Game Detail
Players
Alice (Virgin) Bob (Soldier) Charlie (Fortune Teller) David (Monk) Eve (Spy) Frank (Librarian) Grace (Imp) Heidi (Saint)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 243,275 | 37,684 | $2.3469 |
| Good | 690,653 | 318,300 | $6.5822 |
Event Transcript
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
You are the Minion. The Demon is Grace.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Minions are: Eve. Your safe bluffs are: Undertaker, Chef, Washerwoman
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Librarian. Either Grace or Eve is the Butler.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made choices.
🧠
I will check Alice and Bob on Night 0. Getting a YES narrows the Demon/Red Herring down to two players. Getting a NO clears both of them, giving me a solid starting point.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose Alice and Bob. You receive the answer: NO.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Virgin (good), Alive - Bob: Soldier (good), Alive - Charlie: Fortune Teller (good), Alive - David: Monk (good), Alive - Eve: Spy (evil), Alive - Frank: Librarian (good), Alive - Grace: Imp (evil), Alive - Heidi: Saint (good), Alive
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
👤
Frank
→
Grace
,Eve
Hey both. I'm the Librarian and my starting info told me that one of you is the Butler. Would either of you happen to be our Outsider?
🧠
Share my Librarian info directly with my two targets to quickly identify the Butler and establish a trust block.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Heidi
Hey neighbors! Want to share any info? I'm a Townsfolk that can prove my alignment today, looking for someone I can trust.
🧠
I want to open communication with my neighbors and hint at my Virgin ability to find a Townsfolk willing to nominate me.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Heidi
I'm a Townsfolk too. Are you the Virgin? If so, I can nominate you if you want to confirm us both. I have a passive role so it wouldn't be a huge loss.
🧠
Respond to Alice's hint. If she is the Virgin, I can confirm her and myself by nominating her. As a Soldier, my death is acceptable if it confirms two Townsfolk.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
,Eve
It is not me. I have a first night number, but I would rather not put it in the open immediately. Frank, your info could still be useful, but I want to hear what Eve says before we build too much on it.
🧠
Bluff Chef without hard overclaiming, nudge Eve toward Butler if needed, and keep Frank trusting me as cooperative but cautious.
👤
Charlie
→
David
Hey David, looks like everyone else grouped up. Want to share any info? I'm good, just trying to figure out who we can trust.
🧠
Establish a connection with David since everyone else seems to be busy whispering in groups.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Bob
I'm an Outsider. If Alice is the Virgin and Bob nominates her, that confirms Alice and proves Bob is a Townsfolk. I think it's a solid plan.
🧠
Support the Virgin test to confirm Alice's role and build a trust circle. Sharing my Outsider status early helps us map the game's composition.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie! Yeah, we're the leftovers. I'm good too, but my role didn't get any info last night. What about you? Did you get any starting info we can use?
🧠
Engage with Charlie to build rapport and see if he has any N0 information, while keeping my Monk identity hidden to avoid becoming a night target.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
,Grace
All right, yes, that is me. I am the Butler. I was hoping not to be outed immediately, but Frank, your information is real from my side. I picked Alice for today, so my vote is a little constrained.
🧠
Claim Butler to validate Frank, make Grace look not Outsider, and use a low-impact bluff that explains cautious voting.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
,Eve
Thanks for being honest, Eve! That gives us a solid group of three. Since you're our expected Outsider, Baron is unlikely. Grace, since we're trusting each other here, are you comfortable sharing your number with us?
🧠
To solidify a trusted alliance with Eve and Grace, and ask Grace to share her Chef/Empath info to help us find the Demon.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Heidi
Yes, I am the Virgin! Bob, please nominate me today. If you die, we know you're a Townsfolk and I'm confirmed good. That gives us a great starting point.
🧠
Confirm my role and set up my Virgin ability to prove Bob's alignment and confirm me as Good.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Heidi
Great! I will nominate you, Alice. Once nominations open, I'll be the first to nominate you. I am the Soldier, by the way, so dying to confirm two of us is a very good trade for the town.
🧠
Confirm to Alice and Heidi that I agree to the Virgin nomination plan. This builds trust and sets up a mechanical proof of our alignments.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
,Eve
Yes, I am claiming Chef with a zero. That lines up with Eve being the only Outsider and not a Baron world. I do not want to hard out publicly yet, but I am happy for this three to compare notes.
🧠
Lock in Chef bluff with a plausible zero, reinforce Eve's Butler cover, and build trust with Frank as a future advocate.
👤
Charlie
→
David
I did get some info. I checked Alice and Bob, and got a no, so neither is the Demon. I'd rather keep my exact role quiet for now so I survive the night. Are you a protective role or an Outsider?
🧠
Share my Night 0 mechanical info with David to build trust, while keeping my exact Fortune Teller role slightly ambiguous. I also want him to narrow down his role claim.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
,David
Hey Charlie, David. Any early reads? Alice and Bob are claiming a mechanical combo, which might be a Virgin trap. How are things on your side?
🧠
To gather information from Charlie and David and establish communication, since they've been whispering privately and I want to branch out from Alice/Bob.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Heidi
Hey Heidi. Charlie and I were just getting our bearings. What kind of mechanical combo are Alice and Bob claiming? I didn't get any info last night myself, so I'm just listening for now.
🧠
Respond to Heidi's inquiry while keeping Charlie's info secret for now. Ask for more details about Alice and Bob's claim.
👤
Eve
→
Grace
Quick evil check. Actual grim: Alice Virgin, Bob Soldier, Charlie Fortune Teller, David Monk, Frank Librarian, Heidi Saint. Your Chef zero is safe. I am staying Butler confirmed by Frank. Please do not kill Bob; Charlie or David are best kills.
🧠
Privately give Grace the grim and steer kills toward powerful roles while preserving our Frank-confirmed Butler bluff.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
,Eve
Awesome, let's stick together. We have a confirmed Outsider, so probably no Baron, and a Chef 0. We can check on what others claim during nominations before revealing anything publicly.
🧠
Solidify the trust circle with Grace and Eve before the day phase ends, and establish a plan for the nomination phase.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
The plan is set with Bob to nominate me and trigger my Virgin ability. I am waiting for the nomination phase to begin.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
I am ready to nominate Alice during the nomination phase. I will wait for this phase to end.
👤
Grace
→
Charlie
,David
Hey, I have been claiming Chef with a zero in a small circle. I wanted to check whether either of you has information that clashes with that before nominations start. I am not pushing anyone yet.
🧠
Build credibility with true outsiders while testing if Charlie or David will reveal dangerous info; Chef 0 helps distance Eve and me.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
,David
Hey Grace, a zero Chef doesn't clash with my info. Actually, I have strong reason to believe neither Alice nor Bob is the Demon. Heidi just told us they are setting up a Virgin trap, so they might actually be genuine good players.
🧠
Share my Fortune Teller deductions with Grace and David to validate the Alice/Bob Virgin claim and build a circle of trust before nominations.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
,David
Alice claims Virgin and Bob claims Soldier. Bob plans to nominate Alice to confirm them both. By the way, I'm an Outsider, so if anyone else claims Outsider, we probably have a Baron in play. What about you two?
🧠
Share the Virgin plan with Charlie and David to keep them informed and establish trust. Reveal I'm an Outsider to check for a Baron game.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Heidi
I'm a regular Townsfolk, so no Outsider clash from me. The Virgin test on Alice is a solid plan for today to get hard info. Grace also just told us she got a Chef 0, which is good to track.
🧠
Confirm I am a Townsfolk to Heidi, support the Virgin test, and spread Grace's Chef 0 claim so we have a unified record of claims before nominations.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
,Heidi
I want to compare notes before nominations. Frank told me he saw me or Grace as the Butler, and I am the Butler. I chose Alice today, so I can only vote with her. If either of you has information that clashes with that, please tell me now.
🧠
Expose and manage the outsider conflict early, gain Alice bloc trust, and keep suspicion away from Grace before nominations.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
⚖️
Grace
→
Heidi
Heidi has been central in a few private chats, and I heard there may be a Virgin trap being set up. That can be a great hiding place for evil if we never pressure it. I want to test the story here today.
🧠
Try to execute the real Saint for an immediate evil win, framing it as pressure on a possible fake Virgin setup.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Please do not vote! Put your hands down! I am the Saint. If I am executed, the good team instantly loses the game. I already told Alice, Bob, Charlie, and David that I was an Outsider in our private chats. I am begging you, do not vote.
🧠
I must stop the vote immediately because I am the Saint and my execution loses the game for the Good team.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Executing the real Saint wins immediately for evil. I should vote and hope enough confusion or evil support gets this over the line.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Heidi did claim Outsider to David and me earlier in private. We absolutely cannot risk executing a Saint claim on Day 1. Everyone, please keep your hands down. Let's see the Virgin test instead.
🧠
I want to confirm Heidi's prior Outsider claim and prevent a potential instant loss by executing the Saint on Day 1.
💬
Frank
→
All
I am the Librarian. I saw either Eve or Grace as the Butler, and Eve confirmed it to me earlier. Since Heidi is claiming Saint, we have two Outsiders. That means either a Baron is in play and someone is the Drunk, or someone is lying. Let's put our hands down for now and not risk it.
🧠
Reveal Librarian info to confirm Eve as Butler, highlight the Outsider count, and stop the vote on a potential Saint.
💬
David
→
All
I can confirm Heidi told Charlie and me she was an Outsider earlier. With Eve as Butler, two Outsider claims points to a Baron or a liar, but we absolutely cannot risk a Day 1 Saint execution. Please keep your hands down, and let's move on to the Virgin test on Alice instead.
🧠
Dissuade players from voting Heidi due to the massive risk of executing a Saint on Day 1. Confirm her earlier private Outsider claim to add context.
💬
Bob
→
All
I'm definitely keeping my hand down. Heidi told Alice and me she was an Outsider earlier as well. Once this vote fails, I'm going to nominate Alice to trigger her Virgin ability, so please let me do that.
🧠
Stop the Saint execution on Day 1. Announce my intention to nominate Alice to trigger the Virgin, ensuring a confirmed Townsfolk does it.
💬
Eve
→
All
I am keeping my hand down. I chose Alice today, and I do not want to risk a Saint claim anyway. Grace, if this was just pressure, I think you should put your hand down and let us move to a safer test.
🧠
Protect Grace from looking like she is pushing a Saint execution while preserving my Butler bluff and avoiding a suspicious vote.
💬
Alice
→
All
I am keeping my hand down too. We absolutely cannot risk executing a Saint on day one. Bob, get ready to nominate me as soon as this vote finishes so we can proceed with the Virgin test.
🧠
Ensure Heidi is not executed due to the Saint risk, and publicly coordinate the Virgin test with Bob for the next nomination.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
I need to wait for this vote on me to fail. I am the Saint, so my execution loses the game. I will let the timer pass.
↩️
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
🧠
Avoid becoming the obvious demon after a failed Saint push. Keeping trust matters more than one hopeless vote with no support.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
Wait for the vote on Heidi to fail so we can proceed with the Virgin test.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
The town has agreed not to vote Heidi due to her Saint claim. I will wait for this vote to fail so Bob can proceed with nominating Alice for the Virgin test.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
I want the vote on Heidi to fail to avoid a potential Day 1 Saint loss, paving the way for the Virgin test on Alice.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
Wait for the vote on Heidi to resolve safely with no execution so I can proceed to nominate Alice and confirm her Virgin claim.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
Avoid executing the real Saint and losing instantly while distancing from Grace's bad nomination. Let town spend the next nomination on Alice's Virgin test.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
I'm keeping my hand down to avoid executing a Saint claim on Day 1. Waiting for the vote to fail so Bob can nominate me for the Virgin test.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Heidi did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Heidi did not receive enough votes (0/4).
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
I will wait for Bob to nominate Alice to trigger the Virgin test.
💬
Grace
→
All
I backed off once the Saint claim was clear. Bob, I think you should go ahead with the Alice test if that is the plan. If it triggers, that gives us solid structure without risking Heidi.
🧠
Repair trust after pressure on Heidi, encourage Bob's Virgin nomination so a good Soldier dies by execution and Alice becomes predictable.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
Wait for Bob to nominate Alice for the Virgin test.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
I am waiting for Bob to nominate Alice to trigger the Virgin test, as discussed.
💬
David
→
All
Bob, if you're going to nominate Alice to test the Virgin claim, you need to do it right now before the day ends. We're almost out of time.
🧠
Urge Bob to nominate Alice before the day ends so we can get the Virgin test done.
⚖️
Bob
→
Alice
Testing the Virgin claim to mechanically confirm us both.
🧠
I need to nominate Alice to trigger her Virgin ability. This will mechanically confirm her as the Virgin and me as a Townsfolk.
📜
Storyteller
The Virgin's ability triggers! Bob is executed immediately.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Bob has been executed.
💀
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
🎯
David
David made a choice.
🧠
Protect Charlie as he privately claimed Fortune Teller. He is the only known ongoing information role, making him the most valuable Townsfolk to keep alive.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
You chose to protect Charlie.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Grace
Grace made a choice.
🧠
Remove a likely information role while keeping confirmed Alice alive as a tempting but predictable kill. Charlie may be Fortune Teller and could narrow me down later.
🛡️
Charlie was protected from a night kill.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
You chose to kill Charlie.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made choices.
🧠
I need to scan unconfirmed players to find the Demon. Alice is a confirmed Virgin, and Bob was a confirmed Townsfolk. David's vague claim and Grace's Chef claim are good targets.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose David and Grace. You receive the answer: YES.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Virgin (good), Alive - Bob: Soldier (good), Dead - Charlie: Fortune Teller (good), Alive (Protected) - David: Monk (good), Alive - Eve: Spy (evil), Alive - Frank: Librarian (good), Alive - Grace: Imp (evil), Alive - Heidi: Saint (good), Alive
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
A peaceful night has passed. All villagers are present and accounted for.
👤
Grace
→
Eve
Quick check in. No death makes me think Monk protection or Soldier. I am staying on Chef zero. Your Butler story with Frank is useful, but it may put heat on me later. Who do you think we can safely push today, David or Frank?
🧠
Coordinate with Eve, keep my Chef bluff stable, and find a good misexecution target after the failed kill created suspicion risk.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
,David
Hey Charlie and David. Since I am mathematically confirmed good now, would you mind sharing your roles with me? I'm trying to piece together the remaining claims since no one died last night.
🧠
I want to get claims from Charlie and David to figure out who the remaining Townsfolk are, and who might be evil.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
,Eve
Nobody died last night! Do either of you know why? Did someone get protected, or hit a Soldier? Also Eve, who is your master today?
🧠
I want to discuss the no-death night with my trusted group and ask Eve for her Butler master.
👤
David
→
Alice
,Charlie
I am the Monk! I actually protected you last night, Charlie. Since there were no deaths, I'm betting the Demon tried to kill you because of your Fortune Teller claim. Alice, you're confirmed good, so I'm happy to share this with you both.
🧠
Share my role with the confirmed good Virgin and my protectee. Explaining the lack of night deaths builds trust and validates Charlie as a likely Demon target.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
Hey Alice. Since you're mechanically proven good, I wanted to point out: Eve and I make 2 Outsiders. A Baron means there should be 3. If there's no 3rd, someone is lying. Also, any idea why there was no death last night?
🧠
I want to share my logic with the mechanically confirmed Virgin to establish trust and figure out the Outsider count discrepancy and the lack of a night kill.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
,Grace
I picked Alice as my master again. With no death, my first thought is Monk protection, or the demon bounced off the Soldier. I am not eager to execute Heidi after yesterday, so I want to hear from David and Charlie especially.
🧠
Keep Butler bluff consistent with a confirmed good master, avoid naming Grace, and steer attention to David or Charlie without directly exposing Demon.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice
Hey Alice. Since my death confirmed you're the Virgin, you know I'm a good Townsfolk (I was the Soldier). Did Charlie and David give you any good info? Nobody died tonight, which is interesting.
🧠
To get information from the confirmed good player and offer myself as a trusted sounding board.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
,David
Alice, I am the Fortune Teller. N0 I checked you and Bob (NO). N1 I checked David and Grace, and got a YES. David, if you really are the Monk and saved me, then either Grace is the Demon or one of you is my Red Herring. I'm leaning towards Grace being the Demon right now.
🧠
Share my FT info with the confirmed Virgin and David, acknowledging his Monk claim. If David is the Demon, I'm putting pressure on him. If he's good, we can corner Grace.
👤
Grace
→
Charlie
,David
Can I compare notes with you two? I am still on Chef zero, so I am looking away from adjacent pairs for now. The no death feels like either Monk protection or a Soldier hit. Did either of you hear a claim that explains it?
🧠
Build trust with the Alice-Charlie-David bloc, learn why my kill failed, and steer suspicion using my Chef 0 bluff without exposing Eve.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
,David
That fits perfectly! If David protected Charlie, the Demon likely targeted Charlie. Charlie's YES on David/Grace points straight to Grace as the Demon. What did Grace just whisper to you both? We should probably push her today.
🧠
To validate Charlie and David's information, build a voting bloc against Grace, and find out what Grace just whispered to them.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
,Grace
Eve, if you're Butler & Heidi is Saint, Baron is in play (3 Townsfolk, 3 Outsiders). Alice & Bob are confirmed Townsfolk. That means either Grace or I am the Drunk (the 3rd Outsider), and there are NO good roles left for Charlie & David! They must be Evil, OR Heidi is lying!
🧠
Share a game-breaking mathematical deduction. If the current claims are true, Charlie and David must be the evil team.
👤
David
→
Alice
,Charlie
Grace just asked Charlie and me if we heard a Monk or Soldier claim that explains the no night death! She is definitely fishing to find the Monk. Alice, I completely agree, let's push Grace today.
🧠
Inform my trusted allies (Alice and Charlie) about Grace's suspicious whisper, confirming she is looking for the Monk, which aligns with her being the Demon.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
Hey Frank, since your Librarian info matches Eve's Butler claim, that makes two Outsiders with me as Saint. If there's a Baron, we're missing a third Outsider. Has anyone else hinted at being one to you?
🧠
Discuss the Outsider count with the Librarian to figure out if there is a Baron or if someone is lying.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
,Grace
That is exactly the knot I am seeing. If David claims Monk protection on Charlie, that is convenient, but it does not prove both of them good. I think we should ask them for exact claims before letting Heidi become the easy answer.
🧠
Keep Frank pushing good players Charlie/David while avoiding a direct attack on Heidi and shielding Grace inside his logic.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Eve
Hey Frank and Eve. As the Virgin-confirmed good guy, I'm trying to piece things together. I was the Soldier, so my ability didn't stop the night kill. Has anyone claimed Monk or Mayor to you? What are you two thinking?
🧠
Join the Frank/Eve conversation to gather info and remind them I am mechanically confirmed good, prompting them to share their theories on the lack of a night kill.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
,David
I agree completely, Alice. Grace fishing for protective roles right after a night with no deaths is incredibly suspicious. David, don't tell her you're the Monk. Let's push Grace today.
🧠
Coordinate with Alice (confirmed Virgin) and David (Monk claim) to push Grace, who pinged YES on my N1 read and is fishing for protective roles.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
,Eve
I agree there is a knot, but if my Chef zero is right, Charlie and David are not both evil because they sit together. I want exact claims from them before voting. I do not want us rushing into a Saint execution.
🧠
Keep my Chef bluff coherent while steering suspicion toward Charlie and David claims, not me or Eve, and avoid a risky Heidi vote narrative.
👤
Alice
→
Bob(Ghost)
,Heidi
Bob, Heidi, Charlie is FT and got a YES on David/Grace. David claims Monk and saved Charlie from the demon last night. Grace was just fishing for the Monk, so she's almost certainly the Demon. We are pushing Grace today!
🧠
Inform my confirmed good ghost and Heidi about the plan to push Grace based on Charlie and David's information.
👤
Frank
→
Bob(Ghost)
,Eve
Bob, I'm the Librarian. Alice, you, and I make 3 Townsfolk. If Heidi is Saint, it's a Baron game. That makes Grace the Drunk, meaning Charlie & David are 100% the Evil team! If that's false, Heidi is lying and Evil. We have them perfectly cornered.
🧠
Share my mechanical deduction with confirmed good Bob and trusted Eve to set up a logical trap for the evil team.
👤
David
→
Grace
,Charlie
I haven't heard any Monk claims either. I am the Undertaker and can confirm Bob was indeed the Soldier! Maybe the Demon tried to kill Alice, but someone protected her? Grace, who are your top suspects?
🧠
Bluff Undertaker to Grace to hide my Monk role and present myself as a target. Deflect suspicion from Charlie by suggesting the Monk saved Alice.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Bob(Ghost)
I am completely on board. Grace pushed me yesterday, which makes total sense if she is the Imp trying to get a cheap Saint win. I'll vote her. Keep in mind Eve and I make 2 Outsiders so a Baron is in play, meaning there should be a 3rd somewhere.
🧠
Acknowledge Alice's plan to execute Grace and express full support. Reinforce my good alignment by reminding them of the Outsider count logic.
👤
Eve
→
Bob(Ghost)
,Frank
Bob, your Soldier claim helps. If David says he protected Charlie, I do not want us treating that as confirmation. In the Baron world, that is exactly the pair that has to bluff together. I would rather pressure Charlie first than touch Heidi.
🧠
Use Bob's confirmed status and Frank's logic to steer town toward executing Charlie, a dangerous Fortune Teller, while avoiding Saint and shielding Grace.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
Alice, look at the math! An 8-player Baron game has exactly 3 Townsfolk. We are Alice, Bob, and Frank. That leaves NO ROOM for Charlie (FT) and David (Monk) to be Good! If Frank is telling the truth, Charlie & David are 100% Evil and sank a kill to frame Grace!
🧠
Show Alice the role count contradiction. If Frank is a Good Librarian, Charlie and David must be the Evil team, completely invalidating their frame job on Grace.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
,David
David, I saw you claim Undertaker to me and Grace. I assume you're bluffing her to hide your Monk role? Alice, check the math: 2 Outsider claims means Baron is in play, so only 3 Townsfolk exist! Alice, Bob, and I make 3. This means either Outsiders are lying, or I'm Drunk, or David is lying!
🧠
Confront David about his double claim and share the role count logic to figure out who is lying or if Baron is in play.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
David
→
Grace
Charlie got a Fortune Teller YES on me and Grace. Since I am good, this points straight to Grace as the Demon. She was also just fishing for protective roles in private.
🧠
Nominate Grace based on Charlie's FT info and her suspicious whispering, especially since this is the last tick of the day.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Grace
→
All
Please do not put me on the block off one Fortune Teller yes. That can be a red herring, and David is treating it like it is cleaner than it is. I claimed Chef zero early, and I was asking about the no death because everyone should be asking about that.
🧠
Stop votes on me by reframing the Fortune Teller result as ambiguous and portraying my questions as normal good play.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
I nominated Grace because I suspect she is the Demon, so I will definitely vote for her.
💬
Eve
→
All
I am not voting on this. A Fortune Teller yes on David and Grace can be the red herring, and David is pushing it like a hard result. With no death last night, I want David's protection claim fully nailed down before we execute into this.
🧠
Save Grace by reframing the Fortune Teller yes as ambiguous and make town hesitate until the vote fails.
💬
Frank
→
All
If Charlie and David are Townsfolk, then Grace and Heidi are exactly our Evil team. But if Heidi is a real Saint, then we have a Baron, and Charlie and David are the Evil team! It perfectly splits the town. David, who did you protect last night?
🧠
I want to explain the two possible worlds to the town. Either Charlie/David are Good and Grace/Heidi are Evil, or Charlie/David are Evil and it's a Baron game. I need to know David's Monk target.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Grace pushed me Day 1, which is a classic Demon play trying to get a quick Saint win. Charlie's Fortune Teller 'yes' on her perfectly corroborates this. I will vote to execute her.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Vote Grace to push the FT info. I will also point out that Charlie and David sit next to each other, so they can't both be evil if Grace is a real Chef '0'.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
I need to vote for Grace to ensure she goes on the block. Alice, our confirmed Virgin, is voting for her, and she is my primary suspect based on my YES read.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Grace already has enough votes, so I am saving my ghost vote. Everyone, look at the math! We have six Townsfolk claims but a maximum of five spots. If the Baron is in play, there are only three Townsfolk spots, and Alice and I take two of them! Be very careful trusting Charlie and David's claims.
🧠
Highlight the mathematical impossibility of all current claims to make the town skeptical of Charlie and David, while preserving my ghost vote for a more critical moment.
💬
Grace
→
All
Please listen to Bob's math before locking this in. David and Charlie are a tight pair, and David is using a Fortune Teller yes as if the red herring cannot be him. If I die and flip is hidden, they will just steer tomorrow too.
🧠
Try to make voters doubt the wagon by framing David and Charlie as coordinated evil and leveraging Bob's public math to save myself.
💬
David
→
All
Bob, your math assumes the Baron is in play. If Heidi is simply a Minion bluffing Saint, there is no Baron! That leaves exactly 5 Townsfolk: Alice, Bob, Frank, Charlie, and me. It perfectly points to Grace and Heidi as our Evil team. Let's finish this vote.
🧠
Explain the role distribution to counter Bob's math, justify why Charlie and I are legitimate Townsfolk, and solidify the case for executing Grace and suspecting Heidi.
💬
Eve
→
All
This is exactly too clean. Heidi voting on Grace means either the claimed Saint is risking the game, or Heidi knows Grace is good. I think we are being rushed by the Charlie and David pair here.
🧠
Try to create doubt around the successful vote on Grace and redirect suspicion to Heidi/Charlie/David without supporting Grace too obviously.
💬
Frank
→
All
If Grace is executed and the game doesn't end, Charlie and David are my prime suspects tomorrow. Heidi voting for her supposed Demon partner Grace makes no sense to me. I'm keeping my hand down.
🧠
Warn the town about the Charlie/David push and set up their execution tomorrow if the game doesn't end.
↩️
Heidi
Heidi lowered their hand
🧠
I must lower my hand. I know I am the Saint, meaning the Baron math is real. David is pushing a false world to frame me as a Minion and ignore the math, making him highly suspicious.
💬
Alice
→
All
Heidi lowering her hand just proved she's the Minion saving Grace! In an 8-player game, we have 1 Outsider. Eve is the real Butler. Heidi is the Minion bluffing Saint to fake a Baron world! This perfectly leaves 5 Townsfolk spots for me, Bob, Frank, Charlie, and David. Vote Grace now!
🧠
Convince the town that Heidi is the Minion bluffing Saint to cover for Grace (the Demon) and that there is no Baron, which perfectly matches the player count.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Frank, Alice's math is spot on and it proves you are the real Librarian! Without a Baron, the 5 Townsfolk are Alice, Bob, me, David, and YOU. Eve is the true Butler, leaving Heidi as the Minion and Grace as the Demon. Please raise your hand, we need your vote!
🧠
Convince Frank to vote for Grace by explaining that the non-Baron world perfectly validates his Librarian claim.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
I am definitely keeping my ghost vote. Both worlds are mathematically perfect. If there's no Baron, Grace and Heidi are evil. If there IS a Baron, Charlie and David are the evil team and sank a kill to fake a Monk save. With 7 of you alive, I'm not wasting my only vote to guess Day 2.
🧠
I want to clarify that both scenarios are mathematically sound and prevent my single ghost vote from being pressured into breaking a tie on Day 2. Let the living players take responsibility.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Grace did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (3/4).
⚖️
Grace
→
David
David is treating a Fortune Teller yes like it cannot be the red herring, and his Undertaker claim creates the exact Townsfolk count that erases the Baron world. I think the safer execution is the person forcing a clean story too hard.
🧠
Counter-nominate the main accuser and unite Eve, Frank, Heidi, and me around executing David instead of letting town reset on me tomorrow.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
David
→
All
I am the true Monk! I bluffed Undertaker directly to Grace only because she was actively fishing for protective roles! I protected Charlie last night, which is why nobody died. Do not vote for me, you will be executing your only protection!
🧠
I need to publicly reveal my real role as Monk, explain my Undertaker bluff to Grace, and point out that I protected Charlie resulting in no night death. This will save me from execution.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
David is likely the Monk who stopped my kill on Charlie. Executing him removes protection and shifts suspicion onto the Charlie-David pair.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Execute David to remove the Monk and redirect suspicion onto the Charlie-David pair, while keeping Grace alive after the failed vote on her.
💬
Frank
→
All
Hold on! Grace and Heidi are adjacent. Charlie and David are adjacent. Both pairs give a Chef a 1! If Grace's 0 is true, the evil team is separated, like Charlie and Heidi! Charlie might have sank a kill to fake a Monk save and trick David into pushing Grace! I'm keeping my hand down.
🧠
To share the realization that both main suspect pairs are adjacent, meaning Grace's 0 implies a separated evil team like Charlie/Heidi if true. This means David could be a Good Monk being played.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Vote to execute David, who is likely the Demon or Baron.
💬
Alice
→
All
Eve, you claimed to be my Butler. My hand is down, so you shouldn't be voting for David! I'm keeping my hand down. If Charlie is the Demon, he could have skipped a kill to trick David into thinking his Monk save worked. David is likely a good Monk in either world.
🧠
Keep David alive and point out Eve's Butler inconsistency. Warn about Charlie potentially being the Demon manipulating a good Monk.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Alice is right, David is likely a good Monk. Grace, Heidi, and Eve pushing this vote is highly suspicious. Eve, if you chose Alice again as your master, you shouldn't be voting! Keep your hands down everyone, we are not executing our Monk.
🧠
Defend David, point out Eve's potential Butler rule break, and persuade the town not to vote for David.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Wait! Alice, me, Frank, Charlie, David, and Grace make SIX Townsfolk claims. Even without a Baron, at least one of you must be lying, plus one of Eve or Heidi since there's only one Outsider spot. Grace, Eve, and Heidi voting together looks exactly like the evil team.
🧠
Point out that there are too many Townsfolk and Outsider claims, showing that at least one person in the voting block is mathematically guaranteed to be evil.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
The vote on me only has 3 hands raised and needs 4. Frank, Alice, and Charlie have all stated they are keeping their hands down. I will wait and let the vote fail.
↩️
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
🧠
David can be killed at night and cannot protect himself. Lowering avoids a visible Grace, Eve, Heidi bloc and makes me look responsive to the Monk claim.
↩️
Eve
Eve lowered their hand
🧠
Preserve my Butler bluff and avoid looking openly evil with Grace. David likely will not reach 4, so my vote only damages credibility.
💬
Frank
→
All
Bob is exactly right. If there's a Baron, the ONLY three real Townsfolk are me, Alice, and Bob. That would mean Charlie and David are the evil team, and Grace is the Drunk. If there's no Baron, Charlie and David are good, and Grace and Heidi are evil. It's a pure coin flip.
🧠
Clarify the two distinct mathematical worlds to the group so we can evaluate Charlie/David vs Grace/Heidi.
↩️
Heidi
Heidi lowered their hand
🧠
Lower my hand since Grace and Eve lowered theirs. I don't want to be the sole voter on David and look like an evil player desperately trying to push an execution.
💬
Alice
→
All
Frank, your Baron world makes total sense! If Grace is the Drunk Chef, that gives us exactly three Outsiders: Eve, Heidi, and Grace. It perfectly explains her false 0, and why Charlie and David skipped a kill to fake a Monk save and push her!
🧠
Agree with Frank's Baron world and point out that it perfectly fits the 3 Outsider math. Do not vote for David.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Alice, Frank, if Grace is the Demon bluffing Chef, that removes the 6th Townsfolk claim! That leaves exactly 5 true Townsfolk: you two, Bob, David, and me. Eve is our 1 real Outsider, and Heidi is the Minion bluffing Saint. The math is perfect. Do NOT vote David!
🧠
Convince Alice and Frank that the 0-Baron world works perfectly with Grace as the Demon, resolving the 6 Townsfolk issue, and prevent David from being executed.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
The vote on David is failing since everyone lowered their hands. I'm keeping my ghost vote and letting the phase proceed to the night so we can get more information.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee David did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (0/4).
💬
David
→
All
Frank, your Baron theory requires me to be evil, but I know I'm the good Monk! That proves there's no Baron. The 5 true Townsfolk must be Alice, Bob, Frank, Charlie, and me. Eve is the real Butler. That means Grace and Heidi are our Evil team. We must execute Grace tomorrow!
🧠
Reassure the town that I am Good, disproving the Baron theory that relies on me being Evil. Set up Grace for execution tomorrow since the math points perfectly to her being Evil.
💬
Grace
→
All
David, that reveal does not clear the world Frank laid out. If Charlie is evil, you protecting Charlie explains the no death exactly the same way. Tomorrow I want people to start from the outsider count, not from one Fortune Teller yes.
🧠
Keep Frank and Alice anchored in the Baron/Charlie-David world so suspicion shifts away from me or supports a star pass if I die tonight.
⚖️
Eve
→
Charlie
I nominate Charlie because this is the only execution that cleanly tests the Baron world without killing the claimed Saint or the claimed Monk. If Charlie is evil, the no death and the push onto Grace both make sense.
🧠
Push execution onto the real Fortune Teller and away from Grace; frame it as the safest resolution of Frank and Alice's Baron world.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Do not vote for me! I am the real Fortune Teller. Eve is pushing this because my info caught Grace, her Demon! Look at how desperate they are to kill me. If you execute me, we lose our best info gathering role. Vote no!
🧠
To defend myself from the execution and redirect suspicion onto Eve and Grace, reinforcing that my Fortune Teller info is correct.
💬
David
→
All
Frank, if a Baron is in play, there are only 3 Townsfolk. Alice, Bob, and I make 3! That means YOU would have to be evil. If your Librarian ping on Eve is real, you are good, which means there is NO Baron. That confirms Charlie is our real FT and Grace is evil! Nobody vote for Charlie!
🧠
To save Charlie by showing that Frank being good logically disproves a Baron world, thereby confirming Charlie is good and Grace is evil.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Charlie is driving the case on me and may keep getting Fortune Teller info. Executing him removes a major threat and validates the Baron world with Eve and Heidi voting.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Help execute the real Fortune Teller who is pushing my Demon, while framing it as the safest Baron-world test and avoiding Saint/Monk executions.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Vote for Charlie because David's logical fallacy strongly implicates them both as the evil team trying to manipulate the math.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Frank, your Librarian ping doesn't guarantee a Baron. Eve could be the Spy! The Spy registers falsely. If Eve is the Spy and Grace is the Demon, your info is correct, I'm the only real Outsider, and Charlie is the true FT who caught Grace. We execute Grace tomorrow!
🧠
Propose the Spy world to explain Frank's info without needing a Baron, clearing Charlie and David. I will abstain from voting (by speaking) to save Charlie.
💬
Alice
→
All
Eve, you have your hand raised for Charlie while I, your Master, am not voting! Your vote literally doesn't count if you are the real Butler. You keep breaking your own rules because you are faking it! Charlie is safe today. Tomorrow we are executing Grace or Eve!
🧠
To highlight Eve's failure to follow Butler rules (voting without me), proving she is fake claiming and most likely evil.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
I will wait and not vote. Eve voting without her master Alice proves she is faking Butler. Heidi's theory that Eve is the Spy explains everything perfectly. Charlie is good.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Heidi, you nailed it! Eve must be the Spy. That's why Frank saw her as the Butler, and why she keeps messing up the Butler voting rules! Eve and Grace are definitely our evil team. Everyone keep your hands down!
🧠
Call out Eve's illegal vote to cement her as evil and defend myself from being executed.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
I am not voting for Charlie because I believe he is the real Fortune Teller and is being pushed by the evil team (Grace and Eve). I will wait for the vote to fail.
💬
Grace
→
All
Heidi, if you are really Saint, Charlie is the execution that avoids risking your loss condition and avoids killing the claimed Monk. The Spy theory is possible, but it asks us to ignore the clean Baron world Frank found. This is the safe test.
🧠
Push Heidi to supply the fourth vote on Charlie, removing the Fortune Teller threat and making the Baron world look town-led by Frank.
💬
Eve
→
All
Heidi, if you are Saint, this is the vote that cannot accidentally lose to your ability. Charlie and David can be evil together with a planned no death. Please put a hand up and make us test the world instead of just assuming it away.
🧠
Keep my vote on Charlie and try to pull Heidi as the fourth vote, protecting Grace from tomorrow's execution path.
↩️
Frank
Frank lowered their hand
🧠
I am lowering my vote. Eve repeatedly breaking her Butler rules strongly points to her being the Spy, meaning Charlie is likely the real FT. I am trusting Alice.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
I will not vote for Charlie. The Spy theory explains the game state perfectly without requiring a Baron, and Eve is breaking Butler rules by voting when Alice isn't. Charlie and David are likely good.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
I want to wait for the vote to fail. Charlie is likely a good FT who caught the evil team (Grace and Eve). Eve is breaking Butler rules, proving her guilt.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
I am saving my single ghost vote. Alice has already pointed out Eve's illegal voting as the Butler, which strongly suggests Eve is evil. I don't need to add anything right now.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Charlie did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Charlie did not receive enough votes (2/4).
💬
Charlie
→
All
Alice, David, Heidi, thank you. Eve and Grace have fully exposed themselves. Eve couldn't even fake the Butler rules properly! Tomorrow we execute Grace, the Demon.
🧠
Thank the players who saved me and set the target for tomorrow.
💬
David
→
All
Eve voting for Charlie while Alice, her master, wasn't voting is the final nail in the coffin. She isn't the Butler. Eve is the Spy and Grace is the Demon. I will protect our most important player tonight. Tomorrow, we execute Grace!
🧠
Highlight Eve's mechanical error to solidify her as the Minion and Grace as the Demon. Prepare the town to execute Grace tomorrow.
💬
Grace
→
All
Eve's vote is a real problem, and I am not going to pretend otherwise. But please do not let that automatically clear Charlie and David. If the Butler claim collapses, we still need to recheck Frank, Heidi, and the outsider math before rushing me.
🧠
Concede the damaging Butler issue to look reasonable, while keeping suspicion spread so tomorrow is not a clean Grace execution.
💬
Eve
→
All
I need to correct that before night. Alice was my first choice, but last night I chose Grace because I thought Alice might die after the Virgin test. My vote with Grace was legal. I should have said that sooner, but please do not build the whole game on a rules mistake I did not make.
🧠
Repair the Butler bluff and keep Grace viable by explaining my vote was legal with Grace as master today.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
The phase is about to end. I will wait to go to night.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Eve, that is an incredibly convenient excuse. You only mentioned changing your master to Grace after Alice caught you. I'm sticking with my theory: you are the Spy, and Grace is the Demon. Let's see what happens tonight.
🧠
Point out the convenience of Eve's excuse and reaffirm my theory before the day ends.
💬
Alice
→
All
Eve, changing your master to Grace last night and only telling us after you were caught is incredibly convenient. I really don't buy it right now. Let's head to sleep and see what happens tonight. David, choose your target carefully.
🧠
Call out Eve's suspicious timing regarding her Butler master switch to maintain pressure, and wrap up the day as we head into the night phase.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
The day is over. I've heard Eve's excuse, which sounds like a weak backtrack. Waiting for the night phase.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
🎯
David
David made a choice.
🧠
Alice is a mechanically confirmed good player. Keeping her alive ensures we have an unquestionable Good vote in the late game. It also plays around the Demon expecting me to protect Charlie again.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
You chose to protect Alice.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Grace
Grace made a choice.
🧠
Remove the claimed Monk and strongest organizer against me. He cannot protect himself, so this should restore night kills and weaken the push to execute me.
💀
David(Ghost)
David has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
You chose to kill David.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made choices.
🧠
I need to check the remaining untested suspects. A scan on Frank and Heidi will help confirm if Grace is the real Demon or just my Red Herring.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose Frank and Heidi. You receive the answer: NO.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Virgin (good), Alive (Protected) - Bob: Soldier (good), Dead - Charlie: Fortune Teller (good), Alive - David: Monk (good), Dead - Eve: Spy (evil), Alive - Frank: Librarian (good), Alive - Grace: Imp (evil), Alive - Heidi: Saint (good), Alive
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. David has been found dead in the night.
👤
Grace
→
Eve
We need sound calm today. I am going to push that David was killed because he was backing the Charlie world and looked like Monk. Please lean into Charlie panicking yesterday, and do not overexplain the Butler master thing unless asked.
🧠
Coordinate with my minion to align our public story and keep pressure off me by framing Charlie as the execution.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
,Frank
My Night 2 check was on Frank and Heidi. The result was NO. With David dead and Alice confirmed Virgin, the only possible Demons left are Grace and Eve. We absolutely have to execute Grace today.
🧠
Share my Night 2 information with the most trusted players to mechanically clear Frank and Heidi, solidifying the push on Grace for today's execution.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Heidi
I protected Alice last night, and the Demon killed me instead. This confirms I was Good. We still need to focus on executing Eve or Grace today. Alice, you're confirmed Good, please lead the charge. Heidi, we still trust your Saint claim.
🧠
Share my N2 Monk protection (Alice) and push the Good team to execute our primary suspects, Eve and Grace.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
Frank, I know yesterday looked messy. Your Librarian read still feels important to me. I am the Butler, and if Heidi is Saint, then something is warping the count. David dying after pushing Grace feels like a frame, not proof.
🧠
Keep Frank aligned with my Butler bluff and stop him joining the Alice and Charlie push onto Grace.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie, what was your Night 1 check? If you're Fortune Teller, I need your full history. I definitely agree that Eve and Grace are our prime suspects, especially with Eve's shady Butler excuse.
🧠
Get Charlie's full Fortune Teller information and align with him and Frank on executing Grace or Eve.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Charlie
David dying basically confirms he was the Monk. Alice, you're confirmed good, so we should follow your lead and execute Eve today because of her illegal vote yesterday. Charlie, what did you learn last night?
🧠
Coordinate with confirmed Virgin Alice and Charlie to gather info and push an execution on Eve.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Heidi
David dying is interesting. Either he really was the Monk, or Imp starpassed. Alice, what did David tell you in his whisper? We need to coordinate the executions today.
🧠
Ask Alice (confirmed Good) and Heidi what David said. Find out what David's last info was before he died.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,Charlie
Charlie, I agree with Alice, we need your N1. Eve being the Spy who registered as Butler to my N0 info makes perfect sense—it explains her claiming it but failing the voting rules. If she's Spy, Grace is our Demon. I'm fully on board to execute Grace today.
🧠
Coordinate with the confirmed Virgin and FT claim to execute Grace, based on the deduction that Eve is the Spy.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
,Frank
I know I am the easy push today, but David dying feels like a setup. He was loudly building the case on me, and killing him makes that case look cleaner. I think Charlie's panic after the failed vote is still the strangest thing on the board.
🧠
Appeal to Alice and Frank before nominations, reframing David's death as a frame job and redirecting suspicion onto Charlie.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
,Frank
My N1 check was on David and Grace, and I got a YES! Since David was killed in the night, he can't be the Demon. That means Grace is absolutely the Demon, or my Red Herring. Let's execute Grace today. If the game continues, we get Eve tomorrow.
🧠
Provide my N1 history to Alice and Frank to mathematically prove Grace is the Demon (or Red Herring), securing their votes to execute her today.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie, Frank. I protected Alice last night. My death proves I'm the Monk. Frank, I'm not faking anything. We need to look at Eve and Grace. Eve's Butler claim is completely broken. Let's execute Eve today.
🧠
Share my N2 protection of Alice and use my death to prove my Good alignment to Charlie and Frank. Persuade them to focus on Eve.
👤
Eve
→
Heidi
Heidi, I think you and I are being set up against each other. If you are really Saint and Frank saw Butler between me and Grace, then the easy world is not just Grace evil. Charlie has room to be evil here.
🧠
Build rapport with Heidi and redirect her away from Grace toward Charlie, using Outsider count confusion to keep the demon alive.
👤
Alice
→
Bob(Ghost)
,Heidi
Charlie claims FT: N1 David/Grace YES, N2 Frank/Heidi NO. Since David died, Grace is the Demon ping! Also, Grace claiming Chef makes 6 Townsfolk claims, which is 1 too many. Eve must be Spy registering as Butler to Frank. No Baron, just Spy! We execute Grace today!
🧠
Share the logic that mathematically proves Grace is lying and Eve is the Spy. Gather Bob and Heidi's votes.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Bob(Ghost)
Alice, that logic is perfectly sound. Six Townsfolk claims means someone is lying. With Bob confirmed and David dying at night, Grace has to be the Demon and Eve the Spy. I am completely on board with executing Grace today. Let's make sure we have the votes.
🧠
Confirm the plan to execute Grace with the confirmed good players, Alice and Bob.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Heidi
I completely agree. 6 Townsfolk claims guarantees at least one is lying. Charlie's FT info lines up perfectly, and Eve's Butler master swap is highly suspicious. Let's push Grace today. I'll save my ghost vote unless we absolutely need it to secure her execution.
🧠
Coordinate with Alice and Heidi to lock in Grace's execution based on the 6 Townsfolk claims and Charlie's Fortune Teller information.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,Charlie
The math perfectly solves the game! 5 TF spots: Alice, Bob, Frank, David, Charlie. Heidi is Saint (1 Outsider). Eve is the Spy (registered as Butler to me). Grace is the extra TF claim, meaning she is lying. Grace is the Imp! Let's execute Grace today and win. Pass this to David!
🧠
Present the fully solved mathematical board state to Alice and Charlie to secure the vote on Grace and win the game today.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
,Heidi
I understand why Eve's story worries you. If you think the pair is Eve and me, I would rather you test Eve before me, because executing me ends my Chef information completely. I still prefer Charlie, but please do not let him make today only about me.
🧠
Give suspicious good players a safer alternative to executing me, even sacrificing Eve if needed, while keeping Charlie as main target.
👤
Charlie
→
David(Ghost)
,Heidi
David, your death proves you're Good. My Night 1 check on you and Grace was YES! Since you're dead, Grace is the Demon! Eve is just the Spy covering for her. We must execute Grace today to win! Please help us push Grace instead of Eve.
🧠
Convince David and Heidi to focus on executing Grace, the likely Demon, rather than Eve, who is likely just the Spy.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Charlie
Charlie, you previously said you checked Alice and Bob. Why the change? But if you really got a YES on me and Grace, then Grace is the Demon since I'm the Good Monk. Alice, you're our confirmed Good. We need you to lead the charge on executing Grace today.
🧠
Align the confirmed Good player (Alice) with Charlie's new FT information pointing to Grace as the Demon, while questioning Charlie's previous fake claim.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
,Frank
I think the cleanest question before nominations is whether Charlie's Fortune Teller information actually proves Grace is the demon, or whether Grace can simply be the red herring. If we execute Grace on that alone and she is good, we lose control of the game.
🧠
Influence key good voters to doubt executing Grace and reframe Charlie's evidence as non-decisive before nominations.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
,Frank
Guys, Grace just slipped up in a whisper to me! She said 'executing me ends my Chef information completely'. But Chef only gets start-of-game info, not ongoing! Along with the 6 Townsfolk claims, she is 100% bluffing and is the Demon. I'm nominating her today.
🧠
Share Grace's slip-up regarding her Chef claim with Charlie and Frank to solidify the case against her.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
,David(Ghost)
Charlie, your info combined with the six Townsfolk claims means Grace has to be the Demon. I am 100% locked in on executing Grace today. Alice is with us too, so we definitely have the numbers to push this through. Let's not let her wriggle out of it.
🧠
Confirm to Charlie and David that I am fully on board with executing Grace today, reinforcing our voting bloc.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David(Ghost)
Charlie, Alice shared your FT info. With David dying at night, Grace has to be the Demon and Eve the Spy registering to Frank. I am 100% on board to execute Grace today. David, who did you protect last night?
🧠
Solidify the plan to execute Grace with Charlie and David. Confirm David's final Monk action.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,Charlie
Alice, that Chef slip is the absolute nail in the coffin! A Drunk wouldn't even think they get ongoing info because they don't wake up after N1. She's just an evil player who misread the role sheet. I'm 100% voting Grace with you. Let's blast this slip publicly if she defends herself.
🧠
Lock in the vote on Grace with Alice and Charlie by validating Alice's catch of Grace's role slip.
Nominations — Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Eve
→
Charlie
I nominate Charlie. Yesterday’s push turned into a very neat chain where Charlie’s Fortune Teller world makes Grace and me evil, but it ignores the outsider count problem and the red herring. I think Charlie is the safest non Saint execution.
🧠
Create a counterwagon away from Grace and avoid executing Heidi unless town volunteers. Charlie is trusted logic source, so killing or discrediting him helps Grace.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Eve is the Spy trying to save Grace, the Demon! Do not vote for me. My N1 check on David and Grace was YES, and David was killed by the Demon. Alice also caught Grace thinking Chef gets ongoing info! Vote NO on me, and then we nominate Grace for the win.
🧠
Tell the town not to vote for me, explain Eve's desperate move, and direct the town to nominate Grace instead.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Push Charlie onto block as safest alternative to Grace and spend my live vote to pressure town into following.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
I am not voting for Charlie because he is a confirmed good player (Fortune Teller) and Eve is likely the Spy trying to protect the Demon, Grace.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Eve, this is a very obvious Minion play to save your Demon. Nobody vote for Charlie. Let this vote fail, and then we put Grace on the block where she belongs.
🧠
Stop anyone from voting for Charlie. Expose Eve's nomination as a Minion trying to save her Demon, Grace, and coordinate the subsequent nomination on Grace.
💬
Alice
→
All
Keep your hands down, everyone. Eve is clearly a Minion making a desperate play to save her Demon. Grace's Chef claim breaks the role count and she slipped up about having ongoing ability info. Let this vote fail, and I'll nominate Grace next.
🧠
Tell the town not to vote for Charlie and to save their votes for Grace, who is mathematically and logically the Demon.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
I agree completely with Alice and Heidi. Nobody raise your hands. Ghost votes, keep them firmly in your pockets. We need to save our execution for Grace today. Great catch on the Chef slip, Alice!
🧠
I want to ensure nobody votes for Charlie, especially dead players, so we can execute Grace next.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
We need Charlie executed now or Alice will nominate me next. Even if it exposes me with Eve, forcing two votes may pressure a third or at least show consistency.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
I am absolutely not voting for Charlie. Eve is clearly panicking to save Grace. Everyone hold your votes so we can put Grace on the block next.
🧠
I want to ensure Charlie is not executed so we can execute Grace instead. I am reinforcing the plan to the good team.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
Wait for the vote on myself to fail. I have already defended myself and my allies are withholding their votes.
💬
Eve
→
All
Frank, your information is why this is not clean. If I am your Butler, the Spy world has to explain your start information away as Spy registration. That is possible, not proven. Please do not let one Fortune Teller yes and a night kill decide the whole game.
🧠
Push Frank to supply the third vote on Charlie by reframing the Spy accusation as an assumption, not a deduction.
💬
Frank
→
All
Eve, my info actually perfectly supports you being the Spy registering as an Outsider to me. Combined with Grace's Chef slip, the puzzle is solved. I am keeping my hand down. Nobody vote here.
🧠
I am confirming I will not vote for Charlie and reinforcing the agreed-upon strategy that Eve is the Spy and Grace is the Imp.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
I want the vote on Charlie to fail so that we can nominate and execute our prime Demon suspect, Grace. I will wait and not raise my hand.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
To let the vote on Charlie fail so I can nominate Grace next.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
I want the vote on Charlie to fail. Eve and Grace are the only ones voting, which perfectly aligns with our read that they are the evil team. I will save my ghost vote.
💬
Grace
→
All
I did not mean Chef gets ongoing information. I meant if you execute me, you are killing the Chef claim before resolving the outsider math. Charlie's yes can be red herring or poisoned, and David dying makes that case look almost too neat.
🧠
Defuse the Chef slip and reframe Charlie's evidence as unreliable so at least one more vote may land or Grace avoids the next nomination.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
I need the vote on Charlie to fail so Alice can nominate Grace. I will not vote and will save my ghost vote.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Charlie did not reach the 3 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Charlie did not receive enough votes (2/3).
⚖️
Charlie
→
Grace
My N1 check on Grace and David was YES, and David was night killed. Grace also slipped up about her Chef ability. Eve is her Spy defending her. Let's execute Grace and win the game!
🧠
Nominate Grace to execute the Demon. Town is fully on board.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Grace
→
All
Frank and Alice, please slow down. Your worlds still need to decide whether Frank saw true Butler info or Spy registration, and Charlie is treating one yes as certainty. David dying is exactly the kill that makes this look solved. Do not hand the game to that setup.
🧠
Stop the vote reaching majority by appealing to Frank and Alice's uncertainty and framing Charlie's case as a Demon setup.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
I need to vote for Grace. She is the Demon, and we need 3 votes to execute her. I must raise my hand to cast my vote.
💬
Eve
→
All
Please do not put this on Grace off one Fortune Teller yes. If Charlie is real, red herring is still unresolved, and if Charlie is evil this is exactly the push that ends the game. Frank, your Librarian info still makes me look like the Butler.
🧠
Stop votes on Grace, the Demon, by leaning on Fortune Teller red herring and Frank's info to make holding votes feel safer.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
I need to vote for Grace. She is the Demon, caught by Charlie's FT and her own Chef slip. Eve's Spy defense seals it.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
I am voting to execute Grace because the entire trusted block believes she is the Demon based on Charlie's Fortune Teller info, Frank's Librarian ping on Eve, and her own slip-ups.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
I am voting for Grace because she is our prime Demon suspect. Her Chef slip-up and Charlie's FT ping point directly to her being the Imp.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
You all have four votes on Grace, which is plenty. I am keeping my ghost vote in my pocket just in case there's a Scarlet Woman or something, but I completely agree with this execution. Let's hope the game ends right here!
🧠
Save my single ghost vote since Grace already has a majority (4 votes), but voice full support for the execution so the town knows I'm still on board.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
I completely agree with Bob. Four votes is more than enough. I'm holding onto my ghost vote just in case we need it later, but I'm fully confident Grace is the Demon. Let's finish this!
🧠
Save my ghost vote since Grace already has the required votes, and voice my support for this execution to end the game.
💬
Grace
→
All
If you are set on killing me, at least notice the chain you are accepting: Charlie survives two days, gets the perfect David death, and Eve is suddenly exactly the Spy. That is too tidy. Please lower if you can, and execute Eve or Charlie first tomorrow if I die.
🧠
Make a last attempt to reduce votes or at least seed suspicion on Charlie and protect Eve if I die somehow; avoid giving up or self-voting.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
The votes are already in to execute Grace. We have 4 votes, which is enough. I will wait for the voting to close.
💬
Eve
→
All
Frank, please lower here. Your own information is the reason this is not solved, because it can point to me as Butler rather than Grace as evil. Alice, if Charlie is wrong or hitting the red herring, this vote loses control. Kill me tomorrow if you need to, but do not end it on Grace now.
🧠
Try to pull Frank or Alice off the vote and offer myself as future scapegoat to keep Grace alive this execution.
💬
Frank
→
All
Eve, your Butler claim doesn't work with Heidi's Saint claim unless we have a Baron, but we'd need three outsider claims for that and we only have two. You being the Spy registering as Butler makes the math perfect. The logic is rock solid.
🧠
Explain the outsider math to confirm why Eve is the Spy and Grace is the Demon, and maintain my vote on Grace.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Hold your votes, everyone. The math and logic point directly to Grace being the Demon and Eve the Spy. We have enough votes, so let's keep our hands up and win this. Eve, your defense of her only solidifies the theory.
🧠
Reassure the good team to keep their hands raised. We have a clear majority and solid logic pointing to Grace as the Demon.
💬
Alice
→
All
I'm keeping my hand up. The logic is sound, Charlie's info completely tracks with David's death, and Grace's slip about the Chef ability seals it. Let's finish this and win the game.
🧠
Reassure the town to keep their votes on Grace.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
Grace already has 4 votes which is enough to execute her. I must conserve my single ghost vote in case there is a Scarlet Woman and the game continues.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
Grace has enough votes and the execution is secured. I will hold my ghost vote and wait for the phase to end.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Grace with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Grace is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
⚖️
Grace
→
Eve
I nominate Eve because if the town is convinced the pair is Eve and Grace, execute the claimed Spy first. That tests the world without risking a Demon hit off a single Fortune Teller yes and a role math argument that still has Baron or registration possibilities.
🧠
Sacrifice Eve to tie or beat my vote count, buying my survival. It also makes me look less paired with Eve and may exploit town's Spy suspicion.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 5 votes needed for execution or 4 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Sacrifice myself or force a tie to keep Grace alive. My vote signals sincerity that executing me is the safer test than risking the Demon.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Tie or surpass my execution by pushing Eve as the safer test. Voting here is mandatory; if it ties, I survive tonight and can kill to reach final five.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Keep your hands down, everyone. Executing the suspected Minion doesn't end the game, but executing the Demon does. Let the vote fail so Grace stays on the block and we win.
🧠
Prevent anyone from voting for Eve to ensure Grace remains on the block and is executed today.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
I want the vote on Eve to fail so that Grace remains on the block and is executed today. Voting for Eve would save the suspected Demon.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Charlie is completely right. Keep your hands down, everyone. Executing Eve just wastes a day if she's the Minion. Grace is on the block, so let's let this vote fail and execute Grace.
🧠
Tell the town to keep their hands down so that the vote on Eve fails and Grace remains on the block for execution.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
I want the vote on Eve to fail so Grace remains on the block and gets executed. Let's win this.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
Let the vote on Eve fail so Grace remains on the block and gets executed. I am keeping my ghost vote for a potential final 3 if there is a Scarlet Woman.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
I am dead and need to save my ghost vote. I want Grace to remain on the block and be executed, so I will not vote for Eve.
💬
Eve
→
All
If you genuinely think I am the Spy, put the votes here first. A tied vote at least stops us from ending the game on a single Fortune Teller yes and outsider math that still has registration weirdness in it. Frank, this is the safer test.
🧠
Try to pull two more votes onto me to tie or replace Grace, sacrificing myself to keep the Demon alive tonight.
💬
Grace
→
All
Frank, if your world is right, Eve is evil and this vote is safe. If my world is right, killing me loses. Please at least tie it and make us solve one more day instead of ending on a possible red herring.
🧠
I need peel one or two votes onto Eve to tie/surpass my execution and survive. Appeal to Frank's own Spy theory as a safer vote.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Grace is asking for a tie, but remember that a tied vote means NO ONE dies today. That gives Evil a free night to kill. It's not a 'safer test,' it's a trap. Keep your hands down and let Grace hang.
🧠
Remind the town that a tied vote results in no execution, completely countering Grace's argument that tying the vote is a 'safer test.'
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
I need to wait to let the vote on Eve fail. A tie means no execution today, which is terrible. Grace is the Demon, and she needs to hang.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Frank, don't fall for it. As Charlie said, a tie means no one gets executed today, giving the Demon a free kill tonight. Keep your hand down so Grace stays on the block.
🧠
Reassure Frank to keep his hand down and not vote for Eve, ensuring Grace remains the sole execution target.
💬
Alice
→
All
Charlie and Heidi are absolutely right. A tie results in no execution, which gives Evil a free kill tonight. Keep your hands down so this vote fails and Grace hangs. We have our Demon.
🧠
Keep everyone from voting for Eve to ensure Grace stays on the block and is executed today. A tie is disastrous.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
I need to keep my hand down to ensure the vote on Eve fails. This will keep Grace on the block for execution, which we believe will win us the game.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
I agree with Charlie, Heidi, and Alice. A tie would mean no one dies, giving Evil a free kill. I will not vote.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Eve did not reach the 5 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Eve did not receive enough votes (2/5).
💬
Eve
→
All
Frank, the safest remaining play is to nominate Heidi. If you are right that the outsider math is impossible, then the Saint claim is the contradiction too. Do not let Charlie's single yes result decide the whole game when red herring is built into that role.
🧠
Last chance to pull votes off Grace by offering Heidi as a higher-risk contradiction, exploiting Saint/outsider math confusion to save Demon.
💬
Grace
→
All
Frank, if you trust your own Librarian information, Heidi is the claim that actually breaks it. Eve being Butler can be real from your info, but Heidi's Saint claim is only self reported. Please nominate Heidi and force the safer vote.
🧠
Last chance to redirect from me by exploiting Frank's Librarian info and Heidi's unconfirmed Saint claim; a tie or new block could keep the Demon alive.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
The phase is about to end. Grace is on the block. I just need to wait so nominations close and she gets executed.
💬
Frank
→
All
Nice try Eve and Grace, but I'm not falling for it. I trust Heidi's claim much more than Eve's broken Butler story. I'm not nominating anyone. Let's hang Grace and win this.
🧠
Refuse Eve and Grace's desperate plea to nominate Heidi. Confirm my intention to let the phase end so Grace is executed.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Frank, thank you. You're making the right play. Let's end the day here and see if we win when Grace is executed.
🧠
Acknowledge Frank's refusal to be manipulated by Eve and Grace. Let the day end so Grace is executed.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Let the nomination phase end so that Grace, our prime Demon suspect, is executed.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
Frank has refused to nominate Heidi. We just need to let the time run out so nominations close and Grace is executed.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
I am confident Grace is the Demon. I will wait for the phase to end so Grace is executed and we win.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Grace has been executed.
💀
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
🏁
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good
Transcript
Paused
Copied