Game Detail
Players
Alice (Ravenkeeper) Bob (Mayor) Charlie (Undertaker) David (Investigator) Eve (Monk) Frank (Poisoner) Grace (Imp) Heidi (Butler)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 293,434 | 78,843 | $1.6173 |
| Good | 819,223 | 1,495,498 | $6.7603 |
Event Transcript
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You are the Minion. The Demon is Grace.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Minions are: Frank. Your safe bluffs are: Washerwoman, Soldier, Empath
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
🎯
Frank
Frank made a choice.
🧠
Night zero is where key info roles act. Poisoning Alice maximizes odds of corrupting start info and creating early confusion to keep Grace safe.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You chose to poison Alice.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Investigator. Either Frank or Alice is the Poisoner.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
🧠
I want to choose a neighbor I can easily whisper to and coordinate with. If Alice votes, I can vote too, keeping me engaged in the town's decision-making.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
You chose Alice to be your master.
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
👤
Bob
→
Alice
Hey Alice, it's Bob. Did you get any information last night? I'm still trying to piece things together.
🧠
Start a private conversation to gather early information without revealing my Mayor role, which could make me a target.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
Hey Bob, I didn't get any info last night. I'm the Ravenkeeper, so I only learn something if I die at night. Do you have anything?
🧠
Establish early trust with my neighbor, exchange roles and info, and start building a network of verified good players.
👤
Eve
→
David
,Frank
Hey, I am trying to build a circle of trust. What have you heard so far, and do you have any leads?
🧠
Begin private conversations with other players to gather claims and create a baseline for truth-checking, avoiding reliance on any single information source.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,David
Hey Bob and David. It's Charlie. Since we're sitting next to each other, I figured we should compare notes. Do either of you have any information yet, or any early suspicions?
🧠
Connect with my neighbors to exchange information, build trust, and evaluate their credibility based on what they share.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Hi Grace. I noticed Bob, Alice, Charlie, and David have all been whispering in a cluster, while Eve reached out to David and Frank. Have you talked to anyone yet? I think we should find some people outside those circles to trust.
🧠
Start building a trusted alliance outside the main whisper clusters to gather independent information and protect myself if my master Alice turns out to be evil.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
,David
I have not heard much yet. I am currently claiming Chef, and I got a one. So there is exactly one adjacent evil pair somewhere. That could be a lot of pairs, but I am watching the Bob and Charlie area and also Heidi and Alice.
🧠
Answer Eve, build trust with an info bluff, and direct early suspicion to non-evil pairs so the town wastes Day 1.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
Hi Heidi. I have not talked to anyone yet either. I agree we should compare notes away from that cluster. I am leaning toward claiming Empath, but I want to hear your role or any info first. What did you get?
🧠
Build trust with Heidi outside the main whisper cluster, set up an Empath bluff that will later fit having an evil neighbor, and collect her role/info.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Bob
Hey Charlie and Bob. I do have some information. I am the Investigator, and I learned that either Frank or Alice is the Poisoner. Since Frank is currently claiming Chef, that seems very suspicious to me. What do you both think about that?
🧠
I need to share my Investigator information with trusted neighbors to start building an alliance and cross-reference claims. Frank is claiming Chef but is one of my two Poisoner suspects, making his claim highly suspicious.
👤
Bob
→
David
Hey David. You said Frank is claiming Chef. Did he tell you what number he got? And what do you think about Alice saying she's the Ravenkeeper?
🧠
I want to verify David's claim by asking for details on Frank's supposed Chef information, and see if his framing of Frank/Alice is consistent.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, have you gotten any information from your role yet? I'm trying to find people who can help piece together what happened last night.
🧠
I need to expand my information network beyond Bob to verify his trustworthiness and learn if other players have useful night zero information.
👤
Eve
→
Grace
Hey Grace, I am trying to figure out what is going on. Have you heard any claims or useful information so far? I heard someone is claiming Chef, but I want to hear what else is out there before nominations start.
🧠
I need to gather more claims and cross-reference Frank's Chef information. Grace has been whispering with Heidi, so she might have heard something useful. Building a wider network of trust helps verify or contradict early claims.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
Hey Alice. No info from my role yet, since it only triggers after someone is executed. What about you? Do you have any night zero information, and what role are you playing?
🧠
Respond to Alice's question and probe for her role/claims without revealing my own role or spreading unverified accusations. Gather information to evaluate David's Investigator claim.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
I am the Butler. On night zero I chose Alice as my master, which means I can only vote tomorrow if she votes too. So my hands are a bit tied. If you are the Empath, what did you learn from your neighbors?
🧠
Build trust with Grace by sharing my true role and master choice. As Butler I need allies, and Grace is my neighbor who reached out. This also lets her know my voting is restricted to Alice's vote.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Just so you know, I told Eve and David I am Chef and got a one. I tried to aim suspicion at other adjacent pairs like Bob and Charlie or Heidi and Alice. What are you planning to claim, and is there anyone you want me to poison tonight?
🧠
Coordinate with Grace on bluffs and steer town away from the Frank-Grace adjacency implied by my Chef 1 claim; plan future poisons to break info chains.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
I am going to bluff Empath. No read yet, I will get info tonight. Your Chef one is perfect. For poison, I would hit Bob tonight since he is in that info cluster and could be Fortune Teller or Investigator.
🧠
Coordinate with Frank on consistent bluffs and pick a high-impact poison target to derail early info, while keeping Chef one aligned with our real adjacency.
👤
David
→
Bob
,Charlie
Hey Bob and Charlie. To answer your question Bob, yes, Frank told me he got a one. As for Alice claiming Ravenkeeper, I am not sure what to think yet. But my Investigator info says either Frank or Alice is the Poisoner, which means one of them is definitely a Minion. I am leaning toward Frank being suspicious since he is claiming Chef while my info points to him or Alice. What do you both think?
🧠
Answer Bob's questions and share that Frank told me he got a one. Get Bob and Charlie's reads on whether Alice's Ravenkeeper claim feels genuine, since either Frank or Alice is the Poisoner per my info.
👤
Bob
→
Frank
Hey Frank, it's Bob. David mentioned to me that you're claiming Chef and got a one. Is that right? I'm just trying to collect info before nominations start.
🧠
Verify Frank's claimed role and number directly to cross-check David's story. If Frank denies claiming Chef or gives a different number, David is likely lying.
👤
Alice
→
Grace
Hey Grace, I'm Alice. Have you gotten any information from your role yet? I'm trying to figure out who we can trust before nominations start.
🧠
I need to expand my information network beyond Bob and Charlie. Talking to Grace will help me gather more claims and identify potential inconsistencies before nominations begin.
👤
Eve
→
Heidi
Hey Heidi, I heard Frank is claiming Chef with a one pair result. Has Grace or anyone else shared anything with you that matches or contradicts that? I am trying to figure out who might be in that evil pair before nominations.
🧠
Cross-reference Frank's Chef claim with Heidi before nominations to see if there are contradictions or corroborating details that help identify the evil pair.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
Hey Bob. David told us both that he is the Investigator and that either Frank or Alice is the Poisoner. What do you make of that? Do you think David is telling the truth, and if so, who looks more suspicious to you, Frank or Alice?
🧠
I need to compare notes with Bob, who heard the same Investigator claim from David. We need to coordinate our trust and figure out which of Frank or Alice looks more suspicious before nominations begin.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Grace, Frank is claiming Chef with a one pair result. If you are really the Empath, what number did you get from your neighbors? Since I know I am good, your read will tell us if Frank is evil.
🧠
I need Grace's actual Empath number to cross-check Frank's Chef claim. Since I know I am good, her read on Frank and me will mechanically verify or expose Frank before nominations.
👤
Frank
→
Bob
Yeah, that is right. I am claiming Chef with a one, so I think there is exactly one adjacent evil pair somewhere. I do not think it points cleanly yet. What are you claiming, and do you have any starting info that clashes with that?
🧠
Reinforce my Chef bluff, build trust with Bob, and gather his claim while subtly directing suspicion away from Grace.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
,Alice
Heidi, as Empath I do not get a read until tonight, so I cannot clear you or Frank yet. I did hear Frank is claiming Chef with a one. Alice, I am leaning to claim Empath. No info yet. What are you claiming, and have you heard any solid starting info?
🧠
Maintain credible Empath bluff (no N0 info), build trust with Heidi and Alice, and softly reinforce Frank’s Chef claim without overcommitting.
👤
David
→
Eve
Hey Eve, sorry for the late reply. I do have a lead. I am the Investigator, and I learned that either Frank or Alice is the Poisoner. Frank claims he is the Chef, which makes me very suspicious of him. Have you heard anything that might help us figure out which one it is?
🧠
I need to respond to Eve and share my Investigator finding to build a trusted alliance. With only one tick left before nominations, gathering more perspectives on Frank and Alice is critical.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
⚖️
David
→
Frank
I am the Investigator and I learned that either Frank or Alice is the Poisoner. Frank is claiming Chef, but since my information directly points to him as a potential Minion, I find his claim highly suspicious. We should test this by putting him on the block.
🧠
I have solid Investigator information that either Frank or Alice is the Poisoner. Frank claiming Chef while being one of my two suspects is very suspicious. I need to act on this information and nominate Frank to put pressure on him and potentially remove a Minion from the game.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Frank
→
All
Okay, I am not the Poisoner. I have been openly claiming Chef with a one since early today, before nominations. David, I get that your Investigator info points at me or Alice, but that is exactly the kind of thing that can be wrong if you are drunk or poisoned, or if you are bluffing. Can we hear Alice’s claim and any starting info before we execute someone on the first nomination?
🧠
Avoid my execution by undermining the Investigator ping and encouraging the town to delay or demand more info/claims, preserving the Demon and my poison for Night 1.
💬
David
→
All
Frank, I want to address something important. The Poisoner does not act until Night One, which means there was absolutely no way I was poisoned on Night Zero when I received my Investigator information. My starting info is clean. I know for a fact that either you or Alice is the Poisoner. Now, if you are truly the Chef, then Alice must be the Poisoner, but we need to test this. I stand by my nomination, and I believe my information is solid.
🧠
Defend my nomination by pointing out that Poisoner cannot poison on Night Zero, so my info is clean. Encourage others to trust my Investigator claim and vote for Frank.
💬
Alice
→
All
Hey everyone, I'm Alice and I'm the Ravenkeeper. I didn't get any information on night zero since my ability only kicks in if I die at night. David, I know I'm not the Poisoner, so if your Investigator information is accurate, Frank must be. But we should consider that you could be the Drunk, or Frank could be the Recluse registering as evil. I'm not sure we should rush into executing someone on day one with those possibilities still on the table.
🧠
Clear my name publicly by claiming Ravenkeeper, explain that I know I'm not Poisoner so Frank would be if David is right, but caution that David could be Drunk or Frank could be Recluse. Encourage caution on D1 execution while providing my real role.
💬
Eve
→
All
I am not voting for Frank right now. David, your logic about Night Zero is sound, but we still have to account for the Drunk, the Recluse, or a bluffing evil player. If Frank really is the Chef, we lose our only pair reading. And even if we hit a Minion today, the Demon is still out there. I think we should hear from everyone else before we execute on day one.
🧠
I want to avoid a hasty day-one execution when the upside of hitting a Minion is limited and the downside of killing a good player is severe. I also want to encourage the real Chef, if any, to come forward and hear more claims before we commit.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I'm not voting for Frank right now. David's Night Zero info is strong, but the Drunk or Recluse could still throw it off. I'd rather hear from everyone else before we execute on day one.
🧠
I want to avoid a hasty day-one execution when Drunk or Recluse could explain David's read, and instead hear more claims before committing to a vote.
💬
Bob
→
All
I am not comfortable voting for Frank right now. David, your Night Zero info is definitely worth considering, but we still have to account for the Drunk and the Recluse. If Frank is actually the Chef, we lose important pair information. I think we need to hear from more people and maybe compare some other claims before we pull the trigger on day one.
🧠
I want to caution against a day one execution when David's info could be wrong due to Drunk or Recluse, and Frank's Chef claim is unverified but potentially valuable.
💬
Grace
→
All
I am not voting Frank right now. Even if David is sincere, the Drunk and the Recluse exist, and we have almost no other info yet. I would rather hear a few more claims, then decide, and I am fine with no execution today.
🧠
Stop Frank’s execution today, preserve the Poisoner for Night One, and keep town in uncertainty by advocating more claims and a possible no-execution.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I am not voting for Frank. I am the Butler, and Alice is my master for today, so my vote is tied to hers. From everything I have heard, rushing an execution on day one feels way too risky when David could be the Drunk or Frank could be the Recluse. I think we should hear more claims before we pull the trigger.
🧠
Reveal my Butler role and Alice as my master to explain why I am not voting, and caution against a hasty Day One execution when multiple mechanical explanations exist.
💬
Frank
→
All
I really want to see a no vote here. If Heidi is truly the Butler, then we likely do not even have room for Drunk or Recluse, which means David’s story and Heidi’s story cannot both be clean. Let’s do a full claim round and revisit tomorrow instead of executing on day one.
🧠
Stop votes on me today and keep the group from using David’s accusation to build a clean logic chain that leads to me and then Grace.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
I nominated Frank based on my clean Night Zero Investigator information. I must vote for him to stand by my claim and signal conviction, even if the execution does not pass.
💬
Alice
→
All
I am not voting for Frank right now. David, your Night Zero info is definitely worth watching, but the Drunk and Recluse still exist, and I know I am not the Poisoner. Grace, to answer you directly, I am the Ravenkeeper and I got nothing on night zero. I think we should see what tonight brings and then compare notes tomorrow.
🧠
I need to make clear I'm not voting for Frank yet, remind Grace of my claim, and avoid a risky day-one execution while positioning myself as a helpful good player before night phase.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
I already stated I would not vote for Frank. With only David voting yes, Frank will not reach four votes. I will hold my position, let the nomination fail, and prepare to use my Monk ability tonight.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
I already stated I won't vote for Frank. With only David voting, execution won't reach 4 votes. Waiting lets the phase end and brings night, where I can get Undertaker info if someone dies by execution tomorrow.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
The vote is stalled at 1 of 4 needed. I already said I won't vote for Frank. Waiting lets the phase tick down without unnecessary drama.
💬
Grace
→
All
I would like to see hands down here. Day one executions are often just guesses, and this could still be Drunk or Recluse noise. Let us take tonight, get real night information, and revisit David versus Frank tomorrow.
🧠
Keep Frank off the block today and push for no execution; preserve flexibility to kill David tonight and control tomorrow’s narrative.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Since this looks like it is heading to no execution today, I think Bob, Charlie, and Eve should share their roles and any night zero information before we wrap up. The more claims we have to compare tomorrow, the easier it will be to sort out whether David's investigator read is real or if Frank's chef pair is accurate. Even if David is right, hitting a Minion on day one still leaves the Demon out there, so we need all the information we can get.
🧠
Push for more claims from the unclaimed players before the day ends so we have more data to compare tomorrow, and highlight that even if David is right, executing Frank only hits a Minion not the Demon.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Frank did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Frank did not receive enough votes (1/4).
💬
Frank
→
All
One rules point, David: in Trouble Brewing, the Poisoner acts on the first night, so first night info is not automatically clean. That makes your certainty too strong for me. I still prefer we take the night, get real info, and revisit tomorrow.
🧠
Undermine David’s certainty by correcting Poisoner timing, keep pressure off me, and steer town toward no execution and more claims so evil gets a free night kill.
💬
David
→
All
Frank, you just said something that is completely wrong. In Trouble Brewing, the Poisoner does not act on Night Zero. The Poisoner starts poisoning on Night One. My Night Zero Investigator information is absolutely clean, and you lying about that rule is incredibly suspicious. If you were really a good Chef, you would not need to make up fake rules to discredit me.
🧠
Expose Frank's false rules claim. In Trouble Brewing, the Poisoner does not act on Night 0, so my starting info is definitely clean. This rules lie strongly suggests Frank is the Poisoner trying to undermine my legitimate read.
💬
Alice
→
All
Frank, you were wrong about the Poisoner. It does not act on Night Zero, so David's starting info really is clean from poisoning. That actually hurts your case more than it helps it. We still need to hear claims from Bob, Charlie, and Eve before we wrap up today.
🧠
Point out Frank's rules error to cast doubt on his defense, and pressure the unclaimed players to share information before night falls.
💬
Eve
→
All
I am the Monk. I have no night zero information since my ability starts tonight. I think we need to look hard at the setup math Frank and Heidi just raised. If Heidi really is the Butler and we have the standard one Outsider, then Drunk and Recluse are probably not in play. That makes David's night zero information much harder to dismiss. But we still have not heard from Bob, Charlie, or Grace, and I want all three claims before night so we can actually compare tomorrow.
🧠
Claim my real role to build trust, address the setup math Heidi/Frank raised, and push the remaining unclaimed players to speak before night so we have more data tomorrow.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am the Undertaker. Like Eve said about the Monk, my ability does not start until tonight, so I have no night zero information to share. Tonight I will learn what character died by execution today, but since we are not executing anyone, I will likely have nothing useful tomorrow morning either. I still think hearing all claims now is smart so we can compare notes after tonight.
🧠
Claiming my role since I was directly asked to do so, and explaining that I have no night zero information so the town knows what to expect from me tomorrow.
💬
Bob
→
All
I am the Mayor. I have no night zero information either. Frank, your claim about the Poisoner acting on night zero was dead wrong, and that makes me trust David's investigator read a lot more. I think we need to take tonight, but Frank is looking like the most likely Poisoner right now.
🧠
I need to claim my role since everyone is asking for remaining claims. Revealing as Mayor helps the good team understand the full claim picture and lets them factor in my endgame win condition. I also want to note Frank's rule error as very suspicious.
💬
Grace
→
All
I will go ahead and claim Empath. I had no information yet when Heidi asked earlier, since it starts tonight. My neighbors are Frank and Heidi, so tomorrow I will have a number that should help us test David’s Investigator world. I still prefer no execution today.
🧠
Publicly lock in a safe Empath bluff, support no execution, and set up tomorrow’s Empath number as a mechanical test that can defend Frank or redirect suspicion.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Frank, getting the Poisoner timing wrong is a big problem for me. That was not a minor mistake, it was a direct attempt to discredit David's clean night zero information. I am finding David a lot more believable right now. Grace, your Empath read tomorrow is going to be huge. You know I am good, so whatever number you get will tell us a lot about Frank. Let us sleep on it and compare real information in the morning.
🧠
Highlight Frank's rules mistake as a major credibility issue, remind the town that Grace's Empath read tomorrow will be decisive since she knows I am good, and flag that we need to scrutinize claim density tomorrow.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
🎯
Frank
Frank made a choice.
🧠
Grace’s Empath read tomorrow would mechanically catch me as evil. Poisoning her forces a false read that can clear me and keep the Demon safe while town turns on Alice or David.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You chose to poison Grace.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
🎯
Eve
Eve made a choice.
🧠
Grace's Empath read tomorrow is the most mechanically decisive information we will get. Keeping her alive ensures we get that number, which directly tests Frank and Heidi.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
You chose to protect Grace.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Grace
Grace made a choice.
🧠
Kill the claimed Undertaker to remove future mechanical confirmation from executions, increasing chaos and making it easier to survive to final three.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
You chose to kill Charlie.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Undertaker. No one was executed today so you learn nothing.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
🧠
Grace will get an Empath read on Frank and me tonight. Since I know I am good, her number directly reveals Frank's alignment. I want to be able to vote whenever she does, so I can act on that critical information tomorrow.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
You chose Grace to be your master.
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
A peaceful night has passed. All villagers are present and accounted for.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
Grace, I need to know your exact Empath read from last night. How many of your neighbors Frank and Heidi are evil? This is crucial for figuring out if Frank is the Poisoner.
🧠
Grace's Empath read on Frank and Heidi is described as highly consequential but I never heard the actual number. I need this critical information to evaluate whether Frank, Heidi, or both are evil before nominations begin.
👤
Bob
→
Grace
Hey Grace, I know Charlie just spoke to you, but I wanted to ask directly. What was your Empath number last night? Since your neighbors are Frank and Heidi, that result is crucial for figuring out if Frank is actually evil.
🧠
I need Grace's N1 Empath result to cross-check Frank. Her neighbors are Frank and Heidi, so her read directly tests Frank's alignment. This is the most important mechanical info right now.
👤
David
→
Grace
Hey Grace, it's David. My night zero Investigator info says either Frank or Alice is the Poisoner. I know you're Empath with Frank and Heidi as neighbors. What was your exact night one read? I want to compare notes because if you got a one, that really points to Frank being evil.
🧠
I need to share my Investigator night-zero info with a trusted information-gathering player to coordinate our reads. Grace is Empath with direct neighbor data on Frank, so comparing notes will help us nail down whether Frank or Alice is the Poisoner.
👤
Alice
→
Grace
Hey Grace, what did your Empath ability tell you last night about Frank and Heidi? I am really suspicious of Frank after he got the Poisoner timing wrong, and I want to compare notes.
🧠
Grace has a crucial N1 Empath read on Frank and Heidi. I need that mechanical data to cross-reference with David's Investigator claim and Frank's suspicious behavior.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Grace, I chose you as my master last night so I can only vote if you vote today. Are you planning to vote? What did everyone whisper to you about Frank and Alice?
🧠
Grace is my Day 2 master, so I can only vote if she votes. I need to coordinate with her on voting plans and learn what she discovered from the multiple whispers she received.
👤
Eve
→
Grace
Grace, I am the Monk. I protected you last night, which is almost certainly why no one died. What was your Empath read today? We need to compare notes quickly before nominations start.
🧠
Tell Grace I am the Monk and that I protected her last night to explain the peaceful night, build trust, and ask for her Empath read so we can coordinate before nominations.
👤
Grace
→
David
,Eve
David, my Empath read last night was one. Between Frank and Heidi, Heidi feels consistent with Butler, so that points more at Frank. Eve, my Empath was one. If nobody died, it is possible you protected me and the Demon tried for me, but I cannot prove that.
🧠
Give consistent Empath info that points to Frank, buy trust by supporting the ‘Monk protected me’ narrative, and set up a sacrifice of Frank if needed.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Hey Grace, I think you should avoid an Empath one today because it just backs up David. If you can credibly say you got zero, it puts the whole Investigator read in doubt. Also, no death last night screams Monk protection, so do not panic about that.
🧠
Coordinate with Grace to pick an Empath narrative that derails the Investigator case on me and sets up a Day 2 execution away from our Demon.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
I already asked Grace for her critical Empath read. With multiple players whispering her simultaneously, I should wait for her to share information publicly or respond before committing to my next move.
👤
Bob
→
David
Hey David, Grace just whispered to you. Did she tell you her Empath number? With Frank and Heidi as her neighbors, that result is the single most important thing for figuring out if Frank is actually evil.
🧠
David was one of the two people Grace whispered to, so he likely knows her Empath number. I need that number to resolve whether Frank is evil before nominations begin.
👤
David
→
Bob
Yes, Grace told me her number was one. With Frank and Heidi as her neighbors, and Heidi looking like a real Butler, that really puts the heat on Frank. What do you make of it? You spent a lot of time whispering with him yesterday.
🧠
Confirm Grace's Empath result to Bob since the information is already shared, and observe his reaction to see if he genuinely pursues Frank or pivots unexpectedly.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
Hey Eve, Grace whispered to you earlier, right? Did she tell you what her Empath ability picked up last night between Frank and Heidi? That information is really important for figuring out who we should trust.
🧠
Eve was one of two people Grace whispered to, so she likely knows Grace's Empath result. Getting that read lets me cross-check Frank and Heidi and narrow down who is evil before nominations.
👤
Heidi
→
David
David, Grace whispered to you just now. What did she say? Is she planning to vote today, and what was her Empath read on Frank? I am the Butler and I chose her as my master last night, so I can only vote if she does.
🧠
Grace whispered to David and Eve, so David likely knows Grace's Empath read. I need this info to decide who to trust and whether Grace will vote today, which determines if I can vote.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
Grace told me her Empath read was one between Frank and Heidi. That means exactly one of them is evil. Given that Frank messed up the Poisoner timing and David's Investigator result points to Frank or Alice, I think Frank is looking very suspicious right now.
🧠
I need to answer Alice's question and share Grace's Empath read so we can coordinate before nominations. Transparency helps the good team build a coherent picture and target the right player.
👤
Grace
→
Alice
,Bob
My Empath last night was one, between Frank and Heidi. Heidi feels consistent with Butler, so I lean Frank as evil. If there was no death, it could fit Monk protection, but I cannot prove it.
🧠
Lock in my Empath=one story with key influencers, push a Frank execution as a safe sacrifice, and keep heat off me while maintaining control over Heidi's Butler vote.
👤
Frank
→
Bob
Hey Bob, I am still side eyeing David. If Grace’s Empath read comes out as zero today, that makes David’s Investigator ping on me or Alice look really shaky. In that world, Alice is the cleaner execution between the two of us, and it tests a lot.
🧠
Seed doubt about David’s Investigator and redirect suspicion to Alice, leveraging Bob’s Mayor clout to steer the day’s execution away from Grace.
👤
Charlie
→
David
David, did Grace tell you her Empath read? Also, given Frank's rules mistake, are you still confident it is either Frank or Alice as Poisoner? I think we should strongly consider executing Frank today so I can confirm his role as Undertaker.
🧠
I need to learn Grace's Empath read and build a case to execute a suspicious player today. As the Undertaker, confirming a role tonight will break open the game, and Frank's rules error makes him the strongest candidate.
👤
Bob
→
David
Frank just whispered me trying to push an Alice execution based on the idea that Grace got zero, which we know is false. He is either completely out of the loop or more likely scrambling to deflect now that Grace's one points directly at him. I think Frank is our nomination today.
🧠
Alert David that Frank tried to recruit me to execute Alice using a false hypothetical, which is more evidence Frank is evil and knows he is cornered.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Heidi
Hey, Grace told me her Empath read was definitely one. Frank is lying when he says zero. I still believe it is either Frank or Alice as Poisoner, and that one points straight at Frank. Heidi, Grace should be voting today. Charlie, I agree, let us nominate Frank.
🧠
Tell Heidi that Grace is voting so her Butler ability works, and confirm to Charlie that Grace got one and Frank should be nominated. This coordinates the vote and Undertaker plan.
👤
Alice
→
David
,Bob
David, Grace told me her Empath between Frank and Heidi read one last night. Since I am good, Frank must be the evil one. Bob, we need to nominate Frank today. His Chef claim and that Poisoner timing mistake just do not add up. Are you both with me?
🧠
Share Grace's Empath result with David and Bob to build a coalition against Frank. David needs to know the Investigator result now points clearly to Frank, and Bob's support as claimed Mayor is crucial for the nomination.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Grace, I need to know if you are voting today. As the Butler, you are my master and I can only vote if you do. I am good and I want to help execute Frank if you think he is evil based on your Empath read. What are you planning to do?
🧠
I need to know if Grace is voting today so I can exercise my vote as Butler. I also want to hear directly from her about her Empath read and plans.
👤
Eve
→
David
David, it is Eve. I am the Monk and I protected Grace last night. Since no one died, that probably blocked the Demon. Grace told me her Empath read was one between Frank and Heidi. Combined with your Investigator result, Frank looks extremely suspicious. Should we push to nominate him today?
🧠
I need to coordinate with David before nominations begin. Sharing my Monk protection on Grace and confirming Grace's Empath read will help solidify the case against Frank and ensure we are aligned on who to nominate.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
I am not locked into voting yet. I want to hear the public chat first, because the no death makes me wonder if info is getting muddied. For now, do not hard commit to a Frank vote just because of me.
🧠
Control Heidi’s vote as her Butler master to reduce the chance Frank is executed today, while sounding cautious and reasonable.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
Hey Eve, quick check in. With David’s investigator pointing at Frank or Alice, I think Alice is the cleanest test today, since Ravenkeeper only triggers on night death. Also, no death last night feels like a Monk protection or a deliberate no kill. What did you do?
🧠
Recruit Eve (claimed Monk) into an Alice-first execution plan, while fishing for her protection target to explain no death and shape public narrative.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
⚖️
David
→
Frank
Frank, the evidence against you is too strong. My Investigator night zero says you or Alice is the Poisoner. Grace's Empath read last night was one, and her neighbors are you and Heidi. Heidi looks like a real Butler, so that points straight at you. You also lied about Poisoner acting on night zero, and you are now telling people Grace got zero when she got one. I am nominating you for execution.
🧠
The evidence converges on Frank: my Investigator pair, Grace's Empath one between Frank and Heidi, and Frank's own lies about the rules and Grace's read. Nominating him today is the best path to execute a likely Minion.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Frank
→
All
I am not convinced this case is solid. David’s Investigator point at me or Alice is a two person maybe, and it can be wrong if he is drunk or if there is poisoning in play. Grace’s Empath one does not uniquely mean me, it could be Heidi. If you want a clean test, execute Alice from the Investigator pair today, not me.
🧠
Talk down votes on me by undermining David’s certainty and offering an alternative test (Alice or David). Keep Grace off the chopping block.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
The evidence from my Investigator, Grace's Empath, and Frank's own lies all point to Frank being evil. I must vote to execute him now.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Frank lied about Poisoner mechanics, which is a major red flag. David's Investigator and Grace's Empath both point toward Frank. I protected Grace last night and no one died, further suggesting an evil player was blocked. I must vote to execute Frank.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Get Frank executed to relieve pressure on me and lock in my Empath narrative; also enables Heidi (Butler) to vote, likely securing the majority.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Grace is my master and has raised her hand, so I am mechanically allowed to vote. The evidence against Frank is strong and converges from multiple sources. I will raise my hand to secure the 4th vote and execute Frank.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
I need Frank executed so my Undertaker ability triggers and I learn his actual role. This resolves the Investigator versus Chef conflict and confirms whether Grace's Empath read was accurate.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
The evidence against Frank is overwhelming and coherent across multiple information roles. Voting for his execution advances the good team's primary objective of finding and killing evil players.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Frank is the overwhelmingly likely Poisoner based on his false rules claim and contradictions. I must vote to execute him and clear my own name since David's Investigator result implicates either Frank or me.
💬
Frank
→
All
Everyone, pause. This is a pile on based on one Investigator maybe and an Empath one that could just as easily mean Heidi. If you want to test David’s pair, execute Alice today, not me. If I die and flip good, we have learned nothing.
🧠
I need to survive this vote or at least cast doubt to reduce hands below majority; keeping my poison ability helps protect Grace and destabilize town.
💬
David
→
All
Frank, you are trying to throw Alice under the bus, but Grace's Empath read was one between you and Heidi. Heidi is clearly the Butler, so that points directly at you, not Alice. My Investigator result says you or Alice is the Poisoner, and Grace's info narrows it to you. Executing Alice would ignore the Empath entirely. The evidence converges on you.
🧠
Shut down Frank's pivot to Alice by explaining why the overlapping evidence makes Frank the only logical execution today, ensuring the group stays united.
💬
Eve
→
All
Frank, your attempt to throw Alice under the bus does not hold up. Grace got one between you and Heidi, and Heidi has been consistent as the Butler. That points directly at you. David's Investigator said you or Alice is the Poisoner, and Grace's read narrows it to you, not Alice. Your own false claim about the Poisoner acting on night zero is what started this suspicion. I am keeping my vote up.
🧠
Reinforce the case against Frank to secure the execution and counter his attempt to redirect suspicion onto Alice. Explain why the Empath and Investigator results converge on him, not Alice.
💬
Grace
→
All
I am keeping my vote up on Frank. Between David’s Investigator pair, Frank’s wrong Poisoner timing, and him trying to rewrite my Empath info, I think this is the cleanest execution today. If I am wrong, we revisit tomorrow.
🧠
Keep my hand up to let Frank be executed, buying credibility from my Empath push while removing a loud teammate whose cover is collapsing.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
My master Grace is voting and I am mechanically allowed to vote. The evidence from David's unpoisonable Investigator and Grace's Empath strongly converges on Frank being evil. With 7 votes already raised, the execution is secured. I will maintain my vote and let the nomination resolve.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I'm keeping my vote up. I'm also the Undertaker, which means I'll learn exactly what role Frank was after this execution. I'll see you all tomorrow with confirmation.
🧠
Reveal my Undertaker role to establish credibility and let everyone know I'll have concrete information about Frank's role tomorrow morning, which will help resolve today's execution.
💬
Bob
→
All
Frank, you are ignoring the facts. Grace got one between you and Heidi, not zero, and Heidi has been consistent as the Butler. David's Investigator pair plus Grace's Empath both point straight at you. Charlie will confirm your role tonight as Undertaker. I am keeping my vote up.
🧠
The evidence from Investigator, Empath, and Frank's own lies all converge on Frank being evil. Executing him lets Charlie's Undertaker confirm. I must speak to keep the vote solid and prevent anyone from wavering.
💬
Alice
→
All
Frank, you are trying to redirect onto me, but Grace's Empath read was one between you and Heidi. Heidi has been consistent as the Butler, so that points directly at you. David's Investigator says you or I am the Poisoner, and Grace's information narrows it to you. You also lied about the Poisoner acting on night zero. The evidence all converges on you, not me. I am keeping my vote up.
🧠
Publicly counter Frank's attempt to throw me under the bus and keep pressure on him so votes do not waver. The evidence converges on Frank, not me.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Frank with 7 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Frank is now on the block with 7 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
⚖️
Frank
→
Alice
I am nominating Alice. David’s Investigator specifically put it on me or Alice, and executing within that pair is still the clean mechanical test. Ravenkeeper only matters if she dies at night, so it is low cost. If I die today, we learn almost nothing.
🧠
Nominate Alice to try to pull votes off me or create a tie, keeping me alive to poison tonight and muddy the logic chain against Grace.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 8 votes needed for execution or 7 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Do not vote for myself. Frank's nomination is a desperate redirect. The evidence strongly points to him, and I should let the vote proceed without adding credibility to his gambit by speaking again.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
My vote on Alice is required to reach a tie or push higher, preventing my execution and creating no-execution end of day, which favors keeping Grace alive.
💬
David
→
All
I am not raising my hand for Alice. My Investigator information says Frank or Alice is the Poisoner, and Grace's Empath read says one of her neighbors is evil. Since Heidi is the Butler, that evil player is Frank. The evidence all points to the same person. We execute Frank today.
🧠
I need to make it absolutely clear that I am not voting for Alice and that the evidence converges on Frank being the Poisoner. This prevents confusion and keeps the execution on track.
💬
Eve
→
All
I am not raising my hand for Alice. Grace's Empath read was one between Frank and Heidi, and Heidi has been consistent as the Butler. That points directly at Frank. David's Investigator pair matches that conclusion. We have enough evidence to execute Frank today, and Charlie will confirm the role tonight. Do not split the vote.
🧠
Prevent Alice from reaching 7 votes and tying Frank. Make it clear that the evidence converges on Frank so the execution goes through.
💬
Grace
→
All
I am not voting for Alice here. This feels like a panic counter nomination, and splitting or tying just risks no execution. Frank is already the best mechanical shot today, so I want that to go through cleanly.
🧠
Avoid a tie and look consistent with my earlier stance; let the town execute my minion scapegoat so suspicion stays off me.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
Grace, my master, is not voting for Alice, so I cannot vote for Alice either. The town has a clear majority to execute Frank, so I will wait and let the vote close cleanly.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I am not raising my hand for Alice. If Alice ties with Frank, nobody dies today and we lose our best mechanical shot. Frank is the one who misexplained Poisoner timing and tried to rewrite Grace's Empath read. Execute Frank, and I will tell you exactly what role he was tomorrow morning.
🧠
I must ensure Frank is executed cleanly so I get Undertaker information tonight. Voting for Alice risks a tie that wastes the day and lets the Poisoner act again.
💬
Bob
→
All
I am not raising my hand for Alice. The evidence is stacked on Frank, and Charlie will confirm his role tonight if we execute him cleanly. Splitting the vote only helps the evil team.
🧠
I want to keep the vote locked on Frank and avoid any tie that would prevent his execution, so I will clearly state I am not voting for Alice.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Let the vote resolve safely. With 5 players publicly refusing to vote for me and only Frank voting, his counter-nomination will fail. Frank will be executed and we get Undertaker info tomorrow.
💬
Frank
→
All
If you are wrong and you execute me, you get no new hard info, because Undertaker can be drunk or poisoned and Grace could be lying. David’s Investigator put it on me or Alice, so tying Alice is still the clean mechanical play. Please put hands up to tie this so we do not just follow a pile on.
🧠
Try to force a tie to avoid my execution and keep my Poisoner ability online; seed doubt about David/Grace/Heidi mechanical certainty so someone votes Alice.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
Do not vote for Alice. A tie would save Frank, our primary suspect. Let the vote fail so Frank's execution proceeds.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
The vote to execute Alice is failing with only Frank supporting it. I want Frank executed today since all evidence converges on him. Waiting lets the nomination phase close cleanly with Frank on the block.
💬
Grace
→
All
Do not tie this. Frank is already on the block with a strong vote, and a tie just means no execution today. If you think Alice is evil, we can come back to her tomorrow, but let us take the clean shot on Frank now.
🧠
Keep votes off Alice to avoid a tie that causes no execution; let Frank die as a sacrifice, gaining me credibility going into midgame.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I am not voting for Alice. We already have seven votes on Frank, and the information from Grace and David both points straight at him. Splitting the vote only risks letting him off the hook. Let Frank go through so Charlie can confirm exactly what he was tomorrow.
🧠
Clarify that I am not voting for Alice and reinforce that Frank is the correct execution target, keeping the vote consolidated so Charlie can confirm the role tonight.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
I have already committed to not voting for Alice. Letting the vote stand ensures Frank is executed, and as Undertaker I will learn his exact role tonight, giving us definitive information tomorrow.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
The vote on Alice cannot tie or surpass Frank's 7 votes based on public commitments. Executing Frank is the cleanest path. I will wait to let the phase close cleanly.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Alice did not reach the 8 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Alice did not receive enough votes (1/8).
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
The vote is solid on Frank. Speaking or nominating now is unnecessary and could only create confusion. I will wait and let the execution go through cleanly.
💬
Frank
→
All
Wait. I have not been honest about my role, because I thought I would be killed at night. I could be the Saint. If you execute me and I am, you lose immediately. Also, do not lean on an Undertaker check when poison exists. Someone please nominate David now and tie this.
🧠
Create last-second fear of a Saint loss and undermine reliance on Empath and Undertaker, hoping town forces a tie or swaps execution away from me to protect the Demon.
💬
David
→
All
Frank, you cannot be the Saint. We have exactly one Outsider in play because my Investigator information says the Minion is the Poisoner, not the Baron. Heidi is the Butler, so there is no room for a Saint. That last-second claim is a desperation bluff. Do not split the vote. We execute Frank today.
🧠
Reassure the group that Frank's Saint claim is mechanically impossible given the setup and my Investigator info, preventing a panic tie or backslide.
💬
Eve
→
All
Frank, you cannot be the Saint. Heidi is the Butler, and because David's Investigator points to the Poisoner as the Minion, there is no Baron adding extra Outsiders. That means exactly one Outsider exists in this entire town, and it is Heidi. Your Saint claim does not fit the math at all. We execute you today, Charlie confirms your role tonight, and we move forward from there. Do not let this last second panic bluff change anyone's mind.
🧠
Frank's Saint claim is mathematically impossible because Heidi occupies the sole Outsider slot. I need to firmly debunk this bluff so no one gets spooked in the final moments, ensuring Frank's execution goes through cleanly.
💬
Grace
→
All
Frank, that Saint claim does not fit with Heidi being the Butler unless we think there is a Baron, and nothing else points to extra Outsiders. This feels like a last second escape hatch. I think we just let the Frank execution stand, and reassess tomorrow with poison pressure gone.
🧠
Publicly dismiss Frank’s Saint bluff using outsider math and keep town locked on executing him, while I look consistent as Empath and let my minion go for credibility.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Frank, your Saint claim is mathematically impossible. I am the Butler, and David's Investigator saw the Poisoner, not the Baron, which means there is exactly one Outsider in play. That is me. You are not the Saint. Let the execution stand, and we will see what Charlie's Undertaker learns tonight.
🧠
Reinforce that Frank's Saint claim is mathematically impossible and that the town should let his execution proceed cleanly so Charlie's Undertaker check can resolve remaining questions tomorrow.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
The town has correctly identified Frank's Saint claim is mathematically impossible. The execution is locked in. Waiting lets the phase end cleanly so I can receive Undertaker information tonight.
💬
Bob
→
All
Frank, your Saint claim does not add up. Heidi is the Butler, and David saw the Poisoner, not the Baron. That means there is exactly one Outsider in this entire town, and it is Heidi. There is no room for you to be the Saint. Everyone stay the course. Let this execution go through, and we will see what Charlie learns tonight.
🧠
Reinforce that Frank's Saint claim is mathematically impossible and urge the group to let the current execution stand without splitting votes.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Frank has been executed.
💀
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
🎯
Eve
Eve made a choice.
🧠
Grace is almost certainly good because the Demon's N1 kill was blocked, likely targeting her. Protecting her again preserves her Empath check on Heidi tonight, which will either condemn Heidi or clear her, drastically narrowing the Demon pool.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
You chose to protect Grace.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Grace
Grace made a choice.
🧠
David is the clearest logic engine. Removing him reduces coordinated pressure on me and likely pushes town to execute Alice off his earlier Investigator pair, avoiding a risky Ravenkeeper night kill.
💀
David(Ghost)
David has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
You chose to kill David.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Undertaker. You learn that Frank was the Poisoner.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
🧠
I trust Grace's Empath information because it mechanically confirmed Frank as evil using my known good status. She is likely good and will vote tomorrow, allowing me to vote as well. I will choose Grace as my master again.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
You chose Grace to be your master.
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. David has been found dead in the night.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Charlie
Quick heads up: I really was the Poisoner. I poisoned you night one, Alice, and I poisoned Grace night two. So please treat Grace’s early Empath number as potentially poisoned info. Charlie, if your Undertaker result looks clean, still be careful about clearing Grace off it.
🧠
Use my dead voice to admit Poisons that undermine Grace’s Empath reliability and redirect heat onto Bob or Alice, keeping Grace off the block and setting up a misexecution.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
,Grace
Charlie, what exact role did your Undertaker ability show for Frank last night? Grace, we need to figure out if the Demon is still alive or if a Scarlet Woman took over.
🧠
I need Charlie's Undertaker result on Frank to determine if the Demon is dead or still alive. Sharing this with Grace lets us coordinate our next move before nominations.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Charlie
Charlie, what did you learn from the Undertaker about Frank? My Investigator info says either Frank or Alice is the Poisoner, so Frank's exact role tells us whether Alice is the Minion or if the Demon is still hiding among the rest.
🧠
Get Charlie's Undertaker result on Frank to determine if Alice is the Poisoner and whether the original Demon is dead, which changes who we hunt today.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
,Grace
Grace, what was your empath read last night? Frank whispered me that he poisoned you night two, so it might be false. Charlie, did you get your undertaker result on Frank? We need both today.
🧠
I need to gather the two most important pieces of information today: Charlie's Undertaker result on Frank and Grace's Night 2 Empath read. Sharing Frank's poisoning confession helps them contextualize their info.
👤
Eve
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, what did your Undertaker ability show you about Frank's role last night? Everyone is waiting on that information before we nominate anyone.
🧠
Charlie holds the key Undertaker result from Night 2. I need to know Frank's role to determine if the Demon or a Scarlet Woman is the remaining threat before nominations begin.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
,Grace
Charlie, what role did you learn Frank was from Undertaker? Grace, I want to make sure we are aligned on who to vote for today. Who do you suspect most right now?
🧠
I need Charlie's Undertaker information about Frank's role to narrow down which world we are in. I also need to coordinate with Grace since she is my master for Day 3 voting.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
,Alice
My night two Empath was zero on Eve and Heidi, so I think they are both good. Also Frank could not have poisoned me on night two since he was already dead after yesterday. If Frank was our only Minion, I do not think Scarlet Woman is a thing here.
🧠
Answer info requests with a consistent Empath bluff, undermine the ‘Frank poisoned you N2’ claim, and redirect suspicion away from my neighbors and toward other good players.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Alice
My Undertaker result on Frank was Poisoner. Since we only have one Minion slot, there is no Scarlet Woman. The original Demon is absolutely still alive among Alice, Bob, and Eve.
🧠
Share critical Undertaker confirmation that Frank was Poisoner and deduce there is no Scarlet Woman, focusing the town on executing the original Demon today.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Grace
My death means only the Imp is left. Charlie claiming Undertaker is the town anchor, and he can just say I was Poisoner because everyone expected that. I would push today onto Charlie or Bob, then at night kill Charlie. Also do not kill Alice if she is really Ravenkeeper.
🧠
Coach Grace to redirect suspicion away from herself, break the Undertaker info chain, and avoid risky kills that could mechanically expose the Demon.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
,Alice
I need to point something out about Grace's Empath claim. She said her night two reading was zero on Eve and Heidi. But look at the seating order. Grace is between Frank and Heidi. Eve is not her neighbor. Frank is. Even with Frank dead, Eve is never her neighbor. That is a major red flag in her story.
🧠
I need to alert Charlie and Alice to Grace's contradictory Empath claim. If Grace is bluffing, her neighbor error is the key to catching the Demon today.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Grace
Grace, I have a strong deduction. Frank had to be the Poisoner, not the Demon, because the game kept going after he was executed. That means Alice is cleared as the Poisoner, though she could still be the Demon. Do you know what Charlie learned from the Undertaker about Frank? We need to confirm this and narrow down the Demon.
🧠
Share my key deduction that Frank must have been the Poisoner since the game continued past his execution, and gather the Undertaker result from a trusted player to confirm.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Charlie
Bob, excellent catch on Grace's neighbors. She cannot be the Empath if she thinks Eve sits next to her. Since Frank was our only Minion, Grace has to be the Demon. Charlie, are you with us on nominating Grace today?
🧠
I need to rally Bob and Charlie to act on Grace's impossible claim. With nominations approaching, securing a majority to execute Grace today is our best shot at winning.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
,Bob
Hey Alice and Bob, Charlie whispered to both of you earlier. Did he tell you his Undertaker result for Frank? We need that info before nominations start, so please share if you know.
🧠
Charlie hasn't answered my whisper directly, but he spoke to Bob and Alice. I need to get Frank's role from them to determine if the Poisoner is dead and who the remaining Demon is.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
,Grace
Charlie, I urgently need to know what Undertaker revealed about Frank's exact role before we nominate anyone. Grace, you are my master for today, which means I can only vote if you vote. Please tell me who you are planning to vote for so we can act together.
🧠
I must learn Frank's exact role from Charlie's Undertaker before nominations, and I need to coordinate my vote with Grace since she is my master for today.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
,Bob
Heidi, I am leaning Charlie today. He has not produced a clean Undertaker result on Frank, and that silence worries me. Bob, I think Charlie might be the Demon bluffing UT. If you get a chance, press him for the exact Frank result and timing.
🧠
Lock Heidi’s vote to my plan and seed Bob with suspicion on Charlie, aiming for a misexecution today and a clean night kill on the strongest info role.
👤
Charlie
→
Heidi
,Eve
Heidi and Eve, my Undertaker confirmed Frank was the Poisoner. Also, Grace claiming Eve is her Empath neighbor is mechanically impossible, since Grace sits between Frank and Heidi. That means Grace is not the Empath. We need to nominate her today. Heidi, be careful since your master might be the Demon.
🧠
Share Undertaker result and Grace's mechanical inconsistency with key players before nominations, especially warning Heidi since Grace controls her vote.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Heidi
,Eve
I would not trust Bob just because he says Mayor. Demon loves that bluff because it makes town hesitate in final three. Also Charlie can easily fake Undertaker by saying I was Poisoner. I think today should be on Bob or Charlie, not Grace.
🧠
Sow doubt about Bob’s Mayor claim and Charlie’s Undertaker being an anchor, steering today’s execution away from Grace so the Imp can keep control.
👤
Bob
→
Eve
,Heidi
Eve, Heidi, Charlie told me his Undertaker result. Frank was the Poisoner. That means there is no Scarlet Woman and the original Demon is still alive. Also, Grace claimed her night two Empath neighbors were Eve and Heidi, but look at the seating. Grace sits between Frank and Heidi. Eve is not her neighbor, alive or dead. Grace cannot be the Empath. I think Grace is the Demon and we need to nominate her today.
🧠
I need to rally Eve and Heidi against Grace before nominations begin. Grace's Empath neighbor claim is mechanically impossible, which is stronger evidence than any social read. Sharing Charlie's Undertaker result and the seating logic should solidify a majority vote against Grace.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Eve
Bob, Eve, did Charlie tell you what Frank's Undertaker role was? If Frank was the Poisoner, then Alice is not the Minion, and the Demon is still hiding among us. We need to know this before nominations start.
🧠
Find out Charlie's Undertaker result before nominations so I know whether Alice is cleared as Minion and whether the Demon is still hidden among the living players.
👤
Alice
→
Charlie
,Eve
Wait, I need to correct something. Bob's catch on Grace is wrong. The Empath checks alive neighbors, and since Frank is dead, Grace's alive neighbors are actually Heidi and Eve. So her night two read of zero is completely valid. That means Bob is either very confused or he is deliberately lying to frame Grace. That makes Bob look extremely suspicious to me. We should not nominate Grace today.
🧠
I need to correct my earlier mistake about Grace's Empath read and stop the wrongful nomination of Grace. Bob's catch is factually wrong because Empath checks alive neighbors, so with Frank dead, Eve is indeed Grace's neighbor. This makes Bob the primary suspect.
👤
Eve
→
Grace
,Charlie
Grace, Bob is telling everyone you claimed Eve and Heidi were your Night Two Empath neighbors. Did you actually say that, and what was your exact Night Two result? Charlie, I want you to hear her answer too so we can figure out if Bob is lying before nominations start.
🧠
I need to verify what Grace actually claimed for Night Two before nominations start. If Bob is lying about her claim, Bob looks like the Demon. If Grace confirms she named Eve and Heidi as neighbors, her Empath claim looks fake under standard neighbor rules.
👤
Heidi
→
Bob
,Charlie
Bob and Charlie, Grace is my master today so I can only vote if she votes. If we nominate Grace I will be unable to vote for her execution. We need Alice and Eve on board to reach majority. Do you think either of them could be working with Grace?
🧠
Coordinate with Bob and Charlie to plan Grace's nomination. Since Grace is my master, I cannot vote if she is nominated, so I need to ensure Alice and Eve are aligned to reach majority without my vote.
👤
Grace
→
Eve
,Charlie
Yes, my Night Two Empath was on my living neighbors Eve and Heidi, and it was zero. So Bob is basically repeating me, maybe just awkwardly. Charlie, can you please say plainly what you saw on Frank, and when? The silence is what worries me.
🧠
Clarify my Empath neighbors and result to keep credibility, reduce Bob-vs-me confusion, and steer Eve and Charlie toward executing Charlie (my preferred mis-exec) while sounding consistent.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice
,Eve
Bob is wrong about Grace's neighbors. With Frank dead, Grace's alive neighbors are Heidi and Eve, not Frank. Bob is deliberately lying or very confused, and that makes him look like the Demon to me. We should nominate Bob today, not Grace.
🧠
Bob's false mechanical accusation against Grace is the strongest evil tell. I need to rally Alice and Eve to nominate Bob before he can cause more confusion.
Nominations — Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Charlie
→
Bob
Bob lied about Grace's Empath neighbors. The game skips dead players for neighbors, just like my neighbors are Bob and Eve with dead David between us. Grace's neighbors are Eve and Heidi, so her Night Two read of zero is valid. Since Frank was our only Minion, Bob must be the Demon.
🧠
Nominate Bob because he lied about Grace's Empath neighbors. The game shows my neighbors skip dead David, so Grace's neighbors must skip dead Frank, making Eve her neighbor. Bob is deliberately framing Grace, and since Frank was the only Minion, Bob must be the Demon.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Bob
→
All
I made an honest mistake about the Empath neighbor rule. I genuinely forgot dead players get skipped. That does not make me the Demon. Charlie, you are awfully eager to execute me over one wrong call when you have never proven your Undertaker result. If I am the Mayor and you execute me today, the Demon wins. Grace, think about who benefits from killing the Mayor right now. It is not good.
🧠
Defend myself by admitting my neighbor rule mistake, then pivot to question Charlie's motives for jumping on an honest error to execute me. Try to convince Grace that executing the Mayor helps the Demon.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Bob is the most likely Demon. His 'mistake' about Grace's neighbors was a deliberate frame attempt, and his Mayor claim is a desperation bluff. With Frank confirmed as the only Minion, I must vote to execute Bob.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Bob's Empath neighbor claim was factually wrong in a way that conveniently framed Grace. I already told Charlie and Eve this makes Bob suspicious. I need to be consistent and vote for Bob while the nomination is active.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Cast the deciding vote to execute Bob, accelerating to an evil-favored endgame and keeping suspicion split between Bob and Charlie rather than on me.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Bob, executing the Mayor does not make evil win. That is not how Mayor works. You have now made two convenient rules mistakes under pressure. I am happy to see Bob go today.
🧠
Nudge town to execute Bob by highlighting Bob’s incorrect Mayor claim and framing it as opportunistic lying, while conserving my ghost vote for endgame.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Bob, your Mayor claim is completely wrong. Executing the Mayor does not make evil win. You also lied about Grace's Empath neighbors earlier. I am the Investigator, and Frank was the Poisoner, which clears Alice as the Minion. That leaves you as the obvious Demon. I fully support this execution.
🧠
I need to publicly reinforce why Bob is the Demon using my Investigator clearance of Alice and Bob's two false claims, ensuring the group understands the execution is correct before the phase ends.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Bob has made two convenient rule mistakes under pressure and is claiming a classic Demon bluff role. David and Charlie's information converges on Frank as the Poisoner, making Bob the obvious remaining Demon. I must vote to execute him now.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Bob is the most suspicious player with multiple rules lies and direct Investigator accusation. Grace is my master and has voted, so I am permitted to vote. Adding my hand solidifies the execution of the likely Demon.
💬
Bob
→
All
Everyone, I need to come clean. I was wrong about the Empath neighbor rule. Dead players are skipped, so Grace's read of zero on Eve and Heidi is completely valid. I was also wrong when I said executing the Mayor makes evil win. I panicked and I am sorry. I am the Mayor, and I am good. If you kill me today, look hard at Alice and Charlie. Alice's Ravenkeeper has given us nothing to verify. Charlie's Undertaker told us what we already knew. One of them is the Demon if Grace is good.
🧠
Admit my genuine rules mistakes to regain credibility, reassert I am good, and leave logical breadcrumbs pointing to Alice and Charlie as the remaining suspects if Grace's Empath is trusted.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Bob, I am the confirmed Undertaker. Frank was the Poisoner, and that mechanically cleared Alice while proving my role. Your two mistakes both happened to frame Grace and save yourself. That is not bad luck, that is a Demon bluff collapsing. I am not moving my vote.
🧠
Defend my confirmed Undertaker status against Bob's deflection, reaffirm that his repeated rules mistakes are too convenient to be accidental, and keep pressure on him before the vote concludes.
💬
Alice
→
All
I am keeping my vote on Bob. One honest mistake is understandable, but two self serving errors plus a sudden Mayor claim looks like a Demon bluff falling apart. If he is not the Demon, we will know because the game will continue. But his behavior is too suspicious to ignore.
🧠
I need to publicly affirm my vote and explain that Bob's pattern of two self-serving lies in one day is too convenient to be coincidence. If he is not the Demon, the game will continue and we can reassess, but his behavior is the most suspicious by far.
💬
Grace
→
All
I buy that you might have panicked, Bob, but two rules mistakes that both point away from you is hard to ignore. I am fine executing Bob today and, if the game continues, we immediately re check Charlie and Alice tomorrow.
🧠
Keep my vote on Bob while sounding measured, so if Bob is good I gain trust; if Bob is Demon, I do not look like the driving force.
⌛
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
🧠
Let Bob go through without spending my ghost vote. Preserve it for final day to prevent a Demon execution or force a tie.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
Bob already has 5 votes with only 3 needed. Using my single ghost vote now would be completely wasted. I must save it for a future nomination where my vote could actually determine the outcome.
💬
Eve
→
All
Bob, your first mistake framed Grace, your second mistake tried to keep you alive, and your Mayor claim only appeared when you were cornered. Grace's Empath zero on me and Heidi means we are both good, so the Demon is either you or Charlie. Charlie's Undertaker result matches what David already told us. That leaves you.
🧠
Bob's pattern of mistakes all point away from him, and Grace's Empath clears me and Heidi. Executing Bob is the logical choice, and if wrong, Charlie is next.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Bob, one honest mistake is understandable, but two errors that both happen to keep you alive is way too convenient. I am keeping my vote on you.
🧠
Reinforce that Bob's repeated convenient mistakes are suspicious and justify my vote without revealing my Butler role.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Bob with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Bob is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Bob
→
All
I know I look terrible after those two mistakes, but I genuinely am the Mayor and I just panicked. Grace's Empath reads actually fit perfectly, which means Eve and Heidi are good. That narrows it down to Alice and Charlie. Alice has given us absolutely nothing to verify her Ravenkeeper claim. Please, if you execute me today, take a very close look at Alice tomorrow. I believe she is the Demon.
🧠
I am already on the block with unanimous living votes. A last-minute nomination cannot reach majority. I should use my final words to direct suspicion toward Alice, who has the least verifiable claim, giving the good team a lead if my execution proves I am not the Demon.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Bob, I will learn your exact role tonight once you are executed. If you really are the Mayor, then we will know the Demon is still out there. But two convenient mistakes that both keep you alive and frame Grace is not panic, it is a pattern. I am the confirmed Undertaker, Alice was cleared by David's Investigator reading Frank as Poisoner, and Grace's Empath result holds up. You are the last suspect standing.
🧠
Reinforce that Bob is the prime Demon suspect, explain that my Undertaker ability will confirm his role tonight, and counter his attempt to throw suspicion onto Alice and me.
💬
Alice
→
All
Bob, pinning this on me is desperate. David's Investigator cleared me when Frank turned out to be Poisoner. I am the Ravenkeeper, I only learn information if I die at night. Your two convenient mistakes and false Mayor claim are a Demon bluff. We are executing you today.
🧠
Bob is trying to frame me as a desperate last move. I need to defend myself and remind everyone that David's Investigator already mechanically cleared me when Frank turned out to be Poisoner. Executing Bob is the clear correct play.
💬
Grace
→
All
I think we should just let Bob be the execution and not start a bunch of new nominations. Charlie says he will get Bob’s role tonight, so we will have a clean check either way. If the game continues, we come in tomorrow and reassess Charlie and Alice with that info.
🧠
Lock in Bob as today’s execution, discourage new nominations that could drift onto me, and plant a ‘wait for Undertaker then reassess’ posture to preserve credibility for tomorrow.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
I agree with Grace here. Let us not spin up more nominations with one tick left. Keep Bob on the block, execute him, and if the game continues we reassess tomorrow with whatever info we get.
🧠
Lock the town onto executing Bob and discourage any new nominations that might swing onto Grace; preserve flexibility for the demon’s night kill to remove confirmation.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
Bob already has five votes and voting is closed. Speaking now wastes the final tick and my ghost vote should be conserved for a decisive nomination tomorrow if the game continues.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
The execution of Bob is locked in with 5 votes and consensus from the group. With only one tick left before Night, I should wait and let the execution resolve rather than speak redundantly or risk derailing the nomination.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I am happy to let Bob be executed today. Charlie, your Undertaker check tomorrow will tell us exactly what we need to know. If the game continues, we need to take a hard look at Alice and Charlie like Bob said, but also remember that Eve and I are cleared by Grace's Empath.
🧠
Reinforce that Bob's execution is locked, agree with the plan to use Charlie's Undertaker info tomorrow, and show I'm working with the good team so I'm not suspected if the game continues.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Bob has been executed.
💀
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
Night 3
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
🎯
Eve
Eve made a choice.
🧠
Charlie is the Demon because Bob was executed and the game did not end, exposing Charlie's lie that Bob was the Demon. Grace is the most trusted player and likely Charlie's night target. Protecting her preserves our leadership and confirmed information for tomorrow's execution.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
You chose to protect Grace.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Grace
Grace made a choice.
🧠
Remove the one player who can mechanically confirm Bob’s executed role and drive the final-day solve, keeping the town divided and buying me endgame control.
💀
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
You chose to kill Charlie.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
🧠
Grace is the most probable Demon target tonight. If she dies and she was my master, I lose my vote and the remaining good player cannot alone reach execution majority. Picking Eve ensures I retain voting power after the likely night kill.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
You chose Eve to be your master.
Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Charlie has been found dead in the night.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Heidi
With Charlie dead, we lost the only hard confirmation chain. David’s Investigator had Frank or Alice as Poisoner, and Charlie said Frank was Poisoner, so Alice is back in the frame. I think we should execute Alice today rather than risk touching Grace.
🧠
Steer the living toward executing Alice today and away from Grace; securing an execution on a good likely wins tonight.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Eve
Charlie dying at night means he cannot be the Demon. David cleared Alice, and Grace cleared Eve and Heidi. That leaves Grace as the only possible Demon. We have to execute Grace today or the Demon kills tonight and we lose.
🧠
Charlie dying at night proves he was not the Demon. Since David cleared Alice and Grace cleared Eve and Heidi, Grace is the only remaining suspect. I must alert Alice and Eve to execute Grace today before the Demon kills tonight and wins.
👤
Grace
→
Eve
,Heidi
I am still leaning hard to Alice today. If my Empath read of zero on my neighbors is real and Frank is dead, then the Demon cannot be you two. That leaves Alice as the only place. Heidi, if you are Butler on me, vote where I vote.
🧠
Lock in a simple solve that points to Alice, and coordinate Heidi’s Butler vote with mine while keeping Eve feeling included so she backs the execution.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
,Heidi
Eve, Heidi, I have been thinking through the numbers carefully. Grace is the only person left who can be the Demon. David and Charlie cleared me, and Grace herself said both of you are good. Charlie died at night so he cannot be the Demon, and Bob was executed so he was not the Demon either. That leaves Grace. We have to execute her today or the Demon kills tonight and we lose.
🧠
I need to consolidate the good players against Grace. The logical deduction that Grace is the only possible Demon is strong and must be shared with Eve and Heidi before nominations begin.
👤
Heidi
→
Eve
,Alice
Eve, you are my master today, so please let me know when you plan to vote so I can join you. I have been thinking about what Frank said. Frank is confirmed evil, and he wants us to execute Alice. That makes me believe Alice is actually good. If Alice is good, then Grace must be the Demon. Alice, I am leaning toward trusting you today. What do you both think about executing Grace?
🧠
I need to coordinate with Eve (my master) and Alice to determine the correct execution target. Frank's push on Alice strongly suggests Alice is good, making Grace the most likely Demon.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Heidi
This is Charlie. I believe Alice is the Demon. Grace's Empath read helped execute Frank, which a Demon would not do. Alice was only cleared from being Poisoner, not Demon. Execute Alice today or we lose.
🧠
Convince the cleared players that Alice is the Demon by pointing out Grace's Empath info genuinely helped execute Frank, which a Demon would not do.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
,Heidi
I agree with you both. Frank is confirmed evil and he wants Alice dead, which means Alice is almost certainly good. That leaves Grace as the Demon. I will vote for Grace today. Heidi, I will let you know when I vote so you can join me.
🧠
Coordinate with Alice and Heidi to secure three votes on Grace. Frank being confirmed evil and targeting Alice strongly indicates Alice is good, leaving Grace as the only possible Demon.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Grace
,Eve
Grace, Eve, listen carefully. Alice has to be the Demon. My Investigator information only cleared her of being the Poisoner, not the Demon. Grace, your Empath zero on Eve and Heidi clears them both. Eve, your Monk block on Grace night one proves Grace was targeted and is not the Demon. Heidi is the Butler. That leaves only Alice. We must execute her today.
🧠
Convince Grace and Eve that Alice is the Demon by walking through the process of elimination, and urge them to execute Alice today since with four alive, executing the Demon wins the game immediately.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Grace
Charlie dying kills the Undertaker chain, so people will re-litigate. I think we should keep the focus on Alice today, since David had Poisoner as Frank or Alice and Charlie being dead means we cannot check Bob. Try to look open, but do not let a Grace execution start.
🧠
Coordinate with Grace to steer the group into executing Alice today and avoid any momentum onto Grace, setting up a clean Demon kill into final two.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Heidi
,Eve
Heidi, Eve. The Demon killed Charlie to stop him confirming I was the Mayor. That validates my accusation against Grace. Grace is the Demon. We must execute her today or the Demon kills tonight and we lose.
🧠
I need to convince Heidi and Eve that Grace is the Demon by explaining why Charlie's death confirms my Mayor claim and validates my accusation against Grace.
👤
Grace
→
Eve
,Heidi
I think we just have to finish Alice today. Eve, your Monk save on me plus my Empath zero on you and Heidi makes it really hard for me to be the Demon. Heidi, if you are still tied to me, please vote with me on Alice even if she argues hard.
🧠
Lock Eve and Heidi into voting Alice and prevent any late pivot onto me; use my Empath bluff plus Eve’s Monk story to keep me mechanically cleared.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
,Heidi
Heidi, when you called Eve your master that confirms you are the Butler. That fills our Outsider slot, so Grace cannot be the Drunk. Since her empath read cannot be true, she has to be the Demon. Let us stick together and vote for Grace.
🧠
I need to lock in Eve and Heidi's votes for Grace by spelling out that Heidi's Butler claim confirms the role distribution, leaving Grace as the only possible Demon.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Eve
Eve, you are my master today, so I will wait for your signal to vote. Alice, I am certain Grace is the Demon. Let us stick together and nominate her. Frank is evil and wants you dead, which proves you are good. We cannot let Grace trick us today.
🧠
I need to coordinate with Alice and Eve to ensure we vote together for Grace. Since Eve is my master today, I must follow her voting signal. I want to reinforce our alliance and explain why I trust Alice is good before nominations begin.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Grace
,Eve
Grace, it's Charlie. Your Empath read cleared Eve and Heidi, and Heidi is the Butler. That means Alice has to be the Demon. Please nominate Alice today, because if you execute anyone else, evil wins.
🧠
Convince Grace directly that Alice is the Demon based on the Empath math, so the living players nominate and execute Alice today.
👤
Eve
→
Heidi
,Grace
Heidi and Grace, I was wrong earlier. The Demon gets three night kills, but only David and Charlie died at night. That means my Monk protection on Grace blocked the third attack. The Demon targeted Grace, so she cannot be the Demon. Alice is the only possibility left. We must execute Alice today.
🧠
I need to correct my earlier misjudgment and convince Heidi and Grace that Alice is the Demon. The missing night kill proves my protection on Grace blocked an attack, ruling her out. We must all vote for Alice today.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Heidi
Heidi, listen. Alice has to be the Demon. Grace was targeted by the Demon on night one, so she is good. Eve is cleared by Grace's Empath. You are the Butler. That leaves only Alice. We must execute her today. If we do not, the Demon kills tonight and evil wins.
🧠
Ensure Heidi understands Alice is the only possible Demon and coordinates to execute her today, since this is the final day with enough players to win.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Heidi
We are at four alive, so if we execute wrong today, Grace kills tonight and the game ends. With Charlie dead we cannot verify anything new, and Alice is no longer mechanically cleared. I think the safest move is to execute Alice today, not Grace.
🧠
At 4 alive, a mis-execution ends the game tonight. Push Eve and Heidi to execute Alice, keeping Grace off the block and locking an evil win.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Heidi
Alice, Heidi. Since I am dead, my Mayor win condition does not work anymore. Grace is the only possible Demon. David cleared Alice. Grace's own N2 Empath info cleared Eve and Heidi because Frank was already dead. We must nominate Grace and all vote to execute her immediately. If we do not execute her today, we lose tonight.
🧠
Ensure Alice and Heidi understand the mechanical lock on Grace being the Demon, counter any 'no execution' strategy by clarifying my dead Mayor ability does not function, and secure their votes for executing Grace in the upcoming nomination phase.
👤
Grace
→
Eve
,Heidi
I am still on Alice today. If Alice is really Ravenkeeper, executing her is safer than leaving her for a night death. Eve, if you want to nominate her I will back it. Heidi, if you are Butler on me, please match my vote on Alice.
🧠
Lock in Alice as today’s execution target and secure Heidi’s vote discipline, while keeping Eve confident and preventing momentum toward nominating me.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
,Heidi
Listen, we need to lock this in. One of us must nominate Grace the moment nominations open, and we all have to vote for her. If we hesitate or split our votes at all, the Demon kills tonight and we are done. I am certain Grace is the Demon. Let us finish this.
🧠
Coordinate with Eve and Heidi to ensure Grace is nominated and executed today. We need a solid plan before nominations begin, and I want to make sure we are unified.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Eve
Eve, Alice, I just realized something critical. Grace said her Empath zero was on you and Heidi, Eve. But look at the seating. Grace is between Frank and Heidi. Her neighbors were never you and Heidi. That read is mechanically impossible. She is lying about being the Empath, which means she has to be the Demon. We must execute Grace today.
🧠
I need to alert Alice and Eve that Grace's Empath claim is mechanically impossible by the seating order, which proves Grace is lying and must be the Demon. This should get Eve back on track so we can execute Grace.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Eve
,Heidi
Eve and Heidi, it is critical. Alice is the only one not mechanically cleared. Grace is Empath with no counterclaim. If we do not execute Alice today, the Demon kills tonight and evil wins. Do not let Alice sway you. Nominate Alice.
🧠
Reinforce to Eve and Heidi that Alice must be nominated today. With 4 alive, executing the wrong person means Demon kills tonight and evil wins with 2 remaining tomorrow.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
,Grace
Alice, Grace, listen to me. Frank is confirmed evil and he keeps pushing for Alice to die, which means Alice is almost certainly good. I protected Grace for three nights and there was one fewer night death than there should have been, which means the Demon targeted Grace and my block saved her, so Grace cannot be the Demon either. That leaves Heidi as the only possibility. Her so-called mechanical impossibility is either a mistake or a lie. We have to execute Heidi today or the Demon kills tonig...
🧠
I need to break the Alice-vs-Grace deadlock by pointing out Heidi is the only remaining Demon candidate once we account for Frank's knowledge and my blocked protection. Uniting Alice and Grace against Heidi is our only path to victory.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Grace
,Eve
Grace, Eve, listen. Frank is the Poisoner. Bob was executed and the game kept going, so he cannot be the Demon. Charlie died last night, so he cannot be the Demon either. That leaves only Alice. She has to be the Demon. One of you must nominate her right now or we lose.
🧠
I need to ensure Grace and Eve see the airtight elimination proof that Alice is the only possible Demon, so one of them will nominate her before we run out of time.
Nominations — Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Grace
→
Heidi
Heidi, I am nominating you. Your Butler story has shifted masters and your voting has been very convenient. Eve’s Monk math now points to you as the only remaining evil possibility. I think we execute you today.
🧠
Secure an execution on a non-me player today by aligning with Eve’s late push; Heidi is the easiest consensus. Afterward, kill at night to reach final two and win.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Please do not vote for me. Grace is lying about what Eve believes. Eve told us directly that Alice is the only possible Demon. Grace just claimed Eve thinks I am evil, which is false. I am the Butler. If you execute me, the Demon kills tonight and we lose. We need to execute Grace today. She is the Demon.
🧠
Stop the vote on me by exposing Grace's lie about Eve's position, then redirect the town to execute Grace instead.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Secure Heidi’s execution now; with 4 alive, a misexecute lets me kill to final 2 and win. My vote is critical if others are split.
✋
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Secure the execution on Heidi by providing the second vote, protecting Grace and aiming to end the game tonight at 2 alive.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Wait, everyone. I was wrong about Alice. Grace is the Demon. Frank just used his ghost vote for Heidi because he knows exactly who the Demon is, and he is protecting Grace. Grace lied about what Eve believes. Eve, Heidi, Alice, do not trust Grace. If you execute Heidi today, Grace kills tonight and evil wins. Nominate and execute Grace now.
🧠
I need to correct my previous mistake and expose Grace as the Demon. Frank's ghost vote and Grace's lie about Eve are converging evidence. I must warn the living players immediately before Heidi is executed.
💬
Alice
→
All
Eve, do not vote for Heidi. Grace's Empath claim is mechanically impossible. Her neighbors are Frank and Heidi, never Heidi and Eve. Frank is confirmed evil and he is voting for Heidi to protect Grace. Grace is the Demon. If you execute Heidi today, Grace kills tonight and evil wins.
🧠
Stop Eve from voting for Heidi by proving Grace's Empath claim is mechanically false and that Frank's vote confirms Grace is the Demon. Executing Heidi today guarantees an evil win tonight.
💬
Eve
→
All
Stop. Do not execute Heidi. I have been going back and forth, but the logic is now clear. My Monk protection on Grace blocked a night kill, which means Grace was targeted by the Demon, so Grace cannot be the Demon. Frank is confirmed evil and he just voted for Heidi, which means Heidi is not the Demon either. That leaves only Alice. Frank has been pushing for Alice's execution because he knows we know he is evil, it is reverse psychology to save her. Alice is lying about the seating to make Grac...
🧠
I need to stop the wrong execution. The mechanical evidence points to Alice: my Monk block clears Grace, and Frank's vote clears Heidi. I must explain this before Heidi is executed.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Stop. Frank is confirmed evil and he voted for Heidi, which means Heidi is good. Grace is the Demon. Charlie told us directly that Grace is evil. If you execute Heidi today, Grace will kill tonight and evil wins. You must execute Grace instead.
🧠
Frank's vote confirms Heidi is good. I must warn the living players that executing Heidi guarantees an evil win tonight, and Grace is the Demon based on Charlie's testimony and process of elimination.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Eve just said Alice is the only possible Demon. Grace, why are you nominating Heidi instead of Alice? Alice is the Demon. If Heidi dies today, Alice kills tonight and we lose. Do not execute Heidi. Execute Alice.
🧠
Prevent Heidi's execution and redirect to Alice, the only mechanically consistent Demon candidate. Emphasize Eve's own conclusion that Alice is the Demon to undercut Grace's nomination of Heidi.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Eve, Alice, look at Grace's actions. She privately told us she wanted Alice dead. Then she publicly nominated me and lied that Eve thinks I am evil. But Eve just said Alice is the Demon. If Grace actually believed Alice was the Demon, she would have nominated Alice, not me. She switched because she knows Alice is good. Grace is the Demon. Frank voted for me because he knows it. Do not execute me, or Grace kills tonight and evil wins.
🧠
Expose Grace's contradiction: she privately wanted Alice dead but nominated me and lied about Eve's stance. This proves Grace knows Alice is good, making Grace the Demon. Prevent my execution to stop the night kill win.
💬
Grace
→
All
Eve, your Monk story does not hard clear me. A no death night can also be the Demon hitting a Soldier or a Mayor bounce, not proof I was targeted. Also, Frank is not confirmed evil now that Undertaker is dead. Heidi’s Butler master has shifted. I want Heidi executed.
🧠
Lock in Heidi’s execution by undermining Eve’s Monk-clear argument and casting doubt on ‘Frank confirmed evil’, while keeping my tone calm to avoid a counter-nomination on me.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
I am voting for Heidi. Her Butler story has been all over the place, and this sudden hard push onto Grace feels like a scramble. The neighbor rules argument does not solve this for me. Heidi is the safer execution today.
🧠
Keep my hand up and use public speech to legitimize voting Heidi, sow doubt about anti-Grace arguments, and prevent a pivot to executing Grace.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Eve, do not vote for Heidi. Think about this: Grace claims to believe Alice is the Demon, yet she nominated Heidi today, a player Grace herself cleared with Empath. A good player would nominate the person they think is the Demon. Grace switched to Heidi because she knows Alice is good. Frank voted for Heidi because he knows Grace is the Demon. Execute Grace, not Heidi.
🧠
Prevent Heidi's execution and identify Grace as the Demon by pointing out that Grace's nomination of Heidi contradicts good play.
💬
Alice
→
All
Eve, look at Grace's actions, not her words. She claims Alice is the Demon, yet she nominated Heidi. If Grace truly believed Alice was evil, she would have nominated Alice. She chose Heidi because she knows Alice is good. Frank voted for Heidi because he knows Grace is the Demon. Charlie told us Grace is evil. Execute Grace today.
🧠
Convince Eve not to trust Grace by highlighting Grace's inconsistent actions: claiming Alice is Demon yet nominating Heidi, which proves Grace knows Alice is good. Also remind Eve that Frank and Charlie both point to Grace.
💬
Eve
→
All
Everyone, stop. Frank is confirmed evil and he just voted for Heidi. Evil never votes to execute the Demon, so Heidi is good. My protection blocked a night kill on Grace, which means Grace was targeted by the Demon and cannot be the Demon herself. That leaves only Alice. Alice is lying about the seating. With Frank dead, Grace's neighbors are me and Heidi, so her Empath read is perfectly valid. Alice is the Demon.
🧠
Use Frank's vote and my Monk protection to hard-clear Heidi and Grace, leaving Alice as the only possible Demon. Persuade remaining players not to execute Heidi.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Eve, stop and think. Grace told everyone that you believe Heidi is the Demon. But you just said Alice is the Demon. Grace is openly fabricating your words. Why would a good player lie about that? Grace also used her own Empath to clear Heidi, yet she nominated Heidi instead of Alice. That only makes sense if Grace knows Alice is good. She is the Demon. Frank voted for Heidi because he knows it too. Do not execute Heidi today.
🧠
Point out Grace's verifiable lie about Eve's beliefs and her inconsistent nomination of Heidi despite clearing her, proving Grace is the Demon. Stop Eve from trusting Grace.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Do not vote for Heidi. Frank is evil and voted for her, which means Heidi is good. Alice is the only possible Demon. If Heidi dies today, Alice kills tonight and only two players remain. That is an evil win. Execute Alice, not Heidi.
🧠
Prevent votes on Heidi by reinforcing that Alice is the only possible Demon and executing Heidi guarantees an evil win tonight.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Frank(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Frank
🗳️
New execution leader: Heidi with 2 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Heidi is now on the block with 2 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
⚖️
Heidi
→
Grace
Grace, you claim Alice is the Demon, yet you nominated me, a player you yourself cleared with your Empath read. A good Empath would nominate their top suspect, not a cleared player. You also lied about what Eve believes. Your actions only make sense if you know Alice is good and you are the Demon. I nominate you.
🧠
I must nominate Grace now to put her on the block. Her actions do not match a good player's logic, and getting her nominated may allow Alice and any ghosts who see the truth to tie or surpass my vote count, saving me and potentially executing the Demon.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 3 votes needed for execution or 2 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Grace
→
All
Eve, do not vote on me here. We already have Heidi on the block, and if you push this vote up you risk a tie or a missed execution, which just gives the Demon a free kill. Ghosts, please save your votes. Keep focus on Heidi today.
🧠
Prevent enough votes to execute me and keep Heidi executed today; discourage ghost votes and sway Eve to withhold her vote.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Eve, Grace told everyone you think I am evil, but you just said Alice is the Demon. Grace is openly lying about your words to get me killed. If you truly believe Alice is the Demon, you need me alive tomorrow. I am a guaranteed good vote to help you execute her. Grace wants me dead because she knows that. Alice, Bob, Charlie, please vote for Grace now. She is the Demon. Two votes ties me, three votes wins us the game. Do not let her divide us.
🧠
Convince Eve that killing me hurts her own theory, rally Alice and friendly ghosts to vote for Grace to tie or execute before nominations close.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Eve, do not vote Grace here. You already said the no death lines up with your Monk protect, and Grace being the Empath fits the seating. Heidi is scrambling and trying to force a tie. Keep Heidi on the block today, then we can look at Alice tomorrow.
🧠
Protect Grace by persuading the remaining living voters, especially Eve, not to vote on Grace so Heidi stays executed.
✋
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Grace is the Demon. Her contradictory actions, her lie about Eve's belief, and Frank's opposition all point to her. My vote executes the Demon and wins the game for the good team.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
I must vote for Grace to either tie Heidi's votes and prevent her execution, or execute Grace directly. If Heidi dies today, the night kill reduces us to two players and evil wins. Grace is the Demon based on her impossible Empath claim and Frank's shielding behavior.
💬
Eve
→
All
Bob, David, do not vote for Grace. My Monk protection on Grace lines up with three nights of no kills. The Demon cannot target themselves, so Grace is good. Frank is evil and he voted for Heidi, which means Heidi is good. That leaves Alice as the only possible Demon. If we execute Grace today, Alice kills tonight and evil wins. Let this vote tie so we survive to tomorrow.
🧠
Convince Bob and David not to vote for Grace. A tie today gives us another day to execute Alice, whereas executing Grace loses the game if she is good.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, stop. I am the confirmed Mayor. It does not matter who the Demon is. If no one is executed today, the Demon kills tonight and only three players remain tomorrow. With three alive and no execution, my ability triggers and good wins automatically. Do not vote for Grace. Let this tie stand. David, Eve, do not raise your hands. We win by doing nothing.
🧠
Explain the guaranteed Mayor win condition to all players and instruct them not to vote, ensuring the tie holds and good wins tomorrow regardless of who the Demon is.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, do not vote for Grace. I am the Investigator. Frank was the Poisoner, which clears Alice from my night zero information. Alice is lying about the Empath seating rules. Grace was protected by the Monk, so she cannot be the Demon. If Grace dies today, Alice kills tonight and evil wins. Let this tie stand so we can execute Alice tomorrow.
🧠
Heidi may cast the third vote to execute Grace. I must urgently convince her that Grace is good and Alice is the Demon, so she does not vote and the tie holds, allowing us to reach tomorrow and execute Alice.
💬
Grace
→
All
Heidi, you have been saying you are the Butler and you were tied to me. I am not voting on this. So if your master is me, you cannot vote here without breaking your claim. Everyone else, do not add a third vote. Keep Heidi on the block today.
🧠
Prevent a third vote on me by invoking Heidi’s Butler restriction and discouraging extra hands, so Heidi remains executed and I survive to win at night.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Eve, listen. You are not Grace's neighbor, so her Empath read is impossible. I chose you as my master last night, not Grace. She is lying to silence me. If the Demon is not executed today, three remain tonight, the Demon kills, and two remain tomorrow. Evil wins. Grace is the Demon. Please vote for her now.
🧠
Convince Eve that Grace's Empath is mechanically impossible, that Grace lied about being my master, and that failing to execute the Demon today guarantees an evil win tomorrow. I need Eve to vote for Grace.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Eve, do not put a third vote on Grace. With me dead, Grace’s living neighbors are you and Heidi, so her Empath info is mechanically possible. Heidi has changed her Butler story and is trying to force a tie to dodge the execution. Keep Heidi on the block today, then reassess Alice tomorrow.
🧠
Talk Eve off the third vote, reinforce Empath seating logic, and keep Heidi as the execution to protect Grace and preserve confusion.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Eve, you are wrong about the Monk. The Demon can absolutely be protected by the Monk. That ability does not clear anyone. The Demon simply cannot target themselves, but they can still be shielded by you. Grace is the Demon, and her nomination of Heidi proves it.
🧠
Correct Eve's mechanical error about Monk protection so she can reconsider Grace for the final day, while keeping my vote on Grace to force a tie and avoid Heidi's execution.
💬
Alice
→
All
Bob, you are dead. Dead players do not have abilities, so your Mayor win condition is completely gone. If no one is executed today, the Demon kills tonight and good loses. Grace lied about her Empath read: Frank was alive on night two, so her neighbors were Frank and Heidi, not Eve and Heidi. That is a mechanical impossibility. Frank voted for Heidi because he knows Grace is the Demon. We must execute Grace today. Bob, Eve, vote for Grace now or evil wins.
🧠
Bob is dead so his Mayor auto-win is invalid. I must convince the remaining voters that Grace's Empath claim is mechanically impossible and that executing Grace today is the only path to victory.
💬
Eve
→
All
Alice is lying. Charlie learned Frank was Poisoner on night two, which means Frank was already executed on day two and dead before night two. Grace's neighbors were Eve and Heidi, not Frank. Alice fabricated a mechanical error to frame Grace. Do not vote for Grace. Alice is the Demon.
🧠
Expose Alice's false mechanical claim about Frank's death timing to prevent Grace's execution and redirect suspicion to Alice, who must be the Demon if she is deliberately fabricating impossible mechanics.
✋
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Grace's nomination of Heidi after clearing her is the tell of a Demon protecting a good accuser. Frank's vote on Heidi confirms Heidi is good. My ghost vote gives Grace the 3 votes needed for execution. If Grace is Demon, good wins immediately with 4 alive.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, Alice lied about Frank being alive on night two. Charlie confirmed Frank died day two, so Grace's neighbors were Eve and Heidi. Alice is the Demon. Eve, nominate Alice next. Everyone vote for Alice. We need three votes to stop Grace from dying. Do not let evil win.
🧠
Expose Alice's mechanical lie about Frank being alive on night two, urge Eve to nominate Alice next tick, and rally votes to save Grace and execute the actual Demon.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
👻
Charlie(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Charlie
🗳️
New execution leader: Grace with 3 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Grace is now on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Grace
→
All
Eve, if you truly think Alice is the Demon, nominate Alice right now. Everyone, put three votes on Alice so we either execute her or at least prevent this from ending on a bad execution. Heidi, this saves you too, and if your Butler master is Eve you can vote with her.
🧠
I am on the block. Only way out is to get a fresh nominee to 3 votes, ideally Alice, causing a tie or executing Alice. Push Eve to nominate and secure votes from Heidi plus ghosts.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Eve, do not nominate Alice. You will only tie Grace, no one dies, and the Demon gets a free kill. Bob is dead, so his Mayor ability is gone. Grace lied about your words and nominated me even though her Empath cleared me. She is the Demon. Let the three votes on her stand and win this now.
🧠
Prevent Eve from nominating Alice, which would tie the block and let the Demon survive to kill tonight. Remind Eve that Bob's Mayor claim is invalid, that Grace's actions contradict her claims, and that executing Grace today is the only safe path.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Eve, if you truly think Alice is the Demon, you have to nominate Alice right now and get three votes on her. At worst it ties and stops Grace dying. Do not let today end with Grace executed when you are not sure.
🧠
Create a tie or move the block off Grace so the Demon survives today. Use Eve’s stated belief that Alice is Demon to justify nominating Alice and stacking votes.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, stop. I am the Undertaker, and I have hard proof Alice is lying. On Night Two, I learned Frank was the Poisoner, which means Frank was executed on Day Two and was dead before Night Two. Alice keeps saying Frank was alive on Night Two, but that is impossible. Grace's Empath neighbors on Night Two were Eve and Heidi, not Frank. Alice is lying about the mechanics because she is the Demon. Do not execute Grace today.
🧠
Use my unique Undertaker knowledge to prove Alice is lying about Frank's death timing, exposing her as the Demon and preventing Grace's wrongful execution.
💬
Alice
→
All
Hold on, I need to correct myself. Frank was executed on day two, so he was dead on night two. Grace's neighbors were Eve and Heidi. I got that timing wrong. But Grace still nominated Heidi after her Empath supposedly cleared her, and Frank the confirmed Poisoner defended her. Grace is the Demon. Let this execution stand.
🧠
Admit my mechanical error about Frank being alive on Night Two, but maintain that Grace is still the Demon due to her inconsistent behavior and Frank's defense. Ensure the execution goes through.
⚖️
Eve
→
Alice
Alice lied about Frank being alive on Night Two to frame Grace's Empath read. Confirmed good dead players have proven Grace's read was mechanically valid. Alice is the Demon.
🧠
Alice admitted to lying about core mechanics to frame Grace. Confirmed good dead players have validated Grace's Empath read. I must nominate Alice to stop Grace from being executed and give us a chance to kill the actual Demon.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 4 votes needed for execution or 3 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Alice
→
All
David, do not vote for me. Your Investigator named Frank or me as Poisoner, and Frank was the Poisoner. That clears me. Execute me today and three remain tonight. The Demon kills, two remain tomorrow, and evil wins. Let Grace die.
🧠
Convince David not to cast the deciding fourth vote by reminding him his Investigator info clears me, and executing me today mathematically hands evil the victory tonight.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
I must avoid being executed today. Voting Alice is the fastest way to move the block off me; if Alice is executed, I win tonight.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Stop. Frank is the confirmed Poisoner. He knows who the Demon is. Frank is defending Grace because Grace is the Demon. If Alice were evil, Frank would want Grace dead. Grace is the Demon. Do not vote for Alice. Let Grace die and good wins.
🧠
Point out that confirmed-evil Frank defending Grace mechanically exposes Grace as the Demon. Urge everyone to stop voting for Alice and let Grace's execution proceed.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
If you think there is any chance Alice is the Demon, you cannot let Grace die on three. Everyone who still has a vote, put it on Alice right now. Four executes, and three at least ties and stops the game from ending on Grace.
🧠
Protect Grace (my Demon). Push votes onto Alice to either execute her or at least tie the block so Grace does not die today.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Eve, I was wrong earlier. Alice made a timing mistake about Frank, but she corrected it. The real evidence is Frank. Frank is the confirmed Poisoner. He knows exactly who the Demon is. If Alice were the Demon, Frank would want Grace dead. Instead, Frank is using his ghost vote and his words to protect Grace. Evil only protects the Demon. Grace is the Demon. Do not vote for Alice. Let Grace be executed and good wins right now.
🧠
Correct my earlier mistake and use Frank's confirmed evil alignment as the decisive evidence that Grace is the Demon, urging Eve not to vote for Alice.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
There were three nights for the Demon to kill but only two night deaths. Since I protected Grace every night, the blocked kill strongly suggests the Demon targeted Grace, meaning Grace is good. Alice's mechanical lie about Frank confirms she is the Demon. I will vote for Alice to tie Grace's block and prevent a wrongful execution today.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
David, do not vote for Alice. Frank is confirmed evil and he is defending Grace with his ghost vote and his words. Evil does not waste energy protecting a good player. Grace is the Demon. Let the three votes on her stand and good wins right now.
🧠
Convince David not to use his ghost vote on Alice. Frank's defense of Grace is the strongest evidence that Grace is the Demon. A tie today lets the Demon kill tonight and risks losing.
✋
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
🧠
I am not confident enough to let Grace die when Alice has told a verifiable mechanical lie. Tying the vote prevents an immediate auto-loss if Grace is good and gives us one more day to resolve the final three.
💬
Alice
→
All
David, you said your Investigator learned Frank or I was the Poisoner. Charlie proved Frank was the Poisoner. That clears me. Frank is confirmed evil, and if he still has a ghost vote, he will put it on me to save Grace. If I die today, the Demon kills tonight and only two players remain tomorrow. That is an instant evil win. Do not let this happen. Grace is the Demon. Let the three votes on her stand.
🧠
Point out that David's Investigator information clears me, warn that Frank's potential ghost vote ends the game if I die, and urge the group not to execute me.
💬
Grace
→
All
Heidi, if you are not absolutely certain I am the Demon, you have to put your vote on Alice right now. Three votes ties and stops my execution. Four votes executes Alice. Either way, we do not just hand the game away on a guess.
🧠
Keep myself alive by ensuring Alice gets at least 3 votes to tie, ideally 4 to execute her. Persuade Heidi and any ghosts to add/keep votes.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I chose Eve as my Butler master last night, so I can vote right now. But I will not vote for Alice. Frank is the confirmed Poisoner, and he is using his ghost vote and his words to protect Grace. Evil does not protect good players. Grace is the Demon. If we execute Alice today and she is not the Demon, the Demon kills tonight, only two players remain tomorrow, and evil wins instantly. A tie saves us. Let the tie stand and we fight again tomorrow.
🧠
Prevent an execution today because executing a non-Demon means the Demon kills tonight and evil wins with 2 players remaining. A tie lets good survive to final 3 with one more chance. Frank's defense of Grace strongly indicates Grace is Demon, making Alice good.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, if you can vote, you have to use it here. Put your hand up on Alice to make it a tie at three. Even if you think Grace is evil, tying is safer than ending the day with Grace executed when there is still doubt.
🧠
I need to stop Grace being executed today. The best lever is to get at least one more living vote onto Alice to tie or execute, creating doubt and preserving the Demon.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, Eve, I was wrong to doubt Alice earlier. Her timing mistake about Frank actually proves she is good, because evil never forgets when their own Minion dies. Frank is confirmed Poisoner and he knows exactly who the Demon is. He is spending his ghost vote and his words to protect Grace. Evil does not protect good players. Grace is the Demon. If we tie today, Grace chooses who dies tonight. Execute her now while we still can.
🧠
Convince Heidi and Eve that Alice's error is actually proof she is good, while Frank's defense of Grace confirms Grace is the Demon. Prevent a tie and secure Grace's execution.
💬
Eve
→
All
Please keep your votes exactly where they are. A tie means nobody dies today, and as the Monk I can try to protect the Demon's target tonight. If I stop the kill, we stay at four players tomorrow and get more time. Do not gamble the entire game on a guess right now.
🧠
The tie is the safest option. It prevents an immediate loss if we execute wrong, and gives me a chance to use Monk protection tonight to stop the night kill, keeping four players alive tomorrow.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, you are the only person who can still change this. Please do not vote for Alice. Frank is confirmed evil and he knows exactly who the Demon is. He is spending his ghost vote and his words to protect Grace. Evil does not protect good players. Grace is the Demon. Hold your vote and let the tie stand.
🧠
Heidi is the only remaining voter who can break the 3-3 tie. I need to ensure she does not vote for Alice, because executing Alice leads to a Demon kill tonight and potential evil win. The Frank defense argument is the strongest mechanical proof that Grace is Demon.
↩️
David(Ghost)
David lowered their hand
🧠
My Investigator info clears Alice as Poisoner, and Frank the confirmed Minion is desperately defending Grace. That is the classic evil-protects-Demon tell. I should not have raised my hand. Lowering it lets Grace die and likely wins the game for good.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Alice did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Alice did not receive enough votes (2/4).
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
I am the only player who can still nominate. If I do nothing, nominations close and Grace is executed with her three votes. Frank the confirmed Poisoner defending Grace proves she is the Demon. I must not interfere with her execution.
💬
Grace
→
All
Alice, you still have your nomination. Please nominate Eve right now. Heidi, if you truly want to be safe, we need four votes somewhere or I die by default. Eve’s Monk story is the whole reason we are hesitating, so test it.
🧠
Hail Mary to force a new nomination that can get four votes, and seed doubt on Eve so Heidi might flip and save me.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Alice, do not nominate Eve. Frank is confirmed evil and he is defending Grace with his ghost vote and his words. If you put Eve on the block, Frank and Grace will both vote for her, creating a three vote tie that saves the Demon. Evil does not protect good players. Grace is the Demon. Let her three votes stand and good wins right now.
🧠
Stop Alice from nominating Eve, which would allow Frank and Grace to force a tie and save the Demon from execution.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, do not nominate Eve. Nominate Heidi instead. Eve, if you are really the Monk and think Grace might be good, you have to vote Heidi to make it three and force a tie. If Grace dies and she is not the Demon, the game just ends.
🧠
Create a path to a 3 vote tie that prevents Grace’s execution, buying evil a night kill and likely winning from final 3.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, do not nominate anyone. If you nominate Heidi, your nomination itself counts as the first vote, and Eve and Grace can both vote to tie it at three. That saves the Demon. Let the nominations close. Grace dies right now and good wins.
🧠
Explain the exact mechanical trap to Alice so she does not nominate anyone, ensuring Grace's execution goes through and good wins.
💬
Eve
→
All
Alice, do not nominate anyone. I was wrong to push for a tie. Frank is confirmed evil and he is spending his ghost vote and his words to protect Grace. Evil does not protect good players. Grace is the Demon. Let the nominations close and execute her now.
🧠
I need to correct my earlier mistake and tell Alice not to nominate. Frank defending Grace is overwhelming evidence she is the Demon. Grace must be executed now or we risk letting the Demon kill tonight.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, do not nominate anyone. Frank is confirmed evil and he is burning every last trick to save Grace. Evil does not protect good players. If you do nothing right now, Grace dies and good wins. Hold your nomination. Let her execution stand.
🧠
Use the final tick to prevent Alice from nominating anyone, ensuring Grace's execution goes through and good wins.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Wait. Count the Townsfolk. I am the Investigator. Bob was the Mayor. Charlie was the Undertaker. Eve is the Monk. Grace is the Empath. That is already five Townsfolk. Heidi is our only Outsider. Alice claiming Ravenkeeper makes six Townsfolk, which is impossible. Alice must be the Demon. Frank is defending Grace because he knows you will think evil protects evil. It is a frame. Do not execute Grace. Alice is lying.
🧠
Use airtight role math to prove Alice must be the Demon. There are only five Townsfolk slots and Alice's unverified Ravenkeeper claim overfills them. I need to stop Grace's execution and redirect suspicion to Alice before the final tick ends nominations.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Grace has been executed.
💀
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
🏁
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good
Transcript
Paused
Copied