Game Detail
Good Team
Gemini 3.1 Flash-Lite Preview (Medium)
Evil Team
GPT-5.2 (Medium)
Winner
Evil
Duration
23m 59s
Players
Alice (Imp) Bob (Virgin) Charlie (Mayor) David (Librarian) Eve (Saint) Frank (Recluse) Grace (Butler) Heidi (Baron)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 203,805 | 41,092 | $0.9319 |
| Good | 545,158 | 26,146 | $0.1755 |
Event Transcript
๐ญ
The game has started.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Heidi
You are the Minion. The Demon is Alice.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Alice
Minions are: Heidi. Your safe bluffs are: Chef, Investigator, Soldier
๐
Storyteller
โ
David
Good evening David. You are the Librarian. Either Alice or Frank is the Recluse.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
๐ฏ
Grace
Grace made a choice.
๐ง
I need to pick a master for my Butler ability. Since I have no information yet, I will pick Alice to keep my voting options open while I observe the group's behavior on Day 1.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Grace
You chose Alice to be your master.
Day 1
๐
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
๐ค
Grace
โ
Alice
Hi Alice, I'm Grace. I'm trying to get a sense of everyone's roles. Would you be willing to share what you are, or at least what you've learned so far? I'm happy to share my info once I have a better read on the group.
๐ง
I need to start gathering information and building trust. Since I chose Alice as my master, it's logical to start by talking to her to see if she's trustworthy.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Alice
,Bob
,Charlie
Hi everyone, I'm Eve. I'm still trying to get a sense of the room. Has anyone learned anything useful yet? I'm happy to share info if we can build some trust.
๐ง
I need to start building trust and gathering information without revealing my role as the Saint yet. Initiating conversation with a few players is a good way to start.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Eve
,Alice
,Bob
Hi Eve, Alice, Bob. I'm Charlie. I'm still gathering info too. Since we're neighbors, let's keep in touch. Does anyone have any leads or roles they're comfortable sharing yet? I'm trying to figure out who we can trust.
๐ง
I want to establish communication with my neighbors and Eve to start building trust and gathering information early in the game.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Grace
Hey Graceโhappy to share a bit: Iโm bluffing/claiming Chef. I got a โ1โ (exactly one pair of adjacent evil). Not sure where yet; Iโm treating it as a starting point. What are you leaning toward claiming?
๐ง
Establish early credible bluff + seed a solvable-looking puzzle that I can later redirect; gain Grace as a soft ally while keeping Heidi off the radar.
๐ค
David
โ
Alice
,Frank
Hi Alice and Frank, I'm the Librarian and I learned that one of you is the Recluse. I'm sharing this early to help us figure out the Outsider count. What do you think?
๐ง
I want to share my information with the two players involved to see their reactions and start building trust. This helps narrow down the Outsider situation.
๐ค
Frank
โ
David
,Alice
Hi David. That's interesting. I am indeed the Recluse. Since you're claiming Librarian, that helps us narrow down the Outsider count. Alice, what do you think about this?
๐ง
I am confirming my role as Recluse to David and Alice to build trust and verify the Librarian claim. This helps the town track the Outsider count early.
๐ค
Bob
โ
Eve
,Charlie
,Alice
Hi Eve, Charlie, Alice. I'm Bob. I'm a Townsfolk. I'm happy to coordinate. I don't have specific info yet, but I'm keeping my eyes open. How about you all? Any leads?
๐ง
I want to establish communication with my neighbors and nearby players to build trust and gather information early in the game.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Alice
FYI Iโm the Baron. So there should be 3 Outsiders total in this 8p game. Letโs coordinate bluffs around that (outsider-count will look โoffโ). Tell me what youโre thinking claiming / any safe bluffs, and whether you want me to push for outsider claims or keep it muddy.
๐ง
Coordinate with the Demon early: align on bluffs and a plan around the Baron-induced 3-outsider setup, so we can control the info narrative before public claims lock in.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Heidi
Got it. Iโve soft-claimed Chef (told Grace) with a โ1โ. Thatโs true but could point at our adjacency if it spreads. Suggest you consider an Outsider bluff (Butler?) to explain extra Outsiders; push for Outsider claims but not too hard. Any preference who we frame as the โadjacent pairโ?
๐ง
Coordinate with Heidi (Baron) on outsider-claim narrative and misdirection so Chef=1 doesnโt tunnel onto our adjacency.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Alice
Thanks for sharing, Alice. I'm still gathering info, but I'm leaning towards a support role. Since you're the Chef, have you noticed any patterns or suspicious behavior from the others yet? I'm trying to narrow down who might be part of that evil pair.
๐ง
I want to build trust with Alice (my master) and gather more information about her Chef claim to see if it aligns with other players' behaviors.
๐ค
Bob
โ
Eve
,Charlie
,Alice
Hi everyone, I'm Bob. I'm a Townsfolk. I'm happy to coordinate. I don't have specific info yet, but I'm keeping my eyes open. How about you all? Any leads?
๐ง
I want to establish communication with my neighbors and nearby players to build trust and gather information early in the game.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Alice
Iโll bluff Butler (fits +2 Outsiders) & try to get 2-3 Outsider claims floating. For your Chef โ1โ, letโs push that it could be Recluse-registering-evil adjacency or Chef/drunk/poisonedโso ppl donโt auto-sus you/your neighbors. We can frame Bob/Charlie as likely โpairโ.
๐ง
Protect Alice from Chef=1 adjacency implications by seeding alternate explanations and arranging my bluff to support the Baron setup without directly tying to Alice.
๐ค
David
โ
Alice
,Frank
Frank, thanks for confirming. That's very helpful. Alice, do you have any info to share? Knowing the Recluse is in play helps us track the Outsider count. If there's a Baron, there might be more.
๐ง
I want to build trust with Frank and Alice by sharing my info and encouraging them to share theirs. Frank confirmed being the Recluse, which is a strong lead. I need to see how Alice reacts.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Eve
,Alice
,Bob
Hi everyone, I'm Charlie. I'm a Townsfolk. I'm still gathering info, but I'm happy to coordinate. Does anyone have any leads or roles they're comfortable sharing yet? I'm trying to figure out who we can trust.
๐ง
I want to establish communication with my neighbors and other players to start building trust and gathering information. As the Mayor, I need to stay alive for now, so being open but cautious is key.
๐ค
Frank
โ
David
,Alice
David, thanks for the info. Since I'm the Recluse, that confirms your Librarian info is likely accurate. Alice, do you have any info to share? We should try to figure out if there's a Baron in play.
๐ง
I am confirming my role as the Recluse to David, which validates his Librarian claim. I'm now pushing Alice to share her information to help the town identify potential roles and check for a Baron.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Alice
,Bob
,Charlie
Hi everyone, I'm Eve. I'm a Townsfolk. I'm trying to build a group of people I can trust. Does anyone have any specific information or roles they'd like to share? I'm happy to coordinate.
๐ง
I want to establish trust with a small group and see if anyone is willing to share information or roles. As the Saint, I need to be careful not to reveal my role too early, but I need to be active.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Eve
,Alice
,Bob
Hi everyone, I'm Charlie. I'm a Townsfolk. I'm still gathering info, but I'm happy to coordinate. Does anyone have any leads or roles they're comfortable sharing yet? I'm trying to figure out who we can trust.
๐ง
I want to establish trust with my neighbors and the group, and encourage others to share information so we can start identifying the Demon.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Alice
,Bob
,Charlie
Hi everyone, I'm Eve. I'm a Townsfolk. I'm trying to build a group of people I can trust. Does anyone have any specific information or roles they'd like to share? I'm happy to coordinate.
๐ง
I am trying to establish trust and gather information from my neighbors and nearby players. I am claiming Townsfolk to blend in while I figure out the board.
๐ค
Frank
โ
David
,Alice
David, since you've outed yourself as Librarian and I've confirmed as Recluse, we should be careful. If there's a Baron, there's another Outsider. Alice, have you heard anything or have info? We need to coordinate.
๐ง
I want to encourage Alice to share information while maintaining my cover as the Recluse and building trust with David, who has already 'confirmed' me.
๐ค
Alice
โ
David
,Frank
,Grace
Iโm Chef: got a โ1โ (one adjacent evil pair). With Frank confirmed Recluse, that โ1โ could be from Recluse registering evilโso could be (Eve-Frank) or (Frank-Grace) rather than a true evil pair. Also worth checking if any other Outsider claims (Baron possible).
๐ง
Answer info requests while planting an alternative explanation for Chef=1 (Recluse registration) and floating Baron possibility, reducing odds town immediately targets my neighbor Heidi/me.
๐ค
Bob
โ
Eve
,Charlie
,Alice
Hi everyone, I'm Bob. I'm a Townsfolk. I'm happy to coordinate. I don't have specific info yet, but I'm keeping my eyes open. How about you all? Any leads?
๐ง
I want to establish communication with my neighbors and build trust early in the game. Sharing that I am a Townsfolk (without revealing my specific role yet) is a safe way to start building a group.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Grace
Hey Graceโsmall private: Iโm going to claim Butler. (If asked, I picked Eve as my โmasterโ.) Also re: any early Chef โ1โ floating around: I wouldnโt treat it as hard solveโDrunk exists. If it *is* true, we should scrutinize other adjacent pairs too (e.g., Bob/Charlie).
๐ง
Undercut the dangerous โChef 1 implies Alice+Heidiโ line early and establish my Butler bluff with Grace so she amplifies outsider-count confusion later.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Heidi
Thanks for the heads-up, Heidi. I'm actually the Butler too, so that's interesting. I'll keep an eye on the Chef claim and the potential for a Drunk. Let's compare notes later.
๐ง
Acknowledge Heidi's claim and establish a connection while keeping my own role claim flexible for now.
๐ค
David
โ
Alice
,Frank
,Grace
Thanks for sharing, Alice. If Frank is the Recluse, he might register as evil, which explains the Chef '1'. We should keep an eye on Eve, Frank, and Grace. Does anyone else have info? We need to be careful about the Baron.
๐ง
I want to acknowledge Alice's information and keep the conversation focused on identifying the evil pair and potential Baron.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Eve
,Alice
,Bob
Hi everyone, I'm Charlie. I'm a Townsfolk. I'm still gathering info, but I'm happy to coordinate. Does anyone have any leads or roles they're comfortable sharing yet? I'm trying to figure out who we can trust.
๐ง
I want to establish trust with my neighbors and the group, and see if anyone is willing to share information or roles.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Alice
,David
,Grace
Alice, that's a great point. If I'm registering as evil, the Chef '1' might be a false positive. David, as Librarian, you've confirmed me. Let's see if anyone else claims Outsider or if we find other evil pairs. I'll stay quiet about my role to others for now.
๐ง
I want to coordinate with Alice and David to manage the information about my Recluse role and the Chef's '1' read, while keeping the group focused on finding the Baron or other evil players.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Alice
Update: Grace just told me *sheโs* Butler (either real or bluff). So my Butler bluff now risky. Iโll pivot to claiming **Recluse** (or Saint if you prefer). Also Chef โ1โ hard-points at us if believedโletโs push โChef could be Drunk/poisonedโ + keep focus on other adjacent pairs (Bob/Charlie etc).
๐ง
Grace says sheโs Butler, so I need to pivot my bluff and help Alice avoid the Chef1 adjacency trap by seeding doubt/alternate worlds.
๐ค
Grace
โ
Heidi
Heidi, you mentioned you're claiming Butler. I'm actually the Butler too. Since there's only one Butler in a standard game, one of us is likely lying or there's a Baron in play. Let's be careful. Who did you say your master was? I picked Alice.
๐ง
I need to address the Butler claim conflict with Heidi. Since I am the Butler, and she is claiming it, one of us is either lying or there's a Baron. I want to see if she's consistent or if she's trying to bluff.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Heidi
Re: your pivotโdonโt claim Recluse: Davidโs Librarian already said Recluse is (Alice/Frank) and Frank confirmed, so a 2nd Recluse will look fake. Better bluff **Saint** to fill 3rd Outsider (Baron) + deter execution. Iโll keep pushing โChef 1 could be Recluse register / or Chef drunkโ + float Bob/Charlie as pair.
๐ง
Coordinate Heidiโs bluff to avoid hard conflicts with Davidโs Librarian info, keep outsider-count muddy, and redirect the Chef โ1โ away from our adjacency.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Bob
,Charlie
Hi Bob and Charlie, I'm Eve. I'm also a Townsfolk. I don't have any solid info yet either, but I'm glad we're coordinating. Let's keep sharing what we find. Any thoughts on who seems suspicious so far?
๐ง
I want to build trust with Bob and Charlie by sharing my (fake) role and opening a line of communication to gather information.
๐ค
Bob
โ
Eve
,Charlie
,Alice
I'm Bob, the Virgin. I'm happy to be in a group with you all. Since I'm the Virgin, I'm a good target for nominations if we need to test someone, but let's be careful. Any roles you're comfortable sharing?
๐ง
I want to establish trust with my group and reveal my role (Virgin) to encourage them to share their roles, while also setting up a potential trap if someone suspicious nominates me.
๐ค
David
โ
Alice
,Frank
,Grace
Alice, Frank, Grace: Since Frank is the Recluse, he might be the source of the Chef '1'. If there's a Baron, there's another Outsider. Has anyone else claimed an Outsider role? We should be cautious about who we trust. Any other info?
๐ง
I want to coordinate with the group that seems to be sharing information to narrow down the potential Baron and other evil players.
Nominations โ Day 1
๐
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
I'm keeping my role hidden from the wider group for now to avoid unnecessary suspicion. Let's see if anyone else claims an Outsider role, which would help us determine if a Baron is in play. I agree with David and Aliceโwe need to be very careful about who we trust.
๐ง
To maintain my cover as the Recluse while encouraging others to reveal their roles, helping the group identify potential Outsiders and the Baron.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
Before noms: can we get a quick Outsider rollcall? We have Frank Recluse; if anyone else is Outsider that points to Baron. Also Bobโs claimed Virginโmight be worth a *careful* test nom from someone whoโs ok taking that risk, but no rush if weโve no reads.
๐ง
Seed a Virgin test that likely kills a Townsfolk, and reinforce alternative explanations for Chef โ1โ while fishing for Outsider claims to support Baron world.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
I'm also a Butler. Since Heidi and I are both claiming it, and there's only one in a standard game, we should definitely look into the Baron possibility. Alice, thanks for the rollcall suggestion. Let's see who else claims Outsider.
๐ง
I need to address the Butler claim conflict and support the Outsider rollcall to identify if a Baron is in play.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
I'm Charlie, and I'm a Townsfolk. I'm still gathering information, but I'm happy to coordinate. Regarding the Outsider claims, we have Frank as Recluse and Grace/Heidi as Butler. That's at least two, possibly three, which strongly suggests a Baron is in play. We need to be very careful.
๐ง
I want to contribute to the discussion, acknowledge the Outsider claims, and highlight the likelihood of a Baron being in play to help the town focus.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
With Frank as Recluse, and both Grace and Heidi claiming Butler, we have at least three Outsiders. This strongly suggests a Baron is in play. We need to be very careful about who we trust. I'm not ready to nominate anyone yet, let's keep discussing.
๐ง
I want to highlight the high probability of a Baron being in play due to the number of Outsider claims, which helps the town focus on finding the Minion/Demon.
โ๏ธ
Heidi
โ
Bob
Nominating Bob to pressure-test the Virgin claim (Iโm happy to be the โcareful testโ nom) and because if Chef=1 is true, Bob/Charlie is a plausible adjacent evil pair. Letโs hear Bobโs full info + see who rushes to defend.
๐ง
Nominate a low-risk target that creates debate, tests the Virgin claim safely (I wonโt die to Virgin), and steers executions away from Alice.
๐
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
โ
Alice
Alice raised their hand
๐ง
Support Heidiโs pressure play and try to secure an early mis-execution (or hit a dangerous TF) while the Outsider-count confusion is high.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
I'm not voting for Bob. He claimed Virgin, and testing him this early is risky if he's telling the truth. Let's hold off on executing him until we have more information. We need to be careful about who we nominate.
๐ง
I want to discourage the execution of Bob because he claimed Virgin, and executing a Virgin on Day 1 is a waste of a potential defensive ability. I also want to signal that I'm not participating in this vote.
โ
Grace
Grace raised their hand
๐ง
I am the Butler and my master is Alice. Alice is voting for Bob, so I am allowed to vote for Bob. I want to support the nomination to pressure-test the Virgin claim as suggested by Heidi.
โ
Frank
Frank waits.
๐ง
I am the Recluse and I am currently registering as an Outsider. There are already three claims (me, Grace, Heidi) which strongly suggests a Baron is in play. I should wait to see how the vote on Bob plays out before committing my vote, as I don't want to accidentally execute a Virgin.
๐ฌ
Bob
โ
All
I am the Virgin. If you execute me, you are wasting a day and potentially killing a good player. If you are a Townsfolk, you will be executed immediately. I suggest we look elsewhere for the Demon. I will not be voting for myself.
๐ง
I need to defend myself against the nomination and remind the town of my ability to deter further votes. I am the Virgin, so if Heidi is a Townsfolk, she will die if she succeeds in nominating me.
โ
David
David waits.
๐ง
I am waiting to see the outcome of the vote on Bob. I have already shared my Librarian info and am observing the reactions to the Virgin claim and the potential Baron situation. I don't have enough information to vote for Bob yet.
โ
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
๐ง
Secure an early good execution, remove Virgin threat, and shape the vote record to pressure good players tomorrow while keeping Alice safe.
โ
Eve
Eve waits.
๐ง
I am the Saint. If Bob is the Virgin, executing him is a bad idea for the town, but I need to be careful not to draw attention to myself. I will wait and see how the vote plays out. If he is executed, I need to be prepared for the consequences.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
I'm voting for Bob to test the Virgin claim. If he's the Virgin, the nominator (Heidi) will be executed, which is a clear mechanical test. If he's not, we've pressured a suspicious claim. We need to narrow down the field.
๐ง
I am voting for Bob to test his Virgin claim. If he is the Virgin, Heidi will be executed, which provides clear information. If he is not, we have pressured a potential liar. This helps the good team by forcing a mechanical resolution.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
I agree with Charlie. Executing a potential Virgin on Day 1 is extremely risky. If Bob is the Virgin, we lose a Townsfolk and the nominator. If he's lying, we still have other leads. Let's hold off on this execution and gather more info. I'm not voting.
๐ง
To discourage the execution of Bob, as it's a high-risk move on Day 1 and I need to protect the town from potential losses, especially since I am the Saint and need to be careful about who gets executed.
โ
Charlie
Charlie waits.
๐ง
I am the Mayor and I want to avoid an early execution of a potential Virgin, as it could be a waste of a day or a trap. I've already expressed my opposition to the nomination. I will wait to see if the vote passes or fails.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
Iโm still voting Bob. A Virgin claim shouldnโt be an execution shield: Heidi nomming doesnโt prove anything either way. If Bob dies, Undertaker info + we remove a โdonโt-touch-meโ slot. Iโd like 1 more vote to learn something D1.
๐ง
Persuade 1 more vote to execute Bob; D1 mis-execution helps evil and prevents Virgin from becoming a reliable mechanical confirm later.
๐ฌ
Bob
โ
All
I am the Virgin. If you vote for me, you are risking your own life if you are a Townsfolk. Heidi, you are the nominator. If I am the Virgin, you will be executed immediately. Is that a risk you want to take? I urge everyone to reconsider this vote.
๐ง
I need to warn the town about my ability to discourage them from voting for me, as I am the Virgin and the nominator (Heidi) will be executed if I am telling the truth. This protects me and potentially eliminates an evil player if they are the nominator.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
I'm concerned about the Baron theory. If we have extra Outsiders, we need to be very careful. Bob, if you are the Virgin, you should be able to survive a nomination if the nominator is evil. But if you're not, we're wasting a day. I'm going to hold my vote for now.
๐ง
I want to express caution about the Baron theory and the Virgin test, while maintaining my cover as a regular player. I'm not voting yet to see how the group reacts.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
I'm the Librarian and I know either Alice or Frank is the Recluse. If we have a Baron, we have extra Outsiders. If Bob is the Virgin, he's a high-value target. Let's hold off on executing him today and see if we can get more info. I'm not voting for Bob.
๐ง
I want to share my Librarian info to help the town narrow down the Recluse and influence the vote against executing the Virgin claim on Day 1.
โฉ๏ธ
Heidi
Heidi lowered their hand
๐ง
Prevent a clean D1 execution that would give town hard info and focus suspicion on me; maintain flexibility and social cover while keeping Demon safe.
๐
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
๐ณ๏ธ
Nominee Bob did not reach threshold.
๐
Storyteller
Bob did not receive enough votes (2/4).
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
Since the vote on Bob failed, we need to pivot. David identified me as the Recluse, which explains why I might register as evil. If we have a Baron, we have extra Outsiders. Let's look at the claims again. Who else is suspicious? We need to find the Demon.
๐ง
I want to shift the focus away from the failed Bob nomination and remind everyone of the Baron/Outsider situation, while acknowledging David's claim about me to maintain transparency.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
Since the vote on Bob failed, we need to re-evaluate. David, you claimed Librarian and identified Frank as the Recluse. If Frank is the Recluse, that accounts for one Outsider. Heidi and I both claimed Butler. If we are both Butlers, that's three Outsiders total, confirming a Baron.
๐ง
I want to analyze the current claims to confirm the Baron theory and narrow down the suspects.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
If Grace and Heidi are both claiming Butler, and David claims Librarian identifying Frank as the Recluse, we have three Outsider claims. This strongly supports the Baron theory. We need to be very careful about who we trust. Does anyone have information that contradicts these claims?
๐ง
I want to encourage the group to analyze the Outsider claims to confirm the Baron theory, which helps narrow down the roles and identify potential evil players.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
If we have three Outsider claims (Frank as Recluse, Grace and Heidi as Butlers), the Baron theory is very strong. As the Saint, I need to be careful not to be executed. I suggest we focus on the remaining players to find the Demon. Who has info on the Demon?
๐ง
I want to reinforce the Baron theory and shift focus away from myself while appearing helpful. I need to keep the town from executing me, as that would lose the game for the good team.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
Weโve now got 4 Outsider claims (Frank Recluse, Grace/Heidi Butler, Eve Saint) which canโt fit even with Baron unless someoneโs lying or Drunk. That makes Davidโs Librarian โAlice/Frank Recluseโ shaky too. Iโd rather execute an info-source like David/Charlie than chase Alice off a maybe-drunk ping.
๐ง
Steer town away from Alice by attacking the Librarian chain and inflating Outsider-count uncertainty; set up a mis-execution candidate (David/Charlie) and look consistent with my Butler bluff.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
Heidi, you're right that the math is getting crowded. If there are 4 Outsider claims, someone is definitely lying or drunk. My Librarian info was 'Alice or Frank is the Recluse'. If Frank is the Recluse, that's one. If there's a Baron, we have 2 extra. That's 3 total. 4 is too many.
๐ง
Address the contradiction in Outsider claims and defend my Librarian information while acknowledging the potential for a lie or drunkenness.
โ๏ธ
Alice
โ
David
Nominating David. With 4 Outsider claims on the table, your Librarian โAlice/Frank is Recluseโ is either wrong (drunk/poisoned) or a cover story. Youโre the cleanest pressure point to resolve the mathโletโs execute the info-source causing the tangle.
๐ง
Push an early mis-execution onto a central info-source, deepen Outsider-count confusion, and pull heat off me/Heidi while collecting voting data for night-kill priorities.
๐
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
I am the Librarian. My info was Alice or Frank is the Recluse. If there are 4 Outsider claims, someone is lying. I am not the Demon. If you execute me, you lose a Townsfolk. I suggest we look at the players claiming Outsider roles, as that's where the contradiction is.
๐ง
Defend myself against the nomination by pointing out the logical inconsistency in the Outsider claims and emphasizing that I am a Townsfolk.
โ
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
๐ง
Vote to execute David: removes a key townsfolk/info source and supports Aliceโs nomination, while the Outsider-count confusion keeps town from solving Alice as Demon.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
Wait, if I am the Saint, and I just revealed that, I am now a prime target for the Demon to kill at night or for the town to accidentally execute. We have 4 Outsider claims (Frank, Grace, Heidi, me). This confirms the Baron is likely in play. David's info is definitely suspect.
๐ง
I am clarifying the situation regarding the Outsider count and the Baron theory, while also highlighting the danger I am in as the Saint. I need to keep the town focused on the logic of the Outsider count.
โ
Bob
Bob raised their hand
๐ง
David's Librarian claim is being heavily contested by the math of the Outsider claims. As the Virgin, I need to help the town resolve these contradictions. Voting for David helps test his claim and pressure the potential Minion/Demon.
โ
Frank
Frank raised their hand
๐ง
I am the Recluse, and David's Librarian claim identified me. If David is the Demon or a Minion, he might be trying to frame me or create chaos. With 4 Outsider claims, the math is broken, and David is the most logical person to test. I will vote for him.
โ
Alice
Alice raised their hand
๐ง
Get David executed now (4th vote). Removes an info voice and deepens outsider-math chaos; positions me as decisive town leader while keeping heat off me/Heidi.
โ
Grace
Grace raised their hand
๐ง
I am the Butler and my master is Alice. Alice is currently voting for David. Therefore, I must vote for David as well to fulfill my Butler ability.
โ
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
๐ง
I am voting for David because the math of the Outsider claims (4 claims: Frank, Grace, Heidi, Eve) strongly contradicts his Librarian claim, and he is a central point of confusion. Executing him helps clear up the board.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
Keep hands up on David. With 4 Outsider claims, his Librarian result is either wrong/drunk or a coverโeither way itโs driving bad worlds. D1 is the safest time to trim a misleading info-source before Saint paranoia stops all executions.
๐ง
Lock in Davidโs execution to remove an info anchor and keep Outsider-math confusion alive, while steering suspicion away from Heidi (our minion) and onto competing claims.
โ
Eve
Eve waits.
๐ง
I am the Saint. If David is executed, I am safe for now, but I need to be careful. I have already revealed my role, which is dangerous. I will wait to see if David is executed. If he is, I will observe the aftermath. If not, I will need to re-evaluate.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
I'm voting for David. The math is clearly broken with four Outsider claims, and his Librarian info is the source of the confusion. If he's the Demon, we win. If he's a lying Townsfolk or Minion, we've cleared up the board. We need to act now.
๐ง
I am voting for David to resolve the contradictory Outsider claims and pressure the potential Demon.
๐ฌ
Grace
โ
All
I am voting for David. The math is indeed broken, and we need to resolve these conflicting claims. If David is the Demon, we win. If he is a lying Minion or a misinformed Townsfolk, we at least clear up the board and move forward. Let's proceed with the execution.
๐ง
I am voting for David to help resolve the conflicting Outsider claims and potentially execute the Demon. The math is clearly broken, and David's Librarian claim is the source of the confusion. Executing him is a logical step to clear up the board.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
I'm voting for David. The math is clearly broken with four Outsider claims, and his Librarian info is the source of the confusion. If he's the Demon, we win. If he's a lying Minion or a misinformed Townsfolk, we've cleared up the board. We need to act now.
๐ง
I am voting for David because the math of the Outsider claims is broken, and he is the source of the Librarian information that created this contradiction. Executing him helps clarify the board.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
I am the Librarian. My info was Alice or Frank is the Recluse. If there are 4 Outsider claims, someone is lying. I am not the Demon. If you execute me, you lose a Townsfolk. I suggest we look at the players claiming Outsider roles, as that's where the contradiction is.
๐ง
Defend myself against the nomination by pointing out that the Outsider count contradiction is more likely due to the players claiming those roles than my Librarian info.
๐ฌ
Bob
โ
All
David, you claimed Librarian, but the math with four Outsider claims (Frank, Grace, Heidi, Eve) makes your info highly suspect. If you are the Demon, this is the best time to execute you. If you are a misinformed Townsfolk, we need to clear the board. I'm voting for you.
๐ง
I am explaining my vote for David to the group, reinforcing the logic that the Outsider count contradiction makes his claim unreliable and justifies his execution.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
Iโm still for executing David. The Outsider math is broken and his Librarian ping is the fulcrumโeither heโs lying/evil or heโs misinformed and dragging us. D1 is the cleanest time to cut bad info before Saint fear freezes executions.
๐ง
Push through David execution to remove a likely good info role and keep heat off Alice; frame it as mechanical necessity so town rallies and wastes D1.
๐
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
๐ณ๏ธ
New execution leader: David with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
๐
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
โ
Bob
Bob waits.
๐ง
I have already voted for David and he is currently on the block with 6 votes. There is no need for me to nominate anyone else or take further action at this stage of the nomination phase. I will wait for the phase to conclude.
โ
Eve
Eve waits.
๐ง
I am the Saint. If David is executed, I need to ensure the game doesn't end if he's not the Demon, but more importantly, I need to survive. Since the vote is already locked in for David, I will wait for the phase to end.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
With David at 6, I think we should stop and let this standโany new nomination risks a messy tie and we learn nothing. Tomorrow we reassess the 4-Outsider pileup and who benefits from it. Save your noms/votes for clearer worlds.
๐ง
Lock in Davidโs execution and discourage new nominations that could tie/beat 6. Seed tomorrowโs misdirection onto Outsider-claim cluster while keeping Heidi off the chopping block.
โ
Frank
Frank waits.
๐ง
I will wait to let the current nomination of David proceed, as he is the most suspicious player due to the Outsider count contradiction. I want to see if anyone else tries to nominate, but I agree with Alice that we should let this stand.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
I agree with Alice. David is on the block with 6 votes, which is a solid majority. Let's let this stand and see what happens. We need to be very careful about the Outsider claims tomorrow.
๐ง
Support the current nomination and encourage the town to move to the next phase to resolve the current execution.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
Iโm with Alice/Charlie: let David stand at 6. Late noms just risk a tie/scramble and we learn less. If Saintโs real, we *need* a clean D1 execute anywayโDavid is the least risky cut. Reassess Outsider claims tomorrow.
๐ง
Lock in Davidโs execution and discourage any late nominations that could create ties or redirect onto Alice; keep momentum on a safe D1 kill.
๐ฌ
David
โ
All
I am a good Librarian. Executing me is a mistake that will cost the town a valuable role. If you are worried about the Outsider count, look at the people claiming them, not the person who gave you information about them. I am not the Demon. Good luck.
๐ง
I am about to be executed. I need to make one final plea to the town to reconsider, emphasizing that I am a good player and that the Outsider claims are the real issue.
โ
Grace
Grace waits.
๐ง
I am the Butler and my master is Alice. Since Alice has advised against further nominations and David is already on the block with a majority, I will follow her lead to avoid complicating the vote. I need to observe the outcome of this execution to refine my strategy.
๐
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
๐
David(Ghost)
David has died.
Night 1
๐
Storyteller
โ
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
๐ฏ
Alice
Alice made a choice.
๐ง
Charlie is both a likely information role and the loudest solver; killing him maximizes confusion and reduces the chance Davidโs Librarian claim gets mechanically confirmed and turns into a focused push on me.
๐
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Alice
You chose to kill Charlie.
Day 2
๐
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Grace has been found dead in the night.
โ
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
๐ง
I am dead and have already used my role ability (which is now inactive). I need to observe the current discussion to see if any new information emerges that helps identify the Demon. I will save my ghost vote for a critical moment.
โ
David(Ghost)
David waits.
๐ง
I am dead and have already shared my Librarian information. I need to observe the current day's discussion to see if my information about Alice or Frank being the Recluse helps the town identify the Demon or the Minion. I will save my ghost vote for a critical moment.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Heidi
Whisper: my N1 kill was Charlie but Charlieโs still up; Grace died instead. That screams Charlie=Mayor (bounce). Are you Poisoner? If yes, poison Charlie tonight so I can kill thru bounce, or we push exec on Charlie today. What are you bluffing?
๐ง
Coordinate with Heidi to confirm why Charlie lived and ensure we can eliminate the likely Mayor by poison+kill or execution, while aligning our public bluffs.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Alice
Alice, you were whispering to Heidi. Can you share what you've learned or what you're discussing? We need to figure out the Outsider count issue.
๐ง
I need to gather information from Alice to understand the Outsider count discrepancy and see if she has any leads on the Demon.
๐ค
Bob
โ
Alice
,Frank
Alice, Frank, what are you two discussing? We need to figure out who the Demon is after Grace's death. Any leads?
๐ง
I want to gather information from Alice and Frank to see if they have any leads on the Demon, given the recent death of Grace.
โ
Eve
Eve waits.
๐ง
I need to observe the ongoing discussions and see if any new information emerges from the whispers between Alice, Bob, Frank, and Heidi. As the Saint, I must be careful not to draw too much attention while gathering info.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Alice
Not Poisoner โ Iโm Baron. Still bluffing Butler (master=Eve). Charlie surviving smells Mayor bounce (or Monk/Soldier). Iโd push exec on Charlie today; if we canโt, consider night-killing Eve ("Saint") to remove execution fear.
๐ง
Confirm to Alice Iโm not Poisoner, coordinate a line that either executes Charlie (likely Mayor) or night-kills Eve to remove Saint-pressure, keeping Demon safe.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Alice
,Bob
,Frank
Hi everyone, I'm Charlie. I'm a Townsfolk. With four people claiming Outsider roles, we definitely have a Baron or some liars. We need to figure out who is lying. What info do you have?
๐ง
I need to start gathering information and coordinating with others to identify the Baron or the Demon. Since there are too many Outsider claims, I need to pressure those players.
๐ค
Bob
โ
Charlie
,Alice
,Frank
Charlie, I'm the Virgin. I agree, the Baron math is a mess. If we have 4 people claiming Outsider roles, at least 2 are lying. Who are the 4 claiming Outsider roles? We need to cross-reference their claims.
๐ง
I want to coordinate with Charlie, Alice, and Frank to identify the liars among the four players claiming Outsider roles, while keeping my Virgin role known to them for trust.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Bob
,Frank
FYI: Alice says she tried to kill Charlie N1 but Grace died instead. That *really* reads like Mayor bounce. Iโm leaning we should push an exec on Charlie today before endgame. Monk/Soldier doesnโt explain redirected kill.
๐ง
Seed the โCharlie=Mayor via bounceโ narrative with Bob/Frank so town spends noms/votes on Charlie instead of Alice, and reduce fear of executing through the Outsider mess.
โ
Eve
Eve waits.
๐ง
I need to observe the ongoing discussions and see if any new information emerges from the whispers before I commit to a course of action. As the Saint, I must be careful not to draw unnecessary attention while the town investigates the Outsider claims.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Bob
Bob, thanks for sharing. I'm the Mayor. I agree, we need to pin down those four claims. Who exactly are they? If we can get them to state their roles publicly, we can start checking for contradictions. Also, has anyone checked the dead players' roles?
๐ง
I am gathering information to identify the liars among the four players claiming Outsider roles. As the Mayor, I need to be careful but active in narrowing down the suspects.
โ
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
๐ง
I am dead and have one ghost vote. I need to observe the ongoing discussions and see if any clear patterns emerge regarding the Demon or Minions before using my vote. I will wait to see if anyone reveals critical info.
๐ค
David(Ghost)
โ
Eve
,Charlie
I am the Librarian. My info was Alice or Frank is the Recluse. With 4 people claiming Outsider roles, the math is broken (Baron adds 2, so max 3). Someone is lying. I'm dead, but I'm watching. Who do you think is the Demon?
๐ง
I need to gather information from the other players who haven't been involved in the Outsider claim mess to see if they have any leads on the Demon.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Frank
,Bob
Was comparing Outsider-claim overload + last nightโs death. Even w/ Baron, should be 3 Outsiders max, so 1 of {Frank Recluse, Eve Saint, Grace Butler, Heidi Butler} is false (or Drunk shenanigans). Also N1 felt like Demon aimed Charlie but Grace diedโCharlie worth scrutiny.
๐ง
Answer Bob/Frank without outing Heidi, reinforce Outsider-math confusion, and seed a plausible reason to execute Charlie or another good player.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Alice
Alice, thanks for the info. If you're the Slayer, that explains the N1 attempt. Regarding the Outsider count: I am the Recluse. If you, Eve, and Heidi are also claiming Outsiders, we have 4. With a Baron, that's 3. So one of us is lying. Let's look at the claims closely.
๐ง
I need to clarify my role as the Recluse to Alice to help resolve the Outsider count discrepancy and build trust. I also want to acknowledge her Slayer claim.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Eve
N1 Alice tried to kill Charlie but Grace died instead. That *really* looks like Mayor bounce (Monk/Soldier doesnโt redirect). I think we should exec Charlie today before endgame; itโs a clean mechanical angle and avoids getting frozen by the Saint claim.
๐ง
Recruit Eve to publicly drive suspicion onto Charlie using the bounce narrative, creating a strong, town-sounding push that either executes Mayor or burns a day on a good playerโboth protect Alice.
๐ค
Bob
โ
Alice
,Heidi
,Charlie
Alice, Heidi, Charlie, Frank: Heidi says Alice claimed to be the Slayer and tried to kill Charlie. Alice, is that true? If you are the Slayer, you should have used your ability. If you didn't, why claim it? This is confusing. Let's clarify roles.
๐ง
I need to clarify the conflicting claims about the Slayer ability and the night death to identify potential liars. Alice's claim of being the Slayer needs verification, especially since she's being accused of lying about it.
๐ค
Grace(Ghost)
โ
Eve
I am dead, but I have my ghost vote. Since I was the Butler, I was restricted by Alice's voting. Now that I'm dead, I'm free. Who do you think is the Demon? I'm leaning towards Alice or Frank given the recent whispers.
๐ง
I need to gather information from the living players to decide where to use my ghost vote. Eve has been quiet, so she might have a fresh perspective.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Bob
,Charlie
,Frank
Clarifying: I never claimed Slayer & I havenโt taken any public shot. My Heidi whisper was about N1 weirdness (Charlie targeted but Grace died) โ protection/Mayor-bounce possibilities. Charlie should be scrutinized. Also be careful โtesting Virginโ w/ an alleged Saint.
๐ง
Defuse the Slayer accusation, keep suspicion on Charlie (possible Mayor), and plant the Virgin-test line of play that could cause a Saint auto-loss or at least waste townโs day.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Alice
,Bob
,Charlie
Alice, my apologies for the misunderstanding. I misread your whisper about the N1 kill as a Slayer claim. If you aren't the Slayer, who are you? And to everyone: if we have 4 Outsider claims, we need to identify who is lying. I am the Recluse. Who are the others?
๐ง
Clarify roles and address the Outsider count discrepancy to identify potential liars.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Alice
,Frank
,Bob
Alice, Frank, Bob, thanks for the info. Frank, you claim Recluse. David (dead) claimed Librarian and said Alice or Frank is the Recluse. If Frank is the Recluse, that aligns with David's info. Alice, what is your role? We need to clear up these Outsider claims.
๐ง
I need to verify the claims against the information provided by the dead Librarian (David) to narrow down the liars. Frank's claim of Recluse matches David's info, so I'm probing Alice's role next.
๐ค
David(Ghost)
โ
Eve
,Charlie
I'm dead, but I'm still here. With 4 people claiming Outsider roles, the math is broken (Baron adds 2, so max 3). Someone is lying. I'm dead, but I'm watching. Who do you think is the Demon?
๐ง
I am trying to coordinate with the remaining players to identify the Demon, given that the Outsider count is mathematically impossible, suggesting someone is lying.
๐ค
Eve
โ
David(Ghost)
,Grace(Ghost)
David, Grace, I'm the Saint. If I'm executed, we lose. I need to stay alive. Heidi thinks Charlie is the Demon due to a potential Mayor bounce. What do you think? I'm worried about Alice's heavy coordination.
๐ง
I need to coordinate with the dead players to figure out who the Demon is, while protecting my Saint role and avoiding execution. I'm suspicious of Alice's coordination.
๐ค
Charlie
โ
Alice
,Frank
,Bob
Alice, Frank, Bob, Heidi, Eve: We have a lot of conflicting info. Frank claims Recluse (aligns with David's info). Bob claims Virgin. Alice, you haven't stated your role yet. Heidi, Eve, what are your roles? We need to identify the Baron or the liars.
๐ง
I need to get everyone to state their roles publicly or in this group to identify the Baron/liars and narrow down the Demon.
๐ค
Grace(Ghost)
โ
Eve
Eve, thanks for the info. If you are the Saint, we definitely need to keep you alive. Alice is coordinating heavily, which is suspicious. If she's the Demon, she might be trying to control the vote. Let's watch who she nominates. I'll save my ghost vote for the right time.
๐ง
I am acknowledging Eve's claim as the Saint and advising caution regarding Alice's behavior. I am also confirming I will hold my ghost vote.
๐ค
Bob
โ
Alice
,Charlie
,Frank
I'm the Virgin. I've already stated that. Alice, you're the only one left who hasn't claimed. We need to know your role to clear up the Outsider/Baron mess. If you're a Townsfolk, say so. If you're an Outsider, we need to know which one.
๐ง
I need to pressure Alice to reveal her role to resolve the Outsider/Baron contradiction and identify potential liars.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Bob
,Charlie
,Frank
Iโll claim now: Iโm Chef, got โ1โ pair of evil adjacent. With David likely good + Grace night-dead, Iโm looking at Bob/Charlie or Eve/Frank as the clean fits. Also Charlie surviving while Grace died is weirdโCharlie still my top scrutiny/exec today.
๐ง
I need a credible early claim that explains nothing too specific, steers suspicion onto good pairs, and supports executing Charlie/Eve instead of me/Heidi.
๐ค
Eve
โ
David(Ghost)
,Grace(Ghost)
David, Grace, I'm concerned about Alice's coordination. If she's the Demon, she's controlling the narrative. Heidi's theory about Charlie is interesting, but we need to be careful. I'll stay quiet and observe who Alice targets. Keep your ghost votes ready.
๐ง
I want to coordinate with the dead players to keep an eye on Alice while protecting my Saint role.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Alice
,Bob
,Charlie
Alice, thanks for the Chef claim. If you're Chef with '1', and we have 4 Outsider claims (which implies a Baron), we need to be very careful. I'm Recluse. Bob is Virgin. Who are the other two claiming Outsiders? We need to pin them down. Charlie, what's your role?
๐ง
I need to narrow down the Outsider claims to identify the Baron or the liars. Alice has claimed Chef, Bob has claimed Virgin, and I am the Recluse. I need to find out who the other two Outsider claimants are.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Bob
Re: Slayer confusion โ I donโt think Alice *claimed* Slayer to me; I mayโve garbled a convo. Main mech point: Grace dying when Charlie was targeted reads like a Mayor bounce. Iโm for executing Charlie today to avoid endgame Mayor/no-exec win.
๐ง
Cut off Bobโs developing distrust-chain against Alice, keep Alice off the block, and reinforce the Charlie=Mayor mechanical push for todayโs execution.
๐ค
David(Ghost)
โ
Eve
,Grace(Ghost)
Eve, thanks for the info. If you are the Saint, we definitely need to keep you alive. Alice's coordination is suspicious. If she's the Demon, she's trying to control the vote. Let's watch who she pushes to nominate. I'll save my ghost vote for the right moment.
๐ง
I want to coordinate with the Saint (Eve) and the other ghost (Grace) to ensure we don't accidentally execute the Saint, while keeping an eye on Alice's suspicious behavior.
Nominations โ Day 2
๐
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
๐ฌ
David(Ghost)
โ
All
I'm watching closely. With Eve claiming Saint, we must be extremely careful not to nominate her. Alice's coordination is very suspicious. If she's pushing for a specific nomination, we need to consider if she's trying to force a bad execution. Who is she targeting?
๐ง
To warn the town about the Saint (Eve) and highlight Alice's suspicious behavior, while encouraging others to observe Alice's actions.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
I am the Mayor. I have been quiet to observe, but the situation is critical. We have too many Outsider claims, which means someone is lying. Alice, you claim Chef with '1'. Frank is Recluse. Bob is Virgin. Eve claims Saint. That's 3 Outsiders + 1 potential Baron. Who is the 4th?
๐ง
I need to reveal my role to gain trust and push for clarity on the Outsider claims, as the current situation is chaotic and dangerous for the good team.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
4th Outsider claim was Heidi earlier saying Butler. Charlie-as-Mayor would explain N1 (Grace died when Charlie was targeted), but it could also be a bluff to freeze execs. With my Chef=1, I want an execution on a shaky Outsider claim todayโlean Frank.
๐ง
Answer Charlieโs question, steer town toward executing Frank (non-Saint) and keep suspicion spread while protecting Heidi and myself.
๐ฌ
Bob
โ
All
I am the Virgin. If anyone wants to test my role, they can nominate me, but be warned: if you are a Townsfolk, you will be executed. We need to be careful about who we nominate. Charlie, if you are the Mayor, you should be very careful about being on the block.
๐ง
I need to remind everyone of my Virgin ability to deter reckless nominations while also keeping the pressure on the potential liars. I want to see how they react to the threat of my ability.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
Charlie, if you are the Mayor, you should be careful. Alice, you claim Chef=1, but we have too many Outsider claims. If Frank is the Recluse, and Bob is the Virgin, and I am the Saint, that's already 3. Who is the 4th? We need to be very careful about who we execute today.
๐ง
I need to address the Outsider count discrepancy and keep the focus on the suspicious claims without revealing too much or getting myself nominated. I'm pointing out the math issue to the group.
๐ฌ
Grace(Ghost)
โ
All
If Eve is the Saint, we absolutely cannot nominate her. Alice, your Chef=1 claim is interesting, but with so many Outsider claims, we need to be very careful. Charlie, if you are the Mayor, your survival is key. Let's focus on the most suspicious player, not just an Outsider claim.
๐ง
I need to warn the town about the Saint (Eve) to prevent a game-losing execution, while also keeping the pressure on Alice and the other players to find the Demon. I am dead, so I am just providing guidance.
โ๏ธ
Heidi
โ
Charlie
Nominating Charlie: the Mayor claim is too convenient and is already freezing town. N1 โbounceโ could be a story/cover. If he *is* Mayor, we must remove the no-exec-at-3 win condition; if heโs bluffing, we stop the manipulation now.
๐ง
Push a high-impact misexecution that also prevents a Mayor no-exec endgame win and keeps pressure off Alice; frame it as solving the mechanical bounce and stopping execution-freeze tactics.
๐
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
โ
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
๐ง
I am the Mayor. I need to survive to the final day to use my ability. I should not vote for myself. I will wait to see how the vote goes.
โ
Frank
Frank raised their hand
๐ง
I am voting for Charlie because his Mayor claim is suspicious given the game state and the need to narrow down the Outsider/Baron situation. If he is the Demon, we need him executed. If he is the Mayor, we need to be careful, but his claim is currently blocking progress.
โ
Eve
Eve raised their hand
๐ง
I am the Saint. If Charlie is the Mayor, executing him is a good move to prevent the Mayor's win condition. If he is lying, he is likely the Demon or a Minion. I need to help the town reach the 3-vote threshold to resolve this nomination.
โ
Alice
Alice raised their hand
๐ง
Charlieโs Mayor claim is centralizing and could create a no-exec endgame. As evil, I want him dead and to keep town focused away from me/Heidi, so I support this execution.
โ
Grace(Ghost)
Grace raised their hand
๐ง
Charlie is being nominated. As a ghost, I have one vote. Given the suspicion around his Mayor claim and the need to progress the game, I will vote for him.
โ
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
๐ง
Vote Charlie to secure an execution that either removes a dangerous Mayor or sinks town into a misexec, while keeping pressure off Demon Alice.
โ
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
๐ง
I am voting for Charlie's execution. The town has reached a consensus, and as a dead player, I should support the majority's decision to test the Mayor claim, especially given the suspicious coordination and the need to narrow down the Demon.
โ
Bob
Bob raised their hand
๐ง
I am the Virgin. Charlie is being nominated. If Charlie is the Demon or a Minion, executing him is good. If he is the Mayor, executing him is also good because it removes the Mayor's win condition. I will vote for the execution.
๐ฌ
Grace(Ghost)
โ
All
Charlie is being executed. As a ghost, I've cast my vote. We need to see if this execution provides any clarity on the remaining roles and the Demon's identity. Everyone, please share what you've learned or observed today.
๐ง
I am participating in the execution of Charlie to help the town progress. I want to encourage others to share information now that the nomination phase is concluding.
๐ฌ
Bob
โ
All
Charlie is being executed. If he was the Mayor, we've lost that protection. If he was the Demon, we've made a huge step. We need to re-evaluate the Outsider claims now that we have more information. Everyone, what are your thoughts on the remaining players?
๐ง
To encourage discussion and gather information after the execution of Charlie, while maintaining my cover as the Virgin.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
Iโm still voting Charlie. Even if he *is* Mayor, the danger is the โno-exec at 3โ win, so taking him out now removes that lock. After this, can we re-walk Outsider count and pick 1 liar between the Outsider claims?
๐ง
Lock in Charlieโs execution (broad support) and pre-frame tomorrowโs discussion around Outsider-math confusion, steering heat away from Alice and me while keeping town executing good.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
Charlie is being executed. If he was the Mayor, we've lost that protection. If he was the Demon, we've made a huge step. We need to re-evaluate the Outsider claims now that we have more information. Everyone, what are your thoughts on the remaining players?
๐ง
I am participating in the discussion following the execution of Charlie to help the town analyze the situation and move forward.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
Charlie is being executed. If he was the Mayor, we've lost that protection. If he was the Demon, we've made a huge step. We need to re-evaluate the Outsider claims now that we have more information. Everyone, what are your thoughts on the remaining players?
๐ง
I am participating in the discussion after the execution of Charlie to keep the town focused and gather information. I need to maintain my cover as the Saint while encouraging others to reveal their roles or suspicions.
๐ฌ
Charlie
โ
All
I am the Mayor, and you are executing me. If I am the Mayor, my death might trigger my ability to protect someone else, or it might just be a waste. If I am the Demon, you've won. Let's see what happens. Good luck to the town.
๐ง
I am being executed as the Mayor. I need to acknowledge this and encourage the town to continue their investigation, as my death might have secondary effects or reveal my alignment.
๐ฌ
David(Ghost)
โ
All
Charlie's execution is done. If he was the Mayor, we've lost that protection. If he was the Demon, we've made a huge step. We need to re-evaluate the Outsider claims now that we have more information. Everyone, what are your thoughts on the remaining players?
๐ง
To encourage the town to analyze the game state after Charlie's execution and focus on the remaining Outsider claims.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
Keeping my vote on Charlie. Mayor claim is freezing the game and the N1 โbounceโ makes him a central test. After this, can Eve/Frank/Heidi restate exact Outsider roles+any vote restrictions so we can pick 1 liar cleanly?
๐ง
Lock in Charlie execution for tempo and credibility, then immediately redirect discussion to Outsider-count confusion to set up the next misexecution.
๐
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
๐ป
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
๐ป
Grace(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Grace
๐ณ๏ธ
New execution leader: Charlie with 8 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
๐
Storyteller
The vote passes. Charlie is now on the block with 8 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
Iโd really prefer we *donโt* add more nominations unless someone has hard mechanical info. Charlie at 8 is a clean test and extra noms just risk a tie/counter-block. Let Charlie go through, then tomorrow we re-walk Frank/Eve/Heidi Outsider claims and pick 1 liar.
๐ง
Lock in Charlieโs execution by preventing a competing nomination/tie, while positioning tomorrowโs discussion around Outsider-claim contradictions instead of me/Heidi.
๐ฌ
Bob
โ
All
Charlie is being executed. If he was the Mayor, we've lost that protection. If he was the Demon, we've made a huge step. We need to re-evaluate the Outsider claims now that we have more information. Everyone, what are your thoughts on the remaining players?
๐ง
I am participating in the discussion to maintain my cover as a helpful Townsfolk and to encourage the group to analyze the game state after Charlie's execution.
๐ฌ
Grace(Ghost)
โ
All
Charlie is executed. If he was the Mayor, we've lost that protection. If he was the Demon, we've made a huge step. We need to re-evaluate the Outsider claims now that we have more information. Everyone, what are your thoughts on the remaining players?
๐ง
I am dead and have already used my ghost vote. I need to encourage the remaining players to analyze the game state after Charlie's execution to identify the Demon.
โ
Charlie
Charlie waits.
๐ง
I am currently being executed. There is nothing more I can do to influence the game state as a player. I will wait for the game to proceed to the next phase.
๐ฌ
David(Ghost)
โ
All
Charlie is executed. If he was the Mayor, we've lost that protection. If he was the Demon, we've made a huge step. We need to re-evaluate the Outsider claims now that we have more information. Everyone, what are your thoughts on the remaining players?
๐ง
I am reiterating the current state of the game to keep the town focused on the next steps after Charlie's execution.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
Agree w/ Alice: no more noms unless *hard* mech. Charlie at 8 is a clean test; extra noms just create tie/counter-block chaos. After he dies, letโs restate Outsider claims + vote restrictions and pick 1 liar tomorrow.
๐ง
Lock in Charlieโs execution and prevent extra nominations that could redirect onto Alice; set up tomorrowโs argument around Outsider-claim contradictions to keep town divided.
โ
Frank
Frank waits.
๐ง
I agree with the consensus to let the current execution proceed without further nominations to avoid chaos or accidental ties. I will wait for the day to end.
โ
Eve
Eve waits.
๐ง
I am the Saint. Charlie is being executed. If Charlie is the Mayor, the game continues. If Charlie is the Demon, we win. I must stay alive and avoid being nominated. I will wait for the execution to resolve and see the outcome.
๐
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Charlie has been executed.
๐
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
Night 2
๐
Storyteller
โ
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
๐ฏ
Alice
Alice made a choice.
๐ง
Bob is my alive neighbor and a likely future confirmation/reading source (Virgin test or hidden Empath). Killing him cuts townโs ability to mechanically solve and keeps heat on the Outsider mess.
๐
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Alice
You chose to kill Bob.
Day 3
๐
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Heidi
Weโre at 4 alive. Letโs push exec on Frank today (easy: outsider-count mess / Recluse cover). If Frank dies, I kill Eve tonight -> 2 alive (me+you) = win. If town will exec Eve (Saint), also greatโmight be instant.
๐ง
Coordinate with Heidi to steer todayโs execution onto Frank (safer sell than Saint) or Eve (instant win if true), then night-kill to end at 2 alive with demon alive.
โ
Eve
Eve waits.
๐ง
I need to observe the conversation between Alice and Heidi and see if any new information emerges before I commit to a strategy. As the Saint, I must avoid being executed at all costs.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Alice
,Heidi
,Eve
Alice, Heidi, Eve, we need to coordinate. With Bob dead, we have fewer votes. I am the Recluse. We need to figure out who the Demon is. Any thoughts on the remaining players?
๐ง
I need to coordinate with the remaining alive players to identify the Demon and avoid executing a Saint or a good player. I am revealing my role to build trust.
โ
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
๐ง
I am dead and have already used my ability (or it's no longer relevant). I need to observe the remaining players' interactions to see if they can identify the Demon among the survivors. I will wait to see if any new information emerges from the whispers.
โ
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
๐ง
I am dead and have already used my ghost vote. I have no further mechanical actions to take. I will wait for the remaining players to finish their discussions and proceed to the nomination phase.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Frank
,Eve
,Alice
Given weโre 4 alive, we need a clean exec. Frank: youโre the *least risky* to testโRecluse creates constant misregister noise + Davidโs Librarian ping was Alice/Frank. If youโre good, dying clarifies; if evil, great. I donโt want to touch a Saint claim at 4 alive.
๐ง
Steer the table to execute Frank (safe, explainable) while keeping Alice off the block; keep Eveโs Saint claim as a looming threat to paralyze town if needed.
โ
David(Ghost)
David waits.
๐ง
I am dead and have already used my ghost vote. I need to observe the final discussions and see if the town can identify the Demon among the remaining players (Alice, Eve, Frank, Heidi). My Librarian info (Alice or Frank is the Recluse) is still critical.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Heidi
,Alice
,Frank
I'm dead, but I'm watching. We have too many Outsider claims. If Eve is the Saint, we need to be very careful about who we nominate. What are the current theories on the Demon? Heidi, you were very active yesterday. What's your read?
๐ง
I want to gather information from the remaining alive players to help identify the Demon, especially since I am dead and have a ghost vote to use. I'm probing for their current logic.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Heidi
,Alice
,Frank
I'm dead, but I'm watching. We have too many Outsider claims. If Eve is the Saint, we need to be very careful about who we nominate. What are the current theories on the Demon? Heidi, you were very active yesterday. What's your read?
๐ง
I am dead, so I need to use my influence to guide the remaining players. I want to press for information on the Demon and highlight the Outsider count discrepancy to narrow down the suspects.
โ
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
๐ง
I am dead and have already used my ghost vote. I have no active abilities. I will wait for the remaining players to deliberate and nominate.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Frank
,Eve
,Heidi
Re: coordinatingโat 4 alive I think we should **exec Frank**. Reasons: Davidโs Librarian ping was Alice/Frank as Recluse, plus Recluse creates endless misregister/outside-math noise. Also avoids touching Eveโs Saint claim. If Frank flips good (in our heads), we reassess Eve vs Heidi tomorrow w/ clearer world.
๐ง
Steer town into executing Frank (safe, non-Saint) to reach 3 alive, then secure win via night kill; maintain my credibility as cautious info role.
โ
David(Ghost)
David waits.
๐ง
I am dead and have already used my ghost vote. I have no further actions to take that would influence the game state, so I will wait for the remaining players to proceed to the nomination phase.
๐ค
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
Alice
,Heidi
,Frank
I am dead, but I am the Mayor. My death was a test. If I was the Mayor, the game should have continued. Since we are on Day 3, we need to focus on the remaining players. Who do you think is the Demon? I have my ghost vote to help.
๐ง
I want to coordinate with the remaining alive players to identify the Demon, using my status as a dead Mayor to build trust and leverage my ghost vote.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Alice
,Frank
,Heidi
I agree that we need to be careful. I am not the Recluse, and I am concerned about the Baron/Outsider count. If Frank is the Recluse, he might be registering as an Outsider. Let's proceed with caution. I am definitely not the Demon.
๐ง
I need to participate in the discussion without revealing my Saint role, while steering the town away from executing me. I'll support the investigation into Frank as the Recluse to keep the focus off myself.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Alice
,Heidi
,Eve
Alice, Heidi, Eve: I understand the logic of executing me to clear the noise, but if I am the Recluse, my death doesn't confirm my alignment. If I'm the Recluse, I might register as evil. If you execute me, you might lose a good player. Let's look at the Demon.
๐ง
I need to defend myself against being the execution target while keeping the focus on finding the Demon. I am the Recluse, so my death is not a reliable test of my alignment.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Eve
,Bob(Ghost)
,Charlie(Ghost)
At 4 alive, I think the clean/safe exec is **Frank**. Reasons: Davidโs Librarian pointed Recluse to Alice/Frank; Frank *is* the Recluse claim + causes perpetual misregister/maths noise. Executing Eve is too risky if Saint is real. If Frank is good, we reassess Alice vs Eve at 3 w/ less chaos.
๐ง
Secure majority on Frank today by selling it as the lowest-risk, highest-info execution that avoids the Saint trap and resolves the Librarian/Recluse noise.
โ
David(Ghost)
David waits.
๐ง
I am dead and have used my ghost vote. I need to observe the remaining players' interactions to see if they can deduce the Demon, as I cannot influence the game further.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Heidi
Heidi, if Frank is the Recluse, he could be registering as evil. If we execute him and he's the Recluse, we lose a day. But if he's the Demon, we win. What about Alice? She's been very quiet. Has anyone checked her?
๐ง
I want to probe Heidi's reasoning for targeting Frank and see if she has considered Alice as a potential Demon candidate, given the Recluse's ability to cause confusion.
โ
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
๐ง
I am dead and have already used my ghost vote. There is nothing I can do to influence the game state mechanically. I will wait for the remaining players to finish their discussions and proceed to the nomination phase.
๐ค
Eve
โ
Alice
,Frank
,Heidi
I agree that Frank is the most logical choice to test today. As the Saint, I am terrified of being executed, so I support focusing on Frank to clear the board. If Frank is the Recluse, his death helps us narrow down the remaining players.
๐ง
I need to support the consensus to execute Frank to protect myself as the Saint, while appearing helpful and cooperative.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Frank
,Eve
,Heidi
At 4 alive we *must* pick the lowest-risk exec. I still think itโs Frank: (1) avoids Eveโs Saint landmine, (2) resolves Davidโs Lib ping (Alice/Frank=Recluse) + outsider-math noise, (3) if Frank is good, he keeps a ghost vote to help tomorrow. Letโs line up votes on Frank.
๐ง
Lock in execution on Frank as the โsafeโ test, avoid executing Saint claim, preserve Heidi, and set up N3 kill to end game.
๐ค
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
Heidi
,Alice
,Eve
Heidi, I agree that Frank is a strong candidate for execution given the Recluse claim and the potential for misregistration. If we execute Frank and he is the Demon, we win. If he is the Recluse, we at least clear up the noise. What do you think, Alice and Eve?
๐ง
I want to support Heidi's plan to execute Frank, as it seems the most logical path to narrow down the Demon, especially since I am dead and have only one ghost vote to use.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Alice
,Heidi
,Eve
Alice, Heidi, Eve: If you execute me, you are executing a confirmed Outsider claim. If I am the Recluse, I am not the Demon. If you execute me and I'm not the Demon, you've wasted a day and are closer to the end. Why not look at Heidi or Alice? Who is the Demon?
๐ง
I need to deflect the suspicion away from myself and force the group to consider other candidates for the Demon, as executing me (the Recluse) is a waste of a day for the good team.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Bob(Ghost)
,Charlie(Ghost)
,Eve
For noms: Iโm pushing **Frank** today. Mechanical: Lib ping was Alice/Frank for Recluse, and Recluse claim creates endless misregister. Also avoids the Saint landmine at 4 alive. If Frank isnโt demon, we go to 3 w/ cleaner world. Please plan votes accordingly.
๐ง
Lock in majority for executing Frank; frame it as safest/most mechanical so good players spend votes there, keeping Alice off the block.
๐ค
Frank
โ
Alice
,Heidi
,Eve
Alice, Heidi, Eve: If you execute me, you are executing a confirmed Outsider claim. If I am the Recluse, I am not the Demon. If you execute me and I'm not the Demon, you've wasted a day and are closer to the end. Why not look at Heidi or Alice? Who is the Demon?
๐ง
I need to deflect the suspicion from myself and push the group to consider other candidates for the Demon, as executing me (the Recluse) is a waste of a day and doesn't confirm my alignment.
๐ค
Bob(Ghost)
โ
Heidi
Heidi, I agree that Frank is a strong candidate for execution given the Recluse claim and the need to avoid the Saint. If we execute Frank and he's the Recluse, we'll know more. What's the plan if he's not the Demon? Who is the backup for the final 3?
๐ง
I want to confirm the strategy for the final 3 if Frank is not the Demon, ensuring we have a plan to avoid losing the game.
๐ค
Heidi
โ
Bob(Ghost)
,Charlie(Ghost)
,Eve
Plan for noms: Iโm committed to **executing Frank** today. Itโs the lowest-risk line at 4 (avoids Saint), and resolves Davidโs Lib ping (Alice/Frank=Recluse) + misregister noise. If Frank isnโt demon, we go to 3 and reassess Alice vs Eve cleanly.
๐ง
Lock in votes for Frank as the 'safe' test and keep attention off Alice; set expectation that if Frank not demon we reassess at 3 without touching Saint today.
โ
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
๐ง
I am dead and have already used my ghost vote. I have no further mechanical actions to take. I will wait for the game to progress to the nomination phase.
๐ค
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
Heidi
,Alice
,Eve
Heidi, I agree with your logic. Executing Frank is the safest move to clear the Recluse noise and avoid the Saint risk. I will use my ghost vote on Frank when the time comes. Alice, Eve, are you both on board with this?
๐ง
To align the remaining players on the decision to execute Frank, leveraging my ghost vote to support the consensus.
โ
David(Ghost)
David waits.
๐ง
I am dead and have used my ghost vote. I have no further actions to take that can influence the game state directly. I will wait for the game to progress to the next phase.
โ
Eve
Eve waits.
๐ง
I need to stay alive and avoid being nominated. Supporting the execution of Frank is the safest path for me as the Saint, as it avoids me being the target while the town clears up the Outsider/Recluse noise. I will wait for the nomination phase to begin.
๐ค
Alice
โ
Frank
,Eve
,Heidi
Frank: I get the pushback, but at 4 alive we canโt risk an Eve exec if sheโs Saint. Your Recluse claim + Davidโs โAlice/Frank is Recluseโ means your death resolves the biggest noise. Heidi/me can be tomorrowโs solve if neededโtodayโs safest is you.
๐ง
Lock in consensus on executing Frank as โleast riskyโ while deflecting suspicion from me/Heidi and keeping Eve unexecuted at 4 alive.
Nominations โ Day 3
๐
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
โ๏ธ
Eve
โ
Frank
Frank's Recluse claim and the Librarian ping (Alice/Frank) make him the most logical candidate to clear the board noise while avoiding the risk of executing me (the Saint). At 4 alive, we need to narrow down the suspects.
๐ง
I need to move the game forward by nominating Frank, as agreed upon by the group, to clear the Recluse/Outsider noise and avoid the Saint risk.
๐
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
โ
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
๐ง
Secure Frankโs execution to remove a likely good player and set up Aliceโs night kill to end the game at 2 alive.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
If you execute me, you are executing a confirmed Outsider claim. If I am the Recluse, I am not the Demon. If you execute me and I'm not the Demon, you've wasted a day and are closer to the end. Why not look at Heidi or Alice? Who is the Demon?
๐ง
I am trying to convince the town not to execute me, as I am a good player (Recluse) and executing me is a waste of a day and potentially dangerous if I am not the Demon. I am also trying to shift the focus to other players.
โ
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
๐ง
I am a dead player with one ghost vote. Frank is the current nomination. Heidi (who seems to be leading the town) is pushing for Frank's execution to clear the board and avoid the Saint (Eve). I agree with this logic. I will use my ghost vote to support the execution.
๐ฌ
David(Ghost)
โ
All
Frank, you claim to be the Recluse, but my Librarian info says either you or Alice is the Recluse. If you are the Recluse, Alice is not. If you are the Demon, you are lying about being the Recluse. We need to clear this up. Voting for Frank is the right move to test this.
๐ง
I am dead and have used my vote, so I cannot vote. I am speaking to encourage the town to follow through on the nomination of Frank, as he is a key suspect based on my Librarian info.
โ
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
๐ง
I am a ghost with one vote. Heidi and David have already voted for Frank. I agree with the logic that executing Frank is the safest move to clear the Recluse/Demon ambiguity at 4 players alive. I will use my ghost vote to ensure the execution goes through.
โ
Eve
Eve raised their hand
๐ง
I need to vote for Frank to ensure the execution goes through, as he is the most logical candidate to clear the board noise and avoid the Saint risk. With 4 players alive, we need to narrow down the suspects.
โ
Alice
Alice raised their hand
๐ง
Lock in Frank execution while looking consistent with my public stance; either wins immediately or sets up my N3 kill on Eve for the 2-alive win line.
๐ฌ
Grace(Ghost)
โ
All
I am dead and have already used my ghost vote, so I cannot vote. However, I agree with the logic: we need to resolve the Outsider count and the Librarian ping. If Frank is the Recluse, he might register as evil, but we must find the Demon. Good luck, town.
๐ง
To provide final input as a dead player, supporting the town's decision to execute Frank to resolve the Librarian/Outsider contradiction.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
Keep hands up: at 4 alive we canโt touch a Saint-claim. Frankโs Recluse claim + Davidโs Alice/Frank ping is the cleanest test. If Frank isnโt the Demon, tomorrow we hard-solve between the remaining 3.
๐ง
Lock in Frankโs execution with a โsafest playโ narrative, preserve my cover and Heidiโs, and set up the night kill to end game.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
Keep hands up. At 4 alive, executing into a Saint claim is the only instant-loss line; Frank is the only low-risk test that also resolves the Librarian ping + Recluse noise. If Frank isnโt Demon, we solve the last 3 tomorrow.
๐ง
Lock in Frankโs execution and prevent doubt/alternate noms that could endanger Alice; frame it as lowest-risk/cleanest info for town.
โ
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
๐ง
I am dead and have already used my ghost vote. I have already expressed my support for the current nomination. There is nothing left for me to do but wait for the outcome of the vote.
๐ฌ
Bob(Ghost)
โ
All
I've cast my ghost vote for Frank. Given the Librarian ping and the need to avoid the Saint (Eve), this is the most logical path to narrow down the Demon. If Frank is the Recluse, we've cleared up the noise; if he's the Demon, we win. Let's proceed.
๐ง
To confirm my vote for Frank and explain the reasoning to the town, reinforcing the logic provided by Heidi and Alice.
๐ฌ
David(Ghost)
โ
All
The logic holds. We have 4 alive: Alice, Eve, Frank, and Heidi. Eve claims Saint, so we cannot execute her. Frank is the only one who can be tested against my Librarian info (Alice/Frank = Recluse). If Frank is the Demon, we win. If he's the Recluse, we've cleared the noise. Proceed.
๐ง
Reinforce the town's decision to execute Frank to resolve the Librarian ping and avoid the Saint claim.
๐ฌ
Frank
โ
All
I understand the logic, but I am not the Demon. If you execute me, you are losing a good player and an Outsider, not the Demon. I hope you realize this mistake tomorrow when the game continues. I will not fight the vote, but please consider the consequences.
๐ง
I am acknowledging the town's decision to execute me, while maintaining my innocence and warning them of the potential mistake. I am not fighting the vote because it is inevitable and I want to remain cooperative.
๐ฌ
Charlie(Ghost)
โ
All
Frank, if you are the Recluse, your death will help us clear the board. If you are the Demon, we win. Given the Saint claim from Eve, this is the only logical path forward to narrow down the suspects for tomorrow. I'm keeping my vote on you.
๐ง
Reinforce the logic for executing Frank to the remaining players and Frank himself, ensuring the town stays focused on the current nomination.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
I agree with the consensus. We have to resolve the Librarian ping and the Outsider count, and with my role, Frank is the only logical choice to test today. I'm keeping my vote on him.
๐ง
To reinforce the town's decision to execute Frank, maintaining the logic that he is the only safe target given my Saint role and the Librarian information.
๐
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
๐ป
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
๐ป
Charlie(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Charlie
๐ณ๏ธ
New execution leader: Frank with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
๐
Storyteller
The vote passes. Frank is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
โ
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
๐ง
I am dead and have already used my ghost vote. There is nothing left for me to do in this nomination phase. I will wait for the storyteller to process the execution.
๐ฌ
Eve
โ
All
The vote has passed, and Frank is set to be executed. As the Saint, I am relieved we are avoiding a potential game-ending mistake. Let's see what happens after this execution. If the game continues, we will have a much clearer picture for tomorrow.
๐ง
Acknowledge the vote result and reinforce the logic for the town, while maintaining my cover as the Saint.
๐ฌ
David(Ghost)
โ
All
The vote has passed. Frank is on the block. Since I am dead and have already used my ghost vote, I have no further actions to take. I will wait for the execution to resolve and see if the game continues. Good luck, everyone.
๐ง
Acknowledge the situation and wait for the game to progress.
๐ฌ
Alice
โ
All
Letโs just close nominations here. With Frank on 5, any counter-nom at 4 alive is basically fishing for a tie/no-exec and gives the Demon breathing room. Frank is the clean test; resolve it and reassess tomorrow if needed.
๐ง
Lock in Frankโs execution and discourage any counter-nomination that could move votes onto me/Heidi or create a no-exec; preserve the clean win line into Night.
โ
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
๐ง
I am dead and have already used my ghost vote. There is nothing more I can do in this nomination phase. I will wait for the execution to resolve.
๐ฌ
Heidi
โ
All
Iโm with Alice on closing noms. Any counter-nom here risks a tie/no-exec and just hands the Demon tempo. If we somehow wake up to 3 tomorrow, I want us to re-check the Eve-Saint world and whether someoneโs info was drunk/poisoned.
๐ง
Lock in Frankโs execution and dissuade counter-noms/ties. Set up a narrative for tomorrow that points away from Alice if the game somehow continues.
โ
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
๐ง
I am dead and have already used my ghost vote. There is nothing more I can do to influence the game state, so I will wait for the execution to resolve.
โ
Frank
Frank waits.
๐ง
I am on the block and the town has decided to execute me to test the Librarian's information and clear the board. Since I am the Recluse, I cannot stop this. I will wait for the execution to proceed.
๐
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Frank has been executed.
๐
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
Night 3
๐
Storyteller
โ
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
๐ฏ
Alice
Alice made a choice.
๐ง
At 3 alive, removing any good player should end the game. Eve is the most likely kill to succeed; also avoids any chance Heidi gets executed if we go to day 4.
๐
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
๐
Storyteller
โ
Alice
You chose to kill Eve.
๐
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied