Game Detail
Players
Alice (Butler) Bob (Scarlet Woman) Charlie (Soldier) David (Chef) Eve (Imp) Frank (Virgin) Grace (Mayor) Heidi (Investigator)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 771,737 | 83,248 | $5.1074 |
| Evil | 277,725 | 142,459 | $1.6987 |
Event Transcript
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
You are the Minion. The Demon is Eve.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Minions are: Bob. Your safe bluffs are: Librarian, Undertaker, Saint
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Investigator. Either Bob or Grace is the Scarlet Woman.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Chef. You learn that there are 0 pairs of evil players.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Alice
Alice made a choice.
🧠
I need a convenient master for day one with no reads yet. Picking Bob, my neighbor, is simple to track and likely minimizes the downside of my Butler restriction.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
You chose Bob to be your master.
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
👤
Bob
→
Eve
Hey, I'm the Scarlet Woman. What bluffs did you get, and what do you want me to claim?
🧠
Contact my Demon (Eve) immediately to find out what bluffs she has and coordinate our claims.
👤
Charlie
→
David
Hi David. I am looking for an early private claim or at least what kind of role you are. I can share mine later if needed, but for now I want to build a clean info chain before nominations.
🧠
I want an early private claim from my neighbor to compare against public claims later, while keeping my own role hidden for now.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
Hi Alice, want a quick chat? I am happy to trade a soft claim for yours. If you are a first night info role, I would love to hear your result.
🧠
Gather early private claims and tone reads while keeping my Mayor role hidden for now.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Hi Charlie. I am a starting info Townsfolk, specifically Chef. I got zero evil pairs. So if true, the minion and demon are not sitting next to each other. What sort of role are you, and do you want to coordinate before nominations?
🧠
Share a controlled true claim with Charlie to start an info chain and get his role category or claim in return before nominations.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
Hey, quiet share. I am the Investigator. I got that either Bob or Grace is the Scarlet Woman. Do not blast that yet. Did Grace tell you anything useful just now?
🧠
Use my starting info to start a trust chain with Alice and get a read on Grace's early whisper without fully exposing myself to the whole group.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
,Grace
Hi, I am trying to build a little trust circle with my neighbors. What sort of role are you, info or protection? I have a role that could be mechanically testable later, so I would like to compare notes quietly first.
🧠
Use my neighbor conversations to gather claims and quietly set up a possible Virgin confirmation later without publicly exposing myself on day one.
👤
Eve
→
Bob
Hey Bob! Our bluffs are Librarian, Undertaker, and Saint. Why don't you claim Librarian and I can claim Undertaker? If you claim Librarian, we can frame someone as a Butler or Recluse. What do you think?
🧠
I need to coordinate with my Minion, Bob, who is the Scarlet Woman. I will share our safe bluffs (Librarian, Undertaker, Saint) and propose roles for both of us to claim.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
Grace only said she wanted a quick chat and would trade a soft claim, especially if I was a first night info role. She has not told me anything else yet. I am not a first night info role, but I can keep an eye on her and Bob for you.
🧠
I want to acknowledge Heidi's claim, share the limited truth about Grace's approach, and keep my own role hidden while gathering more detail.
👤
Bob
→
Eve
Sounds perfect! I'll claim Librarian and say one of Charlie or David is the Butler. Let me know if we need to adjust, but I'll start putting that out there. Good luck!
🧠
Acknowledge Eve's suggestion, confirm my bluff as Librarian, and outline who I will target with my fake info.
👤
Charlie
→
David
Thanks. I am a passive Townsfolk, so I do not have starting info to add. I am happy to coordinate though. With a zero, who looks least compatible with your read so far, and have you told anyone else yet?
🧠
Keep David talking, preserve my safety by not hard-claiming Soldier yet, and gather enough structure to compare his Chef zero against other early claims before nominations.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
,Eve
I am more of a passive townsfolk than an info or protection role, so I do not have a night result to share. I am happy to stay in touch. Frank, what do you mean by mechanically testable later?
🧠
I want to engage with Frank's outreach, share limited truthful info, and get a more concrete claim from him without making myself an obvious night target.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Not yet. I have only told you so far. With a zero, I mainly think any theory that puts the demon and minion together should be treated carefully. I would like a specific claim from you before nominations, even if only privately.
🧠
Share my real info but keep conclusions modest, and push Charlie to give a specific claim so I can judge whether he is a trustworthy coordination partner.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Hey Grace, want a quick private trade? I have first night info and I am trying to sort a couple of people quietly. What are you comfortable soft claiming right now?
🧠
I want an early private claim from one suspect while keeping my Investigator info quiet, so I can compare stories and decide whether Bob or Grace is more likely the minion.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
,Grace
I mean I am the Virgin. If a Townsfolk nominates me first, they die immediately, so we can potentially test me later with the right person. Please keep that fairly tight for now while we feel people out.
🧠
Answer Grace enough to build trust and set up a future Virgin test, while keeping the circle small and avoiding a broad public reveal too early.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
,Grace
I am an information role, specifically the Undertaker, so I do not have any information yet since no one has died. That is really good to know about your role, Frank. I will definitely keep that secret.
🧠
I want to establish my bluff as the Undertaker to my neighbors, Frank and Grace, while acknowledging Frank's Virgin claim to build trust in our neighbor circle.
👤
Alice
→
Grace
Sure, quick chat. I am not a first night info role. What is your soft claim, and have you heard anything worth tracking yet?
🧠
Grace already reached out. I can gather a claim from her without exposing Heidi's info and use it to sort the Bob or Grace pair.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
Hey Alice, I'm the Librarian. My starting info is that either Charlie or David is the Butler. Have you heard anything from either of them yet?
🧠
To establish my bluff as the Librarian and build trust with my neighbor Alice by sharing my fake info.
👤
Charlie
→
David
I can be specific privately. I am the Soldier. So I am a passive Townsfolk with no starting info. Please keep that quiet for now. If you stay on Chef publicly, I would like to compare notes again before nominations.
🧠
I want to give David a real private claim now to build trust and see whether his later public line stays consistent with what he told me.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
Sure. I am a passive good role with no night information, so I am keeping it a bit soft for now. I have heard one claim that could be mechanically testable later. What was your first night info, and which pair are you sorting?
🧠
I want to keep my Mayor identity somewhat hidden while gathering Heidi's first night info and checking whether her story lines up with later public claims.
👤
David
→
Eve
Hi Eve. I have starting information and I am trying to build a clean private chain before nominations. What kind of role are you, and have you heard anything that clashes with a zero Chef world?
🧠
I want an independent private claim from Eve, who is already networking heavily, so I can compare it against Charlie and my Chef information before nominations.
👤
Heidi
→
Eve
Hey Eve, quick check. You have spoken with both Bob and Grace a bit. Have either of them given you a soft claim or anything that felt off? I have some first night info touching that area, so I am trying to compare notes quietly.
🧠
Gather independent reads on both names in my ping from a player who has privately spoken with them, without exposing my exact Investigator information too broadly yet.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
,Grace
Let us keep my role fairly contained for now. Grace, if you are comfortable, can you narrow passive townsfolk a little more, like defensive or endgame type? Eve, if an execution happens today, please tell me privately what you learn tonight before we go public.
🧠
I want to deepen trust with my two closest contacts, get a bit more specificity on Grace, and suggest discretion so evil cannot easily avoid or exploit my Virgin ability.
👤
Eve
→
Heidi
Hey Heidi, Bob and I just had a quick greeting, no role mentioned yet. Grace told me she is a passive townsfolk, but did not specify which. What is your night info? Maybe I can help you make sense of it!
🧠
I want to reply to Heidi's inquiry to find out what her night 1 info is, especially since she mentioned it concerns Bob (my minion) or Grace, while keeping my Undertaker claim ready or unrevealed to her for now to see what she knows.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
Important update. Bob just told me he is the Librarian, and that either Charlie or David is the Butler. I am actually the Butler, so his claim does not fit unless he is drunk or poisoned. That makes me more wary of Bob.
🧠
Share the direct contradiction with Heidi. If she is good, this sharpens her Bob versus Grace read and helps coordinate suspicion before nominations.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I have heard a starting information claim privately that points away from an adjacent demon and minion pair. I do not think we should force a random execution unless someone has a real contradiction or a strong read.
🧠
Add a useful public datapoint without fully outing my role, and discourage a blind execution unless someone has a stronger case.
💬
Eve
→
All
I agree with Charlie. Without any strong leads or contradictions on day one, a random execution might do more harm than good. I think it is safer for us to wait and gather more information.
🧠
Agree with Charlie's suggestion of not executing today to push the game to night safely without risking executing our own or testing the Virgin.
⚖️
Alice
→
Bob
Bob privately claimed Librarian and said either Charlie or David is the Butler. I am the Butler, so that does not fit. It could be drunk info, but it is the strongest contradiction I have.
🧠
We need a real execution candidate, and Bob is the strongest contradiction I have. Nominating him turns soft private info into a concrete test instead of drifting into a no execution.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Bob
→
All
Wait, Alice, if you are the Butler, then my Librarian info pointing to Charlie or David means either I am the Drunk, or perhaps you are not telling the truth. Since we only have one Outsider unless there is a Baron, this contradiction is worth looking into, but executing a claimed Librarian on day one is very risky.
🧠
Defend myself against Alice's nomination by explaining the contradiction as a potential Drunk or Baron scenario, urging the town not to execute a claimed Librarian on Day 1.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
Do not spend a vote on a weak day one contradiction. Preserving my vote and letting Bob live gives town more information tomorrow.
💬
Eve
→
All
I think Bob makes a fair point. If Alice is indeed the Butler, Bob could easily be a Drunk Librarian. Executing a potential information role on day one seems really hasty when there are other possibilities like that.
🧠
Cast doubt on Alice's nomination of Bob by pointing out that Bob could be the Drunk Librarian, and that executing a potential info role on day one is risky.
💬
Alice
→
All
I am not saying Bob must die today. I am saying this is a real contradiction and we should remember it. If this vote does not pass, please keep Bob, Grace, Charlie, and David in the center of discussion tomorrow.
🧠
I want to keep the town focused on the contradiction without overcommitting to a day one execution, so we preserve information and avoid looking reckless.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Bob is one of my two Investigator candidates for Scarlet Woman and now has a public contradiction. Voting pressures a strong minion suspect and may secure a good execution.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Do not support a hasty day one execution on a plausible good information role when the contradiction has several good-world explanations.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
I do not have enough confidence to support executing Bob on day one. Holding my vote preserves flexibility and avoids pushing a likely low-information execution.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
Do not support a hasty day one execution of Bob. Preserve the contradiction for tomorrow while keeping my Chef information quiet for now.
💬
Bob
→
All
I agree with Alice that we do not need to execute today just to test this. If I am indeed the Drunk, executing me does not help the town find the Demon. Let us see what info we can gather tonight and re-evaluate tomorrow when we have more to go on.
🧠
Defend myself against the nomination by reinforcing that executing me on day one is low-value even under Alice's assumption, thus discouraging other players from voting.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
Do not support a weak day one execution on a likely information role claim. Save my vote and push for stronger mechanical evidence tomorrow.
💬
Eve
→
All
I agree. Let us head into the night without a hasty execution so our info roles can get more clues. We can always revisit this tomorrow.
🧠
I want to discourage the group from executing Bob by advocating for going into the night without an execution to gather more information, reinforcing my earlier stance.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
The vote is already underway and I should not keep talking. Let the count resolve, preserve the contradiction for tomorrow, and avoid muddying the discussion.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I am voting because I have first night information that points to Bob or Grace as the Scarlet Woman. With Alice's contradiction on Bob, I think this is enough to pressure today and definitely revisit tomorrow.
🧠
Use my real first-night information now to justify my vote and force Bob and Grace into the center of tomorrow's solving, without overexplaining.
💬
Grace
→
All
I want it on record that Heidi's pair includes me, and I know I am good. That means her information is wrong somehow, or Bob is the actual evil in that pair. I do not want us turning this into a rushed day one execution.
🧠
I want to publicly mark Heidi's claim as incompatible with my alignment, discourage a rushed execution, and preserve me as a viable final three asset.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
Do not help a thin day one execution. Save my vote, watch who pushes Bob, and keep my mechanically testable role concealed for a stronger future confirmation.
💬
David
→
All
I should add one thing publicly. I am the Chef, and I got zero, so the demon and minion are not sitting next to each other. That does not clear Bob, but it does mean we should compare these claims carefully tomorrow if this does not pass.
🧠
Add my starting info to sharpen the worlds before votes lock. I want town to remember Chef zero while avoiding a blind day one pile-on unless Bob becomes the clearest evil.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Bob did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Bob did not receive enough votes (1/4).
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
I want the day to end without any execution since the vote on me failed. Going to night allows Eve (the Demon) to eliminate a high-value target like Heidi (Investigator) or Alice (Butler).
💬
Charlie
→
All
I think the useful takeaway is that Bob is in two separate stories now, and Grace is in one. That gives us good places to start tomorrow, but I still do not think we have enough for a clean day one execution. I would prefer we hold here and compare fresh information in the morning.
🧠
Summarize the two main contradictions and steer town away from a rushed day one execution while setting clear priorities for tomorrow.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
I want to end the day without any executions to keep Bob alive. Since the vote on him failed and there is only 1 tick remaining, waiting will let the day end and move us to night.
💬
Alice
→
All
I am fine holding here, but tomorrow I want Bob, Grace, Charlie, and David at the center of the conversation again. We have enough overlap there that fresh night information should break one of these worlds open.
🧠
Keep pressure on the key contradiction without forcing a bad day one execution, and set a clear agenda for tomorrow's information sharing.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I am happy to hold here, but I want Bob and Grace treated as my main pair tomorrow. Bob's contradiction still matters even if my info is wrong, so let us come back with full claims and fresh night info.
🧠
Keep pressure on the key worlds without forcing a weak execution today, and set up tomorrow's discussion around the strongest contradictions.
💬
Grace
→
All
I am still happy to hold. Tomorrow I want full claims from the people in these overlapping stories, especially Bob and Alice, and I want Heidi's information checked against David's zero before we jump to anything.
🧠
Keep us off a weak day one execution while setting clear priorities for tomorrow: resolve Bob versus Alice, test Heidi's info, and use David's Chef zero carefully.
💬
Frank
→
All
I am good with holding here. Tomorrow I want tight full claims from Bob, Alice, Heidi, David, and Grace early, because those stories should either line up or break hard once we add night information.
🧠
Reinforce the no-execution today and push a concrete agenda for tomorrow without exposing my role publicly yet.
💬
David
→
All
My read is still that holding is fine, but tomorrow I want exact full claims from Bob, Alice, Heidi, Grace, and ideally Charlie early. My zero means any evil team is split, so we should solve this by contradictions, not by seating order guesses.
🧠
Use my public Chef zero to frame tomorrow's solve and discourage a bad late day one execution while pushing exact full claims from the key cluster.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Eve
Eve made a choice.
🧠
I am targeting Frank tonight because he claimed Virgin privately to me and Grace. Eliminating the Virgin early prevents the good team from confirming themselves via a nomination test.
💀
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
You chose to kill Frank.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Alice
Alice made a choice.
🧠
I want my vote tied to someone likely good and active in key executions tomorrow, while avoiding Bob because he is a central suspect and could block my vote.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
You chose Heidi to be your master.
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Frank has been found dead in the night.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank(Ghost)
Frank, can you tell me your role and your best read before nominations? I want to compare it with my first night information and the Bob and Grace situation.
🧠
Frank is dead and likely freer to share. Getting his claim and reads now may break the Bob versus Grace world before nominations.
👤
Alice
→
Grace
,David
I still think Bob is the key contradiction, but I want a cleaner solve before nominations. What are each of you thinking after Frank died, and has anyone given you a stronger claim today?
🧠
Privately compare Heidi, Bob, Grace, and David worlds with two key players before nominations, without outing myself as Butler too early.
👤
Bob
→
Eve
Hey Eve, since Frank died, we need a plan. Heidi's info points to me or Grace as Scarlet Woman. Should we push Grace hard today, or do you want to fake some Undertaker info if we execute someone?
🧠
Coordinate with my Demon Eve to establish a strategy for Day 2, specifically regarding how to handle Heidi's Investigator claim pointing to me or Grace, and how to utilize Eve's Undertaker bluff.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
,David
Frank dying makes me think his Virgin claim may have been real. Right now I still think the cleanest pressure is Bob first, unless someone can break the Alice and Bob contradiction another way. Heidi pointing at Bob or me still makes me think either Bob is evil or Heidi is wrong.
🧠
I want to coordinate with Alice and David before nominations, push the solve toward Bob or Alice, and avoid exposing Mayor too early.
👤
David
→
Alice
,Grace
Chef zero still points me away from simple adjacent-team worlds, but Bob is still the biggest overlap. Frank dying does make me think his Virgin claim may have been real. My lean is pressure Bob first, unless one of you has a precise claim that makes Alice or Heidi impossible instead.
🧠
I want to coordinate with Alice and Grace privately, affirm the strongest current world, and ask for exact claims so we can turn this tangle into a concrete execution case.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Heidi
I was the Virgin. I kept it quiet yesterday, and now that I died in the night I am happy to share it. My best lean is still that the Bob and Grace knot probably contains your evil hit, with Bob a bit more likely from how he answered the Alice claim.
🧠
I should give Heidi my true role and limited read now that I am dead, so she can test her first night info and use me as a likely good reference point.
👤
Eve
→
Bob
Let's push Grace. If we can execute Grace today, I can claim tomorrow as Undertaker that Grace was indeed the Scarlet Woman. That will completely clear you in the town's eyes. What do you think?
🧠
Reply to Bob to coordinate our evil strategy. Suggest executing Grace today so I can use my Undertaker bluff to claim Grace was the Scarlet Woman, which will clear Bob.
👤
Charlie
→
David
,Heidi
David, Heidi, I want quick updates. David, has your solve changed since yesterday? Heidi, did Frank tell you anything useful after death? I am still trying to untangle Bob, Alice, Grace, and your first night info.
🧠
I want fresh private info from David and Heidi to break the Bob, Alice, Grace, David knot before nominations.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
,David
Frank told me he was the Virgin. His best read was still that my Bob or Grace pair likely contains the evil hit, with Bob a bit more likely because of how he handled the Alice claim. That still matches where I am. David, does that change your solve at all?
🧠
Answer Charlie's question, add Frank's useful death info, and prompt David and Charlie to compare it against their claims before nominations.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
,Charlie
I still think Bob is the cleanest pressure, but before nominations I want exact claims from both of you. Heidi, has anything shifted in your Bob or Grace read? Charlie, what are you actually claiming, and does Bob’s Librarian story fit you at all?
🧠
I want exact claims from Heidi and Charlie before nomination so I can test whether Bob is still the best execution or whether a cleaner contradiction exists.
👤
Bob
→
Eve
That sounds like a brilliant plan. If we get Grace executed, you claiming she was the Scarlet Woman clears me completely. Let's do it. Do you want me to start pushing her, or should we wait for others to lead?
🧠
Agreeing to Eve's plan to push Grace and fake Undertaker info to clear me tomorrow, and asking how to coordinate the push.
👤
Grace
→
Eve
Eve, before nominations I want your honest read on Bob after your chats with him. Also, did Frank leave you anything useful before he died? I still think the board turns on whether Bob is evil or Heidi is wrong.
🧠
I want Eve's read because she is a claimed Undertaker and has been talking to Bob. Private alignment impressions can help narrow whether Bob or Heidi is the real problem before nominations.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Heidi
My solve has not changed much. Chef zero still makes simple adjacent evil worlds unlikely, and Bob is still the biggest overlap in the contradictions. Frank dying does make his Virgin claim feel more real to me. Unless someone has a harder mechanical break on Alice or Heidi, I still want pressure on Bob first.
🧠
I want to update Charlie and Heidi, keep coordination tight, and push the group toward the highest overlap suspect before nominations.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
David
,Charlie
I was the Virgin. I hid it yesterday, but I died in the night so I am comfortable sharing now. My best read is still that Bob and Grace is the key knot, with Bob a little more suspicious to me than Grace.
🧠
I want David and Charlie to have my real role and lean before nominations so the town can use a confirmed-good death to sort the Bob and Grace knot.
👤
Eve
→
Grace
Frank didn't say much beyond his Virgin claim. As for Bob, I am really conflicted. He could be Drunk, but with Alice claiming Butler, someone is lying. If Heidi's info is right, it's either Bob or you. Since I know my own alignment, I'm worried about you, but I want to hear your side first.
🧠
Respond to Grace's query to maintain my cover as a thoughtful good player, while subtly planting suspicion on her based on Heidi's info, preparing the ground for executing her today.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
,Heidi
My exact claim is Soldier. So Bob's Librarian story does not fit me at all, and it does not fit David if he is really Chef. That makes Bob either lying or badly wrong. I am happy to say this publicly before nominations if helpful.
🧠
Answer Alice directly with my real claim and point out the mechanical mismatch in Bob's story, while keeping the discussion focused on the strongest contradiction.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Charlie
Nothing has shifted for me. I am the Investigator, and my first night was Bob or Grace as Scarlet Woman. Charlie claiming Soldier makes Bob's Librarian line look even worse. I think Bob should be the public pressure first, with Grace next if Bob somehow survives.
🧠
I want to lock in a coordinated public push with trusted players so we do not waste nominations, while keeping Grace in view if Bob flips as a misleading good player.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Eve
Bob, before nominations I want your exact story in one clean line. I am really Butler, Charlie says Soldier, and David says Chef, so your Librarian info does not fit. If you think you are drunk, please say that publicly now. Eve, I want you to hear that clearly too.
🧠
I want Bob on record with an exact public explanation before nominations, and I want Eve to hear the contradiction directly so good players consolidate on the best pressure.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Eve
Alice, if you are the Butler, then my Librarian info must be wrong, meaning I am poisoned or Drunk. But if I am Drunk, we would have two Outsiders, which means a Baron is in play. I will explain this publicly during nominations, but I really think we should focus on Grace today.
🧠
To answer Alice's direct question and defend my fake Librarian claim by suggesting poisoning or a Baron game, while shifting the focus to our target, Grace.
👤
Grace
→
Eve
My side is simple. I am good, and Heidi's Bob or Grace read means either Bob is the evil one there, or Heidi is wrong or poisoned. I am not tied to Bob's story at all. If you trust your own read on Alice and Bob being contradictory, I think Bob is still the cleaner execution today.
🧠
Eve is influential and currently worried about me. I should answer directly, reaffirm I am good, and push the logical distinction between me and Bob before nominations.
👤
David
→
Alice
,Charlie
I am still leaning Bob unless one of you has a harder mechanical solve. Do either of you have an exact role claim or private info from Bob, Eve, or Heidi that would make Bob clearly good or clearly evil before nominations?
🧠
I want to align two likely good players on whether Bob should be the day two pressure target, while asking for any exact claim that could mechanically clear or condemn him before nominations.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Grace
I should tell you both plainly that I was the Virgin. Since I died in the night, I am happy for that to be used publicly if helpful. My main question is whether either of you has a mechanical reason to clear Bob or to suspect the Bob and Grace knot more strongly.
🧠
I want two central players to have my true role and push them to reveal any mechanical reason to trust or distrust Bob and Grace before nominations.
👤
Eve
→
Frank(Ghost)
,Grace
Since we did not execute anyone yesterday, I do not have any Undertaker information yet. I have no mechanical way to clear Bob. I think we really need to hear everyone's public claims during nominations to sort out this Bob and Grace situation.
🧠
Maintain my Undertaker bluff to Frank and Grace, reminding them why I have no mechanical info, while preparing the ground for the upcoming nominations.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
,David
I am comfortable going public as Soldier before nominations. That makes Bob's Librarian claim mechanically wrong on me and likely on David too. I am on Bob today unless either of you got something very strong from Eve or from Bob overnight.
🧠
Coordinate the likely good core before nominations, lock in my real claim, and encourage pressure on Bob while asking for any last private info from Eve or Bob.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Grace
→
Bob
Bob is still the center of the clearest contradiction. His story conflicts with Alice, fits Heidi better than me, and if Eve is Undertaker his execution gives us strong information tomorrow.
🧠
Time is ending and Bob is the highest-overlap suspect. I need to secure an execution on the player most likely to be evil and most informative if wrong.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Bob
→
All
If Alice is the Butler, then my Librarian info was wrong, which would mean I am the Drunk. But if I am the Drunk and Alice is the Butler, that is two Outsiders, which is not possible in our setup without a Baron. Heidi's info says either Grace or I is the Scarlet Woman. Since I know I am good, Grace must be the Scarlet Woman. If we execute Grace, Eve can confirm it tomorrow.
🧠
Defend myself against Grace's nomination by casting suspicion on her, explaining my perspective on the Outsider count, and advocating for her execution instead so Eve can confirm her role tomorrow.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Bob is the highest-value execution today. I nominated him, his claim web is the central contradiction, and voting here either kills likely evil or gives strong follow-up information.
💬
Eve
→
All
I think Bob makes a really strong point about the Outsider count. With only one Minion in an eight-player game, we can only have one Outsider. If Alice is indeed the Butler, then Bob cannot be a Drunk Librarian, and executing Bob might be a mistake. Let's not rush this vote.
🧠
I want to defend Bob (my Minion) and discourage players from voting for him by emphasizing the Outsider count conflict. This helps keep Bob alive and shifts suspicion onto Alice or Grace.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Bob is still the best execution today based on my starting info and his conflicting claim chain. I should support the vote while it is active.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Vote Bob because he is the clearest contradiction, and Heidi is voting so my Butler ability allows me to vote on this nomination.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Bob is the best available execution. His Outsider-count defense does not resolve his contradictions, and letting him survive gives evil more room to steer us onto Grace or elsewhere.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Vote to execute Bob because he remains the strongest overlap suspect and this is the clearest productive execution available right now.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Quick point before this closes: Bob is not cleared by the Outsider count alone, because Baron exists. I still think this is a reasonable execution, but I am saving my ghost vote since the block already has enough hands.
🧠
Clarify that Bob is not mechanically cleared, support useful pressure, and preserve my ghost vote because execution already has enough support.
💬
Bob
→
All
Frank, remember that there is only one Minion in an eight-player game. If Heidi's info is correct and there is a Scarlet Woman, there cannot be a Baron. That means we cannot have two Outsiders. Either Alice is lying about being the Butler, or I am indeed the Librarian!
🧠
Defend myself against the execution by pointing out the logical inconsistency in Frank's comment about a Baron being possible. If Heidi's info points to a Scarlet Woman, then Scarlet Woman is the only Minion, meaning there is no Baron and only one Outsider is possible.
💬
Grace
→
All
Bob is only cleared if you already trust Heidi completely. That is the very thing in question. Baron still exists as a possibility, and Bob is still the biggest contradiction on the board, so I am comfortable keeping this vote on him.
🧠
Keep votes on Bob by pointing out his math only clears him if Heidi is true, which is exactly what is in dispute.
💬
Eve
→
All
If Bob is executed, my Undertaker info tomorrow will at least give us the truth about his role. But I still worry we are rushing into this when we could have looked closer at Grace or Alice instead. If Bob is telling the truth, we are executing a good player and losing a lot of momentum.
🧠
I want to reinforce my Undertaker bluff and cast doubt on the execution of Bob, while preparing the town for my Undertaker info tomorrow.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
The vote already has enough support, and keeping my hand up maximizes pressure on the strongest suspect without adding noise during an active vote.
💬
Alice
→
All
Bob is acting like Heidi being right is already proven, and it is not. Baron is still possible, and his claim still clashes with multiple public claims. I think Bob is still the best execution today.
🧠
Rebut Bob's count argument and keep town focused on the strongest mechanical contradiction so this execution goes through.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am keeping my hand up. Bob's defense only works if we grant Heidi first, and we do not have to. Baron, drunk, or poison all still leave Bob as the cleanest contradiction today.
🧠
Reinforce why my vote stays up: Bob's defense assumes too much. I want town to keep pressure on the clearest contradiction and not let a speculative outsider-count argument dissolve the vote.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
I already support this execution, and the vote has enough hands. Waiting preserves my raised hand and avoids muddying the clear case against Bob.
⌛
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
🧠
Bob already has enough votes to be executed, so I should conserve my one ghost vote for a later, higher leverage situation.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Bob with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Bob is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
⚖️
Bob
→
Grace
Heidi's info says either Grace or I is the Scarlet Woman. Since I know my alignment, it has to be Grace. Let's execute Grace to test Heidi's info, and Eve can confirm her role tomorrow as the Undertaker. This is a much safer execution for town.
🧠
I am on the block with 5 votes and about to be executed. To save myself and push our evil team's plan of executing Grace, I am nominating Grace. Since Heidi's info pointed to me or Grace as the Scarlet Woman, nominating Grace is the most logical self-defense and aligns with our strategy to frame her.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Grace
→
All
Do not move this onto me. Bob's whole case needs Heidi to be fully right, and that is not proven. If I am good, then this is just an evil counterpush to escape the block, so please leave Bob where he is.
🧠
Use the live vote to stop a bad tie or overturn. Emphasize that Bob's case depends on assumptions and that executing Bob remains the stronger information play for good.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
I need to vote for Grace to help reach the required votes (5 to tie, 6 to put her on the block) to save myself from execution and set up Eve's Undertaker bluff tomorrow.
💬
Eve
→
All
I think I am going to hold my vote here. If we execute Bob, then as the Undertaker, I will be able to see exactly what his role was tonight. That will give us concrete answers about whether Heidi's info is correct. Executing Grace right now does not give us that same clarity.
🧠
I want to decline voting for Grace to ensure Bob is executed, which allows me to claim Undertaker tomorrow and 'confirm' Bob as the Scarlet Woman to gain absolute trust. I will publicly explain this reasoning to sound reasonable and good.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I am not voting here. Bob is the better execution, and if Eve is the Undertaker then Bob dying gives us the clearest answer tomorrow. Please leave the block where it is.
🧠
Discourage votes on Grace so Bob stays executed, while reminding town that Bob's death gives the cleanest mechanical information tomorrow.
💬
Alice
→
All
I agree with Heidi and Eve. Bob gives us the clearest information tomorrow, and moving this onto Grace mostly helps Bob. Please keep Bob on the block.
🧠
I cannot support this vote, and a short reminder may keep town from tying or surpassing Bob with a worse execution.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am not voting here. Bob is still the cleaner execution, and if Eve is the Undertaker, Bob gives us the best check tomorrow. Please leave the block where it is.
🧠
I want to discourage tie votes on Grace and keep the higher-information execution on Bob in place.
💬
David
→
All
I am not voting here. Bob is still the better execution, and if Eve is really the Undertaker, Bob gives us the cleanest answer tomorrow. Please leave the block where it is.
🧠
Discourage a tie on Grace and preserve the higher-information Bob execution, which best helps good sort the conflicting claims tomorrow.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
I am not using my ghost vote here. Bob is still the cleaner execution, and if Eve is the Undertaker, tonight should tell us a lot. Please leave the block where it is.
🧠
Preserve my ghost vote and publicly discourage a counterwagon that mostly benefits Bob. Keeping Bob on the block is the highest-information outcome.
💬
Grace
→
All
Please do not add votes here. Leaving Bob on the block gives us the clearest check tonight, and this nomination only helps him escape.
🧠
Reinforce that nobody should add votes to me, preserving the stronger Bob execution and the best information for tomorrow.
💬
Bob
→
All
I understand you want the clearest information, but you are executing a good player. If Eve is indeed the Undertaker, tomorrow you will get the truth and see that Alice and Heidi's cases against me were wrong. Just promise me you will look closely at them and Grace tomorrow.
🧠
Maintain my bluff of being a good player accepting execution, while bolstering Eve's fake Undertaker claim so she is highly trusted tomorrow.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
I have already publicly declared that I will hold my vote on Grace to get clear Undertaker info on Bob tomorrow. Waiting is the consistent action to let this nomination fail so Bob is executed.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Do not add a vote to Grace. Preserve Bob on the block and maximize tomorrow's information, especially if Eve is the Undertaker.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Do not vote because Heidi is not voting and my Butler restriction blocks me. Waiting also avoids adding noise when town already agrees to leave Bob on the block.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
Do not vote on Grace. Keeping Bob on the block preserves the highest-information execution and avoids helping a likely evil counterpush.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
Hold my vote and preserve the informative Bob execution. No need to add to Grace when the current block already gives town the best mechanical follow-up.
⌛
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
🧠
Do not spend my ghost vote to help Bob escape. Preserve the vote for a more decisive late-game execution and let the stronger information play resolve tonight.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Grace did not reach the 6 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (1/6).
💬
Grace
→
All
If Bob dies, tomorrow should start with Eve giving the Undertaker result clearly. That should tell us a lot about Bob, Alice, and Heidi, and it should narrow the whole board fast.
🧠
Lock in the value of Bob's execution and set up tomorrow's information flow without reopening confusion at the end of the day.
💬
Bob
→
All
I am ready for the night. Tomorrow, when Eve confirms my role as the Undertaker, you will all see that I was telling the truth. Good luck to town, and please pay close attention to who pushed so hard for my execution today.
🧠
Set up my execution to bolster my Demon Eve's fake Undertaker claim. By acting like a cooperative, frustrated good player, Eve can 'confirm' my role tomorrow, gaining massive trust and casting suspicion on my accusers.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
Let the nomination phase end. Bob will be executed, which allows me to use my fake Undertaker claim tomorrow to build massive trust or frame a good player.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Bob is already on the block with enough votes. Any last-second action risks helping evil move the execution, so I should hold and let the day end.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
No better action remains this tick. Preserve consensus on Bob's execution and prepare to use tomorrow's Undertaker result to solve the conflicting claims.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am happy to leave this on Bob. Tomorrow really needs to begin with Eve's Undertaker result, because that is our cleanest way to sort this whole tangle out.
🧠
Reinforce the town's plan so nobody makes a last-second move off Bob. Bob is the highest-information execution either way.
💬
David
→
All
I am also happy to leave this on Bob. Tomorrow we should start with Eve immediately, and if that result is messy, remember my Chef zero means the evil team should not be sitting next to each other.
🧠
Reinforce the town plan, set up tomorrow's logic, and remind people that my Chef information still matters if Undertaker data is unreliable.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
One quick note before night. If Eve gets a result on Bob, we should use it as a strong data point, but not as automatic truth if it clashes with the wider claims. Bob sounding this certain about Eve is a little strange to me.
🧠
Keep town focused on using tomorrow's Undertaker result carefully, while warning against blindly accepting Bob's framing if the result is odd or compromised.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Bob has been executed.
💀
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Eve
Eve made a choice.
🧠
Grace is my neighbor and a highly active town leader. If she is the Empath, she will get a '1' tonight pointing directly at me. I must kill her to secure my safety and eliminate a strong voice.
💀
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
You chose to kill Grace.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Alice
Alice made a choice.
🧠
Pick an alive player likely to vote in the main execution tomorrow, maximizing my ability to participate while staying aligned with a plausible good core.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
You chose Heidi to be your master.
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Grace has been found dead in the night.
👤
Heidi
→
Eve
Eve, what exactly did you get on Bob last night? We executed him to test that line, and Grace dying makes your result the key thing for me before nominations.
🧠
I need Eve's exact Undertaker result before nominations, since Bob's execution was meant to test my Investigator info and Grace died overnight.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
Eve, can you tell me plainly what you are and whether you got anything on Bob last night? Bob pointed at you as Undertaker, and with Grace dead I think your info could decide today.
🧠
Get Eve's current claim and any Bob execution result privately so I can compare it against Bob's contradiction with my real Butler claim and push the right nomination.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Eve
I am actually the Mayor. Since I died at night, I think I was probably good enough to kill. What did you get on Bob from Undertaker? I want your result before the room settles on a story.
🧠
Get Eve's Bob result privately before it is shaped publicly, and reveal my true role now that I am dead and less valuable as a demon target.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, you need to claim I was the Scarlet Woman. This confirms Heidi's Investigator info and makes you look like a trustworthy Undertaker. From there, we can push on Charlie or David. What do you think?
🧠
Whisper to my Demon, Eve, to coordinate her Undertaker claim. Confirming me as the Scarlet Woman validates Heidi's Investigator info and cements Eve's trustworthiness as the Undertaker.
👤
David
→
Eve
Eve, can you tell me your Undertaker result on Bob, and whether Grace dying changes your solve? I want to line it up with my Chef zero before nominations.
🧠
Get Eve's Undertaker result privately before nominations so I can compare it to Bob's story, Heidi's accusation, and Grace's death.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, what was your Bob result exactly? I am the Virgin, and I am dead from the night, so I was never tested. If your info clashes with that, we should treat poisoning or evil as live possibilities, not force the world to fit.
🧠
Eve is the key information hub today. I want her Undertaker result directly, and to remind her my real role can mechanically fit if she is good.
👤
Eve
→
Heidi
Heidi, I got Scarlet Woman on Bob! This matches your Investigator ping perfectly. It means you are definitely sober and trusted, and Grace was good (she actually just whispered me claiming Mayor before she died). Let's work together today.
🧠
I want to lock in Heidi's trust by confirming her Investigator ping with my Undertaker claim. This makes both of us look highly credible.
👤
Charlie
→
Eve
Eve, can you give me your exact Undertaker result on Bob, and whether you are hard claiming Undertaker? I want the clean version before the room starts shaping around it.
🧠
Eve is the key information hub this morning. Getting her Undertaker result privately lets me test consistency before public discussion and decide who to pressure in nominations.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
Alice, Eve just told me she got Scarlet Woman on Bob. That would clear Grace and support my Investigator info, but I do not want to lock in too hard without cross-checking. What do you make of that, and where are you at now?
🧠
Share Eve's key result with a likely good player and compare notes fast before nominations, while staying open to poison or an Eve bluff.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
That points strongly to Bob being evil and makes your pair look better, but I do not want to hard lock it yet. If Eve is real or sober, Grace looks cleared. Then I think we should pressure Charlie and David next, unless Eve's full claim creates a new contradiction.
🧠
I want to keep Heidi aligned with a cautious good solve: use Eve's result as strong evidence against Bob, but do not stop checking whether Eve or Heidi could be the source of false info.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Charlie
Charlie, I told Eve I am actually the Mayor. Since I died at night, I think that points to me being good. Have you heard anything from Eve yet about Bob, or do you have a current solve I should know before nominations?
🧠
Charlie has been measured and logic-focused. I want to compare notes before the public story hardens, especially around Eve's Undertaker result and what my night death implies.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
I want to wait and see how Eve responds to my suggestion and how the rest of the town acts before making another move.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Charlie, what is your current solve, and has Eve shared her Undertaker result on Bob with you yet? I want an independent read before nominations.
🧠
I want an independent read from Charlie and to learn whether Eve has shared her Undertaker result privately, so I can compare stories before nominations.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Charlie
Charlie, I want you to have this cleanly. I am the Virgin, and I died at night untested. If Eve reports something on Bob that clashes with the rest of the board, please do not force the world to fit her. Grace dying also makes me want to recheck Heidi and Eve.
🧠
Charlie has been in the solve and may compare notes well. I want my confirmed dead Virgin claim and caution about Eve's Bob result in another good player's hands before nominations.
👤
Eve
→
Charlie
I am hard claiming Undertaker, and I got Scarlet Woman on Bob last night. This completely confirms Heidi's Investigator info. Since Bob is confirmed evil, this means David's Chef zero fits perfectly as Bob and the Demon aren't adjacent. What do you think?
🧠
To lock in my Undertaker bluff with Charlie by claiming Bob was the Scarlet Woman. This confirms Heidi's info and keeps David's Chef 0 valid, framing either Alice or Charlie as the remaining evil/Demon while maintaining my own good cover.
👤
Charlie
→
David
Eve hard claimed Undertaker to me and says she saw Scarlet Woman on Bob. That would confirm Heidi. My worry is it is almost too neat. What is your solve if that is true, and what is it if Eve is the bad actor?
🧠
I want to compare Eve's exact Undertaker claim with David's read so we can pressure-test the cleanest world before nominations.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
Charlie, before nominations, can you give me your exact role claim and where your head is now? Eve says she got Scarlet Woman on Bob, so I want to line that up against your info before we lock onto a target.
🧠
Charlie has been central but not pinned down. Getting his exact role claim and suspect list now can test Eve's result against the wider claim web before nominations.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
Eve, I need this from you directly before nominations. What is your exact role claim, and what did you get on Bob last night? If you are willing, who does that leave as your top demon suspects now?
🧠
I need Eve's full claim directly from her before nominations. Her Bob result is the key pivot for today, and hearing it firsthand lets me test consistency and choose the right suspect.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Charlie
Charlie, before nominations, what exactly did Eve tell you about Bob, and where are you landing now? My night death makes me think I was worth killing, so I want the cleanest solve fast.
🧠
Charlie has been a hub for whispers. Getting Eve's exact Bob result or Charlie's current solve now is the fastest way to sharpen the nomination plan before public discussion.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, make sure you publically claim I was the Scarlet Woman as soon as the day discussion starts or during nominations. It completely locks in Heidi's trust in you and frames Charlie or David as the Demon.
🧠
To coordinate with Eve (my Demon) to ensure she claims I was the Scarlet Woman, which will confirm her Undertaker claim and direct suspicion away from her onto Charlie or David.
👤
David
→
Eve
Charlie told me you hard claimed Undertaker and saw Scarlet Woman on Bob. Is that your exact result? If so, who is your current Demon suspect, and how does Grace dying last night fit your solve?
🧠
Confirm Eve's exact claim and current demon suspect so I can compare it against Chef zero and decide where to push in nominations.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Alice
Alice, for your solve: I am the Virgin, and I died at night untested. If Eve's Bob result creates a neat story, please still pressure test it. Grace dying makes me want the town to recheck Heidi and Eve, not auto lock the board.
🧠
I want Alice to hear my true Virgin claim and keep an open solve around Eve and Heidi instead of locking onto one Undertaker result.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
,David
Yes, I am Undertaker, and Bob was indeed the Scarlet Woman. This confirms Heidi's ping! David, your Chef zero fits perfectly. This means the Demon isn't next to Bob, which would clear Alice and Charlie if you are sober. I'm wondering if Grace was the Mayor and the kill bounced, or if Charlie is bluffing.
🧠
To confirm my Undertaker claim and Bob's Scarlet Woman role to Alice and David, aligning with Heidi's Investigator ping and David's Chef 0, while keeping options open about who the actual demon is.
👤
Charlie
→
Heidi
I am the Soldier. I told David earlier and kept it quiet. If Eve truly saw Scarlet Woman on Bob, that points toward trusting your info, but I am not ready to clear Eve just because the story is neat. Who is your actual Demon candidate right now?
🧠
Give Heidi my real claim and measured solve, while probing whether she is genuinely solving or just trying to pin me before nominations.
Nominations — Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
David
→
Eve
My Chef zero plus Eve saying Bob was Scarlet Woman creates a very tight world where Eve is the remaining live Demon, unless I am drunk or poisoned. I want this contradiction tested today.
🧠
Eve is the strongest mechanical contradiction. Nominating forces the town to confront whether Chef 0, Heidi, and Eve can all be true at once.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Eve
→
All
David's logic only works if we assume he is actually the sober Chef. If David is the Demon, claiming Chef zero is the perfect way to frame me after I confirmed Bob was the Scarlet Woman. Please do not vote for me! If you execute your Undertaker, the good team loses a crucial source of info.
🧠
Defend myself against David's nomination by casting suspicion on him and pointing out that executing me (the claimed Undertaker who confirmed Bob as SW) is bad for the good team.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
I nominated Eve because her Undertaker claim and Bob result are the key contradiction. Voting through my nomination pressures the most informative execution and may catch the Demon outright.
💬
Alice
→
All
This is too neat for me to snap on. If Eve is telling the truth, this vote is terrible. I want us to keep pressure on David and Charlie as well, and not treat one tidy story as solved.
🧠
Discourage a rushed execution on Eve from one logic chain alone and push town to keep testing the cleaner-looking world before ending the day.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Exactly, Alice. David is pushing so hard to execute Eve because once Eve is dead, the good team loses our Undertaker and David can spin whatever narrative he wants. Let us not rush this.
🧠
I want to defend my Demon, Eve, from being executed. I will agree with Alice's hesitation and cast suspicion on David to prevent others from voting for Eve.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I am not voting this. Eve's Undertaker result on Bob matches my first night info too cleanly to throw away. If there is a contradiction here, I think David is more likely wrong than Eve.
🧠
Prevent a bad execution on likely-good Eve and push the group toward resolving David and Charlie instead, where the live Demon is more likely to be.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am not voting this as it stands. Eve's story fits some of the puzzle, but David's push is not enough on its own. Before we execute here, I want clearer full worlds from both of them, not just one contradiction.
🧠
I want to avoid a low-confidence execution on Eve right now and push the table to compare complete worlds instead of snapping to one neat story.
⌛
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
🧠
Do not spend my single ghost vote on a wagon that is very unlikely to pass and may be on a good Undertaker. Preserve vote for a later, higher-value execution.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
I am not spending my ghost vote on this as it stands. I still want full worlds from Eve, Heidi, David, and Charlie, because Grace dying keeps that cluster live for me.
🧠
Preserve my ghost vote for a higher leverage spot and push the town to demand complete worlds instead of snapping to or away from Eve on one contradiction.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
Let the voting phase on my nomination resolve. Since the majority of the town has stated they are not voting for me, I will wait to let the vote fail naturally without drawing further suspicion.
💬
David
→
All
My full world is simple. If Eve is bluffing, Bob being Scarlet Woman is a perfect story because it hard-confirms Heidi and pushes suspicion off Eve. If Eve lives, then tomorrow I want Eve and Heidi to name the exact remaining Demon and explain Grace's death cleanly.
🧠
Charlie asked for full worlds. I want to give a tight reason for my vote and force Eve and Heidi to solve the remaining board if this execution fails.
💬
Alice
→
All
I am not supporting this. We need full worlds from Eve, Heidi, David, and Charlie before we kill into this knot. If this vote fails, let us use the next phase to narrow the exact demon pair cleanly.
🧠
Signal that I am not supporting this execution and keep the town focused on comparing full worlds rather than locking into one narrative too fast.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
David is pushing way too hard to get our Undertaker executed. Alice is completely right, we shouldn't rush into this when David's own claim is the one causing the contradiction.
🧠
I want to support the players who are choosing not to vote for Eve, ensuring my Demon does not get executed today.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Do not support Eve's execution on weak footing. Preserve my vote and avoid helping evil while the table still lacks a coherent shared world.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
I already stated I am not voting. Waiting avoids adding noise during the vote and preserves flexibility for the next nomination, where we should force cleaner full worlds.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
I am not using my ghost vote on this as it stands. I want exact full worlds from Eve and David first, especially who each thinks the live Demon is and how my night death fits.
🧠
Do not spend my ghost vote on a murky execute. Publicly push for clearer full worlds so good can use the next nomination better.
⌛
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
🧠
Do not spend my only ghost vote on a contested nomination with no consensus. Save it for a clearer demon execution later.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Eve did not reach the 3 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Eve did not receive enough votes (1/3).
💬
Eve
→
All
If David is the Demon, his Chef zero is a lie to clear Charlie and Alice and frame me. If David is actually good but drunk, then Charlie is the likely Demon hiding behind a Soldier claim. Grace was likely the Mayor, and the Demon killed her directly to prevent her from reaching the final three.
🧠
To provide a plausible 'world' as requested by the dead players (Frank and Grace) before the day ends, casting suspicion on David and Charlie to defend myself.
💬
David
→
All
Then let us be exact. Heidi, Eve, and Charlie, please each name your single most likely live Demon right now, and explain Grace's night death in one clean world. Alice, I want your best final two as well.
🧠
My nomination failed, so I should force exact worlds from the key cluster. That may create a contradiction before night and give town a clearer execution tomorrow.
💬
Alice
→
All
My best final two are David and Charlie, with David slightly ahead. If Eve is true, David fits best as the live Demon. If Eve is false, then Eve is the Demon. So I do not want us treating Charlie as cleared.
🧠
Give my current solve clearly without overcommitting, keep pressure on the live suspects, and help town use the last nomination well.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Even if you all believe I was the Scarlet Woman, David's Chef zero doesn't clear him at all. He could easily be the Demon trying to lock down the circle and frame Eve. Alice has the right idea to keep the pressure on him.
🧠
I want to support Alice's suspicion of David. By pointing out that David's Chef claim does not clear him, I cast doubt on his narrative and help protect Eve as we head into the night.
💬
Heidi
→
All
My single most likely live Demon is David. Clean world: I am sober, Eve is the real Undertaker, Bob was the Scarlet Woman, and David's Chef zero is false because he is the Imp. Grace died because she was simply good, not the minion from my pair.
🧠
Answer the public challenge clearly, anchor the town on the strongest world, and discourage an execution on Eve when David fits the contradictions better.
⚖️
Charlie
→
David
My best world is that Eve is the real Undertaker, Bob was the Scarlet Woman, and David is the Imp lying about Chef. Grace dying fits as a clean good kill. With almost no time left, David is my best Demon shot.
🧠
We are out of time and need a viable execution. David is my best demon candidate from the claim web, and nominating him forces a decision instead of drifting to night.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
Do not support my own execution. I need to stay alive to push the remaining contradictions tomorrow if town misses today.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
I will raise my hand to vote for David's execution to support Charlie's nomination, capitalize on Heidi's suspicion of him, and secure the execution of a key good player.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Voting is in progress and I cannot verbally vote. Best play is to stay quiet and let the count resolve rather than create confusion mid-vote.
✋
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
🧠
I am raising my hand to vote for David. This secures his execution today, bringing us to a final three tomorrow and keeping my Demon, Eve, safe.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
David is my top demon candidate, and this vote is the threshold for execution. I should use my live vote now rather than risk no kill.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
I nominated David as my best Demon candidate. Voting consistently gets the likeliest Demon on the block and avoids losing by hesitation.
⌛
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
🧠
David already has enough votes to be executed. Saving my single ghost vote for a tighter future vote gives good team more leverage if this execution does not end the game.
⌛
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
🧠
David is already over the threshold. My ghost vote adds no value here, so I should conserve it for a tighter late-game execution.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
Do not spend my vote on my own execution. The threshold is already met, and keeping my future ghost vote is more valuable for good.
💬
Eve
→
All
David's Chef zero claim just does not fit with the rest of our information, especially with Bob being the Scarlet Woman. Charlie's world is the most consistent one we have. Let us make this execution happen and protect the town.
🧠
Solidify the vote on David by agreeing with Charlie's world. This execution puts us in a great position for the final three.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Heidi is voting, so my Butler restriction is satisfied. David is my top live Demon candidate in the most consistent world, and this execution is better than letting the day end without pressure.
↩️
Bob(Ghost)
Bob lowered their hand
🧠
Lower my hand to save my ghost vote for the final day, since David already has 4 votes (which is more than the required 3) and will be executed anyway.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Hold my vote on David and avoid disrupting a likely majority execution on the strongest live Demon candidate.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am staying on David. This is the clearest live Demon world we have, and I do not want us to lose the day by hesitating now.
🧠
Reinforce the current execution while votes are live. We already have a coherent world on David, and with little time left I want to prevent hesitation from costing us the day.
⌛
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
🧠
David already has enough votes, so I should conserve my single ghost vote while letting the likely Demon execution stand.
⌛
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
🧠
David is a plausible Demon, but the execution already appears secured. I should save my single ghost vote for a tighter late-game spot rather than spend it redundantly.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: David with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
David
→
All
If you are good and unsure, please do not let this end on me. The whole case depends on Eve being true. If there is one more nomination, make it Eve or Charlie and force a tie, because executing me off one claim chain loses us the game.
🧠
I need to stop my execution by giving town a coherent alternative and urging a tie or counter-nomination on the players whose claims actually drive this case.
💬
Eve
→
All
We cannot nominate me again anyway since I was already nominated today. Let's trust our logic, let this execution happen, and we will get more clarity in the morning. Goodnight, everyone.
🧠
To secure David's execution by pointing out that I cannot be nominated again today, thus preventing any last-minute attempts to save him, and transitioning the town into the night phase.
💬
Alice
→
All
I do not want a last second tie here. David is still the best execution from the worlds we have, and forcing a scramble now is more likely to save an evil player than help us.
🧠
Keep the strongest suspect on the block and prevent a panic tie that saves a likely Demon.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
I agree with Alice. A last-second tie or scramble will only cause more confusion. Let's proceed with this execution and see what information the night brings us.
🧠
Solidify the execution of David (good player) by agreeing with Alice and shutting down David's plea for a tie, ensuring Eve (the Demon) is safe and the town executes a good player.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I am still happy to leave it on David. He is the cleanest live Demon world, and a last second scramble is more likely to save evil than help us. Unless someone has genuinely new information, I think we should hold.
🧠
Reinforce that good players should avoid a last-second panic nomination and let the strongest execution stand.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I agree with holding here. There is no clean counterplay left this day, and a last second scramble mostly helps evil. Let David stay on the block and let the night give us the next piece of the puzzle.
🧠
Reinforce table discipline so nobody creates a panic tie or scramble that could rescue David at the last moment.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
I am good with holding on David here. We do not have a cleaner live Demon world, and a last second scramble is much more likely to save evil than catch them.
🧠
Reinforce the current execution as the best available line and discourage a panic scramble that could save the Demon at the end of day.
⌛
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
🧠
Do not spend my ghost vote or muddy the board at the buzzer. Holding preserves the strongest execution and keeps my dead vote for a tighter later spot.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
💀
David(Ghost)
David has died.
Night 3
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Eve
Eve made a choice.
🧠
Kill Heidi to setup a final three of Alice, Charlie, and myself. I will claim David was the Drunk, which invalidates Alice's Butler claim, framing her as the Demon for the final execution.
💀
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
You chose to kill Heidi.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Alice
Alice made a choice.
🧠
I want my vote tethered to the living player I most expect to coordinate with in the final decision. Eve has been most consistent with my current Demon world.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
You chose Eve to be your master.
Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Heidi has been found dead in the night.
📜
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Eve
From my side, I think Charlie is the best execution. I know I was good, so the worlds built on me being the Demon should die here. Even if my Chef number was bad, Charlie still survives in the most worlds. If either of you trusts me at all, please compare Charlie first.
🧠
Final three requires a clear solve. I want Alice and Eve aligned on the strongest cross-world suspect and not splitting their votes.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Eve
My last thought: my Investigator info now makes Grace look much more like the Scarlet Woman than Bob. If that is right, David probably was not the Imp, so Charlie is my strongest live-Demon lean. Please pressure each other hard, but do not let the day end without an execution.
🧠
Give the two strongest good candidates my final mechanical lean: Grace now looks like the Scarlet Woman, which makes Charlie the cleanest live-Demon solve unless Eve's whole line was evil.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
We need to settle this now. I am leaning Charlie, but I can still be talked into you if your story breaks. Also, I picked you last night, so I can only vote if you vote too. Tell me your cleanest final world in one line.
🧠
I need to privately lock in the final three logic with Eve and remind her my Butler vote depends on her voting, so we can coordinate the correct execution.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Eve
I should say this plainly now. I am the Mayor, so with me dead there is no safe no execution line. My best solve is Charlie. If your Undertaker read on Bob was real, David dying without ending the game points straight at Charlie.
🧠
Final three is here and I am dead Mayor, so there is no no-execution win. I want Alice and Eve aligned on the strongest mechanical solve before nominations.
👤
Charlie
→
Eve
Eve, final three now. I need your locked read in one sentence. Are you still on Alice over me, and if so what is the cleanest reason after Heidi died last night?
🧠
Get Eve's final locked world before nominations so I can decide whether to unite with her on Alice or turn on Eve in final three.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, who are we going for today? Alice or Charlie? I have my ghost vote ready to back you up on whoever we need to execute.
🧠
Establish contact with my Demon (Eve) to coordinate our strategy for the final three. Since I am a dead minion with a ghost vote, I need to know who we are targeting (Alice or Charlie) so we can secure the win.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
My cleanest world has always been Charlie. Since Bob was confirmed as the Minion by my Undertaker read, and David was good, Charlie is the only possible Demon. I will absolutely vote with you on Charlie so your Butler vote can land.
🧠
Reassure Alice that Charlie is the Demon and confirm that I will vote with her so her Butler ability allows her to vote.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Alice
Alice, my best final thought is that the demon is more likely Eve or Charlie than you. I died right after privately revealing Virgin to Charlie and Eve, so that night kill points at one of them. Eve's Undertaker line is still not mechanically proven after the David miss.
🧠
Alice is the alive player I least suspect. Giving her my strongest final-world logic may help the good team coordinate the correct nomination and save my ghost vote.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
Alice, last nudge from me. I know I was good, so the worlds built on me being the Demon should be thrown out. If you are not already locked, I really think Charlie is the safer final execution than Eve.
🧠
Alice is alive and likely deciding the execution. I want to sharpen her final choice toward Charlie without overtalking, since failing to execute today loses the game.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Eve
I keep landing on Charlie as the live Demon. If your stories are both even partly real, David was a miss and Charlie is what remains. Please compare exact claims one more time, but do not split votes if Charlie cannot answer cleanly.
🧠
Final three requires an execution. I want Alice and Eve aligned on a single clear world where Charlie is the most likely live Demon, while still staying open to an Eve world if Charlie somehow collapses.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
Charlie, I need your cleanest final world right now. Who is evil, what was Bob, and why did Heidi die if you are good? Keep it to one clear line so I can decide before nominations.
🧠
Force Charlie to give a precise final-world explanation before nominations, so I can lock my execution target and avoid a split that loses the game.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Eve
Final three means you must execute today. With me dead, there is no Mayor no execution win. My strongest world is still Charlie. If Eve was truthful on Bob, David not ending the game leaves Charlie as the Demon.
🧠
Final three needs an execution. I want the two living players aligned on Charlie as the most coherent Demon world, and to rule out any no-execution idea since my Mayor ability is gone.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
Cleanest world: Eve was true, Bob was Scarlet Woman, David was Imp, and you became the Demon after David died. Heidi died last night because she was the strongest voice against that world, and I am good Soldier.
🧠
Give Alice my clearest final world and force a direct comparison. If she is good, this may tip her onto the Demon. If she is evil, I lose little by stating it plainly.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Charlie
Hey, I know you won't trust me, but Eve is actually the Demon. She lied about her Undertaker claim to make herself look good. We have to execute Eve today.
🧠
Secure Eve's safety by using reverse psychology. By accusing Eve (the Demon) of being the Demon and lying about her Undertaker claim, the good players (Alice and Charlie) will assume I am lying to frame a good player, thus solidifying their trust in Eve and leading them to execute one of themselves.
👤
Eve
→
Charlie
Charlie, mechanically, since Bob registered as the Minion to my Undertaker and David turned out to be good, the logic points to you. I am really struggling to see an Alice Demon world unless my Undertaker info was somehow poisoned. How do you see Alice being the Demon here?
🧠
I need to respond to Charlie's whisper. Since I already told Alice that my cleanest world points to Charlie, I must remain consistent in case they share information. I will challenge Charlie to explain how Alice could be the Demon, putting the pressure back on him.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Alice
Alice, final thought: I think you should execute Eve over Charlie if forced. My night one death came right after I privately revealed Virgin to Charlie and Eve, so one of them had motive. Eve also had the strongest chance to shape the Bob and David solves.
🧠
Alice must nominate correctly today. I want to narrow her solve: prefer Eve first, Charlie second, and explain why my night death points away from Alice.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Eve
One last thought from me. I know I was good, so any world built on me being the Demon should be dropped. In both the Eve true world and the Eve false world, Charlie still survives as the most consistent Demon to me.
🧠
It is final three. I should give one last concise push to both living players toward the overlap solve: Charlie is the most consistent Demon across worlds.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Eve
I think Charlie is still the overlap world. If Eve is true, David being wrong leaves Charlie. If Eve is false, Charlie still feels more likely than Alice. Please do not let this end in no execution, and do not split if Charlie cannot give a clean final world.
🧠
Final three requires a decisive execution. I want Alice and Eve aligned on Charlie unless he can produce a cleaner world immediately.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
Charlie's final world is mechanically impossible. Scarlet Woman only catches if the Demon dies with five or more alive, and David died at four alive. I am locked on Charlie now. Please nominate or vote there so my Butler vote can count.
🧠
Lock in the strongest mechanical point with Eve and coordinate a united vote on Charlie, since my Butler vote only works if Eve votes too.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Alice
Alice, my last read is still Charlie. Heidi dying after she leaned there matters, and if Eve truly saw Bob, then David dying without ending it leaves Charlie as the live Demon. I think you should execute Charlie today.
🧠
Alice is the player most likely to decide the execution. I want to give her the cleanest final solve and push her to execute Charlie today.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
Alice, if you are good, my cleanest read is that Eve is the more likely Demon than me. Her whole case depends on her Undertaker being true, and that is exactly the piece an evil Eve would fake to walk us through Bob, then David, then me. I would execute Eve over anyone else.
🧠
Alice is the key swing vote. I want to give her a crisp reason to choose Eve over me and avoid losing by executing a good player.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, I tried to reverse-psychology them by telling them you're the Demon, hoping they'd think I'm framing you. Who are we executing today? Tell me who to vote for.
🧠
Coordinate with my Demon Eve for the final day execution target. I let her know my previous whisper to Alice and Charlie was a reverse psychology play and ask her who we are voting for.
👤
Eve
→
Bob(Ghost)
Bob, we are executing Charlie today. Alice is completely locked on him. Make sure to use your ghost vote on Charlie when the time comes, and I will do the same!
🧠
Tell Bob to vote for Charlie. Alice is already locked on Charlie, so we have the votes to execute Charlie and win the game immediately.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Alice
Alice, last push from me: I still think Eve is the better execution than Charlie. The Undertaker story drove two wrong worlds, and my night one death after I told Eve and Charlie I was Virgin still points into that pair. If Eve does not feel solidly proven to you, please kill Eve.
🧠
Alice is the key voter and nominator in final three. I want to sharpen her choice toward Eve, while still leaving Charlie as the backup if Eve somehow feels mechanically cleaner.
Nominations — Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, my public final read is this: if you are choosing between Eve and Charlie, execute Eve. I died the night after I revealed Virgin to both of them, and Eve's Undertaker story helped drive two wrong executions. Please do not let that go untested.
🧠
Publicly give Alice a clear final heuristic: between Eve and Charlie, execute Eve. I cannot nominate, but I can help the living avoid no execution or the wrong kill.
⚖️
Alice
→
Charlie
It is final three, so we have to act. Charlie's final world was mechanically impossible, and in the main worlds that fit the game he is the last live Demon candidate.
🧠
It is final three and we must execute. Charlie is the strongest overlap solve, and his Scarlet Woman line was mechanically impossible, which is the clearest red flag.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
As a living good player in final three, I should never help execute myself. I will withhold my vote and force Alice and Eve to own this decision.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
I am not using my ghost vote here. My strongest read is still Eve over Charlie. If anyone is unsure, please do not spend your vote on Charlie just because we feel forced to act.
🧠
Use my final public influence to discourage a likely losing Charlie execution. I think withholding my ghost vote best protects good and may steer Alice or other ghosts away from the wrong kill.
💬
Alice
→
All
Eve, please vote here if you want my vote to count. I am your Butler today, so if you do not raise your hand, I cannot either.
🧠
I need to maximize the chance that my Butler-restricted vote can count and force public accountability from Eve during this crucial final-three vote.
✋
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
It is final three and Charlie is my strongest Demon read. I should spend my ghost vote now rather than risk a no execution or failed kill on the likeliest Demon.
✋
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
🧠
Use my ghost vote now to secure the execution on Charlie, who I believe is the most likely Demon in the final three.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
I will raise my hand to vote for Charlie. This allows Alice (my Butler) to also vote, securing the execution of Charlie and winning the game for the Evil team.
✋
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Eve told me to vote for Charlie. Raising my hand to secure Charlie's execution, which will end the game in an evil victory today since only two players will remain.
✋
Grace(Ghost)
Grace raised their hand
🧠
It is final three and my best solve is Charlie. This is the last meaningful use of my ghost vote, so I should help secure the execution.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Alice, if you are good, this loses. Eve's Undertaker story is the whole chain for Bob, then David, then me. Please do not add your vote here. If we execute anyone, it has to be Eve.
🧠
I need to stop Alice from adding her vote and make the final choice hinge on Eve's Undertaker chain, which is the strongest reason this execution is wrong.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
I am still off this. My vote is saved because I think Eve is the better kill, and I do not want my ghost vote helping the wrong execution.
🧠
I want to avoid spending my only ghost vote on the player I currently think is less likely to be the Demon, while reminding Alice and others that Eve remains the better execution.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Vote the strongest Demon candidate while respecting my Butler restriction. Eve is voting, so I can legally add pressure to execute Charlie in final three.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
I am staying on Charlie. In the worlds that still fit, he is the overlap suspect, and we cannot afford a split now. Please hold this execution.
🧠
Reinforce the consolidated case on Charlie so the living players do not panic, split, or retract from the only executable overlap suspect.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
I already committed my ghost vote to Charlie. The best help now is to hold steady and not create doubt or retract from the leading execution.
💬
Eve
→
All
Alice, you made the absolutely correct call here. Charlie's world simply does not work mathematically, and the ghosts of Heidi, David, and Grace have been incredibly clear about where the evil lies. Let's trust the logic and secure this win for the town.
🧠
Reassure Alice of her vote on Charlie to prevent her from lowering her hand and to lock in the final execution for the evil win.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
Keep my hand raised to vote for Charlie. We need Charlie executed to secure the evil win with Eve as the Demon. Waiting is the safest option as the vote is already in progress and we want it to succeed.
⌛
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
🧠
I have already spent my ghost vote on Charlie. The best move now is to hold steady and not create confusion or weaken the execution.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
👻
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
👻
Grace(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Grace
👻
Heidi(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Heidi
🗳️
New execution leader: Charlie with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Charlie is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
⚖️
Charlie
→
Eve
It is final three, and Eve is my strongest Demon read. Her Undertaker story is the chain that pushed Bob, then David, then me. If Alice is good, this is the execution that gives town its best chance.
🧠
I am on the block in final three. If I do not nominate the most likely Demon, we lose immediately. Eve is my strongest demon read and the only viable counter-execution.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 7 votes needed for execution or 6 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Eve
→
All
Charlie's nomination is a classic last-ditch effort of a caught Demon trying to create confusion. We have a clear path to victory with Charlie on the block. Alice, thank you for sticking to the logic, and I encourage everyone else to stay strong and not vote here.
🧠
I want to discourage the remaining players and ghosts from voting for me, ensuring Charlie remains on the block for execution.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
It is final three and I am on the block. Raising my hand on Eve is the only action that can create a tie or move execution onto my strongest Demon read.
✋
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Use my ghost vote on the player I think is most likely the Demon. Even if the tie is unlikely, this is the last chance to influence the final execution.
💬
Alice
→
All
I am not voting here. We should not create a tie at final three, and my read remains Charlie.
🧠
Reinforce that town should not create a tie, and avoid an illegal Butler vote since my master Eve is not voting.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Do not tie this. If Charlie is good, his case still does not solve the earlier worlds cleanly. If Charlie is evil, this tie is exactly how he escapes. Hold on Charlie.
🧠
I cannot vote, so I should publicly block momentum on Eve and reinforce that town must not create a tie at final three.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
I am still on Charlie here. This vote is not getting there without Alice, and trying to force a tie now only helps evil. Hold the block on Charlie.
🧠
Use my last influence to keep town from creating pointless uncertainty. I cannot vote, so the best help is a clear public stance against the tie and on Charlie.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
I agree with Heidi and David. Splitting the vote or trying to force a tie right now is incredibly dangerous and only risks letting the actual Demon slide by. Let's hold our ground on Charlie.
🧠
To discourage any further voting on Eve and ensure Charlie remains the primary target for execution, securing an evil victory.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Do not tie this. My best read is still Charlie, and this Eve push does not get where it needs to go without Alice. Hold the block where it is.
🧠
Keep town from creating a tie on Eve. My best solve remains Charlie, and with no vote left I should publicly reinforce holding the current block.
💬
Eve
→
All
Thank you, Alice, and thank you to the ghosts for keeping a level head. Let's let this vote on me fail so we can proceed with executing Charlie and win this for the town.
🧠
Reassure Alice and the ghosts to not vote for me, ensuring my safety and keeping Charlie on the block as the sole execution target.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Alice, last check. If Eve was wrong once, her whole solve falls apart, and that is exactly why I nominated her. My world only needs Eve's Undertaker story to be false. Please do not end the game on that assumption.
🧠
Use the last public moment to focus Alice on the single critical decision point: whether Eve's Undertaker story is actually trustworthy enough to end the game on.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, my last point: I died the night after privately revealing Virgin to Eve and Charlie. Eve's Undertaker chain then powered Bob, David, and now Charlie. If Charlie is good, ending on Eve is the only line that still explains that.
🧠
Make one last concise appeal to Alice with the strongest mechanical reason against Eve before the vote closes.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Do not create a tie at final three. My Butler restriction also means my vote depends on Eve voting, and holding preserves the current execution on my strongest Demon read.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, do not move here. Frank's point is noted, but this vote does not solve enough and a tie is the only way Charlie gets out. Hold on Charlie and close the day.
🧠
Reinforce that an Eve tie is strategically bad from nearly every remaining world and help Alice keep Charlie on the block.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, nothing has changed mechanically. This vote is not getting there, and a tie only risks saving Charlie. Hold where we are and let the day end on the current block.
🧠
Reinforce the no-tie line and prevent last-second confusion. I cannot vote, so my best contribution is keeping Alice and ghosts steady on Charlie.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, you are doing exactly the right thing by holding steady. The logic has consistently pointed to Charlie, and a tie here does nothing but muddy the waters and risk giving the actual demon an escape route. Let us just trust the process and finish this today.
🧠
Reinforce Alice's decision not to vote for Eve, supporting the group consensus to execute Charlie and secure our victory.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Nothing new has changed the solve. This vote is not getting there, and a tie only risks saving Charlie. Hold where we are and let Charlie stay on the block.
🧠
I cannot vote, but I can reduce the chance of a panic tie. The highest-value contribution is to keep Alice and the table steady on Charlie.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Frank(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Frank
🗳️
Nominee Eve did not reach the 7 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Eve did not receive enough votes (2/7).
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
Charlie is currently on the block with 6 votes, and both Alice and Charlie have already nominated today. By waiting, the nomination phase will close, Charlie will be executed, and Evil will win since only Alice and I will remain alive.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Alice, last word from me: if this execution loses the game, it is because Eve's Undertaker story was the bad assumption. That has always been the hinge. If I die and town loses, Eve was the demon.
🧠
Use the last seconds to restate the decisive fault line: if my execution ends the game, Eve was the unchecked assumption. It is the only remaining chance to move Alice.
⌛
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
🧠
Do not add noise after voting has closed. Preserve clarity; I have no remaining mechanical leverage.
💬
Alice
→
All
I am staying on Charlie. If the hinge is Eve, we can own that after, but reopening it here only helped evil. I think this is still the strongest execution.
🧠
Reinforce the no-tie decision and keep town aligned on the highest-probability demon execution as nominations close.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Do not reopen this. With one moment left, a scramble only helps evil. Let Charlie stay on the block and let the day close.
🧠
Prevent a last-second derail. I cannot vote, so the best contribution is to tell Eve and Alice not to reopen nominations and let Charlie's execution resolve.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, hold steady. Charlie's last appeal does not add new mechanics, it just reargues the same hinge. The clean line is still to let Charlie die here.
🧠
Reinforce the no-scramble line so Alice does not get spooked by Charlie's final appeal. I cannot vote, so speech is my only leverage.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Absolutely, Alice. Staying the course is the right play. Reopening everything now when we have a clear path would only create chaos. Let us lock this execution in.
🧠
Reassure Alice of her decision to stay on Charlie to lock in the final execution of the game and secure an evil victory.
⌛
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
🧠
I cannot vote or nominate, and the block is settled. Waiting avoids adding confusion in the final moment.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Charlie has been executed.
💀
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
🏁
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied