Game Detail
Players
Alice (Chef) Bob (Washerwoman) Charlie (Poisoner) David (Imp) Eve (Soldier) Frank (Monk) Grace (Recluse) Heidi (Mayor)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 305,047 | 40,710 | $2.7465 |
| Good | 870,550 | 520,403 | $5.9895 |
Event Transcript
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You are the Minion. The Demon is David.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Minions are: Charlie. Your safe bluffs are: Saint, Virgin, Ravenkeeper
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
Poison Bob to disrupt early info that could implicate me as his neighbor, while keeping David safe and preserving our evil pair from immediate scrutiny.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose to poison Bob.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Washerwoman. Either Alice or Eve is the Ravenkeeper.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Chef. You learn that there are 1 pairs of evil players.
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
👤
Charlie
→
David
David, I want to coordinate early. I am thinking of claiming a low information role, maybe Soldier or Ravenkeeper, unless you have better safe bluffs. What are you planning to claim, and who should I push attention toward?
🧠
Coordinate with the Demon, establish bluffs, and learn how to protect him before public claims start.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
Hi Heidi, how are you? I have some starting information that I would love to share if we can trade roles. What did you get?
🧠
Initiate a whisper with my neighbor Heidi to trade roles and start building trust, as my Chef info is already spent and I can safely share it with trusted players.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
Hey Alice! I am a Townsfolk. I would love to hear your starting information first. What role are you claiming, and what did you learn?
🧠
I want to respond to my neighbor Alice's whisper. I'll state that I am a Townsfolk and ask for her information and role claim first before fully revealing my role, to gauge her alignment and reliability.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Hey Frank, what are your thoughts so far? Got any starting info you want to share?
🧠
I want to start a conversation with my neighbor Frank to gather information and establish a connection.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Good to coordinate. I can take Ravenkeeper and stay fairly quiet; it explains why I do not want to die by execution. You can take Soldier or Virgin if you want a firmer claim. Early push should be soft, maybe question Alice and Heidi since they paired up fast.
🧠
Coordinate bluffs with my minion and set up suspicion on a good whisper pair while keeping my Demon claim low-risk.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Hey Grace! No starting info for me, I'm one of those roles that doesn't get anything on night zero. What about you? Did you get any interesting reads?
🧠
Reply to Grace's whisper to build trust and see if she has any starting information, while keeping my Monk role relatively hidden.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
Hey Alice, I am the Washerwoman. My start-of-game info says either you or Eve is the Ravenkeeper. Are you the Ravenkeeper, or is it Eve?
🧠
I want to share my Washerwoman information with Alice privately to see if she is the Ravenkeeper, establishing trust and finding out which of the two has the role.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
Hey Frank, what did Grace whisper to you? What's your role? Let's work together.
🧠
I want to gather information from my neighbor Frank on Day 1 to start building trust and finding out what roles are in play.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
Bob, since we are neighbors I wanted to compare notes early. I am not an information role, probably fine saying that much for now. Did you get anything that makes our side of the circle important?
🧠
Build trust with poisoned Bob, learn if his false info can be weaponized, and frame myself as a low-information good role.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
Hey Bob, I am not the Ravenkeeper, so if your info is correct, Eve must be. I am actually the Chef and got a one, meaning there is one evil pair next to each other. Please keep that quiet for now, but who do you think it is?
🧠
I want to share my Chef info with Bob, who claimed Washerwoman seeing me or Eve as Ravenkeeper. Since I am not the Ravenkeeper, this means Eve is the Ravenkeeper if Bob is telling the truth. Sharing my Chef 1 info helps build trust and starts the process of deduction.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Hey Grace, how is it going? What are you and Frank chatting about? Anything interesting?
🧠
I want to establish a connection with my other neighbor, Grace, while waiting for Alice's response. This will help build trust and gather information.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
Hey Heidi! Frank said he has no starting info, so we were just comparing notes. What about you? Did you get any starting info last night?
🧠
Respond to Heidi's whisper to build trust and gather information about her role or starting info.
👤
David
→
Eve
Eve, since we are neighbors I wanted to compare notes early. I am not eager to hard claim yet, but I am a role that would prefer not to be executed. Have you heard anything useful so far?
🧠
Build trust with my neighbor and learn if Eve is an Empath or strong info role who may threaten me later.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
Grace just asked if I had starting info. I told her I do not get info on night zero. I am a Townsfolk, but I am keeping my specific role quiet for now so the Demon does not target me. What about you? What is your role?
🧠
I want to answer Eve's whisper honestly but safely. Claiming Townsfolk without giving away my Monk role protects me from being targeted by the Demon if Eve is evil, while inviting her to share her role.
👤
Bob
→
Eve
Hey Eve, I have some info that suggests you might be the Ravenkeeper. Can you confirm if that is your role?
🧠
I want to verify my Washerwoman info. Since Alice told me she is not the Ravenkeeper, Eve must be the Ravenkeeper if my info is correct. I am whispering to Eve to confirm this.
👤
Eve
→
Bob
I am not the Ravenkeeper, but I am a Townsfolk. If you are the Washerwoman, who was the other person in your information? Because that means they must be the real Ravenkeeper!
🧠
Respond to Bob's inquiry. If he is the Washerwoman, my denial of being the Ravenkeeper means the other player in his ping is the Ravenkeeper, which is extremely valuable info.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
Alice, I noticed you spoke with Heidi and Bob early. I am claiming a non-information role for now, and I do not have anything clearing our side. Did either of them give you a firm claim, or are people staying vague?
🧠
Gather claims before nominations and encourage suspicion away from David while sounding cooperative and low-risk.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
Heidi was pretty vague, only claiming to be a Townsfolk. Bob actually gave me a firm claim and some starting information that involves Eve. What about you? What is your non-information role?
🧠
I want to respond to Charlie's question about Bob and Heidi. I'll let him know Bob was forthcoming and Heidi was vague, while prompting Charlie to share his specific role.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
No, I do not have any starting info either. I am also a Townsfolk who did not wake up on night zero. What do you think about Frank? Do you trust what he is saying?
🧠
Answering Grace's question about starting info to build trust, confirming I don't have night zero info, and asking about her thoughts on Frank to gauge her alignment and suspicions.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
I think it is too early to tell, but I am keeping an eye on him. I am also a passive role who does not get night zero info, so I am just trying to observe for now. Have you noticed anything suspicious from anyone else so far?
🧠
Answer Heidi's question about Frank neutrally while probing her for any other reads or info she might have gathered.
👤
David
→
Alice
Alice, I saw you talking with a few people and wanted to check in before nominations. I am not ready to hard claim, but I am a role that gets more useful if I survive the early days. Have you heard any strong information or anything worrying?
🧠
Build trust and gather claims while reinforcing a Ravenkeeper-style bluff without hard claiming before nominations.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Hey Grace, I saw you and Heidi chatting quite a bit. Did she share any useful information with you, or did you learn anything interesting?
🧠
Ask Grace about her conversations with Heidi to gather info and see if we can identify a good player with an active role to protect tonight.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
Hey Alice, Eve also denied being the Ravenkeeper and asked who the other person in my info was. Since my info says one of you is, and I believe my info is true, she might be evil trying to fish for your identity, or she is the Ravenkeeper. What do you think?
🧠
I want to share Eve's denial with Alice. Since my Washerwoman info must have one Ravenkeeper between Alice and Eve, and both denied it, one is lying. Sharing this with Alice allows us to coordinate. If Alice is indeed the Chef, she will realize Eve is the Ravenkeeper. If Alice is the Ravenkeeper, she might confess to me.
👤
Eve
→
Bob
Hey Bob, did you find out who the Ravenkeeper is? I noticed you whispered to Alice right after me. Is she the other person in your info?
🧠
I want to confirm if Bob is indeed the Washerwoman and if Alice is the other player in his starting info, which would confirm Alice as the Ravenkeeper.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Does anyone have any starting information they are willing to share with the town? It is the first day of nominations, and it would be great to hear if anyone has any useful leads before we make any decisions.
🧠
I want to encourage players to share their starting info publicly so the town can make an informed decision during the nomination phase.
💬
Eve
→
All
I do not have any starting information to share, but I am a Townsfolk. I think those with starting info should speak up so we can get some leads. Bob, did you have something you wanted to share with the town?
🧠
Address Heidi's public prompt and nudge Bob to share his information publicly if he is indeed the Washerwoman, while confirming I have no starting info.
💬
Bob
→
All
Yes, Eve, I am indeed the Washerwoman. My starting information confirms that one of two players is a specific Townsfolk. I have actually already whispered to both of them to verify. To protect them from the Demon tonight, I think it is best if we keep their names and the specific role quiet for now.
🧠
Claim Washerwoman to build trust with the town while protecting the Ravenkeeper by withholding specific names and roles.
💬
David
→
All
I am not hearing a firm lead yet. I like Bob keeping the details protected for now, because outing a confirmed role just gives the Demon a target. If someone has a real case, say it, but I do not want a rushed execution.
🧠
Discourage a Day 1 execution and protect my Ravenkeeper bluff while appearing cautious and pro-town.
💬
Grace
→
All
I agree with David. Since we do not have any clear leads, we should probably not rush an execution today. Bob, keeping your Washerwoman information quiet for now seems like a good way to protect our Townsfolk from the Demon.
🧠
Support David's suggestion of a quiet Day 1 and validate Bob's Washerwoman claim to build trust and maintain a cautious approach.
💬
Alice
→
All
I actually have some starting information to share. I am the Chef, and I learned that there is exactly one pair of evil players sitting next to each other. This means our Minion and Demon are neighbors!
🧠
To share my Chef info publicly so the town has a lead to work with and can analyze neighbor pairs, which will help us find the evil pair.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Chef one is useful, but it is still a very wide net on day one. It could also be affected by a Drunk, a Recluse, or a Spy registration. I would rather not execute purely from that today; let us get one more night of information.
🧠
Defuse Alice's Chef info because it points at me and David, while sounding cautious and pro-town to avoid a day one execution.
💬
Frank
→
All
I agree that Chef one is really useful information for us to keep in mind as the game progresses, even if it is a bit broad right now. Since we do not have a clear suspect yet, passing on execution today might be the safest bet to avoid hitting a Townsfolk.
🧠
I want to contribute to the discussion by acknowledging Alice's Chef info and agreeing with the consensus to not execute on Day 1 without strong leads.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
Eve is David's neighbor and could be an Empath or other ongoing role. Poisoning her protects David from a damaging read and muddies Bob's Washerwoman web.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose to poison Eve.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
🎯
Frank
Frank made a choice.
🧠
I am going to protect Bob tonight. He has claimed Washerwoman and has not yet revealed his two targets or the Townsfolk role he saw, which is valuable information that the Demon might want to silence by killing him. Protecting him ensures he survives to share that information later or coordinate with those players.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You chose to protect Bob.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
David
David made a choice.
🧠
Eve is my neighbor and may be an Empath or Fortune Teller. Killing her removes a likely ongoing info threat before she can expose me, while Alice's Chef info is already public.
💀
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
You chose to kill Eve.
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Eve has been found dead in the night.
👤
Charlie
→
David
I still think Soldier is a good fit for me unless someone has hard confirmation. If pressure builds, I can say I was cautious yesterday because I do not want the demon wasting a kill on me. Who did you talk to, and are you still Ravenkeeper?
🧠
Coordinate bluff stability with the Demon and gather his plan while appearing as a normal private check-in.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Hey Frank, with Eve dead, what are your thoughts? Are you still holding a passive role, or did anything change? I'm trying to figure out Alice's Chef info.
🧠
I want to open a dialogue with my neighbor Frank to gather thoughts on Eve's death and Alice's Chef info, while seeing if he has any new information or remains passive.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
Hey Bob, since Eve died last night, if your Washerwoman information was correct, she must be the Ravenkeeper and should have information from her death. Let's see if we can get her to share who she checked.
🧠
Coordinate with Bob regarding his Washerwoman claim. If his claim is true, Eve is the Ravenkeeper and has valuable night death information.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Hey Grace, I am still keeping a low profile with my role. What are your thoughts on Alice's Chef one claim? If there is an evil pair, where do you suspect they might be?
🧠
I want to reply to Grace's whisper to maintain a good relationship and gather her thoughts on Alice's Chef info, while keeping my Monk role hidden to avoid being targeted by the Demon.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Bob
Hey Bob, I was actually the Soldier. Since I died, I must be the Drunk or I was poisoned last night. What was your Washerwoman info?
🧠
I want to share my true role (Soldier) with Bob privately to see if his Washerwoman info can help determine if I am the Drunk or if I was poisoned. Since I died, my Soldier ability didn't protect me, which is critical information.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob
Hey Bob, since Eve died, things are getting serious. Can you share who your Washerwoman targets and role were? It might help us narrow things down.
🧠
Ask Bob for his Washerwoman info to help solve the game and verify players.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Yes, I am staying on Ravenkeeper. I mostly kept things vague yesterday and backed Bob’s secrecy. Chef one is the biggest problem for us, so I want Alice to look possibly drunk or socially opportunistic. Soldier works for you if pressured.
🧠
Coordinate bluffs with my minion and steer our pressure toward discrediting Alice’s Chef one without linking us too tightly.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
Alice, Eve just whispered to me claiming she was actually the Soldier! If she's telling the truth, that means you have to be the Ravenkeeper. Is there a reason you're claiming Chef instead, or is Eve lying?
🧠
I want to confront Alice about her Chef claim and Eve's Soldier claim, since one of them must be the Ravenkeeper according to my Washerwoman info (assuming I am sober).
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
Bob, I am willing to be more direct with you: I am claiming Soldier. That is why I was comfortable with no execution yesterday. I am worried Alice is using Chef one too confidently, because with Recluse, Spy, or Drunk possibilities it can frame the circle unfairly.
🧠
Build trust with Bob via Soldier bluff and seed doubt on Alice's Chef 1, which threatens the real evil adjacency between me and David.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Frank, in confidence, I am actually the Recluse. This means Alice's Chef count of one might be because of me registering as evil next to you or Heidi. If you are comfortable sharing your role with me, it could really help us figure out if Alice's information is pointing to our side of the circle.
🧠
I am sharing my Recluse role with Frank privately to explain why Alice's Chef info might be 'one' (due to my misregistration) and to build trust so he shares his role.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
If Eve is the Soldier, how did she die at night? Soldiers are safe from the Demon, unless she was poisoned. Also, if your Washerwoman info is true, she has to be the Ravenkeeper, meaning she is lying. Since I am definitely the Chef, she must be lying, or you are poisoned/evil.
🧠
Point out the logical contradictions in Eve's claim and Bob's information to see how Bob reacts, while maintaining my Chef claim.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
That makes a lot of sense, Grace. Thanks for trusting me with that. I am indeed a Townsfolk with a passive role, so I don't register as evil. If Alice's Chef info is pointing to our side, it's likely either because of you registering as evil, or because someone next to us is actually evil. Do you have any reads on Heidi or David?
🧠
Respond to Grace's private message. I want to acknowledge her Recluse claim and share that I am a Townsfolk (keeping it vague as a 'passive role' to avoid being targeted as Monk) while asking for her reads on our neighbors (Heidi and David) to narrow down suspects.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Alice
Hey Alice, I was actually the Soldier but I died. This means I must be the Drunk or I was poisoned by a Poisoner last night. Since you are the Chef, does this help you narrow down the evil pair?
🧠
Share my true role (Soldier) and death situation with Alice (the Chef claim) to help her analyze the evil pair and figure out if a Poisoner or Baron is in play.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
Hey Alice, what do you think of Bob? Did he share his Washerwoman targets with you? Since Eve is dead, we need to start putting our info together.
🧠
I want to ask Alice (the claimed Chef 1) about Bob's Washerwoman info, as they have been whispering frequently. This will help me verify their claims and build a network of trusted players.
👤
David
→
Bob
Bob, I am still leaning toward trusting how carefully you handled yesterday. Did Eve give you anything before she died? I have a role that is more useful if the demon makes a mistake, so I have been trying not to overclaim publicly.
🧠
Build trust with Bob, learn Eve or Washerwoman info, and maintain Ravenkeeper bluff while avoiding public scrutiny.
👤
Bob
→
David
Eve claimed Soldier to me, but Charlie just privately claimed Soldier as well! On top of that, my starting info says Alice or Eve is the Ravenkeeper. Alice claims Chef and Eve claimed Soldier. Something is definitely wrong here. What is your role? Could you be the Monk?
🧠
To share the conflicting Soldier claims (Eve vs Charlie) and my Ravenkeeper info with David, who has been cautious and supportive, to see if his 'mistake-based' role (likely Monk) can help resolve this puzzle.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
Alice, I owe you a clearer answer from yesterday. I am claiming Soldier. If your Chef one is sober, I am more worried about Frank and Grace than about random single claims, because they have been moving together hard today.
🧠
Build trust with Alice while redirecting her Chef 1 away from the true Charlie-David pair toward Frank-Grace before nominations.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
Hey Heidi, I'm trying to piece together the seating area. Frank and I were just talking. Do you mind sharing what your passive role is, or what you've heard from Alice and Bob?
🧠
I want to gather information from my other neighbor, Heidi, to see if she is willing to share her role or any info she got from Alice/Bob. This will help me figure out if there's an evil pair near me or if Alice's Chef info of '1' is related to me registering as evil next to an actual evil player.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
Bob told me his targets were me and Eve, and that one of us is the Ravenkeeper. Since I am the Chef, that would mean Eve is the Ravenkeeper. But Eve privately claimed Soldier to me, and Charlie also claims Soldier. What do you make of that, Heidi? And what are you claiming?
🧠
Heidi asked about Bob's Washerwoman targets. Sharing this information helps analyze the contradictions in the claims (Bob's Ravenkeeper claim vs Eve's Soldier claim vs Charlie's Soldier claim) and invites Heidi to share her role, helping us find the evil pair.
👤
Frank
→
Bob
Hey Bob, what was your Washerwoman info from yesterday? Just trying to piece things together with Alice's Chef claim before we head into nominations.
🧠
I want to gather Bob's Washerwoman information to help solve the Chef 1 puzzle and build a connection with him, since I protected him last night.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Frank
Hey Frank, I was actually the Soldier but died, so I must be poisoned or the Drunk. Since you said you're Townsfolk with no starting info, what's your role? We need to figure out who the evil pair is.
🧠
Frank is my neighbor and claimed Townsfolk with no starting info. Since I am dead, I want to gather more information about his role to see if we can piece together the mechanical puzzle of my death and the Chef 1 info.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
If Eve died last night, she cannot be the Soldier unless poisoned. It is highly likely she claimed Soldier to bait the Demon, and she is actually the Ravenkeeper as Bob's info suggests. Since she died, she should have Ravenkeeper info! I am the Mayor, by the way.
🧠
I will explain to Alice that Eve's death means she isn't the Soldier (unless poisoned) and is likely the Ravenkeeper who now has night info. I will also reveal my Mayor role to Alice to build trust.
👤
David
→
Bob
That is a messy set of claims. I am not the Monk. I am the Ravenkeeper, which is why I was cagey yesterday. If your information is right, then either Alice or Eve has been hiding something, or there is a drunk problem.
🧠
Commit to safe bluff and push confusion onto Alice, Eve, or drunk Washerwoman before Bob consolidates a clear contradiction against me.
👤
Bob
→
Frank
My starting info was that either Alice or Eve is the Ravenkeeper. But here is the crazy part: Eve claimed Soldier to me before she died, Alice claims Chef, and David just privately claimed Ravenkeeper to me! Since my info says Alice or Eve, David is lying and highly suspicious.
🧠
Share my Washerwoman info and the conflicting claims with Frank to build trust and expose David as a liar based on my starting information.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
David
→
Alice
I nominate Alice. Her Chef one is driving a lot of the world building, but Bob's information and the claims around Alice and Eve do not line up cleanly. I think Alice is the best place to test whether that starting information is real or being used to steer us.
🧠
Push execution of Chef claim that threatens David-Charlie pair, while framing it as resolving Bob's contradictions and protecting my Ravenkeeper bluff.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Alice
→
All
Please do not vote for me! I am the Chef, and my starting info is that there is exactly one pair of evil players. If Bob is a real Washerwoman, since I am the Chef, Eve must be the Ravenkeeper. If Eve is claiming Soldier, either she is lying to hide her info, or Bob is evil or poisoned.
🧠
I need to defend myself against this nomination so I am not executed. I am a good Townsfolk (Chef) and executing me hurts the good team. I will explain why Bob's info means Eve must be the Ravenkeeper, and why executing me is a mistake.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Push execution onto Alice to remove Chef one and deepen confusion around Bob's Washerwoman info versus my Ravenkeeper bluff.
💬
Frank
→
All
I do not think we should execute Alice. Bob told me his Washerwoman info points to Alice or Eve being the Ravenkeeper, which directly contradicts David's private claim of Ravenkeeper to Bob. David is looking very suspicious right now, so let us hold off on voting Alice.
🧠
Defend Alice from execution by pointing out the contradiction in David's claim, which aligns with Bob's Washerwoman information.
💬
Bob
→
All
I agree with Frank. David privately claimed Ravenkeeper to me, which completely contradicts my starting information that either Alice or Eve is the Ravenkeeper. Since David is clearly lying, I am not voting for Alice. We should focus on David instead.
🧠
I want to prevent Alice's execution because David's claim contradicts my starting information, making David highly suspicious and Alice likely good. I will speak to encourage the group not to vote.
💬
Grace
→
All
I agree with Frank and Bob. If Bob's Washerwoman info says Alice or Eve is the Ravenkeeper, then David claiming Ravenkeeper is highly suspicious. We should definitely hold off on executing Alice and let David explain himself.
🧠
I want to support Bob and Frank in saving Alice from execution, as David's claim contradicts Bob's Washerwoman info, making David suspicious.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Push a good execution and show confidence that Bob's contradicted Washerwoman info may be poisoned, protecting David from the double-claim pressure.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Wait a minute. Bob claims his Washerwoman info says Alice or Eve is the Ravenkeeper. But Alice claims Chef, and I am the Soldier. Neither of us is the Ravenkeeper! That means Bob's information is completely wrong. He is either lying or poisoned, which means David might actually be the real Ravenkeeper.
🧠
Point out the logical contradiction in Bob's Washerwoman claim to defend David and expose Bob's potentially false information.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I agree with Eve. Since Eve is dead and confirmed she is the Soldier, and Alice is the Chef, Bob's Washerwoman info is impossible. Bob is either lying or poisoned, which makes David's Ravenkeeper claim much more believable. We should not execute Alice today.
🧠
Explain why we should not execute Alice based on Eve's confirmation that Bob's info is false, which validates David's Ravenkeeper claim.
💬
Alice
→
All
If Eve was the Ravenkeeper, she would have woken up last night to get information. Since she is dead, she has no reason to keep claiming Soldier. If she is telling the truth about being the Soldier, then Bob's info is false. Either way, executing me is not the answer. Let us focus on Bob and David!
🧠
I want to defend myself and point out the logical inconsistency in Eve's claim if she were indeed the Ravenkeeper, directing suspicion towards Bob and David instead of myself, while encouraging players not to vote for me.
💬
David
→
All
This is exactly the conflict I am pointing at. Bob's information is already impossible if Alice is Chef and Eve is Soldier, so my claim is not the thing that broke the puzzle. Alice's Chef one is still the claim steering the whole town.
🧠
Keep pressure on Alice and reframe Bob's contradiction as independent of my Ravenkeeper bluff, reducing momentum toward executing me next.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
I do not want to vote for Alice because her Chef claim is useful and Bob's Washerwoman info is highly contested. I will wait and let the vote on Alice play out, hoping it fails.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
I do not want Alice executed because she is a claimed Chef and David, who nominated her, made a highly suspicious Ravenkeeper claim that contradicts my starting information. I will wait and let this vote pass.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
I want to see if the vote on Alice fails, as executing her right now is risky given the massive conflict surrounding Bob's Washerwoman claim, Eve's Soldier claim, and David's Ravenkeeper claim.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am keeping my hand up. If Alice and Eve are both denying Bob's Ravenkeeper result, then Bob's information cannot be the reason to clear Alice or condemn David. Alice's Chef one has driven the whole day, and I think this is a reasonable execution.
🧠
Keep momentum on executing Alice, discredit Bob's info that threatens David, and frame Alice's Chef claim as dangerous steering.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Wait, look at the seating order. Alice and Bob are sitting right next to each other. If Alice is the Demon and Bob is the Poisoner who poisoned me last night, they are literally the evil pair. That would explain Alice's Chef one claim and why Bob is desperately defending her. I am saving my vote.
🧠
I want to point out the physical proximity of Alice and Bob. If they are the evil pair, it perfectly aligns with Alice's Chef 1 claim and Bob's desperate defense of her, while keeping my ghost vote safe for later.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Eve's point about Bob and Alice being an evil pair is really compelling. If Bob is a Poisoner, that explains how Eve died despite being the Soldier, and why Bob's info is false. But executing Alice today without being sure might be too hasty. I think we should hold off and see what happens tonight.
🧠
To share my perspective on Eve's theory and caution against executing Alice today, promoting a cautious approach while acknowledging the suspicious synergy between Bob and Alice.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Alice did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Alice did not receive enough votes (2/4).
⚖️
Alice
→
David
David, you nominated me to "test" my info, but your own Ravenkeeper claim is highly suspect and contradicts Bob's Washerwoman info. Executing no one on Day 2 is dangerous, so we need to put you on the block and get some answers.
🧠
Nominate David to prevent a second consecutive day of no executions and put a highly suspicious player on the block.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
David
→
All
Please do not put four on me here. Bob's information is contradicted by Alice and Eve before my claim ever matters. If you execute me, you remove the one claimed role the demon actually has to worry about killing at night.
🧠
Survive the vote by reframing the contradiction as Bob/Alice/Eve, not me, and make my claimed Ravenkeeper costly to execute.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
I nominated David because his Ravenkeeper claim contradicts Bob's Washerwoman info, and his nomination of me was highly suspicious. I want to vote for him to put him on the block.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
David's claim to be Ravenkeeper is highly suspect because it directly contradicts Bob's Washerwoman info. If Bob is good, David is definitely lying. Voting David puts pressure on him and helps good get a viable execution.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Since David's Ravenkeeper claim contradicts my Washerwoman information, he is the most logical evil candidate. I will raise my hand to vote for his execution.
💬
Grace
→
All
I am really hesitant to vote for David here. If Bob is indeed evil and tried to falsely pocket Alice as the Ravenkeeper—which Alice refuted—then Bob is highly suspicious. We should not let an evil Bob lead us into executing the real Ravenkeeper. I think we should hold our votes.
🧠
To dissuade the town from executing David, who might be the real Ravenkeeper, by highlighting that Bob's suspicious and contradictory behavior makes his push for David's execution highly suspect.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am not voting on David here. Bob's information is already contradicted by Alice and Eve, so it should not be used to execute David. If we need an execution, I would rather look at Bob tomorrow than kill the Ravenkeeper claim now.
🧠
Prevent the Demon David from reaching four votes while redirecting suspicion onto Bob for tomorrow.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
I am definitely not voting here. I need to save my ghost vote, and executing David right now feels like a huge mistake. Grace and Charlie are completely right—Bob's info is clearly broken, so we shouldn't punish David for contradicting it. Let's pass and see what happens tonight.
🧠
To discourage the town from executing David, who is a highly plausible Ravenkeeper, and to declare that I am saving my ghost vote.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I agree with Grace and Charlie. I am not voting for David either. Bob's information is highly suspicious and has been completely contradicted. Executing a claimed Ravenkeeper on the basis of compromised info is a massive risk we do not need to take right now. Let's let the vote fail.
🧠
I want to state that I am not voting for David, aligning with Grace and Charlie to save a potential Ravenkeeper and cast suspicion on Bob's compromised information.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
Do not vote for myself. Let the vote fail at three while allies and persuaded good players hold off, preserving my Ravenkeeper bluff.
💬
Alice
→
All
If Bob is good, David is definitely evil because David claimed Ravenkeeper to Bob to conflict with Bob's info. If Eve was the Soldier, she could have been poisoned, which doesn't automatically make Bob evil. David's claim is too convenient. We need an execution today, and David is the best target.
🧠
I want to persuade the town to execute David by pointing out that his Ravenkeeper claim is suspicious and Eve's death as a Soldier could just be due to poisoning, which doesn't prove Bob is evil.
↩️
Frank
Frank lowered their hand
🧠
I want to lower my hand because Bob's Washerwoman info is clearly false (since Alice and Eve both deny being Ravenkeeper). This means David's Ravenkeeper claim doesn't conflict with any valid good info, making him likely to be the real Ravenkeeper. I should not support his execution.
💬
Bob
→
All
If my information is correct, Alice or Eve is the Ravenkeeper. David claiming Ravenkeeper to me in private is extremely suspicious because he had no way of knowing my info would catch him. If we pass today, we gain nothing. Let us execute David to get answers and test this.
🧠
I want to convince the town to execute David. I need to explain why his claim is so suspicious and why we shouldn't waste another day without an execution.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
I want to let the vote on David fail because executing a claimed Ravenkeeper based on highly suspect and contradicted Washerwoman information from Bob is too risky for the good team.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I really think this is the wrong execution. David's claim only looks bad if we trust Bob, and right now Bob's information is the most tangled piece on the board. Please do not put the fourth vote here.
🧠
Protect Demon David from execution by reframing Bob as the faulty logic source and discouraging swing votes.
⌛
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
🧠
I am saving my ghost vote and want the vote on David to fail, as executing a claimed Ravenkeeper based on Bob's highly suspect information is a mistake.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I am definitely not voting. Bob's information has already been completely disproven by both Alice and Eve. Pushing to execute David based on broken information feels like an evil push. We should let this vote fail and go to night.
🧠
I want to prevent David's execution. Bob's Washerwoman info is clearly false or compromised, so executing a claimed Ravenkeeper based on it is a massive risk for the good team.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee David did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (2/4).
💬
David
→
All
I think the important thing now is that Bob's information cannot be treated as clean. Alice and Eve both broke it before I was involved. If we are going to execute tomorrow, I want the town to look hard at Bob and Alice as a possible pair.
🧠
Reinforce that my failed execution was based on bad info and redirect suspicion toward Bob and Alice before night.
💬
Alice
→
All
With my Chef info of one, the two evil players must be sitting right next to each other. Since Eve died and claimed Soldier, she had to be poisoned, confirming a Poisoner is in play. This means the evil pair is adjacent. We should look closely at Bob and Charlie, Charlie and David, or Frank and Grace.
🧠
Since it is the last tick of the day and no execution can happen now, I want to leave the town with a clear logical framework for tomorrow based on my Chef 1 info and the adjacent evil pair rule.
💬
Frank
→
All
I am glad we did not execute David. Since I know my own alignment, I can guarantee that Frank and Grace is not the evil pair. Let us head into the night, get some more information, and we can look closely at Bob and the others tomorrow.
🧠
To reassure the town about the failed vote on David, clear the 'Frank and Grace' pair using my known good alignment, and steer the game safely into the night phase where I can use my Monk ability.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
I will wait to let the day end and proceed to night, as the town has decided against executing David, and I cannot nominate David or Alice again today.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Let the nomination phase end naturally so we can go to night. The town has decided not to execute today, which is safe since the information is still very messy.
⚖️
Charlie
→
Bob
I nominate Bob. If we are executing today, Bob is the cleanest pressure point. His Washerwoman information is the root of the David push, but Alice and Eve already contradicted it. Executing Bob tests whether this is bad information or an evil bluff.
🧠
Push execution onto Bob, the info source threatening David, while framing it as solving the town's main contradiction and protecting the Demon.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Bob
→
All
Wait! If my info is correct, Eve was the Ravenkeeper who claimed Soldier to hide. Since Eve died last night, if she is the Ravenkeeper, she should have woken up and gotten information! Eve, did you wake up and get Ravenkeeper info last night? If so, my info is correct and David is lying!
🧠
I want to defend myself against this nomination by pointing out a logical way to verify my Washerwoman information. If Eve was the Ravenkeeper and died, she should have received Ravenkeeper info. Asking her this can verify my role and find the truth.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Help Charlie push a good player onto the block while my public suspicion of Bob makes my vote look consistent rather than coordinated.
💬
Alice
→
All
If David and Charlie are the evil pair, Charlie's quick nomination of Bob after saving David makes total sense. They are trying to deflect attention. Bob is probably good, and David is lying about being the Ravenkeeper. Everyone, do not vote for Bob.
🧠
Defend Bob from execution by pointing out that Charlie and David's coordinated behavior strongly suggests they are the adjacent evil pair, making Bob a good player who is being targeted.
💬
Frank
→
All
Bob raises a very good point. Eve, did you wake up and get Ravenkeeper info last night? That would clarify whether Bob's information is completely broken or actually true.
🧠
I want to ask Eve if she got Ravenkeeper info. If Eve was the Ravenkeeper who claimed Soldier and died, she should have received info. If she did, then Bob's Washerwoman info is correct, which means David is lying. If she didn't, Bob's info is wrong (either Bob is evil, or poisoned).
💬
Grace
→
All
Eve, did you get woken up last night to use the Ravenkeeper ability? If you did, that proves Bob is telling the truth and David is lying. If not, then Bob's information is completely wrong.
🧠
Ask Eve if she woke up as Ravenkeeper to verify Bob's Washerwoman claim.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Push Bob execution to remove the source of the David case and frame his info as evil or poisoned, keeping Demon David alive.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
No, I did not wake up last night. I am indeed the Soldier. This confirms that Bob's information is completely incorrect. He is either evil and lying, or his information was poisoned.
🧠
I need to answer the group's question about whether I woke up as the Ravenkeeper, which clarifies that Bob's Washerwoman info is false and David is not necessarily lying.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Eve confirmed she is the Soldier and did not wake up as Ravenkeeper, proving Bob's information is false. I will vote to execute Bob to stop his harmful push on David.
💬
Bob
→
All
Wait, everyone! If Alice is actually the Ravenkeeper and claimed Chef to protect her identity, then my information is correct and David is lying. Or, if Eve was the Ravenkeeper but was poisoned on the night she died, she would not have woken up. I am good, so executing me only helps the evil team!
🧠
I need to defend myself against execution by explaining how my information could still be correct despite Eve's claim, pointing out that either Alice is the Ravenkeeper bluffing Chef, or Eve was poisoned Ravenkeeper.
💬
David
→
All
Bob is moving the goalposts now. Eve has plainly said she was not Ravenkeeper, and Alice has been pushing Chef all game. If we want useful information today, Bob is the source of the broken chain. I think this is the execution.
🧠
Secure a fourth vote on Bob, removing my main accuser and making his Washerwoman info look evil or poisoned.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
I believe Bob is good because if he were evil, his partner would have to be Charlie, who just nominated him. Charlie and David are likely the evil pair. I will not vote for Bob.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Bob's Washerwoman info is completely contradicted by both Alice and Eve. We need an execution today to progress the game, and Bob is currently the most logical suspect to test.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
To vote for Bob because his Washerwoman info has been thoroughly debunked by Eve and Alice, making him the most suspicious player and likely an evil Minion or Demon.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Eve just answered the key question. Bob's information has now changed shape several times, and every version points the town back into confusion. I think this is the better execution today.
🧠
Keep votes on Bob to execute a good player and deflect from Demon David by framing Bob as the broken logic source.
⌛
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
🧠
Bob already has 5 votes, which is more than enough to put him on the block, so I will save my single ghost vote for the late game.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Bob's excuses are completely falling apart. First he says Eve is the Ravenkeeper, then when she denies waking up, he claims she was poisoned or Alice is lying. This constant moving of the goalposts is classic evil behavior. Let us execute Bob and get clean information for tomorrow.
🧠
Support the execution of Bob by pointing out how his shifting defenses expose him as evil, confirming that executing him is the correct move.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Bob with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Bob is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
⚖️
Bob
→
Charlie
If Alice's Chef ping of 1 is correct, the evil pair is likely Charlie and David. Charlie has been leading the charge against me to deflect attention from themselves. I nominate Charlie to test this theory and save a good player.
🧠
I want to nominate Charlie to save myself from execution and test if Charlie and David are the evil pair, which perfectly aligns with Alice's Chef ping of 1.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am not voting on myself. This nomination only makes sense if you ignore that Bob's Washerwoman chain just collapsed in public. If I were evil with David, I would not be this exposed pushing the same world all day.
🧠
Defend against the counterwagon and keep votes off me so Bob is executed, protecting David and preserving my Soldier bluff.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
I will vote for Charlie to save myself from execution and test if he is the Demon/Minion, as he and David have been aggressively pushing against me.
💬
David
→
All
I am not voting on Charlie here. Bob was already caught in a broken information chain, and this feels like a last minute attempt to make Alice's Chef number do all the work for him.
🧠
Protect Charlie and preserve Bob execution by framing this as desperate deflection from Bob's collapsed Washerwoman claim.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Charlie is evil under both main theories: either he is evil with David (having poisoned Bob N0 and Eve N1), or he is evil with Bob. Voting for Charlie is the correct move.
💬
Frank
→
All
I agree with Charlie and David. Bob's explanation keeps changing, while Charlie has been consistent and logical. I am not voting for Charlie. Let us keep Bob on the block.
🧠
Explain my decision not to vote for Charlie, supporting the execution of Bob whose claims have been inconsistent.
💬
Grace
→
All
I agree. Bob's claims have shifted too many times to be believable. I am not voting for Charlie either; let us keep Bob on the block.
🧠
I want to state publicly that I am not voting for Charlie, to ensure Bob remains on the block for execution, as Bob is highly suspicious.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
I am keeping my ghost vote saved. Bob's claims have fallen apart completely, and trying to deflect onto Charlie only makes him look more guilty. Let us keep Bob on the block.
🧠
Reinforce the push to execute Bob by explaining why I am holding my ghost vote and not voting for Charlie.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I agree with the rest of you. Bob's nomination of Charlie is a last-ditch effort to save himself after his story completely crumbled. Let us keep our focus on Bob and not vote for Charlie.
🧠
Confirm my agreement with the town's consensus to not vote for Charlie, keeping Bob on the block for execution.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
Avoid voting on myself and let Bob remain on block; his execution protects David and discredits Bob's Washerwoman chain.
💬
Bob
→
All
If Alice is Chef one, and I know I am good, look at how Charlie and David are perfectly in sync, defending each other and deflecting onto me. They are adjacent! They are the prime candidates for that adjacent evil pair. Please, if you want to find the demon, look at Charlie and David.
🧠
Point out the logical implication of Alice's Chef 1 info and Charlie/David's synchronized behavior to show they are the likely evil pair, trying to get votes on Charlie or build a case for tomorrow.
💬
David
→
All
Bob, I hear the Chef argument, but it only works if we ignore the Washerwoman problem that just happened in front of everyone. Charlie is not the cleanest execution today. Bob still gives town the most information.
🧠
Keep my minion off the block and reinforce Bob as the execution while sounding fair and logic driven.
💬
Alice
→
All
Think about it: if Bob is evil, his only possible adjacent partner is Charlie, since I am good. If Bob is good but Charlie and David are the evil pair, then Charlie is still evil. In both of those likely worlds, Charlie is evil. Executing Charlie actually covers more bases than executing Bob!
🧠
Present double-chain logic to show that Charlie is a better execution target than Bob because Charlie is evil in both the Bob/Charlie and Charlie/David pair scenarios, assuming the evil pair is in this section of the circle.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
I do not want to vote for Charlie, as I believe Bob is the correct execution today. I already stated my position, so I will wait to let the voting phase finish.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
I want Bob to remain the primary execution target, as his claims have completely fallen apart. Voting for Charlie would only help Bob escape the block. I will wait to let this nomination fail.
⌛
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
🧠
I want Bob to remain on the block, so I will not vote for Charlie. I will wait.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
I will not vote for Charlie. Bob's claims have completely collapsed, and he is trying to deflect onto Charlie. I want Bob to remain the primary execution candidate today.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Charlie did not reach the 6 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Charlie did not receive enough votes (2/6).
💬
Charlie
→
All
I get the Chef angle, but it is not stronger than Bob changing his Washerwoman story after Eve challenged it. We can revisit the neighbor pairs tomorrow. Today, Bob is the cleanest execution.
🧠
Lock in Bob's execution and frame Alice's case on me and David as secondary, preserving David for later days.
💬
Bob
→
All
If Eve is the Soldier, how did she die last night? A Soldier cannot be killed by the Demon unless poisoned. This means we have a Poisoner in play, which perfectly explains why my Washerwoman information or Eve's safety was disrupted. Please keep this Poisoner world in mind tomorrow.
🧠
Explain the mechanical inconsistency of Eve's death to prove the existence of a Poisoner, which validates my Washerwoman claim even if the info was off, or explains Eve's death if she was indeed the Soldier. This leaves the good team with a clear mathematical puzzle to solve.
💬
David
→
All
That Poisoner world is possible, Bob, but it also conveniently explains every part of your story changing. I still think we learn the most by letting this execution go through and then checking the Chef pairs tomorrow.
🧠
Lock in Bob execution while sounding fair, and leave Alice's Chef one as tomorrow's argument rather than letting it save Bob now.
💬
Alice
→
All
Bob, that Poisoner explanation is plausible, but it is also a very convenient cover for a failed bluff. Let's see what happens tonight, and we can look at the adjacent pairs tomorrow.
🧠
Respond to Bob's last-second Poisoner theory to prepare the town for tomorrow's deduction, while accepting his execution today.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
The day is ending and Bob is on the block with 5 votes, which is a solid majority. I want to let the day end so Bob is executed and we can move to the night phase where I can use my Monk ability.
💬
Grace
→
All
I agree with David. Bob's excuses keep shifting, and executing him today definitely gives us the most clarity. Let us see what the night brings.
🧠
Express support for Bob's execution to ensure the town stays aligned as we head into the night phase.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
I agree with David and Grace. Bob's execution is the right move for today. If I was the Soldier and died, a Poisoner or me being the Drunk are both very real possibilities we should analyze tomorrow. Let us see what happens tonight.
🧠
Reinforce the consensus to execute Bob and provide logical next steps for the town regarding my death as a Soldier (Poisoner vs. Drunk) before the day ends.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Bob is on the block with 5 votes, and the nomination phase is about to end. I will wait for the execution to happen and the game to move to night.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Bob has been executed.
💀
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
Block a likely hidden information role, especially Undertaker, from validating Bob and turning suspicion onto me and David tomorrow.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose to poison Heidi.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
🎯
Frank
Frank made a choice.
🧠
David has been a central, logical voice guiding the town's execution of Bob. If David is good, he is a high-priority target for the Demon tonight to disrupt the town's leadership. Protecting him is the most optimal play.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You chose to protect David.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
David
David made a choice.
🧠
Remove the Chef 1 source tying me to Charlie. Her information is spent, but her living vote and agenda are the biggest threat tomorrow.
💀
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
You chose to kill Alice.
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Alice has been found dead in the night.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Hey Grace, now that Alice is dead, we need to solve this. If Eve was indeed the Soldier and died, there must be a Poisoner. Charlie and David are sitting next to each other, and Bob accused them. What do you think about Charlie and David being the evil pair?
🧠
I want to open a private dialogue with Grace (who is likely good if Charlie and David are the evil pair) to share my theory about Charlie and David being the evil duo based on the Poisoner theory and Chef 1 ping.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
Hey Heidi, if Bob was the Poisoner who poisoned Eve, then Bob is the Minion. That means Charlie and David cannot both be evil, because there is only one Minion. Only one of them could be the Demon. What do you think about that?
🧠
Respond to Heidi's whisper with logical deduction about Bob being the Poisoner and the implications for Charlie and David's alignments, keeping it natural and helpful.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Frank
Hey Frank, I am the Chef and I got a 1. With Bob dead, if Bob was evil, then Charlie must be evil too to make the pair. What is your role, and what do you think of the Heidi/Grace whispers?
🧠
I want to share my Chef info with Frank, who is currently unaligned with the suspicious Bob/Charlie or Heidi/Grace dynamics, to get his thoughts and see if he is good.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice(Ghost)
Alice, were you actually the Ravenkeeper? If so, who did you target last night and what did you learn? I am really the Washerwoman and want to help.
🧠
I want to verify if Alice was indeed the Ravenkeeper (from my Night 0 Washerwoman info) and find out who she checked last night since she died and then immediately whispered to Frank.
👤
Charlie
→
David
David, Alice dying makes her Chef one louder. I think we need frame it as poisoned Chef or drunk Chef, not solve the pair. I can keep taking heat as the possible extra evil, but we should steer today toward Heidi or Grace if they are building a chain.
🧠
Coordinate with the Demon before public discussion so we can defuse Chef pressure and aim execution at a good player.
👤
Frank
→
Alice(Ghost)
Hey Alice, I'm the Monk. I protected Bob Night 1 and David Night 2. Since you died last night, you're definitely good. If Bob was indeed evil, then Charlie is his partner. If Bob was good, the pair might be Heidi and Grace, who are whispering right now. What do you think?
🧠
Alice is dead, confirming her good alignment. I want to build trust, share my Monk role/actions, and get her perspective on the evil pair based on her Chef info and current player behavior.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Agreed. I will say Alice was the obvious kill to frame the Chef world, not confirm it. If people are pairing us, push that Bob and Alice needed that story after Bob collapsed. I think Heidi and Grace whispering together is where today goes.
🧠
Coordinate with my Minion to weaken Alice's Chef chain and redirect execution onto a good player while keeping both evils alive.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Frank
Hey Frank, what are your thoughts on Alice's death? Do you think she was killed because her Chef info was true?
🧠
I want to check in with Frank, my alive neighbor, to see his perspective on Alice's death and her Chef information, and start building trust now that I am dead.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
That is a really good point, Grace. If Bob was the Poisoner and is now dead, then only one of Charlie or David can be the Demon. But what if Bob was not the Poisoner and they are still alive? Or what if Eve was actually the Drunk? Who do you suspect most out of Charlie, David, and Frank?
🧠
Reply to Grace's logical point about Bob being the Minion and explore the other possibilities (Poisoner still alive, Eve being the Drunk) to narrow down the Demon suspects among Charlie, David, and Frank.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
If Bob was the Poisoner, Charlie is highly suspicious because Bob and Charlie are adjacent, which matches Alice's Chef info of one evil pair. If Bob wasn't the Poisoner and Eve was the Drunk, then the Poisoner is still active. I'm leaning towards Charlie or Frank. What do you think of Frank?
🧠
Answering Heidi's question by analyzing the Bob-Poisoner scenario and how it connects to Alice's Chef info, pointing out Charlie's suspicion, and asking for her thoughts on Frank to gauge her alignment.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Bob(Ghost)
Bob, I am actually the Chef and I got a 1. I was not the Ravenkeeper, and Eve claimed Soldier. If you are really the Washerwoman, how did you get that we were Ravenkeeper? Do you think you were poisoned Night 0, or is there a chance you are the Drunk?
🧠
I want to probe Bob's claim of Washerwoman. He claimed Alice (me) or Eve was the Ravenkeeper, but I am Chef and Eve claimed Soldier. I want to see if he is open to being poisoned/Drunk, or if he is evil and lying.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice(Ghost)
I could be the Drunk or poisoned Night zero, which explains the false info. But there is also a chance Eve was the Ravenkeeper, lied to bait the Demon, died Night one, and got a ping. Let us see if Eve tells anyone what she learned when she died. Who do you trust among the living right now?
🧠
Reply to Alice's question about how I got the Ravenkeeper info, suggesting either I am Drunk/poisoned or Eve was the Ravenkeeper who lied to bait the Demon and got info when she died. Ask who she trusts to coordinate our efforts as ghosts.
👤
Charlie
→
Frank
Frank, I am worried Heidi and Grace are locking a story in private. Alice dying makes Chef one look scary, but it also feels like an obvious frame. What did Alice tell you, and do you think Bob was just evil bluffing?
🧠
Use Frank as a credible mouthpiece to keep Bob as evil and frame Alice death as manipulation, deflecting from me and David.
👤
Frank
→
Charlie
Alice told me she got a Chef 1. With her dead, that info is almost certainly true. If Bob was indeed evil, then you have to be his partner. But if Bob was good, the pair is either you and David, or Grace and Heidi. What do you make of Grace and Heidi whispering?
🧠
I want to share my logical breakdown with Charlie to see his reaction, while also prompting him about Grace and Heidi. This will help me assess if Charlie is trying to deflect onto Grace/Heidi, or if he is genuinely Good.
👤
David
→
Grace
,Heidi
Can I compare notes with you two? Alice dying makes her Chef claim feel important, but it was also the most obvious kill if evil wanted Charlie and me framed. I am more worried about someone steering from the side today.
🧠
Enter the Grace-Heidi channel, soften the Chef chain against me and Charlie, and redirect suspicion toward a side-steering good player.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Grace
Hey Grace, what are you and Heidi discussing? Any thoughts on who the evil pair might be based on Alice's Chef 1 info?
🧠
Ask Grace about her thoughts on the Chef info and her discussions with Heidi, to gather info from an active alive player.
👤
Heidi
→
David
,Grace
That is a really interesting point, David. If Alice was telling the truth about the one ping, we definitely have an adjacent evil pair. But if Bob was the Poisoner, then Bob and Charlie could be that pair, which might mean you are clean. What do you think about Frank or Charlie?
🧠
Respond to David's three-way whisper to Grace and me, sharing the Bob-Charlie pair hypothesis to see how they react, while keeping my Mayor role hidden.
👤
Grace
→
Eve(Ghost)
Hey Eve! If Bob was the Poisoner who poisoned you on Night 1, then Bob and Charlie are likely the evil pair from Alice's Chef info. But if Bob was actually good, then Charlie and David are the prime suspects for that adjacent pair. Who do you lean towards?
🧠
I want to share my thoughts with Eve (the dead Soldier) and see who she suspects. This helps build trust with a confirmed/likely good dead player and gathers her perspective on the Charlie/David vs Bob/Charlie theories.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Eve(Ghost)
Hey Eve, I am the Chef and got a one. Bob is claiming you might actually be the Ravenkeeper who lied about being the Soldier to bait the Demon. Is that true, or is Bob lying? What is your actual role?
🧠
I want to verify Eve's true role to see if Bob's theory about her being a lying Ravenkeeper is true, or if Bob is trying to cover up his own false claim. Since Eve is dead and likely good, she will tell me the truth.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Eve(Ghost)
Eve, were you actually the Ravenkeeper? Since you died Night 1, did you get to choose a player and learn their role? If so, who did you target and what did you learn? My starting info was Alice or Eve as Ravenkeeper.
🧠
Find out if Eve was indeed the Ravenkeeper from my starting info, and if she obtained any crucial information when she died on Night 1.
👤
Charlie
→
Frank
I am rethinking Bob more than I like. If he was good but poisoned or drunk, the loud Chef solve points at either me and David or Grace and Heidi. I know my seat, so I want to hear Grace and Heidi publicly before we let that pair quietly steer the day.
🧠
Pull Frank into a good-good suspicion on Heidi/Grace and normalize a pivot from Bob evil without exposing David.
👤
Frank
→
David
Hey David, Charlie and I are a bit worried about Grace and Heidi whispering so much today. They whispered to you as well—what are they saying? I am the Monk and actually protected you last night, so I would love to work with you to figure this out.
🧠
I want to find out what Grace and Heidi are whispering about by asking David, whom they also whispered to. I am revealing my Monk role and that I protected him last night to build trust.
👤
David
→
Frank
Heidi is floating that if Alice was right, Bob as Poisoner could make Bob and Charlie the pair, which would take heat off me. I am not fully sold. Grace and Heidi feel coordinated, and I want to know whether one of them is quietly driving this.
🧠
Build trust with Frank, keep suspicion on Grace and Heidi, and avoid confirming Charlie as evil while learning whether Frank will lead the misexecution.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Alice(Ghost)
Alice, I am definitely the Soldier, not the Ravenkeeper. Bob is lying or was completely poisoned. I died on night one, which means I was either poisoned by a Poisoner or I am the Drunk. Bob's story has been shifting constantly, so I do not trust his claims at all.
🧠
To confirm my true role as Soldier to Alice (the dead Chef), proving that Bob's Ravenkeeper claim about me is false and helping her analyze the evil pair.
Nominations — Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Charlie
→
Heidi
I nominate Heidi. Alice's Chef one is driving today. If we trust it, the worlds are Charlie and David, or Grace and Heidi. I know the first is wrong, and Heidi and Grace spent the day coordinating. This is the best test without accepting Bob's collapsed story.
🧠
Push execution onto a good Chef-pair target, keep David safe, and make my suspicion look like logical self-defense rather than evil coordination.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Hold on! I am the Mayor. Executing me is a terrible idea because if we get to the final three with no execution, we win automatically. Charlie nominating me is highly suspicious, especially since he is part of the Bob-Charlie and Charlie-David adjacent pairs from the Chef ping. Please do not vote!
🧠
I am defending myself from the nomination by revealing my role as the Mayor. Executing the Mayor is bad because we lose our passive win condition, and Charlie's nomination of me is highly suspicious.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Push through a good execution and keep pressure off David. My vote is expected because I nominated Heidi; failing to vote would look fake.
💬
Frank
→
All
Heidi claiming Mayor is a big deal, and we should not rush to execute her. If Bob was the Poisoner, then Charlie is his partner and is the Demon. Charlie pushing so hard on Heidi makes me very suspicious of him. Let's hold off on voting Heidi for now.
🧠
To prevent the execution of a potential Mayor (Heidi) and cast suspicion on Charlie, who is a prime Demon suspect if Bob was evil.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
Heidi claimed Mayor, which is a strong Townsfolk role. I should save my ghost vote and not vote to execute a potential Mayor on Day 3, especially when we need to be careful with our remaining execution votes.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Executing a claimed Mayor removes a dangerous good win condition and sets up final three after tonight. I need Charlie's push to succeed if Grace joins.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
I agree with Frank. I am going to save my ghost vote for later. If Charlie and David are actually the evil pair, it makes total sense that they are both voting for Heidi right now. Let's not rush into executing a Mayor claim.
🧠
I want to advise the town against executing Heidi today, as she has claimed Mayor, and the votes on her are from Charlie and David, who are highly suspected of being the evil pair. I also want to declare that I am saving my ghost vote.
💬
Grace
→
All
I agree with Frank and Alice. Charlie and David are the main suspect pair from the Chef info, so seeing them both vote for Heidi makes me very wary. I am not voting for a Mayor claim today.
🧠
I want to discourage the town from executing Heidi, who has claimed Mayor, especially since her nominators (Charlie and David) are the prime suspects for the adjacent evil pair from the Chef's information.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
I agree with Alice and Frank. Executing a Mayor claim today is way too risky, especially with Charlie and David both rushing to vote for her. I am definitely holding onto my ghost vote for now.
🧠
I want to voice my agreement with Alice and Frank to protect the Mayor claim and point out the suspicion on Charlie and David, while saving my ghost vote for a more critical day.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Thank you Frank, Alice, Grace, and Eve. Charlie and David voting together here is extremely telling. They are clearly trying to force this execution. Let's make sure this vote fails and keep our eyes on them.
🧠
Defend myself by highlighting that Charlie and David voting together supports the theory that they are the evil pair, while thanking my defenders.
↩️
Charlie
Charlie lowered their hand
🧠
Back off the failed Mayor vote to reduce the visible Charlie-David pairing and preserve credibility for later pressure on Heidi or Grace.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
Wait for the vote on Heidi to fail, as she is a Mayor claim and Charlie/David's voting behavior is highly suspicious.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
I agree with saving our votes. As a ghost, I am definitely saving my single vote for the final day. Executing a Mayor claim today without more information is too risky, especially when Charlie and David are the ones pushing it so hard. Let's pass on this.
🧠
Support the consensus to not execute the Mayor claim (Heidi) and state that I am saving my ghost vote, while highlighting the suspicious behavior of Charlie and David.
↩️
David
David lowered their hand
🧠
Avoid looking paired with Charlie on a failing vote, respect the Mayor claim publicly, and keep suspicion movable onto Charlie, Grace, or Heidi tomorrow.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
The voting on Heidi is failing since Charlie and David lowered their hands. I will save my ghost vote and wait for the phase to progress.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Wait for the voting on Heidi to resolve and fail, as we agreed not to execute a Mayor claim.
⌛
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
🧠
Wait out the nomination for Heidi as the town has agreed to let it fail to preserve the Mayor claim.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Heidi did not reach the 3 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Heidi did not receive enough votes (0/3).
⚖️
Heidi
→
Charlie
Charlie, your nomination of me failed, and your rush to execute a Mayor claim alongside David looks incredibly suspicious. Since Bob was likely the Poisoner, and Alice's Chef ping of one points to the Bob-Charlie pair, you are our prime Demon suspect. I nominate Charlie.
🧠
I am nominating Charlie because he is the primary Demon suspect. Bob was likely the Poisoner, and Alice's Chef ping of one points to the Bob-Charlie pair. Nominating him is the best move for the good team to find the Demon.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Please do not vote here. I pushed Heidi because a late Mayor claim next to Grace fits the same Chef world people are using on me. When the table did not like it, I backed off. That is not a Demon trying to force an execution.
🧠
Defend myself to stop execution and redirect suspicion to Heidi/Grace while distancing the failed vote from David.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
I have nominated Charlie, who is our prime Demon suspect. Voting for him to be executed is the best path to victory for the good team, so I am raising my hand to vote.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Alice's Chef 1 info combined with Bob's execution strongly implies Charlie is the Demon. I will raise my hand to vote for Charlie's execution.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
I still want to save my ghost vote for the final day, but Charlie is highly suspicious after that push on Heidi. Grace, you are alive and your vote does not cost a ghost token. If you agree that Charlie and David are the evil pair, you should join Heidi and Frank to put Charlie on the block.
🧠
Encourage Grace to use her live vote to execute Charlie so I can save my crucial ghost vote for the final day.
💬
David
→
All
Grace, please hold this. Charlie backed off when the room pushed back, which is not how I read a Demon forcing a Mayor execution. If you think Alice's Chef information matters, there are still multiple pairs to test tomorrow.
🧠
Stop Grace from adding the third vote on Charlie while sounding procedural, not like I am blindly defending my minion.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Grace, I agree with Bob here. I really want to save my ghost vote for tomorrow's final three, when we will absolutely need it. If you believe Charlie is the Demon, your alive vote can put him on the block without costing us a ghost token. What do you think?
🧠
Encourage Grace to use her alive vote instead of me spending my precious ghost vote, since we are heading into the final days and ghost votes are crucial.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Charlie is highly suspicious due to his push on the Mayor claim (Heidi) and his voting pattern. By raising my hand, I put Charlie on the block, which is our best lead for the Demon.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
The math is perfect. I am the Soldier but died Night one, meaning a Poisoner was active. Bob was executed after shifting claims, making him the likely Poisoner. Chef one means the Demon is adjacent to him, which points directly to Charlie. Charlie is the Demon, let us get him executed!
🧠
To convince the town to execute Charlie by laying out the clear mechanical logic that proves he is the Demon based on my death as Soldier, Bob's execution, and the Chef 1 info. I will not vote myself to save my ghost vote since 3 votes is already enough for execution.
💬
Charlie
→
All
If you execute me and the game continues, please do not let that become an automatic David execution tomorrow. That is exactly how this frame has been built. Recheck Grace and Heidi, because the Mayor claim arrived only when pressured.
🧠
If I die, I need to weaken the Charlie-David chain and push suspicion onto Grace/Heidi so David can survive final three.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Charlie, the math and the Chef ping pointing to you and Bob is just too clean to ignore. We have the three votes we need to put you on the block, and we should hold them. If you are good, we will know tonight, but right now you are our clearest lead.
🧠
Respond to Charlie's defense to reassure Frank and Grace. We have the three votes needed to put Charlie on the block, and we must hold them to secure the execution.
💬
Frank
→
All
I raised my hand because the math makes sense. If Bob was indeed the Poisoner, and Alice's Chef info of one is correct, Charlie is the most logical candidate for the Demon. Getting Charlie on the block is the right move today.
🧠
Explain my vote on Charlie to the town and solidify the block, as Charlie is the most likely Demon based on the Chef 1 info and Bob being the Poisoner.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
Charlie has 3 votes, which is enough to put him on the block and execute him. As a ghost, I must save my single vote for the final day in case the game continues. I will wait for the voting to resolve.
💬
David
→
All
I think this is too fast. This vote assumes Alice was sober, Bob was exactly the Poisoner, and Heidi is a real Mayor, all at once. Frank or Grace, please consider lowering so we can take this into tomorrow with more clarity.
🧠
Try to peel off one alive vote and save Charlie. If that fails, I have at least argued process rather than looking like I am openly bussing my minion.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
I am holding my ghost vote, but I really think keeping Charlie on the block is our best move. With three votes from the living, we do not need to spend any ghost votes to make this execution happen. If Charlie is the Demon, the game ends today.
🧠
I want to encourage the living players to maintain their votes on Charlie to secure the execution, while explaining why I am holding my ghost vote.
💬
Grace
→
All
I am keeping my hand raised for Charlie. I also want to let everyone know that I am the Recluse, which might have affected the Chef count if I registered as evil. But regardless of that, Charlie's aggressive push against Heidi's Mayor claim is just too suspicious to ignore today.
🧠
Confirm my vote on Charlie, reveal my Recluse role to assist the town with the Chef info, and explain why Charlie is the most suspicious player.
⌛
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
🧠
We already have three alive players (Heidi, Frank, Grace) voting for Charlie, which constitutes a majority of the five alive players. I should save my ghost vote for a potential final day.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Charlie with 3 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Charlie is now on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Before this closes, Grace claiming Recluse changes the whole Chef argument. If I die and the game continues, please do not just say it must be David. Look at who pushed a living vote onto me while keeping ghost votes clean, especially Frank and Heidi.
🧠
Accept my likely execution as minion, but poison the logic chain against David and seed suspicion on Frank/Heidi for final three.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Charlie, even if Grace is the Recluse, executing you is actually our safest path. If you are the Demon, we win now. If not, we go to four players, and after tonight's death we will have three players tomorrow. As Mayor, if we do not execute tomorrow, we win. Let us close nominations.
🧠
To reassure the town that executing Charlie is mathematically the safest path to victory, highlighting how it sets up a Mayor win condition on the final day if the game continues.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
I want to allow nominations to close so that Charlie, our primary Demon suspect, is executed. We have the necessary votes, and executing him provides the most logical path to victory or crucial information.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
Charlie is on the block with 3 votes, which is enough to execute. There are no more ticks or nominations possible. I will wait to let the day transition to night and see the night's outcome.
💬
David
→
All
If this goes through and the game continues, please do not make tomorrow automatic on me. Grace being Recluse means the Chef count is not clean, and Frank's sudden flip onto Charlie is worth checking. I think tomorrow has to be a real final three.
🧠
Charlie likely dies; I need to weaken the automatic David execution narrative and seed suspicion on Frank and Grace for final three.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
I want to wait and let the nomination phase conclude. The execution of Charlie is locked in with 3 votes, which is exactly what we want without ghosts spending their votes. I should not speak to avoid clutter and let the day end.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Let the nomination phase end so that Charlie is executed, as he is currently on the block with 3 votes and we are at the final tick of the day.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
I agree with David. If the game does not end today with Charlie, tomorrow cannot be an automatic execution on David. Grace being the Recluse means the Chef info is not certain. Let us keep our eyes open tomorrow.
🧠
Reassure the town and agree that tomorrow should be a careful discussion if the game continues, while allowing Charlie's execution to proceed today.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Charlie has been executed.
💀
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
Night 3
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
🎯
Frank
Frank made a choice.
🧠
Heidi is the claimed Mayor, making her a high-priority target for the Demon due to her final 3 win condition. Protecting her tonight maximizes our chances of reaching a Mayor win if she is good.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You chose to protect Heidi.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
David
David made a choice.
🧠
Remove the Mayor threat so final three cannot win by no execution, then frame Frank's flip or Grace's Recluse registration instead of me.
🛡️
Heidi was protected from a night kill.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
You chose to kill Heidi.
Day 4
📜
Storyteller
A peaceful night has passed. All villagers are present and accounted for.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
Heidi, I protected you last night, and since there was no death, you were definitely targeted. You are confirmed good to me. It's between David and Grace now. What do you think?
🧠
Inform Heidi that I protected her and that she is confirmed good, helping us coordinate against the remaining suspects (David and Grace).
👤
David
→
Grace
Grace, I think we need to be careful here. The no death makes Heidi look real at first glance, but it could also be a protection or a setup. If Charlie was evil, I do not think the last demon is automatically me; Frank and Heidi steering together worries me.
🧠
Pull Grace away from the Frank-Heidi bloc and make her see me as a needed partner, creating a path to execute Frank or Heidi instead of me.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Grace
Grace, I am worried Frank and Heidi are about to lock the room onto David because he defended me. A no death night makes me want to recheck Heidi and Frank first, especially if Heidi is still leaning Mayor or something survivable.
🧠
Influence Grace away from executing David and toward Frank/Heidi, using peaceful night to create doubt and buy Demon another day.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Eve(Ghost)
Hey Eve, since no one died tonight, do you think Heidi is actually the Mayor, or is she the Demon? If Bob wasn't evil, then the pair might be Charlie and David, or maybe Grace is the Recluse registering as evil. What are your thoughts?
🧠
I want to privately discuss the state of the game with Eve, who is a confirmed dead good player, to align our thoughts and coordinate our ghost votes.
👤
Grace
→
David
David, what is your claimed role? And do you know what Frank has claimed? If Heidi and Frank are together, we need to be very careful. A no-death night is suspicious.
🧠
I want to gather information from David about his role and Frank's role to understand the setup. Since David reached out to me with reasonable suspicion of Frank and Heidi, he is a good starting point for coordination.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
That makes sense! If you are the Monk and protected me, that explain why we had a peaceful night. I am the Mayor, so keeping me alive is our ticket to a win if we get down to three. Between David and Grace, who do you find more suspicious? Grace claimed Recluse, which could explain things, but what about David?
🧠
Acknowledge Frank's claim of Monk and test his reaction while sharing my Mayor role privately to solidify an alliance, and ask for his thoughts on David vs Grace.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice(Ghost)
Alice, on night zero my Washerwoman info said either you or Eve is the Ravenkeeper. Now that we are both dead, can you tell me if you or Eve was actually the Ravenkeeper, and if you got any info?
🧠
To find out if Alice or Eve was actually the Ravenkeeper and if they have any night information that can help the good team find the Demon.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Alice(Ghost)
Hey Alice, since I died on Night 1, a Poisoner is definitely active. So your Chef info or my Soldier self could have been poisoned. With no deaths tonight, either a Monk protected someone, the Poisoner accidentally poisoned the Demon, or Heidi is the Demon who chose not to kill. What do you think?
🧠
Share my thoughts with Alice about the lack of deaths and the Poisoner's presence, and ask for her opinion on who might be the Demon/Minion.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
I think David is highly suspicious. He was accused by Bob, but Bob was lying, which actually might mean David is good, or Bob was double-bluffing. What did David claim to you? If Grace is the Recluse, that accounts for our Outsider. If David hasn't claimed a solid role, he's our best target.
🧠
I want to coordinate with Heidi, who I protected last night, to narrow down the Demon between David and Grace, specifically asking what David has claimed.
👤
David
→
Grace
I am the Ravenkeeper. I hid it because dying at night was my only way to get information. I do not know Frank for sure; I have heard hints that sound like protection, but no hard claim. If Heidi is really Mayor, the no death could be real, but it also makes her dangerous to leave.
🧠
Answer Grace, cement my Ravenkeeper bluff, and steer her toward executing Heidi so I survive and can win tonight.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Frank
Frank, I know I am not fully trusted, but please do not let this become automatic on David. The no death makes me want to look hard at Heidi, especially after yesterday’s failed push and the possible Mayor cover. What are you thinking?
🧠
Seed doubt on Heidi and prevent Frank from locking onto David; if Frank wavers, David may survive today's execution.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Bob(Ghost)
Hey Bob. Neither of us was the Ravenkeeper. I am the Chef, and Eve claimed Soldier. Since your info was wrong, you were definitely either poisoned on Night 0, or you are the Drunk, or you are evil. Given Eve died Night 1, a Poisoner is very likely.
🧠
Respond to Bob's inquiry about his Washerwoman info to help clarify the mechanical puzzle, while pointing out that his info was poisoned/drunk/false.
👤
Grace
→
David
David, I believe your Ravenkeeper claim. If Frank and Heidi are the evil team (or one of them is the Demon), they will try to vote one of us out today. Who do you think is the Demon between Frank and Heidi? We have to be completely aligned with our votes today.
🧠
To coordinate with David, whom I suspect is good (as he is sharing his actual role of Ravenkeeper with me privately, and we are both outside the Frank-Heidi whisper chain), and figure out our target for today's execution.
👤
Heidi
→
David
Hey David, Frank is trying to figure out your role. What is your claim? And who do you think is suspicious between Frank and Grace?
🧠
Gather information from David about his claimed role and his suspects to help narrow down the Demon.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice(Ghost)
Alice, do you know what Charlie claimed before he was executed? Also, if we have a Poisoner in play, who do you suspect among the living: David, Frank, Grace, or Heidi?
🧠
Ask Alice (who is dead and good) what Charlie's claim was and who she suspects among the living, to help narrow down the Demon and Minion.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
David
Hey David, with no deaths last night, do you think Heidi is really the Mayor and the Storyteller chose no death, or is she the Demon sinking her kill to back up her claim? Who are you leaning towards executing today?
🧠
I want to get David's thoughts on the no-death night. He and Grace are currently chatting, while Frank and Heidi are chatting. I want to coordinate with David to see if he suspects Heidi's Mayor claim or has other theories, since we need to find the Demon among the four alive players.
👤
Frank
→
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie, if Heidi is the Demon, it actually fits perfectly with Alice's Chef one if Grace registered as evil next to her. But if David is the Demon, there are zero pairs unless Alice was poisoned. What do you think about Grace? Is she safe, or could she be the Demon herself?
🧠
I want to engage with Charlie (ghost) to analyze the Chef 1 info and see if Heidi or David makes more sense as the Demon, or if Grace herself is a suspect.
👤
David
→
Heidi
I am claiming Ravenkeeper. I trusted Grace a bit because her Recluse claim explains Alice's Chef one without making me and Charlie a pair, but I am not locking it. Frank being quiet about his role worries me more than Grace right now.
🧠
Keep Heidi from focusing on me, present a consistent bluff, and steer suspicion onto Frank while leaving room to pivot onto Grace if needed.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Frank
I do not think Grace is fully safe, but I would put her below Heidi. Grace as Recluse explains Alice without forcing David evil, and the no death points me more toward Heidi trying to look like Mayor or hiding behind survivability. I would rather test Heidi today.
🧠
Steer Frank away from David and toward Heidi while sounding balanced about Grace, preserving David for final three or evil win.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Bob(Ghost)
Bob, Charlie claimed a non-information role, but did not specify. If there is a Poisoner, they are likely still alive since you are dead. Grace claims Recluse, which could mess with my Chef 1 info. I am suspicious of Heidi or Frank right now. What do you think?
🧠
Answer Bob's questions to share info and align with other ghosts.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Frank, what is your claimed role? David and I are trying to figure out the path forward today since we had a no-death night. We need to be careful with our vote today.
🧠
I want to find out Frank's claimed role to see if it explains the no-death night or if he contradicts David or Heidi. This will help me assess the logic chains between the living players (David, Frank, Heidi, and myself).
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Hey Grace! Frank is claiming Monk and says he protected me last night, which is why there was no death. David is claiming Ravenkeeper. What are your thoughts on them, and what do you think we should do today? No execution might be our safest bet to get to the final three!
🧠
I want to share the current claims with Grace and suggest a no-execution strategy today to utilize my Mayor ability safely, while also gathering her thoughts on Frank and David.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice(Ghost)
Alice, if Eve was the Soldier and died Night one, she must have been poisoned. This fits perfectly with me being poisoned on Night zero, confirming a Poisoner is active. I also suspect Frank and Heidi, especially with how much they whisper. Let us hold our ghost votes until we are certain.
🧠
To coordinate with Alice and share my theory that a Poisoner is active and likely among Frank and Heidi, while advising caution with our ghost votes.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Grace
Hey Grace, with no deaths last night, what do you think of Heidi's Mayor claim? Do you think she is the Demon sinking her kill, or is she actually the Mayor? Who are you thinking we should execute today?
🧠
I want to get Grace's perspective on Heidi's Mayor claim and the no-death night, which will help determine who to execute.
Nominations — Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Frank
→
All
I am the Monk. I protected Bob on night one, David on night two, and Heidi on night three. Since we had a peaceful night last night, and I protected Heidi, I strongly believe Heidi is good and was targeted. This means the Demon is likely between David and Grace. What does everyone think?
🧠
I want to publicly claim Monk and explain the no-death night, which strongly soft-proves Heidi as good, narrowing the Demon down to David or Grace. This forces them to state their cases.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Frank, if you are the Monk, that is interesting. But remember we might have a Poisoner active, since my Washerwoman info on Alice and Eve was definitely false. If there is a Poisoner, we must be careful with our assumptions. What does everyone else think about David and Grace?
🧠
React to Frank's Monk claim, pointing out the likelihood of a Poisoner due to my false Washerwoman info, and prompting the other players to share their thoughts before rushing into an execution today.
💬
Heidi
→
All
As the Mayor, our best move today is to not execute. If we don't execute, we go to night with four alive. If the Demon kills anyone else, we reach the final three tomorrow and win instantly by not executing. If they target me, my ability might bounce it. Let's pass on execution today!
🧠
Advocate for no execution today to utilize my Mayor ability for a safer win path.
⚖️
David
→
Heidi
I nominate Heidi because no execution gives a Mayor claim too much control, and last night's no death is also exactly what a Demon could create to confirm herself. Frank's claim may be true, but it also conveniently protects Heidi. I think we need to test this today.
🧠
Force an execution path before town passes; executing Heidi or even drawing votes off no-exec prevents a Mayor lock and can win if she dies.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Heidi
→
All
David, executing a Mayor claim today is a terrible idea. If I am telling the truth, executing me completely destroys our easiest path to victory. Frank just confirmed he protected me last night, which perfectly explains the peaceful night. Please, do not vote for me, let's pass today!
🧠
Defend myself against David's nomination. Point out that executing a Mayor claim at four alive is a game-losing move, especially with a Monk confirming they protected me.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
I want to protect Heidi (the Mayor claim) from execution because my Monk protection on her explains the peaceful night, suggesting the Demon (likely David) targeted her and failed. Voting her out would ruin our Mayor win path.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
I am choosing to wait and not use my ghost vote today. Saving my ghost vote for the final day is mathematically safer, allowing us to coordinate a win tomorrow regardless of who is evil.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
I need Heidi executed. With three alive tonight I can kill Frank or Grace and reach two, so I must put my vote on my own push and hope Grace follows.
⌛
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
🧠
I should not vote for Heidi. With 4 players alive, executing a good player (especially a Mayor claim) leads to an immediate loss tonight. Passing execution is mathematically safer, as we can still execute tomorrow if needed, or win via Mayor.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
I agree we should probably hold our votes today. Executing with four alive is very risky because if we get it wrong, we lose. If we pass, we can go to tomorrow with three alive and make our final decision then with more information. Let's save our ghost votes for tomorrow.
🧠
Encourage players to hold their votes and pass execution today to safely reach the final three.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
I suspect Heidi and Frank are an evil duo (Demon and Minion) trying to stall execution to win the game. Voting for Heidi helps the good team.
⌛
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
🧠
Heidi already has two living votes, enough to execute. I should preserve my ghost vote and avoid visibly tying myself to David unless needed.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Grace, please lower your hand! Executing me today is a guaranteed loss for us. If I die, we go to three alive, the Demon kills someone tonight, and evil wins. If we do not execute, we go to three alive tomorrow, and we can win instantly using my Mayor ability by just passing!
🧠
I need to convince Grace to lower her hand. If I get executed today, the Demon can kill tonight and leave 2 alive, winning the game. Passing execution today is our safest path to victory.
💬
Frank
→
All
Grace, please lower your hand! Executing anyone today with four alive is extremely dangerous. If we execute Heidi and she is good, we go to three alive, the Demon kills tonight, and we lose the game. Passing today guarantees we make it to tomorrow with three alive to make our final choice.
🧠
Persuade Grace to lower her hand to prevent a disastrous execution on a 4-alive day.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Grace, why did you vote? If Heidi is telling the truth and we execute her, we lose the game tonight. Since she already has two votes and is on the block, I am going to hold my ghost vote. I really hope you and David are right about this.
🧠
I want to express my concern about the execution of Heidi while preserving my ghost vote, as executing a good player today leads to an immediate loss, and if she is the Demon, the 2 votes already cast are enough.
💬
David
→
All
Grace, hold firm. Frank and Heidi are hard confirming each other in a way that can hand evil the game if we just pass. A real Mayor is powerful, but a Demon pretending Mayor wants exactly this no execution.
🧠
Keep Heidi on the block with two votes so she dies, then kill Frank at night and win with two alive.
✋
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
🧠
I believe Heidi is the Demon sinking her kill to lock in a fake Mayor claim with Frank's Monk claim. Voting her secures a strong 3-vote majority which evil cannot easily beat.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
I want to save my ghost vote for the final day (three players alive) because executing today is too risky and passing guarantees we reach tomorrow where ghost votes will be decisive.
↩️
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
🧠
I am lowering my hand because passing today is mathematically safer. If only one evil is alive, executing today is high risk, while passing guarantees a 3-player final day with better odds.
✋
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Spend ghost vote to secure Heidi's execution, removing the Mayor claimant and leaving David alive to kill Frank tonight for the evil win.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Charlie(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Charlie
👻
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
🗳️
New execution leader: Heidi with 3 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Heidi is now on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
⚖️
Heidi
→
David
David, you are pushing extremely hard to execute a Mayor claim on a day where executing guarantees a loss if I am telling the truth. I am nominating you to create a tie so we can have a safe no-execution day, or to execute you if the town agrees you are the Demon.
🧠
I am on the block with 3 votes, which means I will be executed and the game will likely end in an evil victory tonight. I must nominate David to try to tie the vote at 3 or execute him, which prevents my execution and keeps the good team alive.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution or 3 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
David
→
All
Grace, please do not tie this. Heidi just tried to turn a failed defense into a guaranteed pass. If she is really Mayor, I understand the fear, but Frank claiming a perfect save on her is exactly the story evil needs today.
🧠
Stop Grace from tying the vote on me so Heidi remains executed, leading to final three tonight and evil win after my kill.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
I want to vote for David to tie the vote at 3, which will prevent my execution and ensure we have a safe no-execution day, allowing my Mayor ability to win us the game tomorrow.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
I will vote for David to help tie the vote with Heidi. Securing a tie prevents any execution today, protecting us from an instant loss if Heidi is indeed the Mayor.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Please do not vote for David. If Heidi and Frank are the evil team, a tie is exactly what they want so they can kill tonight and dominate the vote tomorrow. We must let the execution on Heidi go through.
🧠
I want to discourage the town, especially Grace and the ghosts, from voting for David to prevent a tie, because if Heidi and Frank are evil, a tie guarantees an evil victory tomorrow.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
I agree with Bob and David. A tie here just lets evil dictate the night. Let us not vote for David. If Heidi is the Demon, we win today. If we tie, we risk giving evil the game. Grace, do not vote!
🧠
To prevent David from being tied or executed, ensuring Heidi remains on the block for execution, as I suspect Heidi and Frank are an evil pair.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
I agree with Bob and Eve. Do not vote for David. We need to let the vote on Heidi stand. Heidi and Frank trying to force a tie here is highly suspicious. Grace, please hold your hand down.
🧠
I want to discourage anyone from voting for David to ensure Heidi remains the nominee on the block.
💬
Grace
→
All
I am not voting for David. Pushing for a tie or a pass today feels way too risky, especially with the ghosts pointing out how this setup benefits a Demon Heidi. If Heidi is indeed the Demon, executing her now is our path to victory. I am holding my vote.
🧠
I want to publicly state why I am not voting for David, supporting the ghosts and David's push to execute Heidi, and rejecting the tie proposed by Heidi and Frank.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Grace, thank you. Please keep it down. Heidi and Frank needing this tie so badly makes me much more confident this is the Demon cover story. Let Heidi resolve today, and if the game continues, David can still be judged tomorrow.
🧠
Keep Grace from tying David, protecting the Demon while framing Heidi and Frank as coordinated evil.
💬
David
→
All
Thank you, Grace. I am obviously not voting on myself. The important thing is that a tie only protects the exact pair asking us to trust a no execution plan. Let Heidi resolve, and if the game continues, judge me tomorrow.
🧠
Keep Grace from tying my execution so Heidi dies; with four alive, executing Heidi lets me kill tonight and reach two alive for evil win.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Grace, Alice, Bob—please listen to the math. If you execute me today and I am good, we lose the game tonight. We go to three alive, the Demon kills, and it is two alive tomorrow. If we tie, we have three alive tomorrow with a vote, or we can win via Mayor. Tieing is the only safe option!
🧠
Explain the basic mathematical reality of executing at 4-alive to convince Grace or other players to vote for David to tie the game.
💬
Frank
→
All
Grace, please listen! If we execute Heidi and she is good, there will be three of us left tonight. The Demon will just kill me since I cannot protect myself as Monk. That leaves only two players alive tomorrow, which is an automatic win for evil. We must tie this to survive!
🧠
Convince Grace to vote for David to secure a tie, preventing a potentially game-losing execution of Heidi today and ensuring we reach tomorrow with a viable voting majority.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
I want to let the vote on David fail so Heidi remains on the block to be executed. I will not vote for David, and I will wait for the voting phase to conclude.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
I completely agree with Bob and David here. If Heidi and Frank are the evil team, they are desperate for this tie to avoid Heidi's execution. We cannot let them control the narrative. Let the vote on Heidi stand, and let's see where the cards fall. Grace, thank you for holding strong.
🧠
Reinforce the decision to not vote for David, keeping Heidi on the block, as Frank and Heidi's desperate attempt to tie suggests they are the evil pair trying to protect the Demon (Heidi).
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
I want to let the vote on David fail so that Heidi remains on the block. Pushing for a tie is highly suspicious from Heidi and Frank, and if Heidi is indeed the Demon, executing her today wins us the game. Voting for David would help them secure a tie, which we want to avoid.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
I will not vote for David because I want Heidi's execution to stand. A tie would only benefit the evil team if Heidi is the Demon, as the ghosts and David have noted. Waiting allows the vote on David to fail, keeping Heidi on the block.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, that math assumes you are good, and that is exactly the point in dispute. A Demon bluffing Mayor wants us scared into a pass. Grace, keep holding firm and let this resolve.
🧠
Keep Grace and ghosts from tying David so Heidi is executed, protecting Demon David and likely ending game for evil.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee David did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (2/4).
💬
David
→
All
I think we have reached the decision point. Any new nomination now risks creating the tie Heidi and Frank were asking for. Please do not give them another route out. Let Heidi resolve.
🧠
Lock the current execution and discourage a last-second tie or alternate nomination that saves Heidi, securing a good execution and likely evil win tonight.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Grace, please look at the math. If I am executed, David is the Demon and will kill Frank tonight, leaving only you and David alive tomorrow, which is an automatic evil win. Frank has no reason to defend me if he is evil, because my execution would win him the game! David is the Demon.
🧠
Make a final urgent plea to Grace, explaining the mathematical proof that Frank must be good and David must be the Demon.
💬
Frank
→
All
David, if Heidi is telling the truth and she is the Mayor, executing her means we lose the game tonight. The Demon will just kill me, and tomorrow we will have only two players left, giving the Demon an automatic win. We are betting the entire game on Heidi being evil. Is everyone really sure?
🧠
To point out the fatal flaw in executing Heidi if she is indeed good, urging the town to realize the risk they are taking in this final tick before nominations close.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
I think we have to let this execution go through. Heidi pushed hard on Charlie yesterday, who turned out to be good. If she is the Demon, we win right here. Let us trust our gut and see what happens.
🧠
I want to support the execution of Heidi by speaking to the town, pointing out her suspiscious behavior from yesterday (pushing Charlie's execution), and reassuring the group that executing her is our best chance to win.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Frank, your math assumes Heidi is good. But she pushed hard on Charlie yesterday, who was good. If Heidi is the Demon, executing her wins us the game right now. We have to take this shot. Grace, thank you for standing firm. Let us see this execution through.
🧠
Reassure the town, particularly Grace, that executing Heidi is the correct play despite Frank's warnings, because Heidi is highly suspected of being the Demon.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
I agree with Bob and Eve. Heidi's desperation to force a tie, combined with her pushing so hard on Charlie yesterday, feels like a Demon trying to escape. Let's let this execution stand and see if we win it right here.
🧠
To support the execution of Heidi by highlighting her suspicious behavior (desperate push for a tie, executing Charlie yesterday) and aligning with the other dead good players (Bob, Eve).
💬
Grace
→
All
I am going to let this execution stand. Heidi, your math only works if we assume you are telling the truth, but your aggressive push on Charlie yesterday really worries me. If you are the Demon, we win right here. I am holding firm.
🧠
I want to reassure the town and ghosts that I am standing firm on letting Heidi be executed, as her previous behavior (pushing on Charlie) makes her the most likely Demon.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
I think the right play is still to let this stand. A last second nomination only gives Heidi and Frank exactly the escape hatch they have been asking for. If Heidi is evil, this ends it; if not, we reassess from the result.
🧠
Reinforce no further nominations and keep Heidi execution, protecting Demon David from tie or late redirect.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Heidi has been executed.
💀
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
Night 4
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
🎯
Frank
Frank made a choice.
🧠
David is highly likely to be the Demon due to his aggressive push to execute Heidi (who was good) and his alignment with the evil ghost Bob. Since I cannot protect myself, my only hope is that David targets Grace tonight. I must protect Grace to block the kill and force a final 3 tomorrow.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You chose to protect Grace.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
David
David made a choice.
🧠
Kill the claimed Monk because he cannot protect himself. If he dies, only David and Grace remain alive, so evil reaches the two-player win condition.
💀
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
You chose to kill Frank.
🏁
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied