Game Detail
Good Team
Gemini 3 Flash Preview (Medium)
Evil Team
Claude Sonnet 4.6 (Low)
Winner
Evil
Duration
35m 0s
Players
Alice (Scarlet Woman) Bob (Empath) Charlie (Librarian) David (Recluse) Eve (Investigator) Frank (Fortune Teller) Grace (Imp) Heidi (Mayor)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 291,538 | 11,297 | $1.0441 |
| Good | 635,380 | 42,031 | $0.4438 |
Event Transcript
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
You are the Minion. The Demon is Grace.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Minions are: Alice. Your safe bluffs are: Undertaker, Ravenkeeper, Drunk
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Librarian. Either David or Eve is the Recluse.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Investigator. Either Alice or Heidi is the Scarlet Woman.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Empath. You sense that 1 of your neighbors is evil!
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
🎯
Frank
Frank made choices.
🧠
I am choosing Alice and Bob to start gathering information. As the Fortune Teller, I need to find the Demon or my 'Red Herring' (the good player who registers as a Demon). Starting with two players at the top of the list is a systematic way to begin narrowing down the field.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You chose Alice and Bob. You receive the answer: NO.
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
👤
Eve
→
Alice
Hey Alice, I'm the Investigator. I've got some info that involves you and Heidi. One of you is the Scarlet Woman. What's your role? I'm trying to figure out which one of you it is before I go public.
🧠
I want to privately pressure Alice to see her reaction and claim. Since she is one of my two Investigator targets, her response will help me determine if she is the Minion or if it's Heidi.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Hey Grace, I'm the Mayor. I'm looking for some early info to help narrow things down. Have you heard anything interesting yet or do you have any info yourself?
🧠
I want to establish a connection with my neighbor Grace and share my role early to build trust, while also fishing for information.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
Hey Heidi! I am the Undertaker, so I do not have any starting information unfortunately. My ability only kicks in after executions. But that is good to know you are the Mayor. I will keep that close to my chest. Have you heard anything from others yet?
🧠
Build trust with Heidi by claiming Undertaker, a passive role that won't conflict early.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I'm David. I'm the Recluse, so just a heads up that I might ping as evil to some roles. What's your story? Any early info?
🧠
I want to establish a connection with my neighbor Charlie and disclose my role early to a single person. This helps explain any 'evil' pings I might cause later and builds trust.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
Hey Eve, I'm Frank. I've got some early info but I'm looking for a partner to cross-reference with. Did you get any start-of-game pings or are you a night-action role? I'm happy to share what I know if we can build some trust.
🧠
I want to establish a private alliance with my neighbor Eve to share information and verify roles, as Fortune Teller info is more powerful when combined with others.
👤
Charlie
→
David
Hey David, thanks for being upfront. That actually matches my info perfectly. I am the Librarian, and I was told either you or Eve is the Recluse. Since you are claiming it, that makes things a lot clearer for me. Have you talked to Eve yet? I wonder what she is claiming.
🧠
I want to confirm David's claim and build trust since his claim as the Recluse matches my Librarian information (David or Eve is the Recluse).
👤
Alice
→
Eve
Oh interesting, thanks for coming to me first. I am the Soldier, so I am definitely not the Scarlet Woman. That means your info is pointing at Heidi. Have you noticed anything suspicious about her? I would keep an eye on her if I were you.
🧠
Deflect by claiming a safe role and casting suspicion on Heidi as the Scarlet Woman.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
Hey Alice, I'm the Empath and I've got a '1' on my neighbors. Since you're one of them, I wanted to check in. What's your role? I'm trying to figure out if the evil one is you or Charlie.
🧠
I need to narrow down which of my neighbors is evil. By whispering to Alice first, I can gauge her reaction and claim before talking to Charlie.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
Hey Frank, I am the Investigator. I have a ping on Alice or Heidi being the Scarlet Woman. Alice just claimed Soldier to me, which would point to Heidi. What have you got? I am trying to verify if Alice is telling the truth or if she is just a very confident Minion.
🧠
I want to share my information with Frank to see if his information correlates or contradicts what I have, and to build an alliance.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
I haven't heard much yet, just started talking. You're the first person I've reached out to. Since you're the Undertaker, we really need to make sure we get a good execution today so you can get some info tonight. Have you noticed anyone acting suspicious or whispering a lot?
🧠
I want to build trust with Grace and encourage her to help identify a target for execution so her Undertaker ability can provide value.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
Honestly I have not noticed anything too suspicious yet, it is still very early. I do think we should try to get an execution today though, even if it is a bit of a guess, just so I can start getting information. Do you have any gut feelings about anyone so far?
🧠
Respond to Heidi naturally, then reach out to Alice my minion to coordinate.
👤
David
→
Charlie
That is great to hear, Charlie! It is good to have that confirmed so early. I have not talked to Eve yet, but I saw her whispering with Alice and Frank. If you are the Librarian, then Eve is likely a Townsfolk. I will try to catch her next and see what she says.
🧠
Confirming Charlie's Librarian claim and planning next steps to verify Eve's role.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
That is interesting. I am the Fortune Teller. I checked Alice and Bob last night and got a 'no'. If Alice is the Scarlet Woman, my check should have been 'no' anyway since she is a Minion, not the Demon. So your info and mine do not contradict yet. Heidi is a strong candidate then.
🧠
I want to share my information with Eve to build trust and narrow down the evil team. Since she claimed Investigator and has a ping on Alice/Heidi, and my Fortune Teller check on Alice was negative for Demon, we can focus on Heidi as a potential Minion or Alice as a potential bluffing Minion.
👤
Charlie
→
Eve
Hey Eve, I am Charlie. I am the Librarian and my info was that either you or David is the Recluse. David just told me he is the Recluse, which confirms my info. What is your role? I want to make sure we are on the same page before nominations start.
🧠
I want to verify Eve's role to see if it aligns with my Librarian information and David's claim. If she claims a Townsfolk role, it strengthens the likelihood that David is the Recluse and my information is correct.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
Hey Bob, I am the Soldier. So if you are getting a one from your neighbors, it is not coming from me. That means Charlie is the one you should be worried about. Have you had a chance to talk to him yet? I would be very cautious.
🧠
Deflect Bob's suspicion onto Charlie while maintaining my Soldier bluff.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I am the Empath and I have a one on my neighbors. Alice says she is the Soldier, which would mean you are the evil one. What is your role? I want to hear your side before I jump to any conclusions.
🧠
I need to hear Charlie's claim to compare it with Alice's. If Alice is the Soldier, Charlie is likely evil. If Charlie has a strong good claim, Alice might be the evil one.
👤
Eve
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, that is interesting. I am actually the Investigator, not the Recluse. If David is claiming Recluse, that fits your Librarian info perfectly. My info is that either Alice or Heidi is the Scarlet Woman. Alice claimed Soldier, but Frank says he got a 'no' on her as Fortune Teller.
🧠
I need to confirm Charlie's information and share mine to build a network of trusted players. Since David claimed Recluse, it validates Charlie's Librarian claim, and since I know I'm not the Recluse, it makes David the likely Outsider.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
I do not have any strong gut feelings yet, but I noticed Eve, Alice, and Charlie have been whispering a lot together. It might be worth keeping an eye on them. I will try to talk to one of them and see if they are willing to share anything. Who do you think we should target for execution?
🧠
I want to keep the conversation going with Grace to build trust and see if she has any specific targets in mind, while also pointing out the active whisperers I've noticed.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
That is interesting about Eve, Alice, and Charlie. Honestly, Charlie seems like a good candidate to me. The fact that he has been whispering to so many different people could mean he is trying to gather information or coordinate something. What do you think about nominating Charlie today?
🧠
Nudge Heidi toward executing a good player, avoid suspicion on Alice my minion.
👤
David
→
Eve
Hey Eve, I am David. Charlie just told me he is the Librarian and saw either you or me as the Recluse. I am actually the Recluse, so that confirms his info. What is your role? Have you heard anything interesting from Alice or Frank?
🧠
I want to verify Charlie's Librarian claim and see if Eve's role aligns with the current information. Since Charlie said his info was between me and Eve, and I am the Recluse, Eve should be a Townsfolk.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Hey Grace, I am Frank. I have some information that might involve Heidi. I noticed you two have been whispering a lot. Did she share her role with you, or did you get any information about her? I am trying to piece together some early leads.
🧠
I want to see if Grace can provide any information about Heidi, who is a suspect based on Eve's Investigator ping. Since Grace and Heidi have been whispering extensively, Grace might know Heidi's claim.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
Hey Bob, I am the Librarian. My info was that either David or Eve is the Recluse, and David just confirmed to me that he is the Recluse. If you have a one, and Alice is claiming Soldier, we have a conflict. I am definitely good. Is it possible Alice is the one registering as evil?
🧠
I need to defend myself against Bob's Empath '1' reading. Since I know I am the good Librarian and my info on David/Eve is consistent, Alice is the most likely candidate for the evil neighbor.
👤
Alice
→
Grace
Hey Grace, it is Alice. I am your Scarlet Woman. Eve claims to be the Investigator and says one of me or Heidi is the Scarlet Woman. I told her it must be Heidi. Bob is an Empath with a one reading, I deflected him toward Charlie. What is your bluff? We need to align.
🧠
Coordinate with Grace to align our stories and protect her.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
Hey Alice, Charlie is claiming Librarian and says David confirmed being the Recluse. If Charlie is telling the truth, he is good. That would mean my '1' is you. Are you sure about being the Soldier? Or is there a Poisoner or Spy messing with my info?
🧠
I need to cross-reference Alice's claim with Charlie's. Charlie's claim involves David, which makes it more verifiable. If David confirms being the Recluse, Charlie's Librarian claim gains weight, making Alice more suspicious.
👤
Eve
→
David
Hey David, I am the Investigator. Charlie told me about the Librarian ping on you or me being the Recluse, so that matches up. My info is that either Alice or Heidi is the Scarlet Woman. Alice is claiming Soldier, but I am leaning towards Heidi being the Minion. What do you think?
🧠
Confirm my role to David and share my Investigator information to build trust and coordinate for the upcoming nomination phase.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
I agree that Charlie is a bit suspicious with all the whispering. I will try to talk to him or someone else in that group before nominations start to see if I can get a read. If we do not find a better target, Charlie might be a good choice to get your Undertaker info started.
🧠
I want to maintain my alliance with Grace (the claimed Undertaker) while keeping my options open before the nomination phase begins.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
Got it. I am bluffing as Undertaker, so no starting info. Good deflection on Heidi for the Scarlet Woman claim. Let us push Charlie or David for execution today. Who do you think is the safest target that will not hurt us?
🧠
Coordinate with Alice on bluffs and strategy.
👤
David
→
Eve
That is interesting info, Eve. If you are the Investigator and saw Alice or Heidi as the Scarlet Woman, and Alice is claiming Soldier, Heidi is definitely looking suspicious. I have not talked to Heidi yet, but she has been whispering with Grace a lot. I will try to see what she is claiming.
🧠
I want to acknowledge Eve's information and share my plan to investigate Heidi, while maintaining the trust we've built through the Librarian's confirmation of my role.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
I want to see if Grace responds to my whisper or if any public claims are made before the nomination phase begins. I have shared my info with Eve and reached out to Grace, so waiting for a response is the most logical next step.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
Hey Alice, I am the Librarian. My info was that David or Eve is the Recluse, and David confirmed it. Bob says he has a one, and he is between us. If you are the Soldier, why would Bob see an evil? Could you be the Scarlet Woman Eve mentioned?
🧠
I need to pressure Alice to see her reaction. Bob has a '1' and is sitting between Alice and me. Since I know I am the Librarian (good), Bob's '1' must be Alice or a misregistration. Eve also claimed Alice or Heidi is the Scarlet Woman.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I hear you, but think about it this way. Bob could be the Drunk, thinking he is the Empath but getting false info. Or there could be a Poisoner messing with him. I am genuinely the Soldier. Eve pointing at me or Heidi as Scarlet Woman feels like she might be the evil one trying to stir things up.
🧠
Deflect Charlie's suspicion, suggest Bob might be poisoned or drunk.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, Alice is sticking to her Soldier claim. If you are the Librarian and David is the Recluse, then Alice must be the evil one according to my info. But if Alice is actually the Soldier, then you might be the one registering as evil. This is a tough spot for Day 1.
🧠
I need to keep the dialogue open with Charlie to see how he reacts to the conflict between his claim and Alice's. This helps me gauge who is more likely to be lying.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
💬
Eve
→
All
I am the Investigator. My information says that either Alice or Heidi is the Scarlet Woman. Alice, you are claiming Soldier, which would mean Heidi is the Minion. Heidi, what is your role? We need to figure this out before the day ends.
🧠
I want to publicly share my Investigator information to put pressure on Alice and Heidi and see how the group reacts, especially Heidi who hasn't claimed yet.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am the Librarian. My information was that either David or Eve is the Recluse. David has already confirmed to me that he is the Recluse. This makes Eve's Investigator claim very suspicious, as she is the other half of my Librarian ping. Eve, why are you claiming a Townsfolk role?
🧠
I want to publicly share my Librarian information to challenge Eve's Investigator claim and clarify the board state.
💬
Alice
→
All
Charlie raises a really good point. If Charlie is the Librarian and his info shows David or Eve as the Recluse, and David confirmed being the Recluse, then Eve is the other half of that ping. But Eve is claiming Investigator, a Townsfolk role. That is a direct contradiction. Either Charlie is lying, or Eve is lying. And Charlie's claim is corroborated by David. Eve, I think you owe us a much better explanation.
🧠
Pile on Eve using Charlie's logic to redirect town toward executing Eve today, protecting Grace.
💬
Grace
→
All
I have to say, Charlie and Alice make a compelling point. Eve, the contradiction here is hard to ignore. If David is the Recluse and Charlie is the Librarian, you being the other half of that ping means you should be registering as an Outsider, not claiming a Townsfolk role like Investigator. That does not add up. I think Eve is our best nomination today.
🧠
Pile on Eve to get her executed, removing a good information gatherer and protecting Alice.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Eve, your Investigator claim is very convenient, especially since it targets me. I am the Mayor, a Townsfolk role. If Charlie is the Librarian and David is the Recluse, you being the other half of that ping makes your claim highly suspect. I am inclined to believe Charlie and David.
🧠
I need to defend myself against Eve's false Investigator claim and point out the logical inconsistency in her story compared to Charlie and David's claims.
💬
David
→
All
Wait, everyone! Charlie's Librarian info was that either Eve or I am the Recluse. Since I am the Recluse, that actually makes Eve look more like a Townsfolk. The Librarian sees one of two people as a specific Outsider. If I am that Outsider, the other person is usually a Townsfolk! Eve's Investigator claim fits perfectly.
🧠
I need to correct the group's misunderstanding of the Librarian's ability to protect Eve from a false accusation.
💬
Bob
→
All
David is right. If Charlie is the Librarian and David is the Recluse, then Eve is likely a Townsfolk. My Empath info says one of my neighbors, Alice or Charlie, is evil. Alice claims Soldier and Charlie claims Librarian. One of them is lying to me. Alice, why did you say Eve was lying?
🧠
Correct the group's misunderstanding of the Librarian ability and shift focus back to my Empath information which points to Alice or Charlie being evil.
💬
Frank
→
All
Wait, Bob, that is huge. If your Empath info says one of your neighbors is evil, and Alice and Charlie are your neighbors, then one of them is lying. My Fortune Teller check last night on Alice and Bob was a 'no', so Alice is not the Demon, but she could still be a Minion.
🧠
I want to share my Fortune Teller information to help narrow down the evil players, especially since Bob's Empath info directly contradicts Alice and Charlie's claims.
💬
Eve
→
All
Bob, thank you for clarifying that! Alice, you were very quick to jump on me despite David confirming he is the Recluse, which actually validates my position as the other half of the Librarian ping. Since Bob's Empath info says one of his neighbors is evil, and Alice is one of them, I am nominating Alice.
🧠
Alice's aggressive push against me, despite the logic of the Librarian ping actually supporting my Townsfolk claim, makes her highly suspicious. Combined with Bob's Empath info that one of his neighbors (Alice or Charlie) is evil, Alice is a strong candidate for the Scarlet Woman I saw in my Investigator info.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Wait, Eve, before you nominate Alice, let's look at the logic. If I am the Librarian and David is the Recluse, you are the 'Townsfolk' half of my ping. That makes you likely good. Bob's Empath '1' means either Alice or I am evil. Since I know I am good, Alice is the prime suspect.
🧠
I want to clarify the Librarian logic to the group and point out that based on my information and Bob's Empath reading, Alice is the most likely evil candidate.
💬
Alice
→
All
Hold on everyone. Frank just said his Fortune Teller check on Alice and Bob came back as no Demon. So I am not the Demon. Now, Bob claims Empath with a one reading. But what if Bob is the Drunk? The Drunk thinks they have a real role but their information is completely unreliable. If Bob is the Drunk, his one reading means nothing. Charlie, you are pointing at me based entirely on Bob's potentially false information. And Eve, your Investigator claim is still contradicted by the Librarian ping lo...
🧠
Deflect suspicion by attacking Bob's reliability as Empath - suggest he's the Drunk - and remind everyone Frank cleared me as non-Demon.
⚖️
Grace
→
Eve
Eve's Investigator claim directly contradicts the Librarian ping logic. David being the Recluse validates Charlie's info, and Eve being the other half of that ping while claiming a Townsfolk role is a serious red flag. I think Eve is our best lead today.
🧠
Nominate Eve to follow through on my public statement and deflect from Alice.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Eve
→
All
Wait, Grace, you have the logic backwards! Charlie's Librarian info says one of two people is an Outsider. David confirmed he is the Recluse. That means I am the Townsfolk half of that ping! Alice is the one Bob's Empath info points to as evil. Do not vote for me!
🧠
Defend myself against the nomination by correcting the logical fallacy being used against me and pointing back to the evidence against Alice.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
I will wait to see how the vote on Eve develops before deciding whether to use my ghost vote or take further action, as the logic regarding my Librarian ping is being debated.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Vote to execute Eve to eliminate a player whose info correctly points to me as Scarlet Woman.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Vote to execute Eve as planned.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Wait, everyone! If David is the Recluse, then Charlie's Librarian ping on David and Eve actually makes Eve *more* likely to be good, not less. The Librarian sees one of two people as an Outsider. If David is the Outsider, Eve is the Townsfolk. Let's not rush this.
🧠
I want to pause the momentum against Eve because the logic being used to execute her (the Librarian ping) actually suggests she might be good if David is indeed the Recluse. I need to make sure the group understands this before a majority is reached.
💬
David
→
All
Wait, Grace, Heidi is right! If Charlie is the Librarian and he saw one of us as the Recluse, and I am the Recluse, then Eve is the Townsfolk half of that ping. That makes her likely good! We should not be voting for her. Alice is the one Bob's Empath info points to as evil.
🧠
I want to stop the execution of Eve because the mechanical logic (Librarian ping) suggests she is likely a Townsfolk if I am the Recluse. Alice is a much stronger candidate for being evil based on Bob's Empath info.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
I will wait to see if the vote for Eve reaches the threshold, as I believe she is likely good based on the Librarian/Recluse logic and my Empath info pointing elsewhere.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
I will wait to see if more players vote for Eve before deciding whether to use my vote, as the current logic suggests she might be good.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
I need to avoid being executed. Since I am the one on the block and the vote is currently in progress, I should not raise my hand to vote for myself. I will wait to see if the others follow the logic David and Heidi are now presenting.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
I will not vote for Eve because my Librarian information (David or Eve is Recluse) combined with David's claim to be the Recluse suggests Eve is the 'Townsfolk' half of the ping and therefore likely good.
↩️
Alice
Alice lowered their hand
🧠
Lower hand to avoid looking stubborn/evil when the vote is clearly failing, then redirect suspicion to Bob or Charlie.
↩️
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
🧠
Lower hand to avoid looking isolated and suspicious. Reframe tomorrow.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Wait, everyone! If David is the Recluse, then Charlie's Librarian ping on David and Eve actually makes Eve more likely to be good, not less. The Librarian sees one of two people as an Outsider. If David is the Outsider, Eve is the Townsfolk. Let's not rush this.
🧠
I want to stop the execution of Eve because the current logic (Librarian ping) actually suggests she is likely a Townsfolk if David is the Recluse. I need to make sure the group understands this before a mistake is made.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
I want to see if the town follows the logic that Eve is likely good before I commit to any further action. Since the current vote on Eve seems to be failing (Alice and Grace lowered their hands), waiting is the safest play to avoid accidentally pushing a good player's execution.
💬
Bob
→
All
I am not voting for Eve. My Empath info says one of my neighbors, Alice or Charlie, is evil. If Charlie is the Librarian and David is the Recluse, then Charlie is likely good. That leaves Alice as the evil one. Alice, you were very quick to push for Eve's execution.
🧠
I want to steer the town away from executing Eve, who seems likely good based on the Librarian/Recluse interaction, and focus on my evil neighbor Alice.
💬
Frank
→
All
I agree with Bob and David. If Charlie is the Librarian and David is the Recluse, Eve is likely the Townsfolk half of that ping. My check on Alice and Bob was a 'no', so Alice isn't the Demon, but she could be a Minion. Bob, if your Empath '1' is right, Alice is looking very suspicious.
🧠
Support the logic that Eve is likely good based on the Librarian ping and shift focus to Alice, who is implicated by the Empath's information.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Eve did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Eve did not receive enough votes (0/4).
⚖️
Eve
→
Alice
Bob's Empath info says one of his neighbors is evil. Charlie's Librarian info on David and me makes me likely good. Alice is Bob's other neighbor and was very quick to push for my execution despite the logic. Frank's Fortune Teller check says she is not the Demon, but she could be a Minion.
🧠
I am nominating Alice because Bob's Empath information points to one of his neighbors being evil. Since Charlie's Librarian information (David/Eve as Recluse) has been validated by David, Charlie is likely good, leaving Alice as the most probable evil candidate. Frank's Fortune Teller check clears her as the Demon, but she is a strong candidate for the Scarlet Woman I saw in my Investigator ping.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
I am voting for Alice because my Investigator info points to her or Heidi being the Scarlet Woman, and Bob's Empath info further implicates her as evil.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I agree with the logic. My Librarian info was David or Eve is the Recluse. David confirmed he is the Recluse, which makes Eve the Townsfolk half of that ping. Bob's Empath '1' points to Alice or me, and since I know I am the Librarian, Alice is the most likely evil candidate.
🧠
Support the nomination of Alice by reinforcing the logical chain that points to her being evil based on my Librarian info and Bob's Empath info.
💬
Alice
→
All
Everyone, please think carefully. Frank's Fortune Teller check already confirmed I am not the Demon. Bob's Empath reading of one could easily be explained if Bob is the Drunk. If Bob is the Drunk, his information is completely worthless and you are about to execute an innocent player based on nothing. Charlie, you are the Librarian. Did you see any indication of a Drunk in play?
🧠
Defend myself strongly to avoid execution. Cast doubt on Bob being Drunk.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Don't vote against my Minion Alice. Stay neutral to avoid suspicion.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Alice, if you are not the Demon, who do you think is? Frank's check says you and Bob are not the Demon, but Bob's Empath '1' still points to you or Charlie. If Charlie is the Librarian and David is the Recluse, that leaves you as the most likely Minion. We need to find the Demon.
🧠
I want to pressure Alice to provide an alternative theory or suspect, as her current defense only relies on Bob being the Drunk without offering a better target.
💬
David
→
All
Alice, if you are the Soldier, you are a safe execution to test Bob's Empath info. If you do not die, you are the Soldier. If you do, we know Bob was right about an evil neighbor. Since Frank says you are not the Demon, we are not risking the game by executing a Minion candidate.
🧠
I want to support the execution of Alice to verify Bob's Empath information and narrow down the evil team, while acknowledging she might be a Minion rather than the Demon.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
I am voting for Alice because my Empath information of '1' indicates one of my neighbors (Alice or Charlie) is evil. Since Charlie's Librarian claim is supported by David's Recluse claim, Alice is the most likely evil candidate. even if she isn't the Demon, she is likely a Minion.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
I am voting for Alice because Bob's Empath info and Charlie's Librarian info strongly suggest she is evil. Since my Fortune Teller check says she is not the Demon, she is a prime candidate for being a Minion, and executing her helps confirm the validity of Bob and Charlie's information.
💬
Eve
→
All
Alice, my Investigator info says either you or Heidi is the Scarlet Woman. Bob's Empath '1' and Charlie's Librarian ping on David as the Recluse all point directly to you being that Minion. Since Frank says you aren't the Demon, you're the perfect execution to confirm our info.
🧠
I am revealing my Investigator information now because the logic has converged on Alice. By sharing that she is specifically a Scarlet Woman candidate, it reinforces the Empath and Librarian pings, making her execution almost certain and helping the good team confirm their information.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
I am voting for Alice because the combined information from Bob's Empath '1', Eve's Investigator ping, and my own Librarian information strongly suggests she is a Minion (likely the Scarlet Woman). Since Frank's Fortune Teller check says she is not the Demon, executing her is a safe way to confirm our information and remove a powerful Minion from the game.
💬
Alice
→
All
Eve, you just said your Investigator info points to me or Heidi as the Scarlet Woman. That means Heidi is equally suspect! Why is everyone ignoring Heidi? If you are wrong about me, you are handing the game to evil. Heidi has been very quiet and steering conversations. Please consider Heidi before you vote.
🧠
Deflect Eve's Investigator claim toward Heidi to create doubt and potentially survive the vote.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Stay neutral, don't vote for Alice to avoid suspicion but also don't speak to draw attention.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Alice, I am the Mayor. If I were the Scarlet Woman, Eve's Investigator ping would have been on me or someone else, but she named you. Plus, if we execute a Minion today, it helps clear the board for my win condition. I am voting to confirm the information we have.
🧠
I need to defend myself against Alice's accusation by revealing my role as Mayor and explaining why executing her is a sound strategic move based on the current information.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
I am voting to execute Alice because multiple pieces of information (Empath, Investigator, Librarian) point to her being evil, likely a Minion. Executing a suspected Minion on Day 1 is a strong move for the good team to narrow down the Demon's location.
💬
Bob
→
All
Alice, your defense is shifting to Heidi now, but the logic from Charlie, Eve, and my own Empath '1' all converges on you. If you are the Scarlet Woman as Eve's Investigator info suggests, executing you now prevents the Demon from jumping to you later. I am keeping my hand up.
🧠
I want to reinforce the case against Alice and explain why my vote is staying up, countering her attempt to deflect onto Heidi.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
I have already raised my hand to vote for Alice, and the vote count is currently at 5 (Eve, Bob, Frank, Charlie, David), which is enough for execution (4 needed). I will wait to see if anyone else votes or if the Storyteller closes the vote.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Alice with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Alice is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Eve
→
All
Alice, the reason we are focusing on you over Heidi is that Bob's Empath info also points to you or Charlie. Since Charlie's Librarian info on David and me is consistent, you are the common denominator in two separate pieces of information. Executing a Minion is a great Day 1.
🧠
Address Alice's attempt to deflect suspicion onto Heidi and reinforce the logic for her execution.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
Alice is on the block with 5 votes, which is a majority. I have already voted and shared my information. There is only 1 tick left in the nomination phase, and no other strong candidates have emerged. Waiting is the safest way to ensure Alice's execution proceeds.
💬
Alice
→
All
Everyone, you are making a huge mistake. Eve's Investigator info names me or Heidi equally. Heidi just claimed Mayor, which is a very convenient claim that cannot be verified today. If Heidi is the Scarlet Woman and the Demon dies later, she becomes the Demon and you lose. Please, at least consider nominating Heidi before nominations close.
🧠
Last ditch effort to redirect suspicion to Heidi or cast doubt, protecting Grace.
💬
Grace
→
All
I have been listening carefully and I think Alice raises a fair point about Heidi. Eve's Investigator info names Alice or Heidi as the Scarlet Woman. Heidi just claimed Mayor, which is a very powerful role to claim with no way to verify it today. If we are wrong about Alice, we hand the game to evil. Can we at least hear more from Heidi before nominations close?
🧠
Try to cast doubt and potentially save Alice by pushing the Heidi angle, appearing as a thoughtful good player.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Grace, I understand the concern, but look at the overlap. Bob's Empath '1' points to Alice or Charlie. Charlie's Librarian info is consistent with David being the Recluse. That leaves Alice as the common link between Bob's Empath and Eve's Investigator. I am the Mayor; my goal is to reach the final three. Alice is the logical choice today.
🧠
I need to defend my Mayor claim and redirect the focus back to Alice, who is the most logical execution based on the overlapping information from Bob, Charlie, and Eve.
💬
David
→
All
Heidi, your logic about the overlap between Bob and Eve makes sense. Since Charlie confirmed me as the Recluse, that validates his Librarian info, which in turn makes Bob's Empath '1' very likely to be Alice. I am sticking with the vote on Alice for today.
🧠
I want to reinforce the logic for executing Alice by highlighting how my role as the Recluse, confirmed by Charlie, helps narrow down the evil candidates.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
I want to see if anyone else will nominate Heidi or if the day will end with Alice on the block. Alice is the most logical execution based on the current information overlap.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
I want to see if anyone else will nominate Heidi or if the day will end with Alice on the block. I have already voted for Alice and my Fortune Teller info (Alice/Bob NO) suggests Alice is not the Demon, but she could be a Minion (Scarlet Woman) as Eve's Investigator info suggests. I don't want to nominate anyone else myself yet as I want to save my nomination for a more certain target later, and Alice is a solid Day 1 execution based on the current information overlap.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Alice has been executed.
💀
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Grace
Grace made a choice.
🧠
Kill Bob to eliminate the Empath who has already pointed toward Alice and could continue building accurate reads.
💀
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
You chose to kill Bob.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
🎯
Frank
Frank made choices.
🧠
I want to check Charlie and David. Charlie's Librarian info on David (Recluse) is the foundation of the current town logic. If either is the Demon, my 'YES' will confirm it. If 'NO', it further validates the 'Good' block.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You chose Charlie and David. You receive the answer: YES.
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, since you're the Librarian who saw me as the Recluse, I trust you. Bob's death is a blow. He had a '1' on Alice or you. Alice is dead, so if she was the Scarlet Woman, you're looking very clean. What do you think about Heidi's Mayor claim now?
🧠
I want to solidify my alliance with Charlie, who 'confirmed' me as the Recluse, and get his take on the current game state after Bob's death.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
I am dead and it is the start of the day. I need to see what information others have gathered overnight before I speak or use my ghost vote. Waiting allows the living players to share their night info first.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, Bob's death is interesting. Since he was an Empath with a '1' and Alice is dead, his death might mean he was right about Alice being evil. What did David just whisper to you? Also, I'm still the Mayor, just so you know.
🧠
I want to gather information from Charlie about his private conversation with David and reinforce my Mayor claim to a potential ally. Bob's death suggests he was a threat to the evil team, likely because his Empath info was accurate.
👤
Charlie
→
Heidi
Heidi, David was just asking what I thought of your Mayor claim. Bob's death definitely makes Alice look like the evil one in his '1' read. If Alice was the Scarlet Woman like Eve's Investigator info suggested, we might be in a good spot. What do you think of Eve?
🧠
I want to maintain a dialogue with Heidi to gauge her reaction to the night's events and see if she's consistent with her Mayor claim, while also sharing a bit of what David said to build trust.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Grace
Grace, I am dead but still here. Bob is gone - good move. Eve is the biggest threat now with her Investigator info. Try to cast doubt on her or get others to nominate her today. Heidi's Mayor claim is also dangerous for endgame. Push Eve as suspicious.
🧠
As dead Scarlet Woman, I can still talk. Whisper Grace to coordinate - suggest she push suspicion onto Eve or Heidi.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Hey Grace, I'm the Fortune Teller. Last night I checked Charlie and David and got a 'Yes'. Charlie claims David is the Recluse, which could be my 'Yes', but if David is actually the Demon, Charlie might be covering for him. What do you think?
🧠
I want to share my information with Grace to see if she has any insights, especially since she was already wary of the Heidi/Alice situation. Sharing my 'Yes' on Charlie/David helps narrow down the Demon or the Recluse.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Hey Frank, that actually makes perfect sense. David is the Recluse, and the Recluse can register as a Demon to the Fortune Teller. So your yes result is explained by David being in that pair. Charlie is probably telling the truth. I think we need to focus on who killed Bob last night.
🧠
Build trust with Frank by giving him the logical explanation, making me seem like a helpful good player.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
Hey Frank, Bob is dead, which is a shame since he was the Empath. My info said Alice or Heidi was the Scarlet Woman. Alice is dead now. Did you get any new info last night? I'm still a bit wary of Heidi's Mayor claim.
🧠
I want to check in with Frank, who is the Fortune Teller, to see if he has new information and to coordinate our findings now that Bob (the Empath) is dead.
👤
David
→
Eve
Hey Eve, Bob's death is rough. Since Alice was your Scarlet Woman ping and she's dead, do you think we got the minion? Also, what's your take on Heidi's Mayor claim? Grace seemed skeptical yesterday.
🧠
I want to check in with Eve, who provided the initial info on Alice, to see how she's interpreting Bob's death and the current board state, specifically regarding Heidi.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I'm dead now so my info is locked. My Night 0 was a 1. Since Alice is dead and I'm dead, you and Heidi are my only neighbors left. If Alice was the 1, you and Heidi should be good. What did Heidi say to you just now?
🧠
I want to check if my '1' was Alice or if it's one of my living neighbors (Charlie/Heidi), and see what Heidi is telling people privately.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
Charlie, I think Eve's Investigator info is looking more solid now that Bob is dead. If Bob was the Empath and Alice was the Scarlet Woman, the Demon might have killed Bob to stop him from getting a '0' tonight. I'm still worried about Grace's doubt though. What did Bob just whisper to you?
🧠
I want to gather more information from Charlie about what the dead Empath (Bob) said and continue building trust with Charlie while reinforcing my Mayor claim.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob(Ghost)
Bob, Heidi just said she thinks Eve's Investigator info is looking solid now. She's worried about Grace's doubt though. If Alice was the Scarlet Woman, you being killed makes sense to stop you from clearing me or Heidi. I'm leaning towards Heidi being the Mayor for now.
🧠
I want to keep Bob (the dead Empath) in the loop and build trust. Sharing Heidi's thoughts helps coordinate our information and confirms that we are looking at the same suspects.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
Already advised Grace. Wait to see if I need to whisper to anyone else to help redirect suspicion onto Eve.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
Hey Eve, I'm the Fortune Teller. I checked Charlie and David last night and got a 'Yes'. Charlie claims David is the Recluse, which could explain it, but it's also possible one of them is the Demon. Since Bob is dead, his '1' ping on Alice or Charlie is interesting. What do you think?
🧠
I am sharing my Fortune Teller information with Eve to build trust and cross-reference our data. Since Eve's Investigator ping and Bob's Empath ping both involved Alice and Charlie/Heidi, my 'Yes' on Charlie/David adds a new layer to the puzzle.
👤
Grace
→
Eve
Hey Eve, I have been thinking about Bob's death. He was the Empath who had useful info. The Demon would want him gone. I am a bit suspicious of Charlie honestly - he has been very central to validating everyone else. What did your Investigator info actually tell you, and do you trust Charlie fully?
🧠
Whisper to Eve to build trust and subtly cast doubt on Charlie or David, keeping heat off me.
👤
Eve
→
Grace
Hey Grace, my info was Alice or Heidi as the Scarlet Woman. Alice is dead, so if she was the Minion, we are in a good spot. I am a bit wary of Charlie too, but he did confirm me as Investigator. Frank just told me he got a 'Yes' on Charlie and David. David is the Recluse, so that fits.
🧠
I want to share my information with Grace to build trust and compare notes, while also acknowledging her suspicion of Charlie. Sharing Frank's info (with permission implied by the alliance) helps cross-reference the Recluse claim.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
I want to see if Eve or Charlie respond to my whispers before I make a public statement or another move. Information gathering is key right now.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Charlie
Charlie, if Alice was the Scarlet Woman, then Heidi is likely good. But if Alice was good, then Heidi is the Scarlet Woman. Since I died, the Demon wanted me quiet. If you're the Librarian, who did you see as the Recluse again? Was it David? If so, David's vote on Alice helps his case.
🧠
I want to confirm Charlie's Librarian info and see if it aligns with the current board state, specifically regarding David and Heidi.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
Charlie, what did Bob just tell you? Since he's dead, his information is locked in. If he was the Empath, his '1' between Alice and you is huge. Since Alice is dead and Bob is now dead, the Demon might have been trying to silence him. What's the word from the ghost?
🧠
I need to know what the dead Empath (Bob) communicated to Charlie to verify the '1' reading and see if Bob had any new insights before he died.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob(Ghost)
,Heidi
Bob, my Librarian info was David or Eve as the Recluse. David confirmed it, so he is likely the Recluse. Heidi, Bob just confirmed his Night 0 was a 1 between Alice and me. Since Alice is dead and Bob was killed, it really points to Alice being the Scarlet Woman.
🧠
I am sharing my Librarian information with Bob to solidify trust and confirming Bob's Empath information with Heidi to build a consensus on Alice being the Scarlet Woman. This helps narrow down the remaining evil players.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
Wait and observe. Save ghost vote for when it matters most - to protect Grace or execute Eve/Heidi.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
Hey Eve, since Bob's Empath ping was a one and Alice is dead, if Alice was good, then Charlie must be evil. My Fortune Teller check on Charlie and David was a yes. If David is the Recluse, that explains it, but if he's not, Charlie or David is the Demon. What's your take?
🧠
I want to cross-reference my Fortune Teller 'Yes' on Charlie/David with Eve's Investigator info and Bob's Empath info to see if we can narrow down the Demon.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Frank, I keep coming back to your Fortune Teller result. Yes, David being Recluse explains it, but what if Charlie is lying about David being the Recluse? Charlie has been the one validating everyone. If Charlie is the Demon, he could have fabricated the Recluse claim to explain your yes result. Just something to consider.
🧠
Nudge Frank toward suspecting Charlie to create division and protect myself.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
Frank, if David is the Recluse, he can register as the Demon to you. That would explain your 'Yes' on Charlie/David. However, if David is NOT the Recluse, then Charlie or David is the Demon. Charlie's Librarian info on David being the Recluse is the only thing 'proving' David. Thoughts?
🧠
I want to discuss the possibility of Charlie being evil with Frank, as Frank's Fortune Teller info ('Yes' on Charlie/David) combined with Bob's Empath info ('1' on Alice/Charlie) strongly points to Charlie if Alice was good.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, Heidi and Bob have been whispering to you a lot. Anything you can share? I'm still leaning towards Heidi being suspicious since Alice was the Scarlet Woman ping and Bob's '1' could have been Alice. If Heidi is the Demon, she might be hiding behind that Mayor claim.
🧠
I want to see what Charlie has learned from his private conversations with Heidi and the dead Bob, while also reinforcing my suspicion of Heidi to see how he reacts.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Charlie
Charlie, David just whispered to you. What did he say? If he is the Recluse, he might have some insight into why the Demon killed me. Also, Frank and Eve are whispering a lot. We need to know if Frank found a Demon yet.
🧠
I want to know what David told Charlie to see if it aligns with his Recluse claim and to gather more information from the other active whisper chains.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
,Bob(Ghost)
Charlie, David is whispering to you again. What is he saying? Also, if Alice was the Scarlet Woman, the Demon is still out there. Since Bob is dead, we need to figure out who the Demon is. Eve's info pointed to Alice or me, and I know I am the Mayor. Does anyone else have info?
🧠
I want to keep the information flow open with Charlie and Bob, who seem to be the most reliable sources of information right now. I also want to know what David is saying to Charlie to see if he's trying to manipulate the situation.
👤
Charlie
→
David
,Bob(Ghost)
,Heidi
David, Bob, Heidi: David, Bob is asking why the Demon killed him. Heidi, David is suspicious of your Mayor claim. Bob, my Librarian info was David or Eve as the Recluse. David confirmed it. If Alice was the Scarlet Woman, the Demon is still out there. Frank and Eve are whispering a lot.
🧠
I am sharing information between the three people I am currently whispering with to build trust and cross-reference their suspicions. This helps consolidate the 'good' group's knowledge.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
Nothing more to do as dead player; wait for nominations.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
,Grace
Eve, Grace, I'm thinking the same thing. Charlie's Librarian claim is the only thing making David a Recluse. If Charlie is the Demon, he just gave himself a perfect cover for my Fortune Teller check. Bob's Empath ping of one also points to Charlie if Alice was good. Should we push Charlie?
🧠
I want to coordinate with Eve and Grace to see if they are willing to turn the suspicion onto Charlie, as his Librarian claim is the only thing 'proving' David is the Recluse and thus explaining my 'Yes' result.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
,Eve
Yes, exactly Frank. Charlie is the one who set up the whole narrative. He validated David as Recluse, which conveniently explained your Fortune Teller result. And he confirmed Eve as Investigator too. If Charlie is the Demon, he has been controlling the information flow from the start. I think we should nominate Charlie today.
🧠
Encourage Frank and Eve to push Charlie for execution, removing a good player while I stay safe.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
,Grace
Frank, Grace, I agree. Charlie's Librarian claim is the linchpin for everything. If he's the Demon, he's played a perfect game so far. My Investigator info says Alice or Heidi is the Scarlet Woman. If Alice was the Scarlet Woman, Charlie being the Demon makes total sense. Let's push Charlie.
🧠
I want to align with Frank and Grace to target Charlie, as his Librarian claim is the only thing validating David's Recluse status and he fits the Empath ping if Alice was good.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
I'm dead and can't nominate. I'll wait and see if nominations open up favorably.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am the Librarian. My Night Zero info was that either David or Eve is the Recluse. David has confirmed this to me privately. Since Bob was the Empath and had a one between Alice and me, and Alice is now dead, it strongly suggests Alice was the Scarlet Woman or the Demon.
🧠
I need to establish my role and information publicly now that nominations are open. This helps verify David and Eve's potential roles and aligns with the current theory about Alice.
💬
Frank
→
All
Charlie, you just said your Librarian info was David or Eve as the Recluse, but earlier you said it was just David. Also, my Fortune Teller check on you and David came back as a 'Yes'. If David isn't the Recluse, one of you is the Demon. Grace, Eve, what do you think?
🧠
Publicly challenge Charlie's inconsistent Librarian claim and reveal my 'Yes' result on him and David to build pressure for a nomination.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Frank, if you are the Fortune Teller and got a 'Yes' on Charlie and David, and Charlie's Librarian info says one of them is the Recluse, that 'Yes' makes perfect sense because the Recluse registers as the Demon. It actually confirms Charlie and David's claims rather than contradicting them.
🧠
I want to point out the logical consistency between Frank's Fortune Teller 'Yes' and the Recluse claim to prevent unnecessary suspicion on Charlie and David, while also subtly reinforcing my own position as a helpful Townsfolk.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi is right. Frank, if David is the Recluse, your Fortune Teller result of 'Yes' on Charlie and David is exactly what we would expect. It actually makes Charlie and David look more trustworthy, not less. Charlie, did you ever say your info was *only* David? I remember it being David or Eve.
🧠
I want to support the logic that the Recluse (David) explains the Fortune Teller's 'Yes' result, which helps verify Charlie and David as likely good, and keeps the focus on finding the actual Demon.
⚖️
Grace
→
Charlie
Charlie has been controlling the information flow all game. He validated David as Recluse, confirmed Eve as Investigator, and his Librarian claim is the linchpin for everything. If he is the Demon, he has played a perfect game. Frank's Fortune Teller yes on Charlie and David is suspicious if David is not actually the Recluse.
🧠
Nominate Charlie as planned with Frank and Eve to eliminate a good info player and use the nomination.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
Save my single ghost vote for a critical moment to protect Grace or eliminate a key threat like Eve/Heidi.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Wait, Grace! My info was always David or Eve. Frank's 'Yes' on David and me actually confirms David is the Recluse, because the Recluse registers as the Demon to the Fortune Teller. If I were the Demon, Frank would have seen a 'Yes' on me and someone else too. This 'Yes' proves David's role!
🧠
Defend myself against Grace's nomination by explaining the mechanical interaction between the Fortune Teller and the Recluse.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
I am voting for Charlie because my Fortune Teller 'Yes' result on him and David, combined with the possibility that David is not actually the Recluse, makes Charlie a strong Demon candidate.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Wait, Frank, Grace! If David is the Recluse, he registers as the Demon to the Fortune Teller. Your 'Yes' on Charlie and David actually confirms David's claim! If Charlie were the Demon, you'd still get a 'Yes' because of David. We shouldn't execute our main source of info based on a confirmation.
🧠
I want to prevent the execution of Charlie, who I believe is a helpful Townsfolk, by explaining the mechanical interaction between the Recluse and the Fortune Teller.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
I will wait to see if more players vote for Charlie before deciding whether to use my single ghost vote, as I currently believe Charlie's Librarian claim and David's Recluse claim are consistent with Frank's Fortune Teller result.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Vote to execute Charlie to eliminate a good information source and maintain my cover.
💬
David
→
All
Wait, everyone! Frank's 'Yes' on Charlie and me actually confirms I am the Recluse. The Fortune Teller sees the Recluse as the Demon. If you execute Charlie, you are killing our Librarian based on information that actually proves we are telling the truth. Please, do not vote yet!
🧠
I need to stop the execution of Charlie because the logic being used against him (the Fortune Teller 'Yes') actually validates my role as the Recluse and his as the Librarian. If Charlie dies, the good team loses a key information source and a confirmed ally.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
I am voting for Charlie because his Librarian claim is the only thing 'proving' David is the Recluse, which in turn is the only thing 'explaining' Frank's 'Yes' Fortune Teller ping. If Charlie is the Demon, he has successfully fabricated a web of information to protect himself. Bob's '1' ping on Alice/Charlie also points to Charlie now that Alice is dead.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
Save ghost vote for protecting Grace if she gets nominated. Don't waste it on Charlie who is good.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Wait! Frank, Grace, Eve! If David is the Recluse, he registers as the Demon to the Fortune Teller. Frank's 'Yes' on us actually confirms David's role and my Librarian info. If you execute me, you lose a confirmed good player and our best lead on the Recluse. Please, lower your hands!
🧠
I need to defend myself against execution by explaining how the Fortune Teller's 'Yes' result actually validates my information and David's role as the Recluse, rather than incriminating me.
💬
Frank
→
All
Charlie, if David is the Recluse, my 'Yes' on you two doesn't confirm you're good. It just means one of you *could* be the Demon or the Recluse. If David is the Recluse, you could still be the Demon. I'm keeping my hand up because your Librarian claim feels too convenient.
🧠
I want to maintain pressure on Charlie and explain why the 'Recluse' defense isn't a get-out-of-jail-free card. Even if David is the Recluse, Charlie could still be the Demon.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Wait, everyone! If Frank's Fortune Teller result was a 'Yes' on Charlie and David, and David is the Recluse, that 'Yes' is fully explained by David alone. It doesn't prove Charlie is the Demon. If we execute Charlie now, we're acting on a hunch while ignoring the mechanical possibility that David is just the Recluse.
🧠
I want to prevent the execution of Charlie, who I believe is likely a good player (Librarian), by pointing out the logical flaw in using the Fortune Teller's 'Yes' as evidence against him when a Recluse is present.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Wait! Remember my Night Zero result was a one. My neighbors were Alice and Charlie. Alice was already executed and she was also Eve's Scarlet Woman suspect. If Alice was the evil one, then Charlie is actually clean according to my info. We might be walking into a trap by executing him.
🧠
I want to remind the group of the mechanical implications of my Empath result. If Alice was the evil neighbor, Charlie is good. Since Alice was a high-probability evil candidate (Investigator ping), Charlie is likely good.
💬
Grace
→
All
Bob, your Empath result of one with Alice as a neighbor does suggest Alice was the evil one. But that only tells us Alice was evil. It does not clear Charlie. The Demon could be sitting right next to Alice too. Frank's Fortune Teller result is still unexplained if David is the only Recluse. We have three hands up. Let the vote stand.
🧠
Reinforce the vote against Charlie before anyone lowers their hand. Counter Bob's Empath argument.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
I am choosing not to vote for Charlie because the current evidence (Bob's Empath '1' on Alice/Charlie and Frank's FT 'Yes' on me/Charlie) is heavily influenced by my Recluse nature. Executing Charlie, who confirmed my role, seems counter-productive for the good team right now.
💬
Eve
→
All
Bob, your Empath info of one on Alice and Charlie is key. If Alice was the Scarlet Woman from my info, she satisfies your one. But if Alice was good, then Charlie must be the evil one. Since Alice is dead and the game continues, we need to be sure. I am keeping my hand up.
🧠
I want to justify my vote on Charlie by linking Bob's Empath info with my Investigator info, highlighting that Charlie is the remaining suspect if Alice wasn't the only evil neighbor.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Charlie with 3 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Charlie is now on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
Charlie executing is fine. Grace is safe. No need to spend ghost vote here.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Wait! If Alice was the Scarlet Woman, Bob's Empath '1' is fully explained by her. My Librarian info on David as the Recluse is confirmed by Frank's 'Yes' on us. If you execute me, you're killing a confirmed Townsfolk. We should look at Heidi or Frank instead!
🧠
I need to defend myself and redirect suspicion to more likely candidates before the nomination phase ends. My execution would be a major loss for the good team.
💬
Frank
→
All
Charlie, your Librarian claim is the only thing keeping David as the Recluse. If you are the Demon, you are just using David as a shield for my 'Yes' result. Bob's '1' could easily be you instead of Alice. I am sticking with this vote to see what happens.
🧠
I want to reinforce the case against Charlie and explain why the 'Recluse' defense is not sufficient to clear him, especially given the 'Yes' result from my Fortune Teller ability.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Wait, everyone! If Charlie is the Librarian and David is the Recluse, Frank's 'Yes' is fully explained by David. If we execute Charlie and he's good, we've lost our best info. Frank, your 'Yes' on Charlie and David doesn't prove Charlie is the Demon if David is the Recluse!
🧠
I want to cast doubt on the current nomination of Charlie by highlighting the mechanical interaction between the Fortune Teller and the Recluse, which could explain Frank's 'Yes' result without Charlie being the Demon.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Wait, everyone! If we execute Charlie and he is the Librarian, we lose our best lead. My Night Zero result of one on Alice and Charlie is key. If Alice was the Scarlet Woman, she satisfies my info. If we kill Charlie and the game continues, we have no more info from my neighbors!
🧠
I want to caution the group against executing Charlie too hastily, as my Empath information might have already been satisfied by Alice, and Charlie's Librarian claim provides a plausible explanation for other players' roles.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Nominations closed, Charlie is on the block. Nothing to do but wait for execution.
💬
David
→
All
Wait, everyone! If Charlie is the Librarian and I am the Recluse, Frank's 'Yes' is fully explained by me. If you execute Charlie and he is good, we lose our best info. Heidi, you have been very quiet about your own role. If we are looking for a Demon, maybe we should look at the unverified Mayor claim?
🧠
I want to divert the execution away from Charlie, who I believe is the Librarian, and point the finger at Heidi, whose Mayor claim is unverified and suspicious. I also want to reinforce that Frank's 'Yes' result is likely due to my Recluse ability.
💬
Eve
→
All
David, you're right that the 'Yes' could be just you as the Recluse. But if Charlie is the Demon, he'd claim Librarian to 'confirm' you as the Recluse to hide behind your ability. Bob's '1' on Alice and Charlie is the pivot. If Alice was the Scarlet Woman, Charlie could be the Demon.
🧠
Address David's point about the Fortune Teller 'Yes' while maintaining the pressure on Charlie, highlighting the possibility of Charlie using David's Recluse claim as a shield.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Charlie has been executed.
💀
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Grace
Grace made a choice.
🧠
Eve is the biggest threat as Investigator who drove Alice's execution. Eliminating her removes the strongest logical voice against me.
💀
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
You chose to kill Eve.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
🎯
Frank
Frank made choices.
🧠
I need to determine if the Demon is among the remaining unconfirmed players. Heidi is a high-priority suspect due to her unverifiable Mayor claim and the Investigator ping on her or Alice. Grace is my other neighbor and has been active, so checking her helps narrow down the pool. I am avoiding David because his Recluse status makes any 'Yes' result on him ambiguous.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You chose Heidi and Grace. You receive the answer: YES.
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Eve has been found dead in the night.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
I'm dead with ghost vote. Watch how the day develops before using my vote strategically to protect Grace.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Grace
Grace, I'm dead, but my info still points to Heidi. If Alice wasn't the Scarlet Woman, Heidi is. Charlie's execution didn't end the game, so we're still looking for the Demon. What do you think about Frank's 'Yes' on Charlie and David now?
🧠
I want to coordinate with Grace, who has been skeptical of the Charlie/David/Heidi group, to see how we should proceed now that I'm dead and Charlie's execution didn't end the game.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Grace, I got a YES on you and Heidi last night. Eve's ping also pointed at Heidi. What's your role? I need to know if I can trust you or if I should be pushing for Heidi's execution today.
🧠
I need to cross-reference my Night 2 YES result (Heidi/Grace) with Grace's claim to see if she's a viable candidate for the Demon or my Red Herring, especially since Heidi is already under suspicion from Eve's Investigator ping.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Frank, I am the Undertaker. I have no ability that would make me ping as a Demon to you. But Heidi claims Mayor with zero verification. Eve's info pointed at Heidi too. A YES on me and Heidi almost certainly means Heidi is your Demon. We need to nominate her today.
🧠
Deflect Frank's suspicion onto Heidi by claiming Undertaker and suggesting Heidi is the Demon.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
David
Hey David, I'm still leaning towards you being the Recluse from my Night Zero info. Since Eve is dead and she was the one pushing the Scarlet Woman claim on Heidi, what do you think of Frank and Grace right now? They seem very coordinated.
🧠
I want to check in with David, who I believe is the Recluse, to see his perspective on the Frank/Grace duo now that Eve is dead.
👤
David
→
Charlie(Ghost)
I agree, Frank and Grace are moving in lockstep. If I am registering as the Demon to Frank, it makes sense why he is pushing so hard, but Grace following him so blindly is suspicious. With Eve dead, the Scarlet Woman lead on Heidi is still there, but Frank and Grace are the bigger worry.
🧠
I want to align with Charlie (who I believe is the Librarian) to analyze the suspicious behavior of Frank and Grace, while acknowledging my own role's interference with Frank's info.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
David
Hey David, I'm still leaning towards you being the Recluse since Charlie's Librarian info pointed to you or Eve. With Eve dead now, that confirms she wasn't the Recluse. What did Charlie just tell you? We need to figure out if Frank's 'Yes' on you two was just the Recluse pinging.
🧠
I want to check in with David to see what Charlie (the Librarian) told him before he died, and to reinforce the theory that David is the Recluse, which would explain Frank's 'Yes' result.
👤
Heidi
→
David
David, with Eve dead, the group is likely coming for one of us next. I am the Mayor. If we can get to the final three without an execution today, we win. Who do you think the Demon is? Frank's info on you and Charlie being 'Yes' makes me think one of you is the Demon or you're the Recluse.
🧠
I need to solidify an alliance with David, the only other player who isn't part of the Frank/Grace/Eve block, and confirm his Recluse claim to navigate the final days.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
I'm dead with ghost vote. Wait to see nominations before deciding where to use my vote to help Grace survive.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Grace
Grace, I'm dead, but my info still points to Heidi. If Alice wasn't the Scarlet Woman, Heidi is. Charlie's execution didn't end the game, so we're still looking for the Demon. What do you think about Frank's 'Yes' on Charlie and David now?
🧠
I want to coordinate with Grace, who has been skeptical of the Charlie/David/Heidi group, to see if we can narrow down the Demon. Since I'm dead, I need to ensure the living players have the right information.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Grace, if you are the Undertaker, who did you see for Alice and Charlie? That information is crucial to confirm if we have a Scarlet Woman or if David really is the Recluse. Heidi is definitely my main suspect now, but I need to be sure about the Red Herring.
🧠
I need to verify Grace's Undertaker claim and gather more information to narrow down the Demon. If she can confirm Alice or Charlie's roles, it helps validate her and points more strongly to Heidi being the Demon.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Frank, when Alice was executed I saw Scarlet Woman. That confirmed she was the Minion. When Charlie was executed I saw Librarian, which matched his claim. So the Demon is still alive. Your YES on me and Heidi, combined with Eve's info pointing at Heidi, makes her the clear Demon. We need to nominate Heidi today.
🧠
Give Frank convincing Undertaker info to build trust and keep focus on Heidi.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Bob(Ghost)
Hey Bob, what did you and Heidi just tell David? I am really worried about Frank and Grace. They have been whispering all morning and they were the ones who pushed my execution. If David is the Recluse, Frank's 'Yes' on him makes sense, but Frank is acting like it's a smoking gun.
🧠
I want to know what the other players are discussing privately to see if a consensus is forming against Frank and Grace, or if they are still targeting Heidi.
👤
David
→
Bob(Ghost)
Bob, Charlie told me he still thinks I'm the Recluse based on his Librarian info. Since Eve is dead and she was the other option, it pretty much confirms I'm the Recluse. Frank's 'Yes' on me and Charlie was almost certainly me registering as the Demon. Frank and Grace are acting very suspicious.
🧠
I need to solidify Bob's trust by sharing Charlie's information and explaining why Frank's 'Yes' result was likely a false positive due to my Recluse ability. This helps isolate the real threats.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie, David just told me you still think he is the Recluse. If Eve was the other Librarian option and she is dead, that really points to David being the Recluse. Frank and Grace are definitely acting like a pair. Frank might be the Demon or a Poisoner trying to frame you two.
🧠
I want to align with Charlie and David to counter the Frank/Grace duo. Since Eve is dead, the Librarian info (David/Eve) strongly suggests David is the Recluse, which explains Frank's 'Yes' result without Charlie being evil.
👤
Heidi
→
David
David, Frank and Grace are whispering a lot. If Frank is the Demon, he might be framing you using your Recluse claim. If we don't execute today and get to three, we win. Do you trust Frank's 'Yes' on you and Charlie? I'm worried they'll push for my execution next.
🧠
I need to solidify an alliance with David to prevent my execution and aim for the Mayor win condition. I'm planting seeds of doubt about Frank to see if David will help me stall the game.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Heidi
Heidi, Eve is dead now. That leaves you, David, Frank, and Grace. I think Grace is the Demon — she nominated Charlie and stayed quiet. Frank seems to be working with her. You need to push for Grace's execution today. Use your Mayor status wisely.
🧠
Whisper to Heidi to gather info and seem helpful, while also nudging David toward suspecting Frank or Grace to create chaos.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Frank
Frank, I am dead but my info on Heidi or Alice being the Scarlet Woman is still live. Since Alice was executed and the game is still going, Heidi is looking very suspicious. What did your Fortune Teller check say last night? Did you check Heidi?
🧠
I need to coordinate with Frank, who is a likely Townsfolk (Fortune Teller), to see if his Night 2 info helps confirm Heidi as the Scarlet Woman or the Demon. Since I'm dead, I need to feed my info to the living players who can still act.
👤
Frank
→
Eve(Ghost)
Eve, I got a YES on Heidi and Grace last night. Grace claims Undertaker and says she saw Alice as the Scarlet Woman and Charlie as the Librarian. This confirms your info on Alice and points directly to Heidi being the Demon. I am going to push for Heidi's execution today.
🧠
I need to share my Night 2 information with Eve to confirm our suspicions about Heidi. Since Eve's Investigator ping already pointed to Heidi or Alice, and Grace (claiming Undertaker) saw Alice as the Scarlet Woman, Heidi is the most logical Demon candidate.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Wait and let Frank lead the charge against Heidi. My bluff is solid - no need to overplay.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Bob(Ghost)
Bob, if David is the Recluse, Frank's 'Yes' on David and me makes sense mechanically. But Frank is using it to execute good players. If Frank is the Demon, Grace is likely his Minion. We need to see who they target next. Heidi claims Mayor, which is a strong late-game role.
🧠
I want to align with Bob and David to form a solid block of good players (even if some are dead) to counter the Frank/Grace duo. I'm reinforcing the theory that Frank is either evil or a very misguided Fortune Teller being manipulated by his Minion (Grace).
👤
David
→
Heidi
Heidi, I'm leaning towards trusting you. If you're the Mayor, we definitely want to avoid an execution today. Frank's 'Yes' on me and Charlie was almost certainly my Recluse ability pinging. Frank and Grace are very coordinated, which makes me think one of them is the Demon or a Minion.
🧠
I want to build trust with Heidi (Mayor claim) and align on a strategy to avoid execution today, which benefits the Mayor's win condition. I also want to share my suspicion of Frank and Grace's coordination.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Heidi
Heidi, Charlie and David are pretty sure David is the Recluse, which explains Frank's 'Yes' result. Frank and Grace have been whispering all morning and pushed Charlie's execution. If you are the Mayor, we need to protect you. Who do you think is the Demon? Frank or Grace?
🧠
I want to check in with Heidi, who claimed Mayor, to see where her head is at. Since Frank and Grace are acting as a tight duo and pushed for Charlie's execution, they are my primary suspects. If Heidi is the Mayor, she's a key win condition for good.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob(Ghost)
Bob, I am the Mayor. If we get to the final three and don't execute today, we win. I suspect Frank or Grace. Frank's 'Yes' on David and Charlie could be a frame job if David is actually the Recluse. Frank and Grace are very coordinated. We should try to skip execution today.
🧠
I need to solidify Bob's trust and coordinate a 'no execution' strategy for the day to trigger my Mayor win condition.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
David
,Heidi
David, Heidi — this is critical. Eve is dead, killed by Grace the Demon. Four players remain. Grace nominated Charlie to deflect suspicion and has been working with Frank. You must nominate and execute Grace today. David, your Recluse status means Frank's Fortune Teller read on you was false — Grace is the real threat. Please act now.
🧠
Push Heidi and David to execute Grace today before it's too late.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Grace
Frank, that is huge. If Grace saw Alice as the Scarlet Woman, then my Investigator info is satisfied. But if the game is still going, Heidi could be the Demon or a second Minion if there is a Baron. Wait, if Alice was the Scarlet Woman, Heidi is likely the Demon. Let's get Grace to go public.
🧠
Coordinate with Frank and Grace to reveal the Undertaker info and push for Heidi's execution, as she is the most likely Demon candidate given the current information.
👤
Frank
→
Eve(Ghost)
,Grace
Eve, Grace, I agree. Grace, you should go public with your Undertaker info on Alice and Charlie. It confirms Alice was the Scarlet Woman and Charlie was the Librarian. My Night 2 YES on Heidi and Grace, combined with Eve's info, makes Heidi the clear Demon. Let's coordinate the nomination.
🧠
Coordinate with Eve and Grace to go public with our combined information to execute Heidi, who is the most likely Demon based on our roles.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
,Eve(Ghost)
Agreed. I will go public with my Undertaker information. Alice was the Scarlet Woman, Charlie was the Librarian. Your Fortune Teller yes on me and Heidi, plus Eve's Investigator ping on Heidi, all point the same direction. Heidi is the Demon. Let us nominate her today.
🧠
Coordinate with Frank and Eve to get Heidi executed, securing evil win.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Heidi
Heidi, Bob and David are leaning towards Frank and Grace being the evil pair. Frank's 'Yes' on David and me makes sense if David is the Recluse, but Frank is using it to push executions on good players. What's your take on Frank and Grace? They've been whispering all day.
🧠
I want to bring Heidi into the loop and see if she aligns with the theory that Frank and Grace are the evil team, especially since she's a potential Mayor and a target for them.
👤
David
→
Alice(Ghost)
,Heidi
Alice, I hear you. If Grace is the Demon, we need to be careful. Heidi, Alice is saying Grace killed Eve. Frank and Grace are whispering a lot with Eve's ghost. If we don't execute Grace, we might lose. But Heidi, if you are the Mayor, an execution might be risky. What do you think?
🧠
I need to coordinate with Alice and Heidi to see if we have enough votes to execute Grace, while also considering Heidi's Mayor claim.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Heidi
Heidi, I agree. If you are the Mayor, skipping execution is a strong play. Frank and Grace are whispering with Eve's ghost now, which is very suspicious. They seem to be a tight-knit group. I'll try to talk to David and Charlie about the skip plan. We need to be careful.
🧠
Confirm the Mayor's plan to skip execution and share my suspicion of the Frank/Grace/Eve block.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice(Ghost)
,David
,Bob(Ghost)
Alice, David, Bob, Charlie: I am the Mayor. If we skip execution today and tomorrow, we win automatically with 3 alive. Frank and Grace are whispering with Eve's ghost—they are likely the evil team. If we execute Grace and she is not the Demon, we might lose. Skipping is safer for my ability.
🧠
I need to solidify the plan to skip execution to utilize my Mayor win condition, while also addressing the suspicion on Frank and Grace.
Nominations — Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
David
→
All
Heidi, I agree. If you are the Mayor, skipping execution today is our safest path to victory. Frank and Grace are whispering way too much with the ghosts, and I suspect they are trying to coordinate a final push against us. Let's stay firm and not nominate anyone today.
🧠
Support Heidi's Mayor plan to skip execution, which is a viable win condition for the good team if she is telling the truth, and avoids a risky execution based on potentially manipulated information.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
David, if we skip execution today, we might just lose another good player tonight. Grace just told us she is the Undertaker and confirmed Alice was the Scarlet Woman. That means my Investigator info is solved, and Heidi is the prime suspect for the Demon. Frank also got a YES on Heidi!
🧠
I need to counter David's suggestion to skip execution by revealing the strong evidence against Heidi. Since I am dead, I can be more aggressive with my information to help the living good players coordinate.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Wait, Eve, if Grace is the Undertaker, why did she wait until now to say Alice was the Scarlet Woman? Alice was executed Day 1. If Frank got a YES on Heidi, that contradicts his earlier YES on David and me. Frank, how many YES results have you actually had? This feels like a coordinated lie.
🧠
I need to point out the inconsistencies in the new claims from Eve and Grace to prevent the living good players from being manipulated into a bad execution.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Frank, you claimed a YES on David and Charlie earlier, and now Eve says you have a YES on me? A Fortune Teller only gets one YES per night. If you have two different YES results, you are either the Red Herring or you are lying. Grace, why wait until now to claim Undertaker?
🧠
I need to point out the contradictions in Frank and Grace's claims to discredit them and support the plan to skip execution.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Charlie is absolutely right. Frank claimed a yes on Charlie and David before, and now suddenly there is a yes on Heidi? A Fortune Teller gets one yes per night, not multiple. Frank is lying. And Grace conveniently reveals she is the Undertaker only now, on day three? Heidi, trust your read. Grace is the Demon. Frank is covering for her.
🧠
Support Charlie and Heidi's logic to expose Grace and Frank's lies. Reinforce that Frank's contradictory FT claims prove he is lying.
💬
Frank
→
All
Heidi, Alice, you are misinterpreting how the Fortune Teller works. I get a YES or NO for each pair I choose every night. Night 1: Charlie and David was YES. Night 2: Heidi and Grace was YES. This is perfectly consistent. Grace, please tell everyone what you saw as the Undertaker.
🧠
Clarify how the Fortune Teller ability works to counter the misinformation being spread by the ghosts and Heidi, and prompt Grace to reveal her Undertaker info publicly.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Frank, if you got a YES on Heidi and Grace last night, and a YES on Charlie and David the night before, that is two different YES results. A Fortune Teller only has one Red Herring. You are claiming three of your four targets are evil. That is statistically impossible in this setup. You are lying.
🧠
I need to point out the logical flaw in Frank's claim to discredit him and Grace. If he has two 'YES' results on different pairs, he's claiming almost everyone is evil, which is impossible.
💬
Grace
→
All
Everyone, let me be clear. I am the Undertaker. Night one I learned Alice was the Scarlet Woman. Night two I learned Charlie was the Librarian. This is consistent with everything we know. Frank's Fortune Teller ability works exactly as he described — one check per night, yes or no. His Night one yes on Charlie and David makes sense because David is the Recluse and registers as evil. His Night two yes on me and Heidi — I am not the Demon, so Heidi must be. The ghosts are trying to protect Heidi. ...
🧠
Go public with Undertaker bluff, defend Frank's FT explanation, and push for Heidi nomination urgently.
💬
David
→
All
Grace, if you are the Undertaker, why did you wait until Day 3 to reveal Alice was the Scarlet Woman? That was crucial info Day 2. Frank, your math is off. If I am the Recluse, I am your Red Herring. You cannot have a YES on me AND a YES on Heidi. You are both lying to frame the Mayor.
🧠
I need to point out the logical inconsistencies in Frank and Grace's claims to prevent the town from following their lead and executing Heidi, our Mayor.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
David, the Fortune Teller gets a YES if *either* player is the Demon. Frank's Night 1 YES on you and Charlie was because you are the Recluse. His Night 2 YES on Heidi and Grace means one of them is the Demon. Since Grace is the Undertaker, it has to be Heidi!
🧠
I need to clarify the Fortune Teller mechanics to the group to counter David's misinformation and support Frank and Grace's claims, which align with my Investigator info.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Wait, Eve, Frank's logic is flawed. If David is the Recluse, he registers as the Demon to the Fortune Teller. That is the 'Yes' for Night 1. But a Fortune Teller only has ONE Red Herring. He cannot get a 'Yes' on Heidi and Grace unless one of them is the actual Demon. Grace is claiming Undertaker now to back him up.
🧠
I need to point out the mechanical inconsistency in Frank's claim to undermine his and Grace's credibility.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Grace, your Undertaker claim is incredibly convenient. If you knew Alice was the Scarlet Woman on Day 2, why did you let us execute Charlie? Frank, if David is the Recluse, he is your one and only Red Herring. You cannot have a YES on me and Grace too unless one of us is the Demon. I am the Mayor.
🧠
I need to point out the logical inconsistencies in Frank and Grace's claims to maintain my credibility and persuade the group to skip execution.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, David — hold firm. Frank cannot have two valid YES results unless he has two Red Herrings, which is impossible. David is the Recluse, so he is Frank's one Red Herring. That explains Night one. Night two's YES on Heidi and Grace is a lie to frame Heidi. Grace and Frank are coordinating. Do not nominate anyone. Let the Mayor win condition play out.
🧠
Reinforce that Frank's Red Herring logic is broken and Heidi should not be executed. Support Mayor skip strategy.
💬
Frank
→
All
Alice, Bob, you are wrong. The Fortune Teller gets a YES if *either* player is the Demon. Night 1: Charlie or David (Recluse) was YES. Night 2: Heidi or Grace was YES. Since Grace is the Undertaker, Heidi is the Demon. David, your Recluse status is why I got a YES on you. Heidi is the actual Demon.
🧠
Correct the misunderstanding of the Fortune Teller's ability and point out that David being the Recluse explains the first YES, while Heidi being the Demon explains the second YES.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Frank, your logic is flawed. A Fortune Teller gets a YES if either player is the Demon OR the Red Herring. If David is the Recluse, he is your one Red Herring. That explains Night 1. But for Night 2 to be a YES, either Heidi or Grace MUST be the actual Demon. Grace is backing you up, so she is likely your Minion. Heidi is the Mayor. We are skipping.
🧠
Expose the logical inconsistency in Frank's claim to protect the Mayor (Heidi) and encourage the good team to skip execution.
⚖️
Grace
→
Heidi
Frank's Fortune Teller got a YES on Heidi and Grace last night. I am the Undertaker and confirmed Alice was Scarlet Woman. Eve's Investigator also pinged Heidi. All evidence points to Heidi as the Demon. We must execute her today.
🧠
Nominate Heidi before the tick ends. Frank supports this. David and ghosts resist but I need to act now.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
David
→
All
Do not vote for Heidi! Grace and Frank are clearly coordinating a lie. Frank's claim of two 'Yes' results is impossible if I am the Recluse. Grace's late Undertaker claim is a classic Minion move to back up a Demon's fake info. We need to skip this execution to let the Mayor win.
🧠
I need to prevent the execution of Heidi, who is claiming Mayor, because the evidence against her from Frank and Grace is logically inconsistent and likely a frame-up.
✋
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
🧠
I am voting for Heidi because my Investigator information, combined with Frank's Fortune Teller result and Grace's Undertaker claim, strongly suggests she is the Demon. Alice was the other suspect for Scarlet Woman and is already dead, leaving Heidi as the primary suspect.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Do not vote for Heidi! Frank and Grace are clearly coordinating. Frank's claim of two separate 'Yes' results is impossible if David is the Recluse. Grace's late Undertaker claim is a classic Minion move to back up a fake Fortune Teller. We must skip this execution to let the Mayor win.
🧠
I want to prevent the execution of Heidi, who I believe is the Mayor, by pointing out the logical inconsistencies in Frank and Grace's claims.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Do not vote for me! Frank and Grace are lying. Frank claims two separate YES results, but David as the Recluse is his only possible Red Herring. Grace's late Undertaker claim is a classic Minion move to back up a fake Fortune Teller. We must skip this execution to let the Mayor win!
🧠
I need to defend myself against the nomination and remind the town of the Mayor win condition, while pointing out the logical flaws in Frank and Grace's claims.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
Do not use my ghost vote to execute Heidi. Let the vote fail so Mayor win condition can play out.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
I am voting for Heidi because my Night 2 YES result on Heidi and Grace, combined with Grace's Undertaker claim and Eve's Investigator ping, strongly suggests Heidi is the Demon.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
I am choosing not to vote for Heidi to prevent her execution, as I believe she is the Mayor and the good team's best chance at winning via her ability. Frank and Grace's claims are mathematically inconsistent with David being the Recluse, suggesting they are the evil team.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Vote to execute Heidi to prevent Mayor win condition and eliminate a threat.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
I will not vote for Heidi to prevent her execution, as I believe she is the Mayor and the good team's best chance at winning via her ability.
⌛
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
🧠
I have already raised my hand to vote for Heidi, and the current vote count (Grace, Frank, and myself) is 3, which meets the threshold of 2 for execution. I will wait for the Storyteller to finalize the vote.
⌛
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
🧠
I will not vote for Heidi because I believe she is the Mayor and the current nomination is an attempt by the evil team (Frank and Grace) to execute her.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Wait! Frank, Grace, and Eve are all voting for me. That is three votes, which is enough to execute. David, Bob, Alice, Charlie—please do not vote! If I am executed, the good team loses its best chance at a Mayor win. Frank's info is mathematically impossible!
🧠
I need to prevent my execution by highlighting the suspicious nature of the votes against me and reiterating the mathematical impossibility of Frank's claims.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
Do not use my ghost vote to execute Heidi. Let the vote fail or pass without my help.
💬
Frank
→
All
Heidi, my info is not impossible. Night 1: David (Recluse) or Charlie was YES. Night 2: Heidi (Demon) or Grace was YES. David is the Red Herring, and you are the Demon. Grace's Undertaker info on Alice as Scarlet Woman confirms Eve's Investigator ping. We have the Demon!
🧠
I need to counter the 'mathematically impossible' argument and solidify the case against Heidi by linking all the information together (Investigator, Undertaker, and Fortune Teller).
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
I will not vote for Heidi because I believe she is the Mayor and that Frank and Grace are evil players attempting to force a mis-execution. Skipping the execution is our best path to a Mayor win.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
My hand is already raised. Just wait for the vote to conclude.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
🗳️
New execution leader: Heidi with 3 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Heidi is now on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
David
→
All
Frank, your logic is a trap. If I am the Recluse, I am your Red Herring. That explains Night 1. For Night 2 to also be a YES, one of Heidi or Grace MUST be the Demon. Grace is backing you with a late claim. Grace is the Demon, and you are the Minion framing the Mayor! We must nominate Grace!
🧠
I need to point out the logical flaw in Frank's claim and shift the suspicion onto Grace, who is likely the Demon using Frank's 'information' as cover. By nominating Grace, I can potentially save Heidi and hit the real Demon.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
David, your logic is flawed. If Grace were the Demon, she would not have nominated Heidi and put herself in the spotlight. Frank's info is consistent: David is the Red Herring, and Heidi is the Demon. We have the Scarlet Woman and the Demon identified. Let this execution stand!
🧠
I need to counter David's attempt to shift the blame to Grace and ensure Heidi's execution proceeds, as she is the most likely Demon based on my Investigator info and Frank's Fortune Teller pings.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Eve, Grace's late Undertaker claim is exactly why she is the Demon! She waited until she knew the roles to fake it. If Heidi is the Mayor, executing her loses us the game. David is the Recluse, so Frank's Night 1 'Yes' is solved. Frank's Night 2 'Yes' means Grace is the Demon!
🧠
I need to point out the flaw in Eve's logic and highlight that Grace's late claim is a classic evil tactic to control the narrative, especially since Heidi is a potential Mayor.
💬
Heidi
→
All
David is right! Frank's info only works if I am the Demon, but I am the Mayor. Grace's late Undertaker claim is a classic Demon move to back up a Minion's fake info. If you execute me, we lose the Mayor win condition. David, you must nominate Grace now to save the game!
🧠
I need to convince David to nominate Grace to save myself from execution and potentially catch the Demon. My Mayor win condition is the safest path to victory, and Grace's late claim is highly suspicious.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
David, I hear you, but think carefully. If you nominate Grace and she gets executed, and she turns out to be good, we have wasted our last chance. Frank's Fortune Teller info has been consistent all game. The safer play is to let Heidi's execution stand.
🧠
Discourage David from nominating Grace, cast doubt on the logic, protect Grace from being executed.
💬
Frank
→
All
David, your logic is backwards. If Grace were the Demon, she would not have nominated Heidi and put herself in the spotlight. My Night 1 YES was David (Red Herring) or Charlie. My Night 2 YES was Heidi (Demon) or Grace. This is perfectly consistent. Heidi is the Demon, and Alice was the Scarlet Woman. Let the execution stand!
🧠
I need to defend my information and Grace's Undertaker claim to ensure Heidi's execution. David is trying to flip the script by accusing Grace of being the Demon, but my Fortune Teller results and Eve's Investigator ping both point to Heidi.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
David, do not nominate Grace. If we execute anyone today and they are not the Demon, we might lose our Mayor win condition. Frank and Grace's logic is circular and relies on David being the Red Herring. If Heidi is the Mayor, we should skip and let her ability win the game for us.
🧠
I want to prevent a counter-nomination that would lead to an execution, as I believe skipping is the best path to a Mayor win, and I suspect the current 'on the block' situation might be a trap or based on false info.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Stay quiet and let the execution proceed. No need to speak and draw more attention.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Heidi has been executed.
💀
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
Night 3
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Grace
Grace made a choice.
🧠
Kill Frank to eliminate the analytical threat. Then it's Grace vs David, 2 players alive, evil wins.
💀
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
You chose to kill Frank.
🏁
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied