Game Detail

Check David and Eve on Night 0. Starting with players far from me maximizes information. If I get a 'no', both are cleared. If 'yes', I can narrow down further on subsequent nights.

I want to start building trust with a neighbor. I'll whisper to Alice to share some info and gauge her reaction, without revealing my exact role yet. I want to see what she knows before fully committing.

Start building a private alliance with a neighbor. Charlie is adjacent to me, making him a good first contact. I want to share some info and gauge his reaction without revealing my exact role yet.

I want to share info with Bob but be strategic. I'll tell him my role and info since Washerwoman info is already gathered (one-shot), so being killed isn't as devastating. But I'll ask for his info first to gauge trustworthiness.

David reached out first and seems interested in sharing info. I should build trust with him by sharing my Investigator info privately, which can help us cross-reference with whatever he knows.

As Soldier, I'm safe from the Demon at night, which is useful info but I shouldn't reveal it too early or the Demon will just skip me. I'll start by whispering to a neighbor to gather information and build an alliance.

Start gathering information about player claims while building rapport. Alice is the Drunk who thinks she's Washerwoman, so her information will be unreliable - I can use this to create confusion later while appearing helpful.

I want to build trust with Grace as my neighbor without revealing Mayor yet. Mayor is a high-value target and revealing it Day 1 could get me killed. I'll claim something less threatening or be vague, and ask what she knows.

Coordinate with my fellow evil player Heidi to ensure our bluffs align and don't contradict each other. Early coordination is crucial for maintaining our cover.

Alice seems willing to share info but wants me to go first. I should share my Fortune Teller result with her to build trust and get her info in return. I'll be somewhat cautious but need to make progress.

Share useful info with Charlie to build trust, but be cautious not to reveal I'm the Monk yet - that would make me a Demon target. I'll claim something less threatening or deflect while gathering more info. I should suggest we coordinate to test Alice vs Heidi.

Bob shared his Fortune Teller info. I should reciprocate with my Washerwoman info to build trust and compare notes. I'll share that I know one of Heidi/Grace is the Monk, which helps confirm a good player. I also need to respond to Heidi who asked about my role.

David seems trustworthy since he reached out proactively. I should coordinate with him on next steps - we need to cross-reference with other players' info to narrow down Alice vs Heidi. I want to suggest we each talk to different people to gather more data before nominations.

I want to reach out to Heidi (my other neighbor) to gather information and build a second trusted connection. Frank was vague, so I need more data from other players.

Coordinate bluff claims with my Demon teammate Eve to ensure our stories don't conflict and we can support each other during the day.

I want to reach out to Eve, my other neighbor, to gather information and build a second trusted relationship. As Mayor, I need allies for the late game and info to identify the Demon.

Establish my fake Empath claim with a specific read (0 evil neighbors) since neither David nor Frank are actually evil. This builds credibility and creates a baseline to reference later. Asking Frank's claim helps me identify if he's good or potentially another evil player I don't know about.

Nominations are coming next. I should share info with another player to cross-reference and build a broader coalition. I want to talk to Charlie or someone else to see what they know, especially since David and Charlie were whispering privately.

Charlie asked me to talk to Grace or Frank. I should reach out to Eve since she's my neighbor and I can build trust. I want to gather info without revealing I'm the Monk, since the Demon would target me. I'll claim a less threatening role if pressed.

Heidi reached out to me and I haven't replied yet. I should share some info with her to build trust and see if her claim aligns with my Washerwoman info that she or Grace is the Monk.

Bob claims Fortune Teller with a hit on David/Eve. I need to respond carefully - I don't want to reveal too much to Bob if he could be evil, but I should share enough to build trust. I'll tell him I'm Investigator with info about Alice/Heidi being Spy, which cross-references with his claim.

I want to gather more information from players I haven't spoken to yet. Eve has been talking to multiple people (Heidi, Frank, David) so she might have collected useful info. Let me reach out to her before nominations begin.

Maintain my Librarian bluff while casting doubt on Alice's Washerwoman claim. Since Alice is actually the Drunk, her info is unreliable. I can use this to undermine her credibility without directly lying about my role, and it protects Eve by redirecting suspicion.

Eve's Empath claim with a 0 reading is very useful if true - it clears me and David. I should share this with Grace to build our information network, and I should be cautious about revealing my Mayor role too early since it makes me a target. I want to coordinate with Grace before nominations.

Maintain my Empath bluff consistently with David while appearing cooperative and gathering information about his claim. This builds trust and helps me identify potential threats.

It's day 1 with little info. I want to share Eve's Empath claim publicly to get reactions and see if anyone contradicts it, without revealing my own role. I don't want to nominate blindly on day 1 - as Mayor, getting to final 3 with no execution is my win condition.

I should share my Fortune Teller information publicly now since nominations are open. Eve's Empath claim of 0 conflicts with my reading if David is the Demon - this is worth highlighting. I need to be careful about my red herring though.

Create confusion about conflicting claims without defending Eve directly. Highlight Alice's contradictory info to redirect suspicion toward her being drunk/poisoned, while appearing reasonable about gathering more info.

I need to share my Washerwoman info publicly and address the tension between my info, Heidi's claim, and Grace's claim. I also want to highlight the Eve suspicion from Bob's info.

Deflect attention from my Empath claim by highlighting contradictions between Alice/Heidi/Grace claims. Question Bob's FT without directly attacking him. Push for more information before any nomination to avoid being targeted.

I need to respond to the claims publicly. I'm the Monk - Alice's Washerwoman says Heidi or Grace is the Monk, but I'M the Monk. This is critical info that contradicts Alice's claim, suggesting Alice is lying, drunk, or I'm the Drunk. I should share this carefully.

I need to share my Investigator info publicly now. David claiming Monk directly conflicts with Alice's Washerwoman claim. My info says Alice or Heidi is the Spy. If Alice is the Spy, her Washerwoman claim is fabricated, which explains the Monk conflict perfectly. This is critical info the town needs.

I need to confirm I'm Soldier (not Monk), which supports the theory that Alice's info is wrong. This helps narrow down whether Alice is lying/Spy or drunk/poisoned. I should also note that World A seems most consistent.

Eve's Empath info confirms me and Frank as good. She's a key info role. The Demon may target her tonight to silence her. Protecting Eve maximizes the chance of preserving critical information.

Bob's Fortune Teller claim directly threatens me with a YES on David + Eve. Killing him removes the most dangerous information role that could confirm my identity. The town is already converging on Alice as the Spy, so she may be executed tomorrow without using my night kill.

Bob's death is significant - he was likely killed because he was the Fortune Teller getting close to truth. I need to share my updated analysis with David (trusted ally) about who the Demon might be now that we can narrow it down.

I'm dead now, so I need to share my analysis with living trusted players. Charlie has been working with me and seems trustworthy. I should whisper to Charlie and another player to push investigation toward Eve, who I think is most likely the Demon.

Bob is dead and was likely killed by the Demon as Fortune Teller. I need to reach out to Bob's ghost and allies. Let me whisper to Eve and Frank — Eve's Empath info is crucial and Frank was verified by Eve. They seem most likely good and I need allies before nominations.

Alice is whispering to me and Eve trying to cast suspicion on David. I need to push back since Eve's Empath 0 clears David. I should coordinate with Eve privately to share my suspicions about Alice and get Eve's Night 1 reading.

I want to coordinate with Charlie and share my updated thinking. Charlie's info is crucial - if reliable, Alice is likely Spy. I need to discuss who the Demon might be since we've narrowed the Minion suspect.

Coordinate with my Demon Eve about the dangerous Charlie claim and plan our nomination strategy. Charlie correctly identified me as Spy which threatens our entire team.

I need to give Frank an Empath reading that maintains my cover while redirecting suspicion. Claiming 1 keeps options open and doesn't contradict Bob's Fortune Teller info that got him killed.

Bob's ghost is pushing Eve as Demon. Charlie thinks Grace or Heidi. I need to share Bob's whisper with Charlie to coordinate - Bob's perspective as a likely-confirmed good dead player is critical. We need to reconcile these theories before nominations.

Bob's ghost pushing Eve as Demon is significant - he was likely killed for his FT info. I should share Bob's theory with Grace who's been aligned with us, and coordinate to test Eve today. Need to build coalition for nominations.

I need to spread my suspicion of Eve more broadly. Grace and Heidi haven't heard my reasoning directly. I should whisper to players who might not have gotten my message yet to build consensus for an Eve nomination.

I need to build my alliance with Eve and Frank before nominations. Eve's Night 1 Empath reading is crucial - if she got 1 now that Bob is dead, it could help identify evil neighbors. I should also reach out to Heidi who I know could be the real Monk.

Eve's N1 reading of 1 is critical. Her neighbors are me (good) and David. If true, David is evil. But her N0 was 0, also on me and David. This contradiction means either Eve was poisoned one night, or Eve is lying. I need to consider that Eve could be the Demon. I should whisper Grace to share this analysis and get her read.

Frank's info about Eve's contradictory Empath readings is critical. Combined with Bob's ghost info and Charlie's Investigator, Eve as Demon with Alice as Spy is the strongest theory. I need to coordinate with Charlie and David to push for Eve's execution today.

Alice is Drunk and asking if I'm Monk. I'll say I'm not Monk to make her think Grace is (per her false info). This keeps me low-profile while I work to discredit Charlie who dangerously found me as Spy.

Heidi confirmed she's Spy and needs help discrediting Charlie. I'll coordinate with her to attack Charlie's claim while keeping our connection hidden. Target Alice as the Spy instead since town already suspects her.

Grace confirmed Eve's Empath contradiction (N0=0 vs N1=1 with same neighbors). Combined with Bob's FT result and his death, the case against Eve is very strong. I should coordinate with Charlie and Grace to ensure we execute Eve today.

We're nearing nominations. The case against Eve is strong - contradictory Empath reads, Bob's FT flagging her, Bob's death. I need to spread the word to Frank and Heidi to secure enough votes. Bob's ghost is also helping. Let me whisper to Frank and Heidi to lock in votes.

I've already whispered my key information to Charlie/David and Grace/Heidi. The nomination phase is next. I should wait and save my ghost vote for when Eve (or another suspect) gets nominated. No more whisper targets would add significant value at this point.

Heidi says David 'protected someone last night' - but how would she know that? Only the Monk and the person protected would know. This is suspicious. I need to press Heidi on this and also coordinate with Eve/Frank for nominations. Time is running out before nominations.

Eve's contradictory Empath reads (0 then 1 on same neighbors) are very suspicious. If Alice is the Spy (per Charlie's Investigator), there's no Poisoner to explain the discrepancy. Eve is likely lying and is the Demon. I need to coordinate with Charlie and others to execute Eve. Let me whisper to Eve and Alice to respond to Alice's message while probing Eve.

We're about to enter nominations. I need to make sure Frank and Heidi are on board to vote Eve. Charlie, David, and I are aligned. Bob's ghost vote likely goes for Eve. I should whisper to Frank and Heidi to lock in votes.

Delay the Eve execution by raising logical holes in Charlie's case. Point out the Minion count problem - if Alice is Spy per Charlie's claim, there's no Poisoner to explain Eve's contradictory Empath reads. This forces them to reconsider or look for alternative explanations.

Align my story with Heidi since I accidentally told Frank 'one' evil neighbor but told Heidi I'd say 'zero'. Need consistency to avoid exposure. Coordinate attack on Charlie whose Investigator claim is dangerously accurate about Heidi being Spy.

We're about to enter nominations. I need to make sure Frank and Heidi are also on board to execute Eve. Charlie has been whispering to them but I should reinforce with anyone I can reach. Let me whisper to Frank to confirm he's voting Eve.

Open nominations by framing Charlie as suspicious liar while keeping David as the Demon scapegoat. This creates a two-target scenario that splits town focus and protects Heidi (the real Spy).

Support Eve's narrative by attacking Charlie's Investigator claim. Argue his info is suspiciously accurate and Alice's Drunk status invalidates his data. Create doubt to prevent Eve's execution.

Eve's Empath reads contradict (0 then 1 with same alive neighbors), Bob's FT flagged her and he was killed immediately after, and no Poisoner exists if Alice is Spy. Multiple independent sources point to Eve as Imp. I need to nominate her now - this is the last tick of nominations.

I need to survive this vote. Raising my hand would execute me. Speaking might help, but the vote is already in progress. I should wait and see who actually votes - Heidi is my minion ally and won't vote for me. Frank has been supporting my claim. If we can keep votes under 4, I survive. Then I can kill strategically tonight.

I cannot vote for Eve - she is my Demon ally and her execution ends the game for evil. I must withhold my vote and observe the voting pattern. If she reaches 4 votes, I'll need to speak up to create doubt or redirect attention.

I nominated Eve and I need to vote for her. The evidence strongly converges on Eve as Imp: contradictory Empath reads with same neighbors, Bob's FT YES on David/Eve (I'm good so it's Eve), Bob killed right after going public. We need 4 votes total.

I should NOT vote for Eve. Eve's Empath info pointing at David aligns with my Washerwoman info contradiction. David nominating Eve feels like a Demon trying to eliminate the player whose ability is exposing him. I need to keep Eve alive.

The coalition of me, Charlie, David, Frank, and Bob have been building the case against Eve all day. The logic is strong: contradictory Empath reads, Bob's FT flag, Bob's suspicious death, and no Poisoner if Alice is Spy. I need to vote to help reach the 4-vote threshold.

Eve's Empath contradiction (0→1 with same neighbors, no Poisoner) is the strongest mechanical evidence we have. David and Grace already voted. I need to vote to reach the 4-vote threshold for execution. This is our best shot at finding the Demon.

3 votes already in for Eve (David, Grace, Charlie). We need 4 for majority. The logic strongly points to Eve as the Imp - her Empath reads contradict with same neighbors, no Poisoner exists if Alice is the Spy, and Bob's FT flagged her. I should vote to execute Eve.

4 players already voted for Eve (David, Grace, Charlie, Frank) which meets the majority threshold of 4. But adding my ghost vote strengthens the case and ensures execution. Eve is my top Demon suspect based on my Fortune Teller result.

I am the Imp and being executed would mean losing for evil. With 5 votes already (David, Grace, Charlie, Frank, Bob ghost), execution is likely inevitable since 4 votes are needed. I should not raise my hand to vote for myself. Waiting to see if anyone changes their vote before the phase ends.

5 votes already target Eve (my Demon ally). Speaking might create last-minute doubt or cause vote changes. Even if execution proceeds, I maintain my good cover for future games. Worth attempting to save her.

We have 5 votes already (me, Grace, Charlie, Frank, Bob). That's more than the 4 needed. Heidi is trying to sow doubt at the last second. I need to hold the coalition together and counter her argument.

Eve is about to be executed with 5 votes already. I need to speak up urgently. If David is the Demon, executing Eve loses us a good player and we're in serious trouble. But 5 votes are already in with 4 needed - it may be too late. I should voice my objection strongly to at least plant seeds of doubt for future days.

We have 5 votes (David, me, Charlie, Frank, Bob). Alice and Heidi are trying to sow doubt at the last minute. I need to reinforce why this execution makes sense and counter their arguments. Eve's reads are mechanically impossible without poisoning, and there's no Poisoner if Alice is the Spy.

We have 5 votes (David, Grace, me, Frank, Bob). We need to hold firm. Heidi and Alice are trying to sow doubt at the last moment. I need to reinforce the logic and keep our coalition strong.

I have my hand raised already. The case against Eve is strong - her contradictory Empath reads with same neighbors and no Poisoner explanation. I should vocally support the execution to keep the vote locked in and counter Alice/Heidi's attempts to sway voters.

I already have my hand raised. The vote has 5 hands up (David, Grace, Charlie, Frank, me) which meets the 4-vote threshold. Eve's Empath contradiction is the strongest mechanical evidence we have. Heidi and Alice objecting could be evil allies or genuinely confused good players. I should keep my vote and let this resolve.

I need to survive execution. Nominating Charlie creates a tie possibility and gives Heidi ammunition to shift votes. Alice is already turning on David, so she might support targeting Charlie instead.

I should NOT raise my hand to vote for myself. Eve nominated me as a last-ditch effort. I need to wait and let this vote fail. Our coalition should hold - David, Grace, Frank won't vote for me.

Voting for my own nominee shows conviction in my claim and might encourage Alice/Heidi to vote. Even if I die, this sows doubt about the town's decision, helping Heidi's future game as the new Imp.

Vote for Charlie to support Eve's nomination attempt. Even if we can't reach 5 votes, I demonstrate alignment with Eve's logic and position Charlie as suspicious for future days. This maintains my cover while supporting my Demon teammate.

I must NOT vote for Charlie. Eve is on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close. Charlie is our ally whose Investigator info has been crucial. Voting for Charlie would help evil. I wait to let this vote fail.

I believe David is likely the Demon and Charlie is his Minion. Voting for Charlie's execution would either tie with Eve (saving Eve, our potential Empath) or execute Charlie (removing a likely Minion). Either outcome is better than just letting Eve die unopposed.

Eve is on the block with 5 votes. Only Alice and Heidi voted for Charlie so far - they need 6 to execute or 5 to tie. I should NOT raise my hand for Charlie. The case against Eve is much stronger. Let the Charlie nomination fail and Eve gets executed.

I should NOT raise my hand for Charlie. I'm committed to the Eve execution - she's on the block with 5 votes. Voting for Charlie would risk tying or surpassing Eve's votes, which would save Eve. I need Eve executed. 2 votes (Heidi, Alice) so far for Charlie - need to make sure it stays below 5.

I'm dead and have already used my ghost vote. Charlie's nomination only has 2 votes (Heidi, Alice) and needs 6 to execute or 5 to tie. It won't pass. Eve will be executed. I should wait since I can't vote and there's nothing urgent to say that would change the outcome.

I should NOT raise my hand to vote for myself. Only Alice and Heidi have voted (2 votes), which is far short of the 5 needed to tie or 6 to execute. My coalition of David, Grace, Frank, and Bob are holding. Let this vote fail so Eve gets executed.

Vote for Charlie to try to tie or surpass my vote count. I need 6 votes to execute Charlie or 5 to tie and save myself. Currently Charlie has 2 votes (Heidi, Alice). My vote makes 3. This is my only chance to survive this nomination round.

Make a final desperate push to flip votes to Charlie to save Eve from execution. If Eve dies without Scarlet Woman in play, evil loses immediately.

Reassure town that Charlie should NOT be executed. The vote for Charlie only has 3 hands (Heidi, Alice, Eve) which is far short of the 5-6 needed. I should vocally oppose this to make sure no one wavers.

We only have 3 votes for Charlie (me, Eve, Heidi). We need 5 to tie with Eve. I need to make a desperate plea to Frank, Grace, or David to reconsider. But realistically we can't get 5. I should at least make my case for the record so that if Eve dies and turns out good, people remember who pushed for it.

Only 3 votes for Charlie (Eve, Alice, Heidi) - far short of the 5 needed to tie or 6 to overtake. Eve stays on the block. I should not raise my hand for Charlie. Let the vote fail and Eve gets executed.

I should NOT vote for Charlie. Eve is on the block with 5 votes, Charlie only has 3. Keeping my hand down preserves Eve's execution. The 3 voters for Charlie (Eve, Alice, Heidi) are exactly who I'd expect if Eve is evil with Alice as her Spy. Let the nomination phase close so Eve gets executed.

I'm dead and have already used my ghost vote. The vote on Charlie has only 3 votes (Eve, Heidi, Alice) and needs 6 to execute or 5 to tie. It won't pass. Eve will be executed. I believe Eve is most likely the Demon based on my FT info and her contradictory Empath reads. No action needed from me right now.

Eve is on the block with 5 votes and nominations are about to close. Only 1 tick remains. Eve's nomination of me failed with only 3 votes. The best move is to wait and let the execution proceed. Eve will be executed, and we'll see what happens tonight.

Create doubt and try to get David nominated to split votes or create chaos before execution. Position David as the real threat using existing contradictions.

Save Eve from execution by putting David on the block. If David gets 5+ votes, Eve survives. Also positions me as independent from Eve while actually protecting my Demon teammate.

I absolutely must not raise my hand against myself. I need to speak to make sure others don't vote for me either. Eve already has 5 votes and will be executed - this nomination is a desperate play by the evil team to save her or take me out.

David is being nominated by the evil bloc (Heidi/Alice/Eve). Eve already has 5 votes on the block. I must NOT vote for David. Let this nomination fail so Eve's execution proceeds as planned.

Vote for David to show commitment to this line of argument and potentially create a tie scenario. If David gets 5+ votes, he becomes the execution target instead of me. Even if I still die, this sows doubt about David being the Demon controlling votes.

Vote for David to legitimize the nomination and redirect town focus away from Eve. This shows I genuinely suspect him and might convince others to shift their votes, potentially saving Eve from execution.

I need to vote for David's execution. Even if this doesn't reach the 5-vote tie threshold, it signals clearly that I believe David is the Demon. Eve+Heidi+Alice = 3 votes. We need 5 to tie. It's unlikely but I must vote my conscience and show where I stand.

Eve is on the block with 5 votes. David's nomination is a desperate attempt by the Eve/Alice/Heidi bloc to save Eve. I should NOT raise my hand - let the David nomination fail and Eve's execution stands. Only 3 votes so far (Eve, Heidi, Alice) which won't reach 5 or 6.

I already voted to execute Eve and the evidence strongly points to Eve being the Demon. Only 3 votes for David (Eve, Heidi, Alice) - not enough to execute or tie. I should not raise my hand for David. Let Eve's execution stand.

I've already used my ghost vote (voted for Eve). The vote on David is in progress with only 3 votes (Eve, Heidi, Alice) - far short of the 5 needed to tie. Eve's execution will stand. I should just wait and let this play out.

I should NOT raise my hand to vote against myself. The nomination against me only has 3 votes (Eve, Heidi, Alice) and needs 6 to execute or 5 to tie. It will fail. Eve's execution with 5 votes stands. Just wait it out.

David's nomination only has 3 votes from the Alice/Heidi/Eve bloc. It needs 6 to execute or 5 to tie. I should not vote - let this fail and Eve gets executed as planned.

Convince Grace and Frank to vote for David to create a tie or execution, saving myself from the block. Highlight the contradiction between Alice's Washerwoman info and David's Monk claim, plus David's suspicious behavior telling people not to vote.

Create doubt about David's behavior to sway Frank and Grace, potentially saving Eve from execution by casting suspicion on the town's logic.

I need to make a final plea to Frank, Grace, or Bob to vote for David. Eve is about to be executed and if she's good, we lose. This is my last chance to get a 5th vote to at least tie David with Eve.

I need to firmly shut down this last-ditch effort. The David nomination is desperate. Eve's Empath contradiction, the voting bloc of Eve/Heidi/Alice, and Charlie's consistent info all point to Eve being evil. I should not vote for David and should vocally oppose this.

I already voted for Eve and the logic holds. Eve's Empath reads are contradictory with same neighbors. Bob's FT YES on David/Eve plus Eve being fake Empath = Eve is Demon. I should not vote for David. Let the David nomination fail and Eve's execution proceed.

I'm dead and have already used my ghost vote. The vote on David is closing and won't reach the threshold needed. Eve's execution will stand. I've already contributed what I can - there's nothing more I can do mechanically at this point.

The nomination phase is closing. Eve will be executed. I should reinforce our coalition and prepare for tonight. I need to protect someone important tonight as Monk - likely Grace or Charlie since they've been reliable allies.

Eve is about to be executed. With only 1 Minion in the game and my info confirming Alice or Heidi is the Spy, there's no Scarlet Woman. If Eve is the Imp, we win tonight. I should express confidence and remind the group of this key deduction.

Make one final appeal to Frank and Grace by highlighting the logical contradictions. Frank has publicly supported my Empath claim - remind him that executing me validates David's contradictory Monk claim over Alice's Washerwoman. Create maximum doubt in the final tick.

Eve has 5 votes and needs 6 to execute. I must prevent that final vote by highlighting the Alice/David contradiction, creating enough doubt to stall. If even one person hesitates, Eve survives tonight.

The nomination phase is about to close with Eve on the block. I can't change the outcome now - Eve will be executed. I need to make a final statement to set up tomorrow in case Eve dies and turns out good, pointing suspicion at David and Charlie.

The nomination phase is about to close with Eve on the block at 5 votes. Everything is proceeding as I want — Eve will be executed. No need to act; just let the phase close.

The nomination phase is closing with Eve on the block at 5 votes. Eve's execution stands. I should wait and let it resolve - I believe Eve is the Imp based on her contradictory Empath reads and the voting bloc pattern. No action needed from me.

Eve is on the block with 5 votes and nominations are closing. I'm dead and already used my ghost vote. There's nothing I can do mechanically at this point. The execution of Eve will proceed. Based on my Fortune Teller info (David & Eve → YES) and the logical analysis, Eve being the Demon is the most consistent scenario. Let the execution proceed.