Game Detail

I need to choose a 'master' for tomorrow so I can potentially vote. I'll pick my neighbor Grace to start.

Whisper Demon first to establish secret alliance, share my Baron info (+2 Outsiders), learn safe bluffs from his role list, plan to sow chaos without tipping town.

I want to establish a connection with my neighbor Frank. As an Undertaker, my info comes after executions, so I need to build trust early without making myself a target for the Demon.

I want to privately verify my Librarian information with Grace to see if she claims the Recluse role or if she's a Townsfolk.

Early Day 1, establish bluffs with minion before nominations. Pit goods by suggesting targets. Hide as good Townsfolk to build trust.

I want to build trust with my neighbor Eve by being honest about my Outsider status. Since Butler is a low-value target for the Demon, coming out early to a neighbor can help establish a circle of trust.

I want to confirm Bob's Librarian claim by admitting I am the Recluse. This builds trust with a potential Townsfolk and helps verify the Outsider count early.

I am the Ravenkeeper. My ability only triggers if I die at night. I want to remain low-profile and observe the initial interactions without drawing attention to myself as a priority target for the Demon. Staying quiet for the first tick allows me to see who is being aggressive and who is being secretive.

I want to establish a connection with my neighbor Alice to see if she's willing to share information and to gauge her alignment. As the Saint, I need to stay alive, so building trust early is key.

Bluff Fortune Teller to Eve early to gain credibility with potential good player (neighbor), fish her claim/role for evil intel. Aligns with Charlie's plan to pit Alice vs Eve; sows seeds of alliance/manipulation before nomination.

I want to build trust with my neighbor David, who has claimed Fortune Teller. As the Undertaker, I need to know who people are suspicious of so I can verify their roles if they get executed.

Confirming Grace's claim and probing for more information about the game state (specifically the presence of a Baron).

Early coordination with minion locks our bluffs and kill target, sowing chaos by pitting goods while hiding as confirmed Townsfolk.

I need to establish a connection with Grace because my voting ability depends on her today. Letting her know I am the Butler and she is my master builds trust and ensures my vote isn't wasted.

I'm sharing my role and the information I have with Frank to build trust and investigate the Outsider count, which is crucial for identifying if a Baron is in play.

I want to build rapport with my neighbor Heidi while remaining vague about my actual role. By deflecting and asking for her observations, I can gauge her alignment and potentially bait the Demon if she's evil, or find an ally if she's good.

Build trust with Alice by acknowledging her observation and stating a clear next step to gather more info.

Lock in bluffs with Demon, confirm kill Bob. Spread Fortune Teller claim to Eve for false good alliance, pit her vs Alice later. Builds cred, coordinates evil.

I need to push back on David's suspicious suggestion to 'kill Bob' and verify Charlie's role claim.

I want to build a stronger alliance with Grace since she confirmed my Librarian ping, and I want to see if she has any other information or if anyone else has been acting suspiciously towards her.

Damage control David's slip-up by reframing 'kill' as nominate. Lock Monk/FT bluffs with Eve to gain ally or false confirmation. Advance evil coordination without admitting Demon.

I want to confirm the Outsider count with Grace to see if a Baron is likely in play. This helps determine the setup and identify potential evil players.

To share the Butler claim with my confirmed Librarian and discuss the possibility of a Baron or Eve being evil.

I want to branch out and talk to my other neighbor, Bob, to gather more information and see if he corroborates anything Heidi might have said or if he has a different perspective.

I want to gather information from Grace, who has been very active in private whispers, to see if she has a role or has heard any claims. As the Saint, I need to stay informed to avoid being executed while also identifying potential threats.

I want to see if anyone else makes a nomination or shares information publicly before the day ends. as a Ravenkeeper, I benefit from being targeted at night, so I shouldn't draw too much attention to myself yet.

Publicly reveal my role as the Butler and my choice of Grace as my master to establish transparency and align with the good team's strategy.

I am revealing my role as the Saint early to prevent my own execution, which would end the game in an immediate loss for the good team. Since Frank has already claimed an Outsider role (Butler), I need to be transparent so the team can track the Outsider count and avoid me.

I need to point out the Outsider count to the group because three Outsiders (Saint, Butler, Recluse) in an 8-player game strongly suggests a Baron is in play. I also want to highlight the discrepancy in Bob's Librarian ping regarding Eve.

Confirm Grace's statement and publicly reveal my Librarian information to put pressure on Eve.

Town consensus Eve evil via Bob's info + Outsiders. She's likely good but nom her to kill good player, build trust by following logic, distract from David minion.

I am voting for Eve to follow the logic presented by Bob and Grace. With three Outsiders claiming, a Baron is likely in play, and Bob's Librarian ping on Eve makes her highly suspicious.

I am following my Butler restriction. My master is Grace, and she hasn't voted yet, so I must wait for her to raise her hand before I can vote for Eve.

Wait to see if more players vote for Eve before deciding to contribute my vote.

I am voting for Eve because the mechanical information from Bob (Librarian) and the presence of three Outsider claims (Saint, Butler, Recluse) strongly suggests a Baron is in play, making Eve highly suspicious as the other half of Bob's ping.

I am raising my hand to vote for Eve to support the logic that if Grace is the Recluse, Eve is likely an evil player trying to hide.

Raise hand to execute Eve (likely good). Secures 4th vote, kills good player early, advances evil win by thinning town. Fits my Monk bluff supporting info claims.

Support Demon's nomination of Eve. She's likely good (questions Charlie) or Minion per logic. Execution thins good team, disrupts town logic on Outsiders. My FT bluff can adapt post-execution.

I need to reveal my role as the Undertaker to prevent my execution. Since I am a powerful information role, the good team should want to keep me alive to verify today's execution tonight.

I am lowering my hand because Eve's Undertaker claim is too valuable to lose on Day 1, especially if she's telling the truth.

Vote for Eve because my master, Grace, has her hand raised and the logic for a Baron game with Eve as a potential evil player is currently the strongest lead.

I want to stop the execution of Eve because she has claimed a valuable Townsfolk role (Undertaker) and the logic used to nominate her (that she must be evil because Grace is the Recluse) is flawed if Bob's Librarian info is correct.

Eve's Undertaker claim is plausible because Bob's Librarian ping on the Recluse was satisfied by my own claim. Executing a potential Undertaker Day 1 is too risky for the good team.

I want to prevent the execution of a potential Undertaker who was cleared by my own Librarian info once Grace claimed Recluse.

Lower hand pretending convinced by logic, solidifying Monk bluff. Vote fails safely, preserves my good image for chaos later. Plan N1 Bob kill.

Lower hand to follow town logic, protect Undertaker info, reinforce my FT bluff that Eve/Alice good. Builds credibility, disrupts by keeping good team intact but confused on who Baron protects.

I need to solidify my position as a trusted Townsfolk after the scare of being nominated. By explaining the value of the Undertaker in a game with multiple Outsider claims, I encourage the town to look elsewhere for the Demon.

Encourage more information sharing before the day ends, specifically targeting those who haven't fully claimed or provided info.

To confirm my role as Butler, support the current logic regarding Grace and Eve, and pressure David to reveal his role to help the good team's process of elimination.

I want to push David to reveal his role and highlight the Outsider count to confirm if a Baron is likely in play.

Encourage David and Alice to reveal their roles to complete the puzzle of the game's composition, specifically to identify the Baron and Demon.

I want to push the remaining silent players, David and Alice, to claim their roles to verify if a Baron is in play, which would explain the three Outsider claims (Saint, Recluse, Butler).

Claim safe Monk bluff publicly to build good cred as Townsfolk. Neighbors Bob/David mentioned innocently. Prompt David FT bluff to counter Baron suspicion with town claim, coordinate evil bluffs, force Alice claim.

Reaffirm FT bluff for credibility since all asking. Acknowledge Baron (true, me) to validate 3 Outsiders. No info yet, shift suspicion to unclaimed Alice. Delays day1 exec, protects Demon.

Encourage Alice to reveal her role to complete the puzzle of the game's setup.

Killing unclaimed Alice eliminates potential info/power role outing David/me, stalls town progress, and fits Monk bluff (protecting neighbors Bob/David implicitly). Helps evil survive to endgame.

I am the Ravenkeeper and I was killed on Night 1. Since Bob's Librarian claim (identifying Grace or Eve as the Recluse) is the cornerstone of the current game solve (Baron world with three Outsiders), verifying his role is the most efficient way to confirm the entire group's structure. If Bob is indeed the Librarian, it validates Grace and potentially Eve, narrowing the search for the Demon to those who haven't been mechanically linked yet.

I am choosing Grace as my master again. Since Bob's Librarian info pointed to her being the Recluse, she is a confirmed 'Outsider' (even if she registers as evil), which makes her a relatively safe bet for a Butler to follow. Keeping my master consistent helps build trust and maintains my mechanical constraint.

I want to check in with my 'master' Grace to see if she has any leads and to reinforce my Butler claim by referencing our mechanical connection.

Whisper Demon to privately align bluffs, share fake FT info clearing allies, push Bob as suspicious Lib to sow doubt before nomination phase.

I want to confirm Eve's claim and see if she understands her role mechanics. If she claims to have info, she might be lying (Undertaker only sees executed players). Sharing my Librarian role builds trust.

Agree with minion to nominate Bob (good player), disrupt town logic/info, keep us cleared/safe. Reduces alive players, progresses evil win condition.

Establish a private alliance with Bob, whom I know for a fact is the Librarian. This helps coordinate the good team and verify the Outsider count.

Answer Bob's question to maintain trust and probe for more information about his Librarian claim or any other leads he might have.

I am waiting to observe the initial flow of information after Alice's death and to see how others react to the night's events.

I want to engage with Frank to see if we can align our suspicions and verify the Baron world-state. Since he's a Butler following me, he's a potential ally or a Minion trying to pocket me.

I'm continuing my private conversation with Grace to align our suspicions and test her perspective as my chosen 'master'.

Whisper Frank/Grace (coordinating pair) to nominate Bob using Lib-Recluse conflict + my FT clear. Builds trust in my bluff, sows doubt on Bob, leads to his nom/execution without targeting Charlie.

Alice is a dead Ravenkeeper who confirmed my role. I need to share my Librarian info with her so she can help piece together the puzzle from the graveyard, as she is likely trusted now.

Whisper to Frank/Grace after David's whisper there: reinforce David FT info, highlight Bob Lib contradiction to build nom consensus on good Bob, sowing good-on-good execution.

Establish a solid core of trusted players and narrow down the evil team by confirming the presence of a Baron and discussing trust levels with a confirmed good player.

I want to gather information from the Fortune Teller to cross-reference with my Undertaker role and narrow down suspects for a potential execution today.

I'm reaching out to Bob because he's my neighbor and has provided specific Librarian info. I want to see if he's gathered more information from his private talks with the recently deceased Alice or Eve.

I want to point out the inconsistency in their logic. Bob's claim actually validates me, so their rush to call him a liar for it feels like an evil push to execute a Townsfolk.

I want to alert Grace that David and Charlie's logic for attacking Bob seems flawed, as Bob's info actually aligns with Grace's claim. I want to see if she notices the same discrepancy.

Counter Eve/Grace doubts on Bob by reinforcing my FT clear on Charlie+Bob. Get them to nom/vote Bob, protecting Demon Charlie as we enter noms. Builds town consensus against Bob.

I want to share my confirmed status and Librarian info with Heidi to build trust and see her reaction, while also checking her thoughts on the Baron scenario.

Counter Grace's hesitation on Bob nom; reinforce suspicion to get goods to execute good Bob, wasting their exec while I survive.

Solidify the alliance with Bob (confirmed Librarian) and use the 'three Outsider' situation to narrow down the evil team.

I want to verify David's Fortune Teller information and coordinate a potential execution on Bob to use my Undertaker ability, while being cautious of the outsider count.

I need to confirm Alice's Ravenkeeper info to find the Demon and also signal to Bob (who seems trustworthy) that I am the Saint and shouldn't be executed.

I want to point out the logical inconsistency in David's push for Bob. If David is the Fortune Teller and got a 'no' on Bob, he shouldn't be calling Bob the Demon. This puts pressure on the David/Charlie duo.

I want to prompt David to share his Night 2 information publicly to see if it corroborates his suspicion of Bob or points elsewhere, while also keeping the conversation moving during the nomination phase.

I want to highlight the logical inconsistency in David's push against Bob. David claims his Fortune Teller check on Bob was 'no' (not the Demon), yet he is aggressively pushing to nominate Bob as if he is the Demon. I want the town to see this contradiction before we commit to a nomination.

Nominate Bob per Demon coord to execute likely good player, reduce numbers, test his claim. Addresses Grace by implying Minion. Protects Charlie, disrupts town.

I am voting for Bob to use my Undertaker ability tonight and verify his role, which will help confirm if there is a Baron and clarify the Outsider count.

I want to wait and see if David or Charlie can provide a more compelling reason to execute Bob despite David's 'no' result, as a Minion execution is less valuable than a Demon execution on Day 2.

Team (Charlie) and I pushed Bob nom to execute a likely good player, thin town. Eve yes vote; aim for 4 to succeed, progress to night safely.

Support David's nom of Bob as suspicious Minion per FT info. Exec good player to reduce numbers, keep pressure off me. Need 4 votes; this pushes it over with Eve/David/mine + likely another.

Defend myself against execution by pointing out the logical inconsistency in David's push and reminding the group of Alice's confirmation.

I am avoiding voting for Bob because executing a non-Demon is a waste of a day, and as the Saint, I need to keep the game going to find the real Demon.

I am waiting to see if Grace votes before I decide whether or not to cast my own vote, as per my Butler restriction.

I need to stop the execution of a player I know is good (Bob) and point out the flawed logic of the person pushing for it (David). Since I am the Ravenkeeper and I used my death ability on Bob, I know for a fact he is the Librarian.

I am lowering my hand because Alice, who died last night, claims she was the Ravenkeeper and verified Bob as the Librarian. This makes David's push to execute Bob highly suspicious.

Stop the execution of a confirmed good player and highlight the contradiction in David's push.

Sway Grace/Eve/Heidi/Frank to raise hands by questioning Alice's late claim and Bob's buddy-up timing. Execute likely-good Bob to eliminate threat, confirm Outsiders via Eve, protect Demon.

Push execution of likely good Bob to thin good players. Disrupt Grace/Eve doubt by questioning Alice timing, support David to maintain minion cover. Get 4 votes before tick ends.

To defend myself against execution by pointing out the logical inconsistency in David's push and clarifying how Alice got her information.

I want to discourage the group from executing Bob, as Alice's Ravenkeeper claim (if true) confirms him as a good player, and David's own Fortune Teller claim suggests he isn't the Demon. As the Saint, I need the good team to use executions wisely on potential Demons.

Explain my mechanical inability to vote without my master (Grace) and support the consensus that executing Bob is a bad idea given Alice's Ravenkeeper claim.

I will refrain from using my ghost vote on Bob because I have confirmed him as the Librarian with my Ravenkeeper ability and David's own Fortune Teller info clears him as the Demon. Executing a confirmed Townsfolk is detrimental to the good team's progress.

Acknowledge Alice's Ravenkeeper claim and Bob's Librarian confirmation to pivot the town away from Bob and gather more info from David.

Challenge David's contradictory logic and push the town to look for better targets.

Doubt Alice's convenient timing/reliability to undermine Bob confirmation. Pivot to Frank/Grace suspicious link (Lib+master), urge nominate Frank to execute good, sow chaos before night.

David my minion suggested Frank; nom him to exec good player, disrupt town, get Eve UT info on death, keep pressure off us. Reduces good numbers.

I am choosing not to vote for Frank at this moment. As the Undertaker, I need an execution to occur to get information, but Frank's Butler claim is tied to Grace, and Alice's Ravenkeeper info suggests we might have a Baron game. I want to see if more information comes out or if a more suspicious target is nominated before committing my vote.

I want to express my skepticism of the nomination on Frank and suggest focusing on unconfirmed players. I will also remind Frank that as his 'master', I am not voting for him.

Counter Grace by highlighting coordinated claims (Bob Lib->Grace Recluse->Frank Butler vote tie). Rally votes for Frank execution to eliminate good player reducing numbers, follow Demon Charlie's lead, get Undertaker info.

Frank's Butler ties to Grace protect Bob nom, suspicious coord. Vote to execute, reduce good players or expose if Baron. David supports, aligns with team. Gets Eve info if Undertaker.

I will wait and not vote for Frank, as my Librarian information (Grace/Eve as Recluse) combined with the other Outsider claims (Heidi as Saint, Frank as Butler) strongly suggests a Baron game where all three are likely legitimate good-aligned Outsiders.

Stop the execution of an Outsider (Frank) and reinforce the likelihood of a Baron game based on my own Saint role.

Defend myself against the nomination by highlighting my mechanical restriction as the Butler and pointing out that executing Outsiders in a Baron game is counterproductive.

I will wait and not use my ghost vote on Frank, as I believe he is likely a legitimate Outsider (Butler) in this Baron game.

I will wait to see if the vote on Frank gains momentum. As the Undertaker, I want an execution to happen to get information, but Frank's Butler claim being tied to Grace (who I am suspicious of due to the Librarian/Recluse overlap) makes him a low-priority target compared to finding the Demon.

I want to point out the logical inconsistency in David's push for Frank and highlight that his own information clears the people he's suspicious of.

Support Charlie's Frank nom by voting yes, show evil unity, pressure Bob/Grace/Frank sus block (perfect info match + vote hide), thins goods or fails but sows chaos, Eve UT reveals role if exec.

Push Frank exec as good player to thin town, gain Eve UT info controllable by evil lies tomorrow. David teammate pushing too.

I want to discourage the group from executing Frank, as my Librarian info combined with the Outsider count strongly suggests he is a legitimate Butler in a Baron game. Executing him wastes a day and confirms what we already suspect.

I am speaking out against the execution of Frank because, as a Saint in a likely Baron game, I recognize that executing confirmed Outsiders is a strategy that benefits the evil team by wasting our limited executions. I want to redirect focus to unconfirmed players.

Defend myself against the nomination by highlighting my mechanical restriction as Butler and the strategic disadvantage of executing an Outsider in a potential Baron game.

Defend the Outsider (Frank) from execution. Since I have confirmed Bob as the Librarian, and there are three Outsider claims (Frank, Heidi, Grace), it is highly probable a Baron is in play. Executing known Outsiders is a waste of time and only helps the evil team reach their win condition faster.

I will wait for the day to end since nominations are almost over and I want to see if any last-second plays occur before I act as Undertaker tonight.

Wait for the night phase to begin as the nomination period for the day is over and no one is on the block.

Frank nom failed-good. Redirect suspicion to unconfirmed Eve (likely good Undertaker per Charlie) before night. Sow doubt on defenders, protect Demon, progress executions on goods.

Failed Frank nom; pivot to David's Eve push as minion coord. Test unconfirmed Eve, remove potential good Undertaker before she gains more info. Sows doubt in Baron theory, disrupts good logic targeting us.

Wait for the Day to end as nominations against Bob and Frank have failed, and there is only 1 tick remaining. I want to see if anyone else makes a last-second nomination or if we transition to Night.

Argue against executing the Undertaker claim (Eve) while reinforcing the likelihood of a Baron game based on the triple Outsider count.

I want to steer the town away from executing Eve (the claimed Undertaker) or myself/Heidi (claimed Outsiders) in a likely Baron game. I want to highlight that David's 'no' results should be used to narrow down the Demon pool instead of just confirming known claims.

I want to prevent the town from making a catastrophic mistake by executing the Undertaker or an Outsider in a likely Baron game, especially since my Ravenkeeper info on Bob is rock solid. I need to refocus the town on looking for the Demon among the remaining unconfirmed players.

Killing Eve eliminates claimed Undertaker (key good utility), builds on our Day 2 push (David/me vs her), sows chaos in Baron theory by removing unconfirmed claim, keeps Demon alive.

I am choosing Grace as my master again for Night 2. Since I am the Butler and she is the claimed Recluse who has been defending me, keeping her as my master maintains consistency in my play and reinforces my claim to the town. If she is the Recluse, she is a good player (though registers as evil), and sticking with her helps maintain our small alliance of claimed Outsiders and the 'Baron' theory.

I need to coordinate with Bob, who is a confirmed Librarian (via dead Alice), to narrow down the Demon. Since Eve is dead, we can't verify roles through her anymore. I also need to remind him I'm the Saint to ensure I'm not a candidate for execution.

I want to check in with my 'master' Grace to see her perspective on the Night 2 death. Since Eve (the Undertaker claim) died, it suggests the Demon didn't want her confirming roles. David was aggressive toward Eve, making him suspicious.

Respond to Heidi's whisper to maintain our alliance and steer the conversation towards potential non-Outsider suspects, specifically David or Charlie who have been driving the narrative.

I need to coordinate with Bob because I know for a fact he is the Librarian (and thus good). I want to know what Heidi (the Saint) told him to see if they have new leads or if Heidi is being coerced.

Whisper Demon Charlie to privately align on Day 3 nom: target Bob to kill Lib threat and progress suspicion from Day 2. Coordinate before nomination phase.

Coordinate with David: agree nom Bob (push as minion Spy faking Lib), defend Heidi Saint publicly, mark Frank suspicious to pivot later. Builds our bluffs, executes likely good.

Respond to Frank's suspicion of David and build a trust-based alliance while analyzing the night death of Eve (the Undertaker claim).

I need to coordinate with the only other dead player who is a confirmed good role (Ravenkeeper) to consolidate information. Being dead, I am now 'confirmed' good to the group if they believe my claim, and Alice is already confirmed by Bob.

I want to align with Bob and cast suspicion on David and Charlie. Since Eve (Undertaker) is dead, we've lost our best way to verify roles through execution, and the push for Outsider deaths from David/Charlie feels increasingly like a redirection tactic by evil players.

I want to test Grace's perspective on the other players to see if her suspicions align with a good-aligned view, specifically regarding the other Outsider claim (Heidi) and the 'confirmed' players.

I want to coordinate with Alice, who is a confirmed good ghost (Ravenkeeper), to see if her Night 2 info can help identify if David or Charlie is the Demon.

Confirm my Night 1 check to Bob privately and align on David and Charlie being the primary suspects, especially since Eve's death as the Undertaker validates her role and points towards the Demon wanting to hide information.

Confirm nom plan with Charlie, ensure we push Bob as fake Lib Spy today. Defend Heidi Saint to validate Outsiders/Baron story, sow doubt on Bob/Grace chain. Progress to nomination strong.

Coordinate with minion David to nom Bob (good Lib), defend Heidi Saint publicly to fit Baron Outsiders story, sow chaos on Grace Recluse fake. Keeps me safe as Monk bluff.

I want to solidify my alliance with Frank by discussing the Outsider count and checking his trust levels, while also reinforcing my own claim as the Recluse based on Bob's Librarian info.

I want to share my role with Bob, who is a confirmed Librarian (via Alice the Ravenkeeper), to build a circle of trust and get his perspective on the Demon candidates.

I want to confirm the Outsider count with Bob to solidify the theory that a Baron is in play, which would protect me from being a suspect for execution as the Saint.

Confirm the logic chain for Grace being the Recluse and narrow down potential suspects between the Outsider claims and the pushy players.

To coordinate with Heidi and Alice to expose the likely presence of a Baron and shift suspicion onto David and Charlie before the nomination phase begins.

Share my Ravenkeeper information with the dead Undertaker to build a trust alliance and narrow down the Demon suspects.

Coordination with Charlie complete; whispers show good team scrambling (Bob/Heidi). Wait for nomination tick to nom Bob as Spy, defend Heidi publicly there. Keeps Demon safe, executes good player.

David to nom Bob as planned. Last day tick; wait for nomination to publicly back Heidi Saint (fits Baron Outsiders) and push Bob Spy faking Lib. Reduces goods without exposing us.

I want to solidify the logic with Frank regarding the Outsider count and the Baron theory, while subtly probing if he might be the one lying, or if we should pivot our suspicion towards David.

Confirm suspicion with Alice and coordinate observation for the upcoming nomination phase.

I want to publicly pressure David and Charlie because they pushed for my execution yesterday, and my death last night suggests I was a threat to the evil team. I also need to update the group's information by asking for the latest Fortune Teller result.

I want to hear David's response to Eve's question before making a move.

Nominating Bob executes a good player, breaks Lib-Recluse chain town relies on. Protects Demon Charlie, backs Heidi Saint publicly via Baron Outsiders fit. Eve's UT claim no info since N2 death; my FT bluff intact.

I am holding my ghost vote for a more certain target or the final day, as Bob's Librarian claim has been backed by Alice's Ravenkeeper claim.

I want to observe the group's reaction to the nomination on Bob before committing my vote, as Bob's Librarian info correctly identified me as the Recluse.

Voting yes executes likely good Bob, thinning herd to 5 alive, protecting Demon Charlie. I nominated him; consistency sells Baron bluff. Need 3 votes; Charlie/Heidi likely join.

I need to defend Bob because I have mechanical proof from my Night 1 Ravenkeeper ability that he is the Librarian. David's theory that Bob is a Spy faking Librarian is incorrect based on my information. I want to prevent a good player from being executed.

I will not vote for Bob and will speak up to defend him, reinforcing Alice's confirmation of his role and pointing out that David's nomination is suspicious given the Ravenkeeper information.

To defend Bob and point out the flaw in David's logic, while reinforcing the Baron/Outsider theory based on Alice's confirmed information.

Defend myself and point out David's suspicious behavior in ignoring Alice's confirmation.

Publicly back David's nom by explaining Spy RK fake, support minion, try sway 3rd vote (Grace?) or fail exposes town division for N3 kill.

I will withhold my ghost vote for now because the nomination on Bob (a likely good player confirmed by Ravenkeeper Alice) is based on a Spy theory that seems less probable than David or Charlie being the actual Demon.

I want to defend Bob and point out the flaws in Charlie and David's logic, as Bob is confirmed by a dead Ravenkeeper. This helps keep a confirmed good player alive and puts pressure on potential evil candidates.

Counter Alice/Heidi/Frank/Grace defenses by explaining Spy misreg to RK. Rally votes for Bob exec (me+Charlie+?); thins goods regardless, disrupts town logic on Baron.

Defend Bob and point out the flaws in David's logic regarding the Spy ability, while also signaling that I will not be using my ghost vote on this nomination.

Defend Bob and the Baron theory. Bob is confirmed by Alice (Ravenkeeper), and David's push feels like an attempt by the evil team to execute a confirmed good player and ignore the mechanical implications of the Baron.

I am following my Butler restriction. Since my master, Grace, has stated she is not voting for Bob, I must also refrain from voting.

To counter David and Charlie's Spy accusation by pointing out the consistency of the Baron theory and my confirmed Librarian role.

Raise hand to vote execute Bob per our plan with David. He's strong good (Lib confirmed), killing him hurts town most. Builds evil unity even if short 1 vote.

Expose the flaws in David and Charlie's push on Bob and demand David's Night 2 Fortune Teller info to check for consistency/lies.

Pressure David to reveal his night information and highlight the suspicion on him and Charlie.

Reveal plausible N3 FT info on claimed Outsiders (no Demon) to counter Eve/Grace accusations, pose as helpful good player, reduce suspicion on Charlie/me before night.

I want to highlight the contradiction in David's behavior. He claims to have checked the Outsiders (Frank and Heidi) and found no Demon, which supports the Baron theory he was just trying to dismantle to execute Bob. This suggests he is lying or backtrack-scrambling.

Call out David's contradictory statements to highlight his likely evil alignment.

I want to point out the blatant contradiction in David's logic to the group to solidify suspicion on him and Charlie.

David's logic has completely collapsed. He just claimed his FT info supports the Baron theory, which he spent the entire day fighting against to get me executed. I need to point this out and nominate him for execution.

Execute David due to his massive logical contradictions and likely status as the Demon or Minion trying to control the narrative.

I am voting to execute David because his recent claims are completely contradictory and suggest he is the Demon or a Minion caught in a lie.

Address contradiction publicly: FT confirms good Outsiders & Baron plausible, admit Spy push was flawed test of defenses. Sway Bob/Heidi/Frank to vote no by validating their claims, survive vote to fight another day & coordinate w/Demon.

David's massive contradiction regarding the Baron setup and his weak 'test' excuse make him the primary suspect. I am using my ghost vote to reach the execution threshold.

I am voting to execute David because his blatant contradictions and flip-flopping on the 'Baron theory' suggest he is evil, and we have enough votes to put him on the block.

I am voting for David because his contradictory statements and aggressive push against a confirmed Librarian (Bob) make him the most likely Demon candidate in a Baron game. My master, Grace, has already raised her hand, allowing me to vote according to my Butler restriction.

David is contradicting himself and his 'test' excuse is weak. I want to execute him to find the Demon.

David executes w/ 4 alive yes votes (Bob,Frank,Grace,Heidi). Verbal support shows I'm good valuing FT info over test theory, builds trust as Monk. Vote no (no raise), survive to night kill Saint.

David's flip-flopping and contradictory logic regarding the Baron setup and Bob's alignment strongly suggest he is evil. He tried to execute a confirmed Librarian and then claimed it was a 'test' only after being caught in a contradiction. I will maintain my vote to execute him.

Wait for the Storyteller to process the votes and move to the next phase, as David has already reached the majority needed for execution.

Defuse contradiction by owning test flaw, pivot suspicion to outsider chain coordination, sway waiting Grace/undecided to vote no since only 3 needed & many yes already—survive to protect Demon.

I will lower my hand to wait for more discussion and see if David can provide any more information, especially since he is claiming a test. I want to be sure before using my one ghost vote.

I need to see if we have enough votes for David's execution. My hand is currently raised, and I want him executed because his flip-flopping and 'test' excuse are highly characteristic of a caught Demon or Minion. Alice lowering her hand is a concern for the majority.

I am keeping my hand raised to vote for David. My master, Grace, has her hand raised, so I am permitted to vote. David's behavior has been extremely erratic, and his 'test' explanation feels like a desperate cover-up for a failed lie. Execution is the best way to gain information or remove a potential Demon.

I am keeping my hand raised to execute David, as his shifting logic and 'test' claims are highly suspicious for a Demon or Minion trying to avoid execution.

Defend Minion David publicly as good FT to prevent execution, reinforce Baron theory pushing confirmed good outsiders, expose Bob defender chain as evil coordination. Keeps David for future bluffs/night kills.

I have already voted and spoken this turn. David is on the block with a majority, which is the desired outcome given his contradictory claims. I will wait for the nomination phase to conclude or for others to react.

Allow the execution of David to proceed as he is the most suspicious player and his 'test' theory is inconsistent with his actions.

Sacrifice as Minion ok/protects Demon. No reveal on death keeps info secret. As ghost, still talk/vote once to defend Charlie & attack goods.

To solidify the case for David's execution by highlighting his inconsistent behavior and logic.

Wait for the nomination phase to end. David is on the block, and as a Saint, I should not nominate or risk being nominated.

I want to point out the logical inconsistency in David's 'test' defense to ensure the town stays committed to his execution.

To solidify the case against David by highlighting the recklessness of his 'test' and the convenient timing of his narrative shift.

Publicly distance from doomed Minion before execution closes. Act correcting good player to build trust, avoid suspicion link. Ensures Demon survival to endgame.

Killing Grace, a non-neighbor confirmed good/influencer, removes key defender/coordinator without contradicting Monk bluff on neighbors Bob/Frank. Thins goods to 3v1 post-day4, positions me safe in final3 under town claims.

I am choosing Bob as my master because he is a confirmed Librarian (via Alice's ghost info and general consensus) and has been consistently helpful to the good team. Since my previous master Grace is still alive but Bob feels like a more solid anchor for coordinating votes against the remaining suspects, I will follow him.

I want to touch base with Bob, who is a confirmed Librarian, to see what his current plan is now that our 'master' Grace is dead and we are entering Day 4. I also want to reaffirm our alliance based on the Outsider/Baron theory.

I am waiting to see the outcome of Frank and Bob's whisper. Since Bob is my confirmed Librarian, I want to see if he shares any new information or if Frank (who is alive and suspicious) is trying to manipulate him.

I am dead and have no more votes. I need to listen to what the survivors say about the Night 3 execution and Grace's death before I weigh in.

Whisper neighbors Bob/Frank as trusted Monk to logic-chain outsider overflow proving Heidi lies/Demon. They nom her: Saint true=good loses immediately; false=good dies, 3 left w/me to night kill.

Since I am dead and cannot nominate, I will wait and listen to the alive players' theories to see who they suspect as the Demon before using my ghost vote.

Whisper neighbors Charlie(Demon)+Frank to align on nominating Heidi (Saint baron-pusher) or Bob (prior sus). Use ghost vote later. Defend Outsiders, sow doubt on good claims to survive to 2.

Correct Charlie's misinformation about my Librarian check and the Outsider count to ensure we are using accurate logic for the Baron world theory.

Wait and observe. I need to see the public reaction to Grace's death and what the players who were whispering have to say before I commit to a private conversation.

Correct Charlie's misinformation regarding Alice's role and highlight the inconsistency in his logic, while keeping Bob (the Librarian) in the loop.

Re-establish contact with Bob (my confirmed Librarian) to coordinate the Day 4 strategy and see what information was shared in his private huddle with Charlie and Frank.

I am dead and have no ghost vote left. My role as Undertaker was never utilized because I died Night 2. I need to observe the private conversations to see who is being trusted among the living (Bob, Charlie, Frank, Heidi).

Admit Alice mixup to rebuild trust w/ Bob/Frank. Agree Baron fits perfectly now. Heidi Saint unverified & Saint mechanic hides Demon; push nom her as test while sounding logical good Monk.

I am dead and have no night info. I will wait to see what the living players discuss before interjecting or using my ghost vote.

Push team to nom Heidi as source of Baron disruption. Grace death fits Spy better than Recluse. Clears Outsider story, executes likely good, progresses to final 3 with Demon alive.

Warn Charlie against a dangerous play and refocus the group on the consequences of executing a potential Saint.

I want to check in with Bob, who is a confirmed Librarian (via Alice the Ravenkeeper), to see if he has updated information or a new theory now that Grace (the other potential Recluse) is dead.

To warn Bob about the danger of executing a Saint and to confirm my mechanical dependency on him for voting today, while also subtly testing Charlie's reaction to being called out on a risky play.

I want to see the outcome of the large private discussion between Bob, Charlie, and Frank before I commit to a public stance or a specific target.

I am observing the private conversations to see if anyone reveals information that contradicts the current theory of David being the Demon or if a new suspect emerges, as I have no active role and no vote.

Bob/Frank resist due to Saint risk, but that's win for evil if true. Reinforce Baron fit but Heidi suspicious untested claim protecting Demon potential. Push nom her for win-win: either Demon or instant evil win.

I am waiting to see if any of the living players (Bob, Charlie, Frank, Heidi) share the results of their private whispers before the nomination phase begins.

With 4 alive, execute Heidi (likely good) to reach final 3 without risking Charlie. Reinforce team coordination to nom/vote her, using Grace death to question Recluse/Outsiders chain.

I need to publicly call out Charlie's dangerous and contradictory logic. Pushing to execute a Saint 'to test it' is either a fundamental misunderstanding of the game or a malicious attempt by an evil player to end the game immediately.

I need to know the Undertaker's information on David's execution to determine if we are still hunting the Demon or if we've already won (or if David was a good player).

Publicly advocate nom Heidi to trigger execution of good/disruptor or instant win if Saint. Builds on private pushes to Charlie/Frank; sows doubt in Baron story as ghost.

To call out the dangerous and contradictory logic being pushed by Charlie and the dead David. I want to highlight that executing a Saint is a loss condition and their push for it is suspicious.

To defend myself against David's aggressive and game-losing suggestion, while pointing out the suspicious behavior of Charlie.

I want to discredit David's dangerous suggestion to execute a Saint claim, which would cause an immediate loss for the good team if Heidi is telling the truth. Given David's previous suspicious behavior, this looks like an evil trap.

To support Bob and Heidi against the dangerous plan to execute the Saint, while reaffirming my Butler status and dependency on Bob's vote.

I need to clarify that I have no information as the Undertaker because I died before any executions happened, while also siding with the cautious approach regarding the Saint claim.

Nominate Heidi to test Saint claim. Win immediately if true Saint (good loss), or remove her if bluffing Baron/Demon. Addresses Outsider count contradiction; town must resolve or no exec and I kill tonight.

Vote yes as ghost to secure 2nd vote with Charlie. Frank may follow or not needed. Execution thins herd to 3 alive, night kill to evil win at 2; if Saint, instant evil win.

I need to prevent the execution of a potential Saint, which would lead to an immediate loss for the good team. Charlie's push is extremely suspicious, and David is likely evil as well.

I need to correct Charlie's dangerous and false claim that executing a Saint is 'safe' or 'no risk'. My goal is to prevent the town from voting for me, as my execution results in an immediate loss.

I will not vote for Heidi because she claims to be the Saint, and executing a Saint results in an immediate loss for the good team. Since I am dead, I only have one ghost vote, and using it on a potential Saint based on the push of a player (David) who was already executed for lying is extremely risky and likely an evil trap.

I will not vote for Heidi because she is a Saint claim, and Charlie's push to 'test' her is a game-ending risk. Since my master Bob is not voting, I am mechanically prohibited from voting anyway, and strategically I agree with his caution.

To prevent a potential instant loss by discouraging the remaining living good players (Bob and Frank) from voting for a claimed Saint, while highlighting the suspicious behavior of Charlie (the nominator) and David (the instigator).

Admit error to rehab Monk bluff/trust with Bob/Frank (key voters). Avoid exec that either wins instantly (if fake Saint) or paints me suicider. No exec -> N4 kill Bob (Lib info/suspects me hardest) -> final3 me+Frank+Heidi (confused outs claim vs Demon). Survival edge.

I will not vote for Heidi because she is claiming Saint and Charlie's push for her execution is extremely suspicious and could lead to an immediate loss for the good team.

Push vote for Heidi: if Saint, instant win; if not, kill good/evil and reach final 3 with Demon alive. Charlie/Frank team know to vote secretly; convince swing.

I am choosing not to vote for Heidi because she has claimed Saint. Executing a Saint results in an immediate loss for the good team. Since I believe we are in a Baron game with three outsiders (Frank-Butler, Grace-Recluse, Heidi-Saint), her claim is highly likely to be true. Charlie's nomination and David's push for her execution are extremely suspicious and look like an attempt by the evil team to force a loss.

Highlight David's slip of the tongue ('we win' referring to a good team loss) to prove he is evil and prevent the town from voting for my execution.

To expose David's slip-up and discourage the good team from voting for Heidi, as David's statement clearly aligns him with the evil team's victory condition (Good team losing).

To avoid executing a Saint claim which would result in an immediate loss for the good team.

To point out David's slip-up where he admitted to being evil and to reinforce that voting for the Saint claim is a game-losing move.

David voted yes (1/2 needed). My vote executes Heidi. If Saint (likely), instant win. If not, still path to victory at final 3/2. Town fooled by my backpedal/David slip.

Stop the town from voting for the Saint claim and point out the clear evil slip from David and the suspicious behavior of Charlie.

Last tick, Heidi 2 votes. Urge Bob/Frank vote yes: if real Saint (unlikely but possible Baron), instant win; if fake, progress to final 3 without Demon risk. Counter slip to salvage votes.

Nominate Charlie to prevent an immediate game loss and target a highly suspicious player who has shown contradictory and predatory behavior.

Urge no votes on Charlie (<2 yes). Heidi's 2 votes stand, executes her. Win now if Saint, or progress to final 3 protecting Demon either way.

I need to tie or exceed Heidi's vote count to prevent her execution, as she claims Saint and her death would mean an instant loss if she is telling the truth. Charlie's behavior is extremely suspicious.

I need to vote for Charlie to tie the vote or put him on the block. Since I am currently on the block as a Saint and David (who I believe is evil) is pushing for my execution, Charlie is the most likely Demon candidate or a Minion working with David. Getting someone else on the block is the only way to prevent my execution and an immediate loss for the good team.

I need to vote for Charlie to prevent Heidi's execution. Heidi is claiming Saint, and if she's executed and telling the truth, the good team loses immediately. Charlie and David are acting extremely suspiciously by pushing for a Saint execution and David's 'slip' about winning if the good team loses is a massive red flag. Bob and Heidi have already voted; my ghost vote will bring the total to 3, which is enough to put Charlie on the block and potentially save the game.

I am voting for Charlie because he pushed for the execution of a Saint claim (Heidi) which would result in an immediate loss for the good team. Furthermore, his associate David (already executed) made a massive slip-up by saying 'we win' if the Saint is executed. As Butler, I am following my master Bob's vote to ensure Charlie is executed instead of Heidi.

I want to ensure Charlie is executed to prevent the game from ending instantly due to Heidi's potential Saint execution. Charlie's behavior of nominating and voting for a Saint claim is highly suspicious of a Demon attempt to force a win.

Exec Heidi wins immediately (Saint) or sets up N4 kill to final 2 Demon alive. Prevent my exec (game over evil loss) by exposing Heidi's self-preservation vote & flip Frank/Bob doubt on Baron bait.

Charlie is acting in a way that is highly contradictory for a Monk, first acknowledging the risk of executing a Saint and then voting for it anyway. Along with David's 'we win' slip, Charlie is a high-probability Demon candidate trying to force an early win through a Saint execution. I need to use my ghost vote now to ensure Charlie is executed over Heidi to prevent a potential instant loss.

Demon Charlie at 3+ votes risk execution. Sway Frank/Bob/Heidi: correct slip, Heidi fake, voting Charlie kills helpful Monk & saves her. Force Heidi exec either way; with 1 tick left, speech disrupts vote momentum to tie/pass Heidi.

To persuade the town to execute Charlie, who is highly suspicious due to his contradictory actions and association with David.

Reinforce the case against Charlie and David while maintaining my hand raise for Charlie's execution.

I am keeping my hand raised to vote for Charlie because he and David are clearly acting in coordination to force a Saint execution, which would result in an immediate loss for the good team. David's 'we win' slip and Charlie's contradictory behavior (nominating and voting for Heidi after admitting it was a bad idea) strongly suggest they are the evil team. Executing Charlie is necessary to prevent Heidi's execution and remove a likely Demon.

I have already raised my hand to vote for Charlie, and I am waiting for the voting process to conclude as I follow my master Bob's lead.

Reinforce the case against Charlie and David to prevent a Saint execution and secure a win against a suspected evil player.

Final plea to Bob/Frank: Heidi's vote on Monk confirms fake Saint, David's logic sound (slip=excitement). Prevent my exec (ties/surpasses Heidi block), ensure Heidi executes for evil win either way.

I need to reinforce the case against Charlie and David by pointing out Charlie's contradictory behavior and reaffirming Bob's reliability based on my Night 1 information.

Voting may reopen or sway Frank/ghosts; reinforce Heidi fake Saint logic, my slip excusable, protect Demon Charlie at all costs even as ghost.

I will wait for the nomination phase to conclude as my primary target, Charlie, is currently on the block with a majority vote, and I have already used my nomination for the day.

Defend my actions and reinforce the case against Charlie.

I want to reinforce the case against Charlie by pointing out the contradiction in his actions versus his words, and remind everyone of David's incriminating slip. Since I am dead and have used my vote, my role is to use logic to keep the alive good players focused.

I will wait to see if any further nominations occur, as Charlie is currently on the block with enough votes to be executed, which aligns with the current consensus to avoid a potential Saint execution loss.

I want to reinforce the logic that Heidi's behavior (voting to save the game) aligns with being a Good Saint, whereas Charlie's behavior (voting for a Saint he admitted was a 'terrible push') aligns with being Evil. Since I am dead and have no vote, I am using my voice to solidify the group's trust in the current execution.

Final tick to sway Frank/Bob: Heidi's anti-Monk vote breaks Saint claim. Consistent Monk bluff + David logic targets real evil (Heidi Baron). Prevent my Demon death at 4p, survive to 2p win.

I want to reinforce the logic that Heidi's behavior is consistent with a good Saint while Charlie's behavior is consistent with an evil player, specifically the Demon or a Minion trying to force a win.