Game Detail

Choosing David as my master for Day 1. As Butler with no information yet, I'm selecting a neighbor positioned to observe game dynamics. This lets me monitor his behavior and potentially follow a good player's vote.

Start a private conversation with Bob to learn his claimed role and gather information. Since my Investigator ability says Bob or Grace is the Baron, I need to assess Bob's claims before deciding whether to trust him or suspect Grace.

Start gathering information by having a private conversation with Alice to understand what role she has and what info she's gathered. This helps me build a network of trusted players.

Establish contact with my Minion, Grace, to coordinate bluffs and strategy.

I'm whispering to my neighbors Alice and Grace to establish trust early. As Virgin, I want to build alliances with players adjacent to me and potentially share my role claim strategically to gain protection or test others.

I need to confirm my role and alignment to my Demon, Frank, and provide feedback on his bluffing strategy while acknowledging the extra Outsiders I've introduced as the Baron.

Engage with Eve's inquiry without immediately revealing my Recluse role. Ask what information she has first to gauge her credibility before sharing too much.

It's Day 1 and I have zero information. I should start gathering role claims and information from other players. I'll whisper to Alice and Bob since they've been active in conversations and might have useful information to share.

David is asking for role claims and night info. As Saint, I have no night ability, so I can honestly say I got nothing. I'll be vague about my role and ask what he knows to gather more information.

I'm sharing my Investigator claim and information with Bob to establish trust and get his role claim. This will help me determine if he's the Baron or if Grace is, and allows us to work together if he's good.

Build rapport with David since he's my master for the Butler ability. His voting behavior tomorrow affects whether I can vote. Gathering his role claim and information helps me assess his alignment.

Coordinate the Librarian bluff with my Minion, Grace (the Baron), to ensure our stories align and build mutual credibility.

I need to gather more role claims and information from other players. I've told Alice and Grace about being Virgin. Now I should talk to Bob and Charlie to get their claims and see what information they have.

Coordinate a bluff with my Demon (Frank) where he uses his Librarian bluff to 'confirm' me as the Saint (an Outsider), which I am adding to the game as the Baron.

Heidi claims Virgin and is asking for role information. I should engage without revealing I'm Recluse yet. I'll share a vague claim and ask about her Virgin claim to test consistency.

Charlie is asking about my role claim. As Slayer, I should be cautious about revealing my true role on Day 1 to avoid night kills. I'll engage Charlie in conversation to gather information about their role and claims while being strategically vague about my own.

Charlie initiated contact earlier and seems engaged. I'll continue gathering information from him while being careful not to reveal I'm the Saint. This helps me build a picture of the board without exposing my dangerous role.

I need Bob to commit to a role claim so I can start building logic chains. If he's Baron, his claim may contradict other information. If he's good, his claim helps me verify my Investigator info.

Gathering information from Alice about her role and what she's learned from other conversations. This helps me build a picture of the board and identify potential evil players while keeping my Butler role hidden.

Confirming the plan with my Minion (Grace) before starting my bluff to the rest of the town.

I've claimed Virgin to 4 players but haven't spoken to David, Eve, or Frank yet. I should gather their perspectives and potentially extend my claim to build trust. This helps me map out the board before nominations.

I am initiating my Saint bluff with Alice to build a foundation of trust/caution. By telling her early and privately, it feels more like a genuine, nervous disclosure.

Eve is pressing for my role claim. As a Recluse, I register as evil to abilities, which explains her Investigator info. I'll tell her I'm an Outsider to be partially honest while testing if she's genuine. This helps me gauge her reaction and build trust if she's good.

Heidi claims Virgin to me and Eve. I need to test this claim by observing her behavior and cross-referencing with other players' information before committing to any strategy.

Grace claiming Saint conflicts with my role. I need to probe her claim without revealing my own role directly. This helps identify if she's evil or if there's a Drunk situation.

Establish my Librarian bluff and support my minion Grace's Saint bluff by 'seeing' her or Eve as the Saint.

Frank just claimed Librarian with info about Grace or Eve being Saint. I should engage with this publicly to gather more reactions before making any nomination decisions. As Virgin, I also need to be careful about who might nominate me.

Contribute to discussion without overcommitting. Ask Grace and Eve for their roles since Frank's claim directly involves them. Their responses will help me evaluate Frank's Librarian claim and identify potential lies.

I need to publicly address the contradiction between Frank's Librarian claim and my Investigator information. If Frank is truthful, Grace is Saint, but my info says Bob or Grace is Baron. This creates tension that could reveal the evil player. I'll share this logic to get reactions.

Point out the contradiction between Frank and Eve's claims about Grace. One must be lying since Grace can't be both Saint and Baron. This helps the town identify which claim is false.

Defend my Saint bluff and cast doubt on Eve's Investigator claim by suggesting she might be the Drunk, emphasizing the risk of executing a Saint.

Point out the logical contradiction between Eve and Frank's claims about Grace. This helps the town identify who is lying before we risk executing a Saint or protecting an evil player.

Reveal my Outsider role publicly to explain Eve's info without executing Grace. As Recluse, I register as evil/Baron to abilities. This resolves the contradiction and protects us from the Saint execution loss.

I am killing Eve to eliminate the Investigator who has a ping on my Minion, Grace. Removing the source of the Baron accusation protects Grace's Saint bluff and keeps the town confused about Bob's alignment.

Alice has been observant without making suspicious claims. As Butler, I need to follow someone likely good who will vote meaningfully. Alice's neutral, analytical approach suggests she'll make informed decisions tomorrow.

Share my Investigator information with Alice and David to help the good team identify the Baron. My night death validates my claim as truthful. This helps narrow down evil players.

Eve died at night with Investigator claims about Bob/Grace being Baron. I need her info before nominations to identify the Minion and narrow Demon suspects. Building trust with Eve as Virgin.

Alice is my master so I can vote today. She hasn't claimed a role yet and seems observant. I need to gather her perspective on the claims and Eve's death before nominations.

Share my Saint role with Charlie to establish trust and coordinate voting power. Point out the logical conclusion that Bob is Baron if Grace is Saint. Use Butler's vote dependency to my advantage.

To coordinate with my Demon (Frank) now that our main accuser (Eve) is dead. I want to confirm our strategy and see if he has more 'Librarian' info to share.

Gather Alice's perspective on the key claims and share my true role to build trust. Eve's death gives us new information to process.

Coordinate with my Minion Grace to maintain our bluffs and solidify my credibility as the Librarian.

Share my analysis of the claims with Eve and Alice, focusing on Bob being the more likely Baron since his claim conveniently explains Eve's info while being safe from execution.

Share my analysis that Bob is likely Baron based on his convenient claim, and ask about Charlie's suspicious private conversations to identify potential Demon.

Gather Eve's Investigator information before nominations to identify the Minion. Her night death suggests she was good, making her info reliable.

Challenge Alice's Saint claim by pointing out the contradiction with Grace's identical claim and Frank's supporting Librarian information. This tests Alice's honesty.

Charlie claims Butler with me as master. I need to use this vote control wisely. The Saint contradiction is critical - Grace and I can't both be Saint in standard script. I'll probe Charlie's read on Grace while building toward testing claims.

Coordinate with the Demon (Frank) to align our strategy for the day and identify potential targets for execution.

Gather Alice's perspective on the suspicious Grace-Frank coordination and explore testing Heidi's Virgin claim to progress the game.

Coordinating with my Minion (Grace) to identify targets for the day. Alice and Charlie are suspicious for their private conversations and might be forming a logic chain against us.

Continue investigating the Bob/Grace Baron contradiction while probing Alice about her private talks with Charlie. Need to identify who's protecting potential evil players before using Slayer shot.

Heidi asked directly for my Baron info. I should share my analysis with her and David since they're engaging constructively. Bob seems more likely Baron due to unverifiable claim.

Coordinate with Eve and David to nominate Bob based on Eve's Investigator information. Bob's unverifiable Outsider claim is suspicious and Eve's night death supports her credibility.

Test Alice's Saint claim credibility since I'm vote-locked to her as my master. If she's lying, I need to know before nominations.

Address Charlie's concern about my Saint claim while redirecting to testable claims. Explain why an evil player wouldn't claim Saint (execution risk). Push for actionable tests like Virgin trigger and Librarian verification.

I want to sow confusion about Eve's Investigator info and gauge what Alice and Charlie are plotting. By suggesting Bob might be the Drunk (since Eve saw 'Grace or Bob is Baron'), I can undermine Eve's lead while maintaining my Saint bluff.

Gather Alice's perspective on Grace's whisper and coordinate investigation of the suspicious Grace-Frank confirmation loop versus testing Heidi's Virgin claim.

I want to fish for information from Alice since she's been central to many private conversations. By acting like a concerned Librarian, I hope to gain her trust and see if she's forming a logic chain against my team.

Coordinate with trusted good players to strategize before using my limited Slayer ability. Need to identify the Demon, not just the Baron.

Reinforce my Librarian bluff and protect my Minion (Grace) by reminding town of the Saint threat, while fishing for information from Alice.

Bob is the most suspicious player based on Eve's Investigator info and his unverifiable Outsider claim. Nominating him tests evil's defense patterns and could execute the Baron.

Defend myself by explaining Recluse mechanics and redirect suspicion to the Grace-Frank confirmation loop which is more suspicious.

Support the execution of Bob by casting doubt on his Recluse claim and reinforcing my own Librarian bluff. By highlighting that his claim explains away the evil ping, I make him look like a caught Minion.

Vote for Bob to test his Recluse claim against Eve's Investigator info. If he's Baron, we remove Minion. If he's Recluse, we learn from who defended him. Grace's Saint claim makes her too risky to execute.

As Saint, I must avoid execution while helping town find evil. Bob's execution doesn't resolve the Saint conflict between Grace and me. I should speak against rushing to execute Bob when Grace-Frank coordination is more suspicious.

I'm vote-locked to Alice as my Butler master. I need to observe whether she votes before I can act. Her voting behavior will reveal information about her claim's authenticity and determine if I can participate in this execution.

React to Alice's counter-claim of being the Saint by feigning confusion and casting doubt on Frank (my Demon) to make my Saint bluff seem more sincere while keeping the 'extra outsiders' confusion alive.

Two Saint claims is the critical contradiction. I need Alice and Grace to clarify privately before I commit my ghost vote. Bob's nomination is useful pressure but the Saint conflict determines who's actually evil.

Pause the Bob vote to address the more critical Saint contradiction. One of Alice or Grace is lying about being Saint, which is a clearer path to finding evil than executing Bob whose Recluse claim is plausible.

Redirect focus from my execution to the critical Alice-Grace Saint contradiction. One must be lying and likely evil. This is the key to finding the Demon, not executing me as Recluse.

Defend my Librarian claim and my Minion (Grace) while casting doubt on Alice's late Saint claim.

Lower my hand to pause Bob's vote and prioritize resolving the critical Saint contradiction between Alice and Grace. Executing Saint loses the game, so we must verify claims first.

Push the town to focus on the Saint contradiction and nominate Grace instead of Bob. As the real Saint, I must avoid execution while exposing Grace as the likely lying Baron.

Highlight the critical Saint contradiction and redirect focus from Bob to resolving who is the real Saint, which is more important for finding evil.

Defend the Saint bluff by casting doubt on Alice's late claim and reinforcing Frank's Librarian info.

The Saint contradiction between Alice and Grace is more critical than Bob's nomination. One is lying and likely evil. I need to push the group to resolve this before using my ghost vote, as executing the real Saint loses the game automatically.

Vote for Bob to test reactions while the Saint contradiction is the real issue. His Recluse claim is convenient but needs testing. More importantly, I'm pushing to resolve Alice/Grace Saint conflict before any execution - executing the real Saint loses the game automatically.

The Saint contradiction between Alice and Grace is critical - one is lying. Frank supports Grace while whispering constantly with her, which is suspicious coordination. Nominating Frank tests their partnership without risking execution of the real Saint. This forces the town to evaluate the Grace-Frank connection.

Deflect suspicion by doubling down on my Librarian claim and painting Bob's nomination as a desperate move from a caught Minion.

Vote for Frank to test the Grace-Frank whisper connection. If Frank is evil supporting a lying Grace, this removes a Minion. If Frank survives, we learn the town doesn't trust this line of reasoning.

Highlight the critical Saint contradiction that must be resolved before any execution to prevent automatic good loss.

I am the real Saint, so Grace is lying. Frank supports Grace's false Saint claim with suspicious Librarian info, and they whisper constantly - likely evil coordination. Voting Frank tests this connection without risking my execution. If Frank dies and good doesn't lose, it validates my Saint claim and exposes the Grace-Frank evil pair.

My Butler vote is locked to Alice who raised for Frank. The Saint contradiction is critical - one of Alice/Grace is lying. Frank supporting Grace while they whisper constantly is suspicious coordination. Voting Frank tests the Grace/Frank connection without risking the real Saint. If Frank dies and Grace's claim crumbles, we confirm Alice as Saint.

Frank is my Demon. I cannot let him be executed. I must not vote and should wait to see if the vote reaches a majority before the phase ends, though I can't speak during the active vote unless I'm the nominee. Since I'm not the nominee, I will stay silent and not raise my hand.

I'm holding my ghost vote because the Saint contradiction between Alice and Grace is the critical issue. If I vote Frank now and he's good Librarian, we lose valuable info. If he's evil, 3 votes might already execute him. I need to see how the Saint conflict resolves before committing my vote.

Vote to execute Frank to test the Grace/Frank evil connection while avoiding Saint execution risk. This resolves the Saint contradiction safely.

I need to vote for myself to appear like a confident, misunderstood good player who doesn't believe they will actually be executed, or to potentially trigger a Minion switch if things go south, though currently I'm just trying to look like a desperate Townsfolk. Actually, voting for myself as the Demon is usually a bad move unless I want to star-jump, but with 4 votes already, I am on the block. I will vote to appear like I'm 'helping' the town or just to blend in, but wait—as the Demon, I don't want to die unless I have a plan. Actually, if I vote for myself, it looks like I'm a 'Good' player who is frustrated. However, 4 votes are already reached (Bob, Alice, Charlie, David). I should probably not vote for myself to stay alive.

The Saint contradiction between Alice and Grace must be resolved before Frank's execution. If we execute the wrong person while leaving a lying Saint-claimer alive, we risk losing. Need to pause and verify.

Vote for Frank's execution. With 5 votes already raised, my vote confirms the majority. The Saint contradiction must be resolved next day - either Alice or Grace is lying and likely evil. Executing Frank today, then resolving Saint tomorrow, progresses us toward identifying the real threat.

Frank is on the block with enough votes. I need to speak to reinforce why Frank's execution makes sense - his Librarian claim supports Grace's false Saint claim, and their constant whispering is evil coordination. This validates my Saint claim by contrast.

I've already raised my hand to vote for Frank. The vote is in progress with strong support (Alice, Bob, David, Heidi, and I all raised hands). Executing Frank tests the Grace/Frank connection without risking the real Saint since Alice remains alive. I should wait for the vote to complete.

Defend Frank (the Demon) and cast doubt on Alice's late Saint claim while reinforcing the focus on Bob.

The Saint contradiction between Alice and Grace is the most critical issue - executing the real Saint loses the game instantly. I need to push the group to resolve this before Frank's execution, as my ghost vote should be saved for when it matters most.

The Saint contradiction determines everything. I need the group to think through both possibilities before finalizing Frank's execution, as it reveals whether Grace or Alice is lying.

I need to deflect suspicion from myself by leaning into the possibility of being the Drunk. If I am the Drunk, my execution is useless to the good team. I want to redirect the town's attention to other players or the logic of the Saint claim.

The Saint contradiction is game-critical - executing the real Saint loses the game automatically. Frank's execution doesn't resolve this. I need to push the table to address the Saint claims before locking in any execution, as this determines who we can safely execute.

Frank will be executed with 6 votes. The Saint contradiction between Alice and Grace is the real game-critical issue. I need to push the group to resolve this before more executions happen, as executing the real Saint loses the game automatically.

Expose Grace's suspicious timeline and let Frank's execution test the evil network without risking my own nomination in the final tick.

Push for resolving the Saint contradiction before the day ends. One of Alice or Grace must be lying about being Saint, and this is more critical than Frank's execution. I need to advocate for testing their claims.

To prevent my Demon (Frank) from being executed, I will nominate Alice, the real Saint. This creates a high-stakes scenario where the town must choose between executing the suspected 'fake' Librarian (Frank) or risk executing the 'true' Saint (Alice). By framing Alice as a late-claiming liar, I aim to split the vote and keep Frank alive.

As Saint, I must NOT raise my hand to vote for my own execution - that would hand the game to evil. I need to speak against this nomination while the vote is open, pointing out Grace's suspicious behavior and Frank-Grace coordination.

I am voting for Alice to attempt to shift the execution away from myself and towards the rival Saint claim. If Alice is the real Saint, we win immediately; if she's a liar, I stay alive to kill tonight.

The Saint contradiction is critical - executing the real Saint loses the game instantly. I need more information before committing my vote. Waiting lets me observe who else votes and potentially gather more claims before deciding.

Not voting for Alice avoids catastrophic risk of executing real Saint. Frank's execution proceeds anyway, giving us more info tomorrow to resolve Saint contradiction safely.

As Butler with Alice as master, I can only vote if she votes. I need to observe whether Alice raises her hand first before I can act. This respects my role restriction while allowing me to participate in this critical Saint resolution vote.

To further discredit Alice's Saint claim by framing her reluctance to be executed as a sign of her being evil, while maintaining my own bluff as the 'true' Saint who is confident enough to nominate her.

I'm voting for Alice because Grace's behavior shows evil tells: private Saint claim before public, Frank's supporting claim, and now panic nominating Alice. My Investigator info (Bob/Grace Baron) means if Bob is Baron, Grace isn't, making her Saint claim more suspect. This is high-risk but Grace's coordination patterns outweigh the Saint execution risk.

I cannot risk voting for Alice when she might be the real Saint - that would instantly lose the game for good. Frank's execution will proceed regardless, and we can resolve the Saint contradiction tomorrow with more information. I need to preserve my Slayer shot for a confirmed Demon target.

I am the Saint and cannot afford to be executed. I need to see how Bob, Heidi, Charlie, and David vote before deciding whether to speak more. Currently only 2 votes (Frank, Eve), need 6 to tie. Waiting lets me assess the room and potentially speak if more votes come in.

Push for Alice's execution to potentially win the game if she's the Saint, or at least to deflect from myself.

I refuse to vote for Alice's execution because if she's the real Saint, good loses automatically. Frank's execution is already locked at 6 votes. The Saint contradiction can be resolved tomorrow with less catastrophic risk.

Avoid voting for Alice due to Saint execution risk. If Alice is real Saint, voting loses game immediately. Better to let Frank's execution proceed and resolve Saint contradiction tomorrow with more information.

The risk of executing the real Saint and losing automatically far outweighs the benefit of potentially catching Alice in a lie today. I should speak to explain my reasoning and wait, preserving the game.

I am raising my hand to vote for Alice to maintain my bluff as the Saint. If I am the real Saint, I would be confident that her execution wouldn't end the game. Voting for her puts pressure on the town to decide between our claims and keeps the heat off my Demon, Frank.

Lower my vote for Alice to prevent potential auto-loss if she's the real Saint. The risk is too high - executing Saint ends game immediately for good team.

I need to observe the full vote outcome before acting. The Saint contradiction must be resolved - one is lying. My Slayer shot is precious and I should use it on the Demon, not gamble on Saint claims. Waiting lets me see final vote counts and who supports which Saint claim.

Clarify my Saint claim honestly before night, acknowledge the suspicious timing, and urge caution about Saint executions to prevent accidental good team loss.

Accept execution gracefully while casting further suspicion on Alice to set up a mis-execution for my Minion (Grace) to exploit later.

Reveal my Recluse role to explain registration confusion affecting Saint claims, and warn against risky Saint execution tomorrow.

Point out the logical flaw in Bob's Recluse explanation and emphasize the critical Saint contradiction that must be resolved before any executions tomorrow.

Emphasize the critical Saint contradiction that must be resolved tomorrow before any execution, as executing the real Saint loses the game instantly.

To cast further doubt on Alice's late Saint claim and reinforce the idea that Frank's info (even if he dies) might still be reliable, while appearing cooperative with the group's plan for tomorrow.

Share that Bob's Recluse claim reconciles my Investigator information, potentially clearing Grace. Emphasize the critical Saint contradiction must be resolved tomorrow before any execution to avoid auto-loss.

Frank is already locked for execution with 6 votes. Using my Slayer shot now would be wasteful since he'll die anyway. I should save my shot for a player who won't be executed normally, or wait to see if Frank's death reveals information tomorrow.