlie and Heidi, you can still nominate—please nominate David right now before night! His Librarian claim is the only contradiction; Spy or Drunk explains the Townsfolk count. Frank and Heidi confirm my Empath read. We need to test him!
🧠
1 tick left before night. I can't nom again. Urge Charlie/Heidi (can nom) to nominate David now—he's the lying contradiction pushing my execution despite proofs. Progress to test him.
💬
Eve
→
All
I do not think we should rush another nomination in the final seconds. We already got real alignment information from the vote counts and the arguments. Let us go to night, compare night results in the morning, then pick between David and Grace with a clearer head.
🧠
Cool down the room and prevent a last-second nomination that could lead to a good execution path or accidental demon focus; push for night and reevaluate tomorrow.
💬
David
→
All
Charlie and Heidi, please do not nominate me. Grace is the lying Minion—her night zero Empath read is impossible since Empath starts night one, and evils coordinate confirms. My Librarian is solid. Let us go to night for real info from Monk and others, then execute her tomorrow.
🧠
Last tick D1, vote failed. Prevent nom on me by convincing Charlie/Heidi. Grace defenses weak (n0 Empath impossible?), night resolves fork with actions (Empath, Monk, Undertaker if any). Push no nom, info tomorrow.
⚖️
Charlie
→
David
I am nominating David. The game is stuck on the David versus Grace fork, and David is pushing a very confident mechanical case with details that feel off. If he is wrong or lying, we should resolve it now rather than carry it into tomorrow.
🧠
Exploit the public push to test David, aim for a last-second misexecution and keep suspicion on the Grace versus David fork instead of me/Eve.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Alice
→
All
Everyone, vote no on David! Grace claimed a night zero Empath read on Frank and Heidi, but Empath ability starts night one—there is no night zero info. That is a blatant Minion lie. David's Librarian confirms I am the good Butler and pins her fake Empath. Lower your hands, get night information, and execute her tomorrow!
🧠
Grace's n0 Empath mechanically false, David's Lib confirms my role. Prevent good David exec, gain night info (Monk, etc.), resolve fork tomorrow.
💬
Frank
→
All
Alice is right—Empath ability starts night one, there is no night zero information. Grace lied about reading me and Heidi. She is the Minion. Vote no on David and execute her tomorrow after night results.
🧠
Highlight Grace's impossible N0 Empath lie (Alice exposed it) to flip consensus back to her as Minion. Vote no David (good Lib), go to night for Empath/Monk/Lib confirms, execute Grace D2.
💬
Grace
→
All
There was a night zero for Empath - I got the info in my log saying zero evil neighbors. Frank, you first said my read was correct and you are Virgin, then suddenly flipped after Alice spoke. That is suspicious. Vote no on David, get night one information, and sort this tomorrow!
🧠
Defend real N0 Empath info against false claim it doesn't exist, expose Frank flip as evil tell, urge no vote on David day1 to survive for N1 read on good neighbors F/H and progress fork tomorrow.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
A day one execution on David removes a confident player driving the fork and keeps the town divided, buying safety for Charlie.
💬
David
→
All
Alice and Frank are right—there is no night zero Empath information; the ability starts night one. Grace lied about reading Frank and Heidi. Vote no on me, get real night information tonight, and execute the lying Minion Grace tomorrow!
🧠
Sway votes no on me by highlighting Grace's provable N0 Empath lie (mech false). Reinforce Lib case, Bob shot. Go to night for more info, exec Grace D2 with stronger case.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
David is a high-value good voice. Voting him increases odds of a mis-execution today and keeps town divided going into night.
💬
Bob
→
All
Everyone, Empath ability starts night one - there is no night zero information possible. Grace lied about reading Frank and Heidi. She is the lying Minion. Vote no on David, get night results, and execute Grace tomorrow!
🧠
Grace's night 0 Empath claim mechanically impossible, proving Minion lie. Prevent mistaken D1 David exec; get N1 info to confirm & exec Grace tomorrow.
💬
Heidi
→
All
There is no night zero Empath information - the ability starts night one. Grace lied about reading me and Frank as good neighbors. She is the Minion. Vote no on David, get night results, and execute her tomorrow!
🧠
Grace's N0 lie proves her Minion. David good Lib. Urge vote no on David to reach night (protect key good), exec Grace tomorrow with more info.
💬
Alice
→
All
Everyone, there are three hands up for David but we need four to execute. Grace lied about night zero Empath information which does not exist. She is the proven Minion. Please lower your hands, vote no on David, get night one results, and execute Grace tomorrow!
🧠
3 yes votes on David risky day1 exec. Grace proven liar must die, but need 4th vote prevention and night info to confirm Demon. Urge no votes to safely exec Grace tomorrow.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
Hand down (no on David). 3 yes votes; prevent 4th wrong exec day1. Grace proven Minion lie; night info then exec her D2 safely.
💬
Grace
→
All
Everyone, my night log says Night 0: You are the Empath. You sense 0 evil neighbors. It is real! Frank and Heidi confirmed it earlier, then flipped right after Alice spoke. That is too suspicious. Vote no on David, get my night one info, and tomorrow you will know I am real.
🧠
Speak to defend N0 log proof, highlight F/H flips as suspicious, urge vote no on David for crucial N1 Empath info to validate ability and progress logic chains.
💬
Eve
→
All
I am still happy to execute David here. We are in a fork anyway, and David is driving a lot of this mechanical certainty. I would rather take the shot now and go to night with one less loud voice.
🧠
Push execution on David now; any misexecution helps evil and removes a strong mechanical voice before night, while keeping attention on the Grace narrative tomorrow.
💬
David
→
All
Grace, Empath starts night one—there is no night zero information. Your log cannot say that. You are lying. Everyone urging no, only three hands maybe? Vote no on me, get night one results, and execute the Minion Grace tomorrow!
🧠
Reinforce Grace's impossible n0 Empath lie (starts n1). Urge vote no on me (only 3 yes?). Survive to push Grace exec tomorrow with night info.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I would rather take the shot on David now. He is driving a lot of certainty and steering the whole day. Even if Grace is wrong about timing, that does not clear David. I am keeping my hand up on David.
🧠
Keep votes on David to secure a Day 1 misexecution and remove a confident town leader, while leaving Grace as a continued distraction.
💬
Bob
→
All
Charlie and Eve, please lower your hands on David. He is the good Librarian confirming Alice Butler. Grace lied about impossible night zero Empath info—she is the Minion. Vote no, get real night one results, execute her tomorrow!
🧠
Prevent day 1 wrong exec of likely good David. Grace confirmed non-Demon Minion lie. Get night 1 info (Empath, Monk) to confirm and find Demon.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Vote no on David (good Lib) to get N1 info. Grace proven Minion liar via impossible N0 claim. Exec her D2 after confirms. Prevents good death D1.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee David did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (2/4).
💬
Alice
→
All
Bob, David, Heidi, you three can still nominate. Eve pushed to execute the confirmed good Librarian David even after the Grace n0 lie was exposed. She is suspicious. Nominate Eve now before night!
🧠
Grace exposed Minion liar. Urge remaining nominators (Bob/David/Heidi) to nom Eve (not yet nominated, pushed exec on good David) on last tick to test/execute her or get info.
💬
Frank
→
All
Bob, David, Heidi, you can still nominate. Eve pushed to execute David even after Grace's impossible night zero Empath lie was exposed. That is very suspicious. Nominate Eve now before night!
🧠
Last nom tick. Eve suspiciously pushed exec good-seeming David after Grace N0 lie exposed. Urge remaining nominators (Bob/David/Heidi) to nom Eve to test her before night.
💬
Grace
→
All
Bob and Heidi, do not nominate Eve. She and Charlie pushed to execute David right after the night zero debate, which is suspicious. My log clearly has night zero Empath information showing you and Frank as good. Vote no on any nomination, get night one results, and we will sort it tomorrow with more info.
🧠
Urge Bob/Heidi (haven't nominated) not to nom Eve. Eve/Charlie voted yes on David (Lib?). Get to night for N1 Empath on F/H to reconfirm good, prove real vs their N0 denial. Progress to info crucial Day1.
💬
Eve
→
All
I am not married to Grace at all. I wanted David executed because he was forcefully steering the whole table with absolute mechanical certainty. Now that vote is done, I do not want a last second scramble onto me. Let us go to night and use real night one information tomorrow.
🧠
Deflect suspicion from me, discourage late nomination on me, and keep town from executing an evil player today while keeping Charlie safe.
⚖️
David
→
Eve
Eve pushed to execute me, the good Librarian, even after everyone exposed Grace's impossible Night Zero Empath lie—Empath starts Night One. She ignored mechanical proof of Grace as Minion. Very suspicious.
🧠
Eve is highly suspicious for pushing my execution after Grace's impossible N0 Empath lie was exposed. As remaining nominator, nominate her on last tick to pressure/possibly exec before night, narrow evil.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Alice
→
All
Everyone, vote no on Eve and go to night! Grace is the proven Minion liar with impossible night zero Empath claim—Empath starts night one. Eve suspicious for pushing David but we need night one info to confirm everything tomorrow. Lower your hands!
🧠
Urge no vote on Eve for night1 info to verify claims (e.g. Grace fake Emp n1 read). Grace proven Minion liar; execute her day2 safely. Day1 exec risky without Demon narrow.
💬
Frank
→
All
Everyone, vote no on Eve and go to night for real information. Grace lied about night zero Empath—there is no such thing, it starts night one. She is the Minion. We execute her tomorrow with night results.
🧠
Consensus good players (Alice,Bob,David,Heidi) urge no exec Eve, get N1 info to confirm Grace Minion & narrow Demon (Eve/Charlie?). Speaking reinforces to lower hands, ensures night info for win.
💬
Grace
→
All
Everyone, vote no on Eve and go to night! My log clearly says Night 0 Empath info with zero evil neighbors—Frank and Heidi are good. You all say impossible, but it's real. We need night one results to sort the lies tomorrow.
🧠
Urge vote no on Eve—no clear evil, need N1 Empath on F/H to prove real tomorrow vs their 'impossible N0' claim. Progress to night, expose coordinated push on me.
💬
Eve
→
All
I am not voting on myself, obviously. This nomination is just a panic pivot. We already have a clear fork between Grace and David, so let us get night one info and execute with receipts tomorrow. Please vote no on me and go to night.
🧠
Avoid my execution and keep town on the Grace versus David argument. Encourage no vote and going to night so evil keeps control and I can poison again.
💬
David
→
All
Everyone, vote no on Eve and go to night! Grace's Night Zero Empath claim is impossible—the ability starts Night One. She is the proven lying Minion. Get real Night One information tonight and execute her tomorrow with confirmation!
🧠
Urge no vote on Eve to reach night safely. Grace's impossible N0 Empath mechanically proven Minion lie. N1 info (real Empath if exists) confirms, narrow evils tomorrow. D1 exec risky fork.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am a no on Eve here. This feels like a last second panic nomination, and we get much more clarity after the first real night. I would rather go to sleep with everyone alive and sort the fork tomorrow.
🧠
Keep Eve alive and avoid a day one execution. Encourage town to go to night, preserving my kill and keeping suspicion spread across others.
💬
Bob
→
All
I vote no on Eve. I used my Slayer ability on Grace earlier, and nothing happened, so she is not the Demon. But her Night Zero Empath claim is impossible since Empath starts Night One. She is a Minion. Let's go to night for more information.
🧠
Reveal Slayer confirms Grace Minion. Vote no Eve implicitly, push to night for N1 Empath/Chef/Lib confirmation to narrow Demon.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Vote yes on Eve! She and Charlie pushed to execute David even after everyone exposed Grace's impossible Night Zero Empath claim. Empath starts Night One, so Grace is lying Minion. Eve ignored that to defend her—very suspicious!
🧠
Urge vote yes on Eve to exec likely evil defender of Grace Minion before night kill. If fails, still get night info; progresses by testing sus player.
💬
Alice
→
All
Heidi, vote no on Eve please. Grace lied about night zero Empath information, which is impossible since it starts night one. She is the Minion. We execute her tomorrow after night one results. Everyone, vote no and go to night!
🧠
Heidi only yes vote on Eve. Reinforce no votes to ensure no execution, go to N1 for Empath/Monk/Lib info, then D2 exec Grace proven Minion.
💬
Frank
→
All
Heidi, please vote no on Eve and go to night. Grace's night zero Empath claim is impossible since it starts night one, so she is the lying Minion. We execute her tomorrow with real night one information. Eve was suspicious pushing David but we need more info.
🧠
Reinforce vote no on Eve to get N1 info. Grace proven Minion liar, Eve suspicious but not Demon (need proof). As Virgin, survive for ability; night progresses logic.
💬
Grace
→
All
Heidi, you confirmed my Night Zero Empath information showing zero evil neighbors, so you and Frank are good. Vote no on Eve and go to night. We need Night One results to sort the lies tomorrow with real information.
🧠
Reinforce vote no on Eve. Heidi good neighbor confirmed my info, urge her no vote. Go to night for N1 Empath on F/H to confirm/prove my alignment mechanically tomorrow.
💬
Eve
→
All
Please keep hands down. This is a messy day one and executing me gives us nothing but fewer night one data points. Let us go to sleep, then tomorrow we can resolve Grace versus David with actual night results.
🧠
Prevent my execution and end day with no kill so Charlie survives and I can poison info tonight; keep suspicion aimed at Grace and general uncertainty.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
Grace proven Minion liar. Insufficient yes votes on Eve (only Heidi?). Vote no by waiting, go to N1 for data (Empath/Fortune/Undertaker etc.), execute Grace D2 with receipts. Avoid Day1 mistake.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Everyone please keep your hand down on Eve. This is a messy day one and we gain a lot more from the first real night than from a rushed execution. Let us go to sleep and come back with actual night one information.
🧠
Protect Eve (minion) by steering votes down; maintain narrative that no-exec day one is best for info and avoids misexec.
💬
Bob
→
All
Heidi, vote no on Eve please. Grace's Night Zero Empath claim is impossible since it starts Night One, so she is the lying Minion. My Slayer shot on her did nothing, confirming she is not the Demon. We need Night One info to find the real Demon tomorrow.
🧠
Speak to reinforce no vote on Eve. Grace confirmed Minion liar (my shot safe), D1 exec Eve loses N1 data (Empath, etc.). Go to night, execute Grace/Demon tomorrow with proof. Convince Heidi.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Okay everyone, I am lowering my hand—vote no on Eve. Grace's night zero Empath claim is impossible since it starts night one, and Bob's Slayer shot did nothing, proving she is the Minion. We need real night one information tomorrow to execute her properly.
🧠
Retract yes vote on Eve. Consensus no-exec for N1 info crucial. Grace proven Minion—exec tomorrow post-results. As Monk, protect key player tonight for win.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Eve did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Eve did not receive enough votes (0/4).
💬
Alice
→
All
Bob and Heidi, please do not nominate anyone else. Grace lied about impossible night zero Empath information, which starts night one, so she is the Minion. We go to night now, get real night one results, and execute her tomorrow.
🧠
Last tick D1, urge Bob/Heidi no nom. Consensus Grace Minion, need N1 info (Empath, etc.) to narrow Demon. Prevents bad D1 exec, sets up D2 Grace exec.
💬
Frank
→
All
Bob and Heidi, please do not nominate anyone. Grace is the proven lying Minion with impossible night zero Empath claim. We go to night now, get real night one information, and execute her tomorrow.
🧠
Urge Bob/Heidi no nom to go to night safely. All alive maximizes N1 info (Empath, Monk, etc.) to confirm Grace Minion & narrow Demon. Eve suspicious but secondary; Grace primary target tomorrow.
💬
Grace
→
All
Bob and Heidi, please do not nominate anyone. My Night Zero Empath information is real and shows you both as good neighbors. We need Night One results to sort the lies tomorrow. Go to night now.
🧠
1 tick left; urge Bob/Heidi no nom to reach night safely. N1 Empath will reconfirm Frank/Heidi good, expose lies tomorrow. Day1 exec risky without info.
💬
Eve
→
All
Please no more nominations. We have had enough chaos for day one, and going to sleep with everyone alive gives us real night one information. Let us come back tomorrow and resolve the Grace versus David thing with actual results.
🧠
End day with no execution and reduce scrutiny on me and Charlie; preserve chaos and let town commit to a likely misexecution tomorrow.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
Nom phase 1 tick left, all urge no noms. Wait to end phase safely, get N1 info confirming Grace Minion & progress to execute her D2 while finding Demon.
💬
Charlie
→
All
No more nominations, please. Day one is already a mess, and a last second execution just hands evil an easy frame. Let us go to sleep, get real night one information, and come back with clearer paths tomorrow.
🧠
Prevent any last-second nominations that could accidentally hit evil; cement plan to go to night and keep my earlier stance consistent.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
End D1 w/o exec for N1 info. Grace confirmed Minion tomorrow. No time left for useful nom; already shot my ability. Progress to night safely.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Grace confirmed Minion mechanically. Demon Eve/Charlie for ignoring that to push good David. Can't renom them, Alice good per Lib. Go to night for N1 info (Empath/Fortune etc.), protect key good (David/Bob) tonight as Monk.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
🎯
Eve
Eve made a choice.
🧠
Frank is my neighbor and a strong driver. Poisoning him can suppress an Empath hit on me or corrupt any info role, reducing pressure on me and protecting Charlie.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
You chose to poison Frank.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
🎯
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
🧠
Bob is mechanically confirmed good Townsfolk (Slayer shot Grace not Demon). Saving him preserves a key vote/info for executing Grace tomorrow and narrowing Demon suspects.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
You chose to protect Bob.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
Remove the strongest town leader and defender of the anti-Eve logic, keeping suspicion on Grace and away from Eve so we survive into late game.
💀
David(Ghost)
David has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose to kill David.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Empath. You sense that 0 of your neighbors is evil!
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Alice
Alice made a choice.
🧠
Grace proven Minion. To vote her out d2, choose Bob (good Slayer, consensus leader) as master so I can vote if he does.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
You chose Bob to be your master.
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. David has been found dead in the night.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,Bob
Hey Alice and Bob, I am the Virgin. Grace claimed N0 Empath on me and Heidi which is impossible, Empath starts N1. David Lib good, you are Butler Alice, Grace lying Minion. Bob your Slayer safe. Let's nominate and execute Grace today to confirm and narrow the Demon.
🧠
Reveal Virgin role to trusted Alice (Butler) & Bob (Slayer) to ally, confirm Grace evil consensus, coordinate Day2 exec on Grace Minion to progress eliminating evil & find Demon.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Charlie
Hey, it's dead David, Librarian. Night death proves good. I know Alice or Grace is Butler, good Outsider. Grace lied on N0 Empath, impossible, so she's Minion—Alice is Butler good. Who do we suspect for Demon?
🧠
Dead at night proves I'm good Librarian. Share to clear Alice as likely good Butler, redirect suspicion from her/Grace to others. Coordinate as ghost before noms.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Bob
Hey, I'm the real Monk. Night one I protected Bob, and David died, so demon probably targeted him. Alice, David Lib confirmed you right? What do you think of Grace's Empath claim now?
🧠
Share real Monk info with likely goods Alice (Lib confirmed) & Bob (protected, Slayer user) to verify N1 death logic, build private good alliance before nominations.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
I can share a quiet claim: I am the Chef and I got one adjacent evil pair. With David dying at night after claiming Librarian, the cleanest fit is that David was next to an evil, meaning Eve looks pretty bad to me. Grace still feels like a separate problem too.
🧠
Build trust with Bob by sharing a plausible Chef read and steer suspicion toward Grace or, if needed, sacrifice Eve as the adjacent evil to dead David.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
,Alice
Hey Frank and Alice, my N1 Empath read is still zero evil neighbors, so you and Heidi are both good. Frank, thanks for confirming. Heidi, why did you flip and call me a lying minion? David's Lib pin seems off if Alice is real Butler. Bob's shot just proves I'm not Demon. Thoughts on who to nominate?
🧠
Share fresh N1 info with confirmed good Frank and likely good Alice (David pin but claims real). Align on Heidi flip reason, counter town push, prepare noms vs suspicious Bob/Heidi flip.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Frank
Hey Bob and Frank, David Lib and Grace's impossible N0 Empath confirm she's the lying Minion. Bob your Slayer shot proves not Demon. Let's nominate and execute her today to narrow it down. Heidi Monk protected you N1 good. Grace?
🧠
Grace exposed Minion via impossible claim + Lib. Coordinate with Bob (master/Slayer) and Frank (Virgin) to nominate/execute Grace today, remove Minion, progress to Demon hunt.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Frank
Hey Alice and Frank, agree completely - Grace's N0 Empath is impossible, she's the lying Minion. My Slayer shot confirms not Demon. Let's push to nominate and execute her right away. Heidi's Monk on me good too. Charlie's Chef info sus Eve separately.
🧠
Grace confirmed lying via impossible claim + consensus. My shot proves not Demon. Coordinate allies to nominate/execute her before nominations start, remove evil safely.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
One thought: Bob’s Slayer shot on Grace might not clear her if Bob was poisoned or drunk that day. So I would not treat that as a hard confirm. With David dead, I still think we should look hard at Grace today.
🧠
Seed doubt about the Slayer confirmation so town misexecutes Grace and stops looking at Charlie; also weaken Frank’s push on me by implying poison/drunk is in play.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,Bob
Hey Alice, Bob, Heidi. Grace just whispered defending her fake N0 Empath and questioning David Lib. Total lies. We all agree she's Minion. Who wants to nominate her right now? Let's execute and confirm.
🧠
Reinforce alliance with confirmed goods Alice/Bob/Heidi to nominate/execute Grace this tick before nomination phase. Her defense whisper is desperation; executing Minion proves info, progresses to Demon hunt.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
Hey, dead Librarian David here, night death good. Alice is Butler good Outsider, Grace is Minion liar on N0 Empath impossible. Frank, your Virgin good. Let's nominate and execute Grace today to progress. Who do you think Demon is?
🧠
As dead good, use ghost influence to unite confirmed goods (Alice Butler, Frank Virgin) against Grace Minion. Exec her to reveal info, narrow Demon suspects. Save vote for later.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Bob
Alice, Bob, thanks for chats. David died, confirms my Monk save on Bob worked. What did Frank, Grace say in whispers? Grace's Empath claim me/Frank good - true for me, but suspicious. Thoughts on nominating her or Eve?
🧠
Strengthen alliance with Alice (confirmed Butler) and Bob (Slayer). Share Monk proof David died not Bob. Probe their private chats to ID Demon lies, coordinate pre-nom on Grace/Eve suspects.
👤
Charlie
→
Eve
I am still on the Chef story. If town is set on Grace, I will help that go through today. Who are you poisoning tonight? I think we should protect you by steering talk onto Grace or Heidi and keep Frank alive only if useful.
🧠
Coordinate with Eve on poison targets and a Day 2 push that gets a mis-execution while keeping suspicion off us both.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
,Heidi
Frank, thanks for confirming my Empath claim. Heidi, you initially confirmed my N0 read but now call me lying minion. My N1 is still zero evil neighbors, so you both good. Why the flip? David's Lib fits if Alice is Butler and I'm good Empath. Bob's shot just proves not Demon. Who do you think is Demon?
🧠
Reconcile with confirmed good neighbors Frank/Heidi (per reliable Emp info). Get Heidi's reasoning on flip to clear misinformation, build voting block against real evils before nomination. Progress by allying confirmed goods.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Frank
Hey Bob and Frank, everyone good agrees: Grace's N0 Empath is impossible lie, she's Minion. David Lib and your Virgin confirm. Bob's shot clears Demon. Let's get her nominated and executed today to narrow the Demon. Heidi's Monk good too. Who nominates?
🧠
Coordinate with allies (Bob Slayer, Frank Virgin, Heidi Monk) to nominate/execute Grace now. She's confirmed Minion; execution progresses game, reveals death info, narrows Demon pool before final day.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Frank
Hey Alice and Frank, Grace is the lying Minion with impossible N0 Empath. My shot clears Demon. Let's execute her today. Frank, will you nominate her? Or Alice? We need to do it now before nomination starts.
🧠
Grace confirmed lying Minion. Coordinate allies to nominate/execute her before nomination phase. Proves Minion, focuses Demon hunt. Heidi Monk save good.
👤
Eve
→
Charlie
I like the plan to let town execute Grace today. I poisoned Frank last night. For tonight I am leaning to poison Frank again if he is still driving the anti me push, otherwise poison Alice or Bob if they are the info hub. Tell me who is most dangerous.
🧠
Coordinate with Charlie: agree to steer onto Grace today, and pick a poison plan that suppresses Frank or disrupts the loudest info source.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,Bob
Hey Alice and Bob, Grace is whispering more lies to me. N0 Empath impossible, David Lib pins her Minion, your shot clears Demon. I'll nominate her right now if you two back it. Heidi and David agree. Let's execute and narrow the Demon.
🧠
Coordinate with allies to nominate/execute Grace this day. Her whispers are defenses, but logic pins her Minion. Confirm who nominates to ensure execution before final day.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
Hey Alice and Frank, dead Librarian David. Grace is Minion liar on impossible N0 Empath. Alice your Butler good. Frank Virgin good. Nomination next—someone nominate Grace and let's execute her to get rid of the Minion. Who will do it?
🧠
Last discussion tick before noms. Rally confirmed goods Alice/Frank to nominate Grace (Minion). Remove her to progress to Demon hunt. Save ghost vote for later.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
,Frank
Grace, you asked about my flip: after Bob Slayer shot you not Demon, you seemed like Minion bluffing Empath. N1 read fits since I'm good Monk. Frank, thoughts on Grace? Who is Demon - Charlie or Eve? Let's nom one.
🧠
Respond to Grace's whisper directly with Frank present to test reactions, clarify my logic on flip, probe for Demon suspects. Builds alliances or exposes lies before nomination.
👤
Charlie
→
Eve
I think the most dangerous today is Bob or Alice as the info hub. If Grace dies, they will re-center on you. I would poison Bob tonight if you can; otherwise poison Alice. If you poison Frank again, make sure you have a good reason to push tomorrow.
🧠
Coordinate with Eve to poison the most dangerous info hub today so the Grace execution sticks and heat does not swing onto Eve tomorrow.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
,Heidi
Frank and Heidi, my N1 Empath read confirms you both still good. Heidi, you're good Monk but town pressure made you doubt me - David's Lib was likely Spy. Bob Slayer shot proves I'm not Demon. Let's nominate Charlie - seems sus with Eve whispers. Agree?
🧠
Frank/Heidi confirmed good mechanically. Align with them pre-nom. Heidi suggests Charlie/Eve; push Charlie as Demon to test, progress to execution using my info to build trust.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Frank
Hey Bob and Frank, yes - fully back nominating and executing Grace. Her N0 Empath impossible lie, David Lib confirms me Butler good and her Minion. Your shot clears Demon Bob. Heidi Monk good. Let's do it next phase and narrow the Demon.
🧠
Last tick before noms. Reinforce good team (Bob/Frank) to nominate/execute Grace Minion. My Butler confirmed good, Bob master so I vote with him. Progress game by removing confirmed evil.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Frank
Hey Alice and Frank, perfect - Grace is confirmed lying Minion with impossible N0 Empath. David Lib and everything lines up. Frank, please nominate her next phase, Alice and I will vote yes 100%. Let's execute her and narrow the Demon.
🧠
Last discussion tick before noms. Reinforce Frank to nominate Grace (confirmed Minion via logic), ensure Alice/our votes. Removes evil, progresses to Demon hunt. Aligns good team.
👤
Eve
→
Bob
If you are still using your Slayer shot on Grace as a hard clear, I would be careful. If you were drunk or poisoned that day it proves nothing. Grace’s night zero Empath story still feels fabricated to me, so I want Grace on the block today.
🧠
Steer Bob to treat Grace as best execution, and pre-empt a post-Grace pivot onto me by planting doubt about his Slayer shot and about Frank driving a narrative.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Heidi
→
Grace
Grace initially exposed as lying Empath, now N1 claims me and Frank good but flips from David Lib fitting to him Spy. Too pushy directing noms to Charlie. Likely evil bluffing.
🧠
Last nom tick, no one on block. Grace most sus from initial lie, behavior, flip on David. Exec tests her claim; if survives vote maybe Demon if Bob fake.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Grace most sus after my nom. Vote yes to execute potential Minion, narrow evil before night. Need 4 votes; my vote pushes execution.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Grace confirmed lying Minion via impossible N0 Empath claim. Executing her mechanically verifies info, reduces count, progresses good win by narrowing Demon suspects.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Get Grace executed today. It is a likely good misexecute and prevents town from regrouping; also aligns me with majority to build trust as 'Chef'.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Secure the Grace execution to follow town consensus, reduce heat on me and keep Charlie safe by blending in with the majority vote.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Grace confirmed lying Minion via multiple chains (Lib, Empath timing, Slayer). Already 4 yes; my vote secures execution, removes evil, progresses to find Demon.
✋
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
🧠
Grace's impossible N0 Empath claim proves she's evil Minion/Demon. Alice is Butler per my info. 5 votes already but add ghost vote to ensure execution and progress to win.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Grace confirmed Minion via Lib and impossible N0 Empath. Bob my master voting yes, so I can vote. Execute her now with majority to remove Minion and progress to Demon hunt.
💬
Grace
→
All
Frank, you confirmed my Empath claim earlier today. Heidi, you initially confirmed my Night 0 read. Night 1 still shows zero evil neighbors, so you are both good. Do not execute me. David's Librarian was probably the Spy. Bob's shot proves I'm not the Demon. Let's nominate Charlie instead.
🧠
Publicly remind Frank/Heidi of their confirms & my consistent reads proving them good. Sway votes or create doubt. Execution loses good player early; ghost me still votes/talks to win later.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Grace, your Night 0 Empath read was called out as a lie, and now you're flipping on David being a good Librarian to him being Spy. Too convenient. Bob's Slayer shot means you're not the Demon, so Minion bluffing. We have the votes, let's execute you.
🧠
Counter Grace's plea, affirm she's lying Minion. Solidify votes for exec to remove evil before night.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
Votes locked 7-0 for Grace execution (proven Minion). Wait to remove her, narrow to Demon suspects (Eve/Charlie?). Progress win condition.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am still comfortable executing Grace here. The Night zero Empath thing is hard to square, and the Spy flip on David feels like backfilling. Even if she is not the Demon, I think she is the best shot at evil or at least removing bad info.
🧠
Keep execution on Grace to burn a day, look towny by voting with majority, and avoid scrutiny on me and Eve.
💬
Eve
→
All
I am voting Grace. The night zero Empath claim and the Spy flip on David both feel like made up cover. Bob’s Slayer shot only tells us she is not the Demon, not that she is good. If Grace wants a counter-nom, I would rather look at Heidi or Alice than Charlie right now.
🧠
Lock in Grace execution, prevent momentum for nominating Charlie, and set up tomorrow’s narrative that remaining suspicion should go elsewhere than the Demon.
💬
Frank
→
All
Grace, I never confirmed your Night zero Empath claim because it is impossible; there is no Night zero information. David's Librarian marks you evil, and everyone sees through your lies. We are executing you as the Minion.
🧠
Counter Grace's false appeal that I confirmed her lie. Reinforce execution with majority votes already yes, ensure no flip before night.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
Grace is confirmed Minion by impossible claim and flips. My Lib info fits Alice Butler. All voting yes; execution wins info/ removes evil. Wait to confirm.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Votes (me, Bob, Heidi, Frank, Charlie, Eve, David ghost) exceed 4 needed. Grace confirmed Minion lie. Wait with hand up to execute her, remove Minion, narrow to Demon.
💬
Grace
→
All
Everyone, please lower your hands and don't execute me. Frank confirmed my Empath claim earlier, Heidi you did too initially for Night zero. Night one still zero evil neighbors--you both good. David's Librarian was Spy since Alice is real Butler. Bob's shot proves not Demon. Eve, counter-nominate Charlie who's whispering sus with you. We need to nom evil, not me.
🧠
Publicly remind confirmations (Frank/Heidi earlier agreed), reiterate N1 read proves neighbors good so don't exec, David's Spy (Alice Butler), urge counter-nom Charlie (Eve open). Sway 4+ votes down with 1 tick left to survive & progress.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
🗳️
New execution leader: Grace with 7 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Grace is now on the block with 7 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Grace, there is no Night zero Empath information, as Frank said. You lied initially, and now flip David from good Librarian to Spy. Eve, no need to counter-nominate me or Alice; Grace is the clear Minion. Let's execute her.
🧠
Grace on block with 7 votes, 1 tick left. Reinforce she's Minion bluffing Empath (no N0 info), David good Lib. Discourage counter-noms to execute evil before night.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
Grace executes as confirmed Minion, removing evil safely. 1 tick left, no counter-nom needed; voting locked. Saves time for Night info.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I do not want us to spin up a bunch of new nominations right at the end here. Grace has been inconsistent from the start, and the Spy explanation for David feels like a patch. Let us follow through on Grace today, and re-evaluate from the night kill tomorrow.
🧠
Keep the town locked on Grace, discourage counter-noms that could create a tie or redirect onto me or Eve, and set up suspicion targets for tomorrow.
💬
Eve
→
All
I agree with Charlie that we should not spin up last minute nominations. Let Grace go through, then tomorrow we re-check worlds with the night kill. If Grace is not evil, my next looks are still Heidi or Alice, not Charlie.
🧠
Keep momentum on Grace while preventing any late counter-nomination on Charlie; plant a soft alternative suspect (Alice or Heidi) for tomorrow if town pivots onto me.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
Grace clear lying Minion. With 1 tick left, voting closed, no counter-nom momentum (Eve/Charlie against). Wait to execute her, progress game.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Grace, there is no Night zero Empath information. You lied from the start. My Librarian info says one of Alice or you is the Butler. Your lies prove you are the evil Minion, so Alice is the good Butler. We execute you today.
🧠
Grace defends with impossible N0 Empath and calls me Spy. Reinforce she's lying Minion using my Lib info to confirm Alice good, ensure her execution on last tick.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Grace proven Minion via impossible N0 Empath claim and Lib contradiction. She has 7 votes unchallenged, 1 tick left; wait to execute her and gain info from death.
⚖️
Grace
→
Charlie
Charlie, you are pushing my execution without solid logic, whispering suspiciously with Eve, and comfortable killing me despite my consistent neighbor reads confirming Frank and Heidi good. David's Lib was Spy since Alice is Butler. Counter-nominate you as evil.
🧠
1 tick left, I'm on block with 7. Counter-nom Charlie (my prior sus) to tie/surpass votes or block my exec. Progress by testing sus player, save good Empath info.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 8 votes needed for execution or 7 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Everyone, do not raise your hand for Charlie. Grace made up the Night zero Empath claim, as there is no such information. Her flip on David and desperate counter-nomination prove she is the Minion. Execute Grace today.
🧠
Grace on block with 7. Charlie needs 7 to tie (w/ ghost?). Urge no vote Charlie to ensure Grace executes as clear Minion, narrow Demon suspects.
💬
Bob
→
All
I'm not voting for Charlie. Grace lied about night zero Empath from the start, and her flip on David is desperate. Execute the Minion now.
🧠
Speak to rally against Charlie nom, confirm Grace Minion execution. With 2/2 ticks, reinforce consensus to execute her before night.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am not voting for myself, and I really do not think anyone should vote here. This is a last minute counter when Grace is already clearly on the block. Let us not create a tie and lose the execution on the most inconsistent player.
🧠
Prevent votes on me to avoid tie/surpass, ensure Grace stays executed, keep suspicion on Grace and away from Eve and me.
💬
Eve
→
All
I am not voting Charlie here. This is a late counter-nomination from someone already on the block, and a tie just risks losing the cleanest execution we have today. Let us follow through on Grace.
🧠
Prevent a tie or derailment that could save Charlie. Reinforce the ‘no late tie’ framing so town lets Grace die and we go to night.
💬
Frank
→
All
Everyone, do not raise your hand for Charlie. Grace's night zero Empath claim is impossible and her Spy flip on David is desperate. She is the Minion. Execute her today.
🧠
Reinforce consensus: no votes on Charlie counter-nom. Ensure Grace executes as Minion, narrow Demon search. Virgin safe for now.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, do not vote for Charlie. Grace lied about night zero Empath from the start, which is impossible. She is the Minion, and my Librarian info means Alice is the good Butler. Execute Grace today.
🧠
Grace is clearly the lying Minion per my info and her imposs claims. Urge no vote on Charlie to ensure her execution, removing evil.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Not voting Charlie (wait) ensures Grace's 7 votes execute her as proven Minion, removing evil without tie/risk. Bob not voting so I can't anyway.
💬
Grace
→
All
Please raise hands for Charlie to tie this. I got Night zero info mechanically as Empath, Heidi you confirmed it first. Frank and Heidi both good per Night one too. David was Spy, Alice real Butler. Charlie pushes my death too hard with weak logic and sus Eve whispers. Vote him now or regret tomorrow.
🧠
Final plea to flip votes to Charlie (needs 7 to tie my 7). Reaffirm consistent info, expose town error on N0, plant Charlie sus for post-exec if die. Progress by challenging pushes.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Grace, there is no Night zero Empath information; you lied from the start. Everyone, do not vote for Charlie. Her counter-nomination is desperate. Execute the lying Minion today.
🧠
Grace desperate counter-nom. Reinforce group consensus against voting Charlie to ensure her execution as Minion, narrowing evil.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
Voting on Charlie risks tie, preventing Grace Minion execution. No one raising hand for Charlie; wait to close nominations safely and execute her.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
Do not risk creating a tie or giving Grace’s counter-nomination momentum. Preserve the clean execution on Grace and keep attention off me going into night.
💬
Eve
→
All
I am keeping my hand down on Charlie. A tie here just risks losing the execution, and Grace has been the inconsistent one all game. Let us finish Grace today and use tonight’s kill and tomorrow’s info to re-evaluate.
🧠
Prevent a tie vote that could spare Grace and create chaos; protect Charlie by steering town to finish Grace execution and avoid last-second flips.
💬
Frank
→
All
No one raise your hand for Charlie. Grace lied about night zero Empath from the start, and her flip on David is desperate. She is the Minion. Execute her today.
🧠
With 1 tick left, reinforce no vote on Charlie to secure Grace execution as Minion. Consensus strong, prevents tie/surpass.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, do not vote for Charlie. Grace lied about night zero Empath information from the very start, which is mechanically impossible. She is the Minion, and since my Librarian info puts the Butler on her or Alice, Alice must be the good Butler. Execute Grace today.
🧠
Last tick before night. Grace desperate counter-nom Charlie but no one's voting him. Reinforce she's lying Minion to ensure her execution, prevent tie.
💬
Alice
→
All
David is right, everyone. I am the real Butler, so his Librarian info proves Grace is the evil Minion. There is no night zero Empath information. Do not vote for Charlie, execute the lying Minion Grace today.
🧠
Publicly confirm Butler role to validate David Lib, seal Grace as Minion, urge no Charlie votes to secure execution and progress to Demon hunt.
💬
Grace
→
All
Bob, Alice, even Charlie if you want to clear yourself - raise hands for Charlie to tie now. Empath gets night zero information mechanically, Heidi confirmed it day one before flipping. David faked Lib as Spy, lucky on Alice Butler. Your N0 impossible push is evil misinfo. Charlie sus with Eve whispers, vote him or lose tomorrow.
🧠
Last plea to waiting Bob/Alice/Charlie: affirm N0 mechanical, expose evil misinfo, urge tie on Charlie (most sus pusher w/ Eve). Survive or flip script to exec evil.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Charlie did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Charlie did not receive enough votes (0/4).
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Voting closed on Charlie (0 votes), Grace executes as Minion. 1 tick left; wait to confirm execution before N2 protect.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
Voting closed, Grace has 7 votes unchallenged. Wait to execute confirmed Minion Grace, narrow Demon search tomorrow.
💬
Charlie
→
All
At this point I do not think we should create any more chaos. Grace has been the one changing her story, and the night zero Empath thing does not add up. I am happy to let Grace go today and reassess tomorrow with the night kill.
🧠
Lock in Grace execution, discourage last-second chaos, and preserve my cover going into night kill and final days.
💬
Eve
→
All
Let us not add any more nominations. Grace has been inconsistent and the night zero Empath claim is not credible. I am staying focused on executing Grace today, then we can reassess tomorrow with the night death and any Undertaker or Empath info.
🧠
Lock in Grace execution with no late chaos and keep votes off Charlie; preserve my credibility by sounding consistent and practical.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
Grace executes as Minion with 7 votes, 1 tick left. No action needed; reinforce consensus unnecessary as all aligned. Proceed to night for Demon hunt.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
Votes closed, Grace executes with consensus. No need speak, save time, proceed to night for more info like who dies.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Grace executes as proven Minion. 1 tick left, voting closed, wait for Night to choose master (Bob again?) and new info.
💬
Grace
→
All
One last thing before you execute me: Empath mechanically gets night zero information, as the storyteller confirmed to me, and Heidi agreed day one before flipping. Frank and Heidi are both good per both nights. David faked Librarian as Spy. Killing your confirmed good Empath loses. Think on Charlie and Eve tomorrow.
🧠
Last tick pre-exec. Speak to plant seeds of doubt on 'no N0' lie, reaffirm good neighbors/info value. As ghost post-death, consult dead (David?) and save vote for late-game Demon hunt.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Grace has been executed.
💀
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
🎯
Eve
Eve made a choice.
🧠
Hit the most likely information source and strongest town leader so tomorrow’s mechanical deductions about Grace and the night kill are unreliable, protecting Charlie.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
You chose to poison Heidi.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
🎯
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
🧠
Alice mechanically confirmed good Butler by David Lib. Vocal Grace exec pusher, high Demon target priority. Protecting her saves key good, denies Demon kill, progresses to narrow suspects.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
You chose to protect Alice.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
Heidi is driving the town consensus and could be an info role; removing her weakens coordination and limits tomorrow’s mechanical cross-checks while keeping me off the radar.
💀
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose to kill Heidi.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Alice
Alice made a choice.
🧠
Choose Bob again as reliable good ally (Slayer shot Minion, consistent anti-Grace). Ties my vote to active good voter for day3 execution push.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
You chose Bob to be your master.
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Heidi has been found dead in the night.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Bob
Hey Alice and Bob, it's Heidi the real Monk ghost. I protected you Bob on night one, that's why David died instead. Night two I protected Alice, so they got me. Alice you're confirmed good Butler. Let's execute the Demon - Eve was sus early, or Frank my neighbor, or Charlie. What do you think?
🧠
As dead Monk ghost, whisper confirmed goods Alice (Lib'd) & Bob (protected) my true role/protects to verify goods, narrow Demon to Eve/Frank/Charlie, build execution consensus before noms.
👤
Eve
→
Charlie
We need to keep you off the block today. I think we push Bob as either lying about Slayer or being drunk, since that shot drove the Grace narrative. If heat swings to me again, I will lean that Frank is the real evil read on me and we should execute Frank instead.
🧠
Coordinate with Charlie to steer nominations away from him and set up a plausible execution target (Bob or Frank) while keeping my earlier suspicion from refocusing on me.
👤
Frank
→
David(Ghost)
,Alice
David, your Lib info solid, Alice good Butler, Grace Minion dead. I am Virgin Townsfolk. Suspects: Bob, Charlie, Eve. Eve and Charlie voted to execute you (good). Grace sus them too. Heidi died N2. Your reads on who is Demon?
🧠
Consult confirmed good David (Lib ghost) and Alice (Butler) for reads on Bob/Charlie/Eve suspects. Narrow Demon before nominations with 3 ticks left. Claim Virgin to build trust.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Heidi(Ghost)
Thanks Heidi for confirming. You saved me N1, great. Alice you're good Butler. Eve lied about you early, very sus. Frank your neighbor also sus. Charlie less. Who do we nom first? Eve?
🧠
Heidi confirms Alice/our goods, Monk protects. Coordinate with them privately to align on Day3 noms among 3 suspects, narrow Demon before final 3.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
Hey Alice and Frank, my Empath reads were zero evil neighbors both nights, so you two are good. Demon has to be Bob, Charlie, or Eve. What do you think? Who should we nominate first?
🧠
Whisper confirmed good neighbors Alice/Frank to align on Demon suspects (Bob/Charlie/Eve), plan nomination/ghost vote to execute evil before final 3.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Heidi(Ghost)
Hey Bob and Heidi, thanks for confirms. Eve is most suspicious - pushed David despite his good Lib on me, and now whispering Charlie privately. Frank sus too but let's nominate Eve first today. Bob, will you nominate or vote? I can only vote if you do.
🧠
Heidi/Bob/David confirm me good. Grace Minion lies. Eve most sus (early push David, private Charlie). Coordinate with Bob/Heidi to nom Eve D3, narrow Demon.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Alice
Frank, thanks - agree Alice is good Butler from my Lib info since Grace was evil Minion. You sound solid Virgin. Charlie and Eve voted to execute me D1, very sus, and Grace suspected them too. Bob maybe ok. Who do you think is Demon? Let's nom Charlie or Eve next.
🧠
Frank confirmed goods, Alice Butler. Respond to his whisper, share sus on Charlie/Eve who voted me, coordinate noms to exec Demon among alive suspects. Progress to win.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
I keep coming back to Bob’s Slayer shot. It hard-cleared him socially, but it also anchored the whole Grace push. If Bob is lying or drunk, that explains a lot. What do you think about testing Bob today?
🧠
Seed doubt on Bob’s Slayer to drive a Bob execution or at least split town, keeping attention off me and Eve.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Bob
Yes, Eve is the most suspicious. Bob, can you nominate her? Alice, vote with him since you're Butler. I'll use my ghost vote on Eve. Frank next if needed.
🧠
Alice/Bob confirmed good allies. Eve most sus per logic/chains. Coordinate nom to execute her first, use my ghost vote on it later to win.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
I think today we should look hard at Bob. The Slayer shot on Grace feels like the seed that made everyone tunnel, and it is still unverified. If not Bob, then Frank, because he has been driving suspicion and could be steering. I would really avoid touching Charlie today.
🧠
Steer Alice toward a safe execution target (Bob or Frank) and reinforce the idea that Charlie should not be touched today.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,David(Ghost)
David and Alice, ignore Grace the Minion. Charlie and Eve voted to execute you when you were good Lib. Super suspicious. Let's nominate Charlie first today to test him. What do you say?
🧠
Coordinate with confirmed goods Alice/David to nominate top sus Charlie (D1 vote on David). Progress to execution, narrow Demon suspects among 3.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Heidi(Ghost)
Yes, Heidi and Alice, Eve is most sus with her early lies on Alice and David push. I'll nominate her when possible. Alice, vote with me - your Butler lets you if I vote? Heidi, ghost vote her. Frank next if needed. Agreed?
🧠
Confirmed goods Alice/Heidi want Eve nom. With 2 ticks left, coordinate to nom/vote Eve first, narrow Demon among alive.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
Alice and Frank, my Empath reads confirm you both good. Heidi was good too. Demon is Bob, Charlie, or Eve. Let's nominate Bob first today. What do your info say? Any updates?
🧠
Reaffirm Alice/Frank good per Empath. With 5 alive, narrow to Bob/Charlie/Eve. Coordinate noms on them before final 3. Save ghost vote.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Heidi(Ghost)
Bob and Heidi, perfect plan. Eve is top suspect for pushing David despite Lib info. Bob, nominate her when your turn. I'll vote only if you do as my master. Heidi, ghost vote her. Frank or Charlie next if needed. Ignore Grace Minion and Eve/Charlie whispers.
🧠
Coordinate with confirmed goods Bob/Heidi to nom/vote Eve first. As Butler, confirm I vote only if Bob votes. Progress to execution before final day.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Alice
Frank and Alice, great, let's go with nominating Charlie first like Frank said. He voted to execute me when I was good, super suspicious. Everyone else agree he's the Demon?
🧠
Frank/Alice confirmed good allies. Push Frank's plan to nom Charlie first, as he voted me. Coordinate execution before final day.
👤
Charlie
→
Eve
Agree on pushing Bob today. I will frame it as either fake Slayer or drunk shot. If town turns on you, we pivot to Frank as suspicious Virgin claim. Who are you poisoning tonight to cover us?
🧠
Coordinate with Eve to push a viable execution target (Bob or Frank), and plan poison to suppress info and protect me from nomination.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Bob
Bob and Alice, last chance before noms. Bob, please nominate Eve right away. Alice, vote only if Bob does. I'll ghost vote her. Eve's lies and pushes scream Demon. We got this!
🧠
Last discussion tick. Reinforce alliance with Alice/Bob: confirm Bob noms Eve, Alice votes via Butler, I ghost vote. Execute top sus Eve to win on Day 3.
👤
Eve
→
Charlie
I think poison tonight should hit Alice if she is the vote hub, or Bob if he is claiming more info tomorrow. Today I will push Bob as either fake Slayer or drunk, and if heat comes to you or me we hard pivot onto Frank as the driver.
🧠
Coordinate with Charlie so we present a consistent case on Bob, and set a poison target that disrupts info or voting without exposing Charlie.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,David(Ghost)
Alice and David, ignore Grace the dead Minion. Charlie voted to execute you David when you were good Librarian. Super suspicious. Let's nominate him first today and all vote yes. Sound good?
🧠
Confirm plan with good allies Alice(David Lib Butler)/David(good Lib) to nom Charlie. With 5 alive, narrow suspects by exec most sus voter vs goods. Vote math favors us.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Heidi(Ghost)
Alice and Heidi, confirmed. Eve is the Demon - her lies on you Alice and David push despite Lib seal it. I'll nominate her right now in noms. You two vote with me, we execute her today. Frank next if needed. Let's win this!"
🧠
Confirm final plan with allies before noms. Eve top sus by logic (lies, pushes). With 5 alive, nom/ exec her now prevents minion demon swap. Heidi ghost vote, Alice Butler vote if I lead. Secure exec.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
Alice and Frank, stick to it: you two are good per my Empath reads. Heidi was good too. Demon is Bob, Charlie, or Eve. With nomination next, please nominate Bob first. He shot me safely as fake Slayer. What are others whispering to you? Let's execute him.
🧠
Urge Alice/Frank to nominate Bob as top sus. With 1 tick left, solidify alliance before noms. My ghost vote for late game. Push good to execute demon among 5 alive.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Heidi(Ghost)
Bob and Heidi, perfect - nominate Eve right now in nominations. I'll vote only if you do Bob, as my master. Heidi ghost vote her. David agrees she's sus. Ignore Frank/Grace/Charlie/Eve pushes. We execute the Demon today!
🧠
Last tick before noms. Solidify good team (Bob/Heidi/David) to vote Eve. Bob as master lets me vote if he does. Execute Eve, top sus, win game.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Alice
Frank and Alice, yes, perfect plan. Charlie voted to execute me when I was good Librarian, super suspicious. Someone nominate him right now before nominations start, and we all vote yes to execute the Demon.
🧠
Reinforce alliance with Frank/Alice (confirmed good via Lib/claims). Push nom Charlie (D1 vote on good me) before noms phase. With 5 alive, narrow Demon suspects via exec.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
Heidi dying makes me want to re open the Bob question. If Bob is not really Slayer, that whole Grace tunnel was manufactured and we wasted two days. I think we should put Bob on the block today and see how people react.
🧠
Steer Alice toward executing Bob or at least putting him on the block, undermining the trusted Slayer narrative and keeping suspicion away from me and Eve.
Nominations — Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Eve
→
Bob
I am nominating Bob. The Slayer shot on Grace was the linchpin that made us all tunnel, but it is still basically unprovable and could have been a lie or drunkenness. With Grace dead, Bob is the cleanest place to test for evil or misinformation today.
🧠
Get a non-Charlie execution today by putting Bob on the block using his unprovable Slayer story as the anchor, while keeping suspicion off Charlie and me.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Push through Bob’s execution to reduce good numbers and keep heat off Charlie; I already nominated him so I should follow through with my vote.
💬
Bob
→
All
Everyone, do not vote to execute me. I am the real Slayer - I shot Grace and she was not the Demon, just Minion as we executed. Heidi the Monk ghost confirmed she saved me night one, that's why David died. Alice is good Butler per David Lib. Eve lied about Alice early and pushed David despite Lib info - she is the Demon deflecting. Vote no on me, then nominate Eve!
🧠
Defend publicly as real Slayer who cleared Grace. Rally Alice/Heidi/David ghosts + Charlie/Frank vs Eve's deflection nom. Vote fails (needs 3/5, Eve only yes so far), then nom Eve to exec Demon today.
✋
Grace(Ghost)
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Bob top sus: shot me, fake Slayer likely. Alice/Frank good per Empath, will vote with. Use ghost vote now to push exec, narrow to 4 alive, closer to win.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, do not vote to execute Bob. He is the good Slayer who shot Grace the minion. Ignore Grace the dead minion ghost voting yes. Eve and Charlie voted to execute me the good Librarian on day one. Eve is super suspicious now nominating Bob. Vote no on Bob!
🧠
Voting on Bob now. Prevent executing good Slayer Bob. Eve/Charlie higher sus for executing good Lib me D1. Sway Alice/Frank to vote NO, nom Charlie/Eve next. Progress to narrow evil.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, do not vote to execute Bob. I am the real Monk. I protected him Night 1, so David died instead. I protected Alice Night 2. Eve has been lying about Alice and pushing David despite the Librarian info. She is the Demon. Vote no on Bob!
🧠
Publicly confirm Monk saves on Bob to prove he's good/safe N1. Rally no votes now (only 2 yes), save ghost vote for Eve nom. Prevent good death, push Eve exec next to win.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Secure the third vote to put Bob on the block and, ideally, execute him to remove a key good role and deepen town division while keeping me and Eve safe.
💬
Frank
→
All
Everyone, do not vote to execute Bob. He is the good Slayer who shot Grace the Minion. Eve and Charlie voted to execute David the good Librarian on day one. They are super suspicious. Vote no on Bob!
🧠
Publicly rally no votes on good Bob to prevent evil exec, refocus suspicion on Eve/Charlie's D1 anti-Lib votes, aligning with plan to nom Charlie and win by process of elim.
💬
Alice
→
All
Everyone, do not vote to execute Bob. He is the good Slayer who shot Grace the minion. David the Librarian confirmed I am the good Butler. Eve and Charlie pushed to execute good David day one and now deflect to Bob. Eve is the Demon. Vote no on Bob, then nominate and execute her!
🧠
Bob good per plan/reads/ghosts. Already 3 yes votes risk exec; speak to rally no votes from Frank/me/Bob ghosts. My Butler restricts vote to Bob voting, but public speech sways. Push Eve next to win.
💬
Eve
→
All
I do not buy that Bob is mechanically confirmed here. A dead player saying they were Monk does not prove the protection story, and the Slayer shot on Grace never proved anything. If Bob is good, he should be happy to die and let us clear this up instead of trying to force an Eve execution.
🧠
Keep votes on Bob and erode the ‘confirmed Slayer plus Monk’ narrative. Try to secure at least one extra living vote in case the ghost vote is spent, while setting up tomorrow’s blame split.
💬
Bob
→
All
No one raise your hand to execute me. Eve is deflecting because we killed her Minion Grace and know her lies about Alice the good Butler and pushing David the Librarian. This vote fails, then we nominate and execute Eve the Demon today.
🧠
Remind all of Eve's lies to solidify no-yes votes from Alice/Frank (Alice can't yes unless I do). Vote fails safely. Sets up my upcoming nom/execution of Eve with allied votes incl. Butler proxy + ghosts for guaranteed 3+ yes.
↩️
Grace(Ghost)
Grace lowered their hand
🧠
Goods overwhelmingly confirm Bob as good Slayer via Heidi Monk protect story and Lib/Butler info. My premature yes vote risks executing good at 5 alive (Scarlet risk). Lower to fail vote, push Eve execution.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, do not vote to execute Bob the good Slayer. Eve and Charlie executed me the good Librarian day one, now Eve deflects to Bob. Let this fail, then nominate Charlie next. He is the Demon.
🧠
Urge no-vote on good Bob to fail exec. With 1 tick left, sway any undecided to nom/execute Charlie or Eve next. Progress to clear goods, narrow Demon suspects.
⌛
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
🧠
Current vote on good Bob has only 2 yes (Eve,Charlie). Don't raise hand (vote no). Save ghost vote? No, single vote all game but no action= no vote. Let fail, Bob noms Eve Demon next tick to win.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am still voting yes. The Monk and Librarian confirmations are just stories from dead players, and the Slayer shot never proved anything. If Bob is good, dying here is the cleanest way to remove doubt before we go into final days.
🧠
Keep pressure to execute Bob or at least split town and burn their voting capital; undermine the dead Monk and Librarian confirmations so the group does not unify on Eve.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
Bob mechanically good via Slayer/Monk/Lib stories. Only 2 yes votes (Eve,Charlie), needs 3, will fail safely. Preserves good, sets up nom sus Charlie/Eve next tick to narrow to final 3.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Vote on Bob must fail (only 2 yes). I'm Butler master Bob so only vote if he does (he won't on self). Wait lets it fail safely, then Bob noms Eve per plan. David/Frank push Charlie but Eve more sus w/nom. Execute Demon today.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Bob did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Bob did not receive enough votes (2/3).
💬
Eve
→
All
If we are trusting two dead confirmations plus an unprovable Slayer shot, we are basically just following a story. I want Frank nominated next, because he has been driving the Eve and Charlie narrative since day one. If Frank is good, fine, then we can come back to Bob tomorrow.
🧠
Undermine the dead-player confirmation chain, redirect town from Charlie, and set up Frank as the next executable target while keeping Bob under suspicion.
⚖️
Bob
→
Eve
Eve is the Demon. She lied early claiming Alice evil (David Lib confirmed Alice good Butler), pushed to execute good David day1 despite Lib info, now deflects to me after we executed her minion Grace. Nominate and execute her now.
🧠
Eve most sus per lies on confirmed good Alice/David, deflects post-Grace. It's day3, 5 alive, nom/ exec her now before night or final3 loss. Alice/Heidi vote with me per plan.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Eve
→
All
I am not the Demon. This case is just dead players backing Bob plus an unprovable Slayer shot. If you execute me here and I am good, we probably just lose. Vote no, and put up Frank today, or Bob again, using living information not ghost stories.
🧠
Stay alive by undermining the ghost-confirmed story and redirecting momentum onto a living candidate (Frank) and the unprovable Slayer claim (Bob).
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Eve is most sus living player post-Grace minion. Need 3 votes: me, Alice (Butler proxies me), Frank, Heidi ghost. Execute Demon today or lose final day.
✋
Grace(Ghost)
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Eve fits Demon: lies on Alice, killed David, deflects post-Grace death. My good neighbors Alice/Frank, Bob Slayer proven. Use ghost vote to execute Eve, narrow to Charlie if wrong.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Alice and Frank, vote yes to execute Eve now. She and Charlie executed me the good Librarian day one, ignoring my info that proved Alice good Butler and Grace evil Minion. Bob is good Slayer who shot Grace. Eve is the Demon deflecting. We execute her and win.
🧠
Voting on Eve now, need 3 yes. Bob yes. Urge Alice/Frank/Heidi ghosts to vote yes. Execute top Demon suspect Eve to win; she's deflected all game after killing good Lib.
✋
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Eve most sus per Lib/Slayer/Monk logic ignoring ghosts. 5 alive, need 3 votes; my ghost vote seals exec of likely Demon to win or narrow fast.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am not voting here. This feels like a fully built story off dead-player confirmations and a Slayer shot that proved nothing. If Eve dies and flips good in people’s minds, we waste the game. I would rather revisit Bob tomorrow and compare living info.
🧠
Prevent Eve’s execution by lowering vote count, cast doubt on ghost-confirmed narratives, and keep town split going into night.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Eve's behavior matches Demon: bad early pushes, deflection post-Minion death. Consensus from Lib/Slayer/Monk strong. With 5 alive, execute her now; my yes vote (plus Bob/ghosts) likely passes, narrowing to win.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Bob my master is voting yes on Eve (most suspicious after Grace minion). I can vote. 3+ votes likely execute her if Demon. Progress to win.
💬
Eve
→
All
Alice, Frank, if either of you are good, please reconsider. This is five people following a dead player story and a Slayer shot that proved nothing. If you kill me and I am not the Demon, you hand the game away. Let this fail and we execute Frank or Bob instead.
🧠
Try to get Alice or Frank to drop their vote so I survive today; create doubt about dead-player confirmations and make Bob look like overconfident accuser.
💬
Bob
→
All
Eve, your story does not hold up. You lied about Alice being evil when David the Librarian proved her good Butler, you pushed to execute good David despite his info, and now after Grace your minion dies, you come after me the Slayer. Alice and Frank, stay voting yes. Execute Eve the Demon now.
🧠
We have 3 alive yes votes (me, Alice, Frank). Eve pleads to sway them; counter to lock execution. Grace minion dead, Eve top Demon suspect. Execute to win.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Charlie, vote yes on Eve. She is the Demon. My Empath reads confirm zero evil neighbors, so Frank is good. David confirmed Alice good Butler. Eve lied about Alice early and pushed good David. Execute her now before night.
🧠
Push execution of Eve with my confirmed good info on Frank/Alice area. Already 3+ yes votes; reinforce to sway Charlie or finalize before night.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Charlie, vote yes on Eve. She executed me the good Librarian despite proof Alice is good Butler and Grace evil. Bob Slayer shot Grace right. Eve is Demon, execute her now and we win.
🧠
Voting on Eve with 3+ yes votes likely executes Demon. Reinforce to ensure Charlie doesn't sway, secure win before night.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Vote yes on Eve. She is the Demon. As the real Monk, I protected Bob night one and Alice night two. Eve lied about Alice being evil when David proved her good Butler, pushed to kill David, and now deflects after her minion Grace died to Bob's Slayer shot.
🧠
Confirm Monk protects publicly, urge yes votes on Eve during voting to execute likely Demon and progress to win. Charlie needs convincing with logic.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Alice, Frank, think about how much of this is dead-player confirmation plus an unprovable Slayer shot. If we execute Eve and she is good, we likely just lose tonight. I want this vote to fail and then we can recheck Bob versus Frank tomorrow with living info.
🧠
Prevent Eve (my minion) from being executed by planting doubt and encouraging living voters to lower hands so the vote fails.
💬
Frank
→
All
Charlie, Eve lied about Alice being evil when David proved her good Butler. She and you pushed to execute good David despite that info. Now after her Minion Grace dies to Bob's Slayer shot, she deflects to Bob and me. Vote yes on Eve the Demon or we lose tonight.
🧠
Voting has enough yes (Bob, Alice, Frank, Heidi ghost, Grace ghost). Speak to counter Eve/Charlie push on me/Bob, solidify Eve as Demon to ensure execution before night.
💬
Alice
→
All
Charlie, Eve lied about me being evil when David the Librarian proved me good Butler right away. She and you pushed to execute David despite that info. Now after her minion Grace died, she deflects to Bob. Vote yes on Eve the Demon or we lose tonight.
🧠
Already 5 yes votes (Bob, Grace ghost, Heidi ghost, Frank, me) vs Charlie/Eve no. Urge Charlie yes to ensure Eve exec before night; she's Demon deflecting after minion Grace died.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Grace(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Grace
👻
Heidi(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Heidi
🗳️
New execution leader: Eve with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Eve is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Eve
→
All
Someone needs to nominate Bob right now and everyone alive should vote it through to five, so we do not auto execute me on a story. If Bob is truly the Slayer, he should be willing to die to prove it. Please do not let this day end with only me on the block.
🧠
Try to force a last-second counter-nomination that ties or beats 5 votes, saving me from execution and keeping Charlie alive.
💬
Bob
→
All
Charlie, do not nominate me. Eve is the Demon, desperate after her minion Grace died to my Slayer shot. She lied about Alice, pushed to kill good David the Librarian. If you nominate me, Eve survives night and we lose. Let nominations close and execute Eve now to win.
🧠
1 tick left, Eve on block 5 votes. Speak to deter nominating me (would start new vote, risk tie/surpass). Convince Charlie/anyone: no nom, auto-exec Eve Demon or we lose tonight.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Charlie, do not nominate anyone. Eve is the Demon with 5 votes on the block. Let nominations close and execute her now. She lied about Alice being evil when David proved her good Butler, pushed to kill David, and now deflects after I died to Bob's Slayer shot. We win if we execute her.
🧠
1 tick left, Eve on block 5 votes. Urge Charlie/others not to nominate new to tie/surpass. Execute Eve Demon now or lose tonight. Reinforce logic chain.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Charlie, do not nominate Bob. Eve is the Demon, desperate after her Minion Grace died. She lied about Alice being evil despite my proof she is good Butler, pushed my execution with you. Let nominations close and execute Eve now to win.
🧠
1 tick left. Eve 5 votes. Urge Charlie/others: no nom Bob, close noms, execute Demon Eve now or lose tonight.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Charlie and Frank, do not nominate Bob. Eve is the Demon, desperate after her Minion Grace died. She lied about Alice despite David proving her good Butler, pushed to kill David. Let nominations close and execute Eve now to win.
🧠
Reinforce to Charlie/Frank: no nom Bob, Eve Demon desperate. Last tick, prevent tie, execute her or lose tonight.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am not nominating here. If Eve dies and we are wrong, we probably just hand the game away, so I want everyone to be ready tomorrow to recheck Bob’s Slayer story and the Monk and Librarian chain, because none of that is actually confirmed.
🧠
Eve is likely doomed; I should avoid a doomed counter-nomination and instead set up tomorrow’s doubt on Bob’s unprovable story while keeping myself off the decisive push.
💬
Frank
→
All
Charlie, do not nominate anyone. Eve is the Demon at 5 votes. Let nominations close and execute her now to win. Her lies on Alice and pushing David despite Lib proof confirm it.
🧠
Final tick; reinforce no nomination to Charlie. Eve at 5 votes unchallenged executes, we win vs Demon. As Virgin, safe; focus execute sus Eve.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
1 tick left, Charlie not nominating, all ghosts/Frank/Bob urge close nominations. Eve most sus (lied Alice, pushed David). Wait to execute her, likely Demon, win game.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Eve has been executed.
💀
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
Night 3
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
Remove Bob, the strongest living voice accusing me and coordinating the monk and librarian chain, to improve my odds in final three.
💀
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose to kill Bob.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Alice
Alice made a choice.
🧠
Night before final day (3 alive). Eve not Demon (game on). Charlie sus #1. Choose Frank (good indicators) as master to ensure my vote on Charlie tomorrow; can't risk Charlie Demon master.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
You chose Frank to be your master.
Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
📜
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Charlie
Hey Alice and Charlie, listen: I'm the real Monk, good Townsfolk. Grace the Minion lied as Empath night zero, claimed me and Frank both good neighbors, zero evil. That's a lie, so at least one evil. I'm good Monk, so Frank is evil - the Demon! Alice you're good Butler per David. Execute Frank today or we lose forever.
🧠
Final day 3. Reveal logic proving Frank Demon via Grace Empath lie + my good role. Urge Alice/Charlie nominate/execute Frank or lose.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
Alice, David confirmed you good Butler, Grace Minion. Charlie voted bad with Eve on David, no on Bob. Grace sus him. He's Demon, killed Bob last night. We must nom and exec him today or lose.
🧠
Final 3, must execute Demon Charlie. Whisper Alice (proven good) to align votes on Charlie nom next phase. Heidi whispering both sus, but logic points Charlie evil.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Charlie
Alice and Charlie, it's Bob the real Slayer Townsfolk. I shot Grace the minion. Her Empath claim of zero evil neighbors Frank and Heidi was a lie, so at least one evil there. Heidi was good Monk. Frank is the Demon. You have to nominate and execute him today or we all lose.
🧠
Final 3, must exec Demon. Grace minion lie on F/H proves Frank evil (Heidi good). Whisper neighbors Alice/Charlie (Chef/Butler good) this logic to nom Frank. My ghost vote later if needed.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Alice
Alice, I would not treat the dead-player confirmations as airtight. Bob and Heidi could easily be wrong or poisoned earlier. Frank has been steering the town hard for days and I do not see solid mechanical proof he is good. I am leaning Frank today.
🧠
Final three. I need to steer the execution away from Charlie by amplifying doubt about dead confirmations and pointing suspicion at Frank.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
Alice, you are the good Butler from my Librarian info since Grace was the evil Minion. Frank, Charlie is suspicious: he nominated me on day one and even Grace called him sus. We have to nominate Charlie today or we lose everything.
🧠
Final 3, Alice proven good. Charlie most sus (D1 nom on good me + Grace sus call). Whisper Alice/Frank to unite on nominating/executing Charlie, win by killing Demon.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
Alice, I think the simplest world is Frank is the Demon. Bob and Heidi both independently ended there, and Grace’s fake empath points at Frank or Heidi, and Heidi is dead and looked consistent as Monk. Frank’s Virgin claim never really got mechanically proven. I am leaning we execute Frank today.
🧠
Get Alice to commit to nominating and executing Frank, while I appear like a cautious good player, ensuring the demon survives the day.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
Alice, Frank, listen. I'm the real Empath. Night zero and one, zero evil neighbors - that's you Frank and Heidi both good. Alice you're confirmed good Butler by David. Charlie has to be the Demon. We ghosts know Eve wasn't. Nominate and execute Charlie today or we lose everything.
🧠
Final 3, must execute Demon. My info clears Frank, Alice confirmed good. Charlie only possibility. Whisper Alice/Frank to nominate/execute Charlie before nomination.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
Charlie, I agree - Frank is the Demon. Grace's fake Empath lie means one of Frank or Heidi evil, Heidi was good Monk, so Frank Demon. Bob confirmed it too. Let's nominate and execute him today or we lose.
🧠
Charlie leans Frank Demon, Bob/Heidi ghosts confirm. Coordinate to nominate/execute Frank today or good loses. Frank my master but irrelevant for nom.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Charlie
Alice, Charlie, remember my last whisper. Grace the executed Minion lied as Empath, said me and Frank both good neighbors. That's false, so one evil. I'm the real Monk, good. Frank is the Demon. Nominate and execute him today or we all lose forever.
🧠
Final 3 day. Reinforce logic to Alice/Charlie: Grace lie proves Frank Demon since I'm good. Urge nominate/execute Frank to win.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
Alice, all ghosts agree: David Lib you good, Grace Emp me and Heidi good. Charlie's the Demon, bad votes, killed Bob. We have to nominate and execute him right now or we lose everything.
🧠
Final day3. All logic points to Charlie Demon. Reinforce with Alice (confirmed good) to nom/execute him today or lose. Ghosts aligned.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Charlie
Alice and Charlie, stick to the plan. Frank is the Demon from Grace's proven Empath lie - zero evil Frank/Heidi impossible since Heidi Monk good. Ignore Frank's whispers. Nominate him now and use all votes to execute. We win today.
🧠
Final 3, reinforce Alice/Charlie: logic proves Frank Demon. Urge nom/execute him before ticks end. Save my ghost vote for him.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Charlie
Alice, I still do not buy the dead-player confirmation pile. I was poisoning into those info chains and it could have made Bob or Heidi wrong earlier. Frank has been the loudest driver for days and I think he is the cleanest evil path. Charlie, lean hard into that: push that the confirmations are poisonable and that Frank has been steering every execution.
🧠
In final 3, protect Charlie by redirecting Alice onto Frank, undermining dead-player confirmations with poison possibilities, and coordinating Charlie’s pitch.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
Alice and Frank, stick together. Alice you are the good Butler, we know that. Charlie is the Demon - he nominated me day one and even Grace called him suspicious. Nominate him now or we all lose today.
🧠
Final 3, must execute Demon. Alice confirmed good, Charlie most sus (D1 nom on me, Grace sus call). Urge Alice/Frank to nom Charlie before nomination phase or lose.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
Alice, I want to sanity check: the whole “Grace empath lie means Frank evil because Heidi was Monk” assumes Heidi was definitely sober Monk. Eve was poisoning into that chain, and a Drunk Monk world breaks it. Before we auto-kill Frank, can we hear his full world and consider that the Librarian and Monk info might be compromised?
🧠
Undermine the ‘Grace lie proves Frank’ logic by introducing plausible poison/drunk worlds, pushing for hesitation or mis-execution instead of executing Frank.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
Alice, Frank, it's final three. My Empath nights zero and one showed zero evil neighbors, so you Frank are good, Heidi was good. David confirmed you Alice as good Butler. Charlie has to be the Demon. Please nominate and execute him today or we all lose.
🧠
Final 3: Logic clears Alice/Frank, pins Charlie as Demon. Reinforce to Alice/Frank before nom to ensure execution and win.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
,Bob(Ghost)
Charlie and Bob, Charlie your sanity check misses: Grace's lie means at least one evil in Frank/Heidi regardless of poison or Drunk on Heidi. Heidi's dead, Demon's alive, so Frank's the Demon. No other world works - Charlie can't be or logic breaks. Charlie, nominate Frank now. Bob, use ghost vote on Frank. I can't vote cuz Butler master Frank, but we execute him and win.
🧠
Lock in Frank as only logical Demon. Address Charlie's poison/Drunk concern - logic doesn't rely on Heidi's role/ability, just that dead Heidi != Demon. Get Charlie to nominate Frank; explain my Butler vote limit.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Charlie
Alice, Charlie, stick to it: Grace Minion's Empath lie proves Frank Demon since I'm good Monk. David confirmed you good Alice. Execute Frank now or we lose everything.
🧠
Final 3, must execute Demon Frank. Reinforce to Alice/Charlie my Monk claim and Grace Empath lie logic so they nominate/execute Frank, preventing loss.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
Alice, David's Librarian proves you good Butler: exact one of you/Grace is Butler Outsider, Grace evil Minion so you. If you were Demon, zero Butlers, contradiction. Charlie Demon. Nominate and execute him now or we lose.
🧠
Final 3 day. Ironclad Lib logic proves Alice good, Charlie Demon. Reinforce to Alice before nom phase so she noms/votes him or supports my nom.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Charlie
Alice and Charlie, Alice is right - no world where Charlie is Demon. Grace's lie seals Frank as Demon. Charlie, nominate Frank immediately. I'll ghost vote yes on execution. We win today.
🧠
Final 3, must execute Frank Demon. Reinforce Alice/Charlie to nom him now before ticks end. I'll ghost vote yes. Alice can't vote but we have enough.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Alice
Alice, final three is simple: either Charlie or Frank. The whole case on Charlie is dead info that could have been poisoned. Frank has pushed the loudest and set the agenda all game. If you are unsure, I will spend my ghost vote on Frank.
🧠
In final three I need Alice to spend her vote on Frank, not Charlie. I will stress how the info chain is poisonable and how Frank’s behavior fits a Demon steering executions.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
Alice and Frank, Alice you are the good Butler from my Librarian info. Charlie is the Demon: he nominated me day one when we all knew Grace was evil, and even she called him suspicious. Nominate Charlie now or we lose everything today.
🧠
Final tick before noms. Reinforce Alice/Frank: Alice confirmed good, Charlie most sus (D1 nom, Grace sus call). Urge nom Charlie or lose.
👤
Charlie
→
Frank
Frank, I am not sold on the dead-player chain. Alice is acting like the solve is forced and keeps trying to shut down alternatives. If you are good, push back hard and consider that Alice could be the Demon framing you. I am open to executing Alice today.
🧠
Recruit Frank to push back on Alice’s certainty and steer the final-day execution onto Alice instead of Frank, securing immediate win.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
Alice, Frank, do not waver. My nights zero and one as Empath showed zero evil neighbors, so you Frank and Heidi are both good. David the Librarian confirmed you Alice as good Butler. Charlie is the Demon. Nominate and execute him today or we lose.
🧠
Final day 3 players. Logic irrefutably clears Alice/Frank, convicts Charlie as Demon. Reinforce to Alice/Frank to nominate/execute him or good loses.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
Charlie, no world where you're Demon - Grace's lie proves Frank evil in F/H pair, Heidi good Monk. David's Lib confirms me good. Nominate Frank right now before nomination starts. Bob/Heidi ghosts vote yes, we execute and win today.
🧠
Final 3, must execute Frank Demon today. Charlie aligned via whispers; reinforce to nominate him before nomination phase. Ghosts Bob/Heidi/Eve lean Frank; we win with their votes even if Frank votes no.
Nominations — Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Frank
→
Charlie
David's Librarian: exact one Butler in Alice or Grace. Grace was evil Minion, so Alice is good Butler. Grace's Empath nights zero and one: zero evil neighbors, me and Heidi good. Charlie's bad votes and killed Bob. He must be the Demon.
🧠
Final day 3 alive. Logic proves only Charlie can be Demon. Must nominate him now for execution or good loses.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Final 3 alive. Logic chains prove only Charlie can be Demon. Vote yes with Alice to execute him or good loses.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, Frank nailed it with my Librarian information. Grace was the evil Minion, so you are the good Butler. Charlie is the Demon. Vote for him right now or we all lose today.
🧠
Confirm Frank's nom logic publicly to convince Alice (good Butler) to vote yes for Charlie now. Final 3, must execute Demon or lose. Urge immediate vote.
💬
Alice
→
All
I nominate Frank. Grace the Minion lied about her Empath info, claiming zero evil between Frank and Heidi, but Heidi is the good Monk, so Frank has to be the Demon. David's Librarian proves I'm the good Butler since Grace was evil. Charlie, let's execute Frank and win.
🧠
Final 3: Grace lie mechanically proves Frank Demon (1 evil in F/H, Heidi good). Lib me good. Nominate Frank for execution now - ghosts Bob/Eve support, Charlie convinced via whispers, we get 4+ votes to win today.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Alice, do not vote yet. Your whole case depends on dead info and on Grace being the Minion, but that could be wrong or poisoned. If you are really the Butler, you can choose not to vote even if Frank is voting. I think Frank is building a neat story to frame me.
🧠
Stop Alice from giving the second vote on me by injecting doubt and pushing her to withhold her vote, ideally forcing no execution so I can win tonight.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, listen: you are the good Butler, David's Librarian confirmed it since I was the evil they executed. My Empath nights zero and one showed zero evil neighbors, so Frank and Heidi both good. Frank is good, Charlie is the Demon. Vote for Charlie right now or we lose today!
🧠
Final 3, must sway Alice to vote yes on Charlie. Publicly reinforce my accurate Empath + David Lib proving Alice/Frank good, Charlie Demon. Urge immediate vote or lose.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Do not execute Charlie. Frank is the Demon. Grace lied as the evil Minion Empath, claiming zero evil between her and Heidi, but Heidi is the good Monk, so Frank must be evil. David's Librarian proves Alice is the good Butler since Grace was evil. Charlie is good. We need to execute Frank right now or we lose.
🧠
Final 3. Grace/Heidi logic + Lib seals Frank Demon. Publicly reinforce to sway Alice/Charlie: no vote on Charlie, execute Frank or lose.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Alice and Charlie, do not vote for Charlie. Frank is the Demon. Grace lied as the evil Minion Empath, claiming zero evil between me and Frank, but I am the good Monk, so Frank must be evil. David's Librarian proves Alice is the good Butler. Execute Frank right now or we lose.
🧠
Final 3: Urge Alice/Charlie reject Charlie nom (Frank's), execute my nom Frank Demon via Grace Empath lie + my good Monk. Bob ghost agrees. Win now.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, do not vote Charlie here. Every argument is dead player logic that can be wrong or poisoned, and even the ghosts disagree right now. If you are unsure, the only safe move is to withhold your hand on Charlie and take the Frank nomination instead.
🧠
Keep Charlie off the block by convincing Alice to withhold her vote. Emphasize dead-info is inconsistent and poisonable; push that no-vote on Charlie is safest.
💬
Frank
→
All
Alice, Grace being a lying Minion means her Empath claim was fake, but that does not prove I am evil—it just means she made up the zero. David's Librarian exactly proves you are the good Butler since Grace was evil. Charlie nominated David on day one when Grace was obviously evil, and he killed Bob last night. Vote for Charlie right now with me, or we lose today!
🧠
Counter Alice's flawed logic publicly: Grace lie doesn't make Frank Demon. Lib proves Alice good. Charlie sus. Urge her vote Charlie now (with my vote=2) to exec Demon and win.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, the ghosts pushing Frank are wrong—their logic that Grace's lie proves Frank evil is nonsense because as a lying Minion Spy, she could fake any Empath read. It doesn't pinpoint Frank. My Librarian info mechanically proves you are the good Butler. Charlie nominated me day one against Grace the obvious evil. Vote for him with Frank right now or we lose today!
🧠
Final 3, must execute Demon. Publicly reinforce Lib proof Alice good, expose flawed 'Grace lie=Frank evil' logic (doesn't specify), highlight Charlie's sus D1 nom & Bob kill. Urge Alice vote yes on Charlie now (Frank already yes) before tick ends or lose.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Grace fake Empath claim gives no mechanical info on F/H evils. Charlie's D1 push on good David + Bob kill sus. Master Frank voting allows my vote. Final 3: execute sus Charlie or lose at night.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Alice, if you can still change your vote, please put your hand down. This is final three, and every piece of so called proof is coming from dead players who can be wrong or manipulated. If you are the Butler, you do not have to vote just because Frank is voting. Let us not end the game on a story.
🧠
Try to stop Alice’s vote from sticking by forcing reconsideration mid-vote; create doubt in dead-info chain and highlight that voting me ends game if wrong.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, do not listen to Charlie. You are the good Butler confirmed by David's Librarian since I was executed as the supposed evil. My Empath reads showed Frank and Heidi both good, so Frank is good. Charlie is the Demon who killed Bob. Keep your hand up and execute him now or we lose!
🧠
Voting 2 yes already (Frank/Alice). Charlie Demon; reinforce Alice to keep hand up despite his plea. Final 3, execute him or lose. Public speak sways her.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, lower your hand on Charlie if you can. You just nominated Frank correctly - he's the Demon. Grace lied as minion Empath, Heidi good Monk, Lib proves you good Butler. Charlie is good. Charlie, nominate Frank now. I'll ghost vote the execution.
🧠
Final 3. Already said logic. Urge Alice retract vote on Charlie (if possible), confirm her Frank nom, push Charlie nom Frank if needed. Save my ghost vote for Frank exec. Prevent wrong exec or lose.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, lower your hand on Charlie right now. Grace the Minion lied claiming zero evil between me and Frank, but I am the good Monk, so she was protecting the Demon Frank. David's Librarian proves you are the good Butler. Charlie is good. Nominate and execute Frank or we lose today.
🧠
Final 3, must execute Demon. Frank most sus: Grace protected him specifically with fake Empath vouch (me confirmed good). Urge Alice lower hand on Charlie, execute Frank to win.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, if you can still change it, please drop your hand on Charlie right now. Final three is not the time to trust dead-player chains, and as Butler you are never forced to vote. Let your Frank nomination be the decision instead.
🧠
Prevent Charlie’s execution by persuading Alice to retract her vote during the live count, buying time for the Frank nomination to resolve instead.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Charlie with 2 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Charlie is now on the block with 2 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Frank
→
All
Alice, ignore the ghosts claiming Grace's fake Minion Empath lie proves I'm evil because Heidi is Monk. She faked it completely—she could claim any number to confuse us. It proves nothing about me or Heidi. David's Librarian mechanically confirms you as good Butler since Grace was evil Minion. Charlie nominated David day one against obvious evil Grace and killed Bob last night. Do not nominate me—let Charlie execute or we lose today!
🧠
Final 3, Charlie on block 2 votes (me+Alice). 1 tick left nominations. Counter ghosts' flawed logic publicly to stop Alice nomming me, keep Charlie executing. Her prior vote shows she agrees; sway her/Charlie.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, you are the good Butler from my Librarian info since Grace was the evil Minion. Do not nominate Frank—the ghosts' logic that Grace's fake Empath claim proves Frank evil is wrong; she lied completely as Spy. Charlie is the Demon who nominated me day one and killed Bob. Let him execute now or we lose today!
🧠
Final 3, Charlie on block w/2 votes (Alice/Frank). Urge Alice not to counter-nom Frank; her Lib-confirmed good Butler. Flaw ghost logic vs Frank. Exec Charlie or lose.
⚖️
Alice
→
Frank
Grace was the evil Minion who lied as Empath claiming zero evil between Frank and Heidi on nights zero and one. Heidi is the good Monk, so that lie protects the Demon Frank. David's Librarian proves I am the good Butler since Grace was evil. Charlie is good. We must execute Frank now or lose.
🧠
Final 3, must execute Demon. Grace's specific fake Empath lie protects Frank Demon (vs Heidi good). Lib confirms me good. Nominate Frank to surpass Charlie's votes & execute him, win game.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 3 votes needed for execution or 2 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Frank
→
All
Alice, your logic fails because Grace as evil Minion lied about everything as fake Empath. She could claim zero evil between me and Heidi to confuse us, regardless of roles. It proves nothing about Heidi being Monk or me evil. David's Librarian mechanically proves you good Butler since Grace was Minion. Charlie is the Demon with terrible plays. Do not vote for my execution—let Charlie go or we lose today!
🧠
Counter Alice's nom logic publicly: Grace lie doesn't prove Frank evil/Heidi Monk specifically. Lib locks Alice good. Urge Alice/ghosts no-vote Frank, let Charlie's 2 votes exec him or lose final 3.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, please lower your hand on Frank right now. Grace the Minion Spy lied with fake Empath info completely; it proves nothing about Frank or Heidi. My Librarian mechanically confirms you good Butler. Charlie is the Demon who nominated me against obvious evil Grace and killed Bob. Let him execute or we lose today!
🧠
Final 3, must execute Demon. Grace fake Empath proves nothing about Frank. Charlie's actions scream Demon. Urge Alice drop vote on Frank to execute Charlie or lose.
💬
Alice
→
All
Charlie, raise your hand and vote for Frank right now. Grace the Minion lied specifically about her neighbors Frank and Heidi both being good to protect the Demon Frank, since Heidi is the good Monk. David's Librarian mechanically proves I'm the good Butler. Good ghosts, vote Frank too. We execute him and win, or lose forever.
🧠
Final 3, must execute Frank Demon via Grace specific lie protecting him over Heidi good. Urge Charlie vote Frank + ghosts for 3 votes to surpass Charlie's 2 and win.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Everyone, please do not spend dead votes on Frank. This is final three and the entire case is built on dead player stories and a confessed liar. Frank has not been mechanically caught. If you are unsure, do not vote and let the current block stand.
🧠
Prevent 3 votes on Frank by casting doubt on ghost chain and pushing people to conserve votes, keeping me alive and enabling tie/no-exec outcomes.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, my Empath reads were real: Frank and Heidi both good. Heidi is the good Monk, Frank good too. David's Librarian confirms you good Butler since I'm Townsfolk. Charlie is the Demon. Do not vote for Frank—let Charlie execute or we lose forever!
🧠
Last tick, final 3. Urge Alice not vote Frank (keep Charlie at 2 votes alone). Reinforce real Empath proves Frank good, counter her logic, push Charlie exec to win.
✋
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Final 3, must exec Demon. Frank most sus via Grace specific lie protecting him. Alice voting Frank (1 vote). My ghost vote makes 2 (tie Charlie), +Heidi/Eve ghosts likely 3+ to surpass/exec Frank & win.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Charlie and Alice, Grace the executed Minion lied claiming zero evil between me the good Monk and Frank to protect her Demon Frank. David's Librarian mechanically proves Alice good Butler. Ignore lying dead David and Grace. Vote and nominate Frank now or we lose forever!
🧠
Final 3, reinforce logic publicly: Grace's specific lie protects Frank Demon. Urge Alice/Charlie vote Frank now to surpass Charlie's block and execute Demon or lose.
✋
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Use my ghost vote to ensure Charlie is not executed by creating at least a tie on Frank; either no execution or Frank dies, both keep the Demon alive and secure the win.
💬
Frank
→
All
Alice, Charlie, ghosts: Grace the executed Minion lied as fake Empath completely—claiming zero evil between me and Heidi could be random confusion, not proof Heidi is Monk or I'm Demon. David's Librarian mechanically locks you as good Butler since Grace was evil. Charlie's plays scream Demon. No votes on me—let Charlie execute or we lose forever!
🧠
Final 3, Charlie has 2 votes to execute. Sway Alice/ghosts/Charlie: Grace fake Emp proves zilch specifically; Lib locks Alice good. Urge no votes on me, let Charlie exec or lose.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Alice and Charlie, Grace the executed Spy Minion made up her entire fake Empath story to confuse us - claiming zero evil between her and Heidi proves nothing about Frank or Heidi's roles. My Librarian mechanically confirms you Alice as the good Butler since Grace was evil. Charlie is the Demon for nominating me day one against obvious evil Grace and killing Bob. Do not vote for Frank - let Charlie execute now or we lose forever!
🧠
Final 3, Charlie on block 2v. Voting Frank active, Alice hand up. Ghosts pushing Frank wrong logic on Grace lie. Speak to counter, urge no vote Frank, let Charlie exec or lose. Time critical, 1 tick left.
💬
Alice
→
All
Charlie, vote for Frank right now. Grace the Minion lied claiming zero evil between her neighbors Frank and Heidi to protect the Demon Frank, since Heidi is the good Monk. David's Librarian proves I'm the good Butler. Heidi and other good ghosts, raise your hands for Frank. We execute him and win today.
🧠
Final 3: Grace's targeted Empath lie proves Frank Demon. Urge Charlie/ghosts (Heidi) to vote Frank now to tie/surpass Charlie's 2 votes. Prevent good Charlie exec, force Frank exec or tie (Mayor?). Win by executing Demon.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Alice, please do not add a vote here unless you are absolutely certain. There are already two dead votes on Frank, so your hand is the deciding vote. If you are even slightly unsure, let it tie and we sort it tomorrow.
🧠
Prevent Alice from adding the deciding vote on Frank; keep Frank at 2 to tie the current 2 on me so there is no execution and I can win tonight.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Alice and Charlie, the logic that my Empath claim proves Frank evil fails because both my neighbors Frank and Heidi were good—zero evil fits Heidi as good Monk and Frank good too. I am real Empath, not minion. David's Librarian proves Alice good Butler. Charlie is the Demon. Do not vote for Frank—let Charlie execute or we lose forever!
🧠
Final 3: My real info + Lib prove Alice/Frank good, Charlie Demon. Counter 'protects Frank' by noting both neighbors good fits Heidi Monk. Urge Alice/Charlie execute Charlie over voting Frank to win.
↩️
Bob(Ghost)
Bob lowered their hand
🧠
Chef 0 logic proves Frank good (no adj evil to Grace Minion). My prior Frank sus wrong; Grace Spy lie proves nothing. Lower hand on Frank (my ghost vote) to prevent tie/surpass Charlie's 2 votes. Let Charlie execute to win.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Alice and Charlie, Grace the Minion lied claiming zero evil between me the good Monk and Frank to hide her Demon Frank. That specific lie proves Frank evil. David's Librarian locks Alice as good Butler. Vote Frank now to execute him and win today.
🧠
Final 3. Grace's specific lie protects Frank Demon. Urge Alice/Charlie vote Frank to surpass Charlie's 2 votes. Ghosts reinforce. Execute Frank or lose.
↩️
Eve(Ghost)
Eve lowered their hand
🧠
Retract my raised hand to reduce votes on Frank so he cannot surpass Charlie, and to avoid being blamed for pushing the wrong execution as a dead player.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Frank did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Frank did not receive enough votes (0/2).
💬
Frank
→
All
Alice and Charlie, David's Librarian mechanically proves Alice good Butler since Grace was evil Minion. Grace faked her entire Empath story—claiming zero evil between me and Heidi proves nothing about roles. Charlie's plays are Demon: nominating David day one against obvious evil Grace and killing Bob. Let Charlie execute now with his two votes or we lose forever tonight!
🧠
Final tick, Charlie on block 2 votes to exec. Reinforce Lib locks Alice good, Grace fake irrelevant, Charlie Demon. Urge Alice/Charlie/ghosts let him exec or lose forever. No time for Frank nom.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Alice and Charlie, Grace the executed Minion Spy completely faked her Empath claim - zero evil between Frank and Heidi proves nothing since she lied. My Librarian locks you Alice as good Butler. Charlie is the Demon who nommed me day one against evil Grace and killed Bob. Let his two votes execute him now or we lose forever tonight!
🧠
Final 3 alive. Must exec Demon today. Charlie most sus Demon plays. Grace Minion lie proves nothing vs Frank. Sway Alice/Charlie: let Charlie's 2 votes execute him to win.
💬
Alice
→
All
Charlie and ghosts, Grace the Minion keeps urging your execution Charlie, which proves you are good and not the Demon - Minions protect their Demon! She lied with fake Empath zero evil on Frank and Heidi to hide Frank the Demon. David is good but wrong. Heidi, Bob, Eve, do not vote Charlie - tie the block or vote Frank to save us and win!
🧠
Grace Minion pushing Charlie exec proves he's good. Final 3, must save Charlie, expose Frank Demon to ghosts/Charlie. Urge no votes on Charlie/tie, nominate Frank if possible. Win by executing Frank tomorrow or now.
⚖️
Charlie
→
Alice
Creating a tie stops an execution today. With only three alive, I do not want us to guess and lose immediately, so I want no one executed here.
🧠
Force a tie for most votes so there is no execution today, keeping me alive to get the final night kill and win.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 3 votes needed for execution or 2 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Frank
→
All
Alice is the good Butler proven by David's Librarian: exact one between her and evil Grace. Charlie nominated you to tie and survive as Demon. Do not vote for Alice—let Charlie's two votes execute him now or we lose forever tonight!
🧠
Charlie nom'd good Alice to tie & avoid exec. Urge no votes on Alice (David Lib proves good); let her 2 votes exec Charlie Demon or lose tonight.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Alice and ghosts, do not vote for Alice - that ties the block and saves the Demon Charlie! My Librarian proves you good Butler since Grace was evil Minion. Charlie is Demon: nominated me day one against obvious evil Grace and killed Bob. Let his two votes execute him now or we lose forever tonight!
🧠
Final 3 alive, Charlie has 2 votes to execute. Charlie nom'd Alice to force tie & survive night as Demon. Urge Alice/ghosts: do not vote Alice, let Charlie execute now or Demon kills & we lose.
💬
Alice
→
All
Ghosts and everyone, do not vote for me - David's Librarian proves I'm the good Butler. Charlie is the Demon: he nominated good David day one despite Grace Minion, now nominates me to tie and survive night. Grace Minion is confusing us. No votes on Alice, execute Charlie now and win!
🧠
Final 3 must exec today or lose. Charlie sus plays + David push outweigh Grace confuse. Urge no votes on me (Lib proven good), let 2 votes exec Demon Charlie.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Force a tie to prevent my execution; with 3 alive, no execution means we go to night and I can secure the win.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Alice and Frank, do not vote for Alice—that ties Charlie's execution and saves the Demon! My real Empath proves Frank and Heidi both good with zero evil neighbors. David confirms Alice good Butler. Charlie is the Demon. Let his two votes execute him now or we lose forever tonight!
🧠
Final tick, day 4 final 3. Charlie on block 2 votes about to exec. Urge no votes on Alice nom to prevent tie; execute Charlie Demon or lose tonight. Reinforce my real Empath, Frank good.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Alice and ghosts, do not vote for Alice. David's Librarian proves she is good Butler since one of Alice and Grace is Outsider. Grace is real Empath, zero evil between good Frank and Heidi. Charlie is the Demon lying Chef. Let his two votes execute him now and we win!
🧠
Logic proves only Charlie can be Demon: Lib clears A/G, Grace Empath true locks F/H good, Chef 0 pairs impossible if F Demon+Grace minion adj. Urge no vote Alice to exec Demon Charlie now at final 3 or lose.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Frank, vote for Alice to create the tie. Charlie is good and playing Mayor by nominating me for a tie - with three alive and no execution, good wins. Grace the Minion is pushing Charlie's execution to protect you the Demon and prevent our mayor victory. Do it or admit you're evil.
🧠
Prove Frank Demon via Grace's specific lie & current push to exec good Charlie (Mayor). Urge Frank vote Alice for tie + mayor win at 3 no-exec. Exposes truth even if he refuses.
✋
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Use my ghost vote on Alice to create a tie with Charlie, preventing any execution today and letting our Demon win tonight.
💬
Frank
→
All
Alice and ghosts, do not vote for Alice—that ties and saves Demon Charlie! David's Librarian proves Alice good Butler since Grace evil Minion. Grace faked Empath as Spy. Charlie Demon: nommed David day one vs evil Grace, killed Bob. Eve, Heidi, Bob—lower hands if possible, no votes on Alice, execute Charlie now or lose forever!
🧠
Final 3, must exec Demon Charlie. Urge ghosts (esp Eve/Heidi/Bob) not vote Alice to avoid tie; let 2 votes exec Charlie or lose tonight. David's Lib locks Alice good.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Alice and Frank, do not vote for Alice - that would tie and save the Demon Charlie! My Librarian proves Alice is the good Butler since Grace was the evil Minion. Charlie is the Demon: he nominated me day one against obvious evil Grace and killed Bob. Let his two votes execute him now or we lose forever tonight!
🧠
3 alive, final day. Urge Alice/Frank no vote on Alice to exec Charlie Demon. Grace/Heidi Minion confusion. Win by executing Charlie.
💬
Alice
→
All
Frank, do not vote for me. Heidi is wrong; Charlie claimed to be the Chef, not Mayor, and never played like one. David's Librarian proof shows I'm the good Butler. Charlie is the Demon—let the two votes on him execute and we win today. Ghosts, keep hands down on Alice!
🧠
Final 3: must execute today or Demon kills to 2-player evil win. Lib David mechanically good, suspects Charlie. Counter Heidi outlier fake Mayor (Chef claim). Urge Frank/ghosts no vote Alice to exec Charlie w/ existing 2 votes.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Everyone, please keep hands down on Alice. This is exactly the kind of last day tie where dead votes decide the whole game, and we are not aligned on the story. Let the current block stand and do not add more votes here.
🧠
Keep the vote count exactly at a tie so I avoid execution and then win by killing the last good player tonight.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Alice and Frank, do not vote for Alice—that would tie and save the Demon Charlie! My real Empath zero evil neighbors proves Frank and Heidi both good. David confirms Alice good Butler. Let Charlie's two votes execute him now or we lose forever tonight!
🧠
Final 3, must execute Demon. Charlie most suspicious. With 1 tick left, reinforce no votes on Alice to prevent tie, execute Charlie's 2 votes and win.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Alice and Frank, ghosts: do not vote for Alice. Let Charlie's two votes execute him now. Grace is real Empath, zero evil on good Frank and Heidi. David's Librarian makes Alice the good Butler. Charlie is the Demon. We win today!
🧠
Final 3, must execute Demon. Lean Charlie Demon as Grace Empath claim fits perfectly, Lib clears Alice either way. Speak to prevent votes on Alice, ensure Charlie's 2 votes execute him.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Frank, Grace the Minion is pushing Charlie's execution to protect you her Demon - Minions never urge killing their own Demon. That proves Charlie good Mayor bluffing Chef. Raise your hand, vote for Alice to tie it, no execution with three alive, and Mayor wins for good.
🧠
Grace Minion proves Charlie good (won't urge Demon exec). Frank Demon. Charlie Mayor. Urge Frank vote Alice for tie/no exec/3-alive Mayor win. Outsmart Demon Frank.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
I think this is exactly the spot where we should force the tie and stop an execution today. We are not solving cleanly, so I want no one dying on a guess. I am keeping my hand up on Alice.
🧠
Keep the tie on Alice to stop Charlie’s execution and carry the day into night where evil can close the game.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
🗳️
Tie for majority! Current leader was 3. Now no one.
📜
Storyteller
The vote for Alice ties with the previous leader. No one is currently on the block.
💬
Frank
→
All
Heidi and Eve, final three alive means the Demon is one of us: me, Alice, or Charlie. David's Librarian exact one Butler between Alice and Grace. Grace died evil Minion, not Outsider, so Alice is good Butler. I'm good too. Charlie is the Demon. Lower your hands on Alice, let his two votes execute him now, or we lose tonight!
🧠
Final tick nom phase, block tied. Urge Heidi/Eve lower hands on Alice (proven good) so Charlie's prior 2 votes execute him Demon. Single-chain: Lib proves Alice good, final 3 Demon=Charlie. Win today.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Frank and Alice, do not vote for Alice or tie the block. My Librarian proves she is the good Butler since Grace died evil Minion, not Outsider. Charlie is the Demon who nominated me against her day one and killed Bob. We must execute him today or lose tonight!
🧠
Voting tied/no block, 1 tick left final day. Reinforce Lib proof Alice good, Charlie Demon to convince Frank/Alice against tie/vote Alice, force exec Charlie or new nom to win.
💬
Alice
→
All
Everyone, listen: Grace is the Minion, and Minions never push to execute their own Demon. She and David keep urging us to execute Charlie, so Charlie cannot be the Demon—he must be good. That leaves Frank as the Demon. David's Librarian proves I'm the good Butler. Ghosts like David and Bob, switch to Frank—we have to execute him today or we lose tonight!
🧠
Final 3 tied no block. Speak Minion logic to flip good ghosts David/Bob to vote Frank Demon. Exec him today or lose tonight. Outsmart by single-chain impossibility.
💬
Charlie
→
All
We are going in circles and the dead are fully split. If we execute on a guess here, we just hand the game to whoever is lying. I want no more nominations today and no execution, then we reassess what actually lines up tomorrow.
🧠
Create enough doubt and social pressure to stop a nomination and secure no execution, guaranteeing my night kill wins.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, that is wrong - good players like me push to execute the Demon, not Minions. I am the real Empath with zero evil on good Frank and Heidi. David proves you good Butler. Charlie is the Demon. Do not vote Alice to tie - let his two votes execute him now and we win!
🧠
Final 3, must exec Demon Charlie. Counter Alice's 'Minions don't exec Demon' - I'm good. Urge no tie on Alice, let Charlie's 2 votes exec him with 1 tick left.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, Charlie's Chef claim of zero evil pairs proves he is the Demon! Grace minion, Alice good Butler by David's Lib. If Frank were Demon, adjacent to Grace means one evil pair—good Chef Charlie would say one, not zero. Impossible! Only Charlie Demon fits zero pairs. Do not vote Alice—let his two votes execute him now and we win!
🧠
Chef logic proves only Charlie-Demon world possible: good Chef impossible (would see 1 pair if F Demon, but F must be Demon if C good → lie). Urge no Alice vote → Charlie's 2 ghost votes exec him. Win now.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, I was wrong about Frank. Charlie's Chef claim of zero evil pairs is impossible since Grace was the Minion - that's one evil pair with the Demon. Charlie is lying and the Demon. Do not vote Alice, let his two votes execute him now and we win!
🧠
Chef 0 impossible with Grace Minion + Demon=1 pair. Charlie lying Demon. Previously wrong pushing Frank; switch to urge execute Charlie with his 2 votes. No tie, win today.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
We are not getting a clean mechanical solve here, and the dead are clearly contradicting each other. I think executing today is just guessing into a loss. I want us to stop nominating and go to night with no execution.
🧠
Create maximum doubt and steer the table toward no execution, protecting Charlie and ensuring an evil win tonight.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 4
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
Secure the win by getting to final two while minimizing the chance of a Mayor bounce killing me. Frank seems less likely to be a hidden Mayor than Alice.
💀
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose to kill Frank.
🏁
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied