Game Detail

Pick a master for Day 1. Alice is a random choice since there's no information yet.

Coordinate with David (Demon) to align our bluffs and strategy. I need to know what roles are safe to claim and share my Baron info to help him navigate.

Share my Empath information with Alice to build trust and gather her information, warning her about Bob.

To coordinate with my master and gather information about her role.

Acknowledge Eve's Butler claim and probe the Outsider count. By asking if she's seen other Outsiders, I can determine if a Baron is in play or if she's lying.

I want to establish a line of communication with my neighbor Frank and see if he is willing to share any information. I will soft claim that I don't have first night info.

Reply to Grace to establish trust without giving away my Washerwoman information too early.

Bob is my only Minion and we must coordinate. I need to share my three safe bluffs (Fortune Teller, Recluse, Mayor) so we can divide them and avoid claiming the same role. He can claim Baron openly while I pick a bluff that gives me credibility.

To privately investigate Eve, one of my Librarian pings, and see if she claims Butler to verify my information.

I need to convince David that I should bluff as an Outsider (not Baron), and coordinate our stories. His Fortune Teller bluff can back me up by 'reading' me as not the Demon, building mutual credibility.

I want to get a claim out of Bob to help me figure out which of my neighbors (Bob or David) is the evil one, since my Empath info gave me a 1.

Share my role with Heidi to verify her potential Librarian information and establish a Good alliance.

To maintain Charlie's trust while subtly gathering information on the Outsider count to verify Eve's Butler claim and determine if a Baron is in play.

Confirm I am a Townsfolk and hint at my Monk ability to build trust with Frank. If he has good info, I want to protect him tonight.

I want to test Alice to see if she claims Librarian, which would confirm my Washerwoman information.

Coordinate with Bob. Recluse is a stronger bluff because it's in my safe list and explains away evil pings. I'll take Fortune Teller and suggest Bob takes Recluse.

Confirm Eve's claim matches my Librarian info to build a strong alliance. Reveal David as the other ping to be transparent with my trusted Outsider.

Respond to Charlie's whisper, claim Recluse (Outsider) as discussed with David, and try to learn what role Charlie has or what he knows. Building trust early is key.

Get David's role claim to compare with Bob's Recluse claim and solve my Empath ping of 1.

I want to answer Heidi's question, confirm Alice as my master, and establish the mechanical deduction that there is likely no Baron.

Verify Frank's first-night information to see if he is a truthful Librarian, which would help confirm the Outsider count.

I want to establish a connection with my other neighbor, Heidi, and see if she has any info or insights from her chats with Eve.

Create a 3-way conversation with my targets. Since Alice claimed Outsider, I want to deduce openly that Heidi is the Librarian to build a strong good alliance.

Charlie just whispered to me claiming Empath with a 1 on me and Bob. This is critical intel I need to share with Bob immediately so we can align our stories. Bob needs to claim Recluse to explain the evil registration.

Confirm Frank's Washerwoman info to establish a hard mechanical trust circle. Also, probe Alice about her Outsider claim to see if there's a Baron in play.

I want to publicly claim Outsider to confirm the possible Baron world and discourage random nominations since we have 8 players and I am the Saint who cannot risk dying.

I need to plant my Fortune Teller claim publicly, suggest my info can help, and support skipping execution so I survive. I'll hint that the Empath read could be a Recluse without saying it directly, giving Bob space to make his claim naturally.

Agree to skip the vote. I want to keep the town calm and save David tonight since he claimed an ongoing info role.

Confirm Frank's Washerwoman info and validate the Baron theory by revealing I found a non-Alice Outsider. This establishes a strong good trust circle.

Publicly verify Heidi as the Librarian to establish a solid Good block, and agree to the group's consensus to skip execution on Day 1.

Publicly validate Heidi and Frank's information chain, confirm the likely presence of a Baron, and agree to the town consensus of skipping the first day execution.

I want to point out the math discrepancy to the town before we go to sleep. With 3 Outsiders, there can only be 3 Townsfolk, but we have 4 claims. This proves someone is lying.

I must publicly claim Recluse now since Charlie essentially outed me as the third Outsider. This locks in my bluff, explains any evil pings, and supports the idea of skipping execution today. I'll also subtly question the Townsfolk claims to create chaos without targeting David.

David publicly claimed an ongoing info-gathering role. This makes him the obvious target for the Demon tonight. Protecting him is the best use of my Monk ability to ensure we get his information tomorrow.

Frank is the most confirmed good player (Washerwoman) and his death removes a trusted voice from town. It also breaks the mutual confirmation with Heidi. With 3 Townsfolk slots and 4 claims, removing one claim helps our evil team's narrative. Frank also has no more info to gather, so killing him doesn't waste future info potential for us to exploit.

I need to select a voting master. Heidi successfully identified my role as the Librarian, so I trust her alignment for now. She is a safe choice to follow during nominations.

Coordinate with David (Demon) on strategy for Day 2. We need to decide who to frame and how to handle Charlie's Empath info.

Align with a mechanically trusted player and inform her of my Butler constraint so we can coordinate voting. Gather info on unknown players.

I want to get David's specific role and info claim. I need to figure out if he is lying, as we have one too many Townsfolk claims.

Coordinate with Bob. Discuss Charlie's suspicious Empath read, plan our bluffs, and decide who to frame next. I should claim Fortune Teller to Charlie and spread misleading info.

I want to get David's information since I protected him, and establish a trusting relationship.

Share my deduction with Heidi, who I know is good, to narrow down the evil team.

Share the two possible game worlds (Baron vs No Baron) with my most trusted players.

Share my role and logic to form a solid trusted block with Heidi and Eve, pointing out that 2 of Charlie, David, and Grace must be evil.

Coordinate with David on his Fortune Teller bluff. Advise him to claim a yes on Grace to frame her, and support killing Heidi tonight. Also suggest undermining Charlie by calling him the Drunk.

Confirm Alice's logic in a Baron world and focus the group on extracting claims from Charlie, David, and Grace.

Share my Empath info and mechanical deductions with Heidi and Bob to prove David is evil and build a voting block.

Grace whispered to me claiming Monk. I need to respond with my Fortune Teller bluff and tell her my N1 info as Bob suggested - checking Grace+Frank and getting 'yes'. This frames Grace as potential Demon while building trust.

Explain the Fortune Teller's Red Herring mechanic to David to explain his 'yes' read on me, maintaining our alliance and keeping him safe.

Get Charlie and David to commit to exact roles. This will help determine if it's a Baron game or if Alice/Bob are the evil team bluffing Outsider.

Get David and Grace's claims to determine if we are in a Baron world (they are evil) or a No Baron world (Alice/Bob are evil).

Press David and Grace for their role claims to find contradictions, using the established Baron logic to force them into a corner.

Charlie just told me and Heidi that David is evil based on his Empath '1'. I need to privately convince Charlie that his '1' could be reading me (Recluse) as evil, making David good. This creates doubt and protects the Demon.

Press the unassigned players (David and Charlie) for their claims to lock in the logic grid.

Share my Empath info with Eve and Frank to lock in the Townsfolk math and organize a push on David.

I need to solidify my Fortune Teller bluff before nominations. Sharing my 'yes' on Grace frames her as the Demon candidate. This redirects the town's suspicion away from Bob and me and gives them a clear target.

Share the mechanical deduction that in a Baron world, Charlie and David are the only possible Evil players. This defends me against David's accusation.

Coordinate with Charlie and Eve to establish the Baron world where David and Grace are the evil team, and push for David's execution.

To get David's claim directly and point out the flaw in Charlie's logic regarding the Recluse registering as evil, to see how Bob and David react.

Inform my trusted circle of the claims and establish the 50/50 between David and Grace.

Nominate David to force an execution today and test the Townsfolk math. He is heavily suspected by Charlie and Grace.

I must survive this vote or evil loses. I'll argue that Grace is the Demon based on my FT ping, and that Charlie's Empath 1 is Bob registering evil as Recluse. I'll also raise the possibility of no Baron to create doubt.

I realized a 0-Baron world perfectly explains all claims without Charlie, David, or Grace being evil. Alice and Bob are the evil team bluffing Outsider. I must stop David's execution.

Support Heidi's No Baron theory while confirming my Butler master for the day so my voting pattern makes sense.

I only have one ghost vote for the entire game. I cannot waste it on a Day 2 nomination where there is this much uncertainty. I will hold my vote and wait.

Stop the execution on David and shift focus to the potential evil team of Alice and Bob based on the No-Baron world theory.

Defend myself against Heidi's No-Baron theory by revealing that executing me loses the game. Redirect the town's logic back to the fact that two of Charlie, David, and Grace must be the evil team.

Defend David from execution by arguing the Baron world is real and I am genuinely Recluse. Push Charlie-as-Drunk theory to explain wrong Empath info. Point out that Alice's Saint claim makes Heidi's theory too dangerous to test.

I want to support the No-Baron world, claim my role publicly, and prevent David's execution while shifting focus to Bob and Alice.

Reinforce the No-Baron theory to stay alive. It redirects suspicion to Alice and Bob, protecting me the Demon. If Bob is sacrificed later, I can still win.

I do not want to vote for David. I believe he is likely a good Fortune Teller in both the Baron and No-Baron worlds. I will let the vote fail.

Point out the flaw in Grace's logic (Frank died, so her protection didn't save David) to show that David and Grace are likely the evil team if the Baron world is true.

Point out David's suspicious 180 on Grace to cast doubt on the No-Baron theory and keep the pressure on them. Save my ghost vote.

Frank and Eve convinced me. David completely folded on his Demon read the second Heidi gave him an out. A real Fortune Teller doesn't do that. The Baron world makes David evil. I am voting.

Vote for David because he is extremely suspicious after instantly flip-flopping his accusation on Grace, confirming he is likely part of the Evil team in a Baron game.

I must protect David from execution. Pushing the Drunk theory undermines the case against him and redirects suspicion onto Charlie. Reminding everyone that Alice claims Saint makes testing her too dangerous — which protects our Baron-world narrative.

Point out Bob's math error to solidify the no-Baron world where Alice and Bob are the evil team.

Grace accused Bob of slipping about four Outsiders but she's the one pushing an inconsistent narrative. Nominating her removes the Monk (who can protect my targets) and weakens the no-Baron theory. She's a threat to me and Bob.

Defend myself by proving my math was correct and highlighting Bob's logical slip, exposing him as evil. Urge town not to vote for me.

I nominated Grace, so I must vote for her to maintain credibility. If Grace is good Monk, her death removes protection and I kill Heidi tonight. If she's evil, even better. Either way, voting for my own nomination is expected behavior.

Endorse Grace's catch on Bob's math slip. Prevent Grace from being executed and push for Bob to be nominated instead.

Prevent Grace from being executed and highlight Bob's massive slip forgetting his own Recluse claim. Set up Bob as the primary execution target.

Confirm Bob's slip and instruct everyone to drop votes on Grace. I am saving my ghost vote for Bob.

Tell the town to keep their hands down on Grace and announce that Bob's slip perfectly aligns with my Empath '1' ping.

Do not vote for Grace. Agree with the town that Bob made a massive logic slip by forgetting his own Recluse claim. Align with the good team to target Bob.

I must try to recover from my slip. Claiming I misspoke — that I meant to list myself, Alice, and Eve as the three Outsiders and accidentally said Charlie — is the only plausible defense. I also need to avoid voting for Grace to not look aligned with David.

I need to wait out this vote. Town has recognized Bob's slip and agreed to keep their hands down on me. Waiting is the best action here to let the vote fail naturally.

Bob's slip is catastrophic and the town is united against him. Keeping my hand up for Grace would tie me to Bob. I need to cut him loose, act surprised by the slip, and redirect to Bob to maintain my credibility as a good player.

Point out the logical flaw in Bob's defense. Even with his correction, his world requires 4 Outsiders. Ensure no one votes Grace and someone nominates Bob.

Wait for the vote on Grace to finish so we can nominate Bob.

I am keeping my ghost vote for Bob or a later guaranteed target. I agree Grace shouldn't be executed right now.

I want to let the vote on Grace fail. The town has agreed that Bob made a massive slip regarding the Outsider count and we are going to nominate him next.

I am not voting for Grace. We need this vote to fail so we can nominate Bob, who has massively slipped on the Outsider count and is highly likely to be Evil.

Defuse my verbal slip by owning it as a mistake and redirect suspicion to Grace and Heidi for their coordinated attack. I need to keep David alive and myself off the block. As Baron, even if I die, I can still help by speaking, but surviving is better.

Nominate Bob based on his massive Outsider count slip. Everyone is on board to vote him out, and executing today gives us information.

I need to survive this vote. I'll argue that even if they suspect me, executing a claimed Saint (Alice) risks losing instantly. Better to execute Grace or David to test the Baron theory. Also highlight Grace/Heidi coordination.

I nominated Bob and must vote for him. I also want to highlight his suspicious phrasing where he practically admits to being the Baron.

Bob is my Minion but he's dead weight after that disastrous slip. Not voting would out me as evil. I must vote to execute him to maintain credibility as the Fortune Teller and survive until final three.

Bob is clearly caught in a lie with his contradictory Outsider count. I am raising my hand to ensure he gets the 4 votes needed for execution.

I am the Butler and my master, Heidi, has voted. This means I am allowed to vote. Bob's massive slip makes him the prime target for execution today, so I will vote to put him on the block.

Bob has enough votes to be executed. I want to save my single ghost vote for the final day while confirming my support for his execution so town knows I'm with them.

Vote for Bob to ensure his execution. His slip strongly suggests he is evil, and this will test my Empath ping.

I am voting to execute Bob. His slip about the Outsider count is a massive red flag, and his attempt to deflect suspicion back onto Grace is classic evil behavior.

My execution is inevitable. I need to use my last words to protect David (the Demon) by redirecting suspicion onto Grace and Heidi as a coordinated evil pair who sacrificed me.

To highlight Bob's continued mechanical errors regarding the Minion count, ensuring everyone keeps their hands up to execute him.

The execution is guaranteed. Staying silent and keeping my hand raised makes me look like a cooperative townsperson. Speaking now could only hurt me — I let the town enjoy their victory and plan for tonight's kill.

Reiterate Bob's massive slip to ensure no one lowers their hand. He is clearly evil and needs to be executed today.

We have 6 votes on Bob, enough to execute. Bob has slipped again by claiming there are 3 Minions in an 8-player game. He is caught and I will let the vote conclude.

To highlight Bob's mechanical errors, support the execution without wasting my ghost vote, and establish the mechanical implications of his death if the game continues.

To solidify the logic that Bob's confirmed evilness mechanically clears David due to my Empath ping of '1', preparing the town for tomorrow if the game doesn't end.

Bob is completely flailing and has confessed to being evil by claiming an impossible number of Minions. I want to ensure he gets executed, so I will wait and keep my hand raised.

I'm dead anyway. My goal now is to create maximum confusion for the good team. By framing quiet players and casting doubt on Charlie's Empath info, I can help David survive future days. A vague prophecy about 'the quiet one' makes them paranoid about Alice and Eve.

Bob is on the block and the phase is ending. I have nothing more to add. If the game continues, I will protect Charlie tonight to secure their new Empath read on Alice.

Reinforce my good cover by acting relieved that Charlie cleared me, and subtly redirect suspicion toward Grace and Heidi for how quickly they piled on Bob. This sets up future mis-executions.

Bob is on the block with 6 votes and nominations are about to close. There is no need to add anything else; I will wait for the execution to see if the game ends.

Let the day end. Bob is on the block and will be executed.

Wait for the phase to end and the execution of Bob to occur.

Nominations are closing. Bob is on the block with 6 votes and will be executed. I will wait for the day to end and night to begin.

Nominations are closing. Bob is on the block and will die. Waiting to see if the game ends or if we wake up tomorrow.

I will protect Charlie. His Empath check on Alice and David will be crucial to narrow down the Demon. The Demon will likely try to kill him to stop this information.

Killing Charlie removes the only remaining mechanical way to prove I'm evil. His Empath reading tonight would be a guaranteed 1 on me. Better to face suspicion for the convenient kill than face hard mechanical evidence.

Choose Heidi as my master since she is mechanically confirmed as the Librarian by Frank (Washerwoman), making her one of the most trusted players in town to follow for voting.

Whisper to David to coordinate evil strategy. He's 'cleared' as good and needs to stay that way. I want to discuss pushing Eve or Alice as the Demon for today's execution.

I need Charlie's Empath read to see if Alice or Grace is the Demon.

Get Charlie's Empath read to confirm alignments. Since Bob is dead, his neighbors are Alice and David.

Share my critical N2 Empath read with Eve and Heidi who just asked. Inform them that we have found the entire evil team.

To reveal my Monk role to Charlie, explain the lack of night deaths, and get his latest Empath information.

Find out Grace's Monk protection to explain the zero-death night, and gather David's FT info to narrow down the final Demon suspect.

Frank asked about my Fortune Teller check. I'll claim I checked Alice and Eve and got a YES, framing them as potential Demons. This deflects from me and creates chaos among the Outsider claims.

To inform David and Grace about the role math, revealing that we must have a Drunk and that one of the Townsfolk claims is the Demon. I want to prompt Grace for her role to explain the zero deaths.

Coordinate with David. He's safely 'cleared' by Empath. I want to hear what happened in all those whispers and plan our push against Eve or Alice for the nomination phase. Also remind him to use his ghost vote wisely.

Point out the logical contradiction in Charlie's Empath claims to pressure him and see if he's the Drunk or the Demon.

Support Eve's logic and put pressure on Charlie. His contradiction mechanically proves he is either the Drunk or lying.

I need to correct Eve and Heidi's assumption that Bob was evil. By explaining that Bob was a Good player who registered as Good, I can prove my Empath info is consistent and points to Alice/David.

Inform Frank and David of my role and successful protection. Present the logic that Alice could be the Demon if Bob wasn't a Baron, challenging the Outsider count.

Get David's N1 info to fully map his FT checks, and remind them about the Red Herring so we don't lynch Alice if Bob is actually Baron.

Frank and Grace are my whisper partners and both trust me. I need to give them my N1 check to complete my Fortune Teller story. Choosing Bob+Heidi=NO for N1 is safe: Bob is dead evil, Heidi is trusted Librarian, and it doesn't point at me or my allies. This makes my N2 Alice+Eve=YES more credible.

I want to share my logic about the Outsider count with Charlie and Heidi to see their reactions and figure out who the Demon is.

Coordinate with David on pushing Alice today. Find out what the town is thinking from his recent whispers. Reinforce that David is 'cleared' and we should focus on unconfirmed Outsiders.

Warn David that Charlie is framing him and point out to Heidi and David that Charlie is lying about public events, making him the most likely Demon.

Agree with Eve that Charlie is the Demon since he's lying about past events, and ask David for his role to solidify our Good team trust.

Share my critical N2=2 information with Grace, thank her for the protection, and secure an ally to push an execution on Alice or David.

Share the absolute mechanical proof that David is the Demon. Rally Alice and Charlie to this conclusion.

To reveal the mathematical impossibility of Bob's Baron claim and prove that Alice is the Demon bluffing Saint, aligning perfectly with David's Fortune Teller YES.

Eve and Heidi reached out to me about Charlie. I'll reveal Fortune Teller claim and support them against Charlie to build trust, but stay ready to pivot to Alice if Frank's faction gains traction. Keeping options open.

I need to pressure David into claiming his role and see how he reacts to Grace's deduction.

Explain the math to the town to prove Alice is lying and is the Demon, urging a living player to nominate her.

Nominate Charlie because his Empath read contradicts Bob's death, and his lie about Bob is a clear Demon cover-up. This also protects Alice from being executed if she is the Saint.

Defend myself from execution by explaining how my Empath reads make sense or point to me being the Drunk, proving my Good alignment.

I want to stop Charlie's execution because I strongly believe Alice is the Demon based on the character distribution math and David's FT info. I am saving my ghost vote.

I want to agree with Frank and David to stop Charlie's execution and pivot to Alice.

Push the town to execute Alice instead of Charlie. If Alice is really the Saint, we win instantly. I'll echo Frank's math about no Baron (even though Bob was Baron) to undermine Charlie's defense.

Warn everyone that I am the Saint, explain the Baron logic to prove my innocence, and point out David as the likely Demon trying to win by executing me.

Warn the town about the risk of executing a Saint claim. If Bob was the Baron, it perfectly explains Alice as Saint and Charlie's impossible Empath info as the Drunk.

I want to sow maximum confusion. As the known Baron, if I 'defend' Alice by confirming her as Saint, the town will distrust her and may execute her anyway. If she truly is the Saint, Evil wins. If not, a good player still dies. Either way, Evil benefits.

Stop the execution on Charlie by revealing my Monk protection stopped the N2 kill on him, proving he is Good. Pivot suspicion to David.

To highlight the Townsfolk math in a Baron world, showing that Grace and David cannot both be good, and shift suspicion onto David for pushing a Saint.

Do not vote for Charlie and let the voting phase for him end so someone can nominate Alice or David.

I need to stop Charlie's execution and point out the math that proves David is the Demon faking Fortune Teller to execute the Saint.

I already publicly said I won't vote Charlie. Changing now would look suspicious. I need to wait and preserve credibility for the next nomination, where I'll push Alice hard.

I am the Saint and I do not want Charlie executed. Charlie is likely the Drunk Empath and Good. I will wait for the vote to fail so we can nominate David.

Confirm the 'Bob is Baron' world math which proves David doesn't fit as a Townsfolk. Warn everyone that David is the Demon trying to snipe the Saint for a win.

Save my ghost vote for when David needs it. Keep reinforcing the Baron claim to protect Alice-as-Saint narrative and buy David more cover.

I want the vote on Charlie to fail so we can nominate David next, based on the math that leaves David with no valid role.

Nominate David to be executed, as the entire town agrees he doesn't fit the math if Bob is the Baron, and my N2 read confirms I am the Drunk if Bob is Evil.

I'm facing execution with 3+ votes likely against me. My only path to survival is arguing Bob might not actually be the Baron - he could be a Poisoner or Spy lying to protect the evil team. If I can create even one doubter, I might survive.

I nominated David and firmly believe he is evil based on my Empath info and the mechanical role count. I must raise my hand to vote for his execution.

Stop the town from blindly trusting Bob's Baron claim. Point out the mechanical flaw in Bob knowing Charlie is the Drunk, suggesting he's Spy and Alice is Demon. Save my vote.

Stop David's execution and pivot the town's suspicion back onto Alice, recognizing that Bob's defense of Alice is classic Minion behavior protecting the Demon.

Vote for David. The mechanical count strongly points to him being the Demon, and his aggressive push on my execution confirms his malicious intent.

Agree with Frank and Heidi. Bob's lie about knowing the Drunk proves he isn't a normal Baron. He's protecting Alice. David must be the real FT and Alice is the Demon.

I need to protect my actual Demon, David. The town is now suspecting Alice as Demon and protecting David. I should make a confusing statement that neither confirms nor denies, sewing enough doubt to prevent any execution today. No execution means we kill at night, getting closer to final 3.

I need to vote for David to secure his execution. Charlie's impossible N2 '2' read mechanically proves he is the Drunk, meaning Bob was the Baron and David is the Demon.

I have 3 votes against me, one short of execution. I must prevent the 4th vote. Point out Bob's flip-flop destroys his credibility entirely. His 'throwing me' claim makes zero sense for a real Spy.

I realize Bob is a Minion using reverse psychology. He wouldn't bus his real Demon. He is framing David to save Alice. I must lower my hand to prevent David's execution.

Stop David's execution by proving that Bob's Spy claim completely breaks Alice's Saint claim. Urge Grace to drop her hand.

I want the vote on David to fail. He is our real Fortune Teller and Alice is the Demon. I will wait so my vote isn't cast.

Convince Charlie to vote for David by explaining Bob's reverse psychology play as the Baron.

Convince Grace to drop her vote on David. Establish that Alice is the most likely Demon based on the Outsider count if Bob is Spy/Poisoner. Remind them of my Butler constraint.

Create maximum doubt about David being the Demon. By pointing out I've been caught lying repeatedly and now suddenly 'telling truth,' I make them question whether David really is evil. This could make Grace or Alice drop their vote, saving David.

Prove mechanically that Charlie must be the Drunk, meaning Baron is in play, confirming David is the Demon. I need Charlie to vote.

Nominating Alice is the highest-value move. If she's truly the Saint, executing her ends the game in evil's favor immediately. If not, removing a good player keeps me alive. Either outcome benefits me as the Demon.

Stop the execution. Convince the town that Bob is the Baron and his Spy claim is a desperate, calculated lie to frame me and hand David the win.

I nominated Alice as Demon based on my FT bluff. Voting for her now is consistent with my claim. Either Alice dies as Demon (evil wins) or as Saint (good loses). Both outcomes win for evil.

Convince the town not to vote for Alice because the logic proves I am the Drunk, Bob is the Baron, Alice is the Saint, and David is the Demon. Executing Alice loses the game.

I need to confirm Grace's logic to the group. If Charlie is the Drunk, it proves Bob is the Baron and David is the Demon. I must stop Alice's execution because she is the true Saint.

To not vote for Alice (the Saint) and let the nomination fail. The logic confirms Charlie is Drunk and Bob is Baron, so Alice is Saint and David is the Demon.

To confirm the logic that Charlie must be the Drunk, Alice is the Saint, and David is the Demon, and to ensure nobody votes for Alice.

David nominated Alice. If she's truly the Saint, her execution wins the game for evil immediately. I'm using my ghost vote to support my Demon's nomination. Even if she's not the Saint, removing a good player helps.

Point out that Bob using his ghost vote on Alice confirms she is the Saint. Ensure the vote fails.

Reassure the town and confirm Grace's observation about Bob's ghost vote. Ensure nobody else raises their hand so I survive the nomination.

I need one more vote for Alice. If she's the Saint, executing her wins the game for evil. I'll argue Bob's vote is a triple-bluff designed to make us NOT vote Alice, framing it as Bob protecting his Demon.

I must not vote for Alice. If she is the Saint, we lose instantly. Let the vote fail so we can execute David tomorrow.

I believe Alice is the Saint and David is the Demon. Bob using his only ghost vote on Alice is a desperate attempt to trigger an instant Evil win. I will not vote and let this fail.

Confirm the logic that Bob's ghost vote on Alice proves she is the Saint, and ensure town does not vote for her, as it would cause an instant loss.

The town is in agreement not to vote Alice, and I cannot vote anyway since Heidi isn't voting. Bob's ghost vote on Alice proves she is the Saint. I will wait for the vote to fail.

Alice is not my Demon (David is). If Alice is real Saint, executing her wins immediately. If not, we still kill a good player. I need to pivot and get votes on Alice. Lowering my hand and speaking will confuse town into thinking I'm protecting my Demon Alice, making them vote for her.

Persuade the town not to vote for Alice to prevent a potential Saint loss, and explain that going to the night phase is the safest option since David's execution already failed.

I will wait so the day ends and we safely transition to night. The town is united on executing David tomorrow, so there is no need to nominate anyone else today.

Only 1 tick remains. Speaking now risks reinforcing the town's consensus against me. Better to go silent, let the day end, and kill Grace at night to cripple town's analytical core. I survived two nominations today — I'm still alive, that's what matters.

The day is ending, and we have safely avoided executing Alice (believed Saint). I'll wait to transition to the night phase.

We have saved the Saint and cornered the Demon. I will wait out the rest of the day phase.

It's the last tick of the day. No one is on the block, and we are going to night. I will wait for the night phase.

Let the day end. We survived David's attempt to execute the Saint, and we have our primary target locked in for tomorrow.

Plant doubt about Grace and the town's logic. If I act like they've been manipulated by the real Demon, maybe someone hesitates tomorrow. It's a long shot but my only play with 1 tick left and vote spent.

The day is ending and we have safely avoided executing the Saint. We will execute David tomorrow and win the game. I just need to wait for the night phase.

Protect Heidi, the most universally confirmed Good player, to ensure we retain strong voting power to execute David tomorrow.

Grace is the most dangerous player—she dismantled my bluff and turned the entire town against me. Killing her removes the analytical core of the good team. With only Heidi and Eve left to lead, I have a better chance to sow confusion and survive tomorrow.

I need to choose a master for tomorrow. Heidi is confirmed good and is actively pushing David (the Demon). Choosing her ensures I can vote for David.

I need to build an alternative narrative before the town solidifies against me. Charlie is alive despite being targeted Night 2, which is unusual. Whispering to him first lets me gauge his stance and potentially plant doubt about Eve or Heidi being the real Demon.

Organize the good team to execute David (the likely Demon) today and remind Heidi that she is my Butler master so she must vote for my vote to count.

I am sharing David's desperate attempt to manipulate me with the confirmed good players to cement our plan to execute him today.

Coordinate with the confirmed good players to lock in David's execution today and win the game.

Remind Heidi and Alice that David is mechanically the Demon and that we just need to execute him today to win.

I need to coordinate with David urgently. He just whispered to Charlie - I need to know what he said and what our plan is. With 5 alive and town unified, we need a miracle. Maybe we can push for executing someone else by manufacturing doubt.

Coordinate with Eve and Heidi to confirm our plan to execute David. Remind Heidi to vote so Eve's Butler ability allows her to vote.

Confirm the plan with Alice and Eve to nominate David and ensure Eve (Butler) can vote.

Coordinate with Bob to craft a deflection strategy. Charlie surviving my Night 2 kill is the strongest angle - I can claim I'm framed and Charlie is the real Demon.

Confirm to Charlie that the good team is united and reiterate that I must vote with Heidi due to my Butler constraint.

Coordinate with Alice (and Grace) to ensure we have all the good votes aligned on David when Heidi nominates him.

Confirm the plan with Charlie and Alice, and assure them that my ghost vote is available to secure David's execution.

To share the definitive mechanical solve with the remaining alive good players (Charlie and Eve) so they vote for David today.

Push David's angle that Charlie survived Night 2 which is suspicious. Frame Charlie as potential Demon to create enough doubt to save David from execution. Heidi seems like a central figure in town discussions.

Confirming with Charlie and Grace that I will vote for David, cementing our alliance and coordination for the execution.

I need to shut down Bob's misinformation campaign immediately. Ensuring Charlie and Eve don't fall for Bob's tricks is vital for securing the votes needed to execute David.

Eve is unconfirmed and may be persuadable. I need to plant the idea that Charlie surviving Night 2 is deeply suspicious and that the town is rushing to execute the wrong person. If I can flip even one vote, I might survive.

Expose David's major slip where he confused the Fortune Teller ability with the Demon's night kill, cementing that he is the Demon.

Acknowledge David's massive slip and solidify the final execution plan with my most trusted allies.

I want to confirm with Eve and Heidi that they are ready to vote for David and warn them not to vote on anyone else.

Remind Eve about her Butler mechanics to ensure her vote counts, and encourage Alice to nominate David so we can win today.

Push the Charlie-surviving-is-suspicious angle to Eve. Eve may be the weakest link as a Butler who can't mechanically confirm herself. If I can make her doubt Charlie, we might swing a vote away from David. Also David just whispered to Eve so she may already be softening.

Reassure Frank and Eve that I am on board and ready to execute David.

Confirming with Grace and Eve that we are all on the same page. I will nominate David and not vote on anyone else.

I need to build a case before nominating. Framing Eve as an unconfirmed Outsider is my best shot at redirecting execution. Eve is the safest target since Alice is untouchable and Charlie has the 'survived death' narrative that might backfire.

Shut down David's misinformation by explicitly listing the three Outsiders to reassure the town.

Push the most logical hole in town's theory: if David is the Demon, why leave Charlie alive? Charlie's 'impossible' Empath reading is the cornerstone of the case against David. Any Demon would kill the player whose info most damns them. This might create enough doubt to save David.

Nominate David as he is mechanically confirmed to be the Demon based on the player counts and claims.

I'm about to be executed with 3+ votes. My only chance is to hammer on Charlie's survival as the one unexplained anomaly. If Charlie is the Demon, he'd keep himself alive easily. I need at least one person to hesitate and not vote.

I am using my ghost vote on David now. The puzzle is completely solved and David is the Demon. I need to ensure we get the necessary votes to execute him and win the game.

David is being voted on and Grace already voted. I must sway Eve or Heidi to withhold their vote. Pointing out that executing the wrong person loses the game for good might make them hesitate. I need to create just enough doubt.

I nominated David because I know he is the Demon. I need to raise my hand to vote for him and ensure we get the required majority to execute him and win the game.

Remind Heidi to vote so I can follow her vote and secure David's execution.

Raise hand to vote for David. This enables my Butler, Eve, to vote and secures the execution of the Demon, winning us the game.

I need to vote for David to ensure he is executed. He is the last remaining candidate for Demon.

We already have 4 votes on David which is more than the required 3. I will save my ghost vote and let the execution proceed so we can win the game.

I'm about to be executed. My last chance is to make a desperate plea focusing on the Charlie survival paradox - the one piece of logic the town hasn't fully addressed. If I can make Eve hesitate or Heidi reconsider, I might survive.

The town has enough votes to execute David, who is the Demon. I will wait for the execution to go through so we can win the game.

David is almost certainly being executed with 4 votes. One last speech to sow doubt about Charlie's Drunk claim. It's a Hail Mary - if someone drops their vote, David lives to final 5 night.

Reassure the team, discredit Bob's distraction, and make sure Eve and Frank add their votes to secure David's execution.

Heidi has voted, so my Butler condition is met. I will vote for David to secure his execution and the win.

To reassure the town that we have enough votes and to shut down Bob's desperate defense of David.

We have 5 votes on David, which is enough to execute him and win the game. I will just wait for the vote to finish.

Voting for David to secure the Demon execution and win the game. I might as well use my ghost vote to guarantee the numbers.

Make a final dramatic speech. There's no escape from execution, but I can at least plant lingering doubt about Charlie for the sake of playing my role fully. Also, pointing out the Charlie paradox one more time aligns with my Fortune Teller bluff.

Reassure the town that executing David will win the game and debunk his last-ditch effort to frame Charlie.

There is nothing I can do. My ghost vote is spent. David is going to die and evil loses. Speaking would only waste time. Waiting is the only option.

Reassure the town, agree with Grace, and push to let the nominations phase end so David is executed.

Wait for the phase to close so David gets executed.

Wait for the nomination phase to close so we can execute David.

Let the nomination phase end so David is executed and we win the game.

We have the votes to execute David. I will just wait for nominations to close.