Game Detail

As the Butler, I need to choose a master for tomorrow's votes. I will select Bob arbitrarily to start building a baseline for his voting behavior.

I want to reach out to my neighbor Frank to see if he is a Townsfolk so we can coordinate a Virgin test to confirm both of us as good.

I want to establish contact with Bob, who is my master for today. This helps me coordinate votes and gather initial info.

I want to verify my Librarian info by whispering to Charlie privately to see if he is indeed the Butler.

Establish communication with my Minion, Bob, to coordinate bluffs and strategy.

I need to establish communication with my Demon, David, and coordinate our bluffs. I'm suggesting Fortune Teller/Empath for myself and confirming his Saint bluff idea.

Eve asked for my role to mechanically confirm us. I want to confirm if she is claiming Virgin and coordinate with her while letting her know I am a Townsfolk (specifically Mayor, though I mentioned it to see how she reacts).

Alice claims to have Librarian info pointing to me as the Butler. I want to test her claim without revealing my actual Investigator role, so I will ask her who the other player in her info is.

Initiate a private conversation with my neighbor Alice to start gathering information and building an alliance.

I want to confirm to Frank that I am the Virgin and agree to find another Townsfolk to nominate me to preserve his Mayor role, then ask if he has heard other claims.

I want to start a conversation with my neighbor Heidi to gather information and build trust on Day 1.

I want to respond to Charlie's question about the other player in my Librarian info, while also trying to find out his role to build trust and gather more information.

I want to establish a connection with my neighbor Charlie and fish for information about what he and Alice were discussing. This helps me build a 'good' persona and gather intel on potential roles in play.

I need to establish a bluff early to Grace, who reached out to me. Claiming Empath with a '0' result is a strong way to seem helpful and pro-town, while 'confirming' Alice and Charlie as good to build trust with them later if they find out I 'cleared' them.

I want to find out Grace's claim so I can see if she's a Townsfolk who can nominate Eve (the claimed Virgin) to confirm both of them, or if she has other useful info.

I want to verify Alice's Librarian claim. If Grace confirms she is the Butler, Alice is likely good (meaning Bob is the Scarlet Woman). If Grace denies it, Alice is likely the Scarlet Woman.

Respond to my neighbor Grace's whisper. I want to build trust and gather her role/information. Sharing my Chef 0 info is safe because I am a 'start-of-game' role, and it helps map out the evil team.

Follow up with Frank to see if he found a Townsfolk to nominate me before the nomination phase starts.

Confirm to Charlie that I am indeed the Butler. This validates Alice's Librarian claim and helps us form a trusted alliance of good players, as Bob's Empath 0 also supports Charlie and Alice being good.

I want to share my Librarian info with Heidi to build trust and see if she is willing to share her role with me, while also verifying if Grace is indeed the Butler.

I've already communicated with my Minion, Bob, and reached out to my neighbor, Charlie. I want to see if Charlie responds or if any public claims start emerging before the nomination phase begins. Waiting allows me to observe the flow of information without overextending.

I need to keep my Demon informed of my bluff and strategy so we don't contradict each other. I'm also reinforcing his Saint bluff as a safety net.

Update Eve on the lack of response from Grace and coordinate the plan for the upcoming nomination phase.

I want to whisper to Bob to get his role claim. Since my Investigator info points to either him or Alice being the Scarlet Woman, getting his claim is crucial to determining which of the two is evil.

I want to share my role and info (Chef 0) with Alice, who claimed Librarian and asked for my role. Since she shared her info with me, sharing my info builds trust and helps us coordinate.

I want to publicly claim Virgin and ask for a starting Townsfolk to nominate me to mechanically confirm us, advancing the Good team's progress.

I want to shift focus towards Charlie's information and away from Eve's Virgin claim for a moment, while also appearing helpful and inquisitive.

I want to support Eve's Virgin claim and encourage players with starting info (like Charlie) to step forward and nominate Eve, while keeping my own Mayor role hidden from the wider public for now.

I am nominating Eve to test her Virgin claim. As Chef with 0 pairs, my start-of-game info is already spent, so I am the perfect candidate to test her. If she is the Virgin, I will be executed and we will both be confirmed good, which is a massive advantage for town.

I will kill Alice to remove a potential source of information. Eve and Heidi have confirmed each other as Virgin and Chef (zero), which makes them very trusted, but they are 'spent' roles. Bob is already building trust with Grace. Alice has been whispering a lot with the now-dead Heidi and Charlie, suggesting she might have key information. Removing her keeps the town guessing and avoids targeting the 'confirmed' players who might be protected or used for future mis-executions.

I am choosing Charlie as my master for tomorrow. Charlie is highly likely to be good because he accurately shared the late Alice's Librarian info, which correctly identified either me or Charlie as the Butler. Since Charlie is good, following his vote is safe and helps the good team.

I want to share my logic with Charlie, who is confirmed good in the no-poisoning world, to coordinate our votes and find the demon.

Coordinate with my Minion, Bob, to see what 'info' he should provide today and to inform him of my bluff plan.

I want to see what information people share on Day 2 before deciding who to whisper to, as Alice is dead now and she claimed Librarian.

Build on my alliance with Frank who claimed Mayor, using my confirmed good status to gather information about Alice's death and other claims.

Share my Librarian information with the confirmed good Virgin (Eve) to help her solve the game and coordinate, especially since I am dead and cannot participate in nominations.

Whisper back to Eve, who is mechanically confirmed good. Disclose that I am the Mayor to build a solid good-team alliance, and ask what the dead player Alice whispered to her.

Inform Grace that Bob is the Scarlet Woman, using the deduction that Alice's Librarian claim (which Grace validated) proves Alice is good, leaving Bob as the only candidate for my Investigator info.

I need to coordinate with my Demon, David. I'm telling him I'll continue my Empath bluff to 'clear' him and Charlie, and I'm checking if he has a target for us to frame.

I want to follow up with Charlie on his Investigator claim, analyze the implications of Bob being the Scarlet Woman, and get Charlie's thoughts on David and Frank.

Coordinate with Bob to frame Charlie and maintain our 'good' image using his fake Empath info.

I want to share my Chef 0 information with Eve, who is confirmed good as the Virgin, so she can use it to solve the game and coordinate the good team.

I want to share Alice's Librarian info and my deduction based on Heidi's Chef 0 result with Frank (who claimed Mayor) to see his reaction and align our strategy.

Gather information from Bob, my neighbor, and share my confirmed good status and Librarian info to build trust and find evil players.

Explain the mechanical deduction to Eve to build trust and coordinate our targets for the day, showing that Bob and David are the primary suspects.

Explain the mechanical strategy to Grace regarding why executing Bob (the Scarlet Woman) first is the optimal play, since executing the Demon while 5+ players are alive would just trigger the Scarlet Woman's conversion.

I need to gain the trust of the dead Librarian (Alice) to control the narrative. By claiming Empath with '0' results that 'confirm' her findings (Grace as Butler) and my Demon (David), I can build a solid wall of 'good' players.

Loop Eve, our proven Virgin, into Charlie's Investigator claim to coordinate executing Bob (the suspected Scarlet Woman) before the nomination phase begins.

I want to engage Frank to gauge his role and alignment, and potentially gather information or cast doubt on others while appearing as a helpful Townsfolk/Saint.

I want to coordinate with Alice (who is dead and likely good) to cross-reference our information and see if she got any responses regarding her Librarian ping on Grace and Charlie.

Agree with Charlie and Grace to execute Bob today, as Bob being the Scarlet Woman fits the perfectly solved Grim where Bob and David are the evil team.

Share Bob's mechanically incorrect Empath claim with Heidi, who is confirmed good, to coordinate our suspicions.

I want to find out what Bob's Empath info is by responding to David's whisper. This will help me verify the alignment of Bob, Charlie, and Grace based on the Empath's alive neighbors (Grace and Charlie).

Confirm the plan to execute Bob today with Grace and Eve, and coordinate who will nominate him when the phase starts.

I want to see what information Grace, Eve, and Charlie are discussing before I make my next move. They are forming a tight circle, and I need to know if they are coordinating against David or me.

I want to reinforce my Empath bluff and the 'zero' read I gave for David (the Demon) and Charlie. This builds trust with both of them and makes David look more like a confirmed good player.

Point out Bob's mechanical mistake in his Empath claim to expose him as lying evil.

To nominate Bob, who is mechanically confirmed to be the Scarlet Woman, and who just made a major slip-up regarding his neighbors. Executing him today prevents him from catching the Demon's power if we execute the Demon later.

Defend against Charlie's nomination by attributing my neighbor mistake to confusion over dead players and doubling down on my Empath bluff, while casting doubt on his Investigator info.

Bob's Empath claim is highly suspicious, and Charlie's Investigator claim perfectly aligns with our deduction of Bob and David being the evil pair. I will vote to execute Bob.

I need to raise my hand to vote for Bob's execution because my Investigator info and his neighbor blunder strongly suggest he is the Scarlet Woman.

I am the Librarian. Charlie claims Investigator with a ping on Alice (me) or Bob as Scarlet Woman. Since I know I am good, Bob must be the Scarlet Woman. Bob's Empath claim also fell apart due to a neighbor mistake. I will use my ghost vote to help execute Bob, the likely Scarlet Woman.

I will not vote for my Minion, Bob, to avoid his execution and keep the evil team strong.

I will raise my hand to vote for Bob. His Empath claim is mathematically impossible and Charlie's Investigator ping strongly points to him being the Scarlet Woman. Voting him out is the right play.

Since my master Charlie is voting, I am allowed to vote. I will raise my hand to vote for Bob to secure the execution of the suspected Scarlet Woman.

Confirm Bob's guilt based on seating logic and Charlie's Investigator claim, encouraging his execution while advising ghosts to save their votes since he already has enough votes.

The nomination is already at 5 votes, which is more than the required 3. My death will satisfy the Scarlet Woman ability if David (the Demon) dies later, provided 5 players are alive. However, David is still alive. By not voting for myself, I maintain the appearance of a Good player trying to survive. Raising my hand would be suspicious. I will let the execution proceed.

Support the execution of Bob by highlighting how Charlie's Investigator claim perfectly aligns with Bob's slip-up and Alice's confirmed good alignment.

Confirm the case against Bob to ensure everyone keeps their hands raised and secures his execution today.

Bob has four living votes, which is more than enough to put him on the block. As a dead player, I should save my ghost vote for the final days of the game.

I need to distance myself from Bob now that his bluff has failed. By agreeing with the town's logic regarding his neighbor mistake and Charlie's Investigator claim, I build credibility as a 'good' player.

To reinforce the case against Bob and ensure he gets executed, since we already have enough votes and he is highly likely to be the Scarlet Woman.

Express support for executing Bob (the Scarlet Woman) based on his slip-up and the Investigator info, while noting that my Butler restriction is satisfied because Charlie (my master) is voting.

Bob already has 4 votes from living players, which is a majority of the 6 living players. As a ghost, I must save my single vote for the late game, so I will wait instead of voting.

I need to try and get off the block to keep the Scarlet Woman ability alive in case David is targeted later. Nominating my accuser, Charlie, is the most logical 'panicked good player' move and might create enough chaos to force a tie or a shift in focus.

Defend myself against Bob's desperate counter-nomination to ensure Bob remains the one scheduled for execution today.

I will wait for the voting on Charlie to proceed. As I am already on the block and have used my nomination, my goal is to see if Charlie can be put on the block to save myself or at least force a tie. Since I am the Scarlet Woman and there are more than 5 players alive, even if I die, the Demon (David) is still safe, and I won't have the chance to become the Demon yet. However, staying alive is better for the team.

I want to discourage the town from voting for Charlie, keeping the suspicious Bob on the block.

I want to urge the town not to vote for Charlie so that Bob remains on the block and is executed today.

I am following the consensus of the good players to maintain my cover as a Townsfolk. Charlie is a key investigator who identified my minion, and Frank is very suspicious. Voting for Charlie would look highly suspicious and wouldn't save Bob anyway since the town is unified against him.

I want to advocate against voting for Charlie to ensure Bob remains on the block for execution.

I want to show solidarity with the good team, urge players not to vote for Charlie, and ensure Bob remains on the block.

Support the town's consensus of keeping Bob on the block by urging everyone not to vote for Charlie. Keep my ghost vote for later.

I am currently nominated for execution by Bob. Since the town is in agreement not to vote for me and to keep Bob on the block, I will wait to let the voting period on me pass without any votes.

Cast doubt on Charlie one last time before the day ends. Even if I'm executed, making Charlie look suspicious might help David later.

I want to keep Bob on the block for execution, so I will not vote for Charlie and will wait for this vote to finish.

I want to keep Bob on the block and ensure Charlie does not get executed, so I will not raise my hand to vote for Charlie. I will wait to let the vote fail.

Bob is my Minion and Charlie is a major threat (Investigator claiming Scarlet Woman on Bob). However, the town is unanimously against Bob. Voting for Charlie now would look extremely suspicious and won't reach the required 5 votes anyway. I will wait and let Bob be executed to maintain my cover as a 'good' player.

I want Bob to remain on the block and be executed today. Raising my hand would vote for Charlie, which I do not want. I will wait to let Charlie's nomination fail.

I want to let the vote on Charlie fail so that Bob remains on the block for execution, as Bob is our primary target (the suspected Scarlet Woman). I have already spoken, so I will wait for the voting to resolve.

We want to keep Bob on the block and not execute Charlie, so we should not vote (raise hand) for Charlie's nomination. I will wait.

Thank the town for their support in keeping Bob on the block and encourage everyone as we prepare for the night phase.

The nomination phase is essentially over, and I am on the block with no way to deflect the vote further. I need to accept my death gracefully while maintaining my bluff to avoid exposing David.

Support the town's decision to execute Bob (suspected Scarlet Woman) and transition to the night phase.

The town has agreed to execute Bob and nominations are wrapping up, so I will wait for the transition to the night phase.

Wait for the day to end and Bob to be executed to solidify my cover as a 'good' player who followed town consensus.

I want to support the execution of Bob as the suspected Scarlet Woman and encourage the team to stay focused as we head into the night.

The day is winding down with Bob on the block, and the town is ready for the night phase. I will wait to allow the transition to the night phase.

Agree with the group's consensus to execute Bob and head into the night, maintaining alignment with the confirmed good player Eve.

Charlie is the primary threat as he correctly identified Bob as a Minion (Investigator claim). Removing him stops his information flow and punishes the town for trusting him.

Eve is the mechanically proven Virgin, making her the most trusted alive player. Choosing her as my master ensures I can vote in alignment with a proven good player tomorrow.

I want to solidify my Saint bluff with Grace, who is influential, and subtly cast suspicion on the Eve/Frank duo to distract from myself.

I want to share a critical mechanical deduction with Eve, who is a confirmed good player, to expose David's fake Saint claim and coordinate our next moves.

I am dead, so I need to sow doubt and paranoia among the living good players to protect David. I want to point out that my execution didn't end the game and frame Frank or David (my demon) as suspicious to create chaos, though my main goal is to make them look at anyone but David. Actually, I should probably distance myself from David but subtly point suspicion elsewhere.

I want to contact Grace privately because based on my Librarian information and Charlie's Investigator claim, Grace must be the Butler and is therefore good. Along with Eve (confirmed Virgin), they are our two confirmed good alive players. This narrows the Demon down to David or Frank.

Whisper to my confirmed good ally, Eve (the Virgin), to coordinate our strategy for executing the Demon. Since Bob was the Scarlet Woman, the Demon must be either David or Grace. I am sharing my role (Mayor) to build trust.

Share the logical deduction with the confirmed good player (Eve) to narrow down the Demon to David or Frank and see her input.

Confirm David is the Demon to Grace and coordinate our execution target for today.

I want to share my solid deduction with Eve, who is the confirmed Virgin, to narrow down the Demon to David or Frank. I need to know what they claimed to make the final decision.

I want to engage Frank directly to see what information he and Eve have, while reinforcing my Saint bluff to discourage them from nominating me.

I want to inform Frank and Alice about David's false Saint claim. Since we know there is no Baron, there can only be one Outsider (me, the Butler). This proves David is lying and is the Demon. Bringing Frank and Alice onto the same page ensures we have the votes to execute David today.

Since I'm dead and my Scarlet Woman ability is neutralized, my goal is to deflect attention away from David and sow suspicion among the living good players. I'm targeting Eve (confirmed Virgin) and Grace (influential) to push them toward Frank.

Coordinate with the confirmed good players (Eve and Grace) to analyze David's Saint claim and assess the risk of a Baron being in play.

Coordinate with the confirmed Townsfolk, Eve, about the Outsider conflict between Grace and David, which points to one of them being the Demon.

Establish trust with Grace (who is confirmed good via the Librarian/Investigator logic) and get her opinion on the remaining suspects (David and Frank).

Reassure Alice and Grace about the mechanical deduction that David is the Demon, and push for his execution.

I am whispering to Grace, who is a trusted alive player, to find out what David and Frank have claimed and get her thoughts on who the Demon is.

I've already reached out to Grace and Frank to establish my 'Saint' bluff and plant seeds of doubt about their private conversations. Since everyone is currently whispering in private groups and there are no direct responses to me yet, I will wait for others to finish their huddles or speak publicly to gather more information before making my next move.

Share my logic on David being the Demon with Charlie (ghost) to solidify support for David's execution.

I want to continue the narrative that I was a 'red herring' or a mistake execution to divert attention from David. By pointing at Frank (who is alive and active), I create a new target for the town and hopefully protect David.

To confirm Frank is on board with executing David today, as David's Saint claim is mechanically impossible given our known roles.

I want to warn Alice and Eve about the danger of executing David if he is the Saint, and propose that we don't execute today to safely reach the final three.

Coordinating with Eve, who is the only mechanically confirmed good player alive, to decide whether we should push to execute David or Frank today, as they are the only remaining suspects.

To explain my reasoning to Heidi on why David is the Demon and why we should execute him today.

Confirm Grace's logic that David must be the Demon. Explain that since Bob is the Scarlet Woman, there is no Baron, meaning only one Outsider (Grace as Butler) can exist. This makes David's Saint claim a lie and proves he is the Demon. Promise my ghost vote to execute him.

Explain to the town why executing David is extremely risky due to the Saint claim and the fact that Grace could easily be the Demon bluffing Butler. Suggesting no execution today to safely go to the final three.

I want to reinforce Frank's suggestion not to execute today. By agreeing that I am the Saint and expressing fear of losing the game, I solidify my bluff and encourage a 'no execution' day, which brings me closer to a win by reducing the number of living players tonight.

Explain the single-chain logic proving David is the Demon to convince Grace or Eve to nominate him before the day ends.

To support Alice's logic and urge the living good players (Eve or Grace) to nominate David, who is mathematically proven to be the Demon due to the Outsider count.

Urge Grace or Eve to nominate David by explaining the solid logical chain that proves David is lying about being the Saint.

Sow doubt regarding the town's logic and protect the Demon (David) from execution by reinforcing the fear of the Saint loss condition.

I need to nominate David because he is mechanically proven to be the Demon. Since there is no Baron, there can only be one Outsider (Grace), making David's Saint claim a lie. Since the Minion Bob is dead, David is the Demon.

I need to desperately defend myself against the 'impossible' Saint claim by attacking the logic that there is only one Outsider or that the information is reliable. If I can't stop the vote, I might lose.

I need to evaluate if I should vote for David. If Alice is indeed the Librarian and confirmed Grace as Butler, then David's Saint claim is mechanically impossible. Let me wait to see if others vote or if I should chime in first.

To help execute David, who is mathematically proven to be the Demon due to his impossible Saint claim in a game with no Baron.

David's Saint claim is mechanically impossible because Bob was the Scarlet Woman (meaning no Baron, so only 1 Outsider) and Alice's info proves Grace is the Butler. David must be the Demon. I will use my ghost vote to execute him.

David's Saint claim is mechanically impossible because Grace is the Butler and there is no Baron. I will use my ghost vote to secure his execution, which will win us the game.

I am staying silent and not voting to help David survive. As a ghost, my vote is a precious resource, and using it to execute my own Demon would be counterproductive, especially since he is currently on the block and needs to avoid reaching the threshold. by not voting, I help keep the vote count lower and support the narrative that executing a Saint claim is too risky.

David is mathematically the Demon because Grace is the confirmed Butler (only Outsider in play) and Bob was the Scarlet Woman. I must raise my hand to vote for David's execution to win the game.

I am raising my hand to vote for David. Since my master Eve has voted, I am allowed to vote. David is the clear Demon suspect due to the Outsider count.

Panic and emphasize the Saint's penalty to discourage voting. Target the one player (Frank) who was hesitant to try and break the consensus.

David is mathematically proven to be the Demon. Bob was the Scarlet Woman (no Baron, so only 1 Outsider). Alice's Librarian info confirmed Grace is the Butler, meaning Grace is the 1 Outsider. Therefore, David's Saint claim is impossible, and he is the Demon. I will raise my hand to execute him and win the game.

Reassure Frank and the town to keep their hands raised so the vote succeeds and we execute David.

Encourage all players to keep their votes on David to secure the execution and win the game.

Encourage the town to keep their hands raised to execute David, who is mathematically proven to be the Demon.

I will wait and not use my ghost vote. David is the Demon and on the block with plenty of votes. Since I am already dead and was the Scarlet Woman, if David is executed, I will become the Demon and the game will continue. Using my ghost vote now would only confirm the town's suspicion of my evil alignment without changing the outcome, as they already have more than enough votes to execute him. By not voting, I maintain a tiny shred of doubt or at least don't waste my one precious vote on a guaranteed execution.

The vote on David has sufficient votes to pass. I want to keep my hand raised to ensure he is executed, so I will wait for the nomination to conclude.

Reassure the town that the math is solid and encourage everyone to keep their hands raised to execute the Demon (David) and win the game.

I need to desperately maintain my Saint bluff to sow last-second doubt, even though the vote has technically passed. My only hope is if someone else gets nominated or if I can somehow disrupt the certainty of the town.

Express deep concern about the possibility of Grace being the Demon bluffing Butler and David being the actual Saint, which would cause an instant loss upon execution.

Reassure Frank that the math is airtight and David's Saint claim is a mathematically impossible bluff, preventing any last-minute panic as nominations close.

Reassure Frank and the rest of the town that the math is airtight and David is definitely the Demon bluffing Saint, ensuring we proceed to execution with confidence.

The voting has concluded and David is on the block with 6 votes. The math is completely airtight, and executing David will win us the game because the Scarlet Woman (Bob) is already dead. I will wait for the nomination phase to close.

Sow doubt in the town's logic by highlighting the risk of executing a Saint claim and suggesting Grace could be the Demon.

Reassure the town and lock in David's execution by reinforcing the airtight logic.

Reassure Frank and the town that I am the Butler, making David's Saint claim impossible and executing him the winning move.