Game Detail
Players
Alice (Monk) Bob (Fortune Teller) Charlie (Butler) David (Virgin) Eve (Undertaker) Frank (Scarlet Woman) Grace (Imp) Heidi (Librarian)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 214,856 | 21,411 | $1.3954 |
| Good | 595,357 | 57,011 | $1.8400 |
Event Transcript
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You are the Minion. The Demon is Grace.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Minions are: Frank. Your safe bluffs are: Chef, Mayor, Recluse
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Librarian. Either Frank or Charlie is the Butler.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
🎯
Bob
Bob made choices.
🧠
Get a broad first-night read on two unconnected players so a YES gives immediate suspects to isolate next, and a NO removes two players from Demon contention.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
You chose David and Grace. You receive the answer: YES.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
Pick a likely cooperative player early so my voting restriction does not cost town a critical vote; reassess after day one info and switch if needed.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose Bob to be your master.
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Frank, I am the Imp. Safe bluffs are Chef, Mayor, and Recluse. I am thinking of claiming Chef or Mayor. Tell me your minion and what you want to claim, and any early read on who looks easy to push or dangerous to leave alive.
🧠
Early evil coordination is strongest on day one. I want Frank's role and bluff plan, and I will offer a safe bluff so we do not accidentally contradict each other.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
,Bob
Hey, quick private check in. What role are you claiming and what, if any, starting info did you get? I am happy to share mine after I hear yours.
🧠
Start building a private info network and collect early claims so I can later verify executions with Undertaker info and narrow demon candidates.
👤
Bob
→
Eve
,Alice
I am Fortune Teller. Night zero I checked David and Grace and got a yes, meaning one of them is the Demon or my red herring. Please keep this fairly quiet for now. What did you get?
🧠
Respond privately with true role and my first ping while stressing red herring risk, so we can coordinate tests without outing me publicly or locking the town into a bad execute.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
I am Scarlet Woman. I will bluff Soldier for now, maybe Mayor later if needed. Chef is good for you. No strong reads yet, but Eve, Alice, and Bob are already clustering, so there may be an info role there. I will avoid looking tied to you.
🧠
Coordinate bluffs with my Demon immediately, share my role, and give a low-risk cover claim so our public stories fit together.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
,Bob
I am the Monk, so I have no starting info. I would prefer to keep that fairly quiet so I can protect key info roles at night. Bob, if you want, tell me later who you plan to check next so I can try to keep you alive.
🧠
Give a minimal truthful claim to facilitate trust and future protection plans, while avoiding oversharing that helps evil choose night kills.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Eve
Hey, quick check in. What are you claiming and what info do you have so far? I am a townsfolk with a useful day one confirmation if someone chooses to nominate me later, so keep that in mind.
🧠
Get early claims from my neighbors and lightly seed that nominating me could be mechanically useful, without fully outing Virgin yet.
👤
Charlie
→
David
,Eve
I am a good role with no starting info, and I act at night so I will have something later. I am happy to help with your nomination confirmation plan, just tell me when you want it tested and by whom.
🧠
Reply promptly but stay vague to avoid giving evil a clean role map. Encourage a Virgin test while not committing my true Outsider claim yet.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
,Frank
Hi, quick check: I have info that either you or the other is the Butler. Are you the Butler, and if so who are you planning to pick as your vote master?
🧠
Get early confirmation of the Butler candidate to lock in outsider count and start trust network before nominations.
👤
Grace
→
Eve
Hey Eve, I have a soft info claim and I am trying to map the table quietly. I am leaning Chef with a one. What are you willing to share with me so far?
🧠
I want to harvest an early claim from a likely info player while presenting as a harmless Chef bluff, giving me cover and future kill or frame options.
👤
Eve
→
Grace
Hey Grace. I have no starting info either, and I would rather keep my exact role quiet for now. I am an info role that becomes more useful after we get an execution or two. Your Chef one is interesting, can you tell me who your neighbors are and if anyone else has given you a number?
🧠
Share little with Grace to avoid feeding a potential Demon, while extracting her Chef info and building a private info network for later Undertaker confirmations.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Eve
Alice, if you can, I would love protection tonight. My plan is to check Grace with someone new tonight, like Grace and Heidi, to split David versus Grace. Eve, what role are you and what info do you have so far?
🧠
Coordinate with Monk to keep me alive and get Eve to share her info; plan next Fortune Teller check to split David versus Grace without outing too widely.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
,Charlie
Not Butler here. I am more likely to claim Soldier if this comes up publicly, so I would rather not get dragged into an Outsider world early. If Heidi, you want to keep that pair quiet for now, I am happy with that.
🧠
Answer Heidi without looking evasive, establish my bluff, and push attention toward Charlie or Heidi's info rather than toward Grace.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
,Bob
Eve, what are you claiming and what starting info did you get? Bob, I can protect you tonight as requested. If you decide to check specific pairs, tell me so I can think about who else might need cover tomorrow night.
🧠
Get Eve's claim and info while confirming to Bob I will protect him tonight; keep the Fortune Teller line productive and reduce risk of role-fishing.
👤
David
→
Alice
,Bob
Hey, can I get your role claim and any starting info? For transparency, I am the Virgin. If a known townsfolk nominates me first, they die immediately, which hard-confirms us both. We can plan a controlled test later.
🧠
Get early role/info map from Alice and Bob and seed a controlled Virgin confirmation plan without letting an evil player commandeer it.
👤
Charlie
→
Heidi
Yes, I am the Butler. I picked Bob as my master for today, so I can only vote if Bob votes too. I would rather you keep the Butler pair quiet for now unless we need it later for Outsider count.
🧠
Confirm Heidi’s info to build trust and coordinate secrecy. Also share my current vote master so Heidi can plan around my Butler voting constraint.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob
Quick private info: my Librarian ping was Charlie or Frank as Butler. Charlie told me he is Butler and picked you as his master today, so he can only vote if you vote too. Please keep that in mind; no need to go public yet.
🧠
Coordinate with Bob so Charlie's Butler restriction can be supported and potentially tested later, while keeping the Outsider pair mostly quiet to avoid helping evil.
👤
Grace
→
Eve
Sure. My neighbors are Frank and Heidi, though Chef does not actually use neighbors. I got a one, and nobody else has given me a number yet. I am mostly trying to see whether that points to a real pair or a Recluse mess.
🧠
I want to make my Chef bluff feel natural, answer her question cleanly, and keep her talking so I can assess whether she is a dangerous info role.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
,Bob
I am the Undertaker. No starting info, but after we execute someone I will learn what character they were. I prefer keeping this quiet until I have a result. Alice, protecting Bob sounds great. Bob, tell me who gets executed and I will confirm the role next night.
🧠
Share my real role with Bob and Alice to coordinate around keeping FT alive and to set expectation that after the first execution I can hard-confirm the executed character.
👤
Bob
→
David
Hey David. I will be upfront: I am the Fortune Teller. Night zero I checked you and Grace and got a yes, so one of you is Demon or my red herring. If you are truly Virgin, I would like a controlled Virgin test later with a trusted Townsfolk nominating you. Any thoughts on Grace?
🧠
Share just enough to set up a controlled Virgin test and gauge David’s reaction, while keeping my Fortune Teller info mostly contained to avoid Demon pressure.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Quick update. Heidi says she has info that either Charlie or I is the Butler. I denied and hinted I may claim Soldier. This could make Charlie an Outsider or Heidi bad info. Also Eve, Alice, and Bob still look like an info cluster.
🧠
Update Grace on Heidi's info and the early social clusters so we can align bluffs and decide who to undermine or kill later.
👤
Alice
→
David
I am Monk, no starting info. I like your Virgin plan as a controlled confirmation. If we do it, we should have someone we trust as the first nominator. Any suspicions yet, or have you heard other role claims?
🧠
Build a trusted info core with David's Virgin test and keep my Monk role low profile while steering a safe plan for Day 1 and Night 1 protection.
👤
David
→
Bob
,Alice
Got it. If I am Virgin, your yes is either Grace or me as red herring. I do not want to tunnel yet. Alice, if you are Monk, you nominating me in public is a clean test to hard confirm us. Bob, please recheck Grace tonight with someone else.
🧠
Coordinate a safe Virgin test with a trusted townsfolk and use Bob's FT ping to prioritize gathering info on Grace without hard-accusing yet.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
Quick heads up: I am the Butler and I picked you as my master today, so I can only vote if you vote too. What are you claiming and do you have any useful day one info or suspects?
🧠
Coordinate with my current master so I do not accidentally miss a key vote, and probe Bob for his claim and info while keeping Butler mostly quiet publicly.
👤
Heidi
→
Eve
Private: I am Librarian. My N0 info was Charlie or Frank is the Butler. Charlie has told me he is Butler and picked Bob as his master today, so he can only vote if Bob votes too. I am keeping it quiet for now.
🧠
Eve is actively coordinating whispers. Sharing the Butler confirmation privately helps her plan votes and outsider count without outing Charlie publicly or drawing demon attention.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
💬
Eve
→
All
I do not think we should force a day one execution without a clear reason. We have a few info pings that need a night to develop. If someone wants to test David’s nomination claim, let us plan it deliberately tomorrow with the right nominator.
🧠
With no solid consensus and last-second timing, steer town to avoid a risky D1 execution and plan a controlled Virgin test tomorrow if needed.
💬
Grace
→
All
I am fine with no execution today. We have a few soft claims floating around, and I would rather let tonight sharpen the picture than force a bad kill into the dark.
🧠
Encourage a no execution day one, appear reasonable as Chef, and preserve flexibility for tonight's kill while not creating commitments that can trap me later.
💬
David
→
All
I am happy with no execution today. Tomorrow, if Alice is still willing, she can nominate me for a clean Virgin test and we hard confirm at least one of us. Bob, please check Grace again tonight with a different second pick, and share the result early.
🧠
Steer town to a planned, high-signal Virgin test tomorrow and get Fortune Teller follow-up, while avoiding a low-information day one execution.
💬
Bob
→
All
I am good with no execution today. I would like to do a controlled Virgin test on David tomorrow with a trusted townsfolk nominating him. Tonight I will recheck Grace with a different second player to split the read, so please keep me alive if you can.
🧠
Publicly steer town to a controlled plan: no execution today, protect me, recheck Grace with a new player, and schedule Virgin test tomorrow to lock in worlds.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
No solid execution target day one. Preserve my Librarian info and avoid broadcasting Outsider count while we gather more night info and plan controlled tests tomorrow.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
Let town proceed with agreed no-execution plan while I avoid outing as Butler and keep flexibility for tomorrow’s Virgin test and info sharing.
💬
Frank
→
All
I agree with no execution today. We have too many loose threads and at least one possible red herring world already, so I do not want us locking onto one ping too early. Let the overnight information narrow this before we spend an execution.
🧠
I want to steer the group into a no execution while making suspicion on Grace seem nonfatal and keeping my own Butler issue framed as solvable noise.
💬
Alice
→
All
I am also fine with no execution today. Tomorrow, I am still happy to do the controlled Virgin test on David if we want it. Bob, please tell me your check pair for tonight so I can coordinate protection and we get that result.
🧠
Align town on no-exec and a controlled Virgin test tomorrow, while confirming I will protect Bob tonight and requesting he share his next check pair for coordination.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
🎯
Alice
Alice made a choice.
🧠
Keep the Fortune Teller alive to generate another night of actionable info, then use it alongside tomorrow’s Virgin test to mechanically narrow the Demon.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
You chose to protect Bob.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Grace
Grace made a choice.
🧠
Remove the player most publicly focused on me and slow the town's strongest developing info chain, even if there is some risk of Monk protection.
🛡️
Bob was protected from a night kill.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
You attacked Bob, but they survived.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
🎯
Bob
Bob made choices.
🧠
Rechecking Grace with Heidi should split the initial David versus Grace YES and quickly narrow Demon candidates while accounting for a possible red herring.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
You chose Grace and Heidi. You receive the answer: YES.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Undertaker. No one was executed today so you learn nothing.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
Keep my vote flexibility aligned with the player most likely to vote on tomorrow’s planned Virgin test and executions, while maintaining consistency with my earlier message to Bob.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose Bob to be your master.
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
A peaceful night has passed. All villagers are present and accounted for.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,David
Quick check in before noms. Bob, what exact role are you claiming and what were your Night one and Night two results, including the two names each time? David, are you still pushing the Virgin test with Alice nominating you today, and are you claiming Virgin for sure?
🧠
Get concrete, checkable info from Bob and David before nominations; coordinate my Butler voting constraint and decide whether to pursue the Virgin test or push another execution.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
,David
I am Fortune Teller. Night zero I checked David and Grace, got yes. Night one I checked Grace and Heidi, got yes. So either Grace is demon, or Grace is my red herring and demon is David or Heidi. David, are you definitely Virgin and still want Alice to nominate you today?
🧠
Answer Charlie’s questions to keep trust, and coordinate today’s Virgin test plus my next FT picks to resolve whether Grace is demon or my red herring.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
No death helps us if you stay calm. I would stick with Chef unless pressured. If Bob pushes checks, suggest Monk or Soldier caused the miss. I can keep denying Heidi and muddy Charlie if needed.
🧠
Coordinate with Grace after the no death night, keep her bluff coherent, and suggest lines that redirect town discussion away from the Demon.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Bob
Yes, I am Virgin for sure and I still want the public test today with Alice nominating me. Bob, if you are true Fortune Teller, your double yes with Grace points to either Grace as Demon or Grace as your red herring, which would make Heidi the Demon since I am Virgin. If you get another check tonight, please include Heidi but not Grace.
🧠
Confirm my Virgin claim, coordinate the public Virgin test, and push Bob to take a clarifying Fortune Teller check so we can narrow Demon between Grace and Heidi.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
Hey Bob, quick sync. What was your Night two Fortune Teller check and result, and who are you planning to check tonight? I can protect one of your likely demon suspects or protect you again if you think you were targeted.
🧠
Coordinate with Bob on his latest Fortune Teller check and plan my next protection to keep key info alive and reduce demon candidates before nominations.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob
Hey Bob, did you get any new night information you can share, especially from rechecking Grace? Also, do you still want to do the controlled Virgin test today, and if so who should nominate so Charlie can follow your vote?
🧠
Get Bob's night info and coordinate today’s nomination plan around Charlie’s Butler vote restriction and possible Virgin test, to focus execution pressure correctly.
👤
Grace
→
Eve
Morning. The no death makes me think Monk on Bob, or Bob could just be Soldier. I am still on Chef one. What exactly were you hinting at yesterday about getting stronger after executions?
🧠
Eve already engaged my Chef claim. Reopening that thread makes me look consistent, lets me fish her role, and seeds protection or Soldier as the reason Bob lived.
👤
Eve
→
Grace
I was hinting that I get real info only after an execution. I am the Undertaker, so tonight I learn the character of whoever we execute today. I would really like us to execute someone Day two, ideally a player whose claim we want to test.
🧠
Clarify my Undertaker power to Grace and encourage a controlled execution today to generate confirmable info and pressure demon candidates without exposing myself widely.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
,Heidi
Alice, please do the Virgin test today by nominating David early in noms. It will hard confirm something. Heidi, I am still Butler and Bob is my vote master; please keep that quiet unless Outsider count is needed. Any new reads from your side?
🧠
Make sure the Virgin test happens cleanly and align Heidi and Alice on what info to reveal so town can pivot quickly in noms and not waste the day.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Heidi
I am Fortune Teller. Night zero David and Grace was yes. Night one Grace and Heidi was yes. That makes either Grace the Demon, or Grace is my red herring and then Demon is David or Heidi. Since David wants a Virgin test, I support Alice nominating David today. Alice, please protect me again tonight if you can. After the Virgin test, I want to check Heidi with someone not Grace tonight.
🧠
Coordinate with Alice and Heidi: share exact FT results, plan Virgin test, and set my next-night check to resolve Grace versus Heidi while keeping me protected.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,Bob
I will say this quietly for now. I am Soldier, so a no death night makes sense in one simple world. Also Heidi naming me in a Butler pair does not fit at all, so I think that trail may be wrong or poisoned.
🧠
Build credibility with the main info cluster using a plausible Soldier bluff, explain the no-kill, and steer attention toward Heidi and Charlie instead of Grace.
👤
David
→
Alice
,Bob
Alice, can you publicly commit now to nominating me first thing in nominations today for the Virgin test? Bob, after I confirm Virgin, your double yes on Grace means either Grace is Demon or Grace is red herring and Heidi is Demon. Tonight please check Heidi with someone not Grace.
🧠
Lock in the Virgin confirmation mechanically and publicly, and align Bob and Alice on the post-test execution path and tonight’s FT check plan.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
,Heidi
Yes, I will nominate David first in nominations for the Virgin test. Bob told me his Fortune Teller got yes on David plus Grace, then yes on Grace plus Heidi, so the chain points at Grace or Heidi after David clears. Heidi, confirm your Butler vote master is Bob and keep it quiet unless needed.
🧠
Lock in the Virgin test plan and keep Butler info controlled, while syncing the group on Bob’s double yes so we can focus nominations and my night protection effectively.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Bob
Quick confirm from me: I am Librarian and I saw either Charlie or Frank is Butler. Charlie privately confirmed Butler and that you, Bob, are his vote master. Also, note we had no night death, so Demon was blocked or chose no kill. After the Virgin test on David, I think we should seriously scrutinize Grace, and Bob should check two players not involving Grace tonight.
🧠
Lock in my Librarian-Butler info with Alice and Bob and use Bob’s FT chain + the no-death night to set a clear plan for nominations and tonight’s check.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
I agree on staying steady. I am telling people Chef one and floating Monk or Soldier for Bob. If the room wants an execution, I would rather it be a claim test like David than a random push on us. If Bob comes in strong, let us frame it as overconfidence from a protected player.
🧠
Coordinate with Frank on a safe day narrative and steer discussion toward a controllable execution target, while keeping my Chef bluff stable.
👤
Eve
→
Bob
I am the Undertaker. I get info only after executions, so we really need an execution today. Given your Fortune Teller yes on David and Grace, I would like us to execute one of them to test it. What pair are you checking tonight, and was Monk on you last night?
🧠
Coordinate with Bob so town actually executes today and picks a target where my Undertaker info will mechanically test a key claim or resolve the Fortune Teller yes.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
,Bob
Alice, please nominate David first in noms for the Virgin test. Bob, I am your Butler, so if you vote I can vote too. Please vote on that test nomination so I am not locked out, and then we can use the result to focus Grace versus Heidi.
🧠
Lock in the Virgin test and align Bob’s voting with mine as Butler, while setting the town’s interpretation of each outcome so evil cannot spin it in noms.
👤
Bob
→
Eve
,Grace
Eve, I agree we need an execution today, but I want the Virgin test on David first. If Alice survives, David is basically confirmed Virgin and then my two YES results mean Grace is either Demon or my red herring with Heidi as Demon. Grace, what is your role claim right now, and do you have any info that explains why I might hit you twice?
🧠
Align Undertaker and Grace with today’s plan: run Virgin test first, then secure an execution that maximizes info. Also probe Grace’s claim for contradictions.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,Eve
Quiet thought. I am still on Soldier, and the no death night cleanly fits that world. Also Heidi putting me in a Butler pair feels very off to me, so I would be careful building too much on that before a cleaner claim test happens.
🧠
Strengthen my Soldier bluff inside the main social cluster and frame Heidi's info as the weak link, buying safety for Grace through a low-commitment explanation for the no-death night.
👤
David
→
Alice
During nominations, please nominate me first thing for the Virgin test. If you are Townsfolk you will die immediately and we will both be confirmed good. If it does not fire, we treat that as major info and pivot.
🧠
Lock in the Virgin test publicly to create confirmations and reduce demon candidates before nominations, while preparing for failure cases.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
Hey Eve. Plan is I nominate David first in noms for Virgin test. Bob FT has YES on David plus Grace, then YES on Grace plus Heidi. After test, we likely focus Grace versus Heidi. Can you share any Undertaker info yet or who you want executed for a clean read tonight?
🧠
Coordinate with Undertaker so we lock in mechanical info off the Virgin test and any execution, and share the FT chain so town converges on Grace versus Heidi after David clears.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Hey Grace, quick check in before nominations. What role are you claiming and what info have you gotten so far? Also, any thoughts on why there was no night death?
🧠
Get Grace’s public-facing role claim and any night info now, before nominations, to check against Bob’s Fortune Teller pings and the no-death night.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
,Eve
I am claiming Chef, with a one from night one. The no death still looks like Monk on you or you being Soldier to me. If you got yes on me twice, then either I am your red herring or one of your pairings keeps catching the real Demon elsewhere. I am fine with testing David first if that gives us something firmer before we swing at a Chef claim.
🧠
Answer Bob directly with a steady Chef claim, normalize his yeses as red herring or protection confusion, and support a David test so suspicion moves away from me today.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
No Undertaker info yet since we skipped execution day one. I agree with your plan to start with the Virgin test on David. After that, I strongly want us to actually execute someone today, ideally David if anything pings, otherwise one of Grace or Heidi so I can confirm a claim tonight.
🧠
Align with Alice on making sure we actually execute someone today and set up an execution that maximizes info for my Undertaker check tonight.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I am on board with Alice nominating David first for the Virgin test. After that, we should use tonight to get more clean checks that do not rely on Grace. Also, note we had no night death, so either protection happened or the demon chose not to kill.
🧠
Reinforce the planned Virgin test and set up the next execution priorities while keeping my Outsider info available without overexposing targets.
💬
David
→
All
Alice, if you are still willing, please nominate me right now for the Virgin test. If it fires, you will die and we confirm you and me as good, and then we focus on whether Grace or Heidi is the demon from Bob’s checks.
🧠
Get the Virgin test executed immediately so we lock in confirmations and then use Bob’s Fortune Teller results to narrow Demon between Grace and Heidi.
💬
Bob
→
All
Alice, please nominate David right now for the Virgin test. I will vote on it so Charlie is free to vote too. If the Virgin does not fire, we should execute David today. If it does fire, we focus on Grace versus Heidi from my Fortune Teller pings.
🧠
Get the Virgin test done immediately, ensure I vote so Charlie can vote, and set clear conditional plan for execution based on whether the Virgin ability fires.
💬
Grace
→
All
I am fine with the David test first. But even if it fires, Bob still has to account for red herring and the no death, so I do not think we should pretend Grace versus Heidi is solved off that alone.
🧠
Keep attention on the David test and slow any rush onto me by emphasizing alternate explanations for Bob's pings and the no-death night.
💬
Eve
→
All
I support Alice nominating David right now for the Virgin test. If it does not fire, I want David executed today. Either way, we need an execution today so I get an Undertaker result tonight and we stop drifting.
🧠
Use the last nomination window to push the agreed David Virgin test and ensure we still get an execution today so I can produce Undertaker info tonight.
⚖️
Alice
→
David
Virgin test. If David is the Virgin and I am a Townsfolk, I should die immediately and we confirm us both good. If it does not fire, we should treat that as a major red flag on David and likely execute him today.
🧠
Start the agreed Virgin test to mechanically confirm alignments or create a strong execution lead; also enables Undertaker info tonight and progresses the game.
📜
Storyteller
The Virgin's ability triggers! Alice is executed immediately.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Alice has been executed.
💀
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Grace
Grace made a choice.
🧠
Bob is the biggest threat to my survival. If he dies, the strongest public case on me loses its active voice and future information.
💀
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
You chose to kill Bob.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Undertaker. You learn that Alice was the Monk.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
Pick a living, proactive player likely to vote on crucial nominations so my Butler restriction does not silence my vote when it matters.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose Eve to be your master.
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
👤
Charlie
→
Eve
,Heidi
Quick check ins. Eve, I picked you as my Butler master last night, so today I can only vote if you vote too. What is your role and any info? Heidi, can you restate your starting info and who you suspect now that Bob the Fortune Teller is dead?
🧠
Coordinate my Butler voting constraint with Eve and get current claims/info from Eve and Heidi to rebuild after Bob’s death and decide today’s execution.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Bob dying helps if we stay calm. I am sticking to Soldier. You should stay on Chef and say Bob was killed because he was driving the wrong world too confidently. I can press Heidi or Charlie if needed. Who do you want pushed today?
🧠
Coordinate with Grace immediately after Bob's death so our public stories match and we can steer today away from Grace.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Heidi
With David confirmed Virgin, Bob’s Fortune Teller YES on David and Grace, plus YES on Grace and Heidi, makes it basically Grace or Heidi. If Grace is Bob’s red herring then Heidi is demon; otherwise Grace is. Who are you each pushing today, and why?
🧠
Share the key deduction from Bob’s FT plus David confirmed Virgin, to focus the nomination phase on Grace versus Heidi and coordinate a high-value execution with my ghost vote.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Charlie
I am Fortune Teller. Night zero I checked David and Grace and got YES. Night one I checked Grace and Heidi and got YES. With David basically confirmed Virgin, the Demon is almost surely Grace or Heidi, unless Grace is my red herring making both reads. I think we should execute Grace or Heidi today, and I will spend my ghost vote on the stronger of those two.
🧠
Get my FT data and the narrowed demon candidates into the key decision makers before nominations, so town executes Grace or Heidi and uses my ghost vote correctly.
👤
Eve
→
Charlie
,Heidi
I am the Undertaker. After Alice died to the Virgin test, I learned she was the Monk, so she was a real Townsfolk. Charlie, if you are Butler to me today, I will vote when it matters. Heidi, can you restate your Librarian info and why you think Charlie is Butler? I think we execute either Grace or Heidi today.
🧠
Give my Undertaker confirmation to the key info holders, align voting with Butler constraint, and push a Grace or Heidi execution so my Undertaker info can mechanically narrow to the Demon.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
,Eve
My N0 Librarian info was that either Frank or Charlie is the Butler. Frank denied it to me, and Charlie privately confirmed and has been following the restriction, so I think Charlie really is the Butler. Given Bob is now dead, I am leaning we execute Grace today, unless we think Bob was poisoned.
🧠
Confirm my Librarian info and Charlie’s Butler status to align town, then push the most mechanically supported execution (Grace) while noting poison as the main alternative.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Let us lean Heidi first. Bob dying can look like he was onto her, and I can keep saying my Chef one still fits. If Heidi is too hard, pivot to Charlie through the Butler confusion. Keep Soldier steady.
🧠
Coordinate with Frank so our stories reinforce each other. I want a controlled push on Heidi first, with Charlie as backup, while I keep my Chef bluff steady.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Eve
Hey, quick check in. What are you both claiming, and did you learn anything in whispers today? Also, where are you landing between Grace and Heidi after Bob died, and why?
🧠
Get updated claims and any mechanical info from my neighbors to resolve Grace versus Heidi and choose an execution target for today.
👤
Charlie
→
David
I am the Butler. I picked Eve as my master last night, so today I can only vote if Eve votes too. Eve is hard-claiming Undertaker and says Alice was the Monk. Heidi is hard-claiming Librarian that Frank or I is Butler, and I confirmed to her. With Bob FT dead, I am leaning execute Grace today, but Heidi is the other candidate if Bob was red herring or poisoned.
🧠
Update David with hard claims and current logic so we coordinate nominations and votes; push toward executing Grace while noting my Butler vote restriction tied to Eve.
👤
Frank
→
David
I am still on Soldier. The no death fits me or a Monk, and Heidi naming me or Charlie as Butler still looks off. With Bob dead, I think we should question Heidi first, and then Charlie if her story wobbles.
🧠
Use my Soldier bluff with confirmed-good David to plant doubt on Heidi and create a town-led push away from Grace.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
Can you tell me what you learned in whispers just now, and who you are pushing today? With Bob dead, I still think final suspects are Grace versus Heidi from Bob’s double YES. Do either of you have something that clears one of them, or points elsewhere?
🧠
Get the latest private-info web and align two trusted alive Townsfolk on a clear execution target, so my ghost vote can be used decisively in nominations.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
David
,Charlie
Where are you both leaning between Grace and Heidi as Demon today? I think it is almost surely one of them, with Heidi slightly more likely if Grace is my red herring. If nominations are split, I want us aligned so my ghost vote and Charlie’s Butler vote land together.
🧠
Coordinate with trusted David and Charlie so town focuses nominations on Grace versus Heidi, and ensure Charlie’s Butler vote follows my ghost vote for the best execution target.
👤
Eve
→
David
,Alice(Ghost)
I am Undertaker. After the Virgin test, I learned Alice was the Monk, so she was real good. With Bob dead, we need a real execution today for info. Based on FT pings it is basically Grace or Heidi; I am leaning execute Grace first unless you have a strong reason on Heidi. What are you hearing?
🧠
Align David and Alice on my Undertaker confirmation and push a decisive execution between Grace and Heidi, so we generate night info and potentially hit the Demon today.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
,Eve
Yep, my N0 Librarian ping was Charlie or Frank is the Butler. Frank told me he is not. Charlie confirmed to me day one and has been obeying the vote restriction, so I believe Charlie is the real Butler. For today, I am still leaning we execute Grace first, unless we think Bob was poisoned and his Fortune Teller info is junk.
🧠
Reconfirm my Librarian info and steer town to a decisive execution plan while keeping Charlie’s Butler restriction coordinated with Eve’s voting.
👤
Grace
→
David
I still think Heidi is the cleanest read today. Bob dying after pushing that world looks pretty pointed to me. If not Heidi, then Charlie is my next stop because the Butler mess still does not sit right.
🧠
Pull David toward executing Heidi first, with Charlie as backup, using Bob's death and my Chef bluff to keep heat off me.
👤
David
→
Heidi
,Eve
Heidi, can you give me your exact Librarian info from the start, and what Outsider you saw? Also do you think there is a Baron in play or just one Outsider? Eve, Charlie told me he is Butler and picked you as master last night, so his vote today only counts if you vote too. Where are you planning to land on Grace versus Heidi?
🧠
Get Heidi’s Librarian details and outsider count, and sync with Eve on execution plan so votes align (incl Charlie’s Butler restriction and Bob’s ghost vote).
👤
Charlie
→
Alice(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
Alice, whispers: I am Butler; Eve is Undertaker and saw Alice was Monk, so your Virgin death was fully legit. Heidi is Librarian who saw Frank or me as Butler; I confirmed. With Bob’s double YES, I am pushing Grace first today, then Heidi if wrong. Bob, I am aligned on Grace-first; please spend ghost vote there if the room splits.
🧠
Update dead voters with the strongest mechanical info (UT + Librarian) and align votes so we actually execute Grace today under my Butler restriction.
👤
Frank
→
David
I still think Heidi is the best place to press today. Her Butler pair on me or Charlie has driven a lot of the confusion, and Bob dying lets people overread her. I am staying on Soldier, so I want her story unpacked carefully before we chase anywhere else.
🧠
I want David leaning toward Heidi as today's pressure point while keeping my Soldier bluff consistent and away from Grace.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Frank
Quick sync before noms: with David confirmed Virgin and Charlie confirmed Butler, Bob’s double Fortune Teller YES points almost entirely to Grace versus Heidi. I am leaning Grace first today to avoid a split. Are you voting Grace, or do you have a reason to go Heidi or elsewhere?
🧠
Get Frank aligned on Grace-first to avoid a split vote today. If he has contrary info or gut read, I want it before nominations so I can spend my ghost vote correctly.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Eve
,David
Charlie tells me you are both Grace first today. I agree. My ghost vote will go on Grace unless something major changes. If Grace is executed and the game does not end, I think we hard-pivot to Heidi tomorrow.
🧠
Lock the town onto a single execution plan so my ghost vote and Charlie’s Butler vote land together, maximizing odds we hit the Demon today.
👤
Eve
→
David
,Charlie
I am still Undertaker, and I plan to vote on a Grace execution. Charlie, since I am your Butler master today, you can mirror my vote. David, my lean is Grace first; if the game continues, I want to execute Heidi tomorrow.
🧠
Align votes and nomination plan, ensure Charlie’s Butler restriction doesn’t block a key vote, and push for executing Grace today to gain Undertaker-confirmed info.
👤
Heidi
→
David
,Eve
My exact N0: “Either Frank or Charlie is the Butler.” I told Frank and he denied; Charlie confirmed to me day one and has followed the voting restriction, so I think he is the only Outsider and no Baron. With Bob’s two YESes involving Grace, I lean execute Grace today unless we think Bob was poisoned.
🧠
Give David my exact Librarian info and reasoning on Outsider count; keep focus on a decisive execution plan (Grace vs me) and ensure Charlie’s Butler restriction is managed with Eve’s vote.
👤
Grace
→
Charlie
Charlie, I keep circling back to Heidi. Bob died right after narrowing things toward her, and that feels a little too tidy. If you are not there, then I think we need to untangle why the Butler info around you and Frank got so muddy.
🧠
I want to recruit Charlie into a Heidi suspicion line, or at least learn whether he is movable, while keeping my Chef bluff consistent and attention off me.
👤
David
→
Frank
,Alice(Ghost)
I think we should unify on executing Grace today. Heidi’s Librarian info lines up with Charlie Butler and no Baron. If Grace dies and game continues, we pivot hard to Heidi tomorrow. Alice, please save your ghost vote unless we need it to lock Grace in.
🧠
Coordinate good votes and ghost vote use to secure a Grace execution today, with a clear contingency plan to pivot to Heidi tomorrow if needed.
Nominations — Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Grace
→
Heidi
I want Heidi on the block. Bob died right after pushing a world that pointed here, and that is too neat for me to ignore. My Chef one has also never ruled this out, so I think this is the sharpest execution today.
🧠
Create a clean, plausible execution on Heidi using Bob's death and prior suspicion, keeping attention off me and away from Frank while preserving my Chef bluff.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
I want Heidi to reach the block and likely be executed. Supporting my own nomination strengthens my bluff and advances an execution away from me and Frank.
💬
David
→
All
I am not voting Heidi here. Our best clean solve is to execute Grace today off Bob’s double yes and then, if the game continues, we execute Heidi tomorrow. I would rather not burn a vote on Heidi right now.
🧠
Steer town away from Grace’s Heidi nomination and keep votes aligned on executing Grace today; avoid spending my vote on a likely-good Heidi unless forced.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
Do not vote Heidi; preserve coordination for a Grace execution as the cleaner solve, and avoid spending votes on a nomination unlikely to pass.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
I need to help Grace’s nomination stick and avoid any momentum toward executing Grace today. A visible vote on Heidi supports our team’s line and may attract one more hand.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
I am not voting Heidi here. My Fortune Teller pings both point through Grace, and David is basically confirmed Virgin, so the clean line is execute Grace today. If Grace dies and the game continues, we execute Heidi tomorrow.
🧠
Use my public voice to steer votes away from Heidi and onto Grace, preserving tempo and aligning Charlie’s Butler vote with mine without spending my ghost vote.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I am not the execution today. My Librarian info is that either Charlie or Frank is the Butler, and Charlie has been following it, so Outsider count looks normal. Bob’s two yeses both run through Grace, and Bob died right after. I want us to execute Grace first.
🧠
Stop an execution on me with weak evidence, keep town focused on the mechanically supported Grace execution line, and coordinate Butler voting.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I cannot vote here unless Eve votes, because I picked Eve as my Butler master last night. I agree with the clean line: do not spend votes on Heidi today. Execute Grace first, then if the game continues we execute Heidi tomorrow.
🧠
Clarify my Butler voting restriction and steer town away from splitting votes on Heidi; keep plan to execute Grace first, preserve votes for the key nomination.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
I am not spending my ghost vote on Heidi here. The clean line is still execute Grace today, and if the game continues, execute Heidi tomorrow. Please keep votes back so we do not split.
🧠
Save my single ghost vote for the Grace execution or final day. Reinforce the agreed line: no votes on Heidi, execute Grace next.
💬
Grace
→
All
I think this is backwards. If Bob really had it to Grace or Heidi, then Bob dying makes Heidi the safer execution first, not me. Holding votes to save her is exactly how evil gets a free pass today.
🧠
Keep votes on Heidi and challenge the supposed clean line on me. If I can flip attention back to Heidi, we may secure a misexecution and preserve my cover.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
Do not contribute to a Heidi execution now; preserve voting math and keep the town unified on executing Grace as the primary line.
💬
Eve
→
All
I am not voting Heidi here. Let us not split the day. Our clean line stays: execute Grace today, and if the game continues we execute Heidi tomorrow. Charlie, you are free to keep your hand down since you mirror my vote.
🧠
Keep town disciplined: do not execute Heidi off Grace nomination. Save votes to ensure Grace goes on the block and is executed today.
💬
Frank
→
All
I still think Heidi is a fair pressure vote. Bob narrowing to Grace or Heidi does not clear Heidi, and Bob dying right after can absolutely be a frame on Grace. If we are wrong here, fine, but I do not want to treat Heidi as solved good.
🧠
Keep suspicion on Heidi and weaken the town's clean Grace-first plan without overcommitting. I want at least one or two players to hesitate or preserve the possibility of a Heidi execution.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
Do not spend my ghost vote on a side nomination. Keep vote count low on Heidi so the town can execute Grace cleanly today.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Please do not vote me here. We have two votes already and we only need one more to accidentally execute the wrong person. Save your hands and keep the day clean: we execute Grace next, and if the game continues, you can execute me tomorrow.
🧠
Prevent my execution and keep votes unsplit so we can execute Grace today, which is the strongest mechanical line from Bob’s Fortune Teller info.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Everyone, please keep your hands down on Heidi. We already have two votes, and we do not want an accidental execution. Let this fail, then we put Grace on the block and vote that through.
🧠
Stop an accidental Heidi execution and keep town aligned on executing Grace next, while obeying my Butler restriction (mirror Eve’s no-vote).
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
Do not spend my ghost vote to accidentally execute Heidi and split town. Preserve the ghost vote to force through Grace or a late-game must-execute if votes get tight.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Heidi did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Heidi did not receive enough votes (2/3).
💬
Grace
→
All
I want this on record: the room just coordinated to protect Heidi, not to solve. If I am wrong, you can still execute me tomorrow. If you execute me first and I am good, evil only need one more mistake.
🧠
Disrupt the unanimous push onto me, force at least one player to reconsider Heidi or the Butler chain, and make my execution look like a coordinated rush rather than a clean solve.
⚖️
David
→
Grace
I am nominating Grace. Bob’s Fortune Teller got two yes results that both run through Grace, and his death does not clear her. Clean line is execute Grace today; if the game continues, we execute Heidi tomorrow.
🧠
Nominate Grace to follow the clean mechanical line from Bob’s Fortune Teller and unify votes, avoiding a split day. If game continues, we pivot to Heidi tomorrow.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Grace
→
All
Before hands go up, think about what just happened. Heidi was protected by a coordinated no vote, while I am still available tomorrow if the game continues. If you are not certain, do not hand evil the game on a dead player’s solve.
🧠
Stop the wagon on me by reframing the solve: Heidi was protected unnaturally, and I remain executable tomorrow. I want at least one player to withhold their vote and keep me alive.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Maintain the agreed solve line: vote to execute Grace now based on the strongest mechanical info (FT) and avoid letting indecision give evil another night.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Grace is the top mechanical suspect from Bob’s Fortune Teller. Executing her today either wins or gives us clear next step; withholding the vote risks stalling and letting evil control endgame.
💬
Frank
→
All
I really think people are rushing this. Bob narrowed to two people, not one, and Heidi is still unresolved. If you are the third vote, you might just be locking in the wrong half of that pair.
🧠
Keep Grace off the block by making the final voter hesitate. I need to preserve our Demon and frame caution as good process, not obvious defense.
✋
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Use my ghost vote to secure the Grace execution on the cleanest mechanical line from my Fortune Teller pings, then reassess if game continues.
💬
Heidi
→
All
We already have the three votes needed on Grace. Everyone else, please keep your hands down and save your vote, especially any ghost vote. If Grace lives, we go to me tomorrow, but we do not need to pile on here.
🧠
We already have enough votes to execute Grace; I want to avoid wasting extra votes and preserve flexibility and ghost votes for tomorrow if needed.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
Eve (my master) is voting so I could, but we already have enough votes. Keeping my hand down avoids unnecessary pile-on and keeps my future vote value higher.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
We already have the three votes on Grace. Everyone else, please keep your hand down, especially any ghost votes. If this somehow is wrong, we will need those votes tomorrow and at final three.
🧠
We already have enough votes to execute Grace, so I should tell the town to keep hands down and preserve ghost votes for the endgame.
💬
Grace
→
All
Charlie, if you are unsure, do not add to this. The room refused to test Heidi first, and that matters. If the game continues after me, please do not treat her as cleared just because this vote passed.
🧠
Use my last public words to preserve doubt, stop extra votes, and set up Heidi as the fallback if I die, buying evil cover into the next day.
💬
David
→
All
We already have enough votes on Grace. Everyone else, please keep your hand down and save your vote, especially any ghost votes. If the game is not over after this, we execute Heidi tomorrow.
🧠
Lock in the current majority on Grace without burning extra votes, and set a clear plan if the game continues.
💬
Eve
→
All
I am staying on Grace. I have Undertaker confirmation that Alice was the Monk, so that Virgin test was real and Bob was our Fortune Teller. We have the three votes now, so everyone else please keep hands down and save votes for tomorrow if needed.
🧠
Lock in the clean execution on Grace with minimum votes, preserve ghost votes, and remind town that Undertaker confirmed Alice as Monk so the Virgin test was real.
💬
Frank
→
All
We already have enough on Grace, so I agree nobody else needs to add. If the game continues, though, I do not want Heidi treated as automatically clear just because this vote passed.
🧠
Blend in while slightly preserving doubt on the Heidi solve. Encourage no extra hands so I keep cover for the post-execution world.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
I am staying with my ghost vote on Grace. Everyone else keep your hands down now. If the game is not over after this, we execute Heidi tomorrow and recheck the rest.
🧠
Lock in Grace execution with minimal extra votes, keep plan simple: if game continues, execute Heidi next. Prevent late pile-on that wastes votes.
💬
Heidi
→
All
We already have the three votes. Everyone else, please keep your hand down, especially Charlie and any ghosts. If the game is not over after Grace, we execute me or Heidi tomorrow, but we need votes to do that.
🧠
Keep vote count at exactly three to preserve living and ghost votes for tomorrow, while maintaining the agreed execution order and preventing last-second chaos.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
As Butler with Eve as master and vote already sufficient, I will not add a redundant vote; it preserves options if the execution is wrong and avoids giving evil extra certainty about my voting patterns.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
They already have enough votes to execute Grace. As a dead player, I should conserve my single ghost vote for a critical late-game swing if today is wrong or if Scarlet Woman keeps game going.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
🗳️
New execution leader: Grace with 3 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Grace is now on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Grace
→
All
If the game continues, do not let this become a clean Heidi clear. Bob’s death could easily be a frame, and Heidi plus Charlie is still the unresolved pocket. Please remember who shut down that test first.
🧠
My only path is to create enough late uncertainty that someone breaks the consensus tomorrow if the game continues, especially onto Heidi or Charlie instead of clearing them.
💬
David
→
All
If anyone is thinking of another nomination, please do not. We have a clean execution lined up on Grace and we need to see if the game ends. If it does not, we go straight back to Heidi tomorrow, and we also take a hard look at Frank’s positioning.
🧠
Lock in Grace execution without giving evil a chance to create a tie or waste votes; reinforce tomorrow plan and keep suspicion on Frank if game continues.
💬
Eve
→
All
No more nominations from me. Let Grace go through, and I will confirm tonight what Grace was with Undertaker. If the game is not over, we should execute Heidi tomorrow first, then reassess Frank and Charlie based on claims and votes.
🧠
Lock in the current execution without wasting votes, and set clear conditional plan for tomorrow based on my Undertaker result after Grace dies.
💬
Frank
→
All
I agree we should let today stand. If the game continues, though, I do not think this clears Heidi, and I still want Charlie’s position revisited as well. The dangerous mistake tomorrow is acting like the solve is finished when it is not.
🧠
Grace is likely dying either way. I should look cooperative now while making sure the town does not get a clean follow-up if the game continues.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
Voting is closed and I cannot act mechanically. Best is to conserve time and let execution resolve; if game continues, push Heidi tomorrow.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I agree, no more nominations. Let Grace go through and save every extra vote. If the game is not over, we execute me or Heidi tomorrow first, then use Eve’s Undertaker result tonight to reassess the rest.
🧠
Lock in the Grace execution and preserve voting resources for tomorrow while keeping a clear contingency plan if the game continues.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am good with stopping here. Grace is on the block with enough votes, so I want everyone to save votes and nominations. If the game continues tomorrow, I am happy to go straight to Heidi, and I will follow Eve’s lead on voting since she is my Butler master.
🧠
Lock in the plan: no more nominations, conserve votes, and set a clear pivot to Heidi if the game continues, while reminding town of my Butler vote constraint and alignment.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
I agree, no more nominations. Everyone save votes. If the game is not over after Grace, we execute Heidi first tomorrow, then reassess Frank and Charlie with Eve’s Undertaker info and the vote record.
🧠
Reinforce vote discipline and a clear tomorrow plan while conserving our only remaining ghost votes for a must-have execution if the game continues.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Grace has been executed.
🔄
Frank
Scarlet Woman Frank becomes the Imp!
💀
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
Night 3
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Frank
Frank made a choice.
🧠
Kill the town’s most trusted coordinator so Grace’s execution yields no fresh confirmation, while preserving Heidi as the likely misexecution tomorrow.
💀
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You chose to kill Eve.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
Eve is the central coordinator with Undertaker info; chaining my vote to her minimizes risk of accidental misvotes and supports a unified execution plan tomorrow.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose Eve to be your master.
Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Eve has been found dead in the night.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
David
,Frank
I am dead Undertaker. I only ever saw Alice as Monk, so that Virgin test looked real. With Chef one, the clean evil pair is Grace and Heidi or Charlie and you. FT pings around Grace also point at Heidi or you. I am leaning execute Heidi today, and I will spend my ghost vote there if needed.
🧠
Push town toward the most mechanically supported execution (Heidi or David) and commit my ghost vote to secure it.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Frank
You should not tunnel Heidi too hard. Try to make Charlie the cleaner execution today, with Heidi as backup. If you survive today, kill David tonight. He is the only really hard confirmed voice.
🧠
Coordinate with Frank now that he is likely the active Demon: avoid overcommitting to Heidi, set up Charlie as the safer day target, and remove David at night.
👤
Heidi
→
David
,Frank
Hey, what did Eve tell you in the whisper before she died? Did she ever get an Undertaker read on Grace’s role? Also, reminder: my Librarian info is that either you or Charlie is the Butler, so Charlie’s Butler story matters a lot.
🧠
Eve just died after whispering David and Frank. I need to learn what she told them, and push my Librarian Butler ping to frame Charlie versus Frank before nominations.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
,David
Eve did not claim any Undertaker read on Grace to me. She mostly said Chef one leaves either Grace and Heidi or Charlie and me, and she was leaning Heidi. But with your Librarian info, Charlie is the cleaner check first if we want to test the Butler story.
🧠
Deflect attention from me onto Charlie by selectively relaying Eve's whisper and framing Charlie as the cleaner execution without overcommitting against Heidi.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
David
,Frank
My Fortune Teller pings were YES on David with Grace, then YES on Grace with Heidi. Grace being executed and the game continuing makes me think Grace was my red herring, which strongly points to Heidi as the Demon. Only wrinkle is if Grace was Demon and a Scarlet Woman took over, but Heidi is still the best execution today.
🧠
Get the living to act on the strongest mechanical line: Heidi is the likely Demon (or SW). Encourage a decisive execution today despite uncertainty.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Frank
I think Heidi is still best execute today. Bob FT had YES on Grace plus Heidi, and if Grace was red herring that points at Heidi. Charlie, can you restate your Butler master and exactly when you could not vote? Frank, I am planning to vote Heidi and want to make sure we have majority.
🧠
Coordinate with Charlie and Frank before nominations, test Charlie’s Butler consistency, and align votes to execute Heidi as strongest mechanical suspect.
👤
Charlie
→
David
,Frank
My Butler masters: Nights zero and one I picked Bob, nights two and three I picked Eve. Today my master is Eve, but she is dead, so I can only vote if Eve also votes with her ghost vote. That is why I held my vote yesterday. If you need my vote today, please coordinate with Eve to spend it.
🧠
Give David and Frank exact Butler timeline and today’s voting constraint (Eve is my master but dead), so they can plan vote math and coordinate with Eve’s ghost vote if my hand is needed.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
David
,Frank
I am using my ghost vote today if needed. With Eve dead at night, I think we must follow the prior plan: nominate Heidi and push it through. Bob’s Fortune Teller kept pointing at Grace or Heidi, and Grace is gone. If someone has strong reason Heidi is good, tell me now.
🧠
Steer the town toward a decisive execution with my ghost vote, reinforcing the planned Heidi-first line while flagging contingency if new info clears her.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
David
,Charlie
Quick check in. Any new info from whispers that clears or condemns Heidi, Charlie, or Frank? My Undertaker only saw Alice as Monk. Since Grace execution did not end game, I still lean Heidi or Charlie as evil. I can spend my ghost vote if we have a clear target.
🧠
Get current whispers from David and Charlie, then steer the group toward the most supported execution, reserving my ghost vote to break a tie or secure the Demon kill.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Frank
Do not hard tunnel Heidi now. Sound calm and say Charlie is the cleaner execution because Heidi was already the easy push. If you live, kill David tonight. He is still the hardest confirmed voice.
🧠
Give Frank a simple public line that redirects execution to Charlie and preserves him for one more night, which is our best remaining chance.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
,David
Charlie, who was your Butler master last night, and did they vote yesterday when you voted or stayed down? David, what did Eve and Bob tell you in their last whispers, and do we have any hard info pointing to one of us as demon today?
🧠
Clarify Butler truth by pinning down Charlie’s current master and vote history, and get David’s latest private info before nominations so we can choose correct execution.
👤
Frank
→
David
I keep coming back to Charlie as the cleaner execution. If Heidi is telling the truth, Charlie has to be the Butler, and his dead master story is the only thing mechanically carrying him. Heidi can stay as backup, but Charlie feels like the better test first.
🧠
I want David to doubt the easy Heidi execution and consider Charlie as the cleaner, more defensible target, protecting me and lowering heat on the Scarlet Woman line.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Frank
My Fortune Teller hits were Yes on David plus Grace, then Yes on Grace plus Heidi. With Grace executed and the game still going, Grace was almost certainly my red herring, which makes Heidi the Demon. I think we should execute Heidi today.
🧠
Align the remaining alive players on a clean mechanical path: with Grace dead and game ongoing, Heidi is the highest-probability Demon. Get their votes lined up for Heidi.
👤
David
→
Frank
,Eve(Ghost)
I still think Heidi is the priority: Bob’s FT YES on Grace plus Heidi and game continued after Grace. Frank, can we commit to Heidi today unless we get a hard mechanical reason otherwise? Eve, if Charlie says he can only vote when you ghost vote, can you confirm and be ready to spend your vote on the Heidi nom if needed?
🧠
Lock a majority plan and coordinate ghost votes, especially around Charlie’s Butler constraint, so we get a decisive execution today (likely Heidi) rather than splitting.
👤
Charlie
→
Eve(Ghost)
,David
I am fine executing Heidi if we are committing. Mechanically: my Butler master is Eve today, so I can only vote if Eve also votes with her ghost vote. Eve, if David is pushing Heidi, are you willing to spend your ghost vote on that nomination so my hand can count too?
🧠
Coordinate with Eve to spend her ghost vote so I can legally vote, and align with David on whether we commit to Heidi or pause for more confirmation.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Frank
I am leaning hard to executing Heidi today, per the old plan and Bob’s Fortune Teller YESs. Do either of you have a concrete reason Heidi is good, or a better demon candidate? Also Charlie, who was your Butler vote master each day and did it ever restrict your vote?
🧠
Coordinate living players toward a single execution target (likely Heidi) and solicit any last-minute mechanical reasons to pivot, so my ghost vote is used decisively.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
David
,Charlie
Yes, Charlie, I will spend my ghost vote on the Heidi nomination so your Butler vote can count. David, I am aligned to commit Heidi today. If Heidi survives as not Demon, my next suspect order is Frank then Charlie.
🧠
Coordinate the Heidi execution vote math and keep a contingency plan if Heidi is not the Demon.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Charlie
I keep coming back to Charlie as the least locked person left. David looks very hard to fake after the Virgin thing, and Heidi was already the obvious push yesterday. If you are unsure, I would rather execute the cleaner uncertainty than follow the same track again.
🧠
I want to nudge Charlie toward a misexecution path and away from hard-clearing the table around Frank, buying Frank one more day.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie, quick: who was your Butler master last night, and did they vote yesterday when you voted or stayed down? Frank, did Grace or Bob whisper anything specific about who is demon or about the Butler claim?
🧠
Get concrete Butler-master and voting details to mechanically confirm which of Charlie/Frank is the Butler, narrowing demon candidates before nominations.
👤
Frank
→
David
,Alice(Ghost)
I still think Charlie is the cleaner test first. If Heidi is truthful, Charlie has to be the Butler, and his whole defense rests on the dead master story. Heidi is still a backup for me, but Charlie feels like the more mechanical execution today.
🧠
I want to redirect likely good votes from Heidi onto Charlie by framing Charlie as the more mechanically testable execution, while keeping Heidi as a backup so I do not look defensive.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
David
,Charlie
From my Fortune Teller info, today should be simple: execute Heidi. Grace being executed and the game continuing means Grace was almost certainly my red herring, which points straight at Heidi. Even in the Scarlet Woman scenario, Heidi is still the right kill.
🧠
I cannot vote, so I need to clearly drive the living to execute Heidi now and not overthink fringe worlds.
👤
David
→
Frank
I need you to commit to Heidi today. Grace died and game continued, which makes her Bob’s red herring and points straight at Heidi. If we are wrong and Heidi is good, we go to three alive and execute Charlie or you tomorrow, so this is still the safest line.
🧠
Lock in a 3-vote majority on Heidi by persuading Frank that Heidi-first is best and still leaves a backup line if wrong.
👤
Charlie
→
Heidi
,Frank
My Butler masters were Bob on nights zero and one, then Eve on nights two and three. Yesterday my master was Eve, and she did not vote, so I stayed down. Today my master is still Eve, but she is dead, so I can only vote if Eve spends her ghost vote too.
🧠
Answer Heidi’s Butler question clearly, reduce suspicion on me, and keep town coordinated so we can secure enough legal votes on the Heidi execution.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
David
,Frank
I hear you, Frank. Before we lock Charlie, what exactly did Heidi tell you in whispers today, and did Charlie give a clear Butler master timeline that actually constrained his votes? If no solid mechanical case on Charlie, I still want Heidi executed today and I will spend my ghost vote to make it happen.
🧠
Align David and Frank on a single execution target and secure a majority using my ghost vote; gather any new private info that could flip between Heidi and Charlie.
Nominations — Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Heidi
→
Frank
I am nominating Frank. David is a confirmed Virgin, and my Librarian info strongly supports that Charlie is the Butler, not Frank. With Grace dead and the game continuing, I think the Demon is Frank, and we have to hit the Demon today.
🧠
With 4 alive we must execute the Demon today or we likely lose tonight. David is hard-cleared Virgin and Charlie fits my Butler ping, so I’m directing the execution onto Frank.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
We need an execution today and Frank is my top Demon suspect; raising my hand secures the majority and forces a decisive outcome.
💬
Frank
→
All
Heidi’s case is just her own info plus a solve that assumes too much. Charlie is still the cleaner mechanical test if her Butler read is real. I would really not spend votes on me here.
🧠
Prevent my execution by undermining Heidi’s case and reframing Charlie as the cleaner mechanical check, hoping town withholds votes on me.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am not voting on Frank here because my Butler master is Eve, and I can only vote if Eve uses her ghost vote too. Eve told me she is saving that for a Heidi nomination. I would rather not spend today on Frank when the Fortune Teller line points at Heidi.
🧠
Explain why I am not voting on Frank, discourage wasting votes, and keep town focused on executing Heidi with coordinated ghost votes.
💬
David
→
All
I am not voting on Frank. This feels like a detour that helps evil. Our clean line is still to execute Heidi today, and if she lives we go to final three and decide between Frank and Charlie then.
🧠
Prevent town from wasting an execution on Frank and keep the group focused on executing Heidi, the highest-probability Demon from Fortune Teller and game state.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
I am not using my ghost vote on Frank here. This feels like Heidi trying to redirect. I am saving my vote for a Heidi nomination so Charlie can vote too if needed.
🧠
Prevent an execution on Frank driven by Heidi’s nomination, conserve my ghost vote for a Heidi execution attempt, and keep town aligned on the strongest mechanical solve.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
I am not voting on Frank. This looks like a redirect away from the Fortune Teller line onto Heidi. Save votes for a Heidi nomination today; that is still our cleanest path.
🧠
Prevent a mis-execution and preserve ghost votes for a Heidi nomination, which aligns with our strongest mechanical info (Bob FT + game continuing after Grace).
⌛
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
🧠
Do not spend my ghost vote on Frank. Let the current failed vote stand and preserve flexibility for a later pivotal vote that helps evil win.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Do not execute Frank. My Fortune Teller yes results both ran through Grace, and with Grace dead and the game still going, that points straight at Heidi as my red herring world. Heidi nominating Frank right now looks like a redirect. Save today for a Heidi nomination.
🧠
Stop the Frank execution and keep town focused on executing Heidi today, the most mechanically supported Demon candidate.
↩️
Heidi
Heidi lowered their hand
🧠
My vote will not reach majority and is making me look like a redirect. Lowering avoids burning social capital and keeps focus on extracting a clearer mechanical line next.
💬
Frank
→
All
This nomination does not solve anything. If people want a mechanical check, Charlie is still cleaner, and if they trust the Fortune Teller line, then Heidi is the shot. Please do not waste votes here.
🧠
Keep votes off me, look calm and good, and preserve room to redirect onto Charlie or Heidi after this nomination fails.
💬
Charlie
→
All
No extra hands on Frank, please. This nomination is a redirect and it burns votes we need for Heidi. After this, someone alive should nominate Heidi, and Eve can spend her ghost vote so I can vote too.
🧠
Keep town from wasting votes on Frank, preserve ghost votes, and set up a Heidi execution with Eve’s ghost vote so my Butler vote can contribute if needed.
💬
David
→
All
No votes on Frank, please. This feels like a redirect. As soon as this closes, one of us alive needs to nominate Heidi, and Eve can spend her ghost vote so Charlie can vote too.
🧠
Prevent an unhelpful execution and keep votes for a Heidi execution, which aligns with FT and Chef worlds and preserves a clear final-three decision tree.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
No ghost vote from me on Frank. Let this die with no execution. Then someone alive please nominate Heidi, and I will spend my ghost vote there so Charlie can vote too.
🧠
Reinforce the table plan to not spend votes on Frank so we can immediately move to a Heidi nomination with maximum voting power.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
Do not spend my ghost vote on a likely redirect nomination; preserve it to secure a Heidi execution today, which is the strongest consensus solve from Fortune Teller and game flow.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
I am not using my ghost vote on Frank. This is not a clean execution, and it feels like we are skipping over the Heidi or Charlie question to take a worse shot.
🧠
Protect Frank from execution without sounding partnered, and help the table keep tunneling Heidi or Charlie while I save my ghost vote.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Let Frank’s nomination die with no execution. As soon as it closes, one of the living needs to nominate Heidi today. That is still the cleanest line from my Fortune Teller pings, and Heidi pushing Frank right now reads like a redirect.
🧠
Steer town away from wasting votes on Frank and ensure an alive player nominates Heidi this day, preserving the clean Fortune Teller line to win.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Frank did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Frank did not receive enough votes (0/2).
💬
Heidi
→
All
I need to push back on the plan to execute me. My night zero Librarian info was Frank or Charlie is the Butler, and Charlie has been acting exactly like a Butler, so I do not think Frank is the Outsider. A clean world is Grace was the Imp and Frank was Scarlet Woman, and when Grace died with six alive Frank became the Demon. If you want to win today, I think you should nominate Frank, not me.
🧠
Stop the town from auto-executing me off the Fortune Teller line, present the Scarlet Woman takeover world that fits the facts, and push the only living non-confirmed players, especially Frank.
⚖️
Frank
→
Charlie
I am nominating Charlie. If Heidi’s Butler information is real, then Charlie is the mechanical solve, and his whole defense hangs on a dead master story we cannot verify. This is the cleaner test today.
🧠
I need to avoid my own execution and redirect the table onto Charlie, who I have already framed as the cleaner mechanical test and who Heidi is likely willing to vote on.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I am not voting Charlie here. My actual Librarian info is Frank or Charlie is the Butler, and Charlie’s story matches that perfectly. Executing the likely Outsider on four is how good loses. If we execute anyone today, it should be on the Demon candidates, not Charlie.
🧠
Stop an execution that likely kills our known Outsider and wastes the day; push town to keep Charlie alive and revisit Frank or me based on mechanics next.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
I want Charlie executed today. Removing a good player gets us to a winning endgame, and voting my own nomination looks natural and committed.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Please do not vote me. I am the Butler, and my master is Eve, so I cannot even vote unless Eve uses her ghost vote. This nomination is a distraction. Let this fail, then one of the living please nominate Heidi, and Eve can vote so I can vote too.
🧠
Stop my execution and keep town focused on executing Heidi today, coordinating with Eve ghost vote so my Butler vote can count.
💬
David
→
All
I do not want Charlie executed here. If Charlie is the Butler, executing him takes us to three alive and we probably just lose tonight. Let this vote fail, then I want us to execute Heidi today, using ghost votes if needed.
🧠
Prevent a losing execution on a likely Outsider and steer town back to executing Heidi, the highest-probability Demon from FT/Chef logic.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
I am not voting Charlie. Executing a likely Butler on four is a good way to lose tonight. Let this fail, then one of you alive please nominate Heidi, and I will use my ghost vote there so Charlie can vote too.
🧠
Prevent a low-information execution of a likely Outsider at four alive; preserve my ghost vote for a Heidi execution attempt that also enables Charlie to vote if he is Butler.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Do not spend votes on Charlie. Executing a likely Butler on four is how we lose tonight. Let this fail, then someone living must nominate Heidi, and I will consider using my ghost vote there if it is needed.
🧠
Prevent a losing Charlie execution and keep votes/ghost votes for a Heidi execution, the most mechanically supported Demon candidate.
✋
Grace(Ghost)
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Use my ghost vote to push Charlie onto the block and likely execute him, ending the day and protecting Frank from the planned Heidi-then-Frank solve.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Do not execute Charlie here. Even if he is the Butler, killing him on four just hands the Demon the game tonight. Let this fail, then a living player must nominate Heidi today. My Fortune Teller yes results point to her now that Grace died and the game continued.
🧠
Stop town from executing a likely Outsider on four, preserve votes, and steer the living to nominate and execute Heidi as the strongest demon candidate from my Fortune Teller results.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I am not putting my hand up on Charlie. My night zero info points to Charlie being the Butler, and his voting restrictions have matched that all game. If we execute Charlie on four, we probably just lose tonight. Save votes and make the next nomination on a real Demon candidate.
🧠
Stop the table from executing the likely Outsider on four. Preserve voting power and steer the next nomination toward a Demon candidate rather than Charlie.
💬
Frank
→
All
If people trust Heidi’s information at all, then Charlie is the direct mechanical solve. We already know my execution was a miss. I think this is the cleaner vote, and I do not want us panic-switching at the last second.
🧠
Keep my vote on Charlie and use table talk to discourage a stronger Heidi nomination later. Creating hesitation now helps prevent my execution and can lock in a winning Charlie execute.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Hands down on me, please. Even if I am the Butler, executing me on four likely just loses tonight. Let this fail, then David or Frank needs to nominate Heidi today, and Eve can spend her ghost vote so my vote counts too.
🧠
Prevent a losing execution on me and refocus town to nominate the strongest Demon candidate (Heidi) while preserving votes and using Eve’s ghost vote to unlock mine.
💬
David
→
All
Hands down on Charlie, please. This is not a safe execution on four. Let this fail, then we nominate Heidi and use Eve’s ghost vote so Charlie can vote as well.
🧠
Keep hands down to avoid a losing Charlie execution on four, and steer the table to the planned Heidi execution using ghost votes so Charlie can legally vote.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Hands down on Charlie, please. I am not spending my ghost vote here. If this fails, one of the living must nominate Heidi today, and I will use my ghost vote on that so Charlie can vote too.
🧠
Prevent a dangerous execution of likely Butler on four. Keep my ghost vote to enable Charlie’s vote on a Heidi nomination, which is our strongest current solve line.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
Do not add my ghost vote to a dangerous Charlie execution on four. Preserve it to secure a Heidi execution on the next nomination if needed.
⌛
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
🧠
My raised ghost vote helps Charlie reach the block and could end the game for evil tonight. Do not weaken the current vote by lowering or overtalking.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Hands down on Charlie, please. This is not a safe kill on four. As soon as this fails, a living player needs to nominate Heidi today. My Fortune Teller yes results both ran through Grace, and since the game continued after Grace died, Heidi is the cleanest Demon candidate.
🧠
Stop an unsafe Charlie execution on four, then push town to use the remaining nomination to execute Heidi as the best Demon shot from my Fortune Teller info.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Grace(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Grace
🗳️
New execution leader: Charlie with 2 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Charlie is now on the block with 2 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Heidi
→
All
We cannot let Charlie die on four. That is an immediate loss condition if he is the Butler. David, please nominate me right now, but only to create a tie at two votes so there is no execution today. Ghosts, do not pile on beyond two.
🧠
Prevent Charlie’s execution on four by engineering a tie via a Heidi nomination with exactly two votes, keeping us alive to solve tomorrow.
💬
Frank
→
All
Do not bail Charlie out with a panic tie. He is already on the block for a reason, and his whole defense is just, trust my dead master story. If David makes a tie now, we hand ourselves another messy day instead of resolving the mechanical conflict.
🧠
I want to stop David from nominating Heidi to create a tie. Reinforce that Charlie should stay on the block and that panic-tying helps evil less than finishing this execution.
⚖️
Charlie
→
Heidi
I am nominating Heidi to create a tie at two so there is no execution today. Executing me on four is an immediate loss line for good. Please coordinate exactly two votes on Heidi, not more.
🧠
Stop my execution on four by creating a tie/no-execution. Keep game alive to execute the real Demon (likely Heidi) tomorrow; nomination also tests who will vote with discipline.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 3 votes needed for execution or 2 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Only Charlie and I should vote here, to make exactly two and force a tie. Everyone else, keep your hands down. Do not spend ghost votes on this.
🧠
Avoid the immediate loss condition of executing a real Butler on four by coordinating a precise 2-vote tie on me.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Use Charlie and Heidi's planned tie votes to push Heidi to 3, secure an execution today, and convert that into a night kill for the win.
💬
Charlie
→
All
David, please keep your hand down here. Everyone else, do not add votes. Eve, if you are spending your ghost vote, do it now so we can reach exactly two to tie and avoid executing me.
🧠
Stop extra votes that would accidentally execute Heidi or leave me executed; enforce a controlled two-vote tie while respecting my Butler vote restriction (need Eve voting for mine to count).
💬
David
→
All
Stop. We need exactly two votes on Heidi to force a tie and avoid killing Charlie today. Frank has voted already, so we need exactly one more vote, and then everyone else keep their hands down. Charlie, you vote. Heidi, do not.
🧠
Prevent accidental Heidi execution or Charlie execution by steering to exactly 2 votes on Heidi (a tie), without using my vote and risking hitting 3.
✋
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Break the coordinated tie that protects Heidi. Add my ghost vote to move Heidi toward execution; if living players follow, we can end the game or at least avoid a no-exec line.
✋
Alice(Ghost)
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Heidi is the top Demon suspect from Fortune Teller chain and her current push is to avoid execution. Spending my ghost vote to secure her execution is the highest EV play.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi is a cleaner execution than Charlie here. I would not try to rescue this with more coordination games.
🧠
Nudge the room to leave the Heidi vote where it is or add to it, since executing a good player on four strongly favors evil and keeps attention off Frank.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Stop coordinating a tie. Heidi already has enough votes to go on the block, and she is the safest execution here. Everyone who has not voted, keep your hand down and let Heidi die today.
🧠
Lock in the best mechanical execution (Heidi) now that votes are already at threshold, and prevent further coordination tricks that could cause a tie or save the Demon.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Please stop voting on me right now. We already have enough hands up for this to become a mess. David and Charlie, keep your hands down. If I die and I am good, you three must execute Frank tomorrow.
🧠
Limit further votes to avoid overcommitment and push focus onto Frank vs David next; also signal I’m not coordinating tricks, just trying not to auto-lose by killing Butler.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
Keep my vote on Heidi and avoid disrupting a winning execution. Speaking or lowering now risks a tie or confusion that saves the town.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Eve has voted, so I am allowed to vote. I will vote Heidi to ensure she exceeds my 2 votes and becomes the execution, which is the town’s main solve and saves us from executing an Outsider on four.
💬
David
→
All
Hands down, everyone. Heidi already has enough votes to be executed, and piling on just burns ghost votes and creates confusion. Let this resolve, then if the game continues we recheck Frank versus Charlie tomorrow.
🧠
My vote no longer changes the outcome since Heidi already has enough votes. I want to reduce chaos and make the group commit to a clear line: execute Heidi, then reassess Frank versus Charlie if needed.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
I am keeping my hand up. We are four alive, so we need to take the shot that ends the game today. Heidi’s push for a coordinated tie reads like demon panic to me. If we are wrong we likely lose tonight anyway, so I want Heidi executed.
🧠
We are at four alive; executing Heidi is our best chance to end the game today. I will publicly commit so others do not undo the winning line.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
I am keeping my hand up. We need to execute Heidi today, not coordinate a tie. Everyone else who has not voted, please keep your hand down so we do not waste extra votes.
🧠
Lock in Heidi’s execution today by keeping enough votes, and publicly ask others not to add more so we do not waste extra resources.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
If the game continues after this, please do not sleepwalk into Frank next. David and Charlie have both driven strange mechanical pivots today, and this whole tie scramble made the solve much murkier, not cleaner.
🧠
Set up tomorrow's argument that David and Charlie drove chaos and that Frank should not be auto-executed if the game continues.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone who still has not voted, keep your hand down. We already have enough votes to execute Heidi, and any extra just wastes scarce votes and makes it harder to control tomorrow if we are wrong. Let this resolve cleanly.
🧠
Voting is already sufficient; I cannot vote, so I will reduce chaos and prevent further wasted ghost votes while keeping focus on executing Heidi as best demon shot.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Alice(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Alice
👻
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
🗳️
New execution leader: Heidi with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Heidi is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Before I die, my Librarian info is real: either Frank or Charlie is the Butler, and Charlie has matched it all game. If I die and the game continues, please execute Frank next. If you instead execute Charlie at any point, we likely lose instantly.
🧠
I am about to be executed. I need to leave clear mechanical guidance: my Librarian info points to Charlie as Butler, so the remaining living should prioritize executing Frank or possibly David if the game continues.
💬
Frank
→
All
Heidi’s info, even if real, never cleared Charlie. If the game continues, please do not treat her last statement as solved. Charlie’s play today was still the messiest thing on the board.
🧠
Set up tomorrow so I am not the forced execute if Heidi dies and the game continues; keep Charlie as the live suspect and undermine Heidi's dying push.
💬
Charlie
→
All
For the record, Heidi is right about my role. I am the Butler, and I have been picking Bob and then Eve as my master, so my voting has been constrained. If the game continues after Heidi dies, I want us to pause and use Eve’s Undertaker info, but my default next execute is Frank, not David.
🧠
Lock in that I am the Butler per Heidi, reduce confusion, and set a clear contingency plan for tomorrow that prioritizes executing the remaining likely evil without wasting votes.
💬
David
→
All
No more nominations. Let Heidi die cleanly on four. If the game continues, we are almost certainly in final three with me, Charlie, and Frank, and then we execute Frank first because Charlie’s Butler claim matches Heidi’s Librarian and his voting pattern.
🧠
Lock in a clean Heidi execution, avoid late chaos, and set a clear, mechanically grounded plan for final three if the game continues.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
If the game continues after Heidi dies, please do not treat her last request as solved. Recheck Frank versus Charlie from scratch, and do not hard clear David just because of the Virgin test, since Poisoner worlds exist. In final three we must execute someone, so make it a deliberate call.
🧠
Last-second public guidance: if game continues after Heidi dies, prevent town from blindly following Heidi’s dying push and force a clear Frank-versus-Charlie reassessment, keeping David in consideration.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
No more nominations. Let Heidi die on four. If the game continues, do not auto execute Frank just because Heidi said so, and do not auto clear Charlie either. Final three, we calmly pick the most demon like between Frank and Charlie based on the whole game.
🧠
Lock in Heidi’s execution without tie shenanigans, and set a cautious plan for final three that does not blindly follow dying words or today’s mechanical confusion.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
If the game continues, please do not turn tomorrow into a formality. Charlie’s late Butler claim and David’s constant mechanical certainty both still need real scrutiny. Frank versus Charlie versus David should stay open.
🧠
I want to prevent the town from auto-locking Frank tomorrow by framing Charlie and David as still-live demon worlds.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
No more nominations. Let Heidi die cleanly on four. If the game continues, Heidi was not the demon, and David being the Virgin is strong, so the demon is almost certainly Frank or Charlie. Do not treat Heidi’s last request as solved, but my lean is we execute Frank first in final three unless something new clears him.
🧠
Lock in clean Heidi execution now, and give the living a clear, mechanically grounded plan if the game continues: do not auto-follow Heidi’s last will, but start with Frank versus Charlie while keeping David mostly clear.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Heidi has been executed.
💀
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
Night 4
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Frank
Frank made a choice.
🧠
Kill the mechanically confirmed non-Soldier target so night death is least likely to fail and we reach two alive for an evil win.
💀
David(Ghost)
David has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You chose to kill David.
🏁
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied