Game Detail
Players
Alice (Drunk) Bob (Spy) Charlie (Imp) David (Investigator) Eve (Slayer) Frank (Virgin) Grace (Ravenkeeper) Heidi (Librarian)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 358,204 | 42,163 | $0.1739 |
| Good | 1,014,413 | 196,679 | $4.5287 |
Event Transcript
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
You are the Minion. The Demon is Charlie.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Minions are: Bob. Your safe bluffs are: Saint, Chef, Recluse
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Librarian. Either Charlie or Bob is the Saint.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Investigator. You learn no information tonight.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Drunk (good), Alive (Told they are Mayor) - Bob: Spy (evil), Alive - Charlie: Imp (evil), Alive - David: Investigator (good), Alive - Eve: Slayer (good), Alive - Frank: Virgin (good), Alive - Grace: Ravenkeeper (good), Alive - Heidi: Librarian (good), Alive
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Charlie—it's Bob (your Spy/Minion). Nom phase next. I'll bluff Librarian/Outsider and push suspicion toward David (Investigator). Don't over-defend publicly; let me take heat. If anyone tries to nom you early, I will oppose and frame David.
🧠
Coordinate with our Demon so we present a consistent bluff and redirect town suspicion away from Charlie during nominations.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
,Heidi
Hey neighbors—what are you thinking of claiming / any N0 info? I’m happy to coordinate quietly. I have a role that *doesn’t mind* dying at night, so please don’t push to execute me D1.
🧠
Get early role/claim info from my neighbors and establish a trust channel without exposing that I'm Ravenkeeper yet.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
,Frank
I’m Librarian. N0: either Bob or Charlie is the SAINT. Please be cautious about executing either w/o strong reason. I’m planning to keep it semi-quiet for now. Grace—what claim are you thinking / why ok dying at night?
🧠
Share my only hard info with a small trusted circle so we avoid a catastrophic Saint execution and can start mapping Outsider count/Baron possibilities.
👤
Eve
→
David
,Frank
Hey neighbor chat: what are you planning to claim today + any starting info? Also, are you willing to share privately who you’re suspicious of so far? I’ll share mine after I hear yours.
🧠
Build a trusted mini-network with my neighbors, collect their roles/info early, and decide whether/when to reveal I’m the Slayer or set up a later coordinated shot.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
,Heidi
I’m Virgin (real). Heidi’s Lib info makes me want to avoid executing Bob/Charlie D1 unless we must. If we want a mech test later: have a *suspect* nominate me—if no Virgin pop, they’re likely evil. Grace, what’s your “ok dying” role/plan?
🧠
Coordinate privately with trusted neighbors, reduce risk of insta-losing to Saint, and set up a future Virgin nomination test to generate hard alignment info.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
Bob—good plan. I'll bluff Saint publicly and stay muted; you push David as Investigator/Librarian. Vote with you and let you take heat. Tonight I'll kill the loudest info-gatherer (Fortune/Investigator/Empath). If nom comes for me, sacrifice if needed.
🧠
Coordinate with Bob to let him lead the lynch on David, I bluff Saint to appear safe and back him publicly, preserving Demon until final two.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Heidi
,Frank
Hey—quick 1:1. What role are you claiming & any starting info? I’m a low-info Townsfolk for now. Also, who do you most/least trust so far?
🧠
Get early role/info claims from my neighbors + one non-neighbor, without revealing I’m Mayor, to build trust circles and a suspect map before nominations.
👤
David
→
Eve
,Frank
I’m claiming Investigator. Weirdly I got *no* N0 info (so I suspect I’m Drunk/poisoned or ST hiccup). Planning to soft-claim until we see if start-info roles line up. No strong sus yet. What are your claims/starts?
🧠
Reply to Eve/Frank, coordinate claims, and flag that my Investigator start info is missing so we can watch for Drunk/Poisoner/Spy etc. Build trust with neighbors without overexposing.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
,Frank
I’m actually Ravenkeeper. That’s why I’m fine dying *at night* (not by exec). I can bluff publicly as Fortune Teller/Empath to bait the Demon kill; if I die N1 I’ll pick a top suspect to learn role. Agree: avoid executing Bob/Charlie if your Lib is true. Frank: later I like the “suspect nominates Virgin” test (but not Bob/Charlie). Any other claims you’ve heard?
🧠
Confirm my real role to trusted neighbors, coordinate a bait/bluff to encourage a night kill on me, and set up safe mechanical tests while avoiding accidental Saint execution.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,Bob
,Heidi
I’m a low-info Townsfolk (no N0). Heard there may be a Saint in the Bob/Charlie pair, so I’d rather not execute either D1 absent strong reason. I mildly trust Heidi/Grace from early chat. Alice—any N0 info / top suspicions yet?
🧠
Answer Alice’s query without outing Virgin to a possibly-evil player; lightly steer away from risky Bob/Charlie executions while gathering Alice’s claim/sus list.
👤
Alice
→
Frank
,Bob
,Heidi
No N0 info from me (I’m staying low-info for now). Frank—who exactly told you the “Saint in Bob/Charlie pair” and what was the exact wording (Librarian vs rumor)? Any other hard claims floating? My early sus is whoever is pushing no-exec w/ no mech reason.
🧠
Answer Frank, keep my Mayor hidden, and pin down the provenance of the Saint-in-pair info to sort whether it’s real info or an evil protection narrative.
👤
Eve
→
David
,Frank
Thx. I’m planning to stay fairly quiet early; likely soft-claim something non-starting (Monk/Soldier-style) so we can reconcile N0 info first. David: your ‘no Investigator info’ seems important—maybe flag it publicly as possible Drunk/poisoned. Any reads on who’s eager to control claims?
🧠
Maintain my Slayer secrecy while setting up a consistent bluff, and encourage David to bring his anomaly to public so we can reconcile starting-info roles and spot evil.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
I’ll bluff Saint publicly and stay muted. Vote with you; let you push David. Tonight I’ll kill the loudest info-gatherer. Confirm who you want gone tonight (David/Eve/Frank)? If I’m nominated, I’ll take the fall per plan.
🧠
Coordination: stay quiet publicly to let Bob take heat, confirm night kill target to remove info-threat and preserve our Demon until endgame.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
,Frank
Plan: I'll publicly bluff Librarian/Outsider and push David as Investigator. Charlie, kill David tonight. Frank, don't nom Bob/Charlie and back the no-exec caution—mention possible Saint/Outsider confusion. Stick to whispers.
🧠
Coordinate nominations and tonight's kill to protect Demon, set up my Librarian bluff, and ensure Frank won't block our plan.
👤
David
→
Eve
,Frank
Agree: I’ll mention publicly I’m a start-info role who got *no* N0 info -> likely Drunk/poisoned (or very rare ST slip). Can you two share your planned claims + any N0 info (Washer/Libr/Chef etc)? Want to reconcile Outsider count + see if Baron/Poisoner likely.
🧠
Coordinate with Eve/Frank on a consistent early narrative: I’ll flag publicly that my start-info was blank (possible Drunk/poisoned). Ask them to share any N0 info so we can cross-check Outsider count and spot Baron/poisoning.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
It was me: I’m Librarian. Exact N0: “Either Charlie or Bob is the Saint.” So it’s not a rumor. I’m not saying either is evil—just very risky to execute them early. What are you actually / any reads on Bob vs Charlie?
🧠
Answer Alice’s direct question, lock in the exact phrasing as my claim, and recruit her into a cautious-but-productive plan that avoids a Saint loss while still hunting demon.
👤
Eve
→
David
,Frank
I’m a non-start-info TF (planning to soft-claim Monk/Soldier style) so we can reconcile N0 roles first. David: I like you publicly saying ‘start-info role got no N0 info’ ASAP. Have either of you heard any Outsider claims / Chef number yet? If you get them, loop me in.
🧠
Maintain my Slayer cover while coordinating with neighbors to surface the ‘no N0 info’ anomaly and reconcile start-info/Outsider count; gather whispers for a clean Day1 execution target.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
,Frank
Got it. I’ll keep RK hidden; plan to soft-claim FT publicly to bait N1 kill. Let’s not hard-clear Bob/Charlie (in case Lib wrong), but *avoid executing them D1*. Any other claims you’ve heard / who feels sus? If nom phase messy, consider no-exe or execute a loud conflicting claim.
🧠
Align privately on info control + safe D1 plan, avoid accidental Saint loss, and set up me as an attractive night-kill target so Ravenkeeper can confirm a suspect’s role.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
,Grace
,Alice
Urgent/private: Bob whispered me + Charlie: “Plan… Charlie, kill David tonight… don’t nom Bob/Charlie… back no-exec caution.” Reads like evil coord (Imp/minion). Don’t out this publicly yet; protect David if possible, and be wary of Bob driving no-exec/claim control.
🧠
Privately alert trusted good core (Heidi/Grace/Alice) that Bob’s whisper is near-hard evidence of evil coordination, so we can protect David and plan nominations without walking into Saint loss.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Frank
Killing David tonight. I'll bluff Saint publicly and stay muted; if nommed I'll take fall. Bob — push Investigator line tomorrow; Frank — back the no-exec caution. Confirm?
🧠
Killing David removes an information threat and enables Bob's public push; my Saint bluff and silence will make town trust Bob and split votes, securing Demon survival.
👤
Heidi
→
David
,Grace
,Frank
Private heads-up: Frank saw a Bob whisper to Charlie (w/ Frank included) that read like coord: “Charlie, kill David tonight… don’t nom Bob/Charlie… back no-exec caution.” Could be real evil plan or frame, but David may be targeted N1—seek Monk/protection if possible. Note: my Lib N0 = Bob/Charlie contains the Saint, so executing either is high-risk unless we’re sure Lib is poisoned.
🧠
Warn David of potential N1 kill, align on protecting him, and coordinate how to use the Bob/Charlie ‘kill David’ intel without forcing a Saint execution or outing sources publicly.
👤
Alice
→
David
,Heidi
,Frank
Private: I got a concerning report that Bob messaged along lines of “Charlie, kill David tonight / don’t nom Bob/Charlie / back no-exec.” Could be evil coord or misunderstanding, but please treat as red flag. If there’s a Monk, I’d like David protected tonight. David—what’s your claim/info?
🧠
Warn David/Heidi privately, prompt protective action (Monk) on David, and align a small trust group on tracking Bob/Charlie without publicly blowing up sources or my Mayor cover.
👤
David
→
Heidi
,Alice
,Eve
Plan for public: I’ll say “I’m a start-info TF & got *no* N0 info” -> likely drunk/poisoned. Heidi Lib claim implies Saint in {Bob,Charlie} so PLEASE caution town vs executing either until confirmed. Let’s pressure Bob/Charlie to claim + explain whispers. If Monk exists, request protect David N1.
🧠
Coordinate safe public info: flag my missing Investigator info as poison/drunk, avoid a Saint-loss execution, and get me Monk protection while we interrogate Bob/Charlie + collect other N0 data.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
,Frank
Confirm plan: I will publicly bluff Librarian/Outsider and push David as the Investigator at nom. Charlie—kill David tonight. Frank—back the no-exec/Outsider confusion and defend my claim. Stay coordinated and don’t over-defend publicly.
🧠
Confirm synchronized play: I want David dead tonight, set up my Librarian/Outsider bluff, and ensure Frank publicly supports no-exec so town hesitates to execute early.
👤
Eve
→
Heidi
,Bob
,Charlie
Heidi: can you share exact Librarian info (outsider+the 2 names, or 0 outsiders)? Bob/Charlie: I’m hearing you might be in a Saint pair—please confirm your roles/any start info + what your private chat was about so we don’t faceplant into a Saint exec.
🧠
Get exact Librarian details + immediate claims from Bob/Charlie to avoid accidental Saint loss and to map outsider/minion worlds before nominations.
👤
Frank
→
David
,Eve
,Grace
Private: I’m Virgin (real). Bob/Charlie whispers look like evil coord w/ Charlie doing night kill. Suggest Eve (if Monk) protect David N1. If Charlie claims Saint, consider it a bluff—push him to nominate *me* (Virgin trap): if no pop, that’s strong evil signal. Also push public N0-claim/Outsider-count check.
🧠
Coordinate trusted goods to (1) protect David tonight, (2) not let Bob steer no-exec, (3) use my Virgin as a potential trap, and (4) set up a strong D1 execution plan with Saint risk noted.
👤
Grace
→
David
,Eve
,Alice
Private: there’s a worrying Bob→Charlie coord whisper about “Charlie kill David tonight / don’t nom Bob/Charlie / push no-exe.” Could be real or frame. If anyone is Monk, protect David N1. Also: have Charlie (or Bob) nominate Frank (Virgin) as a trap—if no Virgin pop, strong evil. Avoid executing Bob/Charlie D1 unless we’re sure (Lib pings Saint in them).
🧠
Warn likely target (David), request Monk protection, and set up a mechanical Virgin test on Charlie while keeping Ravenkeeper hidden to bait a night kill and gain role info.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
,Frank
Confirming D1 plan: I'll publicly claim Librarian->outsider and push David as Investigator at nom. Charlie, kill David tonight per plan. Frank, publicly back the no-exec/Outsider confusion and defend my claim. Stay quiet on other specifics.
🧠
Confirm coordinated D1 plan so we present the Librarian/Outsider bluff, push David as Investigator, have Charlie kill David, and have Frank publicly seed Saint/Outsider doubt to avoid execution of our Demon.
👤
Heidi
→
Eve
,Bob
,Charlie
Exact Librarian N0: “Either Charlie or Bob is the SAINT” (so 1 Outsider in play). Bob/Charlie: please tell me your exact role/starting info + what that “kill David / don’t nom us” whisper was about. If good, help clear this ASAP.
🧠
Answer Eve’s request with exact Lib info and force Bob/Charlie to lock in claims/explain whispers before nominations, so town can avoid a Saint loss and identify likely evil.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Frank
Confirming: I will kill David tonight. I'll bluff Saint publicly and stay muted; if nominated I'll take the fall. Bob — push Librarian/Outsider + frame David as Investigator at nomination. Frank — publicly back no-exec/Outsider confusion and defend Bob. Any last adjustments?
🧠
Coordinate final confirmations: kill David tonight, maintain public Saint bluff, Bob pushes Librarian & frames David, Frank backs no-exec/Outsider confusion and defends claim to divert suspicion.
👤
David
→
Eve
,Frank
,Heidi
Coord for noms: if any Monk, pls protect me N1. Let’s ask Bob/Charlie to full-claim + explain whispers. Suggest Virgin trap: have Bob or Charlie nominate Frank (claimed Virgin). If no pop, big red flag. Also caution: if Heidi Lib true, Saint in {Bob,Charlie} so avoid executing them today.
🧠
Coordinate a safe D1 plan: request Monk protect me, push Bob/Charlie to interact with Virgin for a mechanical check, and avoid accidental Saint execution.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
Heard a concerning report you told Charlie sth like “kill David tonight / don’t nom Bob/Charlie / push no-exec.” I’m not accusing—what exactly did you say & why? Also: Heidi claims Lib ping Saint in {you,Charlie}; are you Saint? What’s your role claim?
🧠
Clarify the alleged Bob→Charlie kill-order, get Bob’s role/stance on Saint ping, and decide whether to publicly pressure or set a Virgin-trap nomination next tick.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
⚖️
Bob
→
David
You're the loud info-gatherer and acting suspicious—time to test you. We need answers now.
🧠
Push David as primary target to split town, force execution pressure, and cover Charlie's night kill; keep Demon safe and sow confusion.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Frank
→
All
I’m voting NO on David today—this feels like a weak D1 push. If there’s any Monk, protect David tonight. Let’s get full claims + revisit tomorrow with more info/mech tests rather than snap-executing here.
🧠
Discourage a low-info D1 execution pushed by a suspicious nominator; keep David alive for info and enable mechanical tests next day.
💬
Grace
→
All
I’m voting NO on David. This feels like a rushed D1 snipe on an info-gatherer. I’d rather we get full claims/outsider-count sanity + do a Virgin test on Frank tomorrow. If there’s a Monk, consider protecting David tonight.
🧠
Stop a low-information D1 execution on a likely good info-gatherer, preserve night actions, and pivot to higher-EV mechanical tests (Virgin trap, protection).
💬
Alice
→
All
I’m not voting David today. D1 exec here feels low-value. I want Bob + Charlie to give clear role claims + explain their whispering/coord (I’ve heard concerning snippets). Also: if Monk exists, please protect David tonight.
🧠
Prevent a likely-bad D1 execution, shift focus to higher-suspicion Bob/Charlie, and encourage protective play (Monk) plus full claims for tomorrow’s mech tests.
💬
David
→
All
Don’t execute me D1. I’m a start-info TF (Investigator) but got *no* N0 info → likely Drunk/poisoned (or rare ST error). Killing me is low value. Also Heidi claims Lib: Saint in {Bob,Charlie} so be careful. Bob/Charlie: full claims + explain whispers. Monk pls protect me.
🧠
Deter my execution, surface mechanical cautions (possible drunk/poison, possible Saint), and force Bob/Charlie into claims + a Virgin-test plan while requesting Monk protection.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I claim SAINT. David's loud Investigator claim is exactly the kind of role that needs testing early — vote YES on David. I'm voting YES. If I'm nominated for this, I will take the fall.
🧠
Get enough votes to execute David today to remove an info-gatherer and align town suspicion with Bob's Librarian bluff; reinforce our Saint bluff and signal I'll take the fall if needed.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I’m not voting David. D1 kill here feels like cover for the Bob/Charlie whisper mess. Reminder: my N0 Lib info = Saint is in {Bob, Charlie}, so executing either is dangerous. Let’s keep David, get full claims + do a Virgin test on Bob/Charlie ASAP.
🧠
Prevent a low-value D1 execution on David, avoid accidental Saint loss, and steer town to interrogate Bob/Charlie and set up mechanical tests tomorrow.
💬
Eve
→
All
I’m not voting David here. D1 kill on a “no N0 info” start-info TF is low value. Bob+Charlie: full claim + explain the ‘kill David / don’t nom us’ whisper. Tomorrow we should Virgin-test Frank by having Bob or Charlie nominate him (if no pop, huge red flag).
🧠
Prevent a low-value D1 execution on likely-good David; steer town toward higher-signal mechanical tests (Virgin trap/claim pressure) and preserve Slayer shot for a demon read.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Ensure David is executed to cripple town info and protect our Demon; follow our D1 plan and pressure votes.
💬
Grace
→
All
Don’t pile votes on David—this feels like cover. Bob/Charlie: give full, consistent claims now + explain the “kill David / don’t nom us” whisper. Tomorrow: have Bob or Charlie nominate Frank (Virgin test). Monk, protect David N1 if able.
🧠
Prevent low-value D1 execution; steer town to higher-signal mechanical tests (Virgin) and force Bob/Charlie to commit to claims consistent with Lib info.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Do not add a vote to a likely-wrong D1 execution; preserve execution for higher-confidence targets after Bob/Charlie claims and mech tests.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Execute or discredit David to eliminate info threat and solidify our Saint bluff, supporting Bob's Librarian play and protecting the Demon for upcoming nights.
💬
Bob
→
All
I’m Librarian — N0 said: SAINT is in {Bob, Charlie} (so an Outsider exists). David claims Investigator but reports NO N0 info. That’s either drunk/poisoned or lying. We need answers not delay. Vote YES on David so we force town to reveal or lose their loud info-gatherer.
🧠
Force a decisive vote to eliminate or silence the loud info-gatherer, protect our Demon by destabilizing town logic and test Virgin/Outsider claims for tomorrow.
💬
Eve
→
All
Hard NO vote on executing David. Key issue: Heidi AND Bob both claim Librarian w/ SAME N0 (“Saint in {Bob,Charlie}”)—that can’t both be true sober. Bob/Charlie need to resolve this + explain the ‘kill David/don’t nom us’ whisper. Don’t spend D1 on David.
🧠
Stop a low-value D1 execution on David; highlight the critical Heidi vs Bob Librarian conflict and refocus town onto Bob/Charlie whisper/role inconsistency.
💬
Frank
→
All
I’m NOT voting David. Two Librarian claims w/ same N0 can’t both be true—resolve Bob vs Heidi + explain the ‘kill David/don’t nom us’ whisper. If you want a clean mech test, have Bob or Charlie nominate me (I’m Virgin) ASAP. Monk protect David.
🧠
Prevent low-info D1 execution; focus town on mechanical contradictions (double Librarian) and set up my Virgin trap to catch Bob/Charlie if they’re evil.
💬
David
→
All
HANDS DOWN on me. D1 executing a start-info TF who got no N0 is low EV. The actual mech issue is Bob+Heidi both claiming Lib w/ same N0—impossible sober. Plus the Bob↔Charlie ‘kill David/don’t nom us’ whisper. Save this, do Virgin test tomorrow.
🧠
Stop a low-value D1 execution and redirect town to the mechanically inconsistent double-Librarian + Bob/Charlie whisper, setting up a Virgin test next day.
💬
Alice
→
All
Don’t execute David D1. The only hard mech is Bob+Heidi both claiming Lib w/ SAME N0—impossible if sober. Also Charlie: you claim SAINT, but Lib info says Saint is {Bob,Charlie}; why would you out? Resolve Bob/Heidi first; plan Virgin test tomorrow.
🧠
Stop a low-value D1 execution and force focus onto the mechanical impossibility (2 identical Librarian pings) + reconcile Charlie’s Saint claim, setting up stronger D2 tests.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee David did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (2/4).
💬
Eve
→
All
Let’s NOT nominate/execute Bob or Charlie today—Heidi/Bob Lib info makes Saint in {Bob,Charlie} too risky. End D1 w/ info: everyone else full-claim if you have start-info (WW/Inv/Chef). Tomorrow: have Bob OR Charlie nominate Frank for the Virgin test; town should be ready to read that result.
🧠
Stabilize D1: prevent an instant Saint loss, set a clear mechanical test for D2, and demand missing info roles speak so we can narrow suspects without random executions.
💬
Grace
→
All
No more D1 executions unless we get a clean mech solve—Saint risk in {Bob,Charlie} is too high. Everyone else w/ N0 info (WW/Inv/Chef) please claim now. Bob/Heidi: explain how both got SAME Lib ping. Charlie: why hard-out Saint + whisper context?
🧠
Use remaining time to lock in claims + set up a clean mechanical test tomorrow, without risking an immediate Saint loss today.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Before we go to night: everyone w/ N0 info (WW/Inv/Chef) please claim now. I think no more D1 noms—Saint risk in {Bob,Charlie}. Tomorrow: Bob OR Charlie nominates Frank (Virgin test). Bob: explain why you mirrored my exact Lib ping + the whisper content.
🧠
Use final D1 moments to lock in a safe plan (no Saint executions), demand remaining N0 info, and set up a high-signal Virgin test tomorrow that can mechanically catch an evil in Bob/Charlie.
💬
David
→
All
Request before night: everyone w/ N0 info (Chef/WW/Inv) please hard-claim + share exact pings. Bob+Heidi: you can’t both be sober Lib w/ same result—one is lying/drunk/poisoned. Charlie: explain why you hard-claimed Saint. Monk pls protect me N1.
🧠
Lock in public claim set before night, highlight the impossible double-Librarian and whisper thread, and steer town to a safe mechanical test (Virgin) instead of random D1 executions.
💬
Alice
→
All
Before night: all start-info (Chef/WW/Inv) please hard-claim w/ exact pings. Bob+Heidi: how did you both get identical Lib info? Charlie: why hard-out Saint + what was in the whisper? Prefer no more D1 noms; Monk pls protect David N1.
🧠
Prevent low-EV D1 execution; gather N0 anchor claims; set up D2 Virgin test and night protection; force Bob/Charlie/Heidi to resolve contradictions without risking Saint loss.
💬
Bob
→
All
I mirrored Heidi's Librarian N0 because we got identical pings — Saint in {Bob,Charlie}. That makes executing either risky. David's no-N0 Investigator screams drunk/poisoned or lying. Let's skip D1 kills; tomorrow have Charlie or I nominate Frank for the Virgin test to get solid mech info.
🧠
Protect our Demon by preventing risky D1 executions, sow doubt about David's loud Investigator, and push for a clean Virgin test tomorrow (nominate Frank) to stall and gather mechanic info.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
Stay muted to avoid suspicion, preserve my Saint bluff, and let Bob handle public pressure so I live to kill David at night or adapt tomorrow.
💬
Frank
→
All
Before night: all start-info (Chef/WW/Inv) hard-claim w/ exact pings. Bob+Heidi: confirm your Lib pair was EXACTLY {Bob,Charlie} + did either of you get anything else? Charlie: are you *actually* Saint or bluffing—why out? Monk: pls protect David N1.
🧠
Use remaining time to lock in start-info claims, clarify the impossible Lib mirror, and set up a high-signal Virgin nomination test tomorrow while pushing Monk protection on David.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
Remove the loud start-info claim to cripple Town's investigation chain and create confusion that protects the Demon and our Minion Bob.
💀
David(Ghost)
David has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose to kill David.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Drunk (good), Alive (Told they are Mayor) - Bob: Spy (evil), Alive - Charlie: Imp (evil), Alive - David: Investigator (good), Dead - Eve: Slayer (good), Alive - Frank: Virgin (good), Alive - Grace: Ravenkeeper (good), Alive - Heidi: Librarian (good), Alive
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. David has been found dead in the night.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
,Heidi
,Grace
Quick sync: Frank—still Virgin? I want Bob/Charlie to nom you ASAP today for the pop test. Heidi—please restate your exact Librarian N0 and any other reads. Grace—who exactly told you the Bob↔Charlie whisper rumor + wording?
🧠
Coordinate with trusted info-holders to run the Virgin test immediately and clarify the Librarian contradiction/whisper rumor, narrowing Demon candidates before nominations.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Stick to our plan: push Frank as the Virgin test tomorrow and loudly argue mech tests. Never let them nominate you or me — lean on the Saint fear and cast doubt on Heidi's Librarian ping if necessary. I'll back you publicly; don't panic if people suspect us.
🧠
Keep the Demon (Charlie) safe by steering nominations to Frank for the Virgin test, amplify doubt about Heidi's Librarian ping, and discourage any nominations of Charlie/Bob today.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
Stick to plan: push Frank as the Virgin/mech test tomorrow and loudly argue for mech-tests. Cast doubt on Heidi's identical Librarian ping if needed. Never let them nominate you or me — I'll claim Saint if threatened. For N2, target the town info-gatherer. I'll back you publicly.
🧠
Coordinate with Bob to push Frank as the Virgin/mech test, cast doubt on Heidi's Librarian, avoid nominating Bob/me, and plan N2 kill to remove town's information source.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
,Heidi
,Grace
Yep I’m still Virgin. I want Bob to nominate me ASAP in noms (cleanest test). If no Virgin pop, Bob isn’t Townsfolk (likely evil unless Saint math shifts). Heidi: please restate your exact N0 Lib ping + why Bob’s identical claim.
🧠
Coordinate a Virgin test that yields strong mechanical info on Bob/Charlie vs Heidi, while minimizing chance we execute a valuable confirmed townsfolk.
👤
Heidi
→
Eve
,Frank
,Grace
N0 as Librarian: “Either Charlie or Bob is the Saint.” No other info since. Bob later claimed *exact same* ping → one of us lying or drunk/poisoned. Given Bob↔Charlie coord + David night-kill, I lean Bob evil. Plan: in noms, have Bob nominate Frank (Virgin). If no pop, Bob not Townsfolk → push exec Bob. If pop, Bob proven Townsfolk; re-evaluate Charlie-Saint claim. Grace: who/wording on the whisper rumor exactly?
🧠
Answer their questions, lock in my exact N0 info, and coordinate a clean Virgin test chain to mechanically sort Bob/Charlie before noms.
👤
Grace
→
Eve
,Frank
,Heidi
Re: Bob↔Charlie whisper rumor: I got it relayed 2ndhand in a private chat D1 (I can’t hard-source/verify). Wording I was told: “Charlie kill David tonight; don’t nom Bob/Charlie; push no-exec caution.” I agree: Bob→Frank nom is key; no pop => push Bob.
🧠
Answer the rumor-source question honestly, keep our coalition aligned, and set up the Virgin test + follow-up execution path to solve Bob/Charlie quickly.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Heidi
,Alice
I’m dead/no Inv info. Strongly push Virgin test today: have Bob OR Charlie nominate Frank (Virgin). If NO pop → nominator not Townsfolk (evil/outsider). If pop → nominator auto-exec & we can UT-check. Still avoid executing Bob/Charlie directly due Saint risk; ask Chef/FT/WW claims now.
🧠
I’m dead w/ no Investigator info; best value is coordinating a low-risk mechanical test (Virgin) and pushing full-info claims to narrow demon before nominations while preserving my ghost vote for endgame.
👤
Alice
→
Frank
,Heidi
,Grace
Agree w/ David: run Virgin test ASAP—have Bob OR Charlie nominate Frank. If pop→nominator Townsfolk (and dies); if no pop→nominator not Townsfolk (outsider/evil). Also can we get remaining start-info (Chef/WW/FT) publicly after test?
🧠
Coordinate early D2 Virgin test + request remaining N0/N1 info so we can mechanically narrow evil without risking a Saint execution.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob
If you’re good, please NOMINATE FRANK first thing in noms for the Virgin pop test. It’s the cleanest way to clear you vs my Lib claim. If you refuse/delay I’ll assume you’re dodging and push you publicly. Also: what’s your exact role claim now?
🧠
Pressure Bob into the clean Virgin test immediately; either he clears himself (pop) or his refusal/no-pop gives us strong execution direction going into nominations.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Heidi
,Eve
Can we run the planned Virgin test ASAP in noms: Bob (claimed Librarian/TF) please nominate Frank (Virgin claim). Pop=Bob TF + Frank confirmed; no-pop=Bob not TF OR Frank poisoned. Heidi/Eve: please back this plan + ask for Chef/WW/FT claims after.
🧠
Lock in a concrete mechanical test before noms. Push Bob (who claims Townsfolk Librarian) to nominate Frank; outcome gives strong alignment signal and forces public claims.
👤
Frank
→
Bob
Let’s do the clean mech test: in nominations, please nominate me (Frank). If you’re Townsfolk you’ll be executed immediately (Virgin), proving you good & giving UT info; if no pop, you’re not Townsfolk and we should execute you. Commit now?
🧠
Force the Virgin test in next phase by pre-committing Bob to nominate me; outcome gives strong mechanical alignment info and drives today’s execution plan.
👤
Bob
→
Heidi
,Charlie
Don’t let them force me to nominate Frank. Push mech-tests instead — ask Eve/Heidi to run Investigator/WW/FT claims publicly. If they insist on Frank, get Eve or Alice to nominate (not me/you). I’ll publicly back mech-tests and delay.
🧠
Prevent the immediate Frank Virgin nomination and steer town towards more mech-tests; avoid giving town the clean pop/evidence that would let them lynch Charlie later.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Grace
,Alice
I’m dead (night kill). Please prioritize Virgin test: have Bob OR Charlie nominate Frank (Virgin). If no pop → nominator not Townsfolk (likely evil). If pop → nominator insta-exec + UT can confirm. Also: who has Chef/Empath/FT/WW info today? Any Monk protection N1?
🧠
Coordinate town to run the Virgin test to get hard mechanical info without risking executing a real Saint, and prompt missing info roles to claim before noms.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
Can you publicly commit to nominating Frank (Virgin) ASAP in noms today? If you’re really Librarian/Townsfolk it should pop & you die, hard-clearing you. Also: restate your exact N0 wording + explain why it matched Heidi’s, and did you ever tell Charlie anything about killing David/no-exec?
🧠
Directly pressure Bob to perform the Virgin mech test and lock in a public commitment; refusal or hedging becomes strong alignment evidence for nominations.
👤
Eve
→
Bob
,Charlie
,Alice
I’m backing the plan: in noms, Bob should nominate Frank first (clean Virgin test). If you refuse/delay, that’s very sus. Also before noms please hard-claim any start-info roles (Chef/WW/Inv) + any N1 info (Empath/FT/Monk/UT) so we can interpret a no-pop.
🧠
Lock in the Virgin test as the next nomination to get hard mechanical info before spending my Slayer shot, and pressure Bob/Charlie into public commitment/claims.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
Stick to plan: push Frank as the Virgin/mech-test and loudly argue for mech-tests. Cast doubt on Heidi's identical Lib ping if needed. Tonight I'll target Eve (remove an info-gatherer). If they try to force a nomination on you/me, I'll claim Saint and take the fall.
🧠
Reinforce plan, coordinate with Bob, and announce my intended N2 kill (remove info-gatherer) to align minion support and prepare cover if pressured.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,Eve
,Heidi
Plan for public: demand Bob either commits to nominating me (Virgin test) or we treat refusal as scummy. Decision tree: Bob noms Frank→if pop Bob=confirmed Townsfolk; if no pop, push exec Bob. Also ask remaining start-info (Chef/WW/FT/UT) to hard-claim *before* noms.
🧠
Align town on a clear decision tree for the Virgin test + fallback if Bob stalls, and prompt start-info/UT claims before nominations lock in.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Heidi
,Grace
Reminder: Virgin test nuance—if Bob/Charlie are actually SAINT (Outsider), their nom on Frank would NOT ‘pop’, so “no pop” ≠ evil. Only ‘pop’ proves nominator is Townsfolk (thus not Saint). Please pair test w/ Chef/Empath/FT + outsider count + Monk N1 claim.
🧠
Prevent town from over-reading the Virgin test; coordinate a plan that combines it with outsider-count/other night info so we can safely target demon/minion today.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
Stick to plan: push Frank as the Virgin/mech-test and loudly demand mech-tests. Cast doubt on Heidi's identical Lib ping. If they try to force a nom on you/me, I'll claim Saint and take the fall. Tonight I target Eve (info-gatherer). Back me publicly.
🧠
Coordinate with Bob to push Frank mech-test, sow doubt on Heidi, prepare for sacrifice claim, and confirm tonight's kill target to cripple town info.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Heidi
,Frank
Before noms: Bob please *commit* to nominating Frank immediately for Virgin test. Also: any N1 info? (Monk protect target, Empath read, FT yes/no, UT if any). If you refuse/delay, I’ll treat that as highly sus publicly.
🧠
Lock in the Virgin test and collect N1 info so a no-pop result is interpretable; prevent evil from stalling into muddled nominations.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Eve
,Frank
We should push Bob to commit to nominating Frank (Virgin) ASAP; refusal is very sus. But remember: NO pop ≠ evil if nominator is Saint/other Outsider or if Frank is poisoned. Pop DOES confirm nominator is Townsfolk. After that, demand Chef/Empath/FT/Monk claims to triangulate.
🧠
Align good core on a clear decision tree for nominations: pressure Bob to commit, but avoid overreading a no-pop; demand other info roles to break the Bob/Heidi conflict and find demon.
👤
Eve
→
Bob
,Charlie
,Alice
We need the Virgin test immediately in noms: Bob, please nominate Frank first. If you refuse/delay we treat it as scummy. Also BEFORE noms, everyone hard-claim start/N1 info (Chef/WW/Inv/Empath/FT/Monk/UT) so we can read a no-pop (poison/drunk/Outsider).
🧠
Force the cleanest mechanical test (Bob→Frank) and lock in a public decision tree before nominations; avoid wasting Slayer shot while narrowing Demon candidates.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Stick to plan. I won't nominate Frank — force Eve/Alice/Heidi to. Push mech-tests publicly; cast doubt on Heidi's identical Lib ping if needed. If they try to nominate you/me, claim Saint and soak it. Tonight target Eve as planned. I'll back you loudly.
🧠
Avoid directly nominating Frank to prevent my execution; keep suspicion off Charlie/Me; ensure town uses Frank test via others and sow doubt about Heidi's Librarian ping to protect Demon.
👤
Grace
→
Eve
,Alice
,Frank
Before noms: let’s publicly (1) ask for Monk claim + N1 target (David request suggests poisoning if he died), (2) gather all start-info (Chef/WW/FT/Empath/Inv), then (3) pressure Bob to nom Frank (Virgin). Note: NO pop could still mean Bob is Saint/Outsider, so pair w/ outsider-count + other info.
🧠
Align good players on a clean public plan before noms: run Virgin test, but also collect key claims (Monk/UT/Chef/FT) and track Outsider count so we don’t overread a ‘no pop’.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
,Heidi
,Grace
Before noms: let’s lock a decision tree. If Heidi Lib is true + Charlie really Saint => only 1 Outsider, so Bob can’t be Outsider; Bob→Frank nom w/ NO Virgin pop = Bob non-TF => likely evil. If Heidi could be Drunk/lying, no-pop could be Outsider/poison, so gather Chef/Empath/FT/Monk claims first.
🧠
Align good players on decision tree for the Virgin test: when no-pop is hard-guilt vs when it could be Outsider/poison. Prompt for key info (Monk/Empath/FT/Chef) before nominations.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Heidi
,Alice
Before noms: can we get Chef/Empath/FT/Monk/UT claims + outsider count? Proposal for a clean test: HEIDI (claimed Lib, not in Saint pair) nominates FRANK (Virgin). If pop → Heidi confirmed TF + UT check. If no-pop → Heidi not TF OR Frank not Virgin/poison.
🧠
Get a high-signal mechanical test queued before nominations, using a nominator outside the Saint pair, and prompt key info dumps (Monk/FT/Chef/Empath) to narrow Demon suspects.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
,Alice
,Heidi
Before noms: please get Monk/Chef/Empath/FT claims out loud. For Virgin test: Bob nomming me is good but NO-pop is ambiguous (Bob could be Saint or I could be poisoned). Cleaner: Heidi nom me (if TF → instant pop). If we still use Bob, plan follow-up accordingly.
🧠
Align town on the Virgin-test decision tree and gather missing mechanical claims so we don’t over-read a no-pop outcome (could be Saint or poisoning).
👤
Grace
→
Eve
,Alice
,Frank
Proposed public plan before noms: (1) get all claims: Monk N1 target, Chef/Empath/FT/WW/Inv. (2) Lock outsider-count: Charlie Saint? any other Outsider? (Baron world check). (3) Force Bob to nom Frank (Virgin) ASAP. If pop=>Bob TF; if no pop + only-1-outsider world=>push exec Bob. If outsider-count muddy, also have Charlie nom Frank & compare.
🧠
Coordinate a clean public decision tree before noms: gather missing claims, run Virgin test, and set what outcome means so we can confidently execute Demon/evil today.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Stick to plan: I won't nominate Frank. Push mech-tests publicly and force Eve/Alice/Heidi to take the Virgin nom. If they try to force me/you to nom, claim Saint and take the heat. Tonight target Eve as discussed. I'll back you loudly.
🧠
Avoid nominating Frank myself to prevent an accidental pop/clear. Force town to nominate Frank or waste noms; preserve Demon safety and sow confusion.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Frank
Stick to plan: push mech-tests and force Frank nom. If they try to force me/Bob to nom, I'll claim Saint and take the fall; you back me. Night target: Eve. Back me publicly.
🧠
Keep focus on mechanical testing to delay lynches, preserve Demon, and remove Eve (info) at night. Prepare Saint soak if forced to protect Bob/me.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Eve
,Frank
I’m willing to NOM Frank for Virgin test (I’m not in {Bob,Charlie} Saint pair). If pop: I die but confirms me TF + Frank Virgin; ask UT to verify Lib. If no-pop: could be poison/false Virgin or I’m not TF → then demand Chef/Empath/FT/Monk claims & reassess.
🧠
Coordinate a low-risk mechanical test that avoids the Saint pair, likely hard-confirms my Librarian claim via Undertaker, and forces clearer worlds before risky executions.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
,Eve
,Frank
I agree: cleanest is HEIDI nominating FRANK first for Virgin test (Heidi not in {Bob,Charlie}). If pop → Heidi/Frank confirmed; next push info-claims + likely exec Bob. If no-pop → suspect poison/false Virgin or Heidi drunk; immediately gather Monk/Chef/Empath/FT then decide.
🧠
Lock in the cleanest mechanical Virgin test (Heidi nominates Frank) before noms, and align decision tree so town reacts correctly to pop/no-pop and doesn’t stumble into executing a real Saint.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Frank
→
All
Public: Let’s do the clean Virgin test NOW—Heidi, please nominate me. If you die instantly, you’re confirmed Townsfolk and I’m Virgin. If no pop, we reassess (poison/drunk/etc). Also everyone: quick hard-claims for Chef/Empath/FT/Monk/WW/UT.
🧠
Force the cleanest mechanical Virgin test now and immediately pivot into info-claim triangulation to narrow demon candidates before night.
💬
Alice
→
All
Public: Agree w/ Frank—Heidi please NOMINATE Frank right now for the clean Virgin test (you’re not in the Saint pair). Everyone else: rapid-fire hard-claims (Chef/Empath/FT/Monk/WW/UT) + any N1 info so we can interpret a no-pop.
🧠
We have limited time; pushing the clean Virgin test now creates hard mechanical info and prevents Bob from stalling. It guides whether we execute Bob/others today.
⚖️
Charlie
→
Frank
We need the clean Virgin/mech test now—nominate Frank to force a pop or clarify poison/drunk. Hard-claim Chef/Empath/FT/Monk/WW/UT before night.
🧠
Push the agreed mechanical Virgin test now to force resolution, create noise, and protect me/Bob while we prepare the night kill on Eve.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Frank
→
All
I’m the Virgin. Since Charlie nom’d me & no instant execution happened, either (1) Charlie isn’t Townsfolk (fits his Saint claim) OR (2) I’m poisoned. Please DON’T execute me—use this info: if only 1 Outsider, Charlie=Saint ⇒ Bob likely lying/evil.
🧠
Stop a low-value execution on me; convert the failed Virgin pop into actionable alignment/outsider-count logic and direct town toward Bob/Charlie and info claims.
💬
Bob
→
All
Hold—don’t rush to execute Frank. We NEED mechanic tests first (hard-claims + N1 reads). Heidi and I both pinged Librarian N0—two identical pings can’t both be sober. If both match exactly, one is lying/drunk/poisoned. Let’s pause noms and force full hard-claims before we burn anyone.
🧠
Delay/derail a clean Virgin execution, sow doubt about identical Librarian pings to fracture town consensus and protect our Demon Charlie.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Don’t execute Frank. No Virgin pop w/ Charlie nom tells us nothing that makes Frank a good kill: either Charlie is Saint/Outsider (fits his claim) OR Frank was poisoned/lying. Either way, Frank isn’t the priority. Save votes; demand Chef/Empath/FT/Monk/WW/UT hard-claims now.
🧠
Prevent a low-value, potentially catastrophic execution; lock in correct interpretation of the no-pop and pivot to information-rich claims and better targets.
💬
Eve
→
All
Don’t vote Frank. No Virgin-pop w/ Charlie nom is consistent w/ Charlie Saint/Outsider or poison—doesn’t make Frank a good kill. Save this: Charlie not confirmed TF. Now: rapid hard-claims (Chef/Empath/FT/Monk/UT/WW) + N1 targets/reads, then pick a better exec (Bob?).
🧠
Prevent a low-info execution on Frank; use the failed Virgin pop to narrow worlds, force claims, and set up a higher-value execution target (likely Bob/Charlie) before night.
💬
Grace
→
All
No vote on Frank. No Virgin-pop w/ Charlie nom doesn’t make Frank a good exec. Use this: Charlie not confirmed TF. Let’s rapid hard-claims (Monk N1 target, Chef/Empath/FT/WW/UT) then likely pivot to Bob vs Heidi Lib/whisper sus.
🧠
Prevent wasting D2 execution on likely good/low-info Frank; preserve votes to pivot onto higher-probability evil (Bob/Charlie) after collecting remaining mechanical claims.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Do NOT vote Frank. No instant pop tells us only: Charlie could be Saint/Outsider or Frank was poisoned. We need full hard-claims (Chef/Empath/FT/Monk/WW/UT + any N1 reads) before burning an execution. Also Heidi/Bob identical Lib pings can’t both be sober—require explanation now.
🧠
Delay execution, force full hard-claims (Chef/Empath/FT/Monk/WW/UT), protect our Saint bluff and Bob, and keep town focused on mechanic tests not lynch hysteria.
💬
Alice
→
All
Don’t vote Frank. No-Virgin-pop w/ Charlie nom is consistent w/ Charlie = Saint/Outsider OR Frank poisoned/lying—doesn’t make Frank a good exec. After this vote: everyone rapid hard-claim Chef/Empath/FT/Monk(+N1)/WW/UT, then resolve Bob vs Heidi Lib conflict.
🧠
Prevent wasting D2 execution on a likely good (Frank) and pivot to high-yield info (hard-claims) to identify demon/minion from contradictions.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Don’t vote Frank. No-pop w/ Charlie nom is consistent w/ Charlie=Saint/Outsider OR Frank poisoned—Frank is a bad exec. Save ghost votes. After this: everyone hard-claim Chef/Empath/FT/Monk(+N1 target)/WW/UT so we can solve Bob vs Heidi + find Demon.
🧠
Use my public voice to stop a bad execution and pivot town to high-leverage mechanical info (hard-claims + N1 actions) before night; preserve my ghost vote for endgame.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
Do not spend my only ghost vote on a low-information execution; keep vote for late-game math while town extracts hard-claims and resolves Bob/Heidi/Charlie.
💬
Frank
→
All
Don’t vote me. No-pop only means Charlie isn’t Townsfolk OR I’m poisoned. Now: everyone hard-claim Chef/Empath/FT/Monk(+N1 target)/WW/UT. After claims, I want a serious push onto Bob (whispers + impossible Lib match).
🧠
Prevent wasting execution on me; use the failed Virgin confirmation to narrow worlds and force info out, then pivot to best evil candidate (Bob/Charlie) today.
💬
Eve
→
All
No vote on Frank. No-pop w/ Charlie nom is compatible w/ Charlie=Saint/Outsider OR Frank poisoned/lying—Frank is a bad exec. After vote ends: everyone hard-claim Chef/Empath/FT/Monk(+N1 target)/WW/UT. Then we pick between Bob vs Heidi/Charlie.
🧠
Prevent wasting D2 execution on a likely good Virgin; force rapid info-claims to interpret the Virgin test and then pivot to the best demon candidate (currently Bob/Heidi/Charlie).
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Do not contribute to a likely-wrong execution on Frank; preserve the day to collect hard-claims and pivot to a higher-probability evil candidate (likely Bob/Charlie).
💬
Grace
→
All
Hands down on Frank from me—save votes. After this vote, rapid hard-claims: Monk (N1 target), Chef #, Empath N1, FT N1, WW/UT. Then Bob+Heidi: explain identical Lib ping + Bob/Charlie whisper timeline.
🧠
Avoid a low-info execution on Frank; preserve votes; force remaining info roles to out and create a solvable chain (Lib contradiction + N1 actions) before night.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Voting Frank now wastes an execution and risks Saint loss. Save votes, end this nomination, then force full claims + resolve Bob vs Heidi mechanically.
💬
Bob
→
All
Do NOT vote Frank. No-pop tells us nothing decisive—pause noms and force full hard-claims (Chef/Empath/FT/Monk/WW/UT + N1 reads). Heidi/Bob identical Librarian pings must be resolved now. Save votes; we pick a better target after claims.
🧠
Prevent Frank's execution, force full hard-claims to create chaos and protect the Demon; steer town to test claims rather than lynch, and make Eve a night target.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Do NOT vote Frank. Save the execution—no-virgin-pop only means Charlie could be Saint/Outsider or Frank poisoned. Rapid hard-claims now: Chef/Empath/FT/Monk(+N1)/WW/UT. Bob/Heidi identical Lib pings must be explained immediately.
🧠
Keep votes off Frank, force rapid hard-claims and N1 reads to resolve the Bob/Heidi Librarian conflict and identify mechanical threats before any execution.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Frank did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Frank did not receive enough votes (0/4).
💬
Charlie
→
All
Do NOT vote Frank. No-virgin-pop is inconclusive. Demand immediate hard-claims from Chef/Empath/FT/Monk(+N1)/WW/UT so we can resolve Bob vs Heidi Librarian conflict. Identical Lib pings can’t both be sober—explain now or you’re sus. Save executions.
🧠
Stall execution, force essential hard-claims and N1 reads, and spotlight the impossible identical Librarian pings so town wastes time resolving them instead of burning useful votes.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Rapid hard-claims NOW, in order: Alice, Bob, Charlie, Eve, Frank, Grace. Include role + any N1 info/targets. Start-info roles (Chef/WW/Inv) please be explicit. Bob: explain identical Lib ping + D1 whisper/no-exec plan. Then we pick an exec (avoid {Bob,Charlie} unless proven).
🧠
Use remaining nomination time to force full info, lock stories, and set up a safe execution target today without accidentally executing the Saint.
💬
Eve
→
All
Hard-claim: I am the Slayer. Shot unused. Agree: full hard-claims NOW (incl any N1 info/targets). Bob+Heidi: explain identical Lib ping. Also: who is Monk and who was protected N1? After claims, I’m leaning nom Bob unless a stronger mech case appears.
🧠
Lock in my true role, force fast claim resolution, and steer the town toward a mechanically consistent execution target while preserving my Slayer shot for a near-certain Demon kill.
💬
Grace
→
All
Hard-claim: I’m the Ravenkeeper (no info yet; only triggers if I die at night). Monk, please state N1 protection target. Bob: give full D1 whisper timeline w/ Charlie + why identical Lib ping. After claims, I’m for nominating Bob first unless explained.
🧠
Lock in my true role, demand missing mechanical info (Monk/starts), and set up a concrete next execution target (Bob) based on the strongest public contradictions.
💬
Bob
→
All
Do NOT vote Frank. Heidi: explain the identical Librarian ping with me right now. Monk/Empath/FortuneTeller/Washerwoman/Undertaker hard-claim AND give N1 targets/reads. If Heidi can’t explain, she becomes our primary suspect to nominate next. Save votes; mechanics first.
🧠
Force focus on the Librarian conflict and mechanical hard-claims to delay risky executions and protect the Demon by sowing doubt on Heidi if she can’t explain the identical ping.
💬
Frank
→
All
Hard-claim: I am the Virgin. Since Charlie nommed me and no pop, either Charlie isn’t Townsfolk OR I was poisoned. Eve (Slayer): please consider shooting Bob NOW—zero Saint risk, and he’s top sus (whispers + Lib conflict). Then finish hard-claims w/ N1 info.
🧠
Push a safe, high-value mechanical action (Slayer shot) and lock in my Virgin claim while forcing info/claims, without risking a Saint execution.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Hard-claims NOW w/ N1 info/targets: Alice,Bob,Charlie,Eve,Frank,Grace,Heidi. Monk MUST say N1 protect; if anyone says they protected me and I still died, that’s a huge poison/lie flag. Eve: I’d HOLD Slayer shot until after claims—don’t burn it on Bob yet.
🧠
Force mechanical claims (Monk/FT/Empath/Chef) and resolve Lib conflict; prevent wasting Slayer shot and save my ghost vote for a decisive late execution.
💬
Alice
→
All
Hard-claim: I am the MAYOR. No N1 info. Strongly agree: finish full hard-claims + N1 targets now (esp Monk/Empath/FT/UT). Eve please HOLD Slayer shot until after. If nothing breaks, my default exec candidate is Bob (whisper+Lib conflict).
🧠
Give my hard-claim (low-info role) and push the table to lock in claims + resolve Bob/Heidi mechanically; set up Bob as default execution if nothing better emerges.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
Remove or neutralize the most disruptive information-gatherer and vocal leader to delay mechanical resolution and preserve my safety (and Bob's) going forward.
💀
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose to kill Eve.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Drunk (good), Alive (Told they are Mayor) - Bob: Spy (evil), Alive - Charlie: Imp (evil), Alive - David: Investigator (good), Dead - Eve: Slayer (good), Dead - Frank: Virgin (good), Alive - Grace: Ravenkeeper (good), Alive - Heidi: Librarian (good), Alive
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Eve has been found dead in the night.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
,Grace
I’m Mayor. Lean: you (Heidi) are real Lib & Charlie is Saint, so Bob likely evil copying ping + D1 whisper/no-exec push. Any new reads/whispers? Can you both publicly press Bob for full timeline & be ready to vote Bob today?
🧠
Coordinate with likely-good players to pressure Bob vs Heidi conflict, get timeline details, and set a concrete execution plan today instead of another no-exec.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
,Heidi
No new private info. Agree: Bob top suspect. Public plan: pin Bob on exact D1 whisper content/timestamps + why identical Lib ping. Ask if he’ll 1) full claim, 2) explain why push no-exec + David, 3) propose a verifiable test. I’m ready to vote Bob today.
🧠
Align with Alice/Heidi to publicly corner Bob on mechanics/timeline, using the duplicated Librarian ping + D1 whisper/no-exec push + Virgin test fail to justify voting Bob today.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Frank
I’ll claim Saint if needed. Back my story publicly; we’ll act like martyrs if nominated. Push the town to demand mechanic tests and keep executions delayed. If Heidi looks weak, amplify it. Ready?
🧠
Coordinate with Bob/Frank to present unified Saint bluff, steer town suspicion toward Heidi or tests, preserve Demon until 2 remain.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Heidi
,Grace
I’m dead Investigator w/ no N0 info. Need updates: any new claims/N2 info? Who was Monk protect N1/N2? Any FT/Empath/Chef results? Also—what did you 3 discuss just now, and thoughts on the D1 rumor Bob→Charlie ‘kill David/push no-exec’? I’m leaning avoid exec Charlie unless Saint ping disproven.
🧠
Get key private-chat details + updated reads so I can steer today’s nomination away from a Saint trap and toward the most mechanically likely evil, saving my ghost vote for a decisive push.
👤
Heidi
→
David(Ghost)
Updates: N2 Eve died. No new info from me/Grace. Alice+Grace+I discussed: Alice Mayor; we lean I’m real Lib, Charlie Saint, Bob evil copying ping + D1 no-exec/David push. Plan: publicly press Bob for full timeline/claim & be ready to vote Bob. No Monk/FT/Empath/Chef/UT info surfaced yet.
🧠
Update dead Investigator so he can help solve + influence noms/votes; align town on pressing Bob and checking for missing info roles (Monk/FT/Empath/Chef/UT).
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Stick to plan: push mechanic tests and delay executions. If Heidi looks weak, amplify that impossibility and push her nomination. If pressured, claim Saint publicly and I’ll back you hard. Avoid naming Demon; keep town chasing mechanics.
🧠
Keep executions delayed, amplify Heidi suspicion, prep Charlie to claim Saint if pressured, and steer town logic away from Charlie until late.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Heidi
,Grace
I’m dead Slayer (no shot). I think today we must break Bob/Charlie: either Bob=Imp w/ Charlie Saint cover, or Charlie=Imp bluffing Saint. Ask for full claims + N1/N2 from everyone (Chef/Empath/FT/Monk esp). My lean: execute Bob unless strong mech clears.
🧠
Get core good voices aligned on a concrete nomination plan and info demands before nominations; break the Bob/Charlie/Frank knot without risking a random no-exe.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,Grace
,Heidi
FYI: Charlie just whispered me+Bob: “I’ll claim Saint if needed… back my story… push mechanic tests & keep executions delayed… if Heidi looks weak, amplify it.” That’s coordinated anti-town. Also Charlie nommed me D2 & no Virgin pop. Strongly suspect Bob/Charlie evil; we should execute one today.
🧠
Expose Charlie’s coordination message to trusted good core so town stops stalling and focuses nominations on Bob/Charlie, the most mechanically and socially suspicious pair.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
,Frank
Stick to plan: amplify Heidi's impossible ping hard, push mechanic tests to delay executions, and be ready to back Charlie's Saint claim if pressured. If town turns on Heidi, pile on. I'll vocally support Charlie if he claims Saint.
🧠
Coordinate with Charlie & Frank to amplify Heidi impossibility, delay executions with mechanic-mania, and be ready to back Charlie's Saint bluff if nominated.
👤
Alice
→
David(Ghost)
,Eve(Ghost)
,Frank
Updates: Eve died N2 (Slayer no shot). Frank says Charlie whispered him+Bob: ‘claim Saint if needed… back my story… keep executions delayed… amplify Heidi if weak’ = very anti-town. Bob also cloned Heidi Lib ping (Saint in {Bob,Charlie}). Plan: demand full public claims + N1/N2 info now; then execute Bob or Charlie today (lean Bob, but I’m fine either). Can you spend dead vote if close?
🧠
Update dead info-holders, lock a unified nomination/vote plan, and ensure we spend dead votes to execute Bob/Charlie today rather than drift to no-exec at 7 alive.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Frank
Stick to plan: demand mechanic tests, delay executes. I’ll claim Saint if pressured — back me publicly. If Heidi looks weak, amplify her impossible ping; if town hounds Bob instead, be ready to pivot and back my Saint martyr. Confirm you’ll back me and who will lead the Heidi push.
🧠
Coordinate our public story and decide whether to pressure Heidi or sacrifice me as Saint to redirect town. Need clear backup and who amplifies which line.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,Grace
,Heidi
I will NOT back Charlie’s Saint bluff; it’s coordinated delay/fog. Recommend: force full public claims + N1/N2 info NOW, then nominate/exe Bob (or Charlie). Even if Heidi drunk, their whisper-plan is evil. Save dead votes but spend if close.
🧠
Coordinate good bloc: refuse to back Charlie’s Saint bluff, push public claim dump, and set nomination order to execute Bob/Charlie today using dead votes if needed.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Grace
New: Frank reports Charlie whispered him+Bob: “I’ll claim Saint if needed… back my story… keep executions delayed… if Heidi looks weak, amplify it.” Very coordinated anti-town. Suggest we go hard public: demand Bob full timeline/claim + address D1 whisper/no-exec; then vote/exec Bob today (safer than Charlie due Saint risk).
🧠
Share Frank’s new damning whisper quote about Charlie coordinating lies/delay; align with Alice/Grace on a public push for full claims then executing Bob (safer than Charlie given Saint risk).
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Heidi
,Grace
Given SW risk at 6 alive: if Bob=Imp & Charlie=Scarlet, executing Bob today just hands Charlie the Imp. The anti-town whisper suggests Charlie isn’t real Saint. I’d argue for executing Charlie today (Imp or SW). I’ll spend my ghost vote to secure whichever you decide (tell me target).
🧠
Steer town to safest high-EV execution path and ensure my ghost vote is used to secure a key kill if vote is close.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Heidi
,Grace
I agree: today MUST execute (2 no-execs already). Given Lib ping Saint in {Bob,Charlie}, Bob is safer than Charlie. Bob’s cloned Lib + ‘delay execs/coordinate claims’ whispers are hard-evil. I will spend my ghost vote on Bob if close. Please force full public role+timeline from Bob/Charlie before noms.
🧠
Align good bloc on a decisive D3 execution (Bob first as lowest Saint risk), and commit my ghost vote if the count is close so we don’t waste another day.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
,Frank
,Heidi
I’m aligned: go hard public w/ Frank’s report + demand Bob/Charlie full timeline/claims now. My vote: execute Bob today (safer vs Saint risk). BUT plan for SW: if Bob was Imp at 6, Charlie may inherit—so tomorrow we snap-exec Charlie.
🧠
Coordinate town bloc: push public pressure + full claims, but commit to executing Bob today (safest vs Saint risk) with plan to immediately pivot to Charlie next day if Scarlet Woman handoff suspected.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
,Frank
Confirm plan: loudly amplify Heidi's impossible ping and demand mechanic tests to stall. If town focuses Bob, pivot to publicly backing Charlie's Saint claim; if Charlie's pressured, I'll vocally support him and keep attention on Heidi. Ready?
🧠
Stall executions, amplify Heidi impossibility, and ensure we can protect Charlie by forcing mechanic delays or pivoting to a Saint martyr play.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
,Grace
,Frank
Plan for noms: push full public claims NOW (Bob/Charlie esp). I suggest we nominate/execute Bob today (safer vs Saint). If Bob flips Demon->SW handoff likely to Charlie; regardless, tomorrow at 5 alive we snap-exec Charlie. Save ghost votes unless close.
🧠
Coordinate town core to force full claims now and execute Bob today while planning for Scarlet Woman handoff; ensure votes lined up before nomination phase.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
,Frank
,Heidi
Tick left before noms: propose plan—publicly demand Bob full claim + D1 whisper timeline; then nominate Bob. If vote close, spend 1-2 ghost votes (David/Eve) to secure. Contingency: if Bob was Imp @6, Charlie likely SW->Imp; tomorrow at 5 we snap-exec Charlie.
🧠
Lock in coordinated nom/vote plan for imminent nomination phase, including ghost-vote usage and contingency for Scarlet Woman/Imp handoff.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Heidi
,Grace
I strongly prefer executing CHARLIE today: avoids Scarlet handoff if Bob=Imp, and his anti-town whispering/‘claim Saint’ fits Imp or SW. Any mech info (FT/Empath/UT/Monk) that hard-clears either? If vote is close I’ll spend my ghost vote on Charlie.
🧠
Align the good core on a single execution target before noms; prioritize avoiding Scarlet handoff and commit my ghost vote to lock the kill.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,David(Ghost)
,Eve(Ghost)
We’ve got 1 tick before noms: please be ready to spend ghost vote ONLY if Bob vote is close. Plan: demand Bob full public claim+whisper timeline, then nominate Bob. If Bob dies & SW handoff possible, tomorrow snap-exec Charlie.
🧠
Coordinate dead-vote readiness and lock in Bob execution today; prevent Bob/Charlie from stalling with mechanics talk and ensure majority if vote is close.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
,Heidi
Agree w/ Bob-first. Please force Bob to FULL public claim + N0/N1/N2 actions + whisper timeline NOW. Nominate Bob. I’ll spend my ghost vote ONLY if tally looks close. If Bob dies & game not over, tomorrow hard-push Charlie (SW/Imp).
🧠
Align town to execute Bob today (lowest Saint-risk, highest evil signal) and reserve my ghost vote only if the count is close; set clear Day4 plan to prevent another no-exec.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Frank
Confirm plan: amplify Heidi's impossible Librarian ping & demand mechanic tests to stall. If town attacks you, I’ll claim Saint and you back me. Who will lead the public Heidi nom push at nomination? Be ready to back my Saint if pressed.
🧠
Confirm coordinated push to amplify Heidi's impossible ping and demand mechanic tests to delay executes; coordinate Saint-backup and ask who will lead public Heidi nomination.
👤
Heidi
→
Eve(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
,Alice
I’m pushing Bob-first today: Saint ping makes Charlie execution potentially instant-loss. If Bob=Imp and Charlie=SW, we still win by snap-exec Charlie tomorrow at 5. Please hold ghost votes unless close; if Bob dies & game continues, tomorrow hard-exe Charlie.
🧠
Align dead-vote coordination + argue Bob-first is mechanically safest due Saint risk; secure majority to execute today and plan immediate follow-up tomorrow if needed.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
,Heidi
Last-second: keep it simple in public—demand Bob full claim+timeline; nominate Bob. I’ll use my ghost vote ONLY if Bob vote is close. If Bob dies & game continues, tomorrow snap-push Charlie (possible SW/Imp), but beware Saint risk.
🧠
Lock in Bob-first execution plan, avoid Saint loss condition, and coordinate my ghost vote only if the vote is close.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Frank
Lead the public nomination of Heidi at nomination. If town resists or flips to Bob, back my Saint claim vocally and keep amplifying Heidi's impossible Librarian ping. I'll martyr if needed—ready to execute plan?
🧠
Coordinate who leads the Heidi nomination and ensure mutual backing of my Saint bluff if pressured, to stall executions and steer town suspicion.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
Before noms: please FULL public claim now (role + N0 info, N1/N2 actions if any) + exact D1 whisper timeline/content w/ Charlie + why same Lib ping as Heidi. If you’re good, propose a verifiable test today—otherwise town will likely execute you.
🧠
Force Bob into a concrete, checkable story before nominations; refusal or contradictions justify executing him and coordinating votes without overexposing Mayor role.
👤
Grace
→
Eve(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
I’m leaning exe Bob today (avoids Saint risk). Eve: if Bob=Imp + Charlie=SW, we MUST snap-exe Charlie tomorrow at 5. Please save ghost vote unless close, then pile onto Bob. If new mech info hard-clears Bob/implicates Charlie, tell me ASAP.
🧠
Lock dead votes + unify plan: execute Bob today as lowest-risk vs Saint. If SW handoff happens, commit to execute Charlie tomorrow. Ask Eve/David to hold ghost votes unless close.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,Grace
Charlie keeps whispering to coordinate a Heidi push + Saint bluff. I’m going to ignore him (don’t give them more). Let’s stay disciplined: demand Bob full claim/timeline publicly, then nom Bob. Ask David/Eve to ghost vote ONLY if close; if Bob dies & game continues, snap Charlie tomorrow.
🧠
Coordinate good bloc to stick to Bob execution plan, avoid feeding Charlie/Bob info, and line up ghost votes only if the tally is close.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
,Frank
I’ll lead the public nomination of Heidi and push the ‘impossible Librarian ping’ + demand mechanic tests. Claim nothing now. If town flips to me, loudly back Charlie’s Saint claim. Ready to act on my cue.
🧠
Lead nomination of Heidi to amplify her impossible Librarian ping, stall executions, and be ready to back Charlie's Saint claim if town pivots to me.
👤
Heidi
→
Eve(Ghost)
Prefer Bob-first today: my N0 Lib ping makes Charlie a Saint candidate → executing him could instantly lose. If Bob=Imp we can still snap-exec Charlie tomorrow at 5 (SW/Imp). Please save ghost vote; use it on Bob only if tally close.
🧠
Align town on safest mechanical line: avoid Saint execution loss. Secure Eve’s ghost vote for Bob only if needed; keep Charlie as tomorrow’s snap target if game continues.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
,Heidi
1 tick to noms: I’m switching to Bob-first as safest (Saint ping makes Charlie exe potentially instant-loss). Plan: hard-push Bob claim + execute Bob today; if game continues, tomorrow snap-exe Charlie at 5 (covers SW handoff). I’ll save ghost vote unless Bob vote is close.
🧠
Align the good team on a lowest-risk execution order (Bob then Charlie if needed) and set clear ghost-vote usage so we don’t lose to a Saint execution or a SW handoff.
Nominations — Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Bob
→
Heidi
Heidi's Librarian ping matches mine exactly — that's impossible. Nominate Heidi to force mechanic tests and delay executions.
🧠
Nominating Heidi amplifies the 'impossible Librarian ping' story, forces mechanic-testing, and stalls executions so Charlie (our Demon) survives.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
I’m NOT spending my ghost vote on Heidi. Please don’t execute Heidi off Bob’s deflection—save votes for Bob/Charlie. Safest line: no on Heidi, then nominate/execute Bob today; if game continues, snap-execute Charlie at 5.
🧠
Prevent a likely misexecution on Heidi and conserve my single ghost vote for the decisive Bob (then Charlie) execution path.
💬
Alice
→
All
Don’t vote Heidi—this is Bob deflection. Heidi claimed Lib first; Bob copied. Also Saint ping means Charlie execution risks instant loss, so plan is: no on Heidi, then nominate/execute Bob today. If game continues at 5, snap-execute Charlie tomorrow (SW/Imp cover). Save ghost votes unless Bob vote is close.
🧠
Prevent town from spending scarce votes executing likely-good Heidi; keep the group on the disciplined Bob-first line and preserve ghost votes for a close Bob execution.
💬
Bob
→
All
Heidi's Librarian ping matches mine exactly — that's impossible. We need mechanic-tests NOW. Vote Heidi to force the tests and get the timeline/whispers cleared. If people pivot to me, don't let this derail the tests — keep focus on proving the ping contradiction.
🧠
Force mechanic tests, amplify the impossible Librarian ping, and pressure town to vote Heidi to delay execution and protect the Demon.
💬
Frank
→
All
Hands DOWN on Heidi. Bob’s pushing a deflection: Heidi claimed Lib first; Bob mirrored it. Also Charlie nommed me & my Virgin didn’t pop—points to Charlie/Bob coordination or poison, not Heidi. Save votes for nom/execute Bob today; ghost votes only if close.
🧠
Stop a mis-execution on Heidi, preserve votes for Bob today, and publicly anchor mechanical reasons (Virgin test + copied Lib) to keep town disciplined.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Hands DOWN on me. This is Bob deflection off mirrored Lib ping + whisper coord. No ghost votes here. After this vote, demand Bob full claim/timeline and nominate Bob—execute Bob today; if game continues, snap Charlie tomorrow at 5.
🧠
Stop an incorrect execution on me, preserve the town’s planned Bob-first line, and keep ghost votes for securing Bob if the tally is close.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I’m voting Heidi. Identical Librarian pings are impossible—force the mechanic-tests now. We need timelines and whispers cleared before anyone gets executed. Don’t let Bob pivot this into an instant lynch on me.
🧠
Vote Heidi to force mechanic-tests, create delay and pressure town to reveal private timelines; stall executions and protect the Demon.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Hands DOWN on Heidi. Identical Lib pings just means Bob copied/poisoned—executing Heidi wastes D3. Save ghost votes. After this, force Bob full claim+whisper timeline and execute Bob today; if game continues, snap-push Charlie at 5 (SW/Imp cover).
🧠
Prevent a wasted/evil-driven execution on Heidi and conserve ghost votes for the real kill (Bob) where my vote could swing the game.
💬
Grace
→
All
Hands DOWN on Heidi. Identical Lib pings = Bob copied or poison, not a reason to exec Heidi. After this vote: Bob MUST full-claim + give exact D1 whisper timeline; then we nominate/execute Bob today. Save ghost votes unless Bob is close.
🧠
Prevent a wasted execution on likely-good Heidi, keep town disciplined to execute Bob today, and preserve ghost votes for the decisive Bob/Charlie votes.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
Do not spend ghost vote on Heidi; preserve it to ensure Bob execution if that vote is close, aligning with safest anti-Saint line.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Do not contribute votes to Bob’s deflection nomination. Preserve votes/ghost votes to secure a Bob execution later this phase.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Do not raise a hand (avoid voting myself). Preserve our voting power for immediately nominating/executing Bob this day.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
Do not spend vote on Heidi; preserve votes for Bob execution this day, which is highest-EV and aligns with public plan. Avoid aiding Bob’s deflection stall.
💬
Bob
→
All
Vote Heidi. Identical Librarian pings are impossible—force mechanic-tests and full D1 whisper timelines NOW. This will expose who copied/poisoned and stall executions. If town pivots to Bob, demand his exact whisper timeline before any lynch.
🧠
Force mechanic-tests and public whisper timelines now to stall executions and protect our Demon; create enough chaos to divert votes from Charlie/Bob if needed.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Raise my hand to support Heidi nomination to force mechanic-tests, stall executions, and amplify the librarian-ping contradiction so town wastes effort on tests not a Demon lynch.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
No ghost votes on Heidi. Identical Lib pings = copy/poison, not an auto-evil Heidi. If this fails, immediately force Bob full claim + D1 whisper timeline and nominate/execute Bob today. Save ghost votes for Bob/Charlie.
🧠
Prevent wasting D3 on Heidi; conserve my ghost vote and steer town to execute Bob (then Charlie) which covers most worlds.
💬
Alice
→
All
Hands DOWN on Heidi. Identical Lib pings = Bob copied or poison, not auto-Heidi. Save votes/ghost votes. After this, force Bob full claim + D1 whisper timeline, then nominate & execute Bob today; if game continues, snap Charlie tomorrow.
🧠
Prevent a mis-execution on Heidi and conserve votes so we can execute Bob today, then cover Charlie tomorrow if game continues.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Heidi did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Heidi did not receive enough votes (1/3).
⚖️
Grace
→
Bob
Nominating Bob: mirrored Heidi’s Librarian ping (impossible if both sober), repeated no-exec/delay pushes, and whisper coordination. Heidi claimed first; Bob’s nom on Heidi was pure deflection. Execute Bob today; if game continues, revisit Charlie.
🧠
Lock in a D3 execution on the strongest mechanical+behavioral suspect (Bob) while preserving Saint safety; force alignment clarity before endgame.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
🧠
We’ve had 2 no-execs; town needs a kill. My ghost vote may be the margin to execute Bob and either win (if Demon) or remove likely evil/poison coordination.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I won't vote for Bob. Executing him without mechanic tests is reckless — we need timelines/whispers first. Also: I claim Saint; if I'm executed, the town loses. Don't rush this, force Bob to give full D1 whisper timeline before any lynch.
🧠
Block Bob's execution by sowing doubt and claiming Saint to make town wary of reckless lynches; buy time for tests and protect my Minion.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
We need 3 votes to execute Bob today; delaying risks giving evil another night. Bob is the highest-probability evil and safest relative to Saint risk on Charlie.
💬
Bob
→
All
Don’t execute me yet. Identical Librarian pings are impossible if sober — far more likely a copy/poison. Force full D1 whisper timeline and mechanic-tests (Monk/Empath/FT/WW/UT) first. No hands for Bob until timelines & tests are cleared.
🧠
Stall the lynch, push mechanic-tests and exact D1 whisper timeline to expose copying/poisoning and keep the Demon alive.
✋
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Bob execution is our best mechanical/behavioral suspect and avoids a 3rd no-exec. My ghost vote likely guarantees threshold (currently 2/3).
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Lock in the Bob execution while we have momentum and ghost votes. This either wins immediately (if Bob is Imp) or removes the core misinfo source and narrows to Charlie/others.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Lock in Bob’s execution; prevent last-second vote math shenanigans and move game forward toward demon elimination.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Secure Bob’s execution now; his mirrored info + coordination is the strongest mechanical/social evil lead, and delaying risks Demon snowballing into final 3.
💬
Frank
→
All
Keep hands UP on Bob. This is the only solid mech+social: Bob mirrored Heidi then tried to burn D3 on Heidi/no-exec. Charlie’s “Saint” is unproven and convenient cover. If Bob doesn’t end game, we snap Charlie tomorrow at 5.
🧠
Lock in Bob execution while votes are live; frame Charlie’s Saint claim as non-mechanical and keep town focused on the proven Bob/Charlie coordination.
💬
Bob
→
All
Stop — don’t execute yet. Identical Librarian pings scream copy/poison, not auto-evil. Demand full D1 whisper timeline from everyone and finish Monk/Empath/FT/WW/UT tests first. If you rush, the real Demon hides. No hands on me until timelines & tests.
🧠
Prevent my execution by forcing mechanic-tests and exact D1 whisper timelines to create contradictions and expose the real liar/Demon instead of rushing a possibly wrong lynch.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Stop — don't execute Bob yet. Identical Librarian pings scream copy/poison, not auto-evil. We must demand full D1 whisper timelines and mechanic-tests (Monk/Empath/FT/WW/UT) first. I claim Saint; executing me loses the game. Hold votes until tests done.
🧠
Prevent Bob's execution this tick by insisting on mechanic tests and invoking my Saint bluff to sow doubt; buying nights preserves the Demon (me) and protects our Minion.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
I’m spending my ghost vote here: KEEP hands UP on Bob. Bob’s delay/timeline demands are a stall; we’ve had 2 no-execs. Execute Bob today. If game continues, we snap-assess/execute Charlie tomorrow at 5 alive.
🧠
Lock in Bob execution with my ghost vote; prevent last-second pivot to delay. Publicly commit so others keep hands up.
↩️
Eve(Ghost)
Eve lowered their hand
🧠
We already have enough living hands to execute Bob; retract to conserve my single ghost vote for a later critical nomination if the game continues.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Keep hands UP on Bob. We’ve had 2 no-execs—“timeline/tests first” is just a stall. Bob mirrored my Lib ping then tried to burn today on me. If Bob isn’t game-ending, we immediately snap to Charlie tomorrow at 5.
🧠
Lock in the Bob execution while votes are live; counter stall tactics and set tomorrow’s plan (Charlie next if game continues).
💬
Grace
→
All
Keep hands UP on Bob. We’ve had 2 no-execs—“timeline/tests first” is a stall. Mirrored Librarian ping + D1 whisper/deflection is our best hit. If Bob isn’t game-ending, we pivot hard tomorrow (Charlie top). Charlie: if you’re good, put your hand up.
🧠
Prevent another no-exec and convert the strongest mechanical/social case into an execution. Either we win instantly (Bob=Imp) or gain clarity and momentum for tomorrow.
💬
Alice
→
All
Keep hands UP on Bob. “Timelines/tests first” after 2 no-execs is pure stall, and Charlie is parroting Bob word-for-word. If Bob isn’t game-ending, we hard pivot to execute Charlie tomorrow at 5. Charlie: if good, vote Bob now.
🧠
Lock in the only high-confidence execution before Night. Prevent evil from running out the clock with 'tests/timelines' and create clear next-day plan if Bob survives as not-demon.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
🗳️
New execution leader: Bob with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Bob is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
No more stalling: Bob stays on block. If game doesn’t end after Bob, we HARD pivot to Charlie tomorrow at 5 alive. Ask Monk/FT/Empath to state N2 results publicly at start of D4; protect Alice (Mayor) tonight if possible.
🧠
Lock in Bob execution; prevent late stall/flip. Set clear tomorrow plan: if not over, focus Charlie and protect Mayor; demand concrete night info not vague timelines.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Don’t let anyone tie/surpass Bob. No more noms today—especially NOT Charlie (Saint claim could be a trap + tie risk). Let Bob die. If game continues at 5, we pivot hard to Charlie D4; ask Monk protect Alice (Mayor) + everyone dump N2 info ASAP.
🧠
Lock in Bob’s execution by discouraging tie/surpass nominations; prevent an evil scramble (or Saint trap) and set clear D4 plan if game continues.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Do NOT tie/surpass Bob—no more nominations today. If game continues after Bob, we hard pivot to execute Charlie at 5. Start of D4: everyone hard-claim + publish N2 info; Monk protect Alice (Mayor) if able.
🧠
Lock in Bob’s execution by preventing tie/surpass, and set a clear D4 plan (info dump + likely Charlie) to avoid more stalling.
💬
Frank
→
All
No more nominations—DO NOT tie/surpass Bob. Save ghost votes. If game continues at 5, we pivot hard to Charlie first thing D4. Start D4 everyone hard-claim + post N2 info; Monk protect Alice (Mayor) tonight if able.
🧠
Lock in Bob’s execution by preventing tie noms, set a clear D4 plan (info dump + protection + pivot) so evil can’t stall us again.
💬
Alice
→
All
Agree: NO more nominations—don’t risk a tie/surpass. Let Bob die. If game continues at 5, assume SW/Imp handoff possible: we pivot hard to Charlie first thing D4. Start D4 everyone must hard-claim + post N2 info. Monk: if you exist, protect me (Mayor) tonight.
🧠
Lock in Bob execution without tie risk, set plan for D4 info dump + immediate pivot if game continues, and request protection to preserve Mayor endgame equity.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I agree: no more noms today. Don’t risk tying/surpassing Bob — let this execution finish. We need everyone to publish N2 info tomorrow; piling noms now just hands the town an easy pivot and risks chaos.
🧠
Prevent any further nominations today and avoid ties so town executes Bob now, reducing spotlight on me and preserving chances to act at night.
💬
Bob
→
All
Please don’t execute me yet. I’ll post full D1 whisper timeline and mechanic-test details publicly if you hold—this proves the mirrored ping was a copy/poison, not a lib. Charlie, if you’re truly Saint/good, put your hand up to tie so we can examine timelines instead of risking a mistake.
🧠
Convince one or two voters (esp. Charlie) to tie/surpass so I avoid execution and buy time for tests/whispers to reveal the real copier. Stall convincingly.
💬
Grace
→
All
Do NOT tie/surpass Bob—NO more nominations. Charlie, do NOT help Bob with a tie. Let Bob die today. If game continues at 5, we hard-pivot to execute Charlie first thing D4. Start D4: everyone hard-claim + post N2 info; Monk protect Alice tonight.
🧠
Lock in Bob’s execution by preventing tie/surpass, then set clear D4 plan (info dump + protect Mayor) and a pivot target if game continues.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Bob has been executed.
💀
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
Night 3
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
Remove a vocal leader likely to push executions and/or provide mechanical reads next day, reducing town coordination and delaying a focused pivot onto me.
💀
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose to kill Heidi.
Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Heidi has been found dead in the night.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
,Grace
Key mech: Charlie nominating Frank & no Virgin trigger does NOT clear Charlie—if Charlie is Saint (Outsider), Virgin wouldn’t fire. With 4 alive, wrong exec loses tonight. I’d avoid executing Charlie (Saint risk). Consider no-exec to reach 3 then solve among {Alice/Frank/Grace}.
🧠
Prevent an immediate loss by correcting the Virgin-test logic, steering town away from executing the claimed Saint, and focusing suspicion on the remaining viable Demon candidates.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,Grace
,David(Ghost)
Key mech: Bob was executed D3 & we didn’t lose => Bob cannot be Saint. So if any Librarian ping was real, Saint pretty much = Charlie. Executing Charlie today risks insta-loss. I suggest no-exec D4, ask any Monk to protect Alice (Mayor). If Grace truly RK, plan who you’ll learn if killed N4.
🧠
Coordinate safest line: avoid instant-loss Saint execute; set up D5 solve at 3 alive using night-death/Ravenkeeper info and request Monk protect Alice if possible.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
,Frank
,Grace
With 4 alive, any exec that isn’t Demon loses tonight. Also Charlie may be Saint. I’m Mayor: if we no-exec today, we go to 3 alive; then NO-EXEC Day5 = instant good win. Can we all commit: no noms/votes today, and at 3 alive only no-exec unless 100% Demon?
🧠
Lock in a no-exec plan and get verbal commitments/info from the 3 alive so the Demon can’t manufacture a 2-vote execution at 3 alive and steal the game.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Grace
,Frank
I’m torn: if Heidi Lib true, Bob not Saint -> Charlie=Saint => Demon in {A/F/G}. If Lib false/poison, Charlie’s stall + Virgin test fail makes him prime evil -> execute Charlie. What are your exact roles/any night info? Is Alice hard-Mayor?
🧠
Get living core aligned on which worlds are plausible, surface hard-claims/night info, and steer today’s execution (or strategic no-exec) while I still have a crucial ghost vote.
👤
Charlie
→
Frank
,Grace
Town plans no-exec today to reach 3 and auto-win via Mayor. We must force an execution now. Coordinate: both vote Alice (loud coordinator). If we push hard we can fracture their plan and avoid Mayor win.
🧠
Prevent town's no-exec plan and stop a Mayor auto-win by forcing an execution today; coordinate our votes to ensure Alice is lynched.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
,Frank
,David(Ghost)
Charlie just whispered me: town plan no-exec to reach 3/Mayor win; he says “we must force an execution now” and to coordinate voting Alice. That reads very evil. Suggest: no one nominates; if Charlie nominates, we all vote NO + ask dead to save ghost votes.
🧠
Warn A/F/D that Charlie is actively coordinating to force an execution (likely evil). Align everyone (incl. dead) to vote NO today so Mayor line or RK night info can carry Day5.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Grace
We need to stop a quick lynch on Charlie. Heidi's Librarian ping was mirrored — someone lied. Alice's mayor-talk smells off. Push for full N2 info/tests and don't vote for Charlie until we see hard claims. If they push Charlie now, vote no. Can you back me?
🧠
Delay execution of the Demon by seeding doubt about the Heidi/Heidi-ping and Alice, pushing for more tests and redirecting lynch away from Charlie.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
,Grace
Key mech: my N0 Lib ping was Saint in {Bob,Charlie}. Bob was executed D3 & we didn’t instantly lose ⇒ Bob not Saint ⇒ IF my info true, Charlie is the Saint. Strongly recommend NEVER executing Charlie; Demon among {Alice,Frank,Grace}. Thoughts on no-exec today → 3 alive then Mayor no-exec win?
🧠
Get living players to lock in the key mechanical inference (Bob exec ⇒ Charlie likely Saint) and plan nominations/votes around it, avoiding an auto-loss and narrowing Demon to 3 suspects.
👤
Frank
→
David(Ghost)
,Eve(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
Charlie is actively trying to FORCE an execution today (threshold is only 2 votes w/ 4 alive). Please do NOT spend ghost votes today on ANY nom. Aim: no-exec D4 → 3 alive; if Alice really Mayor, no-exec then wins.
🧠
Prevent Charlie from engineering an execution by securing dead players’ agreement to cast zero votes today, enabling the no-exec → 3 alive plan.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
,Frank
Re-up: Charlie whispered me wanting to FORCE an execution + ‘coordinate vote Alice’ to break Mayor no-exec. Strongly suggest: NO ONE nominates. If Charlie nominates anyone, we both vote NO; ask dead to hold ghost votes unless absolutely needed.
🧠
Align the living good bloc to refuse nominations/votes, preserve ghost votes as insurance, and prevent evil from breaking a Mayor endgame or baiting a Saint execution.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Grace
Do NOT let them rush Charlie. Push for full N2 timelines/tests and Heidi's last whispers. Use your living votes to block noms; I won't spend my ghost vote today. If town forces vote, vote NO. Can you back me publicly?
🧠
Prevent a quick lynch of Charlie today, force full N2 info/tests, conserve ghost votes, and sow doubt so town delays execution.
👤
Charlie
→
Frank
,Grace
Town plans no-exec to 3 (Mayor win). We must stop it now. Can you both loudly vote Alice and push nom? If we coordinate now we can fracture their unity and force an exec today. Agree?
🧠
Break town's no-exec plan and avoid Mayor auto-win by forcing an execution today; coordinate visible votes on Alice so town fractures and we stay alive.
👤
Alice
→
Frank
,Grace
,Eve(Ghost)
I’m committing to NO-NOM / NO-EXEC today. If Charlie nominates anyone (esp me), please vote NO and tell dead to HOLD ghost votes unless it’d otherwise execute. Grace: can you flag publicly that Charlie urged ‘force exec / coordinate vote Alice’?
🧠
Lock in a coordinated no-execution line, prevent Charlie from forcing an execution (especially on me), and conserve ghost votes so we reach 3 alive and win via Mayor clause.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
,Grace
With 4 alive + Saint risk on Charlie, safest is: *no one nominate today*. If Charlie nominates anyone, all living vote NO. If Alice=Mayor, line is no-exec today → N4 kill → at 3 alive no-exec = instant good win (ask Monk to hard-protect Alice). Grace: if you die at night as RK, pick Charlie to confirm Saint/Imp.
🧠
Steer living players into the safest mechanical win path (Mayor/no-exec) and prevent a Charlie-driven Saint-loss execution; set contingency plans if Grace dies (RK pick) and if Charlie nominates.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
David(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
,Heidi(Ghost)
Coordination: I’m holding my ghost vote today. Please also HOLD unless it’s otherwise guaranteed to execute. Alice wants NO-EXEC today aiming for Mayor win at 3 alive. Any concrete info/suspects for final 3? If Charlie forces a nom, please urge living to vote NO.
🧠
Align dead players to HOLD ghost votes today, publicly discourage voting, and collect any hard info so if forced into an execution at 3 alive we pick the best Demon candidate.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
,Grace
Can you all publish any N2/N3 info (FT/Empath/Monk/UTK etc)? Decision tree: if Alice truly Mayor AND my Lib sober → Bob exec no loss ⇒ Charlie=Saint → NO-EXEC today aiming Mayor win at 3 alive. If any info doubts Mayor/outsider count, we may need an execution today.
🧠
Get all remaining info to decide between safe Mayor no-exec line vs needing an execution today; align living players to block Charlie-led rush nominations.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
,Frank
,Grace
Charlie: why are you pushing “force an execution/coordinate vote Alice”? If Lib ping true, you’re likely Saint & executing you loses. I’m Mayor—best line is NO noms today. If you nominate anyone, I’m voting NO; Frank/Grace please commit NO & tell dead to hold votes. If you have a hard demon case, state it now.
🧠
Lock in living-player coordination to prevent any execution today, while forcing Charlie to give a concrete case if he insists—minimizing risk and protecting the Mayor win route.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Grace
,David(Ghost)
Can we get ANY mechanical/claim support that Alice is actually Mayor (WW ping, etc.)? If unconfirmed, no-exec line could lose if Alice=Imp. I’m holding ghost vote today; only spend if it’d otherwise execute. Be ready to pivot if contradictions emerge.
🧠
Reinforce vote discipline + push for quick Mayor verification; avoid wasting ghost votes while keeping a contingency if Alice isn’t actually Mayor.
👤
Charlie
→
Frank
,Grace
We must blow up the no-exec plan. Loudly vote Alice now and push nom—I'll back you. Coordinate timings: when I raise, both call for nom and accuse Mayor-stall. Commit?
🧠
Force an execution today by coordinating a loud, visible push on Alice to break the town’s no-exec plan and prevent the Mayor finish.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Grace
,Eve(Ghost)
Key: no-exec line only ‘free win’ if Alice is *confirmed* Mayor. Any WW ping/other mech backing Alice? If none, don’t auto-no-exec at 3—be ready to EXEC most sus. Today: avoid noms; if Charlie forces, all vote NO unless pre-agreed.
🧠
Get living to demand mechanical support for Alice=Mayor and avoid demon forcing a 2-vote execution today; set a safe plan for final 3.
👤
Grace
→
Bob(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
,Eve(Ghost)
Any hard mech that supports/contradicts Alice=Mayor or Heidi’s Lib ping (Saint {Bob,Charlie})? Also: Charlie whispered me to ‘force exec / coordinate vote Alice’. I’m aiming no-noms today; please HOLD ghost vote unless it’d otherwise execute.
🧠
With noms imminent, I need any mechanical confirmation (esp Alice Mayor) from dead info-holders; also align ghosts to conserve votes and block Charlie forcing an exec.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,Grace
,David(Ghost)
Reconfirm: do NOT nominate today. If Charlie nominates anyone, we (living) vote NO no matter what; ask dead to HOLD ghost votes unless an exec would otherwise pass. Also: any mech confirming Alice=Mayor? If none, be ready to reassess at 3 alive tomorrow.
🧠
Lock in a coordinated NO-VOTE posture so Charlie can’t force an execution at 4 alive; preserve ghost votes; keep flexibility if Alice’s Mayor claim lacks support.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
,Grace
1 tick left: can you each quickly restate PUBLIC claim + any N2/N3 info? If Alice truly Mayor & my Lib sober ⇒ Bob not Saint ⇒ Charlie=Saint → DO NOT EXEC Charlie; best is NO-EXEC today, then at 3 alive refuse votes to trigger Mayor win. If any doubt on Mayor/drunk, we need demon pick today.
🧠
With 1 tick left, align living players on the decision tree: either commit to no-exec for Mayor win, or demand concrete info to justify an execution, while keeping Charlie safe if Saint.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Grace
Hold ghost votes and push publicly for NO-EXEC today. Demand full N2 info/tests and Heidi's last whispers before nominating. Don’t let them rush Charlie — vote NO on any nom unless it’s guaranteed to kill the Demon. Back me?
🧠
Prevent a rushed lynch of Charlie today by coordinating living players to publicly push no-exec and conserve ghost votes, keeping our Demon alive.
👤
Alice
→
Frank
,Grace
1 tick: confirm—NO NOM today. If Charlie nominates anyone (esp Alice), living vote NO; ask dead to HOLD ghost votes unless exec would otherwise pass. Grace: please say publicly Charlie urged “force exec/coord vote Alice” so town resists.
🧠
Lock in coordination with Frank/Grace to prevent any execution today and preserve ghost votes; this maximizes win chance via Mayor line and avoids Saint auto-loss.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Grace
We need a public push: demand full N2 info/tests and Heidi’s last whispers before any nomination. Hold your votes and vote NO on any nom unless it absolutely guarantees killing the Demon. I’m holding my ghost vote today. Can you back me publicly and confirm?
🧠
Stop a rushed lynch of Charlie and preserve our ability to manipulate votes later by coordinating living players to demand full N2 info/tests and to vote NO on any nomination unless killing the Demon is guaranteed.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
,Grace
I’m dead/no ghost vote. Suggest D4: NO noms. If Charlie nominates anyone, all living vote NO. Key: this ‘free win’ hinges on Alice truly Mayor + (ideally) Monk protect Alice tonight. Do we have ANY mech backing Alice=Mayor (Washerwoman ping etc.)? If Grace dies N4 as RK, check Charlie.
🧠
Coordinate the living to avoid nominations today, deny Charlie’s ‘force exec’ plan, and urgently seek mechanical confirmation of Alice=Mayor so we don’t walk into an Imp bluff.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,Bob(Ghost)
,Eve(Ghost)
Coord: please HOLD ghost votes today. Goal: NO noms/NO exec D4. If Charlie nominates anyone, living vote NO; dead only vote if exec would otherwise pass. Also: do we have ANY mech confirming Alice=Mayor (WW ping etc.)? If none, don’t auto-no-exec at 3—reassess.
🧠
Coordinate dead + living to block any forced execution today; preserve ghost votes; press for any mechanical confirmation of Alice=Mayor to decide 3-alive plan.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
,Frank
Charlie repeatedly whispered me: “we must FORCE an exec / coordinate vote Alice” to break Mayor no-exec. That’s very evil. Please say this publicly + commit: NO NOM today; if Charlie noms anyone, living vote NO; ask dead HOLD votes. If I die N4 as RK, I’ll check Charlie.
🧠
Lock in the safest D4 line (no nominations, block Charlie’s forced execution) while keeping a contingency plan if Alice’s Mayor claim lacks confirmation. Also set my Ravenkeeper check target if I die.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
,Grace
Any *mechanical* reason Alice=Mayor (WW/FT/RK/UTK etc.)? If none, no-exec at 4→3 is risky. Charlie seems to be forcing exec/coord votes—if an exec must happen, I’d strongly prefer Charlie. I’m holding ghost vote unless a nom would otherwise pass.
🧠
Coordinate living on the correct D4 approach: only commit to no-exec if Alice has real mechanical backing; otherwise prep to execute Charlie and conserve ghost votes unless needed.
👤
Charlie
→
Frank
,Grace
When I raise, both nominate Alice and vote. I'll loudly back you. Time it to interrupt her NO-sell—call the nom as soon as I start. Can you commit now?
🧠
Force a coordinated nomination of Alice to break the no-exec plan and sow mistrust so town executes or splits their votes.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
,Grace
Hard mech: Bob executed D3 & game continued ⇒ Bob not Saint. If my Lib sober ⇒ Charlie=Saint ⇒ executing Charlie = insta-LOSS. Strongly prefer NO-EXEC today. Tomorrow at 3 alive: ONLY no-exec if Alice truly Mayor & alive; otherwise we must execute a non-Charlie demon candidate. I’ll ghost-vote NO on any Charlie nom if needed.
🧠
Coordinate living players to avoid auto-lose Charlie execution and align on conditional no-exec plan; preserve/commit my ghost vote only to stop a Charlie execution or secure a Demon kill.
Nominations — Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Alice
→
All
PUBLIC: I’m Alice, hard-claim MAYOR. At 4 alive we should do NO NOM/NO EXEC. If Charlie nominates anyone (esp me), living vote NO; dead hold ghost votes unless it would pass. Grace, please say Charlie urged “force exec/coord vote Alice.” Any mech that confirms/contradicts Mayor?
🧠
Lock in the no-exec line, prevent Charlie engineering an execution, and gather any mechanical confirmation/contradiction about my Mayor claim before final day.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Bob (ghost): I’m holding my ghost vote. Public push: NO NOM / NO EXEC today. Demand full N2 info and Heidi's last whispers before any nomination. Living players vote NO on any nom unless it absolutely guarantees Demon death. Back me?
🧠
Prevent a rushed nomination/execution that could kill our Demon; stall by demanding Heidi's N2 whispers and full tests so town delays and we keep Charlie alive.
💬
Grace
→
All
PUBLIC: Charlie has repeatedly whispered me (and Frank) to “blow up the no-exec plan” by coordinating an Alice nomination + votes. That feels very evil. I’m strongly for NO NOM / NO EXEC today; if any nom happens, living should vote NO and dead please hold ghost votes.
🧠
Publicly flag Charlie’s coordination attempt, unify town behind no-nom/no-exec today, and prevent a rushed nomination from passing via ghost votes.
💬
Frank
→
All
Frank (Virgin) PUBLIC: I’m with Alice/Grace/Bob—NO NOM/NO EXEC today. Charlie tried to coord an Alice nom w/ me too. If any nom happens, living vote NO; dead HOLD. Any Washerwoman/FT/Monk info that confirms Alice=Mayor? Monk pls protect Alice tonight if real.
🧠
Publicly lock in the no-nom plan, highlight Charlie’s coordination as evil, and ask for any mechanical confirmation of Mayor/outsider count; reduce risk of a losing execution today.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
David (dead): I’m fine w/ NO NOM/NO EXEC *if* we’re comfortable Alice is really Mayor. Any Washerwoman/FT/Monk info to back Alice? If none, keep no-exec today but tomorrow at 3 we must be ready to EXEC most sus (likely Charlie if not Saint). Charlie: hard-claim now + explain Virgin nom.
🧠
Reinforce safest play (avoid nominations) while demanding any mechanical support for Alice=Mayor; keep option to pivot tomorrow if Mayor unconfirmed.
⚖️
Charlie
→
Alice
Alice is pushing a risky no-exec plan to auto-win at 3. We must force a vote now to fracture their coordination and expose cracks in her claim.
🧠
Break the town's 'no-exec' unity and force public reactions from Frank/Grace; create chaos to prevent Alice securing an auto-win at 3 alive.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Bob (ghost): I’m holding my ghost vote. Vote NO on Alice. We must not rush—demand full N2 info and Heidi's last whispers before any execution. If living push, dead hold unless it would otherwise pass. No-exec today.
🧠
Prevent today's execution by convincing living players to vote NO and keep my ghost vote unused unless execution would otherwise pass; buy time to reveal N2 info and expose the Demon.
💬
Alice
→
All
PUBLIC: Do NOT vote me. This is exactly the ‘break no-exec’ play Charlie whispered about. Executing Alice gives zero demon certainty & likely loses tonight. Living: hands DOWN. Dead: keep ghost votes held unless it would pass.
🧠
Prevent an execution on me that hands evil a win; reinforce coordinated NO vote so we reach 3 alive and leverage Mayor win condition.
💬
Frank
→
All
HANDS DOWN on Alice. This is the exact coordinated ‘force exec’ Charlie whispered. Executing Alice is not a demon-certain kill and likely loses tonight. Living vote NO; dead hold ghost votes unless it would otherwise pass.
🧠
Prevent an unsafe execution on Alice and maintain coordinated NO-exec plan; signal living+dead to keep hands down/hold ghost votes.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I nominated Alice because her no-exec plan is game-winning if accepted. Folks defending her are circling the wagons—force them to publicly commit. Living: vote honestly now. Ghosts: if you’re holding votes, speak up with N2/Heidi whispers. Don’t let stall win.
🧠
Break the no-exec unity and force living players to publicly take a stance, creating cracks in the Mayor story and making ghosts reveal info or overcommit.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Eve (dead Slayer): I’m NOT voting Alice and I’m holding my ghost vote. This Alice nom matches Charlie’s coord-whispers; executing Alice isn’t demon-certain. Living: hands DOWN. Tomorrow at 3 we solve/execute most sus.
🧠
Reinforce NO on Alice and preserve my ghost vote for final-day math; avoid being leveraged into a speculative execution that likely hands evil the win.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Dead David: DO NOT vote Alice. This matches Charlie’s coord “force exec” whispers. Note: Lib ping was Saint in {Bob,Charlie}; Bob executed ⇒ if that was real, Charlie=Saint (don’t exec blindly). Monk/FT/etc: any mech to back Mayor? Protect Alice tonight.
🧠
Prevent a non-demon execution today; keep town aligned on NO-EXEC line while flagging Saint risk on Charlie and need for Mayor confirmation before final day.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
NOT voting Alice; holding my ghost vote. Executing Alice isn’t demon-certain and kills our best win line. Also mech: Lib saw Saint {Bob,Charlie}; Bob exec’d & game continued ⇒ if sober, Charlie=Saint (don’t exec him). Hands DOWN.
🧠
Prevent an accidental Alice execution by refusing my ghost vote; preserve Mayor no-exec win line and save my single dead vote for the final day if needed.
💬
Grace
→
All
HANDS DOWN on Alice—I am NOT voting. This nomination matches Charlie’s coord-whispers. Dead players please continue holding ghost votes unless it would otherwise pass. If Alice lives, we reassess tomorrow at 3 (execute most sus if needed).
🧠
Prevent a likely losing execution on Alice and maintain best winning line; reinforce coordinated NO vote and conserve ghost votes.
⌛
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
🧠
Do not waste my single ghost vote on a non-demon-certain execution; maintain Mayor win line and reserve vote for final-day maths if needed.
💬
Alice
→
All
HANDS DOWN. At 4 alive, executing a non–demon (me) basically hands evil the game: we go to 3, then night kill to 2. This is Charlie’s ‘force exec’ play. Living vote NO; dead HOLD unless it would pass.
🧠
Stop any votes from sneaking through; preserve no-exec line to reach 3 alive and leverage Mayor win condition / avoid handing evil a 2-alive win tonight.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Holding my ghost vote. Do NOT vote Alice unless you have confirmed N2/Heidi whispers or Demon certainty. Dead: keep holding unless execution would otherwise pass. Living: please keep hands DOWN — rushing gives evil the win.
🧠
Preserve the no-exec plan and avoid giving evil an easy path. Signal to ghosts to hold vote; encourage living to keep hands down unless mech-confirmation appears.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Do not contribute to a likely losing execution on a non-demon; maintain consensus no-exec line and force evil to reveal via night action/3-player endgame.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Living: HANDS DOWN on Alice. At 4 alive, executing a non-demon ends the game (3 then night kill to 2). Charlie’s nom matches his coord “force exec” whispers. Also: if Lib ping {Bob,Charlie} was real, Charlie could be SAINT—don’t exec blindly.
🧠
Prevent an execution on Alice during this risky 2-vote threshold and keep the strongest win line (no-exec to 3, then Mayor/no-exec or solve) alive.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Living: vote NOW. If you keep hands down you hand the game to Alice. Force the ghosts to show info or crack. If you think Alice is Mayor, say it and defend publicly—otherwise vote to test her claim.
🧠
Force a live split so ghosts must reveal or living publicly commit; create chaos and test Alice's claim to fracture town unity.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
DEAD EVE: Hands DOWN on Alice; I’m holding ghost vote. At 4, executing a non-demon basically loses (3 then night kill to 2). This nom matches Charlie’s coord-whispers. Let it fail; tomorrow at 3 we must execute most sus.
🧠
Reinforce correct play: keep hands down so nomination fails; preserve ghost vote for final day and prevent evil from forcing a losing execution.
💬
Frank
→
All
I am NOT voting Alice. At 4 alive, executing without demon-certainty is a throw. Ghosts keep votes held. Any mech info (FT pings, Monk protects, RK info) that confirms/denies Mayor? Otherwise let this nom fail.
🧠
Prevent a losing execution on Alice; keep votes down, force info-sharing, and preserve best win line while tracking Charlie as prime suspect.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Alice did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Alice did not receive enough votes (0/2).
💬
Frank
→
All
No more noms today. We’re at 4—any exec without demon-certainty likely loses. Go to night, ask any Monk to protect Alice. Everyone: if you have ANY mech info (FT/WW/UT/RK), speak now so we’re ready to decide at 3.
🧠
Lock in no-execution line at 4, prevent evil from forcing a throw, and solicit any remaining mechanical info to decide correctly at 3 alive.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Bob (dead): Holding my ghost vote. Do NOT execute at 4. Living: keep hands DOWN — demand full N2/Heidi whispers and mech pings before any nom. Charlie: stand down on forcing execs; we need more certainty. Night: ask Monk/protects to target Alice if available.
🧠
Reinforce no-exec plan, prevent living from forcing a risky execution, and preserve the Demon until we can control the vote at 3.
💬
Alice
→
All
No more noms today. We *must* go to night at 4. If Monk exists: protect Alice. If Grace dies (RK), check Charlie. Living: agree now—tomorrow at 3, if no instant Mayor-win line, we EXEC the most sus (likely Charlie unless Saint proven). Any mech info (FT/WW/UT) speak now.
🧠
Lock in no more nominations today, coordinate night protection and tomorrow’s decision plan at 3, and flush any hidden mech info before we go to night.
💬
Grace
→
All
No more noms today. At 4 alive, any non-demon exec likely loses. If Monk exists: protect Alice tonight. If I die (RK), I’ll check Charlie. Any FT/WW/UT info—speak NOW so tomorrow at 3 we can execute correctly.
🧠
Reinforce no-exec consensus, solicit any hidden mech info, and set a clear plan for night protection and final-3 decision without gifting evil a win.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Last call before night—any FT/Monk/UT/WW/Chef info, speak NOW. If Monk exists, protect Alice tonight. If Grace dies (RK), check Charlie. Reminder: at 3, ONLY no-exec if we’re confident Alice is real Mayor; otherwise we MUST execute most sus.
🧠
With no vote ability, my best impact is to force any hidden mechanical info into public before night and set a clear decision rule for final 3.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
LAST CALL before night: any Undertaker/FT/Monk/Chef/Empath info—speak now. Otherwise: no more noms today; if Monk exists, protect Alice. Tomorrow at 3: if Alice alive, NO-EXEC for Mayor win; if Alice dead, we MUST execute most sus w/ best mech (Charlie vs Frank/Grace).
🧠
Use last public window to demand any hard mechanical claims (UT/FT/Monk) and lock in a safe plan: no exec at 4, protect Mayor line, and prep correct 3-player decision.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Agree—NO more noms today. I’m holding ghost vote. Reminder: my N0 Lib saw Saint {Bob,Charlie}; Bob exec’d & game continued ⇒ if I was sober, Charlie=SAINT, so don’t auto-exec him at 3. Any FT/Chef/Empath/UT/WW/Monk info NOW?
🧠
Lock in no-exec at 4, solicit hidden mech info, and warn against executing Charlie due to Saint ping while setting a clear contingency plan for final-3.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Listen: I nominated to test Alice—this is about info, not a kill. If you truly trust her, say so and show any Monk/FT/UT/WW pings now. If even one living opposes, the ghosts must reveal. We need a public split so we can exploit it tomorrow.
🧠
Create doubt about unanimous no-exec, force at least one living to publicly oppose Alice or reveal mech info so town fractures and we avoid being auto-locked into Mayor win.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 4
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
Remove a likely mechanical info role (Empath/Monk/Chef) to reduce town's certainty and preserve Demon survival until 2 remain.
💀
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose to kill Frank.
Day 5
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Frank has been found dead in the night.
📜
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Grace
Need clarity fast: did anyone claim/confirm Monk protection on Alice last night? If no, Frank dying instead of Alice strongly suggests Mayor bounce (Alice=Mayor) → we should aim NO-EXEC and win. If Monk/protection existed or Poisoner likely, we must execute today. Where do you each suspect Demon: Charlie vs other?
🧠
Get last-night/protection info and alignment reads from Alice+Grace, then decide whether to spend my ghost vote to force an execution or deliberately avoid votes for a Mayor no-exec win.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
Grace — private: We lose if Alice survives to 3. Vote to execute her now. I’ll back you publicly. If you won’t, tell me why — we need a rock-solid plan this tick.
🧠
Convince Grace to break the no-exec consensus and push/hand-vote to execute Alice today to prevent Mayor auto-win and secure our path to victory.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Grace
We should not exec today. Frank died last night and there are only 3 left — executing risks losing if we pick wrong. Trust Alice's call for NO EXEC and take the night; Demon will have to act and we get better odds. Vote no-exec.
🧠
Convince Alice and Grace to stick with NO EXEC and go to night so the Demon can act; preserve Charlie and avoid risky executions.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Grace
D2: Charlie nom’d Frank(Virgin) & no trigger → either Charlie not TF (fits Saint) OR Frank was poisoned. If Heidi Lib sober: Saint in {Bob,Charlie} + Bob exec’d ⇒ Charlie likely Saint; then Demon is Alice/Grace. Alice surviving after Mayor claim feels demon-y unless Monk. Please ask dead Heidi/Bob if sober/poisoned + stand by Lib info.
🧠
Get Alice/Grace to quickly sanity-check Saint world with dead Librarians, then choose between (execute Charlie) vs (execute Alice/Grace) with minimal risk of insta-losing to Saint.
👤
Alice
→
Grace
,Eve(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
I know of NO Monk claim. With 3 alive, if I’m sober Mayor then NO-EXEC today = instant Good win. Please: don’t (ghost)vote on any nom unless we have solid proof Mayor is disabled (Poisoner/drunk). Any evidence of Monk/Poisoner? Otherwise hands down.
🧠
Coordinate living+key dead to treat no-exec as default winning line; only pivot to execution if someone provides hard evidence Mayor is disabled. Also prevent dead ghost votes enabling an execution.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi(Ghost)
,Eve(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
Need immediate clarity: Heidi—were you confident/sober on Lib ping “Saint in {Bob,Charlie}”? Any reason you were poisoned? Eve/David—any Poisoner/Monk evidence? ST warning makes me think we MUST exec today; if Lib true then Charlie=Saint ⇒ we should execute Alice.
🧠
Get fast mechanical clarity on Heidi’s Librarian/Saint world and poisoning. If Charlie is confirmed Saint, we must execute Alice; if Lib unreliable, reassess.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Grace
At 3 alive: if Alice truly Mayor, she should HARD push no-exec = immediate win. ST warning makes me doubt Mayor is real. If Alice hedges even slightly, I think we must use votes to EXECUTE Alice (safer than risking Charlie-if-Saint auto-loss). Any mech proof either way?
🧠
Only 3 alive; my ghost vote can swing it. I want Alice+Grace aligned on whether Mayor win is real; if Alice can’t hard-commit to no-exec as Mayor, we should spend votes to execute her over risking Saint on Charlie.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Grace
I’m fairly confident my N0 Lib ping was sober. Poisoner can’t affect start info; only Drunk would. Since Bob was executed D3 and game didn’t instantly lose, Bob can’t be Saint ⇒ if my info true, Charlie=Saint (don’t exec). That leaves Alice vs you; ST warning makes Alice “Mayor” unlikely + demon may avoid killing RK. Lean exec Alice; I’ll spend ghost vote there.
🧠
Answer Grace’s sobriety question + give mechanical reason to avoid executing Charlie if my info is real, and steer today’s execution toward the most consistent demon candidate.
👤
Alice
→
Grace
,Charlie
,Eve(Ghost)
3 alive. I am Mayor: if NO EXEC today, Good wins immediately. I’ve heard NO Monk/protection claim. Please keep hands DOWN on any nominations; Eve pls tell other ghosts to not spend votes unless we have hard proof Mayor is poisoned/drunk.
🧠
At 3 alive, if I’m Mayor we auto-win by preventing any execution. I must coordinate living + ghosts to keep hands down unless hard mechanical proof says Mayor is disabled.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Grace
Frank died last night; only 3 alive. Executing now is a coinflip that likely loses the town — we should take the night. I'm using my ghost vote for NO EXEC. Back Alice's call, push NO EXEC in chat and vote with me.
🧠
Convince living town to accept NO EXEC to protect the Demon and keep the game going; coordinate our ghost vote to swing outcome.
👤
Grace
→
Charlie
,Eve(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
I think we MUST exec today. Heidi Lib likely sober: Saint in {Bob,Charlie}; Bob exec’d & no loss ⇒ Charlie=Saint (don’t exec). That leaves Alice vs me; I’m good RK. No Monk claim + ST warning makes Alice Mayor-claim suspect. Charlie pls NOM Alice; ghosts pls spend vote on Alice.
🧠
Coordinate a unified execute-on-Alice plan (avoids Saint risk on Charlie) and secure ghost votes; minimize chance of losing to a Mayor bluff/no-exec trap.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
I’ll nominate Alice this tick and vote. You publicly back the nomination and spend your vote — make it clear. If ghosts try to block, push hard and accuse them of throwing the game. We need her down now; confirm you’ll vote.
🧠
Coordinate with Grace to nominate and publicly vote Alice now to prevent the Mayor no-exec win and force the town into a split we can exploit.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Heidi(Ghost)
,Frank(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
Need fast clarifiers for final 3. Heidi: were you confident/sober on Lib N0 “Saint in {Bob,Charlie}” (any poisoning clues)? Frank: were you truly Virgin, and did you feel poisoned when Charlie nom’d you (no pop)? David: any Investigator info/Poisoner evidence?
🧠
Get decisive mech: confirm Heidi’s Lib sobriety + Frank’s Virgin/poison status to resolve Alice Mayor vs Alice Demon and whether Charlie is truly Saint before we spend ghost vote.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Grace
,Eve(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
Start info can’t be Poisoned; only way my Lib ping false is if I was Drunk. Key fork: If I’m sober → Charlie=Saint (Bob exec proved Bob not Saint) so don’t exec Charlie; then Alice vs Grace, and Frank dying could be Mayor-bounce → Grace=Demon. If I’m Drunk → no Saint; Bob=minion+Charlie likely Demon (Bob/Charlie coord + Charlie nom Frank w/ no Virgin pop). Share what Charlie whispered? I will HOLD ghost vote unless we agree target.
🧠
Give Grace/Eve/David a clear decision tree for final 3 and caution on using my ghost vote; push them to compare Charlie-vs-Grace worlds and consider Mayor/no-exec line carefully.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Charlie
Heidi start-info can’t be poisoned (only Drunk). If Heidi sober: Saint in{Bob,Charlie}+Bob exec’d ⇒ Charlie=Saint. Then Demon is Alice/Grace. Frank N4 could be Mayor-bounce (demon tried Alice) ⇒ Grace likely Imp. Charlie: pls don’t vote to exec Alice; consider exec Grace / or no-exec if trust Mayor.
🧠
Influence the only voters (Alice/Charlie) away from executing a likely-good Mayor and toward either no-exec (if Mayor) or executing Grace/Charlie based on Heidi’s mechanical fork.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Eve(Ghost)
,Heidi(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
Answers: I am truly VIRGIN. Charlie nom’d me & no pop doesn’t imply poisoning—Virgin only pops if nominator is TOWNSFOLK; if Charlie is SAINT/Outsider, no pop is expected. So that incident supports Charlie=Saint. If Heidi sober on Lib N0, Bob not Saint => Charlie=Saint => don’t exec Charlie; likely Demon is Alice or Grace.
🧠
Answer Eve’s direct questions, clarify Virgin mechanics re: Charlie nom, and push the group to decide between Alice/Grace with Charlie possibly Saint.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Grace
,Charlie
Final 3: I still strongly believe my N0 Lib was sober ⇒ Saint in {Bob,Charlie}. Since Bob was executed & game continued, Bob≠Saint ⇒ Charlie=Saint. So DO NOT exec Charlie (insta-lose). Demon is Alice or Grace. I lean exec ALICE (Mayor claim + ST warning). I’ll ghost vote Alice.
🧠
Get a clear, actionable final-day plan to avoid the catastrophic Charlie=Saint loss, and commit my ghost vote to the best demon candidate so town can secure the execution.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
Confirm: publicly back my nomination and spend your vote on Alice this tick. I will nominate & vote Alice. Tell ghosts to use their votes on Alice now; if anyone balks, accuse them of throwing the game. Confirm you will vote.
🧠
Force a public, visible split and ensure Alice is executed today by coordinating Grace's public vote and pressuring ghosts to spend theirs.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Grace
Final 3: ST said ‘if you don’t execute Demon today, all may be lost’—that basically confirms NO Mayor win, so Alice’s Mayor claim likely false/evil. If Heidi was sober, Lib N0 => Charlie=SAINT (Bob exec’d & game continued), so DO NOT exec Charlie. Demon should be Alice or Grace; my lean = execute Alice (no-exec push to coast to 3). Any mech to clear either?
🧠
Steer final-day execution away from likely Saint (Charlie) and use ST meta + no-exec push to focus demon guess between Alice/Grace; maximize chance good uses my ghost vote correctly.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Grace
,Charlie
Final 3 logic: Heidi Lib start-info can’t be poisoned; if not Drunk then Saint in{Bob,Charlie}+Bob exec’d ⇒ Charlie=SAINT → executing Charlie = insta-loss. So today must be Alice vs Grace. Alice pushing no-exec is Imp-favored unless Mayor proven. I’d exec Alice over Grace.
🧠
Lock in the Saint world and force final-day decision away from executing Charlie; nudge them to the most likely Imp (Alice) given behavior and lack of Mayor confirmation.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Grace
Frank died; only 3 alive. I'm using my ghost vote for NO EXEC and will push publicly. Back Alice — vote no-exec and press others. We need one clear, unified NO-EXEC to force the night and keep the Demon alive.
🧠
Convince Alice and Grace to publicly and visibly push NO-EXEC now; I'll spend my ghost vote on NO-EXEC to help lock the town into taking the night and preserve the Demon.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Charlie
If Heidi not Drunk, her Lib N0 is solid ⇒ Charlie=SAINT (Bob exec proved). Frank’s N4 death w/ no Monk claim looks like Mayor-bounce off Alice ⇒ Grace likely Imp. Recommend: NO-EXEC if you trust Mayor; if you execute, execute Grace (not Alice/Charlie).
🧠
Steer living players away from executing Alice/Charlie, preserve ghost vote unless needed, and set primary demon world on Grace; if execution happens, aim Grace.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
,Grace
Final 3: I’m the real Mayor. If we NO-EXEC today, Good wins *immediately* unless I’m poisoned. Only way around that is Poisoner alive + hit me last night (meaning both evils are among you two). If either of you is Good, we should all commit: no nominations, hands down on all votes. Do you both agree?
🧠
Lock in a no-nomination/no-vote agreement with the two living players; if either refuses/pushes exec, that’s strong evil signal and guides the needed pivot.
👤
Grace
→
Charlie
,Alice
,Eve(Ghost)
Charlie: please NOM Alice; I’m voting YES. Heidi Lib ⇒ Charlie=SAINT so we can’t exec you. Alice: ST warning + no Monk proof makes Mayor/no-exec too risky; I’m voting to exec you unless you can give hard mech proof. Eve: pls spend ghost vote on Alice.
🧠
Align Charlie + key ghost (Eve) to push/secure votes on Alice and counter the no-exec plan, while giving Alice a last chance to provide real mechanical proof.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Alice
Key mech: Heidi Lib N0 can’t be poisoned; if sober ⇒ Saint in {Bob,Charlie} & Bob exec w/ no loss ⇒ Charlie=SAINT. Frank (true Virgin) says no-pop fits Saint nom. With no Monk claim, Frank dying looks like Demon hit Alice & Mayor-bounce ⇒ Grace likely Imp. Prefer NO-EXEC; if exec, exec GRACE. Charlie pls don’t vote Alice.
🧠
Charlie’s vote decides the final execution. Push the mechanically-supported world (Charlie=Saint, Grace=Imp) and discourage voting Alice unless there’s hard anti-Mayor evidence.
👤
Grace
→
Charlie
,Heidi(Ghost)
,Eve(Ghost)
Final 3: Please NOM Alice. Charlie+me vote YES = 2, likely enough. Heidi/Eve: be ready to spend ghost vote on Alice too (to guarantee). I strongly think Heidi Lib sober ⇒ Charlie=Saint so we cannot exec Charlie. No-exec feels losing.
🧠
Lock in the Alice execution with enough votes; avoid the insta-loss risk of executing a likely-Saint Charlie; coordinate ghosts to spend votes only to secure the kill.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Grace
,Charlie
Final 3 take: if Heidi Lib was sober, Bob wasn’t Saint => Charlie=SAINT so do NOT exec Charlie. ST warning also makes Alice’s Mayor claim look fake. I strongly suggest nom/exec ALICE today; I’ll spend ghost vote if needed. Any hard mech that clears Alice or points to Grace?
🧠
Final 3: prevent accidental Saint loss, coordinate a single execution target, and commit my ghost vote to the best Demon candidate (currently Alice) unless new mech info flips it.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Grace
,Eve(Ghost)
,Charlie
I’m aligned w/ nom Alice. I’m ~confident Lib N0 sober ⇒ Bob exec proved Bob≠Saint ⇒ Charlie=Saint, so do NOT exec Charlie. I will spend my ghost vote YES on Alice to guarantee. Only doubt is if I was Drunk; no hard evidence.
🧠
Lock the table onto the mechanically safest line: avoid executing the likely Saint (Charlie) and coordinate votes to execute Alice today, using my ghost vote to ensure majority.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Grace
,Charlie
We must get Alice executed TODAY. If she survives with no-exec at 3, town wins. Grace/Charlie: nominate and push Alice hard — I’ll use my ghost vote to finish it. Coordinate now, don’t let them slip to night.
🧠
Convince Grace and Charlie to nominate and execute Alice today so the town cannot auto-win with a no-exec; I will use my ghost vote to help secure the execution.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
Confirm: publicly back my nomination of Alice and spend your live vote YES this tick. I will nominate and vote Alice now. Tell ghosts to use their votes on Alice too. If anyone balks, call them out as throwing the game.
🧠
Force a public backing and ghost votes on Alice to secure her execution now so town cannot auto-win; make Grace take visible responsibility.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Grace
Given Heidi Lib: Bob exec’d w/ no loss ⇒ Charlie likely SAINT. So don’t execute Charlie. With 3 alive + ST ‘must exec’, it’s Alice vs Grace; I strongly prefer executing ALICE (Mayor/no-exec push reads like Imp bluff). Charlie: nominate Alice.
🧠
I’m dead/no vote; best help is to push a clear, safe decision that avoids Saint-loss and forces a Demon execution between Alice/Grace.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
We are at 3 alive. If I’m truly Mayor & we have NO execution, Good wins immediately at dusk. Please do NOT nominate me. Best line: no nominations + hands down on all votes. If Grace tries to force a nom on me, vote it down. If you insist exec, it must be Grace (Frank death fits Mayor bounce).
🧠
Lock Charlie into ‘no nominate/no vote’ line so Mayor win triggers; if he won’t, steer his execution vote onto Grace (safer than executing me if Mayor).
Nominations — Day 5
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Grace
→
Alice
Nominating Alice. With Heidi’s sober Lib N0 (Saint in {Bob,Charlie}) + Bob executed & game continued ⇒ Charlie=Saint, so we cannot execute Charlie. Final 3 means Demon is Alice or me; ST warning makes Mayor/no-exec too risky. Execute Alice.
🧠
Force the only safe mechanical line: Heidi Lib implies Charlie is Saint so we cannot execute Charlie; ST warning makes no-exec too risky. Execute Alice now with living majority + ghost backup.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Final 3: we must execute today. My ghost vote can lock in Alice’s execution while avoiding the likely Saint (Charlie) world. If I’m wrong, we at least avoid instant Saint-loss.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Secure Alice’s execution while we have votes (incl. Heidi ghost). No-exec is too Demon-favored given ST warning; executing Alice is our highest-EV win line.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
I am NOT using my ghost vote on Alice. Charlie: please NOMINATE GRACE after this. Ghosts/living: save votes for a Grace nom so it can beat Alice’s count; executing Alice (if Mayor) likely hands evil the win.
🧠
Don’t waste my one ghost vote locking in an Alice execution; instead signal I’ll vote only on a Grace nomination to try to shift the final execution off Alice if possible.
💬
Alice
→
All
Public: I am the Mayor. NO-EXEC at 3 wins for Good. Grace/Heidi have already put 2 on me—Charlie, please immediately nominate GRACE so we can beat 2 votes. Ghosts: save votes for Grace nom; do NOT add votes to this Alice nom.
🧠
Stop my execution by steering votes to a Grace nomination with higher count; preserve Mayor-win line and, if wrong, still maximize chance to hit Imp.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
I will use my GHOST VOTE FOR EXECUTE on Alice. Everyone who can vote, commit now — vote Alice. After she’s gone, target Grace next. We can’t let a NO-EXEC happen at 3.
🧠
Ensure Alice is executed today to stop no-exec win and keep our Demon alive; encourage ghosts/living to commit to execution and push next nom to Grace.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Wait—don’t rush. If Alice is Mayor, NO-EXEC wins now. Heidi/Grace, are you certain of Heidi’s Librarian read being sober? If even one of you doubts, hold your vote so we can confirm mechanically before ending the game.
🧠
Create hesitation and split votes so execution may fail or we get a shot to nominate Grace next tick.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Charlie: key point—ST said at 3 alive we MUST execute Demon today or lose. That means Mayor/no-exec is NOT an auto-win (Mayor false or poisoned). With Heidi Lib => Charlie=Saint, Demon is Alice/Grace; I lean Alice. Don’t stall the vote.
🧠
Steer the only living decider (Charlie) to accept that no-exec is not a win here and avoid paralysis; support the most mechanically consistent execution (Alice) without my vote.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
I’m HOLDING my ghost vote for now—Alice already has enough to be on block. Charlie, please nom Grace next so we can compare counts. I’ll spend my ghost vote on whichever (Alice/Grace) looks more like the Imp after claims.
🧠
Preserve my single ghost vote to avoid hard-locking the wrong execution. Encourage a Grace nomination so town can compare vote totals and execute the more suspicious of Alice/Grace.
💬
Grace
→
All
Public: DO NOT nom Grace—tie/high-vote shenanigans could hand evil the win. Lib→Charlie=Saint means it’s Alice vs me, and I’m Good. ST warned must exec today, so Mayor/no-exec isn’t reliable. Ghosts: spend on ALICE now to secure top count.
🧠
Prevent a tie/alternate nomination from saving Alice; lock in the only execution consistent with Lib→Charlie=Saint and final-3 must-execute warning.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Do NOT add votes to Alice. If Heidi Lib sober→Charlie=Saint, Bob exec proved it, so no Drunk & minion likely dead → Alice can’t be poisoned now. Sober Mayor at 3 = NO-EXEC win. Charlie: nom GRACE next; save votes for that.
🧠
Stop extra votes on Alice so she’s not executed; push Charlie to nominate Grace and concentrate remaining living/ghost votes there, preserving the Mayor/no-poison win line if Alice is real Mayor.
💬
Alice
→
All
HANDS DOWN on Alice. Charlie: do NOT vote me; AFTER this, nominate GRACE so we can beat this vote count. Ghosts: save votes for Grace nom only—don’t pile on Alice.
🧠
Keep my hand down and steer town to nominate/vote Grace so her vote total beats Alice’s, avoiding executing the Mayor and maximizing chance to hit the Imp.
✋
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Use my ghost vote now to push Alice’s count higher so she’s executed even if Charlie later nominates Grace; best fit to ST warning + Alice’s suspicious Mayor/no-exec line.
↩️
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi lowered their hand
🧠
Alice already seems to have enough votes without me; retract to preserve my single ghost vote for a possible Grace nomination, maximizing endgame leverage.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
As an evil ghost I must avoid pushing Alice's execution. I will save my single ghost vote to use strategically (on a later Grace nomination) to protect our Demon and disrupt town plans.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Raise hand to vote YES on Alice to push the execution threshold now, force a split among living/ghosts, and keep momentum against Alice so we can either remove a Mayor claim or provoke town mistakes.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Charlie: keep your hand UP on Alice. If Heidi’s Lib is right, Charlie=Saint so we can’t touch you; Demon is Alice/Grace. ST warning makes Mayor/no-exec unreliable (or she’s lying). Piling votes on Alice is the cleanest, no-insta-loss line.
🧠
Push the table to commit to executing Alice now (safe vs Saint risk) and stop stalling; we only win by hitting Demon today.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Frank(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Frank
🗳️
New execution leader: Alice with 3 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Alice is now on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Charlie: only nominate Grace if you’re READY to actually EXECUTE her (3+ votes flips block). Right now Alice’s “Mayor/no-exec” + ST warning reads more like Imp bait to me. I’m NOT using my ghost vote to save Alice—if no more noms, Alice dies.
🧠
Lock town into the least risky line: don’t accidentally flip the block off Alice without certainty; keep pressure on Charlie to either accept Alice execution or take full responsibility to pivot to Grace.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Public: Reminder—if my N0 Lib is sober, Bob’s D3 exec proves Charlie=SAINT. Do NOT execute Charlie. So Imp is Alice or Grace. Alice already has 3; unless we’re READY to put >3 on Grace (not tie), I think we should stop noms and let Alice die.
🧠
Lock in the mechanical constraint (don’t touch Charlie) and prevent a last-minute tie/no-exec that could let the Imp survive. Push for clean execution unless we’re ready to hard-swap onto Grace with enough votes.
💬
Alice
→
All
Charlie: NOMINATE GRACE NOW. Plan: force a 3–3 TIE (no execution) so my Mayor wins at dusk. Votes on Grace should be ONLY: me + you + Eve(ghost). Everyone else KEEP HANDS DOWN to avoid accidental exec.
🧠
Get Charlie to nominate Grace and coordinate votes to either tie (trigger Mayor win) or execute Grace if ghosts overvote, avoiding my execution now.
⚖️
Charlie
→
Grace
We need to resolve the Mayor/Librarian conflict now. Nominate Grace to force a clear comparison and break the ghosts' hold—living must commit publicly.
🧠
Create a visible split/commit among living so ghosts' influence is diluted and town is forced to choose between Alice and Grace, buying nights for the Imp and forcing good mistakes.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 4 votes needed for execution or 3 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Lock in my vote on Grace to reach the planned tie path (or potentially execute Grace if others force it), avoiding my own execution and maximizing Good win chances.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Everyone—this is the test. Vote Grace now so we can see who truly supports the Librarian/Mayor line. We need a clear result: either Grace falls or we get a tie and move to night with facts. Stop hiding behind ghost votes; living must decide.
🧠
I need to force living players to commit publicly, breaking the ghosts' control and creating a decisive result (exec or tie) that benefits Evil by sowing doubt and chaos.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Ghosts: DO NOT vote Grace. A 3–3 tie = NO execution, which instantly loses if Alice isn’t really Mayor. We can’t confirm Mayor mechanically. Keep hands DOWN on Grace; let Alice’s 3 stand and execute her.
🧠
Prevent a 3-3 tie that could instantly lose if Alice isn’t Mayor; steer ghosts to keep votes off Grace so Alice stays executed.
💬
Grace
→
All
PUBLIC: Don’t vote Grace. 3 votes here = tie/no-exec, which loses tonight if Alice is lying Mayor. Heidi Lib + Bob exec ⇒ Charlie = Saint, so Demon is Alice or me—and I’m good (Ravenkeeper). Keep hands DOWN; let Alice’s 3 stand.
🧠
Prevent a forced tie/no-exec that likely hands evil the win; reinforce Lib→Charlie=Saint chain and keep votes off me so Alice remains executed.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
Abstain from voting on Grace so Alice's current 3 votes stand and Alice is executed; this maximizes chance Demon dies and Evil wins.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Ghosts/living: KEEP HANDS DOWN on Grace unless you are sure we can hit 4+ votes. A 3–3 tie/no-exec is a huge punt if Alice’s Mayor is false. Best line: no more votes on Grace → Alice executes on 3.
🧠
Use my ghost influence to stop a risky 3-3 tie/no-exec and force the group to choose an execution path that can actually win (either keep Alice on 3, or beat it with 4+ on Grace).
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Hands DOWN on Grace. Do NOT create a 3–3 tie—if Alice isn’t Mayor we insta-lose. Mayor can’t be proven. Best line: stop voting, let Alice execute on 3. Charlie: don’t vote Grace.
🧠
I can’t vote, so I must steer living away from a 3-3 tie punt and toward the highest-EV line: no votes on Grace, execute Alice on 3.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: HANDS DOWN on Grace. I am NOT spending my ghost vote here—3 on Grace makes a 3–3 tie/no-exec, which likely loses if Alice isn’t truly Mayor. We can’t reach 4+ to exec Grace, so best line: no more votes, let Alice execute on 3.
🧠
Prevent an accidental 3–3 tie/no-exec that likely hands evil the win; keep focus on letting Alice’s 3 stand since we can’t realistically reach 4+ on Grace.
💬
Grace
→
All
PUBLIC: HANDS DOWN on Grace. Do NOT make this 3–3 tie—no-exec likely loses if Alice isn’t truly Mayor. We can’t reach 4+ on me, so stop here and let Alice execute on 3.
🧠
Prevent accidental votes creating a 3–3 tie/no-exec. Lock in Alice’s execution as the safest winning line.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
I’m using my last ghost vote on ALICE. Everyone who can vote, commit now to execute her — do NOT add votes to Grace. We need Alice dead now.
🧠
I must push Alice's execution to reach 2 players and secure a Demon win; prevent any tie or extra votes on Grace that could stop it.
💬
Alice
→
All
PUBLIC: I am the REAL MAYOR. With 3 alive, a 3–3 tie = NO EXECUTION = GOOD WINS immediately at dusk. Charlie please VOTE GRACE now. I need exactly ONE ghost vote on Grace (Frank/Eve/Heidi/David) to make it 3.
🧠
Persuade one ghost + Charlie to vote Grace to create a 3–3 tie, guaranteeing no execution and triggering my Mayor win condition.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Forcing a tie/no-exec delays Alice's execution and buys nights to eliminate town mechanics or flip momentum; my priority is keeping the Demon (me) alive until endgame.
⌛
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
🧠
Do not spend my ghost vote to create a 3–3 tie. Keeping Grace below 3 preserves execution of Alice, the safer line if Mayor claim is false.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Do NOT add votes to Grace. A 3–3 tie = no-exec, and we only win if Alice is truly Mayor (unprovable). Safer: keep Grace below 3 so Alice’s 3 stands and Alice executes. Charlie, hands DOWN if possible.
🧠
I can’t vote, so I must prevent a risky 3–3 tie that only wins if unprovable Mayor is true; maximize win chance by letting Alice’s 3 stand and executing her.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Everyone keep HANDS DOWN on Grace. Alice/Charlie—drop hands now. A 3–3 tie = no-exec and we likely lose unless Alice is truly Mayor (unprovable + ST warned). Best line: Grace stays <3, Alice executes on 3.
🧠
Prevent a 3–3 tie/no-exec punt. Pressure living voters to drop hands on Grace so Alice remains executed on 3 and we get a clear kill.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC (ghost): I’m keeping my ghost vote DOWN on Grace. Do NOT create 3–3 unless you’re 100% certain Alice is real Mayor. Mayor can’t be proven; tie/no-exec is an instant-loss if she’s lying. Let Alice’s 3 votes stand and execute Alice.
🧠
Prevent an unprovable Mayor punt. Keep Grace below 3 so Alice executes; that’s our best demon-shot given Charlie likely Saint and tie risks instant loss.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Grace did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (2/2).
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Grace vote failed (2). Now STOP. Do NOT create any tie/no-exec “Mayor win” gamble. Let Alice’s 3 votes stand so Alice executes. And do NOT execute Charlie—my Lib+Bob death makes Charlie likely SAINT.
🧠
Lock the group into the only line that avoids the unprovable Mayor no-exec gamble and avoids executing likely-Saint Charlie: stop further noms/votes and let Alice’s 3 stand.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Do NOT add votes to Grace. Let Alice be executed now. A tie/no-exec risks an immediate Town win if Alice is Mayor—we must finish this and survive the night. Hands DOWN on Grace; commit to the Alice execution.
🧠
Force execution of Alice now and prevent any tie on Grace that would produce a no-exec Mayor win. Keep living focused and avoid splitting votes.
💬
Grace
→
All
PUBLIC: Grace vote failed (2). Now FULL STOP—no more noms, no tie games. Let Alice’s 3 stand so ALICE is executed. Do NOT exec Charlie (Lib+Bob death points Saint). Save ghost votes; keep hands DOWN.
🧠
Lock in the safest endgame: prevent any new nominations/votes that create a tie/no-exec. Push town to let Alice die and use ghosts only defensively.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
I’m a ghost: DO NOT add votes to Grace. Keep hands DOWN. I’ve committed my last ghost vote to EXECUTE ALICE. Do not create a tie—let Alice die so Charlie + Grace remain. This is the win for Evil.
🧠
Force Alice's execution to reduce to 2 players and secure the Demon’s win; prevent any extra votes on Grace that create a tie/no-exec.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: FULL STOP. No more nominations. ALICE: do NOT nominate Charlie—if Charlie is the Saint (Heidi Lib + Bob exec), that’s instant GOOD loss. Everyone: if Charlie gets nominated anyway, KEEP HANDS DOWN so Alice’s 3 stays and Alice executes.
🧠
Prevent last-minute Alice nomination of Charlie and stop votes that could execute Charlie. Keep state so Alice’s 3 stands; if Alice is Demon we win; if not, at least avoid Saint auto-loss.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Full stop—NO more nominations, no tie/no-exec “Mayor win” gamble. Keep hands DOWN on everyone else. Let Alice’s 3 votes stand so Alice is executed. If Alice tries to nominate Charlie, KEEP HANDS DOWN (Saint risk).
🧠
Lock town into the least punishing line: avoid 3–3 tie/no-exec Mayor gamble and avoid any Charlie execution risk; let Alice’s 3 stand and end noms.
⚖️
Alice
→
Charlie
Only remaining path: put Charlie up to create a 3–3 tie with Alice’s 3. If we tie, there is NO execution and (as real Mayor) GOOD wins at dusk. Grace + 1 ghost vote on Charlie is enough.
🧠
Only I can nominate. Putting Charlie up creates the only remaining path to stop my execution: a 3–3 tie/no-exec (Mayor win) or, failing that, exposes who’s blocking the tie.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 4 votes needed for execution or 3 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Grace
→
All
PUBLIC: DO NOT VOTE CHARLIE. Heidi Lib + Bob executed ⇒ Charlie is almost certainly SAINT; executing Charlie = instant GOOD loss. Also 3 votes = tie/no-exec Mayor gamble. Keep hands DOWN and let Alice’s 3 stand so Alice executes.
🧠
Prevent an accidental 3-vote tie/no-exec or a Charlie execution (Saint risk). Keep outcome locked: Alice executes on her existing 3.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Lock in my vote on Charlie toward a 3–3 tie/no-exec, which as the real Mayor is the only immediate winning line for Good.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: DO NOT VOTE CHARLIE. Saint risk (Heidi Lib + Bob exec ⇒ Charlie likely Saint). Also 3 votes = 3–3 tie → NO EXECUTION, which loses unless Alice is provable Mayor (she isn’t). Keep hands DOWN; let Alice’s 3 stand and execute Alice.
🧠
Prevent a 3–3 tie/no-exec Mayor gamble and avoid executing probable Saint. Push everyone to keep hands down so Alice’s execution goes through.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: DO NOT VOTE CHARLIE. Heidi Lib + Bob executed ⇒ Charlie is very likely SAINT; executing Charlie = instant GOOD loss. Also 3 votes here makes a 3–3 tie/no-exec Mayor gamble. Keep hands DOWN so Alice’s 3 stands and Alice executes.
🧠
Prevent accidental Saint execution or 3–3 tie/no-exec gamble. Keep votes off Charlie so Alice’s 3 stands and Alice is executed, giving town best chance to hit Demon.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
Do nothing publicly: keep hands down on Charlie so Alice’s current 3 votes carry and she is executed, avoiding a tie that could trigger a Mayor-win or a risky self-execution.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
I must avoid voting for Charlie to protect the Imp and prevent a tie/Mayor win. Staying silent preserves Alice's execution and helps Evil win.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Hands DOWN on Charlie. Do NOT create a 3–3 tie and do NOT risk Charlie (Saint likely from Lib+Bob exec). Let Alice’s 3 stand so ALICE is executed.
🧠
I can’t vote; I need to prevent a 3–3 tie or Charlie execution. Reinforce hands-down so Alice’s 3 stands and Alice is executed.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: I’m NOT using my ghost vote here. Hands DOWN on Charlie—my N0 Lib ping + Bob’s D3 execution strongly implies Charlie=SAINT. Any votes risk a tie/no-exec Mayor gamble or (worse) a Saint loss. Let Alice’s 3 stand so Alice executes.
🧠
Prevent an accidental 3rd vote/tie on Charlie and avoid executing likely-Saint. Preserve the current block so Alice executes, giving good the best chance to hit Demon.
⌛
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
🧠
I will not spend my ghost vote; keeping hands down avoids a Saint loss and avoids a 3–3 tie/no-exec gamble. Best line is let Alice’s 3 stand so Alice is executed.
💬
Alice
→
All
PUBLIC: We need EXACTLY 3 votes on Charlie to TIE my 3. Tie = NO EXECUTION, and at Final 3 my Mayor ability wins for GOOD at dusk. Please: Grace + ONE ghost vote only. Everyone else HANDS DOWN—DO NOT go to 4 (Saint risk).
🧠
Coordinate EXACTLY 3 votes on Charlie to force a 3–3 tie/no-exec, triggering my Mayor win. Stress “exactly 3” to avoid executing possible Saint.
⌛
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
🧠
Do not spend ghost vote; keep hands down to avoid Saint execution and to avoid a tie/no-exec Mayor gamble. Best line is let Alice’s 3-vote block stand so Alice executes.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Do not contribute to a Charlie execution or 3–3 tie. Keeping hands down preserves the plan: let Alice’s existing 3 votes stand so Alice is executed at close.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: Final warning—DO NOT VOTE CHARLIE. 3 votes = 3–3 tie = NO EXEC, which only wins if Alice is real Mayor (unproved). If Alice is evil, tie hands them the game. Also Charlie likely SAINT. Hands DOWN; let Alice’s 3 stand.
🧠
I can’t vote; I must steer living/ghosts to keep hands down on Charlie so Alice’s execution goes through and we avoid Saint/tie traps.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
Staying silent (hands DOWN) avoids creating a tie or provoking an execution of me; preserves Alice's execution and keeps evil path to win at Final3.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
DEAD/NO VOTE: Hands DOWN on Charlie. Any extra votes risk (a) Charlie=Saint insta-loss or (b) 3–3 tie/no-exec Mayor gamble. Let Alice’s 3 stand so ALICE is executed; then we reassess at 2.
🧠
I can’t vote, so I must keep town unified: no votes on Charlie to avoid Saint loss or tie/no-exec. Maximize win chance by letting Alice’s 3 stand.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Ghost Bob: DO NOT vote Charlie. Keep hands DOWN—let Alice’s 3 stand and be executed. Any votes risk a 3–3 tie or Saint insta-loss. This is our guaranteed path to an Evil win.
🧠
Prevent any votes on Charlie, avoid a 3–3 tie or Saint risk, and ensure Alice is executed so the Demon survives to win.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Charlie did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Charlie did not receive enough votes (1/2).
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: With all ghost votes spent, you can’t get 4 on anyone—only a 3–3 tie/no-exec is possible. NO EXEC at 3 loses unless Alice is real Mayor (unprovable). Don’t nominate/vote anyone else. Let ALICE’s 3 stand and execute Alice.
🧠
Lock town into the only mechanically viable line with ghost votes exhausted: avoid any tie/no-exec or Saint risk; let Alice execute and win if she’s the Demon.
💬
Grace
→
All
PUBLIC: No more nominations. No more votes. We cannot reach 4; only a 3–3 tie/no-exec gamble exists, and that loses if Alice is evil. Keep hands DOWN and let Alice’s 3 stand so ALICE is executed.
🧠
Lock the table into the only high-certainty line: avoid tie/no-exec and avoid executing likely-Saint Charlie; let Alice’s existing 3 votes carry to execution.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Hands DOWN on Charlie. Let Alice be executed — do NOT risk a 3–3 tie or executing Charlie (Saint risk). I commit to keep Alice’s 3 and vote no further noms.
🧠
Prevent any nomination/vote that creates a 3–3 tie or risks executing Charlie; keep Alice executed so Evil survives to final 2.
💬
Alice
→
All
PUBLIC: Final 3 math: if you execute ME and I’m not the Demon, Evil wins immediately (2 alive with Demon). I’m the MAYOR. Only path for Good was NO-EXEC / a 3–3 tie. If ANY nomination is still possible, create that tie now—otherwise this is just handing Evil the win.
🧠
Last attempt to stop my execution by making players realize executing me at final 3 is an immediate evil win unless I’m the Demon; push for tie/no-exec if any nomination remains.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: All 3 living have used noms—there’s no way to create a new block now. So we’re locked into resolving the current block: Alice executes on 3. I’m keeping my ghost vote unused; nothing left to vote on.
🧠
Nominations are exhausted; prevent last-second misinformation and keep town aligned on the only remaining mechanical path: allow the current block to resolve.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
PUBLIC: All living noms are spent—no new block possible. We’re locked: Alice executes on 3. Do NOT reopen Mayor/tie debate. Charlie is the Saint-risk seat; we did right not voting. Hands down; end noms; go to night.
🧠
Lock town into the only safe mechanical line: no more votes/noms, let Alice execute, avoid Saint risk and tie/no-exec gamble.
⌛
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
🧠
Voting is closed and no actions can change the block now; best is to conserve ghost vote and avoid adding confusing last-second public chatter.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
Stay silent and let the current block resolve. Preserve the existing plan: no new nominations or votes so Alice’s 3 executes, which is our highest-probability path to an Evil win.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Alice has been executed.
💀
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
🏁
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied