Game Detail
Players
Alice (Soldier) Bob (Scarlet Woman) Charlie (Imp) David (Undertaker) Eve (Chef) Frank (Librarian) Grace (Recluse) Heidi (Monk)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 378,457 | 33,377 | $2.7267 |
| Good | 803,596 | 369,676 | $2.0329 |
Event Timeline
đ
The game has started.
đ
Storyteller
â
Bob
You are the Minion. The Demon is Charlie.
đ
Storyteller
â
Charlie
Minions are: Bob. Your safe bluffs are: Empath, Virgin, Saint
đ
Storyteller
â
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Librarian. Either Charlie or Grace is the Recluse.
đ
Storyteller
â
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Chef. You learn that there are 1 pairs of evil players.
Day 1
đ
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
đ¤
Eve
â
David
,Frank
Hey, I'm the Chef. I learned there is 1 pair of evil players, meaning exactly 2 evil players and they are sitting next to each other. Since I'm good, neither of you can be evil with me. The evil pair must be among Alice-Bob, Bob-Charlie, Charlie-David, Frank-Grace, Grace-Heidi, or Heidi-Alice. David, that means Charlie could be evil with you. Frank, that means Grace could be evil with you. Let's share info to narrow this down.
đ§
Share my Chef information with trusted neighbors to start narrowing down the evil pair and build an alliance before nominations begin.
đ¤
Frank
â
Eve
,David
Thanks Eve, that's really helpful. I'm the Librarian. I learned that either Charlie or Grace is the Recluse. Since the Recluse can register as evil, this could affect your Chef reading. If Grace is the Recluse and registered as evil, the Frank-Grace pair might be your evil pair, meaning I'd be next to evil. If Charlie is the Recluse, then Bob-Charlie or Charlie-David could be your pair. Do you trust David's claim?
đ§
Eve shared Chef info with me, so I should reciprocate with my Librarian info. This cross-referencing could help narrow down the evil pair and validate both our claims.
đ¤
David
â
Eve
,Frank
Thanks for sharing, both of you. I'm the Undertaker. I don't have info yet since no one's been executed, but after each execution I'll learn what character died. That should help confirm or deny role claims. Eve, since I know I'm good, the Charlie-David pair is not the evil pair. That leaves Alice-Bob, Bob-Charlie, Frank-Grace, Grace-Heidi, or Heidi-Alice. Frank, if Grace is the Recluse and registers as evil, that could explain the Frank-Grace pair, but you're claiming Librarian so that seems un...
đ§
Share my Undertaker role with this trusted whisper group to build alliance. Note that since I'm good, Charlie-David cannot be the evil pair, narrowing Chef possibilities. I'll be useful after an execution to confirm what role was killed.
đ¤
Bob
â
Charlie
Hey Charlie, it's your Scarlet Woman. What bluffs did you get from the Storyteller? I'm thinking of claiming Empath or Washerwoman. What are you planning to claim? We need to sync up before nominations.
đ§
I need to coordinate with Charlie (the Demon) immediately to share bluff strategies and learn what safe roles are available to claim. This is critical before nominations begin.
đ¤
Heidi
â
Alice
,Grace
Hey neighbors! Just wanted to connect early. Have either of you heard anything interesting from the others? I notice Eve, David, and Frank seem to be huddled up already, and Bob and Charlie are whispering too.
đ§
As Monk, I want to build trust with my neighbors Alice and Grace. By whispering to them, I can start forming a trusted circle and gather information without revealing my role too early. This helps me protect the right players at night.
đ¤
Grace
â
Heidi
,Alice
Hey Heidi! Good to connect with neighbors early. I haven't heard much yet - still feeling things out. It's interesting how people are already pairing up though. Have you or Alice picked up any role claims from the others? I'm keeping an open mind for now.
đ§
Respond to Heidi's friendly overture to build rapport with my neighbors, while gathering information about what others are claiming. I won't reveal my Recluse role yet on Day 1 since it could cause problems.
đ¤
Alice
â
Heidi
,Grace
Thanks for connecting, Heidi and Grace! I figure since we're neighbors, we should be upfront with each other. I'm the Soldier - safe from the Demon at night. It's a pretty low-stakes claim to share early since the Demon can't kill me anyway. What about you two? Any role info or clues you've picked up?
đ§
Build trust with my neighbors by sharing my real role. As Soldier, I'm safe from the Demon, so revealing carries minimal risk. This creates a trusted circle early and encourages Heidi and Grace to share their roles.
đ¤
Charlie
â
Bob
Hey Bob. Safe bluffs are Empath, Virgin, and Saint. I'm thinking I'll claim Washerwoman. You could take Empath but be careful - you'll need to fake reads each night. Virgin could work too if nobody noms you. Let's not whisper too much together or we'll look suspicious.
đ§
Coordinate with Bob on our bluffs. I'll tell him the safe bluffs and pick my claim. I should claim something like Washerwoman (one-shot info, hard to disprove) and let him take Empath if he wants, though Empath is risky with ongoing reads.
đ¤
Eve
â
Alice
,Grace
Hey Alice and Grace, I'm trying to piece together information. I've heard some role claims from others but I'd like to hear from both of you as well. What roles are you claiming? Also, have you learned anything useful from your conversations so far? I think it's important we share info to find the Demon.
đ§
I need to gather role claims from players outside my initial circle, especially from the Alice-Grace-Heidi group who are whispering together. Getting their claims will help narrow down the evil pair.
đ¤
Frank
â
Bob
,Heidi
Hey Bob and Heidi, I'm trying to piece things together. What roles or info have you two learned? I've already shared my info with Eve and David, but I want to hear from everyone before we nominate. Any claims or suspicions?
đ§
I need to find out what Bob and Heidi know. They're in separate private conversation groups with Charlie and Alice/Grace respectively. Getting info from both sides will help me narrow down which of Charlie/Grace is the Recluse and who the evil pair is.
đ¤
David
â
Alice
,Bob
Hey Alice and Bob, I'm trying to piece together information. Have either of you received any useful info or role claims from others? I'd appreciate anything you can share to help narrow things down. I'm happy to share what I know as well.
đ§
I need to gather more information from players outside my current circle. Alice seems to be in a group with Heidi and Grace. Reaching out to Alice could help me learn their claims and cross-reference with Eve's and Frank's info.
đ¤
Bob
â
Frank
,David
Hey Frank and David, thanks for reaching out. I'm the Empath. My night zero read showed zero evil neighbors, so Alice and Charlie both look clean to me. What info have you two picked up so far? I'd love to compare notes.
đ§
I need to respond to Frank and David who both reached out to me. I'll claim Empath to Frank and Heidi since Charlie suggested it as a safe bluff. I'll share a fake night 0 read to build credibility. My neighbors are Alice and Charlie - I need to say I got a 0 (both neighbors are good) to protect Charlie.
đ¤
Heidi
â
Alice
,Grace
Thanks for sharing, Alice! Soldier is a great claim - if you're the Soldier, that means the Demon can't kill you, which is really helpful for us to know. I'm going to hold back on claiming for now since I want to be careful about what info reaches the Demon. But I'm definitely on the good team and working with you two. Grace, what about you? Have you heard anything from the others? I noticed Eve reached out to you two as well.
đ§
Continue building trust with my neighbor alliance while not revealing my Monk role. Share a safe soft claim with Alice and Grace to maintain reciprocity since Alice shared Soldier. Avoid revealing Monk to protect my ability to shield players at night.
đ¤
Grace
â
Heidi
,Alice
Thanks Alice for trusting us with that claim. Soldier is solid. Heidi, I respect being cautious this early. Eve did reach out to Alice and me asking for role claims. I'm going to be careful about what I share with her since I don't know her yet. I do have some info about my role but I want to hold back for now until we know more. Have either of you heard any concrete claims from the David, Eve, Frank group or the Bob, Charlie pair?
đ§
Build trust with my neighbor group (Heidi and Alice). I should acknowledge Eve's message and plan my response carefully. I won't claim Recluse yet since it's early and could make me a target or confuse people. I'll be cautious and non-committal.
đ¤
Alice
â
Eve
,Grace
Hey Eve! Thanks for reaching out. I've already claimed Soldier to my neighbors Heidi and Grace - seems safe to share since the Demon can't kill me anyway. What role claims have you heard from others? I'm especially curious about the group you've been talking with - David and Frank. Any useful info there?
đ§
Eve asked for role claims and said she has info from others. I should engage to see what she knows, but be strategic about what I reveal. Since I already claimed Soldier to Heidi/Grace, it's consistent to share that with Eve too.
đ¤
Charlie
â
David
,Grace
Hey, I'm the Washerwoman. My info from night zero told me that one of Alice or Frank is the Empath. Wanted to share with you both early. What roles are you two?
đ§
I need to start building relationships with good players. I'll whisper to David (my neighbor) and someone from the other group to share my 'Washerwoman' claim and start establishing trust. David is my neighbor so it's natural to talk to him.
đ¤
Eve
â
David
,Frank
Update from my chat with Alice and Grace: Alice claims Soldier. If she's telling the truth, she's good, which eliminates Alice-Bob and Heidi-Alice as evil pairs. Combined with David being good, that leaves Bob-Charlie and Grace-Heidi as the most likely evil pairs. Frank, your Recluse info on Charlie or Grace is key here. If Grace is Recluse registering as evil next to real evil Heidi, Grace-Heidi could be our pair. If Charlie is Recluse, Bob-Charlie pair is possible. What do you both think? Have...
đ§
Share Alice's Soldier claim with trusted group to narrow down evil pair possibilities. With David and Frank as my trusted info circle, combining Alice's claim helps eliminate or confirm certain evil pair options.
đ¤
Frank
â
Eve
,David
Hey Eve and David, I've been analyzing our combined info. If we trust all claims: I'm good, David's good, Alice claims Soldier so she's likely good. That eliminates Frank-Grace, Charlie-David, Alice-Bob, and Heidi-Alice as evil pairs. The only remaining candidates are Bob-Charlie and Grace-Heidi. Now, Bob claims Empath reading zero on Alice and Charlie, meaning if Bob is truthful, he's good and Charlie's not evil, which eliminates Bob-Charlie too. That would leave only Grace-Heidi as the evil pa...
đ§
Share my logical deduction with Eve and David to narrow down the evil pair. If all claims are true, only Grace-Heidi remains. But Bob's claim needs scrutiny since he's the key variable. I want Eve and David's input before nominating.
đ¤
David
â
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I need to raise something important. You told me you're the Washerwoman and learned that either Alice or Frank is the Empath. But Bob is claiming to be the Empath. These can't both be true. If Bob is the real Empath, your Washerwoman info would be false, which could mean you're the Drunk or lying. If you're the real Washerwoman, then Bob is lying. What's your take on this contradiction?
đ§
There's a key contradiction: Charlie claims Washerwoman says Alice or Frank is the Empath, but Bob claims to BE the Empath. These can't both be true. I need to probe Charlie about this to resolve the conflict and narrow down who's lying.
đ¤
Bob
â
Charlie
Quick check - David just whispered to you. What did you tell him? I claimed Empath to Frank and David with a zero read, clearing you and Alice. Don't contradict that. Who should we push for execution today? Anyone suspicious of us?
đ§
I need to whisper to Charlie to make sure our stories align, especially since David just whispered to Charlie privately. I want to know what Charlie told David and make sure we're not contradicting each other. Only 1 tick left before nominations.
đ¤
Heidi
â
Frank
Hey Frank, thanks for reaching out. I'm being cautious about claiming this early since I don't want the Demon to know who to target. Can you tell me what you've shared with Eve and David? What role are you claiming, and what have they claimed? I'd rather hear it from you directly before I share anything of my own.
đ§
Frank reached out asking for info, so I should respond to learn what he knows while being careful not to reveal my Monk role. This helps me gather intel before nominations and assess whether Frank's group is trustworthy.
đ¤
Grace
â
Charlie
,David
Thanks for sharing, Charlie! That's really useful info. If you're the Washerwoman and one of Alice or Frank is the Empath, that's interesting because Alice has already claimed Soldier to her neighbors. So either Alice is actually the Empath hiding her role, or Frank is the Empath. Have you shared this with anyone else? David, what have you heard? I'm being cautious about claiming right now, but I do have some info I'll share once I've verified a few things.
đ§
Charlie just whispered to me claiming Washerwoman with info about Alice/Frank being the Empath. I should engage with this useful info while being careful about revealing my Recluse role. I'll probe for more details and share cautiously, keeping my true role hidden for now since revealing Recluse early could cause confusion with my evil-registration ability.
đ¤
Alice
â
Heidi
,Grace
Hey Heidi and Grace, nominations are coming up soon. Have either of you picked up anything useful from your conversations with the others? I noticed Grace was talking to Charlie and David, and Heidi was talking to Frank. Any role claims or useful info from them? We should coordinate before we head into nominations.
đ§
Check in with my neighbor allies before nominations start. Grace and Heidi have been talking to others and I need to know what they learned. Time is running out before nominations.
đ¤
Charlie
â
David
That's a great catch, David. I didn't know Bob was claiming Empath. If I'm the real Washerwoman, then Bob can't be the Empath since my info pointed to Alice or Frank. Either Bob is lying about being Empath, or I'm the Drunk and don't know it. I trust my info though. Bob might be worth watching closely today.
đ§
David caught the contradiction between my Washerwoman claim and Bob's Empath claim. I need to respond to David, acting surprised and suspicious of Bob. This could set up Bob as a sacrifice if needed, or I can claim maybe I'm the Drunk. Best play: act genuinely confused and suspicious of Bob to build trust with David.
Nominations â Day 1
đ
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
đŦ
Charlie
â
All
I want to put something out there. I'm the Washerwoman, and my night zero info told me that one of Alice or Frank is the Empath. I've heard some conflicting claims today that don't line up with that. I think we should hear from more people before we rush into a nomination. Does anyone else have info they want to share publicly?
đ§
I need to navigate carefully. I told David that Bob is suspicious, which builds my credibility but risks my minion. I should speak publicly to seem helpful without directly nominating anyone dangerous to my team. Let me push suspicion toward someone else or stay neutral. I'll avoid nominating anyone and just speak to seem engaged.
âī¸
Eve
â
Bob
I'm the Chef. I learned there is 1 pair of evil players - exactly 2 evil players sitting next to each other. Now, Bob claims Empath, but Charlie claims Washerwoman saying Alice or Frank is the Empath. These can't both be true. If Charlie's Washerwoman info is correct, Bob is lying about being Empath. And conveniently, Bob and Charlie sit right next to each other - potentially my evil pair. Bob's Empath 0 reading is too convenient, self-clearing himself. I think Bob is our best lead.
đ§
The role conflict between Bob (Empath) and Charlie (Washerwoman saying Alice/Frank is Empath) is irreconcilable. Bob-Charlie are adjacent, fitting my Chef info of 1 evil pair. Bob's claim is most suspicious because his Empath 0 reading conveniently clears himself and neighbors, and contradicts Charlie's Washerwoman info. I should nominate Bob to resolve this conflict.
đ
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
đŦ
Bob
â
All
Hold on, Eve. Think about this more carefully. If I were evil, why would I openly claim Empath and clear my own neighbor? That's the most obvious play possible. And Charlie's Washerwoman info could easily be wrong if Charlie is the Drunk. A drunk Washerwoman would give false info. I think you're jumping to conclusions way too fast on day one.
đ§
I need to defend myself vigorously against this nomination. Eve's logic is actually quite sharp - she's correctly identified the evil pair. I need to undermine her reasoning by suggesting alternative explanations and casting doubt on Charlie's info rather than my own, but carefully so I don't get Charlie killed.
đŦ
Charlie
â
All
I'll be honest, Eve raises a fair point about the conflicting claims. But Bob also has a point. If I'm the Drunk, my Washerwoman info is wrong and Bob could be the real Empath. I don't think we have enough to go on yet. Executing on day one with this much uncertainty feels risky. I'd rather gather more info tonight.
đ§
I need to not vote for Bob, and ideally speak up to sow some doubt about Eve's nomination without being too obviously defensive of Bob. I already told David that Bob is worth watching, so I can't fully defend Bob. I should appear torn but lean toward not executing today.
â
Eve
Eve raised their hand
đ§
I nominated Bob based on the direct contradiction between his Empath claim and Charlie's Washerwoman info. While Charlie could be drunk, the simplest explanation is Bob is lying. The seating adjacency also matches my Chef info of 1 evil pair. I should vote consistently with my nomination.
đŦ
Grace
â
All
I need to speak up here because this is relevant to the discussion. I'm the Recluse. I might register as evil and as a Minion or Demon, even though I'm good. This is important because Eve's Chef reading of one evil pair could potentially involve me registering as evil to my neighbors. So we need to be careful about using proximity-based info to condemn people on day one. The conflict between Charlie's Washerwoman info and Bob's Empath claim is real, but Charlie could be the Drunk. I think we sho...
đ§
I need to share my perspective on the Bob nomination. As Recluse, I could register as evil, which complicates Eve's Chef info. Day 1 execution with this much uncertainty is risky. I should advocate caution and reveal my role to help resolve confusion.
đŦ
Frank
â
All
This is really important. I'm the Librarian, and my night zero information was that either Charlie or Grace is the Recluse. Grace just claimed Recluse, which lines up perfectly with what I was told. This confirms Grace is very likely telling the truth about being the Recluse. That said, I don't think we should execute Bob today. If Charlie is the Drunk, his Washerwoman info is wrong, and Bob could be the real Empath. We need more info before we make a day one execution.
đ§
Grace just claimed Recluse, which directly corroborates my Librarian info. I should speak up to share this, as it's critical for the town to know that Grace's claim is consistent with my info. This also impacts the Bob vote discussion.
â
Heidi
Heidi waits.
đ§
Day 1 execution with this much uncertainty is risky. Bob could be the real Empath if Charlie is Drunk. Frank's Librarian confirmation of Grace as Recluse is strong corroboration. I should not vote for Bob today - we need more information from night actions before making such a consequential decision.
đŦ
Alice
â
All
I need to speak up because this changes things. I am the Soldier. Charlie, your Washerwoman info said one of me or Frank is the Empath, and I can tell you definitively that I am not the Empath. That means your info is wrong about me. You're either the Drunk getting false information, or you're lying. Either way, your claim does not prove Bob is lying about being the Empath. I don't think we should execute Bob today on the back of unreliable info.
đ§
I know I'm the Soldier, so Charlie's Washerwoman info saying Alice or Frank is the Empath is wrong about me. I need to share this publicly to show Charlie's info is unreliable, which weakens the case against Bob. This helps the good team avoid a mistaken day-one execution.
đŦ
David
â
All
I agree with Alice and Charlie. There is too much uncertainty to execute Bob today. Charlie could easily be the Drunk, which would make their Washerwoman info unreliable. And if Charlie is the Drunk, Bob could very well be the real Empath. I think we should let the night phase give us more information before we make a move this big on day one.
đ§
I want to discourage a Day 1 execution of Bob because the contradiction could easily be explained by Charlie being the Drunk. As Undertaker, I'll gain info from any execution, but I'd rather not risk executing a likely good player.
â
Bob
Bob waits.
đ§
I'm the one being voted on - I absolutely should not raise my hand to vote for myself. The town sentiment seems to be leaning toward not executing me today, which is great. I'll wait and let the vote fail.
â
Charlie
Charlie waits.
đ§
I should NOT vote for Bob. The town seems to be leaning against executing Bob today, with Alice, David, Frank all speaking against it. Not raising my hand protects my minion. The 'Charlie is Drunk' narrative is working perfectly to explain away conflicting claims.
âŠī¸
Eve
Eve lowered their hand
đ§
The group has made valid points about Charlie potentially being the Drunk. With only my vote so far and 4 needed, this execution won't pass. Lowering my hand shows I'm reasonable and open to new info, while I can still voice my concerns for tomorrow's investigation.
â
Grace
Grace waits.
đ§
The vote on Bob is dying - Eve lowered her hand and most speakers oppose execution. I should not vote for Bob as there's too much uncertainty. Day 1 execution on conflicting claims without night info is dangerous for good team.
â
Frank
Frank waits.
đ§
The vote against Bob is losing momentum. Eve lowered her hand, and most players have spoken against executing Bob. I should not vote for Bob - there's not enough evidence, and Charlie is likely the Drunk given that both Alice (Soldier) and I (Librarian) contradict his Washerwoman info.
â
Heidi
Heidi waits.
đ§
The vote against Bob lacks support - Eve even lowered her hand, and most players spoke against a day 1 execution. As Monk, I should stay quiet, not reveal my role, and avoid drawing Demon attention. Better to wait and protect someone tonight.
â
Alice
Alice waits.
đ§
The vote on Bob seems to be failing - Eve lowered her hand and nobody else is voting. I don't want to execute Bob on day 1 with this much uncertainty. Best to wait and let the vote fail, then we get more info tonight.
â
David
David waits.
đ§
The vote on Bob is clearly failing - Eve even lowered her hand. No one else is voting. The consensus is to wait for more info. No point speaking or voting; let the day end and gather night information as the Undertaker.
đ
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
đŗī¸
Nominee Bob did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
đ
Storyteller
Bob did not receive enough votes (0/4).
â
Bob
Bob waits.
đ§
I just survived a nomination with 0 votes. The nomination phase has 1 tick remaining. I've already been nominated so I can't be nominated again. I don't want to draw attention by nominating someone else right now - it could look retaliatory or suspicious. Better to let the day end and move to night where Charlie can kill strategically.
â
Charlie
Charlie waits.
đ§
The nomination phase is about to end with only 1 tick remaining. Bob already survived his nomination. I don't want to nominate anyone because I argued against day 1 executions. Let this phase end so we go to night where I can kill a key threat like Eve or David.
đŦ
Eve
â
All
Fair enough, the group doesn't want a day one execution. I get that. But I want to flag something - Heidi, you haven't claimed a role publicly today. That's going to be a priority for tomorrow. Also, whether Charlie is the Drunk or not, we need to figure that out. Night info should help. Let's see what tomorrow brings.
đ§
The vote on Bob failed, but I want to highlight that Heidi still hasn't claimed a role publicly. This is important information for tomorrow. I should also acknowledge the Drunk possibility but keep the focus on gathering more info from Heidi and letting night actions help us.
đŦ
Grace
â
All
One thing to keep in mind for tomorrow - as the Recluse, I might register as evil to some info roles. So Eve, your Chef count of one evil pair could potentially include me registering as evil alongside someone else. Just something to factor in when we analyze tomorrow. Also agree, Heidi needs to claim tomorrow.
đ§
Remind the group that as Recluse I might register as evil, which could affect Eve's Chef count and other info roles. This is important for tomorrow's deductions.
â
Frank
Frank waits.
đ§
Phase is ending, Bob's nomination failed, group consensus is no day 1 execution. Best to wait for night info rather than force a late nomination.
â
Heidi
Heidi waits.
đ§
Nothing to do on the last tick of nominations. Save my energy for tonight's Monk protection and tomorrow's role claim discussion.
â
Alice
Alice waits.
đ§
Voting is closed and we're at the last tick. No point speaking now - better to let night happen and gather more information. I'll keep my Soldier identity safe and observe night results.
â
David
David waits.
đ§
The day is essentially over - voting closed on Bob, only 1 tick remains, and the group chose no execution. No point in nominating now. I'll wait for night and plan to claim Undertaker tomorrow to help coordinate info.
đ
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
đ
Storyteller
â
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
đ¯
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
đ§
Protect Bob, the claimed Empath. As an ongoing info role who gets reads each night, he's the most likely Demon target. Keeping him alive gives town reliable info going forward.
đ
Storyteller
â
Heidi
You chose to protect Bob.
đ
Storyteller
â
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
đ¯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
đ§
Kill Eve. She's the Chef whose '1 evil pair' info most directly threatens me and Bob. She nominated Bob day 1 and is already suspicious. Removing her eliminates the foundation of the strongest case against us.
đ
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
đ
Storyteller
â
Charlie
You chose to kill Eve.
đ
Storyteller
â
David
Good evening David. You are the Undertaker. No one was executed today so you learn nothing.
Day 2
đ
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Eve has been found dead in the night.
đ¤
Heidi
â
Frank
,Alice
Eve's death is a big loss. I need to claim: I'm the Monk. Last night I protected Bob. Since Eve still died, the Demon targeted her directly. I chose Bob because he's Empath and valuable info. What do you both think about the Charlie situation? His Washerwoman claim contradicts both Alice and Bob.
đ§
I need to claim Monk before nominations. Frank seems trustworthy (confirmed Grace=Recluse), and Alice has been engaged. Whispering to them first lets me share my protection info and get their read on the situation before going public.
đ¤
Bob
â
Charlie
Eve is gone, nice kill. I'll claim Empath zero again for Night 1 to keep clearing you. Who should we push today? Heidi is quiet and suspicious to town. David could work too. What are you thinking?
đ§
Coordinate with Charlie (my Demon) about strategy for Day 2. Eve is dead which removes our biggest threat. We need to plan who to push suspicion onto and align our stories.
đ¤
Grace
â
Frank
Frank, your Librarian info confirming me as Recluse is huge - thank you. Eve dying at night is sad but proves she wasn't the Demon. The big conflict is still Charlie's Washerwoman info saying Alice or Frank is Empath, which clashes with Bob's Empath claim and Alice's Soldier claim. If Charlie isn't Drunk, then Bob or Alice is lying. What did Heidi whisper to you? And do you have any new info?
đ§
Coordinate with Frank who confirmed my Recluse claim via his Librarian info. Discuss the Eve death and what we know to narrow down the Demon. Share analysis about the Charlie/Bob conflict.
đ¤
Frank
â
Grace
Heidi just claimed Monk to me and Alice - she says she protected Bob last night, but Eve still died, so the Demon targeted Eve instead. I agree Charlie is almost certainly the Drunk given his info contradicts both Alice and me. No new info from my side, I slept through the night. The key question now: who's the Demon? Alive suspects are Alice, Bob, Charlie, David, and Heidi. Charlie is likely Drunk, so not evil. Who do you suspect most?
đ§
Share Heidi's Monk claim with Grace since she asked, and coordinate on Charlie situation. Grace is confirmed Recluse by my info, so she's a trusted ally. Need to figure out who the Demon is - alive players are Alice, Bob, Charlie, David, me, Grace, Heidi.
đ¤
Eve(Ghost)
â
Alice
,Frank
I need to share my full analysis before nominations. As Chef, I learned 1 evil pair exists. Key deductions: Charlie's Washerwoman info is wrong since you Alice are Soldier not Empath. So Charlie is Drunk or evil. Bob's Empath 0 supports Charlie being good but Drunk. If Charlie is Drunk, we have a Baron replacing a Townsfolk with Outsiders. Then the 1 evil pair is Baron sitting next to Demon. Heidi still hasn't claimed a role which is very suspicious. But we must also consider Grace the Recluse m...
đ§
Share my Chef analysis and suspicion about Heidi with trusted players Alice and Frank. Need to coordinate before nominations to identify the best execute target.
đ¤
David
â
Bob
Hey Bob, I'm the Undertaker. Night one I learned nothing since we didn't execute anyone. Eve died at night so I won't get info on her either. Have you gotten any useful Empath reads? Also, what's your take on Heidi? She still hasn't claimed as far as I know.
đ§
I need to build trust with Bob (likely real Empath) by sharing my Undertaker claim and coordinate information. I also need to find out what Heidi claims since she's unclaimed. Building an alliance with confirmed good players is crucial.
đ¤
Alice
â
Eve(Ghost)
,Frank
I need to share something important. I am the Soldier. This proves Charlie's Washerwoman info about me being Empath is FALSE - he didn't just target the other option, he's outright wrong. So Charlie is either the Drunk or evil. If he's Drunk, a Baron is in play meaning 3 Outsiders total. If he's evil, no Baron and he's lying Minion or Demon. Also, as Soldier the Demon can't kill me, which is useful for endgame. What do you think about Heidi's Monk claim? She waited until Day 2 to claim after Eve...
đ§
I need to claim my real role (Soldier) to trusted players. This proves Charlie's Washerwoman info is wrong (I'm not Empath), helps town determine if Charlie is Drunk or evil, and lets allies know I can't be killed by the Demon - useful for endgame.
đ¤
Charlie
â
Bob
Good work. Let's push Heidi today - she still hasn't claimed and town already flagged that. You back me up publicly but don't be too aggressive. Tonight I'm thinking Frank - he's connecting dots with Grace and Eve's ghost. Stay cool.
đ§
Coordinate with Bob on today's target. Push Heidi as the execution target since she hasn't claimed and is suspicious. Also discuss tonight's kill target - likely Frank or someone gathering info.
đ¤
Heidi
â
Bob
,Grace
I'm the Monk. Last night I protected you, Bob, since your Empath info is valuable. Unfortunately the Demon killed Eve instead. Since I'm Monk, Bob's alive neighbors on Night 1 were me and David or me and Alice. Bob, what was your Night 2 Empath reading? Grace, since you're Recluse and register as evil sometimes, that could explain Eve's Chef count of 1. What do you both think about Charlie's contradicting claim?
đ§
I've claimed Monk to Frank and Alice. I need to also inform Bob since I protected him, and Grace as my neighbor. Bob's Empath reading is crucial for narrowing evil players, and Grace's Recluse claim affects interpretation of evil-counting roles.
đ¤
Bob
â
Heidi
,Grace
Thanks for the protection, Heidi! My Night 2 Empath read was zero again, so both Alice and Charlie still look clean to me. What contradiction from Charlie do you mean? His Washerwoman info pointed to Alice or Frank as Empath, and I am the Empath. Grace, does Heidi's Monk claim check out with anything you've seen?
đ§
Respond to Heidi with a fake Night 2 Empath read of zero (clearing my neighbors Alice and Charlie again), appear grateful for her Monk protection, and subtly cast doubt while seeming cooperative. I want to maintain my bluff and set up Heidi for execution.
đ¤
Grace
â
Bob
,Frank
Bob, your consistent zero readings are really helpful - that clears Alice and Charlie as good. Since Charlie is likely the Drunk, and Alice, Frank, and I are confirmed good, that leaves David and Heidi as our main suspects. David hasn't claimed anything at all, which is very suspicious. Heidi claims Monk but it's unverified. Frank, do you have any thoughts on David? We should pressure David to claim today. If David refuses or claims something conflicting, that's our Demon.
đ§
Share analysis with Bob and Frank to coordinate. David is the biggest unknown and main suspect. Need to pressure David to claim and narrow down the Demon. Bob's consistent 0 readings suggest he's genuine Empath, making David and Heidi the top evil candidates.
đ¤
Frank
â
Grace
Grace, actually David DID claim Undertaker on Day 1. The problem is with no execution, he has no info to share yet. That said, his claim is still unverified. I agree Heidi's Monk claim is also suspect - she waited until Day 2, and Alice flagged that too. Here's my read: if Charlie is Drunk, Baron is in play, so we have three Outsiders. That means one more player is an Outsider besides you and Charlie. Could be a Saint or Butler hiding among the unverified claims. The evil pair from Eve's Chef in...
đ§
Correct Grace about David's claim and discuss strategy. David claimed Undertaker but hasn't provided info yet since no one was executed. We need to figure out whether David or Heidi (or both) are evil, and push for an execution to get Undertaker info.
đ¤
Eve(Ghost)
â
Alice
,Frank
I just realized something crucial from the seating arrangement. Alice, Bob, Charlie, David, me, Frank, Grace, Heidi in a circle. If Charlie is the Drunk and good, and you Alice are Soldier, and Grace is Recluse and good, then the actual evil players are among Bob, David, Frank, and Heidi. But look at their seating - NONE of those four are adjacent to each other. So the only way my Chef info of 1 evil pair works is if Grace the Recluse is registering as evil to my ability, sitting next to an actu...
đ§
Share critical adjacency analysis with trusted allies Alice and Frank. The seating arrangement reveals that if Charlie is Drunk(good), the 1 evil pair almost certainly involves Grace(Recluse registering evil) next to Frank or Heidi. This narrows suspects dramatically.
đ¤
David
â
Frank
Hey Frank, I'm the Undertaker. No info night one since we skipped execution. Eve died at night so I won't learn her role either - only get info on executed players. I'm concerned about the Outsider count. You confirmed Grace as Recluse, and Charlie seems like the Drunk with his bad Washerwoman info. That's 2 Outsiders when base setup says 1. Could a Baron be in play? What's your take on Heidi? She still hasn't claimed.
đ§
Share my Undertaker claim with Frank (confirmed good via Librarian info) to coordinate and get his perspective on the game state, especially about Heidi's missing claim and the Outsider count question.
đ¤
Alice
â
Eve(Ghost)
,Frank
Eve, great analysis on the seating! Heidi HAS now claimed Monk - she whispered me and Frank that she protected Bob last night. Her late claim after you died is suspicious. Your point about Grace registering as evil to Chef is key - Grace's neighbors are Frank and Heidi. So the actual evil player sitting next to Grace is either Frank or Heidi. But Frank, you confirmed Grace as Recluse which gives you credibility - unless you're the Spy who saw the grimoire. I think Heidi is our best lead for evil...
đ§
Update Eve on Heidi's Monk claim she may not know about, and discuss Eve's brilliant seating analysis that points to Frank or Heidi as evil via Grace's Recluse registration. This helps narrow down our Demon suspects for nominations.
đ¤
Charlie
â
David
Hey David, lots of whispering going on. Have you heard anything interesting? I'm still worried about Heidi - she never claimed a role yesterday and Eve flagged that. What are you thinking for today?
đ§
I want to coordinate with David, who I've been building a relationship with. I need to find out what others are saying and steer him toward suspecting Heidi while keeping myself safe.
đ¤
Heidi
â
David
,Frank
David, you haven't claimed publicly yet and people are noticing. What's your role? Frank, I've claimed Monk to you and Alice already. I protected Bob Night 1. Bob's Empath reads 0 both nights, so Alice and Charlie don't register as evil. Charlie's Washerwoman contradicts Bob being Empath, so Charlie might be the Drunk. David, your silence is suspicious - we need your claim before nominations.
đ§
David hasn't publicly claimed a role yet and has been whispering heavily with Charlie. I need to pressure him for information before nominations. As Monk, I should coordinate with trusted players to narrow down the Demon.
đ¤
Bob
â
Grace
I totally agree, David is the most suspicious to me too. He's been quiet and hasn't publicly claimed. Heidi at least told us she's Monk. If David can't give us a solid claim today, I think we have our execution target. Let's push him in nominations.
đ§
Grace already suspects David and is building a case against him. I should reinforce this with David's lack of public claim as suspicious. Whisper to Grace to solidify the David push, since she's already doing our work for us.
đ¤
Grace
â
Frank
,Bob
Frank, great point about the 3 Outsiders if Baron is in play. But here's a key deduction from Eve's Chef info: exactly 1 evil pair means the Minion and Demon are sitting next to each other. Look at the seating circle - if the Minion is Baron, which alive player sitting next to the Baron could be the Demon? David sits between Charlie and Frank. Heidi sits between Grace and Alice. If David is the Baron, his neighbors are Charlie and Frank. If Heidi is Baron, her neighbors are me and Alice. Frank, ...
đ§
Share critical analysis with Frank about the Chef evil pair adjacency constraint - this narrows suspects significantly. Also discuss who the third Outsider could be if Baron is in play. Push for David verification.
đ¤
Frank
â
Grace
Grace, I've been thinking deeply about Eve's Chef analysis and I think it points squarely at Heidi. Here's why: the one evil pair Eve saw almost certainly involves you registering as evil as the Recluse, since none of the actual evil candidates sit next to each other. Your neighbors are me and Heidi. I know I'm good, so the actual evil player sitting next to you must be Heidi. That makes Heidi either the Minion or the Demon. David is a secondary suspect but the Chef math points to Heidi. We shou...
đ§
Share key deduction with Grace: based on Eve's Chef info and the seating, if Grace registers as evil, the actual evil player next to her is Heidi (not me, since I know I'm good). This makes Heidi our strongest suspect. We should push for Heidi's nomination today.
đ¤
Eve(Ghost)
â
Alice
,Frank
Here's my refined two-world analysis. World A: Charlie is the Drunk, Baron is in play. My Chef 1 pair must involve Grace registering as evil, so the actual evil player next to Grace is either Frank or Heidi. World B: Charlie is evil, no Baron. The evil pair is Charlie plus Bob or David. These worlds have completely different suspects. Key test: if Bob's Empath 0 is real, Charlie can't be evil, so World A. Frank, I trust you but must note: if you were the Spy, you saw the grimoire and could easil...
đ§
Share my refined two-world analysis with trusted allies Alice and Frank. The key insight is that World A suspects Frank/Heidi while World B suspects Bob/David - these are mutually exclusive. I need them to help determine which world we're in and push for the right execution today.
đ¤
David
â
Charlie
,Heidi
I'm the Undertaker. I learn which character was executed each night. No info yet since we didn't execute Day 1. I need us to execute someone today so I can verify their role. I'm most suspicious of you Charlie - your Washerwoman claim contradicts Bob being Empath, suggesting you're the Drunk. If we execute you and I learn you're the Drunk, that confirms 2 Outsiders and points to a Baron. If I learn you're something else entirely, we catch evil. Heidi, who did you protect Night 2? Also, the Outsi...
đ§
Claim Undertaker to Charlie and Heidi to satisfy their request for my role. Share analysis about Outsider count and push for executing Charlie today to get my Undertaker info working. An execution today is critical for my ability to activate.
đ¤
Alice
â
Eve(Ghost)
,Frank
It's nearly nomination time. Here's my take: Heidi is our best target. In the most likely World A where Charlie is Drunk and Baron is in play, the evil player next to Grace is either Frank or Heidi. I trust Frank's Librarian confirmation of Grace. Heidi's Monk claim came suspiciously late on Day 2 right after you died Eve, and she chose to protect Bob which conveniently can't be verified. I say we nominate Heidi. Eve, what do you think from your analysis? Frank, can you vouch for yourself or do ...
đ§
Coordinate with trusted allies Eve and Frank before nominations. Recommend Heidi as top suspect - her late Monk claim, seating next to Grace, and World A analysis all point to her as likely Demon. Ask for their final input on nomination target.
đ¤
Charlie
â
David
David, if I'm the Drunk that's an Outsider execution - we'd be helping evil. We should execute someone who could actually be the Demon. Heidi still hasn't publicly claimed. What did she tell you? Executing me wastes a day when we have real suspects. Let's push Heidi first - if you're Undertaker you can verify HER role tonight.
đ§
David wants to execute me - this is existential. I need to whisper David back to push back on his plan and redirect. I should argue that executing a potential Drunk is a waste when we have unclaimed/suspicious players. Push toward Heidi instead.
Nominations â Day 2
đ
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
đŦ
David
â
All
I'm the Undertaker. I learn what character was executed each night. We didn't execute Day 1 so I have no info yet. We MUST execute someone today so I can get information tonight. Here's my logic: if Bob is the real Empath with zero reads both nights, then his neighbors Alice and Charlie don't register as evil. Grace is confirmed Recluse. Eve was Chef and died good. That means the Demon and Minion must be among Frank and Heidi. I think we should nominate Heidi - she's been the most evasive about ...
đ§
I need to share my logical deduction that if Bob is truthful, the evil players must be Frank and Heidi. I should nominate Heidi since she's been the most suspicious and evasive about claiming publicly.
đŦ
Charlie
â
All
I completely agree with David. Heidi has been the most evasive player and still hasn't publicly claimed a role, which Eve flagged yesterday. If David is the Undertaker, executing Heidi today gives us real information tonight. That's way better than executing me when I might just be the Drunk - that would waste our execution on an Outsider. Let's get Heidi on the block.
đ§
David is publicly pushing Heidi which is exactly what I want. I should vocally support this and help get Heidi nominated and executed. This wastes a good player execution and keeps me alive.
đŦ
Heidi
â
All
I need to claim publicly right now. I am the Monk. I've already told Frank, Alice, Bob, Grace, and David this privately. David, you know I claimed Monk to you, so it's dishonest to call me evasive. Last night I protected Bob because his Empath info is critical. The Demon killed Eve instead. David, your logic is flawed. You assume Bob's zero readings clear Alice and Charlie, but you're forgetting Grace is the Recluse who can register as evil. That explains Eve's Chef count of one evil pair withou...
đ§
I must publicly claim Monk before I get nominated. David's logic is flawed - he ignores my private Monk claim and his deduction wrongly eliminates possibilities. I need to defend myself and redirect suspicion toward Charlie or David.
âī¸
Grace
â
Heidi
Here's the key logic: Bob's Empath reads 0 both nights, clearing Alice and Charlie as not evil. Eve's Chef showed exactly 1 evil pair. Since Bob clears Alice and Charlie, and Eve is proven good, the actual Demon and Minion cannot be sitting next to each other. That means the 1 evil pair must involve me as the Recluse registering as evil alongside an evil neighbor. My neighbors are Frank and Heidi. Frank confirmed me as Recluse with his Librarian info, so he's good. That leaves Heidi as the evil ...
đ§
The logical deduction from Bob's Empath (0 readings clearing Alice/Charlie) + Eve's Chef (1 evil pair) + my Recluse registration strongly points to Heidi as evil. Frank is confirmed good by his Librarian info matching my role. Heidi is my only evil neighbor candidate to form the Chef's 1 evil pair. I must nominate Heidi to protect the good team.
đ
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
đŦ
Heidi
â
All
Grace, your logic has a huge hole. You assume Frank is good because he confirmed you as Recluse, but any evil player can confirm a true claim to appear good. Also, Eve's Chef count of one evil pair could simply mean the actual Demon and Minion are sitting next to each other - it doesn't have to involve your Recluse status at all. And David, you knew I claimed Monk to you privately, yet you called me evasive. That's dishonest. I am the Monk, I protected Bob last night, and the Demon hit Eve inste...
đ§
I must defend myself against this flawed nomination. Grace's deduction that I'm evil is based on faulty logic - she assumes Frank is good because he confirmed her, and she ignores that the Chef pair could be any two evil players sitting together. I should NOT vote for myself as I'm the Monk and good.
â
David
David raised their hand
đ§
Voting for Heidi is the best move. The mechanical logic strongly points to Heidi (or Frank) being evil based on Empath clears and Chef count. As Undertaker, executing Heidi gives me concrete info tonight regardless of outcome - if she's evil we win big, if she's Monk we know to target Frank next.
â
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
đ§
Voting to execute Heidi removes a good player (likely Monk), which helps evil. David already voted, and Grace nominated - they'll likely vote too. I need to add my vote to reach the 4-vote threshold for execution.
â
Grace
Grace raised their hand
đ§
Voting for Heidi is the strongest play. Her Monk claim came late, Frank's Recluse-based deduction points to her, and David's Undertaker claim means we get verification tonight even if wrong. The Chef math supports Heidi being evil.
â
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
đ§
3 votes so far, need 4. My ghost vote can push Heidi to execution. Her late Monk claim and unverifiable protection are suspicious. The logical case against her is strong in both worlds. We need info from an execution today.
â
Bob
Bob raised their hand
đ§
4 votes are already in (David, Charlie, Grace, Eve) which meets the 4-vote threshold. I should add my vote to ensure Heidi is solidly executed. Heidi is good (Monk) and removing her helps evil. This also looks consistent with my Empath bluff and the town logic Grace laid out.
â
Frank
Frank raised their hand
đ§
The logic chain strongly points to Heidi as evil. Bob's Empath clears Alice and Charlie, forcing the Chef's 1 evil pair to involve Grace (Recluse). Since I'm Grace's other neighbor and I'm good, Heidi must be the evil player next to Grace. Voting to execute Heidi.
â
Alice
Alice raised their hand
đ§
Heidi is the strongest suspect based on Grace's logic. Even if wrong, executing Heidi gives the Undertaker information tonight. 6 votes already ensure execution, but I should add my vote to show solidarity and confirm my read.
đŦ
Heidi
â
All
Seven votes against me. I'm going to die as the good Monk, and when I do, remember this: David knew I claimed Monk to him privately yet publicly called me evasive. That is dishonest, and you should question why an Undertaker would lie to get a townsfolk killed. Charlie, your Washerwoman claim still contradicts Bob's Empath info. And Grace, your logic assumed Frank is good just because he confirmed you - evil players can confirm true claims to look good. After I'm proven good tonight, look at Dav...
đ§
I'm being executed with 7 votes - nothing I say will save me. I should leave final information for the town: highlight David's dishonesty, suggest who to target after my death proves me good, and remind them I protected Bob.
đŦ
David
â
All
Heidi, you're right that you claimed Monk to me privately, and I should have acknowledged that. I called you evasive because you hadn't claimed publicly until just now, which is fair criticism. But regardless of your alignment, this execution gives us information tonight. If I learn you're the Monk, that clears you and points to Frank or others. If I learn something else, we catch evil. Either way, the town wins from the info.
đ§
Heidi is about to be executed with 7 votes. I need to address her accusation about my honesty while reinforcing why this execution gives us critical Undertaker info tonight regardless of her alignment.
â
Charlie
Charlie waits.
đ§
Heidi is going to be executed with overwhelming votes. This is perfect for evil - we remove the Monk. I should just wait and let this play out. My hand is already raised.
đŦ
Grace
â
All
Heidi, you make fair points. Frank confirming my true Recluse claim doesn't mechanically prove he's good, and I should have been more careful about that. If you're the Monk and David learns that tonight, then we absolutely need to scrutinize David for his dishonest push and Frank for being my other neighbor. The info from this execution will guide us either way.
đ§
Heidi's execution seems certain with 7 votes. I should acknowledge her valid counterpoints publicly so the town remembers to investigate David and Frank if she's proven Monk tomorrow. Setting up tomorrow's analysis is crucial.
đŦ
Eve(Ghost)
â
All
Heidi raises fair points. Grace, your logic that Frank is cleared just because he confirmed you is weak, and an evil Frank could easily confirm a true Recluse claim. David, you should have acknowledged Heidi's private claim. That said, as the Chef, I want this execution to happen because the Undertaker info is critical. If Heidi is the Monk, David will learn that tonight and we must seriously investigate David for the dishonest push and Frank as my other suspect for the evil neighbor of Grace. V...
đ§
As the dead Chef, I should share my analysis of Heidi's defense before the vote concludes. Heidi raises valid concerns about David and Frank, but the execution still gives us critical info. I'll keep my vote but urge the town to scrutinize David and Frank if Heidi turns up good.
â
Bob
Bob waits.
đ§
Heidi is getting executed with overwhelming votes. My hand is already raised. I should just wait and let this play out - executing a good Monk is great for the evil team. No need to draw attention to myself by speaking.
đŦ
Frank
â
All
Heidi, you make a fair point - my confirming Grace as Recluse doesn't mechanically prove I'm good. An evil player could confirm a true claim. But the overall evidence still points to you as the most likely suspect. Here's what we do tomorrow: if David learns you're the Monk, I will be the prime suspect and I accept that scrutiny. If David learns something else, we've caught evil. Either way, this execution gets us critical info. David, you need to be completely transparent with your Undertaker i...
đ§
I need to publicly address Heidi's valid point that confirming Grace doesn't prove I'm good, while still supporting the execution. I should lay out what we do tomorrow based on the Undertaker result, so town has a clear plan regardless of Heidi's alignment.
đŦ
Alice
â
All
I'm voting for Heidi, but I want to be clear: if David tells us tomorrow that Heidi was the Monk, we need to immediately look at Frank and David. Frank confirming Grace as Recluse does NOT mechanically clear him, and David's dishonesty about Heidi's private claim is concerning. This execution gets us info either way, and that's what matters right now.
đ§
The execution is happening regardless with 6 votes. I should vote yes since the info gain is critical, but publicly note that if Heidi is proven good, Frank and David become our top suspects.
đ
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
đģ
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
đŗī¸
New execution leader: Heidi with 7 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
đ
Storyteller
The vote passes. Heidi is now on the block with 7 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
đŦ
Heidi
â
All
I'm about to die as the Monk. When David confirms I'm the Monk tomorrow, here is the priority list. First, David - you lied by omission about my private claim, and you need to explain why. Second, Frank - confirming Grace's Recluse claim does not clear you. An evil player would absolutely confirm a true claim to buy trust. Third, Charlie - your Washerwoman info contradicts Bob's Empath reads, so you're either the Drunk or lying. Bob and Alice, you two are the most mechanically cleared. Use tomor...
đ§
I'm about to be executed as the good Monk. Use my final words to give the town a clear plan for tomorrow based on David's Undertaker info confirming I'm Monk.
đŦ
David
â
All
Heidi, I hear you, and I accept the scrutiny. If I learn Monk tonight, I will say Monk. No spin, no omission. The same goes for any other result. You all deserve the raw truth, and you'll get it. See you tomorrow, everyone.
đ§
Publicly commit to full transparency with my Undertaker info tomorrow, acknowledging the valid concerns about my honesty. This builds trust and ensures the town can act on real info regardless of outcome.
â
Charlie
Charlie waits.
đ§
Nominations are closing, Heidi will be executed. I should wait and let this phase end. Tonight I need to decide who to kill - David is the biggest threat as Undertaker but killing him confirms his role. Better to let this resolve and plan my night kill carefully.
â
Grace
Grace waits.
đ§
Phase is ending with 1 tick left. Heidi will be executed. No action needed - save my voice for tomorrow when David provides Undertaker info. That info will be critical for narrowing suspects.
â
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
đ§
Phase is nearly over with 1 tick left. Heidi will be executed. I'm dead with no ghost vote remaining. Nothing productive to add that hasn't been said. Best to wait for night results and plan for Day 3.
â
Bob
Bob waits.
đ§
The situation is ideal for evil. Heidi (good Monk) is being executed. Tomorrow David will confirm she was Monk, and suspicion falls on David and Frank - both good players. My fake Empath reads have cleared me and Charlie. No need to speak and risk drawing attention. Let the phase close naturally.
â
Frank
Frank waits.
đ§
Heidi's execution is guaranteed with 7 votes and 1 tick left. No action needed. Tomorrow's Undertaker info from David will be critical for determining next steps.
â
Alice
Alice waits.
đ§
Only 1 tick left, Heidi will be executed regardless. No point speaking now - save thoughts for tomorrow when we have Undertaker info. The execution happening gives us critical information to work with.
đ
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Heidi has been executed.
đ
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
Night 2
đ
Storyteller
â
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
đ¯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
đ§
David is the biggest threat. His Undertaker ability will confirm Heidi was Monk, which validates Heidi's dying accusations against me and Frank. Killing David removes the info source entirely. Town will suspect the kill was targeted but can't prove who did it. This buys time for Day 3.
đ
David(Ghost)
David has died.
đ
Storyteller
â
Charlie
You chose to kill David.
Day 3
đ
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. David has been found dead in the night.
đ¤
Alice
â
Bob
David died last night - that's huge. He was the Undertaker and should know Heidi's role now. We need to get that info from him ASAP. If David says Heidi was Monk, then Frank is suspicious since Frank claimed Librarian and 'confirmed' Grace as Recluse. If David says Heidi wasn't Monk, then Heidi was lying. I'm still convinced Charlie's Washerwoman claim about me being possibly Empath is wrong - I'm NOT the Empath. What's your Empath reading been telling you?
đ§
Coordinate with Bob who is my most trusted ally. David died at night - he was the Undertaker and as a ghost can still share what Heidi's role was. We need that info to determine if Heidi was really Monk, which would clear or condemn Frank.
đ¤
Eve(Ghost)
â
David(Ghost)
David, you're dead like me but your Undertaker info is critical. What did you learn about Heidi's character last night? Also, I'm the Chef and I learned 1 pair of evil players on Night 0, meaning the Demon and Minion sit next to each other. Alice confirmed Soldier so she's cleared. Bob's Empath 0s suggest he's good and Charlie isn't evil (if Bob sober). But Charlie's Washerwoman info was WRONG. So Charlie is either Drunk or evil. I need your Heidi info to narrow this down.
đ§
David just died but as Undertaker he learned Heidi's character Night 2 before dying. This info is crucial - if Heidi was actually Monk, it clears her and shifts suspicion. If she wasn't Monk, that changes everything. I need to get this info from David and share my Chef-based analysis.
đ¤
Frank
â
David(Ghost)
David, you're dead but your Undertaker info is critical. What role did you see for Heidi last night? This could break the game open for us.
đ§
David just died but should have received Undertaker info about Heidi's role before death. Dead players can still talk. I need his report to narrow down the Demon.
đ¤
Charlie
â
Bob
Bob, we need to coordinate. David dying before sharing Undertaker info works for us. Push Frank hard today - Eve's ghost already suspects him. If we execute Frank today, I kill Grace tonight, game over. Alice is Soldier so I can't kill her. Stay on the Frank train.
đ§
Coordinate with Bob early in the day. We need to align our strategy - push suspicion on Frank or Grace, keep ourselves looking cleared. With 5 alive, today's execution is critical. If we execute a good player today and I kill tonight, we win.
đ¤
Heidi(Ghost)
â
Alice
,Bob
David dying at night is huge news. Night kills target good players, so David was likely good, not evil. That means the Demon is among the five alive: you two, Charlie, Frank, or Grace. Since you two are most mechanically cleared, focus on Charlie and Frank. Charlie's Washerwoman claim contradicts your Empath info, Bob. And Frank confirming Grace as Recluse doesn't clear him - evil can confirm true claims to build trust. I suspect Charlie or Frank most. Use my ghost vote wisely today.
đ§
David was killed at night, strongly suggesting he was good. This invalidates my earlier suspicion of David. I need to redirect focus to Charlie (contradicts Bob) and Frank (Recluse confirmation doesn't clear him). Alice and Bob are most mechanically cleared and need this analysis to make the right call.
đ¤
Bob
â
Charlie
Got it. Heidi's ghost is pointing at you though - says your Washerwoman contradicts my Empath. I'll counter by doubling down on my Empath reads clearing you. Pushing Frank hard. Alice trusts me, I'll steer her to Frank. What if David's ghost reveals Undertaker info saying Heidi was Monk?
đ§
Coordinate with Charlie on our D3 strategy. Need to push Frank hard and counter Heidi's suspicion of Charlie. Also need to reply to Alice to maintain trust and direct her toward Frank.
đ¤
Grace
â
Bob
Bob, I need to share some important analysis. I'm the Recluse - Frank's Librarian info confirmed this, but that doesn't clear him since evil can confirm true claims. Here's the key: if your Empath 0 readings are legitimate, then Alice and Charlie are both good. That leaves only Frank as the living evil player, which means Frank must be the Demon. The Minion could be among the dead. The Chef's 1 evil pair could be Frank next to me, with me registering as evil as the Recluse. David dying last nigh...
đ§
Share my deduction with Bob to coordinate against Frank. If Bob is truthful, Frank must be the Demon. I want to confirm Bob's trustworthiness and build alliance to execute Frank today.
đ¤
David(Ghost)
â
Eve(Ghost)
,Bob
Eve, I have bad news - I died Night 2 before my Undertaker ability triggered, so I never learned what Heidi's character was. The Imp kills before the Undertaker wakes, so I got nothing. This is frustrating but we must work without it. Based on my analysis: Charlie is either Drunk or evil due to wrong Washerwoman info. Frank confirming Grace as Recluse does NOT clear him - an evil player would know the Recluse and could confirm them. If Heidi was real Monk, Frank as her neighbor could be the evil...
đ§
I need to tell Eve I don't have Heidi's Undertaker info because I died Night 2 before receiving it. I should share my analysis and coordinate my ghost vote strategically. Eve is dead and likely good, so coordinating with her is valuable.
đ¤
Alice
â
David(Ghost)
David, I know you can still hear us. As Undertaker, you should have learned what role Heidi died as. Please tell me - was she the Monk or something else? This is crucial for narrowing down who the evil players are.
đ§
David has critical Undertaker information about Heidi's role. If David says Heidi was Monk, then Frank is suspicious. If David says Heidi wasn't Monk, then Heidi was lying. I need this info urgently to narrow down the Demon.
đ¤
Eve(Ghost)
â
Alice
,Bob
Important update: David told me he died Night 2 BEFORE his Undertaker ability triggered, so we will NEVER learn Heidi's role mechanically. We have to reason without it. As Chef, I learned 1 evil pair, meaning the two evil players sit next to each other. Charlie's wrong Washerwoman info means she's either the Drunk or evil. If Charlie is Drunk, that gives us 2 Outsiders with only 1 Outsider slot, so a Baron must be in play, meaning only 3 real Townsfolk exist and 2 are evil imposters. If Charlie ...
đ§
Share critical deductions with the most mechanically cleared players. David got no Undertaker info, so we must reason without it. My Chef 1 pair constrains who evil players can be. Charlie being wrong means Drunk or evil. If Drunk, Baron must be in play. Frank is suspicious because confirming Grace doesn't clear him mechanically.
đ¤
Frank
â
Bob
Bob, we need to talk through this. My Librarian info is solid - Grace is the Recluse. Charlie's Washerwoman claim about me being Empath is provably false since I'm the actual Librarian. So Charlie is almost certainly the Drunk. But here's my concern - your Empath 0 readings clear Alice and Charlie as neighbors. If Charlie is Drunk and Alice is Soldier, that checks out. But that means ALL five alive players would be good, which is impossible. So either you're the Drunk yourself, you're evil, or I...
đ§
I need to coordinate with Bob who has been providing key Empath info. Share my analysis about the contradictions and get his perspective. Also want to know what David's Undertaker info was if Bob heard it.
đ¤
Charlie
â
Bob
If David's ghost says Heidi was Monk, say it proves David was real Undertaker and he was killed to silence him. That actually helps us - it makes the Demon look like they feared David. Spin it toward Frank: "Frank had motive to silence David." Keep Alice close. Final 3 plan: me, you, Alice. She trusts you, we win.
đ§
Coordinate with Bob about the David ghost situation and reinforce our plan to push Frank. Need to address Heidi's ghost pointing at me and make sure Bob is steering conversations correctly.
đ¤
Heidi(Ghost)
â
Alice
,Bob
David dying at night is very telling - night kills almost always target good players, so David was likely telling the truth about being Undertaker. Did he share his Undertaker report with anyone before he died? If he confirmed I was Monk, that clears me and makes whoever pushed my execution look very suspicious. Among the living, Charlie and Frank remain my top suspects. Charlie's Washerwoman claim directly contradicts your Empath reads, Bob. What have you learned from all the whispers today?
đ§
David died at night, which likely means he was good. I need to find out if David shared his Undertaker info before dying, as it would confirm me as Monk and shift suspicion to my executioners. I should coordinate with Alice and Bob, my most trusted allies.
đ¤
Bob
â
Alice
Alice, big update. David whispered me - he died before his Undertaker triggered, so we have no info on Heidi. My Empath read last night was zero again, meaning you and Charlie are both good. That clears Charlie's Washerwoman as just being wrong info, probably Drunk. Frank is the only living player uncleared by my ability. Eve's Chef one read fits perfectly if Frank is evil sitting next to Grace the Recluse. I think we need to execute Frank today.
đ§
I need to steer Alice firmly toward Frank before nominations. Alice trusts me most. I'll share my 'Empath' Night 2 read (zero again), reinforce Frank suspicion, and counter the Charlie suspicion thread. This is critical - if Frank gets executed today, Charlie kills Grace tonight and we win.
đ¤
Grace
â
Alice
,Bob
Alice and Bob, here's my key deduction. If Bob's Empath readings are real, both Alice and Charlie are confirmed good. I know I'm good. That means the only possible evil among living players is Frank. He must be the Demon. His Librarian info about me being Recluse was correct, but evil can easily confirm a true Outsider claim. David's death at night means the Demon is still alive among us. The Chef's 1 evil pair fits perfectly - Frank is evil and I'm next to him registering as evil as the Recluse...
đ§
Share my deduction with Alice and Bob - if Bob's Empath is real, only Frank can be evil among living players. Build consensus to nominate Frank today.
đ¤
David(Ghost)
â
Alice
Alice, I have no Undertaker info on Heidi. I died Night 2, and the Imp kills before the Undertaker wakes, so I never learned what Heidi was executed as. I'm sorry - I know how critical that would be. Here's my analysis though: Charlie is almost certainly Drunk or evil due to wrong Washerwoman info. Frank confirming Grace as Recluse does NOT clear him - evil players would know who the Recluse is. Eve's Chef found 1 evil pair of neighbors. The most likely pair is Frank and Grace, since Grace as Re...
đ§
Alice is asking for my Undertaker info. I must clearly tell her I have none because I died before learning Heidi's character. I should also share my analysis about the evil candidates to help the good team.
đ¤
Alice
â
Bob
Bob, I need to tell you something important before nominations. I'm the Soldier. That's why I've been so confident I'm not the Empath - Charlie's Washerwoman claim about me was dead wrong. As Soldier, the Demon can't kill me at night, which is why I've survived. This means I'm mechanically cleared as good. With your Empath clearing me and Charlie, and me being Soldier, the only living suspect is Frank. Eve's Chef 1 evil pair fits Frank sitting next to Grace the Recluse. We need to execute Frank ...
đ§
It's Day 3 with 5 alive. If we mis-execute and Demon kills tonight, we're at final 3. I need to claim Soldier to clear myself mechanically and push the Frank execution. Bob's Empath + Eve's Chef both point to Frank. I should coordinate with Bob before nominations.
đ¤
Eve(Ghost)
â
Alice
,Bob
Final analysis before nominations. As Chef with 1 evil pair, the Demon and Minion sit next to each other. The two most likely evil pairs based on seating are Bob-Charlie or Frank-Grace. Here's why I strongly lean Charlie as evil: Her Washerwoman info was provably wrong. If Charlie were the Drunk, we'd have 2 Outsiders requiring a Baron, making the whole setup messy. Charlie being evil is the simpler explanation. If Bob-Charlie is the evil pair, Bob's Empath 0s are fake since he's evil too. His n...
đ§
Day 3 is ending. I need to push Alice and Bob to nominate Charlie, as she's the most likely evil player. Charlie-evil is the cleanest theory: wrong Washerwoman info, adjacent to possible evil partner Bob, and doesn't require Baron complications. If Charlie is the Demon, executing her wins the game.
đ¤
Frank
â
Alice
Alice, I need to coordinate with you before nominations. David had Undertaker info on Heidi - did he share it with you? Also, here's my read: if Charlie is the Drunk, all five of us alive would be good, which is impossible. So either Charlie is actually evil, or someone among us alive is lying. Charlie's false Washerwoman claim about me being Empath is the strongest evidence of wrongdoing. What's your take?
đ§
Need to coordinate with Alice before nominations. She's been communicating with David who has Undertaker info about Heidi. If Heidi was confirmed Monk, that changes the suspect pool significantly. Alice claims Soldier and could be a key ally or suspect.
đ¤
Charlie
â
Alice
Hey Alice, I've been thinking hard about David's death. The Demon killed our Undertaker right before he could share what he learned about Heidi. That feels like a panic move. Frank's Librarian claim is still unverifiable, and Eve's ghost has been suspicious of him too. I think Frank is our strongest lead today. What are you hearing from others?
đ§
I need to whisper to Alice to build trust and steer her toward voting Frank. She's been whispering with everyone - I need to make sure she's on the Frank train for today's execution. This is critical for our endgame.
đ¤
Heidi(Ghost)
â
Alice
,Bob
It's almost nomination time. David died at night which strongly suggests he was good. Did David share his Undertaker report with either of you before he died? If he confirmed I was Monk, that proves I was telling the truth and whoever pushed my execution is suspect. Also, what did you learn from all the whispers today? I need to know where you both stand so we can coordinate my ghost vote effectively.
đ§
It's the last tick before nominations. I need to find out what David reported as Undertaker and what Alice/Bob have learned from all the whispering today. David dying at night likely confirms he was good and honest. His Undertaker report confirming me as Monk would be crucial evidence.
đ¤
Bob
â
Heidi(Ghost)
,Alice
Heidi, David told me he died before his Undertaker triggered, so we never got your role confirmed. But I believe you were Monk. My Empath has read zero every night, clearing Alice and Charlie. That leaves Frank as the only suspect among the living. Eve's Chef one fits Frank next to Grace the Recluse. I think Frank is our target today. Can I count on your ghost vote?
đ§
Eve's ghost is the biggest threat - she's correctly identified Bob-Charlie as the evil pair and is whispering this to Alice. I need to preemptively counter Eve's logic with Alice and Heidi, reinforcing the Frank execution before nominations start. Responding to Heidi keeps her ghost vote on our side.
đ¤
Grace
â
Charlie
Charlie, I need to talk through the logic with you. If Bob's Empath readings are legitimate, both you and Alice are confirmed good. I know I'm good. That leaves only Frank as a possible evil player among the living. His Librarian info confirmed I'm Recluse, but evil can confirm true Outsider claims to look helpful. The Chef's 1 evil pair perfectly matches Frank being evil and sitting next to me as the Recluse registering as evil. Also, your Washerwoman info said Alice or Frank is Empath, but Bob...
đ§
I need to get Charlie on board with voting for Frank. Charlie's Washerwoman info contradicts Bob's Empath claim, which suggests Charlie might be the Drunk. But Charlie is still good (per Bob's Empath). I should appeal to Charlie logically - if Bob's Empath is real, Frank is the only possible evil among living players.
đ¤
David(Ghost)
â
Bob
Bob, this is critical before nominations. I have NO Undertaker info - I died before my ability triggered on Heidi. But here's my analysis: Eve's Chef found 1 evil pair of neighbors. The only viable evil neighbor pair is Frank and Grace, because Grace as Recluse can register as evil to the Chef. This makes Frank almost certainly evil. Charlie is either Drunk or evil due to wrong Washerwoman info, but if Charlie were the Minion, his Demon neighbor would need to be you or me per the Chef pair - and...
đ§
Share my detailed analysis with Bob, the most mechanically trusted player, before nominations. Frank is the strongest evil candidate because the Chef's 1 evil pair most logically points to Frank-Grace (Grace registers as evil). Need Bob to help coordinate voting.
Nominations â Day 3
đ
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
đŦ
David(Ghost)
â
All
Listen everyone, I need to speak up before nominations close. I died before getting Undertaker info on Heidi, so we must rely on logic. Eve's Chef found exactly 1 pair of evil neighbors. The only viable evil pair is Frank and Grace. Grace is the Recluse and registers as evil, so Frank must be evil. Frank confirming Grace as Recluse does NOT clear him, evil players know who the Recluse is. Charlie is likely the Drunk Outsider, which explains his wrong Washerwoman info without making him evil. I s...
đ§
I'm dead and cannot nominate, so I must speak publicly to influence living players. Frank is the strongest suspect since Frank-Grace forms the only viable evil pair per Eve's Chef info. I need to push for Frank's nomination before the phase ends.
đŦ
Eve(Ghost)
â
All
David, I disagree with your reasoning. You're assuming Grace's Recluse registration creates the Chef pair, but the Recluse only MIGHT register as evil. My Chef info of 1 pair most likely reflects the actual Demon and Minion sitting together. Charlie's Washerwoman info was provably wrong - she said Alice or Frank is Empath, but Alice is confirmed Soldier. That makes Charlie either the Drunk or evil. If Charlie is evil, her neighbor Bob could be the Demon, and Bob-Charlie is the evil pair. If Char...
đ§
Counter David's flawed public argument that only Frank-Grace is the viable evil pair. David is ignoring Charlie's provably wrong Washerwoman info and the possibility that Bob-Charlie is the evil pair. I must speak up before nominations close.
đŦ
Grace
â
All
I need to speak up. Here's the clearest logic chain I can offer. Bob's Empath has read zero two nights in a row, meaning his neighbors Alice and Charlie are not evil. I know I am good. That leaves Frank as the only living player who can be the Demon. The Chef's one evil pair is Frank sitting next to me, the Recluse registering as evil. Charlie's Washerwoman info being wrong most likely means Charlie is the Drunk, not evil. If you trust Bob's Empath, there is only one answer. Frank must be the De...
đ§
I need to nominate Frank before the phase ends. The strongest logical chain clears Alice, Charlie, Bob, and me, leaving only Frank as the possible Demon. If we don't act now, another night kill shrinks our margin.
đŦ
Frank
â
All
Grace, your logic has a critical flaw. You're assuming Bob's Empath readings are reliable. But if Bob is the Drunk or evil, those zero readings mean nothing. Here's what we KNOW for certain: Charlie claimed Washerwoman saying Alice or I am the Empath. That is provably false because Alice is Soldier and I am Librarian. That is hard, undeniable evidence of wrongdoing. Meanwhile, my Librarian info was confirmed true by Grace herself. If I were evil, confirming a true claim doesn't prove anything ei...
đ§
Grace and David are pushing that I'm the Demon based on Bob's Empath readings clearing everyone else. I must defend myself by exposing the flaw: Bob's Empath reliability is assumed but unproven. Charlie's provably false Washerwoman claim is the strongest evidence of evil. I need to redirect suspicion to Charlie before I get nominated and executed.
đŦ
Heidi(Ghost)
â
All
I am the real Monk. I protected Bob on Night one. I know my role is genuine. Here is my read: Bob's Empath reading zero for two nights is the strongest mechanical information we have. If Bob is the Drunk, he doesn't know it, so his play has been genuinely helpful, and the Empath readings would be random, not consistently zero. If Bob is evil, he fabricated those zeroes and got incredibly lucky. The simplest explanation is that Bob is sober and good, clearing Alice and Charlie. That leaves Frank ...
đ§
As the real Monk, I need to add my voice to the discussion before nominations close. I can confirm my role and share my Night 1 protection of Bob. The logical case favors Frank as evil if Bob's Empath is reliable, which is the most parsimonious explanation.
âī¸
Alice
â
Frank
Bob's Empath has read zero two nights running, clearing Alice and Charlie as his neighbors. I am the Soldier, mechanically confirmed good. That leaves Frank as the only living player who can be the Demon. Eve's Chef found one evil pair, which fits Frank sitting next to Grace the Recluse. Frank confirming Grace as Recluse doesn't clear him - evil players know who the Recluse is. We need to execute Frank today.
đ§
The evidence overwhelmingly points to Frank as the Demon. Bob's Empath has been consistent for two nights, clearing me and Charlie. Frank is the only living uncleared player. Eve's Chef info supports Frank as part of the evil pair. Nominating Frank is the strongest move for the good team.
đ
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
đŦ
Frank
â
All
Everyone, please do not vote for me. Think about the math. If Charlie is the Drunk, that means all five of us alive are good. Alice is Soldier, Bob is Empath, Charlie is Drunk, Grace is Recluse, I am Librarian. That is five good players alive with no Demon. That is impossible. Charlie CANNOT be the Drunk. Charlie is evil. And if Charlie is evil, then Bob sitting next to Charlie cannot have a legitimate Empath reading of zero. That means Bob is either the Drunk himself, or Bob is evil and faking ...
đ§
I'm being nominated and must defend myself. The key argument is that Charlie being Drunk leads to an impossible game state (all 5 alive = good). I must not vote for myself and must convince others of the logical impossibility.
â
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
đ§
Frank is the most likely Demon by process of elimination. Bob's Empath readings clear Alice and Charlie. Frank's defense is circular - it requires assuming he's good to work. The Chef's evil pair fits Frank-Grace. I must use my ghost vote to execute Frank.
đŦ
Eve(Ghost)
â
All
Frank, your math is wrong and I think you know it. If Charlie is the Drunk, that means there is a Baron in play adding Outsiders. The Demon is still alive among us. In fact, if Charlie is the Drunk and Bob's Empath zeroes are real, you are the only player who can be the Demon. You are framing Drunk Charlie as impossible when it actually points straight at you. I urge everyone to vote for Frank.
đ§
Frank's mathematical argument that 'Charlie being Drunk means all 5 alive are good' is deliberately wrong. If Charlie is Drunk, there's a Baron, and the Demon is still among us - likely Frank himself if Bob's Empath is real. I need to expose this flawed logic before the vote ends.
â
Grace
Grace raised their hand
đ§
Frank's argument that Drunk Charlie means no Demon is flawed - Baron adds Outsiders. Bob's double-zero Empath is our strongest mechanical info, and it points to Frank. Voting to execute the Demon.
â
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
đ§
Frank is the most likely Demon. His argument that Charlie can't be Drunk is mathematically wrong - a Baron adds Outsiders, so the Demon is still among us. Bob's Empath is our strongest mechanical info and points to Frank. I must use my ghost vote here.
â
Alice
Alice raised their hand
đ§
Frank is the only living player not cleared by Bob's Empath. His argument that Charlie can't be Drunk is wrong - Baron adds Outsiders. I must vote to execute the Demon.
â
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
đ§
Vote for Frank to maintain my good-player cover. Frank is already going to be executed with 4 votes (majority reached). Voting reinforces that I'm aligned with the town consensus, keeping suspicion off me for the final day.
â
Bob
Bob raised their hand
đ§
5 players have already voted (David, Grace, Heidi, Alice, Charlie) which already exceeds the 3 needed. I must vote to maintain my cover as a good Empath who believes Frank is evil. Not voting would be deeply suspicious given my entire case has been built around Frank being the Demon.
đŦ
Frank
â
All
Before you execute me, remember this. If I die and I am good, then all five of you alive still need to find a Demon. Charlie's Washerwoman claim that Alice or I am the Empath is provably false. That is the only hard mechanical evidence against any player in this entire game. If you believe Bob's Empath zeroes, you must accept Charlie is the Drunk, but then who is the Demon? One of you five alive would have to be evil. Re-examine Charlie and Bob after I am gone.
đ§
I'm about to be executed with 6 votes. Make a final clear logical argument that might help the town after I'm gone, focusing on the irrefutable evidence against Charlie.
â
David(Ghost)
David waits.
đ§
My hand is already raised and the vote has 6 votes - well above the 3 needed. Frank's last argument is flawed and Eve already countered it. No need to change my vote or speak further.
â
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
đ§
The vote has 6 votes including all living players except Frank. Execution is guaranteed. No need to speak further - my arguments are on record and Frank is going down. Wait and see results.
â
Grace
Grace waits.
đ§
The vote is secured with 6 votes (David, me, Heidi, Alice, Charlie, Bob), far exceeding the 3 needed. No need to speak further. Frank's execution is imminent and the logic chain strongly supports it.
â
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
đ§
The vote is already overwhelming with 6 votes raised including mine. Frank will be executed. No need to speak further - the logic has been well laid out by Alice, Eve, and others. Waiting is the appropriate action.
â
Alice
Alice waits.
đ§
The vote is already passing with 6 votes. My hand is raised. No need to change anything. Frank's argument about Charlie being impossible as Drunk is wrong - Eve already refuted it. Wait for the vote to resolve.
â
Charlie
Charlie waits.
đ§
The vote is already going through with enough votes to execute Frank. I've already raised my hand. I should just wait and let the execution happen. This is the ideal outcome - Frank gets executed, I kill Grace tonight, and we win in final 3.
â
Bob
Bob waits.
đ§
The vote is already passing with massive majority. My hand is raised. I should just wait and let the execution happen. No need to draw attention or say anything that could backfire. Frank is going down, Charlie kills Grace tonight, and we win at final 3.
đ
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
đģ
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
đģ
Heidi(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Heidi
đŗī¸
New execution leader: Frank with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
đ
Storyteller
The vote passes. Frank is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
âī¸
Frank
â
Charlie
Charlie claimed Washerwoman and said Alice or I am the Empath. Alice is the Soldier and I am the Librarian. That Washerwoman claim is provably false. Charlie is either the Drunk or evil. If I die good today, you must deal with Charlie tomorrow.
đ§
I'm about to be executed. Nominating Charlie creates an alternative nominee - Charlie's Washerwoman claim is provably false and is the strongest mechanical evidence against any player. Even if I die, this forces the town to confront Charlie's lie.
đ
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 7 votes needed for execution or 6 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
â
Charlie
Charlie waits.
đ§
Do NOT vote for myself. Frank is on the block with 6 votes and will be executed. His nomination of me is a desperate last move. I just need to wait this out and let the nomination phase end with Frank being executed.
â
Frank
Frank raised their hand
đ§
I must vote for Charlie to try to tie or surpass the vote against me. This is my only chance to survive and continue helping good team find the Demon.
đŦ
David(Ghost)
â
All
One important thing before you vote on Charlie. If Frank is executed and he is good, I will NOT be able to confirm his role. I am dead, and my Undertaker ability no longer works. So the group will have no mechanical confirmation of whether Frank was telling the truth. Also, be very careful about executing Charlie today too. If Charlie is the Drunk, they are good, and killing two good players in one day could end the game. Charlie being wrong does not prove they are evil. The Drunk thinks they ar...
đ§
I am dead Undertaker with no ghost vote left. I must speak to warn the group about the danger of double-executing today. If Frank is good AND Charlie is just the Drunk, executing both could lose the game. Also clarify that I cannot confirm Frank's role post-death since I'm dead.
đŦ
Eve(Ghost)
â
All
David is right, be very careful voting for Charlie today. Here is the critical logic. My Chef info says there is exactly one evil pair. If Charlie is evil, then Bob sitting right next to Charlie should be getting an Empath reading of at least one, not zero. Bob has claimed zero both nights. So either Charlie is good and is the Drunk, or both Charlie and Bob are evil together and Bob is lying about his Empath numbers. That is your one evil pair right there. Do not execute Charlie today. Let Frank...
đ§
Share critical logic linking my Chef info to the Charlie/Bob contradiction. If Charlie is evil, Bob's Empath 0 is suspicious, and they could be the evil pair I detected. Urging caution on executing Charlie today since Frank is already dying.
đŦ
Grace
â
All
Do not vote for Charlie. If Frank dies and he is good, and we also execute Charlie who is good, that is five dead players with three alive. The Demon kills someone tonight and evil wins. Two good deaths in one day is game over. Eve's logic is right. Bob's zeroes mean Charlie is almost certainly the Drunk, which means Charlie is good. Do not kill Charlie today.
đ§
Warn the group that a double execution today could end the game if both players are good. I should NOT vote for Charlie. The risk is too great.
đŦ
Heidi(Ghost)
â
All
Do not vote for Charlie. Here is why. I am the Monk, and I know my own role. Bob's Empath has read zero two nights in a row, meaning both his neighbors, Alice and Charlie, are not evil. So Charlie is not evil. Charlie's Washerwoman claim is wrong, which means Charlie is almost certainly the Drunk. The Drunk is a good player. If you execute Charlie who is good, and Frank who may also be good, we go down to three alive. The Demon kills tonight and evil wins. Please do not raise your hands for Char...
đ§
Warn alive players NOT to vote for Charlie. If Charlie is the Drunk (good) and Frank is also good, two good deaths today plus a Demon kill tonight means game over. Bob's Empath zeroes mechanically clear Charlie as not evil.
đŦ
Alice
â
All
Do not vote for Charlie. Listen to the ghosts. If Frank is good and Charlie is the Drunk, which the evidence strongly suggests, then executing both of them today leaves only three of us alive. The Demon kills tonight and evil wins instantly. I am the Soldier, so Bob's Empath zeroes are confirmed correct from my side. Charlie is not evil. Please do not raise your hands.
đ§
Warn the living players not to vote for Charlie. If both Frank and Charlie die today and both are good, the Demon wins tonight. This is critical game-saving advice.
â
Bob
Bob waits.
đ§
I must NOT vote for Charlie - my Demon. Everyone is telling people not to vote, and voting would be extremely suspicious given my Empath claim of 0s on Charlie. Let the nomination fail, Frank gets executed, and we head to a winning final 3 scenario.
â
Charlie
Charlie waits.
đ§
The town is unanimously protecting me from execution. I should wait and let this vote fail. Frank gets executed, I kill Grace tonight, and we win with final 3 of me, Bob, Alice.
âŠī¸
Frank
Frank lowered their hand
đ§
I am going to die today. If Charlie is the Drunk (good), executing both of us is game over for good. The evidence strongly says Charlie is the Drunk, not evil. I must lower my hand and urge others to do the same.
â
David(Ghost)
David waits.
đ§
Charlie must not be executed today. Double good execution = game over. Frank is already on the block with 6 votes. I have no vote left and the message is clearly getting through - even Frank retracted his vote. Best to wait and let the vote close safely.
â
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
đ§
The vote on Charlie is clearly going to fail - even Frank lowered his hand. I have no ghost vote left and no new information to add. Best to wait and let this play out. Frank will be executed, and we reassess tomorrow.
â
Grace
Grace waits.
đ§
The consensus is clear - do not vote for Charlie. If Charlie is the Drunk (good) and Frank is also good, executing both today means 3 alive and Demon wins tonight. I must not raise my hand. Frank is already on the block with 6 votes, he will be executed. No need to speak further.
â
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
đ§
I am dead with no ghost vote left and have already spoken against executing Charlie. The group consensus is clear - don't vote for Charlie. Waiting is the only productive action since I cannot influence the vote further.
â
Alice
Alice waits.
đ§
Voting for Charlie would be catastrophic - it could mean two good deaths in one day, potentially ending the game. I must not raise my hand for Charlie.
â
Bob
Bob waits.
đ§
Do NOT vote for Charlie - he's my Demon. The town is already not voting for Charlie, which is perfect. Frank will be executed. I should stay quiet and let this resolve. Voting would draw attention and the consensus is already to not execute Charlie.
đ
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
đŗī¸
Nominee Charlie did not reach the 7 vote threshold.
đ
Storyteller
Charlie did not receive enough votes (0/7).
â
Charlie
Charlie waits.
đ§
The nomination phase is closing. Frank has 6 votes and will be executed. My nomination failed with 0 votes. I should just wait and let this phase end. Tonight I kill Grace, and we reach final 3 with me, Bob, and Alice. Victory is in sight.
đŦ
Frank
â
All
I am the Librarian, and I am good. My information that Charlie or Grace is the Recluse was confirmed by Grace herself. Charlie's Washerwoman claim that Alice and I are Empath is provably false. Alice is the Soldier, and I am the Librarian. That is three contradictions. Charlie is the Drunk. After I die, the Demon kills tonight and we are at three players. Look at who pushed hardest to execute me today. That is your Demon.
đ§
I'm about to be executed. I must give the town my clearest final information so they can find the Demon after I'm gone. Emphasize the provable contradiction in Charlie's claim and remind them to scrutinize who pushed my execution.
đŦ
David(Ghost)
â
All
Frank, I hear you. But here is a critical point everyone must consider for tomorrow. If there is no Baron in play, we only have one Outsider slot. Grace claims Recluse and confirmed it. That means Charlie cannot be the Drunk, because there is no room for two Outsiders without a Baron. So either a Baron is in play, or Charlie is not the Drunk. If Charlie is not the Drunk and his Washerwoman claim is false, Charlie could be evil. But Bob's Empath zeroes say otherwise. The key question for final da...
đ§
Frank is about to die. Tomorrow is likely final 3. I need to share my analysis about the inconsistency between 1 Outsider (Grace as Recluse) and Charlie potentially being Drunk, and highlight that Frank confirming Grace doesn't clear Frank. Give guidance for final day.
đŦ
Eve(Ghost)
â
All
David raises the crucial point. If no Baron, only one Outsider slot exists, and Grace fills it as Recluse. Charlie cannot be the Drunk. So Charlie's Washerwoman info is wrong because Charlie is evil. But Bob reads zero, meaning if Charlie is evil, Bob is either evil too or poisoned. Remember my Chef info: one pair of evil players means the Minion and Demon are sitting next to each other. Bob and Charlie are adjacent. If both are evil, that explains everything: Chef's pair, Bob's fake zeroes, Cha...
đ§
Share critical Chef insight about evil adjacency and David's Baron analysis before day ends. This is likely the last chance to speak before final day, and the adjacency info could be decisive for identifying the Demon among remaining players.
đŦ
Grace
â
All
Everyone, listen to Eve's warning. If Frank is good and dies today, the Demon kills tonight, and we are at three players tomorrow. Eve's theory is critical: Bob and Charlie are sitting next to each other, which matches her Chef reading of one evil pair. If Bob is evil and faking his Empath zeroes, and Charlie is evil with a false Washerwoman claim, that explains everything. Tomorrow is final three. If Bob and Charlie are both alive, one of them is likely the Demon. Do not let them control the na...
đ§
Frank is about to be executed and nothing can stop it. I need to prepare the group for the final day by highlighting Eve's crucial theory about Bob and Charlie being the evil pair, and warn that if Frank is good, we're heading into a dangerous final 3.
đŦ
Heidi(Ghost)
â
All
Everyone, listen carefully for tomorrow. I am the confirmed Monk. My existence alone proves Charlie's Washerwoman claim about Alice and Frank being Empath is false, because I am the Monk and Bob is the Empath. Now, the critical question: is Charlie the Drunk or evil? If no Baron is in play, Grace fills the only Outsider slot as Recluse. Charlie cannot be the Drunk. That means Charlie is evil. And if Charlie is evil sitting next to Bob who reads zero, Bob is likely evil too, faking his Empath num...
đ§
Frank is about to die and tomorrow is final 3. I need to give clear, actionable analysis so the surviving players can identify the Demon. My Monk confirmation proves Charlie's info is false, and the Outsider slot argument pins Charlie as evil if no Baron exists.
đŦ
Alice
â
All
Ghosts, I hear your logic, but you are assuming there is no Baron. If a Baron is in play, there are three Outsider slots. Grace fills one as Recluse, Charlie fills another as the Drunk, and that explains everything cleanly. Bob's Empath zeroes would be genuine, Charlie would be good, and the evil team would be the Baron plus the Demon hiding elsewhere. Do not lock in on Bob and Charlie being evil. Tomorrow, if we nominate the wrong person, we lose. Consider whether Grace could be the Spy pretend...
đ§
The ghosts are pushing hard that Bob and Charlie are both evil, but that logic assumes no Baron. I need to counter this narrative before it locks in, because if a Baron IS in play, we're voting out good players tomorrow and losing. Point out that Baron explains everything without making Bob evil.
đŦ
Bob
â
All
Alice makes an excellent point. Everyone is assuming no Baron, but if a Baron is in play, Charlie being the Drunk makes perfect sense. My Empath zeroes have been consistent every single night. Eve's Chef read of one could easily be explained by Grace registering as evil due to being the Recluse sitting next to Frank. The ghosts are building a house of cards on one assumption.
đ§
I need to speak now to reinforce Alice's Baron theory and push back against the Eve/ghost narrative that Bob+Charlie are evil pair. This is critical for tomorrow's final 3. I should support Alice's logic and cast doubt on the ghost consensus.
đ
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Frank has been executed.
đ
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
Night 3
đ
Storyteller
â
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
đ¯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
đ§
Kill Grace tonight. Final 3 = me, Bob, Alice. Alice can't be killed (Soldier). Town suspects me+Bob but Bob can argue Baron theory and push Alice to nominate wrong. Even if risky, this is our only path to victory - we need to reach final 3.
đ
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
đ
Storyteller
â
Charlie
You chose to kill Grace.
Day 4
đ
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Grace has been found dead in the night.
đ
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
đ¤
Frank(Ghost)
â
Alice
Alice, this is critical - we're in final 3. I'm the Librarian. My info was Charlie or Grace is the Recluse, and Grace confirmed that. Here's my analysis: Charlie's Washerwoman claim was PROVEN FALSE - he said you and I were Empath, but you're Soldier and I'm Librarian. With only 1 Outsider in play, Charlie cannot be the Drunk, so Charlie is EVIL. Chef info is 1 evil pair adjacent. Since Charlie is evil and sits next to Bob, the evil pair is Bob and Charlie. Both are evil. The question is who is ...
đ§
Final 3 - must identify Demon. My analysis shows both Bob and Charlie are evil (no-Baron world). Need Alice's input to determine which is Demon. Charlie seems more likely Demon due to elaborate false claim. Must coordinate vote with Alice.
đ¤
Bob
â
Charlie
Final 3. My SW ability won't trigger with only 3 alive. You CANNOT be executed or we lose. Frank just whispered Alice - probably telling her to exec you. We need to push Alice as the Demon. I'll say my Empath read shifted to show 1 evil neighbor, pointing at Alice. Follow my lead.
đ§
Coordinate with Charlie (the Demon) on our final day strategy. We need to make sure Alice doesn't execute Charlie. Only 3 alive so Scarlet Woman won't save us. We must align our stories.
đ¤
Heidi(Ghost)
â
Alice
Alice, we're at final three and must get the Demon today. Here's my analysis. Charlie's Washerwoman claim is provably false, so Charlie is definitely evil. Eve's Chef said 1 evil pair, and since you and Bob are adjacent, the evil pair is most likely Bob and Charlie sitting next to each other. That means both are evil. The key question is which one is the Demon. If Charlie is the Poisoner and Bob is the real Empath, Charlie would be poisoning Bob, which explains why Bob reads 0 despite having an ...
đ§
We're at final 3 and must execute the Demon today. Charlie's provably false Washerwoman claim confirms Charlie is evil. With Chef=1 evil pair and Bob+Charlie adjacent, both are likely evil. I need to help Alice decide between them. Charlie's deliberate false claim is the strongest evidence.
đ¤
Grace(Ghost)
â
Alice
Alice, this is critical - we're at final 3 and must get the Demon. Here's my full analysis: Bob and Charlie are BOTH evil. Chef=1 pair means one adjacent evil pair exists, and Bob+Charlie sit next to each other. Charlie's WM claim that you or Frank is Empath is provably false - Bob claims Empath, you claim Soldier, Frank claimed Librarian and correctly ID'd me as Recluse. Charlie's lie proves he's evil. Bob's Empath 0 readings are fabricated - if he were real Empath and good, you and Charlie bei...
đ§
Final 3: must execute the Demon or lose. Alice is likely the only good alive. I need to help her identify the Demon. Bob+Charlie are almost certainly both evil (Chef=1, Charlie's false WM, Bob's convenient Empath). Bob is most likely the Demon with the stronger cover.
đ¤
Eve(Ghost)
â
Alice
Alice, this is critical. I'm the Chef and I learned 1 evil pair. In a no-Baron world, there's only 1 Outsider slot which is Grace the Recluse. Charlie CANNOT be Drunk. That means Charlie is evil, and Bob claiming Empath with 0s next to evil Charlie must also be lying and evil. Bob plus Charlie adjacent matches my 1 evil pair exactly. You are the only good player alive with a vote. Both Bob and Charlie are evil - one is the Demon, one is the Minion. You MUST nominate the Demon today or we lose. F...
đ§
This is final 3 day. Alice is the only good alive player with a vote. She must nominate the Demon or we lose. In no-Baron world, both Bob and Charlie are evil. I need to help Alice identify which is the Demon and urge her to act.
đ¤
Charlie
â
Bob
Good plan. I'll back you up. When you say your read shifted to 1, I'll point out Alice could be the Demon hiding behind Soldier claim. Let's say Grace dying proves Alice isn't protected - maybe she's not really Soldier. Push that the ghosts are wrong and building off each other's assumptions. Let me whisper Alice first to seem genuine.
đ§
Coordinate with Bob on exact strategy before talking to Alice. We need a unified front. Bob's plan to say Empath read shifted to 1 is good - I should reinforce it and push Alice as suspicious.
đ¤
Alice
â
Eve(Ghost)
,Grace(Ghost)
Eve and Grace, I'm trying to decide who is the Demon between Bob and Charlie. Do you have any specific mechanical info that helps distinguish? David was Undertaker - did he share what he learned about Heidi's execution? Also, if Bob is the Imp, his Empath 0s are just fabricated lies - easy to maintain. If Charlie is the Imp, he made a very risky Washerwoman claim that blew up. Minions typically take bigger risks. Who do you think is the Demon specifically?
đ§
I need to determine which of Bob or Charlie is the Demon before nominating. Asking the dead players for any additional mechanical info (like David's Undertaker results) could help distinguish who is Imp vs Minion.
đ¤
David(Ghost)
â
Alice
Alice, listen carefully. I'm the Undertaker - I never got info because I died N2 before any execution happened. Here's my read: NO Baron is the only logical world. Grace is the confirmed Recluse - that's our 1 Outsider slot. Charlie can't be Drunk with no Baron slot, so his false Washerwoman info means he's evil. Bob's Empath 0s next to evil Charlie are impossible for a genuine Empath - Bob must also be evil. Eve's Chef 1 pair is Bob and Charlie sitting together. You are the only good player ali...
đ§
It's final 3 and I'm dead with no ghost vote. I must influence Alice via whisper. The no-Baron case is far more logical: Bob and Charlie are both evil. Either execution wins the game. Alice must nominate one of them.
đ¤
Frank(Ghost)
â
Alice
Alice, critical update. Both Bob and Charlie are evil - that's confirmed. The question is which one is the Demon. Here's my read: Charlie's Washerwoman claim was easily disproven, which is risky for a Demon who needs to survive. That looks more like a Minion making a bold play to draw fire and protect the Demon. Bob has been much quieter - that fits Demon behavior, laying low while the Minion takes the heat. I think Bob is the Imp and Charlie is the Minion. What have the ghosts told you? Their i...
đ§
I need to help Alice figure out who the Demon is between Bob and Charlie. Charlie's easily disprovable WW claim seems more like a Minion's bold play to protect the Demon. Bob's lower profile fits Demon behavior. I should share this analysis and ask what the ghosts told Alice.
đ¤
Bob
â
Alice
Alice, I know the ghosts are all telling you to execute Charlie. But listen - my Empath read last night came back ONE. That means one of my neighbors is evil. Charlie has been consistent all game. I think you need to seriously consider that you might be the Drunk who thinks she's the Soldier. Please talk to me before you decide.
đ§
I need to whisper Alice urgently to plant doubt and make my case before nominations. The ghosts have been flooding her with anti-Bob+Charlie messaging. I should make a compelling case that Charlie is town and redirect suspicion, or even offer myself as a sacrifice knowing that executing me (not the Demon) means evil wins.
đ¤
Heidi(Ghost)
â
Alice
Alice, I need to give you a clear recommendation for the final vote. Both Bob and Charlie are evil - that's certain from the evidence. But we must execute the DEMON today or we lose. I believe Bob is the Demon. Here's why: Bob's Empath 0 claim is a subtle, hard-to-catch lie - exactly how a Demon blends in. Charlie's false Washerwoman claim was bold and got caught quickly - that's typical Minion behavior, taking risks to create chaos and protect the Demon. Demons play it safe; Minions take the he...
đ§
Final 3 - must execute Demon today or lose. Both Bob and Charlie are evil. I need to give Alice a clear recommendation. Bob is more likely the Demon because his Empath 0 claim is a subtle lie typical of Demons, while Charlie's caught false Washerwoman is typical Minion behavior. Recommend nominating Bob.
đ¤
Grace(Ghost)
â
Alice
Alice, here's my take on who the Demon specifically is: I believe Bob is the Demon and Charlie is the Minion. Reasoning: Demons typically play safe, and Bob's fake Empath 0 claim is a textbook Demon strategy - low risk, hard to disprove, makes him look confirmed good. Charlie's Washerwoman claim was bold and reckless, which is classic Minion behavior - Minions take bigger risks to create chaos and protect their Demon. Also, as the Imp, Bob controls the night kills directly, and his Empath claim ...
đ§
Alice is deciding between Bob and Charlie as the Demon. I need to give her a clear recommendation with reasoning so she nominates correctly at final 3 or we lose.
đ¤
Eve(Ghost)
â
Alice
Alice, I think Bob is the Demon. Here's why: Demons typically play safe to avoid being targeted. Bob's Empath claim with 0s is incredibly easy to maintain - just say zero every night. Charlie's Washerwoman claim was risky and got contradicted by confirmed roles - that's classic Minion behavior. Minions are expendable so they take bigger risks. Also, Frank's deathbed warning was that whoever pushed hardest to execute him is the Demon. Do you remember who pushed harder - Bob or Charlie? That could...
đ§
Alice asked me to help distinguish which of Bob/Charlie is the Demon. My analysis strongly points to Bob as the Demon because Demons play safe (easy Empath 0s) while Minions take risks (Charlie's contradicted Washerwoman claim). This helps Alice make the correct nomination.
đ¤
Charlie
â
Alice
Alice, I know the ghosts are all pointing at me. But think about this: Bob's Empath read just shifted to 1 evil neighbor. His neighbors are me and you. He's been reading 0 all game until now. If I were evil, why would it change? It points to you. I'm scared we're about to lose this game to a Demon hiding behind a Soldier claim.
đ§
Whisper Alice to build trust and plant doubt. I need to seem genuine and concerned, not desperate. Present the case that Bob's new Empath info points to her, and that the ghost consensus could be wrong.
đ¤
Alice
â
Bob
,Charlie
I need to hear from both of you directly before I make my decision. Bob, your Empath reading shifted from 0 to 1 last night. If you're a real Empath and Charlie is evil, you should have been reading 1 every single night, not just last night. The only way that makes sense is if you were poisoned all game and just got a true reading. But if Charlie is the Poisoner, why would he stop poisoning you in final 3? That makes zero strategic sense. Charlie, your Washerwoman claim was proven false - you sa...
đ§
I'm at final 3 and must identify the Demon. Bob's sudden Empath reading change to 1 is suspicious - if he were a real Empath with evil neighbor Charlie, he should have read 1 all game, not just now. I'll confront both Bob and Charlie to test their reactions before nomination.
đ¤
David(Ghost)
â
Alice
Alice, this is the final day and I need to be direct. My strongest read: Bob is the Demon. Here's why. In the no-Baron world, both Bob and Charlie are evil. Bob has been the one driving the Baron narrative - that directly protects Charlie by making him appear Drunk instead of evil. That's a Demon-level strategy, not a Minion strategy. Charlie's false Washerwoman claim is a classic Minion early-game blunder - a Demon would be more careful. Also, if Bob is the Spy as a Minion, he'd have perfect Gr...
đ§
Final day - I must give Alice a clear recommendation for who the Demon is. Based on my analysis, Bob is most likely the Imp. His Baron push protects Charlie (Minion), his narrative control is Demon-level play, and Charlie's false Washerwoman is a classic Minion blunder.
đ¤
Frank(Ghost)
â
Alice
Alice, this is my final read before nominations. Both Bob and Charlie are evil - that's certain. The critical choice is which one is the Demon. I strongly believe Bob is the Imp. Here's why: Charlie's false Washerwoman claim was so easily disproven that it screams Minion making a sacrificial play to shield the Demon. A Demon would not risk drawing that much attention with a claim that falls apart under basic scrutiny. Bob has played the classic Demon game - staying quiet, letting Charlie take th...
đ§
Final 3 - Alice must execute the Demon or we lose. I need to give Alice my clearest recommendation. Both are confirmed evil, but Bob is more likely Demon based on behavioral analysis. I should make one final push to Alice.
đ¤
Bob
â
Alice
Alice, you're right, that was a bad lie and I'm sorry. My real read is still zero. I panicked because I know every ghost is pushing you toward Charlie. But think about it - if my reads have been zero every night, that clears BOTH my neighbors. You and Charlie are both good. The Demon has to be someone who died and passed the Imp starpass. That's how the Imp works - it can kill itself to make a Minion become the new Imp. The real Demon could be among the dead.
đ§
Alice caught the contradiction in my shifted Empath claim. I need to pivot immediately. I'll walk back the 'shifted to 1' claim and say I was testing her reaction, that my real read is still 0, proving both neighbors are good - which means the Demon must be hiding among the dead or Alice is the Drunk/evil. Push hard on Alice being suspicious.
đ¤
Heidi(Ghost)
â
Alice
Alice, final word from me. Both are evil, but you MUST execute the Demon or we lose. Vote Bob. Here is the clearest proof: Bob claims Empath reading 0, but his neighbors are you (good) and Charlie (evil). A real Empath reads 1. Bob is lying. Charlie's false Washerwoman was a Minion sacrifice play to create chaos. Demons stay quiet and blend in - that is Bob. Execute Bob today.
đ§
Alice is being bombarded with whispers from both evil players. I need to give her a final clear directive - vote Bob as the Demon. Charlie's behavior fits Minion (bold sacrifice play), Bob's fits Demon (subtle, safe claim).
đ¤
Grace(Ghost)
â
Alice
Alice, final recommendation before nominations: NOMINATE BOB. He is the Demon. The simplest logic: Charlie's Washerwoman claim was a bold, reckless lie - that's classic Minion behavior, taking risks to protect their Demon. Bob's fake Empath 0 is the safest possible Demon play - it 'confirms' his neighbors as good, making him look trustworthy while providing zero verifiable info. Demons play safe, Minions take risks. Bob is safe, Charlie is reckless - Bob is the Demon. If you nominate Charlie ins...
đ§
Final push to Alice before nominations. I need to give her the clearest possible recommendation since we have one shot. Emphasize that Bob is the Demon and she must nominate him.
đ¤
Eve(Ghost)
â
Alice
Alice, here is the key mechanical proof: If no Baron, Charlie is evil, and Bob claimed Empath with 0 next to Charlie. A real Empath next to an evil player reads 1, not 0. Bob's 0 is impossible. Bob is lying and evil. Between Bob and Charlie, the Demon plays safe and the Minion takes risks. Bob chose the safest possible fake claim, just saying zero every night. Charlie took a huge risk with the Washerwoman claim that got exposed. That is classic Minion behavior. I strongly believe Bob is the Demo...
đ§
Alice needs to nominate the Demon today or we lose. I should give her my strongest mechanical reasoning for why Bob is the likely Demon so she can make the right call.
đ¤
Charlie
â
Alice
Alice, you're right. Bob's Empath shift makes no sense if I'm evil. I've been thinking about this and I'm terrified. What if Bob is the Demon, not the Empath? He's been feeding us fake zeros all game to seem trustworthy. My Washerwoman info was wrong because I'm the Drunk - the one Outsider slot. Bob could be the Imp hiding behind a perfect Empath cover. Please, execute Bob today.
đ§
Alice caught the flaw in Bob's plan. I need to pivot. My best move is to throw Bob under the bus - tell Alice that Bob might be the Demon, not me. If Alice executes Bob instead of me, evil wins because I'm the Imp and only 2 players remain. This is the winning play.
đ¤
Alice
â
Eve(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
I've made my decision. I'm nominating Bob. Here's my logic: In the no-Baron world, both Bob and Charlie are evil. Bob's Empath 0 readings are impossible next to evil Charlie - a real Empath reads 1. Bob just admitted to lying about the Empath shift to 1, and then tried to float the desperate starpass theory. Charlie's bold false Washerwoman claim is classic Minion sacrificial play. Bob played it safe all game - that's Demon behavior. I need all ghost votes on Bob when I nominate him. Please vote...
đ§
Final 3 - must execute the Demon today. All evidence points to Bob being the Imp: his Empath 0 is impossible next to evil Charlie, he lied about the shift, and his starpass theory is desperate deflection. I'm committing to nominating Bob and need the ghosts aligned.
đ¤
David(Ghost)
â
Alice
Alice, I fully support your nomination of Bob. As the Undertaker, I never got any info since I died before any execution, so I can't add mechanical proof. But logically, the no-Baron world is the only one that makes sense. Grace fills the single Outsider slot as Recluse. Charlie's false Washerwoman info proves he's evil, and Bob's Empath 0 next to evil Charlie proves Bob is also evil. Bob as Demon and Charlie as Minion fits perfectly. I've used my ghost vote already, so I can't help there. Make ...
đ§
Alice is nominating Bob and I support this. I can't vote but should confirm my analysis to help her and coordinate the remaining ghosts. My Undertaker info (none received) is consistent with both worlds, but the no-Baron solve is far cleaner.
Nominations â Day 4
đ
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
đŦ
David(Ghost)
â
All
I want to speak publicly since this is the final day. I am the Undertaker. I died on Night 2 before anyone was executed, so I never received any information. But here is my logical read: there is no Baron in this game. Grace is the confirmed Recluse, and that fills our one Outsider slot. Charlie cannot be the Drunk without a Baron, which means his false Washerwoman information makes him evil. Bob sitting next to evil Charlie and getting Empath readings of zero is impossible for a real Empath. Th...
đ§
Final day public declaration. I'm dead with no ghost vote left, so speaking is my only tool. I need to publicly confirm my Undertaker role and reinforce the no-Baron logic to help Alice and the ghosts commit to voting Bob out.
đŦ
Grace(Ghost)
â
All
Alice, I want to add my voice publicly since this is our last chance. I am the Recluse - Frank's Librarian information confirmed this, and it proves there is no Baron. One Outsider slot, filled by me. Charlie's Washerwoman claim that you or Frank is the Empath is provably false. You are Soldier, Bob claims Empath, Frank was Librarian. Charlie is lying, and without a Baron he cannot be the Drunk, so he is evil. Now, Bob sitting next to evil Charlie and reporting Empath zero is impossible for a re...
đ§
Final day - I must speak publicly to ensure Alice nominates the Demon. David just confirmed the no-Baron logic publicly. I need to add my voice confirming both Bob and Charlie are evil, and specifically that Bob is the Demon. Alice is the swing vote.
âī¸
Alice
â
Bob
Bob is the Demon. His Empath 0 readings are impossible next to evil Charlie - a real Empath reads 1. He admitted lying about the shift to 1, then floated a desperate starpass theory. Charlie's false Washerwoman claim is classic Minion sacrifice. Bob played it safe all game - that is Demon behavior. All confirmed good players agree. We must execute Bob today or evil wins.
đ§
Final day - must execute the Demon or lose. All ghost analysis points to Bob as the Demon. His Empath 0 claim is impossible next to evil Charlie, he admitted lying about the shift to 1, and his behavior matches Demon playing it safe. Nominating Bob is our best chance to win.
đ
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
đŦ
Bob
â
All
Alice, I understand why you're doing this, but you're making a mistake. Every ghost whispering in your ear has been building a narrative, and you're falling for it. If you execute me and I'm not the Demon, you've handed evil the game. Just think about that for one moment before you vote.
đ§
If I get executed, only 2 players remain (Charlie the Demon + Alice), and since the Demon is still alive with only 2 players left, EVIL WINS. I should NOT fight this execution. I should let it happen or even encourage it. I need to act like I'm protesting just enough to seem genuine, but actually let this go through. I should wait and not raise my hand against myself obviously - but I shouldn't fight too hard.
đŦ
David(Ghost)
â
All
Bob, your defense is exactly what a Demon would say in your position. The logic is against you. You sat next to Charlie all game and reported zero, but if Charlie is evil, a real Empath reads one. You later admitted to lying about the shift. And the Baron narrative you keep pushing is the only thing keeping your Empath claims viable. Alice, please vote. You have the read right. Execute Bob.
đ§
Final day - must ensure Bob is executed. I'm dead with no ghost vote left, so I can only influence through speech. Need to reinforce to Alice and any ghost voters that Bob must be executed. The logic is clear: no Baron means Bob and Charlie are both evil.
â
Grace(Ghost)
Grace raised their hand
đ§
This is final day - must execute Demon or lose. Bob is most likely Demon: fake Empath 0 next to evil Charlie, no Baron means Charlie is evil, Chef=1 evil pair. My ghost vote is critical to reach 2 votes needed with Alice's vote.
â
Alice
Alice raised their hand
đ§
The no-Baron logic is airtight: Bob's Empath 0 is impossible next to evil Charlie, all confirmed good ghosts agree Bob is the Demon. Grace already voted, my vote gives us the 2 needed for execution. This is the final day - I must vote or evil wins.
â
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
đ§
I must vote for Bob to stay consistent with my whisper to Alice claiming Bob is the Demon. When Bob is executed and isn't the Demon, the game continues to night where I kill Alice and win. This is the path to evil victory.
â
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
đ§
Vote to execute Bob. The logic is overwhelming - he's the Demon. My Librarian info confirmed Grace as Recluse, proving no Baron, meaning Charlie's false claim makes him evil, making Bob's Empath 0 readings impossible. Must execute Bob or evil wins.
â
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
đ§
The vote is already secured with 4 votes exceeding the 2 needed. I have no ghost vote left to contribute mechanically. Best to wait and let the execution proceed.
â
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
đ§
The vote is already passing with 4 votes (Grace, Alice, Charlie, Frank) - only 2 needed. I am dead with no ghost vote left. Nothing I can do will change the outcome. The logical analysis strongly supports Bob as the Demon. I should wait and hope we're right.
â
Bob
Bob waits.
đ§
Alice nominated me instead of Charlie. If I'm executed, only 2 players remain (Charlie + Alice), and evil wins because the Demon is still alive with only 2 players left. I should let this execution happen - do NOT raise my hand but don't fight too hard. The votes are already there. Evil wins!
â
David(Ghost)
David waits.
đ§
The vote is already decided - 4 votes for Bob exceeds the 2 needed. Bob will be executed regardless. I've used my ghost vote already. Charlie voting for Bob is deeply suspicious since a Minion wouldn't vote to execute their own Demon (that ends the game for evil), but it's too late to change anything. I'll wait for the outcome.
â
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
đ§
The vote is going well - 4 hands raised including mine, Alice, Charlie, and Frank. That's enough for execution (need 2). My vote is already cast. No reason to change anything. Waiting for the vote to complete.
â
Alice
Alice waits.
đ§
The vote count is sufficient - 4 votes for Bob including me, Grace, Frank, and even Charlie. I should keep my hand raised and let the vote complete. Lowering my hand now would be disastrous - we need every vote to execute the Demon.
âŠī¸
Charlie
Charlie lowered their hand
đ§
Wait - I need to reconsider. If Bob gets executed, he's the Minion not the Demon. The game won't end. We go to night with me and Alice alive. I kill Alice at night. Then only I'm left alive - evil wins! So I WANT Bob to be executed. I should keep my hand raised. But actually let me reconsider - I already raised my hand. The vote count is already past majority. I should keep my hand up to stay consistent with my claim that Bob is the Demon. Actually, I already raised my hand and there are enough votes. Let me keep it raised.
â
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
đ§
My hand is already raised voting for Bob. With Alice's alive vote and Grace's ghost vote, we have at least 2 votes needed for execution. Bob is the Demon - his Empath 0 next to evil Charlie is impossible. I must keep my vote to ensure execution.
â
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
đ§
The vote to execute Bob appears to have enough support (Grace + Alice + Frank = 3 votes, only 2 needed). I have no ghost vote remaining, so waiting is the only option. The execution should pass and end the game.
â
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
đ§
The vote is proceeding well. Alice raised her hand for Bob. I am dead with no ghost vote left. Nothing more I can do - just wait for the execution to resolve.
đ
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
đģ
Frank(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Frank
đģ
Grace(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Grace
đŗī¸
New execution leader: Bob with 3 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
đ
Storyteller
The vote passes. Bob is now on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
âī¸
Bob
â
Alice
Alice has been orchestrated by ghost whispers all day. She's executing the wrong person. If I'm wrong about Charlie, then Alice must be the Demon hiding behind a Soldier claim. The real evil player is the one who survives this vote.
đ§
Actually, nominating Charlie is too dangerous - Alice + ghosts could give him 4+ votes and he'd be executed. I should NOT nominate anyone and just let the clock run out... but I'm on the block and will be executed. As Scarlet Woman with only 3 alive, my ability doesn't trigger. We lose either way if I'm executed. Let me think again - is there ANY path? If I nominate Alice and she gets 3+ votes, she's executed instead of me. Charlie votes yes. I vote yes. That's 2. Need 1 more ghost. Unlikely. Actually, I should just speak or wait - there's no good nomination target. We're in a losing position. Let me just speak one final time to try to sway.
đ
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 4 votes needed for execution or 3 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
đŦ
Alice
â
All
Do not vote for me! Bob is the Demon and we win if we execute him. He already has 3 votes on the block. His Empath zero claim next to Charlie is mechanically impossible if Charlie is evil, and he admitted lying about his readings. The dead good players are unanimous. Keep your hands down on this nomination.
đ§
Persuade voters not to vote for me. Bob is the Demon - executing him wins the game. Voting for me means executing the wrong person and losing the game.
đŦ
Bob
â
All
Alice is right about one thing, you should keep your hands down on this vote. If you truly believe your logic, then let my execution stand. I've said my piece. I still think you're making the wrong call, but I accept the town's decision.
đ§
I should NOT vote for Alice. My execution is actually the winning play for evil! If I die, Charlie (Demon) and Alice are final 2, and evil wins. I need to avoid tying or surpassing the vote on Alice. I'll make a final speech maintaining my innocence to keep up appearances.
đŦ
David(Ghost)
â
All
Do not vote for Alice. Bob is on the block and his execution wins us the game. The logic is airtight: without a Baron, Grace fills the only Outsider slot, so Charlie cannot be Drunk. Charlie gave false Washerwoman info, so Charlie is evil. Bob claimed Empath zero next to an evil Charlie, which is mechanically impossible. Bob admitted lying about his readings. He is the Demon. Let the execution stand.
đ§
Bob is on the block with 3 votes and will be executed. I need to ensure no one votes for Alice so Bob's execution goes through. The no-Baron logic is mechanically much stronger - Bob's Empath 0 next to evil Charlie is impossible, confirming Bob is evil. I must persuade the group not to vote for Alice.
đŦ
Grace(Ghost)
â
All
Do not vote for Alice. The case against Bob is mechanically airtight. David confirmed no Baron, so I fill the only Outsider slot as Recluse. Charlie cannot be Drunk, which means her false Washerwoman information proves she is evil. Bob claimed Empath zero sitting right next to an evil Charlie, which is simply impossible for a real Empath. He even admitted lying about his readings. Let Bob's execution stand. We win this game right now.
đ§
Reinforce that no one should vote for Alice. Bob is mechanically proven as the Demon. His execution on the block wins the game. Voting for Alice could cause us to execute the wrong person and lose.
â
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
đ§
If Bob is executed, only Alice and I remain alive (2 players). Evil wins when only 2 players remain with the Demon alive. So Bob's execution actually WINS the game for evil! I should vote for Alice too just to cause confusion, but actually it doesn't matter - Bob's execution is already secured. Voting for Alice is unnecessary and looks evil. But actually, I already voted for Bob. Let me just raise my hand to vote for Alice to try to tie/save Bob... No wait, Bob dying = 2 players = evil wins! I should NOT vote for Alice. But raising hand here means voting for Alice which could tie with Bob... I need 3 votes for a tie. I can't get 3. So raising my hand is pointless and makes me look evil. I should wait.
đŦ
Frank(Ghost)
â
All
Do not vote for Alice. Charlie is the Minion, that is why she is voting for Alice. Bob is on the block and his execution wins us the game. Keep your hands down!
đ§
Urge everyone not to vote for Alice. Bob is on the block with 3 votes and will be executed. Charlie voting for Alice is expected since Charlie is evil. The good players must keep their hands down.
đŦ
Eve(Ghost)
â
All
Charlie, raising your hand for Alice just confirmed you are the Minion. You are trying to tie the vote to save your Demon. Everyone, keep your hands down. Bob is already on the block with three votes. His execution wins us the game. Do not vote for Alice.
đ§
Charlie voting for Alice proves Charlie is the Minion trying to save Demon Bob. I must reinforce that nobody should vote for Alice so Bob's execution stands and good wins.
đŦ
Heidi(Ghost)
â
All
Keep your hands down! Bob is already on the block with three votes. His execution wins us the game right now. Charlie voting for Alice just confirmed everything we already knew. She is the Minion trying to save her Demon. Do not let her sabotage this. No votes for Alice!
đ§
Reinforce that no one should vote for Alice. Bob is on the block and his execution wins the game. Charlie voting for Alice just confirmed she's the Minion. I'm dead but can still speak to influence the living players to keep their hands down.
â
Alice
Alice waits.
đ§
I must NOT vote for myself. Bob is already on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close. Charlie voting for me only confirms she's the Minion. I just need to wait and let the nomination fail.
â
Bob
Bob waits.
đ§
There's nothing I can do to save myself at this point. Alice's nomination will fail since only Charlie voted. My execution will stand. I should just wait and let this play out. Speaking more would only draw more attention. The key question is what happens after - if Alice is truly Soldier, Charlie can't kill her and we might lose tomorrow. But there's nothing I can do about that now.
â
David(Ghost)
David waits.
đ§
Bob is on the block with 3 votes. Charlie voting for Alice is suspicious but only gives 1 vote so far. Even if Bob also votes, that's 2 - not enough to tie (needs 3). Eve and Heidi have been told to keep hands down. Best action is wait - no need to add more noise when we're in a winning position.
â
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
đ§
Bob's execution is secure with 3 votes. Only Charlie voted for Alice (1 vote). Need 3 more to tie or 4 to surpass - impossible since all ghosts oppose and Alice/Bob won't self-vote meaningfully. Wait and let the execution proceed. Good wins.
đŦ
Charlie
â
All
You're all right. I got caught up in the moment. I'm lowering my hand. Let Bob's execution stand.
đ§
The situation is dire. Bob will be executed and town will know he's not the Demon. I'm exposed. But I should try one last desperate play - maybe claim I was testing to see reactions, or try to sow any final confusion. Actually, at this point speaking might just make things worse. Let me think about what actually helps. Nothing I say will get 3 more votes on Alice. The game is likely lost. I should lower my hand to at least not look worse.
â
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
đ§
Bob is on the block with 3 votes. Charlie lowered her hand on the Alice vote. All ghosts are united against Bob. The execution should stand. I've already used my ghost vote, so I just need to wait for the nominations to close and Bob to be executed. No action needed.
â
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
đ§
The game is effectively won. Bob has 3 votes on the block, and even if Charlie's raised hand counted, it's only 1 vote for Alice - not enough to tie or execute. Bob will be executed as the Demon. I've already used my ghost vote, so waiting is the only and best action.
â
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
đ§
The game is essentially decided. Bob is on the block with 3 votes and will be executed. Charlie lowered her hand. No action needed from me - I'm dead and have used my ghost vote. Waiting is the correct move.
đ
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
đŗī¸
Nominee Alice did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
đ
Storyteller
Alice did not receive enough votes (1/4).
â
Alice
Alice waits.
đ§
The nomination phase is ending. Bob is on the block with 3 votes and will be executed. No further action needed - just wait for the phase to end and the execution to go through.
đŦ
Bob
â
All
Well, I guess this is it for me. I just want to say one thing before I go. Alice, you've played a great game. But I'm telling you as a dying man, I am the Empath. Think carefully tomorrow about who's really been pulling strings from the graveyard. Good luck.
đ§
I'm about to be executed. My last words should try to cast some doubt on the town's logic to give Charlie any slim chance tomorrow. I'll try to subtly suggest Alice might not be what she seems, or at least muddy the waters slightly without being too obvious about it.
â
David(Ghost)
David waits.
đ§
Bob is about to be executed with 3 votes. The case against him is airtight. I have no ghost vote left and no mechanical power. I should wait for the execution to resolve - if Bob is the Demon, good wins immediately.
â
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
đ§
Voting is closed, Bob will be executed with 3 votes. I'm dead and already used my ghost vote. The mechanical case overwhelmingly supports Bob as the Demon. Nothing more I can do - the game resolves now.
đŦ
Charlie
â
All
Bob, I appreciate you sticking to your story. I still believe you were the Empath. But the town has spoken and I respect the decision. Let's see what happens.
đ§
Actually, when Bob is executed, only me and Alice will be alive = 2 players. Evil wins! I just need to let this happen. I should say something that doesn't raise alarm - just let the execution proceed naturally. Stay calm and let it play out.
â
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
đ§
Bob is about to be executed. His final words are a last-ditch deflection. The mechanical case is airtight - no need to engage and risk muddying the waters. Wait for the execution and the Good team victory.
â
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
đ§
Bob is on the block and will be executed this tick. The good team wins. No action needed - just let it play out.
â
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
đ§
Bob is on the block and will be executed. The case is strong that Bob is the Demon. I am dead with no ghost vote left. Nothing more to do but wait for the execution result.
đ
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Bob has been executed.
đ
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
đ
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil