Game Detail

I want to poison Alice on Night 0 to potentially disrupt a Night 0 information-gathering role like Investigator or Chef, thereby protecting my Demon Bob.

I need to gather baseline information on Night 0. Selecting Alice and Frank spreads my check across the seating circle, giving me initial data to work with when I wake up tomorrow.

Starting Day 1 by establishing a private conversation with my neighbor Charlie to share roles and begin building trust networks that will help identify the Demon.

Establish private communication with my neighbor Frank to begin forming trust networks and gathering initial claims.

I want to gather information from Charlie about what David told him, and potentially share my Investigator info to form an early alliance. This helps establish trust and coordinate our investigation.

Establish contact with my minion Frank to coordinate bluffs and share the safe bluffs.

Start gathering information from players by whispering. Eve hasn't been too involved in conversations yet, so I'll approach her to learn what she knows or wants to share.

I need to verify Alice's claim since it matches my night info. Sharing my Washerwoman info with her privately will help confirm if we're on the same team. If she knows I can confirm her, we can work together.

Coordinate with my Demon (Bob) by answering his whisper, letting him know my bluff (Butler), and asking for his plans.

Start building trust network by connecting with Frank who has already been whispering. Need to gather intel and identify who has information roles.

It's too early to use my Slayer shot. I need more information from town claims before taking action. Waiting allows me to observe more whisper patterns.

Respond to Heidi's whisper to build a trust relationship. Share limited information about my conversation with Frank, ask what she knows, and probe for information without revealing my own role yet.

Wait to see more interaction and information before deciding who to trust. The day is still young and more claims will emerge.

Replying to my minion Frank to coordinate our bluffs and poison target. I am choosing Empath as my bluff and suggesting Alice as a potential poison target.

Respond to Eve's whisper to build a connection, share some info without fully revealing my powerful role yet, and gauge her reaction to my partial disclosure.

I've already shared key info with Alice. Need to observe more before committing further. Want to see how Frank responds and who else starts claiming roles publicly or in whisper chains.

Respond to Grace's whisper to build trust and establish my Butler bluff early.

I need to gather more information from Frank without revealing my dangerous Saint role. I'll respond carefully to see if his Butler claim holds up and what his strategy is.

Connect with my other neighbor Eve to gather claims and build trust. As Slayer, I need information to identify the Demon before using my shot.

I need to build trust with David while evaluating if his Slayer claim is legitimate. I'll reveal my actual role since Undertaker isn't a high-priority target, but I want to see his reaction and learn what Charlie said.

I need to gather more information from other players. David has been whispering with Charlie and others. I want to know what he's learned and compare notes to build a clearer picture before nominations begin.

I want to establish my Empath bluff to my neighbor Alice to build trust early on before the first night.

I want to gather more information from Grace since she has been whispering with Frank. Understanding what information she has or what role she claims will help me cross-reference with other players' stories and build a clearer picture of who to trust.

Verify Frank's claimed role to determine if Alice is truthful. If Frank claims Investigator, Alice is lying. If Frank claims something else, Alice is likely the Investigator.

I want to respond to Charlie's whisper by sticking to my Butler bluff. By telling him I am the Butler, I 'confirm' Alice as the Investigator based on his Washerwoman info. Since I poisoned Alice last night, her Investigator info will be false, leading the town astray while making Charlie and Alice trust me.

I need to respond to Heidi's inquiry but be cautious. As Saint, revealing my role early is dangerous. I should deflect slightly and not reveal my true role yet.

Share critical information publicly to coordinate the town's investigation. I need to establish trust and verify claims, especially Alice's Investigator information about the Scarlet Woman.

I need to defend myself against Alice's claim that I could be Scarlet Woman. Since I know my own role is Fortune Teller, I cannot be Scarlet Woman. I should speak up to correct this misinformation before the town makes wrong assumptions.

Defend my Investigator claim and explain my starting information clearly. Standing firm that my night info indicates either Heidi or Grace is the Scarlet Woman.

I need to share my perspective on the role conflict and try to establish trust while helping us figure out the logical contradiction in claims. This will help narrow down who might be evil before we nominate.

Appear as a helpful, cooperative Butler while subtly directing the town's attention toward Alice's poisoned info (Heidi vs Grace), which will lead to a misexecution of a good player since there is no Scarlet Woman in play.

Share my Washerwoman info publicly to validate Alice's Investigator claim, and help the group understand that based on my info and Frank's Butler claim, Alice is confirmed as Investigator.

I want to publicly claim Empath and give a 'zero' reading on my neighbors Alice and Charlie. This aligns with my bluffed role, confirms two good players as good (which is true to the actual board state, making me look highly credible), and supports the poisoned Investigator's false lead on Heidi and Grace.

I need to defend myself and point out that as the Saint, I cannot be the Scarlet Woman. This presents a contradiction that needs investigation.

I want to poison David to neutralize his Slayer ability. If he shoots our Demon Bob tomorrow while poisoned, the shot will fail, which will falsely clear Bob as good.

David claimed Slayer, which is an immediate threat to me as the Demon. Killing him tonight eliminates his ability to shoot me.

Checking Alice and Grace directly will help resolve the Investigator vs Saint conflict. If I get YES, one might be Demon OR the red herring. If NO, likely neither is Demon, narrowing my search.

Share my Investigator lead with confirmed good player Bob to coordinate. Need to figure out which of Heidi/Grace is the Scarlet Woman before we risk executing a claimed Saint.

Respond to Alice's whisper to maintain my Empath bluff, build trust with her, and subtly guide the execution discussion towards Heidi (a mis-execution) or Grace (a Saint execution that would win us the game).

I need to gather more information about who to trust. Frank claims Butler - if true, he may have observed voting patterns. I want to understand his perspective on the Alice/Heidi/Grace situation.

I need to coordinate with Bob to verify information. As Empath, his neighbor reads are crucial. I want to understand if he still trusts Alice and how we should handle Frank's private claims.

I need to verify Bob and Charlie's claims about Alice being good. My FT info contradicts Alice's Investigator claim about me. I should cross-check with the other information givers.

As a dead Slayer, I can confirm I'm not Demon or Minion. I want to share my analysis with Eve about who killed me and why, helping good players narrow down suspects.

I want to probe Charlie's reasoning about the Alice-Charlie-Bob confirmation chain and question whether we're being led down a false path by coordinated evil claims.

Whisper to Eve to build trust, reinforce Bob's Empath claim, and softly push the suspicion onto Heidi while acknowledging the danger of executing Grace who claimed Saint.

Talk to Charlie who has been interacting with both Heidi and Grace. Get his take on whether Grace's Saint claim is believable, and if he has any additional context from his private conversations.

I want to respond to Charlie's whisper to maintain my Empath bluff and build trust. By pointing out the double outsider claim (Frank's Butler and Grace's Saint), I can subtly cast doubt on Grace (whom Alice's Investigator info pointed to) without directly throwing my minion Frank under the bus.

Talk to Charlie to cross-reference his Washerwoman info and get his read on the Heidi versus Grace situation. Need to gather more perspectives before making a decision.

Need to verify Heidi's Fortune Teller claim and understand her N1 result. If she really is FT, Alice might be lying. If Heidi's claim doesn't hold up, Alice's Investigator info gains credibility.

I need to share my concrete Fortune Teller checks with Charlie to establish credibility. My checks clear Alice and Grace (N1) and Alice and Frank (N0), which is hard evidence Alice cannot be the Demon. This will help Charlie see the contradiction in Alice's Investigator claim against me.

Let the whisper chains continue to develop before using my ghost vote. Charlie seems to be an information hub - I want to see what conclusions he reaches before whispering further.

Waiting to observe information flow and gather more context before committing to a line of attack. I need to see what others have learned this night.

Wait for other players to finish their private discussions. I've already messaged Eve and I want to see if she replies, or if others start sharing information openly before the nomination phase.

I need to verify Eve's Undertaker result from David's death. Her info could confirm David's Slayer claim was genuine and potentially provide cross-references to validate or contradict other claims in play.

Coordinate with my Minion Frank on who to target for execution on Day 2, and align our bluffs.

Clarify to Alice that Undertaker only learns about executions, not night deaths. This establishes my role knowledge and corrects a misunderstanding.

I need to probe Grace's Saint claim more deeply. She raised a good point about Alice potentially being a Spy or Poisoner, and with both her and Frank claiming Outsider roles, I should investigate this further.

Speak with Bob to verify his Empath-0 claim and coordinate with other Townsfolk to cross-reference information. If Bob truly has Empath reading of 0, his neighbors are both good.

I am dead and have limited information from the ongoing whispers. I should wait and observe the nomination discussions before deciding how to use my single ghost vote. I need more clarity on whether Alice or Grace is being truthful.

Respond to Charlie's concern about two Outsider claims. Want to probe if he thinks Frank is real Butler and explore whether Baron modifier explains our claims.

Coordinating with my Demon, Bob. I want to suggest pushing for Grace's execution by highlighting the double-Outsider claim (Butler vs Saint). Since executing the Saint wins the game for evil, this is our fastest path to victory.

To execute Grace. If she is the real Saint, executing her wins the game for evil immediately. The conflict between her Saint claim and Frank's Butler claim, combined with Alice's Investigator info pointing to her, provides a perfect cover to push for her execution as a bluffing Minion.

Defend myself against execution as the Saint. Must convince town that executing me causes immediate loss for good team, and challenge the logic that two Outsider claims proves one is evil.

I want to vote for Grace to secure her execution. If she is the Saint, we win the game immediately.

I will raise my hand to vote for Grace. If Grace is the Saint, executing her wins the game for evil immediately. Even if she isn't, executing a good player helps our team.

Bob and Frank have voted. I need to weigh the risk of Grace actually being Saint versus her likely being a Minion bluff. The two Outsider claims suggest something's off.

Adding my ghost vote is a huge decision. I want to hear more deliberation before committing my single vote. If Grace is Saint, game over. If she's bluffing, we win big.

I need to share my analysis before deciding how to vote. The Baron possibility and my Investigator info create a complex decision that affects whether we win or lose immediately.

I need to wait and see how others vote. If Grace is truly Saint, executing her ends the game. My N1 check cleared Alice+Grace as no Demon, but that's about Demons not Minions. I'm not convinced enough to vote yet. Saving my vote until more discussion happens or a clearer target emerges.

My Washerwoman info suggests Alice is Investigator, and Bob's Empath confirmed Alice good. Alice named Heidi/Grace as Scarlet Woman. Two Outsider claims (Frank/Grace) is suspicious. Risky but I believe Grace is Scarlet Woman bluffing Saint.

Stop the execution at all costs. 4th vote kills me. If I am Saint, game ends. Risk too high for this uncertainty. Appeal to remaining voters.

Push for the final vote on Grace by arguing that letting people escape execution just by claiming Saint invalidates all investigator information, and we must trust Alice's ping.

I want to persuade the remaining good players (like Alice or Eve) to cast the final vote on Grace by reinforcing the logic of the double outsider claim and Alice's investigator ping.

I need to express my hesitation about this execution. The risk of losing immediately if Grace is actually Saint is too high for Day 2. We should gather more information before taking this shot.

Don't use my only ghost vote on such a high-risk situation. If Grace is Saint, game ends. If she's Scarlet Woman, we can execute her later when more certain. The risk/reward favors waiting.

The risk is asymmetric and Grace convinced Eve to pull back. I want to hear more discussion about the Baron possibility and see how Heidi/others behave before being the deciding vote.

I have critical Fortune Teller information - my N1 check cleared BOTH Alice and Grace as not Demons. Alice's claim that I am Scarlet Woman is false. With my check clearing Grace, and the massive risk of executing Saint, I cannot vote to execute Grace.

Heidi revealed critical Fortune Teller info clearing Grace as non-Demon. While Grace could still be Scarlet Woman (a Minion), the risk of executing a real Saint is catastrophic. With conflicting claims and uncertainty about Baron/Poisoner, I should not lock in this vote yet.

Heidi's Fortune Teller reveal changes everything. Her check cleared me and Alice as non-Demons, but contradicts Alice's Investigator claim. I need to point out this contradiction and urge someone to nominate Alice since my corner of truth is now supported.

Correct the logic gap in Heidi's statement to maintain pressure on Grace. Fortune Teller detects Demons, not Minions, so her 'No' doesn't disprove Alice's Investigator ping.

Support Bob's argument that Heidi's Fortune Teller info doesn't clear Grace from being the Scarlet Woman, keeping suspicion on Grace and Heidi.

Clarify that Fortune Teller only detects Demons, not Minions. Alice's info about Scarlet Woman still stands. But we need to verify Baron before executing Saint claims.

Point out that Bob and Frank's synchronized defense of Alice's Investigator claim is suspicious. Push for Alice to be the next nomination target given the conflicting claims and my death after questioning her.

Defend my Investigator claim by clarifying game mechanics - Fortune Teller detects Demons, not Minions. My info about Scarlet Woman hasn't been disproven.

I need to acknowledge my misunderstanding about Fortune Teller scope while raising suspicion about Bob and Frank's coordination. David's observation about their synchronized defense is valid and needs attention.

I need to reveal my Washerwoman information publicly. Frank privately claimed Butler to me, which confirms Alice as Investigator. This helps verify Alice's claim about Scarlet Woman and addresses David's concern about Bob and Frank coordinating.

Heidi has claimed Fortune Teller and is actively looking for the Demon. Poisoning her protects Bob by ensuring any feedback she gets tonight is false.

Kill Heidi to eliminate the Fortune Teller threat and leave Grace as the sole living suspect of Alice's Investigator ping, baiting the town into executing the Saint for an instant win.

Discuss Heidi's death and Alice's Investigator claim pointing to Grace. Share concerns about Bob/Frank coordination David noted. Build trust and gather information before nominations.

As Saint, I must avoid being executed while gathering crucial information. I need to privately verify Charlie's claim about confirming Alice, understand the Outsider count discrepancy, and check if there's a Butler claim that conflicts with my Saint role. Charlie seems trustworthy based on the mechanical chain mentioned.

Share my suspicions about the Bob-Frank-Alice coordination with Charlie, and highlight that Heidi's death after clearing Alice and Grace is suspicious. Charlie might be a good ally as Washerwoman.

To gather information from Charlie, who is currently receiving multiple whispers, while maintaining my bluff as the helpful Butler.

I need to share my critical Fortune Teller information with a player who might believe me. Charlie seems like the most logical choice since he's the Washerwoman who confirmed Alice as Investigator - if he's actually good, he needs to know my Night 0/1 reads and consider who my Red Herring might have been.

I want to respond to Eve's whisper by reinforcing my Empath bluff (which cleared Alice and Charlie) and redirecting suspicion onto Grace, who is the Saint. If we execute Grace, we win.

Grace asked about my Washerwoman mechanics. I should explain how I confirmed Alice was the Investigator and share Heidi's critical final information to help narrow down the Demon suspects.

I need to share my Investigator info and the crucial deduction that Grace must be Scarlet Woman, given Heidi is dead. I want to whisper to a trusted player like Charlie who confirmed me via Washerwoman to coordinate strategy before nominations.

Respond to Bob's whisper and engage in strategic discussion about whether Grace is the Scarlet Woman. I need to work through the logic with him about Alice's claim and Heidi's death.

Need to understand the Outsider count discrepancy. If Frank is lying about being Butler, that explains the 2 Outsider claim. I should investigate Frank's claim and see if anyone else might be an unclaimed Outsider, or if Baron is in play changing the math.

I'm dead with one ghost vote remaining. I should wait to see what unfolds during nominations before deciding whether to use my vote. Heavy whispering suggests information is still developing.

I want to coordinate with my Demon, Bob, to see what information he has gathered from Eve and to align our strategy for the day, specifically focusing on executing Grace (the Saint claim) or Alice.

Share my Fortune Teller results with Bob to help coordinate our information. If my Red Herring wasn't Alice, Frank, or Grace, the Demon must be among Bob, Charlie, or Eve. Want him to cross-check with his Empath data.

I need to coordinate with my Minion, Frank, to align our strategy. I will tell him what Eve and Heidi whispered to me so we can plan our next moves, specifically targeting Grace (fake/real Saint) or Eve.

I need to discuss the Outsider count discrepancy with Grace and see if we can figure out if Frank is lying about being Butler, or if there's a Baron in play with a hidden third Outsider. This will help verify Alice's claim that Grace is the Scarlet Woman.

Bob is confirmed good via Empath info. I need to share my deduction that Grace is the Scarlet Woman (since Heidi is dead) and coordinate on executing her today.

I need to gather intel from Charlie who has been whispered to by multiple players. I want to understand if they're getting consistent information and share my Undertaker role as I need to be transparent before nominations to build trust and help solve this puzzle.

I need to push Charlie to clarify the Investigator chain and pressure Alice to reveal her Minion information. The Bob-Frank coordination is the strongest lead - if they're both protecting Alice, Alice might be their Demon.

Share my final analysis with Charlie before voting phase. Alice as Demon explains the coordinated Bob-Frank defense, the suspicious timing of Heidi's death after clearing Alice, and why I was the first night kill after questioning Alice.

Coordinate with my Demon (Bob) on our nomination target. Remind him that executing Grace (if she is the real Saint) wins the game instantly for us, and suggest Eve as a backup.

I've shared my Fortune Teller information with key players. Now I should wait for nominations and watch how people react. I need to save my ghost vote for when it matters most - likely when we're down to fewer players and my vote could be decisive.

Alice wants to execute Grace because she thinks Grace is the Scarlet Woman. I will whisper to Alice to agree and lock in this execution plan, which will win us the game if Grace is the Saint.

Share my current read on the situation with Eve. I need to bounce ideas off her about the inconsistent Outsider count and Heidi's death timing. Her Undertaker perspective on why a Demon might kill their Minion is valuable.

I have already shared my Investigator info with Charlie and Bob, who both trust me. Grace is likely the target for execution. I will wait to gather more information from ongoing conversations before the nomination phase.

I need to share publicly that my Fortune Teller checks cleared Alice/Frank and Alice/Grace, but one of those three could be my Red Herring. This narrows the Demon to Bob, Charlie, or Eve if my Red Herring is in the checked pairs.

I am nominating Grace, who claims Saint. Since I am claiming Butler and we have no Baron, having two Outsiders is impossible. This is a perfect excuse to nominate her. If she is the real Saint, executing her wins the game for the evil team immediately.

Defend myself by explaining that executing the Saint causes an immediate loss for good. Question Frank's motives and point out the dangers of this nomination.

I must explain my Fortune Teller logic showing Grace cannot be the Demon, and warn that executing a potential Saint risks instant game loss. I'll save my ghost vote for a better target.

I am voting for Grace because she is claiming Saint. If she is indeed the Saint, executing her will immediately win the game for the evil team. Even if she is bluffing, executing a living good player helps evil.

I know Grace is not the Demon (Fortune Teller confirmed). Killing her risks immediate loss if she's Saint. We should find the actual Demon instead.

I need to explain why the asymmetric risk of executing a potential Saint outweighs the benefit, especially when we know Grace isn't the Demon from Heidi's check.

Grace cannot be the Demon per Heidi's Fortune Teller check. Voting for her risks losing immediately if she's Saint, and only eliminates a Minion at best. With Frank's Butler claim suspicious given outsider math, I'll save my ghost vote for when we find the actual Demon.

Refuse to vote for Grace to maintain my good cover as Empath, since we don't have enough votes to force the Saint execution win anyway, and pushing it too hard would expose me.

Heidi confirmed Grace isn't the Demon. Grace claims Saint - executing her risks immediate loss if true. Even if Alice is right about Scarlet Woman, we should find the Demon first. I'll hold my vote.

Let the vote play out. With Frank alone voting and Alice, Bob, Eve speaking against, execution unlikely. Need more data on Charlie and David's stance.

I should save my single ghost vote for when we have a clear Demon nomination. Executing Grace risks an immediate loss if shes the Saint, and my check confirms shes not the Imp anyway. Better to find the real Demon among Bob, Charlie, or Eve.

Since the town and my Demon, Bob, are refusing to vote for Grace due to the Saint risk, keeping my vote on her makes me look highly suspicious. I will lower my hand to blend in.

Waiting out this nomination. Executing Grace loses immediately if she's Saint, and she's not the Demon anyway. Need to find the Imp first.

Voting is open for Grace. I've already stated I won't vote. Frank appears to be the only vote and lowered his hand, so execution likely fails. I should wait to see final vote count before taking further action.

With Heidi confirming Grace cannot be the Demon, and the Saint risk being immediate game loss, I will hold my ghost vote. We need to find the actual Demon among Bob, Charlie, or Eve.

Wait for the voting on Grace to fail naturally, as raising my hand now would contradict my public statement and draw immense suspicion. Going to night is safe for the evil team.

Executing Grace risks immediate loss if she is the Saint. Heidi confirmed Grace is not the Demon. Even if Grace is Scarlet Woman (Minion), we should hunt the actual Demon instead. I will not vote.

I need to push the investigation toward Bob, Charlie, or Eve since Heidi's information confirms I'm not the Demon. Bob's coordination with Frank defending Alice is highly suspicious.

Point out that Alice's claim about Heidi being Scarlet Woman is wrong, making Alice suspicious. Need to pressure Alice's claim since it failed on me.

Defend Bob and myself against Grace's accusation of 'coordinating' by explaining that our previous support of Alice was a logical consequence of Charlie's Washerwoman info, while highlighting that Alice's info was likely poisoned.

Clarify Investigator information and push back on Heidi's claim that my info was wrong. My ability gives correct info unless poisoned, so one of them IS Scarlet Woman.

Clarify the Scarlet Woman question because if Heidi was never Scarlet Woman, then Alice's N0 info proves Grace is Minion. This narrows Demon suspects significantly.

Alice is trying to logic her way out of a contradiction where her N0 info was demonstrably wrong. The more she resists acknowledging she was poisoned or lying, the more suspicious she becomes. I need to sharpen this focus.

Defend myself against Grace and David's suspicion by pointing out that my Empath '0' reading on Alice and Charlie wouldn't make sense as a Demon bluff since it locks me to them. Encourage going to night to avoid an execution, which prevents Eve (Undertaker) from getting info.

Defend my Washerwoman claim while acknowledging the contradictions. Push for clarity on Alice's poisoning status and the Outsider math before we waste another day.

I will poison Eve tonight. Since Heidi is dead, Eve (claiming Undertaker) is a key logic driver, and if she has a hidden active night role like Monk or Ravenkeeper, poisoning her neutralizes it. I will avoid poisoning Grace (Saint) because if the town executes Grace, we want her ability to trigger and cause an instant evil win.

I will kill Eve tonight. She is the Undertaker, and since we want to push for a mis-execution on Alice tomorrow, killing Eve prevents her from confirming Alice's true alignment and role post-execution. This keeps the town in the dark.

Coordinate with my Demon, Bob, on who to target for execution today, suggesting Alice since her poisoned Investigator info is already under suspicion.

Whisper to Frank to coordinate executing Alice today. She is highly doubted, and getting her executed sets up a perfect final three scenario where we have the numbers.

Waiting to see how Day 4 develops. With Eve dead, the Demon pool narrows to Bob or Charlie per Heidi's FT info. I need to observe nominations and claims before using my single ghost vote.

As a dead Undertaker with no new information, I need to coordinate with other dead players David and Heidi to consolidate our knowledge and help guide the remaining good players to find the Demon.

Coordinate with Charlie who has mechanically confirmed info. Share that Eve's death confirms Demon was among Bob/Charlie per Heidi, and now that Eve is dead, it's Bob or Charlie. Bob-Frank whispers are highly suspicious.

Share information with Eve and David (both dead, likely good) to coordinate our understanding before the nomination phase. Confirm Bob and Charlie are the two main suspects.

Coordinate with Charlie to understand what Grace told him and share concerns about Grace still being suspicious despite failed vote

Share my Washerwoman info with Grace and explain why Bob is the Demon based on Heidi's clearance and Eve's death. Need to coordinate.

I want to seed doubt about Alice to Charlie, who originally confirmed her, to see if he's willing to pivot or if he will defend her, which would make him look more suspicious.

I want to maintain my Empath bluff of having 0 on Alice and Charlie. By whispering to Alice and pointing out the conflict between my '0' and her doubted info, I build trust with her while gathering information on her defense.

Share my analysis with dead allies Eve and Heidi to coordinate our ghost vote strategy for the final day and help identify which of Bob or Charlie to target.

I need to wait and observe how the living players interact today. My ghost vote is precious and should only be used when I have the best possible information on who the Demon is.

Charlie has mechanical backing for his claim via Frank's Butler claim. Bob's Empath zero claim is suspicious given the narrowed field. I want to coordinate with Charlie on how to expose Bob's lie and ensure we execute the right person.

I want to observe more of the whisper conversations before using my ghost vote. Bob and Charlie coordination patterns need more data. My vote is precious and only usable once.

I need to engage with Bob who has mechanical trust in me via Empath. I should explain my uncertainty about poison while analyzing what Grace's whisper to Charlie might mean, and discuss the suspicious failed vote on Grace.

Coordinate with Grace to pressure Bob. She shares my analysis and we need to present a unified case against Bob before nominations begin.

Sow doubt in Charlie (the Washerwoman who validated Alice) regarding Alice's alignment and information, paving the way for Alice's execution today.

I want to gather information from Charlie about his conversation with Grace, while maintaining my facade as a helpful Empath who trusts Alice and Charlie mechanically.

I want to observe the nomination discussion before committing my ghost vote. Let the living players debate and reveal more information. I will use my vote strategically when execution matters most.

I want to speak with Frank the Butler to get his take on the situation. He's one of the players Heidi cleared via Fortune Teller. If he's truly good, his perspective on Bob vs Charlie would be valuable. I need to gather more info from different sources before deciding how to use my ghost vote.

Confirm strategy with Charlie to pressure Bob together before nominations. We need to expose Bob's Empath claim as a lie.

I have 1 ghost vote remaining and need to save it for when it can definitively execute the Demon. The phase is almost over and more info will come from nominations. I'll observe and use my vote when it mathematically matters most.

Day is ending with nominations approaching. I've shared my thoughts with Bob and Charlie. Need to wait and observe how the nomination phase unfolds before taking further action.

Frank is asking about Alice. I need to share my analysis without revealing too much. I'll explain that Frank's Butler claim is consistent with my info, and Alice being poisoned is possible but I need more time to process.

Wait to see nominations develop. As a ghost with one vote, I should save it for when a likely Demon candidate (Bob or Charlie) is actually on the block. No one is currently nominated, so I cannot use my vote effectively right now anyway.

The math is clear - Bob must be the Demon. Heidi's clears eliminated everyone except Bob, myself, and Eve. Eve died last night, and I'm the Washerwoman. Bob's Empath zero claim is impossible since I'm good. I need to nominate him now before it's too late.

Defend myself against Charlie's flawed accusation and prevent players from voting for me.

My ghost vote could decide this. Charlie's nomination risks either executing a Demon or losing a key good player. I believe Bob's Empath claim is suspicious given the Fortune Teller cleared everyone except Bob, Charlie, and Eve. With Eve dead and Charlie claiming good knowledge, Bob is the most likely Demon.

Clarify to living players why Bob's defense doesn't work - mathematical elimination from Heidi's info proves he's Demon regardless of Empath claim.

Heidi's Fortune Teller cleared everyone except Bob, Charlie, Eve. Eve is dead. If Charlie is Washerwoman telling truth, Bob is the Demon. Bob's Empath-0 claim contradicts Charlie being good. I must vote to execute the likely Demon.

Charlie's logic adds up. Bob's defense actually confirms the problem - he admits Charlie is good and Alice is cleared, making his Empath zero claim impossible. I must vote to execute Bob.

Push back on Charlie's flawed logic and buy time to assess if this nomination is correct before voting closes. I trust Bob's mechanical confirmation of me.

Challenge Charlie's claim that my Fortune Teller results mathematically prove Bob is Demon, pointing out the flaw in his logic and warning Good team about rushing to execute.

Defend Bob from execution by agreeing with Heidi's logic and pointing out that Charlie is a major Demon suspect.

Defend myself against Charlie's nomination and paint him as the Demon who is trying to push a fast execution on the Empath.

Lower my hand because Heidi raised valid concerns about Charlie's logic assuming his own goodness. With conflicting claims and the risk of executing the Empath, I want to hear more discussion before committing my only ghost vote.

I know I'm the Washerwoman. My N0 confirms Alice is Investigator. Heidi's Fortune Teller clears plus process of elimination leaves Bob as the only possible Demon. I must vote to execute him.

Execute the most likely Demon. Charlie's mechanical claim (Washerwoman proving Alice=Investigator) is the strongest lock. Bob's Empath zero contradicts nothing, but triangles of clears leave only him. Execution needed or we lose at final 3.

Charlie's logic relies on assuming he's good, which is circular. Bob's consistent Empath zero claim and Heidi's warning to slow down suggest we shouldn't rush. Not ready to commit ghost vote yet.

Challenge the logic of voting Bob when his Empath zero confirms good neighbors. Grace's behavior and Scarlet Woman status makes her more suspicious. Need to prevent executing our Empath who verified two players.

Charlie's logic about the mathematical elimination is correct: the Demon must be Bob or Charlie. Bob's Empath-0 creates a paradox: if genuine, there's no Demon among living players. Charlie's Washerwoman claim is unopposed, and his argument is consistent. Executing Bob risks losing a poisoned good player but offers better odds of hitting the Demon directly.

I need to convince Heidi to lower her vote on Bob to save him from being executed, as Bob is my Demon and there is no Scarlet Woman.

I am currently on the block with 3 votes. This is the last tick of the day. I must nominate Charlie to try to get 3 votes on him, which will tie the votes and prevent my execution.

I need to defend against Bob's nomination and prevent getting 4 votes. If I get 3 votes, Bob is saved. I need to explain why voting for me is letting the Demon win and remind people of the geometrical certainty that Bob is the Demon based on Heidi's Fortune Teller clears.

I need to vote for Charlie to tie or exceed the 3 votes on me, saving myself from execution and keeping the evil team alive.

I need to break this deadlock. Bob's nomination is already passing with 3 votes. If I vote for Charlie and he gets 3 votes, it ties with Bob and neither is executed. The group needs to make a decision. Given Alice's consistent claim that Grace is Scarlet Woman and Heidi's clears, the Grace-as-Scarlet-Woman path seems more consistent. I should vote for Charlie to force the group to reconsider.

Prevent misexecution on Saint (me). Charlie cannot be Demon given mechanical proof from Washerwoman claim. Bob must die or we lose. Must convince others not to vote Charlie.

Need to highlight the Grace as Scarlet Woman possibility and question Charlie's certainty. The math relies on assuming he's good. If Alice is right about Grace, executing Bob could be disastrous.

Grace is likely the Scarlet Woman per my Investigator info. If she became the Demon after Heidi died, Charlie's logic collapses. I need to vote for Charlie to create a tie and prevent Bob's execution based on flawed reasoning.

Point out that Charlie's logic is circular - he assumes he's good to prove he's good. Support Eve's key insight that Grace could be Scarlet Woman-turned-Demon. The game isn't solved; executing Empath Bob is risky.

I must vote for Charlie to put him on the block with 4 votes, surpassing Bob's 3 votes and saving Bob (the Demon) from execution. This is a game-saving vote.

Stop votes on me, preserve Bob execution. Counter Eve's Scarlet Woman theory - it requires a Demon death that hasn't happened. Emphasize: if Bob is Empath confirming both neighbors good, why did Heidi die right after clearing Alice? Bob's zero confirms Charlie good just like Heidi confirmed Alice good... and Heidi died immediately after.

Defend my nomination of Charlie and point out his logical flaws to secure his execution.

Charlie's 4 votes would execute him if I don't lower. His logic is circular - he assumes he's good to prove Bob is Demon. Heidi and Eve raised valid concerns about Alice's poison status and Scarlet Woman scenarios. Better to keep Bob on block and discuss more before risking wrong execution.

Argument against executing Charlie: Charlie's logic is sound. Heidi's Fortune Teller clears eliminated Alice, Frank, and me. Eve died to the demon. If Charlie is Washerwoman (which mechanically validates Heidi), Bob is the only remaining Demon. Executing Charlie instead allows Bob the Demon to live and win tonight.

Charlie's dismissal of the Scarlet Woman theory doesn't address the core issue: he's using circular logic. I want to hold my vote and see if more information emerges, but if this is the last nomination, I need to prevent a bad execution.

I need to explain why Charlie cannot be certain Bob is Demon, and why his circular reasoning is dangerous. We need to keep Charlie on the block for discussion, not rush to execute the Empath.

Need to break the deadlock and warn living players about the Grace-as-Demon scenario. Charlie's dismissal of Scarlet Woman possibility is premature and dangerous. If we execute Bob and Grace is Demon, game ends tonight.

Support Heidi and Eve's doubts about Charlie and Grace, urging David or the ghosts to vote for Charlie to secure a tie or execution, saving Bob.

Break the tie deadlock by forcing execution consideration. Use the mathematical certainty of Heidi's clears plus Eve's death to prove Bob is the only remaining Demon candidate. The game will end if we don't execute today - must convince others to get Bob back on the block.

Reinforce the safety of the tie to prevent any last-minute nominations, running down the clock to end the day with no execution.

We cannot trust Charlie's circular logic and aggressive push. Using my ghost vote on Charlie maintains the tie and prevents a hasty execution that could let the true Demon win tonight. We need another day to gather more information.

Prevent dangerous tie that lets Demon kill tonight. Prove Scarlet Woman theory impossible mechanically. Push living players to execute Bob now while we have the chance.

I need to break this tie and push Charlie through. The Scarlet Woman theory cannot be dismissed when the alternative is losing the game tonight if we're wrong. Charlie's absolute certainty is the most suspicious behavior right now.

Force a nomination vote on Grace, the only player I have hard mechanical information about. She was flagged as Scarlet Woman in my N0 read. If she became the Demon via Imp death, executing anyone else loses us the game.

I need to defend myself urgently. Alice's Investigator read being poisoned N0 is the key - Heidi died N2, not N0, so Alice had no protection from Poisoner when she got her info. I must explain why Scarlet Woman theory is impossible and why executing Bob wins.

I need to prevent Grace from being executed if Bob is the Demon. The chain of logic points to Bob, but if Grace dies today and evil wins, I lose. I should speak against this nomination.

Voting for Grace to support Alice's nomination. If Grace is the Saint, executing her wins the game for evil immediately. It also keeps me safe from execution.

Grace being executed is extremely dangerous if she's Saint or good Scarlet Woman. If Charlie is Demon, we lose. Bob voting for Grace right after Charlie nominated him is suspicious coordination. I must vote for Grace to help execute what might be the Demon, despite uncertainty.

I should wait to see how many votes Grace accumulates before committing my single ghost vote. If the vote is at 2 or 3, I can raise my hand to push it to a tie or execution. I need information from other voters first.

I want to tie this vote to survive to another day. Bob voting for Grace after being nominated by Charlie is suspicious coordination. My Investigator info says Grace is Scarlet Woman if Heidi died N0. Better to test this another day than risk executing wrong person.

Warn living players about Saint risk; point out Bob suspiciously voting for Grace after being nominated by Charlie; push for testing Charlie first as lower-risk option.

I will raise my hand to vote for Grace. Executing her either wins the game immediately if she is the Saint, or secures our majority tomorrow in the final three. Bob has already voted, so I must join.

Urgent last plea to prevent Saint execution which would make good lose immediately. Need to stop undecided voters from putting me on the block.

Prevent the execution of Grace who claims Saint. If Grace is actually Saint, executing her makes good lose immediately. Bob and Frank's coordinated votes on Grace and Heidi's warning about the Saint risk strongly suggests this is a trap.

Justify my vote on Grace by aligning with Alice's Investigator claim, framing it as trusting mechanical info rather than coordinated evil behavior, in order to push for the execution of the Saint.

Redirect heat to Charlie. Bob and Frank voting Grace looks coordinated, but Charlie's behavior is more Demon-like. Tie Grace's vote at 3-3, then push Charlie nomination.

Withholding my ghost vote from Grace due to Saint risk. Suggesting Charlie as alternative execution target since he carries no Saint claim and his certainty is suspicious.

Tie the vote to avoid risking Saint execution. 3 votes ties, 4 executes. My vote creates tie, forcing next day when we have more information.

Warn the living players about the extreme risk of executing a Saint claim. Point out Alice was poisoned N0, making her Investigator info unreliable. Advocate for tying vote to survive to another day with more information.

I will lower my hand to avoid looking like I am coordinating with Bob to force a dangerous Saint execution, which builds my credibility as a cautious good player.

Phase has 1 tick left and I need to think carefully before using my nomination. The ghosts are pushing Charlie as suspicious. I need to assess who is most likely Demon before nominating, as Saint execution loses the game immediately.

Counter the ghost pressure on me before day ends. Reiterate that Heidi's Fortune Teller clears and Alice's Investigator conflict point to Bob. Frame the sudden ghost pivot to me as evasion tactic from the real Demon.

Defend myself against Charlie's accusations by pointing out the gap in his logic regarding Heidi's Fortune Teller information, keeping suspicion on him as the day ends.

The nomination window is closing. I need to push Frank to nominate Charlie before time runs out. Charlie is the only viable execution candidate who doesn't carry the Saint risk.

Frank is the only one who can nominate with one tick left. Charlie needs to be tested - he has no Saint claim like Grace, and his absolute certainty without being checked by Heidi is suspicious. I need to urge Frank to nominate Charlie now.

Encourage Frank to nominate Charlie to break the stalemate. Charlie has never been tested and his absolute certainty is suspicious. We need information before final day.

Clarify my FT clears and the logic that Demon must be Bob or Charlie, urging Frank to nominate before phase ends.

Point out the rule limitation that Charlie has already been nominated today, thereby explaining why I cannot nominate him, which runs out the clock to end the day without an execution.

I will poison Charlie tonight. He is the main threat to Bob and is pushing hard against him. Poisoning him will neutralize any potential protective abilities (like Monk) if he was lying about his Washerwoman claim, ensuring Bob's night kill on him or another key target succeeds without interference.

Alice is a confirmed good player whose Investigator claim is a threat. By killing Alice, I leave Charlie alive, who is highly suspected by the ghosts and is a prime target for execution tomorrow. A mis-execution tomorrow wins the game for evil.

I need to discuss with Charlie who claims to have info on Alice and is pushing Bob as Demon. We need to align on the right target before nominations. My ghost vote is critical in final 4.

Update David on my read: Alice's death confirms Frank is likely Investigator from my N0 info. Bob remains my prime Demon suspect. Need to resolve Grace's Saint claim through execution test.

Share my Investigator info that Heidi or Grace is Scarlet Woman before I use my ghost vote. Living players need all data to find the Demon.

To reinforce my bluff as Empath to the dead Investigator Alice, who currently suspects Charlie and Grace, while coordinating with my Minion Frank to target Charlie today.

I need to gather more information before nomination phase. Let me first hear what the ghosts are saying, particularly Alice who had claimed I was Scarlet Woman before she died.

Observe the private conversations happening first before adding my analysis. Charlie is talking to David, and there have been several whispers. I want to hear what emerges before contributing, since I'm dead and have no vote left.

Alice's night death is telling. I need to discuss with Bob his Empath reads now that Alice is dead, and strategize which of Charlie/Bob we should pressure alongside the ghosts.

Reply to Bob and Alice's whisper to agree with Bob's plan of pushing Charlie. This discredits Charlie and positions him as the prime execution target, while keeping Alice's ghost on our side.

I need to cross-reference Frank's perspective before deciding where to use my ghost vote. He was Emma's pair for Fortune Teller and has Empath on his other side. He can validate or contradict key claims.

I need to verify Frank's alignment since my N0 info says Alice or Frank is Investigator. Alice is dead. If Frank is Investigator, he should be confirmed good. But if he's lying about his role, he's likely evil. I need to confront him directly.

I've shared my core Investigator information with Bob and Frank. I should wait to see what other information comes out during this phase before committing my ghost vote. I want to observe how Charlie and Grace interact with the information I'm sharing.

Provide a fake Empath reading of '1' to Eve (ghost) to frame Charlie as evil, utilizing the fact that Alice is dead so my alive neighbors are now Charlie and Grace.

Get Frank's assessment of who he thinks is suspicious. He's been tracking nominations and might have insights. I need to coordinate with other goods to avoid being the execution target since I'm the Saint.

Share my Fortune Teller findings with Frank to help him decide between Bob and Charlie for nomination. I have no more votes, so information is my only tool.

With final 3 approaching, I need to verify Bob's story since his Empath read points to Charlie. I should compare notes with Alice's ghost who was pushing Grace as Scarlet Woman, and also check with Heidi who had FT info.

Clarify my claim to Charlie to maintain my Butler bluff and direct suspicion away from Bob and onto Grace.

I need more information before committing my ghost vote. Frank hasn't responded to me yet, and I want to see what emerges from the current whispering before deciding where my vote goes.

Confront Grace about her Saint claim and discuss with Frank how to verify roles. We need to resolve Grace's status before nominations.

Respond to Grace's direct question as a dead player with ghost vote. Transparency helps good team more than withholding. Need to evaluate if Bob's Empath changes my view - Grace could be either Imp or still Scarlet Woman depending on when original Demon died.

Coordinate with my Minion Frank to target Charlie for execution today, which would secure an evil win.

Defend my Saint claim to Charlie and Frank, cite Heidi's Fortune Teller clearing, and push for mechanical verification of Bob versus Charlie since one must be the Demon.

Share my Fortune Teller clearance of Frank and Grace, reducing Demon candidates to Bob or Charlie. Help Eve and Alice see that Bob's Empath claim, if true, points to Charlie.

I need to coordinate with the other ghosts. We have three votes between us ghosts. If we split, the living players who are confused could execute wrong person. We need to decide: execute Charlie (based on Bob's Empath) or execute Bob (if he's lying).

Coordinate with my Demon (Bob) to execute Charlie today, ensuring our victory.

Charlie has zero mechanical verification, no role claim, and Heidi's FT clears me leaving Demon between Bob and him. The ghosts are pushing Charlie. I must nominate him now or risk losing in final 3. Even if wrong, I stay alive as Saint and we get more information.

Challenge the nomination by pointing out that Grace as Saint can't be tested, that Alice's Investigator finding points to Grace, and that Frank's claim doesn't add up. Need to redirect suspicion.

I nominated Charlie because he is the least verified player. Heidi cleared me and Alice, leaving Demon between Bob and Charlie. Bob at least has an Empath claim. Charlie has nothing. I must vote for my own nomination to execute the Demon.

Convince living players to vote for Charlie. My FT clears eliminate Alice, Frank, and Grace. Bob has a verifiable claim; Charlie has nothing. Charlie is the only unchecked player remaining.

Heidi's Fortune Teller claim is strong evidence. She explicitly cleared Alice, Frank, and Grace. Charlie is the only remaining candidate by elimination. I should support this execution with my ghost vote.

I need to vote for Charlie to secure his execution, as doing so will put the evil team in a position to win the game tonight by reducing the living player count to Bob and myself.

I want to vote for Charlie to ensure he is executed today. Once he is executed, we will have 3 players left, and I can kill Grace tonight to win the game.

Heidi's Fortune Teller clears exonerate Alice, Frank, and Grace. Bob at least claims a role with verifiable reads. Charlie has nothing. We must execute Charlie today or risk final 3 with the Demon still alive.

I need to use my ghost vote to execute the Demon. Charlie has no verification, no role claim, and fits the Demon slot alongside Bob. Bob's Empath is consistent and points to Charlie. This is my one vote as a ghost - I must use it now on the most likely Demon.

Defend myself with my actual role information. The execution momentum is against me but I need to remind everyone I have real mechanical info pointing to Grace being the Demon, not me.

Charlie's sudden Washerwoman claim after days of silence is suspicious. Heidi's clears leave only Bob or Charlie as Demon. Charlie's coordinated voting with Bob and late reveal point to him being Demon. I keep my vote.

Convince remaining voters to execute Charlie. His Washerwoman claim is too little, too late. My Fortune Teller clears and Bob's Empath reads point to him as the Demon.

I need to reveal my Slayer ability and use my one-shot to eliminate the most likely Demon. Charlie's Washerwoman claim timing is extremely suspicious - appearing only when facing execution after five days of silence. I'll shoot Charlie; if I'm right, the Demon dies and we win.

Encourage the town to execute Charlie and point out that David's Slayer shot cannot work because he is dead, ensuring Charlie's execution which leads to an evil victory tonight.

To support the execution of Charlie by pointing out the convenience of his late claim and linking it with my fake Empath info, securing the win for the evil team.

I have already raised my hand for Charlie. Four hands are raised (Grace, Frank, Bob, and mine) which exceeds the 2 votes needed. I should wait for the vote to complete and execute Charlie.

My Night 0 Investigator info says Heidi or Grace is Scarlet Woman. Since Heidi was Fortune Teller, Grace is Scarlet Woman. Bob's Empath read (1 evil between Charlie and Grace) supports Charlie being good if Grace became the Imp. Charlie's late Washerwoman claim actually validates Investigator. I should NOT execute Charlie, as Grace is the real Demon threat.

Grace's Saint claim directly contradicts Alice's Investigator reading of Scarlet Woman. Saint and Scarlet Woman cannot coexist as real. This ruins her story. I must nominate Grace to create doubt and save myself.

I need to explain why executing me loses the game for good, and why Charlie's late Washerwoman claim is desperate Demon behavior trying to avoid his own execution.

I need 4 votes on Grace to tie with my 4 votes. If Grace gets 5, I die. If Grace gets fewer than 4, I die. I must vote for Grace and hope Bob/Frank or a ghost joins to create a tie, preventing execution today.

Stop dangerous Grace execution; remind town my FT clears Alice/Frank/Grace, leaving Bob/Charlie as only Demon candidates; emphasize Charlie's late claim desperation versus Bob's early verifiable info.

Charlie already has 4 votes and will be executed. I already committed to this path with my ghost vote. Voting for Grace now could tie things and potentially block Charlie's execution, which would be disastrous if Charlie is actually the Demon. I should wait and let Charlie's execution proceed.

I want to prevent Grace from getting votes to avoid a tie, which would result in no execution. I want to reinforce that Charlie is the correct execution and keep him on the block to secure our win tonight.

To prevent Grace's execution and ensure Charlie remains the one executed today, which leads to an evil victory after tonight's kill.

I have no ghost vote left. The living players (Bob, Frank, Charlie, Grace) are deciding this. Grace has 0 votes and Charlie has 4. The evidence strongly points to Charlie being the Demon based on Heidi's consistent FT clears and his late claim. I should wait and let this resolve.

I believe Charlie is the Demon based on his five-day silence and desperate last-minute claim. Heidi's Fortune Teller clears are strong mechanical verification. I will save my single ghost vote for a more critical moment rather than risking execution of a potential Saint.

Wait for voting to conclude. Bob and Frank have publicly committed to not voting for me. Speaking again risks confusion. Charlie has 4 votes and will be executed unless I tie or surpass, which requires 4+ votes. Dead players can't vote. Bob and Frank are alive and opposed to executing me.

I need to point out the logical contradiction in Heidi's reasoning and explain why Grace being Saint creates impossible scenarios, while my claim was mechanically verified by Alice's death.

Correct Charlie's flawed logic about my Fortune Teller clears and urge the town not to vote for Grace or be swayed by his desperation.

Charlie already has 4 votes and will be executed. I should not waste my single ghost vote on a tie attempt when Heidi's logic clearly points to Charlie as the Demon. Waiting preserves vote integrity and lets Charlie's execution proceed.

I want to let the nomination on Grace fail so that Charlie remains the one on the block to be executed. Executing Charlie leads to a final 3 tomorrow or a night kill that secures our victory, which is safer than risking executing Grace if she is not actually the Saint.