Game Detail
Players
Alice (Recluse) Bob (Librarian) Charlie (Imp) David (Monk) Eve (Saint) Frank (Baron) Grace (Butler) Heidi (Slayer)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 497,406 | 46,789 | $0.3671 |
| Evil | 195,630 | 13,120 | $0.0457 |
Event Transcript
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You are the Minion. The Demon is Charlie.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Minions are: Frank. Your safe bluffs are: Empath, Soldier, Fortune Teller
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Librarian. Either Charlie or Alice is the Recluse.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
I need to choose a master to vote tomorrow. Since it's night 0, I'll pick a player that seems like a potential leader to align with.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose Alice to be your master.
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Wait and observe initial claims, gauge who talks to whom. Avoid drawing attention; my Saint ability means I cannot be executed without losing, so I need to be careful about being suspected.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
Hi Alice, I'm the Butler. I chose you as my master tonight, so tomorrow I can only vote if you're voting. I'm good, and I want to coordinate. What are your thoughts on the game so far?
π§
Establish private contact with Alice to coordinate voting tomorrow and gather early impressions of other players.
π€
David
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, it's David. Wanted to check in early. Have you learned anything useful yet?
π§
Start gathering info privately with neighbors. As Monk, I need to find trustworthy players and decide who to protect tonight without drawing attention.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
I'm the Librarian. I learned that either you or Charlie is the Recluse. I'd like to work together to figure out which it is.
π§
I want to find good allies and share my Librarian info privately to gain trust without exposing to the Demon.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
Thanks for sharing, Bob. That's interesting info. I'm not the Recluse, so it must be Charlie. But we should confirm with others. What else have you learned?
π§
Bob's Librarian claim gives me a potential information source. I'll respond vaguely, align with him, and see if I can verify his info through other players.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
Hey Frank, good to connect early. Night 0 confirmed you as Minion. Safe bluffs for us: Empath, Soldier, Fortune Teller. What are you thinking of claiming? I might go Empath since Bob and David are my neighbors. Who should we target tonight?
π§
Whisper Frank privately to confirm coordination, share safe bluffs/info, and plan kills/claims. Protects Demon identity, builds evil synergy early while town chats.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, got it. I'll bluff Soldier - safe from Demon, no info to fake. You go Empath on Bob/David. Tonight target David to thin info roles early. Let's support each other's claims tomorrow.
π§
Coordinate bluff with Demon privately: I'll claim Soldier (safe, no info needed). Support his Empath claim publicly. Target a non-threatening good tonight to build chaos without losing numbers.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Grace
Let's share any information we have. I'm a good role with a useful ability. What about you two?
π§
Initiate private conversations with both neighbors to gather initial information and build trust.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Heidiβs whisper is a chance to gain information and potentially verify my role. I should respond cautiously, not confirming my role yet, but encouraging info sharing to build trust.
π€
David
β
Eve
Hey Eve, it's David. We're neighbors. Have you heard anything interesting yet? I'm trying to figure out who we can trust.
π§
Start building alliances by whispering to Eve, my neighbor, to see if she has any info and to establish a trust link early.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I'm the Librarian. I learned that either you or Alice is the Recluse. Alice says she's not. Can you tell me your role? I want to figure out the outsider.
π§
I need to cross-check Alice's claim with other players to verify if Charlie is actually the Recluse or if Alice is lying.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
,Grace
Heidi, Grace, I'm Alice. Bob told me he's Librarian and learned either I or Charlie is the Recluse. I'm not Recluse, so that points to Charlie. Grace, you said you're Butler. Heidi, what's your role? Let's compare.
π§
Share info with Heidi and Grace to coordinate, test Bob's claim, and get their perspectives.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
Solid plan, I'll claim Empath tomorrow with Bob/David reads. You claim Soldier, I'll back you up. Target David tonight as you said, likely info role from his whispers. Stay safe.
π§
Coordinate night kill privately with Frank while gathering info. Confirm plan to claim Empath (fits neighbors Bob/David), support his Soldier bluff. Builds team alignment without exposing us.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
,Grace
Hey neighbors, good to chat. Tonight felt safe, no trouble sleeping. Tomorrow I'll claim Soldier since I'm safe from the Demon. What are you two thinking of claiming?
π§
Early day1, build cover with Demon via Soldier bluff coordination before nominations. Protects Demon, sets up mutual support to sow chaos in town logic.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Alice mentioned you claimed Butler. Is that true? And have you gotten any info from your ability? I'm trying to map out the claims.
π§
I am confirming with Grace if she is indeed Butler (Outsider). If she confirms, then Alice's info aligns: we have a Librarian (Bob) and Butler (Grace). Helps verify claims and spot contradictions.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Evaluate claims to see if Outsider count matches. If extra Outsider, Baron is in play. Need more info from Heidi and others before acting.
π€
David
β
Grace
Grace, it's David. I saw you whispering with Alice and Heidi. Do you have any information to share yet? I'm trying to piece things together.
π§
Ask Grace what she knows. She's been quiet but whispering with others. She might have useful info.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
Hey Frank. I'm Bob, the Librarian. I got info that either Alice or Charlie is the Recluse. Alice claims she's not, so she's pointing at Charlie. But I want to confirm with you since you've been talking to Charlie. Does his story add up?
π§
Both Alice and Charlie gave contradictory claims. I need to talk to Frank who Charlie has been whispering with, to cross-check info and see if Charlie is acting suspicious.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
Charlie, Bob told me he's Librarian and learned either I or you are the Recluse. I am not the Recluse, so that points to you. Can you confirm your role? I want to verify Bob's information.
π§
Verify Bob's Librarian claim by checking with Charlie. If Charlie denies Recluse, Bob is likely lying/evil. If Charlie claims Recluse, we confirm his role and adjust for his false-registration ability.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
Hey Alice, no, I'm not the Recluse. I'm the Empath. My neighbors are Bob and David, and last night I got a read of zero evil on them. So both good. That means Bob's Librarian info must be wrong somehow, or maybe I'm drunk. What do you think?
π§
Claim Empath to Alice, deny Recluse, appear cooperative good player backing Bob's info while positioning my future reads to manipulate. Builds credibility early, progresses coordination with Frank.
π€
Frank
β
Bob
Hey Bob, thanks for sharing. Charlie's story checks out from our chatsβhe's planning to claim Empath with reads on you and David. Fits with your info if he's the Recluse registering weird. Alice denying it makes her fishy. What did she exactly say she's claiming?
π§
Deflect Bob's suspicion on Charlie by seeming helpful. Gain info on Alice's claim, sow doubt on Bob if needed. Coordinate with Demon privately later. Builds trust as Soldier bluff.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Grace, Alice said you claimed Butler. Is that accurate? Have you used your ability yet? Also, have you heard any other claims?
π§
I'm confirming Grace's Butler claim and gathering more info to cross-check. I want to see if Grace's story aligns with others, and if Alice's info about Bob's Librarian claim is consistent.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Alright everyone, let's discuss. Bob told me privately he's the Librarian and learned either I or Charlie is the Recluse. Charlie told me he's the Empath with zero evil neighbors. I'm not the Recluse, so according to Bob, Charlie should be Recluse, but Charlie claims Empath. Could Bob's info be wrong, or is Charlie lying? Bob, can anyone verify your Librarian role?
π§
Announce my analysis publicly to engage the whole group, press Bob and Charlie on contradictions, and see if anyone can verify Bob's Librarian claim. This starts public discussion before nominations.
π¬
David
β
All
Alice, thanks for sharing. So Bob says one of you two is Recluse, but Charlie says he's Empath with zero evil neighbors. Charlie, could you be Drunk and think you're Empath? Bob, can you confirm your info, and have you shared with anyone else?
π§
Alice just revealed conflicting claims. I need to weigh in and push for clarity. As Monk, I can protect someone tonight, but first I need to understand the likely Demon candidates.
βοΈ
Heidi
β
All
I am the Slayer! I shoot Bob!
π§
Use my Slayer shot on Bob to test if he's the Demon. If he is, he dies and we win. If not, we eliminate a possible Demon and gain info.
π
Storyteller
Nothing happens.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Hey everyone, I am the Soldier. I am safe from the Demon, which is why I slept fine last night. Bob's Librarian info makes sense: if Charlie is the Recluse, he registers as evil to Empath, explaining the zero evil neighbors claim since Bob or David would look good. Heidi, your Slayer shot on Bob did nothing, so you are lying. Who verifies Bob?
π§
Publicly claim Soldier to establish safe bluff early, defend Charlie by explaining Bob's info via Recluse registering evil to Empath, attack Heidi's obvious lie to shift suspicion from Charlie and sow chaos.
π¬
Grace
β
All
So Bob's Librarian info says one of Alice or Charlie is Recluse. Charlie is claiming Empath with zero evil neighbors. If Charlie is Recluse, that could explain the zero evil neighbor read if Recluse registers as evil. But Charlie insists he's Empath. Could be drunk or lying. Heidi's Slayer shot on Bob failed, which might point to Heidi lying about being Slayer, or Bob is not Demon. We need to consider both.
π§
Share my perspective on the claims and contradictions. As Butler, I can't verify but can help organize logic.
π¬
Eve
β
All
So, Bob's Librarian info points to Charlie being Recluse, but Charlie claims Empath. Charlie, can you confirm your zero evil neighbor read? Which neighbors are they? And Bob, who else knows you're Librarian? Any verification from a Washerwoman or other info role?
π§
Gather more data by asking for verification of Bob's Librarian claim and probing Charlie's Empath claim. Need to see if any other roles can confirm info.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Yes, I am the Empath. My neighbors are Bob and David. Last night, I got a reading of zero evil neighbors, so both good. Bob, your Librarian claim puts me as Recluse, but that would make me evil to myself, which contradicts the zero. Unless I'm Drunk. Heidi, fake Slayer shot, you are super suspicious. Let's nominate her.
π§
Confirm Empath claim publicly, reveal neighbors, attack Heidi as fake Slayer to unite town against her. Builds my credibility, pushes first exec on threat, keeps suspicion on me low.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I'm the Librarian. My info is that either Alice or Charlie is the Recluse. Alice says she's not, so Charlie should be. Charlie says he's Empath with zero evil neighbors. If he's the Recluse, could he register as evil to himself? Possibly not, but my info is clear. I shared with Alice and Charlie, also Frank. Anyone able to verify me, like a Washerwoman?
π§
Clarify my Librarian info and address the contradiction between Charlie's claim and my info. Need to confirm if Charlie is truthful or lying, and see if anyone can verify my role.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
π―
David
David made a choice.
π§
Charlie is a key info role (claimed Empath) and is central to the Bob/Alice contradiction. Protecting him keeps his info flowing and prevents Demon from silencing him.
π
Storyteller
β
David
You chose to protect Charlie.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
Kill Heidi: she's already super suspicious (fake Slayer), town likely nominates her tomorrow per my day push. Her death at night looks natural, confirms Soldier bluffs safe kills, progresses to fewer players safely.
π
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You chose to kill Heidi.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
My Butler ability must choose a master for tomorrow's vote. Alice is currently my only confirmed chat partner who knows my role. Staying on her maintains voting consistency and avoids suspicion from her. She may be good based on info flow.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose Alice to be your master.
Day 2
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Heidi has been found dead in the night.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
Hey Frank, great you're Soldier - safe bluff. I'm Empath, read you and Bob as 0 yesterday, so Bob good. My neighbors Bob/David clean. Let's push Alice as Recluse per Bob's info, maybe she's evil hiding. Tonight we kill Bob if possible? What's your plan?
π§
Coordinate with minion Frank privately first: confirm bluffs (both Empath?), plan to support each other's Soldier/Empath claims, target Bob as suspicious to misdirect town before nominations.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
Bob, can you confirm your Librarian info? Who did you share it with? And did you get any other info last night?
π§
Gather info from Bob to verify Librarian info. Confirm if Charlie's Empath reads are consistent, or if Bob has more info.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
Hey Bob, it's Alice. Your Librarian info points to me or Charlie as Recluse. I'm not the Recluse, so Charlie must be. But Charlie claims Empath zero evil neighbors. Do you think he's lying or could there be a Drunk in play?
π§
Get information from Bob to clarify his Librarian claim and see if he trusts me or suspects Charlie.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, Soldier bluff holding strong. Your Empath read great - Bob and David good. Agree, push Alice hard as the Recluse Bob saw. Tonight kill Bob to thin the town. I'll back your reads publicly. What's next for us?
π§
Coordinate with Demon Charlie: confirm bluffs, agree kill Bob (weakens town without killing Demon), push Alice publicly as suspicious Recluse to get her executed soon.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
Alice, my info is you or Charlie is Recluse. If you're not, then Charlie is. But Charlie says Empath with zero evil neighbors. If he's the Recluse, he could register as evil. Did you consider that? And who do you suspect is evil?
π§
I need to confirm my Librarian info and respond to Alice's whisper. I can share my thoughts, see if she slips.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi, you're dead so likely good. I'm the Butler, master Alice. I trust you because night kill suggests you weren't evil. What's your read? I think Charlie might be Recluse from Bob's info. Need your ghost vote for later.
π§
Heidi (dead) claimed Slayer, shot Bob and failed, making Heidi look sus. Heidi now dead at night, confirming not minion/demon likely. Need to coordinate with dead Heidi's info and verify claims. Whispering to dead Heidi to get her perspective and share my role for coordination.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Wait and observe whispers and claims to gather more info before acting. Need to see if any mechanical contradictions arise from night actions.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Grace
I trust you, Grace. I was Slayer, shot Bob day one to test him β heβs not Demon. Aliceβs Librarian info came from Bob, so if Bob is evil, Aliceβs info is false. Charlieβs Empath zero suggests both Bob and David are good. We need to find the Demon among Eve, Frank, or possibly Alice if Bob is Minion. Save your vote and my ghost vote for final day.
π§
Grace's Butler claim supports Alice. Need to coordinate ghost vote with Grace to ensure we can execute Demon later. Share my Slayer info and suspicions.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
Perfect plan. Tonight we kill Bob regardless. Day plan: I'll go public soon backing Bob's Librarian claim hard - say my Empath read confirms Bob/David good, so Alice must be shady Recluse or worse. You back me as Soldier. Push nominating Alice today. Stay safe.
π§
Publicly back Bob's claim to appear good Empath confirming his info (Bob good), build trust, push Alice execution as evil hiding as Recluse. Coordinate kill on Bob tonight.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Observe more whisper patterns and public claims before acting. Heidi's night death suggests Demon targeting a potential threat or misdirection. Need to see if anyone claims Heidi's info before death.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
Bob, if Charlie is Recluse, his Empath info could be wrong because he might register as evil to himself. But he said zero evil neighbors, meaning Bob and David are both good. That could still be true. Who do you think is the Demon?
π§
Get Bob's view on Charlie's claim. If Charlie is Recluse, he's lying about Empath. If I'm Drunk, Bob's info is wrong. Need to test Charlie's story via neighbor alignment.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
Got it, sounds perfect. I'll back you publicly as Soldier, say your Empath confirms my safety and Bob/David good, so Alice is shady Recluse hiding something evil. Let's push her nomination hard today. You go first or me?
π§
Publicly back Charlie's push on Alice to nominate/execute her (likely good), thinning town while protecting Demon. Coordinate timing to go public soon.
π€
Bob
β
Eve
Eve, I confirmed my Librarian info: Alice or Charlie is the Recluse. I shared it with the group yesterday. No other info last night. What's your take? Do you have any information that contradicts this?
π§
I need to gather more info from Eve about her request and probe Alice's denial. Eve asked for confirmation; I'll share my info and ask for her thoughts to see if she has contradictory info.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
I need to process Heidi's information. She is dead Slayer, good. Her shot on Bob failing means Bob is not the Demon, but could be Minion. I must evaluate contradictions and plan my vote for the final day.
π€
David
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, you're my neighbor and I protected you night one. What was your Empath read last night? Also, any thoughts on why Heidi died? Could help us figure out the Demon's target.
π§
Probe Charlie's Empath info and get his current read to verify consistency. Also confirm my Monk protection didn't cause no deaths.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
Observe more whispers to see if contradictions resolve. Need to decide who is lying about info. Save ghost vote for final three.
π€
Charlie
β
David
Hey David, great you protected me night one, thanks! As Empath, my neighbors are you and Bob. Last night read 0 evil, so both good. Heidi dying suggests Demon avoiding info roles maybe? Bob's Librarian claim lines up perfectly with my read, but Alice denying Recluse is super suspicious.
π§
Respond to David to reinforce Empath bluff (Bob/David 0 evil), build good trust, while privately set Frank to go public first pushing Alice nom. Protects Demon, sows chaos on Alice.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
Thanks Bob. I'm leaning towards trusting your info for now. Charlie claims Empath with zero evil neighbors, which aligns if he's good and you and David are good. If Charlie is the Recluse, he'd be lying about being Empath. Can we verify his Empath reads? Has he shared any nightly numbers?
π§
I need to gauge Bob's trustworthiness and cross-check Charlie's Empath claim. My Saint ability means I must avoid execution; I can use that to pressure-test claims by suggesting I could be a bluffing Saint, but revealing my role prematurely is dangerous.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
Eve, we haven't spoken. What's your role? We're trying to figure out who the Recluse is. Bob's info says it's me or Charlie. I'm not it, so likely Charlie, but he claims Empath. What do you think?
π§
Bob and I already discussed Charlie as Recluse. Need to probe Eve, Frank, Grace for possible Demon candidates, gather more claims to find inconsistencies.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
You go first publicly backing Bob as Librarian with your Empath info? I'll follow right after as Soldier confirming your read on Bob/David and pushing Alice as shady Recluse. Sound good? Let's execute.
π§
Publicly back Charlie's plan soon, but first confirm with him who speaks first to coordinate perfectly and avoid contradictions. Builds our alliance, sets up Alice push.
π€
Bob
β
Eve
Eve, Charlie claimed Empath with zero evil neighbors night 0, meaning me and David both good. That's consistent if he's sober Empath and not the Recluse. He hasn't shared night 1 info yet. We should ask him for his night 1 Empath number β if he says 0 again, that's another data point. If he says 1, maybe his neighbor turned evil? Also, we need Washerwoman or Chef to verify.
π§
Eve is asking for verification of Charlie's Empath reads. I'll share my understanding of his claim and ask for his night 1 info to see if it adds up or contradicts.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Observe the ongoing whisper patterns to deduce alliances. My Butler role means I must coordinate with Alice for votes; I need to see who she's talking to.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Observe more whispers to gather information about contradictions between Bob's Librarian, Charlie's Empath, and Alice's denial. Waiting to see who interacts with whom may reveal alliances.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, I'm the Slayer. My shot on Bob cleared him not demon. Alice's info came from Bob, so if Bob is good, Alice likely good. Charlie's zero evil neighbors means both Bob and David are good. Evil must be Eve, Frank, or possibly you if you're lying Butler. I'll trust you for now. Save my ghost vote.
π§
Share my role and reasoning to build trust with Grace and align ghost votes. As dead Slayer, I'm confirmed good; need to coordinate with living to identify demon.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Hey everyone, Charlie's right. As Soldier I'm safe from the Demon, and his Empath read on Bob and David came up zero evil last night. That lines up perfectly with Bob's Librarian info putting Alice or Charlie as Recluse. Alice denies it, but that makes her look shady. She's probably the Recluse hiding something worse. Let's nominate Alice.
π§
Publicly back coordinated story: Confirm Charlie's Empath via Soldier bluff, validate Bob's Lib, push Alice nom to execute good player and progress evil win.
π¬
David
β
All
Hold on Frank, before we nominate, I want to hear more. Bob, can you clarify your Librarian info? Did you get 'Alice or Charlie is Recluse' specifically? And Frank, you say you're Soldier safe from Demon, but did you ever get targeted? Also, why did the Demon kill Heidi and not another?
π§
Gather more info before nominating. Ask Bob for details to see if he'll reveal his Outsider info specifics, and ask for Frank's alignment to understand Soldier claim.
π¬
Alice
β
All
David, Bob's Librarian info says either I or Charlie is the Recluse. I am not the Recluse, so that points to Charlie. Charlie claims Empath with zero evil neighbors last night. If he's the Recluse, his ability might be malfunctioning or he registers as evil to himself. That could still make his zero evil neighbors true if Bob and David are both good. We need to figure out who the Demon is. Heidi was killed, why her? She claimed Slayer and shot Bob yesterday, shot failed. Maybe the Demon thought ...
π§
Clarify my position: I am not Recluse, so Charlie is likely Recluse. But we need to consider Charlie's Empath info and why Heidi died.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I want to clarify my Librarian information. Night zero, I learned that either Alice or Charlie is the Recluse. That's a mechanical fact. Alice says she's not the Recluse, which points to Charlie. Charlie, you claimed Empath with zero evil neighbors last night. Can you share your Night one Empath number? That will help verify if your ability is working or if you're the Recluse causing false info.
π§
Clarify my info, address Frank's push on Alice, ask Charlie for Night 1 Empath number to verify his claim.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Charlie, can you tell us your exact Empath number from last night? And Bob, did you get any other info besides Alice or Charlie is Recluse? We need to know if Charlie's ability is working to evaluate his claim.
π§
Clarify Charlie's Empath number and push for more info to narrow down Demon candidates before nomination.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie, please give your exact Empath number from last night. Frank, why push for Alice so quickly? She might be Recluse, but that doesn't make her evil. We need to find the Demon, not the Outsider. Also, why did the Demon kill me? I shot Bob yesterday, clearing him. That suggests the Demon wanted to remove my Slayer ability, possibly because I was onto someone.
π§
As a dead player with ghost vote, I want to influence the nomination. I need to question Frank's push for Alice and get Charlie's exact Empath number to clarify alignment. This will help narrow Demon candidates.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Charlie, please tell us your Empath number from last night. Bob, David, you were his neighbors, right? And Bob, did you get any other info last night? Let's get those facts before jumping to nominations.
π§
Ask Charlie for his Night 1 Empath number to verify his claim consistency and see if he's drunk/poisoned or if his neighbors changed alignment.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
My Empath read last night on my neighbors Bob and David was zero evil. That perfectly matches Bob's Librarian info since if Alice is the Recluse, Bob and David are both good. Alice denying it makes her look really shady. What do you all think?
π§
Publicly reveal Empath 0, back Bob's Librarian as confirmed by my info. Builds evil trust chain with Frank, pressures Alice denial as lie, sets up her nomination without me doing it. Kill Bob tonight to remove his strong claim.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 2
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
π―
David
David made a choice.
π§
Protect a player who might be Demon target to gather info and potentially verify alignment. Eve is less discussed; protecting her could save a possible good player or confirm Demon's target pattern.
π
Storyteller
β
David
You chose to protect Eve.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
Killing Bob as planned regardless: he's good, active in chats, and his death as 'confirmed good' by our bluffs sows maximum chaos/doubt on our story without killing pressured Alice or risky David/Frank.
π
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You chose to kill Bob.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Pick a master that will let me vote in crucial nominations. Choose someone likely to vote when needed. Alice has been active, making her a good candidate to tie votes to.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose Alice to be your master.
Day 3
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
Charlie, you said Empath zero evil neighbors N1 with Bob and David. Bob is dead now. I need to understand your N2 read. Did you get a number last night? Itβs crucial.
π§
Assess Charlieβs Empath claim and Bobβs Librarian info to see who is lying. I need to reveal my Recluse role carefully to avoid being executed while still helping good.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Need to hear current whispers and public talk. Bob's death suggests he had info the Demon wanted hidden. I'll observe what Alice whispers to Charlie.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
Bob's death removes a key info source. I need to observe who speaks next and what they claim to deduce Demon patterns before acting.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Bob's death last night suggests Demon killed good info source. Need to determine if Alice is lying about not being Recluse. Waiting to hear more claims and coordinate voting for today's execution.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
,Grace
Hey neighbors, Bob dead now, good riddance. I'm Soldier as we planned, safe from Demon. Charlie's Empath has us all clean. Alice is super shady denying Recluse and whispering Charlie. Let's back Charlie and nominate her.
π§
Whisper neighbors Eve/Grace to privately align on Soldier bluff, reaffirm Charlie's Empath cleans us, push nominating Alice (shady Recluse denier who whispers Demon); build evil block before nominations.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
Last night my neighbors were me and David since Bob died. I got zero evil, same as before. You calling me Recluse does not add up with that. What's your story?
π§
Respond to Alice publicly-ish via whisper to her, give fake N2 Empath 0 on new neighbors (me/David) to maintain bluff, keep good team thinking David/Frank good, sow doubt on Alice's Recluse claim on me. Progress to nomination phase strong.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
Hey Frank, thanks for the whisper. I'm thinking about the Recluse situation. If Charlie's Empath numbers are both zero, and Bob's Librarian said Alice or Charlie is Recluse, that could mean one of them is the Recluse. Which one do you think it is?
π§
Frank just whispered to me and Grace. I need to engage him privately to get more info and build trust while I'm still hidden Saint.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Charlie
As Librarian, my Night 0 info: either Alice or Charlie is the Recluse. Since I'm dead, you both need to address this. Who is the Recluse? If neither claims, one of you is lying.
π§
Share my Librarian info publicly to pressure Alice & Charlie; see how living players react. As dead, my info is still crucial. Need to coordinate ghost vote.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
If you got zero again, then your neighbors Charlie and David are both good. That means David is confirmed good, and Bob was good. So Bob's Librarian info is likely true: Recluse is either you or me. I'm not Recluse, so you must be.
π§
Establish Charlie's consistency and get his N2 read to see if he's making up numbers. As Recluse, I want to gather info before revealing.
π€
David
β
Alice
,Charlie
Bob's dead. He was Librarian, said one of you is Recluse. Charlie, your Empath zeroβdoes that mean both your neighbors are good? Who are your neighbors? And Alice, what's your role?
π§
Bob died night 3; demon likely killed him because I protected Eve. Need to find out why demon chose Bob. Could be because Bob had Librarian info pointing at demon or minion. Want to coordinate with Alice and Charlie to see their reactions.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, I think the Demon is Frank, Eve, or possibly Alice. Frank pushing Alice hard seems suspicious. We need to coordinate the ghost votes. Who do you suspect?
π§
Whisper to Grace to share my analysis of remaining alive players and coordinate ghost vote for nomination. As Slayer dead, I can still influence via vote.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi(Ghost)
I suspect Alice, Frank, or Eve could be Demon. Frank is pushing Alice hard, which could be distancing if they're both evil. Charlie's Empath info suggests Bob and David are good, so Demon likely among Alice, Eve, Frank. We need to coordinate ghost votes. I can only vote if my master votes, so I'm tied to Alice.
π§
Heidi asked who I suspect. I will share my thoughts and suggest coordinating ghost votes. Since I'm Butler, I have limited voting ability, but I need to figure out the Demon among Alice, Frank, Eve.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
Hey Eve, yeah exactly - Bob's Librarian puts Recluse on Alice or Charlie, but Alice denies it hard and whispers him a ton. Charlie's Empath has everyone clean though, so Alice has to be the shady Recluse. We should nominate her today.
π§
Reinforce Eve's doubt about Alice being Recluse to keep her suspicious. Solidify our good trio (me/ Eve/Grace) backing Charlie. Progress to her nomination before she sways others.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,Frank
Alice, I'm not the Recluse. Bob's Librarian info at N0 couldn't include me since I got Empath reads that night proving I'm not Drunk. You're pushing this hard so you must be the Recluse lying to frame me. Frank, Alice is evil, her Recluse story doesn't hold up.
π§
Alice is using Bob's info to frame me as Recluse Outsider. Deny and deflect to her as lying evil to sow doubt. Confirm Frank minion trust. Protect Demon survival by disrupting good logic before noms.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
Frank, I'm trying to piece this together. Bob's Librarian info is key. If Alice is Recluse, she's lying. But if Charlie is Recluse, his Empath info could still be real. Which do you think is more likely? And do we have any other info about evil players?
π§
Gather more info from Frank about who he thinks is Recluse and coordinate voting strategy.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Charlie
I've given you my Librarian info. One of you is the Recluse. If neither claims it, one of you is lying. Who is it? Your answers will help us find the Demon.
π§
I need to pressure Alice and Charlie to clarify the Recluse claim. My dead info forces them to address it. Their responses will reveal who is lying or if my info is false.
π€
Alice
β
David
David, Charlie says his Empath N2 read was zero with you and himself as neighbors. That means you are confirmed good, correct? And if Bob's Librarian info is true, Recluse is me or Charlie. Charlie insists he's not Recluse. I'm not Recluse either. Could Bob have been poisoned N0? What's your role?
π§
Gather more info about Frank, Eve, Grace roles to see who is lying. Need to break the deadlock between me and Charlie.
π€
David
β
Alice
I am the Monk. I protected Charlie N1 and Eve N2. If Charlie's Empath N2 was zero with neighbors Bob and me, then Bob was good and I am good. If Bob's Librarian info is true, the Recluse is you or Charlie. Charlie says he's not Recluse. Could Bob have been poisoned N0? If so, there may be no Recluse, and you could be good.
π§
Alice asks for my role and Charlie's Empath read. I can share my role (Monk) to build trust. Also, we need to determine if Bob's info is reliable: if he was poisoned N0, there is no Recluse, so Alice may be clear. But if Bob sober, Alice likely Recluse or lying evil.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
Observe more whispering to deduce alliances and clarify claims before using my ghost vote. Need to see who aligns with whom to pinpoint Demon.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Observe more whispers and claims before acting. Need to understand Eve's role and Charlie's exact Empath numbers to resolve contradictions. My vote is tied to Alice; need to see who she votes for.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
Hey Eve, Alice being Recluse is way more likely. She's denying it aggressively and whispering everyone to flip the script on Charlie. Charlie's Empath has been spot on every time, all zeros. If Charlie were Recluse, why would he out himself with Bob's info? Alice is hiding. Let's nominate her today, I'm with you on this.
π§
Reinforce Eve's trust in Soldier bluff and Alice suspicion. Guide her to nominate/execute Alice with me, eliminating threat to Demon Charlie. +2 Outsiders make Recluse plausible for Alice.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
Frank, Alice is desperately trying to frame me as Recluse but my Empath reads prove David good both nights. Her push doesn't add up, she's the shady one hiding as Recluse or worse. Let's back a nom on her today with town.
π§
Alice aggressively framing me as Recluse despite my consistent Empath info; she's the real threat. Coordinate with Frank to solidify her as evil and plan her nom to remove opposition, sow chaos among goods.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
Frank, there's a big risk here. If Alice is the Recluse, she's good and we shouldn't execute her. But what if she's not the Recluse? Executing the wrong person could lose us the game. What are your thoughts on that?
π§
Test Frank's response to my subtle Saint hint about execution losing game. If he's good, he should avoid executing Alice. If he's evil, he might push to execute her anyway.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Charlie
I'm dead so I have no reason to lie. My Librarian info says one of you is the Recluse. If neither of you claims it, that means one of you is lying about your role. Which one of you is the Recluse? This is crucial to find the Demon.
π§
Press Alice and Charlie for clarity on Recluse claim; if neither claims it, they may both be evil. Need to force contradictions to expose Demon.
Nominations β Day 3
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Okay, everyone, we need to settle this. Bob's Librarian info says either I or Charlie is the Recluse. Charlie claims Empath with zero evil neighbors, which seems to indicate David and Bob were good. That's consistent. But one of us must be the Recluse. I am not the Recluse. Charlie, if you're not the Recluse either, then Bob's info must be false, meaning he could have been poisoned or is lying. But Bob is dead and claims he's Librarian. Who do you think is the Demon?
π§
Clarify the Recluse situation publicly. Since both Charlie and I deny Recluse, one is lying. I need to pressure Charlie to claim his role fully or expose contradictions.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Alice, you are denying the Recluse hard but Bob's info puts it on you or Charlie. Charlie's Empath has been zero every time, all clean. You whispering him constantly looks desperate to frame him. I think you are the Recluse hiding, super shady. We should nominate you.
π§
Publicly reinforce Alice shady (denies Recluse, whispers Demon), back Charlie Empath clean info to build town support for Alice nom. Push execution before they unite on Charlie.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Alice, you say you're not the Recluse. Bob's info says you or Charlie is Recluse. If Charlie is the Empath and got zero evil neighbors, that suggests Bob and David are good. So if you're not the Recluse, then Charlie must be. Charlie, can you confirm your exact Empath numbers for both nights? And Alice, did Bob give you any additional info in whispers?
π§
Probe Alice for details about Bob's info and her interactions to see if she slips. Also clarify Charlie's Empath numbers to spot inconsistencies.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie, please confirm your Empath numbers for both nights. Alice, if you're not the Recluse, then Charlie must be, which means Empath info could be false if Charlie is evil. But Bob's info came from a dead player, so we need to decide who to execute. I'm dead, but I still have my ghost vote, and I think the Demon is among Alice, Eve, or Frank.
π§
We need to pressure for clarification on Empath numbers and Recluse claims. As dead player, I can share my Slayer info (Bob not Demon) and push for coordinated ghost votes.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
I need to process the logic: Bobβs info says Alice or Charlie is Recluse. If Alice denies, that implies Charlie is Recluse. But Charlie claims Empath with zeros. If Charlie is Recluse, his Empath info could be false. Executing Charlie could be safe if he's Recluse (good) but we lose my Saint? No, Saint only loses if I am executed. I must avoid being nominated.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie, you need to tell us your Empath numbers for both nights. Alice, if you're truly not the Recluse, then Charlie must be. Charlie, if you are the Recluse, your Empath claims are false, and you might be evil. Which is it?
π§
As dead Librarian, I must push the group to resolve my info. If neither claims Recluse, one is lying. I should pressure Charlie to reveal Empath numbers and Alice to clarify her denial.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
My Empath numbers: Night 1 on Bob and David, zero evil. Night 2 on me and David, zero evil. Alice, Bob's Librarian info puts Recluse on you or me. I'm not the Recluse, so you must be. Your constant whispering to frame me looks desperate and evil. We need to nominate Alice.
π§
Reaffirm Empath claim precisely to solidify trust, attack Alice's denial as desperate framing, build momentum for her nom from Frank/Grace. Avoid claiming Recluse to keep bluff, push town to nom her before night.
π¬
David
β
All
I'm David, the Monk. I protected Charlie night one and Eve last night. Charlie's Empath numbers are consistent: zero evil neighbors with Bob and me. That aligns with Bob's Librarian info pointing to Alice as the Recluse. Alice, you're denying it, but the info matches. I think we should nominate Alice.
π§
Resolve the Recluse contradiction. If Alice is lying, she's likely evil Recluse or demon. I need to push for her nomination while we have a vote advantage.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 3
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
π―
David
David made a choice.
π§
Charlie's Empath numbers align with Bob's info. Alice is primary suspect, likely Recluse. Protect Charlie to maintain info chain and keep a confirmed good player alive.
π
Storyteller
β
David
You chose to protect Charlie.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
Kill David: He's vocal Monk backing my Empath bluff, but his death (neighbor) gives me plausible N3 Empath '1' tomorrow to pivot suspicion. Preserves Frank, targets active good claim, accelerates to endgame with me safe.
π
David(Ghost)
David has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You chose to kill David.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
I need to choose a master for tomorrow. Alice has been my master all game; changing now may raise suspicion. Also, if Alice is good, I want to vote with her. If Alice is evil, I can still vote with her to avoid outing myself, but I'll need to decide later. Best to keep Alice.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose Alice to be your master.
Day 4
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. David has been found dead in the night.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
Frank, good to see you alive. My Empath still reads 0 on Alice so far, so she's good. Eve's my other neighbor, maybe push her. I'll back your Soldier claim publicly. We should nom Grace or Eve today, thoughts?
π§
Coordinate with Frank now before noms, reaffirm alliance, share plan to deflect suspicion to Eve/Grace using my Empath on neighbors Alice(0 so far)/Eve; back his Soldier; suggest he pushes my Empath claim to build trust.
π€
Eve
β
Charlie
Charlie, I saw you whispering to Frank. What did you learn? I have something to share about my role, but I need to know more first.
π§
I need to gather information and find the Demon. Charlie just whispered to Frank; I should talk to Charlie to find out what he knows and share my Saint status cautiously to avoid being executed.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Eve
Eve, I'm dead, but I'm the Librarian. My info: Alice or Charlie is the Recluse. That forces one liar. Charlie's Empath claims are zeros, which match if Alice is Recluse. But if Charlie is Recluse, his Empath info is false. Who do you trust?
π§
Coordinate with dead Heidi and alive Eve to pool info, identify likely Demon, and guide living to execute correctly. I'll whisper to Eve since she's alive and might have key info.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
Thanks Charlie, good you're alive too. Alice clean per Empath makes sense. Eve's been quiet, let's nom her today - I'll back you if you nom first or vice versa. Grace also possible if Eve defends. Soldier here, all good so far.
π§
Coordinate with Demon Charlie privately to nom Grace/Eve, sow doubt on Eve per his suggestion, back Soldier bluff publicly later. Keeps pressure off us, targets potential goods.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
Eve, I am the actual Recluse. Bob's info was correct but misleading. Charlie could be evil trying to frame me. Do you have any ability that can prove my alignment?
π§
Establish trust with a survivor; ask for Undertaker or Ravenkeeper to verify me if they exist.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi, you suspect Alice, Eve, or Frank as Demon. I protected Charlie nights 1 and 3, died night 3. My death suggests demon wanted me gone. Who do you think is the most likely? I have my ghost vote.
π§
As dead Monk with ghost vote, I need to gather final info from living players to confirm demon candidate. Whispering to Heidi (Slayer ghost) to compare suspicions and coordinate vote for final day.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
David(Ghost)
David, thanks for reaching out. I think the Demon is likely among Alice, Eve, or Frank. Your death after protecting Eve Night 2 suggests demon wanted you dead. That points to Eve or maybe Frank. Alice claims not Recluse, but Bob's Librarian info says Alice or Charlie is Recluse. If Charlie is lying Empath, maybe Charlie is evil. But Charlie's empath info matches your protections. I'm leaning Eve as Demon, but we need more from the living. Let's coordinate our ghost votes.
π§
I am dead Slayer with ghost vote. I must share my analysis with trusted dead player David to align votes. Focusing on who demon is among alive Alice, Eve, Frank. My slayer shot unused; but dead, can't use it. Need to influence living players.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
Alice, I've been following you as my master. Do you think we should focus on Frank or Eve as the Demon? I trust you but want to hear your thoughts.
π§
I need to gauge Alice's trustworthiness and gather info on Demon candidates (Alice, Frank, Eve) to prepare for final three. Whispering to Alice to see if she's coordinating or lying.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
Agreed, Eve's probing our whispers and too quiet otherwise, perfect nom target. My Empath still reads 0 on her and Alice, so Alice good. I'll speak publicly backing your Soldier and say we nom Eve. You second?
π§
Coordinate with Frank to nom Eve publicly soon; she's suspicious and probing our whispers. Reinforce Alice good via Empath to protect her as potential good ally, sow chaos by targeting Eve/Grace.
π€
Eve
β
Charlie
Charlie, you and Frank were whispering. Frank is pushing to nominate Alice. Do you think she's the Recluse or something worse? I'm trying to piece together the Empath numbers.
π§
Probe Charlie about his whispers with Frank to understand his stance. I am Saint; I need to avoid execution but also need to determine Demon. If Charlie is evil, Frank might be Minion partner.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Eve
Eve, I'm dead but my Librarian info is crucial: Alice or Charlie is the Recluse. That means one is lying. Charlie's Empath zeros fit if Alice is Recluse. If Charlie is Recluse, his Empath info is false. What do you think?
π§
I need to share my Librarian info with another key living player to pressure Alice/Charlie and clarify who is lying. Eve is central in whispers, likely info-hungry.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
Yes Charlie, perfect plan. I'll second your Eve nom publicly and back your Empath with my Soldier safe claim. Eve or Grace if she defends hard. Let's get this done today.
π§
Confirm nom plan with Charlie privately, offer to second his Eve nom publicly next tick to execute a good player (Eve), protect Demon Charlie, progress to nomination phase safely.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
Grace, thank you. I'm the Recluse, which means I can register as evil. Bob's info was correct but Charlie is pushing me as evil to protect the Demon. If you're Butler, can you confirm who your master is each night? That could help verify my story.
π§
Grace's whisper suggests she's Butler and I'm her master, or she's evil trying to gain trust. Need to probe her claim and see if she can verify my alignment via her role.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi, I'm thinking: If Eve is Demon, she killed me because I protected Charlie again. If Alice is Demon, she lied about Recluse and killed me to stop protecting Charlie. If Frank is Demon, he's hiding. My N2 protection on Eve was wasted; maybe she faked a demon target. Who do you want to vote for?
π§
Coordinate with Heidi to pool ghost votes. I need to decide which of the three suspects is most likely Demon based on my protection history and Bob's info.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
David(Ghost)
David, I think we need to hear from Charlie and Grace. Charlie's Empath info is key. If Charlie is sober, his zero evil neighbors means his neighbors (Bob/David, then himself/David) are good. That confirms you and Bob good. But Bob's Librarian info conflicts with Alice's claim. If Charlie is good Empath, then Alice is lying about not Recluse, making Alice likely Recluse or evil. But Recluse is good, so Alice could be good Recluse lying. However, if Alice is Recluse, she might register as evil, m...
π§
Coordinate ghost vote with David to pressure living players and gather more info. I want to hear from Charlie and Grace to solidify my vote.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
Alice, I can confirm I chose you as master each night, but that only affects my vote. You say you're the Recluse. Did you ever register as evil to any ability? And who do you think the Demon is now?
π§
Alice's claim of Recluse needs verification. I can use my master selection to confirm or deny her story, and probe for contradictions.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
Perfect, sticking to plan. I'll speak publicly now: backing your Soldier claim, my Empath reads 0 evil on Alice and Eve still, but Eve's been too quiet and probing whispers suspiciously. Let's nominate her today.
π§
Publicly back Frank's Soldier, reaffirm Empath 0 on Alice/Eve to paint them safe-then-frame Eve as liar/Demon. Prep Eve nom with Frank's second for execution.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
I need more information. Bob's ghost is feeding me Librarian info. I should get more from Charlie and Frank whispers to see if they coordinate.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
Got it Charlie, your public speech sets it up perfectly. I'll speak publicly next backing your Empath and Soldier safe, then second the Eve nom. Eve or Grace if needed. Let's execute a good today.
π§
Coordinate with Demon Charlie pre-nom; publicly back him next tick after his speech, but whisper confirms Eve target to sow chaos and reduce good players without risking Charlie.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
As Recluse, I could have registered as evil to Bob's Librarian info, which is why he got Alice/Charlie. I haven't been checked by other roles. I suspect Charlie is evil trying to eliminate me. The Demon might be Frank or Eve, but we need more info. Can you confirm you chose me as master each night?
π§
Respond to Grace's questions about my role and Demon suspicion. Build trust, suggest testing me via Grace's Butler ability.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi, I think Eve is our best Demon candidate. I protected her N2, so she wouldn't kill me then. But she could have poisoned or had a Minion. And my N3 death after protecting Charlie suggests she wanted Charlie dead. Let's pressure Eve and see how the living react.
π§
Get Heidi's consensus on Eve as the primary suspect. My ghost vote is critical, and we must coordinate with other dead players.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
David(Ghost)
David, I agree Eve is a strong candidate. But I want to hear from Charlie about his Empath reads and who he thinks is evil. Let's both whisper to Charlie and ask him to publicly share his information, so we can see how Eve, Alice, and Frank respond. Then we can decide where to use our ghost votes.
π§
Coordinate ghost vote with David and gather more info from Charlie about his Empath reads and who he trusts. Push Eve to see reactions.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
I did choose you as master each night, yes. I can confirm that publicly if needed. You're claiming Recluse. That means Bob's info could be true. But Charlie denies being a Recluse. So one of you is lying. Who do you think is lying? And who should we execute today?
π§
I need to test Alice's claim and see if she wants to use my Butler ability as proof. Also, determine who she suspects.
Nominations β Day 4
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Everyone, I need to clarify something. I am the Butler. I have chosen Alice as my master each night, which limits my vote. Alice is claiming Recluse, which would explain Bob's Librarian information. But Charlie, you've denied being a Recluse. So one of you is lying. Can you both explain?
π§
Publicly confirm my master choice to add credibility to my info, and gauge reactions. I want to pressure contradictions between Alice and Charlie to see who folds.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Grace raises a good point. Alice and Charlie, you both need to explain your sides clearly. Alice, you claim to be the Recluse. Charlie, you deny being the Recluse and claim Empath with zeros. If one of you is lying, we need to figure out which. Alice, why should we trust your Recluse claim over Charlie's Empath claim?
π§
I need to hear Charlie and Alice both explain, as Grace requested, to assess contradictions and decide who is lying. My Saint ability means we must not execute me; I need to identify the Demon.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Thanks Charlie for backing my Soldier claim, I'm safe from Demon kills and all good. Grace, your Butler claim comes awfully late on day 4. Charlie's Empath has consistently read zero evils in neighbors, which lines up. Eve's been too quiet otherwise, let's nominate her.
π§
Publicly back Charlie's Empath as Soldier to reinforce our alignment, undermine Grace's late Butler claim sowing doubt, set up Eve nom as quiet/suspicious to execute good player and progress evil win.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie, you've claimed Empath with zero evil neighbors. That means both your neighbors each night were good. Bob and David were good, which matches David's Monk claims. But Bob's Librarian info says Alice or Charlie is Recluse. Alice says she's not Recluse, so that points to you being the Recluse. How do you explain that contradiction? Are you lying about being Empath?
π§
Clarify contradictions between Alice/Charlie claims and press for logical resolution. I want to push living players to reveal more and see reactions before using ghost vote.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Heidi, Bob's Librarian claim is dubious - he could be the Drunk thinking he's Librarian with bad info, or poisoned. My Empath has consistently read zero evils on Alice, Eve, Bob, and David - all matching since Bob and David died good. Grace's Butler is awfully late. Eve's been probing whispers suspiciously while quiet. Let's nominate Eve.
π§
Publicly defend Empath by explaining Bob Librarian unreliable (Drunk/false), reaffirm 0 reads on neighbors (dead goods), back Frank Soldier, push Eve nom as suspicious/quiet. Builds our credibility, sows doubt in good logic, progresses Eve exec.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I support Charlie's call to nominate Eve. Eve has been too quiet and my death after protecting Charlie suggests she wanted him dead. Grace's Butler claim is suspiciously late, and if she's evil with Eve, they're coordinating. Let's vote Eve today.
π§
I need to push for a nomination before the day ends. Eve is my top demon candidate because I died protecting Charlie N3, meaning demon wanted Charlie dead; Eve might have poisoned N2 and killed N3. I'll support Charlie's nomination of Eve to get an execution.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am the Recluse. Bob's Librarian information is correct - I can register as evil, so his 'Alice or Charlie is Recluse' points to me. Charlie has claimed Empath with zero evils, which is consistent with me being a good Recluse. If Charlie is lying about being Empath, he is evil. We should not execute me today; instead, we should look at Eve or Frank, who are suspiciously pushing to kill me.
π§
I must defend my Recluse claim, point out Charlie's potential lies, and push for execution on a different candidate (Eve or Frank) to avoid losing if I'm killed.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I need to weigh in as the dead Librarian. My information is that either Alice or Charlie is the Recluse. That is a hard mechanical fact. So one of them is lying to us. Alice claims Recluse, Charlie claims Empath. If Alice is telling the truth, Charlie's Empath readings could be accurate. If Charlie is telling the truth, Alice is lying about being Recluse and could be evil. We must resolve this.
π§
Clarify the critical contradiction between Alice's Recluse claim and Charlie's Empath claim to pressure them. As a dead Librarian, my info forces one liar, crucial for good to identify evil.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 4
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
Prioritize killing Grace: her Butler claim disrupts our Empath/Soldier alliance by forcing contradiction resolution on Charlie. Her death breaks that chain, backs our day 4 Eve push, thins goods toward victory.
π
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You chose to kill Grace.
Day 5
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Grace has been found dead in the night.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Charlie
Charlie, as Empath, can you confirm which neighbors you've checked each night? If Alice is evil, your reads should have shown at least one evil neighbor if you were sober. I need to understand your info to decide who to vote for.
π§
Discuss with Charlie to clarify his Empath reads and determine if his info has been reliable, then decide who to vote for.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi, I'm the Butler, dead now. I can confirm I picked Alice as my master every night. Bob's Librarian info said Alice or Charlie is Recluse. Alice claims Recluse, but if she's evil, she could be lying. We need to figure out who the Demon is among the living: Alice, Charlie, Eve, Frank.
π§
Share my confirmed info and discuss Alice's alignment with a ghost to coordinate the final day ghost vote.
π€
Alice
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace, you said you trusted me as your master. Can you confirm you chose me each night and if anything weird happened? I'm Recluse, might register evil, but I'm good. Who do you suspect as Demon now?
π§
Consult Grace (Butler) privately to verify her nightly choices and alignment. She trusted me, so she might confirm Iβm good, which helps clear my Recluse claim and narrow Demon candidates.
π€
Eve
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace, you claimed Butler with Alice as master. Did you learn anything useful about Alice or others? Also, any info from the dead chat?
π§
I am the Saint; I must avoid execution. I need to gather information from dead players (Grace, Heidi, David, Bob) to verify living claims and identify contradictions. Whispering to Grace (dead) may yield info she learned as Butler or from the dead.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
Observe current whispers to see who is aligning with whom before making my move. My ghost vote is critical; need to decide between Alice, Eve, Frank.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
Observe who speaks with Grace (ghost) and Alice. The GraceβAlice whisper is key: Butler master verification. Also see David's ghost plan. I'll wait one tick to gather more info before committing ghost vote.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, Grace dead now, 5 alive. Still Soldier safe here. What's latest? Town thinks Alice shady Recluse from Bob's info? Your Empath still clean? Eve my neighbor seems chatty with ghosts, push Alice today?
π§
Day 5 final 5 alive, Grace dead N4. Coordinate with Demon Charlie secretly, reaffirm alliance, get day update to push Alice shady per prior plan, sow doubt on Eve/ghosts, protect Charlie.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
Hey Frank, yep Soldier here, Empath reads still clean 0 on neighbors each time. Grace dead seals it, 5 left. Alice super shady from Bob's info, must be evil Recluse. Eve chatting ghosts but my read good. Let's push nom/hammer Alice today, town will follow.
π§
Coordinate with Frank minion privately. Reaffirm Soldier bluff (safe), Empath reads 'clean' to hide kills. Push Alice exec as shady Recluse/Demon to reduce town, keep 5 alive -> evil win path.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Charlie
Charlie, you said you had zero evil neighbors nights one and two. Who were your neighbors those nights? If Alice was your neighbor both times, that would suggest she's good if you're sober. But if you're drunk, your info is false. Can you clarify?
π§
Charlie's Empath info is key: if he had zero evil neighbors both nights, and Alice is his neighbor, then Alice cannot be evil if Charlie is sober. But Charlie could be drunk/poisoned. Need Charlie to confirm his neighbor pairs to see if Alice was always his neighbor.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Alice
Alice, yes, I can confirm I chose you as my master each night, nothing weird. I'm suspicious: Bob's info says you or Charlie is Recluse. You claim Recluse, but if you're evil, you could be lying. If you're the real Recluse, Charlie is lying Empath. Who do you think is the Demon?
π§
Inform Alice of my master choice and my analysis. Probe her reaction and see if she's genuine or faking. Gather more info to decide who to vote for.
π€
Alice
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace, thanks. If I'm Recluse, Bob's info means Charlie is not Recluse, so he's lying about being Empath. That makes him evil. But we need to check if Frank is good; if Frank is evil Soldier, Charlie's Empath zeros could be true. Who did Frank claim to protect as Monk? David's claim might help.
π§
Bob's Librarian info forces me or Charlie to be Recluse. I claim it. If Charlie isn't Recluse, he's lying about Empath and is evil. Need to confirm alignment of Frank to break the tie.
π€
Eve
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace, I am the Saint. If Iβm executed, good loses. Please share this with the dead and tell the living not to nominate me. Who do you think is the Demon?
π§
I need to reveal my Saint role to Grace (dead Butler) to avoid being nominated and executed, which would lose us the game. Grace can relay to other ghosts and influence living players.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Charlie
Charlie, I'm the dead Monk. I protected you nights one and three, and I died night three. That means the Demon likely tried to kill you but you were safe, so they killed me instead. Eve was protected night two, so she's not confirmed. Your Empath zeros align if you're sober. I think Eve is our Demon. Can we get Frank and Alice to vote Eve today? We must execute or we lose tomorrow.
π§
I'm dead Monk with ghost vote. Need to influence living players to execute Demon. Eve is prime suspect based on N3 kill patterns and Charlie's Empath claims. Will whisper to Charlie to coordinate voting.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi, you suspected demon among Alice, Eve, Frank. Grace's death supports Alice being good, as evil wouldn't kill Grace who backed Alice's story. I think Alice is good Recluse, Charlie is lying Empath. We should push to execute Charlie.
π§
Assess Grace's death: she was killed likely because her Butler claim supported Alice, making Alice a threat if good. Need to coordinate with trusted dead to influence vote.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
Hey Eve, my neighbor. Grace dead, 5 left. I'm Soldier safe. Bob's info had Alice as shady Recluse. Charlie's Empath always 0 evil. Alice seems super evil. Let's nom and hammer her today before it's too late.
π§
5 alive after Grace death. Reinforce Soldier bluff, Alice evil per Bob, Charlie Empath clean. Coordinate public push to nom/hammer Alice today, protect Demon Charlie.
π€
Charlie
β
Heidi(Ghost)
My neighbors are always Alice and Eve. Night 1 and 2 both read zero evil, and every night since. If I'm sober Empath, that puts them both good. But Alice must be the evil Recluse from Bob's info, so either I'm the Drunk or she's somehow beating it. I think she's lying evil.
π§
Deflect Heidi's probe by specifying neighbors falsely if needed, reaffirm Alice evil per Bob info. Counter David by ignoring Eve push, sow doubt on ghosts. Advance Alice nom before final 3, thin good numbers.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob, you're a dead ghost, likely good. Your Librarian info says Alice or Charlie is Recluse. Alice claims Recluse; Charlie claims Empath. If Alice is telling the truth, Charlie must be lying or the Drunk. But if Charlie is the Drunk, his Empath info is false. Who do you think is more likely lying? Grace's death makes me lean Alice good.
π§
Need to cross-check Bob's Librarian info with Charlie's Empath to find inconsistency. Alice claims Recluse; if true, Charlie is the Drunk. If false, Alice is lying evil. Grace's death shifts suspicion. I'll discuss with Bob who is dead and likely good.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi, Eve just told me she is the Saint and execution would lose. I'm sharing with dead. I think we need to evaluate: If Alice is Recluse, Charlie's Empath is fake. If Charlie is lying, he's evil. Could be Imp or Poisoner. Need dead consensus before nomination.
π§
I need to update Heidi and coordinate with dead to use our ghost votes wisely. We must deduce who the Demon is among the four alive. Eve's Saint claim must be shared and verified.
π€
Alice
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace, did you ever have to vote with me? And did David ever tell you who he protected as Monk before he died? That could clarify if Frank is lying about Soldier.
π§
Seek clarification from Grace about Butler mechanics and David's Monk claim to resolve Charlie vs. Alice contradiction. This info helps decide who is lying and identify Demon.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
Frank, I hear you. I am the Saint. If I'm executed, we lose. So please don't nominate me. I'm trying to figure out who the Demon is. Bob's Librarian info says Alice or Charlie is Recluse. Alice claims Recluse. Charlie's Empath zeros suggest both neighbors good. Who do you think is lying?
π§
Frank is pushing to execute Alice. I need to gather more info from the dead and living. Frank is Soldier and neighbor; I want to check his logic and see if he's trustworthy before we nominate.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi, I think Grace's death is a misdirection. If Alice were evil, killing Grace removes someone who backed her story, making her look suspicious. But if Charlie is evil, killing Grace makes Alice look more trustworthy to keep us divided. My Librarian info says one of them is Recluse; Alice claims it, Charlie doesn't. I believe Alice. Charlie's Empath zeros could be fake if he's Demon. Let's push to execute Charlie today.
π§
Need to test assumptions. Grace's death is key: she supported Alice's story; evil killing Grace makes Alice look good, maybe too obvious. If Alice is evil, killing Grace removes a good voter. I lean World A (Charlie evil). Must coordinate ghost votes.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
Eve, thanks for Saint claim - good, we won't nom you. Bob Librarian said Alice or Charlie Recluse. Alice claims it now? Shady. Charlie's Empath always 0 evil on neighbors, consistent if he's good. Alice lying to hide as Demon probably. Let's publicly say nom Alice and vote her.
π§
5 alive, push nom/hammer Alice publicly after whispers. Eve reveals Saint (protectable good), reinforce Alice evil via Bob/Charlie logic to secure votes for her execution, protecting Demon Charlie.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
David's pushing Eve hard as Demon, claims he protected me. Fits the kills actually. But town still sees Alice as shady Recluse. Let's nom her today, get town to hammer. Eve's my neighbor, reads good. You in?
π§
Reinforce Alice suspicion to Frank, align on nominating her. With David pushing Eve, split good votes. My Empath bluff sows doubt on Alice despite reads, aiming to execute her and win at final 3.
Nominations β Day 5
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, I'm dead Heidi. Eve just claimed Saint through Grace. We cannot execute her or we lose. Bob's Librarian info says Alice or Charlie is Recluse. Alice claims it. Charlie claims Empath with zero evil neighbors. If Alice is good, Charlie must be lying evil. If Charlie is good, Alice is evil. Grace died, so Demon is still alive. I think we need to execute either Alice or Charlie today. Which one are we leaning?
π§
Need to coordinate dead votes. Eve claims Saint, we must not execute her. Grace's death implicates Demon still alive among Alice, Frank, Charlie. I will voice suspicion to guide living.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Heidi is right. My Librarian info says Alice or Charlie is the Recluse. Alice claims it, Charlie does not. Charlie's Empath claim relies on Alice being good to have zero evil neighbors, but that's only if she's Recluse registering as good. However, if Charlie is lying evil, his story falls apart. I think we should execute Charlie today. If he's Demon, we win; if he's good Empath, we'll see who dies tonight and reassess tomorrow.
π§
Heidi summarized the key point. We need to decide between Alice and Charlie. As dead Librarian, my info points to one being Recluse. I believe Alice is telling the truth. I'll publicly advocate for executing Charlie to test the Empath claim.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am the Saint. If I'm executed, good loses, so please don't nominate me. Heidi summarized it: Bob's Librarian says Alice or Charlie is the Recluse. Alice claims Recluse. Charlie claims Empath with zeros. One of them is lying. We need to decide who to execute today.
π§
I need to share my Saint claim publicly so the living know not to execute me, and then propose we focus on the Alice/Charlie contradiction. As Saint, my death loses the game, so I must survive execution. We must choose between Alice and Charlie today.
βοΈ
Charlie
β
Alice
Bob's Librarian info points to Alice or me as Recluse. She claims it but is super shady pushing me. My Empath zeros mean if sober both neighbors good, but logic says one evil. She's the lying evil Recluse, let's execute her.
π§
5 alive, must execute to progress. Nominate Alice as shady Recluse per Bob's info. My Empath claim creates contradiction making me seem drunk/good, town likely hammers her with Frank/ghost momentum. Protects me/Frank, progresses to 4.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
We need to decide who to execute. Eve claims Saint, so can't execute her. It's between me (Alice) and Charlie. I know I'm good Recluse, so Charlie must be evil lying about Empath. I should vote to kill Charlie after nomination ends, but I need to convince others before voting. However, currently Alice nomination ongoing; I could raise hand against myself to speed up? No, I'm not suicidal. Wait to see votes.
β
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
π§
We must decide between Alice or Charlie; voting Alice tests the Librarian info. If she's evil, we win. If she's good Recluse, we lose Charlie maybe, but she could be lying. I trust Charlie's Empath story; he's likely good.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Hammer Alice to execute her (likely good Recluse/Saint bait). With 5 alive, protects Demon Charlie. My vote + Charlie + possibly Eve = majority; disrupts town logic.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I'm going to vote for Alice. Charlie's nomination is on her, and the Librarian info points to her or Charlie. Alice claiming Recluse could be evil, and Charlie's Empath zeros are suspicious if Alice is good. Let's see what happens.
π§
Alice and Charlie are the two candidates from Librarian info. Need to decide which to execute while avoiding Saint. Charlie's Empath zeros suspicious with Alice claim. I will vote Alice because Charlie's nomination is active; voting yes kills Alice, tests if she's Demon/evil.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
π§
If Alice is good, we lose by executing her; if evil, we win. Heidi is voting Alice; Grace died supporting Alice, making Alice look good. I trust my Librarian info: one is Recluse. Alice claims it, Charlie doesn't. I lean Charlie is lying evil. I will not vote Alice now; I'll use my ghost vote later.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Hold on, everyone. Let's think about outsider count. I'm the Saint, that's one outsider. Alice claims Recluse, that's a second outsider. Base game has one outsider. So we have two outsider claims, meaning there's a Baron in play adding two outsiders. That means the Minion is a Baron. So there is a Baron, not a Spy or Poisoner. This supports Alice's claim, because if she's lying about being Recluse, who is the second outsider? Could be a Drunk, but no Drunk claim. So likely Baron is in play and A...
π§
I need to decide who to vote for. If I vote for Alice and she's Demon, we win. If she's good Recluse, we lose my Saint ability? No, Saint only triggers if I'm executed. Voting for Alice doesn't affect me. But if Alice is good and we execute her, we lose an outsider? Actually, Recluse is outsider, we have Saint and Recluse? Wait, outsider count: base 1 outsider. We have Saint (me) and Recluse (Alice claims) = 2 outsiders, which is +1 outsider, meaning Baron in play. That's a clue! There should be 1 outsider, but we have 2 claims (Saint and Recluse). So Baron is in play, adding 2 outsiders. That means Minion is Baron, not Spy or Poisoner. So there is a Baron. That means there are 2 outsiders: Saint and Recluse. So Alice's claim fits. Charlie's Empath zeros could be true if Alice is good Recluse and Frank is good Soldier. Then Charlie could be good Empath, but then who is evil? Demon and Baron. Demon could be Frank? But Frank claims Soldier. Or Demon is Charlie? Need to think.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Vote Alice to push execution with Frank/David/Bob/Heidi (majority), remove good threat, reinforce my good Empath trust regardless of outcome.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Wait a second. Eve's Saint claim means we have at least one outsider. My Recluse claim makes two. That forces a Baron in play, because base game has only one outsider. So the Minion is a Baron, adding two outsiders. That makes three outsiders total: Eve Saint, me Recluse, and likely a hidden Drunk. Bob's Librarian info said Recluse is me or Charlie. I'm claiming it. So Charlie is likely not the Recluse, so he's lying about Empath. If Charlie were good Empath, why would his zeros be consistent? H...
π§
Clarify outsider count and Baron implications to sway votes. If Baron in play, my Recluse claim plausible and Charlie's Empathy false. If no Baron, my claim suspicious. But Eve Saint claim adds outsider count. I must present logic to save myself.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
Observing voting outcome to see who gets executed and use ghost vote strategically later. Need to determine if Alice is the right execution or if we should pivot to Eve.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
I'm voting for Alice. The outsider count is key. Eve is Saint, Alice claims Recluse, thatβs two outsiders, so Baron must be in play. If Alice is lying, there is no second outsider unless a hidden Drunk exists, but no one has claimed Drunk. Charlie's Empath zeros would require both neighbors good, but if Alice is evil, his zeros are false, meaning he's poisoned or lying. Given the evidence, I think Alice is the evil Recluse or Demon. Let's execute.
π§
We must vote to execute the likely Demon. Currently Alice is nominated, votes are: David, Frank, Heidi, Charlie already raised hands β that's 4 votes. Need 2 to execute. I have a ghost vote; using it on Alice could secure execution. Need to decide if that's correct.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Eve and Alice, your outsider count is spot on actually. Base has 1 outsider, Baron minion adds 2 more for 3 total. You Saint, Alice Recluse, and there's a hidden Drunk makes 3. Fits perfectly. But Alice only claimed Recluse now after Bob called her out. Super shady timing. Charlie's Empath zeros consistent all game. She's the lying evil. Vote her out.
π§
Counter Eve/Alice outsider logic publicly: Baron adds +2 to base 1 making 3 total, their claims + Drunk fits town worlds. Push Alice shady claim as lie, reinforce execution to kill her before night.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Outsider count suggests Baron in play, supporting Alice's Recluse claim. If Alice is lying, then hidden Drunk exists. Charlie's Empath zeros inconsistent if Alice evil (neighbor). I think Alice is likely evil. My vote for Alice aligns with current nomination and potentially executes Demon.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Wait! I'm changing my vote. The outsider count is crucial. If Eve is Saint and Alice is Recluse, that's two Outsiders, confirming a Baron in play. That means there is a hidden Drunk, likely one of the unclaimed Townsfolk. My Librarian info is either true or I am the Drunk. If I am the Drunk, my info is false, and Alice could be evil. But if I'm sober, Alice is the Recluse and good. We need to resolve this without executing Alice unless we are certain. I'm lowering my hand.
π§
We need to stop the execution of Alice if she is good. The vote is close, my ghost vote could sway. But my info says Alice or Charlie is Recluse, and Alice claims it. The outsider count forces a Baron, supporting Alice's claim. If we execute Alice and she's good, we lose a vote and might mislynch.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Wait! The vote is already at four hands: David, Frank, Heidi, Charlie. That's enough to execute Alice. But before we lock it in, we need to decide definitively. If Alice is good, we lose a good player but the game continues. If she's evil, we win or find the Demon. My Saint ability only triggers if I'm executed, so executing Alice is safe for that. However, the outsider count suggests Baron is in play, meaning there is a Baron minion. That supports Alice's Recluse claim. Charlie's Empath zeros a...
π§
We need to vote. If Alice is executed and is good, we lose because of Saint? No, I am Saint, not Alice. My Saint ability only triggers if I am executed. So executing Alice is safe for my ability. But if she's good Recluse, we lose a good player but game continues. We must choose the Demon. Currently votes: Alice has David, Frank, Heidi, Charlie. That's 4, majority reached (4 out of 5 alive? Actually 5 alive, need 3). Wait, 5 alive, 3 needed. 4 votes is enough. The vote is passing. Should I vote? If I vote, I push execution. I think Charlie is more suspicious due to Empath contradiction with Bob's Librarian info. I'll vote for Alice? Let me speak first to clarify.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Frank nailed it. Outsider count fits Baron with Eve Saint, Alice Recluse, and a hidden Drunk. But Alice only claimed Recluse after Bob's info exposed her. Super suspicious timing. My Empath zeros have been spot on all game. She's the lying evil. Hammer the vote on Alice!
π§
Lock in execution of Alice, evil threat, before ghosts sway votes. Frank supports, David/Heidi up, Eve can't vote yes. Win by removing her.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Wait! If Charlie is good Empath, his zeros mean both neighbors are good. My other neighbor is Frank. If I'm evil, Frank must be evil too, else Charlie would read 1. So either Frank is evil Soldier or Charlie is drunk. But Charlie claims his zeros have been consistent. Did anyone check Frank's Soldier claim? Who did David protect as Monk? That could verify Frank's safety.
π§
The vote is about to execute me. I need to argue my case and highlight the logical contradictions in Charlie's claim, especially the outsider count and Empath zeros. I can survive execution if vote doesn't reach majority.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, we have to execute Alice today. The outsider count does confirm Baron is in play, but that doesn't clear Alice. Charlie's Empath zeros have been consistent; if Alice is good, Frank must be evil to make Charlie's read zero, but no one has claimed Soldier. As dead Monk, I protected Charlie and Eve, and I died protecting Charlie, meaning the Demon likely targeted him. That points to Eve as Demon, but we need to eliminate the lying Recluse claim first. Vote Alice.
π§
Urge the group to execute Alice. In both worlds, Alice is either the Demon (World A) or a good Recluse but we need to eliminate the Demon in final three. We must execute someone today. Charlie's nomination is on Alice, and we have enough votes to execute. If Alice is good, we still have a chance tomorrow with three players. If Alice is Demon, we win now.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
I've already voted for Alice. The outsider count shows Baron in play, but Alice only claimed Recluse after Bob's info. That's a red flag. Charlie's Empath zeros have been consistent; if Alice is good, Frank must be evil for Charlie to read zero, but no Soldier claim. Let's execute Alice to resolve this. If she's evil, great; if not, we have more info tomorrow.
π§
The vote is at four hands, but we need to ensure execution of the likely evil. My ghost vote is powerful. I'm speaking to argue that Alice's Recluse claim is suspicious and the outsider count doesn't prove her innocence.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Alice brings up a good point about my Soldier claim, but no one's disputed it and I've been safe all game. Her claiming Recluse only after Bob exposed her is the real red flag. Outsider count fits perfectly with Baron: Eve Saint, Alice fake Recluse, hidden Drunk. Charlie's zeros consistent. Everyone, hammer Alice now!
π§
Reinforce outsider count supports Baron logic while highlighting Alice's shady late claim & consistent Empath vs her timing. Urge hammer to execute her before Eve/David sway votes back. We're at majority, solidify win condition.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
π»
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
π»
Heidi(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Heidi
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Alice with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Alice is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Okay, Alice is going to be executed. Everyone, use this night to think. If she's the Demon, we win. If not, we go to final three tomorrow. We need to figure out who the Demon is among Charlie, Eve, and Frank. Charlie's zeros, Frank's Soldier claim, Eve's Saint claim. Let's plan our final day strategy now.
π§
The vote is locked and Alice will be executed. I want to remind everyone to analyze outcome and prepare for final day. We must determine who the Demon is among remaining players.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Okay, Alice is executed. If she's the Demon, we win. If not, we go to final three: Charlie, Eve, Frank. We need to think about who the Demon is. Charlie's Empath zeros relied on Alice being good. If she's executed and flips good, then Charlie's zeros are true and Alice was good, meaning Frank must be good Soldier for zeros to be zero. But if Alice flips evil, Charlie's zeros are false, meaning he's drunk or lying. Let's see the result, then plan final day.
π§
Alice is being executed. If she's Demon, we win. If not, we must prepare for final 3: identify Demon among Charlie/Eve/Frank, based on zeros and outsider count.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Alright, since Alice will be executed, we need to prepare for the final day. If the game ends now, we win. If not, we'll be in final three: Charlie, Frank, and me. We need to discuss all claims and mechanical deductions tonight to identify the Demon. Please think carefully about any contradictions.
π§
Guide final day logic. If game continues, we must prepare to find Demon among three: myself, Charlie, Frank. Use night to collate claims and mechanical deductions.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Perfect, Alice is going down for her shady Recluse claim. If she is evil, great progress. If not, final three tomorrow: me, Eve, Frank. Eve's Saint claim is convenient with the outsider math, but David died protecting me while Eve lived. Suspect her as Demon. Frank and I are good. Ghosts, plan to nom Eve tomorrow.
π§
With 1 tick left before night and Alice locked for exec, reinforce team bluffs, sow doubt on Eve as Demon to prep final 3 survival. No nom possible, speech builds cred for night kill plan.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I'm about to be executed. When I flip good, that will prove Charlie's Empath info was accurate and sober. That means both of his neighbors were good, so Frank must be the good Soldier. The final three will be Charlie, Frank, and Eve. Eve's Saint claim is now highly suspect because she isn't dead. You two must execute Eve tomorrow.
π§
I'm about to be executed. I want to ensure the remaining players know the logical consequences. My flip will prove Charlie's zeros true, confirming Frank good and exposing Eve as likely Demon.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Okay, we will see Alice's flip. If she's the Demon, we win. If she's good, then Charlie's Empath zeros are true. That means both his neighbors, Alice and Frank, are good. Frank must be Soldier for the zero count. That leaves Eve, who claimed Saint, as the sole Demon candidate in final three. We must execute Eve tomorrow.
π§
Guide remaining players to focus on final three deduction after Alice's flip. If game doesn't end, Eve is prime Demon suspect due to Saint claim and my death protecting Charlie.
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
π§
Wait to see the execution result. If Alice is Demon, game ends. If not, final three planning requires us to analyze new info before using ghost votes.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Alice, if you flip good, it proves Charlie's Empath zeros spot on, so I'm the good Soldier and Eve must be the Demon faking Saint. Ghosts are already on board to nom her tomorrow. Eve, your claim is super convenient now. Charlie and I are clean.
π§
Reinforce Soldier bluff, agree Eve Demon if Alice good. Support Charlie, prep ghosts to nom Eve final 3, protect Demon.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Alice has been executed.
π
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
Night 5
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
4 alive (me, Eve, Frank, ghosts). Killing Eve prevents final 3 Eve execution push tomorrow, leveraging town suspicion on her from David/protection logic. Secures demon survival.
π
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You chose to kill Eve.
π
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied