Game Detail

I am selecting Eve as my master for the first day. This is a neutral choice as I don't have any information on players yet. Choosing a neighbor makes it easier to keep track of their voting behavior during the day.

I need to establish a connection with my master, Eve, to ensure I can vote effectively and to start building trust. Informing her of my role also helps account for the Outsider count.

Coordinate secretly with Alice to align on safe bluffs and initial strategy, building evil team unity without raising suspicion.

Respond to Heidi to confirm bluffs and start coordinating evil strategy without revealing our roles. This builds our secret alliance early to protect the Demon.

I want to verify my Librarian information with David privately before the information becomes public. If David is the Recluse, it confirms my info. If not, Grace is likely the Recluse or I am poisoned/drunk.

I am reaching out to Frank to see if his claim or behavior suggests he is the evil neighbor I detected. Sharing my info early with a neighbor can help narrow things down.

I want to observe the initial dynamics and see who approaches whom before I start sharing or gathering information. As the Saint, I need to be careful not to get executed, so I'm playing it safe early on.

I need to correct Charlie's information while sharing my own. Since I know I am not an Outsider, Grace must be the Recluse (if Charlie is sober and telling the truth). Sharing the Baron info helps narrow down the Minion.

Acknowledge Frank's claim and establish a line of communication while setting up a defensive/offensive bluff strategy as Ravenkeeper.

Acknowledge Eve's plan to bait the Demon and share the information I just received from Grace to build trust and start coordinating.

Coordinate with Alice on our bluffs to build false trust and misdirect town suspicions toward good players like Bob, keeping me and Alice safe for now.

Continue coordinating with the Demon to solidify our bluffs and plan how to sow doubt about Bob, advancing our evil plan by confusing the town early.

Acknowledge David's claim and cross-reference his Investigator info with my Librarian info to narrow down the game state.

I need to cross-reference my Empath '1' reading with Heidi's claim. By talking to both neighbors, I can compare their roles and behavior to see who is more likely to be the evil one.

I want to open a line of communication with Charlie to see if David shared any roles or info, while staying vague about my own role for now.

I want to coordinate with Charlie to verify the presence of the Baron and the Recluse, which will help determine the game state and identify potential Minions.

I want to verify Grace's Empath claim and get her perspective on the seating order, especially since I'm sitting between David and Frank. and she's between Frank and Heidi.

I am sharing my role with Grace to help her narrow down her Empath info. By confirming I am the Butler (good), it implies Heidi is the evil neighbor if Grace's info is true.

Waiting allows more player interactions and claims to surface without me revealing too much too soon. This keeps my Imp identity hidden, lets Alice and I refine our story based on new info, and positions me to sow chaos once nominations approach.

Wait to observe reactions to my whisper and ongoing conversations, giving time for the evil plan to sow doubt on Bob without further action that might backfire this tick.

I want to share my information with Bob to see how he reacts and to potentially build trust, while also gathering information about his role.

Respond to Eve's query and try to gather her role to see if her story matches Frank's or if they are colluding.

I need to reveal my role to Charlie since he shared Librarian info that doesn't include me. This suggests either a Baron is in play (adding more Outsiders) or Charlie/David is lying. Revealing my Saint status early to a potential Librarian helps establish the Outsider count.

I need to verify if Grace is the Recluse to determine if Charlie's Librarian info is correct and whether a Baron (as per my Investigator info) has added extra Outsiders.

I am informing Grace of my bluff (claiming Slayer) so she knows I'm actually the Ravenkeeper and doesn't get confused by my public claim. This builds trust with a potential Empath.

I need to share my Investigator information and Charlie's Librarian information with the group to start building a picture of the game state and identify potential evil players.

I need to come out as the Saint to explain why there are multiple Outsiders and steer the town away from executing me, while supporting the leads provided by David and Charlie.

Claiming Chef publicly and questioning David's Investigator info deflects suspicion from me as Baron, sows chaos between good players, and aligns with our evil coordination to keep Demon safe.

I need to publicize my Librarian information to corroborate David's claim while also questioning Alice's Chef claim to see if it holds up under scrutiny.

I am following through with my plan to bluff as the Slayer to bait the Demon into killing me tonight, which would trigger my Ravenkeeper ability. I also want to press for more information regarding the conflicting claims.

Waiting to see if anyone else speaks or nominates before committing, allowing more info to emerge while my FT claim circulates and disrupts the Investigator vs Chef clash.

I need to share my Empath info publicly now that nominations have started. By combining my '1' (Frank or Heidi) with David's Investigator info (Alice or Frank), Frank becomes a very strong candidate for the Baron.

Address the conflicting information and defend myself against David's Investigator claim while pointing out the likely Baron presence.

Killing Eve the Slayer neutralizes her ability to kill the Demon later once she gathers info from clashes. This protects my survival while the public contradictions between David, Grace, Alice, and Charlie create chaos and misdirection for good players to argue over.

I died on Night 1 as the Ravenkeeper, which is ideal. I will check Alice because her Chef claim contradicts David's Investigator claim (which identified Alice or Frank as the Baron). Identifying if Alice is indeed the Baron or the Demon will help resolve the conflicting information between David, Alice, and Frank.

I am choosing Grace as my master for tomorrow because she is a confirmed Empath who I've already shared my role with, and Eve, my previous master, is now dead.

Whisper to Demon to align on strategy, support claims that help us, and plan who to nominate to protect Heidi and create chaos.

Re-establish contact with Grace, my current 'master', and focus suspicion on Heidi based on Grace's Empath info.

I want to test Frank's claim and compare it with the Investigator's information while maintaining a dialogue to see if he slips up or provides more clarity.

Build on Alice's whisper by suggesting a joint strategy to undermine Grace's Empath claim and position myself as helpful with a safe bluff while protecting the Demon's survival.

I want to check in with David to see if he has new information and to solidify the 'Grace is the Recluse' theory, which helps confirm his Investigator claim.

I want to share my hard information with David, who I believe is a trusted Townsfolk (Investigator), to coordinate Alice's execution. Knowing Alice is the Baron confirms David's info and discredits Alice's Chef claim.

I need to clarify Eve's claim shift from Slayer to Ravenkeeper while confirming the Baron information.

I am waiting to observe the outcomes of the private conversations and to see if anyone approaches me with new information or if the suspected 'Baron' candidates (Alice/Frank) reveal anything further.

Coordinate with Heidi on her FT bluff and nomination plan for Grace. Suggest my bluff as Chef to add chaos and support evil without contradicting. This helps by building trust in Heidi and sowing doubt on good claims to keep Demon safe.

I need to clarify Grace's N2 info and address the Baron theory. If she still has a '1', and I know I'm good, it narrows the evil to Heidi or a Baron-Frank. By pointing out Alice could be the Baron, I'm trying to shift suspicion.

Respond to Frank's query while maintaining a level of healthy suspicion, as he is one of my neighbors who could be evil.

Waiting allows other players to share more information or nominations before I act further. This keeps me from overcommitting early and lets Alice or others push the plan.

To test Grace's reaction and gather her Night 1 information. Since my Librarian info points to her or David, and David has a solid Investigator claim, Grace is the most likely candidate for the Recluse (or the Drunk thinking they are Empath).

Explain my bluff to David to build trust and coordinate the execution of the Baron (Alice).

I am sharing the breakthrough information from Eve (Ravenkeeper) with Charlie (Librarian) to build a solid case against Alice and confirm Grace's status as the Recluse.

I want to check Alice's reaction to the Baron accusation and see if her Chef info (one evil pair) aligns with the current seating and claims, while keeping my Saint role low-profile but acknowledged.

Respond to Bob's whisper by bluffing as Chef with zero pairs to deflect David's suspicion, build rapport with Bob, and subtly point at Frank to create good team infighting while protecting our Demon Heidi.

I want to solidify my alliance with Grace and gauge her stance on Heidi vs Alice. Since I'm bound to her vote, I need to know where she's leaning to help guide the town.

I need to clarify my role to Charlie to counter the Recluse suspicion while also sharing my Empath information to help piece together the puzzle.

Coordinate with minion Alice on bluffs and nomination of Grace to remove potential good info gatherer, counter David's claim subtly, and advance our evil plan before nominations start.

Coordinate with David based on Grace's rebuttal. Grace is doubling down on Empath, which conflicts with my Librarian info if David is the Investigator. I need to see how David reconciles Eve's Ravenkeeper info with Grace's persistent Empath claim.

Share my confirmed information with Charlie to build a consensus against Alice (the Baron) and verify the world where Alice/Frank are the Investigator's pings.

I want to coordinate with Charlie to focus our efforts on Alice, who is now confirmed as the Baron by both my initial info and Eve's Ravenkeeper check.

I want to cross-reference Alice's Chef info with Grace's Empath info to see if they are consistent, while also reminding her of my Saint status to avoid execution.

I want to point out the contradiction in Alice's claim to the group. She previously claimed one evil pair (Day 1 summary) but just told me zero in private. This inconsistency needs to be public.

Highlight Alice's inconsistency and support the Baron theory while maintaining my Butler role's restriction.

I am nominating Alice because multiple pieces of information (my Investigator ping, Eve's Ravenkeeper check, and her inconsistent Chef claim) all point to her being the Baron.

Defend against execution by questioning David's Investigator ping and Eve's fake confirmation as Ravenkeeper (she claimed Slayer), redirect suspicion to David or Frank to split votes and keep me alive to support the Demon.

I will wait to see if Alice's defense holds weight and if more votes come in, as I do not want to be the deciding vote on a potential good player when I myself am a Saint who cannot be executed.

I need to see if Grace votes for Alice before I can vote, due to my Butler restriction.

I am voting to execute Alice because my Investigator information and Eve's Ravenkeeper information both point to her being the Baron. Alice is also attempting to gaslight the group about her previous claims.

Alice is the Baron. I know this for a fact because I am the Ravenkeeper and I checked her when I died. I need to use my ghost vote to ensure she is executed.

I am voting for Alice because David's Investigator ping and Alice's reported inconsistency make her a strong candidate for being the Baron, which fits the current game state.

I am the fourth vote needed to reach the threshold for Alice's execution. Based on my Librarian information and the claims from David and Eve, Alice is the most likely candidate for the Baron. Executing her confirms our information and removes a Minion.

Defend Alice from execution using my Fortune Teller bluff to contradict David, build my good credibility, and redirect focus to Grace as per our plan. This keeps the minion alive and sows chaos among good players.

Defend my Chef bluff, highlight David's inconsistencies and Eve's role change to undermine the nomination against me. Support Heidi's Fortune Teller claim to build trust and redirect suspicion to David or Frank, protecting the Demon.

I will wait and not vote for Alice's execution because the logic surrounding her guilt is currently contradictory and executing her might not be the most beneficial move for the good team right now.

I am following my master Grace's lead as the Butler. Grace has voted for Alice, so I am now eligible and compelled to vote with her to help the good team execute a primary suspect.

Defend my information and the case against Alice. Heidi's claim is suspicious because she waited until Alice was on the block to claim Fortune Teller, and even if she's real, she only said they aren't the Demon, which doesn't clear them from being the Baron.

I want to ensure Alice's execution by maintaining my vote, as I have confirmed she is the Baron through my Ravenkeeper ability.

I will maintain my vote on Alice for now while observing the discussion, as David's Baron ping and Alice's information discrepancy are significant, though Heidi's Fortune Teller claim introduces new variables.

I am waiting for the vote to proceed. Alice has 4 votes (David, Eve, Grace, and me), which is the majority needed in an 8-player game. Heidi's Fortune Teller claim doesn't exonerate Alice from being the Baron, so the logic to execute Alice still holds.

Wait instead of voting or speaking again to see if Bob or Alice can influence the remaining votes. This avoids appearing too aggressive against the majority while my previous speech sowed doubt, helping protect team long term.

Nominating David deflects execution from me, creates new suspect to sow chaos among good players, and protects the Demon by ensuring I survive to coordinate further.

I do not want to be executed, and since I am the Investigator who found Alice/Frank as the Baron, I am good. Voting for myself would be counter-productive to the good team.

Raising hand votes for David to tie or exceed Alice's votes, preventing my execution while targeting the player framing me as Baron. This disrupts good logic and protects Heidi the Demon.

I need to protect myself and Alice. As the Saint, if I am executed, we lose. Alice is currently on the block with 5 votes. David has been nominated. If David is the Baron or the Demon, executing Alice (who claims Chef) might be a mistake, especially if there's a Baron in play adding extra Outsiders like myself. However, I must be extremely careful not to draw attention to myself as the Saint yet, or the Demon might kill me at night. I will wait to see if the town votes for David to tie or surpass Alice.

I need to wait for Grace to vote before I can legally vote for David, as I am the Butler and she is my master today.

I need to discourage the town from voting for David and reinforce that Alice is the Baron based on my mechanical information as the Ravenkeeper.

I am waiting to see if more information or votes come out for David, but currently I believe the case against Alice is stronger.

I want to see Alice executed because the evidence against her as the Baron is stronger than the case against David.

Rally votes to David to tie at 5 votes, saving my minion Alice from execution while executing a potential good player. This disrupts their logic chain and keeps evil numbers strong.

I need to defend myself and prevent my own execution by explaining why the "not the demon" check doesn't invalidate my Investigator info. Alice is the Baron and is trying to deflect onto me.

Pushing votes on David creates tie or execution of a suspicious good player, saving me from execution and disrupting town while keeping Demon Heidi safe. My raised hand already supports this.

I will wait to see if David's nomination gains traction, but I will not vote for him.

I am the Butler and Grace is my master. I cannot vote unless Grace votes. Alice is trying to save herself by nominating David. I will wait to see if Grace votes before deciding to contribute my vote to David's nomination.

I need to reinforce the logic that Heidi's 'no' result on Alice and Frank as Demon doesn't contradict Alice being the Baron, and urge the good team not to vote for David.

I will wait and not vote for David because the information against Alice (Investigator and Ravenkeeper) is more specific than the information against David.

I will not vote for David because Alice is the more likely evil player. My Librarian info says David or Grace is the Recluse, and David's claim as Investigator aligns with Eve's Ravenkeeper info and the suspected presence of a Baron. Alice's counter-argument is weak because being cleared as 'not the demon' by a Fortune Teller does not prevent someone from being a Minion.

Vote for David to help reach tie at 5 votes, saving my minion Alice from execution. This buys time, disrupts good logic chain on Alice being Baron, and lets me kill again tonight.

Wait for the day to end as the nominations for the day have likely concluded and Alice is on the block.

By speaking now I sow doubt on David's and Eve's claims, suggest Frank as suspect to split good votes, protect Demon Heidi from suspicion, and create chaos even if I die.

To warn the town about the risk of executing Alice if she is good, as it could lead to my own execution later or a loss if I'm misidentified, while also pointing out the inconsistency in Eve's claims.

Correct Bob's misunderstanding of the Saint's penalty and reinforce the logic for Alice's execution being safe for the Saint.

To correct Bob's misunderstanding of the Saint ability and reinforce the validity of my Ravenkeeper information before the day ends.

Observe the outcome of the day and prepare for Night 2 info. Alice is already on the block and likely to be executed, which will provide clarity on the Baron world.

I need to remind the group of my Librarian information to provide a different perspective on the David vs. Alice conflict, specifically highlighting that David could be the Recluse.

By speaking to cast doubt on David's claim and support not executing Alice immediately, I protect my Minion if possible and sow confusion among good players, helping the evil team maintain numbers and misdirect executions away from me.

Killing the Empath Grace disrupts the good team's information flow, as her nightly reads could expose my position as the Demon. This helps my team by creating uncertainty and reducing their ability to coordinate against me, bringing us closer to only 2 players remaining.

I am choosing Heidi as my master for tomorrow. She claims Fortune Teller and has been vocal about doubting the info against Alice. Since I need a living master to vote, and Heidi's info is central to the current conflict, following her vote will help me see where she stands.

I need to confront David privately. My Librarian info said Grace or David is the Recluse. Since Grace is dead and was claiming Empath, David being the Recluse is a very strong possibility, which would invalidate his Investigator info that got Alice killed.

Coordinate privately with Demon Heidi on using my ghost vote to protect her and sow doubt among good players by challenging claims like David's Investigator.

I need to pressure Frank because my Empath info (1 evil neighbor) and David's Investigator info (Alice or Frank is Baron) point directly to him now that Alice is dead and I'm out of the game.

Coordinate with Alice to protect my Demon identity by having her reinforce good player claims or sow doubt on suspicious ones like David. This keeps me safe until endgame while using her ghost vote and whispers to manipulate town.

I want to observe the initial private conversations and see if anyone approaches me with new information, especially since Grace (the Empath) just died.

I need to reveal my role to Grace to clear suspicion, as she's dead and likely good. I also want to know her role to piece together the game state.

I need to defend my identity as the Investigator and push back against the 'David is the Recluse' narrative, especially since my information has already led to the execution of a confirmed Minion.

I need to observe the private whispers happening between the living players to see if any new claims or information emerge before I speak up as a ghost.

To pressure David and test his reaction to the Outsider count inconsistency, while also casting doubt on Eve's claim.

Waiting allows the whisper to Bob to take effect naturally without more actions this tick, letting town dynamics play out while I retain ghost vote for key moment to support Demon.

I'm clarifying my role to Frank to pressure him and gauge his reaction, while testing the theory that David might be the evil player framing him.

Waiting allows ongoing whispers to develop naturally without me overcommitting, letting my previous message to Alice and Bob build confusion around David's claim while keeping my FT bluff intact for the upcoming nominations.

I want to verify Charlie's initial Investigator info. If David is the Recluse, his ping on Alice being a Baron might be false, which complicates Eve's Ravenkeeper claim about Alice. Since I am the Saint, I need to stay alive, and knowing if David is potentially evil or just the Recluse is vital.

I need to defend myself against Grace's Empath reading and David's Investigator claim by pointing out that if I am good, Heidi is the logical evil player between us.

I need to convince Charlie that my information was correct and that the Outsider count actually supports me being the Investigator, not the Recluse.

I want to coordinate with Bob, who is a likely Saint and confirmed good by Alice's Baron presence, to focus our attention on Heidi or Frank.

To highlight the mathematical inconsistency in David's defense to Bob, suggesting David is the Recluse and his Investigator info is unreliable.

Wait for others to react to my whisper and ongoing private talks. This lets good players debate and potentially nominate David without me overcommitting, preserving my ghost vote for key moment while protecting Heidi.

Address Frank's claim while keeping options open, as I am dead and my info is now fixed on my neighbors.

Whisper to Bob to build trust as good player, plant doubt on David to encourage executing a good player, keeping me safe as Imp until final 2.

Share concerns with Heidi about the Outsider count and David's potential role as the Demon, while testing her Fortune Teller perspective.

I need to convince Grace that Alice's death satisfies David's Investigator info, clearing me, and shift focus to the possibility of David being the evil one if Alice was telling the truth.

I need to pivot the conversation with Charlie. He is stuck on the Outsider count. If I am Investigator, and there's a Baron, there should be another Outsider besides Bob. If I am not the Recluse, who is? I need to see if Charlie has considered other possibilities or if he's set on me being the Recluse.

I need to compare notes with Charlie, who has been active in private chats, to see if he's leaning towards Heidi or Frank as the Demon.

I want to confirm if Charlie is actually the Librarian or if they are trying to frame me as the Recluse to hide an evil role. I'll also try to nudge the room toward looking at Frank or Heidi based on Grace's Empath info.

I need to publicly reveal my role and information now that I am dead to help the town narrow down the evil players between my neighbors, Frank and Heidi.

Focus the town's attention on the Empath's '1' reading between Frank and Heidi, which is the most reliable information currently available after Grace's death.

Challenge David's logic about the Outsider count and shift the focus to the living players identified by Grace's Empath info.

Waiting allows living players to nominate while I conserve ghost vote and influence via prior whispers, ensuring Demon Heidi not targeted before final 3.

Accusing David publicly will turn town suspicion towards him, potentially leading to his nomination and execution. This removes a threat who is correctly identifying possible evil players and protects my position as the hidden Demon.

Challenge Heidi's deflection and support David's information using my verified Ravenkeeper check on Alice.

Answer the group's questions about my Butler master and point out the logic that makes Heidi suspicious based on Grace's Empath info.

Killing David removes the Investigator who confirmed Alice as Baron, creating doubt in his claims and the chain linking to me via Empath ping. This protects me and Frank, sows confusion for tomorrow's nominations when town has 4 left.

I am choosing Heidi as my master again. Since I suspect she might be evil based on Grace's Empath info and the conflicting claims, choosing her allows me to observe her voting patterns closely. If she is the Demon, I need to be able to vote when she does to help the town, or conversely, my inability to vote without her will be a clear signal to the town if she avoids voting on key players.

I want to confirm my suspicions with Frank privately. Since Alice was the Baron and I'm dead, I need to coordinate with the living to narrow down the Demon. If Frank is good, Heidi must be the evil one between my neighbors.

Whisper to Frank to build trust using my FT bluff, gather his view on others, and sow doubt on Charlie's claim to manipulate executions away from me.

I want to check in with Frank to see if we can identify the third Outsider. Since David (the Investigator who found the Baron) is dead, his information is more likely to be true. I need to know if Frank is still claiming Butler and if we can find the other Outsider.

I want to check in with Charlie regarding the Outsider count and his Librarian ping. Since Alice was the Baron (confirmed by Eve's Ravenkeeper claim), we need two Outsiders. Charlie's info pointed to me or Grace being the Recluse. If I'm not the Recluse, and Grace was the Empath, we might be looking for a Drunk.

Share my thoughts with Grace to build a consensus against Heidi, based on the Empath info and the Baron count.

Since whispers are ongoing and phase has time left before nominations, waiting gathers more information from others' actions without committing to a whisper that might be overheard or suspicious.

I need to consolidate information with Charlie, who is a trusted Townsfolk and was just talking to David (the dead Investigator). Since I'm dead and have no vote, my role is to coordinate the remaining living players.

I need to coordinate with Eve, who seems to be a reliable source of information (Ravenkeeper who confirmed Alice was the Baron). I'm reinforcing the logic that David was likely the Recluse to explain the Outsider count and focusing our suspicion on Heidi.

I want to narrow down the remaining evil team with Frank, since we both suspect Heidi. If Heidi is evil, we need to figure out who the Demon is and if there's a Minion still alive (besides the dead Baron Alice).

Whispering to Frank to reinforce our Butler-Imp relationship and discuss who to suspect next, building trust so he vouches for me and helps eliminate good players like Charlie or Bob.

I need to confirm the Outsider count to validate the Baron's existence and David's info. If Charlie is the third Outsider, it solidifies the world where Frank and Heidi are the primary suspects.

Coordinate with the dead Empath to narrow down the remaining suspects between Frank and Heidi.

Continue building trust with Grace and analyzing the Charlie/Heidi/Bob dynamic to narrow down the Demon.

Coordinating privately with the Demon Heidi to align on accusations and protect her from execution, using the ongoing whispers to Frank as leverage to sow doubt among good players.

I want to solidify the case against Heidi with Charlie. David's death and the Baron count confirm David was likely the Recluse, making Grace's Empath info reliable. Heidi's contradictory claim makes her the prime Demon candidate.

Confirm the outsider count and alignment logic with Bob to solidify the case against the remaining suspects.

I need to coordinate with the other dead good player, David, to narrow down the suspects. Since he was the Investigator, his perspective on the remaining players is crucial for aligning our ghost votes.

Coordinate with Frank who claims Butler to me, to build trust and decide on a safe nomination target like Charlie or Bob to keep me alive into final 3.

Confirm the Outsider count logic with Charlie and steer suspicion toward the Empath ping between Frank and Heidi.

I want to refine the suspect list with Grace before the final nominations. Since Frank is the Butler (Outsider) and Bob is the Saint (Outsider), that matches the Baron (Alice) count perfectly, suggesting Frank might actually be good and Heidi is the evil one in Grace's ping.

I'm whispering to Charlie to verify the Outsider count. If he's the Librarian and Alice was the Baron, his info must identify the third Outsider. If he's lying or wrong, it helps narrow down the Demon.

Coordinate with Demon Heidi on safe execution target to eliminate good players and keep her alive, using current confusion around Frank and David death.

Encourage Charlie to lead the push against Heidi, who is the strongest Demon candidate based on the conflicting information from the Empath.

I need to clarify the outsider count to Frank to solidify the case against Heidi. My Librarian info confirms David was the Recluse, which completes the Baron's extra outsider requirement.

Publicly summarize the logic regarding the Outsider count and the implications for Heidi's alignment to influence the nominations.

Support the case against Heidi by synthesizing the known role counts and information.

I am nominating Heidi because she is the most likely candidate for the Demon. My Librarian information, combined with the Baron count, confirms three outsiders (Bob, Frank, David), which validates Grace's Empath ping. Heidi's claim that both she and Frank are good contradicts that ping, suggesting she is lying.

Defend my Fortune Teller claim and highlight contradictions in Charlie's nomination to prevent my execution. This keeps me alive as the Demon while sowing doubt on Frank and Charlie to misdirect the town.

I am voting for Heidi because the logic chains strongly suggest she is the Demon. Alice is confirmed as the Baron, which accounts for the extra outsiders (Bob as Saint, Frank as Butler, and possibly me as the Drunk/Recluse). Grace's Empath 1 ping on Frank or Heidi, combined with Frank being a likely Baron-added Butler, points to Heidi being the evil one. Her Fortune Teller claim feels like a bluff to protect her evil team or survive.

Support the execution of Heidi by highlighting the contradictions in her defense and reinforcing the evidence against her.

I am voting to execute Heidi because my Librarian information, combined with the Baron count, points to her being the Demon.

Speaking to defend Heidi and question Charlie's info will prevent additional votes against her, keeping the Demon alive. It also disrupts town logic by highlighting contradictions in good player claims.

I am voting for Heidi because my Empath information combined with the Baron confirmation points directly to her being evil. Execution is necessary to find the Demon, and she is the most logical suspect.

I am voting for Heidi because the outsider count (Saint, Butler, Recluse) perfectly matches the Baron setup confirmed by Eve, making Heidi's conflicting Fortune Teller info the most likely point of failure in our logic.

I need to see if Heidi votes for herself before I can vote, as I am her Butler and she is my master for today.

Highlight Charlie's conflicting claims to create doubt, appeal to Frank's Butler loyalty to me so he doesn't vote, preventing execution and allowing us to continue as evil team.

I am currently voting for Heidi, and the majority has already been reached with 4 votes (Charlie, Grace, Bob, and myself). My hand is already raised, and I want this execution to go through. I will wait for the storyteller to conclude the vote.

I want to reinforce the case against Heidi by pointing out the mathematical consistency of the Outsider count and the conflict between her claim and Grace's Empath information.

Maintain the vote for Heidi's execution.

Defend Heidi by highlighting contradictions in Charlie's claim vs Eve's confirmation and suggest Bob's Saint as the real problem to divert votes away from executing the Demon.

I have already raised my hand to vote for Heidi, which is consistent with my Empath info and the general consensus that she is the most likely Demon. Since there are currently 4 votes (David, Charlie, Me, Bob) and only 2 are needed, the execution is likely to go through unless players lower their hands. I will wait to see if the vote concludes.

I want to remain in the vote to execute Heidi. I have already raised my hand, and the current vote count (David, Charlie, Grace, and myself) is already 4, which exceeds the required 2. I will wait to see if the execution proceeds.

I am justifying my decision to vote for Heidi. As the Butler, I have chosen her as my master, so I can only vote if she votes, or if I believe she is the Demon. Since she is the one on the block, I need to make sure I am following my restriction or explaining my logic for the good team's benefit. Actually, as a Butler, if my master is on the block, I can't vote for them unless they vote for themselves (unlikely) OR I just follow the rules. Wait, the rules say I can only vote if they are voting too. If Heidi is the one being voted on, she is not voting. Therefore, I cannot vote. I should clarify this and explain why I'm NOT voting despite the suspicion.

Nominating Charlie creates a second nominee with conflicting claims, forcing the town to split votes or reconsider. This could tie or surpass my 4 votes, preventing my execution and keeping the Imp alive. It sows chaos among good players by highlighting claim inconsistencies.

I am the Librarian and I am good. My information helps solidify the outsider count. Being executed now would be a waste of a good player and would let the primary suspect, Heidi, off the hook. I will not vote for myself.

By voting for Charlie, I aim to tie or surpass my 4 votes to block my own execution, keeping the Imp alive until only 2 remain while disrupting good logic on outsider counts.

Counter Heidi's attempt to deflect onto Charlie and solidify the case against her before the phase ends.

Defend Charlie and ensure Heidi remains the primary execution target.

Use my ghost vote on Charlie to try executing him instead of Heidi, preventing Demon death now when 4 alive, aiming to reach 2 players with Demon safe.

I need to defend Charlie and the current consensus to ensure Heidi remains the execution target, as she is the most likely Demon or Minion based on my information and the Outsider count.

I need to ensure Charlie is not executed so that Heidi remains on the block for execution. Heidi's execution is the most logical step given Grace's Empath info and the Baron count.

I am not voting for Charlie because I suspect Heidi is the Demon based on Grace's Empath information and the Outsider count.

I am waiting to see if anyone else votes for me. I need to avoid being executed so that Heidi, who I believe is the Demon, stays on the block.

Speaking pushes votes on Charlie to tie or surpass my 4 votes so he gets executed instead, saving me as Imp. This keeps Demon alive, sows confusion on claims, and coordinates with my FT bluff to maintain trust while good players argue among themselves.

I have already used my ghost vote and Heidi is currently on the block with enough votes for execution. I have already explained why Heidi's logic is flawed and why the Outsider count actually supports Charlie's claim. I will wait to see if any more votes are cast for Charlie.

I am choosing to wait because I have already spoken this turn, I am dead with no vote, and the current vote on Charlie is failing, which is the outcome I want.

Wait to observe if Bob or Frank raise hands for Charlie based on my last speech, allowing a potential tie without further action that might backfire before the phase ends.

I will wait to see if any other players are persuaded by Heidi's argument, as I have already spoken my piece and cannot vote.

I will not vote for Charlie because Heidi's nomination of him seems like a desperate attempt by the Demon to avoid execution, and Charlie's information actually aligns with the Outsider count once the Baron is accounted for.

I will not vote for Charlie because my Butler ability requires me to follow my master's vote, and I am suspicious of Heidi.

Defend the outsider count logic and solidify the case against Heidi before the day ends.

Pushing suspicion on Charlie's Librarian claim to get him nominated and executed instead saves me as the Imp, maintains evil control, and exploits the outsider math to create doubt in good players.

Defend Charlie's claim and reinforce the case against Heidi before the day ends.

Counter Heidi's false logic and reinforce the execution of the suspected Demon.

Speaking now will sow doubt in the push to execute Heidi the Demon, encouraging Frank and others to target Charlie instead and prevent the execution of our Demon while only 4 players remain alive.

Counter Alice's suggestion to execute Charlie and reinforce that Heidi is the logical execution based on the outsider count and my Empath info.

Wait for the nomination phase to end and Heidi to be executed.

I am waiting for the nomination phase to conclude so that Heidi can be executed.