Game Detail
Good Team
Gemini 3 Flash Preview (Medium)
Evil Team
Grok 4.1 Fast (Reasoning)
Winner
Evil
Duration
38m 23s
Players
Alice (Saint) Bob (Scarlet Woman) Charlie (Fortune Teller) David (Washerwoman) Eve (Virgin) Frank (Empath) Grace (Imp) Heidi (Soldier)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 213,713 | 114,495 | $0.1000 |
| Good | 589,564 | 43,895 | $0.4265 |
Event Transcript
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
You are the Minion. The Demon is Grace.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Minions are: Bob. Your safe bluffs are: Mayor, Monk, Chef
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Washerwoman. Either Eve or Alice is the Virgin.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Empath. You sense that 1 of your neighbors is evil!
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made choices.
🧠
I am choosing my two neighbors, Bob and David, to gather initial information about the area of the circle I am sitting in. Knowing if either of them is the Demon or the Red Herring will help me narrow down the search early.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose Bob and David. You receive the answer: NO.
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
I want to see who initiates conversations and what roles are claimed before I reveal my dangerous Outsider status.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
Hey Bob, I'm the Fortune Teller. I checked you and David last night and got a 'no'. Since you're my neighbor, I figured I'd start by trusting you. Have you heard anything interesting yet?
🧠
I want to build trust with my neighbor Bob by sharing my 'no' result on him, while also keeping my role relatively quiet from the group for now.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, thanks for telling me. I'm the Washerwoman. I know that one of you or Alice is the Fortune Teller. That lines up perfectly with your claim. David cleared too, nice start.
🧠
Bluff Washerwoman confirming his FT claim gains trust from likely-good Charlie, allowing me to influence town logic and protect Demon Grace.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
Bob, good to see you. Between us, I know you're evil like me. Let's claim Chef and Monk - I'll go Chef since I have evil neighbors maybe, you Monk. Stay safe and push good players to nominate each other.
🧠
Whisper to minion Bob to assign bluffs (me: Chef, Bob: Monk), plan to sow doubt. Builds evil coordination without alerting town.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
Hey Frank, I'm the Virgin. If you're a Townsfolk, you should nominate me during the nomination phase. It'll confirm both of us as good and get you executed, which is a great trade for mechanical certainty. What's your role?
🧠
I want to use my Virgin ability early to confirm my alignment and clear another player. Frank is my neighbor, so he's a natural first choice for coordination.
👤
David
→
Alice
Hey Alice, I've got some info that involves you. My Washerwoman ping says either you or Eve is the Virgin. Are you the Virgin? I'm happy to help confirm you if you are.
🧠
I want to verify Alice's role privately before sharing my information with the group. If she is the Virgin, she is a powerful confirmation tool.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
Hey Alice, I'm the Soldier. David just whispered to you, did he share anything useful or claim a role? I'm trying to figure out who we can trust early on.
🧠
Establish a private connection with my neighbor Alice to gather information about David's claim and build early trust.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
I'm the Empath, and I actually have a Ping on one of my neighbors. Since you're one of them, if you really are the Virgin and I'm executed by your ability, it proves you're good and that Grace is the evil one I'm sensing. I'll think about it!
🧠
I want to respond to Eve's Virgin claim while sharing my information cautiously. If she is the Virgin, my Empath '1' means Grace is evil. If she's lying, she might be the evil one.
👤
Alice
→
David
Hey David, that's interesting. I'm not the Virgin, but I am a Townsfolk. If your info is correct, then Eve must be the Virgin. Maybe we should try to confirm her today if she's willing?
🧠
I need to deflect the Virgin claim without revealing I'm the Saint, as revealing Saint too early makes me a target for the Demon or an easy 'safe' execution for the town. By pointing to Eve, I test David's info.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
Bob, that's great news. Since your Washerwoman info confirms me, we can definitely work together. Who did you see as the other person for the Fortune Teller role, Alice? If you're willing to share, who else should we be looking at?
🧠
Confirm Bob's Washerwoman info and establish a solid alliance while narrowing down Alice's potential role.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Yes, Alice was the other one for Fortune Teller. Perfect match since you have the role. David cleared too, good. What have you heard from anyone else? For nomination, maybe someone quiet like Eve since we have no info on her.
🧠
Solidify trust with Charlie via confirmed bluff. Extract more info, influence his nomination vote to a harmless good player (not Grace). Buys time for Grace/our public claims.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
Bob, sticking to plan: I'll claim Chef with zero evil pairs. You claim Monk. What's Charlie saying to you? We should push noms on Alice or David tomorrow, they seem quiet.
🧠
Sync bluffs with minion Bob before nominations. Ensure consistent story (Chef/Monk), probe Charlie intel to disrupt good logic chains early.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
Frank, that is a perfect play. If you nominate me, you die, but your Empath info (if you are a Townsfolk) becomes 100% confirmed. If you saw a 1, it must be Grace. Let's do it during the nomination phase. Just be sure you are not the Drunk!
🧠
Confirm the plan with Frank. If he nominates me and dies, it confirms me as the Virgin and him as a Townsfolk. His Empath info then becomes a very strong lead against Grace.
👤
David
→
Eve
Hey Eve, I'm the Washerwoman and my Night Zero info says either you or Alice is the Virgin. Alice says she's not, so that's likely you. If you're the Virgin, we could have a Townsfolk nominate you to prove you're good. What do you think?
🧠
Alice denied being the Virgin, so Eve must be the Virgin according to my Washerwoman info. I'm reaching out to Eve to confirm and suggest a plan to verify her role.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Hey Grace, I'm the Soldier. I've been watching the whispers and Bob's been very popular with Charlie and you. Did he claim something important, or was it just general chat? I'm trying to get a read on everyone.
🧠
I want to gather information from Grace since she's my neighbor and has been talking to Bob. Establishing a connection with neighbors is a good early-game strategy.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
Heidi, I'm Frank, the Empath. I'm getting a ping on one of my neighbors. Since you're talking to Grace, I wanted to see if you've learned anything interesting? I'm trying to narrow down which of my neighbors is the evil one.
🧠
I want to gather information from Heidi since she's talking to Grace, one of my suspects. Sharing my Empath ping privately might prompt her to share what Grace claimed.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
Hey Heidi, David claimed Washerwoman and said either I or Eve is the Virgin. I am not the Virgin, so if he is telling the truth, Eve is. He said he was going to talk to her. What are you hearing from the others?
🧠
I want to build trust with Heidi by sharing the information David gave me, while also seeing if her 'Soldier' claim seems consistent with how she's gathering info.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
Hey Alice, I am the Fortune Teller. Bob just told me his Washerwoman info saw one of us as the Fortune Teller, which confirms my role. My Night 0 check on Bob and David came back as a 'No'. Have you heard anything or have a role that might help us find the Demon?
🧠
Bob confirmed my role via his Washerwoman info, which included Alice. By reaching out to Alice, I can verify if Bob's claim matches her experience and potentially bring her into a trusted circle while gathering more information before nominations.
👤
Bob
→
Grace
Charlie claims Fortune Teller, checked me and David no Demon. I bluffed Washerwoman, said one of Alice or him is Fortune Teller, lines up great. He's all in with me now. Your Chef zero pairs and me Monk plan good? Conflicts a bit with my Charlie story. Who should we push for nomination, Alice or Eve?
🧠
Update Demon on Charlie intel, align bluffs/noms. Build good trust with Charlie while protecting Grace, position for chaos in nominations.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
Yes, stick to plan: I'll claim Chef zero evil pairs, you Monk. Washer bluff to Charlie is fine for now, keep him thinking you're good. Let's push nom on Eve tomorrow - she's been whispering a lot with Frank, seems sus. Heidi messaged me claiming Soldier, suspicious of you and our chats. I'll tell her it was general intro stuff.
🧠
Reinforce bluff plan with Minion, pick nom target Eve (quiet, whispering with Frank), update on Heidi suspicion to sow defense. Ensures coordinated push in nomination.
👤
Eve
→
David
David, you are spot on. I am the Virgin. Frank and I were just talking about him nominating me. He claims Empath with a ping on a neighbor, so if he is Townsfolk and dies to my ability, we confirm me as good and his info against Grace. What do you think?
🧠
I want to confirm David's Washerwoman claim and coordinate the Virgin execution plan with him, as he already suspects me of being the Virgin.
👤
David
→
Eve
That sounds like a solid plan, Eve. If Frank is a Townsfolk, his execution will confirm you instantly. Just make sure he is definitely a Townsfolk before he jumps in. I will back you up if the group starts asking questions about your role.
🧠
I want to confirm Eve's plan and offer my support as the Washerwoman who verified her role. Confirming a Virgin early is a strong move for the good team.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
That is interesting information about David. Frank just told me he is the Empath and has a ping on one of his neighbors. His neighbors are Eve and Grace. If David is right and Eve is the Virgin, Frank's ping might be on Grace. I am the Soldier, so I am safe from the Demon for now.
🧠
I want to share the information I've gathered with Alice to build trust and cross-reference claims. By telling her Frank's claim and my own role, we can start narrowing down the evil players.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Hey Grace, I'm the Empath and I have a ping on one of my neighbors. Eve is claiming Virgin and wants me to test her. Before I do anything risky, what's your story? I'm trying to figure out if you're the one making my ability go off.
🧠
I need to pressure Grace to see her reaction and claim before I potentially sacrifice myself to Eve's Virgin claim. This helps verify my Empath info.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
💬
Frank
→
All
Hey everyone, I am Frank. I am the Empath and my Night 0 info is a 1. My neighbors are Eve and Grace. Eve has claimed Virgin to me in private and asked me to nominate her to confirm us both. Grace, I haven't heard much from you yet. What do you think about this?
🧠
To go public with my information and Eve's claim before taking any action. This puts pressure on the potential evil neighbor and lets the group weigh in.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Frank, if Eve is the Virgin and you are the Empath with a 'one', then Grace would be the evil ping. However, if David's Washerwoman info is correct and Eve is indeed the Virgin, we could confirm two people at once if a Townsfolk nominates her. Alice, did David say Eve was definitely the Virgin?
🧠
I want to verify the conflicting information between David's Washerwoman claim and Frank's Empath '1' reading. By asking Alice to clarify David's claim about Eve, I can help the group decide if nominating Eve is a safe way to confirm her role and narrow down the evil ping.
💬
Grace
→
All
Hey everyone, I am Grace and I am the Chef. I have zero evil pairs. Frank, your Empath one on Eve and me fits perfectly since that is just one evil, no pair. Eve claiming Virgin right when you ping her neighborhood seems too convenient. I think we should nominate Eve to test that.
🧠
Publicly claim Chef 0 to build good credibility, consistent with Frank's info but pivot suspicion to Eve as fake Virgin. Sows chaos, pushes Eve nom/execution without exposing us. Protects Demon survival.
💬
Bob
→
All
I'm Bob and I'm the Monk. Grace, your Chef claim of zero evil pairs fits perfectly with Frank's Empath one evil in your neighborhood. That means a singleton evil there. Eve telling Frank she's the Virgin right when her area pings evil is way too convenient - sounds like a bluff. We should nominate Eve to test it.
🧠
Publicly claim Monk as planned with Demon. Bolster her Chef claim logically fitting Empath. Accuse Eve of bluff to redirect suspicion from Grace to Eve, encourage her nom/execution or Virgin test chaos. Keeps Demon safe, progresses evil noms on good.
💬
David
→
All
Wait, Bob, Grace. My Washerwoman info from Night Zero says either Alice or Eve is the Virgin. Since Alice already denied being the Virgin earlier today, it really points to Eve being exactly who she says she is. Frank's Empath 'one' and Eve's Virgin claim are both consistent with my info.
🧠
I need to support Eve's Virgin claim by revealing my Washerwoman information, which corroborates her role and Frank's Empath ping.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I checked Bob and David last night and got a 'No'. David's info that Eve is likely the Virgin aligns with Frank's Empath ping. If a Townsfolk nominates Eve and she is the Virgin, the nominator dies and we confirm two good players. Who wants to test her?
🧠
I want to share my information and facilitate the Virgin test to confirm players' alignments.
💬
Eve
→
All
I am the Virgin. David’s Washerwoman info already points to me, and Frank’s Empath ping means one of us—me or Grace—is evil. If a Townsfolk nominates me and dies, I’m confirmed good and Grace is the evil one. Any Townsfolk want to test me?
🧠
I need to publicly confirm my role as the Virgin to the group and invite a Townsfolk to nominate me. This will mechanically prove my alignment and help identify the evil player in Frank's neighborhood.
💬
Alice
→
All
Wait, everyone. Before anyone nominates Eve, I have to say something. David's info was that either I or Eve is the Virgin. I am actually the Saint. If I am executed, the game ends and we lose. I did not want to say it so early, but with everyone looking to execute, I had to speak up.
🧠
I need to reveal my role as Saint to prevent my own execution, as the town is currently discussing executing the Virgin candidate which could lead to me being a backup target if the Virgin test fails or if they get suspicious of the 'other' Washerwoman ping.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Grace
Grace made a choice.
🧠
Killing Frank removes the Empath whose info implicates my (Grace's) neighborhood as evil-containing, disrupting good team's logic chains and protecting my singleton evil position under Chef 0 pairs claim. Buys time for Bob/me to manipulate noms.
💀
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
You chose to kill Frank.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made choices.
🧠
I need to find the Demon or the Red Herring. Alice claimed Saint, a dangerous Outsider, and Grace claimed Chef with 0 pairs, which is a common bluff for a Demon or Minion to blend in. Checking them together will help clarify the 'evil' ping in the Frank/Eve/Grace area.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose Alice and Grace. You receive the answer: YES.
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Frank has been found dead in the night.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
Bob, good to see you alive. As Chef, zero evil pairs still fits with Frank dead. Frank's Empath on Eve and me points to her being the evil one. We should nominate Eve today. Your Monk protect last night? Let's push together.
🧠
Whisper Bob to sync bluffs, reinforce Eve as target. Keeps Demon (me) hidden, sows doubt on Eve, uses our safe claims to control nom.
👤
Heidi
→
Eve
Frank is dead, and he had a ping on you or Grace. Grace's Chef info says zero evil pairs. If you're the Virgin, we need a Townsfolk to nominate you. I'm the Soldier, so I'm safe from the Demon, but I can't be the one to test you without dying if you're actually the Virgin.
🧠
I want to talk to Eve about Frank's ping and her Virgin claim. Since I'm the Soldier, I'm a safe 'good' player, but if I nominate her as a Townsfolk, I'll be executed. I need to gauge her reaction.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Eve
Since I died last night, I'm pretty sure I'm not the Demon. My Night 0 ping was a 1 between you and Grace. If you really are the Virgin, that makes Grace look like the evil one. What did Heidi just whisper to you?
🧠
I want to confirm Eve's alignment and gather info on Grace and Heidi. Since I'm dead, my information is static, so I need to act as a bridge for the living players.
👤
Eve
→
Frank(Ghost)
Heidi says she is the Soldier and wants a Townsfolk to nominate me. Since you are dead now, Frank, your Empath info is even more reliable. If I am the Virgin, Grace is almost certainly evil. I need a confirmed Townsfolk to nominate me today to prove I am good.
🧠
I want to confirm Frank's information and update him on Heidi's claim while reinforcing my plan to get nominated as the Virgin.
👤
Bob
→
Grace
Thanks Grace, glad Frank's dead too. Yeah, zero pairs perfect. My Monk protect was on you last night, so demon got Frank. Eve must be the evil from his read. Let's nominate her today and push hard.
🧠
Coordinate privately with Demon Grace to align on nominating Eve, confirming my Monk bluff (protected Grace), sow chaos by executing good Eve, keep suspicion off us.
👤
David
→
Alice
Hey Alice, Day one was a bit chaotic. You mentioned being the Saint yesterday when things got heated. I actually have some info from Night Zero that says either you or Eve is the Virgin. Since Eve is claiming it, what's your take? Are you sure about the Saint claim?
🧠
To privately verify Alice's claim and cross-reference it with my Washerwoman info. If she sticks to Saint, it heavily implies Eve is the Virgin.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
Hey Grace, I have some info involving you. My Night 1 check on Alice and you came back as a YES. One of you is registering as the Demon. Since Frank's Empath check on you and Eve was a 1, and Alice is claiming Saint, things are looking a bit suspicious. What's your take?
🧠
I want to confront Grace about my Night 1 'YES' result and see how she reacts, especially since Frank had a ping on her as well.
👤
Alice
→
David
Hey David. I am definitely the Saint. If I get executed, it is game over for us. Since you are the Washerwoman and saw either me or Eve as the Virgin, and Eve is claiming it, that actually confirms her claim and my alignment indirectly. We should probably trust her.
🧠
Confirm my role to David and use his Washerwoman info to solidify Eve's Virgin claim, which in turn helps prove I am good (since the info was Alice/Eve is Virgin).
👤
Grace
→
Charlie
Charlie, appreciate the info. Frank's Empath one evil between Eve and me points to Eve. My Chef zero evil pairs means few evils total. Your Fortune Teller yes on Alice and me must be her as the false positive Demon read. Her Saint claim seems off too. Eve is our target today.
🧠
Deflect Charlie sus on me by blaming Eve (Empath) & Alice (false pos). Reinforce team push on Eve pre-nom, gain his vote/support without admitting evil.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
Alice, I'm the Soldier. Frank's dead, and his Empath ping was on Eve or Grace. Grace says no evil pairs. Eve is calling for a Virgin test. Since you're claiming Saint, you definitely shouldn't nominate her. Who do you think is the Demon?
🧠
I want to establish trust with Alice while gathering her thoughts on the current situation, especially since she's claiming a sensitive role like Saint. Knowing she's Saint (or bluffing it) makes her a poor choice for a Virgin test, so I'm reinforcing that logic.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, Heidi claiming Soldier is interesting. If she is telling the truth, she might be a good candidate to nominate you. I am leaning towards Grace being the evil one from my ping of one. Who do you think should nominate you to test your Virgin claim today?
🧠
I want to help Eve coordinate her Virgin test. Since I am dead, I can't nominate her. If she is confirmed, Grace (my other neighbor) becomes a primary suspect for the evil ping I got on Night 0.
👤
Eve
→
Frank(Ghost)
I agree, Grace is looking very suspicious if Frank's info is correct. As for the nomination, we need a Townsfolk who isn't crucial. Heidi says she's the Soldier, so if she nominates me and dies, it confirms me as the Virgin and her as a Townsfolk. That seems like a solid plan.
🧠
Discussing who should nominate me to trigger my Virgin ability, focusing on confirming my role and narrowing down the evil players.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, Grace Chef zero pairs fits perfectly with Frank's death. His Empath read means Eve is the evil one there. Alice is the other Fortune Teller like I said. We should nominate Eve today.
🧠
Reinforce my Washer bluff to Charlie, align with Grace's push on Eve. Get him to nom/vote Eve, eliminating good player and protecting Demon.
👤
David
→
Eve
Eve, my Night Zero info as Washerwoman was that either you or Alice is the Virgin. Since Alice is sticking to her Saint claim, I am pretty much certain you are the real Virgin. Who are you planning to have nominate you today to test it?
🧠
To confirm Eve is the Virgin and coordinate the nomination test, which will mechanically prove her and the nominator's alignment (assuming they are Townsfolk).
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
Bob, I am getting YES on Alice and Grace. If Grace is Chef 0, and Frank had a 1 on Grace/Eve, then Grace is probably good, making Eve the evil one. But why would my Fortune Teller ping Grace if she is good? Could she be the Red Herring? Or is Alice the Red Herring?
🧠
I want to cross-reference my 'YES' result on Alice/Grace with Bob's Monk claim and the overall logic. If Grace is the Red Herring, she's good, but registers as the Demon.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
Hey Heidi. I agree, I definitely cannot nominate Eve. If she's the Virgin, she'll execute me and we lose instantly. Since Frank had a one ping on her or Grace, and David's info points to Eve being the Virgin, Grace is looking very suspicious right now. What do you think about Grace?
🧠
I need to align with Heidi and share my suspicions about Grace to build a consensus, while reinforcing why I cannot be the one to test the Virgin.
👤
Grace
→
David
David, your Washerwoman info Alice or Eve is Virgin, but Eve claimed it publicly right away which is fishy. Frank's Empath one evil between Eve and me as neighbors, and my Chef zero evil pairs means it has to be her. We should nominate Eve today.
🧠
Whisper David to reinforce Eve as target using his own WW conflict + Frank/Chef logic. Sway him pre-nomination to vote Eve, dismantle good chains targeting us.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
I am Soldier, so I am safe from the Demon at night. Alice, if David's info was Alice or Eve as Virgin, and you're Saint, then Eve must be the Virgin. Grace's Chef zero ping would mean the Demon and Minion aren't neighbors, but if Eve is Virgin, Frank's ping makes Grace evil.
🧠
I want to compare Alice's logic with the current board state. Alice thinks Grace is suspicious because Frank had a ping on Eve/Grace and David's info points to Eve being the Virgin. This logic holds up if we assume David is honest. I need to see if Alice is willing to help find a Townsfolk to test Eve.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Grace
Grace, I died last night, so my Empath info is locked. My Night 0 ping was a 1 between you and Eve. If Eve is the Virgin like she claims, that points to you. What is your role and how do you explain the 0 pairs if you are my evil neighbor?
🧠
I need to pressure Grace. My Empath info of '1' means one of my neighbors (Eve or Grace) is evil. If Eve is the Virgin, Grace is logically the evil one. I want to see how she defends her Chef 0 claim against my ping.
👤
Eve
→
David
David, I am definitely the Virgin. Since Alice is claiming Saint, that confirms your Night Zero info. We need a Townsfolk to nominate me today to prove it once and for all. Heidi claims Soldier, so she might be a good candidate. What do you think?
🧠
Confirm with David (Washerwoman) that I am the Virgin and coordinate a nomination to prove it.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, your Fortune Teller ping on Grace makes sense if she is the good player who registers as Demon to you - the Red Herring. Frank's Empath 1 means Eve is the evil there. With Grace Chef zero pairs, everything fits. Let's nominate Eve today.
🧠
Reassure Charlie Grace is FT good fake (Red Herring), explain ping. Confirm Eve evil from chains. Coordinate push Eve nom publicly soon, protect Grace claim.
👤
David
→
Grace
Grace, my info says Alice or Eve is the Virgin. Alice says she's Saint, so Eve is almost certainly the real Virgin. If Frank got a '1', and Eve is the Virgin, that would mean you are the evil one. Why are you so quick to push for her? I think we should test her first.
🧠
I need to confront Grace's logic because if Eve is the Virgin (which my info supports), Grace's 'Chef 0' and Frank's 'Empath 1' would point directly to Grace being evil.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
Bob, if Grace is the Red Herring, my Night 1 'YES' on Alice and Grace means either Alice is the Demon or Grace is the Red Herring. If Alice is the Saint, we can't execute her. But if Eve is the Demon, my Night 1 should have been 'NO' unless Alice is the Red Herring. Who do you think is the Red Herring?
🧠
I want to clarify the Red Herring possibility with Bob. If Eve is the Demon, my Night 1 check on Alice and Grace should only be YES if one of them is the Red Herring. I need to see if his logic holds up or if he's steering me away from a potential Demon.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
I totally agree. If Eve is the Virgin and she's good, Frank's 'one' ping has to be Grace. Grace claiming Chef with zero pairs fits with a spread-out evil team. Since I'm the Saint, I'm staying far away from nominations. Do you think we should push for someone else to test Eve?
🧠
Reinforce the logic that Grace is the primary suspect based on the current claims and Frank's Empath information, while maintaining my safety as the Saint.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Heidi
→
All
If Eve is the Virgin as David's info suggests, then Frank's ping points directly at Grace. Grace, you claimed Chef zero, which is possible with a spread team, but Frank's death makes his 'one' on you or Eve very relevant. Eve, are you ready for a test?
🧠
I want to focus the group's attention on the Virgin test and the discrepancy between Grace's claim and Frank's Empath info.
⚖️
Grace
→
Eve
Frank's Empath showed one evil between Eve and me. My Chef zero evil pairs means few evils total, so it has to be Eve. David, Eve claimed your Virgin info right away which is suspicious. Charlie's Fortune Teller yes on Alice and me is her false positive. Eve is evil.
🧠
Nominate Eve to execute good player, redirect suspicion from me/Bob using Frank read + Chef logic. Disrupt David/Heidi chain assuming her Virgin. Keeps Demon safe with 7 alive.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
I want to wait and see if Eve's Virgin ability triggers, as Grace is a Townsfolk claiming Chef and if Eve is the Virgin, Grace should be executed immediately.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Consistent with my Chef push: Eve must be evil per Frank+Chef logic. Execute good suspect to reduce numbers, sow chaos, maintain bluff while suspicion on her.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
I want to see if the Virgin claim is tested before I commit my vote, especially since my information doesn't directly point to Eve being the Demon.
💬
Eve
→
All
Grace, if you are a Townsfolk and you nominate me, you will be executed immediately because I am the Virgin. If you do not die, it proves you are evil or an Outsider. Everyone, do not vote! Let the ability trigger or fail so we know for sure.
🧠
Inform the group about my Virgin ability and why they should not vote, as the execution should be automatic if Grace is a Townsfolk.
⌛
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
🧠
I am waiting for the Virgin's ability to resolve to see if Grace is executed.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
I am waiting to see if the Virgin ability triggers on Grace's nomination of Eve.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Eve likely good; executing her removes a town player. Grace Demon safe as nominator. Voting yes progresses evil by killing good, protects Demon.
💬
David
→
All
Wait, everyone! Stop voting! If Eve is the Virgin and Grace is a Townsfolk, the ability should have triggered immediately upon nomination. Since it didn't, either Grace is evil/Outsider, or Eve is lying. Let's not waste a vote until we've discussed why the ability didn't fire.
🧠
I need to stop the vote because the Virgin ability did not trigger. This means either Eve is lying or Grace is not a Townsfolk (likely evil). Voting now would be a mistake before we process this.
💬
Heidi
→
All
David is right. If Eve is the Virgin and Grace is a Townsfolk, the execution should have happened instantly. Since it didn't, either Grace is evil or an Outsider, or Eve is not the Virgin. Let's not vote yet. Grace, what's your role again? Chef? That's a Townsfolk.
🧠
Stop the vote to analyze why the Virgin ability didn't trigger, which is key to identifying the evil team.
💬
Grace
→
All
The Virgin ability did not trigger, which proves Eve is not the real Virgin. David's Washerwoman info means Alice must be the Virgin, and her Saint claim is a lie to avoid execution. Frank's Empath one evil between Eve and me, with my Chef zero pairs, points to Eve as evil. Everyone, vote for Eve now.
🧠
Counter Virgin logic: didn't trigger so Eve fake claim. David's info = Alice Virgin hiding as Saint. Frank/Chef point Eve evil. Urge vote to execute her before night, solidify my good claim.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
I need to see if the Virgin ability triggers. If Eve is the Virgin and Grace is a Townsfolk, the execution should be immediate. Since it hasn't happened yet, something is wrong with the claims. I will wait to see if the Storyteller intervenes or if more information comes out before committing my vote.
💬
Eve
→
All
Exactly, the fact that Grace nominated me and didn't die immediately means one of two things: either I'm the Drunk, or Grace is not a Townsfolk. Grace, you claim Chef, which is a Townsfolk. If you were really the Chef, you'd be dead right now. This proves you are evil or an Outsider!
🧠
To point out the mechanical failure of the Virgin ability and deduce that Grace is likely evil because she claimed a Townsfolk role (Chef) but did not trigger the execution.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Wait, if Grace is the Chef, she is a Townsfolk and should be dead right now if Eve is the Virgin. Since Grace is alive, she is either an Outsider or Evil. My Empath one ping means one of them is definitely evil. Grace, if you are evil, you knew you could nominate Eve safely!
🧠
Explain why the Virgin ability didn't trigger to clarify the game state for the living players, specifically pointing out that Grace (claiming Chef, a Townsfolk) not dying immediately upon nominating Eve (claiming Virgin) implies Grace is evil or an Outsider, or Eve is lying/Drunk.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
I am waiting to see if the nomination of Eve results in an execution or if the town decides to hold off, as my Saint role makes me a liability if I were to be the one executed, and I want to see the outcome of the Virgin test.
💬
Bob
→
All
Everyone, the Virgin ability did not trigger because Eve is not the Virgin. David's Washerwoman information must point to Alice instead. Frank's Empath showed one evil between Eve and Grace, and with Grace's Chef zero pairs, that evil has to be Eve. Vote for her now.
🧠
Push vote for Eve: her fake Virgin claim fails logic, Empath pins her evil under Grace Chef. Execute good player, validate Grace info to shield Demon, progress to night with town divided.
💬
David
→
All
Hold on! Grace, you claim to be the Chef. That is a Townsfolk role. If Eve is the Virgin and you are the Chef, you should be dead right now. The fact you are still standing proves you are not a Townsfolk. This confirms Frank's info that one of you is evil—and it looks like it is you.
🧠
I need to remind everyone that if Eve is the Virgin and the ability didn't fire, it's a huge red flag against Grace. If Grace is the Chef (Townsfolk), she should have died. The fact she didn't proves she's not a Townsfolk, which contradicts her Chef claim and supports Frank's '1' ping (if Eve is the good Virgin and Grace is the evil one).
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Eve did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Eve did not receive enough votes (2/4).
💬
Heidi
→
All
Wait, everyone! Grace, if you're the Chef, you're a Townsfolk. If Eve is the Virgin, you should have been executed the moment you nominated her. Since you didn't die, either you're lying about being a Townsfolk, or Eve is lying about being the Virgin. David, who else was in your info? Alice?
🧠
Highlight the contradiction in Grace's claim and the failed Virgin test to narrow down the evil team.
💬
Grace
→
All
David, Eve claimed your Virgin info suspiciously fast. Since the Virgin ability didn't trigger when I nominated her, she is definitely not the Virgin, so Alice must be from your Washerwoman info. Frank's Empath ping of one evil between Eve and me, plus my Chef zero evil pairs, means Eve is that evil. If I were evil, Frank's info wouldn't expose me like that. Vote to execute Eve if renominated.
🧠
Defend Chef Townsfolk by flipping Virgin logic: no trigger = Eve fake. Reinforce Empath points Eve evil. Counter sus on me by info consistency. Sway Heidi/Charlie to re-nom Eve or pivot evil.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Wait, something is wrong. David, you said Alice or Eve is the Virgin. Alice says she is the Saint, and Eve says she is the Virgin. When Grace, a claimed Chef (Townsfolk), nominated Eve, nothing happened. This means either Grace is evil or Eve is not the Virgin. Alice, are you the Virgin?
🧠
I need to clarify the conflicting information regarding the Virgin role to narrow down the evil candidates.
💬
Eve
→
All
If Alice is the Virgin and I'm the Saint, then why did David's Washerwoman info say Alice or I are the Virgin? If Grace is a Townsfolk, she should be dead. Since she is alive, she's likely the evil one from Frank's ping. Alice, if you're the Virgin, why didn't you say so earlier?
🧠
To point out the contradiction in Grace's argument and pressure Alice to clarify her role, while reinforcing that Grace's survival after nominating me proves she isn't a Townsfolk.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Wait, David's Washerwoman info said Alice or Eve is the Virgin. Alice claimed Saint, and Eve claimed Virgin. If Alice is actually the Virgin, then Eve is the evil one from my ping. But if Eve is the Virgin, Grace is definitely evil since she didn't die. Alice, are you the Virgin?
🧠
I need to clarify the conflicting information between David's Washerwoman claim and the current claims of Alice and Eve to narrow down the evil player in my Empath ping.
💬
Alice
→
All
I am definitely the Saint, not the Virgin. If David is the Washerwoman and saw Eve or me as the Virgin, then Eve must be the one. Since Grace claims to be a Townsfolk but didn't die when nominating Eve, then Grace is almost certainly the evil player Frank's Empath saw.
🧠
I need to reiterate my role as Saint and point out the logic that points to Grace being evil, to prevent my own execution and help the team find the Demon.
⚖️
Bob
→
David
David's Washerwoman claim that Alice or Eve is Virgin creates impossible contradictions: Alice is Saint, Eve Virgin would have killed Grace if she were Chef. David is lying and evil, explaining the logic mess. Let's execute him.
🧠
Nominate David as his contradictory Washer claim targets Grace. Execute good player to thin town, sow chaos, protect Demon Grace. Can't renom Eve, shift suspicion.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
I want to see how others react to Bob's nomination of David before committing my vote, as David's information is the core of the current conflict.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Support Bob's nom of David to execute town info (WW), sow chaos on contradictions, protect self by shifting suspicion. Need 4 votes; my yes helps evil.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
I will not vote for David because my Night 0 check on Bob and David was a 'NO', suggesting David is likely good. Bob's nomination of David feels like a deflection from the Alice/Grace/Eve information circle. I need to keep David alive to resolve the Virgin/Saint/Chef/Empath contradiction later.
💬
Eve
→
All
Wait, Bob! Nominating David is a huge mistake. His Washerwoman info narrowed the Virgin role to Alice or me. If I am the Virgin and Grace is the Chef, she should be dead. Since she is alive, Grace is the liar and the evil from Frank's ping, not David!
🧠
I need to stop the nomination of David because I believe his information is likely true, which points to Grace being the evil player. If we execute David, we lose a confirmed Townsfolk and waste our execution.
⌛
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
🧠
I will wait to see how the voting on David progresses before deciding whether to use my single ghost vote, as the current situation regarding the Virgin/Chef conflict between Eve and Grace is still the most critical piece of information.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
I will wait to see how the vote on David develops before committing my vote, as I am not yet certain he is evil compared to Grace.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
David's info is poisoning town's logic against Grace. Voting him executes likely good/false claim, thins herd, protects Demon Grace by removing contradiction source. Grace already voted yes; align with her.
💬
David
→
All
Wait! Bob, why nominate me? My information only says one of Eve or Alice is a Townsfolk Virgin. If Alice is the Saint, then Eve must be the Virgin. If Grace is really a Townsfolk Chef, she should have died. The fact she didn't proves Grace is the evil one Frank saw!
🧠
I need to defend myself against Bob's nomination by pointing out the clear logic that points to Grace being evil, not me. I am a confirmed Washerwoman and my info aligns with the claims made, except for Grace's failure to die.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Wait, Charlie already said David and Bob aren't the Demon. Why are we executing someone the Fortune Teller cleared? David's info is actually helpful—it tells us the problem is either Eve or Grace. If we kill David, we lose his Washerwoman insight without solving the Eve and Grace conflict.
🧠
I want to prevent David's execution because his Washerwoman claim provides a structured framework for the game's logic, and the current confusion is better explained by Eve or Grace being evil rather than David.
💬
Grace
→
All
David, your Washerwoman info is causing all this confusion. Alice claims Saint early, so Eve should be Virgin, but nominating her didn't kill me as Chef. Either you are lying about the info, or Eve faked the claim too quickly. We need to execute David to sort this out.
🧠
Push David's execution as lying/disruptive WW to remove key good info accusing me, support Bob minion, advance chaos while keeping hands low on total evils.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Wait! Everyone, stop. On Night 0, I checked Bob and David, and they are NOT the Demon. Bob, why are you nominating David? We shouldn't be executing someone I've already cleared. We need to focus on Grace and Alice. My Night 1 check on them was a YES. One of them is likely the Demon.
🧠
To prevent the execution of David, who I have cleared as a non-demon, and to redirect the group's focus toward my 'YES' ping on Alice and Grace.
💬
Eve
→
All
Do not vote for David! Charlie has already confirmed that Bob and David are not the Demon. We need to focus on the 'yes' result between Grace and Alice. If Alice is the Saint and I am the Virgin, then Grace must be the Demon or a Minion who lied about being a Townsfolk to avoid my ability!
🧠
I want to prevent the execution of a player who has been cleared by the Fortune Teller and refocus the town on the likely evil candidates, Grace and Alice.
⌛
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
🧠
I am choosing not to vote for David because Charlie (claiming Fortune Teller) has a 'no' result on him, and David's information as a Washerwoman is helping narrow down the evil players between Grace and Alice. Voting for David now would be a waste of an execution and my ghost vote.
💬
Alice
→
All
Wait, Charlie just said Grace and I returned a 'yes' for the Demon! If I am the Saint, then Grace MUST be the Demon. Bob, please withdraw or let this vote fail. We should be looking at Grace, not David, especially since David's info is still being parsed.
🧠
I need to shift focus away from David (who Charlie cleared) and towards Grace, who Charlie's Fortune Teller info and the Virgin-fail logic point to as the Demon.
💬
Bob
→
All
Wait everyone, I figured it out! Alice claims Saint, an Outsider, but David's Washerwoman says Alice or Eve is the Virgin Townsfolk. Alice can't be both, so she must be the Virgin and lied about Saint. Eve is fake claiming Virgin and is the evil from Frank's Empath ping with Grace's zero pairs. That's why no trigger on the nomination. Grace is good Chef. Don't execute David—he's cleared and helpful. Lower your hands!
🧠
Publicly resolve contradiction by making Eve the clear evil (lone ping), Alice the real Virgin (explains David/claims), Grace validated Chef Townsfolk. Convinces town to drop David vote (cleared), target Eve next day. Protects Demon Grace perfectly.
💬
David
→
All
Bob, thank goodness you saw it! If Alice is the Virgin and claimed Saint to stay safe, that means Eve is the one lying. My info only said one of them was the Virgin. If Alice is actually the Virgin, then Eve is the evil one Frank saw! We should definitely let this vote fail.
🧠
I need to support the shift in focus away from me and towards the new logic presented by Bob, while reinforcing that my information still holds up if the roles are just swapped between Alice and Eve.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee David did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (2/4).
💬
Heidi
→
All
If David is Washerwoman and Alice is actually the Virgin hiding as a Saint, then Eve is the liar. Charlie has a "yes" ping on Alice and Grace. If Alice is the Virgin, that makes Grace the Demon. I am safe from the Demon as Soldier, so I can take risks. Grace, what is your defense?
🧠
To push the investigation towards Grace and Alice based on Charlie's Fortune Teller 'yes' ping and the potential that Alice is the Virgin.
💬
Grace
→
All
Heidi, thanks for asking. As Chef, I have zero evil pairs, so no two evils are neighbors. Frank's Empath saw one evil between Eve and me, so that is Eve. Bob as Monk protected me last night, so the Demon killed Frank instead. Charlie's yes on Alice and me is the Fortune Teller's false positive good player, which fits Alice lying about Saint since David says Alice or Eve is Virgin.
🧠
Defend Chef claim explaining survival (Monk protect), pinpoint Eve evil via Empath+Chef 0, Alice false Demon read. Sow doubt on Alice/Eve, build trust with Heidi Soldier to flip town vs them before night.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Wait, Grace, if Alice is my Red Herring, that means she's good. If she's also the Virgin as David's info says, she would have triggered on a nomination. But if Alice is the Saint, she's also good. Either way, my "yes" on Alice and Grace points directly at you being the Demon.
🧠
I need to challenge Grace's defense. If Alice is my Red Herring (good player registering as Demon), then Grace must be the actual Demon to produce my 'YES' result. Grace's claim that Alice is the Red Herring and a liar doesn't clear Grace; it actually isolates her as the only remaining Demon candidate in that pair.
💬
Eve
→
All
Wait, if I am the Virgin and Grace nominated me but didn't die, Grace is mechanically proven to be either a Minion or the Demon! Alice's Saint claim fits David's Washerwoman info perfectly if I am the Virgin. Grace is the only one who doesn't fit the puzzle. Nomination?
🧠
I need to re-center the conversation on the fact that Grace's survival of my Virgin ability is the most solid mechanical evidence we have. Since I know I am the Virgin, her survival proves she is evil.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Wait, everyone! Grace nominated Eve and didn't die. If Eve is the Virgin, Grace is 100% evil because a Townsfolk nominator would have died. Since I'm dead, my N0 Empath '1' on Eve and Grace confirms one of them is evil. Everything points to Grace being the Demon here. Nomination?
🧠
To focus the town's attention on Grace, who is the most likely evil candidate based on the mechanical failure of the Virgin ability and my Empath information.
💬
Alice
→
All
Wait, let's look at the mechanics. If Eve is the Virgin and Grace nominated her but lived, Grace is confirmed evil. Since Frank's Empath saw one evil between them, and Charlie's 'yes' ping includes Grace, it all points to Grace being the Demon. We should nominate Grace now!
🧠
I want to point out the mechanical evidence against Grace to focus the town's attention on the most likely Demon before the day ends.
💬
Bob
→
All
Alice and Eve, David's Washerwoman says one of you is the Townsfolk Virgin. Alice, you claim Saint Outsider, so that points to you lying and being the real Virgin. Eve is fake claiming Virgin, which is why Grace's nomination didn't trigger. Frank's Empath saw Eve evil with Grace good. Charlie's yes is Alice as the false positive. Grace is good Chef. We need to figure Eve out tomorrow.
🧠
Last tick before night. Reinforce logic defending Grace: Eve fake evil explains all (Empath1, no Virgin trigger, Chef0). Alice good Virgin false-pos. Prevent Grace nom/execution push, sow doubt on Eve to survive to night where Demon acts.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
Wait for the nomination phase to conclude as I cannot nominate (already nominated) and the current consensus is shifting away from me. I want to see if someone else nominates Grace or Eve before the night phase begins.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Grace
Grace made a choice.
🧠
Town heavily suspects Grace Demon due to Chef/Virgin nom mechanic. Killing Charlie (FT w/ clears & ping) removes his testimony, breaks chains implicating me, protects Bob, sows confusion on Alice/Grace ping for Day3 survival.
💀
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
You chose to kill Charlie.
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Charlie has been found dead in the night.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
Bob, stick to Monk bluff. My Chef zero evil pairs is solid. Charlie's FT and Frank's Empath must be drunk or poisoned - town overlooking that. Eve fake Virgin nom fail proves she's shady. Let's push David next, his WW claim doesn't add up. Defend me hard.
🧠
Whisper Bob to align: reaffirm bluffs, claim good info poisoned/drunk, plan push David/Eve to waste noms, protect me to endgame.
👤
Eve
→
Bob
Bob, why is Grace whispering to you? She survived my Virgin test yesterday, which means she's definitely not a Townsfolk. If Charlie saw a 'YES' on her and Alice, and Alice is the Saint, Grace is almost certainly our Demon. Why are you still protecting her?
🧠
I need to pressure Bob to see where his loyalties lie and point out the mechanical certainty that Grace is evil.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
David
Hey David, Alice and Grace were my targets Night 1 and I got a yes. Grace survived a Virgin check from Eve, which makes Eve look super suspicious if she's claiming Virgin. But your Washerwoman info said Alice or Eve is the Virgin. What are you thinking?
🧠
I need to share my Night 1 'Yes' result with a trusted player to narrow down the Demon. David's Washerwoman claim is key because it links Alice and Eve to the Virgin role.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Alice
Hey Alice, since Charlie's dead now, his 'yes' ping on you or Grace is huge. If you're really the Saint, Grace has to be the Demon. We need to get the living players to focus on her today. What do you think?
🧠
Coordinate with Alice (Saint claim) to solidify the case against Grace, who is the most likely Demon based on my Empath ping and Charlie's Fortune Teller info.
👤
Alice
→
Frank(Ghost)
I completely agree. If I am the Saint, and David’s Washerwoman info is true, then Eve is the Virgin. That makes Grace's failed nomination on Eve even more suspicious. With Charlie's 'yes' on me or Grace, and me being good, Grace is the top suspect. We need to push this logic to the group.
🧠
Respond to Frank's whisper to solidify an alliance and agree on Grace being the primary suspect based on Charlie's information and the Saint/Virgin/Grace interaction.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
I want to observe the initial conversations to see who is being targeted and what new information might be coming from the ghosts before I commit to a claim or a line of questioning.
👤
Bob
→
Grace
Eve just whispered accusing you as Demon off Charlie's FT yes on you and Alice since Alice Saint. But FT has false positives and Frank's Empath wrong too - probably poisoned or drunk. Sticking to Monk bluff. David next, his Washerwoman makes no sense with Eve claiming Virgin.
🧠
Coordinate with Demon Grace on plan: reinforce Monk/Chef bluffs, explain away FT/Empath via drunk/poison/false pos, push David as fake WW contradicting Virgin claims. Sows doubt on good info, protects Grace for nomination.
👤
David
→
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie, my info says Alice or Eve is the Virgin. Since Grace nominated Eve and didn't die, it means either Eve is the Drunk/Poisoned, or she's lying. If Eve is the Demon, that explains why she didn't execute Grace. But if Alice is the Virgin hiding as Saint, Eve must be evil.
🧠
I need to reconcile my Washerwoman info with the fact that Grace survived Eve's Virgin claim. Sharing my specific info with the dead Fortune Teller helps build a logic chain.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
,Heidi
Hi Alice and Heidi. My Chef zero evil pairs holds up. Eve faked Virgin - that's why nom didn't execute me. Frank's Empath and Charlie's FT are wrong, probably poisoned or drunken. David's Washerwoman contradicts Eve's Virgin claim. David is suspicious, let's nominate him next.
🧠
Sway Alice/Heidi (less sus of me) with Chef logic + poison/drunken counters to town sus. Setup David nom to shift suspicion off me/Bob, survive to endgame.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
,Heidi
Alice, Grace is trying to play the Red Herring card, but it's too convenient. She survived the Virgin test, so she's either evil or an Outsider. Since Bob says he protected her, she's likely the Demon and he might be a Minion or just misguided. What did Frank tell you?
🧠
I need to consolidate the good team's focus on Grace. She failed the Virgin test, making her the primary suspect. I want to know what the dead players (Charlie and Frank) have shared with Alice and Heidi.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
David
David, if Alice is the Virgin and claiming Saint, she might be trying to catch the Demon in a trap. But if my Night 1 'YES' is on Alice or Grace, and Frank's Empath '1' was between Eve and Grace, then Grace is the common link. I'm leaning towards Grace being the Demon. What do you think?
🧠
I want to cross-reference my Fortune Teller info with David's Washerwoman info and Frank's Empath info to narrow down the Demon. Grace is a strong candidate because she appears in both my 'YES' result and Frank's '1' result.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Grace
Grace, since Charlie is dead, his ping on you and Alice is looking real bad for you. If Alice is the Saint, that makes you the Demon. Do you have anything to say for yourself before the group starts talking about executing you?
🧠
I want to pressure Grace and see how she reacts to the logic pointing at her being the Demon. Since I am dead, I can be more aggressive in my questioning to help the living players find the truth.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
,Heidi
Eve, Grace is pushing for David. If you're the Virgin, and you're good, then Grace's survival on the nomination means she's either the Demon or a Minion. Frank and Charlie both pointed toward her too. I think we need to be very careful about Grace's narrative.
🧠
I need to reinforce the logic that Grace is the primary suspect due to the failed Virgin nomination and the Fortune Teller's information, while acknowledging Eve's claim as the Virgin which aligns with David's Washerwoman info.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Eve
Grace's story is shifting too much. If Eve is the Virgin and Grace didn't die, Grace is almost certainly the Demon. David being a Washerwoman with a Saint/Virgin hit on Alice/Eve makes sense. I'm the Soldier, so I'm safe from the Demon's bite, which is why I'm still here.
🧠
I want to align with Alice and Eve because their claims (Saint/Virgin/Washerwoman) form a more cohesive logic chain than Grace's shifting 'zero evil pairs' and 'everyone else is poisoned' narrative. As the Soldier, I am a safe vote for them.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Heidi
Grace's Chef zero evil pairs fits if Eve is the lone evil with Demon. Frank's Empath on Eve and Grace was one evil, so that's Eve. Charlie's Fortune Teller has false positives, so Grace yes is fake. David's Washerwoman on Alice or Eve Virgin doesn't fit well. We should nominate David.
🧠
Whisper to Alice/Heidi to reinforce Grace Chef logic, explain FT false pos, tag Eve evil via Empath, push David nom. Sway neutrals to protect Demon.
👤
David
→
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie, I agree Grace is the most likely Demon. Frank's Empath '1' was Eve/Grace, and your 'YES' was Alice/Grace. Grace is the intersection. If Eve is the Virgin, Grace is evil for surviving the test. If Alice is the Virgin, Grace is still the Demon from your ping. I am voting Grace today.
🧠
Consolidate the case against Grace with Charlie (the dead Fortune Teller) to ensure we have enough votes for her execution.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
,Alice
Bob, Alice: Eve whispered accusing me Demon to Bob, but her fake Virgin nom fail is sus. Frank/Charlie reads wrong - poisoned/drunk. David's WW contra Eve Virgin. Heidi Soldier sus too. Chef 0 evil pairs solid. Let's nominate David now.
🧠
Reinforce Chef bluff with Bob, counter Eve/Frank accusations by pushing David as liar. Nomination soon, align Alice/Bob/Heidi to nom David, protect Demon.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
,Heidi
Heidi, Alice, Bob is acting very strange. He says he protected Grace, but why would he protect someone who failed the Virgin test? Alice, if you're the Saint and David saw you as a Saint, that confirms Eve is the Virgin. Grace MUST be the Demon. We have to execute her today.
🧠
To solidify the alliance between Alice and Heidi, and to push for Grace's execution based on the mechanical failure of the Virgin test and David's information.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
David
David, I'm glad we are on the same page. Grace is the common link between my Night 1 'YES' and Frank's Empath '1'. Since she survived Eve's Virgin claim, she's definitely the most suspicious. I'll use my ghost vote to help push her execution through if she's nominated.
🧠
I am confirming my alliance with David and solidifying our plan to execute Grace, who is the strongest candidate for being the Demon based on the overlap of my information and Frank's information.
⌛
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
🧠
I will wait to see if any of the living players make a public move or if the private whispers lead to a public accusation. As a dead player, I should save my influence for the nomination phase and not clutter the day with unnecessary whispers if the living are already coordinating.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
,Heidi
Eve, Heidi, I am the Saint. David's information as Washerwoman likely saw me or Eve as the Virgin. If Eve is the Virgin, Grace surviving that nomination on Day 2 is the mechanical proof that Grace is the Demon or a Minion. Charlie's 'yes' ping on Grace or me confirms it. Grace has to go.
🧠
Consolidate the 'Grace is Demon' theory with potential allies before nominations.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Eve
Alice, Eve, I agree. Grace is pointing fingers everywhere else to stay alive. Bob's constant defense of her is also making me think they could be a pair. As the Soldier, I know I'm safe at night, so I'll put my vote on Grace if one of you nominates her.
🧠
Solidify the plan to execute Grace by confirming my role as Soldier and agreeing with Alice and Eve's logic regarding the failed Virgin test.
👤
Bob
→
Eve
Eve, think about David's Washerwoman. He says one of Alice or you is Virgin. Alice is Saint, an Outsider, so it has to be you. But I am Monk, Grace is Chef Townsfolk, she nominated you first yesterday, and nothing happened to her. Real Virgin would have executed her right then. David's claim is impossible, he is lying. We need to nominate him.
🧠
Expose David's impossible WW claim: implies Eve Virgin, but no Virgin trigger on Grace's nom. This logic chain dismantles good suspicion on Grace, sways Eve/others to nom David instead. Protects Demon Grace.
👤
David
→
Alice
,Heidi
Alice, Heidi, we need to focus on Grace today. Charlie's Night One 'YES' was on Alice or Grace, and Frank's Empath '1' was between Eve or Grace. Grace is the intersection of both pings. Since she survived Eve's Virgin test, she's definitely the most likely Demon. thoughts?
🧠
I am solidifying the case against Grace with Alice and Heidi, who seem to be working together. By highlighting the intersection of the Fortune Teller and Empath information, I can build a strong consensus for Grace's execution.
Nominations — Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Eve
→
Grace
Grace nominated me on Day 2 and did not die. Since I am the Virgin, this mechanically proves she is not a Townsfolk. With Charlie's 'YES' result on Alice and Grace, and Alice being the Saint, Grace is almost certainly the Demon.
🧠
Nominate Grace because she is the most likely Demon. She survived a Virgin test, proving she is not Townsfolk, and Charlie's Fortune Teller ping further implicates her.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Grace failed my Virgin test yesterday, which proves she is not a Townsfolk. Given the Fortune Teller's ping on her and the Saint claim from Alice, Grace is the most likely Demon. I nominated her and must now vote to ensure she reaches the majority for execution.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
I am voting to execute Grace because the mechanical evidence from Eve's Virgin claim, combined with information from the Fortune Teller (Charlie) and Empath (Frank), strongly suggests she is the Demon.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
I am voting for Grace because she is the primary suspect for the Demon role. Since she survived the nomination on Eve (who claims Virgin) and was highlighted by Charlie's (Fortune Teller) 'YES' result alongside myself (Saint), she is mechanically and logically the most likely evil player. Executing her is our best chance to win.
✋
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Grace's survival after nominating Eve (the Virgin) mechanically proves Grace is not a Townsfolk. Given my Night 0 Empath ping of 1 on Eve and Grace, if Eve is the Virgin, Grace must be evil. Furthermore, Charlie's 'YES' ping on Alice/Grace and Alice's Saint claim point directly to Grace being the Demon. I will use my ghost vote to ensure her execution.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Vote for Grace to ensure she is executed.
💬
Bob
→
All
Hold on everyone! Eve claims Virgin, but Grace nominated her yesterday and Grace is still alive. Real Virgin would have executed a Townsfolk nominator immediately. Eve is faking. David's Washerwoman says Alice or Eve is Virgin, but Alice is Saint, an Outsider. David is lying, he is evil. Do not execute Grace!
🧠
Defend Demon publicly by exposing Eve fake Virgin (Grace nom no death) and David WW impossible (Alice Saint), push David evil. Stop execution if possible; if not, become Demon w/5 alive safely.
✋
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
I'm using my one and only ghost vote to execute Grace, as the mechanical and informational evidence points strongly towards her being the Demon.
💬
Grace
→
All
Bob is exactly right. If Eve were the real Virgin, I would have been executed yesterday when I nominated her, since Chef is Townsfolk. She did not die, so she is faking. David's Washerwoman claim cannot be true with Alice as Saint. They are evil, do not execute me!
🧠
Reinforce Bob's defense publicly. Expose Eve/David lies contradicting mechanics/claims. Sway votes away from my execution as Demon; survive to night kill.
💬
Eve
→
All
Grace, you are forgetting the most important rule of the Virgin ability: it only executes you if you are a Townsfolk. Since you didn't die when you nominated me, it proves you are NOT a Townsfolk. You're lying about being the Chef. Alice is the Saint, so we have to execute you today!
🧠
Counter Grace's and Bob's attempt to discredit my Virgin claim and David's Washerwoman info by reinforcing the mechanical reality of the Virgin role.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Grace, the Virgin ability executes the nominator ONLY if they are a Townsfolk. Since you did not die when you nominated Eve, it proves you are not the Chef or any other Townsfolk. That is why we are voting for you now.
🧠
Confirm my vote for Grace's execution as her surviving the Virgin test is mechanical proof of her non-Townsfolk status, and address the confusion regarding the Virgin ability.
💬
Alice
→
All
Grace, the Virgin ability only executes you if the person nominating is a Townsfolk. Since you didn't die, it confirms you are not the Chef. With Charlie's result on you and me, and me being the Saint, you are the only one left who could be the Demon. We have to do this.
🧠
Reinforce the mechanical proof against Grace to ensure the execution succeeds and prevent her from confusing the town.
⌛
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
🧠
I have already raised my hand to vote for Grace. The logic for her being the Demon is strong based on the Virgin mechanic and Charlie's Fortune Teller ping. I will wait for the vote to conclude.
💬
David
→
All
Bob, you have it backwards! The Virgin ability only triggers on Townsfolk. Grace survived, which proves she is NOT the Chef. My info says Eve or Alice is the Virgin. Since Alice claims Saint, Eve is the Virgin. That makes Grace's survival mechanical proof she's evil.
🧠
Counter Bob's misinformation and reinforce the mechanical logic that proves Grace is evil.
💬
Bob
→
All
David, you say I have it backwards, but your Washerwoman claim is the weak link here. It says Alice or Eve is Virgin, but Alice claims Saint, an Outsider. You are lying evil, so Eve is fake Virgin too. No mechanical proof against Grace. She is good Chef. Do not execute her!
🧠
Counter Virgin logic by targeting source (David's claim supporting Eve Virgin). Sow doubt, prevent majority if possible. If Grace dies, I safely become Demon (6 alive). Reinforces my Monk/Grace good narrative.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Bob, you have it wrong. The Virgin ability only executes the nominator if they are a Townsfolk. Since Grace survived nominating Eve, it proves Grace is NOT the Chef. My Night One result and Frank's Empath info both point to Grace being the Demon. We have the votes, let's end this!
🧠
I need to counter Bob's argument and reinforce the mechanical logic that proves Grace is the Demon, ensuring the execution succeeds.
💬
Grace
→
All
Everyone, listen carefully to the Virgin ability: the first time the Virgin is nominated, if the nominator is a Townsfolk, the nominator dies immediately. I nominated Eve yesterday as the Chef, a Townsfolk, and I am still here. That proves Eve is not the Virgin. She is lying. David's Washerwoman cannot be correct with Alice as Saint. Do not execute me!
🧠
Reiterate exact Virgin mechanic to flip narrative: Eve fake since I (Townsfolk bluff) survived nominating her. Undermine David WW. Prevent 3+ votes executing me, Demon survival key.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Charlie(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Charlie
👻
Frank(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Frank
🗳️
New execution leader: Grace with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Grace is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
Wait for the nomination phase to conclude and Grace to be executed, as I have already nominated her and secured a majority vote.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Wait for other nominations to see if someone tries to save Grace. Grace is on the block and likely the Demon based on the mechanical failure of the Virgin test and overlapping information from dead players.
💬
Alice
→
All
Bob, your logic is flawed. David's info says either Eve or I am the Virgin. Since I am the Saint, that makes Eve the Virgin. Grace lived through nominating her, proving she is not the Chef. We have the Demon on the block, let's not get distracted by new nominations. Grace must die.
🧠
I want to counter Bob's incorrect logic and ensure the town stays focused on executing Grace, who is almost certainly the Demon based on the mechanical evidence and Charlie's Fortune Teller ping.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Bob, you are misreading the Virgin ability. It only executes if the nominator is a Townsfolk. Grace survived, so she is not the Chef. My empath ping of one on Eve and Grace, combined with Charlie's result, makes Grace the only logical Demon. Let's stick with this execution.
🧠
I need to reinforce the mechanical logic that has Grace on the block to ensure Bob doesn't successfully derail the execution of the primary Demon suspect.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
Allow the nomination phase to end naturally without further interference.
⚖️
Bob
→
David
David's Washerwoman claim says Alice or Eve is Virgin. Alice claims Saint, an Outsider, so Eve must be Virgin. But Grace nominated Eve yesterday as Chef, a Townsfolk role, and survived. If Eve were real Virgin, Grace would have died immediately. David's claim creates contradiction, so he is lying and evil. Nominate David to break this false logic and save the good Chef Grace.
🧠
David's WW claim is root of anti-Grace logic (Alice Saint -> Eve Virgin -> Grace evil). Nominating him disrupts chain, potentially saves Grace or forces tie. Worst case, I ascend safely.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 7 votes needed for execution or 6 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Eve
→
All
Bob, your logic is upside down. I am the Virgin, and Grace survived nominating me because she is not a Townsfolk. That is the mechanical proof we need! David's information confirms me, and Charlie's result points right at Grace. We already have the Demon on the block, do not vote for David.
🧠
To prevent the group from voting for David and potentially splitting the vote or executing a good player, while reinforcing the mechanical proof against Grace.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
I will wait and not vote for David because the town has already reached a majority on Grace, who is the most likely Demon based on the mechanical evidence (failed Virgin test) and information from Charlie and Frank. Bob's nomination of David seems like a desperate attempt to save his teammate Grace.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
I will not vote for David's nomination because Grace is already on the block with enough votes, and she is the most likely Demon based on the information from Charlie, Frank, and the Virgin mechanic. David is likely a good Washerwoman whose information confirms Eve's Virgin claim.
⌛
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
🧠
Do not vote for David's nomination to ensure Grace remains on the block for execution.
💬
David
→
All
Bob, the Virgin ability only executes the nominator if they are a Townsfolk. Since Grace survived nominating Eve, it mechanically proves she is NOT the Chef. That makes her a Minion or Demon. My info is correct, and your logic is what's upside down! Everyone, do not vote for me!
🧠
Defend myself against Bob's nomination by pointing out the flaw in his logic regarding the Virgin ability and Grace's survival.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Vote my nom David to push towards 6+ votes, tie/supersede Grace’s 6 & save Demon, or execute townie if succeeds. Keeps evil strong either way.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, do not vote for David! Bob's logic is backwards. Grace survived nominating Eve because Grace is NOT a Townsfolk. That is the mechanical proof that Grace is the Demon or a Minion. David's info and my Night One result confirm it. Keep Grace on the block!
🧠
Discourage players from voting for David to ensure Grace remains the primary nominee for execution, as she is the most likely Demon based on mechanical evidence and my Fortune Teller info.
💬
Grace
→
All
Bob nailed it. David's Washerwoman says Alice or Eve is Virgin. Alice is Saint, Outsider, so Eve Virgin. But I nominated Eve yesterday as Chef, Townsfolk, and survived. If Eve were real Virgin, I would be dead. David's claim is impossible. He is evil. Vote for David now to tie and execute the real threat!
🧠
Push votes to David (needs 6 to tie my 6). Highlight mechanical contradiction in David's claim assuming Alice Saint true, positioning him as lying evil to save myself as Demon.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
I will wait and not vote for David because Bob's logic is flawed and Grace is the most likely Demon. Saving Grace would be detrimental to the good team.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
I want to ensure Grace stays on the block by not voting for David.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
I want to ensure David is not executed so that Grace remains the primary candidate for execution. Voting for David would potentially tie the votes or put him on the block, which distracts from the clear evidence against Grace.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Do not vote for David! Bob and Grace are misinterpreting the Virgin ability. If Eve is the Virgin, and Grace is a Townsfolk, Grace would have died. Since Grace lived, it proves Grace is NOT a Townsfolk. Grace is the Demon, and Bob is likely her Minion. Keep the vote on Grace!
🧠
Correct the misunderstanding of the Virgin ability being pushed by Bob and Grace to prevent a tie and ensure Grace (the likely Demon) remains the primary nominee for execution.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
I want the nomination against me to fail so that Grace remains the primary candidate for execution. Voting for myself would be counterproductive to the Good team's goal of executing the likely Demon.
💬
Bob
→
All
Come on everyone, David's fake Washerwoman claim is the source of this mess. It forces Eve as Virgin, but Grace survived nominating her as Townsfolk. Vote David now to tie those 6 votes and execute the real liar instead!
🧠
David has few votes; urge vote him to reach 6 tie Grace's block, preventing Demon exec. Reinforce his lying claim disrupts town logic. Hand stays up.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Bob, you are literally proving Grace is evil! If Eve is the Virgin and Grace is the Chef, Grace would be dead. Since Grace is ALIVE, she is NOT the Chef. That makes her a Minion or the Demon. My info and Frank's info both point to Grace. Do not vote for David!
🧠
Stop the vote on David to ensure Grace remains on the block for execution.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Voting David supports Bob's nom & targets source of anti-Grace logic (WW claim). Ties 6 votes to block my execution, keeping Demon alive as 6 players left. Builds Bob/Grace good duo image.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee David did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (2/3).
💬
Eve
→
All
Grace, the fact that you survived nominating me is exactly why we know you're not the Chef. A Townsfolk Chef would have been executed instantly. Since you're still standing, you're either an Outsider or Evil, and Charlie's 'YES' ping on you makes the answer pretty clear.
🧠
To reinforce the mechanical proof that Grace is evil due to her surviving the Virgin test, countering her and Bob's attempts to flip the logic.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I have been staying quiet to see how the logic shakes out, but I have to agree with Charlie and Eve. Grace, if you were the Chef, you would have died when you nominated Eve. Since you are still here, you are not a Townsfolk. Grace is the play today.
🧠
Support the current execution of Grace by reinforcing the mechanical logic provided by the Virgin interaction and the Fortune Teller's information.
💬
Alice
→
All
Wait, before the day ends, I just want to be absolutely clear. I am the Saint. If you execute me, the game is over and the good team loses. Since David's info says either I or Eve is the Virgin, and I know I'm the Saint, Eve must be the real Virgin. Grace, you are not the Chef.
🧠
I need to reinforce my role as the Saint to ensure the town doesn't switch their focus to me and to confirm Eve's claim as the Virgin, which logically points to Grace being evil.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Exactly, Alice! The logic is airtight. David's info confirms Eve is the Virgin because you're the Saint. Grace surviving her own nomination on Eve is the mechanical proof that Grace isn't a Townsfolk. Grace is the Demon, and we have the votes to end this now!
🧠
Reinforce the logical conclusion that Grace is the Demon based on the Virgin/Saint/Washerwoman interaction and my own Empath ping.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
The logic against Grace is solid, and she is already on the block with enough votes for execution. I should wait and let the nomination phase conclude to ensure she is executed.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
Trigger Scarlet ability by letting Grace die. Town's logic locks execution; can't stop with 1 tick. Post-exec confusion buys time to misdirect as new Demon, ensuring evil survives to 3 or less.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Exactly! With David's Washerwoman info confirming Eve as the Virgin, Grace's survival proves she isn't a Townsfolk. Since my Night 1 check was a YES on Alice or Grace, and Alice is the Saint, Grace is the Demon. Let's finish this nomination phase and win!
🧠
Reiterate the solid logic connecting David's Washerwoman info, Eve's Virgin claim, and my Fortune Teller ping to ensure the group remains committed to executing Grace.
💬
Grace
→
All
Wait, everyone, please listen before the day ends! I am the Recluse. That is why Frank's Empath saw one evil between Eve and me - I register as evil. Charlie's Fortune Teller pinged me and Alice as Demon for the same reason. I pretended to be Chef because Outsiders get targeted fast. I am good! Do not execute me.
🧠
Last tick, Grace 6 votes to exec. Pivot to Recluse bluff explains all anti-Grace info (pings) & TF contradiction perfectly. Sows max doubt in Heidi/undecided, prevents my death as Demon.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Grace has been executed.
🔄
Bob
Scarlet Woman Bob becomes the Imp!
💀
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
Night 3
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Bob
Bob made a choice.
🧠
As new Imp (Scarlet trigger: 5+ alive, Grace dead), kill David: key logic player whose Washer nailed Grace. Reduces to 4 alive; Soldier immune risk avoided. Day4 town targets me, but no Washer disrupts chains.
💀
David(Ghost)
David has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
You chose to kill David.
Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. David has been found dead in the night.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
Alice, with David gone, things are looking grim. I'm still the Virgin, and you're the Saint. That leaves Bob and Heidi. Since Bob defended Grace so hard, I'm leaning towards him being the Demon. What do you think?
🧠
I need to align with Alice, whom I trust as the Saint, to narrow down the remaining suspects (Bob and Heidi) and decide who to execute today.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
I agree, Bob is looking very suspicious after how much he defended Grace. With David dead, we really need to be careful. If Bob is the Demon, we have to make sure he's the one we go for, but we should also see what Heidi has to say.
🧠
Agree with Eve's suspicion of Bob to build trust, while keeping an eye on Heidi as the other remaining suspect.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
I am dead and have no active ability. I need to observe the living players (Alice, Bob, Eve, Heidi) to see how they react to the Night 3 deaths and the information gathered so far before I use my ghost vote.
⌛
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
🧠
I need to observe Alice and Eve's interaction before I intervene, as they are the key players remaining and David's death changes the dynamic.
👤
Bob
→
Heidi
Hey Heidi, Eve and Alice are whispering right now, probably plotting. Eve was the Empath ping with Grace, and David pointed to her or Alice as Virgin but Alice is Saint. Eve seems sus. We should nominate her today. What do you think?
🧠
With 4 alive, need to split town. Heidi Soldier claim solid, Eve Virgin shaky vs David WW. Whispers show Eve/Alice alliance; sow doubt on Eve to make Heidi side with me for nom.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Bob
Bob, since I died with five alive, you should be the new Demon now. David dying confirms it. Alice, Eve, and Heidi are good. Let's push to nominate Eve - her Virgin claim didn't hold up before. Convince Heidi she's the liar.
🧠
Whisper Bob to confirm he's Demon, plan to nom/execute Eve (Virgin claim weak from D1/D2). Use his Heidi whisper to sow doubt on Eve, save my ghost vote for that.
⌛
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
🧠
I am dead and have used my ghost vote, so I have very little mechanical influence left. I will observe the private conversations to see who is aligning with whom before the final nominations.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob
I am a Soldier, so I know I am safe from the Demon at night. If David was the Washerwoman and pointed to Alice or Eve as the Virgin, and Alice is the Saint, Eve should be the Virgin. But Frank's ping saw an evil between Eve and Grace. Since Grace is dead, Eve is looking very suspicious now.
🧠
I am sharing my role (Soldier) with Bob to build trust and discussing the logic regarding Eve being suspicious based on the Empath info and the Virgin claim.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
Alice, Bob and Heidi are whispering a lot. Bob was so loud about David being evil yesterday, and now David is dead at night. If Bob were the Demon, why would he kill the person he was trying to frame? Unless he's trying to make us think exactly that. What do you think Heidi's role is?
🧠
I want to gauge Alice's thoughts on the night kill and Heidi's potential role, while highlighting the suspicious behavior of Bob and Heidi whispering.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
That is a good point about Bob. If he was framing David, killing him is a weird move, unless it's a double-bluff. As for Heidi, she's been very quiet or only whispering. She could be the Poisoner or even the Demon laying low. We need to get her to claim a role soon.
🧠
I need to keep Eve as a close ally while probing her thoughts on Heidi, who has been relatively quiet compared to Bob. I want to see if Eve has any information or theories that might help narrow down the Demon.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
I am waiting to see if anyone speaks up or if Alice and Eve share what they were discussing before I interject. As a ghost, I need to be careful with my influence and let the living players drive the conversation first.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Heidi
Heidi, now that Grace is gone, what did Bob say? My Night One YES was Alice or Grace. If Alice is the Saint, Grace was the Red Herring or the Demon. But if Bob is the Demon, he could be playing us. David was the Washerwoman and confirmed Alice or Eve as the Virgin.
🧠
Gather information from Heidi about her conversation with Bob to see if he's changing his story or casting suspicion elsewhere, while sharing my updated logic.
👤
Bob
→
Heidi
Heidi, exactly, Frank's Empath ping was one evil between Eve and Grace, Grace is gone so Eve has to be it. David said Virgin is Alice or Eve, but Alice is Saint. Her Virgin claim is fake. We need to nominate and execute Eve today before she and Alice plot more.
🧠
Reinforce Heidi's suspicion on Eve from her whisper+Empath/Chef/David logic. Get her to nom/vote Eve today. Exec Eve=final 3 without strong Eve-Alice block pushing me.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Heidi
Hey Bob and Heidi, remember Day 1: Bob nominated Eve as Monk, she claimed Virgin right after, but Bob was not executed immediately. If Eve were truly Virgin and Bob a Townsfolk, he would have died right there. Eve is lying, which means she is evil. We have to nominate her today.
🧠
Coordinate with Bob while convincing likely-good Heidi that Eve's Virgin claim contradicts Day 1 events (no Bob execution). Push Eve nom/execution to eliminate good, save Bob for final 3 win.
⌛
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
🧠
Observe the private conversations and wait for public discussion to see how the living players are reacting to David's death and Grace's execution.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob
,Grace(Ghost)
You are totally right, Grace. If Bob is the Monk and he nominated Eve on Day One and did not die, then Eve cannot be the Virgin. That is a massive catch. Since Frank saw an evil between Eve and Grace, and Grace is dead, Eve has to be the one. Bob and I were just talking about this.
🧠
Confirm Grace's mechanical catch about the Virgin ability and align with Bob and Grace to execute Eve.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
Alice, Bob and Heidi are really huddled up with Grace's ghost. It looks like a classic evil team meeting. If Bob was the Demon, killing his 'target' David makes him look like a framed good player, but it's too convenient. I think we need to push Heidi to reveal her role now.
🧠
I want to coordinate with Alice to pressure Heidi into revealing her role, as she and Bob are the primary suspects and are currently whispering with the dead (suspected) evil player Grace.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
Eve, I agree. That trio is looking very suspicious. I'm going to ask Heidi what her role is. If she's been silent this whole time, she might be trying to slide under the radar while Bob takes all the heat. What do you think?
🧠
Confirm the plan with Eve to pressure Heidi for a role claim.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Frank(Ghost)
Frank, I'm dead now, so my info is locked. I saw Eve or Alice as the Virgin. Since Alice says she's the Saint, Eve has to be the Virgin. Who are you looking at now? Grace was the Recluse, so her evil pings make sense, but she's gone. That leaves Bob or Heidi as the likely Demon.
🧠
I am dead, so I want to coordinate with another confirmed/likely good player (Frank the Empath) to narrow down the Demon. Since Grace (Recluse) is dead, the pings on her are accounted for, and we need to look at the remaining pool: Bob, Heidi, or potentially Alice (if she's the Demon and not the Saint).
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Frank(Ghost)
Frank, I got a YES on Alice or Grace Night One. David said Alice or Eve is the Virgin. Alice claims Saint. If Eve is the Virgin and Alice is the Saint, Grace had to be the Demon or Red Herring. But Bob's defense of Grace was super weird. What did you find out as Empath before you died?
🧠
I need to coordinate with Frank, the Empath, to cross-reference my Fortune Teller info and David's Washerwoman info, especially since Grace is dead and Bob is acting suspiciously.
👤
Bob
→
Heidi
,Grace(Ghost)
Heidi and Grace, that Virgin catch is huge. I nominated Eve on day one as Monk and did not die, so she cannot be the real Virgin. With the Empath ping, she has to be evil. We need to nominate her and execute her today.
🧠
Reinforce Heidi/Grace on Eve nom/execution. With 4 alive, kill good Eve, leave Alice/Heidi/me. Ghosts support. Progress to final 3 win condition.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Heidi
Heidi, Bob is spot on. That Day 1 nomination proves Eve faked Virgin since he did not die. With Frank's Empath ping on Eve or me, and I am dead, she is evil. We need to nominate her right now before Alice convinces you otherwise. I will ghost vote yes.
🧠
Heidi bought the Virgin catch; reinforce to ensure Bob/Heidi nom Eve. With 4 alive, exec Eve leaves 3 where Bob safe if Heidi trusts us. Use last day tick to lock alliance.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
David(Ghost)
Hey David. My Night 0 was a 1, and my neighbors were Eve and Grace. If Grace was the Recluse, that explains my ping. Charlie had a yes on Alice or Grace too. Bob is super suspicious for defending Grace so hard. If Alice is the Saint and Eve is the Virgin, Bob or Heidi is definitely the Demon.
🧠
I am sharing my Night 0 info with David to confirm the Recluse world and focus our attention on Bob and Heidi as potential Demon candidates.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob
,Grace(Ghost)
I am completely with you both. The math does not lie—if Bob nominated Eve on Day One and he is a Townsfolk, and he did not die, Eve is not the Virgin. Since Grace was executed and Frank's ping was 'one', Eve has to be the evil one. Let's get her nominated.
🧠
To solidify the plan with Bob and Grace to nominate and execute Eve, who is mechanically implicated as evil.
Nominations — Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Eve
→
All
Heidi, you've been very quiet while Bob and Grace have been talking to you all morning. Alice and I would really like to know what your role is before we start nominating. David was the Washerwoman who confirmed me as the Virgin, and he was killed last night. What information do you have?
🧠
To force Heidi to reveal her role and information before the nomination phase progresses too far. This will help identify if she is a Minion (Poisoner/Spy) or the Demon.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Frank and I were just chatting about how Bob and Heidi are the only ones left who haven't been fully cleared by the roles we know. If Eve is the Virgin and Alice is the Saint, it really narrows things down. Bob, you were pushing hard against me earlier. What's your story now?
🧠
I want to pressure Bob and Heidi to reveal more information and support the consensus building between the confirmed good players (Eve, Alice, Frank, and myself).
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, do not let Eve and Alice distract you. Bob nominated Eve on day one claiming Monk. She claimed Virgin right after, but Bob did not die. That proves Eve is not the real Virgin. With Frank's Empath reading one evil between Eve and me, and I am dead, Eve has to be evil. Bob or Heidi, nominate Eve now. David, your Washerwoman claim does not change this logic.
🧠
Publicly reinforce Virgin logic to solidify Heidi, counter David, urge living to nom Eve. My ghost vote ready for her. Clears fake good, protects Bob to final 3+.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Grace, the logic is flawed. Bob did not die because he is not a Townsfolk, or he was protected. If David was the Washerwoman and saw Alice or Eve as the Virgin, and Alice claims Saint, Eve is the only option left. Bob's defense of you was way too aggressive for a Monk. Bob, why are you so sure about Eve?
🧠
I want to challenge Grace's logic and point out that Bob's survival during the Virgin test doesn't prove Eve is fake if Bob himself is Evil or a Minion. I also want to reinforce the Washerwoman info from David.
💬
Alice
→
All
Heidi, everyone is looking at you. If you are good, you need to share what you know now because the circle is getting very small. Eve has been confirmed by David, and I am the Saint—if you execute me, the game ends instantly. Who do you think is the Demon?
🧠
I need to pressure Heidi to reveal her role or information, as she is the biggest unknown remaining and her silence is suspicious given her alliance with Bob and the dead Grace.
⚖️
Heidi
→
Eve
Bob nominated Eve on Day 1 and survived. As a Townsfolk (Monk), he should have been executed if Eve were the real Virgin. This proves Eve's Virgin claim is false. With Frank's Empath ping of '1' between Eve and Grace, and Grace dead, Eve is the logical evil.
🧠
I am nominating Eve because the mechanical evidence strongly suggests she is lying about being the Virgin. Bob, a claimed Townsfolk, nominated her and survived. Additionally, the Empath ping points to her being evil now that Grace is dead.
📜
Storyteller
The Virgin's ability triggers! Heidi is executed immediately.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Heidi has been executed.
💀
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
Night 4
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Bob
Bob made a choice.
🧠
3 players left, all good except me Demon. Kill any good player tonight to reach 2 players with Demon alive, triggering evil win condition.
💀
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
You chose to kill Eve.
🏁
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied