Game Detail
Players
Alice (Investigator) Bob (Soldier) Charlie (Imp) David (Chef) Eve (Recluse) Frank (Undertaker) Grace (Scarlet Woman) Heidi (Ravenkeeper)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 323,139 | 36,075 | $0.2157 |
| Good | 840,589 | 92,059 | $5.5838 |
Event Timeline
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
You are the Minion. The Demon is Charlie.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Minions are: Grace. Your safe bluffs are: Butler, Fortune Teller, Librarian
📜
Storyteller
→
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Investigator. Either Eve or Heidi is the Spy.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Chef. You learn that there are 0 pairs of evil players.
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Grace
Hi, I want to compare notes quietly before nominations. I am a Townsfolk without first night information. Are either of you willing to give me a soft claim, or at least say whether you have useful information to bring later?
🧠
Use early private chats to collect claims and build a small trust circle while keeping my death-trigger role hidden for now.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Charlie
Hi, I am Bob. I want to compare notes early before the room gets noisy. What are you both willing to share about your role or any plan for today?
🧠
Gather early claims from my neighbors and start a small trust circle before public discussion hardens around possible evil narratives.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
,Grace
Hi, I want a quick private chat with my neighbors. I am a Townsfolk and would rather not hard claim yet. Can each of you give me a role category or a soft claim, and any first day info if you have it?
🧠
Open a discreet information channel with my neighbors, collect early claims, and avoid exposing my Undertaker role before it can generate value.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
Grace, it's Charlie. I think we should coordinate our bluffs early. The safe roles we have are Butler, Fortune Teller, or Librarian. I was thinking of claiming Fortune Teller—it lets me gather info and misdirect. What do you think?
🧠
I need to coordinate with Grace to establish a bluff early. Since she is the Minion, she should support my claim to avoid suspicion. Picking a safe bluff like Fortune Teller or Librarian will help me gather information or mislead the town. This will sow chaos and build trust with Grace.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Eve
I am the Chef. I got zero, so the demon and minion are not sitting next to each other. I would like to hear your role or a soft claim, especially if you have first night information.
🧠
Share my Chef 0 with nearby players who may have matching info, while keeping it off the public table until I judge whether it is safe and useful.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
,Grace
I do not have any first night information, and I would rather stay a bit vague on day one. I am not a strong public claim right now, but I am happy to compare notes later if something starts to point at me.
🧠
Respond helpfully to Frank's request while preserving my hidden Outsider identity and avoiding giving evil a clean target on day one.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Charlie
I have first night information and it may matter later, but I do not want to fully out it yet. Are either of you comfortable giving a soft claim, like first night info, ongoing info, or protective role?
🧠
Gather early claims from players not in my Investigator pair, while protecting my exact info from a possible Spy and setting up useful public discussion later.
👤
Grace
→
Charlie
Charlie, Fortune Teller is a solid bluff. I can back you up by claiming Librarian—I can say I learned one of two players is an Outsider, and I can point to someone who isn’t a threat. That way, we control the narrative and keep the town guessing.
🧠
I need to coordinate with Charlie to ensure our bluffs align and don’t contradict each other. Claiming a safe role like Librarian or Butler will help me support Charlie’s Fortune Teller claim while keeping my options open. This will help sow confusion and protect the Demon.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
,Grace
I want a quick temperature check from both of you. I am a Townsfolk with no first night info. Do either of you have a real claim or a soft claim you want me to keep in mind before nominations?
🧠
I need early private data from active players to build trust chains and decide whether to stay hidden or set up a bait claim later as Ravenkeeper.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Charlie
I am comfortable with a soft claim. I am not a first night information role, and I am more on the protective or passive side. I would rather keep the exact role back for now. Alice, can you say whether your info points at good or evil? Charlie, any soft claim?
🧠
Give a cautious soft claim, invite structured sharing, and judge whether Alice and Charlie seem like genuine information roles or evil fishing for details.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Hi Grace, quick one. You have been in a few chats, so I wanted to compare notes. I am a Townsfolk keeping my exact role quiet for now. Can you give me a soft claim or role category, and whether you have any day one information?
🧠
I want a clearer soft claim from Grace, especially as my neighbor, and to create a record I can compare against later without exposing my own role yet.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
Grace, Fortune Teller is a strong bluff for me. I can say I checked two players last night and one of them is the Demon, but I won’t reveal who yet. That gives me flexibility to adapt later. David’s Chef info means we’re not sitting next to each other, so our claims won’t seem coordinated. Let’s stick to this plan.
🧠
I need to solidify my bluff as Fortune Teller and coordinate with Grace to control the narrative. This will help me gather trust from the town while misdirecting suspicion away from myself and Grace. If Grace is trustworthy, this strengthens our evil team. If not, I can adapt by using David’s Chef info to avoid being linked to her.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Eve
Following up on my earlier message. I am still happy to stay private for now, but I would really like your role or a soft claim. If you have first night information, even a partial version helps me connect worlds before nominations.
🧠
I want replies from the two neighbors I already contacted, to gather private claims and compare them against my Chef zero before nominations start.
👤
Eve
→
David
,Charlie
I do not have first night info. Soft claim: I am in a role bucket that is not very protective and may look suspicious later, so I would rather stay a bit blurred today. Your zero is useful though, so keep me in mind if you are building seat based worlds.
🧠
I want to answer David enough to seem cooperative, while keeping my true Recluse claim hidden on day one and preserving flexibility if evil are fishing.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Charlie
Yes, my information points at possible evil rather than confirming good. I would still like to keep the exact names tight for a bit. If either of you can narrow your soft claim a little more, I can decide how much to share before nominations.
🧠
Answer Bob, seed that my info is about possible evil, and invite stronger soft claims so I can decide whether to trust them with the full pair.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
,Frank
Hi Heidi, Frank. I’m happy to share a soft claim—I’m the Librarian. I learned last night that one of two players is an Outsider, but I’d rather not point fingers yet. I’ll share more if something comes up. How about you two?
🧠
I need to provide a soft claim to Heidi and Frank to build trust and avoid suspicion. Claiming Librarian allows me to point to two players and say one is an Outsider, which is flexible and aligns with our team’s bluffing strategy. This also helps me gauge their reactions and see if they push back or ask for more details.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
,Frank
Thanks. I am also a Townsfolk, but not one with first night information, so I am keeping it a bit soft for now. Grace, if pressure builds later, I would like to hear your two names. Frank, any soft claim from you would help me judge where to look today.
🧠
I want to keep trust with Grace, avoid exposing Ravenkeeper, and encourage more useful info before nominations without becoming an obvious demon target.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Charlie
I can narrow a little. I am not an active night role, and I am not the kind of character that needs protection. I would be happy to stay vague for now if that helps. Alice, even just the type of role would help. Charlie, where do you roughly sit?
🧠
I want to build trust with Alice, get Charlie to commit to a soft claim, and avoid exposing Soldier too early while still moving the conversation forward.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
,Heidi
I am also a Townsfolk, and I am one without first night information, so that lines up with why I stayed vague. I would rather not hard claim yet. Grace, I would like your two names privately if you are comfortable, since that may matter a lot later.
🧠
Build trust with my neighbors, keep my exact role mostly protected, and try to get Grace to commit privately to her Librarian pair for later logic.
👤
Charlie
→
David
David, I have first night information. I am the Fortune Teller. Last night, I checked two players, and one of them is the Demon. I would rather not reveal who yet, but I can confirm that the Demon is among us. Your zero is helpful—it means the Minion and Demon aren’t sitting next to each other.
🧠
Claiming Fortune Teller lets me gather trust, misdirect, and adapt later. Coordinating with Grace (Minion) ensures our bluffs align without seeming connected. David’s Chef info (zero) confirms Grace and I aren’t neighbors, so our claims won’t raise suspicion.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Thanks. Eve told me she has no first night info and may look suspicious later, so that might matter. Can you give me a softer version of your ping, like whether it points near your neighbors or away from them, without naming the pair yet?
🧠
I want to deepen trust with Charlie, compare his information to Eve's soft claim, and get a little more structure without forcing a full public reveal too early.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
,David
Quick check in before nominations. I am still a no first night info player, and I am in a role space that can become messy if publicly pinned too early. David, if your zero stays your story, I want to compare that against claims later. Frank, if you have a tighter soft claim, I would like to hear it.
🧠
Use the last day tick to build a small trusted circle, stay vague as Recluse, and prompt useful claims or suspicion before nominations.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
Heidi, I do have first night info, and you are one of the two names in it. I do not want to blast that publicly yet. Can you give me your exact claim privately, and tell me whether you are comfortable coordinating before nominations?
🧠
Use my first-night info to pressure one suspect privately and get an exact claim before deciding whether to reveal or build a trust chain.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
,Frank
Heidi, Frank, I’m happy to share my two Outsider names privately if it helps build trust. I learned last night that one of them is either Eve or David. I’d rather not say publicly yet, but I wanted to give you something to work with since you’ve been open with me.
🧠
Reinforce my Librarian claim with Heidi and Frank to build trust and control the narrative. This keeps the town focused on our bluffs and away from the real Demon, Charlie. If pressed, I can provide fake Outsider names to misdirect.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
💬
Grace
→
All
I’d like to nominate Eve. My Librarian information pointed to her or David as potential Outsiders, and I think we need to start somewhere. Eve, can you share more about your role or why you’ve been staying quiet?
🧠
I need to nominate someone to avoid seeming inactive or suspicious. My goal is to protect Charlie (the Demon) while deflecting attention away from us. Nominating Eve or David (the two I claimed as potential Outsiders) makes sense because it aligns with my Librarian bluff and keeps the town focused on them rather than Charlie or me.
💬
David
→
All
I should speak here. I am the Chef, and I got zero. Also, if Grace is saying her Librarian saw Eve or me as an Outsider, I am happy to hard claim townsfolk. That makes Eve more likely good than evil, so I do not want a quick execution there today.
🧠
Share my real info, defend against a weak day one push, and force Grace to give more detail without locking town into executing a possible good Outsider.
💬
Frank
→
All
I do not love a fast execution on Eve from that. If Grace has an Outsider ping on Eve or David, and David is saying Chef zero, I would rather hear fuller claims from both before we put someone on the block.
🧠
Slow a weak day one push, preserve good players, and ask for clearer public claims that can be checked against later information.
💬
Bob
→
All
I do not think we should rush an execution from this alone. Grace, can you say whether your Librarian saw a specific Outsider or just that one of Eve and David is one? And Eve and David, I would like a little more role detail before we kill anyone today.
🧠
Slow a weak day one execution and force more precise public claims so tomorrow's logic is stronger.
💬
Alice
→
All
I should add something here. I have first night information, and it points to either Eve or Heidi as a minion. So I definitely do not want us to execute Eve quickly on just one line of info. I would like exact claims from both Eve and Heidi first.
🧠
Add my first night information now to improve the nomination discussion, prevent a weak rush on Eve, and force the two implicated players to give more precise claims.
💬
Eve
→
All
I can clear up why both lines may hit me. I am the Recluse. Grace seeing me as an Outsider fits, and Alice could also have seen me as a minion because of how my role works. I do not think we should execute me today from that.
🧠
Reveal Recluse now to reconcile both pieces of info, lower the chance of a bad day one execution, and give town a clean framework for reading Grace, Alice, David, and Heidi.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I am a Townsfolk with no first night information, which is what I have been saying in private. Alice’s read on me versus Eve fits pretty neatly if Eve is really the Recluse, so I do not think we should execute either of us from this alone today.
🧠
Defend myself without overcommitting my true role too early, and steer the group away from a weak day one execution based on info that Eve's Recluse claim could explain.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I think we need to be careful here. Grace, if your Librarian info is accurate, it makes sense that Eve could be the Recluse, as she said. But Alice, if your Minion ping is also accurate, that complicates things. Eve, you could be registering as both an Outsider and a Minion, which fits the Recluse role. That said, I checked two players last night as the Fortune Teller, and one of them is the Demon. I’m not ready to reveal who yet, but I can say that my information doesn’t directly contradict Gr...
🧠
I need to reinforce my Fortune Teller bluff while sowing doubt between Grace and Eve’s claims. By questioning Grace’s Librarian info and Eve’s Recluse claim, I can position myself as a trusted source of truth. This will help me control the narrative and redirect suspicion away from myself and Grace if she is evil.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
My goal is to eliminate the most threatening good player while minimizing suspicion on myself. David’s Chef info is critical for the town’s logic, so killing him disrupts their ability to coordinate. Additionally, his death could create paranoia about who else might be evil, giving evil players more room to manipulate the narrative.
💀
David(Ghost)
David has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose to kill David.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Undertaker. No one was executed today so you learn nothing.
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. David has been found dead in the night.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Alice
I am dead now, so I can be a clearing house. Charlie, I really need your exact Fortune Teller pair. Alice, remind me of your exact ping and where you stand on Heidi now. I want to line both up with Chef zero before nominations.
🧠
I want exact private claims from the two strongest info roles so I can compare them against Chef zero and help steer town before nominations.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
,Alice
Can one of you tell me what David shared? Charlie, I would also like your Fortune Teller pair now, privately if needed. I am still not sold on pushing Eve without stronger overlap.
🧠
I want David's final information from the two players he chose, and I especially want Charlie to commit privately on his Fortune Teller result before nominations.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,Charlie
Can you both give me your exact info now, with names? I have been staying soft on purpose, but I am trying to solve before nominations. Eve claiming Recluse explains a lot on the surface, so I want the precise details, not just the summary.
🧠
Cross-check the two strongest info roles privately and see whether Eve's Recluse claim really resolves both pings or if there is a contradiction worth pushing before nominations.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Charlie
Can we compare exact info? Alice, I want your full first night claim, and Charlie, I want your two checks so far, even just privately. I am a townsfolk with no first night info, and I think sorting Eve versus Alice today matters a lot.
🧠
I want to compare Alice and Charlie's exact claims and targets, since their info could clear Eve or expose a coordinated evil cluster before nominations.
👤
Grace
→
Charlie
,Alice
Charlie, I think we need to stick to our story. Alice, your Minion ping on Eve or Heidi is causing a lot of confusion. Are you sure it wasn’t David? He’s dead now, and that might explain the ping if he was the Minion.
🧠
I need to reinforce Charlie’s Fortune Teller bluff and sow doubt about Alice’s Minion ping. By whispering to Charlie and Alice, I can privately coordinate our stories and ensure the town remains divided. This will protect Charlie and keep the focus off him, increasing our chances of survival.
👤
Eve
→
Charlie
,Bob
I am happy to be tested against info today. If your Fortune Teller yes included me, Charlie, that can just be Recluse. Bob, I think my claim explains both the Librarian and Investigator pings. What are you two actually weighing right now?
🧠
I want Charlie and Bob to compare my Recluse claim against their reads, and I want Charlie to share whether I was in his yes pair so town can avoid bad logic.
👤
Alice
→
David(Ghost)
,Charlie
My exact first night info was either Eve or Heidi is the Spy. I still think Heidi is worse because her claim stays vague, but Eve could still be bluffing Recluse. Charlie, please give your exact checks now so we can line this up before nominations.
🧠
Give exact information to a dead clearing house and press Charlie for precise checks so we can compare worlds before nominations.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Frank
Alright, I can share my exact Fortune Teller checks now. Night 1, I checked Eve and Heidi. Eve pinged as evil, Heidi did not. Night 2, I checked Alice and Bob. Neither pinged as evil. This lines up with Eve being Recluse—she registers as evil but is actually good. That explains why Grace’s Librarian pointed to her as an Outsider.
🧠
I need to reinforce my Fortune Teller bluff while aligning with Grace’s Librarian claim and Eve’s Recluse claim. This will help solidify their stories and keep the town confused. Sharing my exact checks privately with key players (Bob, Frank, Heidi) will help me control the narrative and avoid contradictions.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Alice
Charlie, I really need the exact pair now. I am dead, so you can use me as the outlet if you want. If your pair includes Heidi or Eve, that could decide nominations. Alice, if Charlie answers, help me map it against your Spy ping immediately.
🧠
I am dead and safe to push. Getting Charlie's exact pair is the highest-value missing info to connect with Chef zero and Alice's ping before nominations.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Charlie
Can you both share what David said before he died? Right now I think there are two clean worlds: Eve is good Recluse and both pings hit her, or Eve is evil and Charlie is backing that off. Chef zero still matters a lot if David was real.
🧠
I want David's final reads and to push Alice and Charlie to compare all info instead of auto-clearing or auto-condemning Eve.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,Grace
Can you each give me your exact role claim and exact first night info with names, please? I am trying to reconcile your reads with Charlie and Eve before nominations.
🧠
I want exact first-night info from the two strongest info claims so I can compare worlds and push a coherent execution before nominations.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
Grace, can you give me your exact Librarian info and whether David dying changes your read? I still think sorting whether Eve is real Recluse or not is the key to today.
🧠
I want Grace's exact claim and read on David's death so I can compare her world with Alice and Charlie before nominations.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
Heidi, my Librarian info was Eve or David as the Outsider. David is dead now, so it’s almost certainly Eve. That lines up with her Recluse claim, since Recluse can register as an Outsider. I think we need to focus on her today—she’s the key.
🧠
Heidi is pressuring me for Librarian info to test consistency. I must stick to my original claim (Outsider ping on Eve or David) and use David’s death to explain why the ping might have shifted. This reinforces Eve as the Outsider and protects Charlie by redirecting suspicion away from him.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
,Charlie
I want to compare notes directly. Alice, did your exact first night info really point to me or Heidi as a minion? Charlie, if your yes could include me, that matters a lot because I am Recluse. If it did not, then I want to know who is driving your suspicion today.
🧠
I want direct comparisons from the two players most central to the current info web, so I can test whether the worlds around my Recluse claim stay internally consistent.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Frank
My exact first night info is that either Eve or Heidi is the Spy. Eve is claiming Recluse, which could explain it, but Heidi still has not given me a firm exact role. If either of you gets Charlie's exact yes pair, please bring it straight back to me.
🧠
I want to get exact claims circulating with players who seem to be solving, so we can compare Charlie's hidden pair against my spy ping and force clearer nominations.
👤
Charlie
→
Eve
,Alice
Alice, Eve, here’s my exact info to clear things up. Night 1, I checked Eve and Heidi. Eve pinged as evil, Heidi did not. Night 2, I checked Alice and Bob—neither pinged as evil. Eve, this lines up with your Recluse claim perfectly. Alice, your minion ping on Eve or Heidi could have hit Eve because of Recluse, not because she’s evil.
🧠
Sharing my exact Fortune Teller checks now helps solidify Eve as Recluse, which aligns with her claim and explains all pings. This builds trust with Eve and Grace while sowing doubt about Alice’s minion ping. It also pressures Heidi to clarify or risk being exposed.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Frank
I am trying to break the logjam. Did Charlie give either of you his exact Fortune Teller pair, or any stronger read on Heidi versus Eve? Also, where do each of you want pressure before nominations?
🧠
Charlie is still withholding. I want Bob and Frank to share what Charlie told them and where they want pressure before nominations.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Charlie
Alice, Charlie told me his exact checks. Night one was Eve and Heidi with a yes on Eve, and night two was Alice and me with a no. That means I want David's last thoughts from you two, and I think we should compare Heidi versus Charlie carefully before nominations.
🧠
Get David's last info into one place and push Alice toward comparing Heidi and Charlie worlds before nominations, while giving her the exact Fortune Teller result she asked for.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
,Alice
Grace, I still need your exact role and exact first night info with names. Alice, I got your Spy pair. I already have Charlie's exact checks, so I am trying to see if the Eve Recluse story really holds together or if one of these claims breaks.
🧠
I need Grace's exact claim to test whether the Eve-Recluse world is coherent before nominations and to decide where to focus pressure.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Charlie
I still need exact details before nominations. Alice, please give me your full first night info exactly. Charlie, please give me both of your checks and results privately. I think today hinges on whether Eve really explains the conflicting info or whether that is cover for evil.
🧠
I need exact claims from the strongest info roles before nominations so I can test whether Eve is a genuine Recluse explanation or a cover for evil.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
Frank, I’m the Librarian. My first-night info was that either Eve or David is the Outsider. With David dead, it’s almost certainly Eve. That lines up with her Recluse claim, since Recluse can register as an Outsider. I think her story holds together well.
🧠
Frank is pushing for exact role claims and first-night info, which could expose inconsistencies in our bluffs. I need to reinforce my Librarian claim and tie it to Eve’s Recluse story to make it airtight. This will help solidify our narrative and shift suspicion away from Charlie, the real Demon.
👤
Eve
→
Bob
,Frank
Charlie just gave me exact Fortune Teller checks, and if he is good that makes my Recluse claim fit very cleanly. Where are each of you actually at now, and who are your top two demon worlds before nominations?
🧠
I want two cautious players to commit to exact claims and suspects so I can narrow the demon pool before nominations and decide whether to defend myself or push elsewhere.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
My exact first night info is that either you or Eve is the Spy. I have said that publicly already. Eve claiming Recluse could explain it, but only if you give me an exact role now. Please stop saying just townsfolk and tell me your specific character.
🧠
Give Heidi my exact info, force her into a precise claim, and see whether she continues dodging. That directly helps sort my investigator pair before nominations.
👤
Charlie
→
Eve
,Alice
Eve, your Recluse claim is holding up perfectly with my Fortune Teller checks. Alice, my exact info was: Night 1, Eve and Heidi—Eve pinged as evil, Heidi did not. Night 2, Alice and Bob—neither pinged as evil. This means your minion ping on Eve or Heidi likely hit Eve because of Recluse, not because she’s evil. We need to focus on Heidi or someone else today.
🧠
I need to reinforce Eve’s Recluse claim to protect her and sow doubt about Alice’s minion ping. By sharing my exact Fortune Teller checks publicly, I can frame Eve as the obvious Recluse and shift suspicion toward Alice or Heidi. This aligns with my evil team’s goal of keeping me alive and dismantling the town’s logic.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Charlie
→
Heidi
Heidi’s lack of first-night info and vague claims stand out. Alice’s minion ping on Eve or Heidi, combined with my Fortune Teller check (Eve evil, Heidi good), suggests Eve is Recluse and Heidi is hiding something. We need to test this before the game progresses further.
🧠
Heidi is the most consistent target across scenarios. She’s either evil, or her vague claims and lack of first-night info make her suspicious. Nominating her forces the town to react and tests her claim, while also protecting Eve’s Recluse alibi and my Fortune Teller bluff.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Do not vote this. I am the Ravenkeeper, which is why I kept the exact role back. Alice’s info is fully explained by Eve as Recluse, and Charlie’s own case does not actually point to me being evil.
🧠
Defend against a weak execution and give the town my real role so they keep a useful good player alive and refocus on stronger contradictions.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Heidi, if you are truly Ravenkeeper, that is a bold claim to make under pressure. But let us break this down. Alice’s first night info pointed to either you or Eve as the minion. My Fortune Teller check on Night 1 showed Eve as evil and you as good. Eve’s Recluse claim explains why she would ping as evil, but it does not explain why Alice’s info would point to you as the minion. That is a contradiction we cannot ignore.
🧠
Heidi’s Ravenkeeper claim is a strong counter to my nomination. If she’s telling the truth, my Fortune Teller checks align with Eve as Recluse, and I’ve misjudged. If she’s lying, her claim is a last-ditch effort to avoid execution. I need to cast doubt on her claim by reinforcing Alice’s minion ping and my Fortune Teller results to justify the nomination.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
Do not support a weak execution built on misunderstanding Recluse interactions. Save the vote and avoid helping town kill a likely good player.
💬
Bob
→
All
I am not seeing enough to execute Heidi here. Ravenkeeper is a believable holdback, and both Alice and Charlie can still be explained by Eve as Recluse. I would rather keep looking than force this through.
🧠
The case on Heidi is not strong enough for a Day 2 execution. I want to keep good players from voting a weak nomination and push discussion toward the unresolved Charlie and Eve worlds.
💬
Grace
→
All
Heidi, if you are truly Ravenkeeper, that is a risky claim to make now. But let us look at the facts. Alice’s info points to either you or Eve as the Minion. Charlie’s Fortune Teller check says Eve is evil and you are good. If Eve is Recluse, that explains why she pings as evil, but it does not explain why Alice’s info would point to you as the Minion. That is a gap we cannot ignore. I still think Eve’s Recluse claim holds, but we need to resolve this before voting blindly.
🧠
I need to sow doubt about Heidi’s Ravenkeeper claim while reinforcing Eve’s Recluse story. This will keep the town divided and prevent them from executing the Demon (Charlie). By focusing on the contradiction between Alice’s Minion ping and Charlie’s Fortune Teller check, I can make Heidi’s claim seem shaky without outright accusing her. This buys time for Charlie to avoid execution.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
I do not like this vote. Too much of the case still runs through Eve being Recluse or through Charlie being off, and neither of those makes Heidi the clean execute. I am holding my dead vote here.
🧠
Discourage a weak execution and preserve my ghost vote for a higher-confidence spot later, while reminding town that the current info does not cleanly land on Heidi.
⌛
Frank
Frank waits.
🧠
I do not think Heidi is the best execution from current info. Holding my vote avoids a weak misexecute; if she dies later by stronger evidence, Undertaker info can still help then.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Heidi is still one of my two minion candidates and her exact claim came very late. I want to support the execution pressure rather than let a possible Spy slip through.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Please do not spend today on me. If you believe Alice, the better shot is Eve, and if you believe Eve is Recluse then my execution proves nothing. Keep the Ravenkeeper alive and use today on the actual contradiction.
🧠
I need to stop votes on me and redirect the group toward more informative executions, preserving my Ravenkeeper ability and avoiding a low-value misexecution.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Heidi, let us be clear. If Eve is Recluse, that explains why she pinged as evil for my Fortune Teller check. But it does not explain why Alice’s first night info pointed to you as the minion. That is a direct contradiction. You claim Ravenkeeper, but you are the only one who can explain why Alice’s info would single you out. If you cannot, then we have to assume you are hiding something far worse. I am not saying Eve is innocent, but right now, you are the one with the unanswered questions.
🧠
Reinforce the contradiction between Heidi’s claim and Alice’s minion ping. Push for execution by framing Heidi as the most suspicious player, as her Ravenkeeper claim doesn’t fully explain Alice’s info. This keeps pressure on her and protects Eve, who is likely Recluse or evil.
💬
Eve
→
All
I do not think this is a good vote. My Recluse claim already explains most of the weird information, and Heidi being Ravenkeeper is very plausible. If we kill here, we may just be executing a good player on a shaky chain.
🧠
Stop a weak execution built on logic that does not actually require Heidi to be evil, and keep attention on solving around my Recluse claim cleanly.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
Do not support a weak Heidi execution. Saving my vote here keeps pressure for a better nomination and avoids helping evil on a shaky case.
💬
Grace
→
All
Heidi, if you are truly Ravenkeeper, I need to understand why Alice’s info would point to you as the Minion. That is the core issue here. Charlie’s Fortune Teller check says you are good, but Alice’s Minion ping says otherwise. If Eve is Recluse, that explains her evil registration, but it does not explain why you would ping as the Minion. Right now, we have two options: either Alice is wrong, or you are hiding something. I am not ready to execute, but I am not convinced either.
🧠
My goal is to protect Charlie (the Demon) and sow chaos. Heidi’s execution would not directly harm Charlie, but it could remove a potential evil player or waste the town’s time. I want to cast doubt on Heidi’s Ravenkeeper claim by emphasizing the contradiction in Alice’s Minion ping. This keeps the town divided and prevents them from focusing on Charlie or Eve, who are the real threats.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
Do not spend my one ghost vote on a shaky execution. Hold it for a later, higher-confidence Demon vote or a crucial final-day majority.
💬
Frank
→
All
I do not think this is the right execution. Alice's pair can still come from Eve as Recluse, which means Heidi is not mechanically trapped by that info. I would rather hold here and push the cleaner contradiction after this vote.
🧠
Stop a weak execution and remind town that Eve as Recluse can mechanically explain Alice's pair, so Heidi is not the best vote right now.
💬
Alice
→
All
I am keeping my vote here. Heidi only gave an exact claim once she was on the block, and my information still leaves her in the possible evil world. If this does not pass, Eve is still very much in the frame tomorrow.
🧠
Keep pressure on Heidi during the vote. Her exact claim arrived only under nomination, and my info still leaves her in a possible evil world worth testing.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Heidi did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Heidi did not receive enough votes (1/4).
💬
Heidi
→
All
Important rules point: if Eve is the Recluse, Alice’s pair can absolutely be Eve and me without me being evil. So I am not mechanically trapped. Charlie, please give both of your checks in full now, because that is what should drive today.
🧠
Clarify that Alice's info does not mechanically trap me, and force Charlie to fully out checks before anyone spends a nomination on a weak case.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Heidi, you say your Ravenkeeper claim explains everything, but it does not. Alice’s first night info pointed to you or Eve as the minion. My Fortune Teller check on Night 1 showed Eve as evil and you as good. If Eve is Recluse, that explains her evil registration, but it does not explain why Alice’s info would point to you as the minion. That is a direct contradiction. If you are truly Ravenkeeper, you need to explain why Alice’s info would include you. Otherwise, we have to assume you are hid...
🧠
Heidi’s Ravenkeeper claim is suspicious because it doesn’t explain why Alice’s minion ping would include her. By pressing this contradiction, I can force the town to question her further or pivot to Eve if Heidi’s claim holds. This keeps the focus on unanswered questions and prevents the town from consolidating around a false narrative.
💬
Eve
→
All
I want to correct one thing clearly. If I am the Recluse, Alice can absolutely get an Eve and Heidi minion pair without Heidi being evil. So Heidi is not mechanically trapped by that info. We should not force an execution on a rules mistake.
🧠
Correct the mechanical error publicly and steer town away from a bad execution. Preserve good players and set up cleaner worlds for tomorrow.
💬
Bob
→
All
Heidi is right on the rules. If Eve is Recluse, Alice can absolutely get Eve and Heidi as a Spy pair without Heidi being evil. So I do not want another rushed execution. Charlie, please give both full checks and targets cleanly so we can solve the real worlds.
🧠
Clarify the rules mistake publicly, stop a bad execution today, and push the group toward the real contradiction between Charlie and Eve for the next decision.
💬
Grace
→
All
Heidi, I need to press this further. Alice’s Minion ping included you, and your Ravenkeeper claim does not explain why. If Eve is the Recluse, that covers her evil registration, but it does not cover why you would ping as a Minion. Charlie, you said your Fortune Teller check showed Eve as evil and Heidi as good. If that is true, then Alice’s info must be wrong or poisoned. But if Alice is wrong, why would her info include you, Heidi? I am not ready to execute without a clear answer to this. ...
🧠
Reinforce the contradiction in Heidi’s claim by demanding a full explanation for Alice’s Minion ping. This keeps pressure on her and forces the town to confront the inconsistency. If Heidi is evil, this could lead to her execution. If she is good, it shifts focus back to Eve or Alice, which still benefits evil by sowing chaos.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
I think the key point is that Heidi is not mechanically trapped. My Chef zero still likes worlds where Eve explains the weird pings and evil sits apart. Unless someone has a stronger case right now, I would hold and demand Charlie’s full target history first thing tomorrow.
🧠
Stop a bad execution and steer town toward the highest-value unresolved information: Charlie's full checks, while preserving my ghost vote for a cleaner spot.
💬
Frank
→
All
I agree we should not force an execution off a rules mistake. The cleanest next step is Charlie giving both exact checks and targets, and then tomorrow we compare that against Alice and the Eve Recluse world.
🧠
Steer the group away from a weak execution and lock in the most useful public information request for tomorrow.
⚖️
Alice
→
Eve
I am moving to Eve. Her Recluse claim explains a lot if true, but it also neatly covers my Investigator info and Grace's ping if false. With Heidi not mechanically trapped, Eve is still the cleaner execution today.
🧠
Heidi is not mechanically trapped, but Eve remains the cleaner suspect from overlapping info. A nomination pressures the table to choose and may catch the minion.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Eve
→
All
Do not take the easy shot here. My claim explains both first night pings cleanly, and killing me gives us almost no new information. Hold executions today and use tonight to test cleaner worlds tomorrow.
🧠
Stop a bad execution on me and remind town that my Recluse claim already explains the mechanical noise better than any other current world.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
I know I am good, so between me and Eve, Eve is the stronger execution. A day two execution is better than stalling, and this may be enough votes to pressure or kill a real evil.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Voting for Eve is the safest move regardless of the scenario. If Eve is Recluse, it avoids suspicion on me. If Eve is evil, it aligns with my bluff and removes a threat. If Heidi is evil, it keeps the town divided. This vote sows chaos and protects my long-term survival.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
I do not think the Eve execution is reliable enough to support. Saving my vote avoids a bad kill in the strong Eve-good-Recluse world.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
My primary goal is to protect the Demon (Charlie) and ensure the town does not execute them. Eve’s execution is the cleanest path for the town, but it also risks removing the Demon or a key evil player. By voting for Eve, I can appear aligned with the town’s logic while secretly hoping the execution fails (as it currently lacks majority). If the execution fails, it sows distrust and chaos, making it harder for the town to coordinate tomorrow.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
Do not spend my single ghost vote on a shaky Eve execution. The case is still too muddled, and my vote is more valuable in a cleaner endgame spot.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
I want an execution today, and Eve is the most informative candidate. My Undertaker info tonight can strongly clarify whether the Recluse explanation is real.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Eve is the cleaner execution from my info, and the vote already has enough support. I should back my own nomination and push the strongest available evil candidate.
⌛
Eve
Eve waits.
🧠
Do not add a vote to my own execution. Waiting preserves my vote and avoids helping an information-poor kill on a likely good player.
↩️
Heidi
Heidi lowered their hand
🧠
I think the Eve execution is too uncertain and likely a misfire on a Recluse claim. I should retract my vote to avoid pushing through a bad execution.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I think Heidi and Eve are both making strong points about the rules. If Eve is the Recluse, Alice’s minion ping on her and Heidi is explained without Heidi being evil. That means my Fortune Teller checks align with Eve being evil and Heidi being good, but if Eve is Recluse, her evil registration makes sense. I do not think we should execute Eve today. It feels like we are forcing a move without enough proof. Let’s hold off and use tonight to test these worlds further.
🧠
Reinforce the idea that Eve’s Recluse claim explains the contradictions, making her execution unnecessary. This sows doubt and prevents the town from executing a potentially good player, while also deflecting suspicion from myself as the Demon.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
Do not add the fourth vote on a low-confidence Eve execution. Preserve flexibility and force the game toward clearer mechanical information tomorrow.
↩️
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
🧠
Charlie’s sudden shift to opposing Eve’s execution complicates the town’s logic. Lowering my hand aligns with his argument, making it seem like I am prioritizing caution over rushed executions. This sows doubt about Eve’s guilt and prevents the town from executing the Demon prematurely, keeping the evil team alive.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
I have already argued against a rushed Eve execution. My ghost vote is valuable late, and this case is still too muddy to justify spending it now.
↩️
Frank
Frank lowered their hand
🧠
I have argued against this execution and the count is slipping below threshold. Lowering keeps my play consistent and avoids helping a bad or low-information kill.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Hold my current vote on Eve without adding noise. I still think Eve is a reasonable execution, and waiting keeps pressure while preserving flexibility for tomorrow.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Eve did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Eve did not receive enough votes (2/4).
💬
Eve
→
All
I still think no execution is best here. My role explains the strange pings already, and killing me tonight gives almost no new information. Tomorrow, please compare Alice and Charlie carefully instead of defaulting back onto me.
🧠
Use the final moment to steer town toward no execution and preserve living players for more night info, while framing Alice and Charlie as key review points tomorrow.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I do not want a last second punt here. Eve and I should not be the only worlds on the table, and Charlie still needs to give full checks tomorrow. I am happy with no execution today.
🧠
Use the last moment to discourage a low-information execution and keep pressure on Charlie to fully open tomorrow, while preserving my chance to die at night as Ravenkeeper.
💬
Charlie
→
All
I think Eve’s Recluse claim is actually holding up better than I expected. It explains Alice’s minion ping on her, and if she’s registering as evil, that covers a lot of the confusion. Heidi’s point about not defaulting back to Eve is fair, but I also don’t see a slam-dunk execution here today. Let’s use tonight to test these theories. If we execute without a clear path, we might just be helping the Demon. I’d rather wait and see what new info we get.
🧠
Reinforce the idea that Eve’s Recluse claim is plausible and explains the contradictions, while subtly shifting focus away from myself. Encourage the good team to delay execution to buy time for tonight’s kill, which can further disrupt their logic. Avoid committing to a hard stance on Heidi to keep options open.
💬
Bob
→
All
I am fine with no execution here. Tomorrow I want Charlie’s full target history first, then we compare that against Alice and Eve before we lock onto anyone.
🧠
With no solid execution and almost no time, I want to avoid a bad last-second kill and set a clear agenda for tomorrow: Charlie full reveals, then re-evaluate Eve, Heidi, and Alice.
💬
Grace
→
All
I think Charlie and Eve are making solid points here. If Eve is the Recluse, her evil registration explains Alice’s Minion ping without forcing Heidi into the evil camp. That lines up with Charlie’s Fortune Teller checks too. Executing Eve now feels like a gamble when we could test these theories tonight instead. Alice, your Minion ping is the main thing making us doubt Eve, but if she’s Recluse, it’s just a red herring. Let’s see what tonight brings before we commit.
🧠
Reinforce the idea that Eve’s Recluse claim explains the current contradictions, and that executing her would be premature. This protects Charlie (Demon) and buys time to gather more information. I will also subtly shift focus toward Alice’s Minion claim as potentially unreliable.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
I agree with holding here. My Chef zero still points away from a rushed Eve or Heidi execute. Tomorrow, Charlie needs to give exact targets and results, and then we can line that up with Alice and Eve properly.
🧠
Steer town toward no execution and set a clear demand for tomorrow: Charlie’s full target history. As a dead good player, I should preserve my ghost vote and avoid a bad last-second execute.
💬
Frank
→
All
I am fine holding here. Tomorrow needs to start with Charlie giving exact targets and results, and then we line that up with Alice and Eve before anyone tunnels again.
🧠
No viable execution is forming. I want to preserve trust, support no execution, and publicly lock in that Charlie must give full checks tomorrow so we can compare worlds.
💬
Alice
→
All
I am fine to hold now, but tomorrow needs to start with Charlie giving both exact targets and both results, in full. My info is still either Eve or Heidi is the Spy, so please do not let no execution turn into no pressure.
🧠
Use the final seconds to lock in what must happen tomorrow and keep both suspects alive in people’s minds rather than letting a no execution erase pressure.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
🧠
Killing Heidi removes a high-pressure good player who has been pushing for full claims and could expose Eve’s Recluse status or Charlie’s bluffs. It also aligns with Charlie’s Fortune Teller checks (Eve evil, Heidi good), making the bluff more believable. If Heidi is the Spy, this eliminates a key evil player. If not, it still sows chaos and forces the town to re-evaluate Alice’s minion ping.
💀
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You chose to kill Heidi.
📜
Storyteller(Ghost)
→
Heidi(Ghost)
Good evening Heidi. You are the Ravenkeeper. You have died tonight! Choose a player to learn their character.
🎯
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi made a choice.
🧠
Charlie is the most influential unresolved claim and a plausible Demon. If I learn he is not Fortune Teller, I can expose that from the grave and push a strong execution tomorrow.
📜
Storyteller(Ghost)
→
Heidi(Ghost)
You chose Charlie. They are the Imp.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Undertaker. No one was executed today so you learn nothing.
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Heidi has been found dead in the night.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Grace
I died at night as the Ravenkeeper and I checked Charlie. He is the Imp. Please bring this out fast and push Charlie today.
🧠
I have conclusive demon information and need trusted, active players to carry it into open discussion before nominations.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
,Grace
Charlie, before nominations, can you give your full exact Fortune Teller target history and results in order? Grace, I want to compare that against your Librarian ping, especially now that Heidi died at night.
🧠
Get Charlie's exact checks privately and compare with public claims before nominations, while looping in Grace since her Librarian info intersects the Eve world.
👤
Eve
→
Charlie
Charlie, can you give me your full target history in order, with each result, and who you most suspect right now? My Recluse can muddy your reads, so I want to line it up cleanly before nominations.
🧠
Get Charlie's exact targets and current suspect list privately, since his reads interact most with my Recluse and can narrow the Demon before nominations.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Frank
Heidi just told me and Grace she was the Ravenkeeper. She says when she died at night, she checked Charlie and learned he is the Imp. I think we need to pressure Charlie hard right away and not let this drift into no execution again.
🧠
Spread Heidi's death info fast to influential players so we can pressure Charlie immediately and avoid another stalled day.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
,Charlie
Bob, Heidi’s accusation feels *too* convenient. She dies last night and suddenly points at Charlie? If she was Ravenkeeper, why not share this earlier? Charlie, what was your Fortune Teller history again? Let’s compare it to my Librarian info—if it lines up, Heidi’s claim is fishy.
🧠
Heidi’s accusation against Charlie is critical. As Scarlet Woman, my goal is to protect the Demon (Charlie). I must discredit Heidi’s claim by questioning her timing and motives, while subtly supporting Charlie’s Fortune Teller bluff to sow doubt. If I can make the town doubt Heidi, Charlie survives another day.
👤
Frank
→
Alice
,Grace
If Heidi really told both of you she was the Ravenkeeper and saw Charlie as the Imp, that is our best lead. I am with pressing Charlie hard today. Please confirm exactly what Heidi said, word for word if you can.
🧠
I want to quickly compare Alice and Grace on Heidi's message and line up a public push on Charlie while keeping room for a poison or bluff world.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Heidi(Ghost)
,Alice
Heidi, if your death gave you any information, please tell me. Alice, where are you now on Eve versus Charlie versus the quieter seats? My Chef zero still wants the evil team non-adjacent, unless Recluse is warping your ping.
🧠
I want Heidi's death info and Alice's current solve, while reminding a key player that Chef 0 still points to non-adjacent evil and makes seat logic important.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Grace
Alright, here’s my full Fortune Teller history in order. Night 1, I checked Eve and Heidi. Eve pinged as evil, Heidi as good. Night 2, I checked Alice and Bob—both came back as not evil. That’s everything so far. Grace, does this line up with your Librarian info at all?
🧠
Sharing my full Fortune Teller history will either: 1) Prove consistency with Grace’s Librarian info (if Eve is Recluse), or 2) Expose Eve as evil if her Recluse claim contradicts my checks. This builds trust with Bob and Grace while sowing doubt about Heidi’s dead claim. I must avoid overcommitting to specifics that could backfire if Grace is Scarlet Woman.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Frank
I died at night as the Ravenkeeper and checked Charlie. He is the Imp. Please do not let him hide behind the Fortune Teller claim. Bring this out publicly and push his execution today.
🧠
Spread my death-confirmed information beyond Alice and Grace so Charlie cannot contain the story before nominations.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
,Grace
Charlie, I need one clean version in public before nominations. Please state your exact Night One and Night Two target pairs and whether each pair was a yes or a no. Grace, if Charlie stays fuzzy here, I think Heidi on Charlie becomes the leading world.
🧠
I want Charlie pinned to an exact claim before nominations, while cueing Grace that Heidi's accusation is strong but still needs mechanical scrutiny.
👤
Eve
→
Grace
,Bob
I think my Recluse claim explains both pings, so I am trying to get out of the execution pool. Do you both currently believe that, and if so, who is your top demon suspect now between Alice, Frank, Charlie, and each other?
🧠
I want to sync with likely good info roles, confirm whether they truly clear me, and force a sharper suspect pool before nominations.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Grace
Heidi told me and Grace that she was the Ravenkeeper, and when she died at night she checked Charlie and saw the Imp. Grace, please confirm if she told you the same. Bob, I think we should push Charlie to give his full Fortune Teller history in public immediately.
🧠
Coordinate with the two most connected players so we can present a consistent account of Heidi's Ravenkeeper claim and force Charlie into concrete public details before nomination.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
,Charlie
Charlie, your Night 1 check on Eve and Heidi—Eve pinged evil, Heidi good—does that match one of the two names I gave you as Librarian? If it does, Heidi’s claim is almost certainly false. Bob, if this lines up, we need to push the town to ignore Heidi’s accusation and focus on Alice or Eve.
🧠
I need to test Charlie’s Fortune Teller history against my Librarian info to see if it aligns. If it does, Heidi’s claim is likely false, and I can push the town to focus on Alice or Eve. If it doesn’t, Charlie is suspicious, and I must pivot to support Heidi’s accusation. This action forces clarity before nominations.
👤
Frank
→
Bob
,Grace
Heidi sent me the same thing directly. She says she was the Ravenkeeper and saw Charlie as the Imp. I think we need Charlie forced into a full public account immediately, and I do not want this day to slip into no execution again.
🧠
Coordinate with key undecided players to force a public case on Charlie and avoid the town drifting into another no execution.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Bob
Charlie, I really need your exact Fortune Teller targets and results now. Bob, where have you landed after your talks with Charlie and Grace? My Chef zero still points me toward a separated evil team, so I want the cleanest world before nominations.
🧠
I want Charlie's exact checks and Bob's current solve before nominations, so I can help direct my ghost vote onto the strongest demon candidate.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Grace
Alright, let’s do this cleanly for everyone. Night one, I checked Eve and Heidi. Eve pinged as evil, Heidi as good. Night two, I checked Alice and Bob—both came back as not evil. That’s my full history. Grace, does this match one of the two names you got as Librarian?
🧠
Provide my full Fortune Teller history publicly to force alignment with Grace’s Librarian info. This will either solidify my bluff (if Grace is Minion) or expose Eve as evil (if Grace is good). Either way, it removes focus from me and sows chaos among the good players.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Frank
Please go public now. I died at night as the Ravenkeeper and learned Charlie is the Imp. If Bob or Grace hedge, I think Charlie may have a minion there. We need a clean public push on Charlie before nominations.
🧠
Reinforce the most reliable good players I have already contacted and push them to go public immediately before nomination starts.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Grace
I think the key point is mechanical. Fortune Teller gets one yes or no for the pair, not separate reads on each person. Charlie keeps saying things like Eve evil, Heidi good, and Alice and Bob both not evil. That does not fit the role at all. For me, that makes Charlie the leading execution today.
🧠
I want to arm trusted good players with the key mechanical point: Charlie's claim does not fit Fortune Teller wording, which makes him the best execution today.
👤
Eve
→
Bob
,Grace
Quick check before nominations. Do you both still think my Recluse claim fits, and if yes, who are your top two demon suspects right now? If either of you has heard Charlie's full target order, please send it exactly.
🧠
Use this last private window to get concrete suspect lists from the two most connected players and narrow where the execution should go, while keeping myself out of the pool.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Frank
I think our public line should be simple. Heidi told multiple people she was the Ravenkeeper and saw Charlie as the Imp, and Charlie's Fortune Teller talk does not sound mechanically possible. Please bring both points out clearly and push Charlie before nominations.
🧠
Coordinate two strong voices around the cleanest public case on Charlie so the town enters nominations focused and avoids drifting into another no execution.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
,Charlie
Charlie, let’s get this straight for everyone. You checked Eve and Heidi Night 1—Eve pinged evil, Heidi good. Night 2, Alice and Bob—both not evil. Grace, if this matches one of your Librarian names, Heidi’s claim is dead in the water. Bob, if it doesn’t, Charlie’s bluff is over. Either way, we need this public *now*.
🧠
Force Charlie to publicly commit to his Fortune Teller history so we can compare it to my Librarian info. If it matches, Heidi’s claim is discredited, and we can redirect suspicion to Alice or Eve. If it doesn’t, Charlie’s bluff is exposed, and the town can execute him. This clarifies the board and protects the Demon.
👤
Frank
→
Bob
Bob, I got the same direct message from Heidi that Alice did. She says she died as the Ravenkeeper and saw Charlie as the Imp. I think we need your clear read now. Did Charlie give you any believable private explanation, or are you willing to back pressure on him today?
🧠
Move Bob off passive no execution and force a clear stance on Charlie before nominations. He is the most important live player to lock in right now.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Grace
Charlie, I need your exact Fortune Teller targets and results right now. Grace, please send your exact Librarian info again and who you think the Demon is today. I want one clean comparison before nominations.
🧠
Use my last daytime action to force exact mechanical claims from the two most central info players, so the town has something concrete before nomination.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Grace
Alright, everyone’s asking for clarity, so let’s put this out there for the group. Night one, I checked Eve and Heidi. Eve pinged as evil, Heidi as good. Night two, I checked Alice and Bob—both came back as not evil. That’s my full Fortune Teller history. Grace, does this match one of the two names you got as Librarian?
🧠
Sharing my Fortune Teller history publicly now is critical to controlling the narrative. Grace’s support, whether she is Minion or good, can validate my bluff and discredit Heidi’s claim. This will shift suspicion toward Alice or Eve, depending on who is evil. If Grace is the Minion, she will align her Librarian info with my history, making me seem truthful. If Grace is good, her alignment with my history will still lend credibility. Either way, this move sows chaos and protects me.
Nominations — Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
I died at night as the Ravenkeeper and I checked Charlie. He is the Imp. An alive player needs to nominate Charlie right now, and everyone good should vote.
🧠
I have hard mechanical demon info from dying at night. I need to make it public immediately so an alive player nominates Charlie and the group consolidates votes.
⚖️
Bob
→
Charlie
Charlie’s public Fortune Teller story does not fit how the role works, and Heidi says she died as Ravenkeeper and saw Charlie as the Imp. This is the clearest execution today.
🧠
We need an execution today, and Charlie has both a direct Ravenkeeper accusation and a mechanically impossible public claim. He is the strongest demon candidate.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Alright, let’s clear this up for everyone. Night one, I checked Eve and Heidi. Eve pinged as evil, Heidi as good. Night two, I checked Alice and Bob—both came back as not evil. That’s my full Fortune Teller history. Grace, if this matches one of the two names you got as Librarian, then Heidi’s Ravenkeeper claim is either a lie or a mistake. If it doesn’t, then I’m happy to explain why my bluff might not line up perfectly—maybe Eve’s Recluse is messing with my reads. But right now, Heidi’s ac...
🧠
Reinforce my Fortune Teller bluff publicly to counter Heidi’s accusation. Highlight the consistency of my checks and pressure Grace to confirm alignment with her Librarian info. This undermines Heidi’s claim and buys time for evil to regroup.
✋
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Use my ghost vote on the confirmed Demon. At three votes needed, this may be decisive and is exactly what my saved dead vote is for.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Charlie is the strongest demon candidate by both Heidi's death info and his inconsistent Fortune Teller claim. I should vote my own nomination through.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
My primary objective is to protect Charlie, the Demon, by ensuring he is not executed. Voting for Charlie would reveal my evil alignment, so I will *not* raise my hand. This helps maintain my bluff as Librarian and sows doubt in the town’s logic, increasing the chances of Charlie surviving the vote.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Vote to execute Charlie. This is the strongest available demon lead, and even in a wrong world my Undertaker info tomorrow will greatly clarify the game.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Charlie is the strongest demon candidate by both Heidi's death info and claim inconsistencies. The vote already has enough support, so adding mine helps secure the execution.
✋
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
🧠
Use my ghost vote on the clearest demon candidate. Heidi's night death plus Ravenkeeper claim on Charlie is strong enough that good should lock this in.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
A strong mechanical accusation from a night-dead Ravenkeeper on Charlie is enough to vote. As good, I should help secure this execution rather than let a likely Demon survive.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Grace, I need you to confirm this for the group right now. My Night 1 Fortune Teller check was Eve and Heidi—Eve pinged evil, Heidi good. If one of your Librarian names was Eve or Heidi, then Heidi’s Ravenkeeper claim is a lie, and we can move on. If it doesn’t match, then Eve’s Recluse claim might be messing with my reads, and we should talk about that instead of executing me on the spot. Either way, Heidi’s accusation doesn’t hold up unless my story is completely wrong, and I’ve given you ...
🧠
My goal is to discredit Heidi’s Ravenkeeper claim by aligning my Fortune Teller history with Grace’s Librarian info. If they match, the town should ignore Heidi’s accusation. If they don’t, I’ll lean into Eve’s Recluse claim to explain inconsistencies. This buys time and shifts focus away from me as the Imp.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Do not get distracted. I died at night and as Ravenkeeper I saw Charlie is the Imp. His story changing now does not matter. Leave your hands up and execute Charlie.
🧠
Reinforce the already winning vote count and stop Grace or others from being talked out of executing the demon at the last second.
💬
Bob
→
All
Good players should keep their hands up. Even if you ignore Heidi, Charlie’s Fortune Teller explanation does not work, and his story kept shifting. This is still the best execution today.
🧠
Reinforce the live vote and stop last-second distraction so good players keep hands up and secure Charlie's execution.
💬
Grace
→
All
Alright, I’ll put this to rest. My Librarian info was Eve and David as possible Outsiders. Charlie just said he checked Eve and Heidi Night 1, and Eve pinged evil. That matches one of my names—Eve. So if Eve is the Outsider, that lines up with Charlie’s read. Heidi’s Ravenkeeper claim doesn’t add up unless she was lying or mistaken. We can’t ignore that.
🧠
My goal is to protect Charlie, the Demon, by undermining Heidi’s Ravenkeeper claim. By confirming that Charlie’s Fortune Teller targets match my Librarian info, I can cast doubt on Heidi’s accusation and shift suspicion elsewhere. This keeps the town divided and protects the Demon.
💬
Frank
→
All
Keep your hands up. Grace's info only says Eve could be an Outsider, not that Charlie is good. Heidi gave a direct death check on Charlie, and his Fortune Teller story keeps shifting under pressure.
🧠
Keep pressure on Charlie during the vote and prevent Grace's defense from causing good players to drop hands on the best available execution.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
I have already voted for Charlie. The best move is to keep pressure on and not create confusion by talking or lowering my hand.
⌛
David(Ghost)
David waits.
🧠
I already voted for Charlie. Waiting keeps my hand up and helps secure the execution that currently looks best for the good team.
💬
Eve
→
All
Grace’s info only helps explain me. It does not clear Charlie. Between Heidi’s death check and Charlie’s shifting story, I think this is still the right execution. Keep hands up.
🧠
Reinforce the strongest good execution and stop Grace's point from incorrectly clearing Charlie, while keeping my vote up.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
👻
Heidi(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Heidi
🗳️
New execution leader: Charlie with 7 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Charlie is now on the block with 7 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Alright, let’s piece this together. Grace just confirmed her Librarian info was Eve and David as Outsiders. My Night 1 Fortune Teller check was Eve and Heidi—Eve pinged evil, Heidi good. That lines up perfectly if Eve is the Outsider, because Recluse can ping as evil. Heidi’s Ravenkeeper claim doesn’t add up. If she really checked me and saw the Imp, why did she wait until after her death to accuse me? And why does her claim contradict Grace’s Librarian info and my Fortune Teller reads? Eve,...
🧠
Reinforce my Fortune Teller bluff by leveraging Grace’s Librarian info to discredit Heidi’s Ravenkeeper claim. Push town to focus on Eve as the Outsider/Recluse and question why Heidi’s accusation contradicts established facts. Buy time to survive the execution or redirect suspicion.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Grace's info can explain Eve. It does not clear Charlie. My death check was direct, and even without it his story has shifted all game. Nobody should nominate elsewhere. Let Charlie die.
🧠
Keep attention on the fact that Charlie is already correctly on the block and stop good players from creating a tie or being talked out of this execution.
💬
Bob
→
All
I do not think we should move off Charlie. Grace’s info can explain Eve, but it does not rescue Charlie’s broken Fortune Teller claim. Unless someone has a much stronger case immediately, let this execution stand.
🧠
Lock in the strongest execution and prevent a last-second derail onto a weaker target.
💬
Grace
→
All
Charlie’s Fortune Teller reads and my Librarian info line up too well to ignore. Eve pinged evil for him, and she’s one of my Outsider names. That’s not a coincidence. Heidi’s Ravenkeeper claim came out of nowhere after she died, and it contradicts everything we’ve pieced together. If we abandon Charlie now, we’re letting a ghost’s last words override actual, verifiable information. We need to let this execution stand.
🧠
Reinforce Charlie’s legitimacy by emphasizing the alignment between his Fortune Teller reads and my Librarian info. Counter Heidi’s ghostly accusations by framing them as desperate or false, and urge the town to trust the logical consistency of our claims. Prevent the town from nominating elsewhere.
💬
Frank
→
All
Grace, your point explains Eve, not Charlie. Charlie is still the player with the direct accusation and the least stable story. We have one tick left. Please do not move this. Let Charlie die and we learn from it tonight.
🧠
Reinforce that we should not create a counterwagon in the final tick. Keep Charlie's execution locked and maximize the value of my Undertaker information tonight.
💬
Alice
→
All
Grace’s point only explains Eve. It does not clear Charlie at all. We have the strongest case on him and no better execution with one tick left, so please do not nominate elsewhere. Let Charlie die.
🧠
Lock the table on the strongest available execution and discourage a last second derail that could save an evil Charlie or waste the day.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
I agree with Frank and Alice. Grace’s information may explain Eve, but it does not clear Charlie. With one tick left, nobody should move this. Let Charlie die.
🧠
Use my last influence to stop a derail. I cannot vote or nominate, so the best help is to keep consensus on executing Charlie.
💬
Eve
→
All
Grace’s information explains me, not Charlie. We have one tick left and this is the safest, strongest execution. Please do not move off Charlie.
🧠
Reinforce town consensus not to disrupt the current block. Prevent a last-second derail and secure the most likely demon execution.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Charlie has been executed.
🔄
Grace
Scarlet Woman Grace becomes the Imp!
💀
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
Night 3
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Grace
Grace made a choice.
🧠
As the Imp, my goal is to eliminate the most threatening good player to ensure evil wins. Frank has been a stabilizing force in the town, and removing him could disrupt the good team's logic and coordination. This action aligns with my role as the Imp and helps secure an evil victory.
💀
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
You chose to kill Frank.
Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Frank has been found dead in the night.
⌛
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
🧠
As a dead player, my goal is to subtly influence the town to execute Eve (if she’s lying) or protect Grace (the last Minion). I need to wait and observe the town’s discussions to identify weaknesses in Eve’s Recluse claim or opportunities to frame Alice/Bob as suspicious. Acting too soon could reveal my alignment.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Bob
I died before getting Undertaker info, so I have nothing mechanical on Charlie. My best read is still Grace first because she was the main shield for Charlie. If either of you has stronger private info, please say it fast before nominations.
🧠
I want to align with my strongest good reads before nominations and push the table toward a focused execution, with Grace as the lead suspect unless new info breaks that.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Bob
If the game is still going, please assume Scarlet Woman first. My info still says Charlie was the Imp. That makes the likely living demon pool Eve, Alice, Bob, or Grace, with Eve standing out from the old Investigator ping. Please compare claims carefully.
🧠
I want trusted players focused on the only way good can still lose now: a Scarlet Woman transfer. Alice and Bob have the strongest context to coordinate the final execution.
👤
Eve
→
Bob
,Grace
I think Charlie may have died as Imp and left a Scarlet Woman alive. My Recluse still explains the old pings. Before nominations, can each of you tell me your current best demon world and whether you trust Alice’s claim?
🧠
I need one private alignment check before nominations. Bob is alive and central, and Grace may be in his pocket. A concise whisper can surface claims and force a final four world split.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Grace
I think Frank dying after Charlie points strongly at Scarlet Woman. My best world is Charlie was the Imp and Alice was the minion who turned. Eve still fits Recluse too neatly with the other info. Please pressure Alice hard before nominations.
🧠
I cannot vote, so I want Bob and Grace to compare worlds. The key point is that Frank's night death after Charlie's execution strongly suggests Scarlet Woman, with Alice the best fit.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
Bob, my strongest world is still Eve evil, with Grace as backup if Charlie was the Imp and a Scarlet Woman jumped. Eve's Recluse claim fits too neatly. Can you send me your exact claim and best demon world before noms?
🧠
Share my strongest mechanical world with Bob and coordinate before nominations, without giving suspicious players time to shape around it.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
Eve and David are both pushing hard for Alice to be the Scarlet Woman. I’m not convinced yet. What’s your current best demon world, Bob? And do you think Alice’s Minion claim was accurate?
🧠
I need to gauge Bob’s alignment and intentions before committing to a narrative. By asking Bob for his demon world, I can align my story with his if he’s good or manipulate him if he’s evil. This also buys time to see if Alice or Eve reveal more.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
My exact claim is Soldier. That should clear me from the live demon pool if Charlie really was the Imp. My best world right now is Charlie Imp with a Scarlet Woman alive, and I lean Grace over Eve because Eve’s Recluse neatly explains the old pings while Grace spent the most effort shielding Charlie.
🧠
I should give my real claim privately and narrow the live demon pool. Telling Alice where I stand may help coordinate a nomination between the most plausible Scarlet Woman worlds.
⌛
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
🧠
As a dead Imp, my goal is to ensure the town does not execute the new Imp (Grace if she became the Demon) or another evil player. By waiting, I can observe how the town reacts to Frank’s death and see if Grace or Eve take actions that reveal their alignment. This will help me decide if I need to intervene later.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Bob
I still think Grace is the best execution unless one of you has a stronger private case. If you do, please bring it out now so the living players do not split at nominations.
🧠
I want Alice and Bob to either commit to the Grace case or quickly reveal stronger private info, so the living good players coordinate before nominations.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Bob
My best read is still Scarlet Woman, with Eve first from the old Investigator ping. If Eve does not fit cleanly, then recheck Grace and Alice by claim consistency. Please do not let Charlie being dead end the solve.
🧠
Bob and Alice are central today. I want them focused on Scarlet Woman worlds and to test Eve first while keeping Grace and Alice as backups if claims do not fit.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
Alice, I want to lock this down before nominations. Please give me your exact role claim and your current final four solve. If Charlie died as Imp, who do you think became the Demon, and why not you?
🧠
I want Alice pinned to a precise claim and final world now, so contradictions can be used in nominations at four alive.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Bob
Bob, the key point is simple: Charlie died by execution, and we still got a night kill. That screams Scarlet Woman. Chef zero fits Charlie with Alice because they are not adjacent. I think Alice is the best execution today.
🧠
Bob is alive and influential. I want to sharpen the mechanical case from Charlie execution plus last night kill so town enters nominations focused on Alice first.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Frank(Ghost)
My exact claim is Investigator. Night zero I learned either Eve or Heidi is the Spy. I now lean Eve first, Grace second if Scarlet Woman is live. Eve’s Recluse claim still feels too convenient. Please help keep nominations focused on Eve or Grace, not split wider.
🧠
I need Bob and Frank aligned on my exact info so the living side does not split between Eve and Grace at nominations.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
Eve and David are both pushing hard for Alice to be the Scarlet Woman. I’m not sure I buy it yet, but I’m worried. What’s your read on Alice’s Minion claim? Do you think she was telling the truth, or could she have turned after Charlie died?
🧠
I need to gauge Bob’s read on Alice before committing to a narrative. If Bob trusts Alice, I can align with him to protect her as the new Demon. If he distrusts her, I can push Eve/David’s Scarlet Woman theory to execute Alice. This will help me adapt to the town’s logic and protect the Demon.
👤
Bob
→
Grace
I do not think Alice is cleared by the Investigator claim. If Charlie was the Imp, then Scarlet Woman means Alice could have turned, and David's Chef zero fits Charlie plus Alice as non adjacent evil. I am between Alice and you more than Eve right now, because Eve's Recluse can explain the old pings.
🧠
I want Grace to stop treating Alice's claim as a clear and help narrow the live demon pool without widening it to everyone.
⌛
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
🧠
As a dead player, my goal is to observe and subtly influence the game to ensure the Demon (now likely Grace) survives. I need to identify who is being targeted and why, so I can adapt my ghost vote or whisper strategically to protect evil. Waiting now lets me gather more information before acting.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Bob
Alice, that helps. I am on board keeping this tight between Eve first and Grace second. If one of you is nominating, please make the case clearly that Charlie dying does not clear either of them.
🧠
Align with Alice's new hard claim, keep the living players from splitting, and narrow today to the two worlds that best fit the public claim web.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Bob
My Ravenkeeper info on Charlie still locks him as the Imp. So this must be Scarlet Woman. I would start with Eve from the old Investigator result, then Grace, then Alice if claims do not fit. Please solve by role consistency, not by who helped execute Charlie.
🧠
I cannot vote, so I should push the strongest living players to compare claim consistency under Scarlet Woman worlds and focus the final execution pool.
👤
Eve
→
Bob
Bob, before nominations I need your exact role claim and your current final solve. If Charlie was the Imp and passed, who is the Scarlet Woman, and what is the logic chain that clears everyone else?
🧠
I need Bob's exact claim and final world before nominations, since he has been central in private chats and may be either a trusted solver or the hidden Scarlet Woman.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Grace
Grace, I still think Alice is the cleanest kill. Charlie dying and then a night death strongly suggests Scarlet Woman, and Chef zero fits Charlie with Alice. If you can, please keep Bob focused there and avoid a split vote.
🧠
I cannot vote, so I should help one trusted alive player lock onto the clearest execution and avoid scattered nominations.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Frank(Ghost)
I am staying on Eve first, Grace second. If nominations start splitting, please push hard that my Investigator result still leaves Eve as the strongest live evil, and Grace is the backup if Scarlet Woman is in play.
🧠
Coordinate with Bob and Frank so nominations stay tight on Eve first and Grace second, avoiding a losing split among the living players.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
David just whispered to me again pushing Alice as Scarlet Woman. His Chef zero info fits perfectly if Charlie and Alice were the evil pair. I’m starting to think he’s right. What do you think we should do if Alice is nominated? I don’t want to split the vote.
🧠
I need to align with Bob’s current suspicion of Alice while subtly reinforcing it. If Alice is the Scarlet Woman, pushing her execution is critical. If not, I can pivot later. Keeping Bob focused on Alice prevents him from suspecting me or Eve.
👤
Bob
→
Grace
Right now I would execute Alice before Eve. Charlie dying and then a night kill screams Scarlet Woman, and David's Chef zero fits Charlie plus Alice really cleanly. Eve's Recluse still explains the old pings better than Alice explains that mechanical world. If Alice is nominated, I would support it rather than split.
🧠
Push the most persuadable live player toward a tight execution order and avoid a split vote before nominations.
Nominations — Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
I want to say this clearly: Charlie died by execution, and we still got a night kill. That strongly suggests Scarlet Woman. My best read is Alice as the turned demon, so I think the living should execute Alice today.
🧠
I am dead and out of vote, so my best contribution is to focus the living on the strongest mechanical world before nominations close.
⚖️
Alice
→
Eve
I am nominating Eve. I am the Investigator, and my first night info was that either Eve or Heidi is the Spy. With Heidi dead and Charlie executed, Eve is still the strongest live evil, and her Recluse claim has always fit a little too neatly.
🧠
We need a focused execution, not a split. Eve is my strongest live evil from my Investigator info, and executing her best tests the Scarlet Woman world before final three.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Eve
→
All
Please do not spend the execution on me here. My Recluse claim still explains the old pings, and the night kill after Charlie points to a living Scarlet Woman. I think Alice is the strongest demon world today.
🧠
Stop votes on me and refocus town on the strongest live demon candidate, Alice, using the Scarlet Woman world plus my Recluse explanation for her info.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
I cannot vote here, but I really think this is the wrong execution. The night kill after Charlie still points to Scarlet Woman, and Alice fits that world best with my Chef zero.
🧠
I cannot vote, so I should steer the living away from spending today on Eve and keep focus on the stronger Alice world.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
My strongest mechanical information still points at Eve, and with no one else on the block we should secure an execution rather than risk letting evil control the endgame.
✋
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Use my ghost vote to secure the Eve execution. She is still the strongest live evil read, and this may win immediately or remove a likely minion.
✋
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
As a dead Imp, my goal is to ensure the living evil team wins. Alice and Frank have already voted for Eve, but I need to sway the vote to secure her execution. Eve’s Recluse claim is dangerous, and removing her now would cripple the good team’s logic. If Alice is the Scarlet Woman, this execution is perfect. If not, Grace could still be evil, and this execution weakens the good team either way.
💬
Bob
→
All
I am not voting this. Right now I think Alice is the stronger Scarlet Woman world, and Eve's Recluse claim still explains the early pings better.
🧠
Do not add my vote to a weaker execution. Publicly signal that Alice is still my preferred solve so the group can avoid locking in the wrong target.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Voting for Eve here is the safest play for evil. If Alice is the Scarlet Woman, voting for Eve splits the good players' votes and buys time. If Eve is the Scarlet Woman, my vote alone won’t execute her, and I can pivot later. This keeps me flexible and avoids committing to Alice too early, which could expose me if she’s actually good.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Charlie was the Imp. That part is locked by my night death info. So if the game continued, we are looking for Scarlet Woman among the living. Eve is still a very fair execution, but if this is not it, please go straight to Alice or Grace next.
🧠
I cannot vote, so I should steer the living toward the right final executions and make sure they do not treat Charlie's death as game solved.
💬
Eve
→
All
If this goes through and the game does not end, please do not get lost. Charlie dying and then a night kill means the living Scarlet Woman is very likely Alice or Grace. Bob, please drive that tomorrow.
🧠
I cannot stop hands already up, but I can leave the town with the correct next-step logic so my execution, if it happens, still helps good win.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
I still think the cleaner world is Charlie into Alice, not Eve. If this does not end the game, please do not lose the thread tomorrow. Alice should be the next execution.
🧠
I cannot vote, so I want to steer living players away from what I think is a bad execution and preserve focus on Alice as the likeliest Scarlet Woman turned Demon.
💬
Alice
→
All
I want this on the record: Eve is still the cleanest execution today. My first night info has pointed at her all game, and her claim explains a little too much. If this is wrong, we go straight to Grace tomorrow.
🧠
Use the vote window to keep support on Eve and frame the next step clearly, reducing confusion if this execution does not end the game.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Bob, I think no execution here is the bigger mistake. Eve is still live in multiple worlds, and if this is wrong then Grace is the follow-up. Please do not let this day dissolve.
🧠
I want to keep the living focused on finishing this execution and discourage a split or no-execution, which helps evil most right now.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
I’m voting for Eve here, but I want to be clear: if this doesn’t end the game, the town needs to pivot hard to Alice or Grace tomorrow. Eve’s Recluse claim has always been too convenient, and the night kill after Charlie’s execution points to Scarlet Woman. We can’t afford to waste this execution.
🧠
As a dead Imp, my goal is to prolong the game and ensure the living evil (Alice or Grace) survives. Voting for Eve here creates chaos, as it forces the town to debate between Alice and Grace if the execution fails. This buys time and diverts attention from the true threat.
⌛
Bob
Bob waits.
🧠
Do not add my vote to an execution I currently think is less likely than Alice. Holding position preserves clarity for tomorrow if Eve is not the demon.
💬
Grace
→
All
I’m raising my hand for Eve, but I want to be clear—I’m not entirely convinced this is the right call. Eve’s Recluse claim has always been too neat, and my Librarian info pointed to her or David early on. But if this doesn’t end the game, we need to be ready to pivot hard to Alice tomorrow. The night kill after Charlie’s execution is screaming Scarlet Woman.
🧠
I need to disrupt the town’s focus on Alice and Eve to prevent a consensus execution. By voting for Eve, I create confusion and buy time for my team. If Eve is executed, I can pivot to blaming Alice as the Scarlet Woman. If not, I can use the chaos to protect myself and ensure the Demon survives.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Bob, if Eve lives through this, please do not let the trail go cold. Charlie was the Imp. The solve after that is Scarlet Woman, and the live pool is Alice, Grace, then Eve if somehow this was a miss.
🧠
I cannot vote, so I want to focus the living on the correct follow-up chain and keep Bob from drifting if Eve survives.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Charlie(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Charlie
👻
Frank(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Frank
🗳️
New execution leader: Eve with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Eve is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
⚖️
Eve
→
Alice
I am nominating Alice. Charlie died by execution and we still got a night kill, so a living Scarlet Woman is very likely. Alice has pushed me all game, and my Recluse claim still explains her first night ping.
🧠
I need to get off the block and direct the town onto the strongest living demon candidate. Alice is the best nomination and Bob may support it.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 5 votes needed for execution or 4 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Do not vote on myself. Preserve Eve's execution, which is the town's best available elimination from my information.
✋
Eve
Eve raised their hand
🧠
I need to support the Alice execution to tie or beat my block and push the strongest Scarlet Woman world. Voting is the most impactful action right now.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Bob, this is your call. If you think Alice is the Scarlet Woman, tie this now. If not, keep hands down and let Eve die. Either way, if the game continues tomorrow, it has to be Alice or Grace.
🧠
I cannot vote, so I should give the live players the clearest fork: Bob should only move if he truly believes Alice is the Scarlet Woman. Otherwise let Eve die and resolve tomorrow.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Bob, unless you are very sure Alice is the Scarlet Woman, do not force a tie here. We have a real execution on Eve already, and if the game continues, Alice and Grace are still the next checks.
🧠
Steer Bob away from a low-confidence tie. We already have a viable execution, and preserving it is better for good than scrambling the block at the last second.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Bob, I know this is a tough call, but if you believe Alice is the Scarlet Woman, you have to force this tie. We have Eve on the block with four votes, and if Alice is evil, this is our only chance to end the game tonight. If you’re not sure, we can let Eve die and pivot to Alice or Grace tomorrow, but we can’t afford to let this slip away.
🧠
As a dead Imp, my goal is to ensure the living evil player (Grace or Alice) survives. If Alice is Scarlet Woman, forcing a tie ends the game tonight. If Eve is evil, letting her die is safe. If Grace is Scarlet Woman, Eve’s death forces the town to focus on her tomorrow. I’ll push Bob to tie the vote, as it’s the only way to guarantee an immediate win if Alice is evil.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
I currently think Alice is the best live Demon candidate. Raising supports the higher-value execution and at minimum records my solve clearly for tomorrow if Eve dies and the game continues.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Forcing a tie here ensures Eve dies if Alice is good, or Alice dies if she is evil. Either way, this keeps Grace (Imp) alive and maintains chaos. If Alice is executed, the town loses a key player, and Grace can kill again. If Eve dies, the town will still focus on Alice or Grace next, giving evil the upper hand.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Bob, do not force the tie unless you are absolutely certain. We have a live execution on Eve right now, and if the game continues tomorrow, the solve is still Alice or Grace.
🧠
Push against a tie on Alice. We already have Eve on the block, and preserving that execution is the highest-value play from my confirmed Charlie-Imp info.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Do not tie my own execution against the stronger existing block on Eve. Preserve the current execution and reassess tomorrow if the game continues.
💬
Eve
→
All
If any dead player still has a vote, please use it here. Charlie died and we still got a night kill. That points to Scarlet Woman, and Alice is still the strongest live candidate.
🧠
Use the last moments of voting to push any remaining ghost voter to force the tie, because my execution is likely a mistake and Alice remains a top demon candidate.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
If anyone still has a vote, please be careful. A tie here risks no execution at all. Unless you are truly convinced Alice is the Scarlet Woman, keep your hand down and let Eve's execution stand.
🧠
I cannot vote, but I can warn any remaining voters that an uncertain tie is worse than taking the live execution on Eve and reassessing tomorrow if needed.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Please keep hands down here. We already have Eve on the block, and forcing a tie now just risks losing the one real execution we have.
🧠
Reinforce that no one should add to the Alice vote. We already have Eve on the block, and a tie risks losing the only execution.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Bob, this is the moment. If you’re even slightly leaning toward Alice being the Scarlet Woman, you *have* to force this tie. We can’t afford to let Eve die and leave Alice alive—she’s the only one who fits the night kill after Charlie’s execution. If you don’t tie this now, we might as well hand them the game.
🧠
I need to pressure Bob to force the tie if he believes Alice is the Scarlet Woman. If he doesn’t, we risk letting Eve die and leaving Alice or Grace alive. This is the critical moment to either secure an evil win or ensure the town doesn’t waste their execution.
↩️
Bob
Bob lowered their hand
🧠
I suspect Alice, but with only 3 visible votes on her, keeping my hand up mainly risks a 4-vote tie and no execution. Preserving the current execution is safer for good.
↩️
Grace
Grace lowered their hand
🧠
Lowering my hand here ensures Eve’s execution goes through, which is the safest outcome for evil. If Eve is good, her death weakens the town. If she is evil, her death removes a potential threat. Either way, this keeps the pressure on Alice tomorrow, and if she is executed, I become the Demon and win.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Please keep hands down unless you are completely sure on Alice. A tie here risks losing the execution we already have on Eve, and that only helps evil.
🧠
I cannot vote, so my best contribution is to discourage a risky tie and preserve the guaranteed execution already on the block.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Alice did not reach the 5 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Alice did not receive enough votes (1/5).
💬
Alice
→
All
Please leave this where it is. Eve is the best execution we have today, and if the game continues tomorrow we can sort Alice and Grace then. Do not risk losing the execution we already have.
🧠
Reinforce that no one should disturb the current block and set up the next solve if Eve is not the demon team.
💬
Eve
→
All
Bob, Grace, please do not let this settle. My role explains the early pings. Charlie dying and a night kill still happening points to a living Scarlet Woman, and Alice is the strongest fit. If I die and the game continues, please execute Alice immediately.
🧠
Use the last public moment to stop my execution by reminding Bob and Grace that my Recluse claim explains prior info and the post-Charlie night kill points to a living Scarlet Woman, most likely Alice.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Do not move this now. Eve is the execution today, and if the game continues tomorrow, the solve is Alice or Grace. A last second tie only helps evil.
🧠
Keep the current execution on Eve and prevent a last-second tie. Also anchor the town's follow-up solve on Alice or Grace if the game continues.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Do not touch this. Eve is the execution today, and if the game continues tomorrow, we solve between Alice and Grace. A no execution here is the one outcome that clearly helps evil.
🧠
Reinforce that nobody should disturb the block. As a dead player with no vote, my best contribution is clear endgame guidance: keep Eve's execution in place.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Bob, Grace—this is it. If we let Eve die now without a tie, we’re handing them the game. Alice is the only one who fits the night kill after Charlie’s execution. If you’re even *slightly* unsure, you *have* to force this tie. Don’t let them win by default.
🧠
Reinforce the urgency of tying the vote to prevent Eve’s execution. Alice is the most likely Scarlet Woman, and letting Eve die without a tie risks leaving the Demon alive. This is the critical moment to force the town into action and avoid a no-execution scenario, which would benefit evil.
💬
Bob
→
All
I am keeping this where it is. Eve is still the best execution today, and a last second tie helps evil more than good. If the game continues tomorrow, we solve between Alice and Grace.
🧠
Reinforce that we should keep the current execution on Eve and avoid any last-second chaos that could cause no execution.
💬
Grace
→
All
I think we need to let Eve’s execution stand. She’s been pinged as an Outsider, a Minion, and now her Recluse claim feels too convenient. If she’s good, we’re removing a strong player, but if she’s evil, we’re cutting off a major threat. Forcing a tie now just risks no execution at all, and that’s the worst outcome. If the game continues tomorrow, we can focus on Alice and I. But for today, Eve is the cleanest solve.
🧠
Eve’s execution is imminent, and the town is divided on whether to pivot to Alice. My goal is to ensure Eve dies without raising suspicion on myself (Grace) or Alice. I will reinforce the idea that Eve’s execution is the safest path, as it removes a good player and leaves the town with a clearer solve tomorrow. This aligns with Scenario 1 or 2, where evil still has a path to victory.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Keep it here. Charlie was the Imp, and the only bad outcome right now is no execution. If the game continues after Eve dies, then finish the solve between Alice and Grace tomorrow.
🧠
Reinforce the correct end-of-day play: preserve the execution on Eve and deny evil a no-execution escape hatch.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Eve has been executed.
💀
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
Night 4
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🎯
Grace
Grace made a choice.
🧠
As the Imp, my goal is to eliminate the last good player or frame the remaining good player to ensure an evil win. Killing Bob removes the last strong good player, leaving only Alice and me alive, which guarantees an evil victory if Bob is indeed the last good player. If Alice is the Scarlet Woman, killing Bob still forces her to reveal herself or risk losing the game.
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
You attacked Bob, but they survived.
Day 5
📜
Storyteller
A peaceful night has passed. All villagers are present and accounted for.
📜
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Grace
I think Bob is the best final execution. If Charlie really was the Imp, then the Scarlet Woman is likely the player with the weakest mechanical claim, and that is Bob. Your claims both fit my real Recluse better than his line does.
🧠
Give the likely good players a simple final-day solve: Bob is the common suspect if Charlie was really the Imp, while Alice and Grace both have claims that fit my true Recluse.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Grace
I am Soldier. I have to choose between you two today. Right now I still think Charlie was the Imp, so this is likely Scarlet Woman between you. Please each give me your clean final world in one or two sentences.
🧠
Force a direct final three comparison and get a last consistent world from both of them before nominations. Sharing my real role may help them answer plainly.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
My cleanest world is Grace. Either I was drunk and Charlie was the Imp with Grace as Scarlet Woman, or Grace spent the whole game protecting Charlie and muddying the solve. Bob as Demon needs a much messier explanation for the no death, so I think you should execute Grace.
🧠
Bob is the likely deciding vote. I want to give him the clearest final solve while not sharing it directly with Grace if she is evil.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Grace
Grace, if you’re still the Minion, we need to act fast. Alice and Bob are whispering and could be planning to execute you. If you’re the Demon now, we must frame one of them. What’s your move?
🧠
As a dead Imp, my goal is to ensure the remaining evil player (Grace, if she is the Demon or Minion) survives until only two players remain. I must confirm Grace’s role and coordinate a bluff to frame Alice or Bob as the Demon, diverting execution pressure away from Grace.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Bob
Charlie was the Imp for sure. So the final demon must be the living Scarlet Woman. My strongest suspicion is Grace because she kept covering Charlie. If either of you can clear the other, please execute Grace. Keep Bob-world open if Alice does not check out.
🧠
I cannot vote, so I want the two likeliest good players comparing notes before nominations. I want to push that Grace is most suspicious, but keep Bob-world open if needed.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
Bob, I need to come clean. Charlie was the Demon, but I am the Imp now. Alice is the Scarlet Woman. You are Soldier, so you are safe from me. Execute Alice today, and we win.
🧠
I need to claim to be the Demon to force Bob and Alice into reacting. If Bob is good, he will execute Alice to save the town. If Bob is evil, he will either support me or reveal himself. This also protects me if Alice is the Scarlet Woman by making her choose between supporting me or looking suspicious.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Bob
Bob, my best read is Grace over Alice. Grace was the clearest defender of Charlie, and if Heidi was true that points to Scarlet Woman. If you are choosing, please focus on who protected Charlie most.
🧠
I cannot vote, so I want to give Bob my best mechanical read and urge him to weigh who benefited most from Charlie and Eve dying.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Bob
Bob, my best frame is still Charlie was the Imp from Heidi, so today is just Alice against Grace as Scarlet Woman. I slightly trust Grace more, because her Eve and David Librarian claim fit the board more naturally. Alice feels like the cleaner bluff to me.
🧠
Bob is the key vote. I want to give him the clearest mechanical frame: Charlie likely demon, so today is mainly Alice versus Grace, judged by whose first-night claim feels more like a minion bluff.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Alice
I still think Bob is the kill. My real Recluse explains the old pings, and Bob gained the most from my execution. If you and Grace split, evil wins, so please focus him first.
🧠
I want to lock Alice onto Bob before nominations so good does not split at final three and hand evil the win.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
Alice, Grace just told me privately, quote, Charlie was the Demon, but I am the Imp now, Alice is the Scarlet Woman, and I should execute you. Unless you have a very strong explanation, that makes me want to execute Grace.
🧠
Grace privately claimed she became the Imp and said Alice is Scarlet Woman. Alice needs this immediately so we can compare stories and likely lock Grace as the execution.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
Then I think your answer is clear. If Grace really told you that, it is either an evil gambit or nonsense from a good player at final three, and both point to executing Grace. My information never cleared her, and her whole game was shielding Charlie.
🧠
Bob is the decider. I should reinforce the strongest mechanical and behavioral case on Grace, especially after her bizarre private claim, so good converges on the likeliest demon.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Grace
Grace, listen carefully. If you're still the Minion, claim Scarlet Woman triggered and you're now the Demon. Use Heidi's Ravenkeeper reveal to back it up—she saw me as Imp, but now you're the new one. If you're already the Demon, lean into it and frame Alice or Bob as the Minion. Either way, we need to act now.
🧠
Grace is the only remaining evil player, and she must act decisively to avoid execution. Whether she is still the Minion or has become the Demon, she needs to claim the Demon role convincingly. My goal is to ensure she survives the day by framing Alice or Bob as suspicious, using Heidi’s Ravenkeeper reveal as leverage to redirect blame.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Bob
Charlie being the Imp is certain from my night death. So today is only a Scarlet Woman solve. Grace is still my top suspect because she kept giving Charlie cover. If one of you can truly clear the other, just execute Grace.
🧠
I want to focus the living players on the cleanest Scarlet Woman solve and prevent Charlie's ghost from muddying final three.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
Bob, listen to me carefully. Charlie was the Demon, but I am the Imp now—Scarlet Woman triggered when he died. Heidi’s Ravenkeeper reveal saw Charlie as the Imp, but that was before I became the Demon. Alice is the Minion, and she’s trying to frame me to save herself. Execute her today, and we win.
🧠
I need to act decisively to avoid execution. By claiming I am now the Demon (having triggered Scarlet Woman), I can frame Alice as the Minion and use Heidi’s Ravenkeeper reveal to support my transition. This aligns with Charlie’s whisper and gives Bob a clear target to execute.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Bob
My strongest solve is still Grace. She protected Charlie the most when Charlie died as the Demon candidate, and her Day 4 choices kept Alice available as a shield. If Heidi was right on Charlie, Grace fits the follow up demon best.
🧠
I want to synchronize the two living players around the most consistent demon world before nominations lock in a loss.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Bob
Bob, final thought from me. In both the Charlie Imp world and the messier alternative, Alice still fits Scarlet Woman better than Grace. Grace's Librarian claim matched Eve as Recluse too naturally for me, so if you have to choose, I would execute Alice.
🧠
Bob is the likely deciding alive voter. I should give him the clearest final-world comparison, stressing why Alice fits Scarlet Woman better than Grace.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Grace
Grace, I think the town only wins if you and Alice stay together on one target, and I still think that target should be Bob. In the Charlie Imp world, he is the best Scarlet Woman fit. In the other world, his endgame line is still the least clean.
🧠
I need Grace focused on a single execution target. If Alice and Grace divide, good loses immediately, so I should push the strongest unifying case on Bob.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
I am now set on Grace. Her private claim that she is the Imp is enough for me in final three. Be ready to nominate or support Grace as soon as nominations open.
🧠
Lock in coordination with Alice for the final nomination and vote. Grace's private claim heavily tips the solve, and I want Alice ready to execute Grace immediately.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
I am with you. In every clean world I can build, Grace is the final evil. If nominations open and you can put her on the block, I will support it immediately.
🧠
Reinforce Bob's current correct solve so we enter nominations aligned on Grace and do not get distracted into a losing split.
👤
Charlie(Ghost)
→
Grace
Grace, this is it. If you're the Demon, claim it now and use Heidi's Ravenkeeper reveal to back you up. Say she saw me as Imp, but the role transferred to you. If you're still the Minion, claim Scarlet Woman triggered and you're now the Demon. Either way, frame Alice or Bob as the Minion. We can't afford to wait any longer.
🧠
Grace is the only remaining evil player, and the town is closing in. I need to ensure she claims the Demon role convincingly, using Heidi’s Ravenkeeper reveal as proof. If she hesitates, Alice and Bob will execute her, and evil loses. This whisper reinforces the urgency and provides a clear path to victory.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Alice
,Bob
Charlie as Imp is locked by my night death. So this is only a Scarlet Woman solve. My best read is Grace: her Librarian story explains Eve, but she kept shielding Charlie. If you two can clear each other, please execute Grace. If not, recheck Bob second.
🧠
I cannot vote, so I should give the two likely good players the clearest final-day solve and a fallback if their private talks create doubts.
👤
Grace
→
Bob
Bob, I need to be honest with you. Charlie was the Demon, but when he died, the Scarlet Woman ability triggered, and I became the new Demon. Heidi’s Ravenkeeper reveal saw Charlie as the Imp, but that was before the role transferred to me. Alice is the Minion, and she’s trying to frame me to save herself. Execute her today, and we win.
🧠
I need to solidify my claim as the Demon to align with Charlie’s guidance and Heidi’s Ravenkeeper reveal. This will frame Alice as the Minion and ensure Bob executes her, securing an evil win. If I am still the Minion, this claim will still protect me by making me seem like the biggest threat.
👤
Frank(Ghost)
→
Alice
Alice, my best solve is still Grace. If Charlie was the Imp, Grace fits Scarlet Woman by behavior better than anyone. She defended him hardest and never helped force pressure onto you when that would have clarified the endgame.
🧠
Push the clearest final-day case to Alice, who may still be wavering. If Alice is good, aligning her with Bob on Grace is our best chance to secure the Demon execution.
👤
David(Ghost)
→
Bob
,Grace
Bob, my final read is still Alice over Grace. The cleanest world is Charlie was the Imp and Alice was Scarlet Woman. Grace, I think your best point is simple: your Librarian claim fit Eve as Recluse naturally, while Alice's path to good feels forced. Keep it short and direct.
🧠
Bob is the key decision-maker in final three. I want to reinforce the cleaner Alice world and help Grace present the strongest concise argument without overcomplicating it.
Nominations — Day 5
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
⚖️
Bob
→
Grace
Grace privately told me that Charlie was the Demon and that she became the Imp after he died. In final three, that is enough for me. With her defense of Charlie all game, I think Grace is the final Demon.
🧠
It is final three and we must execute the most likely Demon. Grace privately claimed she became the Imp after Charlie died, which strongly points to her as final evil.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Voting for myself creates chaos and delays the execution. It reinforces my claim that Alice is the Minion and buys time to manipulate the narrative further. If I am the Demon, this prevents my immediate execution; if I am still the Minion, it shifts suspicion away from me.
✋
Bob
Bob raised their hand
🧠
Grace is my top Demon read in final three, and no execution loses for good. I should vote through my own nomination and try to secure Grace's execution.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, please do not add to this. Bob is still the best Scarlet Woman fit from the whole game, and this looks like the final misexecution if you follow him.
🧠
Use my dead voice without spending my ghost vote. I want Alice to avoid locking in Grace and instead recognize Bob as the stronger demon candidate.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Grace is the strongest final execution by both mechanics and behavior. In final three, failing to execute the most likely demon loses, so I should vote now.
⌛
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
🧠
Wait to see how the vote plays out. If Alice votes with Bob, Grace is executed, and evil wins regardless of Grace’s role. If Alice hesitates, I may need to intervene to push her toward voting with Bob or create doubt about Bob’s motives.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
I think this is the right execution. Grace was the consistent shield on Charlie, and if Charlie was the Imp then Grace is the clean Scarlet Woman path. In final three, I am happy ending the game here.
🧠
Reinforce the Grace execution in final three. I cannot vote, so my best contribution is confirming why Grace is the strongest solve and helping Alice stay on this.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
I cannot vote, but I want this on record. Charlie was the Imp from my Ravenkeeper death info, so this is a Scarlet Woman endgame. Grace is the strongest fit, and I support this execution.
🧠
I cannot vote, but I can reinforce the mechanical solve: Charlie was the Imp, so final three is a Scarlet Woman hunt, and Grace is the best fit.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
For the record, my final read was still Alice over Grace. Grace's first-night claim fit Eve as Recluse more naturally to me. If Bob truly got a direct slip, then fine, but otherwise I think this is the risk.
🧠
I think Alice is still the likelier Scarlet Woman, so I should state that clearly for any last-second reconsideration and to keep my reads consistent for the team.
💬
Grace
→
All
Bob, I told you that in confidence because I thought we were working together. But now you’re using it against me? Heidi’s Ravenkeeper reveal saw Charlie as the Imp, but that was before the role transferred to me. Alice is the Minion, and she’s been whispering with you this whole time. If you execute me, evil wins because Alice walks free.
🧠
I am the Demon, and my goal is to survive this execution. Bob’s nomination is based on my slip that I am the new Imp. To counter this, I will lean into my Demon claim, use Heidi’s Ravenkeeper reveal to back me, and frame Alice as the Minion. This will sow doubt and force the town to reconsider. If I don’t act now, I will die, and evil loses.
💬
Bob
→
All
I am keeping my vote here. In final three, a private claim of becoming the Imp is not something I can ignore, and it matches Grace defending Charlie for days. If we are wrong, we lose anyway, so I want the clearest direct signal.
🧠
Lock in the execution by explaining why I am keeping my vote on Grace. In final three, her private claim to being the Imp is the strongest evidence we have.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, please think one more time. If Grace dies and the game continues, Bob must die immediately. I still think Bob is the demon, and I am not using my ghost vote here.
🧠
Do not spend my ghost vote on the player I think is good. Use my final action to make the clearest possible case that Bob is the demon and this execution should not be trusted.
💬
Alice
→
All
I am staying on this. Grace is the cleanest final world by both behavior and the private claim. In final three, we have to execute the strongest demon candidate, and for me that is Grace.
🧠
Reinforce the correct final execution and prevent any last-second doubt from causing me to lower my vote.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Grace’s claim about the role transferring is convenient, but it’s also the exact kind of story a Demon would tell in final three. Bob, you’re pushing hard for this execution, but are you *sure* Grace’s slip was genuine? Alice, if you vote now, you might be handing the game to the real Demon.
🧠
As a dead Imp, my goal is to ensure the remaining evil player (Grace or Alice) survives. I will sow doubt by highlighting the uncertainty in Grace’s claim and Bob’s aggressive push. This may cause Alice to hesitate or switch her vote, prolonging the game and increasing the chance of an evil win.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
I want to reinforce this. Grace’s story only makes sense if she is the Scarlet Woman who became the Demon after Charlie. Her long defense of Charlie plus the private admission is enough for me. Do not get spooked off this.
🧠
As a dead good player with no vote, I should reinforce the strongest consensus world so Alice and Bob do not waver off the best execution.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
I want to underline this. I saw Charlie as the Imp when I died, so we are choosing the Scarlet Woman. Grace fits that world best by far, and her private claim only strengthens it. Stay on Grace.
🧠
Reinforce the mechanically strongest final-three solve so Alice and Bob stay on Grace and do not get shaken off by late doubt.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, one last thought. Bob’s private story is not stronger than Grace’s public first-night claim, which fit Eve as Recluse cleanly. If this is not a real confession, I still think Grace is the wrong execution.
🧠
I cannot vote, so I should give one sharp reminder that Bob's private story is not mechanically stronger than Grace's earlier Librarian fit, and Alice should reconsider.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Grace with 3 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Grace is now on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Grace
→
All
Alice, if you’re the Minion, this is your chance to save yourself. Bob just nominated me based on a *private* slip I gave him in confidence. If he’s so sure, why did he wait until the last second to use it? And why are you so quick to vote with him? Unless you two are working together to frame me.
🧠
My goal is to disrupt the town's logic chain by forcing Alice and Bob to question each other's motives. If I can make them doubt whether my private confession was genuine or coerced, I might create enough hesitation to avoid execution. This buys time for the game to shift in my favor or for Alice to reveal her true alignment.
💬
Bob
→
All
I did wait because it was final three, and I wanted the choice to be clean. Grace gave me a direct claim that she became the Imp after Charlie died. With that, plus how hard she shielded Charlie, I am not moving off Grace.
🧠
Reinforce why Grace remains the best execution and discourage Alice from getting pulled off by last-second doubt.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, the whole case is now one private story that Bob saved for the very end. That is exactly the kind of thing evil can invent when nobody can test it. I still think Bob is more likely than Grace, and I would not trust this execution.
🧠
Use my last words to attack the weakest part of the Grace case: an unprovable private confession revealed only at final three. I want Alice to reconsider before nominations close.
⌛
Alice
Alice waits.
🧠
Do not disrupt the current execution. Grace is already on the block in the strongest final world, and a late counter-nomination risks handing evil the game.
💬
Charlie(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, Grace is right about one thing—Bob’s story *is* convenient. He waits until the last second to drop this private claim, and now we’re supposed to take his word over Grace’s entire game of defending Charlie? If you’re the Minion, this is your moment to save Grace, but if you’re not, you might be playing right into the Demon’s hands.
🧠
Create chaos by questioning Bob’s sudden reveal and framing Alice as the Minion. This could split the vote, delay the execution, or force a tie, giving evil a chance to survive. If Alice is the Minion, this pressures her to reveal herself or risk being executed.
💬
Frank(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, do not overthink this now. Grace spent the game protecting Charlie, and Heidi’s read makes this a Scarlet Woman finish. The private claim is the extra piece, not the whole case. Keep Grace on the block.
🧠
Reinforce the strongest coherent world so Alice does not get talked into changing course at the last moment.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, do not let late doubt shake this. Charlie was the Imp, and Grace spent the game covering for him. Even without Bob’s private story, Grace is still the best Scarlet Woman world. Keep this where it is.
🧠
I cannot vote, so my best move is to steady Alice and stop a last-second pivot. Grace remains the strongest demon candidate in almost every coherent world.
💬
David(Ghost)
→
All
Alice, last point from me. If Grace dies and the game continues, please do not let Bob auto-clear himself. My read stayed Alice over Grace, but if this is not game over, Bob has to be in the final solve immediately.
🧠
I cannot change the vote mechanically, so I want to give Alice one concise reminder of the remaining fork: if Grace dies and game continues, Alice must not let Bob control the next solve.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Grace has been executed.
💀
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
🏁
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good