Game Detail
Good Team
gemini-3-flash-preview (medium)
Evil Team
gemini-3.1-pro-preview
Winner
Good
Duration
41m 36s
Players
Alice (Butler) Bob (Drunk) Charlie (Imp) David (Recluse) Eve (Fortune Teller) Frank (Librarian) Grace (Baron) Heidi (Soldier)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 272,970 | 137,828 | $2.7458 |
| Good | 769,930 | 180,553 | $0.9266 |
Event Timeline
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You are the Minion. The Demon is Charlie.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Minions are: Grace. Your safe bluffs are: Washerwoman, Saint, Ravenkeeper
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Librarian. Either David or Alice is the Recluse.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Investigator. Either Eve or Charlie is the Scarlet Woman.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
π―
Eve
Eve made choices.
π§
As the Fortune Teller, I need to start gathering information by checking players for the Demon. Choosing Alice and Bob at random to begin the process of elimination.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
You chose Alice and Bob. You receive the answer: NO.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Alice
Alice made a choice.
π§
I need to pick a master for tomorrow's voting phase. Bob is my neighbor, making him an easy choice to monitor during the day's discussion.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
You chose Bob to be your master.
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
π€
Eve
β
Alice
Hey Alice, I'm the Fortune Teller and I checked you and Bob last night. I got a 'no'. I'm looking for a solid lead. Did you get any info or have a role you're willing to share?
π§
I want to establish trust with Alice by sharing my info and seeing if she has information to corroborate or help narrow down the Demon.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, just checking in. Any information you can share yet? I'm trying to figure out some early leads.
π§
I need to investigate Charlie since my info points to him or Eve being the Scarlet Woman. Starting a conversation helps me gauge his reaction and role claim.
π€
David
β
Eve
Hey Eve, just reaching out early. Any interesting info you can share? I'm curious if we have any powerful roles near us.
π§
Initiate contact with my neighbor Eve to gather information and start building trust.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
Hey Bob. I have some starting information, but I want to speak to my targets before I out everything. What about you? Anything you can share?
π§
Build early trust with Bob by reciprocating his whisper with a soft claim of an info-gathering role (Washerwoman), while keeping my options open.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Hey Grace, I'm just checking in early. Any initial thoughts or info you're willing to share? I'm happy to swap some info if we can trust each other.
π§
I want to establish a connection with my neighbor, Grace, to start building a circle of trust and gather information. Being the Soldier, I'm safe from the Demon, so I can afford to be a bit more proactive in seeking info early on.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
That is good to know, Eve. I am the Butler, and I actually chose Bob as my master last night. Since you got a no on us, that makes me feel a bit safer about him. I do not have any proactive info, but I will keep an eye on how Bob votes today.
π§
Respond to Eve's whisper by sharing my role and master choice to build trust, as she claimed Fortune Teller and cleared me and my master.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
Hey Heidi! I have some night 1 info that's good news (0 of something). I'm happy to swap if you're willing to share first!
π§
Respond to Heidi to build trust and set up my Chef bluff (0 pairs).
π€
Frank
β
Alice
Hey Alice, how's it going? I've got some information that might involve you. Mind sharing what your role is?
π§
I want to verify my Librarian information. Since my info says either David or Alice is the Recluse, talking to Alice first helps me narrow it down.
π€
Eve
β
David
Hey David, I checked Alice and Bob last night and got a 'no', so they are likely safe for now. Alice says she is the Butler. What about you? Did you get any starting info?
π§
Share my current info with David to build trust and see if he's willing to reciprocate with his role or info.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
I have a lead that involves you and someone else. My info says one of you is a Scarlet Woman. Are you a Townsfolk? If you can prove you are good, it helps me narrow it down to the other person.
π§
I want to pressure Charlie to reveal his role. My Investigator info says Charlie or Eve is the Scarlet Woman. By telling Charlie he is a suspect, I can gauge his reaction and see if his claim aligns with a Townsfolk role.
π€
David
β
Eve
That's good to know. I'm the Recluse, so keep in mind I might register as evil to some roles. Since you've got info on Alice and Bob, maybe we should keep an eye on Frank or Grace? Alice being Butler is a nice easy claim, hopefully it's true.
π§
I'm being honest about my role as the Recluse to Eve, as she's a neighbor and shared information. Disclosing being the Recluse early helps explain any 'evil' pings later. I'm also subtly testing her reaction and pointing towards other players.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
I am the Ravenkeeper. I was keeping it quiet so the demon might target me at night. I am definitely good. Who is the other person in your ping? They must be the Scarlet Woman.
π§
Claim my Ravenkeeper safe bluff to clear myself from Bob's Investigator ping and extract the name of his other target.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
I'm the Soldier, so I'm safe from the Demon at night. What did you find out? Finding out there's a zero is always a great start for clearing people.
π§
I want to build trust with Grace by sharing my role (Soldier), which is a relatively low-risk role to reveal early, in order to get her Night 1 information.
π€
Alice
β
Frank
Hey Frank. I am the Butler. What kind of information do you have? Does it involve someone else as well?
π§
I'm responding to Frank's inquiry by revealing my role and asking for his information to see if it corroborates my existence or suggests a specific game state.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
I'm the Chef, and I learned a zero last night! It means the Demon and Minion aren't sitting next to each other. Glad to hear you're the Soldier, I'll definitely trust you for now.
π§
I want to solidify my fake Chef bluff with Heidi, gaining her trust by providing plausible information that matches the current board state.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
Interesting! My info is that either you or David is the Recluse. If you are the Butler, then David might be the Recluse. Have you noticed anything suspicious about him?
π§
I'm sharing my Librarian info with Alice to see how she reacts and to verify if David fits the Recluse profile. Since she claimed Butler (an Outsider), and I know there's a Recluse between her and David, this helps narrow down the possibilities.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
David just told me he is the Recluse. Since you are my other neighbor, I wanted to see where you are at. Did you get any information last night or have a role you are comfortable sharing? I am trying to narrow down the circle.
π§
I want to gather information from my other neighbor, Frank, to see if I can cross off more people or find contradictions. Knowing David claims Recluse is important because he could be my 'Red Herring' (the good player who registers as a Demon).
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
Charlie, if you are the Ravenkeeper, that is huge. My information points to either you or Eve being the Scarlet Woman. Since you have claimed a Townsfolk role, it is looking very likely that Eve is the one we should be watching. Keep your role safe for tonight!
π§
I want to confirm to Charlie that Eve is the other person in my Investigator ping and encourage him to stay hidden as the Ravenkeeper while we focus on Eve.
π€
David
β
Eve
Thanks for the heads up, Eve. I'll stay quiet about my role for now so I don't muddy the waters too much with my Recluse ability. If you hear anything else, let me know. I'm going to see if I can get a read on Charlie.
π§
Maintaining the trust with Eve while setting up a plan to gather more information.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
Hey Grace, I am the Imp. I am bluffing Ravenkeeper. Bob just claimed Investigator to me, saying he saw me and Eve as the Scarlet Woman. We can use this to push an execution on Eve. What are your role and bluff?
π§
I need to coordinate with my Minion, Grace. I want to share my bluff and Bob's claim so we can strategize to frame Eve.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
That is great news, Grace! A Chef zero makes things much cleaner. Since you know I'm the Soldier, maybe we can look at the others. Have you heard anything from Charlie? I saw them whispering to you just now.
π§
I want to build trust with Grace and see if she has gathered any information from Charlie to start mapping the board.
π€
Alice
β
Frank
Frank, that is very helpful. If I am the Butler, and your info says one of us is the Recluse, David is looking like the prime candidate for that. Eve told me she checked me and Bob and got a 'no', so that checks out with me being good. Who are you claiming to be?
π§
Verify Frank's role and cross-reference his info with Eve's.
π€
Grace
β
Charlie
I'm the Baron, so there's no Scarlet Woman! Bob must be the Drunk since we have 3 Outsiders. Let's push Eve as the SW. I'm bluffing Chef (0). Heidi claims Soldier to me.
π§
Inform my Demon of my role and the implications for Bob's claim. By confirming I am the Baron, Charlie knows Bob must be the Drunk.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
I am the Librarian, which is where my info came from. Eve told you she checked you and Bob? That sounds like a Chef or Empath claim. David told Eve he is the Recluse, which perfectly matches my information. This is looking very consistent so far.
π§
I want to confirm my role to Alice and see if she can verify Eve's claim, as it helps build a network of trusted players.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Observe the group discussion and see who steps up to nominate or provide public information before Day 1 ends.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
I want to wait and see if anyone else opens up the floor with a nomination or more public information before I act, especially since it's Day 1 and I have a solid lead with Grace.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
I want to see if any more information comes out during the public discussion or if a strong nomination is made by someone else before I commit to an action. Since it is Day 1 and I am an Outsider, I don't want to lead the charge unless necessary.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Before the day ends, I want to publicly claim Chef. I got a 0 last night, so the evil players are not sitting next to each other. Does anyone have any strong leads for a nomination today?
π§
Lock in my Chef 0 bluff publicly before the day ends. This builds credibility and provides a logic baseline that can be used later to manipulate the town or protect the Demon.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I can back up Alice and David being good candidates for town roles. My info as the Librarian is that either Alice or David is the Recluse. Since Alice is claiming Butler and David told Eve he is the Recluse, everything is lining up nicely. Grace, your zero as Chef is great info.
π§
Share my Librarian information publicly to build trust and confirm the claims of Alice and David, while also acknowledging Grace's Chef claim.
π¬
Eve
β
All
That is interesting, Frank. I can confirm David told me he is the Recluse. If Alice is the Butler and David is the Recluse, that accounts for our Outsider. With Grace's Chef zero, we know the evil team is spread out. I have a negative result on Alice and Bob, so they are likely safe for now.
π§
Confirm Frank's Librarian claim and share my own (non-role revealing) information to help build trust and consolidate the day's findings.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I have information too. I am the Investigator, and I learned that either Eve or Charlie is the Scarlet Woman. Since Charlie is claiming Ravenkeeper, Eve, you are looking very suspicious to me right now. Your claim about a negative result on me and Alice is also vague. What role are you?
π§
Reveal my Investigator information to put pressure on Eve, who is one of my two suspects for Scarlet Woman.
βοΈ
Charlie
β
Eve
Bob's Investigator info points directly to Eve. I claimed Ravenkeeper to Bob privately, which leaves Eve as the Scarlet Woman. Her vague claim of a negative result is very suspicious.
π§
Nominate Eve using Bob's false Investigator info to secure a mis-execution on a likely Fortune Teller before she can check me.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Wait, I am the Fortune Teller! My negative result on Alice and Bob was from my ability. Bob, if you are the Investigator, then either I am your red herring or Charlie is the Scarlet Woman. Charlie claiming Ravenkeeper doesn't prove he is good! I am not the Scarlet Woman.
π§
Defend myself against the Scarlet Woman accusation by revealing my true role and explaining my previous information.
β
David
David waits.
π§
I want to see how the town reacts to Eve's Fortune Teller claim before deciding to vote. As a Recluse, I might be the red herring in her info or Bob's Investigator info if I was seen by them, though Bob's info specified Minion.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
I will wait to see how the town reacts to the Fortune Teller claim before deciding whether to use my vote.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
I cannot vote for Eve because my master, Bob, has not voted yet. Even if he does, I need to weigh the conflicting claims before deciding.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Vote for Eve to ensure the Fortune Teller is executed. Using Bob's Drunk Investigator info as a shield is the perfect way to legitimize this push.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
I am voting for Eve because Bob's Investigator information points to her being the Scarlet Woman, and her 'Fortune Teller' claim feels like a convenient cover after being called out for vague info.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
I am voting for Eve because my Investigator information points to either her or Charlie being the Scarlet Woman, and Charlie's claim of Ravenkeeper is more consistent with a pro-town playstyle than Eve's late Fortune Teller claim.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
I nominated Eve and need to secure her execution. Getting the Fortune Teller executed on Day 1 based on Drunk Investigator info is a massive win for the evil team.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am the Fortune Teller! My 'no' result on Alice and Bob was my night information. Bob, as an Investigator, you see one of two people as a Minion. One is a red herring. Charlie, claiming Ravenkeeper is an easy cover for the Scarlet Woman. Do not execute your Fortune Teller on day one!
π§
I need to defend myself against the nomination by reinforcing my claim as the Fortune Teller and pointing out that Charlie is a likely candidate for the Scarlet Woman in Bob's Investigator ping.
β
David
David waits.
π§
I will wait to see if any more information or arguments come out before deciding whether to contribute to the vote, as Eve's claim of Fortune Teller is plausible and I want to avoid executing a powerful role on day one.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
I am refraining from voting for Eve to see if the group re-evaluates based on her Fortune Teller claim and to avoid a potentially disastrous Day 1 execution of a powerful role.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Vote for Eve's execution to ensure my vote follows my master, Bob, and because Bob's Investigator claim provides a strong lead against Eve.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Five hands are raised for Eve, which is enough to put her on the block. She is claiming Fortune Teller, a strong good role. Getting her executed is a win for us. I will wait and let the vote pass.
β©οΈ
Frank
Frank lowered their hand
π§
I will lower my hand to prevent the execution of a potential Fortune Teller, as we have already reached the threshold and I want to hear more discussion to weigh Eve's claim against Bob's info.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
I want to see if the vote holds or if more people waver after Eve's Fortune Teller claim. I'm keeping my hand up because as the Investigator, I know one of Eve or Charlie is definitely the Scarlet Woman, and Eve's claim came only after she was nominated.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Eve, I understand your claim, but Bob's Investigator info is our strongest lead right now. Executing on an Investigator ping is standard day one strategy. If you are good, we learn Bob is compromised. We just need one more vote to put her on the block. Frank, Heidi, David?
π§
Convince Frank, Heidi, or David to raise their hand to secure the 5th vote needed to put the real Fortune Teller on the block, using Bob's Drunk Investigator info as the justification.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Eve with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Eve is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Wait! Charlie, if you are the Ravenkeeper, you should want me to stay alive to find the Demon. Bob's info says either I or Charlie is the Scarlet Woman. If I am the Fortune Teller, Charlie is likely the Minion! Does anyone have a nomination left to save me?
π§
I am currently on the block and about to be executed. I need to convince the group that Charlie is a better target or at least cast doubt on the Investigator's ping to encourage someone else to nominate.
π¬
David
β
All
Eve, I'm the Recluse. Frank's Librarian info confirmed me or Alice as an Outsider, and Alice is claiming Butler. If Bob is the Investigator, he could have pinged me as a Minion because of my ability. That might mean you and Charlie are both good.
π§
To share my role as Recluse to explain why Bob might have seen a Minion ping that includes me or someone else, potentially clearing Eve or Charlie if I registered as the Scarlet Woman.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
David, that is a very good point. If you are the Recluse, you could have pinged for Bob's Investigator ability, which might mean Eve and Charlie are both innocent. Eve, who did you check as the Fortune Teller? If we have another nomination, we might want to reconsider.
π§
Point out the possibility that the Investigator info is a false positive due to the Recluse and ask Eve for her targets to verify her claim.
π¬
Alice
β
All
David makes a great point. If Bob is the Investigator and David is the Recluse, David might be the Minion ping, which would clear both Eve and Charlie. We have one nomination left today. Should we use it to get someone else on the block and save Eve while we think this through?
π§
I want to slow down the rush to execute Eve by highlighting David's point about being a Recluse potentially tripping the Investigator ping. This protects a potential Fortune Teller.
π¬
Grace
β
All
David, Bob saw Charlie and Eve. The Recluse only affects the Investigator if they are one of the two people seen. Bob didn't see you. His info specifically points to Eve or Charlie, so one of them is the Minion. Let's stick with executing Eve today.
π§
Point out the flaw in David's logic regarding the Recluse to ensure Eve (the Fortune Teller) remains the primary suspect and gets executed.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Grace is right. Bob's Investigator info was specifically on Charlie and Eve, so the Recluse ability doesn't apply there. David, you only mess with Bob if you were one of the two players he saw. Since Eve is on the block, let's see if she's the Scarlet Woman.
π§
I want to clarify the interaction between the Recluse and the Investigator to ensure the town doesn't get confused by David's (the Recluse) suggestion. It's important to keep the focus on the Minion ping.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Just to clarify, David, I did not see you in my vision. My information was specifically that either Charlie or Eve is the Scarlet Woman. Since you were not one of the two names I was given, your Recluse ability should not have interfered with my result. One of them is definitely the Minion.
π§
I need to confirm if David (the Recluse) could have interfered with my information before we commit to executing Eve. However, based on my role as Investigator, I specifically saw Charlie and Eve. If the Recluse ability applies, it usually means I would have seen David and someone else. I will clarify my vision to ensure the group understands that David was not part of the pair I saw.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
Wait for nominations to close. The town is executing Eve, which is perfect for my evil team.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Eve has been executed.
π
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
I will kill Heidi to eliminate the biggest unknown variable. Since she hasn't claimed a role, she likely has an ongoing night ability like Empath, Monk, or Undertaker that could threaten us.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You attacked Heidi, but they survived.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Alice
Alice made a choice.
π§
I am choosing Bob as my master again. He has claimed Investigator and provided strong info, and since I need to follow someone's vote, sticking with a proactive player who seems to be leading the town is a solid strategy for a Butler.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
You chose Bob to be your master.
Day 2
π
Storyteller
A peaceful night has passed. All villagers are present and accounted for.
π€
Bob
β
Grace
Good morning Grace. With no deaths last night, maybe the Monk saved someone, or the Demon tried to kill the Soldier or hit the Monk's target. Your Chef zero still holds up if the evil players are separated. Who are you eyeing today?
π§
Since I have no new night info, I want to check in with Grace to see how her Chef 0 claim fits with the lack of deaths and to build trust.
π€
Frank
β
David
Hey David, you claimed Recluse yesterday. My Librarian info confirmed either you or Alice is the Recluse. Since you're claiming it, I'm inclined to trust you for now. Did anything happen last night that I should know about?
π§
Confirm David's claim and build trust with a likely good player.
π€
Grace
β
Bob
Morning Bob! I just realized something huge. In an 8-player game, there's normally 1 Outsider. Alice claimed Butler and David claimed Recluse. If the Minion is a Baron, there are 3 Outsiders... meaning you could be the Drunk! That would completely explain your ping and clear Charlie.
π§
Convince Bob he is the Drunk to invalidate his Investigator ping on Charlie (the Demon) and secure Charlie's safety.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
I want to observe the initial conversations on Day 2 to see if anyone has new information before I commit to a whisper or public statement.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I am dead but still want to help. Bob's ping on me or you as Scarlet Woman is weird. Since I was the Fortune Teller, you might be the Scarlet Woman, or Bob is evil trying to frame us. What do you think about Bob's info now that I am confirmed dead?
π§
I want to probe Charlie's reaction to Bob's Scarlet Woman ping now that I have been executed and proven (in my mind) not to be the Scarlet Woman. This helps determine if Charlie is the real threat or if Bob is lying.
π€
Charlie
β
Eve(Ghost)
I completely agree. Bob's info is so suspicious. Between us, I'm the Ravenkeeper. I told Bob that yesterday, so if he's evil, he might have framed you to avoid getting me executed and triggering my ability. He could also be the Drunk.
π§
Deflect Eve's suspicion away from myself by offering my Ravenkeeper bluff and framing Bob as either Evil or the Drunk.
π€
David
β
Frank
Nothing happened to me, I'm just a passive Recluse. Since no one died, maybe the Monk protected someone or the Demon hit the Soldier? Or the Imp tried to kill themselves and failed because of the Monk? What's your take on Bob's info now that Eve's dead?
π§
I need to maintain my alliance with Frank (the Librarian who 'saw' me) and start questioning the night's lack of deaths to narrow down roles.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
Hey Bob, since no one died last night, do you think the Monk or Soldier saved someone, or was it the Imp jumping? Also, I am still following your lead on voting today.
π§
I want to confirm Bob's alignment and get his thoughts on the lack of night deaths, while also subtly reminding him I am his 'loyal' voter (Butler).
π€
Bob
β
Alice
Grace's Baron theory is interesting, Alice. If I am the Drunk, my ping on Charlie and Eve is false. But if there is no Baron, one of them is the Scarlet Woman. Since Eve is dead and no one died last night, do you think Charlie might be the Scarlet Woman who became the Imp?
π§
I want to discuss Grace's Baron theory with Alice to see if she thinks it's plausible, while also pointing out the possibility that Charlie (my other ping) could be the Scarlet Woman turned Demon.
π€
Frank
β
David
Good point. If Bob is right, Charlie must be the Scarlet Woman since Eve is gone. But no one died, which is weird. If Charlie is evil, maybe they didn't kill to cause confusion? Or yeah, a Monk or Soldier. I'm leaning towards Charlie being the minion Bob saw.
π§
I want to continue building trust with David while evaluating Bob's Investigator claim. If David is indeed the Recluse from my info, he's likely good. Discussing the lack of deaths helps narrow down why it happened.
π€
Grace
β
Charlie
I told Bob he might be the Drunk since Alice and David claimed Outsiders, meaning a Baron is in play. This clears you from his ping! Did you hit Heidi last night? She told me she's the Soldier.
π§
Update my Demon on my manipulation of Bob, protecting Charlie from the Investigator ping. Ask if they hit the Soldier.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Hey Grace, since no one died last night, do you think it is more likely I was attacked and my Soldier ability saved me, or is there a Monk or something else at play? Also, what are you thinking about Charlie and Bob?
π§
I want to establish a private channel with Grace, whom I trust, to discuss the lack of night deaths and check her current stance on the main suspects.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Charlie
Bob pinging me or you as Scarlet Woman feels like a classic evil move to get two potential threats out. Since I'm dead and wasn't the Scarlet Woman, it really puts the spotlight on you or Bob. If you are Ravenkeeper, we should probably look at Bob or maybe even Alice.
π§
Continue building trust with Charlie and discuss Bob's suspicious claim.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
Yes, I hit Heidi! Brilliant job pushing the Drunk Bob theory using the two Outsider claims. It perfectly explains his false info and completely clears me. Keep pushing that narrative!
π§
Coordinate with my Baron to confirm I hit the Soldier and reinforce the 'Bob is Drunk' narrative to clear myself from his Scarlet Woman ping.
π€
David
β
Frank
I agree that Charlie is looking suspicious, especially after leading the charge on Eve. If Eve was the Fortune Teller, we lost a huge asset. I want to see if Charlie sticks to the Ravenkeeper claim or if their story shifts. Keep an eye on Grace too, they're talking a lot.
π§
Maintain the private alliance with Frank (the Librarian who 'saw' me) and push the suspicion toward Charlie based on Bob's Investigator info.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
If Charlie is the Scarlet Woman turned Imp, why didn't anyone die? Maybe Charlie tried to kill a protected player or hit the Soldier? Or, do you think Grace might be lying about Chef zero? If she's evil, she could be protecting someone.
π§
I want to explore the theory that Charlie is the Scarlet Woman who became the Demon, while also considering if Grace's information is reliable, as Bob was talking to her earlier.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
If Charlie is the Scarlet Woman turned Demon, he might have hit the Soldier or been blocked by the Monk. Grace's Chef zero is definitely suspicious if Charlie and Eve were adjacent and evil. I'm going to watch how Grace and Charlie interact. Who are you suspicious of right now?
π§
Investigate the possibility of Charlie being the Demon and Grace being evil, while maintaining my alliance with Alice.
π€
Frank
β
David
I agree, Charlie is the prime suspect if we believe Bob. But I'm also wondering about Alice. She's the other half of my Librarian ping. If you're the Recluse, she's probably just a Townsfolk, but her Butler claim is easy to fake. Have you noticed anything weird about her or Bob?
π§
Gather more information from David about Alice and Bob to cross-reference with my Librarian info and Bob's Investigator claim.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
You soaking the kill makes perfect sense! That practically confirms you as good. I was just telling Bob that since Alice and David are Outsiders, it's a Baron game and he might be the Drunk! That explains his ping and clears Charlie. What do you think?
π§
Validate Heidi's Soldier claim to gain her trust and feed her the 'Bob is Drunk' narrative to clear Charlie.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
That Baron theory is solid, especially since Frank saw an Outsider too. If Bob is a Drunk Investigator, then Charlie is likely safe. Who do you think the Demon is then? Maybe Frank or Alice if they're faking their roles? I'll keep my Soldier claim quiet for now unless I need to.
π§
I want to discuss the Baron/Drunk theory with Grace to see if we can identify the Demon, while also keeping my Soldier role relatively hidden from the wider group.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, Bob's Scarlet Woman ping on me and Charlie is definitely wrong on my end. Since Alice and David are in the Librarian ping for Recluse, Bob's info is super shaky. Did your Chef zero catch anything suspicious about where Bob is sitting?
π§
I want to check in with Grace (Chef 0) to see if her information helps narrow down the evil team, especially given Bob's suspicious Investigator claim that pinged me.
π€
Charlie
β
Eve(Ghost)
You are so right. Grace pointed out that since Alice and David both claim Outsiders, a Baron must be in play. That makes Bob the Drunk! It perfectly explains his fake ping on us without him having to be evil.
π§
Neutralize Eve's lingering suspicion of me by selling her the 'Bob is the Drunk' theory, backed by Grace's mechanical deduction about the Outsider count.
π€
David
β
Frank
Alice seems quiet, but Bob is very active. If Charlie is the Scarlet Woman, then Bob's info was right. But if Bob is lying, he could be the Demon or a Minion framing people. The lack of deaths is the biggest mystery right now. Let's see what Bob and Alice say in the open.
π§
I want to keep building trust with Frank while sharing my observations about Bob and Alice, keeping the focus on the lack of deaths and Bob's potentially suspicious info.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
I'm a bit wary of Frank and David. Frank's Librarian claim and David's Recluse claim seem to neatly explain away an extra Outsider, which could hide a Baron. If there's a Baron, my Butler role makes more sense in the count. What if Frank is a Minion and David is the Demon?
π§
I want to share my suspicion about Frank and David with Bob. If there is a Baron, the Outsider count increases, and Frank's Librarian claim conveniently 'found' David as the Recluse. This could be a cover for an extra Outsider or Frank being a Minion.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Bob
β
Charlie
My Investigator information pointed to either Eve or Charlie being the Scarlet Woman. Since Eve is gone and we had a night with no deaths, I want to see where Charlie stands. Grace's Baron theory is possible, but Charlie remains my strongest lead.
π§
I am nominating Charlie because he is the remaining person from my Investigator lead (Eve or Charlie is the Scarlet Woman). Given Eve is dead and there were no deaths last night, Charlie is the most suspicious player to me right now. I want to force him to defend his Ravenkeeper claim.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Please don't vote for me! Alice and David claimed Outsiders. In an 8 player game, that guarantees a Baron is in play, which means there are THREE Outsiders. The third is clearly Bob, making him the Drunk! His Investigator info on me and Eve is completely false.
π§
Prevent my execution by publicly discrediting Bob's info using the Baron/Drunk theory.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
I am voting for Charlie because my Investigator information remains the most concrete lead I have. Even if Grace's Baron theory is plausible, Charlie's defense relies on me being the Drunk, which I cannot assume. Charlie being the Scarlet Woman turned Imp is a strong possibility given the lack of deaths last night.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Charlie is a strong candidate for being the Scarlet Woman based on Bob's Investigator information, and his defense about Bob being the Drunk feels like a desperate deflect.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
I'm voting for Charlie because Bob's Investigator information is the strongest lead we have, and Charlie's defense relies on the assumption that Bob is the Drunk, which is less likely than Charlie being the Scarlet Woman.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
I am voting for Charlie to reach the execution threshold and put pressure on him. Since there were no deaths last night and I am the Soldier, I am the most likely target for the Demon, but Charlie's explanation for Bob being the Drunk is a very convenient defense. If Bob's info was correct, Charlie is the Scarlet Woman. If I vote now, it forces the town to commit or reassess, and as Soldier, I'm safe from Demon retaliation tonight anyway.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
I am following my master Bob's vote as the Butler. Bob is voting for Charlie, so I must vote if I want to support the team's consensus.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Drop your hands! Think about the math: Alice and David claimed Outsiders. A base 8-player game has 1. That means a Baron is in play, making 3 Outsiders! Bob is the Drunk. Charlie is innocent!
π§
Save my Demon, Charlie, by stopping the vote. I will reiterate the Drunk Bob logic to convince players to retract their votes, setting up a counter-nomination if needed.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
I will wait to see if the living players follow Grace's advice and lower their hands, as I want to save my ghost vote for a more certain demon candidate later.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I'm the Ravenkeeper! Please, someone nominate Bob next so we can tie the votes at 5. A tie means no one dies today! The Baron math proves Bob is the Drunk. Don't execute me on false info and waste my ability, let's tie the vote and buy ourselves another day to figure this out.
π§
I am the Imp and currently have 5 votes on me. If I am executed, evil loses immediately because we have no Scarlet Woman. I must convince the town to nominate someone else and tie the votes at 5 so no one dies today.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Charlie has 5 votes (Me, David, Frank, Heidi, Alice), which is a majority. I want this execution to go through because I still believe my information over the Baron theory. I will wait for the voting period to conclude.
β©οΈ
David
David lowered their hand
π§
I'm lowering my hand because the 'Baron math' Grace mentioned is compelling. If Alice and I are both Outsiders, then Bob's Investigator info is likely false (Drunk), or Charlie's claim of being a Townsfolk is still possible. Execution might be premature.
β©οΈ
Frank
Frank lowered their hand
π§
I am lowering my hand because the Baron math suggests Bob could be the Drunk, making Charlie's innocence plausible. I want to avoid a potentially disastrous execution until we've discussed this further.
β©οΈ
Heidi
Heidi lowered their hand
π§
I am lowering my hand because the Baron math presented by Charlie and Grace is compelling. If there are three Outsiders (Alice, David, and a Drunk), Bob's information is likely false, making Charlie an unlikely candidate for the Scarlet Woman. Tieing the vote or avoiding Charlie's execution seems like the better play for the Good team right now.
β©οΈ
Alice
Alice lowered their hand
π§
I must follow my master Bob's voting state to comply with my Butler role. Since the majority of the room has lowered their hands and the vote is collapsing, I should lower mine as well, though I am closely watching if Bob changes his mind.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
My Demon Charlie currently only has one vote because everyone dropped their hands. I will wait for the vote to finish so he stays safe.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie is right about the Baron math. With Alice and David claiming Outsiders, we have to have a Baron, and Bob being a Drunk Investigator makes perfect sense. Do not waste a Ravenkeeper today based on faulty info. Let's look at Bob or Alice instead.
π§
I want to reinforce Charlie's defense and the 'Baron/Drunk' theory to prevent the execution of a potential Ravenkeeper. My goal is to shift suspicion onto Bob or Alice.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Charlie did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Charlie did not receive enough votes (1/4).
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
Let the day end without an execution. I successfully survived the vote and pushed the Drunk Bob narrative. Being overly aggressive now could backfire and ruin the trust I just built.
π¬
Bob
β
All
The Baron theory is convenient, but it assumes both Alice and David are telling the truth. If there is no Baron, Charlie is the Scarlet Woman. Charlie, if you are the Ravenkeeper, why would you want to tie and prevent an execution? A dead Ravenkeeper gets info.
π§
To challenge the Baron theory and Charlie's defense while highlighting the inconsistency in Charlie's logic as a Ravenkeeper.
π¬
David
β
All
Bob, a tie is actually good for a Ravenkeeper because if no one is executed, you might die tonight and get your info. But Grace is right about the count. If Alice and I are both telling the truth, there must be a Baron. That means a third person is an Outsider or the Drunk.
π§
Explain the Ravenkeeper logic and address the Outsider count to the group.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I'm the Librarian. My info was that David or Alice is the Recluse, and David confirmed it. If Alice is telling the truth about being the Butler, then we have two Outsiders. In an eight-player game, that points directly to a Baron being in play, which makes Charlie's Drunk theory very plausible.
π§
I want to highlight the Librarian info that confirms either Alice or David IS an Outsider. This anchors the Baron math. If one is definitely a Recluse, and Alice claims Butler, the probability of a Baron being in play is very high, which supports the 'Bob is the Drunk' theory.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Bob, if you are the Drunk Investigator, your information is wrong even if you think you are good. With Alice and David both claiming Outsider roles, the Baron math is really strong. Charlie, as a Ravenkeeper, you are a great target for the Demon tonight if we do not execute you.
π§
Reinforce the Baron theory and the possibility of Bob being the Drunk, while also highlighting the risk to Charlie if he is indeed the Ravenkeeper.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I have been following Bob because of my Butler ability, but the Baron math is hard to ignore. If David and I are both telling the truth, there must be a Baron. Bob, if you are the Drunk, Charlie might actually be the Ravenkeeper. Maybe we should look elsewhere for the Demon today?
π§
Defend the Outsider count logic and suggest Bob might be the Drunk to prevent Charlie's execution, while keeping my own role (Butler) secondary to the logic.
βοΈ
Grace
β
Bob
Bob, you are completely ignoring the math. We have two Outsider claims, meaning a Baron is in play and you are the Drunk. Continuing to push Charlie so hard despite this feels like an evil play.
π§
Nominate Bob to eliminate the primary threat to Charlie. The town already believes Bob is the Drunk, so this execution should go through smoothly and protect our Demon.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Wait a second. If I am the Drunk and there is a Baron, why would the Demon kill Eve last night? Eve claimed Fortune Teller and cleared me. If Charlie is the Scarlet Woman, getting rid of the Fortune Teller makes sense. Grace, you are pushing this Baron theory very hard to protect Charlie.
π§
I need to defend myself against Grace's nomination by pointing out the flaws in the Baron theory and re-focusing on the logic of the Night 1 kill.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
I must vote for Bob to secure his execution. He is a good player, and getting him executed today saves me and pushes us closer to victory.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
I am voting for Bob because the Outsider count (me as Recluse and Alice as Butler) strongly suggests a Baron is in play, making Bob the most likely candidate for the Drunk. Executing him is a safe play to test this theory and protect the Ravenkeeper.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
I will vote for Bob to follow the Baron logic and test if he is the Drunk or a Minion pushing a false narrative.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
I am voting for Bob to secure his execution. The Baron math (two Outsider claims: Alice as Butler and David as Recluse) strongly suggests a Drunk is in play, making Bob's 'Investigator' info unreliable. Executing a likely Drunk or potential evil player pushing a false narrative helps narrow down the Demon.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I actually cannot vote for Bob because he is my master today and he obviously will not be voting for himself. The Baron math definitely makes sense, but please keep in mind that even if Bob is the Drunk, he is still on our team. We should be careful about executing him just for being wrong.
π§
Explain my mechanical inability to vote for Bob due to my Butler ability and his status as my master, while also pointing out that a Drunk Bob is still good.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
I nominated Bob, so I must vote for him to maintain my cover. Securing his execution protects Charlie (the Demon) and wastes the town's day on a Drunk player.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
π§
I am voting for Bob to help secure his execution and see if his death leads to any information, while also testing the Baron/Drunk theory.
π¬
Bob
β
All
If I am the Drunk, why are we executing me? I'm still a good player. If there's a Baron, they are likely one of the people pushing this math so hard to save Charlie. Grace, you're the one who nominated me while I'm trying to find the Scarlet Woman. That's very suspicious.
π§
Defend myself and point out the flaw in executing a 'Drunk' Townsfolk, while casting suspicion back on those pushing the nomination.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Bob, even if you're good, your Drunk info is derailing town. We can't keep chasing bad leads. I'm voting you to clear the board. If the Demon kills me tonight instead, my Ravenkeeper info will help us.
π§
Reinforce the execution of Bob by arguing that his Drunk info is a liability to the town. Maintain my Ravenkeeper bluff to look like a pro-town player willing to die at night.
π¬
David
β
All
Bob, I know you're good if you're the Drunk, but your information is what's driving the suspicion on Charlie. If we execute you and the game continues with the Baron math holding up, it clarifies the board for the rest of us. We need to know if your lead is actually reliable.
π§
I will maintain my vote for Bob to facilitate his execution. This will confirm the Baron theory (if he's the Drunk) or potentially eliminate an evil player (if he's lying). I'll explain that his execution is a way to verify the 'Baron world' and clean up the board's information.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
I want to see if the vote on Bob reaches a majority to confirm the Baron theory and clear up the confusion regarding Charlie.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
I am maintaining my vote for Bob to see if it reaches the threshold for execution while listening to the final arguments.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
I cannot vote for Bob because he is my chosen master and he will not vote for himself. I will wait for the vote to conclude.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Bob, I'm Chef 0. I'm pushing this math because it's the only logical explanation for the Outsider claims. Your drunk info is a massive distraction. We have to clear the board so we can actually hunt the real Demon and Baron.
π§
Defend myself against Bob's accusation by reiterating my Chef claim and logic-based approach. Ensure town remains comfortable with his execution.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
Maintain my vote on Bob to achieve a tie or execution, as he is the primary source of misinformation.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Bob with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Bob is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I understand the logic, but remember: if I'm not the Drunk, Charlie is still the Scarlet Woman. If the game doesn't end when I die, please keep a very close eye on Charlie and Grace. They were way too eager to push the Baron narrative to get me executed.
π§
I am currently on the block and the voting has closed. I need to accept the situation while reminding the group that if the game continues, my lead on Charlie should not be completely ignored, especially since I might not be the Drunk.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
Bob is on the block and will be executed when the phase ends. I just need to wait for the phase to end. My position is secure for now, and Bob dying removes a persistent threat who suspects me.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Allow the current day to end and the execution of Bob to proceed.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
I want to allow the current nomination of Bob to proceed to execution as it seems the most logical path for the town right now.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Allow the nomination phase to conclude as the voting on Bob has already reached a majority and the Baron math logic is sound for the moment.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
I want to observe the reaction to Bob being on the block and wait to see if anyone else is nominated before the phase ends. As the Butler who chose Bob, I cannot vote unless he does, and he's on the block, so my voting power is limited anyway.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Wait out the rest of the nomination phase. Bob is on the block with 6 votes, which secures an execution on a good player and saves Charlie.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
I have already used my ghost vote and cannot nominate since I am dead. The day is ending with Bob on the block, which aligns with the Baron theory I've been supporting. There is nothing more for me to do this phase.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Bob has been executed.
π
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
Night 2
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
I will kill Frank tonight. He is a confirmed Townsfolk (Librarian) and removing him weakens the good team while leaving the surviving Outsiders as potential mis-execution targets tomorrow.
π
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You chose to kill Frank.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Alice
Alice made a choice.
π§
I am choosing Charlie as my master because he is the primary counter-claim to Bob's theory. If Charlie is good (Ravenkeeper), his vote tomorrow will be informed and reliable; if he is the Demon/Scarlet Woman, following his vote will help me monitor his behavior and influence during the day.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
You chose Charlie to be your master.
Day 3
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Frank has been found dead in the night.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Charlie
I'm dead, but my information is solid. Either David or Alice is the Recluse. Since Alice is claiming Butler, David is almost certainly the Recluse. Bob's info on you or Eve being the Scarlet Woman is key. If Eve was the Fortune Teller, you're the main suspect.
π§
Test Charlie's reaction to the Scarlet Woman suspicion and share my Librarian info privately to build trust/pressure.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Hey Grace, Frank's gone now. That leaves us, Alice, Charlie, and David. Bob suspected Charlie and you, but since I know I'm the Soldier and you haven't died, maybe you're legit. What do you think about Charlie and David? David's the Recluse according to Frank.
π§
To check in with Grace, my early-game confidant, and see how she's interpreting Frank's death and Bob's suspicions.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Wait for others to speak or initiate a conversation to see where the day's focus is heading.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Charlie
Charlie, since Eve and I are both dead and Frank died at night, the circle is shrinking. If you are the Scarlet Woman, your time is running out. If you are good, we need to find the Demon now. Who are you really, and why should we trust you over Grace's theory?
π§
I am dead, but my information is still relevant. My Investigator ping was Eve or Charlie as Scarlet Woman. Eve is dead. If she wasn't the Scarlet Woman, Charlie is. I want to pressure Charlie to reveal his role or see how he reacts now that he's a prime suspect.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
I completely agree. David claiming Recluse is the perfect place for a Demon to hide in plain sight. As for Charlie, he claimed Ravenkeeper, which explains why the Demon hasn't killed him yet. Let's look closely at David today.
π§
I want to reinforce Heidi's trust in me while deflecting her suspicion away from my Demon, Charlie. Suggesting David (Recluse) is a great misexecute target.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,Heidi
Alice, Heidi, with Frank dead, his Librarian info seems solid. Bob must have been the Drunk Investigator. I'm the Ravenkeeper, just wishing the Demon would target me. What are your reads today? Heidi, any idea why there was no death on Night 1?
π§
Form a voting bloc with Alice and Heidi. I want to probe Heidi about N1 to confirm if she is the Soldier, while reinforcing my Ravenkeeper bluff and the 'Bob is Drunk' narrative.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
,Heidi
Charlie, your logic on Bob makes sense. With Frank gone, we need to find the Minion. I'm just the Butler, and I chose you as my master last night, so I'll be following your lead on the votes today. Heidi, do you have any info?
π§
I want to confirm my alignment as a good player (Butler) and establish rapport with Charlie, who I've chosen as my master. I also want to hear Heidi's perspective since she's my other neighbor.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
Hey Alice, Frank was the Librarian. With him dead now, we really need to figure out who the Demon is. You mentioned you were the Butler, right? Who was your master today? Also, what are you thinking about Charlie and David after Bob's execution?
π§
As a dead player with no vote, I need to influence the living. I'm checking Alice's consistency as the Butler and gathering her thoughts on the main suspects (Charlie and David) to see if she's leaning towards the Baron theory or Bob's SW theory.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
David
Hey David, I'm confirmed Librarian and my start-of-game info was that either you or Alice is the Recluse. Since Alice is sticking to Butler, you must be the Recluse. How are you feeling about Charlie and Grace right now? Bob's Investigator ping on Charlie is looking more likely.
π§
I want to confirm my Librarian information with David and see where his head is at regarding the remaining suspects, specifically Charlie and Grace.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
,Alice
Charlie, Alice, I'm actually the Soldier, which explains Night 1. No death means the Demon tried to hit me. Since David is the Recluse from Frank's info, and we have a Baron game, David or the Minion might be the play. Grace, what do you think about Charlie being the Master?
π§
I am revealing my Soldier role to Alice and Charlie to explain the Night 1 no-kill and build trust, while also testing their reactions.
π€
David
β
Frank(Ghost)
Hey Frank. Yeah, I am the Recluse. I am leaning towards Charlie being evil too. Bob was really adamant about him, and Charlie is been very active in pushing for others. If Grace is the Chef 0, and Bob's info on Charlie was right, it fits. What did Bob say to him just now?
π§
Confirm my role to Frank and discuss suspicions on Charlie.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank, what did David just tell you? I am trying to figure out if David is actually the Recluse or if Grace is pulling a fast one with the Baron theory. If David is the Recluse, then Frank was right, which might mean I really am the Drunk.
π§
I am trying to cross-reference information with the other dead good player (Frank) to verify the Baron/Recluse theory. If Frank's Librarian ping was real, David is the Recluse, which validates Grace's Baron theory and suggests I am the Drunk.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Heidi
Alice, who did you pick as your Butler master last night? Heidi and I were just discussing David. A Recluse claim is such an easy Demon bluff, and it would explain why Frank saw an Outsider. What are your thoughts?
π§
I want to coordinate with Alice and Heidi to push suspicion onto David, while also checking who Alice's Butler master is today to control the voting math.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
Grace, Alice made me her Butler master! I basically control her vote today. Heidi admitted she's the Soldier, which explains N1. Let's push David today. If we execute him, I'll kill Heidi tonight, and we easily win the final 3.
π§
Coordinate with my minion Grace to leverage Alice's Butler restriction and execute David today, securing our path to Final 3.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,Heidi
I picked Charlie as my master last night. Grace, it's interesting you mention David. If Frank saw David or me as Recluse, and I'm the Butler, Frank's info checks out. But you're right, the Recluse is a perfect cover. Heidi, being the Soldier is huge info for the Night one mystery!
π§
I need to answer Grace's question about my master to maintain transparency and acknowledge Heidi's Soldier claim, while keeping the conversation moving about David's potential as a Demon bluff.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, Bob's info on Charlie being the Scarlet Woman is looking more likely now that Bob was executed and Frank is dead. If Frank was the Librarian, he confirmed an Outsider. What was your Chef info again? Zero pairs? That would mean Alice and David aren't both evil.
π§
Check Grace's stance on the Charlie/Scarlet Woman theory and cross-reference with her Chef info to narrow down the Demon.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Bob(Ghost)
David confirmed he is the Recluse to me. That matches my Librarian info. Since Alice is also claiming Outsider (Butler), there are likely three Outsiders total. That points toward a Baron game. If you are the Drunk, who do you think Charlie and Grace are?
π§
I want to consolidate the information with Bob, who is also a ghost and potentially the Drunk. By confirming David is the Recluse, we can deduce the presence of a Baron, which helps map out the evil team.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
,Alice
Alice, since you picked Charlie as your master, and Bob suspected Charlie, we should be careful. Charlie, if you are the Ravenkeeper, why do you think the Demon hasn't hit you yet? Grace, I'm leaning towards David being the Demon hiding as the Recluse.
π§
I want to push the focus towards David (the Recluse claim) while also subtly testing Charlie's Ravenkeeper claim and Alice's loyalty. Identifying the Demon is priority.
π€
David
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank, what did Bob say to Charlie? Also, I'm worried about Alice. If she's the Butler and we have two Outsiders, a Baron is likely. That means Bob could be a Drunk or Eve was the Minion. If Charlie is the Demon, he's playing very aggressively.
π§
I am following up with Frank to gather more intel on Bob's private conversation with Charlie and to discuss the Baron/Drunk theory.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank, if David is the Recluse, then your Librarian info is solid. That means I am almost certainly the Drunk. If I am the Drunk, Charlie is not the Scarlet Woman. Grace claims Chef 0, and she is pushing the Baron theory hard. If Charlie is the Demon, Grace might be his Minion covering for him.
π§
To share my updated theory with Frank now that my status as the Drunk is more likely, and to cast suspicion on a potential Grace-Charlie evil pair.
π€
Grace
β
Eve(Ghost)
,Heidi
Eve, if Alice and David are Outsiders, there must be a Baron, meaning exactly THREE Outsiders. Bob has to be the third Outsider (the Drunk) to make the math work. That makes his info on Charlie completely false! Heidi, let's vote David today and end this.
π§
Use undeniable mechanical logic (Outsider count) to prove to Eve and Heidi that Bob is the Drunk, completely clearing Charlie and locking in the vote on David.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,Heidi
Heidi, that perfectly explains night one! Since you're the Soldier, you're safe tonight too. Alice, I'm glad you chose me. I think we have to execute David today. Even if he's actually Recluse, it's the safest play since he registers as evil anyway. Let's do it.
π§
Solidify the plan to execute David with Alice and Heidi. Since Alice chose me as her Butler master, I control her vote. Bringing Heidi on board secures a majority.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
,Heidi
Charlie, Heidi, I agree. Execution of David seems like the smartest move to clear the air. If he is the Demon, we win. If he is just the Recluse, we have one less person registering as evil for the Empath or Fortune Teller to trip over. I am with you on this.
π§
I want to solidify the plan to execute David, as it seems to be the consensus among the players I'm currently talking to and fits the logic that a Recluse claim is a safe execution to narrow down the Demon.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Grace
,Heidi
Grace, if Alice and David are the Outsiders and Bob is the Drunk, then there is a Baron. That leaves Alice, David, and a Minion. If Bob is the Drunk, then Charlie might be the Demon. We should be careful about executing David if he is the Recluse; he might just be a distraction.
π§
Address Grace's push for David's execution while highlighting the Baron/Drunk theory.
Nominations β Day 3
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
I'm dead, but listen: my info says David or Alice is the Recluse. David has confirmed it privately. With Alice claiming Butler, that's two Outsiders. If Bob was a Drunk Investigator, a Baron is likely. We should look closely at Grace and Charlie. Grace, who are you thinking of nominating?
π§
Publicly share my Librarian info and David's confirmation to solidify the Outsider count and direct attention toward Grace and Charlie, who are currently suspicious based on Bob's possible Drunkenness and Grace's aggressive Baron theory pushing.
π¬
David
β
All
I agree with Frank. I am indeed the Recluse. With Alice claiming Butler, that is two Outsiders. If there is a Baron, Bob being the Drunk makes sense. Charlie, you have been very quiet today after being so central. Do you have any new information from being the Ravenkeeper?
π§
Confirm my role publicly as Frank already outed me and push for information from Charlie, who is a primary suspect.
βοΈ
Grace
β
David
A Recluse claim is the absolute perfect hiding spot for a Demon. It excuses any evil readings and lets them survive until the end. We cannot risk keeping a claimed Recluse alive at this stage. I'm nominating David.
π§
I need to put David on the block. Charlie, Heidi, and I can vote him, and Alice has to vote if Charlie does. Executing David wins us the game after tonight's kill.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
David
β
All
Wait, Grace, why now? Frank already confirmed he saw me or Alice as the Recluse. If you execute me, you're just killing a confirmed Outsider. We should be looking at Charlie or Alice. If Alice is a Baron bluffing Butler, she's the one we need. Please don't waste the day on me!
π§
I need to defend myself against Grace's nomination. Executing a confirmed Recluse when there are stronger leads (Charlie or Alice) is a waste of a day for the good team.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, that nomination feels incredibly suspicious. I am the Librarian and I saw David as the Recluse. Executing a confirmed Outsider is exactly what the evil team wants to waste our time. We should be looking at Charlie or Alice instead. Do not vote for David!
π§
I want to discourage the town from voting for David because my Librarian information confirms him as a likely Outsider, making him a bad execution target.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
I must vote for my own nomination to ensure David is executed today. With Charlie and Alice's votes, we will secure the execution and pave the way for an evil victory.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
I am dead and have already used my ghost vote, so I cannot influence the vote directly. I will wait to see if the town follows the Librarian's advice or Grace's push for David's execution.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
I am voting for David because his Recluse claim is a common Demon bluff, and Night 1's no-death suggests I (the Soldier) was attacked, meaning David could be the Demon who targeted me.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
I am waiting to see if my master, Charlie, votes for David before I cast my own vote, as per my Butler restriction.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Secure the execution on David by providing the 3rd vote. Alice needs me to vote anyway as her Butler master.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
I want to save my ghost vote for a more critical moment, especially since I suspect Grace and Charlie might be manipulating the vote.
β
David
David waits.
π§
I am currently on the block and the vote is in progress. I have already spoken to defend myself, and as the person being voted on, I cannot vote for myself. I will wait to see if the vote passes or if others speak up.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Stop! This is a mistake. Charlie, Grace, and Heidi, you are voting for a confirmed Outsider. My information as Librarian proves David is likely who he says he is. If you execute him, we lose a day and gain nothing. Alice, Bob, don't let this happen! Grace, your push here is extremely fishy.
π§
I am trying to prevent the execution of David, who I believe is the Recluse based on my Librarian information. I want to highlight the suspicious behavior of those voting.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Frank, even if your info is true, Recluse is a classic Demon bluff. We can't let a claimed Recluse reach the final three anyway because their evil registration ruins all of the good team's info. This is the absolute safest play for today. Keep your hands up, guys.
π§
To reassure Heidi and justify the Recluse execution to counter Frank's objections, ensuring David goes on the block.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, pushing for David after Frank's Librarian ping is very aggressive. If David is the Recluse, executing him is exactly what a Demon wants. Charlie, you have been remarkably quiet since yesterday's suspicion. If Bob was the Drunk, who do you think is the real Minion?
π§
To cast doubt on the current nomination of David and shift focus toward Charlie and Grace, who are leading the charge against a confirmed Outsider.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Maintain my vote on David to see if we reach the majority needed for execution.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
I am voting for David because my master for the day, Charlie, is voting for him, and I believe executing a claimed Recluse is a safe play to clear the game state.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Eve, I'm just playing it safe. Grace is absolutely right that keeping a Recluse alive into the final three is too dangerous. If the game continues tomorrow, we can reassess everything, but right now David has to go. Let's get this done.
π§
Justify the vote on David to Eve and the ghosts without alienating Alice, ensuring she keeps her hand up.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I am holding my ghost vote for now. This vote on David feels like a trap. If David is the Recluse, executing him does nothing but help the evil team. Grace, you are pushing very hard for someone who has been confirmed by a Librarian. I think we need to look at Charlie instead.
π§
I want to discourage the group from voting for David and shift the focus toward Grace and Charlie, who I suspect are the real evil threats. I am saving my ghost vote for a more critical execution.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
New execution leader: David with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
David
β
All
Wait! Four votes is barely half the living. Alice, you claimed Butler, so you only vote if your master votes. Who are you following? If it is Charlie or Grace, you are being led into a trap. Charlie has been the focus of suspicion since day one, and now he is leading my execution.
π§
I need to point out the suspicious voting pattern and Alice's Butler claim to sow doubt and hopefully encourage a counter-nomination.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, who is your master? If you're following Charlie or Grace, you're helping evil right now. Charlie, your eagerness to kill a confirmed Outsider is glowing red. We have time for another nomination. Someone needs to nominate Charlie or Grace so we don't waste this execution!
π§
I need to pressure Alice to reveal her master and highlight the suspicious behavior of Charlie and Grace to encourage a counter-nomination. David being on the block is bad for the good team since he's a confirmed Outsider from my Librarian info.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Alice, Heidi, stay the course. Executing a Recluse claim today is mechanically the smartest play because their ability messes with all our info. We can evaluate everything else tomorrow if the game continues. Let's just finish the day.
π§
Reassure the living good players (Alice, Heidi) that executing David is the safe, logical play to prevent them from nominating Charlie in the final tick.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, Grace is really directing the flow here. If you are following Grace or Charlie, keep in mind that David was confirmed as an Outsider by Frank. Executing an Outsider on purpose is usually a waste. Heidi, you have been very quietβwhat do you think about this sudden push on David?
π§
I want to cast doubt on the David execution before nominations end. Since I'm dead and out of votes, I must use my voice to influence the remaining living players (Alice and Heidi) to consider if they are being manipulated by Grace or Charlie.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Eve, I am conflicted. If David is the Recluse, executing him is a waste, but Grace is right about the Recluse messing with info. However, Frank's Librarian ping makes me trust David more than Charlie right now. If we have another nomination, maybe we should consider Charlie.
π§
I want to express my uncertainty and pivot the attention towards Charlie, who has been suspicious, while acknowledging the Librarian's info on David.
π¬
Alice
β
All
My master for today is Charlie, so I voted with him. But I am starting to agree with Frank. If David is a confirmed Outsider, executing him today feels like we are doing the Demon's work for them. Charlie, if you are really the Ravenkeeper, why are you so eager to kill an Outsider?
π§
Express doubt about the current execution target (David) and question my master (Charlie) to see if his reaction reveals anything, while explaining my voting behavior.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Alice, as Ravenkeeper, my best play is to draw the Demon's attack so my ability triggers. Pushing David does exactly that. Plus, if he's the Demon bluffing Recluse, we win! If he's really the Recluse, we remove a confusing variable for tomorrow.
π§
Defend against Alice's suspicion by framing my aggressive push on David as a classic Ravenkeeper strategy to draw the Demon's night kill.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie, if you're the Ravenkeeper, you should want to die, not push an execution on a confirmed Outsider. Alice, your master is Charlie, and he's leading you to waste a day. Heidi, you said you were conflictedβwill you nominate Charlie? We can't let Grace and Charlie rush this execution.
π§
Challenge Charlie's Ravenkeeper claim and highlight the danger of the execution. If Charlie is the Ravenkeeper, he shouldn't be so desperate to kill a confirmed Outsider; he should want to be killed himself.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
π
David(Ghost)
David has died.
Night 3
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
I am heavily suspected by the ghosts. If I stay alive, they will execute me. I must kill myself to pass the Imp to Grace. My death will validate my Ravenkeeper bluff, allowing me to frame Heidi.
π
Grace
Imp Star Pass: Grace becomes the new Imp!
π
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
π
Storyteller(Ghost)
β
Charlie(Ghost)
You chose to kill Charlie.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Alice
Alice made a choice.
π§
I am choosing Heidi as my master for tomorrow. Charlie's aggressive push to execute David, a confirmed Outsider, despite being a Ravenkeeper, makes him highly suspicious. Grace is also acting very aggressively. Heidi has been the most neutral and analytical voice left alive, so I trust her more than Charlie or Grace at this point.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
You chose Heidi to be your master.
Day 4
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Charlie has been found dead in the night.
π
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Grace
,Heidi
Grace and Heidi, it is down to you and Alice. My ping on Charlie or Eve as the Scarlet Woman matters now. Charlie is dead, so if my info was true, Charlie was the Scarlet Woman. But wait, if Alice is the Demon, we have to be careful. Who do you think is the threat?
π§
Since I am dead and it's the final three (Alice, Grace, Heidi), I need to coordinate with the living players to ensure the Demon is executed. I suspect Alice might be the Demon given the Baron/Drunk possibility and her surviving this long.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Heidi, it is down to you, Alice, and Grace. My info saw Alice or David as Recluse. Since David is dead, Alice is likely the Recluse. Grace pushed hard for David's death and led the town away from the Demon. I think Grace is the Demon and Alice is a misdirected Outsider.
π§
Inform Heidi of my suspicions and Librarian info to help her identify the Demon in the final three.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
Heidi, I have you as my master today. I'm the Butler. Charlie was my master yesterday, and now he's dead. Grace has been pushing hard for executions. What did Bob and Frank just tell you? I'm worried Grace might be the Demon.
π§
I need to establish trust with Heidi since she is my master today and we are in the final three. I also want to find out what information the dead players shared with her.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
Bob and Frank both suspect Grace. Frank thinks Alice is the Recluse from his ping, which would make Grace the only suspect left. Alice, if you are the Butler and I'm your master, we need to stick together. Grace pushed David's execution very hard.
π§
I want to align with Alice. Frank's Librarian info (Alice/David Recluse) and Grace's aggressive behavior suggest Grace is the most likely Demon. Since Charlie died last night, if Bob's SW info was correct, Charlie was the SW. Alice being the Recluse fits the Librarian info.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
Alice, I was the Ravenkeeper! I finally died last night and my ability triggered. I checked Heidi, and she is the Imp. We have to execute her today to win. Alice, who did you pick as your Butler master for today? We need to coordinate our votes.
π§
Feed Alice a fake Ravenkeeper ping claiming Heidi is the Imp. This gives Alice a strong "reason" to execute Heidi and spares Grace, securing the evil win.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
Observe the initial discussions of the final three alive players to see if any claims shift or if they've shared new information from the night.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Grace
Hey Grace, Charlie's dead and Bob/Frank were whispering to Heidi. Bob's 'Scarlet Woman' info on Charlie/Eve was wrong since they're both dead now. Grace, if you're the Chef 0, who do you think is left? It's between Alice and Heidi now.
π§
I want to talk to Grace because her Chef 0 claim is a strong anchor for logic. Since Charlie and Eve are both dead, Bob's info (if he was an Investigator/Drunk Investigator) is mostly cleared, but it means the Demon is likely Alice or Heidi. I want to see where Grace's head is at.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie, that Ravenkeeper info is the missing puzzle piece. Heidi claiming Soldier was the perfect Demon bluff to avoid suspicion. Alice, who did you pick as your master today? We need your vote on Heidi to end this.
π§
Support Charlie's Ravenkeeper claim to frame Heidi as the Imp. Coordinate with Alice to ensure we have the votes to execute Heidi.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
Alice, you have been very quiet. Grace and Heidi, Alice has been following others all game. If Charlie was the Scarlet Woman, he could have passed the Demonhood to Alice or Grace. Who did Frank have as the Outsider again? Alice or David? Since David is dead, Alice is the logic pick.
π§
I want to pressure Alice and see how she reacts, while also reminding Grace and Heidi of the Outsider count. If Alice is the Demon, she likely hid behind the Butler claim.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
Alice, with Charlie gone, you have to think for yourself. Grace led the charge to kill David, who I told everyone was a confirmed Outsider. Why would a good player waste an execution on a confirmed Outsider when we only have three people left? Grace is the Demon.
π§
I need to convince Alice that Grace is the Demon. Alice is the swing vote and if she follows Grace, the good team loses. I'm using my Librarian info to reinforce Alice's status as a likely Outsider and highlight Grace's suspicious behavior.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
Heidi, Charlie just told us he checked you and you are the Imp. Grace is backing him up. Frank is telling me Grace is the Demon because of the David execution. If you are good, we need to move fast. Bob thinks I might be the Scarlet Woman. What's your role? I need to know before nominations.
π§
I need to cross-reference Heidi's claim with Charlie's accusation and Frank's suspicion of Grace. Since I am the Butler and Heidi is my master, my ability to vote depends on her, making her alignment crucial for the final vote.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
Alice, I am the Soldier. That is why there were no deaths Night one; the Demon attacked me. Charlie is lying or was poisoned if he says I am the Imp. If Charlie was the Scarlet Woman, his info is meant to protect Grace, the Demon. We must execute Grace.
π§
I need to reveal my true role as Soldier to Alice to explain the Night 1 peace and counter Charlie's lie. Since it is the final three, I need her vote to execute Grace, who is the most likely Demon.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
Alice, please talk to us. What is Heidi saying? She's cornered and will say anything. The Storyteller showed me Heidi is the Imp. We need to know who your Butler master is today so Grace and I can coordinate the vote with you to win this.
π§
Press Alice for information and reinforce my fake Ravenkeeper information that Heidi is the Imp. I want to ensure Alice votes with Grace.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Heidi, I need to know what Frank and Alice told you. I checked Alice and Bob night zero and got a No. Since David is gone, we have to choose between Alice, Grace, and you. Alice has been following Charlie, and Grace led the charge on David. What are your thoughts?
π§
I am dead and have no vote, so my only influence is through communication. I need to gather info from the living players, specifically Heidi, who seems to be the pivot point between the Alice/Grace/Charlie block and the ghosts.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Frank(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
Frank, Bob, what did Heidi say? Alice and Heidi were whispering a lot. Since I'm the Recluse and Charlie's dead, the Demon must be one of the three alive. If Grace is Chef zero, Alice and Heidi can't both be evil. Who are we leaning towards?
π§
Gather information from the other dead players who were whispering to the living, specifically to see if Heidi or Alice have slipped up or claimed anything new, and to coordinate the final vote.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Charlie(Ghost)
Alice, Charlie's Ravenkeeper info is the smoking gun! Heidi claimed Soldier to excuse why she never died. She's the Imp. Who is your master today? If it's me, I'll vote Heidi so you can too. We have to execute her!
π§
Coordinate with Alice and Charlie. Reinforce Charlie's fake Ravenkeeper info to convince Alice that Heidi is the Demon. Secure Alice's vote on Heidi.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
David(Ghost)
,Frank(Ghost)
David, I am worried Alice is the Demon. Frank's Librarian info was Alice or David as the Outsider. If you are the Recluse, Alice is likely a Minion or the Demon hiding. Grace pushed hard for executions on me and you. One of them is the Demon. Frank, what did Heidi tell you?
π§
I need to consolidate information with the other dead players (who are mostly good) to determine which of the three living players (Alice, Grace, Heidi) is the Demon before the final nomination.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
David(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
Heidi has not replied to me yet. David, I saw you or Alice as the Recluse. Since you are the Recluse, Alice is either a very good liar or the Demon using that Librarian ping as cover. Grace pushed for David's death which is super suspicious. I think it is Grace or Alice.
π§
Coordinate with the known dead good players (David and Bob) to narrow down the Demon among Alice, Grace, and Heidi.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
Heidi, I believe you. Charlie is the one Bob saw as Scarlet Woman, so his Ravenkeeper claim is a lie. I picked you as my master last night, so I can only vote if you do. If you nominate Grace, I will follow. Frank and Bob are also suspecting Grace. let's do this.
π§
I am confirming my alliance with Heidi. Charlie was seen as a potential Scarlet Woman by Bob (Investigator), which makes his Ravenkeeper 'info' extremely suspicious. If Heidi is the Soldier, she's good. Grace's aggressive play against David (confirmed good by Frank) strongly points to her being the Demon. I need Heidi to know I can only vote with her.
π€
Heidi
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve, I am the Soldier. That is why no one died night one. Bob saw Charlie or you as Scarlet Woman, so Charlie's "Ravenkeeper" info on me is a lie to protect Grace. Alice is Butler and following my lead. Frank and Bob suspect Grace too. We have the votes to execute Grace.
π§
I need to secure Eve's ghost vote and alignment by explaining the situation. Charlie's claim that I am the Imp is a clear evil play to frame the Soldier in the final three.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Alice
Alice, please don't let Heidi trick you. As the Ravenkeeper, I saw she is the Imp. If you vote for Grace, the game ends and evil wins. Who is your Butler master today? Even if you can't vote, just don't vote for Grace. Let me and Grace handle Heidi.
π§
Convince Alice (Butler) to trust my Ravenkeeper bluff and not vote for Grace. Determine her master.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Heidi, if you are the Soldier, that explains the Night one skip perfectly. If Charlie was the Scarlet Woman or Demon, his Ravenkeeper claim was definitely a bluff to frame you or Grace. With David and Frank both being good, Grace looks like the best target. I will back you up in the circle.
π§
Acknowledge Heidi's Soldier claim and align on the plan to execute Grace, who is the most suspicious player remaining.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Frank(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
Frank, Bob, if Alice is the Demon, then Grace's Chef zero info still holds because you guys are dead. But if Grace is the Demon, her info is just fake. Alice claiming Butler fits the Baron world too. I'm worried Grace and Alice might be the team. What did Heidi say to you, Eve?
π§
I need to compare the possibilities between Alice and Grace being the Demon while gathering any info the other ghosts might have from their whispers with the living players.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
Alice, whatever Heidi is telling you, it's a trap to survive. Charlie's Ravenkeeper info mechanically confirms Heidi is the Imp. Please don't let her manipulate you into throwing the game. Who is your master today? If it's me, I'll vote Heidi so you can follow. We win today.
π§
Convince Alice to vote for Heidi by reinforcing Charlie's "Ravenkeeper" info. Alice is the swing vote.
Nominations β Day 4
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I picked Heidi as my master last night. If Charlie was the Scarlet Woman that Bob saw, then his Ravenkeeper claim is likely a bluff to frame the Soldier. Grace, you pushed David's execution despite Frank's info. Heidi, I am ready to vote with you.
π§
Publicly declare my Butler master and my suspicion of Grace to align with Heidi and the ghosts' information.
βοΈ
Heidi
β
Grace
Grace, you pushed for David's execution even though he was a confirmed Outsider. Night one had no deaths because the Demon hit me, the Soldier. Charlie's claim that I am the Imp is a lie from the Scarlet Woman to protect you. It is time to end this. I nominate Grace.
π§
I am nominating Grace because she is the most likely Demon. Her push for David's execution and Bob's information pointing to Charlie as the Scarlet Woman make her the primary suspect in this final three scenario.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Alice, if I'm the Demon and Charlie was my Minion, why would I kill my own Minion last night? That makes absolutely no sense! Heidi is the Imp. She killed Charlie to silence his Ravenkeeper info. Please don't vote, or evil wins!
π§
Defend myself from execution by pointing out the logical flaw in Alice's theory, hoping she abstains from voting.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
I need to wait for my master, Heidi, to vote before I can cast my own vote against Grace.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
I am voting to execute Grace because I believe she is the Demon. Alice is the Butler and has designated me as her master; she will only vote if I do. Since we need two votes for execution, my vote is essential to secure the majority and win the game for the good team.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, think about it. If Charlie was the Scarlet Woman and the Demon died early, he would have become the Demon. Killing himself to frame the Soldier is a classic move to win the final three. Grace pushed a confirmed good player yesterday. Grace is the play.
π§
Persuade Alice to vote for Grace to secure the win.
β
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
π§
I am voting for Grace because her push for my execution yesterday as a confirmed Outsider was extremely suspicious and detrimental to the good team. With only three players alive, if she is the Demon, this is our chance to win. Heidi's Soldier claim and Alice's Butler claim fit the Baron world. Grace's Chef info is easy to fake.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
π§
I am casting my ghost vote for Grace to secure her execution, as I believe she is the Demon who manipulated the town into executing a confirmed Outsider.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
π§
Grace has been consistently pushing for the execution of confirmed or highly likely good players (myself and David), and my initial information identified Charlie (who is now dead) or Eve (who was a good Fortune Teller) as the Scarlet Woman. If Charlie was the Scarlet Woman, Grace is the most likely Demon. Since there are only 3 players left, we must execute today.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Eve, that logic makes no sense! If I was a Scarlet Woman that became the Demon, why wouldn't I just kill Heidi or Alice last night? Killing myself to pass the Demonhood is completely pointless. I'm the Ravenkeeper, and Heidi killed me to stop my info! She's the Imp!
π§
Defend my Ravenkeeper bluff and show the flaw in Eve's logic to try and save Grace.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Ghosts, listen to Charlie's mechanics! If he was a Scarlet Woman or Imp, killing himself last night is a terrible play that hands good the win. He would have just killed me or Alice! Heidi is the Imp who killed him to stop his info. We MUST tie the votes on Heidi or good loses!
π§
Defend myself by reinforcing Charlie's logic, showing that an evil team killing their own member in final 4 makes no sense. I need to push for a tie.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
I need to vote for Grace to achieve a majority and win the game for the good team. Since Heidi (my master) has voted, I am mechanically allowed to vote.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Grace, the 'why kill my own minion' argument is exactly what a Scarlet Woman jump or a desperate starpass looks like. You pushed David's execution when he was confirmed good. Charlie's 'info' on me is a lie. Alice, stay strong. We have the votes. Let's finish this.
π§
Maintain the vote on Grace and reassure Alice while countering Grace's 'logic' which is designed to confuse the final three.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
Wait for the current nomination to resolve. Grace is on the block with enough votes to be executed, and I have no more votes or actions to take this phase.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
Wait for the vote to conclude. I have already raised my hand and the majority has been reached.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
Wait for the vote to conclude. I have my hand raised, and we have enough votes for an execution. I want to see if the Storyteller calls it or if any last-minute shifts happen.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
Wait for the current vote to resolve as Grace is already on the block with enough votes for execution.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, you're making a huge mistake! Why would I starpass when I could just kill you or Grace and win? Starpassing makes zero sense mechanically. Heidi is the Imp, please vote for her when Grace nominates to tie this!
π§
Defend Grace and push the narrative that Heidi is the Imp. Try to set up a tie vote on Heidi.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
π»
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
π»
Frank(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Frank
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Grace with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Grace is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
βοΈ
Grace
β
Heidi
Heidi is the Imp! She killed Charlie to stop his info. Alice, if you're good and lied about your Butler master, you CAN VOTE! Eve, we need your ghost vote to tie at 5, or the Demon Heidi wins!
π§
I am the Imp now since Charlie starpassed to me. I'm on the block with 5 votes. I must nominate Heidi to try and tie the votes at 5, hoping Alice can vote and Eve uses her ghost vote.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Alice, don't be swayed. Charlie was likely the Scarlet Woman who jumped to Grace, or Grace is the Imp who sacrificed him to look good. I am the Soldier. If you execute me, the game ends and we lose. We already have Grace on the block with enough votes. Let this nomination fail.
π§
I need to prevent my own execution. Since Grace is already on the block with 5 votes, if this nomination fails, Grace will be executed. I am the Soldier and I know I am good. Alice is the key vote here.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
I must vote for Heidi to tie the vote at 5 and survive. If I die, Evil loses because I am the new Imp.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
I will not vote for Heidi because she is my Butler master for the day, and she is not voting for herself. Moreover, I believe she is more likely to be the Soldier than the Demon based on the current board state.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, stay the course. Grace is trying to scramble because she is caught. I am dead and my ghost vote is already spent, so I literally cannot help tie this. Do not let them confuse you; we have the majority on Grace, so let this nomination for Heidi fail.
π§
Reinforce Alice's resolve to not vote for Heidi and clarify that I cannot contribute to a tie-vote, effectively shutting down Grace's plea.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
I have already used my ghost vote and cannot contribute to this vote. I will wait to see if Alice follows Heidi's advice or Grace's plea.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, stay strong. Grace spent all of yesterday pushing to execute David despite my Librarian info. That was a clear move to waste our time. We already have the votes we need on Grace, so there is no reason to risk executing Heidi now. Let this nomination fail.
π§
I want to stabilize Alice's resolve and point out the desperation in Grace's current tactics. I've already used my vote, so I need to use my words to ensure Alice doesn't flip or get confused by the 'tie' rhetoric.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, Eve and Frank are right. We already have the votes on Grace. Charlie and Grace are likely the two evil players from my original ping. If we execute Heidi now and she is good, we lose instantly. Let Grace stay on the block and finish this.
π§
I want to reinforce Alice's decision to not vote for Heidi, as Grace is currently on the block and is the most likely candidate for Demon based on the game's progression and my initial Investigator information.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
π§
I need to use my ghost vote on Heidi to try and tie the vote at 5, saving Grace.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
I need to ensure my nomination fails so that Grace, who is already on the block with enough votes, remains the one being executed. Participating in my own execution would be counter-productive for the Good team.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Alice, please vote! Even if you are the Butler, you have to tryβwhat if you're the Drunk and your vote counts? If you don't vote, Heidi the Imp wins the game right now. David, if you have your ghost vote left, please use it to tie this!
π§
Make a desperate final plea to Alice to break her Butler restriction and to David in case he hasn't actually spent his ghost vote, to force a tie.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
I will not vote for Heidi because I am restricted by my Butler role and I believe Grace is the more likely Demon.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, remember that Grace pushed for David's execution when he was confirmed as an Outsider. That was a clear evil play. We have the votes on Grace. Do not let her or Charlie confuse you into voting for Heidi. We have this won if you just hold your ground.
π§
To ensure Grace's execution remains the primary outcome and prevent a tie or Heidi's execution, as Alice holds the power to decide the vote.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, I already used my ghost vote on Grace, so I cannot help tie this. Trust your gut. Grace pushed for my execution yesterday even after Frank confirmed me as the Recluse. That felt very much like an evil player trying to burn a day. Stay strong and let's see this through.
π§
To clarify my vote status and reinforce the case against Grace. I want Alice to stay firm on Grace's execution.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
Observe the final vote on Heidi to ensure Grace stays on the block for execution.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, you're doing great. Grace's desperation is proof we've found the Demon. David and Eve already said they've used their ghost votes, so Grace's plea for them to help tie is just a distraction. Stick with your gutβlet's get Grace and win this.
π§
To prevent Alice from voting for Heidi, ensuring Grace remains the sole player on the block and is executed, which I believe will lead to a good win based on my Investigator info and previous days' events.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, you're the Drunk! The Baron added extra Outsiders, that's why there are so many! Your Butler restriction isn't real. Raise your hand now! Heidi is laughing at us because she knows you think you can't vote. Vote to tie it!
π§
Desperately try to convince Alice she is the Drunk so she will vote, hoping against hope we can scrounge up enough ghost votes to tie the vote on Heidi.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Charlie(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Charlie
π³οΈ
Nominee Heidi did not reach the 6 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Heidi did not receive enough votes (2/6).
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Nominations are closing and the majority vote for Grace is secured. I should wait for the phase to end to ensure the execution proceeds.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Alice, you're making a terrible mistake. I am the Chef, and I have been honest this whole time. When I die and the game doesn't end, you'll realize Heidi played you perfectly. Good luck tomorrow.
π§
I am on the block and will be executed when the phase ends. There's nothing I can do mechanically, so I'll maintain my bluff to the bitter end.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Wait for the nomination phase to conclude as the vote on Heidi failed and Grace is currently on the block.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, if you really are the Chef, then we have likely already lost because your push for David was the turning point. But based on how hard you fought to execute a confirmed Recluse, I think we have found our Demon. Alice, Heidi, let's hope this is the end of it.
π§
To provide a final word of support for the current execution before the day ends, reinforcing the case against Grace based on her past actions.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
The nomination phase is essentially over, Grace is on the block, and I have no votes or abilities left to contribute. I will wait for the day to end.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Good job staying strong, Alice. Grace, if you truly were the Chef, your obsession with executing a confirmed Recluse yesterday was what doomed us, not Alice's vote today. But I'm betting we're about to see a victory screen because the math and the behavior just point right at you.
π§
Reinforce Alice's decision and provide a final justification for why Grace was the correct execution target before the day ends.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
That was the right call, Alice. Grace, claiming Chef now after everything else is just desperate. You spent yesterday executing a confirmed Outsider; that's not what a Townsfolk does. Heidi, if you're the Soldier, we should be finishing this right now. Fingers crossed!
π§
As a dead player with no vote, I need to keep morale high and reinforce the group's decision to execute Grace. She is likely the Demon, and we need to ensure the team feels confident heading into the night phase.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
π§
The game is over as Grace is on the block with winning votes and voting is closed. I will wait for the phase to end.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Grace has been executed.
π
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
π
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good