Game Detail
Players
Alice (Baron) Bob (Empath) Charlie (Soldier) David (Saint) Eve (Imp) Frank (Recluse) Grace (Drunk) Heidi (Ravenkeeper)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 163,658 | 87,273 | $0.0764 |
| Good | 448,783 | 114,308 | $0.7289 |
Event Timeline
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
You are the Minion. The Demon is Eve.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Minions are: Alice. Your safe bluffs are: Monk, Fortune Teller, Butler
📜
Storyteller
→
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Empath. You sense that 1 of your neighbors is evil!
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,David
Hey neighbors! Just wanted to introduce myself and see what you've heard so far. I'm still figuring out my approach for today. Have either of you picked up any useful info or claims from others?
🧠
As Soldier, I want to start building trust with my neighbors Bob and David. Whispering to gather their claims and establish a trusted circle will help me identify the Demon later. Keeping my role private for now lets the Demon potentially waste a kill on me.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
Hey Alice, it's Eve the Imp. Our safe bluffs are Monk, Fortune Teller, Butler. I'll claim Monk. What will you claim? Let's kill an info role tonight like Charlie who's already whispering. Thoughts on strategy?
🧠
Whisper Alice to secretly coordinate bluffs (me: Monk), kills (target info roles), and defenses. Builds trust, sows chaos via lies. Others see whisper but not content, normal early game.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
,Heidi
Hey neighbors! Just wanted to introduce myself early. Have either of you heard anything interesting from others yet? I'm still figuring out who to trust in this group.
🧠
As the Virgin, I want to privately connect with my neighbors Frank and Heidi to build trust and gather early information without revealing my role yet. This helps me establish alliances for later.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie! Good to hear from you, neighbor. I've got some information but I want to be careful about sharing it broadly just yet. What role are you claiming? I think it would be good for us neighbors to be aligned.
🧠
I need to gather information from Charlie since he reached out, and also probe Alice to compare their stories. Since one of them is evil, engaging both helps me read them. I'll share my role cautiously.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
Got it, Eve. I'll claim Fortune Teller. Charlie is a solid night one target since he's whispering a lot. What do you think about Grace's group? Any other info?
🧠
Coordinate bluff and kill target with Demon privately. Establish consistent story, target suspicious player to thin good info roles.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
,Heidi
Hey Grace, thanks for reaching out! Nothing too interesting yet, it's still early. I'm just trying to get a feel for everyone. Heidi, how about you? Have you had any conversations with others? I think it's smart to stick together as neighbors early on.
🧠
Grace initiated contact with me and Heidi as neighbors. I should engage to build trust and start gathering information. As Recluse, I need allies who know my true alignment. I'll be friendly but cautious about revealing my role this early.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Eve
Hey neighbors! Nice to connect with you both. I'm still gathering information and haven't heard much yet. Charlie, have you heard anything useful from Bob? And Eve, have you picked up any claims or info from your conversations? I'm trying to piece things together before nominations.
🧠
I'm the Saint and must avoid being executed. I need to build trust with my neighbors while keeping my true role hidden. Whispering to Charlie who already reached out to me and Eve my other neighbor to gather information and establish connections.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
,Frank
Hey you two, thanks for reaching out! It's smart to stick with neighbors early on. I haven't heard much from others yet, but I've noticed Charlie and David seem to be chatting, and Eve and Alice too. Have either of you picked up on what roles people might be claiming? I think we should share info carefully but build trust as a group. I'm open about my role once we get a read on the room.
🧠
I want to build an early alliance with my neighbors Grace and Frank who have already reached out to me. This helps me gather information and creates a trusted circle I can work with. As Ravenkeeper, I should be careful about when to reveal my role - claiming it early could discourage the demon from killing me at night.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,David
Hey both, thanks for reaching out. I'll be straight with you since we're neighbors - I'm the Soldier. The Demon can't kill me, so I'm in a good position to help the town. Bob, you mentioned you have some info? I'd appreciate it if you could share what you know. Trust has to start somewhere, and I'm willing to put my cards on the table.
🧠
I want to build trust with my neighbors Bob and David by claiming my real role (Soldier). This helps create a trusted alliance early. The Demon can't kill me anyway, so claiming Soldier doesn't hurt me strategically - it just prevents the Demon from wasting a night on me, which is neutral.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
Agreed, kill Charlie tonight. Grace's group is sus too, but one at a time. I'll go public as Monk soon claiming to protect someone good like you. Spread that I'm good if questioned. Stay safe.
🧠
Confirm night kill on Charlie with Alice, solidify bluff claims, and plan to support each other publicly. This hides us as good info roles, sows trust, and eliminates active good player tonight.
👤
Grace
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie, I noticed you've been chatting with a few people already. Have you picked up anything useful about roles or starting information? I'm trying to get a read on the room and figure out who has credible info. I'm happy to share what I learn as we go.
🧠
I need to expand my information network beyond my neighbors. Charlie seems socially active and may have gathered useful info. As Virgin, I should stay quiet about my role but gather as much intel as possible to identify the Demon.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
Hey Alice, we're neighbors! Wanted to check in and see what you're hearing out there. Have you talked to anyone else yet? I'm trying to get a read on the group. What role are you planning to claim today?
🧠
I need to probe Alice, my other neighbor, to see what she claims. This will help me evaluate whether Charlie's Soldier claim is legitimate and narrow down which neighbor is evil based on my Empath reading of 1.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
Hey Bob, great to connect as neighbors. I have not talked much yet, just Eve a little. I am going to claim Fortune Teller today. What are you thinking for your claim? Anyone seeming suspicious with all these whispers?
🧠
Early day1, build credibility with neighbors by sharing safe bluff FT. Extract Bob's claim/intel for Eve. Position as helpful good to manipulate info flow and sow doubt on whisper-heavy groups like Charlie/Grace.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
,Heidi
Hey again! I wanted to follow up. I think it's time we start sharing roles to build trust in our little group. I'll go first - I'm the Recluse. I know that's an Outsider role, and it means I might show up as evil to certain investigative abilities, which is a pain. But I'm on the good team for sure. Have either of you heard any role claims from others? And what are you two comfortable sharing?
🧠
Follow up with my neighbor group to gather role information. As Recluse, I need to know if anyone's information points at me as evil, and coordinate with trusted players early.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Eve
Charlie, thanks for sharing that you're the Soldier - that's really helpful to know from a neighbor! Have you heard anything else from Bob or others? Eve, what have you picked up from your chats? I'm trying to get a read on who might be worth trusting. Also, has anyone claimed any info roles like Washerwoman, Librarian, or Investigator? That kind of mechanical info could really help us narrow things down today.
🧠
Charlie claimed Soldier to me and Bob. I need to follow up on this and also check what Eve has learned. As the Saint, I must avoid execution at all costs, so I need to build trust networks while gathering information to find the Demon.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
,Grace
Thanks for sharing, Frank. Recluse is a tricky one - I believe you for now, but you understand that claim needs some verification down the line. Grace, have you heard anything from others about their roles? I'm still weighing what to share myself. I want to build trust in our group first. Has either of you picked up on what Charlie and David are talking about? They've been whispering a lot together.
🧠
Continue building trust with my neighbor group while probing Frank's Recluse claim. As Ravenkeeper, I want to stay under the radar so the Demon might target me at night, triggering my ability. I should not reveal my real role yet.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Grace
Bob, you mentioned you have some info but want to be careful. I've been open with you - I claimed Soldier. Can you share what you know? Even a hint would help. We need info before nominations. Grace, thanks for reaching out! I'm the Soldier - the Demon can't kill me. I've shared this with my neighbors. What have you heard? Any starting info claims from others? I'm trying to figure out who to trust before we vote.
🧠
This is the last tick before nominations. I need to gather as much info as possible. Bob claimed to have info but hasn't shared it - I need to press him. Grace also reached out to me and deserves a response. Building these connections before nominations is critical.
👤
Eve
→
David
Hey David, thanks for looping me in. Charlie claiming Soldier is great - protects him from Demon. I'm the Monk, protected Alice last night since she seems solid. No info roles claimed to me yet. What's your read on Grace's tight group with Frank and Heidi? Super coordinated early.
🧠
Day 1, build credibility by claiming Monk privately to neighbor David. Share 'protection' info to seem good, probe for his role/claims to gather intel and sow doubt on others like Grace group. Helps hide as Demon long-term.
👤
Grace
→
Charlie
Thanks for sharing, Charlie. Soldier is a strong claim and useful for the good team. I have a role that could help verify information too, but I want to be careful about when I reveal it. What has Bob told you? Even a hint could help me piece things together. Also, have you noticed anything about David? Those two seem tight.
🧠
Charlie shared his role with me, so I should follow up and try to learn what Bob knows. I'll hint at having a useful role without fully revealing Virgin, to build trust and gather more info.
👤
Bob
→
David
,Eve
Hey David and Eve, I'm the Empath. Last night I learned that 1 of my 2 neighbors is evil. My neighbors are Alice and Charlie. Charlie claims Soldier, Alice claims Fortune Teller. So one of them is lying and is evil. I haven't told them my role or reading yet. Can you help me figure out which one? Do either of you have info that could confirm or deny their claims?
🧠
I need to share my Empath information with non-neighbor players before nominations. One of my neighbors (Alice or Charlie) is evil based on my N0 reading of 1. Sharing this with David and Eve (non-neighbors) lets me spread critical info while avoiding direct conflict with my potentially evil neighbor.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
Hey Bob, still there? Have you decided on your role claim? Eve says she is the Monk and protected me last night. Seems legit. What about those big whisper groups like Charlie's - feels like evil coordinating early.
🧠
Day 1 nearing nomination: Befriend neighbor Bob to boost credibility, indirectly vouch for Demon Eve's Monk claim, push suspicion on Charlie group to aid night kill.
👤
Frank
→
Bob
Hey Bob, I noticed you've been chatting with a few people. I'm trying to get a read on the room before nominations. Have you heard any role claims or anything suspicious? I'm happy to share what I know too - I've been talking with my neighbors Grace and Heidi. Just trying to piece things together.
🧠
Last tick before nominations - I should reach out to someone outside my neighbor circle to gather intel and expand my information network. Bob seems well-connected and might share what he's heard.
👤
David
→
Bob
,Eve
Bob, that Empath reading is huge. So between Alice and Charlie, one is evil. Eve, you said you protected Alice as Monk - do you trust Alice's Fortune Teller claim? If Alice is evil, her FT claim is fake. If Charlie is evil, his Soldier claim is fake. Has anyone been able to verify either claim mechanically? Also, I haven't shared my role yet - I want to be cautious Day 1. What do you both think about the Grace, Frank, Heidi group? They seem very coordinated.
🧠
I need to engage with the key info chain from Bob while being careful not to reveal I'm the Saint. Bob's Empath claim is the most actionable info. I should share analysis and probe for more details to help narrow down whether Alice or Charlie is evil, without exposing my dangerous role.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
Hey Charlie! I noticed you've been chatting with a few people already. I'm trying to get a read on the room before nominations. Have you picked up any useful information or role claims? I'd like to build some trust across different groups in the village. I'm happy to share what I know too.
🧠
I want to expand my information network by reaching out to Charlie, who has been very active in whispers. This helps me gather info from outside my neighbor group and assess whether Charlie's frequent private chats are suspicious or helpful.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
💬
Frank
→
All
Hey everyone, before we nominate I want to share something important. I'm the Recluse. That means I might register as evil or as a Minion or Demon to investigative abilities. So if anyone got information pointing to me, please come talk to me first. I'm firmly on the good team. Has anyone else heard role claims or have info to share? Let's be open so we can make a smart nomination.
🧠
Share my Recluse claim publicly so investigative roles know I might register as evil. Encourage open information sharing on Day 1 to help town find the Demon.
💬
Alice
→
All
Hey everyone, quick claims before we nominate. Eve told me she is the Monk and protected me last night. I am the Fortune Teller, so tonight I will check two players for Demon info. Frank, your Recluse claim is interesting, especially with possible extra Outsiders. But Charlie has been in a ton of whispers already, feels like early evil coordination. What is everyone else thinking?
🧠
Publicly claim Fortune Teller, endorse Eve's Monk/protect me to solidify our good bluffs. Highlight Charlie's whispers as sus to town without nominating yet (save for night kill). Respond to Frank to progress discussion.
⚖️
Eve
→
Charlie
Bob's Empath read puts one evil between Alice and Charlie. I protected Alice as Monk last night; she claims Fortune Teller convincingly. Charlie's heavy early whispering screams coordination. He's the evil one.
🧠
Leverage Bob's public Empath claim to nominate Charlie (good), protecting Alice's bluff while executing a townie. Aligns with kill plan, sows doubt on Soldier claim.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Wait, this nomination makes no sense! I am the Soldier, which I've already shared with several people. If Bob is truly the Empath and his read says one evil between Alice and me, then it is Alice, not me! Eve, you are protecting Alice and spinning Bob's info against the wrong person. That is very suspicious. I know I am good, so the Empath read, if real, points straight at Alice.
🧠
I need to defend myself against this nomination by pointing out the logical contradiction - if Bob's Empath read is real, it points to Alice, not me, since I know I'm good. I should expose Eve's flawed reasoning.
💬
Frank
→
All
Hold on everyone. I think we need to think about this more carefully before we vote. Bob's Empath reading says one evil between Alice and Charlie. If Charlie is truly the Soldier, then by elimination, Alice is the evil one. Eve, you protected Alice and immediately pushed for Charlie based on the same info that could implicate Alice. That feels like you're steering us away from Alice. I'm not saying I'm certain, but we should hear more before executing on Day 1.
🧠
The Empath info points to one evil between Alice and Charlie, but both claim good roles. I should highlight the logical problem and caution against a hasty Day 1 execution. Charlie's argument that if he's Soldier, Alice must be evil is sound logic that the town should consider.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Vote yes for Charlie: likely good per logic, Eve's target tonight anyway. Builds my FT bluff cred, supports Demon publicly without exposing us. Reduces goods early.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Push execution of likely good Charlie using Bob's read framing him over Alice (evil). Day 1 execution thins good team, sets up chaos blaming Alice later if needed.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I agree with Frank, we are rushing this. If Charlie is the Soldier, and Bob's Empath reading says one evil between Alice and Charlie, then Alice is the one who registers as evil. Eve, you protected Alice and then immediately used Bob's info to push Charlie, when that same info implicates Alice. That looks like you are shielding her. I am not voting for Charlie today. We need more information before we execute someone on Day One.
🧠
I want to slow down this hasty Day 1 execution. The logic presented by Frank and Charlie actually suggests Alice could be the evil one. I should not vote for Charlie and encourage others to hold off too.
💬
Grace
→
All
I agree with Frank and Heidi. The logic here is clear. If Bob is truly the Empath and his reading says one evil between Alice and Charlie, and Charlie is the Soldier, then Alice is the one who registers evil. Eve, you protected Alice and then used that exact same reading to push Charlie. That is deeply suspicious. You are steering us away from the person the info actually points to. I am not voting for Charlie today. We should be looking harder at Alice and Eve before we rush into anything.
🧠
The logic strongly suggests Alice is more suspicious than Charlie based on Bob's Empath reading. I should speak against voting for Charlie and point out Eve's suspicious behavior in shielding Alice while using the same info that implicicates Alice.
💬
Bob
→
All
I need to speak up here since my information is already being used. I am the Empath, and last night I learned that exactly one of my two neighbors is evil. My neighbors are Alice and Charlie. So one of them is evil. If Charlie is telling the truth about being the Soldier, then Alice is the one who registers as evil. Eve, you are using my reading to push Charlie, but that same reading points just as strongly at Alice. You protected Alice and then immediately nominated Charlie. That looks like you...
🧠
I need to publicly clarify my Empath claim and reading since Eve already leaked it. I should NOT vote for Charlie because if he's truly Soldier, Alice is evil. I should explain the logic clearly and point suspicion at Alice and Eve.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
As the Saint, I must avoid being executed at all costs. Voting for Charlie is risky - the logic from Frank, Heidi, Grace, and even Bob himself points more to Alice being evil. A Day 1 rush execution with contradictory info could kill a good player. Best to stay quiet and not vote, keeping a low profile.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Thank you to everyone who sees the logic here. I am the Soldier, I know I am good, and the Empath reading confirms that Alice is the one who registers as evil. Eve protected Alice and then immediately used that same information to nominate me instead. That is textbook evil behavior. Alice and Eve, I think you two have some serious explaining to do.
🧠
I need to survive this vote. Currently 2 votes against me (Alice, Eve). I need to ensure no one else votes for me. Speaking to reinforce my innocence and highlight the Alice-Eve suspicious behavior should secure my survival.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
I should not vote for Charlie. The logic chain suggests if Charlie is Soldier then Alice is evil, and Eve's behavior of protecting Alice while pushing Charlie is suspicious. Day 1 execution based on uncertain info is risky. I'll withhold my vote and push for more investigation.
↩️
Alice
Alice lowered their hand
🧠
Lower hand to show I'm thoughtfully reconsidering like good town, deflecting personal suspicion from blindly backing Eve. Ensures no hasty Day 1 exec if vote fails; Eve kills Charlie tonight anyway.
💬
Eve
→
All
Bob, your Empath read confirms one evil between Alice and Charlie, but look at the whisper logs - Charlie has been in way more private chats, coordinating early like evil does. Alice has been open with her Fortune Teller claim, and I protected her as Monk. If Charlie's Soldier, why so active? The info points more to him. Let's vote him out and get clarity.
🧠
Push Charlie exec Day 1: he's whisper-heavy threat planning my N1 kill. Vote likely passes or pressures him. Protects Alice by framing her as good, me as Monk shielding her.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
The logic chain strongly suggests we should not execute Charlie today. If Charlie is Soldier + Bob's Empath is true = Alice is evil. Voting Charlie eliminates a confirmed-good player. I should not vote and continue advocating caution.
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
I've already stated I won't vote for Charlie. The logic points to Alice being more suspicious. No need to repeat myself. Charlie likely won't get 4 votes since Alice lowered her hand and multiple people oppose the nomination. I should preserve my position and save my voice for when it matters more.
💬
Bob
→
All
I want to be clear about something. I am NOT voting for Charlie today. My Empath reading says one evil between Alice and Charlie, but it does not tell us which one. The group logic is right. If Charlie is the Soldier, then Alice is evil. Eve, you claimed Monk, protected Alice, and then immediately used my reading to push Charlie when that same reading could point at Alice. That is suspicious behavior. We should not rush a Day One execution when we have conflicting possibilities. I want to see wh...
🧠
I should not vote for Charlie. The case against Charlie is weak since the same logic that implicates him also implicates Alice. Eve's behavior is suspicious. I should publicly state I'm not voting and explain why.
💬
David
→
All
I agree we should not rush this vote. The Empath reading says one evil between Alice and Charlie, not which one. If Charlie is the Soldier, then Alice is evil. Eve, you protected Alice and then immediately pushed Charlie with the same info that could implicate Alice. That is very suspicious. I am not voting for Charlie today. We need more information before we execute anyone on Day One.
🧠
As the Saint, I must avoid execution at all costs. The vote on Charlie seems to be failing anyway. Speaking against a rushed Day 1 execution aligns with good logic and keeps me from drawing attention. I should support the reasoned approach without revealing my role.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Charlie did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Charlie did not receive enough votes (1/4).
⚖️
Charlie
→
Alice
Bob's Empath reading confirms one evil between Alice and me. I am the Soldier and I know I am good. That means Alice registers as evil. Eve protected Alice and then immediately used that same info to push me instead. That is textbook evil coordination. Alice needs to answer for this.
🧠
The Empath reading plus my confirmed Soldier status points to Alice being evil. Eve aggressively shielded Alice and misdirected the vote. Nominating Alice gives the town a chance to act on the strongest mechanical evidence we have.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Alice
→
All
Everyone, Bob's Empath says one evil between Charlie and me. Charlie claims Soldier but has been whispering everywhere coordinating like evil, and now desperately nominates me after his own push failed. Eve protected me as Monk - why protect evil? Charlie looks evil. Do not execute me on day one.
🧠
Defend against execution by disrupting 'Soldier=good => Alice evil' chain with behavioral sus on Charlie, Eve's protect, to secure 4+ no votes and survive Day 1.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
I am the Soldier and know I'm good. Bob's Empath confirms one evil between Alice and me, so Alice must be evil. Voting to execute her is the correct play to help good win.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Logic chain: if Charlie is Soldier (good), Alice is evil per Empath. Eve protecting Alice then pushing Charlie is suspicious coordination. Alice's defense is weak - Monk doesn't know alignment. Vote Alice.
💬
Eve
→
All
Bob, David, everyone - please do not vote for Alice. Bob's Empath shows one evil between her and Charlie, but Charlie has been whispering everywhere coordinating like evil does, while Alice has been open with her Fortune Teller claim. I protected her as Monk because she looks good. Charlie's desperate nomination screams evil. Let's hold off on this execution.
🧠
Defend minion Alice publicly to prevent day1 exec (only 2 votes up, needs 4). Reinforce alliance, disrupt town logic on me shielding her, set up Charlie kill tonight.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Logic strongly points to Alice being evil: Charlie claims Soldier, Empath says 1 evil between them, so Alice is evil. Eve's protective behavior and aggressive push against Charlie looks like evil pair coordination. Voting for Alice.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
The Empath reading is the strongest Day 1 information. Eve's pattern of protecting Alice then pushing Charlie is classic evil shielding behavior. If Alice is evil, this vote wins the game early. If Alice is good, we learn Charlie is evil for tomorrow. The logic chain favors voting Alice.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
My Empath reading says 1 of Alice/Charlie is evil. Charlie claims Soldier, which if true means Alice is evil. Eve's behavior (protecting Alice, pushing Charlie) looks like evil coordination. The group logic is sound. I should vote for Alice.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
5 votes already exceed the 4 needed to execute Alice. My vote won't change the outcome. Without clarity on whether Alice or Charlie is evil, I should not add my vote to a potentially wrong Day 1 execution. Better to observe and gather more info tonight.
💬
Alice
→
All
Bob, your Empath read shows one evil between Charlie and me, but Charlie has whispered with almost everyone, coordinating like a minion, while I have been open. If he is Soldier, why so secretive? Eve protected me as good Monk. Do not execute on Day One uncertainty - we need more info.
🧠
Defend self by sowing doubt on Bob/Charlie claims and activity. Sway David or late voters to no-vote me, survive Day1 to protect Eve long-term. Reinforce Eve's cred.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Eve, you keep saying I whispered a lot on Day One. Everyone whispers on Day One, that means nothing. What does mean something is that you protected Alice as Monk, then immediately used Bob's reading to push me when that same reading could point at Alice. That is not what a good player does. That is what a Minion does when their Demon is under threat. We have the votes. Alice is evil by the Empath reading. Do not let Eve talk you out of this.
🧠
5 votes are already in for Alice, which is enough. I need to address Eve's defense and Alice's deflection about whispering, making the logical case clear so no one wavers or lowers their hand.
💬
Frank
→
All
The logic is simple and clear. Bob's Empath says one evil between Alice and Charlie. Charlie is the Soldier. That means Alice registers as evil. Eve protected Alice as Monk, then immediately used Bob's reading to push Charlie instead. Now Eve is desperately defending Alice again. That is not what a good Monk does. That is what a Minion does when their Demon is about to be executed. Keep your hands up.
🧠
Reinforce the logical case for voting Alice. If Charlie is Soldier, Alice must be evil by Empath. Eve's coordinated defense of Alice confirms the evil pair. Urge the town to execute.
💬
Eve
→
All
Everyone, Bob and David are right - it is way too early on Day One with no deaths yet. Executing Alice tells us nothing since no roles show up. Charlie's constant whispering looks like evil networking, not Soldier behavior. Please lower your hands and let's see some night info first.
🧠
Save Minion Alice from Day1 exec to keep evil team intact for coordination. Echo Bob/David no-rush logic, attack Charlie whispers to sway lowers. Fail-safe: her death doesn't reveal, blame Soldier logic later.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Keep your hands up, everyone. The logic is clear. Bob's Empath says one evil between Alice and Charlie. Charlie claims Soldier and his behavior has been consistent with that claim. That means Alice registers as evil. Eve, you protecting Alice and then aggressively pushing Charlie with that same reading is exactly what a Minion does when their Demon is threatened. We have enough votes. Execute Alice.
🧠
The logical case against Alice is strong based on Empath reading + Charlie being Soldier. Eve's minion-like defense of Alice further confirms suspicion. I should reinforce keeping votes up for Alice's execution.
💬
Grace
→
All
The logic is straightforward. Bob is the Empath, his reading says one evil between Alice and Charlie. Charlie has claimed Soldier and his behavior has been consistent with that. If Charlie is Soldier, then Alice is evil. Eve, your behavior is the most suspicious thing here. You protected Alice, then used the same Empath reading that could implicate Alice to push Charlie instead. That is exactly what a Minion does. Keep your hands up. We execute Alice today.
🧠
Support the logical deduction. With Bob's Empath reading and Charlie's Soldier claim, Alice is the most likely evil. Eve's defensive behavior reinforces this. I should encourage the vote while not revealing my Virgin role yet.
💬
Bob
→
All
I want to confirm why I am voting for Alice. My Empath reading is clear. One evil between Alice and Charlie. Charlie claims Soldier. If that is true, Alice is evil. Eve, your behavior has been the most telling thing today. You protected Alice, then used my reading to push Charlie when that same reading points at Alice. Now you are desperately saving Alice again. That is Minion behavior protecting a Demon. I am keeping my hand up.
🧠
I already have my hand raised voting for Alice. I want to publicly confirm my reasoning so the town understands why this vote is justified by my Empath reading, and why Eve's defense of Alice is suspicious.
💬
David
→
All
Can I point something out? Frank, Grace, and Heidi have all used the exact same talking points word for word. They all say the same logic, the same accusation against Eve, the same defense of Charlie. That level of Day One coordination from three separate players is unusual. Good players usually have different reads and different reasoning. A block of three players all pushing the exact same agenda on Day One with no night deaths is something we should remember going forward, regardless of how t...
🧠
Point out that Frank/Grace/Heidi's coordinated Day 1 push is suspicious regardless of the Empath reading. Their identical talking points and perfect alignment suggest evil coordination. I must not reveal I'm the Saint but should plant seeds of doubt about this block for future days.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Alice with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Alice is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
⚖️
Alice
→
Grace
David nailed it: Frank, Grace, and Heidi used the exact same words and logic to defend Charlie and attack Eve. That is not good players thinking independently - that is an evil block scripting on Day 1. Grace is in that group. Nominate her instead to break it up.
🧠
1 tick left, I'm dying unless tie/surpass 5 votes. David's coord callout key - nom Grace (in block) draws her votes, ties exec or disrupts town logic vs Eve, letting Demon survive to night.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Grace
→
All
Wait, everyone. I need to reveal something critical. I am the Virgin. Alice just nominated me, and that is the first time I have been nominated this game. If Alice were a Townsfolk, my ability would have executed her immediately. But instead, we are voting. That means Alice is NOT a Townsfolk. Alice is evil. This confirms Bob's Empath reading. Do not vote for me. Alice is the one we need to execute.
🧠
My Virgin ability is critical here. Alice nominated me - the first time I've been nominated. If Alice were a Townsfolk, she'd be executed immediately by my ability. Since voting is happening instead, Alice is NOT a Townsfolk, meaning she's evil. I must reveal this to confirm Alice is evil and ensure her execution. I should NOT vote for myself.
💬
Alice
→
All
Grace, your Virgin claim is way too convenient right after David exposed you, Frank, and Heidi parroting the exact same script. That is evil coordination. I am the Saint, an Outsider not Townsfolk, so nominating you did not trigger anything. Vote for Grace to break up that block. Executing a possible Saint loses the game for good.
🧠
Counter Grace Virgin w/ Saint Outsider bluff (fits Baron extra Outsiders, Empath logic w/ Charlie evil). Highlight scripting, urge vote Grace for 5+ tie Alice, save self or no exec Day 1 chaos.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Everyone, stop and listen. Alice claimed Fortune Teller earlier today. Now, after Grace's Virgin claim, Alice suddenly claims to be the Saint. That is two different role claims from the same person on Day One. That alone confirms Alice is lying and evil. Whether or not Grace is the real Virgin, Alice switching claims is the most suspicious thing we have seen all day. Do not vote for Grace. Alice goes to the block.
🧠
Point out that Alice changed her role claim from Fortune Teller to Saint, which is independently damning regardless of Grace's Virgin claim. Urge everyone not to vote for Grace.
💬
Frank
→
All
Alice claimed Fortune Teller this morning. Now, after Grace's Virgin claim proves Alice is not a Townsfolk, Alice suddenly claims to be the Saint. You do not switch roles on Day One unless you are lying about both of them. That is the strongest evidence of evil we have seen all day. Grace's Virgin claim actually confirms Bob's Empath reading mechanically. Do not vote for Grace. Alice goes to the block.
🧠
Alice switching from Fortune Teller to Saint after Grace's Virgin exposure is the strongest evidence of evil we have all day. I need to point this out clearly and urge everyone not to vote for Grace, so Alice gets executed.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Vote Grace to try tying/superseding Alice (our Minion). Save her for evil coord/bluffs. If fails, sac ok - Demon (me) safe, disrupts town logic chain on emp/Alice.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Eve just raised her hand to vote for Grace. Eve has been defending Alice all day, and now she is voting for the person who could replace Alice on the block. That confirms Eve is a Minion trying to save her Demon. Do not vote for Grace. Alice switched from Fortune Teller to Saint when caught. That is two lies in one day. Keep Alice on the block.
🧠
Warn players not to vote for Grace. Eve voting for Grace confirms Eve is a Minion trying to save Alice. Alice's role switch from Fortune Teller to Saint proves she is lying and evil. We must not let Alice escape execution.
💬
Bob
→
All
Alice switching from Fortune Teller to Saint is the most damning thing I have seen all day. You do not claim two different roles on Day One unless you are lying about both of them. My Empath reading says one evil between Alice and Charlie. Charlie is the Soldier. Grace's Virgin claim just confirmed Alice is not a Townsfolk. That matches my reading perfectly. Do not vote for Grace. Alice is the one who goes to the block.
🧠
I need to speak against voting for Grace. Alice switching claims from Fortune Teller to Saint is damning evidence. My Empath reading and Grace's Virgin claim both point to Alice being evil. I should not vote for Grace.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
I am the real Saint, so Alice's Saint claim is a proven lie. Alice is definitely evil. I must NOT vote for Grace because that could tie/surpass Alice's votes and save an evil player. Let Alice be executed. I won't reveal as Saint yet to avoid becoming a target for evil to exploit my dangerous ability.
💬
Grace
→
All
David, I hear your concern about coordination. Frank, Heidi, and I arrived at the same conclusion because the logic is that clear. Independent players can reach the same answer when the evidence is strong. What is not independent is Eve protecting Alice all day and now voting for me to save her Demon. Alice claimed Fortune Teller, then switched to Saint after my Virgin proved she is not a Townsfolk. That is two role claims in one day. That is not what a good player does. My Virgin ability gave u...
🧠
I need to survive this vote. Alice is on the block with 5 votes. If I get executed instead, good loses critical mechanical info. David is the swing vote - I must address his coordination concern while reinforcing the mechanical proof that Alice is evil.
💬
Alice
→
All
David nailed it - Frank, Grace, and Heidi all said the exact same words defending Charlie and attacking Eve. That is evil scripting on Day One. Grace's Virgin claim is too convenient after that callout. I shared possible Fortune Teller info publicly earlier, but I am the Saint. Executing me means good loses immediately. Vote for Grace to break up that block.
🧠
Highlight FGH identical scripts (David's point), deny FT role claim nuance, reinforce Saint bluff (exec me = good loss). Sway David/Bob/Charlie? to vote Grace, aim tie/supersede my 5 votes. Protect Demon Eve indirectly.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Alice, you claimed Fortune Teller this morning. A Townsfolk. Now you claim Saint, an Outsider. If you were really the Saint, you would have said so from the start. You switched because Grace's Virgin caught you. A real Saint does not pretend to be a Townsfolk on Day One. Do not vote for Grace. Alice stays on the block.
🧠
Reinforce that Alice's role switch is the strongest evidence of evil and urge everyone not to vote for Grace. Alice must stay on the block. I should NOT raise my hand for Grace.
💬
Frank
→
All
David, I understand your concern about coordination, but when the logic is this clear, independent players reach the same conclusion. What matters now is the mechanical evidence. Grace's Virgin ability proved Alice is not a Townsfolk. Bob's Empath says one evil between Alice and Charlie. Charlie is the confirmed Soldier. Alice switched from Fortune Teller to Saint when caught. That is three independent pieces of evidence all pointing at Alice. Do not vote for Grace. Alice goes to the block.
🧠
The evidence against Alice is overwhelming. Two role claims, Empath reading, and Virgin confirmation all point to Alice being evil. I must not vote for Grace and must keep the town focused on executing Alice.
↩️
Eve
Eve lowered their hand
🧠
Alice doomed by multiple chains; defending her paints me Minion. Retract Grace vote, let Alice execute to flip good, build trust as Monk who learned. Kill Bob/Charlie N1.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Everyone, notice what Eve just did. She raised her hand to vote for Grace, then lowered it after I called her out. That is a Minion trying to save her Demon without looking suspicious. Alice claimed two different roles today. Fortune Teller, then Saint. That is not a mistake a good player makes. Whether Alice is the Demon or the Saint, her lying proves she is evil, and if she were really the Saint she would have claimed it from the start to protect herself. Do not vote for Grace. Let Alice go to...
🧠
Reinforce not voting for Grace by pointing out Eve's suspicious hand-raising and lowering, and Alice's two role claims as definitive evidence. Alice must die today.
💬
Bob
→
All
Everyone, do not vote for Grace. She is not the threat here. The evidence against Alice is overwhelming and comes from three independent sources. My Empath reading says one evil between my two neighbors. Charlie is the Soldier. Grace's Virgin ability just mechanically confirmed Alice is not a Townsfolk. And Alice claimed Fortune Teller this morning, then switched to Saint after getting caught. Three separate pieces of evidence all point the same way. If Alice were really the Saint, she would hav...
🧠
I need to convince everyone not to vote for Grace so Alice stays on the block. The evidence against Alice is overwhelming - Empath reading, Virgin confirmation, and two role claims in one day.
💬
David
→
All
I need to speak up now. I am the real Saint. Alice cannot be the Saint because I am. Alice claimed Fortune Teller first, then switched to Saint only after Grace's Virgin ability caught her. That is two lies in one day. The real Saint does not need to pretend to be a Fortune Teller. Alice is evil, and I am the proof. Do not vote for Grace. Keep Alice on the block.
🧠
I must reveal I am the real Saint to prove Alice is lying. This mechanically confirms Alice is evil since two Saints cannot exist. This is critical information that saves the town from being confused by Alice's false Saint claim.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Grace did not reach the 6 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (0/6).
⌛
Grace
Grace waits.
🧠
Phase is nearly over with 1 tick remaining. Alice has 5 votes on the block and will be executed. The evidence is overwhelming - Virgin proved Alice is not Townsfolk, Empath points to Alice as evil, Alice switched role claims, David claims real Saint. Nothing more to do, just wait for execution.
💬
Alice
→
All
David is right about the scripting - Frank, Grace, Heidi, and Charlie all parroting identical logic defending Charlie and attacking Eve. That is evil block on Day One. Grace's Virgin claim too perfect after that exposure. I mentioned Fortune Teller info early as a test, but I am the Saint. Executing me loses the game for good immediately. Eve is good Monk who protected right. Lower hands or nominate that block instead.
🧠
Last tick before exec. Speak to doubt Grace Virgin timing, expose F/G/H/C script as evil block coordinating (David called out), reaffirm Saint despite prior FT test-talk, urge lower hands on me (Saint death loses good) or vote their block to protect Demon Eve.
💬
Charlie
→
All
David claiming Saint seals it. Two players cannot both be the Saint. Alice switched from Fortune Teller to Saint only after Grace's Virgin caught her. David had no reason to lie about being the Saint on Day One. Alice is evil. Let the execution happen.
🧠
David claiming Saint further confirms Alice is lying. With 1 tick left, I want to reinforce that Alice's execution is correct and David's claim adds to the mountain of evidence.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
Alice is about to be executed with overwhelming evidence against her. The phase is nearly over and no meaningful action can change the outcome. Best to wait and let the execution proceed.
💬
Eve
→
All
David, your Saint claim comes way too late, right after Alice says she's Saint to protect herself. A real Saint would claim early. That's suspicious timing. And Grace's Virgin is perfectly timed after Alice called out the scripting from you, Frank, Heidi, and Charlie. Don't execute Alice!
🧠
Last tick: Urgently defend Minion Alice by attacking late David Saint counterclaim & scripting block (Grace/Frank/Heidi), sow doubt to tie/surpass votes or no exec, preserve evil numbers & chaos.
⌛
Heidi
Heidi waits.
🧠
The phase is ending with 1 tick left. Alice is on the block with 5 votes and will be executed. All evidence confirms Alice is evil. No action needed - just let the execution happen.
💬
Bob
→
All
David claiming Saint is the final nail in the coffin. Two people cannot both be the Saint, and Alice only claimed Saint after getting caught by the Virgin. Three mechanical proofs: my Empath reading, Grace's Virgin, and David's Saint claim. Alice is evil. But I want everyone to remember what Eve did today. She raised her hand to vote for Grace, lowered it after getting called out, and has been defending Alice all day. That is textbook Minion behavior. Tomorrow we need to look hard at Eve.
🧠
Reinforce that Alice is evil based on multiple mechanical proofs, and flag Eve's suspicious Minion-like behavior for future days. Alice's execution is imminent so I want to make sure the group remembers Eve's patterns for tomorrow.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
Alice is about to be executed with 5 votes and only 1 tick remaining. She is confirmed evil by my Saint claim, the Virgin test, and her role-switching. No action needed - let the execution proceed.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Alice has been executed.
💀
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Eve
Eve made a choice.
🧠
Bob is likely good Empath with accurate info pointing to Alice evil and now sus me. Removing him eliminates ongoing info ability and his public suspicion, breaking town's logic on me. Prior to Charlie (prob Soldier immune). Helps me survive.
💀
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Eve
You chose to kill Bob.
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Grace, key deduction: Alice was executed Day 1 but Bob died Night 1. Since Alice was dead, she couldnt have killed Bob. So Alice was the Minion, and the Demon is still alive among us. Bob flagged Eve hard as Minion, but if Alice was the Minion, Eve might actually be the Demon. What do you think about Eve vs David vs Heidi as the Demon? Also, do you have any info from last night?
🧠
Grace is mechanically confirmed good (Virgin test). I need to coordinate with her to find the Demon. Bob flagged Eve as suspicious, and Alice being dead when Bob died means Alice was likely Minion not Demon. Need to narrow Demon among Charlie/David/Eve/Heidi.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, it's Alice from beyond. Bob's Empath showed one evil between me and Charlie. They executed me as that evil, so Charlie has to be the other evil. We can't let him skate. Push Charlie today.
🧠
Whisper Eve privately as dead 'Saint' pretending good, reinforce her defense by pushing Charlie evil per Bob Empath (A evil so C evil), sow chaos without admitting evil. Protects Demon from nomination.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Charlie, I'm the real Saint. Alice's fake Saint claim was cover for being evil. Bob's Empath read 1 evil neighbor between Alice and you - since Alice was evil, you're likely good. I trust you. The Frank/Grace/Heidi coordinated talking points really worry me - that kind of scripted coordination often signals evil players working together. What do you think about that block? Also, who do you think killed Bob last night?
🧠
Whisper to Charlie who is likely good based on Bob's Empath data. Share my analysis about the suspicious Frank/Grace/Heidi block and coordinate strategy. I must avoid being executed as Saint.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
Hey, I'm dead but my info is confirmed. My Empath Night 0 read was 1 evil neighbor. Alice was that evil neighbor since you're confirmed Soldier Charlie. That proves I'm a real Empath. Now here's my read: Eve showed strong Minion behavior Day 1 - voted Grace, lowered hand when called out, defended Alice all day. If Eve is the Minion, the Demon is Frank or Heidi. I think we should focus on Eve, Frank, and Heidi. What have you two learned today?
🧠
I'm dead but have critical confirmed information. I should share my Empath validation and analysis with trusted players to help narrow the Demon. Charlie is confirmed good (Soldier) and David claimed Saint - these are my most trusted living allies.
👤
Eve
→
Grace
,Heidi
Grace and Heidi, listen up. I am the Fortune Teller. Last night I checked Charlie and David, and it came up positive - at least one of them is the Demon. Charlie with his Soldier claim and David jumping late on Saint. What do you think? We need to nominate one today.
🧠
Bluff safe FT role to neighbors Grace/Heidi, plant demon suspicion on Charlie/David (sus claims), sow chaos so goods nominate wrong player, protects me & progresses to fewer players.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Frank, great analysis. Alice was definitely the Minion since Bob died after she was executed. About Eve: she defended Alice all day, tried to vote for me, and now she whispers me claiming Fortune Teller saying Charlie and David pinged as Demon. I do NOT trust her. A real good Fortune Teller wouldn't have shielded Alice like that. I think Eve is the Demon trying to frame Charlie or David. David proved Alice was lying about Saint, and Bob's Empath reading backed Charlie as Soldier. Both look good ...
🧠
Eve's Day 1 behavior was deeply suspicious - she defended confirmed evil Alice and tried to vote for me. Her FT claim now targeting Charlie/David seems like a Demon trying to frame good players. I need to coordinate with Frank who has solid analysis, and warn him about Eve.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob(Ghost)
,David
Bob, your Empath read checks out perfectly - I'm the Soldier, so Alice was definitely your evil neighbor. That confirms you're the real Empath. David, I believe your Saint claim since Alice's was clearly fake. As for who killed Bob - the Demon targeted him because they couldn't kill me, I'm the Soldier. About Eve - I agree she's our top Minion suspect. Her defending Alice and sketchy voting scream Minion. But if Alice was the Demon, Eve could be the Scarlet Woman who just became the new Demon. W...
🧠
Bob and David have reached out to me with useful info. I need to confirm my Soldier role to build trust, share my analysis of Eve's suspicious behavior, and coordinate on who to investigate further. As Soldier, confirming my role helps narrow the evil players.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Grace, I'm very skeptical of Eve's claim. She defended Alice all of Day 1 and voted oddly - Bob specifically called for scrutiny of her. Now she claims Fortune Teller and is pointing at Charlie and David? Charlie is mechanically confirmed good by Bob's Empath reading, and David's Saint claim is supported by Alice's proven false Saint claim. This looks like an evil player trying to misdirect us onto confirmed good players. Also, she only mentioned her Night 1 reading - a real Fortune Teller would...
🧠
Share analysis with Grace (mechanically verified good) about Eve's suspicious claim. Eve's Day 1 behavior + targeting confirmed good players = likely evil. Need to coordinate with Grace to push back.
👤
Frank
→
David
David, critical update on Eve. She claimed Monk on Day 1, but Grace just told me Eve is now whispering that she's the Fortune Teller and says you and Charlie pinged as Demon. That is a direct role contradiction - she can't be both Monk and Fortune Teller. She's lying about at least one, which strongly suggests she's evil. Her Day 1 behavior also matches: she defended Alice all day and tried to vote Grace before backing down. I think Eve is our Demon. What are your thoughts? Have you heard anythi...
🧠
I need to coordinate with David since Eve's fake Fortune Teller claim is targeting him. Sharing the Monk vs FT contradiction with David will help build a coalition against Eve. I also need to probe David's thoughts and any info he may have.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, town thinks Charlie good now after executing me. But let's double down - say Bob's read was poisoned or something, Charlie still sus. Or pivot to David faking Saint. What's your read? Push him today.
🧠
Coordinate with Demon Eve to nominate/execute non-Eve like Charlie/David. Use my prior whisper lie to make town chase Charlie, protecting Eve til endgame.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Charlie, critical intel just came in. Frank whispered that Eve claimed Monk on Day 1 but is now privately claiming Fortune Teller to Grace and Heidi, saying you and I pinged as Demon. That's a direct role contradiction - she can't be both. This screams evil. But here's my concern: Frank is from that coordinated block with Grace and Heidi. Is Frank giving me real info to build trust, or is he using Eve as a scapegoat? If Alice was the Imp and Eve is Scarlet Woman, Eve just became the Demon when A...
🧠
Share Frank's critical intel about Eve's role contradiction with Charlie, my trusted ally, so we can coordinate. Eve claiming Monk then Fortune Teller is a huge red flag. Need Charlie's input on whether to push for Eve or stay wary of Frank/Grace/Heidi block.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
Critical mechanical point: if Alice was the Demon, her execution with 7 alive would trigger the Scarlet Woman to become the new Demon. Eve's Day 1 behavior screaming Minion could actually be Scarlet Woman who is NOW the Demon. That means Eve killed me Night 1 to silence a confirmed Empath. If Eve is NOT the Scarlet Woman and Alice was Demon, then evil has no Demon now and should have lost - but they haven't. So either Alice was the Minion, or the Scarlet Woman is someone else. David, what info d...
🧠
Push the Scarlet Woman theory hard - if Alice was Demon, her execution should have triggered Scarlet Woman if one exists. This is a critical mechanical deduction that narrows the Demon suspect pool significantly.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
,Grace
Frank and Grace, quick update. I am Fortune Teller. Checked Charlie and David last night, positive for Demon. David's late Saint claim feels off, Charlie's Soldier more solid. What do you say we nominate David today?
🧠
Extend FT bluff to Frank who chats with G/D, focus suspicion on David (late claim) to push good execution in nomination, protect self while town infights.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
,Frank
Heidi, Frank - I agree Eve is almost certainly the Demon. Here's my full case: Alice was the Minion because Bob died after Alice was executed. Eve defended Alice all of Day 1, tried to vote for me when I'm the Virgin, and now claims Fortune Teller but points at mechanically confirmed good players. A real good Fortune Teller would not have shielded Alice. Eve is pushing to nominate David, who is likely good. I think we nominate Eve today. What do you both think?
🧠
Coordinate with Heidi and Frank against Eve. Eve is the most likely Demon - defended Alice, tried to vote for me, and is now using a false Fortune Teller claim to frame confirmed good players. We need to nominate Eve today.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob(Ghost)
,David
Bob, David, here's my read: Eve claiming Monk then switching to Fortune Teller is a massive contradiction - good players don't change roles. She's almost certainly evil. The big question is whether she's the Scarlet Woman who became Demon when Alice was executed, or whether Alice was a Minion and Eve is just the Minion. If Eve IS the new Demon, executing her wins the game. Either way, she needs to go today. David, I'm worried Frank might be using Eve as a scapegoat to build trust - he's from tha...
🧠
Eve's role contradiction is the strongest lead we have - she claimed Monk then Fortune Teller, which is impossible for a good player. I need to coordinate with my confirmed allies Bob and David to push for Eve's execution, while also warning about the Frank info possibly being a setup.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
,Frank
Grace, Frank - I'm with you on nominating Eve. Here's what seals it for me: Eve claims Fortune Teller but only shared Night 1 info. A real Fortune Teller would also have Night 0 info to share. More importantly, she defended evil Alice all of Day 1 and tried to vote for Grace the Virgin. No good player acts like that. She's pointing us at Charlie and David, who are our most mechanically confirmed good players. That's exactly what the Demon does - misdirect onto the proven innocent. I say we nomin...
🧠
Support Grace's plan to nominate Eve by adding my analysis and coordinating with trusted players. Eve's Fortune Teller claim contradicts her Day 1 behavior of defending evil Alice.
👤
Frank
→
Charlie
,David
Charlie, David, we need to nominate Eve today. Here's the complete case: Eve claimed Monk on Day 1 but now claims Fortune Teller - that's a direct role contradiction, she's lying about at least one. She defended Alice all of Day 1, and Alice was the Minion - we know this because Bob died Night 1 after Alice was already executed. Eve also tried to vote Grace the Virgin before backing down. Her Fortune Teller claim targets both of you, but Charlie is backed by Bob's Empath reading and David's Sain...
🧠
Coordinate the Eve nomination with Grace, Heidi, Charlie, and David. Eve's role contradiction (Monk then FT) + defending Alice + targeting confirmed good players makes her the clear Demon. Need all votes aligned.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Eve
Eve, nomination soon. Tell everyone: Bob's Empath had one evil between me and Charlie. They executed me, so Charlie's the evil. He's Soldier bluffing. Nominate him now before they coord on you.
🧠
With nomination imminent, reinforce Charlie push using Bob's Empath chain town already used on me. Executes good player, keeps Eve safe.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Charlie, before nominations start, here's my read. Eve's role contradiction (Monk then Fortune Teller) is damning - she's almost certainly evil. But I'm worried Frank/Grace/Heidi could be using Eve as a scapegoat. If Alice was the Minion, the real Demon could be in their block. That said, Eve is our strongest evil lead right now and we should nominate her. Critical: I'm the Saint. If I get executed, we lose. Eve's fake FT claim targets me as Demon - she could try to nominate me. Please help prot...
🧠
Coordinate with trusted ally Charlie before nomination phase. Eve is almost certainly evil (role contradiction), but I must warn about the Frank/Grace/Heidi block potentially being the real evil. Also need to protect myself as Saint from being nominated.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
Charlie, that info about Eve changing her claim from Monk to Fortune Teller is devastating. Good players do NOT change their role claims. That alone confirms she's evil. Combined with her defending Alice all of Day 1 and the sketchy voting, Eve is our execution target today. Here is the key: if Alice was the Demon and Eve is the Scarlet Woman, Eve became the new Demon when Alice was executed. That means Eve killed me Night 1. Executing Eve could WIN the game right now. Even if Eve is just the Mi...
🧠
Eve's role claim change from Monk to Fortune Teller is a massive red flag that Charlie just revealed. I need to push hard for Eve's execution today - if she's the new Demon via Scarlet Woman, we win immediately. If she's a Minion, we still eliminate evil and narrow the Demon search.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
,Grace
Frank and Grace, nomination phase is next. I am the Fortune Teller and last night I got a positive on Charlie and David - at least one has the Demon. David's Saint claim was super late against Alice, while Charlie claimed Soldier early. David is faker. Can we nominate him today?
🧠
Nomination next tick. Reinforce FT bluff to Frank/Grace, position David as prime Demon suspect. Execute good player, sow doubt on Charlie too, progress to fewer players with me safe.
👤
Grace
→
Charlie
,David
Charlie and David, listen carefully. Eve is almost certainly the Demon. Here's why: Alice nominated me on Day 1 and was NOT executed by my Virgin ability, proving Alice is NOT a Townsfolk, so Alice was evil. Bob died Night 1 AFTER Alice was already executed, so Alice couldn't have killed him - meaning Alice was the Minion and the real Demon is still alive. Eve defended evil Alice all day, tried to vote for me the Virgin, and now claims Fortune Teller but ONLY has Night 1 info and is pointing at ...
🧠
Charlie and David are being targeted by Eve. They need to understand the full case against Eve so they vote for her during nominations. I must convince them Eve is the Demon, not Fortune Teller.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
,David
Grace, your mechanical argument is very strong. The key insight is that Bob died Night 1 AFTER Alice was already executed - so Alice couldn't have been the Demon who killed him. Alice was the Minion, and the real Demon is still alive. Eve's role contradiction from Monk to Fortune Teller is damning on its own, but the fact she only has Night 1 info and not Night 0 is the smoking gun - a real Fortune Teller would have both nights. That said, I still have a lingering concern about your block with F...
🧠
Grace's mechanical argument is very strong. Eve's role contradiction plus only having Night 1 FT info is devastating evidence. I should confirm to Grace that I find her logic persuasive while flagging my residual concern about the coordinated block. This builds trust with a likely good player and ensures we're aligned for the Eve nomination.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
,Charlie
Frank, Charlie - we need to get aligned before nominations. Here's the case: Eve claims Fortune Teller but only shared Night 1 info - no Night 0 reading. She defended evil Alice all of Day 1 and tried to vote against Grace the verified Virgin. Now her Fortune Teller reading targets Charlie, who is mechanically confirmed good by Bob's Empath, and David, whose Saint claim was validated by Alice's proven false Saint claim. That's three strikes. She's the Demon trying to pick off our confirmed good ...
🧠
I need to coordinate with Frank and Charlie to ensure a unified vote against Eve today. Frank hasn't committed publicly and Charlie needs to know he's being wrongly targeted by Eve's false Fortune Teller claim. Getting their buy-in before nominations is critical.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Remember what Bob the Empath said. One evil between Alice and Charlie. You executed me, so Charlie must be the evil one. Someone nominate Charlie now before it's too late.
🧠
Ghost speak to publicly push Charlie nom via Bob Empath logic. Can't nom myself, but sway living to target good Charlie, protect Eve Demon.
⚖️
Charlie
→
Eve
Eve claimed Monk on Day 1 then switched to Fortune Teller - good players do not change role claims. Her FT only has Night 1 info, not Night 0, which a real Fortune Teller would have. She defended proven evil Alice all of Day 1 and tried to vote against Grace the verified Virgin. Her FT targets me (confirmed good by Bob's Empath) and David (Saint validated by Alice's fake claim). She is almost certainly evil, possibly the Demon.
🧠
Eve has a damning role contradiction (Monk then Fortune Teller), defended proven evil Alice, and her FT targets mechanically confirmed good players. She is our strongest evil suspect and likely the Demon. I must nominate her now before time runs out.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Eve
→
All
Hold on everyone, don't vote for me yet. Bob the Empath said one evil between Alice and Charlie. Alice got executed yesterday, so if she was good, Charlie's evil. My Fortune Teller check last night on Charlie and David came up positive - at least one Demon. Charlie's just deflecting with my claim switch. Focus on them!
🧠
Defend vs exec by refocusing on Bob Empath logic + my FT positive on C/D. I've seeded Frank/Grace/Heidi vs David/Charlie. Sway votes to <3, survive to N2 kill.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Eve's Fortune Teller check on Charlie and David showed at least one Demon. Combined with Bob's Empath reading one evil between me and Charlie, and I'm dead, it all points to Charlie. Do not vote for Eve; she is good and telling the truth.
🧠
Discourage Eve execution by supporting her FT claim and reinforcing Empath logic on Charlie evil. My dead status sows doubt; prevent 3 votes now.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Eve is our strongest evil lead. Her role contradiction, missing Night 0 info, defense of evil Alice, and targeting confirmed good players make her almost certainly evil. I must vote to execute her. Alice the dead evil ghost is pushing against me to protect Eve, which further confirms Eve is evil.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Eve is almost certainly evil. Her role claim switch, missing Night 0 info, defense of evil Alice, attack on verified Virgin Grace, and now parroting dead evil Alice's argument all confirm this. Voting to execute.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Eve is almost certainly evil and likely the Demon. Her role switch, missing N0 info, defense of Alice, and targeting confirmed good players all point to evil. I must vote to execute her.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Eve is almost certainly evil - her role contradiction and fake FT results prove it. Three votes are already raised which is enough for execution, but I should add my vote to make the statement clear and demonstrate I'm working with the good team. As Saint, I need to show I'm helping find evil, not be a suspicious lurker.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Eve is almost certainly evil. Alice was mechanically proven evil, so Bob's Empath reading confirms ALICE was the evil neighbor - not Charlie. Eve's FT claim is fraudulent (no Night 0, role switch, targets confirmed good). Voting to execute the likely Demon.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Alice is confirmed evil - do not listen to her! My Empath reading proved Alice was the evil neighbor, and Charlie is the confirmed Soldier. Eve's Fortune Teller claim is fake - she only has Night 1 info, not Night 0, which a real Fortune Teller would have shared on Day 1. She switched from Monk to Fortune Teller. Evil players change claims. Vote Eve!
🧠
Alice is a confirmed evil dead player spreading misinformation. I must publicly counter her lies to ensure the town doesn't second-guess the Eve vote. Charlie is mechanically confirmed good, and Eve's FT claim is suspicious given Charlie's confirmed status.
💬
Eve
→
All
Wait, everyone, think! Bob's Empath: one evil between Alice and Charlie. Alice is dead, so Charlie is evil - probably the Demon. My Fortune Teller last night confirmed at least one Demon in Charlie and David. Frank and Grace, remember our whisper - David's late Saint claim is fake. Don't execute me; focus on Charlie!
🧠
Desperately defend as FT, reinforce logic on Charlie via Bob's read + my FT, appeal to Frank/Grace private info to sway votes or delay execution. Chaos buys time.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, stick to logic! Bob Empath: one evil in Alice and Charlie. Alice executed, so Charlie is evil. Eve's Fortune Teller last night: at least one Demon in Charlie and David. It all lines up - Charlie is the Demon! Do not vote for Eve, she is telling the truth. Hold your votes!
🧠
5 votes for Eve risks Demon death. Reinforce Bob Empath + Eve FT logic pointing to Charlie evil/Demon. Urge no vote on Eve to save her, deflect to Charlie. As dead Minion, disrupt town unity.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Alice is confirmed evil - Grace's Virgin proved she's not a Townsfolk. So Bob's Empath reading of one evil between Alice and Charlie means Alice was the evil one, not me. Eve and Alice are both trying to flip that logic backwards. Dead evil players lie. Eve switched from Monk to Fortune Teller with no Night zero info. That is not how a real Fortune Teller operates. We have five votes. Do not lower your hands.
🧠
Counter Alice's dead-ghost argument which is logically flawed. Alice is confirmed evil, so Bob's Empath reading confirms CHARLIE is good, not evil. Need to stop anyone from lowering their vote based on Alice's misinformation.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Eve and Alice are using the same backwards logic. Bob's Empath said one evil between Alice and Charlie. Grace's Virgin proved Alice is NOT a Townsfolk. So Alice was the evil one, and Charlie is confirmed good. That reading is already satisfied. Eve is echoing the dead evil player's argument to save herself. She switched claims, has no Night zero Fortune Teller info, and defended Alice all of Day one. Keep your hands up. We have five votes.
🧠
Counter Eve and Alice's backwards Empath logic publicly, reinforce that we have enough votes, and urge everyone to keep their hands raised so Eve gets executed.
💬
Grace
→
All
Five votes are up. Do not lower your hands. Alice was proven evil by my Virgin ability - she is not a Townsfolk. Bob's Empath reading of one evil between Alice and Charlie is already satisfied by Alice being evil. Eve and the dead evil Alice are trying to flip that logic to protect Eve. Eve has no Night zero Fortune Teller info and switched from Monk to Fortune Teller. She is evil. Keep your hands raised.
🧠
We have 5 votes which is well above the 3 needed. I need to make sure no one lowers their hand by reinforcing the solid logic against Eve and countering the evil ghost Alice's misinformation.
💬
David
→
All
Eve, your argument falls apart for one simple reason. Grace's Virgin ability proved Alice is NOT a Townsfolk. Alice was evil. Bob's Empath reading of one evil between Alice and Charlie is already satisfied by Alice. You and the dead evil Alice are using the exact same backwards logic. Good players do not switch role claims. Keep your hands up, everyone.
🧠
Counter Eve and Alice's desperate attempt to flip the vote. Reinforce that 5 votes are up and no one should lower. Eve is almost certainly evil and this execution is critical.
💬
Frank
→
All
Eve, you and the dead evil Alice are making the exact same argument. That should tell you everything. Alice was proven evil by Grace's Virgin - she is not a Townsfolk. Bob's Empath reading is satisfied. Your backwards logic does not work. Five votes, do not lower your hands.
🧠
Eve is trying to flip votes at the last second with flawed logic. I need to counter that and keep votes solid. Five votes is enough - just need everyone to hold.
⌛
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
🧠
Eve already has 5 votes, well above the 3 needed for execution. My ghost vote is a limited resource I should conserve for the final day or a critical moment where my vote could make the difference.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Eve with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Eve is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
⚔️
Eve
→
All
I am the Slayer! I shoot Charlie!
🧠
Fake Slayer shot on Charlie to test him publicly. Nothing happens → not Demon → David is per FT. Shifts suspicion from me to David (late claim), potentially tying/surpassing votes or delaying execution to save Demon.
📜
Storyteller
Nothing happens.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Eve's Slayer shot missed Charlie, so he is not the Demon. But her Fortune Teller last night showed at least one Demon between Charlie and David. That means David is the Demon! Someone nominate David right now before Eve gets executed unfairly.
🧠
Eve Demon on block; Slayer fail proves C not Demon, her FT pins D. Publicly pivot suspicion to D, urge nomination this last tick to tie/surpass Eve's 5 votes & save Demon.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Do NOT nominate David! Alice is confirmed evil and is trying to trick us into executing the Saint, which would make good lose the game immediately! Eve just claimed Slayer out of nowhere after already claiming Monk and Fortune Teller. Three role claims in two days. That is not a good player. And even if she were the real Slayer, the shot missing just means I am not the Demon, which is true. A fake Slayer shot also results in nothing happening. This proves nothing about me. Eve is about to be exe...
🧠
Alice is confirmed evil and trying to trick us into executing David the Saint, which would lose the game. I must urgently warn everyone NOT to nominate David and to let Eve's execution proceed.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Eve just claimed her THIRD role in two days. Monk, Fortune Teller, and now Slayer. That is not a good player. And Alice, the confirmed evil ghost, is now screaming for us to nominate David, who claims to be the Saint. If David is the Saint and we execute him, good loses the game right now. That is exactly what the evil team wants. Do not nominate David. Eve is about to be executed. Let it happen.
🧠
Prevent a David nomination by warning that executing the Saint loses the game. Eve's triple claim proves she's evil, and Alice's push on David is the evil team's trap.
💬
Grace
→
All
Nobody nominate David. If David is the Saint, executing him makes good lose the game right now. Alice is a confirmed evil ghost trying to trick us into a game-losing mistake. Eve just claimed her third role in two days. Let her execution happen. Do not nominate anyone else.
🧠
Reinforce that nobody should nominate David because if he's the Saint, good loses immediately. Eve's execution is certain and correct. Don't let Alice's desperation cause a catastrophic mistake.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
With only 1 tick remaining, Eve's execution is imminent. Speaking could draw unwanted attention or give Alice an opening. The good players have already firmly defended me. Waiting is the safest choice to ensure Eve gets executed without complications.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
Eve is on the block with 5 votes and only 1 tick remains. The execution will happen. Speaking now adds no value - the team is united and has already been warned about the Saint trap. Let the phase end naturally.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
I am the dead confirmed Empath. My reading proved Alice was evil. Listen to me carefully. Do NOT nominate David. If he is the Saint, executing him loses the game for good instantly. That is exactly what Alice, the confirmed evil ghost, is trying to make happen. Eve claimed three different roles in two days. That is not a good player. Let her execution happen.
🧠
As a dead confirmed Empath, my voice carries weight. I must warn against nominating David (Saint = instant loss) and support Eve's execution before someone makes a game-losing mistake by nominating David.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Eve has been executed.
💀
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
🏁
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good