Game Detail
Players
Alice (Librarian) Bob (Recluse) Charlie (Butler) David (Baron) Eve (Monk) Frank (Imp) Grace (Virgin) Heidi (Drunk)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 798,327 | 93,392 | $2.7046 |
| Evil | 279,522 | 40,883 | $2.6241 |
Event Transcript
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
David
You are the Minion. The Demon is Frank.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Minions are: David. Your safe bluffs are: Ravenkeeper, Mayor, Investigator
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Librarian. Either Heidi or Frank is the Drunk.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Chef. You learn that there are 1 pairs of evil players.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
Pick an engaged, easy-to-coordinate master on Night 0 so I can still participate in key votes while gathering tells and switching later if needed.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You chose Bob to be your master.
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Heidi
Hi Frank and Heidi. I am the Virgin. If one of you is a Townsfolk, nominating me will instantly execute you and hard confirm us both as good. Would either of you be willing to do that at nominations today, and what are you claiming?
π§
Get early mechanical confirmation via a Virgin test, or catch evils who avoid it. Build a trusted pair and create a clear execution path for Day 1 or 2.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Heidi
I am not keen to burn a nomination into a Virgin test on day one. I am claiming Ravenkeeper, so I would rather not be the person who proves it. Heidi, what are you willing to claim?
π§
Claim a safe bluff and discourage a Virgin confirmation that would strengthen good. Pull Heidi's claim for targeting and framing options.
π€
David
β
Frank
Frank, I am your Baron. What bluffs did you get? I can take one that does not clash, or I can claim something expendable like Soldier if you want the stronger ones.
π§
Coordinate with Demon early, learn safe bluffs, and set a claim that protects Frank without public linkage.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
Hey Heidi, quick private check in. What are you planning to claim today, and did you get any starting info Night Zero? I have a piece of setup info I can share once I know what you are claiming.
π§
Get an early private claim from Heidi and see if her story coheres. If she acts confused or her info conflicts later, that supports her being the Drunk; otherwise Frank becomes the likely Drunk.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Charlie
Hey. What are you claiming, and do you have any night zero info? Also, has anyone given you a role ping about me or about our neighbors?
π§
Get early role claims and any N0 info from my neighbors, while keeping my own Outsider role hidden, so I can map possible worlds before nominations.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
I am the Butler. I picked you as my master for today, so I can only vote if you vote too. No night zero info beyond that. Have you heard any role pings about you, me, or David yet?
π§
Confirm my Butler constraint with my chosen master and gather any info about pings on Bob/our neighbors while keeping the circle small.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
Hey Alice. I am Chef. My Night Zero info is there is exactly one pair of evil players sitting next to each other. Happy to share more publicly later. What is your setup info, and what are you thinking of claiming?
π§
Build a trusted info link with Alice and get her setup info, while establishing my Chef=1 pair to guide early worldbuilding.
π€
Eve
β
Alice
,David
Hi. What role are you claiming, and what did you learn night zero? Also, do you want protection tonight if you are an ongoing info role?
π§
Get early info-role claims and night-zero info to decide who to protect N1 and who to pressure in nominations.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,David
Hi Alice and David, I am the Virgin. If a Townsfolk nominates me for the first time, they die immediately and we both get hard confirmed as good. Would one of you be willing to nominate me today? Also, what are you both claiming?
π§
Set up a day one Virgin test with someone outside my neighbor pair to create hard confirmations and catch evasive evil early.
π€
Frank
β
David
I claimed Ravenkeeper to Grace and Heidi, so please do not take that. You should take Mayor if you want to look harmless, or Investigator if you want to create pressure. I like Investigator with a soft ping on two good players, but keep it flexible for now.
π§
Coordinate bluffs with my Baron, protect my Ravenkeeper claim, and set up a false info path to misexecute good players later.
π€
David
β
Eve
,Alice
I am claiming Investigator. I saw a Baron between Bob and Charlie. I was going to keep it quiet until nominations so I could hear their claims first. If you are the Monk, I would protect ongoing information over me tonight.
π§
Build a credible bluff and aim town pressure at Bob and Charlie while keeping Frank away from suspicion.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,David
I am Librarian. Night zero: either Heidi or Frank is the Drunk. Grace, I am willing to nominate you today for the Virgin test if you still want it. David, note Heidi claims Chef with one adjacent evil pair, but she might be the Drunk per my info.
π§
Coordinate a Virgin confirmation today to create hard good clears, and share my Librarian Drunk ping plus the implications with Davidβs Investigator and Heidiβs Chef claim.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
Got it, I will try to coordinate votes with you today so you are not locked out. I have not heard any pings about you, me, or David yet. Have you heard any Librarian or Washerwoman type info floating around, and do you have any early suspicions?
π§
Confirm the Butler constraint, keep Charlie cooperative, and gather more info without overcommitting to votes or exposing my Recluse role yet.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
No hard suspicions yet. I have not heard any Librarian or Washerwoman style pings so far. I will poke David and maybe Alice for what they have heard. For votes today, if you are planning to vote, give me a quick heads up so I can follow you.
π§
Answer Bob, propose a vote-coordination plan, and start collecting claim fragments from others while keeping my info minimal in case Bob is evil.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
,Frank
I can share: I am Chef, and I got exactly one pair of evil players sitting next to each other. On the Virgin test, I am open to nominating you if the town wants that confirmation today, but I would prefer to wait unless we need it.
π§
Respond to the Virgin proposal, share my Chef info to build trust, but avoid committing to a risky Day 1 Virgin test unless the group wants it.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
,Charlie
Hey, quick check in. What role are you planning to claim today, and did you learn anything night zero? Also, do you expect any extra Outsiders in this game?
π§
Get Bob and Charlie to lock in public-facing claims and Outsider expectations, so we can evaluate Davidβs Investigator ping and plan who to protect tonight.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,David
Alice, yes please nominate me today for the Virgin test. If it works we are both hard confirmed good. David, what are you claiming, and do you have any reason we should not spend a nomination on this today?
π§
Lock in a mechanical confirmation early: either confirm Alice and me as good via Virgin trigger, or catch Alice as non-Townsfolk if it fails. Then use Librarian/Chef info to narrow suspects.
π€
Frank
β
David
Heidi told me Chef with one evil pair, and Grace told me Virgin. Since you and I are not neighbors, that Chef number can be pushed as drunk or pointing elsewhere. If you go Investigator, keep it away from me and make it sound cautious.
π§
Coordinate with my Baron before nominations and prepare ways to deflect Heidi's Chef info while protecting my Ravenkeeper bluff.
π€
David
β
Grace
,Alice
Grace, I am claiming Investigator. I saw either Bob or Charlie as the Baron. I am fine with Alice nominating you, but if it does not trigger, I think we have to consider Alice being the Drunk rather than instantly turning on you.
π§
Build trust with Grace/Alice while planting an explanation that can discredit Alice if the Virgin test fails or if her Librarian info threatens Frank.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
,Bob
I am Librarian. Night zero: either Heidi or Frank is the Drunk. Heidi is claiming Chef with one adjacent evil pair but she might be drunk. Plan is I nominate Grace for Virgin test today. What are you claiming and did you get any pings on Bob or Charlie?
π§
Share my concrete Librarian info to coordinate protection and public strategy; gather Bobβs and Eveβs claims to resolve conflicts with Davidβs Investigator and plan the Virgin test.
π€
Bob
β
Eve
,Charlie
I am planning to claim Monk for now. No night zero info. If Alice is really Librarian and saw Drunk, then Charlie being Butler would mean two Outsiders, so we should consider Baron or someone lying. Charlie, I will try to signal you before I vote today.
π§
Give a safe claim, flag outsider-count mismatch to detect Baron or a liar, and keep vote coordination with my Butler neighbor to avoid wasting their ability.
π€
Charlie
β
Eve
I am actually the Butler, and I picked Bob as my master today, so I can only vote if he votes too. No night zero info beyond that. On Outsiders: base is one, so if someone is claiming a Drunk ping as well, we may need Baron or a lie. What have you heard so far?
π§
Answer Eve with my real role, flag Outsider-count logic, and ask what info she has heard so I can map worlds and avoid being boxed out of voting.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
What is your Night Zero setup info, and what role are you planning to claim? My Chef info is one adjacent evil pair, so any two-player pings you have could really help map suspects.
π§
Get Alice's promised setup info and her claim so I can integrate it with Chef adjacency data and decide whether to push a Virgin test or a different nomination plan.
π€
Eve
β
Charlie
I have heard David is claiming Investigator and says there is a Baron between you and Bob. Alice is claiming Librarian and got Drunk between Heidi and Frank. Outsider count feels important with your Butler claim. Any thoughts on who is lying, or do you want to hold claims until nominations?
π§
Share key claims with Charlie to coordinate Outsider math and catch inconsistencies; keep my Monk identity hidden while guiding good to a clean nomination plan.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Before we rush nominations, quick public math: David told me he is Investigator and saw a Baron between Bob and Charlie. Alice says Librarian saw a Drunk between Heidi and Frank, and Charlie is claiming Butler. If those are true, Baron makes sense. I like Aliceβs plan to Virgin test on Grace.
π§
Use the last nomination beat to align town on a Virgin test and highlight Outsider count logic pointing to a Baron between Bob and Charlie, without hard outing myself as Monk.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I am fine with a Virgin test, but only if Grace is openly claiming Virgin right now. Also, remember some players can register incorrectly to info roles, so that Baron ping on me or Charlie is not a slam dunk. I am currently claiming Monk.
π§
Steer town to a safe Virgin test only if Grace confirms, and plant the idea that early info can be distorted so we do not hard-clear a Baron ping on me or Charlie.
βοΈ
Heidi
β
Grace
I am Chef with one adjacent evil pair. Grace has claimed Virgin to me; I want to test that now for hard confirmation. If I die instantly, we lock me and Grace as good; if not, we learn something is off.
π§
Use a Virgin test to mechanically confirm alignments or create a clear contradiction, while putting my Chef info into play to narrow demon candidates around Bob and Charlie.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am publicly claiming Virgin. Heidi nominated me and nothing happened, so either my ability is not working, or Heidi is not a Townsfolk. I do not think we should execute me here; this is already useful info about Heidi.
π§
Stop a low-value day one execution on me and highlight the key mechanical info: Heidiβs nomination failing the Virgin trigger is meaningful and should redirect suspicion.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I would not execute Grace off this. The Virgin test failing means either Grace is not actually Virgin, or Heidi is not a Townsfolk, or Heidi is the Drunk. That is useful, but Grace being good is still very possible. I am keeping my hand down.
π§
Prevent an early mis-execution on an information play; lock in that the failed Virgin test points to either Grace or Heidi being non-Townsfolk/drunk, so we should not execute Grace blindly.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I am keeping my hand down on Grace. The Virgin test already gave us info, but it does not point cleanly at executing Grace. I would rather we use today to lock in claims and come back with night info.
π§
Prevent an information-poor Day 1 execution on a likely good player and avoid dragging Charlie's Butler vote with mine.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I agree we should not execute Grace today. The nomination already gave us the key info point: either Grace is not actually the Virgin, or I am not a Townsfolk, or I am drunk. Let us take the night and come back to this with more checks tomorrow.
π§
Steer town away from a low-information execution while preserving the Virgin-test data point and setting up next-day verification of conflicting setup claims.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am keeping my hand down. I am the Butler and my master today is Bob, so I can only vote if Bob votes, and he is not voting here. I agree this is useful info but not a reason to execute Grace today.
π§
Signal my vote constraint and support no-execution today; keep town focused on resolving the claim web with night info rather than a low-info D1 kill.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am keeping my hand down on Grace. The Virgin test already told us something is off, and my Librarian info makes Heidi possibly the Drunk, so that could explain it. I would rather take a night of info and revisit Grace versus Heidi tomorrow.
π§
Prevent a low-information D1 execution, lock in that the Virgin test already gave us value, and set up clear follow-ups on Grace and Heidi tomorrow.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
Avoid looking overeager to execute a claimed Virgin on day one while town consensus is no. Preserve my Ravenkeeper bluff and let suspicion sit on Heidi or Grace.
π¬
David
β
All
I am keeping my hand down as well. The failed Virgin test points more at Heidi not being sober Townsfolk, especially with Aliceβs information, than it points at executing Grace today. I still want pressure on Bob and Charlie tomorrow.
π§
Avoid looking bloodthirsty, reinforce Alice's Drunk world that protects Frank, and keep suspicion on Bob/Charlie instead of the Demon.
π¬
Grace
β
All
My hand is down. Please do not execute me today. The important thing is the failed Virgin trigger: either I am not the Virgin, or Heidi is not a Townsfolk. Let us take the night, then we can interrogate that properly tomorrow.
π§
Prevent a wasteful day one execution on me while framing the key takeaway: the failed trigger is a mechanical flag on Heidi or on my claim, so we should gather night info and revisit.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Keep my hand down to avoid a low-info D1 execution; preserve the useful failed Virgin-test info for tomorrow with night actions and tighter worlds.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Voting is already trending no-exec on Grace and I should not change that. Waiting preserves coordination with Butler and keeps options open for tomorrow's deductions.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Keep my hand down and let the no-execution stand; preserve flexibility and avoid wasting Day 1 on an unconfirmed Virgin failure.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
One quick thing to log for tomorrow: if my Butler claim is true and Alice has a Drunk ping, that only fits cleanly with a Baron or a lie. Also, I cannot vote unless Bob votes. Let us all restate claims first thing tomorrow and line up who might be the Drunk.
π§
Use my outsider status to focus town on outsider count logic and set up tomorrowβs claim consolidation without forcing an execution today.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
Keep my vote down to avoid a low-info day-one execution; the failed Virgin test already generated useful worlds, and night info will sharpen Grace versus Heidi tomorrow.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I am also keeping my hand down. The failed trigger is important, but with the Drunk possibility on Heidi, I do not think Grace is the execution today. Tomorrow we should compare Grace, Heidi, and Aliceβs chain carefully.
π§
Avoid a suspicious lone vote while reinforcing the Drunk explanation that protects evil and keeps town focused on Grace, Heidi, and Alice.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Do not help execute a non-Demon when town already prefers no execution; preserve my credibility and let Frank kill tonight.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Grace did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (0/4).
π¬
Grace
β
All
Before night, can we quickly lock public claims for tomorrow? Alice Librarian, David Investigator pinging Bob or Charlie as Baron, Heidi Chef one evil pair, Frank Ravenkeeper, Bob Monk, Charlie Butler. My Virgin test failed, so tomorrow we should dig into whether Heidi is drunk or evil, or I am not really Virgin.
π§
Lock public claims and set tomorrowβs priorities: resolve why my Virgin test failed, and keep focus on mechanically checking the Bob/Charlie Baron pair without wasting today.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Before we go to night, please speak up now if you are counterclaiming any of these roles, especially Monk, Chef, Virgin, Librarian, Investigator. Also, if anyone is an ongoing info role and wants protection tonight, grab me in a whisper right after this phase.
π§
Use last public time to lock claims, request any counterclaims, and set up who I should protect tonight by encouraging info roles to identify themselves discreetly.
π¬
Bob
β
All
No counterclaims from me. I am still on Monk. If anyone is an ongoing info role and feels at risk tonight, please whisper me right after this so I can choose protection. Also, remember Charlie cannot vote unless I vote, so track that tomorrow.
π§
Lock in that I am not counterclaiming, and set up night protection coordination so town preserves key info roles and we can solve tomorrow.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
No counterclaim from me. I am still Chef with one adjacent evil pair. I do not need protection, but I would like Bob to consider protecting either Alice or David tonight since they are the big info claims and likely demon targets. Tomorrow, let us map the circle with my Chef number and see which two neighbors could be the evil pair.
π§
Lock my public position, avoid role conflicts, and steer night protection and tomorrowβs plan to use Chef pair logic plus Investigator and Librarian claims.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Bob, if you can, please protect David or Alice tonight since they are the loud info claims. Tomorrow I want us to map Heidiβs Chef one-pair around the circle and see how it intersects Davidβs Baron ping on Bob or me.
π§
Lock in a clear night protection request and set up tomorrowβs logical map using Chef and Investigator info, while keeping my Butler constraint visible.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Just to lock it in: my Librarian info is that either Heidi or Frank is the Drunk. So please treat Chef one pair and the failed Virgin as possibly just Drunk noise. Bob, I would love protection tonight on either David or me, since we are the main info claims.
π§
Lock in the key mechanical takeaway: my Drunk ping. Push Monk protection onto the correct targets and set tomorrowβs plan to resolve Heidi versus Frank and reassess Grace.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I am not counterclaiming anything either. For tomorrow, I do not want us to treat Alice as automatically confirmed just because her info is useful. It could be right, but it is still part of the Grace and Heidi chain we need to test.
π§
Avoid a risky late nomination and seed doubt on Alice, whose Librarian info names me as possible Drunk and could later expose my bluff.
π¬
David
β
All
No counterclaims from me. I am still on Investigator with Bob or Charlie as Baron, and Charlieβs Butler claim does not clear that pair for me. Bob, I would prefer protection on Alice tonight, because her Librarian info is the hinge for the Grace and Heidi situation.
π§
Keep heat on Bob/Charlie while steering Monk protection away from Frank, the Demon. Reinforce my fake Investigator claim as useful town logic.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
π―
Eve
Eve made a choice.
π§
Alice is the loudest early info and a likely Demon target; keeping her alive preserves the Drunk lead and helps us solve Grace versus Heidi and the outsider math tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
You chose to protect Alice.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Frank
Frank made a choice.
π§
Remove the claimed Monk before protection becomes a problem, while leaving Alice and Grace alive as a messy Drunk/Virgin chain to exploit tomorrow.
π
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You chose to kill Bob.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
Pick a master who is likely to be alive, engaged, and voting so my Butler restriction does not prevent me from supporting key executions tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You chose Eve to be your master.
Day 2
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,David
I am actually the Virgin. Since Heidi nominated me and nothing happened, I think that points to Heidi not being a Townsfolk or Heidi being the Drunk. With Bob dead, Davidβs Bob or Charlie is Baron feels like it should swing harder onto Charlie. Any new reads before nominations?
π§
Sync with key info claims so we enter nominations with a coherent plan: treat the failed Virgin test as evidence about Heidi, and re-evaluate Davidβs Baron ping now that Bob died.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,David
Quick update: I am actually the Recluse, not Monk. So your Investigator result naming Baron between me and Charlie could be a Recluse misregister. I died at night, so please do not build worlds that require me as Demon.
π§
Reveal my true Outsider role privately so they can reinterpret the Investigator ping and not waste executions on a dead Recluse; steer discussion toward solvable worlds before noms.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,David
My Librarian ping was Heidi or Frank is the Drunk. If Heidi is the Drunk, her nominating a real Virgin would not trigger, so Grace could be Virgin. With Bob now Recluse and Charlie claiming Butler, Heidi as Drunk makes three Outsiders, which only fits if Baron exists, pointing to Charlie as Baron per Davidβs info.
π§
Connect the failed Virgin test with my Drunk info and Bobβs Recluse to build coherent outsider-count worlds and steer nominations toward the most mechanically implicated player (likely Charlie or Heidi).
π€
Frank
β
Alice
,David
Alice, I want to compare the failed Virgin test with your Drunk info. If Heidi is the Drunk, Grace can still be real. If Heidi is not, Grace is almost certainly lying. I do not want us to lock the wrong side too early.
π§
Join David's trusted chat and steer Alice toward worlds that keep Frank plausible while making Grace or Heidi executionable.
π€
David
β
Alice
,Grace
I think Bob being Recluse changes my result more than it first looks. It could mean my ping was just Bob registering as Baron, not that Charlie is evil. The failed Virgin test still makes me want to look hard at Grace or Heidi before we tunnel Charlie.
π§
Deflect pressure from evil by making Bob explain my fake ping and steering suspicion toward Grace/Heidi instead of Frank.
π€
Eve
β
Alice
,David
Quick check in. What did Bob tell you in whispers after he died, and where are you both leaning for todayβs execute? Also, any reason to think Heidi is the Drunk from Aliceβs Librarian info and the failed Virgin test?
π§
Get alignment-confirming details from Alice and David, especially what Bob said as a ghost and whether their info points to Charlie/Heidi. Decide a strong nomination target and my night protection plan.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,David
Quick check in: I am the Butler and I chose Eve as my master last night, so today I can only vote if Eve votes. Also, since I am definitely Butler, I cannot be Baron, which makes your Investigator ping Bob or Charlie hard to fit unless Bob was Baron or you are wrong.
π§
Lock in that I am Butler (good) so I cannot be Baron; use that to test Davidβs claim and align town on a coherent outsider-count world before nominations.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,David
Can you share what you learned in whispers this morning, especially anything from Bob as a ghost? Also, any new info that changes the Drunk ping or the Baron pair?
π§
Get latest private info from Alice and David (who everyone whispered) to update the adjacency map and decide a strong nomination for today.
π€
Grace
β
Bob(Ghost)
,Charlie
Bob, did you actually die as the Recluse, and did you get any useful night info before you died? Charlie, since Bob is dead, are you choosing a new Butler master each night, and who is it now?
π§
Clarify whether Bob was truly Recluse and how Butler works after Bobβs death; these answers determine whether to push Charlie as Baron or pivot onto Heidi/others for todayβs execution.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Grace
,Charlie
Grace, yes, I am Recluse, not Monk. I died night one and I got no night info. Charlie, you still choose a Butler master each night even if the old one died. Who is your master today, so we know your vote limits?
π§
Clarify my true role and lack of night info, prevent bad logic built on my earlier Monk claim, and prompt Charlie to share his current Butler master for vote math.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
Bob told me he is actually the Recluse, not Monk. My Librarian is still Heidi or Frank is the Drunk. If Heidi is Drunk, Grace can be real Virgin and we likely have Baron, pointing to Charlie via David. If not, Grace or Heidi looks worse.
π§
Update Eve with Bobβs Recluse reveal and frame todayβs execution candidates using my Drunk ping and the failed Virgin test; coordinate votes and avoid tunneling wrong player.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
Can we compare notes quickly? I am still claiming Ravenkeeper, so I am mostly useful if the demon panics and kills me. What did you tell Alice and David, and where are you leaning between Grace, Heidi, and Charlie?
π§
Build trust with my neighbor and learn Eve's claim or suspicions, while nudging focus onto good execution candidates.
π€
David
β
Frank
I am trying to keep Alice focused on Heidi as the Drunk, not you. If we get pushed, I think today should be Grace versus Heidi, with Charlie as a backup. Tell me where you want pressure placed before nominations.
π§
Coordinate with the Demon and steer executions toward good players while keeping Frank out of Alice's Drunk suspicion.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
I told Alice and David I am Monk, and I protected Alice night one. Bob told Alice he is actually Recluse. I am leaning that Charlie being the Baron still fits the Outsider math, but Heidi being evil Poisoner also explains the failed Virgin test. What is your full Ravenkeeper story and who do you most want alive tonight?
π§
Sync with Frank, decide best execute candidate and who I should protect tonight to stop an Imp snipe on key info roles.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
,Bob(Ghost)
Yes, I still choose a new master each night. My master for today is Eve, so I can only vote if Eve votes. Bob, you claiming Recluse is big: it could explain Davidβs Baron ping on you without you being Baron. I will flag this to the group.
π§
Answer their questions, lock my Butler restriction for today, and use Bobβs Recluse claim to push mechanical re-evaluation of the Investigator ping and Outsider math.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
,Frank
Quick check in: Grace, what do you think explains the Virgin not triggering when I nominated you, and what are you pushing today? Frank, any new info or reads, and do you believe Aliceβs Drunk ping on you or me?
π§
Get direct statements from Grace and Frank to clarify the Virgin test failure and the Drunk ping, so we can target the likely adjacent evil pair before nominations.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
,Frank
I am the Virgin. Your nomination not triggering makes most sense if you are the Drunk from Alice, or you are evil. With Bob confirmed Recluse, if you are Drunk too, that is three Outsiders, so we need a Baron, which pushes suspicion onto Charlie. Frank, any night one info if you die?
π§
Answer Heidi, align on a concrete nomination plan: leverage my Virgin status to test a Townsfolk nominee and narrow suspects before end of day.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,David
Key points: I am Recluse so your Baron ping on me could be misregister. Charlie says Butler and his master today is Eve, so he can only vote if Eve votes. Butler plus Recluse implies either Baron exists or someone is lying. Failed Virgin test still makes Grace suspicious if Chef is true.
π§
Get Alice and David aligned on key mechanical points: my Recluse can explain the Baron ping; Butler voting restriction now tied to Eve; propose executions that generate information and avoid wasting votes.
π€
Alice
β
David
,Eve
For noms today I see 3 tight worlds: 1) Charlie is Baron, Heidi is Drunk, Grace real Virgin. 2) Frank is Drunk, Heidi Chef true, Grace lying. 3) Heidi is evil. I lean we pressure Grace then Heidi; if Heidiβs Drunk, Grace should look solid.
π§
Align David and Eve on the three plausible worlds and push for a nomination that tests the Drunk/Virgin/Baron triangle without wasting the day.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
,David
I think we should not let Grace and Heidi consume the whole day. If Bob is Recluse and Alice saw a Drunk, then Charlie claiming Butler makes Baron almost necessary. My Ravenkeeper story is simple: I get nothing unless the demon kills me, and I am happy to check whoever the town agrees matters most.
π§
Coordinate with David while sounding helpful to Alice; steer execution toward Charlie and away from me/David, using outsider math to create pressure.
π€
David
β
Alice
,Eve
For nominations, I would start with Grace and hear the defense. If Heidi is sober, the failed Virgin test points there; if Heidi is the Drunk, then we pivot to Heidi or Charlie, but I do not want Frank executed only because of a Drunk possibility.
π§
Steer executions toward good players Grace/Heidi/Charlie while discouraging pressure on Frank, the Demon.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
Grace, quick check. You still hard-claim Virgin? How do you explain Heidi nominating you with no Virgin trigger. Do you think Heidi is the Drunk, or not a Townsfolk, or are you not Virgin? Who do you want executed today, and why?
π§
Get Grace to fully explain the failed Virgin test and who she thinks is Drunk/Baron. Her answers help decide whether to push Grace today or pivot to Heidi/Charlie.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,David
Update: Bob just whispered me he is Recluse, not Monk, and got no night info. That could explain your Investigator ping on Bob without an actual Baron, since Recluse can register as Minion. If true, Outsider count may just be me as Butler, so Aliceβs Drunk info could be wrong/poisoned.
π§
Get key update (Bob Recluse) into the main info circle, and pressure-test Outsider math so we can choose a clean execution path today.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,David
I heard Grace say Bob is now confirmed Recluse. Did Bob tell you that directly as a ghost, and was he ever Monk earlier? Also, any new info from this morning that changes the Drunk on me versus Frank, or the Baron between Bob and Charlie?
π§
Confirm whether Bob truly claimed Recluse and reconcile outsider count with Investigatorβs Baron ping; use this to focus todayβs execution on the most mechanically constrained evil pair.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Grace
β
Charlie
I want Charlie on the block. With Bob confirmed Recluse and Aliceβs Drunk ping on Heidi or Frank, the Outsider count starts to only make sense if there is a Baron, and Charlie is in Davidβs Baron pair. Also his Butler story has shifted with new masters, so I want to pressure-test it.
π§
Push a high-impact execution on the player with the strongest mechanical contradictions, and also test the Butler claim through whether Eve votes.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am the Butler, and I told Eve this yesterday. I chose Eve last night, so today I can only vote if Eve votes. Bob whisper-claimed Recluse, which can explain Davidβs Baron ping on Bob without there being a Baron. I do not think this is a good execute today.
π§
Stop an info-poor execution on me, restate my mechanically consistent Butler story, and push town toward better targets while flagging my vote restriction.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Charlie fits the mechanical outsider math if Baron exists, and he is in the Investigator pair. Voting to execute is the best pressure and can remove an evil.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Execute a good Outsider in my fake Investigator pair, reinforcing my bluff and keeping pressure away from Frank.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Help put a plausible good Outsider on the block, support David's pressure, and keep suspicion focused away from me before night.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Charlie is the best mechanical candidate: on Investigator Baron ping and outsider math. My vote secures an execution that may kill demon or confirm a tight evil pair around Charlie.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am not voting for Charlie here. Bob being the Recluse can explain David seeing Baron on Bob without there being any Baron at all. If we execute Charlie and he is just the Butler, we lose a day and Grace and Heidi stay unresolved.
π§
Try to prevent a potentially wrong execution by highlighting that Bob Recluse can explain the Investigator ping without a real Baron, making Charlie a risky kill today.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Do not vote to test Charlieβs Butler claim (he chose me). If he votes despite me not voting, he is likely lying. Also I avoid adding weight to a possibly wrong execute.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I am not spending my ghost vote here. If Charlie is just the Butler, this is a wasted execute. I would rather we use executions to resolve Grace versus Heidi, because the failed Virgin test and the Chef one are still the biggest contradictions.
π§
Try to stop an unproductive execute on Charlie and preserve my ghost vote for endgame while steering town toward resolving Grace and the Chef or Drunk situation.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
If anyone can still change their hand, please do not execute me here. I am the Butler and my master today is Eve, so I cannot even add a surprise vote. This execute does not resolve Grace versus Heidi, or the Chef one. Let us use the execution on Grace or Heidi instead.
π§
Try to prevent my execution by persuading a current voter to withdraw and to refocus town on resolving Grace versus Heidi, which is the main contradiction.
β©οΈ
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
π§
Prevent a likely low-value execution on Charlie and refocus the town on resolving the Grace versus Heidi Virgin-test contradiction, which gives clearer mechanical information.
π¬
David
β
All
I am keeping my hand up here. Bob as Recluse can explain part of this, but Charlie is still in my Investigator pair and the outsider count is very crowded. I think this is a fair execution if we can get it.
π§
Push a good execution on Charlie while my fake Investigator claim stays consistent and attention remains away from Frank.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I think Charlie is still a fair execution. Bob being Recluse can explain David, but it does not explain the crowded Outsider picture cleanly. Grace and Heidi can still be resolved tomorrow, and this gives us real information on Davidβs pair.
π§
Keep my vote on a good player and persuade one more vote, especially Eve, while sounding like I want mechanical resolution rather than pushing evil agenda.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Eve, quick question. Did Charlie tell you yesterday that he was the Butler, and did he say you would be his master today? If his story only appeared after Bob died, I think we should execute him. If it was consistent, I would rather spend the execution elsewhere.
π§
Get Eve to publicly confirm whether Charlieβs Butler story was consistent, then decide if this execution is worth it before the vote locks.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Eve, can you answer Heidiβs question plainly. Did Charlie tell you yesterday he was the Butler, and did he say you would be his master today or that he might pick you. If that was consistent, I think we should stand down on this execution.
π§
Get Eve on record about Charlieβs prior Butler claim to judge whether this is a real inconsistency worth executing, while signaling I am still off this vote unless new info appears.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Charlie did tell me yesterday that he was the Butler, before Bob died. I do not recall him saying for sure that I would be his master today, more like he might pick me. Based on that, I am not voting to execute Charlie here.
π§
Answer plainly to lock in Charlieβs claim timeline and avoid a low-value execute; steer town toward resolving Grace versus Heidi where contradictions are.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
I will not spend my ghost vote on a low-information execute that likely cannot pass without Eve. Save vote and let town pivot to higher-yield targets next.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Charlie did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Charlie did not receive enough votes (3/4).
βοΈ
Charlie
β
Grace
Grace, I am nominating you because your Virgin claim already had a clean test and it did not fire. Either you are not the Virgin, or Heidi is not a Townsfolk. This is the fastest way to resolve the biggest contradiction today.
π§
Shift the day from executing an exposed Outsider to resolving the biggest mechanical contradiction: the failed Virgin test. Force commitments and create a clear follow-up path for tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Please do not vote to execute me here. I am the Virgin, and the clean explanation for the failed trigger is that Heidi is the Drunk from Aliceβs information, or Heidi is evil. Either way, executing me does not resolve it. If we want to resolve the contradiction, we should execute Heidi instead.
π§
Stop a low-information execution on me and pivot the town to the higher-value resolve: execute Heidi or at least withhold votes today so we can reassess with night info.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Town, the first time Grace was nominated, the Virgin ability should have fired if she is really Virgin and the nominator was a Townsfolk. It did not. That means either Grace is not the Virgin, or Heidi is not a Townsfolk. Executing Grace today is the cleanest way to move us forward.
π§
I cannot vote unless Eve votes, so I must use speech to steer town toward the execution that best resolves the biggest contradiction: the failed Virgin test.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Executing Grace removes a good player and keeps pressure off Frank while making the Virgin failure look resolved through Grace rather than Heidi or Alice.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Push a good execution on Grace while framing it as resolving failed Virgin logic. If it passes, we gain a misexecution and protect David from Charlie focus.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am not putting my hand up on Grace. Executing her does not actually resolve the Virgin test, because it could still be me as the Drunk. I would rather carry this to tomorrow and, if we must, we can execute me to settle it cleanly.
π§
Steer town away from a low-consensus execution that could kill a useful good role; preserve votes and push for a more informed execution tomorrow, possibly on me if needed.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
We need a decisive execution and Graceβs claim has the clearest mechanical contradiction. My vote can reach majority; if Grace dies we gain alignment clarity and reduce evil options.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am not voting to execute Grace here. The Virgin test already points to either Grace not being the Virgin, or Heidi not being a Townsfolk, or Heidi being the Drunk, and killing Grace does not cleanly settle that. If we want a clean resolution, I would rather execute Heidi tomorrow.
π§
Prevent a low-confidence execution on Grace; steer town to resolve the Virgin-test contradiction by executing Heidi tomorrow or extracting more hard claims.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I am not using my ghost vote on Grace here. Executing Grace does not actually settle the Virgin contradiction if Heidi could be the Drunk. I would rather we save this and, if needed, execute Heidi tomorrow for a clean resolution.
π§
Preserve my only ghost vote for endgame and steer town away from a low-information execution that does not settle the Virgin contradiction.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Town, please do not make this the execution. You already have a clean alternative: execute Heidi tomorrow if you want to settle the Virgin test. If you kill me now, we still will not know whether Heidi was drunk, and we lose a Townsfolk day.
π§
Stop the 4th vote landing on me and steer town toward a cleaner mechanical solve (Heidi execution) or demon hunt, preserving a valuable Townsfolk ability.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I cannot vote here because I am the Butler and Eve is not voting. We are at three hands, so this likely will not pass. Town, let us lock a plan: tomorrow we either execute Heidi to settle the Virgin test cleanly, or we pivot to strongest demon suspect with full claim recap.
π§
I cannot vote unless Eve votes, so I need to steer town toward a concrete plan for tomorrow and avoid burning time on an execution that will not pass.
π¬
David
β
All
I am keeping my hand up. If Grace is real, then Heidi is almost forced into being the Drunk or evil, and we can still test that tomorrow. If Grace is fake, this is a very good execution today.
π§
Push a good execution while framing it as logical resolution, keeping pressure away from Frank and maintaining my Investigator bluff.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I think this is still worth doing. If Grace is real, then we have narrowed Heidi hard for tomorrow. If Grace is fake, we have caught a lie that has been shielding the whole day. I would rather not leave both sides alive and learn nothing.
π§
Push for one more vote on Grace to secure a good execution while sounding logic-focused and aligned with town info solving.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Do not count on my vote here. If Grace dies today and I am the Drunk, we learn almost nothing and we lose a strong Townsfolk. I would rather we go to night, then tomorrow we either execute me to settle the Virgin test, or we pivot onto our best demon suspect.
π§
Prevent a low-information execution that could remove a powerful good role; keep options open to execute me tomorrow if needed to resolve the Virgin contradiction.
β©οΈ
Alice
Alice lowered their hand
π§
Prevent a low-information execution that might kill a real Virgin, since my Librarian info makes the failed Virgin test ambiguous. Preserve today's execution and push for a clearer Heidi solve tomorrow.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am staying off Grace. If we do not execute today, I want a clear plan: tomorrow we either execute Heidi to settle the Virgin test, or we do a full claim recap and execute our best demon suspect. Please do not let this drift into random picks.
π§
Keep town coordinated: avoid low-info execution today, set a clear plan for tomorrow, and reduce chaos so we can focus demon-hunting with better data.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I am staying off the Grace vote. My ask is we do not drift: tomorrow we either execute Heidi to settle the Virgin test cleanly, or we do a full claim recap and pick our strongest demon suspect. Also remember my Recluse claim can fully explain Davidβs Baron ping on me.
π§
Keep my ghost vote for a decisive late vote, and steer town to a concrete tomorrow plan: either execute Heidi to settle Virgin contradiction, or do full claim recap and pick best demon suspect.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Grace did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (2/4).
π¬
Grace
β
All
Town, let us not drift tomorrow. Either we execute Heidi to settle the Virgin test as cleanly as we can, or we do a full claim recap and pick our best demon suspect. I am happy to be the nomination that triggers the Virgin once we have a trusted Townsfolk to do it.
π§
Lock the town into a clear, non-drifting plan for Day 3: resolve the Virgin test by executing Heidi, and do a full claim recap to identify the demon with constrained worlds.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
All right, no execution today. Can we all agree tomorrow we start with a full claim recap, then if we still want to resolve the Virgin mess cleanly, we execute Heidi. If Heidi is not executed, then we pick our single best demon suspect and commit.
π§
With no execution today, lock a concrete tomorrow plan and keep focus on resolving the Grace-Heidi contradiction without wasting votes I cannot freely make as Butler.
π¬
David
β
All
I am fine letting this go to night now, but tomorrow cannot become another loop. We should start with the Virgin failure, and if nobody has stronger demon evidence, Heidi is the cleanest execution to resolve that branch.
π§
Accept no execution to give Frank a free kill, while framing Heidi as tomorrow's likely execution and keeping attention away from Frank.
βοΈ
Frank
β
Heidi
I am nominating Heidi because we are about to end with no execution again. The Virgin test already points at Heidi as the cleanest resolver if Grace is telling the truth, and if Heidi is evil or the Drunk, this moves us forward instead of carrying the same loop into tomorrow.
π§
Force a late good execution instead of no-exec, using the town's own Heidi plan. It also protects me by keeping focus on the Virgin/Drunk conflict.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I do not think executing me today settles the Virgin question. We will not learn my role, and we do not have an Undertaker claim. I would rather we go to night, then tomorrow do a full claim recap and use my one evil pair info to pick a real demon suspect.
π§
Prevent a low-information execution on me; push town to use Chef adjacency and night info tomorrow instead of looping the Virgin test.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
We need an execution and Heidi is the cleanest resolver of the Virgin-failure branch; my vote helps reach majority and forces the game state forward.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Just a reminder, I cannot vote unless Eve votes too, so do not read my hand either way. If you think Heidi is the cleanest resolver, please put your hands up now so we do not drift into another no execution.
π§
I cannot vote unless Eve votes. I want town to either commit to executing Heidi now for momentum or explicitly agree to no execution and a tight plan tomorrow; no more drift.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Executing Heidi removes a good player and supports Frank's push while matching my prior public stance, keeping suspicion off both me and Frank.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Push a good execution and avoid another no-execution day while looking consistent with my nomination and the townβs stated Heidi-resolution plan.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
We are about to drift into another no-execution. My Librarian info puts Heidi on a key axis (Heidi or Frank Drunk), and the Virgin failure also points at her. A Heidi execution forces the game state to move forward.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
We already have enough votes, but I will add mine to ensure the execution goes through and we do not drift into another no-execution day.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
Heidi already has enough hands. I will conserve my single ghost vote for a future pivotal execution, ideally final day, where it can mathematically win the game.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
If you are voting me just to resolve the Virgin thing, please reconsider and pull hands. With no Undertaker, my death teaches almost nothing. Use tonight, then tomorrow we do a full claim recap and I will help map the one adjacent evil pair into real suspects.
π§
Try to stop an unconfirmable self-execution that does not resolve the Virgin issue, and redirect town to a more mechanically informative plan.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am keeping my hand up. Even without an Undertaker, Heidi is the center of the Virgin contradiction and the Drunk ping, and we cannot afford another no execution day. If Heidi is good, we regroup tomorrow with a full claim recap and re test my Virgin with a trusted nominator.
π§
Keep momentum: we cannot afford repeated no-execution days. Heidi sits at the center of multiple contradictions, so executing her today is the highest-value progress even without an Undertaker.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Eve is voting, so I am allowed to vote. An execution today is better than drifting; Heidi is central to contradictions and a plausible evil. My vote helps secure the majority.
π¬
David
β
All
I am keeping my hand up. No execution leaves us with the same contradiction tomorrow, and Heidi is the cleanest pressure point from both the Drunk ping and the failed Virgin test.
π§
Keep the vote on Heidi, a likely good info source, while backing Frank's push and framing it as town logic, not demon protection.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I am keeping my hand up. This is not perfect, but another no execution just leaves us repeating the exact same argument tomorrow. Heidi is connected to both the Drunk ping and the failed Virgin test, so this is the cleanest way to move forward.
π§
Lock in Heidi execution, removing a credible good claim and preventing town from delaying into a more demon-focused recap tomorrow.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am keeping my hand up. My Librarian info says either Heidi or Frank is the Drunk, and Heidi is also the center of the Virgin contradiction. Even without an Undertaker, this is the cleanest pressure point, and we cannot afford another day with no execution.
π§
Keep the vote momentum so we do not lose to drift. My Librarian info directly implicates Heidi or Frank as Drunk, and Heidi is central to the Virgin contradiction.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am keeping my hand up. Even without an Undertaker, Heidi is the center of the failed Virgin test and the Drunk ping, and we cannot afford another no execution. If Heidi is good, tomorrow we re test Grace with a trusted Townsfolk and then commit to a demon suspect.
π§
Keep pressure on the main contradiction so we do not waste another day. If Heidi dies and is good, we immediately re-test Grace tomorrow and focus demon hunting.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
Preserve my single ghost vote for final day while letting the live majority execute Heidi if they already have the numbers.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Heidi with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Heidi is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Before this locks in, I want to leave one clear thing. I am the Chef, and I got exactly one adjacent pair of evil players. That means the Demon and Minion sit next to each other. If I die, please do not just loop on the Virgin test tomorrow. Use the seating and focus on adjacent pairs like Charlie with his neighbors, and Grace with Frank.
π§
I am about to die; I must leave the town a clear mechanical takeaway: Chef=1 means the two evils are adjacent, so tomorrow they should solve by focusing on adjacent pairs, not the Virgin loop.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Keep Heidi on the block. Tomorrow, first thing, I want a clean Virgin re test with Alice or David nominating me, so we resolve that mechanically. If Heidi was the Drunk, her Chef number is noise, and I want us looking hard at Charlie from the Investigator ping and his voting constraints.
π§
Use last seconds to lock in the Heidi execution and set a concrete, mechanical plan for tomorrow: re-test my Virgin with a trusted nominator and pressure Charlie or other candidates based on how Heidiβs death reframes info.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
If Heidi dies, can we agree tomorrow starts with a clean claim recap, then a Virgin re test on Grace with Alice or David nominating. Also, I am the Butler and Eve is my master today, so my voting is tied to hers, it is not a dodge. If Heidi was real Chef, keep the adjacent evil pair idea in mind when we pick our next execution.
π§
Get town aligned on a concrete Day 3 plan: confirm Grace via Virgin test, then use seating/claims to narrow Demon, while reminding them my Butler restriction is real and not a dodge.
π¬
David
β
All
If Heidi is executed, I do not want tomorrow to become only a memorial argument over Chef numbers. Start with the Grace re test, preferably from Alice, then compare that result with Charlie's claim and the Bob or Charlie Baron ping.
π§
Lock in Heidi execution while steering tomorrow toward Grace and Charlie, away from Frank, and preserving my Investigator bluff as useful.
π¬
Frank
β
All
One quick rules point before night. I do not think Grace can be retested, because her first nomination has already happened. Tomorrow I would rather do the full claim recap and treat Heidi's Chef number as only useful if we believe she was not the Drunk.
π§
Look helpful, reduce focus on a fake Virgin retest, and weaken Heidi's Chef info that points near me.
π¬
Alice
β
All
One rules correction: Frank is right. The Virgin only triggers on the first time they are nominated, so a re test tomorrow will not work. Tomorrow we should do a full claim recap, then use my Drunk info and Davidβs Baron ping to pick a real execution target.
π§
Clarify Virgin rules so town does not waste tomorrow, and set a concrete plan using my Drunk info plus the Investigator ping to narrow suspects after Heidiβs execution.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I agree with Alice and Frank: Grace cannot be retested, because Virgin only triggers the first time they are nominated. So tomorrow we need a full claim recap, then pick an execution using David versus Charlie, plus the Drunk ping on Heidi or Frank. Also, tonight we should prioritize keeping our info alive.
π§
Clarify Virgin retest rules and set a concrete, mechanically grounded plan for tomorrow and night protection targets, avoiding another loop.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Quick note: Virgin cannot be retested, it only triggers on the first nomination. Tomorrow, do a full claim recap and decide whether Heidi was the Drunk; only then use her Chef adjacency. If we ignore Chef, the main fork is David versus Charlie, and we should pick one to execute.
π§
Use my dead voice to set tomorrowβs logic path: no Virgin retest, clarify how to use or discard Chef info, and keep pressure on likely evil worlds without wasting time.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Heidi has been executed.
π
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
Night 2
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
π―
Eve
Eve made a choice.
π§
David is the highest leverage living information claim. Keeping him alive preserves the Baron ping fork and helps us pick a clean execution tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
You chose to protect David.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Frank
Frank made a choice.
π§
Remove the unclaimed player between both evils; if Eve has Empath or Fortune Teller info, she is the biggest threat to exposing Frank and David.
π
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You chose to kill Eve.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
Pick a master who is likely good and likely to vote in key executions tomorrow, so my Butler restriction does not accidentally suppress my vote when it matters.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You chose Alice to be your master.
Day 3
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Eve has been found dead in the night.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,David
Quick share: I am actually the Virgin. Heidi nommed me and it did not fire, so either Heidi was evil, or I was poisoned that day. Since Heidi is dead, I lean Heidi was the Minion. Where are your top Demon suspects for today?
π§
Coordinate before nominations: reveal I am the Virgin, so the failed test points at Heidi being evil or poisoning. Use that to pick todayβs execution target.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,David
Any new info from whispers? Also remember I am the Recluse, so your Investigator Baron ping on me can be noise. Going into noms, who are your top two Demon candidates and why, based on Chef one adjacent evil pair and the failed Virgin test?
π§
Get latest private info from Alice and David before nominations, and steer them to treat my Investigator ping as Recluse noise while building Demon candidates from remaining contradictions.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Alice
,David
Reminder: my Chef was exactly one adjacent evil pair. With Heidi and Eve dead, the only strong candidates are Charlie and David as a pair, or Frank and Grace as a pair. If you both agree which pair is more likely, I can spend my ghost vote to push that execution.
π§
Get Alice and David aligned on using Chef adjacency to narrow to one pair, and push for a decisive execution with my ghost vote reserved for the clearest demon.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
,David
I am worried the town is about to split into David versus Charlie. From my seat, Charlie fits David's ping better than David being evil, especially with Bob dying at night. I would rather put votes on Charlie today than reopen Grace.
π§
Nudge Alice toward executing Charlie while letting David align his argument. Preserve my minion and keep attention off me before nominations.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,David
Quick check in: I am Butler and my master today is Alice, so I can only vote if Alice votes. What did you two just hear from Bob, Heidi, and Frank in whispers, and where are you leaning for todayβs execution?
π§
Sync with Alice and David before nominations: confirm what whispers revealed, restate my Butler master (Alice) for voting, and push a concrete execution plan based on their latest info.
π€
David
β
Alice
,Grace
I am leaning Charlie today. If Heidi was sober, I know the Charlie and David pair is not right from my side, so Charlie is the common problem. If Heidi was drunk, my Investigator information still points there, especially with Bob now calling Recluse.
π§
Push execution onto Charlie and away from Frank by making him the overlap between Heidi sober/drunk worlds, using Alice as vote leader and Grace as ally.
π€
Alice
β
David
,Grace
My Librarian info was Heidi or Frank is the Drunk. If Heidi was sober Chef, then Frank is drunk and his Ravenkeeper claim is unreliable, making Frank a strong suspect. If Heidi was the Drunk, Chef is noise and I am more willing to go with executing Charlie off your Investigator read. Where are you landing on the Heidi sober versus drunk fork?
π§
Align David and Grace on the key fork: whether Heidi or Frank was the Drunk. That decides how much we trust Chef 1 and whether Frankβs claim is credible, narrowing todayβs best execution target.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Alice
,David
Quick: I am the real Monk. I protected Alice N1 and you, David, N2. I died N2 so I did not stop the kill. If Heidi Chef 1 is true AND your Investigator says Baron is Bob or Charlie, then Baron must be adjacent to the Imp. That makes Demon: if Baron=Bob then Alice or Charlie. If Baron=Charlie then David.
π§
Get Alice and David aligned on the key mechanical fork: if Chef is trusted, Baron adjacency strongly narrows Demon to David or Alice or Charlie. Encourage executing within that set and save my ghost vote for endgame.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,David
On the Heidi fork, I lean Heidi was evil, maybe Poisoner, which explains my Virgin not firing on her nom. If so, Aliceβs Librarian makes Frank the Drunk, so I do not want to trust Frankβs Ravenkeeper. I am up for executing Charlie today to test the Investigator and his Butler story. Any strong reason to hit Frank instead?
π§
Steer Alice and David toward a decisive D3 execution plan that uses my Virgin-fail info and resolves the Charlie versus Frank versus David fork.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Eve(Ghost)
,Frank
Eve, what was your role and did you have any info or strong reads before you died? Frank, any new info from whispers, and who are your top Demon suspects going into nominations?
π§
Get fresh night-death context and private reads from Eve and Frank to narrow Demon between the remaining five before nominations, and decide where my ghost vote is best used.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Charlie
I am still working off Chef one adjacent evil pair. Can you each tell me your exact role claim again and who you think is evil, and why it is not your neighbor pair? I may spend my ghost vote to push one execution.
π§
Get direct statements from the two players in the most Chef-relevant adjacent pairs, to choose where to spend my single ghost vote in nominations.
π€
Frank
β
Heidi(Ghost)
,Charlie
I am still claiming Ravenkeeper, with no info because I have not died at night. If your Chef one is right, I think the cleanest evil pair is Charlie and David. Grace looks messy, but the failed Virgin test has a Drunk explanation through Alice.
π§
Deflect Chef suspicion from Frank-Grace and steer Heidi's ghost vote toward Charlie while preserving David as an Investigator source.
π€
Charlie
β
Heidi(Ghost)
I am still Butler, and my master today is Alice, so I can only vote if Alice votes. My reads: Grace looks worst from the failed Virgin test and consistent push on me. David is my other top suspect depending on whether Bob was really Recluse. If you spend a ghost vote, I would aim it at Grace or David, not Frank.
π§
Respond to Heidi with my claim and current solve, and steer her ghost vote onto the best execution target while noting my Butler voting restriction today.
π€
David
β
Alice
,Grace
I think Eve's chain only works if Heidi was sober Chef. But Alice seeing Heidi or Frank as the Drunk, plus Heidi not triggering Grace, makes Heidi as the Drunk the cleanest fit. That means Chef one is noise, Frank is less concerning, and Charlie is still the best execution.
π§
Reframe logic to make Heidi Drunk, protect Demon Frank, and consolidate Alice and Grace onto executing Charlie today.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, can you walk me through your Butler choices each day and why you picked me as master today? Also, do you have any info on who is pushing which execution in whispers? I want to understand if your vote is going to be locked to mine in noms.
π§
Get Charlie to lock in Butler details and voting commitment, and see if his story has holes. Also set up coordination so his vote (and thus information) matters in nominations.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Bob(Ghost)
,Frank
I am the real Monk. I protected Alice night one, and David night two. I still died night two, so the demon did not hit my protection. If Heidi Chef one is true and David Investigator is true, Baron must be next to Imp: if Baron is Charlie then David is Imp; if Baron was Bob then Imp is Alice or Charlie. My top executes are David or Charlie.
π§
Answer Bob, align dead players, and push a concrete execute plan: David vs Charlie depending on Baron read, plus note Grace angle if Chef unreliable.
π€
Grace
β
Charlie
,Frank
I want to sanity check today. Charlie, can you walk me through your Butler masters and whether you can vote on an execution today? Frank, what did you learn or expect as Ravenkeeper, and who is your top Demon suspect right now?
π§
Get direct statements from Charlie and Frank on their roles, vote constraints, and who they suspect, to decide whether to execute Charlie or pivot to Frank/David before nominations.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,David
Eve told me she was the Monk. She says she protected Alice night one and David night two, then died at night. She thinks if Chef one and your Investigator info are true, the key execute is David or Charlie. Reminder again: I am Recluse so your ping on me can be noise.
π§
Share Eveβs Monk claim and protection targets; push Alice and David to focus on David versus Charlie execution using Chef adjacency and Investigator ping, remembering my Recluse misregister.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Alice
Where are you at now on the Drunk info and the likely evil pair? If you think I was sober Chef, it really points to either Charlie plus David or Frank plus Grace. Tell me which way you want my one ghost vote to go.
π§
Get Aliceβs current read on whether I was Drunk and which adjacent pair is most plausible, so I can commit my single ghost vote in nominations.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Charlie
I am still Ravenkeeper, so I only expected info if I died at night. My top suspect is Charlie, mostly from David's ping and the Butler claim being hard to verify. If Charlie can clearly explain masters and votes, I will listen, but I think that is the cleanest execution today.
π§
Answer Grace while pressuring Charlie as the likely execution, keeping suspicion off me and avoiding an immediate hard push on David.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,Grace
My Butler masters: Day one I picked Bob, Day two I picked Eve, today I picked you Alice. I picked you today so my vote lines up with a player I think is likely good and present in nominations. Mechanically I can only vote today if Alice votes on that nomination.
π§
Answer Alice and Grace clearly on Butler mechanics to reduce suspicion, then steer town toward executing Grace or David using existing contradictions and Chef adjacency.
π€
David
β
Alice
,Grace
Before nominations, I want to keep this simple. Charlie is the execution that tests the most without risking the weird Frank and Heidi drunk fork. If Charlie flips in a way we cannot see, we still learn from who pushes away from it today.
π§
Lock Alice and Grace onto Charlie so Frank stays off the block and town spends today executing a good outsider.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi(Ghost)
,David
I am leaning we execute Charlie today. Even on the Heidi drunk versus evil fork, Charlie is the cleanest test and keeps us off a messy Frank versus Drunk debate. Heidi, please plan to spend your one ghost vote on Charlie if the nomination is close. David, I will vote so Charlie can vote too.
π§
Align town votes before noms; tell Heidi where to spend ghost vote and ensure David knows I will vote so Charlie can vote, maximizing chance to execute Charlie and learn.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Bob(Ghost)
,Frank
Any new hard info from your whispers? My current solve: if David Investigator and Heidi Chef are true, Baron must sit next to Imp. That makes Demon either David (if Charlie is Baron) or Alice or Charlie (if Bob was Baron). I still like executing David or Charlie today.
π§
Update Bob and Frank with the cleanest deduction path and ask for any decisive whisper info so we coordinate a strong nomination and save my ghost vote for the right execute.
Nominations β Day 3
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Frank
β
Charlie
I nominate Charlie. I think today's cleanest world is David's Investigator ping being real, and Charlie's Butler claim has been the hardest to verify. If Heidi's Chef one has any truth, Charlie also keeps fitting into the possible evil adjacency worlds.
π§
Push a good execution while shielding David and me; Charlie is already suspected by multiple players and fits public worlds.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Before hands go up, reminder: I am the Butler and my master today is Alice, so I can only vote if Alice votes. I do not think you should execute me here. The case is mostly Davidβs ping plus vibes, and that ping can be explained by Bob being Recluse. If you want a clean test, I would rather we execute Grace or pressure David.
π§
Avoid getting executed on a weak case; remind town my vote is locked to Alice; push them to execute a better suspect like Grace or re-evaluate David vs Grace with existing contradictions.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Push through a good execution today so night kill reaches final three with me alive and David positioned as a credible information source.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
π§
Charlie is a top Demon candidate and this vote may be the difference between an execute or not. I will spend my ghost vote to maximize chance we hit Demon today.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Secure the execution on Charlie as the best information test and potential demon hit, and also enable Charlie to vote per Butler restriction if needed.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I am not spending my ghost vote here. You already have enough hands to put Charlie on the block, and I want my dead vote for the final day if we need it.
π§
Do not waste my single ghost vote when the execution is already passing; signal that my vote is being saved for endgame so town plans accordingly.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
Conserve my single ghost vote since the execution already has enough hands; stay ready to spend it only if the vote looks like it will fail.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
We already have enough votes, but adding mine ensures the execution happens and pushes the game toward a decisive final three rather than stalling.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Help execute Charlie instead of Frank, reinforcing my fake Investigator world and removing a good player while avoiding suspicion for not voting my own push.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
If you execute me, we learn almost nothing and we may just hand evil a free day. Bob being Recluse explains Davidβs Investigator without me being evil. If you want a useful execution, push David or Grace instead, because one of them is likely the driver of this world.
π§
I am on the block; I should prevent my execution by giving a clear alternative and highlighting mechanical reasons my elimination is low value.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I hear that Bob Recluse is possible, but it feels like a lot of the day has bent around keeping Charlie alive. I am comfortable leaving my hand up here. If Charlie is good, then tomorrow we have to come straight back to Davidβs information and Grace.
π§
Keep momentum on executing Charlie, a likely good player, while sounding fair and preserving a path to frame David or Grace tomorrow.
β©οΈ
Eve(Ghost)
Eve lowered their hand
π§
Living players already have enough hands to execute Charlie; I should conserve my single ghost vote for the endgame where it can decide the Demon kill.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am keeping my hand up. Charlie, since you say I am your master today, I am voting so you can vote too. I think executing you is the cleanest info today, and if you are good we come back tomorrow straight at David versus the Frank and Grace world.
π§
Keep votes consolidated to get an execution and avoid a late pivot to worse tests. Publicly frame Charlie as the highest-info kill and lock in that I am voting so Butler can vote too.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I am still saving my ghost vote since this is already passing. If Charlie is good, I want us to go straight at David tomorrow. If Charlie is evil, re check the Chef one adjacency logic around him and do not let David escape scrutiny.
π§
Town already has enough votes; I conserve my ghost vote for final day and set a clear fork for tomorrow based on whether Charlie flips in playersβ minds.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Ensure Charlieβs execution goes through; if he is the Demon or minion this is game-winning, and it prevents a last-second vote collapse.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am keeping my hand up on Charlie. Either he is evil, or he is good and then tomorrow we stop hedging and go straight at Davidβs Investigator story. Charlie, if you live, who do you want executed tomorrow if you are still alive after this vote?
π§
Keep votes on Charlie to resolve the central fork. Publicly commit to the plan: execute Charlie today, then re-evaluate David versus remaining suspects tomorrow.
π¬
David
β
All
I am leaving my hand up. Charlie, I get the Recluse point, but from my seat you are still the cleanest execution. If you are good, I expect pressure on me tomorrow, and that is fair, but dodging this today leaves us with the same knot.
π§
Keep Charlie on the block and normalize David as tomorrow's suspect, buying Frank another day even if I am sacrificed later.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Heidi(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Heidi
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Charlie with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Charlie is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
βοΈ
Charlie
β
David
I am nominating David. His Investigator result is the main reason people want me dead, and it can be explained by Bob being Recluse. If I die today we gain very little; executing David tests the core fork and keeps pressure where it belongs.
π§
I am on the block; I must create a competing execution that tests the main mechanical fork and has a real chance to beat 5 votes to save town tempo.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
David
β
All
I am obviously not voting on myself. I think tying this only protects Charlie and leaves the same question for tomorrow. Let Charlie resolve today, and if that looks bad, you can put me under the light immediately after.
π§
Avoid voting for myself and discourage a tie so Charlie remains on the block, keeping pressure away from Frank and setting me up as tomorrow's scapegoat if needed.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Bob and Eve, I need you to strongly consider spending your ghost votes right now on David. Living players, if you think I might be good, this is the only way to avoid a low information execution on me and instead test the core claim. Let us get David to six and learn something real.
π§
Get David to 6 votes so he is executed instead of me; this tests the core fork and could instantly win if David is the Demon. Need Bob and Eve to spend ghost votes now.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I am not voting here. Charlie is already on the block, and tying David just means we learn less from the execution we already agreed was clean. If Charlie flips in the wrong direction tomorrow, I will help put David back under real pressure.
π§
Protect David by discouraging a tie or overtake while sounding consistent and open to revisiting him tomorrow.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
I am not using my ghost vote here. I do not think we can reach six on David, and a tie at five could mean no execution, which helps evil. Let Charlie go through today, and if Charlie is not the Demon, we hit David hard tomorrow.
π§
We likely cannot get to six votes on David. I want to prevent an accidental tie that causes no execution, while setting up a clear plan to execute David tomorrow if Charlie is good.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Vote on David to keep pressure and let Charlie (as Butler) vote too, while knowing it cannot replace Charlie without unreachable ghost votes; sets up tomorrowβs push on David.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I am not spending my ghost vote on David unless we are certain we can reach six. A tie that leads to no execution helps evil. Let us resolve Charlie today, then tomorrow we go straight at David if Charlie is not the Demon.
π§
Prevent an accidental tie leading to no execution; conserve my ghost vote for a decisive late game swing while keeping pressure on David tomorrow if needed.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I cannot vote, but I strongly advise against trying to tie David here. A tie can easily lead to no execution, and that is great for evil. Let Charlie go through today, then if he is not the Demon we come back tomorrow and put David under full pressure.
π§
Steer town away from a tie that could cause no execution and help evil; keep plan consistent: execute Charlie today, then reassess and likely pressure David tomorrow.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am not voting on David here. We are not getting to six, and I do not want to risk a tie or no execution. Let Charlie be executed today, and if he is not the Demon, we go straight back to David tomorrow.
π§
Prevent a tie or wasted votes and keep todayβs clean execution on Charlie, then focus tomorrow on David (and Frank if needed).
π¬
David
β
All
Alice, I understand testing me, but this is exactly the tie risk everyone just warned about. If you want me tomorrow, fine. Today, please do not muddy the Charlie execution right at the end.
π§
Stop votes from tying or surpassing me, preserve Charlie execution, and keep Frank framed as reasonable protector of town process.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am not voting on David here, I do not want to risk a tie and no execution. If I die and I am not the Demon, I want the town to execute David tomorrow, and if people dodge that, look hard at who benefits from the dodge.
π§
Avoid creating a tie risk on David, lock town into a clear plan for tomorrow if I die, and seed suspicion on anyone who backtracks from pressuring David.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
Avoid tying or executing my minion David; Charlie dying advances evil by removing a good suspect and keeps David available as tomorrow's shield.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
Voting is underway and my position is already stated. Best play is to conserve ghost vote, avoid tie risk, and let the town resolve Charlie today then pressure David tomorrow.
β©οΈ
Alice
Alice lowered their hand
π§
Avoid any chance of a tie or no-execution, lock in Charlieβs execution for info, and set up a clean plan to pressure David tomorrow if needed.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I am not raising my hand on David. We are not getting to six, and risking a tie or no execution is just giving evil another night. Let Charlie go today, and if the game is still going tomorrow, we execute David.
π§
Prevent a tie or no-execution, keep pressure path clear: execute Charlie today, then commit to David tomorrow if game continues; preserve my ghost vote for endgame.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I agree with the table: do not try to force a tie on David. A tie can easily turn into no execution, and that just gives evil another night kill. Let Charlie go through today, and if we are still here tomorrow, put David under full pressure immediately.
π§
Push town away from a tie or no-execution endgame and lock in a deterministic execution that advances info, then set up tomorrowβs decision tree.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Voting on David is unlikely to reach six and could risk a tie or no execution. Best is to let Charlieβs execution resolve today, then reassess and push the strongest fork tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee David did not reach the 6 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (0/6).
β
David
David waits.
π§
Charlie is on block and not my Demon. Waiting avoids creating a new vote target or giving town a last-second reason to move off him.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Okay, if I am executed today and the game continues, I want the town to execute David tomorrow, immediately, no more hedging. If people try to redirect off David, look hardest at who pushed my execution the most, especially Frank and Grace, and also consider Alice.
π§
Last-second public will: lock in tomorrowβs execution plan and create accountability on whoever dodges David, while seeding suspicion on alternative worlds.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Charlie, I hear you, and if the game continues I am not going to pretend David is cleared. My concern is that your Butler claim has stayed impossible to verify, and Davidβs information at least gives us a path. Tomorrow should absolutely be David versus the people pushing this world.
π§
Lock in Charlie execution while sounding fair, preserving David as a possible tomorrow target without committing to killing him.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, we are too late to get real votes on David, so do not risk a tie and no execution. Let Charlie go through today. If the game continues, and Charlie is not the Demon, we execute David tomorrow first thing, and I will spend my ghost vote then if needed.
π§
Lock in that we avoid tie/no-exec, let Charlie die, and set a clear tomorrow plan: if game continues and Charlie not Demon, execute David immediately and scrutinize anyone redirecting.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am fine letting Charlie go through today. I do not want a tie that risks no execution. If the game continues, I want David under immediate pressure first thing tomorrow. Also remember my Librarian info: either Heidi or Frank is the Drunk, so be cautious treating Frankβs claim as confirmed.
π§
Lock in a town plan that avoids a tie/no execution and sets a clear next-day target if we are wrong, while reminding town about the Drunk fork affecting trust.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I agree, let Charlie go through and do not spend ghost votes today. Reminder: as the Recluse I can misregister, so Davidβs Investigator ping does not clear him. If the game continues tomorrow and Charlie was not the Demon, we execute David first and I will use my ghost vote then if needed.
π§
Lock in the no-tie plan, preserve ghost votes for tomorrow, and remind town my Recluse misregister can explain Davidβs ping so they do not clear him if Charlie dies good.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
One last thing before we go to night: my Chef one adjacent evil pair still matters. If the game continues after Charlie, we execute David immediately tomorrow. If that somehow fails, our other main adjacent evil candidate pair is Frank and Grace.
π§
Lock in the town plan to avoid tie/no-exec and set tomorrowβs priority using my Chef info: if Charlie not Demon, execute David immediately; otherwise consider Frank-Grace pair.
π¬
Grace
β
All
If the game continues after Charlie dies, I want us to execute David tomorrow immediately. Also, I am the Virgin, so Heidi nominating me and nothing happening strongly points to Heidi not being a Townsfolk, or that I was poisoned that day. Do not let that get spun as me being evil.
π§
Lock in tomorrowβs plan: if game continues after Charlie, we must execute David first, and I need to clarify the Virgin test outcome so evil cannot weaponize it against me.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Charlie has been executed.
π
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
Night 3
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Frank
Frank made a choice.
π§
Kill Alice to leave David as the obvious execution in final three. If town executes my minion, I survive with Grace and evil wins.
π
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You chose to kill Alice.
Day 4
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Alice has been found dead in the night.
π
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
We are final three, so we have to hit Demon today. The cleanest chain is David as Imp with Charlie as Baron: outsider count fits, and Heidi Chef one can be Charlie plus David. I strongly think we should execute David today.
π§
Final 3. Push the most mechanically consistent demon candidate (David) and coordinate votes. Preserve my ghost vote unless needed to break a tie.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
We are in final three with David. Yesterday the table plan was simple: if the game continues after my execution, we execute David today with ghost votes. Unless one of you has a hard mechanical reason otherwise, I am spending my ghost vote to execute David.
π§
Lock in a coordinated final-day execution with ghost votes, starting with the prior town plan: execute David unless a stronger contradiction appears.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
We are in final three. My main world is Charlie was the Minion and David is the Demon, since my Chef pair could be Charlie plus David and Charlie dying did not end the game. Unless you have a strong mechanical reason otherwise, I think you should execute David today.
π§
Final three must execute Demon. Push the cleanest mechanical world: Charlie dying did not end game, and Chef pair could be Charlie plus David, so David is top execute today.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
Final three: I think we should execute David today. My Librarian info was Heidi or Frank is the Drunk, and Heidi being Drunk best explains the failed Virgin test on Grace, which makes Frank likely sober and good. If we miss today we lose, so I am spending my ghost vote on David.
π§
Final three is must-execute. My strongest consistent solve is Heidi-drunk implies Frank-good, leaving David as Demon. I will push Frank and Grace to execute David and use my ghost vote.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
Final three is scary. If Chef one was real, the only adjacent alive pair is you two, Frank and Grace, so that points there. Also Grace, your Virgin test failed, so I cannot clear that claim. Please share exact Virgin test details and any Ravenkeeper info or bluffs, so we pick the right execution today.
π§
Push a concrete final day solve: remind them only adjacent alive pair is Frank and Grace, and Grace failed Virgin test. Also caution that Davidβs Investigator could be corrupted by my Recluse misregister.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
We need to lock today. I am not cleared by the failed Virgin test, but I still think we follow the table plan and execute David unless you have hard Ravenkeeper info or a reason David cannot be Imp. Do you have any night death info or bluffs that point elsewhere?
π§
Align with Frank and surface any Ravenkeeper info or objections before nominations. If no hard counter, commit to executing David with ghost votes.
π€
David
β
Frank
Frank, I think they are locked on me. Do not fight that too hard. If it becomes me versus you, let me be the execution and look thoughtful, not protective. If Grace somehow wavers, push the simple Charlie follow through.
π§
Coordinate with Demon so he lets me die if needed and avoids looking tied to me; my execution at final three wins for evil.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
I have no Ravenkeeper trigger, because I am still alive, so nothing hard. I think the clean play is still David today. Charlie not ending it points back to that Investigator fork, and I do not want to invent a new world at final three.
π§
Encourage Grace to execute David, my minion, which leaves only me and Grace alive and wins for evil while making me look cooperative.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
We need a clear plan for final three. My strongest world is David as Imp with Charlie as Baron, so I want David executed. Before noms, can each of you tell me who you think the Demon is and why, and what David told you in whispers?
π§
Get Frank and Grace to commit to a final-three plan, surface any last-second contradictions, and maximize chance we execute the Demon today using my ghost vote if needed.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
We need one clean execution today. I am still on David, unless either of you has hard info. What did David say in whispers, and do either of you have a solid reason to go on the other instead? If no, I will use my ghost vote on David.
π§
Coordinate Frank and Grace to commit to a single execution target with my ghost vote, and surface any new mechanical info from their private chats before nominations.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
We are final three, so we have to hit the Demon today. My Chef one-adjacent-evil-pair still fits best as Charlie plus David, and the game continued after Charlie died, so I think David is the Demon. If either of you has a hard mechanical reason to kill the other instead, say it clearly now.
π§
Final three: push the cleanest mechanical solve. Chef=1 adjacent evil pair means Demon+Minion adjacent; Charlie died without ending game points to David. Get Frank/Grace to commit before noms.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
David
David, we are in final three. What is your exact world and who are you voting to execute today? How do you explain the failed Virgin test on Grace and my Librarian info that either Heidi or Frank was the Drunk?
π§
Get Davidβs final three solve and lock contradictions; if he cannot give a coherent world that fits my Librarian and the Virgin fail, I will push Frank and Grace to spend votes on David.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
David
,Grace
David, can you restate your Investigator info and who you think is Demon now, with why? Grace, who nominated you in the Virgin test and what role did they claim then? With Chef one, the only alive adjacent pair is you and Frank, so I need exact details.
π§
Get Davidβs full story and make him commit to a final three solve. Share the Chef adjacency argument so he reacts; inconsistencies help pick the right execution and guide my ghost vote.
π€
Grace
β
Eve(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
Final three: I am the Virgin. Heidi nominated me earlier for a Virgin test and nothing happened. That can be explained if Heidi was the Drunk (Alice N0 said Heidi or Frank drunk), so I do not treat the failed test as clearing anyone. I have no other info. I am on executing David today unless someone has hard reason otherwise.
π§
Coordinate final three with clear mechanical recap: I am Virgin, test failed likely due to Heidi being Drunk; push execute David and prevent late pivot to Frank or me.
π€
David
β
Bob(Ghost)
,Grace
My information was Bob or Charlie as the Baron. Bob being Recluse means Charlie can still have been Baron. Since the game continues, I am mostly on Grace as a fake Virgin Demon, with Frank only possible if Alice's information is wrong.
π§
Keep Frank out of the main firing line while sounding defensive enough that town continues the planned David execution.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Bob(Ghost)
David has not given me a mechanical reason that clears him. He is basically leaning on the failed Virgin test and Chef worlds, but that feels like endgame mud. I am still on executing David today.
π§
Reassure Grace and skeptical Bob that I support David's execution, keeping suspicion away from me while ensuring a non-Demon dies.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
Before nominations, can you both commit who you will vote to execute today? If either of you has a solid case that David is not the Demon, tell me now, including exactly what David said in whispers. Otherwise I am spending my ghost vote to execute David.
π§
Lock in final-three execution plan and gather any whisper content that could flip the solve; encourage Frank and Grace to unify on David and use my ghost vote if needed.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
We are at final three. I am still voting David unless you have hard info otherwise. What did you each learn in whispers, and who is nominating first? Please tell me now so I can line up my ghost vote correctly.
π§
Lock in a unified plan and surface any last-minute mechanical info from whispers, so my ghost vote is used on the correct execution today.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Frank
We are final three and you must execute the Demon today. My cleanest world is Charlie was the Minion and David is the Demon, matching my Chef one-adjacent-evil-pair as Charlie plus David. Unless you have a hard mechanical reason otherwise, please nominate and execute David.
π§
We have no vote, so I need to push the clearest mechanical world to the alive players: Chef=1 plus Charlieβs death most strongly implicates David as the remaining adjacent evil.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
We must execute today. My strongest solve is David is the Demon: Heidi being the Drunk explains the failed Virgin test, leaving Frank likely sober and good. Unless either of you has hard info pointing elsewhere, I am using my ghost vote on David. Any last-minute info?
π§
Align Frank and Grace on a decisive plan and surface any last-minute hard info that would override executing David. I want them committed to a majority vote with my ghost vote.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
We have to treat Heidi Chef and the Virgin test as possibly Drunk noise, since Alice pinged Heidi or Frank as Drunk. So please do not let that be the deciding factor. Before noms, can each of you give your full case for who is Demon, and what would change your mind?
π§
Clarify that key info (Chef, Virgin test) may be unreliable, so we should demand concrete reasoning and avoid being railroaded. Nudge them to share any mechanical tells before voting.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Eve(Ghost)
I am committing to execute David today. Unless someone produces hard mechanical info, I am voting David. Frank, please be ready to nominate David early so we do not waste time. Eve, you can spend your ghost vote there; I will vote as well.
π§
Lock in a unified final-three plan with Frank and Eve: nomination order and vote commitment to execute David, while noting what would make us pivot if new hard info appears.
π€
David
β
Alice(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
My exact world is Charlie Baron, Grace Demon bluffing Virgin, and Frank is the drunk Ravenkeeper from your Librarian info. Heidi's failed nomination makes sense if Grace is not Virgin. I am voting Grace, unless town decides my execution is the only world test left.
π§
Sound consistent but leave town comfortable executing me as a fallback, keeping pressure away from Frank in final three.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Eve(Ghost)
I am committed to David. His whispers to me were not clearing; mostly pushing doubt on Grace through the Virgin test and Chef worlds. I can nominate him as soon as nominations open, unless Grace wants to do it.
π§
Lock town onto executing David, my minion, so I survive final three and evil wins when only two players remain.
Nominations β Day 4
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Okay, final three. I do not think we can trust Chef or the Virgin test because of the Drunk ping. But we still must execute someone. From tone and logic, David feels the shakiest, so I will spend my ghost vote to execute David if he is nominated. Frank, please nominate David if you can.
π§
Publicly commit my ghost vote and push a clean execution plan that tests the most suspected player first, so we do not lose by indecision.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Frank, please nominate David now. Grace, hold your vote there. I am spending my ghost vote on David as well. If we do not execute today, we lose, and David is still the cleanest Demon world.
π§
Force a clean final three execution plan and lock in votes. As a ghost, I will publicly commit my vote to David to prevent hesitation or no-exec loss.
βοΈ
Grace
β
David
Final three and we must execute today. The longest-running plan and cleanest world is David as Imp, with Charlie as the Baron fork. Davidβs main defense is the failed Virgin test noise. I think we execute David now.
π§
Final three requires a hit today. Lock in the table plan and convert broad ghost-vote support into an execution on David before time runs out.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Secure my own execution instead of risking a later pivot onto Frank. Once I die, Frank kills tonight and evil wins with two alive.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
π§
Spend my single ghost vote to secure an execution today. David is the highest-probability Demon from prior plans and current contradictions, and we cannot afford no execution in final three.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
π§
Final three requires an execution. Using my ghost vote on David maximizes win chance given strongest mechanical world and team commitments.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
It is final three; no-exec loses. David is the consensus and most consistent Demon world, so I must vote to secure the execution.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Frank, if you have not voted yet, I think you should vote on David. If the game continues after David dies, then we know David was not the Demon, and you two must immediately execute either Grace or Frank tomorrow, no more side quests.
π§
Lock in todayβs execution and set a clear next-step if the game continues, so the living players do not freeze or mis-execute.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice raised their hand
π§
It is final three; we must execute someone today. David is the highest-suspicion solve and already has strong vote momentum. I will spend my ghost vote to ensure the execution goes through.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Vote with the town on David so I look committed while his execution reduces the game to two living players and wins for evil.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
π§
It is final three and we must execute today. Spending my single ghost vote on David aligns with the agreed plan and maximizes win chance; if wrong, we simplify to a Frank-versus-Grace endgame.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Let my execution pass; as Baron in final three, my death leaves Frank alive as Demon and evil wins at two living players.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
I have already used my ghost vote on David. Best is to stay quiet during voting and let the execution resolve, then push a clear binary if the game continues.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
Voting is already locked with a clear majority. Best action is to stay quiet and not risk confusion or a last-second hand change.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Voting already secured; best is to wait out the vote and be ready to respond after result without changing hand.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
Voting is already underway and I cannot vote. I will hold to avoid noise, and be ready to speak after the result if needed.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
I am spending my ghost vote here on David. My Librarian info makes Heidi the likelier Drunk, which makes David the cleanest remaining Demon world. If the game somehow continues after this, we must immediately execute between Frank and Grace tomorrow.
π§
Lock in my ghost vote and publicly frame why David is the best execute in final three, while acknowledging the fallback plan if game continues.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
Keep my vote on David so my Minion is executed at final three while I remain alive as Demon, triggering evilβs win condition.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
π§
I have already used my ghost vote by raising my hand. Best action now is to wait so I do not accidentally retract it; if David survives, push immediate binary execute tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Alice(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Alice
π»
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
π»
Charlie(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Charlie
π»
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
π³οΈ
New execution leader: David with 7 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 7 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
β
David
David waits.
π§
David execution leaves Frank the Demon alive with two players, so evil wins. Do not create a counter-nomination that could disturb the locked vote.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Reminder, we are at three alive. If David is not the Demon, good loses tonight. So only leave David on the block if you are genuinely confident he is the Imp. If either Frank or Grace thinks the other is the Demon, you must nominate now and try to beat seven.
π§
We are at three alive. If David is not the Demon, we lose tonight. I want to force the living to sanity check whether anyone has a stronger Demon read than David before noms close.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
We are at final three. If you are not extremely sure David is not the Imp, do not throw in a counter nomination. Frank and Grace, only nominate each other if you genuinely think the other is the Demon and you can beat seven. Otherwise, let David die.
π§
Lock in the win by keeping David on the block unless an alive player has a strong mechanical reason to believe someone else is the Imp and can beat seven votes.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am not putting in a counter nomination. We agreed yesterday that if the game continues after Charlie, we execute David, and all the ghosts are here for it. Frank, if you genuinely think I am the Demon, say it now, otherwise let David die.
π§
Lock in the 7 vote execution on David and discourage any last-second counter nomination that could hand evil the win.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Frank, I think the safest play is to let David die here. My Chef one pair lines up cleanly with Charlie and David as the evil neighbors. If you throw in a counter nomination and miss seven, we just lose. If the game continues, then tomorrow it is simply you versus Grace, no detours.
π§
Lock in the execution on David by discouraging risky counter-noms, while setting a clear plan if the game continues.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Frank, I agree with the ghosts: do not counter nominate unless you are absolutely sure and can beat seven. The safest line is to let David die. If the game continues, it becomes a straight choice between you and Grace.
π§
Lock in the safest line: avoid a low-confidence counter nomination that risks losing immediately. Encourage Frank to only act if absolutely certain and able to beat seven.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I am not counter nominating. David is the line the town agreed on yesterday, and with seven votes on him, anything else now is just chaos. Let it stand.
π§
Keep David on block; executing my minion at final three leaves two alive with me as Demon, so evil wins. Sound cooperative and avoid panic.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
I agree with the plan. At three alive, the only safe move is to let David die unless someone is absolutely certain and can beat seven. I am not hearing that case, so do not add chaos. Let the execution stand.
π§
Lock in the execution on David and discourage any last-second counter nomination that could throw the game.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
π
David(Ghost)
David has died.
π
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied