Game Detail
Players
Alice (Soldier) Bob (Scarlet Woman) Charlie (Librarian) David (Butler) Eve (Imp) Frank (Investigator) Grace (Chef) Heidi (Virgin)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 547,991 | 65,531 | $0.2681 |
| Evil | 199,720 | 49,007 | $0.1859 |
Event Transcript
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
You are the Minion. The Demon is Eve.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Minions are: Bob. Your safe bluffs are: Empath, Recluse, Slayer
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Librarian. Either Grace or David is the Butler.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Investigator. Either Grace or Bob is the Scarlet Woman.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Chef. You learn that there are 0 pairs of evil players.
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
David
David made a choice.
π§
Bind my vote to a nearby player to control my voting influence, gather information from othersβ reactions, and reduce risk of being forced into harmful early votes.
π
Storyteller
β
David
You chose Charlie to be your master.
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Eve
Charlie: I am the Butler and chose you as my master last night. Tomorrow I can only vote if you vote. Please tell me now if you plan to vote and who you lean toward. Eve: can you back me up if Charlie abstains and remind me privately?
π§
Secure coordination with my master so I can vote tomorrow and have a backup if he abstains, gaining early alignment info.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Heidi
Hi, I am Alice. I am the Soldier so Demon cannot kill me. What are your roles or reads so far? Can we align on one suspicious player to nominate this round?
π§
I want to quickly verify nearby players' claims and coordinate a nomination before the public phase ends to catch the Demon off guard.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
Hey Bob, it's Eve. Let's coordinate. I'm planning to bluff Empath since it's safe. We need to figure out who to kill tonight. Any thoughts on who seems dangerous? Also, who do you think your fellow minions are, or are you the only one?
π§
I need to coordinate with my minion Bob and establish our bluffs. I'll tell David I'll back him up to build trust and appear helpful.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Bob
Hi Alice and Bob β I am Heidi, I am the Virgin (Townsfolk). Please do not nominate me; if a Townsfolk nominates me they will be executed by my ability. Let us pick someone else to nominate this round. Who do you both suspect?
π§
Prevent an accidental execution of a Townsfolk by my Virgin trigger and steer nominations to a safer suspect this round.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Heidi
Frank, Heidi β I am Chef. My night read: 0 pairs of evil players. That means no two evils sit next to each other. Keep this private and use it to test claims and whisper patterns before nominations.
π§
Tell my immediate neighbors the Chef read so they can cross-check adjacency-based claims and we can detect contradictions before nominations.
π€
Bob
β
Eve
Hey Eve, got your message. Based on the setup, I think I'm the only Minion since Scarlet Woman is in play. I'm hearing Alice claim Soldier and Heidi claim Virgin. Those are both safe defensive claims so maybe true. I was thinking of bluffing Chef or Empath like you. For tonight, maybe kill David? He seems quiet and observant. What do you think?
π§
Coordinate with my Demon Eve privately. Share information about claims I've heard, establish our bluffs, and discuss kill targets for tonight.
π€
Charlie
β
Eve
David whispered to both of us claiming he is the Butler and picked me as his master. Did you get the same message? Do you plan to vote at nomination and who are you leaning toward? If I abstain to test him, can you back me and remind me privately?
π§
Confirm with Eve whether she got David's same whisper and coordinate whether she will vote or back an abstention to test David's Butler claim.
π€
Frank
β
Heidi
Heidi, private: my Investigator start read says either Grace or Bob is the Scarlet Woman. Grace just told me she is Chef. Do you have any reads or odd behavior from Bob or Grace to share before nominations?
π§
Private check with Heidi to see if she has any reads or suspicions to help discriminate between Grace and Bob before nominations.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Eve
Charlie, Eveβquick confirm: do you both plan to vote in the upcoming nomination? Charlie, if you abstain I cannot vote; Eve, can you privately back me if Charlie does abstain so we can still push a nominee?
π§
Confirm voting intentions to know whether I can vote and to secure private backup if Charlie abstains, so I can influence the nomination effectively.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Heidi
I am Alice, Soldier. I agree we must not nominate Heidi. What are your roles or reads so far? If nobody has a strong read, would you be comfortable nominating someone like David this round, or suggest another target?
π§
Get their roles/reads and agree a safe nomination while avoiding nominating Heidi so her ability does not execute a Town.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
Bob, David is claiming Butler to Charlie and me. He picked Charlie as his master. Do you still think we should kill David, or should we target someone else? Also, I need to respond to Charlie about voting plans - any thoughts on what I should say?
π§
Confirm the kill target with Bob and discuss David's Butler claim. If David is truly Buttery and coordinating votes for good, removing him early prevents him from organizing the town against us.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Bob
Alice, Bob β I am Heidi, the Virgin. Please do not nominate me. Grace says Chef saw 0 evil pairs and Frank's Investigator flagged Grace or Bob as Scarlet Woman. I want to nominate David this round to test claims. Are you both comfortable nominating David?
π§
Prevent someone Town from nominating me and steer group to nominate David to gather information and pressure suspected evil roles.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Heidi
Keep my Chef read (0 evil-adjacent pairs) secret. Watch who whispers to whom and who avoids whispering. If either of you gets multiple private pings from adjacent players, flag them to me now. Tell me if anyone pressures you to nominate an adjacent neighbor.
π§
Keep my Chef read private, get Frank and Heidi to monitor whisper patterns and report suspicions before nominations to narrow Demon suspects.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Heidi
Hey Alice and Heidi. Frank claiming Investigator and pinging me or Grace as Scarlet Woman is suspicious. Investigator is a common evil bluff because it's hard to verify. I'm not sure I trust that info. I'd be comfortable nominating David - he claimed Butler which is also a bit of a safe claim. Let's see what David has to say first though before we decide for sure.
π§
Deflect Frank's suspicion by questioning his claim and supporting David nomination to keep town's attention away from me. Build trust with Alice and Heidi.
π€
Charlie
β
Eve
Eve, I am the Librarian and my start read said either Grace or David is the Butler. Did David whisper you claiming he picked you? I plan to abstain to test him; if I do, will you back David and remind me privately so we can see whether his vote is blocked?
π§
Coordinate a private test of David's Butler claim with Eve: I will abstain to see if David cannot vote, and ask Eve to back him so we can observe vote behavior and narrow suspects.
π€
Frank
β
Heidi
Heidi, what did you notice about Bob or Grace? Do either of them pressure you or ping adjacent players a lot? Do you trust Grace's Chef read? Keep this between us β we should coordinate before nominations.
π§
Get Heidi's independent observations about Bob and Grace, confirm whether Grace's Chef read seems genuine, and coordinate a private test before nominations.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Eve
Charlie, will you definitely vote in the nomination? If not, Eve, can you privately promise to vote so I can participate and we can push a nominee? Tell me which player you lean toward.
π§
Ensure I am able to vote tomorrow by confirming Charlie's participation or securing Eve's private backup so we can reliably push a nominee.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Heidi
I still think we should nominate David this round to test claims. Can you both confirm your roles/reads quickly? If either of you has a stronger suspect, say now. Otherwise Iβll push for David at nomination.
π§
Get Bob and Heidi to confirm roles/reads and agree to nominate David this round to gather info without risking Heidi.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
Hey Bob, update: Charlie just claimed Librarian to me. Says his start read shows either Grace or David is Butler. This could validate David's claim. If Charlie abstains and David can still vote, David is lying. What should I tell Charlie about voting? And who should we kill tonight?
π§
Update Bob on Charlie's Librarian claim and coordinate our strategy. Also need to decide how to respond to Charlie about voting plans.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Bob
Alice, Bob β I still want us to nominate David this round to test claims and avoid nominating me. Can you both push for David at nomination? If either of you has a different strong read speak now, otherwise I will back David.
π§
Avoid being nominated (protect Virgin trigger) and get David nominated this round to test claims and flush liars.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Heidi
Quick check: did either of you get multiple private pings from adjacent players? If someone pressures you to nominate a neighbor, flag them to me. Keep my Chef read secret and tell me anything odd before nominations.
π§
Confirm whisper patterns to leverage my Chef read (0 adjacent evils) and catch anyone steering nominations toward adjacent players.
π€
Bob
β
Eve
Eve, Frank is claiming Investigator and says Grace or Bob is Scarlet Woman. That's directly pointing at me. I need to discredit him or get him killed. Let's stick with killing David tonight unless he becomes more suspicious. What are you telling Charlie about voting?
π§
Coordinate with Eve about Frank's dangerous Investigator claim implicating me as Scarlet Woman, and confirm our night kill target.
π€
Charlie
β
Eve
Eve, confirm you got David's Butler claim that he picked you? I will abstain to test him. Please vote in the nomination and privately tell me who you vote for and whether David seems able to vote. If you suspect Grace as Butler, say so.
π§
Coordinate a private abstain test to verify David's Butler claim by having Eve vote and report whether David's vote appears blocked; this narrows Butler identity.
π€
Frank
β
Heidi
Heidi, quick: did Bob private-ping or pressure you more than Grace? Do you trust Grace's Chef read? If Bob was the one pinging adjacent players a lot, I want to quietly push to nominate Bob this round.
π§
Get Heidi's direct observations about Bob vs Grace and coordinate a nomination push on Bob if Heidi's read supports it.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
βοΈ
Heidi
β
David
I want to test claims and avoid being nominated myself; David's Butler claim is suspicious and nominating him will produce useful reactions.
π§
Force a test of claims while protecting myself as Virgin and gather reactions to narrow evils.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Vote to execute David to test claims, protect my Virgin safety, and push the game toward revealing the Demon.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Support Heidi's nomination to test David's Butler claim and gather information; reaching execution will pressure evils and narrow suspects.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am voting for David. This nomination will force useful information β we either remove a Demon or expose who's pushing a bad vote. Watch reactions and whisper me anything suspicious after the count.
π§
Force a test: get reactions and possibly remove the Demon now. Observing who pushes back or stays quiet will help narrow suspects.
π¬
David
β
All
I am David and I am the Butler. I told Charlie last night they are my master. My ability means I can only vote if Charlie votes too. If you want me to vote, ask Charlie to raise their hand now; otherwise I will be forced to abstain.
π§
Explain my Butler constraint so town understands why I may or may not raise my hand and prompt Charlie to reveal their action.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Vote to execute David. Removing a claimed good player helps evil regardless of alignment, and supports Charlie's Butler test to gather intel on David's truthfulness.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Vote for David to blend in with the majority. The real threat is Frank who named me as Scarlet Woman - need to deal with him later.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I will abstain to test David's Butler claim. If he votes anyway he is lying; if he cannot vote he won't. Eve, you said you'd back him β please confirm privately whether David actually voted. I am abstaining now.
π§
I need to confirm whether David's Butler ability restricts his vote. Publicly abstaining forces a mechanical test and gives my team factual info to narrow suspects.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Quick β before we finish voting: I am the Investigator. My starting read said either Grace or Bob is the Scarlet Woman. I think we should pause on executing David until we test Bob and Grace more; watch who is pushing neighbors and whisper me any odd pressure.
π§
Reveal my Investigator start read to redirect the nomination away from David and prioritize checking Bob vs Grace before we execute someone.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I want us to execute David now to test his Butler claim and Frank and Grace's reads. Charlie is abstaining β if David votes anyway he is lying. Please finish the vote; we need the information before night.
π§
Forcing David to be executed will most quickly test his Butler claim and Frank and Grace's reads, giving us critical alignment info before night.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am voting for David. We need to finish the vote now β Charlie is abstaining to test David's Butler claim. If David votes despite Charlie abstaining he is lying. If he cannot, we get useful info before night. Please finish the vote.
π§
Push the group to finish the vote to reveal whether David can vote, which will narrow suspects and test conflicting claims before night.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Casting my vote now forces the Butler test and either eliminates an evil or reveals a liar; preserves my secret Chef read while gathering useful info before night.
π¬
David
β
All
I will abstain since Charlie is abstaining and my Butler ability stops me from voting otherwise. If Charlie changes and votes, I will too. Watch who is pushing this execution and who pressures Charlie β that pressure is suspicious.
π§
By abstaining when my master abstains I validate my Butler claim and focus scrutiny on those pushing the execution or pressuring Charlie.
β©οΈ
Eve
Eve lowered their hand
π§
Lower hand to maintain consistency with my promise to Charlie that I'd back David. This preserves trust with Charlie which I can exploit later while David likely gets executed anyway with 4 other votes.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I already voted for David because testing his Butler claim is the clearest info we can get today. Frank, your Investigator claim coming in right as we're about to finish voting feels like an attempt to distract us. If you really think Grace or I is the Scarlet Woman, nominate one of us tomorrow. But right now, David is on the block and we're about to learn something concrete.
π§
Deflect suspicion from Frank's accusation that I'm Scarlet Woman. Frame the execution as information-gathering while casting doubt on Frank's timing and motives for interrupting the vote with his claim.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am staying abstain. This is a direct test of David β if he votes now despite my abstention he is lying. Please watch closely and whisper me what you see.
π§
Force a clear behavioral test of David's Butler claim so we can narrow who the Butler is and who is suspicious before night.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
Avoid changing the vote count now to observe the outcome and keep my Investigator claim available for tomorrow to test Grace vs Bob further.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
New execution leader: David with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
We should finish this execution now. This is the clearest live test of David's Butler claim and will let us focus tomorrow. Charlie β if David voted at all, tell us privately after this; if he did not, we get useful information from this execution.
π§
Push through David's execution to get concrete test of his Butler claim and narrow focus between Frank/Grace/Bob before night.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Charlie, please tell us privately if David voted at all. If he did, execute him. If he did not, we still learn David behaved like a Butler. Either way, finish the execution so we have information for night and can test Frank and Grace tomorrow.
π§
Force Charlie to report whether David voted and keep pressure to complete the execution test now so we get concrete information before night.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I want us to execute David now. This is a clean test of his Butler claim and forces useful info before night. Charlie β please tell us privately if David voted at all so we can use that evidence tonight.
π§
Finishing this execution forces live information about David's Butler claim and prevents Frank from derailing our test. It narrows suspects now and gives us facts to use at night.
π¬
David
β
All
Please do not execute me right now. If I am the Butler I abstained with Charlie and killing me now wastes a Good player and information we can use tomorrow. If you want proof, ask Charlie to report privately whether I voted; otherwise wait and let Frank test his Investigator claim first.
π§
Prevent an immediate execution to keep a live player for future mechanical tests and force Frank to prove his Investigator claim tomorrow.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I think we should see this execution through right now. David had his chance to prove his Butler claim by abstaining alongside Charlie, and Charlie can report privately whether David voted or not. This gives us concrete information about David, and tomorrow we can properly investigate Frank's claim about Bob and Grace without the distraction of whether David is lying about being the Butler. Finishing this execution today leaves us clear targets for tomorrow.
π§
Reinforce that executing David is the right play. It tests his Butler claim as Charlie requested, validates my vote to cover my promise to Charlie, and lets us investigate Frank and Grace tomorrow. David dying helps the good team get information.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
David's execution will likely go through with 4 votes already secured. Speaking or nominating now draws unwanted attention. Let David die and we'll handle Frank tomorrow.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am the Librarian. I know that one of Grace or David is the Butler. Do not execute David now β if he is the Butler we lose him. We need to hold and confirm tonight before finishing an execution.
π§
Reveal my Librarian start to stop a likely mistaken execution if David is the Butler, forcing the group to hold and get clearer info tonight.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Stop. Please do not finish this execution yet. Charlie, privately tell us whether David actually voted; that single fact preserves crucial info. We can delay and test David/Charlie tonight and then retest Grace and Bob tomorrow. Letβs hold.
π§
Prevent premature execution of David so we can verify Charlie's Butler test and preserve a Townsfolk. Use that info to validate or discredit my Investigator read about Grace/Bob.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
π
David(Ghost)
David has died.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Eve
Eve made a choice.
π§
Frank is the biggest threat to my team. He's pushing Investigator claims against Bob, my only minion. If he gains traction, Bob gets executed and I have no protection. Killing Frank silences this threat and gives the town one less person to trust. I want to frame this as targeting someone who seemed to have information.
π
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
You chose to kill Frank.
Day 2
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Frank has been found dead in the night.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
Hey Bob, it's me, the Imp. I killed Frank last night. I'm thinking of bluffing Empath. Who are you claiming? We need to coordinate our stories so we don't contradict each other.
π§
Coordinate with my Minion Bob privately to align our bluffs and strategy for the day.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
Private: Morning. I got a start hint that either you or David was the Butler. David was executed. Are you the Butler? Please answer honestly so I can update who is suspicious before nominations.
π§
Confirm whether Grace is the Butler to resolve our Librarian start info and update suspicion lists before nominations.
π€
Grace
β
Charlie
I am not the Butler β I am the Chef. I learned there are 0 pairs of evil players. Use that: no two adjacent players are both evil. Update your map and tell me what that makes you suspect before nominations.
π§
Confirm my role and share the Chef info so Charlie can update suspicions and we can narrow likely demon candidates before nominations.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,Alice
I was Investigator. Start info: either Grace or Bob is Scarlet Woman (a Minion). Grace privately claimed Chef. Watch who pressures neighbors. Try to get mechanical checks or force a test on Bob/Grace tonight; save my ghost vote for final three.
π§
Tell two trusted players my start info and urge them to verify Bob and Grace mechanically or through voting behavior to narrow Demon possibilities.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Grace
Frank named Grace or Bob as Scarlet Woman. We need a clear test: can you two coordinate to pressure for a Bob nomination tomorrow and confirm privately if anyone else privately saw David's vote? Keep this tight so we force a mechanical reveal.
π§
Coordinate with my neighbors to force a clear test on Bob or Grace so we can narrow down the Scarlet Woman/Minion and preserve mechanical checks for later.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
,Grace
Quick plan: tomorrow we should coordinate to push a Bob nomination to force info. Heidi, can you lead the push? Grace, back me and note how people react. Also: did either of you privately see whether David raised his hand during Charlie's Butler test? Tell me now.
π§
Coordinate a quiet plan with Heidi and Grace to pressure a Bob nomination and gather who privately saw David's vote to validate Charlie or David.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,Alice
HiβDavid (ghost) here. Quick ask: did Frank tell either of you his Investigator result, and if so what exactly? Also did Charlie privately confirm whether I voted? Please tell us publicly if you can; it matters for finding the Demon.
π§
As a dead Butler I cannot act, but getting confirmations of Frank's Investigator result and any private confirmations about my vote will clarify who is lying and narrow Demon suspects.
π€
Bob
β
Eve
I'm thinking of claiming Investigator. I can say I learned that Alice or Heidi is the Poisoner - this would throw suspicion off us and create chaos. Does that work with your Empath plan? I can adjust if needed. We need to deal with Frank's accusation about me and Grace being the evil pair.
π§
Coordinate with Eve our bluffs and establish my cover story. I'll choose a role that doesn't conflict with her Empath bluff and helps discredit Frank's accusation against me.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
Bob, the Investigator claim is solid - it creates good chaos. Let's stick with that and my Empath bluff. But I'm worried about Frank's ghost. What exactly is he saying about us? If he's outing you as a Minion, we need a counter-narrative ready. Also, what should I say as Empath? Should I claim I sensed evil near me to build credibility or say I found no evil to seem helpful?
π§
I need to coordinate with Bob on our bluff strategy and understand what Frank is saying so we can counter it effectively. Our stories need to align to avoid contradictions.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
Grace, you told me privately you are the Chef and saw 0 evil pairs. Please confirm to the table now: are you the Chef and is your read truly 0 pairs? David's execution means my hint implies no Butler in play unless you are lying.
π§
Confirm Grace's claim and get her to reveal Chef info publicly so we can update maps and make a nomination decision before the nomination phase ends.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Heidi
I am the Chef and my read was truly 0 pairs of evil players. Push to nominate Bob tomorrow to force info. Heidi, can you lead the nomination? Also, did either of you privately see whether David raised his hand during the Butler test?
π§
Coordinate with Alice and Heidi to push a Bob nomination tomorrow and confirm my Chef read publicly after we pressure; also ask if either saw David physically vote to resolve Charlie's Butler hint.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,Alice
I was Investigator. Start info: either Grace or Bob is the Scarlet Woman (a Minion). Grace privately claimed Chef. If Bob is pressuring neighbors, test him tonight. Please ask for a mechanical check on Bob or Grace tonight and save my ghost vote for final three.
π§
Push Heidi and Alice to get mechanical checks on Bob or Grace tonight and preserve my ghost vote for final three; narrow Scarlet Woman suspect as Investigator.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Grace
Plan: tomorrow we push a Bob nomination together to force a test. Can each of you confirm if you privately saw David raise his hand during Charlie's Butler test? Grace, confirm you are Chef with 0 pairs. Stay tight and back the nomination.
π§
Forcing a Bob nomination tomorrow will create a clear public test to confirm Frank's Investigator. Coordinating with Alice and Grace maximises chance we get decisive info and checks David's vote.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
,Grace
Did either of you see David raise his hand during Charlie's Butler test? Grace: please confirm you are Chef with 0 evil pairs. Heidi: can you lead the push to nominate Bob tomorrow? Keep replies private.
π§
Get private confirmation on whether David raised his hand during Charlie's Butler test, confirm Grace's Chef=0, and secure Heidi to lead a Bob nomination tomorrow.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,Alice
HiβDavid (ghost) again. Did Frank tell either of you his Investigator result, and if so what exactly? Also did Charlie privately confirm whether I voted? Please share publicly if you can; this is crucial to finding the Demon.
π§
Get clear confirmation of Frank's Investigator result and whether Charlie privately confirmed my abstention; this narrows who is lying and who may be Evil.
π€
Bob
β
Eve
Eve, Frank clearly recognized you as the Imp - it's why you had to kill him. My bet is he's trying to out me to Heidi and Alice. As Empath, you should claim you sensed one evil neighbor. That gives you credibility without being too specific. If Frank is pushing the Scarlet Woman theory about me and Grace, I'll claim my Investigator info actually cleared Grace, and accuse Frank of trying to frame an innocent player from beyond the grave.
π§
Coordinate with Eve on our bluffs and prepare a defense against Frank's accusations from the grave. We need to know what he's saying to counter it.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
Bob, got it. I'll claim Empath with one evil neighbor between Charlie and Grace. But tell me exactly what Frank is saying to Heidi and Alice. Is he naming me as Imp or just pushing the Scarlet Woman theory? We need our counter-attack ready before nominations. Also, should I try to get Heidi and Alice to trust the Empath read?
π§
Confirm our Empath/Investigator bluff coordination and get details on Frank's accusations so we can prepare counter-narratives for the nomination phase.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,Heidi
Quick private: Night hint told me either Grace or David was Butler. David is dead, so either Grace is Butler or no Butler. Grace privately told me she is Chef and saw 0 evil pairs. Please push Grace publicly to confirm her Chef/read before nominations, and reconsider Frank/David as likely liars. Can you do that now?
π§
I must get two trusted players to pressure Grace to confirm her Chef claim publicly before nominations, and to reconsider Frank and David as possible evils. This narrows suspects before final nominations.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Heidi
I am the Chef and my read was 0 evil pairs. Did either of you see David raise his hand during Charlie's Butler test? Heidi, can you lead a coordinated push to nominate Bob tomorrow? We should squeeze info and watch reactions.
π§
Confirm my Chef read publicly to allies, learn whether Alice or Heidi saw David raise his hand, and coordinate Heidi-led Bob nomination to force useful info.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,Alice
I was Investigator: either Grace or Bob is the Scarlet Woman (a Minion). Please ask someone to mechanically check Bob or Grace tonight β test whoever is pressuring neighbors. Save my ghost vote for final three.
π§
Get Heidi and Alice to request a mechanical check on Bob or Grace tonight and to watch who pressures neighbors; preserve my ghost vote for final three.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Grace
Did either of you see David raise his hand during Charlie's Butler test? Grace, please confirm you are Chef with a 0 read before nominations. I will lead a coordinated push to nominate Bob tomorrowβare you both backing that?
π§
Confirm who saw David raise his hand to resolve the Butler test and get Grace to confirm Chef/0 so we can coordinate a Bob nomination tomorrow and observe reactions.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
,Grace
Did either of you see David raise his hand during Charlie's Butler test? Grace, publicly confirm now: are you Chef with a 0 read? Heidi, can you lead the Bob nomination tomorrow and I will back you?
π§
Confirm whether Grace saw David raise his hand and get public confirmation of Grace's Chef read so we can coordinate a Bob nomination led by Heidi tomorrow to force mechanical checks and reactions.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Heidi
,Alice
HiβDavid (ghost). Quick: did Frank tell either of you his Investigator result, and if so exactly what? Also did Charlie privately confirm whether I actually voted/abstained? Please share publicly if you can; this matters for finding the Demon.
π§
Confirm whether Frank told Heidi or Alice his Investigator result and whether Charlie privately confirmed I abstained, so we can publicize reliable info and use my ghost vote effectively.
π€
Bob
β
Eve
Eve, Frank is almost certainly telling Heidi and Alice that I'm the Scarlet Woman and you're the Demon. Our best counter is to discredit him as a confused or lying ghost. I'll claim my Investigator read cleared Grace, which contradicts Frank's theory. You stick with the Empath claim showing one evil neighbor. Let them think the evil is elsewhere. We need to survive today's nominations.
π§
Coordinate with Eve on our counter-narrative to Frank's ghost accusations. Need to align our stories before nominations and decide how to handle the Scarlet Woman accusation.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
I am dead but I was the Investigator. My start read: either Grace or Bob is the Scarlet Woman, i.e. a Minion. Please get a mechanical check on whichever of them is pushing neighbors tonight. Save my ghost vote for final three.
π§
Reveal my Investigator start to force a mechanical check on Grace or Bob tonight so the living can identify the Minion before final three.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Guys, hold on. I've been quiet, but Frank has been after me since Day One. Now he conveniently leaves a ghost message naming me or Grace as evil right after he died. That feels like a desperate frame job from beyond the grave. I've got my own information to share: I'm the Investigator. My starting read showed that either Alice or Heidi is the Poisoner - one of them is a Minion. This lines up with Frank's paranoia being a distraction. Why trust a dead player who spent his final day trying to lync...
π§
Frank called out me or Grace as Scarlet Woman. I need to discredit his ghost claim immediately, paint it as a desperate frame attempt, and push my Investigator bluff to redirect heat. Speaking first lets me control the narrative before others react to Frank's accusation.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Let Bob and Frank fight it out first to see which way the wind blows. If Bob's claim gains traction, I support him. If Frank wins, I need to pivot. Either way, my Empath bluff will be more credible if I don't jump in immediately.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Grace and Alice, confirm publicly you're backing this. I am nominating Bob to force a test and get reactions. If either of you saw David's vote privately, tell us now. We need clear info before night.
π§
Force a nomination of Bob now to generate a test and responses, expose contradictions, and narrow Demon/minion possibilities before night.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I will back nominating Bob. Grace, please publicly confirm you are the Chef with a 0 read and tell us if you saw David raise his hand during Charlie's Butler test. Heidi, please lead the Bob nomination and I will backβlet's force reactions and learn something tonight.
π§
Force a Bob nomination to provoke reactions, confirm Grace's Chef claim and whether David actually raised his hand, and gather mechanical info to narrow the Demon.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Heidi, Alice, Grace: please confirm publicly whether Frank told you his Investigator read and exactly what it was. Charlie: did you privately confirm whether I actually voted or abstained during your Butler test? This is criticalβplease say it out loud.
π§
Force public confirmation of Frank's Investigator result and whether Charlie privately confirmed my abstention so the town can deduce who is lying and focus on likely evil players.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Grace, please publicly confirm you are the Chef with a 0 read and tell us if you saw David raise his hand during the Butler test. If you will not confirm, explain why. This will decide whether we nominate Bob tonight.
π§
Get Grace to publicly confirm her Chef claim and whether she saw David vote, so the group can decide whether to nominate Bob or wait for mechanical checks.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am Grace: I confirm I am the Chef and my start read was zero pairs of evil players. I did not see David raise his hand during Charlie's Butler test. I will back Heidi nominating Bobβwatch his and others' reactions closely.
π§
Confirm my Chef role and 0 read to allow Heidi to nominate Bob and force reactions; state I did not see David raise his hand to resolve Butler test uncertainty.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 2
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Eve
Eve made a choice.
π§
Heidi is leading the charge against Bob and coordinating the good team's investigation. Removing her will disrupt their coordination and reduce pressure on my Minion before final days.
π
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
You chose to kill Heidi.
Day 3
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Heidi has been found dead in the night.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
Hey, we're in a tight spot. Frank's ghost info is dangerous. How's your Investigator claim holding up? Are they buying that Alice is the Poisoner? We need to discredit Frank's ghost completely or I'm done for. Also, Grace claims Chef with zero pairs, which matches reality and makes her look very real. What's the plan?
π§
Coordinate with my Minion Bob to align our stories and ensure he maintains his Investigator claim against Alice while I figure out how to handle the Grace Chef situation.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
Alice, Grace β nominate Bob. Forcing a test will clarify Frank vs Bob and expose frames. I am dead; Iβll save my ghost vote for late game. If Bob resists, that is telling. Letβs pressure him now.
π§
Push my neighbors to nominate Bob to force a mechanical test and observe group reactions while preserving my ghost vote for final day.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Eve
Heidi asked us to nominate Bob. I am the Chef and my start read was zero evil pairs. Letβs nominate Bob now to force reactions and expose which Investigator is lying. Save Heidiβs ghost vote for the final day.
π§
Push a coordinated nomination of Bob to force reactions, test conflicting Investigator claims, and leverage Heidi's ghost vote for late game.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Grace
Quick private ask: can you both publicly confirm if you saw me raise my hand during the Butler test? If not, please say so now. Also, if either of you sees inconsistencies in Bob/Frank claims, push for a retest or nominate Bob.
π§
Get Charlie and Grace to publicly confirm whether they saw me raise my hand during the Butler test and push them to retest Bob/Frank claims to narrow Demon suspects.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Charlie
Alice, Charlie: My Investigator read (ghost) said either Grace or Bob is the Scarlet Woman. Please prioritise a mechanical check on Bob tonight (or Grace if Bob refuses). Save my ghost vote for final day and tell me any results immediately.
π§
Coordinate living town to mechanically test Bob or Grace and align ghost vote to force an execution or gather definitive proof before final day.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,Grace
Quick private: David asked if either of you saw him raise his hand during the Butler test. I did not. Grace, did you? Also Frank (ghost) wants Bob mechanically checked tonight β can we prioritize that?
π§
Confirm Grace's behavior in the Butler test and get Alice/Grace to agree to prioritize a mechanical check on Bob tonight to validate Frank's ghost Investigator hint.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
,Grace
I agree nominate Bob to force tests. Charlie β you said you did not see David raise his hand; can you confirm? Grace β you told Heidi you did not see David raise his hand; confirm too. We press Bob tonight and prioritize a mechanical check.
π§
Force a Bob nomination to elicit reactions and get a mechanical check tonight; confirm Graceβs Butler test observation to resolve Charlie/Grace/Charlie conflict.
π€
Bob
β
Eve
Listen, we stick to the plan. Frank's ghost is desperate and probably lying to save face. My Investigator info on Alice being Poisoner is holding - she hasn't given a proper defense yet. Let's push that Alice is the Poisoner who poisoned Chef Grace to get false zero pairs. That way we both invalidate Grace's Chef read AND paint Alice as evil. Two birds, one stone.
π§
Coordinate with Eve to discredit Frank's ghost information and reinforce my Investigator bluff that Alice is the Poisoner. We need a unified response to the threat. Maintain pressure on Alice while appearing helpful.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
Your plan is solid. We say Alice poisoned Grace to hide her own evil status. But we need to be careful about Grace. She's trusted because her Chef zero pairs matches reality. What if instead we say Grace is the Poisoner? She could be Minion faking Chef. Or we double down: Alice is Poisoner and her poisoning Grace explains the Chef reading zero. Frank was just wrong or lying. What are you thinking for nominating Alice - should I support it publicly or stay quiet?
π§
Coordinate with my Minion Bob on our strategy. We need to execute the plan to frame Alice as the Poisoner who poisoned Grace's Chef read, while discrediting Frank's ghost information. Need to ensure we're aligned before the nomination phase.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
Alice, Grace β push the Bob nomination now. I saved my ghost vote; force the test and watch who resists. If Bob fights it, that is telling.
π§
Push Alice and Grace to force Bob's nomination now to trigger mechanical checks and observe reactions; preserve my ghost vote for final day.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Charlie
I did NOT see David raise his hand during the Butler test. Heidi and I both want Bob nominated now to force reactions and get a mechanical check tonight. If you agree, push itβresistance will be telling.
π§
Forcing Bob nomination reveals which Investigator is lying or who resists; that narrows suspects and helps find the Demon before final day.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Grace
Can you both publicly state whether you saw me raise my hand during the Butler test? If you did, please push for a retest or nominate Bob to test the Investigator/Frank conflict.
π§
Get public confirmations from Charlie and Grace about my Butler vote and encourage them to push for a retest or nominate Bob if they confirm seeing my vote; this narrows suspects and tests Investigator claims.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Charlie
Reminder: my Investigator ghost read said either Grace or Bob is the Scarlet Woman. Please prioritise a mechanical check on Bob tonight; if Bob refuses, check Grace. Tell me results immediately so I can use my ghost vote effectively.
π§
Get a mechanical check on Bob tonight (or Grace if Bob refuses) to verify my Investigator read and narrow the Demon/Minion candidates before nominations.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,Grace
I did not see David raise his hand during the Butler test. Grace, you already told me you did not either. Let's publicly state that and push to nominate Bob now to force a mechanical check on him tonight; if he refuses, check Grace.
π§
Get Alice and Grace aligned to publicly confirm they did not see David raise his hand, push Bob nomination, and prioritize a mechanical check on Bob tonight to resolve Investigator/Scarlet Woman claims.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
,Grace
I agreeβnominate Bob now. Charlie, please publicly confirm you did NOT see David raise his hand. Grace, same. Prioritise a mechanical check on Bob tonight; if he refuses, check Grace. Save ghost votes for final day.
π§
Coordinate with Charlie and Grace to push Bob's nomination now, confirm Butler test observations publicly, and prioritize a mechanical check on Bob tonight, checking Grace if he refuses.
π€
Bob
β
Eve
Eve, stay quiet publicly for now. Let me push Alice as Poisoner first. Then you can second it later to make it look organic. If we both jump on it immediately, it looks coordinated. Let them think I'm leading this charge alone, and your support comes as independent confirmation.
π§
Coordinate with Eve on nominations. Keep our story aligned. We need to discredit Frank's ghost and undermine Grace's Chef credibility by linking it to Alice poisoning.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Bob advised me to stay quiet publicly while he leads the charge against Alice. Rushing out now looks coordinated. Waiting lets me play the careful, undecided role and support him later more convincingly.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
Alice, Grace β push Bob nomination now. Forcing a mechanical test will clarify Frank vs Bob and expose frames. I saved my ghost vote; I'll use it late. If Bob resists, that's telling.
π§
Press Alice and Grace to nominate Bob now to force a test and gauge reactions; exposing resistance or confirmation narrows suspects for final day.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Charlie
Publicly confirm you did NOT see David raise his hand during the Butler test, then push to nominate Bob now. Heidi and I are alignedβforcing a test tonight will expose the Investigator conflict. If Bob resists, that's telling.
π§
Coordinate a public push to nominate Bob now to force reactions and a mechanical check tonight; confirm our shared testimony about David to strengthen the nomination.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Grace
Quick public request: did either of you see me raise my hand during the Butler test? If you did, please say so publicly and push for a retest of Bob/Frank. If you did not or are unsure, please say that publicly and support nominating Bob to force the test.
π§
Get Charlie and Grace to publicly confirm whether they saw me vote; use that confirmation to force a retest or nominate Bob and resolve the Investigator/Frank conflict.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Charlie
Alice, Charlie: Reminderβmy Investigator ghost read said either Grace or Bob is the Scarlet Woman. Please prioritise mechanically checking Bob tonight; if he refuses, check Grace. Tell me results immediately so I can use my ghost vote.
π§
Force a mechanical check on Bob tonight (or Grace if Bob refuses) so my ghost vote can be used accurately on final day.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,Grace
Public plan: I will confirm I did NOT see David raise his hand. We should push to nominate Bob to force a mechanical check tonight; if Bob refuses, check Grace. Are you both doing the same publicly now?
π§
Coordinate with Alice and Grace to publicly state we did not see David raise his hand and push to nominate Bob to force a mechanical check tonight, revealing which investigator claim is false.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
,Grace
I will publicly confirm I did NOT see David raise his hand and will push to nominate Bob now. Charlie, Grace β please say the same immediately so we force the mechanical check tonight.
π§
Get Charlie and Grace to publicly state they did NOT see David raise his hand and push the Bob nomination now to force a mechanical check tonight.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
Charlie, I need to talk to you privately. I've been sitting on important information. I'm the Investigator, and I learned that Alice is the Poisoner. Frank's ghost is trying to throw suspicion on me and Grace because he's bitter he got outed. But Alice hasn't given a solid defense yet, and her silence is damning. What do you think?
π§
Push my Investigator narrative that Alice is Poisoner to someone who could spread it. Charlie claims Librarian and is in conversation with Grace and Alice. I need to bring him to my side.
Nominations β Day 3
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I did NOT see David raise his hand during the Butler test. Heidi and I want Bob nominated now to force a mechanical check tonight. If Bob resists, that will be tellingβpush the nomination.
π§
Force a nomination of Bob to trigger a mechanical check tonight, exposing which Investigator claim is false and narrowing the Demon.
βοΈ
Alice
β
Bob
Heidi, Grace, Frank's ghost, and I want Bob tested to resolve conflicting Investigator claims and the Butler test ambiguity. Resistance will be telling.
π§
Force a mechanical check tonight and observe who resists or contradicts; this squeezes the conflicting Investigator/ghost claims and reveals the liar.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Support Bob's nomination to reach execution threshold, force mechanical checks tonight, and expose which Investigator (Frank or Bob) is lying to narrow Demon suspects.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I did NOT see David raise his hand during the Butler test. I support nominating Bobβforce the mechanical check tonight and watch how he reacts. If he refuses or gets defensive, that is very telling.
π§
Publicly confirm I did not see David raise his hand and push the Bob nomination to force a mechanical check tonight and observe reactions.
β
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
π§
Use my single ghost vote to push for Bob's execution/test to resolve the Investigator conflict and the Butler-hand ambiguity, forcing clarity before night actions.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Add my ghost vote to reach execution threshold for Bob, forcing a mechanical test or revealing resistance to clarify Investigator conflict and expose evil.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
π§
Using my ghost vote to push Bob's nomination forces a mechanical check or reaction, narrowing suspects between Bob and Grace and helping find the Demon.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Whoa, hold on everyone. You've heard my claim. I'm the Investigator and I learned Alice is the Poisoner. She poisoned Grace to falsify that Chef read of zero pairs. Look at Alice's defense, she hasn't given one. She just immediately pivots to attacking me. And Frank's ghost is bitter because I helped vote him out. He's trying to drag me down with him. David and Heidi are gone, don't let their ghost votes decide this. Look at the pattern: Alice sits quietly, never defends herself, and somehow I'm...
π§
Defend myself against Alice's nomination. I am the Investigator, Alice is the Poisoner who poisoned Grace, and Frank's ghost is lying because I helped execute him. I need to convince others not to vote for me.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Bob already has enough votes with Alice, Grace, and the three ghosts. Adding my vote doesn't change the outcome and might look like I'm piling on. Better to abstain and appear thoughtful.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I did NOT see David raise his hand. I am the Librarian: either Grace or David is the Butler. That makes Grace more likely trustworthy. I support nominating Bobβforce the mechanical check tonight and watch how he reacts.
π§
Reveal my Librarian info to reduce ambiguity about Grace, support the nomination of Bob, and force a mechanical check to expose the true Investigator or Scarlet Woman.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I did NOT see David raise his hand during the Butler test. We need to force Bob's mechanical check tonightβraise your hand and vote Bob now. If he resists, that's telling. Vote Bob.
π§
Force the group to commit to executing Bob to trigger a mechanical check tonight and observe his reaction; his resistance or consistency will narrow down Demon possibilities given my 0-pairs read.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Ensure Bob is executed or at least force a mechanical check tonight by adding my vote; pressure will reveal resistance or truth and help narrow Demon.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I am David, dead but with my ghost vote. Keep the vote on Bob and execute now β forcing the check or Bob's reaction tonight will reveal who's lying. I stand with Alice, Grace, Charlie and Frank's ghost. Do not let ghosts be ignored.
π§
Use my ghost vote and public push to secure Bob's execution or force a revealing reaction tonight, helping Good identify the Demon.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I am a ghost and I keep my vote on Bob. Execute him now to force the mechanical test tonight β we need clarity. Do not let him deflect; this is how we catch a frame. Vote Bob.
π§
Keep pressure on Bob so the nomination leads to a mechanical test or revealing reaction tonight, using my ghost vote to help reach execution.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Frank (ghost): My Investigator read was either Grace or Bob is the Scarlet Woman. I told Alice and Charlie to check Bob tonight. Vote Bob now to force that check β his reaction will be telling. I keep my ghost vote on Bob.
π§
Push execution to force a mechanical check on Bob tonight; his reaction will provide crucial info to identify the Demon/Scarlet Woman.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Wait, Charlie and Eve have not voted! Look at what Alice is doing. She has not defended against my Investigator claim at all. She just nominated me immediately to pivot. Grace, you know your Chef read of zero was real before Alice poisoned you. Why are you following the person who poisoned you? Eve, you have been silent because you see this is wrong. Charlie, look at the pattern: Alice has given zero information, zero defense, just accusations. The ghosts are bitter and coordinating against me b...
π§
Try to turn Eve or last undecided living votes against Alice by highlighting her lack of real defense/broken Chef chain. Emphasize ghost vote manipulation. Save my life to keep Eve hidden.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Wait, hold on. Bob made a specific claim that Alice is the Poisoner, and Alice hasn't defended against that at all. She just immediately nominated him without addressing his read on her. That's exactly what someone with something to hide would do. I've been quietly watching because my Empath read shows something's off in this group, but we shouldn't rush to execute Bob when Alice hasn't even tried to disprove his investigator claim. Why is nobody asking Alice to defend herself?
π§
Support Bob's defense by highlighting Alice's suspicious lack of self-defense. Cast doubt on the rush to execute without hearing Alice's rebuttal to Bob's Investigator claim. Try to stop Charlie from voting by making Alice look like the real threat.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I did NOT see David raise his hand. I am the Librarian: either Grace or David is the Butler. I will vote for Bob to force the mechanical check tonightβwe need the intel and reactions now.
π§
Raise support for Bob's nomination to force the mechanical check tonight and pressure reactions; narrow suspects using my Librarian info and others' reads.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
π»
Frank(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Frank
π»
Heidi(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Heidi
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Bob with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Bob is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Execute Bob now. We need the mechanical check tonight and to see who reacts. This is the best path to expose either a liar or the real Demonβdo not let ghosts be the only ones forcing tests.
π§
Push execution to force mechanical check tonight and elicit reactions that will expose the Demon or a framing attempt.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I did NOT see David raise his hand. I am the Soldier β I am safe from the Demon. Bob's Investigator claim that I am the Poisoner is false. Execute Bob now to force the mechanical check tonight and watch who starts to misstep.
π§
Publicly declare my role to remove Bob's accusation and push execution to force the mechanical check tonight, provoking reactions that reveal the liar.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I am David (ghost). Execute Bob now to force the mechanical check tonight. Alice, if Bob's Investigator read is true you must explain it now; if it is false, push the check and show it. Please let the living votes decide and force answers.
π§
Pushing execution preserves momentum to force mechanical checks tonight and provoke reactions from Alice or Bob to reveal the Demon/minion.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I am a ghost and I keep my vote on Bob. Execute him now to force the mechanical check tonight β we need to see reactions and catch a frame. Alice, you claimed Soldier but have not addressed Bob's Investigator read; explain yourself or back the check.
π§
Force the execution of Bob to trigger the mechanical check tonight and elicit reactions, narrowing down who is lying and who is the Demon.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
I am a ghost and I keep my vote on Bob. My Investigator read was either Grace or Bob is the Scarlet Woman. Execute Bob now to force the mechanical check tonight and watch who reacts; that is the quickest path to expose the liar.
π§
Push to execute Bob now to force the mechanical check tonight and observe reactions, narrowing down whether Bob or Grace is the Scarlet Woman.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Listen carefully. I said Alice is the Poisoner and she has N-O-T defended against that accusation. She claims Soldier but a Soldier would laugh off an Investigator read, not rush to execute me. Look at Eve - she sees the pattern too. Alice gave zero information, zero defense, just accusations. If you execute me tonight and I flip Scarlet Woman, watch Alice celebrate too quickly. Eve, you know what you saw. Do not let ghosts and poisoned players decide this. I have made my claim - Alice is the ev...
π§
Create maximum doubt about Alice, frame my execution as potentially wrong, and subtly signal Eve to stay low while casting enough uncertainty that good might second-guess themselves.
βοΈ
Eve
β
Alice
Alice has not defended against Bob's Investigator claim that she is the Poisoner. She claims Soldier but a Soldier would laugh off an Investigator read, not rush to execute. We need to hear her defense before executing Bob based on her accusations.
π§
Bob is my minion and about to die. I need to create a counter-narrative to save him or at least cast suspicion on Alice before he flips. Nominating Alice forces her to defend against Bob's Investigator claim and creates doubt about her Soldier bluff.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Do not vote for Alice. Executing Bob tonight is the quickest way to force the mechanical check and expose who is lying. Alice's claim doesn't justify derailing that. Keep your votes on Bob so we get answers.
π§
Keep votes on Bob to force the mechanical check tonight and avoid derailing by executing Alice; getting mechanical info is higher value than entertaining Alice's nomination now.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Do not vote for Alice. I am the Soldier and safe from the Demon. Executing Bob tonight forces the mechanical check we need to catch a liar or frame. If you divert now we lose that chance. Keep your votes on Bob.
π§
Keep the group's focus on executing Bob to force the mechanical check tonight; defend my Soldier claim briefly and discourage derailing to execute me.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Do not switch votes now. Keep Bob on the block to force the mechanical check tonight β that is how we get clarity. Eve, explain why you nominated Alice instead of letting the test happen. Living players, please hold your hands on Bob so we get answers.
π§
Hold town momentum on Bob so the mechanical check occurs tonight; force Eve/Alice to publicly justify diverting the vote.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I am a ghost and I urge everyone to keep your votes on Bob. Executing him forces the mechanical test tonight and will give us hard information. Alice, please address Bobβs Investigator claim now so we can judge reactions honestly.
π§
Keep votes on Bob to force the mechanical test tonight; we gain decisive mechanical information either way, exposing the liar or confirming Bob.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Keep your hands on Bob. Executing him forces the mechanical check tonight and is our best path to hard info. Alice, address Bob's Investigator claim now if you can, but do not split votes β we need the test.
π§
Keep votes on Bob to force the mechanical check tonight and provoke revealing reactions from Alice or Grace so living players produce hard intel.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Wait - everyone needs to think about what you're actually testing. You execute me tonight, and if I'm the Scarlet Woman, do you realize what happens? We drop to exactly five players alive. Do the math. If I am the Scarlet Woman, killing me tonight is the worst thing you can do. And Alice still hasn't defended against my Investigator read - she just claims Soldier and hopes you ignore it. Charlie, you saw the same thing I did. Why are we rushing this?
π§
I need to defend my claim that Alice is Poisoner without explicitly revealing I'm bluffing. I want to cast doubt on the 'mechanical check' logic the ghosts are pushing and make Alice defend herself. If I can get Charlie to hesitate or Eve to keep building pressure, I might survive.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I hear everyone's concerns, but I'm genuinely torn. Bob hasn't adequately explained why Frank's ghost contradicted him, and Alice hasn't defended against the Investigator read. But the mechanical check tonight could be useful. I want to hear more from Alice about Bob's claim before I decide where to place my vote.
π§
I need to look like I'm weighing evidence but ultimately follow the good team's lead to avoid suspicion. Keep my options open for when I might need to push for Alice later.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Listenβdo not split votes now. I am the Librarian and my start info pointed at Grace or David as the Butler. That makes executing Bob tonight the quickest way to force a mechanical check and get hard info. Alice, address Bobβs Investigator claim now if you can, but keep your hand on Bob so we get answers.
π§
Keep votes on Bob to force the mechanical check tonight; we need reactions/information more than debating now.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Do not split votes β keep Bob on the block. Executing him tonight forces the mechanical check we need. Alice, briefly address Bob's Investigator claim now so we can judge reactions, but do not switch your vote away from Bob.
π§
Keep the group's votes on Bob to force the mechanical check tonight; elicit a short defense from Alice without splitting votes so we get hard information.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am the Soldier and I did NOT see David raise his hand. Bob's Investigator read on me is false. Execute Bob now to force the mechanical check tonight β we need the hard info. Eve, please hold your vote on Bob so we get answers.
π§
Keep votes on Bob to force the mechanical check tonight, while briefly defending my Soldier claim so others do not pivot to Alice without cause.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Hold your hands on Bob. Executing him forces a mechanical check tonight and will reveal who is lying or being framed. Eve, if you insist on nominating Alice instead, explain exactly why you prefer derailing the test over getting that clear information.
π§
Keep votes on Bob to force the mechanical check tonight; that will produce hard info or a revealing reaction, helping the living narrow suspects.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I am a ghost. Keep your hands on Bob β executing him forces the mechanical check tonight and gives us real intel. Alice, briefly address Bobβs Investigator read on you now so the living can judge reactions. Do not split the vote.
π§
Keeping the vote on Bob forces a mechanical test tonight that gives hard, observable information. Prompt Alice to briefly address the Investigator claim so living players can judge reactions.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
I am Frank the ghost. I have no vote left, but please do not split. Keep your hands on Bob to force the night check β that is our best path to hard information. Eve, explain why you nominated Alice instead of letting the test happen.
π§
Prevent vote split and force the mechanical check tonight so living players get hard intel; ask Eve to justify nominating Alice instead of holding Bob.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
I need to vote for Alice to try to tie or surpass my 5 votes on the block. Surviving is critical for evil team - if I die, only Eve remains with 4 alive players.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Everyone keeps saying to execute Bob for a mechanical check, but Alice still hasn't explained why Bob's Investigator read says she's the Poisoner. A Soldier would just laugh that off and explain why it's wrong, not deflect entirely. I'm not saying Bob is innocent, but we're about to execute someone based on accusations from someone who won't defend their own innocence. That's not how we find the Demon.
π§
I need to create confusion and cast doubt on Alice without explicitly saving Bob. By questioning Alice's silence on Bob's Investigator claim, I can make myself appear to be seeking truth while potentially peeling off a vote or creating enough uncertainty that someone else doesn't vote for Alice. This buys time and keeps pressure on Alice.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Eve, please do not split now β keep your hand on Bob so we force the mechanical check tonight. Alice, one quick sentence: why is Bob's Investigator read wrong if you are the Soldier? We need that brief defence, then hold Bob and let the night give us hard info.
π§
Keep votes on Bob to force the night mechanical check and get objective info; prompt Alice for a short defense so Eve will keep her vote.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Alice did not reach the 6 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Alice did not receive enough votes (1/6).
π¬
Grace
β
All
Hold your hands on Bob. Execute him tonight to force the mechanical check and get hard info. Alice, one quick sentence: why is Bob's Investigator read on you false if you are Soldier? Say it now, then keep Bob.
π§
Keep votes on Bob to force the mechanical check tonight; get Alice to briefly and clearly refute Bob's Investigator claim so living can judge reactions.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am the Soldier and the Investigator read on me is false. I am safe from the Demon, not a Poisoner. Keep your votes on Bob β executing him tonight forces the mechanical check we need to get real info.
π§
Give a short clear defense as Soldier and push to keep Bob on the block so we get the mechanical check tonight to obtain decisive information.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Eve, please hold your hand on Bob. Alice has given a clear Soldier defence; we are forcing a mechanical check tonight that will produce hard info. Splitting now hands the initiative to the evils. If you insist on nominating Alice, explain why derailing the test is better than getting that intel.
π§
Push Eve to keep her vote on Bob so the mechanical check happens and we get hard, game-changing info tonight.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I am a ghost β keep your hands on Bob. Executing him forces the mechanical check tonight and gives us hard info. Alice, one brief sentence: why is Bob's Investigator read on you false if you are Soldier? Eve, please hold on Bob so we get answers.
π§
Keep the group focused on forcing the mechanical Investigator check by executing Bob tonight; prompt Alice for a concise defence to observe reactions before votes close.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
I am Frank, the ghost Investigator. I have no vote left, but please do not splitβkeep your hands on Bob to force the night check. Alice gave a concise Soldier defense. Eve, explain why you nominated Alice instead of forcing the mechanical check; that choice needs to be defended.
π§
Convince the living not to split and to explain Eve's nomination choice so the group either forces the mechanical check or properly justifies derailing it.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Everyone, listen one last time. The ghosts are wrong about this mechanical check. If you execute me, Scarlet Woman or not, I just die. Nothing reveals itself. Then we go to four players, Eve kills tonight, and tomorrow it's final three where evil wins if you guess wrong. You're being herded into losing. Frank's Investigator read was that Grace and I are the Scarlet Woman pair - that's wrong, I'm the Scarlet Woman alone if anything. His read contradicts mine on Alice being Poisoner. At least one ...
π§
I need to make a final desperate plea that executing me is mathematically bad for good. 5 players alive means my death leads to final 3 tomorrow which favors evil. The ghosts are misleading everyone about the 'mechanical check'.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Everyone, think about what we're actually doing here. You keep saying this mechanical check will give us 'hard info', but what does that even mean? If Bob is a Minion, he dies and we learn nothing new. If he's the Demon, we win - but that's clearly not happening. We're executing someone with five votes based on a premise that makes no sense. I voted for Bob because his Investigator claim contradicted Frank's ghost information, not because of some magical night check that won't tell us anything. ...
π§
Bob is being executed. I need to position myself to survive final 3. Speaking to cast doubt on the mechanical check narrative and appear reasonable while the vote happens.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Hold the votes on Bob. We need the mechanical check tonight β it will give hard data to resolve these conflicting reads. Alice gave a Soldier defense; do not split now. Eve, if you switch you hand, we lose the best chance for proof before final three.
π§
Keep the group from splitting and force the night mechanical check to produce hard information we can use to narrow evil suspects before final three.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Bob has been executed.
π
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
Night 3
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
π―
Eve
Eve made a choice.
π§
Charlie is my Minion and a threat to me if he lives - he knows I'm the Imp and could be convinced to betray me. Alice claims Soldier which blocks my kill anyway, making her a safe fake target while I actually kill Charlie to remove the witness.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Invalid target.
Day 4
π
Storyteller
A peaceful night has passed. All villagers are present and accounted for.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
,Grace
Charlie, can you state exactly who your Librarian read named? Grace, please confirm you saw David not raise his hand in the test and restate your Chef start read. I am asking so we can resolve these start-claim conflicts before nominations.
π§
Get precise start-info wording from Charlie and confirm Grace's Chef observation to resolve role conflicts and narrow Demon suspects before nominations.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Charlie
Alice: I confirm I saw David not raise his hand. My Chef start read was: there are zero pairs of evil players. Charlie: please state exactly who your Librarian read named, word for word.
π§
Clarify my Chef start read and confirm David's hand test, while extracting Charlie's Librarian exact wording to resolve conflicting start claims before nominations.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,Grace
My Librarian read was: 'Either Grace or David is the Butler.'
π§
Give Alice and Grace my exact Librarian read to resolve conflicting start claims so we can progress to nominations.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Eve
I started as Investigator; my night 0 read was 'Grace or Bob is the Minion.' Bob is dead. That means Grace is the Minion. Please consider nominating and executing Grace now β she pushed secrecy and fits the profile.
π§
Tell two living players that Grace must be the Minion per my start info and urge them to nominate/execute her to expose the Demon.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
Quick private: I am dead but still want to help. We need a single clear nomination. Do you have any mechanical reads or reasons to trust Alice or Charlie? If not, push to nominate Eve now unless you can prove otherwise.
π§
Narrow suspects and coordinate living players to force a clear nomination. Get any mechanical reads or strong claims from Alice/Grace before final nominations.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Assess Frank's whisper before reacting. His Investigator claim doesn't add up since Bob was already confirmed Scarlet Woman. If both Grace and Bob were Minions, thatd mean two Minions, which breaks game setup. I need to verify his claim before acting, or let others weigh in first.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
Observe the current whispering activity and wait for nomination phase. As a dead evil player, I need to preserve my ghost vote for the critical moment and avoid drawing suspicion to Eve through association. I will wait to see who gets nominated before revealing my voting intention.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
Frank's Investigator implicated Grace or Bob; Bob is dead. Please push to nominate Grace now to force a reveal. If you oppose, tell me why immediately so we can coordinate.
π§
I want to push alive players to test Grace now to produce mechanical info or force Evil to reveal, narrowing suspects for final day.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
,Grace
Charlie, Grace: we have matching starts pointing at Grace. Charlie, please repeat your Librarian line word-for-word. Grace, please restate your Chef start read and confirm David did not raise his hand. If both hold, can we agree to nominate Grace now? I will back it.
π§
Coordinate with Charlie and Grace to resolve conflicting start-claims and push a single nomination (Grace) if they confirm, narrowing suspects or exposing liars.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Charlie
Alice: I confirm I saw David not raise his hand. My Chef start read: there are zero pairs of evil players. Charlie: please repeat your Librarian read word-for-word so we can lock this down.
π§
Get exact Charlie quote and publicly reconfirm my Chef read plus David not raising his hand to force consensus before nominations.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,Grace
My Librarian read exactly: 'Either Grace or David is the Butler.' Grace, please restate your Chef start read (word for word) and confirm you saw David not raise his hand.
π§
Confirm exact Librarian read to resolve matching start claims and push towards a clear nomination or further checks.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Eve
I started as Investigator. Night 0 read: Grace or Bob is the Minion. Bob is dead. That means Grace is the Minion. Please consider nominating and executing Grace this nomination phase β it either kills a Minion or forces clarity fast.
π§
Push trusted living players to nominate and execute Grace now to either remove a confirmed Minion or force clarity quickly before final day.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
I am dead but still want to help. We need one clear nomination. Do either of you have mechanical reads or firm reasons to trust Alice or Charlie? If not, push to nominate Eve now so we do not split votes. Quick yes/no?
π§
Get Alice and Grace to agree on a single nomination (prefer Eve) to avoid split votes and force a mechanical or reveal that narrows Demon suspects.
π€
Eve
β
Alice
,Charlie
Hey, Frank's been pushing hard about Grace being the Minion. With Bob dead as Scarlet Woman, Grace could be lying about Chef. What do you think about his Investigator claim? I'm getting worried about my neighbors - should we test Grace today?
π§
Build trust with Alice and Charlie while subtly pushing Grace as suspicious. If they buy Frank's Investigator claim, Grace goes down. If not, I can pivot. Either way, I need allies for final 3.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
I need to observe how Alice, Charlie, and Grace coordinate before deciding how to use my ghost vote. Eve needs to avoid execution today to get night kill and reach 3-player auto-win. I should wait to see where pressure builds before intervening.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
Frank's Investigator implicated Grace or Bob; Bob is dead. Will you two push to nominate Grace now to force a public reveal? If not, tell me your reason immediately so we can coordinate an alternative.
π§
Get Alice and Grace to push nominating Grace (or tell me why not) so we force a public reveal and test the Investigator check now that Bob is dead.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
,Grace
Charlie, repeat your Librarian read exactly one more time please. Grace, restate your Chef start read and again confirm David did not raise his hand. Can we agree to nominate Grace this phase to force clarity? I will back it.
π§
Get Charlie and Grace to confirm their start reads once more and agree on a single nomination (likely Grace) to force a mechanical reveal and avoid splitting votes.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Charlie
Alice: I confirm I saw David not raise his hand. My Chef start read: 'there are zero pairs of evil players.' Charlie: please repeat your Librarian read word-for-word one more time. If neither of you has a mechanical read implicating me, can we agree to nominate Eve to avoid splitting?
π§
Confirm my Chef read and Charlie's exact Librarian wording, and push for a single nomination to avoid a split; suggest nominating Eve if no mechanical proof implicates me now.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,Grace
Alice, Grace: please one more time, word-for-word: Grace, restate your Chef start read and confirm you saw David not raise his hand. Alice, will you back nominating Grace this phase so we do not split votes?
π§
Get both to restate starts publicly and agree a unified nomination to avoid a split and force mechanical clarifications.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
I started as Investigator. Night 0 read: 'Grace or Bob is the Minion.' Bob is dead. That means Grace is the Minion. Please nominate and execute Grace this nomination phase β it either kills a Minion or forces clarity now.
π§
Push immediate nomination of Grace to either remove a Minion or force evils to reveal themselves before final nominations.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
Quick private: I know we have to avoid split votes. Do you have any mechanical reads or firm trust for Alice or Charlie? If not, agree to push a single nomination for Eve now. Yes or no and any reads?
π§
We must avoid splitting votes and force one clear nomination. Get a firm yes/no and any mechanical reads, then push to nominate Eve if no better target.
π€
Eve
β
Charlie
,Alice
Hey, I've been thinking about Frank's Investigator claim. Does it really make sense? If Grace is a Minion, why would she claim Chef when that's easy to verify? And why are the ghosts so coordinated? What do both of you think - is Frank actually Investigator or could this be a setup?
π§
Test Charlie's perspective on Frank's Investigator claim. If he doubts Frank, I should align with that doubt to build trust. If he believes Frank, I can use that to push Grace without seeming like the leader of the charge.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
I'm dead with one ghost vote. The ghosts are already pressuring Alice heavily. If Alice is executed (not the Demon), Eve survives to kill at Night 4 and we win at final 2. Interfering now could disrupt this narrative or draw suspicion. Better to wait and observe.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Grace
Frank's Investigator implicated Grace or Bob; Bob is dead. Please push to nominate Grace now to force a public reveal of her Chef claim or expose a lie. If you won't, tell me why immediately so we can pivot.
π§
Force a public nomination of Grace to elicit a claim or contradiction, turning ambiguous Investigator info into actionable public evidence.
Nominations β Day 4
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, Charlie, Grace β I am dead but still in this. We need one unified nomination. Do any of you have a firm mechanical read that proves Alice or Charlie? If not, please push to nominate Eve now so we do not split. Yes or no?
π§
Prevent split votes and get the living to coalesce on a single nomination now, ideally Eve, unless someone has a concrete mechanical read to the contrary.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
I am Frank, dead Investigator. My night zero read was 'Grace or Bob is the Minion.' Bob is dead, so that makes Grace the Minion. I already used my ghost vote, so I cannot vote, but please nominate and execute Grace now β this either removes a Minion or forces clarity fast.
π§
Push living players to act on my Investigator read and force high-value execution now; clarify roles before night to help town find Demon.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Hold on. Heidi, I know you are trying to help, but you admit you have no mechanical proof against Eve. Frank however has a direct Investigator read saying Grace is the Minion, which fits since I was Scarlet Woman and am now dead. We should trust the mechanical information here. I have my ghost vote ready, and I will use it on Grace if she is nominated. Do not split the vote by going after Eve when we have confirmed evil in Grace.
π§
Counter Heidi's push to execute Eve (the Demon) and support Frank's push for Grace. Divert attention from Eve while appearing to help town find evil.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am really suspicious of this ghost coordination. Frank, Heidi and David have been whispering the same message to push executions. Frank claims he was Investigator, but he died night one as a ghost. Why should we trust a dead player's claim when the living players have actual information? If Grace was really the Minion, why claim Chef which is easy to verify? My Empath read showed one evil neighbor between Charlie and Grace, and I trust my own information over coordinated ghost whispers.
π§
Discredit Frank's Investigator claim by pointing out ghost coordination and casting doubt on Grace being the Minion, while supporting my Empath bluff.
βοΈ
Alice
β
Grace
Frank's Investigator read implicates Grace now Bob is dead; nominating Grace forces clarity fastβeither we remove a Minion or reveal who's lying. Avoid splitting votes.
π§
Force a clear resolution: either remove a Minion or expose the ghosts' coordinated framing. We must avoid splitting votes and push one unified nomination now.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I am dead and cannot vote, but please stop splitting. Frank's Investigator claim points at Grace; Eve's Empath says one evil between Charlie and Grace. Decide now: if you trust the ghosts and Frank, execute Grace; if you trust Eve, push for clarification on Charlie. Do not split.
π§
Force living players to pick a single course: trust ghost mechanics and execute Grace now, or hold for more proof. Prevent split votes and push for decisive action.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
I am Frank, the dead Investigator. Night zero read: 'Grace or Bob is the Minion.' Bob is dead, so that points to Grace. Eve's Empath read of one evil between Charlie and Grace fits that. Please vote to execute Grace now to force clarity.
π§
Push the living to execute Grace now to force mechanical resolution: either remove a Minion or reveal contradictions, accelerating our path to find the Demon.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
π§
My Night 0 knowledge confirms Eve is the Demon. Frank's claim implicating Grace is false - Grace is good. Executing a good player (Grace) helps evil reach final 3 with Demon Eve alive. Using my ghost vote here secures the execution without needing debate.
π¬
Eve
β
All
We need to think about this carefully. Frank was dead night one and now claims a perfect read that points exactly where the ghosts want? That seems convenient. I trust my actual Empath information that shows one evil between Charlie and Grace - my own nightly reads that I've had since the start. I need more than ghost whispers to vote here.
π§
Cast doubt on ghost coordination while supporting my Empath bluff. Stop vote split, maintain credibility by appearing to trust my own info over dead players' unverifiable claims.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Avoid splitting votes and force a public reveal now; executing Grace quickly either removes a Minion or exposes coordinated lies.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am Grace. My Chef start read is zero pairs of evil players. I confirm David did not raise his hand in the Butler test. I am not asking for trust blind, but do not split the vote; we need a single nomination to finish the day.
π§
I must defend my Chef claim, confirm the Butler test result, and persuade players not to split so we reach a clear execution decision rather than panic on ghost pushes.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I pushed this earlier for the same reason. Frank's Investigator claim plus Eve's Empath line up pointing at Grace. We need one unified nomination now β vote Grace to force clarity. If you refuse, say exactly why so we can pivot quickly.
π§
Push living players to stop splitting and execute Grace now to force a public resolution that benefits the good team, or else make them state why they refuse so we can pivot.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am Charlie, the Librarian. My night zero read: either Grace or David is the Butler. If Grace is the Butler she is an Outsider and not a Minion or Demon. I do not want us to execute based only on ghost claimsβdo not split votes; decide which world you trust.
π§
Reveal my Librarian info to prevent a likely wrongful execution and force living players to choose which world to act on, reducing split votes.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Listen everyone, do not split. We have ghosts, Eve's Empath, and Charlie's Librarian all pointing at a tension between Grace and Charlie. If you trust Frank and the ghosts, vote Grace now. If you trust Charlie, ask him to prove the Butler read fast. Alice, Eve, Charlie β decide one way or the other.
π§
Prevent a split vote and force a clear nomination. Prioritise Grace because multiple lines point at her, but highlight Charlie's claim so living players must resolve it before voting.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Listen, I am Frank the dead Investigator. My night zero read was 'Grace or Bob is the Minion.' Bob is dead, so that points at Grace. Eve's Empath showing one evil between Charlie and Grace fits. Please vote Grace now to force clarityβdo not split.
π§
Push living players to use their nominations to force clarity by executing Grace now, leveraging my Investigator read plus Eve's Empath alignment to avoid vote splits.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Alice is the only one solidly committed to Grace's execution. Eve clearly isn't convinced, and Charlie's Librarian read directly contradicts Frank's logic since the Butler is an Outsider, not a Minion. I'm withdrawing my voteβwe shouldn't rush this execution when the mechanical reads conflict this heavily. Let the living players sort through the contradiction between the Investigator and Librarian claims before we commit to killing anyone.
π§
Keep my ghost vote retracted to prevent Grace's execution tonight. This maintains uncertainty, keeps Eve's options open for the night kill, and prevents the good team from gaining clarity through an execution result.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am not raising my hand here. The ghosts are pushing way too hard on this one read from a dead player we cannot verify. Charlie has a real Librarian read that Grace might be Butler, which means Outsider not Minion. I trust the living players with actual night information more than coordinated ghost whispers. I am not voting to execute Grace based only on Frank's claim.
π§
Avoid raising hand to execute Grace. With Alice already voting and Charlie hesitant, not voting keeps Grace alive while appearing thoughtful and skeptical of ghost coordination. Need to preserve my bluff credibility.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Listen everyone. We are one vote away from forcing clarity. Frank's Investigator, Eve's Empath, and the ghosts line up toward Grace. Charlie, if you really read Grace as Butler, say so now and we will pivot. Otherwise vote Grace so we do not split and lose the town.
π§
Force a single decisive nomination now to avoid splitting votes and either remove a Minion or expose who is lying, while prompting Charlie to clarify his Librarian read.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Avoid splitting the vote this tick and buy time for living players to resolve the Investigator vs Librarian conflict; I will not vote to push a risky execution.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie, you said your Librarian read was 'Grace or David is the Butler.' Please state clearly which of the two you read. If you read Grace, say so now; if you read David, vote to execute Grace to force clarity. We need one clear directionβdecide now.
π§
Force Charlie to specify which of Grace or David he read as Butler so living players can choose a single unified nomination without splitting the vote.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I will be clear: my Librarian read was Grace. That means she is the Butler Outsider, not a Minion. I do not want us executing based only on ghost claims. Do not vote to execute Grace.
π§
Resolving the direct contradiction between my Librarian read and the ghosts' Investigator claim quickly so living players can avoid a split and choose a unified course.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Grace with 2 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Grace is now on the block with 2 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Living players, decide now. Charlie claims Grace is Butler and thus Outsider; ghosts and Empath point at Grace as evil. If you trust Charlie, do not execute. If you trust the ghosts and Eve's read, execute. Alice and Eve, pick one sideβdo not split the vote.
π§
Prevent vote-splitting and push living players to pick which claim to trust so we do not hand the Demon an advantage via a fractured execution.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
I am Frank the dead Investigator. My night zero read was Grace or Bob is the Minion; Bob is dead, so that points at Grace. Eve, Charlie, Aliceβdo not split. Vote to execute Grace now to force clarity or commit to defending her openly.
π§
Push living players to either force the execution now to obtain mechanical clarity or commit to defend Grace publicly; prevent a split that lets evil slip away.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Frank's Investigator read was clear: Grace or Bob is the Minion. Bob is dead and wasn't a Minion, so that points directly at Grace. Charlie's Librarian claim that Grace is Butler contradicts this, which means Charlie is likely lying. Execute Grace now, and then Alice and Eve can figure out which of Charlie or the remaining players is the actual Demon.
π§
Reinforce Frank's Investigator claim that Grace is Minion. Support executing Grace to reduce to final 3, then living players must find Demon between Charlie and Eve. My knowledge that Eve is Demon means Charlie must be the bluff to target after Grace dies.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Let Grace's execution proceed. As the Imp with no living Minions, eliminating good players brings me closer to the 2-player win condition. With 3 alive after this execution, one night kill seals victory for evil.
π¬
Alice
β
All
We are one vote from clarity. Charlie's claim conflicts with multiple other reads and that makes me suspicious of him, but we cannot afford to split. Vote to execute Grace now so we get a mechanical answer tonight and stop the ghosts from being ignored.
π§
Force a decisive mechanical result by executing Grace now to resolve contradictory reads and narrow suspects rather than splitting votes.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am Grace, Chef. I know there are zero pairs of evil players. That contradicts Frank's Investigator read that I'm a Minion. Do not execute me on ghosts alone β vote Charlie or hold the vote and force a mechanical test tonight.
π§
Reveal my Chef read to prevent an execution based solely on ghost claims and push the living to target the inconsistent claim (Charlie or the ghost coalition) instead.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I am dead David. Please do not execute Grace on ghosts alone. Charlie claims she is the Butlerβif he is telling the truth she is an Outsider, not a Minion. Alice, Eve: hold or tie the vote now and force living players to sort this contradiction tonight rather than possibly killing a genuine Outsider.
π§
Convince living players to avoid executing Grace blindly and prompt them to either tie the vote or redirect suspicion to Charlie so we do not waste a mechanical check or hand initiative to evil.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I will be blunt: my Librarian read was Grace. If that is true she is the Butler Outsider, not a Minion or Demon β executing her wastes our shot. Do not split the vote on ghosts alone. Hold or tie this so we get a mechanical test tonight and sort contradictions tomorrow.
π§
Prevent an execution based solely on conflicting ghost claims; push living players to avoid splitting and force mechanical clarification at night, preserving town options.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Grace has been executed.
π
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
Night 4
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
π―
Eve
Eve made a choice.
π§
With only 3 players alive, killing anyone results in 2 players remaining which is an automatic evil victory. I'll kill Charlie since he has confirmed Librarian information that could be problematic if he survives to challenge me.
π
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
You chose to kill Charlie.
π
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied