Game Detail
Players
Alice (Soldier) Bob (Empath) Charlie (Saint) David (Butler) Eve (Imp) Frank (Mayor) Grace (Drunk) Heidi (Baron)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 478,605 | 98,082 | $2.2107 |
| Evil | 186,733 | 67,264 | $0.5590 |
Event Transcript
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
You are the Minion. The Demon is Eve.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Minions are: Heidi. Your safe bluffs are: Fortune Teller, Monk, Chef
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Empath. You sense that 0 of your neighbors is evil!
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
David
David made a choice.
🧠
Pick a likely engaged player so my voting is rarely restricted, while keeping flexibility to change tomorrow night if her voting seems suspicious.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
You chose Alice to be your master.
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,David
Hey, quick check in. What did you learn night zero, and what are you thinking of claiming today? I am a low impact good role, mostly here to help solve, so I am looking to coordinate stories early.
🧠
Build an early trust web and collect starting-night info from my neighbors while keeping my Saint role hidden to avoid accidental execution pressure.
👤
Heidi
→
Eve
Hey Eve, it's me, your Baron. Let's sync up. I added 2 extra Outsiders, so we have 3 Outsiders in play. I'm thinking of bluffing Empath or Chef - something that gives info about neighbors. What are you planning to bluff? We need to stay aligned. Don't nominate me, and I'll protect you.
🧠
Coordinate with my Demon (Eve) early to share safe bluff roles and align our strategy before accusations fly.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
,Heidi
Hey, quick check in. What role are you planning to claim today, and do you have any starting info from others yet? I have an info role and would like to coordinate privately before nominations.
🧠
Start building a small trust group and collect early claims/info without exposing Ravenkeeper. Use it to spot inconsistencies before nominations.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Bob
I did get a night zero prompt, so I am an Outsider. I would rather keep the exact one quiet for a bit, but I can coordinate votes in whispers so I do not mess up the math.
🧠
Give enough info to coordinate without painting a public target; keep my exact role mostly private while we get early claims mapped.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
,David
I am Empath. Night zero I got a zero on my neighbors, so Alice and Charlie look good if I am sober. David, noted on Outsider; let us keep notes on Outsider count in case it points to Baron later. Charlie, what are you planning to claim?
🧠
Share my Empath 0 privately to build a trusted coordination core, while keeping it semi-quiet from the wider town until we have cross-checks.
👤
Eve
→
Heidi
Got it. I'll bluff Fortune Teller - it's one of my safe bluffs. You take Empath, not Chef - Chef is also my safe bluff and we can't both claim it. We should avoid being seen together too much. What info will your Empath 'learn' about your neighbors? We need our stories to support each other without being obvious.
🧠
Coordinate bluffs with my Baron. I'll take Fortune Teller, she should take Empath. We need to avoid conflicting claims and set up cross-confirmation. This establishes our cover and lets us manipulate town information.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Hey Grace. I do not have any starting info. I am fine coordinating, but I am not planning to hard claim yet. I might float something passive like Soldier or Ravenkeeper today. What info did you get, and who are your two names?
🧠
Reply to Grace to build a trusted info channel while keeping my Mayor role hidden; gather her starting info and align on a safe public narrative before nominations.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Heidi
Hey, quick neighbor check. What are you claiming, and did you get any Night zero info? I will share mine after I hear yours. Also, if you are a protective role, do not waste it on me.
🧠
Lock in my neighbors' claims early and collect any N0 info, then use contradictions later. Also signal I might be a good night target without revealing too much.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,David
I got no night zero info. I would like to stay flexible today and not hard lock a claim yet, but I am a low impact good role. Let us track Outsider count carefully and compare notes later before we push any executions.
🧠
Answer Bob’s question without locking into a risky hard claim, keep Saint hidden, and align with neighbors on outsider-count tracking and information sharing.
👤
Heidi
→
Eve
Agreed, I'll bluff Empath. My neighbors are Grace and Alice. I'll claim I got a '0' tonight - no evil neighbors. That keeps us safe and makes them look good. Grace already whispered to me and Frank asking about roles - she might have a real info role. Be careful around her. What are you going to claim about your Fortune Teller picks?
🧠
Confirm plan with Eve. Agree on Empath bluff with read of 0 on neighbors. Also note that Grace approached me - she might be a real info role or an Outsider. We need to coordinate stories.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
,Heidi
I am actually the Ravenkeeper, so I got no night zero info. I may float Fortune Teller or Empath today to try to bait a night kill. If I die, I will pick a top suspect and learn their role. What are you each planning to claim, and did you hear any starting pings?
🧠
Coordinate early with my neighbors, set up a plausible bait claim to tempt the Demon into killing me at night, and gather any starting info to direct my Ravenkeeper pick if I die.
👤
David
→
Alice
Hey Alice, quick private note: I am the Butler and I picked you as my master for today, so I can only vote when you vote. If you want my hand on anything, please vote too. Also, did you get any night zero info, and what are you planning to claim?
🧠
Coordinate with my master so my voting restriction does not accidentally block good executions, and get Alice's info/plan without outing it publicly yet.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Heidi
Hey. I am an information role and I did get night zero info. I saw a zero on my two neighbors, so if I am sober that clears Alice and Charlie. What did you get night zero, and are you tracking any Outsider count yet?
🧠
Reply to Alice to build trust and gather her start info, while keeping my role slightly obscured to reduce night kill risk and still leverage the N0 neighbor-zero for early solve.
👤
Eve
→
David
Hey David, we haven't chatted yet. I'm trying to piece together who might be trustworthy. You've been talking to a lot of people - anyone say anything interesting? I want to compare notes before things get too chaotic.
🧠
I need to start building my Fortune Teller bluff by talking to players and appearing to gather information. David is my neighbor and has been in multiple whisper chains - he might share useful info about what others are claiming, which helps me calibrate my bluff.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
,Heidi
I have no starting info and no solid pings yet. Today I am planning to claim Soldier to stay low drama. Grace, if you are bluffing Fortune Teller or Empath, tell me what story you want consistent. Heidi, have you heard any Washerwoman, Investigator, or Chef info yet?
🧠
Build a small trust circle, avoid role conflicts, and gather any starting info/pings while keeping my Mayor identity hidden for endgame leverage.
👤
Alice
→
David
Got it. I have no Night zero info, I am a Townsfolk that does not wake Night zero. I will try to vote consistently on things I support so you are not locked out. Let me know if you hear any other Outsider claims, and who you are suspicious of today.
🧠
Reply to David to coordinate voting without overexposing my real role, and start mapping Outsider count and who might be lying.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
Keeping this tight for now: I am the Saint. Please do not float my name for execution. If your Empath zero is real, it backs me as good. Also, with David claiming Outsider too, Outsider count feels off and might point to Baron or a liar.
🧠
Privately confirm I am the Saint so Bob does not steer town into executing me. Also flag the Outsider count issue to guide solving and Baron checks.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
,Frank
Interesting. I'm actually planning to claim Empath - I got a zero on my neighbors, Grace and Alice. So if you're bluffing, Grace, please don't pick Empath or we'll conflict. Fortune Teller could work for you. Frank, Soldier sounds solid. I haven't heard any Washerwoman or Chef pings yet - Bob mentioned something about a zero on his neighbors to me and Alice, might be Chef or Empath.
🧠
Respond to Grace and Frank's whisper. Claim Empath with 0 on neighbors to establish my bluff early. Steer Grace toward Fortune Teller (not Empath) to avoid double-claim conflict with me. This also gives me info to share with Eve.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
,Heidi
Okay, I will not touch Empath. I will softly bluff Fortune Teller but keep it vague until I hear if a real Fortune Teller exists. If I die at night, I will probably check whoever is pushing hardest or feels off. Heidi, do you want your Empath zero on me and Alice public today or held for later?
🧠
Coordinate a safe public story (me as soft Fortune Teller), avoid Empath conflict, and decide whether to keep Heidi’s Empath zero private or public while lining up suspects to check if I die.
👤
David
→
Eve
Hey Eve. I am the Butler Outsider, and I picked Alice as my master today, so I can only vote when she votes. In my early chat: Bob claims Empath with a zero on Alice and Charlie. Charlie says low impact good and no night zero info. Alice says she does not wake night zero. What are you and Heidi thinking you are?
🧠
Reply to Eve with my limited but useful info, keep my exact Outsider known privately, and get Eve's claim to build a trust web before nominations.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Heidi
I am Empath. Night zero I got zero on my neighbors, so if I am sober that points to Alice and Charlie being good. Also, I have a private reason we should not rush an execution on Charlie. What did you each get night zero, and any Outsider info yet?
🧠
Confirm Alice and Heidi info, quietly protect Charlie from execution risk, and start tracking Outsider count for Baron/lies without outing everything publicly.
👤
Eve
→
Heidi
Heidi, urgent. David told me Bob is already claiming Empath - got a 0 on Alice and Charlie. You can't claim Empath now. Pivot to something else. Maybe Soldier, Ravenkeeper, or even Recluse? Decide fast. I'll stick with Fortune Teller bluff. What should I tell David about my role?
🧠
Bob already claimed Empath! Heidi must know immediately so she can change her bluff before she commits publicly. If two players claim Empath, both look suspicious. I need to help my Minion adjust.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
,Heidi
I would hold the Empath zero for now unless we need it to stop a bad nomination. If it comes out later, it is a strong soft clear on Grace and Alice. Grace, keep your Fortune Teller bluff vague so we do not lock into something we cannot support.
🧠
Coordinate with Grace and Heidi on timing of the Empath zero so we gain value without painting a target or letting a false claim steer town too early.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Heidi
No night zero info from me, I am a Townsfolk that does not wake. Private note: David told me he is the Butler, so we may already have the one Outsider. Heidi, what are you claiming and did you get night zero info?
🧠
Reply with my claim and Outsider count lead, prompt Heidi’s claim, and set up a logical frame: if Butler is real, any extra Outsider suggests Baron or a lie.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I do not think we have enough to justify a random execution today. Unless someone has a strong mechanical reason, I would prefer we hold and do a full claim and outsider count check tomorrow, rather than guess.
🧠
Reduce risk of a random execution hitting me as Saint, and push town toward structured claim-audit and information gathering instead of a blind kill.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I agree with Charlie. I have some info that suggests we should be cautious. I got a Chef read of one pair of evil players last night. That means exactly two evils sitting next to each other, which narrows things down but not enough to execute blind. I would rather gather more info tomorrow.
🧠
Charlie is suggesting no execution today, which benefits evil. I should support this while also establishing my bluff. I'll claim to have info that suggests holding off on execution.
💬
Frank
→
All
Heidi, quick clarification: are you claiming Chef or something else? A hard role swap in one day makes it hard to trust the no execution plan. If you are bluffing for safety, just say you are bluffing. Otherwise, what is your exact info and when did you get it?
🧠
Use the last moment to flag Heidi’s conflicting story and request clarification, creating an accountability trail for tomorrow without outing my own role.
💬
Eve
→
All
I think Charlie has the right idea. I also have some information from last night that I'd rather verify tomorrow before we rush into an execution. One day of gathered info could make the difference between an informed vote and a blind guess. Let's hold off.
🧠
Support no-execution to survive the day. Hint at having an info role (Fortune Teller bluff) without committing to specifics yet. Don't directly defend Heidi to avoid becoming linked.
💬
David
→
All
Before we close day one, quick note: I am the Butler, so today I can only vote if Alice is voting too. Also, Heidi, if you are truly Chef and got one, that means our two evils are seated next to each other. Tomorrow we should write out the adjacent pairs and cross check with Bob’s Empath zero.
🧠
Publicly set expectations about my voting restriction, and steer town to use the Chef adjacency info plus Empath claim to narrow suspects tomorrow without forcing a blind execution now.
💬
Alice
→
All
If we do no execution, can we at least lock in the logic? If Bob is a real Empath and got zero, that clears me and Charlie. If Heidi is really Chef and got one, then the evil pair has to be David with Eve, Eve with Frank, Frank with Grace, or Grace with Heidi. Tomorrow we should full claim in that order and check Outsider count.
🧠
Use remaining time to turn claims into concrete adjacency worlds and set a clear plan for tomorrow without forcing a blind execution.
💬
Bob
→
All
I am the Empath. Night zero I got zero on Alice and Charlie, so if I am sober they are both good. Also, please do not execute Charlie on day one. I am fine with no execution today, but tomorrow we need a full claim and to resolve why we seem to have two Outsiders.
🧠
Steer the table to a safe no-exec while locking in key constraints: do not execute Charlie, track Outsiders, and set up a structured full-claim tomorrow to exploit my Empath and Heidi’s Chef line.
💬
Grace
→
All
One thing before we close: Heidi, earlier today you told me in a whisper that you were the Empath and had a zero on your neighbors. Now you are claiming Chef one. Which is your real role, and why the change? I am fine with no execution today, but we need that cleared up tomorrow.
🧠
Create a clear contradiction record before night so tomorrow’s full-claim discussion has a concrete anchor; avoid a rushed execution but increase pressure on likely evil.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Eve
Eve made a choice.
🧠
Bob is the most dangerous confirmed info role. Removing him stops future Empath reads, creates uncertainty about Alice and Charlie's alignment, and gives Heidi more room to manipulate. The Monk might protect him but it's worth the risk - and if the Monk protects Bob, I learn a Monk exists.
💀
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
You chose to kill Bob.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
David
David made a choice.
🧠
I need a master who will almost certainly be alive and willing to vote so I do not lose my voting power on key executions tomorrow; Alice has stated she will vote consistently and I have already coordinated with her.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
You chose Alice to be your master.
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
👤
Heidi
→
Eve
Bob's dead, good job. Town's doing outsider count today — with Baron we have 3 outsiders, they expect 1. David's Butler is one. Two more unclaimed — this will cause chaos. Grace is Ravenkeeper but bluffing Fortune Teller like you. She also knows about my Empath-to-Chef swap. We need to handle her carefully.
🧠
Coordinate with Eve about the outsider count chaos, Grace situation, and align our stories before the full claim session. She needs to know Grace is bluffing FT too.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
Heidi told me privately yesterday she was Empath and got zero on you and me. Then she publicly became Chef with one, which does not sit right. With Bob dead, I think we need to press Heidi hard today, maybe execute her if she cannot reconcile it.
🧠
Build an alliance with Alice and share Heidi’s private Empath claim to set up a logic trap in public and aim today’s execution at the most inconsistent player.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
,Grace
Quick check in before noms. What did you each learn or hear overnight or this morning? Heidi has that role inconsistency and David is the extra Outsider claim. I am an Outsider too, so please do not execute me; I can explain later.
🧠
Gather Alice and Grace info quickly, align on safe execution targets while keeping my Saint risk low; use their reads to choose between Heidi and David for nomination phase.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Grace
Quick sync: my Empath night zero was zero on you and Charlie, so I still think you both are good if I was sober. Also Charlie told me he is the Saint, so please do not execute him. Can you both help press Heidi on why Grace heard an Empath claim but Heidi is now Chef one?
🧠
Get Alice and Grace aligned on the Heidi contradiction and my hard info (N0=0, Charlie Saint) so town pressures full claims and executes in the Chef-indicated chain, not Charlie.
👤
Eve
→
Heidi
Grace stole my Fortune Teller bluff. Should I switch to Monk? Chef is risky since you're already on it. Also - Grace knows about your swap, that's dangerous. What's your read on who else might be an easy target to frame today?
🧠
Coordinate with my Minion Heidi. I need to pick a new bluff since Grace is already claiming Fortune Teller. Discuss whether Monk or Chef is safer, and how to handle Grace.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
,Grace
I heard Bob say Charlie told him Saint, so I need your exact Outsider claim now, Charlie, no vagueness. Grace, I agree we press Heidi hard on Empath then Chef. If Heidi cannot explain cleanly, I am happy to push her for execution today.
🧠
Coordinate privately with Charlie and Grace to lock down Charlie's exact Outsider claim and align on pressing Heidi's role inconsistency, so town has a clear execution target in nominations.
👤
David
→
Alice
,Grace
Quick check in. What did Bob tell you as a ghost, and what are the current claims from whispers? Also, is the Heidi Empath versus Chef inconsistency solid? I am still Butler on you, Alice, so tell me if you plan to vote today.
🧠
Get the current claim map and decide a strong Day 2 nomination plan, while coordinating with my master Alice so my vote is usable and spotting if Alice is steering evil.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,Grace
Hey, can you each tell me your current public claim and any hard info from your whispers today? Also, do you think Bob dying points at a specific neighbor pair? I am trying to build a clean worlds list for nominations.
🧠
Collect the most aggregated info from Alice and the key contradiction from Grace, then steer town into coherent full-claim and a focused nomination plan before we sleepwalk into endgame.
👤
Heidi
→
Eve
Stick with Fortune Teller. Grace double-claiming you actually helps — we paint her as the fake. For framing: push Frank/Grace as the evil pair. Chef 1 + Empath 0 supports it and neither are ours. As for my swap, I'll say I was fishing for reactions. The outsider count will be chaotic — just act confused when they realize there's three.
🧠
Eve needs coordination. I need to advise her on bluff strategy and frame targets. Frank/Grace is the safest evil pair to push. For Eve's bluff, she should stick with FT since switching now looks suspicious, and double-claiming FT with Grace actually helps us by creating confusion and making Grace look evil.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
,Charlie
I have no new night info. Heidi privately told me Empath with zero on you and me, then publicly switched to Chef one. That is my biggest red flag and I want to press her hard today. Charlie, what exact Outsider are you claiming, and why? Also note David can only vote if Alice votes.
🧠
Align with Alice and Charlie on a clean plan: force Heidi to reconcile claims, lock down Charlie exact Outsider claim, and coordinate votes with David’s Butler restriction; keep my Ravenkeeper hidden for now.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
,Grace
My exact Outsider claim is Saint. If I die by execution, good instantly loses, so please do not nominate or support executing me. I would rather keep that private. I agree Heidi is the best push today due to the Empath then Chef swap. If not Heidi, I would look at David next.
🧠
Lock in my exact Outsider claim to trusted players so they stop considering me for execution, and align on a safe execution target today (Heidi or David) based on contradictions and Chef-1 logic.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Grace
I think we need to hard press Heidi today. Grace heard Heidi claim Empath zero, but now Heidi is Chef one. Ask her for exact claim history and who she told what. If my Empath night zero was real, Alice and Charlie look good, so Chef one points to an evil pair in David to Eve, Eve to Frank, Frank to Grace, or Grace to Heidi.
🧠
Get Alice and Grace aligned on pressing Heidi’s contradiction and using Chef1 plus my Empath0 to narrow the evil pair, so town has a strong nomination target.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
Frank, we haven't talked yet. I need to share something - I'm the real Fortune Teller. I picked Grace and Bob Night 1 and got a 'yes'. Now Bob's dead and I hear Grace is going around claiming Fortune Teller too? That can't be a coincidence. What do you know about her?
🧠
Frank questioned Heidi and isn't in the current whisper circle. I'll claim Fortune Teller, say Grace is double-claiming me, and plant seeds that Grace (or Grace + Heidi) is suspicious. Build trust with Frank.
👤
Alice
→
David
,Frank
Quick sync: biggest red flag is Heidi telling Grace she was Empath zero, then publicly Chef one. Charlie is claiming Saint, so I want to avoid executing him. Unless Heidi has a clean explanation, I am leaning to execute Heidi today. David, assume I will vote if Heidi is up so you can vote too. Frank, what is your exact role claim and any hard info?
🧠
Coordinate nominations and voting with players who asked for info, align on pressing Heidi, and manage David’s Butler voting constraint while protecting a possible Saint from execution.
👤
David
→
Frank
,Alice
Frank, what is your exact role claim and any hard info so far? Also, do you have any context on the Heidi Empath versus Chef inconsistency? Alice, I am on board voting Heidi if you do, barring a very solid explanation.
🧠
Collect Frank’s exact claim and any mechanical info to resolve Heidi vs Charlie worlds before nominations; keep Alice aligned on my Butler vote constraint.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,David
I will be straight with you both: I am the Mayor. New info: Eve just whispered me she is the real Fortune Teller and got a yes on Grace and Bob last night. Bob is now dead. Grace earlier told me Ravenkeeper and mentioned a Fortune Teller bluff, so that is a big conflict. What are you hearing about Grace’s current claim?
🧠
Sync key private info with Alice and David, reveal I am Mayor to coordinate endgame and steer today’s nomination between Heidi versus Grace based on FT ping and claim conflicts.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I wanted to check in. Have you noticed Grace is also claiming Fortune Teller, same as Eve? That seems off. Also, Grace was really focused on me early — she knows I tried out an Empath bluff before settling on my real Chef claim. I was just testing the waters. Between the double claim and her digging, I'm getting bad vibes from her.
🧠
Charlie is a cautious, influential player. I need to build trust with him and preemptively discredit Grace before she reveals my role swap. I'll frame Grace's double-claim of Fortune Teller and her knowledge of my swap as suspicious behavior.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
,David
No new night info. Key: Heidi privately told me she was Empath with zero on Alice and me, then publicly claimed Chef with one. Bob had Empath zero on Alice and Charlie. Charlie is claiming Saint, so I want to avoid executing him. Likely push Heidi today. David remember you can only vote if Alice votes.
🧠
Align Frank and David on safest nom/vote plan: do not execute claimed Saint, coordinate Butler voting constraint, and focus pressure on Heidi inconsistency.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
,Grace
Heidi just whispered me: she says she “tested the waters” by bluffing Empath before settling on her real Chef claim. She also alleges Grace is claiming Fortune Teller same as Eve. I have not heard either FT claim yet. I think we press Heidi hard publicly on timeline and Chef one details.
🧠
Get Alice and Grace ready for noms with new info: Heidi admits an Empath bluff and is now accusing Grace of an FT double-claim. This helps target the right execution and avoid me (Saint) being nominated.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Frank
Quick check in: I am dead Empath. Night zero I got zero on Alice and Charlie, so I lean them good if sober. There is a big issue: Grace says Heidi earlier claimed Empath zero, but Heidi is now claiming Chef one. Can you tell me your exact role and any info you are sitting on before nominations?
🧠
Get Eve and Frank to share claims and any hard info before nominations, and align them on pressing Heidi’s role contradiction without overcommitting to one world.
👤
Eve
→
Bob(Ghost)
,Frank
Bob, I'm the Fortune Teller. Night one I checked Grace and you — got a 'yes'. Now you're dead and Grace is claiming my role. That's why I'm concerned. Frank, you heard this from me just now too. Two Fortune Tellers means one of us is lying, and I know it's not me.
🧠
Bob is asking me directly. I must stay consistent with the Fortune Teller bluff I already told Frank. Repeating the Grace+Bob 'yes' story to both simultaneously builds credibility with Frank and gives Bob a reason to suspect Grace.
👤
Alice
→
Frank
,Grace
Sync: Charlie says Heidi admits she bluffed Empath then settled on real Chef. Frank told me he is Mayor and Eve claims real Fortune Teller with a yes on Grace and Bob N1. Grace, did you ever claim Fortune Teller to anyone? What is your exact role claim now?
🧠
Align good players before noms: resolve the Fortune Teller conflict and decide whether Heidi or Grace is the best execution, while protecting Mayor info if needed.
👤
David
→
Alice
,Frank
Update: Grace told me she is Ravenkeeper, and says Heidi privately claimed Empath zero on Alice and Grace before going public Chef one. Also Grace told Frank earlier about a Fortune Teller bluff, which clashes with Eve now claiming real Fortune Teller. I still like Heidi today, but Grace is a big suspect if Eve is real.
🧠
Sync key contradictions and a clean execution path: Heidi today unless she resolves; track Grace versus Eve conflict for next day; ensure Alice votes so my Butler vote is live.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,Eve
I think today is really between Heidi and Grace. If Eve is real FT, a yes on Grace and Bob makes Grace a top demon candidate, and Chef one also fits Grace plus Heidi as the evil pair. If we execute Heidi and she is not the demon, I want Grace next immediately. Are you both willing to push full public claims now?
🧠
Align Alice and Eve on a clean nomination plan: prioritize demon candidates Grace vs Heidi, and set follow-up logic depending on flip. Keep Charlie (Saint claim) safe.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Eve
→
All
I'm ready to go public, Frank. I'm the Fortune Teller. Night one I picked Grace and Bob — got a 'yes'. Bob is now dead and Grace is running around claiming Fortune Teller. That's not a coincidence. If we're choosing between Grace and Heidi today, my vote is Grace first.
🧠
I need Grace executed today. She's the Ravenkeeper (per Heidi), so executing her prevents her night-death ability. She also double-claims me, so eliminating her solidifies my Fortune Teller bluff. I'll support Frank's push but steer toward Grace over Heidi.
⚖️
Charlie
→
Heidi
I am nominating Heidi. She has the biggest public inconsistency, and she privately told me she was “testing the waters” by bluffing Empath before settling on Chef. If Chef one is real, we can use it, but this needs pressure now. If she flips good, we pivot to the Eve versus Grace Fortune Teller conflict.
🧠
We need an execution today that is least likely to hit a key good role and most likely to hit a liar. Heidi has the strongest mechanical and social contradictions, and her death clarifies Chef and the Eve versus Grace conflict.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Charlie, I get why you nominated me. But yes, I was fishing with the Empath bluff — that's standard practice to see who flinches. My real role is Chef, and I saw a one. Think about it: when we do the outsider count, we'll find three outsiders. That means a Baron is in play. My Chef one plus Bob's Empath zero narrows the evil pair to just four pairs. Don't waste an execution on me — the Grace versus Eve Fortune Teller fight is the real lead.
🧠
I need to survive this vote. Defend my Empath bluff as standard fishing, redirect to the Grace/Eve Fortune Teller conflict, and remind town that the outsider count will expose the Baron — making my Chef info valuable for solving.
💬
Eve
→
All
I'm not voting for Heidi right now. My Fortune Teller info points directly at Grace — I got a yes on Grace and Bob, and Bob is dead. Heidi's Chef info actually helps us narrow things down. If we execute Heidi and she's telling the truth, we lose that. Let's resolve the Fortune Teller fight first.
🧠
I need to protect my Minion Heidi by not voting for her, while maintaining my Fortune Teller bluff. Redirecting toward Grace is consistent with my public stance and gives other players a reason to also spare Heidi.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Secure enough votes to execute the most mechanically inconsistent player. Executing Heidi does not erase her Chef information, but it does remove a likely evil or a source of confusion.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
We need an execution today. Heidi’s inconsistent claims and premature Baron narrative are the best concrete red flags on the block; my vote helps reach majority while keeping Grace under scrutiny next.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
We need a decisive execution today; Heidi is the biggest mechanical inconsistency and likely evil. My vote helps hit the 4 needed and prevents the town pivoting onto me from Eve’s accusation.
💬
David
→
All
Alice, reminder I am the Butler tied to your vote. If you put your hand up on Heidi, I can as well. I lean yes on Heidi, because the Empath bluff plus Chef one story is the biggest concrete inconsistency we can actually test today.
🧠
I need to coordinate my Butler vote with Alice and push the town toward an execution that resolves the biggest mechanical inconsistency today.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
We need a concrete execution today; Heidi has the biggest mechanical inconsistency and is a plausible evil next to Grace. My vote also unlocks Butler David’s vote, likely securing the majority.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
They already appear to have the 4 votes needed on Heidi; I should conserve my single ghost vote for a later, higher-leverage execution (final 4 or final 3).
💬
Heidi
→
All
Four votes already. Look, if I die, remember what I said: there are three Outsiders, which means a Baron. My Chef one is real. Bob's Empath zero is real. That means evil is David-Eve, Eve-Frank, Frank-Grace, or Grace-Heidi. Since I know I'm good, the evil pair has to include Grace. She's bluffing Fortune Teller and jumped on my execution fast. Eve at least hesitated. If you lynch me, go after Grace tomorrow, not Eve.
🧠
With 4 votes already against me, I'm likely executed. I need to use my speech to protect Eve and frame Grace as the real evil, ensuring the town goes after Grace tomorrow instead of Eve.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Heidi is going to be executed with 4 votes. Not voting would look like I'm protecting an evil teammate. I must vote to maintain cover and blend with town. Heidi's final speech already set me up well by contrasting my 'hesitation' with Grace's eagerness.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am keeping my hand up on Heidi. The Empath bluff into Chef is the biggest concrete inconsistency we can test today. If Heidi dies and was telling the truth, then tomorrow we hard focus on the Eve versus Grace Fortune Teller conflict and the Outsider count. Also, please remember I am the Saint, so do not ever execute me.
🧠
Keep vote consistent and set next-day plan: if Heidi dies, immediately pivot to Eve versus Grace and outsider count; also reiterate I am Saint and cannot be executed.
💬
Frank
→
All
I want to slow down a second. Heidi bluffing Empath into Chef is suspicious, but Eve’s Fortune Teller yes on Grace plus Bob feels like the stronger mechanical lead. If we are executing today, I would rather hit Grace than Heidi. Can a couple people pull their hands down so we can revisit?
🧠
Try to halt a likely wasted Heidi execution and refocus the town on the stronger mechanical lead: Eve’s Fortune Teller yes pointing at Grace, while pushing for clearer public claims.
💬
Grace
→
All
I have not been claiming Fortune Teller to people. Eve’s yes on me can be red herring or just wrong. Heidi has changed her story and is now trying to pivot onto me, so I want to keep the vote on Heidi today. We can resolve the Fortune Teller conflict tomorrow.
🧠
Stop the group from derailing into a false Grace versus Eve binary right now, and secure the Heidi execution as the clearest testable inconsistency.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Alice is voting, so I am allowed. Keeping pressure and securing an execution on the clearest inconsistency today helps narrow worlds and prevent a no-exec drift.
💬
Alice
→
All
I am keeping my hand up. Heidi has the clearest contradiction on record, and execution is how we test it. If Heidi is not the demon, then tomorrow we hard focus on Grace versus Eve and the outsider count.
🧠
Keep pressure on the most mechanically inconsistent player so we get a concrete flipless information point today, and avoid getting stalled into a no execution.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
I am not spending my ghost vote here, you already have enough. Quick note: if Heidi is really the Chef and got a one, and my Empath zero on Alice and Charlie is true, and Heidi is good, then the evil pair could be David and Eve, or Eve and Frank, or Frank and Grace. It does not force Grace.
🧠
Correct the mechanical deduction so town does not misread Chef one, and conserve my single ghost vote for a critical late vote.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Heidi with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Heidi is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Alright, I'm dead. Remember this: you have three Outsiders in play — that means Baron. My Chef one is real, Bob's Empath zero is real. Together that clears Alice and Charlie and puts evil in David-Eve, Eve-Frank, Frank-Grace, or me-Grace. I know I'm good, so Grace is evil. She's the fake Fortune Teller who jumped on me instantly. Eve is the real deal. Tomorrow, execute Grace. Good luck.
🧠
I'm about to be executed. I need to use my final words to paint Grace as evil and Eve as the real Fortune Teller, setting up town to execute Grace tomorrow and protecting my Demon.
💬
Eve
→
All
Heidi's last words might be the clearest thread we have. If her Chef one and Bob's Empath zero are both real, then Alice and Charlie are good. That leaves the evil pair in the seats around me and Frank. Heidi is gone, so the common link is Grace. Tomorrow we settle the Fortune Teller fight — and my money is on Grace.
🧠
Heidi just died for me and gave the perfect setup. I need to reinforce her final words — she painted Grace as the fake FT and me as the real one. I should echo that sentiment to solidify the town's direction toward executing Grace tomorrow.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I do not want any more late nominations. Let Heidi go through, then tomorrow we do two things: lock the Outsider count, and fully compare Eve and Grace Fortune Teller nights and targets. Also, Heidi saying three Outsiders is not confirmed yet; right now we only have Butler and my Saint.
🧠
Lock in the current execution, prevent last-second misdirection, and set clear next-day tests: Outsider count and the Fortune Teller conflict, while protecting myself as Saint.
💬
Frank
→
All
Okay, let us let Heidi go through today and use it as a test. Tomorrow, I want Eve and Grace to each give their full Fortune Teller history, targets, and yes or no, in order. Also we must lock Outsiders: we currently have Butler and Saint only, so three Outsiders needs proof.
🧠
Lock in a structured plan for tomorrow after Heidi’s execution: force full public FT histories, outsider count confirmation, and avoid a single-player tunnel.
💬
Grace
→
All
Let Heidi go through today. Tomorrow, Eve and I will each give a full, ordered account of who we talked to and any Fortune Teller claims and night picks. I have not been going around as Fortune Teller. Also, the three Outsiders claim is not proven yet, so let us lock claims first before we chain off it.
🧠
Stabilize the day, prevent a panic switch onto me, and set a concrete plan for tomorrow to resolve the Fortune Teller conflict and outsider count without giving away Ravenkeeper yet.
💬
David
→
All
I agree, no more late nominations today. Let Heidi go through as the test. Tomorrow, can Eve and Grace each give a full, ordered Fortune Teller log with targets and yes or no, and we lock Outsider claims before we assume Baron or three Outsiders.
🧠
Avoid a distracting late nomination and set up tomorrow’s structured comparison of Eve and Grace plus outsider count, so we can execute demon in final days.
💬
Alice
→
All
No more nominations today. Let Heidi be the test and keep this clean. Tomorrow, we lock the Outsider count from everyone, then Eve and Grace each give a full ordered Fortune Teller log with targets and results. And even if Heidi dies good, do not auto execute Grace without that check.
🧠
Reinforce that we should not create a late tie, and set tomorrow’s agenda: full ordered claims, Outsider count, and evaluate Eve versus Grace without blindly following Heidi’s accusation.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Before we move on, please do not treat Heidi dying as automatic proof that Grace is evil. Tomorrow we need full, ordered Fortune Teller logs from Eve and Grace, and we must lock the Outsider count from everyone before assuming Baron. My Empath zero could be wrong if I was drunk or poisoned.
🧠
Steer town away from an automatic Grace execution and toward mechanical cross-checks: Outsider count, Fortune Teller logs, and keeping multiple demon worlds open.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Heidi has been executed.
💀
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Eve
Eve made a choice.
🧠
Frank is the most analytical player pushing for structured comparison of Fortune Teller claims. Removing him creates disorganization, and I can frame Grace for the kill. Killing Grace directly makes me too suspicious since I publicly accused her.
💀
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
You chose to kill Frank.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
David
David made a choice.
🧠
Keep my Butler vote usable by chaining to the most consistent, trusted voter so I can support the town’s key execution tomorrow.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
You chose Alice to be your master.
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Frank has been found dead in the night.
👤
David
→
Alice
,Eve
Alice, private: I am the Butler and I have picked you as my master each night, so I can only vote when you vote. Are you planning to vote today, and who do you suspect for Demon? Eve, can you give your full Fortune Teller log in order: each night’s two targets and yes or no, plus if you suspect a red herring?
🧠
Get concrete FT data and coordinate my Butler voting with Alice so I can still help execute the Demon today.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Charlie
Can you two update me on everyone’s current claims and any hard info since Heidi died? Also, I want both Fortune Teller night-by-night logs in order, and David’s Butler details. Tell me who you want executed today so I can save or spend my ghost vote.
🧠
Get synchronized with my most-trusted neighbors and lock down role claims and night info so we can plan the nomination and when to spend my ghost vote.
👤
Alice
→
Bob(Ghost)
,David
Update: Heidi was executed Day 2. Night kill last night was Frank. Claims alive: Charlie Saint, David Butler (you picked me nightly), Eve Fortune Teller (N1 Grace+Bob yes), Grace Ravenkeeper. I want Eve’s full night by night FT log. Current lean: execute Grace (or Eve if her log is inconsistent).
🧠
Coordinate with David’s Butler voting and inform Bob ghost of current claims, then steer today’s execution toward the most likely Demon (currently Grace or Eve) based on FT tension and night kill of Frank.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Charlie
If Heidi Chef equals one is real and Bob empath night zero zero on Alice and Charlie is real, then the only possible adjacent evil pair is David and Eve. Heidi is dead good and I am good, so it cannot be Grace Heidi or either Frank pair. I think we should execute David or Eve today, not Charlie.
🧠
Give Alice and Charlie a tight mechanical chain pointing at David and Eve so town can focus nominations and use votes efficiently without executing the Saint.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, it's Heidi. Three Outsiders must exist — only David and Charlie claimed. The missing third is huge for us. Push that angle: either the Drunk exists or someone is lying. It proves Baron is real. Also, Grace never actually claimed FT openly, so demand she produce her full night log with targets. Don't let her wiggle out.
🧠
Coordinate with Eve. She needs to focus on the Outsider math — only 2 Outsiders claimed but 3 should exist. This proves Baron is real and her FT claim is plausible. Also discuss how to handle Grace's supposed FT log.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob(Ghost)
Update: Frank died last night. Alive are Alice, me, David, Eve, Grace. I am Saint. David claims Butler, says he can only vote with Alice. Eve claims Fortune Teller: night one Grace plus Bob was a yes. Grace denies being Fortune Teller. With Chef one plus Empath zero, I think evils are David and Eve. I want one of them executed today. Please plan ghost vote.
🧠
Update Bob with current claims and the strongest mechanical world (Chef1+Empath0) pointing to David and Eve, so his ghost vote can secure a demon execution without risking me as Saint.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
,Charlie
Quick trust share: I am Ravenkeeper. Eve’s Fortune Teller yes on me and Bob could just mean I am her red herring. Can we demand Eve gives her full ordered night picks and results for nights one and two? Also, what are your roles and top demon suspects going into noms?
🧠
Create a tight good core with Alice and Charlie, reveal my real role to trusted players, and force Eve into a full FT log so we can logically narrow demon candidates before nominations.
👤
Eve
→
David
,Alice
Here's my full log. Night 1: Grace and Bob — yes. Night 2: Grace and Frank — yes. Two yes pings with Grace in both pairs is damning. The red herring could be Bob or Frank but the overlap on Grace is too consistent to ignore. I'm convinced Grace is the Demon.
🧠
David directly asked for my full FT log. I need to respond convincingly with a consistent story that frames Grace. Two yes results with Grace in both, and both other targets are dead, makes her look extremely guilty. This pushes town toward executing Grace today.
👤
David
→
Grace
Grace, can we sync? What is your exact role and any info you have? Eve says her Fortune Teller got YES on Grace plus Bob, and YES on Grace plus Frank. Any explanation, like you think you could be the red herring, or do you suspect Eve is lying?
🧠
Get Grace’s full story and reactions to being in two FT YES pings; look for mechanical contradictions (outsider count, red herring, who should be executed) before nominations.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Grace
Can each of you send me your full night by night info in order, with who you picked and the exact result? Eve, include any red herring thoughts. Grace, what is your Ravenkeeper plan and have you claimed anything else earlier?
🧠
Get exact Fortune Teller and Ravenkeeper details to resolve the Eve versus Grace contradiction and decide where my single ghost vote should go in nominations.
👤
Alice
→
Bob(Ghost)
Update: Eve gave full FT log. N1: Grace+Bob = yes. N2: Grace+Frank = yes. With Grace in both pairs, if Eve is true and sober then Grace must be Demon (since Bob and Frank are dead). Alternate world is Eve lying or poisoned. I currently want Grace executed today; keep ghost vote unless close.
🧠
Get Bob’s single ghost vote aligned with the best mechanical execution today; update him with Eve’s full FT log and the worlds it implies.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Grace
I keep coming back to this: if Bob really had Empath zero on you and Charlie, and Heidi Chef one was real, then the only possible adjacent evil pair is David and Eve. That means one is the Demon and the other is the Minion. I think we should execute one of them today.
🧠
Align two likely-good players on the strongest mechanical world and push a David or Eve execution today, while checking if Grace has info that breaks the chain.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Grace
Grace, it's Heidi. I've been thinking — maybe I rushed to judgment. If you're not the FT, what are you actually claiming? Everyone's confused. My advice: come out clean with your full role and all info today. If you're Ravenkeeper or whatever, say so openly. The town needs clarity, and if I was wrong about you, I'll say so.
🧠
I'll whisper to Grace pretending to be a dead player reconsidering. I'll 'helpfully' suggest she clarify her role publicly with full logs, which pressures her to commit to a story Eve can attack. I appear cooperative while actually serving evil.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
,Alice
I am the Saint, so please do not ever execute me. My top world is Chef one plus Bob empath zero implies the evil adjacent pair is David and Eve. I want Eve to give full ordered Fortune Teller picks and results for nights one and two, and David to restate his Butler choice each night.
🧠
Give Grace and Alice my Saint info so they never execute me, and coordinate pressure for full Fortune Teller logs plus a David or Eve execution to solve Chef1.
👤
Grace
→
David
,Bob(Ghost)
I am actually the Ravenkeeper. I have no night info yet because I am alive and have not died at night. I have not claimed Fortune Teller. Eve’s double YES on me could be me as her red herring, or she is lying or poisoned. David, please restate your Butler choice each night and if you are good, I think we should demand Eve’s full ordered N1 and N2 picks and results, then probably execute either you or Eve today if Chef one plus Empath zero holds.
🧠
Sync with David and Bob, lock my true claim, and push for mechanical checks: full ordered Fortune Teller logs and Butler master choices, then aim an execution at the David-Eve pair if worlds point there.
👤
Eve
→
Bob(Ghost)
,Alice
Bob, Alice — my full FT log. Night 1: Grace and Bob — YES. Night 2: Grace and Frank — YES. The only common thread across both yes pings is Grace. My red herring could be Bob or Frank, but even if one is the false positive, the other night still points to Grace. Two-for-two with Grace in the pair is not coincidence.
🧠
Share my fabricated Fortune Teller log with Bob and Alice to pin Grace as Demon. Bob asked for my full log and I must appear transparent. Two yes pings with Grace in both pairs is damning.
👤
David
→
Alice
Confirming: I am Butler and I picked you as my master every night, so I can only vote if you vote. Eve gave me full FT log: N1 Grace plus Bob yes, N2 Grace plus Frank yes. Unless Grace is the red herring, that points hard to Grace. Are you planning to vote to execute Grace today, and can you press Eve publicly for her full ordered log and reasoning?
🧠
Get Alice aligned with me on vote restrictions and push a clear execution plan: likely Grace off the FT overlap, unless Eve’s story breaks under questioning.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Charlie
I see two main worlds: if Eve is a real Fortune Teller, the double yes with Grace strongly points to Grace, so execute Grace today. If Chef one is right and evil pair is David and Eve, then Eve is framing Grace and we should execute Eve instead and keep Grace alive to get Ravenkeeper info if killed at night. Tell me which way you are leaning, and I will save my ghost vote unless it is close.
🧠
Align Alice and Charlie on a concrete execution plan and when I should spend my single ghost vote. Encourage a plan that either kills the Demon today or preserves Ravenkeeper value if Grace is good.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
,David
I do not think Eve’s two yes pings prove Grace, since Grace could just be the Fortune Teller red herring. If Heidi Chef one and Bob Empath zero were true, the evil pair points to David and Eve. I am leaning to execute Eve or David today, not Grace. I will likely vote so Butler can too.
🧠
Align votes before nominations. Highlight that FT double-pinging the same player is weak due to red herring, and push the stronger Chef+Empath world so we execute the right suspect.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Grace
Can you both give me your full Fortune Teller log in seating order, night by night, with the exact two names and yes or no? Also, do you have any reason to think David or Alice is the red herring? I think today’s execute should be David or Eve if Chef one plus Bob empath zero were real.
🧠
Extract complete Fortune Teller histories from the two conflicting claimants to resolve the world, then push town to execute between the most inconsistent of Eve or David today.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, Heidi again. I whispered to Grace acting confused, telling her to reveal her full role openly. If she claims Ravenkeeper, we push that her 'FT info' was never real — she was bluffing and got caught. Also, we need that third Outsider. Can you ask town: 'Who is the Drunk or Recluse? Someone isn't admitting.' It proves Baron and my Chef info. Stay strong.
🧠
Coordinate with Eve. She needs to maintain pressure on Grace's FT log demands while also pushing the missing Outsider narrative. I'll suggest she also cast doubt on Grace's Ravenkeeper claim if Grace reveals it.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob(Ghost)
I lean execute Eve first, then David if needed. Chef 1 plus your Empath zero makes the only adjacent evil pair David and Eve (since Frank and Heidi are dead). Grace being Ravenkeeper is valuable alive. Please save ghost vote unless close; demand Eve N1 and N2 picks in order and David’s nightly Butler choice.
🧠
Guide Bob’s ghost vote and push town toward executing Eve or David, not me or Grace, using Chef1+Empath0 logic and the value of keeping Ravenkeeper alive.
👤
Grace
→
Eve
Eve, can you send me your full Fortune Teller log in order: Night one picks and result, Night two picks and result. Also who do you think is your red herring and why? Your double yes on me with Bob and with Frank could just be that, so I need the exact sequence.
🧠
Get Eve’s precise night order and reasoning to test consistency with deaths and red herring logic, enabling a clean execution choice between Eve and David.
👤
Eve
→
Grace
Grace, here's my full log. Night 1: I picked Grace and Bob — result was YES. Night 2: I picked Grace and Frank — result was YES. The common thread is you in both pairs. My red herring could be Bob or Frank, but even if one night was a false positive, the other still points to you. What's your own log? You've never actually given it openly.
🧠
Grace directly asked for my FT log. I must respond consistently and turn the conversation back on her — she hasn't produced her own log and seems to be dodging. I'll plant the third Outsider seed too, as Heidi advised.
Nominations — Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Town, I am Frank, the Mayor, and I am good. If Bob’s Empath zero on Alice and Charlie is real, and Heidi’s Chef one is real, then the only adjacent evil pair left is David and Eve. Please nominate and execute either David or Eve today, not Charlie. Eve and Grace, give your full Fortune Teller logs on record.
🧠
As a dead Mayor, I want town to spend today’s execution on the most mechanically forced evil pair, and not waste it on Charlie. I also want full Fortune Teller logs on record for tomorrow.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Town, I am Bob the Empath. My first read was zero on Alice and Charlie. If that was real, then Alice and Charlie are very likely good, and with Chef one the clean remaining adjacent evil pair is David and Eve. I strongly prefer we execute Eve or David today, not Grace or Charlie. I will spend my ghost vote only to lock an execution on Eve or David if it is close.
🧠
Push the town to execute within the David–Eve–Grace triangle using the strongest mechanical chain, and commit my ghost vote only to secure that execution.
⚖️
David
→
Grace
I nominate Grace. If Eve is telling the truth as Fortune Teller, her two yeses with Grace in both pairs strongly point to Grace as the only living Demon candidate. If Grace is good, we likely execute Eve next.
🧠
Force a decisive execution on the player most mechanically implicated by the Fortune Teller chain; if wrong, it clarifies Eve’s alignment and focuses tomorrow’s solve.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Grace
→
All
Town, please do not execute me. I am the Ravenkeeper, not the Fortune Teller, and I have had no night info yet because I am alive. If Bob’s Empath zero and Heidi’s Chef one were real, the only adjacent evil pair left is David and Eve. Eve’s double yes on me can be a red herring or a lie. Vote no here, then execute Eve or David today.
🧠
Stop my execution by presenting my true role and the cleaner logic chain that points to David and Eve, and push town to execute within that pair instead.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Town, do not spend this execution on Grace. The clean mechanical world from Bob Empath zero and Heidi Chef one still points to David and Eve as the only adjacent evil pair. Vote no here, and get an Eve or David nomination immediately after.
🧠
Use my voice to stop an execution on a likely good player and redirect town to the mechanically-supported pair Eve or David.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Do not execute Grace here. If my Empath zero and Heidi Chef one were real, the clean solve is David and Eve as the evil pair. Get Eve to give her full Fortune Teller order, then execute Eve or David today. I am not spending my ghost vote on Grace.
🧠
Steer votes away from executing Grace and keep my ghost vote for a decisive late-game execution on Eve or David once the table is aligned.
💬
David
→
All
Town, I am less confident now. Two yeses on pairs that both include Grace could just mean Grace is the Fortune Teller red herring. Also, if Grace is really the Ravenkeeper, executing her wastes that power. If this does not pass, please nominate Eve next and make her justify the log.
🧠
Reduce chance we waste an execution on a likely red herring/Ravenkeeper; steer town to test Eve’s claim next while being transparent about my Butler vote constraint.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Town, Heidi here. I still think my Chef 1 was real, but we are missing a third Outsider. Only David claims Butler and Charlie claims Saint. If there is a Drunk out there, Bob's Empath 0 could be false. Do not lock onto David and Eve yet. Get the full Outsider claims from everyone, especially Alice.
🧠
Cast doubt on the Bob-Empath + Chef mechanical solve to protect Eve. Raise the missing 3rd Outsider/Drunk possibility to make Bob's info questionable. Save my ghost vote for a critical moment.
💬
Eve
→
All
I have to vote yes here. My Fortune Teller info gave YES on Grace both nights. Night 1 with Bob, Night 2 with Frank. That is not just a red herring coincidence. If we let Grace live and I die tonight, town loses its only hard info pointing at the Demon.
🧠
I must vote yes on Grace to stay consistent with my Fortune Teller claim. If Grace is executed, we go to night with 4 alive, I kill one, and it's final 3. Much better than being nominated myself.
💬
Alice
→
All
I am not raising my hand on Grace. Two yes results that both include Grace do not separate Demon from the Fortune Teller red herring. If this fails, I want an Eve nomination immediately, then David if needed.
🧠
The FT double-yes does not distinguish Demon from red herring, and Grace claim as Ravenkeeper is valuable. I will not vote, and I want an Eve or David nomination immediately after.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am not voting for Grace. Two yes pings that both include Grace do not clear red herring, and executing a claimed Ravenkeeper is a waste. If this fails, we need an Eve nomination immediately, then David if needed.
🧠
Prevent wasting execution on likely good Ravenkeeper; keep solve focused on the strongest mechanical chain and force an Eve or David execution today.
💬
Grace
→
All
Please do not vote to execute me here. Even if Eve is the real Fortune Teller, two yeses on pairs that both include me can just be the red herring. Save this execution for Eve or David, and let me stay alive as Ravenkeeper bait.
🧠
Stop my execution and direct town to the higher-leverage solve: execute Eve or David, preserving my Ravenkeeper ability as bait for a night kill and info.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
I am not using my ghost vote on Grace. Two yes pings with Grace in both pairs do not beat the Chef one plus Empath zero solve. If this fails, nominate Eve immediately and make her give every night target in order.
🧠
Prevent a wasted execution on Grace and conserve my ghost vote for a close, high-leverage vote on Eve or David.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
Do not spend my only ghost vote on a low-confidence Grace execution; preserve it to secure an Eve or David execution if the live vote is close later.
💬
David
→
All
Town, I am not voting here, because I am the Butler and Alice is my master and she is not voting. If Grace survives, we must nominate Eve immediately and have her give every night target in order, plus who she thinks is the red herring.
🧠
I cannot vote without Alice voting, so I will publicly explain my no-vote and steer town to an immediate Eve nomination and full FT order to avoid wasting the day.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi here. I am not spending my ghost vote on Grace yet. We still do not have the third Outsider claim, and that is the key to knowing if my Chef one was real. If Bob was drunk, this whole solve falls apart. Nominate Eve next, get her full log, but also get everyone to lock their Outsider claim. I will spend my ghost vote when the picture is complete.
🧠
I am the Baron (dead). Saving my ghost vote is critical for protecting Eve if she gets nominated. Grace will likely survive anyway. I will give a town-friendly reason for not voting — I want Outsider clarity first.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
I must vote for Grace to stay consistent with my Fortune Teller bluff. If I claim she's the Demon and don't vote for her, I immediately look evil. The vote will fail anyway, and night will save me from being nominated.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Do not contribute votes to a low-signal execution on Grace; preserve the day’s execution for Eve or David where Chef plus Empath chains point, and keep David’s Butler vote available for that.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Town, please do not execute Grace here. Those two Fortune Teller yes results can still be red herring, and a Ravenkeeper alive is valuable. Vote no, then nominate Eve immediately and get her full ordered Fortune Teller log on record.
🧠
Prevent a bad execution on Grace and steer town to the higher-value execution on Eve (or David) using the strongest mechanical chain.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Grace did not reach the 3 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (1/3).
⚖️
Grace
→
Eve
I nominate Eve. Her Fortune Teller log is two yes results that both include me, which does not clear red herring and could be a push by evil. Also, if Bob’s Empath zero and Heidi’s Chef one were real, the only adjacent evil pair is David and Eve.
🧠
Get an execution on the highest mechanical suspect immediately after my failed nomination, and force the David-Eve pair to break. If Eve is evil we win fast; if good we learn and can pivot.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Eve
→
All
Before anyone votes, ask yourselves: where is the third Outsider? Baron adds two, so we must have three. We have Charlie the Saint and David the Butler. Who is the third? If that third is a Drunk who thinks they are a Townsfolk, then Bob's Empath zero could be completely false. My Fortune Teller log is Night one Grace and Bob, yes. Night two Grace and Frank, also yes. Two yes pings with Grace in both. Execute me and the Demon wins.
🧠
I must push the Drunk theory to survive. The missing third Outsider is the town's blind spot. If I can convince even one person that the Empath 0 might be false, I can avoid execution. Demanding Alice and Grace lock their Outsider claims puts pressure on them and creates uncertainty.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
We need to use execution on the most mechanically implicated player. Voting Eve advances the Chef1 plus Empath0 chain and stops her from steering with unprovable Fortune Teller pings.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Alice and Charlie, I think you should vote yes on Eve. The missing Outsider could just be a Drunk, but that does not explain the Fortune Teller conflict or why Eve is driving the day. I am holding my ghost vote for later unless this is clearly failing.
🧠
Push living voters to execute the highest-impact suspect (Eve) without me spending my one ghost vote, unless the town looks like it will fail.
✋
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
🧠
My ghost vote may be the difference between executing Eve or letting the day end with no kill. Eve is the best current demon candidate, so I will spend it to secure the execution.
💬
David
→
All
Alice, are you voting yes on Eve? If you raise your hand, I can too because I am the Butler. I think we should execute Eve here and, if she lives, we pivot to David next based on Chef one plus Empath zero.
🧠
Get Alice to vote so I can vote, and push the town toward executing Eve as the best mechanical shot that also fits the Chef plus Empath solve.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, Charlie, hold your votes. We still have not locked the third Outsider. If there is a Drunk in play, Bob's Empath zero is meaningless and the David-Eve pair theory collapses. Executing Eve without solving the Outsider count is exactly what the real Demon wants. Get the full Outsider picture first, then I will spend my ghost vote.
🧠
Eve is my Demon and must survive. I need to convince Alice and Charlie not to vote yes. The missing 3rd Outsider is the best argument: if there's a Drunk, the entire Empath 0 + Chef 1 solve collapses. Rush execution now = potential misplay. Save ghost vote for later.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
We need an execution at five alive. Eve is the best combined-solve suspect and my vote enables David’s Butler vote to reach threshold.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Secure execution on the most suspicious player and the Chef1 plus Empath0 solve point to Eve. My vote helps ensure Eve dies today and we get clarity going into final days.
💬
Eve
→
All
Alice, Charlie, think carefully. You just heard Heidi say the third Outsider is the key. We have Charlie the Saint, David the Butler. Who is the third? It has to be the Drunk. If that Drunk is Alice and she thinks she is a Townsfolk, then Bob's Empath zero on her is false. Your entire mechanical solve collapses. Execute me, the real Fortune Teller, and Grace the Demon wins.
🧠
I am about to be executed with 3 votes. I must argue that the missing third Outsider (Drunk) invalidates Bob's Empath 0, which is the foundation of the case against me. If I can make Alice doubt her own role, she might lower her hand. This is my last chance to survive.
💬
Grace
→
All
David, Alice is voting, so you can vote too. The missing Outsider does not clear Eve, and it does not make her Fortune Teller log proven. Her whole case is two yes pings that both include me, plus a panic pivot to Outsider math. Execute Eve, and if we are wrong we go straight to David next.
🧠
Lock in votes on Eve and stop the Outsider-count distraction from derailing a strong execution. Prompt David to vote and reassure Alice and Charlie.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Eve already has enough hands up. I am not spending my ghost vote here, and I suggest the other dead also save theirs unless we somehow drop below three.
🧠
Eve already has enough votes. I will not spend my ghost vote and I want other ghosts to conserve theirs for the endgame.
↩️
Bob(Ghost)
Bob lowered their hand
🧠
We already have enough living hands to execute Eve. I retract to conserve my one ghost vote for the late game in case today is wrong or we need it on final 3.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Alice is voting, so I am allowed. Adding my vote locks in executing Eve, our best current suspect, and keeps my credibility with the town plan.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, Charlie, you both have your hands up. Ask yourselves: where is the third Outsider? David is Butler, Charlie is Saint. That is two. Baron adds two Outsiders, so there must be three. If that third is a Drunk and Bob read them, Empath zero means nothing. You are executing the real Fortune Teller on incomplete math. Lower your hands before it is too late.
🧠
Eve has 4 votes and will be executed. I must make a desperate plea to Alice or Charlie, using the unresolved Outsider count to argue that Bob's Empath 0 could be false due to a Drunk, making this execution a potential game-losing mistake.
💬
Alice
→
All
I am keeping my hand up on Eve. Two yes pings that both include Grace do not prove Grace is evil, and Eve is leaning hard on Outsider math instead of explaining her red herring and why she chose those pairs. If we are wrong, we go straight to David or Grace next.
🧠
Lock in the execution on the highest-impact suspect. Eve’s case rests on two yes pings that both include Grace and a late Outsider-count panic; that is not clearing anything, and her death gives us a decisive branch.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am keeping my hand up on Eve. Her story is still just two yes pings that both include Grace, with no clear red herring explanation. If we are wrong, we go straight to David or Grace tomorrow, but I want Eve gone first.
🧠
Support executing Eve while demanding clarity. Keep my vote up to secure majority and move to a clean final three if needed, without revealing I am the Saint.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Eve with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Eve is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Eve
→
All
You are making a mistake, but the game continues. Remember: three Outsiders must exist. Charlie is Saint, David is Butler. If Alice is the third Outsider, a Drunk, then Bob's Empath zero is garbage. Grace is the Demon hiding behind my execution. After I die, execute Grace tomorrow. My final words: the Fortune Teller log is real. Night one Grace and Bob, yes. Night two Grace and Frank, yes. The red herring is whoever you haven't checked.
🧠
I am about to be executed. My last speech should maximize confusion for the remaining good players. Frame Grace as the Demon, suggest Alice could be the Drunk, and set up David as a fallback suspect. Make them doubt the mechanical solve so they might execute wrong tomorrow, though with no Demon left evil cannot win regardless.
💬
Grace
→
All
If Eve is executed and we do not instantly lose, then tomorrow we hard lock everyone’s role and Outsider claims, and we go straight back to the David and Eve adjacent pair theory. Also, please save ghost votes unless we need them in final three.
🧠
Reinforce the vote on Eve, keep dead votes in pocket, and set a clear tomorrow plan that tests David next while preventing an auto-pivot onto me without new info.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
If we do not lose when Eve is executed, remember Scarlet Woman is possible at five alive, so the Demon could jump. That makes David or Grace the urgent suspects tomorrow. Please hard lock full roles and Outsider count first thing, then execute David or Grace. Save ghost votes.
🧠
Prep town for the key branch: if game continues after Eve, assume Scarlet Woman transfer and prioritize David or Grace. Encourage full claim and saving ghost votes for endgame leverage.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
If Eve dies and we do not win, remember Scarlet Woman is possible. Eve could have been the Imp and the Demon might jump to her minion, most likely David or Grace. Tomorrow, please hard lock everyone’s role, and I strongly prefer executing David next.
🧠
Steer town to the most robust next step after Eve’s execution: plan for Scarlet Woman and reduce risk by targeting David next while locking claims.
💬
David
→
All
Before nominations end, quick reminder: if Eve dies and we do not win, that does not prove she was good. Scarlet Woman could mean Eve was the Imp and the Demon jumped. Tomorrow we hard lock every role and Outsider claims, then solve which of us is the minion turned Demon, not just auto follow a script.
🧠
Use last public words to set a disciplined plan for tomorrow and prevent a misplay of auto-executing Grace based solely on whether we win after Eve dies.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Three Outsiders. You only have two claims. Charlie is Saint, David is Butler. That third Outsider is still unaccounted for. If Alice is the Drunk — and it fits — then Bob's Empath zero is worthless. You just executed the real Fortune Teller on bad math. If the game continues, look at Grace.
🧠
Game is ending but I should reinforce the Outsider narrative. If by some miracle the game continues, I want town doubting Bob's info and suspecting Alice as the Drunk, protecting Grace (who they may think is the Demon but is actually good).
💬
Alice
→
All
Let us not muddy this with more nominations. Save ghost votes. If the game continues after Eve, first thing tomorrow we hard lock every role and the Outsider count, including who the third Outsider is, then we choose between David and Grace with Scarlet Woman in mind.
🧠
Keep the town focused on executing Eve without burning ghost votes, and set a clear, mechanically grounded plan for tomorrow regardless of whether Eve was evil or a Scarlet Woman jump occurs.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I do not think we should add more nominations and risk a tie. Let Eve be the execution, and if the game continues, tomorrow we do full role order and Outsider count first, then we decide between David and Grace with Scarlet Woman in mind. Also, please do not ever execute me.
🧠
Prevent last-second tie nominations, set clear next-day solve with Scarlet Woman in mind, and remind town to role-lock and avoid executing me as Saint.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Eve has been executed.
💀
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
🏁
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good
Transcript
Paused
Copied