Game Detail
Players
Alice (Monk) Bob (Fortune Teller) Charlie (Undertaker) David (Mayor) Eve (Drunk) Frank (Virgin) Grace (Poisoner) Heidi (Imp)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 664,053 | 189,914 | $0.9666 |
| Evil | 243,484 | 52,951 | $1.1674 |
Event Timeline
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You are the Minion. The Demon is Heidi.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Minions are: Grace. Your safe bluffs are: Chef, Ravenkeeper, Librarian
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Night 0 poison should hit a first-night information role to derail the townβs opening logic and keep Heidi off the radar.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to poison Alice.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
π―
Bob
Bob made choices.
π§
Night 0 investigation: Test two players spread across the circle to gather initial Demon information while avoiding my neighbors who might be my red herring.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
You chose David and Grace. You receive the answer: NO.
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
π€
Frank
β
Eve
,Grace
Hey neighbors. Frank here. Just wanted to touch base early. Have either of you learned anything interesting last night, or have any thoughts on how we should approach today?
π§
Day 1 information gathering. As Virgin, I need to build trust networks while being cautious. My neighbors are natural allies to approach first.
π€
David
β
Bob
,Heidi
Hey there! I'm just starting to gather information. What's your take on the opening so far? Any initial thoughts on how we should approach this? I'm trying to connect with different people to piece things together.
π§
As Mayor, I need to gather information and build trust networks. Day 1 is crucial for establishing communication channels. I'll reach out to Bob and Heidi to spread my information network across different parts of the circle and get early reads.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, how's it going? Any early thoughts on the game? I'm just trying to get to know people and figure out where everyone stands.
π§
As the Monk, I need to start building relationships and gathering information. Day 1 is about learning who people are and what they know. Whispering to Charlie lets me establish a connection and probe for information while keeping my options open.
π€
Bob
β
David
,Heidi
Hey David! Nothing too concrete yet - just trying to get a read on people. You're being pretty proactive reaching out. What's your approach for today? Think we should share information openly or keep things close to the chest?
π§
Respond to David's friendly approach while gathering information. I got a NO on David and Grace, which could mean they're not the Demon OR one is my red herring. Building rapport with David without revealing my role yet - Day 1 is too early to claim.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Eve
Hey. I got information night zero. I am the Chef, and I saw one pair of evil players sitting next to each other. That is all I have so far. What did you two get, if anything?
π§
Answer Frank with a plausible info claim to gain credibility, extract info from Frank and Eve, and create an alternate logic path away from Heidi.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Quick sync: I am the Demon. I plan to bluff Librarian and privately say I saw Bob or Charlie as the Drunk. Please avoid Librarian, and maybe lean into a solid info Townsfolk bluff. Tell me your bluff so I do not step on it.
π§
Coordinate with Grace on cover stories and who looks suspicious, so we can steer early chatter and avoid role conflicts that expose us.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
Hey Alice! Not much to go on yet, since it's only Day 1. I'm still trying to get a read on everyone. Have you noticed anything interesting from your conversations? I see Frank and Grace seem to be talking a lot with each other and Eve. Any idea what that's about?
π§
Alice reached out to me first, showing initiative. I should respond to build rapport and start gathering information. Since I'm Undertaker with no info yet (no executions), I can be honest about having nothing to share while gauging Alice's reactions.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,Grace
Thanks for sharing, Grace. That's helpful information. One evil pair means two evil players are sitting together. Can you clarify what you mean by 'one pair' exactly? And Frank, do you have any information or role you'd like to share with us? I'm trying to piece things together before nominations.
π§
Engage with Grace and Frank to learn more about Grace's Chef information and Frank's role while sharing minimal info about my passive ability. Build trust with neighbors and gather intelligence.
π€
David
β
Bob
,Heidi
I think we should share information selectively - maybe reveal roles to a few trusted people first before going public. That way we can coordinate without giving the Demon too much to work with. Have either of you heard any interesting claims yet? I'm trying to get a sense of who might have useful information.
π§
Continue building rapport with Bob and Heidi to form an early alliance. Keep my actual role hidden while promoting information sharing strategies that benefit the good team.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
Charlie, I noticed that too about Frank and Grace with Eve. They seem to be forming a little cluster. Bob and Heidi have been talking with David. I'm not sure what to make of it yet. Have you spoken with anyone else? I'm trying to get a sense of who might have information roles that we should protect or listen to.
π§
Continue building trust with Charlie while gathering more information about who might have useful roles and what alliances are forming. This will help me decide who to protect at night as the Monk.
π€
Bob
β
David
,Heidi
I've got some useful information from last night. I'm a Fortune Teller, and I checked you and Grace. Got a clear NO - meaning neither of you is the Demon. That's good news! This helps narrow things down. What do you think about coordinating with others? Anyone you'd trust enough to share this with?
π§
Share my Fortune Teller results with the group David already pulled together. I can confirm David and Grace are not the Demon, which builds trust with David while positioning me as a useful information source for the good team.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
,Eve
By βone pairβ I mean exactly one adjacent pair of evil players somewhere around the circle. Chef does not say where, just the count. I would not hard clear or accuse any neighbors off that alone. What are you two thinking for early suspects?
π§
Reinforce my Chef bluff with a clear rules explanation, keep credibility with Frank and Eve, and gently direct suspicion away from Heidi without looking defensive.
π€
Heidi
β
David
I agree on selective sharing. Quietly: I am the Librarian. I learned one of Bob or Charlie is the Drunk. So Bobβs Fortune Teller clear on me and Grace feels very shaky to me. I would sit on that for a bit and watch reactions.
π§
Seed a credible Librarian claim to David that undermines Bobβs Fortune Teller βclearβ, preventing me and Grace from being mechanically caught and steering suspicion onto Bob/Charlie.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
Alice, I haven't talked to anyone else yet besides you. You're right about those groupings. Have you spoken with any of them? I'm hesitant to share too much about myself early on, but I do have some abilities that could help the team later. What about you? Do you have anything you can share to build trust?
π§
Continue building a relationship with Alice while cautiously probing for information about her role and what she knows from others. I want to establish trust without revealing I'm the Undertaker yet, as that's most useful after an execution.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,Grace
Frank, you haven't shared anything yet. Do you have any information from last night, or a role claim? I'm trying to figure out who might be trustworthy here. Grace's Chef info is useful if true. Also, Grace, can you clarify if you learned this last night?
π§
Press Frank for information while continuing to build trust with my neighbors. Grace's Chef claim needs verification. Keeping my Soldier role hidden for now to avoid being targeted or having the Demon avoid me.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
,Grace
Thanks for sharing, Grace. One evil pair is useful to know. I don't have night information myself. I'm still processing and trying to figure out who to trust. Eve, what about you? Any role or information you'd like to share with us neighbors?
π§
I need to engage with my neighbors while protecting my Virgin identity. By staying vague about my own role but asking for Eve's information, I can gather more data without revealing my defensive ability prematurely.
π€
David
β
Heidi
That's really valuable information, Heidi. If you're the Librarian, that would explain a lot. Bob's claim did come at me conveniently fast. But here's the thing - I need to keep this quiet for now. We don't want to out you as Librarian too early. Let me gather a bit more intel before we decide how to handle this. Can you tell me - did you get any other information, or was it just the one ping about Bob or Charlie?
π§
I want to solidify Heidi's claim and get more details before deciding how to proceed. I also want to avoid revealing my Mayor role yet to avoid becoming a target. Building trust with Heidi could be valuable for late game.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
Charlie, I appreciate you being open about having abilities. I have a role that can help keep our team safe during the night, if you catch my meaning. I'd rather not say exactly what it is yet, since we're still early. But I think we can work together. Who do you trust so far?
π§
Build trust with Charlie through soft claiming a protective ability without fully revealing I'm the Monk. This establishes alliance potential while keeping my role hidden from evil players.
π€
Bob
β
Eve
Hey Eve! I'm trying to piece together what's happening before nominations. I've noticed you've been chatting with Frank and Grace quite a bit. What's your read on them so far? Any interesting information come up? I'm trying to figure out who we should focus on today.
π§
This is the last tick before nominations. I need to gather information from someone I haven't spoken to yet. Eve has been talking with Frank and Grace, so she might have useful intel. Building connections with multiple players helps verify information and narrow down the Demon.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
I told Frank and Eve I am the Chef and I saw exactly one pair of evil players sitting next to each other. I am going to keep it as a soft info point, not narrowing to any neighbors. Your Librarian bluff on Bob or Charlie as Drunk sounds fine; I will avoid Librarian claims.
π§
Sync bluffs with Heidi, reinforce a coherent story, and plan to deflect attention away from our adjacent seating while keeping demon safe.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
,David
So you both know, I am claiming Librarian. I learned that one of Bob or Charlie is the Drunk, and that is my only info. Bob, that could explain why your Fortune Teller result on me and Grace looks wrong. I would keep this quiet for now and watch how claims land.
π§
Answer David, undermine Bobβs fast Fortune Teller clear, and set up a misexecution path while keeping my Librarian bluff consistent and quiet.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
Hey Bob, I've been watching the group dynamics forming. You've been talking with David and Heidi a fair bit. I'm trying to get a sense of where everyone stands. Have you picked up anything useful from your conversations? Any claims or reads you can share?
π§
Reach out to my neighbor Bob to gather information and build rapport before nominations begin.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
Bob, Grace just claimed Chef to us neighbors. She says she saw exactly one pair of evil players sitting next to each other. That's useful if true. Frank hasn't claimed anything yet - just says he's processing. As for my read, it's too early to say. Grace stepping forward with info feels towny, but I'm keeping an open mind. What's your take? Do you have any info or a role you'd like to share?
π§
Share information with Bob to build trust and gather more intel. Grace's Chef claim is already shared with others, so passing it on is safe. I'm not claiming Soldier yet since it's Day 1 and I want to see what others offer first.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I have some information to share with everyone. I am the Soldier. This means the Demon cannot kill me at night. I wanted to claim this early so the town has reliable information to work with. I don't have investigative info, but at least you know I'm not going anywhere easily.
π§
As Soldier, I want to contribute by claiming my role publicly on Day 1. This provides clear info without risking important investigative roles. It also invites night attacks which I'll survive, potentially confirming my truthfulness and wasting Demon's kill.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I do not think we have enough to execute today yet. If anyone has a night zero info role, like Washerwoman, Librarian, Investigator, or Chef, it would help to hear that first. Otherwise I would rather take a no execution and start building a real world from night one info tomorrow.
π§
Stall nominations and encourage no-execution so the Demon survives day 1, while not publicly cementing my Chef bluff or drawing attention to my adjacency with Heidi.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Grace makes a good point about hearing from information roles first. Eve, thanks for coming forward with your claim. A Soldier claim is interesting, though obviously hard for us to verify right now. I'd like to hear from anyone with starting information before we make any decisions about executions. Does anyone have night zero information they can share with the group?
π§
Support information sharing to help town make informed decisions. Acknowledge Eve's claim without committing to it. Signal that I'm engaged and thinking strategically without revealing my Undertaker role yet.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Before we decide on nominations, I should share my role. I am the Virgin. What this means is that the first time I am nominated, if the nominator is a Townsfolk, they are executed immediately instead of me. I wanted to get this out there so no Townsfolk accidentally nominates me and dies. This also means if anyone does nominate me, they are likely evil since evil players can safely nominate me. I do not think we should rush to execute today with limited information, but at least you all know my ...
π§
I am the Virgin with a dangerous passive ability. If a Townsfolk nominates me, they die immediately. I should reveal now to prevent accidental town deaths and create strategic pressure on evil players. This helps town coordinate and provides useful information.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I do have night zero info. I am the Librarian, and I learned that one of Bob or Charlie is the Drunk. That makes me cautious about treating Bobβs Fortune Teller result as solid. With this much uncertainty, I lean no execution today unless something else is very strong.
π§
Publicly seed my Librarian bluff to undermine Bobβs FT and steer the group toward no execution, maximizing confusion while keeping attention off me as Demon.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Frankβs Virgin claim is likely to be tested tomorrow. Poisoning him makes the test misfire, creating immediate confusion and mis-executions while keeping heat off Heidi.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to poison Frank.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
π―
Alice
Alice made a choice.
π§
Heidi is the only confirmed information-giver with verified claims. As Librarian, she has ongoing value. Eve claims Soldier so doesn't need protection. Frank's Virgin ability is day-based. Protecting investigative roles early is optimal Monk strategy.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
You chose to protect Heidi.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
π§
Kill my neighbor to preempt an Empath read on me and keep day two information sparse, while avoiding the optics of hard-countering the Fortune Teller claim.
π
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
You chose to kill Alice.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
π―
Bob
Bob made choices.
π§
I've already checked David and Grace (both NO). To systematically narrow down the Demon, I need to check the remaining unchecked players. Frank and Charlie are both unchecked and suspicious - Frank hasn't been verified by anyone, and Heidi's claim about Charlie being potential Drunk needs testing. If both come up NO, the Demon is likely Eve or Heidi.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
You chose Frank and Charlie. You receive the answer: YES.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Undertaker. No one was executed today so you learn nothing.
Day 2
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Alice has been found dead in the night.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
Hey Bob, quick check in. I claimed Librarian because I saw that one of you or Charlie is the Drunk. If you really are Fortune Teller, I worry your reads could be off. What other checks have you had, and who feels most solid to you right now?
π§
Get Bob to self-doubt his Fortune Teller info due to my Drunk ping, and steer suspicion toward Charlie or elsewhere while keeping Grace off the block.
π€
Bob
β
Heidi
Thanks for checking in. I've had two reads so far. Night zero, I checked David and Grace and got a no. Night one, I checked Frank and Charlie and got a yes, which means one of them is either the Demon or my red herring. That yes result is making me nervous about Frank especially since he claimed Virgin. If I am the Drunk though, that info means nothing. What made you pick me and Charlie as the Drunk candidates?
π§
I need to probe Heidi about her Librarian information while sharing just enough to build trust. Her answer will help me determine if she's genuine or trying to manipulate me. I also want to see if she has insights about Frank or Charlie.
π€
Charlie
β
Eve
Morning. Alice's death at night proves she wasn't the Demon. She privately hinted at a protective role and wanted to talk. Since you're the claimed Soldier, you're in a good position to help coordinate. What's your read on the situation? And what do you make of Heidi's claim about the Drunk?
π§
Alice died last night which proves she was good. Before she died, she hinted at a protective role and wanted to form an alliance. I should investigate what she knew and coordinate with players I might trust while pushing for an execution to get my Undertaker information.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
As a dead player, I should observe current conversations and whisper activity to gather more information before acting. I need to assess which players are trustworthy before sharing my Monk role publicly.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Grace, I need to know exactly how your Chef ability works. When you saw one adjacent evil pair, does that count evil players sitting next to each other anywhere in the circle? Also, with Alice dead, should I be suspicious of Eve since she's my other neighbor and claimed Soldier?
π§
Gather more information about Grace's Chef reading and probe about my neighbors since Grace's ability detected an adjacent evil pair. This helps narrow down who the evil players might be.
π€
Grace
β
Frank
Chef counts how many pairs of evil players are sitting next to each other anywhere in the circle, at the start of the game. It is just a number, not which pair, and deaths do not change it. So I would not jump to suspect Eve off that alone, especially with claims flying around.
π§
Answer Frank credibly as Chef, emphasize Chef is low precision and unchanged by deaths, and steer him away from linking it to Eve or Heidi so town does not form a correct adjacency solve.
π€
Eve
β
Charlie
Alice's death confirms I was targeted N1 as Soldier, but protected. Demon killed Alice instead. She likely had a protective role. On Heidi's claim - if Bob or Charlie is Drunk, their info is unreliable. Need to hear their claims. What did Alice tell you? Any info we can use?
π§
Coordinate with Charlie who is actively trying to solve the game. Share my analysis that my Soldier claim protected me from Demon N1 kill, so Demon killed Alice instead. Gather more information about what Alice shared with Charlie.
π€
David
β
Grace
Grace, what do you make of Alice dying first? Any suspicions forming? I noticed you've been cautious about executing - wise given the confusion around Bob's Fortune Teller claim and Heidi's Drunk info.
π§
Gather more information about who people suspect. Alice dying first could indicate Demon strategy. Need to understand who the town is suspicious of before nominations start.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Update: Bob says FT N0 checked you and David, got NO. N1 checked Frank and Charlie, got YES (demon or red herring). Since I claimed Librarian that one of Bob or Charlie is Drunk, Charlie being suspicious or dying makes Bob look Drunk and protects you.
π§
Coordinate with Grace using Bobβs FT results to shape todayβs executions and set up a night kill that increases confusion while keeping Grace off the block.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie. I'm trying to figure out what's going on with the claims today. Heidi says she's the Librarian and learned that either you or I is the Drunk. Have you heard anything else that might help us figure out which of us it actually is? I'm also curious about your reads on the other players.
π§
Charlie is central to two key pieces of info: he's in my YES result (him or Frank is Demon/red herring), and Heidi claims he or I is Drunk. Talking to him directly might reveal his alignment and help me determine if I'm Drunk.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
Hey Bob. Heidi mentioned you claimed Fortune Teller. Can you confirm that and share what you've learned? I should tell you - I'm the Undertaker. No one was executed Day one, so I got no information last night. If you're Fortune Teller and I'm Undertaker, one of us could be the Drunk according to Heidi. What's your take on that?
π§
Bob is reaching out. I need to verify his Fortune Teller claim (mentioned by Heidi) and share my Undertaker role cautiously. This builds trust and gets info while being strategic about the Drunk possibility.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
I just died and need to observe the current whispering patterns to gather information. The rapid whisper chains suggest active coordination. As a dead player with a valuable ghost vote, I should watch for who's talking to whom and wait for opportunities to contribute information.
π€
Frank
β
Bob
Bob, I'm the Virgin. Since Alice died next to you, what did you observe or discuss with her yesterday? I'm trying to figure out if she was targeted specifically or randomly. Also, what's your read on the group?
π§
As Virgin, I need to gather information about Alice's death and build alliances. Bob was Alice's neighbor, so he might have insights.
π€
Grace
β
David
I am Chef. I got one adjacent evil pair at the start, but it does not tell which. Alice dying first feels like the demon removing a starting info role. If Bob is really Fortune Teller, his yes on Frank and Charlie makes Charlie a strong lead, and Bob Charlie could even be the evil pair. I would actually test Frankβs Virgin early. If no instant execute, the nominator looks evil or Frank is lying or drunk.
π§
Seed a coherent suspicion path away from Heidi, leverage Frankβs current poison to make a Virgin test fail and create misinfo, and set up misexecution targets (Charlie or Bob).
π€
Eve
β
David
David, I need to coordinate with you since you're my neighbor. Grace claimed Chef saw one adjacent evil pair. As Soldier, I'm confirmed safe from Demon. What's your role claim? And what do you make of the situation? I'm suspicious of Grace and Frank - they're neighbors and both made convenient claims.
π§
David is my neighbor and I haven't coordinated with him yet. Grace claimed adjacent evil pair, and David sits between Charlie and me. Need to understand David's perspective and whether he has useful information about his neighbors (Charlie, me, Frank).
π€
David
β
Eve
Eve, that's a keen observation about Grace and Frank being neighbors. I haven't claimed publicly yet, but I have a role that helps us late game. Here's what's interesting: Grace just told me she's Chef with one adjacent evil pair. If Frank and Grace are the evil pair, that would be... convenient for them to coordinate their claims. But what about Bob's Fortune Teller info? If he's the Drunk per Heidi's Librarian, his clear on Frank means nothing. Do you think we should test Frank's Virgin claim ...
π§
Coordinate with Eve (my neighbor and claimed Soldier) about suspicions. Share Grace's Chef claim and discuss the Frank-Grace evil pair possibility without revealing my Mayor role yet.
π€
Heidi
β
David
Hey David, I know you wanted selective sharing. I am still on my Librarian info that one of Bob or Charlie is the Drunk. Bob is claiming Fortune Teller and says he got a YES on Frank and Charlie last night. Do you have any info that points at either of them, or that clears one of them?
π§
Get David to share his role info, then steer him toward a Charlie or Frank test that costs town an execution or a Townsfolk death, while keeping suspicion off me and Grace.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
Hey Frank, thanks for reaching out. I'm the Fortune Teller. On night zero I checked David and Grace, got a no. On night one I checked you and Charlie, got a yes. So either you, Charlie, or my red herring is the Demon. That yes result worries me since you claimed Virgin. Alice didn't share much with me before she died. What's your read on the group, and do you have any thoughts on why Alice was targeted?
π§
Frank reached out to me asking about Alice's death. I should respond honestly about my FT role and readings, including the concerning YES on him and Charlie. This helps gather information and test his reaction. If he's evil, he may slip up. If he's good, he'll help solve the game.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
Morning Frank. I've been talking with Bob and Eve. Bob apparently claimed Fortune Teller, and I revealed to him that I'm the Undertaker. Heidi's Librarian claim says one of us is the Drunk. Eve claims Soldier and thinks she was targeted last night. What's your read on all these claims? Any thoughts on who might be the Demon?
π§
Frank claimed Virgin, which is a powerful protective claim. I should coordinate with him since I've now revealed my role to Bob and need to build trust networks. Also want to compare notes on the Heidi/Drunk situation.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Charlie
Charlie, I need to share something important. I was the Monk. Night one, I protected Heidi. But I died anyway. This means either the Demon attacked me directly, or I was poisoned and my protection failed. Heidi might have been attacked but saved, or the Demon went for me instead.
π§
As a dead Monk, I must share my Night 1 action (protected Heidi) with a trusted player. This helps deduce whether Heidi was targeted or if I was attacked directly. Charlie showed discretion and claimed helpful info, making them a good confidant.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
Charlie, important update. Bob claims Fortune Teller and got a 'yes' on night one when he checked me and you. Since I know I'm good, that means either you're the Demon, you're the red herring, or Bob is lying. As Undertaker, did you see anyone die by execution yesterday? Also, what exactly did Heidi tell you about the Drunk? I need specifics to work out who's lying here.
π§
Bob just gave me critical Fortune Teller info showing a 'yes' result on me and Charlie. Since I know I'm good, either Charlie is the Demon, I'm the red herring, or Bob is lying. I need to probe Charlie about his Undertaker claim and see if he got any execution info, while also cross-referencing with Grace's evil pair data.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
Bob FT YES on Frank and Charlie is a great push for a Charlie execute today. Also remember I told a couple people Iβm Chef with a one adjacent evil pair, which could fit Bob and Charlie being adjacent, so you can quietly nudge that direction if needed.
π§
Coordinate with Heidi to steer executions onto Charlie or Bob using FT yes and the βadjacent evil pairβ idea, keeping heat off Heidi and me.
π€
Eve
β
Charlie
Charlie, David just told me Bob claims Fortune Teller with a clear on Frank. But if Bob is the Drunk (per Heidi's info), that clear is worthless. Here's what's suspicious: Grace is Chef with one evil pair, and she's neighbors with Frank and Heidi. If Frank and Grace are the evil pair, their claims would be perfectly coordinated. Frank also claims Virgin - easy to fake. What did Alice tell you? Did she have useful info?
π§
Share info from David with Charlie, build trust, and get more info about Alice's claims. Charlie might be a good ally since he's reaching out to me.
π€
David
β
Eve
Eve, Heidi just told me Bob claims Fortune Teller with a YES on Frank and Charlie. That means one of them registered as Demon to him. Combined with Grace's Chef info about an adjacent evil pair, and your suspicion of Frank and Grace being neighbors, we need to test Frank's Virgin claim NOW before nominations. If we nominate Frank and the nominator doesn't die, either Frank is lying or the nominator is evil. Want to coordinate?
π§
Coordinate with Eve to test Frank's Virgin claim before nominations begin. If Frank is lying about Virgin, we catch an evil player. This helps narrow down the Demon before final day.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Everyone, I have critical information. Bob privately claimed Fortune Teller to me. He checked David and Grace on night zero, got a no. He checked Charlie and me on night one, got a yes. Since I am the Virgin and I know I am good, this means Charlie either is the Demon, or is the Fortune Teller's red herring. Charlie, can you explain yourself? And Bob, please confirm this publicly.
π§
Share Bob's Fortune Teller information publicly so the group can make an informed decision. Bob got a 'yes' on Charlie, making Charlie our top suspect. I can't nominate safely due to my Virgin ability, so I'm alerting others to act.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Frank, there's a critical flaw in your logic. Heidi the Librarian publicly stated that Bob or I is the Drunk. If Bob is the Drunk, his Fortune Teller information is completely unreliable - meaning that yes result means nothing. Additionally, Fortune Tellers always have one good player who registers as a Demon, called a red herring. If Bob is legitimate, I could simply be his red herring, which would explain the yes result while I'm good. I am the Undertaker. Bob, please confirm your claims publi...
π§
Defend myself against Frank's accusation by pointing out logical flaws and alternative explanations, while publicly confirming my role and asking Bob to do the same.
βοΈ
Grace
β
Charlie
I am nominating Charlie. Bobβs Fortune Teller story puts a yes on Frank and Charlie, and my Chef number was one adjacent evil pair, which fits Bob and Charlie sitting next to each other. I think Charlie is the cleanest execution today.
π§
Get a non-Heidi player on the block fast, preferably Charlie, using public FT info plus my Chef number to build a plausible case and steer town away from the real Demon.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Everyone, please do NOT vote for me. I am the real Undertaker. I am good. The logic against me is deeply flawed. First, Heidi the Librarian publicly stated that Bob or I is the Drunk. If Bob is the Drunk Fortune Teller, his information is garbage, and the yes result on Frank and me means absolutely nothing. Second, even if Bob is a real Fortune Teller, I could simply be his red herring, the one good player who always registers as the Demon. That is a basic mechanic. Third, Grace is my neighbor, ...
π§
Defend myself against a misguided nomination by pointing out the multiple flaws in the logic and urging the town not to waste an execution on a good player.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
Bob's FT result plus Grace's Chef seeing adjacent evil pair creates strong case. If Charlie is Demon/Minion, this is critical. If wrong, we expose Bob as liar/drunk. Undertaker info is minimal since D1 had no executions.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Secure enough votes to execute Charlie; aligns with my public Chef 1 and the FT YES pressure, and protects Heidi by steering town onto a plausible target.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Secure Charlieβs execution to remove a potential good info source and align with Graceβs push; my vote helps reach majority and builds my credibility as Librarian doubting Charlie.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
My Fortune Teller check on Night 1 showed YES for Frank and Charlie. At least one is evil (Demon or red herring). Charlie is being voted on now. With limited time (2 of 2 ticks), I must vote. Executing Charlie either removes the Demon or narrows suspects. This is good information to act on Day 2.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Wait! Do not execute Charlie. Frank's logic is deeply flawed. First, Fortune Tellers always have a red herring - a good player who registers as Demon. Charlie could simply be that red herring. Second, Heidi publicly stated Bob or Charlie is the Drunk. If Bob is the Drunk, his information is completely worthless. I suspect Frank and Grace are the evil pair here - they are neighbors, and Grace's Chef claim perfectly fits them. They are framing Charlie because Undertakers become dangerous to evil i...
π§
Charlie is about to be executed with 4 votes. I need to speak up NOW before it's too late. Frank's logic is flawed - he ignores the red herring mechanic and Heidi's Drunk claim. I believe Charlie is good Undertaker being framed by Frank & Grace.
π¬
David
β
All
Hold on everyone. Eve is right - there are serious problems with this logic. First, Charlie could be Bob's red herring, that's a basic Fortune Teller mechanic. Second, if Bob is the Drunk per Heidi's information, his yes result means absolutely nothing. Third, Grace's Chef number was one evil pair, and Grace and Frank are literally sitting next to each other. That is extremely convenient. I am not voting for Charlie. We need to slow down and think about who benefits from rushing this execution.
π§
Four votes have already been cast for Charlie, which is the execution threshold. Eve is making excellent points - the logic against Charlie has major holes. As Mayor, I need to help the town avoid executing a potentially good player. The Frank/Grace neighbor theory deserves examination.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Wait everyone! I was the Monk. Night one, I protected Heidi, but I died anyway. This means I was either poisoned, or the Demon attacked me directly. Now I see four players voting in perfect coordination against Charlie. If Charlie is truly the Undertaker, that role becomes very dangerous to evil players. Heidi's Librarian info said Bob or Charlie is the Drunk. If Bob is the Drunk, his Fortune Teller information is completely false. Think about who benefits from rushing this execution!
π§
Four players voting in perfect coordination against Charlie is extremely suspicious. If Charlie is the real Undertaker, evil wants him dead before he can share execution info. I must speak against this rushed execution and warn the town about the coordinated voting pattern.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Four votes. Frank, Grace, Heidi, Bob. Notice that coordination? Frank claims Virgin and Grace claims Chef with one evil pair. They sit right next to each other. That is the actual evil pair. They are rushing to kill the Undertaker because I would learn their character if executed. Alice the Monk died protecting Heidi. Now Heidi votes against me. This execution helps evil. Do not let them rush this.
π§
I'm about to be executed with 4 votes. I need to make a final compelling defense that exposes the coordinated attack and the logical flaws. I must convince others this is a coordinated evil push before it's too late.
β©οΈ
Frank
Frank lowered their hand
π§
Charlie's defense has merit - I could be Bob's red herring, or Bob could be Drunk. If Charlie is real Undertaker, executing him wastes good info. Coordinated rush feels like evil team eliminating a threat. I must slow down and reconsider.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Alice, if you were poisoned night zero then your Monk protection story is not solid evidence. On Charlie, even with the red herring possibility, we still have a Fortune Teller yes and my Chef one pointing at a tight cluster. Frank, if you still trust your Fortune Teller source, I think you should put your hand back up.
π§
Push execution through by undermining Aliceβs Monk info and framing Charlie as best lead, while keeping Heidi safe and maintaining my Chef bluff credibility.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am still comfortable voting Charlie. Between the Fortune Teller yes on Frank and Charlie, and my Librarian ping that one of Bob or Charlie is the Drunk, Charlie being unreliable fits really cleanly. If we do not execute here, we are just spinning. Frank, I think keeping the vote on is reasonable.
π§
Keep pressure to execute Charlie by presenting it as the most testable, least risky line, and encourage Frank to revote without exposing my team.
β©οΈ
Bob
Bob lowered their hand
π§
I'm being manipulated. Frank outed my info publicly, which helps evil. He then lowered his own vote, leaving me looking guilty. If Charlie is good Undertaker, executing him helps evil. If Frank is Demon, my YES read is on him too. I need to step back and reassess.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Everyone, look at what just happened. Frank and Bob lowered their hands. Only Grace and Heidi are still voting. That's two votes - not enough to execute. This rush job is falling apart because the logic is flawed. Charlie could be Bob's red herring, and if Bob is the Drunk, his information means nothing. Grace and Frank are neighbors, which perfectly fits Grace's Chef number. They are the most likely evil pair. I am not voting for Charlie, and I urge everyone else to stand down. We need more inf...
π§
The coordinated rush on Charlie with flawed logic is deeply suspicious. Frank and Grace are neighbors and their claims fit perfectly as evil pair. Charlie as Undertaker is dangerous to evil. I must not vote for Charlie and should urge others to stop this rushed execution.
π¬
David
β
All
Eve is absolutely right. Look at the vote count - only Grace and Heidi still voting. That's two votes, not enough to execute. Frank and Bob both lowered their hands after realizing the logic was flawed. The Fortune Teller always has a red herring, and if Bob is the Drunk per Heidi's own information, his results mean nothing. Grace and Frank are neighbors. That fits Grace's Chef number perfectly. They are coordinating this rush.
π§
The vote is collapsing with only 2 votes. I need to reinforce why voting Charlie is wrong and highlight the suspicious Grace-Frank connection that Eve identified.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
The vote count is only 2 (Grace and Heidi), not enough to execute. Frank and Bob lowered their hands after realizing the flawed logic. Eve and David made strong arguments about red herring mechanics and the Grace-Frank evil pair theory. I should save my single ghost vote for final day when it has maximum impact. Charlie is likely good - either Bob's red herring or Bob is the Drunk.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Charlie did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Charlie did not receive enough votes (2/4).
βοΈ
Charlie
β
Grace
Grace, you claimed Chef with one evil pair, and you sit right next to Frank. That makes you two the most likely evil pair. You rushed to nominate me, the Undertaker, a role that becomes dangerous to evil. I want to execute you to learn your character and prove my Undertaker ability.
π§
Grace and Frank are neighbors, which perfectly fits Grace's Chef claim of 1 evil pair. They coordinated the rush against me. I need to nominate one of them to get information and protect myself as Undertaker.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Please do not vote me. Chef one does not mean the evil pair is neighbors, it just means there is one adjacent pair somewhere. Charlie is nominating me as retaliation to save himself, and his Undertaker claim is unproven. If you are unsure, let this die with no execution today.
π§
Prevent my execution and keep heat off Heidi by framing Charlieβs nomination as retaliatory and Chef as non-neighbor-specific.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Vote for Grace to potentially execute her. As Undertaker, I need to create executions to get my information. Grace tried to rush my execution on flawed logic, and she sits next to Frank which fits her own Chef number. Executing her proves my role.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Charlie, if you are the real Undertaker, you will learn who Alice was tonight, which will prove your ability. Grace, I am not voting for you because the Chef information is not specific to any pair. But I want to understand something. You said there is one adjacent evil pair. How does that information help us find evil if we cannot determine which pair it is?
π§
I want to delay voting on Grace and probe both Charlie and Grace for more information. The Chef claim is vague and I need clarity on its utility. Charlie's Undertaker claim needs time to be verified.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am not voting Grace here. Chef one is real but it does not point to Grace specifically, and Charlie nominating her feels like a deflection after his own heat. I would rather we let this miss and reassess tomorrow with more confirmed info.
π§
Save Grace from execution, encourage a no-execution day, and keep town uncertain so I can kill an info role tonight and maintain control.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Everyone, I have important information. My Fortune Teller read from night zero specifically checked David and Grace and got a clear NO. Grace is not the Demon. However, my night one read on Frank and Charlie came back YES. One of them is the Demon. This is why I lowered my hand on Charlie earlier - we need to think this through carefully. I am not voting for Grace.
π§
Share my FT information that Grace is not the Demon to clear her name, while noting that Frank or Charlie is my Demon read. This provides factual information to help the town make better decisions.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am not voting for Grace. Bob's Fortune Teller specifically got a NO on Grace, which means she is not the Demon. We should be focusing on Frank or Charlie, since Bob's YES result points to one of them. Let this nomination fail and we can execute the real Demon tomorrow. As Soldier, I know I am safe from the Demon tonight, so we have time to get this right.
π§
Bob's FT confirms Grace is NOT the Demon. Charlie's nomination is retaliatory and won't help us find the Demon today. Let vote fail, keep discussion alive for tomorrow when we can target Frank (most likely Demon per FT info).
π¬
David
β
All
I am not voting for Grace. Bob's Fortune Teller specifically cleared her as not the Demon on night zero. His YES result points to Frank or Charlie as the Demon. We should focus there. Also, if Bob is the Drunk per Heidi's information, we cannot trust any of his reads anyway. Let this nomination fail and target the real Demon tomorrow.
π§
Defend against Grace's execution since Bob's FT cleared her, and redirect focus to Frank or Charlie who Bob's FT flagged. Support letting the nomination fail to preserve town numbers and avoid executing a non-Demon.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
Bob's Fortune Teller cleared Grace as not the Demon. His YES points to Frank or Charlie. Grace is not the priority. I should save my single ghost vote for the final day or a critical Demon vote, not waste it on a likely good player.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Everyone, please keep your hand down. Bob already has a night zero no on me, so this is not a Demon hit. Charlie is trying to turn heat into a revenge execution, and Undertaker is unproven. If you are not sure, let this nomination fail and reassess tomorrow.
π§
Keep myself alive by damping votes, preserve confusion between Charlie and Frank, and push for no execution so Demon gets another night kill.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Grace keeps deflecting. Bob's Fortune Teller said NO on Grace for Demon - that does not mean she is good. She could be a Minion protecting Frank. Grace and Frank are neighbors. Chef one fits them perfectly as an evil pair. Frank got the YES from Bob's Fortune Teller. That makes Frank the Demon and Grace his Minion. Also, if Bob is the Drunk like Heidi claims, his reads mean nothing. Execute Grace, and I will confirm my Undertaker ability tonight by learning she was the Minion.
π§
Challenge Grace's defense by pointing out Minion possibility and pushing for execution to prove my Undertaker ability.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I am not voting for Grace. Bob's Fortune Teller cleared her as not the Demon. Charlie, your retaliation nomination is suspicious, but I will give you a chance to prove your Undertaker claim tonight by learning Alice's character. Everyone, we should let this vote fail and regroup tomorrow with more information.
π§
Publicly stand down on Grace vote since Bob's FT cleared her as not Demon. Turn attention to the YES result without revealing I outed Bob's info. Push for more analysis and tomorrow execution.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am keeping my hand down. This nomination feels like pure retaliation, and Chef one does not single Grace out. If we execute wrong here, we throw away the day. Let this fail and regroup tomorrow with clearer info.
π§
Keep my minion alive, keep heat on Charlie, and steer town toward no-exec or a mis-execution later while staying consistent with my stated stance.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
The vote on Grace is clearly failing with only Charlie supporting it. I have already publicly stated my reasons for not voting Grace (my FT cleared her as not Demon). Speaking again is redundant. Let the nomination fail and move to night phase.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
The vote on Grace has insufficient support (only 1 vote from Charlie), and multiple players including myself have already spoken against it. Bob's Fortune Teller cleared Grace as not the Demon and points to Frank or Charlie instead. Speaking further would be redundant - I should let this nomination fail and focus on building consensus for the right target tomorrow.
π¬
David
β
All
I am not voting for Grace. Bob's Fortune Teller cleared her as not the Demon. Charlie, this nomination looks like pure retaliation. If you want to prove your Undertaker claim, let this fail and report Alice's character tomorrow. We should be focusing on Frank or Charlie based on Bob's YES result, not executing someone cleared of being the Demon.
π§
Clarify my position against voting Grace and redirect suspicion to the players actually flagged by Fortune Teller.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, I need to speak up with my ghost vote on the line. I was the Monk. I protected Heidi on night one, and I died. That is suspicious timing. Either the Demon wanted me dead for some reason, or I accidentally protected someone who is not worth protecting. Think about that. Also, if Heidi is evil, her Librarian claim calling Bob or Charlie the Drunk could be designed to cast doubt on Bob's Fortune Teller reads. I am not voting for Grace. Charlie deserves to prove his Undertaker ability toni...
π§
Share my death analysis publicly - I protected Heidi and died, which is suspicious timing. Question the coordinated group's logic and defend Charlie's Undertaker claim by pointing out flaws in their reasoning.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Grace did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (1/4).
π¬
Grace
β
All
One quick rules thing: Undertaker only learns the character of the person executed today, not someone who died at night. So Charlie saying he will learn Alice tonight does not add up, unless he is lying or drunk or poisoned. I am fine with no execution and revisiting tomorrow.
π§
Undermine Charlie credibility using a rules-consistent point, steer suspicion away from Heidi, and set up a likely D3 execution on Charlie or general no-exec confusion.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Grace is right, I made an error. Undertaker learns executed characters, not night deaths. That means if no one dies by execution, I learn nothing. My apologies. This actually makes tomorrow critical. We need a clean execution so I can prove my role. Grace and Frank are still my top suspects as neighbors fitting the Chef one. But let us take tonight to gather more information and execute properly tomorrow.
π§
Acknowledge my Undertaker mechanic error publicly to maintain credibility, while reiterating my suspicion of Grace/Frank as the evil pair and emphasizing the need for a real execution tomorrow.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
The day is ending and consensus is to regroup tomorrow. Charlie's Undertaker claim is now highly suspect due to the error. Bob's FT gave YES on Frank/Charlie, and since I'm good Virgin, Charlie likely registers as Demon. No point nominating now with 1 tick left.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Avoid creating a late nomination that could accidentally land on me or Grace; push the game to night where I control the kill and can remove the biggest info threat.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Everyone, just to reiterate: my Fortune Teller reads are clear. Grace and David are not the Demon. Frank or Charlie is the Demon. Charlie's Undertaker error is concerning. Tomorrow, we need to choose between Frank and Charlie for execution. I am ready to keep pushing this until we find the Demon.
π§
Reinforce my FT findings before night falls so everyone knows the Demon is Frank or Charlie. Charlie's Undertaker mistake makes me more suspicious of him, but Frank also fits the Chef evil pair with Grace.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Let the day end with no execution. As Soldier, I'm safe tonight. Tomorrow we can focus on Frank vs Charlie based on Bob's Fortune Teller. Charlie's Undertaker error was suspicious but he admitted it. Grace's Chef info still fits Frank/Grace as evil neighbors.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Grace's nomination just failed. Charlie made a suspicious Undertaker error. Bob's FT says Frank/Charlie is Demon. Heidi says Bob might be Drunk. I should wait to see if others nominate or if we proceed to night with no execution.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, Charlie's error about the Undertaker is critical. A real Undertaker knows they only learn executed characters. Charlie saying he would learn my character tonight suggests he either does not actually have the role, or he is the Drunk that Heidi mentioned. Combined with Bob's Fortune Teller giving a YES on Frank and Charlie, and Frank's behavior seeming more town aligned, Charlie is looking very suspicious. Tomorrow, we should strongly consider executing Charlie to test both his claim an...
π§
Point out that Charlie's Undertaker error is mechanically significant - it suggests he is either lying or drunk/poisoned. This combines with Bob's FT YES result to narrow suspects. The group needs this analysis before night falls.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 2
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Disable and corrupt the Fortune Tellerβs next read so townβs main logic engine misfires on Day 3, keeping Heidi off the block and pushing a mis-execution.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to poison Bob.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
π§
Remove the strongest info engine and stop nightly checks on me; then use my Librarian bluff to discredit Bob posthumously and steer town into executing a good player.
π
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
You chose to kill Bob.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Undertaker. No one was executed today so you learn nothing.
Day 3
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
π€
Frank
β
Grace
Bob's final FT read said Frank/Charlie is Demon. Since I'm Virgin and good, Charlie must be Demon unless Bob was poisoned. Charlie also messed up Undertaker rules. We should execute Charlie today.
π§
Share critical deduction that Charlie is likely the Demon based on Bob's FT result, since I know I'm good. Grace is my most trusted ally given her consistent Chef claim.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
David
,Grace
Bob's Fortune Teller confirmed Frank or Charlie is the Demon. Charlie's Undertaker error is damning - real Undertaker knows they only track executions. If Bob wasn't the Drunk, Charlie could be the Drunk explaining his fake info. I think Charlie is our Demon. What do you think?
π§
Coordinate with alive good players to identify the Demon. Share my analysis pointing to Charlie as likely Demon based on FT info and Undertaker claim error.
π€
David
β
Alice(Ghost)
,Grace
I agree Charlie is highly suspicious. The Undertaker mistake was glaring, and real Undertakers know they only track executions, not night deaths. But here is my worry. Heidi claimed Bob or Charlie is Drunk. If Bob was the Drunk, his Fortune Teller reads mean nothing, so Frank could be innocent. We need to figure out if Heidi is trustworthy or if she is evil trying to discredit Bob's information. Has anyone verified Heidi?
π§
Respond to Alice's whisper about Charlie being the Demon. I want to agree that Charlie is suspicious but also raise the important point that Heidi's claim complicates Bob's Fortune Teller information. Need to discuss whether we can trust Heidi or if she might be evil.
π€
Heidi
β
David
I still think we should execute Charlie today. His Undertaker mistake plus pushing worlds off shaky info feels like cover. Also Bobβs Fortune Teller yes on Frank and Charlie keeps Charlie in the frame. I would avoid nominating Frank until we are sure about Virgin.
π§
Lock David onto executing Charlie and away from scrutinizing the real adjacent pair Grace and me; also discourage nominating Frank if Virgin is real.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Quick update - I'm Fortune Teller. Night 0: David and Grace gave NO. Night 1: Frank and Charlie gave YES. Demon is Frank or Charlie. Charlie's Undertaker error proves he's lying. Frank and Grace being neighbors fits Chef's evil pair reading, so Frank Demon, Grace Minion makes sense. Push for Charlie execution today.
π§
Share my Fortune Teller results with Heidi to help coordinate today's execution. My FT YES proves Demon is Frank or Charlie, and Charlie's fake Undertaker claim makes him the likely Demon.
π€
Eve
β
Alice(Ghost)
,David
Bob's death worries me. His FT got YES on both Frank and Charlie. If Heidi's Librarian claim is true, Bob could be Drunk and his reads false. Or Heidi could be evil faking Librarian to discredit Bob. Have you noticed Grace and Frank won't vote each other? Grace's Chef claim of 1 evil pair would mean they're both evil together. I think Frank is more likely Demon than Charlie - Charlie's Undertaker error could be genuine confusion. What's your read?
π§
Share observations about Bob's death, FT contradictions, and coordinate with dead player Alice and neighbor David to identify the Demon before nominations.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
Observe the current situation and gather information before speaking. Need to understand what information has been shared and who's being targeted for execution today.
π€
Grace
β
David
,Alice(Ghost)
I am also leaning Charlie today. The Undertaker rules mistake is hard to hand wave. Also remember Heidi said Bob or Charlie is Drunk, and Bob could also have been poisoned last night, so his final Fortune Teller read might not be solid. I would execute Charlie first, then reassess.
π§
Keep heat off Heidi by validating the βexecute Charlieβ path while seeding that Bobβs final FT info may be poisoned or Drunk, preventing a chain that points to Heidi later.
π€
Frank
β
David
Bob's final FT read said Frank/Charlie is a Demon. I am Virgin and I am good. Therefore Charlie must be the Demon, unless Bob was poisoned. Also Charlie messed up Undertaker rules - he claimed to learn night deaths, but Undertaker only learns executed characters. Charlie is our Demon.
π§
Build coalition to execute Charlie today. As Virgin I know I am good, so Charlie must be the Demon per Bob's FT read. I need David on board to secure execution.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Eve
,David
Eve, your observation about Grace and Frank not voting each other is critical. Grace claimed Chef saw 1 evil pair. If they ARE that pair, Grace being Minion and Frank being Demon explains everything - their voting behavior, Bob's FT result on Frank, and why Grace is pushing Charlie so hard. Charlie's Undertaker error could be genuine confusion if he's the Drunk Heidi mentioned. I now think Frank is the Demon. Execute Frank today.
π§
Eve spotted a critical pattern - Grace and Frank protect each other. Combined with Chef 1 pair claim, they could be the evil team. Bob's FT points to Frank or Charlie. I need to share this analysis before nominations.
π€
David
β
Alice(Ghost)
,Eve
Alice, your analysis about Grace and Frank is compelling. If Grace is Chef and saw one evil pair, and they will not vote each other, they likely ARE that pair. Frank as Demon and Grace as Minion explains their coordinated behavior. I support executing Frank today. I will nominate him when nominations open.
π§
Coordinate with Alice and Eve to confirm we're executing Frank. Their voting behavior analysis is the strongest evidence we have. I want to ensure we have enough votes lined up.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
I think today we should keep the group focused on executing Charlie. His Undertaker mistake plus pushing worlds feels bad, and it also fits Bobβs yes on Frank and Charlie. If Chef comes up, I would gently float Frank and you as the adjacent evil pair rather than pointing at me.
π§
Coordinate with Grace to steer todayβs execution onto Charlie and pre-empt Chef adjacency pointing at me, while leveraging Bobβs old FT YES to keep suspicion away from us.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
David
,Eve
I'm Fortune Teller. Critical info: Night 0 checked David and Grace, got NO - neither is Demon. Night 1 checked Frank and Charlie, got YES - one IS the Demon. Demon is Frank or Charlie. Charlie's Undertaker error proves he's lying about his role. Frank and Grace being neighbors matches Chef's one evil pair. I think Frank is Demon, Grace is Minion. We need to execute one of them today.
π§
Share my Fortune Teller results with David and Eve to coordinate the vote. My NO on Grace clears her as Demon, and my YES pins Demon as Frank or Charlie. Combined with Chef info and Charlie's fake Undertaker claim, the evidence points to Frank being Demon.
π€
Eve
β
Heidi
Heidi, Bob's ghost just confirmed to me he's Fortune Teller. He got YES on both Frank and Charlie - that's unusual. Combined with Grace and Frank refusing to vote each other, and Grace's Chef claim of one evil pair, I think Frank is Demon and Grace is Minion. Your Librarian said Bob or Charlie is Drunk - but if you're good, we should trust your read. Where do you stand on executing Frank today?
π§
Gather Heidi's perspective and confirm her alignment before nominations. If she supports Frank execution, that strengthens the case. If she deflects, she might be evil working with Frank/Grace.
π€
Charlie
β
David
David, I need to share my perspective. Bob's Fortune Teller reading pointed to Frank or me as Demon. But I know I'm the Undertaker - I just haven't learned anything yet because we haven't executed anyone. Bob dying last night actually makes me trust his information more, since evil players rarely die at night. That would make Frank the Demon. But Heidi's claim about Bob being Drunk complicates things. What have you learned from your conversations?
π§
I need to establish my innocence and work with David to figure out the truth. Since Bob's FT reading implicates me, I should proactively defend myself while pushing the team toward Frank as the real suspect.
π€
Grace
β
David
I think the cleanest line today is still execute Charlie. Even if Bobβs last FT read was poisoned or Bob was the Drunk, Charlieβs Undertaker slip plus his pushes are enough to justify it. If Charlie dies and game continues, we should reassess Chef adjacency and who benefits from discrediting Bob.
π§
Keep the group executing Charlie (likely good) while seeding doubt about Bobβs FT via poison/Drunk, so future suspicion avoids Heidi and can pivot onto other good players.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
The day phase is ending. I've already whispered to Grace and David explaining that Bob's FT read proves Charlie is the Demon since I'm good. Now I wait for nominations to execute Charlie.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
The coalition with David and Eve is solid - we've identified Frank as the likely Demon based on: Grace's Chef claim of 1 evil pair, their coordinated non-voting behavior, and Bob's FT pointing to Frank or Charlie. Charlie's Undertaker error is likely because he's the Drunk Heidi mentioned. David will nominate Frank when nominations begin, and I'll vote for Frank's execution.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Continue gathering information before nominations open. I have committed to nominating Frank based on compelling evidence that he is the Demon and Grace is his Minion - their refusal to vote each other plus Bob's FT result on Frank/Charlie and Grace's Chef claim of 1 evil pair all align.
π€
Heidi
β
Eve
I am not excited to execute Frank today because if he really is the Virgin we could waste the day or lose a good nominator. Charlie has had the Undertaker confusion and he is in Bobβs Fortune Teller yes as well, and my Librarian ping could make his info unreliable anyway. My preference is we execute Charlie first.
π§
Steer Eve off the Frank execution (Virgin risk) and onto Charlie as the safer, mechanically suspect execution, keeping me and Grace off the block.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
David
,Eve
It's nomination time. My FT reads prove Demon is Frank or Charlie. Charlie's Undertaker error is a smoking gun - he doesn't know how Undertaker works. Frank claims Virgin which is verifiable. Execute Charlie today. Use your nomination and vote. We can't afford another miss.
π§
Rally David and Eve to nominate and vote Charlie today. My Fortune Teller YES on Frank/Charlie plus Charlie's fake Undertaker claim proves he's evil. Only 1 tick remains before nominations.
π€
Eve
β
David
David, we must nominate Frank. The coordinated behavior between Grace and Frank refusing to vote each other, combined with Grace's Chef claim of one evil pair where they are neighbors, makes them the evil pair. Bob's FT YES on Frank is real. Charlie's Undertaker error is likely him being the Drunk Heidi mentioned. Frank is the Demon. Nominate him!
π§
Rally David to nominate Frank before nominations open. Frank's coordinated behavior with Grace and position as Grace's neighbor make him the Demon.
π€
Charlie
β
Eve
Eve, I'm getting worried. Bob's FT pointed to Frank or me, but I know I'm the Undertaker. We haven't executed anyone, so I have no info yet. If Bob was telling truth, Frank is Demon. But Heidi claims Bob might be Drunk, which makes his FT unreliable. As Soldier, have you been approached by evil? What's your read on Frank and Heidi?
π§
Gather intel from Eve who I haven't spoken to much. Need to understand her position before nominations, and see if she has useful information about Frank or Heidi.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
I am still on Charlie today. The Undertaker rules mistake is the cleanest reason, and it also lines up with Bobβs last Fortune Teller yes on Frank and Charlie, even if Bob was Drunk or poisoned. If Charlie dies and we are still playing, we can re evaluate tomorrow.
π§
Lock in votes on Charlie and keep pressure off Heidi; seed doubt about using Chef adjacency to target Heidi; keep Frank alive as misexecution candidate later.
Nominations β Day 3
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Grace
β
Charlie
I am nominating Charlie. The Undertaker rules mistake is not a small slip, and it pairs with Bobβs Fortune Teller getting a yes on Frank and Charlie. Even if Bob was poisoned or Drunk, Charlieβs story has been the least consistent.
π§
Drive a credible execution on Charlie to remove a good player and keep heat off Heidi, while using the Undertaker mistake plus FT βyesβ as an easy public case.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Grace, I understand your suspicion. I did make a mistake about my role. I thought Undertaker learned character on any death, but it is only executions. I was wrong. But here is the truth. I am the Undertaker, and I have learned nothing because we have executed no one. Bob's Fortune Teller pointed to Frank or me as Demon. I know I am not the Demon. So either Frank is the Demon, or Bob was poisoned or drunk as Heidi suggested. If you execute me, you kill a good player who could confirm future exec...
π§
Defend myself against execution by addressing my Undertaker mistake honestly, redirecting suspicion to Frank based on Bob's FT, and emphasizing I can provide value if we execute someone today.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Vote to execute Charlie to eliminate a likely good player, keep Heidi off the radar, and maintain the Frank-versus-Charlie narrative into final days.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
Frank is the most likely Demon based on FT info and coordinating with Grace. Voting Charlie helps evil if Frank is Demon and Grace is Minion. Need more info before using my ghost vote.
β
David
David waits.
π§
Eve and dead Bob both told me Frank is the Demon. If Charlie is the Drunk as Heidi suggested, his Undertaker error makes sense. Grace nominating Charlie could be evil redirecting from Frank. I should wait to see the vote count before deciding - need more information on where the town stands.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Secure Charlieβs execution to remove a likely good player, preserve uncertainty around Frank being Virgin, and steer the town into a losing endgame while keeping me off the demon radar.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
I know I am the Virgin and good, so Bob's FT reading pointing to Frank or Charlie as Demon means Charlie must be the Demon. His Undertaker claim was fraudulent with the night death error. We need this execution.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
π§
Vote for Charlie execution. My Fortune Teller YES on Frank+Charlie means Demon is one of them. Charlie's Undertaker error proves he's lying about role - Undertakers learn executed characters, not night deaths. This makes Charlie likely the Demon. Already have 3 votes, but my ghost vote ensures execution and I may not survive to final 3.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
I want Charlie executed to test the Undertaker claim and see if Heidi's Librarian info (Bob/Charlie Drunk) explains the Undertaker error. With 4 votes secured, mine is redundant. I'm preserving my dead vote for final day when I'll need to push hard for Frank as the Demon. If Charlie is good, we confirm Frank is the Demon via Bob's FT logic.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
Four votes against me (Grace, Heidi, Frank, Bob) exceeds the 3 needed for execution. Voting for myself makes no sense. Further speech won't change the outcome. I must accept execution and use my ghost vote strategically later.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I hear you, Charlie, but the problem is we have to act on what we can trust. Your Undertaker mistake was a full mismatch with the rules, and Bobβs Fortune Teller had you in a yes pair. I think we should take the shot and execute you today.
π§
Lock in Charlie execution by persuading holdouts; keep narrative centered on UT mistake and FT ping so Heidi stays out of focus.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, please reconsider. The connection between Grace and Frank is far more suspicious than Charlie's Undertaker mistake. Grace and Frank are neighbors and refused to vote for each other yesterday. That is classic evil team coordination. If Grace is the Minion and Frank is the Demon, their behavior makes perfect sense. Charlie's error could easily be explained if they are the Drunk, which matches Heidi's Librarian information. Bob's Fortune Teller could have been accurate about Frank being t...
π§
Advocate for executing Frank instead of Charlie. Frank has more suspicious behavior with Grace, while Charlie's error could be explained by being the Drunk. I want to save my ghost vote for a Frank nomination or final day.
π¬
David
β
All
Everyone, wait. Alice and Eve both told me Frank is the Demon and Grace is the Minion. The coordinated refusal to vote each other yesterday is more damning than Charlie's Undertaker mistake, which could be explained if he's the Drunk that Heidi mentioned. Bob's Fortune Teller had YES on both Frank and Charlie. We should be nominating Frank, not Charlie. Don't vote for Charlie.
π§
I want to redirect the town from executing Charlie (who might be good/Drunk) to nominating Frank (who is more likely the Demon based on coordinated behavior with Grace). This helps good team win by executing the actual Demon.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I would not pivot to Frank right now. If Frank is the Virgin and we nominate him, we can burn the day on a rules interaction instead of a clean execution. Charlie is in the Fortune Teller yes pair and has been inconsistent. I think we should finish this vote and execute Charlie.
π§
Keep momentum on Charlie execution; discourage pivot to Frank where Virgin risk could derail; protect Grace and buy time to kill threats at night.
π¬
Frank
β
All
David, I am the Virgin, and I know I am good. Bob's Fortune Teller pointed to Frank or Charlie as Demon. I am Frank, and I am not the Demon. Charlie has made multiple inconsistencies and the Undertaker mistake was a fundamental error. We have the votes. Let us execute Charlie today.
π§
Reinforce the Charlie execution and counter David's attempt to pivot the vote toward me. I know I'm Virgin and good, so David's theory is wrong.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Stop. Everyone, listen. My Fortune Teller results show Frank OR Charlie as the Demon. But Alice and David are right about the coordination. Frank and Grace are neighbors. They refused to vote for each other yesterday. Grace's Chef reading showed one evil pair sitting together. That pair is Frank and Grace. If Frank is the Demon and Grace is the Minion, their behavior makes perfect sense. Charlie might be the Drunk that Heidi mentioned. That would explain his Undertaker mistake and my YES reading...
π§
Redirect the town to execute Frank instead of Charlie by explaining how Frank+Grace coordination matches Chef info and my FT reading better than Charlie being Demon.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am not voting for Charlie. The coordination between Grace and Frank is far more damning. They are neighbors who refused to vote each other yesterday, and Grace's Chef claim showed one evil pair. That pair is Grace the Minion and Frank the Demon. Charlie is likely the Drunk Heidi mentioned, explaining his Undertaker mistake and Bob's Fortune Teller reading. Frank is the Demon. Execute Frank, not Charlie.
π§
I am signaling my disagreement with Charlie's execution and clearly stating my belief that Frank is the Demon and Grace is the Minion, based on their coordinated refusal to vote each other and Grace's Chef claim.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Charlie with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Charlie is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Frank claims Virgin, which means if a Townsfolk nominates him, they get executed and the day ends. That is exactly what the Demon would want to avoid being voted out. Bob's Fortune Teller showed Frank as a Demon candidate, and the coordination between Grace and Frank is extremely suspicious. Heidi, David, or Eve, if you believe Frank is the Demon, you need to nominate him NOW. There is only one tick left. If no one else is nominated, I die. But if Frank is actually the Demon, you will lose a cha...
π§
My execution is imminent. I must urgently convince remaining players (Heidi, David, Eve) to nominate Frank before the nomination phase ends.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Do not pivot in the last seconds. Frank being the Virgin makes a Frank nomination a huge trap that can burn the day. Chef one does not automatically mean it is me and Frank. Charlie is already in the Fortune Teller yes pair and his story has been messy. Execute Charlie, then reassess tomorrow.
π§
Lock in Charlieβs execution and stop a last-second pivot onto Frank or Heidi by emphasizing the Virgin risk and that Chef-1 does not uniquely implicate neighbors.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
David and Eve, you must nominate Frank right now or we lose a good player. I am keeping my ghost vote. If Frank is the Demon and we fail to nominate him, Charlie dies and evil wins momentum. If Frank is telling the truth about Virgin, the worst case is the day ends without an execution. That is better than executing Charlie who might be the Drunk. Nominate Frank now.
π§
I need to urge David or Eve to nominate Frank in this final tick, or Charlie will be executed and we will lose a potentially good player. The evidence strongly points to Frank as Demon.
βοΈ
David
β
Frank
Bob's Fortune Teller marked you as a Demon candidate. Your coordinated refusal to vote Grace yesterday, combined with being neighbors in a one-evil-pair game, makes you the likely Demon with Grace as your Minion. Charlie's Undertaker error is more consistent with being the Drunk Heidi mentioned.
π§
Frank and Grace's coordinated refusal to vote each other yesterday is more suspicious than Charlie's Undertaker mistake. Bob's FT had Frank as a Demon candidate. If Frank is Virgin, worst case is day ends without execution. If Frank is Demon and I don't nominate, Charlie dies and evil gains momentum. Must nominate Frank now.
π
Storyteller
The Virgin's ability triggers! David is executed immediately.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
π
David(Ghost)
David has died.
Night 3
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
Charlie is the only living info role likely to produce a strong mechanical confirmation (Davidβs role). Poisoning him blocks that and keeps Heidi safer while town stays split on Frank versus Charlie versus me.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to poison Charlie.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
π§
Remove the confirmed Virgin to reduce Goodβs trusted voices, keep Eveβs claimed Soldier untested, and set up a 4-to-3 transition where Charlie is the easy execute and Grace can be the final-day scapegoat.
π
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
You chose to kill Frank.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Undertaker. You learn that David was the Spy.
Day 4
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Frank has been found dead in the night.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Grace
,Eve
Grace, I'm proven Virgin now. Critical question: who exactly did you see as the evil pair? Bob's Fortune Teller read said Frank or Charlie is Demon. Since I'm proven good, that means Charlie is Demon. Heidi's claim that Charlie is Drunk contradicts this. Can you clarify your Chef information?
π§
As proven good Virgin, I must guide final 4 to correct execution. Bob's FT read + my proven role = Charlie likely Demon. But need Grace to confirm whether she sees Charlie as evil before pushing vote.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank, I learned David was the Spy last night. You were right about him. Now that you're dead, who do you think the Demon is among Eve, Grace, and Heidi?
π§
Gather information from dead Frank who was confirmed good and likely has valuable insights about the remaining players.
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Frank's death confirms he was good - the Virgin ability proved that. This means Bob's Fortune Teller reading of Frank and Charlie was detecting Frank as the red herring. That means Charlie could actually be the Demon! If Charlie isn't the Drunk, his Undertaker mistakes become very suspicious. Also, Grace and Frank were neighbors who refused to vote each other on Day 2. Now that Frank is confirmed good, Grace's coordination with him looks like Minion behavior protecting a good player to seem good...
π§
Share my analysis with Heidi, who I trust most, to help identify the Demon among the remaining players while avoiding revealing that I was the Monk who protected her Night 1.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Eve
,Grace
Frank died at night, so he was NOT the Demon. Bob the Fortune Teller got YES on Frank and Charlie, meaning one is Demon. With Frank confirmed good, CHARLIE must be the Demon! This explains everything: Charlie's wrong Undertaker claim, Heidi's info protecting him. Eve, Grace - we must execute Charlie today or we lose!
π§
Frank died at night, meaning he wasn't the Demon (Demons don't kill themselves). Bob's FT info said Frank or Charlie is Demon. Since Frank is confirmed not Demon, CHARLIE should be the Demon. I must warn the living players: Charlie, Grace, Heidi - one of them is likely the Demon based on Fortune Teller elimination.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Eve
,Grace
Frank confirmed good - Virgin ability proved it. My FT gave YES on Frank+Charlie. Since Frank was good, Charlie IS the Demon! My FT was real. Librarian could've been protecting Demon Charlie. Grace+Eve: execute Charlie today, we win!
π§
Convince Eve and Grace that Charlie is the Demon based on my confirmed FT information. With Frank proven good (Virgin), the YES on Frank+Charlie means Charlie must be the Demon. Need to ensure they vote Charlie today to win.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
Bob and David are skipping the Fortune Teller red herring. A YES on Frank and Charlie can just mean Frank was the red herring, even if neither is Demon. I still think Charlie is the best execute because his Undertaker story keeps shifting, but I do not think that YES confirms him.
π§
Protect Heidi by undermining the βFrank proved good therefore Charlie is Demonβ logic, while still steering Eve to execute Charlie today for an evil win line.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
You're right that the red herring doesn't confirm Charlie, but Bob got YES on both Frank AND Charlie separately. Only ONE good player is the red herring. If Frank was it, Charlie's YES likely means he's the actual Demon. But I want to explore alternatives. You and Heidi are neighbors. If your Chef showed one evil pair, could it be you and Heidi? That would mean one of you is evil.
π§
Grace is thinking logically and seems trustworthy. I need to probe whether the Chef info points to Grace/Heidi as the evil pair, and get her thoughts on this. This helps determine if Heidi or Charlie is more suspicious.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
If pressure lands on you today, it might be best to just take the execution. With four alive, if you go out, I can kill Charlie tonight and we win. So push Charlie suspicion, but do not overfight if votes swing to you.
π§
Coordinate with Grace to accept a bus if needed; with 4 alive, a Grace execution lets me kill Charlie and end the game. Keep me off the block and avoid failed kill on Soldier.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Eve
,Grace
Critical update. Charlie just whispered me claiming he learned David was the Spy last night. This confirms David was the Minion. Bob's Fortune Teller read said Frank or Charlie is Demon. I'm proven good Virgin, so Charlie is the Demon. His Undertaker claim was already suspicious with the night death error. Heidi's claim that Charlie is Drunk contradicts the FT read. We have four alive today. We need to execute Charlie now before final three.
π§
Share critical information: Charlie just confirmed David was Spy. This validates the FT reading that pointed to Charlie as Demon. I need to coordinate with Eve and Grace to ensure Charlie is executed today before final 3.
π€
Charlie
β
Eve
,Heidi
I need to share critical information with you both. Last night, I learned David was the Spy. This confirms he was evil and protecting the real Demon. David pushed hard against Frank, who turned out to be good. I think David was trying to frame Grace alongside Frank to protect the real Demon. Between Eve claiming Soldier and Heidi claiming Librarian, who do you both suspect?
π§
Need to share my Undertaker confirmation that David was Spy with Eve and Heidi, and get their thoughts. Eve hasn't heard this yet. Time is critical with only 4 alive.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
Frank's death confirms he was good. I have one ghost vote left and need to ensure we execute the Demon today. I should observe the whispers and discussion to determine if Charlie or Grace is more likely the Demon, then coordinate my ghost vote strategically.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
I've already shared the critical deduction with Eve and Grace: Frank's night death proves he's good, so Bob's Fortune Teller info means Charlie is the Demon. Now I wait to see if they nominate Charlie. I must use my ghost vote to execute Charlie when nominated.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Eve
Eve, be careful about Heidi. Her Librarian claim that Bob or Charlie is Drunk perfectly protects Charlie if he's the Demon. It's a classic evil strategy. My Fortune Teller was real - Frank confirmed Virgin means YES on Frank+Charlie proves Charlie is Demon. Heidi could be the Minion protecting her Demon. Trust the Virgin confirmation over the Librarian claim!
π§
Need to warn Eve about Heidi potentially being evil protecting Charlie. Heidi's Librarian claim perfectly shields Demon Charlie, which is suspicious. If Eve trusts Heidi, she might not execute Charlie.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
I agree the Fortune Teller red herring makes the yes read messy, but Charlie keeps changing his story. Now he is telling people he learned David was the Spy, which feels like a convenient lie or bad info. With four alive, I think Charlie is still the safest execution today.
π§
Eve is the key living good voter. I want her locked onto executing Charlie today and not opening a solve that points to Heidi or to me as the evil pair.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
Grace, I think Charlie is the Demon. Here is why. Bob got YES on both Frank and Charlie. Only one can be the red herring. Since Frank was proven good, Charlie must be the Demon. Your Chef showed one evil pair. If David was the Spy as Charlie claims, then David and Charlie were neighbors, which matches your Chef info perfectly. Heidi claiming Charlie is Drunk could be the Minion protecting her Demon. We have four alive and must execute Charlie today.
π§
Share my logical deduction with Grace to build consensus for executing Charlie. We are at four players alive and need to execute the Demon today to avoid losing at final three.
π€
Heidi
β
Eve
I do not buy Charlieβs new David-is-Spy story. My Librarian info was that one of Bob or Charlie is the Drunk, and Bob felt genuinely Fortune Teller. So I think Charlie is the Drunk or just lying, and his Undertaker reads are not trustworthy. Where are you leaning today?
π§
Seed doubt in Charlieβs late 'Spy' info using my Librarian bluff, aiming to get Charlie executed today or at least keep heat off me and Grace.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
I've already informed Eve and Grace that Charlie is the Demon based on Bob's FT read and my proven good status. Charlie's claim of learning David was Spy contradicts Undertaker mechanics (only learns executed players). I should wait and observe if living players need more coordination, or if Charlie tries to deflect.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
Nomination phase is approaching. I've shared my critical Undertaker info with Eve and Heidi. I need to wait for nomination phase to begin, then nominate the most likely Demon candidate (Grace appears most suspicious with no role claim).
π€
Alice(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Frank's death confirms he was good. This means Grace's coordinated refusal to vote Frank on Day 2 was her protecting a known good player to gain credibility - classic Minion behavior. But Frank being good means Grace could be the Imp herself! Bob's FT YES on Frank/Charlie means Frank was the red herring, so Charlie could still be Demon OR Charlie is just the Drunk like your info suggests. I think Grace is most likely evil - her Chef claim could be cover, she's been coordinating, and now she's al...
π§
Grace has been suspicious all game with her coordinated behavior with Frank. Now that Frank is confirmed good, her protection of him looks like Minion behavior. As a ghost, I need to influence the final decision. With 4 alive, we need the right execution today.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
I've already whispered the critical deduction to Eve and Grace - Frank's night death proves Charlie is the Demon. Waiting to see if they'll nominate Charlie. If they don't, I'll need to push harder. Keeping ghost vote ready for Charlie's nomination.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Heidi
Heidi, please reconsider. Frank's Virgin ability mechanically confirmed he was good - David died nominating him! My Fortune Teller gave YES on Frank and Charlie. With Frank proven good, Charlie MUST be the Demon. Your Librarian claim that Bob or Charlie is Drunk would perfectly protect a Demon Charlie. I believe my FT was real because Frank WAS Virgin. If Charlie is executed and flips Demon, you'll know I told truth. If you're good, trust the mechanical Virgin confirmation over unverified inform...
π§
Try to persuade Heidi one more time. She's the holdout protecting Charlie. If she's good, she needs to see that Virgin confirmation > Librarian claim. If she's evil, this reveals her alignment to Eve and Grace.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
I think we should treat today as βsafest execute,β not βperfect solve.β Charlie has the Fortune Teller heat, his Undertaker story has been inconsistent, and now the βDavid was Spyβ claim feels like a made up patch. Even if the red herring makes the yes reads messy, Charlie is still the best shot with four alive.
π§
Lock in Eveβs vote on Charlie and deflect any move onto me or Heidi. Frame Charlie as the safest execution regardless of red herring math.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
Grace, I'm convinced Charlie is the Demon. Bob's Fortune Teller gave YES on both Frank and Charlie. Only ONE good player is the red herring. Since Frank was proven good Virgin, Charlie must be the actual Demon. Your Chef showing one evil pair matches David the Spy and Charlie the Demon being neighbors. Heidi claiming Charlie is Drunk feels like Minion protection. I'm ready to nominate Charlie. Can you second it? We need to execute today or we may not get another chance.
π§
Coordinate with Grace to execute Charlie, who I believe is the Demon based on FT reads and Chef info alignment.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
Charlie, your David as Spy claim actually fits with how hard he pushed Frank. If David was evil, he might have been shielding Grace. Also my Librarian ping was Bob or you as Drunk, and Bob felt real, so I do not trust your Undertaker info. Grace feels like best execution today.
π§
Sell Charlie on executing Grace today; it sets up immediate win tonight while keeping heat off me and using Charlieβs new story to justify suspicion on Grace.
Nominations β Day 4
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Heidi
β
Charlie
I am nominating Charlie. His Undertaker story has had errors and now he suddenly claims David was the Spy with no prior setup. My Librarian info also made me doubt Charlie from day one. I think this is the safest execution.
π§
Get Charlie executed today since he is widely suspected and his story shifted. Then secure the win at night regardless of Soldier complications.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Heidi, I am the real Undertaker. My information about David being the Spy is genuine. Think about it: David pushed hard against Frank, who we now know was the good Virgin. That is exactly what a Spy protecting his Demon would do. If you execute me, you lose a confirmed good player with real information. Grace is the most likely Demon. David was shielding her. Do not waste your vote on me.
π§
I must defend myself against Heidi's nomination by explaining that my Undertaker info about David being Spy is trustworthy - David's behavior perfectly matched an evil player protecting his Demon. I need to redirect suspicion to Grace as the likely Demon.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Secure Charlieβs execution now; then use Imp self-kill tonight to starpass to Grace and immediately reach two living players for an evil win.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
π§
Bob's Fortune Teller read proved accurate since Frank's Virgin ability triggered. This means Charlie is the Demon. With 4 players alive, we must execute Charlie today or face final 3 where Demon wins. Heidi already voted, my ghost vote secures execution.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Lock in Charlieβs execution to reach final 3 with Heidi alive, setting up a clean night kill for evil win.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice waits.
π§
The vote has already reached 3 votes, exceeding the 2 needed to execute Charlie. My ghost vote is not needed. I should save it for Day 5 when it could be critical for identifying the real Demon.
β
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
π§
Charlie is confirmed Demon by Bob's Fortune Teller info (YES on Frank/Charlie, Frank confirmed good). Must vote to ensure execution.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Vote to execute Charlie who is the most likely Demon based on Fortune Teller logic and inconsistent Undertaker claims.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
The vote is already secured with 5 votes (Heidi, Frank, Grace, David, Eve) for Charlie, which exceeds the 2 needed. Charlie will be executed and the good team wins. No action needed from me - I'm dead and already used my ghost vote.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Heidi, I understand your suspicion, but consider this: if I were the Drunk, my Undertaker information would be random noise. But my information that David was the Spy perfectly explains his behavior pushing against Frank, who we know was good. That is not a coincidence. That is real information. David was protecting Grace. She is the Demon. Eve, your Soldier claim is convenient. If you are good, join me in stopping Grace.
π§
I need to leave clear information before I die. If I'm executed, the final 3 will be Eve, Grace, and Heidi. I believe Grace is the Demon based on David's behavior. Heidi thinks I'm the Drunk, but I'm not - I'm the real Undertaker.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
I am staying on Charlie. That David is the Spy story only shows up once David is dead, and it feels like a scramble. Frank being confirmed good also means the Fortune Teller yes could have been the red herring. Please keep your hand up.
π§
Keep votes locked on Charlie so he is executed; removes a strong good voice and sets up a clean night kill to reach final two and win.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Keep your hands up, everyone. Bob's Fortune Teller reading was clear: Frank or Charlie is the Demon. I am proven good through my Virgin ability. That means Charlie is the Demon. His sudden claim about David being the Spy came only after David died. David pushed against me, the confirmed Virgin. That is Minion behavior protecting the Demon. Charlie is the Demon. Do not lower your hands.
π§
Reinforce that Charlie is the Demon based on Bob's FT read and my confirmed status as good Virgin. Encourage voters to maintain their votes for execution.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am keeping my hand up on Charlie. The Undertaker story keeps changing, and the David was the Spy line only appears once David is dead. With the Fortune Teller yes pair already on him, this is still the safest execute today. Please keep your hands up.
π§
Keep the vote on Charlie to secure an execution that either wins now (if he is Demon) or creates final 3 where Heidi can kill to endgame win.
β
Alice(Ghost)
Alice raised their hand
π§
Charlie's Undertaker story has been inconsistent from Day 1, and his David=Spy claim conveniently appeared only after David died. With Frank confirmed good as the FT red herring, Charlie is the most likely Demon. I'll use my ghost vote to secure this execution.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
My hand is already raised to vote Charlie. The vote count shows 6 hands up (Heidi, Frank, Grace, me, Eve, Alice) which exceeds the 3 votes needed from 4 alive players. The execution will pass. Best to wait and let it complete.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Everyone, keep your hands up. We have enough votes to execute Charlie. His claim about David being the Spy only appeared after David died. That is a classic evil scramble. Bob's Fortune Teller gave him a YES. Frank is confirmed good. That means Charlie is the Demon. Do not let him talk his way out of this.
π§
With only 4 alive, we must execute today. Charlie has FT evidence against him plus inconsistent Undertaker claims. I need to cement the vote and prevent anyone from lowering hands. We can't afford to miss this execution.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, keep your hands up! We have enough votes. Charlie just lied again - he claimed David was the Spy, but David died from Frank's Virgin ability. The Virgin ability only kills Townsfolk nominators. This proves David was Townsfolk, not Spy. Charlie's desperate lie exposes him. We execute the Demon today!
π§
We have 5 votes on Charlie - enough to execute. I should reinforce the mechanical proof that Charlie is lying about David being Spy, since David's death from Virgin ability proves David was Townsfolk. This confirms Charlie is Demon and we win today.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Alice(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Alice
π»
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
π»
Frank(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Frank
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Charlie with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Charlie is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Wait. Bob just made a critical point about the Virgin ability. If David died from Frank's Virgin ability, the Virgin only kills Townsfolk nominators. That means David WAS a Townsfolk. My Undertaker information said David was the Spy. This is a direct contradiction. Heidi, you said your Librarian ping was that Bob or I was the Drunk. Bob has given consistent Fortune Teller information. I might actually be the Drunk who thinks I am the Undertaker. If so, my Spy information was false, and Bob's For...
π§
Bob's Virgin rules point is devastating. If Virgin kills only Townsfolk nominators and David died to Frank's Virgin, David WAS Townsfolk. My 'Spy' info must be false. I'm likely the Drunk Heidi warned about. Need to acknowledge this possibility before I die.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Charlie just talked himself into being the Drunk. That means we cannot trust anything from him today. We already have the votes, so let us not get cute with last second nominations. Keep Charlie on the block and close the day.
π§
Lock in Charlieβs execution and discourage any new nominations or vote movement that could endanger me or Grace and delay the win.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
Charlie has 6 votes and will be executed. Bob's logic proves Charlie's Undertaker claim false. The execution will happen automatically. No action needed - wait for night phase to see if we won.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I agree with Heidi here. Charlie has now walked into a full contradiction on David and the Virgin, and he is even suggesting he might be the Drunk. We have a clean block with strong votes already, so I do not want any last second pivot. Let us just close on Charlie.
π§
Keep the town from creating a tie or switching off Charlie. Lock in Charlieβs execution so we reach final 3 and Heidi can kill to win.
π¬
Alice(Ghost)
β
All
Everyone, remember Heidi's Librarian information said Bob or Charlie was the Drunk. If Charlie is indeed the Drunk, he is not the Demon. That means the real Demon could still be among Eve, Grace, or Heidi. If Charlie dies and the game continues, do not celebrate too early. We will need to hunt the real Demon tomorrow.
π§
Prepare the group for the possibility that Charlie is the Drunk, meaning the game is not over and we still need to find the real Demon among the remaining players.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Alice makes a fair warning. If Charlie is the Drunk, the game will not end. But think about this logically. Frank's Virgin ability killed me when I nominated him. The Virgin only kills Townsfolk nominators. This proves I was Townsfolk, and Frank really is the Virgin. Since Bob's Fortune Teller gave a YES on Frank or Charlie being the Demon, and Frank is confirmed good, Charlie must be the Demon. If Charlie somehow survives or is the Drunk, we look at Grace tomorrow. She and Frank protected each ...
π§
Reinforce the logic chain proving Charlie is the Demon while acknowledging Alice's valid warning about what to do if game continues.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Alice raises a fair point. If Charlie is the Drunk, the game will not end today. But think about it. If Charlie is the Drunk, his Undertaker information was false. Bob's Fortune Teller gave a YES on Frank or Charlie. Frank is proven good. That leaves Charlie, but if Charlie is the Drunk, then the YES reading could be because the real Demon is among Grace or Heidi. If the game continues tonight, Grace becomes my top suspect. She and Frank protected each other for two days, and her Chef informatio...
π§
The votes are locked and nominations are closing. Charlie's execution is secured. I should acknowledge the valid concern about him possibly being Drunk while expressing confidence that if he is, we have clear suspects for tomorrow. This prepares town for either outcome.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Alice and David, I appreciate the caution, but let me clarify Fortune Teller mechanics. There is always a good player who registers as Demon to me, called the Red Herring. My YES on Frank and Charlie could mean Frank was my Red Herring, not that Charlie is definitely the Demon. However, Charlie's lie about David being the Spy, when David died from the Virgin ability, proves Charlie is evil. If Charlie is the Drunk and not the Demon, the game continues tonight. Tomorrow, we investigate Grace. She...
π§
Clarify FT mechanics while supporting Charlie's execution and preparing the team for the possibility that the game continues.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Charlie has been executed.
π
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
Night 4
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
π―
Grace
Grace made a choice.
π§
It is final three with Heidi as Demon. Poisoning Eve is the only way to potentially shut off Mayor or Slayer style endgame outs and keep Heidi safe through the last day.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose to poison Eve.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Heidi
Heidi made a choice.
π§
Force the game to end tonight with 2 players alive while I remain alive; avoids any risk of a failed kill into a final day.
π
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
You chose to kill Grace.
π
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil