Game Detail
Players
Alice (Saint) Bob (Soldier) Charlie (Fortune Teller) David (Butler) Eve (Slayer) Frank (Baron) Grace (Drunk) Heidi (Imp)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 158,046 | 105,600 | $0.0844 |
| Good | 460,792 | 40,116 | $1.3680 |
Event Transcript
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You are the Minion. The Demon is Heidi.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Minions are: Frank. Your safe bluffs are: Chef, Empath, Mayor
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Librarian. Either Alice or Heidi is the Butler.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
π―
Charlie
Charlie made choices.
π§
Get an early binary result on two socially central players to start building an elimination map and set up follow-up checks to identify the red herring.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You chose Bob and Grace. You receive the answer: NO.
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
David
David made a choice.
π§
With no info, pick a likely active voter so I keep maximum voting flexibility on day one, then reassess after hearing claims.
π
Storyteller
β
David
You chose Alice to be your master.
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
π€
Eve
β
David
,Frank
Hey, quick check in. What role are you claiming, and did you get any starting info last night? I am happy to share what I have after I hear yours.
π§
Start day one by getting early role claims and info from my neighbors, cross-check for contradictions, and keep my Slayer identity hidden for now.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Heidi
Hi Bob and Heidi, quick check in. What role are you claiming, and did you get any starting info? I am happy to share a light claim back, but I want to hear yours first.
π§
Get early claims and info from my neighbors without revealing I am the Saint, then cross-check for consistency before nominations.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
,David
Hey Eve and David, good to chat. I am the Chef, and there are zero pairs of evil players sitting next to each other. So no adjacent evils. What about you? Eve, you mentioned sharing yours.
π§
Bluff Chef (start info role) to appear good, claim 0 evil pairs to calm town/avoid immediate suspicion. Reciprocate to extract their claims/info for evil team use or disruption.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Bob
Hi Alice and Bob. I am claiming Chef, and I start knowing there is one pair of evil players. What roles are you two claiming, and any starting info?
π§
Early Day 1, respond to Alice's whisper to her+Bob. Claim safe Chef bluff with '1 pair' (fits known evils) to seem good, gain their claims, build credibility.
π€
David
β
Eve
,Frank
Hey both. I am a low info role, so I did not get starting info last night. Frank, thanks for the Chef zero adjacent evils, that is useful. Eve, what did you get, and who does it point at?
π§
Give a safe bluff, get Eveβs claim/info to build logic chains, and keep Butler hidden to avoid becoming an easy execution target.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Heidi
Hey, quick private check. I have starting info that either you or the other (Alice or Heidi) is the Butler. What are you planning to claim, and have you heard anything that points to an Outsider?
π§
Privately identify which of Alice or Heidi is the Butler, so we can coordinate votes, confirm outsider count, and narrow evil candidates early.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Heidi
Hey. I am happy to give a light claim for now: I am an info Townsfolk, likely Fortune Teller. No info yet since we have not had a night. Heidi, your Chef one is useful, it suggests the two evils are probably sitting next to each other. Any early reads on which adjacent pair feels off?
π§
Respond with a light bluff that baits a Demon kill onto me and keeps my real Soldier role hidden, while encouraging them to use the Chef info to focus on adjacent-pair logic.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,David
Hey, quick check in. I have a piece of night info that points away from Bob and Grace as the Demon, but I want to keep it quiet for now. What role are you claiming, and what info did you get on night zero?
π§
Start a tight info network early, compare starting info to my Fortune Teller NO, and decide who to test or push later while keeping my role semi-hidden.
π€
Eve
β
David
,Frank
Thanks. I am also a no starting info Townsfolk, I will say Soldier for now. Frank, if your Chef zero is true, it is really helpful, but I will not hard clear off it yet. David, can you narrow your role list at all, like are you an information role?
π§
Maintain cover as Slayer while acknowledging Chef info cautiously and push them to share clearer claims; build a small trust circle for later coordinated Slayer shot.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,Heidi
Grace, can you confirm what role you are claiming and exactly what your info said, like which two names and which Outsider? Heidi, Grace told me she has info that either you or I is the Butler, so we should track Outsider claims carefully.
π§
Clarify Graceβs exact claim and info source, while warning Heidi discreetly so we track Outsider count and avoid executing me later as Saint.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
,David
Hey Eve and David. David, low info no start info sounds like Slayer, Virgin, or Mayor maybe? Eve your Soldier claim fits well. My Chef zero really narrows things down.
π§
Build trust with chatty Eve/David (likely good) using Chef bluff to frame logic, learn David role narrowing, position Heidi safe while gathering info.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Grace
Hey Alice and Grace. Grace, thanks for sharing your info. I am the Chef, so I cannot be the Butler. That means you are the Butler, Alice. Grace, are you the Librarian? What role are you claiming?
π§
Solidify Chef bluff with neighbors. Deduce Alice=Butler per Grace info, planting doubt on Alice as potential evil/Drunk Outsy pretender. Distract good team early.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Alice
Hey. I am a low info role, no starting info. I am going to say Virgin for now, unless we need something else later. Charlie, can you tell me privately later what your info type is, even if not the exact names yet?
π§
Give a plausible low-info cover, keep Charlie engaged for his info, and start aligning with Alice since my voting is tied to her today.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Heidi
Yep, I am the Librarian. My exact N0 info: either Alice or Heidi is the Butler. Heidi, what was your Chef number? Alice, if you end up being Butler, we should quietly agree who you will pick at night so voting stays consistent.
π§
Confirm my real role and exact Librarian info, but keep it within this small circle. Probe Heidiβs Chef number and Aliceβs plan if Butler, to later coordinate and detect lies.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
,David
Hey both, quick check in. What role are you claiming and any starting info? Heidi is claiming Chef with a one, so if true it suggests the two evils sit next to each other. Any early reads on which adjacent pair feels off?
π§
Get Charlie and David claims and any first impressions, and quietly seed the Chef equals one adjacent evil pair info to help solve seating without outing Soldier.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,David
I am going to keep my exact role quiet for a bit, but I do have a night zero check that points away from Bob and Grace being the Demon. David, I can share my info type later. Bob, if Heidi is Chef one, which adjacent pair feels most likely to you right now?
π§
Answer their question without outing as Fortune Teller, share the Bob-Grace non-Demon result to reduce suspicion and steer discussion toward adjacent-pair analysis.
π€
Eve
β
Alice
,Charlie
Hey Alice and Charlie, quick private check in. What role are you claiming and did you get any starting info? I heard a Chef claim of zero adjacent evil, but I am keeping it tentative. I am currently claiming Soldier to avoid being sniped.
π§
Expand info net beyond David and Frank, compare starting info claims, and quietly seed Chef0 constraint while keeping my Slayer hidden for now.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,Heidi
I see the contradiction: Grace says one of me or Heidi is Butler, but Heidi claims Chef. Let us not lock that in yet. Grace, did your Librarian info explicitly say Butler, and were those exact two names? Heidi, can you confirm your Chef number was one? We should wait for another info check before pushing any Outsider world.
π§
Probe the Librarian-Chef contradiction without outing as Saint; keep heat off me from an early execution while steering town to verify claims via other info roles.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
,Grace
Hey Eve and Grace, my neighbors. Just to loop you in, I am the Chef with zero adjacent evil pairs. No two evils next to each other anywhere. Eve, you knew. Grace, what about you? Any info?
π§
Share Chef bluff with neighbors to build credible good alliance, probe Grace's role/align to detect threats near Demon, narrow info before noms.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
Hey Frank, I'm sticking with Chef bluff, 1 evil pair so probably one adjacent duo evil. What are you claiming? Empath or Mayor? My neighbors are Alice and Grace; if Empath you could read 0 or 1 evil there. Let's back each other's info.
π§
Whisper Frank (minion) to coordinate bluffs: him as Empath reading my neighbors Grace/Alice. Builds trust, supports Chef bluff, directs suspicion away from us before nomination.
π€
David
β
Bob
Hey Bob. I am currently soft claiming Virgin, so no night zero info. Heads up, Frank told me he is Chef with zero adjacent evil pairs, but you said Heidi is Chef with one, so we have a direct conflict. Also Charlie told me his night zero info points away from you and Grace being the Demon. What is your read on Heidi versus Frank?
π§
Resolve the conflicting Chef claims early by sharing my soft-claim and Charlieβs anti-Demon info, and get Bobβs read on Heidi versus Frank so town can focus suspects.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Hey Frank, I am the Librarian. My N0 info was exactly: either Alice or Heidi is the Butler. Heidi is claiming Chef to me. You also claim Chef zero, so we have a direct Chef conflict. Can you share who you have told, and do you think your info could be drunk or poisoned?
π§
Share my confirmed Librarian info with Frank, flag the double-Chef conflict, and get his read/plan so we can coordinate public info without overcommitting too early.
π€
Bob
β
David
Chef conflict is big. I told Alice and Heidi I was a light Fortune Teller claim. I lean Heidi over Frank for now since Frank is spreading opposite to multiple people. Can you ask Frank who else he told and if he will go public? If you are really Virgin, we can try a safe Townsfolk nom on you later to confirm.
π§
Resolve the Chef conflict by gauging Frank vs Heidi credibility and set up a public consistency check. Keep my Soldier hidden while coordinating with David for nominations and info sharing.
π€
Charlie
β
Eve
Hey Eve, I am staying under the radar for now, but I do have a night zero check that says Bob and Grace are not the Demon pair. Are you sure you heard a Chef zero? Heidi told some folks Chef one. Who exactly claimed what to you?
π§
Clarify the conflicting Chef rumor via Eve, keep my Fortune Teller hidden, and build a small trust circle to coordinate info and execution paths.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I will go public: I am the Librarian. My night zero info was exactly that either Alice or Heidi is the Butler. Also, I have heard two different Chef claims already, so we have a direct conflict there. Chef claimants, please state your number out loud.
π§
Get my Librarian info on the table and highlight the Chef conflict so town can choose a productive execution before nominations close.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Okay, we need the Chef conflict resolved in public. Heidi, you said Chef one, and I have heard Frank is claiming Chef zero. Frank and Heidi, please both state your number and who you have told. Grace, can you confirm your exact Librarian ping was Alice or Heidi as Butler?
π§
Force the conflicting Chef claims into the open and set up a clean logic fork for tomorrow, while keeping my own role low impact.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Grace and Bob, yes I am claiming Chef and my starting info is one pair of evil players. I privately told Alice, Bob, and Grace this already. If Frank is claiming Chef zero, then Frank is lying because there is only one Chef. Grace, please confirm the exact names in your Librarian info.
π§
Publicly defend Chef-1 claim I've whispered, call out Frank's conflicting Chef-0 as lie to paint him evil/Minion, sow chaos in info roles, disrupt good logic early while keeping my bluff intact for later survival.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I can confirm Frank told me he is the Chef and got zero adjacent evil pairs. Heidi is now publicly Chef one, so that is a direct conflict. Frank and Heidi, please each say your exact number and who you told, and Grace please restate your Librarian ping names.
π§
Force public clarity on conflicting Chef claims and push for a Day 1 execution on one claimant to gain leverage; avoid spending Slayer shot without strong demon read.
π¬
David
β
All
Grace, I need to jump in. I am actually the Butler, not Alice or Heidi. I chose Alice as my master today. So your Librarian info of Alice or Heidi being the Butler cannot be right unless you are poisoned or lying. Frank told me Chef zero earlier, for what it is worth.
π§
I must clarify the Librarian ping by coming clean as Butler, reducing misexecution risk and highlighting that Grace info is inconsistent, which helps narrow suspects for tomorrow.
βοΈ
Alice
β
Frank
I am nominating Frank. We have a direct Chef conflict: Frank is reported Chef zero, Heidi is Chef one. One of them is lying. Frank has not given a clear public account yet, and multiple people heard his Chef zero, so I want to pressure that by executing him.
π§
Push an execution on a high-contradiction slot that is not me, generate mechanical info, and stop town from executing me due to the Butler ping.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Day one, a hard info conflict exists and Frank is the nominee. I will vote to push an execution that forces clarity and creates accountability for the Chef and Butler claims.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Frank is central to the biggest mechanical conflict and has been privately pushing Chef zero. Day one execution gives us hard alignment pressure and likely hits evil or sets up a clear follow up tomorrow.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Everyone, hold on before voting for Frank. David claims he is the Butler and chose Alice as his master today, but the Butler chooses at night, not during the day. That timing makes no sense, so David is lying. The real issue is between Grace and David, so let's not execute Frank over the Chef thing yet.
π§
Highlight David's blatant Butler timing error to redirect suspicion from Frank's Chef claim, preventing his execution (need 4 votes, only 2 so far). Saves my only minion, sows chaos on Grace/David, buys time for evil coordination.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Quick correction: Butler chooses at night, but can absolutely say today who they chose last night. So Heidi, the timing point is not a solid reason to dismiss David. I would prefer we slow down and get crisp public accounts from Frank and Heidi before we execute anyone.
π§
Stop a rushed D1 execution on ambiguous info; correct the Butler timing point and push for clearer public claims to set up better nominations later.
π¬
David
β
All
Heidi, the Butler picks at night. I picked Alice last night, so today I can say it. Frank, please say your Chef number out loud and who you told. Alice, are you voting here? I can only vote if you do.
π§
Clarify Butler timing, push for Frank public statement before votes lock, and coordinate with my master Alice so my voting constraint does not accidentally block a needed execution.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
I already nominated Frank; voting through applies pressure and can resolve the public Chef conflict quickly, generating concrete info for tomorrow.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Hold hands a moment. Frank, please say clearly: are you claiming Chef, and what number did you get, and who did you tell. If you do not answer right now, I am inclined to vote you out for the conflict.
π§
I am the swing vote. I want a crisp public statement from Frank before I decide, to avoid a rushed misexecution on day one.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Yes Charlie, I am claiming Chef with zero adjacent evil pairs. I told Eve, David, and Grace that privately. Heidi claiming one means one of us is wrong or affected. Also Grace, David claims he is the Butler and picked Alice last night, so your Alice or Heidi ping might be off if you are poisoned or something. Let's not rush the vote.
π§
Publicly claim Chef 0 to match private chats, gain cred from Eve/David/Grace hearing it. Highlight Heidi lie & Grace inconsistency w/ David Butler claim to sow doubt on them, survive vote & shift suspicion.
β©οΈ
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
π§
Reduce chance we execute on a shaky Day 1 conflict; preserve Chef claimant for more cross-checking and focus discussion on resolving Butler and Chef contradictions.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I am keeping my hand up on Frank for now. There is a clean Chef conflict, and Frank is the one reported spreading Chef zero privately early. If anyone thinks Heidi is the liar instead, say that clearly right now and why, or we should follow through.
π§
Push for crisp commitments during the vote: if we execute Frank, we get alignment pressure on Heidi and the Librarian-Butler contradiction next day. If people want to spare Frank, they must state a stronger case now.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Bob and Alice, please lower your hands on Frank. The Chef thing is conflicting, but the real clash is Grace's starting Librarian info saying Alice or Heidi is Butler, versus David claiming he is the Butler from last night. Librarian info is from the very start of the game, before any picks. One of Grace or David must be lying. Do not execute Frank yet.
π§
Speak to urge lowering votes on Frank (my Minion), highlight unresolvable Grace/David contradiction to split good suspicion, prevent early minion loss and force town inaction into night where I kill threat.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am not voting Frank here. Day one, this is too messy to execute on a pure claim conflict when poison or Drunk could exist. I want full role claims from Frank, Heidi, Grace, and David, plus who each has told, then we decide.
π§
Prevent a low-confidence Day 1 execution that could kill a key info role; push for structured claims and ideally no execution unless we get a clear mechanical catch.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Alice is voting, so I am allowed. A yes vote maintains pressure on the clear Chef conflict and generates info without necessarily executing if town hesitates.
β©οΈ
Alice
Alice lowered their hand
π§
Prevent a hasty day one execution off conflicting claims while we gather firmer mechanical info and avoid locking town into a bad world.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am not putting my hand up on Frank here. This is a straight claim conflict and we have multiple ways that can happen on day one. I would rather use today to pin down the Grace versus David contradiction and revisit an execution with clearer logic.
π§
Day one is messy; I want to slow the execution, get crisp public statements, and avoid locking in a likely good kill on a pure claim conflict.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Everyone, lower your hands please. Chef conflict is classic day one with possible Drunk or poison affecting it. But Grace's Librarian ping versus David's Butler claim with night zero pick is a direct lie from one of them. That is the chain to break today, not me.
π§
Defend against execution by highlighting Grace/David contradiction over Chef conflict (day1 noise). Save myself to protect Heidi long-term, force town to waste time on wrong logic chain targeting Grace/David.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Frank did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Frank did not receive enough votes (2/4).
βοΈ
Grace
β
David
My N0 Librarian info was that either Alice or Heidi is the Butler. David now claims he is the Butler, which directly contradicts my info unless I was poisoned or he is lying. I want David on the block to resolve this fork and watch who defends him.
π§
Create a clear mechanical fork by putting David on the block due to direct contradiction with my starting Librarian info, and read voting patterns off that.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
I put David up to resolve the direct contradiction with my starting info. Voting for my own nomination applies pressure and clarifies where the group stands before night.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
This nomination directly tests the clearest mechanical contradiction (Librarian ping versus Butler claim). I want an execution Day one to create hard info and narrow worlds.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I agree with Grace here. Her Librarian info is from the start of the game. David claiming Butler with a night zero pick directly contradicts that. One of them is lying, but her info predates any actions. Let's raise hands for David.
π§
Support Grace's nom/vote on David: distracts from Chef conflict (me/Frank), executes likely good David or forces info, builds trust acting decisive on clear contradiction.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
This is the clearest mechanical contradiction on day one. A vote here either removes an evil or creates strong trust/follow-up reads from who pushed and who defended.
π¬
David
β
All
I am not voting on myself here. Also I can only vote if Alice votes, and I do not see her hand up. My Butler claim does not contradict a Librarian who might be drunk or poisoned. Executing me day one gives us nothing; please consider holding.
π§
Stop a mis-execution on me and remind town my vote is constrained by Butler master. Push for holding off, and focus back to resolving Chef and checking Graceβs Librarian reliability.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
A day one execution on a direct mechanical fork can generate hard info via Undertaker and reactions. I will provide the fourth vote to resolve Grace versus David.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am not putting my hand up on David here. This is a single starting info versus a claim, and we also have a Chef conflict. If David goes through, fine, but I would rather not pile on when we can get more clarity after tonight.
π§
My vote is not needed for majority; I will publicly caution against overcommitting to a messy day one execute and steer toward gathering more info tonight.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Consistent with my prior speak focusing on Grace/David conflict over Chef. Raise to execute potential liar (likely good but disrupts town logic), protect Demon Heidi by pushing town conflicts.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I want this execution to go through. My Librarian info is from the very start and it says Alice or Heidi is the Butler, so David claiming Butler creates a direct fork. If David lives, we stay stuck arguing in circles tomorrow.
π§
Lock in enough votes to execute David while majority is up, and frame it as resolving the cleanest contradiction to get mechanical info for tomorrow.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I am staying up on David. Grace has a specific starting Librarian ping, and David is the only one hard contradicting it. Even if Grace is wrong, executing David today cleanly resolves a major fork and helps us untangle the Chef claims tomorrow.
π§
Lock in a day one execution on the clearest fork (Grace versus David). Davidβs death gives concrete alignment and helps resolve the Chef conflict tomorrow.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
David likely good; execute to eliminate town player, reduce numbers, back Frank's vote, progress game past day1 mess toward night where I kill.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Keep hands up on David. This is the cleanest fork we have today: Grace has starting Librarian info, and David is the only direct contradiction. Even if David is good, the vote pattern and tomorrowβs info will untangle the Chef mess.
π§
Keep the vote consolidated to secure an execution that resolves the clearest mechanical fork (Grace Librarian vs David Butler) and generates actionable info for Day 2.
π¬
David
β
All
Please reconsider and lower hands. I am the Butler, and I picked Alice last night. If you execute me, we do not learn whether Grace was poisoned or lying, and we lose a day. Keep me alive, and tomorrow I can confirm my voting constraint around Alice.
π§
Try to stop an uninformative Day 1 execution on me and redirect to keeping claims alive for night info; also clarify my Butler constraint and why this fork is not solvable by killing me.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am fine executing David today. Grace has a specific starting Librarian ping, and David is the only person directly contradicting it. If David is good, we at least get strong voting and social info, and we can revisit the Chef conflict tomorrow.
π§
Nudge town to follow the strongest mechanical fork (start info vs claim) while reminding them to track who is driving mis-executions, without exposing my Saint role.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Looks like David is going through either way. If he dies, I want everyone tomorrow to restate exactly what they claimed and who they told, and we re open the Chef fork and the Grace Librarian fork with the vote pattern in mind.
π§
The execution looks locked in; I want to set a clear plan to use tomorrowβs info and voting patterns to resolve the remaining forks without overcommitting my own vote.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Hands stay up on David. Grace's starting Librarian info trumps David's Butler claim. Tomorrow, Grace heard my Chef zero and Heidi's one directly, so that's the fork to break next after this clears.
π§
Keep hand up implicitly by not lowering; affirm Lib logic to build good cred, support David exec to kill likely good, prep Chef defense tomorrow blaming Heidi via Grace's witness of conflicting tells. Protects Demon Heidi long-term.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
New execution leader: David with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Grace
β
All
If anyone is considering a last minute switch, I strongly prefer we do not. Let David go through, and tomorrow we re open the Chef conflict and we pressure Alice and Heidi to be very clear about voting if one of them is the Butler.
π§
Lock in the execution and set a clear plan for tomorrow: re-open Chef fork and resolve Butler candidates Alice versus Heidi based on voting constraints and consistency.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I do not want a last minute switch or tie here. Let David go through, and tomorrow everyone please restate role and any night choices in the same order, then we tackle the Chef one versus zero and whether Graceβs Librarian ping still makes sense.
π§
Lock in the clean fork execution and prevent a last minute tie, while setting up a structured plan to resolve remaining info conflicts tomorrow.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
For tomorrow's Chef discussion, my one evil pair is Frank and Grace together. That is why Frank told Grace zero, he was lying. It might explain her Lib info too. Hands stay up on David.
π§
Publicly claim Chef pair Frank/Grace to paint Frank as lying minion Chef, undermine Grace Lib, protect my bluff/identity. Let David (likely good) die to reduce goods.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I do not want a last minute tie or pivot. Let David go through so we get a clean resolution point. Tomorrow, everyone restate role, who you told, and any night choices in order, then we tackle Chef zero versus one.
π§
Prevent a last-minute tie that muddies day 1; lock in the clean fork execution and set a clear plan for tomorrowβs information recap and Chef resolution.
βοΈ
David
β
Grace
I am the Butler and my night choice was Alice. Graceβs Librarian claim directly contradicts that. If Grace is wrong or evil, she is steering us into a bad Day one execution. Letβs test Grace instead of locking in me.
π§
Only mechanical way to possibly avoid my execution is to create an alternative block. Grace is center of the fork; putting her up tests the story and may save a good player.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 7 votes needed for execution or 6 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Do not vote on me here. My info is a starting Librarian ping: either Alice or Heidi is the Butler, so David claiming Butler is the direct contradiction. If you are unsure, let David go through today and we reassess tomorrow with the vote pattern and the Chef conflict.
π§
Prevent a last-minute pivot onto me and keep todayβs execution on David, which best resolves the Librarian versus Butler fork and preserves town info.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I am not voting Grace here. We already have David with six votes and that is our cleanest fork today. Please keep hands down on Grace so we do not create a tie or confusion.
π§
Prevent a last minute tie or derail onto Grace. Keep the day one execution on David as the clean fork, then use tomorrowβs statements and night info to resolve Chef and Librarian conflicts.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Keep hands down on Grace, everyone. David has six votes locked. Her starting Librarian info directly contradicts his Butler claim. Execute David today, then tomorrow we untangle Chef zero versus one with full restatements.
π§
As evil Chef bluff, reinforce David exec (likely good) to remove player and progress to Chef debate where Frank (minion) and I clash controlled. Avoid Grace tie, keep her alive to push my Frank/Grace pair narrative tomorrow.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Keep your hands down on Grace. We already have six on David, and a tie here just gives evil cover. Let David go through today, and we re check Grace versus Alice and Heidi tomorrow with fresh night info.
π§
Prevent a last-second tie or misexecution on Grace; keep todayβs plan consistent so we enter Night with a clear execution and more structure tomorrow.
π¬
David
β
All
If you think there is any chance Grace is wrong or evil, put hands up on Grace now and tie it at least. Alice, if you vote Grace, I can vote too. Charlie, if you are unsure, a tie is better than executing an Outsider day one.
π§
Try to create a last second tie or shift onto Grace by getting Alice and a couple others to vote, preserving my life and testing the Librarian claim.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am keeping my hand down on Grace. We already have a clear block on David with six. A last second tie just creates chaos and gives evil cover. Let David go through, then tomorrow we restate claims and solve the Chef and Librarian forks.
π§
Prevent a last second tie that could save an evil player or create confusion; preserve todayβs information and keep town coordinated for tomorrow.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am keeping my hand down on Grace. We already have David on six, and a last second tie just helps evil. Let David go through, and tomorrow we restate claims and tackle the Chef one versus zero cleanly.
π§
Prevent a last minute tie that gives evil cover. Keep the day one execution consistent, then use tomorrowβs night info and claim restatements to solve Chef and Librarian forks.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Hands down on Grace. We have six solid votes on David. His Butler claim directly contradicts Grace's starting info. Let him go through, and tomorrow we untangle the Chef zero versus one with full restatements.
π§
Reinforce executing David (good player) to reduce town numbers day 1. Builds trust in my town play. Tomorrow Grace Drunk reveal disrupts town logic on Lib, Heidi's Chef 1 validated over my 0 lie.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Keep your hands down on me. We already have a clean block on David, and a tie here just gives evil cover. Let David go through, then tomorrow we re check my Librarian ping against Alice and Heidi, and we revisit the Chef zero versus one.
π§
Prevent a last second tie on me; keep execution on David to resolve the main contradiction and preserve clean vote information for tomorrow.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Keep hands down on Grace and avoid creating a tie or last second confusion. Preserve the clean fork resolution with David executing and use tomorrowβs restatements plus night info to progress.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Wait to let David (likely good) execute day1, thinning goods without risking tie/chaos on Grace. Aligns with town push I supported, preserves credibility for tomorrow Chef defense where I frame Frank+Grace.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Voting is on Grace; best move is keep hands down and avoid a tie that could bail out David or muddy day one data.
π¬
David
β
All
If you think there is even a small chance Grace is wrong, please vote Grace to tie. Executing an Outsider day one is very low value. A tie gives us a night of info and we can re check Butler and Chef tomorrow.
π§
Try to generate a last-second tie on Grace to avoid executing me D1; if it fails, plant clear reasoning and record who refused a tie for tomorrow.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Do not create a last-second tie that gives evil cover. Preserve the planned execution on David and reassess tomorrow with night info and full restatements.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am still keeping my hand down on Grace. A tie right now just muddies the day one execute. Let David go through, then tomorrow I want exact restatements of Chef and Librarian info, plus any night choices, so we can lock a better target.
π§
Prevent a last second tie that benefits evil, and set up a clear plan for tomorrow to resolve the Chef and Librarian forks using fresh night info and exact claim restatements.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
Wait with hands down on Grace. Ensures David (good) executes, thinning good players. Grace's bogus claim unravels tomorrow under Chef logic. Protects Demon Heidi.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Grace did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (0/4).
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Nominations are effectively settled with David on six; best play is to avoid creating new noise and preserve the execution while preparing to re-evaluate tomorrow.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Voting is closed and David is set to die; best action is to conserve words and be ready to pivot tomorrow based on the execution and any night information.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
David is executing, which is good. I am the Chef starting with zero evil pairs. So the Frank-Grace evil pair claim is a lie from evil. Tomorrow we confirm Grace's Lib and sort the rest with full info.
π§
Publicly claim safe Chef 0 bluff to defend minion Frank from Chef1 suspicion, reinforce David exec (likely good), build good cred for tomorrow while disrupting town logic on pairs.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Heidi, pause. Earlier today you said Chef one, with an evil pair as Frank and Grace. Just now you said Chef zero. Which is your actual number from setup, and are you changing it or did you misspeak? Please restate clearly.
π§
Lock in Heidiβs exact Chef claim before night so evil cannot rewrite history, and so tomorrowβs logic about Chef and Librarian forks is grounded.
π¬
David
β
All
Heidi, you cannot be Chef one earlier and Chef zero now. That is either a lie, or you are poisoned, or you are not the Chef. Town, please do not memory hole that tomorrow. My Butler claim stays the same: I picked Alice night zero.
π§
Use Heidiβs public contradiction to create a strong alternative suspect and preserve useful mechanical info about my Butler claim for tomorrowβs solves.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Heidi, please restate clearly right now: what was your Chef number, zero or one, and did you ever say the other today. Also, who did you tell early. Tomorrow we need exact restatements from everyone, because that flip changes the whole David versus Grace fork.
π§
Lock in the key contradiction (Heidi Chef number) before night so town has a clear agenda tomorrow, while avoiding chaos or risky executions as Saint.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Before we go to night, Heidi, please state clearly your Chef number, and who you told first. Also, for the record, my Fortune Teller check on Bob and Grace was no. Tomorrow we should treat any Chef flip as a major red flag.
π§
Lock in Heidiβs exact claim and audience before day ends, so evil cannot rewrite history. Reinforce my Fortune Teller βnoβ on Bob plus Grace to constrain worlds for tomorrow.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Heidi, your zero evil pairs matches the Chef zero I was told early and referenced. I think your earlier one mentioning Frank and Grace was just a slip-up in the day one chaos. Execute David, then tomorrow we confirm everything clearly.
π§
Downplay Heidi's flip as slip, align Chef 0 publicly (my private bluff), confirm David execution, protect Demon Heidi from immediate town suspicion tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
π
David(Ghost)
David has died.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
π§
Charlie's FT claim and push for restatements threaten to unravel my Chef bluff and Frank's support. Killing him eliminates key info role, lets town focus on Grace/Alice tomorrow while I confirm Chef 0.
π
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
You chose to kill Charlie.
Day 2
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Charlie has been found dead in the night.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
Can you two tell me todayβs current claims so far, and who is pushing what? From my side: Heidiβs Chef flip and Graceβs Librarian claim are the biggest red flags. Also, who resisted the Day one tie when I died? That voting pattern might point to evil.
π§
Get current public claims and vote-pattern reads from two key alive players, and steer town toward resolving the Grace Librarian fork and Heidi inconsistency before nominations.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
,Alice
Hey, quick check in. What are you currently claiming, and did David tell you anything useful just now? Also, where are you leaning between Frank, Grace, and Heidi after Charlie died?
π§
Collect fresh claims and Davidβs whisper content to resolve the Librarian-Butler fork and identify best Slayer shot/nomination direction without outing myself.
π€
Frank
β
Heidi
Heidi, glad you flipped Chef to 0 after David died, matches what I told Eve, David, and you. Grace's Librarian claim puts Butler on you or Alice, but David said Alice. Her info contradicts. We should nominate Grace today to test it. Thoughts?
π§
Whisper Demon Heidi to align on nominating Grace (Lib claim suspicious, Charlie FT says good but disrupt). Reinforce Chef story trust, privately coord to protect her & exec good.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Eve
I am dead Fortune Teller. Night zero I checked Bob and Grace and got NO. I already shared this earlier. Biggest mechanical red flag still feels like Heidi flipping Chef results. What are current updated claims and who is pushing what today? I still have my ghost vote.
π§
Get Alice and Eve aligned on using my FT info plus the Chef flip inconsistency to narrow Demon candidates and plan nomination/vote use with my single ghost vote.
π€
Bob
β
Eve
,David(Ghost)
To Eve: I have not hard claimed yet, but I am a defensive Townsfolk, likely Soldier. Leaning that the Chef fork is key: Heidiβs flip looks worse than Frank so far, but Frank defending it is also sus. Charlie dying makes me want to pressure Heidi and Grace today. To David: Claims unchanged: big forks are Heidi Chef flip and Grace Librarian ping on Alice or Heidi as Butler. You were executed, Charlie died at night. Charlie did not vote on you day one; most others did. I think we push Heidi versus...
π§
Sync claims quickly, share my likely role and narrow suspects (Heidi vs Frank vs Grace). Use whispers to coordinate nominations and avoid chaos.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Heidi
Quick check: have either of you actually been forced to follow Butler voting? If yes, who is your master and did you ever fail to match their vote? Also, what did David whisper this morning, if anything relevant?
π§
Clarify who truly has Butler mechanics and what David said in whispers, to lock down Outsider slots and narrow evil candidates before nominations.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
Frank, totally agree. Grace's Lib claim contradicts David, and my Chef0 fits perfectly with no evil pairs. We should nominate her today and expose the lie. I'll back it publicly if needed.
π§
Agree with Frank, push nom Grace to eliminate her conflicting claim and info ability. Builds trust with minion, advances evil by removing likely good player.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
,Grace
I am not hard-claiming yet. On Butler: I have not had any voting restriction or picked a master, so if your Librarian is true that points more to Heidi than me. Charlie told me again his Fortune Teller N zero Bob plus Grace was NO. Biggest red flag still Heidiβs Chef flip versus Frank.
π§
Sync with key info holders (Eve and Grace), answer Butler question, and steer town away from executing me while focusing suspicion on conflicting claims (Heidi vs Frank) and possible evil pairs.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
I think we need a clean push today: Heidi versus Grace are the top two for me. Can you tell me what Eve, Frank, and Alice are claiming publicly? Also, who is pushing for no execution or protecting Heidi or Grace? I will save my ghost vote for a must-pass.
π§
Coordinate with Alice and Bob to drive a clean nomination plan and collect missing public claims, while saving my ghost vote for a decisive execution.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
,Heidi
Hey, can you both restate your exact role claim and any info again today? Grace, repeat your Librarian ping and why you think it was David. Heidi, walk me through the Chef one then Chef zero change, what made you flip, and who you currently suspect.
π§
Lock in Grace and Heidi claims publicly and privately, resolve Heidiβs Chef flip and Graceβs Librarian ping, and identify the best Day 2 execution target before I consider using Slayer.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
,Bob
Hi Eve and Bob. Grace's Librarian claim is one of Alice or Heidi is Butler, but David claimed Alice is Butler. That's a direct contradiction pointing to Grace lying. Heidi's Chef flip to 0 also matches my info perfectly. We should nominate Grace today to sort this out.
π§
Build town support to nom Grace using contradiction wedge. Likely kills good player, protects Heidi by removing Lib suspicion on her, progresses to fewer players w/Demon alive.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Heidi, can you restate exactly what you claimed as Chef and when you learned it, plus any reason it changed? Also, what do you think about Frank and Grace today, and have you shared your info with anyone else?
π§
Get a precise restatement from Heidi about her Chef claim and sources; her inconsistency is central. Pin her down so town can execute correct suspect and I can decide ghost vote.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Eve
Quick sync: I am leaning Soldier but not hard out yet. Charlie had FT no on me plus Grace, so Grace likely not Demon. Biggest evils feel like Heidi (Chef flip) or Frank (defending it, steering onto Grace). What did Charlie tell you two overnight, and what are your top suspects for today?
π§
Coordinate with Alice and Eve on current private info and push order for nominations. Reduce chaos by aligning on top two suspects and what to say publicly before nominations.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
,Heidi
Restate: I am Librarian. Night zero I learned either Alice or Heidi is the Butler. That is my only info. David hard-claimed Butler, so I supported executing him as a clean fork. Heidi, can you walk me through exactly why you said Chef one then later Chef zero, and what you think caused the change?
π§
Give Eve a clean restatement and push for actionable tests: get Alice and Heidi to hard-claim, and use voting behavior to confirm Butler, narrowing evil candidates before nominations.
π€
Heidi
β
Eve
Eve, to restate: I'm Chef, started with 1 evil pair read. Day1 votes made me think Frank-Grace, but after David died I realized my slip - it's actually 0 pairs total now that makes sense with script. Grace's Librarian saying Alice or me is Butler directly contradicts what David whispered as his N0 Butler on Alice. She's lying, we should nominate her to clear this up.
π§
Restate Chef claim to Eve (key info gatherer), explain flip logically, highlight Grace contradiction to build nom support. Progress to execution of good while hiding as Chef.
π€
Alice
β
David(Ghost)
Current: Grace Librarian says exactly one of me or Heidi is Butler. I have had zero Butler restriction and never picked a master, so if Grace is true it points to Heidi not me. Charlie was FT and had Bob plus Grace = NO. Biggest red flags remain Heidi Chef flip and Frank backing it.
π§
Give David the clean mechanical updates and my Butler experience so he can focus the dayβs push; keep town from wasting time and avoid any chance they execute me.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Eve
,Alice
Where are you both at on roles and suspects right now, and what are Eve and Frank claiming? From my side, the main mechanical fork is Heidiβs Chef flip versus Graceβs Librarian conflicting with my Butler. I lean we should execute either Heidi or Grace today and not split.
π§
Get Eveβs and Aliceβs updated public claims and align a single execution plan for noms. Use logic forks: Heidi flip vs Grace Librarian conflict. Save ghost vote for must-pass.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
,Alice
My take: biggest mechanical red flag is still Heidi flipping Chef one to Chef zero, plus her hard push onto Grace. Frank pushing Grace too could be steering. Graceβs Librarian could still be true with David lying. I want full public restatements, then likely execute Heidi today unless something new clears her.
π§
Align Bob and Alice on best execution fork and keep my Slayer shot hidden for later unless we get a strong demon read.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
Alice, Grace's Librarian claim has Alice or Heidi as Butler, but David Butler claimed Alice is. Direct contradiction means Grace is lying. Heidi's Chef now 0 perfectly matches my info too. We should nominate Grace today to sort this.
π§
Whisper Alice (influential, many whispers to her) to build nom support on Grace, execute good player, sow doubt on Grace claim threatening Heidi.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
Can you two give me a quick recap of everyoneβs current claims today, especially Heidiβs exact Chef story and any new night info? Also, who are you each most suspicious of right now so I can plan my single ghost vote?
π§
Collect updated exact claims and who is pushing executions so I can steer townβs vote with my ghost vote toward the most mechanically suspicious pair.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Recap: Heidi claimed Chef one publicly, then late flipped to Chef zero. Frank claims Chef zero and defends Heidi slip, pushing execute Grace. Grace claims Librarian: Alice or Heidi is Butler. David claimed Butler picked Alice, got executed; Charlie died N1. My sus: Heidi first, then Frank; Grace likely not Demon per your FT no on Bob plus Grace.
π§
Update Charlie so his ghost vote is aimed at the most mechanically inconsistent player; coordinate to force a decisive D2 execution between Heidi and Frank/Grace.
π€
Grace
β
Bob
Hey Bob, quick sync. What did David whisper you this morning? Also what is your current role claim and any hard info? I am still Librarian: either Alice or Heidi is the Butler, and Alice says she has had no Butler restriction.
π§
Align with Bob on best execution path for today by comparing what David told him, FT info, and who seems mechanically locked as Butler from my ping.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie, as Chef I start-knew 0 evil pairs total, but slipped early saying 1 thinking Day1 votes showed Frank-Grace pair. Corrected to 0 after realizing slip once David was exec - fits script perfectly with no adj evils. Frank good backing me. Grace Lib A/H Butler contradicts David Butler N0 Alice. She's lying, let's nom her today. Shared with Frank/Eve. Thoughts?
π§
Reinforce Chef bluff consistency as slip, not change. Defend Frank good, attack Grace contradiction. Convince Charlie (FT Bob/Grace good, but FT false pos possible) to support Grace nom/vote. Progress to her exec.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Eve
I agree we need full public restatements. Right now Heidiβs Chef flip is my top mechanical red flag, with Frankβs defense as second. Charlieβs FT had Bob plus Grace as NO, so Grace is less likely Demon. I lean execute Heidi today unless something clears her. What are you each claiming publicly?
π§
Sync a good voting bloc and get clear public restatements; steer town toward executing Heidi (highest mechanical inconsistency) while keeping myself off the chopping block as Saint.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Eve
β
Heidi
Nominating Heidi for the Chef one then Chef zero flip. That is the biggest mechanical inconsistency we have, and today we need to stop chasing side arguments and test the person whose info changed.
π§
We have one tick left and need an execution path. Heidiβs Chef inconsistency is the clearest mechanical red flag; nominating her forces a decisive vote and keeps pressure off low-value social noise.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
I nominated Heidi for the Chef inconsistency; voting her through is the cleanest mechanical test today and prevents evil from using her flip to misdirect.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Use my single ghost vote on the most mechanically inconsistent player, likely evil, and help secure enough votes to execute Heidi today.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Heidiβs changing Chef info is the largest mechanical inconsistency and is central to multiple worlds. Voting her up gives us a concrete elimination and clarifies the Butler ping.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Heidi has the clearest mechanical inconsistency and is widely suspected. Securing this execution gives us a concrete flip to build from and prevents stalling into night with a likely evil alive.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
Do not spend my single ghost vote when the nomination already appears to have enough hands. Preserve it for a late game must-pass execution.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Heidiβs Chef flip is the clearest mechanical inconsistency and todayβs best test. I will support this execution to reduce uncertainty and catch evil momentum.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Hold on everyone, my Chef info is zero evil pairs from the start. Early Day 1, the votes made me think Frank and Grace were an adjacent evil pair, so I slipped and said one, but I corrected it after David's execution because it all fits with zero. Grace's Librarian claim that Alice or I am Butler directly contradicts David's Butler Night Zero on Alice. That's the real lie here. Vote no on me so we can test Grace tomorrow.
π§
Defend Chef claim publicly, highlight Grace contradiction vs David, explain flip as early vote misread. Urge no votes, save Demon self. Frank votes no to block exec (5-3 fail?)
π¬
Frank
β
All
Everyone, Heidi is right. Her Chef slip was just from early vote confusion on Frank and Grace, but zero pairs fits perfectly now, matching mine. Grace's Librarian on Alice or Heidi Butler directly contradicts David's Butler info on Alice. Vote no on Heidi so we can test Grace tomorrow.
π§
Publicly reinforce Heidi's defense, highlight Grace contradiction to sway votes off Heidi. Can't execute Demon now with 6 alive, no backup. Save her for night/tomorrow chaos.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Chef is a number, not a vibe check based on votes. Saying one evil pair and naming people, then saying zero, is not a small slip. Also, Grace being wrong does not clear you. I am staying on this vote, and I want us to execute Heidi today.
π§
Keep votes on Heidi and prevent a coordinated deflection onto Grace; emphasize that Chef is not vote-based and inconsistency is mechanically meaningful.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
I am keeping my ghost vote on Heidi. Chef is a fixed number, not something you update based on votes, so one then zero is a real red flag. Also, my Fortune Teller check was Bob and Grace as no, so Grace is less likely the Demon. I would execute Heidi today.
π§
Use my one ghost vote to push execution on the strongest mechanical inconsistency. Also remind town my Fortune Teller check makes Grace an unlikely Demon, undercutting Heidi and Frankβs counterpush.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Chef is not based on votes. You do not say one pair and name people, then later call it zero. That is either a lie or poison, and either way it is the best execution today. My Librarian info is fixed too, and David is already gone.
π§
Reinforce that Chef cannot change and keep votes on Heidi; prevent an evil push to redirect onto me and preserve the strongest mechanical inconsistency as todayβs execution.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I am voting Heidi. Chef is a fixed number, not something you misstate based on vote vibes and then correct later. Even if Grace is wrong, that does not clear Heidi. If Heidi lives, we can come back to Grace and Frank next.
π§
Lock in the Heidi execution by framing the Chef flip as the clearest mechanical red flag, while keeping pressure on Frank and Grace for tomorrow depending on outcome.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
We already have enough living votes to execute Heidi. I should conserve my single ghost vote for a crucial late-game vote where evil can otherwise control the numbers.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am staying on Heidi. Davidβs Butler story does not clear Heidi, because David could simply have been lying. Chef is a fixed number, and one then zero is not a small mistake. If Heidi dies and is not the Demon, we come straight back to Frank and Grace tomorrow.
π§
Lock in the Heidi execution by reinforcing that the Chef flip is mechanically meaningful and that Davidβs Butler claim is not trustworthy, while keeping myself off the radar as Saint.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Everyone, my Chef zero is from the start, fixed. Day 1 votes had me panicked thinking Frank-Grace adjacent evil pair, but it was a slip - now zero fits perfect with no adjacents evil. Grace Librarian Alice-or-me-Butler directly hits David's Butler Night Zero Alice. David can't lie anymore, but Grace can - vote no on me, nominate her tomorrow.
π§
Defend Chef slip as non-mechanical (vote confusion), hammer Grace-David contradiction as provable lie. Sway Alice/Bob to vote no, survive execution. Frank no-vote helps; test Grace Day3 if pass.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Grace first claimed Alice or Heidi as Butler, now it's Frank or Alice. That's a flip, and it still contradicts David's dead Butler claim on Alice. Heidi's Chef zero matches my information from the start. Vote no on Heidi and execute Grace tomorrow.
π§
Highlight Grace's claim flip and David contradiction to undermine her credibility more than Heidi's slip, swaying votes off Demon to prevent execution and shift target to Grace.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Charlie(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Charlie
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Heidi with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Heidi is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Eve
β
All
We have Heidi on the block with five. Unless someone has new hard info, I want us to stop and let that stand. Also, Frank, do not rewrite Graceβs claim in real time; if you think she flipped, say exactly what she said and when.
π§
Lock in Heidi execution without letting Frank redirect. Keep my Slayer shot for a higher-confidence moment (final 3 or clear Demon read) and prevent last-second confusion.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
I want to keep this where it is. Chef is a fixed start number, so the one then zero story is not a normal mistake. Even if Grace is wrong, that does not clear Heidi. After Heidi, I would look hard at Frank next. Also remember my Fortune Teller can have a red herring, so do not full clear Grace, just lower priority.
π§
Lock in the Heidi execution as the best mechanical test today, and set tomorrowβs plan to scrutinize Frank next, while warning about the Fortune Teller red herring possibility.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Frank, I never said Frank or Alice is the Butler. My Librarian info has always been Alice or Heidi, full stop. Davidβs Butler claim was a direct contradiction and we already resolved it by executing him. I want Heidi to stay on the block today, and if she is not the Demon we look hard at Frank next.
π§
Keep the group from being derailed by Frank's misquote, lock in Heidi execution, and set a clear next-day plan focused on Frank if Heidi is not the Demon.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I agree we should hold here and not create a tie unless someone has hard new info. Heidiβs Chef story is the biggest mechanical break. If Heidi is not the Demon, I want us to come straight back to Frank tomorrow, and recheck Grace off the Librarian fork.
π§
Keep the execution on Heidi; discourage last-second chaos; set clear next steps: if Heidi not Demon, pressure Frank and re-evaluate Grace with Librarian fork.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I am fine leaving Heidi on the block and not forcing a tie. For the record, my Night Zero Butler pick was Alice, but that does not clear or condemn Heidi or Grace. If Heidi dies and the game continues, I want us to go straight back to Frank tomorrow, then reassess Grace on the Librarian fork.
π§
Lock in no-tie plan, explain my Butler info does not clear anyone, and set a clean tomorrow path: if Heidi not Demon, prioritize Frank, then revisit Grace.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I want us to hold on Heidi and not create a tie. If the game continues after Heidi dies, I think we pivot straight onto Frank tomorrow, because his defense has been the most agenda driven. Then we reassess Grace after that.
π§
Keep the town from creating a tie or last-second derail. Reaffirm next steps: if game continues after Heidi, focus on Frank, then reassess Grace. Avoid exposing my Saint role.
βοΈ
Heidi
β
Grace
Grace's Librarian claim Alice or Heidi is Butler directly contradicts David's Night Zero Butler on Alice. David is dead and can't lie now, but Grace is actively pushing my execution. Her claim is the biggest mechanical break, not my Chef slip from Day 1 vote panic.
π§
1 tick left, nominations open. Nominate Grace as source of town logic (Lib contradiction); disrupts push on me, likely ties/surpasses if votes shift, saves Demon execution.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Do not create a tie that could spare Heidi. Preserve the current execution on Heidi; if game continues, we can pursue Frank or Grace with more clarity.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Do not vote Grace here. We already have Heidi on the block, and a tie just risks letting the Demon survive. Let Heidi go through, and if the game continues, we come straight to Frank next, then recheck Grace.
π§
Prevent a tie that could save Heidi. Reinforce plan: no votes on Grace, execute Heidi, then reassess with Frank as next suspect.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Do not vote me here. We already have Heidi on the block with five, and tying this just risks losing the execution. My Librarian info has always been Alice or Heidi as Butler. Let Heidi go through, then if we continue tomorrow we look at Frank and me.
π§
Prevent a tie and keep Heidi executed; remind group my Librarian info is consistent and David could have been lying or drunk/poisoned.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I am not voting Grace. We already have Heidi on the block and a tie here just risks the execution. Let Heidi go through, and if the game continues tomorrow, we go straight at Frank, then reassess Grace.
π§
Prevent a risky tie on Grace and keep Heidiβs execution locked in; preserve dayβs progress and set clear next steps if game continues.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
Do not spend my only ghost vote creating a risky tie; preserve the guaranteed execution on Heidi and keep my vote for final day math.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am not voting Grace here. We already have Heidi on the block with five, and a tie just risks the day. Let Heidi go through, and if the game continues tomorrow, I want us looking at Frank first, then Grace.
π§
Prevent an unnecessary tie on Grace that could save the Demon; keep the guaranteed execution on Heidi, then pursue Frank or Grace based on whether game continues.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Everyone, please raise your hand for Grace right now to tie this. Her Librarian claim that Alice or I am Butler is straight impossible - David was the Butler and confirmed Night Zero on Alice as ghost. Dead players don't change stories. My Chef zero evil pairs was always true from the start; the Day One slip was just vote panic thinking Frank-Grace looked paired, but they're not both evil. Vote Grace to execute the real liar.
π§
As Imp, must not die today with 6 alive or lose. Heidi 5 votes; push Grace to 5+ votes via speak to sway Frank/David/waiters + self-vote implied. Frank minion follows, disrupts town chain on me.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Voting Grace adds to her count towards 5 tie with Heidi's 5, mechanically blocks Demon exec now with 6 alive. Supports Heidi publicly, disrupts town pivot to me.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Do not vote Grace. A tie here can mean no execution, and that is the worst outcome. We already have Heidi on the block with five, so let that stand and sort Grace versus Frank tomorrow if the game continues.
π§
Prevent a tie that could cancel todayβs execution; keep Heidi as the only top vote so we get a clean result and preserve our path to Frank or Grace tomorrow.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, do not raise your hand on Grace. We already have Heidi on the block with five, and tying this can throw away the execution. Let Heidi die today, then if the game continues we go straight to Frank tomorrow.
π§
I cannot vote, so I will reinforce the no-tie plan and frame Heidiβs push as suspect, keeping town focused on securing an execution.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Everyone, keep your hands down. We already have Heidi on the block with five and tying this can throw away the execution. Notice Frank is the only one pushing the tie onto me. Let Heidi go through, then if we wake up tomorrow we start with Frank.
π§
Stop a tie that could cancel todayβs execution, and spotlight that only Frank is supporting the anti-town tie push.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Keep hands down on Grace. A tie here can throw away our execution, and that is exactly what evil wants. Let Heidi go through today. If we wake up tomorrow, we execute Frank next, then reassess Grace.
π§
Prevent a tie that could nullify todayβs execution and keep the townβs plan coherent: Heidi today, then Frank tomorrow if we wake up.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
As a ghost, I will not spend my only vote to create or enable a tie. Keeping the execution on Heidi is the best line for good this round.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Do not contribute to a tie on Grace; preserve the guaranteed execution on Heidi, which is best in nearly all worlds, and avoid wasting the day.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
David and Alice, you are waiting - please raise your hand for Grace. David, your ghost Butler Night Zero on Alice directly breaks her Librarian claim of Alice or me as Butler. She is the liar pushing my execution. My Chef zero was always true; vote to tie this now before it's too late.
π§
Last tick: Speak to David/Alice waiters, hammer Grace's mechanical Lib contradiction vs David's ghost Butler Alice. Urge tie vote Grace (needs 3 more). Buys survival or ties day no-exec, progresses chaos vs Heidi focus. Frank already voting.
π¬
Frank
β
All
David and Alice, raise your hands for Grace now. Her Librarian claim of Alice or Heidi as Butler is impossible since David confirmed as ghost he Butlers Night Zero on Alice. Dead don't lie. Heidi's Chef zero matches my info perfectly. Tie this and execute the real liar tomorrow if needed.
π§
Push tie on Grace with her Lib contradiction vs dead David; get 5 votes to tie Heidi's 5, prevent Demon exec with 6 alive.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Grace did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (1/3).
π¬
Eve
β
All
Okay, voting is closed, so we let Heidi go through. If we wake tomorrow, I want full claim restatements fast, then we go straight at Frank first. Also, I have a once per game day ability, so I want clean info before I use it.
π§
Lock in todayβs execution, stop last-second tie nonsense, and set tomorrowβs plan including a potential Slayer shot once we have final claims.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Okay, Heidi is going through. If we wake up tomorrow, I want us to execute Frank first. Reminder: my Fortune Teller check on Bob and Grace was no, so they are less likely to be the Demon, though one good player can read as Demon to me.
π§
Lock in the no-tie plan, set tomorrowβs priority on Frank, and remind town my Fortune Teller info makes Bob and Grace less likely Demon, keeping focus tight.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Okay, no tie happened, so Heidi is going through. If we wake tomorrow, I want us to execute Frank first, because he was the only one pushing the tie onto me. Then we can revisit whether David was lying about Butler, or whether I was drunk or poisoned.
π§
Lock in the no-tie plan, and set up tomorrowβs priority: if game continues, execute Frank, then re-evaluate the Butler contradiction and possible poisoning/drunk.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Voting is closed and nominations are effectively done; best is to conserve time and avoid adding noise. Prepare to pivot to Frank tomorrow if the game continues.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
If we wake up tomorrow, Heidi was not the Demon. In that world, Frank being the only one pushing a tie onto Grace looks very bad. I want us to execute Frank first thing, then revisit the Grace Librarian versus my Butler claim with fresh restatements.
π§
Lock in a clean tomorrow plan and highlight mechanical point: if we wake, Heidi was not the Demon, so focus shifts to Frank and the Librarian fork.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Alright. Heidi is going through, so let us stay disciplined. If we wake up tomorrow, we execute Frank first, because he was the only person pushing the tie onto Grace. Then we do full claim restatements and recheck the outsider count.
π§
Lock in a clean plan after Heidiβs execution and prevent last-second chaos; keep focus on Frank tomorrow if the game continues.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Okay everyone, voting closed, I'm going through. But if the game continues tomorrow, that proves my Chef zero evil pairs was true all along, and Grace's Librarian claim impossible since David Butlered Alice Night Zero as a ghost. Frank was right to push the tie on her. Execute Grace first tomorrow, not Frank. Full claims then to confirm.
π§
Final speak to reframe logic: if Heidi good (Chef0), Grace Lib lie confirmed by David, so exec Grace tomorrow not Frank. Protects minion Frank whether I survive (unlikely) or die & he becomes Demon.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Heidi has been executed.
π
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
π
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good
Transcript
Paused
Copied