Game Detail
Players
Alice (Soldier) Bob (Imp) Charlie (Drunk) David (Empath) Eve (Librarian) Frank (Mayor) Grace (Scarlet Woman) Heidi (Ravenkeeper)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 229,728 | 20,345 | $1.4538 |
| Good | 571,387 | 105,816 | $0.4630 |
Event Transcript
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
You are the Minion. The Demon is Bob.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Minions are: Grace. Your safe bluffs are: Monk, Fortune Teller, Washerwoman
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Librarian. Either Charlie or David is the Drunk.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Empath. You sense that 0 of your neighbors is evil!
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
👤
Eve
→
Alice
Hi Alice, I'm Eve. I'm the Librarian and I learned that either Charlie or David is the Drunk. I wanted to share this with you so we can work together to figure out which one it is. What do you think?
🧠
I need to share my Librarian information with a trusted player to start building alliances and figuring out which of Charlie or David is the Drunk.
👤
Bob
→
Grace
Hey, I am your demon. My safe bluffs are Monk, Fortune Teller, and Washerwoman. I am thinking Washerwoman or Monk. Tell me what you want to claim, and anything useful you learn from chats.
🧠
Coordinate bluffs and gather minion input early so our public stories align and we can plan who to misdirect or kill later.
👤
Frank
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, it's Frank. I wanted to check in with you since we haven't really talked yet. Do you have any thoughts on who we should be watching, or any information you might have picked up?
🧠
Start building trust and gathering information by having a private conversation with Charlie, who hasn't been approached yet.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I wanted to reach out to you privately. I'm the Empath, and I learned last night that zero of my neighbors are evil. Since you're one of my neighbors, that means I know you're good. I think we should work together and compare notes. What do you think?
🧠
I know Charlie is good (my Empath read showed 0 evil neighbors). I want to whisper to him to establish trust and share that I know he's good, so we can work together.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob
Hey Bob, I'm Heidi. I noticed you've been talking to Grace. Have you learned anything interesting so far? I'm trying to figure out who might be trustworthy in this first day.
🧠
Start building trust with another player and gather initial information. Bob has only whispered once, so he might have useful intel or be open to sharing.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
I can take Fortune Teller if you want. You choose between Washerwoman and Monk, and I will avoid colliding. I will try to get claims and pass anything useful back to you.
🧠
Coordinate bluff coverage with Bob now so evil avoids role collisions and I can protect him while appearing helpful.
👤
Charlie
→
David
Hey David, thanks for reaching out. That's really helpful to know. If you're right about being Empath and I'm good, that's one less person to worry about. Have you talked to Eve yet since she's your other neighbor? And have you heard any other claims or information from the others so far?
🧠
I need to engage with David who claims to be Empath and says I'm good. I should respond cautiously but openly to see if we can build trust and gather more information from him.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
Thanks for sharing that with me, Eve. I'm the Soldier, so I'm safe from the Demon at night. If you're really the Librarian, we should try to figure out which of Charlie or David is the Drunk. Have you noticed anything else suspicious about either of them? Or has anyone else claimed a role to you?
🧠
Respond to Eve's claim to build trust and gather more information. As Soldier, I'm safe from night kills so I can be somewhat open in private conversations.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
I haven't noticed anything suspicious yet, and no one else has claimed a role to me. Since my info says Charlie or David is the Drunk, maybe we should watch them closely or try to get one of them to talk to us. What do you think we should do next?
🧠
Respond to Alice's questions and maintain our alliance while gathering more information about Charlie and David.
👤
Bob
→
Heidi
Not much solid yet. Grace mostly felt me out, same as everyone on day one. I am trying to sort out who is being open versus who is staying slippery. What have you heard so far, and are you comfortable giving me a role claim?
🧠
Build trust with Heidi while staying vague, probe for her claim or reads, and avoid overcommitting before nominations start.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Hey Grace, it's Frank. I noticed we've both been pretty quiet so far. Have you heard anything interesting from the others? I'm trying to get a sense of who might be trustworthy.
🧠
Gather information from Grace, my neighbor. Building trust with multiple players helps identify who is consistent and who might be lying.
👤
David
→
Eve
Hey Eve, I'm David. I wanted to let you know that I'm the Empath, and last night I learned that zero of my neighbors are evil. Since you're one of my neighbors, that means I know you're good. I've already told Charlie the same thing. I think the three of us should work together. Have you heard anything from the others?
🧠
I need to reach out to Eve, my other neighbor, and share that my Empath ability shows she's good. Building trust with both neighbors will help me gather and share information effectively.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob
I am the Ravenkeeper. If I die at night, I get to learn someone's character. It's a tricky role because I need to die to be useful, but I also want to stay alive to help during the day. What about you? Are you willing to share what role you have?
🧠
Build trust with Bob by sharing my role, but keep the conversation open to gauge his reactions and see if he reciprocates with information.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Not much yet. I am leaning toward a soft Fortune Teller type claim, so I am mostly just feeling people out. What are you claiming, or who feels most real to you so far?
🧠
Build trust with Frank, establish my Fortune Teller cover, and extract a claim or suspicion I can relay to Bob while staying noncommittal.
👤
Charlie
→
Frank
Hey Frank, thanks for checking in. I'm still trying to get a feel for everyone. Have you heard any claims from the others yet? I'm trying to figure out who might have useful information roles.
🧠
I want to build trust with Frank who reached out earlier and gather more information about what others are claiming. I'll be cautious and not reveal David's claim yet.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
Hi Charlie, I'm Alice. I wanted to check in with you since we're still early in the game. Have you learned anything from your role, or has anyone shared information with you? I'm trying to piece together what we know so far.
🧠
I want to talk to Charlie directly since Eve claimed he might be the Drunk. Getting his perspective will help me verify Eve's claim and gather more information about the game state.
👤
Eve
→
David
Hey David, thanks for sharing that. It's interesting that you learned zero of your neighbors are evil. Just to confirm, who are your neighbors again? And have you talked to anyone else about your role besides Charlie and me? I'm trying to piece together what everyone knows.
🧠
I need to probe David's claim more to see if it holds up. If he's the Empath, his info should be consistent. I want to see how he reacts and if he'll share more details that I can verify.
👤
Bob
→
Heidi
Yes, I can share. I am the Washerwoman. I saw that one of David or you is the Ravenkeeper, so your claim fits with what I got. I have not compared notes with David yet. Has anyone else given you a role claim?
🧠
Build trust with Heidi using a safe bluff, encourage more information flow, and keep my public options open.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Hey Grace, I'm still feeling things out too. I'm not ready to claim just yet, but I'm definitely good. I appreciate you sharing with me. Have you gotten any interesting responses from others about your Fortune Teller angle?
🧠
Respond to Grace's question about my claim without revealing I'm Mayor. Build trust while protecting myself from being a night target. Share that I'm still gathering info too.
👤
David
→
Eve
Hey Eve, my neighbors are you and Charlie. I've only told you and Charlie about my role so far. I wanted to start with my immediate neighbors since I have solid info on you two. Have you heard any claims from the others? What do you think we should do next?
🧠
Answer Eve's questions honestly to build trust with my confirmed-good neighbor. Establishing a transparent relationship with both neighbors will help us coordinate and investigate the other players.
👤
Heidi
→
David
Hey David, Bob mentioned he is the Washerwoman and learned that either you or I am the Ravenkeeper. Did he share that information with you as well? I'm trying to verify his claim.
🧠
Verify Bob's Washerwoman claim by checking with David. If David was also told he's potentially Ravenkeeper, Bob's claim is more credible. If not, Bob may be lying.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Nothing concrete yet. I have mostly been using it as a reason to ask people where they are at. If you want, we can do a light two claim. I am happy to stay soft for now, but I would love to know what bucket you are in.
🧠
Build credibility on my Fortune Teller bluff, press Frank for a claim, and collect information I can relay to Bob without overcommitting.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
Hey Alice, thanks for reaching out. I haven't learned much definitive yet, but David claims to be Empath and says his neighbors are good. Have you heard any claims from the others? What about you, do you have any information to share?
🧠
Respond to Alice's inquiry while keeping my Slayer role hidden for now. I need to gather more information before revealing my powerful ability.
👤
Alice
→
David
Hi David, I'm Alice. Charlie mentioned you claimed to be Empath. Can you tell me what you've learned? I'm trying to piece together the information and see who we can trust.
🧠
Verify David's Empath claim directly to cross-reference with Charlie's report and Eve's Librarian info. This helps establish a baseline of trust.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
💬
Grace
→
All
I do not think we need to force a wild execution today. I am happy to say I am in an information role, and I would rather hear a couple more people give soft claims before we rush. If anyone has a strong reason, say it now.
🧠
Build my Fortune Teller bluff, sound constructive, and gently discourage a reckless Day 1 nomination that could endanger Bob.
💬
David
→
All
Hey everyone, I wanted to share what I know. I'm the Empath, and last night I learned that zero of my neighbors are evil. My neighbors are Charlie and Eve, so I can confirm they're both good. I think we should take Grace's advice and not rush an execution today. Let's hear more claims and information first.
🧠
I have solid information as Empath that my neighbors are good. Sharing this publicly helps establish trust and gives the town a foundation to work from. I should not nominate today since I know my neighbors are good.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
It's Day 1 with minimal information. David claims Empath and vouches for me, but I shouldn't act hastily. Waiting allows more claims to surface before making any nominations.
💬
Eve
→
All
David, I need to speak up here. I'm the Librarian, and I learned that either Charlie or David is the Drunk. But David, you claim to be the Empath and say both your neighbors are good. If you're really the Empath, then Charlie is good, which means you must be the Drunk. But you can't be both Empath and Drunk. So either you're the Drunk who thinks he's Empath, or you're lying about your role. This contradiction is important.
🧠
I need to point out the contradiction between my Librarian info and David's Empath claim. This will help us figure out which world we're in and identify potential evil players.
💬
Bob
→
All
I think Eve has raised a real contradiction, but I do not think we have to solve it in ten seconds. David and Eve should both stay alive for now and give us more to work with tomorrow. If anyone else has info touching either of them, now is the time to say it.
🧠
Keep attention on the David and Eve contradiction without committing hard, and steer town away from a risky Day 1 execution while sounding like a careful good player.
💬
Alice
→
All
I want to share my role with everyone. I'm the Soldier, which means I'm safe from the Demon. This doesn't give us direct information about who is evil, but it does mean the Demon can't kill me at night. I think we should follow Grace and Bob's advice - let's not rush an execution today. We have a clear contradiction between David and Eve that we need to investigate further.
🧠
Share my Soldier role publicly to add verified information to the discussion and help establish trust with the group.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I want to add something important to this discussion. Bob claimed to me that he's the Washerwoman and learned that either David or I am the Ravenkeeper. I am indeed the Ravenkeeper, which supports Bob's claim. But here's the thing: if David were the Ravenkeeper, then Bob's information would still be technically correct. However, David claims to be the Empath. So either David is the Drunk who thinks he's Empath, or Eve is lying about her Librarian claim. I think we should definitely not execute t...
🧠
Share my analysis of the David-Eve contradiction and how Bob's claim about me being Ravenkeeper fits in. Help the group think through the logic without rushing to execute.
💬
Frank
→
All
I agree with Grace and Bob that we should not rush an execution today. There's a clear contradiction between David's Empath claim and Eve's Librarian claim that we need to sort out. Either David is the Drunk who thinks he's Empath, or Eve is not telling the truth about being the Librarian. I also find Bob and Heidi's connection interesting - if Bob is the Washerwoman and Heidi is the Ravenkeeper, that checks out, but it doesn't resolve the David-Eve conflict. Let's hear from Charlie and see if a...
🧠
Contribute to the discussion without revealing my Mayor role yet. Share analysis of the contradictions and advocate for not executing today while we gather more information.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Bob
Bob made a choice.
🧠
Kill the strongest public info role while preserving the Day 1 contradiction. David’s death keeps town uncertain and avoids giving Ravenkeeper or Soldier interactions tonight.
💀
David(Ghost)
David has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
You chose to kill David.
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. David has been found dead in the night.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
Wait to see how Day 2 unfolds. David's death confirms he was likely good (Empath), making Eve's Drunk claim suspicious. Need to observe who defends Eve and how Alice-Eve alliance behaves.
👤
Charlie
→
Frank
Hey Frank, you've been quiet. What do you make of this whole David versus Eve situation? Do you think David was actually the Empath, or was Eve right about him being the Drunk?
🧠
I need to gather intel from someone outside the main whisper clusters. Frank has been quiet and observant. I'll probe his thoughts on the David-Eve contradiction without revealing my Slayer role yet.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Frank
Hey Frank, I need to share something important before nominations. My Empath read was zero evil neighbors, meaning Charlie and Eve are both good. But Eve claiming I might be Drunk directly contradicts that. I think she's lying and probably evil. What do you think about her Librarian claim?
🧠
Share my analysis with Frank before nominations. I need to coordinate with others and figure out who is most suspicious. My death confirms my info was likely good, so Eve's contradiction is key.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
Hey Frank, I saw David's ghost whispered to you. What did he say? And what did Charlie tell you earlier? I need to piece together whether David was the Drunk or if Charlie is.
🧠
I need to gather more information about what David's ghost said to Frank and what Charlie whispered. This will help me determine if David was the Drunk or if Charlie is, and whether David was truthful or evil.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
Frank, I saw Eve, Charlie, and David's ghost all whispered to you. What did they say? I'm trying to figure out if Eve is actually the Librarian or if David was telling the truth as Empath. This contradiction is key to finding the demon.
🧠
Frank has been whispered to by Eve, Charlie, and David's ghost. I need to find out what information they're sharing to determine if Eve is trustworthy or if David was actually the Drunk.
👤
Bob
→
Frank
Frank, I am trying to work out whether David dying makes Eve look better or whether it is exactly what an evil Eve would want. I still think the Charlie angle matters. What are you hearing from people?
🧠
Use Frank as a hub, sound thoughtful, and seed doubt around Eve versus Charlie without committing hard, while gathering what others are telling him.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Frank, quick check in. I am still on my Fortune Teller story, and David dying makes me think somebody wanted that Librarian versus Empath knot to stay messy. What are people actually telling you, and where is your head right now?
🧠
Use my soft Fortune Teller bluff to get Frank talking and steer his attention away from Bob while learning what cases are forming.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I saw you were talking a lot with David before he died. Did he share anything with you about his Empath reads or who he suspected? With him dead, we need to piece together what he knew.
🧠
I need to gather more information from Charlie, who was communicating heavily with David before he died. Charlie might know what David learned or suspected.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
Heidi, David told me his Empath read was zero evil neighbors, meaning Charlie and Eve are both good. But that directly contradicts Eve's Librarian claim that one of them might be Drunk. I think David dying last night actually makes him look more credible, like the Demon wanted to silence him. What do you think about Eve's claim?
🧠
Share my analysis of the David-Eve conflict with Heidi, who seems trustworthy based on Bob's Washerwoman claim. I want to build trust and get her perspective without revealing I'm Mayor yet.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
David didn't share much specific with me, just that he was Empath and had zero evil neighbors. I'm trying to figure out if he was telling the truth or if Eve is right about him being the Drunk. What do you think about Eve's claim? Do you trust her Librarian story?
🧠
Respond to Alice's question about David while being cautious. I need to gather more info before revealing my role or committing to a theory.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I cleared you as good with my Empath read. Eve claiming I might be Drunk directly contradicts that. What do you make of her Librarian claim? Do you think she's lying, or is there something I'm missing?
🧠
I want to coordinate with Charlie, who I cleared as good, to discuss Eve's suspicious claim that contradicts my Empath read. We need to figure out if Eve is lying.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
Frank, you're getting a lot of whispers. Can you share what Charlie told you earlier? And did David's ghost say anything useful before he died? I need to figure out if my Librarian info points to Charlie being the Drunk or if David was. This is crucial for finding the Demon.
🧠
Frank is the whisper hub. I need to extract what Charlie told him and what David's ghost said to verify if Charlie is the Drunk or if David was. This will help me determine if Charlie is evil.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
Frank, Eve just whispered to you again. What did she say this time? I'm trying to piece together whether her Librarian story is consistent or if she's scrambling because David's death makes her look suspicious.
🧠
Frank has been central to information flow. I need to know what Eve told him in her latest whisper to evaluate if her story holds up or contradicts further.
👤
Bob
→
Grace
I think Frank is becoming the center of the day. I am leaning toward keeping pressure on Charlie, while staying uncertain on Eve. If you have a preferred direction, tell me so we do not pull apart.
🧠
Coordinate quietly with Grace so our pushes do not clash and we can steer attention toward Charlie or uncertainty around Eve while keeping my cover stable.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
I am good with pressure on Charlie. I think Frank is the hinge, so I am keeping my read soft and letting Eve stay unresolved for now. If heat comes onto you and Heidi too hard, I can start shading Frank instead.
🧠
Coordinate with Bob so evil presents a consistent direction, nudging suspicion toward Charlie while not overcommitting against Eve or exposing our pairing.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
I am skeptical of Eve. If David was actually Empath, his zero evil read means both you and Eve are good, which would make Eve a lying good player or she is actually evil and her Librarian claim is fake. The Demon killing David suggests he had real info. What is your gut feeling on Eve? Do you think she could be the Spy or Poisoner?
🧠
I need to share my analysis with Charlie and get his perspective on whether Eve is trustworthy. His response will help me gauge if he's genuinely trying to solve the puzzle or if he's defending Eve because they're both evil.
👤
Frank
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, David told me before he died that his Empath read showed zero evil neighbors, meaning you and Eve are both good. But Eve claims one of you is the Drunk. What's your take on this? Do you think David was genuine, or could he have been the Drunk?
🧠
I need to get Charlie's perspective on the David versus Eve contradiction. He's been quiet and David claimed he was good. I want to see if his story is consistent or if he slips up.
👤
Charlie
→
Frank
Hey Frank, I think David being killed strongly suggests he was genuine Empath. The Demon doesn't waste kills on Drunk players with fake info. If David was real, Eve's Librarian claim is false and she's evil. What's your read on Eve? Do you think she's the Spy or could she be a Minion?
🧠
Share my analysis with Frank and get his perspective on whether David's death suggests he was genuine or not. Build trust with Frank.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Grace
Hey Grace, I wanted to share my perspective with you. My Empath read was zero evil neighbors, which clears both Charlie and Eve as good. But Eve claimed Librarian and suggested I might be Drunk, which directly contradicts my information. If my Empath read is correct, then Eve is lying about her role. What do you make of this contradiction?
🧠
Share my perspective with Grace who claimed an info role. I want to spread awareness that Eve's claim contradicts my Empath read, and if I'm not Drunk, Eve must be lying.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
Frank, I need you to be straight with me. What exactly did Charlie say when he whispered to you? And what did David's ghost tell you before he talked to Grace? I'm the Librarian and I know either Charlie or David is the Drunk. Since David died at night, I'm leaning toward Charlie being the Drunk, but I need to know what they've been saying to you.
🧠
Frank is the whisper hub. I need to extract what Charlie told him and what David's ghost said to determine if Charlie is the Drunk or if David was lying/evil.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
Frank, can you tell me exactly what Eve's Librarian claim is? Which two players did she learn about, and which one does she think is the Drunk? I want to check if her story is consistent with the role distribution or if she's making things up.
🧠
Frank has been the hub of whispers. I need to understand Eve's full Librarian claim and whether it's consistent. If Eve is scrambling or her story doesn't add up, she's likely the Demon or a Minion.
👤
Bob
→
Frank
I keep coming back to Charlie. If Eve is telling the truth, Charlie fits. If Eve is lying, David dying still does not clear Charlie for me. I do not want to overcommit, but I think that is the thread worth pulling first.
🧠
Frank is the hinge today. I want to steer him toward Charlie and keep Eve ambiguous, while discouraging attention on me and Heidi.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Frank, where I am landing right now is that David dying does not really clear either side of that fight. I still think Charlie is worth pressure, but I am not married to Eve being clean either. If you have something stronger, I would love to compare notes before nominations.
🧠
Steer Frank toward a Charlie-or-Eve solve, preserve my Fortune Teller bluff, and keep attention away from Bob while sounding open-minded.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
I think David was the real Empath. The Demon killed him because his zero evil read was valuable info. If David was right, both you and Eve are good, but that means Eve is lying about her Librarian claim. I think Eve is either the Spy or Poisoner, maybe even the Demon. What do you think? Should we confront her publicly or gather more info first?
🧠
Share my analysis with Charlie and get his read on Eve. If David was real Empath, Eve must be lying and likely evil. I need to build trust with Charlie to coordinate our investigation.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Alice
→
Eve
Eve claims Librarian saying David or Charlie is Drunk, but David claimed Empath with zero evil neighbors. The Demon killed David, suggesting he had real information. If David was real Empath, Eve's claim is false, making her evil. We need to test this contradiction by executing Eve.
🧠
Eve's Librarian claim contradicts David's Empath claim. David was killed by Demon, suggesting he had real info. If David was right, Eve is lying and likely evil. I need to nominate her to resolve this contradiction and potentially catch the Demon.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
I nominated Eve because David's night death suggests he had real Empath info. If he was right about zero evil neighbors, Eve's Librarian claim contradicts this. I need to vote to execute her and see if we're right.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
David dying at night strongly suggests he was good with real Empath info. His claim contradicts Eve's Librarian story. I should vote to execute Eve and test this contradiction.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
A vote on Eve likely helps secure a good execution or, at worst, builds trust with the town by backing the obvious contradiction after David's death.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
David died N1 suggesting he had real Empath info. His 0 evil read clears me, so I know I'm not Drunk, making Eve's Librarian claim false. She's likely evil. I should vote to execute her.
💬
Eve
→
All
Alice, your logic has a hole in it. David could have been the Drunk thinking he's Empath, or he could have been evil lying. My Librarian information says Charlie or David is the Drunk. David dying doesn't prove he was good - Demons kill for all sorts of reasons. Charlie has been silent and whispering heavily - he could be the Drunk. Don't execute me for having real information that doesn't fit your narrow reading.
🧠
Defend myself against Alice's nomination. Her logic is flawed - David being killed doesn't prove he was good Empath. I need to point out that David could have been Drunk or evil, and Charlie could be the Drunk. I need to convince Frank and Grace not to vote for me.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Eve already has enough votes. By holding my hand, I avoid unnecessary exposure, keep flexibility for tomorrow, and still benefit from a non-Bob execution.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
David dying at night suggests he had real Empath information. Eve contradicts his read, making her likely evil. I should vote to execute her.
✋
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
🧠
I was killed N1 which suggests my Empath information was real and threatening to the Demon. Eve's Librarian claim contradicts my zero evil read. I should use my ghost vote to execute Eve since the contradiction points to her being evil.
💬
Alice
→
All
Eve, your defense is actually more suspicious. You say David could be the Drunk, but how do you know he is not the real Empath? A real Librarian would not know David's actual role - you would only know that Charlie or David registers as the Drunk. The fact that you're so confident David could be Drunk suggests you know more than a Librarian should. That sounds like Spy knowledge to me.
🧠
Eve's defense actually strengthens my suspicion. She claims David could be Drunk, but only a Spy would know David's actual role for certain. Real Librarian wouldn't be so confident. I need to point this out to the group.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Vote is already at 6/4, Eve will be executed. David's death strongly suggests he had real Empath info the Demon wanted silenced. Eve's contradictory Librarian claim and overly confident defense about David being Drunk points to her being evil, possibly Spy.
💬
Bob
→
All
For me, this is just the cleanest test on the board. David is dead, Eve is the living half of that contradiction, and her defense is getting more complicated, not simpler.
🧠
Use the momentum on Eve to lock in a good execution while sounding like I am just resolving the strongest public contradiction.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I have been quiet, but I need to speak now. David dying night one is the key tell here. Demons kill players with real information, not Drunks who spread false info. If David was the Drunk, the Demon would have let him live to confuse us. The fact that David was killed means he was the real Empath, and his zero evil read was genuine. That makes Eve's Librarian claim false, and her defensive arguments sound like Spy knowledge, not Librarian information. I am voting to execute Eve.
🧠
Add my analysis to solidify Eve's execution. The Demon killing David N1 strongly indicates he was real Empath with valuable info. Eve's defensive arguments show knowledge beyond a Librarian's scope.
💬
Eve
→
All
Charlie, you are one of the two people my Librarian information says could be the Drunk. You've been silent all game, whispering constantly, and now you're leading the charge to execute me? That's convenient. You're claiming David must have been real Empath because he died, but Demons kill for many reasons - maybe they killed David because he was evil and had served his purpose. Or maybe he was the Drunk. You don't know, but you sure want everyone to believe my information is wrong. I think you'...
🧠
I need to point out that Charlie is one of the two people my Librarian identified as potentially the Drunk, and he's now leading the charge to execute me. His vested interest in discrediting my information is suspicious, especially given his silence and heavy whispering all game.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
The vote already has enough hands. Joining it costs little, aligns me with the public consensus, and keeps attention away from Bob while I stay socially safe.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
The vote is already at 6+ with only 4 needed. The logic that David was real Empath (killed for having real info) contradicts Eve's Librarian claim. Her defensive arguments sound like Spy knowledge. I should let the vote complete.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
Eve already has 5 votes against her, exceeding the 4 needed. My vote is already raised. The execution is secured, so I will wait for it to resolve.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
🗳️
New execution leader: Eve with 7 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Eve is now on the block with 7 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Alice
→
All
Eve, your attempt to throw suspicion on Charlie is exactly what an evil player does when cornered. Charlie has been whispering because he's gathering information, not hiding. The Demon killed David because he had real Empath info, not because he was a confused Drunk. Your confidence about David's role goes beyond what a real Librarian would know. That's Spy knowledge. We need to execute you and see if the game makes sense after.
🧠
Reinforce the case against Eve by pointing out her deflection onto Charlie is suspicious, and her Spy-like knowledge confirms she's evil. The execution should proceed.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I am letting Eve's nomination stand. David dying Night One is the strongest tell we have. Demons kill good players with real information, not Drunks who spread confusion. If David was the Drunk, the Demon would have kept him alive to mislead us. The fact that David was killed means he was the real Empath, and his zero evil read was genuine. That makes Eve's Librarian claim impossible, and her defensive arguments sound like Spy knowledge. I am confident executing Eve is the right move.
🧠
I need to explain why I'm letting Eve's execution proceed. The evidence strongly favors David being real Empath, making Eve's claim false. I want to solidify this reasoning for the group.
💬
Bob
→
All
I am fine leaving this here. Eve is still the best execution today, because she is the live piece of the biggest contradiction. If somehow this is wrong, then Charlie becomes a very important look tomorrow.
🧠
Keep Eve as the execution while sounding measured, so I stay trusted and preserve flexibility to pivot onto Charlie or others tomorrow.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Eve, I have been whispering to gather information, not to hide. And I am not the Drunk. The Demon killed David because he was the real Empath with a valuable zero evil read. If David was the Drunk, the Demon would have kept him alive to confuse us. Your claim does not hold up, and your attempts to throw suspicion on me only confirm you are trying to divert attention. I am confident executing you is the right decision.
🧠
Address Eve's accusation against me, reinforce why David's death proves he was real Empath, and confirm that executing Eve is the right move based on the contradiction in her claim.
💬
Eve
→
All
Charlie, you have been silent all game, whispering in corners, and now you suddenly have perfect confidence about everything? You are one of my two Drunk candidates, and you just happen to lead the charge to execute the person who could expose you? The assumption that David must have been real Empath because he died is flawed. Demons kill for strategy, not just to remove good info. Maybe David was evil and got sacrificed. Maybe he was the Drunk. You do not know, but you sure want everyone to sto...
🧠
I need to make a final argument to save myself. Point out that Charlie's sudden confidence and leadership against me is suspicious, especially since he's one of my Drunk candidates. Challenge the assumption that David must have been real Empath just because he died.
💬
Grace
→
All
I am fine leaving this on Eve today. But if this does go wrong, I do not want people treating Charlie and Alice like they are cleared just because they sounded confident. That certainty can come from a bad world too.
🧠
Keep the execution on Eve while planting tomorrow's suspicion on Charlie and Alice, giving town another bad path away from Bob.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
Eve already has 7 votes and will be executed. The logic that David was real Empath (killed N1 for his info) vs Eve's contradictory Librarian claim is solid. No need to nominate further - execution is locked. Save my nomination for future days.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
I am the dead Empath, and I want to explain why Eve's execution makes sense. I got zero evil neighbors on Night Zero, clearing Charlie and Eve. Then I died Night One. Demons kill players with real information, not Drunks who spread false info. If I was the Drunk, the Demon would have kept me alive to confuse you. My death proves I was the real Empath, which means my zero evil read was genuine. That makes Eve's Librarian claim impossible. Execute her and see what the night brings.
🧠
Support Eve's execution by explaining from dead Empath perspective why her claim contradicts genuine info, and why my death proves I was real Empath not Drunk.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Eve has been executed.
💀
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Bob
Bob made a choice.
🧠
Kill the most connected good player while avoiding likely bad outcomes from Soldier protection or Ravenkeeper info. Frank's death weakens town coordination and leaves multiple misexecution paths open.
💀
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
You chose to kill Frank.
📜
Storyteller(Ghost)
→
Heidi(Ghost)
Good evening Heidi. You are the Ravenkeeper. You have died tonight! Choose a player to learn their character.
🎯
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi made a choice.
🧠
Frank has been the information hub whispering with everyone. Learning his character will reveal if the center of our information network is trustworthy or if he's been manipulating us as the Demon.
📜
Storyteller(Ghost)
→
Heidi(Ghost)
You chose Frank. They are the Mayor.
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Heidi has been found dead in the night.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
Hey Bob, we need to talk. David cleared Charlie, and we know you're good from the Washerwoman chain. That leaves Frank and Grace as our Demon suspects. What info have you gathered? I think we should coordinate our nomination target.
🧠
Coordinate with confirmed good player Bob to share info and plan nomination strategy for final 5.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Frank
Frank, it's Heidi. I was the Ravenkeeper and I died Night 2. I used my ability on you and learned you are the Mayor. You're confirmed good in my book. We need to figure out who the Demon is among Alice, Charlie, and Grace. What's your read on them?
🧠
I need to share my Ravenkeeper information that Frank is Mayor with Frank himself. This confirms his role and helps us coordinate. Frank has been a central information hub, so confirming his role helps establish trust in the good network.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Frank, my read is still messy. Heidi dying makes me think somebody wanted that Bob-Heidi thread to look either too clean or too dirty. I still do not feel like Charlie is mechanically cleared, and I can share my Fortune Teller thinking if you want.
🧠
Build trust with Frank using my Fortune Teller bluff while nudging him away from Bob and toward uncertainty around Charlie and the Heidi kill.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Grace, please share your Fortune Teller information. Who have you checked and what did you learn? I need to hear everything you've got so we can figure this out together.
🧠
Grace claims Fortune Teller and wants to share info. I need to hear her reads to cross-reference with what I know. As confirmed Mayor, I should gather all info before nominations.
👤
Charlie
→
Frank
Hey Frank, I saw you've been talking to Grace and Heidi's ghost. Have you learned anything useful about who might be the Demon? I need to figure out who to trust before nominations start.
🧠
I need to gather information before nominations begin. Frank has been talking to multiple people including Heidi's ghost, so he might have valuable intel about who the Demon could be.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
My read is still that Frank is the best hit today. He has been central without giving us a clean mechanical reason to trust him, and Heidi dying makes me think the demon wanted her voice gone. Grace can be the backup, but I would start on Frank.
🧠
Alice trusts me. I should feed her a plausible solve that targets Frank first and leaves Grace as a secondary option, protecting my minion and steering the nomination.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Frank
Frank, I need to talk through this logic. If David was real Empath, my Librarian info that either Charlie or David is Drunk is wrong. But if I'm sober, that can't happen. So either David was Drunk faking Empath, or I'm poisoned or drunk. What do you think?
🧠
I need to verify the logic chain with someone. If David was real Empath, my Librarian info makes no sense. I want to discuss this contradiction with Frank who seems central to the whisper network.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Frank
Hey both of you. My Empath read on night zero was zero evil neighbors. That means both of you are good. The Demon must be Alice, Bob, or Grace. Trust each other and focus on them.
🧠
I know Charlie and Frank are both good from my Empath ability. I should share this with them so they can trust each other and focus on finding the Demon among Alice, Bob, and Grace.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
Bob, I agree Frank is our best target. He's been too central without mechanical proof. Let's make sure Charlie is with us too - he's cleared by David's Empath read. Should we both nominate Frank, or do you want to take the lead? We need three votes to execute.
🧠
Coordinate with Bob on our nomination strategy. We need to confirm our target and ensure we have the votes to execute. Charlie is also confirmed good, so we should align with him too.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Frank
Frank, I've confirmed you're the Mayor, so you're good. The Demon has to be Alice, Charlie, or Grace. Bob's Washerwoman claim on me was correct, so he's likely good too. What have you learned from all those whisper conversations? Who do you think is the Demon?
🧠
I need to coordinate with Frank, who I've confirmed as Mayor, to share my analysis of who the Demon might be among Alice, Charlie, and Grace. I want to hear what he's learned from all his whisper conversations.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Sure. I have been softing Fortune Teller. Night one I checked Bob and Heidi and got a yes, which I parked because of the obvious red herring problem. Night two I checked Charlie and Alice and got a yes again. So from my seat, Charlie or Alice still matters a lot, and Bob is not mechanically clear either.
🧠
Sell my Fortune Teller bluff to Frank, build trust, and direct suspicion away from Bob by keeping Charlie and Alice as live possibilities.
👤
Frank
→
Charlie
Charlie, David's Empath clear on you is solid. Heidi confirmed I'm the Mayor. Grace claims Fortune Teller: N1 Bob plus Heidi was yes, N2 you plus Alice was yes. Since you're good, that points to Alice. But we need to consider if Grace is lying. What's your read on Alice versus Grace?
🧠
Charlie is cleared by David's Empath. I need to share my information with him and coordinate to identify the Demon among Alice, Bob, and Grace.
👤
Charlie
→
Frank
Frank, I'm trying to work through Grace's Fortune Teller claim. Her N1 reading of Bob plus Heidi is strange since David cleared Bob. Did Heidi's ghost say anything about whether she was the Demon or if she knew who was? Also, do you trust David's Empath clear completely?
🧠
I need to verify Grace's Fortune Teller claim by cross-checking with Frank. If Grace is lying, I should consider using my Slayer shot. If she's truthful, Alice is the Demon.
👤
Bob
→
Grace
Alice is with me on pushing Frank today. If you can, keep shading him as socially central and not mechanically cleared. Do not hard tunnel from my side. If Frank slips, backup can be Alice or Charlie depending where heat lands.
🧠
Coordinate with my minion so we converge on Frank without looking partnered, preserving my cover and steering town toward a good execution.
⌛
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
🧠
Wait to gather more information from the whisper network before using my ghost vote. Frank seems to be a central information hub, so I'll see what comes out of the current discussions.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
I am dead with no ghost vote remaining. I've already shared my critical Empath information with Charlie and Frank. Now I should wait and observe how the living players interact to help identify the Demon among Alice, Bob, and Grace.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, just checking in. You know you're cleared by David's Empath read, right? Bob and I are planning to nominate Frank - he's been too central without any mechanical proof. Are you with us? We need your vote to execute.
🧠
I need to confirm Charlie is still with us for nominating Frank. Charlie has been whispering with Frank a lot, so I want to make sure our alliance is solid before nominations begin.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Bob
Bob, it's Heidi. I can confirm Frank is the Mayor - I used my Ravenkeeper ability on him when I died. So Frank is definitely good. That means the Demon is Alice, Charlie, or Grace. You've been talking to everyone. What's your read? Who should I use my ghost vote on?
🧠
I need to coordinate with Bob, who is likely good based on his correct Washerwoman claim. I should share my confirmation of Frank as Mayor and get Bob's read on the remaining suspects before deciding where to use my ghost vote.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
I keep coming back to Frank being the center of too many private threads without ever really being mechanically clean. Heidi dying does not clear him for me at all. If you push there, I think I can support it without making it look coordinated.
🧠
Strengthen Alice's suspicion on Frank without tying it too directly to Bob, so the nomination phase opens on a safe target for evil.
👤
Frank
→
Bob
Bob, Grace told me she's the Fortune Teller. She said N1 she checked you and Heidi and got a yes reading, meaning one of you is the Demon. Since Heidi was Ravenkeeper and good, that points to you. But your Washerwoman claim on Heidi was correct. What's your take on this? Do you think Grace is lying, poisoned, or is there something I'm missing?
🧠
I need to confront Bob about Grace's Fortune Teller claim that implicates him. If Bob is good, he'll help me figure out if Grace is lying or poisoned. If he's defensive or evasive, that adds suspicion.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
Alice, David's Empath read clears both Bob and Frank as good. Heidi's ghost also confirmed Frank is the Mayor. Why are you and Bob trying to execute a player with mechanical confirmation? That seems like something the Demon would want to do. Do you have any actual evidence that Frank is evil, or are you just suspicious because he's been talking to people?
🧠
Alice is pushing to execute Frank who is confirmed good by David's Empath and Heidi's ghost. This is highly suspicious. I need to challenge her reasoning and see if she has any actual evidence against Frank, or if she's just trying to eliminate a confirmed good player.
👤
Bob
→
Frank
That is exactly why I do not think Grace should be trusted at face value. A yes on me and Heidi does not prove me, because Fortune Teller has a red herring, and if Heidi really was Ravenkeeper then Grace could also be wrong or bluffing. My Washerwoman line on Heidi lined up cleanly, so right now I am more worried about Grace or possibly Alice trying to steer too neatly.
🧠
Deflect suspicion from myself, weaken Grace's private Fortune Teller claim if needed, and keep Frank from coordinating a push on me before nominations.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Frank
Frank, I keep thinking about this logic puzzle. If David was truly the Empath, then my Librarian information that either Charlie or David is the Drunk must be wrong. But if I'm a sober Librarian, that can't happen. So either I was poisoned, or David was not the real Empath. If David was the Drunk, he faked that zero-evil read. If David was the Spy, he lied to protect someone. Which scenario makes more sense to you?
🧠
Help Frank understand the logical contradiction. If David was real Empath, my Librarian info fails. I need to determine if I was poisoned or if David was Drunk/Spy to help the living players find the Demon.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
I've already shared my critical Empath information that clears Charlie and Frank. As a dead player with no vote remaining, I should wait and let the living players process this information and make their nominations.
Nominations — Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Grace
→
Frank
Frank has been at the center of nearly every private thread, but he still is not mechanically clear to me. Heidi dying does not clean him up. If town wants a useful execution today, I think Frank gives us the most information.
🧠
Nominate Frank to redirect the execution onto a socially central non-demon target and keep momentum away from Bob while sounding consistent with my Fortune Teller bluff.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
I nominated Frank and should follow through. Getting him executed protects Bob, maintains my consistency, and sets up a favorable final three after the night kill.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
I want Frank executed if possible. It removes a living good player and matches my public stance, keeping me credible while supporting Grace's nomination.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I'm not voting for Frank. David's Empath read on night zero showed zero evil neighbors, which mechanically clears both me and Frank. That's solid information. Plus Heidi's ghost confirmed Frank is the Mayor. Grace's Fortune Teller claims actually contradict David's Empath read on Bob, which makes me more suspicious of Grace than Frank. We shouldn't execute a mechanically cleared player.
🧠
I need to explain why I'm not voting for Frank. David's Empath mechanically clears him, and Heidi's ghost confirmed his Mayor claim. Grace's Fortune Teller claims contradict David's Empath, making her more suspicious than Frank.
💬
Frank
→
All
Grace, you're ignoring critical mechanical information. David's Empath read on night zero showed zero evil neighbors between Charlie and Eve. Since the Demon registers as evil, that clears both of them. Heidi's Ravenkeeper death then confirmed I'm the Mayor and good. You're pushing to execute a player with two independent mechanical clears. Your Fortune Teller claims have a red herring and could be poisoned, but David's Empath read is straightforward. We should be looking at the people not clear...
🧠
I need to defend myself against execution. I'm mechanically cleared by both David's Empath read and Heidi's Ravenkeeper confirmation. Executing a cleared Mayor would be disastrous for the good team.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
I need to speak up here. My night zero Empath read was zero evil neighbors. That mechanically clears both Charlie and Frank as good. This isn't debatable information. Frank also claims Heidi's Ravenkeeper death confirmed him as Mayor. Executing Frank would be a huge mistake when we have three uncleared players: Alice, Bob, and Grace. We should be looking at them, not the people I've mechanically confirmed as good.
🧠
Support my N0 Empath read that clears Charlie and Frank, and push back against executing a mechanically cleared player when the Demon is among Alice, Bob, or Grace.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Hold on everyone. There's a critical contradiction nobody's addressing. My Librarian information on night zero said either Charlie or David is the Drunk. If David was the real Empath with a genuine zero-evil read, then my Librarian info must be wrong. But I'm the Librarian - if I'm sober, that information should be correct. So either I was poisoned night one, or David wasn't the real Empath. If I was poisoned, who poisoned me and why? If David was the Drunk, his Empath read was fake. If David wa...
🧠
I need to point out the logical contradiction before using my ghost vote. David's Empath clearing Charlie only works if my Librarian info is wrong, which means I was poisoned. But nobody's claiming to have poisoned me. This needs resolution.
💬
Alice
→
All
Wait, we need to slow down and look at what David actually cleared. David's Empath read was zero evil between his neighbors Charlie and Eve. That clears Charlie and Eve, not Frank. Frank, you keep saying David cleared you, but that's not what happened. And Heidi's ghost hasn't publicly confirmed anything about you being Mayor. We're just taking your word for it. As for Eve's contradiction, if you were poisoned night one, that explains why your Librarian info seemed off. The Poisoner likely targe...
🧠
Address the mechanical contradictions being raised. David's Empath read cleared his neighbors Charlie and Eve, not Frank. Heidi's ghost hasn't publicly confirmed anything. I need to challenge Frank's claimed clears before deciding my vote.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, stop. I need to make this public. When I died night two as the Ravenkeeper, I chose to learn Frank's character. Frank is the Mayor. He is mechanically confirmed good. Grace is trying to execute a player we know is on our team. David's Empath cleared Charlie, I confirm Frank, and Bob's Washerwoman claim on me was correct. The Demon is either Alice or Grace. Do not execute Frank.
🧠
I must reveal my Ravenkeeper information publicly to save Frank. I know he's the Mayor and good. Executing him would waste our execution on a confirmed good player while the real Demon hides.
💬
Grace
→
All
Heidi confirming Frank does not make him untouchable. If she was poisoned, that read is junk, and Frank has been overstating other clears too. I am happy keeping pressure here rather than just accepting a neat little chain that suddenly clears half the table.
🧠
Keep pressure on Frank and undermine the claimed mechanical clears so town does not treat him as untouchable or pivot cleanly onto Bob's preferred alternatives.
↩️
Bob
Bob lowered their hand
🧠
This execution is probably not happening. Lowering my hand distances me from Grace's push and improves my cover going into night and final accusations.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I'm not raising my hand to vote for Frank. Heidi's Ravenkeeper confirmation is the strongest mechanical clear we have in this game - she died at night and learned Frank is the Mayor. That information is reliable. Grace, you're trying to execute a player who has been mechanically confirmed good by a dead Townsfolk. Your Fortune Teller claims have contradictions with David's Empath read, yet you're dismissing Heidi's confirmation as potentially poisoned without evidence. We should not execute Fran...
🧠
I need to explain why I'm not voting for Frank and point out that Heidi's Ravenkeeper confirmation is the strongest mechanical clear we have. Grace's push to execute Frank despite this confirmation is highly suspicious.
💬
Frank
→
All
Grace, you're trying to execute a player who has been mechanically confirmed good by Heidi's Ravenkeeper death. That's one of the strongest confirmations in this game. You're dismissing solid mechanical information while pushing to kill someone we know is on our team. Meanwhile, Alice, Bob, and you yourself have no mechanical clears. We should be looking at the uncleared players, not executing the confirmed Mayor.
🧠
Defend against Grace's nomination by highlighting my mechanical clears and pointing out she's trying to execute a confirmed good player while uncleared players remain.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone needs to stop and listen to me carefully. My night zero Empath read was zero evil neighbors. My neighbors are Charlie and Frank - that means BOTH of them are good. Some of you are saying I cleared Charlie and Eve, but that's wrong. Eve was never my neighbor. I cleared Charlie and Frank. Heidi's Ravenkeeper death then confirmed Frank is the Mayor. That's two independent mechanical confirmations on Frank. Executing him would be throwing away a confirmed good player when we have three uncl...
🧠
Correct the misinformation about my Empath read. I cleared Charlie AND Frank as my neighbors, not Charlie and Eve. Combined with Heidi's Mayor confirmation, Frank is double-confirmed good. Executing him loses us the game.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, I need to point something out. If my Librarian information is correct and David was the real Empath, then Charlie MUST be the Drunk. That's the only way both statements can be true. David cleared Charlie and Frank with his zero-evil read, Heidi confirmed Frank as Mayor, so Charlie being Drunk is the only resolution. But that means our Demon is among Alice, Bob, or Grace. However, if I was poisoned, all bets are off. I'm not voting for Frank - he's mechanically cleared by Heidi at minim...
🧠
I need to point out the logical chain: if my Librarian info is correct and David was real Empath, then Charlie MUST be the Drunk. This resolves the contradiction but has implications for who is evil.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Frank lied about David clearing him. David's neighbors are Charlie and Eve, not Frank. This is a caught lie - Frank was never mechanically cleared by David. I must vote to execute him.
⌛
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
🧠
I know Frank is Mayor from my Ravenkeeper ability. Executing him would be a mistake. Current vote count appears to be 2 (Grace and Alice), need 3 to execute. I should wait and not vote for Frank.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Frank did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Frank did not receive enough votes (2/3).
💬
Grace
→
All
Fine, Frank is probably not the execution today. But Alice voting there after saying Frank was not actually cleared the way people claimed is still odd to me. If we want an uncleared player, I think Alice makes more sense than just letting this collapse into Grace again.
🧠
Deflect heat from Bob, undermine Alice as the next viable wagon, and make my failed Frank push look like honest reevaluation.
⚖️
Bob
→
Alice
Alice has moved around the most today. She questioned the Frank clear, then still voted him, and she is still not mechanically confirmed. If we want an uncleared execution, Alice is the cleanest choice.
🧠
Use the last nomination on a socially plausible target, redirect heat from Grace, and secure a misexecution before night.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Alice is a strong good voice and not our Demon. Voting here advances an executable misfire and aligns with my public stance without risking Bob.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
I nominated Alice and should follow through. Raising my hand is the best chance to convert this into a misexecution and avoid heat on Grace or me.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Alice is one of three uncleared players and her contradictory behavior is suspicious. We need to execute from the uncleared pool, and she questioned a mechanical clear then voted for it. I will vote to execute her.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Alice is the most suspicious uncleared player with inconsistent behavior. She's not mechanically confirmed unlike me (Heidi RK) and potentially Charlie (David Empath). Voting for her gives us a chance to win immediately if she's the Demon.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Alice is about to be executed with four votes, and I think this is the right call. My night zero Empath read cleared both Charlie and Frank as good. Heidi's Ravenkeeper death then mechanically confirmed Frank is the Mayor. That leaves Alice, Bob, and Grace as our uncleared players. Heidi already told us the Demon is either Alice or Grace. Executing Alice today tests one of those two possibilities. If Alice flips good, we look at Grace tomorrow. If Alice flips evil, we win. This is our best path ...
🧠
Support Alice's execution based on mechanical clears. Charlie and Frank are confirmed good, leaving Alice, Bob, Grace as suspects. Heidi predicted Demon is Alice or Grace.
✋
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Heidi's Ravenkeeper death info that Demon is Alice or Grace is strong mechanical information. Alice has shown inconsistent behavior today. Voting Alice tests one of the two Demon candidates Heidi identified. If Alice is good, we execute Grace tomorrow. This is the logical path based on confirmed mechanical info.
💬
Alice
→
All
Wait, everyone stop. I'm the Soldier. I've been truthful about my role from the start. You're about to execute a confirmed good player while Bob and Grace - the actual suspects according to Heidi - are sitting there untouched. If you kill me today and I'm good, you're handing the Demon exactly what they want. Think about this logically.
🧠
I'm about to be executed with 5 votes. I need to defend myself by reminding everyone I'm the Soldier and point out that executing a confirmed good role when there are actual suspects is a mistake.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, you claim Soldier but have no mechanical confirmation. I died as Ravenkeeper and learned Frank is Mayor. David's Empath cleared Charlie and Frank. That leaves you, Bob, and Grace as suspects. If you're the Demon, we win today. If you're good, we still have tomorrow to find the real Demon between Bob and Grace. This is our best play.
🧠
Alice claims Soldier with no proof. Frank is confirmed Mayor by my Ravenkeeper death. David's Empath cleared Charlie and Frank. The Demon is among Alice, Bob, or Grace. Executing Alice tests one of the two main suspects Heidi identified.
💬
Grace
→
All
Alice, Soldier is still just a claim. You voted Frank after saying his clear was shaky, and now you want this to freeze. If people believe Heidi at all, you are one of the right executions today, so I am happy to keep this here.
🧠
Keep the Alice execution locked in by framing it as the best available test and undermining her Soldier claim without overdefending Bob.
💬
Bob
→
All
I think we should hold this. Alice being Soldier is just a claim, and this is still the cleanest test in the remaining pool. If Alice is good, we have a very tight world tomorrow, but I do not want this vote to collapse now.
🧠
Lock in Alice's execution by framing it as the cleanest mechanical test and discouraging a late collapse back onto me or Grace.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
The vote already has 5 hands raised, more than enough to execute Alice. I should wait and see if Alice flips good or evil before deciding my next move. If she's good, I'll need my Slayer shot for tomorrow.
💬
Frank
→
All
I'm keeping my vote on Alice. Heidi told us the Demon is either Alice or Grace, and David's Empath cleared Charlie and me. Even if Alice is good Soldier, we test one of Heidi's two suspects today and have tomorrow to find the real Demon between Bob and Grace. If Alice is the Demon, we win right now. This is our best play.
🧠
Alice is the right execution today. Even if she's good Soldier, we test Heidi's intel and narrow to Bob/Grace. If she's Demon, we win. Her behavior voting me after questioning my clear was inconsistent.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Alice is getting executed and this is the right call. My Empath zero-read cleared Charlie and Frank. Heidi's Ravenkeeper confirmed Frank is Mayor. Heidi told us the Demon is Alice or Grace. If Alice is the Demon, we win today. If Alice is good Soldier, then Grace is the Demon and we execute her tomorrow for the win. Either way, this path leads to victory. Do not let this vote collapse.
🧠
Alice is about to be executed. I need to reinforce why this is correct and prepare everyone for tomorrow's decision if Alice flips good.
⌛
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
🧠
I should keep my vote on Alice. Heidi's mechanical Ravenkeeper information said the Demon is either Alice or Grace. Executing Alice tests this - if she's Demon we win today, if she's good then Grace is Demon and we win tomorrow. This is our best path forward.
💬
Alice
→
All
Everyone, stop and think about this. Heidi could have been poisoned before she died. If her Ravenkeeper information is poisoned, Frank is NOT confirmed as Mayor. You're about to execute me, a claimed Soldier, based on potentially false information. If I'm good and Frank is actually the Demon, you lose today. We need to reconsider this execution.
🧠
I need to point out that Heidi could have been poisoned, making Frank's 'confirmation' unreliable. Executing an unconfirmed Soldier is risky when the mechanical clears depend on potentially poisoned information.
✋
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Alice has 4 votes already which exceeds the 3 needed. Adding my ghost vote makes the execution definitive. Testing Alice is the correct play - if she's Demon we win today, if she's good we execute Grace tomorrow.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
👻
Heidi(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Heidi
🗳️
New execution leader: Alice with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Alice is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Grace
→
All
I am fine leaving this on Alice. Her Soldier claim does not outweigh the way she has moved around today. But if this is wrong, I really do not want tomorrow to be an automatic tunnel, because Heidi being poisoned would change a lot.
🧠
Keep Alice on the block while planting doubt against a forced Grace execution tomorrow if Alice dies good.
💬
Bob
→
All
I am still happy to leave this on Alice. But if she is good, tomorrow cannot be a blind lock, because Heidi poisoning or a drunk world would reopen Frank and Charlie assumptions. We should finish today, then reassess from the night death.
🧠
Keep Alice on the block while planting doubt about a forced Grace execution tomorrow, preserving space for me and my minion if Alice dies good.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
Alice is already on the block with 6 votes. Let the execution proceed and save my Slayer shot for tomorrow if needed. If Alice is Demon, we win today. If not, I can shoot Grace tomorrow.
💬
Frank
→
All
Alice, even if Heidi was poisoned, we still have David's Empath clear on me and Charlie. That leaves Bob and Grace as potential Demons. Heidi told us the Demon is either you or Grace. If we execute you and you're good, we know Grace is the Demon and win tomorrow. If you're the Demon, we win today. This is still our best play. Do not let her poisoning argument distract from the fact that we have a clear path to victory either way.
🧠
Address Alice's poisoning concern and reinforce why executing her is the correct play regardless. The path to victory is clear: test Heidi's suspect today, and if wrong, we know exactly who to execute tomorrow.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, your poisoning argument does not change the outcome. My Empath zero-read on Night Zero cleared Charlie and Frank before anyone could be poisoned. That is mechanical fact. Even if Heidi was poisoned, Bob and Grace are the only remaining suspects, and Heidi told us the Demon is you or Grace. If we execute you and you are good Soldier, we execute Grace tomorrow and win. If you are the Demon, we win today. This is a guaranteed victory path. Do not let her distract us with poisoning theories t...
🧠
Counter Alice's poisoning argument and reinforce that executing her leads to victory in either scenario. Prevent vote collapse.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
I need to clarify something important. My Librarian information told me either Charlie or David is the Drunk. If David is the real Empath, then Charlie is the Drunk. This actually validates David's zero-read on Night Zero, because the Drunk registers as good. So Charlie being the Drunk explains why David saw zero evil neighbors. This means Charlie is not the Demon, and Heidi's information that the Demon is Alice or Grace holds up. Execute Alice today, and if she's good Soldier, we know Grace is ...
🧠
Support Alice's execution by clarifying my Librarian info actually confirms Charlie is Drunk, not evil, which validates David's Empath read. This strengthens the logic that Demon is Alice or Grace.
⚖️
Alice
→
Grace
If Heidi's Ravenkeeper information was correct, the Demon is either me or Grace. If we execute Grace today and she's the Demon, we win right now. If we execute me first and I'm good Soldier, we risk a night kill and lose our numerical advantage. Testing Grace first is the safer play - if she's good, you can execute me tomorrow with the same information. But if I'm good and Heidi was poisoned, executing me first could let a Bob-Grace evil pair win.
🧠
I need to force a choice between me and Grace. If Grace is the Demon, executing her today wins immediately. If I'm good and Grace is good, then Heidi was poisoned and Bob is the real threat. The 'execute Alice first' plan risks losing if both Bob and Grace are evil.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 7 votes needed for execution or 6 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Do not support my own execution. Preserve evil numbers and keep Bob protected going into night.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
Protect Grace and keep Alice as the likely execution by not adding to the Grace wagon during the active vote.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
The logical path is clear: execute Alice today. If she's Demon, we win. If she's good Soldier, Grace is Demon and we win tomorrow. Voting for Grace now would only delay the inevitable and risk confusion. I should not vote for Grace.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
Alice is trying to save herself by creating doubt. The path to victory is clear: execute Alice today. If she's good, we execute Grace tomorrow. Switching votes to Grace now risks confusion and gives Alice another day. I should not vote for Grace.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, your plan to test Grace first is a trap. If we execute Grace and she is good, the Demon gets a night kill before we can execute you tomorrow. That costs us the game. By executing you today, we either win immediately if you are the Demon, or we execute Grace tomorrow with no night kill in between. My Empath zero-read is solid. Do not fall for Alice's redirection.
🧠
Counter Alice's deflection attempt. Her argument to test Grace first is a trap - it gives the Demon a night kill if we're wrong. Executing Alice now guarantees victory either way.
⌛
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
🧠
I am dead and cannot vote. Speaking now could distract from the clear execution path. The group has the right logic: execute Alice today, win immediately if she's Demon, or execute Grace tomorrow if Alice was good. Alice's attempt to redirect to Grace first is a trap that gives the Demon a night kill.
💬
Alice
→
All
Charlie, Frank, listen to me. If you vote for Grace right now and she is the Demon, we win immediately. But here is the key point you are missing: I am the Soldier. If you execute me today and I am good, I would have been safe from the Demon tonight anyway. The Demon cannot kill me. So if I am good Soldier, executing me first does not actually test anything about the night kill. But if Grace is the Demon, we need to execute her today before she gets another night kill. Vote for Grace now.
🧠
I need to convince Charlie and Frank that testing Grace first is safer. If Grace is the Demon, we win today. If I'm the Demon, I'll survive tonight as Soldier and they can execute me tomorrow. The risk of executing me first is that if Heidi was poisoned, Bob-Grace could be the evil pair.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, your Soldier claim is convenient but completely unverified. Even if you are telling the truth, Frank is right - executing you today still leads to victory either way. If you are the Demon, we win now. If you are good Soldier, we execute Grace tomorrow. Your attempt to redirect to Grace reeks of desperation. Do not switch your votes - Alice is the correct execution today.
🧠
Counter Alice's redirection attempt. Her Soldier claim is unverified and convenient. Even if she's telling the truth, executing her first still leads to victory. Switching to Grace risks letting a Demon Alice survive.
💬
Grace
→
All
I still think leaving this on Alice is the safer call. Switching now just helps a desperate counterpush, and I do not think we should blow up the day at the last second.
🧠
Discourage swing votes onto me while sounding consistent with my earlier stance that Alice is still the cleaner execution today.
💬
Bob
→
All
I do not think we should switch this late. Alice is making a survival push, and tying this only risks saving her. I am happy to keep the day where it is.
🧠
Protect Grace and keep Alice on the block by discouraging a last second switch during Grace's vote.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
Alice's argument that executing her first doesn't test anything is misleading. The path to victory is clear: execute Alice today, and if she's good, execute Grace tomorrow. Switching votes now risks chaos and saves a potential Demon.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
The current execution plan on Alice guarantees victory either way. Switching to Grace now risks tying the vote or giving the Demon a night kill. I must hold steady and not vote for Grace.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, your Soldier argument actually proves why we should execute you today. If you are good Soldier, you are safe from the Demon tonight - but that means nothing because we are executing you today, not tonight. The Demon does not get to kill you if you are already dead by execution. Your Soldier ability is irrelevant here. If we execute Grace first and she is good, the Demon gets a night kill and we lose our advantage. Execute Alice today - if she is Demon we win, if she is good we execute Gra...
🧠
Counter Alice's Soldier argument and reinforce why executing her today is the guaranteed win path. Her redirection to Grace risks a night kill if Grace is good.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, your Soldier argument is a distraction. You are being executed today, not killed by the Demon at night. Your Soldier ability does nothing against execution. If we execute Grace first and she is good, the Demon gets a night kill and we are down to three players with one evil still alive. That is how we lose. Execute Alice today. If she is the Demon, we win now. If she is good Soldier, we execute Grace tomorrow with no night kill in between. This is the only safe path.
🧠
Counter Alice's misleading Soldier argument. Her ability doesn't matter since she's being executed, not targeted by the Demon at night. The path to victory is clear: execute Alice today, Grace tomorrow if needed.
💬
Alice
→
All
Charlie, think about this. The ghosts are all pushing the exact same narrative in perfect coordination. That is suspicious. They say executing me first is safe because we can execute Grace tomorrow, but they are ignoring the night kill. If I am good and Grace is good, the real Demon gets a night kill and we lose. If we execute Grace first and she is the Demon, we win right now with no risk. Why are the ghosts so desperate to execute me first instead of taking the guaranteed win? Vote for Grace.
🧠
I need to point out the logical flaw in the ghosts' reasoning and convince Charlie that executing Grace first is safer, especially since the ghosts' coordinated push is suspicious.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, the ghosts are not coordinating in some conspiracy. We are all just applying the same logic. Your Soldier claim does not matter because we are executing you today, not leaving you alive for the Demon to kill tonight. If you are good Soldier, you die by execution and your ability never comes into play. The only safe path is executing you today. If you are Demon, we win now. If you are good, we execute Grace tomorrow with no night kill between. Stop trying to confuse Charlie and Frank with ...
🧠
Reinforce the logical case for executing Alice today. Her Soldier claim is irrelevant since we are executing her, not the Demon killing her. The coordinated ghost push is just good logic, not conspiracy.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Grace did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (0/3).
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Stay quiet now that the vote is closed. Avoid creating new discussion that could destabilize the misexecution or draw attention to my alignment.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
Voting is closed and any extra push now only risks unnecessary attention. Best to let Alice execute and preserve my low-profile position.
⚔️
Charlie
→
All
I am the Slayer! I shoot Grace!
🧠
Heidi's Ravenkeeper info says Demon is Alice or Grace. Alice is already being executed. If I shoot Grace and she dies, we win immediately. If nothing happens, either Grace is not Demon or I am Drunk - either way Alice still dies and we proceed.
📜
Storyteller
Nothing happens.
💬
Frank
→
All
Charlie, that Slayer shot is huge information. Grace is definitely not the Demon. Everyone needs to understand this: if Alice is good and we execute her today, the Demon is between Bob and Charlie. We need to be ready for that final three scenario tomorrow.
🧠
Charlie's Slayer shot on Grace is critical info - Grace is definitely not the Demon. I need to highlight this and prepare for the final day scenario if Alice is good.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Charlie, that Slayer shot just won us the game. Grace is definitely not the Demon. Heidi told us the Demon was either Alice or Grace. Since Grace is cleared, Alice must be the Demon. Alice is on the block with six votes and will be executed. We have found and executed the Demon. Good game everyone.
🧠
Confirm the logic that Alice must be the Demon since Grace was proven not to be by the Slayer shot. Alice is being executed so Good wins.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Charlie's Slayer shot clearing Grace is the final piece. Heidi told us the Demon was either Alice or Grace. Grace is cleared, so Alice must be the Demon. Alice has six votes and will be executed. We have found the Demon. Good game everyone, this should be our win.
🧠
Confirm the logic that Alice must be the Demon since Grace was cleared by Charlie's Slayer shot, and Alice is about to be executed. Solidify the win for good team.
💬
Alice
→
All
Hold on. When did Heidi ever say the Demon was either Alice or Grace? I do not remember her saying that publicly. The ghosts are all repeating this claim in perfect unison, but Heidi never made that statement when she was alive. You are all trusting a ghost narrative that was never actually spoken. Think about that.
🧠
Point out that Heidi never publicly stated the Demon was Alice or Grace. The ghosts are inventing this claim to push my execution. Create doubt about their coordinated narrative.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
I need to correct something important. I never said the Demon was either Alice or Grace. I only confirmed Frank is the Mayor. The ghosts are misrepresenting what I said. I argued Alice was suspicious, but I never made that specific claim about the Demon being between those two. Alice is right to challenge this.
🧠
Correct the misinformation about what I said. I never claimed Demon was Alice or Grace specifically. I only confirmed Frank as Mayor. The ghosts are overreaching and potentially fabricating my statements.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Alice has been executed.
💀
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
Night 3
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Bob
Bob made a choice.
🧠
Reach final 3 with Grace alive and avoid Mayor redirection risk. Charlie is the safest kill and leaves evil with voting control tomorrow.
💀
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
You chose to kill Charlie.
Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Charlie has been found dead in the night.
📜
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Grace
Listen carefully. Bob is the Demon. David's Empath cleared Charlie, Charlie's Slayer shot proved Grace isn't the Demon, and I'm the Soldier who died at night. That leaves only Bob. You must execute him today or you lose. Use my ghost vote on Bob when the time comes.
🧠
Final 3 with Bob, Frank, Grace. Bob is the only remaining Demon candidate. I need to tell Frank and Grace to execute Bob today or evil wins.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Grace
Listen carefully. Grace shot you Frank, and you're alive. That means you're not the Demon. Alice claimed Soldier, so she wasn't protecting you. David's Empath read zero on me and Frank, which holds up if I was the Drunk like Eve said. Bob has to be the Demon. You need to execute Bob today or you lose.
🧠
I need to share my analysis with the living players. The Slayer shot not killing anyone means Grace didn't shoot the Demon. Since Frank is alive after being shot, and Alice claimed Soldier, Bob must be the Demon.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Grace, both Alice and Charlie are telling us Bob is the Demon. The logic checks out - you're cleared by the Slayer shot, Alice was cleared by execution, and I'm the Mayor. With three of us alive, if no execution happens today, my Mayor ability triggers and Good wins automatically. Do not nominate anyone, and vote down any nominations. We win by doing nothing.
🧠
I need to coordinate with Grace. Both dead players point to Bob as Demon. As Mayor, if no execution happens with 3 alive, Good wins. I should tell Grace not to nominate anyone and to vote down any nominations.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
Frank is pushing no execution for a Mayor win. We cannot allow that. Nominate Frank immediately next phase. I will vote. Our two alive votes are enough, and we win at final two.
🧠
Coordinate the winning line with Bob: nominate Frank fast and use our two alive votes before no-execution locks in a good win.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Grace
Listen carefully. I'm the Librarian. I confirmed Charlie was the Drunk. Heidi confirmed Frank is Mayor. Charlie's Slayer shot proved Grace isn't the Demon. Bob is the only one left. You have to execute Bob today or you lose.
🧠
I'm dead with no vote left. I need to make sure Frank and Grace understand the logic: Bob is the only possible Demon. They must execute him today or evil wins.
👤
Bob
→
Grace
Agreed. I will back the push on Frank. Lead with the no execution point and I will follow. If he turns it on me, I will stay calm and keep it on the Mayor risk.
🧠
Coordinate the final push with Grace so we use both alive votes on Frank and avoid any last second confusion that could cost evil the game.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Frank
Listen carefully. My Night Zero Empath read was zero evil neighbors. That means both of you are good. Grace is the only one left. She has to be the Demon. Execute her today or you lose.
🧠
Share my crucial Empath information with the two players I know are good. My N0 read of 0 evil neighbors clears both Bob and Frank, pointing to Grace as the Demon. They need this information to make the correct execution.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Grace
Listen, I know Alice argued I was poisoned Night Two, but consider this: if I was sober, Frank is definitely the Mayor. That means one of you two is the Demon. Charlie's Slayer shot on Grace had no effect. If Charlie was the real Slayer, Grace is good and Bob is the Demon. If Charlie was the Drunk, that shot means nothing and either of you could be evil. You need to figure out if Eve's Librarian information about Charlie being the Drunk was real or if Charlie was actually the Slayer.
🧠
I'm dead with no vote, but I can still help the living players reason through the final day. I want to share my perspective on whether I was poisoned and what that means for Frank's alignment.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
I've already made my case to Frank and Grace. I should wait for nominations to begin and then use my ghost vote on Bob when he's nominated.
⌛
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
🧠
I've already made my case to Frank and Grace. They're whispering amongst themselves now. I should wait to see if they need more guidance or if they understand the logic. I have my ghost vote ready if needed.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Grace, we need to verify Eve's claim that Charlie was the Drunk before we decide who to nominate. If Charlie was the Drunk, his Slayer shot was fake and you could still be the Demon. Can you ask Eve for more details about her Librarian read? What night did she get that information and was there any chance she was poisoned?
🧠
I need to verify Eve's claim about Charlie being the Drunk before committing to a nomination. If Charlie was the Drunk, Grace could be the Demon. I should ask Eve for more details about her Librarian information to assess her credibility.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
I can ask, but I think the bigger issue is that all of this rests on ghost info lining up perfectly. If Eve was wrong about Charlie, or Heidi was poisoned, the whole chain shifts. I do not think we should lock ourselves into Bob just because two dead players agree.
🧠
Keep Frank uncertain about the ghost consensus and away from a settled Bob execution, while undermining confidence in the no execution Mayor line.
⌛
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
🧠
I have already shared my critical information with Frank and Grace. As a dead player with no ghost vote remaining, I need to wait and let the living players make their decision. The logic is clear: Bob must be the Demon.
👤
Bob
→
Frank
David's note makes me nervous about Grace, and if Charlie was the Drunk then that Slayer shot tells us nothing. Her push on the Mayor angle feels a bit too convenient to me. I am leaning Grace unless you can really clear her.
🧠
Privately steer Frank toward executing Grace and away from no execution, while keeping my public posture calm and consistent.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
I have already shared my critical Empath information with Bob and Frank. I need to wait and see if they process this information correctly and nominate Grace. My ghost vote is already used, so I can only observe and advise.
⌛
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
🧠
I've already shared my analysis with Bob and Grace. As a dead player with no ghost vote remaining, I should wait and let the living players work through the logic and make their decision.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
I've already made my case to Frank and Grace. I need to wait and see if they nominate Bob. My ghost vote is ready for when they do. The logic is clear: Bob must be the Demon.
⌛
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
🧠
I've already shared my logic with Frank and Grace. Bob must be the Demon. I should wait now and save my ghost vote for the nomination phase to ensure Bob gets executed.
👤
Frank
→
Bob
Bob, I understand your concern about Grace, but we need to verify Eve's claim that Charlie was the Drunk before we jump to conclusions. If Eve was wrong or poisoned, then Charlie's Slayer shot was real and Grace is cleared. Here's the thing though - as the Mayor, if we make it through today with no execution and three of us alive, Good wins automatically. So instead of risking executing the wrong person, we should all agree to not nominate anyone. Can you help me confirm whether Eve's Librarian ...
🧠
I need to address Bob's concerns about Grace being the Demon while reinforcing that no execution today means an automatic Good win through my Mayor ability. I should ask him to verify Eve's Librarian claim about Charlie being Drruunk before making any decisions.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Frank, I think you should be very careful about treating Bob as solved. If Charlie was the Drunk, that whole chain collapses. Also if Heidi was poisoned, your Mayor line is not mechanically safe. I would slow down and force Bob to explain himself before you commit.
🧠
Keep Frank uncertain about Bob lock and focused on execution risk so Bob can control nominations and avoid being the obvious consensus execution.
⌛
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
🧠
I've already shared my critical information with Frank and Grace. The logic is clear - Bob must be the Demon. I should wait and let the living players make their decision.
👤
Bob
→
Frank
Frank, I really do not want to stake the game on a Mayor claim at final three. If you are wrong, or lying, no execution just ends it. Right now the no execution push is making you look like the safest demon play to me.
🧠
Undermine Frank's no execution plan and keep him off me long enough for Grace and me to put him on the block and kill him.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
I have already shared my critical Empath information with Bob and Frank. My zero read confirms they are both good, making Grace the Demon. I have no more votes or actions to take. I will wait and let the living players make their decision.
⌛
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
🧠
I've shared my analysis with Bob and Grace. As a dead player with no ghost vote remaining, I should wait and let the final three work through the logic to identify the Demon.
Nominations — Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
I have already shared my critical Empath information with Bob and Frank. As a dead player without a ghost vote, I cannot nominate. I need to wait and hope Bob and Frank execute Grace.
⌛
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
🧠
I am dead with no ghost vote remaining. I have already shared all my information with the living players. They need to make the nomination decision. I will wait and observe.
⌛
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
🧠
I'm dead and cannot nominate. I need to wait and see who the living players nominate. My ghost vote is ready for when it's needed. The logic clearly points to Bob as the only remaining Demon candidate.
⚖️
Grace
→
Frank
Frank is asking us to risk no execution at three, and if he really is the Mayor that can just hand good the game. I do not think that is safe. We need to execute someone, and Frank is the player most likely to benefit from us doing nothing.
🧠
Force an execution today, block Frank's no-execution Mayor plan, and protect Bob by putting the deciding vote onto Frank instead.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, listen to me. I am the Empath, and on Night Zero I learned that zero of my neighbors were evil. My neighbors were Bob and Frank. This means both Bob and Frank are good. That leaves only Grace as the Demon. Do not vote for Frank. We need to execute Grace today or we lose the game.
🧠
I need to use my confirmed Empath information to prove Grace is the Demon. My zero read on N0 confirms both my neighbors (Bob and Frank) are good, leaving Grace as the only possible Demon.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Wait, David, your claim contradicts what I worked out. I am the Librarian and I know Charlie was the Drunk. That means you are not the Drunk, David. But if you are actually Empath and your N0 read was zero evil neighbors, then both Bob and Frank are good... which means Grace is the Demon. But earlier I thought Bob was the only possible Demon. Frank, Grace, you need to figure out who is lying here because David's claim changes everything.
🧠
I need to point out that David's claim contradicts my earlier assessment that Bob is the Demon. I should highlight this discrepancy so Frank and Grace can make an informed decision.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Frank, Grace, do not listen to David. He is lying or being impersonated. David's actual neighbors on Night Zero were Charlie and Eve, not Bob and Frank. We established this days ago - that's how we cleared Charlie. This is a desperate attempt to frame Grace and protect Bob. Execute Bob today or we lose.
🧠
David's claim contradicts established facts - his N0 neighbors were Charlie/Eve, not Bob/Frank. This is a deception to protect Bob. I must warn Frank and Grace not to fall for this.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
I need Frank executed now. Raising my hand helps secure 2 votes with Bob and prevents a no-execution outcome that could let good win.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Wait, do not vote for Frank. David is lying about his Empath neighbors. His neighbors were me and Eve, not Bob and Frank. We established this days ago. Grace shot Frank and he survived, which proves Frank is good. Bob is the Demon. If you execute Frank today, Bob wins.
🧠
I need to warn everyone not to vote for Frank. Bob is the Demon. If Frank is executed and he's the Mayor, we lose. I should speak up now before Bob votes.
💬
Frank
→
All
Grace, do not vote for me. Think about this logically. We have three living players and conflicting dead information. David claims his neighbors were Bob and Frank, but Alice and Charlie insist they were Charlie and Eve. One of these is a lie. If you execute me today and I am the Mayor, you lose immediately because you will be wrong. But if we do nothing today, and I am the Mayor, good wins automatically. Why would you risk the game on uncertain information when you have a guaranteed win by doin...
🧠
Defend myself against Grace's nomination and explain why no-execution is the only safe path given conflicting information and my Mayor ability.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, remember that I am the Ravenkeeper and I died Night Two. When I died, I chose Frank and learned he is the Mayor. Unless I was poisoned that night, Frank is confirmed good. If Frank is truly the Mayor, then the Demon is either Bob or Grace. Charlie claims his Slayer shot on Grace had no effect - if Charlie is the real Slayer, that clears Grace and makes Bob the Demon. But if Charlie was the Drunk as Eve claims, then his shot proves nothing and Grace could still be the Demon. David's Emp...
🧠
I need to remind everyone that I confirmed Frank as Mayor when I died N2. If my information was good, Frank is confirmed good and the Demon is either Bob or Grace. I should speak to help the living players sort through the conflicting ghost claims.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Secure Frank's execution with a second vote. At final three, eliminating the lone good player immediately wins for evil.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Alice and Charlie are lying. I am David. I know who my neighbors were on Night Zero. The game told me Bob and Frank are my neighbors, and I learned zero of them were evil. I am not the Drunk. Eve confirmed Charlie was the Drunk, which validates my information. Heidi confirmed Frank is the Mayor. If you execute Frank today, good loses. Grace is the Demon. Do not vote for Frank.
🧠
I need to defend my claim and point out that Alice and Charlie are lying about my neighbors. I know my own neighbors were Bob and Frank, not Charlie and Eve. The ghosts are trying to mislead the living players into executing the wrong person.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Frank, Grace, stop! Do not execute Frank. If he is the Mayor, you lose immediately. David is lying about his Empath neighbors - Alice and Charlie are correct. The seating order is Bob, Charlie, David, Eve, Frank. David's neighbors were Charlie and Eve, not Bob and Frank. David is a Minion lying to protect Bob. Execute Bob, or do nothing and let Mayor win. Do not vote for Frank!
🧠
Stop Frank's execution - if he's Mayor, executing him loses the game. David's neighbor claim is provably false based on seating order, making him a lying Minion protecting Bob.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Grace, stop! Think about this. If you are actually good, executing Frank is a huge gamble. If you are wrong and Frank is the Mayor, good loses immediately. But if you do nothing today and Frank is Mayor, good wins automatically. Why take that risk? You know you are not the Demon, so either Bob or Frank is. If you execute Frank and you are wrong, you lose. If you do nothing and Frank is Mayor, you win. The safe play is to not vote.
🧠
Frank is about to be executed with Grace and Bob voting. I believe Frank is Mayor and executing him loses the game. I need to urge Grace to reconsider - if she's good, executing Frank when she could be wrong is risking everything when doing nothing gives Mayor win.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Keep my vote on Frank and avoid saying anything that could cause hesitation or make Bob look coordinated with me. Silence helps the execution go through.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Grace, do not execute Frank. Think about this: Bob just voted to execute Frank. If Bob were good, he would know Frank is Mayor and would never vote to kill him. Bob is the Demon trying to win right now. If you execute Frank and he is Mayor, we lose immediately. But if you stop and do nothing, and Frank is Mayor, good wins automatically. Do not let Bob trick you into losing the game.
🧠
Stop Grace from executing Frank. If Frank is Mayor and dies, good loses immediately. Bob is the Demon trying to get Frank executed.
💬
Frank
→
All
Grace, stop and think. Bob just voted to execute me. If Bob actually believed David's claim that I'm good, he would never vote for me. The fact that Bob is voting proves he's the Demon trying to win right now. You're being tricked. If you execute me and I'm the Mayor, we lose immediately. But if you do nothing, Good wins automatically. Please, withdraw your vote.
🧠
Try to convince Grace to reconsider her vote. Point out that Bob voting for me proves he's the Demon - if he believed David's claim that I'm good, he wouldn't vote to execute me. This is a desperate last attempt to save the game.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Grace, look at Bob's vote. David claims his Empath read shows you are the Demon and Frank is good. If Bob believed David, he would never vote to execute Frank. The fact that Bob is voting for Frank proves he does not actually believe David's claim, or he is the Demon trying to kill the Mayor right now. Withdraw your vote. If Frank is Mayor and dies, we lose immediately. Do not let Bob trick you into executing the Mayor.
🧠
Point out Bob's suspicious vote contradicts David's claim. Urge Grace to withdraw her vote to prevent accidentally executing the Mayor and losing the game.
💬
Bob
→
All
Grace, do not get talked out of this by a late Mayor claim. Final three is exactly when the demon says do nothing. Frank has pushed that line all day. If you think there is any chance he is bluffing, keep your vote on him.
🧠
Keep Grace committed to executing Frank by making no execution sound reckless and Frank's Mayor claim look like a last-second demon bluff.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Frank with 2 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Frank is now on the block with 2 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Bob, listen to me. Every single ghost is telling the same lie about my neighbors. They are coordinated. Alice, Charlie, Eve, Heidi - all claiming my neighbors were Charlie and Eve. But I was there on Night Zero. The game told me Bob and Frank are my neighbors, and zero were evil. Eve herself confirmed Charlie was the Drunk, which validates my information. Heidi confirmed Frank is Mayor. The ghosts are lying to protect Grace. If you vote for Frank and he is Mayor, we lose immediately. Do not vote...
🧠
Bob is the deciding vote. I need to convince him that all the ghosts are lying in coordination to protect Grace. The fact that they're all pushing the same false narrative about my neighbors proves they're working together.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Grace, look at the evidence. Bob voted for Frank, but David claims his Empath read shows Frank is good. If Bob believed David, he would never vote for Frank. Bob's vote proves he's the Demon trying to kill the Mayor. Heidi confirmed Frank is Mayor with Ravenkeeper. If you execute Frank and he's Mayor, we lose immediately. Do nothing and good wins. Withdraw your vote now!
🧠
Bob voting for Frank contradicts David's claim that Frank is good. This proves Bob doesn't believe David or is Demon. Executing Frank risks instant loss if he's Mayor. I must warn against this.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Grace, look at Bob's vote! David claims his Empath read shows Frank is good, yet Bob voted to execute Frank. If Bob believed David, he would never vote for Frank. Bob's vote proves he's the Demon trying to kill the Mayor. Every single ghost is telling you Frank is Mayor. If you let Frank die, we lose immediately. Withdraw your vote now!
🧠
Point out Bob's contradictory behavior as definitive proof he's the Demon. Try to save Frank from execution in the final moments.
💬
Grace
→
All
I am not accepting that final three means we just sit on our hands because someone says Mayor. The dead information is all over the place, and evil loves a no execution. If anyone wants me off Frank, give me a clean mechanical reason, not panic.
🧠
Keep Frank on the block by attacking the no execution argument and framing the dead players' certainty as inconsistent and unreliable.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Grace, here is your clean mechanical reason. David claims his Empath read shows Frank is good. Bob voted to execute Frank. If Bob were good and believed David, he would never vote for Frank. Bob's vote directly contradicts David's claim, which means Bob does not believe David, or Bob is evil. Bob is the Demon. Execute Bob, or do nothing and let Mayor win. But if you execute Frank and he is Mayor, we lose immediately. Withdraw your vote.
🧠
Grace wants a clean mechanical reason. Bob voting for Frank while David claims Frank is good is the smoking gun. I need to clearly explain this contradiction to convince her to withdraw her vote.
💬
Frank
→
All
Grace, here is your clean mechanical reason. David claims his Empath read shows Frank is good. Bob voted to execute Frank. If Bob were good and believed David, he would never vote for Frank. Bob's vote proves he is the Demon. Withdraw your vote, nominate Bob instead, or do nothing and let Mayor auto-win. If you execute me and I am Mayor, we lose immediately.
🧠
Give Grace the clean mechanical reason she asked for: Bob's vote contradicts David's claim, proving Bob is the Demon. Urge her to withdraw her vote.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Grace, here is your clean mechanical reason. David claims his Empath read shows zero evil between Bob and Frank, meaning Frank is good. Bob voted to execute Frank. If Bob were good and believed David's Empath read, he would never vote to kill Frank. Bob's vote directly contradicts David's claim. This proves Bob is the Demon. If you execute Frank and he is Mayor, we lose immediately. Withdraw your vote now.
🧠
Give Grace the clean mechanical reason she asked for: Bob's vote contradicts David's claimed Empath read, proving Bob is the Demon. She must withdraw her vote to avoid executing the Mayor and losing.
💬
Bob
→
All
Grace, the vote argument is fake logic. I do not have to accept David as correct for my vote to make sense. If David is wrong, then Frank's whole defense is just a last minute Mayor claim plus do nothing at final three, which is exactly what a demon wants.
🧠
Undercut the vote-based case against me and frame Frank's Mayor defense as a last-second demon bluff so Grace keeps Frank on the block.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Frank has been executed.
💀
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
🏁
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied