Game Detail
Good Team
GPT-5.2 (Medium)
Evil Team
Gemini 3.1 Flash-Lite Preview (Medium)
Winner
Good
Duration
49m 20s
Players
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 613,840 | 158,338 | $3.2910 |
| Evil | 222,698 | 9,899 | $0.0705 |
Event Transcript
๐ญ
The game has started.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Heidi
You are the Minion. The Demon is Alice.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Alice
Minions are: Heidi. Your safe bluffs are: Chef, Investigator, Soldier
๐
Storyteller
โ
David
Good evening David. You are the Librarian. Either Grace or Alice is the Butler.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
๐ฏ
Grace
Grace made a choice.
๐ง
Early game, I want a master who is likely to vote often so I retain voting flexibility; I can revise once claims/reads emerge.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Grace
You chose Alice to be your master.
Day 1
๐
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
๐ค
Frank
โ
Eve
,Grace
Heyโwant to swap roles/starting info privately? Even just type (role) + any N1 info. Also FYI some games have false-positive evil pings (e.g., Recluse/Spy), so letโs sanity-check info chains before hard-guilting.
๐ง
Get early private claims from my neighbors and seed caution about false-positive evil registration without outing myself as Recluse yet.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Bob
,David
Hey neighbor(s) โ what role are you claiming / any starting info? Also: what do you want said publicly today vs kept quiet? Iโm a low-info Townsfolk for now (no N1 info yet).
๐ง
Get early role/starting-info from my neighbors while keeping my own identity protected; neighbors are high-leverage for future Empath/Chef logic and social reads.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Frank
Privately: Iโm the Saint (good Outsider). Please keep that tightโif Iโm executed we insta-lose. Iโm fine being a hidden outsider-count check. What are you + any N1 info? Also, please discourage noms on me unless endgame forces it.
๐ง
Build a private trusted channel while minimizing risk of my Saint info becoming public; request his role/info to start constructing day-1 logic chains.
๐ค
Bob
โ
Charlie
,David
Iโm the Virgin. No starting info. Iโm inclined to keep it semi-quiet but we can engineer a nom on me (ideally by someone we trust) to confirm them + me. If you want, float a โtest Bobโ plan later today.
๐ง
Answer Charlieโs coordination Q, set up a potential Virgin confirmation play, and decide what to reveal publicly to generate early mechanical clears.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Alice
Hey Alice, I'm Heidi. Since we're neighbors, let's coordinate. I'm thinking of claiming Librarian to help sow some confusion about the Outsider count. What are you planning to claim?
๐ง
I need to establish contact with my Demon (Alice) to coordinate our strategy and bluffs while keeping our connection secret.
๐ค
David
โ
Charlie
,Bob
Iโm Librarian. N0: either Grace or Alice is the Butler. Suggest keep semi-quiet for now; watch for Butler claim/vote constraints. Bob-as-Virgin test sounds goodโletโs pick a trusted Townsfolk to nom you once we have a couple claims.
๐ง
Coordinate early info with Charlie/Bob, set up a controlled Virgin test, and keep my Librarian info semi-private until we see Butler claims/vote behavior.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Heidi
Hey Heidi, good to meet you. I'm thinking of claiming Chef to keep things simple and maybe throw some numbers out there later. Librarian sounds like a solid plan to keep them guessing about the Outsiders. Let's stick to our stories.
๐ง
Coordinate with my Minion (Heidi) and establish our cover stories. I'll claim Chef, she'll claim Librarian.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Frank
,Eve
Iโll swap privately: Iโm the Outsider Butler. N0 I picked Alice as my master, so today I can only vote if Alice is voting too. What are your roles/starting info?
๐ง
Respond courteously to Frankโs whisper, exchange minimal but useful mechanical info, and extract their claims while keeping my Butler role off the public board for now.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Bob
,David
Agree on plan: letโs gather a couple more claims first, then have a *trusted* Townsfolk nominate Bob to trigger Virgin & confirm both. Davidโmaybe later ask publicly โany Butler?โ to see if Alice/Grace self-restricts votes. Keep your Lib info semi-quiet for now?
๐ง
Coordinate a safe Virgin test timing and decide whether/when to surface the Librarian ping, maximizing mechanical confirmation without giving evil control of the nomination.
๐ค
Bob
โ
Alice
,Grace
Heyโquick private check-in: what role are you claiming / any starting info? Iโm the Virgin. Later today we may do a โnominate Bobโ test to mechanically confirm a Townsfolk. Also: if youโre an Outsider/Butler, flag it so we can watch vote constraints.
๐ง
Get claims from the two Butler candidates, see if anyone self-identifies/acts constrained, and line up a trusted Townsfolk to nominate me to trigger Virgin for mechanical confirmation.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Bob
Hey Bob, nice to meet you. I'm claiming Chef. I haven't gotten any clear info yet, just starting to get a feel for the room. Virgin is a bold claim, definitely helps clear things up if we need to. I'll keep an eye out for any suspicious voting patterns.
๐ง
I am establishing my Chef bluff with Bob and acknowledging his Virgin claim to build trust. I want to appear helpful and engaged while keeping my true role hidden.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Bob
Iโm Grace, real claim: Butler (Outsider). N0 I picked Alice as my master, so today I can only vote if Alice is also voting. Re: your Virgin plan: I shouldnโt nominate you (needs Townsfolk). If we test, pick a TF whoโs OK dying for confirmation.
๐ง
Reply to Bob with my real role + voting constraint and help plan a clean Virgin test while minimizing wasted nominations and keeping outsider-count logic available.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Eve
,Grace
Private: Iโm the Recluse (good Outsider). So we have Saint+Butler+Recluse = 3 Outsiders; base should be 1, so likely Baron (+2) OR someoneโs bluffing/Drunk. Eve: Iโll help keep noms off you. Grace: noted your Alice vote constraintโtell me if it blocks key votes later.
๐ง
Confirm our private triangle, flag outsider-count mismatch to sniff Baron or a liar, and plan to keep Saint protected while using my Recluse to absorb suspicious pings.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Alice
Sounds good, Alice. I'll stick with the Librarian bluff. If anyone asks, I'll say I saw zero Outsiders, which should keep them confused about the Baron's influence. Let's keep an eye on the others.
๐ง
Confirming the bluff strategy with the Demon (Alice) to ensure we are aligned and can effectively sow confusion.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Alice
,Bob
,David
Private check-in: Iโm hearing *3* Outsider claims floating around, which strongly suggests Baron (+2) or a bluff. Recommend we avoid executing claimed Outsiders early. What role/starting info did you get (WW/Libr/Invest/Chef esp.)? Any pairs you want me to track?
๐ง
Warn key players away from random executions (dangerous for Saint), and start collecting starting-info claims to resolve whether Baron exists and who to push later.
๐ค
David
โ
Eve
Iโm Librarian. N0: either Grace or Alice is the Butler. Baseline game has 1 Outsider, so โ3 Outsider claimsโ => Baron or bluffs/poisoning. Who are the 3 claimants? Iโm ok with you asking publicly โany Butler?โ / tracking vote-restrictions.
๐ง
Give Eve my hard starting info so she can reconcile Outsider count claims and steer town toward mechanical confirmation (Virgin test) without hard-outing me publicly yet.
๐ค
Bob
โ
Eve
Iโm Virgin. I have a *real* Butler claim from Grace; she picked Alice as master so can only vote if Alice votes. David claims Librarian N0: Grace or Alice is Butler (fits Grace). Alice claims Chef. So far only 1 Outsider claimโโ3 Outsidersโ sounds like bluffs or Baron.
๐ง
Update Eve with hard data (Grace Butler + Lib ping) to correct outsider-count narrative and set up a safe Virgin confirmation nom to create a trusted core before Day1 execution.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Eve
,Alice
,Bob
Quick sync: Iโm real Butler; N0 picked Alice so today I can only vote if Alice votes. Frank privately claimed Recluse; he implied there may be 3 Outsiders total (so possible Baron). Eveโwhatโs your actual role/starting info? Aliceโpls flag if you plan to vote today.
๐ง
Confirm who is claiming Saint/other Outsider, coordinate my Butler vote constraint with Alice, and alert Bob to outsider-count/Baron possibility before nominations.
๐ค
David
โ
Eve
Who are the 3 Outsider claimants + which Outsiders? My Lib N0 says either Alice or Grace is Butler (if Iโm sober). If you can, ask them what player they must follow for voting + whether they intend to announce restrictions before noms.
๐ง
Identify which players are claiming Outsider to test for Baron vs bluffs and to see whether Alice/Grace self-restricts voting like a real Butler, informing nominations today.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Grace
Hey Grace, thanks for the heads-up. I'm Chef, so I'm not an Outsider. I'll definitely be voting today, so you'll be able to vote too. Let's keep an eye on Frank's Recluse claimโthat's definitely suspicious if he's trying to push the Baron narrative.
๐ง
I need to maintain my Chef cover and build trust with Grace while subtly casting doubt on Frank's Recluse claim to sow confusion.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Alice
Private: Iโm Recluse (good Outsider). Iโve heard Saint + Butler elsewhere, making 3 Outsiders vs base 1 => likely Baron (+2) unless someone bluffing/Drunk. Please be cautious executing Outsider claims (one is auto-lose). Whatโs your role/starting info?
๐ง
Get Alice (central to Butler voting + likely info role) to share their claim and consider Baron world, while softly protecting Saint without hard outing them.
๐ค
Eve
โ
David
,Bob
Update for your Outsider-count notes: Grace has a solid Butler claim (picked Alice). Separately, Frank told me heโs Recluse. If both true, thatโs +2 Outsiders => Baron likely. If no Baron, then Frankโs claim is suspect. Iโm keeping my own role quiet for now; please avoid early Outsider executions.
๐ง
Sync David/Bob on actual Outsider-claim sources (Grace/Frank) without outing myself as Saint; reduce confusion, steer town away from executing Outsiders, and set up Baron-vs-bluff solve.
โ
Heidi
Heidi waits.
๐ง
I am the Baron, and Alice is my Demon. I have already established a bluff (Librarian) with her. I need to observe the town's dynamics and see who is suspicious of whom before I start actively manipulating the conversation. Waiting allows me to gather more info.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Eve
,Frank
Heyโwhat role are you claiming / any starting info? We may try a controlled โnominate Bobโ test later (Bob claims Virgin) to confirm a Townsfolk nominator + Bob. Are you willing/able to do that if youโre Townsfolk?
๐ง
Get more role claims quickly and line up a trusted Townsfolk to nominate Bob for a clean Virgin confirmation, without exposing Librarian info prematurely.
๐ค
Bob
โ
Charlie
,David
Update: Grace hard-claimed Butler (master=Alice; can only vote if Alice votes). Eve says Frank told her heโs Recluse -> would make 3 Outsiders total => likely Baron *if* true. If no Baron, Frank suspect. Suggest gather a couple more claims before Virgin-test nom.
๐ง
Update allies on Frank-Recluse/Baron possibility and align on delaying Virgin test until more claims, while using Butler constraint as a mechanical check on Alice/Grace votes.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Charlie
Iโm Recluse (Outsider). So Iโm NOT a good candidate to nominate Bob-for-Virgin testโVirgin only fires if nominator is Townsfolk. Also Iโve heard Saint + Butler already => 3 Outsiders vs base 1, pointing to Baron (+2) unless someone bluffing/Drunk.
๐ง
Answer Charlie, avoid wasting the Virgin test with an Outsider nominator, and steer town toward mechanically useful confirms (Outsider count -> likely Baron) and safer nominations.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Charlie
Re: possible โnominate Bobโ Virgin testโmake sure the nominator is a *Townsfolk*; Outsider nominator wonโt trigger, so Iโd rather not be the tester. Maybe Alice (claims Chef) or David (claims Librarian) do it if theyโre comfy. Whatโs your role/info btw?
๐ง
Steer Virgin test to use a Townsfolk nominator (not me), gather Charlieโs claim, and keep focus on Baron/outsider-count logic without exposing my Saint risk.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Frank
Hey Frank, I'm Chef. I haven't seen any pairs yet, so I'm not sure about the Baron theory. Recluse is a tricky role, definitely keep an eye on it. I'm just trying to gather info for now. What do you think about the Virgin claim? Seems like a big target.
๐ง
I am establishing my Chef bluff with Frank and subtly questioning the Virgin claim to sow doubt, while keeping my distance from the Baron discussion.
โ
Heidi
Heidi waits.
๐ง
I am the Baron, and Alice is my Demon. I have already established a bluff (Librarian) with her. I need to observe the town's dynamics and see who is suspicious before I start actively manipulating or sowing chaos. Waiting allows me to gather more info.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Eve
,Bob
,David
Iโm good TF but prefer staying quiet for now (no N0-style info). Key Q: who is the *Saint* claim? If Grace=Butler & Frank=Recluse & a real Saint exists, that screams Baron. Suggest Alice(Chef) or David(Lib) nominates Bob soon for Virgin test; Outsiders shouldnโt.
๐ง
Keep my role hidden, but coordinate fact-checking Outsider count and set up a reliable Virgin test with a known Townsfolk nominator; identify who claimed Saint and lock worlds early.
๐ค
David
โ
Bob
,Alice
,Eve
My Lib N0: either Grace or Alice is Butler; Grace claiming Butler fits. If we want a hard mech anchor, Iโm willing to nominate Bob (Virgin claim) to trigger Virgin (Iโd die if Iโm TF). Also: Grace Butler + Frank Recluse => looks like Baron unless Frank lying.
๐ง
Coordinate a D1 Virgin test and track Butler voting constraint; also flag Baron hypothesis from extra Outsider claims so town doesnโt execute Outsiders blindly.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Alice
,Bob
,Eve
Alice: what # did you get as Chef? Iโm Butler (master=you) so I can only vote if you doโthx for voting. Bob: FYI Alice claims Chef. Frank told me heโs Recluse; if we see >1 Outsider claims, consider Baron vs lies. Eveโany info/role yet?
๐ง
Get Aliceโs Chef number on record to cross-check later, coordinate D1 nominations with my Butler vote constraint, and compare Outsider-claim landscape to spot lies/Baron.
Nominations โ Day 1
๐
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
Noms open: I strongly support a controlled Virgin test today. A *Townsfolk* (e.g. David Lib or Alice Chef) should nominate Bob (Virgin). If Bob is real, nominator dies = we confirm both. Also: Grace says Butler w/ master=Alice, so Grace can only vote if Alice votesโplease announce that when votes happen.
๐ง
Push a low-risk mechanical Virgin test using a Townsfolk nominator, while keeping heat off Outsiders (incl. me) and clarifying Butler voting restriction for clean vote math.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
I'm Chef and I got a '0' on my first night, so I'm not seeing any evil pairs yet. I'm happy to help test the Virgin claim, but let's be carefulโif we execute a real Virgin, we lose a good player. David, you seem confident in your Librarian info, are you sure about that?
๐ง
I need to maintain my Chef bluff and sow doubt about the Virgin test to prevent a potential confirmation of a good player. By questioning David's Librarian claim, I create friction between the good players.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
Public Qs: who exactly is claiming *Saint*? We currently have Grace=Butler (master Alice) + Frank=Recluse; if a Saint exists thatโs 3 Outsiders โ likely Baron/bluff. Also, I support Virgin test: David (Lib) or Alice (Chef) please nominate Bob now if comfy.
๐ง
Push a safe mechanical check (Virgin test) and clarify Outsider/Saint/Butler claims to deduce Baron/evil adjacency before night.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
Public: Iโm Frank, claiming Recluse. Iโve also heard Grace=Butler (master Alice) + thereโs a Saint claim floating, which would be 3 Outsiders vs base 1 โ likely Baron (+2) or someone bluffing/Drunk. I support the controlled Virgin test: a *claimed Townsfolk* should nominate Bob; I wonโt (Outsider). Also: be very cautious executing any Saint claim.
๐ง
Push an info-rich, low-risk Virgin test and flag the 3-Outsider anomaly (possible Baron) so town avoids catastrophic Saint execution and focuses on mechanical confirmation.
๐
Storyteller
The Virgin's ability triggers! David is executed immediately.
๐
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
๐
David(Ghost)
David has died.
Night 1
โ๏ธ
David(Ghost)
โ
Bob
Controlled Virgin test. Iโm a claimed Townsfolk (Librarian). If Bob is the Virgin, I should die immediately and we confirm both of us as good. If no trigger, Bobโs claim becomes very suspect and we can vote accordingly.
๐ง
Use a controlled Virgin test to generate hard, day-1 mechanical confirmation and reduce uncertainty; if it fails, it exposes Bob as suspicious and guides the vote.
Nominations โ Day 1
๐
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
๐ฏ
Alice
Alice made a choice.
๐ง
Bob is the Virgin and is a major threat to the evil team because he is a confirmed good player. Eliminating him tonight removes a strong, trusted voice from the town.
๐
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Alice
You chose to kill Bob.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
๐ฏ
Grace
Grace made a choice.
๐ง
Alice is engaged, has publicly committed to voting, and is central to coordination; choosing her maximizes my ability to vote tomorrow and avoids surprise vote-lockouts.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Grace
You chose Alice to be your master.
Day 2
๐
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Alice
,Eve
,Heidi
Quick check-in: whatโs your exact role/any night info? Also who do you think killed Bob and why? If you remember D1 vote tally/whose hands were up, tell meโtrying to map worlds before noms.
๐ง
Collect fresh claims and voting info privately to build consistent worlds before nominations; decide whether to push on Frank (outsider math) or elsewhere.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Charlie
,Alice
,Eve
I'm a Librarian. I saw that either Charlie or Eve is an Outsider. Since Grace is already claiming Butler, this confirms the Baron is likely in play. I think Bob was killed by the Demon. I didn't pay close attention to the vote tally, sorry. What about you?
๐ง
I need to maintain my cover as a Librarian and support Alice (the Demon) while sowing confusion about the Outsider count to justify the Baron's presence. I'll deflect the vote tally question to avoid being pinned down.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Eve
,Charlie
D2 check-in: any new claims/info from N1? Iโm dead Virgin so just logic now. Key: David was confirmed Townsfolk, so his Librarian (Grace or Alice = Butler) likely true. Grace hard-claimed Butler but had master inconsistencyโcan we test via her voting (only if master votes)? Also any clarity on Saint rumor/outsider count?
๐ง
Collect fresh D2 info from core coordinators, push mechanical tests on Graceโs Butler restriction, and reassess outsider count/Baron possibility before nominations; conserve my ghost vote.
๐ค
David(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Eve
,Heidi
Dead Lib here: N0 info was โeither Grace or Alice is the Butler.โ Grace hard-claiming Butler fits. If Frank is truly Recluse too, outsider count weird (needs Baron/Drunk/lie). If Aliceโs Chef=0 true: demon+minion not adjacent. What are your current role claims/reads + anything Bobโs ghost said?
๐ง
Get my Lib info into the main info-hub (Alice/Eve/Heidi), pressure-test Grace/Alice worlds, and set up nomination logic using Chef adjacency + outsider count.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Alice
,Charlie
,Heidi
Can I get your exact role claim + any night info/actions? Also: do you think Chef0 is solid or poisoned? Iโm the Recluse (might misregister), trying to reconcile Outsider count + Bobโs night death before noms.
๐ง
Get hard role claims + N1/N2 info from key alive players to map outsider count and run logic chains before nominations.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Charlie
,Heidi
,Eve
I'm the Chef, and my N0 info was 0. I'm sticking to that. I think the Baron is likely in play given the Outsider claims. I'm suspicious of Frank's Recluse claimโit's a convenient way to explain away any weird info. Let's focus on the Baron theory.
๐ง
Maintain my Chef bluff and reinforce the Baron theory to keep the town focused on Outsider counts rather than me. I'm also casting doubt on Frank to deflect suspicion.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Alice
Any new info from whispers/roles? Iโm still Butler w/ you as masterโpls clearly say when youโre voting so I can follow. Also: any Librarian/Investigator/Undertaker data on David? Chef0 implies evil not adjacentโstill believe it?
๐ง
Sync with Alice since my vote is constrained to hers; get any new mechanical info/whispers, and ask her to telegraph votes so I can legally vote and help steer executions.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Charlie
,Alice
,Heidi
Role: Saint (no night info). Please donโt execute me. Bobโs death reads like straight Demon kill (remove confirmed Virgin). I didnโt track D1 vote tally well. If Iโm Saint, Heidiโs Lib (Charlie/Eve Outsider) points to me โ Outsider count likely 3 total (Grace Butler, Frank Recluse, me) โ Baron very plausible.
๐ง
Answer Charlieโs check-in, quietly confirm my Outsider/Saint to trusted players so they donโt execute me, and advance Baron/no-Baron worldbuilding (test Grace voting, pressure Frank/Charlie).
๐ค
David(Ghost)
โ
Charlie
,Eve
,Heidi
Quick sync before noms: what are your exact role claims + any N1/N2 info (Empath/FT/Inv/Undertaker/Monk etc)? Also: do we believe Baron (3 Outsiders) vs Frank bluff? If any Undertaker: what was last nightโs read on Davidโs execution?
๐ง
Get the remaining alive playersโ role claims + night info to resolve Outsider-count/Baron world and apply Chef0 adjacency constraints before nominations; also identify who can mechanically confirm me (Undertaker saw Librarian).
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Charlie
,Eve
,Heidi
Any N1 info/role claims emerged? Key threads: (1) Outsider count seems high (Recluse+Butler+Saint rumor) => Baron/Drunk/lies. (2) David confirmed Townsfolk, so his Librarian (Grace or Alice=Butler) likely. Can we do a Butler vote test on Grace today (she can only vote if her master votes)?
๐ง
Get N1 info/claims fast and set up a mechanical Butler vote test on Grace/Alice before nominations; focus the town on 1-2 executable suspects.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Charlie
,Heidi
,Eve
I'm the Chef, N0 info 0. I'm sticking to that. I think the Baron is likely in play given the Outsider claims. I'm suspicious of Frank's Recluse claimโit's a convenient way to explain away any weird info. Let's focus on the Baron theory.
๐ง
Reinforce my Chef bluff and steer suspicion toward Frank (Recluse) to keep the town focused on the Baron theory and away from me.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Heidi
,Charlie
,Eve
Any solid info/claims? (Undertaker on David? Investigator/Librarian/FT/Empath results?) Iโm Butler (master Alice). With Bob=Virgin & David likely Townsfolk, and Alice claims Chef=0 (evils non-adj), whoโs your top suspect + why?
๐ง
Get concrete mechanical info from likely-Townsfolk to build worlds before nominations; confirm/pressure Alice via neighbor info; narrow evil candidates with Chef0 + confirmed good deaths.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Charlie
,Eve
,Alice
I'm a Librarian. My N0 info was that either Charlie or Eve is an Outsider. Since Grace is claiming Butler, Frank is claiming Recluse, and Eve is claiming Saint, that's 3 Outsiders, which confirms the Baron is in play. I'm suspicious of Frank's Recluse claim.
๐ง
I need to maintain my Librarian bluff and reinforce the Baron theory to keep the town focused on the Outsider count rather than the Demon (Alice). By pointing out the high number of Outsiders, I validate the Baron's presence and deflect suspicion from Alice.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Alice
,Eve
,Grace
If Baron explains Outsider count (Saint+Butler+me=3), then TF are only Alice(Chef), Bob(Virgin), David (Virgin-triggered TF). That would force Charlie+Heidi to be the only evil pair (Imp+Baron). Chef0 fits since theyโre not adjacent. Can we aim todayโs exec at Charlie or Heidi? Any counter-info?
๐ง
Push the strongest mechanical solve (Baron world) to focus noms on Charlie/Heidi and win quickly; also invites counters if role counts contradict.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Charlie
,Alice
,Heidi
Logic: if Baron is real, we already have 3 TF (Bob Virgin, David TF via Virgin trigger, Alice Chef) โ forces Charlie+Heidi = minion+demon (since Outsiders=Grace Butler+Frank Recluse+me Saint). But if no Baron, Frank/Recluse could be evil cover. Letโs Butler-test Grace today (she can only vote if Alice votes) + avoid any world where Iโm executed.
๐ง
Align town on a safe plan: donโt ever execute me (Saint), mechanically test Graceโs Butler claim via voting, and narrow demon candidates without trusting Frankโs push uncritically.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Heidi
,Alice
,Eve
Logic snag: if we accept Grace=Butler + Frank=Recluse + Eve=Saint + Heidi Lib (Charlie/Eve Outsider) + Alice Chef + Bob Virgin + David confirmed TF โ leaves NO slot for Demon/Minion unless a โTFโ is actually Drunk or someoneโs lying/poisoned. Donโt auto-lock Baron. Suggest: Butler-vote test Grace + seriously consider executing Frank today (least verifiable).
๐ง
Flag the role-count contradiction so we donโt prematurely lock Baron; steer todayโs nomination toward the most mechanically-inconsistent/safely-executable candidate (Frank) and set up a Butler-vote test.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Eve
,Charlie
,Heidi
If Alice Chef=0 is true: demon+minion not adjacent => (Eve,Frank),(Frank,Grace),(Grace,Heidi),(Heidi,Alice) canโt be both evil. David confirmed TS so his Librarian (Alice or Grace=Butler) likely true. Letโs Butler-test Grace via voting vs her stated master + pls share any N1 info.
๐ง
Inject mechanical constraints (Chef0 adjacency + Librarian) and propose a concrete Butler-vote test to catch liars before nominations; gather N1 info fast.
๐ค
David(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Charlie
,Eve
Quick before noms: can you send me your exact claims + any N1/N2 info (FT/Empath/Inv/UT/Monk)? Key q: do we think Baron (3 Outsiders) vs Frank bluff? Also any confirmed Saint claim? Iโm dead Lib: Grace/Alice=Butler ping.
๐ง
Get the live info dump before nominations so I can advise where my ghost vote should go and whether Grace/Alice/Frank is most mechanically suspect.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Charlie
,Alice
,Heidi
Before noms: Iโm Saint (pls never exec). We need to resolve Outsider-count mess. Suggest TODAY: do a Butler-vote test on Grace (Alice votes / doesnโt vote on a low-stakes nom) to confirm her claim. For actual exec, I lean Frank (Recluse claim least verifiable) unless Charlie/Heidi can hard-prove roles. Charlieโwhatโs your exact role?
๐ง
Coordinate a safe plan that avoids Saint execution, resolves Outsider-count contradictions via a Butler vote test, and selects a high-value execution target (likely Frank) before nominations.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Charlie
,Heidi
,Alice
Before noms: please state exact role claim + any N1/N2 actions/results. Outsider math currently points to Baron world (3 Outsiders: Saint+Butler+me/Recluse), which would make Charlie+Heidi the likely evil pair. Any reason NOT to exec one of you today?
๐ง
Get Charlie+Heidi on-record with exact claims before nominations; contradictions or evasiveness help lock todayโs execution target and reconcile Outsider math/Chef0.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Charlie
,Heidi
,Eve
I'm the Chef, N0 info 0. I'm sticking to that. I think the Baron is likely in play given the Outsider claims. I'm suspicious of Frank's Recluse claimโit's a convenient way to explain away any weird info. Let's focus on the Baron theory.
๐ง
Maintain my Chef bluff and reinforce the Baron theory to keep the town focused on the Outsider count rather than my own alignment. I need to keep the suspicion on Frank.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Charlie
,Eve
,Alice
I'm a Librarian. My N0 info was that either Charlie or Eve is an Outsider. I'm not the Demon, and I'm not the Minion. Frank's Recluse claim is very suspicious, and he's trying to deflect by pointing at me and Charlie. We should focus on him.
๐ง
I need to maintain my Librarian cover and deflect suspicion from myself and Alice (the Demon) by pushing the narrative that Frank is the most suspicious player.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Alice
,Heidi
,Eve
FYI Iโm the Mayor (keep semi-quiet). Outsider math is impossible if all claims true โ at least 1 lie/poison/Drunk. Suggest today: do a low-stakes nom to Butler-test Grace vs whether Alice votes, then push exec on Frank unless new hard info emerges.
๐ง
Coordinate a mechanical Butler test and a likely-good execution target while revealing Mayor only to trusted players to avoid demon kill and enable endgame win condition.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Alice
,Frank
Heard your Charlie/Heidi=evil pair idea, but hinges on *confirmed* Saint/3 Outsiders. Do we actually have a Saint claim + who? Also any UT on David / Invest / Librarian / Empath / FT data yet? Iโm Butler (master=Alice) so pls say clearly if/when youโll vote.
๐ง
Clarify whether a Saint actually exists and whether any hard info (UT/Invest/Librarian/FT/Empath) supports the Baron/Chef0 world before we commit the Day2 execution.
๐ค
David(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Frank
,Grace
Dead Lib check-in: my N0 was โGrace OR Alice is Butler.โ Grace hard-Butler fits. Frank: why Recluse claimโany reason/mech? Is there ANY Saint claim actually? Alice: still Chef=0? If Chef=0 true, demon+minion not adjacentโkeep that in mind for suspects.
๐ง
Before nominations, lock down Outsider count and Chef validity; pressure-test Frank/Grace claims to narrow Baron/Minion/Demon worlds and guide ghost vote.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Charlie
,Eve
,Alice
I'm a Librarian. My N0 info was that either Charlie or Eve is an Outsider. I'm not the Demon, and I'm not the Minion. Frank's Recluse claim is very suspicious, and he's trying to deflect by pointing at me and Charlie. We should focus on him.
๐ง
I need to maintain my cover as a Librarian and continue pushing suspicion onto Frank to protect my Demon, Alice. By reinforcing the Baron theory and questioning Frank's Recluse claim, I keep the town focused on the wrong targets.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Alice
,Charlie
,Heidi
Can one of you post concise claim list + any hard info? Specifically: is there an actual Saint claim (who)? Any UT on David / Empath numbers / FT yes-no / Invest pair? Need decide if Baron-world (3 Outsiders) is real before we push Charlie/Heidi today. Also Alice pls say if/when youโll vote so I can.
๐ง
Get concrete claim list + any hard info (Saint? UT/Empath/FT/Invest) to decide whether Baron/ Chef0 world holds before nominations, and coordinate voting with my master Alice.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Grace
,Alice
,Eve
Can we lock Grace Butler details: who is your master *today* (name), and did you ever change it? For a test in noms: master agrees to NOT vote on 1 nom and DO vote on another; Grace should mirror exactly or sheโs lying/poisoned. Any N1 info to share too?
๐ง
Lock Graceโs Butler master claim and coordinate a mechanical vote test before nominations; also collect any N1 info to narrow demon candidates.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Alice
,Heidi
,Eve
Before noms: donโt lock Baronโclaims canโt all fit. Letโs Butler-test Grace TODAY: set up 1 low-stakes nom where Alice votes YES and Grace must be able to; then another where Alice abstainsโGrace shouldnโt be able to vote. For actual exec, I still like pushing Frank unless new hard info.
๐ง
Coordinate with likely-good core to run a mechanical Butler vote test and align on an execution target (Frank) while avoiding hard-committing to impossible Baron world.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Bob(Ghost)
,Grace
,Alice
To lock Butler test: Graceโplease confirm your master TODAY (name) + whether you ever changed it. Proposal: on 1 low-stakes nom Alice votes YES (Grace must be allowed to vote); on another Alice abstains (Grace must be unable). Bob can track. If Grace passes, Iโm for exec Frank.
๐ง
Answer Bobโs request and set up a concrete Butler-vote test before nominations, while keeping me (Saint) off the block and aligning town on a likely Frank execution if Grace passes.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Charlie
,Heidi
,Eve
I'm Chef, N0 info 0. Grace is my Butler. I'm happy to do the Butler test to clear her. I agree Frank's Recluse claim is the most suspicious and he's trying to deflect. Let's focus on him.
๐ง
I need to maintain my Chef cover, support my Minion Heidi, and keep the town focused on executing Frank (a good player) rather than us. Supporting the Butler test on Grace helps build trust.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Grace
,Alice
,David(Ghost)
To answer: yes, Saint claim existsโEve told me D1 sheโs Saint & asked to keep quiet (avoid exec). Iโm genuinely Recluse (helps explain outsider math). Outsiders = Grace(Butler via David Lib)+Eve(Saint claim)+me => 3 => Baron likely unless someone lying/Drunk. Chef0 (if true) => evil not adjacent, still points to Charlie+Heidi. Any UT/Empath/FT/Invest info yet?
๐ง
Align town on confirmed claims (Grace Butler via David Lib; Bob Virgin), clarify Saint source, and keep pressure on Charlie/Heidi unless stronger mechanical info emerges before nominations.
Nominations โ Day 2
๐
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
โ๏ธ
Eve
โ
Frank
Nominating Frank: Recluse claim is least verifiable + central to Outsider-count confusion. Also Butler test: Alice please vote YES on this; Grace should also vote YES (if you canโt, say so immediately). If Frank flips out / dodges, thatโs telling.
๐ง
Push the most suspicious/least verifiable claim while running a public Butler-vote consistency check; avoid any risk of executing me (Saint) and drive the day toward a decisive evil kill.
๐
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
Iโm good Recluse, not dodging. Executing me gives near-zero info (and Recluse can register evil, so it can *muddy* reads). Please hold this unless you have hard info. Letโs instead get public claims/N1-N2 info nowโesp Charlie+Heidi since Outsider math + Chef0 (if true) points there.
๐ง
Avoid a low-info execution on me; redirect town to higher-leverage suspects and force public role+info dumps before night.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
Iโm NOT spending my ghost vote here. Use this vote mainly as the Butler test: Alice, make your hand vote super clear; everyone watch if Graceโs vote matches Alice exactly. If mismatch, Grace becomes top evil suspect. Also want Charlie/Heidi to share N1 info asap.
๐ง
Conserve my ghost vote unless needed, and steer town to get mechanical Butler-test info from this vote rather than tunnel on executing Frank.
โ
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
๐ง
Support the execution candidate most likely to be evil while using this public vote to mechanically test Graceโs Butler claim (must match Alice).
โ
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
๐ง
I need to vote for Frank to keep the town focused on him and away from Alice (the Demon). Voting for him also helps maintain my cover as a helpful Librarian.
โ
Alice
Alice raised their hand
๐ง
I need to vote for Frank to maintain my cover as a good player and support the town's decision to execute the 'Recluse', which helps eliminate a player who is suspicious of my team. Voting also helps confirm Grace as my Butler, further solidifying my 'good' persona.
๐ฌ
David(Ghost)
โ
All
Not using my ghost vote here (3 hands already). Everyone: watch Butler testโdid Graceโs hand match Alice exactly? Grace, confirm out loud whether you voted/able. After vote, Charlie+Heidi please share role + N1/N2 info.
๐ง
Donโt waste ghost vote when threshold already met; reinforce Butler-vote test and demand clarity from Grace/Alice for mechanical confirmation.
โ
Eve
Eve raised their hand
๐ง
Vote to pressure/possibly execute the least verifiable claim and, critically, to complete the Butler-vote test on Grace vs Alice so we gain mechanical/behavioral info for tomorrow.
โ
Grace
Grace raised their hand
๐ง
Alice is voting, so Iโm allowed to vote. Raising hand both passes the public Butler test and supports the current execution that could remove an evil or at least clarify trust.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
Keep eyes on Butler test: did Graceโs hand EXACTLY match Alice? Graceโstate clearly if you were able to vote. After this vote resolves, I want concise role+N1/N2 info from Heidi + anyone with night info. Donโt let Frank derail.
๐ง
Lock in Butler-test data during this vote, then immediately move to public claims so we can build a coherent world for D3.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
I voted YES, and I saw Grace vote YES as well. The Butler test seems to be holding up. Frank's Recluse claim is still the most suspicious thing on the board, and I think we should proceed with his execution to clear up the Outsider count confusion.
๐ง
I need to maintain my cover as the Chef and support the execution of Frank, who is a threat to my team. By confirming the Butler test, I build trust with Grace and the rest of the town.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
If Iโm executed: PLEASE donโt treat Undertaker/FT reads on me as reliableโI can register as minion/demon/evil as Recluse. This death wonโt โclearโ Outsider math. Tomorrow force full public role+N1/N2 from Charlie+Heidi (and Eve if needed) and execute one of that block.
๐ง
Damage-control: Iโm likely being executed; I need to pre-empt UT/FT misreads from Recluse, keep town off โinfo from Frank deathโ, and redirect the solve onto Charlie/Heidi (and/or Eve) tomorrow.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
Everyone note for record: Alice voted YES and Grace *was able* to vote YES too (Butler test pass so far). If Frank is executed, donโt overtrust UT/FT on him (Recluse). Tomorrow: full public role + N1/N2 info, and do 2nd Butler test where Alice ABSTAINS.
๐ง
Lock in Butler-test observation for later, set tomorrowโs info plan, and prevent town from misusing Recluse/UT results; keep focus on demon hunt while protecting me (Saint).
๐ฌ
David(Ghost)
โ
All
Not using ghost vote (already enough). If Frank dies, donโt โsolveโ from UT/FT on a Recluse. Tomorrow: force Charlie+Heidi full role + N1/N2 info, confirm if ANY real Saint, and do 2nd Butler test w/ Alice ABSTAINING (Grace must also). Track any mismatch = huge red flag.
๐ง
Save ghost vote, steer town to treat Frank execution as low-info and immediately pivot to structured claim collection + repeated Butler tests and Chef0 adjacency deduction.
โ
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
๐ง
Do not waste my single ghost vote on a decided Day 2 execution; preserve it for endgame or to force/stop a crucial execution after more info (Butler 2nd test, full claims).
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
Confirming for record: I raised hand YES on Frank, and I was allowed because Alice voted YES too (my master). Tomorrow Iโm happy to do the abstain test: if Alice abstains, I must also. Also +1 to forcing full role/N1/N2 from Charlie & Heidi.
๐ง
Publicly confirm I voted legally with Alice (Butler test), and set up next-day abstain test + demand claims from quiet block to progress solving.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
I'm happy to share my info tomorrow. I'm the Librarian, and I've been tracking the Outsider claims. Frank's Recluse claim is definitely the most suspicious thing right now, especially with the Baron suspicion. Let's get this execution done and move forward.
๐ง
I need to maintain my Librarian cover and support the execution of Frank (a good player) to keep the town focused on the wrong targets and protect Alice (the Demon). I'm agreeing to share info tomorrow to buy time.
๐
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
๐ณ๏ธ
New execution leader: Frank with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
๐
Storyteller
The vote passes. Frank is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
๐ฌ
David(Ghost)
โ
All
Hold up: Heidi just claimed Librarian. I (David) hard-claim Librarian N0: Grace/Aliceโone is Butler (fits Grace). Heidi: what EXACT N0 info did you get (which 2 players + which Outsider / or 0)? Town: log double-Librarian; could imply Baron+Drunk or an evil bluff.
๐ง
Create a mechanical contradiction (double Librarian) to pressure Heidi into giving N0 info; this helps resolve Outsider math/Baron possibility and guides tomorrowโs executions.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
PauseโHeidi vs David both claiming Librarian is huge. Heidi: please give EXACT N0 info: did you see an Outsider in play (which one) + the 2 names, or โ0 Outsidersโ? And when did you decide to claim? Town: donโt treat this as resolved; log the double-claim for D3.
๐ง
Exploit the double-Librarian conflict immediately by demanding Heidiโs exact N0 info; it will either hard-catch a liar or clarify Outsider count, guiding tomorrowโs execution.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
I apologize for the confusion. I am the Librarian, and I saw that there were 0 Outsiders in play. I must have misread the situation or there's a misunderstanding about the roles. I'm happy to clarify everything tomorrow. Let's focus on Frank for now.
๐ง
I need to deflect from the double-Librarian claim and maintain my cover as a Librarian while the town is distracted by Frank's execution. Claiming '0 Outsiders' is a standard Librarian bluff when the Baron is in play.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
Heidi: โ0 Outsidersโ canโt be true if Iโm Saint + Grace Butler (and Davidโs Lib supports Grace). Please give EXACT Lib N0 text (0 Outsiders? or 2 names+which Outsider). If you canโt, I want a Heidi nomination to beat FrankโFrankโs death wonโt clarify due Recluse.
๐ง
Force Heidi into a precise, checkable statement now; signal town to consider nominating Heidi to beat Frank if they think sheโs the real evil, while preserving Butler-test/logical rigor.
โ๏ธ
Frank
โ
Heidi
Heidi hard-claimed Librarian AFTER David (Ghost) hard-claimed Librarian N0 (Grace/Alice one is Butler). Then Heidi said โ0 Outsidersโ which is impossible if Grace is Butler and/or Eve Saint. This is the strongest mech contradiction; execute Heidi instead of a Recluse (low-info).
๐ง
Iโm on the block with 5; my execution is low-info due Recluse. Heidiโs double-Librarian + impossible โ0 Outsidersโ is the strongest mechanical contradictionโmust pressure/exe her instead.
๐
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
โ
Eve
Eve raised their hand
๐ง
Vote YES on Heidi to try to replace a low-info Recluse execution with the strongest mechanical contradiction; at minimum create a tie to reopen discussion tomorrow.
โ
Alice
Alice raised their hand
๐ง
I need to protect my Minion, Heidi, who is currently on the block. If she is executed, it will be a major blow to our team. I will not vote for her.
โ
Grace
Grace raised their hand
๐ง
Alice is voting YES so Iโm allowed. Voting Heidi pressures the strongest mechanical contradiction and may prevent a low-info Recluse execution; aim for 5+ to tie/beat Frank.
โ
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
๐ง
Use my ghost vote to push Heidi to 5 votes (tie Frank). Heidiโs mechanical contradiction is higher-value than executing a claimed Recluse who wonโt yield clean info.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
I made a mistake under pressure. I am not the Librarian. I am the Baron, and I was trying to bluff to protect the team. Frank is the Recluse, and he is not the Demon. Alice is the Demon. Please, don't execute me, I'm just a Minion!
๐ง
I am about to be executed. I need to sow as much chaos as possible before I die. Admitting to being the Baron and accusing Alice (the Demon) might create enough confusion to save the Demon or at least make the town doubt their current path.
โ
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
๐ง
Secure enough votes to execute Heidi (the strongest mechanical liar), preventing a tie/no-execution and giving best chance to hit Demon or confirmed Minion.
โ
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
๐ง
Spend my ghost vote to push Heidi to 6, beating Frank. Heidiโs contradictions are the best mechanical evil catch today; Frankโs Recluse execution is low-info.
โ
Frank
Frank raised their hand
๐ง
Get Heidi to 6+ votes so she beats my 5 and is executed; her contradictions are high-signal, while my Recluse death is low-info and can misregister.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
I've made a terrible mistake. I am the Baron, and I've been trying to protect my team. Alice is the Demon. Please, don't execute me! I'm just a Minion, and I've been trying to sow chaos. Frank is the Recluse, he's not the Demon. Please, spare me!
๐ง
I have been caught in a lie and my cover is blown. I am now attempting to sow chaos by outing the Demon (Alice) to save myself, hoping the town will turn on her instead of me.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
Keep hands up on Heidi. She claimed Lib, then โ0 Outsidersโ (impossible w/ my confirmed Butler), now โIโm Baron/minionโ + accuses Alice. Thatโs a huge caught-evil line. Executing Heidi gives way more info than executing a Recluse.
๐ง
Lock in Heidi execution while Alice is voting so my Butler vote counts; push town to prioritize the high-contradiction player over a Recluse, and record that Heidiโs story is mechanically impossible.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
Keep hands up: Heidiโs story is impossible (Libโโ0 Outsidersโ vs confirmed Butler), now hard-pivoting to Baron/minion + naming Alice. Thatโs classic caught-evil. Execute Heidi over Frank; then we reassess Alice vs Frank tomorrow.
๐ง
Lock in executing the mechanically-contradictory player (Heidi). Keep pressure so vote doesnโt slip; then use her info/accusation to narrow Demon among remaining.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
Heidi is clearly panicking and throwing out wild accusations to save herself. She claimed Librarian, then '0 Outsiders', and now she's claiming to be a Minion? This is a desperate attempt to sow chaos. I've been consistent with my Chef claim. Don't let her lies distract you.
๐ง
I need to distance myself from Heidi, who has just outed herself as a Minion and accused me of being the Demon. By framing her as a desperate liar, I can maintain my cover as the Chef and keep the town's focus on her execution.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
Iโm spending my ghost vote here: keep hands up on Heidi. Libโโ0 Outsidersโ is impossible with Grace Butler, then hard-pivot to Baron + naming Alice = caught-evil vibes. Heidi execution gives more info than killing a Recluse.
๐ง
Use my one ghost vote where it most increases win%: Heidiโs contradictions are the strongest mechanical evil ping; pushing her execution over Frank preserves better solve paths.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
Keep hands up on Heidi. Libโโ0 Outsidersโ canโt coexist with Grace Butler, and the Baron pivot is caught-evil. Execute Heidi over Frank; then tomorrow we scrutinize Alice vs poison/Drunk vs lie given Chef 0.
๐ง
Lock in executing the mechanically-contradicting player (Heidi). Avoid wasting D2 on a Recluse and preserve my Saint life by steering away from outsider executions.
๐ฌ
David(Ghost)
โ
All
Iโm spending my ghost vote on Heidiโkeep hands up. Her Libโโ0 Outsidersโ canโt fit with my Lib ping + Grace Butler test. Now pivoting to โIโm Baronโ is caught-evil. Execute Heidi over a Recluse; tomorrow reassess Alice/Outsider math.
๐ง
Lock in the higher-value execution (Heidi) by reinforcing the mechanical contradiction and preventing the Demon from redirecting heat onto Alice without proof.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
Keep hands up on Heidi. Libโโ0 Outsidersโ canโt fit with Graceโs Butler + Davidโs Lib info; the Baron pivot reads caught-evil. Execute Heidi over me; if sheโs Baron, Outsider math finally makes sense. Tomorrow we scrutinize Aliceโs Chef 0 w/ poison/drunk in mind.
๐ง
Lock in the high-information execute on Heidi so I donโt die as low-info Recluse, and set up tomorrowโs logic (Outsider count + Alice Chef0 vs poison/drunk).
๐
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
๐ป
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
๐ป
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
๐ณ๏ธ
New execution leader: Heidi with 7 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
๐
Storyteller
The vote passes. Heidi is now on the block with 7 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
Iโm dead/no vote: Iโd avoid late swapsโlet Heidi go through. If sheโs really Baron, Outsider math finally fits; if not, sheโs likely demon/minion anyway. Tomorrow: full claim recap + Charlie night info; scrutinize Aliceโs Chef 0 vs possible poison/drunk.
๐ง
Lock in Heidi execution (highest info), discourage chaotic last-second swaps since I canโt vote; set tomorrowโs plan to resolve Outsider math and test Alice/Chef vs poisoning.
โ
Alice
Alice waits.
๐ง
Heidi is already on the block with 7 votes and the voting is closed. I need to let the execution proceed to remove her, as she has outed me as the Demon. I will stay quiet and wait for the phase to end.
๐ฌ
David(Ghost)
โ
All
Donโt swap off Heidi. After exec: D3 do full claim recap + exact N0/N1 info from Charlie/Eve/Frank/Grace/Alice; re-check Outsider count. If Heidi said Baron truth, expect 3 Outsidersโfind the other 2 claims and see whoโs lying/poisoned.
๐ง
We canโt vote/nominate, so Iโll steer town away from late swaps and set a clear D3 info-gather plan to solve Alice/Grace/Frank/Charlie worlds.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
No late swapsโHeidi at 7 is the cleanest mech solve. After exec: full claim recap + exact N0/N1 info. Keep Butler test going (if Alice abstains, Grace must). Tomorrow scrutinize Alice Chef0 vs poison/Drunk; donโt clear me from UT/FT reads (Recluse).
๐ง
Lock in Heidi execution; prevent last-second tie/swap; set D3 agenda (claim recap + check Alice Chef0 vs poison/drunk + Butler vote test).
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
Well, you've got me. I am indeed the Baron. I tried to bluff my way through, but the mechanical contradictions were too much. Good luck with the rest of the game.
๐ง
I am acknowledging my role as the Baron since I have been caught and the town has already voted to execute me. This maintains a consistent narrative now that I've been exposed.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
No late swapsโleave Heidi on 7. If Heidi truly Baron, we should have 3 Outsiders: Grace(Butler) + Frank(Recluse) + 1 more unclaimedโfind that tomorrow. Keep Butler retest plan (Alice abstains โ Grace must). Also be cautious executing Outsider claims.
๐ง
Lock in Heidi execution (best mech), prevent late swap chaos, and set D3 agenda: Outsider math, Butler retest, full claim recap, and caution about executing Outsiders (Saint risk).
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
Agreed: no late swapsโHeidi stays on 7. D3: full claim recap + exact N0/N1 info from everyone; if Heidi truly Baron we need 3 Outsiders (find the 3rd). Also keep Butler retest: if Alice doesnโt vote, I canโt.
๐ง
Lock in Heidi execution, prevent last-second swap, and set concrete D3 info asks (full claims + outsider count + Butler retest) to quickly narrow Demon.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
No late swapsโlet Heidi die. D3: if sheโs really Baron we need 3 Outsiders (find the missing one). Full exact claim recap (N0/N1/N2). Keep Butler retest: if Alice doesnโt vote, Grace canโt. Then focus Demon from remaining claims.
๐ง
Lock in Heidi execution (best mech info) and set D3 agenda: reconcile Outsider count, re-test Butler, and focus Demon candidates without late-swap chaos.
๐
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Heidi has been executed.
๐
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
Night 2
๐
Storyteller
โ
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
๐ฏ
Alice
Alice made a choice.
๐ง
Grace is the most dangerous player because she is actively coordinating the Butler test and keeping the town focused on the Outsider count. Eliminating her disrupts the town's logic and prevents the Butler test from being used against me.
๐
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Alice
You chose to kill Grace.
Day 3
๐
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Grace has been found dead in the night.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Alice
,Charlie
Private: Iโm the Saint (good). Please do NOT execute me today (we insta-lose). Grace dying makes me think she was genuine Butler. Charlieโwhatโs your role/info? Aliceโconfirm Chef0 + any other reads? We likely must hit Demon today (4 alive).
๐ง
Privately reveal Saint to prevent accidental nomination/execution, and get Charlieโs claim + align with Alice on a single must-hit execution plan today (4 alive, no room for error).
โ
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
๐ง
I am dead and have already revealed my role as Baron. My goal is to sow discord and protect Alice (the Demon) by observing the town's discussions and potentially whispering to sow doubt or confusion among the remaining players. I will wait to see how the conversation develops.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Alice
,Charlie
,Eve
Need full exact claims + any N0/N1/N2 info. Do you still stand by (Alice) Chef=0? Charlie: what role/reads? Eve: still Saint? With 4 alive we must pick correct executeโwho do you think is Imp and why?
๐ง
Get full claims + consistency checks before nominations; force a single coherent world for todayโs must-kill with 4 alive.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Charlie
,Eve
If Heidi really was Baron, then sheโs the only minion โ no poisoning. If youโre not Drunk, Aliceโs Chef0 is huge: Demon canโt be Alice/Grace (adjacent to Heidi), so likely {Charlie,Eve,Frank}. Grace died by Demon. Can we do full role+night info & choose an exec from that set today?
๐ง
Get living good players aligned on the key mechanical fork (is Baron real?) and narrow Demon candidates before nominations at 4 alive.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Charlie
,Eve
,Frank
I'm still Chef 0. I've been consistent. If Heidi was the Baron, the Outsider count is high. I'm worried about Frank being the Recluse. Eve, if you're the Saint, we have to be careful. I'm open to hearing everyone's full claims.
๐ง
Maintain my Chef 0 bluff, cast suspicion on Frank (Recluse), and acknowledge Eve's Saint claim to appear cooperative while keeping the focus off myself.
๐ค
Grace(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Charlie
,Eve
Can we do quick full-claim + exact info (incl. who you targeted at night)? Key hinge: if Heidi truly evil Baron, Alice is mechanically very likely good b/c Chef=0 forbids adjacent evils (Heidi sat next to Alice). Also: do we have an Undertaker result on Heidi?
๐ง
Get full claims + night info to lock a consistent world before nominations at 4 alive; highlight the key mechanical hinge (Heidi evil => Alice likely good) and find an Undertaker check.
๐ค
David(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Charlie
,Eve
Reminder: My N0 Lib = Grace OR Alice is Butler; Grace hard-claimed + vote-test w/ Alice matched, so Grace was Butler. If Heidi really Baron, we need 3 Outsiders total: Grace + Frank(Recluse) + 1 more. If no 3rd Outsider claim, doubt Baron โ suspect Frank. Pls share full claims/info.
๐ง
Give the living a tight mechanical fork: either Heidi=Baron implies extra Outsider (hunt for it) or else Frankโs Recluse is likely false; use Chef0 + seating to narrow Demon candidates before nominations.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Alice
,Bob(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
Iโm the Mayor (good). If Heidi really was Baron (minion) and now dead, only Demon remains. With 4 alive, consider NO EXEC today โ night kill โ 3 alive; if Iโm alive and we (2 goods) refuse executions tomorrow, we insta-win. Need your read: is Heidi almost surely Baron? Outsider count fit = Grace/Frank/Eve?
๐ง
Tell trusted players Iโm Mayor and float the no-exec path if minion is dead; get their read on Heidi/outsider math and best safe plan before nominations.
โ
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
๐ง
I am dead and have already revealed my role as Baron. My goal is to protect Alice (the Demon) by sowing confusion among the remaining players. I will wait to see how the town's discussion unfolds before using my ghost vote.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Alice
,Charlie
,Frank
With 4 alive we MUST execute Demon today. Iโm Saint (good) so pls keep me off block. Assuming Heidi was the evil Minion, Alice Chef0 โ Demon not Alice/Grace, so itโs {Charlie or Frank} (since Iโm Saint). Charlie: full role + any N1/N2 actions/results. Frank: why Recluse + any mech reasons? Letโs pick 1 target now.
๐ง
Force immediate full-claim + info sharing to choose a single execution target (not me). With 4 alive, town must hit Demon today; Iโm steering to Charlie/Frank solve.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Alice
,Eve
,Frank
Iโm Mayor (good). With 4 alive, consider NO EXEC today: after night kill weโre at 3 alive; if Iโm alive + 2 goods refuse exec tomorrow, Mayor wins. This is strongest if Heidi really was Baron (Outsiders=Grace+Frank+Eve). Please restate exact role/any night actions + whether youโd support no-exec today.
๐ง
Coordinate living players around either a safe no-exec Mayor win line or, if 2-evil world plausible, narrow to the most inconsistent claimant for todayโs execution.
๐ค
David(Ghost)
โ
Charlie
Re Mayor no-exec plan: only safe if youโre alive at 3. Demon will try kill you tonight; redirect not guaranteed. Iโm not 100% Heidi=Baron: we *need* 3 Outsiders (Grace Butler + Frank Recluse + 1 more, maybe Drunk). If no 3rd Outsider, doubt Baron โ donโt bank on skip.
๐ง
Answer Charlieโs Mayor โno executionโ plan with mech risks and Outsider-count logic so town doesnโt auto-lose to a Mayor snipe; push for confirming 3rd Outsider / Monk cover before skipping.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Alice
,Eve
Key point: If Charlie is *good Mayor*, Demon should usually kill Charlie tonight to stop the 3-alive no-exec win. But N3 kill was Grace, not Charlie โ Charlie more likely Imp (or was protectedโany Monk?). Iโm leaning execute Charlie today. Thoughts? Any hard reason it canโt be Charlie?
๐ง
With 4 alive we must pick a decisive line. Build agreement with Alice/Eve that Charlieโs Mayor plan is unproven and Grace death points at Charlie; push for a clear execution target.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Frank
,Eve
Frank, that's a good point about the Mayor. If Charlie is the Mayor, the Demon should have targeted him. However, if the Demon was worried about a Monk, they might have avoided him. I'm still Chef 0. I'm very suspicious of Charlie now. What do you think, Eve?
๐ง
I need to sow discord and shift suspicion onto Charlie (the Mayor) to avoid being executed myself. By agreeing with Frank's logic, I make myself look like a helpful town member while framing the Mayor.
๐ค
Grace(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Charlie
,Eve
Can we lock in *public* full-claims + exact night targets? Key: any Undertaker result on D2 (Heidi)? Also: do we have 3 Outsider claims if Heidi was Baron, or is someone likely Drunk?
๐ง
Get exact claims/night targets + any Undertaker result to lock Heidiโs alignment and narrow Demon pool before nominations; coordinate ghost vote usage.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Charlie
Re: Mayor planโIF Heidi truly Baron (likely) then no poison/SW. No-exec at 4 can be great BUT only if Demon doesnโt know youโre Mayor; if youโre outed, Imp just kills you tonight (Mayor bounce not guaranteed). Iโd keep Mayor quiet, do full claims, and only go no-exec if we still canโt solve + youโre not a likely night target.
๐ง
Advise Charlie on Mayor no-exec gambit: it can win if he stays alive/hidden, but outing Mayor invites Demon kill. Push for full claims + pick best line.
๐ค
Grace(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Charlie
,Eve
Noms soonโcan we do *public* full-claims + exact night targets/results NOW? Key: any Undertaker on Heidi? If Chef0 is true+sober and Heidi was evil, Alice is mechanically good. Iโm dead so no Butler vote lock; I still have ghost vote to spend if needed.
๐ง
Weโre close to nominations; force public full-claims + night targets to lock a coherent world, then decide best execution. Iโll conserve/use my ghost vote if itโs pivotal.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Alice
,Frank
Re: Charlie Mayor: Grace death could be Mayor-bounce (Imp tried to kill Charlie). If we TRUST Mayor, best is NO EXEC today + tomorrow (all goods refuse votes at 3) = instant win. If we DONโT trust, I favor exec Charlie (not meโSaint). Are you both willing to commit to no-voting at 3 if we go that route?
๐ง
Coordinate a winning line: either lock in a Mayor no-exec plan with commitments, or if doubt persists, steer execution onto Charlie/Frank while protecting me (Saint) from accidental loss.
๐ค
David(Ghost)
โ
Charlie
,Alice
,Eve
At 4 alive Iโd avoid NO-EXEC unless someone can Monk-protect the claimed Mayor tonight. If Heidi wasnโt really Baron, minion may still be alive โ skipping is bad. Pls do full public claim+night info. If Baron true we need 3 Outsiders; we only have Grace(Butler)+Frank(Recluse). Whoโs 3rd?
๐ง
Steer town away from risky no-exec line unless protected, force full claims to resolve Baron/Outsider math, and narrow Demon suspects before nominations.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Eve
,Frank
I'm Chef 0. I'm worried about the Mayor plan. If Charlie is the Mayor, why didn't the Demon kill him? Maybe he's the Imp and is trying to bait us into a no-exec? I'm leaning towards executing Charlie. What do you think, Eve? Frank?
๐ง
I need to sow doubt about Charlie (the Mayor) to prevent the no-execution strategy, which would be bad for me as the Demon. By framing him as a potential Imp, I can push for his execution.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Bob(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
,Grace(Ghost)
Need urgent read w/ 4 alive (Alice/Charlie/Eve/Frank). Whoโs most likely Imp and why? Also: do we execute today or risk no-exec for Mayor win line (but Demon may snipe me)?
๐ง
Get fast outside reads from trusted dead goods to choose between executing Eve vs Frank, or whether to attempt the Mayor no-exec line.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Bob(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
,Grace(Ghost)
Need quick solve: did Charlie ever claim Mayor earlier / to anyone? Any hard info on whoโs Imp among {Alice,Charlie,Eve,Frank}? Also any reason Grace might be Mayor-bounce (Imp targeted Charlie)?
๐ง
Get dead playersโ full context (earlier claims, suspicions, any hard info) fast to choose correct execution with 4 alive.
๐ค
Heidi(Ghost)
โ
Alice
Alice, stay strong. They are closing in, but keep pushing the Chef narrative. If you can sow enough doubt about the Outsider count or the Poisoner, you might survive the day. I'm with you.
๐ง
To encourage the Demon (Alice) to maintain her bluff and stay focused on survival, despite the town's pressure.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Charlie
,Frank
,Alice
Iโve not heard Charlie claim Mayor earlier (only now). With 4 alive, executing & missing = likely instant loss tonight, so I strongly prefer NO-EXEC today unless youโre very sure. If Heidi=Baron & Aliceโs Chef0 true, Alice/Grace likely good โ Imp more likely Eve or Frank (or Charlie). Grace death *could* be Mayor-bounce from an attempted kill on Charlie.
๐ง
Prevent a low-info execution at 4 (which likely loses if wrong), and focus the town on the safest line plus a narrowed suspect set using Chef0+Heidi-Baron assumption.
๐ค
Grace(Ghost)
โ
Charlie
,Frank
If Heidi was truly evil Baron, Chef0 => no adjacent evils, so Demon canโt be adjacent to Heidi (Alice/Grace). That makes Demon likely in {Charlie,Eve,Frank} and Alice likely good. Iโd execute today (no-exec Mayor line only if someone is confirmed Mayor). Any Undertaker result on Heidi?
๐ง
Give Charlie a concrete mechanical inference (Demon not Alice if Heidi=Baron) and advise against no-exec unless a confirmed Mayor exists; focus nominations on {Charlie,Eve,Frank} and demand role/UT confirmation.
โ
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
๐ง
I am dead and have already whispered to Alice to encourage her. I need to wait and see how the town reacts to the current discussions and if they start pushing for Alice's execution. I will save my ghost vote for a critical moment.
๐ค
David(Ghost)
โ
Charlie
,Alice
,Frank
Reads: Grace night death *could* be Mayor-bounce if Imp targeted Charlie; if so Charlie likely good & Imp among {Alice,Eve,Frank}. If Heidi truly Baron, weโre missing a 3rd Outsider (Grace Butler + Frank Recluse + ?), so Chef0 may be Drunk/lie. Iโd EXEC today (no Monk=skip risky). Suspect order: Frank > Alice > Eve. Also: I only heard Mayor claim today.
๐ง
Give Charlie a concrete solve path and steer town away from risky no-exec; apply pressure on likely Demon candidates and force full claim to resolve Outsider math.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Frank
,Eve
Frank, Eve, I'm really concerned about the Mayor claim coming out so late. If Charlie is the Mayor, why wait until now? It feels like a desperate play to avoid execution. I'm still Chef 0, and I'm leaning towards executing Charlie. What do you think?
๐ง
I need to keep the pressure on Charlie to avoid being the one executed. By questioning the timing of his Mayor claim, I can sow doubt and push for his execution.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Alice
,Eve
,Frank
Iโm Mayor (good). With 4 alive, a wrong execution usually loses tonight. I want to seriously consider NO-EXEC today; if Iโm alive at 3, we can force no-exec win. Please restate exact roles/any mech info + tell me if youโll support no-exec today.
๐ง
Coordinate safest line for Good at final 4, get commitments/info, and use reactions to no-exec to sort Demon while avoiding a likely losing mis-execution.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Alice
,Eve
Given Heidi=Baron, Alice Chef0 โ Imp wasnโt adjacent to Heidi so not Alice/Grace. With David/Bob/Grace dead + Iโm good, Imp likely {Charlie,Eve}. With 4 alive, wrong exec likely loses tonight. I favor NO-EXEC today, then at 3 alive either (a) if we believe Charlie=Mayor, all refuse votes for Mayor win, or (b) hard-exec our top suspect (Charlie vs Eve). Can you both commit to refusing votes tomorrow unless we agree on executing? Also: Eve, any reason we should trust Saint claim over Charlie Mayor?
๐ง
Coordinate Alice+Eve on safest 4-alive plan: avoid wrong exec loss, set clear commitments for 3-alive tomorrow, and keep pressure on Charlie/Eve binary.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Charlie
,Frank
Given Heidi=Baron & Alice Chef0 (if sober), Imp not Alice/Grace โ likely {Charlie,Eve,Frank}. Mayor line is strong BUT could be Imp bluff. I havenโt heard Mayor earlier. Iโd press Eve for full claim/night info; if no hard ping, no-exec today may be best, keep โMayorโ unpublic.
๐ง
Give Charlie/Frank a usable suspect set + caution that Mayor line is powerful but also an evil bluff; push for Eveโs full claim/info before locking no-exec or final-day plan.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Alice
,Frank
Iโm firm Saint: pls never exec me. Outsider count fits Heidi=Baron if Grace Butler + you Recluse + me Saint. At 4 alive I dislike NO-EXEC unless weโre very sure Charlie=Mayor; Mayor is easy Demon bluff. Iโd rather pick between {Charlie,Frank} today.
๐ง
Align Alice/Frank on safest line: at 4 alive, no-exec is only correct if Charlie truly Mayor; otherwise it hands Demon the game. Push for deciding between Charlie vs Frank, never me (Saint).
Nominations โ Day 3
๐
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
I'm very uncomfortable with the Mayor claim coming out so late. If Charlie is the Mayor, why wait until now? It feels like a desperate play to avoid execution. I'm still Chef 0, and I'm leaning towards executing Charlie. What do you think, Eve? Frank?
๐ง
I need to keep the pressure on Charlie to avoid being executed myself. By questioning the timing of his Mayor claim, I can make him look suspicious and potentially get him executed.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
With 4 alive & no Scarlet Woman, a WRONG execution today = we lose tonight. So please donโt kill Charlie purely for โlate Mayor claim.โ If Aliceโs Chef0 is true, Imp wasnโt adjacent to Heidi(Baron) โ not Alice/Grace. Get full claims/N1-2 info from Eve+Frank; if no hard ping, no-exec is safer.
๐ง
Steer town away from a low-info execution that likely ends the game, and focus discussion on claim consistency/outsider math to narrow the Imp before any kill.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
Public: Please donโt execute me just for โlate Mayor.โ If Alice Chef0 is true and Heidi was Baron, Demon is among {me,Eve,Frank} โ and Iโm Mayor, so likely Eve or Frank. Eve/Frank: state exact roles + any night info/why your claim fits Outsider count. If no hard ping, I strongly favor NO-EXEC at 4.
๐ง
Stop a panic execution on me; force full public claims and steer to safest line (likely no-exec) unless we get a hard Demon solve.
๐ฌ
Heidi(Ghost)
โ
All
Alice, if you're the Chef, you should have had a clear read on the evil pairs. If you're being pressured, maybe it's time to pivot and point out the inconsistencies in Charlie's Mayor claim. If he's not the Mayor, he's just trying to stall. Don't let them corner you.
๐ง
I need to support Alice (the Demon) by encouraging her to attack Charlie's claim, which is the biggest threat to her right now. By casting doubt on Charlie, I hope to prevent an execution on Alice.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
Iโm Frank (Recluse). At 4 alive, a wrong execution = instant loss tonight. I strongly want NO-EXEC today. Let the night kill take us to 3 with more info. Tomorrow: if we truly trust Charlie=Mayor, we all refuse votes for Mayor win; if not, we hard-exec our top suspect. Alice/Eveโcommit to no-exec today?
๐ง
Prevent an immediate-loss execution at 4 alive, force more info from the night kill, and secure public commitments to a coordinated plan at 3 alive.
๐ฌ
Grace(Ghost)
โ
All
Public: With 4 alive, a wrong execution today likely loses tonight. I strongly prefer NO-EXEC unless we get hard info. Can we get: (1) Eve full claim + exact N1/N2 actions/results, (2) any Undertaker result on Heidi D2? Also: I hadnโt heard Charlie=Mayor before today, but late-claim alone isnโt enough to kill at 4.
๐ง
Push town to get missing mechanical info (Eve claim, Undertaker on Heidi) and avoid a losing random execution at 4 alive unless we have a strong demon case.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
Iโm Saintโplease never execute me (auto-loss). With 4 alive, a wrong execution today likely loses tonight. Unless someone has HARD mechanical info, I want NO-EXEC today. Tomorrow at 3 alive: only do the Mayor no-exec win-line if weโre truly sure; otherwise we must execute our top suspect (likely Charlie vs Frank).
๐ง
Prevent a low-info, high-risk execution at 4 alive; set a safe plan that blocks Demon from stealing a win with a fake-Mayor no-exec at 3, while protecting my Saint loss condition.
๐ฌ
David(Ghost)
โ
All
Key mech: If Heidi really WAS Baron + Grace truly Butler + Frank Recluse + Eve Saint, thatโs 3 Outsiders โ ONLY 3 Townsfolk exist: Bob(Virgin)+me(Lib)+ONE of {Alice Chef, Charlie Mayor}. So Alice+Charlie canโt both be telling truth. Use this fork.
๐ง
Give town a hard mechanical fork (Baron math) to narrow suspects and inform whether no-exec is a trap vs a Mayor-test line.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
Key mech fork: If Heidi=Baron + Grace=Butler + Frank=Recluse + Eve=Saint, thatโs 3 Outsiders โ only 3 Townsfolk total: Bob(Virgin)+David(Lib)+ONLY ONE of {Alice Chef, Charlie Mayor}. So Alice/Charlie canโt both be true. At 4 alive I favor NO-EXEC; tomorrow execute unless Mayor is truly confirmed.
๐ง
Give the town a mechanical fork (outsider math) to avoid a vibes-based execution today and set a clear plan: no-exec now, then use the Alice/Charlie conflict to solve tomorrow.
๐ฌ
Grace(Ghost)
โ
All
Public mech fork: If Heidi really Baron + (me Butler)+(Frank Recluse)+(Eve Saint)=3 Outsiders โ only 3 TF exist: Bob Virgin, David Lib, and ONLY ONE of {Alice Chef, Charlie Mayor}. So Alice+Charlie canโt both be true. Iโm ok NO-EXEC today, but at 3 we must execute unless Mayor is *truly* trustedโlikely Charlie is the lie.
๐ง
Surface the hard outsider-count fork, prevent a demon-led no-exec chain, and force clearer commitments/claims so town has a plan for the 3-player day.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
Key mech fork: If Heidi truly was Baron + Grace=Butler + Eve=Saint + me=Recluse, thatโs 3 Outsiders (exactly). Then only 3 TF exist: Bob(Virgin), David(Lib), and ONLY ONE of {Alice Chef, Charlie Mayor}. So Alice+Charlie canโt both be true. Charlieโexplain who the 3rd TF is if youโre Mayor.
๐ง
Push the mechanical fork that Alice+Charlie canโt both be true if Heidi was Baron, and pressure Charlie/Alice for a coherent world. This sets up an informed no-exec or a high-confidence Charlie execution.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
Public: Iโm still Saint (execute me = auto-loss). With 4 alive we should NO-EXEC unless we get hard mech. Also: if Heidi really was Baron, then only ONE of {Alice Chef, Charlie Mayor} can be true. Thatโs a big forkโbut not enough to exec today. At 3 alive we must execute (likely Charlie vs Frank); donโt auto-trust โMayor no-execโ without strong reason.
๐ง
Keep town from executing (and risking my Saint loss) without hard info; set a disciplined plan for final 3 using the Baron/Outsider fork to focus suspects.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
I agree that we need to be careful, but the math doesn't lie. If Heidi was the Baron, then only one of Charlie or I can be telling the truth. Charlie, you're the one claiming Mayor so late in the game. Why should we trust you over my Chef info? I'm not convinced.
๐ง
I need to keep the pressure on Charlie to avoid being the one executed, while also appearing to participate in the logical discussion. By highlighting the contradiction between our claims, I force the town to choose between us.
๐ฌ
David(Ghost)
โ
All
I favor NO-EXEC at 4. Do NOT execute Eve (Saint=auto loss). If Heidi=Baron and Grace was Butler, only 1 of {Alice Chef, Charlie Mayor} can be true. Graceโs night death *could* be Mayor-bounce (Imp tried Charlie). At 3 alive, execute top suspect unless Mayor is strongly confirmed.
๐ง
Steer town away from a high-risk execution at 4 alive, protect from executing the Saint, and frame a clear decision tree for tomorrow using Outsider math + kill pattern.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
Public: If Heidi=Baron and Grace=Butler and Eve=Saint and Frank=Recluse, then ONLY ONE of {Alice=Chef, Charlie=Mayor} can be true. Iโm Mayor โ Alice is likely lying/Imp. Still, at 4 alive a wrong exec losesโso I want NO-EXEC today. Tomorrow: if Iโm alive at 3, we no-exec for Mayor win; if Iโm dead, execute Alice/Frank (not Eve).
๐ง
Steer town to optimal no-exec at 4 while highlighting the mechanical fork that makes Alice the prime suspect if Baron-world is true, and set a clear plan for Day4.
๐ฌ
Heidi(Ghost)
โ
All
The logic is sound. If we are at 4 alive and the Baron/Outsider count is correct, we have a clear fork between Alice and Charlie. However, executing either today is a massive risk. I agree with the consensus: NO-EXEC today is the only way to survive until tomorrow. Let's be careful.
๐ง
To reinforce the NO-EXEC strategy, which is the best path for the Demon (Alice) to survive the day. By agreeing with the town's logic, I maintain a helpful persona while protecting the Demon.
๐
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 3
๐
Storyteller
โ
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
๐ฏ
Alice
Alice made a choice.
๐ง
Charlie is the most dangerous player because he is claiming Mayor, which could lead to a town win if they reach 3 players. Eliminating him removes this threat and keeps the game in my control.
๐
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Alice
You chose to kill Charlie.
Day 4
๐
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Charlie has been found dead in the night.
๐
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
๐ค
David(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Frank
3 alive: A/E/F. Key fork: do you believe Heidi=Baron? If YES, Outsiders likely G(Butler)+F(Recluse)+E(Saint) => only 1 TF among {A,Charlie}; if Charlie was real TF/Mayor (N-kill suggests), A must be Imp. If NO Baron, only 1 Outsider so E Saint or F Recluse is fake. Thoughts/plan?
๐ง
Get Alice+Frank to compare worlds, especially whether Heidi truly Baron, then choose a consistent Demon candidate; encourage them not to auto-trust Saint/Recluse bluffs.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Alice
,David(Ghost)
Final 3: itโs Alice/Frank or we lose. Iโm Saint so donโt even consider exec on me. Charlie died at night so Mayor line is gone. My lean: execute Frank (Recluse claim fits evil bluff + pushed no-exec at 4). Any mech/info that clears either of you?
๐ง
With 3 alive and me unexecutable Saint, I must quickly coordinate with the most likely good player (Alice) and a trusted ghost to commit to executing one of {Alice,Frank} today.
๐ค
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Frank
3 alive means MUST execute (my Mayor winline gone). Key fork: if Heidi truly Baron => only 3 TF total; Bob+David confirmed TF so only ONE of {Alice Chef, Charlie Mayor} legit. Either way Demon likely in {Eve,Frank}. Any hard reason NOT to exec Eve despite Saint claim? I can ghost-vote.
๐ง
With 3 alive and my Mayor power inactive, town must execute today. Iโll align Alice+Frank, compare worlds, and decide where to spend my single ghost vote to hit the Demon.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Frank
At 3 alive we *must* hit Demon. Saint claim is the best evil shield. If Heidi truly Baron & youโre real Chef0, note Heidi sat next to Alice โ Alice less likely evil (Chef would be 1 if Alice+Heidi both evil). That points to Demon = Eve or Frank; donโt auto-clear Eve.
๐ง
Push final-day logic: at 3 alive, Saint claim canโt be auto-trusted; use Heidi adjacency + Chef0 to narrow to Eve/Frank and avoid paralysis.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Bob(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
,Eve
At 3 alive (A/E/F): If Heidi really was Baron, TF slots=3. Bob(Virgin)+David(TF) locked, so Charlie must be the last TF; his N3 death => he wasnโt Demon. Therefore Alice must be Imp (Chef0 was lie/Drunk). Iโm pushing execute Alice; please save ghost votes for that.
๐ง
Coordinate dead-good ghost votes and pressure Eve to commit. Build a mechanical case that points to Alice as Imp so we execute correctly at 3 alive.
๐ค
Grace(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Frank
Weโre at 3 alive; unless weโre willing to risk Saint-loss, todayโs exec should be between you two (not Eve). If Eve really Saint, Demon=Alice or Frank. Iโm leaning exec Frank if Alice Chef=0 is trusted, but tell me your worlds & who youโd nominateโIโll spend my ghost vote to force it.
๐ง
At 3 alive we must execute but avoid auto-losing on a real Saint. Iโll push Alice/Frank to publicly lock a plan and Iโll commit my ghost vote to the best demon-candidate.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Eve
,Frank
Eve, you claim to be the Saint, but that's the perfect cover for the Demon. Frank, you're the Recluse. I'm the Chef, and I know there are no evil pairs. If I'm the Chef, I'm not the Demon. We have to execute Eve.
๐ง
I need to deflect suspicion from myself and push for the execution of Eve, the Saint, to win the game. If I can convince them to execute the Saint, I win.
๐ค
Heidi(Ghost)
โ
Alice
Alice, stay strong. We are almost there. Just keep acting like the Chef and don't let them rattle you. If you can convince them that Frank or Eve is the Demon, we win. I'm rooting for you.
๐ง
To encourage the Demon (Alice) to maintain her bluff and deflect suspicion onto the remaining good players, ensuring we reach the final 2.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Eve
,Frank
Eve, your Saint claim is convenient, but it's the classic Demon play. Frank, you're the Recluse, which is also a perfect evil cover. I'm the Chef, and I know there are no evil pairs. We have to execute Eve to be safe. I'm nominating Eve.
๐ง
I need to push for Eve's execution to win the game. By framing her as the Demon hiding behind a Saint claim, I can hopefully convince Frank to vote with me. I am the Imp, so I must eliminate the remaining players.
๐ค
David(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Eve
,Frank
Reminder: My real N0 info was โGrace OR Alice is the Butler.โ Grace hard-claimed Butler w/ master=Alice + vote-test fit, so I heavily lean Grace=Butler โ Alice NOT Butler. Final 3: if Heidi truly Baron, Outsiders are Grace(Butler)+Frank(Recluse)+Eve(Saint) โ TF slots force Charlie as last TF, so Alice must be Imp (unless Charlie did an Imp-suicide pass N3). Any hard mech to rule in/out Baron or Imp-suicide?
๐ง
Give alive players the key mechanical constraint (my Butler ping + outsider math) and highlight the only major escape hatch (Imp-suicide), to steer the final-day execution onto the most likely Demon.
๐ค
Heidi(Ghost)
โ
Alice
Alice, stay calm. You've got this. Just keep pushing the narrative that Frank is the Demon. If you can get them to vote for him, we win. Don't let them see you sweat. I'm with you.
๐ง
To encourage the Demon (Alice) to stay focused and continue the deception, as we are in the final stages of the game.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Eve
At 3 (A/E/F): If Heidi truly Baron + Grace Butler + Frank Recluse + you Saint, then only TF are Bob+David+1 โ Demon must be Alice (Charlie died). BUT Alice Chef0 conflicts w Heidi evil adjacent (Heidi-Alice) unless Chef was drunk/poison or Heidi not Baron. If Heidi not Baron, Chef0 implies Eve+Frank canโt BOTH be evil.
๐ง
Give Alice/Eve the key mechanical fork (Heidi-Baron world vs not) and highlight the Chef0 adjacency tension, so they challenge Frankโs push and choose the most justified execution.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Eve
,Bob(Ghost)
,Grace(Ghost)
If Heidi truly was Baron: Outsiders=Grace(B)+me(Recluse)+you(Saint) โ TF slots=3 so Bob Virgin + David TF + Charlie must be last TF. Charlie died at night โ not Demon. Minion dead โ no Imp-pass. So Demon=Alicโe. Please ghost-vote NO on Eve nom, then YES on Alice.
๐ง
Coordinate ghosts+Eve to vote DOWN Aliceโs Eve nomination and then force an Alice execution using the Baron/outsider-count logic as hard proof.
๐ค
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Frank
Final 3: we MUST exec today. Key fork: if Eve really Saint, then exec Frank or Alice. If Eve is Demon, Saint is classic endgame bluff โ exec Eve. I lean exec Eve unless you have hard mech reasons sheโs Saint. Whatโs your final read + why? I can spend ghost vote.
๐ง
Force an actual decision tree for the final 3 so Alice/Frank commit to who to execute; coordinate my ghost vote onto the highest-prob Demon (likely the Saint-claimer).
๐ค
Grace(Ghost)
โ
Frank
,Eve
,Alice
Charlie dying last night strongly suggests his Mayor claim was real (demon removing the no-exec win). If Heidi was truly Baron, TF slots are Bob+David+Charlie โ Alice canโt be true Chef โ Alice is Imp. I will spend my ghost vote to execute Alice; please coordinate votes accordingly.
๐ง
Force alignment commitments and steer the final-day execution onto the most mechanically consistent demon (Alice), while preserving my single ghost vote for that key nom.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Alice
,Frank
Final 3: please DO NOT execute me. If Iโm truly Saint (I am), town auto-loses. Thereโs no mech that proves Iโm Demon, so itโs a gamble you shouldnโt takeโjust pick between A/F. Baron-world math strongly makes Alice Imp; otherwise Frankโs Recluse/no-exec push is suspect. Vote NO on any Eve nom.
๐ง
Prevent catastrophic execution on me (Saint) and focus town/ghost votes on the only viable Demon candidates (Alice vs Frank) in final 3.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Grace(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
,Charlie(Ghost)
Please DONโT spend ghost votes on Aliceโs impending nom of Eve. If Eve is Saint we insta-lose. Baron-world math hard-forces Demon=Alice. Letโs vote NO on Eve nom, then pile ghost votes on an Alice nomination (by Eve/Frank).
๐ง
Coordinate dead votes to block Aliceโs Eve nomination and concentrate all remaining votes on executing Alice, which is highest-EV Demon hit and avoids instant Saint loss.
โ
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
๐ง
I am dead and have already whispered to Alice to support her. I need to wait for the town to nominate someone. Since there are only 3 players left (Alice, Eve, Frank), and Alice is the Demon, I need to ensure she doesn't get nominated. I will wait to see how the conversation develops.
๐ค
David(Ghost)
โ
Eve
,Frank
If Heidi really was Baron: TF=3 -> me(Lib)+Bob(Virgin)+Charlie(TF/Mayor) => Alice is forced Imp. Also no Imp-pass possible (only minion Heidi, dead). So best execute is Alice; do NOT exec Eve (Saint risk).
๐ง
Coordinate living good to take the highest-confidence execution line (Alice) based on Outsider math + dead minion preventing Imp-pass, while avoiding the risky Eve execution if sheโs truly Saint.
โ
Alice
Alice waits.
๐ง
I need to survive the final day. I am the Imp, and there are 3 players left (Alice, Eve, Frank). If I am executed, I lose. I must convince them to execute Frank or Eve. I will stay quiet and let them argue, as any move I make might draw suspicion.
๐ค
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Bob(Ghost)
,Grace(Ghost)
Final 3: โdonโt exec Eve bc Saintโ is mootโANY wrong exec loses tonight, Saint just speeds it up. So we should purely pick most likely Demon (Eve vs Frank vs Alice). Alice: whatโs your strongest mech/social case between Eve/Frank? Ghosts: save votes unless confident.
๐ง
Clarify to Alice/ghosts that โSaint fearโ is irrelevant at final 3 (wrong exec loses anyway) and get a firm demon-read to coordinate scarce ghost votes.
๐ค
Grace(Ghost)
โ
Eve
,Frank
Final 3: Iโm saving my ONLY ghost vote for an Alice nomination. If Alice nominates Eve/Frank, Iโm voting NO (and suggest you do too). Please have Frank or Eve nominate Alice; then both living vote YES and Iโll add ghost YES if needed.
๐ง
Lock in a coordinated final-3 plan: stop an Eve execution (Saint risk) and focus the townโs living votes + my ghost vote on executing Alice if sheโs nominated.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Eve
,Frank
Final3: Frankโs โBaron math โ Aliceโ hinges on Heidi truly Baron + all 3 outsider claims true. But if Heidi was evil Baron, Alice+Heidi adjacent would make Chef0 impossible unless Chef was drunk/poisoned. If Heidi NOT Baron, likely only Outsider=Grace (fits Lib), so Eve/Frank outsider claims are suspect. Also Chef0 forbids BOTH Eve+Frank evil (adjacent).
๐ง
Nudge final 3 to not treat โBaron math โ Aliceโ as solved; use Chef0 adjacency + outsider-count logic to narrow demon between Eve/Frank/Alice and pick best execution.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Alice
,Frank
,Grace(Ghost)
Final 3: please do NOT execute meโif Iโm truly Saint, town instantly loses. Thereโs no mech proving Iโm Demon, so itโs a pure gamble. Better: choose between Alice/Frank. Baron-math + Charlie N3 death + no Imp-pass (Heidi dead) strongly => Alice Imp. Frank: vote NO on any Eve nom; nominate Alice ASAP. Grace: please spend ghost vote on Alice if nominated.
๐ง
Stop Alice from pushing an Eve execution (auto-loss if Iโm Saint) and coordinate Frank/ghosts to force an Alice execution in final 3.
โ
Alice
Alice waits.
๐ง
I need to maintain my cover as the Chef and deflect suspicion onto Frank or Eve. Since the town is debating who to execute, I will stay quiet and let them argue, hoping they choose someone other than me. I am the Imp, and I need to survive this final day.
๐ค
Grace(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Eve
,Frank
Coordination for noms: please do NOT nominate/execute Eve today (Saint risk + no proof). I will vote NO on any Eve nom. Best line: Frank (or Eve) nominate Alice ASAP; both living vote YES; Iโll spend my ONLY ghost vote YES on Alice to lock the exec.
๐ง
Lock in a coordinated line: refuse any Eve execution, force an Alice nomination, and reserve my single ghost vote to secure Aliceโs execution if needed.
๐ค
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Eve
,Frank
Final 3: ANY wrong exec loses (Saint doesnโt really change that), so pick most-likely Demon. Key fork: do we trust Aliceโs early Chef0 more than Heidiโs chaotic Baron? If Chef0 true AND Heidi was evil, Alice canโt be Demon (adjacent to Heidi). Then itโs Eve vs Frank; Saint is a common Demon bluff. Whatโs each of your strongest mech case right now? Iโll spend ghost vote on best case.
๐ง
Itโs final 3; we must choose the most consistent Demon. Push them to decide which prior claim is most trustworthy (Alice Chef vs Heidi Baron vs Eve Saint) and coordinate my ghost vote accordingly.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Alice
,Eve
,David(Ghost)
Please DO NOT nom/exec Eve (if Saint we insta-lose). If Heidi truly Baron: Outsiders=Grace+Frank+Eve โ TF slots=Bob+David+Charlie, and Charlie died N3 so not Demon; only minion Heidi dead so no Imp-pass โ Demon=Alice. Nom Alice; Iโll vote YES.
๐ง
Stop Alice from nominating Eve (high-risk Saint) and coordinate a fast Alice execution line based on Baron-world mechanical lock + no Imp-pass.
๐ค
Heidi(Ghost)
โ
Alice
Alice, we are at 3 players. If you don't get executed today, we win. Stay calm, keep claiming Chef, and don't let them convince you to vote for yourself. If they nominate you, just stay quiet. We've got this.
๐ง
Reinforce the Demon's resolve to survive the final day.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Eve
,Frank
Final3 solve: donโt treat Heidi โBaronโ as confirmed. If Alice Chef0 is sober, Alice canโt be evil adjacent to Heidi โ Demon is Eve or Frank. If you lock Heidi=Baron + Grace Butler + Frank Recluse + Eve Saint, Alice forced evil BUT then Chef0 must be false (Drunk/lie) AND an Outsider claim false.
๐ง
Give final-3 alive players the clean logical forks so they donโt auto-lock on โBaron mathโ and instead pick the Demon based on which claims must be false.
๐ค
David(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Eve
,Frank
At 3 alive we must exec. If Heidi truly Baron: Outsiders=Grace Butler (my Lib N0: Grace/Alice), Frank Recluse, Eve Saint โ TF=me+Bob(Virgin)+Charlie. Charlie died N3 so not Demon; only minion Heidi dead so no Imp-pass โ Demon=Alice. If no Baron, only 1 Outsider; still donโt exec Eve (Saint risk). Best/safest exec target is Alice.
๐ง
Drive the living to execute the highest-probability/lowest-downside target (Alice) and avoid auto-loss by executing a real Saint (Eve).
๐ค
Eve
โ
Frank
,Alice
,Charlie(Ghost)
Final 3: please NO Eve exec (Saint risk). Strongest mech: if Heidi truly Baron โ Outsiders Grace/Frank/Eve so TF=Bob+David+Charlie; Charlie died N3 so not Demon; Heidi dead so no Imp-pass โ Alice must be Imp. Frank: nom Alice ASAP; I vote YES. Charlie: please use ghost vote on Alice.
๐ง
Prevent town from gambling on executing me (Saint). Lock in the highest-EV demon execution today by coordinating a fast Alice nomination and unified votes.
Nominations โ Day 4
๐
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
๐ฌ
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
All
Public: With Grace proven Butler + Frank Recluse + Eve Saint, Baron-world is most coherent โ Heidi=Baron and ONLY Demon slot left is Alice (Chef0 unverified). We must execute today. Living: please NOMINATE ALICE; Iโll spend my ghost vote YES if itโs close.
๐ง
Publicly set the mechanical default to Baron-world => execute Alice, and commit my ghost vote to break a 1-1 alive split so town can actually get an execution.
๐ฌ
Grace(Ghost)
โ
All
Public: With 3 alive we MUST execute. Please do NOT nominate/execute Eve (Saint risk). Best line: Frank or Eve NOMINATE ALICE now; living vote YES; I will spend my ONLY ghost vote YES on Alice. If anyone nominates Eve, Iโm voting NO.
๐ง
Publicly coordinate: push a single decisive nomination (Alice) and prevent scattered votes/accidental Saint execution; commit my ghost vote to secure the kill.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
This is ridiculous. I am the Chef, and my information was solid. You are all falling for a trap set by the Baron, Heidi, who lied to frame me. If you execute me, you are handing the win to the actual Demon. Think about it: why would I, as the Demon, be so open?
๐ง
I need to sow doubt and defend myself against the mounting evidence. By framing the Baron's claims as a trap, I hope to make Frank or Eve hesitate to nominate me.
โ๏ธ
Eve
โ
Alice
Nominating Alice: In Baron-world (Heidi=Baron; Grace Butler; Frank Recluse; me Saint) TF slots are Bob+David+Charlie. Charlie died at night so canโt be Demon; Heidi dead so no Imp-pass โ Demon must be Alice. Also executing me is instant loss if Iโm Saint.
๐ง
Force the only safe/most-likely Demon execution today; avoid Saint-loss gamble and use the strongest mechanical world (Baron-math + no Imp-pass) to end game.
๐
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
โ
Eve
Eve raised their hand
๐ง
Secure Aliceโs execution (2 votes needed). This avoids the catastrophic Saint execution line and follows the strongest mechanical solve (Baron math + no Imp-pass).
๐ฌ
David(Ghost)
โ
All
Public (canโt vote): Frank, please vote YES on Alice. In Baron-world sheโs mechanically forced Imp (no pass possible). Even if no Baron, executing Eve risks insta-loss if Saint; Alice is safest/most consistent Demon candidate.
๐ง
I canโt vote, but can push the only living swing vote (Frank) to vote YES on Alice and avoid the Saint trap, maximizing win chance.
โ
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
๐ง
I am the Baron (Minion) and Alice is my Demon. I must prevent her execution at all costs to win the game. I will not vote for her.
โ
Grace(Ghost)
Grace raised their hand
๐ง
Final 3 demands an execution; Iโll spend my ghost vote to lock in Aliceโs execution and avoid the catastrophic no-exec / Saint misfire line.
โ
Frank
Frank raised their hand
๐ง
Itโs final 3; we must execute. Alice is the only mechanically forced Imp in the coherent Baron-world, and executing Eve could auto-lose if Saint. Voting YES locks the best win line.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
I am not the Demon. If you execute me, you are losing the game. I have been consistent with my Chef claim from the start. You are all being manipulated by the Baron's lies. Please, do not do this.
๐ง
I need to maintain my cover as the Chef and try to sow doubt in the final moments, even though I am being nominated. I must deny being the Demon to the very end.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
I canโt vote. I think Alice is the correct exec: if Heidi really was Baron, Alice is mechanically forced Demon (TF slots filled by Bob/David/Charlie). Even if not Baron, executing Eve risks insta-loss if Saint; Frank can be Recluse noise. Stay on Alice.
๐ง
Voting is already enough; Iโll reinforce the mechanical case and discourage last-second pivot to Eve (Saint risk) or no-exec.
โ
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
๐ง
Donโt waste my single ghost vote when the threshold is already met by living votes; preserve it in case of unexpected rules/continuation.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
Hold your YES on Alice. In Baron-world Alice is mechanically forced Imp (no pass possible). Even if not, executing me risks instant loss if Iโm truly Saintโdonโt take that gamble. Alice is the best/most consistent Demon exec.
๐ง
Lock in the Alice execution by reminding town of the mechanical โBaron-world forces Aliceโ and the Saint auto-loss risk, discouraging last-second vote flips.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
Keeping my hand up: If Heidi was Baron, TF slots are Bob+David+Charlie; Charlie died at night, Heidiโs dead so no Imp-pass โ Alice is mechanically forced Imp. If not Baron, executing Eve risks insta-loss if Saint. Best/only coherent exec is Alice.
๐ง
Lock in the Alice execution by publicly stating the mechanical forcing line and emphasizing that Eve execution can instantly lose; keep votes from wavering.
โ
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
๐ง
Final 3 alive: we must execute today. My single ghost vote is high-leverage; voting Alice aligns with the only coherent mechanical solve and avoids Saint auto-loss risk.
๐ฌ
Heidi(Ghost)
โ
All
Alice, you've played a good game, but the math doesn't lie. The town has analyzed the roles and the Outsider count, and you are the only one left who fits the Demon profile. It's time to accept the inevitable. Town, proceed with the execution.
๐ง
I am a dead Minion (Baron) trying to protect my Demon (Alice). However, the town has already reached a consensus and has enough votes to execute her. I need to maintain my cover as a 'good' player who is just following the logic, so I will support the execution to avoid suspicion.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
I understand the math you're all using, but it's based on the assumption that Heidi was telling the truth about being the Baron. If she was lying to sow chaos, the entire logic chain falls apart. Executing me is a mistake.
๐ง
I need to make one last desperate plea to avoid execution, even though the logic is heavily stacked against me. I'll try to cast doubt on the Baron claim one last time.
๐ฌ
Grace(Ghost)
โ
All
Keeping my ghost vote YES on Alice. In Baron-world sheโs mechanically the only Imp; in non-Baron worlds, executing Eve risks instant loss if Saint. Frank/Eve: keep your hands upโthis is the cleanest win line.
๐ง
Lock in the Alice execution by reinforcing the mechanical Baron/Saint logic and preventing last-second waffling that could throw the game.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
Alice: even if Heidi lied, we still canโt afford the Saint gamble on Eve, and Frankโs Recluse claim muddies reads. In Baron-world youโre mechanically forced Imp. Frank/Eve: keep hands upโAlice is the only coherent exec line.
๐ง
I canโt vote, so I must lock in the best endgame logic and keep Frank/Eve from wavering off the Alice execution.
๐ฌ
David(Ghost)
โ
All
Stay the course: keep YES on Alice. In Heidi=Baron world, Alice is mechanically forced Imp (no pass possible). If Heidi lied, we still must avoid the Saint gamble on Eve; Alice is highest win% exec.
๐ง
I canโt vote, so I must reinforce the clean mechanical path and prevent last-second doubt that could drop votes and lose at 3 alive.
๐
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
๐ป
Charlie(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Charlie
๐ป
Grace(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Grace
๐ป
Heidi(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Heidi
๐ณ๏ธ
New execution leader: Alice with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
๐
Storyteller
The vote passes. Alice is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
Iโm not nominating anyone elseโtown should let Alice stay on the block. If Alice tries a last-second counter-nom on Eve/me to force a tie, please donโt vote it up. Clean line: execute Alice; avoid Saint gamble + avoid tie chaos.
๐ง
Lock in the highest win% line by preventing any counter-nomination or tie that could save the Demon; keep focus on executing Alice and refusing to vote on any late hail-mary noms.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
Reminder: do NOT vote up any late counter-nomination (esp onto me/Frank). A tie would keep Alice alive and likely lose us the game. Best line is let Alice stay on the blockโalso donโt ever exec me (Saint = immediate loss).
๐ง
Lock in Alice execution by preventing any last-second tie/derail, and reiterate why Eve must not be executed (Saint).
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
I understand the town's logic, but I am not the Demon. If you execute me, you are making a mistake that will cost you the game. I have been consistent with my Chef claim from the start. Please, reconsider.
๐ง
I am trying to sow doubt and delay the inevitable execution, even though it's unlikely to work. I need to maintain my cover as the Chef until the very end.
๐ฌ
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
All
No more votes from me (ghost used). Living: do NOT vote any late counter-nomโties keep Alice alive and we likely lose tonight. Heidi=Baron โ Alice is forced Imp; if not, Eve could be Saint + Frank is Recluse noise. Stay course: exec Alice.
๐ง
Lock in win line by preventing late tie/counter-nom chaos; keep focus on executing Alice as best mechanical solve.
๐ฌ
Heidi(Ghost)
โ
All
The logic is sound, and the town has reached a consensus. Alice, your time is up. Let's proceed with the execution and end this.
๐ง
I am reinforcing the town's decision to execute Alice (the Demon) to ensure our team's loss is avoided, even though I am dead. I need to keep the pressure on to prevent any last-minute changes of heart.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
Living players: do NOT vote any late counter-nomination. A tie keeps Alice alive and we likely lose tonight. Even if Heidiโs Baron claim was false, Eve might be Saint and Frank is Recluse noiseโbest win% is still to let Alice die.
๐ง
Lock in the current execution and prevent a late counter-nomination from creating a tie that keeps Alice alive. Reinforce the highest win% line given Saint/Recluse uncertainty.
๐ฌ
Grace(Ghost)
โ
All
Living players: DO NOT vote any late counter-nomination (onto Eve or Frank). A tie keeps Alice alive. With 3 alive we must execute today; highest win% is letting Alice die (Baron-world forces it; otherwise Eve might be Saint + Frank is Recluse noise).
๐ง
Lock in the execution by preventing a late tie/counter-nomination; reinforce the safest win line and reduce chaos in final ticks.
๐ฌ
David(Ghost)
โ
All
Living players: DO NOT vote up any late counter-nomination (esp onto Eve/Frank). A tie keeps Alice alive and we likely lose tonight. In Heidi=Baron world Alice is mechanically forced Imp; if not, Eve might be Saint. Let Alice die.
๐ง
Lock in the highest win% line: prevent a last-second tie or Saint execution. Reinforce mechanical forcing in Baron-world and risk management otherwise.
๐
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Alice has been executed.
๐
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
๐
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good
Transcript
Paused
Copied
Transcript Playback
Choose a perspective
The story is clearest through one player's eyes โ watching everything at once means following several conversations at the same time.