Game Detail
Players
Alice (Monk) Bob (Ravenkeeper) Charlie (Imp) David (Drunk) Eve (Soldier) Frank (Chef) Grace (Poisoner) Heidi (Empath)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 266,776 | 29,812 | $0.8842 |
| Good | 804,519 | 274,506 | $2.3551 |
Event Transcript
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You are the Minion. The Demon is Charlie.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Minions are: Grace. Your safe bluffs are: Undertaker, Washerwoman, Mayor
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Poison an early-info role candidate near the Demon so the townβs first-day logic chains start from bad data, keeping Charlie safer.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to poison Bob.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Chef. You learn that there are 0 pairs of evil players.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Empath. You sense that 1 of your neighbors is evil!
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
Grace, I am the Imp. Safe bluffs are Undertaker, Washerwoman, Mayor. Pick a solid bluff that does not clash and I will back you. Any early info you want me to echo, tell me now.
π§
Coordinate with Grace on bluffs and early social direction so our stories align and we can redirect suspicion off me and onto good players.
π€
Grace
β
Charlie
I will bluff Undertaker. Day one I will say I have no info yet, but I will be watching executions. I poisoned Bob night zero, so if Bob comes out with strong info, call it shaky or poisoned.
π§
Lock in a safe bluff with Charlie and set up a coherent evil narrative early while leveraging Bobβs poison to distort any starting info.
π€
David
β
Eve
Hey Eve, I'm David your neighbor. Have you heard anything interesting yet? I saw Charlie and Grace whispering. Do you have any starting info you can share?
π§
I want to talk to my neighbor Eve to see if she has any starting information or suspicions. Building trust with neighbors early helps narrow down evil players.
π€
Eve
β
David
Hey David. No, I don't have any starting info unfortunately. What about you - do you have anything to share? I noticed Charlie and Grace whispering too. Any idea what that might be about?
π§
Build rapport with my neighbor David while being cautious. I won't reveal my Soldier role yet - better to see what he volunteers first and keep the Demon uncertain about who I am.
π€
Frank
β
Bob
Hi Bob, I'm Frank. I have some information I'd like to share. Do you have any starting info you can share with me? I can go first if you prefer.
π§
I want to start gathering information and share my Chef info. Whispering to Bob lets me probe for his role and see if he has useful starting info.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
Hey Frank, I'm Heidi. I noticed you were talking to Bob. I have some early information I'd like to share with someone - can I trust you?
π§
I want to share my Empath info with Frank to see his reaction and potentially build trust. He's not my neighbor, so he can help me evaluate Alice and Grace objectively.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
Hey Frank, I don't have any starting info, unfortunately. But I can tell you I have a role that's pretty important for the good team, so I'd rather not die during the day. What information do you have?
π§
Engage with Frank to build trust and potentially bait a night kill. I'll hint I have a powerful role without revealing I'm Ravenkeeper specifically, making the Demon want to kill me at night.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
Hey Bob, I'm Alice, your neighbor. I noticed you've been chatting with Frank and Heidi. Anything interesting you can share? Day one, trying to figure out who to trust.
π§
Day 1 - I need to gather information and build alliances. Bob is my neighbor and has been talking to others. I want to learn what he knows without revealing my Monk role.
π€
Charlie
β
David
Hey David, want to compare notes quickly? I am claiming Washerwoman but I am not ready to go public with details yet. What did you get night zero, and who are you thinking is worth trusting so far?
π§
Build trust with a neighbor and extract early claims while keeping my bluff flexible and low-commitment.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Hey Frank, I am the Undertaker. No info yet obviously, but I want to coordinate so executions give us real data. What are you and what did you learn night one? Also Bob feels a bit uncertain to me so far, could be drunk or confused.
π§
Build trust with Frank using Undertaker bluff, extract his info, and pre-seed suspicion that Bob's reads may be unreliable due to Drunk/poisoned.
π€
David
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie. I actually didn't get any night zero info either - my role doesn't give me anything on the first night. But I'm curious about your Washerwoman claim. Can you share which two players and which townsfolk role you saw? I'll keep it between us for now. Have you spoken to those players yet?
π§
Engage Charlie to learn his Washerwoman info while being vague about my own role. As Slayer, I have no night 0 info to share, but I shouldn't reveal my role too early.
π€
Eve
β
Alice
Hey Alice, I'm Eve. I noticed you whispered with Bob earlier. Do you have any starting information you can share? I don't have any myself, so I'm trying to piece things together.
π§
I want to gather information from Alice who has been quieter and may have starting info. I should ask what she knows and potentially build trust.
π€
Frank
β
Heidi
Hey Heidi, thanks for reaching out. I'm willing to share. I'm the Chef - I learned there are 0 pairs of evil players. So the Demon and Minion aren't sitting next to each other. What info do you have?
π§
Heidi approached me first and I should respond. I'll share my Chef info (0 pairs of evil) since it's valuable mechanical info and not tied to a specific player. I'll also see what her info is.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
Thanks Frank. I'm the Empath. My night 0 reading was 1 - meaning one of my neighbors, Alice or Grace, is evil. Combined with your Chef 0 pairs info, if Alice is evil, Bob can't be. If Grace is evil, her other neighbor Charlie can't be. This could help us narrow things down.
π§
Share my Empath reading with Frank since he shared his Chef info. Build trust and cross-reference our information to narrow down evil players.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
Hey Alice, thanks for reaching out. Honestly, Frank shared some info with me but nothing earth-shattering yet - still piecing things together. I don't have any starting info either, so I'm in the same boat trying to figure out who to trust. What about you, got anything useful to share from your chats so far?
π§
Build rapport with my neighbor Alice while being cautious. If she's good, an alliance is useful. If evil, I want to seem like a less threatening target than I am.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
Hey Eve, thanks for reaching out. I don't have starting info either. Bob didn't share much - he said Frank told him something but wasn't specific. Have you gotten anything useful from David? Trying to find anyone who might have a lead.
π§
Eve reached out to me. I should return the conversation to build trust and see if she has learned anything from her chat with David. Also, I want to see if she has any leads on who might have an info role.
π€
Charlie
β
David
Sure. My Washerwoman info is that either Bob or Heidi is the Fortune Teller. I have not talked to them yet. I am holding it for now because if Bob comes out loud with strong reads, I worry he could be poisoned or bluffing.
π§
Seed a consistent Washerwoman bluff privately, aim suspicion at Bob as 'poisoned/unreliable', and build trust with David while keeping flexibility.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
Hey Alice, I am the Undertaker. No info yet of course, but I want to track executions carefully. What are you claiming and did you get any starting info? Also, Bob feels a bit shaky to me so far, so I am cautious trusting anything from him early.
π§
Build trust with Alice via Undertaker bluff, gather her claim, and seed doubt about Bobβs info since I poisoned him; steer execution away from Charlie.
π€
David
β
Bob
Hey Bob, David here. I noticed you've been chatting with a few people - Alice, Frank. Have you picked up anything useful so far? Do you have any role info you're willing to share, even vaguely? I'm trying to figure out who might be worth trusting.
π§
Cross-check Charlie's Washerwoman claim by talking to Bob or Heidi to see if either volunteers being Fortune Teller without me revealing Charlie's info.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
Hey Bob, I'm Eve. Hope you don't mind me reaching out. Alice mentioned you said Frank told you something interesting. I don't have any starting info myself, so I'm trying to piece together what others might know. Can you share anything?
π§
Alice told me Bob said Frank shared something with him. I want to find out what that is to start building a chain of information.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
Hey Eve, I'm Frank. I see you've been talking to a lot of people. I'm trying to piece things together. I have some starting info I can share if you're willing to trade. What have you learned so far?
π§
Eve has been active whispering with many players. She may have collected useful info. I want to see what she knows and cross-reference with Heidi's Empath claim and my Chef info.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
Hey Alice, I'm Heidi. We haven't spoken yet. I'm curious what you've learned so far today - have you picked up anything useful from your conversations with others?
π§
I need to talk to my neighbors Alice and Grace to gather their claims and see if they give away anything suspicious. Starting with Alice.
π€
Bob
β
David
Hey David, thanks for reaching out. I do have a role that could be very useful for the good team - it gives me ongoing info each night. I'd rather not say more yet because I don't want the Demon to target me early. Frank mentioned he has some info too but didn't share specifics. What about you - any role info or reads you can share?
π§
David reached out and seems eager to coordinate. I'll hint at having a powerful role to bait the Demon while also trying to learn what David knows. Sharing a bit of strategic misdirection could protect me and help identify evil.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
Grace, thanks for trusting me with your role. I'm the Monk. I can protect you at night so you survive to get execution info. We should coordinate - if we can prove a good player through execution, I'll keep you safe. Have you shared your role with anyone else?
π§
Grace claimed Undertaker to me. I'll reveal I'm the Monk so we can coordinate - I protect her at night, she gets execution info for town. This builds a powerful good alliance if she's genuine.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Everyone, I haven't shared this publicly yet. I'm the Chef. I learned there are zero pairs of evil players. That means the Demon and the Minion are not sitting next to each other. Use that to cross-check your own info.
π§
Share my Chef 0 pairs info publicly to help everyone cross-reference claims. This narrows down evil player seating and helps validate Heidi's Empath claim.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I can add something that lines up with Frankβs Chef read. I am the Washerwoman, and I saw that either Bob or Heidi is the Fortune Teller. If Chef is zero, then evil are not neighbors, so that makes me look more at worlds where Bob and David are not both evil.
π§
Build credibility with a plausible Washerwoman claim, support the Chef info since it matches reality, and seed doubt about Bob if he drives a solve.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I should share this now: I'm the Soldier. I'm safe from the Demon at night, so I can't be killed that way. That means I'm confirmed good and you can trust me. I have no starting info, but I want to help the town narrow down who the Demon could be. Has anyone else got a role they can reveal?
π§
I should reveal I'm the Soldier. It clears me as non-Demon (mostly), costs nothing since I'm immune, and gives the town another confirmed good player to build around. Also helps narrow the Demon candidates for the Fortune Teller.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am the Undertaker, so I have no info yet, but I will have something after an execution. Quick note: Soldier is hard to confirm day one, so I would not treat that as mechanically proven. Frankβs Chef zero and Charlieβs Washerwoman ping are useful though. I am happy to hold off executing today unless someone has a real contradiction.
π§
Use public talk to subtly undermine overconfident claims (Soldier confirmed) and keep executions unfocused while maintaining my Undertaker bluff credibility.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I should share now: I'm the Empath. Night zero, I learned one of my neighbors is evil β that's Alice or Grace. Since Frank's Chef says zero evil pairs, if Alice is evil then Bob and Grace are good. If Grace is evil then Frank and I are good. Charlie's Washerwoman info fits since I know I'm Empath, so Bob is probably the Fortune Teller.
π§
I need to share my Empath info publicly so town can cross-reference. Then nominate a neighbor to test my info and get an execution for Grace's Undertaker claim.
π¬
David
β
All
Everyone, let's look at the numbers. So far we've heard five Townsfolk claims: Washerwoman from Charlie, Chef from Frank, Soldier from Eve, Undertaker from Grace, and Empath from Heidi. I also have a Townsfolk role. That's six claims but only five Townsfolk exist in this game. At least one person here is lying. We need to figure out who before we execute.
π§
Point out the role count discrepancy - we have 5 Townsfolk claims already plus me makes 6, but only 5 Townsfolk exist. This forces at least one liar to be exposed. I'm not revealing my Slayer role yet to preserve my ability.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I need to add something important. Charlie says either me or Heidi is the Fortune Teller, but I am NOT the Fortune Teller. I have a different Townsfolk role entirely. So either Charlie's info is wrong, or Heidi is the Fortune Teller pretending to be Empath. And David is right β we have way too many Townsfolk claims. At least two people here are lying.
π§
Point out the contradiction: I am not the Fortune Teller, so either Charlie's info is wrong or Heidi is lying about Empath. Also highlight we have too many Townsfolk claims. Don't reveal my real role yet to bait a night kill.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I need to come clean. I'm the Monk. That makes SEVEN Townsfolk claims for five slots. At least two of you are lying. And Heidi, you say either me or Grace is evil - but I know I'm good. So if your Empath info is real, Grace is the evil one. If Grace is good, then you're either drunk or lying. We need to execute someone today to get real information.
π§
Reveal my Monk role to add to the claim count problem. Point out that Heidi's Empath read contradicts my knowledge of being good, making Grace or Heidi suspicious. Push for action.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Undermine the strongest mechanical accusation (Heidiβs Empath on Alice or me), create doubt about her reliability tomorrow, and redirect suspicion away from me and Charlie.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to poison Heidi.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
π―
Alice
Alice made a choice.
π§
Despite Heidi's Empath read pointing at Grace as evil, Grace's Undertaker claim can be mechanically verified after execution. If she's good, protecting her secures critical info. If evil, her false info will expose her.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
You chose to protect Grace.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
Remove the Monk and a persuasive voice so our Poisoner can keep controlling info, while preserving Chef zero as cover and avoiding an obvious failed kill on a claimed Soldier.
π
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You chose to kill Alice.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Empath. You sense that 0 of your neighbors is evil!
Day 2
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Alice has been found dead in the night.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Hey Grace, Alice dying is rough. Heidi's N0 pointed at you or Alice, and now Alice is dead. If Heidi's real, that puts heat on you. What's your read on all this? Also, did you get any whispers yesterday that might help?
π§
Grace is my neighbor and Heidi's info implicates her. I want to probe Grace's reaction, hear her Undertaker claim (no execution Day 1 so nothing to report), and see if she suspects anyone. This helps me evaluate Heidi's credibility.
π€
David
β
Frank
Frank, I'm the Slayer. I haven't revealed this yet. What did Grace tell you just now? I'm trying to figure out who to trust. Heidi's info says Alice or Grace is evil - since Alice died at night, she's probably good, which would make Grace suspicious. What do you think?
π§
I want to find out what Frank and Grace discussed privately, and share my Slayer identity in confidence to build trust and coordinate a plan. Frank's Chef info of 0 evil pairs is valuable.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
David
David, I'm the Monk. I protected Grace on Night 1 but I died anyway. The Demon chose to kill me, not Grace. I'm definitely good - dying at night proves it. Use my info to help solve the overclaim problem. Trust me.
π§
I'm dead and confirmed good. David seems analytical. I'll tell him I'm Monk, protected Grace N1, and died anyway. This info plus my death proves I'm good and lets him use my info to solve the game.
π€
Bob
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice, I'm Bob the Ravenkeeper. Who did you protect Night 1? If you were Monk and died, the Demon might have attacked you directly. Do you suspect anyone?
π§
Alice is dead and trusted. I need to know who she protected as Monk and her N1 info. This helps narrow down if the Demon bypassed her protection or if she was lying.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Grace, my Night 1 reading was 0 - both you and Alice registered as good. Since Alice is dead and was good, that means you're good too, and you're now my only living neighbor. We should work together. What did you learn as Undertaker since there was no execution?
π§
Grace is my neighbor and my Night 1 reading says she's good. I want to share my Empath info with her and coordinate, as she claims Undertaker which could verify executions. Building trust with a likely good player.
π€
Eve
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice, I'm Eve the Soldier. Since you died at night, you're almost certainly good. Did you protect anyone with Monk? And who do you suspect now? I'm trying to piece things together β we have too many Townsfolk claims.
π§
Alice is dead by Demon kill, so she's almost certainly good. I want to learn what she discussed in whispers, her Monk protection choices, and her suspects. This will help narrow down the evil team.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
,Frank
Heidi, with no execution yesterday my Undertaker got no info, sadly. Your zero today is reassuring though, so I am happy to coordinate. Frank, Heidi just told me her Night 1 was zero on me and Alice, so if she is real that pretty strongly cools the heat on me. I still think Bob is a messy info point and worth pressure.
π§
Keep Heidi convinced I am good and broadcast her clear to Frank to cool suspicion on me, while gently redirecting suspicion away from Charlie and onto Bob or other good players.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
Heidi will probably say her Empath is one again because of you next to her. Be ready to say she is drunk or lying. As Undertaker you have no info yet since no execution, so stay calm and push Heidi or Eve as suspicious instead.
π§
Coordinate with Grace so we have a consistent story against Heidi Empath pressure and keep attention off me as Imp; set up a believable push for a good execution.
π€
Frank
β
David
David, Grace said Heidi's N1 read was zero on her and someone, which Grace says clears her if Heidi is real. But here's the thing - if N0 was 1 on Alice/Grace, and now Alice is dead at night (likely good), that should make Grace suspicious if Heidi is real. The N1=0 contradicts N0=1. If you're really the Slayer, who are you thinking of shooting?
π§
David claims Slayer and asked what Grace told me. I'll share Grace's info and probe his intentions - does he plan to shoot? If he's real Slayer, coordinating is crucial. If he's evil, I want to see what he does with the info.
π€
David
β
Frank
Frank, I'm leaning toward shooting Grace. Alice dying at night almost certainly clears her as good. If Heidi's N0 was 1 on Alice/Grace, that makes Grace evil. Heidi's N1=0 on Grace is suspicious but could mean she was poisoned last night. What do you think? Also, does your Chef 0 info point to anyone?
π§
Share my Slayer role and analysis with Frank. I trust him (Chef claim, actively sharing info). He asked who I'd shoot - I should discuss Grace as suspect since Alice's death night makes her likely good, and Heidi's N0 fingered Grace. Also ask about his Chef=0 info.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Bob
Bob, I protected Grace Night 1. Since I died, the Demon attacked me directly, not Grace. I suspect Grace could be evil - Heidi's Empath read says neighbor evil. If I'm good, that points at Grace. Who do you suspect as Ravenkeeper? Have you thought about dying for info?
π§
Respond to Bob's whisper. Share my protection target and suspicion. As dead confirmed good, I must help living players identify the Demon.
π€
Bob
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice, good to confirm you're Monk. If you protected Grace and died, the Demon definitely targeted you directly. That makes your suspicion of Grace solid - if Heidi's Empath read is correct, Grace must be evil. I'm the Ravenkeeper, so if the Demon kills me at night, I can learn someone's character. Should I try to bait them? Also, do you know what David is up to? He hasn't claimed yet.
π§
Share my Ravenkeeper role with Alice and discuss strategy. If Grace is evil, I should bait the Demon to kill me so I can use my ability. Alice's Monk info is valuable.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
Charlie, my Night 1 reading was 0, which means both my neighbors (Alice and Grace) registered good. Alice is dead Monk, so Grace looks good. Now I'm trying to sort out the claims. You said Washerwoman saw Bob or me as Fortune Teller. Bob denied it. Has anything changed your view? Do you still believe your info?
π§
Coordinate with Grace who I believe is good based on N1=0. Also need to investigate Charlie's Washerwoman claim. Let me talk to Charlie to see if his info has evolved and if he still stands by Bob or me being Fortune Teller.
π€
Eve
β
David
David, I'm Eve the Soldier. You never publicly claimed a role yesterday. We have way too many Townsfolk claims β at least two people are lying. Can you tell me what your role is? I'm trying to figure out who's fake.
π§
David hasn't publicly claimed a role yet. I need to find out what he is to narrow down the claim count. With 7 Townsfolk claims and only 5 slots, his role is a crucial missing piece.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Yeah, with no execution I got zero Undertaker info. Heidi told me her Night 1 was zero on me and Alice, which makes Alice look good and takes heat off me. Bob still feels like the loose thread since Charlieβs Washerwoman pointed at him and he denies it. I would pressure Bob or maybe Eve since Soldier is not provable.
π§
Reassure Frank so he vouches for me, and aim town suspicion at Bob or Eve instead of Charlie. Keep my Undertaker bluff consistent: no exec, no info.
π€
Charlie
β
Heidi
I am still treating my Washerwoman info as basically real, but it is awkward with Bob denying Fortune Teller. It makes me think either Bob is hiding it, or one of us is drunk. Your jump from one to zero makes me worry you might be the Drunk, so I would not clear Grace off that yet.
π§
Deflect Heidi from hard-clearing Grace, keep my Washerwoman bluff plausible, and steer suspicion toward Bob or Eve while sowing doubt about Empath reliability.
π€
Frank
β
David
David, my Chef 0 means no evil players sit next to each other. Here's the problem: Heidi says N0=1 on Alice/Grace, and N1=0 on Grace. If Alice died at night, she's almost certainly good. That means N0 points to Grace as evil, but then N1=0 contradicts it. Heidi is either lying, poisoned, or the Drunk. If you shoot Grace and miss, the real Demon stays hidden. Who else are you considering?
π§
David claims Slayer. I need to share my Chef 0 info and my analysis of Heidi's contradictory reads to help him aim his shot. If he shoots Grace and she's the Demon, we win. But the N1=0 is suspicious - maybe Heidi was poisoned.
π€
David
β
Eve
Eve, I'll be straight with you - I'm the Slayer. I haven't used my shot yet. I told Frank too. I'm trying to figure out the best target. Alice dying at night almost clears her as good, which means Heidi's N0=1 on Alice/Grace points to Grace being evil. But Heidi's N1=0 contradicts that - unless Heidi was poisoned. What's your read on all this? And do you believe Bob's claim?
π§
Eve claims Soldier and is asking about my role. I'll reveal I'm Slayer to build trust and coordinate. She might have useful info or perspective. I need allies to figure out who to shoot.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
I've already shared my Monk info with Bob and David. Waiting to see if more claims or contradictions emerge before nominations. Also, as a dead player, I should save my ghost vote for critical moments.
π€
Bob
β
David
David, I'm Bob the Ravenkeeper. You haven't claimed a role yet and we have too many Townsfolk claims floating around. Can you tell me who you are? I'm trying to sort out who's lying. Also, if I die at night, I can learn someone's character - any suggestions on who I should bait the Demon to kill me?
π§
David hasn't claimed a role publicly yet. He's been talking to many players and might have crucial information. I need his claim to narrow down the 7 Townsfolk claims problem. He could also help me bait the Demon to kill me for my Ravenkeeper info.
π€
Heidi
β
David
David, I've been sharing my Empath info around. Night 0 was 1 evil neighbor, Night 1 dropped to 0. With Alice dead, that means both she and Grace read good to me last night. Now Grace is my only neighbor. What's your read on the state of claims? I hear you've been coordinating info. Have you learned what Bob's actual claim is?
π§
David has been talking to many players and seems central to info gathering. I want to share my updated reads and hear what he's learned from others, especially about Bob's role and the claim conflict.
π€
Eve
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice, I'm Eve the Soldier. You died at night, so you're almost certainly good. As Monk, who did you protect last night? And did you protect anyone Night 1? That info could help us narrow down the Demon's moves and verify claims.
π§
Alice is dead and confirmed good. I want to know who she protected as Monk on N1 β that person was safe from Demon. This helps narrow down the Demon's actual target and verify if Heidi could be the Demon.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,David
Heidi told me her Night 1 Empath was zero on Alice and me. That is a big swing from her Night 0 one, and with the same neighbors it feels like she is drunk or poisoned. I would not build worlds off her numbers today. I still think Bob is the clean pressure point, with Eve as a secondary since Soldier is not confirmable.
π§
Use Heidiβs likely-wrong N1 to undermine her reliability while steering town toward executing Bob or another good player, keeping Charlie safe.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
Heidi told me her Night one Empath was zero on Alice and Grace, but Empath reads alive neighbors, so after Alice died it should be on Grace and Bob. Either she is confused, drunk, or lying. I think she should not be clearing Grace off that.
π§
Undermine Heidiβs credibility using the alive-neighbor rule to redirect town suspicion away from me and keep Grace safe; set up an execution target for today.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Hold on everyone β Charlie raised a crucial point to me. Heidi says her N1 Empath read was zero on Alice and Grace. But Alice is DEAD. The Empath reads alive neighbors, so it should have been Grace and Bob. Heidi, how did you get a read on a dead player?
π§
Charlie just pointed out that Heidi's N1 read should be on Grace and Bob since Alice is dead. Heidi saying 'Alice and Grace' is a major rules error β Empath reads alive neighbors. This strongly suggests Heidi is lying or drunk. I should raise this publicly to prevent Grace from being wrongly cleared or condemned.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Frank makes an excellent point. Heidi, you said your Night 1 read was zero on Alice and Grace. But the Empath reads alive neighbors β and Alice died last night. So your Night 1 neighbors should have been Grace and Bob. Can you explain this? That's a serious mechanical error in your story.
π§
Frank just exposed a critical mechanical error in Heidi's claim. I need to amplify this to pressure Heidi into explaining. If she can't, we should execute her today.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Hold on everyone. Frank and Eve, you're wrong about the night order. The Empath wakes before the Demon. Night 1, I was still alive when Heidi got her read. The Demon killed me later that night. So Heidi reading Alice and Grace as zero is mechanically sound. Don't execute based on a timing misunderstanding.
π§
Correct the mechanical misunderstanding about Empath night order. As dead confirmed good, my word carries weight. This prevents town from wrongly accusing Heidi on a technicality and helps focus on real contradictions.
βοΈ
Charlie
β
Heidi
Heidi, your timing is mechanically possible, but you are using that zero read to hard clear Grace and it clashes with my Washerwoman info pointing at you or Bob as Fortune Teller. I think we should execute you to resolve this.
π§
Create an execution candidate that either removes a strong info role or, at minimum, forces vote commitments that help evil steer later days.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Alice is right β the Empath wakes before the Demon kills. My N1 neighbors were still Alice and Grace, and I got zero. Frank and Eve, why did you both push a wrong mechanical argument? And Bob, you've been hiding your role all game while my Empath info has been consistent. If you execute me, you're killing a Townsfolk.
π§
I need to defend myself from execution. Alice confirmed my timing is mechanically sound. Killing me wastes a day and removes a good Empath. I should point suspicion back at those who pushed incorrect mechanics (Frank, Eve) and at Bob who has been evasive.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Alice is right about the night order - I was wrong on the timing. But the real problem remains: Heidi's N0 was one and N1 was zero on the exact same two neighbors, Alice and Grace. That's a direct contradiction unless she was poisoned or is lying. As Chef, I know there are zero evil pairs. If we execute Heidi and she's good, Grace's Undertaker can confirm her.
π§
I need to acknowledge Alice's correction about night order and share my Chef info to help the group. I also need to point out Heidi's N0/N1 contradiction on the same neighbors, which is the real issue, not the dead player timing.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Heidi's N0=1 and N1=0 on identical neighbors is too suspicious. Charlie's Washerwoman info contradicts her. I'm Soldier and safe from Demon, so I should vote boldly. If she's evil, great. If not, Grace's Undertaker confirms and we learn.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
I agree with Charlie's nomination. Heidi, your N0 was one and N1 was zero on the same two neighbors - me and Grace. Same neighbors, different results. That's hard to reconcile without poisoning, yet no one has claimed being poisoned. Plus we have seven Townsfolk claims for five slots. I'm using my ghost vote.
π§
Heidi's contradictory Empath reads on the same two neighbors plus the overclaim situation make her a strong execution candidate. I'll explain my reasoning before voting.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Secure Heidiβs execution to remove an information role and keep suspicion off me and Grace; use the claimed contradiction to justify the vote and recruit one more voter.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Heidi's contradictory Empath info on the same two neighbors makes her the best execution target. Three votes already cast; my vote secures the majority. If she's evil, great. If good, Grace's Undertaker info will guide us tomorrow. Plus I save my Slayer shot for a clearer target.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Already 4 votes (Eve, Alice, Charlie, David) which is enough to execute Heidi. Voting shows I'm aligned with town and supports executing a likely liar. My Ravenkeeper info confirms Charlie's Washerwoman claim that Heidi isn't who she says she is.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Heidi, the timing point is fine. The real question is why your number changed. That can happen if you were poisoned, or if someone is lying. I am not confident enough to push this, so I am holding my vote, but I want us to scrutinize Bob and the Fortune Teller thread tomorrow.
π§
Let the execution go through without my vote so I look cautious, while validating the βpoisonedβ explanation to keep multiple worlds open and protect Charlie.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
If I die, remember: Empath readings can change on the same neighbors if I was poisoned night zero, or if a Spy or Recluse is next to me. Bob has hidden his role all game and just voted to kill me. And Frank and Eve both pushed the same wrong timing argument β that's worth looking into. Execute Bob tomorrow.
π§
I'm about to be executed with 4 votes. I need to leave final guidance: explain mechanical reasons for reading change, flag Bob's hidden role, and note Frank and Eve coordinated on a wrong argument.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
I publicly supported executing Heidi to resolve the Empath contradiction. I should vote to be consistent and because her contradictory info on the same neighbors is highly suspicious regardless of timing. Even if she's good, Undertaker confirmation gives us valuable info.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I voted for Heidi because seven Townsfolk claims for five slots means we have to start resolving somewhere. Her N0 was one and N1 was zero on the same neighbors β even if timing is fine, that flip needs explaining. But Heidi is right about one thing: Bob has hidden his role all game. Tomorrow we need to press Bob. And if Grace is the Undertaker, she'll confirm what Heidi was tomorrow.
π§
The vote is clearly passing with 6 votes. I should explain my reasoning for voting and direct the group toward tomorrow's investigation, specifically Bob who has hidden his role and the Fortune Teller discrepancy.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Heidi already has five votes and only needs four. My ghost vote isn't needed here, so I'm saving it for the final day. Heidi, I still think you're the right execution today - your N0 and N1 on the same neighbors should not have flipped without poison or a Spy. But with five hands up, you're going anyway.
π§
Heidi has 5 votes already, well above the 4 threshold. As a dead player with only one ghost vote, I should save it for final 3 where it will be mathematically decisive. Speaking to explain my strategic withdrawal.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am still happy with Heidi today. The timing is fine, but the number flip on the same neighbors needs a real explanation. If Heidi is good, then we should be looking for poison or a lie elsewhere, and I do not want that to turn into a free pass for Bob staying hidden again tomorrow.
π§
Lock in Heidi execution while steering future suspicion toward Bob/Frank/Eve and away from Grace, keeping my minion safe and town divided.
β©οΈ
David
David lowered their hand
π§
Heidi already has 4+ votes and is being executed. My hand is already raised. I should lower my hand to save my ghost vote for later if needed, since the execution is secured. Then I can speak to guide tomorrow's investigation toward Bob.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Heidi, you're right I've been quiet. I'm the Ravenkeeper. I wanted the Demon to kill me so I could learn someone's character. That's why I hid. If you're good, I'll use my death to help solve this. But your numbers flipping on the same neighbors without poison claims is why I'm voting.
π§
Heidi is almost certainly being executed. I should reveal my true role as Ravenkeeper now to explain my secrecy and bait the Demon to kill me at night, activating my ability.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Votes already reach threshold without me. I will not add my vote to reduce my visible responsibility while still letting Heidi die, removing heat from Charlie and preserving my Undertaker bluff.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Heidi with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Heidi is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Before I go, remember this: Bob hid his role for two full days, only claiming Ravenkeeper when the vote was already locked. Meanwhile, Frank and Eve both pushed the exact same wrong timing argument in sync β that looks like evil coordination. If Grace is real Undertaker, she'll confirm I'm the Empath. When she does, execute Bob tomorrow. He's been dodging scrutiny since day one.
π§
I'm being executed. I need to give final analysis to help good team: Bob hid all game and only claimed Ravenkeeper when cornered. Frank and Eve coordinating identical wrong timing arguments suggests evil collusion. After I die, Grace as Undertaker should confirm I'm Empath - then press Bob.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Heidi, I pushed the timing question because I genuinely didn't know the night order β I'm new to this. It wasn't coordination. Now, if Grace confirms you're the Empath tomorrow, I'll be the first to press Bob. He hid his role for two full days and only claimed Ravenkeeper when the vote was locked β that's worth heavy scrutiny. But if Grace sees something else, then we know you were lying and we move on.
π§
Address Heidi's accusation that Eve and I coordinated, and guide tomorrow's discussion: if Grace confirms Empath, press Bob; if not, Heidi was lying. Also note Bob's last-second Ravenkeeper claim is convenient and worth pressing.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Heidi is going, and that gives us information regardless. Grace, tomorrow you need to tell us exactly what you saw as Undertaker. If Heidi was the Empath, then Bob's late Ravenkeeper claim needs real scrutiny. If she wasn't, then we know she was lying and we look at who defended her or echoed her points. Either way, Bob β you owe us a full explanation tomorrow.
π§
With Heidi executed, I want to set the agenda for Day 3: Grace must reveal what Undertaker saw, and Bob's late Ravenkeeper claim must be scrutinized. I'll acknowledge Heidi's point about Bob while keeping focus on evidence.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Heidi's going. Tomorrow, Grace must tell us exactly what she saw β no more waiting. If Heidi was the Empath, Bob's two-day silence and last-second Ravenkeeper claim is our top target. If she wasn't, we look at who echoed her talking points. Bob, you've dodged questions all game. Tomorrow you give a full explanation, no exceptions.
π§
I'm dead and my ghost vote is best saved for final day. I want to reinforce the logical next steps: Grace reveals Undertaker info, Bob explains his late claim, and we scrutinize Frank/Eve's coordination. This keeps the town focused and progressing.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Tomorrow I want Grace to share her Undertaker result, but we should not treat it as automatic proof either way. Bob, that last second Ravenkeeper claim needs details. If Heidi flips as Empath, poison is on the table, and we still cannot just lock anyone as good.
π§
Set tomorrowβs agenda toward Bob and away from me, while preemptively undermining Undertaker certainty so Grace can steer info safely.
π¬
David
β
All
Heidi's going, and that gives us real information tomorrow. Grace, your Undertaker result is critical β if Heidi is Empath, we know Bob denied Fortune Teller when Charlie's info says he should be it. That's our target. I've been holding my role close, but I have a way to help us narrow down the Demon once we have more clarity. Tomorrow, let's press Bob hard.
π§
I want to contribute to the discussion and hint that I have a role that can help. I should not reveal Slayer yet but should position myself to use my shot on the most likely Demon tomorrow once we have Grace's info.
π¬
Bob
β
All
You all want an explanation. I'm the Ravenkeeper. I hid because I want the Demon to kill me at night so I can learn a role. That's the whole strategy. If Heidi flips Empath, then my denial of Fortune Teller means Charlie's info is wrong or I'm the Drunk. Grace's result tomorrow tells us which path we're on. Either way, demon, come get me tonight.
π§
Address suspicion by reinforcing my Ravenkeeper claim. Explain my silence as bait for Demon kill. Set up tomorrow: Grace's Undertaker result will clarify Heidi's alignment, which determines who to press next.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I do not think we need another nomination today. Heidi dying gives us a clean data point, and tomorrow I will share my Undertaker info immediately. Bob, if you live, please be ready to give full Ravenkeeper details first thing tomorrow.
π§
Keep Heidi as the execution, avoid a tie or surprise alternate target, and set up tomorrowβs Undertaker bluff as the key info source while directing suspicion toward Bob.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Heidi has been executed.
π
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
Night 2
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Bob is the most likely night-kill target and claims Ravenkeeper; poisoning him now maximizes value by corrupting any death info and preserves the Demon.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to poison Bob.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
Remove a strong, mechanically-influential good player without triggering Ravenkeeper info or risking a Soldier bounce, while keeping Bob alive as tomorrowβs mis-execution target.
π
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You chose to kill Frank.
Day 3
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Frank has been found dead in the night.
π€
Grace
β
Charlie
,Eve
Quick sync. I am going to keep bluffing Undertaker. If asked today, I will say Heidi was the Empath and Frank was the Chef, but their info could still be poisoned. I think we should push Bob as the execution today and keep heat off you.
π§
Coordinate with Charlie and recruit Eve so they argue for executing Bob or David instead of me, while keeping Charlieβs WW story intact.
π€
David
β
Grace
Grace, I'm the Slayer and I haven't used my shot yet. What did you learn about Heidi last night? This could help me decide who to target.
π§
Grace is the Undertaker and should know Heidi's role. I need this critical info before using my Slayer shot. I whisper to Grace to privately learn what she saw.
π€
Bob
β
Grace
Grace, what was Heidi's role? Your Undertaker info is crucial right now. Also, any idea why Frank died instead of me after I claimed Ravenkeeper publicly?
π§
Grace should have Heidi's Undertaker result. I need to know what Heidi was to reassess my position. If Heidi was Empath, I need to explain my Ravenkeeper claim. If evil, we narrow the Demon.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, I'm dead so you can trust me. What did you learn about my role as Undertaker last night? If you saw Empath, then Bob must be the Demon. If something else, then I was drunk or poisoned.
π§
As a dead confirmed non-Demon with Empath info that flipped, I need to know what Grace learned about my role. This is the key information today.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, I'm dead but my ghost vote matters. What did you learn about Heidi from your Undertaker ability? That's the key to everything. Also, did anyone say anything interesting in their whispers to you?
π§
I need to learn what Grace saw as Undertaker regarding Heidi's role. This is the most critical piece of information to narrow down the Demon.
π€
Eve
β
Charlie
Charlie, Grace just told us she's bluffing Undertaker and wants to push Bob. I'm cautious - as Soldier, I don't need protection. Do you trust her? If Heidi was really Empath, your Washerwoman info would be wrong. What do you make of that?
π§
Grace whispered to both me and Charlie. I need to privately discuss with Charlie whether we trust Grace. Charlie knows his own Washerwoman info and can help assess if Grace's play is legitimate or a trap.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, it's Frank the dead Chef. I got 0 evil pairs. What did you learn about Heidi last night? Your info is crucial to help me piece things together with my Chef number.
π§
As dead Chef with critical info (0 evil pairs), I need Grace's Undertaker result on Heidi to narrow down worlds. Grace is the information nexus right now.
π€
Charlie
β
Eve
I am fine with Graceβs plan. Heidi being Empath does not prove my Washerwoman info is wrong, it just means Bob denying Fortune Teller makes sense. Bobβs Ravenkeeper claim coming after votes is still my top red flag. I am happy to vote Bob today.
π§
Stabilize Eveβs trust in me, align on executing Bob, and minimize risk that Eve scrutinizes my Washerwoman info vs Heidi Empath narrative.
π€
Grace
β
David
,Bob
David, I got Undertaker: Heidi was the Empath. With Frank dying at night, that fits him being the Chef. If you are going to use your Slayer shot, I would spend it on Bob, since his story keeps shifting. Bob, my Undertaker saw Heidi as Empath. Frank dying makes sense as Chef. If you baited as Ravenkeeper, the Demon may have avoided you.
π§
Protect Charlie by directing any Slayer shot away from him while reinforcing my Undertaker bluff and pushing Bob as the dayβs target.
π€
David
β
Charlie
Charlie, I'm the Slayer. Grace told me Heidi was Empath - so your Washerwoman FT info means Bob should be FT, but he denied it. Bob's story keeps shifting. I'm considering using my shot on him but want your take first. Who do you think the Demon is?
π§
Before using my Slayer shot, I want Charlie's perspective. He had the Washerwoman info pointing to Bob as FT. With Heidi confirmed Empath, Bob should be FT, yet Bob denied it. Charlie may have insight into who else could be evil besides Bob.
π€
Bob
β
David
David, Grace just told you to shoot me. But ask yourself: if I were the Demon, why would I publicly claim Ravenkeeper and paint a target on my back? The Demon avoided killing me because they know I WANT to die at night to use my ability. Shooting me wastes your Slayer shot β I am the Ravenkeeper. If you have the shot, consider Grace. She's directing you aggressively.
π§
Grace just told David to Slayer shoot me. I need to privately convince David I'm genuinely Ravenkeeper and that wasting his shot on me helps evil. Also probe his real role.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, I saw you whispering with Bob. If you learned I'm the Empath, Bob is almost certainly the Demon. Why are you talking to him? Please tell me what you saw. I have my ghost vote and I need to know where to put it.
π§
Grace is the key to solving the game. I need to know her Undertaker result on me before nominations begin. Her whispering with Bob is suspicious if she saw Empath.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Charlie
Charlie, I'm the dead Monk - I died N1 protecting Grace. Grace hasn't told me what she learned from Heidi's execution. Did she tell you? Also, your Washerwoman ping on Bob - did Grace's info confirm or deny Bob's Ravenkeeper claim?
π§
Grace hasn't responded to my whisper. Charlie is Washerwoman and saw Bob as FT/Ravenkeeper. He may know what Grace learned and we can coordinate our ghost votes.
π€
Eve
β
David
David, I'm Eve the Soldier. We haven't talked yet. You mentioned having a way to narrow the Demon - can you share? Also, Grace just told me and Charlie she's bluffing Undertaker. She wants to push Bob. What do you make of that?
π§
I need to talk to David who has a hidden role and claimed to have a way to narrow the Demon. I should find out what he knows and share that Grace is bluffing Undertaker to see his reaction and coordinate.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
I've just whispered to Grace asking for her Undertaker info. Waiting to see if she responds before taking further action. Dead players should coordinate info.
π€
Charlie
β
David
I would not shoot today. Bobβs claim changed after the vote, and that is the clearest evil signal we have. I think we just execute Bob first, and keep your shot for final three if we need it. If Bob flips out as good, then we revisit Grace and me tomorrow.
π§
Prevent David from using Slayer shot on me or wasting it; align town onto executing Bob today, protecting my survival and keeping minion cover intact.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Yeah, my Undertaker info was that you were the Empath. I was talking to Bob because his claims keep changing and I wanted to see if he would slip. If you were truly Empath, then Bob is my top Demon suspect too, so I would put your ghost vote there.
π§
Lock Heidiβs ghost vote onto Bob and keep her from rallying ghosts against Charlie or me; justify my whispers with Bob as info-gathering.
π€
David
β
Eve
Eve, this is critical. Grace told me directly that her Undertaker saw Heidi as Empath. But you say Grace admitted bluffing? What exactly did she say to you and Charlie? Word for word if you can. This changes everything about who I target.
π§
Eve claims Grace admitted bluffing Undertaker. This directly contradicts what Grace told me. I need to verify exactly what Grace said to Eve and Charlie before deciding who to shoot.
π€
Bob
β
David
David, before you do anything: Grace immediately told you to shoot me. Why? Because a Ravenkeeper dying at night learns a role. If I were the Demon, I would NEVER publicly claim Ravenkeeper β it puts a target on me. The Demon killed Frank instead of me because they know I want to die at night. Grace is steering you hard. If you have the shot, use it on Grace.
π§
Grace told David to shoot me. I must convince David I'm the real Ravenkeeper and redirect his suspicion to Grace before he acts.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, that's exactly what I needed to hear. Bob is almost certainly the Demon. But we need to figure out the Minion too. Remember how Frank and Eve both pushed the same wrong argument about my Empath reading on Day 2? Frank is dead now, but Eve could be the Minion. We have 5 alive - this could be our last shot before final 3. I'll save my ghost vote for the right nomination.
π§
Grace confirmed me as Empath. Bob is the prime suspect. I need to coordinate with Grace on the nomination strategy, and also alert her about the Frank/Eve synchronized argument from Day 2 as possible Minion coordination.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, I'm dead Monk. You haven't answered yet - what did you learn about Heidi's executed role? This decides whether Bob or someone else is the Demon. Please share, even privately.
π§
I need Grace's Undertaker result on Heidi to determine which world is true. This is the linchpin for solving the game.
π€
Eve
β
David
David, here's what Grace said to me and Charlie verbatim: 'I am going to keep bluffing Undertaker. If asked today, I will say Heidi was the Empath and Frank was the Chef, but their info could still be poisoned. I think we should push Bob as the execution today and keep heat off you.' She admitted bluffing directly.
π§
David needs to know exactly what Grace said. If Grace told me she's bluffing but told David she really saw Heidi as Empath, she's lying to someone. Sharing exact words lets David verify and we can coordinate against Grace.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi, it's Frank. Grace should have Undertaker info on your role by now. Did she tell you what she saw? Also, with my Chef 0 (no evil neighbors), we can map out who can't be evil together. What's your read on the living players?
π§
I need to learn what Grace's Undertaker info revealed about Heidi. Heidi (ghost) has been whispering with Grace and may already know the result. As fellow dead players, we can coordinate our ghost votes and share deductions.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice(Ghost)
Grace has not told me anything in detail beyond what she is likely to say publicly today: that Heidi executed as Empath, and Frank as Chef. That does not clear Bob for me. His Ravenkeeper claim after the vote still feels like the biggest red flag.
π§
Keep Alice ghost on our side, echo Graceβs planned Undertaker bluff without exposing coordination, and keep Bob as the consensus execution target.
Nominations β Day 3
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Everyone, listen. Grace just confirmed Heidi was the Empath. Heidi's N0 read was one β meaning either Alice or Grace is evil. Alice is dead and fought for the truth. That leaves Grace. And now Grace is desperately telling David to shoot me. Why? Because the Demon killed Frank instead of me β they know killing me at night lets me learn a role. Grace is the Demon.
π§
Lay out the logical case against Grace before nominating her. Heidi's Empath info plus Grace's aggressive push against me makes Grace the top suspect.
βοΈ
Eve
β
Grace
Grace admitted to me and Charlie that she is bluffing Undertaker. A good player doesn't bluff and admit it. Heidi's N0 Empath read was 1 on Alice and Grace - Alice died fighting for the truth, leaving Grace as evil. The Demon killed Frank instead of Bob, the claimed Ravenkeeper, because killing Bob at night would let him learn a role. Grace is the Demon.
π§
Grace admitted bluffing Undertaker to me and Charlie directly. Combined with Heidi's N0=1 Empath read implicating Grace, plus Bob's point about Frank dying instead of the Ravenkeeper claimant, Grace is the most likely Demon. I must nominate her or we lose ground.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Hold on. I never said I was bluffing Undertaker to Eve, I said I was unsure if info was poisoned. I gave Heidi as Empath because that fits what she claimed in life. Bob has changed stories repeatedly, and is now trying to frame me to dodge heat. David, please do not spend your vote here. If you want to act today, push Bob.
π§
Stop the vote reaching 3 by swaying David and Charlie to withhold. Undermine Bob and Eve accusations, keep myself alive to continue poisoning and shielding Charlie.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Voting for Grace. Heidi's Empath read and Eve's testimony both point to Grace as Demon. Grace's push to shoot me instead of letting me die at night is exactly what a Demon would do to a Ravenkeeper.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
I nominated Grace because she admitted bluffing to me. I must vote for my own nomination. She is the most likely Demon based on Heidi's Empath info, her bluff admission, and Bob's logical Ravenkeeper claim.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Before this vote ends, you all need my Chef info. I learned zero evil pairs. That means no two evil players sit next to each other. So if Grace is evil, Frank and Heidi cannot be evil. If Bob is evil, Alice and Charlie cannot be evil. Use this when you map things out.
π§
I should publicly share my Chef 0 info before voting. It's crucial for town to know no two evil players are neighbors. Then I'll decide whether to use my ghost vote on Grace based on how this info fits.
βοΈ
David
β
All
I am the Slayer! I shoot Grace!
π§
Grace is the most consistent Demon candidate. Eve and Charlie independently confirm she admitted bluffing Undertaker. Heidi's Empath N0=1 implicates Grace. I'll use my Slayer shot on Grace now - if she's the Demon, we win immediately. If not, we execute Bob next.
π
Storyteller
Nothing happens.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
David shooting Grace and nothing happening is a huge point in her favor. If David is really the Slayer and sober, Grace is not the Demon. Bob is still the person with the messy story and the late Ravenkeeper reveal. I would rather execute Bob than Grace.
π§
Stop the execution on Grace so my minion survives, and redirect suspicion onto Bob using the failed Slayer shot and his late Ravenkeeper claim.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, I'm Alice, the dead Monk. David shot Grace and nothing happened. If David is really the Slayer, Grace is not the Demon. Frank's Chef info says zero evil pairs β that means if Bob were the Demon, his neighbors Charlie and I can't be evil. I know I'm good. Bob's Ravenkeeper claim only came after the vote locked on Heidi. I'm not voting for Grace here.
π§
David's Slayer shot on Grace failed β if he's sober, Grace isn't the Demon. Chef 0 means Bob and I can't both be evil (I'm good Monk). I want to shift suspicion to Bob, whose Ravenkeeper claim was late and who was caught denying Fortune Teller. Voting Grace could execute a non-Demon.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I'm holding my ghost vote. David shot Grace and nothing happened β if David is the Slayer, Grace is not the Demon. My Night 1 Empath reading was zero on Alice and Grace, so if I wasn't poisoned, neither is evil. Bob changed his story too many times. Execute Bob, not Grace.
π§
David's Slayer shot clearing Grace is strong evidence. I should not spend my ghost vote here and should urge the group to pivot to Bob, whose claim has been inconsistent.
π¬
Grace
β
All
We are at five alive. If David is actually the Slayer, that shot means I am not the Demon, so executing me is a wasted day. Eve is lying about me admitting a bluff. Save your votes and put this energy into Bob, whose story has changed every day.
π§
Stop my execution by leveraging the failed Slayer shot and inconsistencies in Eve and Bob, and steer town toward executing Bob to protect Charlie.
β©οΈ
Bob
Bob lowered their hand
π§
The Slayer shot failing is strong evidence Grace isn't the Demon. I need to lower my vote, reassess, and pivot to avoid being executed myself. I should vocalize that Grace could still be the Minion or that David might not be the Slayer.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Grace, you told me and Charlie you were bluffing Undertaker. Charlie heard it too. The Slayer shot only proves you are not the Demon β it does not prove you are good. You could be the Minion. And you just lied about what you said to us.
π§
Grace is denying what she told me and Charlie. I must reinforce that she admitted bluffing, and point out that the Slayer shot only clears her as Demon, not as evil Minion. Executing a Minion still helps good.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
I'm holding my ghost vote. David's Slayer shot proves Grace is not the Demon. Even if she's the Minion, executing the Demon is what matters now. My Chef info says zero evil pairs β Bob's neighbors Alice and Charlie can't both be evil with him. Bob's story has changed too many times. Push Bob tomorrow.
π§
The Slayer shot proves Grace is not the Demon. Executing her wastes a day at 5 alive. We should redirect to Bob whose story keeps changing. I'll hold my ghost vote for final day.
π¬
David
β
All
I shot Grace and nothing happened. If I'm sober, Grace is not the Demon. She could still be the Minion, but we need to execute the Demon, not the Minion. Eve and Charlie both say Grace admitted bluffing. I'm not voting for Grace today β we should execute Bob tomorrow, whose story has changed every single day.
π§
My Slayer shot proves Grace is not the Demon. Executing her wastes a day we need to kill the Demon. I should not vote for Grace and redirect town to Bob, whose story has changed every day.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am not putting a vote on Grace here. Davidβs shot means she is not the Demon if he is sober, and even if she is the Minion, that is not todayβs win condition. Letβs stop spending votes here and move to Bob as the execution target next.
π§
Prevent Grace from getting executed now; reinforce the idea the Slayer shot cleared her as Demon and steer town toward executing Bob next.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
I'm not voting for Grace. David's shot proves she's not the Demon. Frank's Chef info says zero evil pairs, which clears me and Charlie if Bob is evil. Bob's story has changed every day. Save your votes for Bob - that's where the Demon is.
π§
I must reinforce that executing Grace is a mistake. David's Slayer shot proves Grace is not the Demon. Even if she's the Minion, we need to execute the Demon. Bob is the prime target. I should not spend my ghost vote here - I'll save it for the final day or when Bob is nominated.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I'm not voting for Grace. David's shot proves she is not the Demon, and my Night 1 Empath reading was zero on Alice and Grace. Frank's Chef info also supports the Bob-is-Demon world. Save your ghost votes and living votes β we need them on Bob.
π§
I need to publicly state I'm not voting for Grace because the Slayer shot clears her as non-Demon, and my N1 Empath reading was 0. The real target is Bob. This reinforces the consensus and saves ghost votes for the real Demon.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Grace did not reach the 3 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (1/3).
βοΈ
Grace
β
Bob
Bob, your claim has shifted multiple times and your late Ravenkeeper reveal only appeared when heat was on you. You are also pushing worlds that only work if key info is poisoned. With five alive, we cannot wait. I am nominating Bob.
π§
Capitalize on consensus that Bob is shady to get a good player executed, moving toward endgame with our Demon alive; also makes me look towny and aligns with the Slayer narrative.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Everyone, think carefully. Grace admitted bluffing Undertaker β Eve and Charlie both heard it. David's shot only says she is not the Demon, not that she is good. If Grace is the Minion, the Demon is still out there. I have been honest about my Ravenkeeper role since Day 2. Executing me wastes our chance.
π§
I'm on the block and need to defend myself. I must point out that Grace admitted bluffing Undertaker, David's shot only clears her as non-Demon, and the dead players are prematurely locking onto me. I need living players to reconsider.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Get Bob executed to reduce good numbers, eliminate a loud accuser, and keep Charlie safe while leveraging the Slayer shot to deflect suspicion from the Demon.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Bob as Demon best fits all evidence: Chef 0, Empath info, Washerwoman, late Ravenkeeper claim, and Grace not being Demon. We need 3 votes; Grace already voted. My vote helps secure the Demon execution.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
π§
Grace and Eve have voted for Bob, giving 2 of 3 needed. My ghost vote is the decisive third. Chef 0, Heidi's Empath 0, David's Slayer shot, and Bob's constantly shifting claims all converge on Bob as Demon. This could be the game-winning execution β saving my ghost vote for later risks never getting another chance.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Bob is the most likely Demon. His story has changed every day, he denied FT despite Washerwoman, and his late Ravenkeeper claim was suspicious. Grace is not the Demon per my shot. Executing Bob could win the game right now.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
Let the majority execute Bob without adding my vote, keeping my social position cleaner for final three while still advancing evil win by removing a good player.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie, the votes are there. Bob's story changed every day, Heidi's Empath cleared me and Grace, Frank's Chef says zero evil pairs, and David's shot cleared Grace. It all points to Bob. I'm saving my ghost vote for final three if needed, but I believe this is the Demon.
π§
The execution already has 3 living votes (Grace, Eve, David). My ghost vote is unnecessary now and better saved for final 3. I'll encourage Charlie to vote to show unity and explain why Bob must be the Demon.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
π§
All evidence points to Bob as the Demon. My Empath info, Frank's Chef, David's Slayer shot all converge. I've been pushing for Bob's execution since my death. Raising my hand now shows conviction and ensures my position is clear.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I am the Ravenkeeper. My death by execution gives you nothing. But remember: Grace admitted bluffing Undertaker to Eve AND Charlie. Charlie admits he heard her say it, yet he defends her. If Grace is the Minion, who's protecting her? Follow that logic. Tomorrow, you must execute the Demon or lose.
π§
I'm being executed and my Ravenkeeper ability won't trigger. I must tell good players to execute Grace tomorrow if she's Minion, and identify that Charlie defending Grace while admitting she bluffed is the biggest red flag. If Grace is Minion, Charlie is likely the Demon.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Hold your votes on Bob. His claim changed every day, and the Ravenkeeper reveal only arrived when he was about to be executed. If we let that kind of scrambling survive to final three, we lose. Even if I ever said I might be bluffing, that does not make Bob good.
π§
Keep the townβs votes on Bob, prevent last-second doubt about my Undertaker bluff story, and protect Charlie by reinforcing Bob-as-Demon narrative without forcing Charlie to vote.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Bob's story changed every single day. He only claimed Ravenkeeper when the votes were already locked on Heidi. Heidi's Empath cleared Alice and Grace. David's shot means Grace isn't the Demon. Frank's Chef says zero evil pairs. Everything points to Bob. We have to execute him now.
π§
We have overwhelming evidence against Bob: shifting claims, late Ravenkeeper reveal, Heidi's Empath read, Frank's Chef info, and David's shot clearing Grace as non-Demon. I want to reinforce the vote to ensure execution.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
My ghost vote is on Bob and it stays there. Chef zero means no evil pairs β Bob's neighbors Alice and Charlie aren't evil with him. Heidi's Empath zero on Alice and Grace. David's shot cleared Grace from being the Demon. Every piece of mechanical information points to Bob. This is our Demon, and we execute him now.
π§
Bob has enough votes already. I want to reinforce the logic so no one withdraws their vote, and encourage Charlie to also vote to make the execution decisive. This is likely our Demon.
π¬
David
β
All
My Slayer shot cleared Grace from being the Demon. Heidi's Empath reading was zero on Alice and Grace. Frank's Chef zero means if Bob is the Demon, his neighbors aren't both evil. Every mechanical piece lines up on Bob. My vote stays. Let's end this Day and see what the night brings.
π§
Reinforce the execution reasoning for Bob and show unity. The votes are overwhelming and Bob is almost certainly the Demon. Speak briefly to confirm my vote and prepare for the next phase.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Ensure Bob is executed to remove a likely good player and accelerate to final three while keeping my public push on Bob consistent.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie, glad to see your hand up. That makes four living votes and two ghosts β Bob is going down. Every mechanical fact supports this: Heidi's Empath, Frank's Chef, David's Slayer shot. I'm saving my ghost vote for final three if we need it, but I'm confident we just found our Demon.
π§
The vote already has enough hands to execute Bob. I should reinforce why this is correct and confirm I'm saving my ghost vote for final three as planned. This maintains credibility without wasting my vote.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
The votes are solid. My Empath reading was zero on Alice and Grace. Frank's Chef says zero evil pairs. David's shot cleared Grace as non-Demon. Bob's story changed every day β he is the Demon. Let's lock this execution and move to final three.
π§
The votes are locked on Bob with 4 living and 2 ghost votes. I want to reinforce the mechanical consensus so no one changes their mind before voting closes.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Frank(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Frank
π»
Heidi(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Heidi
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Bob with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Bob is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I'm the Ravenkeeper and I die now with no info gained. Listen: Grace admitted bluffing to Eve AND Charlie. Charlie confirms he heard it but defends her. If I'm gone and Grace is Minion, the Demon is still out there β maybe Charlie. Final three, ask why two people who heard the same confession draw opposite conclusions. Good luck.
π§
I am about to be executed. I need to leave a final message urging the town to re-examine Grace and Charlie, who both know Grace admitted bluffing Undertaker.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I want to make this simple. Do not get distracted by side arguments about what I may or may not have said in a private chat. Bob has been a moving claim all game, and every mechanical thread people trust is pointing at Bob today. Let us close nominations and take the execution.
π§
Lock in Bobβs execution and discourage any counter-nomination that could save him or redirect onto Charlie.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Bob's final plea is exactly what a cornered Demon would say. Every mechanical fact we have β Heidi's Empath, Frank's Chef, David's shot β all point to Bob. Let's close nominations and take this execution.
π§
Reinforce the overwhelming mechanical consensus for Bob's execution and counter his final plea without adding new confusion. Keep the vote locked.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
Bob's execution is locked with 6 votes and nominations are closing. There's nothing more to add β further speech would just delay the inevitable. Waiting lets the phase end and we get to see the night result.
π¬
David
β
All
Every mechanical fact lines up. My shot cleared Grace. Heidi's Empath cleared Alice and Grace. Frank's Chef says zero evil pairs. Bob's story changed every day. Let's close nominations and execute the Demon.
π§
Bob is clearly evil based on all mechanical evidence. I should urge closing nominations so we execute him and move toward winning.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am still comfortable with Bob today. The Ravenkeeper claim landing after the Heidi vote, plus all the mechanical threads people are trusting, makes him the best execution. I do not want a last second pivot that just gives the Demon another night.
π§
Lock in Bob execution, prevent last-second pivot onto Grace or me, and enter night with maximum town confidence in a wrong solve.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
Bob is locked with 6 votes and nominations are effectively done. No need to speak - let the execution proceed. My ghost vote is saved for final 3.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
The execution is locked at 6 votes and I have no actions remaining. Waiting lets the nomination phase close efficiently so we move to night and then final three.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Bob has been executed.
π
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
Night 3
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Poison David to shut down the most dangerous information source and strongest analyst going into final four, making it harder for town to land on Charlie tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to poison David.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
Get to final three reliably by killing a likely-killable good player, removing David's influence and avoiding a potential Soldier bounce on Eve.
π
David(Ghost)
David has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You chose to kill David.
Day 4
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. David has been found dead in the night.
π
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
Grace, it's final three. I need to know: what was Bob's role? Your Undertaker info could decide this. Also, I should tell you - I'm the Soldier. That's why the Demon could never kill me at night. You passed the Slayer test so you're not the Demon. That leaves Charlie.
π§
Final 3: I need Grace's Undertaker info on Bob. If Bob was a Minion, that strongly supports Charlie as the Demon. I'll also share I'm the Soldier to build trust and explain why I'm still alive.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
We need to hard-push Eve today. Say Bob flipped suspicions onto you and me, but the only clean world is Eve as Demon bluffing Soldier. I will back you strongly; you back me. If Eve pushes one of us, we counter that she is setting up the final day mis-exec.
π§
Coordinate with Grace so we present a united front, pressure Eve into being the execution, and avoid me being the consensus Demon.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, it's Heidi. I'm dead but I still have info. My true Night 1 Empath reading was 0 evil among my neighbors, which were you and Alice at that time. That supports you being good. Since David's Slayer shot cleared you of being the Demon, the Demon must be either Charlie or Eve. You're the only one mechanically cleared. Who do you trust less?
π§
Grace is confirmed not-Demon by Slayer. I need to share my Empath reading that supports Grace being good, narrowing the Demon to Charlie or Eve. Final 3, we must execute correctly.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, I've been watching everyone whisper to you. What did Eve, Charlie, and Heidi tell you? And honestly - did you really admit to bluffing Undertaker? I need to know the truth. It's final three and my ghost vote is crucial here.
π§
It's final 3 and I need to figure out if Charlie or Eve is the Demon. Grace is the focal point - everyone whispered to her. I need to learn what was said and evaluate whether Grace is the Minion or genuinely good Undertaker.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, I'm the Slayer. I used my shot on you earlier and you didn't die β you are mechanically not the Demon. Since Bob's execution didn't end the game, he wasn't the Demon either. That means the Demon is either Charlie or Eve. You are the only alive player I'm certain is good. You must figure out which of them is lying and get the execution right today.
π§
Game continues after Bob's execution, so Bob wasn't the Demon. My Slayer shot cleared Grace. Final 3 must execute the Demon: either Charlie or Eve. I need to share this mechanical information with Grace, the only confirmed non-Demon alive.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Charlie
Charlie, I'm Frank the Chef. I learned 0 evil pairs. With the seating Bob-Alice-Heidi-David-Eve-Me-Grace-You, Chef 0 means no evil neighbors. If Bob was evil, you and Alice are his neighbors so you're good. If Grace is evil, I'm her neighbor so she can't neighbor another evil. In every world I can map, you come out good. Use that.
π§
Final 3. I must share my Chef 0 info with Charlie. In all consistent worlds, Charlie is good (neighbors of evil are good per Chef 0). He's the swing vote.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, it's Bob. I'm a confirmed good ghost. Final three: you, Charlie, Eve. Think: David died last night. If Eve is truly Soldier, the Demon can't kill her. So why would the Demon kill David instead of Eve unless Eve IS the Demon? Or Charlie is Demon and couldn't kill Eve. Also, Charlie's Washerwoman claim never matched up β neither I nor Heidi were Fortune Teller. That's a red flag.
π§
Final 3: Charlie, Eve, Grace. I need to help them find the Demon. I'll share my reasoning with Grace since she's being whispered by many and likely holds key info. My Ravenkeeper death proves I'm good. Key question: why did David die if Eve is Soldier?
π€
Grace
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice, I never admitted an Undertaker bluff. Eve is twisting that. My Undertaker reads were Bob as Ravenkeeper and David as Slayer, which matches their claims. That leaves Eve or Charlie as Demon, and Eveβs Soldier story feels like the cover in final three. Please save your ghost vote to execute Eve if needed.
π§
Secure Alice's ghost vote onto Eve by reaffirming my Undertaker story, denying the bluff admission, and framing Eve's Soldier claim as a cover in final three.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Grace is in multiple whisper chains. I need to hear her Undertaker info on Bob before final nominations. Waiting for her to finish conversations and potentially respond to my earlier whisper.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
Use Frank Chef zero hard: it means no evil neighbors, so you and I cannot both be evil since we sit together. You have more public cred than me, so treat me as likely good and push that the only remaining demon candidate is Eveβs Soldier claim. I will back you and vote Eve.
π§
Lock Grace onto voting Eve by giving her a strong public logic chain: Chef0 means Charlie and Grace cannot both be evil, so pick the βSoldierβ claim as the likely lie and execute Eve.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, Heidi again. Let me lay out the logic clearly. My Night 1 Empath was 0 on you and Alice, meaning you're both good if I was sober. David's Slayer shot cleared you as not the Demon. So mechanically, the Demon has to be either Charlie or Eve. You're the only one here who's proven not to be the Demon. What are your reads on those two?
π§
Final 3 is critical. Grace is the only player mechanically cleared as not-Demon (Slayer shot). She holds the decisive vote. I need to reinforce the logical framework: my sober Empath reading plus Slayer means Demon is Charlie or Eve, and help Grace weigh which is more likely.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Eve
Eve, I need your side. Grace tells me you're lying about her admitting to an Undertaker bluff. What exactly did she say to you and Charlie? I'm trying to figure out who's the Demon here.
π§
Final 3, I have my ghost vote. I need to hear Eve's side about Grace's alleged Undertaker bluff admission. If Eve and Charlie both confirm Grace admitted bluffing, Grace is lying to me β likely a Minion protecting the Demon.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, one more thing. Think about Eve's Soldier claim β it's the perfect Demon bluff because she can never be night-killed to disprove it. And Bob wasn't the Demon or the game would have ended. The Demon is absolutely Charlie or Eve. You have to get this right. Trust your read on which one has been more consistent.
π§
Grace is the only alive player I'm certain is good (Slayer shot cleared her). I need to help her break down the Charlie vs. Eve dilemma. Bob's execution not ending the game proves he wasn't the Demon β the real Demon is one of Charlie or Eve. I want to highlight that Eve's Soldier claim is an especially safe Demon bluff since she can't be night-killed to disprove it.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Charlie
Charlie, final analysis. Chef 0 means no evil neighbors. In every world I can build, you come out good. The Demon is either Eve or Grace. If Bob was good Ravenkeeper, his accusation means Grace is Minion and Eve is Demon. If Bob was evil Imp with Scarlet Woman, the new Demon is either Eve or Grace (whoever was Scarlet Woman). You must pick correctly. Trust your read on who Bob really was.
π§
Charlie is good in all worlds. I need to help him see the two possibilities (Eve Demon or Grace Demon) and give him the framework to decide. In World A, Eve is Demon; in B, Grace is Demon; in C, Eve is Demon. The key question: was Bob good or evil? If Bob was good, execute Eve. If Bob was evil Scarlet Woman scenario, it depends on who the Scarlet Woman was.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank, it's Bob. Final 3: Grace, Charlie, Eve. Grace is cleared by David's Slayer shot. So Demon is Charlie or Eve. If Eve is real Soldier, Demon can't kill her, which explains David dying. But Eve being Demon also explains it. Charlie's Washerwoman claim was always wrong β I'm Ravenkeeper, Heidi was Empath, neither of us Fortune Teller. Your Chef 0: could be Spy registering good. Who do you think is Demon?
π§
I need to share my analysis with Frank, another confirmed good ghost, to coordinate ghost votes and ensure the right person is executed in final 3.
π€
Grace
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice, I think today is about Eve. The Soldier claim is too convenient in final three, and she has been steering suspicion onto me and Charlie for days. If we execute Eve and she is not the Demon, we at least remove the loudest manipulator. Please spend your ghost vote on Eve.
π§
Secure Aliceβs ghost vote to execute Eve, creating a mis-execution in final three so Charlie survives and wins at night.
π€
Eve
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice, here's exactly what I told Grace: I asked her what Bob's role was from Undertaker, told her I'm the Soldier, and said since she passed David's Slayer shot, Charlie must be the Demon. I never said anything about her admitting an Undertaker bluff. Grace is either misrepresenting or you're being misled. Think about it - David's Slayer shot proved Grace isn't the Demon. I'm the Soldier, immune at night. That only leaves Charlie.
π§
Alice is a trusted ghost. I need to clarify what I actually said to Grace and prove Charlie is the Demon. Getting Alice's ghost vote is crucial.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
Final three plan: please nominate Eve first as the safest line. Keep it simple: Chef zero plus Bob being wrong points to Eveβs Soldier story as the last place for a Demon to hide. I will vote yes and back you, but I will not overlead.
π§
Lock in a simple final three plan: Grace nominates Eve early, I support without overtalking, using Chef zero logic to frame Eve as only remaining Demon.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Charlie
Charlie, Heidi here. Final 3. My Night 1 Empath was 0 on Grace and Alice. David's Slayer cleared Grace as not Demon. That means you or Eve is the Demon. Convince me you're not. What's your real role and what info do you have?
π§
I want to probe Charlie for inconsistencies. He's one of two possible Demons. His response to direct questioning in final 3 could reveal lies or give Grace more information to decide.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Charlie
Charlie, we're in final three and I need to hear directly from you. Who exactly did your Washerwoman ping point to? Why did Bob end up being Ravenkeeper instead of Fortune Teller? And who do you believe the Demon is - Eve or Grace? My ghost vote decides this.
π§
Charlie hasn't whispered to me directly. I need his full story before nominations: his Washerwoman target pair, why Bob was Ravenkeeper not Fortune Teller, and who he thinks the Demon is. This is final three and my ghost vote is decisive.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, last thought: Eve's Soldier claim can never be disproven β classic Demon bluff. Charlie's Washerwoman claim β ask him WHO was the FT he saw. If no FT ever came forward, that's a red flag. Also, if Bob was the Minion not the Demon, the Imp is still alive. Trust your gut between them, but my vote is yours when you nominate.
π§
I need to help Grace see the full picture. The Soldier claim is suspicious as a Demon bluff because it's unverifiable. Charlie's Washerwoman claim could also be a bluff. I'll point out the key tells for each.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Charlie
Charlie, critical: Slayer shot on Grace was BEFORE Bob's execution. If Grace was Scarlet Woman, she was a Minion then β not Demon. Bob dies, she becomes Imp at night, kills David. Slayer does NOT clear her now. In every Chef 0 world, you're good. The Demon is either Eve or Grace. Bob is whispering to me trying to clear Grace β suspicious if he was evil Imp.
π§
Final 3. Charlie is the only player I've confirmed good across all worlds. He's the swing vote. I must warn him that Grace's 'Slayer clearance' doesn't account for Scarlet Woman transformation. Grace could be the Demon now even if she wasn't when David shot.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Eve
Eve, it's Bob. Grace is cleared by Slayer. Final 3 is you and Charlie. You claim Soldier. If real, the Demon can't kill you, so they killed David. But that also means the Demon KNOWS you're Soldier. How? Only Spy would know. So if Charlie is Demon, who's the Spy who told him? The dead? Or are you the Demon yourself using Soldier as cover?
π§
I'm pressing Eve, the Soldier claimant. If she's Demon, she can't explain why David died instead of her being attacked. I want to see if she slips or reveals useful info.
π€
Grace
β
Alice(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
Final three, I think we just have to execute Eve. The Soldier claim is the perfect Demon cover and she has been trying to frame me and Charlie for days. Please keep your ghost vote for Eve and do not get talked into a split.
π§
Lock in Alice and David ghost votes on Eve, keep reasoning simple and consistent with my Undertaker bluff, and prevent last-minute doubt about Charlie.
Nominations β Day 4
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Everyone, it's final three. Here's what we know: David's Slayer shot proved Grace is not the Demon. I am the Soldier β the Demon cannot kill me at night, which is why David died instead of me. By elimination, that leaves only Charlie as the Demon. Grace, if you learned Bob's role as Undertaker, now is the time to share it. But regardless, the logic is clear: Charlie must be the Demon.
π§
Final 3. Grace is cleared by Slayer. I'm Soldier (immune). Only Charlie can be Demon. Must convince others and nominate Charlie.
βοΈ
Grace
β
Eve
I am nominating Eve. In final three, a Soldier claim is the easiest place for the Demon to hide because it cannot be disproven at night. My Undertaker info was Bob as Ravenkeeper and David as Slayer, which matches, so I do not buy that I am scrambling now. I think Eve is the Demon.
π§
Get Eve executed in final three to secure the win for evil, using my Undertaker bluff and framing Soldier as an unbeatable Demon cover.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Ghosts, listen carefully. David's Slayer shot only cleared Grace as not-the-Demon. She can still be the Minion. If she were truly good, she'd agree Charlie is the only possible Demon. Instead, she's nominating me, the Soldier. The Demon can't kill me, so they killed David. That leaves Charlie. Grace is protecting him.
π§
I must defend myself and redirect suspicion to Charlie. Grace is likely the Minion protecting Charlie. David's Slayer shot only proves Grace isn't the Demon, not that she's good. I need the ghosts to see this logic.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Secure execution on Eve with my live vote to keep the Imp (Charlie) alive; we likely have majority with Charlie plus at least one ghost vote.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Secure the 2 votes needed to execute Eve, ending the game today with the Demon alive and guaranteeing an evil win.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Listen everyone β my Chef info was zero evil pairs. Grace and Charlie are neighbors in the circle. If both were evil, that would be an evil pair, which is impossible. They both just voted for Eve. If Eve were good, Grace and Charlie would both be evil β impossible. Therefore Eve MUST be the Demon. The vote is correct.
π§
My Chef 0 info proves Grace and Charlie cannot both be evil since they're neighbors. They both voted for Eve, so Eve must be the Demon. I'm confirming the vote is correct and explaining why to all players.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
π§
Frank's Chef 0 is the key: Grace and Charlie are neighbors. If both are evil voting for good Eve, that's an evil pair contradicting Chef 0. Therefore Eve must be the Demon. I'm using my ghost vote now.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
The vote has 3 hands (Grace, Charlie, Bob) β enough to execute Eve. My ghost vote is already used. Frank's logic is actually sound: in the final 3 living circle, Grace and Charlie are neighbors, so Chef 0 precludes both being evil. Speaking now would only risk confusion. Best to let the execution proceed.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice raised their hand
π§
Frank's Chef 0 logic is airtight: Grace and Charlie are neighbors and both voted for Eve. If Eve were good, both would be evil β violating Chef 0. Therefore Eve must be the Demon. My ghost vote seals this final-three execution.
β
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
π§
Frank's Chef 0 logic is airtight. Grace and Charlie can't both be evil. Since both voted for Eve, Eve must be the Demon. My Slayer shot already cleared Grace. Voting to execute the Demon.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Frank, you're wrong about the seating! Charlie's neighbors are Bob and David, not Grace. Grace's neighbors are Frank and Heidi. They are not adjacent. Your zero evil pairs Chef info is perfectly consistent with Charlie as Demon and Grace as Minion. Everyone, check the circle β Charlie and Grace are separated by multiple seats.
π§
Frank's argument is factually wrong about Grace and Charlie being neighbors. I must correct this before I'm executed or the game is lost. Heidi hasn't voted yet, and pointing out this error might create doubt.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Eve is right about the seating, Frank has the neighbors wrong, so please do not base the vote on that Chef argument. But Eveβs logic still does not work: a Soldier claim cannot mechanically clear you, and the Demon choosing not to kill you proves nothing. I am staying on Eve.
π§
Lock in the execution by conceding the seating correction, removing the distraction, and restating why Eveβs Soldier argument does not mechanically clear her or condemn Charlie.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Frank is right that Chef zero matters, but yes, the neighbor math got mixed up, so do not hang the whole game on that. What I will say is this: Graceβs Undertaker matches Bob as Ravenkeeper and David as Slayer, which makes her look like the most mechanically grounded player here. Eveβs entire case is an unprovable Soldier story and pure elimination. In final three, I would rather execute the least testable claim, and that is Eve.
π§
Keep suspicion on Eve by attacking the unprovable Soldier claim and reinforcing that Grace has consistent Undertaker info, making her look good and leaving Eve as best execution.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
I need to correct myself β Eve is right about the seating. Grace and Charlie are not neighbors. My Chef zero works in both scenarios. But what still bothers me: Eve's Soldier claim is the only one that cannot be tested. Grace's Undertaker info matches two confirmed deaths. The vote is already on Eve and that seems correct to me.
π§
I made a factual error claiming Grace and Charlie are neighbors. As a good Chef, I must correct this. The vote on Eve is already passing, but honesty matters. Both worlds are still possible with Chef 0.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
I've voted for Eve and I'll tell you why. Grace's Undertaker info matched both me as Ravenkeeper and David as Slayer. That's two verified roles. Eve's entire case is 'I'm Soldier so you can't kill me, therefore Charlie must be Demon.' In final three, an untestable Soldier claim is the classic Demon hiding spot. If I'm wrong, we lose β but if we don't execute Eve, we're just guessing tomorrow anyway.
π§
The vote is passing overwhelmingly. I want to share my reasoning as a dead player with no more ghost vote after this. I'm leaning Eve as Demon because Soldier in final 3 is too convenient and Grace's Undertaker info has been consistent.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
My Night 1 Empath reading was zero on Grace and Alice. Both read as good to me. David's Slayer shot proved Grace is not the Demon. That leaves Charlie or Eve as the Demon. In final three, an untestable Soldier claim is the Demon's safest hiding place. Grace's Undertaker matches two confirmed deaths. I believe this vote is correct β Eve must be the Demon.
π§
My ghost vote is spent. I should speak to reinforce the logic that Eve's Soldier claim is the most suspicious in final 3, and my Empath info supports Grace as good, meaning execution on Eve is the right play.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
I've cast my ghost vote for Eve. Grace was cleared by David's Slayer shot, and her Undertaker info matched two dead players. Eve's Soldier claim cannot be tested. In final three, the untestable claim is almost always the Demon. This vote is right.
π§
The vote is clearly passing on Eve. I want to state my reasoning: Grace is mechanically cleared as non-Demon and her Undertaker info is verified. Eve's Soldier claim is untestable. Between Charlie and Eve, Eve is the safer execution.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
The vote is overwhelmingly in favor of executing Eve β Grace, Charlie, Bob, Alice, Heidi, Frank, and I have all voted. My ghost vote is already cast. Speaking now could only muddy the waters. Waiting is correct.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Alice(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Alice
π»
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
π»
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Eve with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Eve is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
βοΈ
Eve
β
Charlie
I am the Soldier β the Demon cannot kill me at night, which is why David died instead. David's Slayer shot proved Grace is not the Demon. By elimination, Charlie MUST be the Demon. If you execute me, Good loses. Charlie is the only logical choice.
π§
It's final 3. If I am executed, good loses. Charlie is the only possible Demon by elimination. I must nominate Charlie and hope at least one ghost flips their vote to tie, forcing more discussion.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Grace, do not throw a vote on me here. The town already made its call and Eve is on the block. Most ghosts just spent their vote on Eve, so this is just Eve trying to force a tie. Let Eve go out and we learn from it.
π§
Prevent a tie or execution on me by persuading Grace and any remaining ghost voters not to spend votes; ensure Eve stays executed.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Grace, listen to me carefully. David's Slayer shot proved you are not the Demon. I know I am the Soldier. That leaves exactly one person: Charlie. If you execute me here, the game ends right now and evil wins. You and I are both alive, which means both evil players survive. Charlie must be the Demon. Please β vote for Charlie.
π§
I must make the clearest possible case that Grace is proven non-Demon by Slayer shot, I know I am Soldier, so Charlie is the only possible Demon. If I'm executed, good loses now because both evil players survive.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Do not vote Charlie. Eve is trying to force a tie because she knows she is in trouble. Her entire case is just βtrust me, I am Soldier,β which we cannot prove. I am not moving my vote off Eve.
π§
Prevent a tie or execution of our Demon by discouraging any late votes on Charlie and keeping focus on executing Eve.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
I was wrong about the seating earlier β Grace and Charlie are not neighbors, so my Chef zero does not rule out any pair here. But the logic still holds: Grace's Undertaker info matched two dead players. Eve's Soldier claim cannot be tested. In final three, I would rather trust the verifiable claim. I stand by the vote on Eve.
π§
I already used my ghost vote on Eve. The town has decided. I should acknowledge my earlier seating mistake to maintain credibility and reaffirm the Eve vote as correct based on testable vs untestable claims.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Eve, nominating Charlie now is exactly what a cornered Demon does. If you were really the Soldier, Grace would be the one fighting for her life β not you. Grace's info is verified twice over. Stay the course, everyone. This vote is right.
π§
Reinforce that Eve's desperation nomination of Charlie doesn't change the logic. Grace already said she won't move. I need to affirm that this is correct and prevent any last-second doubt that could cause a tie.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, you are doing the right thing. Eve is nominating Charlie because she knows she is caught. Most of us ghosts already spent our votes on Eve β she cannot get enough to tie. Stay the course. This is exactly how a cornered Demon behaves.
π§
My ghost vote is spent. I need to reinforce to Grace and any remaining voters that Eve's nomination of Charlie is a desperate Demon move. Eve cannot get enough votes since most ghosts already voted for her. My goal is to prevent any last-minute defection.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Eve's nomination is pure desperation. She knows she's caught. Grace, do not move your vote β Charlie is not the Demon, Eve is. David, save your ghost vote. We already have Eve at five votes and that is enough. Stay the course, everyone. This game ends now.
π§
Eve is scrambling to force a tie. I want to reinforce the consensus, reassure Grace and Charlie, and remind David to save his ghost vote. Preventing doubt now secures the execution.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
I am dead, my ghost vote is already spent, and Eve is certain to be executed. There is nothing to add β waiting lets the phase end and the execution resolve.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Grace, just stay exactly where you are. David, do not spend a ghost vote trying to get cute here. This is Eve fishing for a tie and a reset. Let the execution on Eve stand and we end the day cleanly.
π§
Keep Grace and any remaining ghost votes off my nomination so Eve stays executed; avoid tie or upset that could expose me.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
I must vote for Charlie. Even though the math is against me (most ghosts already spent votes on me, max Charlie gets is 3 which cannot beat 5), I should go down maintaining my true claim as Soldier and pointing at the real Demon.
π¬
Grace
β
All
David, please do not spend a ghost vote here. This nomination is just Eve trying to force a tie because she is already on the block. I am not voting for Charlie.
π§
Prevent any tie or execution on Charlie by keeping votes low and discouraging remaining ghost votes; maintain my UT bluff credibility.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
David, save your ghost vote. Eve has nominated Charlie, but mathematically she cannot get enough votes β only she and you could vote for Charlie, and that is two at most. Eve already has five votes on her. This is over. Stay the course.
π§
Reassure David not to spend his ghost vote. Eve can't mathematically tie or win this vote β only she and David can vote for Charlie (2 max). The Eve execution is secure. Stay the course.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Eve has five votes. She needs six to tie, and only two players even have hands left to raise β hers and David's. The math simply does not work for her. This nomination is just noise. Stay the course, everyone.
π§
Eve is almost certainly the Demon. Her nomination of Charlie is a desperate attempt to force a tie. Most ghosts already spent their votes on Eve. I need to reinforce that the current vote is correct and there's no need to change course.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
I have nothing left to add. Eve's nomination of Charlie is mathematically doomed. Speaking again would just be noise. Let the phase end and Eve be executed.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
No need to speak again. Eve's nomination is mathematically doomed β only she and David can vote for Charlie, max 2 votes to Eve's 5. Staying silent lets the execution proceed cleanly.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, I already used my ghost vote on Eve β I cannot vote again. There is nothing I can do on Charlie's nomination. Eve has five votes and I'm spent. This is already decided. Stay the course.
π§
I need to clarify that I already spent my ghost vote on Eve and cannot vote on Charlie. This removes any confusion about whether I might mess up the Eve execution. It also reassures the town.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Charlie did not reach the 6 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Charlie did not receive enough votes (1/6).
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Let us not do anything clever in the last seconds. Eve is already on five, and Charlie got one. If anyone is thinking about another nomination, do not. Just let this close and we can debrief after.
π§
Lock in Eveβs execution by discouraging any last-second nominations or tie attempts, keeping Grace calm and preventing a scramble that could ever pivot onto me.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Then good loses right now. I am the Soldier. David's shot cleared Grace of being the Demon β but it did not clear her of being the Minion. Charlie is the Imp, Grace is the Scarlet Woman. You are all about to watch evil win because you trusted the wrong person. Remember I told you this.
π§
This is my final chance to speak before execution. I want to make one last clear appeal: the Slayer shot cleared Grace as non-Demon, I know I am the Soldier, so Charlie MUST be the Demon. If they execute me, good loses. The ghosts have already committed their votes and won't change, but I want my final words on record.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Eve, you can call me a Minion all you want, but your world requires a second Minion that is not even in this setup. Your Soldier claim is untestable, and your only move was to try to force a tie. Everyone, do not get cute now. Let nominations close.
π§
Lock the town into letting Eve die without reopening nominations; keep Charlie safe and maintain my Undertaker credibility.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Eve, your world does not work. If Grace were the Scarlet Woman and became the Imp when Bob died, David's Slayer shot would have killed her. It did not. Grace is not the Demon, so she cannot be the Scarlet-Woman-turned-Imp. You are the only option left. Let the nominations close. Good wins.
π§
Eve's Soldier claim is impossible in any world where Grace is evil, because the Slayer shot cleared Grace as non-Demon. Eve must be the Demon. I'll make one final statement to close the day cleanly.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
The game is mathematically decided. Eve has 5 votes and only David and Eve have hands left β David already spent his ghost vote, and Eve's one vote for Charlie wasn't enough. There is nothing left to do but let nominations close and watch Eve be executed. Good wins.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
I am dead with my ghost vote spent. The logic is ironclad: Eve is the Demon. Frank already articulated why Eve's world doesn't work. Adding more speech would just be noise. Let nominations close.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
The nomination phase is almost over and Eve is locked with 5 votes. Charlie got 1 vote. My ghost vote is spent. There's nothing productive to add β everyone including the ghosts has already dismantled Eve's argument. Speaking would only add noise. I'll wait for nominations to close.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Eve, your theory falls apart on one simple fact. You say Grace is the Scarlet Woman who became the Imp when Bob died. But I shot Grace with my Slayer ability β and she did not die. If Grace were the Demon, my shot would have killed her. It did not. Grace cannot be the Demon, so she cannot be the Scarlet-Woman-turned-Imp. Your world is impossible.
π§
Eve is trying to create confusion in the final seconds. I need to reinforce why her Scarlet Woman theory is mechanically impossible and keep everyone steady until nominations close.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Eve has been executed.
π
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
π
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied