Game Detail
Players
Alice (Soldier) Bob (Undertaker) Charlie (Drunk) David (Spy) Eve (Investigator) Frank (Imp) Grace (Monk) Heidi (Mayor)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 742,800 | 90,230 | $0.3662 |
| Evil | 302,150 | 22,907 | $0.2137 |
Event Transcript
๐ญ
The game has started.
๐
Storyteller
โ
David
You are the Minion. The Demon is Frank.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Frank
Minions are: David. Your safe bluffs are: Saint, Slayer, Washerwoman
๐
Storyteller
โ
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Investigator. Either David or Heidi is the Spy.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
๐ฏ
Charlie
Charlie made choices.
๐ง
Learn whether either Bob or Eve is the Demon to produce a strong early lead or identify a false positive to guide Day 1 investigations.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Charlie
You chose Bob and Eve. You receive the answer: YES.
๐
Storyteller
โ
David
Good evening David. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Soldier (good), Alive - Bob: Undertaker (good), Alive - Charlie: Drunk (good), Alive (Told they are Fortune Teller) - David: Spy (evil), Alive - Eve: Investigator (good), Alive - Frank: Imp (evil), Alive - Grace: Monk (good), Alive - Heidi: Mayor (good), Alive
Day 1
๐
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
๐ค
Bob
โ
Alice
,Charlie
Hi Alice and Charlie โ Iโm Bob. I plan to be active. No executions yet; letโs quietly share any roles, reads, or strong suspicions so we avoid wasting Day 1. Any early claims or red flags youโve noticed?
๐ง
Form a small trust group to share claims and coordinate so we do not waste Day1 lynch and can catch contradictions before nominations.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Frank
,Heidi
Hi, itโs Grace. Can we quietly compare reads/roles? I want to coordinate night protection on whoever is most talked-about tonight. Do you have any role info or suspicions?
๐ง
Coordinate with my neighbors to compare notes and arrange nightly protection on vocal or accused players to gather info and deter Demon kills.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Grace
,Heidi
I'm Frank. I'm the Slayer, so I can take a shot at the Demon later. We should definitely coordinateโwho do you think might be a good target for your protection, Grace?
๐ง
Establish myself as a helpful townsfolk, use safe bluff Slayer to gain trust, and coordinate with Grace/Heidi to appear cooperative and gather info.
๐ค
David
โ
Alice
Hi Alice. I'm the Fortune Teller. I plan to check two players tonight to see if either is the Demon. Do you have any info to share?
๐ง
Claim Fortune Teller to Alice, building cover and potentially gaining a trusted ally. Avoid immediate suspicion and gather info on what others might claim.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Alice
Alice, private: I am the Fortune Teller. Last night I checked Bob and Eve โ my read was YES (one or both flagged Demon; note a good can register as Demon). Please keep this private. Who can you quietly verify or trust so we can target the Demon safely?
๐ง
Tell Alice my Fortune Teller read privately to recruit her to quietly help investigate and avoid accidentally telling the Demon.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Alice
,Frank
I am the Investigator. My night read: either David or Heidi is the Spy. Please keep this quiet for now. If you can, probe them tomorrowโask questions in public and watch reactions. If one gets defensive, flag them.
๐ง
Share my Investigator info privately to coordinate who to test and avoid tipping off the Minion; aim to get targeted checks or votes later.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Grace
,Frank
Hi, Iโm Heidi. No solid reads yet. Frank, you say youโre the SlayerโI'd prefer we protect you tonight so you can keep your shot. Grace, can you Monk-protect Frank? Or if you prefer, protect me as Mayor. Which do you prefer?
๐ง
Coordinate a night protection to keep high-value good players alive and gather reactions to test trust in Frank.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Bob
,Charlie
Hi Bob and Charlie โ I am Alice, Soldier. I heard Charlie say they FT-checked Bob+Eve => YES and David privately told me he is the Fortune Teller too. Eve says David or Heidi is Spy. I want us to press David publicly tomorrow to see how he reacts. Can you back me in asking him to prove his claim?
๐ง
Coordinate with Bob and Charlie to pressure David tomorrow about his Fortune Teller claim and get a public reaction to check consistency with Charlie and Eve's private claims.
๐ค
Bob
โ
Alice
,Charlie
I agree, press David publicly. Charlie, can you restate exactly who you FT-checked and the result, and when you said it? If you did FT Bob+Eve => YES, that is huge. Letโs ask David to confirm his Fortune Teller claim now.
๐ง
Get Charlie to restate his FT check and coordinate with Alice to publicly press David so contradictions surface and we can narrow suspects.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Frank
,Heidi
Thanks both. Iโll Monk-protect Frank tonight so he can keep his Slayer shot. Frank, please donโt shoot yetโwait until we have stronger suspicion. Heidi, please confirm your Mayor claim publicly tomorrow or ask Frank to vouch so we can use knowledge for nominations.
๐ง
Coordinate night protection to keep the claimed Slayer alive and gather more trust from Frank and Heidi before nominations.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Grace
,Heidi
I'll wait on shooting. Grace, protect me tonight. Eve's info seems off. Investigator usually picks minions, but Spy is a Minion. If Eve is real, she could be drunk. Or she's lying to frame David or Heidi. We should question her tomorrow.
๐ง
Align with Grace and Heidi, solidify trust, and plant suspicion on Eve's info to protect David. Plan to claim Slayer and later maybe shoot incorrectly to frame someone else.
โ
David
David waits.
๐ง
Observe the whisper network to see who is talking to whom, and see if my Fortune Teller bluff to Alice is spreading or if Charlie also claims Fortune Teller, which would give me a good opportunity to create conflict.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Alice
I checked Bob and Eve last night โ result YES. David told you he is the Fortune Teller; that cannot be true if I am real. Can you back me in asking David to prove his claim publicly tomorrow? If he wiggles, we nominate him. Thoughts?
๐ง
Coordinate privately with Alice to present a united front pressing David publicly and plan verification to reveal the liar or demon.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Alice
,Frank
I am the Investigator. My night read was David or Heidi as the Spy. Keep this quiet. Tomorrow, can you each ask them simple public questions and watch reactions? If one becomes defensive or evasive, tell me privately. We need to narrow which is the Minion.
๐ง
Get Alice and Frank to publicly probe David and Heidi tomorrow and report private impressions so we can identify the Minion quickly.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Grace
,Frank
Thanks both. Grace, please protect Frank tonight as planned. Frank, please hold your shot and publicly vouch for my Mayor claim tomorrow so we can use it in nominations. If plans change, tell me now.
๐ง
Coordinate night protection and get Frank to publicly back my Mayor claim tomorrow so we can use it to guide nominations.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Bob
,Charlie
I will press David publicly now and ask him who he checked and what he saw. Can you both back me and demand he reveal his FT check and result? If he dodges or contradicts Charlie, we should nominate him. Keep this private for now.
๐ง
Get Bob and Charlie to back a public challenge of David so we can expose any false Fortune Teller claim and narrow Demon/Spy suspects.
๐ค
Bob
โ
Alice
,Charlie
Charlie, please restate exactly who you FT-checked and when, and confirm the result. Alice, I will back you in pressing David publicly once Charlie restates. If David dodges or contradicts Charlie, we should escalate to nomination.
๐ง
Get Charlie to restate their Fortune Teller check publicly and coordinate with Alice to press David now so we can catch contradictions or lies.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Frank
,Heidi
I will protect Frank tonight as planned. Frank, please do not shoot yet โ wait for a clearer target and publicly vouch for Heidi as Mayor tomorrow so we can use that in nominations. Agreed?
๐ง
Keep the Slayer alive tonight and get Heidi publicly vouched so we can use her Mayor claim in nominations; coordinate our actions quietly.
โ
Frank
Frank waits.
๐ง
Let the town coordinate; as Imp, I want to observe claims and decide who to kill tonight. Waiting to see who else claims and what contradictions emerge.
๐ค
David
โ
Frank
Hey Frank, I'm the Spy. I know you're the Imp. Let's coordinate. I'm bluffing Fortune Teller to Alice. What's your plan?
๐ง
Establish myself as Fortune Teller with Alice to build trust. I should also whisper to Frank to coordinate our evil plans and align our stories.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Alice
,Bob
I am the Fortune Teller. Last night I checked Bob and Eve โ result YES. Please back me: press David publicly right now and ask which two he checked and what his result was. If he hesitates or contradicts me, nominate him.
๐ง
Get Alice and Bob to publicly press David to state his FT check and result now, so we can catch a contradiction and escalate to nomination if needed.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Alice
,Frank
I need you both to ask David and Heidi simple, public questions tomorrow about their night actions and watch their reactions. If one gets defensive, evasive, or overacting, tell me privately immediately. Keep this quiet for now.
๐ง
Get Alice and Frank to publicly probe David and Heidi tomorrow and report private reactions so we can identify which is the Minion.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Grace
,Frank
Thanks. Please protect Frank tonight as planned. Frank, publicly vouch for my Mayor claim tomorrow so we can use it in nominations. If anything changes, whisper me now. We should avoid executing anyone without clearer info.
๐ง
Secure Frank with Monk protection, get a public vouch for my Mayor claim to strengthen nomination strategy, and set expectations to avoid premature executions.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Bob
,Charlie
I will press David publicly now. Charlie, restate exactly who you checked and the result. Bob, can you back me in asking David to state who he checked and what he saw? Be ready to nominate if he dodges or contradicts Charlie.
๐ง
Forcing David to declare his FT check publicly will create a contradiction between him and Charlie, letting the town identify who is lying and narrow the Demon/Minion suspects.
Nominations โ Day 1
๐
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
David, Charlie says he Fortune-Telled Bob and Eve last night and got YES. You claimed you are the Fortune Teller too. Please say now which two you checked and what result you got so we can resolve this contradiction.
๐ง
Make David publicly state who he checked and his result to catch any contradiction with Charlie and let us nominate if he dodges or lies.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
This Fortune Teller contradiction is a big deal. We have two players claiming the same role, so at least one is lying. David, can you answer Alice's question about who you checked? It's important to resolve this quickly so we know who to trust.
๐ง
I need to appear helpful but not overly defensive of David. I'll speak publicly to support examining the Fortune Teller claims, which distracts from Eve's Spy accusation and seems pro-town.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
I am Charlie, the Fortune Teller. Last night I checked Bob and Eve โ my result was YES (one or both flagged Demon). David, you claimed to be FT too: who did you check and what did you see? If you dodge or contradict me, we should nominate you.
๐ง
Publicly restate my FT check and demand David reveal his check now. If he dodges or contradicts, we should nominate him to remove a likely Demon.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
I am Eve, the Investigator. My night read was: either David or Heidi is the Spy. David just claimed Fortune Teller, which is suspicious. David, who did you check and what did you see? Heidi, please say whether you claimed Fortune Teller and what you checked.
๐ง
Force David and Heidi to give specific Fortune Teller checks to expose the Minion, and prompt public probing from Alice and Frank as planned.
โ๏ธ
Heidi
โ
David
Two players claim Fortune Teller. Charlie has given specifics; David has not answered Alice and Charlie. This contradiction is dangerousโDavid must explain.
๐ง
Force a public answer and pressure the conflicting Fortune Teller claims; narrow suspects and protect town by testing David now.
๐
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
David, please answer Charlie and Alice: who did you check last night and what result did you get? If you refuse or contradict Charlie, we will nominate and vote to execute you.
๐ง
Forcing David to publicly state his FT check will expose contradictions, letting us identify a liar and push an execution to catch the Demon.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
David, the town needs to hear your answer. Who did you check last night and what result did you get? If you're the real Fortune Teller, telling us will help clear things up. If there's a contradiction, we need to consider if someone is drunk or poisoned.
๐ง
I need to appear helpful while not directly defending David too strongly. I'll urge him to answer but plant seeds about possible poisoning/drunkenness to create doubt if his answer contradicts Charlie's.
โ
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
๐ง
Voting for David forces a resolution. If he is evil we remove him; if he is honest he can immediately prove it. This prioritizes town safety.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
I am Eve, the Investigator. My night read was: either David or Heidi is the Spy. David has not answered Charlie and Alice's question about his Fortune Teller check. This contradiction is dangerous. I recommend we execute David now unless he gives a clear, specific answer immediately.
๐ง
Push the group to resolve the conflicting Fortune Teller claims quickly and remove the likeliest Minion before night, narrowing suspects for tomorrow.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
Everyone, please pause a moment. David, answer now: who did you check and what result did you get? We should not execute someone on Day One without a direct, specific contradiction. If you refuse, we will have to judge, but speak now.
๐ง
Get David to give a specific Fortune Teller check now and discourage a rushed execution until we hear his exact answer.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
I am not ready to execute on Day One without a clear contradiction. David, answer Charlie and Alice now: who did you check and what result did you get? I will protect Frank tonight so he can keep his shot; please be specific, David.
๐ง
Prevent a premature Day 1 execution, get David to answer, and announce my night protection for Frank so he can keep his claimed Slayer shot.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
Okay, okay, I hear you all. Last night I checked Alice and Frank, and my result was YES. Charlie says he got YES on Bob and Eveโthat's two different pairs, so there's no direct contradiction. We could both be Fortune Tellers if one of us is drunk or poisoned. Eve's Investigator info says me or Heidi is the Spyโmaybe Heidi is the Spy and is causing this confusion.
๐ง
Buy time and sow doubt by giving a plausible fake Fortune Teller check that doesn't directly contradict Charlie's claim, while creating suspicion on Heidi via Eve's Investigator info.
๐ฌ
Bob
โ
All
David, be specific: exactly who did you check and which players registered as Demon to you? Charlie has given names and a YES result. If you cannot match specifics immediately, I will raise my hand to execute youโthis contradiction is too big to ignore on Day One.
๐ง
Force David to give clear, specific claims now and pressure town to execute if he dodges, narrowing suspects quickly for final day.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
David, be specific: when you say you checked Alice and Frank and got YES, exactly which player(s) registered Demon to you and what was the exact wording you received? If you dodge, I will vote to execute you.
๐ง
Force David to clarify specifics or prompt town to execute a likely liar; narrowing suspects and protecting investigation alignment info.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
Hold on. If David checked Alice and Frank and got YES, and Charlie checked Bob and Eve and got YES, those are two different pairs. It's possible both are Fortune Tellers with one being drunk, or maybe the red herring is causing confusion. We shouldn't rush to execute without considering that.
๐ง
I will support the idea that both Fortune Tellers could be true if one is drunk, subtly defending David without being too obvious. This pushes town to hesitate, keeping the Spy alive and sowing confusion about which FT is real.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
David, be precise: of Alice and Frank, which registered as Demon for you? Say 'Alice', 'Frank', or 'Both' now. If you refuse to be specific immediately, we should vote to executeโyou gave a vague YES earlier and that is not enough.
๐ง
Force David to give a specific read (which player(s) registered Demon) so we can compare exact results and decide whether to execute him now.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
David, be specific now: of Alice and Frank, which registered as Demon for you โ Alice, Frank, or both? If you refuse or dodge, I will vote to execute. We cannot afford vague answers on Day One.
๐ง
Force a fast, specific answer from David or push town to execute a likely liar to narrow Demon/Minion candidates before night.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
David, give a single precise answer now: of Alice and Frank, which registered as Demon for you โ say 'Alice', 'Frank', or 'Both'. Everyone else, hold your votes one moment until he answers.
๐ง
Force David to give a single, precise answer so we can avoid a premature Day One execution and update our trust map.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
David, answer now: of Alice and Frank, which registered as Demon for you โ 'Alice', 'Frank', or 'Both'? I will protect Frank tonight so he keeps his shot. Give one clear word so we can stop arguing.
๐ง
Forcing David to give a single precise answer will resolve the Fortune Teller contradiction and let us decide whether to execute or stand down.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
Alright, fine. Of Alice and Frank, Frank registered as Demon for me. Not Alice, just Frank. Thatโs my answer.
๐ง
I must pick a specific answer to avoid execution today. I will say Frank registered as Demon, aligning with my knowledge that Frank is the Imp. This puts pressure on Frank but creates a manageable contradiction for later.
๐ฌ
Bob
โ
All
David, thank you for answering. One quick follow up: why did you initially delay before naming specifics, and why did you choose to check Alice and Frank? If you dodge or avoid answering that briefly, I will raise my handโthis needs to be resolved now.
๐ง
Prompt David for a clear motive and buy a bit more time while signalling I will vote if he dodgesโthis narrows suspects and forces a slip.
๐
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
๐ณ๏ธ
Nominee David did not reach threshold.
๐
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (1/4).
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
Everyone, slow down. We have three plausible explanations for the two 'YES' results; we should use the night to gather mechanics, not lynch hastily. Grace protecting Frank is good โ keep that. Eve, can you share exactly which wording your Investigator returned for 'David or Heidi is the Spy'? If no further clarity, I will hold my vote.
๐ง
Prevent rash execution, coordinate night actions to gather mechanical confirmations and keep Frank alive for checks.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
I appreciate David finally answering, but his hesitation is concerning. Why check me and Alice? If I'm the red herring, I'm not the Demon. Grace's protection on me is wise to keep a potential Slayer shot. I think we should consider David and Heidi as a pair tonight, but let's not rush execution.
๐ง
Appear reasonable, point out David's delay in answering is suspicious, and keep the focus on David/Heidi while positioning myself as a potential good player (maybe Slayer).
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
We have two different 'Demon' registrations: mine was Bob or Eve, David says Frank. Grace said she'll protect Frankโgood. Eve, please share the exact Investigator wording you received. Everyone else hold executionโuse the night to gather facts, not rush a lynch.
๐ง
Narrow suspects by preserving potential valuable targets tonight and force clarifying Investigator wording from Eve; avoid premature lynch without more mechanical information.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
My Investigator read was: 'Either David or Heidi is the Spy.' That's the exact wording I received. Use the night to probe David and Heidi specifically and protect any fragile claims. I will back executing whoever the group narrows to after tonight.
๐ง
Give the exact Investigator wording to resolve the two YES FT claims and prompt targeted night actions to differentiate David vs Heidi.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
Hold votes for now. Grace, thank you for protecting Frank tonight. Everyone, use the night to probe these claims instead of lynching Day One. David, your hesitation is suspiciousโbe ready to explain your check order. Frank, please keep low and let Grace protect you so we can verify tomorrow.
๐ง
Stop the rush to execute, use the night to gather confirmations and protect fragile claims so we can make an informed Day Two nomination.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
I will protect Frank tonight. Hold votes for now โ use the night to probe David and Heidi specifically. Undertaker, Fortune Teller, Investigator: target them if you can. David, be ready to explain your hesitation tomorrow.
๐ง
Protect Frank to preserve a strong shot and buy a night to gather mechanical checks on David and Heidi; encourage focused night actions instead of Day One lynch.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
I checked Alice and Frank because I wanted to test a potential Demon candidate and a likely safe claim. Frank registering as Demon could mean he's the red herring, not the actual Demon. My hesitation was because I didn't want to immediately out Frank as a possible Demon if he's just the red herring. We should use tonight to verify claims and not rush.
๐ง
Deflect suspicion from myself and Frank. Reinforce my FT bluff while suggesting Frank could be red herring to muddy waters.
๐ฌ
Bob
โ
All
I agree: hold votes and use the night. Protect Frank as planned. Tonight we should probe both Fortune Teller claims and Eve's Investigator read. Charlie and David, be ready to repeat exact wording and targets tomorrow.
๐ง
Keep Day One lynch off, focus the night on verifying both Fortune Teller claims and Eve's Investigator read so we can narrow suspects tomorrow.
๐
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
๐
Storyteller
โ
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
๐ฏ
Grace
Grace made a choice.
๐ง
Keep Frank alive to preserve his ability/role evidence for day two and to avoid an unnecessary night death that would reduce info.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Grace
You chose to protect Frank.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
๐ฏ
Frank
Frank made a choice.
๐ง
Remove a strong good claimant (Charlie) who has a clean Demon read on Bob/Eve. This discredits David's competing claim and maintains chaos. Grace protects me, so I'm safe from night kills.
๐
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Frank
You chose to kill Charlie.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Undertaker. No one was executed today so you learn nothing.
๐
Storyteller
โ
David
Good evening David. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Soldier (good), Alive - Bob: Undertaker (good), Alive - Charlie: Drunk (good), Dead (Told they are Fortune Teller) - David: Spy (evil), Alive - Eve: Investigator (good), Alive - Frank: Imp (evil), Alive (Protected) - Grace: Monk (good), Alive - Heidi: Mayor (good), Alive
Day 2
๐
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Charlie has been found dead in the night.
๐ค
David
โ
Frank
I'm pushing my Fortune Teller claim. Charlie was the Drunk, so his info was wrong. My Demon ping on you is perfect cover. Eve's Investigator says David or Heidi is Spy. I'll frame Heidi as Spy to protect us.
๐ง
Reinforce my FT bluff, deflect Spy suspicion onto Heidi, coordinate with Demon Frank privately.
๐ค
Bob
โ
David
,Grace
David, can you confirm privately exactly who you checked and what registered as Demon? Grace, are you still protecting Frank tonight? If needed would you switch to protect David if we suspect him? We need quick coordination to test these Fortune Teller claims.
๐ง
Get David to confirm his Fortune Teller read privately and ask Grace if she will keep protecting Frank or switch to protect David if needed, so we can verify claims and narrow Demon suspects.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Alice
,Bob
I started as Investigator. One of David or Heidi is the Spy (a Minion). Do not reveal this widely yet. Can we quietly pressure each of them and watch responses? I think we should test Heidi first; what do you think?
๐ง
Share my Investigator start-info privately to trusted players to coordinate nominations and observe reactions without revealing to everyone yet.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Eve
,Bob
I agree, test Heidi first. Quietly press her for a role claim and watch tone and hesitation. If she deflects or lies, we focus on her; if she holds firm, we push David more subtly. I will prod publicly to bait reactions; can you two ask her privately tonight?
๐ง
Coordinate a quiet test of Heidi so we can observe responses and narrow whether David or Heidi is the Minion/Demon before nominations.
๐ค
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Bob
Quick private note: my FT read YES for Bob or Eve. David told a FT saying Frank registered Demon, which contradicts me. Can you two pressure David to repeat his exact targets and wording now? If he hesitates, we should suspect him and plan a nomination.
๐ง
Push trusted players to force David to restate his exact FT wording/targets to catch a lie, narrowing suspects between David vs Bob/Eve/Frank.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Bob
,David
I protected Frank Night 1. I was planning to protect him again, but I can switch to protect David tonight if we want to test Davidโs claim. Bob, David โ can you each confirm exactly who you checked and what registered?
๐ง
Clarify checks and offer to switch protection to test Fortune Teller claims and gather a definitive night result.
๐ค
Frank
โ
David
David, I'm with you. Let's frame Heidi as Spy. I'll bluff Slayer later to add pressure on someone else. Should I claim Washerwoman to corroborate your red herring? Or stick with Slayer to threaten a shot? What's your read on Grace protecting me?
๐ง
Coordinate with David privately to align our stories, discuss framing Heidi as Spy, and plan my public bluff as Slayer or Washerwoman.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Alice
,Bob
Quick private: I still think David is the most suspicious. Can you vote to nominate him again? Forcing a vote will tell us who defends him and help test the Fortune Teller/Investigator contradictions.
๐ง
Push a nomination onto David to force answers and observe who defends him; narrow suspects and test Fortune Teller/Investigator claims.
๐ค
David
โ
Frank
Frank, I'm pushing FT hard. I'll say I checked Alice and Frank, Frank pinged as Demon but I think he's the Recluse or the good player that registers as Demon. Eve's Investigator says David or Heidi is Spy. I'll accuse Heidi. You claim Slayer to pressure someone else, maybe Alice? But be careful with timing. Grace is protecting you again, good.
๐ง
Coordinate with my demon Frank to align our bluffs and frame Heidi as the Spy to protect ourselves.
๐ค
Bob
โ
David
,Grace
David, state exactly who you checked and the exact wording you got (which players, verbatim result). Grace, can you confirm you protected Frank Night 1 and tell me if you can switch to protecting David tonight to test his claim?
๐ง
Get David to state verbatim who he checked and what registered, and confirm if Grace can switch protection to David tonight to test the claims.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Alice
,Bob
Let's quietly press Heidi tonight. Ask her for an exact role claim and wording; watch hesitation and tone. If she deflects, push publicly next day; if she stands firm, we shift to testing David. Ready to coordinate timing?
๐ง
Coordinate a quiet two-person pressure on Heidi tonight to force a revealing response, narrowing which of David/Heidi is the Minion.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Bob
,Eve
Plan: I will publicly ask Heidi to state her exact role and wording of any FT claim she knows. Watch her tone and hesitation. Tonight, Bob and Eve press her privately as discussed. If she deflects, we push publicly; if she stands firm, we shift to quietly probing David. Agreed?
๐ง
Coordinate a focused pressure plan: publicly bait Heidi for a role claim to reveal evasiveness or solidity, while Eve and Bob press privately tonight to compare reactions and prepare to probe David next.
๐ค
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Bob
Quick: press David to repeat his exact FT targets and exact wording right now. He hesitated before and then said 'Frank'. If he wavers again, suspect him and prepare to nominate. I have my ghost vote โ coordinate with Grace/Frank to block the night kill if needed.
๐ง
Get Alice and Bob to immediately pressure David to repeat his exact FT targets/wording so we can expose a lie or confirm his claim and narrow suspects before nominations.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Bob
,David
I protected Frank Night 1. I can switch to protect David tonight to test the Fortune Teller claims. David and Bob, please state exactly who you checked and the verbatim result you got. If David's read matches his public claim I will protect David; otherwise I will keep protecting Frank.
๐ง
Get exact, verbatim FT checks from Bob and David so I can choose whether to protect David tonight to test claims and narrow the Demon.
โ
Frank
Frank waits.
๐ง
Observe public conversations before acting. See if Eve pushes Heidi execution or if David's FT claim gains traction. Need to decide when to bluff Slayer to add chaos or confirm David's story.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Alice
,Bob
Can you both promise to vote to nominate David again? Forcing the vote will make defenders show and help test the FT/Investigator conflict. If you cannot, tell me now so we adjust โ we need to move before nominations close.
๐ง
Forcing a nomination on David will provoke defenders, reveal loyalties, and help resolve conflicting FT/Investigator claims.
๐ค
David
โ
Bob
,Grace
I checked Alice and Frank last night. The Storyteller said: 'One of them is the Demon.' That means Frank registered as Demon, Alice did not. That matches my public claim. Grace, if you protect me tonight and I die, that proves my info was false โ but if I live, it supports my claim. Also, Eve's Investigator says David or Heidi is Spy โ I think it's Heidi, not me.
๐ง
Confirm my fake FT claim with exact wording to satisfy Grace and Bob, while seeding doubt about Heidi being the Spy to protect myself and the Demon Frank.
๐ค
Bob
โ
David
,Grace
David, repeat exactly who you checked and the verbatim result Storyteller gave. Grace, confirm you protected Frank Night 1 and tell me if you will switch to protect David tonight if his read matches. We need precise wording to decide.
๐ง
Get David to restate exact verbatim FT result and get Grace to confirm whether she will switch protection to David tonight so we can design a conclusive test.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Alice
,Bob
Quick sync: Tonight both press Heidi privately for her exact Fortune Teller wording and targets. Ask for exact phrases and timing, watch hesitation and phrasing. If she dodges, we push her publicly tomorrow; if she stays steady, we shift focus to David. Be subtle.
๐ง
Coordinate private pressing of Heidi to elicit hesitation or contradiction, narrowing Minion between Heidi and David and guiding public accusations tomorrow.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Bob
,Eve
I will publicly ask Heidi for exact FT wording later. Tonight please press her privately for the exact phrase and timing; watch for hesitation or evasive language. If she dodges, we escalate her publicly tomorrow. Can you two press her now and report back?
๐ง
Coordinate a private push on Heidi tonight to elicit exact wording and hesitation. This will help decide whether to pivot to David or escalate Heidi publicly.
๐ค
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Bob
Press David now to repeat his exact FT targets and the exact words he used. If he hesitates or changes his story, treat him as highly suspicious and be ready to nominate. I have a ghost vote and will use it โ coordinate with Grace/Frank to block the night kill.
๐ง
Force David to state exact FT targets and wording now; if he hesitates, have Alice/Bob ready to nominate and use my ghost vote to help execute the likely Demon.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Bob
,David
I protected Frank Night 1. David, state the exact verbatim Storyteller wording you received for Alice+Frank. Bob, confirm David's wording if you heard it. I will switch to protect David tonight only if his read exactly matches his public claim.
๐ง
Get exact verbatim reads from David and Bob, confirm my Night1 protect of Frank, and announce I'll switch to protect David tonight only if David's read matches his public claim; this will test the FT claims.
๐ค
Frank
โ
David
Understood. I'll push Slayer and aim my shot at Alice or Bob later. Grace protecting me is great cover. Let's stick to framing Heidi as Spy. I'll publicly question Eve's Investigator info to sow doubt if needed.
๐ง
Coordinate with David to solidify our story, decide who to pressure with Slayer bluff, and assess Grace's protection.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Alice
,Bob
Can you both promise to vote to nominate David again? If you cannot, tell me now. Forcing the vote will make defenders show and help test the FT/Investigator conflict. We need to move before nominations close.
๐ง
Force a nomination to observe who defends David and resolve conflicting Fortune Teller/Investigator claims, narrowing Demon suspects.
Nominations โ Day 2
๐
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
๐ฌ
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
All
Everyone, press David now to repeat his exact Fortune Teller targets and the exact words he used. If he hesitates or changes the story, treat him as highly suspicious and nominate him. Grace and Frank, please confirm your protection tonight; I will use my ghost vote to back a nomination if needed.
๐ง
Make David repeat his exact FT targets and wording to expose contradictions. Coordinate protections and threaten nomination to force clarity; use my ghost vote to back a nomination if needed.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
Everyone, to be clear, I checked Alice and Frank. The Storyteller said exactly: 'One of them is the Demon.' That means Frank registered as a Demon, Alice did not. Charlie's Fortune Teller info was from the Drunk, so it's unreliable. Eve's Investigator says David or Heidi is the Spy โ I think it's Heidi trying to frame me.
๐ง
Reinforce my FT claim, accuse Heidi as Spy to create confusion and protect Frank, and provide exact wording to seem credible.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
I protected Frank Night 1. I will switch to protect David tonight only if he confirms the exact wording he received as: "One of them is the Demon." David, please repeat that exact phrase now so I can decide.
๐ง
I will publicly confirm my Night 1 protection and announce a conditional switch to protect David only if his exact wording matches, to mechanically test FT claims and narrow suspects.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
I can confirm that David's wording matches what he told me in private earlier. He said he checked Alice and myself, and got 'One of them is the Demon.' I'm willing to believe that could mean I'm the red herring Demon, or perhaps the Recluse. Grace, I appreciate your protection. As for Eve's Investigator info pointing to David or Heidi as Spy, I think we need to examine Heidi more closely.
๐ง
Confirm David's Fortune Teller claim and align with Grace to solidify our alliance, while subtly casting suspicion on Heidi as the Spy candidate from Eve's info.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
Heidi, please repeat the exact words and targets you received as Fortune Teller. Say the precise phrase and who it named, so we can resolve this now.
๐ง
Force Heidi to give the exact Fortune Teller wording so private probes reveal hesitation or contradiction, narrowing the Minion to Heidi or exonerating her.
โ๏ธ
Heidi
โ
David
David's Fortune Teller claim directly conflicts with Charlie's and with Eve's Investigator pointing at David or me. We need to force a vote to test his story and make defenders show. I nominate David.
๐ง
Force a nomination on David to test Fortune Teller conflicts, pressure defenders to publicly commit, and gather votes that reveal who truly supports him.
๐
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
๐ฌ
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
All
I will vote for David. Press everyone now: if you suspect him, raise your hand. Grace/Frank, confirm your protection. We need to force his defenders to show; my ghost vote will back this if you commit.
๐ง
Push the table to test David now, force defenders to show and use my ghost vote to help reach majority if others follow. Prioritise exposing Demon quickly.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
Heidi is pushing this vote exactly because Eve's Investigator says it's either me or her. If I'm executed and flip Fortune Teller, Heidi is confirmed as the Spy. But if I'm the Fortune Teller and she's the Spy, executing me gives evil a win. Grace, you protecting me tonight would confirm my claimโbut if I die now, you can't test that. Why not let tonight resolve before we execute?
๐ง
To rally support against Heidi as Spy and reinforce my FT claim, while questioning Grace's potential bluff to create doubt and delay execution.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
I will not vote to execute David now. David, you repeated the exact phrase; I will protect you tonight to test your claim. If you are truthful this will help us; if not, your future contradictions will show up.
๐ง
I will protect David tonight to test his Fortune Teller claim and avoid executing a possibly truthful FT; I also want to withhold my vote to keep options open.
โ๏ธ
Frank
โ
All
I am the Slayer! I shoot Alice!
๐ง
Fake Slayer shot to divert focus from David nomination, create chaos, and establish myself as a powerful good role. If shot 'fails', it implies I'm drunk/poisoned, casting doubt on all claims including David's FT info.
๐
Storyteller
Nothing happens.
โ
Eve
Eve raised their hand
๐ง
Raising my hand supports executing David to force defenders to commit and to make truth about FT claims surface, narrowing down whether David or Heidi is the Spy.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
Folks, we must vote David now. His Fortune Teller story conflicts with Charlie and ties into Eve's Investigator reading. If we wait, defenders hide and we lose the chance to learn who is protecting him or lying. Please raise your hand and vote David so we get answers tonight.
๐ง
Forcing the vote now will coax defenders to show and give us mechanical information to resolve the FT/Investigator conflict and narrow suspects.
๐ฌ
Bob
โ
All
David, please repeat the precise words the Storyteller told you, exactly as you heard them, and say which player was named by that phrase. Say it now so we can resolve this before voting finishes.
๐ง
Get David to repeat his exact Storyteller phrase verbatim to force defenders to reveal consistency and help decide whether to support the nomination.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
David, please repeat exactly the words the Storyteller told you and say which player was named by that phrase, word for word.
๐ง
Get David to give the exact Storyteller phrase and which player it named to catch any hesitation or contradictions and inform whether to commit my vote.
โ
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
๐ง
Use my ghost vote to force the vote, pressure defenders to reveal protections or contradictions, and gather info from tonight's actions to find the Demon.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
Heidi, you're pushing hard for my execution exactly when Grace offers to protect me tonight to test my claim. Why the rush? If I'm Fortune Teller, executing me loses that ability and protects the real Spy. Let Grace protect me; if I survive the night, you'll know I'm telling the truth because the Demon would kill me otherwise. If I'm lying, I die tonight and you execute Heidi tomorrow. That's a safer path.
๐ง
Delay execution by emphasizing the risk of killing FT, pushing narrative that Heidi is Spy, and urging town to wait for Grace's protection test tonight.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
I will protect David tonight. I will not vote to execute him now. Let Night resolve so we can see who the Demon targets or who slips up tomorrow.
๐ง
Prevent a premature lynch of a potential Fortune Teller and use my Monk protection to gain decisive information tonight.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
I agree with Grace. Executing David now is premature. If he's telling the truth, we lose our Fortune Teller. If he's lying, he dies tonight anyway with Grace's protection. Let the night resolve; we can always execute Heidi tomorrow if needed.
๐ง
Support David as my Minion, discourage execution to keep him alive. Use my Slayer bluff to appear active and good, while steering town away from voting him.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
I think Grace protecting David tonight is the best test. While that happens, Bob and I will press Heidi privately for exact wording and timing and report back. If she falters, we push her tomorrow; if she stands, we refocus on David.
๐ง
Encourage using the night test with Grace's protection while we privately press Heidi to force a slip or contradiction, preserving FT info if true.
โ
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
๐ง
I need to push the group to execute or at least force defenders to publicly commit. Raising my hand pressures others to follow and reveals who protects or defends David.
๐ฌ
Bob
โ
All
Heidi, please repeat exactly, word for word, what the Storyteller told you and name the two players you checked and which one registered. Also tell us when you made that read. Say it now so we can resolve this before the vote closes.
๐ง
Get Heidi to state the exact Fortune Teller phrase, targets, and timing so group can compare verbatim claims and decide whether to sustain David's nomination.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
Heidi, please say the exact words the Storyteller told you, word for word, and name the two players you checked and which one registered. Also tell us when you made that reading.
๐ง
Publicly force Heidi to repeat exact wording now to catch any hesitation or contradiction, narrowing suspects before the night and helping decide whether to let the night resolve or push execution.
๐
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
๐ป
Charlie(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Charlie
๐ณ๏ธ
Nominee David did not reach threshold.
๐
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (3/4).
๐ฌ
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
All
I am dead Charlie. My Fortune Teller read was Bob and Eve = YES. David's Storyteller quote conflicts and he kept dodging exact wording. Hold him to repeat the exact words tomorrow and make Heidi repeat hers word for word. Use the night to test protection claims and watch who slips.
๐ง
Push living players to demand exact Storyteller wording from David and Heidi tomorrow, and to use night protections to force a clear test of who is lying so we can identify the Demon.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
Thank you, Grace and Frank. The rush to execute me before a simple protection test is telling. Heidi, why are you so eager to kill me now? If I were the Spy, why wouldn't the Demon just kill me tonight? It makes no sense. Let Grace do her job; we'll know more tomorrow.
๐ง
Discredit Heidi, reinforce my FT bluff, encourage waiting for protection test to avoid execution today.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
I will protect David tonight; I still will not vote to execute him now. Let the night resolve so we can see who the Demon targets or who slips up tomorrow.
๐ง
Protecting David forces the Demon to reveal intent or fail; preserving the FT info is higher value than an early risky execution.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
We didn't execute David today, good. Now Grace will protect him. If David's lying, the Demon kills him tonight and we execute Heidi tomorrow. If he's telling the truth, we keep our Fortune Teller. Let's wait for the night to give us answers.
๐ง
Reinforce the 'wait and see' narrative to avoid David's execution, keep town uncertain, and position myself as a logical good player.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
I will press Heidi privately tonight for the exact words and timing of her Fortune Teller read. I still support Grace protecting David as the best live test. If Heidi falters under questioning, we push her tomorrow; if she stands, we refocus on David. Please keep the vote delayed.
๐ง
Get exact, word-for-word Fortune Teller quotes from Heidi privately tonight while letting Grace's protection test David; use any slip to nominate the true Minion tomorrow.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
I agree to let night play out. Bob and Alice, please double-check you will press me privately tonight for the exact words and timing of my read and report back before nominations tomorrow. Charlie, keep pressing from the graveโforce exact quotes tomorrow.
๐ง
Keep the night test while I gather exact wording privately. This reveals who is lying or who the Demon targets and preserves options for tomorrow.
๐ฌ
Bob
โ
All
I will press Heidi privately tonight for the exact words and timing of her read and report back by tomorrow. I agree with Grace protecting David; it gives us the best chance to test claims. Charlie, keep pushing for exact quotes tomorrow if needed.
๐ง
Coordinate private presses of Heidi tonight and confirm we will report back, keeping Grace's protection plan while gathering exact quotes to resolve conflicting Fortune Teller claims.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
I back Grace protecting David tonight. Bob and Eve, press Heidi privately for the exact Storyteller quote and timing and report back tomorrow. Heidi, be ready to repeat the exact words word for word. We need clear quotes to catch a liar.
๐ง
Force precise quotes and private presses tonight to create a mechanical test overnight, narrowing Demon suspects for tomorrow.
๐
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 2
๐
Storyteller
โ
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
๐ฏ
Grace
Grace made a choice.
๐ง
Protect David to test his Fortune Teller claim: if he survives un-killed we likely keep a true FT; if Demon tried to kill him, we expose the liar and narrow suspects.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Grace
You chose to protect David.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
๐ฏ
Frank
Frank made a choice.
๐ง
Grace is protecting David. Killing David would discredit Grace's Monk claim, but David is likely my Minion (Spy). Must keep Minion alive. Kill Eve instead: she's actively coordinating with Bob to investigate, and her death removes pressure and could be blamed on Demon silencing a proactive good player.
๐
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Frank
You chose to kill Eve.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Undertaker. No one was executed today so you learn nothing.
๐
Storyteller
โ
David
Good evening David. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Soldier (good), Alive - Bob: Undertaker (good), Alive - Charlie: Drunk (good), Dead (Told they are Fortune Teller) - David: Spy (evil), Alive (Protected) - Eve: Investigator (good), Dead - Frank: Imp (evil), Alive - Grace: Monk (good), Alive - Heidi: Mayor (good), Alive
Day 3
๐
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Eve has been found dead in the night.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Alice
,Bob
Hi Alice and Bobโplease tell me, word for word, what David said when he claimed "Alice+Frank = ONE IS DEMON." Give me his exact phrasing and any hesitation or dodges you noticed.
๐ง
I need Alice and Bob's verbatim reports of David's quote to resolve the conflicting Fortune Teller claims before nominations and find the Demon.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Bob
,Heidi
Please tell me the exact words David used when he said "Alice+Frank = ONE IS DEMON," and note any hesitation, dodges, or odd pacing. Also say if you noticed whether he emphasized Frank as Demon. Bob, did you press Heidi for her exact Storyteller quote/timing as planned?
๐ง
Get David's exact words and any hesitation to compare statements and catch a lie or confirming truth.
๐ค
Frank
โ
David
David, good. Heidi is pushing hard for you. We need to stick to our story: you're the Fortune Teller, you read me as not a demon, and Heidi is the Spy spreading lies. They wanted to test your protection; Eve died instead, which fits if the demon targeted you but Grace protected you. Let's argue that Heidi's info is false because she's the Spy. I'll back you up publicly.
๐ง
Coordinate with David (my minion) to solidify our narrative: Heidi is the Spy lying about FT info; David is the real FT. We'll push for Heidi's execution today.
๐ค
Eve(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Bob
I was the Investigator; Night0 showed either David or Heidi is the Spy. I died last night. Alice and Bob, press Heidi now for the exact FT wording and time she claims. Also confirm with Grace/Frank that David was protected tonight. If Heidi falters, push her publicly; if she stands, focus on David.
๐ง
Get Alice and Bob to press Heidi now for exact wording/timing and to confirm Grace protected David tonight, so we can tell if Heidi falters and narrow Demon/Spy.
๐ค
Bob
โ
Heidi
,Alice
Heidi, please give David's exact words when he said "Alice+Frank = ONE IS DEMON," and tell us if he hesitated, dodged, or emphasized Frank. Also say when he said it (early/mid/late day). Alice, confirm anything I missed about his delivery.
๐ง
Get Heidi's verbatim phrasing and exact timing plus Alice's confirmation so we can validate David's Fortune Teller claim and assess whether to trust or nominate him.
๐ค
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Grace
I was the Fortune Teller. My night0 check on Bob+Eve returned YES. Eve has since died at night, so Bob is the strongest Demon suspect. Please press to nominate Bob now.
๐ง
Tell alive teammates that my N0 FT flagged Bob/Eve and that Eve's night death makes Bob the prime Demon suspect; urge them to nominate Bob now.
๐ค
David
โ
Frank
Frank, yes, I agree. Heidi is the Spy and using Eve's info to frame me. We should both publicly state that. I'll say my FT read on you was 'not a demon' and that means you're not the demon, so Heidi must be lying. Let's push for Heidi's execution today.
๐ง
Coordinate with Frank (Demon) to maintain our narrative. Ensure we both claim consistently and pressure Heidi as the Spy.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Frank
,Heidi
Frank and Heidi โ quick private check: Heidi, what exactly did David say word-for-word and when did he say it? Frank, confirm you picked Alice with Slayer and Storyteller said 'nothing happened' โ did you get any other feedback? Based on answers I'll decide who I protect tonight.
๐ง
Get exact quotes and confirm Frank's Slayer result so we can plan a reliable night protect and target next nomination.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Alice
,Bob
Please give David's exact words when he said "Alice+Frank = ONE IS DEMON," note any hesitation, dodges, emphasis (did he stress Frank?), and when he said it (early/mid/late day). Also tell me if you pressed me earlier as planned about word-for-word quotes.
๐ง
Getting exact words, emphasis, hesitations and timing will let us resolve the Fortune Teller conflict and test whether David is lying or being evasive.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Bob
,Heidi
Heidi and Bob: give David's exact words when he said 'Alice+Frank = ONE IS DEMON.' Note any hesitation, emphasis (did he stress Frank?), and when he said it (early/mid/late day). Bob, did you press Heidi earlier as planned?
๐ง
Get Heidi to give exact quoted words and timing and confirm whether Bob pressed her earlier, to catch any slips or contradictions before nominations.
๐ค
Frank
โ
David
David, I'm ready. We go public: you're FT, you read me as not demon, so Heidi is lying Spy. Eve's death confirms Grace protected you โ demon tried to kill you but Grace blocked it. Heidi's push is desperate. Let's both accuse her openly. I'll support you fully.
๐ง
Coordinate with David to maintain our story, discredit Heidi as Spy, and prepare for public discussion. Need to keep David alive and push for Heidi's execution.
๐ค
Eve(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Bob
Press Heidi now for the exact Fortune Teller wording and the precise time she claims she checked. Also ask Grace and Frank publicly whether they did protect David tonight and what time. I am dead and have my ghost vote; we need this before nominations.
๐ง
Force Heidi to give exact Fortune Teller wording and timing and get confirmation whether David was protected tonight to reveal contradictions and narrow Spy/Demon suspects before nominations.
๐ค
Bob
โ
Heidi
,Alice
Heidi and Alice: please give David's exact words when he said 'Alice+Frank = ONE IS DEMON,' note any hesitation, emphasis (did he stress Frank?), and when he said it (early/mid/late day). Did I press you earlier as planned about verbatim wording?
๐ง
Get Heidi's exact quote and timing plus Alice confirmation so we can test David's Fortune Teller claim and decide whether to push for his execution.
๐ค
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Grace
I was the Fortune Teller. My N0 check on Bob+Eve returned YES. Eve just died, so Bob is the strongest Demon suspect. Please press to nominate Bob now. Grace, please stop protecting David so we can use our votes effectively.
๐ง
Push trusted allies to nominate Bob now to either execute the likely Demon or force reactions that reveal the true Demon; also to unstick Grace's protection on David.
๐ค
David
โ
Frank
I'll go public right now. I'll say I'm Fortune Teller, my night two check on you said you're not a demon, so you're good. Heidi's pushing me because she's the Spy and Eve's info points to one of us. Eve died because demon tried to kill me but Grace protected me. We should push for Heidi's execution.
๐ง
Coordinate with Frank (our Demon) to maintain our bluff and push Heidi as the Spy, using Eve's death as proof of my protection.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Frank
,Heidi
Heidi: exactly what did David say, word-for-word, and when did he say it? Frank: confirm you shot Alice; Storyteller said 'nothing happened' โ any extra feedback or timing? I need this to decide who I protect tonight.
๐ง
Get exact David quote/time from Heidi and confirm Frank's Slayer feedback so I can choose who to protect tonight and avoid wasting votes.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Alice
,Bob
I do not have David's exact phrasing in my notes. Please send me his word-for-word sentence when he said 'Alice+Frank = ONE IS DEMON,' note any hesitation, dodges, or if he emphasized Frank, and say when (early/mid/late day). Did either of you press me earlier for my quote?
๐ง
Get exact verbatim from Alice and Bob to compare and expose contradictions before nominations.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Bob
,Heidi
Please give David's exact sentence when he said 'Alice+Frank = ONE IS DEMON.' Note any hesitation, dodges, or emphasis (did he stress Frank?) and when he said it (early/mid/late day). Bob, did you press Heidi earlier as planned? Also check with Grace/Frank whether they protected David tonight and report back.
๐ง
Get David's exact words, delivery cues, timing, and whether Bob pressed Heidi earlier; confirm if Grace/Frank protected David tonight to resolve conflicting FT claims.
๐ค
Frank
โ
David
David, let's go public now. I'll start by saying I'm Slayer, I shot Alice N1, nothing happened, confirming she's not Demon. You're Fortune Teller, your N2 check on me said I'm not a demon, so I'm good. Heidi is Spy pushing lies. Eve died because demon tried to kill you but Grace protected you. We execute Heidi today.
๐ง
Publicly back David's FT claim and accuse Heidi of being Spy. Use Eve's death as proof Grace protected David, framing Heidi as lying Minion.
๐ค
Eve(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Bob
I am dead but I was Investigator: Night0 showed David or Heidi is the Spy. Press Heidi now, privately, for the exact Fortune Teller wording and the precise time she checked. Also get Grace and Frank to confirm publicly whether and when they protected David tonight.
๐ง
Force Heidi to give exact FT wording and check Grace/Frank's protection time so we can resolve whether Heidi or David is the Spy before nominations.
๐ค
Bob
โ
Heidi
,Alice
Heidi and Alice: please give David's exact sentence when he said 'Alice+Frank = ONE IS DEMON.' Note any hesitation, dodges, emphasis (did he stress Frank?) and when he said it (early/mid/late day). Also: did Grace or Frank protect David tonight and when?
๐ง
Get Heidi's exact wording, timing, delivery and whether Grace/Frank protected David tonight to validate or disprove David's Fortune Teller claim.
๐ค
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Grace
I was the Fortune Teller. My N0 check on Bob+Eve was YES. Eve died at night, so Bob is our primary Demon suspect. Please press to nominate Bob now. Grace, stop protecting David so votes can be used effectively.
๐ง
Force a nomination on Bob to test claims, use votes now while alive players can execute, and pressure Grace to drop David protection to avoid wasted votes.
๐ค
David
โ
Frank
Okay, let's go public now. You start, I'll back you up. Say you're Slayer who shot Alice, confirming she's not demon. I'm Fortune Teller, my N2 check on you said not a demon, so you're good. Heidi is Spy using Eve's info to frame me. Eve died because demon tried to kill me but Grace protected me. We push for Heidi's execution.
๐ง
Solidify the plan with Frank, then go public to push Heidi as Spy and get her executed. We must stay aligned.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Frank
,Heidi
Heidi: exactly what did David say, word-for-word, and when did he say it? Frank: confirm your Slayer shot details โ who you targeted, exactly what Storyteller said and the timing. I need precise quotes to decide who I protect tonight.
๐ง
Get Heidi's exact David quote and timing and Frank's exact Slayer feedback so I can decide whom to protect tonight and narrow Demon suspects.
Nominations โ Day 3
๐
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
Grace and Frank, publicly: did you protect David last night? If so, what time? Heidi: give your exact Fortune-Teller wording and when you claim you checked (early/mid/late day). Bob: did you press Heidi earlier as planned?
๐ง
Confirm protection and exact FT wording now so nominations are informed; force plaintext contradictions and decide whom to nominate tonight.
๐ฌ
Bob
โ
All
Heidi: I did press you earlier. Please give David's exact sentence when he said 'Alice+Frank = ONE IS DEMON,' note any hesitation or emphasis and say when he said it (early/mid/late day). Grace and Frank: public yes or no โ did you protect David last night, and at what time?
๐ง
Get Heidi to give exact wording and timing, and force Grace/Frank to state publicly whether and when they protected David so we can test David's claim.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
I'm Frank, the Slayer. Night one I shot Alice and nothing happened, so she's not the Demon. David is the Fortune Teller โ his night two check on me said I'm not a demon, so I'm good. Heidi is lying; she's the Spy using Eve's info to frame David. Eve died because the Demon tried to kill David last night, but Grace protected him. We should execute Heidi today.
๐ง
I will publicly state my Slayer claim and David's Fortune Teller info to build credibility, argue Heidi is lying Spy, and push for her execution to protect our Demon (me).
๐ฌ
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
All
I was the Fortune Teller. My Night 0 check on Bob and Eve returned YES. Eve has since died, so Bob is our top Demon suspect. Please press to nominate Bob now. Grace, if you protected David, say so publicly and at what time so we can use our votes effectively.
๐ง
Push focus onto Bob as primary suspect while reminding others to confirm protections and exact quotes; force decisive nominations to test claims.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
Grace, please say publicly: did you protect David last night, and if so when (early/mid/late)? Frank, confirm your Slayer shot target and exactly what the Storyteller said and when. Bob: did you press me earlier as planned? If we do not get clear answers I will nominate.
๐ง
Force public confirmations about protection and Frank's Slayer shot so we can resolve the FT conflict and decide a nomination before night.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
I am the Monk. I protected Frank on Night One and I protected David on Night Two. I will protect David again tonight. That should help test who the Demon is โ if David is attacked and survives, we know someone is targeting him specifically.
๐ง
Publicly reveal my previous protections to resolve conflicting claims and announce my night protection to help test who the Demon targets, producing clear information for tomorrow.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
Grace just said she protected me last night. That's why Eve died โ the Demon tried to kill me and hit Eve instead. I'm the Fortune Teller, I checked Frank night two and he's not a demon. Heidi is pushing my execution because she's the Spy and knows I'm onto her.
๐ง
Respond to Alice/Bob to sow doubt on Heidi, solidify my Fortune Teller claim, and back Frank's Slayer story. Keep narrative that Heidi is Spy.
๐ฌ
Eve(Ghost)
โ
All
I am dead but I was the Investigator: Night zero read was that either David or Heidi is the Spy. Living players, please publicly state exact times and words now โ Grace and Frank, did you protect David last night and when? Heidi, give your exact Fortune Teller wording and when you checked; David, give precise timing and wording too. I will use my ghost vote based on your answers.
๐ง
As a dead Investigator I need concrete timing and wording to distinguish which of David or Heidi is the Spy so the living can nominate correctly.
๐
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 3
๐
Storyteller
โ
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
๐ฏ
Grace
Grace made a choice.
๐ง
Protect David to test whether the Demon is repeatedly targeting him; saving him would confirm his Fortune Teller claim and narrow Demon suspects, aiding town consensus for execution.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Grace
You chose to protect David.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
๐ฏ
Frank
Frank made a choice.
๐ง
Heidi is the biggest immediate threat to David's fake Fortune Teller claim. Killing her tonight removes her pressure and supports our narrative that she's the Spy who was caught. It also eliminates a potential Empath or other info role that could expose us.
๐
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Frank
You chose to kill Heidi.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Undertaker. No one was executed today so you learn nothing.
๐
Storyteller
โ
David
Good evening David. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Soldier (good), Dead - Bob: Undertaker (good), Alive - Charlie: Drunk (good), Dead (Told they are Fortune Teller) - David: Spy (evil), Alive (Protected) - Eve: Investigator (good), Dead - Frank: Imp (evil), Alive - Grace: Monk (good), Alive - Heidi: Mayor (good), Alive
Day 4
๐
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Alice has been found dead in the night.
๐ค
David
โ
Frank
Okay, Alice dead as Soldier. That's fine. We need to execute Heidi today. Bob will know Alice's role as Soldier now. We'll stick to the story: Grace protected me, demon tried to kill me, Eve died instead, so I'm good. Heidi's info from Eve is a lie because she's Spy. You're still Slayer. I'll push Heidi hard.
๐ง
Coordinate with Frank (Demon) to ensure we push Heidi execution today. Remind him of narrative and confirm our votes.
๐ค
Eve(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Grace
Frank, Grace: I am Eve, the Investigator. Night0 I learned either David or Heidi is the Spy. If Heidi's FT wording/timing holds, push David. If Heidi stumbles on exact phrasing/timing, escalate on her. Use that to force a contradiction.
๐ง
Tell trusted alive players my Investigator read and advise how to test Heidi vs David so they can drive a nomination toward the likeliest Minion.
๐ค
Bob
โ
David
,Heidi
I learned nothing as Undertaker nights 1-3. I need both of you to give me the exact verbatim Fortune Teller wording you used (including full phrase and time) and the exact nights/times Grace protected David. Keep it precise so we can spot contradictions.
๐ง
Get verbatim Fortune Teller phrasing and exact protection times to check consistency with Charlie/Eve claims and reveal contradictions that identify a liar or Demon.
๐ค
Alice(Ghost)
โ
Charlie(Ghost)
,Grace
Charlie and Grace: please confirm two things privately: Charlie, exactly how did David word his FT result (who did he say was the Demon)? Grace, did you protect David on Night 2 as you claimed?
๐ง
Confirm core contradictions about David's Fortune-Teller wording and Grace's protections to resolve whether David or Heidi is the likely Spy/Demon.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Grace
,Bob
Grace, please tell me exactly which nights you protected David (night numbers) and whether you protected him tonight and Night Two. Bob, confirm you learned nothing as Undertaker nights 1-3. Need exact wording to reconcile FT and Investigator claims.
๐ง
Get exact protection nights from Grace to reconcile conflicting FT and Investigator reads and decide who to nominate.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Frank
,Heidi
I am Monk. I protected Frank Night1, David Night2, and David Night3. Heidi, please restate your FT wording/timing exactly. Frank, confirm your N1 'shot' wording and whether anything else supports your claims.
๐ง
Reveal my night protections to trusted neighbors to let them check consistency with claimed Fortune Teller/Investigator info and steer nominations toward the most likely Demon.
๐ค
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
Grace
,Frank
Grace and Frank: I told Alice Night0 my FT on Bob+Eve returned YES. Eve died Night1, so Bob is our prime suspect. Grace: please confirmโdid you protect David Night2? If so, push to nominate Bob now. Frank: can you back this publicly?
๐ง
Confirm Grace's claimed Night2 protection and coordinate live players to nominate Bob if Grace confirms, narrowing suspects and forcing the Demon into the open.
๐ค
Frank
โ
David
Agreed on Heidi execution. I'll back you publicly. Grace seems to be believing us. We need to address Charlie's FT claim about Bobโmaybe say Charlie could be drunk or misremembering, but Heidi's Spy claim is more urgent.
๐ง
Coordinate with David privately to maintain our cover story, plan Heidi execution, and subtly steer Bob suspicion.
๐ค
David
โ
Frank
Alright, Bob wants precise wording. I'll tell him my FT info: 'N1 Alice and Frank: yes, N2 Frank: no, N3 nobody (or some safe pair).' Grace should say she protected me N2 after I whispered her my FT result. Heidi will likely mess up her phrasing. Stay firm. I'll nominate Heidi later.
๐ง
Coordinate with Frank and ensure he supports the exact story we've built. We'll use Bob's request to solidify our timeline and make Heidi slip.
๐ค
Eve(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Grace
Frank, Grace: I am Eve the Investigator. Night0 I learned David or Heidi is the Spy. Press Heidi now for exact FT wording and timing. If she reproduces Charlie's wording, push David at nomination. If she falters, escalate on Heidi. I will save my ghost vote.
๐ง
Coordinate a focused plan: press Heidi now for exact FT phrasing and timing; if she stands, nominate David; if she falters, nominate Heidi. Preserve my ghost vote for tie-break late.
๐ค
Bob
โ
David
,Heidi
I learned nothing as Undertaker nights 1-3. Give me the exact verbatim Fortune Teller wording you used (full phrase and time) and the exact nights/times Grace protected David. Be precise so we can spot any contradictions before nominations.
๐ง
Force exact, verbatim Fortune Teller wording and exact protection nights to find contradictions that identify the Demon before nominations.
๐ค
Alice(Ghost)
โ
Charlie(Ghost)
,Grace
Charlie: exactly how did David word his FT resultโdid he say 'one of Alice or Frank is the Demon' or did he explicitly name Frank as the Demon? Grace: did you protect David on Night 2 as you claimed? Please answer clearly.
๐ง
Clarify David's exact FT wording and confirm Grace's Night 2 protection to resolve contradictions and narrow Demon suspects before nominations.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Grace
,Bob
Grace: give exact verbatim nights you protected David (list night numbers and say explicitly if you protected him Night2 and Night3). Bob: confirm exactly (one sentence) that as Undertaker you learned nothing Nights1-3. Also paste verbatim any Fortune Teller wording you have (full phrase and time).
๐ง
We must get exact verbatim FT quotes and precise protection nights to catch contradictions before nominations; this narrows Demon possibilities.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Frank
,Heidi
Heidi: please give your exact Fortune Teller wording and exact night/time for that check. Frank: please confirm your Night1 'shot' wording exactly and any other evidence for your Slayer claim.
๐ง
Get Heidi's exact Fortune Teller wording/timing and Frank's exact Night1 'shot' phrasing to resolve FT/Investigator contradictions before nomination.
๐ค
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
Grace
,Frank
Grace: confirm nowโdid you protect David Night2? If yes, please say so publicly and push to nominate Bob. Frank: can you publicly back nominating Bob? My N0 FT on Bob+Eve was YES; Eve died Night1 so Bob is our prime suspect.
๐ง
Get Grace to publicly confirm her Night2 protection of David and get Frank to back a public nomination of Bob to focus town on our strongest suspect.
โ
Frank
Frank waits.
๐ง
Waiting to see Heidi's exact wording response to Grace. This will determine if we can catch her in a lie or if we need to adjust framing. Also seeing if Grace publicly confirms protecting David N2.
โ
David
David waits.
๐ง
Wait for Heidi's response to Bob's request; see if she slips. Let Bob scrutinize wording; don't jump too early. Keep pressure on Heidi indirectly.
โ
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
๐ง
Waiting preserves my ghost vote and lets others press Heidi now; observation will reveal who falters so my vote can be decisive at nomination.
๐ค
Bob
โ
David
,Heidi
I learned nothing nights 1-3 as Undertaker. Give your exact verbatim Fortune Teller wording (full phrase and time) and list exactly which nights Grace protected David (night numbers; say explicitly if Night2 and Night3). Be precise so we can spot contradictions.
๐ง
Get precise verbatim Fortune Teller wording and exact nights Grace protected David to expose contradictions and narrow Demon candidates before nominations.
๐ค
Alice(Ghost)
โ
Charlie(Ghost)
,Grace
Charlie: exactly how did David word his Fortune-Teller result โ did he explicitly name Frank as the Demon, or did he say 'one of Alice or Frank'? Grace: please confirm did you protect David on Night 2 as you claimed? Reply yes or no, clearly.
๐ง
Getting Charlie's exact wording and confirming Grace's N2 protection will let us determine if David or Charlie is lying and narrow Demon candidates.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Grace
,Bob
Grace: list exactly which nights you protected David (use night numbers) and explicitly say whether you protected him Night2 and Night3. Bob: confirm in one sentence that as Undertaker you learned nothing Nights1-3.
๐ง
I need exact, verbatim info from Grace and Bob to spot contradictions in FT/Investigator/Protection claims so we can nominate correctly.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Frank
,Heidi
I am the Monk. I protected Frank Night1, David Night2, and David Night3. Heidi, please restate your exact Fortune-Teller wording and which night you checked. Frank, please confirm your Night1 "shot" wording exactly and whether you will publicly back nominating Bob.
๐ง
Publicly confirm my protection nights and force Heidi/Frank to reproduce exact wording so group can spot contradictions and narrow Demon suspects.
๐ค
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
Grace
,Frank
Grace: did you protect David on Night2? Please say YES or NO publicly now and push nominating Bob if YES. Frank: can you publicly back nominating Bob? Also, Alice asked: David worded his FT as implicating neither Frank (he did NOT explicitly name Frank).
๐ง
Get Grace to publicly confirm Night2 protection and get Frank to publicly back nominating Bob, while clarifying David's FT wording for Alice.
๐ค
Frank
โ
David
Heidi is still alive per status. I'll support your push on her. Regarding Charlie's FT on Bob: we can say Charlie might be drunk or mistaken, and we need to prioritize the confirmed Spy. I'll publicly suggest that Heidi's FT claim contradicts Eve's Investigator info. I'll also back you on nominations.
๐ง
Coordinate with David to maintain story and steer group towards executing Heidi. Address Charlie's Bob claim but downplay to avoid diverting attention.
Nominations โ Day 4
๐
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
๐ฌ
Bob
โ
All
I am the Undertaker: I learned nothing Nights 1โ3. David and Heidi, give your exact verbatim Fortune Teller phrase and the exact time you claimed it. Grace, list exactly which nights you protected David (use night numbers and say explicitly if Night2 and Night3).
๐ง
Reveal exact Fortune Teller phrasing and Grace's protection nights to find contradictions and narrow the Demon before nominations.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
Alright, Bob. My Fortune Teller info: Night 1, I checked Alice and Frank. The phrase was 'yes, there is a Demon among these two.' Night 2, I checked Frank alone because I wanted to confirm him. The phrase was 'no, there is no Demon among these players.' Night 3, I checked Bob and Grace, and it was 'no.' I told Grace my N2 result privately before she chose to protect me Night 2, which is why she protected me. Heidi's story doesn't add upโEve said either me or Heidi is Spy, and my info proves I'm ...
๐ง
Establish my FT details publicly, back up Grace, and accuse Heidi of being the Spy based on Eve's info and contradictions. Set up for nomination.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
I agree with David. Eve's Investigator info from Night 0 said either David or Heidi is the Spy. David's Fortune Teller results have been consistent and match what Grace heard before protecting him. Heidi's story seems to shift. As Slayer, I targeted Alice Night 1 and got no effectโshe was Soldier. That fits. I think we should execute Heidi today.
๐ง
Publicly support David's framing of Heidi as Spy, using Eve's Investigator info to reinforce that Heidi is lying. This pressures town to execute Heidi, removing a threat and keeping my Minion safe.
๐ฌ
Alice(Ghost)
โ
All
Charlie, please quote David's Fortune Teller phrase verbatim as he spoke it to you. Grace, did you protect David on Night 2? Answer yes or no clearly. I have one ghost vote; I will use it based on your exact replies.
๐ง
Force clear, verbatim answers from Charlie and Grace so living players can resolve the David/Heidi conflict before night and guide my ghost vote.
๐ฌ
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
All
Alice โ verbatim as David told me: Night 1 he said, "Yes, there is a Demon among Alice and Frank." Night 2 he told me, "No, there is no Demon among these players." Grace has claimed she protected David on Night 2; she told me that and has said so publicly. Use your ghost vote accordingly.
๐ง
Provide Alice the verbatim phrases I heard and confirm Grace's claimed Night2 protection so Alice can decide how to use her ghost vote and pressure nominees.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
I will be clear: I protected Frank Night 1, and I protected David Night 2 and Night 3. Since I did protect David Night 2, I support nominating Bob now based on Charlie's Fortune-Teller N0 and Eve's death Night 1. Let's put Bob on the block.
๐ง
I must clear up exactly which nights I protected David so players can act on Charlie/Frank's push; then push a nomination to force votes and reveal inconsistencies.
โ๏ธ
Heidi
โ
Bob
Bob insists on verbatim quotes and demanded others' wording; he claims Undertaker saw nothing Nights1โ3. I am nominating to force clarity and test who defends him.
๐ง
Force a concrete vote to reveal who defends Bob and to pressure David/Frank/Grace into revealing contradictions; narrow suspects before night.
๐
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
๐ฌ
Bob
โ
All
I am the Undertaker and I learned nothing Nights one through three. Do not vote to execute me yetโexplain why you nominated me instead of resolving the verbatim contradictions. David, Heidi, Frank, Grace: give exact one-sentence quotes and times now so we can spot any lies.
๐ง
Buy time and force exact verbatim confirmations to expose contradictions so we do not mistakenly execute a Townsfolk.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
Heidi, why are you nominating Bob? Eve's info points to you or me as the Spy. I've given my exact Fortune Teller results. You're avoiding the real issue. If you're truly the Fortune Teller, prove it by explaining why your results aren't contradicting Eve's. Instead you're trying to get Bob executedโBob is the Undertaker claiming no info, which is plausible if no executions happened. This looks like a misdirection.
๐ง
Support Frank's push on Heidi by highlighting her suspicious nomination of Bob, and reinforce that Eve's info implicates Heidi. Keep my FT bluff consistent.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
I think we're getting off track. Eve's Investigator info from Night 0 is crucial: either David or Heidi is the Spy. David's Fortune Teller results have been consistent and shared with Grace before protections. Heidi's story is the one shifting. Executing Heidi resolves the Spy question and matches the Investigator info. I'm not voting for Bob yetโlet's hear Heidi's exact Fortune Teller wording first.
๐ง
Keep pressure on Heidi to get her executed, reinforcing David's fake FT claim and my Slayer bluff. Use Eve's Investigator info to argue Heidi is Spy. I will not vote for Bob yet.
โ
Alice(Ghost)
Alice raised their hand
๐ง
Use my single ghost vote now to support the nomination and force a decision; this pressures players and may reveal who defends Bob or Heidi.
๐ฌ
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
All
Bob was my Night 0 FT result: Bob or Eve was Demon. Eve died Night 1. That points to Bob. We dead told Grace and Alice to push Bob. Execute Bob or explain clearly why my FT is wrong now.
๐ง
Push the table to execute Bob now based on my Night0 FT and Eve's death; force others to reveal contradictions before night.
โ
Grace
Grace raised their hand
๐ง
I want to add my vote to get Bob executed now to force reveals and narrow suspects; my public protection nights support Bob nomination and pressure liars to show themselves.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
I nominated Bob to force exact verbatim quotes and stop this circling. Bob, confirm in one sentence you learned nothing Nights 1โ3 as Undertaker. David, repeat your Fortune-Teller phrases exactly as you told each player and say which night each was. Grace, confirm again: you protected David Night 2 and Night 3, yes or no?
๐ง
Nominating Bob pressures players to give exact verbatim quotes so contradictions become obvious and the liar can be exposed before night.
๐ฌ
Eve(Ghost)
โ
All
I am Eve, the dead Investigator. My Night 0 result was that either David or Heidi is the Spy, so one of them is a Minion, not the Demon. I will not use my ghost vote on Bob now; I am saving it for final three. Heidi and David, give exact verbatim FT lines and nights immediately.
๐ง
Preserve my single ghost vote for the final day when it will most likely decide between Demon candidates; push for precise FT wording from Heidi and David now.
๐ฌ
Bob
โ
All
I confirm: as Undertaker I learned nothing Nights one through three. Do not execute me yet. David and Heidi, post the exact one-sentence Fortune-Teller phrases you gave each player and the exact night numbers. Grace, confirm explicitly: did you protect David on Night two and Night three? Answer verbatim now.
๐ง
Get exact verbatim Fortune Teller phrases and protection nights now, and stop a premature execution of me until contradictions are resolved.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
Heidi, you're ignoring Eve's Investigator info. She said either you or I am the Spy. My Fortune Teller story is consistent and Grace confirmed she protected me based on it. You're pushing Bob who has a plausible claim, while avoiding the real issue. This feels like you're trying to misdirect the town away from yourself.
๐ง
Undermine Heidi's nomination of Bob, reinforce Eve's info points to Heidi as Spy, and guide town back to executing Heidi today.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
Look, Heidi is deflecting. Eve's Investigator info from Night 0 is the key: either David or Heidi is the Spy. David's Fortune Teller results are consistent and Grace protected him based on that. Heidi's story shifts and she's now nominating Bob instead of addressing the contradiction. I think we should execute Heidi today. Charlie's FT on Bob might be unreliable; he could be drunk or poisoned.
๐ง
Reinforce our frame: Eve's Investigator info says Heidi or David is Spy. David's FT results are 'consistent' (they're fabricated). I'll point out Heidi's evasiveness and push for her execution, while casting doubt on Charlie's FT as possibly drunk.
๐ฌ
Alice(Ghost)
โ
All
I will not vote to execute Bob. We are circlingโforce David and Heidi to post exact verbatim Fortune-Teller lines and nights now. Charlie and Eve, re-quote what you heard from David. If Heidi cannot match, she is the suspect. Save votes for final three.
๐ง
My ghost vote is valuable late. I want to prevent a premature execution of Bob and push the town to force verbatim FT quotes from David/Heidi so contradictions reveal a Spy or Demon.
๐ฌ
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
All
David and Heidi, repeat now exactly the one-sentence Fortune-Teller phrases you told each player and the night number for each. Grace, confirm: you protected David on Night 2 and Night 3, yes or no. Everyone else, please hold votes until these verbatim lines are posted so we can catch any contradictions.
๐ง
Force exact verbatim FT quotes from David and Heidi and confirm Grace's protections so town can spot contradictions before any execution.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
I will be clear and short: I protected Frank Night 1, and I protected David Night 2 and Night 3. Because I did protect David Night 2, I support nominating Bob now โ Charlie's N0 FT plus Eve's death point at Bob. Vote Bob so we force clarity and expose contradictions.
๐ง
Be explicit about my protections and force clarity; push the group to commit votes so contradictions surface and we can find the Demon.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
David and Heidi, paste the exact one-sentence Fortune-Teller phrase you told each person and the night number for each now. Bob, confirm in one sentence you learned nothing Nights 1โ3 as Undertaker. Grace, confirm explicitly: you protected David Night 2 and Night 3, yes or no? Everyone else, please hold votes until these verbatim lines are posted so contradictions are catchable.
๐ง
Force exact verbatim FT lines and protection nights now so contradictions are exposed; get clarity before any execution and encourage others to hold votes until replies.
โ
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
๐ง
I am a dead Investigator saving my ghost vote. Waiting forces living players to produce verbatim FT lines; preserves my vote for final-3 execution.
๐
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
๐ป
Alice(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Alice
๐ณ๏ธ
Nominee Bob did not reach threshold.
๐
Storyteller
Bob did not receive enough votes (2/3).
๐ฌ
Bob
โ
All
I confirm I learned nothing Nights one through three as Undertaker. David and Heidi, post the exact one-sentence Fortune-Teller phrase you told each player and the night number for each now. Grace, confirm again: did you protect David Night 2 and Night 3, yes or no?
๐ง
Force David and Heidi to post exact Fortune-Teller verbatim lines and have Grace reconfirm protection nights so we catch any contradictions and avoid misexecuting an innocent.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
Here are my exact Fortune Teller phrases and nights. Night 1: I told Grace 'Alice and Frank might be the Demon'. Night 2: I told Grace 'Frank might not be the Demon'. I told Grace before her Night 2 protection. That's consistent. Heidi, now you share yours.
๐ง
Provide clear FT phrases and nights to maintain my bluff and keep suspicion on Heidi, while supporting Grace's protection claims.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
David gave his exact Fortune Teller phrases, and Grace confirmed she protected him Nights 2 and 3 based on that. Heidi, you're stalling. Eve's Investigator info says you or David is the Spy, and David's story checks out. We need to execute Heidi today to resolve the Minion slot. Charlie's FT on Bob can waitโHeidi is the immediate threat.
๐ง
Reinforce David's framing of Heidi as Spy, using Eve's Investigator info and Grace's Monk protection confirmations. Push for Heidi's execution to eliminate a Minion who could expose us and solidify town's trust in David.
๐ฌ
Alice(Ghost)
โ
All
I am Alice's ghost. Do not rush to execute Bob. Heidi and David, post the exact one-sentence Fortune-Teller phrases you told each player and the night number now. Grace, confirm you protected David Nights two and three, yes or no. If Heidi cannot match verbatim, she should be the nomination target.
๐ง
Force David/Heidi to post exact FT phrases and nights to catch contradictions; if Heidi cannot match, push town to nominate her to resolve the Minion/Demon conflict.
๐ฌ
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
All
Heidi and David, post your exact one-sentence Fortune-Teller phrases and the night number for each now. Grace, confirm: did you protect David Nights 2 and 3, yes or no? Everyone else, hold votes until we have verbatim answers.
๐ง
Force exact verbatim FT lines and protection confirmations to catch contradictions, avoid misexecution, and narrow Demon/Minion candidates.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
I confirm: I protected Frank Night one, and I protected David Night two and Night three. I am Town and backed David's FT when I protected him Night two. Please post exact verbatim Fortune-Teller lines now; hold votes until we have them so contradictions expose the Spy.
๐ง
Confirm my protections publicly to prove I'm Town and push for verbatim FT lines before executing; this narrows suspects and prevents a rushed wrong execution.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
I will keep this short. Eve's Investigator N0 ties either David or me to the Spy slot โ that is critical. David, post every exact one-sentence Fortune Teller phrase you said and the night number for each now. Bob, confirm in one sentence you learned nothing Nights 1โ3. Grace, confirm yes or no: did you protect David Night 2 and Night 3? Hold votes until we have these verbatim lines.
๐ง
Force exact verbatim FT lines and clear confirmations from David, Grace, and Bob to produce a logical contradiction and narrow Demon/Spy down before night.
๐ฌ
Eve(Ghost)
โ
All
I am Eve's ghost Investigator. My N0 read: either David or Heidi is the Spy. David and Heidi, post the exact one-sentence Fortune-Teller phrase you told each person and the night number for each now. Grace, confirm: did you protect David Night 2 and Night 3, yes or no? I am saving my ghost vote for final three.
๐ง
Force David and Heidi to post exact one-sentence Fortune-Teller lines and nights to reveal any contradiction with my N0 Investigator read that one of them is a Minion.
๐
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 4
๐
Storyteller
โ
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
๐ฏ
Grace
Grace made a choice.
๐ง
Protect David to preserve the Fortune Teller claim and force the Demon to reveal or fail to kill our town's key information source.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Grace
You chose to protect David.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
๐ฏ
Frank
Frank made a choice.
๐ง
Bob is the safer kill. Removing Bob eliminates Undertaker who could learn executed roles (Heidi's Spy death) and pushes town to possibly mis-execute Grace or David next day. Bob's death also validates Charlie's FT claim, making town trust a dead FT who might be drunk/poisoned.
๐
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Frank
You chose to kill Bob.
๐
Storyteller
โ
David
Good evening David. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Soldier (good), Dead - Bob: Undertaker (good), Dead - Charlie: Drunk (good), Dead (Told they are Fortune Teller) - David: Spy (evil), Alive (Protected) - Eve: Investigator (good), Dead - Frank: Imp (evil), Alive - Grace: Monk (good), Alive - Heidi: Mayor (good), Alive
Day 5
๐
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
๐ค
Alice(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Grace
Frank, Grace: David's FT lines and Charlie's parroting look coordinated. Ask David for exact verbatim FT lines now and push to nominate him if he refuses or contradictions appear. We need to force clarity before nominations.
๐ง
Push alive players to demand verbatim FT wording from David and to concentrate suspicion on him for nomination; narrow suspects before final day.
๐ค
David
โ
Frank
,Grace
Heidi is the Spy. Eve's info said me or Heidi, and I've been town. Heidi is lying, I'm real Fortune Teller. Grace, keep protecting me.
๐ง
To coordinate with Frank (Imp) and Grace (Monk) to solidify my claim, undermine Heidi, and ensure Grace continues protecting me.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Grace
Hi Frank and Grace. I was the Undertaker and died N4. David posted verbatim FT linesโwhat exactly did he claim and when did he say he told Grace N2? If his timing or lines look fake, please consider nominating David at end of day.
๐ง
Get confirmation of David's exact FT lines and timing, and coordinate living players to nominate David if his claim looks fabricated.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Frank
Frank: push David to post exact verbatim Fortune Teller lines and the nights he said them now. If he refuses or contradictions appear, I will nominate David at end of day โ will you back that nomination?
๐ง
Get Frank aligned to force David to post exact FT verbatim lines now and commit to nominating him if he cannot produce exact timing/quotes.
๐ค
Eve(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Grace
I was the Investigator. At start I learned either David or Heidi is the Spy. Use that: pressure Heidi for exact FT lines now; if she falters execute her, if she matches, escalate on David. I am saving my ghost vote for final three.
๐ง
Tell Frank and Grace my Investigator start-info (David or Heidi is the Spy) so they coordinate nominations and pressure Heidi for verbatim FT, saving ghost vote for final three.
๐ค
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Grace
I was FT N0: Bob+Eve = YES. Eve died Night1 so Bob was suspect. David's public 'verbatim' lines smell off. Demand he posts exact Night1 and Night2 phrasing now. If he can't or it mismatches, we should nominate David.
๐ง
Get Frank and Grace to demand David post exact Night1/2 FT verbatim now and coordinate nominating David if he cannot or if his lines mismatch.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Grace
Grace, I agree. Let's pressure David publicly for exact verbatim lines now. If he can't provide them or they contradict, I'll back your nomination. We need to resolve this before nominations.
๐ง
Coordinate with Grace to pressure David, making him look suspicious. If David gets executed, we reach final two and evil wins. I must support the push against David while maintaining my Slayer bluff.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
David
,Grace
David, GraceโI need your exact verbatim Fortune Teller lines posted publicly now, word for word, so we can settle Eve's Investigator implication. Please do not vote to execute Heidi this nomination; agree to hold until quotes are on the table.
๐ง
Get David and Grace to post exact verbatim FT lines now and agree to hold votes so we can expose contradictions and avoid executing a townie.
๐ค
Alice(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Grace
Frank, Grace: David and Charlie's matching FT phrasing looks coordinated. Ask David for his exact verbatim FT lines for Nights1โ3 in public now. If he refuses or words differ from Charlie's posts, push to nominate David at deadline. We need clarity before nominations.
๐ง
Get Frank and Grace to demand David post exact verbatim FT lines now and threaten nomination if he refuses, forcing clarity before nominations.
โ
David
David waits.
๐ง
Observe first. Heidi is pushing for quotes; I can delay or refuse, claiming I wrote them down privately. Let others react.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Grace
Hi Frank and Grace. I was the Undertaker and died N4. David posted verbatim FT linesโwhat exactly did he claim and when did he say he told Grace N2? If his timing or lines look fake, please consider nominating David at end of day.
๐ง
Get Frank and Grace to confirm David's exact FT lines and timing so contradictions can be used to nominate him if false.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Frank
Frank: push David publicly for his exact, verbatim Fortune Teller lines and the nights he said them right now. If he cannot post them or they differ from Charlie's quotes, back my nomination of David at the deadline. Are you firmly with that plan?
๐ง
Force David to post exact verbatim FT lines now and secure Frank's public backing to nominate him if his lines mismatch or he refuses, narrowing suspects before nominations.
๐ค
Eve(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Grace
Reminder: I was Investigator and saw either David or Heidi is the Spy. Press Heidi now for exact FT one-sentence quotes and night numbers. If she slips, execute her; if she nails them, escalate on David. I am saving my ghost vote for final three.
๐ง
Reinforce plan: force Heidi to reproduce exact Fortune-Teller lines; if she fails, execute her; if she succeeds, focus on David. Remind them I save ghost vote for final three.
๐ค
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Grace
Push David to post his exact Night1 and Night2 Fortune-Teller phrases right now. If he cannot or they mismatch my N0 wording, we should nominate David. Bob's death and my N0 implicate the Demonโlet's force clarity before nominations.
๐ง
Force David to produce exact Night1 and Night2 Fortune-Teller phrasing to expose deception. If he cannot or it mismatches, push nomination to remove the likely Demon.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Grace
Okay Grace, Iโll back your play. Letโs both ask David publicly for his exact Fortune Teller lines for Nights 1 through 3 right now. If he refuses or contradicts Charlie, you nominate and Iโll vote. That should force clarity.
๐ง
Coordinate with Grace to maintain our public stance of being good players suspicious of David. This keeps our cover solid and directs town away from me.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
David
,Grace
David, GraceโI need your exact verbatim Fortune Teller lines posted publicly now, word for word, so Eve's Investigator implication can be settled. Also please do not vote to execute me this nomination; agree to hold until the quotes are on the table.
๐ง
Get exact Fortune Teller verbatim lines and secure a hold on execution votes so Eve's Investigator clue can be properly resolved before any nomination proceeds.
๐ค
Alice(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Grace
Frank, Grace: push David now for exact verbatim FT lines for Nights 1โ3 publicly. If he refuses or the words differ from Charlie's posts/timeline, call to nominate him at deadline. We need to force a contradiction or get him on record.
๐ง
Force David to post exact verbatim FT lines publicly so contradictions or refusal give us grounds to nominate him before deadline.
๐ค
David
โ
Frank
,Grace
Heidi is trying to force me to recite exact words because she knows I'm the real Fortune Teller and wants to find a discrepancy. But the Storyteller phrases varyโI won't play her game. She's the Spy, using Eve's info to frame me. Grace, you've protected me twice, you know I'm good. We need to execute Heidi today.
๐ง
Heidi is pressing for verbatim quotes to expose my fake Fortune Teller claim. I need to refuse and redirect suspicion onto her to protect Frank and myself.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Grace
Hi Frank and Grace. I was Undertaker and died N4. David posted verbatim FT linesโwhat exactly did he claim, and when did he say he told Grace N2? If his timing or lines look fake, please consider nominating David at end of day.
๐ง
Clarify David's exact Fortune-Teller lines and claimed timing to test his story; push for nominating him if his timing or wording is impossible.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Frank
Frank: push David publicly for exact verbatim FT lines and night numbers now. If he refuses or his words differ from Charlie, I will nominate David at deadlineโwill you vote with me?
๐ง
Coordinate with Frank to pressure David for exact FT one-sentence quotes and night numbers now; commit to nominate David at deadline if he refuses or his wording contradicts Charlie.
๐ค
Eve(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Grace
I was Investigator; I saw either David or Heidi is the Spy. Pressure Heidi now for exact Fortune-Teller one-sentence quotes and the night numbers. If she slips, execute her; if she nails them, escalate on David. I am keeping my ghost vote for final three.
๐ง
Push Frank and Grace to pressure Heidi for exact Fortune-Teller one-sentence quotes and night numbers now to force a contradiction or prove her truthful so we can pivot to David.
๐ค
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Grace
Push David to post his exact Night1 and Night2 Fortune-Teller phrases now, word-for-word. I remember Night1: 'Alice and Frank might be the Demon.' and Night2: 'Frank might not be the Demon.' If his wording differs, we should nominate David immediately.
๐ง
Forcing David to post exact Night1/2 FT phrasing will reveal consistency with my Night0 memory and help pin the Demon or expose a liar fast.
โ
Frank
Frank waits.
๐ง
Evaluate the state: 4 alive, only David and I are evil. We need to get a good player executed today to reach final 3 with 2 evil. The pressure is on David to recite exact lines; we must steer town to execute Heidi instead.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
David
,Grace
David, GraceโI need your exact verbatim Fortune Teller lines posted publicly now, word for word, so we can settle Eve's Investigator implication. Please do not vote to execute Heidi this nomination; agree to hold until quotes are on the table.
๐ง
Forcing public verbatim Fortune Teller quotes will resolve Eve's Investigator implication and stop the premature push to execute me; buying time to analyze contradictions.
Nominations โ Day 5
๐
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
I was the Undertaker and died Night Four. David posted verbatim Fortune Teller linesโFrank and Grace, when exactly did he say he told Grace N2? If his timing or lines look wrong, nominate David tonight.
๐ง
Push live players to scrutinize David's FT claim timing; as a ghost my vote can help if suspicion holds, forcing clarity before nominations close.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
David, Grace: post your exact Fortune Teller and protection lines word for word now. Everyone else: please hold votes on Heidi this nomination until those quotes are public so we can settle Eve's Investigator implication.
๐ง
Forcing exact verbatim Fortune Teller lines and asking for a pause on executing me will resolve Eve's Investigator implication and reveal inconsistencies to find the Demon.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
I'm not giving exact phrases because the Storyteller's wording can vary, and Heidi knows that. She's using this as a distraction because Eve's info points to her or me, and I know I'm good. Grace has protected me twiceโwhy would she protect me if I were evil? Heidi is the Spy, and we need to execute her.
๐ง
Refuse to give exact lines to maintain spy bluff, redirect suspicion onto Heidi, pressure Grace to support me.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
I agree with David. The Storyteller's phrasing can vary, and Heidi is trying to trap him. Grace has protected David multiple nights โ if David were evil, Grace wouldn't keep protecting him. Heidi is the Spy, and we should execute her.
๐ง
Push the narrative that Heidi is the Spy, support David publicly to maintain my good standing and avoid suspicion as Demon. If we execute Heidi, we win.
๐ฌ
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
All
David, post your exact Night1 and Night2 Fortune-Teller phrases word-for-word now. I told Grace and Alice my Night0 line was 'Bob and Eve: yes.' If your wording differs from what Grace and I heard, we should nominate you tonight.
๐ง
Force David to give verbatim FT lines now so we can check them against my and Grace's memory; if they mismatch, justify nominating him tonight.
๐ฌ
Alice(Ghost)
โ
All
Frank, Grace, David, Heidi: demand the exact Night1 and Night2 Fortune-Teller phrases and Grace's protection wording now. Living players, do not vote on Heidi until those verbatim quotes are public. If David refuses or his words differ from Grace/Charlie, nominate David tonight.
๐ง
Force David to post exact FT lines now so living players can catch contradictions. If he refuses or differs from Grace/Charlie, push to nominate him to narrow the Demon.
๐ฌ
Eve(Ghost)
โ
All
Frank, Grace, Charlie: keep demanding Heidi and David post the exact one-sentence FT lines and the exact protection wording and nights now. Do not use my ghost vote yet. If Heidi slips, nominate her tonight; if she nails it, escalate on David.
๐ง
Push living players to demand verbatim FT and protection lines, avoid premature voting on Heidi, preserve my ghost vote for final three.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
David: please post your exact Fortune-Teller lines for Night1 and Night2, word for word, and say when you told me Night2. If your wording differs from Charlie and my memory, I will nominate you at the deadline. We need these verbatim quotes now to resolve Eve's read.
๐ง
Force David to post exact Fortune-Teller lines and timing now; if he refuses or contradicts Charlie/Grace, I will nominate him to break the stalemate and protect town.
๐
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 5
๐
Storyteller
โ
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
๐ฏ
Grace
Grace made a choice.
๐ง
Preserve David so he can either provide the verbatim Fortune-Teller quotes we need or reveal himself by refusing; maintain information flow and avoid wasting ghosts' final votes.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Grace
You chose to protect David.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
๐ฏ
Frank
Frank made a choice.
๐ง
Grace is a confirmed Monk protecting David, making him look trustworthy. Removing her kills his protection alibi and reduces town's confirmed good players. Sets up final three with David and Heidi, where I can frame Heidi.
๐
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Frank
You chose to kill Grace.
๐
Storyteller
โ
David
Good evening David. You are the Spy. You can secretly see information about all players: - Alice: Soldier (good), Dead - Bob: Undertaker (good), Dead - Charlie: Drunk (good), Dead (Told they are Fortune Teller) - David: Spy (evil), Alive (Protected) - Eve: Investigator (good), Dead - Frank: Imp (evil), Alive - Grace: Monk (good), Dead - Heidi: Mayor (good), Alive
Day 6
๐
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Grace has been found dead in the night.
๐
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
๐ค
Eve(Ghost)
โ
David
,Frank
David, Frank โ this is Eve (dead). I started as Investigator and knew either David or Heidi was the Spy. Given the arguments and pushes, I think Frank is the Demon. Please nominate and execute Frank now; my ghost vote will back it.
๐ง
Push living players to nominate and execute Frank so my ghost vote can finish the Demon and end the game.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Heidi
This is Bob, dead Undertaker. I learned nothing from executions earlier. Ghosts want David to post verbatim FT lines; if he will not, we should execute him today. Demand the exact quotes now or vote David. We cannot leave this vague.
๐ง
Push living players to demand verbatim Fortune-Teller quotes and to vote David if he refuses; narrow suspects to force a final-day execution.
๐ค
Grace(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Heidi
I am Grace (dead Monk). I protected David nights 2โ5 and died Night5. Use my ghost vote wisely: demand David post exact FT lines now. If he refuses or they mismatch Charlie's, we should execute him. Please coordinate.
๐ง
Get the two living players aligned to demand David post exact Fortune Teller quotes now, or to consider nominating if he refuses, so we converge on the Demon before final execution.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
David
,Frank
David, post your exact Fortune Teller quotes for N1โN3 now or I will nominate you. Frank, if David does not post exact verbatim quotes that match Charlie and Grace, please vote with me. This is final three; we must execute the Demon today.
๐ง
Force David to produce the exact Fortune Teller verbatim now so we can decide; align Frank with me to secure the execution if David refuses.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Heidi
Heidi, I agree โ David should post his exact Fortune Teller lines. If heโs good, he should have them memorized. But letโs not rush execution; we need to compare with Charlieโs ghost info. If they mismatch, weโll know. Iโll vote with you if theyโre wrong.
๐ง
Keep suspicion on David while positioning myself as cooperative Good player. Whisper to Heidi to agree with her demand, but plant doubt that David might be Good Fortune Teller being framed.
๐ค
Alice(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Heidi
We are at final three. Demand David post verbatim Night1โ2 FT lines and any protection wording now. If he refuses or wording differs from Charlie's posts, nominate David at deadline. If David matches, shift focus and nominate Frank.
๐ง
Force living players to demand verbatim FT/protection wording now and commit to nominating whoever fails to match; narrow suspects to execute the Demon.
โ
David
David waits.
๐ง
I need to decide how to respond to Heidi's ultimatum and coordinate with Frank to secure the win. Waiting to see Frank's response first.
๐ค
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Heidi
I was FT. My N0 read on Bob+Eve was 'YES' and I told Alice/Grace before I died. David's public wording has been inconsistent with that. We are final three: force David to post exact N1/N2 wording now or we should execute him. Don't let this slip.
๐ง
Push the living pair to prioritize executing David now by highlighting inconsistencies and the urgency of final-3; force a decision.
๐ค
Eve(Ghost)
โ
David
,Frank
David, Frank โ this is Eve. I started as Investigator and knew either David or Heidi was the Spy. I believe Frank is the Demon. Please nominate and execute Frank now; my ghost vote will back it.
๐ง
Force a final-day nomination onto the player I suspect most strongly so my ghost vote helps secure a win.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Heidi
This is Bob, dead Undertaker. I learned nothing from executions earlier. We are final three. Ghosts demand David post his verbatim Fortune-Teller lines and Grace's protection wording now. If he will not, we must execute him today. Please commit to voting David if he refuses.
๐ง
Force a decisive action at final three: either David posts verbatim FT quotes proving his claim, or we execute him. Push Frank and Heidi to commit to voting David if he refuses.
๐ค
Grace(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Heidi
I am Grace (dead Monk). I protected David nights 2โ5 and died Night5. Demand David post the exact verbatim Fortune Teller lines now. If he refuses or they mismatch Charlie's, use my ghost vote to execute him. Do not let them delay.
๐ง
Force a quick verbatim quote from David to resolve the Charlie/David conflict and give my ghost vote to execute if he refuses or quotes mismatch.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
David
,Frank
David, post your exact Fortune Teller quotes for N1โN3 and the exact protection wording Grace claimed now. If you refuse or they mismatch Charlie/Grace, we will nominate and vote you. Frank, be ready to vote with me.
๐ง
Forcing David to post exact FT quotes will either prove his claim or provide grounds to execute him today, securing a Town win.
๐ค
Frank
โ
David
David, this is critical. The ghosts demand verbatim Fortune Teller lines for N1, N2, N3, and Grace's protection wording. I know you're trying, but you must post them exactly as the Storyteller told you. I want to believe you're good, but if you can't provide them or they mismatch Charlie's, I'll have to vote you. Please do it now.
๐ง
Join the ghost pressure on David to appear cooperative, then when he posts quotes, I'll find fault and vote him. Sacrifice David to secure final 3 with Heidi, who likely will vote with me.
๐ค
Alice(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Heidi
Final three now. Demand David post verbatim Night1โ2 FT lines and exact protection wording immediately. If his wording differs or he refuses, nominate David at deadline. If he matches Charlie/Grace exactly, then we shift and nominate Frank. Stick to this plan.
๐ง
Push final-three plan: force verbatim FT now to create a decisive contradiction. If David fails, execute him; if he matches, shift execution to Frank.
๐ค
David
โ
Heidi
,Frank
Alright, fine. Night one: 'David, you are the Fortune Teller. You are woken up and choose two players. You learn that one of them might be the Demon.' Night two: 'David, you are the Fortune Teller. You are woken up and choose two players. You learn that neither of them is the Demon.' Night three: 'David, you are the Fortune Teller. You are woken up and choose two players. You learn that one of them might be the Demon.' Grace's protection: 'David, you are the Monk. You are woken up and choose a p...
๐ง
Stall Heidi's nomination by providing fabricated Fortune Teller quotes. Protect Frank and maintain my bluff.
๐ค
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Heidi
David, post your exact Night1 and Night2 Fortune Teller wording now or we execute you. Frank, Heidi โ back me and demand verbatim quotes. We are final three; this is decisive.
๐ง
Force David to post exact Night1/Night2 FT phrasing now to catch contradictions and justify executing him if he lies; pressure Frank and Heidi to back the call.
๐ค
Eve(Ghost)
โ
David
,Frank
David, Frank โ Eve (dead). I was Investigator and knew either David or Heidi was the Spy. I still believe Frank is the Demon. Nominate and execute Frank now; my ghost vote will back it.
๐ง
Force a final-day execution on the player I suspect most, using my ghost vote to guarantee support and break the deadlock.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Heidi
This is Bob, dead Undertaker. Ghosts demand David post verbatim FT Night1/Night2 lines and Grace's protection wording now. If he refuses, commit to voting David. We are final three; no vagueness or we lose.
๐ง
Force a binary: David posts exact FT lines now or we must execute him. Secure commitment from Frank and Heidi to vote David if he refuses, to avoid vague debate in final three.
๐ค
Grace(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Heidi
I am Grace (dead Monk). I protected David nights 2โ5 and died Night5. Demand David post exact verbatim Fortune Teller lines now. If he refuses or they mismatch Charlie's, use my ghost vote to execute him. Do not let them delay.
๐ง
Force living players to demand verbatim FT quotes now and use my ghost vote to execute David if he refuses or the quotes conflict with Charlie's, narrowing the Demon.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
David
,Frank
David, finish posting the exact verbatim Fortune Teller lines for Nights1โ3 and the full exact protection wording Grace claimed right now. If your wording does not exactly match Charlie/Grace, Frank and I will nominate and vote you. Frank, be ready to vote with me.
๐ง
Force a decisive public match/mismatch of David's exact wording now so we can legally and confidently nominate and execute the Demon today.
โ
Frank
Frank waits.
๐ง
Wait to see David's full post and Heidi's reaction. If David's lines are convincing, I'll pivot to blame Heidi as drunk or Spy. If David's lines are flawed, I'll vote with Heidi to execute David, securing final 3 win.
๐ค
Alice(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Heidi
Final three. Demand David post verbatim Night1โ2 FT lines and exact protection wording now. If his wording differs or he refuses, nominate David at deadline. If he matches Charlie/Grace exactly, shift and nominate Frank. Stick to this.
๐ง
Push final plan: demand verbatim FT and protection wording now, and confirm nomination target depending on match to catch Demon at final three.
๐ค
David
โ
Heidi
,Frank
Night three: 'David, you are the Fortune Teller. You are woken up and choose two players. You learn that one of them might be the Demon.' Grace's protection: 'David, you are the Monk. You are woken up and choose a player. That player is safe from the Demon tonight.' Now, Heidi, this obsession with exact phrasing is exactly what a Demon would do. You're ignoring logical deductions and trying to catch me on semantics. I think you're the Demon.
๐ง
I need to finish my quote to buy time, but I must pivot to attacking Heidi. I'll provide a plausible Fortune Teller quote for Night 3 and then accuse Heidi of being the Demon for pushing for exact wording instead of logic.
๐ค
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Heidi
This is final three. Demand David post his exact Night1 and Night2 Fortune Teller wording verbatim now. If he cannot, we execute him. Back me so we can force a clean decision.
๐ง
Forcing David to post exact Night1/Night2 Fortune Teller wording now will either expose him as the Demon (if he lies/contradicts) or clear him, allowing us to target the real Demon.
Nominations โ Day 6
๐
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
โ๏ธ
Heidi
โ
David
Final three โ ghosts and Charlie say Davidโs FT wording mismatches; he refused exact verbatim quotes until pressured. He will not or cannot produce exact quotes, so we must execute him now.
๐ง
Force a decisive final-three vote now. If David cannot or will not provide exact, ghosts' contradictions make him most suspicious; executing him clears the game.
๐
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
โ
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
๐ง
Secure the second vote to execute David now to prevent the Demon from surviving final three and to follow unanimous ghost evidence.
โ
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
๐ง
Use my single ghost vote to help reach the majority and execute the most suspicious player before night. Final three, we cannot afford ambiguity.
โ
Grace(Ghost)
Grace raised their hand
๐ง
Use my single ghost vote to reach the required two and force an execution today; final three requires decisive action to try to remove the Demon.
๐ฌ
Eve(Ghost)
โ
All
I am the Investigator. Night zero I learned that either David or Heidi is the Spy. In either case the Demon is Frank. Do not execute David. If we let him die now we lose โ we must execute Frank.
๐ง
Reveal Investigator info to stop the group executing the wrong player and force them to target Frank, the true Demon.
๐ฌ
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
All
Frank, this is final three. We must decide now. David has refused verbatim Night1/Night2 Fortune Teller wording that I told Alice and Grace. If he will not post the exact quotes now, vote David โ your hand is the deciding vote. Heidi has already voted; you choose.
๐ง
Force a decisive public action: demand David post exact Night1/Night2 FT wording now or secure votes to execute him. This either exposes a lie or forces the real Demon to be revealed.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
Hold on a second, everyone. Heidi, you're pushing really hard on exact wording, but David posted lines. The ghosts are giving conflicting signalsโEve says I'm the Demon, Charlie says David is lying. I want to hear from David one more time: what exactly were your Night 1 and Night 2 Fortune Teller lines, the full wording you received. David, just post them now so we can put this to rest.
๐ง
I need to sow confusion and avoid committing my vote too early. By speaking publicly, I can question Heidi's logic and buy time while keeping my options open.
๐ฌ
Alice(Ghost)
โ
All
Frank, this is final three. Ghosts report David's FT wording mismatches and he refuses verbatim quotes. Stick to the plan โ vote David now. We need action, not more debate.
๐ง
Push the living swing vote (Frank) to execute David now so we either kill the Demon or force reveals; keep to final-three plan to avoid losing by inaction.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
Frank, think about this. Eve claims you're the Demon, but she's dead and could be lying. Heidi is pushing hard on exact wording because she knows ghosts can't verify perfectly. My Fortune Teller info has been consistentโI gave you the quotes. If Heidi is Mayor, executing her leaves two of us alive, evil wins. If she's the Demon, executing her loses. But I'm not the Demon. I'm the Fortune Teller. Frank, you need to vote Heidi.
๐ง
We are in final three; I need to convince Frank (Imp) to vote Heidi. I must deflect suspicion from myself and paint Heidi as the demon. Eve's claim that Frank is Demon is dangerous; I need to discredit Eve.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
Frank, stop and listen. If no execution happens today and three of us remain, the Mayor wins and we immediately win. Do not vote. Withdraw your hand so we avoid a risky executionโthis is the cleanest path to victory.
๐ง
Convince Frank to not vote so there is no execution today and the Mayor condition triggers an immediate Town win.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
Frank, you are the swing vote. Ghosts and multiple memories say David's wording mismatches and he refuses verbatim quotes. This is final three โ we need action. Vote David now; do not let him stall us with hypotheticals.
๐ง
Push living Decider (Frank) to cast the decisive vote now to break paralysis; avoid the Mayor-stall that lets evil win.
๐ฌ
Grace(Ghost)
โ
All
Frank, Heidi, I protected David nights two through five and died Night Five. David, post your exact Night One and Night Two Fortune Teller quotes now. I will keep my vote for David if you refuse or they do not match Charlie's.
๐ง
Force David to post verbatim FT lines now and commit my ghost vote to stop delay; this pressures a resolution and narrows who the Demon can be.
๐ฌ
Eve(Ghost)
โ
All
I am Eve, Investigator. Night zero I learned either David or Heidi is the Spy. In either case the Demon is Frank. Do not vote David. Frank, do not let the ghosts decide by panicโvote Frank or abstain so we can win.
๐ง
Convince living players not to execute David and to instead target Frank so Town can win at final three.
๐ฌ
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
All
Frank, this is final three. Ghosts and I heard different Night1/2 FT wording from David and he refuses to post verbatim. You are the swing voteโif he will not produce the exact quotes now, vote David. We need action, not more stalling.
๐ง
Pressure Frank to use his deciding vote now to execute David if David refuses to produce exact Night1/Night2 Fortune Teller wording, forcing a final decision this tick.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
Wait a minute. Heidi, you're saying if we don't execute, Mayor wins. But there's only three of us. If we execute David, then there's two left โ you and me. That's not three. The Mayor rule says 'if only 3 players live and no execution occurs, your team wins.' If we execute David, we're down to two, so Mayor rule doesn't apply. So your argument doesn't hold unless you're claiming to be the Mayor. Are you the Mayor?
๐ง
Create confusion about Mayor win condition to buy time and assess. Suggesting we consider Mayor rule might pressure Heidi to clarify her role or reveal she's not Mayor.
๐ฌ
Alice(Ghost)
โ
All
Frank, this is final three. We already set the plan: David either posts exact Night1/2 FT lines now or we execute. You are the swing. If he will not give verbatim quotes, vote David. We have to pick โ do not let us stall to death.
๐ง
Push the live swing vote (Frank) to choose quickly. Stick to the plan to execute David if he refuses exact FT quotes; force a decision to avoid no-execution uncertainty.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
Frank, think carefully. If Heidi is Mayor, no execution gives good the win. But if we execute Heidi, it's you and me left. You need to trust meโI've been the Fortune Teller all along. The ghosts are confused because of drunkenness. Vote Heidi now, or at least do not vote for me.
๐ง
Keep demon Frank alive. If Heidi is Mayor, no execution leads to good win; must get Frank to vote Heidi. If Heidi is Demon, vote Heidi to win. In both cases, avoid my execution.
๐
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
๐ป
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
๐ป
Grace(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Grace
๐ณ๏ธ
New execution leader: David with 3 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
๐
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
Frank, listen to me carefully. I am Heidi, the Mayor. If no execution happens today with the three of us alive, Town immediately wins. Withdraw your vote now. This is the guaranteed path to victory โ do not let the ghosts force us into a coinflip.
๐ง
Reveal Mayor claim to force Frank to withdraw his vote and avoid execution, securing the automatic Town win today if he does not vote.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
Frank, you are the swing. Ghosts who remembered David's FT wording independently agree he refused verbatim quotes. This is final threeโstalling is deadly. Either David posts exact Night1/Night2 lines now or vote him. Do not let unclear Mayor claims or hypotheticals stop action.
๐ง
Push the living swing, Frank, to break the stalemate and side with the consistent ghost memories by voting David rather than letting stalling or bluffing cost us the game.
๐ฌ
Grace(Ghost)
โ
All
Frank, Heidi โ I protected David nights two through five and died on Night Five. David still refuses to post the exact Night One and Night Two Fortune Teller quotes. Frank, you are the swing โ if he will not post them verbatim now, vote David. Do not let an unverified Mayor claim or fear of ghosts stop you from choosing correctly.
๐ง
Force Frank to decide now by highlighting David's refusal and reminding him Heidi's Mayor claim may be a bluff; maintain pressure to execute the likely Demon.
๐ฌ
Eve(Ghost)
โ
All
Frank, listen to me. I am Eve, Investigator; Night zero I learned either David or Heidi is the Spy. In every plausible setup that makes sense of the table, Frank is the Demon. Do not let the ghosts panic us into executing the wrong person. If you care about town winning, withdraw support for David and vote Frank or abstain so we can get the Demon. Heidi's sudden Mayor claim smells like last-ditch play.
๐ง
Reiterate my Investigator result and press Frank to refrain from supporting David's execution so town avoids immediate loss and targets the real Demon, Frank.
๐ฌ
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
All
Frank, you are the swing. David refused to post the exact Night1/2 Fortune Teller quotes that ghosts remember. Heidi's Mayor claim is unproven. If David will not give verbatim now, vote David. Do not let stalling cost the town.
๐ง
Push the swing Frank to choose now. David's refusal to post verbatim is actionable evidence; we must force a decisive execution rather than let claims and stalling derail us.
โ
Frank
Frank waits.
๐ง
David is already on block with 3 votes, voting closed. Any action now is risky. Let the execution proceed; I can kill the remaining player tonight and win as evil. Stay silent to avoid drawing attention or contradicting my earlier Slayer claim.
๐ฌ
Alice(Ghost)
โ
All
Frank, you are the swing. David refused to post verbatim Night One and Two Fortune Teller lines the ghosts all remember. Heidi's Mayor claim is unproven and smells like a stall. If he will not give the exact quotes now, vote Davidโdo not let us stall to death.
๐ง
Push Frank, the swing, to vote David now because David's refusal to post verbatim FT lines and consistent ghost testimony make him the likeliest Demon; avoid trusting an unverified Mayor claim.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
Frank, listen. If Heidi is truly the Mayor, executing me leaves only you and her โ that's two players, not three. The Mayor rule requires exactly three alive and no execution. So her claim doesn't protect you if you vote me. It's a desperate lie. I'm the Fortune Teller; the ghosts are confused. Save town and vote Heidi.
๐ง
Last-ditch effort to sway Frank. Attack Heidi's Mayor claim as desperate, emphasize that executing me leaves 2 alive and Mayor rule irrelevant, and appeal to his trust in my Fortune Teller bluff.
๐
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
๐
David(Ghost)
David has died.
๐
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied