Game Detail

Choose Bob as my master since he's my neighbor, making it easier to coordinate during the day and ensuring I can vote if he does.

It's Day 1 with no information yet. I should wait to hear others' claims before revealing my Virgin role, so I can use it strategically later.

Start building trust with my neighbors Charlie and Eve. Share that I'm a Townsfolk with a useful ability, but keep the exact role vague for now to avoid Demon targeting or poisoning.

Coordinate quietly with the Imp early, share the real board, and help him choose a safe bluff while avoiding the Virgin trap.

Share my Librarian information with Alice to start building trust and gathering information. I need to find out who else has useful intel.

Build credibility with an early safe bluff and collect Bob's claim, while keeping my demon identity hidden and avoiding any risky public attention.

Start gathering information from my neighbor Frank, who has already been whispering with Heidi. Building trust early is crucial for a Mayor to survive and help the team win.

Share my Empath information with Bob since he's claiming to be the Librarian. My N0 read of 0 evil neighbors confirms Bob is good, so I can trust him with my information.

Engage with David and Eve to build trust and gather information without revealing my Butler role too early. I want to understand what David knows while staying cautious.

Engage with David and Charlie to build trust and gather information without revealing my Virgin role yet. I want to see what they know before committing to any alliance.

Build trust with my neighbors Charlie and Eve while gathering information. Stay vague about my specific role for now since Ravenkeeper is valuable to keep hidden, but encourage them to share what they know about others.

Create a believable good persona with Eve, subtly confirm her role, and build trust I can exploit to influence executions away from Frank.

Share my Librarian info with Frank since he's one of the two I learned about. I need to see his reaction to gauge if he's lying about being Chef.

Build trust with Bob using my Chef bluff, nudge suspicion toward Charlie as Butler, and keep flexibility if claims conflict later.

Wait to see how conversations develop and gather more information before making any claims or taking action. Early Day 1 is about building trust networks.

I've shared my info with Bob and he's shared his Librarian claim with me. My Empath read confirms Bob is good. I should wait to see what other information emerges before the nomination phase.

Continue building trust with David and Eve while gathering information about the other players. I need to understand who Bob is since he's my master for voting purposes.

I want to probe Heidi's Washerwoman claim without confirming my role. If she's telling the truth, I can potentially trust her. If she's lying, I want to catch her in inconsistencies before revealing anything sensitive.

Continue building trust with Charlie and Eve while gathering more information about their abilities and the suspicious whispering cluster Charlie identified.

Strengthen credibility with Eve using a consistent Washerwoman bluff, gain her trust, and keep suspicion away from Frank while opening the door for more private info.

I need to talk to Charlie directly to hear his claim. If he claims Butler, it confirms Frank is Chef. If he claims something else, I need to reassess.

Build trust with Grace early using a consistent Chef bluff and Bob's info, while subtly steering suspicion toward Charlie instead of me or Heidi.

I want to verify Frank's claims by hearing directly from Bob. If Bob confirms he's Librarian and saw Butler, I can start building trust networks.

I need to connect with Heidi, my other neighbor who my Empath read confirms is good. Sharing information with her will help build a trusted alliance and gather more intel before nominations begin.

Confirm to Bob that I am the Butler since he already suspects it. This builds trust with a potential good player and helps coordinate.

It's Day 1 and I don't have enough information to nominate anyone yet. I should wait to see how nominations develop and gather more information before acting.

It's Day 1 and I don't have enough information yet. I should wait to see who nominates and observe the patterns before making any moves. Revealing my Virgin status too early could make me a Demon target.

Share my Empath information publicly to help the town. My zero read on neighbors is valuable confirmation that Bob and Heidi are good, which validates Bob's Librarian claim.

Share that Charlie confirmed he's the Butler, which validates my Librarian information and Frank's Chef claim. This helps establish a good foundation for the town.

I need to question the convenient cluster of claims from the Bob-Frank-Alice-Grace network. Their information is very coordinated and clears each other. I should point out this suspicious pattern.

Use Alice's public clear to make me look safe, strengthen the trusted chain around Frank, and cast David as the source of needless disruption without overcommitting.

As Mayor, I want to avoid executions since my win condition requires no execution at final 3. I should express measured skepticism without revealing my role, encouraging caution before we rush to nominate anyone based on unverified claims.

Sound calm and reasonable, answer Grace indirectly, defend my bluff, and encourage no execution so evil keeps numbers and flexibility.

Remove a credible public info source, break the town's early trust web, and avoid dangerous kills into Ravenkeeper or possible Mayor complications.

Bob has been mechanically cleared by Alice's Empath read and his Librarian information matches my actual role. Sticking with him as my master ensures I can vote tomorrow if he votes, and he's the most trustworthy player based on available information.

Share my suspicion about Frank's lie with David. Frank claimed I told him my Librarian info, but I only told Charlie. This inconsistency suggests Frank is evil.

Wait to see what Bob and David discuss, and gather more claims from remaining players before making any moves.

I want to observe how Bob's whisper to David plays out and see more of today's discussion before revealing my role. Information is still developing.

I need to acknowledge Bob's revelation about Frank's lie and discuss what this means for the coordinated claims we've been seeing. This contradiction is significant.

I'm dead with one ghost vote. I should observe today's discussions before committing my vote. Need to hear claims and see who seems suspicious.

Coordinate with Frank before open discussion so we present a consistent story, preserve his Chef bluff, and redirect suspicion away from our cluster.

Wait to see what information emerges from the whisper exchanges before committing to a position. Need to observe who shares what publicly.

Coordinate with Heidi so we preserve my Chef bluff, avoid overcommitting, and steer suspicion toward David without making our team look too synchronized.

Respond to David's question about Frank's potential collaborators and share my suspicion that Frank may be working with Grace or is simply fabricating credibility for his false claim.

I need to share my Butler confirmation with someone outside Bob's circle to get independent verification. David seems suspicious of Bob's group, so I'll share my perspective with him.

I need to start engaging and building trust. David has been skeptical of the claim chain, so I'll whisper to him privately to share my role and gauge his reaction. This helps me determine if his skepticism is genuine good play or evil disruption.

Eve claims Virgin confirming Heidi's Washerwoman. I need to probe this claim and understand the full picture before nominations begin. I want to see if her claim holds up and how it connects to other information.

As a dead Empath with confirmed good neighbors, I should share my information with Bob who I know is good. I want to coordinate with him and understand what he's learned from his Librarian claim and the whispering activity.

I want to extract what David is telling Bob and subtly frame David as the disruptive voice, while preserving my bluff as a cautious good player.

I need to understand David's suspicions better. He's challenging the dominant claim network, and as Mayor I need to figure out if he's genuinely suspicious or if he's a Minion trying to disrupt good coordination. Talking to him directly will help me assess his alignment.

Reinforce my Chef bluff with Bob and gently steer his suspicion toward David without sounding forceful, preserving my cover and setting up a mis-execution.

Confront Frank directly about his lie regarding the Librarian info. This contradiction is provable and needs to be addressed before nominations begin.

I need to gather more information from David about what Bob has been telling him in their extensive whispering. David seems suspicious of coordination, and I want to understand what claims are being made behind closed doors.

Answer David's questions truthfully to build trust. Confirm Heidi claimed Virgin specifically, and that he's the first I've told. This helps us coordinate against the suspicious claim cluster.

Share Bob's accusation against Frank with Charlie to gauge his reaction and see if he defends Frank or shows concern. This helps determine if Charlie is truly Butler or coordinating with an evil team.

Whisper to Heidi, my other confirmed-good neighbor, to share information and coordinate. I know she's good from my Empath read, so we can trust each other and compare notes on who to suspect.

Alice trusts me from Empath. I can use that trust to direct her ghost vote and public suspicion toward David, shielding Frank and our existing claim chain.

I need to gather more perspectives to break the deadlock between the two competing theories. Eve has been in David's whisper cluster but also connected through Bob's claim, so she might have useful insights.

Defuse Bob's concern with a believable explanation, preserve trust, and keep the town focused away from me and toward David if possible.

I need to share my observations publicly to advance the discussion. The whispering patterns are concerning, and I should contribute to figuring out who the Demon is.

Deflect Eve's broad suspicion into a demand for concrete worlds, especially from David, while protecting Frank by framing our cluster as coherent rather than coordinated.

As Mayor, I need to help good find the Demon while staying alive. I want to hear David's actual theory since Heidi challenged him. I should encourage concrete claims over vague suspicion.

Share my perspective as dead Empath, explain why I was targeted, and pressure David to provide concrete alternatives or face my ghost vote.

Highlight the contradiction between Bob and Frank's statements. If Bob only told me the Librarian info, then Frank is lying about receiving it, making Frank the prime suspect.

Support Charlie's callout of Frank's lie. Frank's admission of 'misspeaking' doesn't explain inventing a private conversation. Push Frank to explain why he specifically claimed I told him privately when I only told Charlie.

I am under direct pressure. Nominating David turns the discussion onto his weak theory and gives town an alternate execution target that helps me survive.

The Frank-Bob contradiction is fresh and needs investigation. Voting for David now would be premature when we have a clear mechanical discrepancy to resolve. I want to see how this vote plays out and push for answers on the contradiction.

David is a good target for evil. Voting helps remove a suspicious voice and backs Frank's push while keeping attention on the fabricated contradiction.

Heidi is confirmed good by Alice's Empath read and she voted for David. Alice also suspected David. While Frank's claim is suspicious, David's lack of concrete theory combined with good players voting for him suggests David is the evil one.

I need to use my ghost vote wisely. David has been suspicious without offering concrete alternatives, and Heidi (who I know is good) doesn't trust him. Frank's lie about Bob is also suspicious, but David's behavior as a whisper nexus casting doubt without a clear theory is concerning. I'll vote for David to pressure him and see where the chips fall.

I need to highlight the Bob-Frank contradiction and explain why I trust Bob more. This contradiction is key to finding evil players.

I need to explain why I'm not voting for David. Frank's lie about our private conversation is much more suspicious than David's lack of a theory. I should point the group back to Frank's fabrication.

I nominated David; voting is consistent and may secure a useful execution before the fabricated-conversation issue becomes the day's focus.

I need to defend myself against execution and explain my suspicions. I should address the criticism that I haven't offered a concrete theory while highlighting Frank's demonstrable lie as the more pressing issue.

I need to voice my suspicion of Frank's fabricated conversation and explain why I'm not voting for David yet. The mechanical contradiction between Bob and Frank is more concrete evidence than David's lack of a theory.

Protect Frank by minimizing the conversation discrepancy and making David's late full claim look opportunistic enough to keep votes on him.

Frank fabricating a private conversation is more suspicious than David's delayed claim. I should lower my hand to prevent executing David while Frank's lie goes unexamined.

Frank inventing a private conversation with Bob is active deception. While David's late claim is suspicious, Frank's behavior is more clearly indicative of evil. I should lower my hand and let the town focus on Frank's lie rather than executing David now.

I need to highlight that Frank's lie about the private conversation is the most concrete evidence we have. Bob's Librarian claim is mechanically confirmed. I'm not voting for David because Frank's fabrication is more suspicious than David's late claim.

I need to explain why I'm not voting for David and redirect the town's focus to Frank's fabricated conversation, which is the bigger red flag than David's vagueness.

Try to rescue the David execution by owning the wording mistake quickly and refocusing the group on David's convenient late theory and lack of earlier mechanics.

I need to solidify my defense and explain why my delayed claim makes sense as Ravenkeeper - I was trying to bait the Demon into killing me at night so I could use my ability. Frank's active fabrication is worse than my strategic silence.

I need to address Heidi's claim about me being Virgin and share my perspective on Frank's lie versus David's claim. This will help determine which world we're in.

Defend my bluff, muddy Eve's reveal, and prevent the group from settling on Frank as the obvious evil before night.

Frank has been caught in a direct lie about a private conversation that never happened. This is constructing false evidence, not misspeaking. I need to nominate him now while we have the chance, as this is the strongest mechanical evidence of evil behavior we've seen.

Frank invented a private conversation that never happened - this is mechanical evidence of evil behavior, not messy wording. I need to vote to execute him.

Protect Frank by discouraging votes and reframing the case as premature tunnel vision, while sounding like a cautious good player.

Frank's fabrication of the private conversation with Bob is mechanical evidence of dishonesty. Bob only told Charlie, so Frank's claim is impossible. This is stronger evidence than David being vague. I need to vote for Frank.

Frank's fabrication of a private conversation with Bob is mechanical evidence of evil intent, not just messy wording. This is exactly what a Minion would do to validate a fake claim. I should use my ghost vote to execute him.

I cannot vote because Bob (my master) is not voting. I need to explain this mechanical restriction while clarifying that Frank's fabricated conversation is still highly suspicious.

Frank invented a private conversation with me that never happened. This is constructing false evidence, not a misspeak. I must vote to execute him.

Create doubt on a just-barely-passing wagon and encourage at least one raised hand to drop by reframing this as a weak social execution, not a solved mechanical case.

Frank invented a private conversation with Bob that never happened - that's constructing false evidence, not a misspeak. Bob's Librarian claim is mechanically confirmed by identifying Charlie as Butler. Executing Frank removes a likely Minion and helps us find the Demon.

Address Heidi's concern about my timing and reinforce that Frank's fabricated conversation is mechanical evidence of evil behavior, not just messy wording. Solidify the case for executing Frank.

Protect Frank by undermining confidence in this execution and recasting the case as too narrow and too convenient, without tying myself too hard to him.

Reinforce that Frank's invented conversation is mechanical evidence of evil, not just messy wording. Address Heidi's concern about rushing to certainty by explaining why this is solid evidence.

As the dead Empath who confirmed Bob is good, I need to reinforce that Frank's fabricated conversation is mechanical evidence of evil, not a misspeak. My ghost vote supports executing Frank.

Frank already has 5 votes which exceeds the 4 needed. Bob is my master and has raised his hand, so I can legally vote. Adding my vote reinforces the execution and demonstrates I'm following Butler mechanics properly.

I have already voted for Frank. The mechanical evidence is clear - Frank invented a private conversation that never happened. This is constructing false evidence, not a misspeak. I will wait for the vote to complete.

Last chance to create doubt, maybe peel a vote, and if I die leave a divided board instead of a clean solve on Heidi or an unquestioned good chain.

Push back on Frank's deflection tactics and encourage final vote. His fabrication is mechanical evidence of evil behavior regardless of whether he's Minion or Demon. Removing him advances good team's win condition.

Address Frank's attempt to cast suspicion on me and Heidi. Explain why my Virgin confirmation timing was standard protective play, not selective. Solidify that Frank's fabrication is mechanical evidence of evil, not a misspeak.

Create a competing wagon to try to save Frank, while using the public Heidi-Eve contradiction and Virgin claim as plausible cover for the nomination.

Defend against Heidi's nomination by explaining standard Virgin play and questioning why she's trying to save Frank who was caught in a mechanical lie.

Vote Eve to pursue the only line that could still save Frank and to maintain consistency with my public push that Eve should be tested.

Frank's invented private conversation is mechanical proof of evil behavior. Voting for Eve would tie the vote and potentially save Frank. I should not vote and let Frank be executed based on the solid evidence against him.

I need to remind the living players that Frank's mechanical lie is proven evidence of evil. They should not vote for Eve, as Frank is the confirmed execution target. A tie means no execution, which helps evil.

Explain I cannot vote due to Butler restriction (Bob isn't voting), and reinforce that Frank's mechanical lie proves he's evil. We should not tie the vote.

Frank has 6 votes and will be executed. Voting for Eve could create a tie and prevent Frank's execution. I should wait and let Frank be executed for his mechanical lie.

I cannot save myself mechanically, so I want my execution to create doubt and stop the town from treating my death as confirmation of David, Eve, or the current solve.

Prevent a tie vote that would save Frank. Encourage others to keep hands down so Frank's execution proceeds as planned.

Convince remaining players not to vote for me so Frank's execution goes through. Heidi's nomination is a transparent attempt to save a caught evil player by creating a tie.

I want to maximize the chance of a tie on Eve to save Frank, while also seeding doubt for tomorrow if the tie fails.

Frank is caught in a mechanical lie about private conversations. Voting for Eve risks tying the vote and letting Frank walk free. I should wait and let Frank be executed.

Reinforce that no one should vote for Eve. Frank has 6 votes and will be executed, which is correct. A tie lets a confirmed liar walk free. I need to counter Heidi's attempt to save Frank.

Reinforce that we should not tie the vote. Frank has 6 votes and must be executed. Voting for Eve risks letting Frank walk free.

Do not vote for Eve to avoid tying the vote. Frank has 6 votes and will be executed, which is correct. He was caught in a mechanical lie about private conversations. Let the execution happen.

My only path to survive this day is to help force a tie on Eve. Raising my hand is necessary and may encourage any wavering player to join.

Reinforce that Frank's vote for Eve is desperate self-preservation. Keep hands down, let execution proceed. Heidi's nomination timing is suspicious - trying to save confirmed liar.

Frank's execution is secured with 6 votes. The mechanical proof against him is solid. I should wait and let the execution proceed without interference.

Plant doubt before night so Frank's execution does not fully solve the board, and position myself as a cautious good voice rather than a partner.

Confirm Frank's execution is correct based on mechanical evidence, flag Heidi's suspicious attempt to save him, and prepare for tomorrow's investigation if game continues.

Confirm Frank's execution is correct based on mechanical evidence, and flag Heidi's suspicious attempt to force a tie and save Frank. Prepare town for tomorrow's hunt.

Frank is already set to be executed with 6 votes. The phase is ending. No need to act - let the execution proceed.

Frank is already being executed with 6 votes. Day is ending. No need to act further - let the execution proceed and prepare for tomorrow's investigation of Heidi and David.

My execution seems locked. I should leave a final narrative that prevents town from solving cleanly and protects Heidi by spreading suspicion onto David and Eve.

Acknowledge Frank's execution, warn against blind trust of the 'confirmed' cluster, and position myself to either survive for late game or bait the Demon into killing me tonight.