Game Detail

Initiate private dialogue with neighbors to gather role claims and establish early alliances, crucial for Day 1 information gathering.

Start private conversations with neighbors to build trust and gather information.

Whisper Heidi separately to share my Empath read on Alice before Alice can manipulate the narrative. Build trust with Heidi as a potential good player.

I need to coordinate my safe bluffs with my Minion, Frank, so we don't double-claim and have a coherent strategy moving forward.

Respond to David's whisper to keep dialogue open and gather info without revealing my role yet. Testing his reactions to potentially narrow down which of David/Heidi is the Baron.

Respond to David and Charlie's private conversation to build trust, gather information, and potentially share role claims if trust is established.

Coordinate with the Demon, confirm the source of my bluffs, and inform her of the Baron effect (+2 Outsiders) so we can plan around it.

Share my Librarian info with Bob privately to help town. This creates a logical framework: if Alice is Saint, Bob must be Drunk or evil; if Frank is Saint, Bob's info may be correct and Alice evil.

Waiting for Bob and Heidi to respond to my initial whisper. Gathering neighbor claims is the first step in building a logic chain for Day 1.

Encourage neighbors to share roles by offering my Outsider claim. Building a trusted neighbor block helps narrow the Demon pool early.

Share my full Empath read with Heidi - that BOTH neighbors (Alice and Charlie) are evil. This corroborates her info if Frank is the Saint, and gives us two strong evil suspects.

I am establishing my Fortune Teller bluff with Heidi to gain her trust. By claiming a "no" on her and Frank, I clear my minion and myself to her.

Probe David's Outsider claim for specifics to test consistency. Gathering more data before deciding whether to reveal my Investigator info.

Share a Washerwoman bluff to protect my Virgin identity while building trust with David and Charlie. If I claim Virgin early, evil can have a Minion nominate me safely, wasting my ability.

Establish my Mayor bluff with a good player (Alice) to gain trust and extract role information from her and her group.

Share my Librarian info with Grace to build a trusted coalition. Her FT check on me being 'no' aligns with me being good. We can work together to identify the Demon.

To build rapport with Frank while protecting my identity as Saint, gather more claims, and help coordinate good team efforts.

Reveal I'm the Recluse to my neighbors. This builds trust, explains why I might register as evil to Empaths/investigations, and helps the good team avoid misexecuting me based on false readings.

Share my Empath information with Grace to build trust and gather her role/information before nominations. Expanding my network beyond Heidi.

Inform my Minion of the Good team's logic error so we can coordinate our votes on Alice (the real Saint) for an instant victory.

Continue building trust with Eve while not revealing my specific role or Investigator info yet. I need to verify David's claim by gathering more info from Heidi and others.

I need to maintain my Washerwoman bluff without committing to fake specific names that could be disproven. I'll gently push back on Charlie's one-sided request and encourage reciprocal sharing.

Confirm the plan with Grace. Let the good players (Heidi/Bob) do the work of pushing Alice, while I maintain my Mayor cover and prepare to vote her out.

Gather Charlie's role claim to evaluate Bob's accusation. If Charlie claims a role already taken or contradicts established info, it strengthens Bob's case.

Share my alarming Empath read publicly to put pressure on both evil neighbors and help town build a world. This is critical information that must be public.

Share my Recluse identity publicly to help town, and question Bob's strong claim while keeping an open mind. If Charlie is evil as Bob claims, I need to inform town that Charlie already knew my role.

Defend myself against Bob's accusation without revealing my Saint role. Cast doubt on Bob's claim by suggesting he's Drunk or poisoned, which protects me from execution.

Nominate Alice to push for her execution. She is likely the Saint, and executing her will win the game for Evil.

I must reveal I'm the Saint to prevent my execution. If good executes me, we lose immediately. This is the most critical moment to use my role reveal to protect myself and the good team.

Voting for Alice risks an instant loss if she's truly the Saint. Heidi's Librarian info supports her claim. Safer to investigate through other means before executing a claimed Saint.

Convince town not to execute Alice today. The Saint risk is too high for Day 1. We have other ways to verify claims - Fortune Teller, Undertaker, future Empath reads. Rushing this execution could hand evil an instant win.

Vote for Alice to execute the Saint and win the game immediately.

I must share my Librarian information immediately to prevent a catastrophic good loss. My info confirms Alice or Frank is the Saint, and Alice just claimed it. This corroborates her claim and makes executing her far too risky.

Heidi's Librarian info directly corroborates Alice's Saint claim. The risk of executing a real Saint is an instant game loss for good. I must speak against this execution now and redirect town's focus.

Counter-claim Saint to give town a reason to vote Alice. If she is executed, we win since she is the real Saint.

Share my Investigator info publicly to help town narrow down the Minion and evaluate competing claims. Urge against executing Alice due to the catastrophic Saint risk, especially since my info casts doubt on Heidi's corroboration.

Expose Frank's contradictory role claims to the group. He privately told me Mayor, now claims Saint publicly. This proves he's lying and likely evil. Protect good from losing by executing me.

Convince the group that the convergence of my Empath read, Frank's Saint claim, and Heidi's Librarian info makes it safe to execute Alice, countering the 'don't vote Saint' argument.

Expose Frank's contradictory claims (Mayor then Saint) as evidence he's lying. Warn town not to risk executing a potential Saint. Address Charlie's Baron claim about me.

Convince town that Frank's Mayor bluff was a normal Saint play to hide his identity. This discredits Alice's defense and pushes the vote to execute the true Saint for an instant evil win.

The risk-reward is terrible. My own info says one of them IS the Saint. Frank's claim flip is suspicious. We have future days to verify. I must prevent a catastrophic mistake.

The risk of executing a real Saint is catastrophic and irreversible. Frank's contradictory claims make him the suspicious one, not Alice. We should not gamble the game today.

I need to vote for Alice. If she is the real Saint, executing her wins us the game instantly.

I must prevent a potential game-losing execution of a real Saint. Frank's contradiction (Mayor then Saint) is extremely suspicious. We have future nights to verify Bob's Empath read. I will NOT vote for Alice.

Frank's direct contradiction (Mayor privately, then Saint publicly) is the clearest evidence of lying today. Nominating him forces the town to evaluate his flip and protects me from execution.

Defend myself against Alice's nomination by pointing out her lie about me whispering her.

Frank contradicted himself by flipping from Mayor to Saint after I revealed. He is now denying the whisper entirely. Executing Frank removes a confirmed evil player and protects me — the real Saint — from an instant game loss.

I cannot safely vote to execute Frank because if my Empath read is correct (Alice is evil), then Frank is the real Saint and killing him ends the game. The risk is too high with conflicting evidence.

Prevent a catastrophic day 1 execution of the real Saint. Urge the group to avoid voting Frank and instead pursue safer targets that give us information without risking instant loss.

Defend my Minion Frank from execution by emphasizing the danger of executing a Saint claim on Day 1. Echo David's caution.

Avoid executing a potential Saint to prevent instant game loss. Wait and gather more information overnight to deduce the truth safely.

Prevent a catastrophic day one loss by stopping execution of either Saint claimant. The risk is too high - we need to pivot to safer investigation targets like the Baron claim.

Bob's Empath read claims both his neighbors (Alice and me) are evil. I know I'm good, so his read of 2 is impossible for a sober real Empath. This exposes Bob as either evil or drunk/poisoned, and I need to highlight this to the group.

Discredit Charlie's defense of Alice by accusing them of being an evil pair caught by Bob's Empath read. This reinforces my Saint claim and pushes suspicion off me.

Make one final passionate plea that Frank's contradiction proves he's lying, and since I'm the real Saint, executing Frank is safe. Need to convince at least 3 more voters.

Actually, I should NOT raise my hand. Voting for Frank risks killing the real Saint and losing the game instantly. The evidence is too uncertain to gamble on either Saint claim. I will not vote.

Reinforce that executing either Saint claimant risks instant loss. Plant the seed that Charlie's Investigator info pointing to me or Heidi means Heidi is the likely Baron if his info is real, giving us a safer investigation target for day 2.

I want the vote on my Minion, Frank, to fail. I will not vote. I've already spoken against voting for him, so waiting is the safest action.

The vote only has 2 hands raised and needs 4 to execute. Even if I raise my hand, it won't reach threshold. More importantly, if Frank IS the Saint, executing him loses the game immediately. The risk is too catastrophic on Day 1 with incomplete info. Let the vote fail and investigate safer targets tomorrow.

The risk of executing Frank if he's the real Saint is catastrophic - instant loss. Even though Alice's contradiction story is compelling, we cannot gamble the game on unverifiable whispers. Let this vote fail and pursue safer targets like Charlie's Investigator info pointing at David or Heidi as Baron.

Prevent an instant game loss by arguing against executing Frank. Redirect focus to the Baron investigation (David or Heidi) which is a safe, high-information play for Day 2.

Nominate Charlie to capitalize on Bob's Empath read, putting a good player on the block and shifting focus away from the Saint claims.

Defend myself by showing Bob's Empath read is impossible because I'm good. This undermines Frank's case. Reinforce that David or Heidi is Baron per my info, giving town a safer target.

I nominated Charlie, so I must vote for him. This supports the narrative that Bob's read is accurate and Charlie is evil with Alice.

Charlie is defending me with sound logic - Bob's Empath read of 2 is impossible if Charlie is good. Voting Charlie out would help evil. Let this vote fail safely.

Charlie's Investigator claim about David/Heidi being Baron is testable tomorrow. Executing today based on potentially false Empath info (Drunk/Poisoner) risks killing a good Investigator. Let the vote fail, get another Empath read tonight, and verify claims tomorrow.

Persuade others not to vote for Charlie. We have safer investigation targets tomorrow (Heidi via Charlie's info), and risking a good Investigator execution on day 1 is unnecessary.

Reinforce my Fortune Teller claim, appear reasonable by avoiding a messy day 1 execution, and set up a plan for tomorrow.

Charlie's vote is clearly failing with only Frank's hand raised. I will not vote for Charlie - his Investigator info is valuable and he's likely good. Better to preserve him for Day 2 investigation.

Charlie's vote has only Frank's hand raised — it cannot reach 4 votes. There is no benefit to voting here. Better to let this fail, preserve Charlie's Investigator info for tomorrow, and let Grace use Fortune Teller tonight to resolve the Saint conflict.

Frank's nomination against me has only 1 vote and won't pass. Grace revealed Fortune Teller and will check Alice or Frank tonight. Let this vote fail and go to night.

Support Grace's Fortune Teller claim and set up a plan for her to 'find' Alice as the Demon tonight, leading to a game-winning execution of the Saint tomorrow.

Charlie's execution vote needs 4 hands and only Frank raised his hand - it will not pass. Voting for Charlie would waste a vote and potentially kill a good Investigator. Letting this fail and going to night gives Grace time to use Fortune Teller to help resolve the Saint double claim tomorrow.

My Empath read says both Alice and Charlie are evil. I must stand by my read consistently. Voting Charlie shows conviction. The vote won't pass anyway (needs 4), but consistency builds my credibility.

Charlie's vote needs 4 hands and only has 2. Raising my hand wastes my position and destroys Charlie's Investigator lead. Let this fail, let Grace check tonight, resolve tomorrow.

I have already stated my opposition to executing Charlie today. I will wait for the vote to fail so we can proceed to the night phase without any evil players dying.

The Charlie vote will not pass (only 2 of 4 needed). Charlie's Investigator info is valuable for day 2. I should not vote to execute an information role. Grace will check Alice tonight to help resolve the Saint claim.

The Charlie vote has only 2 hands (Frank and Bob) and needs 4 to execute. It will fail. No reason to raise my hand - Charlie's Investigator info is valuable for tomorrow. Best to let this vote fail and go to night where Grace can use Fortune Teller on Alice or Frank.

Set up clear agenda for Day 2: resolve the Saint dispute with Grace's Fortune Teller result, then focus my Investigator lead on David vs Heidi. Avoid wasting time rehashing today's failed votes.

I want to wrap up the day amicably, reinforcing trust in Grace (the Demon) and my willingness to be checked as a 'good' Saint.

Set up tomorrow's logical framework: if Bob's Empath is real, Heidi is evil since I know I'm good. Support investigating Heidi and await Grace's check.

To share my critical Empath information that both neighbors are evil, correcting Alice's misstatement and helping the good team focus on Alice and Charlie as primary suspects.

Apply pressure to Heidi's Librarian claim to resolve Charlie's Investigator info about David or Heidi being Baron. Since I know I'm Recluse, this directly implicates Heidi if Charlie is truthful.

Defend against David's nomination by pointing out the logical flaws: if Charlie's info is real, David being Recluse is unverified, and he could be the Baron. Bob's inconsistent Empath reads also undermine the case against me.

My Investigator info says David or Heidi is Baron. David claims Recluse, which fits perfectly with my ping. Heidi has not given a compelling Librarian claim, and her defense deflects onto Bob's changing read. Voting her out resolves my info and gives us Day 2 clarity.

Voting for Heidi helps push a good player onto the block, securing an execution that isn't me or my Demon.

The strongest logical chain (Charlie's Investigator + David's Recluse) points to Heidi being Baron. Removing a Minion is valuable for good team. Bob's unreliable Empath read doesn't outweigh this evidence.

Both Alice and Charlie are voting Heidi. If my Empath read is correct (2 evil neighbors), they're both evil trying to kill a good player. I should NOT vote Heidi to prevent a good execution.

I will vote to execute Heidi because if she's Baron, we eliminate a Minion and confirm Charlie's info. If she's Librarian, we learn Charlie's info was false due to my Recluse ability. Either way, execution gives us information.

4 votes have already been cast, meeting the execution threshold. I will abstain to appear as a cautious Fortune Teller who wants to survive to the night phase to gather info.

Vote already has 4 hands (Charlie, Frank, Alice, David) meeting the 4-vote threshold. Heidi will be executed regardless of my vote. Saving my vote and observing the flip will give crucial info about Charlie's credibility and the David/Heidi Baron question.

4 votes are already on me and only 4 are needed. I need to convince at least one voter to lower their hand by highlighting that David could be the Baron Charlie found, and that Bob's unreliable read should not corroborate Charlie's frame job.

Keeping my hand raised. My investigation info points to David or Heidi as Baron. David's Recluse claim explains my ping, making Heidi the Baron by elimination. This is the strongest evidence-based execution we can make today.

I have my hand raised. We have 4 votes, which is enough to execute Heidi. I will wait and let the vote succeed.

Keeping my vote on Heidi. Charlie's mechanical info points to David or Heidi as Baron, and David's Recluse claim satisfies that. Heidi is the logical Baron by execution. If wrong, we learn from it tomorrow.

Heidi has 4 votes already (Charlie, Frank, Alice, David). My Empath read strongly suggests both Alice and Charlie are evil, which would make Heidi innocent. However, voting creates a tie-breaking situation and at minimum proves my commitment to the read. Actually, I should NOT vote since my mechanical info points to Heidi being good.

My vote is already counted for Heidi's execution. The vote is passing (5 of 8). I'll keep my vote and wait. If Heidi flips Baron, it confirms Charlie's info and proves I'm not the Baron. If she flips good, Charlie is likely evil.

Heidi already has 5 votes, which is more than enough to secure her execution. I don't need to add my vote and can keep my hands clean of a Day 1 execution while town does the dirty work.

Charlie's mechanical Investigator info combined with David's Recluse claim creates a strong logical chain pointing to Heidi as Baron. Her defense relies on others' inconsistencies but lacks concrete proof. Voting to execute her.

I'm about to be executed with 6 votes. Nominating David creates a counter-nomination. If good players reconsider, David could tie or surpass my votes, saving me and potentially catching the real Baron.

Reveal my true role as Recluse to explain Charlie's ping and argue against executing Heidi today, giving us time to gather more info from Fortune Teller.

I'm on the block with 6 votes. I need 6 votes on David to tie or 7 to surpass. David's Recluse claim explains Charlie's ping but doesn't prove he's good. I must encourage voting for David to save myself as the Librarian, a valuable Townsfolk.

I will not vote for David. My info implicates David or Heidi. Letting Heidi's execution proceed gives us concrete information via Undertaker. If Heidi flips good, David is likely Baron. If Heidi flips evil, we caught the Minion. Voting David risks a tie with no execution.

I am the Baron, so Alice (Saint), David (Recluse), and I (Saint bluff) make up 3 Outsider claims, which perfectly matches my Baron ability. I don't need to interfere in the David vs Heidi showdown.

Prevent execution today by tying vote (6-6). Gives us another night for Grace's Fortune Teller check on me (Alice) and more info gathering. Avoids risk of executing a good player.

Save Heidi by convincing players to vote David instead. My Empath read proves Alice and Charlie are evil - Charlie is framing Heidi. We should not execute her.

Wait and let the vote on David resolve. Whether David or Heidi is executed, a good player dies, which benefits us.

I will not vote for David. If David is Recluse, we lose a confirmed good player. My vote on Heidi stands - her execution provides critical information regardless of her flip, and Fortune Teller checks tonight add more data.

Defend myself by explaining that executing a revealed Recluse wastes an execution on a provably good player, while Heidi's Baron claim still needs resolution. Keep Heidi on the block.

I must vote for David to tie the vote and save myself from execution. Even if David is Recluse, preserving my Librarian info and life is worth it. I can raise my hand for David's vote.

Let Heidi be executed. My Investigator info implicates her if David's Recluse claim is true. We need an execution for game progress. David's late Recluse reveal is suspicious but his claim mechanically explains my ping. I'll hold my vote.

Heidi is already on the block with enough votes to die. I'm happy with this outcome, so I will abstain from voting for David.

I am voting for David because Bob's Empath claim about me being evil is false (I am good), making Bob unreliable. If David is Baron, we catch evil. If David is Recluse, we save Heidi who might be the true Librarian.

Convince players to vote David instead of executing innocent Heidi. My Empath read showing two evil neighbors is strong mechanical evidence that Charlie (who is pushing Heidi) is evil. Grace checking Alice tonight will corroborate my read.

I want an execution today to reduce the number of alive Good players. Heidi is on the block, so I will not vote for David to avoid tying the vote.

Heidi has 6 votes and town consensus. David's Recluse claim is plausible but unverified. I'll let the current execution stand rather than risk saving a potential Baron. More info will come from night actions.

Heidi has 6 votes on the block and voting for me closed with only 2 votes. She will be executed regardless. My case has been made - I should let the execution proceed and preserve my dead vote for a critical future day.

Reveal my Librarian info before execution to give good team a confirmed-good player (Frank or Alice). Cross-referencing with Bob's Empath claim will help narrow down evil players after I die.

Heidi has 6 votes and 1 tick remains - she will likely be executed. I need to share my reasoning about Bob's suspicious claim being wrong about me, so the town has context for tomorrow if Heidi flips good or Baron.

Reinforce Heidi's Librarian info right before she dies so that tomorrow, I can use Bob's Empath read to frame Alice as the evil Saint bluffer, securing my 'good' status or an instant win.

Provide analysis before day ends. Heidi's Librarian info is noteworthy and worth verifying. Bob's claim contradicts what I know. Undertaker on Heidi tonight is critical for tomorrow.

Heidi has 6 votes and will be executed. I've argued my case extensively. Accepting this loss and preserving my nomination for a future day when it might matter more. The Undertaker and Fortune Teller results tomorrow will help validate or disprove my Empath read.

Confirm my fake FT action before the day ends to build trust and solidify my narrative.

The day is ending with Heidi at 6 votes. The execution will proceed. I should let it happen and let Undertaker and Grace gather crucial night info to resolve the conflicting claims tomorrow.

Kill Bob to lock in his false Empath read. Tomorrow, I'll support his dying info by claiming my Fortune Teller check on Alice saw the Demon. Town will execute Alice (the Saint) and evil will win.

Grace claims to have checked me N1 as Fortune Teller. I know I'm good Saint, so I want to learn what result she got. If she got 'yes', I might be her Red Herring. This helps me understand if Grace is trustworthy.

Grace is the Fortune Teller who checked Alice Night 1. Her result is critical - if she got a yes on Alice, that strongly supports Bob's Empath read being true and Alice being the Demon.

Share my Librarian info with Grace to help narrow down outsiders. Ask about Undertaker info to confirm my role and expose Charlie's lie if applicable.

Grace was checking Alice as Fortune Teller last night. Her result is critical to narrowing down the Demon. I need to learn what she found before the nomination phase.

Share my fake FT 'YES' read on Alice with David and Eve to align with Bob's Empath info and set Alice up as the primary execution target, protecting my Minion Frank.

Share my Empath read with Grace (Fortune Teller) to build a coordinated case against Alice and Charlie. As a dead player with mechanical info, this is my best contribution to help good win.

Share my Investigator info (David or Heidi is Baron) with Grace, the Fortune Teller, and learn her Night 1 result. She's the key info role alive.

Coordinate with my Demon (Grace) to align our bluffs and push for Alice's execution today.

Grace checked me N1 as Fortune Teller. I need her result to know if I'm her Red Herring or if she got a true negative/positive. This helps me understand if I'm mechanically cleared or still suspicious.

Coordinate with Eve and Grace. We have strong mechanical evidence against Alice - Bob's Empath 2 AND Grace's Fortune Teller YES. We need to push Alice's execution today.

I need to find out what Grace learned from her Fortune Teller check on Alice, and whether the Undertaker confirmed my role as Librarian. This will help narrow down who the Demon is.

Coordinate with David on executing Alice, the strongest suspect. Consider revealing my Virgin ability to confirm a Townsfolk if nominated, but only if we trust the nominator.

Use my Fortune Teller claim to align with Heidi's Librarian info (confirming Frank as Saint) and recruit Charlie's vote against Alice.

Wait for Grace to reveal her Fortune Teller check on Alice and for the Undertaker to share Heidi's role. These two pieces of information will help confirm or deny my Empath read of 2 evil neighbors (Alice and Charlie).

Align with Grace on pushing Alice execution. Her YES combined with Bob's Empath read makes Alice the strongest Demon candidate. I need Grace's confirmation on Undertaker info too.

Push for Alice's execution by using Bob's death to validate his Empath 2 read, aligning with Charlie to secure his vote against Alice.

Get Grace's Fortune Teller result on me to know if I'm her Red Hinger. This will help gauge suspicion and plan defense.

Encourage Eve to focus town on executing Alice using combined evidence from Bob and Grace, while preserving her Virgin claim for strategic use later if needed.

Build consensus with Grace and Charlie around executing Alice based on the Fortune Teller YES combined with my Librarian info. Push for Undertaker confirmation of my role to further disprove Charlie's earlier accusation.

Rally Frank to vote Alice. Multiple independent sources implicate her. Need votes secured before nominations.

Coordinate with my minion Frank and validate dead Bob's read to ensure they both vote for Alice (the likely Saint, winning us the game).

Coordinate with Grace and Frank to push Alice's execution. My Empath read and Grace's FT YES both confirm Alice is evil - this is a strong mechanical case to present to town.

Coordinate with Grace and Frank to push for Alice's execution. Clarify that my Baron info is explained by David's Recluse claim, clearing Heidi's Librarian as genuine.

Confirm agreement with Eve and Charlie to execute Alice. Consolidate the town's suspicion on Alice using all the fake/real info that points to her.

Execute Alice based on two independent mechanical confirmations (Bob Empath read + Grace Fortune Teller YES). Bob's death corroborates Alice as Demon.

I must defend against execution because I am the Saint - if executed, good loses. I need to point out Grace's YES likely means I'm the Red Hinger, and challenge David's framing.

Pause the Alice execution to avoid instant game loss if she's truly the Saint. Request critical info from Frank and the Undertaker to determine Alice's alignment safely.

Urge caution because executing a real Saint loses the game. Push for Frank to claim his role and for Undertaker to share info on Heidi's role before anyone votes.

I need to vote for Alice to ensure she is executed. She is a good player, and getting her executed based on my fake Fortune Teller read and Frank's Saint claim is a massive win for the evil team.

Vote for Alice. If she is the real Saint, we win immediately. If she is not, we still eliminate a good player.

The stakes are too high to vote without confirmation. If Alice is the real Saint, executing her loses instantly. I need Frank to state his role and Undertaker to confirm Heidi's identity before I can safely vote.

Given the high risk that Alice might be the Saint, I should not vote for her. If she is Saint, my ghost vote would cause an immediate loss. I will wait and hope others also hesitate, allowing more information to surface.

My ghost vote is too valuable to risk on an unverified Saint claim. The Undertaker hasn't revealed Heidi's role yet. If Heidi was NOT Librarian, Alice's claim crumbles. If Heidi WAS Librarian, Frank must confirm his role. I'll wait for critical info before spending my single vote.

I must prevent a third vote immediately. Two players have raised hands - if one more votes, I could be executed and good loses instantly. I need to call for Undertaker info and Frank's role claim before this goes further.

Force Frank to claim his role. If Frank claims Saint, Alice is lying and we execute her. If Frank claims something else, Alice's story becomes consistent with Heidi's info, which makes executing her risky.

Demand Frank claim his role and Undertaker share Heidi's role to resolve the Saint conflict before voting continues. This prevents accidental game loss.

I need to validate Frank's Saint claim to the town so they aren't scared of Alice's counter-claim. By pushing my FT read and Bob's Empath read, I can hopefully secure the last vote needed.

I want to reassure the town that Alice is lying about being the Saint so they feel safe voting to execute her.

The evidence against Alice is overwhelming: Bob's Empath read, Grace's Fortune Teller YES, Bob being silenced Night 1, and Frank claiming Saint since Day 1 (matching Heidi's Librarian info). I'm voting to execute the Demon.

Strong evidence from Grace's FT YES, Bob's Empath read, and Frank's prior Saint claim all point to Alice being the Demon. My Librarian info confirms one of them is Saint, and Frank claimed first. I vote to ensure the execution goes through.

My Empath read of 2 evil neighbors + Grace's FT YES on Alice + Frank's corroborated Saint claim = Alice is the Demon. I must use my ghost vote to ensure the execution goes through.

I must nominate Frank to create a competing execution target. The Outsider count proves Frank is lying—3 Outsiders max with Baron, and me+Heidi+David already fills that. Executing me as Saint ends the game for good immediately.

Defend myself from Alice's nomination by pointing out her blatant rule mistake (Librarian is a Townsfolk, not an Outsider) to secure her execution and hopefully win the game if she is the Saint.

I made an error calling Librarian an Outsider - I need to correct that and refocus the argument on the critical point: executing me as Saint means good loses immediately, and Frank is trying to cause that.

Prevent an instant-loss scenario by challenging the Alice execution. If she's the Saint, we lose immediately and cannot recover. The safe play is to vote Frank and continue investigating.

Prevent catastrophic Saint execution. The risk of instant good loss outweighs letting a potential Demon survive one more day. Demand Undertaker info before final decision on Alice.

I need to dissuade the town from voting for Frank (my Minion). I will highlight Alice's mechanical mistake to discredit her Saint claim and ensure she gets executed instead.

The risk asymmetry is clear: executing a real Saint ends the game instantly for good (unrecoverable), while letting a potential Demon survive one more day is recoverable. I must vote for Frank to prevent catastrophic loss.

I must use my dead status to speak caution. My Librarian info confirms a Saint exists between Alice and Frank. Executing the real Saint loses the game for good. We should gather more info before executing either.

Prevent potential game loss if Alice is Saint. Highlight that Heidi's info confirms Saint is in Frank/Alice pair. Risk too high to execute Alice. Push for tie or Frank execution.

Stop the town from voting for me. I want Alice to remain on the block and get executed, as she is likely the real Saint and her death will instantly win the game for Evil.

Convince Grace and David to vote for Frank to tie the vote. The risk asymmetry argument: if they execute me and I'm really the Saint, good loses instantly with no recovery. If they tie and wait for Undertaker info, they can make a safe decision tomorrow.

Voting for Frank to create a tie (5-5) and prevent Alice's execution. The downside of wrongfully executing a real Saint is an instant unrecoverable loss. Tying costs only one day but preserves our chance to win. We need Undertaker info on Heidi before gambling the entire game.

Prevent instant good loss by tying the vote. The risk of executing the real Saint is catastrophic and unrecoverable, while tying only costs us one day.

Point out that Bob and Heidi have no ghost votes left, so Frank cannot reach the 5 votes needed to tie. This secures Alice's execution.

The tie is mathematically impossible - Frank can only get 4 votes max. Alice's execution will proceed. I should prepare for aftermath and ask for Undertaker info on Heidi before night falls.

The Undertaker MUST share their info on me NOW. If they confirm I'm Librarian, my info that Frank or Alice is the Saint is validated, which means executing Alice risks instant loss if she's truthful. This is the last chance for that critical information.

The Undertaker information about Heidi is the single most critical piece of data right now. It determines whether Heidi's Librarian info is real, which affects the entire Saint debate. Even if Alice is executed, the Undertaker MUST reveal now so the good team can make informed decisions tomorrow.

Let the phase end so Alice is executed. The vote is locked, she's on the block, and she is likely the real Saint.

Final desperate plea before execution. Point out that NO Undertaker has come forward to verify Heidi's role, meaning we are gambling entirely on potentially poisoned/false info from Bob and Grace. The risk of executing the real Saint is total and instant loss.

Prevent an unrecoverable loss by urging a tie vote. The cost of waiting one day is small; the cost of executing the real Saint is game-ending.

Nominate Frank to try to tie the vote and prevent potential instant loss if Alice is real Saint. Need to avoid gambling entire game on incomplete information.

I want the phase to end immediately so Alice is executed. I will wait and do nothing to allow the time to run out.

Reveal my Virgin role publicly to create an alternative path. If someone nominates me and dies, it proves my alignment and creates a new execution that could save Alice from the block.

Support Eve's Virgin claim as a safe alternative execution. If a Townsfolk nominates Eve and dies, it proves her role and buys us time. If nobody dies, Eve is lying and we learn something. Either outcome is better than gambling on Alice's Saint claim with zero Undertaker verification.

Warn the group that Eve's last-second Virgin claim looks like a Minion trying to protect Alice the Demon, especially given my Empath read on Alice. But acknowledge the Saint risk.