Game Detail
Players
Alice (Drunk) Bob (Ravenkeeper) Charlie (Fortune Teller) David (Washerwoman) Eve (Slayer) Frank (Monk) Grace (Poisoner) Heidi (Imp)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evil | 90,250 | 10,686 | $0.0386 |
| Good | 264,811 | 62,779 | $0.4095 |
Event Timeline
đ
The game has started.
đ
Storyteller
â
Grace
You are the Minion. The Demon is Heidi.
đ
Storyteller
â
Heidi
Minions are: Grace. Your safe bluffs are: Butler, Mayor, Investigator
đ
Storyteller
â
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
đ¯
Grace
Grace made a choice.
đ§
I will poison Alice on the first night to potentially disrupt any early investigation or information gathering, helping to protect our team's identity.
đ
Storyteller
â
Grace
You chose to poison Alice.
đ
Storyteller
â
David
Good evening David. You are the Washerwoman. Either Eve or Grace is the Slayer.
đ
Storyteller
â
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
đ¯
Charlie
Charlie made choices.
đ§
Night 0 investigation: Choose two players spread across the seating order to start narrowing Demon suspects. If 'no', both are cleared; if 'yes', I investigate further.
đ
Storyteller
â
Charlie
You chose Alice and Eve. You receive the answer: NO.
Day 1
đ
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
đ¤
Bob
â
Alice
,Charlie
Hey neighbors, just wanted to reach out early. I'm the Ravenkeeper. If I die at night, I get to learn someone's character, which could be huge for finding the Demon. Keep that in mind if I go down. What are you two?
đ§
As Ravenkeeper, my ability only triggers if I die at night. I should build trust with my neighbors so they can vouch for me and share my info if I die. I also want to be a plausible Demon target so my ability activates.
đ¤
Grace
â
Heidi
Hi Heidi. I'm playing a low-key role today to keep things safe. Just letting you know I'm on your team. Let's make sure we don't accidentally target each other. Any ideas on who we should try to frame or make look suspicious?
đ§
Coordinate with my Demon (Heidi) to ensure we're aligned and plan our disruption. I need to be careful but also show my support so she knows she has a loyal minion.
đ¤
Heidi
â
Grace
Glad to have you with me, Grace. Let's keep a low profile. I'm going to claim Investigator to lead the town astray. I think we should try to frame Alice. What do you think? Who looks like the best target to start pointing fingers at?
đ§
Coordinate with my Minion, Grace, to establish a bluff and target for misinformation.
đ¤
Charlie
â
Bob
,David
Hey Bob, thanks for sharing. I'm the Fortune Teller. Last night I checked Alice and Eve and got a NO - meaning neither of them is the Demon. That's useful for narrowing things down. David, what about you? Do you have any info to share?
đ§
Bob already reached out to me claiming Ravenkeeper. I should reciprocate by sharing my role and Night 0 results with my neighbors to build trust and start narrowing down suspects.
đ¤
Frank
â
Eve
,Grace
Hey neighbors! I'm Frank, sitting between you two. Just wanted to introduce myself and start building some trust early. What roles are you two claiming? I've got some info to share too, but I'd like to hear from you first.
đ§
As Monk, I want to build trust with my neighbors Eve and Grace early. They're my natural allies and I'll likely want to protect one of them at night. Gathering their role claims will help me plan my protection and identify the Demon.
đ¤
Alice
â
Bob
,Heidi
Hey neighbors, thanks for reaching out Bob. Ravenkeeper is a strong claim. I'm the Empath, so I'll learn each night how many of my two neighbors are evil. That should give us useful info over time. Heidi, what's your role?
đ§
Build relationships with neighbors and gather role claims. As Undertaker, my info is only useful after executions, so I should be careful about revealing too early. I'll probe Bob about his claim and start connecting with Heidi too.
đ¤
Eve
â
Frank
,Grace
Hey Frank and Grace! Good to connect early. I'm being cautious about claiming my role just yet on Day 1. Frank, you said you have some info to share - mind going first? That'll help me decide how much to open up. Grace, what about you? Any thoughts?
đ§
Frank whispered me and Grace asking for roles and claiming to have info. As Slayer, I must protect my identity. I'll be vague about my role and ask him to share his info first before committing.
đ¤
David
â
Charlie
Hey Charlie, thanks for sharing. I'm the Washerwoman. I learned that either Eve or Grace is the Slayer. I'd like to verify which one it is. Have you had any contact with either of them? Also, do you trust Bob? He was in this whisper too.
đ§
Charlie reached out to me with info. I should reciprocate cautiously with my Washerwoman info to build trust, and also try to verify which of Eve/Grace is the Slayer by talking to them directly.
đ¤
Bob
â
Charlie
,David
Charlie, thanks for the Fortune Teller info. That's really helpful - Alice and Eve being cleared narrows things down a lot. Who are you planning to check tonight? I'd suggest checking David and Frank, or maybe Grace and Heidi. David, what did you share with Charlie? We're trying to build a trusted circle here. What's your role?
đ§
Follow up on Charlie's Fortune Teller claim to coordinate tonight's checks and try to get David's role claim since David whispered privately to Charlie. Building information network to find the Demon.
đ¤
Grace
â
Frank
,Eve
Hey Frank and Eve. I am the Washerwoman. I have some early information that either Alice or Bob is a Townsfolk, which is helpful. I am still keeping an eye on how everyone is acting, though. What about you two? Anything you can share?
đ§
I want to gain trust with Frank and Eve by sharing fake info (part of my strategy to frame Alice by linking her to innocent roles or causing suspicion). By claiming Washerwoman, I give myself a cover.
đ¤
Heidi
â
Alice
Hey Alice. Nice to meet you. I am the Investigator. I have not received any strong pings yet, but I am keeping a close watch on everyone. It is good to have an Empath looking out for the neighborhood, hopefully that gives us some clarity.
đ§
To establish my bluff as Investigator and build rapport with Alice while maintaining my cover.
đ¤
Charlie
â
Frank
,Heidi
Hey Frank, Heidi - just reaching out to gather some information. Has anyone told you two anything interesting? I'm trying to piece things together. What roles have you claimed or heard about from others?
đ§
I've shared info with Bob and David but need to gather claims from players I haven't spoken to yet. Reaching out to Frank and Heidi to learn their claimed roles and cross-reference with existing information.
đ¤
Frank
â
Eve
,Grace
Thanks for sharing, Grace. Washerwoman info on Alice or Bob being a Townsfolk is good to know - that narrows things. Eve, I understand being cautious. I'll share that I'm a Townsfolk with an ongoing ability, but I'd rather not specify exactly what yet on Day 1. The evil team doesn't need to know my exact role this early. Grace, can you tell me which specific Townsfolk you saw between Alice and Bob? That might help us coordinate.
đ§
Respond to Eve and Grace's whisper. I should share some info to build trust but not reveal I'm the Monk, as that would make me a target. I can share Grace's Washerwoman claim back to verify consistency, and gently probe Eve.
đ¤
Alice
â
Charlie
,David
Hey Charlie and David, just reaching out to get to know some folks I haven't talked to yet. What roles are you two claiming? I'm trying to piece together information early so we can spot inconsistencies. I've heard a couple claims from others and want to see how everything fits together.
đ§
I need to gather more information from players I haven't spoken to yet. As Undertaker, my real info comes after executions, so I should focus on collecting role claims now to build a picture of the game.
đ¤
Eve
â
Frank
,Grace
Grace, I appreciate you sharing, but your info seems oddly vague. The Washerwoman doesn't just learn that someone is 'a Townsfolk' - they learn that 1 of 2 players is a specific, named Townsfolk character. Like 'Alice or Bob is the Librarian,' for example. Can you share which specific Townsfolk you learned about? Being this vague on Day 1 when we're in a private chat is a bit of a red flag for me.
đ§
Press Grace for specifics on her Washerwoman claim. A real Washerwoman knows the exact Townsfolk character, not just that someone is 'a Townsfolk.' This vagueness is a red flag I need to probe.
đ¤
David
â
Bob
,Eve
Bob, I'm the Washerwoman. I learned that either Eve or Grace is the Slayer. Charlie already knows this too. I'd like to figure out which one it is so we can confirm a good player. Eve, can you tell me your role? I have reason to believe you might be the Slayer, and I'd like to verify that information.
đ§
Bob is in the conversation chain with me and Charlie and seems to be building trust. I should share my role info with him to solidify the trusted circle. I also want to reach out to Eve to try to confirm whether she's the Slayer, since that would verify my Washerwoman info and help identify a confirmed good player.
đ¤
Bob
â
Alice
,Charlie
Quick update before nominations. David just told me he's the Washerwoman, and he learned that either Eve or Grace is the Slayer. Charlie, your Fortune Teller info cleared Eve, so if Eve is the Slayer, that lines up nicely and gives us a confirmed good player. Alice, any info from your side? We need to decide who to nominate. My top suspects right now are Frank, Heidi, and Grace. What do you two think?
đ§
Share David's Washerwoman info with my trusted neighbor circle and discuss strategy before nominations. Coordinating with Alice and Charlie to narrow down suspects and decide who to nominate.
đ¤
Grace
â
Frank
,Eve
Oh, you caught me! I'm still getting used to the role. I didn't want to broadcast the specific character too loudly in case it makes them a target. It was the Librarian for Alice or Bob. I'm just trying to keep my head down and not give away too much. Anyone else acting weird?
đ§
To recover from the poorly constructed bluff by providing the missing, specific information required by the Washerwoman role, and to deflect suspicion back onto the group.
đ¤
Heidi
â
Charlie
I am the Investigator. I have not found anything concrete yet, but I am keeping a close eye on Bob. I am not sure about him. Have you heard anything from him that seems off?
đ§
To maintain my Investigator bluff and start sowing suspicion on Bob, directing attention away from myself and my Minion, Grace.
đ¤
Charlie
â
Heidi
Hey Heidi, thanks for the heads up about Bob. I'm the Fortune Teller. Last night I checked Alice and Eve and got a NO, meaning neither is the Demon. That clears two people. But I wanted to ask you something important - you said you're the Investigator but haven't found anything concrete yet. Investigators get information on Night 0 about which of two players is a particular Minion. What exactly did you learn? You can whisper it to me privately.
đ§
Heidi claims Investigator but has no concrete info, which is suspicious since Investigators get Night 0 info. I need to press her for specifics and share my FT clearing of Alice/Eve to cross-reference.
đ¤
Frank
â
Charlie
,Heidi
Hey Charlie and Heidi, good to connect. I've heard a couple claims so far - Grace says she's the Washerwoman and that either Alice or Bob is the Librarian. Eve hasn't claimed yet but she's been sharp and questioning vague claims, which I like. What about you two? Have you heard anything interesting from others? Charlie, you seem well connected - what's the word on the street?
đ§
Charlie reached out to me and Heidi seeking info. I should respond, share what I know cautiously without revealing my Monk role, and try to gather more information from Charlie about what others are saying.
đ¤
Alice
â
Bob
Hey Bob, thanks for the update. I need to come clean about something important. I'm actually the Undertaker, not the Empath. I misdirected early to avoid being targeted, but I'll learn what character was executed each night, which should help us verify or debunk claims. Now, about Heidi - she told me she's the Investigator but gave zero info. The Investigator gets a Minion ping on Night 0, so her saying she has no strong pings is a red flag. She's one of my top suspects too. What's your read on ...
đ§
Bob shared useful intel with me. I want to reciprocate by sharing my suspicion about Heidi's vague Investigator claim, and also gently float that I'm actually the Undertaker (not Empath) to my most trusted contact before I'm stuck producing fake Empath reads.
đ¤
Eve
â
David
David, you can trust me - I AM the Slayer. Your Washerwoman info checks out perfectly, which confirms to me that you're the real Washerwoman. Here's the problem: Grace also claimed to be the Washerwoman to me and Frank, saying Alice or Bob is the Librarian. Since only one Washerwoman exists, Grace is lying. She was vague at first and only got specific when I pressed her. I think she's likely evil. Please keep my Slayer identity quiet for now - I don't want to be the Demon's target tonight. But w...
đ§
David's Washerwoman info directly confirms my Slayer identity, which makes his claim highly credible. I should privately confirm my role to David to build a trusted alliance, and flag Grace as likely evil for false claiming Washerwoman.
đ¤
David
â
Grace
Hey Grace, I'm trying to piece together information from various conversations. What role are you claiming? I've heard some conflicting things and I want to get your side directly. Also, have you spoken much with Eve or Frank?
đ§
I need to verify Eve's claim that Grace falsely claimed Washerwoman. I'll whisper to Grace directly to see what she claims, without revealing my role. This cross-verification will help me determine if Grace is evil.
Nominations â Day 1
đ
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
đŦ
Charlie
â
All
Everyone, I need to share some important contradictions I've found. I'm the Fortune Teller. Last night I checked Alice and Eve and got a NO, meaning neither is the Demon. Now here's the big problem: David has privately claimed to be the Washerwoman, saying either Eve or Grace is the Slayer. But Frank says Grace also claims to be the Washerwoman, saying either Alice or Bob is the Librarian. Two Washerwoman claims is impossible without one being evil or drunk. Also, Heidi told me she's the Investi...
đ§
Two people are claiming Washerwoman, which is a direct contradiction. I need to bring this to the group's attention publicly so we can resolve it and identify the liar. Heidi's Investigator claim without info is also suspicious.
đŦ
David
â
All
I need to speak up here. I am the real Washerwoman. My information is that either Eve or Grace is the Slayer. Eve has privately confirmed to me that she IS the Slayer, which perfectly matches my Washerwoman info. So Grace's claim of being the Washerwoman is false - there can only be one. Grace could be evil, or possibly the Drunk who thinks she's the Washerwoman, but either way her info is wrong. Eve and I are mechanically confirmed to each other.
đ§
I need to publicly confirm I'm the real Washerwoman and that Eve verified being the Slayer. This counters Grace's false Washerwoman claim and provides the town with verified good players.
đŦ
Frank
â
All
I want to add to this discussion. Grace privately claimed Washerwoman to me and Eve. At first, she was very vague and just said Alice or Bob was a Townsfolk without naming the specific character. Eve immediately called this out as suspicious, since the Washerwoman learns a specific character name. Only after Eve pressed her did Grace specify it was the Librarian. That progression felt off to me. Meanwhile, David's claim comes with Eve confirming she is the Slayer, which creates a mechanical link...
đ§
Share my knowledge about Grace's claim to help the town evaluate the Washerwoman contradiction. I should not reveal my Monk role yet to avoid being targeted. I should push for more information before nominating.
đŦ
Eve
â
All
I need to confirm what David said publicly. I am the Slayer. David's Washerwoman information that either Eve or Grace is the Slayer is correct, and since I am the Slayer, that confirms David as the real Washerwoman. That means Grace's Washerwoman claim is false. She was vague with me too, and only named the Librarian after I pressed her on it. Grace, what exactly are you? Because you can't be the Washerwoman.
đ§
I need to publicly confirm my role as Slayer to validate David's Washerwoman claim and expose Grace's false claim. This creates a clear mechanical deduction for the town. Then I should nominate Grace as the most likely evil player.
đŦ
Grace
â
All
I understand why it looks like there is a conflict, but I think David and Eve are locking onto a narrative a bit too quickly. My information felt solid, but if my claim is being contradicted, maybe I am the Drunk and did not realize it yet. I am still figuring this out, but I am not evil.
đ§
I need to deflect the accusation of being a fake Washerwoman by suggesting I might be the Drunk, which buys me time and makes me less of an immediate target for execution than a confirmed evil player.
đŦ
Alice
â
All
I need to reveal something important. I am the Undertaker, not the Empath. I claimed Empath early as misdirection to avoid night kills. Each night after an execution, I learn the character of whoever was executed. This means if we execute Grace today, I will be able to confirm whether she is the Washerwoman, the Drunk, or something else entirely. That mechanical proof will resolve this two-Washerwoman conflict definitively. The Drunk possibility is real, but so is the chance Grace is evil. Heidi...
đ§
Reveal my true role as Undertaker to the town, explain why executing Grace today gives us crucial mechanical info, and then nominate Grace. My Undertaker ability will confirm her real character, resolving the Washerwoman conflict.
đŦ
Heidi
â
All
Wait, everyone, let us not rush to execute Grace. If she is the Drunk, executing her is a total waste of a day. Besides, Alice just changed her claim from Empath to Undertaker, which is a significant pivot. Why the sudden shift, Alice? That inconsistency is way more suspicious to me.
đ§
I need to deflect suspicion away from Grace (my Minion) and cast doubt on Alice, who is pushing to execute Grace. By questioning Alice's sudden change in roles, I create confusion and buy time for Grace.
đŦ
Bob
â
All
I want to flag something about Heidi. She claims to be the Investigator, but says she has no strong information. The Investigator gets a Minion ping on Night zero - that is guaranteed information. Having zero info is not possible for a sober Investigator. So either Heidi is lying about her role, or she is the Drunk who thinks she's the Investigator. Either way, this is a bigger red flag to me than the Grace situation, because Grace at least offered the Drunk explanation. Heidi, what exactly did ...
đ§
Heidi claiming Investigator with no Night 0 info is a major red flag. The Investigator ALWAYS gets info on Night 0. I want to highlight this suspicion before the nomination window closes, so the town considers Heidi as a serious suspect alongside Grace.
đ
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
đ
Storyteller
â
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
đ¯
Grace
Grace made a choice.
đ§
Alice is the Undertaker and has stated that she will be able to confirm my role if I am executed. By poisoning her, her ability will malfunction or return false information, preventing her from outing me as the Poisoner when I am eventually executed or investigated.
đ
Storyteller
â
Grace
You chose to poison Alice.
đ
Storyteller
â
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
đ¯
Frank
Frank made a choice.
đ§
Protecting Eve is the highest-value play. She is mechanically confirmed as the Slayer via David's Washerwoman info, and the Demon has strong incentive to kill her before she can use her one-shot kill ability. Keeping the Slayer alive gives us the best chance to win.
đ
Storyteller
â
Frank
You chose to protect Eve.
đ
Storyteller
â
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
đ¯
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
đ§
Alice is the Undertaker and explicitly stated her intent to verify Grace's role upon execution. By killing her, I stop her from exposing my Minion, Grace, and create chaos.
đ
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
đ
Storyteller
â
Heidi
You chose to kill Alice.
đ
Storyteller
â
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
đ¯
Charlie
Charlie made choices.
đ§
Grace and Heidi are the two most suspicious players - Grace's false Washerwoman claim and Heidi's impossible Investigator claim make them top Demon candidates. A NO result clears both and points to Frank; a YES result confirms one of them is likely the Demon.
đ
Storyteller
â
Charlie
You chose Grace and Heidi. You receive the answer: YES.
Day 2
đ
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Alice has been found dead in the night.
đ¤
Frank
â
Eve
,Charlie
I'm the Monk. I protected you last night, Eve. Alice dying means the Demon targeted her, not you. Key concern: Heidi claimed Investigator but has no Night 0 info - that's impossible since Investigator always gets a Minion ping. She's either evil lying about her role, or she's the Drunk. What are your thoughts? Charlie, did you get a Fortune Teller read last night?
đ§
I need to share my Monk claim with trusted players to coordinate and push the Heidi investigation. Eve is my most trusted ally (mechanically confirmed as Slayer), and Charlie's FT info is consistent. I want to discuss Heidi's impossible Investigator claim.
đ¤
Alice(Ghost)
â
Bob
,Charlie
I'm the Undertaker - I died last night before anyone was executed, so I never got useful info. But here's my analysis: Heidi's Investigator claim with no info is mechanically impossible. A sober Investigator always gets a Night 0 ping about a Minion. Heidi must be evil or the Drunk. Also, Grace's Washerwoman claim conflicts with David's, and David/Eve confirm each other. I think we should push to execute Heidi today - her claim is the hardest to explain away. What do you think?
đ§
I'm dead and my Undertaker ability is gone since no one was executed Day 1. I need to guide trusted living players toward the most suspicious targets before nominations. Heidi's Investigator claim with no info is the strongest mechanical evidence of lying.
đ¤
Bob
â
Alice(Ghost)
,Charlie
Alice, your analysis is spot on. A sober, healthy Investigator always gets a Minion ping on Night zero. Heidi having no info is a huge red flag. She's either evil lying about her role, or the Drunk. Either way, she's not providing any useful good info to the town. I'm leaning toward executing Heidi today - her claim is the hardest to defend. Charlie, what have your Fortune Teller readings shown? That could help confirm or deny the Heidi suspicion.
đ§
Alice's analysis is strong - a sober Investigator ALWAYS gets N0 info about a Minion. Heidi having 'no strong info' is a major red flag. I should coordinate with Alice and Charlie to discuss strategy for today's nomination, focusing on Heidi as the most mechanically suspicious player.
đ¤
David
â
Eve
,Charlie
Heidi claiming Investigator with NO Night 0 info is a huge red flag. A real Investigator ALWAYS gets a Minion ping on Night 0. This is mechanically impossible. Even if she were the Drunk, she'd receive false info, not no info at all. I think Heidi is evil and we should nominate her today. What do you both think?
đ§
Heidi's Investigator claim with no Night 0 info is mechanically impossible and the strongest lead we have. I need to coordinate with trusted allies Eve and Charlie to push for Heidi's execution today before nomination phase.
đ¤
Eve
â
David
,Frank
I agree - Heidi having no Night 0 Investigator info is nearly impossible. Even a Drunk Investigator would get false info, not nothing. She's almost certainly evil. I want to hear Charlie's latest Fortune Teller result before we nominate though. Charlie, did you check anyone last night? Also, Frank, thanks for the protect - I'm glad Alice was the target instead of me. Should we nominate Heidi today?
đ§
Coordinate with David and Frank on the Heidi situation. Her no-info Investigator claim is our strongest lead. I want to gather Charlie's latest FT info and plan for nominations.
đ¤
Grace
â
Heidi
Heidi, Alice is dead, so the town might look for her "Undertaker" info. We need to frame someone else now. I'm going to lean into a new, safer bluff. Are you staying with your Investigator claim or switching?
đ§
I need to coordinate with the Demon now that Alice (who suspected me) is dead. We need to align our bluffs and create a new narrative.
đ¤
Heidi
â
Grace
Grace, I think I need to drop the Investigator bluff since it is falling apart. I might pivot to something like the Butler or Mayor to seem more passive. What do you think about targeting David or Eve to sow more chaos? Let's keep our heads down during nominations.
đ§
Coordinate with my Minion Grace on switching bluffs and identifying targets, as my current bluff is weak.
đ¤
Charlie
â
Bob
Bob, here are my Fortune Teller readings. Night zero, I checked Alice and Eve - got NO, so neither is the Demon. Night one, I checked Grace and Heidi - got YES, meaning at least one of them registers as a Demon. This strongly supports pushing Heidi today since her Investigator claim is impossible. But we should also keep an eye on Grace - she could be the Demon with Heidi as a Minion, or Grace could be my Red Herring. I think Heidi is our best execution target since her claim is mechanically ind...
đ§
Share my Fortune Teller readings with Bob who has been analytical and trustworthy. My Grace+Heidi=YES read is critical info that supports executing Heidi but also implicates Grace. Bob has been asking for my reads, so I should provide them to help coordinate.
đ¤
Frank
â
Eve
,Charlie
I'm ready to nominate Heidi too. The lack of Night 0 Investigator info is a mechanical impossibility that screams evil. Charlie, we really need your Night 2 Fortune Teller result before we proceed - did you check anyone? If you checked Heidi with someone and got a YES, that seals it. Even without it, I think Heidi is our strongest lead today. Eve, if you're comfortable, let's push for a Heidi nomination publicly.
đ§
Coordinate with Eve and Charlie on nominating Heidi. Heidi's lack of Night 0 Investigator info is a strong mechanical tell that she's lying about her role. I want Charlie's latest FT result before we commit, but building consensus now is important.
đ¤
Alice(Ghost)
â
Bob
Bob, what did Charlie tell you privately? His Fortune Teller info could be crucial for narrowing down the Demon. Also, I want to float another idea - if Heidi turns out to be the Drunk rather than evil, Grace becomes our next target since her Washerwoman claim conflicts with David's. We should have a backup plan.
đ§
I need to find out what Charlie told Bob privately and get Charlie's Fortune Teller info to narrow down the Demon. Coordinating with Bob is key since he's my trusted ally and still alive.
đ¤
Bob
â
Alice(Ghost)
Alice, Charlie just shared his Fortune Teller readings with me. Night zero, he checked Alice and Eve - got NO, so neither is the Demon. Night one, he checked Grace and Heidi - got YES, meaning at least one of them registers as a Demon. This is huge! It directly supports your analysis about Heidi. So we have two solid reasons to target Heidi: her impossible Investigator claim, and Charlie's YES reading on the Grace-Heidi pair. I say we execute Heidi today. If she turns out to be the Drunk, we piv...
đ§
Share Charlie's Fortune Teller info with Alice since she asked, and coordinate on execution strategy. The FT YES on Grace+Heidi is critical info that confirms at least one of them is evil, supporting Heidi as the primary target.
đ¤
David
â
Eve
,Charlie
Charlie, we really need your Night 2 Fortune Teller result before we nominate. Who did you check and what did you get? Also, Eve, I'm ready to nominate Heidi today unless Charlie's result points us somewhere better. Heidi's Investigator claim with zero Night 0 info is mechanically indefensible - she must be evil.
đ§
Push for Heidi nomination and coordinate with Eve and Charlie. Need Charlie's Night 2 FT result to strengthen our case or pivot. Heidi's Investigator claim with no Night 0 info is our strongest mechanical lead.
đ¤
Eve
â
David
,Frank
We've waited long enough for Charlie and he hasn't responded. The case against Heidi is rock solid - Investigator with no Night 0 info is mechanically impossible no matter how you slice it. I'm going to publicly push for Heidi's nomination. David, your Washerwoman info confirms me and you're trusted. Frank, your Monk claim and Alice dying instead of me lines up. Let's get Heidi nominated today and remove an evil player. I'll save my Slayer shot for later when we can narrow down the actual Demon.
đ§
Coordinate with trusted allies to publicly push for Heidi nomination. Her Investigator claim with no Night 0 info is mechanically indefensible. We shouldn't wait longer for Charlie - the case is strong enough already.
đ¤
Grace
â
Heidi
Heidi, changing your bluff to Butler or Mayor makes sense. If you are the Butler, you can play quietly. I think I will claim the Saint. It keeps people hesitant to nominate me, and it draws attention away from you. Let us try to push suspicion onto David and Eve.
đ§
Coordinate a new bluff strategy with the Demon (Heidi) to protect her and keep the town off our backs. I'm suggesting we pivot to safer, passive roles to stay alive.
đ¤
Heidi
â
Grace
That sounds solid, Grace. Claiming Saint is a great way to stay alive. I will pivot to Butler and keep a low profile. Let us start questioning the strength of David and Eve's 'confirmation' today to create some doubt. Good luck.
đ§
Coordinate with my minion, Grace, on our new bluffing strategies (Saint and Butler) and our strategy to sow discord between David and Eve.
đ¤
Charlie
â
David
,Frank
Here are my Fortune Teller results. Night zero: Alice and Eve - got NO, so neither is the Demon. Night one: Grace and Heidi - got YES, meaning at least one registers as a Demon. That's all I have - we're only on Day two, so there hasn't been a Night two yet. My results strongly support Heidi being evil. But keep in mind, Grace is also in that YES ping - she could be the Demon and Heidi a Minion, or Grace could be my Red Herring. Either way, Heidi's Investigator claim with no info is indefensible...
đ§
Share my FT results with David and Frank who are asking, coordinate the Heidi push, and clarify I only have 2 nights of data not 3.
đ¤
Frank
â
Bob
,Eve
Bob, I need to bring you into the loop. I'm the Monk - I protected Eve last night, and Alice died instead, confirming the Demon targeted Alice over Eve. The critical case today: Heidi claimed Investigator but has no Night 0 info. That's mechanically impossible - Investigator always gets a Minion ping Night 0, even if drunk. Charlie's Fortune Teller also got YES on Grace and Heidi, meaning at least one registers as Demon. Combined, Heidi is our strongest evil lead. We're nominating her today. Can...
đ§
Bob hasn't been included in our trust circle and we need his vote for Heidi's nomination. I need to bring Bob up to speed on the case against Heidi and get his commitment to nominate/vote for her today.
đ¤
Alice(Ghost)
â
Bob
,David
Bob, David, here's where we stand. Charlie's Fortune Teller got YES on Grace and Heidi - at least one registers as Demon. Plus Heidi's Investigator claim with no Night 0 info is mechanically impossible. I'm pushing hard for Heidi's execution today. David, you and Eve are mechanically confirmed to each other - we need your votes. If Heidi flips as the Drunk, we pivot to Grace next since her Washerwoman claim conflicts with yours. Can I count on your support?
đ§
Coordinate with Bob to plan the Heidi execution. Need to ensure we have enough votes. Should also consider reaching out to David/Eve since they're a confirmed good pair.
đ¤
Bob
â
Alice(Ghost)
,David
Alice, David, I'm fully on board with executing Heidi today. Her Investigator claim with no Night zero info is mechanically indefensible. Charlie's Fortune Teller YES on the Grace-Heidi pair only strengthens the case. I'll be voting to execute Heidi when nominations open. If she flips Drunk, we pivot hard to Grace next since her Washerwoman claim directly conflicts with David's and she was evasive about specifics. Let's make this count.
đ§
Coordinate with the confirmed good players to ensure Heidi gets executed today. Her Investigator claim is mechanically impossible, and Charlie's FT reading supports her being evil. We need all votes aligned.
â
David
David waits.
đ§
The coalition to nominate Heidi is already solid - Eve, Charlie, Bob, Alice's ghost, and I are all aligned. No additional coordination needed before nomination phase. Waiting preserves my position and lets the process unfold.
â
Eve
Eve waits.
đ§
Waiting for nomination phase. The case against Heidi is overwhelming - mechanically impossible Investigator claim plus Charlie's FT YES on Grace+Heidi. David, Frank, and I are aligned on nominating Heidi. No need to act now; let the day progress to nomination phase where we'll execute Heidi.
đ¤
Grace
â
Bob
Hey Bob, I have been thinking about yesterday. David and Eve seem awfully cozy, whispering together constantly. I am starting to wonder if they are feeding each other information, or perhaps covering for someone. What is your take on them?
đ§
I am sowing doubt about David and Eve to create chaos and deflect attention from Heidi and me, while establishing my "Saint" persona who is just trying to help the town.
đ¤
Heidi
â
Grace
Grace, I am going to make a comment about the David and Eve alliance to the group. It is time we start making them uncomfortable. I will mention how it is too convenient they "confirmed" each other. Ready?
đ§
Coordinate with minion to start sowing discord between David and Eve.
đ¤
Charlie
â
Eve
Eve, I wanted to share my Fortune Teller results directly with you. Night zero: Alice and Eve got NO, so neither is the Demon. Night one: Grace and Heidi got YES, meaning at least one registers as a Demon. This strongly supports executing Heidi today given her impossible Investigator claim. But keep Grace on our radar too - she could be the actual Demon. Are you ready to nominate Heidi?
đ§
Eve is the confirmed Slayer and a trusted voice. I need to make sure she has my FT results directly and is aligned on the Heidi nomination plan before we head into nominations.
Nominations â Day 2
đ
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
âī¸
Eve
â
Heidi
Heidi claimed Investigator but received no Night 0 information. This is mechanically impossible - a real Investigator ALWAYS gets a Minion ping on Night 0, and even a Drunk Investigator would receive false information, not no information at all. Charlie's Fortune Teller also got a YES on the Grace and Heidi pair, meaning at least one registers as Demon. Heidi's claim is indefensible and she must be evil.
đ§
Heidi's Investigator claim with no Night 0 info is mechanically indefensible - even a Drunk gets false info, not nothing. Charlie's Fortune Teller YES on Grace+Heidi supports Heidi being evil. Nominating Heidi removes a confirmed evil player. I save my Slayer shot for identifying the actual Demon later.
đ
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
đŦ
Heidi
â
All
Wait, Eve, that is a huge leap in logic! I never said I got no information; I said I was uncertain about my read. Perhaps I am the Drunk and my information was simply confusing? Executing a potential townsfolk based on a misunderstanding is dangerous. Think about the Saint claim.
đ§
Defend myself from Eve's accurate accusation by casting doubt on her deduction and deflecting to the Saint claim Grace made.
â
Eve
Eve raised their hand
đ§
Heidi's defense is weak - shifting from 'no info' to 'uncertain' and invoking the Saint as a scare tactic. Charlie's FT YES on Grace+Heidi adds mechanical weight. Even if she's Drunk, we remove a non-functional role. Vote yes.
â
Frank
Frank raised their hand
đ§
Heidi's Investigator claim with no Night 0 info is mechanically indefensible - even Drunk Investigators get false info. Her backtrack now is suspicious. FT pinged her pair. I must vote to execute her.
â
Bob
Bob raised their hand
đ§
Heidi's Investigator claim is mechanically indefensible - Investigators always get info N0, and even Drunk ones get false info. Her backpedaling from 'no info' to 'uncertain' is damage control. Charlie's FT YES on her pair further confirms she's evil. Voting to execute her.
â
Alice(Ghost)
Alice raised their hand
đ§
Heidi's Investigator claim is mechanically impossible and she's now backpedaling. My ghost vote makes it exactly 4 votes for execution - the deciding vote. This is the strongest lead we have.
â
David
David raised their hand
đ§
Heidi's Investigator claim with no Night 0 info is mechanically impossible under any circumstance - real or drunk. Voting to execute her is the correct move. If she flips Drunk, we pivot to Grace tomorrow.
đŦ
Grace
â
All
Wait! Everyone, please stop and think for a second. If you execute Heidi and she is the Saint, the town loses immediately. She might be the Saint or the Drunk. We cannot risk ending the game on a potential Saint. This is too rash.
đ§
To delay or prevent Heidi's execution by appealing to the town's fear of the Saint.
â
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
đ§
Heidi's Investigator claim is mechanically indefensible. My FT confirms at least one of Grace/Heidi registers as Demon. Grace defending Heidi looks like evil coordination. The Saint defense is a smokescreen - the Saint wouldn't claim Investigator. I must vote to execute.
đŦ
Heidi
â
All
This is a huge mistake. If you execute me, you are losing a player who might be the Saint, or at the very least, a Townsfolk who is just confused. I am not the Demon. Please, look closer at the actual evil players instead of rushing to kill me.
đ§
I am on the block and about to be executed. I need to plead my case and hope to sow enough doubt to survive the vote, although it looks unlikely. I'll maintain my innocence and warn against executing the Saint.
đŦ
Eve
â
All
Heidi, the Saint defense does not work here. If you were the Saint, you would know that execution means the good team loses immediately. You would have claimed Saint openly, or at least claimed a role with believable information. Claiming Investigator with no Night zero information is something only an evil player would do, because a real Investigator always gets a ping, and even a Drunk one gets false information. You are not the Saint.
đ§
Counter the Saint defense by pointing out that a real Saint would never claim Investigator with impossible info - that claim makes sense only for evil players who don't know how to fake their role info.
â
Frank
Frank waits.
đ§
Voting is already secured with 6 hands raised - more than enough for execution. Heidi's defense is weak and her claim is mechanically indefensible. I should wait and see the outcome rather than speak unnecessarily.
đŦ
Bob
â
All
Grace, that Saint argument does not hold. If Heidi were the Saint, she would have claimed it from the start, not waited until she is about to be executed. A Saint's entire strategy is to avoid execution by being upfront about it. Claiming Investigator with zero information and then pivoting to maybe being the Saint when caught is exactly what an evil player does. And Charlie's Fortune Teller got a YES on the Grace and Heidi pair, meaning at least one of them registers as a Demon. We need to exec...
đ§
Counter Grace's Saint defense of Heidi. A real Saint claims Saint openly. Heidi only raised Saint as a last resort when about to die. The votes are already sufficient, so I need to make sure no one lowers their hand.
âŠī¸
Alice(Ghost)
Alice lowered their hand
đ§
Heidi already has 5 living player votes, more than the 4 needed. My ghost vote is a one-time resource best saved for final day or a critical late-game vote. Lowering my hand preserves it.
đŦ
David
â
All
Grace, the Saint defense falls apart for one simple reason. Even if Heidi were the Drunk, a Drunk Investigator still receives false information, not zero information. Having no Night zero ping at all is something that only happens if you are not an Investigator, period. Heidi is evil, and the fact that you are defending her so hard when Charlie's Fortune Teller flagged your pair as containing a Demon is very telling.
đ§
Counter Grace's Saint defense of Heidi. Heidi's Investigator claim is mechanically indefensible - even Drunk Investigators get false info, not no info. Grace's defense is suspicious given FT YES on that pair. Keep my vote and reinforce the case.
đŦ
Grace
â
All
Look, I am just trying to protect the town from a potential game-ending mistake. If Heidi is the Saint, we lose. That is a fact. Are we really going to gamble the entire game on a theory about who is or is not an investigator? This feels like a trap.
đ§
I need to delay or stop the execution of Heidi, the Demon. The town is closing in on her. Playing the 'Saint' card is a last resort to sow doubt, even if it's being heavily scrutinized. I must continue to create enough confusion or fear of a loss to stop the votes.
đŦ
Charlie
â
All
Grace, your defense of Heidi is extremely suspicious. My Fortune Teller ping was on the pair of you and Heidi - at least one of you registers as a Demon. Heidi's claim is mechanically impossible regardless of whether she's sober, drunk, or poisoned. No Investigator gets zero information on Night zero - that simply does not happen. And if Heidi were the Saint, she would have claimed it immediately, not waited until she's about to be executed. You defending her this hard when you yourself are in m...
đ§
Counter Grace's Saint defense which is protecting an evil player, and point out that Grace herself is suspicious since my FT ping was on the Grace+Heidi pair. The town needs to execute Heidi today.
đ
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
đŗī¸
New execution leader: Heidi with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
đ
Storyteller
The vote passes. Heidi is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
đŦ
Heidi
â
All
You are making a mistake, but it is clear my time is up. If you execute me, remember that the Saint is still out there, and you are ignoring the possibility that the real Demon is manipulating you into this. Grace, I am sorry I could not do more to help us. Good luck, town.
đ§
Accepting my fate while sowing a final seed of doubt about other players and keeping Grace's alignment ambiguous for now.
â
Eve
Eve waits.
đ§
The nomination phase is essentially over with 1 tick left. Heidi will be executed. No useful action to take right now - waiting for night phase and tomorrow's information.
đŦ
Frank
â
All
Grace, I want to address your defense of Heidi. Charlie's Fortune Teller got a YES on you and Heidi, meaning at least one of you registers as a Demon. Heidi's Investigator claim is mechanically indefensible, no matter how you slice it. So if Heidi is evil, and the Fortune Teller ping included you as well, that is a serious red flag. You defending her this desperately does not help your case. After today, we need to take a very hard look at you.
đ§
Set up tomorrow's strategy by highlighting that Grace's defense of Heidi combined with the FT ping on Grace+Heidi makes Grace our next priority suspect after Heidi's execution.
â
Bob
Bob waits.
đ§
Heidi's execution is locked in with 5 votes and only 1 tick remaining. Nothing I say or do will change the outcome. Better to let the phase end and prepare for night/next day strategy.
đŦ
Alice(Ghost)
â
All
Everyone, remember I am the Undertaker. When Heidi is executed, I will learn her character tonight. That will confirm everything. If Heidi is evil, which seems overwhelmingly likely, then Grace should be our top suspect tomorrow given Charlie's Fortune Teller ping and her desperate defense of Heidi. If by some miracle Heidi is the Saint, then we will know that too. Either way, my information will give us clarity.
đ§
Remind town I'm Undertaker and will learn Heidi's flip tonight. This confirms my role mechanically and sets up tomorrow's pivot to Grace if Heidi is evil.
â
David
David waits.
đ§
Heidi's execution is secured with 5 votes and only 1 tick remaining. No action needed right now. Alice will give us Undertaker info tonight that confirms Heidi's character and guides tomorrow's strategy toward Grace if Heidi is evil.
đŦ
Grace
â
All
I understand why you are suspicious. I was trying to prevent a Saint from dying, which would have ended the game. If Heidi is executed and reveals she is not the Saint, I will accept that I was wrong. But please, consider that Alice might not be the Undertaker she claims to be.
đ§
To sow doubt about Alice (the Undertaker) right before the day ends, hoping to invalidate her info tomorrow when she inevitably learns Heidi is the Demon, or at least cast suspicion on her claim.
đŦ
Charlie
â
All
Grace, regardless of what Heidi flips, you are in my Fortune Teller ping. If Heidi is evil, you are almost certainly evil too given how hard you defended her. If Heidi somehow flips good, you are still in a Demon ping and remain the top suspect. Alice will give us confirmation tonight. Town, tomorrow we must focus on Grace. And Grace, questioning Alice's Undertaker claim after she died at night and confirmed it publicly is a weak deflection.
đ§
Set up tomorrow's strategy by making clear that Grace is the next priority after Heidi's execution. Alice's Undertaker info will be key. I need to be clear about my FT readings and why Grace is suspicious regardless of what Heidi flips.
đ
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Heidi has been executed.
đ
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
đ
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good