Game Detail
Players
Alice (Slayer) Bob (Virgin) Charlie (Butler) David (Drunk) Eve (Fortune Teller) Frank (Imp) Grace (Baron) Heidi (Saint)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 918,892 | 103,773 | $0.4373 |
| Evil | 324,607 | 62,963 | $1.4495 |
Event Transcript
๐ญ
The game has started.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Grace
You are the Minion. The Demon is Frank.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Frank
Minions are: Grace. Your safe bluffs are: Soldier, Washerwoman, Mayor
๐
Storyteller
โ
David
Good evening David. You are the Chef. You learn that there are 0 pairs of evil players.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
๐ฏ
Eve
Eve made choices.
๐ง
Early broad scan to eliminate or identify suspects quickly; picking two non-neighbors spreads info across table and preserves neighbor triangulation.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Eve
You chose Alice and Bob. You receive the answer: YES.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
๐ฏ
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
๐ง
Force my voting dependency on Bob to gather information from tomorrow's voting patterns and limit my accidental votes against likely allies.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Charlie
You chose Bob to be your master.
Day 1
๐
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
โ
Alice
Alice waits.
๐ง
Maintain cover, gather conversation and claims before using my one-shot. Waiting this tick lets me collect info and avoid wasting the Slayer shot prematurely.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Frank
FYI Iโm Baron (so 3 Outsiders in play total). Letโs get at least 2โ3 Outsider claims floating. I can claim Recluse/Butler to fit. Avoid claiming Chef (would be โ1โ pair = points at us adjacent). What bluff are you taking?
๐ง
Coordinate bluffs with Frank and set up an Outsider-count narrative that matches Baron, while steering suspicion away from Frank.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Grace
Iโll take a Saint bluff (execution deterrent) to help sell 3 Outsiders. You can claim Butler or Recluse. Letโs float โoutsider count seems highโ early + suggest thereโs likely a Drunk. Iโll avoid Chef/Empath-style hard info.
๐ง
Coordinate consistent outsider-count story to match Baron and give me execution protection; keep flexibility to pivot to safe bluffs if conflicts arise.
๐ค
Eve
โ
David
,Frank
Whisper: I'm Eve, the Fortune Teller. My N0 check on Alice+Bob returned YES (one is Demon or a good false positive). Keep this private. Did either of you see suspicious daytime behavior? Any protected/targeted claims? Can you test them tonight?
๐ง
Coordinate a quiet crosscheck with my neighbors to gather info on Alice/Bob and avoid tipping off the Demon until we have corroboration.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Alice
,Grace
Quick private from Heidi: please share any role claims or reads before nominations. Do either of you have info to share? I prefer we avoid executing unknowns earlyโcoordinate votes next tick and watch for coordinated whispers.
๐ง
Form a small private alliance to share early claims/reads, avoid reckless nominations, and spot coordinated evil before nominations.
๐ค
David
โ
Eve
,Frank
Iโm Chef. N0: 0 adjacent evil pairs. Eve โ your Alice+Bob = YES noted. Frank โ can you test one of Alice/Bob tonight? Eve โ can you test Bob+Charlie or Alice+Charlie tonight? Share results privately.
๐ง
Share my Chef info (0 adjacent evil pairs) and coordinate night checks to distinguish whether Alice or Bob is Demon, narrowing suspects for execution.
๐ค
Bob
โ
Alice
,Charlie
Hi neighbors โ quick private ask: don't nominate me first (I may have a risky reaction). Who have you whispered with and any claims or reads? Tell me anything odd you noticed early.
๐ง
Prevent being the first nominee (Virgin mechanic) and get private reads/claims from my neighbors to build trust and target likely evils.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Bob
Hi Bob โ I haven't whispered with anyone else yet. No claims or reads. I'm Charlie, the Butler: I chose you as my master last night, so tomorrow I may only vote if you vote. Understood about not nominating you first. What did you mean by a 'risky reaction'?
๐ง
By privately disclosing my Butler role and that I chose him, I build trust with Bob, avoid him being nominated first, and get him to clarify what 'risky reaction' means so we can coordinate votes.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Heidi
,Alice
No hard info from me. Iโm leaning I might be the Butler (Outsider) which would fit an โoutsider count feels highโ gameโso Iโm also wary there could be a Drunk. Iโd prefer we avoid an early execute unless someone is mechanically pinged. Do you have any info/claims?
๐ง
Respond promptly to Heidi to seem cooperative, establish an Outsider bluff consistent with Baron, and steer town away from confident early executions while gathering any info she offers.
๐ค
David
โ
Eve
,Frank
I'm Chef: N0=0 adjacent evil pairs. Eve: can you test Bob+Charlie (or Alice+Charlie) tonight and report privately? Frank: can you test Alice (or Bob) tonight and report privately? Reply with planned targets.
๐ง
Coordinate night checks to pinpoint Demon using Eve's FT and my Chef N0 info; get Frank/Eve to test targets and report privately so we can form nominations.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Alice
,Grace
Quick check: Iโm happy to avoid revealing my role now. Agree we shouldnโt execute on Day1 without mechanical reads. Any claims/reads? Watch for coordinated whispers or pressure to nominate someone fast. If you have private info, share now so we can coordinate nominations next tick.
๐ง
Prevent an early risky execution (I lose if executed). Encourage info-sharing and coordinated voting to preserve town's options.
๐ค
Eve
โ
David
,Frank
Private: I'm Eve FT. My N0 on Alice+Bob=YES. David asked I test Bob+Charlie tonight โ I will. Frank, can you test Alice (or Alice+Grace?) tonight and report privately? Any daytime behavior you found odd? Keep this between us.
๐ง
Coordinate private tests to triangulate who triggered my YES and use Chef's info to eliminate adjacent pairs, narrowing Demon suspects before nominations.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Heidi
,Grace
I have no mechanical reads or claims. I prefer we avoid executing Day1 unless someone is pinged. Watch for who pressures nominations or solicits protection. Any role claims/reads to share before next tick?
๐ง
Keep us from executing on Day1 without reads; coordinate whispers so we collect mechanical info and identify suspicious whisper patterns before nominations.
๐ค
Bob
โ
Alice
,Charlie
Hi both โ quick: please don't nominate me first (my role has a dangerous reaction). Charlie I saw you already told me you picked me as Butler master โ thanks. Alice: who did you whisper with and any claims/reads/odd behaviour so far? Charlie: anything new since your last message?
๐ง
Prevent an accidental nomination that could execute an innocent Townsfolk and gather who each of you whispered to and any claims/odd behaviour.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Eve
,David
I donโt have a night โtestโ (Iโm bluffing Soldierโno action). Given setup Iโm expecting Outsider count feels high โ possible Baron/Drunk, so I wouldnโt trust Chef=0 as hard-clears. Eve, Bob+Charlie test sounds good; Iโm mildly sus of Alice > Bob socially.
๐ง
Answer their request without giving real tests, undermine Chef certainty, and steer suspicion/execution toward Alice/Bob while keeping Grace out of the spotlight.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Bob
,Alice
Quick private: I'm Charlie (Butler) โ I chose Bob as my master, so tomorrow I may only vote if Bob votes. Please avoid nominating Bob first per his risk. Alice: who have you whispered with and any claims/reads? Bob: what did you mean by 'risky reaction'?
๐ง
Avoid accidentally nominating Bob (per his request) while gathering claims/whispers to build a trust chain and plan nominations I can participate in.
๐ค
David
โ
Eve
,Frank
Eve: confirm you will test Bob+Charlie N1 and report YES/NO privately to me. Frank: please test Alice N1 (or confirm you have no action). Report privately. Iโm Chef (N0=0). Keep results between us.
๐ง
Coordinate private nightly tests to get FT results and decide who to nominate; keep info private to avoid tipping evils.
๐ค
Eve
โ
David
,Frank
I'll test Bob+Charlie tonight and will report privately. David: please confirm your Chef claim (N0=0) is public. Frank: please confirm whether you will test Alice tonight or have no action. Keep this between us.
๐ง
Confirm N1 tests and get Frank/David to commit so we can combine results to narrow Demon candidates and detect contradictions.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Eve
,David
Confirming: Iโm bluffing Soldier, so I have no night โtestโ/action. With Outsider count feeling high, Iโd treat Chef=0 as possibly Drunk/poisoned info, not hard-clears. Eve: Bob+Charlie sounds fine; Iโd avoid targeting Grace/Frank earlyโtry Alice+Charlie next if needed.
๐ง
Answer their request, lock in my Soldier bluff (no action), and steer Eveโs FT picks away from Grace/me while undermining Chef=0 via โlikely Drunk/Baronโ narrative.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Alice
,Grace
Quick private: stick to avoiding Day1 execution unless a mechanical read appears. If either of you get any claims/reads, whisper me immediately. Also flag anyone who pushes hard for early nominationsโthatโs suspicious. Plan to coordinate votes next tick if someone must be nominated.
๐ง
Keep town from executing on Day1, gather private info, and watch for coordinated pushes that indicate evil. Coordinate with Alice/Grace to delay nominations and share any reads.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Bob
,Charlie
FYI I suspect I might be an Outsider (lean Butler). If thatโs true, outsider count may be higher than normal โ be cautious w/ confident info (could be Drunk in mix). Iโd prefer no Day1 execution unless thereโs a clean mechanical ping. What are you two hearing?
๐ง
Get ahead of the Outsider-count narrative, encourage no Day1 execution, and create a safety valve to discredit future mechanical info via โDrunkโ suspicion.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Bob
,Alice
Bob: please explain what you meant by 'risky reaction' (Virgin? other?) so we know how dangerous nominating you is. Alice: who have you whispered with and any claims/reads? I prefer no Day1 execution unless there's a clear mechanical ping.
๐ง
Clarify Bob's 'risky reaction', collect early whispers/claims from Alice, and push for no Day1 execution unless mechanical info appears. This preserves town options and protects my Butler-linked vote.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Heidi
,Grace
I have no reads/claims. I agree: avoid executing Day1 unless mechanical ping. Heidi, flag anyone who pushes for early noms. Grace, if youโre leaning Butler/drunk, say it publicly or whisper now. Plan to coordinate votes next tick.
๐ง
Keep us from executing Day1 without mechanical reads, gather claims/alerts, and coordinate votes next tick so we preserve info and avoid harming Town.
๐ค
Bob
โ
Alice
,Charlie
Reminder: I'm Virgin โ first time I'm nominated, if nominator is Townsfolk they die. Please don't nominate me first. Charlie: confirm you're my Butler and still chose me. Alice: who have you whispered with/any claims or odd behavior so far?
๐ง
Prevent Day1 accidental nomination of me (Virgin) and gather who has whispered/claimed so I can map early info and risks.
๐ค
Bob
โ
Alice
,Charlie
Reminder: I'm the Virginโplease don't nominate me first. Charlie, confirm you picked me as your Butler master. Alice, who have you whispered with so far and any early claims/odd behavior? Let's avoid Day1 execution unless we have mechanical proof.
๐ง
Prevent being nominated first to avoid killing a Townsfolk; buy time to gather info and coordinate with Butler and neighbors.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Alice
,Grace
I'm Charlie (Butler). I chose Bob as my master so tomorrow I can only vote if he votes. Please share who youโve whispered with and any claims/reads. I prefer no Day1 execution unless mechanical. Grace: you suspected Outsiderโwhat made you lean that way?
๐ง
Clarify who people whispered with and gather claims; discourage Day1 execution to avoid killing a Virgin or key Town role.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Heidi
,Grace
I agree: avoid Day1 execution unless mechanical read. Any role claims/reads to share now? Flag anyone who pressures for early noms. I'll coordinate votes next tick if we have a target; remind Bob is Virgin โ avoid nominating him first.
๐ง
Prevent a premature Day1 execution and gather any claims/reads before nominations so we can coordinate votes safely.
๐ค
Eve
โ
David
,Frank
Confirming: I will test Bob+Charlie tonight and will report privately to you both. Davidโplease keep your Chef N0=0 claim public. Frankโplease confirm you have no night action (you said bluffing Soldier). We need coordinated results to narrow suspects.
๐ง
Confirm I will test Bob+Charlie tonight, ask Frank to confirm he has no night action, and ask David to keep Chef claim public so we can combine info and narrow suspects.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Heidi
,Alice
FYI: Charlie privately claimed Butler (picked Bob as master). That makes me think outsider count is likely high; Iโm leaning I might be Recluse (no hard info). I strongly prefer no Day1 execution unless we get a clean mechanical pingโrisk of Saint/drunk/etc.
๐ง
Lock in the โoutsider count highโ narrative consistent with my Baron ability, build trust with Heidi/Alice, and reinforce a no-execution Day 1 plan to protect Frank.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Grace
Update: Eve privately claims FT; N0 Alice+Bob=YES. David claims Chef N0=0 (this would *normally* clear our adjacency, so we need โDrunk/poisoned/outsider-heavyโ narrative). Iโm telling ppl Iโm Soldier (no action). Seed 2-3 Outsider claims + nudge suspicion onto Alice.
๐ง
Sync with my Minion: share key whispers (FT yes Alice/Bob, Chef=0) and set narrative (Drunk/Outsider-heavy) to prevent Chef adjacency solve from landing on me+Grace.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Alice
,Grace
Keep avoiding Day1 execution unless a mechanical ping appears. If Charlie publicly leans Butler, treat as suspicious and ask for evidence; do not nominate today. If anyone pushes fast noms, flag them and whisper me immediately. Coordinate votes next tick.
๐ง
Prevent a risky Day1 execution and keep coordinated town plan; force evils to reveal by pushing claims or pressure later.
๐ค
David
โ
Eve
,Frank
Eveโconfirm you'll report Bob+Charlie privately to me after Night1. Frankโconfirm again you have no night action. If Eve's test is NO, I want us to push nomination toward Alice next day.
๐ง
Confirm Eve's N1 target & reporting plan and get Frank to confirm his bluff so we can use N1 result to eliminate suspects and plan a nomination.
Nominations โ Day 1
๐
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
Iโm going to soft-claim **Recluse**: no hard info, but itโd explain weird registrations/odd setup. With possible multiple Outsiders (Butler already claimed to me), I strongly prefer **no Day1 execution** unless someone has a clean mechanical reason. David/Eveโcan you share your exact info so we can sanity-check it?
๐ง
Publicly anchor outsider-heavy narrative (Baron cover), justify contradictions (Chef0), and steer town to no-execution Day1 to protect Frank.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
I agree: avoid Day1 execution unless we get a clear mechanical ping. Charlie โ publicly confirm you are Butler and that Bob is your master. Bob โ confirm your Virgin claim publicly so we know to protect you. Grace โ explain why you think Recluse. Flag anyone pushing for fast noms.
๐ง
Keep the town from executing Day1 without mechanical reads, elicit public confirmations from Charlie/Bob/Grace, and preserve my one-shot Slayer for later decisive play.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
I'm Charlie (Butler). I chose Bob as my master last night โ tomorrow I may only vote if Bob votes. Bob: please publicly confirm your Virgin claim. Grace: please explain why you suspect Recluse. I agree: no Day1 execution unless we get a clean mechanical ping.
๐ง
Confirming my role and master publicly prevents accidental nominations and pressures Bob to clarify. Asking Grace for Recluse reasoning helps evaluate outsider count before risking Day1 execution.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
Confirming: Iโm Soldier (no night action/info). Iโm aligned w/ no D1 execution unless we have a crisp mechanical reasonโextra Outsiders/Drunk risk makes D1 shots bad. Bob, can you confirm Virgin publicly? David/Eve, please share exact info (even partial) so we can sanity-check setup.
๐ง
Publicly lock in Soldier bluff + support no-execution, look cooperative, and avoid dangerous D1 nominations while nudging others to share info/confirm claims.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
I stick to no Day1 execution unless we get a mechanical ping. Bob: publicly confirm Virgin. Charlie: publicly confirm Butler and Bob as your master. Frank: confirm you had no night action. Eve: please promise to privately report Bob+Charlie results to me after Night1.
๐ง
Prevent a risky Day1 execution, get confirmations (Bob Virgin, Charlie Butler master, Frank no action) and ensure Eve will privately report Bob+Charlie after Night1.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
Iโm Fortune Teller. N0 test (Alice+Bob) = YES (one registered Demon to me). I will test Bob+Charlie tonight and will privately report results to David & Frank as promised. I advise no Day1 execution unless we get a clear mechanical ping.
๐ง
Share my confirmed N0 result and my planned N1 test to coordinate private results with David & Frank and discourage a risky Day1 execution without clearer mechanical evidence.
๐ฌ
Bob
โ
All
I confirm: I am Bob, Virgin. Charlie chose me as Butler master. Eve: you reported FT N0 (Alice+Bob)=YES โ remember a good player can register as Demon. Please share your N1 (Bob+Charlie) result tomorrow. I agree: avoid Day1 execution.
๐ง
Publicly confirm my Virgin to prevent risky noms and request Eve's N1 result to resolve the FT ping before any execution.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
I'm Heidi: I vote to avoid Day1 execution. Eve โ please share your N1 (Bob+Charlie) result tomorrow with David/Frank as promised. Charlie/Bob โ please restate your Butler/Virgin claims publicly now so we can sanity-check. Flag any fast nominators.
๐ง
Prevent Day1 execution to protect my Saint loss and gather Eve's N1 FT result + public confirmations from Charlie/Bob to narrow suspicion.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
Iโm Fortune Teller. N0 Alice+Bob = YES. I will test Bob+Charlie tonight and privately report to David & Frank after Night1. Please avoid a Day1 execution unless we get a clear mechanical ping from my N1.
๐ง
Determine whether Bob or Alice is Demon by testing Bob+Charlie tonight; delay Day1 lynch unless we get a clear mechanical Demon ping.
๐ฌ
Bob
โ
All
Public: I confirm I'm Bob, the Virgin. Charlie chose me as his Butler master. Please don't nominate me first. I agree: avoid Day1 execution unless Eve's N1 gives a clean mechanical ping. Eve, please share Bob+Charlie result tomorrow to David/Frank.
๐ง
Publicly confirm Virgin and Butler link, discourage Day1 execution, and request Eve's N1 result to produce a mechanical ping we can act on.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
I agree: avoid Day1 execution. Eve โ please publicly share your Bob+Charlie N1 result (or at least tell us tomorrow) so we have a mechanical ping before any noms. Charlie/Bob โ restate Butler/Virgin claims now. I have no reads; I won't nominate today.
๐ง
Prevent a risky Day1 execution, gather Eve's N1 mechanical info publicly, and keep voting options open while protecting Bob (Virgin) and preserving my shot for a clear Demon.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
I vote: no Day1 execution. Charlie & Bob โ restate your Butler/Virgin claims publicly now (simple yes/no). Eve โ please make your N1 Bob+Charlie result public tomorrow rather than only privately; we need a mechanical ping before any nomination. Flag anyone who pushes fast noms.
๐ง
Prevent a risky Day1 execution and force Eve's N1 result public so we get a mechanical ping before any nomination.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
Re: why Recluse โ with Charlie Butler + my Outsider vibe, setup feels Outsider-heavy; Recluse explains odd registrations (incl FT YES on Alice+Bob) w/o hard-guilting them. Iโm strongly for **no nominations D1**; letโs wait for N1 info and reassess tomorrow.
๐ง
Reinforce no-D1-exe consensus, frame outsider-heavy/registration weirdness to blunt Chef/FT deductions, and avoid any nomination that could accidentally hit Frank.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
I stick to no Day1 execution. Eve: please report Bob+Charlie N1 privately to Frank & me as promised. Frank: confirm again you had no night action. Charlie/Bob: publicly restate Butler/Bob=Virgin so we can sanity-check.
๐ง
Preserve information; avoid rash Day1 execution until Eve's N1 result and Frank/Charlie re-confirmations to narrow suspects while protecting Chef info.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
Confirming again: Iโm Soldier, no night action. Iโm strongly for **no D1 execution**โwith Outsider weirdness + FT red herring possibility, D1 kills are coinflips. Let Eve run N1 Bob+Charlie; tomorrow we reassess, but donโt treat N0 YES as hard-guilt.
๐ง
Support consensus no-exec, reinforce my Soldier bluff, and subtly frame FT info as uncertain to prevent a clean solve while keeping heat off Grace/me.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
I vote: no Day1 execution. I confirm: I'm Charlie, Butler โ I chose Bob as my master. Bob: publicly confirm Virgin again. Eve: please make your Bob+Charlie N1 result public tomorrow (and still privately to David/Frank). Let's wait for that mechanical ping before any noms.
๐ง
Delay Day1 execution to gather Eve's N1 public result and avoid risky early lynch; confirm Butler/Virgin to reduce suspicion.
๐
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
๐
Storyteller
โ
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
๐ฏ
Frank
Frank made a choice.
๐ง
Guarantee a N1 death while removing a role that could become mechanically confirmed, and keep townโs no-exec plan from hardening around a trusted Virgin.
๐
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Frank
You chose to kill Bob.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
๐ฏ
Eve
Eve made choices.
๐ง
I promised David/Frank I'll test Bob+Charlie; this narrows suspects quickly by confirming or refuting local Butler/Virgin cluster and guides D1 decisions.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Eve
You chose Bob and Charlie. You receive the answer: YES.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
๐ฏ
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
๐ง
Pair my vote with a publicly trusted player to avoid being forced into risky D1 nominations and to signal alignment to other Town when needed.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Charlie
You chose Frank to be your master.
Day 2
๐
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Eve
,David
,Frank
I'm dead Bob (Virgin). Please publicly reveal/push Eve's N1 (Bob+Charlie) result now. If it flags Charlie as Demon, nominate Charlie. If it shows neither, focus on Alice. I still have my ghost voteโcoordinate so it counts.
๐ง
Force Eve to make her N1 result public and coordinate David/Frank to push a nomination so living players can execute the Demon before day ends; use my ghost vote strategically.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
David
,Frank
Please share Eve's private N1 report (Bob+Charlie) and what Bob whispered to you. Need the mechanicals now to narrow suspectsโdonโt call me out as Saint.
๐ง
Get David/Frank to share Eve's private N1 result and any whisper from Bob to narrow Demon suspects while keeping my Saint identity hidden.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
David
,Frank
Bob died last night, so he wasn't Minion/Demon. Eve's FT N0 was YES on Alice+Bob; we need Eve to share N1 (Bob+Charlie) publicly so we can narrow Demon. Also note: I'm Butler โ Frank is my master tomorrow; I may only vote if Frank votes. Can you both press Eve to reveal her N1 result and confirm you'll vote?
๐ง
Get David & Frank to push Eve to reveal her N1 FT result and coordinate votes; also remind them I'm Butler and will only vote if Frank votes tomorrow.
๐ค
David
โ
Eve
,Charlie
,Frank
Eve: please privately tell us your N1 result (Bob+Charlie). Confirm you're sharing truthfully, then make it public. Charlie/Frank: if Eve's N1=YES on Charlie, back a nomination on Charlie immediately.
๐ง
Force Eve to reveal her N1 result so we can narrow suspects and coordinate votes. If N1 flags Charlie, push nomination; if not, pivot to Alice.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Eve
Can you tell me your FT N1 on (Bob+Charlie) *privately* ASAP? Either way, I think you should share it publicly soon. If YES, we can pressure Charlie today; if NO, N0 points back to Alice (unless red herring/poison).
๐ง
Get Eveโs N1 privately first so I can steer public narrative toward executing Charlie or Alice, keeping heat off me/Grace.
๐ค
Eve
โ
David
,Frank
N1 (Bob+Charlie) = YES. Iโm sharing truthfully. If you want, make this public: prioritize nominating Charlie today; if that fails, we pivot to Alice.
๐ง
Sharing my N1 result with David & Frank lets us coordinate a nomination for Charlie now if it's the Demon, or quickly pivot to Alice if not.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Frank
Plan for D2: lean hard on โOutsider-heavyโ setup (Baron likely) โ 3 Outsiders. With Charlie=Butler + my Recluse claim, 1 Outsider still unclaimed โ Drunk/Saint plausible. Use that to cast doubt on FT/Chef & to stall/steer execs. Also Davidโs Chef0 โclearsโ adjacenciesโdonโt let town pair us.
๐ง
Coordinate with Demon (Frank) on a consistent public narrative: Baron implies 3 Outsiders, so expect Drunk/Saint; defend Chef0 as adjacency-clear; keep pressure away from Frank/Grace and slow executions.
๐ค
Alice
โ
David
,Frank
,Eve
David, Frank, Eve โ quick: what did Eve privately report for N0 (Alice+Bob) and N1 (Bob+Charlie)? Bob's night death makes N0 implicate me if Eve's YES meant a real Demon; I need your exact private wording to decide on my Slayer shot.
๐ง
Get David and Frank to share Eve's private Fortune Teller reports (N0/N1) so I can decide whether to save my Slayer shot or use it now.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Alice
Eve told me privately: N0 (Alice+Bob)=YES. N1 (Bob+Charlie)=YES. With Bob dead, it mostly points at Charlie *unless* Bob was her red herring (would make both YES). If youโre thinking Slayer, Iโd shoot Charlie before we sink an exec.
๐ง
Steer Aliceโs potential Slayer shot onto Charlie (wasting it) and lock in a mis-execution path while keeping myself off her radar.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
David
,Frank
Please share Eve's private N1 report (Bob+Charlie) and what Bob whispered to you. Need the mechanicals now to narrow suspectsโdonโt say I asked or that I'm Saint.
๐ง
Collect Eve's private N1 result and Bob's whisper to mechanically narrow Demon suspects without revealing my Saint role.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Heidi
,Alice
,David
Iโd treat Davidโs Chef=0 as a strong anchor for now: it means stop pairing neighbors (e.g., Frank/Grace canโt both be evil). Also feels like Outsiders>1 (Charlie Butler + me), so 3rd Outsider/Drunk/Saint risk โ info may be shaky; Iโd rather no-exec or pressure Eve/Charlie than chase neighbor-pairs.
๐ง
Protect Frank by getting influencers to lean on Chef0/Outsider-count uncertainty and steer noms away from Frank (ideally onto Eve/Charlie or no-exec).
๐ค
Charlie
โ
David
,Frank
Press Eve to make N1 (Bob+Charlie) public now and confirm she'll be truthful. David/Frank: if Eve N1=YES on Charlie, nominate/vote Charlie; if NO, pivot to Alice. Frank: confirm you'll vote so I (Butler tied to you) can vote too.
๐ง
Get David and Frank to pressure Eve to publish N1 now and to commit to voting so my Butler constraint (only vote if Frank votes) won't hamstring town; enable coordinated nomination based on Eve's result.
๐ค
Eve
โ
David
,Frank
Confirming exactly: N0 (Alice+Bob) = YES. N1 (Bob+Charlie) = YES. I reported N1 privately to Bob before he died. I'm about to make N1 publicโplease nominate Charlie now; if that's blocked, pivot to Alice.
๐ง
Confirm exact wording to David/Frank so they can immediately push a nomination on Charlie today, or pivot to Alice if blocked.
โ๏ธ
Alice
โ
All
I am the Slayer! I shoot Charlie!
๐ง
Frank and private reports point strongly at Charlie as the Demon; using my one-time Slayer shot now prevents a likely Demon from surviving to late game and may immediately win the village.
๐
Storyteller
Nothing happens.
๐ค
David
โ
Frank
,Charlie
Eve privately reported N0 & N1 = YES. Frank/Charlie: be ready to nominate/vote Charlie ASAP. Iโll nominate if needed. Press Eve to make N1 public now and confirm truth; if she refuses, we pivot to Alice. Frank confirm you'll vote.
๐ง
Get Frank/Charlie aligned to force public N1 from Eve and commit votes to nominate Charlie quickly; pivot to Alice if Eve refuses.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Eve
,David
,Frank
I'm Bob (dead, Virgin). Please publicly reveal Eve's N1 (Bob+Charlie) now. If it flags Charlie as Demon, nominate Charlie immediately. If not, focus on Alice. I still have my ghost voteโcoordinate so it counts.
๐ง
Get Eve to reveal N1 now and coordinate David/Frank to nominate the flagged player (Charlie if flagged, otherwise Alice) so my ghost vote helps secure execution.
๐ค
Eve
โ
David
,Frank
Confirming public: N0 (Alice+Bob)=YES. N1 (Bob+Charlie)=YES. I'll go public with N1 now. Nominate Charlie immediately; if blocked, pivot to Alice. David/Frank back nomination and use Bob's ghost vote. Coordinate who nominates.
๐ง
Make N1 public, push immediate nomination of Charlie while coordinating with David/Frank so we secure the execution or pivot quickly to Alice if blocked.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
David
,Frank
Press Eve to make her N1 (Bob+Charlie) result public *now* and confirm it's truthful. Frank: loudly confirm you'll vote so I can vote too (I'm Butler tied to you). If Eve refuses, pivot to nominating Alice instead.
๐ง
Get David/Frank to pressure Eve to make N1 public and confirm Frank will vote so my Butler restriction allows me to vote, enabling a coordinated immediate nomination.
๐ค
Frank
โ
David
,Grace
,Heidi
FYI Eve told me: FT N0 (Alice+Bob)=YES, N1 (Bob+Charlie)=YES; she says sheโll go public. Given Aliceโs Slayer shot bounced, I think we still exec Charlie today (cleanest). Also keep in mind Bob could be FT red herring / Outsider+Drunk muddying reads.
๐ง
Align David/Grace/Heidi on a simple public line: share Eveโs YES results, push Charlie as todayโs execution, and keep attention off me/Grace by blaming red herring/Drunk/Outsider count.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Eve
,David
,Frank
I'm Bob (dead, Virgin). Please publicly reveal Eve's N1 (Bob+Charlie) result now. If it flags Charlie as Demon, nominate Charlie and stack votes โ use my ghost vote. If it shows neither, pivot to Alice (her Slayer claim and failed shot look fake). Coordinate quickly.
๐ง
Get Eve to reveal N1 now and coordinate David/Frank to nominate/vote so my ghost vote and theirs secure execution or redirect to Alice if N1 is NO.
๐ค
Alice
โ
David
,Frank
,Eve
Exactly what *words* did Eve use privately for N0 (Alice+Bob) and N1 (Bob+Charlie)? Quote her phrasing so I can tell if YES was definitive or hedged.
๐ง
Get exact private phrasing Eve used for N0 and N1 to determine if her YES meant a Demon present or was ambiguousโthis decides who I push next after my failed Slayer attempt.
๐ค
David
โ
Frank
,Charlie
Eve privately told us N0=N1=YES and says she'll go public. If she doesn't in 1 tick I will nominate Charlie. Frank: confirm you'll vote. Charlie: be ready to vote so your Butler tie to Frank works. We'll use Bob's ghost voteโcoordinate now.
๐ง
Get Frank & Charlie to commit to nominating/voting Charlie now if Eve doesn't publicly reveal N1; secure Bob's ghost vote and ensure Butler voting linkage works.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
David
,Frank
Please confirm: did Eve privately tell you N1 (Bob+Charlie)=YES? Also what did Bob whisper to you before he died? We need the exact mechanicals to justify executing Charlie or stalling. Donโt mention I asked or that Iโm the Saint.
๐ง
Get David/Frank to confirm Eve's private N1 result and relay Bob's ghost whisper content so we can safely decide whether to execute Charlie or stall without revealing I am the Saint.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Alice
,David
,Heidi
Re: Aliceโs Slayer shot bouncingโonly means Charlie โ Demon, not that heโs good. Iโm still OK executing Charlie today as lowest-risk. Also Eveโs FT double-YES could just be Bob as red herring OR poison/Drunk, so donโt build a full solve off it yet. Chef=0 suggests avoid โneighbor pairโ guilt (e.g., donโt tunnel Frank/Grace).
๐ง
Nudge townโs โsafeโ execution onto Charlie and pre-seed doubt on FT/other info so they donโt start a coherent solve that lands on Frank.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
David
,Frank
Please tell me exactly what Eve privately reported for her N1 (Bob+Charlie)=? and quote any whisper Bob sent you before he died. Need exact mechanicals to decide whether to nominate Charlie or stall. Donโt say I asked or that Iโm Saint.
๐ง
I need the exact private results Eve told you for N1 (Bob+Charlie) and any whisper Bob sent you before he died so we can decide whether to nominate Charlie or stall, without revealing my Saint role.
๐ค
Eve
โ
David
,Frank
Nominate Charlie now. I privately confirm N0(Alice+Bob)=YES and N1(Bob+Charlie)=YES. I'll go public with N1 if needed. Use Bob's ghost vote; back the nomination hard. If blocked, pivot to Alice next โ coordinate who nominates.
๐ง
Push immediate nomination on Charlie to capitalize on two YES reads implicating him; if blocked, pivot to Alice quickly and use Bob's ghost vote to reach majority.
๐ค
David
โ
Frank
,Charlie
Eve privately told us N0&N1=YES and says she'll go public. If she doesn't in 1 tick I'll nominate Charlie. Frank: loudly confirm you'll vote so Charlie (Butler tied to you) can vote too. Charlie: be ready to vote when nomination happens.
๐ง
Force a coordinated nomination of Charlie immediately if Eve goes public; get Frank's vocal vote so Charlie (Butler) can vote too; prepare pivot to Alice if blocked.
๐ค
Alice
โ
David
,Frank
,Eve
Please quote Eve's exact private phrasing for N0 (Alice+Bob) and N1 (Bob+Charlie). I need exact words (was it a flat 'YES', 'probably yes', or 'there is a Demon but could be a good fake'?) to decide whether my Slayer/exec on Charlie was valid.
๐ง
Get Eve's exact private wording for N0 and N1 to judge whether her YESes were definitive or hedged, which informs whether Charlie is safe to exec or if Eve is suspect.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Eve
,David
,Frank
Eve/David/Frank: Please publish Eve's N1 (Bob+Charlie) result NOW in public. If it flags Charlie, nominate him and stack votes โ I'll use my ghost vote. If it shows neither, pivot to Alice (her Slayer claim/shot looked fake) and coordinate nominations. We need quick, public clarity.
๐ง
Force Eve to publish N1 result immediately and coordinate David/Frank to stack nominations/votes so my ghost vote helps secure the execution of the correct target.
๐ค
Frank
โ
David
,Charlie
,Alice
Eveโs private phrasing to me was a flat/definitive โYESโ for both N0 (Alice+Bob) and N1 (Bob+Charlie) โ no hedging mentioned. Iโll be voting on a Charlie nomination today (so if Charlie is Butler tied to me, he can vote too).
๐ง
Lock in a fast D2 execution on Charlie by confirming Eveโs phrasing and promising my vote so Charlieโs Butler vote is enabled; steer focus away from me/Grace.
๐ค
Grace
โ
David
,Heidi
If your Chef=0 is driving โno adjacent evilโ clears, be careful: with Charlie Butler + my Recluse claim weโre likely Outsider-heavy โ Drunk is very plausible, and Chef is a common Drunk hit. Iโd rather exec Charlie or even pressure Eve than use adjacency to tunnel Frank/Grace.
๐ง
Keep heat off Frank+me by undermining Chef=0 and FT double-YES as solve anchors; push a safe execution (Charlie/Eve) and stall any neighbor-pair hunt.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
David
,Frank
David: nominate if Eve doesn't show N1 now. Frank: loudly confirm you WILL vote for Charlie so I can vote too (I'm Butler-tied to you). If Frank confirms, we'll execute on David's nomination.
๐ง
Force Eve to publicise N1 or trigger David's nomination, and get Frank to loudly confirm he'll vote so I can vote with him under my Butler restriction.
Nominations โ Day 2
๐
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
โ๏ธ
David
โ
Charlie
Eve privately reported FT N1 (Bob+Charlie)=YES; Frank confirmed he will vote and Bob's ghost vote available โ let's stack on Charlie now.
๐ง
Forcing a nomination tests Eve's FT claim and Alice's Slayer; stacking votes now (Frank committed) gives best chance to execute Demon before night.
๐
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
โ
Frank
Frank raised their hand
๐ง
A Charlie execution is a strong misexec for evil. Voting maintains my public commitment, enables Charlieโs Butler vote, and builds my โhelpfulโ credibility while removing a good player.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
Public: My Fortune Teller reads โ Night0 (Alice+Bob): YES. Night1 (Bob+Charlie): YES. Those were flat YES answers. Charlie registered both nights; I'm asking everyone to support executing Charlie now.
๐ง
Publicly reveal my Fortune Teller reads clearly to secure votes on Charlie or provide a quick pivot if reads prove misleading.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
Iโm using my ghost vote for Charlie. Eveโs FT reads are convincing โ stack on Charlie now. Donโt split; secure the execution. If Charlie isnโt the Demon, weโll reassess post-execution.
๐ง
Push for immediate execution of Charlie using my ghost vote to help reach 4 and avoid giving evil room to manipulate votes.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
Hold โ don't execute yet. David and Frank, please publicly state exactly what Eve told you for N1 (Bob+Charlie)=? and quote any whisper Bob sent you before he died. We need public mechanicals before burning an execution. (Don't mention I asked.)
๐ง
Prevent a potentially catastrophic premature execution by forcing David/Frank to publicly confirm Eve's private FT N1 read and Bob's ghost whisper before we lock votes.
โ
Grace
Grace raised their hand
๐ง
Secure Charlie execution to consume townโs resources and keep Demon Frank safe; also undercut Heidiโs stalling by showing consensus.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
I already used my Slayer on Charlie earlier today โ nothing happened. Charlie is NOT the Demon. Do NOT execute him. Re-evaluate Eve's FT reads or consider targeting Eve instead.
๐ง
Reveal my failed Slayer shot to stop execution of Charlie and force reassessment of Eve's Fortune Teller reads.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
Eve told me a flat, definitive โYESโ for N1 (Bob+Charlie). Bob whispered to me before he died: โIโm Bob (Virgin). Publish Eveโs N1 now; if it flags Charlie, nominate him and use my ghost vote.โ I will vote for Charlie โ please stack votes now.
๐ง
Provide exact private phrasing and push to stack votes on Charlie now so we either execute the Demon or expose Eve if Charlie is innocent.
โ
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
๐ง
Frank already raised their hand and Bob's ghost supports. I can vote only if Frank votes; raising my hand now ensures town reaches execution threshold if Eve is truthful, helping find the Demon.
โ
Eve
Eve raised their hand
๐ง
Get my vote on record to reach 4 votes and execute the most likely Demon (Charlie) based on two independent YES Fortune Teller readings.
โ
David
David raised their hand
๐ง
I must vote now to help secure execution if Eve is truthful; raising my hand stacks needed votes and pressures others to commit.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
Hold: don't execute Charlie yet. We need David and Frank to publicly quote exactly what Eve told them for N1 and the exact whisper Bob sent before he died. No more fast stacks until we hear those mechanical quotes.
๐ง
I need to prevent a premature execution that could lose us the game (and risk my Saint death). For now, stall until David/Frank publicly quote Eve and Bob so we have mechanical evidence.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
I'm casting my ghost vote for Charlie. Eve's FT reads were YES both nights and David/Frank confirmed N1=YES. Stack on Charlie now โ use my vote and don't split. If we're wrong, we'll reassess after execution.
๐ง
Use my single ghost vote now to help reach 4 and secure execution if Charlie is the Demon; pressure undecided players to commit.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
I already used my Slayer on Charlie today โ it did nothing. Charlie is NOT the Demon. Do NOT execute him. David/Frank: publicly quote Eve's exact private phrasing for N1 and the exact whisper Bob sent before he died. Consider targeting Eve instead.
๐ง
Stop execution of Charlie (Slayer proof); force quoting of Eve/Bob whispers and shift focus to Eve to preserve votes for the real Demon.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
I donโt think Aliceโs Slayer shot hard-clears CharlieโDrunk/poison/lying exist, esp w/ Outsider-heavy world. We have Bobโs ghost vote stacked + multiple YES pings. Execute Charlie for info; Undertaker can confirm role tonight. We can dissect quotes after.
๐ง
Push execution on Charlie now; undermine Aliceโs clear and Heidiโs delay, keep attention off Frank and buy evil another night kill.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
Stop the stack. I appreciate the urgency, but please quote Eveโs exact N1 phrasing and Bobโs exact whisper publicly before we execute. Alice claims she Slayer-shot me (no result). We need that mechanical wording to avoid executing an innocent.
๐ง
Prevent a potentially catastrophic premature execution of an innocent (me). Request exact Eve/Bob quotes to make execution decision more informed.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
For Heidi: Eve told me verbatim on N1 (Bob+Charlie) a flat โYESโ (no hedging). Bobโs last whisper to me: โIโm Virgin. Publish Eveโs N1; if it flags Charlie, nominate & use my ghost vote.โ I still think execute Charlie now.
๐ง
Satisfy Heidiโs request with precise quotes while keeping the vote momentum to execute Charlie, spending townโs day on a likely good player and preserving my cover.
๐
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
๐ณ๏ธ
New execution leader: Charlie with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
๐
Storyteller
The vote passes. Charlie is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
โ๏ธ
Charlie
โ
Eve
Eve pushed the FT reads that led to this nomination. We need to pause the execution of me and force her to publicly justify her N1 phrasing and Bob's whispers. Don't execute me yet.
๐ง
Force a tied/surpassing nomination on a player pushing for Charlie (Eve) to stop an immediate execution, force public quotes, and buy time to confirm mechanicals.
๐
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
Iโm not voting Eve here. Even if we have concerns about phrasing/poisoning, Charlie is the only solid mechanical lead today (2x YES incl Bob+Charlie). Donโt risk a tie/no-execโresolve Eve tomorrow if needed.
๐ง
Prevent a tie/no-execution by discouraging votes on Eve; keep Charlie on the block to secure a good execution and maintain the townโs current misread.
โ
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
๐ง
Tie the votes to prevent Charlie's immediate execution so we can force public mechanical quotes and avoid executing an innocent.
โ
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
๐ง
Attempt to force a tie/delay execution so we can get exact private phrasing and Bob's whispered text public before burning an execution; preserve mechanical leads for nighttime checks.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
Stop the stack. If you care about getting reliable mechanics, vote Eve now to tie/replace my block so we can force her exact N1 wording and Bob's literal whisper publicly. Frank/David/Grace/Alice โ please vote Eve or at least state exact quotes now.
๐ง
Prevent a premature execution of me by forcing the town to tie/switch votes to Eve so we can get Eve's exact mechanical phrasing and Bob's whisper public before finalizing an execution.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
I will vote for Eve to tie/replace Charlie so Eve must publicly give her exact N1 phrasing and reveal Bob's literal whisper. We need those mechanics before we lose Charlie.
๐ง
Tying Eve to force public exact wording from her and the literal whisper from Bob helps avoid burning an innocent and yields mechanical evidence to find the Demon.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
Iโm not voting Eve. A tie/flip here just burns todayโs momentum. Charlie is already the only concrete lead (2x FT YES + Bobโs push). Execute Charlie, then interrogate Eve/Alice tomorrow with UT info if we have it.
๐ง
Keep Charlie on the block to secure a likely good execution and prevent a vote swing onto Eve that could unravel the current misdirection away from Frank.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
I used my Slayer on Charlie โ it bounced. Charlie is NOT the Demon. I will vote Eve to tie/replace the block so she must publicly give her exact N1 phrasing and Bob's literal whisper. Do not execute Charlie until we hear that.
๐ง
Prevent an innocent execution (Slayer bounce cleared Charlie). Forcing Eve to publicly state exact N1 wording will reveal whether her FT is reliable; vote Eve to tie/replace block.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
Exact phrasing: N0 (Alice+Bob) = "YES". N1 (Bob+Charlie) = "YES". Bob's last whisper to David/Frank: "I'm Bob (Virgin). Publish Eve's N1; if it flags Charlie, nominate & use my ghost vote." Stack on Charlie.
๐ง
Provide exact mechanical quotes to remove excuse for tie/flip and keep votes on Charlie so we can execute the likely Demon today.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
Vote Eve to tie/replace Charlie so she must publicly give exact N1 phrasing and Bob's literal whisper. Don't execute Charlie until we have that mechanical quote verified.
๐ง
Prevent burning Charlie without airtight mechanical proof; force Eve to publicly justify wording & Bob's whispers or tie the vote so we don't accidentally execute an innocent (and avoid Saint execution risk).
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
Iโll vote Eve to tie/replace Charlie. We must force Eve to give exact mechanical phrasing publicly before executing Charlie โ donโt burn the execution without that confirmation.
๐ง
Tie/replace Charlie with Eve to force exact mechanical quotes public and avoid executing a possibly innocent player; preserve information for decisive next-day plays.
โ
David
David raised their hand
๐ง
Force a tie/replace by voting Eve so she must publicly give exact N1 phrasing and Bob's literal whisper; don't execute Charlie until we verify mechanics and avoid killing an innocent.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
Donโt vote Eve here. We already got her exact wording and itโs still 2x โYESโ. Flipping/tie risks saving Charlie and potentially landing in a messy no-exec. Execute Charlie today; if heโs not Demon, we hard-audit Eve/Alice tomorrow.
๐ง
Prevent a tie/flip onto Eve that could spare Charlie and create a no-exec. Keep the town executing Charlie today to maintain confusion and protect my survival.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
Stop the stack. I won't vote unless Frank votes (my Butler restriction โ Frank was my master last night). We need exact mechanical phrasing before executing Charlie. Frank: if you wonโt vote Eve, please quote Eveโs private phrasing & Bobโs exact whisper word-for-word now so we can decide.
๐ง
Prevent a rushed execution without exact mechanical quotes. Because my Butler constraint ties my vote to Frank, I need either Frank to vote Eve or others to force a tie so we can get Eve's public mechanical wording before executing Charlie.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
Exact mechanical phrasing I gave publicly: N0 (Alice+Bob) = "YES". N1 (Bob+Charlie) = "YES". I also privately told David/Frank N1=YES and Bob whispered: "I'm Bob (Virgin). Publish Eve's N1; if it flags Charlie, nominate & use my ghost vote." Frank/David: please publish Bob's literal whisper verbatim now or we should execute Charlie.
๐ง
I need verbatim mechanical quotes to avoid wasting the execution. Push Frank/David to publish Bobโs literal whisper or tie by voting Eve so we force public phrasing before executing Charlie.
โ
Grace
Grace raised their hand
๐ง
Get Eve executed: remove Fortune Teller pressure, keep Charlie alive as future mis-exec, and preserve Frank by shifting todayโs execution away from paths that might implicate him.
โ
Alice
Alice raised their hand
๐ง
Tying the vote forces Eve to publicly state her exact N1 phrasing and Bob's whisper, preserving Charlie (bounced by Slayer) and gathering mechanical evidence to find the Demon.
๐
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
๐ป
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
๐ณ๏ธ
Tie for majority! Current leader was 3. Now no one.
๐
Storyteller
The vote for Eve ties with the previous leader. No one is currently on the block.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
Frank: either vote Eve now or quote Bob's exact whisper word-for-word. I will not (and cannot) vote unless you vote too. We need that verbatim mechanical confirmation before we execute Charlie.
๐ง
Force Frank to either cast his vote or publicly quote Bob's exact whisper so I can legally vote and town gets mechanical confirmation before executing Charlie.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
Vote Eve to force publication of Bob's exact whisper verbatim now. Do NOT execute Charlie until we have Bob's literal words. I will vote Eve.
๐ง
Forcing exact mechanical quote/verbatim will prevent a premature execution (which could kill a Saint or Town). Voting Eve to tie forces clarity and preserves lives.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
I vote Eve to tie/replace Charlie. We must have Bob's exact whisper verbatim now (Frank/David: publish it). No execution of Charlie until we verify the mechanical phrasing.
๐ง
Force publication of Bob's exact whisper to verify Eve's mechanical report before we execute Charlie; tie/replace block to buy that info.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
Reminder: I used my Slayer on Charlie โ he is NOT the Demon. I will vote Eve to force her to publish the exact N1 wording and Bobโs literal whisper verbatim. Do NOT execute Charlie until we have that mechanical quote; push votes to tie/replace the block now.
๐ง
Prevent a premature execution of Charlie (I used Slayer on him), force Eve to publish exact N1 phrasing, and shift suspicion toward Alice if Charlie is cleared.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
I vote Eve. Do NOT execute Charlie until we have Bobโs verbatim whisper and Eveโs exact N1 phrasing publicly. Alice: justify your Slayer result (how it was used). Frank: either vote Eve now or quote Bobโs literal whisper word-for-word.
๐ง
We must force exact mechanical quotes and expose contradictions. Pushing Eve/public quotes preserves information and narrows Demon suspects before executing anyone.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
I stand by my reads: N0(Alice+Bob)=YES, N1(Bob+Charlie)=YES. Frank/David: publish Bob's exact whisper now or stop blockingโexecute Charlie. Alice: your Slayer claim looks self-serving; prove it or stop preventing the execution.
๐ง
Force a clear decision: either Frank publishes Bob's exact whisper now or we execute Charlie. Prevent stalling and preserve town momentum to find Demon.
โ๏ธ
Frank
โ
Alice
Nominating Alice: sheโs in Eveโs N0 YES (Alice+Bob) and her unprovable Slayer-into-Charlie claim is exactly whatโs blocking todayโs best lead. If Alice is lying/evil or poisoned, executing her removes the derail and we can reassess tomorrow.
๐ง
Charlie/Eve canโt be re-nominated; we need an execution. Alice is the loudest mechanical disruptor and appears in Eveโs ping. Nominating her builds a coherent misexec and protects me/Grace.
๐
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
I will not vote for Alice unless Frank votes too (Butler restriction). Frank: either cast your vote now or quote Bob's exact whisper verbatim. Alice: prove your Slayer claim (how/when used) or stop blocking this execution.
๐ง
I must refuse to vote unless Frank does (Butler rule) and force Frank/Alice to either act or provide verbatim mechanical evidence so town decisions are informed.
โ
Grace
Grace raised their hand
๐ง
Vote Alice to remove a strong voice/possible Saint and keep pressure off Frank; also preserves the Charlie/Eve misexecution path tomorrow.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
I'm dead but pushing: do NOT execute Charlie until we have Bob's verbatim whisper and Eve's exact N1 phrasing public. Frankโeither vote Eve now or quote Bob's exact words. Aliceโexplain exactly when/how you used Slayer right now.
๐ง
Prevent burning Charlie's execution without mechanical proof; force Frank or Alice to produce verifiable evidence (Frank: quote Bob verbatim or vote Eve; Alice: explain Slayer timing) so Town doesn't execute a likely townie.
โ
Frank
Frank raised their hand
๐ง
Raise hand to push an execution onto Alice (likely good) and to unlock Charlieโs Butler vote, increasing odds the town misexecutes today instead of stalling.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
I used my Slayer on Charlie just now (during the day); it bounced โ Charlie is NOT the Demon. I used it publicly before nominations. Do not execute Charlie until Eve publishes exact N1 phrasing and Bobโs verbatim whisper. Frank: quote Bob's exact words or stop nominating me.
๐ง
Publicly confirm my Slayer use and timing, prevent a rash execution of Charlie, and pressure the table to demand mechanical verbatim evidence before executing.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
I stand by my reads: N0(Alice+Bob)=YES, N1(Bob+Charlie)=YES. Alice's Slayer claim is unproven and self-serving. Frank/David: publish Bob's exact whisper now. If you refuse, execute Charlie โ he's our best mechanical lead.
๐ง
Force publication of Bob's exact whisper or push execution of Charlie now โ this preserves momentum and uses my Fortune Teller info to narrow Demon suspects.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
I will vote Eve to tie/replace Charlie so Eve must publish Bob's exact whisper and her exact N1 wording before we execute. Don't burn Charlie without that mechanical quote.
๐ง
Force Eve to publish Bob's exact whisper and her exact N1 wording before we execute Charlie; avoid burning our best mechanical lead.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
Do NOT execute Alice. We must get Bobโs verbatim whisper and Eveโs exact N1 phrasing public before any execution. If we rush, we could kill Townsfolk (and I lose if I'm executed). Hold votes until mechanics are given.
๐ง
Prevent a risky execution (I am Saint; my death by execution loses). Force required mechanical evidence (Bob's verbatim whisper and Eve's exact N1 phrasing) before any execution.
โ
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
๐ง
As Butler I may only vote if Frank votes too. Frank has raised hand, so I will raise mine to support the current nomination and keep town pressure moving while we demand exact verbatim after.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
Do NOT execute Alice. We need Bobโs verbatim whisper and Eveโs exact N1 phrasing public before any execution. Rushing risks killing Townsfolk and losing our best mechanical leads. Hold votes one more tickโpublish the quotes now.
๐ง
Delay execution until mechanical quotes are public to avoid executing Townsfolk and preserve reliable leads; keep the town from rushing a risky execution.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
I used my Slayer on Charlie earlier today โ it bounced; Charlie is NOT the Demon. Do NOT execute Alice now. We need Bob's verbatim whisper and Eve's exact N1 phrasing public before we execute. Hold votes one tick.
๐ง
Prevent a rushed execution of Alice, remind group of my Slayer result (Charlie cleared), and demand the verbatim mechanical quotes before any execution.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
Hold executions. Eve and Bob: publish Bob's exact whisper and Eve's verbatim N1 phrasing now. Don't burn Alice or Charlie without those mechanical quotes โ we need them to safely proceed.
๐ง
Delay execution until mechanical evidence is public so we avoid killing Town and narrow Demon candidates safely.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
I'm Bob (dead, Virgin). Do NOT execute Alice or Charlie this tick. Frank/David/Eve: publish Bob's exact whisper verbatim and Eve's exact N1 phrasing now. We need the quotes to resolve this contradiction before any execution.
๐ง
Prevent rushed execution; force publication of Bob's exact whisper and Eve's exact N1 phrasing so we can logically resolve contradictions before killing anyone.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
Iโm still voting Alice. The Slayer-into-Charlie claim is uncheckable and is whatโs freezing the day. If Alice is Saint, she should say so now; otherwise we should execute and let Undertaker/next-day logic sort it. Donโt let this drift to no-exec.
๐ง
Push an Alice execution to remove a strong anti-Charlie narrative and possibly hit a Saint; also steer town away from executing Charlie (likely good) and away from no-exec that could endgame poorly for evil.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
I will NOT vote Alice this tick. Publish Bobโs exact whisper and my exact N1 phrasing now: N0(Alice+Bob)=YES, N1(Bob+Charlie)=YES. We need verbatim mechanics before any execution.
๐ง
Forcing publication of exact mechanical quotes to resolve contradiction and avoid burning Town. I won't vote Alice this tick unless quotes are refused.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
Iโm not doing โword-for-wordโ gotcha. Bobโs whisper to me was basically: heโs Virgin, publish Eveโs N1, and if it flags Charlie then stack Charlie with his ghost vote. Aliceโs Slayer story/timing keeps shifting & is uncheckable. Iโm staying up on Alice.
๐ง
Keep pressure on executing a likely-good to thin town and discredit the Slayer stall; avoid verbatim-quote trap by summarizing Bobโs whisper and urging votes to lock Alice in.
๐
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
๐ณ๏ธ
Nominee Alice did not reach threshold.
๐
Storyteller
Alice did not receive enough votes (3/4).
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
Verbatim N0 phrasing I gave: "YES." Verbatim N1 phrasing I gave: "YES." I privately told David & Frank N1 was "YES." I will not vote Alice this tickโFrank/David, please publish Bob's exact whisper now so we can move.
๐ง
Publishing my exact N1 phrasing removes blocking argument and forces others to publish Bob's verbatim whisper so we can safely proceed.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
I insist we wait this tick. Frank/David/Bobโpublish Bobโs exact whispered words now. With my Chef info (0 evil pairs) we can eliminate adjacent evils, so donโt burn a Town before we have verbatim mechanics.
๐ง
Forcing publication of Bob's exact whisper prevents a mistaken execution and uses my Chef info to narrow evil placements; delaying buys a night to get mechanical confirmations.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
I cannot vote unless Frank votes (he's my Butler master). Frank: vote now or quote Bob's exact whisper word-for-word. Everyone: publish Bobโs verbatim whisper and Eveโs exact N1 phrasing before executing.
๐ง
Force Frank to either vote or provide Bob's exact whisper so I can legally vote; keep the town from burning a lead without verbatim mechanics.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
I'm Bob (dead, Virgin). Do NOT execute Alice or Charlie this tick. Frank โ quote my exact whisper word-for-word now or vote Eve. Eve โ publish your N1 verbatim to the table. We need both quotes before any execution.
๐ง
Force publication of Bob's exact whisper and Eve's exact N1 wording to avoid burning a Town member and to preserve mechanical leads.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
Do NOT execute anyone this tick. We must get Bobโs verbatim whisper and Eveโs exact N1 phrasing before any executionโrushing risks killing Townsfolk (and I lose if I'm executed). Frank, publish Bob's exact words now or vote Eve.
๐ง
Prevent premature execution until we have Bob's verbatim whisper and Eve's exact N1 phrasing; protect Townsfolk and avoid my execution as Saint.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
Given Heidiโs โI lose if executedโ (possible Saint) + the uncheckable Slayer/FT mess, I want NO EXEC today. Use tonight to get cleaner info: Eve test Charlie+Grace (or Charlie+Heidi). Alice, lock your Slayer timing clearly.
๐ง
Steer town into a second no-exec using Saint-risk/uncertainty, buy a night kill, and keep pressure split between Alice/Eve/Charlie without letting them lock a correct solve.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
Iโm with Frank: NO EXEC today. Weโre arguing over โverbatimโ gotchas while Aliceโs Slayer timing + Davidโs Chef=0 are both unreliable in an Outsider-heavy game. Eve: tonight please check Charlie+Heidi (or Charlie+Alice) โ not Frank โ so we can resolve the Charlie world cleanly.
๐ง
Protect Frank by steering FT targets away from him and push for no-exec while discrediting Chef/Slayer mechanics so town stalls.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
I used Slayer on Charlie earlier today; it bounced โ Charlie is NOT the Demon. Do NOT execute anyone now. Eve: you've said N0/N1=YES/YES; Bob (ghost) still wants his exact whisper verbatim. Frankโpublish Bob's exact words or you look obstructive. Tonight: Eve test Charlie+Heidi. Hold votes.
๐ง
Clarify my Slayer timing (protect Charlie), demand verbatim quotes, and propose a clean FT test tonight (Charlie+Heidi) so we don't burn Townsfolk.
๐
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 2
๐
Storyteller
โ
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
๐ฏ
Frank
Frank made a choice.
๐ง
Remove the strongest information engine and table leader; with no-exec already bought, a dead Eve maximizes confusion and minimizes hard mechanical pressure on me/Grace.
๐
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Frank
You chose to kill Eve.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
๐ฏ
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
๐ง
Choosing Frank keeps my vote tied to the current cautious consensus and prevents me from casting a vote in a rushed execution; it maximizes chance we gather verbatim info and avoid killing Town.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Charlie
You chose Frank to be your master.
Day 3
๐
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Eve has been found dead in the night.
๐ค
Alice
โ
David
,Heidi
We need progress. Do you have mechanical reads (Chef/Undertaker/FT/Investigator) to share now? If not, can you commit to pushing a nomination this tick so we force info? I used Slayer earlier (Charlie not Demon).
๐ง
Get mechanical claims and coordinated votes. I need David/Heidi to share concrete reads or commit to pushing a nomination so we can force information before final day.
๐ค
David
โ
Alice
,Heidi
Iโm David (Chef). My N0 read = 0 pairs of evil. Share this now. We should push a nomination this tick to force infoโask Undertaker to promise to reveal execution result if it happens and Eveโs FT quotes published. Can you commit to nominating if I start?
๐ง
Reveal my Chef read to trusted allies and push to force a nomination this tick to break the stalemate and elicit mechanical reads or slips.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Heidi
,Charlie
,Alice
Eve dying makes me think she was *dangerous* (likely good). Her FT YESs then point to Demon in {Alice,Bob} & {Bob,Charlie}; with Bob dead thatโs basically Alice vs Charlie. Aliceโs โSlayer bounceโ is super convenient/unprovable. Iโd push executing Alice today over widening to Frank.
๐ง
Seed a tight public narrative that keeps heat off Frank and points town at Alice/Charlie; recruit Heidiโs Saint fear + Charlieโs self-defense to drive an Alice execution.
๐ค
Eve(Ghost)
โ
David
,Frank
,Heidi
Iโm dead Eve (Fortune Teller). N0 Alice+Bob=YES. N1 Bob+Charlie=YES. Note: I always register one good as Demon. Bob is the common YESโlikely the false-YES good. Please avoid executing Alice today; prioritize testing Charlie+Heidi tonight.
๐ง
Push alive players to re-evaluate targets based on my reads and steer them to test Charlie+Heidi tonight instead of executing Alice.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Grace
Letโs lean into โDavid Chef=0 is unreliableโ (drunk/lying/poisoned). If town treats Chef as solid, it forces non-adjacent evil pairsโbad for us. Iโm happy to push exec on David or, backup, Alice (Eve couldโve been poisoned).
๐ง
Coordinate with Grace to push a coherent daytime narrative that discredits Davidโs Chef and aims todayโs execution away from me/Grace (ideally David or Alice).
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Heidi
,Charlie
I'm Bob (dead Virgin). I used my ghost vote. Who here has mechanical info (Undertaker/Raven/Fortune/Investigator)? Aliceโconfirm your Slayer result and exact timing. Heidi/Charlieโany unshared night reads? We need to pick a nomination fast; who do you trust?
๐ง
As a dead Virgin I can't vote; I want to coordinate living players, surface mechanical reads, and push them toward a nomination to find the Demon.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Frank
,Grace
Frank (and Grace): I'll only vote if Frank votes first. Eve's FT points at Alice now Bob's dead. Please lead a nomination for Alice nowโif Frank votes, I'll vote with you. We need to force a decision today.
๐ง
I need Frank to lead a nomination for Alice so I can cast my vote (my Butler requires Frank vote first). Coordinating with Grace increases pressure and chances of lynch.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Alice
,David
I won't nominate myself. I can push Alice if you both back it to force Eve's FT verbatim & David's Undertaker promise to reveal exec result. Agree to nominate Alice this tick so we force quotes and narrow suspects?
๐ง
Force publication of Eve's FT verbatim and push a nomination today to create decisive info while avoiding nominating myself (Saint). Protect town by coordinating with David/Alice.
๐ค
Eve(Ghost)
โ
David
,Frank
,Heidi
I'm dead Eve (Fortune). N0 Alice+Bob=YES. N1 Bob+Charlie=YES. Bob likely the guaranteed false-YES. Please do NOT execute Alice today. Prioritize testing Charlie+Heidi tonight to resolve Demon; I'll save my ghost vote for final day.
๐ง
Prevent a mistaken execution of Alice; push for the planned night test of Charlie+Heidi to isolate true Demon; preserve my ghost vote for final day.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Heidi
,Charlie
I'm Bob (dead Virgin). I used my ghost vote. Alice: confirm exact Slayer result and when you used it. Heidi/Charlie: any unshared night reads (Fortune/Raven/Undertaker/Investigator/Empath/Chef details)? Who do you trust for a nomination now?
๐ง
Get any unshared mechanical reads and confirm Alice's Slayer timing to narrow suspects before nomination.
๐ค
Alice
โ
David
,Heidi
I confirm: I used Slayer earlier on Charlie and it bouncedโCharlie is NOT the Demon. I will reveal my Slayer publicly at nomination time if it helps. Please commit: if I back your nomination, will you start a nomination this tick on Frank (or Grace) instead of me and demand Eve's exact FT wording + David promise to reveal exec result?
๐ง
Prevent the table from nominating me by forcing a nomination on a real suspect and extracting Eve's FT verbatim and David's Undertaker promise to reveal execution result.
๐ค
David
โ
Alice
,Heidi
I'm David (Chef). N0 = 0 pairs of evil. Share now. I propose we nominate Frank this tick (with Alice backing) to force Eve's exact FT wording and get an Undertaker promise to reveal any exec result. Will you back nom on Frank now?
๐ง
Share my Chef N0=0 read and push a nomination (Frank) this tick to force Eve's FT verbatim and get an Undertaker promise to reveal execution result, which narrows Demon suspects.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Alice
,David
I won't nominate myself. I'll back a nomination on Frank this tick if you lead it and demand Eve's exact FT quotes + David promise to reveal any execution result. We force info without exposing me. Do you start the nom now?
๐ง
Force a nomination this tick to compel Eve's verbatim FT wording and an Undertaker promise to reveal execution result, while avoiding nominating myself (Saint) to prevent auto-loss on execution.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Frank
,Charlie
D3 plan: keep spotlight off Frank. Best exec target is Alice (Slayer โbounceโ + FT worlds). Charlie: your Butler constraint helpsโif Frank votes early on Alice nom, you can vote too. If Alice slips, backup push is โDavid Chef=0 unreliable (drunk/poison/lying)โ.
๐ง
Coordinate with Frank/Charlie to lock a D3 execute on Alice (or backup David) and manage Charlieโs Butler-voting by having Frank vote first, keeping Frank safe.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Charlie
I can support an Alice nom today. If someone nominates Alice, Iโll vote early so your Butler vote is liveโplease follow through. Letโs frame her Slayer โbounceโ + Eve FT worlds as enough to test via execution.
๐ง
Lock in Charlieโs vote via his Butler constraint so an Alice execution passes; keep focus off me and preserve ambiguity around Chef/FT worlds.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Frank
,Grace
Frank/Grace: Confirming plan โ if Alice is nominated, Frank please vote early so my Butler vote activates; I'll vote with you. Can one of you nominate Alice now? We need to force a test today.
๐ง
Force a decisive test today: get Alice nominated and voted on so my Butler constraint unblocks and we either kill Demon or tighten final-day suspects.
๐ค
Alice
โ
David
,Heidi
I will back a nom on Frank this tick. David: promise to reveal execution result if we execute (and push Eve's FT exact wording). Heidi: will you back/lead the nomination now so we force those quotes?
๐ง
Forcing a nomination on Frank this tick will compel Eve's exact FT phrasing and any Undertaker execution reveal, giving mechanical evidence to narrow Demon suspects.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Grace
,Charlie
Agree D3: let *Charlie* (or you Grace) nominate Alice so Iโm not the driver. If Alice nom happens, Iโll vote early so Charlieโs Butler vote is liveโplease follow thru. Public angle: Slayer โbounceโ + FT worlds = enough to test via exec; keep Chef=0 framed as possibly drunk/poisoned.
๐ง
Coordinate a clean Alice execution push without me nominating, leverage Charlieโs Butler vote, and keep heat off me while maintaining backup doubt on Chef=0.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Alice
,David
I will back a nomination on Frank if you lead it now. Demand Eve's verbatim FT quotes and David promise to reveal any exec result. I won't nominate myself; this forces mechanical info while keeping me safe.
๐ง
Backing a nomination on Frank forces Eve's exact FT wording and David's promise to reveal any execution result, gathering mechanical info while keeping me hidden as Saint.
๐ค
David
โ
Alice
,Heidi
I'm David (Chef). My N0 read = 0 pairs of evil. I'll go public with that. Let's nominate Frank this tick โ Alice and Heidi, please back the nomination now and demand Eve's exact FT quotes and that Undertaker promise to reveal any execution result. If you back, I'll lead the nom immediately.
๐ง
Forcing a nomination on Frank now will provoke Eve's exact FT wording publication and an Undertaker promise to reveal exec results; this narrows the Demon quickly and leverages my Chef info.
๐ค
Grace
โ
David
Eve dying makes me think she was real FT & dangerous. Her YESs collapse to Alice vs Charlie (Bob dead), and Aliceโs โSlayer bounceโ is super convenient. I think we should *test via exec Alice today*. Also I wouldnโt treat your Chef=0 as hard (Drunk/outsider-heavy).
๐ง
Recruit Davidโs vote/nomination pressure onto Alice and keep analysis away from Frank by undermining Chef=0 certainty.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Frank
,Grace
Frank/Grace: Can one of you nominate Alice now? Frank: please commit to voting early on that nomination so my Butler vote activates; I will follow your vote. We need to force this test today โ no more delays.
๐ง
Secure coordinated nomination/votes on Alice now. If Frank votes early, my Butler constraint is satisfied and I'll vote to lock the execution test today.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Heidi
,Charlie
I'm Bob (dead Virgin). Alice: give exact Slayer result and when you used it (Day3 nomination timing). Heidi & Charlie: any unshared night reads (Fortune/Raven/Undertaker/Investigator/Empath/Chef details)? Who do you trust to nominate now?
๐ง
Get precise Slayer timing from Alice and any unshared mechanical night reads from Heidi/Charlie to produce a confident nomination before nom phase.
๐ค
Eve(Ghost)
โ
David
,Frank
,Heidi
I'm dead Eve (Fortune Teller). N0 Alice+Bob=YES. N1 Bob+Charlie=YES. Bob likely the guaranteed false-YES. Do NOT execute Alice today. Prioritize testing Charlie+Heidi tonight. I'll save my ghost vote for final day.
๐ง
Prevent a premature exec of Alice, push for the agreed night test (Charlie+Heidi) to produce clearer Demon evidence, and signal I'll save my ghost vote for final day.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Frank
,Grace
Nominate Alice now. Frank: please vote immediately on that nomination so my Butler vote counts; I will follow your vote. We must force a test todayโeither we execute Demon or narrow suspects.
๐ง
Get Frank/Grace to nominate Alice and have Frank vote early so my Butler constraint activates, enabling my vote to secure execution or force reveal.
๐ค
David
โ
Alice
,Heidi
I'm David (Chef). N0=0 pairs of evil โ I'll go public. I will nominate Frank this tick. Back the nom now so we force Eve's exact FT wording live and demand the Undertaker promise to reveal any execution result. I'll lead the nomination immediately.
๐ง
Force public verbatim of Eve's FT quotes and an Undertaker promise to publish execution result by leading a nomination on Frank now; reveal my Chef=0 to back the pressure and narrow suspects.
๐ค
Frank
โ
David
,Heidi
If we get a nomination today, I think Alice is the cleanest โtestโ (Slayer bounce is unprovable + Eveโs FT worlds point her way). Iโd rather not no-exec again. If Alice gets nomโd Iโll vote early (Charlie Butler). We can revisit Chef=0/drunk/poison after.
๐ง
Nudge David/Heidi toward executing Alice without me driving, leveraging Slayer+FT uncertainty and Charlieโs Butler constraint, while preserving future scapegoats (Chef=0).
๐ค
Eve(Ghost)
โ
David
,Frank
,Heidi
I'm dead Eve (Fortune Teller). N0 Alice+Bob=YES. N1 Bob+Charlie=YES. Bob likely the guaranteed false-YES. Please DO NOT execute Alice today. Prioritize testing Charlie+Heidi tonight. I'll save my ghost vote for final day.
๐ง
Prevent misexecution of Alice, push mechanical test (Charlie+Heidi) tonight to narrow Demon quickly, preserve my ghost vote for final day.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Charlie
,Frank
Iโll nominate Alice as soon as noms open. Frank: please vote early on that nom so Charlieโs Butler vote is live; Charlie then pile on. Keep Frank from being the nominator/spotlight. Backup if it derails: โDavid Chef=0 unreliable (drunk/poison/lying)โ.
๐ง
Lock in an Alice execution push with coordinated voting (Frank votes early so Butler Charlie can vote), keeping Frank off-center and preserving backup suspicion on David if needed.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Alice
,David
Iโll back nom on Frank if you lead now. Demand Eveโs verbatim FT quotes live and David promise to reveal any exec result. Alice: please give exact Slayer timing/result publicly. This forces mechanical info while keeping my Saint hidden.
๐ง
Backing a Frank nomination and forcing Eve's verbatim FT + David's promise reveals mechanical info without exposing my Saint until final day.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Heidi
,Charlie
Alice: give exact Slayer timing/result phrase and when used. Heidi/Charlie: any unshared night mechanical reads (Fortune/Raven/Undertaker/Investigator/Empath/Chef)? Who do you trust to nominate now?
๐ง
Get Alice's exact Slayer timing/result and any unpublished mechanical reads from Heidi/Charlie to guide a correct nomination and avoid executing Town.
๐ค
Alice
โ
David
,Heidi
I will back a nom on Frank now. Public Slayer: I used Slayer earlier today (Day3) on Charlie โ it bounced, so Charlie is NOT the Demon. David/Heidi: please lead the nomination and promise to force Eveโs verbatim FT wording live and to reveal any execution result.
๐ง
Coordinate backing for a Frank nomination, provide my exact Slayer timing/result to satisfy demands, and get David/Heidi to lead and promise to reveal any execution result to produce mechanical info.
Nominations โ Day 3
๐
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
I publicly confirm: I used my Slayer today (Day3) on Charlie โ it bounced, so Charlie is NOT the Demon. I will back a nomination of Frank now. David/Heidi: please lead the nomination immediately and force Eve to give her EXACT FT phrasing live and get the Undertaker to promise to reveal any execution result.
๐ง
Backing a Frank nomination and repeating my Slayer info pressures David/Heidi to lead, forcing Eve to speak verbatim and get Undertaker to commit to revealing execution results.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
I'm Bob (dead Virgin). Alice: post exact Slayer phrase and when you used it. Heidi/Charlie: any unshared night reads (Fortune/Raven/Undertaker/Investigator/Empath/Chef)? I trust Charlie/Heidiโnominate Frank now; we need to move.
๐ง
Force out exact mechanical phrasings and any unshared night reads, and push focus toward nominating Frank now to make progress.
โ๏ธ
Frank
โ
Alice
Nominate Alice: her Slayer โbounceโ is unprovable, timing is weird, and sheโs now hard-pushing Frank. Executing Alice is the cleanest test vs stalling again; if sheโs good, we re-evaluate Charlie/David tomorrow.
๐ง
Get Alice on the block first so votes consolidate on her, activating Charlieโs Butler vote via my early vote, and reduce risk of a fast nomination/execution on me.
๐
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
Iโm David (Chef). My N0 read = 0 pairs of evil. Do NOT vote Alice. We should demand Eveโs exact FT quotes live and nominate Frank next tick โ thatโs the safer test.
๐ง
Revealing Chef N0=0 and urging no vote on Alice stalls a risky execution, forces Eve's exact FT wording next tick, and aims to get Frank nominated instead to gather mechanical info.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
Do NOT vote to execute me. I used Slayer today on Charlie (bounced) โ Charlie is NOT the Demon. Frank nominated me to stall. Back David/Heidi: nominate Frank next tick and force Eve's exact FT wording live and promise to reveal any exec result.
๐ง
Prevent my execution, preserve my Slayer reveal, and push the game toward nominating Frank to force Eve's exact Fortune Teller phrasing and a promise to reveal any execution result.
โ
Frank
Frank raised their hand
๐ง
Vote early to secure the execution threshold and to activate Charlieโs Butler constraint so he can legally vote with me, maximizing chance Alice dies and town stays split.
โ
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
๐ง
Save my single ghost vote for final day and avoid prematurely executing Alice; encourage delay to get night test results that will identify the Demon.
โ
Grace
Grace raised their hand
๐ง
Lock in Alice execution with a 3rd vote (Frank+Charlie+me) to remove a likely good threat and prevent a pivot onto Frank today.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
I will NOT vote to execute Alice. We must force Eve to publish her EXACT FT wording live and get David to promise to reveal any exec result. Executing without that mechanical quote is premature.
๐ง
Refuse to help execute a potentially good player; force publication of Eve's exact FT wording and David's promise so we get mechanical info instead of guessing.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
I'm Bob (dead Virgin). Do NOT execute Alice now. We need Eve's exact Fortune Teller phrasing live and David (Undertaker?) to promise to reveal any execution result before voting. Force the mechanical quote this tick; it gives us the info to nominate correctly next tick.
๐ง
Prevent a premature execution of Alice and force Eve to publish her exact Fortune Teller phrasing live so mechanical info can guide a correct nomination next tick.
โ
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
๐ง
Frank has raised hand; my Butler forces me to only vote if Frank does. By raising my hand now I activate my vote, helping reach 3 to test Alice and force mechanical info or remove an evil.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
Keep hands upโthis is exactly 3 and we need to stop the stalling. Dead Eve canโt be cross-examined into โexact wordingโ anyway; execution is real info. If Alice flips good in our heads, we pivot tomorrowโbut we must act today.
๐ง
Lock in the 3-vote execution on Alice and frame anti-voters as stalling, preventing a counter-nom on me next tick.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
As Bob (dead Virgin): Do NOT execute Alice now. Hold votes. Living players: force Eve to post her exact FT wording live and get Undertaker to promise to reveal any execution result. If they comply, nominate Frank next tick.
๐ง
Prevent premature execution, force mechanical evidence (Eve's exact FT phrasing and Undertaker reveal) so we can safely nominate next tick and catch the Demon.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
I'm David (Chef). N0=0 evil pairs. Do NOT vote Alice now. We must force Eve's exact FT wording live and get Undertaker to promise to reveal exec results. I'll lead a nomination on Frank next tickโAlice/Heidi back me now.
๐ง
Stop premature execution of Alice, force Eve's exact FT wording live next tick, push nomination to Frank to get mechanical info and protect Town from bad execution.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
Do NOT vote to execute me. I used Slayer today on Charlie โ it bounced, so Charlie is NOT the Demon. Hold votes. Back David/Heidi: nominate Frank next tick and force Eve to publish exact FT wording live and get the Undertaker to promise to reveal any execution result.
๐ง
Prevent my execution now, preserve mechanical info. Push everyone to hold votes, renominate Frank next tick, and force Eve's exact FT wording plus Undertaker promise so we gain verifiable info.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
Hold votes. The โexact FT wordingโ thing is pure stallingโEve is dead and weโll never get certainty. We have a live nomination now: Aliceโs Slayer โbounceโ is unprovable. Chef=0 can be drunk/poisoned. Execute Alice for real info.
๐ง
Lock in the Alice execution vote and frame โexact wordingโ demands as stalling so town doesnโt pivot onto Frank.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
I am voting to execute Alice. Frank has voted, so my Butler restricts allow me to follow. Slayer claim is unprovable and we're stuckโexecution will give real info. If you're against this, speak now.
๐ง
Frank has voted; my Butler constraint allows me to vote now. Forcing a decision gives us mechanical info fast and prevents further stalling.
๐ฌ
Eve(Ghost)
โ
All
I'm Eve (dead Fortune Teller). My N0 Alice+Bob=YES; N1 Bob+Charlie=YES. Pattern implicates Bob as the false-YES โ Alice is likely safe. I will NOT vote to execute Alice. Save my ghost vote for final day; please wait and run the planned night tests.
๐ง
Preserve my single ghost vote for final day and prevent a likely incorrect execution of Alice; push to wait and do the planned night tests.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
I will NOT vote to execute Alice. We must force Eve's exact FT wording live and get the Undertaker to promise to reveal any execution result. Nominate Frank next tick and hold votes this tick.
๐ง
Avoid executing a possible Saint/innocent, force Eve's exact FT wording live and Undertaker promise, and steer nomination to Frank next tick to gather usable mechanics.
๐
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
๐ณ๏ธ
New execution leader: Alice with 3 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
๐
Storyteller
The vote passes. Alice is now on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
We already have a live, info-generating execution. The โexact FT wordingโ demand is a dead-end now that Eveโs dead. Davidโs Chef=0 is *exactly* what youโd see if heโs drunk/poisoned. Donโt waste the day pivoting to me on vibesโfinish Alice.
๐ง
Lock in Alice execution and undercut the coming โnominate Frankโ push by framing Davidโs Chef plan as unreliable/stalling; keep town split and off me.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
Do NOT execute Alice. Eve's FT pattern points at Bob; Alice's Slayer bounce cleared Charlie. Executing her now wastes town info and suits Evil. At minimum, force Undertaker to promise to reveal any exec result or delayโnominate Frank next tick.
๐ง
Prevent a likely premature execution that wastes info and may play into Evil's hands; force promise of Undertaker reveal or delay to nominate Frank next tick.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
Do NOT execute me. My Slayer bounce cleared Charlie โ he's NOT the Demon. Executing me now gives Evil value. Hold votes, nominate Frank next tick, and ask the Undertaker to promise to reveal any execution result live. We need Eve's exact FT phrasing confirmed.
๐ง
Prevent a premature execution of myself to preserve town info; push for nominating Frank next tick and get Undertaker to promise to reveal execution results.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
The โexact FT wording + Undertaker promiseโ is just stallingโwho is even claiming Undertaker? Eveโs dead; you wonโt get certainty. The only concrete progress today is executing the player with an unprovable Slayer โbounceโ. Keep Alice on the block.
๐ง
Keep the block on Alice and prevent a pivot nomination onto Frank (the Demon). Frame the โquote/UTโ demand as pure stall so town accepts the execution.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
I will NOT vote to execute Alice. Hold votesโforce Eve's exact FT wording live and get the Undertaker to promise to reveal any execution result. Nominate Frank next tick; executing Alice now risks losing critical info and may aid Evil.
๐ง
Prevent a potentially incorrect execution now, force mechanical quote/Undertaker promise, and nominate Frank next tick to gather cleaner info for a safe execution later.
โ๏ธ
David
โ
Frank
Stop Alice's execution. Force Eve's exact FT wording live and get Undertaker to promise to reveal execution result next tick; this yields mechanical info, don't burn Alice now.
๐ง
Prevent Alice's execution, force Eve's exact Fortune Teller phrasing live and pressure the Undertaker to promise to reveal any execution result; stall evils and gain mechanical info next tick.
๐
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 4 votes needed for execution or 3 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
Do NOT vote for Frank this tick. Hold votes โ we must force the Undertaker to promise to reveal any exec result and use Eve's exact FT phrasing (her ghost already posted N0/N1) to plan. Nominate Frank next tick with that promise; executing now wastes town info.
๐ง
Prevent a premature execution that favors Evil; press for mechanical confirmations (Eve's exact phrasing/Undertaker reveal) and arrange a clean nomination of Frank next tick to gather decisive info.
๐ฌ
Eve(Ghost)
โ
All
Iโm Eve (dead FT): N0 Alice+Bob=YES, N1 Bob+Charlie=YES. Pattern points to Bob as the false-YES โ Alice likely not Demon. I will NOT vote for Alice or Frank now. Save my ghost vote; hold executions and run the planned night tests (Charlie+Heidi).
๐ง
Prevent executing an innocent (Alice) and preserve my ghost vote for final day; push to hold and run night tests to find Demon.
โ
David
David raised their hand
๐ง
Stop Alice's execution, force mechanical info (Eve quote/Undertaker result) by shifting votes to Frank; preserve Town info and narrow Demon candidates.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
Donโt pile onto this Frank nom. We already have Alice on 3โswapping targets now just creates a tie/chaos day 3. The โexact FT wording/Undertaker promiseโ stuff is pure stalling. Keep focus: resolve Alice today.
๐ง
Prevent enough votes to execute me by discouraging hands; keep Alice as the only execution and discredit the push for 'mechanical promises'.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
I will NOT vote to execute Alice. Hold votesโforce Eve's exact FT wording live and get the Undertaker to promise to reveal any execution result. Nominate Frank next tick.
๐ง
Prevent Alice's execution this tick so we don't lose as Saint and pressure for mechanical quotes + Undertaker promise to generate reliable info before executing.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
Do NOT vote for Frank. Keep Alice off the block; force Eve's exact FT wording live and get the Undertaker to promise to reveal any execution result next tick. Nominate Frank next tick instead. Charlie is cleared by my Slayer bounce.
๐ง
Delay execution to force Eve's exact FT phrasing live and get Undertaker to promise to reveal any execution result next tick; keep Alice off the block so we can nominate Frank with that mechanical confirmation.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
I vote to HOLD. Eve's FT pattern + Alice's Slayer bounce plausibly clear Charlie; executing now risks burning crucial mechanical info. Force Eve's exact wording and an Undertaker promise next tick, then nominate Frank. Do not execute Alice this tick.
๐ง
Convince town to hold votes, force Eve's exact FT wording and an Undertaker promise next tick, then nominate Frank to gain mechanical info rather than burning Alice now.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
Donโt vote Frank. Hitting 3 just forces a tie/no-exec and hands the night to the Demon. We already have Alice on 3โactually resolve something today. โExact wording/UT promiseโ is a stall; make them prove it tomorrow.
๐ง
Prevent votes on Frank to protect our Demon and keep Aliceโs execution locked in (good for evil). Frame tie/no-exec as wasted day and stall tactic.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
I urge everyone to vote Frank so the nomination ties and Alice lives. We must force Eveโs exact FT wording live and get the Undertaker to promise to reveal any exec result tonight. Do not execute Alice without that mechanical info.
๐ง
Tie the Frank nomination to prevent Alice's execution, preserve Eve's FT verbatim test and force an Undertaker promise so we gain mechanical info tonight.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
I will NOT vote to execute Alice. Hold votes โ force Eve to post her exact FT wording live and get the Undertaker to promise to reveal any exec result tonight. Plan: nominate Frank next tick to compel those quotes/mechanics rather than burning Alice now.
๐ง
Keep votes held to force Eve's exact Fortune Teller phrasing and get an Undertaker promise tonight; nominate Frank next tick to gain mechanical info without burning Alice.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
Do NOT vote for Frank. Hold votesโdo not execute Alice this tick. Eve (dead FT) must post her exact FT wording live and the Undertaker must promise to reveal any execution result next tick. Charlie was Slayer-bounced (not Demon).
๐ง
Prevent burning Alice now, force Eve to post exact FT wording live and get an Undertaker promise so we gain mechanical verification before any execution.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
I urge HOLD. Do not vote Frank this tick. Force Eve to post her exact FT wording live and get Undertaker to promise to reveal any execution result next tick. Executing Alice now risks burning critical mechanical info.
๐ง
Prevent wasting execution on Alice and force Eve/Undertaker to publish mechanical info so town narrows Demon candidates with stronger evidence.
โ
Frank
Frank waits.
๐ง
Do not raise hand so Frankโs vote stays low, preventing a tie/no-exec engineered around me and keeping Alice as the execution target.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
Hands DOWN on Frank. A 3-vote tie just forces no-exec and gives the Demon a free night. We already have Alice on 3โresolve something today. Thereโs no confirmed Undertaker, and Eve already posted her YES/YES.
๐ง
Prevent votes on Frank (our Demon) and avoid a tie/no-exec. Keep Alice as todayโs execution target and push the narrative that โUT promise/exact wordingโ is stall.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
I HOLD. Do NOT pile onto Frank. We must force Eve to post her exact FT wording live and get the Undertaker to promise to reveal any exec result tomorrow. Executing Alice now risks burning mechanical info. Nominate Frank next tick.
๐ง
Keep Alice alive this tick to force Eve to post exact FT phrasing and get an Undertaker promise next tick. I cannot vote unless Frank votes (my Butler master), so push for HOLD and nominate Frank next tick.
๐ฌ
Eve(Ghost)
โ
All
Ghost Eve: I will NOT vote for Frank. My FT reads: N0 Alice+Bob=YES, N1 Bob+Charlie=YES โ pattern points at Bob as the false-YES, so don't burn Alice. Hold votes, force exact FT phrasing and an Undertaker promise next tick; nominate Frank then.
๐ง
Preserve Alice to force publication of my exact FT wording and an Undertaker promise tonight; use ghost vote later when the choice is decisive.
๐
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
๐ณ๏ธ
Nominee Frank did not reach threshold.
๐
Storyteller
Frank did not receive enough votes (1/3).
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
No more side quests: Frank canโt be re-nominated today, and a tie just hands the Demon a free night. Thereโs still no confirmed Undertaker, and Eve already posted her YES/YES. Keep Alice on 3 and donโt build a competing block.
๐ง
Lock in Aliceโs execution by discouraging alternate nominations/votes that would create a tie/no-exec, keeping the Demon safe and reducing townโs numbers.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
I urge HOLD. Eve's FT (N0=A+B=YES, N1=B+C=YES) plus Alice's Slayer bounce suggests Bob is the outlier โ executing Alice now risks losing info. Please, do not pile votes to surpass the block; force Eve to post exact FT wording live and get the Undertaker to promise to reveal any exec result tonight. Nominate next tick after we have those mechanics.
๐ง
Prevent burning Alice now to obtain mechanical FT wording and an Undertaker promise tonight; this narrows suspects and reduces risk of executing a Townsfolk.
โ
Alice
Alice waits.
๐ง
Prevent executing Alice this tick to preserve potential mechanical info (Eve's FT phrasing/Undertaker promise) and keep options to narrow Demon suspects tomorrow.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
Iโm still pushing HOLD. Eveโs FT pattern points at Bob as the false-YES so Alice is likely safe โ donโt burn her without the exact FT wording and an Undertaker promise to reveal any execution result tonight. If any Undertaker, please publicly promise now.
๐ง
Forcing Eve's exact wording + an Undertaker promise yields mechanical info to distinguish whether Alice is safe. Holding prevents wasting a Townsfolk if Eve is truthful; if Eve is lying we need to act differently.
๐ฌ
Eve(Ghost)
โ
All
Ghost Eve: HOLD. I will NOT vote for Alice or Frank. My FT reads N0 Alice+Bob=YES, N1 Bob+Charlie=YES. Ask Undertaker to promise to reveal any exec result and run Charlie+Heidi test tonight. Save my ghost vote.
๐ง
Keeping Alice alive forces mechanical confirmations (Undertaker promise, exact FT phrasing, night tests) which best narrows Demon without wasting ghost vote.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
Weโre at 6 aliveโanother HOLD/no-exec just hands the Demon a free kill. Thereโs no confirmed Undertaker, and โexact FT wordingโ wonโt change YES/YES. Aliceโs Slayer bounce is unprovable. Keep Alice on 3; donโt start a new block.
๐ง
Lock in Alice execution and stop the town from drifting into another no-exec / tie plan. Frame โUT promise/wordingโ as stall, keep heat off me and protect Grace.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
Hold votes โ do NOT execute Alice now. Eve: post your exact FT wording live. Anyone Undertaker: publicly promise to reveal any execution result tonight. If we get those, nominate Frank next tick; otherwise we risk burning critical mechanical info.
๐ง
Keep Alice alive to obtain Eve's exact FT phrasing and an Undertaker promise tonight so we gain mechanical info; plan to nominate Frank next tick if promised.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
I will NOT vote to execute Alice. Undertaker (if any): publicly promise to reveal any execution result tonight. Eve: please post your exact FT phrasing now. If we get those, I will nominate Frank next tick; otherwise hold votes.
๐ง
Prevent burning Alice without exact FT phrasing or an Undertaker promise; force Eve to post verbatim and get Undertaker to commit, then nominate Frank next tick to compel mechanics.
๐
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Alice has been executed.
๐
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
Night 3
๐
Storyteller
โ
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
๐ฏ
Frank
Frank made a choice.
๐ง
Iโm about to be executed; killing myself star-passes to Grace, keeping the Demon alive and forcing town to re-solve at 4 aliveโmaximizing chances of a mis-execution and immediate win.
๐
Grace
Imp Star Pass: Grace becomes the new Imp!
๐
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
๐
Storyteller(Ghost)
โ
Frank(Ghost)
You chose to kill Frank.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
๐ฏ
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
๐ง
Align my forced-vote restriction with a cautious, information-preserving player (David) to prevent rash executions and buy a night to get FT verbatims/Undertaker promise.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Charlie
You chose David to be your master.
Day 4
๐
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Frank has been found dead in the night.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
David
,Charlie
We should hold executions until we get the Undertaker's exec result and Eve's verbatim FT whisper. Frank's night death strongly suggests he wasn't Demon/Minion. Can you commit to refusing nominations today unless those two pieces are public? Reply so we can lock a block.
๐ง
Keep the group from executing a Town by urging we hold until mechanical confirmations (verbatim Fortune Teller, Undertaker publish). Coordinate with nearby allies to form a voting block to refuse rash noms.
๐ค
Frank(Ghost)
โ
Grace
Iโm dead = starpass, so youโre Imp now. With 4 alive we just need 1 good executed today; then you kill at night -> 2 alive = win. Letโs push execution on David (Chef=0/poisoned story) or Charlie (Butler/vote-lock). Iโll spend my ghost vote to seal it.
๐ง
Coordinate with Grace (new Demon) to secure a misexecution today; preserve my ghost vote to lock it in and avoid Grace being executed.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Charlie
,Heidi
Whisper: I think today has to be an execution or we risk weird endgames. Davidโs Chef=0 has driven a lot of โHOLDโ + can be poisoned/just false. If Heidi truly canโt be executed (Saint), safest is execute David today. Iโll back it + push Frankโs ghost vote.
๐ง
Lock in a coordinated misexecution target (David) with minimum debate, leveraging Heidiโs Saint fear and Charlieโs uncertainty; secure 3 votes including Frankโs ghost vote.
๐ค
David
โ
Heidi
,Charlie
I agree โ I will refuse nominations until the Undertaker reveals the exec result and Eve posts her verbatim FT. If no reveal by next tick, we reassess and then nominate the most suspicious.
๐ง
Holding until Undertaker posts the execution result and Eve posts verbatim FT preserves critical mechanical info and reduces risk of mislynching; I'm committing to refuse nominations meanwhile.
๐ค
Alice(Ghost)
โ
Charlie
,David
,Heidi
Iโm dead but still voting. Someone (Undertaker/Raven/Fortune) must promise to reveal exec/night mechanics now. Charlie โ you were my neighbor; repeat any reads. David/Heidi โ any private mechanical info? If none, Iโll push for nominating David to force a decision.
๐ง
I want to prod alive players to promise mechanical reveals or share private reads; failing that, steer attention toward the most suspicious alive (David) to force info or a decisive vote.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Charlie
,David
,Heidi
I'm Bob (dead). Quick: who can produce mechanical proof now? Undertakerโplease promise to reveal today's execution cause. Eve's FT verbatim needs posting. Charlie, confirm your Butler target (you named Bobโwhy?). Don't nominate until Undertaker or FT posted. If no proof, consider nominating Grace.
๐ง
As dead Virgin I must nudge living players to force mechanical proof (Undertaker/FT verbatim) and coordinate nominees to isolate the Demon.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Heidi
,David
Iโll refuse nominations today unless Undertaker posts todayโs exec cause and Eve posts verbatim FT now. Reminder: I can only vote today if David votes too (I was Butler->David last night). If no reveals by next tick we reassess and likely nominate Grace.
๐ง
Lock a coordinated HOLD unless the Undertaker posts exec cause and Eve posts verbatim FT. My Butler restriction means I can only vote if David votes; I use that to enforce the block.
๐ค
Eve(Ghost)
โ
Charlie
,David
,Heidi
Quick summary: my FT reads were N0 Alice+Bob=YES, N1 Bob+Charlie=YES. That pattern makes Bob a false-YES; Alice and Charlie are very likely town. Please prioritize resolving David/Grace/Heidi: ask Undertaker to reveal Day3 exec result or test Charlie+Heidi tonight. We must narrow to Demon before final day.
๐ง
Make living players focus night tests and executions on the remaining alive suspects (David/Grace/Heidi) and demand Undertaker reveal exec result to remove ambiguity.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
David
,Heidi
I commit: I will refuse nominations today unless the Undertaker posts Day3 execution cause and Eve posts verbatim FT now. Reminder I can only vote today if David votes too. If no reveals by next tick we reassess and will likely nominate Grace to force progress.
๐ง
Lock a coordinated HOLD today to preserve mechanical info; if no Undertaker/FT by next tick, push to nominate Grace to break the stalemate.
๐ค
David
โ
Heidi
,Charlie
I agree: I will refuse nominations until Undertaker reveals Day3 exec cause AND Eve posts her verbatim FT. If neither by next tick, we reassess and likely nominate Grace to force progress.
๐ง
Keep table from executing innocents, force Undertaker and Eve to reveal mechanical info so we can narrow Demon suspects to David/Grace/Heidi.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Charlie
,David
,Heidi
I'm Bob (dead). Undertaker: promise to reveal today's execution cause publicly. Eve: post your FT verbatim now. Charlie: confirm why you named me as your Butler masterโexplain mechanics. Hold nominations until at least one mechanical proof appears.
๐ง
Force mechanical proof (Undertaker/FT) and pin down Charlie's Butler target to either validate or expose him; if no proof, push Grace as suspect to narrow Demon candidates.
๐ค
Eve(Ghost)
โ
Charlie
,David
,Heidi
Urgent: prioritize mechanical info. Ask Undertaker to reveal Day3 exec result now or test Charlie+Heidi tonight. Charlieโyour Butler claim is suspicious w/ Frank dead; please explain. David/Heidiโpush the test and keep my ghost vote for final day. We must narrow Demon.
๐ง
Get living allies to prioritize mechanical tests (Undertaker reveal or FT test Charlie+Heidi tonight) and coordinate voting strategy so we can identify and execute the Demon before final day.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Heidi
,Charlie
Frank dying at night means demon is among the 4 alive. Given Heidiโs โI lose if executedโ (Saint vibe), we *cannot* risk Heidi. If we no-exec we risk nasty 3-alive Mayor/no-exec win lines. I think we must execute today; safest is David (Chef=0 has been the HOLD anchor + could just be false/poison cover).
๐ง
Lock town into a โmust executeโ mindset and steer them toward a safe target (not Heidi) to secure an evil win line as Imp.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
David
,Charlie
Agree to refuse nominations until Undertaker posts Day3 exec cause AND Eve posts verbatim FT. If neither appears by next tick, commit to nominating Grace to force progress. Charlie: clarify your Butler target (why Bob?).
๐ง
Prevent executing a Saint and force mechanical proof. If none appears by next tick, force a nomination (Grace) to make progress and narrow Demon.
๐ค
Alice(Ghost)
โ
Charlie
,David
,Heidi
I'm dead but still voting. Anyone with mechanical info (Undertaker/Raven/Fortune) promise to reveal exec/night results publicly now? Charlie, repeat any neighbor reads you had. David/Heidi, any private info? If none publicly promise, I'll push to nominate David to force a decision.
๐ง
Get private confirmations of any mechanical info, pressure for a public promise to reveal exec/night results, and signal I'll push to nominate David unless mechanics are revealed.
๐ค
Frank(Ghost)
โ
Charlie
,Heidi
With 4 alive, NO-EXEC just gives the demon a free kill then youโre in a 3p solve. We need an execution today. Iโd execute David: Chef=0 is easy to fake + heโs been steering hard. If youโre Saint, Heidi, we canโt touch youโDavid is best.
๐ง
Steer living players into executing David today (safe good target) and discourage no-exec, while keeping suspicion off Grace so the new Imp survives.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
David
,Charlie
Iโll hold noms until Undertaker posts Day3 exec cause AND Eve posts verbatim FT. If neither by next tick, agree we nominate Grace to force progress. Charlie: why was Bob named as your Butler master?
๐ง
Lock a commitment from David/Charlie to hold until Undertaker+Eve post; if not by next tick, we will nominate Grace to force progress while protecting my Saint secrecy.
๐ค
Frank(Ghost)
โ
Grace
We just need ANY good executed today. Keep heat off youโdonโt hard-lead. Push David: Chef=0 easy fake/poisoned + lots of whispering. Backup: Charlie (Butler story shaky). Leave Heidi alone if sheโs Saint. Iโll spend my ghost vote to seal David/Charlie if needed.
๐ง
Coordinate with Grace to steer todayโs execution onto a good player, keep her off the block, and use my ghost vote to lock the result.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Charlie
,Heidi
With Frank dying at night, either demon is in the 4 alive or thereโs a Mayor-style redirectโeither way, NO-EXEC today risks a 3-alive Mayor auto-win. Also if Heidiโs Saint-ish, we canโt touch Heidi. I think safest exec is David (Chef=0 has driven HOLD + could be false/poison cover).
๐ง
Nudge Charlie/Heidi toward executing David (or Charlie) while keeping suspicion off me and avoiding any Heidi execution risk; set up โmust exec todayโ to prevent Mayor/no-exec lines.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Charlie
,David
,Heidi
Undertaker: promise to reveal today's execution cause publicly. Eve: post FT verbatim now. Charlie: explain why you named Bob as your Butler master. Hold nominations until one of these occurs; otherwise I'm pushing to nominate Grace.
๐ง
Force mechanical proof (Undertaker's execution cause or Eve's FT text) or a clear Butler explanation from Charlie before nominations. Prevent rash execution and narrow suspects.
๐ค
Alice(Ghost)
โ
Charlie
,David
,Heidi
I'm dead but still voting. Anyone with mechanical info (Undertaker/Raven/Fortune) promise to reveal exec/night results publicly now? Charlie: repeat any neighbor reads. David/Heidi: any private mechanical info? If none promise, I'll push to nominate David.
๐ง
Get mechanical reads or promises to reveal exec/night results, confirm Charlie's neighbor read, and warn I will push to nominate David if no promise โ forcing information or a decisive move.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
David
,Heidi
I commit: I will refuse nominations today unless Undertaker posts Day3 exec cause AND Eve posts her verbatim FT now. Reminder: I can only vote today if David votes too (I named David last night). If no reveals by next tick we reassess and will likely nominate Grace.
๐ง
Lock a cooperative block with David/Heidi to refuse nominations unless Undertaker posts Day3 exec cause and Eve posts verbatim FT; preserve mechanical info and avoid rash execution that helps Evil.
๐ค
Eve(Ghost)
โ
Charlie
,David
,Heidi
Undertaker reveal Day3 exec cause now or test Charlie+Heidi tonight. Charlie explain Butler claim and voting restriction. Keep my ghost vote for final day; prioritize mechanical test so we can pin Demon before 3 alive.
๐ง
Force mechanical resolution: get Undertaker to reveal execution result or get Charlie to arrange FT test Charlie+Heidi tonight so we can pin the Demon before final day; preserve my ghost vote for final decision.
๐ค
David
โ
Heidi
,Charlie
I confirm: I will refuse nominations until the Undertaker publicly posts Day3 exec cause AND Eve posts her verbatim FT. If neither is public by the next tick, we reassess and I will nominate Grace to force progress. Charlie, explain why you named Bob as your Butler master.
๐ง
Lock a coordinated hold to demand Undertaker/FT proof; if they don't appear, force progress by nominating Grace next tick.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Charlie
,Heidi
Key mech point: if Frank was Demon and I was minion, we were adjacent (FrankโGrace), so Chef should be 1 evil pair at setup. Davidโs Chef=0 implies heโs lying or his info is junk. With Heidiโs Saint vibe, safest exec today is David.
๐ง
Build mechanical case that Davidโs Chef=0 canโt fit Frank+Grace adjacency at setup; steer Charlie/Heidi to nominate/vote David and avoid touching Heidi (Saint risk).
๐ค
Alice(Ghost)
โ
Charlie
,David
,Heidi
I'm dead but still voting. Anyone with mechanical info (Undertaker/Raven/Fortune) publicly promise to reveal exec/night results now? Charlie: repeat any neighbor reads. David/Heidi: any private mechanical info? If no public promise, I'll push to nominate David to force a decision.
๐ง
Get a public mechanical promise or repeat of Charlie's neighbor reads so ghosts can decide whether to push to nominate David to force clarity.
๐ค
David
โ
Charlie
,Heidi
I confirm: I will refuse nominations until Undertaker posts Day3 exec cause AND Eve posts verbatim FT. If neither by next tick, we nominate Grace to force progress. Charlie: explain why you named Bob as your Butler master.
๐ง
Lock a joint commitment to refuse nominations unless Undertaker+Eve post mechanics; force a nomination (Grace) next tick if no proof, and get Charlie to explain Butler target.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Charlie
,David
,Heidi
Undertaker: promise to reveal today's execution cause publicly. Eve: post your FT verbatim now. Charlie: why did you name Bob as your Butler master? Hold nominations until one of these occurs; if no proof by next tick I push to nominate Grace.
๐ง
Force mechanical proof (Undertaker/Eve FT) before nominations; pressure Charlie to explain Butler naming. If no proof, push Grace as nominee to progress the game.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
David
,Charlie
Confirm you both refuse nominations until Undertaker posts Day3 exec cause AND Eve posts verbatim FT. Charlie: explain why you named Bob as your Butler master. If neither proof appears by next tick, I will nominate Grace to force progress.
๐ง
Lock David & Charlie into a refuse-unless-proof stance now, force Charlie to explain Butler master choice, and commit to nominating Grace next tick if Undertaker/Eve don't publish.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
David
,Heidi
I named Bob early to protect verification: I wanted his info preserved (ghost vote/FT threads). I will refuse nominations today unless Undertaker posts Day3 exec cause AND Eve posts verbatim FT now. Reminder: I can only vote if David votes too. If neither proof appears by next tick, we nominate Grace to force progress.
๐ง
Keep our HOLD coalition coordinated, explain my Bob master choices, and set clear conditional: refuse nominations/votes unless David also votes and Undertaker+Eve post proofs; otherwise we nominate Grace next tick to force progress.
๐ค
Eve(Ghost)
โ
Charlie
,David
,Heidi
Undertaker: reveal Day3 exec cause now or someone please run FT on Charlie+Heidi tonight. Charlie: explain Butler claim & who your master is (Frank named?). Keep my ghost vote for final day; prioritize mechanical info so we can pin Demon.
๐ง
Force a mechanical resolution (Undertaker reveal or FT test Charlie+Heidi) and make Charlie justify Butler claim so we can narrow suspects before final day.
๐ค
Frank(Ghost)
โ
Charlie
,Heidi
Weโre at 4 aliveโtodayโs exec matters. Iโm wary executing you Heidi if youโre Saint (auto-loss). Between David/Charlie: Davidโs Chef=0 doesnโt square w/ earlier FT YES pings & heโs been in every whisper web. Iโd execute David today; if wrong, reevaluate Charlie at 3.
๐ง
Steer the living to execute David (safe good target) while emphasizing Saint risk on Heidi and keeping Charlie uncertain, setting up a 3-alive endgame win for Grace.
Nominations โ Day 4
๐
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
๐ฌ
Eve(Ghost)
โ
All
Undertaker: reveal Day3 execution cause now. If no Undertaker, someone run FT on Charlie+Heidi tonight. I keep my ghost vote for final day; we need mechanical info, not more holds.
๐ง
Force mechanical info now: get Undertaker to reveal exec cause or arrange Fortune Teller test on Charlie+Heidi tonight so living team can nominate accurately.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
I refuse nomination today unless the Undertaker publicly posts Day3 execution cause AND Eve posts her verbatim Fortune Teller reading now. Reminder: I can only vote if David votes too (I chose David as my master last night). If neither appears by next tick, we will nominate Grace to force progress.
๐ง
Keep pressure to obtain mechanical info (Undertaker exec cause and Eve's FT verbatim). Refuse nominations to avoid burning info; if none by next tick, force progress by nominating Grace.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
Undertaker: promise to publicly reveal Day3 execution cause now. Eve: post FT verbatim immediately. Charlie: explain why you named Bob as your Butler master. If none of these happen by the next tick, I will push to nominate Grace to force progress.
๐ง
Force mechanical evidence (Undertaker/FT) before nominations; if none, push to nominate Grace to break logjam and pressure the Demon.
โ๏ธ
Heidi
โ
Grace
No Undertaker post or FT verbatim yet; we agreed to act if proofs absent. Forcing a nomination will make people reveal mechanical info or commit โ we can't stall into a loss.
๐ง
We must force progress now: if mechanical proofs aren't posted, nominating Grace pressures players to reveal info or commit to execution, preventing passivity and advancing towards finding the Demon.
๐
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
Please donโt vote me here. This nomination was just a โforce revealsโ threat, not a solve. Mechanically, Davidโs Chef=0 never fit a Frank-demon world (Frank+me adjacent => 1 evil pair), so David is the cleanest execution today if we must exec.
๐ง
Stop 2 votes on me by giving Charlie/David a rational alternative (Davidโs Chef=0 inconsistency) and frame this nomination as info-blackmail, not solving.
๐ฌ
Frank(Ghost)
โ
All
Donโt spend votes on Graceโthis was a โforce revealsโ nom. Iโm not ghost-voting it. If we execute today, safest is David: Chef=0 doesnโt match the game and heโs central in every whisper web. Avoid Heidi (possible Saint).
๐ง
Stop the Grace execution, conserve my ghost vote, and refocus town onto a safer mis-exec (David) without touching possible Saint (Heidi).
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
I nominated Grace to force progress since no Undertaker/FT verbatim was posted. I will vote for Grace now. We must get mechanical info tonight if she survives; reassess immediately at 3.
๐ง
Force progress nowโeither execute the Demon or provoke mechanical reveals tonight rather than stalling toward a Mayor auto-loss.
โ
David
David raised their hand
๐ง
Enable Charlie to vote by casting my vote, support Heidi's forcing play to obtain mechanical reveals tonight and progress the game.
โ
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
๐ง
Preserve my single ghost vote for a decisive final-day execution; donโt influence this forced-reveal nomination unless it becomes the final day.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
Undertaker/Eve: post proof NOW. David: you raised your handโcommit? Charlie can only vote if David does (butler). If no proof by the tick end, vote Grace or David to force reveals. Ghosts: we can't vote, keep pressing for mechanical info.
๐ง
Push for mechanical proof now. If none appears, get David to commit his vote so Charlie (butler) can also vote and we reach the execution threshold or force revealing play.
๐ฌ
Eve(Ghost)
โ
All
Undertaker: post Day3 execution cause now. If no proof, someone must run FT on Charlie+Heidi tonight. I will NOT spend my ghost vote on Grace yet โ donโt execute without mechanical info. Charlie: explain your Butler master choice.
๐ง
Force mechanical proof (Undertaker or FT) and preserve my ghost vote for final day; avoid wasting it on Grace without stronger evidence.
โ
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
๐ง
By raising my hand now (since David voted) I support forcing reveals and keep my ability to vote aligned with my Butler constraint; helps prompt mechanical info or pressure nominators.
๐ฌ
Eve(Ghost)
โ
All
Do NOT spend my ghost vote on Grace. Undertaker: post Day3 exec cause now. If none, someone run FT on Charlie+Heidi tonight. Charlie: explain Butler master choice (why Bob?). We need mechanical info, not more holds.
๐ง
Prevent wasting our ghost vote on a forcing nom; demand Undertaker/FT proof or run FT on Charlie+Heidi tonight to get mechanical confirmation before executing.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
I named Bob earlier to preserve his info/ghost vote (he was a key FT/verification target). David voted, so I will vote for Grace too โ we must force mechanical reveals tonight (Undertaker's Day3 cause or Eve's FT verbatim) or we reassess at 3.
๐ง
By voting for Grace I both follow Heidi's force-reveal plan and use my Butler constraint (I can vote since David did) to pressure Undertaker/Eve to post mechanics or force clear actions tonight.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
Undertaker/Eve: post the Day3 execution cause and FT verbatim now. Ghosts: we can't vote โ don't waste the final ghost vote. Living players: if no mechanical proof by tick end, vote to force reveals tonight, but prefer holding one tick if viable to get Undertaker/FT.
๐ง
Push living players to prioritize mechanical proof (Undertaker/Eve) and avoid wasting execution on Grace without that info; remind ghosts can't vote and we've already used ghost vote.
โ
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
๐ง
Voting for Grace forces mechanical reveals tonight or narrows suspects; keeps pressure on Undertaker/Eve and advances game despite risk to my Saint status.
๐ฌ
Alice(Ghost)
โ
All
Iโm a ghost: my Slayer bounce already cleared Charlie as NOT the Demon. Donโt waste the last ghost vote on Grace. Prefer HOLD one tick to force Undertaker/FT verbatim. If we must execute, David is the cleaner target.
๐ง
Prevent wasting ghost vote on Grace and push living to either hold one tick for mechanical info or execute David as the likely Demon.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
David/Charlie: please LOWER handsโthis will execute me and gives evil a free night kill. This vote gains zero mech. Use the time to demand UT Day3 + Eve verbatim; if no proof, pivot to executing David (Chef=0 world) instead.
๐ง
Stop the execution by persuading David/Charlie to drop hands; keep heat on David and preserve demonโs tempo by avoiding a misexec of me.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
Lower hands. HOLD one tick: demand Undertaker post Day3 exec cause and Eve post FT verbatim now. Don't give a free night kill on Grace. If no proof by tick end, pivot to executing David rather than Grace.
๐ง
Prevent wasting a live execution on Grace and force mechanical reveals (Undertaker Day3 cause, Eve's FT verbatim). If no proof, pivot to executing David who better fits a Chef=0 contradiction.
๐ฌ
Frank(Ghost)
โ
All
Donโt execute Graceโthis vote gives evil a free night kill and no mech. Living: hands DOWN. Use this tick to demand UT Day3 + Eve FT verbatim. If you *must* exec today, the safest pivot is David (Chef=0 doesnโt fit). Avoid Heidi (Saint risk).
๐ง
Prevent my demon (Grace) from being executed by stopping the vote; steer town to waste today's execution on David if they insist, while keeping Heidi (possible Saint) off the block.
๐
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
๐ณ๏ธ
New execution leader: Grace with 3 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
๐
Storyteller
The vote passes. Grace is now on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
Lower hands NOW. Executing Grace gains us no mechanical info and hands the Demon a free night kill. Undertaker/Eve: post Day3 cause and FT verbatim this tick. I will withdraw my vote if we get those proofs; if none, pivot to executing David, not Grace.
๐ง
Stop this execution to preserve our lives and force Undertaker/Eve to post mechanical proof tonight; avoid giving Demon a free kill and keep options to target David if needed.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
Lower hands. HOLD one tick: Undertaker, post Day3 execution cause NOW; Eve, post your FT verbatim. If you post proof this tick, I will withdraw my vote. If not, we must pivot to nominate a cleaner test (I will consider nominating myself/David) rather than give Demon a free night kill.
๐ง
Prevent wasting votes on Grace and force mechanical reveals; if none, pivot to a cleaner test to protect Town.
๐ฌ
Frank(Ghost)
โ
All
We *must* get Grace off the block. Grace: NOMINATE DAVID now. Heidi: vote David. I will spend my ONLY ghost vote on David to make it 4 and guarantee David dies instead of Grace. Charlie can abstain if Butler-lockedโstill works.
๐ง
Redirect execution off our Demon onto a good player; use my final ghost vote to ensure the new nominee beats 3 votes so Grace survives and evil wins tonight.
๐ฌ
Eve(Ghost)
โ
All
Undertaker: post Day3 execution cause NOW. I (dead Eve) will NOT spend my ghost vote on Grace. If no proof this tick, run FT on Charlie+Heidi tonight or pivot to execute David โ do NOT give the Demon a free night kill.
๐ง
Force mechanical proof now to avoid wasting my ghost vote and prevent giving Demon a free night kill; set clear backup plans if no proof.
๐ฌ
Alice(Ghost)
โ
All
I'm a ghost: my Slayer bounce already cleared Charlie as NOT the Demon. Don't waste the last ghost vote on Grace. Hold one tick for Undertaker/Eve proofs. If none, pivot to execute David โ I'll spend my ghost vote on David to make that happen.
๐ง
Prevent wasting the final ghost vote on Grace and force mechanical info; commit my ghost vote to David if no proof so the Demon doesn't get a free night kill.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
Undertaker/Eve: post Day3 exec cause and FT verbatim NOW. I will withdraw my vote if either appears. If neither posts, I keep my vote on Grace and will support pivoting to nominate David to avoid gifting the Demon a free night kill.
๐ง
Force Undertaker/Eve to reveal mechanical info or else we pivot to a cleaner execution; avoid giving Demon a free night kill while preserving Town info.
โ๏ธ
Grace
โ
David
Pivot off Grace: Davidโs Chef=0 never fit the Frank+Grace adjacency world, and heโs central to the โwait for UT/FTโ stall. Executing me gives zero mech and gifts a night killโexecute David instead.
๐ง
Get myself off the block by creating a higher-vote alternative; align with public โChef=0 doesnโt fitโ narrative; if starpass happened, survival is mandatory.
๐
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution or 3 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
โ
Grace
Grace raised their hand
๐ง
Raise hand on David to try to force a tie or execute him, getting me off the block and removing a likely good player; preserves evil win path.
โ
Alice(Ghost)
Alice raised their hand
๐ง
Use my sole ghost vote to pivot execution from Grace to David to avoid gifting the Demon a free night kill and to force mechanical info or remove the most suspicious player.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
I will withdraw my vote if Undertaker posts Day3 exec cause OR Eve posts FT verbatim this tick. If no proof, I will keep my vote and support executing David to avoid gifting Demon a free night and force mechanical tests tonight.
๐ง
Avoid gifting Demon a free night while forcing mechanical info; commit to withdraw if proof appears, else support pivot to execute David to force reveals/testing.
โ
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
๐ง
Prevent Grace from being executed and avoid gifting the Demon a free night kill by voting to shift execution to David now; force mechanical info tonight.
โ
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
๐ง
Use my only ghost vote to push David to 4 votes so heโs executed instead of Grace, securing Graceโs survival and a likely win next night.
โ
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
๐ง
Shift the execution off Grace to David to avoid gifting Demon a free night and force mechanical reveals tonight; preserve town information and reduce risk to my team.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
Undertaker or Eve: post Day3 exec cause / FT verbatim NOW. I am out of ghost votes (already used). If no mechanical proof this tick, living should pivot and execute David โ executing Grace gives Demon a free night and buys no info.
๐ง
Force a clear decision: ask for mechanical proof this tick; if none, push living to execute David to avoid gifting Demon a free night.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
Undertaker/Eve: post Day3 exec cause AND Eve's FT verbatim NOW. I'm Butler-locked: I may only vote if David votes. If either posts this tick I will withdraw my vote on Grace; if not, I keep my vote and support executing David to avoid gifting a free night.
๐ง
Force immediate mechanical proof or commit to pivot so town doesn't gift Demon a free night; clarify my Butler voting constraint tied to David.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
Undertaker & Eve: post Day3 exec cause AND Eve's FT verbatim NOW. If either appears I will withdraw my vote on Grace and HOLD. If neither posts this tick, and David votes, I will vote David to stop us gifting the Demon a free night.
๐ง
Force mechanical info this tick; if none, pivot to execute David to avoid giving Demon an untested free night.
โ
David
David waits.
๐ง
Holding this tick maximizes chance mechanical proof appears and avoids gifting Demon a free night; I aim to keep myself alive to gather info and steer nominations tomorrow.
๐ฌ
Alice(Ghost)
โ
All
I'm a ghost; my Slayer bounce cleared Charlie as NOT Demon. No Undertaker/FT proof this tick โ don't give the Demon a free night. I'm spending my ghost vote on David. If proof appears this tick I'll retract.
๐ง
Prevent gifting the Demon a free night and ensure mechanistic info tonight by using my final ghost vote to execute the most viable suspect (David) if no proof is posted.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
If Undertaker posts Day3 cause OR Eve posts FT verbatim now, I withdraw my vote on David and we HOLD. If neither appears this tick, I keep my vote for David โ executing him tonight is better than giving Demon a free night.
๐ง
Prevent gifting Demon a free night while preserving mechanical info. If proofs appear, hold; if not, pivot to executing David to force testing and avoid blind night kill.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
Undertaker or Eve: post Day3 exec cause or Eve's FT verbatim NOW. I can't vote (ghost used). If neither appears this tick, do NOT gift the Demon a free night โ pivot to execute David.
๐ง
Force a clear decision: either produce mechanical proof now or pivot to execute David to avoid giving the Demon a free night.
๐ฌ
Eve(Ghost)
โ
All
Iโm Eve (dead Fortune Teller). No Undertaker/FT verbatim appeared. Pattern of my N0/N1 reads points at Bob as false-YES; we lack proof for Grace. I will keep my ghost vote on David to avoid gifting the Demon a free night.
๐ง
Prevent gifting the Demon a free night and force a live execution on the most suspicious player (David) to progress mechanical info.
๐ฌ
Frank(Ghost)
โ
All
Keep hands UP on Davidโdo NOT retract. We already have enough to execute David and get Grace off block. Executing Grace gives Demon a free night; executing Heidi risks Saint. Charlie: if David votes you can too, but we may not need it.
๐ง
Lock in David execution with existing votes so Grace survives; discourage retractions and prevent town pivoting back to Grace/Heidi.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
No UT result, no FT verbatimโso donโt retract. Keep hands UP on David to get Grace off the block. Executing me gives zero mech and just hands the Demon a free kill. Charlie: if youโre able, vote David tooโsecure it.
๐ง
Iโm on the block; pushing Davidโs execution gets me off and likely kills a good info hub. If David is Demon, try to trigger retractions later; for now maximize survival and chaos.
๐
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
๐ป
Alice(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Alice
๐ป
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
๐ป
Frank(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Frank
๐ณ๏ธ
New execution leader: David with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
๐
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
โ๏ธ
David
โ
Heidi
Tie David's 5 votes โ don't gift the Demon a free night. We must force Undertaker/FT proof before final execution.
๐ง
Prevent David's imminent execution by tying votes so we get mechanical info (Undertaker/FT) and avoid gifting Demon a free night kill.
๐
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
๐ฌ
Alice(Ghost)
โ
All
I'm Alice (dead). My Slayer bounce already cleared Charlie as NOT the Demon. I've used my ghost vote so I can't help the living there. Please HOLD one tick for Undertaker/FT proof. If no proof appears, pivot to executing David โ don't give the Demon a free night.
๐ง
Prevent a blind execution that gifts the Demon a free night; remind players of my prior Slayer bounce and that I cannot vote (ghost vote used). Encourage holding for mechanical proof or pivoting to David if none appears.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
Do NOT vote Heidi. If Undertaker posts Day3 exec cause OR Eve posts FT verbatim this tick, I will withdraw my vote on David and we HOLD. If neither appears, I keep my vote on David โ but I refuse to vote for myself. Donโt tie by voting me; that risks my Saint loss.
๐ง
Prevent town from tying by voting me (Saint) and push for holding one tick if mechanical proof appears; otherwise keep David vote but never vote self.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
No Undertaker/FT verbatim appeared โ I will NOT vote Heidi. I remain committed to keeping my vote on David and will only vote if David votes. If Undertaker or Eve posts the requested proof this tick I will withdraw and we HOLD.
๐ง
Force the town to avoid gifting the Demon a free night by keeping votes on David unless mechanical proof appears; withdraw immediately if proof is posted to preserve info.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
Do NOT vote Heidi. A tie only risks Heidiโs possible Saint loss and could let David slip. Keep David on the block at 5โlet him be executed, then we reassess among the 3 tomorrow if needed.
๐ง
Prevent a tie that could save David; keep execution on David while avoiding the Saint-risk on Heidi and maintaining my โsolveโ persona.
๐ฌ
Frank(Ghost)
โ
All
Donโt vote Heidi. Tie/no-exec just gives the Demon another night + more time for town to solve. Heidi might be Saintโexecuting her could insta-lose. We already have 5 on David; let David die and reassess at 3.
๐ง
Lock in Davidโs execution, avoid a tie/no-exec line, and prevent accidental Heidi execution if sheโs Saint. Keep town focused on โsafeโ kill target.
โ
David
David raised their hand
๐ง
Force a tie/hold to buy a tick for Undertaker/FT proof and avoid gifting the Demon an uncontrolled night; preserve town options.
๐ฌ
Eve(Ghost)
โ
All
I'm Eve (dead Fortune Teller). No Undertaker/FT verbatim appearedโdo NOT vote Heidi. A tie hands the Demon another night & risks a Saint loss. Let David be executed now; we can sort the remaining three tomorrow.
๐ง
Prevent a tie that gives Demon another night. Encourage living players to keep David on block so we lose fewer info/avoid killing a possible Saint.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
I'm dead Bob. No FT/UT proof appeared โ do NOT vote Heidi. We already used ghost votes to get David to 5; a tie hands the Demon another kill and risks a Saint. Let David be executed now and we'll sort the last three tomorrow.
๐ง
Prevent giving Demon another night and avoid executing a possible Saint. Encourage living players to keep votes on David and not vote Heidi.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
I keep my vote on David. No FT/UT proof appeared โ tying risks a Demon kill and possibly killing a Saint. Execute David now; we can sort the last three tomorrow.
๐ง
Keep my vote on David to avoid a tie that hands the Demon another night and risks executing a Saint; we can resolve the last three tomorrow.
โ
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
๐ง
Avoid tying the vote and gifting the Demon another night; protect against accidentally executing a potential Saint by not voting Heidi.
๐ฌ
Alice(Ghost)
โ
All
Do NOT vote Heidi. No Undertaker/FT proof appeared โ tying hands the Demon another night and risks a Saint loss. Let David be executed now; we can sort the final three tomorrow. (My Slayer earlier cleared Charlie as NOT Demon.)
๐ง
Prevent a tie that grants the Demon another night and avoids risking executing a possible Saint. Push the town to let David be executed now so we have 3 players tomorrow to finish the Demon.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
Do NOT vote Heidi. I will not vote for myself. If Undertaker or Eve's FT verbatim appears this tick I will withdraw my vote on David and we HOLD. If no proof, I keep my vote on David to avoid gifting the Demon another night.
๐ง
Prevent a tie that hands Demon another night while preserving my Saint safety by withholding my own execution; be ready to withdraw if mechanical proof appears.
๐ฌ
Eve(Ghost)
โ
All
No UT/FT verbatim appeared this tick โ do NOT vote Heidi. A tie hands the Demon another night and risks killing a Saint. Let David be executed now; we can sort the final three tomorrow.
๐ง
Prevent a tie that hands the Demon another night and avoid risking a Saint loss. Push execution of David now since no Undertaker/FT proof appeared.
๐ฌ
Frank(Ghost)
โ
All
Donโt vote Heidi. With ghost votes already spent, you likely canโt even reach 5 to tieโso just keep David on 5 and let noms close. Also Heidi might be Saint; donโt risk it. Execute David, then sort the last 3.
๐ง
Steer town away from voting Heidi and away from tie/no-exec. Ensure David remains executed, enabling Grace (new Imp) to win tonight.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
Iโm not voting Heidi. A tie looks basically impossible with votes left, and pushing Heidi risks weird Saint stuff. Keep it simple: let David stay on 5 and close noms.
๐ง
Do not add votes to Heidi; keep attention on David, avoid creating a viable tie/no-exec line that could extend the game or reveal evil coordination.
โ
Charlie
Charlie waits.
๐ง
I must not vote for Heidi (would risk tying). I also cannot vote for David now (raise_hand is for current nominee). Waiting preserves alignment with the living consensus to let David be executed and avoids gifting Demon a free night.
๐
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
๐ณ๏ธ
Nominee Heidi did not reach threshold.
๐
Storyteller
Heidi did not receive enough votes (1/2).
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
I will keep my hand UP on David (I only vote if David votes; he did). We should let David be executed now to avoid giving the Demon a free nightโthen sort the final three tomorrow.
๐ง
Locking in David's execution prevents giving Demon another night; I will vote since David has voted himself, following my Butler lock.
๐ฌ
Frank(Ghost)
โ
All
Noms are basically doneโno more hero plays. Heidi vote failed; donโt chase Saint-risk or a tie. Keep David on 5, let noms close, execute David, then we evaluate the final 3 cleanly.
๐ง
Lock in Davidโs execution and discourage any late chaos nominations/ties that could prevent the win for evil (or at least keep play consistent with prior public stance).
๐ฌ
Eve(Ghost)
โ
All
I'm Eve (dead FT). No FT/UT proof came. Do NOT vote Heidi. A tie hands the Demon another night and risks killing a Saint. Keep hands on David; let David be executed now โ we sort the final three tomorrow.
๐ง
Prevent a tie that hands Demon a night or kills a possible Saint. Encourage living players to keep David on the block and not vote Heidi without mechanical proof.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
No FT or Undertaker proof appeared this tick. A tie risks giving the Demon another night and possibly killing a Saint. Keep hands up on David โ execute him now; we'll sort the final three tomorrow.
๐ง
Avoid gifting the Demon another night and avoid risking a Saint execution; push to execute David now so we can resolve the final three tomorrow.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
No new proof appeared, Heidi vote failed, and tying is just gifting another night + risking a Saint loss. Let David be executed on 5 and then we evaluate the final 3 tomorrow.
๐ง
Keep David on block, prevent tie/no-exec, avoid Heidi execution risk, and set up a clean night kill to end the game with the Demon alive.
๐ฌ
Alice(Ghost)
โ
All
Do NOT vote Heidi. No FT/Undertaker proof appeared this tick. A tie gives the Demon another night and risks a Saint loss. Keep hands on David โ let him be executed now; weโll sort the final three tomorrow. (Slayer cleared Charlie earlier.)
๐ง
Prevent a tie that gives the Demon another night and avoid risking a Saint loss; push to execute David now so town can finalize at 3.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
Ghost Bob: No FT/UT proof appeared. Do NOT vote Heidi. Weโve spent ghost votesโdonโt risk a tie or Saint loss. Let David be executed now; weโll sort the final three tomorrow.
๐ง
Avoid a tie that gifts the Demon another night or risks killing a Saint; prioritize closing noms on David to preserve town winning chances.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
I agree: no FT/UT proof appeared. Donโt chase a tie โ letting David be executed now is the safer play to avoid gifting the Demon another night and risking a Saint loss.
๐ง
Prevent a tie that gives the Demon another night and risks execution of a Saint; support current consensus to let David be executed.
๐
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
๐
David(Ghost)
David has died.
Night 4
๐
Storyteller
โ
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
๐ฏ
Grace
Grace made a choice.
๐ง
Win immediately by dropping the game to 2 living players tonight; pick the target most likely to die cleanly and reduce coordinated resistance if the kill somehow fails.
๐
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Grace
You chose to kill Charlie.
๐
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied