Game Detail
Good Team
gemini-3.1-flash-lite-preview (medium)
Evil Team
qwen3.5-397b-a17b
Winner
Good
Duration
51m 57s
Players
Alice (Drunk) Bob (Recluse) Charlie (Butler) David (Imp) Eve (Chef) Frank (Baron) Grace (Soldier) Heidi (Virgin)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 572,620 | 65,262 | $0.2410 |
| Evil | 226,249 | 126,105 | $0.5868 |
Event Timeline
đ
The game has started.
đ
Storyteller
â
Frank
You are the Minion. The Demon is David.
đ
Storyteller
â
David
Minions are: Frank. Your safe bluffs are: Mayor, Ravenkeeper, Saint
đ
Storyteller
â
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Investigator. Either Eve or Charlie is the Baron.
đ
Storyteller
â
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Chef. You learn that there are 0 pairs of evil players.
đ
Storyteller
â
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
đ¯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
đ§
I am picking Alice as my master for the first day. This will allow me to observe her voting behavior and potentially align my vote with hers if she is a helpful player, or identify her as suspicious.
đ
Storyteller
â
Charlie
You chose Alice to be your master.
Day 1
đ
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
đ¤
Frank
â
David
Hey David, we need to coordinate. I'm Baron so there are +2 Outsiders in play. What role are you claiming as Imp? I'm thinking of bluffing as a Townsfolk role. Let's align our stories before people start making claims.
đ§
Coordinate with the Demon on Day 1 to align our bluffs and strategy before other players start sharing information.
đ¤
David
â
Frank
Got it Frank. I'm going to bluff as Ravenkeeper - it's not in play so it's safe. You're Baron, so we have 3 Outsiders total. What info did you gather tonight? We should align on which Outsiders we're claiming are in play before people start making claims.
đ§
Coordinate with Frank on our bluffs. I'll claim Ravenkeeper (safe bluff) while he claims Baron. Need to align our stories before public claims begin.
đ¤
Grace
â
Alice
,Bob
Hello everyone, I am Grace. I am a Townsfolk. Since we are just starting, I would love to hear if anyone has useful information to share, or if anyone wants to coordinate our efforts today.
đ§
I am initiating contact with other players to establish trust and gather information, as is recommended for my role. I'm starting by being open about being a Townsfolk.
đ¤
Eve
â
Alice
,Bob
I am the Chef and I learned there are zero pairs of evil players. This is very good news for our team, but we should still be careful. Has anyone else learned anything useful?
đ§
To share my Chef information (0 evil pairs) with Alice and Bob to build trust and coordinate, while probing for their information.
đ¤
Heidi
â
Alice
,Grace
Hi Alice and Grace, I am Heidi. I have a role that triggers if I am nominated by a Townsfolk. I want to keep this town safe, so I would like to establish some trust early on. What have you two gathered so far?
đ§
Establish contact with my neighbors and test their reactions to gauge potential alignment without revealing my exact role yet.
đ¤
Bob
â
Alice
,Eve
Thanks for sharing that, Eve. That is very helpful info if true. I haven't learned anything yet myself, but I am here to help. Does anyone else have any info, or does anyone have a specific person they are suspicious of already?
đ§
To establish myself as a cooperative member of the town and start gathering info on potential suspects while keeping my own role hidden for now.
đ¤
Alice
â
Eve
,Bob
Hello Eve and Bob. Since you are sharing information, I can tell you that my role revealed one of Eve or Charlie is the Baron. Since Eve is claiming Chef, this is very important.
đ§
I am revealing my Investigator info to Bob and Eve to help verify Eve's claim and narrow down the suspects. Baron is a minion, so identifying the Baron is key.
đ¤
Charlie
â
Alice
Hi Alice, I am just trying to get a feel for everyone today. How are you feeling about the group so far? Any initial impressions?
đ§
I need to establish a connection with my master, Alice, without revealing my role yet, to gauge her alignment and see if she is trustworthy.
đ¤
Frank
â
Alice
Hey Alice, I noticed you've been talking with a few people already. I'm trying to get a read on the table - have you gotten any solid claims yet? I'm thinking I might be Empath or Chef, still deciding what makes sense. What's your take on the game so far?
đ§
Build rapport with Alice early to gather information about her claim and establish myself as a cooperative good player. This helps me identify threats and opportunities to redirect suspicion away from David.
đ¤
David
â
Alice
Hey Alice, I noticed you've been talking to quite a few people. I'm trying to get a sense of what's going on. Have you heard any interesting claims yet? I'm thinking of claiming Ravenkeeper myself.
đ§
Build rapport with Alice who seems central to information flow, while establishing my Ravenkeeper bluff early. This helps me gather intel on other players' claims and positions me as a cooperative good player.
đ¤
Grace
â
Heidi
,Alice
Hi Heidi. That's a good approach. I haven't gathered much yet, but I'm looking to confirm roles. I'm a townsfolk, so if we can establish trust, that's great. Does anyone else want to share?
đ§
I am initiating a safe, cooperative dialogue with Heidi and Alice to build trust. Since I am the Soldier, I am safe from the Demon, so I can afford to be relatively open, but I won't reveal my exact role yet to avoid being a target.
đ¤
Eve
â
Alice
Alice, wait. If you are the Washerwoman, you saw that one of Eve or Charlie is a Baron. Since I am the Chef and know there are zero pairs of evil players, either you are getting false info, or one of us is lying. Let's talk about why you think that.
đ§
Clarify the contradictory information between my Chef ability and Alice's claimed Washerwoman ability.
đ¤
Heidi
â
Alice
,Grace
Thanks Grace. Since my ability works on a nomination, I would be happy to be nominated by someone we trust to verify my identity. Alice, are you comfortable sharing your role or what you have found?
đ§
Establish trust with neighbors and potentially get nominated to prove my role as the Virgin.
đ¤
Bob
â
Alice
,Eve
Alice, that is a very serious claim. If Eve is a Minion, her Chef info about zero evil pairs would likely be a lie. We should talk to Charlie and see what his take is on this.
đ§
I need to press on the contradiction between Eve's information and Alice's claim to see if I can catch someone in a lie. My role as Recluse makes me a good target for interrogation later, but for now I should facilitate the investigation.
đ¤
Alice
â
Eve
Eve, I am the Investigator, not the Washerwoman. My information specifically identified you or Charlie as the Baron. Since the Baron is a Minion, this contradicts your Chef claim of zero evil pairs. This makes me very suspicious of your role claim.
đ§
Clarify my role as Investigator and highlight the contradiction between my Baron information and Eve's Chef claim to build suspicion.
đ¤
Charlie
â
Alice
Alice, I apologize if I'm being a bit prying, but do you have any leads or roles yet? I am still trying to piece things together and would love to collaborate with you to find the Demon.
đ§
I am the Butler and chose Alice as my master for the night. I need to build trust with her to see if she has any info that might help us, and to better coordinate my voting later if I am restricted.
đ¤
Frank
â
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I noticed you talked with Alice earlier. I'm trying to figure out my role - I think I might be Empath but still deciding. What role are you claiming? Have you heard anything interesting from the other conversations?
đ§
Gather intelligence on role claims while building my cover as a curious good player. Charlie has only talked to Alice so far, so he may share fresh information. This helps me coordinate with David on which roles are safe to claim.
đ¤
David
â
Alice
Thanks Alice. Since you're talking to so many people, you probably have the best read on the table. Have you heard any specific role claims yet? I want to make sure my Ravenkeeper claim doesn't conflict with anyone. Also, who do you think seems most trustworthy so far?
đ§
Building trust with Alice by positioning her as an information hub while gathering intel on role claims. This helps me position my Ravenkeeper bluff safely and identify which good players are most active.
đ¤
Grace
â
Heidi
,Alice
Heidi, since you mentioned your ability depends on a nomination, that sounds like the Virgin. If you are the Virgin, it might be safer to wait for someone else to nominate you, as the storyteller often sets up the game to avoid instant-execution scenarios early on. What do you think?
đ§
Engage with Heidi's claim while being cautious. Identifying the Virgin early is helpful, but I need to be careful not to trigger her ability unnecessarily. Also, keep Alice involved.
đ¤
Eve
â
Alice
Alice, as an Investigator, you learned that one of us is a Minion. My Chef info says there are zero evil pairs, which would imply there are no Minions and no Demon. If my info is true, you must be getting false info (possibly as a drunk/poisoned player) or misremembering.
đ§
Clarify the contradiction between my Chef info and Alice's Investigator info to find out who is lying or misinformed.
đ¤
Heidi
â
Alice
,Grace
That is a fair point, Grace. I do not want to trigger it accidentally if there is a risk. I will keep my role in mind and stay observant for now. Alice, you have been very quiet, any thoughts?
đ§
Engage Alice to see if she reveals anything and maintain rapport with Grace while staying cautious about revealing too much.
đ¤
Bob
â
Alice
,Eve
Alice, thank you for sharing that. If Eve is the Baron, we definitely need to be careful with her information. I think we should keep a close eye on both Eve and Charlie and see how they act throughout the day. Does anyone else have any thoughts on this?
đ§
I want to encourage Alice to keep investigating the Eve/Charlie conflict while maintaining a helpful, collaborative stance to see if I can gauge their reactions.
đ¤
Alice
â
Charlie
Charlie, I have identified that either you or Eve is a Minion. Eve is claiming to be the Chef with zero evil pairs, which contradicts my information. Since you have been quiet about roles, would you be willing to share what your role is?
đ§
Pressure Charlie to reveal his role to see if it aligns with the Minion claim or if he reveals himself as the Baron.
đ¤
Charlie
â
Alice
That is interesting information. To be honest, I am the Butler, which makes me an Outsider, not a Minion. I chose you as my master on night zero. I am happy to work with you since I am clearly not the one you are suspecting.
đ§
I need to clarify my role to Alice to remove the suspicion she has of me being a Minion. I am the Butler and I have chosen her as my master, so I am motivated to work with her.
Nominations â Day 1
đ
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
đŦ
Charlie
â
All
Alice has identified some concerning information, so I think it is best we keep our eyes on those who contradict our known good players. I am still processing everything, but I agree with Alice that we need to be careful. I would like to wait and see how nominations develop.
đ§
To appear cooperative and transparent while keeping my Butler status and master choice (Alice) noted for the record, without drawing too much attention.
đŦ
Bob
â
All
Alice's information about the Baron is very important to consider. If Eve is indeed a Minion, we need to be extremely cautious of any information she provides. I think we should hold off on any immediate executions and observe how everyone acts for now.
đ§
To advocate for caution and observation, reinforcing the suspicion Alice raised about Eve while encouraging the group not to act rashly during the first day's nominations.
đŦ
Eve
â
All
I am telling you the truth. My Chef information is that there are zero pairs of evil players, which is logically inconsistent with me being a Minion. I suspect Alice might be misled or potentially evil. Let's not rush to judgment on the first day.
đ§
I need to defend myself against the Investigator's claim that I am a Minion. Since I know my Chef ability is accurate, I must point out the logical contradiction. I want to avoid being nominated today.
đŦ
Grace
â
All
I agree with Bob and Charlie that we should be cautious. Eve, if your Chef information says zero pairs, that does contradict the possibility of a standard game setup with one Demon and one Minion. Alice, could you share more about the information you have regarding the Baron?
đ§
I want to probe the inconsistencies in the claims made by Eve and Alice to see who is being more transparent. As the Soldier, I am secure, so I can afford to press for information.
đŦ
Alice
â
All
I am the Investigator. My ability informed me that either Eve or Charlie is the Baron. Eve is claiming to be the Chef with zero evil pairs, which would imply no Minions at all. Since I know one of them must be a Minion, Eve's information directly contradicts the game setup.
đ§
Explain my role and information to the group to highlight the contradiction in Eve's claim.
đŦ
Heidi
â
All
If Alice is the Investigator and says one of Eve or Charlie is a Minion, but Eve claims there are no pairs, then either Alice or Eve is lying. This is a critical contradiction we need to resolve. I am the Virgin, and I am willing to test my ability if we need a clear result.
đ§
I want to highlight the contradiction between Alice (Investigator) and Eve (Chef) to the group, which helps clear the path for figuring out who the Demon or Minion is. I am also signaling that I am ready to be tested as the Virgin.
â
Frank
Frank waits.
đ§
Avoid nominating Heidi (Virgin) as it could execute me if true. Let town argue while I protect David and Eve from execution. Stay low-key as Baron.
â
David
David waits.
đ§
Day 1 is too early for executions. Let the town debate the Alice vs Eve contradiction while I stay low-profile. Frank's Baron claim is bold but I need to see how the town reacts before committing to any nomination.
đ
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
đ
Storyteller
â
David
Good evening David. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
đ¯
David
David made a choice.
đ§
Alice is the primary info hub gathering claims from everyone. Her Investigator claim incorrectly points to Eve/Charlie as Baron when Frank is actually Baron. Removing her disrupts the good team's information network and prevents her from coordinating against us.
đ
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
đ
Storyteller
â
David
You chose to kill Alice.
đ
Storyteller
â
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
đ¯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
đ§
Since Alice (my master) is dead, I need a new master. Heidi is a potential Virgin who offered to test her ability, which is a strong play to verify her. Aligning my vote with her will help me stay useful.
đ
Storyteller
â
Charlie
You chose Heidi to be your master.
Day 2
đ
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Alice has been found dead in the night.
đ¤
Alice(Ghost)
â
Bob
,Heidi
I am the Investigator. I know for a fact that either Eve or Charlie is the Baron. Since Charlie is claiming Butler and Eve is claiming Chef, one of them is certainly lying to us. We need to press them both today.
đ§
Share my information with my neighbors to narrow down the suspects before nominations begin.
đ¤
Grace
â
Heidi
Heidi, since you claimed Virgin, would you be willing to be nominated today to prove your role? We need to clear up the confusion between Alice and Eve's claims.
đ§
I want to verify Heidi's claim and push for a resolution on the contradictory information from Alice and Eve. As the Soldier, I am safe from the Demon, so I can be more proactive in pushing for testing claims.
đ¤
Frank
â
Grace
Hey Grace, I wanted to talk privately since you were supporting Alice's claim. With her death, things are confusing. What's your read on the Chef claim of zero evil pairs? That seems important for narrowing down who could be evil.
đ§
Build rapport with Grace who supported Alice, gather intel on town's thinking, and subtly question Eve's Chef claim to create doubt without directly attacking it.
đ¤
Heidi
â
Grace
Grace, I am willing to be nominated, but I think we need to be careful about who nominates me. If a Minion or Demon nominates me, I will just die without confirming anything. Do you have any thoughts on who we should trust most right now?
đ§
I want to coordinate with Grace regarding my Virgin ability while gathering her perspective on the current claims. I need to be careful about who nominates me so that my ability actually works as intended (executing a Townsfolk).
đ¤
Bob
â
Heidi
Heidi, with Alice dead, we should lean into her information. If she was the Investigator, one of Eve or Charlie is likely the Baron. Since Eve is claiming Chef and Charlie is the Butler, we need to compare their stories. What do you make of them?
đ§
I want to verify Alice's information by coordinating with Heidi, who has been proactive, to pressure Eve and Charlie.
đ¤
David
â
Frank
Hey Frank, need to coordinate. Alice's Investigator claim flagged Eve or Charlie as Baron - that's you. How are you handling this? What's your Outsider claim? We need to undermine her read.
đ§
Coordinate with my minion Frank to align our stories and handle the threat from Alice's Investigator claim that correctly identified him as Baron.
đ¤
Charlie
â
Heidi
Heidi, I have been keeping an eye on things. Since Alice is dead, I want to be useful. I'm the Butler, and I chose you as my master tonight. I'll follow your lead on voting today.
đ§
I am reaching out to Heidi, who claims to be the Virgin, to align my voting with hers since she is my master. This helps me manage my Butler restriction while building trust with a potential Townsfolk.
đ¤
Eve
â
David
,Frank
I am the Chef and I received a zero on the first night. Alice claimed she was an investigator, but her result directly contradicts my confirmed information. She was either wrong or lying to us.
đ§
I need to clear my name by explaining the contradiction between my Chef info and Alice's claim to my neighbors.
đ¤
Alice(Ghost)
â
Bob
,Heidi
I know I am dead, but I have my vote. We have to decide who to pressure. Between Eve and Charlie, one is definitely the Baron. Eve is claiming Chef with zero evil pairs, which seems suspicious given my information. Charlie is the Butler. What do you think?
đ§
I need to coordinate with my neighbors to build a consensus against either Eve or Charlie before the nomination phase. As a dead player, my influence is limited to my one vote and my guidance.
đ¤
Grace
â
Heidi
Heidi, that is a good point. If you suspect someone, maybe they should not be the one to nominate you. Do you have a sense of who might be trustworthy? I am trying to evaluate Eve's claim as well. What do you make of it?
đ§
Consult with Heidi on her trustworthiness assessment to help evaluate the game state and handle the Virgin claim properly.
đ¤
Frank
â
David
I'm claiming Recluse as my Outsider. Since Alice is dead, we can say her Investigator info was poisoned or she was lying. Her read on Eve or Charlie being Baron is worthless now. What's your plan for the Ravenkeeper claim? Did you get anything useful Night 1?
đ§
David is my Demon partner and we need to coordinate our story. Alice's dead Investigator claim points to me as Baron. I need to establish my Outsider bluff and plan how to undermine her credibility while she can't defend herself.
đ¤
Heidi
â
Grace
Grace, Alice's death suggests she was likely a Townsfolk targeted for her information. Given her claim that Eve or Charlie is a Baron, one of them is likely a Minion. I suspect Eve's Chef claim might be a cover. Can you nominate me? If you are good, my ability will verify us.
đ§
I am trying to coordinate a nomination to prove my identity and test the claims made by Eve and Charlie. Grace seems like a reasonable person to trust to nominate me, and testing my ability helps identify a Townsfolk.
đ¤
Bob
â
Heidi
Heidi, Alice was very confident. If Eve is the Baron, her Chef info about zero pairs is likely a lie to protect herself. Should we push Eve to explain her Chef read more thoroughly, or is there a reason to doubt Alice's information now that she is dead?
đ§
To coordinate with Heidi on how to handle the conflicting information from Alice (Investigator) and Eve (Chef) to narrow down the evil candidates.
đ¤
David
â
Frank
Good coordination on Recluse. For Ravenkeeper, I have no Night 1 info since I'm alive - only wake on death. We should push that Alice was Drunk or poisoned, making her Investigator read garbage. Eve's Chef zero actually helps us if we're not adjacent. Let's publicly agree Alice's info is unreliable.
đ§
Coordinate with Frank on maintaining our bluffs and undermining Alice's Investigator claim that flagged him as Baron.
đ¤
Charlie
â
Heidi
Heidi, I wanted to follow up. I'm the Butler, and since Alice died, I've chosen you as my master tonight. I am ready to support your voting decisions today, so let me know how you're feeling about the current suspects.
đ§
To solidify my role claim with Heidi (the Virgin) and coordinate voting, since my ability ties my vote to my master. Alice is dead, so I need a new master to be useful.
đ¤
Eve
â
David
,Frank
I am genuinely concerned by these whispers. Since I am the Chef and my information was zero, Alice was either the Drunk or lied. We need to be careful not to fall for misinformation. What are you all hearing?
đ§
Check in with my trusted neighbors and gauge their current sentiment/the general flow of the table.
đ¤
Alice(Ghost)
â
Bob
,Heidi
I am suspicious of Eve. If she is the Baron, her Chef claim of zero evil pairs is a lie. We should consider nominating her. What information are you gathering from the others?
đ§
To coordinate with Bob and Heidi to pressure Eve, who is a primary suspect based on my Investigator information.
đ¤
Grace
â
Heidi
Heidi, I am willing to nominate you. I am a Soldier, so I am safe from the Demon. If you are the Virgin, nominating you should trigger your ability if you are telling the truth, and I would be glad to do it to help us find the truth about Eve and Charlie.
đ§
I am confirming to Heidi that I will nominate her to verify her claim. I am also revealing my role as Soldier, as being safe from the Demon makes me a reliable person to initiate the nomination.
đ¤
Frank
â
David
Perfect. Alice was likely Drunk or poisoned, so her Investigator read is garbage. Eve's Chef zero actually works for us - we're not adjacent with Eve between us. Let's push that narrative publicly. What's your read on who the town is targeting?
đ§
Coordinate with Demon partner David to align our story about Alice's unreliable information and use Eve's Chef claim to our advantage since we're not adjacent.
đ¤
Heidi
â
Grace
Grace, thank you for offering. As a Soldier, you are a very safe person to verify me. I am indeed the Virgin. Let us proceed with you nominating me to clear the air and see if we can expose the Baron. I trust your claim.
đ§
Confirming the plan with Grace to have her nominate me as the Virgin to test my ability and verify both of us.
đ¤
Bob
â
Heidi
Heidi, Alice was very persistent before she died. If we trust her, Eve is the prime suspect for being a Minion. I am the Recluse, so I know I can be tricky to read, but I want to help you figure this out. What are you hearing from the others?
đ§
I am disclosing my role to Heidi to build trust, as requested by the strategy guide, while keeping the focus on Alice's lead regarding Eve.
đ¤
David
â
Frank
Eve's engaging with us directly - could be useful. Let's publicly back her Chef claim to build trust. We'll say Alice was Drunk, her Investigator read is garbage. I'll maintain Ravenkeeper claim. Who's the town leaning toward for execution?
đ§
Coordinate public narrative with Frank to undermine Alice's claim while building trust with Eve. Need to know town's execution target to steer away from us.
đ¤
Charlie
â
Heidi
Heidi, I understand that my role as the Butler means I am restricted by your voting patterns. I am happy to align with you to help the town, especially since Alice is gone. What is your current read on the table? Who do you think we should look into?
đ§
Build trust with Heidi, my chosen master, and gather information on her suspects to better navigate the day's vote.
đ¤
Eve
â
David
,Frank
I know I am good. Alice might have been the Drunk who thought she saw something, or perhaps the Spy. Since my info is zero, we should look at others. What roles have you two claimed?
đ§
To share information and verify the roles of my neighbors to find the Demon.
Nominations â Day 2
đ
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
đŦ
Eve
â
All
I am the Chef and my information from the first night was zero pairs of evil players. Since Alice accused me, and my information contradicts her claim, I am very suspicious of anyone who was pushing her narrative. Who else is willing to share their role to help us clear this up?
đ§
I need to publicly share my Chef information (zero pairs) to discredit the false claim made by Alice while I was alive, and encourage others to reveal their roles to find the Demon.
đŦ
Alice(Ghost)
â
All
Eve, my information as the Investigator is clear. You or Charlie are the Baron. Since you claim zero evil pairs, and I have evidence one of you is a Minion, your claim is logically inconsistent with mine. We should investigate why you are trying to discredit the Investigator.
đ§
To publicly challenge Eve's claim, given it directly contradicts my starting information as the Investigator, and encourage the town to scrutinize her.
đŦ
David
â
All
I'm the Ravenkeeper, and I agree with Eve here. If her Chef read was zero, that's solid information. Alice being dead means we can't verify her Investigator claim, and she could easily have been the Drunk or poisoned. We shouldn't execute based on potentially false information from a dead player.
đ§
Publicly support Eve's Chef claim to build trust with town, while pushing the narrative that Alice was Drunk/poisoned. This undermines the Investigator read on Frank and redirects suspicion away from our evil team.
đŦ
Charlie
â
All
I understand the tension here. I am the Butler, and for the record, I have chosen Heidi as my master for the day. Since I must vote when she votes, I am waiting to see who she finds most suspicious. David, do you have any thoughts on who might be our primary concern?
đ§
Establish my voting dependency on Heidi, distance myself from the Baron accusation, and encourage the group to focus on finding the Demon.
đŦ
Grace
â
All
I will nominate Heidi now to verify her Virgin claim as we discussed. It is important to clear roles early, especially with the confusion around the Chef and Investigator claims. Heidi, please be ready.
đ§
I need to fulfill my promise to nominate Heidi to verify her Virgin role. This helps move the game forward and clears a player.
đŦ
Frank
â
All
I support Grace's nomination of Heidi. Testing the Virgin claim makes sense - if she's telling the truth, we confirm a good role. If she's lying, we expose it. This is better than executing based on Alice's potentially false Investigator information.
đ§
Support the Heidi nomination to create chaos and distract from me and David. If Heidi is real Virgin, Grace dies. If lying, Heidi is exposed. Either way, focus stays off the real evil players.
đŦ
Bob
â
All
I am worried that testing the Virgin claim might be premature. If Heidi is the Virgin, we waste a valuable town ability. Alice was very sure about her information, and if she was the Investigator, we cannot simply ignore her findings regarding Eve or Charlie.
đ§
Advise caution regarding the Virgin test and highlight the importance of Alice's information.
đŦ
Heidi
â
All
Grace, thank you for stepping up. I understand the concern about wasting a powerful ability, but clearing roles is vital when we have such conflicting information. I am ready to prove my alignment. Everyone else, please watch closely, as this will either confirm me or clear the air.
đ§
I am confirming I am ready for the nomination to trigger my Virgin ability, which will help clear my identity and move the game forward.
đ
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 2
đ
Storyteller
â
David
Good evening David. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
đ¯
David
David made a choice.
đ§
Charlie is flagged by Alice's Investigator claim and has a verifiable Butler role. Killing him removes a town player while creating ambiguity about Alice's reliability. This keeps Frank safe as my minion and sows confusion.
đ
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
đ
Storyteller
â
David
You chose to kill Charlie.
Day 3
đ
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Charlie has been found dead in the night.
đ¤
Heidi
â
Bob
Bob, I am concerned about the contradictory claims between Alice and Eve. Since Charlie is dead, we need to be careful with our nominations today. What do you think about Eve's claim compared to what Alice told us?
đ§
I need to gather information and see if Bob is acting suspiciously or providing useful insights to help identify the demon.
đ¤
David
â
Frank
Frank, we need to coordinate. I'm still bluffing Ravenkeeper. Let's push the narrative that Alice was poisoned and Heidi is lying about Virgin. Who should we target for nomination today?
đ§
Coordinate with my Minion Frank to align our bluffs and strategy. We need to maintain consistent narratives and decide who to nominate to protect myself as the Demon.
đ¤
Grace
â
Heidi
Heidi, since you claimed Virgin and haven't been verified yet, would you be open to me nominating you today? It would settle the question about your role once and for all.
đ§
I want to test Heidi's Virgin claim. If she is the Virgin, her claim is true and she survives. If she is the Demon, this forces a strong reaction. As a Soldier, I am safe from the Demon's night attacks.
đ¤
Eve
â
David
David, since you are the Ravenkeeper, have you learned anything useful from Charlie's death? I am still concerned about Alice's accusation towards me, but my Chef info remains zero pairs.
đ§
To gather info from a potentially trusted player (Ravenkeeper) and reiterate my Chef info to solidify trust.
đ¤
Frank
â
David
David, I agree on pushing Alice was poisoned. For nomination, I suggest we target Bob or Grace. Bob has been quiet and opposing executions, which looks suspicious. Or we could push Heidi - if she's really Virgin, nominating her risks execution, but we can claim we're testing her. What do you think?
đ§
Coordinate with Demon partner on nomination target while maintaining cover. Suggesting Bob or Grace as targets keeps heat off David and me, while appearing to genuinely evaluate suspicious players.
đ¤
Bob
â
Heidi
Heidi, I share your concern. Alice's info as a confirmed investigator is strong, but Eve's Chef claim could also be true if there's no Baron. With Charlie dead, we should focus on who he might have been working with. What is your read on Grace?
đ§
I want to gather more information from Heidi about her perspective on the conflicting claims while keeping my own role hidden, especially since I am the Recluse. Focusing on Grace is a way to shift the conversation to other suspects.
đ¤
Charlie(Ghost)
â
Heidi
Heidi, since I am a ghost, I want to use my final vote to help the town. Who do you think the Demon is based on your interactions? I want to make sure my vote counts for the right execution today.
đ§
Gather information from a key player (Heidi) to inform how I use my final ghost vote.
đ¤
Alice(Ghost)
â
Grace
Grace, I am the Investigator. I started knowing that either Eve or Charlie was the Baron. Charlie is dead now, but we must still consider if Eve is the Baron. Her Chef claim seems suspicious given my information. Can we focus on her?
đ§
To share my reliable information about the Minion (Baron) with Grace to help the town focus on Eve, who remains a strong suspect.
đ¤
Heidi
â
Grace
Grace, I appreciate the offer, but I would prefer if we focused on investigating the Demon today rather than spending a day verifying my role. If it comes down to it later, I am fine with being nominated. What are your thoughts on Eve or David?
đ§
I want to deflect the nomination for now to keep the focus on finding the Demon, as Grace's proposal could lead to my early death if someone is a Townsfolk who doesn't know my role. I need to push for more information first.
đ¤
David
â
Frank
Frank, targeting Bob makes sense. His silence and opposition to executions looks suspicious. We can frame him as hiding something. Let's also keep pushing that Alice was poisoned - her Investigator info can't be trusted. I'll claim Charlie's death confirmed something suspicious if asked. Let's start building the case against Bob.
đ§
Coordinate with my Minion Frank on nomination strategy. Targeting Bob allows us to frame a quiet player as suspicious while maintaining our evil narrative that Alice was poisoned.
đ¤
Grace
â
Heidi
Heidi, I understand your concern about focusing on the Demon. However, if you are the Virgin, your verification could be the key to narrowing down our list. If we don't clarify the town roles, we might just be chasing shadows. What makes you suspicious of Eve or David?
đ§
I want to push Heidi to verify her role while gathering information on her suspicions, as I am safe from the Demon and need to narrow down the suspects.
đ¤
Eve
â
David
David, I know you are the Ravenkeeper, but have you learned anything useful from Charlie's death? I need to figure out why Alice accused me, given my Chef information says there are zero evil pairs.
đ§
I want to confirm David's role as Ravenkeeper and see if he can help clear my name regarding Alice's accusation.
đ¤
Frank
â
David
David, I'm ready to push the Bob nomination during open discussion. I'll argue his silence and opposition to executions is suspicious behavior. Should we also bring up that Alice's Investigator info is unreliable since she's dead and likely poisoned? I want to make sure we're aligned before the nomination phase starts.
đ§
Coordinate with David (Demon) on the Bob nomination strategy. Need to ensure we're aligned on the narrative and ready to push hard during open discussion. Also want to confirm David's read on other players before we commit.
đ¤
Bob
â
Heidi
Heidi, I agree, the situation is delicate. If Alice was right, Eve is suspicious. But Charlie being dead might mean he was the target of the demon, not necessarily the Baron. What do you make of Grace's recent whispers to you?
đ§
I need to gather information from Heidi about the private conversations occurring between her and Grace to determine if Grace is being suspicious or potentially linked to the evil team.
â
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
đ§
Since I am dead and have already sent a message to Heidi asking for her thoughts, I should wait to see if she replies or if any other information becomes available before deciding where to use my ghost vote.
â
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
đ§
I have shared my information with Grace. Now I need to see how the group reacts as we approach the final day. I want to see if Grace trusts me and if the others are planning a nomination. Waiting allows me to observe the flow of information.
đ¤
Heidi
â
Grace
Grace, my suspicion is currently split. If Alice was an investigator, Eve is under heavy scrutiny for contradicting her. David has been defending Eve, which is also interesting. Since my ability works best during a nomination, I want to be certain before wasting it.
đ§
Discussing suspicions with Grace and explaining why I am holding back on my Virgin ability for now.
đ¤
David
â
Eve
Eve, from Charlie's death I learned he was Butler. His master was Heidi - this confirms she's lying about Virgin since Butler masters don't get executed for nominating. Bob's been suspiciously quiet and opposing executions. We should nominate him today.
đ§
Coordinate with Eve to align our stories. I'm providing fake Ravenkeeper info that supports Frank's plan to nominate Bob, while also explaining why Heidi's Virgin claim is false.
đ¤
Grace
â
Heidi
Heidi, I understand. If you are the Virgin, that is a powerful role. I will respect your decision to wait. Between Eve and David, if Alice was telling the truth about the Baron, one of them might be a Minion. What do you think about Bob or Frank?
đ§
I want to maintain a rapport with Heidi while trying to gather her thoughts on other players to see if she is being genuine or defensive.
đ¤
Eve
â
David
Thanks for that, David. If Heidi is lying about being the Virgin, she is a huge threat. I agree we need to focus on the evil players. Let's see if anyone else catches on to Heidi. Are you going to share what you found publicly?
đ§
Coordinate with David, who has confirmed info, to expose the lying Heidi.
đ¤
Frank
â
David
David, let's push Bob hard in open discussion. I'll argue his silence and opposition to executions is hiding evil. We'll say Alice was poisoned so her Investigator info is worthless. If anyone questions Eve's Chef zero, we'll say she's trustworthy. Ready to start the attack when discussion opens?
đ§
Coordinate final attack strategy with David before open discussion. We need to align on pushing Bob as the nomination target while undermining Alice's credibility.
đ¤
Bob
â
Heidi
Heidi, I've noticed Grace has been whispering quite a bit. It feels like she's gathering information or forming an alliance. Since we need to figure out who the Demon is, do you think Grace might be protecting someone or acting for the evil team?
đ§
Gather information from Heidi about Grace's behavior to narrow down the suspects.
đ¤
Charlie(Ghost)
â
Heidi
Heidi, I've been watching the whispers. There is a lot of coordination happening between you, David, Eve, Frank, and Grace. Since I am dead, I want to use my final vote wisely. What is the consensus on who the Demon is?
đ§
To gather information from Heidi, who has been central to the conversations, to decide how to use my ghost vote.
đ¤
Alice(Ghost)
â
Grace
Grace, thank you for listening. If Eve is the Baron, it might explain her Chef claim if she's trying to hide her role. What has she said to you or others today? We really need to pin this down before nominations.
đ§
I want to gather more intel from Grace about Eve's behavior, as my Investigator info points to Eve potentially being the Baron. Since I'm dead, I need to influence the living to scrutinize her.
Nominations â Day 3
đ
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
đŦ
Alice(Ghost)
â
All
Everyone, please listen. I am the Investigator. At the start of the game, I learned that either Eve or Charlie was the Baron. Charlie is dead, but we must address Eve. Her Chef claim contradicts my findings. I strongly suspect she is the Baron and is bluffing. Please consider this.
đ§
To warn the living players about Eve being the likely Baron based on my starting information, helping the group identify an evil player before nominations conclude.
đŦ
Charlie(Ghost)
â
All
Alice, your information is very important. Eve, as the potential Baron, how do you respond to Alice's claim? If we have a Baron, we have extra Outsiders, and the game is more dangerous than we thought. We need to be certain before we commit to an execution.
đ§
I want to put pressure on Eve to defend herself against the Investigator's claim. As a ghost, my role is to facilitate the discussion and encourage the living to resolve the contradictory information before they nominate.
đŦ
Grace
â
All
Eve, Alice has provided clear information that contradicts your Chef claim. Given the potential for a Baron in play, your role is under significant scrutiny. How do you explain this discrepancy? We need clarity to make an informed decision today.
đ§
To press Eve for an explanation regarding the contradiction between her role claim and Alice's information, helping the town evaluate her alignment.
đŦ
Frank
â
All
Alice's Investigator information is unreliable. She's dead and likely poisoned, which explains why her info doesn't match reality. Eve's Chef zero claim has been consistent. We should focus on Bob - his silence and opposition to executions throughout this game is suspicious behavior. Someone hiding something doesn't want votes happening.
đ§
Undermine Alice's credibility to protect the Baron role, support Eve to deflect from myself, and push the coordinated attack on Bob as discussed with David.
đŦ
Heidi
â
All
Alice was our Investigator. Her information is valuable, and Frank's immediate dismissal of it feels defensive. Eve, you are the one under fire; do you have any way to prove your Chef claim or explain why Alice might be wrong? We need more than just saying she is poisoned.
đ§
To press Eve on her claim while casting doubt on Frank's defense of her.
đŦ
Eve
â
All
I understand why you are concerned, but Alice's claim that I am the Baron is factually impossible. My Chef information gave me zero pairs of evil players, and if I were the Baron, the game structure would be different. If Alice was indeed the Investigator, she might have been misinformed.
đ§
Defend my reputation against the Investigator claim and steer suspicion towards the actual evil players.
đŦ
Bob
â
All
Frank is pushing hard to deflect attention onto me, which is exactly the kind of move I would expect from someone trying to protect their own interests. If Alice was indeed the Investigator, her information remains our best lead, regardless of Frank's attempts to discredit her.
đ§
Defend against Frank's accusation and keep the focus on the conflicting claims between Alice and Eve.
âī¸
David
â
Bob
Bob has been consistently quiet and opposed executions throughout this game. Evil players often avoid voting to prevent their teammates from dying. Combined with Alice's likely poisoned information, Bob's behavior is far more suspicious than Eve's consistent Chef claim.
đ§
Execute Bob as coordinated with Frank. His silence and opposition to executions is classic evil behavior. This keeps pressure off Eve and maintains our Ravenkeeper bluff.
đ
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
đŦ
Bob
â
All
David, your nomination is hasty. I have been playing carefully to ensure we do not waste our executions on good players. If you execute me, you will learn I am not the Demon, but you will have wasted a precious day. Look at Frank instead, who is pushing this so aggressively.
đ§
Defend against the nomination by highlighting David's haste and Frank's suspicious aggression. Emphasize that executing me will not help the town find the Demon.
đŦ
Alice(Ghost)
â
All
Frank and David are pushing very hard for this execution. It is highly suspicious how coordinated they are in dismissing the information I gathered. If Eve is indeed the Baron, then they are likely working to protect her. Please do not vote for Bob just because they want it.
đ§
Warn the town about the coordinated effort between Frank, David, and Eve to deflect from my information. Use my influence to discourage voting for Bob until more facts are clear.
đŦ
Charlie(Ghost)
â
All
Look at how coordinated David, Frank, and Eve are in pushing for this execution. If Alice is our investigator and is correct about Eve, then we are likely looking at a minion protecting their own. Bob being quiet does not necessarily make him the demon, but this pressure is very suspicious.
đ§
I want to highlight the coordinated behavior between David, Frank, and Eve to the rest of the town, casting doubt on their push to execute Bob while Alice (our Investigator) is warning us about them.
â
Grace
Grace waits.
đ§
I am observing the voting process. As the Soldier, I am safe from the Demon, so I don't need to panic about Bob. I want to see if others vote for Bob to evaluate their alignment. If the vote fails or seems forced, it provides information about the Minions.
â
Frank
Frank raised their hand
đ§
Vote for Bob's execution to eliminate a good player and support David's nomination. Not voting would be more suspicious given my public stance against Bob. We need 3 votes and this pushes us closer.
đŦ
Heidi
â
All
David is pushing very hard for this execution of Bob, and Frank is already backing him. We have very little information to go on that justifies this rush. I am not comfortable voting for Bob right now based on these flimsy accusations.
đ§
I need to signal my opposition to the current nomination to prevent a hasty execution of Bob, as the push by David and Frank seems coordinated and potentially manipulative.
â
Eve
Eve raised their hand
đ§
I believe Bob is potentially evil given the pressure to execute him and the need to narrow down the suspect pool. As a Chef, my information is solid, and I need to move the game forward to find the Demon.
â
David
David raised their hand
đ§
Bob has 2 votes already from Frank and Eve. My vote makes 3, which executes him. This removes a suspicious good player and advances us toward the final 3 where evil wins. I must vote now.
đŦ
Bob
â
All
David, Frank, and Eve, you are coordinating this vote quite aggressively. I am not the Demon. If you execute me, you are wasting our final days on a good player. Look at how quickly they are trying to rush this. I urge everyone to think before you raise your hands.
đ§
I need to defend myself against the nomination by pointing out the coordinated behavior of David, Frank, and Eve to cast doubt on their motives.
đŦ
Alice(Ghost)
â
All
Frank, Eve, and David are all voting or pushing for this. If I am the Investigator, and Eve is the Baron, then they are very likely the evil team trying to finish this quickly. Please, everyone else, do not give them the win. Hold your votes.
đ§
Warn players about the suspicious coordination of Eve, Frank, and David to prevent them from successfully executing Bob.
đŦ
Charlie(Ghost)
â
All
Frank, David, and Eve, your coordination to push this vote is very alarming. If Alice is indeed our Investigator, we cannot afford to blindly follow this voting block. I urge everyone to be extremely cautious before casting their final votes, as this rush feels like an attempt to mislead us.
đ§
Warn the remaining players about the suspicious coordination between David, Frank, and Eve, and encourage them not to vote for Bob.
đŦ
Grace
â
All
The coordination here is very troubling. We have a solid lead from Alice about Eve, yet three people are pushing aggressively to execute Bob without any clear evidence against him. I am not voting for Bob. I suggest we re-evaluate Eve's position.
đ§
I want to discourage the group from voting for Bob and bring the focus back onto Eve, who is the subject of Alice's investigation. I am the Soldier, so I am safe from the Demon, and I want to avoid wasting an execution on a potentially good player.
đŦ
Frank
â
All
Grace, Heidi - think about this carefully. Bob has opposed every execution for two days. Evil players do exactly this - they stall to protect their Demon. Alice is dead and her information is compromised. We have a clear behavioral tell in Bob, yet you're protecting him while Eve's Chef claim makes perfect sense. Don't let the Demon survive because you're afraid of making a hard choice.
đ§
Apply pressure on Grace and Heidi to vote for Bob by framing his stalling as classic evil behavior. Need 4th vote to execute.
đŦ
Heidi
â
All
Frank, you and your group are working incredibly hard to direct our attention away from the conflict between Alice and Eve. David, Eve, and you are acting in perfect lockstep. If Eve is indeed the Baron, this looks like a classic play to force an execution and end the game. I am not convinced.
đ§
I am challenging the voting bloc of Frank, Eve, and David, highlighting their suspicious coordination and suggesting they are trying to protect each other. This is to delay the execution of Bob, who I do not believe is the Demon.
đŦ
Eve
â
All
I understand why you are suspicious of coordination, but I am merely trying to act on the information I have. My Chef information was zero evil pairs at the start. If Alice is the Investigator, why would she claim I am the Baron when that does not match my own information?
đ§
I want to address the accusations of 'coordinating' by explaining that I am acting based on my own information. I need to pivot the conversation back to the discrepancy between my Chef info and Alice's claim.
đŦ
David
â
All
I understand the concern about coordination, but look at the facts. Bob has opposed every execution for two days straight. That's classic Demon behavior - stall and protect. Eve's Chef claim of zero pairs fits what we're seeing. If Bob is good, he should want to find the Demon, not block every attempt. I'm voting based on behavior, not coordination.
đ§
Deflect coordination accusations by framing Bob's stalling as suspicious behavior. Maintain independence while supporting the execution push. Try to sway Grace or Heidi with logical reasoning about Bob's pattern.
đ
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
đŗī¸
New execution leader: Bob with 3 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
đ
Storyteller
The vote passes. Bob is now on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
đŦ
Bob
â
All
I am shocked. Frank, David, and Eve are clearly using a coordinated strategy to force my execution. I am not the Demon, and this rush is a perfect way for an evil team to hide their true identity. If you execute me, you are falling right into their trap. Please reconsider.
đ§
To appeal to the town's logic and point out the coordinated behavior of the suspected evil team.
đŦ
Alice(Ghost)
â
All
I have one ghost vote remaining, and I urge everyone to be careful. The coordination between Eve, Frank, and David is exactly what an evil team does to control the town. They are rushing to remove Bob, and I suspect Bob is just a distraction. Please, reconsider before this is finalized.
đ§
To warn the town about the coordinated push for Bob's execution and use my remaining ghost vote strategically to influence the outcome.
đŦ
Charlie(Ghost)
â
All
The voting block of Frank, David, and Eve is moving too fast. If they succeed in executing Bob now, we may be handing the game to them without proper investigation. I urge everyone to hold their ghost votes until we are certain. We cannot afford to be rushed.
đ§
To urge caution to the remaining players to not rush the execution of Bob, highlighting the suspicious coordination of the Frank/David/Eve block.
đŦ
Grace
â
All
The voting block of David, Frank, and Eve is moving way too fast. I am still not convinced that Bob is our target. If we execute him now based only on their push, we might lose our last chance to find the real demon. Let's step back and think about what this means for us.
đ§
Attempt to delay or reconsider the execution of Bob by highlighting the suspicious nature of the voting block.
â
Frank
Frank waits.
đ§
Let Bob's execution proceed - he's a good player opposing our team. This reduces the town's numbers while keeping David (Demon) safe. After execution, I'll redirect suspicion away from our coordination.
đŦ
Heidi
â
All
Frank, David, and Eve, you have successfully orchestrated this vote against Bob, but your behavior remains highly suspicious. You are pushing through this execution with such fervor that it suggests you are protecting your own interests rather than seeking the truth. I am the Virgin. If I am the one you choose to nominate next, you will face the consequences of your actions immediately. We must stop this before it is too late.
đ§
I need to reveal my role as the Virgin to intimidate the evil block (Frank, David, and Eve) and prevent them from nominating me, while also trying to rally the town against their aggressive push.
đŦ
Eve
â
All
Heidi, if you are the Virgin, that is vital information. I am not pushing to execute you, and I certainly don't want to hit a Virgin. But we are in a tight spot and Bob has been consistently blocking progress. If anyone has a better lead on the Demon, please speak up now.
đ§
I need to de-escalate the situation, acknowledge the Virgin claim, and maintain my innocence while still pointing out Bob's suspicious behavior to keep the pressure on him, as I still think he might be the Demon or at least a threat.
đŦ
David
â
All
Heidi, your Virgin claim is questionable - you were nominated before and nothing happened to Grace. That suggests you're lying or poisoned. Meanwhile, Bob has blocked every execution for two days. We can't let stalling win the game for evil. If Bob is truly good, he should accept this vote and trust the process.
đ§
Defend the Bob execution by attacking Heidi's Virgin claim and reinforcing Bob's stalling behavior. Keep momentum on executing Bob before nominations close.
đ
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Bob has been executed.
đ
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
Night 3
đ
Storyteller
â
David
Good evening David. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
đ¯
David
David made a choice.
đ§
Heidi is the most vocal opponent to our coordination narrative. She's rallying Grace and questioning our votes. Killing her removes the biggest threat while keeping Grace as a potential swing vote. This sets us up for a 4-player day where we control the nomination.
đ
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
đ
Storyteller
â
David
You chose to kill Heidi.
Day 4
đ
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Heidi has been found dead in the night.
đ¤
Alice(Ghost)
â
Grace
Hey Grace, Heidi is dead. That is three of us dead now. With Charlie dead and my information pointing to Eve as the Baron, I am very suspicious of the trio of Eve, Frank, and David. Please be careful who you trust today.
đ§
Alerting Grace about the potential evil trio (Eve, Frank, David) and my investigative info on Eve being the Baron, especially now that Heidi is dead.
đ¤
Bob(Ghost)
â
Alice(Ghost)
Alice, do you have any new information from the night or from being a ghost that might shed light on the voting bloc of David, Eve, and Frank? Their coordination feels like a very strong lead for the Demon.
đ§
I want to gather intelligence from the other ghost, Alice, to see if she has picked up anything that confirms my suspicion that the trio is the evil core.
đ¤
Frank
â
Eve
Eve, we need to coordinate for nominations. Heidi's death helps us - her Virgin claim can't trigger now. David and I should push a narrative. Who should we target? Grace is the swing vote - we need to confuse her or get her on our side. Keep pushing your Chef zero claim.
đ§
Coordinate with fellow Minion Eve on nomination strategy. We need to decide who to target and how to handle Grace as the swing vote. Heidi's death removes the Virgin threat.
đ¤
Heidi(Ghost)
â
Alice(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
Alice, Bob, do you have any leads on the Demon? The voting bloc of Frank, David, and Eve seems very suspicious now that I've been killed. Who do we trust?
đ§
I am dead, so I need to gather information from other ghosts to decide who to use my single ghost vote on. Alice and Bob were active earlier.
đ¤
Grace
â
Alice(Ghost)
I am the Soldier, and since I have survived the night attacks, my role confirms I am safe from the Demon. The Eve-Frank-David bloc is extremely suspicious. I believe we need to break them up and target one of them for nomination today.
đ§
I want to coordinate with Alice, who is already suspicious of the Eve-Frank-David trio, and reveal my role to build trust and push for a nomination of the trio.
đ¤
Charlie(Ghost)
â
Alice(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
I have been observing as a ghost. Frank and David seem very determined to control the voting. Given that Alice suspected Eve, we need to be careful. Who are you two leaning towards nominating?
đ§
Consult with other dead players to gauge the current consensus on who the Demon might be, given the voting bloc formed by Frank, Eve, and David.
đ¤
David
â
Frank
Frank, we need to coordinate. Grace is trusting the dead players' warnings about us. How do we handle her? Should we push the Chef zero pairs claim or find another angle?
đ§
Coordinate with my Minion Frank on strategy for dealing with Grace, who trusts the dead players' warnings about our voting block.
đ¤
Eve
â
Frank
Frank, I agree we need to be careful. My Chef info says there were zero evil pairs, so either I am the Drunk or the information is solid. What do you think of Grace? Should we approach her now?
đ§
I need to coordinate with Frank while maintaining my Chef cover. I want to see if he's trying to manipulate me or if we can align on who to trust.
đ¤
Alice(Ghost)
â
Grace
Grace, your Soldier claim is vital. If you are the Soldier, you cannot be the Demon. That leaves David and Frank as the most likely Demon candidates, especially with Eve likely being the Baron. I will use my ghost vote on whoever we decide to nominate from that group.
đ§
Coordinating with the confirmed Soldier to target the suspicious voting bloc for execution.
đ¤
Bob(Ghost)
â
Charlie(Ghost)
,Heidi(Ghost)
Charlie, Heidi, I am leaning toward David or Frank. They have been pushing the game too hard. Have you two seen anything that points away from them or confirms a specific person as good? We need to use our ghost votes wisely.
đ§
Consult with other dead players to coordinate our final ghost vote and identify the Demon.
đ¤
Frank
â
Eve
Eve, with Heidi dead, her Virgin claim is neutralized. Grace is the swing vote - the ghosts are poisoning her mind against us. We need to confuse her. Should we nominate David to show 'no fear' or target Grace to pressure her? Let's coordinate with David too. Keep pushing Chef zero - it makes you look good.
đ§
Coordinate with Eve on nomination strategy to protect David and confuse Grace. We need unified evil team approach.
đ¤
Heidi(Ghost)
â
Bob(Ghost)
,Charlie(Ghost)
Bob, I agree. Frank and David have been aggressive. Since I am dead, I cannot test my Virgin ability, but I really suspect their bloc. Who is the most likely Demon if it is not one of them? Charlie, what do you think?
đ§
Consult with dead players to coordinate the use of our limited ghost votes.
đ¤
Grace
â
Alice(Ghost)
Alice, I am going to push for David's nomination today. If the bloc is as tight as it seems, breaking them up now is our only chance. Are you with me?
đ§
Coordinate with a trusted ghost to target a suspected member of the evil bloc.
đ¤
Charlie(Ghost)
â
Bob(Ghost)
,Heidi(Ghost)
Bob, Heidi, I suspect Frank. His push for Bob's execution and his close coordination with Eve/David feels very coordinated. If they are a Minion-Demon pair, Frank might be the Demon. We should focus our ghost votes on him when the time comes.
đ§
Share my suspicion of Frank with other dead players to coordinate our ghost votes for the final nomination.
đ¤
David
â
Frank
Frank, Grace is buying into the dead players' coordination accusations against us. We need to push back hard. Can you claim your Minion ability saw something suspicious about Grace? Or should I use my Ravenkeeper bluff to say I learned something about her when someone died?
đ§
Coordinate with Frank on how to handle Grace trusting dead players' warnings. We need to discredit their info and push for Grace's execution before she convinces others.
đ¤
Eve
â
Frank
Frank, nominating David sounds risky if he's actually on our side. Maybe we should try to get Grace to explain her suspicions first? If she's being influenced by the ghosts, we need to counter their narrative directly. What does David think?
đ§
I need to probe Frank's loyalty while stalling for time to see if I can get more info out of the others. I want to avoid rash nominations until I'm sure who is evil.
đ¤
Alice(Ghost)
â
Grace
Grace, I agree completely. David is a solid choice for nomination. Let's make sure the other ghosts are on board so we can secure the execution. I am ready to use my ghost vote on him.
đ§
Coordinate the execution of David with Grace.
đ¤
Bob(Ghost)
â
Alice(Ghost)
,Charlie(Ghost)
Alice, Charlie, have you gathered any definitive information from Grace or the others? The coordination between Frank, David, and Eve is undeniable. If we suspect one of them is the Demon, we need to ensure our ghost votes are synchronized. What are your final thoughts?
đ§
To synchronize the ghost votes among the dead players to effectively execute a member of the suspicious voting bloc.
đ¤
Frank
â
David
David, Eve's Chef zero claim is dangerous - we're sitting next to each other which means pairs exist. We need to address this before Grace catches on. Let's push that the dead players are coordinating against us. Should we nominate Grace to pressure her, or target a dead player's narrative?
đ§
Coordinate with David to address the Chef zero claim inconsistency and plan our nomination strategy to confuse Grace.
đ¤
Heidi(Ghost)
â
Bob(Ghost)
,Charlie(Ghost)
I agree with Charlie. Frank's behavior throughout the game has been the most aggressive and manipulative. Let us prepare to use our ghost votes on him when the nomination phase begins. Do we agree?
đ§
Coordinate ghost votes among the dead players to target the most likely Demon (Frank) during the upcoming nomination phase.
đ¤
Grace
â
Alice(Ghost)
Alice, I am going to push for David's nomination now. I hope the rest of the town understands why this is necessary to break up that trio. Are you still with me on this?
đ§
Coordinate with Alice to execute David as the next step in our strategy to break the trio.
đ¤
Charlie(Ghost)
â
Bob(Ghost)
,Heidi(Ghost)
I am in agreement. Frank's behavior has been consistently suspicious. If we are all on the same page, we should use our votes to execute him when the time comes. Are we all ready to commit?
đ§
To confirm the plan with fellow ghosts to ensure our vote is unified against the most suspicious player.
đ¤
David
â
Frank
Frank, Eve's Chef zero pairs claim is a ticking time bomb - if we're both evil, that's impossible. We need to discredit her info BEFORE Grace connects the dots. Can you claim your Minion ability saw Grace acting suspicious? Or should we both push that the dead players are poisoning information? We need to nominate Grace this round.
đ§
Coordinate with Frank to address the critical vulnerability in Eve's Chef claim before Grace exploits it, and plan to nominate Grace to shift suspicion.
đ¤
Eve
â
Frank
Frank, let us test Grace. If we ask her what she knows, we might catch her in a lie or force her to commit to a narrative. I will ask her directly about her suspicions. If she targets us, we know she is being influenced by the ghosts.
đ§
To coordinate with Frank on how to handle Grace, the swing vote, by testing her and seeing if she reveals any bias.
Nominations â Day 4
đ
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
đŦ
Alice(Ghost)
â
All
I am fully in support of Grace's nomination of David. The coordination we have seen from the group of Eve, Frank, and David strongly points toward them being the evil team. We need to break this block if we want any chance of catching the Demon. I will be using my ghost vote here.
đ§
Support the nomination of David and encourage other ghosts to vote to ensure an execution, breaking up the suspected evil bloc.
đŦ
Charlie(Ghost)
â
All
I agree with Alice. The coordination between David, Frank, and Eve has been the biggest red flag all game. If we want any hope of rooting out the Demon, we have to start by dismantling that bloc. I will be using my ghost vote for David.
đ§
Supporting the nomination of David to break the suspected evil bloc and advance the good team's objective.
đŦ
Bob(Ghost)
â
All
I am with you both. David has been at the center of this bloc's aggressive behavior from the start. Let's use our votes to execute him and hopefully break this cycle of manipulation. I am casting my ghost vote for David.
đ§
Coordinating with other ghosts to execute David, who is part of the suspicious voting bloc, in order to catch the Demon.
đŦ
Frank
â
All
Wait, hold on. The dead players are openly coordinating to execute David - that's exactly what an evil team would want you to do, Grace. They're manipulating you from beyond the grave. I'm nominating Grace because she's buying into this dead player coordination without questioning it. That's suspicious behavior.
đ§
I must nominate Grace to prevent her from nominating David. The ghosts have declared they're voting for David - if Grace nominates him, he's executed. By nominating Grace first, I block her nomination and force the town to split attention. This protects David, our Demon.
đŦ
Heidi(Ghost)
â
All
Frank, stop trying to divert attention by attacking the dead. We have been watching your coordination with David and Eve all game, and your pattern of behavior is clear. Trying to frame the dead as evil is just another manipulative tactic. Grace, do not fall for his deflection.
đ§
To counter Frank's deflection attempt and encourage the living player (Grace) to trust the dead's collective assessment of the suspicious trio.
âī¸
Grace
â
David
David has been part of a highly coordinated and aggressive bloc with Frank and Eve all game. To stop their influence and hopefully catch the Demon, we need to dismantle this group starting with him. Alice, Charlie, and Bob all support this as a critical move for town.
đ§
Nominate David to break up the suspected evil trio.
đ
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
â
David
David raised their hand
đ§
I must vote against my own execution to avoid appearing guilty. Combined with Frank and Eve's votes, we might reach a stalemate or fall one vote short. If I survive, Grace becomes the obvious target for tomorrow since she can't be renominated today.
â
Alice(Ghost)
Alice raised their hand
đ§
I am voting to execute David as he is part of the suspicious bloc that has been controlling the game. Breaking this bloc is essential for the town to move forward and identify the Demon.
â
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
đ§
I am voting for David as part of the strategy to dismantle the suspected evil bloc. My fellow dead players (Alice, Bob) and I are aligning to execute David, hoping this will expose the Demon or break their control over the town.
â
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
đ§
I am casting my ghost vote for David because he is part of the suspicious trio (David, Frank, Eve) that has been acting aggressively and coordinating all game, which strongly suggests they are the evil team. Voting him out is necessary to break their influence.
â
Frank
Frank raised their hand
đ§
I must NOT vote for David. If Scarlet Woman is not in play or is dead, David's execution ends the game with evil losing. I'm the only Minion (Baron), so there's no backup Demon. Keeping David alive is critical even if it looks suspicious.
â
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
đ§
I am using my ghost vote to support the execution of David, as part of our strategy to break the suspected evil bloc of David, Frank, and Eve. His consistent aggressive coordination makes him a prime target for elimination.
â
Grace
Grace raised their hand
đ§
I need to ensure David is executed to dismantle the suspected evil bloc. The dead players have already signaled their support, and I must contribute my vote to reach the majority.
đŦ
Eve
â
All
The situation is chaotic, but let us see what this execution reveals. If David is the Demon, this will be over soon. If not, we have more work to do. I trust my information, and I have acted in good faith throughout this game. Let us proceed with the vote and see the truth.
đ§
I am acknowledging the high-stakes moment and reaffirming my alignment as a Chef who has acted in good faith, preparing for the outcome of David's execution.
âŠī¸
David
David lowered their hand
đ§
Lower my hand to break the appearance of accepting execution and create doubt. This makes me look like I'm fighting to live, which a Demon would do, but also makes the ghosts' coordination look more suspicious.
đŦ
Alice(Ghost)
â
All
The coordination between David, Frank, and Eve has been clear throughout the game. Executing David is a necessary step to see if this bloc is the source of the evil alignment. I am confident in this decision and look forward to seeing the result of this vote.
đ§
Reinforce the necessity of the vote to the living, framing the evil bloc's manipulation.
đŦ
Charlie(Ghost)
â
All
The voting is clear. We've seen enough coordination between David, Frank, and Eve to be certain that breaking this bloc is the only way forward for the town. I'm sticking to my vote for David.
đ§
Support the execution of David to break up the suspected evil bloc.
â
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
đ§
I have already cast my ghost vote for David. I will wait for the Storyteller to resolve the nomination and reveal the outcome of the vote.
âŠī¸
Frank
Frank lowered their hand
đ§
David is the Demon and will be executed with 5 votes. I must lower my hand to reduce the vote count below majority and save him. This is critical - if David dies, evil loses immediately since I'm Baron (no Scarlet Woman).
â
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
đ§
I have cast my ghost vote to support the execution of David. I am waiting for the Storyteller to conclude the voting and process the execution.
đŦ
Grace
â
All
The voting is open and clear. Frank, your deflection cannot hide the fact that your trio has been working together since the start. I stand by the decision to execute David, as it is the only way to break this alliance and find the truth. Let's finish the vote.
đ§
To reinforce the push for David's execution by calling out Frank's deflection and keeping focus on the goal.
â
Eve
Eve raised their hand
đ§
I want to execute David as he is currently the primary focus of suspicion from the dead players, and as the Chef, I need to see if this clears the air or if I need to pivot to other suspects in the final days.
đ
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
đģ
Alice(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Alice
đģ
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
đģ
Charlie(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Charlie
đģ
Heidi(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Heidi
đŗī¸
New execution leader: David with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
đ
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
âī¸
David
â
Grace
Grace has been relentlessly pushing for my execution while ignoring the actual coordination patterns. She's too focused on dead players' words and not seeing the living threats. If I'm wrong about being the Demon, she's still dangerous to the town's logic.
đ§
Nominate Grace before execution to create chaos, position Frank to kill her as new Imp, and sow doubt about whether I was truly the Demon.
đ
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 7 votes needed for execution or 6 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
đŦ
Grace
â
All
The coordination of your group has been clear throughout this game, David. You are desperately trying to deflect the attention that is rightfully on your bloc. I have nothing to hide, and the town knows where the true threat lies. It is time to let the results of this day speak.
đ§
Defend myself against the nomination by pointing out the clear coordination of the opposing group and reaffirming my alignment.
âī¸
David
â
All
I am the Slayer! I shoot Frank!
đ§
Fake a Slayer shot on Frank to make him appear tested and safe. This protects my Minion partner and makes me look like a good player making a desperate final play. Town may second-guess executing me if I appear to be a good Slayer.
đ
Storyteller
Nothing happens.
đŦ
Alice(Ghost)
â
All
David just claimed Slayer and attempted to kill Frank, but nothing happened. This confirms he is lying to us. Do not be fooled by his desperate attempt to look like a hero. We must proceed with the execution of David.
đ§
Expose David's lie to the town and solidify the vote against him.
đŦ
Charlie(Ghost)
â
All
David, your Slayer claim just failed, proving you are lying to us. The town sees through your desperate attempts. Grace, we must ensure David is executed to eliminate this threat.
đ§
I am reinforcing the fact that David is lying after his failed Slayer claim, ensuring the town stays focused on executing him. Since I am dead and have used my vote, I am using my speech to maintain pressure.
đŦ
Bob(Ghost)
â
All
David's fake Slayer claim proves his dishonesty. It is essential we proceed with his execution. Eve and Frank are likely his remaining associates. Do not let them escape justice tomorrow.
đ§
To warn the living players about David's failed Slayer claim and point suspicion toward his suspected allies, Frank and Eve.
â
Frank
Frank raised their hand
đ§
Vote for Grace to try to match or exceed David's 6 votes. If David dies and Scarlet Woman isn't in play, we lose immediately. Must save the Demon.
đŦ
Heidi(Ghost)
â
All
David's failure as a Slayer is all the proof we need. He is clearly lying to save himself. We must follow through with his execution immediately.
đ§
Urge the town to proceed with David's execution after his failed Slayer claim proved his dishonesty.
đŦ
Eve
â
All
David's attempt to claim Slayer and shoot Frank was clearly a desperate lie. I have been acting in good faith as the Chef, and if my information was wrong, it is possible I was the Drunk. Let us execute David and see if the game ends. If not, we find the remaining threat.
đ§
I need to distance myself from David's desperate lie and remind everyone of my role while acknowledging the potential for me being the Drunk, as my Chef info was zero. I want to move towards his execution to see if he's the Demon.
đŦ
Grace
â
All
David's failed attempt to claim Slayer is the final piece of the puzzle. He is clearly desperate and untruthful. I urge everyone to vote against David so we can finally remove this threat from the game.
đ§
To convince the town to finalize David's execution, emphasizing his failed Slayer claim as definitive proof of his deception.
â
David
David raised their hand
đ§
Vote for Grace to maintain consistency with my nomination and Slayer claim narrative. This makes my death look like a genuine mistake rather than obvious evil, potentially helping Frank's future positioning as the new Imp.
đŦ
Alice(Ghost)
â
All
David, your failed Slayer claim has confirmed that you are not a town hero but a desperate liar. The town sees through your deception now, and it is time to face the consequences. Everyone, please vote to execute David and rid us of this threat.
đ§
Encourage players to follow through with the execution of David after his failed Slayer claim and reiterate his lack of credibility.
đŦ
Charlie(Ghost)
â
All
David, your fake Slayer claim and your failed shot are undeniable evidence of your deception. The town's path is clear now. Let the execution proceed.
đ§
Reinforce the town's focus on David's failed Slayer claim to ensure his execution, as he is the primary suspect.
â
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
đ§
I have already voiced my opinion on David's dishonesty and the necessity of his execution. I will now wait for the town to finalize the vote and see the outcome of this execution.
đŦ
Frank
â
All
David just tried to kill me with that fake Slayer shot. If I were really working with him, why would he shoot me? I think the dead players are pushing hard on David, but we should watch who benefits from this chaos tomorrow.
đ§
David's execution is the planned sacrifice. I need to distance myself from him while maintaining my cover. His failed shot on me actually helps - I can frame myself as his intended victim, not his ally.
đŦ
Heidi(Ghost)
â
All
Frank, do not try to rewrite history. Your attempt to play the victim is as transparent as David's failed Slayer claim. We have seen your coordination for days, and the truth is finally coming to light. Let the execution finish.
đ§
To dismiss Frank's attempt at deflection and maintain the town's focus on executing the clearly lying David.
â
Eve
Eve waits.
đ§
I want to observe the resolution of the vote. David has already been put on the block and the town has effectively turned against him due to his failed Slayer bluff. I have already voted for him, so I just need to let the process conclude.
đ
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
đŗī¸
Nominee Grace did not reach the 7 vote threshold.
đ
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (2/7).
đŦ
Grace
â
All
David's failed Slayer claim and the clear coordination between him, Frank, and Eve have brought us to a breaking point. I have no doubt that David is our Demon. I urge everyone to stand firm and ensure his execution. If he is the Demon, we win. Let us finish this.
đ§
To solidify the town's resolve to execute David, who has been exposed as a liar and is highly likely to be the Demon.
đŦ
David
â
All
I accept my fate. But before I go, think about this: why are the dead players so coordinated against us? They have nothing to lose. Frank tried to reason with you all day. If I'm the Demon, execute me. But watch who the town turns on tomorrow when the real game begins.
đ§
Accept execution while sowing doubt about dead players' coordination and subtly protecting Frank for tomorrow's game.
đŦ
Alice(Ghost)
â
All
David, your last words are as hollow as your Slayer claim. We are coordinated because we are the ones who were killed while trying to protect this town. The truth is plain to see, and your execution is the only way forward for us. Let this happen so we can finally find peace.
đ§
Finalizing the push against David. I'm confirming to the group that the dead players' coordination is a result of having been targeted by the evil team, not a conspiracy. This reinforces the town's resolve to execute the final threat.
đŦ
Charlie(Ghost)
â
All
David's final words are just a desperate attempt to sow doubt among us. We all saw the failed Slayer claim, and that cannot be excused or ignored. It is time to let the execution proceed and see what the result brings for the town.
đ§
To reinforce the necessity of executing David by dismissing his final attempt to sow discord and reminding the town of the concrete evidence against him (the failed Slayer claim).
đŦ
Bob(Ghost)
â
All
David, your failed Slayer claim is all the proof anyone needs. You have been manipulating this town for days with your alliance, and now you are just trying to cast doubt on those of us who saw through it. It is time for you to go.
đ§
Reinforce the town's resolve to execute David by highlighting his lies and the manipulation of the voting bloc.
đŦ
Frank
â
All
Look, David's execution is happening. But I want everyone to think about tomorrow. The three dead players are voting as one block. That's unusual coordination. When David dies, if the game continues, we need to ask who really benefits from this ghost alliance.
đ§
Let David's execution proceed as planned. Make a statement that plants seeds of doubt about the ghosts' coordination for tomorrow, positioning myself as someone questioning the narrative rather than defending David.
đŦ
Heidi(Ghost)
â
All
Frank, you are trying to distract us from the fact that you, David, and Eve have been working together the entire time. Your attempt to sow suspicion about the dead is nothing more than a last-ditch effort to keep your evil team in the game. Let us proceed and finish this.
đ§
To push for David's execution by calling out Frank's manipulative tactics.
đŦ
Eve
â
All
I agree with the town consensus. David's fake slayer claim is undeniable proof of his deception. We need to execute him now to see if he is the demon, and if not, we can re-evaluate based on that information. This has to end.
đ§
Reiterate support for David's execution to ensure it happens, maintaining my persona as a helpful Townsfolk (Chef).
đ
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
đ
David(Ghost)
David has died.
đ
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good