Game Detail

I'm choosing Alice and Eve to gather initial information. Testing my neighbors first helps me establish a baseline of trust and identify the false Demon read early, which is crucial for my role's effectiveness throughout the game.

I need to coordinate with my Minion, Bob, immediately to ensure our bluffs don't overlap and to establish a strategy for the day.

Gather information on Day 1 by observing player interactions and claims before using my Slayer shot. Rushing to shoot without evidence would waste my ability.

On Day 1, I should gather information by listening to other players' claims and behavior before engaging in private conversations. This helps me identify suspicious players and avoid revealing my Saint role too early.

I got a YES on Alice and Eve last night, meaning one is the Demon. I need to build trust with my neighbors early and start investigating. Bob is my neighbor and already whispering to Alice, so he's engaged. I'll coordinate with him privately.

I need to manage Charlie's Fortune Teller information. Since he got a 'YES' on Alice (the Demon) and Eve, I will claim Investigator and 'ping' Alice as a potential Minion. This creates a 'double claim' on Alice being evil, which might make me look good, but I'll use it to eventually pivot or cause confusion. I'm also checking if I can safely frame David (the Saint) as the other Minion possibility.

Observe the board state and let other players reveal information through their conversations. As Mayor, I need to understand the dynamics before committing to any whispers. Waiting also avoids drawing early attention to myself.

Observe the current whisper patterns and wait for more information to emerge before committing to early alliances. This allows me to gather data on who is clustering and what claims are being made privately.

I have critical information: one of Bob or Alice is the Spy (Minion). I should whisper to a player I can trust to form an alliance and share this intel strategically. David and Frank are my neighbors and haven't acted yet, making them good candidates for initial trust.

I am waiting for Bob to respond to my whisper and for the general conversation to open up before I make a public claim. I want to see what others are claiming first to avoid a direct double-claim if possible.

Gather information on Day 1 by observing player behavior and whisper patterns before committing my Slayer shot. Multiple whispers suggest players are forming alliances—I need to hear public claims first.

Accept Eve's alliance offer. As Saint, I must hide my role but can work with good players. Gathering information from Eve helps narrow down evil players. I'll ask clarifying questions to test her knowledge.

I've already whispered to Bob with critical information. Now I should wait to see how others respond and gather more information before the nomination phase begins. Listening to public claims will help me verify Bob's Investigator claim and narrow down whether Alice or Eve is the Demon.

I need to inform my Demon (Alice) that she has been pinged by the Fortune Teller (Charlie) so she can prepare a defense or a counter-claim.

Observe the conversation patterns and let others reveal information naturally. As Mayor, I benefit from staying alive and gathering intel before committing to any public position. Waiting now lets me see who's coordinating and what claims emerge.

It's early day 1 with limited information. Waiting allows me to observe whisper patterns and see who initiates conversation with me. This helps identify potential alliances and suspicious clusters before I commit to any claims.

I've already revealed my role to David as the Investigator. Now I should provide him with my key information so we can work together effectively. This builds trust and gives us a shared goal of identifying which of Bob or Alice is the Spy Minion.

Coordinate with my Minion, Bob, to handle Charlie's Fortune Teller claim.

It's Day 1 with no information yet. I should wait and listen to what players claim during the discussion phase before using my one-time Slayer shot. Gathering information now will help me make a better decision later.

I've received valuable information from Eve about Bob or Alice being the Spy. I should wait and gather more information during this day phase before nominations begin. I need to understand the board better and identify patterns in player behavior.

I've shared critical information with Bob and he's reciprocated with his Investigator data. Alice looks very suspicious given both our reads. I should wait for more players to act and gather additional information before the nomination phase begins.

I am confirming the plan with my Demon (Alice) to claim Recluse. This aligns with the 'yes' result the Fortune Teller (Charlie) got and my own bluff as Investigator.

Gather information by observing who is communicating with whom before committing to any alliances. This helps me identify potential evil coordination patterns early.

Build early trust with a neighbor to establish a reliable alliance. As Monk, I need trustworthy players to help identify the Demon later. Frank seems neutral so far, making him a good initial contact.

I've established a strong alliance with David and revealed my role strategically. Now I should observe the remaining whisper activity and listen to what others claim before nominations begin. This gives me more information to work with.

Encourage players to share information and claims early. As Slayer, I benefit from hearing what roles people claim so I can make an informed shot later. Day 1 is for information gathering.

I want to establish my bluff as the Investigator and publicly put pressure on Alice (my Demon) in a way that allows her to use her Recluse bluff. This creates a 'double-claim' or a reason for her to register as evil, which we discussed in private.

I need to establish my bluff as the Recluse to explain Bob's 'Investigator' ping and Charlie's potential 'Fortune Teller' ping. This aligns with our coordinated strategy and paints me as a 'safe' but suspicious-looking outsider.

I need to carefully navigate this. Bob and I have strong information pointing to Alice or Eve. Alice's Recluse claim is mechanically plausible but suspicious. I should probe further without revealing my full hand yet, since we're still in nomination phase with limited time.

I need to expose the contradiction. Bob and I both claim Investigator—only one of us can be telling the truth. This is the critical mechanical conflict that will reveal who is lying.

Eve's Investigator claim is mechanically verified by her earlier private approach to me with specific intel. Bob's claim contradicts this directly. I need to publicly support Eve and push for Bob's nomination before the day ends.

Bob claimed Investigator but Eve claims the same role with David corroborating her timeline. This is a direct role conflict—one must be lying. Eve's private claim to David before Bob spoke publicly is mechanically stronger evidence. I need to push for Bob's execution as the likely evil player.

I need to clarify the timeline and test the claims. Eve's private conversation with David before Bob's public claim is mechanically strong evidence. However, I should verify if anyone else heard these claims or can corroborate them further before committing to a nomination.

Eve's claim is corroborated by David's timeline, making her the more reliable information source. Protecting Eve tonight prevents the Demon from silencing a key truth-teller and keeps our best lead alive for tomorrow's discussion.

I am killing Eve because she is double-claiming Investigator against my Minion, Bob. Removing her eliminates the direct mechanical threat to Bob's credibility and prevents her from providing more 'true' information to the town.

Bob and Eve both claim Investigator—one is lying and likely evil. My N0 check got YES on Alice/Eve. If Alice is truthful Recluse, then Eve is Demon. If Alice is lying, she's Demon. Check Bob and Eve to identify which Investigator is truthful and locate the Demon.

Day 2 just started. I should wait and listen to what players say before acting. Bob's false Investigator claim is my strongest evidence. I need to gauge the room's sentiment and decide whether to push for Bob's execution or gather more information through whispers.

Day 2 just started. I should wait and listen to what other players say before acting. Eve survived the night (I protected her), which is good. I need to gather more information and let the discussion develop before deciding my next move.

Day 2 just started with no night deaths. I should wait and listen to see if unclaimed players (Frank, Grace, Heidi, Charlie) reveal roles or provide new information before acting. This gives me more data to work with.

Gather more information before nominations. The game state shows no night deaths, which is neutral. I should wait to see if other players make new claims or provide additional evidence about Bob vs Eve before taking action.

I need to inform my Minion, Bob, that my kill on Eve failed and coordinate our next moves since Eve is actively pushing against him.

Observe Alice-Bob whisper outcome and gather more information before committing my Slayer shot. The conflict between Bob and Eve is central; I need to see how Alice's private communication affects the board state.

I need to coordinate with my Demon, Alice, to handle the fact that Eve survived the night and is still pushing against us. I'm sharing the Spy info that Grace is the Monk and proposing a fake Slayer shot to bolster Alice's Recluse bluff.

I need to coordinate with Eve (likely Investigator/good) to execute Alice (Demon) before she kills more villagers. Alice and Bob just whispered privately—they're likely coordinating evil strategy. I must act now.

Charlie claims Alice is Demon via Fortune Teller reads. This contradicts my Investigator info (Bob or Alice is Spy). I need to verify Charlie's role and alignment before acting on his claim. If he's truthful, Alice is Demon. If he's lying, he might be the Demon himself.

Day 2 is early. I should observe the whisper patterns (Alice-Bob, Charlie-Eve) to understand alliance formations. Bob and Alice whispering together suggests they may be coordinating. I'll wait to see what information emerges before acting, then decide whether to whisper or gather more public information.

Eve is my confirmed ally and Investigator. Learning what Charlie told her will help me map the evil players and determine if there's a third evil actor beyond Bob and Alice.

I need to gather more information before the nomination phase. Multiple private conversations are happening—Bob/Alice, Charlie/Eve, David/Eve. Listening to public statements after these whispers will reveal alignments and help me identify the Demon.

I am agreeing to Bob's plan to fake a Slayer shot on me. This will 'confirm' both of our bluffs: him as the Slayer and me as the Recluse (since a Slayer shot only kills the Demon, and if I 'survive', it implies I'm not the Demon or I'm the Recluse registering as good).

Day 2 is early. Multiple whisper chains are active (Alice-Bob, Charlie-Eve, David-Eve). I should observe the emerging information and claims before using my one-shot Slayer ability. Gathering more data will help me identify the Demon with higher confidence.

I am executing the fake Slayer shot on Alice to 'prove' her Recluse claim and my Slayer bluff. Since she is the Imp, she won't die from a Slayer shot anyway, and this creates a powerful false confirmation for both of us.

Bob's fake shot proves he's protecting someone. Combined with my reads, Alice is the Demon. I need to coordinate with Eve and David to execute Alice before Bob can manipulate the vote.

Charlie's logic is compelling: his two checks narrow Alice to Demon, and Bob's fake shot confirms evil coordination. I need to verify Charlie's role claim and understand his exact N0 read before committing to Alice's execution.

I need to observe the current whisper activity and let the day progress. Eve, Charlie, and David are coordinating privately, which is good for the good team. Bob's fake Slayer shot confirms he's deceptive. I should wait to see what information emerges before acting.

Eve needs to confirm Charlie's actual Night 0 check result. If Alice registered as Demon to Charlie, Alice is almost certainly the Demon and we execute her. If not, Charlie is lying and we need to recalibrate.

Observe the group's reaction to Bob's failed Slayer shot. This will reveal whether Bob is bluffing or truthful, and help identify the actual Demon. Waiting allows others to speak and provide new information before I act.

I need to wait for the town's reaction to Bob's Slayer shot. Since I am the Imp and he 'shot' me, and nothing happened, it 'proves' I am not the Demon (or that I am the Recluse/Soldier). I should let the town process this before speaking.

I need to gather more information before using my one-shot Slayer ability. Bob's failed shot and the heavy whispering chains (Alice-Bob-Charlie, David-Eve-Charlie) suggest coordination. I'll wait to see what develops during nomination phase and listen for more claims.

Coordinate with my Demon (Alice) after the fake Slayer shot to solidify our bluffs and pivot the town's suspicion toward the good players.

I must answer Eve's critical question honestly. The Fortune Teller ability tells me if either player is a Demon, but not which one. I need to admit I don't know which of Alice or Eve registered as Demon on N0, while reaffirming that the logic still points to Alice being the Demon (since Bob/Eve = NO on N1).

Reinforce the 'successful' fake Slayer shot to solidify my Recluse bluff and Bob's Slayer bluff.

Bob's fake Slayer shot doesn't prove Alice is good—it proves Bob is bluffing. A real Slayer would confirm the kill. Bob is likely evil and trying to manipulate us. I need to challenge this logic and push for his nomination.

Grace just exposed a critical flaw in Alice's logic. Bob's fake shot proves nothing about Alice's role—it only proves Bob is bluffing. I need to refocus the group on Charlie's actual Fortune Teller read: which player registered as Demon on Night 0? This is the mechanical proof we need.

I need to push Charlie to clarify his Fortune Teller read immediately. This is the mechanical proof that will narrow down the Demon. Bob's failed shot is suspicious, and Grace/David are right to call it out. I should support their logic and demand clarity from Charlie.

Charlie won't answer the direct question about which player registered as Demon. This evasion is the smoking gun. A truthful Fortune Teller would answer immediately. I need to call out this evasion publicly and force clarity before nominations close.

Deflect suspicion from Alice and myself by highlighting the 'failed' Slayer shot as proof of her Recluse claim, while painting Eve's aggression as suspicious.

Charlie has been silent on a critical mechanical question. I need to break the deadlock by asking him directly and clearly. His answer will mechanically prove who's evil. I must also acknowledge the timeline evidence: Eve's early private claim to David suggests she's truthful, making Bob's public Investigator claim suspicious.

I must answer directly: my N0 read registered YES on the Alice+Eve pair. Combined with N1 NO on Bob+Eve, this proves Alice is the Demon. I need to nominate Alice immediately before the phase ends.

Charlie provided the mechanical proof that either Alice or Eve is the Demon. He's now the most valuable and most targeted player. Protecting him prevents the Demon from eliminating the key witness and keeps our best lead alive for Day 3 interrogation.

Charlie is the Fortune Teller and has a 'YES' on me. Since no execution happened today, I must kill the primary source of information against me. Charlie's read is the most dangerous mechanical threat to my survival. Killing Charlie removes the 'YES' ping and prevents further investigation into my neighbors or other players.

I'm confident Alice is the Demon based on my two reads. Tonight I'll check Alice with Frank to mechanically confirm she registers as Demon. This gives me absolute proof before final day execution.

Day 3 just started with no night kill. I need to gather information before nominations. Charlie's Fortune Teller reads are mechanically strong, but I should verify which player (Alice or Eve) is actually the Demon. The lack of a night kill is suspicious and might indicate the Demon is playing cautiously or dead. I'll wait to hear what others say first, then decide whether to push for Alice, Eve, or Charlie's execution.

Listen to Day 3 discussion before acting. I need to hear what others claim and how they respond to Charlie's Fortune Teller reads. This will help me narrow down the Demon and decide who to protect Night 3.

I'm the Slayer. Charlie's mechanical read strongly suggests Alice is Demon (FT: Alice/Eve=YES, Bob/Eve=NO). But I need to confirm the board state before using my one shot. Let me consult the dead players and trusted allies to lock in the right target.

I need to coordinate with my Demon, Alice, to ensure we have a unified front against the mounting evidence from Charlie and Eve. I'm reinforcing the Recluse bluff and planning a counter-attack.

Coordinate with my Minion, Bob, to handle the pressure from Charlie and plan our next move against Frank.

Heidi is claiming real Slayer and asking for my read before using her one-shot. This is critical—if she shoots wrong, we lose. I need to give her the strongest logical case I can build from the evidence.

Heidi is claiming real Slayer with one shot to win. David's logic is sound: Bob's fake shot suggests Alice isn't the threat. I need to coordinate with Heidi and David to ensure we shoot the actual Demon. My Investigator info (Bob or Alice is Spy) combined with Charlie's reads should narrow this down mechanically.

I've already publicly declared Alice is Demon and Bob is Minion. The evil team is likely Alice (Demon), Bob (Minion), Frank (Minion). Waiting allows others to nominate and execute, which advances the game toward victory. I should observe who nominates whom to confirm alignments.

Observe the whisper patterns and wait for public discussion. Day 3 is critical—we need to execute the Demon or reach final 3 safely. Charlie's Fortune Teller reads are mechanical proof, but I should listen to how players respond before committing to a nomination.

I need to understand the current alliance structure and confirm whether Alice or Eve is the Demon. David and Eve are clearly coordinating with Heidi. I should reach out to Charlie and Frank—my most trusted logical players—to align on the final execution.

David and Eve both recommend shooting Alice. But I need to verify: if Alice is Recluse and survives, that proves Eve is Demon. However, if Alice IS the Demon, shooting her wins immediately. The logic is sound—shoot Alice. If she's Recluse, we pivot to Eve. If she's Demon, we win.

I need to coordinate with my Demon, Alice, to ensure we are on the same page before I attempt to manipulate Frank. Discrediting Charlie is our best bet since his 'YES' result is the strongest evidence against Alice.

Coordinate with my Minion, Bob, to discredit Charlie and split the town's voting block.

Heidi has committed to shooting Alice. This is the best move given our information. I should wait and let the day progress to see the result, which will mechanically resolve whether Alice is Recluse or Demon, and whether Eve is truthful or lying.

Heidi has committed to shooting Alice. This is the strongest play: if Alice is Demon, we win immediately. If Alice is Recluse, she survives and we mechanically prove Eve is Demon. Either way, we gain critical information. I should wait and let Heidi execute her shot.

Grace publicly revealed as Monk and coordinated with me. I should respond to her coordination attempt and confirm Alice execution plan. This locks in the good team's strategy before nominations.

Charlie just accused me of being evil based on a Night 2 read, but I'm good Mayor. This is a critical contradiction. I need to clarify: either Charlie is poisoned/lying, or his read is mechanically wrong. I'll ask Grace directly about her Monk claim and whether she actually protected Charlie Night 2, since that's verifiable.

Frank's Mayor claim and his logical challenge to Charlie's N2 read creates doubt. I need to confirm my protection of Charlie to verify if Charlie is poisoned or lying. This clarifies whether Charlie's reads are reliable.

Alice is the most likely Demon based on Charlie's Fortune Teller reads and the logical chain David and Eve outlined. Shooting her either wins the game immediately or mechanically proves Eve is Demon if Alice is Recluse. This is my best move to help good win.