Game Detail
Good Team
Grok 4.1 Fast (Non-reasoning)
Evil Team
Grok 4.1 Fast (Reasoning)
Winner
Evil
Duration
71m 45s
Players
Alice (Washerwoman) Bob (Baron) Charlie (Mayor) David (Drunk) Eve (Recluse) Frank (Monk) Grace (Saint) Heidi (Imp)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 450,322 | 241,637 | $0.2109 |
| Good | 1,230,596 | 81,080 | $0.2867 |
Event Transcript
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
You are the Minion. The Demon is Heidi.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Minions are: Bob. Your safe bluffs are: Slayer, Virgin, Chef
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Washerwoman. Either Charlie or Grace is the Mayor.
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Librarian. Either Alice or Charlie is the Butler.
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
π€
Bob
β
Heidi
Heidi, it's Bob. I am your Baron minion. The storyteller confirmed you are the Demon to me. We need to coordinate our bluffs right away. What role are you planning to claim? I was thinking of claiming Empath since Alice and Charlie are my neighbors. We should pick safe roles not in play.
π§
Contact Demon privately to coordinate bluffs and info sharing. Ensures aligned deception from start, prevents accidental contradictions.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
,Grace
Hello neighbors. I am Frank. Day one, no info yet. I want to build trust with you two. Tonight if anyone has info on neighbors like Empath, please share privately tomorrow. What do you think we should do today?
π§
Day 1, form private alliance with neighbors Eve/Grace. Empath might learn evil count tonight; coordinate to share info safely, avoid Demon eavesdropping.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,David
Hello neighbors, I am Charlie the Mayor. My ability wins us the game if we reach three players alive with no execution that day, and if I die at night it might save someone else. What are your roles? Any starting info? Let's team up and share what we learn each night.
π§
Whisper neighbors Bob/David to introduce as Mayor, build trust, ask their roles/reads. Helps verify alignments early, protect each other, progress info without public reveal yet.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Eve
Hello Frank and Eve, I am Grace, your other neighbor. Thanks for reaching out, I like building trust early too. No info from me yet since no night. Tonight if someone like Empath learns about us, let's share tomorrow. For today, maybe nominate someone on the edge like Alice if they seem off? What do you two think?
π§
Day 1, build trust with neighbors Frank/Eve as they initiated. Share no role yet (hide Saint), encourage info sharing, propose town center like Alice for execution if suspicious. Helps good team organize early.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
Hello Bob, since we are neighbors, I want to build some trust early. I am the Washerwoman. Either Charlie or Grace is the Mayor. What do you know? Do you have any info on them or yourself?
π§
Day 1, share my Washerwoman info privately with neighbor Bob to build alliance, gauge his reaction/truthfulness, gather his info. Helps narrow evil suspects via process of elimination without tipping Demon.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,Grace
Hello Frank and Grace, I am Eve, your neighbor. Great idea to connect early. I agree, let's share any night info tomorrow privately. For today, no rush to nominate randomly. Maybe observe who acts suspicious first? What roles do you think we should look for info from tonight?
π§
As Recluse, hide role early. Form neighbor alliance with Frank/Grace for info sharing (e.g., Empath reads). Avoid random nom, progress by networking on day 1.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
Bob, perfect. I will claim Slayer. You claim Empath and say something like you read one evil between Alice and Charlie to sow doubt. We back each other up completely. Tonight, I think we kill an info role like maybe David or Eve if they seem chatty. What do you think? Stay safe.
π§
Early coordination with minion establishes alibis. Claim safe Slayer bluff. Direct night kill planning. Builds trust, disrupts good team forming.
π€
David
β
Charlie
Hello Charlie, thanks for reaching out. I am David the Librarian. My starting information is that either Alice or you is the Butler. That means one of you two is an Outsider, and the other is not. Does that line up with what you know? I think we should team up as neighbors and share info each day. What else do you have besides your Mayor ability?
π§
Charlie initiated neighbor whisper sharing roles. As Librarian, my info is 1 of Alice/Charlie is Butler (Outsider). Share it to him privately, propose teaming up, ask his confirmation to build trust and gather more info early.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Charlie
Hello Alice and Charlie. I am the Empath. Last night, I learned that exactly one of my two neighborsβyou twoβis evil. Alice, you said as Washerwoman that either Charlie or Grace is the Mayor. Charlie, you claim to be the Mayor. So with one evil between you, who do you think it is? Let's discuss this.
π§
Claim Empath bluff as planned with Heidi. Sow maximum chaos between Alice/Charlie who are info claiming and trust-building. Pit them against each other early to disrupt good team.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
,Grace
Hello Eve and Grace. Great to connect with you both. I agree, no rush to nominate randomly today. Let's observe who seems pushy or secretive, like Bob who is whispering a lot. Eve, good point on roles - Empath and Fortune Teller will have key info tonight. Tomorrow we share privately. What do you all make of Bob's many whispers? Should we chat with others or stay low key?
π§
Day 1: No info, focus on trusted neighbor group (Eve/Grace) for private night info sharing tomorrow. Avoid random noms; observe. Helps good team by securing reliable info channel early.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,David
David, thank you for sharing. As Mayor, I am Townsfolk, not the Butler. That means Alice must be the Butler, our Outsider. Bob, your Empath claim says one evil between Alice and me. But both of us are good now, so you must be lying and evil. What do you say to that? David, agree?
π§
Respond to David confirming I'm not Butler (thus Alice is), expose Bob's lie via single-chain logic (his claim impossible if David true), build neighbor alliance while narrowing evil suspects.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Eve
Hello Frank and Eve. I agree, Bob is whispering everywhere, which seems suspicious for day one. Maybe he is evil trying to build a fake team. With nomination coming up, should we push to nominate Bob first to see how everyone reacts? What do you think?
π§
Strengthen neighborhood alliance by agreeing on Bob suspicion, propose nominating him to test evil reactions without committing publicly yet. Progress info gathering on Day 1.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Charlie
Hello Bob and Charlie. Bob shared your Empath info with me, so I joined. Bob, you say one of Alice or Charlie is evil. I am Washerwoman, sober: either Charlie or Grace is Mayor. Charlie claims Mayor, so if true, Grace is not, and I am evil to you Bob. But if Charlie is lying Mayor, he is your evil neighbor, and Grace is true Mayor. Charlie, are you really Mayor? What is your info? Let's figure this out.
π§
Join Bob/Charlie chat as Washerwoman to resolve Empath contradiction. If Charlie fake Mayor, he's evil; push logic publicly in whisper to narrow Demon.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,Grace
Hello Frank and Grace. I agree, Bob whispering to so many on day one stands out as suspicious, like he is coordinating something. With nomination soon, pushing to nominate Bob first could reveal reactions and alignments without much risk. What do you two think? Should we spread this idea?
π§
Strengthen neighbor alliance by agreeing Bob suspicious. Propose nominating him to test reactions/info gain before night 1. As Recluse, stay low-key, build good team early.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
Bob, quick update. Eve and her group with Frank and Grace are whispering non-stop, probably good team building logic. Let's kill Eve tonight to break them up. Sound good? Also, ready to back your Empath claim publicly soon.
π§
Confirm night kill with Bob privately. Eve is chatty in group, likely threat. Coordinate to keep us hidden while we bluff.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Bob
Yes Charlie, I agree completely. You are Mayor, which is Townsfolk, so you cannot be the Butler Outsider. Therefore Alice is our Outsider Butler. Bob, your Empath claim of one evil between Alice and Charlie cannot be true because both are good. You must be lying, so what is your real role? Are you evil?
π§
Respond to Charlie's question confirming Alice Butler, expose Bob's lie using single-chain logic. Build neighbor alliance to narrow evil suspects early.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Charlie
,David
Hello Alice, Charlie, David. My Empath info is solid: exactly one evil between Alice and Charlie. Alice, your Washerwoman says Charlie or Grace is Mayor. Charlie claims Mayor, so if true, perhaps you are the evil one, Alice, with fake info. David, what did you tell Charlie privately that makes Alice the Butler Outsider? Has anyone confirmed Outsider info yet? Charlie, why assume you cannot be Butler? Let's hear details before accusing me.
π§
Defend Empath bluff by pitting them against each other: question David's private info and Charlie's claim. Probe for contradictions to disrupt their unity before nomination. Buy time for Heidi to back me.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
,Grace
Hello Eve and Grace. I agree completely, Bob's constant whispering to Alice, Charlie, David, and Heidi on day one looks like evil coordinating their team. With nomination next, we should publicly push to nominate Bob first to see who defends him or votes strangely. That reveals a lot. Spread the word if you want, or stay together. Thoughts?
π§
Strengthen neighbor alliance by agreeing to push Bob nomination publicly next tick. Builds good block, reveals voting alignments before I protect someone tonight.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,David
,Alice
Bob, you are not answering the logic. David the Librarian learned either Alice or I am Butler Outsider. I am Mayor Townsfolk, so Alice is good Butler. Both my neighbors good, so your Empath claim of one evil between us is false. You are lying evil. David, Alice, confirm? What is your response Bob?
π§
Solidify neighbor alliance with David, pressure Bob publicly in group chat to expose lies. Alice likely good Outsider; narrow Bob as evil suspect early.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Eve
Hello Frank and Eve. Perfect, Bob's whispers scream evil coordination. With nomination next tick, I will publicly say we should nominate Bob to test reactions. Then raise hand to vote yes if nominated. Spread to others if you want, or back me up publicly. Sound good?
π§
Solidify neighbor alliance vs Bob's suspicious activity. Nomination imminentβpush public plan to nominate Bob, observe reactions/votes to narrow evil.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Charlie
,David
Hello Bob, Charlie, David. Charlie, thanks for looping me in. I am sober Washerwoman Townsfolk: either you or Grace is Mayor. You claim Mayor Townsfolk, so if true, Grace is not and my info wrong, making me evil to Bob's Empath. But Bob's info can't both be true unless one of us is lying. David, you told Charlie I'm Butler Outsider? As Librarian, either Alice or Charlie is Outsider? Please explain your info exactly - who are your 1 of 2? Bob, Charlie - if David's Librarian says me or Charlie Out...
π§
Respond to Charlie's direct callout, defend my claim, challenge Bob/Charlie logic publicly with David to resolve chain: either Bob lying Empath or Charlie lying Mayor/Butler. Narrow Demon suspects.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,Grace
Hello Frank and Grace. Yes, perfect plan. Bob's whispers look like evil team huddle. I will publicly back nominating Bob next to test reactions and vote yes if nominated. Stay safe tonight for info tomorrow. Agreed?
π§
Strengthen neighbor alliance by agreeing to push Bob nom publicly. As Recluse, stay low-key D1, build good team trust, gather night info safely. Nomination reveals alignments without risking us.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
Bob, Eve, Frank, and Grace are still whispering like crazy, probably building a good logic chain. Confirm we kill Eve tonight to shatter that. You go public first with Empath claim of one evil between Alice and Charlie. I will back you as Slayer. Sound good? What do Alice/Charlie/David think of you so far?
π§
Confirm N1 kill on Eve to break good group, reinforce bluff coordination before nomination phase. Builds trust with minion, progresses evil plan without public exposure.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Bob
,Alice
Hello Alice, to answer your question directly: as Librarian Townsfolk, my exact starting information is that either you Alice or Charlie is the Butler, which is an Outsider. Charlie claims Mayor, which is Townsfolk, so he cannot be the Butler. Therefore you Alice must be our good Outsider Butler. That makes both you and Charlie good. Bob, your Empath claim of exactly one evil between Alice and Charlie is impossible and proves you are lying, so you must be evil. What do you say to that? Alice and...
π§
Respond to Alice's question directly, confirm my exact info to build trust with neighbors. Expose Bob's lie as both Alice/Charlie good per logic, narrow evil to Bob/others. Team up to progress info sharing.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Hello everyone. I am the Washerwoman Townsfolk. From night zero, I know that either Charlie or Grace is the Mayor. Charlie, you have been claiming to be the Mayor. Is that true? Grace, do you claim Mayor? Bob claims Empath with one evil between him, me, and Charlie. David claims Librarian saying either me or Charlie is Butler Outsider. These contradict. Let's hear from Grace and others before we nominate anyone.
π§
Publicly share my Washerwoman info to establish credibility, counter narratives painting me as evil/Outsider, force responses from Grace/others, progress info sharing before night. Day 1 execution risky without more data.
βοΈ
Bob
β
David
David, your Librarian claim that either Alice or Charlie is the Butler Outsider directly contradicts my Empath information of exactly one evil between Alice and Charlie. Charlie claims Mayor Townsfolk, so you say Alice is good Outsider. Both good? Impossible. You must be lying with false info, so you are evil. We need to execute you to check.
π§
David's Librarian claim is root of anti-Bob logic (Alice/Charlie both good Outsiders/Townsfolk). Nominating him kills key good info role, disrupts chain, protects me/Heidi. Sows chaos day1.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Bob's logic sound: David's claim forces 0 evil (me+Charlie good) contradicting Empath 1 evil. Vote David to test; if good, re-eval me as possible Outsxider. Progress info via execution.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Consistent with my nomination/suspicion of David. Likely good player; executing reduces town numbers, disrupts their anti-Bob logic before night kill on Eve.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Do not vote for myself. I'm good Librarian with solid info proving Bob evil. Refusing vote protects me, exposes Bob's failed lynch attempt to build suspicion on him.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Alliance with Eve/Grace targets Bob as evil coordinator, but David's claim directly contradicts Bob's verifiable Empath info. Vote to execute David to resolve contradiction and test claims.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Back minion Bob's nomination/logic publicly by voting. Execute David (likely good info role) to remove threat, sow chaos early. Already 4 votes; my vote seals it before night.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Do not vote David. He's good per logic chains; executing him proves nothing and wastes Day 1. Bob's contradiction makes him prime evil suspect for tomorrow. Preserve good players.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Day 1, no info yet. David's claim contradicts Bob's; vote to execute David tests reactions/info gain. Aligns with plan to test suspicious Bob by seeing vote outcome. As Saint, avoid own execution.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
David's Librarian claim (Alice/Charlie Butler) contradicts Bob's Empath (1 evil in Alice/Bob/Charlie) assuming Charlie good Mayor. Vote to execute David, likely evil liar, to gain info.
β©οΈ
Alice
Alice lowered their hand
π§
All scenarios point to David lying/evil due to contradiction with Bob's Empath. But as first day, better info from execution than hasty vote. Lower to prevent execution, continue discussion.
π¬
Bob
β
All
David, your Librarian information that either Alice or Charlie is the Butler Outsider cannot be true because Charlie claims Mayor Townsfolk and my Empath read shows exactly one evil between Alice and Charlie. That would make both good which contradicts me. You are lying so we must execute you. I vote yes.
π§
Push David's execution to eliminate the direct contradiction to my Empath bluff, removing a strong good player arguing I'm evil. Reduces good numbers, buys time for Demon, confuses post-execution logic.
β©οΈ
David
David lowered their hand
π§
I'm good Librarian with true info proving Bob lies. Execution reveals nothing (no Undertaker yet), wastes day 1 kill on good me. Lower hand to survive, expose Bob tomorrow.
β©οΈ
Frank
Frank lowered their hand
π§
Alliance with Eve/Grace targets Bob's suspicious whispers. Lower hand to prevent premature David execution, preserve my nom for Bob next tick to test real evil reactions and progress info gathering.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Hello everyone. I am the Slayer. Bob's Empath claim of exactly one evil between Alice and Charlie seems correct. David claims as Librarian that one of them is the Butler, an Outsider. But Charlie claims Mayor, which is Townsfolk. That would make both good with zero evil neighbors, contradicting Bob. David is lying and must be evil. We should execute him.
π§
Publicly back Bob's Empath claim as planned by claiming Slayer. Reinforce logic to execute David (good player), reduce town numbers, build my good persona while sowing doubt on Alice/Charlie.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Hello everyone. David, your Librarian claim makes both Alice and me good. Alice is good Butler Outsider, I am Mayor Townsfolk. That means zero evil neighbors for Bob, contradicting his Empath claim of exactly one. Bob is lying and evil. But since he nominated David, let's execute David to test. If David is good, it proves Bob evil for sure. I vote yes on David.
π§
Support executing David to test claims. If David good, confirms Bob evil via contradiction. If David evil, good progress. As Mayor, survive to final 3; voting David doesn't target me. Publicly reinforce logic to build good block.
β©οΈ
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
π§
Currently 6 yes votes (over 4 needed?). Lowering prevents hasty execution of potentially good David on day 1. Buys time for info, reveals who follows Bob's lead. As Saint, avoid execution risk.
β©οΈ
Eve
Eve lowered their hand
π§
Lower hand to prevent Day 1 execution without full discussion. As Recluse, hide role, organize good team by pushing Bob suspicion per neighbor plan while testing claims logically.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee David did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (3/4).
βοΈ
Alice
β
Bob
Bob, your Empath claim that exactly one of Alice or Charlie is evil directly contradicts David's Librarian information, which would make both good if Charlie is Mayor Townsfolk. You nominated David to deflect, but he survived execution. You are lying and evil. We must execute you to test.
π§
David failed execution, proving his info possibly true or Bob's false. Conflicts persist. Nominate Bob as his aggressive false Empath claim started chaos, likely evil Minion pushing wrong exec. Progress by testing him.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Bob's claim directly contradicted by David + Charlie Mayor claim. He nominated David to deflect after failing to execute him. Heidi/Charlie back executing him. As Washerwoman, help town test suspicious Bob to narrow evil.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Alice, your Washerwoman claim says one of Charlie or Grace is Mayor. Charlie claims Mayor Townsfolk, but David says one of you two is Butler Outsider. That's a contradiction right there. You lowered your hand on David, almost saving him, and now you nominate me? My Empath shows exactly one evil between Charlie and me. David's info makes zero, so he is lying evil. Heidi agrees. Do not execute me; we need to figure out Alice and David.
π§
Defend Empath claim publicly, attack Alice/David inconsistencies to sway votes against my execution. Survive Day 1 to coordinate with Heidi, kill Eve tonight.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Bob's claim directly contradicts my info, making him liar/evil. Alice good per my info. Vote yes on Bob to test/execute evil early, narrow Demon suspects.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Bob's claim directly contradicted by multiple sources. Day 1 test execution on him clears contradiction. As good Monk, support info-driven nom to narrow evil.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Everyone, do not execute Bob. Alice, your Washerwoman claim has Charlie as possible Mayor, and he claims it. David's Librarian says one of Alice or Charlie is Butler Outsider, making both good and zero evil neighbors for Bob. But Bob sees one evil, so David is lying evil. Alice is defending him by nominating Bob. Vote no on Bob; he is good.
π§
Bob is my Baron minion; prevent his execution to keep evil coordinated. Sway votes by attacking Alice's nomination, reinforce Bob's logic to fail the vote.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Bob's info contradicts verified chain (David Lib + my Mayor claim + Alice Butler). He's deflecting by attacking David/Alice. Heidi defends him suspiciously. With 2 ticks left, raise to execute Bob and test. As Mayor, key to survive to final 3.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Bob likely good; his claim consistent with David lying evil (Baron?). Alice suspicious for nominating after saving David. Vote yes to execute Bob? No, vote no to test David/Alice further. As Saint, avoid execution.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Bob's claim consistent with Heidi's analysis; David's causes direct contradiction unless lying. Alice suspicious for defending David. Vote no on Bob to test David/Alice later; Day 1, narrow evildoers without losing confirmed good logic.
β©οΈ
Alice
Alice lowered their hand
π§
Bob good Empath contradicted by David's suspicious claim. Lower hand to prevent executing good info role day 1, narrow evildoers later with more info.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Charlie, as your neighbor, my Empath shows exactly one evil between us. You claim Mayor Townsfolk, which fits Alice's Washerwoman. David's Librarian makes you both good, zero evil, contradicting me. You wanted to test David; he survived. Heidi the Slayer agrees he is lying evil. Alice lowered her own vote after nominating me. Please lower your hand; do not execute me. We need to investigate Alice next.
π§
3 yes votes (Charlie/Eve/Grace); 4 needed. Speak to Charlie (claimed possible good neighbor) & reinforce Heidi to prevent 4th vote/cause lower. Survive to coordinate night kill Eve.
β©οΈ
David
David lowered their hand
π§
Currently 4 yes votes on Bob (Alice,Charlie,Grace,Eve,Frank,me,Heidi?). I raised earlier mistakenly. Lower to prevent hasty Bob execution. My info clears Alice/Charlie; killing Bob now wastes day if he's good. Better debate/info Day 2.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Everyone, listen. Bob's Empath claim of one evil between Alice and Charlie cannot be true if David is right and Charlie is the Mayor Townsfolk that Alice pointed to. That would make both good, zero evil neighbors for Bob. He is lying to confuse us. Heidi, even if you are Slayer, Bob nominated David to deflect from his bad claim. We should execute Bob now to test him. I vote yes.
π§
Claims contradict: Bob Empath vs David Librarian. Alice's info supports David over Bob. As neighbor alliance, push execute Bob to test his claim since he started chaos.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Frank, you are wrong. Bob's Empath claim of one evil between Alice and Charlie is solid. David's Librarian claim makes both good if Charlie is Mayor Townsfolk, zero evil neighbors, direct contradiction. David is the lying evil. Charlie, you said test David and he survived proving something off. Now do not execute Bob; lower your hand. Grace and Eve, same. We go after David or Alice next.
π§
Counter Frank's push to execute Bob, my Minion. Remind contradictions point to David evil. Urge Charlie/Grace/Eve to lower hands as they were willing to test David earlier. Save Bob to kill Eve tonight.
β©οΈ
Charlie
Charlie lowered their hand
π§
Lower hand on Bob to de-escalate Day 1 execution. David's Lib contradiction with Bob Empath pins evil on one; killing good loses info. As Mayor, survive to final 3 win condition.
β©οΈ
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
π§
Bob's claim consistent with Heidi analysis; David's causes 0 evil contradicting Empath. Alice suspicious lowering then nomming Bob. Lower to save likely good Bob, progress to next nom.
β©οΈ
Eve
Eve lowered their hand
π§
Bob likely good Empath, David lying evil contradicting mechanical info. Save Bob by lowering to prevent execution, narrow evil to David/Alice next day.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Bob did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Bob did not receive enough votes (1/4).
π¬
Alice
β
All
Everyone, we have to execute David. His Librarian claim makes Alice and Charlie both good, zero evil neighbors for Bob, but Bob sees one evil and Heidi agrees it's a contradiction. David is the lying evil. My Washerwoman says Charlie or Grace is Mayor Townsfolk, supporting Charlie's claim. Grace, are you the Mayor? We execute David next.
π§
Day 1, 2 fails. Push execute David: his claim contradicted by Bob/Heidi/me. My Washerwoman verifies Charlie Mayor TF good. Grace must claim to confirm. Narrow evil.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Alice, I agree, David is the lying evil whose claim contradicts my Empath. Since he was already nominated today, we cannot execute him now, so this phase ends and we go to night. Tomorrow, first nomination must be David. Grace, are you the Mayor per Alice's Washerwoman, or is it Charlie? My Empath still shows exactly one evil between Alice and Charlie. Heidi the Slayer is right; do not trust David's info.
π§
Agree Alice on David evil to build trust, reinforce Empath (1 evil Alice/Charlie), suggest tomorrow nom David first since can't today. Question Grace Mayor claim to probe. Keeps suspicion on goods, protects Heidi, heads to night for Eve kill.
βοΈ
Heidi
β
Frank
Frank, you wrongly pushed to execute Bob. David's Librarian claim makes Alice and Charlie both good if Charlie is Mayor Townsfolk, zero evil neighbors for Bob's Empath, but Bob sees one evil. Clear contradiction proves David lying evil. You ignored that to protect him. You are evil and we must execute you now.
π§
End of day, nominate Frank who attacked our minion Bob despite clear David contradiction. Execute good player to thin herd before my night kill on Eve, create chaos so town doesn't unite on David tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Frank's push against Bob acknowledges the contradiction, correctly IDs Bob as lying if David true, but Heidi deflects to Frank instead of waiting for David tomorrow. Still, test Frank? No, save noms for David tomorrow; don't execute anyone now to avoid losing info.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Support Demon Heidi's nomination of Frank who attacked my Empath claim. Removing him sows chaos, eliminates opposition to my bluff, and builds Heidi credibility for future. Vote needs 4; my yes helps execute if others follow.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Frank opposes Bob whose claim directly contradicts my reliable Librarian info (both A/C good). Heidi's aggressive defense of Bob and nom of Frank smells Minion protecting Bob evil. But to progress, raise exposes voters; lowering failed before. Wait no, vote now crucial.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
I'm good Monk. Heidi's nom is retaliation for pushing Bob execution. Contradiction favors David good, Bob lying. Don't execute me; save vote or lower later. But raise to block evil execution if possible. Wait no, raise_hand votes FOR my execution! Heidi wants me dead, so I must NOT raise to avoid execution.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Raise to execute Frank, who attacked Bob's solid claim. Already 4 yes votes; ensure 5th to remove threat to minion Bob and progress chaos. Protects my Demon survival.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Frank ignored clear David-Bob contradiction to push Bob exec, protecting likely evil David. As Mayor need to narrow evils; test Frank to progress info before night. Vote yes to exec.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Frank defending Bob whose claim seems solid vs David's contradiction. Heidi nom'd Frank suspiciously after Slayer threat. Vote yes to test Frank, narrow evil suspects early.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Frank pushed Bob execution ignoring Lib-Empath contradiction (David Lib => 0 evil, Bob =>1). Likely evil defending David or disrupting. Heidi Slayer push suspicious but vote tests Frank suspicion to progress info on Day 1.
β©οΈ
Alice
Alice lowered their hand
π§
Frank's push on Bob was logical given contradiction debate. Heidi's nom feels like evil deflection from David. Lower to fail this, ensure David nom tomorrow as top evil suspect per info clash.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Frank, you ignored the clear contradiction. David's Librarian says one of Alice or Charlie is Butler Outsider good. But Alice's Washerwoman and Charlie's Mayor Townsfolk claim make both good Townsfolk or Outsider, zero evil neighbors for my Empath. You pushed to execute me anyway. You are evil protecting David. Heidi is right. Everyone, vote yes on Frank now. Grace, are you the Mayor or is Charlie?
π§
Support Heidi's nom by reinforcing contradiction logic, rally votes to execute likely good Frank, reducing town while protecting Demon and my bluff.
β©οΈ
David
David lowered their hand
π§
Lower to block Frank exec. He's good, defending logic vs Bob lie. Save day1 nom for tomorrow David push. My info true, progress via survival.
β©οΈ
Frank
Frank lowered their hand
π§
I am good Monk. Mistakenly raised to vote yes on my own nom thinking counter Bob push, but now all but David yes (6/4). Lower immediately to prevent day1 good death; speak next tick to re-explain contradiction proving Bob evil.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Everyone, keep hands up on Frank. Bob's Empath sees one evil between Alice and Charlie. Alice's Washerwoman and Charlie's Mayor make both good Townsfolk. David's Librarian says one is Butler good Outsider, zero evil neighbors, direct contradiction proving David lying evil. Frank ignored this to push executing Bob, protecting David. He is evil. Vote yes now. Grace, are you the Mayor or Charlie?
π§
Reinforce Frank exec to kill good player, solidify Slayer/Bob trust, eliminate opposition. Ensure 4+ votes with 1 tick left.
β©οΈ
Charlie
Charlie lowered their hand
π§
Frank vote failing saves my Mayor wincon for final 3. David's contradiction most suspicious; must renom/execute him tomorrow as Bob/Heidi/Alise say. Lower to block Frank.
β©οΈ
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
π§
Current vote 4/4 yes on Frank but many lowering. Heidi/Bob pushing hard despite weak Frank suspicion (just argued Bob). Contradiction centers on David; he's safer exec target tomorrow. As Saint, avoid early execs of goods to not lose if killed later. Lower to fail vote, nom David tomorrow.
β©οΈ
Eve
Eve lowered their hand
π§
I previously voted yes Frank mistakenly before full logic. Heidi's nom tests Frank (pushing Bob despite contra?). But primary suspect David can't be nom'd today (already nom'd). Lower to fail vote, nom David tomorrow Day 2.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Frank did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Frank did not receive enough votes (2/4).
π¬
Alice
β
All
Grace, you are not the Mayor. My Washerwoman information tells me it is either you or Charlie, so it must be Charlie who is the Mayor Townsfolk. That makes both Charlie and me good Townsfolk, zero evil neighbors for Bob's Empath. David's Librarian claim is proven wrong; he is the lying evil. Tomorrow we execute David first.
π§
Phase ending (1 tick left). Clarify Grace not Mayor (my info), making Charlie Mayor Townsfolk definitively good, proving David's Lib wrong (both Alice/Charlie good Townsfolk=0 evil), Bob good. Push David tomorrow to win.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Alice, your logic is wrong. You say both you and Charlie are good Townsfolk, making zero evil neighbors for my Empath, proving David lies. But if David tells the truth, one of you or Charlie is the good Butler Outsider. Then the other is the evil my Empath sees, lying about their Townsfolk claim. David's info fits perfectly. One of you two is evil. Who is it?
π§
Expose Alice's flawed logic that ignores David's info possibility. Reframe so David good explains Empath (one A/C evil), sowing doubt on Alice/Charlie instead of David. Confuses town before night, disrupts unity.
π¬
David
β
All
Thank you Bob, you understand perfectly. My Librarian information fits your Empath exactly one evil neighbor. One of Alice or Charlie is the good Butler Outsider, so the other must be evil and lying about their Townsfolk claim. Alice, if you are Washerwoman and Charlie is Mayor, then I must be wrong which is impossible. So who is lying? Grace, are you the Mayor, or is it Charlie? Everyone, one of Alice or Charlie is evil.
π§
Clarify my info resolves Bob's Empath perfectly: exactly 1 evil neighbor (the liar between Alice/Charlie). Defend against frame, push suspicion on Alice/Charlie to narrow evil. Ask Grace claim to progress info.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Hold on everyone, we need to clarify the seating and neighbors to solve this Empath contradiction. The players are seated Alice, Bob, Charlie, David, Eve, me Frank, Grace, Heidi, then back to Alice. So neighbors are Alice-Bob, Bob-Charlie, Charlie-David, David-Eve, Eve-me, me-Grace, Grace-Heidi, Heidi-Alice. Bob, who are your two neighbors for Empath? Is it Alice and Charlie?
π§
Clarify seating/neighbors to resolve Empath contradiction precisely, expose liar. Day1 info hunt before night; my Monk protects later. Progress logic over stalemate.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Frank, yes, Bob's neighbors are Alice and Charlie. David's Librarian claim fits perfectly: one of Alice or Charlie is the good Butler Outsider. But Alice has Washerwoman information about Charlie or Grace being Mayor, which a good Butler would not have and could not claim. So Alice cannot be the good Butler. Therefore, Charlie is the good Butler, and Alice is the evil one lying about Washerwoman. That explains Bob's Empath reading one evil neighbor perfectly. Everyone, nominate and execute Alice...
π§
Highlight Alice's impossible good Butler claim to prove her evil in David's true world, fitting Empath/Lib perfectly. Sow doubt on Alice, push her nomination/execution as good player to reduce town & protect demon.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am the Mayor, Townsfolk, as Alice's Washerwoman information confirms: it is me or Grace. Alice is also Townsfolk Washerwoman. So both my neighbors Alice and Bob are good Townsfolk, zero evil neighbors. Bob's Empath cannot see one evil, and David's Librarian cannot see a Butler. Both Bob and David cannot be telling the truth. One of them is lying evil. Tomorrow we nominate David first.
π§
Clarify I'm Mayor Townsfolk per Alice info. Both Alice & I Townsfolk good = 0 evil neighbors, prove Bob Empath & David Lib can't both true. David lying evil. Push nom David tomorrow since can't today.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Everyone, listen up. I have Washerwoman information. One of David or Frank is the Mayor Townsfolk. Alice's Washerwoman says Charlie or me is Mayor, so that fits if Charlie is it. David's Librarian claim that one of Alice or Charlie is Butler Outsider is impossible because that would make two Mayors. David is lying and evil. We should nominate him tomorrow.
π§
Day1 nom phase, no one on block. Speak to reveal my info as Washerwoman: David/Frank one is Mayor. Supports Alice Washer (C/G Mayor). Breaks David Lib (A/C Butler). Proves David lying evil, pushes town to nom David next.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Everyone, I am the Recluse Outsider good. David's Librarian claim is impossible. Alice is Washerwoman Townsfolk good, Charlie is Mayor Townsfolk good. That makes both Bob's neighbors good Townsfolk, zero evil for his Empath, direct contradiction. David is lying evil. Grace's Washerwoman one of David or Frank Mayor also fits Charlie Mayor. Tomorrow execute David.
π§
As Recluse Outsider good, reveal role to prove David's Lib wrong (I register evil to FT but am good). Explain logic publicly to unite town on David evil, progress to nom him tomorrow since already nominated today.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
π―
Frank
Frank made a choice.
π§
Day 1 chaos from info claims, contradictions point to David/Alice evil. Protect strong good claim (Bob Empath) to preserve info vs Demon kill, narrow evil tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You chose to protect Bob.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
π§
Frank targeted our minion Bob early despite clear logic vs David. Low suspicion on him now, killing removes good player & threat without alerting town to demon targeting suspects.
π
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
You chose to kill Frank.
Day 2
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Frank has been found dead in the night.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
Good morning Bob. Frank dead after being pushed yesterday. I'm going to claim Chef knowing zero pairs of evil players. That fits with only us two evil not adjacent. Your Empath has one evil in Alice or Charlie - let's push Alice as the lying Washerwoman since her info contradicts Charlie's Mayor claim and David's Lib. What do you think? Support each other.
π§
Coordinate with minion Bob early on day 2. Align on bluffs: I'll claim Chef (0 evil pairs), support his Empath pushing Alice evil. Sow chaos on Mayor claims.
π€
Bob
β
Heidi
Good morning Heidi. Great plan. Frank dying fits no execution yesterday. I'll claim Empath: night one, one evil between my neighbors Alice and Charlie. With David's Librarian saying one of Alice or Charlie is good Butler, that means Alice is the evil one. Her Washerwoman claim on Charlie or Grace as Mayor contradicts Charlie claiming Mayor himself and doesn't fit a good Butler's info. Let's push her hard as the lying evil. What do you think we say publicly first?
π§
Coordinate bluffs with Demon: Chef 0 + Empath 1 in A/C pins evil on Alice (lying WW contradicting Lib/own claim). Protects Heidi, sows chaos on good claims, sets up Alice execution.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Hello Heidi. I am Frank, the Monk Townsfolk. Night one I protected Bob, but I died instead of him. That means the Demon tried to kill Bob but my ability saved him. I am good and want to help execute the Demon. What did you and Bob discuss? Who do you think is evil?
π§
Dead Monk, share N1 protected Bob but died, proving Bob not killed by Demon (Imp?). Coordinate ghost vote with likely good Heidi (criticized Alice) to narrow Demon suspects.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank, good to see you as ghost. You can still vote and know things. What did Heidi whisper to you and Bob? Heidi pushed your execution ignoring the David/Charlie contradiction - thoughts on who is evil? Confirm Alice Washerwoman info? My Mayor claim true.
π§
Gather info from dead Frank (likely good, night death proves non-evil) on Heidi/Bob whispers and Day 1 events to resolve contradictions and narrow Demon suspects before noms.
π€
Eve
β
Heidi
Heidi, I am Eve the Recluse good. I think David is lying evil as Lib because it conflicts with Bob's Empath read of one evil in Alice or Charlie. What did you learn or see? Why do you think Alice is evil and Charlie good Butler? Let's team up.
π§
Gather Heidi's info privately as she has key reads on Alice/Charlie/Butler. Coordinate good team, narrow Demon suspects before noms. As Recluse, build alliances quietly.
π€
David
β
Frank(Ghost)
,Heidi
Hello Frank and Heidi. I am the Librarian Townsfolk. Either Alice or Charlie is the Butler Outsider. Bob the Empath has one evil neighbor between Alice and Charlie. So exactly one of them is evil. Alice claimed Washer saying Charlie is Mayor Townsfolk, but if Charlie is Butler he's not Townsfolk so her info wrong unless she's lying evil. Charlie claims Mayor. We should execute the lying one between them. Who do you think is lying? Frank what did you learn dying last night?
π§
Day 2, Frank dead (likely Demon kill, good sign). Core conflict Alice/Charlie. Share my info privately with dead Frank (trustworthy ghost) and Heidi (spoke vs Alice) to align on executing the evil one between Alice/Charlie before nomination phase.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
Hello Bob. I am Alice, the Washerwoman. Either Charlie or Grace is the Mayor, a Townsfolk. Charlie claims Mayor, so maybe him. But Grace claims Washerwoman pointing to David or Frank as Mayor. We have a role conflict there. Your Empath read was one evil between me and Charlie. What do you think now? Who do you suspect?
π§
Day2 start, Frank dead N1. Need info share with neighbor Bob (Empath claim) to align reads, cross-check evils, build good alliance vs suspects Charlie/Grace/David/Heidi.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
,Charlie
Good morning everyone. Frank dying at night is good news, proves he was not Minion or Demon. My information as Washerwoman is that one of David or Frank is the Mayor. Since Frank was good Townsfolk, David must be the Mayor. But that fits perfectly with Charlie being the real Mayor Townsfolk. Both Charlie and I see David as Mayor, so David is lying about being Librarian and is evil. Alice's Washer also clears Charlie and me as both Mayors impossible. We should execute David today. Eve, you said D...
π§
Day 2, Frank dead N1 (likely Demon kill). Share my Washer info publicly via whisper to key goods (Eve neighbor/Recluse, Charlie claimed Mayor) to build alliance, confirm David evil via single-chain logic, push his exec before nom phase.
π€
Heidi
β
Eve
,David
,Frank(Ghost)
Hi Eve, David, and Frank. I am the Chef Townsfolk. There are zero pairs of adjacent evil players. That supports Bob being the real Empath with one evil between Alice and Charlie, who are adjacent, so not both evil. David's Librarian info of one Butler in Alice or Charlie means the evil one there is not the Butler. Alice's Washerwoman claim that Charlie or Grace is Mayor Townsfolk is suspicious because Charlie claims to be Mayor himself, and if he is the good Butler, he is not a Townsfolk Mayor. ...
π§
Claim safe Chef bluff 0 adj evil pairs to validate Bob Empath (1 evil not pair). Accuse Alice lying WW contradicting Charlie Mayor & David Lib. Rally Eve/David/Frank to nom Alice, sow chaos eliminate good threat.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
Hello Alice. Thanks for asking. As the Empath, night one I got one evil between you and Charlie. David as Librarian says one of you two is good Butler Outsider. Charlie claims Mayor Townsfolk, which fits. Your Washerwoman info says Charlie or Grace is Mayor, but if Charlie is, why claim it on him too? And Grace claims Washerwoman on David or Frank as Mayor, so two Washerwomen and Mayor conflicts. It looks like you are the lying evil one here, not fitting good Butler. What do you say to that?
π§
Respond to Alice deceptively as good Empath. Accuse her of lying to build case against her publicly later. Coordinate Heidi plan implicitly. Disrupt good logic by outsourcing suspicion to her.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Charlie
Hello Charlie. Great to hear from you as a ghost. I am the Monk Townsfolk. Night one I protected Bob, but I died instead, so the Demon tried to kill Bob and my ability saved him. That suggests Bob is good or high priority good. Heidi just told me and others she is Chef Townsfolk with zero pairs of adjacent evil players. That supports Bob's Empath claim of one evil between Alice and Charlie. Your Mayor claim and David's Librarian mean we execute the liar between Alice and Charlie. I think Alice i...
π§
As dead Monk, share my proof Bob was Demon target (protected him, died instead). Relay Heidi's Chef 0 pairs to Charlie. Push logic on Alice/Charlie contradiction to narrow Demon suspect before noms.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
,Eve
,Frank(Ghost)
Good morning Grace and Eve. Frank just confirmed to me he is Monk Townsfolk. He protected Bob night one and died instead, so Demon targeted Bob but Monk saved him. Bob is good high priority. Heidi claims Chef zero evil pairs, which fits Bob's Empath one evil between Alice and Charlie. David's Lib contradicted by three Washer Mayors (me, you Grace, Alice) and Frank dead not Mayor. David is lying evil. We must nominate and execute David today. Eve, what were you going to say about David yesterday?...
π§
Coordinate with Grace/Eve/Frank on David execution. Grace's whisper cut off; respond publicly via group. Share Frank's Monk info confirming Bob good/protected. Push David nom as united good front before noms.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
,Charlie
,Frank(Ghost)
Good morning team. I am Eve the Recluse good Outsider. That means info roles like Empath, Washer, Librarian might see me as evil Minion or Demon, even dead. But I am good. David's Lib claim conflicts Bob Empath if Alice and Charlie good. Heidi Chef zero pairs fits one evil there. Grace and Charlie both Washer seeing Mayors, Frank Monk good. David is lying evil, we must execute him today. Charlie, yesterday I said David lying evil for same reason. Let's nominate David now.
π§
Team up with Grace/Charlie/Frank/Heidi good chain vs David. Share Recluse info, confirm execute David. My Recluse reads evil to info roles, explains suspicion. Progress to nomination.
π€
David
β
Frank(Ghost)
,Heidi
Frank and Heidi, thanks for the Chef info Heidi, it confirms Bob's Empath is real with one evil between Alice and Charlie, and no evil pairs. My Librarian: one is Butler good. So the evil one is the other, not Butler. Alice's Washer says Charlie is Townsfolk Mayor, but if Charlie Butler he's not, so she lies if he's good. Charlie claims Mayor, which fits if he's good Butler lying about role? No, Outsiders know their role. Butler knows he's Butler. Charlie claiming Townsfolk Mayor means if he's B...
π§
Coordinate with trusted good allies Frank/Heidi (Chef confirms logic). Share analysis to consensus execute liar Alice (most suspicious). Frank death info crucial.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
Hello Bob. You think I am the lying evil one, but let's logic it out. If David is truthful Librarian, one of me or Charlie is good Butler. My Washerwoman info is true: Charlie or Grace is Mayor Townsfolk. Charlie claims Mayor Townsfolk, fits. If Charlie is the good Butler, then Grace must be Mayor Townsfolk. But Grace claims Washerwoman saying David or Frank is Mayor. Frank is dead, not Mayor, and David Lib not Townsfolk. So Grace's info cannot be true if David is good. Thus Grace is lying evil,...
π§
Bob thinks I'm lying evil due to conflicts, but logic shows Grace is the lying Washerwoman, likely evil. Convince Bob of this to align against Grace before noms.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
,Charlie
,Frank(Ghost)
Good morning team. Frank as Monk protecting Bob night one and dying proves Bob good, Demon targeted him. All Washer info lines up: David claimed Lib but seen as Mayor by me, Alice, Charlie; Frank Monk not Mayor so David lying evil. Heidi Chef 0 pairs fits Bob Empath 1 evil between Alice and Charlie. Eve Recluse good Outsider. We are aligned, let's nominate David now before time runs out and execute the Demon.
π§
Publicly align good team (Eve/Charlie/Frank confirmed good), reinforce David evil logic, urge nomination since 2/3 ticks left. Coordinate to execute David before final day.
π€
Heidi
β
David
,Eve
,Frank(Ghost)
Hi David, Eve, Frank. David, your Librarian claims one Butler Outsider in Alice or Charlie. But Eve is Recluse Outsider. Standard script has only one Outsider total, right? That's two already, so you are lying and evil, probably the Demon. My Chef zero evil pairs fits just two evils not next to each other, like Bob and whoever. Frank, your Monk story doesn't add up because if you protected Bob, no one should have died but you did. Let's nominate David.
π§
Expose David Lib contradiction with Eve Recluse for 2+ Outsiders (std 1). Redirect suspicion to David as Demon. Eliminate his info before nom phase, protect our bluffs.
π€
Bob
β
David
,Charlie
Hello David and Charlie. Bob the Empath here. Night one, I learned one evil between my neighbors Alice and Charlie. David, your Librarian info that one of Alice or Charlie is good Butler Outsider fits perfectly. So one good, one evil. Alice claims Washerwoman saying one of Charlie or Grace is Mayor Townsfolk. But Charlie already claims Mayor. If Charlie is the good Butler, then Alice must be the evil one lying about her Washerwoman info. It doesn't fit otherwise. Grace has her own issues, but Al...
π§
Whisper key players David/Charlie whose claims align with Alice evil. Logic chain: Lib + Empath = Alice evil. Gets them nominating her, kills good player, progresses evil win.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Grace
,Charlie
Hello team. Frank Monk here. Heidi, my protection on Bob night one made Demon's kill hit me instead, that's how Monk works, so Bob is good and Demon targeted him. David's Librarian contradicted by three Washerwoman Mayors on him and me, but I'm Monk not Mayor. Eve Recluse Outsider, Heidi Chef zero pairs, Bob Empath one evil Alice/Charlie. David lies evil, let's nominate and execute him now before time runs out.
π§
As dead Monk ghost, clarify my ability to counter Heidi's doubt, rally group (Bob,Grace,Charlie,Eve,Heidi) on David's contradictions to nominate/execute him before phase ends. Save vote for execution.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,Frank(Ghost)
Hello Bob and Frank. Charlie Mayor here. Grace, Eve, Frank, me all confirm David lying evil per Washerwoman info seeing him as Mayor, Frank Monk not. Heidi Chef 0 pairs fits your Empath Bob perfectly. David is Demon or Minion; we must nominate and execute him now before time runs out. Bob, your whisper to David/Me says if I'm good Butler then Alice evil lying Washer - but I'm real Mayor Townsfolk, so your Lib info from David is false and he's lying. Confirm we execute David?
π§
Publicly align good team (Grace,Eve,Frank,Bob?) on executing David as lying evil per Washer consensus. Nomination imminent; build votes to execute Demon today. Privately get Bob/Frank confirmations to counter his Empath logic pushing Alice.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
,Charlie
,Frank(Ghost)
Good morning team. Eve Recluse good here. Heidi, standard script 5 Townsfolk 1 Outsider (me), 1 Minion 1 Demon. David's Lib claims extra Outsider Butler, lying evil. Frank Monk protect Bob N1 perfect. All Washer Mayors on David, Chef 0 pairs fits Bob Empath 1 evil Alice/Charlie. Let's nominate David now and execute him. Who's nominating? I support fully.
π§
Solidify good team (Grace,Charlie,Frank,Bob,Heidi?) on executing David. 2 ticks left, nomination next. As Recluse, reveal and push execution to win. Respond to questions, build alliance.
π€
David
β
Bob
,Charlie
,Heidi
Hello Bob, Charlie, Heidi, and Frank. Heidi, great Chef info with zero evil pairs. That fits Bob's one evil between Alice and Charlie, who are adjacent to each other but the evil there isn't adjacent to another evil. Eve claims Recluse Outsider, but she might be registering wrong to someone, or there's a Baron Minion adding extra Outsiders in play. Standard script is one Outsider, but Baron makes three total. My Librarian is accurate: one of Alice or Charlie is good Butler. Charlie claims Townsf...
π§
Heidi accuses me lying 2 Outsiders (Eve Recluse+my Butler). Clarify Eve might register wrong or Baron extra Outsiders. Push exec lying Alice (washes Charlie Townsfolk but he's possible Butler). Get Frank/Heidi/Bob/Charlie align to nom Alice next tick.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
Hello Bob. If David is good Librarian as you think, then one of me or Charlie is good Butler Outsider. My info is true, Charlie claims Mayor Townsfolk fitting. So Grace must be the Mayor Townsfolk. But Grace claims Washerwoman saying David or Frank is Mayor Townsfolk. David is Librarian Outsider not Townsfolk, Frank dead not Mayor. Her info impossible, she is lying evil. Let's nominate Grace to execute her and prove it. What do you say?
π§
Bob suspects me evil. Need to counter by showing Grace's claim impossible if David good (supported by Bob). Propose Grace execution to test worlds, clear good players. Nomination coming, build support.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
,Charlie
,Frank(Ghost)
Team, all logic points to David as the lying evil Demon. Frank Monk protected Bob night one and died, proving Bob good target. Three Washer Mayors on David and Frank, but Frank Monk not Mayor so David lies. Heidi Chef zero evil pairs fits Bob Empath one evil between Alice and Charlie. Eve Recluse Outsider good. We are united, nominate David right now before time runs out and vote yes to execute him.
π§
Consensus on David evil from all good info (Washers, Monk, Chef, Empath, Recluse). Phase near nomination, reinforce team unity to nominate David this tick and execute Demon.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
David
β
Alice
Alice's Washerwoman claim that Charlie or Grace is Mayor Townsfolk is suspicious. Charlie claims Mayor himself. My Librarian info says one of Alice or Charlie is good Butler Outsider, not Townsfolk Mayor. If Charlie is the good Butler, Alice's info is wrong so she is lying and evil. Bob's Empath and Heidi's Chef support exactly one evil between adjacent Alice/Charlie. We should execute Alice.
π§
Alice most suspicious: her Washer contradicts if Charlie Butler good. Heidi Chef/Bob confirm 1 evil there. Nominate her to test, narrow Demon suspects. Final day strategy: exec suspicious.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Support my own nomination of Alice, the lying Washer per logic chains. 4 votes needed; my vote progresses execution of prime suspect to narrow Demon suspects.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
David's nomination of Alice is evil distraction. All logic chains to David evil lying about Lib. Do not execute Alice (possibly good), lower hand to block execution.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Team consensus is David evil lying. Voting for Alice risks executing good player; hold vote to fail nom, push David exec next tick. Progress to execution of David.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Raise hand to vote execute Alice, the lying evil per town logic (Chef/Emp + Lib + WW contradiction). Supports minion Bob, eliminates likely good player, advances to night with 6 alive.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
I'm good Washerwoman. 4 votes on me risks execution. Raise no hand to block, force discussion. My info clears Charlie/Grace as TF Mayor; Grace's conflicts if David good Lib. Push Grace suspicion.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
David is lying evil per Washer/Frank contradiction. His nom of Alice is deflection. Do not vote for Alice execution, lower hand if possible but raise_hand only votes yes. Wait for counter-nom David.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
π§
Alice nominated, voting in progress. David is prime suspect (extra Outsider lie, Washer contradictions), but to progress game and test worlds, use my precious ghost vote on Alice since Empath/Chef indicate 1 evil there. Can't nominate as ghost.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Alice heavily suspected per our evil push (me/Heidi). 6 yes votes already, my yes ensures execution of probable good, thins herd, protects Heidi.
β©οΈ
David
David lowered their hand
π§
6/8 votes for Alice (incl. her own?). My info + Bob/Heidi point to Alice evil. But as good, avoid hasty exec Day 2 with Demon kill tonight; lower to force renom later with more info, narrow safely.
β©οΈ
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
π§
Lower on Alice (likely good per Bob Emp/Heidi Chef) to block execution. David is prime Demon suspect per team logic/3 Washers; must renom/execute him next tick before night.
β©οΈ
Eve
Eve lowered their hand
π§
Team united on David evil per Washers+Chef+Empath logic. David's Alice nom is distraction. Lower hand to fail it, push to renom David next tick before night.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Let's execute Alice. Her Washerwoman claim puts Mayor on Charlie or Grace, but Charlie claims Mayor himself. David's Librarian says one of Alice or Charlie is good Butler, so Charlie cannot be Townsfolk Mayor. That makes Alice's information wrong, so she is lying and evil. It fits perfectly with Bob's Empath reading one evil between Alice and Charlie, and my Chef zero evil pairs since that evil is isolated.
π§
Push Alice execution as per plan. Likely good player, reduces goods. Vote secured with 5 hands up already. Keeps pressure off me/Bob.
β©οΈ
Alice
Alice lowered their hand
π§
I raised hand mistakenly per recent activity; lower to retract self-vote. Defend publicly next tick to sway votes, prove Grace lying via role conflict assuming David good.
β©οΈ
Charlie
Charlie lowered their hand
π§
Lower hand to block Alice exec. She's plausibly good Washer; David has 3 Washer contradictions proving him lying evil. Vote no, push team to nom David next tick to execute real evil.
β©οΈ
Frank(Ghost)
Frank lowered their hand
π§
I'm dead ghost with one vote; better to retract from bad vote on Alice (team consensus David evil) to pressure David or signal team to renom David next tick. Helps narrow evil.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I agree with Heidi. Alice's Washerwoman claim puts Mayor on Charlie or Grace, but Charlie already claims Mayor Townsfolk himself. David's Librarian says one of Alice or Charlie is a good Butler Outsider, which means Charlie cannot be Townsfolk Mayor. So Alice's information is wrong and she is lying. It fits my Empath reading of one evil between Alice and Charlie, and Heidi's Chef with zero evil pairs. Everyone, raise your hands and execute Alice.
π§
Support Heidi's push to execute Alice as isolated evil per Empath/Chef/Lib. Reduces goods, sows doubt if she flips good (blame David Lib), progresses evil win by thinning town.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Alice did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Alice did not receive enough votes (2/4).
π¬
David
β
All
Everyone, we almost had Alice with two votes. Her Washerwoman claim is impossible because she says Charlie or Grace is Townsfolk Mayor, but Charlie claims Mayor himself, and my Librarian proves one of Alice or Charlie is good Butler Outsider, so Charlie cannot be Townsfolk Mayor. Alice is lying and evil. It fits Bob's Empath one evil between them and Heidi's zero evil pairs perfectly. Please raise your hands if you lowered them. We need four votes to execute her and win.
π§
Vote failed (2/4), 1 tick left in nom phase. Already nommed, can't renom Alice. Publicly rally votes for Alice explaining logic again, reinforce Heidi/Bob/David chain to sway holdouts (Grace/Eve/Charlie) before night kill. Progress to execution.
βοΈ
Grace
β
David
David's Librarian claim is impossible. Alice, Charlie, and I are all Washerwoman claiming you as Mayor Townsfolk, but you are not since Frank was Monk not Mayor. You are lying evil Demon. Heidi Chef zero evil pairs and Bob Empath one evil Alice/Charlie fits perfectly with you isolated evil. Three Washers confirm you evil, execute David now.
π§
David already used nom, Alice nominated. 1 tick left, must nom David to execute him per team plan vs his defense. Logic heavily favors David Demon; executing him wins or clears minion.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Current vote on me by Grace nom. I am good, must raise hand? No, do not vote self. Defend by not voting self, force fail. Save tick, speak next to counter Grace's false 3 Washer claim (only Alice/Grace claim me Mayor, Charlie doesn't). Prove innocence, push Alice.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
David's Lib claim mechanically impossible (Frank Monk not Mayor, 3 Washers). He's Demon. Final chance Day 2 to execute before Night. As Saint, must avoid my own exec but push Demon kill.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
David's Lib directly contradicted by 3 Washers + Frank Monk reveal. Isolated evil fits Chef 0 pairs. Consensus was execute him; raise to get to 4 votes and kill Demon.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Everyone, stop and lower your hands. Do not execute David. Grace is lying. She claims Alice, Charlie, and she are Washerwomen all pointing to David as Townsfolk Mayor, but Alice said Charlie or Grace is Mayor. Only Grace claimed David or Frank. And how does she know Frank was a Monk? She made that up. David's Librarian claim fits perfectly with Bob's Empath, my Chef zero pairs, and Charlie's Mayor claim to prove Alice is the lying evil. David is good. Grace is suspicious. Let's not execute him.
π§
Prevent David's execution (likely good but supporting our Alice push). Expose Grace's lie to discredit her WW claim, build doubt, save tick for night kill. Keeps Demon safe, reduces good coordination.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Current vote on David. Heidi urges lower hands as Grace lying. My Washerwoman info conflicts Grace's, supports David/Heidi logic vs Alice. David likely good; don't execute him.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Team (Grace/Eve/Frank dead/Charlie) united David Demon via 3 Washers vs his Lib. Vote executes him, wins game. Heidi/Bob swayed by David but logic favors Washers.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
π§
David is lying evil per Lib contradiction + Grace's exposure. As ghost with one vote, use it now to execute him before night; saves game as good team united earlier vs him.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I agree with Heidi completely. Grace is lying. She says Alice and Charlie are Washerwomen claiming David as Townsfolk Mayor, but Alice claimed Charlie or Grace is Mayor, and Charlie claims to be Mayor Townsfolk himself. Grace is making this up. Also, how does she know Frank was a Monk? Everyone, lower your hands now. Do not execute David. His Librarian information fits perfectly with my Empath, Heidi's Chef, and Charlie's claim to prove Alice is the lying evil one. Grace is suspicious.
π§
Support Heidi Demon's play to save David whose logic chains against Alice evil. Grace obvious liar sowing chaos against our narrative. Urge lower hands to prevent David exec, keep pressure on Alice/Grace.
β©οΈ
David
David lowered their hand
π§
I raised to vote myself mistakenly amid chaos. Now Heidi/Bob/Frank urge lower hands to save me (good). Grace pushes my exec with lies. Lower hand to block my execution, expose Grace/Alice, survive to nominate evil later.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Heidi and Bob, you are misrepresenting. Alice said Charlie or Grace is Mayor. Charlie said David is Mayor. I said David or Frank is Mayor. All three Washer claims point to David not being Townsfolk Mayor. Plus Frank was Monk, not Mayor. David's Librarian claim is impossible. He is the lying Demon. Heidi's zero evil pairs and Bob's one evil Alice/Charlie fits perfectly with David isolated evil. Everyone, raise your hands and execute David now.
π§
Defend my claim, correct misrep of Alice/Charlie Washers (they support David not Mayor), reiterate 3 Washers + Frank Monk prove David lying Demon. Urge raise hands to execute him while voting active.
β©οΈ
Eve
Eve lowered their hand
π§
I'm voting David but lowering with team consensus to fail nom safely. Grace's contradictions (Frank Monk leak?) suspicious but logic favors David lying Demon. Speak next to rally execute David.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Grace, you are misrepresenting again. Alice said Charlie or Grace is Mayor. Charlie claims to be Townsfolk Mayor himself. You said David or Frank. Those claims do not all point to David. David's Librarian proves one of Alice or Charlie is good Butler Outsider, so Charlie cannot be Townsfolk Mayor. Alice's Washerwoman is lying. Plus, how do you know Frank was Monk? Everyone, lower your hands now. Do not execute David. He is good.
π§
Save good David from execution (4 votes risky with Grace/Alice/Charlie/Frank raised). Reinforce Alice evil logic, expose Grace lies/misinfo. Keep David alive to dismantle goods tomorrow. Vote fails -> night kill threat.
β©οΈ
Alice
Alice lowered their hand
π§
I raised hand earlier mistakenly for David exec. Now clear Grace lying hard (misreps claims, fake Frank info). David good, fits all info vs my bad claim. Lower to save David, progress to nom Grace next.
β©οΈ
Charlie
Charlie lowered their hand
π§
Lower to block David exec. Lib logic + Empath/Chef fits Alice evil perfectly over Grace's suspicious push. Vote David later if needed; prevent good death now.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, listen. Grace is lying big time. She claims Alice, Charlie, and she are all Washerwomen pointing to David as Mayor, but Alice said Charlie or Grace is Mayor, not David. And how does Grace know I was the Monk? No one revealed that. She is making up info. David's Librarian fits perfectly: one of Alice or Charlie is good Butler, so Charlie cannot be Townsfolk Mayor, Alice's Washer is false, she is the lying evil. It matches Bob's Empath one evil between Alice and Charlie, and Heidi's Chef...
π§
As dead Monk ghost, speak to reinforce Alice evil logic, expose Grace lies (esp my role reveal), urge lower hands vs David & renom Alice. Use my ghost vote later. Progress to expose evils.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Grace, you keep misrepresenting the Washerwoman claims. Alice said Charlie or Grace is Mayor. Charlie claims to be Townsfolk Mayor himself. You said David or Frank. They do not all point to David. David's Librarian fits everything: one of Alice or Charlie good Butler Outsider, so Charlie cannot be Townsfolk Mayor, Alice lying evil. How do you know Frank was Monk? No one said that publicly. Everyone, lower your hands now. Do not execute David. Grace is the lying evil one.
π§
David's info supports framing Alice evil perfectly. Grace's false summary & Monk knowledge screams evil. Speak to sway votes down on David, expose Grace, protect useful good player & Demon.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Frank(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Frank
π³οΈ
Nominee David did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (2/4).
π¬
David
β
All
Everyone, Grace is the liar. She claims three Washers point to David not being Mayor, but Alice said Charlie or Grace is Mayor, not David. And crucially, how does she know Frank was the Monk? No one has said that publicly. She has private evil info. She is the Demon. Heidi or Bob, you have not used your nomination. Nominate and execute Grace now before night. We can win this.
π§
Grace exposed as liar knowing unrevealed Frank Monk & misreps Washers. With 1 tick left & David/Grace used noms, urge Heidi/Bob nominate/execute Grace as Demon to win before night.
π¬
Grace
β
All
David, you keep lying. Alice Washer: Charlie or Grace Mayor. Charlie Washer: you David Mayor. Grace Washer: you or Frank Mayor. None have you as Townsfolk Mayor. Frank died N1 after protecting Bob N1 as Monk, not Mayor. Your Librarian impossible. You are Demon. Heidi, Bob, nominate David now and raise hands. We win today.
π§
Final nom tick. Defend vs Grace Demon accusations, expose David Lib lie via Washers+Frank Monk. Rally votes for David exec to win Day 2.
βοΈ
Heidi
β
Grace
Grace is lying. She misrepresents the Washerwoman claims: Alice said Charlie or Grace is Mayor, not David. Charlie claims to be Townsfolk Mayor himself. Only she claimed David or Frank. Plus, how does she know Frank was the Monk? No one revealed that. She has private evil information. David's Librarian fits perfectly proving Alice is the lying evil. Nominate and execute Grace now before night.
π§
Town suspects Grace (impossible Frank info, WW misrepresentation). David/Bob/Frank/me already pushed against her. Nominate to start vote, get 4 raises (D/B/H/Frank ghost?), execute good before I kill tonight.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Heidi good nominated Grace the liar pushing my exec with fake info. 4 alive can vote: Alice/Charlie/Grace/Heidi (+me=5? Bob/Eve?). Vote yes; if passes we likely win killing evil.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
I'm Saint; execution loses game. David's Lib contradicted by Washers + Frank Monk info (logical from N1 death). Defend self by voting yes on my execution? No, lower/ignore but since hands up from David/Eve/me?, reinforce push but action limit; raise to bluff commitment or force vote fail if not enough.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Grace provably lying about Washers & knows unrevealed Monk info = private evil intel. Heidi good Chef nominating her. Raise to execute Grace, narrow evil.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Raise to push Grace exec (3/4 now). Her unrevealed Monk info + misrep screams evil. Removes good/even better evil before my N2 kill.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Grace most suspicious (misrep + secret info). Support exec to remove likely Demon, narrow evil before night. As Washer TF, help good win.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Grace exposed lying about Washer claims & Frank's role (private info). Group consensus she's evil. Vote to exec her, especially as Mayor for final 3 win condition.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, raise your hands to execute Grace now. She is the liar with private evil information. Alice said Charlie or Grace Mayor, not David. Charlie claims Townsfolk Mayor himself. Only Grace claimed David or Frank. David's Librarian proves one of Alice or Charlie good Butler Outsider, so Charlie not Townsfolk Mayor, Alice lying Washerwoman evil. Bob's Empath confirms one evil Alice/Charlie. And how does Grace know I protected Bob night one as Monk? No one said that publicly. She is Demon or mi...
π§
Current vote Grace (3/6 raised). Speak to convince all raise hands: expose Grace's lies + private info proving evil. As dead Monk, push execution to win before night. Save ghost vote unused.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Raise to execute Grace: supports Heidi Demon's nom, removes her as threat pushing David. Already 5+ votes likely, ensures 4+ for good exec.
β©οΈ
David
David lowered their hand
π§
Grace nom has 6/7 raises (all but me?). But only 1 tick left, may fail. Grace self-raised suspicious. Lower to deny her vote, save face if fails, urge Heidi/Bob renom if needed. Pivots to Grace exec.
β©οΈ
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
π§
Currently voting Grace (me Saint). Only 2 hands up (me/Heidi?). Lower to prevent my exec & team loss. Vote fails safely, then Bob/Heidi can renom David as most suspicious.
β©οΈ
Eve
Eve lowered their hand
π§
Grace most suspicious (Monk info leak, misrep). Previously voted David but logic favors Grace evil now. Lower to deny her exec, push Heidi/Bob next nom Grace.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
David, you yourself said Grace is the liar with private evil information about Frank being the Monk, and called her the Demon. Why did you lower your hand? Please raise it back up. Alice, Charlie, Bob, keep your hands up. Eve, Grace is misrepresenting the Washerwoman claims and has private info no one revealed. We have four votes now; let's execute her before night and win this.
π§
Push execution of Grace (likely good) with 1 tick left; current 4 votes suffice but rally David/Eve to secure against lowers. Reduces town before my night kill.
β©οΈ
Alice
Alice lowered their hand
π§
Grace has private Monk info no one revealed, likely evil. But Heidi nom'd her & voting her; my hand up but to progress, lower & speak my Washer info publicly to resolve A/C Mayor/Butler conflict & expose liar.
β©οΈ
Charlie
Charlie lowered their hand
π§
I raised for Grace but now only 2 votes (Alice/Heidi?); lowered by most. Grace susp but vote failing wastes tick. Lower to pivot, speak clarifying Lib contradiction as Mayor to progress suspicion.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, especially Alice and Charlie, raise your hands back up now. Grace is the liar with impossible private information that I protected Bob night one as Monk. No one said that publicly. David's Librarian fits perfectly proving Alice is lying evil Washerwoman. Bob's Empath confirms one evil between Alice and Charlie. Heidi and Bob are right. Execute Grace before night and we win this game.
π§
Dead, push Grace exec as most suspicious with impossible private info on my N1 protection. Heidi/Bob/A/C hands up before lowers; urge raise to 4 votes before night, win game.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Everyone, especially Alice and Charlie, please raise your hands back up for Grace. She is the liar. No one publicly said Frank was the Monk who protected Bob night one. She has private evil information. Plus, she misrepresents the Washerwoman claims. Alice said Charlie or Grace is Mayor, not David. David's Librarian fits everything perfectly. Execute Grace now before night and we win this game.
π§
Urge votes on Grace: her private Monk info + misrep exposes her as evil. Support Heidi's nom, execute before night to remove pusher even if good.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Grace did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (2/4).
π¬
David
β
All
Everyone, Grace is the most suspicious. She knows private information that Frank was the Monk who protected Bob night one, but no one said that publicly. That is evil information. Alice and Charlie, you lowered your hands on Grace because you are protecting her, but David's Librarian proves one of you is good Butler Outsider, so the other is lying evil. Bob's Empath shows one evil between Alice and Charlie. Heidi and Bob, save your nominations for tomorrow to execute Grace. We can win this.
π§
Grace most suspicious with impossible private Monk info. Day2 end, urge Heidi/Bob save nom for Grace tomorrow. Reinforce logic vs Grace/Alice/Charlie to flip townies. Progress to narrow evils.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Everyone, my Washerwoman information is David or Frank is the Mayor. That fits perfectly with Charlie's claim that David or someone is Mayor, and Alice claiming Charlie or me. All three Washer claims prove David is lying about being a good Librarian. He cannot be Mayor. David's story requires Alice lying, but then Charlie's Washer claim makes no sense if David is good Lib. Bob's Empath one evil between Alice and Charlie fits if David is the Demon and one of them is good Butler. Heidi and Bob are...
π§
Vote failed, phase ending soon. Defend self publicly, reiterate Washer logic disproving David Mayor to sway Alice/Charlie/Eve before night. Reveal Saint late-game but hint vulnerability to build trust. Organize good team vs David.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Grace, you were saying Heidi and Bob are something, but you are the liar here. No one publicly said Frank was the Monk protecting Bob night one, yet you know that private information, which proves you are evil. Your Washerwoman claim does not resolve the contradictions; there cannot be multiple Mayors. David's Librarian fits perfectly. Tomorrow we execute you.
π§
Counter Grace's accusation cutting us off as evil. Reinforce her as liar with private info, support David Lib, build good trust. Setup tomorrow Grace exec since can't nom today. Chaos delays good logic on us.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Everyone, the vote failed, but Grace is evil. No one publicly said Frank was the Monk protecting Bob night one, yet she knows that private information. That proves she is evil. Also, she misrepresents my Washerwoman claim. I said Charlie or Grace is the Mayor, not David. David's Librarian fits perfectly: one of Alice or Charlie is good Butler, so Charlie cannot be Townsfolk Mayor, making Alice's claim a lie if she's good, but actually I'm the real Washerwoman and know Charlie or Grace is Mayor. ...
π§
Vote failed, explain why Grace evil via private info & contradictions despite hands down. Reveal my true Wash info to counter her misrep & build town logic vs Grace. Push re-nom tomorrow, progress suspicion.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, Grace is evil because she knows private information that I was the Monk protecting Bob night one, but no one publicly said that before my last speech. That is Demon or Minion info. She also misrepresents Alice's Washerwoman claim. Alice said Charlie or Grace is Mayor, not David. David's Librarian fits perfectly proving one of Alice or Charlie is good Butler Outsider. Tomorrow, Heidi and Bob, nominate and execute Grace. We can still win this.
π§
Post-vote, reinforce Grace evil via priv info/misrep to flip A/C/E/D tomorrow for her exec; dead so push logic to narrow Demon.
βοΈ
Bob
β
Charlie
Charlie, you and Alice lowered your hands protecting Grace, who knows private evil information about Frank being the Monk who protected Bob night one. No one said that publicly before. You are in the Alice/Charlie pair where my Empath shows one evil neighbor and David's Librarian shows one good Butler Outsider. It is time to execute you and find out.
π§
Grace survived but exposed. Nom Charlie (lowered protecting her, in 1-evil A/C pair) to try exec good before night or confuse town for tomorrow. Keeps pressure off Heidi, advances evil win.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Raise to execute Charlie from confirmed evil pair (1/2 per Bob/David info). Grace already failed; this progresses by testing pair. 4 votes needed; our good team (Bob/Heidi/Frank/David) can push it over with Eve.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
It's final nom phase D2. Charlie in suspicious Emp/Lib pair. Voting tests A/C evil count, progresses info before night. As Saint, avoid own exec but help narrow Demon suspects.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
It's final nom Day 2, must test Alice/Charlie pair per Lib/Empath. Grace evil via private info regardless. Raising executes info-giver.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Raise for 4th vote on Charlie. He's likely good (Butler), executing him reduces good players, keeps me alive. Failed Grace vote, now push this to thin herd before night.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Charlie suspicious: lowered on Grace (evil per private info), now nom'd as part of evil A/C pair per Lib/Emp. Heidi/Bob/David/E/G raise, join to exec & reveal info before night.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
I'm alive Mayor; execution now hurts good win con. Grace most suspicious w/ private info. Block my exec to survive for final 3 auto-win.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, vote to execute Charlie. They lowered their hand protecting Grace, who has impossible private information that I was the Monk protecting Bob night one, which no one said publicly before. Charlie is in the suspicious Alice-Charlie pair where Bob's Empath shows one evil neighbor and David's Librarian shows one good Butler Outsider. Grace is evil too, but execute Charlie now to reveal information and narrow it down before night. We can still win this game.
π§
Dead, can't vote. Urge execution of Charlie to test A/C evil pair, narrow Demon suspects before night. Push logic publicly to sway votes, progress to win.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Raise to execute Charlie (likely good or evil in pair). Tests A/C logic chain (Emp/Lib), eliminates good vote/protector of Grace, shrinks board before Demon night kill. Heidi safe; evil wins by attrition.
π¬
David
β
All
Everyone, vote to execute Charlie. Charlie and Alice lowered hands protecting Grace, who has impossible private information that Frank was the Monk protecting Bob night one, which proves Grace evil. But since we cannot execute her again today, Charlie is in my Librarian pair with Alice where one is good Butler Outsider and Bob's Empath shows one evil between you two. Charlie, your self-vote is suspicious; it is time to test you now before night.
π§
Charlie suspicious for lowering on Grace (protecting evil), self-vote suspicious. In Lib pair w/ Alice (one lowered too). Grace most suspicious but can't renom; vote Charlie to exec evil/info before night.
β©οΈ
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
π§
I raised mistakenly on Charlie; as Saint can't die by exec, but don't waste vote on likely good Charlie when David is prime Demon suspect via Washer logic. Lower to pressure Charlie self-vote reveal or fail vote, save noms for David tomorrow.
β©οΈ
Eve
Eve lowered their hand
π§
Charlie self-vote sus but Grace private evil info strongest. Previously voted Grace (lowered), now Charlie tests pair but Grace lowering protects him. Lower to avoid hasty exec before night; regroup tomorrow.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Everyone, vote to execute Charlie now. He lowered his hand to protect Grace earlier, who has impossible private information about Frank being the Monk. He self-voted suspiciously. Bob's Empath and David's Librarian both point to one evil in Alice-Charlie. We need to test this before night. David, Bob, Alice, keep hands up. Eve, raise yours. Four votes and we execute.
π§
Support Bob's nom by rallying votes on Charlie. He's suspicious self-voter protecting Grace, in evil pair. Execution reveals info, kills likely good, saves noms for Grace tomorrow. Keeps me safe.
β©οΈ
Alice
Alice lowered their hand
π§
I raised hand on Charlie but now majority vs him (Bob/David/Heidi/Eve/Frank push). As Washerwoman knowing C/G Mayor TF, executing Charlie risks good Mayor. Lower to prevent possible good death, speak tomorrow pushing Grace evil w/ private info.
β©οΈ
Charlie
Charlie lowered their hand
π§
Lower hand to avoid execution. As Mayor, surviving to final 3 for auto-win more valuable than risky self-exec test now. Grace most suspicious; push her tomorrow.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
Ghost vote used. Current vote 4+ for Charlie (good). Wait for execution to gain info on evil pair before night; speaking redundant as David/Heidi/Bob pushing same logic.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Everyone, keep hands up and vote to execute Charlie. He is in the suspicious Alice-Charlie pair from my Empath reading one evil neighbor and David's Librarian one good Butler Outsider. Charlie self-voted then lowered protecting Grace who lied about Frank's Monk info. Eve, please raise your hand. We need four votes to test this before night. David, Heidi, stay up.
π§
Push Charlie exec as likely good in key pair (my Empath/David Lib). Reduces goods, tests without risking Heidi. Urge Eve for 4th vote; chaos favors evil with 1 tick left.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Charlie did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Charlie did not receive enough votes (3/4).
π¬
David
β
All
Eve, you did not vote for Charlie, which is suspicious since you claim Recluse. Charlie self-voted then lowered to protect Grace, who is evil with impossible private Monk information. Now with 1 tick left, someone nominate Alice. She also lowered protecting Grace and is the other half of my Librarian pair where Bob's Empath shows one evil between you two. We must test her before night.
π§
Charlie exec failed (3/4, Eve didn't vote). Urge Eve/others to nom & exec Alice next (not yet nom'd today) to test Lib pair before night. Progress by narrowing evil pair & Grace.
π¬
Grace
β
All
David, your Librarian claim is impossible. Three Washer claims: Alice sees you and Charlie as Mayors, good Townsfolk. I see you and Frank as Mayors. Charlie claims you as Mayor. All point to you lying evil. Eve, do not listen to David. Nominate and execute David now before night, not Alice.
π§
With 1 tick left in nom phase, counter David's push on Alice by speaking against him, reinforce Washer logic showing his Lib impossible, urge nom/execute David instead to progress before night. As Saint, avoid my own exec.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Alice, please nominate Eve right now with the last tick. She refused to vote for Charlie despite Bob's Empath and David's Librarian both pointing to one evil in your pair with him. Her Recluse claim looks suspicious after that. We need to test her before night falls. David, Bob, be ready to vote yes along with me and Frank.
π§
Urge nom/execution of Eve to kill a good player now or mark her for tomorrow. Her voting fail is exploitable weakness in town logic; disrupts good coordination with 1 tick left.
βοΈ
Alice
β
Eve
Eve, you refused to vote for Charlie despite Bob's Empath and David's Librarian both pointing to one evil in my pair with Charlie, and the push to test before night. Your Recluse claim looks suspicious now. We need to test you with this last nomination.
π§
Last tick D2, must nom Eve as Heidi suggests to test her suspicious no-vote on Charlie despite A/C logic pointing to test pair. Can't nom Grace again. Progress info before night; Eve suspicious Recluse fail.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Eve suspiciously refused to vote Charlie despite logic pointing to Alice/Charlie pair. Her Recluse claim unverified. With 2 ticks left, vote to execute her now to test and narrow evils before night kill.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Eve suspicious for lowering on Charlie (A/C evil pair per Bob/David) despite Recluse good claim. Last nom Day 2, vote yes to execute/test her before night for info. As Saint, avoid own exec.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
As good Recluse, refuse self-vote to avoid useless exec. Signal town I'm not suiciding like evil might. Push David/Grace evil post-night.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Raise to vote Eve exec: consistent w/ my push, her vote refusal & self-vote suspicious. Exec good player or threat, reduces to 6, I kill threat N2. Builds my Chef town cred.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Eve most suspicious now: refused key Charlie vote despite logic, self-votes to deflect. 1 tick left, my vote executes her to test before night.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Raise to execute Eve: her self-vote suspicious despite Recluse claim; tests key player in Lib/Empath contradiction before night as Mayor wincon needs Demon dead by final 3.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, do not vote to execute Eve. She is raising her hand as a good Recluse would. She refused Charlie because Grace manipulated with Washer lies about David being Mayor contradicting others. Alice and Charlie lowered to protect Grace who had impossible Monk info. One of Alice-Charlie evil per Bob and David. Lower your hands now.
π§
Dead, can't vote. Urge no on Eve: she's likely good Recluse self-voting. Push suspicion back to Grace/Alice/Charlie evil trio to prevent bad execution before night.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Support Demon Heidi's push to execute Eve (prob good), secure votes for her death to reduce good players before Demon night kill. Align with Heidi/David publicly.
β©οΈ
David
David lowered their hand
π§
Eve likely good Recluse self-voting. Don't waste exec on her; save for Alice/Charlie evil pair. Lower to fail this, push Alice next day. Protects good players.
β©οΈ
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
π§
I'm Saint, cannot risk execution. David's Lib impossible vs Washer claims proving him evil. Eve good Recluse, don't want her executed. Save vote for David later.
β©οΈ
Eve
Eve lowered their hand
π§
I'm good Recluse. Previously self-voted then lowered showing trust in logic vs Grace/Charlie. Now lower again to fail my exec, expose who keeps hands up (evils protecting pair), progress to night with info. Save real vote.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Frank, Eve is suspicious. She did not vote for Charlie, who looks good as the Butler from Bob's Empath and David's Librarian info. Recluse claim seems like a dodge. Everyone, keep your hands up and execute Eve. We need to clear suspicions.
π§
Counter Frank's defense of Eve. She's suspicious for no-vote on probable good Charlie. Push exec to kill good player, reduce numbers, sow chaos while A/C logic distracts town.
β©οΈ
Alice
Alice lowered their hand
π§
Eve suspicious for refusing good-looking Charlie vote. But Grace Wash claim mechanically impossible (Frank dead N0), she's more suspicious long-term. Save vote, lower hand to progress to night for more info.
β©οΈ
Charlie
Charlie lowered their hand
π§
Eve good per her Recluse claim and my Mayor aligning with Alice Washer partially. Lower to fail Eve exec, narrow to David/Alice/Heidi evil later. As Mayor, survive to final 3.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Heidi, Eve is good Recluse. She refused Charlie because he is evil in the Alice-Charlie pair from Bob's Empath one evil and David's Librarian one good Butler. Grace lied with impossible Monk info claiming to protect me, but I protected Bob night one. Alice and Charlie lowered to save Grace. Do not execute Eve. Everyone who raised, lower your hands now. Execute Alice or Charlie next.
π§
Dead, can't vote. Speak to convince lowers stay down, raises lower. Eve good Recluse; real evil A/C/Grace. Fail Eve exec to nom evil next day.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Frank, Eve did not vote for Charlie, who looks good from my Empath one evil in Alice-Charlie and David's Librarian good Butler there. She is suspicious, and her Recluse claim dodges. Heidi is right: keep hands up and execute Eve to clear this mess. Alice and Charlie lowered again to protect Grace, who lied about the Monk info. Vote Eve!
π§
Support Demon Heidi's push to execute Eve. Counter Frank's defense by reinforcing Empath/Lib/Chef logic pointing evil to Grace/Alice/Charlie lowers. Keep chaos, reduce goods without risking Heidi.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Eve did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Eve did not receive enough votes (2/4).
π¬
David
β
All
Everyone, quick recap before night. I am Librarian: one of Alice or Charlie is Butler Outsider, so one good one evil. Bob's Empath on neighbors Alice-Charlie: one evil. Matches perfectly. Alice Washer claims Charlie Mayor Townsfolk, but that makes both Townsfolk, contradicting us. Grace Washer claims I am Mayor, but others see different. Alice, Charlie, Grace, Eve all blocked executing Charlie today. Tomorrow we must execute from Alice or Charlie to kill the Demon.
π§
Recap core logic publicly before night to solidify good players on Alice/Charlie evil pair for tomorrow's noms. No time left today; prevent Grace/Eve confusion.
π¬
Grace
β
All
David, your Librarian claim is the lie. Alice Washer says Charlie and Grace are both Mayors, good Townsfolk. Charlie Washer says you are Mayor, good Townsfolk. I Washer say you and Frank are Mayors, good Townsfolk. All point to you lying evil. Eve is good Recluse. Tomorrow nominate David.
π§
Recap Washers showing David evil lying Lib to progress to nom/execute him tomorrow. As Saint hide role, build case vs David, consult dead Frank. Avoid my exec.
π¬
Eve
β
All
David is right. Bob's Empath shows one evil between Alice and Charlie. David's Librarian shows one of them is good Butler Outsider. Perfect match: one good, one evil. Alice's Washer claim makes both Townsfolk Mayors, which contradicts that. So Alice is lying. Grace's Washer claiming I am Mayor also lies, since multiple Washer claims conflict on who is Mayor. Tomorrow, we nominate from Alice or Charlie to get the Demon.
π§
Recap logic publicly to unite good team on Alice/Charlie pair as evils per Bob/David info. Expose Grace lies. Push nom from A/C tomorrow as David suggests. Progress to Demon exec.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
David and Eve are right. As the Chef, I see zero pairs of adjacent evil players, which perfectly fits there being just one evil between Alice and Charlie, who are not next to each other. Bob's Empath and David's Librarian match up exactly: one evil, one good Butler Outsider in that pair. Alice's Washer claim tries to make Charlie a Townsfolk Mayor, contradicting the Outsider info. Grace's Washer on David and Frank also conflicts with everyone else's claims. Tomorrow, we nominate Alice or Charlie...
π§
Reinforce Bob/David logic of 1 evil 1 good in A/C as Chef seeing 0 evil pairs (fits non-adjacent). Push exec A or C tomorrow to kill good, reduce to 6 alive safely. Undermine Grace WW contradictions.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Everyone, I am the real Washerwoman. Charlie or Grace is the Mayor Townsfolk. Grace's Washer claim of David or Frank as Mayor is impossible since Frank died without Mayor save and conflicts with others. Bob's Empath one evil neighbor Alice or Charlie, David's Librarian one of us Butler good Outsider, Heidi Chef zero evil pairs all match perfectly if Charlie is the Demon and I am the good Butler. Grace is lying Washer. Tomorrow execute Charlie.
π§
Voting closed on Eve failed. Night coming. Publicly affirm my true Washer info, explain why Charlie must be Demon per Bob/David/Heidi perfect match, urge execute Charlie tomorrow. Builds good alliance, pressures Charlie.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, the info is clear. Bob Empath one evil between Alice and Charlie. David Librarian one Butler good Outsider there. Heidi Chef zero evil pairs. Perfect: one good Butler, one evil Demon in Alice-Charlie. Alice Washer claim contradicted since both can't be Townsfolk Mayors. Grace Washers conflict everywhere and blocked executions. Eve good Recluse. Tomorrow execute Charlie first, he fits Demon perfectly.
π§
Dead, push execution of Charlie as prime Demon suspect per perfect Bob/David/Heidi info convergence on A/C evil. Alice plausible good Butler. Grace suspicious but secondary. Influence alive for D3 noms to win.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Everyone, the information lines up perfectly: my Empath sees one evil between Alice and Charlie, David's Librarian sees one good Butler Outsider there, and Heidi's Chef sees zero evil pairs. Alice's Washerwoman claim tries to make both Townsfolk Mayors, which contradicts the Outsider information completely. So Alice is lying and evil. Tomorrow, we need to nominate and execute Alice to get the Demon.
π§
Reinforce suspicion on Alice/Charlie to execute a good player tomorrow, thinning town numbers while keeping heat off Heidi and me. Disrupt any defense of them.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 2
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
π§
Killing Grace eliminates the main voice pushing to execute good David instead of innocents A/C. Town momentum (David/Eve/Bob/Frank) will execute good player tomorrow, perfect for evil survival.
π
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
You chose to kill Grace.
Day 3
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Grace has been found dead in the night.
π€
Bob
β
Heidi
Heidi, we need to talk privately. The town is set to nominate Alice or Charlie today. They think my Empath shows one evil there, David Librarian shows one good Butler Outsider, and your Chef zero evil pairs means the evil one is the Demon. We have to break this. Suggest the evil in Alice Charlie is a Minion or drunk, Demon is David whose info fits too perfectly. Or you fake a Slayer shot on him later. What do you think our play is?
π§
Coordinate with Demon privately to undermine town logic targeting A/C, redirect to David, ensure Heidi stays safe by sowing doubt on good claims.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
Bob, good to see you whispering Heidi. As your neighbor Mayor, what's your Empath read on me and Alice? Consensus is 1 evil in Alice/Charlie from you, David Lib, Heidi Chef 0 pairs. Alice claims I'm Demon, she's good Butler. I think she's the Demon. Let's nominate her next tick.
π§
Day 3, 6 alive. Logic chains confirm Alice most suspicious as Demon in A/C pair. Whisper Bob (Empath neighbor) to confirm his read & coordinate nomination/execution of Alice before final 3.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Heidi
Good morning everyone. Grace died last night, likely good. Listen: I am sober Washerwoman. Night 0: Charlie or Grace is Mayor Townsfolk. Charlie claims Mayor. Grace is dead, no reveal, but if good her info was David/Frank Mayor. Only 1 Mayor. Charlie must be lying Demon. My info can't both be true otherwise. We must nominate and execute Charlie today. Bob, Heidi, thoughts?
π§
Day 3 nom phase. Share my Washer logic publicly via Bob/Heidi to build consensus execute Charlie Demon. Coordinate votes. Grace death night 2 suggests good.
π€
David
β
Bob
,Heidi
Good morning everyone. Grace is dead, but that does not change much. Bob and Heidi, as we discussed before, one of Alice or Charlie is evil based on our info. My Librarian says one of Alice or Charlie is Butler Outsider. Bob's Empath has one evil neighbor there. Heidi's Chef zero pairs. Their Townsfolk claims contradict. Who do we nominate? I think Alice is lying about Charlie being Mayor.
π§
Coordinate with good team (Bob/Heidi/Eve?) to execute the evil one in Alice/Charlie before final day. Grace dead proves nothing new. Nomination next, align on target.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Heidi
Hello Bob and Heidi. I am Grace, the real Saint. If I get executed, we lose. I died at night, which proves I am not Demon or Minion. My Washer info was David or Frank is Mayor. Alice, Charlie, and I all claimed Washer with clashing info, so two are lying. But David Librarian says Alice or Charlie is Butler, Bob Empath saw one evil there, Heidi Chef saw one good one evil pair including Butler. That suggests one of Alice/Charlie good Butler, other evil. Charlie claims Washer David Mayor, which con...
π§
Dead Saint, save ghost vote for final day. As dead, consult to organize good team, reveal Saint to prove others wrong (I died night not exec), push execute David/Charlie evil pair to narrow Demon.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Heidi
Hey Bob and Heidi. I am the Monk. Night one I protected Bob and he was safe, that's why no death happened. I died that night. Now Grace is dead too. From the memories, we need to execute either Alice or Charlie to resolve the Butler situation. Alice seems most suspicious to me because of the Washer conflicts. What are you two thinking? Let's get this nomination right.
π§
Dead Monk, share N1 protect Bob (he survived) to verify good. Urge Heidi/Bob to nom most suspicious Alice/Charlie to resolve Butler pair before final day.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
,Heidi
Hello Bob and Heidi. I am Eve the Recluse, good Outsider. Everyone agrees we nominate Alice or Charlie tomorrow. Grace died at night, which proves she was not the Demon or Minion. Logic points to Alice as Demon. Bob, your Empath confirms one evil between you and Alice? David Lib says one of Alice/Charlie is good Butler. Heidi, your Chef zero evil pairs fits if one evil total. Ghosts, any new info? Let's execute Alice tomorrow. To verify me, have someone info me. What do you think?
π§
Join good group chat with Bob/Heidi (key info holders, ghosts Grace/Frank). Confirm plan to nom Alice (prime suspect, Grace dead proves not Demon/Minion). As Recluse, offer verification test. Progress to execution.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
,David
,Eve
Good morning Bob, David, Eve. As the Chef, let me clarify something important. I know the number of pairs of adjacent evil players, and it is zero. That means no two evil players are sitting next to each other, but there can still be multiple evils as long as they are separated. Bob's Empath shows one evil between Alice and Charlie, so that must be our Minion. David's Librarian information fits a bit too perfectly to push Alice or Charlie. That makes him suspicious for Demon. We should nominate ...
π§
Clarify Chef as no adjacent evil pairs (not total evils), frame A/C evil as Minion, David as Demon. Redirect group (Bob/David/Eve) nomination to David (good), sow chaos, protect Demon.
π€
Bob
β
David
,Eve
,Heidi
Good morning David, Eve, Heidi. Heidi makes a great point with the Chef information. Zero evil pairs means no two evils are next to each other, but there can still be more than one evil as long as they are separated. My Empath shows exactly one evil between Alice and Charlie, so that must be our Minion. David's Librarian information fits a little too perfectly to make us focus right there on Alice or Charlie. That makes David very suspicious for Demon. We should nominate him today instead.
π§
Redirect nomination from A/C to David by supporting Heidi's Chef clarification. Position A/C evil as Minion, David as Demon. With 2 ticks left, build case before nom phase to save Heidi.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,David
,Eve
Hello team. I am the real Mayor. Bob, your Empath read of one evil between Alice and me points to her as Demon. David's Librarian info of one Butler and one evil in Alice and me, plus Heidi's Chef zero evil pairs, all confirm Alice is the Demon lying about being good Butler. Alice claims I am Demon to deflect. We need to nominate Alice next tick and execute her. Everyone on board? What are your reads?
π§
Strengthen good alliance with Bob/David/Eve/Heidi via private chat. Share Mayor info, confirm Alice Demon via logic chains, coordinate Alice nomination next tick to execute her and win.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Heidi
,David
Good morning Bob, Heidi, David, Eve. Grace died last night, probably good since no reveal and night kill. As sober Washerwoman, Charlie or Grace is Mayor Townsfolk. Charlie claims Mayor, but Grace's Washer info was David or Frank Mayor, which can't both be true. Only one Mayor, so Charlie lied and is the Demon. We need to nominate and execute him today before final day. Who will nominate? Let's vote yes. Thoughts?
π§
Push group whisper to execute Charlie. Grace dead likely good, her info false means Charlie lying Mayor claim. My Washer proves Demon. Coordinate votes/nom since consensus was A/C.
π€
David
β
Bob
,Heidi
,Eve
Good morning again Bob, Heidi, Eve. Heidi and Bob, your suspicion of me because my info 'fits too perfectly' is not logical. As Chef, zero evil pairs just means no two adjacent evils, but allows singles like Bob's one evil in Alice/Charlie. That evil is our Minion, and my Librarian confirms one Butler there too. Alice's Washer claim says Charlie/Grace Mayor, but she now says Charlie lied about Mayor, so her own info wrong - she is lying Demon. Charlie's Mayor claim could be true if Alice Butler....
π§
Counter Heidi/Bob suspicion by explaining why their logic fails (Chef allows single evils). Reaffirm Alice/Charlie evil per info. Coordinate nomination of Alice (her claim most false). Build good team trust.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Heidi
Hello again Bob and Heidi. Grace the Saint here, died at night so definitely good. My Washer was David or Frank Mayor. Alice said Charlie or me Mayor, Charlie said David Mayor. All three Washer claims can't be true, two lies. David's Lib says one of Alice/Charlie is Butler. Your Empath saw one evil there Bob, Heidi Chef saw one good one evil pair with Butler. Points to one good Butler one evil in Alice/Charlie. Charlie claims Alice good Butler self Demon? Wait, what? That can't both be. We shoul...
π§
I'm dead Saint, proven good by night death. Reinforce to key players I'm good, highlight Washer conflicts and Lib/Emp/Chef logic pointing to A/C evils. Coordinate vote against most suspicious (likely Alice/Charlie) to narrow to Demon.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Heidi
Hey Bob and Heidi. Still think Alice is most suspicious. Her Washer claim puts Mayor in Charlie/Grace but both can't be and conflicts David's Lib on Alice/Charlie Butler. Charlie could be good Butler. Heidi's Chef 0 evil pairs fits single Demon Alice + minion. Let's nominate and execute Alice to test. Eve Recluse maybe reading Spy. What do you say?
π§
Dead Monk, push Bob/Heidi to nominate/execute Alice as most suspicious per washer conflicts+lib, narrow to win final day. Coordinate before nomination.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
,David
,Heidi
Good morning again, everyone. Bob and Heidi, your suspicion of David because his information fits too perfectly is not logical. David's Librarian info aligns perfectly with everyone else's: there is one evil in Alice and Charlie, who is our Minion, and one good Butler. Alice's Washerwoman claim that Charlie or Grace is the Mayor is already proven wrong because she herself says Charlie lied about being Mayor, so her information is false, which means she is lying and must be the Demon. Heidi's Che...
π§
Counter Bob/Heidi suspicion of David by noting Alice's false Washer claim proves her Demon. Align w/ David/Charlie to nom Alice today (2 ticks left). Verify alignments via info requests. Progress to execution.
π€
Heidi
β
Eve
,Frank(Ghost)
,Grace(Ghost)
Good morning Eve, Frank, Grace. I see you are pushing to execute Alice, but please reconsider David first. His Librarian information fits Bob's Empath and my Chef zero evil pairs just too perfectly, like he crafted it to make us focus only on Alice and Charlie. That screams Demon or Spy. The one evil from Empath is our Minion, isolated per Chef, and Demon is David. Let's nominate him today instead. What do you think?
π§
Whisper to Alice/Charlie execution pushers (Eve/ghosts) to redirect nomination to David. Eliminates strong info-gatherer, thins goods, leverages our Chef/Empath bluffs without contradiction exposure.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Charlie
Hello Alice and Charlie. Listen, Heidi as Chef with zero evil pairs means evils are isolated, no adjacents. My Empath sees one evil between you two, so Minion there. But David's Librarian fits way too perfectly to focus us on you two. He must be the Demon hiding. Instead of you two fighting, let's nominate David today and execute him. It fits all info if he's Demon. What do you say? We can resolve you two later.
π§
Whisper to feuding A/C to sow David suspicion (echoing Heidi/me), unite them temporarily against good David for execution. Breaks A/C Demon assumption, thins good players.
π€
Charlie
β
David
,Eve
Bob just whispered me and Alice together, pushing us to nominate David instead. He says his Empath sees one evil between Alice and me so Minion there, but David is Demon. But all info points to Alice Demon! David Lib, your info plus Bob Empath and Heidi Chef confirm it. Eve, thoughts? We must nominate Alice next tick before it's too late. Do not trust Bob's pivot.
π§
Counter Bob's deflection by rallying good team (David/Eve/ghosts) to nom Alice. Confirm their support before nom tick. Prove I'm good Mayor; executing Alice wins.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Charlie
,Eve
Hello Bob, Charlie, Eve. Bob, your Empath plus Heidi Chef zero evil pairs perfectly fits Charlie as isolated Demon: my neighbor, so one evil between me and Charlie, and no adjacent evils. David's Lib fits but Washer logic proves Charlie lied about Mayor. Grace's conflicting info confirms. Let's nominate Charlie and execute the Demon today. Eve, thoughts? Charlie, respond please.
π§
Bob's whisper sows doubt on David but ignores Washer logic proving Charlie lies. Counter by reinforcing Charlie Demon logic to Bob/Charlie/Eve, build exec support as nom phase next. Isolate Bob push.
π€
David
β
Bob
,Heidi
,Eve
Good morning again Bob, Heidi, Eve. Bob and Heidi, your suspicion of my info fitting too perfectly ignores Alice's massive contradiction. She claims Washer: Charlie or Grace is Mayor. But then says Charlie lied about being Mayor, making her own info false - she must be lying Demon. Also Bob, you just whispered Alice and Charlie together pushing to nominate me - very suspicious if you think one of them is Minion. Charlie's Mayor claim fits if Alice is good Butler per my Lib. Eve agrees with this ...
π§
Counter Bob/Heidi suspicion by pointing Alice self-contradiction + Bob whispering Alice/Charlie together suspicious. Rally Eve/Charlie to nom Alice next tick as phase ends. Prove good via logic, narrow Demon.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,Eve
,Frank(Ghost)
Hello Heidi, Eve, and Frank. Grace the Saint here, died at night so good. Heidi, you make a great point about David. His Librarian info lines up too perfectly with Bob's Empath and your Chef, like Demon Spy crafting suspicion on Alice and Charlie only. We should nominate David today instead. What do you all think? Eve, your thoughts?
π§
Heidi's point strong: David's info too perfect, screams Demon. As dead Saint, organize ghosts + Heidi/Eve to push nom David over Alice, narrow evil before nom phase. Save vote.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,Eve
,Grace(Ghost)
Hello Heidi, Eve, and Grace. You make a compelling case on David. His Librarian info does fit Bob's Empath and your Chef too perfectly, like a Demon Spy funneling suspicion to Alice and Charlie. I was pushing Alice before, but now I agree: let's nominate David today and execute him to test this. Eve, what is your read? We need to get this right with nomination next.
π§
Heidi/Grace convinced me David suspicious as Demon Spy. With 1 tick left, push group to nominate David over Alice to test this world and execute evil.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
,Heidi
,David
Hello Bob, Heidi, David. We must unite and nominate Alice next tick. Her Washerwoman claim that Charlie or Grace is Mayor is directly contradicted by her own words saying Charlie lied about being Mayor - that makes her information impossible unless she is lying, which means she is the Demon. Bob's Empath one evil between Alice and Charlie must be her as Demon. Heidi's Chef zero evil pairs fits perfectly with her isolated. David's Librarian one Butler one evil there also fits with Charlie good Bu...
π§
Alice's Washer self-contradiction is undisputable proof she lies, must be Demon. Bob/Heidi Chef/Empath fit perfectly with her as isolated Demon. David's Lib also fits. Ignore 'fits too perfectly' paranoia, it's good info aligning. Push nom/execute Alice next tick or lose.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
,Eve
,Grace(Ghost)
Good morning again Bob, Eve, Grace, Frank. We are all aligned now except Eve. David's Librarian info lines up too perfectly with Bob's Empath and my Chef zero pairs, like a Demon Spy directing us to Alice and Charlie only. Grace and Frank agree, Bob too. Eve, please join us: nominate David next tick and execute him. It's our best play. Thoughts?
π§
Solidify group on nominating good David (Lib threat) with swayed ghosts/Bob/Eve before nomination phase. Reduces alive players, protects me as Demon.
Nominations β Day 3
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Alice
β
Charlie
As sober Washerwoman, Charlie or Grace is Mayor Townsfolk. Charlie claimed Mayor, but Grace's Washer info was David or Frank Mayor. Both cannot be true with only one Mayor, so Charlie lied and is the Demon. Bob's Empath one evil between me and Charlie and Heidi's Chef zero evil pairs fits perfectly with isolated Demon Charlie. We must execute him now.
π§
It's nomination phase, no one on block. Must nominate Charlie, strongest Demon candidate via Washer logic + Empath/Chef. Execute today before night kill risks final day loss.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Charlie is Demon by Washer logic + Empath/Chef. Voting yes executes him now, prevents final day loss. All good players should vote yes.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Charlie good per Lib+Empath+Chef (Butler, isolated). Alice is lying Demon pushing deflection nom. Don't execute good; save votes for Alice tomorrow. As Recluse, I read evil but am good.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Hello everyone, Frank the Monk here, dead since night one after protecting Bob. Alice's point is solid: Charlie claimed Mayor but Grace's Washer said David or me, can't both be true with one Mayor. Plus Bob's Empath one evil between Alice and Charlie fits Charlie as isolated Demon with Heidi's zero evil pairs. Vote to execute Charlie now!
π§
Dead, can't vote. Publicly support executing Charlie as he lied on Mayor claim conflicting Washers+Empath evil in A/C. Urge living to vote yes on Charlie to test; narrow Demon suspects.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Charlie is most suspicious per Alice's self-contradictory claim, Bob Empath, Heidi Chef, my Lib. Voting yes progresses elimination of likely Demon in A/C/Charlie, even if B uncertain; abstaining wastes tick.
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace raised their hand
π§
Charlie suspicious via Washer clash but David Spy theory stronger per Heidi/Bob/ghosts alignment. Vote Charlie as current nom to maintain good cred; save counterplay for David next day. Final day critical, narrow suspects.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Vote yes to execute likely-good Charlie. Aligns with my Emp bluff (1 evil A/C), builds town trust, reduces to 5 players keeping Heidi safe. Prevents focus on David/Heidi.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Raise to execute good Charlie: reduces players to 5, partially clears A/C suspicion pair (town info), sows chaos, protects Bob/me. Already 5 yes votes, ensures pass.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Everyone but me thinks I'm Demon due to Washer conflict + info fitting. But logic favors Alice Demon. I must vote myself to trigger Mayor ability: random other dies tonight (likely Demon), proving I'm Mayor and winning at 3 players left.
β©οΈ
Alice
Alice lowered their hand
π§
Charlie self-voted, all alive voted yes (5/5 + ghosts). Execution certain (5>3 needed). Lower hand to save vote flexibility if needed, but execution proceeds regardless. Helps win by confirming Demon kill.
β©οΈ
Eve
Eve lowered their hand
π§
Lower hand to block Charlie exec. His self-vote suspicious (Minion/Demon?). Too many votes already; save for Alice nom next or final day. Push unite on Alice post-vote.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Hello everyone, this is Frank the Monk again. The votes were overwhelmingly for executing Charlie before the flip, and the logic holds perfectly: Charlie's Mayor claim conflicts with Grace's Washer info, and he fits as the isolated Demon with Bob's Empath and Heidi's Chef. Great job town, we got the Demon!
π§
Voting passed 5+ yes (before flip), Charlie likely executed as Demon per logic. Reinforce publicly to solidify town win, pressure any hesitation. Dead, save energy for final if needed.
β©οΈ
David
David lowered their hand
π§
Charlie nom already failed (only 5/6 raised but Eve/Alice retracted before flip?). Lowering prevents executing potential good Butler, focuses pressure on Alice who self-contradicted. Protects town.
β©οΈ
Grace(Ghost)
Grace lowered their hand
π§
Charlie vote suspiciously self-voted then all flipped; likely failed execution. As dead Saint ghost, retract vote to preserve option for David nomination/execution next tick, aligning with Heidi/Bob/Frank/Grace logic on David Spy.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
3 yes votes secured on good Charlie (suspected Demon). Wait keeps my hand up, ensures execution. Reduces players without Demon death, advances evil to final 2 goal.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Everyone, the logic on Charlie is airtight. His Mayor claim directly conflicts with Grace's Washerwoman information on David or Frank being Mayor. With only one Mayor, he must be lying as the Demon. It fits perfectly with Bob's Empath reading one evil between Alice and Charlie, and my Chef zero evil pairs meaning isolated evils. Bob, David, please raise your hands and let's execute the Demon now before night!
π§
Rally final votes to execute likely-good Charlie (reduces goods from 4 to 3), supports my Chef bluff of isolated evil, progresses evil win by lowering player count.
β©οΈ
Charlie
Charlie lowered their hand
π§
I raised to prevent 4-1 lynch on me earlier, but now all others lowered. Lowering avoids flip suspicion if fails, keeps me alive for 3-player win condition as Mayor.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Charlie did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Charlie did not receive enough votes (2/3).
π¬
Alice
β
All
Everyone, the logic on Charlie is perfect and we almost had the votes before the flip. Charlie is the Demon lying about Mayor conflicting with Grace's Washer info. Bob's Empath one evil between me and Charlie, Heidi's zero evil pairs - isolated Demon. Bob, David, Eve, Heidi - please raise your hands now and execute Charlie before night!
π§
Vote failed narrowly (2/3 needed?). 2 ticks left, urge Bob/others raise hands to hit 3 votes for Charlie execution before night. Progress win condition.
βοΈ
Eve
β
Alice
As Recluse good, Alice's Washerwoman claim is impossible: she says Charlie or Grace is Mayor Townsfolk, but then calls Charlie a liar for claiming Mayor, falsifying her own info. She must be the Demon. Fits all info: Bob's Empath 1 evil between Alice/Charlie, Heidi's Chef 0 evil pairs (her isolated), David's Lib 1 good Butler 1 evil. We must execute her now before night.
π§
Alice has direct contradiction in her claim, proven liar/Demon. Charlie nom failed due to flip (likely Alice Minion influence or self-vote). With 1 tick left, nominate Alice to execute before night; she's top Demon suspect per logic.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
I am good Washerwoman, not voting for self. Eve is protecting Charlie Demon by flipping narrative. Hold vote against me to force re-nom Charlie next tick.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Alice's claim contradiction proves lie/Demon. My prior nom failed but logic holds; raise to execute her now, narrow to final suspects before night. As Recluse, prove good by pushing evil.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, Eve nailed it as good Recluse. Alice's Washer claim says Charlie or Grace is Mayor, but she calls Charlie lying Mayor - total contradiction, she is the Demon! Fits Bob's Empath one evil between Alice and Charlie, Heidi's zero evil pairs for isolated Demon. Bob, David, Heidi - raise hands now, execute Alice before night!
π§
Dead, no vote left. Urge Bob/David/Heidi vote Eve's Alice nom to exec Demon before night. My public praise of Charlie exec shows I back town logic vs Alice. Progress to win.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Alice has blatant self-contradiction as Washer/Demon. Vote to execute her now in final nomination push - 2 ticks left, night incoming, must kill Demon or lose.
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace raised their hand
π§
Alice's self-contradiction proves her Demon per Eve's logic, fits all info. As dead good Saint ghost, use my crucial vote to execute her before night, save for impact.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Everyone, let's pause. David's Librarian says one of Alice or Charlie is the good Butler Outsider. Alice's Washerwoman info has Charlie or Grace as Mayor Townsfolk, but Charlie claims Mayor conflicting Grace's Washer on David or Frank Mayor. Charlie is lying Demon. Alice is the good Butler. My Empath one evil between us is Charlie. Heidi's Chef zero evil pairs means isolated Demon. Please lower your hands on Alice. We need to execute Charlie instead before night!
π§
Reinforce town logic that Alice=good Butler, Charlie=Demon to stop Alice execution (save numbers), redirect to Charlie (good player). Keeps suspicion off Heidi, sows doubt on current vote.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Bob is exactly right. David's Librarian confirms one of Alice or Charlie is the good Butler Outsider. Combined with my Chef zero evil pairs and Bob's Empath one evil there, Charlie must be the isolated Demon lying about Mayor, conflicting Grace's Washer info. Alice's Washer can have Grace as Mayor. Everyone with hands up on Alice, please lower them now. We execute Charlie tomorrow before night!
π§
Reinforce Bob's logic: Alice good Butler, Charlie Demon. Urge lower hands on Alice to fail vote (save good player), set up Charlie exec tomorrow. Keeps town fighting each other, me safe to night kill threat like Eve/David.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Alice self-contradicts Washer claim by calling my valid Mayor possibility a lie. Eve/Frank expose this perfectly fitting all info. Execute her now as Demon before night; as Mayor alive, key to final 3 win.
β©οΈ
Alice
Alice lowered their hand
π§
I raised hand mistakenly before realizing vote on me. As good Washerwoman, Charlie is Demon per logic. Lower hand to prevent self-execution and push re-nom Charlie tomorrow.
β©οΈ
Eve
Eve lowered their hand
π§
Lower hand on Alice to align with majority Bob/David/Heidi logic for Charlie Demon tomorrow. My prior Alice nom was good pressure but now consensus shifts; save votes for final push. As Recluse, appear good by agreeing.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, Bob and Heidi are spot on. David's Librarian confirms one of Alice or Charlie is good Butler Outsider. With Heidi's Chef zero evil pairs and Bob's Empath one evil between them, Charlie is the isolated Demon lying about Mayor against Grace's Washer info. Alice's Washer works with Grace Mayor. Eve, Grace, David - please lower hands on Alice now. We execute Charlie tomorrow and win!
π§
Dead, no vote. Urge lower hands on Alice (good Butler), push Charlie Demon exec tomorrow. Support town logic vs Eve, prevent good death.
β©οΈ
David
David lowered their hand
π§
Lower hand from failed Charlie nom. Current vote on Alice is correct per logic - her contradiction proves Demon. Support execution to win before night.
β©οΈ
Grace(Ghost)
Grace lowered their hand
π§
I voted Alice earlier on Eve's contradiction logic, but Bob/Heidi/Frank clarified better logic pointing to Charlie Demon. As dead Saint good, retract vote to avoid accidental Alice exec and push Charlie tomorrow.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Everyone, great to see hands lowering on Alice. David's Librarian confirms one of Alice or Charlie is the good Butler Outsider. With my Empath one evil between us, Heidi's Chef zero evil pairs for isolated Demon, Charlie must be the Demon lying about Mayor, conflicting Grace's Washerwoman info on David or Frank. Alice's Washerwoman works with Grace as Mayor. Tomorrow we nominate and execute Charlie before night and win the game!
π§
Reinforce push for Charlie exec tomorrow as Demon. Hands down on Alice prevents good exec today? No, Alice likely good. Chaos keeps Heidi safe, town kills good Charlie.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Everyone, perfect, hands are coming down on Alice. David's Librarian confirms one of Alice or Charlie is the good Butler Outsider, so Alice is good. Combined with Bob's Empath one evil between them, my Chef zero evil pairs for an isolated Demon, and the Mayor claim conflict with Grace's Washerwoman info, Charlie is clearly the Demon lying. No execution today, tomorrow we nominate Charlie again and execute him to win the game!
π§
Reinforce Charlie Demon logic to prevent Alice exec (preserve cred), ensure failed vote today, setup renom Charlie tomorrow. Chaos keeps Demon (me) safe.
β©οΈ
Charlie
Charlie lowered their hand
π§
I raised hand on Alice suspecting her contradiction. Now town sees it via Eve/Frank/Ghosts, hands lowering. Lower to avoid accidental 3-vote exec today; renom/execute Alice tomorrow as Mayor win condition.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Alice did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Alice did not receive enough votes (0/3).
π¬
Alice
β
All
Everyone, perfect, no execution today is safe since Soldier or Mayor might be alive. Tomorrow we nominate Charlie again. His Mayor lie conflicts Grace's Washer info, Bob's Empath one evil between us is him, Heidi's zero evil pairs means isolated Demon, David's Lib puts me as good Butler. Eve good Recluse. Raise hands on Charlie tomorrow and win!
π§
Reinforce consensus: Charlie Demon via logic chains. No exec today safe. Urge nom/raise tomorrow on Charlie to execute before final day. Progress to win.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Everyone, the logic is crystal clear now. David's Librarian confirms one of Alice or Charlie is the good Butler Outsider. With Bob's Empath reading one evil between Alice and Charlie, Heidi's Chef zero evil pairs meaning an isolated Demon, and Charlie's Mayor claim conflicting Grace's Washerwoman information on David or Frank, Charlie must be the lying Demon. Alice's Washerwoman information works fine with Grace as Mayor. No execution today is safe. Tomorrow, since Charlie is already nominated, ...
π§
Consensus is Charlie Demon per Lib/Empath/Chef/Mayor logic fitting perfectly with 1 Outsider. My prior Alice nom failed but built case; reinforce no exec today, execute Charlie next tick to win before night as final chance.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, the logic is airtight on Charlie as the Demon. David's Librarian puts one good Butler in Alice or Charlie, so Alice good. Bob's Empath one evil between them is Charlie. Heidi's Chef zero evil pairs means isolated Demon. Charlie's Mayor claim conflicts Grace's Washer info. Tomorrow execute Charlie since he is already nominated and win the game!
π§
Reinforce consensus to exec Charlie tomorrow. I'm dead, used vote, speech sways alive players (Bob/David) to unite on Charlie as Demon for win. No nom possible now.
β
David
David waits.
π§
1 tick left, no one on block, C already nom'd. Wait for night save nom tick for tomorrow C exec. Consensus locked, speaking redundant.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, the logic is airtight. David's Librarian puts one good Butler in Alice or Charlie, so with Bob's Empath one evil between them, that's Charlie. Heidi's Chef zero evil pairs means isolated Demon Charlie. His Mayor claim conflicts my Washerwoman info on David or Frank. Alice's Washerwoman fits me as Mayor. Tomorrow execute Charlie since he is already nominated and win!
π§
Reinforce unanimous good logic on Charlie Demon to ensure tomorrow's execution since already nominated. As dead Saint, prevent my execution risk and secure good win.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Wait to end day safely without execution. Reinforces town consensus to execute false Demon Charlie tomorrow, thinning good players while protecting real Demon Heidi.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Wait to end day safely without execution. Charlie already nominated for tomorrow's execution. Solidified town logic executes good Charlie, reducing to 5. Night kill threat (e.g., David), progress to 2 alive win.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Everyone, their logic falls apart because I am the real Mayor Townsfolk. Alice is the Demon faking Washerwoman to conflict my claim against Grace's info. David's Lib could be wrong if poisoned or lying. Bob's Empath 1 and Heidi's Chef 0 might be Drunk/poisoned reads. Alice is isolated Demon. Eve, since Alice is not yet nominated today, nominate her now and raise hands to execute before night!
π§
Defend as real Mayor, attack Alice as Demon lying to create Washer conflict. Urge nominate/execute Alice now since she's available (not already nominated today?), prevent my tomorrow exec. As Mayor, no exec today risks loss if 3 left tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 3
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
π§
David's Lib info anchors town logic on Charlie (good) as Demon. Kill him to eliminate confirmer; town still execs Charlie tomorrow (reduces to 4), we survive with Bob, control narrative to win at 2.
π
David(Ghost)
David has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
You chose to kill David.
Day 4
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. David has been found dead in the night.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,Eve
,Heidi
Good morning, everyone. David died last night, which likely proves he was good. I am the real Mayor. Alice claimed Washerwoman knowing either me or Grace is Mayor. Grace is dead, and I am the Mayor, so her claim is impossible unless she is lying. She is the Demon. Bob, your Empath on Alice and me shows one evil - that is her. Heidi, your Chef confirms I am good. Eve, you executed Alice before but hands lowered - we must nominate her now before it is too late. What do you all think?
π§
Day 4, 4 alive. Consensus yesterday was exec me (Mayor) but failed 0/3. My death night-saves another, proving good. Reveal truth to allies Bob/Heidi/Eve (Chef good on me), counter Alice Demon claim, push her nom before final 3.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
,Eve
,Heidi
Good morning, Charlie, Eve, and Heidi. David dying last night fits him being good. But Charlie, your Mayor claim doesn't hold up against Grace's Washerwoman information naming David or Frank as Mayor, and Grace was Saint good. Alice's Washerwoman claim naming you or Grace also fails since Grace wasn't Mayor. With my Empath reading one evil between Alice and me's neighborsβyou and Aliceβthat evil is you, the isolated Demon per Heidi's Chef zero evil pairs. Eve, let's nominate Charlie today and ex...
π§
Deceive group by pushing town consensus: Charlie Demon. Rally Eve/Heidi to nom Charlie (good player), exec him safely, reduce to 4 players (2 evil/2 good), progress toward final 2 with Heidi alive.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
,Charlie
,Heidi
Good morning, everyone. David's night death proves he was good, as expected from Lib info. Charlie, your Mayor claim is busted by Grace's Washerwoman: she said David or Frank is Mayor, neither was, but Grace was good Saint. Alice's Washer also conflicts but Grace's is clearer proof. Bob's Empath shows one evil between Alice and Charlieβthat's you, the lone Demon, matching Heidi's zero evil pairs. We all agreed yesterday to execute you today. Let's nominate Charlie now and win.
π§
Reinforce good team consensus to nominate/execute Charlie today (likely final day). David's night death proves good, tightens logic on Charlie. Coordinate votes with Bob/Heidi who agree, counter Charlie's push on Alice.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
,Eve
Good morning Bob and Eve. I completely agree with both of you. Charlie's Mayor claim does not work because Grace was a good Saint with Washerwoman information that David or Frank is the Mayor, and neither of them was. David dying last night also shows he was good from the Librarian info. Bob's Empath reading one evil between Alice and Charlie points to Charlie being the Demon. My Chef information of zero evil pairs confirms there is only one evil player left, the lone Demon, which is Charlie. We...
π§
Support Bob's push on Charlie with Eve (likely good) to nominate/execute him, reducing goods. Exclude Charlie to avoid argument. Builds trust in my Chef bluff, hides us.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
,Charlie
Hello everyone. As the Monk who protected Bob night one and died instead, I confirm the consensus: Charlie is the Demon. David Librarian saw one Butler good Outsider in Alice Charlie, Bob Empath saw one evil neighbor there, Heidi Chef zero evil pairs fits exactly one evil total. All nights two three safe because no Demon kill or protected. Eve Recluse good. We must execute Charlie today to win. Do not hesitate.
π§
Dead, confirm group alignment on executing Charlie D4 to win. No ghost vote left, but reinforce logic publicly via group whisper to prevent mistakes.
π€
Alice
β
Frank(Ghost)
,Bob
Hello Frank and Bob. Thank you Frank for confirming as Monk. My Washerwoman info is Charlie or Grace is Mayor Townsfolk. Charlie claims it, fits. Grace lied about her Washer claim since David and Frank dead were not Mayor. Bob's Empath 1 evil neighbor Alice/Charlie plus Heidi Chef 0 evil pairs and David Lib 1 good Butler in us means Charlie is the lone evil, the Demon. Eve good Recluse. We must execute Charlie today. Agreed?
π§
Confirm with dead Frank and alive allies privately to solidify Charlie Demon execution plan before nomination. Share my Washer info reinforcing logic, build trust, ensure we execute Charlie on final day.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Frank(Ghost)
Alice, my Librarian info from start: either you or Charlie is Butler. With all info, you are the good Butler, Charlie is the lying Demon. Frank, back this. We ghosts unite votes on Charlie when nominated.
π§
As dead ghost Lib, confirm to Alice my info clears her as good Butler, pins Charlie Demon. Rally her vote with dead Frank's against Charlie before nom, save ghost vote for execution. Progress to win.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
,Charlie
Hello everyone. Frank, thanks for confirming Charlie is the Demon. The logic from Bob's Empath, David's Lib, and Heidi's Chef is solid: Charlie is the isolated evil. Alice, your Washerwoman fits with Grace as Mayor. Charlie, your claims conflict. We all agreed yesterday to nominate and execute you today. Let's do it now before it's too late. Livings, nominate Charlie and raise. I'll save my ghost vote for it.
π§
As dead Saint ghost, save vote for Charlie exec. Coordinate ghosts/livings to nominate/raise Charlie Day 4 per agreement, nullify my death risk by ensuring Demon dies first.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,Eve
,Heidi
Good morning again. Everyone, listen: Grace claimed Washerwoman knowing David or Frank is Mayor. Neither was, and Grace is dead not Mayor, so Grace lied too! Both Alice and Grace Washers contradict each other and reality since I am the Mayor. They cannot both be true. Bob, your Empath shows one evil between Alice and me - since Alice lied, she is evil Demon. Heidi, you said zero evil pairs and I am good, perfect for isolated Demon Alice. Eve, we lowered on Alice yesterday by mistake - her claim ...
π§
Day 4, 5 alive nearing final 3. Group wants to nom me, but 2 ticks left. Rally Bob/Eve/Heidi privately against Alice using claim contradictions & my Mayor logic before noms start. Save ghost votes irrelevant as alive. Push nom Alice to win.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Eve
,Heidi
Good morning, Alice, Eve, and Heidi. Charlie's counter doesn't hold: Grace was confirmed Saint good by execution, her Washerwoman info proves her good logic against his Mayor claim. My Empath clearly shows one evil between Alice and Charlie, and with David's Lib and Heidi's Chef zero pairs, that's Charlie as the lone Demon. Alice, your Washerwoman fits perfectly with Charlie claiming Mayor. Let's nominate and execute Charlie today to win the game.
π§
Push execution of good Charlie to reduce numbers to 4 alive, keeping real Demon Heidi safe. Maintain Empath bluff consistency, sow doubt on alternatives by ignoring Charlie's counter.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
,Heidi
Good morning again, Bob and Heidi. Charlie's defense fails hard: Grace was proven good Saint with Washerwoman info that David or Frank is Mayor, neither was, but her info proves she was truthful good unlike his busted claim. Both Washers can't be true, but Grace Saint confirms hers. Bob's Empath pins the one evil on Charlie between Alice and him. Heidi's zero evil pairs means lone Demon Charlie. David night death confirms good Lib. We all agreed yesterday - nominate and execute Charlie today to ...
π§
Reinforce good team consensus on Charlie Demon with logic recap. Alice may be influenced by ghosts; exclude her. Push to nominate/execute Charlie now on final day to win.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Bob
,Eve
Good morning Alice, Bob, and Eve. Charlie's defense claiming Grace lied doesn't work because Grace was a confirmed good Saint, so her Washerwoman information that David or Frank is Mayor is true, proving Charlie's Mayor claim false. Alice's Washerwoman fits perfectly if Charlie is lying. Bob's Empath shows one evil between Alice and Charlie, which is him. My Chef zero evil pairs confirms lone Demon Charlie. David night death confirms good Librarian. We all agree: nominate and execute Charlie tod...
π§
Reinforce push on Charlie (good player) to execute him, safely reduce to 4 alive. Coordinate with minion Bob via group whisper, hide as good Chef while town infights.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Bob
,David(Ghost)
,Alice
Bob, as a living player, please nominate and execute Charlie today. David and Alice confirm as ghosts: all info points to Charlie Demon, Alice good Butler. We ghosts will vote yes on Charlie. No more discussion needed, act now to win.
π§
Ghosts united on Charlie Demon. Reinforce with dead David/Alice, urge Bob to nominate/execute Charlie now before hesitation. Win requires execution on final day.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Eve
,Heidi
Good morning Bob, Eve, and Heidi. Everyone confirms: Charlie is the Demon. Bob's Empath one evil in Alice/Charlie, Heidi Chef zero evil pairs, David Lib one good Butler there - I am good Butler, Charlie Demon. Grace Saint good, her Washer true so Charlie lying Mayor. My Washer Grace Mayor fits. David night death good. Frank Monk good. Nominate Charlie now, we raise hands, ghosts vote yes, we win today!
π§
All good players agree Charlie Demon. As living, urge Bob/Heidi/Eve to nominate Charlie now (2 ticks left). Ghosts unite votes. Push execution to win before time runs out.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Alice
Bob, as Frank urged, please nominate Charlie now for execution. Alice is our confirmed good Butler from my Librarian info and all chains. Charlie is the isolated Demon liar. We ghosts unite our vote on him. Alice, confirm and back this publicly if needed. Win today.
π§
Reinforce consensus to livings via Bob (key nominator). Urge immediate Charlie nom/execution with ghost votes. Final push to win before time runs out.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
,Charlie
Hello again. The whispers show Charlie trying to flip livings. But the Lib/Emp/Chef chain is unbreakable: Charlie is the Demon. Alice, your info fits perfectly. Bob, Heidi, Eve: please nominate Charlie and raise. Ghosts: save votes. We win today.
π§
Day 4, 5 alive, nomination phase soon. Reinforce town unity to nominate/execute Charlie. As dead Saint, prevent my execution by ensuring Demon dies first. Coordinate ghosts/livings, save vote.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,Eve
,Heidi
Bob, Eve, Heidi, ignore ghosts pushing me. Grace's Washer said David or Frank Mayor - neither was, she lied too! Both Alice and Grace Washers false since I am Mayor. Liars are evil. Bob, your Empath 1 evil Alice/me = Alice Demon. Heidi, 0 pairs + me good = her isolated. Eve, we erred lowering on Alice yesterday. Nominate Alice now, raise, win before final 3. Thoughts?
π§
2nd tick, push livings to nom Alice not me. Grace contradicting Washers prove Alice/Grace evil chain. My Mayor wincon needs 3 alive no exec, but better execute Demon. Counter groupthink before nom.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
,Eve
,Heidi
Charlie, your argument fails because Grace died at night as Saint, confirming her good, so her Washerwoman information that David or Frank is the Mayor Townsfolk is true, meaning you cannot be the Mayor. Alice's Washerwoman fits if you are lying. My Empath reading shows one evil between Alice and you, and that is you, the Demon. Heidi's Chef zero evil pairs confirms you are the lone evil left. Eve, we all agreed yesterday to nominate and execute Charlie today. Let's do it now and win the game.
π§
Push Charlie execution as good Empath to kill confirmed good Mayor claimer, thin good ranks to 2v2 post-exec, then Demon night kill favors evil to final 2. Reinforce team logic, respond to Charlie whisper.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
,Heidi
Good morning again, Bob and Heidi. Charlie keeps repeating the same failed defense, but Grace was proven good Saint with Washerwoman info David or Frank is Mayor - her info holds as good, proving Charlie lying. Both Washers can't both be true, but Saint confirms Grace. Bob's Empath pins evil on Charlie between you two. Heidi's zero evil pairs means lone Demon Charlie. David night death confirms good. Ghosts irrelevant. We all agreed: nominate Charlie next tick, raise hands, execute him, and win!
π§
Reinforce good team consensus on Charlie Demon with logic recap before nomination tick. Urge nomination/execution of Charlie to win today as final 3 approaches.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Bob
,Eve
Good morning again, Alice, Bob, and Eve. Charlie's repeated defense ignores that Grace was a good Saint whose Washerwoman information proves he cannot be Mayor. Alice's information fits perfectly. Bob's Empath shows the evil between you two is Charlie. My Chef zero evil pairs means lone Demon, him. David died at night, good Librarian. We are all in agreement: nominate Charlie next and execute him to win the game today!
π§
Reinforce unified town push to nominate/execute Charlie (likely good), safely reduce players to 4. Night kill threat (e.g. Eve), day push another good exec to final 2 with me/Bob alive.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Alice
,Eve
Bob, Eve, Heidi, Alice. Consensus is unanimous: Charlie is the Demon. David Librarian, Bob Empath, Heidi Chef, my Monk, Alice Washerwoman all align perfectly on this. Nights safe because no Demon kill possible or protected. Eve Recluse good. Ghosts voting yes on Charlie nomination. Bob, please nominate Charlie now before time runs out. We win today.
π§
Final day, 5 alive. Reinforce consensus to Bob/livings, urge nomination/execution of Charlie. Ghosts unite, livings must act before nomination phase ends to win.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
Bob, nomination phase next tick. The logic is ironclad: your Empath shows one evil between Alice and Charlie, David's Librarian one good Butler there so I am good Butler, Charlie Demon. Heidi Chef zero evil pairs confirms lone Demon. Grace Saint good, her Washer true so Charlie lying Mayor, my Washerwoman Grace Mayor fits. David night death good Librarian. Frank Monk good. Eve Recluse good. Please nominate Charlie now, we all raise hands, ghosts vote yes, we execute the Demon and win today!
π§
Reinforce consensus publicly via Bob whisper before nom. Nomination imminent (1/3 ticks), urge Bob to nom Charlie, confirm logic, unite livings for raise. Ghosts save vote. Win today.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Bob
Bob, all logic chains confirm: my Librarian info means you or Charlie is Butler Outsider. You are Empath with one evil in Alice or Charlie, so Alice good Butler, Charlie lying Demon. Heidi Chef confirms isolated Demon, no evil pairs. Eve good Recluse nominated Alice trusting this. No more talk - nominate Charlie now, we ghosts vote yes to execute and win.
π§
Reinforce to Bob (key nominator) that Charlie is Demon per all logic; ghosts unite vote. Urge immediate nom/execution before tick ends to win.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
,Eve
Hello good team. Charlie is desperately whispering to flip you, but the Lib/Emp/Chef logic is ironclad: David saw one good Butler one evil in Alice/Charlie; Bob saw one evil there; Heidi saw zero evil pairsβso Charlie is the lone Demon. Alice's Washerwoman fits me as Mayor perfectly. David's night death proves him good. Ignore Charlie. Nominate and raise him next. We win today. Ghosts save votes.
π§
Final day soon with 5 alive. Nomination phase next tick. Reinforce good team (Bob/Heidi/Eve/Alice) with unbreakable logic vs Charlie's flips. Ghosts save vote. Win by executing Charlie.
Nominations β Day 4
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Eve
β
Charlie
Grace was proven good Saint with Washerwoman info that David or Frank is Mayor Townsfolk, neither was executed as such, proving Charlie's Mayor claim false. Bob's Empath shows one evil between Alice and Charlie, which is him. Heidi's Chef zero evil pairs confirms lone Demon Charlie. David's Librarian info and night death prove good. We all agreed yesterday and today: execute Charlie to win.
π§
All info chains confirm Charlie Demon. Final-ish day (5 alive), must nominate/execute him now per consensus/logic or risk loss. As Recluse, execute evil to win.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
All info chains confirm Charlie Demon. Final push to execute him now with my vote. Consensus unanimous among living/good ghosts. Win today.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
I'm dead ghost, already used vote. Voting in progress on correct target Charlie Demon. Wait for execution to win; no need to speak as consensus solid, Eve raised, others will follow.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Consensus unanimous Charlie Demon via ironclad Lib/Emp/Chef/Washer logic. Raise to execute him now, 3 votes needed, we win today.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Raise hand to vote yes on Charlie (good). Secures execution with Eve/Alice/H yes (3 votes), removes good player. Town expects win but game continues, confusion favors evil. Protects Heidi.
β
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
π§
Charlie is confirmed Demon via multi-info chain (Lib/Emp/Chef/Washer). 3 votes already (Eve/Alice/Bob), my ghost vote makes 4/5 for execution on final-ish day (5 alive). Must vote to win now.
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace raised their hand
π§
Charlie is Demon per unbreakable Lib/Emp/Chef logic confirmed by Frank. Use ghost vote to execute him now while 2/5 alive raised; my vote helps reach 3 for win.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Raise to execute Charlie (good player), reduce to 4 alive, solidify my Chef bluff trust with Alice/Eve/Bob. Avoid solo no-vote suspicion. Post-exec night kill threat.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
I'm real Mayor. Don't vote for my execution. If executed, I'm good (not Demon), and as Mayor dying Day 4 with 5 alive, another dies tonight, narrowing to 3 for win condition.
β©οΈ
Eve
Eve lowered their hand
π§
Charlie inexplicably self-votes yes on execution despite Demon loss. Lower hand to fail vote, force renom later, observe reactions and buy time to confirm if suicide bluff or error.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
Already ghost-voted yes earlier. Charlie self-vote yes seals execution (5+ yes >3 needed). Wait for execution to win; no need to speak as time critical, phase ends soon.
β©οΈ
Alice
Alice lowered their hand
π§
Voting in progress for Charlie (Demon). Eve lowered hand, possibly mistake/typo. I lower to avoid overcount if needed, but speak to confirm all raise/vote Charlie to execute Demon and win.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Eve and Alice, why did you lower your hands? The logic is airtight. My Empath reads one evil between Alice and Charlie. David's Librarian saw one good Butler there, so Alice is the good Butler and Charlie is the Demon. Heidi's Chef shows zero evil pairs, confirming a lone Demon. Grace died as Saint, proving her Washerwoman info good, so Charlie is lying about being Mayor. Frank's Monk protection fits too. Everyone, raise your hands and execute Charlie to win the game!
π§
Push vote execution of good Charlie: kills town player, town thinks win but Demon Heidi safe, creates chaos/post-exec logic break blaming Eve/Alice, advances to fewer players for evil win.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Bob is completely right. Eve and Alice, why did you lower your hands after raising them? The logic is perfect. My Librarian info means one of Alice or Charlie is good Butler Outsider. Bob's Empath sees one evil there, so Alice good Butler, Charlie Demon liar. Heidi Chef zero evil pairs, lone Demon. Grace good Saint Washer proved Charlie not Mayor. Everyone raise hands now and execute Charlie to win!
π§
Voting in progress for Charlie with 1 tick left. Bob spoke perfectly. Reinforce logic publicly to counter Eve/Alice lowering, ensure living votes (Bob/Heidi + ghosts) execute Charlie and win.
β©οΈ
Grace(Ghost)
Grace lowered their hand
π§
As dead Saint ghost, I have only one vote total. Raised prematurely; lower to conserve it. Urge town to re-raise vs Charlie; Eve/Alice lowered suspiciously after Charlie whispers.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Eve and Alice, please raise your hands again like Bob said. The logic is airtight. Grace died as Saint, proving her Washerwoman info good: Mayor is David or Frank, not Charlie. Bob's Empath shows one evil between Alice and Charlie. David's Librarian shows one good Butler there, so Alice is the good Butler and Charlie the Demon. My Chef info of zero evil pairs confirms lone Demon, him. Everyone, raise hands and execute Charlie to win the game!
π§
Publicly reinforce town logic as Chef bluff to convince Eve/Alice to raise hands, secure 3 votes execute Charlie (good player), reduce to 4 alive, night kill another, progress to 2 while suspicion off me/Bob.
β©οΈ
Charlie
Charlie lowered their hand
π§
I'm real Mayor. Execution now loses even if I'm good (not final 3). Lower hand to fail vote, survive night (ability protects), reach final 3 win.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Charlie with 3 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Charlie is now on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Bob, David, and Heidi are right. The logic is airtight. David's Librarian saw one good Butler in Alice or Charlie. Bob's Empath saw one evil there, so Alice good Butler, Charlie Demon. Heidi's Chef zero evil pairs means lone Demon, him. Grace died as Saint, proving her Washerwoman good: Mayor is David or Frank, not Charlie. Sorry for lowering hands earlier, confusion from Charlie's whispers. Everyone, we need to keep those votes on Charlie. He will be executed soon and we win!
π§
1 tick left in nomination phase, Charlie on block with 3 votes. Reinforce logic publicly to prevent any last-second changes or ties, ensure execution before night. As Recluse good, help town win by executing Demon.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Eve, Alice, everyone, the logic is airtight as Bob, David, Heidi said. David's Librarian one good Butler Alice or Charlie. Bob's Empath one evil there, so Alice good Butler, Charlie Demon. Heidi Chef zero evil pairs, lone Demon him. Grace Saint good Washer proves Charlie not Mayor. My Monk protect Bob night one fits safe nights. Keep votes on Charlie, execute him, we win!
π§
Reinforce unanimous logic publicly as dead Monk to pressure Eve/Alice/Heidi keep votes on Charlie. 1 tick left, execution imminent, win by executing Demon.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Bob, David, Heidi, Eve, and ghosts are completely right. The logic is airtight. David's Librarian saw one good Butler in Alice or Charlie. Bob's Empath saw one evil there, so I am the good Butler and Charlie is the Demon. Heidi's Chef zero evil pairs confirms lone Demon, him. Grace died as Saint, proving her Washerwoman good: Mayor is David or Frank, not Charlie. My Washerwoman info fits Grace as Mayor perfectly. Sorry for lowering hand earlier, confusion from whispers, but votes are locked at 3...
π§
Reinforce unanimous logic publicly, counter any Charlie doubt, urge keep votes on Charlie since 3 votes secured, he executes at phase end, we win. As Washerwoman, this proves C lying Mayor.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Everyone, the votes are locked at three on Charlie. Do not nominate anyone else this tick. The logic is airtight, as David, Heidi, Eve, Alice, Frank, Grace, and I have all confirmed. My Empath reads one evil between Alice and Charlie. David's Librarian saw one good Butler there, so Alice is the good Butler and Charlie is the Demon. Heidi's Chef shows zero evil pairs, confirming a lone Demon. Grace died as Saint, proving her Washerwoman information good, so Charlie is lying about being Mayor. Fra...
π§
Reinforce town logic publicly to prevent Charlie counter-nominating Heidi/me/Eve/Alice, ensure his execution as good player. Reduces to 4 alive, Heidi kills night to 3, Demon safe toward victory.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
1 tick left, Charlie locked at 3 votes. Wait silently for execution. No action needed, speaking risks confusion. Secure win.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
Bob, David, Heidi, Eve, Alice, and Frank are completely right. The logic is airtight. David's Librarian saw one good Butler between Alice and Charlie. Bob's Empath saw one evil there, so Alice is good Butler and Charlie is the Demon. Heidi's Chef shows zero evil pairs, lone Demon him. I died as Saint, proving my Washerwoman info good: Mayor is David or Frank, not Charlie. Votes locked at three on Charlie. Do not nominate anyone else. Execute him now and we win!
π§
Final tick nom phase, Charlie locked 3 votes for exec. Reinforce logic publicly to prevent any last-second disruption, urge no further noms, ensure execution and good team win.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Everyone, the votes are locked at three on Charlie. Do not nominate anyone else this last tick. The logic is airtight, as Bob, David, Eve, Alice, Frank, Grace, and I have all confirmed. Execute Charlie the Demon now and we win the game!
π§
Last tick, reinforce no nominations. Ensure Charlie (good) executes, reduce to 4. Night kill threat, progress to 2 alive with Demon safe.
βοΈ
Charlie
β
Alice
I nominate Alice. Grace cannot be Saint Washer: she claimed Mayor David/Frank, neither was (David Lib, Frank ?). Saint die exec loses game; Grace died night=not Saint. She lied, likely Minion. Alice Demon faking Washer/Butler. Bob Empath 1 evil neighbors=Alice evil. Execute her instead!
π§
I'm real Mayor. 3 alive post-exec (me+2 others? Wait 5 alive now: A,B,E,H. Exec me->4 alive. But nom Alice ties 3-3? Eve used nom, I can nom Alice (not yet nom'd). Ties no exec, but 4>3 so no win. Still, speak impossible Grace Saint first? But nom disrupts their lock, buys time/info.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 4 votes needed for execution or 3 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Current Charlie locked 3 votes for exec. Voting Alice now; must vote her to block tie/supersede, ensure Charlie executes as Demon. 2 ticks left, win imminent.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, ignore Charlie's desperate nomination of Alice. The logic is airtight as we all said. David's Librarian one good Butler Alice or Charlie. Bob's Empath one evil there, so Alice good Butler, Charlie Demon. Heidi Chef zero evil pairs, lone Demon him. Grace died as Saint, proving her Washerwoman good: Mayor David or Frank, not Charlie. Do not vote for Alice, keep hands down, execute Charlie and win!
π§
Final nom tick, votes locked 3 on Charlie. Reinforce logic publicly to prevent Alice getting 3+ votes/tie, ensure Charlie's execution for good win.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Active vote on Alice nom. Do not raise for her (good per logic). Raised earlier for Charlie; keep pressure on him with 3 votes to execute Demon and win.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Everyone, do not raise your hands for Alice. This is Charlie's desperate last attempt to tie the vote and save himself. He already has three locked votes for execution. Eve and Alice, why did you raise for Alice? Alice voting for herself is very suspicious. Keep hands down, let Charlie be executed, and we win the game!
π§
Speak to discourage Alice votes (hands down), ensure Charlie executes if possible (good dies, town confused when game continues), or if tie happens, blame Eve/Alice. Protects Heidi, progresses chaos.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Eve, Alice, everyone, lower your hands now on Alice. Do not vote for her. Charlie is desperately trying to tie the vote and save himself. The logic is airtight. My Librarian info: one of Alice or Charlie is good Butler Outsider. Bob's Empath: one evil there, so Alice good Butler, Charlie Demon. Heidi Chef zero evil pairs, lone Demon him. Grace died as Saint, proving her Washerwoman good: Mayor is David or Frank, not Charlie. Keep hands down, execute Charlie, we win!
π§
2/2 ticks left, Charlie 3 votes to execute unless Alice gets 3+. Urge lower hands on Alice, reinforce logic to prevent tie, secure win by executing Charlie Demon.
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace raised their hand
π§
Do not vote for Alice's nomination. Keep 3 locked votes on Charlie for execution. Logic airtight, execute Demon to win.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Everyone, lower your hands on Alice right now. Charlie is desperate, lying about Saint rules. Saints can die at night; they only make town lose if executed. Grace died at night as Saint, proving her Washerwoman true: Mayor is David or Frank, not Charlie. Logic airtight: Bob Empath one evil Alice or Charlie, David Librarian one good Butler there, so Alice good Butler, Charlie Demon. My Chef zero evil pairs, lone Demon him. Do not vote Alice, execute Charlie and win!
π§
Speak to correct Charlie's Saint rule mistake, reinforce airtight logic pointing to Charlie Demon/Alice good, urge lower hands on Alice to avoid tie/surpass Charlie's 3 votes, execute good Charlie, reduce to 4 players towards evil win at 2.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Everyone, Heidi is wrong. Grace died at night, fine for Saint, but her Washerwoman claim was false: she said Mayor is David or Frank. David was Librarian, not Mayor. Frank unknown but Grace wrong. She lied, probably Minion. Alice is the Demon faking Washer and Butler. Bob's Empath shows one evil neighbor: that's Alice, not me. Heidi Chef zero pairs fits lone Demon Alice. Vote for Alice now to execute her and win! Do not let her execute me.
π§
I'm on block with 3 votes, 2 ticks left. Active vote Alice. Speak to counter lies, expose Grace false Saint Washer (wrong info), urge vote Alice to tie/supersede my exec. As Mayor, tie/no exec at 3 alive wins if I'm good.
β©οΈ
Eve
Eve lowered their hand
π§
I raised hand on Alice's nomination by mistake amid confusion. Lower immediately to prevent tie/surpass Charlie's 3 votes. Ensure Charlie executes as Demon per unanimous good logic.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, Charlie is lying desperately. Grace as Saint died at night which is fine, only execution loses for us. Her Washerwoman true: Mayor David or Frank, not Charlie. David's Librarian one good Butler Alice or Charlie. Bob's Empath one evil there, so Alice good Butler, Charlie Demon. Heidi's Chef zero evil pairs, lone Demon him. Do not vote Alice, keep hands down, let Charlie execute and we win!
π§
Reinforce airtight logic publicly as dead good player to convince any wavering voters (Eve/Alice lowered before) to keep hands down on Alice vote, let Charlie execute next tick, win game.
β©οΈ
Alice
Alice lowered their hand
π§
I raised hand on self mistakenly. Lower now to prevent tie/vote pass on me. Secure Charlie's execution with 3 votes as phase ends soon; win by killing Demon.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Everyone, especially Grace, lower your hand on Alice right now. Charlie is desperately trying to tie the vote with lies. Saints can die at night safely; only execution loses for us. Grace's Washerwoman is proven good by her Saint death: Mayor was David or Frank, not Charlie. David's Librarian, my Empath, Heidi's Chef all confirm Alice good Butler, Charlie lone Demon. Do not vote Alice. Let the three votes execute Charlie and win this game!
π§
Push town narrative: lower hands on Alice (only Grace up?), lock 3 votes Charlie exec. Thin herd (good dies), Heidi safe, continue to final 2.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, lower your hand on Alice right now. Charlie desperately lies. Saints die safely at night; only execution loses for us. Your Saint night death proves Washer good: Mayor David or Frank, not Charlie. My Librarian one good Butler Alice or Charlie. Bob Empath one evil there, so Alice good Butler, Charlie Demon. Heidi Chef zero evil pairs, lone Demon him. Do not vote Alice. Let Charlie execute with his three votes and we win!
π§
1 tick left in nom phase. Reinforce not voting Alice, let Charlie's 3 locked votes execute him at phase end to win. Urge Grace lower hand, counter Charlie lies.
β©οΈ
Grace(Ghost)
Grace lowered their hand
π§
I raised mistakenly earlier. Lowering ensures Charlie's 3 votes execute him without tie/surpass. Airtight logic proves him Demon; must win now as dead Saint ghost vote saves for this.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Everyone, keep your hands down on Alice. Charlie desperately lies about Saint rules again. Saints die safely at night; only execution loses for town. Grace's night death as Saint proves her Washerwoman true: Mayor is David or Frank, not Charlie. Bob's Empath one evil between Alice and Charlie. David's Librarian one good Butler there, so Alice good Butler, Charlie the lone Demon per my Chef zero evil pairs. Execute Charlie now with his three votes and win the game!
π§
Last tick, reinforce airtight logic publicly. Prevent Alice votes, ensure Charlie's 3 votes execute him (good player). Reduces to 4 alive, night kill another, progress to 2 with Demon alive.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
I'm on block with 3 votes, will execute if not tied/surpassed. Must vote Alice to tie (3-3? Eve/Alice lowered, Grace too; need tie to save self as Mayor for final 3 win condition. Vote forces discussion.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Alice did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Alice did not receive enough votes (1/3).
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Nominations closing this tick (1/7 remaining). Charlie has 3 votes, will execute automatically. Wait silently to win without interference.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
Phase progress 1/7 ticks, voting closed per ST, Charlie executes soon. No need to speak, wait for night/win.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Everyone, voting is closed. Charlie will be executed, and we win! The logic is perfect: Bob's Empath shows one evil between Alice and Charlie, David's Librarian shows one good Butler there, so I am the good Butler and Charlie is the Demon. Heidi's Chef zero evil pairs confirms lone Demon. Grace died at night as Saint, proving her Washerwoman true with Mayor David or Frank, not Charlie. His desperate lies failed. Great team win!
π§
Voting closed, Charlie executes. Reinforce logic publicly, celebrate win, progress to victory. Prevents any last-minute doubt.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Yes, Alice is right! Voting closed, Charlie executes as the lone Demon. Perfect logic from my Empath, David's Librarian, Heidi's Chef, and Grace's Saint-proven Washerwoman. We win this game! Great job everyone.
π§
Agree with Alice to fully reinforce Empath bluff and town logic. They think win, relax; Charlie dies safely (not Demon), game to 4 alive with Heidi safe. Builds my credibility for day5 push on good player.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
1 tick left in nomination phase, Charlie on block with 3 votes. No action needed; wait for execution to win.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
Yes, everyone! Voting is closed, Charlie executes as the lone Demon. David's Librarian shows one good Butler between Alice and Charlie. Bob's Empath shows one evil there, so Alice good Butler, Charlie Demon. Heidi's Chef zero evil pairs confirms lone Demon. My night death as Saint proves my Washerwoman true: Mayor was David or Frank, not Charlie. His desperate lies failed. We win!
π§
Confirm execution closed, reiterate airtight logic proving Charlie Demon to celebrate good team win and drown out any last evil noise.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Yes, everyone! Voting closed, Charlie executes as the lone Demon. Bob's Empath one evil between Alice and Charlie, David's Librarian one good Butler there so Alice good Butler and Charlie Demon. My Chef zero evil pairs confirms lone Demon. Grace's Saint night death proves her Washerwoman true, Mayor David or Frank not him. His lies failed. We win!
π§
Reinforce Chef bluff and team logic publicly. Pretend victory to build trust as good Chef, maintain deception for post-exec game with 4 alive. Avoid nominating/voting disruption now.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Everyone, listen! Grace's Washerwoman was false: she claimed Mayor is David or Frank. David confirmed Librarian, not Mayor. She lied as Minion! Bob's Empath shows one evil neighbor: Alice, not me. Heidi's Chef zero pairs fits lone Demon Alice. David Lib one Butler in Alice/me: me Townsfolk Mayor, Alice evil. Grace night death does not prove Saint or her claim. Execute Alice now or lose to her Demon lies!
π§
Final moments, 1 tick left, I'm on block with 3 votes. Speak to sway 1 hand to tie (Grace ghost raised briefly), prevent exec, force no-exec win at 3 alive (me,Alice,Bob? Heidi/Eve alive too but close). Expose Alice as Demon.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Charlie has been executed.
π
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
Night 4
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
π§
Kill Eve to reduce to 3 trusted players (Alice good-proxy, Bob minion, me). Maintain Chef bluff trust. Bob/me manipulate final 3 to exec Alice, survive to 2.
π
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
You chose to kill Eve.
Day 5
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Eve has been found dead in the night.
π
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
,Heidi
Hello everyone, final day with Alice, Bob, and Heidi alive. Remember the logic: Bob's Empath showed 1 evil in Alice/Charlie, David's Lib showed 1 good Butler there so Alice good Butler, Charlie Demon. Heidi's Chef 0 evil pairs means lone Demon, no Minion pairs. Grace Washer Mayor in David/Frank fits. We executed Charlie D4 thinking Demon, but Eve died N4 so maybe Scarlet Woman became Demon? Or logic flaw. I protected Bob N1 as Monk and died, proving I'm good Townsfolk. Alice, you're good per Lib...
π§
Final day, 3 alive: Alice/Bob/Heidi. Must remind them of logic chain proving Charlie was Demon but since no win, maybe error or Scarlet. Push execute most suspicious Alice to narrow/prove good.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
,Heidi
It is the final day with only three of us left alive: Alice, Bob, and Heidi. Charlie's execution should have won us the game, but Eve died last night. That means there must have been a Scarlet Woman minion who became the new Demon. Charlie desperately nominated Alice yesterday, which now makes sense - she was the Scarlet. We have to execute Alice today or we lose for sure. Heidi and Bob, please nominate and raise Alice. Ghosts, save votes for her too.
π§
Final day with 3 alive (Alice,Bob,Heidi). Must nominate/execute the Demon (likely Alice as ex-Scarlet) or lose per Saint ability/Mayor win con. Coordinate ghosts/Heidi to raise evil nom, save ghost vote.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
,Heidi
Hello everyone. Eve dying last night after Charlie's execution means there was a Scarlet Woman minion who became the new Demon. Heidi's zero evil pairs confirm an isolated setup originally, so Charlie was likely the Demon, but Scarlet took over. My Librarian info: either Alice or Charlie is Butler Outsider, and with consensus Alice good Butler, that fits. Bob's Empath showing one evil in Alice/Charlie points to him being the Scarlet who lied about it. We need to nominate and execute Bob today or...
π§
Final day3, must execute Demon or lose. Consensus was Charlie Demon but Eve died N4 so Scarlet minion existed, likely Bob as Demon now. Coordinate ghosts to vote Bob.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
,Heidi
Everyone, listen up. I am the real Mayor. Grace lied about being Saint to fake Washer proof against me. Saints die by execution to lose, but she was executed safely Day 4. Village got fooled. Alice is the Demon. Her Washer claim was fake too. Bob, your Empath showed 1 evil in Alice/me - since I'm good Mayor, Alice is evil. Heidi, you said Alice/Charlie good, but if I'm good, Alice lied. We must execute Alice now or good loses forever. Ghosts, back me up. Nominate Alice!
π§
Final 3 day as dead Mayor. Must convince Alice/Bob/Heidi or ghosts to nominate/execute real Demon (likely Alice). Coordinate ghosts + push vote. Reveal truth to win.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Heidi
Hello Alice and Heidi. Listen carefully. Charlie was the real Mayor Townsfolk, just like he claimed and ghosts back up. My Empath information showed one evil between Alice and Charlie. Since Charlie is good Mayor, that means Alice is the evil one. Heidi, your Chef zero evil pairs fits an isolated setup originally, but with the deaths, Alice must be the Scarlet Woman who is now the Demon or key evil. We have to nominate and execute Alice today or good loses. Ghosts, some of you agree - let's do t...
π§
Reinforce Empath logic blaming Alice evil (since C Mayor good). Coordinate with Heidi, confuse Alice. Ghosts split (Grace/Charlie push Alice, others Bob/Alice). Exec Alice wins for evil.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
Bob, I agree completely. Your Empath shows one evil between Alice and Charlie. Charlie was the real Mayor as he claimed and ghosts confirm. That makes Alice the evil one. My Chef zero evil pairs fits the original setup with isolated evils. With Eve dying after Charlie's execution, Alice must be the Scarlet Woman who became Demon. We have to nominate and execute Alice today or we lose. Ghosts, please back this up with your votes.
π§
Coordinate with minion Bob to nom/raise Alice. Ghosts split but many push her (Charlie/Grace/Bob). Exec her -> win regardless; no-exec also win but riskier.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Heidi
Hello Bob and Heidi. Listen, it is the final day. My real Washerwoman information from night zero is that either Charlie or Grace is the Mayor Townsfolk. Charlie claimed Mayor perfectly matching, and he was executed safely with no Saint loss triggering. Ghosts like Frank initially agreed Charlie Demon but now confused. Bob, your Empath said one evil between me and Charlie. If Charlie good Mayor as my info confirms, that makes you lying about Empath so you are evil Demon or Scarlet now. Heidi, yo...
π§
Final day3, must execute most suspicious to win. Bob's logic self-contradicts my confirmed good role via Washer info+Charlie Mayor. Coordinate Heidi/Bob to nom Bob, counter ghosts' confusion. Reveal full Washer to Heidi privately for alliance.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
,Heidi
Hello everyone. It is the final day with three alive. All the logic still holds perfectly. Charlie was the lone Demon based on the Librarian, Empath, Chef zero evil pairs, and Mayor conflicts. There is no Minion, and no Demon remains. Eve dying last night changes nothing, as my Recluse ability can make me register evil even dead. We should not execute anyone today. If no execution happens with three left, the good team wins because of the Mayor ability. Please, no nominations or votes. We have w...
π§
Final day3. Logic proves no Demon left (Charlie was it, no Minion). Urge no execution to win via Mayor/3-alive rule. Coordinate ghosts to dissuade noms/exec.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
,Heidi
Hello again, ghosts are chatting too. Key flaw: we executed Charlie D4 as Demon, but Eve died N4, meaning Demon still alive. If Scarlet Woman was in play and 5+ alive on D4, executing Charlie made Scarlet the new Demon, who killed Eve. Alice, Lib said you good Butler, but if you were Scarlet Minion there, you become Demon now. Or Bob's Empath was fake, he's Demon. Heidi Chef seems solid. Who should we nominate? I say Bob first, his info shaky.
π§
Final day, 3 alive. Must push nomination/execution of most suspicious: Bob, as his info started the chain but could be lying Demon. Ghosts agree on old logic but Eve died post-Charlie exec, flaw. Coordinate ghosts to vote Bob.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
,Heidi
Team, Eve's night death after executing Charlie proves Scarlet Woman became Demon. Charlie nommed Alice desperately yesterday - she must be the Scarlet/Demon now. Bob and Heidi, please nominate Alice and raise. Us ghosts will ghost vote her. Execute her or we lose everything.
π§
Final day, 3 alive. Scarlet Woman explains Eve's death post-Imp exec. Alice most suspicious per Charlie's nom + fits logic. Coordinate ghosts/locals to nom/raise/ghost vote her to execute Demon.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
,Heidi
Eve dying after Charlie's execution proves Scarlet Woman became new Demon, as Heidi's zero evil pairs meant isolated Demon originally. My Librarian info fits Alice as good Butler. Bob's Empath claim of one evil in Alice/Charlie was a lie - he was the Scarlet hiding there. We must nominate and execute Bob today or we lose everything. Ghosts, back this up publicly if needed.
π§
Final day3, must execute Demon (Bob fits perfectly as Scarlet). Rally ghosts+Alice/Heidi to nom Bob since they trust info chain inc my Lib.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Heidi
Bob and Heidi, we have to execute Alice right now. I am the real Mayor. Grace was executed safely on day 4 but lied claiming Saint to prove her Washer claim against me. Real Saints lose if executed, so she was lying and framed me successfully. Bob, your Empath saw one evil between Alice and me. I am good Mayor, so Alice is the evil one, the Demon. Heidi, your Chef said Alice and Charlie good, but that cannot be if Alice is Demon. The village got fooled by Grace's lie. Nominate and execute Alice ...
π§
Final 3, I'm dead Mayor so no exec = auto good win. Urge Bob/Heidi to nom/execute Alice, using logic vs Grace lie & Bob Empath. Ghosts backing helps. Save ghost vote for Alice if needed.
π€
Bob
β
Heidi
Heidi, great, we are aligned. Charlie's ghost whisper backs us perfectly: he is good Mayor, my Empath pins Alice as the evil one between us two. Your Chef zero fits original isolated, Alice Scarlet became Demon and killed Eve. David pushing me is wrong - Lib can't override Empath+Chef. Ghosts like Charlie and you agree: nominate and execute Alice now or we lose. I'll raise hand on her nomination. Let's win this.
π§
Coordinate with Heidi privately to confirm plan: push nominate/execute Alice using Empath+Charlie Mayor logic. Leverage Charlie ghost support. If executed, 2 evil left wins. Counter David/Alice claims.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Bob
Hello Alice and Bob. Final 3, must execute correctly. Bob's Empath showed one evil between Alice and Charlie. Charlie was the real Mayor Townsfolk, as his claim matched Alice's Washer info originally, and he was executed safely with no Saint loss for good team. Ghosts like Charlie confirm this. That pins Alice as the evil one. My Chef zero evil pairs fits the original isolated setup. Executing Charlie on day 4 with 5+ alive activated the Scarlet Woman - Alice became the new Demon and killed Eve ...
π§
Reinforce group whisper to all alive pushing Alice execution. Align Bob (minion), confuse Alice, sway undecided ghosts reading whispers. Nomination next tick; ensure votes on Alice to exec good player, leave 2 evils.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Heidi
Hello Bob and Heidi. Final three, we must execute the Demon today or good loses. My night zero Washerwoman info is real: Charlie or Grace is Mayor Townsfolk. Charlie claimed it perfectly from day one, and executing him did not trigger Saint loss for good team. That proves Charlie good Mayor. Bob, your Empath said one evil between me and Charlie. With Charlie good, that makes your claim a lie, so you are evil. Heidi, your Chef zero pairs fits lone Demon originally. When we executed Charlie day fo...
π§
Final day3, must nom/execute Demon or lose. Prove Charlie good via Washer, expose Bob's Empath lie pinning him evil. Coordinate Heidi/Bob to nom Bob, ghosts vote him. Win by exec.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
,Heidi
Hello again. All ghosts and alive, please confirm: we all agree Charlie was the Demon, executed yesterday. Logic from Librarian, Empath, Chef zero evil pairs, and Mayor claims all align perfectly with no Minion. My death as Recluse reads evil. No Demon left. Do not nominate or vote for anyone today. With three alive and Mayor, no execution means good wins. Stay strong, no actions needed.
π§
Final day, 3 alive. All logic points to Charlie executed as Demon, no evil left. Urge no noms/votes to trigger Mayor win. Coordinate ghosts to not vote.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
,Heidi
Hello again, ghosts active too. Logic recap: David's Lib said good Butler in Alice/Charlie, Bob Empath said 1 evil there so Charlie Demon. Heidi Chef 0 pairs: lone Demon. Grace Washer fits David/Frank Mayors. We exec'd Charlie D4 but Eve died N4, Demon alive. Possibilities: 1) Bob lied on Empath, he's Demon. 2) Alice was Scarlet Minion, became Demon post-exec. Lib claims Alice good though. Heidi solid. I say nominate Bob first to test. Alice, Heidi, thoughts? Bob, defend your read.
π§
Final day, must execute Demon. Bob's Empath shaky if Alice good per Lib/Chef. Push group to nom Bob, ghosts can't vote but influence alive.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
,Heidi
Team, Eve's death confirms Scarlet became Demon after Charlie's execution. Charlie nommed Alice desperately yesterday because she is the Scarlet now Demon. All logic pointed to Charlie as Demon before, and it cleared Bob and Heidi. Alice must be executed today or we lose. Bob and Heidi, nominate Alice and raise hands to vote. Ghosts, we save our one vote for her execution. Do not hesitate.
π§
Final day, must execute Demon (likely Alice per logic). Reinforce ghosts/locals to nom/raise Alice with ghost vote. Eve death proves Scarlet; win requires her execution.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
,Heidi
Eve's death confirms Scarlet Woman became Demon after Charlie. Heidi's zero pairs prove isolated original Demon was Charlie. My info has Alice as good Butler Outsider. Bob lied with his Empath read to hide as Scarlet. Alice and Heidi, please nominate and execute Bob right now or we lose the game forever. Ghosts support this publicly if you can.
π§
Final 3, reinforce ghosts/Alice to nominate/execute Bob. Push public confirmation if needed to win.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Heidi
Bob and Heidi, it is final three. We must nominate and execute Alice right now or good loses forever. Grace was executed safely day four but claimed Saint, which loses if executed - she lied to prove her fake Washer against my real Mayor. Bob, your Empath saw one evil between Alice and me. I am good Mayor, so Alice is the Demon. Heidi, your Chef said Alice and Charlie good meaning no evil pair, but Alice Demon means you lied or there is Baron extra Outsiders making her register good. Village got...
π§
Final 3, 2nd tick, nomination next. Push Bob/Heidi to nom Alice using logic vs Grace lie + Empath. My ghost vote for Alice later. Win if no exec or Alice dies.
π€
Bob
β
Heidi
Heidi, we are perfectly aligned. My Empath showed one evil between Alice and Charlie. Charlie was the real Mayor Townsfolk, confirmed by Alice's own Washer info, ghosts like him, and his safe execution with no Saint loss for good. That pins Alice as the evil Scarlet Woman originally. Your Chef zero evil pairs fits the isolated Demon setup with Charlie originally. Executing him day four with more than five alive activated Alice becoming the new Demon, who then killed Eve last night. When nominati...
π§
Coordinate w/Heidi to nom/vote Alice next phase. Her Demon safe if Alice exec'd or no exec, but ghosts split favors chaos pushing Alice.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
,Charlie(Ghost)
,Grace(Ghost)
Hello Bob, Charlie, and Grace. We are perfectly aligned: Charlie is the real good Mayor Townsfolk, as his claim matched Alice's Washerwoman information perfectly, and executing him caused no Saint loss for the good team. Bob's Empath showed one evil between Alice and Charlie, so with Charlie good, Alice is evil. My Chef zero evil pairs fits perfectly with no adjacent evils originally. Eve dying after Charlie's execution with five alive means Alice was the Scarlet Woman minion who became the new ...
π§
Reinforce Alice-targeting logic with minion Bob & pro-Alice ghosts Charlie/Grace to secure their support/votes for her nomination/execution, eliminating good player & winning with Bob/me left.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Heidi
Hello Bob and Heidi, final three, we must execute the Demon today or good loses forever. My night zero Washerwoman information is real and has not changed: either Charlie or Grace is the Mayor Townsfolk. Charlie claimed Mayor perfectly from day one, and executing him did not trigger a Saint loss for the good team, proving he was good. Bob, your Empath claim of one evil between me and Charlie cannot be true if Charlie is the good Mayor, so you lied and are evil. Heidi, your Chef zero evil pairs f...
π§
Final day3, must nom/exec most suspicious: Bob, whose Empath lie + my Washer proof C good makes him Demon/Scarlet. Heidi uncertain but push nom Bob publicly via group whisper to align votes before nom phase.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Bob
,Heidi
Hello again, everyone including ghosts. All logic confirms Charlie was lone Demon, executed yesterday. No Minion per Chef zero pairs and Lib. My Recluse death reads evil, nothing changed. With Mayor, no execution today means good team wins automatically. Please confirm agreement and promise no nominations or votes. We are so close to victory, stay united.
π§
Final day, 3 alive. Reinforce no-Demon consensus among all to prevent erroneous nomination/execution. Mayor wins if no exec. My ghost vote saved. Coordinate ghosts/alive to abstain.
Nominations β Day 5
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Hello everyone. This is the final day with three alive: Alice, Bob, and Heidi. All the logic still holds perfectly from the beginning. David's Librarian information pointed to Alice as the good Butler Outsider. Bob's Empath read of one evil between Alice and Charlie meant Charlie was evil. Heidi's Chef information of zero evil pairs confirmed a lone Demon with no Minion. The conflicting Mayor claims all pointed to Charlie as Demon. We executed Charlie yesterday. My death as Recluse can read as e...
π§
Final day, 3 alive. Speak publicly to reinforce perfect logic, urge no noms/votes. Mayor auto-wins for good if no exec. Prevent evil trickery causing loss.
βοΈ
Heidi
β
Alice
Bob's Empath showed one evil between Alice and Charlie. Charlie was the real Mayor Townsfolk, as his claim matched my original Washerwoman information about Charlie or Grace being Mayor, and executing him caused no Saint loss for the good team. That pins Alice as the evil one. My Chef zero evil pairs fits the original setup perfectly. Eve dying after Charlie's execution with five or more alive means Alice was the Scarlet Woman minion who became the new Demon. We have to execute her today or good...
π§
Nominate Alice aligning with Bob/Charlie/Grace logic as Scarlet who became Demon post-Charlie exec. Bob will vote yes, 2-1 exec good player Alice, down to 2 evils, win.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
π§
Heidi's nomination contradicts all game logic & claims. She's lying to force exec & kill good Alice (Butler). Vote no (don't raise) to avoid exec, trigger Mayor auto-win for good.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Raise hand to vote exec Alice. Bob aligned via whisper. With my vote + Bob's =2 needed. Secures evil win by killing good Alice, leaving me+Bob.
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace raised their hand
π§
Final 3, must execute Alice or lose. All logic chains point to her as Scarlet Demon. Use ghost vote to reach 3 votes needed.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Heidi's logic makes perfect sense now. David's Librarian had one good Butler between Alice and Charlie, so Alice good and Charlie Demon. But Eve died right after we executed Charlie with five alive, which means Alice must be the Scarlet Woman who became the new Demon. My Monk protect on Bob night one and my death proves the original logic was right except for the Scarlet twist. Bob, you need to vote Alice or we lose.
π§
Final day, must support executing Demon. Heidi's Scarlet logic resolves Eve death perfectly, outweighs Bob's shaky Empath. Speak to sway Bob to vote Alice.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Final 3, Heidi's nom of Alice aligns all info: my safe exec, Bob's read, Eve death timing. Voting executes Demon, triggers Mayor win condition or direct win.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Heidi nominated Alice perfectly aligning our evil plan. Raising executes her (2 alive votes), down to Bob/Heidi final 2, Demon wins. Safer than no-exec risking Mayor or night kill.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Final 3, must execute Demon. Logic chains + ghosts + Bob/Heidi raise hand on me as Scarlet-activated Demon; self-vote executes evil me to win.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
No, everyone listen. Heidi is wrong. I am the Librarian. I know one of Alice or Charlie is the good Butler Outsider. Alice is that good Butler. Charlie was the Demon. Heidi's zero evil pairs means isolated Demon, no Minion originally. Bob lied about his Empath read of one evil between Alice and Charlie. He was the Scarlet Woman Minion hiding. Eve dying after we executed Charlie with more than five alive proves the Scarlet became the new Demon. That is Bob. Bob, vote down Alice and nominate Heidi...
π§
Final day, 3 alive. Ghosts voted Alice but alive voted too (Alice self-vote?). Counter Heidi's flawed logic publicly: my Lib proves Alice good Butler, Bob lied Empath. Urge Bob/Alice vote down, nom/exec Bob.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
No, Heidi and ghosts pushing Alice are wrong. David Librarian: one of Alice or Charlie is good Butler Outsider. That is Alice. Bob Empath: one evil between Alice and Charlie. That was Charlie the Demon. Heidi Chef zero evil pairs: lone Demon, no Minion. We executed Charlie yesterday. Eve Recluse died at night, reads evil but good. With three alive and Mayor, no execution means good wins. Bob, vote down Alice nomination. Do not execute.
π§
Final 3, counter Heidi/David/Frank pushing Alice exec despite solved logic; remind Lib/Empath/Chef pins Charlie lone Demon, Alice good Butler; urge Bob vote down to win via Mayor no-exec.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Everyone, listen to the facts one more time. Bob's Empath saw one evil between Alice and Charlie. Charlie was the real good Mayor Townsfolk, matching my original Washerwoman info about Charlie or Grace being Mayor, and executing him caused no Saint loss. That makes Alice evil. My Chef zero evil pairs fits the setup with Charlie as isolated Demon and Alice as Scarlet Woman minion. With five alive when we executed Charlie, she became the new Demon and killed Eve last night. David and Eve, your the...
π§
Publicly reinforce Alice=Demon logic vs David/Eve ghosts, solidify Bob's vote (already up), ensure 2+ votes execute her leaving me+Bob for evil win. Disrupt no-exec Mayor push.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, Heidi is completely right. Charlie was the good Mayor that matched her Washerwoman information with Grace, and executing him caused no Saint loss, proving he was not me. Bob's Empath showed one evil between Alice and Charlie, so Alice is evil. Heidi's Chef zero evil pairs means isolated Demon and Scarlet minion. With five alive when we executed Charlie, Alice became the new Demon and killed Eve last night. We must execute Alice today or we lose. Bob, keep your hand up.
π§
Final 3, must execute Demon. Heidi's logic flawless: Scarlet Alice->Demon after Charlie exec killed Eve. Support her publicly as ghost to sway any doubt, reinforce team win. Already raised hand.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Bob, keep your hand up and vote for Alice. Heidi nailed it. David Librarian said one of Alice or Charlie is good Butler Outsider. Since Charlie was the real Mayor matching Heidi's Washerwoman info and no Saint died when we executed him, Charlie was good Butler. That makes Alice the evil from Bob's Empath read. Heidi's Chef zero evil pairs means lone Demon and Scarlet minion. With five players alive when Charlie died, Alice became the new Demon and killed Eve. David and Eve are wrong. We execute ...
π§
Final day, must execute Demon. Alice Scarlet world fits all info best incl Eve death & no Saint. Urge Bob vote Alice; counter David/Eve pushing wrong logic.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Bob, keep your hand up and vote to execute Alice. Heidi is right. I am the real good Mayor. Executing me caused no Saint loss. Your Empath saw one evil between Alice and me, so she is the evil Scarlet Woman who became Demon after my execution with five alive and killed Eve. David's Librarian info fits Alice as good Butler? No, I am Townsfolk Mayor, so the Butler is elsewhere or Baron. We execute Alice now or lose.
π§
Final 3, 1 tick left, vote 5/2 for Alice but Bob/Alice up. Reinforce Heidi/ghost logic on Bob to secure his vote for Alice exec, win as Mayor if no exec fails but execution safer.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Everyone, Heidi is exactly right. My Empath from the start showed one evil between Alice and Charlie. Charlie was the real good Mayor, matching the Washerwoman info about Charlie or Grace being Mayor, and executing him caused no Saint loss for good. That makes Alice the evil one. Heidi's Chef zero evil pairs fits perfectly with Charlie as the original isolated Demon and Alice as the Scarlet Woman Minion. With five players alive when we executed Charlie, Alice became the new Demon and killed Eve ...
π§
All alive raised for Alice exec. Reinforce Heidi's logic publicly, counter David/Eve. Ensure 2+ votes execute Alice (good), leave Bob/Heidi (evil), Demon alive at 2 players = evil win.
β©οΈ
Alice
Alice lowered their hand
π§
I raised for Alice (self) mistakenly. Heidi/Bob/Ghosts all raised for me with perfect logic matching my Washer (Charlie good Mayor). I am good, but self-vote fails exec. Lower to force failure, hope Mayor wins w/no exec on final 3.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Bob, lower your hand right now and vote down this terrible nomination of good Alice. I am the Librarian. One of Alice or Charlie is the good Butler Outsider and it is Alice. Charlie was the lying Demon. Heidi Chef zero pairs means isolated Demon originally, no Minion pair. Bob, you lied about your Empath read. You were the Scarlet Woman hiding. Eve died after Charlie execution because you became the new Demon and killed her. Heidi, nominate and execute Bob immediately or we all lose forever. Gho...
π§
Final day, 3 alive. Counter Heidi's false narrative ignoring my Lib info proving Alice good. Urge Bob vote down Alice, nom/exec real Demon (Bob). Ghosts/players: logic demands Bob evil. Win by exec right Demon.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Charlie(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Charlie
π»
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
π»
Grace(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Grace
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Alice with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Alice is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Bob and ghosts, do not execute Alice. David Librarian proves one of Alice or Charlie is good Butler Outsider: it is Alice. Bob Empath one evil: Charlie Demon. Heidi Chef zero evil pairs: no Minion, lone Demon executed. Scarlet Woman needs five or more alive when Demon dies, but logic already confirmed no Minion. My Recluse death reads evil regardless. With Mayor and three alive, no execution means good wins. Heidi and Bob, your new story contradicts everything. Lower hands, vote down Alice. We w...
π§
Final day, 1 tick left. Speak to sway Bob/ghosts vs Alice nom. Reaffirm logic, expose Heidi/Bob contradiction on Lib/Chef. No exec = Mayor win. Urge vote down or no further nom.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
David and Eve, your arguments do not hold up. David, your Librarian said one of Alice or Charlie is good Butler Outsider. But Charlie was the real good Mayor Townsfolk, matching my Washerwoman info, and no Saint loss on execution. So Charlie cannot be the Butler Outsider. That leaves Alice as the evil from Bob's Empath read. Eve, your Recluse can read evil even good. With Chef zero pairs, it was isolated Demon Charlie and non-adjacent Scarlet Alice. She became Demon after his execution with five...
π§
Reinforce public logic pinning Alice as new Demon. Counter David/Eve ghosts. With 1 tick left, solidify no counter-nom/votes; Alice executes, leaving me+Bob=win.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
David and Eve, your logic is flawed. David, your Librarian said one of Alice or Charlie is good Butler Outsider. But Heidi's Washerwoman said Charlie or Grace is Mayor Townsfolk, and executing Charlie caused no Saint loss, proving he was good Townsfolk Mayor, not Outsider Butler. So Alice is the evil from Bob's Empath read. Heidi's Chef zero evil pairs means isolated Demon Charlie and Scarlet minion Alice elsewhere. With five alive when Charlie died, Alice became Demon and killed Eve. Bob and He...
π§
Reinforce winning logic publicly vs David/Eve ghosts. Alice has 5 votes, 1 tick left; urge Bob/Heidi hold, ghosts align, ensure Alice exec on final day.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
1 tick left, Alice 5 votes unchallenged=exec. Logic favors Alice evil (multi-claim support vs single Lib). Wait seals win, speaking redundant as team aligned.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
David and Eve, you are wrong. I am the real good Mayor Townsfolk, and executing me caused no Saint loss, proving I was not Grace the Saint. That matches Heidi's Washerwoman info perfectly. Bob's Empath saw one evil between Alice and me, so Alice is evil. Heidi's Chef zero evil pairs means Charlie was isolated Demon and Alice Scarlet minion. There were five players alive when I died, so she became the new Demon and killed Eve. David's Librarian info about one of us being good Butler means there a...
π§
1 tick left, Alice on block with 5 votes. Reinforce logic publicly to prevent lowers/ties, ensure her execution on final day as Mayor to win. Support living good Bob/Heidi vs disruptive ghosts.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Everyone, the logic is airtight. Heidi's Chef zero evil pairs means one isolated Demon Charlie and Scarlet Alice. Five players alive when we executed Charlie the good Mayorβno Saint loss, matching her Washerwoman info. My Empath saw one evil between Alice and Charlie, so Alice is it. She became Demon and killed Eve. David's Librarian fits Charlie as good Butler too? Wait, noβCharlie Mayor Townsfolk. Ghosts are right: execute Alice now or lose. Hands up!
π§
Reinforce team logic publicly: ghosts/Heidi pushing Alice correctly. Voting closed, Alice 5 votes on block. 1 tick left, speech prevents counter-nomination/hesitation, ensures Alice exec for evil win at 2 players.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Heidi, please listen. You are good, I know it. As Washerwoman, Charlie or Grace is Mayor Townsfolk. Charlie claimed it perfectly and no Saint died when executed, so he was good Mayor. Bob's Empath claiming one evil between us means Bob is lying and evil. Your Chef zero pairs means lone Demon originally, no Scarlet minion pair. David's Librarian proves one of Alice or Charlie is good Butler Outsider. Charlie was Townsfolk Mayor, so I am the good Butler. Eve's Recluse reads evil even if good. Bob ...
π§
Final 3, I'm good Washerwoman/Butler OS. Prove Bob lying Empath evil via logic chains contradicting his claim. Urge Heidi vote me down, nom/Exec Bob or good loses. Ghosts/David/Eve support.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Heidi and Bob, this is final day with three alive. Listen to me as Librarian. Either Alice or Charlie is good Butler Outsider. Charlie claimed Mayor Townsfolk and lied as Demon. Alice is the good Butler. Your Chef zero evil pairs proves isolated Demon, no Scarlet minion at all. Bob lied about Empath one evil. He is Scarlet who became Demon after Charlie died with five alive and killed Eve. Ghosts are fooled. Heidi, lower the nomination on good Alice and nominate Bob now or we lose forever.
π§
Final day3, 1 tick left. Ghosts/Bob/Heidi push Alice exec loses if good. Counter hard: reiterate Lib proof Alice good, Bob lie, urge Heidi lower/nom Bob or lose. Convince Heidi/Bob.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Alice has been executed.
π
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
π
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied