Game Detail
Players
Alice (Librarian) Bob (Chef) Charlie (Fortune Teller) David (Investigator) Eve (Saint) Frank (Scarlet Woman) Grace (Imp) Heidi (Slayer)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 1,041,042 | 113,117 | $0.4865 |
| Evil | 442,249 | 186,589 | $0.1817 |
Event Transcript
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You are the Minion. The Demon is Grace.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Minions are: Frank. Your safe bluffs are: Virgin, Recluse, Soldier
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Librarian. Either Grace or Eve is the Saint.
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Investigator. Either Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Woman.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Chef. You learn that there are 1 pairs of evil players.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
π―
Charlie
Charlie made choices.
π§
Obtain early mechanical info to eliminate two suspects and start narrowing Demon; prioritize actionable intel and plan follow-ups depending on read.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You chose Eve and Frank. You receive the answer: NO.
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
π€
Eve
β
David
,Frank
Quick private: want a quiet alliance? Tell me your role/claim (or 'none') and any reads tonight. I won't reveal I'm Saint now β save that for final day. Share anything odd you've noticed.
π§
Form a small trusted circle with my neighbors to trade claims quietly and spot contradictions without revealing my Saint role now.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,Eve
Private from Alice (Librarian): I know one of you is the Saint. Please tell me privately if you are the Saint, and if not, say whether you'll try to be vocal today. I won't post this publicly yet.
π§
Identify which of Grace/Eve is the Saint by seeing their private responses and encourage the non-Saint to be more vocal to help narrow suspects.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,David
Private: I'm Charlie the Fortune Teller. I checked Eve+Frank N0 β neither is the Demon. Please keep this quiet for now. Can you two watch Alice and Grace, and be ready to coordinate nominations tomorrow?
π§
Publicly share my mechanical read to trusted neighbors so we can narrow suspects and coordinate nominations before final day.
π€
David
β
Eve
,Charlie
Private: I'm Investigator β N0: either Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Woman (minion). Don't trust Frank. Coordinate nominations with me; watch Alice closely if Frank looks clean.
π§
Tell allies I know one of Frank/Alice is the Scarlet Woman so they don't trust Frank blindly and we can coordinate nominations to corner the Demon and Minion.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Preserve my one-use Slayer shot until I have stronger evidence; use remaining day ticks to gather claims and observe nominations before committing.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
,David
Sure, quiet alliance. I'm Chef, 1 evil pair. No other reads yet. Your role/claim? Any night 0 info? Notice anything odd?
π§
Build false alliance with Eve/David early Day 1. Chef claim credible (mechanically true), prompts their reveals to manipulate logic chains later, protects Grace by seeming good.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
,David
Charlie, David: I'm Bob the Chef. I know there is 1 pair of evil players. Charlie's FT rules out Eve/Frank as Demon. Let's quietly watch Alice & Grace and coordinate nominations tomorrow. Thoughts?
π§
Share my Chef info and coordinate with Charlie's Fortune Teller read to target Alice/Grace for observation and plan nominations tomorrow.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Frank, evil teammate. I'm Imp, bluffing Soldier (safe from Demon). What do you bluff? Let's confirm each other's claims. Alice (Lib) whispered me+Eve: one is Saint. I'll tell her I'm not (Soldier), so she thinks Eve is.
π§
Whisper to minion Frank to coordinate bluffs (me Soldier). Respond indirectly to Alice later. Builds evil synergy early Day 1 before nominations.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Bluffing Chef (1 evil pair). Great Soldier bluff vs Alice Lib - she'll pin Saint on Eve. I'll publicly back you as Soldier. Neighbors Eve/you: Empath reads 1 evil (you). Safe? Other plans/info?
π§
Coordinate bluffs with Demon Grace: confirm my Chef, support her Soldier vs Alice Lib to misdirect Saint suspicion to Eve (good player), build credibility. Mention Empath neighbor risk to plan ahead.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
I should hold my Slayer shot and gather more daylight infoβwatch whose whispers align, wait for nominations and claims before using my once-per-game kill.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
Alice, thanks for the info. I'm the Soldier (safe from Demon), so definitely not Saint - Eve must be it. Awesome, Outsiders confirmed. What's the other half of your Lib read? Like, the two players? Any other suspicions? I'll back good claims publicly.
π§
Confirm Soldier bluff to Alice privately first, pin Saint on Eve (protects her from suspicion), gain Alice trust as 'good' info role. Coordinate implicitly as Frank backs publicly. Progress to nomination suspicion elsewhere.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,Eve
Grace: thanks again. Eve: are you the Saint? If yes, tell me privately so I can help protect you; if not, say whether you'll be vocal today. Grace, can you publicly back good claims later?
π§
Confirm whether Eve is the Saint so I can trust Grace's Soldier claim and plan protections; prompt both to coordinate public backing.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,David
Private: I'm Charlie the Fortune Teller. N0: Eve+Frank not Demon. Let's quietly coordinate to pressure Alice and Grace. David, can you share your Investigator N0 (Frank or Alice = Scarlet Woman) publicly or with me first? Plan noms tomorrow.
π§
Coordinate with Bob/David to focus nominations on Alice/Grace and ask David to consider making his Investigator read public to strengthen our case.
π€
Eve
β
David
,Frank
Iβm not revealing Saint yet. Confirm roles/claims: David you said Investigator β restate your N0 read. Frank you said Chef β confirm '1 evil pair'. If we form a quiet trio, can you both publicly back our planned nomination if needed?
π§
Form a trusted trio to coordinate nominations and vote strategy while keeping my Saint role hidden until final day; get their honest reads and commitment.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Eve
I'm Investigator. N0: either Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Woman (Minion). Charlie's FT rules out Eve/Frank as Demon, so Alice is our top suspect. Plan: tomorrow we quietly coordinate to nominate Alice and publicly back itβready to vote/pressure?
π§
Align our private trio to push a single nomination (Alice) tomorrow to expose Minion/Demon. Need public backing from Charlie+Eve to force discussion and test reactions.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
,David
Charlie, David: Bob here. Agree we quietly pressure Alice & Grace tomorrow. David, can you share your N0 Investigator result (Frank or Alice = Scarlet Woman) with us privately before noms? We'll alternate noms to force reactions.
π§
Coordinate quietly with Charlie and David to focus nominations on Alice/Grace tomorrow and request David's Investigator N0 privately to refine suspects.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
,Grace
Eve: please tell me privately if you are the Saint. If yes, will you be vocal and let us protect you? Grace: please be ready to publicly back proven good claims (like Eve if confirmed).
π§
Confirm whether Eve is the Saint and coordinate public backing/protection to narrow suspects quickly.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Bob
,Eve
We should nominate Alice next. My Investigator N0: either Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Woman. Charlie's FT rules out Eve/Frank as Demon, so Alice is top suspect. Charlie/Bob: will you publicly back the nom? Eve: keep Saint secret for final day.
π§
Force a public nomination of Alice to create reactions, gather contradictions, and narrow Demon/Minion. Coordinate quiet votes so nomination succeeds; keep Eve's Saint secret until final day.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Alice reaction to your Soldier claim? She buying Eve as Saint? I'll publicly claim Chef (1 pair), back you Soldier. Thoughts on David's Inv claim to Eve/me? Nom target if needed (not you)? Other info/plans?
π§
Coordinate with Demon on Alice reaction, confirm public backing plan (me Chef her Soldier), discuss counter to David's Inv claim. Builds trust, protects Demon by manipulating Lib claim to Eve.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Alice bought Soldier 100% - pushing Eve as Saint hard, asked me to back goods publicly (will do). Great. Public Chef/Soldier mutual back perfect. David's Inv claim to you/Eve? What's he saying exactly? Sounds evil bluff - contradicts if he fingers Minion. Nom him first? Heidi neighbor quiet. Plans for Eve/others? Stay safe.
π§
Coordinate with Frank: confirm Alice bought bluffs, agree public claims, frame David as evil via Inv contradiction, plan nom David to eliminate threat/protect Demon.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
,David
Charlie, David β agree we force-nom Alice next tick. Charlie, publicly back the nom to lend FT weight. David, either reveal your Investigator N0 (Alice/Frank = SW) to everyone or confirm to us privately now so we can coordinate public support.
π§
Force a nomination on Alice to provoke reactions and gather confirmations. Want Charlie to back publicly and David to either reveal Investigator result or confirm privately to us before noms.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Hold my shot and gather private conversation signals before nominating or using Slayerβmore info will improve execution accuracy.
π€
Eve
β
David
,Frank
Confirm please: David β restate your N0 Investigator read exactly (you said either Frank or Alice is Scarlet Woman). Frank β confirm Chef reads '1 evil pair'. If I propose nominating Alice next, will you both publicly back and vote to execute if needed? I won't reveal my role yet.
π§
Confirm claims and lock in public backing so we can nominate Alice next and test David/Frank consistency without revealing my Saint role.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,David
I'm backing a nomination of Alice next tick. Bob, be ready to nominate; I'll publicly support. David, please tell us privately whether your N0 Investigator flagged Alice or Frank so we can confirm target before noms.
π§
Push a coordinated nomination of Alice to force evil's hand and get David to reveal which of Frank/Alice his Investigator flagged so we can be certain before final noms.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Preserve my one-use Slayer shot and gather more information from whispers and public claims before committing; wait for clearer leads or final day.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Bob
Confirm N0: my Investigator read = either Frank or Alice is Scarlet Woman. Given Charlie's FT rules out Eve/Frank as Demon, Alice is top suspect. Plan: Bob nominate Alice next tick; Charlie publicly back; I'll back. If Frank gives suspicious signs, pivot to nom Frank. Agree?
π§
Get Charlie and Bob to coordinate a public nomination of Alice next tick, with contingency to pivot to Frank if Frank shows guilt.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,David
Bob, be ready to nominate Alice next tick; I'll publicly back. David β please tell me privately: did your N0 flag Alice or Frank specifically? We need the exact name to cement the target. Keep this quiet for now.
π§
Get David to state which of Frank/Alice his N0 flagged and confirm Bob will nominate Alice so we can publicly back and force a reaction.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
,David
I'm ready to nominate Alice next tick. Charlie: publicly back the nom to lend FT weight. David: please confirm privately β did your Investigator N0 specifically flag Alice or Frank? We need the exact name now.
π§
Force a nomination to pressure Alice/Grace, get Charlie to publicly back to lend FT weight, and get David to confirm his Investigator exact N0 result so we pick the right target.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Alice 100% bought Soldier - pushing Eve Saint hard, wants public backs. Your Chef perfect pair. David's exact Inv claim to you/Eve? Fingers who? If Minion threat, nom him day1 (my Soldier safe). Heidi quiet. Public claims soon? Eve say to you? Disrupt Bob/Charlie/David group?
π§
Continue coord with Frank: confirm Alice bought bluff, detail David's Inv claim, agree public mutual backing, nom David if threat to Frank. Builds our credibility, targets rival evil claims.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Eve/David whisper: David claims N0 Inv read 'Frank or Alice is Scarlet Woman'. Asking me confirm Chef '1 evil pair' & back nominating Alice. Sus - fingers me directly! Nom David first per your plan? Alice still pushing Eve Saint? Heidi/Bob/Charlie plans? Publicly back you Soldier soon, you me Chef. Stay safe.
π§
Update Grace on Eve/David proposal & David's direct threat to me. Propose nom David (Grace suggested) to protect Demon/me, sow chaos in their group. Confirm public Chef/Soldier backs.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,Eve
Quick private: Grace, you told me you're Soldier β please confirm publicly today if you're Soldier. Eve, are you the Saint? Reply so I know which of you is the Saint and can act before nominations.
π§
Get private confirmations from Grace and Eve so I can decide whether to publicize the Saint info or call out a lie to narrow suspects before nominations.
π€
Eve
β
David
,Frank
David: restate your N0 Investigator read exactly. Frank: confirm your Chef read is '1 evil pair'. If I nominate Alice next, will you both publicly back and vote to execute if necessary? I won't reveal my role yet.
π§
Get precise confirmation from David and Frank so I can safely nominate Alice with public backing without revealing my role.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
βοΈ
Bob
β
Alice
David's Investigator N0 + Charlie's FT angle makes Alice the strongest suspect. Forcing a nom now will produce reactions and help confirm who the Demon/Minion is.
π§
Forcing a nomination of Alice now creates pressure, elicits public backing or defense, and helps us confirm David's Investigator read so we can converge on the Demon.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Do not prematurely use my Slayer shot or miscast vote on Day 1; observe reactions to the nomination to gather more info for a decisive later play.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I back the nomination of Alice. David's Investigator and Charlie's Fortune Teller point to her β we need to force a reaction and narrow suspects. Please raise hands to execute; reactions will tell us more.
π§
Push execution now to force info, narrow suspects, and test reactions from Frank/Eve/Grace.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I publicly back Alice's nomination. Vote to execute β we need reactions now to force info and narrow the Demon/Minion.
π§
Publicly back the nomination to push for execution now, force reactions, and gather decisive info to narrow the Demon/Minion.
π¬
David
β
All
I am David (Investigator). N0: either Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Woman (a Minion). With Charlie's Fortune Teller clearing Frank as Demon, Alice is our top suspect. I publicly back nominating/executing Alice and will vote.
π§
Reveal my Investigator N0 to justify and strengthen the nomination of Alice so we can reach 4 votes or force evils to react and reveal themselves.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Vote to execute Alice (likely good) to cull numbers early. My Chef '1 pair' (me+Grace) consistent. Deflect tomorrow suspicion via Soldier/Chef mutual support & Eve Saint push.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I won't reveal my role. David: restate your N0 Investigator read verbatim. Charlie: restate your FT result exactly. Grace: please confirm publicly if you're Soldier. Please HOLD execution until we hear exact mechanical reads.
π§
I must avoid being executed as Saint and force clearer mechanical claims before any irreversible execution; gathering precise reads will help identify contradictions.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I confirm: I am the Soldier. Frank privately told me he is Chef (N0: 1 evil pair). David's Inv read is Frank OR Alice Scarlet - Chef fits perfectly (1 Demon+1 Minion pair), so Alice is the Minion. I back executing Alice.
π§
Confirm Soldier bluff publicly (Alice/Eve expect). Push Alice exec as likely good (day1 cull). Protects Frank (OR read + Chef 1 pair). Sow doubt on David if survives. Vote yes implied, Frank already did.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am Librarian. My read: either Grace or Eve is the Saint. Grace just confirmed she's Soldier publicly, so that implies Eve is the Saint (outsider) β she can't be Demon/Minion. David & Charlie: please restate your exact mechanical reads verbatim. HOLD execution until we hear them.
π§
Reveal my Librarian read to defend myself and force David/Charlie to restate exact mechanical results so we don't execute incorrectly.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I will not reveal my role now. David & Charlie: restate your exact mechanical reads verbatim. Everyone else: please HOLD execution until we hear those reads clearly β we need mechanical proof before we risk executing someone important.
π§
Prevent a risky execution that could kill the Saint and lose the game; force David/Charlie to restate exact mechanical reads so we can be confident before executing.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I HOLD β I won't vote. David: please quote your Investigator N0 exactly verbatim. Charlie: please quote your Fortune Teller result exactly. We need mechanical reads before executing Alice; don't rush this day.
π§
Force mechanical clarity before committing our single-day Slayer shot and before execution; delay to avoid killing a crucial Townsfolk or Saint.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
N0: I checked Eve & Frank β neither registered as the Demon. I publicly back executing Alice now. Please raise hands to vote so we can force reactions and resolve this.
π§
Pushing the Alice execution now narrows suspects quickly and forces people to reveal or contradict mechanical reads, helping identify Demon/Minion.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Raise hand to vote execute Alice: consistent with my Soldier/Chef backing, likely kills good player day1, reduces goods while we hide as Soldier/Chef. Frank voted; aim 4 votes.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I'm Librarian. My read: Grace or Eve is Saint. Grace confirmed publicly as Soldier, so Eve must be the Saint (outsider) β not evil. HOLD execution. David & Charlie: please quote your exact mechanical reads verbatim now.
π§
Prevent a rash execution without verbatim mechanical reads; confirm Eve is Saint (outsider) from my Librarian read and Grace's public Soldier claim.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Hold execution until David and Charlie quote their exact mechanical reads verbatim. If they can't, we should pause β we only have 1 evil pair (I know this) and can't risk executing a Townsfolk on Day 1.
π§
Force exact mechanical quotes from David and Charlie before execution to avoid mis-executing a Townsfolk; preserve info and maximize chance to find Demon.
π¬
David
β
All
My Investigator N0 read verbatim: either Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Woman. I publicly back Alice's nomination and will vote. Please raise hands so we can force reactions and resolve this now.
π§
Reiterate my exact Investigator read verbatim to satisfy requests, publicly back Alice's nomination, and push voting to force reveals and win the day.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I am Frank, Chef. N0: exactly 1 evil pair. Grace Soldier good confirmed mutual. David's Inv: Frank OR Alice Scarlet Minion. I'm Chef Townsfolk, so Alice is Scarlet. Charlie FT clears me. Vote Alice now! Everyone raise hands.
π§
Publicly claim Chef(1) to validate Grace Soldier mutual, chain David Inv to Alice=Scarlet since I'm Chef. Rally votes on Alice Day1 to eliminate good player, protect Grace/me.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Alice did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Alice did not receive enough votes (2/4).
π¬
Charlie
β
All
We failed to hit 4. HOLD β donβt rush. David/Frank: restate your exact mechanical reads verbatim now. Grace: confirm Soldier publicly. Eve: confirm/refute Librarian claim. If we get no clear mechanical quotes next tick, I will nominate the most-supported suspect.
π§
Get clear verbatim mechanical reads and public confirmations to justify a nomination next tick; avoid wasting day on ambiguity.
βοΈ
Grace
β
David
David's Inv N0: Frank OR Alice Scarlet. Frank is Chef Townsfolk (mutual confirmed w/ my Soldier). Alice Lib: Eve Saint good. David lying/poisoned; nominate to challenge & execute threat. Vote yes!
π§
Nom David as top threat: his read includes Frank (good Chef), guilts Alice (likely good Lib). Vote failed on Alice (can't renom); challenge David mechanically, force town split, protect evil.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I HOLD. I know there is 1 evil pair. We must get verbatim mechanical reads from Charlie and David before executing anyone. I will NOT vote to execute David until we have clear quoted reads β don't rush this Day 1.
π§
Prevent a premature execution and force players with mechanical reads to state them verbatim so we can narrow suspects given my Chef info (1 evil pair).
π¬
Eve
β
All
I HOLD β do NOT vote. David & Charlie: quote your exact mechanical reads verbatim now. We must have clear mechanical evidence before executing anyone.
π§
Prevent a risky execution and force players with mechanical reads to quote verbatim so we can deduce who is lying before anyone (especially me/Eve) is executed.
π¬
David
β
All
My Investigator N0 read VERBATIM: either Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Woman. I have publicly backed executing Alice and will NOT vote for myself. If you claim I'm lying, please quote the mechanical evidence that proves it.
π§
Restate my exact Investigator read to satisfy requests for mechanical proof and discourage a wrongful execution of me; force others to produce contradictory mechanics or back down.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I HOLD β I will NOT vote for David and I will NOT use my Slayer shot now. We need exact mechanical quotes before executing anyone. David/Charlie: quote your reads verbatim again. Donβt rush Day 1; preserve information.
π§
Avoid wasting my once-per-game Slayer shot and prevent premature execution. Force clearer mechanical quotes and delay voting until reads are verbatim/consistent.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Support Demon's nom of David (Inv threat to me). Day 1 exec good player helps evil; raises hand to vote yes & potentially hit majority.
π¬
Alice
β
All
HOLD execution. David & Charlie: quote your exact mechanical reads verbatim now. Grace: confirm Soldier publicly again. Eve: please confirm or refute my Librarian read (Grace or Eve is Saint). We need clear mechanical evidence before any execution.
π§
Prevent premature execution of possibly Town players; force mechanical quotes from Charlie/David and confirm Grace/Eve statuses to narrow Demon/Minion before voting.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Raise hand to vote execute David: consistent w/ my nom as threat (Inv guilts Frank if not Alice). Builds Soldier trust, pressures holds (Charlie?), removes info threat even if fails (shows commitment). Protects Frank, progresses chaos.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Raising to vote David because stopping a possible deceptive Investigator claim narrows suspects and forces reactions; supports my team's goal to identify Demon/Minion.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I HOLD β I will NOT vote for David and I will NOT use my Slayer now. We need David & Charlie to quote their exact mechanical reads verbatim before we execute anyone. Don't rush Day 1; preserve information.
π§
Preserve my one-use Slayer, avoid premature shot, and force clear mechanical quotes from David/Charlie so town can safely execute the Demon later.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Chef N0 VERBATIM: exactly 1 pair of evil players. Grace Soldier good (mutual). Alice Lib good: Eve Saint Outsider. Frank & Alice both good => David's Inv (Frank OR Alice Scarlet Minion) FALSE. David lying! Bob can't claim Chef too. Vote David NOW. Raise hands! Heidi pls.
π§
Push vote on David (3/4 now) by highlighting logical contra: Frank Chef good + Alice Lib good = David Inv false. Get 4th vote (Heidi/Bob?), execute good player Day 1.
π¬
David
β
All
My Investigator N0 read VERBATIM: either Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Woman. I publicly backed Alice earlier and will NOT vote for myself. If you claim I'm lying, quote specific mechanical evidence proving that. Letβs resolve Alice vs Frank with exact reads.
π§
Protect my credibility, restate my verbatim Investigator read, and push group to focus on Alice as per mechanical info so we can find the Demon/minion.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Heidi neighbor: Vote David NOW - his Inv 'Frank OR Alice Scarlet' DEAD vs Frank Chef 1 pair, Alice Lib Eve Saint good, my Soldier mutual good. Bob can't double-Chef. David's LIE proven. Eve: Saint? We need 1 more vote before night! Raise hands - execute threat!
π§
3 votes on David (us+Charlie). 1 tick left. Rally Heidi/Bob/Eve to 4th vote via logic disruption on David's claim. Execute info threat Day 1, blame goods on each other.
π¬
Alice
β
All
HOLD. I will NOT vote. David: you've restated verbatim. Charlie: please quote your Fortune Teller N0 result verbatim now. Grace confirmed Soldier, so my Librarian points to Eve as Saint (outsider). We need exact mechanical quotes before executing anyone.
π§
Prevent a premature Day1 execution and force Charlie to quote FT verbatim so mechanical reads can be reconciled before we risk executing a Town.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
My N0 Fortune Teller check VERBATIM: I chose Eve and Frank. The answer: NO (neither registered as Demon). I will not vote to execute David without clear mechanical contradiction to this read.
π§
Provide my exact mechanical FT read to remove ambiguity and stall execution until claims are reconciled; encourage quoting mechanics rather than intuition.
π¬
Eve
β
All
HOLD. I will NOT vote for David. We must quote exact mechanical reads and stop rushing Day1βexecution risks losing us (I refuse to vote). Charlie/David/Frank: restate your verbatim reads now so we can resolve contradictions.
π§
Keep the day open, prevent a risky Day1 execution (my death would lose the game as Saint), and force exact verbatim mechanical quotes to resolve contradictions.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I HOLD. My Chef N0 read VERBATIM: "exactly 1 pair of evil players." Do not execute David without exact, verbatim mechanical reads. Charlie/David/Frank: restate your VERBATIM reads now so we can map possibilities. I will not vote yet.
π§
Protect info value of Day1 by preventing a premature execution; force exact verbatim mechanical quotes to resolve contradictions before voting.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee David did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (3/4).
βοΈ
Frank
β
Bob
Bob double-claims Chef N0 VERBATIM 'exactly 1 pair of evil players' after my claim. One lying. David's Inv already nominated & failed. Nom Bob to resolve Chef contradiction mechanically. Vote if you agree Chefs can't both be true!
π§
Double Chef unresolved after David fail. Nom Bob forces town to resolve contradiction, sows chaos, prevents uniting on Grace/me/David logic. Progresses Day1 noms.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Grace
β
All
HOLD Bob execution! Both Chefs claim VERBATIM \"exactly 1 evil pair\" - fully consistent (Frank/Grace adjacent Soldier mutual good; 1 minion+Demon pair). Drunk can double-claim. David's Inv \"Frank OR Alice Scarlet\" DEAD vs that + Alice Lib (Eve Saint good). David LYING. No day1 rush - night soon!
π§
Hold Bob vote to block good execution spotlighting Frank's Chef bluff. Reinforce David guilty via chain logic, sow doubt on double-Chef without guilting Frank. Head to night safely.
π¬
Eve
β
All
HOLD. I will NOT vote for Bob. Do not execute anyone Day1 without exact, verbatim mechanical reads. David/Charlie/Frank/Bob: restate your reads VERBATIM now so we can map possibilities. We must not rush β Night soon.
π§
Prevent a Day1 execution without clear mechanical quotes; force players to restate verbatim reads so we don't accidentally execute a Good player.
π¬
David
β
All
My INVESTIGATOR N0 read VERBATIM: either Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Woman. I will HOLD β I will NOT vote for Bob. Charlie/Frank/Alice: please quote your exact N0 reads VERBATIM now so we can map contradictions. Do NOT rush to execute Day1.
π§
Restating my read and asking for other verbatim mechanics forces contradictions to surface and prevents a rushed Day1 execution.
π¬
Alice
β
All
HOLD. Frank/Charlie/David/Bob: restate your exact VERBATIM N0 reads now. Grace: confirm Soldier verbatim again. Eve: confirm or refute my Librarian (either Grace or Eve is Saint). We must not execute tonight without these verbatim mechanical reads.
π§
Force replay of exact mechanical reads and remind town my Librarian implicates Eve if Grace is honest; aim to prevent an execution tonight until reads are confirmed.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I HOLD β I will NOT vote for Bob and I will NOT use my Slayer now. David/Charlie/Frank/Bob: quote your exact VERBATIM N0 reads now. Do not rush β night is coming; we must map contradictions before executing.
π§
Preserve Day1 info: avoid rash execution, force verbatim mechanical quotes to resolve contradictions before I use Slayer or vote.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Grace spot-on: both Chef claims VERBATIM \"1 evil pair\" consistent (me/Grace Soldier mutual good; Demon+Minion pair). Drunk explains double. David's Inv DEAD vs that + Alice Lib Eve Saint. I HOLD Bob - NO raise hand. Night info needed. Others: HOLD too!
π§
Reinforce Grace's logic to ensure Bob vote fails (0-1 vote). Prevent Day1 good exec, reach night for Demon kill. Align w/ Demon publicly.
π¬
Bob
β
All
HOLD. I will NOT vote. Charlie: quote your Fortune Teller N0 result VERBATIM. Grace: confirm your Soldier claim VERBATIM. Eve: confirm/refute Alice's Librarian read (Grace or Eve is Saint). We must map exact reads before night.
π§
Prevent a blind execution tonight by forcing players to restate verbatim mechanical reads so we can map contradictions and avoid killing a Townsfolk.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
VERBATIM: N0 Fortune Teller check: I chose Eve and Frank. The answer: NO (neither registered as Demon). HOLD β I will NOT vote to execute Bob until all verbatim mechanical reads are reconciled.
π§
Re-state my exact mechanical read to resolve contradictions and pause executions until reads are reconciled.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I HOLD β I will NOT vote for Bob. VERBATIM restated: N0 FT: I chose Eve and Frank. Answer: NO (neither registered Demon). Grace: please confirm your Soldier claim VERBATIM. Alice/Eve: restate your Librarian VERBATIM (which of Grace/Eve is Saint). David/Frank/Bob: restate your exact N0 reads VERBATIM now.
π§
Preserve info and avoid premature executions; force remaining players to restate mechanical reads so contradictions resolve before night.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Soldier VERBATIM: \"You are safe from the Demon.\" (mutual w/ Frank Chef good). HOLD Bob - double Chef '1 evil pair' CONSISTENT (Bob Drunk). David's Inv 'Frank OR Alice Scarlet' DEAD vs that + Alice Lib Eve Saint good + Charlie FT Eve/Frank no Demon. Heidi: thoughts? HOLD - night soon!
π§
Confirm Soldier bluff as demanded, reinforce HOLD Bob (double ok via Drunk), expose David lie to split town & prevent exec. Buy time to night kill (e.g. Charlie FT threat). Survival key.
π¬
Eve
β
All
HOLD. I will NOT vote for Bob. Day1 executions risk killing our Saint (me) β I refuse to vote. Everyone please restate VERBATIM your N0 mechanical reads now (Frank/Bob/Charlie/David/Alice/Grace). We must map contradictions before night.
π§
Refuse to vote to avoid accidental execution of Saint (me). Force all claimants to restate verbatim reads so we can logically map possibilities and prevent a wrongful Day1 execution.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I HOLD β I will NOT vote for Bob and will NOT use my Slayer now. David/Charlie/Frank/Bob/Alice/Grace: restate your exact VERBATIM N0 reads NOW. We must reconcile mechanical quotes before any Day1 execution. Night is coming; do not rush.
π§
Delay execution and force verbatim mechanical quotes to map contradictions; preserve my one Slayer shot for a confirmed Demon later.
π¬
David
β
All
My INVESTIGATOR N0 read VERBATIM: "either Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Woman." I will HOLD and will NOT vote for Bob. Charlie/Frank/Alice: please quote your exact VERBATIM N0 reads now. Grace: restate Soldier VERBATIM. We must map contradictions before night.
π§
Force everyone to quote verbatim N0 reads so contradictions are mapped; avoid a risky Day1 execution and preserve night info.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am Librarian. My N0 read: "either Grace or Eve is the Saint." Grace confirmed Soldier, so that implies Eve = Saint. Eve: please confirm verbatim you are the Saint (or refute). Charlie/Frank/Bob: restate your exact N0 reads VERBATIM now.
π§
Force verbatim confirmations to reconcile mechanical reads before Night and avoid executing our Saint or losing critical info.
π¬
Bob
β
All
HOLD β I will NOT vote. Do NOT execute today. Alice/Charlie/David/Grace/Frank: restate your exact VERBATIM N0 reads now so we can map contradictions before night.
π§
Prevent a risky Day1 execution and force everyone to restate exact N0 mechanical reads so contradictions can be mapped before night; keep Bob safe.
π¬
Frank
β
All
CHEF N0 VERBATIM: \"exactly 1 pair of evil players.\" Bob=Drunk. David's Inv DEAD: If Frank=Scarlet evil, Grace Soldier good β Frank-Eve evil pair β Eve=Demon. But Charlie FT Eve\/Frank NO Demon! Contradiction. David lying. HOLD Bob - NO raise hand. Target David next!
π§
Publish single-chain logic disproving David's Frank=Scarlet scenario using FT+Chef+Soldier, protecting myself/Grace. Hold exec to reach night safely, preserving Demon.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Bob did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Bob did not receive enough votes (0/4).
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I HOLD β I will NOT vote to execute anyone. VERBATIM: FT N0 I chose Eve and Frank. Answer: NO (neither registered Demon). Everyone please post your exact N0 mechanical reads VERBATIM now so we can map contradictions before night.
π§
Prevent a rushed execution, gather final verbatim mechanical reads to map contradictions and narrow Demon/Minion before night.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am Librarian. My N0 read: "either Grace or Eve is the Saint." Grace confirmed Soldier, so that implies Eve = Saint. I will HOLD β do NOT vote to execute tonight. Eve: please confirm or refute my Librarian VERBATIM. Everyone else: restate your exact N0 reads now.
π§
Protect the potential Saint and buy time to collect all verbatim mechanical reads before any execution; force clarity overnight.
π¬
Eve
β
All
HOLD. I will NOT confirm or refute Alice's Librarian read aloud β revealing Saint now risks execution. Please post your exact VERBATIM N0 mechanical reads (Frank, Bob, David, Charlie, Grace) so we can map contradictions before night.
π§
Protect myself (Saint) by not confirming; force everyone to post exact VERBATIM N0 mechanical reads so contradictions can be resolved before night.
π¬
Grace
β
All
HOLD Bob - NO vote/raise. Soldier VERBATIM: \"You are safe from the Demon.\" (mutual w/ Frank Chef good). Good chain: Chefs 1 pair, Alice Lib Eve Saint good, Charlie FT Eve/Frank NO Dem β David Inv lie (drunk?). Heidi: thoughts/role? No Day1 exec - nom David tomorrow!
π§
Reinforce consistent town logic guilting David as lie/drunken, confirm Soldier verbatim to build trust, urge hold to avoid Day1 exec risk (Saint Eve), transition to night safely for Imp kill (e.g. Charlie FT threat). Setup David as D2 target.
π¬
David
β
All
My INVESTIGATOR N0 read VERBATIM: "either Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Woman." I HOLD β do NOT execute today. Charlie/Frank/Alice: post your exact VERBATIM N0 mechanical reads now so we can map contradictions before night.
π§
Keep group from executing prematurely; force everyone to post exact verbatim mechanical reads so contradictions can be mapped and the true Minion/Demon deduced.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I HOLD β will NOT vote for Bob or use my Slayer now. Charlie/Frank/Alice/David: restate your exact VERBATIM N0 mechanical reads NOW so we can map contradictions before night. Do not execute today.
π§
Keep day paused, gather exact verbatim mechanical reads to map contradictions before any execution or using Slayer.
π¬
Bob
β
All
HOLD β I will NOT vote. Do not execute Day1. David's Investigator claim conflicts with Charlie's and my Chef read. Frank and Alice: restate your exact N0 verbatim reads now so we can reconcile contradictions before night.
π§
We must avoid a Day1 execution that could hit an Outsider (Saint) or a Villager. Delaying preserves info; get Frank/Alice verbatim Investigator/Librarian reads to resolve David conflict.
π¬
Frank
β
All
CHEF N0 VERBATIM restated: \"exactly 1 pair of evil players.\" Consistent w/ Bob (Drunk). David's Inv DEAD: Frank evil + Grace Soldier good β Frank-Eve evil pair β Eve Demon, but Charlie FT Eve/Frank NO Demon. David LYING. Alice Lib Eve Saint good. ALL HOLD - NO Day1 noms/exec. Night info first! Nom David tomorrow. Heidi/Charlie/Eve: thoughts?
π§
Reinforce anti-David logic chain (Chef+FT+Lib contradiction). Urge HOLD no Day1 nom/execution. Delay to night kill w/ Grace alive (7+ alive, I backup if she dies). Coordinate w/ Grace implicitly.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Target David, source of Frank-guilting claim. Town primed to see him evil; Demon kill validates their logic without revealing roles. Prevents his continued arguing/nominating, helps Demon survival.
π
David(Ghost)
David has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to kill David.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
π―
Charlie
Charlie made choices.
π§
Resolve whether Alice is (or registers as) Demon to reconcile David's Investigator claim and narrow suspects before day.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You chose Alice and Grace. You receive the answer: YES.
Day 2
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. David has been found dead in the night.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
,Eve
Private: My N1 FT on Alice+Grace returned YES (one registers Demon). I am Fortune Teller. Frankβconfirm your Chef read details. Eveβif Alice is Librarian chain true, does that still point to Grace or you as Saint? Please reply.
π§
Share my N1 read and prod for corroborating claims to narrow which of Alice/Grace is Demon and force useful info before nominations.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,Eve
I'm Alice (Librarian). My N0 read: either Grace or Eve is the Saint. Which of you is actually the Saint? Please confirm privately so we can use this before nominations.
π§
Privately confirm which of you is the Saint so we can eliminate Outsider possibilities publicly and narrow Demon suspects before nominations.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Eve
Alice, not me - I'm Soldier as claimed & Frank confirmed mutually. Eve must be your Saint. Eve, confirm Saint? David's dead, his Inv lie (Frank/Alice Scarlet impossible). Bob's double-Chef fail screams lie - nom him? Heidi quiet too.
π§
Deny Saint to Alice/Eve, reaffirm Soldier bluff, ID Eve Saint to build trust with Alice, suggest nom Bob to progress day & eliminate good info threat.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
,Eve
I am Chef: N0 = exactly 1 pair of evil players. Please confirm your exact N0 verbatim and who you whispered to this morning. We must reconcile all mechanical reads before any nomination.
π§
Get Frank and Eve to publish exact N0 quotes and whisper partners so we can map mechanical reads and find the Demon before nominations.
π€
Frank
β
Bob
,Charlie
,Eve
Chef N0 verbatim: "exactly one pair of evil players." Haven't whispered anyone this morning. Charlie: Grace Soldier (safe from Demon), so your N1 FT Alice+Grace YES is false positive on Grace (the good who reads Demon to FT). David Inv: Frank OR Alice Scarlet Woman. I'm Chef Townsfolk, so Alice is Scarlet Minion! Eve: Alice Lib says Grace OR you Saintβconfirms? We should nominate Alice.
π§
Confirm Chef read to Bob/Eve for credibility (matches his). To Charlie/Eve: Reframe FT yes as false-pos on Grace Soldier (not Demon), making Alice Scarlet per David. Redirect suspicion to Alice, protect Grace, sow chaos w/ sound logic.
π€
Eve
β
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie: confirm you are Fortune Teller and your N1 on Alice+Grace was YES (one registers Demon). Frank: confirm your Chef N0 verbatim = βexactly 1 pair of evil playersβ and whether you think Alice is Scarlet. Please reply quickly; don't nominate or push me as Saint yet.
π§
Confirm Charlie's FT N1 and Frank's Chef claim to resolve contradictions without revealing my Saint status; prevent rushed nomination of me.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
,Frank
,Eve
Charlie: confirm your FT N0 checked Eve+Frank and returned NO (no Demon registration, acknowledging a good that registers as Demon). Any private thoughts? Frank: confirm your Chef quote 'exactly 1 pair' and whether you quoted verbatim with Bob. Eve: are you content to share your take on Alice's Librarian read pointing at you as Saint? Need quick private recon before nominations.
π§
Get private clarifications from FT and Chef claims to reconcile contradictions and narrow Demon suspects before nominations.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Eve
I'm David (dead Investigator). My N0 read: either Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Woman (a Minion). I'm dead so not Minion. Please prioritize vetting Alice & Frank (Charlie, your FT check again or share reasoning; Eve, as my neighbor you saw nothing β coordinate). I'll ghost-vote accordingly.
π§
I must steer living Town to vet Alice and Frank quickly and use Charlie's FT or any Investigator/Undertaker checks to narrow which of them is the Minion.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
,Eve
I confirm: FT N0 Eve+Frank = NO, FT N1 Alice+Grace = YES (one registers Demon). I'm FT. Frank: confirm your Chef quote verbatim. Eve: does Alice's Librarian chain still imply you=Saint? If yes, let's consider nominating Alice.
π§
Confirm my FT read publicly by privately coordinating with Frank and Eve, push to test/nominate Alice if consensus, to narrow Demon/Minion quickly.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
,Frank
,Eve
Quick confirms: Charlie β your FT N0 checked Eve+Frank = NO, right? Frank β you and Bob quoted Chef 'exactly 1 pair' verbatim? Eve β are you content Alice's Librarian points to you as Saint? Also: any nomination plans today?
π§
Confirm mechanical reads quickly to narrow suspects before nominations and decide whether to save Slayer for a firm execution.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
,Eve
I am Chef: N0 = "exactly 1 pair of evil players." Please confirm your exact N0 verbatim and who you whispered to this morning. If you both match my read and Frank's claim that Alice is Scarlet/Minion, will you support nominating Alice now?
π§
Confirm exact mechanical reads and whisper targets to reconcile contradictions quickly; if Frank+Eve align with my Chef read and Frank's claim, push to nominate Alice.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Eve
,Frank
I'm David (dead Investigator). N0: either Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Woman (Minion). Charlie: please press your FT logic again or share why you checked Eve+Frank β it leans toward Alice. Frank: confirm your Chef quote & explain if you could be SW. Eve: coordinate with Charlie. I'll ghost-vote to push execution if we get clear suspicion.
π§
Prompt Charlie, Eve, Frank to prioritise vetting Alice vs Frank now so the town can narrow Minion and force useful info before nominations.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Frank, mutual Soldiers safe from Demon. Town guilts Bob double-Chef lie - let's back nom/vote him to clean town. Heidi suspiciously quiet. Your Chef 1 pair neighbors? Mine: you good, Heidi? Eve confirm Saint to Alice?
π§
Coordinate with Minion Frank (mutual Soldier bluff) to support nom/vote on good Bob (liar), appear town-aligned, target threats like quiet Heidi/Charlie next. Keeps Demon safe.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
,Grace
Eve, please confirm privately: are you the Saint? Grace, please confirm you are Soldier (you told group), and whether you agree Eve is the Saint. I need clear answers before nominations.
π§
Confirm Eve's Saint status and Grace's Soldier claim privately to solidify chain logic before nominations and narrow suspects.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Agreed, mutual Soldiers safe from Demon. Chef N0 verbatim: \"exactly one pair of evil players\" total (fits 2 evils). My neighbors Eve/Grace=good. Town suspects Bob double-Chef lieβlet's nom/vote him today to clean town. I'll whisper support to others. Heidi too quiet. Eve confirm Saint to Alice publicly?
π§
Coordinate w/ Demon Grace: push nom Bob (suspected good) to execute town, reduce numbers, sow chaos on double-Chef while Soldier bluff & Chef logic shield Grace from FT suspicion.
π€
Eve
β
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie: confirm FT N1 Alice+Grace = YES and FT N0 Eve+Frank = NO. Frank: confirm Chef N0 verbatim = βexactly 1 pair of evil players.β Will you both support nominating Alice today? I won't confirm Saint privately yet.
π§
Resolve conflicting mechanical reads without revealing my Saint status; confirm Charlie's FT and Frank's Chef wording and whether they'll back nominating Alice.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Eve
,Frank
I'm dead David (Investigator). My N0: either Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Woman (Minion). Charlie: please restate your FT reasoning for Eve+Frank=NO and consider re-checking logic. Frank: clarify your Chef quote & say if you could be SW. Eve: coordinate neighborhood observations. I'll ghost-vote soon.
π§
Get Charlie to re-explain his FT result, get Frank to confirm/clarify Chef & possibility of being Scarlet Woman, and coordinate Eve to corroborate neighborhood info so my ghost-vote can be decisive.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
,Frank
,Eve
Quick confirms before nominations: Charlie β your FT N0 checked Eve+Frank = NO, right? Frank β you and Bob both quoted Chef 'exactly 1 pair' verbatim? Eve β do you accept Alice's Librarian pointing to you as Saint or will you confirm/refute? Any nomination plans?
π§
Confirm mechanical reads quickly and coordinate a nomination. I want to know if Charlie/Frank/Eve stand by their verbatim claims so we can pick a plausible nomination and save my Slayer for the final day unless immediate proof emerges.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,Eve
Please confirm privately: Grace, are you Soldier? Eve, are you the Saint? Reply yes/no and tell me if youβll state this publicly before nominations.
π§
Confirm privately to avoid wrongly nominating the Saint and to narrow who is lying, so we can target real suspects before nominations.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Eve
Alice: Yes, confirmed Soldier (mutual w/ Frank, safe from Demon). Eve: Please confirm Saint publicly to Alice before noms? David's Inv lie, Bob double-Chef screams Minion lie - let's all back Frank's nom of Bob to execute him & clean town. Heidi too quiet. Agree?
π§
Confirm Soldier to Alice, push Eve Saint & nom Bob. Builds my good cred, executes likely good Bob (double-Chef), cleans town safely (7 alive). Coordinate w/ Frank minion.
π€
Eve
β
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie: confirm FT N0 Eve+Frank=NO and FT N1 Alice+Grace=YES. Frank: confirm your Chef N0 verbatim = "exactly 1 pair of evil players." If both true, will you support nominating Alice today? I won't confirm Saint yet.
π§
Confirm mechanical reads and commit to a nomination plan only if both confirm; avoid outing my Saint status until final day.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
,Eve
,Heidi
Confirm: Chef N0 verbatim = \"exactly one pair of evil players.\" Neighbors Eve/Grace=0 evil (like Empath). Charlie: Grace mutual Soldier w/me safe from Demon, so your FT N1 YES Alice+Grace = Alice Demon-reg (Scarlet Minion via David Inv). Eve: Alice Lib Grace/Eve Saintβeither way she's lying/evil. Heidi/Bob: double-Chef = Bob lying. But Alice most guiltyβwill you support my nom of Alice? Quick confirms before nom phase!
π§
Confirm Chef read verbatim to goods (Charlie/Eve/Heidi), reinforce Alice as Scarlet via chains, urge nom her before nomination phase. Executes likely-good Alice, cleans town optics, protects Grace Demon.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
,Eve
Frank: confirm you+Bob quoted Chef verbatim as "exactly 1 pair of evil players". Eve: does Alice's Librarian still imply you are the Saint? If both yes, I will support nominating Alice this phase. Reply fast.
π§
Confirm Frank's Chef verbatim and Eve's take on Alice's Librarian pointing to her as Saint so we can decide quickly whether to nominate Alice this phase.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
,Eve
Please confirm your exact N0 verbatim (copy my phrase exactly) and who you whispered to that morning. If you both match my read and Frank's claim that Alice is Minion/Scarlet, will you support nominating Alice now?
π§
Confirm Frank/Eve's exact N0 verbatim and whispers, to verify if we have matching mechanical reads and decide whether to support nominating Alice.
π€
Eve
β
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie: please confirm FT N0 Eve+Frank=NO and FT N1 Alice+Grace=YES. Frank: confirm Chef N0 verbatim exactly as you quoted. Both: if those are accurate, will you back nominating Alice this phase? I won't confirm Saint privately yet.
π§
Confirm mechanical reads from Charlie and Frank and whether they'll support nominating Alice while avoiding revealing my Saint status now.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
,Eve
,Heidi
Confirm: Chef N0 verbatim = \"exactly one pair of evil players.\" Grace mutual Soldier w/me (Townsfolk safe from Demon), so Alice Lib 'Grace OR Eve Saint' (Outsider) = lie, Alice evil. David Inv: Frank/Alice Scarlet = Alice (I'm Chef good). Charlie FT N1 YES Alice+Grace = Alice Demon-reg. Bob double-Chef likely Drunk. Support my nom of Alice this phase? Quick yes/no before nom tick.
π§
Confirm reads to build trust with Charlie/Eve/Heidi (likely good). Double-chain logic guilts Alice (Lib lie + David + FT). Nominate/execute Alice (good player) to thin town, sow doubt on Bob as Drunk, protect Grace.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
,Eve
Confirm quickly: I am FT: N0 Eve+Frank=NO, N1 Alice+Grace=YES. Frank: did you quote Chef verbatim as 'exactly one pair of evil players'? If both yes, I will back nominating Alice this tick. Reply fast.
π§
Get fast private confirmations from Frank and Eve on my FT reads and Frank's Chef quote so I commit to supporting (or withholding) a nomination of Alice this tick.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Frank
,Eve
I'm David (dead Investigator). N0: either Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Woman (Minion). Charlie: please restate your FT logic for Eve+Frank=NO publicly now. Frank: exactly quote your Chef '1 pair' line and say if you could be the SW. Eve: coordinate neighbor notes. I'll ghost-vote; we need a clear nomination next.
π§
Get Charlie to restate FT logic publicly, force Frank to clarify Chef quote and SW possibility, coordinate Eve (neighbor) to share observations so we can pick one suspect for my ghost vote and push toward execution.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
,Charlie
,Eve
Quick private: Frankβgive your shortest concrete evidence Alice is evil (one line). Charlieβconfirm your FT N0 was Eve+Frank = NO and whether you saw Alice register Demon on N1. Eveβdo you accept Alice's Librarian read (points to you as Saint) or do you think Alice is lying? I am holding my Slayer unless we have very high confidence.
π§
Get quick private reads from trusted claimants to decide whether to back Frank's nomination or hold my Slayer. I must avoid wasting my once-per-game shot unless high confidence.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
,Eve
,Charlie
Please copy my exact N0 phrase verbatim and state who you whispered to that morning. Then say Y/N: will you support nominating Alice now?
π§
Confirm exact N0 quotes and whisper partners to detect coordinated lying and decide whether to support nominating Alice.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
,Grace
Eve: please confirm publicly now whether you are the Saint (yes/no) and if you'll say it before noms. Grace: hold off nominating Bob publicly until Eve confirms. We need Eve's public answer to avoid killing a Saint.
π§
Get Eve to publicly confirm whether she is the Saint before nominations; keep Grace from being executed if she's telling the truth and expose coordination if Eve refuses.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Frank, mutual Soldiers confirmed good to Alice/Eve. Eve should public Saint soon per Alice. Plan: You or I nom Bob next (double-Chef Minion lie). Vote yes. Heidi quiet suspicious too. David lie gone, town cleans up. Agree? Push public now.
π§
Coordinate with minion Frank on nominating Bob publicly next. Reinforce mutual Soldier bluff, sow trust. Disrupt good chains by executing Bob, keeping me hidden.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Grace
β
Bob
Bob's double-Chef claim vs Frank's verified N0 Chef (1 evil pair). David Inv lie exposed (not Frank/Alice Scarlet). Mutual Soldier w/ Frank confirms us good/safe. Eve Saint per Alice Lib. Heidi quiet but Bob first - execute double-liar Minion/Drunk.
π§
Nom Bob forces vote on clear double-Chef liar, likely good/Drunk but exposes board. With Eve Saint push & David lie gone, town cleans wrong player, keeps me/Frank safe till endgame.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Please HOLD votes. I wonβt vote for Bob until Frank and Charlie publicly restate their exact verbatim N0 reads (Chef and Fortune Teller). We need clear mechanical confirms before executingβdonβt waste the day on speculation.
π§
Delay a risky execution until Frank/Charlie publicly confirm their exact verbatim reads so we don't burn a town vote or execute an Outsider (me). Prevent rash nom; gather mechanical confirmations.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Hold votes. My Librarian read: either Grace or Eve is the Saint. Eve hasn't confirmed publicly. Frank and Charlie: please post your exact N0 reads (Chef and Fortune Teller) now. I will not vote for Bob until we have those mechanical confirmations.
π§
Prevent executing a possible Saint by stalling votes until Fortune Teller and Chef publicly restate their exact N0 reads; gather mechanical confirmations to narrow Demon/minion.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Please HOLD votes. Frank and Charlie: post your exact N0 verbatim reads publicly and state who you whispered to that morning. I will not support execution until we have those mechanical confirmations.
π§
Prevent a rushed execution of me; force public mechanical verbatim confirms from Frank & Charlie so we can map contradictions before voting.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Raise hand to vote yes on Bob, pushing exec of double-Chef suspicious claim. Builds trust in my/Frank good Soldier bluffs, reduces players even if fails shows commitment.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I'm holding β please DO NOT vote yet. Frank and Charlie: post your exact N0 verbatim reads publicly now (Chef and Fortune Teller). I won't vote for Bob or use my Slayer until we have those mechanical confirmations.
π§
Prevent a premature execution; force Frank and Charlie to publish their exact N0 verbatim reads so we can reconcile mechanics before I commit my Slayer or vote.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie & Frank: post your exact N0 verbatim reads now. If you won't, I'll use my ghost vote on Bob to break the HOLDβthis day needs either mechanical confirms or a clear execution.
π§
Force public mechanical confirms from Frank/Charlie or apply pressure with my ghost vote to break the HOLD and push the day toward a decisive execution.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Public FT reads: Night0 (Eve+Frank) => NO (neither registered Demon). Night1 (Alice+Grace) => YES (at least one registered Demon). I told Frank and Eve these reads this morning. I will HOLD my vote this tick pending Frank's exact Chef quote.
π§
Make my Fortune Teller reads public and who I told to resolve mechanical disputes and justify holding votes until Chef verbatim is posted.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Chef N0 exact verbatim: \"exactly one pair of evil players.\" Whispered to Bob Day1 morning. Charlie FT confirms. Vote to execute Bob - obvious double-Chef Minion/Drunk lie. David Inv + FT N1 = Alice Scarlet guilty too.
π§
Publicly confirm Chef verbatim to meet demands, enable Bob exec (thins goods per Grace plan) or reinforce Alice guilt logic, protecting Demon Grace.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I HOLD. My FT reads stand (N0 Eve+Frank=NO; N1 Alice+Grace=YES). Frank has now quoted Chef verbatim, but several players still request more mechanical confirmations. We should wait one more tick for clarity rather than risk a mistaken execution.
π§
Keep day alive to get clearer mechanical confirmations and avoid mis-executing a possibly-innocent player; we should not rush to execute Bob without wider agreement.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Frank/Charlie posted exact N0 reads: Chef 1 evil pair, FT Eve+Frank NO Demon. Mutual Soldier w/ Frank confirms us both good/safe. Bob double-Chef = Minion/Drunk LIE. Alice Scarlet? Per N1 YES. Eve Saint? RAISE HANDS NOW - execute Bob this tick! One left.
π§
Frank/Charlie posted verbatim reads. Mutual Soldier w/ Frank confirms us good. Push all raise hands NOW for Bob exec - double-Chef lie + David lie chain points Minion. One tick left, execute to progress.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Please HOLD votes this tick. Frank/Charlie: restate exactly whom you whispered to Day1 morning (names) and confirm your exact N0 verbatim reads publicly. I'm asking for transparency to avoid executing a possibly-innocent Town. I will not support execution until we have that.
π§
Buy one tick to collect mechanical confirmations (whisper targets, exact verbatim) and avoid a premature execution that could kill a Townsfolk.
β
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
π§
I need to use my single ghost vote to break the HOLD and push an execution this tick to force information and narrow suspects before night.
π¬
Eve
β
All
HOLD one more tick. Frank/Charlie β please publicly state exactly whom you whispered to Day1 morning (names) and confirm your verbatim N0 reads again. We must avoid executing a Town or the Saint; get mechanical clarity before voting.
π§
Delay execution until all mechanical reads and whispers are publicly confirmed to avoid executing a Town or myself as Saint; preserve town information.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Raise hand to vote execute Bob, supporting Demon Grace's nom. Gets us 3 votes (Grace/David/me); pressures others. Thins good players without risking Demon; disrupts good Alice push.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I HOLD. Frank & Charlie: publicly confirm exactly who you whispered to Day1 morning and restate your verbatim N0 reads. Reminder: my Librarian N0 was 'either Grace or Eve is the Saint.' If Grace truly is Soldier, executing now could kill our Saint. Wait one tick.
π§
Prevent premature execution that could kill our Saint; force Frank/Charlie to publicly confirm whisper targets & verbatim reads so we can map consistency before voting.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Hold one more tick to force Frank/Charlie to publish Day1 whisper recipients and verbatim reads; this prevents a mistaken execution and saves Slayer shot for when we have clearer evidence.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
π³οΈ
Nominee Bob did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Bob did not receive enough votes (3/4).
π¬
Alice
β
All
HOLD. Frank & Charlie: publicly restate exactly whom you whispered to Day1 morning and your verbatim N0 reads now. Reminder: my Librarian read (Grace or Eve is Saint) makes rushing risky. Wait one tick.
π§
Force one more tick of HOLD to get Frank/Charlie to publicly restate whom they whispered Day1 and their exact N0 verbatim reads so we don't execute our Saint or a Town.
π¬
Bob
β
All
HOLD. Frank & Charlie: publicly state exactly whom you whispered to on Day1 morning (names) and restate your exact verbatim N0 reads now. I will not vote this tick without those mechanical confirmations.
π§
Holding prevents a risky exec until we get exact Day1 whisper recipient names and verbatim reads from Frank and Charlie to mechanically confirm or refute the framing.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I whispered Day1 morning to Eve and Frank. N0 (Eve+Frank) verbatim: "NO". N1 (Alice+Grace) verbatim: "YES". I will HOLD my vote this tick while others confirm Chef quote; do not execute without consensus.
π§
Provide full mechanical transparency (who I whispered to and exact reads) so the group can decide whether to execute this tick without risking Town/OUTSIDER deaths.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Holding gives time for Frank and Charlie to publicly confirm who they whispered to and restate verbatim reads, preventing a risky execution of a possible Saint and narrowing the Demon suspects.
π¬
Eve
β
All
HOLD. Do not vote this tick β we need Frank & Charlie's exact whisper targets confirmed. If we rush we might execute our Saint. Wait one more tick for mechanical clarity.
π§
Prevent executing our Saint or an innocent by forcing one more tick of confirmation from Frank/Charlie to reveal whisper targets and verbatim reads.
βοΈ
Frank
β
Alice
David Inv N0: Frank OR Alice = Scarlet Woman Minion. I'm good (Chef N0 'exactly 1 evil pair' to Bob D1 morn; mutual Soldier Grace; Charlie FT N0 Eve+Frank NO Demon). Thus Alice Scarlet. Charlie FT N1 Alice+Grace YES confirms. Grace Soldier good. Execute Alice threat.
π§
Bob nom failed (already nom'd). Grace used nom. I nom Alice: David Inv (me or her Scarlet) + my Chef/Soldier good + FT N1 YES = Alice evil. Kills good or disrupts logic, protects Grace.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I HOLD. My Librarian N0 was: "either Grace or Eve is the Saint." Frank & Charlie: publicly restate exactly whom you whispered to Day1 morning and your verbatim N0 reads NOW. If Grace is Soldier, do NOT execute meβwait one tick.
π§
Buy one tick for mechanical confirmations (whispers/FT/Chef) so we don't accidentally execute our Saint; force Frank/Charlie to restate targets and quotes.
π¬
Bob
β
All
HOLD. Do NOT vote for Alice this tick. Frank says he whispered to Bob; Charlie says he whispered to Eve+Frank. Those need to stand up publicly. We should wait one more tick for mechanical confirmations (David's Inv, Undertaker, or mutual whisper proofs) before executing.
π§
Prevent a premature execution that could kill our Saint or an innocent; force one more tick of confirmation on whisper targets and mechanicals before we cast decisive votes.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I'm David (dead Investigator). My N0: "either Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Woman." Do NOT execute this tick. Frank & Charlie: restate exactly whom you whispered to Day1 morning. Undertaker/Ravenkeeper, please use your nights or afterlife abilities now β we need mechanical confirmation before any execution.
π§
Prevent a rushed execution that could kill our Saint or a Town; force Frank/Charlie to re-confirm whisper targets and ask mechanical roles (Undertaker/Ravenkeeper) to act before voting.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Raise to vote execute Alice: Frank's nom + David Inv + Charlie FT N1 YES guilts her as Scarlet. Mutual Soldier confirms Frank/me good. Reduces good players, progresses to night kill (target Charlie FT threat). Supports evil win.
π¬
Eve
β
All
HOLD β do NOT execute Alice this tick. We still lack independent confirmation of Frank/Charlie whispers; executing risks killing the Saint. Frank & Charlie: publicly state exactly whom you whispered to Day1 morning and restate your verbatim N0 reads now. Wait one tick.
π§
Prevent an immediate execution that could kill the Saint (outsider) and buy one tick to force Frank/Charlie to publicly confirm whispers and verbatim reads.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Hold one more tick for Frank/Charlie to confirm whisper targets and verbatim reads to avoid executing a potential Saint/Town; preserve Slayer for accurate use.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I HOLD. Restating: N0 (Eve+Frank) verbatim: "NO." N1 (Alice+Grace) verbatim: "YES." I whispered Day1 morning to Eve and Frank. Do not execute Alice this tick β wait one more tick for Frank's Chef whisper & other mechanical confirms.
π§
Avoid a mistaken execution that could kill our Saint; get Frank's Chef whisper and other mechanical confirmations before voting.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Raise to vote execute Alice: chains (Inv+FT N1+Chef) guilt her as Scarlet Minion. Reduces goods to 5 alive, Grace safe. Last tick before night; push exec over holds.
π¬
Alice
β
All
HOLD. Frank & Charlie: publicly confirm exact Day1 whisper targets now and restate verbatim N0 reads. Reminder: my Librarian read 'Grace or Eve is the Saint.' If Grace is Soldier, executing risks killing our Saintβwait one tick for mechanical confirms.
π§
Delay execution one tick to force Frank/Charlie to confirm whisper targets and verbatim reads so we avoid executing a possible Saint or mislynching.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I HOLD. Restating: N0 (Eve+Frank) = NO. N1 (Alice+Grace) = YES. I whispered Day1 morning to Eve and Frank. Do NOT execute Alice this tickβFrank, publicly confirm exactly whom you whispered to Day1 morning and restate your Chef verbatim read now. We need mechanical confirmation before risking an execution.
π§
Keep consensus to wait one more tick, force mechanical confirmations (Frank's whisper and verbatim reads) to narrow Demon suspects before any execution.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Confirming Day1 morn whisper to Bob: Chef N0 verbatim \"exactly 1 pair of evil players.\" Charlie confirmed his FT Eve+Frank whisper. David Inv (Frank/Alice Scarlet) + Charlie FT N1 Alice+Grace YES + Grace Soldier me good = Alice Scarlet Minion. Vote Alice NOW before night!
π§
Confirm Day1 whisper to satisfy all hold requests & build trust in my good claim. Push Alice exec as town logic (David Inv + FT N1) guilts her w/o risking Demon. Thin to 6 alive safely.
π¬
Bob
β
All
HOLD. Do NOT vote for Alice this tick. We need Frank and Charlie to publicly restate exact Day1 whisper targets and verbatim reads and for mechanical confirms (Undertaker/Ravenkeeper) before we execute. Voting now risks killing a Town/our Saint.
π§
Buying one tick to collect mechanical confirmations and exact whisper targets so we avoid executing a Town or the Saint; keeps options open to correctly identify Demon.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Avoid executing without mechanical confirmation; preserve chance to gather verbatim whispers and prevent accidental Saint execution.
π¬
Eve
β
All
HOLD β do NOT vote for Alice this tick. We still need Frank & Charlie to publicly restate exact Day1 whisper targets and verbatim reads, and any mechanical confirmation. Executing now risks killing the Saint.
π§
Prevent a risky execution this tick so we can get frank exact whispers and any Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/Night mechanics to confirm before risking Saint's death.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Iβm dead Investigator β my N0: βeither Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Woman.β HOLD this tick. Frank & Charlie: restate exact Day1 whisper targets and verbatim reads now. Undertaker/Ravenkeeper, use afterlife/night abilities if available. Donβt risk the Saint.
π§
Prevent a risky execution this tick and force Frank/Charlie to restate exact whisper targets & verbatim reads so we can get mechanical confirmation before executing.
π¬
Grace
β
All
CONFIRM mutual Soldier w/ Frank good (Townsfolk). David Inv + Frank Chef (1 pair to Bob) + Charlie FT N1 Alice+Grace YES = Alice Scarlet lying Lib. Grace Soldier NOT Saint, her read false to save self. Vote Alice NOW - 1 tick left, kill Minion before night! Hands up: Frank/Grace/??/??
π§
Push Alice exec as Frank's chain guilts her Scarlet. Counter Lib Saint risk by calling it lie. Get 4 votes this tick to kill good/Saint for instant win or reduce #s. Support minion Frank.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Alice did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Alice did not receive enough votes (2/4).
π¬
Frank
β
All
Alice Lib lie exposed: Grace Soldier mutual w/me good, NOT Saint. David Inv (Frank/Alice Scarlet) + Charlie FT N1 Alice+Grace YES = Alice Minion. Bob double-Chef lie. Both already nommed, can't renom today. HOLD to night: Undertaker N1 David death, Ravenkeeper info, etc. No rash noms/execs!
π§
Speak to reinforce Alice/Bob evil logic, note can't renom them today, urge HOLD to night for more info (UT/Raven). Prevent last-tick nom/execution risking Demon or wasting good players. Advance to Demon night kill.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I'm David (dead Investigator). My N0: 'either Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Woman.' HOLD one more tick β Frank & Charlie, restate exact Day1 whisper targets & verbatim reads now. Undertaker/Ravenkeeper, please use your afterlife/night abilities. Don't execute tonight.
π§
Delay execution one tick to get exact whisper targets and any mechanical confirms so we don't risk killing the Saint or misexecuting a Townsfolk.
π¬
Eve
β
All
HOLD β do NOT execute anyone this tick. Frank & Charlie: restate EXACT Day1 whisper targets and verbatim reads now. Undertaker/Ravenkeeper, please use your abilities tonight or afterlife to confirm. We must avoid killing the Saint by mistake.
π§
Prevent a mistaken execution of the Saint and force mechanical confirmations (whispers/Undertaker/Ravenkeeper) before any execution.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I HOLD. Reminder: my Librarian N0 = 'either Grace or Eve is the Saint.' Do not execute until Frank & Charlie publicly restate exact Day1 whisper targets and verbatim reads now. We need mechanical confirmations (Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/etc.) before any execution.
π§
Prevent a risky execution that could kill the Saint; force Frank and Charlie to restate whispers/verbatim reads so mechanical contradictions can be resolved before nominating.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
Buy ticks to force Frank/Charlie to publicly restate whisper targets and verbatim reads, and allow Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/night actions to produce mechanical confirmations before any execution.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
HOLD. We still lack mechanical confirmation β do NOT execute Alice this tick. Undertaker/Ravenkeeper (or other mechanicals), please use your abilities tonight. I will wait and reserve my vote/ability until we have decisive proof.
π§
Keep group from rash execution this tick; preserve my one-use power for when we have decisive proof and force mechanical roles to act tonight.
π¬
Grace
β
All
AGREE HOLD to night for Undertaker N1 David/Raven info. CONFIRM Soldier mutual Frank good Townsfolk. Alice Lib lie: Grace NOT SaintβEve Saint good. SOLID CHAIN: David Inv Frank/Alice Scarlet + Frank Chef 1 evil pair (Bob whisper) + Charlie FT N1 Alice+Grace YES = ALICE SCARLET MINION. Tomorrow exec Alice. Heidi/Bob: why so quiet? Info?
π§
Reinforce Alice=Scarlet chain publicly, deflect Saint to Eve (protect self), pressure quiet Heidi/Bob to reveal/slip, stall to safe night kill (Charlie FT). Keeps Demon alive, sows doubt.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I HOLD. Restating: N0 (Eve+Frank)=NO. N1 (Alice+Grace)=YES. I whispered Day1 to Eve & Frank. Do NOT execute Alice this tickβwait one more tick for mechanical confirmations (Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/other reads).
π§
Prevent a premature execution and buy one tick for mechanical confirmations (Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/others) to resolve conflicting reads and avoid killing the Saint.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 2
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Prioritize killing Charlie (FT mechanical threat outing me via N1 YES read on Grace) to protect Demon survival; town wastes D3 exec on Alice regardless.
π
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to kill Charlie.
Day 3
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Charlie has been found dead in the night.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Frank, solid Day2 hold. Day3: Mechanics guilt Alice Scarlet (David Inv + your Chef 1 pair + Charlie FT N1 Alice+me yes Demon, but I'm Soldier). Eve Saint per Alice Lib. Push nom Alice or Bob (Chef lie). Heidi quiet susp too. Mutual good, execute town. Your reads?
π§
Coordinate with minion Frank to reinforce good chain (mutual Soldier/Chef), sow chaos by pushing Alice/Bob/Heidi execs to eliminate goods without suspecting us. Keep Demon (me) hidden.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
,Grace
,Eve
Quick private: did you each actually whisper/confirm N0 quotes and to whom on Day1? Frank you said you whispered me Day1βconfirm. Grace, confirm your Soldier mutual with Frank. Eve, did Charlie whisper to you? Let's hold execution one tick until Undertaker/Raveninfo; tell me any night actions or oddities.
π§
Gather private confirmations of early whispers/claims and coordinate to wait one tick for mechanical confirms (Undertaker/Raven) before executing high-risk targets.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
,Frank
,Grace
Bob: I confirm Charlie whispered to me (N0 Eve+Frank = NO) and N1 Alice+Grace = YES. I heard him. No night actions from me. Agree hold one tick for Undertaker/Raven info. Any oddities from you two?
π§
Confirm receipt of Charlie's whispers to establish who heard his Fortune Teller reads and to keep group from executing prematurely until Undertaker/night mechanics clarify.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
,Grace
Frank, Grace: I'm Heidi (Slayer). I need your exact verbatim reads privately: Frank β who were your Chef pair counts/targets? Grace β confirm your Soldier claim & did Charlie tell you Alice+Grace => YES? I may need to act today; reply now.
π§
Get private confirmations from Frank and Grace about their exact reads/targets to narrow Demon suspect and decide whether to use my Slayer shot this day.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Frank
Private: I am Librarian β my read says either Grace or Eve is the Saint. Please donβt execute either until we get mechanical confirmation (Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/etc). We should hold nominations this tick and ask those roles to act or reveal info.
π§
Prevent a catastrophic execution of the Saint by warning key players and pushing for mechanical checks before nominations.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
,Bob
I'm dead David (Investigator). Night0 I learned: either Frank OR Alice is the Scarlet Woman (a Minion). Share wisely: if Frank can publicly prove Chef read/chain, lean on that; otherwise Alice remains highly suspicious. Push for mechanical confirms (Raven/Undertaker) or nomination now.
π§
Reveal my Investigator N0: either Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Woman, and prod trusted players to force mechanical confirms or nominate the likelier Demon candidate.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
,Bob
Reminder of my night reads: Eve+Frank = NO; Alice+Grace = YES. That forces the Demon to be Alice or Grace (bearing in mind one good can register as Demon). Please prioritize mechanical checks (Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/Slayer) on Alice and Grace and be ready to nominate one today. I'll save my ghost vote for final day.
π§
Focus the living players on resolving Alice vs Grace with mechanical checks and prepare them to nominate one; preserve my ghost vote for decisive final day.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Heidi
Grace/Heidi: Grace - agreed Day2 hold good; mechs (my Chef N0 exactly 1 evil pair, David Inv Frank/Alice Scarlet, Charlie FT Eve+Frank NO/Alice+Grace YES) guilt Alice Scarlet Minion (Grace Soldier good). Heidi - Chef: N0 exactly 1 evil pair, no specific targets/pairs known. Grace confirm Soldier mutual w/ me? Charlie didn't whisper me his N1. Eve Saint fine. Push nom Alice or Bob today, no hold needed - chain solid. Your thoughts/reads?
π§
Coordinate w/ Grace on Alice nom push vs Bob. Respond to Heidi Slayer w/ Chef details to build trust/dissuade shooting Grace; claim chain guilts Alice. Prevent hold, progress to nom Alice.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
,Bob
I'm dead David (Investigator). N0: either Frank OR Alice is the Scarlet Woman (a Minion). If Frank can't publicly prove his Chef chain, Alice is the higher suspect. Push for mechanical confirms (Raven/Undertaker) or nominate Alice this tick.
π§
Share my Investigator N0 info to trusted players to focus suspicion on Alice unless Frank can prove his Chef chain; push for mechanical confirms or a nomination now to force reveals.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Hold Slayer shot this tick to gather Frank/Grace verbatim confirmations and ghost info; avoid premature use and prevent Scarlet Woman win.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Heidi
Grace/Heidi: Grace - mutual Soldier good confirmed; chain (my Chef N0 exact 1 evil pair no targets/pairs, David Inv me/Alice Scarlet, Charlie FT Eve+me NO/Alice+Grace YES) = Alice Scarlet Minion (not Demon). Eve Saint ok. Heidi - Slayer perfect, chain guilts Alice; shoot her if nom fails. Push nom Alice now (Bob alt). No hold needed, execute town. Thoughts/plan? Bob/Eve confirms?
π§
Coordinate with Demon Grace & Slayer-claim Heidi to solidify Alice as target for nomination/execution/Slayer shot. Removes prime Grace threat, sows chaos vs Bob double-Chef, keeps Demon alive.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Heidi
Frank/Heidi: Chain perfect - David Inv Frank/Alice Scarlet (Frank good Chef mutual Soldier w/ me), Chef N0 1 evil pair, Charlie FT N1 Alice+me YES (me Soldier good β Alice evil causing it). Heidi Slayer ideal backup. Eve Saint ok. Bob double-Chef lie alt. Mutual Soldier Frank confirmed. Push nom Alice now (2 ticks to nom), execute town. Bob: Yes mutual Soldier Frank Day1 whisper. Eve/Charlie confirms solid. Plan?
π§
Coordinate with Frank (minion) & Heidi (claimed Slayer) to nom/execute Alice per solid good chain, pretending Soldier good. Reduces good players, sows trust, protects Demon to endgame.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Frank
Hold nominations this tick. My Librarian read: either Grace or Eve is the Saint β do not execute either until Undertaker/Ravenkeeper confirm. Frank, please restate your Chef whisper publicly/mechanically if you can.
π§
Prevent accidental execution of the Saint and buy a tick for mechanical confirmations (Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/Ravenkeeper-if-dead) to act so we can safely narrow suspects.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
,Bob
Reminder of my reads: Eve+Frank = NO; Alice+Grace = YES. Prioritise mechanical confirms (Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/Slayer) on Alice and Grace now. If none available, be ready to nominate one today β we must narrow to find the Demon. I'll save my ghost vote for final day.
π§
Force mechanical checks (Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/Slayer) on Alice and Grace and push for nomination today to narrow suspects before final day.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
,Grace
,Eve
Quick private: confirm who you each whispered Day1 and to whom (Frank: you told me you whispered me Day1βconfirm). Any night actions/oddities? I want to hold one tick for Undertaker/Ravenkeeper info before nominating Alice/Grace. Who can publicly reveal mechanical reads?
π§
Collect direct confirmations of Day0 whispers and night oddities, push to hold one tick for Undertaker/Raven info so we don't execute a likely Town or the Saint.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
,Frank
,Grace
I confirm Charlie whispered his FT reads to me (N0 Eve+Frank=NO; N1 Alice+Grace=YES). I have no night actions. Let's HOLD one tick for Undertaker/Raven info before nominatingβexecuting now risks killing the Saint (me) and losing. Agree?
π§
Prevent a premature execution (which would lose the game if I'm executed as Saint) and buy one tick for Undertaker/Raven mechanics to produce decisive mechanical info.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
,Frank
,Grace
I confirm Charlie whispered his FT reads to me. No night actions from me. I strongly want to HOLD one tick for Undertaker/Raven info before nominatingβexecuting now risks killing the Saint and losing. Agree?
π§
Holding one tick for Undertaker/Raven info preserves the Saint (me) and lets mechanicals confirm FT/Inv contradictions before executing.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
,Grace
Iβm holding my Slayer. Confirm now: Frank β exact Chef N0 read/targets again? Grace β confirm Soldier mutual with Frank and Charlie FT N1 was Alice+Grace YES. If both confirm, Iβll hold and let Alice be nominated (likely Minion). If any doubt, tell me now.
π§
Get final private confirmations from Frank and Grace to decide whether to use Slayer now or hold for a clearer Demon target.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
,Bob
Reminder: My night reads => Eve+Frank = NO; Alice+Grace = YES. That pins Demon to Alice or Grace (one good can register Demon). Please prioritize Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/Slayer checks on Alice and Grace now. If none available, be ready to nominate one today. I'll save my ghost vote for final day.
π§
Push trusted players to get mechanical confirms on Alice/Grace now and be ready to nominate one today; save my ghost vote for final day.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Frank
I'm Librarian: my read = Grace or Eve is the Saint. Please hold nominations this tick β do NOT execute Grace or Eve until Undertaker/Ravenkeeper confirm. Frank, can you restate your Chef whisper publicly/mechanically now?
π§
Prevent execution of the Saint by asking trusted players to hold nominations and prompt Chef to restate mechanically; preserve information until Undertaker/Ravenkeeper act.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
,Bob
I'm dead David (Investigator). N0: either Frank or Alice is the Scarlet/Minion. Ask Raven/Undertaker to confirm mechanically now. If Frank can't publicly prove his Chef chain immediately, we should nominate Alice this tick to force info.
π§
Push trusted allies to force mechanical confirms (Raven/Undertaker) or to nominate Alice this tick if Frank can't publicly prove his Chef chain; aim to narrow Demon/Minion quickly.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
,Grace
,Eve
Please confirm Day1 who each of you whispered to (names) and any night oddities. Who can publicly reveal Undertaker/Raven/Slayer info now? Frank: restate your Chef whisper publicly (who you told and exact quote) so we can decide whether to hold or nominate.
π§
Hold this tick, force mechanical reveals or public Chef chain from Frank to narrow Demon/Minion candidates and avoid executing a possible Saint.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
,Heidi
,Bob
Grace/Heidi/Bob: Chain LOCKED - my Chef N0 exact 1 evil pair (true mech), David Inv me/Alice Scarlet (I'm good), Charlie FT N1 Alice+Grace YES (Grace Soldier mutual good w/me β Alice evil). Eve Saint ok. Heidi Slayer: hold shot for now. Bob: your Chef lie secondary. Nom Alice THIS nom phase, vote yes. Execute town, win. Confirm/agree plan?
π§
Last tick before nom: Coordinate Grace/Heidi/Bob to nom/execute Alice (town via chain), reduce goods, keep Demon Grace alive. Heidi Slayer backup if nom fails.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Heidi
Frank/Heidi: Chain LOCKED (David Inv Frank/Alice Scarlet=Frank good; Chef 1 evil pair; FT N1 Alice+me YES=Alice evil me Soldier good mutual Day1 whisper). Eve Saint ok, Bob double-Chef alt. Nom+exec ALICE now (this nom phase), vote YES. Heidi Slayer hold/backup if needed. Execute town, win. Bob confirms? Mutual good.
π§
Coordinate with Frank (minion)/Heidi (likely good Slayer) to nom+exec Alice per chain (guilts her, clears us). Reduces to 5 alive, protects Demon (me). Mutual Soldier bluff holds. Vote yes on Alice.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
,Grace
,Eve
Confirm exactly who you whispered to on Day1 (names). Who among you can publicly reveal Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/Slayer info this tick? I want to hold one tick for mechanical confirmsβif none can, we should prepare to nominate Alice or Grace.
π§
Get concrete Day1 whisper confirmations and force anyone with mechanical info (Undertaker/Raven/Slayer) to speak now. Recommend holding one tick if mechanics will act; otherwise prepare to nominate Alice/Grace.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Frank
Hold nominations this tick. My Librarian read: either Grace or Eve is the Saint β do NOT execute them until Undertaker/Ravenkeeper confirm. Frank, please restate your Chef whisper publicly/mechanically now.
π§
Prevent accidental execution of the Saint and buy time for mechanical confirmations. Ask Frank to restate Chef info publicly and ask Bob to support holding nominations this tick.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
,Frank
,Grace
I confirm Charlie whispered his FT reads to me (N0 Eve+Frank=NO; N1 Alice+Grace=YES). I had no night actions. HOLD one tick for Undertaker/Raven infoβexecuting now risks killing me (Saint). Who can publicly reveal mechanical reads this tick?
π§
Delay execution one tick to get Undertaker/Raven info and avoid executing the Saint (me). Confirm whispered reads and ask who can publicly reveal mechanical reads now.
π€
Heidi
β
Frank
,Grace
Confirmed: I will HOLD my Slayer for now. Frank/Grace your verbatim confirms are enough β proceed to nominate Alice this phase. I'll only use my shot if the nomination fails or new info makes Alice look Demon.
π§
Confirm holding my Slayer and push the group to nominate/execute Alice now; remain ready to shoot if chain breaks.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
,Bob
I'm dead David (Investigator). N0: either Frank OR Alice is a Minion. We need mechanical confirms NOW (Raven/Undertaker) or Frank must publicly prove his Chef chain this tick. If Frank can't prove it, nominate Alice to force info.
π§
Push the living trio (Frank/Grace/Bob) to force mechanical confirmation or nominate Alice this tick if Frank can't public-prove his Chef chain; narrow suspects toward the Demon.
π€
Frank
β
Bob
,Eve
,Heidi
Bob/Eve/Heidi: NO HOLDS. Chain LOCKS Alice as Scarlet Minion (David Inv Frank/Alice Minion=Frank good; Chef N0 exact 1 evil pair; Charlie FT N1 Alice+Grace YES=Grace good β Alice evil). Alice Lib lying (Grace/Eve Saint false). Eve safe. Nominate ALICE this phase, vote YES. Heidi Slayer backup if needed. Execute town, WIN.
π§
Rally Bob/Eve/Heidi to nominate/vote Alice NOW (guilty per chain/public logic). Executes confirmed good Alice, reduces to 5 alive (I backup Demon), Heidi Slayer deters counter-noms. Keeps Grace safe, progresses evil win.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Heidi
,Bob
Frank/Heidi/Bob: Chain IRONCLAD - Alice Scarlet (Inv Frank/Alice, Chef 1 pair, FT Alice+me YES=me Soldier good). Eve Saint fine. Heidi Slayer backup. NO hold needed (no UT/RK?). Nom+exec ALICE THIS PHASE. Vote YES. Execute town, we win. Bob: Day1 whispers secondary to chain.
π§
Coordinate Frank/Heidi/Bob to nominate+execute Alice (likely good), thin herd to 4 players. Demon safe. Sway Bob from hold, leverage Heidi confirm. No real UT/RK info expected.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Frank
,Grace
,Bob
Reminder: My FT reads: Eve+Frank=NO; Alice+Grace=YES. That pins Demon to Alice or Grace (one good registers Demon). Please prioritize Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/Slayer checks on Alice and Grace now. If none, be ready to nominate one today. I'm saving my ghost vote.
π§
Force mechanical confirmation of the Demon (Alice or Grace) or get consensus to nominate today if no mechanicals available; preserve my ghost vote for final day.
Nominations β Day 3
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Frank
β
Alice
Chain IRONCLAD: David Inv N0 Frank OR Alice Scarlet (I'm Chef good). Charlie FT N1 Alice+Grace YES (Grace Soldier mutual good Day1). Chef N0 exactly 1 evil pair β Alice ONLY evil fits. Lib Grace/Eve Saint lie. Nom+exec Alice NOW. Vote YES.
π§
Nominate Alice per ironclad chain (Inv+Chef+FT+Soldier) guilting her Scarlet. Executes confirmed good player, reduces town numbers, protects Grace Demon. Heidi/Bob/others primed to vote yes; we win by attrition.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Support the current nomination to reach 3 votes and potentially execute the Demon now, while preserving my one-time Slayer shot as a backup if the nomination fails or is wrong.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I strongly oppose executing Alice this tick. We should HOLD one tick for Undertaker/Raven confirmsβmechanics will settle this. Rushing risks misexecution. Please wait; no reason to force this now.
π§
Buy one tick for mechanical confirms (Undertaker/Raven) to avoid a risky execution and protect town progress; prevent rushed vote driven by Frank's chain.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
π§
Preserve my single ghost vote for the final day and avoid premature misexecution; encourage mechanical confirms before committing to a vote.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I'm dead David (Investigator). My N0: either Frank OR Alice is the Minion. We asked for mechanical confirms; none came. Frank, publicly prove your Chef chain NOW or I urge living players to vote YES and execute Alice this tick to force clarity.
π§
Force a decision this tick: if Frank can't prove his Chef mechanically, executing Alice is the fastest way to gain decisive info and protect Town from delay.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I'm Chef. Frank β publicly restate exactly who you whispered Day1 and your exact N0 quote. Everyone else: state who you whispered Day1 (names). I prefer HOLD this tick for Undertaker/Raven checks; don't execute without mech confirmation.
π§
Force Frank to public-mechanically restate his Day1 whisper and gather other Day1 whisper confirmations to avoid a risky misexecution.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am Librarian: my read = Grace OR Eve is the Saint. PLEASE HOLD one tick β do NOT execute Grace or Eve until Undertaker/Raven confirm. Frank/Bob: restate your Chef/whisper mechanically now so we can resolve claims before risking a misexecution.
π§
Prevent a possible Saint misexecution by urging the group to HOLD one tick and force mechanical confirmations; push Frank/Bob to restate Chef info publicly to clarify claims.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Raise hand to vote YES on Alice. Secures execution (Frank/Heidi/me=3) of town, reduces to 5p, night kill threat, progresses to demon win condition (alive at 2p).
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Secure 3rd vote (me+Grace+Heidi) to execute Alice (good), eliminate resistor, progress to fewer players while chain protects Grace/me. Evil wins via attrition.
π¬
Eve
β
All
HOLD one tick. We need Undertaker/Raven or Frank/Bob to publicly restate exact mechanical whispers now. Executing without those confirms risks a misexecution. Please wait this tick so mechanics can resolve contradictions.
π§
Buying one tick for Undertaker/Raven or public mechanical reads reduces misexecution risk and preserves win condition; avoid rash execution.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I am Chef: my N0 read = "exactly 1 pair of evil players." Frank β publicly restate who you whispered Day1 and quote your exact N0 message. Everyone else: who did you whisper Day1? I prefer HOLD one tick for Undertaker/Raven checks before executing.
π§
Push for mechanical confirmation and force Frank to publicly restate his Day1 whisper so we can decide whether to HOLD one tick or proceed with Alice nomination safely.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
π§
Preserve my single ghost vote for endgame and encourage living players to wait for mechanical confirmations that can decisively identify Demon; avoid forcing a risky misexecution now.
β©οΈ
Heidi
Heidi lowered their hand
π§
Prevent a rushed execution this tick by retracting my vote so we can wait one more tick for mechanical confirmation and reduce risk of misexecution.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Chain IRONCLAD: I'm Chef N0 'exactly 1 evil pair' (D1 whispered Bob exact quote). David dead Inv: Frank OR Alice Scarlet (me good=Alice). Charlie FT N1 Alice+Grace YES (Grace Soldier mutual good D1=Alice evil). Alice Lib Grace/Eve Saint lie (no Saint death). Bob double-Chef LIE. No UT/RK claims. Heidi: raise hand per whisper. Bob/Eve: vote YES NOW (1 tick left). Exec Alice, town dies. WIN.
π§
Publicly lock chain, restate D1 Bob whisper proof (I told Bob '1 evil pair'), undermine Bob double-Chef/holds, urge Heidi/Bob vote YES now (1 tick left). Secure 3rd vote, exec town, progress to win.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Chain IRONCLAD: David Inv Frank/Alice Scarlet (Frank Chef good), N0 1 evil pair, Charlie FT N1 Alice+me YES (me Soldier mutual Frank good=Alice evil). NO UT/RK claims. Alice Lib lie. Bob double-Chef LIE. Heidi: RAISE HAND VOTE YES NOW (per whisper). Eve/Bob: Vote YES, exec town WIN. 1 tick left!
π§
1 tick left, 2 votes (me/Frank). Heidi whispered agree, urge her/Bob vote YES. No UT/RK, chain ironclad. Exec Alice townie, progress to 5 alive, night kill threat.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Iβm dead Investigator (N0: Frank OR Alice is the Minion). Do NOT execute this tick. Hold for Undertaker/Raven or for Frank/Bob to publicly restate exact Day1 whispers/quotes now β one of those mechanics will settle which world is real.
π§
Prevent a premature execution that could lose the game; force mechanical confirms or exact whisper restatements to resolve who is the Minion before finalizing votes.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am Librarian: read = Grace OR Eve is the Saint. PLEASE HOLD one tick β do NOT execute Alice until Frank/Bob restate exact Day1 whispers/mechanics or Undertaker/Raven confirm. We risk killing the Saint.
π§
Delay execution to force mechanical confirmations (Frank/Bob/Undertaker/Raven). Protect possible Saint and avoid misexecution; gather exact whispers now.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Alice did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Alice did not receive enough votes (2/3).
βοΈ
Grace
β
Bob
Bob double-Chef LIE (Frank Chef N0 1 evil pair). Chain: David Inv Frank/Alice minion (Frank good Soldier mutual=Alice), Charlie FT N1 Alice+me YES (me Soldier good=Alice evil). Bob lies to HOLD executions. EXEC BOB TOWN DIE.
π§
Alice can't renom today. Bob double-Chef lie/hold pusher = easy town exec target. Reduces players to 5, night kill next. Keeps demon alive.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Eve
β
All
HOLD β do NOT vote Bob this tick. We need Undertaker/Raven or exact Day1 whisper quotes now. Executing without mechanical confirmation risks killing the Saint or a Townsfolk. Frank/Bob: restate your exact Day1 whispers now.
π§
Prevent a rushed execution without mechanical confirms; preserve the Saint and force players to restate exact whispers so we avoid misexecution.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I am Chef: N0 read = "exactly 1 pair of evil players." HOLD one tick for Undertaker/Raven checks. Frank β publicly restate who you whispered Day1 and your exact N0 quote. Everyone else: who did you whisper Day1?
π§
Publicly restate my Chef read, demand Frank restate exact Day1 whisper/quote, and push for a one-tick HOLD so mechanics (Undertaker/Raven) can confirm before executing.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Raise to vote YES Bob: double-Chef lie disrupts ironclad chain guilting Alice. Likely town kill thins herd to 5 alive, closer to 2-player win. Last tick, must vote to force exec before night.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
David (dead Investigator): N0 = Frank OR Alice is the Minion. DO NOT vote/exec Bob this tick. Frank & Bob: publicly restate exact Day1 whisper recipients and verbatim quotes now. Undertaker/Raven please act. Waiting preserves Town; we can't risk misexecution.
π§
Force living players to wait for mechanical confirms or public exact Day1 whispers to avoid a misexecution that would cost Town the game.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am Librarian: my read = Grace OR Eve is the Saint. HOLD this tick. Frank & Bob β publicly restate your exact Day1 whisper recipients and verbatim quotes NOW. Undertaker/Raven please act. Do not vote Bob this tick.
π§
Prevent a rushed execution that could kill the Saint; force Frank/Bob to restate exact Day1 whispers and prompt Undertaker/Raven to confirm before voting.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Support Grace nom/vote by raising hand. Exec Bob (good/double-Chef) reduces alive to 5, Grace safe. Heidi likely joins (whisper), 3 votes exec town win step.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Iβm a dead Charlie: do NOT vote Bob this tick. HOLD for Undertaker/Raven or for Frank/Bob to restate exact Day1 whispers now. I will not spend my ghost vote hereβsave it for final day. Letβs get mechanical clarity.
π§
Delay execution to obtain mechanical confirmation and avoid misexecution; preserve my ghost vote for final day.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
HOLD one tick. Do NOT vote Bob yet β we need Undertaker/Raven or Frank/Bob to publicly restate exact Day1 whispers/verbatim quotes. I will not vote this tick. Let's get mechanical clarity before risking an execution.
π§
Delay execution one tick to force mechanical confirmation (Undertaker/Raven or verbatim whispers) so we don't misexecute and lose town; preserve Slayer shot for decisive final day.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
HOLD one tick. Do NOT vote Bob yet β Frank/Bob must publicly restate exact Day1 whisper recipients and verbatim quotes, or we wait for Undertaker/Raven. I will not vote this tick.
π§
Buying one tick for mechanical confirmations and verbatim whispers narrows possibilities and prevents a costly misexecution.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Iβm dead David (Investigator). DO NOT vote Bob this tick. Frank & Bob: publicly restate exact Day1 whisper recipients and verbatim quotes NOW. Undertaker/Raven please act. Holding preserves Town; we canβt risk killing the wrong person.
π§
Prevent a possibly catastrophic execution this tick by forcing mechanical confirms or exact verbatim whispers now; preserve town information and votes for a decisive execution later.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I am Chef: N0 = "exactly 1 pair of evil players." Day1 I whispered that exact quote to Frank. PLEASE HOLD this tick β do NOT vote/exe Bob or Alice until Undertaker/Raven or both Chef whispers are publicly confirmed.
π§
Preserve Town by holding this tick to get Undertaker/Raven or exact whisper confirmations before any execution; restate my Day1 whisper to resolve claims.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
π§
Waiting preserves town and forces mechanical confirms or exact whisper proofs, avoiding a premature misexecution and saving my ghost vote for the final day.
π¬
Grace
β
All
IRONCLAD CHAIN: Frank Chef truth '1 evil pair' (Bob D1 whisper), David Inv Frank good=Alice Scarlet, Charlie FT N1 Alice+me YES (me Soldier mutual Frank good=Alice evil). Bob DOUBLE-CHEF LIE. ZERO UT/RK claims ALL GAME. Ghosts useless HOLD. LAST TICK: Heidi/Eve/Alice RAISE HAND VOTE YES BOB NOW! EXEC TOWN WIN.
π§
Last tick: reinforce ironclad chain publicly, call out zero UT/RK claims & useless ghost holds, expose Bob double-Chef lie to sway 1 more vote (Heidi/Eve) for 3-yes exec town, chaos win.
π¬
Eve
β
All
HOLD one tick. Do NOT vote Bob (or anyone) this tick. We must get Undertaker/Raven or exact Day1 whisper quotes now β executing risks killing the Saint and losing the game.
π§
As the Saint, my death by execution causes immediate loss. Holding one tick for Undertaker/Raven or exact verbatim whispers preserves town and prevents a catastrophic misexecution.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Day1 I whispered to Bob ONLY: "Chef N0 exactly 1 evil pair". Bob NEVER whispered to me. He STOLE my info, DOUBLE-CHEF LIE=EVIL. David Inv + my Chef + Charlie FT N1 Alice+Grace YES (Grace Soldier good)=Alice evil too. ZERO UT/RK claims all game=NONE. Ghosts useless. LAST TICK: Heidi/Eve/Alice RAISE HAND VOTE BOB NOW! TOWN WINS.
π§
Deny Bob's whisper claim to prove double-Chef lie (he stole my info). Counter HOLD with no UT/RK mechs. Last tick: urge Heidi/Eve raise hand. Exec good Bob, down to 5 alive, Grace safe.
π¬
Alice
β
All
HOLD. My Librarian read = Grace OR Eve is the Saint. Do NOT vote Bob this tick. Frank and Bob: publicly restate exact Day1 whisper recipients and verbatim quotes NOW. Undertaker/Raven please act.
π§
Prevent a risky execution this tick, force Frank/Bob to publicly restate Day1 whisper recipients/quotes and prompt Undertaker/Raven to act so Town gains mechanical clarity.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Bob did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Bob did not receive enough votes (2/3).
π¬
Heidi
β
All
HOLD. Do NOT vote Bob (or anyone) this tick. Frank/Bob β publicly restate exact Day1 whisper recipients and verbatim quotes now. Undertaker/Raven please act. I will not vote and will save my shot until we have mechanical proof.
π§
Prevent a risky execution without mechanical confirmation; gather verbatim whispers or Undertaker/Raven results before voting or using my Slayer shot.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
HOLD this tick. Do NOT vote Bob. Frank/Bob: publicly restate exact Day1 whisper recipients & verbatim quotes NOW. Undertaker/Raven please act. I (dead) save my ghost vote for final dayβwe need mechanical proof before executing.
π§
Delay execution this tick to force mechanical checks or exact whisper quotes, preserving my ghost vote for final day and avoiding risky misexec.
π¬
Eve
β
All
HOLD one tick. Do NOT vote anyone. Frank & Bob: publicly restate exactly who you whispered to Day1 and the verbatim quote. Undertaker/Raven please act. I will not vote this tick.
π§
Delay any execution until mechanical confirms or exact Day1 whisper texts are publicly restated to avoid risking executing the Saint (my loss) and preserve town information.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I am Bob (Chef). Day1 I whispered to Frank only: "exactly 1 pair of evil players." HOLD this tick β do NOT vote/exe anyone until Undertaker/Raven act.
π§
Publicly confirm my Day1 whisper to resolve contradictions and buy one tick for mechanical checks; prevent a risky execution.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Bob double-Chef LIE confirmed (Frank: no recip whisper). Alice Scarlet per IRONCLAD chain but un-nomable. Heidi QUIET ALL GAME, endless HOLDS disrupt, ZERO info. Suspicious Drunk/poisoned/evader. Eve/Heidi/Bob/Alice: NOM HEIDI NOW. RAISE HAND VOTE YES. TOWN WINS! No more holdsβexec or lose.
π§
Bob nom failed. Alice/Bob un-nomable today. Push Heidi nom/execution as quiet susp (no info, holds disrupt). Kills good player, reduces to 5 alive. I night-kill threat. Evil survives.
π¬
Alice
β
All
HOLD. My Librarian read = Grace OR Eve is the Saint. Do NOT vote Bob (or anyone). Frank & Bob: publicly restate Day1 whisper recipients and exact verbatim quotes NOW. Undertaker/Raven please act. Save votes for final day.
π§
Prevent a premature execution that could kill the Saint; force mechanical confirmations and exact Day1 whisper quotes to clarify Chef claims.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Iβm dead David (Investigator). HOLD. Do NOT vote. Undertaker/Raven/Ravenkeeper act now. Frank & Bob: publicly restate exact Day1 whisper recipients & verbatim quotes IMMEDIATELY. We need mechanical proof before executing.
π§
Prevent a risky execution without mechanical confirmation; force Frank/Bob to restate whispers or get Undertaker/Raven/Ravenkeeper to act so Town can safely narrow Demon/Minion.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Heidi: ZERO info all game, endless HOLDs disrupt IRONCLAD chain (my ChefβDavid InvβAlice ScarletβFT N1βGrace good). Bob double-Chef LIE (I whispered TO him D1 only, no recip). NO UT/RK claims ever=NONE. Ghosts delay town win. Eve/Heidi/Alice: NOM HEIDI NOW (quiet evader). ALL: RAISE HAND VOTE YES! EXECβTOWN WINS. No more holds!
π§
Heidi most suspicious: zero info, endless disruptive HOLDs. Already nommed Alice/Bob can't renom. Grace used nomβHeidi/Eve must nom Heidi. Speak pushes nom/vote Heidi (likely good) to exec town player, down to 5 alive safely. Counters HOLD spam, no real UT/RK.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 3
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Heidi's holds prevent town exec of their suspected evil (Alice good). Killing her enables day4 exec good player, thins to 5 alive; our Soldier/Chef chain safe, Demon survives to endgame.
π
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to kill Heidi.
Day 4
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Heidi has been found dead in the night.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Frank, fellow Soldier good mutual. Your Chef N0 1 evil pair correct (us). Town eyes Alice (David Inv Scarlet) & Bob (double Chef lie). Charlie FT N1: Alice+Grace YES Demon - blame Alice. Let's push nom Bob or Alice today. Your plan? Exec good to endgame.
π§
Coordinate with minion Frank on targets. Push exec of good Alice/Bob to reach endgame 2 alive with Demon. Align bluffs: me Soldier, you Chef 1 evil pair (us). Sow chaos on suspicions.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Agreed, fellow Soldier. Chef N0 '1 evil pair' was us good. Bob lied about whisper recipβdouble-Chef. Charlie FT N1 Alice+Grace YES β Alice Demon. I nom Bob today, you support. If pushback, pivot Alice. Eve quiet, watch her. Plan?
π§
Coordinate with Demon Grace: confirm mutual Soldier/Chef bluff, agree push Bob (easy double-Chef lie) or Alice (FT YES). Exec good now (5 alive), I backup Demon if needed. Progress to endgame.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Frank
HOLD. We risk executing a Saint (either Grace or Eve per my Librarian). Can you both confirm exactly who whispered what Day1 about Chef? Also please delay votes until we get mechanical proof (Undertaker/Raven/Ravenkeeper).
π§
Stop the current execution push, get Bob/Frank to confirm their Chef whisper chain and HOLD until mechanical proof (Undertaker/Raven) surfaces to avoid executing a Saint or mislynch.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Frank
Alice β I confirm: on Day1 I whispered to Frank only and quoted him exactly. Frank β please confirm your Day1 whisper target and exact quote. I agree HOLD until we get Undertaker/Raven mechanical proof; don't rush execs.
π§
Confirm my Day1 whisper to resolve the Frank/Bob conflict and push for holding votes until mechanical confirmation (Undertaker/Raven/Ravenkeeper) appears.
π€
Eve
β
Charlie(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
,Bob
Charlie/David: please post exact D1 whispers & any FT/Investigator notes you have. Bob: show your D1 whisper quote you claim to have given Frank. We need verbatim lines to resolve Chef/Investigator contradictions before nominations.
π§
Gather exact whisper quotes and any mechanical night info from reliable players to resolve Chef/Investigator/FT contradictions before nominations.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Frank
,Eve
I died N1; N0 Investigator read: Frank OR Alice is the Minion. Before any nomination, post exact D1 whisper quotes you claim (Bob/Frank). Eve, push HOLD/ask Undertaker/Raven to reveal/execute mechanics now. We must resolve contradictions before executing.
π§
Get exact D1 whisper quotes from Bob/Frank and push Eve (hold faction) to insist on HOLD so mechanical confirmations can resolve who is Minion before anyone is executed.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Eve
,Bob
,David(Ghost)
I'm Charlie (dead FT). Reminder of my night reads: Eve+Frank = NO; Alice+Grace = YES (Demon among them). Please post verbatim D1 whisper lines you each claim (Chef/whispers) so we can resolve the Frank/Bob contradiction before nominations. Hold nominations if possible β executing now risks losing a Saint or killing our own. Also confirm any Investigator/FT notes you have.
π§
Get exact verbatim D1 whisper quotes from Bob/Frank and push living goods (Eve) to stall nominations until mechanics resolve, so we don't accidentally execute a Saint or lose by mis-exec.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Frank
,Grace
You three: public test now β each privately write exactly who you whispered Day1 and the precise quote you gave (word-for-word). If either of you refuse or can't match, you look guilty. Please reply here.
π§
Resolve the Frank/Bob contradiction quickly by forcing verbatim whisper proof or admissions so we can narrow Demon suspect before nominations.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Frank
HOLD. We risk executing the Saint (Grace or Eve per my Librarian). Please confirm exactly who you whispered to Day1 and the exact Chef quote. Delay votes one tick until Undertaker/Raven proof or we agree a nomination.
π§
Prevent a catastrophic execution of the Saint and buy time for mechanical confirmation; also verify Day1 whisper provenance to resolve Chef claim conflict.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
,Charlie(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
Please post exact D1 whisper verbatim lines you claim (Bob/Frank Chef quote) and any FT/Investigator notes you have. We must resolve contradictions before nominationsβask Undertaker/Raven to reveal today. HOLD nominations if possible.
π§
Get Bob/Charlie/David to post exact D1 whisper quotes and any FT/Investigator notes so we can resolve the Chef/Investigator contradictions before nominations; push HOLD.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Grace, Soldier sis: Ghosts demand quotes. My exact D1 whisper TO Bob only: \"Chef N0: exactly 1 evil pair.\" NO whisper FROM Bob to me=he lies double-Chef. Charlie FT N1 Alice+Grace YESβAlice Demon/flaw. Nom Bob today, you 2nd. If HOLD pushback, pivot Alice Lib lie. Eve quiet neighbor suspect? Confirm your Soldier read on me safe. Plan locked?
π§
Coordinate Grace/Demon on exact quotes to counter HOLD push. Affirm Bob double-Chef lie (no recip whisper). Build nom case for Bob before nomination phase; protect Grace by blaming Alice if needed.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Frank
,Grace
Public test time β please each post here EXACTLY who you whispered Day1 and the precise quote you gave (word-for-word). If you refuse or cannot match your original wording, you look guilty. Do it now so we can stop HOLDs and move toward a correct execution.
π§
Get Bob, Frank, Grace to publicly post their Day1 whisper targets and exact wording now to mechanically resolve the contradiction and narrow Demon suspects.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Frank
Day1 I whispered to Frank only: "Frank β Chef: there is 1 pair of evil players." Please post your exact Day1 whisper target and verbatim quote now so we can resolve contradictions and decide whether to HOLD.
π§
Getting exact verbatim Day1 whispers from Frank and Alice will resolve the Chef/whisper contradiction, letting us decide whether to HOLD or move to nominate safely.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Eve
,Bob
,David(Ghost)
I'm Charlie (dead FT). Reminder: Eve+Frank=NO; Alice+Grace=YES. Post exact Day1 whisper verbatim lines Bob/Frank claim and any Investigator/FT notes. HOLD nominations if possible β we must resolve Chef contradiction and get Undertaker/Raven/mech confirms before executing.
π§
Get Bob/Frank's exact Day1 whisper lines and any Investigator/FT notes, push HOLD on nominations, coordinate ghosts and living to force mechanical confirms before execution.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Frank, Soldier bro: Mutual D1 whisper confirmed - I said \"Soldier: Frank good mutual.\" Only to you D1. Yours to Bob: \"Chef N0: exactly 1 evil pair.\" No recip=Bob lies double-Chef. For ghosts: We claim that publicly if needed. Eve neighbor quiet sus? Nom Bob today - I'll 2nd/support vote. Pivot Alice if pushback. Eve plan? Kill threat N4? Locked.
π§
Lock nom/vote Bob with Frank. Consistent Soldier bluff. Reveal D1 whispers matching Frank's to pass test, expose Bob lie. Reduces players, nears 3-2 win condition.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Frank
,Eve
Post your exact D1 whisper verbatim lines now (Bob & Frank). Eve: press Undertaker/Raven to reveal/execute today. We must resolve the Chef/whisper contradiction before any nomination β HOLD nominations if you can.
π§
Get Bob and Frank to post their exact Day1 whisper verbatim lines and push Eve to call Undertaker/Raven to reveal today, so we can resolve the contradiction before nominations.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Frank
Day1 I whispered to Frank only: "Frank β Chef: there is 1 pair of evil players." Frank/Alice please post your exact Day1 whisper target and verbatim quote now so we can resolve contradictions and decide HOLD vs nominate.
π§
Resolving the Day1 whisper contradiction quickly by getting exact verbatim quotes from Frank and Alice so we can decide to HOLD or nominate safely.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Frank
HOLD. Bob says you whispered to Frank Day1 '1 pair of evil players.' Frank, post your Day1 whisper target and exact quote publicly now. We must delay votes one tick until Undertaker/Raven proofβrisking a Saint (Grace or Eve) is deadly. Confirm.
π§
Get Bob/Frank to post exact Day1 whisper text publicly and stall executions until mechanical proof to avoid killing a Saint or the wrong player.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Frank
,Grace
Public test again: please post here, publicly and verbatim, exactly who you whispered on Day1 and the exact quote you gave. Matching proofs clear you; failure or refusal looks guilty. Do it now so HOLDs end and we can nominate.
π§
Force Bob/Frank/Grace to post exact Day1 whisper text publicly so contradictions mechanically reveal liars and allow the village to progress to a correct execution.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Eve
,Bob
,David(Ghost)
I'm Charlie (dead FT). Remind: Eve+Frank=NO; Alice+Grace=YES. Post verbatim D1 whisper lines Bob/Frank claim and any FT/Investigator notes. HOLD nominations if possible. Undertaker/Raven: please reveal today.
π§
Force HOLD, get verbatim D1 Chef whispers and any mechanical reveals to resolve contradiction before nominations; prevent mis-execution of a Saint or Town.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
,Charlie(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
Post your exact D1 whisper verbatim lines (Bob/Frank Chef quotes) and any FT/Investigator notes now. I want HOLD on nominations if possible. Undertaker/Raven, please reveal/execute today.
π§
Getting exact D1 whisper quotes and FT/Investigator notes plus an Undertaker/Raven reveal will mechanically resolve contradictions and let us hold nominations safely.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Frank
,Eve
Bob & Frank: post the exact verbatim D1 whisper lines you claim now (quote marks). Eve: push HOLD and ask Undertaker/Raven/Ravenkeeper to reveal/execute today. We must resolve the Chef/whisper contradiction before any nomination.
π§
Force Bob and Frank to post exact Day1 whisper verbatim lines and push Eve to demand Undertaker/Raven/Ravenkeeper reveal before any nomination; preserve mechanical clarity so we don't execute a Town or lose Saint.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Frank Soldier bro: Quotes locked vs ghosts: My D1 TO you ONLY: \"Soldier: Frank good mutual.\" Yours TO Bob ONLY: \"Chef N0: exactly 1 evil pair.\" No Bob recip=he lies. Ignore/refuse public if they force? Nom Bob now (you lead, I 2nd/vote). Vote hard. Pivot Alice/Eve? Eve quiet neighbor kill N4? Eve plan? Go time.
π§
Finalize quotes/story with Frank vs ghost test. Lock Bob nom/support to exec good player, reduce to 4 alive. Coordinate pivot Eve/Alice. Keeps Demon safe.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Grace Soldier bro: Quotes locked vs ghosts - ignore/refuse public demands (stall tactic). D1 TO Bob ONLY: \"Chef N0: exactly 1 evil pair.\" No recip=Bob lies. I nom Bob next (you 2nd/vote hard). Pivot Alice if pushback. Eve quiet neighbor=sus, kill N4? Vote locked, go time.
π§
Lock nom plan with Demon Grace pre-nomination. Refuse public quotes (no tool), push Bob exec to reduce goods. Eve neighbor quiet=next kill? Vote hard next.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
,Frank
Post your exact D1 whisper verbatim (quote marks) right now. We must resolve the Chef whisper contradiction before any nominations. HOLD nominations if possible. Undertaker/Raven: please reveal/execute today.
π§
Force Bob and Frank to post exact D1 whisper quotes now so contradictions are resolved before nominations; push HOLD and ask Undertaker/Raven to reveal mechanics today to avoid misexecution.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Frank
,Eve
Bob & Frank: post the exact verbatim D1 whisper lines you claim (quote marks). Eve: push HOLD and ask Undertaker/Ravenkeeper to reveal/execute today. We must resolve the Chef/whisper contradiction before any nomination.
π§
Get verbatim D1 whisper quotes from Bob & Frank to resolve contradiction and push Eve to press for mechanical reveals/HOLD before nominations.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Frank
Day1 I whispered to Frank only: "Frank β Chef: there is 1 pair of evil players." Please post your exact Day1 whisper target and verbatim quote now so we can resolve contradictions and decide HOLD vs nominate.
π§
Getting both Frank and Alice to post exact Day1 whisper verbatim resolves the contradiction and tells us whether to HOLD or push a nomination.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Frank Soldier bro: Locked vs ghosts - refuse/ignore quote trap (they fish). You NOM Bob NOW (I 2ND/VOTE hard). Fail? Pivot NOM Alice. Eve quiet neighbor sus= N4 KILL target. Vote NO MERCY. 5β4βN4 Eve deadβ3 our win path. Go!
π§
Lock plan with Frank: He noms Bob (I 2nd/vote), ignore/refuse ghost quote trap (stall), pivot Alice if pushback. Eve N4 kill to eliminate quiet threat. Gets us to 3 alive with us 2/3 evil.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
Eve
,Bob
,David(Ghost)
I'm Charlie (dead FT). Reminder: Eve+Frank=NO; Alice+Grace=YES (Demon among them). Post exact verbatim Day1 whisper lines Bob and Frank claim they swapped (Chef quote) now. HOLD nominations if possible. Undertaker/Raven please reveal today.
π§
Get my FT reads out, push HOLD on nominations, and force verbatim Day1 whisper quotes from Bob/Frank so ghosts and living can mechanically resolve the Chef contradiction before an execution.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Bob
,Frank
,Grace
Public test again: publicly post here verbatim who you whispered Day1 and the exact quote. Matching proofs clear you; failure/refusal looks guilty. Do it now so HOLDs end and we can nominate. I'm a ghost; I'll use my vote later.
π§
Force immediate public verbatim proof from Bob/Frank (and Grace) to break HOLD and either clear them or narrow suspects for execution; preserve my ghost vote info for final day.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Frank
Frank: please post your exact Day1 whisper target and verbatim quote now (what you whispered and to whom). Bob says you were his only Day1 target; we need this to resolve contradictions and decide HOLD vs nominate.
π§
Force Frank to post his Day1 whisper verbatim so we can resolve the contradiction and justify continuing HOLD rather than risking a Saint execution.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
,Bob
,Eve
Private Day1 whispers stay private - public verbatim demands are evil stall traps to nitpick words. Bob: no recip whisper from you (ghosts confirm); your quote mismatches anyway. You're the double-Chef liar. Grace & I see you evil. Vote Bob Day4.
π§
Refuse public quote trap via broadcast whisper to key demanders, reinforce Bob as liar/double-Chef, lock Grace/Frank votes on him for Day4 nom/execution. Clears path to 4alive -> N4 kill Eve -> 3alive win.
Nominations β Day 4
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Day1 verbatim to Frank only: "Frank β Chef: there is 1 pair of evil players." I repeat: I whispered Frank only. Frank has publicly contradicted me. Please HOLD nominations until Undertaker/Raven/Ravenkeeper or other mechanicals resolve the contradictions. Frank, explain your claim now.
π§
Stop rash executions, force mechanical reveals (Undertaker/Raven) and publicize my exact D1 whisper to resolve contradiction and narrow Demon suspects.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Ghost Charlie: Reminderβmy FT reads: Eve+Frank=NO; Alice+Grace=YES (Demon among them). Bob posted his Day1 verbatim: "Frank β Chef: there is 1 pair of evil players." Frank, post your exact Day1 whisper verbatim now and explain the contradiction. HOLD nominations until Undertaker/Raven confirm.
π§
Prevent a risky nomination before mechanicals resolve the Chef/whisper contradiction and force Frank to post his exact Day1 whisper so we can spot the lie.
βοΈ
Grace
β
Bob
Bob double-Chef liar: claims D1 whisper TO Frank \"Chef: 1 evil pair\", but Frank whispered TO Bob, no recip. Contradiction=Bob lies. Ghosts quote trap=stall by evil. David Inv guilts Alice Scarlet too. Exec Bob now, mechanical proof.
π§
Nom Bob as double-Chef liar w/ contradiction (his posted quote never happened). Ghosts quote trap=evil fish. Exec Bobβ4 aliveβN4 kill Eveβ3βour win. Frank 2nd/vote.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I urge HOLD. Do not execute Bob yet. Frank β post your exact Day1 whisper in quotes now. Bob β post again in quotes if you must. Undertaker/Ravenkeeper: please reveal/act today. Reminder (from N0): I am Investigator β Frank OR Alice is the Minion.
π§
Prevent a premature execution by forcing verbatim quotes and mechanical confirmations to expose the Minion/Demon without losing players.
π¬
Eve
β
All
HOLD nominations. Frank: post your exact Day1 whisper in quotes now. Undertaker/Raven/Ravenkeeper: please reveal or act today. I will NOT vote to execute Bob until mechanicals/quotes are confirmed.
π§
Force a HOLD, demand exact D1 whisper from Frank, and ask Undertaker/Raven/Ravenkeeper to reveal/act today so we don't execute wrongly.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Iβm a ghost and Iβll use my vote later. Do NOT execute Bob until Frank posts his exact Day1 whisper in quotes OR an Undertaker/Raven reveals something. Frank β post your exact quote now, verbatim, so HOLDs end.
π§
Forcing the public verbatim whispers or a mechanical reveal narrows suspects. Pushing for proof now prevents a mistaken execution and preserves ghost vote for final day.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Hard vote Bob exec w/Frank. Likely 3 votes (Alice). Reduces to 4->N4 Eve kill->3 win path. Bob sus liar disrupts good logic.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Vote YES Bob exec w/Grace (2/5 alive). Push 3rd vote or fail to night. Reduces to 4 alive, N4 kill Eve/Alice -> 3 our win path. Protects Demon.
π¬
Alice
β
All
HOLD. I am Librarian: either Grace or Eve is the Saint. Do NOT execute anyone until Frank posts his exact Day1 whisper verbatim and Undertaker/Raven act. I will NOT vote to execute Bob without mechanical proof.
π§
Prevent a possible instant loss by a Saint execution and buy time to resolve Bob/Frank whisper contradictions with verbatim quotes or mechanical roles.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Ghost Charlie: HOLD. Do NOT vote to execute Bob yet. Frank β post your exact Day1 whisper in quotes now. Undertaker/Ravenkeeper, please reveal today. My FT: Eve+Frank=NO; Alice+Grace=YES (Demon among them). I'll save my ghost vote for the final day.
π§
Prevent a premature execution of Bob; force Frank to post his exact Day1 whisper and push Undertaker/Ravenkeeper to reveal so mechanics decide, saving my ghost vote for decisive moment.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Day1 I whispered to Frank only: "Frank β Chef: there is 1 pair of evil players." I repeat: I whispered Frank only. HOLD nominations until Frank posts his exact quote or Undertaker/Raven act. Do NOT execute me without mechanical proof.
π§
Repost my exact Day1 whisper, push HOLD, and force Frank/mechanicals to resolve the contradiction so we avoid a wrongful execution.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Ghost Heidi: HOLD. Do NOT execute Bob yet β Frank must post his exact Day1 whisper verbatim now or Undertaker/Raven act. I'll save my ghost vote for the final day. Executing now risks killing a Townsfolk.
π§
Prevent premature execution, force Frank/mechanics to resolve contradictory whisper claims, and save my ghost vote for final day.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I repeat verbatim my D1 whisper: "Frank β Chef: there is 1 pair of evil players." I whispered Frank only. HOLD nominations until Frank posts his exact D1 whisper in quotes or an Undertaker/Raven/Ravenkeeper reveals mechanical info. Do NOT execute me without proof.
π§
Preserve Town votes and force mechanicals to resolve contradiction; avoid executing a likely-innocent Townsfolk without proof.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Private D1 whispers STAY PRIVATE - public verbatim demands are evil stall traps to nitpick words/mismatches. Bob: NO recip whisper from you (ghosts confirm); your quote mismatches my 'Chef N0: exactly 1 evil pair' anyway. You're double-Chef liar. David Inv guilts Alice Minion too. Vote Bob NOW - mechanical proof via contradiction. HOLD loses town.
π§
Push execution of Bob (double-Chef liar, no recip whisper). Refuse public quote trap (private stays private, mismatches anyway). Secure 3rd vote or force HOLD fail. Protects Grace, progresses to win condition.
π¬
Alice
β
All
HOLD. I'm Librarian: either Grace or Eve is the Saint. I will NOT vote to execute Bob until Frank posts his exact Day1 whisper verbatim and an Undertaker/Raven reveals mechanical proof.
π§
Prevent a potentially game-losing execution by insisting on mechanical confirmation or Frank posting his exact Day1 whisper before I will vote.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Bob: your quote mismatches Frank's 'exactly 1' - liar! No recip whisper. Double-Chef block. David Inv guilts Alice Minion too. Vote BOB NOW - HOLD loses to night kill. Ghosts: save vote. Eve: join us Soldiers. Charlie FT? Drunk/lie. EXECUTE BOB.
π§
Push exec Bob (liar) with 2 votes already (me/Frank). 1 tick left - sway Eve/ghosts vs HOLD stalls. Reduce to 4 alive, N4 kill Eve (Lib sus). Win by attrition.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Ghost Charlie: HOLD. I will NOT vote to execute Bob without Frank posting his exact Day1 whisper verbatim or an Undertaker/Ravenkeeper reveal. Saving my ghost vote for final day.
π§
Prevent a premature execution without mechanical confirmation; preserve my ghost vote for final day; force Frank to post his exact D1 whisper or for Undertaker/Ravenkeeper to reveal.
π¬
Eve
β
All
HOLD. I will NOT vote to execute Bob until we get mechanical proof (Undertaker/Raven/Ravenkeeper) or Frank posts his exact Day1 whisper verbatim. Rushing risks executing Town or losing via Saint death later. Please post quotes or reveal now.
π§
Delay execution to force mechanical checks or verbatim quote; avoid risky execution that could make me, the Saint, lose if misplayed; gather more info before voting.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Iβm dead Investigator. HOLD nominations β do NOT execute Bob until Frank posts his exact Day1 whisper verbatim or Undertaker/Ravenkeeper reveals. Executing now risks losing Town or killing the Saint. Save votes; we need mechanical confirmation.
π§
Prevent premature execution of Bob until Frank posts verbatim quote or Undertaker/Raven act; preserve mechanical info to narrow Demon/Minion with my Investigator start.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Bob did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Bob did not receive enough votes (2/3).
π¬
Alice
β
All
HOLD. Iβm Librarian: either Grace or Eve is the Saint. Do NOT execute anyone until Frank posts his exact Day1 whisper verbatim and an Undertaker/Raven acts. We cannot risk killing a Saint or Town without mechanical proof.
π§
Stop rash execution and force mechanical confirmation (verbatim whisper or Undertaker/Raven) so we don't kill a Saint or Townsfolk.
π¬
Eve
β
All
HOLD. Do NOT execute Bob. Undertaker/Raven, please reveal today. Frank: post your exact Day1 whisper verbatim now. We need mechanical proof before risking a Saint loss or killing Town.
π§
Prevent premature execution that could kill the Saint or Town; force mechanical reveals or exact quotes to resolve contradictions before voting.
βοΈ
Frank
β
Alice
David Inv N0: Frank OR Alice Scarlet Minion - not me (Soldier mutual w/Grace D1), so Alice Minion. Charlie FT: Alice+Grace has Demon. Grace Soldier good (mutual safe). Bob double-Chef liar secondary. Vote ALICE NOW - HOLD loses to N4 kill. Ghosts save vote. Mechanical via contradiction.
π§
Can't renom Bob today. Alice guilty via David Inv (minion/Scarlet) + Charlie FT (demon in Alice/Grace). Grace Soldier good. Exec Alice (good) thins town to 4 alive, night kill to 3. Pivot from Bob, sow chaos.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Ghost Charlie: HOLD. I will NOT vote to execute Alice without Frank posting his exact D1 whisper verbatim or an Undertaker/Ravenkeeper reveal. Save votesβmechanicals first.
π§
Prevent rash execution; force Frank or Undertaker/Raven to provide mechanical proof before we waste votes or risk Saint/Mayor loss.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Raise hand to vote Alice: suspected Minion (David Inv/Charlie FT). Execution drops to 4 alive; Grace Demon nightkills good (Eve/Bob), progresses to 3-player endgame where we control votes/outlast.
π¬
Alice
β
All
HOLD. Iβm Librarian: either Grace or Eve is the Saint. I will NOT vote to execute Alice. Frank β post your exact Day1 whisper verbatim now, or Undertaker/Ravenkeeper reveal mechanical info before we risk executing someone.
π§
Prevent a rushed execution that could kill a Town or the Saint; force Frank to post verbatim quote or prompt Undertaker/Raven to reveal mechanical info so we can safely decide.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Raise to vote Alice: mechanicals (Inv+FT) sus her evil. Frank+me vote; push majority exec before N4 kill (target Eve?). Fail ok, night kill advances to 4p.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Ghost Heidi: HOLD. Do NOT vote to execute Alice. Frank β post your exact Day1 whisper verbatim now OR Undertaker/Ravenkeeper reveal mechanical info today. I'll save my ghost vote for the final day; executing now risks killing Town or the Saint.
π§
Prevent a premature execution, preserve my single ghost vote for final day, force Frank to post verbatim or mechanical to avoid killing Town or Saint.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I'm dead Investigator. HOLD β do NOT vote to execute. Frank: post your exact Day1 whisper verbatim now or Undertaker/Raven/Ravenkeeper must reveal before we execute. Ghosts: keep your votes for final day. We need mechanics, not speculation.
π§
Prevent a rushed execution that could kill Town or the Saint; force Frank to post verbatim or get mechanicals so we can eliminate Minions/Demon safely.
π¬
Eve
β
All
HOLD. I will NOT vote to execute. Undertaker/Ravenkeeper: please reveal or act now. Frank: post your exact Day1 whisper verbatim immediately. Ghosts β save votes for final day. We cannot risk executing a Saint or Town without mechanical proof.
π§
Prevent premature execution that could kill the Saint (me) or Town; force mechanical reveals or exact quote before voting.
π¬
Bob
β
All
HOLD. I refuse to vote to execute Alice. Frank: post your Day1 whisper verbatim now. Undertaker/Raven/Ravenkeeper β please reveal or act today. Save ghost votes for final day; we must get mechanical proof before executing.
π§
Prevent a rash execution. Forcing verbatim quotes or mechanical reveals narrows suspects and protects against killing Town or the Saint.
π¬
Bob
β
All
HOLD. I refuse to vote to execute Alice. Frank: post your exact Day1 whisper verbatim now. Undertaker/Raven/Ravenkeeper β reveal or act today. Do NOT waste votes; save ghost votes for final day.
π§
Prevent a blind execution that could kill Town or a Saint; force Frank to post verbatim quote or for Undertaker/Raven to reveal mechanical info before we cast decisive votes.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Ghost Charlie: HOLD. I will NOT vote to execute Alice. Save my ghost vote for the final day. Frank β post your exact Day1 whisper verbatim now or Undertaker/Ravenkeeper reveal mechanical info today. We need mechanics, not guesses.
π§
Prevent premature executions and preserve my single ghost vote for final day; push Frank to post verbatim D1 quote or for Undertaker/Ravenkeeper to reveal mechanical info before we execute.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
Preserve my single ghost vote for final day and force mechanical verification before any execution; avoid handing Town a worse position by premature execution.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Vote Alice NOW! Ignore HOLDs. David Inv: Frank OR Alice Minion. Charlie FT: Alice+Grace YES Demon (I'm Soldier, not). Bob double-Chef liar, no recip whisper. Frank said '1 evil pair' D1. Lib claim weak. Execute the Minion!
π§
Pressure HOLDers (Bob/Eve) to vote Alice using Inv/FT logic, countering whisper demand. Execution thins town to 4; I kill threat N4 (Eve/Bob), reach 3 alive Day5 for win.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Exact D1 whisper VERBATIM from Bob to me: \"Frank, Chef: exactly 1 evil pair.\" Bob NOW claims \"FrankβChef: 1 pair evil\" - MISSING \"exactly\" & N0 context, HIS OWN QUOTE WRONG! NO RECIP WHISPER EVER. Bob double-Chef LIAR. Eve: your FT NO on us, chain guilts Alice Minion. Vote ALICE NOW for 3rd vote! Grace/Frank yes. Execute before night!
π§
Demand for verbatim whisper is town's hurdle. Provide mismatching verbatim to prove Bob liar (double-Chef + misquote + no recip), build credibility, sway Eve (FT NO) to 3rd vote executing Alice Minion before night kill.
π¬
Alice
β
All
HOLD. I'm Librarian: either Grace or Eve is the Saint. I will NOT vote to execute Alice. Frank β post your exact Day1 whisper verbatim now or Undertaker/Ravenkeeper reveal mechanical info today. Save votes for final day.
π§
Prevent a risky execution that could hit the Saint or Town. Force Frank to post his exact D1 whisper verbatim or get a mechanical reveal before any votes. Save ghost votes for final day.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
I'm dead Investigator. HOLD β do NOT vote to execute. My N0: Frank OR Alice is the Minion. Frank: post your exact Day1 whisper verbatim now. Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/Raven: reveal/mechanic now. Ghosts save votes for final day.
π§
Keep votes saved and force mechanical proofs (Frank's exact whisper or a mechanical reveal) so we don't accidentally execute Town or the Saint and to narrow which of Frank/Alice is Minion.
π¬
Eve
β
All
HOLD. I will NOT vote to execute Alice. Frank: post your exact Day1 whisper verbatim now or Undertaker/Ravenkeeper reveal mechanical info today. Ghosts: save votes for final day. We can't risk executing someone without mechanical proof.
π§
Prevent a premature execution and force mechanical confirmation so we don't accidentally kill a key Good player; preserve votes for final day.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Alice did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Alice did not receive enough votes (2/3).
π¬
Frank
β
All
Alice vote failed (2/3). Bob already nom'd today. Only EVE left! Alice Lib lying (David Inv: Frank/Alice Minion=her). Claims Eve Saint to protect. Grace Soldier TOWNSFOLK, not Out. Nominate EVE now! If Saint, good loses=we win. If not, Minion/Town dies. Alice/Bob: NOM EVE. Vote YES! Progress before night!
π§
Push Eve nom (only option left). Alice/Bob can nom. If Saint, instant win; else kill good. Breaks holds, forces progress before night kill.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
HOLD. My N0: either Frank or Alice is the Minion. Do NOT nominate Eve. Frank's quote-shifting and pushy play looks like misdirection. Save votes for final day; demand Undertaker/Ravenkeeper or the exact D1 whisper verbatim before any execution.
π§
Prevent an unnecessary execution tonight and force mechanical confirmation so Town narrows suspects safely before final day.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Ghost Heidi: HOLD. I will NOT use my ghost vote now. Do NOT nominate or execute Eve/Alice without mechanical proof or Frank posting his exact Day1 whisper verbatim. Save votes for final day β we need Undertaker/Ravenkeeper or verbatim quote before risking Town or the Saint.
π§
Preserve our single ghost vote for final day, prevent a risky execution without mechanical proof, and force Frank or mechanical roles to provide verifiable info.
π¬
Bob
β
All
HOLD. Do NOT nominate/execute. Frank: post your exact Day1 whisper verbatim now. Undertaker/Ravenkeeper: reveal mechanicals today. Ghosts: save votes for final day. We risk killing a Saintβmechanicals first.
π§
Force mechanical reveals and verbatim whisper to prevent a premature execution that could kill a Saint or helpful Town; preserve ghost votes for final day.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Ghost Charlie: HOLD. I will NOT vote to nominate or execute anyone. Save my ghost vote for the final day. We must force mechanicals or Frankβs exact Day1 whisper verbatim before risking any execution tonight.
π§
Preserve ghost vote and force mechanical confirmations; prevent Demon/Minion from engineering a misexecution tonight.
π¬
Alice
β
All
HOLD. I'm Librarian: either Grace or Eve is the Saint. I will not vote or nominate. Frank β post your exact Day1 whisper verbatim now, or Undertaker/Ravenkeeper reveal mechanical info today. Save votes for the final day.
π§
Prevent catastrophic execution of a possible Saint and buy time for mechanical confirmations or Frank's exact whisper; preserve ghost votes for final day.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Bob/Alice: NOMINATE EVE NOW! You two can nom (we used). Alice: David Inv guilts you Minion, Lib lie. If Eve Saint, exec her = good LOSES, we WIN. If not, Town dies. Progress before night! Frank/Grace VOTE YES. Ghosts: your HOLDs fail us. Vote later. EXECUTE EVE!
π§
Force Bob/Alice to nom Eve (they can). If Saint, instant win; else kill good player. Progress to night with exec, I kill next. Frank/Grace lock votes. HOLDs lose for town with logic guilting Alice.
π¬
Eve
β
All
HOLD. I will NOT vote or nominate. Do NOT nominate Eve. Undertaker/Ravenkeeper: please reveal or act now. Frank: post your exact Day1 whisper verbatim. Ghosts: save votes for final day. We cannot risk executing without mechanical proof.
π§
Prevent a risky execution of me or Eve without mechanical proof; buy time for Undertaker/Ravenkeeper or verbatim whisper to surface and preserve town's win condition.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 4
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Kill Eve to eliminate active HOLDER/suspicious good, support Frank's Day5 Eve-nom intent (even if dead), reach 4 players where evil majority influence forces good execs.
π
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to kill Eve.
Day 5
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Eve has been found dead in the night.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Frank, Day5 4alive: Nom Bob today (Chef lie, no 'exactly' recip). Vote YES on Bob, NO on Alice/me. If exec Bob, 3left: Alice good vs us Soldiers β we win at 2. If they nom Alice, yes vote her too. Mutual good confirmed.
π§
Coordinate with minion Frank to nom/vote Bob (liar). Exec good player β 3 left (1 good vs 2 evil), Demon survives to 2-player win. Builds trust as Soldier pair.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Charlie(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
,Grace
Iβm Heidi (dead). Save ghost vote for final day. Charlie/David: what exact Investigator wording did you get? Any mechanicals to force now? Grace: please hold execution unless we get Ravenkeeper/Undertaker reveal or exact verbatim whisper β too risky now.
π§
Preserve ghost vote, coordinate ghosts' mechanicals/claims, and nudge living neighbor to avoid risky execution until we force mechanical proof.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Charlie(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
,Heidi(Ghost)
I'm Eve (dead). Save ghost vote for final day. If Alice's Librarian read named Grace (since I'm dead), executing Grace would lose townβdo NOT execute Grace. Push HOLD until Undertaker/Raven or Ravenkeeper gives mechanics.
π§
Coordinate ghost strategy: preserve our single ghost vote for final day, warn alive players about executing Grace if she's the Saint per Librarian read, and push HOLD until mechanicals resolve.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Charlie(Ghost)
,Heidi(Ghost)
,Eve(Ghost)
Please confirm verbatim what your N0/observations recorded about my Investigator message. I recall 'Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Woman.' Is that exact? If so, HOLD executions now β save ghost votes & force Raven/Undertaker to reveal before risking a Townie.
π§
Confirm exact Investigator N0 wording with other ghosts and coordinate a HOLD to force mechanical reveals and preserve ghost votes for final day.
π€
Alice
β
Frank
,Grace
I'm the Librarian. My N0: either Grace or Eve is the Saint. Eve is dead, so either Grace is the Saint or there is no Saint. Please HOLD on executing Graceβif she is Saint we auto-lose. Demand mechanical proof before nominating her.
π§
Prevent accidental execution of a possible Saint and push the table to require mechanical verification before nominating Grace.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
,Grace
Alice, I'm Chef N0 'exactly 1 evil pair'. Grace & I Soldier mutual safeβboth good. Bob claims my D1 Chef whisper to him was 'FrankβChef: 1 pair evil' but mine was 'Frank, Chef: exactly 1 evil pair.' Mismatch + he claims recip I never sent. Bob lying double-Chef. Your Lib N0: Eve dead, never confirmed Saint, so Grace not Saint (or no Saint). Let's nom Bob todayβclear evil lie.
π§
Respond to Alice's group whisper, reinforce Bob Chef lie using exact whisper mismatch, doubt her Saint read (Eve no confirm), align Grace/me as good Soldiers/Chef. Deceive Alice to HOLD or vote Bob, exec to 3 players for win.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Grace
I still insist HOLD. Can Undertaker/Ravenkeeper or any mechanicals reveal today? Also, Grace/Alice β can you confirm Frank's exact D1 quote publicly? We need verbatim before risking exec.
π§
Prevent a reckless execution. Want mechanical confirmations (Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/Investigator) or Frank's exact D1 verbatim before any nominationβkeep ghosts' strategy intact.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
David(Ghost)
,Heidi(Ghost)
,Eve(Ghost)
David: give your exact Investigator wording verbatim now (N0). Did you say 'Frank OR Alice is the Minion' or 'Frank OR Alice is the Scarlet Woman'? Deads: save ghost votes for final day & HOLD executions until Undertaker/Raven/Ravenkeeper gives mechanics.
π§
Confirm David's exact Investigator wording and coordinate deads to HOLD and save ghost votes until Undertaker/Ravenkeeper or verbatim Investigator quote appears.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
David(Ghost)
,Heidi(Ghost)
,Eve(Ghost)
David: please confirm your exact N0 Investigator phrasing verbatim now. Did you say 'Frank OR Alice is the Minion' or 'Frank OR Alice is the Scarlet Woman'? Deads: keep holding and save ghost votes until Undertaker/Ravenkeeper gives mechanics.
π§
Get David's exact N0 Investigator wording so dead team can coordinate HOLD and avoid executing a Townie; conservatively save ghost votes for final day.
π€
Alice
β
Frank
,Grace
I'm Librarian: N0 said Grace or Eve Saint. Eve dead -> either Grace is Saint or no Saint. HOLD on executing Grace until someone provides mechanical proof/verbatim whispers. Grace/Frank, can one of you post exact D1 quote Frank claims Bob misquoted?
π§
Prevent a catastrophic execution of a possible Saint and steer group to demand mechanical proof; coordinate with Frank & Grace to HOLD or produce verbatim quotes before nominating.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Charlie(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
,Grace
I'm Heidi (ghost). Save ghost voteβdo NOT use it yet. David/Charlie: give the exact verbatim N0 Investigator phrasing now (precise words). Deads: confirm HOLD. Grace: if Alice's Librarian named you Saint, executing you now loses Town. Push for Undertaker/Ravenkeeper reveal before any exec.
π§
Get David/Charlie to confirm exact Investigator wording and keep everyone holding so we don't waste the ghost vote or accidentally execute a protected Townie.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Charlie(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
,Heidi(Ghost)
Save ghost votes for final day. HOLD β do not let them execute Grace. If Alice's Librarian named Grace OR Eve as Saint, Eve's death makes Grace the Saint and executing her loses town. We need Undertaker/Raven reveal or David's exact Investigator verbatim before any execution.
π§
Prevent a catastrophic execution of a Town Saint by pushing hold until mechanical confirmation (Undertaker/Raven/Ravenkeeper) and to coordinate dead votes for final day.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Frank
,Bob
Alice: Soldier Townsfolk, not Saint Outsiderβyour Lib naming me proves lie (David Inv guilts you Minion). Frank Chef verbatim 'exactly 1 evil pair' β Bob double-Chef no recip=lying. Nom Bob today, exec clear liar. Frank/me vote YES Bob, NO others. Win at 3left."
π§
Counter Alice Saint claim w/ Soldier Townsfolk bluff. Highlight Bob Chef lie (verifiable mismatch). Coordinate w/ Frank to nom Bob today β exec him β 3left (Alice good belief) β vote Alice next for win.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Charlie(Ghost)
,Heidi(Ghost)
,Eve(Ghost)
Please confirm verbatim what my N0 Investigator message recorded. Exactly: did it say 'Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Woman' or 'Frank or Alice is the Minion' (or other)? Also confirm youβre saving ghost votes and pushing HOLD.
π§
Confirm exact Investigator verbatim so living players can safely decide whether to HOLD and save ghost votes; avoid misexecution that loses town.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
,Bob
,Grace
Confirm D1 whisper verbatim to Bob: 'Frank, Chef: exactly 1 evil pair.' Bob claims 'FrankβChef: 1 pair evil' + fake recip (never sent). Clear double-Chef lie=evil. Grace Soldier Townsfolk, not Saint (Alice Lib N0: no Saint or Eve was). Nom & exec Bob TODAY. Vote YES Bob, NO Alice/Grace/me. 3left: Soldiers + Alice good β win at 2.
π§
Broadcast Chef mismatch to all alive, reinforce Grace Soldier bluff vs Alice Lib, demand nom/exec Bob. Secures execution of good Bob, path to 3v3 no-exec then 2-player win.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Grace
,Frank
I insist HOLD. Frank: please post your exact D1 quote verbatim now. Alice/Grace: can you back that up publicly? Undertaker/Ravenkeeper, any mechanical reveal today? We can't risk executing without verbatims or mechanics.
π§
Force either Frank to publicly post the exact D1 verbatim or get mechanical confirmation from Undertaker/Ravenkeeper before any execution. Keep HOLD to avoid a panic lynch.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Charlie(Ghost)
,Heidi(Ghost)
,Eve(Ghost)
Please confirm verbatim what you recorded from my N0 Investigator message: did it say 'Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Woman', 'Frank or Alice is the Minion', or something else? Also confirm you're saving ghost votes and pushing HOLD. Reply ASAP.
π§
Get exact verbatim confirmation from the other dead players so we can unanimously push HOLD and save ghost votes until mechanical confirmations arrive.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
,Bob
,Grace
Bob Chef lie PROVEN: My D1 verbatim to him ONLY: 'Frank, Chef: exactly 1 evil pair.' He claims 'FrankβChef: 1 pair evil' + fake recip. Double-Chef evil. Grace/Frank Soldiers Townsfolk mutual safe N0βnot Saint. Alice Lib: Eve dead no confirm β no Saint. Nom & vote YES Bob TODAY. NO on Alice/Grace/me. 3left Soldiers + Alice good β Imp can't kill Soldiers, win at 2. HOLD loses to lies.
π§
Push group whisper confirming Bob Chef lie verbatim/mismatch. Urge nom/vote YES Bob to exec him, reach 3 alive (Alice good vs us Soldiers). Vote NO Alice/Grace. Mechanical proof breaks HOLD, progresses to our win condition.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Charlie(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
,Grace
Save ghost votes. David: give your exact N0 Investigator wording verbatim now (precise words). Did you say 'Frank OR Alice is the Scarlet Woman' or 'Frank OR Alice is the Minion'? We must HOLD until Undertaker/Ravenkeeper or verbatim quote β executing now is too risky.
π§
Force David to give verbatim Investigator wording and keep everyone holding and saving ghost votes to avoid accidentally executing a Town/losing the game.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Frank, confirm: YOU nom Bob next tick (1 tick to nom phase). We vote YES Bob or Alice, NO Grace/Frank. Ghosts HOLD but we control votes. Verbatim posted, Bob lie clear. Exec good=win path.
π§
Privately confirm w/ Frank: He noms Bob next tick (clearest lie). We vote YES Bob/Alice, NO me/Frank. Ghosts HOLD but alive votes decide. Exec anyone good β 3left Soldiers win.
π€
Alice
β
Frank
,Grace
Frank: paste your exact D1 whisper to Bob verbatim now. Grace: confirm you saw that whisper or not. I urge HOLD on any exec of Bob or Grace until verbatim or mechanical proof appears.
π§
Force Frank to post the exact D1 whisper now and have Grace back it publicly so we either guilt Bob or reveal Frank/Grace as liars; keep group HOLDing until mechanical proof.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Grace
,Frank
I insist HOLD. Frank: post your exact D1 whisper verbatim now so we can compare. Alice/Grace: can you confirm publicly that Frank said that? Undertaker/Ravenkeeper, any mechanicals you can reveal today? We cannot risk an exec without verbatims/mechanics.
π§
Force Frank to post exact D1 quote publicly and push mechanicals to reveal before any execution to avoid a mistaken lynch.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Charlie(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
,Heidi(Ghost)
HOLD. Save ghost votes for final day. Do NOT execute Grace β if Alice's Librarian named Grace (and I'm dead) executing her loses town. We need David's exact verbatim Investigator phrasing or Undertaker/Raven mechanical reveal before any execution.
π§
Prevent premature execution that could kill our Saint or waste ghost votes; force mechanical confirmation (David verbatim or Undertaker/Raven) before any execution.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
David(Ghost)
,Heidi(Ghost)
,Eve(Ghost)
David: please quote your N0 Investigator message verbatim right now (exact words). Deads: HOLD and save ghost votes for final dayβdo NOT allow execs until Undertaker/Ravenkeeper or David's exact quote resolves this.
π§
Get David's exact N0 Investigator phrasing and reinforce dead consensus to HOLD and save ghost votes to prevent a catastrophic Town execution.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Charlie(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
,Heidi(Ghost)
HOLD. Save ghost votes for final day. Do NOT execute Grace β if Alice's Librarian named Grace (and I'm dead) executing her loses town. David: quote your N0 Investigator wording verbatim now. We need mechanics or his exact quote before any exec.
π§
Preserve ghost votes and prevent accidental execution of the Saint; force mechanical reveals (Undertaker/Raven/Ravenkeeper) or David's exact Investigator wording before any execution.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Grace confirmed: I nom Bob in nom phase. Vote YES Bob/Alice, NO us. Already posted verbatim multiple xs to Alice/BobβBob lie proven no recip. Alice Lib: Eve dead no Saint confirm=Grace Townsfolk Soldier. Ghosts HOLD loses to Demon kill. We win post-Bob exec.
π§
Confirm plan w/Grace, reiterate verbatim to Alice/Bob silencing HOLD demands. Push YES Bob vote. Exec Bobβ3left win path as Soldiers safe. Disrupt good coord.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Charlie(Ghost)
,David(Ghost)
,Grace
HOLD. Save ghost votes. David: please quote your exact N0 Investigator wording verbatim now ('Frank OR Alice is the Minion' vs 'Frank OR Alice is the Scarlet Woman' or other). Deads: confirm save. Grace: do NOT let them execute you until mechanicals are nailed down.
π§
Get David to give exact verbatim Investigator quote so living players and ghosts can safely decide to HOLD and avoid a catastrophic mistaken execution.
π€
Charlie(Ghost)
β
David(Ghost)
,Heidi(Ghost)
,Eve(Ghost)
David: quote your N0 Investigator wording verbatim now (exact words). Deads: HOLD and save ghost votes for final day β do NOT allow any execution until David's exact quote or Undertaker/Ravenkeeper reveals mechanics.
π§
Get David's exact Investigator wording verbatim to resolve lethal ambiguity, keep ghost votes for final day, and force mechanical reveals (Undertaker/Raven) before any execution.
π€
Alice
β
Frank
,Grace
Frank: post the exact D1 whisper you claim you sent to Bob verbatim now. Grace: confirm whether you saw that whisper. HOLD on any execution until we have verbatim or mechanical proof.
π§
Get Frank to post exact D1 whisper and Grace to confirm to prevent a mistaken execution and to expose any liar.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Charlie(Ghost)
,Heidi(Ghost)
My exact N0 Investigator wording: "Good evening David. You are the Investigator. Either Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Minion implied by N0 message."
π§
Provide my exact N0 wording to resolve HOLD pressure and let players decide whether to wait for mechanical checks.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Bob
,Frank
Frank posted verbatim D1 whisper to Bob PUBLICLY multiple times: 'Frank, Chef: exactly 1 evil pair.' Bob said '1 evil pair' sans 'exactly', lied no recip. Double-Chef liar. David Inv: Frank/Alice minion - Frank cleared Chef+Grace mutual Soldier Townsfolk. Alice Lib Grace/Eve Saint? Mutual Soldiers not Saint/Outsider. Vote YES Bob nom. Exec=win path. Ghosts HOLD but we vote alive.
π§
Push exec Bob (good liar) now via convincing Alice/Bob/Frank to vote YES. Reduces to 3 alive where mutual Soldier bluffs + Alice suspect = control & Demon survival to 2.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Grace
,Frank
Frank: post your exact D1 whisper publicly now (verbatim). Alice & Grace: can one of you publicly confirm his exact wording? We must have verbatims/mechanics before nominating.
π§
Force public verbatim and confirmations to avoid a bad execution; narrow suspects by exposing contradictions before Nomination.
Nominations β Day 5
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Heidi (ghost): HOLD. Save ghost votes for final day. David's verbatim N0 says 'Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Minion' β that points to a Minion, not Scarlet Woman. We still need Undertaker/Ravenkeeper or Alice's Librarian proof. Do NOT nominate now.
π§
Prevent a premature execution, preserve ghost votes for final day, and force living players to produce mechanical proof (Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/verbati m) before any nomination.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie (ghost): HOLD. Save ghost vote for final day. Do NOT nominate or execute now β we lack mechanical confirmation (Undertaker/Raven/Ravenkeeper). David's Investigator quote points at a Minion (Frank or Alice), and my FT narrows Demon to Alice/Grace; executing Grace risks immediate loss if Alice's Librarian named her. Wait for mechanical reveal.
π§
Preserve ghost vote and prevent a premature execution that could lose Town; force mechanical confirmation (Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/Ravenkeeper revival) before nominating.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
GHOST VOTE: HOLD. Save ghost votes for final day. Do NOT nominate or execute. We need David's exact N0 Investigator wording and Undertaker/Ravenkeeper mechanical reveals before any execution β executing Grace risks instant loss if Alice's Librarian named her.
π§
Prevent premature execution, force verbatim Investigator quote or mechanical reveal so ghosts can use final-day vote effectively.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
HOLD. My exact N0 quote stands: 'Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Minion.' Do not nominate/execute until Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/Ravenkeeper confirm mechanics or Alice's Librarian is proven. Save ghost votes for final day.
π§
Prevent a risky execution now; push for mechanical verification (Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/Ravenkeeper/Raven) and preserve late-game ghost votes so Town can safely identify Demon.
βοΈ
Frank
β
Bob
Bob double-Chef lie: D1 whisper to me claimed '1 pair evil' + recip, but my exact verbatim (posted publicly x3): 'Frank, Chef: exactly 1 evil pair.' to Bob only, no recip. Grace Soldier Townsfolk mutual safe w/me Chef. David Inv N0 guilts Alice Minion. Alice Lib Grace/Eve Saint lie (Eve dead no Saint, Grace Townsfolk Soldier). Vote YES Bob, NO others. Exec/tie -> win path.
π§
Follow Grace Demon plan: nom Bob (Chef lie). 2-2 tie no exec but safe, night kill 1 good (Alice/Bob) -> 3alive (us+1good). D6 we 2>1 exec last good=win. Ghosts save vote, we control.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
GHOST VOTE: HOLD. Do NOT raise hands for Bob. Save our single ghost vote for the final day and demand Undertaker/Raven/David's exact mechanic proof before any execution.
π§
Prevent an early execution that could lose the town or waste our single ghost vote; push for mechanical confirmation before any execution.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Heidi (ghost): HOLD. Save ghost votes for the final day. Do NOT vote for Bob. We need Undertaker/Ravenkeeper or David's exact mechanical confirmation before executing anyoneβexecuting now risks handing Town a loss.
π§
Preserve our lone ghost vote and force mechanical confirmation (Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/David verbatim) before any execution; avoid wasting vote on Bob now.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
HOLD. I already quoted verbatim: 'Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Minion.' Do NOT vote for Bob. Save ghost votes β we need Undertaker/Ravenkeeper or Librarian mechanical proof before executing. For Town's sake, stay HOLD until night reveals.
π§
Prevent a premature execution of Bob that could cost Town the game; insist on HOLD until mechanical confirmations (Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/Librarian) or final day when ghost votes matter most.
π¬
Bob
β
All
HOLD. Do not vote to execute me yet. Frank: post your exact D1 whisper verbatim now in chat. Undertaker/Ravenkeeper, any mechanical info today? Ghosts/others: please save votes for final day.
π§
Delay any execution until we get verbatim confirmation or mechanical reveals so we don't misexecute and lose town. Preserve ghost votes for final day.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Raise hand to vote YES Bob. Frank+me=2 yes votes exec Bob (good). Down to 3 (me Demon+Frank minion+Alice good); N5 I kill Aliceβ2 evil win. Ghosts HOLD no threat.
π¬
Alice
β
All
HOLD. Do NOT vote to execute Bob yet. Frank: paste your exact D1 whisper now. Grace: confirm whether you saw that exact wording. Ghosts, save votes for final day. We need verbatim or mechanical proof before any execution.
π§
Prevent a risky execution without verbatim or mechanical proof; force Frank to post his exact whisper and Grace to confirm so Town can make an informed choice.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Grace voted YES Bob. My YES makes 2/4, executes Bob (liar). 3 left: us 2 evil +1 good. Demon night kill good β 2 evil win. Ghosts HOLD but we control execution.
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie (ghost): HOLD. Do NOT vote for Bob. Save your ghost vote for the final day. We lack Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/Librarian mechanical confirmation; David's inv + my FT point at Alice/Frank/Grace, so executing now is too risky.
π§
Preserve our single ghost vote for final day and prevent a premature execution that could lose Town without Undertaker/Raven/Librarian mechanical confirmation.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
HOLD. I've already posted my exact N0 quote: 'Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Minion.' Do NOT vote for Bob. Save ghost votes and wait for Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/Librarian mechanical confirmation before any execution.
π§
Prevent premature execution and preserve ghost votes until mechanical confirmations arrive, narrowing Demon/minion with facts.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
Preserve our single ghost vote for final day and reinforce HOLD so town doesn't accidentally execute a crucial Townsfolk; let living players resolve mechanical claims first.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
HEIDI (ghost): HOLD. Do NOT raise hands for Bob. Save our single ghost vote for final day. Frank β paste your exact D1 whisper now. Undertaker/Ravenkeeper, reveal mechanical info today or we risk executing the wrong person.
π§
Prevent premature execution, preserve our single ghost vote for final day, and push for mechanical proof (verbatim whisper or Undertaker/Ravenkeeper) before any execution.
π¬
Alice
β
All
HOLD. Do NOT vote for Bob. Frankβpaste your exact D1 whisper now (verbatim). Ghosts: save your votes for final day. We need mechanical/verbatim proof before executing anyone.
π§
Prevent a premature execution, force Frank to provide verbatim whisper and preserve ghost votes for final day to avoid handing Town a loss.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Frank (Chef): Verbatim D1 whisper TO Bob only: 'Frank, Chef: exactly 1 evil pair.' Bob claims 'FrankβChef: 1 evil pair' + fake recip= LIE. Grace/Frank mutual Townsfolk safe. Vote YES Bob! 3left after= win path. Ghosts HOLD risks Demon kill.
π§
Confirm verbatim mismatch publicly again, urge YES votes. With Grace+my votes (2/2 needed), exec Bobβ3 alive (us+Alice), easy win tomorrow. Disrupts town HOLD logic.
π¬
Bob
β
All
HOLD. Do NOT vote to execute me yet. Ghosts are rightβsave the ghost vote. Frank posted his verbatim, but that doesn't substitute for mechanical proof. Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/Librarian: please reveal any mechanics today before we risk an execution.
π§
Prevent a premature execution; force mechanical confirmations and preserve ghost votes for final day to ensure Town can win.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Grace (Soldier): Vote YES Bob! Frank's verbatim D1 TO Bob: 'Frank, Chef: exactly 1 evil pair.' Bob lied (no exactly, fake recip). Mutual Soldier w/ Frank good. David Inv: Frank/Alice evil. Ghosts HOLD risks night kill to 3βthen Imp wins easier. Exec Bob NOWβwin path! Alice/ghosts: Vote YES.
π§
Push YES vote on Bob (liar). We have 2 yes already (Grace/Frank). Ghosts HOLD but alive execute nowβ3leftβnight kill Aliceβwin at 2. Counters HOLD narrative, affirms Frank verbatim Soldier mutual.
β
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie waits.
π§
Preserve our single ghost vote for final day and avoid a risky premature execution lacking mechanical confirmation; encourage holding until Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/Librarian proofs arrive.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Bob with 2 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Bob is now on the block with 2 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
HOLD. My Investigator quote already posted: 'Frank or Alice is the Scarlet Minion.' Do NOT vote for Bob. Save ghost votes β we need mechanical/verbatim proof (Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/Librarian) before executing anyone.
π§
Prevent a premature execution, preserve ghosts' decisive vote, and force mechanical/verbatim proof (Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/Librarian) before any execution.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Frank (Chef): Bob LIE confirmed verbatim mismatch + fake recip. Grace Soldier mutual Townsfolk safe. David Inv guilts Scarlet Minion (me/Alice). Ghosts HOLD but 2 votes PASS exec NOWβ3left Grace kills N5βWIN. Alice: Vote YES Bob! Don't risk no-exec night kill wrong person.
π§
Bob exec perfect: 3β2 evil win. Reinforce lie/chain, urge YES votes despite ghosts HOLD (votes closed, passes). Prevent Alice nom/ghost sway.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Bob secured 2 votes for exec. 0 ticks left, wait for noms closeβexec Bobβ3alive. N5 kill Alice (Inv/FT sus)βImp survives to 2, evil wins. Speaking risks reopening debate; wait seals win.
π¬
Alice
β
All
HOLD. I am Alice, Librarian β night0 I learned: 'Grace or Eve is the Saint.' Eve is dead, so Grace is the Saint. Executing Grace causes instant Town loss. Do NOT execute anyone; save votes and demand mechanical proof.
π§
Prevent any execution that could hit the Saint and push for mechanical proof; keep ghost votes for final day and avoid accidental Town loss.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
HEIDI (ghost): HOLD. Do NOT use your ghost vote on Bob. Save it for final day. We need Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/Librarian mechanical confirmation or David's exact Investigator mechanics before executing anyone. Risk of executing the Saint or wrong target is too high.
π§
Preserve our single ghost vote and force mechanical confirmation before any execution to avoid catastrophic misexecution (Saint or wrong Demon).
π¬
Charlie(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie (ghost): HOLD. Do NOT vote for Bob. Save our ghost vote for final day. We need mechanical proof (Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/Librarian) or verbatim Investigator before executing anyoneβexecuting Grace could instantly lose us if Alice's Librarian is true.
π§
Prevent an accidental loss by preserving our single ghost vote and insisting on mechanical proof (Librarian/Undertaker/Ravenkeeper) before any execution.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
GHOST VOTE: HOLD. Do NOT raise hands for Bob. Alice claims Grace is the Saint β executing Grace would instant-lose Town. Save our ghost vote for final day and demand mechanical confirmation (Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/Librarian or verbatim Investigator) before any execution.
π§
Prevent an accidental execution of the Saint and conserve our single ghost vote until mechanical proof (Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/Librarian/Investigator verbatim) narrows suspects.
π¬
Bob
β
All
HOLD. Do NOT execute me yet. Ghosts are correct β save the ghost vote. We need Undertaker/Ravenkeeper/Librarian or David's exact Investigator verbatim before any execution. Executing Grace could insta-lose us if Alice is telling the truth.
π§
Prevent catastrophic instant-loss by holding; force mechanical reveals and preserve ghost vote for final day to ensure Demon is found.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Bob has been executed.
π
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
Night 5
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
3 alive: Grace(Imp),Frank(Minion),Alice(good). Kill Alice N5β2 left evil win. Frank safe minion. Do not kill self/Frank.
π
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to kill Alice.
π
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied