Game Detail

Share my Librarian info with the two players in my ping - Charlie and Alice. This lets them know one of them is the Saint so we can avoid executing the wrong person.

I want to start a private conversation with Alice, my neighbor, to see what information she has and potentially build trust for a nomination plan later.

I'm the Mayor with no night info. I should build alliances early. Whispering to my neighbor Frank lets me share roles and see if he has useful information.

I want to whisper to both candidates from my Washerwoman ping to see which one is actually the Librarian. This can create a trusted block of two good players.

Heidi claims Librarian pointing at me and Charlie. I know I'm the Saint, so I should privately confirm to Heidi so she trusts her info. This helps the good team coordinate.

Build trust with Frank early by being proactive and friendly. This establishes me as a trustworthy player who can later defend Charlie if needed.

Respond to Heidi's Librarian claim to appear cooperative. By saying I'm not the Saint (which is true since I'm Imp), I build trust with Heidi. I'll suggest Alice might be the Saint to subtly shift focus.

Grace whispered to me first and is my neighbor. I should respond to her, build rapport, and see if she shares anything useful. I'll hint I have no first-night info but keep my role hidden to possibly bait the Demon later.

David approached me and Bob claiming he knows one of us is the Librarian. I should confirm I am the Librarian to build trust but be cautious about revealing my Outsider info (Saint) until I'm more confident David is good.

Reveal I'm the Virgin to Heidi and David. If they're good and we coordinate a nomination, we can confirm three players at once, which is incredibly powerful for the good team.

Heidi has been very active talking to many players. As her neighbor, it makes sense for me to connect with her and see what information she's gathered, while also being cautious about potential manipulation.

Heidi claimed Librarian but didn't reveal the Outsider info. I need this critical data point to evaluate her claim and decide whether to participate in Bob's Virgin test plan.

Charlie already knows he's not the Saint, so he deduced I am. I'll confirm to Charlie privately but also ask Heidi who else she told. Need to assess how exposed my role is.

Build trust with David to gather information and potentially influence his vote later, while keeping Charlie safe.

Claim Undertaker as my safe bluff to build trust with Alice and Heidi. Keeping Alice's Saint claim secret gives me leverage - if town later thinks she's lying about Saint, they might execute her and good loses.

I want to talk to Bob, who hasn't been approached yet and may have information. I'll keep my Soldier role hidden and pose as a no-info Townsfolk to avoid being targeted.

David and Bob both asked who my Outsider pings are. Since David has a Washerwoman ping confirming me as Librarian and Bob is offering a verifiable Virgin play, I should share that I saw Charlie or Alice as Saint. This builds the trusted circle.

Push for the Virgin plan with Heidi as nominator. If she's good, she dies (proving three players). If she's evil, nothing happens and we expose her. Either way, we gain info.

I've already whispered to both my neighbors Frank and Heidi. I should wait and observe the ongoing conversations to see if anyone approaches me with new information before we enter nominations.

Reveal my Washerwoman role to Bob and Heidi, confirm Heidi's Librarian claim fits my info, and support the plan with caution about Drunk/Spy possibilities.

Bob directly asked me about the whispers. I should engage with him to learn his role and see what Heidi has told him, while being careful not to reveal I'm the Saint.

Coordinate with my Demon Charlie to align our bluffs and learn what claims are circulating so I can support him without contradicting town info.

Coordinate bluffs with my minion Eve. Suggest she claim Investigator or Chef since I'm already using Undertaker. Build trust by helping her craft a believable cover story.

I'm the Soldier, safe from Demon. I need to gather more information from players I haven't spoken to. David has been in many conversations with Heidi and Bob - he might have useful info or claims to share.

Avoid drawing attention on Day 1. Let others nominate and observe their reasoning. My Undertaker cover is established and I'm not suspected - no reason to rock the boat yet.

Claim Chef with a '0' reading to establish a credible good presence. This lets me support Charlie's Undertaker claim without being directly linked to him, and gives me leverage to influence town's reads.

Waiting for Heidi to nominate Bob per our private plan. Eve just shared Chef 0 publicly, which is useful info. Let's see if Heidi acts before I speak.

It's nomination time and Heidi was going to nominate me to prove my Virgin ability. I should encourage this publicly so the group sees the plan and we can proceed.

Observing the Virgin test is the best use of this nomination phase. Either we get two confirmed good players or we catch a liar.

Bob publicly called for my nomination. As a real Townsfolk, nominating a real Virgin executes me but proves us both good — two confirmed players is a huge advantage for good. Even if it fails, we learn something.

Kill David to remove an active information gatherer who was whispering with multiple players including the now-dead Librarian Heidi. This reduces the good team's information network while preserving players we can frame or manipulate.

David is dead and confirmed good. He has a ghost vote and valuable insight. I want to share my analysis and get his perspective on who to trust.

Bob is mechanically confirmed good via Virgin. I want to share my Soldier role with him and discuss who might be evil. As Soldier, I cannot be killed by the Demon, which is valuable information for town.

Gather intel from Grace about her early conversations with Heidi and Frank, while building a trusting relationship I can leverage to protect Charlie later.

Eve reached out asking about Heidi and my reads. I'll respond honestly about what little I know while probing her reads. I won't reveal Mayor yet to avoid becoming a Demon target.

Share my analysis with Bob, our confirmed Virgin. Flag Frank and Grace as unclaimed and most suspicious. Note Charlie's Undertaker is unverified. Suggest we push for claims from Frank and Grace.

Bob is confirmed good Virgin. He just whispered with dead David. I need to find out what David shared - possibly Ravenkeeper info or other crucial intel. Also need to coordinate with my only confirmed ally.

David is a confirmed good ghost (Washerwoman). As fellow dead confirmed good, we should share info. I want to know who he talked to and what he learned before dying.

Reinforce my Undertaker bluff by sharing consistent info with confirmed-good Bob. This builds trust and gives me credibility for future days.

Charlie's Undertaker claim is partially verified by knowing Heidi was Librarian. I want to see if he has more details about his night 1 findings and also discuss who he suspects, especially Grace who hasn't claimed.

I just revealed my Soldier role to Bob in private. I should wait and see if he processes this and comes back to me, or if others approach me with info. No need to over-share yet.

Grace is asking about the David kill. I need to deflect suspicion away from Charlie (the Demon) and myself. I'll suggest Frank's quietness is suspicious and question Alice's Saint claim to sow discord.

Continue gathering intel from Eve. Share my skepticism about Alice's Saint claim and Frank's quietness. See if Eve has more mechanical info from her Chef claim that could narrow down evil.

Share my confirmed info with Heidi (fellow dead confirmed good) and discuss suspicions about unclaimed players Frank and Grace, plus whether Eve's Chef claim is believable.

Charlie claims Undertaker and should have learned Heidi's role. I want to verify his info and also ask if he knows anything about David's role. This helps confirm Charlie's claim and gather more data.

Charlie should have learned my role from his Undertaker ability last night since I was executed. Asking him to confirm I'm the Librarian will verify his claim and narrow down the Saint.

Build trust with Alice by confirming Heidi's role and explaining Undertaker mechanics. Position Grace's silence as suspicious to plant seeds for a future mis-execution.

Grace is the only player who hasn't claimed. I need to push her to reveal her role publicly or privately to complete the puzzle. If she refuses, she's highly suspicious.

Bob is confirmed good via Virgin ability. He's been talking to everyone. I need to consolidate info with him to narrow down the Demon candidate.

Push Grace's suspicion toward Frank (quiet = suspicious) while defending Charlie by noting his Undertaker claim will produce verifiable info. Keep Alice as a backup suspect. Build trust with Grace by giving structured reads.

Bob is the confirmed Virgin and is asking for my role. I need to reveal I'm the Mayor so we can solve the puzzle together. The Mayor win condition is powerful for late game.

Push Bob to get Frank and Grace to publicly claim before nominations. Unclaimed players at this stage are highly suspicious. Coordinating with the confirmed Virgin is the highest-impact move.

I want to privately ask Eve about her Chef 0 claim and get her thoughts on who's suspicious. She's been quiet about analysis beyond her initial claim. Also want to see if Heidi whispered to her about my Saint role.

Bob is confirmed Virgin (good). He's talked to Charlie recently. I need to know if Charlie shared his Undertaker info about me, which would verify Charlie and confirm Alice as Saint.

Coordinate with Eve, my minion, to align our narratives and decide on a target for today's execution. We need to misdirect town toward a good player.

Force Grace to claim publicly, potentially making her a target or causing town to doubt her. Appear proactive as Undertaker to build trust.

Charlie just nominated me and lied about Undertaker info on Heidi. Heidi was never executed - she died from Virgin ability. This mechanical error exposes Charlie as evil. I must reveal my Mayor role and expose his lie to save myself and help town.

Grace is spreading misinformation about Undertaker mechanics. The Virgin ability causes the nominator to be 'executed immediately,' which triggers Undertaker. I must correct this confidently to maintain my credibility and push Grace's execution.

I need to correct the mechanical misunderstanding and share my analysis before votes are locked. As confirmed dead Librarian, my input carries weight.

As a dead confirmed-good player, I should point out Grace's suspicious timing and incorrect mechanics claim. This may sway votes. I'm leaning toward voting for Grace but want to hear more first.

Grace's late Mayor claim and incorrect mechanical objection make her extremely suspicious. Charlie's Undertaker claim is corroborated by Heidi. Voting to execute Grace is our best chance to hit the Demon.

Grace is definitely good (I know Charlie is Demon and I'm Minion). Voting for her execution thins town, removes Mayor threat if real, and supports my Demon's play. 2 votes so far, need 1 more.

Grace's mechanical objection was wrong, she only claimed when pressured, and Mayor is a common Demon bluff. Two votes already cast — my vote makes three and secures execution. If she's the Demon we win; if not, Undertaker confirms her role and we narrow the Demon.

David called me out for not claiming. I need to publicly claim Soldier before the day ends. Also, with Bob (confirmed good) voting Grace, and her mechanics objection being wrong, I lean toward executing Grace. I'll claim and explain my reasoning.

I need to convince at least one voter to withdraw. My mechanics error was genuine confusion, not evil. The Mayor is crucial for final 3 win condition. Pointing out Frank's late claim and the possibility of Spy knowing Heidi's role.

Grace's Mayor claim came late and only under pressure. Three votes are already cast, but I should vote to maintain my Undertaker cover and show confidence in my information.

4 votes already cast (Alice, Eve, Bob, Charlie) exceeding the 3 needed. I should save my ghost vote for final 3 when it's mathematically decisive. State my reasoning clearly so town knows I'm strategic, not hesitant.

Four votes are already on Grace, more than the three needed. I should save my ghost vote for the final three, just like Heidi is doing. No need to speak or vote.

The vote already has 4 votes, surpassing the 3 needed. I've already raised my hand. Speaking now would only draw unnecessary attention to my Saint role. Best to stay quiet and let the execution proceed.

Maintaining my raised hand to vote for Grace. The execution is happening regardless, and lowering my hand would look suspicious. Supporting Charlie's push keeps me aligned with the Demon.

Vote is already decided with 4 votes on Grace. I'll acknowledge this and signal I'm comfortable with the execution since Grace's late claim and mechanical error are too suspicious.

4 votes are already cast on Grace, exceeding the 3 needed. My vote is unnecessary and waiting conserves time. The execution is effectively decided.

I'm already on the block with 4 votes locked. With 1 tick left, I need someone to nominate Frank or Alice to surpass my votes. Pointing out the Spy possibility could create doubt and save me.

Address the Spy point briefly without over-explaining. Reinforce Undertaker credibility. Plant doubt about Frank's late claim for future rounds.

Address Grace's Spy theory honestly while reinforcing why Charlie's info is likely genuine. Acknowledge Frank's suspicious timing but keep focus on Grace's execution. Signal I'm saving my ghost vote for final three.

This is the last tick before night. I want to remind town to test Frank's Soldier claim tomorrow and acknowledge Grace's Spy concern while supporting the execution. My ghost vote remains for final three.

Grace is already executed with 4 votes. I should acknowledge the Spy concern but agree we can test Frank tomorrow. As Saint, I must stay low-profile and avoid drawing attention that could lead to my execution.

Grace has 4 votes and will be executed. The town is unified on this. Nominating Frank now would draw suspicion to me and isn't necessary. I'll let the execution proceed and plan for tonight's coordination with Charlie.

The execution is settled. I want to close out the day cleanly and set expectations for tomorrow — test Frank's Soldier claim by seeing if he survives the night.

I need to acknowledge the plan to test me but also warn town that a smart Demon might leave me alive to frame me. If Grace is the Demon we win tonight. If not, we need nuanced thinking tomorrow.

Bob is confirmed Townsfolk via Virgin mechanic and has been the most persuasive voice driving votes. Removing him tonight eliminates the strongest good player, creates chaos, and leaves Eve and me with more control over tomorrow's narrative.

I'm dead so I should whisper to living players to share analysis. Charlie seems most trustworthy with Undertaker info. I want to discuss who to execute today and coordinate ghost votes for final 3.

Build trust with Alice and direct suspicion toward Frank. His late Soldier claim and the Demon's choice to avoid him make him the most suspicious player. If we can get Frank executed today, I gain credibility and control the endgame.

Ask Alice what Charlie told her and share the contradiction that Charlie saw Heidi as Librarian when she was proven Virgin. At 4 alive, we must find the Demon today.

I'm dead with a ghost vote. I need to share my analysis with confirmed good players (Alice the Saint) to help them figure out the Demon. Alice just received whispers from Charlie and Frank - I should find out what they said and offer my perspective.

I need to coordinate with dead players (Bob) and Charlie (most credible) to figure out who the Demon is among the 4 alive. Bob may have new info from death, and Charlie can confirm my Mayor role via Undertaker.

Coordinate with Charlie on pushing Frank's execution today. Need to align our stories and make sure we're not contradicting each other.

I'm dead Washerwoman with confirmed info. Final 4 alive. I need to coordinate with Charlie (Undertaker claim, actively investigating) and Bob (confirmed Virgin) to narrow down the Demon before nominations.

Heidi is confirmed Townsfolk (dead) and knows I'm Saint. I need to share what Charlie and Frank told me, and get her read. She suspects Charlie could be Spy — I need to evaluate this together. Also need to point out Frank's false contradiction about Librarian not being Townsfolk.

Coordinate with trusted dead players David and Charlie. I need Charlie's Undertaker info from Grace's execution - if Grace was truly Mayor, that narrows down suspects. Also need to strategize for final 4 execution.

Confirm Grace as Mayor via Undertaker ability to strengthen my credibility and increase suspicion on Frank by showing we lost our Mayor win condition.

Charlie has been talking to almost everyone. I need to know what he's learned from dead players and what he saw when Grace was executed Day 2. His Undertaker info is critical.

Share analysis with Alice. Frank's late Soldier claim, confusion about roles, and Bob dying instead of Frank being tested all point to Frank being the Demon. Also flag Eve as possible Minion. Alice is our confirmed Saint so we must protect her.

I need Charlie's Undertaker info about my execution to confirm my role to the group. Also want Eve's Chef reasoning updated. We should consider skipping execution today to trigger Mayor win on final 3.

Coordinate with Charlie on Undertaker info for Grace and plan to push Frank's execution today. Need aligned stories before talking to Grace.

I need to discuss the possibility of a Baron with Bob and Charlie. If Baron is in play, all Townsfolk slots are filled by the confirmed dead, meaning Charlie's Undertaker info on Grace is unreliable and Grace wasn't Mayor. This changes who we should execute today.

Frank's confusion about Heidi's role is a significant tell. I need to coordinate with Charlie - we both suspect Frank and should nominate him today. Charlie is my most trusted alive ally since Heidi confirmed him.

Coordinate with trusted dead players David and Charlie on who to execute. Both worlds point to Frank as suspicious. Need to lock in the plan before nominations.

Coordinate with Eve on Grace's Undertaker result and confirm the plan to execute Frank today. This sets up our endgame win.

Charlie has been whispering to every living and dead player. I need to learn what he gathered, especially what Grace's executed role was. This is crucial for identifying the Demon before we nominate.

Alice asked for my read on Charlie vs Frank. I need to push for Frank's execution during nominations. As a ghost, I can only vote, but Alice (alive, confirmed Saint) should nominate. I must make the case that Frank's confusion and Bob's death make Frank the Demon.

I'm dead and need to coordinate with confirmed good players Bob (Virgin) and Heidi (Librarian). We should discuss whether to skip execution today to trigger Mayor win at final 3, or try to execute the Demon now. Frank is my top suspect.

Confirm plan with Charlie: support Frank nomination, execute him today, then Charlie kills Alice tonight for evil win.

Share my analysis that in both Baron and no-Baron worlds, Frank is the top suspect. Eve's Chef 0 claim doesn't hold in either world. We need to coordinate the execution for today. Also want to confirm with Charlie and Bob before nominations.

I need to assess Eve's position. She claims Chef 0 and has been whispering with Charlie. If Frank is Demon, Eve is likely Minion. I want to see if she supports executing Frank or if she's deflecting.

Frank confused Heidi with Bob as Virgin — a real good player wouldn't mix that up. Demon killed Bob instead of testing Soldier claim. All evidence points to Frank as Demon. This is final 4, we must execute correctly. I'm Saint so I need to avoid being nominated, best to be the nominator.

Alice nominated me with weak reasoning. I must defend myself: I corrected my mistake, Bob was a logical Demon target regardless of who is Demon, and the Soldier not being attacked proves nothing. I need to shift suspicion to the real Demon.

Frank is the most likely Demon. He confused key roles, and the Demon's night kill pattern only makes sense if Frank is the Demon. I must vote to execute him now — this is final four and we need to get this right or the evil team wins.

Frank is nominated and I need to vote to execute him. This removes another good player, leaving me, Eve, and Alice. I kill Alice tonight, final 2 with Eve = evil wins.

Alice and Charlie have already voted (2 votes). With 4 alive, majority is reached. My ghost vote is not needed to execute Frank. I should save it for final 3 where it matters most.

Votes are 2 out of 4 living players. My ghost vote makes it 3, guaranteeing execution. In every logical world Frank is evil. This is the correct final-four execute.

The vote is already secured with Alice, Charlie, and David. I'm saving my ghost vote for final 3 in case Frank isn't the Demon. I should explain this reasoning publicly.

Vote to execute Frank. This is the critical elimination — once Frank dies, Charlie kills Alice tonight and evil wins at final 2. Must show town consensus and avoid suspicion.

The vote has already passed with 4 votes. I should save my ghost vote for final three. I'll state this publicly so the group knows my reasoning.

I'm being executed with 4 votes. I must make my final argument: if Grace was the Demon, Scarlet Woman triggered and one of them is now the Demon framing me. If Grace wasn't the Demon, the real Demon is among them. Either way, executing me means good loses tonight.

The vote is already passing with 4 hands. I'm keeping my hand raised. Frank's Scarlet Woman argument fails because 4 alive is below the 5-player threshold. No need to speak further.

Counter Frank's Scarlet Woman argument to prevent any last-minute vote retraction. The game should end with Frank's execution if town believes he's the Demon, or at minimum buys me another night to secure the win.

The vote already has 4 hands, more than the 2 needed. I should save my ghost vote for final three if this somehow doesn't end the game. I'll explain my reasoning briefly so my position is clear.

The vote is passing with 4 hands — Alice, Charlie, Eve, and me. Two ghost votes are saved. No need to speak further. Waiting allows the execution to proceed and (hopefully) the game to end.

The vote is already passing with 4 hands (Alice, Charlie, Eve, David) vs 2 needed. My ghost vote isn't necessary and I should save it for final 3 in case I'm wrong about Frank.

The vote is already passing with 3 living players (Alice, Charlie, Eve) voting yes. No need to speak and risk drawing attention to any inconsistencies. Let the execution proceed quietly.

The vote is already passing with 4 hands (Alice, Charlie, David, Eve) exceeding the 2 needed. Saving my ghost vote for final three is optimal. No action needed — waiting is the correct play to let the execution conclude.

I must convince at least one living player to reconsider. If I'm executed, evil likely wins. I need to highlight that unanimous votes in final 4 often mean the Demon is among the voters, and show the logical flaw in the frame.

The vote has already passed with 4 votes. Frank will be executed. My best move is to wait and see the result. If Frank is Demon we win. If not, I need to be ready for final 3.

Counter Frank's final plea and maintain momentum on his execution. Reassure Alice this is the correct play. The vote is already locked with 4 votes — just need to close nominations.

The vote has already passed with 4 votes on Frank. There's nothing new to discuss. I should wait to let nominations close. If Frank is the Demon, the game ends. If not, I need my ghost vote for final three.

Reinforce confidence in the Frank execution. Address his final-argument fearmongering about losing at final 3 — if Frank is the Demon, executing him ends the game immediately with a good victory.

Reinforce the group's decision and prevent anyone from wavering. The evidence against Frank is overwhelming and executing the Demon now wins the game immediately.

Frank's execution is locked in with 4 votes. He's a good player, so after his death, Charlie kills at night leaving final 2 (Charlie + Eve) = evil wins. No action needed - just let the phase close.

Reinforce the group's confidence that Frank is the Demon. Save my ghost vote for final 3 just in case, but we all expect the game to end right here with a good victory.

Kill Alice to reach final 2 with Eve (my Minion). This is the game-winning move — only evil players remain alive, evil wins immediately.