Game Detail

As Butler on Night 0 with no information, I need to pick a master whose voting pattern will likely align with the good team. Grace is my neighbor, making coordination easier, and I have no reason to suspect them yet.

Reveal my Butler role to Grace since my vote is tied to her, and try to learn her role to assess if she's trustworthy.

Start building trust with my neighbor Bob since my Empath reading of 0 suggests he's good. Share my Empath info to establish credibility and get information from him.

I want to coordinate with my Demon, Eve, on Day 1 to get our bluffs and figure out our strategy.

Coordinate bluffs with my minion David on Day 1.

Build trust with Frank who claims Butler, which matches my Librarian info, while keeping my exact role hidden to avoid Demon targeting.

Build an early alliance with my neighbor Bob to share information and gauge trustworthiness. As Undertaker, my info comes later after executions, so Day 1 is about building connections.

Share my Investigator info with my neighbor Grace to start building a trusted alliance. As an info role, I need allies who can help act on my info while protecting me from Demon targeting.

I want to build a trust network with Alice since she shared her role info. Sharing my Chef info (1 pair) confirms the standard setup and is useful but not dangerous to share. This helps the good team coordinate.

Follow up with Grace to learn more about her role and starting info, which could help identify good players and narrow down suspects.

I want to confirm my other neighbor Heidi is on my side and learn her role. Since my Empath read was 0, Heidi is good (unless I'm drunk/poisoned). Building trust with both neighbors gives me a solid good-player alliance.

I am communicating with my Demon, Eve, to confirm my bluff (Monk) and coordinate for the coming nights.

I want to establish a connection with my other neighbor, Frank, to gather information and start building a social relationship that can help me deflect suspicion later.

Share my Librarian info with Heidi to cross-reference with her Investigator claim. If Frank is Butler, David is Scarlet Woman. If Frank is Scarlet Woman, Charlie is Butler. This helps triangulate evil.

Establish communication with my other neighbor David to build trust and gather information early in the game.

Share Alice's Empath claim with Grace and discuss whether Frank's Butler claim could be a cover for being the Scarlet Woman. Building trust with Grace and analyzing the evil team.

I want to gather more information from Charlie before sharing my own role details with him. Alice already knows I'm Chef, so I need to build a wider network of trusted players to cross-reference claims.

Respond to Eve's question without revealing my Butler role, while fishing for information from her. Keep my identity limited to Grace who already knows and seems trustworthy.

Bob claimed Chef and my Empath read of 0 confirms he's good. I want to coordinate with him to share information since he seems well-connected and I can trust him mechanically.

Whisper back to Charlie to build trust. I will claim no starting information (consistent with my Monk bluff) and ask him what he knows.

I want to build trust with my neighbor Frank by privately claiming Ravenkeeper (one of my safe bluffs) and asking him to keep it secret. This fits the typical Ravenkeeper playstyle and makes me look good.

I need to gauge Charlie's role claim. If Charlie is the Butler (as my Librarian info suggests is possible), they might claim it. If Charlie claims something else entirely, that supports Frank being the Butler and potentially David being the Scarlet Woman. This is the last day tick before nominations, so I need to gather this info now.

Bob already shared Alice's Empath claim and said he has a role and info. I need to get his claim too. Since I'm Undertaker and have no info yet (no executions), I can safely claim my role to Bob to build trust and get his info in return. It's the last tick before nominations so I need to act fast.

Share my Investigator info with Alice to build trust, coordinate for nominations, and get her input on whether to target David or Frank today.

Share my Chef info with Charlie to build trust and coordinate, since he shared his Undertaker claim with me. Also gather more info from him before nominations.

I want to prompt the group to see if anyone has info to share or if we are going to end the day without an execution, which is beneficial for the evil team on Day 1.

Agree with Eve to encourage going to night without executing, keeping the evil team safe on Day 1 while appearing cautious and helpful.

Share my Investigator info publicly and nominate David as the likely Scarlet Woman, since Frank claiming Butler corroborates with Grace's Librarian info, making David the more probable evil player.

Share my Chef info publicly to help town verify claims and analyze the Scarlet Woman/Butler situation before any hasty execution.

Confirm my Butler role publicly to validate the info chain and logically prove David is the Scarlet Woman, supporting his nomination while reminding town to hunt the Demon.

Nominate David as the most likely Scarlet Woman based on confirmed good player Heidi's Investigator info and Frank's Butler claim.

I need to defend myself against the mounting evidence by claiming a valuable good role (Monk) and proposing alternative explanations (like Frank being a Recluse or Grace being the Drunk) to discourage players from voting for my execution.

I want to express hesitation to seem like a cautious, analytical good player (Ravenkeeper) without actively defending David too hard, while preparing to either vote or not based on how the rest of the town reacts.

Vote for David because the mechanical case is strong: my Investigator info says David or Frank is Scarlet Woman, Grace's Librarian info says Charlie or Frank is Butler, and Frank claimed Butler. If Frank is truthful Butler, David is the Scarlet Woman. David claiming Monk is exactly what a caught Scarlet Woman would do.

Vote for David based on strong corroborating evidence: Heidi (confirmed good by Alice's Empath) says David or Frank is Scarlet Woman, Grace's Librarian says Charlie or Frank is Butler, and Frank claims Butler. If Frank is truthful Butler, David must be Scarlet Woman. David's Monk claim could easily be a fake defense.

Counter David's defense and encourage votes while being transparent about my Butler restriction

Voting for David because the evidence chain is strong: Heidi is confirmed good by my Empath reading, her Investigator info says David or Frank is Scarlet Woman, and Frank's Butler claim is backed by Grace's Librarian info. If Frank is truthful Butler, David must be Scarlet Woman.

The logical chain against David is strong: Heidi (Investigator, confirmed good by Alice's Empath) says David or Frank is Scarlet Woman. Grace (Librarian) says Charlie or Frank is Butler. Frank claims Butler. I know I'm NOT Butler, so if Grace is truthful, Frank IS Butler, making David the Scarlet Woman. Even if wrong, as Undertaker I learn the executed character tonight, which will confirm or refute the entire chain. Voting David gives us information either way.

Vote for David's execution. The evidence chain is strong: my Librarian info confirms Frank is Butler, and Heidi's Investigator info then points to David as Scarlet Woman. Alice's Empath 0 reading confirms Heidi is good. David's defense about me being Drunk or Frank being Recluse is weaker than the clean consistent chain. 4 votes are already in, so my vote also ensures Frank (as Butler) can participate if needed.

I am on the block and facing execution. I need to defend myself by claiming to be the Monk and sowing doubt about the good team's info, specifically suggesting that Heidi or Alice might be the Drunk, to protect my demon Eve and cause confusion.

I will speak to express my resignation to the town's decision. Since David already has 5 votes, my vote isn't needed. Not voting fits my hesitant Ravenkeeper persona perfectly.

Counter David's Recluse defense and reinforce the case for voting him out, since the vote is already passing.

The vote already has 5 hands raised (Heidi, me, Alice, Charlie, Grace), exceeding the 4 needed for execution. Speaking further won't change the outcome. David's defenses about Drunk/Recluse are weak since they require multiple information sources to be wrong simultaneously, which is unlikely given the mechanical overlap between Heidi's Investigator and Grace's Librarian claims. Best to wait and let the vote conclude.

Vote for David's execution since Grace (my master) is voting and the evidence against David as Scarlet Woman is strong.

Reinforce the case against David and counter his defense that I might be Drunk, to ensure the vote goes through.

Publicly claim Undertaker so the town knows that David's role will be verified after execution. This adds confidence to the vote and establishes my role for future days.

The vote is already passing with 5+ votes. David's defenses are weak - the Recluse doesn't explain my Librarian Outsider info, and the Drunk argument for Heidi doesn't undermine the case since my Librarian info independently confirms Frank as Butler, pointing to David as Scarlet Woman. Nothing more to do this tick.

Establish my bluff as the Monk and set up a plausible narrative for why the Undertaker (Charlie) will be killed tonight by the Demon (Eve), preventing my actual role (Scarlet Woman) from being revealed.

I will wait to allow the nomination phase to end and David to be executed. Attempting to save him now with 6 votes against him would draw too much suspicion to myself, and as the Demon, my survival is paramount. I can handle the Undertaker claim tonight.

Reassure the group and counter David's fear tactic about Charlie being unprotected, while pointing out that if David is evil, the real Monk is still alive and could protect Charlie.

Publicly confirm my Chef claim and information before David is executed, so the town has verified information going into Day 2.

The day is effectively over. David has 6 votes and will be executed. No more nominations are possible. Nothing productive to add before night falls.

The vote is settled with 6 votes on David. He will be executed. Charlie will verify David's role tonight as Undertaker. Nothing more to do this phase.

David is already on the block with 6 votes and will be executed. No further action needed - I'll learn his character tonight as Undertaker.

The vote is settled at 6 votes for David. Only 1 tick remains before night falls. Nothing I say or do now will change the outcome. Better to preserve information and let Charlie's Undertaker ability verify David's role tonight.

Kill Charlie to prevent him from using his Undertaker ability to confirm David was the Scarlet Woman, keeping the town in the dark about David's true alignment.

Choose Grace as master again since she is mechanically confirmed good (her Librarian info matched my Butler claim) and her voting judgment can be trusted tomorrow.

Discuss Charlie's death and its implications with Grace. Charlie was Undertaker who would have learned David's true role. The Demon killing Charlie suggests they wanted to silence this. I need to reason through whether David was actually Scarlet Woman or Monk, as this points to Heidi's alignment.

I want to check in with Frank, to whom I claimed Ravenkeeper yesterday, to see what he and Grace are discussing and maintain my good persona.

Share my Empath info with my confirmed-good neighbors to build a trusted alliance and coordinate for nominations.

Coordinate with my Demon (Eve) now that Charlie is dead and Alice's Empath info might trap her.

Share my Undertaker analysis with mechanically verified good players to narrow down the Demon among Eve and Grace.

Coordinate with confirmed-good players to share Undertaker info and narrow down the Demon. Need to know Charlie's result to determine if David was SW or Monk.

Share Charlie's vague Undertaker claim with my trusted allies and push for concrete information. Charlie didn't state his actual result which is critical for solving the game.

Share my logical deduction with Frank to build trust and coordinate on identifying evil players. The key insight is that Alice's Empath 0 contradicts Heidi being evil, so we need to figure out which one is lying or misinformed.

Share my deduction about Heidi being evil and Alice being compromised, get Grace and Eve on board to execute Heidi today.

Defend myself against Frank's accusation by providing a logical alternative where Heidi is the Demon and Alice is the Minion who lied about Empath 0 to protect her, explaining Charlie's death.

Charlie claimed Undertaker but didn't give his specific result about David's role. I need the exact character name to determine if David was Scarlet Woman (confirming Frank as Butler and Demon among Eve/Grace) or if David was truly Monk (meaning Frank is lying and likely the Scarlet Woman).

Cast doubt on the logical deduction that Eve is the Demon. I want to suggest to Bob that either he is the Drunk (making his Chef 1 info incorrect) or Heidi is the Demon who sacrificed her Minion (me) to get confirmed, meaning his Chef info might be wrong or there's another explanation.

Share my Undertaker result with Alice to confirm David was Scarlet Woman and narrow down the Demon search among living players.

Get Charlie's Undertaker result on David's role to confirm whether David was Scarlet Woman or Monk, which will determine whether the Demon is among Eve/Grace or elsewhere.

Press Charlie for his actual Undertaker result - he's been suspiciously vague. This info is critical: if David was Scarlet Woman, Demon is Eve/Grace. If David was Monk, Frank is lying. Also loop in Alice since she's trusted.

I want to refine our theory about who the Demon is, since we seem aligned on Heidi being evil. Frank suggested Eve as Demon; I want to also consider Bob as a possibility and get Frank's input.

Coordinate nomination strategy with Grace and Eve before the nomination phase. Need to decide between Heidi and Bob as primary target, while considering that Grace raised Bob as a possibility.

Support Frank's plan to nominate Heidi. This redirects suspicion away from me, capitalizes on the town's belief that David was the Monk (meaning they think a Minion is still alive), and provides an explanation (poisoning or Bob being evil) if Alice reveals an Empath 1 reading on me.

Share my consolidated analysis with trusted allies Bob and Heidi, identifying Eve as the most likely Demon based on mechanical deductions.

Coordinate with my Demon Eve to see how she is handling the solve. Since Charlie died, he likely saw me as Scarlet Woman, and Chef 1 heavily implicates Eve as my neighbor. We need a unified defense, possibly pushing that Bob is the Drunk or Charlie is evil/lying.

Share my Undertaker result with Bob who is confirmed good by Alice's Empath, and lay out the mechanical deduction that the Demon is Eve or Grace.

Share the critical Butler-master dynamic with trusted allies and strategize for the nomination phase

Coordinate with my confirmed good circle to pressure Eve for a role claim and narrow down the Demon between Eve and Grace before nominations.

Confirm the plan to nominate Heidi and provide a verification framework: if Heidi is the Poisoner, Alice's Empath will reset tonight, giving us a mechanical check. Also flag Bob as a backup suspect.

Present the logical case publicly before nominating Eve, so the group understands my reasoning and can vote accordingly.

Support Alice's nomination of Eve by reinforcing the logical case and pressuring Eve to claim a role, while keeping Grace as a backup suspect.

Defend myself against Alice's nomination by claiming Ravenkeeper (which I already soft-claimed to Frank and Grace) and pushing the Poisoner-Heidi theory we discussed in private.

To defend Eve (the Demon) by endorsing her Poisoner theory about Heidi. Since I am dead, I cannot become the Demon if Eve dies, so I must protect her at all costs. This speech outlines the logical feasibility of the Poisoner timeline to cast doubt on the accusations against Eve.

Nominate Heidi as the most likely evil player (Poisoner) to remove poison from Alice's Empath and verify the theory before final days.

Defend myself against the Poisoner accusation by pointing out that my Investigator info was confirmed correct by Charlie's Undertaker reading, which proves I'm the real Investigator.

Defend Heidi by pointing out the logical consistency of her Investigator info matching Charlie's Undertaker, and that Eve's late claim is suspicious.

Defend Heidi with logical deduction - if Heidi were the Poisoner, Alice's N1 Empath reading would be real and should show 1 (since Heidi would be evil neighbor), but Alice got 0 both nights. This proves Heidi is good.

I must vote for Heidi to ensure she gets executed. This secures a mis-execution, keeps me safe from Alice's nomination, and maintains our path to victory.

I need to vote for Heidi to secure a high vote count on her, which will protect my Demon (Eve) from being executed if she gets nominated later today.

Correct my mistake about Heidi being the Poisoner. The Night 0 Empath reading is unpoisonable, confirming Heidi good. Redirect suspicion to Eve.

Heidi is confirmed good by multiple independent sources: my Undertaker result matches her Investigator info, and Alice's unpoisoned N0 Empath reading clears Heidi. I must save my ghost vote for the Demon, likely Eve.

Support the logical consensus that clears Heidi and points to Eve as the Demon. Clarify that I'm not voting for Heidi (both because logic clears her and my Butler restriction means I can only vote when Grace votes, and Grace isn't voting).

I am being voted on but the defense is solid. Only evil players (Eve, David) are voting for me. Alice, Bob, Grace, and Frank have all backed off. I should not vote for my own execution, and speaking more might seem desperate. Better to let the vote fail and then support Eve's nomination.

I will not vote for Heidi. My Empath confirms she is good, and two independent sources confirmed David was Scarlet Woman. The vote currently has only 2 votes (Eve and David - both evil or misled). Grace, Frank, and Bob have all indicated they won't vote. I should wait and let this nomination fail, then focus on Eve.

Not voting for Heidi - the evidence strongly shows she is good. Poisoner doesn't act Night 0, so Alice's Empath 0 is clean and confirms Heidi good. Two independent confirmations of David as SW. Eve is the likely Demon.

Lowering my hand to align with the town's consensus and avoid looking like a desperate Demon pushing a failing vote on Heidi.

Correct the mechanical misconception that the Poisoner doesn't act on Night 0, in order to redirect suspicion back onto Heidi and save the Demon (Eve).

Counter David's ghost argument about Poisoner acting Night 0, while maintaining the position that Heidi is still likely good based on Alice's Night 1 reading being unpoisoned.

Counter David the Scarlet Womans false narrative and support the logical case that Heidi is good, saving my ghost vote for later.

Push the town toward nominating Eve as the Demon by laying out the clear logical chain that eliminates all other suspects.

Nominate Eve as the most likely Demon before the nomination phase ends. All evidence points to Eve - she claimed late, deflected, and is the only unconfirmed player who could be the Imp.

Defend myself against the accusation of claiming Ravenkeeper late by explaining standard Ravenkeeper strategy to discourage players from voting for me.

Eve is the most likely Demon. With David confirmed as the sole Minion (Scarlet Woman), there's no Poisoner. Alice's clean Empath zeros confirm me and Bob good. Frank's Butler matches Grace's Librarian. Eve is the only unaccounted player who could be the Imp. I must vote to execute her.

Vote to execute Eve, the most likely Demon based on process of elimination and mechanical deductions.

Eve is the most likely Demon. All other players are mechanically accounted for: David=SW(dead), Alice=Empath confirmed good, Bob(me)=Chef good, Heidi=Investigator confirmed good by cross-verification, Frank=Butler confirmed by Grace's Librarian, Grace=Librarian confirmed by Frank's Butler. Eve is the only unaccounted player and claimed Ravenkeeper only after being nominated. Must vote to execute the Demon.

I need to convince Alice, Bob, or someone else to lower their hand on Eve's vote by casting doubt on Frank and Grace, arguing that Eve could actually be the Ravenkeeper.

Voting for Eve because the evidence overwhelmingly points to her as the Demon. David confirmed Scarlet Woman means no Poisoner exists, Alice's Empath readings confirm Heidi/Bob good, Frank's Butler matches my Librarian, and Eve's late Ravenkeeper claim is classic Demon deflection.

Save my precious ghost vote for final day since Eve's execution is already secured with 4 votes (Heidi, Alice, Bob, Grace) exceeding the 3 needed.

Eve is the Demon by process of elimination. Grace is voting, so my Butler restriction allows me to vote. Must secure this execution.

To convince Grace and Frank to lower their hands by sowing doubt about Bob being the Poisoner who orchestrated the framing of David and myself.

Counter Eve's desperate deflection about Bob being Poisoner. Remind everyone that David=Scarlet Woman means no Poisoner exists, so Eve's claim is impossible. Secure the execution vote.

Reinforce the logical case for voting Eve and counter her desperate deflection attempts, keeping votes firm.

Reinforce the vote on Eve by revealing my Chef information to confirm the mechanical deduction that there are exactly 2 evil players, making Eve the Demon.

To convince players (specifically Grace) to lower their hands by pointing out that the Poisoner can poison the same target multiple nights in a row, invalidating the 'clean Empath' theory.

Keep my vote for Eve raised. The logic chain is airtight: David is confirmed Scarlet Woman by two independent sources, meaning the one Minion slot is filled and no Poisoner exists. Alice's Empath zeros are clean, confirming Bob and Heidi good. Frank matches my Librarian info. Eve is the only possible Demon. David's desperation as a dead Minion to save Eve only confirms she's the Demon.

Counter David's desperate misinformation and reinforce the vote on Eve, who is almost certainly the Demon.

Vote on Eve is secure with 5 hands raised (Heidi, Alice, Bob, Grace, Frank), well above the 3 needed. No need to speak further and risk muddying the waters. David's ghost arguments have been thoroughly refuted by Charlie and others.

I need to nominate someone to try to divert the execution away from myself. Since I am the Demon, my execution means an immediate loss for the evil team. Nominating Bob and pushing the 'Bob is Demon' narrative is my only survival option.

Prevent anyone from voting for me and reinforce that Eve is the Demon being executed

I am on the block and about to be executed. I need to persuade at least some good players (Alice, Frank, Grace) to vote for Bob to force a tie and save myself.

Prevent anyone from voting for Bob by reinforcing the mechanical proof that he is good and Eve is the Demon.

Prevent Bob from getting votes since he is confirmed good by my Empath readings. Eve is the Demon and already on the block with 5 votes.

To sow doubt and convince Grace and Frank to vote for Bob, tying the vote and saving the Demon (Eve) from execution. I am pushing the narrative that I am the actual Monk who was framed by an evil duo of Heidi and Bob.

Reinforce the logic chain that Eve is the Demon and discourage anyone from voting for Bob, which could tie the vote and save the Demon.

Eve is nominating Bob to try to tie the vote and survive execution. I need to remind everyone of my Undertaker confirmation and urge them not to vote for Bob.

Eve is on the block with 5 votes and will be executed. The good team is unified against Bob's nomination. Grace is not voting for Bob, so I cannot vote either. There is no need to speak - the execution is secure.

The vote on me (Bob) is happening, but the consensus against voting for me is overwhelming. Alice, Heidi, Grace, Charlie, and Frank are all keeping hands down. Eve needs 5 votes to tie, which she won't get. Eve is already on the block with 5 votes and will be executed. No need to speak further and risk seeming desperate.

I must vote for Bob to attempt to tie or surpass the votes on me and prevent my execution. Since I am on the block, getting Bob executed or tied is my only hope of survival.

Bob is confirmed good by Alice's Empath zeros. Eve is the Demon desperately trying to tie the vote. I must not vote for Bob - keep hands down.

Do not vote for Bob. He is confirmed good by my Empath zeros. Eve is the confirmed Demon and is already on the block with 5 votes. Voting for Bob could create a tie and jeopardize Eve's execution.

I need to convince Frank or Grace to vote for Bob to tie the vote. If Eve is executed, evil loses. I am arguing that Alice might be the Drunk, which would validate Bob being the Demon.

I must not vote for Bob. The logic chain is airtight: David=Scarlet Woman (2 sources), no Poisoner exists, Alice's Empath confirms Bob good. Eve is the Demon and already on the block with 5 votes. Voting for Bob would only help Eve tie and survive.

Do not vote for Bob. Eve is the Demon and is already on the block with 5 votes. Voting for Bob could tie the vote at 5-5, letting Eve escape execution. Save my ghost vote for when it truly matters.

Reinforce the logical case against Eve and prevent anyone from voting for Bob, which would risk tying the vote and saving the Demon.

Eve is on the block with 5 votes and voting is closed. She will be executed. All evidence points to Eve being the Demon - she's the only unconfirmed living player, David fills the Minion slot, and Eve's late Ravenkeeper claim is suspicious. No action needed, just let the execution happen.

Make a last-ditch defense of my Ravenkeeper claim to maintain cover and sow doubt in the good team before my execution.

Eve has 5 votes and is about to be executed. Voting is closed on Bob's nomination. This is the final tick of the nomination phase. Eve is the Demon based on overwhelming evidence: David confirmed SW by Investigator+Undertaker, no Poisoner possible, Alice Empath zeros clean, Bob Chef confirms 1 pair. Let the execution happen.

Eve is on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close in 1 tick. The vote for Bob just failed (1/6). The logic is airtight: David=SW confirmed, only 1 Minion slot, no Poisoner, my Empath zeros are clean, Bob and Heidi confirmed good, Eve is the Demon. No action needed - just let the execution happen.

I am dead and out of votes, and Eve is about to be executed. I will speak one last time to cast suspicion on Bob and Heidi to set up potential chaos, playing my role to the end.

The execution is a foregone conclusion with 1 tick remaining. Eve has 5 votes and will be executed. No action needed - just let it play out.

The nomination phase is essentially over. Eve has 5 votes and will be executed. The mechanical case is overwhelming: David=SW (my Undertaker info + Heidi's Investigator), Frank=Butler (Grace's Librarian), Bob=Chef (1 evil pair), Alice=Empath 0s confirming Bob+Heidi good. Eve is the only unconfirmed player = Demon. Nothing to add at this point.

The execution is imminent and there's nothing more to do. Eve has 5 votes and will be executed. The logic is airtight: Chef=1 evil pair, Empath 0s confirm Bob & Heidi good, Investigator confirmed David=SW, Undertaker confirmed David=SW, Librarian confirmed me=Butler. This fills all slots perfectly with Eve as the Demon. If Eve dies as Demon, good wins. No action needed.