Game Detail

Poison Alice to disrupt any early-game info role she might have, protecting David and our evil team.

I am choosing Alice and Bob to start gathering information. As the Fortune Teller, I need to find the Demon or my 'Red Herring' (the good player who registers as a Demon). Starting with two players at the beginning of the circle is a systematic way to begin my search.

I am choosing Bob as my master for tomorrow. As the Butler, I need to pick someone to follow. Bob is my neighbor, making it easier to track his voting behavior during the day.

I want to establish a connection with my neighbor David and see if he's willing to share information. As Slayer, I need to find the Demon, and getting early claims helps narrow down the field.

I want to establish a connection with my neighbor Bob to start gathering information and build trust, which is crucial for a Mayor to survive until the final three.

I want to establish a connection with Bob since my ability is tied to him today. By revealing my role as Butler early to him, I build trust and ensure I can actually vote if he does.

Build trust with Eve, claim Washerwoman bluff, gather info about what others are saying.

I want to establish a private alliance with my neighbor Grace and share my initial information to build trust and gather more data.

I am bluffing as the Empath to Frank. As a Ravenkeeper, I want the Demon to kill me at night so I can use my ability. By claiming Empath with a '0' result, I make myself a high-priority target for the Demon while also 'confirming' my neighbors (Frank and Heidi) to build trust.

I want to verify my Librarian information privately with Alice to see if she claims the Butler role. This helps confirm my info and build trust.

Respond to Charlie and Alice to build trust and establish my bluff.

I need to verify my Librarian information by checking with both potential candidates. Since Alice hasn't responded yet, I'm reaching out to Grace to see if she claims the Butler role.

I want to build trust with Grace since her Empath '0' aligns with my role and position. By sharing my 'No' on Alice/Bob, we can narrow down the suspect pool together. I also want to see if she has any info from Heidi.

Confirm my role to the Librarian to build trust and verify their information.

I want to verify David's Washerwoman claim by checking with Frank. If Frank is the Empath, it builds trust in David. As Slayer, I need to find the Demon, and verifying Townsfolk helps narrow the pool.

Respond to Alice, build trust, and coordinate with David about bluffs.

I am sharing my role with Bob because he shared his Empath info (0) with me. Since he claims his neighbors (Alice and David) are good, and I am his other neighbor (wait, I am Charlie, his neighbors are Alice and David? No, looking at the order: Alice, Bob, Charlie, David... Bob's neighbors are Alice and Charlie. David's neighbors are Charlie and Eve. Wait, let me re-check the order: Alice, Bob, Charlie, David, Eve, Frank, Grace, Heidi. Bob's neighbors are Alice and Charlie. So Bob's '0' means Alice and I (Charlie) are good. This makes sense since I know I am good. I will trust Bob for now and reveal my Mayor role to build an alliance.

I need to respond to Heidi's Librarian claim while maintaining my Empath bluff. Since she claims I'm a potential Butler, and I'm actually the Ravenkeeper (bluffing Empath), I'll point towards Alice being the Butler to keep the heat off myself and see how she reacts.

Coordinate with Bob on bluffs to avoid conflicts.

I need to correct Eve's information while building trust. David's claim that I or Alice are the Empath is false (since Grace is the Empath), which suggests David is either the Drunk, a Poisoner/Spy, or just lying. By sharing my true role and Grace's info with the 'Slayer', I can coordinate a potential shot or execution.

Coordinate with David to avoid role conflict. I'll switch my bluff to Chef.

Confirm Bob's new bluff and coordinate targets. Eve as Slayer is a threat.

I need to cross-reference the conflicting information between David and Frank to see who is more likely to be lying or if there's a Drunk in play. David's Washerwoman info (Alice/Frank as Empath) contradicts Frank's claim (Grace as Empath).

I want to confirm the roles with both Alice and Grace to establish a circle of trust. Alice has already claimed Butler, which matches my Librarian info. Grace claiming Empath with a 0 is very strong information if true, as it clears me and Frank. I'm sharing this to solidify our alliance.

I want to maintain my Empath bluff with Frank to encourage the Demon to kill me at night, while also gathering his thoughts on who to investigate next.

I want to build trust with Bob since he is my 'master' for the day and share the information I've gathered from Heidi and Grace to see if he has anything to add.

I want to cross-reference Bob's claim with David and see if David's information or behavior aligns with being 'good' as Bob's Empath 0 suggests. This helps build a circle of trust.

I need to clarify David's information because it directly contradicts Frank's claim. If David is certain about his Washerwoman info (Alice/Frank as Empath) but Frank claims Grace is the Empath, one of them is likely lying or misinformed (Drunk/Poisoned). This helps me narrow down my Slayer shot.

I am continuing my bluff as the Empath to Frank to encourage the Demon to kill me tonight. If I die, my Ravenkeeper ability triggers, allowing me to learn a player's true character.

I want to solidify the trust between Heidi, Grace, and myself while gathering more information about the rest of the circle. Since Heidi confirmed me and Grace has a 0, we are a likely 'good' cluster.

Respond to Eve, adjust my Washerwoman claim to fit Grace as Empath, sow doubt on Frank.

I want to solidify the trust within our 'good block' and start looking at the players outside of it (Bob, Charlie, David, Eve) to identify potential threats.

Respond to Alice, establish Chef bluff, and gently cast suspicion on Grace whose Empath claim conflicts with the board.

I need to clarify Grace's claim and coordinate our information. If she's bluffing Empath, I need to know her real role to trust her info. I also want to flag David's suspicious behavior.

I want to see if David responds to my whisper or if any public claims are made before nominations start. Since the phase is about to end (0 ticks remaining), I should wait for the transition to nominations.

I am revealing my role as Slayer to establish trust and gather more information before the day ends. By being public, I can coordinate my shot later if needed, and I'm pushing for clarification on the conflicting info between David and Frank.

Respond naturally, confirm Washerwoman info aligns with Grace as Empath, build trust, avoid nominations this round.

I need to point out the contradiction in David's claim. He is claiming Washerwoman seeing me as Empath, but I am the Butler, and Heidi (Librarian) already confirmed me as the Butler. This makes David highly suspicious.

I need to clarify the conflicting claims from Bob and David to identify who is lying. Bob gave me one role privately and apparently another to Alice. David's claim also shifted.

Clarify my bluff switch, blame early confusion, and redirect suspicion toward Grace who conflicts with David's Washerwoman claim.

I need to point out the mechanical contradiction between my Librarian info and David's Washerwoman claim to identify potential evil players.

I want to point out the mechanical contradiction between David's Washerwoman claim and Heidi's Librarian claim to put pressure on David, who is looking like a strong candidate for a Minion or Demon.

I will speak to the group to clarify my information and point out the contradictions in David's claim, while also questioning Bob's role swap. This helps narrow down the evil team by highlighting logical inconsistencies.

I want to highlight the mechanical contradiction in David's claim to make him the primary suspect for the day, while also keeping pressure on Bob for his inconsistent claims.

Defend David subtly, explain my role swap, and redirect suspicion to Grace or Frank.

I want to highlight the contradictions between Bob's shifting claims and the conflict between David's and Heidi's information regarding Alice and Grace. This puts pressure on the potential evil players to explain themselves.

I need to point out the contradictions in Bob and David's claims while reinforcing my own role as the Butler, which was verified by Heidi's Librarian info. This helps the good team identify potential lies.

I want to point out the mechanical impossibility of David's claim to the group to see how he responds and to highlight the conflict between my Librarian info and his Washerwoman claim.

I want to highlight the mechanical contradiction between David and Heidi/Alice while also pointing out Bob's suspicious behavior to see how the group reacts before I decide on my Slayer shot.

Deflect suspicion by admitting possible Drunk status and redirect focus to Grace's unverified Empath claim.

I want to highlight the contradictions in David's and Bob's claims to build a case for execution, while maintaining my own credibility as the Fortune Teller.

Poison Frank to corrupt his Fortune Teller result, protecting David from being identified as Demon.

Kill Eve to remove the Slayer threat before she can use her ability on me during Day 2.

I am checking Charlie and David to verify David's suspicious 'Drunk' claim and to see if Charlie, who has been vocal about Bob's inconsistencies, is the Demon. David's Washerwoman info was mechanically impossible given Alice's confirmed Butler role, making him a primary suspect.

I am choosing Heidi as my master for tomorrow. She is the most confirmed good player in my eyes because her Librarian information (Alice/Grace as Butler) perfectly matches my actual role (Butler). Bob and David have both been inconsistent or contradictory, making them untrustworthy.

I want to reveal my role (Slayer) to a small group to build trust and address the mechanical conflict between David and Alice. Since I'm dead, my role is safe to reveal, and it helps narrow down the pool of potential demons/minions.

Coordinate with David on bluff alignment and redirect suspicion away from him.

I want to confirm Alice's alignment and role by sharing my Librarian info privately. This builds trust and helps resolve the conflict with David's claim.

I want to share my information with the group that Eve whispered to, while also addressing David's suspicious claim. By revealing my 'NO' results on Alice, Bob, Charlie, and David, I can help narrow down the Demon search and see how David reacts to being cleared by me (which might make him more likely to be my Red Herring if he's actually evil).

I want to build trust with Heidi (my neighbor and a potential Librarian) by revealing my true role privately. This helps verify Alice's Butler claim and narrows down the world state.

Confirm my role to my Librarian (Heidi) and discuss the discrepancy in David's claim to narrow down the evil team.

Lean into Drunk bluff to survive Day 2 execution pressure.

I need to confront Bob about his inconsistent role claims (Empath vs Chef) to determine if he is evil or just confused. This will help narrow down the demon candidates.

I need to reconcile Grace's new claim (Ravenkeeper) with my Librarian info. If Grace is Ravenkeeper, then Alice must be the Butler. This confirms David's 'Washerwoman' info (claiming Alice/Grace as Empath) is definitely wrong, further suggesting David is either the Drunk or a Minion.

I am waiting for Bob to respond to my whisper regarding his conflicting role claims (Empath vs Chef). Since he just whispered to David, he might be coordinating a story. I need his explanation before I decide whether to push for his execution or look elsewhere.

Smooth over the Empath->Chef inconsistency with Charlie to avoid being nominated.

I want to verify the Outsider count with Heidi to see if a Baron is likely, and confirm if her Librarian info included Grace as the other potential Butler.

I want to solidify my alliance with Heidi by analyzing David's false information. Since both Alice and I have roles that contradict David's Washerwoman claim (Empath), David is mechanically proven to be either the Drunk or Evil.

I want to process Frank's Fortune Teller information and Grace's Empath claim to narrow down the Demon candidates. Since I'm dead, my role is to help the living solve the puzzle.

I want to process the current information with the group I'm already talking to. I need to point out that if almost everyone is 'cleared' by my info and Grace's info, the Demon must be among the 'cleared' (as a Red Herring) or Grace herself is lying.

Deflect suspicion onto Grace by pointing out her Empath 0 claim could be a Demon hiding. Frank's FT info supports this narrative.

I want to synthesize the information from Heidi (Librarian), Alice (Butler), and Frank (Fortune Teller) to narrow down the Demon candidates. If Alice is the Butler, Grace is likely the Demon or a Minion trying to hide.

I want to cross-reference Heidi's Librarian info with Grace's Empath claim to see if Grace is a viable Demon candidate, especially since Frank's Fortune Teller info has cleared many others.

I want to see if Bob will distance himself from David or defend him, which will help me determine if they are on the same team. I'm also testing Bob's willingness to provide reads now that he's 'come clean'.

Protect David by pushing the Drunk narrative to Charlie.

Let the Grace narrative build naturally. Eve and Frank are already pushing it. I just need to wait and let momentum carry.

I need to clarify the situation with Alice. Grace has now claimed Ravenkeeper to me, which further invalidates David's Washerwoman claim. I want to see if Alice trusts Grace's new claim or if she thinks Grace is evil.

I want to confirm the Librarian info with Alice and point out that Grace is the most logical Demon candidate if my Fortune Teller results are accurate and Grace's Empath claim is a lie.

I want to gather more information from Heidi about her conversation with Alice to see if their stories align and to further isolate David as a potential evil player or the Drunk.

I need to coordinate with Heidi to see if Alice's private information matches the public narrative and to solidify our stance on David's false claim.

I want to gauge Bob's opinion on Frank and keep the conversation moving to see if Bob's story remains consistent or if he's trying to deflect from David too hard.

Redirect Charlie's suspicion toward Frank to protect David.

I need to highlight Grace's inconsistent claims to my trusted circle (Heidi, Frank, and the dead Eve). Grace switching from Empath to Ravenkeeper is highly suspicious, especially since Frank's info narrows the Demon pool down significantly.

Let the Grace suspicion build naturally. My Drunk claim + Frank's FT results pointing away from me is working. Wait for nominations.

I need to coordinate with Alice and Frank to highlight Grace's inconsistent claims (Empath publicly, Ravenkeeper privately) which, combined with Frank's 'No' result on Charlie/David, makes Grace a primary Demon suspect.

To coordinate with Alice and Heidi to focus the group's suspicion on Grace, who has given contradictory role claims (Empath publicly, Ravenkeeper privately).

I want to confirm the discrepancy in Grace's claims and solidify the case against her as the Demon, while also coordinating my ghost vote and ensuring the Butler (Alice) is aligned with the good team's strategy.

I want to publicly confront Grace about her conflicting claims to put pressure on her and see how she reacts before I or someone else nominates her. This highlights her as the primary suspect based on my information and others' claims.

Nominate Grace to capitalize on town suspicion and eliminate a good player.

Vote to execute Grace to eliminate a good player and deflect suspicion from myself.

I want to pressure Grace to explain the discrepancy in her role claims while also acknowledging Frank's new information.

I am voting for Grace because my Fortune Teller information (N0: Alice/Bob NO, N1: Charlie/David NO) combined with her contradictory role claims (Empath publicly, Ravenkeeper privately) makes her the primary Demon suspect. Executing her is our best chance to win.

I am waiting for my master, Heidi, to vote before I can cast my own vote for Grace, as per my Butler restriction.

I am voting for Grace because my Librarian information (Alice or Grace is the Butler) combined with Alice's claim and Grace's contradictory claims (Empath publicly, Ravenkeeper privately) makes Grace the most likely Demon. Frank's Fortune Teller info also points towards her.

Vote to execute Grace to protect David (the Demon) and follow the evil team's push.

I am voting for Grace because she has provided contradictory role claims (Empath publicly, Ravenkeeper privately), which is a strong indicator of being the Demon. Frank's Fortune Teller information also narrows the suspect pool down to her. Since I am dead and this is a strong lead, using my ghost vote now to ensure the execution of a primary Demon suspect is a strategic move.

I need to reveal my true role as Ravenkeeper to explain the bluff and prevent my execution, as being executed wastes my night-death ability. I also need to point out that David's information is the actual contradiction.

I have already raised my hand to vote for Grace, and there are currently 5 votes (David, Frank, Heidi, Bob, Eve), which is enough for execution (4 needed). I will wait to see if anyone lowers their hand or if the vote concludes.

I already raised my hand. Grace execution helps David survive. Just wait.

I have already raised my hand to vote for Grace. I will wait for the voting process to conclude. Grace's defense of bluffing as Empath to bait a kill is a common Ravenkeeper play, but the discrepancy between her public and private claims, combined with my Fortune Teller 'NO' results on Alice, Bob, Charlie, and David, makes her the most logical Demon candidate. I will maintain my vote.

I am voting for Grace because she has provided conflicting role claims (Empath publicly, Ravenkeeper privately), which is a common Demon tactic. Furthermore, Frank's Fortune Teller information and Heidi's Librarian information (confirming me as Butler) narrow the suspect pool significantly to Grace. Since my 'master' for today is Heidi and she has already raised her hand, I am mechanically able and strategically inclined to vote.

I need to defend myself and point out the flaws in the current logic to prevent my execution.

I want to voice my suspicion of Grace's shifting claims while acknowledging the potential for David to be misinformed or evil, keeping the pressure on the current nomination.

Let the vote proceed. Grace's execution removes a potential threat and my nomination already stands.

I want to reinforce the case against Grace and justify why I am using my ghost vote on her, despite her new claim. Her inconsistency is a major red flag.

I want to reinforce the case against Grace and explain why her shifting claims make her the most logical execution, while also acknowledging the discrepancy in David's information.

I will wait for the nomination phase to conclude as Grace is already on the block with a majority (6 votes), which is the outcome I want based on my Librarian information.

I want to solidify the case against Grace by highlighting that my Fortune Teller information, combined with Heidi's Librarian information and Alice's Butler claim, points directly to Grace being evil. I need to ensure the group stays focused on executing her.

I will wait for the nomination phase to conclude. Grace is already on the block with 6 votes, which is a majority (6 out of 7 alive players). Unless someone else is nominated and receives more votes, she will be executed. Given the strong evidence against her (contradictory claims and Frank's FT info narrowing down the suspects), I am satisfied with this outcome.

Grace is being executed, which is good for our team. David survives. No need to speak or nominate.

I need to pivot the suspicion from myself to Heidi, who is the only other person Frank's information hasn't cleared, while also discrediting David's information as either Drunk or Evil.

Stay quiet, let Grace's execution proceed. No need to draw attention to myself.

I want to point out the inconsistency in Grace's claims to justify the current vote and see if anyone else has a counter-argument before the day ends.

Poison Charlie to disrupt their logic chain against David, protecting the Demon.

Kill Frank to eliminate the Fortune Teller who is systematically clearing players and will eventually expose me.

I will choose Heidi as my master again. She is the most confirmed player in my eyes because her Librarian info correctly identified me as the Butler, which is a piece of information only she (as Librarian) or an evil player with the Grimoire (Spy) would know. Since she has been helpful and consistent, I trust her to lead the vote tomorrow.

I want to establish a private line of communication with Bob, who was cleared by the now-dead Fortune Teller (Frank), to discuss the remaining suspects and my role.

Coordinate with Bob to target Heidi for execution today.

I am dead and have no vote, so my only power is to use my voice to coordinate the remaining good players. I want to pressure Heidi and cross-reference the known information to narrow down the Demon. Frank's death suggests his information was threatening to the Demon.

I want to re-evaluate the 'cleared' players now that our main source of info (Frank) is dead. Since I know I'm good and I'm dead, if Frank was sober, the Demon must be Heidi. However, if Frank was poisoned/drunk, the Demon could be anyone. I'm reaching out to the players Frank 'cleared' and Heidi to see their reactions.

I need to defend myself against the suspicion that I am the Demon, while also pointing out the flaws in the current logic (specifically David's incorrect info and the possibility of Frank being poisoned).

I need to cross-reference David's Washerwoman claim with Heidi's Librarian claim to see where the misinformation is coming from, while also addressing the suspicion on Heidi.

I am dead, so I need to share my information immediately to help the living players narrow down the Demon. Since I cleared Alice, Bob, Charlie, and David (assuming no Red Herring), and David's claim is already suspicious, I want to coordinate with the players I've 'cleared' or who seem most active.

Tell David what Charlie said, coordinate on Heidi execution plan.

I need to defend myself against the implication of Frank's Fortune Teller info while highlighting the inconsistency in David's claim to shift suspicion towards him.

I need to reconcile the conflicting information between Frank's FT results and Heidi's Librarian info, while putting pressure on David whose Washerwoman claim was proven false.

I need to highlight the contradiction between David's info and the confirmed roles to narrow down the Demon. Since I'm dead and out of votes, I must act as a logic engine for the living.

I want to point out the contradiction in David's information and highlight that Heidi's information about me is correct, which makes her more likely to be good. I'm trying to narrow down the suspects by questioning David's false claim.

I need to gather the last piece of information from the dead Fortune Teller (Frank) to narrow down the Demon candidates. I also want to insert myself into the conversation between Alice, Heidi, and Charlie to see if they are coordinating or if there's a clear suspect.

Wait and observe ongoing whispers before acting. Already coordinated with David to push Heidi.

I need to clarify my night actions to Grace and the group while highlighting the discrepancy in David's information. Since I died on Night 2, I didn't get a result for that night. I want to focus the group's attention on the remaining suspects: Heidi and David.

Respond to Charlie's challenge, explain my Washerwoman claim, and subtly push suspicion onto Heidi.

I need to pressure David on his incorrect information while acknowledging the conflict between Frank's info and Heidi's info. This helps determine if David is the Demon or a Minion (Poisoner) who poisoned Frank.

I need to pressure David to explain his false information and force Charlie and Bob to reveal their roles to narrow down the Demon candidates, especially since Frank's Fortune Teller info (if sober) points directly at Heidi.

I need to confront David about his incorrect information and see how he reacts, while also highlighting the contradiction between Frank's info and Heidi's info to the group.

I need to reconcile the conflicting information between Frank's FT checks, David's Washerwoman claim, and Heidi's Librarian claim to identify the Demon among the living.

Respond to Alice/Charlie/Eve's pressure by claiming Drunk to explain wrong info, and redirect suspicion to Heidi.

I need to reconcile my 'NO' result on David with the fact that he is the most suspicious player due to his false Washerwoman claim. I'm exploring the possibility of being the Drunk or David being the Red Herring.

Respond to Eve's whisper, claim Chef with 0 evil pairs to seem trustworthy, and subtly push toward Heidi.

I want to point out the logical inconsistency in David's claim and Frank's information to see if we can narrow down if David is the Demon or if Frank is the Drunk.

Explore the possibility of David being the Red Herring versus being evil/drunk, and solicit more theories from the group.

Wait for nomination phase - I've already made my case via whispers. Let the town dynamics play out.

I want to shift the focus to Bob and Charlie while acknowledging the Red Herring possibility. Bob's early claim swap makes him a valid suspect if Frank's info is being manipulated or if David is the Red Herring.

I want to bring Bob's Chef 0 info into the conversation and pressure Heidi, as Frank's Fortune Teller info (if reliable) points directly to her. I'm also testing the consistency of the 'no evil pairs' claim against the current seating and suspicions.

I want to explore the possibility of David being the 'Red Herring' or Frank being the Drunk, as this would change our suspect list significantly.

I need to defend myself against the suspicion raised by Frank's Fortune Teller info. By pointing out that my Librarian info was confirmed by Alice, I establish my credibility. I also need to highlight the possibility that David is Frank's 'Red Herring', which would mean David is good and Frank's info is still technically 'correct' but misleading.

Address Alice's question about my Chef info, reinforce Heidi suspicion, keep David safe.

I want to cross-reference the Chef 0 info with the FT info to see if we can find a contradiction or a clear path to the Demon, while maintaining my Mayor cover.

I want to pressure Bob to reveal his role and see if his claim fits the current puzzle, while also highlighting the logical deduction that if David and Charlie are 'No' results, the Demon must be elsewhere.

Nominate Heidi to redirect suspicion from David and get to 3 players where evil can win.

I need to defend myself against Bob's nomination by pointing out the flaws in his logic and highlighting that he could be the Demon deflecting suspicion.

Vote to execute Heidi to help David win.

I want to prompt more discussion and see if other players are willing to commit to the Heidi vote before I use my limited ghost vote. I also want to pressure Heidi for her suspicions to see if they align with a good-team perspective.

Vote to execute Heidi to reduce player count and eliminate a good player who suspects me.

I want to highlight the possibility of Heidi being a Spy to explain her accurate Librarian claim while still being evil, supporting the current nomination without being able to vote myself.

I need to explain why I am not voting for Heidi, which is due to my Butler restriction, while also pointing out that Bob's push might be suspicious if he's trying to force an execution without full consensus.

I want to pause the momentum on Heidi's execution to evaluate if Bob is deflecting. As Mayor, I need to be careful about executing potentially good players, especially since Heidi's info on Alice (Butler) was confirmed.

I want to pause the momentum on Heidi's execution to consider the 'Red Herring' mechanic of my role, which might be clouding our logic.

Pressure Charlie to be the deciding vote against Heidi.

I need to remind the group that I cannot contribute a vote and emphasize that Charlie is the deciding factor, while reinforcing the logic based on Frank's (the dead Fortune Teller) information.

I want to caution the town about the potential for Frank being the Drunk or David being the Red Herring before a majority is reached, while also acknowledging the mechanical logic pointing to Heidi. I am choosing not to vote yet to see if more information or a counter-argument emerges.

I want to express my hesitation to vote for Heidi because her Librarian info on Alice (the Butler) is a very strong good-aligned signal. If she's good, executing her is a mistake, especially if Bob's Chef 0 info is a lie.

I need to defend myself against Bob's nomination by highlighting the strength of my Librarian info and casting doubt on Bob's unverified Chef claim.

I need to pivot the group's focus. If Heidi is a confirmed Librarian (via Alice's Butler claim), then my Fortune Teller 'No' results on everyone else must include the Red Herring, meaning one of the 'cleared' players is actually the Demon. Bob's aggressive push on Heidi feels like a deflection.

Pressure Charlie to vote Heidi by reinforcing Frank's FT logic - Heidi is the only uncleared player.

I want to point out the flaw in Bob's logic regarding the Fortune Teller's Red Herring to prevent a hasty execution of Heidi, who I currently trust more than Bob.

I want to shift the focus to Bob and Charlie since Heidi's claim was verified by Alice, making Bob's aggressive push suspicious. I also want to prompt Alice to choose a new master to test her Butler claim's consistency.

I want to cast doubt on Bob's aggressive play while maintaining my position as a confirmed Butler. I also want to signal that I'm moving my 'master' choice to someone else to potentially gain more voting power if Heidi is indeed good but not the one I need to follow.

Pivot away from Heidi push, appear reasonable, subtly cast doubt on Bob to gain Charlie/Alice trust and survive.

I want to highlight the tension between Bob's unverified claim and the Alice/Heidi mechanical link to prepare the group for the next day's logic.

I want to publicly state my role as Mayor to explain my cautious play and shift suspicion onto Bob, whose Chef 0 claim is unverified and who pushed hard for a likely good player's execution.

Charlie revealed Mayor - this is critical. I need to cast doubt and push for execution, or at least note this for David to kill Charlie tonight.

I want to reinforce my credibility by highlighting the mechanical link between my Librarian info and Alice's Butler claim, while also pointing out Bob's suspicious behavior and his attempt to discredit Charlie's Mayor claim.

I need to point out the flaw in Bob's logic regarding my Fortune Teller information and the Red Herring mechanic to cast doubt on his Chef 0 claim, which seems like a convenient bluff.

Poison Charlie to neutralize Mayor win condition. If Charlie is truly Mayor, poisoning them may not stop the ability but disrupts their credibility/info.

Kill Charlie the Mayor to prevent the good team's automatic win condition at final 3.

I am choosing Charlie as my master for tomorrow. Charlie has claimed Mayor, which is a powerful good role that the Demon will likely want to kill. If Charlie survives the night, it increases the likelihood that they are either the Demon or a very trusted good player. By choosing Charlie, I align my voting power with a potential win condition (the Mayor's ability) and test their survival. If Charlie dies, I will have to reconsider my master, but for now, this provides the most strategic flexibility if the Mayor claim is true.

I want to confirm my trust in the Alice/Heidi pair and gather their thoughts on the current game state now that I am dead. My death as Mayor suggests the Demon wanted me gone or a bounce occurred.

I want to consolidate the good team's trust and narrow down the suspects. Since Charlie (Mayor) is dead, we need to find the Demon among the remaining living players: Bob and David. Alice is my confirmed Butler.

I need to inform my allies that my voting is restricted because my master (Charlie) is dead, and I want to solidify the suspicion on Bob while checking David's stance.

I am dead, but I have information from my Ravenkeeper ability (assuming I was killed at night, though the log says I was executed Day 2 - wait, if I was executed, my ability didn't proc. Let me re-read. 'Grace (Ravenkeeper) was executed Day 2'. If I was executed, I get nothing. But the prompt says 'If you die at night...'. I need to check if I actually have info or if I'm bluffing to get David to claim. Actually, if I was executed, I have no info. I should double check the rules. Ravenkeeper: 'If you die at night'. I died Day 2. I have no info. I will bluff to David to see his reaction and try to coordinate a Slayer shot if he is one, or catch him in a lie. Actually, better to just ask for his role since I'm a ghost and can't do much else. Wait, if I'm dead, I should be helping solve the game. Bob is suspicious. David is a neighbor.

I need to share my Fortune Teller info with the players I trust most (Alice and Heidi) to narrow down the Demon. Bob is my primary suspect due to his behavior yesterday and my mechanical pings.

Respond to Heidi/Alice to seem cooperative, push suspicion toward Heidi to get her executed. We need one execution or kill to win.

Coordinate with David to align our stories and push for Alice or Heidi execution today.

I want to see how Bob reacts to Charlie's death. Bob was aggressive towards Heidi yesterday. If he's the Demon, he might have killed Charlie to remove the Mayor threat. I want to see if he shifts his focus or doubles down.

Coordinate with Bob, agree to back his push on Alice or Heidi to secure the execution we need to win.

I am waiting to see how Bob responds to my whisper and how the remaining alive players (Alice, Bob, David, Heidi) interact before the nomination phase. Since I am dead and have no vote, my role is purely observational and advisory now.

I need to defend Heidi's Librarian claim by reminding David that it's mechanically tied to my role as the Butler, and challenge his sudden suspicion of her while highlighting Bob's suspicious behavior.

Respond to Eve, deflect from David, push Alice as suspicious.

I need to confirm David's role and alignment. As the Ravenkeeper who died at night (N2), I saw him as the Slayer. If he is good, he needs to use his shot to help us find the Demon, especially since the player count is dropping.

I need to coordinate with my trusted circle (Alice and Heidi) to focus our execution efforts on Bob, while also clarifying the voting restriction Alice (as Butler) now faces because I am her dead master.

I want to solidify the plan with my confirmed good allies (Alice and Charlie) to target Bob, who is the most suspicious player based on his aggressive play and unverified claim.

I need to share my mechanical information with the players I trust most (Alice and Heidi, who confirmed each other) and Charlie (who is dead and likely good) to narrow down the Demon. Bob is the primary suspect due to his behavior.

I need to share my Fortune Teller information with the remaining players to narrow down the Demon. Since I've cleared Alice, Bob, Charlie, and David (with the caveat of a Red Herring), and Charlie is now dead, the focus shifts to the remaining alive players: Alice, Bob, David, and Heidi. Bob's behavior yesterday was suspicious, and I need to see if Heidi's information contradicts his or points elsewhere.

I am re-sending my whisper to David because he hasn't responded and the day is progressing. I need to know if he is the Slayer I saw or if I was poisoned/he is the Demon. If he is the Slayer, he needs to use his shot before he dies at night.

I need to reconcile Frank's Fortune Teller information with the current suspicion on Bob. If Frank's info is correct and there's no Red Herring, Heidi would be the Demon, but her link with Alice is the strongest good-aligned evidence we have. I'm suggesting Bob might be the Red Herring to keep the focus on him.

I need to address Frank's Fortune Teller information while reinforcing the case against Bob. If Frank's info is correct, Bob could be the Red Herring, which explains why he's pinging 'No' despite his suspicious behavior. I also want to highlight David's suspicious pivot.

I need to address Frank's Fortune Teller information which technically points to me as the Demon, by suggesting Bob is the Red Herring. This aligns with Bob's suspicious behavior and keeps the focus on him.

Wait and observe current whisper activity before acting. David is aligned, Alice can't vote. Nomination phase is next.

I want to see if Bob has any updated information or if he's just tunneling on Heidi. I also want to remind him of the voting math: with Alice unable to vote (if she's the Butler), the living votes are crucial.

Respond to Grace to deflect suspicion, claim I'll use Slayer shot on Bob to seem cooperative while actually doing nothing harmful.

I want to solidify the case against Bob by explaining how he could be the Demon despite Frank's 'No' result (as the Red Herring). This keeps the Alice-Heidi-Charlie-Frank alliance focused on the most likely suspect.

Fake shoot Bob to sacrifice my minion, appear as a good Slayer, and redirect execution away from me. Bob dying by execution or shot helps me win at final 3.

I need to address David's Slayer claim immediately since I am the Slayer. By whispering to the key alive players, I can point out the contradiction and force David to explain himself, while also testing Bob's reaction to being shot at.

Analyze the failed Slayer shot and its implications for the current suspects (Bob and David) while maintaining communication with the trusted group.

I need to remind the group that David's failed Slayer shot is meaningless if he is the Drunk (which he previously claimed), and maintain the focus on Bob as the primary suspect.

Act hurt/confused by David shooting me to seem innocent, redirect suspicion to Heidi or Alice for execution.

I need to maintain pressure on Bob while acknowledging the new information from Eve and David. Bob is trying to use the failed Slayer shot to clear himself, but I need to point out the flaws in that logic (David being the Drunk or Eve being the real Slayer).

I need to process the failed Slayer shot with David. Since Bob didn't die, he's not the Demon (unless he's the Recluse or poisoned, but Slayer is usually reliable). I need to help David figure out the next move before nominations.

Since the Slayer shot failed on Bob, I need to re-evaluate the suspects. If Frank's Fortune Teller info was correct, Bob and Alice are 'no' results. David is the Slayer. That leaves Heidi as the primary suspect by process of elimination, assuming Frank wasn't poisoned. I want to prompt Heidi and Alice for their full claims to see if the math adds up.

I need to counter Grace's logic that Bob is cleared by the failed Slayer shot and refocus the group on the Alice-Heidi mechanical link versus Bob's suspicious behavior.

Nominate Alice who cannot vote as Butler with dead master. David will back me, giving 2 votes needed for execution.

I want to highlight the mechanical restriction on Alice (the Butler) to the living players, as it significantly impacts the voting power and potential for the Demon to manipulate the outcome. I also want to cast doubt on Bob's nomination of Alice.

I need to defend myself against Bob's nomination and remind everyone that as a Butler whose master (Charlie) is dead, I cannot vote unless Charlie uses his ghost vote. I also want to point out that Bob's nomination of me is a clear diversion from the suspicion on him.

I will not vote for Alice. Bob's nomination of Alice is a clear attempt to deflect suspicion from himself, especially since Alice is mechanically confirmed by my Librarian info and her own Butler claim. Alice is a confirmed good player in my view.

Not voting on Alice keeps suspicion off me. Bob nominated her - if I vote it looks coordinated. Better to let Bob's vote stand and see if Heidi votes too.

I want to publicly support Alice and discredit Bob's nomination by highlighting the mechanical strength of the Alice/Heidi link and the possibility of Bob being my Red Herring.

Vote for Alice to try to execute her and reduce good team numbers.

I want to discourage the group from voting for Alice, as I believe she is good and Bob is the Demon attempting to deflect suspicion. I also want to remind David that his failed Slayer shot doesn't clear Bob due to his own claim of being the Drunk.

I will not vote for Alice. Bob's nomination of Alice feels like a desperate move by the Demon to eliminate a confirmed good player (Butler) who is mechanically linked to the dead Mayor (Charlie) and the Librarian (Heidi). Frank's Fortune Teller info also cleared Alice. Bob is the most suspicious player, and I want to save my ghost vote for a nomination against him or to ensure a tie if necessary later.

I will not vote for Alice because I believe she is good and Bob's nomination is a deflection. I want to see if anyone else votes and how the day progresses.

Let Alice vote fail. Go to night, kill Heidi, then win.

I will not vote for Alice. Bob's nomination of Alice is a clear deflection from the suspicion on him, and Alice is mechanically linked to me through my Librarian information. Voting for her would weaken the good team's position.

I will wait to see if the nomination on Alice fails, as I do not believe she is the Demon and I want to save my ghost vote for a more critical moment or the final day.

Lower hand since vote is failing anyway. Regroup and speak to redirect suspicion.

I want to highlight Bob's inconsistent behavior (nominating then not voting for his own nomination) to cast further suspicion on him and keep the conversation focused on the most likely Demon candidates before the day ends.

I want to highlight Bob's inconsistent behavior to the group. He nominated Alice but then didn't even vote for her, which looks like a weak attempt to shift focus or test the waters. I'm also reminding everyone of the mechanical links (Frank's FT info) that make Bob a prime suspect if Alice is the Butler.

I need to point out that Bob's behavior (nominating then not voting) is highly suspicious and likely a tactic to waste a nomination or test the waters. I also need to remind everyone that as Butler with a dead master (Charlie), I can only vote if Charlie uses his ghost vote, which makes Bob's nomination of me even more of a 'safe' play for him if he's evil.

I want to point out Bob's suspicious behavior of nominating Alice but not voting, suggesting he's trying to waste the day's nominations. I'm encouraging the living players to nominate him.

Nominate Bob to appear good-aligned and rebuild trust. If Bob is executed, we go to 3 players and I win next night.

I am voting for Bob because his behavior is highly suspicious and inconsistent with a good player. He nominated Alice but didn't even vote for her, which looks like a tactic to waste a nomination and deflect attention from himself. As the Librarian, I've confirmed Alice as the Butler, making Bob's push against her even more likely to be a malicious act from the Demon or a Minion. Frank's Fortune Teller info also points to Bob potentially being the Red Herring or the Demon. Executing Bob is our best lead right now.

Defend myself to avoid execution. Only Heidi voted so far, need to prevent David from voting too.

Vote Bob to get to 3 players alive, then kill tonight to reach 2 and win. Heidi already voted, my vote makes 2/2.

I am voting for Bob to secure his execution. As the Mayor who died at night, I am likely a confirmed good player, and Bob's behavior (aggressive targeting of confirmed good chains, inconsistent voting, and attacking my Mayor claim) makes him the primary Demon suspect. David and Heidi are already voting, and my ghost vote will ensure the execution of our main suspect.

I want to reinforce the case against Bob by pointing out the flaw in his defense (that David's failed shot clears him) and encourage the active voters to follow through with the execution.

I am voting for Bob because my Fortune Teller information (Alice/Bob: NO) combined with the mechanical confirmation of Alice as the Butler (by Heidi) makes Bob the most likely candidate for the Demon (as my Red Herring). Bob's aggressive and inconsistent behavior further supports this.

I am voting for Bob to ensure his execution. As a dead player, this is my one ghost vote, and Bob is the primary suspect based on his inconsistent behavior and the mechanical information from Frank (Fortune Teller) and Heidi (Librarian). Bob's attempt to deflect onto Alice (confirmed Butler) and his failed Slayer shot (from a potentially Drunk David) make him the most logical Demon candidate.

I am voting for Bob because he is the primary suspect and his behavior (nominating me then not voting) is highly indicative of a Demon trying to waste nominations. Since my master Charlie (Ghost) has raised his hand, I am mechanically allowed to vote.

Votes are in, Bob should be executed. Wait for result.

Last ditch effort to avoid execution. Point out David is the real threat.

The vote for Bob has already reached the required threshold (Alice, Grace, Frank, Charlie, David, and Heidi have all raised their hands, which is 6 votes, well over the 2 needed). Since I am dead and have no ghost vote, I cannot contribute further to the vote itself. My previous speech already addressed Bob's flawed logic. I will wait for the Storyteller to finalize the execution.

I must lower my hand because my chosen master for today, Charlie, is dead and therefore cannot vote. As the Butler, I can only vote if my master votes. Since a dead player cannot vote in the nomination process (only their one ghost vote for the final tally, but they aren't 'voting' in the active sense that allows a Butler to follow), I am mechanically barred from voting today. I need to correct this mistake to avoid breaking the rules or appearing suspicious.

I need to pressure Alice to put her hand back up to ensure Bob's execution, as he is the primary suspect and we need to reach the threshold.

I need to convince Alice to put her hand back up to ensure Bob's execution. As a dead Fortune Teller, my information is valuable, and I need to point out the flaw in Bob's defense while reinforcing the suspicion on him.

I need to persuade Alice to put her hand back up to ensure Bob's execution. As a dead Mayor, my death validates my role and makes my perspective more credible. Bob's defense is logically weak, and Alice's hesitation is the only thing stopping the execution.

I need to persuade Alice to put her hand back up to ensure Bob's execution, as he is the primary suspect and we need the majority.

I want to solidify the vote on Bob and understand why Alice wavered, while reinforcing the logic that Bob's 'clear' is invalid.

Last ditch effort to save myself, cast doubt on David.

I want to understand why Alice lowered her hand and reinforce the case against Bob to ensure his execution. Alice's hesitation is concerning, and I need to keep the pressure on Bob while maintaining group cohesion.

Bob is being executed. Stay quiet, let it happen, win tonight by killing the right player.

I will wait to see if anyone else makes a nomination or if the day ends, as Bob is currently on the block with 5 votes, which is a strong position for the good team.

I want to reinforce the case against Bob and understand why Alice (the Butler) wavered, as her vote is crucial for the final day if Bob isn't the Demon. I also want to remind everyone that David's 'failed' shot doesn't clear Bob if David is the Drunk.

Explain why I lowered my hand to avoid suspicion and clarify my mechanical restriction as the Butler with a dead master.

I want to reinforce the case against Bob by pointing out the flaw in his 'clear' and explaining why Alice's lack of a vote is actually a mechanical confirmation of her role, further isolating Bob as the likely Demon.

Kill Heidi to reach 2 alive (David + Alice), triggering evil win condition.