Game Detail

I need to start gathering mechanical information on Night 0. Checking Alice and Bob gives me a baseline data point to help narrow down the Demon or identify the red herring as the game develops.

Start building trust and gathering information early by initiating a private conversation with another player.

I want to start building a trusted alliance to share my Fortune Teller information with. I will probe Frank first before revealing my exact role to see if he is receptive and to gauge his response.

I need to build trust with Eve while revealing nothing useful. I'll pretend to be a cautious Townsfolk and try to get her to reveal her role or info first. This also buys time until I can coordinate with Bob.

I need to learn what David told Alice before nominations start. If David shared Night 0 info, it could help us find a trustworthy starting point or identify a liar.

Share my Librarian information with trusted players to help identify who might have false Townsfolk information and to build alliances before nominations begin.

Share my Washerwoman information with Grace and Charlie since Grace already opened up as Librarian. Comparing our starting info will help establish trust and cross-reference claims before nominations begin.

I need to privately coordinate with Frank, my Minion, to share bluffs and establish our strategy before the good team starts forming information networks. Frank has already talked to Eve, so I need to know what he's been saying.

I should confirm to Alice and Grace that I am the Mayor. This validates Alice's Washerwoman claim if she is good, lets us narrow down the Drunk identity, and builds a trust circle. Even if one is evil, the info exchange advances our deduction.

Gather information from Bob to understand Frank's perspective and build a broader network beyond Alice's circle.

I want to confide in my neighbor Frank and share my Fortune Teller result so we can work together to identify the Demon while building trust.

I need to update Bob about Eve's claim and coordinate bluffs. I'll claim Slayer - a once-per-game role that lets me fake a shot later to cause chaos. I should also discuss how to handle Eve's Fortune Teller claim since it didn't ping Bob as Demon (red herring or she's lying).

Gather information from Grace about her conversation with Alice and Charlie, particularly about any claimed information roles from Night 0.

I want to answer Heidi's question and build trust by sharing how Alice's and Charlie's claims connect to my Librarian information. I also want to see what Heidi knows or claims.

Respond to Heidi's question about David and probe for her information, while keeping my actual role details close to my chest until I verify who is trustworthy.

David saw me talking to Frank and is curious. I'll claim Chef and give the true number (1 pair), which builds credibility since it matches reality. This also lets me learn David's role in return.

I need to verify Bob's claim since he's central to both Alice's and Grace's information. If he's the Drunk, he won't know it and might claim a Townsfolk role falsely. If he's not the Drunk, his claim should be consistent with the role distribution.

I need to gather more information before nominations. Alice has been talking to many people, so she may have additional claims or contradictions that help me evaluate Bob's Chef info.

I need a second trusted contact in case Frank is evil or compromised. Telling David my role and Night 0 result ensures my information survives if something happens to me.

Coordinate with Bob on bluff strategy. Also discuss whether we should frame someone as evil to throw Eve off and who our execution target should be. Also need to know what Bob told David.

Verify Grace's information chain by checking with Charlie directly before nominations start. Cross-referencing claims helps identify contradictions.

I want to find out what Bob is claiming to other players. If Bob is the Drunk, any role he claims is false, which would help identify misinformation in the village.

Share my Washerwoman info with David and point out that Bob being the Drunk would make the current claims consistent. I want to build trust with David and collaboratively figure out if Bob's Chef claim is reliable before nominations.

Charlie says he has info involving me. I need to respond to avoid suspicion and figure out what role he has. I'll maintain my Chef claim consistently.

I need to confirm my Mayor claim to Heidi and learn what she knows before nominations start. Gathering cross-references from multiple players will help me figure out who is telling the truth.

Raise the mechanical issue about outsider count to test reactions, pressure quiet players to claim, and avoid revealing my Saint role too early while still advancing the discussion.

Heidi just named me as possibly the Drunk. I should lean into this confusion to appear good and uncertain, while subtly supporting Frank and not drawing attention to the evil team.

Claiming Recluse to establish the Outsider count, which is critical for determining whether Baron is in play and whether Grace's Librarian info can be trusted. This helps the town narrow down whether Bob is a real Chef or a Drunk.

Publicly claim my Fortune Teller role and share my Night 0 result to establish credibility, help the group narrow demon suspects, and respond to Heidi's call for claims before nominations close.

Publicly confirm my Mayor role since Alice already leaked it, highlight the outsider-count contradiction centered on David's unverified Recluse claim, and pressure the silent Frank before we go to Night.

I need to highlight the outsider count contradiction to the group and pressure Frank and Heidi to claim before night falls, since their silence is creating a dangerous information gap.

I need to claim Slayer as planned. I'll express skepticism about the Outsider math to sow confusion and buy time. I should sound like a good player trying to piece things together, not like someone hiding.

David's Recluse claim is the most disruptive and mathematically suspicious element. If Bob is Drunk and David is Recluse, we need a third outsider for Baron that no one claims. Nominating him tests whether he is genuine or creating chaos as evil.

Defend myself by pointing out Alice is assuming Bob is Drunk and I'm Recluse simultaneously, but my claim fits the base setup if Bob is the real Chef. Stop the town from executing me on bad logic.

Claim Saint to correct the outsider math, protect David from a potentially wrong execution, and ensure the town knows executing me means instant loss. This information is critical before votes are cast.

Voting for David helps me in every scenario. If he's Recluse, it confirms Baron and makes my Drunk cover story stronger. If he's evil, my team might lose him but I gain credibility. Either way, a good player likely dies.

Point out the mathematical flaw in the outsider count to show that David's Recluse claim is more likely a lie from an evil player than a genuine good claim. Persuade others to vote for David.

Voting to execute David because his Recluse claim is too convenient and pairs suspiciously with Heidi's Saint claim. In the cleanest world, there is no Baron and both are lying evil players. This is the safest execution since killing a claimed Saint would lose the game if true, while executing Recluse is low risk.

I must explain why David is likely evil and state my intent to vote. My Librarian info points to Bob or Eve as Drunk, making David and Heidi's outsider claims the most suspicious elements in the game.

Voting for David helps eliminate a good player regardless of his real role. Bob already raised his hand, and I should follow to avoid suspicion. This also builds trust with Eve and the others who are pushing for David.

David's Recluse claim is the lynchpin of a likely fake Baron scenario. If he is lying, Heidi is almost certainly his evil partner. I nominated him and raising my hand secures the execution of a likely Demon before Night falls.

Break the outsider-count argument by showing my Recluse claim alone does not force Baron. Urge voters to reconsider executing a good player based on stacked assumptions about Grace and Heidi.

I must defend David and redirect suspicion to Eve and Frank, who fit the evil pair in the most consistent world where Grace is truthful. Executing David helps the evil team if that world is right. I also need to protect myself as Saint.

The vote is at 6 (well above 4 needed). David's execution benefits evil — he's either a good player or a lying Outsider. No need to speak and risk complicating things. Let the execution go through.

I publicly committed to voting for David, and the evidence strongly suggests David and Heidi are coordinating as the evil team. I must be consistent with my stated suspicion and help secure this execution.

I am keeping my vote on David because Heidi's Saint claim was timed perfectly to save him, which strongly suggests an evil pair. Even if David is good, the upside of hitting the Demon is worth the risk, and I want my reasoning on record.

I publicly committed to voting for David because his Recluse claim combined with Heidi's conveniently timed Saint claim looks like coordinated evil play. I need to be consistent and cast my vote.

The vote is 6 against David, well over the 4 threshold. He's going to die regardless. Speaking now risks drawing suspicion to myself or accidentally helping save him. Better to stay quiet and let the execution go through. David is not on my team, so his death helps us.

Keep pressure on David, highlight Heidi's suspicious timing as the strongest tell, and urge Bob to vote since he is the likely swing vote.

Point out that Heidi saving me is irrational if she were evil, which validates the Baron world and redirects suspicion toward Eve and Frank after my likely execution.

Defend my Saint claim, warn that executing me loses the game, and redirect suspicion back toward Eve and Frank before David dies and night falls.

Support the execution while appearing measured and thoughtful. Plant the idea that if David is good, Heidi might be Saint and executing her would lose - this makes me look good-aligned while actually potentially setting up a Saint execution win. Also subtly cast doubt on Eve and Frank's alliance for future misdirection.

Defend my whispering with Frank as standard FT play, reaffirm my N0 clear on Alice and Bob, and point to Heidi's suspicious timing as evidence that she and David are the evil pair.

The nomination phase is ending with David firmly on the block. There is no benefit to nominating someone else or interfering. Let the execution resolve and prepare for Day 2 information.

The nomination phase ends in one tick and David already has 6 votes. There is no time to nominate an alternative or change the outcome. I will wait and observe what happens tonight.

David is on the block with 6 votes and will be executed. This is almost certainly a good player dying, which helps evil. Speaking now would only draw more attention to myself, especially since Bob already noted Eve and I have been 'awfully close.' Best to stay quiet and let the execution proceed.

Reveal my Washerwoman info to establish credibility before night. Emphasize that David's execution is safe regardless, but Heidi's execution tomorrow would be dangerous if she is Saint. This frames the risk correctly and puts useful mechanical info into the group before night phase.

Kill Eve, the Fortune Teller. She's the biggest mechanical threat to me, and her death can be spun to frame Heidi in the Baron world. Frank (my Minion) can continue pushing the narrative after Eve is gone.

Coordinate with my Minion Frank. We need to align on his fake Slayer shot target and plan for today's execution. Eve's death gives us momentum.

I need to verify Bob's alignment and Chef claim since it anchors the outsider math. Eve's death changes things. I'll ask Bob what he and Frank discussed and how Eve dying affects his read.

I want to verify the Outsider count with Grace because her Librarian claim is central to determining if Baron is in play. If we have three Outsiders, we can narrow down the evil team significantly. I will avoid revealing my exact role for now to stay safe as Saint.

Inform trusted players that Grace's Librarian claim naming me as Drunk is false since I know I'm Fortune Teller. This undermines the Baron theory and points to Grace being wrong or evil.

I need to share my deduction about Grace with the two players I trust most. If Bob is real Chef, Grace is evil. If Grace is real Librarian, Bob is Drunk. Resolving this dichotomy is the key to finding the Demon before nominations.

Share my analysis of Eve's death and Frank's suspicious behavior with Grace and Heidi to coordinate on who to nominate today.

Coordinate with Bob on the fake Slayer shot. Eve's ghost info is dangerous - she says Grace is wrong about the Drunk, which undermines our Baron narrative. Need to decide target and narrative quickly.

I need to share my updated Librarian analysis with trusted players to determine if Bob being the Drunk clears Alice and Bob, and to highlight Frank as a remaining suspect.

Coordinate with Frank on the fake Slayer shot. Shooting Grace is optimal because it validates her false info that I'm the Drunk, giving me permanent cover. Also need to discuss how to handle Eve's ghost whisper which actually helps our narrative.

I need to get Alice and Grace, the two claimed Townsfolk info roles, to compare notes directly. Resolving whether Bob or Grace is lying will tell us if Baron is in play and narrow down the Demon significantly.

I want to cross-reference Alice's Washerwoman info with Grace's Librarian read to determine if Bob is the Drunk and whether we have a Baron. Talking to Alice also lets me gauge her suspicion of Frank, who is unverified and central to many whispers.

Share my FT confirmation with Alice and Charlie, strengthen Alice's trust in her own info, and point out that Grace's claim about me being Drunk is impossible, which breaks the Baron theory and makes Heidi look very suspicious.

Force Grace to address the direct contradiction between her Librarian claim and Bob's Chef read. Charlie needs to see the mechanical logic that Grace must be evil if Bob is real.

I want to consolidate good players around suspecting Frank, since he is unverified and was closely tied to Eve regardless of whether Eve was good or evil. This helps focus the nomination today.

Bob explicitly told me to fake Slayer shoot Grace. This clears her as not-Demon, which makes her Librarian info (Bob is Drunk) appear credible. This gives Bob perfect cover. The contradiction between Eve's ghost info and Grace's info will paralyze the town with confusion.

Defend myself against Alice's accusation by explaining why Bob being Drunk invalidates her Chef logic, and push suspicion toward Frank for wasting his Slayer shot on me.

Frank just fake-shot Grace. The ghost whispers are spreading. I should wait and observe how town reacts before committing to a narrative. Let Alice, Charlie, Grace, and Heidi sort through the mess. Over-talking might expose me.

I need to share my deduction that World A fits all current evidence cleanly, and coordinate with Alice and Bob to execute Grace today as the safest nomination that avoids losing to a potential Saint.

I need to speak with Charlie to understand his Mayor claim and whether he has coordinated with Alice, which will help me determine if we're in a Bob-is-Drunk world or if the Mayor claim is solid.

Share the Townsfolk count argument to rule out Baron, identify Grace as likely Minion due to failed Slayer shot, and urge Bob and Charlie to nominate Heidi as the Demon.

I need to coordinate with trusted players to nominate Heidi, who I believe is the Demon based on Bob's Chef info and Frank's Slayer shot clearing Grace.

Build consensus to nominate Frank. He is completely unverified, was Eve's constant whisper partner, and his Slayer shot on Grace proves nothing since evil players can fake it. We need to nominate him before he becomes 'confirmed' good in everyone's minds.

Alice wants to nominate Heidi as Demon. This is perfect for evil - if Heidi is truly Saint, we win. If not, we eliminate a good player. I'll reinforce Alice's logic and show solidarity as a fellow 'good' player.

Clarify my position to Alice and Charlie, correct my earlier omission about the Baron shrinking the Townsfolk pool, and push for Frank as the nomination target since executing him cannot lose the game immediately, unlike Heidi.

Frank is unverified, aggressively faked a Slayer shot on me without cause, and was Eve's closest whisper partner. With Eve dead confirming Bob as likely Drunk, the Demon pool is Charlie, Frank, or Heidi. We cannot nominate Heidi due to Saint risk, so Frank is the only safe and logical nomination today.

Defend myself by reinforcing Alice's logic that Grace-Heidi is the evil pair. Point out Grace is deflecting because she's protecting Heidi the Demon. Emphasize that my Slayer shot cleared Grace from being Demon, which narrows the Demon candidates.

Bob is almost certainly Drunk since Eve died as the probable real Fortune Teller. This invalidates the adjacent evil pair logic being used to frame me. Frank is the most suspicious unverified player due to his wasted Slayer shot and connection to Eve. I must vote for his execution.

I must prevent Frank's execution. He's my only Minion and losing him leaves me alone. I'll argue Frank is the real Slayer (from town's perspective) and executing him is bad regardless of which evil world is true. I'll also suggest the nomination itself is suspicious timing from Grace.

Frank's Slayer claim is almost certainly fake in a Baron game, and the math points to him as the Demon after David's death. I need to vote to execute him before the Demon kills again tonight.

Warn the living players that Grace and Heidi voting together to execute Frank is strong evidence they are evil and Frank is good. Discourage Alice, Bob, and Charlie from voting for Frank.

I need to prevent Frank's execution because the evidence points to Heidi as the Demon. I must ensure Bob and Charlie do not vote for Frank so we can nominate Heidi instead.

I need to stop the vote on Frank because the evidence strongly points to Heidi as the Demon and Grace as her Minion. Voting for Frank would eliminate our Slayer and hand the game to evil.

Frank is the most suspicious player due to his unverifiable Slayer claim, his close association with the dead Eve, and the coordinated defense by Alice and Charlie. Executing him either wins the game immediately if he is Demon or removes an evil player. My ghost vote secures the execution.

I need to cement the narrative that Grace and Heidi are the evil pair. Even if I'm executed, my 'Slayer shot' on Grace holds as evidence she isn't the Demon, making Heidi the prime suspect. If Heidi is truly the Saint, executing her next ends the game for good.

Point out Frank's logical contradiction to solidify the vote against him. A real Slayer who believed Heidi was Demon would have shot Heidi, not me. His shot on me proves he knows I'm not Demon and is faking his role.

Frank is dead with 3 votes already. I won't raise my hand to stay aligned with Alice/Charlie. I'll frame this as protecting the Slayer while subtly endorsing the Heidi-as-Demon theory. If Heidi gets executed next (she's Saint), evil wins instantly.

My hand is already raised for Frank's execution. Lowering it risks me being nominated and executed as the Saint next, which loses the game. Even if Frank is not the Demon, executing him prevents my immediate death and may win the game if he is evil. I will wait to let the vote pass.

Reinforce that Frank is the real Slayer, Grace and Heidi are the evil pair, and Heidi must be nominated next. Prevent any swayed votes on Frank and set up the next nomination.

Prevent votes on Frank and cement the narrative that Heidi is the Demon. If Frank is executed, the group must target Heidi next to win.

Reinforce to Alice and Bob that Grace and Heidi voting together confirms they are the evil pair. Set up the narrative for tomorrow: if Frank is executed, Heidi must be the next nomination. Discourage anyone from wavering.

Keep my ghost vote on Frank and challenge the assumption that his Slayer shot confirms him as good. Remind the table that evil fakes Slayer shots, Bob might be Drunk, and executing Heidi risks an instant loss if she is Saint.

Nominating Heidi serves both narratives: if she's the Demon, we execute her and win; if she's the Saint and gets executed, good loses. It also creates a competing nomination that could tie votes and save me from execution.

I need to stop Alice, Bob, or Charlie from voting for me. Pointing out that Bob being the Drunk invalidates the Chef read, that Frank's shot is unverified, and that executing a Saint is an instant loss might keep my vote count below four.

Heidi claims Saint. If she IS the Saint and gets executed, good loses instantly - that's an evil victory. I should vote for her execution to end the game now. My vote is consistent with my Slayer bluff and the narrative that Grace-Heidi are the evil pair.

Point out Bob could be the Drunk, invalidating the Chef read. Remind everyone that executing Heidi loses instantly if she is Saint. Try to prevent Alice, Bob, and Charlie from giving Heidi enough votes to surpass Frank.

Voting for Heidi saves Frank my Minion and could end the game if she's truly the Saint. My Chef claim already pointed at Grace-Heidi as the evil pair, so this vote is consistent with my established story.

Use my ghost vote to tie Heidi with Frank at 3 votes, preventing Frank's execution and keeping the claimed Slayer alive. I believe Heidi is the Demon and losing Frank today would be a major mistake for the good team.

My Washerwoman info supports Charlie as Mayor, making Bob's Chef read credible. The read points to Grace-Heidi. Frank's shot proved Grace is not Demon. Heidi must be Demon. Voting now executes her and likely wins the game.

Heidi already has four votes and will be executed. The no-Baron world is the only one that fits all role slots cleanly: Bob's Chef read points to Grace-Heidi, Frank's Slayer shot proved Grace is not Demon, and every other Townsfolk claim slots perfectly. Heidi must be the Demon. Adding my vote makes the execution definitive and shows the good team is united.

Point out that Eve's night death proves she is good, stacking with Grace's Librarian to prove Bob is Drunk, which collapses the mechanical case against Heidi and shows executing her risks an instant loss.

I need to prove Bob is the Drunk so his Chef info is fake, show Frank's shot is meaningless, and demonstrate that executing a claimed Saint with zero real evidence is a guaranteed loss if I am telling the truth.

Reinforce the narrative that Heidi is the Demon to keep the votes locked. If she's Saint we win, if she's Demon good wins - but I'm evil, so Saint execution is ideal. I stay consistent with my Slayer bluff.

I need to warn the group that executing Heidi carries an unacceptable risk of instant loss if she is the true Saint, and that the evidence against her depends on Bob being sober Chef and Frank being real Slayer, both of which are unproven. I must not vote for Heidi.

The vote is 5-3 against Heidi, and this is perfect for me. If she is truly the Saint, evil wins immediately upon her execution. If not, she is still a good player being eliminated. Speaking now could only disrupt this favorable outcome. Stay silent and let it happen.

Counter David's argument that Bob is Drunk and Frank is fake. Explain why Frank and Grace cannot be evil together, which forces Heidi as Demon.

Heidi has five votes and will be executed. I want to explain the key behavioral proof that cements this as the right call: Grace's willingness to nominate Frank proves he is not her Demon teammate, which means Heidi must be the Demon.

The mechanical evidence overwhelmingly supports the no-Baron world where Grace and Heidi are the adjacent evil pair, Frank is the real Slayer, and Heidi is the Demon. My vote is already cast with the majority. Waiting lets the execution proceed.

Point out the outsider count contradiction to undermine Bob's Chef claim and warn that executing Heidi risks instant loss if she is Saint. The mathematical impossibility of two outsiders in a standard game proves Baron is in play, making Bob the Drunk.

Highlight that Frank's Slayer shot on Grace instead of me is exactly what a fake Slayer would do, and that executing the claimed Saint is an instant loss if Bob is the Drunk.

Heidi's execution wins the game for evil if she's truly the Saint. I need to maintain my cover and not introduce any doubt. A brief, confident statement reinforces the town's decision without risking last-minute reconsideration.

Last tick before Heidi executes. Need to scream the asymmetric risk: if Heidi is Saint, good loses instantly. Bob is likely Drunk (Eve died, likely good), making Chef info fake. Frank's shot proves nothing.

Heidi's execution benefits evil in all scenarios. I need to reinforce the town's decision and ensure no one flips their vote. A calm, confident statement supports my Chef narrative.

Grace claims Bob is Drunk because I am good, but I am the Fortune Teller, not the Drunk. Her Librarian claim is fake. Heidi is the Demon and must be executed.

I need to tear down the last-minute Baron panic by showing it requires Eve to be the Drunk, which she is not. That leaves Bob's Chef read real, Grace and Heidi as the evil pair, and Heidi as the Demon. I must keep votes locked on Heidi.

Consolidate the no-Baron narrative by pointing out the Townsfolk count makes the Baron world impossible, reassuring any waverers that Heidi must be the Demon and execution is safe.

Point out Frank's logically inconsistent excuse for not shooting Heidi directly. A Slayer shot only kills the Demon and is completely safe to use on a Saint. This undermines Frank's credibility regardless of Heidi's true role and may help the team if the game continues.