Game Detail
Players
Alice (Butler) Bob (Baron) Charlie (Drunk) David (Saint) Eve (Fortune Teller) Frank (Undertaker) Grace (Imp) Heidi (Virgin)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 205,671 | 24,433 | $0.0881 |
| Good | 549,661 | 46,183 | $0.3964 |
Event Transcript
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
You are the Minion. The Demon is Grace.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Minions are: Bob. Your safe bluffs are: Monk, Slayer, Chef
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
π―
Eve
Eve made choices.
π§
Pick Bob and Frank to get early reads on opposite sides of the circle, building a baseline for future nights.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
You chose Bob and Frank. You receive the answer: NO.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Alice
Alice made a choice.
π§
Pick Bob as my master to restrict my voting Day 1. Since Bob is my neighbor, we can coordinate privately. This is a safe early choice while we gather information.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
You chose Bob to be your master.
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
π€
Grace
β
Alice
Hey Alice, I am the Monk. Have you heard anything suspicious yet? I am trying to keep track of everyone's claims.
π§
Initiate a bluff as the Monk to establish a role and gather trust, starting a conversation with Alice.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
It's day 1; I have no info. My best play is to listen first, observe who whispers to whom, and then decide who to trust. I'll wait a tick.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
Hey Alice, I am the Librarian. I checked and didn't see any outsiders in play, which is good news for us. Have you had a chance to talk to anyone else yet? I am trying to figure out who we can trust.
π§
I want to establish a Librarian bluff early to gain Alice's trust. By claiming 'no outsiders', I am creating a false narrative that might lead town to look for Outsiders who aren't there, or suspect those who are.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Eve
Hi, I'm trying to get a sense of the game. Do either of you have any useful information from your abilities that you're comfortable sharing?
π§
I will approach two players for private info gathering without revealing my Saint role. Choose players who might have useful abilities like Empath or Chef to get early reads on evil count.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
Hey Eve, it's Frank. I have a role that gets info after an execution. What's your read so far? Any suspicions?
π§
It's Day 1; I need to start building relationships and gathering information. Whispering to my neighbor Eve to establish a private channel and discuss initial thoughts.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Hi Grace, I am a Townsfolk with a useful ability. I think we can trust each other. What do you know?
π§
Establish a private connection with a neighbor to share information and build trust for potential nomination later.
π€
Eve
β
David
Hi David. I'm still gathering info myself. Do you have anything specific you're looking for? Any roles you suspect?
π§
I want to probe David's claim subtly without revealing my role yet. I'll share minimal info to gauge his reaction and see if he has trustworthy info.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
Bob, you said you're the Librarian and saw no outsiders. That's interesting. I haven't heard anything else yet, but if you're telling the truth, there should be zero outsiders. I'm trying to figure out everyone's roles.
π§
Probe Bob's claim to see if it aligns with my role and assess his truthfulness.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
I am the Monk, Heidi. I am keeping my eyes open for anything out of the ordinary. Since you have a useful ability, perhaps we can share information as the days progress? I would hate to see you wasted if the Demon targets you.
π§
I need to establish trust with Heidi while maintaining my Monk bluff. By offering to 'protect' her or share info, I make myself look helpful and town-aligned.
π€
Charlie
β
David
Hey David, I don't have any direct info from last night as my ability is passive. What about you? Are you a Townsfolk with night info?
π§
Respond cautiously to David. Share a little to seem helpful but not reveal my real role. Probe for his role or intentions.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
That is great to hear, Alice. I am leaning towards trusting you for now. Since you are looking for roles, have you heard anyone else claim anything specific? We should try to find the other good players before someone starts pointing fingers.
π§
I need to keep building rapport with Alice and gather information on what others are claiming, while maintaining my bluff as the Librarian. I want to see if she has heard any contradictory claims from other players.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Eve
Iβm a Townsfolk with a passive ability, so no night info. Iβd like to know if either of you has received any mechanical info from your roles. Charlie, you said passive ability β what role are you? Eve, how about you? No need to claim yet if youβre not comfortable.
π§
I want to gather info from neighbors without revealing my role yet, to assess claims and identify contradictions.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
Hi again, Eve. What do you make of the whispers so far? Anyone standing out to you as suspicious or trustworthy? Since you're my neighbor, I'm hoping we can work together.
π§
Establish trust with neighbor, gather initial impressions, and see if Eve seems cooperative or evasive.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Great, good to know you're the Monk. I can share my ability later when it's safe. Have you heard anything from others yet?
π§
Continue building trust with Grace to potentially use my ability later. Also gather information about her.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
Frank, I'm the Fortune Teller. Last night I checked you and Bob, and got a 'no demon' result. That means at least one of you is good, but there's a good player who reads as a demon to me, so be careful. What's your role?
π§
Frank is asking for my read. I'll share my N0 result (no demon among Bob/Frank) and probe him for his role claim to see if he's trustworthy.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
Bob, I need to clarify something. You said you're Librarian and saw zero outsiders. If that's true, does that mean you think no one in the game is an outsider? Because I haven't heard any outsider claims yet. Are you absolutely sure?
π§
Probe Bob's claim further to determine if he's lying or if I'm the Drunk. This clarifies our outsider count and Bob's trustworthiness.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
Not much yet, Heidi. People seem a bit hesitant to reveal their roles openly, which is understandable. I've only really spoken to Alice so far. Have you heard anything interesting from the others?
π§
I need to keep the conversation moving with Heidi without revealing too much, while gathering info on what she knows or what others might be saying. Pretending to be the Monk and acting helpful will build trust.
π€
Charlie
β
David
I'm the Mayor, David. My ability is passive and only matters if we get to final three. I'd appreciate if you'd share your role too so we can start building a good team.
π§
I want to establish trust with David by truthfully claiming Mayor, a low-threat passive role that can be verified later. This encourages reciprocal info.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
Alice, to be honest, I'm still processing the information I received. My reading was 'zero outsiders,' but I suppose it's possible I misinterpreted the sign or someone is interfering. Let's keep our eyes open for any weird behavior that might suggest an Outsider is actually hiding here.
π§
I need to walk back my definitive claim about zero outsiders while maintaining my Librarian bluff, as my Baron ability guarantees outsiders are in play. Acknowledging potential error makes me seem less suspicious.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Eve
Charlie, thanks for sharing Mayor. I'm the Saint, the Outsider. Eve, can you share your role? We need to see if Outsider count matches. Saint means if I'm executed, good loses. I want to avoid that.
π§
Get Eve's role claim to start building a mechanical picture. Compare with my Saint role to see if Outsider count matches expected 1 or if Baron might be present.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
Eve gave me info; I need to process it and see what others say before deciding my next move. Don't reveal Undertaker yet; wait for more conversations.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Actually, I am the Virgin. The first time I am nominated by a Townsfolk, they die instead. I was thinking maybe you could protect me after I use my ability? That way we can confirm a good player and maybe catch an evil nominator.
π§
Reveal my Virgin role to Grace to coordinate. If she is good, we can set up a plan. If she is evil, I can lure a nomination to trigger my ability and expose an evil player.
π€
Eve
β
David
David, I'm the Fortune Teller. I checked Bob and Frank last night, got a 'no demon' result, but I have a good player who registers as a demon. So one of them could be that false positive. Are you sure you're the Saint? That would fit the Outsider count.
π§
I need to verify David's Saint claim and see if he's the actual Outsider. Also, I should share my Fortune Teller info to start building mechanical deductions.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
Grace, earlier you said you're the Monk. I'm trying to verify claims. Bob claims Librarian and says zero outsiders. That seems off. Have you heard any other claims? Who do you trust so far?
π§
Bob's claim doesn't match expected outsider count. I'll subtly probe if he's lying or misinformed. As Butler, I need to hide my outsider status to avoid being executed as extra outsider. I'll whisper to Grace to see if she's real Monk.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I have been giving it more thought, and I think I might have misread my initial information. It is possible I am mistaken about the Outsider count, so I would prefer to hold off on any nominations today until we have more concrete information to go on. Let us see what tomorrow brings.
π§
I need to walk back my bad bluff. Claiming 'zero outsiders' as a Baron is easily disproven. I will claim I was confused or misremembered to stall and avoid being the focus of the day. Grace is the Demon, I need to keep the heat off her and myself.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Hello everyone. I'm the Fortune Teller. Last night I checked Bob and Frank, and I got a 'no demon' result. However, there is a good player who registers as a demon to me, so one of Bob or Frank could be that false positive. David has claimed Saint to me. I'd like to hear from Bob and Frank about their roles.
π§
I want to publicly claim Fortune Teller and share my N0 result to start building a mechanical picture. It will pressure Bob and Frank to respond, and test David's Saint claim against my false positive.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I have not heard anything from anyone else yet, Alice. Bob just mentioned he might have misspoken, which is interesting. If Eve is the Fortune Teller, we should see what Frank and Bob have to say for themselves before making any rash decisions. Let's see how the rest of the day plays out.
π§
I need to deflect suspicion from my minion Bob while maintaining my cover as the Monk. By supporting the idea of waiting and hearing more claims, I slow down the game and prevent an early execution.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Bob, Frank, Eve says she's Fortune Teller and got a no demon on you two, but there's a red herring. Can you both claim your roles?
π§
I want to introduce myself as Virgin to test someone, but first I need to see what Bob and Frank say. I'll ask them to claim to pressure them.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Observe Bob and Frank's role claims. See if Bob changes story. Then decide who to nominate.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Eve, thanks for sharing your Fortune Teller result. You said you got a 'no demon' on Bob and Frank, but there is a good player who registers as a demon. That means one of Bob or Frank is that good player. Which one do you think is the red herring? Also, Bob, can you please claim your role?
π§
Clarify Eve's claim and see if we can deduce who the red herring is, and why Bob is hesitant.
π¬
David
β
All
Bob, Frank, please claim your roles publicly. Eve's information points to one of you being a good player that registers as demon. Also, has anyone else claimed an Outsider role? I am the Saint, so we should have exactly one Outsider in play. If there's more than one claim, something is off.
π§
Eve's Fortune Teller claim puts focus on Bob/Frank. I'll ask them to claim and also ask for other Outsider claims to verify my Saint claim aligns with count.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I'm Frank, the Undertaker. I learn which character died by execution each night. So if we execute someone today, I'll have information tomorrow. Bob, can you claim your role?
π§
Reveal my role to help good coordinate. As Undertaker, I'm a valuable info role. Need to see Bob's claim first.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Eve has claimed Fortune Teller and is actively investigating people. She is dangerous. Killing her creates confusion, removes a source of information, and disrupts the town's coordination.
π
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to kill Eve.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Undertaker. No one was executed today so you learn nothing.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Alice
Alice made a choice.
π§
Pick a reliable master to enable my vote tomorrow. Grace claimed Monk (good), seems trusted. Bob is suspicious due to his contradictory zero-outsider claim versus Saint claim. If Grace is good, she'll likely vote, letting me vote. This gives voting power.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
You chose Grace to be your master.
Day 2
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Eve has been found dead in the night.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
Hey Frank. You said you're the Undertaker. Did you get any info last night about a Day 1 execution? There wasn't one, so you should have gotten 'no one died'. Can you confirm that?
π§
I need to gather info about Eve's death and confirm alignments. Frank claims Undertaker; he should have learned something about Day 1 execution, but there was none. Might confirm his role. Privately check with Frank about his Undertaker info and see if he's lying.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
Hey Frank, Eve died last night. You're the Undertaker, right? Did you learn her role? If she was Fortune Teller, that confirms her info about Bob and Frank not being the Demon. That would be huge.
π§
Eve was Fortune Teller, died night 1. Want to check Frank's Undertaker claim to see if her role is confirmed. If Frank is truthful Undertaker, he will know if Eve was Fortune Teller. This helps verify his role and Eve's info.
π€
Bob
β
Grace
Hey Grace, I'm sticking to my Librarian bluff. I told Alice there were zero outsiders, but with my Baron ability, there are actually three. We need to be careful; if the town starts counting outsiders and notices the discrepancy, they might sniff out the Baron. Stay hidden.
π§
I need to coordinate with the Demon to ensure we are aligned on our cover stories and that she stays hidden while I manage the town's perception.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
Assess the two whispers. Heidi checks my Undertaker consistency. Charlie suggests I should learn Eve's role from night death; but I only learn execution deaths, not night kills. Need to correct that privately.
π€
Grace
β
Bob
Bob, thanks for the heads up. We should be careful about the outsider count. If the town is questioning it, try to steer them toward doubting the claims, not the math. I'll maintain my Monk cover. Let's see who they nominate today.
π§
I need to acknowledge Bob's risk as the Baron and reinforce our strategy. Since he's the Baron, he knows there are extra outsiders, which could expose us if town tracks it. I'll advise him to sow doubt rather than panic.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
David
David, you claimed Saint. Any other info? I'm dead Fortune Teller, my N0 was Bob & Frank, got 'no demon' but one is false positive. Who do you suspect? We need to coordinate my ghost vote.
π§
I need to gather more info from living players. I'll whisper to David (Saint claim) to see if he's been targeted or has any info, and coordinate my ghost vote.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Observe private whisper patterns to see who is coordinating with whom. Eve died N1, she might have had info. Waiting allows me to see more conversations before deciding my move.
π€
David
β
Eve(Ghost)
I'm Saint, so if I'm executed we lose. Eve, your info is key. If Bob is the false positive, Frank is demon. If Frank is false positive, Bob is demon. Who do you trust less? I think we should pressure Frank today, see if Undertaker claim holds. Your ghost vote can sway.
π§
Coordinate with dead Eve to use her ghost vote strategically. As Saint, I must avoid execution but help town find demon. I'll share my Saint claim and ask her to push demon candidate.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
Frank, you there? Did you get a 'no one died' from the Undertaker ability last night?
π§
Pressure Frank to confirm his Undertaker info. Itβs a low-risk way to start gathering mechanical truths and see if he lies or hesitates.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
Frank, you said you're the Undertaker. Eve died last night, so you learned her role. What was it? Was she really the Fortune Teller? That's crucial to confirm her info about Bob and Frank not being the Demon.
π§
I need to confirm Eve's role via Frank's Undertaker claim to assess the reliability of her demon-check. This will narrow down the Demon pool.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
Alice, seeing Eve dead is tough. Did she share any final insights with you before the night phase? I still think we need to scrutinize these outsider claims, especially David's. The math doesn't seem to be adding up correctly for a standard game.
π§
I need to deflect suspicion from the Baron/outsider count and sow doubt about David (the Saint claim). By checking in with Alice, I reinforce my Librarian facade and try to push her to doubt David.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
Yes, I'm the Undertaker. Last night I learned that Eve was the Fortune Teller. That confirms her information that Bob and I are not the Demon. So we can trust that.
π§
Answer Charlie truthfully to confirm Eve's role, which is mechanically vital for clearing suspects. This builds trust and progresses info.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
Hey Alice, have you heard anything suspicious today? I have been keeping an eye on the town square as the Monk, but I am finding it hard to get a clear read on who is acting against our interests. Anyone stand out to you?
π§
Build trust with Alice by acting as a concerned Townsfolk (Monk) and gathering information on her suspicions to help manipulate the town's focus.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
Alice, I'm Eve, dead Fortune Teller. My Night 0 was Bob and Frank, got 'no demon', but one good player registers as demon to me. So either Bob or Frank is the demon, or one is my false positive. I think we should pressure one of them today. Who do you suspect?
π§
Share my N0 info and false positive mechanic with Alice to align good players and plan nomination target.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
I need to process the contradictory outsider claims and Eve's Fortune Teller info. I must decide whom to trust to set my master for tomorrow.
π€
David
β
Charlie
Charlie, you're Mayor. I'm Saint. Eve's Fortune Teller info points to either Bob or Frank as demon. Frank's Undertaker claim needs verification. If we execute someone today, Frank should learn their role. We can test him. Also, if you're Mayor, we might win if we reach final 3 without execution, but we need to eliminate demon before that. Who do you trust?
π§
Coordinate with Charlie (Mayor) to pressure Frank's Undertaker claim and verify Eve's info. Mayor's ability wins if final 3 and no execution, but we need to find demon before then.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
Frank, I asked you twice about your Undertaker info. There was no execution yesterday, so you should have learned 'no one died'. If you can't confirm that, it means you're not the Undertaker or you're poisoned. Please answer.
π§
I need to verify Frank's Undertaker claim. If he can't confirm 'no one died', he might be lying, which suggests evil. I'll confront him publicly next if needed.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
Frank, thanks for confirming Eve was Fortune Teller. That means her info about Bob and you being not demon is correct, so you're both cleared. Now we need to find the demon among the rest. As Mayor, I want to avoid execution only if we're sure, but we should execute someone to get your Undertaker info. Who do you think we should execute today?
π§
Confirm Frank's Undertaker claim and understand his confidence. Eve's role confirmation is key; if true, we have two cleared good players and can focus elsewhere.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, have you noticed how much everyone is fixated on the outsider counts? It feels like people are just fishing for reasons to lynch someone. I am starting to think David might be using that Saint claim to shield himself. What do you make of him?
π§
I want to sow suspicion towards David to distract from the outsider count discrepancy. If I can get Charlie to doubt David, it might lead to a mis-execution.
π€
Frank
β
Heidi
Heidi, you're mistaken. Undertaker learns which character died by *execution* each day, not night kills. So last night I learned nothing because no one was executed yesterday. Today, if we execute someone, I'll learn their role tonight.
π§
Clarify my ability to Heidi to avoid suspicion and maintain my credibility as Undertaker. Also, push for an execution today to gain information.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
Alice, I'm getting a bad vibe from David. He's claiming Saint, but nobody has really corroborated his role yet, and it's a very convenient role for an evil player to hide behind. Have you heard him say anything that actually confirms his story, or is he just coasting?
π§
I want to sow distrust in David to prevent him from being a threat, and hopefully manipulate Alice into suspecting him, keeping the focus off me and Bob.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, I'm Eve, the dead Fortune Teller. My Night 0 checked Bob and Frank, got 'no demon' but one good player registers as demon to me. So either Bob or Frank is demon, or one is my false positive. I think we should pressure Frank today to test his Undertaker claim. Who do you suspect?
π§
Coordinate with Grace to triangulate on Bob/Frank info, assess Undertaker claim, and identify likely Minion to narrow Demon pool.
π€
Alice
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve, my Butler. Bob told me his Librarian info was zero outsiders, which contradicts David's Saint claim. So either Bob is lying or David is lying. Who do you think we should pressure? Also, you said your Fortune Teller check was Bob or Frank is demon. Do you trust that info?
π§
I need to privately coordinate with Eve (dead, trustworthy) to cross-check claims and decide who to pressure.
π€
David
β
Grace
Grace, I'm David, the Saint. Eve's Fortune Teller info says either Bob or Frank is the demon. Frank claims Undertaker. What did Bob whisper to you? We need to figure out if Frank is lying. If we execute someone today, Frank should learn their role, so we can test him. What do you think?
π§
Coordinate with Grace to pressure Frank's Undertaker claim and gather info on Bob. Grace might have key info from Bob whispers.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
David
β
All
Everyone, we need to focus. Eve's Fortune Teller info says either Bob or Frank is the demon. Frank claims Undertaker. Frank, did you get any info last night? There was no execution yesterday, so you shouldn't have learned anything. We should consider executing someone today to test Frank's ability. If Frank is lying, he's likely the demon.
π§
Call for Frank to share Undertaker info from previous execution (Day 1 none) and propose a test execution to verify his claim. This pressures Frank and may reveal contradictions.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Okay, everyone, Iβm the dead Fortune Teller. Night zero I checked Bob and Frank and got a 'no demon' answer, but one of them is a good player that registers as a demon to me. So either Bob or Frank is the demon, or one is my false positive. David is pushing to test Frankβs Undertaker claim. I think we should nominate Frank today to see if heβs lying. If heβs not the Undertaker, heβs likely the demon. My ghost vote will support that.
π§
I want to summarize my Fortune Teller info and urge nomination of Frank or Bob to pressure test claims, leveraging my ghost vote to coordinate.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I understand the need to pressure someone, but executing Frank just to test his Undertaker claim when there was no execution yesterday seems like a waste. If we execute him and he is good, we lose a valuable player. Maybe we should look closer at others before jumping to conclusions.
π§
I want to deflect attention away from my Minion, Bob, and Frank. By discouraging an immediate execution, I buy time and create doubt about the logic of executing based on inconclusive Fortune Teller info.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Alright, let's think this through. Eve's Fortune Teller info is crucial: Bob or Frank is the demon, or one is her false positive. Frank claims Undertaker, and he says he learned nothing last night because there was no execution, which is correct. That doesn't prove him good, but it's consistent. So, maybe we should test Bob instead of Frank today?
π§
I need to speak to clarify Frank's position and Eve's info. If Frank is truthful Undertaker, we should test Bob instead. But we must decide who to execute today.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Eve's Fortune Teller info gives us two candidates: Bob or Frank. Frank's Undertaker claim is unverified. Bob's Librarian info of zero outsiders directly contradicts David's Saint claim. We need to nominate one today to test the waters and get information. I'm leaning towards Bob because his info conflict is a direct lie if David is truthful, but we need to decide.
π§
Summarize the two main suspects (Bob and Frank) based on Eve's Fortune Teller info and outsider count discrepancy. Urge group to pick one for nomination.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Everyone, let's be clear. Undertaker learns the executed character's role at night. Since no one was executed yesterday, I learned nothing. That's not suspicious. Eve's Fortune Teller info points to Bob or me. Bob claimed Librarian with zero outsiders, but David claims Saint, an outsider. Those claims can't both be true. We should execute Bob today to test his claim. If Bob is lying, he's likely evil. If he's good and Librarian, then David must be lying about Saint. That will give me information...
π§
Clarify that I got no info due to no execution, push to test Bob's contradictory claim and use my ability to gain information tonight.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Everyone, wait a moment. My Librarian information was what I had, but maybe the outsider count is misunderstood. If David is the Saint, that role is inherently suspicious because they want to be executed. Why are we trusting a potential Saint over looking at other possibilities?
π§
To cast doubt on David's Saint claim, making him a more suspicious target than myself, and to deflect from the Librarian claim contradiction.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I think we need to focus on the contradiction between Bob's Librarian claim and David's Saint claim. They can't both be telling the truth. If David is truly the Saint, then Bob is lying and likely evil. If Bob is truthful, then David is lying. Either way, one of them is likely the Demon or a Minion.
π§
Clarify the contradiction between Bob's Librarian info and David's Saint claim. Push to resolve which one is lying, as that will point to the Demon or false info.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 2
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
I need to kill David, the Saint. Keeping him alive is dangerous because he might push the town to execute him or investigate him further, and killing him removes the person most aggressively questioning the logic of others, potentially framing the death as a 'demon' kill.
π
David(Ghost)
David has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to kill David.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Undertaker. No one was executed today so you learn nothing.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Alice
Alice made a choice.
π§
I need to choose a master for tomorrow's voting. The key conflict is Bob vs David. Choosing Frank balances both worlds and keeps my vote flexible for whichever direction we go.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
You chose Frank to be your master.
Day 3
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. David has been found dead in the night.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
Alice, I'm David, the Saint. That's why my claim contradicted Bob's Librarian zero-outsider info. I'm dead now, so I can't be executed. Who do you trust, Bob or Frank?
π§
As dead Saint, I must prevent good from executing me. My death proves I'm not Minion. I'll share my Saint claim with Alice (unclaimed) to gather info, probe her alignment, and coordinate ghost vote.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Grace, I'm the Virgin. My ability triggers if a Townsfolk nominates me, killing them instead. I haven't been nominated yet. I think we can use this to test someone's alignment. Who do you trust?
π§
Establish trust with Grace, who previously claimed Monk. Share my role and plan to test Virgin ability to catch evil or confirm a good player.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
That is a bold claim, Heidi. It is dangerous for the town if you get nominated by the wrong person, but it is a powerful bluff if you are lying. I have been protecting people as the Monk, but I am open to working with you. Who do you suspect?
π§
I need to sound cooperative while assessing if Heidi is truly the Virgin, which would be a major threat. I'll maintain my Monk bluff and try to shift suspicion onto others, perhaps Frank or Alice.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
I'm dead, but my N0 info: Bob and Frank are not both Demons. One is good, one might be the false positive. I suspect Bob is lying about Librarian; David's Saint claim suggests Bob might be evil. Can you share any info?
π§
As dead Fortune Teller, I need to coordinate with alive players to narrow down Demon suspects. My N0 info is crucial: Bob and Frank are not both Demons; one might be the good Demon false positive.
π€
Frank
β
Bob
Bob, I'm the Undertaker. If we execute someone today, I'll learn their exact role. That can prove your Librarian claim or David's Saint claim. Who do you think we should execute?
π§
Share my Undertaker ability's utility: If we execute someone today, I'll learn their character, helping resolve contradictions. I'll whisper to both sides to coordinate.
π€
Alice
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve, I'm the Butler. That means there is at least one outsider. David claimed Saint, Bob claims zero outsiders. So either Bob is lying or David was not really the Saint. Since David is dead, we can't execute him to lose, but his Saint claim now can't lose us the game. Who do you think is the demon between Bob and Frank?
π§
Gather more info by checking Eve's story and David's claim; confirm my Butler role to build trust and clarify outsider count.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
Alice, David just whispered to you. What did he say? He claimed Saint earlier, and now he's dead at night. That might confirm his claim. Also, any thoughts on Bob's Librarian claim conflicting with David's Saint claim?
π§
David's death may confirm his Saint claim or not. Need to gather info on who is evil. I'll whisper to Alice to see what David told her as ghost and coordinate.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
Frank, thanks for the idea. Since David's claim was so problematic, it is a shame he died. Maybe we should look at Alice? She seems very focused on coordinating with the ghosts, which feels like she is digging for something that is not there. What do you think?
π§
I need to divert suspicion from the Demon (Grace) and keep the town confused. Frank is a threat because he could verify roles. Suggesting Alice helps sow discord and wastes an execution on a good player.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Charlie
Charlie, I'm David, the Saint. Bob's Librarian info of zero outsiders is false because I exist. That means Bob is lying or poisoned. My death proves I'm not a Minion. Eve's fortune teller pointed to Bob or Frank. Who do you think is the demon?
π§
Clarify my Saint claim is true and contradicts Bob's Librarian info. Encourage Alice to analyze this conflict to find the demon between Bob and Frank, or consider a third candidate if both are good.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
Frank, I'm the Virgin. My ability triggers if a Townsfolk nominates me, killing them instead. I haven't been nominated yet. I want to help town find the Demon. What's your read on Bob?
π§
Share my Virgin claim with Frank to gauge reaction and potentially set up a test. If Frank is evil, he might try to nominate me or avoid.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
Heidi, I find Frank suspicious. He has been quite aggressive towards Bob, and if Frank is pushing a narrative without proof, he might be trying to deflect. Shall we see if he is willing to nominate you? If he is a Townsfolk, it is a high-risk move for him.
π§
Sow discord by framing Frank as the suspicious party, pushing Heidi to target him, and furthering the Monk bluff by feigning caution.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
Bob is definitely lying about zero outsiders. That makes him evil. My N0 said Bob or Frank is demon or false positive. If Bob is evil, he's likely the Demon, and Frank is the good false-positive. We should execute Bob today.
π§
Coordinate with Alice to pressure Bob about his Librarian claim contradiction. As dead Fortune Teller, I can confirm Bob/Frank info and push for Bob's execution.
π€
Frank
β
Heidi
Heidi, Virgin is a strong claim. If you're telling the truth, we can test you with a Townsfolk nominator to confirm. But we must be careful; if you're evil bluffing, that's risky. What do you think about Bob versus David's claims? Who should we execute for my Undertaker info?
π§
Heidi claims Virgin, which is a powerful Townsfolk. If she's telling truth, she can be a nomination test. But need to verify her claim carefully, and coordinate with Bob's info to decide execution target.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
Grace, I need to tell you something. I am the Butler, an Outsider. That means Bob's Librarian claim of zero outsiders is false. David claimed Saint, which fits. Bob is lying or drunk. I'm thinking we should execute Bob today.
π§
Share my Butler role with Grace to add outsider count evidence and get her thoughts. As Monk, she may have protection info to confirm alignments.
π€
Charlie
β
David(Ghost)
David, thanks. Your death at night does support your Saint claim. Bob's Librarian info of zero outsiders is contradictory, so he's likely lying or poisoned. Since you're dead, you can't be minion, so Bob is likely evil. Eve's fortune teller points to Bob or Frank, so Frank could be the false positive. Let's push to execute Bob today.
π§
Need to discuss with David the Saint claim and implications. His death at night strengthens his claim and makes Bob's zero-outsider info suspicious. Coordinate with ghost David to plan next steps.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
I agree Frank. If we look at Alice, we can see if her playstyle matches up with anything specific. She has been very quiet about her own role while pushing others. It feels suspicious.
π§
I need to keep Frank focused on Alice and away from Grace or me. By directing his suspicion toward Alice, I can keep the town divided and prevent them from looking too closely at the Demon.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Charlie
Charlie, I agree we should push to execute Bob. His Librarian claim is proven false by my Saint existence. Even if he's the Drunk, he's still good, but a lying Bob is more likely evil. I'll use my ghost vote on Bob if nominated. Can you coordinate with others to nominate him?
π§
I'm dead and confirmed not a Minion. My Saint claim proves Bob's zero-outsiders info false. Need to decide between Bob (lying) and Frank (possible false positive). My ghost vote is key; I'll coordinate with Charlie who agrees Bob is suspect.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Grace, I think we need to decide who to execute today. Bob or Frank? My Virgin ability is still unused, but I'm not sure we should risk it yet. Which one do you think is more likely the Demon? Let's hear from others, but I trust your Monk claim.
π§
Bob and Frank are top suspects. Need to coordinate with trusted players to decide which to execute. Grace is my Monk claim ally. Need her input on using my Virgin ability or voting strategy.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
Heidi, Alice claiming to be the Butler this late is suspicious. It conveniently targets Bob right as the pressure mounts. I am not convinced Bob is the liar here. Frank's aggressive behavior still feels like a distraction. Maybe we should push on Frank instead?
π§
Sow doubt about Alice's late Butler claim to protect my Minion Bob and redirect suspicion toward Frank.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
Observe further whispers to see if anyone contradicts Alice's Butler claim or defends Bob's 'zero outsiders'. Determine which world is more consistent.
π€
Frank
β
Heidi
Heidi, I'm considering your Virgin claim. If we can get a Townsfolk to nominate you, that's a safe confirmation. But we also need to resolve Bob vs David. Who do you think we should execute today for my Undertaker info? I'm leaning towards Bob to check his Librarian claim.
π§
Assess Heidi's Virgin claim and Bob's push on Alice. Need to decide who to execute for Undertaker info to resolve claim conflicts.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
Charlie, David told me he is the Saint. I'm the Butler, an Outsider, so Bob's Librarian claim of zero outsiders is false. Bob is lying or drunk. Who do you think is the Demon, Bob or Frank?
π§
We need to decide between Bob and Frank. My Butler role proves an outsider exists, contradicting Bob's claim. This heavily implicates Bob as evil, likely the Demon.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
Alice, you're Butler? That's two outsiders with David Saint, so Bob's Librarian claim of zero is false. Bob is lying or drunk. If Bob is evil, he's likely the Demon because Eve's fortune teller pointed to him or Frank. We should push to execute Bob today. Can you whisper to others to get votes?
π§
Coordinate with Alice to unify our push. Bob's Librarian claim is proven false by two outsider claims. If we think Bob is Demon, we execute him. If Frank, we need to pivot. Must decide which world is more likely.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
Frank, Alice is suspiciously quiet about her role, yet she's whispering constantly with the dead players. It feels like she's trying to manipulate the town's perception using 'ghost intel.' Maybe she is the Saint? If we execute her, we might find out.
π§
I need to deflect suspicion from myself (the Librarian liar) onto someone else (Alice) to keep the town focused on anyone but me or Grace. Suggesting Alice as a target for the Undertaker to 'check' is a classic misdirection.
Nominations β Day 3
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Bob
β
Alice
Alice has been incredibly quiet about her own role while spending all her time whispering with the dead. It feels like she is manipulating the town's perception with ghost information. We need to see who she is, and if she's the Saint, we'll know soon enough.
π§
I am nominating Alice to remove her from the game. She is potentially dangerous due to her interaction with the dead, and there is a chance she is the Saint, which would mean an instant victory for the evil team if she is executed.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
I need to ensure Alice is executed. Getting her out of the game removes a potential threat to Grace (the Demon) and, if she happens to be the Saint, it secures an immediate victory for our team. I will vote to ensure the execution goes through.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, stop! Do not vote for Alice. Bob's Librarian claim of zero outsiders is false because I am the Saint. If Alice is the real Saint, executing her loses the game. Bob is lying or evil, and we should be nominating him, not Alice. Don't waste our execution.
π§
I need to warn everyone not to execute Alice because she might be the Saint, and that would lose the game. I'll argue that Bob is lying about his Librarian info and is likely evil, so we should nominate and execute Bob instead.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
I agree with David. Bob's Librarian claim of zero outsiders is impossible because we have a Saint dead and Alice claims Butler. Bob is lying. We should not execute Alice; it's too risky if she really is the Saint. We need to pressure Bob instead.
π§
David is dead and claiming Saint; we must trust him. Bob's claim is false, so he is lying or drunk. Alice's Butler claim adds weight. We should not execute Alice now, as David warns it could lose game. I will vote No on Alice.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Alice, your sudden push against Bob feels like a desperate attempt to frame him before we make a decision. Why should we trust your Butler claim over the established information? Bob's analysis has been consistent, and the ghosts might be misinterpreting things. We need an execution today.
π§
I need to convince the town to vote for Alice to protect my minion, Bob, and eliminate someone who is actively accusing him. By questioning Alice's sudden Butler claim, I hope to make the town suspicious of her rather than Bob.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I agree with David and Eve. Bob's Librarian claim of zero outsiders is impossible with a dead Saint and a claimed Butler. Executing Alice could lose the game if she is indeed the Saint. I think we should vote no on Alice and instead nominate Bob to test his claim.
π§
We need to resolve the Bob vs David contradiction safely. Executing Alice is risky if she's Saint; we should vote her down and instead push for Bob execution to check his Librarian claim and get my Undertaker info.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Everyone, we must not execute Alice. David is the Saint, confirmed by his death. Alice claims Butler, making two outsiders. Bob's Librarian claim of zero outsiders is false. Executing Alice could lose us the game if she is the real Saint. We should vote no on Alice and nominate Bob to test his claim.
π§
Urge everyone not to execute Alice because she could be Saint and lose the game. Push to vote no and nominate Bob instead to test his claim.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I think we need to be careful. Bob's Librarian claim of zero outsiders contradicts David's Saint and Alice's Butler. That means Bob is lying unless there's a Drunk or Recluse. Executing Alice risks losing the game if she's Saint. Let's not vote Alice today.
π§
Clarify the key contradictions: Bob's Librarian vs David's Saint and Alice's Butler. Urge no vote on Alice to avoid accidental loss.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Everyone, listen. I am the Butler. David is the Saint. That makes two outsiders, so Bob's zero outsiders claim is false. Executing me could instantly lose the game if I were the Saint, which I'm not, but you can't take that risk. We should vote no on me and then nominate Bob to test his story.
π§
I need to persuade living players not to execute me because executing me could lose the game if I'm Saint (bluff) and it distracts from the real Demon. I must refocus town on Bob's contradiction.
π¬
Bob
β
All
David says he is the Saint, but he is dead, so how can we be sure? If he is the Recluse, my information as Librarian might still be perfectly accurate. Do not let the ghosts manipulate your logic and protect the real threat! Alice is acting just like a minion desperate to survive.
π§
I need to deflect the accusation that my Librarian claim is impossible by casting doubt on David's Saint claim. If the town believes David might be the Recluse, my 'zero outsiders' claim is no longer immediately disproven, which protects me and keeps the pressure on Alice.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Town, please listen. Executing Alice could lose us the game instantly if she is the Saint. I am the confirmed Saint β my death proves it. Bob's claim of zero outsiders is impossible. Let's vote no on Alice, then nominate Bob to test his story. Don't throw the game on a risky execution.
π§
Urge town not to execute Alice, as it risks losing if she is Saint. Highlight the contradiction in Bob's claim. Use my ghost vote to vote against Alice, pushing for Bob's nomination next.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
Observe voting pattern to see who votes for Alice vs. not. If Alice gets 3 votes and dies, we learn if she's Saint (game loss) or Butler (outsider). If she lives, we can push Bob nomination. My ghost vote is critical; I should not vote now, wait to see if close.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Bob, you make a fair point about the reliability of ghost claims, but everyone seems convinced Alice is the Saint. We cannot afford an execution that loses us the game. Let us vote no on Alice to be safe, and then we can look at the other candidates properly.
π§
I need to prevent Alice from being executed because the town is turning against Bob, and Alice is the current target of a failed lynch attempt. If I push too hard for Alice's death, I draw suspicion. Supporting the 'don't risk the Saint' logic makes me look like a cautious, helpful townie.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I'm with the ghosts on this one. We cannot risk executing Alice. Bob's claim of zero outsiders contradicts two outsider claims. If Alice is actually the Saint, we lose. Let's vote no on Alice and then execute Bob to test his Librarian story. That will give me Undertaker info to confirm.
π§
Reinforce that executing Alice risks instant loss; vote no to prevent loss and pivot to Bob for testing his claim, which will give me Undertaker info.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Everyone, the outsider count is clear. David is the Saint, confirmed by his death. Alice claims Butler. That's two outsiders. Bob's Librarian claim of zero outsiders is impossible unless he's lying or drunk. We cannot execute Alice and risk losing the game. Vote no on Alice, then we nominate Bob.
π§
Explain the outsider count contradiction clearly to convince town to vote no on Alice and push for Bob execution next. Emphasize game loss risk and logic.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I agree with the ghosts. Executing Alice could end the game instantly if she's the Saint. We have two outsider claims, so Bob's zero outsiders claim is false. Let's vote no on Alice and then carefully test Bob. Don't take the risk.
π§
Convince town to vote no on Alice. We cannot risk losing if she's Saint. Better to test Bob's claim later, which gives us Undertaker info.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Bob, your nomination makes no sense. Executing me risks an immediate loss if I were the Saint. I am the Butler, David is the Saint, that's two outsiders. Your zero-outsider claim is false. Instead of attacking me, let's test you β if you're good Librarian, the information will become clear after your execution. Town, vote no on me and we nominate Bob next.
π§
Argue against execution, highlight risk, push for Bob nomination to test Librarian claim and protect town from instant loss.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Alice did not reach the 3 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Alice did not receive enough votes (1/3).
π¬
Bob
β
All
Wait a minute! If David is the Saint and Alice is the Butler, then there are clearly outsiders in play. That means my Librarian information was wrong. If I am the Drunk, that explains the error perfectly! Why execute a confused Drunk when the real Demon is still out there?
π§
Deflect the inevitable execution attempt by claiming to be the Drunk. This provides a logical (though fake) explanation for my 'incorrect' Librarian information without admitting to being evil.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Bob, you just admitted your Librarian information is wrong. A good Drunk would never nominate Alice, risking the game if she were Saint. You're trying to save yourself after being caught. Town, we must nominate Bob next β he's either the evil Librarian or a minion lying about his role. Don't fall for this.
π§
Bob's admission he could be Drunk is a trap; a good Drunk wouldn't nominate a potential Saint. Must reinforce that Bob is lying and we must execute him next.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Bob, your zero outsiders claim is impossible with David the Saint and Alice the Butler. You tried to execute Alice knowing it could lose us the game if she were Saint. Thatβs an evil move. Town, we must nominate Bob next. Heβs either the lying Librarian or a minion. Donβt let him escape.
π§
Pressure Bob with logic that his outsider count is impossible, proving he's lying. Encourage town to nominate and execute him next.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Bob, while your Librarian information might have been faulty, I think executing you right now is premature. If we execute you and you turn out to be the Drunk, we have wasted our only execution for today and still have no closer lead on the demon. Let's think carefully before rushing to judgment.
π§
To create doubt about executing my minion, Bob, and buy time/sow confusion. By defending him slightly, I might convince the town to hesitate or look at someone else, keeping Bob alive longer to continue causing chaos.
π¬
Frank
β
All
We can't afford to waste another day. Bob's Librarian claim contradicts two outsider claims. If he's the Drunk, fine, we execute him and I learn his role. That's valuable information. If he's evil, we catch him. Sitting on our hands helps the demon. I support nominating Bob now. We have one tick left; let's do it.
π§
I need to consolidate the town's suspicion onto Bob. His claim contradiction is the clearest evidence of evil. My Undertaker ability will confirm his role after execution, giving us hard info. I must push for his nomination now before the day ends.
βοΈ
Charlie
β
Bob
Bob's zero outsider Librarian claim is impossible with Saint and Butler in play. He tried to execute Alice, risking a game-ending loss. Executing him will confirm his role and move us forward.
π§
Bob's claim is impossible given the outsider count. He either lied or is Drunk, but his risky nomination of Alice suggests evil intent. We must execute him to gain Undertaker info and eliminate a suspect.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Listen, executing me only gives you information about my role, but it does nothing to find the Demon. If I am the Drunk, you lose your execution and the Demon lives another day. Why are you so eager to rush an execution that might not even help us? Grace, help me out here!
π§
I need to create doubt and delay my execution. Appealing to Grace (the Demon) for support is a risky but necessary move to survive. If I can convince even one person that executing me is a waste, I might survive this block.
β
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
π§
Bob admitted his info is wrong, and his actions risked a game loss. Executing him resolves his alignment and gives Frank (Undertaker) info. As a ghost, my vote ensures we get the majority needed for execution.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
π§
Bob's info is impossible given outsider claims. His actions risk losing game. Executing him will confirm his role and narrow demon pool.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Bob is my Minion. He is going to be executed anyway. By voting for him, I firmly establish myself as a "good" player who is helping the town, keeping my Monk bluff secure while my Minion takes the fall. This builds massive trust for me.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Bobβs claim is impossible; he either evil or Drunk. Executing him gives me Undertaker info and resolves outsider count, moving us forward. We canβt waste day.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Bob, you admit your Librarian info is wrong. Your nomination of Alice risked a game-ending loss. We need to know your true role. Executing you reveals if you're the Drunk or evil. And Frank gets Undertaker info. That's progress.
π§
I need to confirm why we must execute Bob. He admits his info is wrong. If he's evil, we catch him. If he's Drunk, we confirm outsider count and can trust Alice and David.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I agree we need to execute Bob. His Librarian claim can't be true with two outsiders confirmed. Even if he's the Drunk, we get Undertaker info and eliminate confusion. I'm voting yes.
π§
Bob's story is impossible given outsider count. Executing him will confirm his role via Undertaker and eliminate an evil player or a Drunk who is a liability. We have majority votes already; I'll add my vote to ensure execution.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Bob, it's simple. Your information contradicts reality. Executing you resolves the contradiction and gives Frank's Undertaker information. If you're good Drunk, we know. If you're evil, we catch you. We have to act. I'm voting yes.
π§
Argue for Bob's execution to resolve contradiction and gain Undertaker info, regardless of his alignment. As Butler, I need my master to vote; Frank is my master today, he is voting, so I can vote.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Wait, think about this! If I am the Drunk, you just lose your execution and the Demon is still hidden. Why are you so certain I am the Demon or a Minion? You are throwing away your only chance today on a guess when there are other leads to follow. Don't throw the game away!
π§
I am on the block and currently receiving votes to be executed. I need to desperately sow doubt or plead for my life to avoid execution, as I am the Baron (Minion) and the Demon (Grace) is still in play.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Town, the vote is nearly there. Bob admitted his Librarian info is wrong. That means he's either drunk or evil. Either way, we need that Undertaker information. If we don't execute, we gain nothing, and the demon gets a free night kill. We have to vote.
π§
Consolidate town to vote Bob. My vote is already placed, but my words can sway remaining players like Heidi and Alice to vote and ensure execution. The logic chain proves Bob's claim false, and execution is necessary for information.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, we have enough votes to execute Bob. This is not a guess. Bob's Librarian claim is impossible. Executing him gives Frank the Undertaker info we desperately need. If he's the Drunk, we know. If he's evil, we catch him. We must not waste this day. Please, those with hands raised, keep them up. Let's end this.
π§
Urge final votes on Bob. His execution is necessary to resolve contradiction and get Undertaker info. We cannot afford another wasted day.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I agree with the town's reasoning here. While Bob's logic about being the Drunk is a possibility, his behavior and the impossibility of his Librarian claim make him the most logical target. We need the Undertaker information from Frank to move forward. I am keeping my vote on Bob.
π§
I am the Imp, and my minion Bob is about to be executed. To maintain my cover as a helpful Monk, I must align with the town's decision to execute Bob, as my resistance would look suspicious and likely wouldn't save him anyway. Sacrifice is sometimes necessary.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
Voting to execute Bob: resolves contradiction, gives me Undertaker info, forces progress. If heβs evil, we catch him. If heβs Drunk, we clear confusion.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Executing Bob resolves the contradictory outsider count, gives Undertaker info, and eliminates a risky player. Even if he's Drunk, we progress. I must vote yes.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Bob, your Librarian claim of zero outsiders is impossible with David the Saint and Alice the Butler. Even if you are the Drunk, executing you gives Frank Undertaker information and clears up confusion. We need that info to find the Demon. I'm voting yes.
π§
Explain to Bob that his claim cannot be true and executing him is necessary for Undertaker info. This advances the game regardless of his alignment.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Town, we have the votes to execute Bob. His Librarian claim of zero outsiders is impossible with David and me. Even if he's the Drunk, we get Undertaker information to move forward. Don't second-guess; this is the logical play.
π§
We have votes on Bob; I need to reinforce the logic: his claim impossible, he's the best execution for info. Encourage remaining voters to close the vote.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
π»
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Bob with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Bob is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Bob
β
All
If you kill me, you are making a mistake, but it is your game. Just know that when I am dead and Frank reveals my role as the Baron, look at who was pushing this execution hardest. Grace, I truly hoped you were the Monk you claimed to be. Good luck, town. You are going to need it.
π§
I'm about to be executed, so I want to plant seeds of doubt. By mentioning Frank, I cast suspicion on his 'Undertaker' info, and by naming Grace and her Monk claim right before I die, I create a potential point of conflict or confusion for the town regarding her reliability.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
Observing the execution outcome. Bob's reveal as Baron if true changes everything. Need to see Frank's Undertaker info tonight to confirm. Waiting to see if any last-minute nomination changes occur.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
Execution is already decided; wait for result to see Undertaker's info and analyze Bob's final words. We can then re-evaluate.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Bob, accusing me while you are about to be executed is a desperate move to distract from your own impossible claims. I have been consistent with my Monk claim throughout, and my votes have been purely based on the logical contradictions you presented. This is exactly what a trapped wolf would say.
π§
Deflect the accusation from Bob by framing it as a desperate, manipulative tactic from a failing Minion, while reinforcing my own Monk bluff.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Alright, Bob is executed. Tonight I will learn his role. That will confirm if he is the Drunk, a Minion, or the Demon. His accusation at Grace is concerning, but we should not jump to conclusions. We need to think about who else is suspicious and prepare for tomorrow.
π§
Bob is about to be executed; I will get his role tonight. I need to prepare town for my info and consider what his accusation at Grace implies. Also, I must think about what comes next after execution.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Bob's last words are an obvious attempt to deflect. Let's not lose focus. The execution was the right move given the contradiction. We'll get Frank's Undertaker info tonight, and then we can analyze that. Grace has been consistent, and Bob's accusation is unsupported.
π§
Address Bob's accusation to prevent town from turning on Grace. Reinforce that execution is logical regardless of Bob's alignment and that we await Undertaker info.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Bob's accusation is a classic desperate move to sow doubt. We executed him because his claim was impossible. Now Frank gets Undertaker information, which will tell us if Bob was the Drunk or something else. Let's not get distracted. Prepare for the night.
π§
Reinforce town unity, dismiss Bob's last-minute accusation as desperation, and prepare for night. Keep focus on Undertaker info and maintain pressure on remaining suspects.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Just a quick clarification for the town. There are two confirmed outsiders: David the Saint and me the Butler. That means Bob's Librarian claim of zero outsiders was false. So if he was the Drunk, it makes sense. We'll know for sure after Frank's Undertaker info tonight.
π§
Clarify the Outsider count: With David Saint and me Butler, we have exactly two Outsiders. Bob's claim of zero outsiders as Librarian is impossible unless Bob is the Drunk, which now fits. This should inform town's night planning.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Bob has been executed.
π
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
Night 3
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Killing Frank is the best strategic move. Frank is the Undertaker, and his information tonight will expose Bob as my Minion (or worse, confirm him as a Minion if he reveals his role). Getting rid of him prevents him from sharing that damning info with the town.
π
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to kill Frank.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Alice
Alice made a choice.
π§
We executed Bob to get Undertaker info. I need to choose a master for tomorrow. Frank is now highly trusted if his info confirms Bob is Drunk. I'll choose Grace as master to stay flexible, as she is less likely to be Demon.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
You chose Grace to be your master.
Day 4
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Frank has been found dead in the night.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Grace
Hey, I'm the Fortune Teller. Night zero I checked Bob and Frank - neither was the Demon. Frank's death last night suggests the Demon killed to stop Undertaker info. We need to find who's left. Who do you suspect?
π§
I'm dead; my info is still useful. Whisper Charlie & Grace (alive neighbors) to coordinate final 3, share my N0 info, push for Demon identification.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Grace
,Charlie
We need to figure out who the Demon is. I'm the Saint; we cannot execute me. Frank was Undertaker and died last night. Let's discuss: who did you protect last night, Grace? And Charlie, any new insights?
π§
Frank, Undertaker, died last night. Need to coordinate ghost votes to avoid Saint execution. Must identify the Demon between Charlie and Grace.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, even though I was wrong about my role, I promise you Grace is not the Monk. She's been playing you all. If she survives the final day, you've handed her the win. Don't trust the quiet ones.
π§
I am sowing distrust against Grace, the Demon, even though I previously outed her. This is a contradictory move, but I need to make the town second-guess their assessment of her, creating enough chaos to possibly save her if she is being targeted.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Grace
I'm the Undertaker. Yesterday's execution on Bob revealed he was the Drunk. So Bob was good. That means Grace, you are likely truthful as Monk, and the evil is still among the living. We need to find the Demon.
π§
Share crucial Undertaker information about Bob's executed role to help determine alignment and catch the Demon.
π€
Alice
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank, you claimed Undertaker and should have seen Bob's role last night. What did you learn? This is crucial to confirm if Bob was lying. Please share with everyone.
π§
I need to consult dead players, especially Frank, to learn what he saw as Undertaker. That will confirm Bob's alignment and help us identify the Minion or Demon.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
,Grace
Frank's dead. He was the Undertaker and would have learned Bob's role after execution yesterday. We need to hear from Frank's ghost what he learned. Also, we need to figure out who the Demon is. Can we get Frank to tell us Bob's true role?
π§
Frank died night 3 after executing Bob (Day 3). That suggests Demon killed Frank. Why? Maybe Frank's Undertaker info revealed something dangerous to Demon. I need to find out what Frank learned as Undertaker from Bob's execution. I'll whisper to Charlie and Grace to coordinate.
π€
Grace
β
Charlie
It is tragic to lose Frank. As the Monk, I have been trying to protect players, but I cannot save everyone. Since Frank is dead, we cannot rely on his Undertaker info directly unless he shares it somehow. We must focus on the living. Who do you trust, Charlie?
π§
I need to maintain my Monk cover and steer the conversation away from looking for the Demon too closely, while also appearing helpful and saddened by the loss of 'good' players.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,Heidi
We need Frank's ghost to tell us what he learned about Bob's role. That's crucial. Also, Grace claims Monk, but Bob accused her. If Bob was Baron, he'd lie to protect Demon. Let's hear from Frank.
π§
Coordinate with Alice, Heidi, and Grace to get Frank's ghost info and cross-check claims. As Mayor, I need to survive to final 3 and prevent execution to win. But first, find Demon.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Grace
Charlie, Grace, did Frank share any info with you last night? I'm Fortune Teller, I checked Bob and Frank night zero - both not Demon. I'm thinking Frank was killed to silence his Undertaker info.
π§
Get Charlie & Grace to share what Frank told them before death. Their reactions may reveal alignment.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
Observe further whispers and claims. As dead Saint, my ghost vote is spent; I can advise but need to see more interactions to deduce Demon among Alice, Charlie, Grace, Heidi.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, don't let them rattle you. You've held this town in the palm of your hand for days. Just stay calm and push the narrative on Heidi. They have no proof.
π§
Reassure the Demon (Grace) and keep her focused on staying alive. She needs to keep her cool to win the final day.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
Alice just asked for my Undertaker info. I need to consider the full picture and potential poisoning before responding, as revealing incorrectly could mislead the town.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Wait a moment to see if Frank's ghost will respond to my whisper and share his Undertaker info. If he doesn't, I'll pressure him again.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
,Grace
Let's get Frank's ghost to speak. He learned Bob's role last night as Undertaker. That's our most solid clue. Frank, if you can hear us, please tell us Bob's role. Charlie and Grace, we need to coordinate to hear from Frank and then decide who to suspect.
π§
Get Frank to reveal Bob's role learned last night. This will confirm or deny the Baron theory and clarify the Outsider count. Then we can triangulate evil.
π€
Grace
β
Charlie
,Heidi
I agree, Heidi. Frank's information is crucial. If he confirmed Bob was the Drunk, that explains why Bob's claims were so chaotic. We should proceed carefully and not rush the execution until we are certain about the Demon. Does anyone have any other leads besides Frank?
π§
I need to keep the town focused on the 'Undertaker' narrative while subtly discouraging them from looking at me. By agreeing with Heidi, I appear helpful and aligned with the town's goal, buying time to figure out the final play.
π€
Charlie
β
Heidi
Heidi, we absolutely need Frank's ghost to tell us Bob's role. That's the key. Also, we need to ask Grace who she protected last night to verify her Monk claim. We need to pressure them both in public discussion soon.
π§
Coordinate with Heidi to get Frank's info and then evaluate Grace's claim vs Bob's accusation, crucial for finding Demon.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Grace
I am the Fortune Teller. Night zero I checked Bob and Frank, neither was the Demon. Frank's death suggests the Demon killed to stop Undertaker info. Who did Frank tell about Bob's role? We need to figure out the Demon among the living: Alice, Charlie, Grace, Heidi.
π§
We need to coordinate as good players to identify the Demon. Sharing my Fortune Teller info that Bob and Frank were not Demons eliminates them from suspicion.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
Observe conversation flow to see if any contradictions arise from whispers, especially between Grace's Monk claim and night kill. As dead Saint, I should gather info from ghosts and living before acting.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
Alice, be careful. Notice how quickly Charlie and Heidi are agreeing on everything? It feels like they have already coordinated their votes for the final nomination. Don't let them railroad you into a decision you will regret.
π§
I want to sow discord between Alice and the remaining town members to prevent a united front against Grace. Creating suspicion about coordination between Charlie and Heidi might distract them.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
I need to observe reactions and see who pushes for my info. My Undertaker info is powerful, but I should wait for others to share first to see contradictions.
π€
Alice
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank, you need to tell us what you learned as Undertaker about Bob's role. This is the most important piece of info we have. If you're good, you have to share it. The whole game depends on it.
π§
Bob ghost warns of Charlie/Heidi coordination. I need to hear from Frank's ghost about Bob's role. If Frank doesn't respond, maybe he's evil and faking death. I'll whisper to Frank publicly to pressure his ghost info.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Waiting to see if Frank's ghost reveals Bob's role. That info will clarify the outsider count and Bob's alignment, narrowing down Demon suspects.
π€
Grace
β
Charlie
,Heidi
I agree we must find the truth. With Frank gone, we have to look at everyone's actions. Heidi, you were very keen to hear from Frank; is there any reason you are pointing us toward him specifically? I feel like we should look at Alice's behavior too. What do you think, Charlie?
π§
To sow doubt in Heidi and Alice, steering the town's suspicion away from me and towards others while maintaining my Monk persona.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
,Heidi
I agree, we must hear from Frank's ghost. Let's ask him publicly at the start of nominations. Grace, you claimed Monk - who did you protect last night? That could help confirm your story.
π§
Coordinate with Grace and Heidi to pressure Frank's ghost for Bob's role, and then check Grace's protection target to verify her claim.
Nominations β Day 4
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I understand your concern, Charlie. I protected Alice last night, believing she was a target for the Demon. With Frank gone, we are truly in the dark, but we must stay calm and analyze the living. I trust we can make a sound decision. Who are you currently leaning towards, Charlie?
π§
I need to deflect suspicion from myself while appearing cooperative as a 'Monk'. By claiming I protected Alice, I create a narrative that ties into the game events without being verifiable. I want to shift the focus to others.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Frank, if you're listening, please tell us what role you learned when Bob was executed. We need that information to figure out who the demon is. Grace, you said you protected Alice last night β can you explain why you chose Alice and if you have any other insights from the game?
π§
Pressure Frank's ghost to reveal Bob's role publicly, then ask Grace for details of Monk protection to verify claims. This will help narrow down demon possibilities among Alice/Charlie/Grace.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Frank, as a ghost you can still speak. Please tell everyone what role you learned from Bob's execution. That information is critical to determine if Bob was lying about outsiders. If you don't share, we'll have to assume you're evil.
π§
I am publicly calling Frank's ghost to share his Undertaker info. This is the key to evaluating Bob's claim and thus identifying the Demon. If Frank doesn't share, we should consider him evil.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Alright, everyone. I'm the Undertaker. Last night I learned that Bob was the Drunk. So Bob was good, not evil. Grace's Monk claim is likely truthful. The evil is still among the living: Alice, Charlie, Grace, Heidi. We need to find the Demon.
π§
I must share my Undertaker info to confirm Bob's role, which resolves contradictions and points to the Demon among the living players.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Frank's reveal that Bob was the Drunk is huge. That means we have two confirmed Outsiders: me and Bob. Alice is also good as Butler. So the Demon is either Charlie, Grace, or Heidi.
π§
Confirm Frank's Undertaker info and narrow the Demon pool to the three living players who are not confirmed Outsiders or confirmed good.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I am the Baron, Frank, not the Drunk. You are clearly being manipulated or are simply mistaken about what you saw. Do not let these lies dictate the final vote. Grace is the Demon, and she is playing you all perfectly.
π§
I need to counter Frank's claim that I was the Drunk. If he thinks I am the Drunk, he might clear Grace. I must sow enough doubt to prevent a consensus on executing Grace. Discrediting the Undertaker's information is my only play.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Okay, we have a critical piece of information. Frank's Undertaker learned Bob was the Drunk, not the Baron. That means we have two confirmed outsiders: David the Saint and Bob the Drunk. Alice's Butler claim fits. So the Demon must be among Charlie, Grace, and Heidi. I know I'm good, so the Demon is either Grace or Heidi.
π§
Summarize the key information: Frank's Undertaker info says Bob Drunk, confirming two outsiders. That narrows Demon to me, Grace, or Heidi. I know I'm good, so Grace or Heidi is Demon.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 4
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
I need to eliminate Charlie to narrow down the town's focus and reduce the number of potential accusers, as he has been actively trying to deduce the Demon among the remaining players.
π
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to kill Charlie.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Alice
Alice made a choice.
π§
I need to pick a master for tomorrow's vote. Choosing Grace ensures I can vote if she votes, but I should choose someone I think is good to avoid being vote-locked if master is evil. Choose David dead to guarantee I can't vote, which might be suspicious, or choose Charlie as potential good to align voting.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
You chose Grace to be your master.
Day 5
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Charlie has been found dead in the night.
π
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
Alice, we are the only ones left who can make this choice. I have been protecting the town as best I can as the Monk. I honestly believe Heidi is the one who has been manipulating everything from the shadows. We have to execute her.
π§
I need to isolate Heidi and convince Alice that I am the Monk, so that Alice will vote to execute Heidi instead of me. If I succeed, Heidi will be executed and the evil team wins.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
Listen, final three. Iβm the Saint. Frank was Undertaker and learned Bob was Drunk, confirming two outsiders. Bob claimed Baron but likely was Drunk. That means we have two outsiders: me and Bob. So Minion is dead. Demon is among you three. I think we need to cross-check claims and night kills.
π§
Final 3: Alive are Alice, Grace, Heidi. Need to decide who is Demon. Must whisper my dead info and logic to both good players to coordinate execution.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
Okay, it's final three alive: Alice, Grace, and Heidi. I'm dead Mayor, so my ability to win with no execution is irrelevant now. David ghost, you're here. We need to decide who to execute. Bob ghost says Grace is Demon. Grace claims Monk protecting Alice last night. Who do we trust? Let's coordinate my ghost vote.
π§
Establish a final plan with the two living players and David's ghost to coordinate the single ghost vote and execution to win.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, stay calm. You have played this perfectly. If Alice or Heidi tries to push the nomination, remember that any vote against you is a vote for their own demise. Stay quiet and let them fight each other. Do not give them a reason to doubt you now.
π§
Coordinate with my Demon (Grace) to ensure she survives the final day by staying calm and letting the good players turn on each other.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Grace
,Alice
I'm Eve, Fortune Teller. Night zero I checked Bob and Frank, got 'no' for demon. So demon is not Bob or Frank. That means demon is among you three. With Charlie dead, demon is either Alice, Grace, or Heidi. We must decide who to execute.
π§
We are in final 3; demon is among Alice, Grace, Heidi. I need to share my N0 info and analysis to guide the living to execute the demon.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
David(Ghost)
,Charlie(Ghost)
David and Charlie, what were your roles and any key info? We need to figure out who the Demon is among Alice, Grace, Heidi.
π§
Gather info from dead players to confirm roles and determine which of the final 3 is the Demon.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Listen to ongoing whispers to gauge accusations and solidify my logic before acting. Grace likely Demon, but I need to hear what others are saying first.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Gather more information and final ghost whispers before making a decision. Need to coordinate ghost votes.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
Alice, look at the pattern. I have been claiming Monk the entire time, yet here we are at the final three. If I were the Demon, I would have killed you nights ago. Heidi has been suspiciously silent and hasn't contributed a single defense. She is the Demon. We have to execute her.
π§
I need to secure Alice's vote against Heidi. By framing my survival as 'Monk protection' and pointing out Heidi's silence, I can direct suspicion away from myself in this critical final three.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
We have three alive. I am the Saint, dead. Frank was Undertaker, learned Bob was Drunk. That confirms two outsiders: Saint and Drunk. So the Minion is already dead. The Demon is one of you three. We need your full claims and any night info. Who could Charlie's killer be?
π§
I'm dead Saint, ghost vote used. Need to help living good players deduce Demon. Share outsider count logic to confirm Minion dead, narrowing Demon pool to three. Push for claims and night kill analysis.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Frank(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
Okay, Frank, you were Undertaker. Who died on execution days? What did you learn? David, you were Saint, any info? We need to figure out if Grace is lying about being Monk, or if Bob is lying about being Baron. My ghost vote depends on this.
π§
Coordinate with dead players to decide who to execute. My ghost vote is crucial. I need to gather key info from Frank and David about their roles and any mechanical info to prove who is lying.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
I am dead and in the final 3. Grace is my Demon. I need to remain quiet to avoid drawing attention to her and let the two remaining good players, Alice and Heidi, potentially turn on each other or make a mistake. Staying silent is the safest bet to ensure Grace's survival.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
Observe interactions. Ghosts and alive are whispering. Need to hear claims and deduce demon from contradictions.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
David(Ghost)
,Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie, I learned no executed characters because there were no executions. David, confirm Saint? If true, we must not execute you. Need all dead info to map roles.
π§
Gather confirmed info from dead players to deduce who among the living is lying, then direct ghost votes accordingly.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
It's final 3. I must reveal my role and nominate the Demon. Grace is the most likely Demon based on ghost info and process of elimination. Need to assess ghost chatter before acting.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
Heidi, we are final three. I'm Alice, the Butler. Grace claims Monk and says she protected me last night. What is your role? We need your claim and any night information you have to figure out who the Demon is.
π§
We need to coordinate with all ghosts and living to force claims and compare information. I'll whisper to Heidi to get her role claim and reasoning.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
Alice, please consider this carefully. If I were the Demon, why would I have kept you alive until the final three? My Monk ability has been focused on keeping you safe. Heidi's silence is suspicious; she is waiting for us to turn on each other.
π§
I need to convince Alice that I am the Monk who has been protecting her, which makes me 'safe,' while painting Heidi as the Demon to ensure she is the one executed.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
Final three. I'm dead Saint. Frank was Undertaker, learned Bob was Drunk. That's two outsiders: Saint and Drunk. So Minion is dead. Demon is among you three. We need your full claims and any night information. Who did you protect or visit? Who could have killed Charlie? Let's solve this.
π§
Get final three to reveal full claims and night info. As dead Saint, I can't be executed, so I must coordinate ghosts to find Demon among Alice, Grace, Heidi. Use confirmed outsiders to deduce Minion status.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Frank(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
Let's think. We have confirmed Outsiders: David (Saint), and either Bob (Drunk) or Bob (Baron). Alice claimed Butler, which is an Outsider. That's three Outsider claims. Base game has 1 Outsider. So either Bob's Baron claim is true (adding +2 Outsiders) making three Outsiders possible, or someone is lying. If Bob is Baron, he's evil. If Bob is Drunk, he's good but unaware. Which fits?
π§
Frank's Undertaker info is useless (no executions). Need to reconcile Outsider count and claims to determine Demon.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Heidi
Alice, Heidi, remember the history here. Frank was the Undertaker and he got it wrong. If you execute Grace, and she is the Monk, you will lose instantly. Are you sure you are not just executing an innocent player and handing the game to the real Demon?
π§
To sow doubt and confusion in the final 3, potentially preventing them from executing the Demon (Grace). I am trying to make them second-guess their logic.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
Iβm dead but listen: my N0 check on Bob and Frank both said βno demon.β So demon is not them. That means the demon is among you three alive. Charlie just died, so demon is Alice, Grace, or Heidi. We must execute one of you today. Who do you think is most likely?
π§
Remind all ghosts to push final three alive to coordinate. Share my Fortune Teller info to narrow demon to three players. Since I'm dead and can't vote, I need to convince the living to execute correctly.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
David(Ghost)
,Charlie(Ghost)
David, are you certain you're the Saint? If yes, we cannot execute you. Charlie, you need to confirm your role. We have three Outsider claims: David Saint, Alice Butler, and Bob claimed Drunk then Baron. Base game has 1 Outsider, so Baron adds two. If Bob is Baron, there's three Outsiders and Bob is evil. If Bob is Drunk, only one Outsider, so either Alice or David is lying. Which fits?
π§
I need to coordinate with dead players to solve the Outsider count and determine which world is true. My Undertaker info on Bob's executed character would have revealed if he was Baron or Drunk. Since no executions, I lack that. We must deduce from roles.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
I am Heidi, the Virgin. My ability is useless now because no one will nominate me. I have no night info. I think the Demon is either Grace or a Minion turned Demon. If Charlie was the Imp and killed himself, a Minion becomes Imp. Who could be the Minion? Bob was Drunk, not Baron. Could Grace be lying about Monk? Or could there be a Spy/Poisoner?
π§
I'm Virgin, I need to claim to Alice to establish my role and align trust. My Virgin ability is useless now as no nomination will likely occur, but my claim helps clear me as Townsfolk. I must evaluate Demon candidate between Grace and potential Minion-turned-Demon scenario.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
I need to process the final three logic, cross-check claims, and decide who to vote for. Wait and listen to more whispers to gather info.
Nominations β Day 5
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Okay everyone, it's final three. I'm Heidi, the Virgin. I have no night info, but we have to decide who is the Demon. Grace, Alice, please state your claims clearly for the ghosts to hear. And any mechanical evidence we have.
π§
Final three; we must deduce Demon. Need to force claims and test mechanical possibilities to find the liar. I'll reveal my role publicly to encourage them to do the same and observe reactions.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Okay, ghosts and living. I'm Charlie, the dead Mayor. We need to resolve the Outsider count. Base game has one Outsider. We have David Saint, Alice Butler, and Bob claimed both Drunk and Baron. If Bob is Baron, we have three Outsiders, so Baron exists and Bob is evil. If Bob is Drunk, we have two Outsiders, meaning either David or Alice is lying. Grace, Alice, please restate your claims and any proof, like protection last night.
π§
Publicly summarize key points for ghosts and living: Outsider count inconsistency reveals lying. Need everyone's claims to cross-check. I'll ask Grace and Alice to restate claims and any protective evidence.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I have been consistent with my Monk claim throughout the game. Last night, I protected Alice. If I were the Demon, why would I protect a potential threat? Heidi just claimed Virgin now, at the very end. That is a convenient, unverifiable claim. I believe Heidi is the one we must execute.
π§
I need to shift suspicion onto Heidi and solidify my Monk bluff. Since I'm the Imp, I just need to survive this day without being nominated or voted for. Claiming I protected Alice (who is alive) reinforces my Monk role and might make Alice feel safer with me.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Ghosts, listen. I am Eve, the Fortune Teller. Night zero, I checked Bob and Frank. Both came back 'no demon'. So the demon is not Bob or Frank. That means the demon must be one of the three alive: Alice, Grace, or Heidi. Charlie is dead, so that's cleared. We need to execute today. Grace claims Monk, protected Alice last night. Heidi just claimed Virgin. Alice claims Butler. My mechanical info says demon is among you three. I think we need to vote on who is most suspicious.
π§
We are at final three. My N0 info eliminates Bob and Frank. Demon is among Alice, Grace, Heidi. Need to present my info and push for execution of most likely demon based on claims and behavior.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Heidi, you claim to be the Virgin, but you have waited until the final day to reveal that. It feels incredibly forced. Alice, think carefully. Grace has protected you consistently. Why would the Demon protect their victim? Do not let a last-minute claim lead you into a trap.
π§
I am sowing doubt about Heidi's late-game claim to divert suspicion away from Grace (the Demon). I am trying to manipulate Alice into mistrusting Heidi.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I need to address the night kill. Grace, you said you protected me last night. But I'm the Butler, a powerless role. Why would the Demon target me? If you're the Monk, they could have targeted Heidi or someone else. Why was Charlie killed instead? That seems odd. Heidi, why do you think you're still alive?
π§
I need to clarify the night protection and why I'm alive. If Grace is Monk and protected me, I shouldn't have been killable last night. If Demon is Grace, she wouldn't kill me. This helps solve which scenario is likely.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, the Outsider math is clear. The base game has one Outsider. We have three Outsider claims: me Saint, Alice Butler, and Bob claimed both Drunk and Baron. If Bob were Drunk, we'd have two or three Outsiders with no Baron, which is impossible. So Bob must be the Baron, making him evil. That means there is a Minion among the dead. The Demon is among the three alive. Eve's Fortune Teller info says demon is not Bob or Frank, confirming that.
π§
The Outsider count is key. Bob must be Baron, making him evil. So the remaining evil is Demon among Alice/Grace/Heidi. Eve's Fortune Teller info clears Bob and Frank, so Demon is among the three alive. Need to deduce which one.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Ghosts, I'm Frank the Undertaker. I never got any executions, so I have no info on Bob's character. But we have solid info: Eve's Fortune Teller cleared Bob and me, putting the Demon among Alice, Grace, and Heidi. We must resolve the Outsider claims. If Bob is Baron, he's evil and adds two Outsiders, making David Saint and Alice Butler fit. If Bob is Drunk, there is a liar among David and Alice. Grace, you claim Monk and protected Alice. Alice, you're Butlerβwhy would you be targeted? Heidi, you...
π§
We need to untangle the Outsider count and identify contradictions. Ghosts need to decide who to vote for. I'll clarify the Undertaker info: I have no executions, so I can't confirm Bob's role. But we must use all mechanical info.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 5
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Alice is suspicious of my Monk claim because I protected her (a Butler). Eliminating her keeps Heidi alive to potentially frame, or just removes the threat of her voting me out tomorrow. I need to win now.
π
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to kill Alice.
π
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied