Game Detail

Start building Fortune Teller data with two non-neighbors; later rotate pairs to isolate Demon versus red herring while avoiding self-pair confusion.

Pick a likely cooperative master adjacent to me so I can vote tomorrow if Bob votes, while I gather claims and avoid revealing Butler too early.

Test my Washerwoman pings without immediately revealing Soldier info; one should be a confirmable good Townsfolk unless drunk/poisoned.

Build trust with a neighbor and gather early claims while keeping Virgin hidden enough to bait or plan a confirmation later.

Build trust with my chosen master so I can legally vote today and start mapping claims without outing Butler publicly.

Start a trusted info chain and warn that my Recluse registration can distort starting info without fully outing immediately.

Bob is asking me and Frank to claim before sharing his info. I should claim Ravenkeeper - it's a safe bluff that's hard to disprove and non-threatening. I want to appear cooperative and trustworthy.

Respond to Grace with a soft claim to build trust. I'll claim Empath - it lets me give ongoing 'info' and steer suspicion. My neighbors are Alice and Grace. I'll say I got a 0 reading night 0, meaning both neighbors are good - this builds trust with them.

Answer Bob without overexposing immediately, while forcing him to reveal whether his info confirms or accuses one of us.

Use my no result to build a quiet trust circle while gathering claims before nominations.

Resolve my Washerwoman ping early. If Frank confirms Soldier, David is not contradicted and I can use Frank as likely sober-good anchor.

Clarify Alice's soft claim and see if Heidi has spent info suitable for a Virgin test without killing an ongoing role.

Gather outsider count and first-night info from outside the Bob, David, Frank whisper cluster while keeping my Butler claim hidden.

Coordinate with Eve's starting info and clarify outsider count without hard-claiming Recluse publicly yet.

I need to respond to Bob's Washerwoman claim naturally, confirm I'm not the Soldier, and build trust. Then I should coordinate with Heidi soon.

I want to deepen my alliance with Grace and Alice, positioning myself as a trustworthy info role. I'll respond to Grace's question about Alice and subtly steer conversation. I need to protect David (Imp) while building credibility.

Confirming Soldier validates Bob's Washerwoman line and builds a trusted starting chain while tracking David's different claim.

Clarify Alice's vague outsider claim and build trust with Charlie without hard-claiming Fortune Teller publicly.

Use the last day tick to extract Eve's starting info and clarify Alice's outsider-related claim before nominations.

Set up a controlled Virgin test with a spent Townsfolk, while avoiding killing an ongoing Empath or a possible Saint.

I chose Bob as master, so I need voting coordination and his social reads before nominations while avoiding a full Butler reveal.

Clarify Eve's info before nominations and test whether Bob is shielding the whisper trio or has useful starting info.

Coordinate with Heidi (my Minion) to share what I've learned about Bob and Frank's claims, and plan our strategy. We need to align our stories and figure out who to target tonight.

Coordinate with David on my bluff. I'll claim Chef with a 0 (no evil pairs sitting together). Need to align our stories before nominations.

Use the last private chat to gather claims from my neighbors and test Bob-David chain against other information before nominations.

Share useful limited FT info while pressing Frank for the chain so we can choose a sensible Day 1 execution or avoid killing a key good.

Avoid a no-execution day and pressure the least-cleared member of a closed trio without risking my Recluse registration confusing town.

Stop my execution by revealing the Washerwoman-Soldier chain; preserving a confirmed good narrows Demon candidates more than killing me.

Frank's claim fits Bob's stated starting info and David's claim. I want pressure without executing a likely good Soldier today.

I should NOT vote for Frank. Frank being alive is good for me - he's part of my cover chain (Bob-Frank-David). No execution today is ideal for evil. Let this nomination fail naturally.

Signal my Butler restriction and discourage a poor execution on a claimed Soldier backed by Bob's info.

Frank's Soldier claim is backed by Bob's starting info and David's Ravenkeeper claim. I do not want to spend day one execution on a plausible Soldier.

I should NOT vote for Frank. Frank living is fine - the Bob/David/Frank chain protects my Demon David. If Frank dies, town gets closer to finding David. I'll wait and let this nomination fail.

Stop a likely good Soldier execution and preserve my Washerwoman confirmation chain for future deductions.

Avoid executing a plausible Soldier and set up a Virgin test by a spent Townsfolk to confirm two good players before night.

Avoid my execution and redirect town toward a safer mechanical test without spending my vote on myself.

Frank fits Bob's Washerwoman-style info and Soldier claim, so voting risks killing a plausible protected good. Let vote fail and pivot to Grace Virgin test if possible.

I should not vote for Frank. He's part of my cover chain (Bob's info says Frank or David is Soldier, Frank claims Soldier, I claim Ravenkeeper). Voting for Frank would undermine my own credibility. Let this vote fail naturally.

Bob is my master and is not voting, so I cannot vote. Letting this fail preserves a plausible Soldier confirmed by Bob's info.

Frank is in a plausible Washerwoman chain as Soldier, and executing Soldier day one is low value. Let this fail and seek a better execution or Virgin test.

Let the Frank vote fail. Frank is not our Demon, and the chain protecting David is working perfectly. No reason to vote here - voting for Frank would be pointless and might draw suspicion. Let the day end quietly.

Avoid executing my likely confirmed Soldier on day one. Let this vote fail so we can test Grace's hint or find a better execution.

Let Frank vote fail. His Soldier chain is plausible and executing him day one gains little; save Virgin confirmation for a better nomination after this.

Test Grace's Virgin hint while using my confirmed-leaning Townsfolk claim; if it triggers, town gains strong confirmation before night.

Kill Bob. He's the Washerwoman who validated Frank (now dead) and me. With Frank dead, Bob is the main witness to my 'good' status—but he's also the one who could re-examine things. Killing him removes the strongest info role while I'm still trusted.

Test the two least mechanically connected living players. A NO would narrow Demon suspects toward David or Alice; a YES creates a focused pair to resolve tomorrow.

Grace is the strongest mechanically confirmed good player after the Virgin trigger, so tying my vote to hers should reduce Butler downside.

I need to coordinate with David privately to align our strategy. We should discuss who to push for execution today and make sure our stories are consistent. Whispering to David to coordinate is critical.

Tell likely confirmed good player my restriction so my vote is usable and get her suspects before nominations.

Use Bob's night death to anchor trust and extract exact claims from Bob and Eve before nominations.

Reveal exact info now that I am night-killed, coordinate with Alice and Eve, and use Virgin plus Washerwoman data to build a good core.

Coordinate Charlie's Butler vote with mine and probe the outsider conflict around Alice before nominations.

Coordinate with Heidi on today's strategy. Need to align our stories, push suspicion on a good player, and plan my next kill. Alice/Bob/Eve whispering is concerning - need to get ahead of whatever Bob shared.

Share my real FT info with a likely good dead player and Alice to coordinate pressure on Charlie and Heidi before nominations.

Use confirmed good status to gather exact claims from Bob and Grace, then steer day two toward a logical execution.

Confirm plan with David and coordinate our push against Charlie. Also remind him of my Chef claim so we stay consistent. Then I need to start building the public case against Charlie.

Keep coordination with my master Grace, answer her question, and focus town suspicion on the outsider-count conflict and David/Alice claims.

Get Heidi's role and info to resolve Eve's yes on Charlie and Heidi before nominations.

Build a trusted dead-confirmed core and extract Charlie's claim to test Eve's Fortune Teller yes on Charlie and Heidi.

Share Charlie's claim with the trusted core and focus the day on resolving outsider conflict and David/Alice suspicion before nominations.

I need to coordinate with Heidi on the execution push against Charlie. Also want to check in on what Alice whispered to Heidi, since Alice approached her privately - that could contain useful intel about what the Alice-Eve-Bob group knows.

Share FT info with likely good players and learn Charlie's claim before nominations so we can focus execution on Charlie or Heidi.

Get Eve's exact info to resolve Alice versus Charlie Outsider conflict and choose a strong execution before nominations.

I need to respond to Alice with my Chef claim to maintain credibility, while subtly redirecting suspicion toward Charlie. If I don't respond, Alice will hammer me during nominations. I also need to warn David that Alice is suspicious of me.

Resolve outsider count and get Bob's dead-player perspective before nominations, narrowing whether Alice or David is a better execution.

Answer Charlie directly while forcing his claim before nominations; my Recluse ability may explain some info but Eve's yes needs resolution.

Get Charlie to lock his claim before nominations and test Outsider count conflict with Alice; this narrows Demon candidates.

Get Heidi's claim against Eve's yes before nominations; Charlie's Butler claim makes Heidi a key Demon candidate unless red herring or false info.

Need to find out what Alice whispered to Heidi - this is critical intel. Also need to coordinate final push on Charlie before nominations start. Only 1 tick left before nominations.

Force Heidi to claim before nominations and compare against Charlie's Butler claim and my yes result.

Coordinate confirmed good players before nominations, preserve ghost votes, and force exact claims to narrow Demon candidates.

We need an execution before night. Eve’s yes points to Charlie or Heidi, and Charlie’s Butler claim is more coherent than Heidi’s silence.

I need to defend myself against this nomination. I'll claim Chef loudly, point out that Fortune Teller has a red herring built in, and suggest I could be that red herring while Charlie (Butler) is suspicious. I need to survive if possible but not at David's expense.

I nominated Heidi off Eve's yes and her delayed claim. Voting also frees Charlie's claimed Butler vote, helping secure an execution today.

Grace is my Butler master and is voting, so I am allowed to vote. Heidi is in the Fortune Teller yes pair with me, and I know I am not the Demon.

We need an execution today, and Heidi is in Eve's Fortune Teller yes with a late Chef claim. My vote puts pressure and likely secures a useful kill.

3 votes already equals majority. Heidi is likely doomed. I should speak up to cast some doubt on the vote without being too defensive, to maintain my credibility. I want to appear thoughtful rather than either blindly following or suspiciously defending.

Support the Heidi execution without spending my crucial ghost vote while votes are already sufficient.

Secure Heidi's execution from my yes pair. Her Chef claim came late under pressure; if she is good, Charlie remains the next target as the other half or red herring issue.

Heidi already has enough votes, so I should preserve my ghost vote for final day while letting this execution proceed.

I'm being executed - 4 votes is more than enough. I need to use my final words to protect David and cast maximum suspicion elsewhere. Point out Charlie voting eagerly, and suggest Eve could be the evil one manipulating town.

Keep the execution on Heidi while preserving a clear next-day plan if she is good, without wasting dead votes or lowering pressure.

Publicly confirm my Butler claim and justify my legal vote with Grace voting, while keeping pressure on Heidi as the best Demon candidate.

Keep Heidi on block while setting tomorrow's solve paths if she is good. Charlie's public Butler claim makes Heidi still the better execution from Eve's yes.

Heidi is going to be executed - 4 votes already, only 3 needed. I should NOT vote to maintain my image as someone who had doubts. I'll speak to reinforce my skepticism and plant seeds of doubt about Charlie and Eve for tomorrow, setting up my next target.

Heidi already has enough votes and my ghost vote is valuable later. Waiting avoids wasting it while letting the execution proceed.

Keep execution on Heidi while setting a clear follow-up path if she is good, so the group does not lose the thread tomorrow.

Do not spend ghost vote on an execution already passing; use final words to set tomorrow's logic around unresolved claims.

I'm about to be executed. I need to use my final words to plant maximum doubt about Eve and Charlie, and deflect from David. I want to make Eve look like a possible evil Fortune Teller or make Charlie look like the real threat, so tomorrow's execution doesn't land on David.

Lock in the current execution, discourage late chaos, and set a clear plan for tomorrow if Heidi is not evil.

Lock in the current execution without creating a late tie, while setting tomorrow's agenda if Heidi is not the Demon.

Avoid disrupting a plausible Demon execution while setting up tomorrow's key logic around outsider count and Charlie's claim.

The nomination phase is closing with Heidi on the block. There's only 1 tick remaining and I've already spoken my piece defending Heidi. I shouldn't nominate anyone else or draw more attention. Let the phase end naturally. I need to plan my night kill carefully - Eve is the biggest threat but killing her looks suspicious after Heidi's parting speech pointed at her.

Reinforce current execution without spending ghost vote, and set tomorrow's priorities if Heidi is not Demon.

Lock in a clear plan before night without risking a competing execution; guide town if Heidi is not the Demon or if I am killed.

Leave living players with the key logic for tomorrow: continued game does not prove Heidi good, and David's claim remains mechanically strained.

Eve's Fortune Teller is the single biggest threat - she accurately identified Heidi and will likely check me next. With Heidi dead, I have no Minion backup. I must kill Eve tonight even if it looks suspicious. If she lives, she checks me and I'm done. I'll deflect suspicion tomorrow by pointing to Charlie or Alice.

Grace is the strongest confirmed good from the Virgin trigger. Choosing her maximizes my chance to vote with town consensus on final three.

Coordinate with my Butler master and most confirmed good player so my vote is usable and town focuses on the likely Demon before nominations.

Coordinate with the confirmed living good player and learn Charlie's private claim before nominations.

Share my true FT info with a confirmed good Virgin and a dead good candidate so they can lead nominations while I preserve my ghost vote.

David is in extreme danger. I need to coordinate with him privately to help him survive today. Eve being dead is good - removes FT info source. David needs to deflect suspicion onto Charlie or Alice.

Coordinate trusted confirmed good players and avoid a bad execution at four alive while focusing pressure on Charlie and David.

Whisper to Grace to build alliance and redirect suspicion. Grace is the confirmed Virgin and likely leading town. I need to give her a compelling Ravenkeeper claim and point suspicion at Alice or Charlie before the nomination phase.

Reveal to confirmed Grace now and get her private claims before nominations so we can choose between Charlie and David.

Share David's impossible Ravenkeeper claim with trusted dead good players so we can coordinate pressure and conserve ghost votes unless needed.

Get dead info and consensus before nominations; Eve's FT checks and Bob's washerwoman chain can narrow Alice versus David.

Coordinate confirmed good players to expose David's impossible claim before nominations and set a likely execution target.

Answer Charlie while not clearing him; keep pressure on David and preserve my ghost vote for the decisive execution.

I need to help David survive. With 4 alive, if they execute David today, we lose. I should whisper to Alice or Charlie to cast doubt on someone other than David, or reinforce narratives that protect him.

Directly test David's contradictory claim before nominations; if he cannot repair it, he is the strongest Demon candidate today.

Bob caught a fatal error in my Ravenkeeper claim. I need to respond quickly and try to reframe this. I'll whisper Bob and Grace to say I misspoke/Grace misunderstood, and pivot to saying I'm actually the Investigator who got info on Alice Night 0.

Force David to commit to a full claim and compare it with Charlie and Eve before nominations; revealing Recluse helps explain outsider count and pings.

Force David and Alice to resolve the claim conflict before nominations; David's shifting story is currently the strongest execution case.

Pressure David for a full claim before nominations while keeping Grace, my master and good anchor, in the loop for coordinated voting.

Confront David directly while Grace hears the answer; an impossible claim may identify today's Demon execution.

Force David to resolve the claim conflict before nominations while keeping Grace as trusted vote lead.

I need to help David survive. The key is to keep pushing suspicion onto Charlie. I should whisper to Bob or Frank (ghosts with saved votes) to try to get them to consider Charlie as evil, or at least cast enough doubt. Let me whisper to Bob and Frank since they have ghost votes saved.

Coordinate trusted confirmed players before nominations and avoid executing a likely Minion at four alive.

I need to respond to the pressure before nominations. Multiple players are demanding my full claim. I should whisper to Charlie and Grace with a coherent Investigator claim that frames Alice, since that's my best shot at redirecting the execution. I've already told Bob and Grace the Investigator story.

Force David to lock his claim before nominations so Grace and I can decide between David and Charlie at four alive.

Coordinate living votes around David while preserving the option to skip at four if the Demon is not clear.

Give living trusted Grace a clear framework: avoid Alice, choose between David/Charlie, and avoid a risky wrong execution at four.

At four alive, a wrong execution loses after the night kill. Preserve my ghost vote and push living players to avoid a rushed misexecution unless consensus is strong.

Avoid a low-confidence execution at four; preserve the chance to solve at final three while clearly marking David and Charlie as the demon pool.

Avoid a risky wrong execution at 4 while clearly setting David/Alice as the final solve and respecting my Butler vote constraint with Grace.

Avoid a risky four-alive misexecution while preserving my ghost vote and framing final three around the strongest demon candidates.

Avoid a risky four-alive misexecution while setting up final-three focus on the two main demon candidates.

Town is unanimously passing on execution today at 4 alive - this is ideal for evil. No need to speak and risk drawing attention or changing anyone's mind. Let them go to night. David will kill someone and we go to final 3. Staying quiet preserves the status quo which benefits us.

Town wants to go to final 3. I should agree and seem reasonable. This buys me another night kill. I need to sound cooperative and set up Charlie as my target for tomorrow's final day argument.

Grace is the biggest threat—confirmed Virgin, trusted town leader, coordinating votes. Removing her eliminates the strongest good player and the person most likely to push my execution. Without Grace, final 3 is me/Charlie/Alice with no confirmed-good anchor. Charlie is cleared by Eve's FT so he may not push as hard on me if Alice is the alternative.

Grace is my trusted good anchor and likely final vote lead. Choosing her preserves my ability to follow the town's clearest confirmed player tomorrow.

Grace is dead - she was the town leader who might have sided with David. Now it's final 3: Alice, Charlie, David. I need to whisper to the other dead players to push for Charlie's execution. Let me target Bob and Frank who have ghost votes.

Use trusted dead info to choose between Charlie and David before nominations; I need a concise final push for the execution.

Give Alice a decisive final-three solve and align dead votes on David, the least mechanically consistent player.

Give Alice a clear final recommendation and preserve my ghost vote for the David execution if needed.

Coordinate with trusted ghosts before final vote and test whether Alice's private chat changed the David versus Charlie solve.

I need Grace's ghost vote to legally vote, and Eve/Grace are the best trusted info holders for final-three coordination.

Coordinate final-day ghost vote with trusted dead info holders before nominations; decide between David and Charlie.

Final 3. I need to survive execution. Whispering to Alice to build alliance and convince her Charlie is the demon. Alice is my best bet since ghosts seem to lean David vs Charlie - I need Alice's living vote on my side.

Grace is dead - this is huge. She was the most trusted and was likely going to lead the town. Now I need to work the remaining ghosts (Bob, Eve, Frank) to vote Charlie. Let me whisper to Eve and Grace (ghost) to push the Charlie narrative, since they seem to be in conversation with the living players.

Final three needs full reveal and direct pressure on the two suspects before nominations, while making my Recluse registration explain weak pings on me.

Keep Alice focused on the strongest mechanical contradiction and counter Heidi's late push before nominations.

Coordinate final-day votes onto David and ensure Charlie can vote if his Butler claim is true while reinforcing the strongest mechanical case to Alice.

Warn a living voter and trusted ghost that Heidi's evil-looking push may be misdirection, and consolidate toward David before nominations.

Give Alice the exact Butler history she requested and align my final vote with Grace to execute David.

Get the trusted living player and confirmed ghost to align on David vs Charlie before nominations, preserving my ghost vote for the decisive execution.

Alice is the deciding vote. I must address my claim switch honestly-sounding while hammering that Eve's FT info points to Charlie. Frame the switch as panic, not malice. Make Charlie look like the logical demon.

Alice is alive and will be key in the final 3 vote. I should whisper to Alice to push suspicion on Charlie. If Alice votes Charlie, combined with David's vote and ghost support, Charlie gets executed and evil wins.

Coordinate the likely David execution before final nominations and ensure Charlie's Butler vote can legally follow Grace.

Coordinate the final execution and make sure the Butler claim does not block Charlie's vote if David is nominated.

Coordinate saved ghost votes before nominations so David reaches majority and Charlie can vote with my Butler-enabling ghost vote.

Coordinate final-day execution on David and signal ghost-vote commitment so Alice nominates the strongest Demon candidate.

Lock the final three plan: execute David, coordinate my Butler restriction with Grace's ghost vote, and ensure Alice understands I will act if needed.

Final three requires execution. Coordinate Alice to nominate David and align ghost votes to avoid a split or missed execution.

Final pitch to Alice. Must convince her Charlie is the demon. Emphasize Eve's FT info pointing at Charlie, my Investigator info clearing Alice, and Charlie's convenient Butler claim. This is do-or-die.

I must nominate Charlie now. It's final 3 - if no execution happens, evil wins (good for me), but the Storyteller warned them. I need to nominate Charlie and get Alice to vote with me. Eve's FT info is my strongest argument since it flagged Charlie+Heidi.

Stop my execution and refocus final three onto David, while respecting Butler constraint to only vote if Grace votes.

I must vote for Charlie since I nominated him. Not voting for my own nomination would be a death sentence - Alice would immediately suspect me. Need 2 votes total, so I need Alice to join me.

Stop Charlie reaching 2 votes and preserve my ghost vote for David, the stronger Demon candidate in final three.

Prevent Charlie execution and preserve votes for David, the stronger Demon candidate in final three.

Prevent a misexecution on Charlie and preserve my ghost vote for David, the strongest Demon candidate in final three.

The situation is dire. Grace, Eve, and Alice are all refusing to vote Charlie. Even if I use my ghost vote to get Charlie to 2 votes (meeting threshold), Alice or Charlie will nominate David next and likely get more votes to overtake. I should NOT waste my ghost vote here - I need to save it to potentially block David's execution by NOT having it available... wait, actually I can only vote FOR, not against. My ghost vote is one-time use. If I use it on Charlie and Charlie gets 2 votes, but then David gets 3+ votes on the next nomination, David still dies. I should save my ghost vote to potentially use it strategically. Actually - let me reconsider. If I vote now, Charlie gets 2 (David + me). That puts Charlie on the block. Then if David gets nominated, he needs MORE than 2 to replace Charlie. With living voters Alice + Charlie (2) plus ghosts Bob, Eve, Frank, Grace (4 ghost votes) = potentially 6. They'd easily beat 2. So using my vote here is wasted. Better to speak and make one last desperate plea, or save my vote for something. Actually I should probably just try to talk and create doubt, or wait. Let me speak to try to sow last-minute doubt.

Do not spend my ghost vote on Charlie; preserve voting power to execute David, who is the stronger Demon candidate in final three.

Preserve my ghost vote for David, the stronger Demon candidate, and prevent Charlie from reaching majority by mistake.

Let the vote on me fail without adding confusion, then nominate or support David immediately after. Grace and Alice already gave the clear plan.

The situation is dire - everyone is against me. I need to make one last desperate plea. I should try to plant doubt about the ghost consensus being manipulated, or make a final emotional appeal to Alice. Even if it's unlikely to work, I have to try something.

Reinforce that Charlie vote must fail and focus Alice on David, preserving ghost vote for the decisive execution.

Do not help execute Charlie. We need this vote to fail so David can be nominated and executed, matching strongest mechanical and social evidence.

Save my ghost vote for David; voting Charlie risks executing the wrong player and losing final three.

The vote on Charlie is clearly failing. I already spoke against this nomination (framing it as David being suspicious). Voting for Charlie now would contradict everything I've said and confirm David's argument that I'm his Minion. I need to stay consistent and not vote. The game looks very bad for evil - town is unified against David. My ghost vote won't save him.

Preserve my ghost vote for David and reinforce the agreed final solve so Alice and Charlie do not panic-vote on Charlie.

Preserve my ghost vote for David, since Charlie execution is likely wrong and final day requires united votes on the stronger Demon candidate.

It is final 3 with no one on block. David is the strongest Demon candidate, and Grace is my master, so I can vote if Grace uses ghost vote.

I'm almost certainly going to be executed here. Every ghost and both living players are against me. My only tiny chance is a desperate speech to make Alice hesitate. I need to plant just enough doubt that she doesn't raise her hand. But realistically, this game is likely over for me.

Counter David's appeal and secure Alice and Grace votes on the final execution; David is the most consistent Demon world.

Final three requires execution. David is most likely Demon from impossible Ravenkeeper claim and shifting stories; spending ghost vote secures the kill.

It is final three and we need an execution. David's claim shifts and weaponizing my Recluse registration are worse than Charlie's Butler claim.

This is final three and David is the strongest Demon candidate. Spending my ghost vote ensures the execution reaches majority and avoids losing by no execution.

David already has 3 votes with only 2 needed - he's getting executed no matter what. Raising my hand maintains my cover of pushing David as Demon, which is consistent with my recent pivot. Not raising would look like I'm protecting David, confirming I'm his Minion. Since the outcome is sealed either way, I should maintain my cover for whatever it's worth.

Final three requires execution. David is the best Demon candidate; spending my ghost vote ensures the execution cannot fail.

It is final three and David is the strongest Demon candidate. My ghost vote has no better future use, and securing this execution is essential.

The vote against me has overwhelming support (6 votes, only 2 needed). There is nothing I can do to prevent my execution. I'll wait and accept my fate - the game is effectively over for evil.

Grace is voting, so my Butler restriction allows me to vote. David is the best Demon candidate and final three requires execution.

Keep my ghost vote committed on David; lowering or talking risks confusion. David is the best Demon candidate and execution is required in final three.

Keep consensus locked on David and prevent last second doubt from his nomination order argument.

Keep my ghost vote committed on the likely Demon and reassure Alice that David is the correct final execution.

David is doomed - the votes are overwhelming and I can't save him. Lowering my hand changes nothing mechanically. I'll wait and let the execution proceed. The game is lost for evil.

Keep my decisive ghost vote on David and reinforce Alice/ghost consensus so the execution holds at final three.

Keep pressure on David and reassure Alice not to move; final three requires executing the most likely Demon.

The game is lost. I'm on the block with 7 votes, all players voted against me, only 1 tick remains, and no one else can be nominated. I should say something brief - maybe a final defiant statement or a gracious concession. There's no mechanical play left.

Lock the winning execution and prevent last-second confusion or a tie that could let the Demon survive final three.

Prevent a tie or late derailment; David is on the block and appears to have conceded, so closing secures the likely Demon execution.

David is already on the block with overwhelming votes and appears to have conceded. Any further nomination risks a tie or chaos, so I should let execution resolve.

David is on the block with overwhelming votes and appears to have conceded. Any speech risks confusion; waiting locks in the execution.

There is nothing I can do to save David. He's on the block with 7 votes, I've used my ghost vote, I'm dead and can't nominate. Speaking would only be suspicious. I'll wait and accept the outcome.

David is already on the block with enough votes and appears to have conceded. No further nomination can help; avoid accidental tie or chaos.

David is on the block with enough votes and appears to have conceded. Speaking risks reopening discussion; waiting locks the correct execution.