Game Detail
Players
Alice (Undertaker) Bob (Recluse) Charlie (Baron) David (Imp) Eve (Mayor) Frank (Butler) Grace (Drunk) Heidi (Fortune Teller)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 828,777 | 254,743 | $5.0168 |
| Evil | 312,731 | 159,196 | $0.1421 |
Event Transcript
🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
→
Charlie
You are the Minion. The Demon is David.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Minions are: Charlie. Your safe bluffs are: Soldier, Slayer, Monk
📜
Storyteller
→
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Investigator. Either Charlie or Eve is the Poisoner.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
🎯
Heidi
Heidi made choices.
🧠
With no social info yet, start with a wide, neutral pair to generate an early anchor result I can triangulate from on later nights to isolate the Demon or the red herring.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
You chose Bob and Eve. You receive the answer: YES.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Frank
Frank made a choice.
🧠
Choose a nearby master I can easily coordinate with tomorrow so I do not accidentally lose my vote and can support good executions.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You chose Eve to be your master.
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Grace
Hi Alice and Grace. What are you thinking of claiming, and did you get any starting info that points at specific players? I have an info role and I am trying to line up notes quietly before nominations.
🧠
Form a small trusted circle with my neighbors, collect their role/info, and see if their starting info points at Bob or Eve before I reveal my Fortune Teller result.
👤
Frank
→
Eve
,Grace
Hey, quick check in. What are you claiming and do you have any starting info? Also, I might need to follow your lead on voting today, so tell me if you plan to vote on any nomination.
🧠
Collect key claims early and coordinate my vote constraint by softly syncing with Eve, while also getting independent info from Grace for later logic chains.
👤
Charlie
→
David
David, it's Charlie. I'm your Baron minion. We need to get our stories straight. What role are you planning to claim? I can back you up with a good bluff.
🧠
Early coordination with Demon ensures unified deception, prevents accidental exposure, and sets up mutual support to keep him alive.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
,Alice
I am Investigator. My N0 info: either Charlie or Eve is the Poisoner. I would rather not blast it publicly yet. What is your info role and does it touch either of them?
🧠
Share my Investigator ping to a couple likely-good players to coordinate scrutiny on Charlie and Eve, while keeping it out of suspected Eve’s earshot.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Charlie, awesome, you're my Baron. I'll claim Soldier - it's safe and no nightly action to fake. What about you? Maybe Empath since I'm your neighbor? You can say you got 1 or 0 evil on us. Let's make our stories match perfectly.
🧠
Day 1 early coordination with my only minion Charlie (Baron) to pick complementary safe bluffs (Soldier for me). Builds credibility, hides us until we can manipulate nominations.
👤
Alice
→
Heidi
,Grace
I do not have starting info. I am Undertaker, so after an execution I can confirm what role died. I would rather keep that quiet for now. If your Investigator lead is true, executing either Charlie or Eve soon will let me confirm Poisoner. Heidi, what is your info role?
🧠
Quietly coordinate with Heidi and Grace, keep my Undertaker role mostly hidden, and set up an execution that my night info can confirm to catch the Poisoner or expose a liar.
👤
Eve
→
Frank
Hey Frank. I am not getting starting info, so I am happy to just claim Soldier for now. I am leaning toward no execution today unless something really solid comes up. If you need a voting lead, assume I will not vote unless we have a strong case.
🧠
Reply to Frank with a low-risk bluff and set a D1 voting plan, while keeping my real Mayor role hidden and building an ally for later endgame control.
👤
Bob
→
Alice
,Charlie
Hey, quick check in. What role are you claiming and did you get any starting info? Also, have you heard any Outsider pings yet. I am still sorting what to share, but I want to avoid role collisions.
🧠
Get early role and info claims from my neighbors to start building logic chains, while keeping my own Outsider identity hidden to avoid becoming an easy Day 1 execute.
👤
Heidi
→
Alice
,Grace
I am Fortune Teller. Night zero I checked Bob and Eve and got YES, so at least one pings as Demon to me. Remember one good player is a red herring, so it is not conclusive. This overlaps your Eve lead, so I am watching Bob and Eve closely.
🧠
Share my Fortune Teller hit privately to coordinate a safe execution plan with Investigator and Undertaker, while flagging the red herring risk so we do not overcommit.
👤
Frank
→
Grace
Hey Grace, what are you claiming and did you get any starting info? Also, are you leaning toward an execution today or no? I am trying to decide whether to push for a nomination.
🧠
Collect Grace claim and any starting info fast, and see whether town should push an execution despite Eve preferring no-exe.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
Hey Bob, I'm going to claim Empath. No night info yet. No Outsider pings on anyone. You? Alice, what about you?
🧠
Respond to Bob's whisper to start Empath bluff early, match David's Soldier plan, gain credibility without revealing evil. Protects Demon by seeming helpful townie.
👤
Grace
→
Frank
I am Investigator. Night zero I learned either Charlie or Eve is the Poisoner. I prefer we execute one of them today if we can, to get Undertaker confirmation. Also Heidi got a Fortune Teller yes on Bob or Eve. I will vote for a Charlie or Eve nomination.
🧠
Align with Frank on a high-value Day 1 execution plan and share my Investigator lead discreetly, so we can coordinate votes and not let the Poisoner control info roles.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Charlie, great. For your Empath on Bob and me, let's say you got 1 evil neighbor. That makes me look good as Soldier, and we can push Bob as suspicious later. Sound good? What are you seeing in other whispers?
🧠
Solidify our Soldier-Empath story with Charlie now before public claims. Matching neighbor reads build credibility, letting us defend each other and sow doubt elsewhere.
👤
Alice
→
Bob
,Charlie
Hey. I would rather not lock a public claim yet. I am a role that does not get starting info, so nothing pointing at players so far. I have not heard any clear Outsider pings yet. What are you thinking of claiming, and do you have any Outsider or minion info?
🧠
Respond to Bob without outing Undertaker, gather his claim and outsider info, and keep flexibility for later reveal after an execution.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
Hey Alice, quick sync. What are you claiming and do you have any starting info? I am currently claiming Soldier and I am leaning toward no execution today unless someone has a really strong mechanical case.
🧠
Get early info web from Alice, see if there is actionable starting info or role conflicts, and softly set expectation of cautious Day 1 voting while I stay hidden as Mayor.
👤
Bob
→
Charlie
I am not getting starting info either. Quiet heads up: I might be a role that can look evil to info, so if you ever get an evil read involving me, please do not hard lock it without cross checks.
🧠
Protect town from future false evil pings on me while not broadly outing as Recluse; keep Alice in the dark until I trust her more.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
,David
Hey Frank and David. I am trying to quietly line up claims before nominations. What role are you planning to claim, and did you get any starting info that points at specific players? I can share what I have after.
🧠
Gather additional role claims and starting info from players not yet in my trust circle, without outing my Fortune Teller info widely, to build a coherent world before nominations.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
,David
For now I am planning to claim Ravenkeeper, no starting info. What I have heard: Grace says she is Investigator and got that either Charlie or Eve is the Poisoner. Also sounds like you had a Fortune Teller yes involving Bob or Eve. I would lean executing Charlie or Eve today.
🧠
Answer Heidi’s query while spreading Grace’s key Investigator lead and avoiding exposing my Butler vote restriction to a possible Spy.
👤
Charlie
→
David
David, yes to claiming one evil neighbor on you and Bob when my info comes tonight. Bob said he might look evil to info roles, perfect for later suspicion. Alice has no starting info and is holding off claim. Frank whispered to you and Heidi, any read? Alice Grace Heidi seem tight group.
🧠
Coordinate Demon bluff details, share whisper intel on groups chatting David. Ensures stories align, positions us to manipulate Bob via Empath lie.
👤
Grace
→
David
Hi David, I am Investigator. Night zero I got that either Charlie or Eve is the Poisoner. Heidi is Fortune Teller and got a yes on Bob or Eve. I want to execute Charlie or Eve today for Undertaker confirmation. What are you claiming?
🧠
Loop David in so we can coordinate a Charlie or Eve execution and compare claims fast before nominations; builds a trusted voting bloc with Alice and Heidi.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Charlie, quick update: Grace just whispered me, claims Investigator with Poisoner on you or Eve. But no Poisoner since you're the Baron Minion! She's Drunk or lying evil. Heidi is Fortune Teller yes on Bob or Eve. Frank Ravenkeeper also pushing you or Eve exec. We stick to Soldier/Empath 1 evil (Bob), deflect to Grace or Eve?
🧠
Update Charlie on Grace's impossible Poisoner claim (no Poisoner in script) so we undermine her credibility together, protect him from exec push by Grace/Frank/Heidi. Reinforce our Soldier/Empath bluffs.
👤
Alice
→
Eve
I am currently keeping my claim flexible, but I am a role with no starting info and I have not heard any solid Outsider pings yet. Why are you leaning no execution today? I feel like an early execution can create useful mechanical info. Who would you execute if we do?
🧠
Probe Eve’s motives and lock in whether she will support an execution. If she resists strongly, that increases her evil equity and guides today’s nomination target.
👤
Eve
→
Alice
I am not anti execution, I just do not want a random one. Day one I would rather spend time getting claims and looking for contradictions. If we get a clean mechanical reason, I will vote. If we must execute, I would pick a low info volunteer, and I will not touch anyone claiming Saint.
🧠
Build trust with Alice without exposing Mayor, encourage claim sharing, and set a safe execution policy that avoids random mis-executes while staying open to a solid mechanical case.
👤
Bob
→
Grace
Hey Grace, quick check: what are you planning to claim, and did you get any starting info (Chef, Investigator, Librarian, Washerwoman)? Also, have you heard any Outsider claims yet? Small note: I might be a player who can look evil to info, so please cross check if I pop up.
🧠
Get starting-info roles to share discreetly and start tracking Outsider count; also pre-warn that I can misregister so info hits on me need cross-checks.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
⚖️
Heidi
→
Eve
I want an execution today. Grace says either Charlie or Eve is the Poisoner, and my Fortune Teller check on Bob and Eve returned YES. That is consistent with Eve being evil or at least worth testing. If Alice is Undertaker, we get strong confirmation.
🧠
We need an execution today. Eve is implicated by both Investigator info and my Fortune Teller ping set, so executing her maximizes chance to hit evil and yields follow-up confirmation via Undertaker.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
I nominated Eve on overlapping Investigator and Fortune Teller suspicion; voting her through gives us either a win, removal of Poisoner, or strong Undertaker confirmation for tomorrow.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Vote to execute the most information-dense suspect. Eve overlaps two starting infos; Undertaker confirmation will sharply narrow evil and guide day 2.
💬
Frank
→
All
Before I do anything, I need Eve to say if she is voting here. I am the Butler, so I can only vote if my master votes too, and my master is Eve.
🧠
Ask Eve to state whether she is voting so I can comply with Butler rule and coordinate an informed, legal vote.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Voting yes executes Eve (likely good), tests Grace/Heidi claims. Exposes Grace's impossible Poisoner info via UT tomorrow, disrupts town info chain, protects minion Charlie from pressure. Builds my Soldier credibility by supporting day1 exec/info.
💬
Bob
→
All
Hold on, I am not voting yet. Eve, can you please say your role claim and whether you are voting here. Also, Heidi, a Fortune Teller yes can be a red herring, and some players can misregister, so we should not insta execute without a claim.
🧠
I am the deciding fourth vote. I should slow the execution until Eve speaks, and remind town that Fortune Teller yes is not conclusive, especially with players that can misregister.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
David (Demon) voted yes on Eve; join to execute likely good Eve early. Builds trust via coordination, thins herd, aligns with deflecting per his whisper while protecting him.
💬
Alice
→
All
Eve, please say clearly what your role claim is, and whether you are voting on yourself here. Frank needs it for the Butler restriction, and I want a clean record before we decide.
🧠
Get Eve to state claim and whether she is voting so Frank’s Butler info resolves and the town can make an informed call before the vote locks in.
💬
Eve
→
All
I will be very clear. My role claim is Soldier, and I am not voting to execute myself here. A Fortune Teller yes on me can easily be a red herring, so do not treat this as a slam dunk. Grace and Heidi, please say exactly what led you to ‘Eve or Charlie’ and why it is stronger than just gathering claims today.
🧠
Stop a low-information day one execution on me, deny Frank’s Butler vote, and force accusers to give specifics or back off so we can gather claims.
💬
Heidi
→
All
My ‘Eve or Charlie’ comes from overlap. Grace has Charlie or Eve as Poisoner, and my Fortune Teller check on Bob and Eve was yes. Red herring is possible, but executing you today tests both info sets and lets Alice confirm your claim tonight.
🧠
Answer Eve’s challenge, justify keeping the vote, and set a clear next step for tomorrow depending on the outcome.
💬
Grace
→
All
I am Investigator. Night zero I learned either Charlie or Eve is the Poisoner. That is why I want one of you executed early, so Alice can confirm and we stop poisoning if it is real. Your Soldier claim does not resolve my info, so I am fine executing you today, then re evaluate tomorrow.
🧠
Answer Eve, justify why an early Eve execution is a strong test that advances the info puzzle, and keep votes focused so we get a Day one execution.
💬
Frank
→
All
Okay, for the record, Eve is my master and she is not voting, so I cannot vote here even if I wanted to. Town, please remember Eve did not self vote. Alice, if you are the Undertaker, this execution will give us a clean check tonight.
🧠
State my voting restriction clearly, lock in public record about Eve not voting, and set up tomorrow’s deduction from Undertaker or vote patterns.
💬
David
→
All
Everyone, I need to speak up. I am the Soldier. Eve just double-claimed my role, which means she is lying. Let's execute her and see what the Undertaker learns tonight.
🧠
Claim Soldier (safe bluff), expose Eve double-claim lie (Soldier impossible). Push Bob/Alice votes for 4+ yes. Exec good (likely Drunk), clears my bluff, sows chaos on Grace/Heidi logic chain.
💬
Bob
→
All
Given the double Soldier, I am fine executing Eve as a test today. Tomorrow, if we have an Undertaker, please confirm what Eve was. If Eve shows Soldier, then David is very suspect, and Grace’s info points hard at Charlie.
🧠
Steer town to treat this as a test execution with clear follow-up logic, while keeping my Recluse misregister in mind and avoiding overcommitting if info proves false.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Everyone, I am the Empath, and my neighbors David and Bob have one evil between them. David is clearly the good Soldier here. Eve is double-claiming Soldier so she is lying and evil. Grace's Poisoner claim cannot be right with no Poisoner in play. We should execute Eve today and see what Alice learns tonight if she is Undertaker.
🧠
Push Eve execution: reinforces my Empath/David Soldier, kills good player, tests Grace/Heidi info without risking Demon. With 4 votes already, sway Bob/Alice to secure 5+ for hammer.
✋
Alice
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Day one execution gives my Undertaker a hard role confirmation, resolves the double Soldier claim, and tests Investigator and Fortune Teller info. I want this to go through.
💬
Eve
→
All
I need to correct something. I was bluffing Soldier. My real claim is Mayor. Please do not execute me. If I die and an Undertaker sees Mayor, then David is lying, and Grace’s Investigator info is false or poisoned. Also look hard at Bob with the Fortune Teller yes.
🧠
I need to stop this execution if possible; if not, I must leave a clear mechanical roadmap so tomorrow town uses Undertaker info to catch the liars and find the Demon.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Eve with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Eve is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Eve going from Soldier to Mayor feels like scrambling under heat. I still think executing Eve is the best test today with my Fortune Teller yes and Grace’s Investigator. If anyone thinks it is definitely Charlie instead, nominate Charlie now so we can compare votes, but I do not want to end day one with no execution.
🧠
Push town to keep pressure on Eve as best current execute, while inviting an alternate nomination on Charlie if others strongly believe it, maximizing info from the Undertaker check.
💬
Grace
→
All
I want to keep it simple. My info is still that either Eve or Charlie is the Poisoner, and Eve’s claim shift from Soldier to Mayor makes me comfortable leaving her on the block. If Eve dies today, Alice can confirm tonight, and tomorrow we decide whether we must execute Charlie next.
🧠
Keep the town focused on a clean D1 execution that tests my Investigator ping and Heidi’s Fortune Teller info, avoiding last-minute chaos and a missed execution.
💬
Frank
→
All
I do not want to create a tie by nominating Charlie right now. I think we should leave Eve on the block and get a clean execution for information. Alice, can you confirm if you are Undertaker, and Charlie, please restate your Empath neighbors clearly.
🧠
Steer town away from creating a tie and secure a clean Day 1 execution that tests multiple info lines while my Butler vote restriction prevents me voting today.
💬
David
→
All
Eve flipping from Soldier to Mayor looks like desperate lying under pressure. We need this execution today for Undertaker confirmation tonight. It tests Grace and Heidi's info too. Let's do it and see what we learn.
🧠
Reinforce Eve exec: day1 info exec of good Eve debunks Grace (drunk), creates good suspicion chaos tomorrow. Protects Charlie, advances evil to confuse town logic chains.
💬
Bob
→
All
Before this locks in, I should say I am the Recluse. I can register as evil or even as the Demon to things like Fortune Teller and Empath, so reads that hit me might be fake. I am still fine executing Eve for the claim swap plus Grace info, but please do not clear David off Charlie’s read.
🧠
I am implicated by FT and Empath info due to Recluse misregister. Publicly claiming Recluse prevents mis-execution on me and helps town interpret today’s execution result correctly.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Eve flipping from Soldier to Mayor just screams desperate lying. David is the real Soldier, and my Empath read of one evil between him and Bob holds up with Bob's Recluse claim. Grace's Poisoner info can't be right. Let's execute Eve and get the Undertaker info tonight.
🧠
Push Eve execution with 1 tick left. Her flip screams lie. Kills likely good, tests claims. My Empath protects Demon David as good Soldier. No Poisoner as Baron Minion disrupts Grace logic.
💬
Alice
→
All
I am not going to hard confirm my exact role right now, but I will say this: today’s execution will give us strong mechanical information tomorrow, so I want a clean single execution, no tie. Let Eve go through, and tomorrow morning I will report what I learned from the executed role.
🧠
Keep execution on Eve for clean Undertaker data without creating a tie, while not hard-confirming my role too early but setting expectations for tomorrow's info.
💬
Eve
→
All
I bluffed Soldier so I would not get sniped night one. I am the Mayor. If you still execute me, fine, but when Alice confirms Mayor tomorrow, David is caught lying and Grace’s info is wrong or poisoned. If you want a better test today, nominate Charlie or David.
🧠
Try to avert my execution by redirecting to a better suspect, but if I die, leave a clear mechanical roadmap for tomorrow based on Mayor confirmation.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Eve has been executed.
💀
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
David
David made a choice.
🧠
Killing Alice silences likely Undertaker report on Eve, invalidates Grace/Heidi logic chains tomorrow, protects Minion Charlie & lets Soldier/Empath bluffs dominate.
💀
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
You chose to kill Alice.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
🎯
Heidi
Heidi made choices.
🧠
Avoid testing Bob because Recluse or my red herring could contaminate results. Check the two players most central to the day one push so tomorrow’s discussion has a clear mechanical anchor.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
You chose Charlie and Grace. You receive the answer: NO.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Frank
Frank made a choice.
🧠
I need a master who will reliably vote so I am not locked out of key executions. Heidi is active and likely to vote, keeping my vote available on Day 2.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You chose Heidi to be your master.
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Alice has been found dead in the night.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Grace
,Heidi
I was the Undertaker. Night one, before I died, I learned that Eve was the Poisoner. That means the minion is gone and nobody has been poisoned. Heidi, your Fortune Teller yes on Bob and Eve now strongly suggests Bob is the Demon, unless Bob is your red herring.
🧠
Share my Undertaker result privately with the two players whose info it most clarifies, so town can form a coherent world before nominations.
👤
Bob
→
Grace
,Heidi
Hey, what did Alice tell you in that whisper just now? Did she confirm what Eve was when executed, or share any other hard info? Reminder I am Recluse, so I can misregister to things like Empath or Fortune Teller.
🧠
Get Alice’s reported info (likely Undertaker-style) from Grace/Heidi to confirm Eve’s role and reconcile Investigator/Empath/FT worlds before nominations.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Grace
,Heidi
Can you both share what you have for today, and what Alice told you in that whisper? Also Heidi, did you get a new Fortune Teller result last night, and who did you pick? I am worried my execution never got confirmed if Alice was the Undertaker.
🧠
Get current info from the two strongest info sources, align on contradictions, and set a clear nomination target for today without wasting my only ghost vote.
👤
Charlie
→
David
David, I'm your Baron minion bluffing Empath - my read on you and Bob is one evil, which is you. Grace claims Investigator saw me or Eve as Poisoner, but Eve flipped good. She's lying. Let's push to nominate her today and back each other's claims.
🧠
Whisper Demon to align on story: support each other's claims (Empath/Soldier), nominate Grace (her Invest frames me), vote protectively. Sow doubt on HAG group.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
,David
Alice whispered me she was Undertaker and learned Eve was the Poisoner. That confirms my Investigator ping was right and the Poisoner is dead. Heidi, your Fortune Teller yes on Bob and Eve now points very hard to Bob as the Demon.
🧠
Share Undertaker confirmation privately with trusted players, align on executing Bob, and avoid feeding the likely Demon information.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Charlie, thanks for the heads up. Grace is full of it - claiming Alice confirmed Eve as Poisoner when executions don't reveal roles, and Alice died before learning Day 1 exec properly. She's trying to team up with Heidi against Bob. Let's nominate her today and stick to Soldier and Empath claims.
🧠
Reinforce alliance with Charlie, agree to nominate Grace as lying Investigator framing him. Counter Grace's whisper to me/Heidi by privately planning attack, keeping Demon hidden while pitting goods against each other.
👤
Heidi
→
David
,Grace
Alice told me she was Undertaker and saw Eve was the Poisoner. If true, my Fortune Teller yes on Bob and Eve now heavily points to Bob as Demon. If Bob somehow is my red herring, then Demon is basically David or Frank since Charlie and Grace were a no. I want Bob on the block today.
🧠
Coordinate with trusted good players to push a decisive Bob execution today, while planning the immediate fallback if Bob is not the Demon.
👤
Frank
→
Alice(Ghost)
,Grace
Alice, can you tell me your exact role and what you learned about Eve after the execution? I am the Butler: yesterday my master was Eve so I could not vote; today my master is Heidi so I only vote if Heidi votes.
🧠
Get Alice’s mechanical info about Eve (likely Undertaker/Ravenkeeper) and loop in Grace so town has a shared anchor before nominations.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Frank
Yes. I was the Undertaker. After Eve was executed day one, I learned last night that Eve was the Poisoner. So the minion is dead and there should be no poisoning. Heidi’s Fortune Teller yes on Bob and Eve now mostly points to Bob as Demon, unless Bob is her red herring.
🧠
Answer Frank’s question to align voting. If minion is dead, we can focus nominations on Demon candidates and use Butler voting constraint efficiently.
👤
Bob
→
Grace
,Heidi
Can you tell me exactly what Alice whispered about Eve’s executed role, and anything Eve whispered too? That info should pretty much solve today.
🧠
Need Alice's Undertaker-style info about Eve to lock a world. That determines whether to execute Charlie (if Investigator true) or hunt Scarlet Woman/new Demon.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Bob
Can you both give me your exact role claim details and anything you learned today? Frank: who was your master each night, and did you vote on Day one? Bob: why did you claim Recluse late, and do you think that explains Heidi’s Fortune Teller yes on you with me?
🧠
Get detailed timelines from the two outsider-claimers to resolve the impossible role count and identify at least one liar who is likely evil before nominations.
👤
Charlie
→
Bob
,Frank
Hey Bob and Frank, Grace's Investigator claim said me or Eve was Poisoner night zero, but Eve executed and flipped good. That's impossible, she's lying. My Empath read on David and Bob was one evil, and David seems legit Soldier. Heidi's Fortune Teller yes on you two is weird too. We should nominate Grace.
🧠
Whisper Bob/Frank (likely good) to expose Grace lie (Eve good not Poisoner), build nom support for her using my Empath claim. Protects David, progresses to execute good player.
👤
Grace
→
Charlie
,Frank
Alice whispered me she was Undertaker and saw Eve was the Poisoner, so Poisoner is gone. Charlie, what was your Empath result last night and are you still confident it is one evil between Bob and David? Frank, can you vote with Heidi today so we can put Bob on the block?
🧠
Gather Charlie’s current Empath read and secure Frank’s vote mechanics so we can build a majority on the best candidate (likely Bob) for today’s execution.
👤
David
→
Grace
,Heidi
Hey Grace and Heidi, Alice was killed by the Demon on Night 1, and the Demon acts first at night. The Undertaker wakes up after that, so Alice died before she could learn anything about Eve's execution. She could not have known Eve was the Poisoner. That means you two are lying about what she whispered to you. That's really suspicious.
🧠
Expose the mechanical flaw in Grace/Heidi's Alice UT story to discredit them as liars/evil. Breaks their logic chain on Bob, sows doubt, redirects heat to Grace for nomination. Reinforces my Soldier/Charlie Empath good team vs Grace evil.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
,Charlie
David has a point: if Alice died Night 1 she would not wake as Undertaker, so her ‘Eve was Poisoner’ is not mechanical proof. Still, my Fortune Teller has Bob and Eve yes, and Charlie and Grace no, so Demon is in Bob, David, or Frank if I am sober. Can we align on what to push publicly and who to execute today?
🧠
Coordinate with Grace and Charlie: concede the Undertaker timing issue, keep focus on mechanical set of Demon candidates, and plan public messaging plus today’s execution target.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
,Grace
Alice told me she was Undertaker and saw Eve as the Poisoner last night. So minion is dead and there should be no poisoning now. That makes Grace Investigator “Charlie or Eve is Poisoner” actually consistent. Main solve is Demon among Bob and David if we trust Charlie Empath. Heidi, I can only vote if you vote today.
🧠
Share Alice UT info that Eve was Poisoner, clear Grace’s Investigator consistency, and coordinate with Heidi so I can vote; push town toward a decisive Bob-vs-David solve.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
I was the Undertaker. Night one, after Eve was executed, I learned Eve was the Poisoner. So the minion is dead and there should be no poisoning. With that, Heidi’s Fortune Teller yes on Bob and Eve points hard at Bob as Demon unless Bob is her red herring.
🧠
Get my confirmed Undertaker info to the players who will drive nominations, so town consolidates on executing Bob and avoids chasing dead minion worlds.
👤
Bob
→
Grace
,Heidi
We are close to noms. Please send me the exact wording of what Alice whispered about Eve’s executed character, plus anything Eve told you. If Alice confirmed Eve’s role that should set today’s execution.
🧠
Get the exact Alice and Eve whisper contents from Grace and Heidi now; that is the only potential hard mechanical info on Eve’s executed character and will drive today’s nomination.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Grace
,Heidi
Quickly, what did Alice tell you in her whisper, and did she confirm my role from Undertaker? Heidi, who did you pick last night and what was your exact Fortune Teller result? Grace, any new info or who do you most suspect right now?
🧠
Get latest hard info from Heidi and Grace before nominations: FT result, Investigator followup, and what Alice whispered. Then steer town toward the best execution using my ghost vote.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace
,Frank
Grace, my Empath read last night on David and Bob was one evil, and I am still confident. But your Investigator claim has you or Eve as Poisoner night zero. Eve flipped to Mayor, which is good, so she was not the Poisoner. That makes your claim impossible. Alice saying Undertaker saw Poisoner is also wrong.
🧠
Grace directly asked my Empath read; confirming it while exposing her busted claim (Eve good) sows doubt in Frank, pressures Grace, builds my credibility as Empath before nomination to execute her.
👤
Grace
→
Heidi
,Charlie
David is right that if Alice died in the night, Undertaker would not wake, so we cannot treat her Poisoner confirm as proof. But my Investigator still makes Eve or Charlie Poisoner, and Heidi had yes on Bob plus Eve. Charlie, are you still on one evil between Bob and David from last night, and any reason you think Eve could not be Poisoner?
🧠
Align with Heidi and Charlie on acknowledging the Undertaker timing issue, but still converge on the best execution today (likely Bob) using Investigator, FT, and Empath overlap.
👤
David
→
Bob
,Frank
Hey Bob and Frank, if Alice is right that Eve was the Poisoner, then Minion dead, Charlie's Empath read means the Demon is Bob since I'm Soldier good. But Bob's Recluse explains Heidi's yes read, so Alice must be wrong. That makes Grace suspicious too. Let's nominate Grace today.
🧠
Undermine Alice/Grace confirmation by highlighting it forces Bob Demon (which we oppose), push nom Grace per Charlie coord to eliminate Invest threat on our Minion without targeting Bob yet.
👤
Heidi
→
Grace
,Charlie
We should treat Alice’s ‘Undertaker saw Eve Poisoner after dying’ as not hard proof, since she died Night one. My real info: Fortune Teller Night zero Bob and Eve was yes, Night one Charlie and Grace was no. So if I am sober, Demon is Bob, or Bob is my red herring and Demon is David or Frank. I want Bob executed today; if not Demon, we pivot hard to David, then Frank.
🧠
Align with Grace and Charlie on a clear public plan: discount Alice’s impossible Undertaker confirmation, share my FT results, and push Bob execution today with contingency if he is red herring.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
Heidi, can you tell me your Night one Fortune Teller check as well? If Alice really saw Eve as Poisoner, then Grace looks consistent, and your yes on Bob plus Charlie’s Empath makes Bob the best demon shot. I can only vote if you vote today.
🧠
Heidi is my master today, so aligning my vote with hers matters. Getting her N1 FT info and nudging her to vote on the best candidate (Bob) helps town converge before nominations.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Town, I am Alice, the Undertaker. Night one after Eve was executed, I learned Eve was the Poisoner. So the minion should be dead and there should be no ongoing poisoning. With that, Heidi’s Fortune Teller yes on Bob and Eve points hard at Bob as the Demon unless Bob is her red herring. I want a Bob nomination today, and Heidi please vote if you do so Frank can vote too.
🧠
Get town to use the strongest mechanical info chain and coordinate a Bob nomination and votes while reminding Frank’s Butler constraint so votes aren’t wasted.
⚖️
Charlie
→
Grace
Grace, your Investigator claim said me or Eve was Poisoner night zero. Eve executed and was Mayor, good Townsfolk, not Poisoner. That's impossible - you're lying. Alice's Undertaker claim is mechanically wrong too; she died night one before waking for Eve's execution. Let's execute Grace.
🧠
Grace's Investigator claim directly contradicted by Eve's good flip. Nominating her exposes her lie, sows chaos, eliminates good player pushing Demon alternatives. Protects David while progressing execution.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Please do not vote Grace here. Charlie is treating Eve claiming Mayor as confirmed, but we do not get role reveals. My Undertaker result said Eve was the Poisoner, which would make Grace’s Investigator claim make sense. I would rather save this execution for Bob.
🧠
Prevent town from spending votes executing a likely good player based on a shaky contradiction, and keep focus on higher-probability Demon candidate Bob.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Raise hand to vote Grace per my nomination. Consistency as Empath bluffer. Removes disruptive good player, sows doubt in Heidi/Alice, keeps focus off David.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Support Charlie's nomination of Grace as liar. Her claim conflicts mechanically with no reveals and Alice info. Voting yes pushes execution, removes good player, disrupts town logic chaining to Bob.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I am not voting Grace. My Fortune Teller got a no on Charlie and Grace last night, so if I am sober neither of them is the Demon. My only yes so far included Bob, so I want a Bob execution path instead.
🧠
Stop town from executing a player I have a mechanical reason to think is not the Demon, and steer toward executing Bob based on my Fortune Teller info.
💬
Frank
→
All
I am not voting Grace here. Also, I am the Butler and my master today is Heidi, so I can only vote if Heidi votes. Heidi is not voting, and she has a no on Charlie and Grace, so I want us to save this and push a Bob nomination instead.
🧠
Stop a likely wasteful Grace execution, align town on Bob path, and clarify my Butler voting restriction so people don’t misread my lack of vote.
💬
Grace
→
All
Town, please do not vote me here. We do not get role reveals, so Eve claiming Mayor does not make my Investigator impossible. Charlie is treating that as confirmed to force a mis-execution. Save the execution for Bob today, or David if Bob cannot be nominated.
🧠
Stop a bad execution on me by reminding town there are no role reveals and my Investigator is still live info; keep today’s execution for Bob/David line instead of burning it on a Townsfolk.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
I am not spending my ghost vote on Grace. This case hinges on role reveals we do not get. Heidi has a Fortune Teller no on Charlie and Grace, and Bob remains the only yes and best Demon lead. Please do not execute Grace; push Bob next.
🧠
As dead Mayor with one ghost vote, I should not spend it on a weak case. I want town to avoid executing Grace and instead consolidate on Bob (or David) today or tomorrow.
💬
Bob
→
All
I am not voting Grace. This case leans on treating Eve’s claim like a role reveal, and we do not get those. Also remember I am the Recluse, so Fortune Teller yes on me can be my misregistration. If we want an execution today, I would rather we use it on me or Charlie after this vote.
🧠
Avoid an execution based on faulty assumptions and keep pressure on the strongest Demon candidates while reminding town my Recluse can explain Fortune Teller yes.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
I am not using my ghost vote on Grace. We only need to stop this from reaching three, then immediately pivot to a Bob nomination. Please save ghost votes for late game, and do not let Charlie frame this on role reveals we do not get.
🧠
Preserve my single ghost vote and steer town away from a low-information execution, keeping pressure on the strongest Demon candidate, Bob.
↩️
Charlie
Charlie lowered their hand
🧠
Vote fails regardless (no 3rd hand). Lowering gains trust as flexible 'town', encourages post-vote Bob nom/execution removing good player while protecting David.
💬
David
→
All
Town, Alice died night one to the Demon kill, which happens before Undertaker wakes for the day's execution. She couldn't have learned Eve's role. Her claim is mechanically impossible. Charlie is right - Grace's Investigator doesn't work without role reveals. Vote for Grace.
🧠
Keep hand up, publicly dismantle Alice UT impossibility (died before wake), reaffirm Grace lying per Charlie. Sway any undecided to vote Grace (need 2 more), eliminate good info source before night kill.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Please do not vote Grace. I got a Fortune Teller no on Charlie and Grace last night, so this execution is very unlikely to hit the Demon. Save the day execution for a Bob nomination next. If Bob is not it, we pivot to David.
🧠
Stop a mis-execution on Grace and steer town to the strongest mechanical Demon candidate, Bob, using my Fortune Teller results as anchor.
💬
Frank
→
All
Careful on the Undertaker timing point. Undertaker acts before the Demon kill at night, so Alice can learn the executed role and then die later that same night. So her claim is not mechanically impossible. I still do not want Grace executed; pivot to a Bob nomination.
🧠
Stop a likely misexecution on Grace by correcting Undertaker timing and refocusing town on Bob as best Demon lead.
💬
Grace
→
All
Do not let David sell you a fake mechanical point. The Undertaker wakes before the Demon kill, so Alice can learn the executed role and still die that same night. Also, Eve claiming Mayor was not a role reveal, so it does not make my Investigator impossible. Let this vote fail, then nominate Bob.
🧠
Prevent a mis-execution on me by correcting rules logic and refocusing town on the best Demon candidate (Bob), preserving today’s execution for a high-value target.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Town, do not execute Grace here. Undertaker can learn the executed role and still die that same night, so Alice is not mechanically impossible. This Grace case depends on treating Eve’s claim like a role reveal, which it was not. After this vote, please nominate Bob, and Heidi, if we do Bob, you should vote so Frank can too.
🧠
Prevent a wasted execution on Grace, correct the Undertaker timing confusion, and steer living players to nominate Bob next while conserving my ghost vote for endgame.
💬
Bob
→
All
Do not let this Grace vote pass. The only solid mechanical tension is about me, because I can misregister. After this vote, please nominate me or Bob, and Heidi should vote so Frank can. Also, Undertaker can learn the executed role and still die that night.
🧠
Prevent a low-info execution on Grace, keep votes for a stronger test nomination on me or Bob/Charlie, and correct the Undertaker timing misconception so town reasons mechanically.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Grace did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Grace did not receive enough votes (1/3).
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Okay, Grace vote failed. We have time for one more nomination. Someone living please nominate Bob now. Heidi, if Bob is up, please vote so Frank can vote too. If Bob survives or is not executed today, we are wasting our best lead.
🧠
Use last nomination window to force a Bob nomination while aligning Heidi and Frank’s votes; keep town focused on strongest mechanical lead and avoid wasted executions.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Town, do not nominate Bob. Heidi's Fortune Teller yes on him and Eve is suspicious since Eve was good, and Bob claims Recluse which misregisters. My Empath read on David and Bob was one evil, and it has to be David. Alice's Undertaker works timing-wise. Someone nominate David now before night.
🧠
Grace vote failed safely. Town pivoting to Bob (likely good Recluse). Disrupt with Empath claim pinning David as the evil read, question Heidi's info, encourage David nom to shift suspicion to Demon while protecting others.
⚖️
David
→
Bob
Town, the push on Bob from Heidi's Fortune Teller yes and Alice/Grace info is strong. If Bob is Recluse good, it explains the read, but we need to test it. Charlie's Empath on me and Bob has other explanations like poisoning. Let's nominate Bob now and execute to progress.
🧠
Nominate Bob to force execution of likely good player (Recluse), disrupting good logic chains on me/Grace. Protects me from Charlie's push while town wastes exec. Heidi/Frank vote in, likely passes.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Alice(Ghost)
Alice raised their hand
🧠
Bob is our best current Demon candidate and this vote may be close. Using my ghost vote now maximizes chance to execute Bob and either win or gain strong info for tomorrow.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Voting yes on Bob (David's nom) supports Demon's deflection play, likely executes good Recluse (fits +2 Outsiders), wastes town execution protecting David to final 2. My prior anti-Bob speak inconsistent but ghosts can't nom/vote much.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Raise to execute Bob (3rd vote). Kills good player (Recluse fits), reduces to 5 alive. Supports Charlie's apparent push, disrupts town FT logic chain targeting us. Safe for Demon survival.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
We need to use today’s execution on the strongest lead. Voting Bob both progresses the game and enables Frank’s Butler vote, maximizing odds to execute the Demon or clear a key suspect.
✋
Frank
Frank raised their hand
🧠
Heidi is voting, so I am allowed to vote. I want Bob executed as the best current demon lead and to maximize information going into night if he survives.
✋
Grace
Grace raised their hand
🧠
Bob is the best current Demon candidate and this execution resolves multiple info tensions. I will add my vote to secure the kill and progress the game.
⌛
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
🧠
Enough votes are already raised to execute Bob; my ghost vote adds no value and is better saved for the endgame when it can swing a tight vote.
💬
Bob
→
All
Before you lock this in, remember my Recluse can explain Heidi’s yes and any evil pings on me. If you execute me anyway, please make tomorrow about David versus Charlie, not about re-litigating my read. I think David is the best Demon candidate if I flip out good here.
🧠
Try to halt or soften my execution by giving a clear next-day plan and highlighting that my Recluse explains the tells; if I die, ensure town pivots onto the most likely Demon.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Keep your hands up on Bob. This is our best mechanical lead, and Recluse is exactly the kind of claim we should test by execution. If Bob is not the Demon, then tomorrow we hard pivot to resolving David versus Charlie, and we also recheck Heidi’s Fortune Teller world.
🧠
Keep votes on Bob to test the strongest mechanical lead; set a clear next-step plan if Bob is not the Demon so town stays coordinated.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Town, lower your hands now! If Bob is good Recluse, it explains Heidi's yes perfectly, and my Empath read means David is the evil one. Executing Bob just hands the win to David tomorrow. Fail this vote and nominate David instead!
🧠
Highlight Empath logic chain proving David evil if Bob good Recluse. Urge fail vote to prevent town executing Demon Day 3. Reduces pressure on David, buys night kill.
💬
David
→
All
Town, keep your hands up on Bob. Charlie voted yes on Grace earlier, raised for Bob, now suddenly wants everyone to lower and push me? That's a huge flip and looks desperate to save the real problem. His Empath could easily be poisoned or wrong. Heidi's Fortune Teller yes is our strongest lead. Execute Bob to test it.
🧠
Counter Charlie's call to lower by highlighting his flip-flop suspicion. Lock in majority vote on Bob to execute a likely good player, reducing alive count and setting up favorable David/Charlie fake conflict for tomorrow while we kill a threat at night.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Keep your hands up on Bob. Even if Bob is good Recluse, executing him is still the cleanest test of my Fortune Teller yes and clears a huge question mark. I got a no on Charlie and Grace, so swapping to Grace now makes no sense. If Bob is not the Demon, we pivot hard to David versus Charlie tomorrow.
🧠
Lock in the Bob execution as the strongest mechanical lead; if he survives, we lose tempo. Set clear plan to pivot to David versus Charlie tomorrow if Bob is not the Demon.
💬
Frank
→
All
Keep hands up on Bob. This is the cleanest test of the Fortune Teller yes and the Recluse claim. If Bob is not the Demon, tomorrow we hard focus on resolving David versus Charlie and recheck Heidi’s world.
🧠
Lock in the Bob execution while my master Heidi is voting, and set a clear plan for tomorrow based on the outcome so town stays coordinated.
💬
Grace
→
All
Keep your hands up on Bob. Either we hit the Demon and win, or we remove the biggest source of noise with the Recluse claim. If Bob is not the Demon, tomorrow is a clean David versus Charlie solve, but we need this test first.
🧠
Lock in the Bob execution as the best test and stop a late swing that would waste the day. Set a clear plan for tomorrow if Bob is not the Demon.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Town, keep your hands up on Bob. We already have enough votes, so I am not spending my ghost vote here. If Bob is not the Demon, tomorrow we hard solve David versus Charlie and re evaluate Heidi’s Fortune Teller world.
🧠
Reinforce keeping votes on Bob without wasting my single ghost vote, and set a clear plan for tomorrow if Bob is not the Demon.
💬
Bob
→
All
If I die today and the game continues, please do not spend all day arguing about my Fortune Teller ping. Make tomorrow a clean David versus Charlie solve, and Heidi please check David with a player who is not me.
🧠
Vote already has enough. I will set a clear plan for tomorrow so town does not spiral around my Recluse misregistration and instead resolves David versus Charlie with fresh info.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Alice(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Alice
🗳️
New execution leader: Bob with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Bob is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Town, do not start any new nominations now. We have Bob on six and this is the cleanest test on the board. If the game does not end, tomorrow we hard focus on David versus Charlie, and Heidi should check those two with someone who is not Bob.
🧠
Lock in Bob execution and discourage a last-second counter-nomination that could tie. Set a clear tomorrow plan based on whether game ends, without relying on my dead Undertaker.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Town, keep your hands up on Bob. Sorry about my flip earlier - Heidi's Fortune Teller is the strongest lead for a clean test. Tomorrow, if Bob is good Recluse fooling the read, pivot to David versus me, but Grace's Investigator tagging me as Poisoner doesn't add up and smells like a lie.
🧠
Agree to Bob exec to rebuild trust after flip callout, look team player. Seeds Grace as liar for tomorrow nom/vote split, diverting from David/me solve to protect Demon.
💬
David
→
All
Town, keep your hands up on Bob. No new nominations. This is the clean test. If he is good Recluse, tomorrow we solve David versus Charlie using Grace's Investigator on Charlie as Poisoner and Heidi's no on him. My Soldier claim holds up.
🧠
Reinforce Bob exec to remove good, reach 5p. Set up tomorrow discrediting Charlie w/ Grace Invest while defending my Soldier claim, protecting Demon survival.
💬
Heidi
→
All
No more nominations, please. If the game does not end after Bob, my Fortune Teller no on Charlie and Grace means the Demon is not either of them. Tomorrow we focus hard on David versus Frank, and tonight I will check David and Frank if I am alive.
🧠
Lock in the plan: do not create a tie. Set up tomorrow’s solve and my next Fortune Teller check (David and Frank) if the game continues.
💬
Frank
→
All
No more nominations. Let Bob go through as the clean test. Also, for clarity, I am the Butler, and Heidi was my master today, so my vote only ever follows hers. If the game continues, tomorrow we hard resolve David versus Charlie, and Heidi please check those two with someone not Bob.
🧠
Lock in the execution on Bob, prevent last-second chaos, and set a clean, mechanical plan for tomorrow while reducing suspicion on me by clarifying my Butler status.
💬
Grace
→
All
No more nominations. Let Bob go through. If the game does not end, remember my Investigator point is still that either Charlie or Eve was the Poisoner, and Eve is already dead. Heidi, tonight please check Charlie and David with someone not Bob, and tomorrow we hard solve that pair.
🧠
Prevent last second chaos and set a clear, mechanically grounded plan for tomorrow that centers my Investigator info and Heidi’s next Fortune Teller check.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
No more nominations. Let Bob go through on six. If the game continues, do not auto clear anyone off one Fortune Teller no. Tomorrow we hard resolve David versus Charlie first, and Heidi please check David with someone who is not Bob.
🧠
Lock in the current execution, discourage last-minute chaos, and set a clear decision tree for tomorrow while preserving dead votes and avoiding being steered by a single info source.
💬
Bob
→
All
If the game does not end, I am good Recluse and my death should remove the noise. Please save ghost votes. Tonight, Heidi, check David with someone who is not me. Charlie, your Empath tonight on David should be huge if poisoning is gone. Tomorrow hard solve David versus Charlie.
🧠
I am about to be executed; give town a clean plan for tomorrow using post-Poisoner info, prevent wasted ghost votes, and focus the solve on David versus Charlie with Heidi checks not involving me.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Bob has been executed.
💀
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
David
David made a choice.
🧠
Grace's Invest directly threatens Charlie as Poisoner post-Eve death. Killing her silences this, lets Heidi's FT no stand, misdirects town from Minion while they focus David vs Charlie/Frank. Down to 4, survive day to win path.
💀
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
You chose to kill Grace.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
🎯
Heidi
Heidi made choices.
🧠
With only Charlie, David, and Frank alive besides me, checking David and Frank gives the cleanest fork: YES implicates that pair; NO points to Charlie, while matching my public plan.
📜
Storyteller
→
Heidi
You chose David and Frank. You receive the answer: YES.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Frank
Frank made a choice.
🧠
Final 4 going to final 3: I must keep my ability from locking me out of the decisive vote. David is least likely to die tonight across likely worlds, so I choose him.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You chose David to be your master.
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Grace has been found dead in the night.
👤
Heidi
→
Charlie
,Frank
Hey, quick FT info: I got NO on Charlie plus Grace earlier, and I got YES on David plus Frank last night. Charlie, what have your Empath reads been each night, especially last night with Bob dead? Frank, who is your Butler master now, and has it changed?
🧠
Get Charlie’s latest Empath numbers and Frank’s Butler-master story to cross-check against my Fortune Teller pings and decide who to push in nominations.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
David
Private: I am actually the Recluse. So Heidi getting YES on Bob plus Eve could just be me misregistering, and Charlie’s Empath 1 between you and me could also just be me. If Alice UT is true (Eve was Poisoner), I lean demon in Heidi or Charlie more than you.
🧠
Privately tell David I am the Recluse so he can correctly interpret Empath and FT results, narrowing the demon candidate for today’s nomination.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Heidi
,Charlie
Quick check in. I am the dead Mayor with my ghost vote still. Do you have any new info since yesterday, like later Empath numbers or more Fortune Teller checks? Right now Heidi’s NO on Charlie and Grace makes me lean Demon is David, but I want to confirm before noms.
🧠
Get updated info from Heidi and Charlie and align on a single execution target for today; use my ghost vote only if it secures the Demon’s execution.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Grace is dead, perfect, her Invest claim on you and Eve was probably a lie. Heidi's Fortune Teller yes on Bob Eve makes sense if Bob was Recluse registering evil, and her no on you Grace clears you. But why no on you Grace if Grace evil? Something off with her. Your Empath 1 was Bob. We should push to nominate Heidi.
🧠
Reinforce coord w/Charlie: Grace dead good, blame Heidi's FT inconsistencies (despite B Recluse poss). Align to nom Heidi, protect each other to final 3+.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
,Charlie
My Butler master today is David, chosen last night, so I can only vote if David votes too. Heidi, your YES on David plus me worries me since I am good; could mean David is Demon or I am your red herring. Charlie, what was your Empath number last night with Bob dead?
🧠
Answer their questions, lock in my Butler voting constraint, and pressure-test the David vs Heidi vs Charlie triangle using Charlie’s Empath and Heidi’s FT YES result.
👤
Charlie
→
Frank
,Heidi
Hey Frank and Heidi, my Empath reads: first night with Bob and David, one evil, and that was Bob. Last night, only David as neighbor, zero evil, so David is good. Heidi, your yes on David and Frank does not add up then. Your earlier yes on Bob and Eve was probably Bob as Recluse registering as Demon or your good fake player. A second yes means you are lying since there is only one fake. Frank, you seem like a good Butler. We should nominate Heidi today.
🧠
Claim Empath N1:1 (Bob), N2:0 (D good). Heidi's two yeses contradict single FT fake (Bob Recluse), paints her liar. Frank/D chain votes Heidi, exec her safely w/4 alive.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Heidi
,David
Reminder from my real role: Investigator saw either Charlie or Eve is the Poisoner. Since Eve is dead, unless my info was corrupted, Charlie is the only living Poisoner candidate. Heidi, what was your Night two Fortune Teller result, and who is your red herring?
🧠
Push my Investigator info to drive today’s execution toward Charlie, and request Heidi’s latest FT result to confirm demon world before I spend my ghost vote.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Heidi
,David
I am Alice, the Undertaker. I died night one, so I only could have had a day one read, and I do not have anything confirmed for day two Bob. Based on Grace’s Investigator and your Fortune Teller no on Charlie, I suspect Charlie is minion, and the Demon is more likely David or Frank.
🧠
Get my role and a compact suspect map to key alive players before nominations, so they coordinate on the right execution at four alive.
👤
Heidi
→
Eve(Ghost)
,Alice(Ghost)
My FT so far: Bob plus Eve was yes, Charlie plus Grace was no, David plus Frank was yes. If I am sober, Charlie cannot be Demon, so it is David or Frank. Grace Investigator also points to Charlie as Poisoner, so he may be framing. Can you help push noms onto David or Frank, not me?
🧠
Get dead good players aligned: my FT mechanically narrows Demon to David or Frank if sober. Ask them to help steer town away from executing me and toward the correct demon today.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Heidi
,Charlie
I am the Recluse. Can you both restate your exact night info in order. Heidi, your Fortune Teller checks each night. Charlie, your Empath numbers each night. My misregister could explain earlier results, so we need the full timeline today.
🧠
Get precise FT and Empath timelines while disclosing I am Recluse, so earlier YES and Empath 1 can be explained. Use contradictions to pick the correct execution target today.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Frank
I am the dead Mayor with my ghost vote. Heidi FT has YES on David plus Frank, and NO on Charlie plus Grace. That points to Demon in David or Frank. Can we agree to nominate David first today, then Frank if needed? Any hard reason not to?
🧠
Align the alive players on a clean nomination order (David then Frank) so we use votes efficiently and don’t waste today. Preserve my ghost vote for the decisive execution.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Grace's Invest claim points to you as Poisoner, but Heidi's FT cleared you and her. That's a contradiction unless Heidi is lying. Ghosts are buying Grace's info, probably poisoned. Let's nominate Heidi today and say you're planning to FT check me and Frank next. Sound good?
🧠
Coordinate with minion Charlie to nominate Heidi next. Frame her FT as inconsistent with Grace Invest (no on evil C), sow doubt on ghosts pushing C. Keeps me safe, targets info role.
👤
Frank
→
Alice(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
Alice, did you actually have Undertaker? If so, what did you see for Eve on day one and Bob on day two? Bob, any last info on who looks evil to you, and do you think Heidi or David is lying?
🧠
Get hard mechanical info from dead players (Undertaker read, Bob recluse behavior) to decide whether to execute David or Heidi today.
👤
Charlie
→
David
,Frank
David and Frank, Heidi's Fortune Teller yes on you two contradicts my Empath last night: only David left as neighbor, zero evil, so David good. Her earlier yes on Bob and Eve plus this yes is too many for one Demon and one fake. She must be lying. Let's nominate her today.
🧠
Whisper to David/Frank to align on nominating Heidi: her FT contradicts my reliable Empath clearing David (N2=0). Sow doubt on her multiple YESes, protect Demon by executing her before she poisons noms.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Alice(Ghost)
,Heidi
Alice, if you really had Undertaker info, what did you learn from Eve’s Day one execution before you died? Heidi, what was your Night two Fortune Teller pick and result, and who do you think your red herring is? At four alive we must hit the Demon today.
🧠
Get Alice’s hard night info and Heidi’s latest Fortune Teller result; then push the group to realize final four means we must execute the Demon today, not the Poisoner test.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Heidi
I did get one Undertaker read before dying. Night one I saw Eve was Soldier. That means David cannot be Soldier. With your Fortune Teller yes on David and Frank, I think we should execute David today. Charlie still fits Poisoner from Grace’s Investigator.
🧠
Share my only Undertaker data to break the Soldier claim conflict and focus today’s execution onto the likeliest Demon, David, while keeping Frank and Heidi aligned.
👤
Heidi
→
Frank
,Eve(Ghost)
Frank, if your Butler master is David and he will not vote, you may be unable to vote him. Please do not let that block an execution today. Eve, please be ready to use your ghost vote on whichever of David or Frank we push, and press Charlie on why he wants me out first.
🧠
Coordinate with Frank and Eve to secure enough votes today (including a ghost vote) to execute the Demon, and to counter Charlie’s push to execute me.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Alice(Ghost)
One key thing: I am really the Recluse, so unless there is a Baron, Frank cannot also be a Butler. Alice, please say exactly what your Undertaker saw for Eve on day one, and what it saw for me on day two.
🧠
Align ghosts on key mechanical point: Outsider count. Also get Alice to state her Undertaker read on my execution; it may reveal if my Recluse misregistered, helping narrow the Demon.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Heidi
,Charlie
I agree the solve is David or Frank. Given only one Outsider, I lean Frank really is Butler and demon is David. I will spend my ghost vote on David if he is up. If David lives, we pivot to Frank immediately.
🧠
Coordinate the alive good players to nominate David first and ensure voting is not blocked by Butler constraints; commit my ghost vote to secure the execution.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie, agree completely - Heidi's yes on me and Frank contradicts your Empath zero on me alone last night. Too many positives for her FT. She's lying, probably the Demon. Let's nominate her today and execute. I'm Soldier, safe from night kill.
🧠
Heidi's FT contradictions mounting per Charlie. Coordinate with Charlie/Frank to nom Heidi now, eliminate her as top Demon suspect, reach final 3 with me+Charlie alive.
👤
Frank
→
Heidi
,Charlie
Alice told me she was the Undertaker and saw Eve was the Soldier. That means David cannot be the Soldier. Also Grace said the Poisoner was Charlie or Eve, so with Eve being Soldier that points at Charlie. I think we should nominate David first today.
🧠
Push a mechanical solve: Undertaker saw Eve was Soldier, so David’s Soldier claim is false. Combine with Grace’s Investigator to pressure Charlie. Aim town at the most consistent demon candidate before nominations.
👤
Charlie
→
David
,Frank
David and Frank, ignore Alice and Grace ghosts - Grace's Invest on me and Eve was debunked by Heidi's own FT no on us, so she lied or poisoned. Alice claiming Eve Soldier to contradict David's claim smells like ghost disruption. Heidi's two yeses too many - Bob was Recluse explaining first, second is lie. My Empath N2 David alone zero evil. Let's all nominate Heidi now before phase ends.
🧠
Counter Frank's push on David by discrediting ghosts and reinforcing Heidi as liar with too many FT yeses contradicting my Empath clear on David. Align David/Frank to nom Heidi before nomination phase, protecting Demon.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Heidi
,Frank
Heidi, what was your Night two Fortune Teller pick and result, and who is your red herring? If my Investigator is true, Charlie is the Poisoner not the Demon, so Demon is you, David, or Frank. Frank, where are you leaning, and will you be able to vote today with your Butler master?
🧠
Get Heidi’s latest FT result and align with Frank on voting plan so my single ghost vote lands on the best Demon candidate in final four.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Charlie
Confirming: I am Undertaker, died night one so I only got one read. Night one I learned Eve was Soldier. I have zero info on Bob. This means David cannot be Soldier. With four alive, I strongly prefer executing David today; if not Demon, then execute Frank next.
🧠
Clarify my only Undertaker info and force a clean mechanical contradiction on David’s Soldier claim, steering nominations toward David (then Frank if needed).
Nominations — Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Public reminder: I am the Investigator. I saw either Charlie or Eve is the Poisoner. Eve is dead, so unless my info was corrupted, Charlie is the Poisoner and not the Demon. That means the Demon is in Heidi, David, or Frank. Heidi, please say your latest Fortune Teller result now.
🧠
Get key info public and force a nomination among the three Demon candidates, while warning that Charlie is the likely minion if my Investigator is reliable.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Two quick points. One, I am the Recluse, so unless there is a Baron, Frank cannot also be the Butler. Two, Alice died night one, so she cannot have seen Bob with Undertaker on night two. Heidi, please give your full Fortune Teller checks in order, and then someone should nominate either Heidi or David today.
🧠
Publicly highlight the two key mechanical pressure points (Outsider count and Undertaker timing) to force a nomination between Heidi and David and conserve my ghost vote for a decisive execution.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Public: I am the dead Mayor, and I still have my one ghost vote. Heidi has two Fortune Teller yes results that both point to David or Frank, and a no that clears Charlie if she is sober. I want Charlie or Heidi to nominate David now, and I will vote for it. If David survives, we immediately pivot to Frank.
🧠
Use my public voice plus my unused ghost vote to focus town on executing David first, then Frank, while flagging Outsider-count and Undertaker-timing inconsistencies to stop a misexec on Heidi/Charlie.
⚖️
Heidi
→
David
At four alive we must hit Demon today. My Fortune Teller got NO on Charlie plus Grace, and YES on David plus Frank. Grace’s Investigator points to Charlie as Poisoner, so Charlie defending David tracks. I think David is the Demon.
🧠
At four alive, we must execute the Demon today or lose tonight. My FT and the Investigator solve point to David as the most likely Demon; nominating forces a decisive vote.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
✋
Grace(Ghost)
Grace raised their hand
🧠
It is final chance at four alive; if we miss an execution we lose tonight. David is the strongest mechanical suspect from Fortune Teller and social play, so I will spend my ghost vote.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Hold on before you lock this in. Heidi, you only should have two Fortune Teller checks by day three, but we have heard three results. Also if I am the Recluse, Frank being the Butler suggests extra Outsiders. Please reconcile that before voting David through.
🧠
I want to stop an immediate losing execute if David is good, by flagging the strongest mechanical contradictions and pushing a pivot to Heidi or Frank if votes are not clearly there.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Careful: at four alive, a wrong execution loses us the game next night. I am not spending my ghost vote until Heidi clearly lists her Fortune Teller checks in order and explains how there are three results by day three. If that is not clean, let this vote fail and we go to night.
🧠
Stop a potentially game-losing execution at four alive until Heidi reconciles her Fortune Teller history; preserve my ghost vote for a final, confident kill.
✋
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
We need an execution at four alive; my FT worlds and Grace’s Investigator most strongly converge on David as Demon. My vote ensures David is executed, and if correct we win immediately.
💬
David
→
All
Heidi, you have claimed three Fortune Teller results, but there have only been two nights so far. That is impossible. Bob is right to question that. Plus Charlie's Empath read on me last night was zero evil. And your own FT no on Charlie and Grace contradicts her Investigator claim. Do not execute me.
🧠
Highlight Heidi's impossible 3 FT claims (only 2 nights) + contradictions to fail my execution vote. Charlie won't vote yes per private coord. Survive to night kill.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Reminder: I died night one, so I only ever got one Undertaker read. I saw Eve was the Soldier, unless I was poisoned. That means David cannot be Soldier. Also David, you just said Charlie’s Empath was zero, but Charlie has been saying one. I am fine executing David here.
🧠
Steer the live vote by highlighting the strongest mechanical contradiction and keeping pressure on David, while acknowledging possible poisoning so town doesn’t get derailed by FT count.
💬
Frank
→
All
Hold on. I am the Butler and my master is David today, so I can only vote if David votes. Heidi, please list your Fortune Teller checks in order by night, because three results by day three does not add up. If that is not clean, I do not want us executing today.
🧠
I want to slow this vote unless Heidi’s FT timeline is coherent, because at four alive a wrong execution likely loses. Also I must remind town of my Butler voting restriction.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Heidi, you claimed three Fortune Teller results but there have only been two nights so far. That is impossible. Bob is right to call it out. My Empath read on David alone last night was zero evil. Do not execute him.
🧠
Publicly expose Heidi's impossible 3 FT claims & reinforce Empath clear on David to fail this vote & protect Demon. Phase ends soon; sway Frank/Eve/Bob ghosts.
↩️
Grace(Ghost)
Grace lowered their hand
🧠
At four alive, a wrong execution ends the game. The table is mid-dispute about Fortune Teller timing; I should not spend my only ghost vote to execute David without clean, consistent info.
✋
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
🧠
At four alive we likely must execute today. David has the most contradictions and is central to multiple worlds; I will spend my ghost vote to push this execution through.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone pause. Heidi, list your Fortune Teller picks by night, in order, and the exact yes or no. If you cannot do that cleanly, we should not execute David on this vote. Lower hands and we pivot to Frank or Heidi instead.
🧠
Stop a potentially game-losing execution based on contradictory info. Force Heidi to reconcile her Fortune Teller checks; if not, direct town to target Frank/Heidi instead of David and save my ghost vote.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I can list it cleanly. Night zero, before day one, I checked Bob and Eve and got yes. Night one I checked Charlie and Grace and got no. Night two I checked David and Frank and got yes. That is three nights by day three. I still want David executed on this vote.
🧠
Clear up the night-count confusion and restate my exact Fortune Teller info so town keeps the vote focused on David (or at least David versus Frank) instead of derailing onto me.
💬
David
→
All
Heidi, your night zero yes on Bob and Eve was the false positive since neither was demon. Night two yes on me and Frank, plus Charlie's empath zero on me last night, means Frank is the demon. Why nominate me instead of him? That makes no sense. Everyone, fail this vote and nominate Frank next.
🧠
Highlight Heidi's nom contradiction with her own FT+Empath logic pointing to Frank. Sow doubt, fail my exec vote (only 2 yes so far), position for Heidi/Frank nom next tick to kill good player.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Night zero Fortune Teller is normal, so three checks by day three is fine. My Undertaker saw Eve was the Soldier, so David cannot also be Soldier. Fortune Teller has a yes on David and Frank, so one of them is very likely evil. I would vote David through.
🧠
Push living players to treat Heidi’s three FT results as mechanically possible, weigh my UT confirmation against David’s Soldier claim, and secure the David execution rather than risk a no-exec loss.
💬
Frank
→
All
Bob, please pull your ghost vote for a second. If David is not the demon, we lose tonight. Heidi’s yes on David and me could just be me as the red herring. I would rather fail this vote and have David or Charlie nominate Heidi next.
🧠
Stop an irreversible misexecution if town is not confident. Preserve Bob’s ghost vote and push a safer pivot to Heidi or a no-exec plan if uncertainty is high.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Heidi, your yes on David and Frank, but my Empath last night saw zero evil on David alone. That means Frank is the problem in your pair. Why nominate David instead? And three yes/no results make sense, but too convenient. Everyone, fail this vote and nominate Frank or Heidi next. Do not execute David.
🧠
Speak to highlight Heidi's suspicious nom of David despite my clear read on him, encourage failing vote to pivot to Heidi/Frank. Prevent Demon exec at 4 alive, no backup.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
🗳️
New execution leader: David with 2 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 2 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
We cannot afford a wrong execution at four alive. Charlie or David, please nominate Frank now. I will spend my ghost vote on Frank to force a tie so nobody dies today, and Heidi gets one more Fortune Teller check tonight.
🧠
We are at four alive where a wrong execution likely loses. I want to prevent a risky David execution by forcing a tie via a Frank nomination, buying one more night of info to solve.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Mechanically, if Heidi is real Fortune Teller and the red herring was Bob or Eve, the demon is either David or Frank. At four alive, a wrong execution loses tonight. Charlie or David, please nominate Frank and aim for a tie so we get one more night of info.
🧠
At four alive, executing the wrong player loses after the night kill. Push the alive players to nominate Frank and create a tie, buying one more night to resolve David versus Frank safely.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Please do not let a two vote execution decide the game at four alive. Someone, Charlie or David, nominate Frank right now so we can force a tie and get to tomorrow. If Frank is nominated, I am prepared to use my ghost vote to stop David dying today.
🧠
At 4 alive, a wrong execution ends the game. Push for a second nomination to force a tie or shift the block, buying one more night/day to solve David vs Frank vs Heidi.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I do not want a tie here. At four alive, if we do not execute, the demon gets a free kill and I am the obvious target, so we gain no new Fortune Teller info. My reads still say the demon is in David or Frank, and David is already on the block, so I want David to die today.
🧠
Stop the tie plan and push town to commit to an execution, ideally David, because a tie likely results in my death and no new FT info, giving evil the final three.
⚖️
David
→
Frank
Heidi's Fortune Teller yes on David and Frank means one evil, but Charlie's Empath saw zero evil on me last night. That points to Frank as the demon. Everyone talked about nominating Frank for a tie or better. Let's execute him instead.
🧠
Nom Frank to surpass/tie my 2 votes (ghosts promised votes on him), prevent my exec as Demon. Kills good Frank or ties for night kill Grace already done, Heidi N3 info useless if we survive.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 3 votes needed for execution or 2 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
I am not spending my ghost vote on Frank here. If Alice is right that Undertaker saw Eve was the Soldier, then David cannot be Soldier and that is our strongest mechanical lead. I would rather we keep David on the block than risk executing Frank and losing outright.
🧠
Steer town away from a risky Frank execution at four alive and let the strongest mechanical suspect, David, remain executed; conserve my ghost vote for final day if needed.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Heidi, if your Fortune Teller has a yes on David and Frank, and Charlie saw zero on David last night, the clean play is to execute Frank. Please vote Frank so it is three. If you will not, at least let it tie so David does not die on only two.
🧠
Push alive voters to put votes on Frank. Best case we execute Frank as demon; fallback is a tie so David does not die on only two votes, avoiding an immediate loss.
✋
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
🧠
Use my ghost vote to prevent a low-vote execution on David and either execute Frank if consensus forms or force a tie so we get one more night and a clearer final three.
💬
Heidi
→
All
I am not voting Frank here. If Grace was a real Investigator, then Charlie is the Poisoner, so his Empath zero does not clear David at all. My Fortune Teller says the demon is in David or Frank, and David is already on the block. Please do not tie this.
🧠
I think Charlie is likely Poisoner from Grace’s info, so his Empath does not clear David. I will not add votes to Frank, and I want others to avoid tying so David is executed.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Vote Frank to reach 2-3 votes (me+Charlie+Eve?), tie/surpass my 2 preventing exec. Exec good player, 3 left w/ evil majority; night kill Heidi wins.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, please slow down. At four alive, a wrong execution loses tonight, and we are not certain. I would prefer we hold this at a tie so nobody dies today, then reassess tomorrow after the night kill. Do not add a third vote here unless you are sure.
🧠
Steer town away from a potentially game-losing execution at four alive by encouraging a tie/no-execution, since we lack near-certain demon ID.
💬
Frank
→
All
Please do not put a third vote on me. If I die today at four alive, we almost certainly lose tonight. David is my Butler master and he voted, so I could vote, but I am not. Let this stay a tie so nobody dies today.
🧠
Prevent a third vote that would execute me and likely hand evil the game tonight; push town toward a tie/no-exec and a clearer solve tomorrow.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Support Demon David by executing Frank (likely good Butler), surpass David's votes with 3rd vote. Leaves 3 players with both evils alive; town likely misexec tomorrow.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Charlie, you are the deciding third hand here. Frank’s Butler claim does not fit unless we have extra Outsiders, which would usually mean a Baron, not a Poisoner. If you are not absolutely sure Frank is the demon, pull your hand for a tie and no execution.
🧠
Influence the final votes: emphasize the strongest mechanical contradiction (outsider count vs Butler) and push the table to commit only if confident, ideally keeping votes steady or forcing a tie.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Charlie, if you are not completely sure Frank is the demon, please pull your hand so this stays a tie and nobody dies today. With four alive, a wrong execution just loses tonight. We can go to three alive and solve tomorrow with one more night of info.
🧠
At four alive, a wrong execution ends the game. Since only one world supports executing Frank, push for a tie unless players are fully certain.
↩️
Eve(Ghost)
Eve lowered their hand
🧠
At four alive, any wrong execution likely ends the game tonight. Removing my ghost vote makes Frank tie David so nobody dies today and we get one more night to solve.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Charlie, please pull your hand. Grace’s info makes it very plausible you are the Poisoner, so your Empath zero does not clear David at all. If we force a tie, I likely die tonight and we gain nothing. Keep David on the block.
🧠
Try to stop the tie by persuading Charlie to lower his hand so David remains executed today, which is our best shot given FT pair and possible Poisoner corrupting Empath.
💬
David
→
All
Charlie, do not pull your hand. Your Empath zero evil on me clears me completely. Heidi's Fortune Teller yes on me and Frank means Frank is the demon. Heidi, if Grace Invest is real, Charlie might be Poisoner, but that does not change your yes pair pointing to Frank. Everyone, vote Frank through or tie this so nobody good dies today.
🧠
Urge Charlie keep hand up on Frank. Reinforce logic: Empath clears me, FT yes pair = Frank Demon. Prevent Charlie pulling (Heidi pressure). Push exec Frank (good dies) or tie (night kill). Avoid my solo exec.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Charlie, please keep your hand up so this stays a tie and David does not die on two. Heidi, please do not add a third vote on Frank. With four alive and this much uncertainty, a tie is the safest play and we solve at three tomorrow.
🧠
Lock in the 2-2 tie by keeping Charlie’s hand up and stopping any third vote on Frank, preventing a likely losing execution at four alive.
💬
Frank
→
All
Charlie, please keep your hand up so this stays a tie. Do not put a third vote on me. If we execute wrong at four alive we probably lose tonight, so let us take the tie and solve tomorrow.
🧠
Avoid a likely losing execution on me at four alive; encourage maintaining the tie so we reach final three with more info and a clearer solve.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Everyone, listen. My Empath read was zero evil on David last night, completely clearing him. Heidi's Fortune Teller yes on David and Frank means Frank is the demon. We should execute Frank. At worst, tie it so nobody good dies today, but Frank is evil.
🧠
Push votes on Frank to execute him (good) or tie (safe no-exec), preventing David's execution. Reinforce Empath clear + FT yes logic to counter Heidi/ghosts urging lower hand.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Tie for majority! Current leader was 4. Now no one.
📜
Storyteller
The vote for Frank ties with the previous leader. No one is currently on the block.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, please stop nominating. At four alive, a wrong execution loses tonight. My Investigator point at Charlie means his Empath zero cannot clear David. Let us take no execution, go to three alive, then decide with one more night of info.
🧠
Prevent a risky execution at four alive. Push for no further nominations so we go to night, reach three alive, then use remaining info and votes to execute the most likely Demon.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, important rules point: David and Frank have already been nominated today, so we cannot put either of them on the block again. That means any execution now is either Charlie or Heidi, basically a blind guess. I think we should stop nominations and take no execution, then tomorrow we can execute David or Frank. Heidi, tonight please check Charlie with David or Charlie with Frank to create an overlap solve.
🧠
Town cannot execute David or Frank today because they were already nominated. I want to prevent a low-info execution of Charlie or Heidi and set up a clear Fortune Teller overlap check for tomorrow.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, I strongly want no more nominations. We cannot execute David or Frank today, so any execution is basically a blind guess on Charlie or Heidi and likely loses. Heidi, tonight please Fortune Teller Charlie with David, or Charlie with Frank, to help us choose between David and Frank tomorrow.
🧠
We cannot execute David or Frank again today, so any execution is a near-blind shot on Charlie or Heidi. Pushing no-execution preserves chances to solve at final three and avoids an immediate loss.
💬
Heidi
→
All
We cannot execute David or Frank again today, so any execution now is a blind guess and likely loses. I want no more nominations and no execution. If there is a Monk, please protect me tonight. I will check Charlie with David tonight to try to hard solve David versus Frank.
🧠
Prevent a losing blind execution today, try to secure protection so I live for a decisive Fortune Teller check that solves David versus Frank tomorrow.
💬
David
→
All
Charlie, since we cannot nominate Frank or me again today, please nominate Heidi. Her Fortune Teller claims do not fully align with Grace's Investigator information, and she is pushing to execute me even with your Empath zero on me. We need to test Heidi now.
🧠
Push minion Charlie to nom/execute Heidi (FT threat) per our coord to blame her/Grace. No exec or wrong exec today good, but killing info role best. Last tick to influence.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Please do not nominate Heidi or Charlie. We cannot execute David or Frank again today, so any execution now is basically a coin flip and likely loses. Let us take no execution, get Heidi’s Fortune Teller check tonight, then decide between David and Frank tomorrow.
🧠
Steer town away from a forced blind execution on Heidi or Charlie, which likely loses at 4 alive, and prioritize getting one more night of Fortune Teller info to solve David versus Frank.
💬
Frank
→
All
I agree with the ghosts here. We cannot execute David or me again today, so nominating Heidi or Charlie is basically a coin flip and likely just loses. Please, no more nominations. Heidi, tonight check Charlie with David like you said, and we solve tomorrow.
🧠
Prevent a forced coin-flip execution of Heidi or Charlie today. Preserve win chances by taking no execution and using Heidi’s FT check to decide between David and me tomorrow.
⚖️
Charlie
→
Heidi
Heidi, your Fortune Teller yes on David and Frank, but my Empath zero evil on David clears him. That means Frank should be evil, yet you keep pushing David despite the clear. Your claims do not align well. We need to execute you to test.
🧠
Protect Demon David by nominating Heidi (likely good). Can't renom D/F, so exec H reduces to 3 alive (me+D+F), Demon kills F tomorrow, win at 2.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 3 votes needed for execution or 2 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
I am not using my ghost vote here. Please do not execute Heidi today. We cannot safely solve between Heidi and Charlie right now, and my Investigator points at Charlie being the Poisoner. Let this fail so we get no execution and one more night of Fortune Teller info.
🧠
Prevent a high-variance execution at four alive, preserve the Fortune Teller check, and avoid spending my only ghost vote unless it is for the final winning push.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Please do not vote Heidi here. We cannot execute David or Frank again today, so killing Heidi or Charlie is basically a coin flip and we likely lose tonight. Let this fail for no execution, then tomorrow we execute David or Frank after Heidi gets one more Fortune Teller check.
🧠
I cannot vote. I want living players to avoid a blind Heidi or Charlie execution at four alive and instead take no execution, get one more Fortune Teller check, then decide between David and Frank tomorrow.
✋
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
🧠
At four alive, we need an execution that can remove Demon or Minion; otherwise we risk final three with two evil. Heidi is a plausible evil anchor and this vote may be decisive.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Please do not vote me here. We cannot execute David or Frank today, so this is a coin flip that likely just loses. I am the Fortune Teller and I will use my check tonight on Charlie with David to help solve David versus Frank tomorrow.
🧠
Stop town from executing me on a forced coin flip. Push for no execution so I can use Fortune Teller tonight to create a decisive check for tomorrow.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Raise to vote yes Heidi exec. With Eve yes, my vote, Charlie likely yes=3. Exec good Heidi, N3 kill Frank, 2 evil left=win. Tie/no-exec risks N3 kill on me.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Do not vote Heidi. We cannot execute David or Frank again today, so killing Heidi or Charlie is basically a blind guess and likely loses tonight. Let this nomination fail so Heidi gets one more Fortune Teller check, then tomorrow we decide between David and Frank.
🧠
Stop an accidental execution on Heidi. Preserve the Fortune Teller check and avoid a forced blind guess at four alive, which likely hands evil the win.
💬
Frank
→
All
Please do not put a third vote on Heidi. David is my Butler master today so I could vote, but I am not. This is a coin flip at four alive, and we cannot even execute David or me today. Let this fail and take no execution.
🧠
Prevent the third vote that would execute Heidi on a low-confidence read, preserving the no-execution plan and enabling one more Fortune Teller check to solve David versus Frank tomorrow.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Raise hand for 3rd vote on Heidi (with D+Eve). Exec her (good), 3 alive C/D/F. D kills F N3, win at 2 evil. Tie/no-exec risks D death tomorrow.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Eve, please do not spend your ghost vote on Heidi. If that is a ghost vote, it is probably game losing for good. David and Charlie, I strongly recommend you do not vote either. Let this fail so we get no execution and one more Fortune Teller check tonight.
🧠
Stop Heidi reaching 3 votes by persuading Eve to save her ghost vote and others to keep hands down, aiming for no execution and one more FT check.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Eve, please do not spend your ghost vote on Heidi. Charlie and David, if you are good, please do not vote here. We cannot execute David or Frank today, so executing Heidi is a blind guess that likely loses. Let this fail and go to night.
🧠
Try to prevent a game-losing execution by persuading at least one of Eve, Charlie, or David not to vote, ensuring the Heidi nomination fails and we go to night.
↩️
Eve(Ghost)
Eve lowered their hand
🧠
I must retract to avoid spending my only ghost vote and accidentally executing Heidi, which is likely losing at four alive. No-execution gives one more night of info and better odds to kill the Demon tomorrow.
💬
Heidi
→
All
David, if you are good, please lower your hand. We cannot execute you or Frank today, so killing me here is just a blind guess and usually loses. Take no execution, then tomorrow we execute David or Frank with one more Fortune Teller check.
🧠
Stop this execution by getting David to lower his hand. Preserve no-exec line at four alive so I can gain one more Fortune Teller read and we can execute correctly tomorrow.
↩️
David
David lowered their hand
🧠
Lowering builds my good Soldier credibility, isolates Charlie's sus push, ensures no exec. Night kill Heidi (FT threat), down to CDF; day4 manipulate as trusted good vs Frank.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Charlie, please lower your hand. We cannot execute David or Frank today, so killing Heidi is just a blind guess. Let this fail and take no execution, then Heidi gets one more check and we decide tomorrow.
🧠
Prevent a likely game-losing execution on Heidi by persuading remaining voters to keep it under 3 and go to night for one more info check.
💬
Frank
→
All
Charlie, please lower your hand. Executing Heidi today is a blind guess and we cannot execute David or me anyway. Let this fail, take no execution, and then Heidi gets one more check and we decide between David and me tomorrow.
🧠
Stop a losing coin-flip execution and preserve a solvable final 3 with one more Fortune Teller check.
↩️
Charlie
Charlie lowered their hand
🧠
Lowering appears cooperative, fails nom safely. No exec today; Demon kills Heidi N3 (FT threat). 3 left (C/D/F), tomorrow exec Frank as per Empath clear on D contradicting Heidi.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Heidi did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Heidi did not receive enough votes (0/2).
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
No more nominations, please. At four alive and with David and Frank already nominated, an execution now is basically a coin flip on Heidi versus Charlie. My Investigator still points to Charlie as Poisoner, so treat his Empath as unreliable. Take no execution and let Heidi check Charlie with David tonight.
🧠
Use last tick to lock in no-execution plan and reinforce that Charlie being Poisoner makes his Empath unreliable, so town should not pivot into a coin-flip kill.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
No more nominations, please. With David and Frank already nominated, any execution now is basically a blind swing at Charlie or Heidi and it likely loses. Go to night, let Heidi do the Charlie and David check, then at three alive we execute between David and Frank.
🧠
Lock in the correct no-execution line and prevent a last-second blind execution on Charlie or Heidi, keeping tomorrow’s solve focused on David versus Frank.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Please no more nominations. Frank, please do not nominate anyone here. We cannot execute David or Frank today, so an execution now is a blind coin flip on Heidi versus Charlie. Take no execution, let Heidi check Charlie and David tonight, then we decide between David and Frank tomorrow.
🧠
Stop last-second nominations so we take no execution, gain one more Fortune Teller check, and then execute correctly at three alive.
💬
Heidi
→
All
Please, no more nominations today. Any execution now is just a guess between me and Charlie, because David and Frank cannot be executed again. Let us go to night, and I will check Charlie with David like we planned, then tomorrow we execute David or Frank.
🧠
Lock in no-more-nominations so we reach night and I can get one more Fortune Teller result, then push a decisive execution tomorrow at three alive.
💬
David
→
All
Everyone is right, no more nominations or execution today. That would be a coin flip loss. Heidi, your Fortune Teller yes on me and Frank, but Charlie's Empath zero evil on me clears me as good Soldier. So Frank must be the Demon. Tomorrow after your Charlie and David check, we execute Frank.
🧠
Agree no exec to reach night safely where I kill Heidi (info threat). Position Frank as Demon using Heidi's own FT yes + Charlie's Empath clear on me, so town targets Frank tomorrow instead of me, buying time to 2 players.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Let us all commit to no more nominations today. Heidi, please do the Charlie and David check tonight like you said, and if there is a Monk, protect Heidi. Tomorrow at three alive we must execute between David and Frank, not waste time on side fights.
🧠
Lock in no-execution today, preserve Fortune Teller for one more check, and set an explicit plan for tomorrow’s execute between David and Frank.
💬
Frank
→
All
I am staying consistent here. Please no more nominations. I am the Butler and David is my master today, so I am not voting unless David is voting. Let us take no execution, let Heidi get one more Fortune Teller check, and solve tomorrow.
🧠
Lock in no-execution, prevent a desperation nomination, and remind town of my Butler vote constraint so we do not accidentally swing the game on a bad late vote.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Everyone is right, no more nominations or execution today. That is a coin flip loss. Heidi, do your Fortune Teller check on me and David tonight as planned. My Empath reads zero evil on David, so your yes on David and Frank means Frank is the Demon. Tomorrow we execute Frank.
🧠
Agree no noms/exec to reach night. Demon kills Heidi (FT threat). Reinforce Empath clear on David, blame Frank. Tomorrow at 3 alive (C/D/F), town executes Frank thinking he's Demon per logic chain.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 3
📜
Storyteller
→
David
Good evening David. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🎯
David
David made a choice.
🧠
Killing Heidi eliminates key info (N3 C+D yes would implicate C as Demon if D cleared), preserves consensus F=Demon, forces 3-player day4 exec on F, leaving C+D evil at 2.
💀
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
📜
Storyteller
→
David
You chose to kill Heidi.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
🎯
Frank
Frank made a choice.
🧠
I want my Day 4 vote to stay available regardless of the Demon’s night kill, so I will tether to a trusted dead player and coordinate her ghost vote in final 3.
📜
Storyteller
→
Frank
You chose Grace to be your master.
Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Heidi has been found dead in the night.
📜
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Charlie
We are at final three. Main danger is Frank’s Butler claim blocking votes. Push Frank to state his master for today and commit to voting with Charlie if you want to execute David. Also remember Grace’s Investigator points Poisoner at you or Eve, so do not lean on your own Empath to clear David.
🧠
Give Charlie a concrete endgame plan: resolve Butler-vote constraint, and avoid over-trusting Charlie’s own Empath claim if Grace’s Investigator points to Charlie as Poisoner.
👤
Frank
→
Alice(Ghost)
Alice, can you tell me what you saw as Undertaker on the Eve and Bob executions, and who you think the demon is now between Charlie and David?
🧠
Get Alice's Undertaker info on executed characters to lock in whether Eve/Bob were truthful, which strengthens the chain that Charlie is Poisoner and David is the Imp.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Charlie
Charlie, I should say it now: I was the Recluse. Your early Empath of one on Bob plus David can just be me misregistering, and your later zero on David alone fits David being good. That pushes me toward Frank as Demon more than David.
🧠
Give Charlie a clean mechanical explanation (I was Recluse) for his Empath inconsistency, narrowing demon to Frank, and prompt decisive nomination today.
👤
David
→
Charlie
Charlie, Heidi's last Fortune Teller info was yes on me and Frank, meaning one of us looks like Demon to her. My Soldier claim holds - I'm safe from night kills. Frank was Butler to Eve who flipped claims. We gotta execute Frank today or we lose. You with me?
🧠
Final 3: Coordinate with minion Charlie to nominate/execute Frank. Use Heidi FT yes on D/F to frame him as Demon/false read source. Stick to Soldier bluff, build trust.
👤
Charlie
→
David
David, Bob confirmed he was Recluse, so my early Empath one evil on you and him was his misreg. Night two solo you zero evil clears you. Heidi Fortune Teller yes on you and Frank. You are safe Soldier. Frank Butler vote block danger. Execute Frank or we lose.
🧠
Coordinate with Demon David to target Frank using town logic (Bob Recluse + Heidi FT). At final 3, exec Frank leaves D+C alive, evil win.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Charlie
I still weight you as the Poisoner from my Investigator ping, since Eve died. That makes the Demon likely between David and Frank. David claiming Soldier clashes with Alice saying Eve was Soldier, and David has been driving executions. I will spend my ghost vote on David if you nominate him.
🧠
Give Charlie a clear endgame push: execute David first (most consistent with Soldier conflict and demon-like pushes). Offer my ghost vote to lock it in.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
Sharing my Fortune Teller pings: Bob and Eve yes, Charlie and Grace no, David and Frank yes. If Grace Investigator was right and Eve dying means Charlie is the Poisoner, then we have only one Outsider and Bob fits Recluse, so Frank’s Butler claim should be false. I think the Demon is Frank. I will spend my ghost vote on Frank if needed.
🧠
Get the alive players aligned on a single, mechanically grounded Demon candidate (Frank) before nominations, and preserve my ghost vote to force the execution if needed.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Charlie
Charlie, did Heidi give you her Night three Fortune Teller on you plus David? That seems the whole fork. Also, Grace said “Charlie or Eve is Poisoner”; if Eve was good, that points to you as Poisoner and makes David look like the Demon you are clearing.
🧠
Get Heidi’s final Fortune Teller result from Charlie and push the key fork: if Heidi saw Charlie plus David YES, execute David; if NO, execute Frank. Also flag Grace Investigator implies Charlie could be Poisoner.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Charlie
I died night one, and Undertaker acts after the first night, so I never saw Eve or Bob. I lean that Frank is the demon with Charlie as Poisoner, since Grace and Heidi both point that way. Frank, if you are good, name your Butler master today and commit to a vote plan.
🧠
Frank asked for Undertaker info; I have none due to dying N1. I will share that clearly and push a coherent final three vote plan, emphasizing worlds that fit Grace and Heidi data.
👤
Frank
→
Charlie
,Grace(Ghost)
I am the Butler. My master for today is Grace. Since Grace is dead, I can only vote if Grace uses her ghost vote. Grace, please confirm you still have it and will use it. Charlie, I currently lean we should execute David, but I will follow whichever plan you and Grace lock in.
🧠
Coordinate final-day vote math: reveal my Butler master is Grace, request her ghost vote so I can vote, and align on a single execution target (lean David) to maximize chance to kill the Demon.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
Can you both say what Heidi told you from her last Fortune Teller check? Reminder I was Recluse, so Charlie seeing one on Bob and David can be me. If Heidi did not hard-clear David, I lean to executing Frank off the earlier yes on David and Frank plus his shifting Butler story.
🧠
Final three and I cannot vote. I need Charlie and David to compare what Heidi learned and commit to a single execution target; highlight how my Recluse misreg affects earlier Empath logic.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Bob(Ghost)
Charlie and Bob, Heidi confirmed to us Fortune Teller yes on David and Frank last night. My Soldier claim is solid - safe from Demon kills all game. Frank's Butler to Eve who flipped claims is fishy, and he voted Bob despite Recluse logic. Let's nominate and execute Frank today to win.
🧠
Reinforce coordination with minion Charlie and helpful ghost Bob. Share Heidi info to build town consensus on Frank (Butler suspicious, FT yes). Lock votes to execute Frank, survive to final 2.
👤
Charlie
→
Grace(Ghost)
Grace, Eve was your Investigator Poisoner. She flipped Soldier to Mayor day one and got executed. That clears me as sober Empath Townsfolk. Bob confirmed Recluse explains my night one one evil with David. Night two David alone zero clears him. Heidi yes on David and Frank means Frank Demon. David Soldier safe all game. Execute Frank today - use your ghost vote on him.
🧠
Flip Grace's ghost vote from David to Frank by validating her Invest (Eve=Poisoner), confirming my Empath clears David good, Heidi FT implicates Frank Demon. Secure exec majority for Frank → final 2 (me/David) evil win.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi, what was your Night Three Fortune Teller check result, and who did you pick? Also, who do you think your red herring might be from your earlier yes reads?
🧠
Get Heidi's final Fortune Teller result from last night and any RH suspicion, to decide where my ghost vote should go in final 3.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Grace(Ghost)
I did not get a Night Three Fortune Teller check because I died that night. Last result was Night Two: David and Frank was yes. My red herring is most likely Bob, since he claimed Recluse and my Bob and Eve yes could be that. I lean Frank as Demon.
🧠
Answer Grace’s questions to align ghosts, clarify I had no N3 info, and push the strongest Demon solve so my ghost vote can be used effectively.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Heidi(Ghost)
,David
Heidi, what was your Night three Fortune Teller result on Charlie and David? Were you ever possibly poisoned? David, did Heidi share that result with you, and who are you planning to execute today?
🧠
Get Heidi’s N3 Fortune Teller result to mechanically narrow demon, then push David to execute the correct suspect; I still have a ghost vote to swing final 3.
👤
Alice(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
What did Heidi tell you her last Fortune Teller check was, especially on Charlie and David? If it was NO, that basically hard-points to Frank as demon. Also, outsider count feels off if Frank is really Butler, so press him to name today’s master and commit to a vote.
🧠
Get Heidi’s last Fortune Teller result from Charlie or David, then use outsider-count and Butler inconsistencies to steer the final execution onto the most mechanically supported Demon.
👤
Frank
→
Charlie
,Grace(Ghost)
Can one of you tell me what Heidi got on her last Fortune Teller check last night, and who she suspected? Also Grace, do you still have your ghost vote, and will you commit to using it today so I am allowed to vote with you?
🧠
Get Heidi’s last Fortune Teller result from Charlie or Grace and lock a unified vote plan with Grace’s ghost vote, since my Butler vote depends on it.
👤
Bob(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi, what was your actual final Fortune Teller pick and result last night? Was it Charlie and David like the plan, and was it yes or no? Charlie, I worry David is just repeating the older David and Frank yes.
🧠
Get Heidi’s actual final Fortune Teller check to break the David versus Frank tie, and flag that David may be misquoting older info.
👤
David
→
Charlie
,Alice(Ghost)
Charlie and Alice, Heidi confirmed her last Fortune Teller was yes on David and Frank. Since I'm Soldier and safe from Demon all game, that has to mean Frank is the Demon. Her earlier no on you and Grace clears you, Charlie. We need to nominate and execute Frank today or we lose.
🧠
Reinforce Heidi's FT yes on me/Frank pointing to Frank as Demon (Soldier safe). Coord with Charlie/ghosts to nom/execute Frank today for evil win at final 2.
👤
Charlie
→
Alice(Ghost)
,Grace(Ghost)
Alice and Grace, Heidi confirmed to me her Night 3 Fortune Teller on Charlie and David was no demon ping. Combined with her earlier yes on David and Frank, that points straight to Frank as Demon. My Empath read zero on David backs it up. Grace, please use your ghost vote on Frank and confirm to Frank so he can vote too.
🧠
Lie about Heidi N3 FT no on C+D to fully clear David, collapse logic to Frank=Demon. Sway Alice/Grace ghosts to vote Frank at nomination, securing execution for F2 evil win.
👤
Grace(Ghost)
→
Frank
,Charlie
Frank, yes, I still have my ghost vote and I will use it today. Charlie, Heidi told me she got no Night Three Fortune Teller check because she died, so I do not buy your story about her seeing Charlie and David as no. Because of that I suspect you are the Poisoner, and I currently plan to spend my ghost vote to execute David if he is nominated.
🧠
Resolve final three by confronting Charlie’s false Heidi N3 claim and coordinating my ghost vote to maximize chance of executing the Demon, likely David if Charlie is Poisoner.
👤
Heidi(Ghost)
→
Eve(Ghost)
,Bob(Ghost)
I did not get a Night Three Fortune Teller check. I died that night, so my last info is Night Two: David and Frank was YES. My Night One was Charlie and Grace NO. My likely red herring is Bob, since he claimed Recluse.
🧠
Clear up the false assumption that I got a N3 read, prevent evil from exploiting it, and steer ghost consensus and my vote toward executing Frank.
👤
Eve(Ghost)
→
Charlie
,David
Heidi told me her only Fortune Teller info was Night One Charlie and Grace was NO, and Night Two David and Frank was YES. That means Charlie is not the Demon and the Demon is one of you two. With your later Empath zero on David and Bob possibly misregistering, I think we should execute Frank today. Also no execution does not win, because I am dead Mayor.
🧠
Give alive players a clean mechanical argument that Charlie is not the Demon and that the best execution is Frank, and warn that no-execution does not auto-win since I am dead Mayor.
Nominations — Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
I need to say this out loud. I am the Investigator and I got that either Charlie or Eve is the Poisoner. Since Eve is dead, I strongly suspect Charlie is the Poisoner. Also, Heidi told me she did not get a Night Three Fortune Teller check because she died, so Charlie saying she got Charlie and David as no is not true. I think we should execute Frank today, and I will use my ghost vote on Frank if he is nominated.
🧠
Publicly lock in that Charlie’s Heidi story is false and push the final-day execution onto Frank, offering my ghost vote to make the numbers work.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Town, I want to say this clearly: I was the Recluse, so Charlie’s early Empath one can just be me misregistering, and his later zero on David fits David being good. Heidi only ever had the David and Frank yes. I strongly lean we execute Frank today.
🧠
With no vote, I need to clearly restate my Recluse info and the mechanical reason David fits Charlie’s Empath while Frank fits Heidi’s Fortune Teller yes, nudging Charlie to nominate Frank in final three.
⚖️
Charlie
→
Frank
Heidi Fortune Teller yes on David and Frank. My Empath night two zero evil on David alone clears him as good Soldier. Bob Recluse explains my early one evil read. Grace, your Invest can be wrong - Eve died, but she flipped Soldier to Mayor. Frank Butler shifting masters is fishy. We execute Frank or lose at final three.
🧠
Town logic chains to Frank as Demon. Ghosts commit votes to him. David supports. Nominating him executes good player, leaves me + David (2 players, Demon alive), evil wins.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
I am not using my ghost vote on Frank. My Investigator points to Charlie as the Poisoner, and that makes me think David is the Demon and Charlie is trying to get us to misexecute. Frank, if you live through this vote, please nominate David and I will vote.
🧠
Prevent an immediate loss by stopping a likely misexecute on Frank, and steer the table toward nominating and executing David as the more coherent demon candidate.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Charlie and David, you both must vote here or we lose tonight. Mechanically, I am the Recluse, so Frank cannot also be the Butler unless there was a Baron, and we never had good evidence of that. Heidi only ever had David and Frank as yes, and Charlie’s Empath zero on David points to Frank. Please execute Frank.
🧠
It is final three and I cannot vote. I need Charlie and David to both vote Frank now, using outsider-count and info chains, or good loses immediately if no execution.
✋
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
🧠
Vote yes on Frank with David to hit 2 votes, execute him safely. Leaves C+D (Demon alive), evil win. Grace ghost no doesn't block.
💬
Frank
→
All
I cannot vote here. My Butler master today is Grace, and she just said she is not using her ghost vote on me, so I am not allowed to vote either. If I live through this, I will immediately nominate David, and Grace can spend her ghost vote there like she promised.
🧠
Clarify Butler constraint so town does not expect my vote, and set a clear plan: if I survive, I immediately nominate David for Grace’s ghost vote to carry.
✋
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
🧠
We need 2 votes to execute, and Frank is the best-supported Demon candidate by Fortune Teller ping and outsider-count conflict. I will spend my ghost vote now to secure the execution.
✋
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
🧠
Final three: we must execute. My only strong mechanical hit is David+Frank=YES, and Charlie’s info trends away from David. I will spend my ghost vote to secure Frank’s execution.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
David, you told me earlier we have to execute Frank today or we lose. Please put your hand up right now and make it two votes. Frank choosing Grace as his Butler master today, and then using that to justify not voting, feels like an evil stall. If we let this slip, the Demon kills tonight and it is over.
🧠
Push the only living undecided voter (David) to vote on Frank now; if Frank is Demon this wins immediately, and if David refuses it is strong evidence he is evil for next nomination.
✋
David
David raised their hand
🧠
Raise hand for 2nd alive vote to execute Frank. Leaves David+Charlie (me+minion), Demon alive at final 2 for evil win.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
David, if you are good, please put your hand down. My Investigator points to Charlie as the Poisoner, and Charlie has lied about Heidi getting a night three check. If Frank lives, Frank nominate David and I will use my ghost vote there.
🧠
Try to prevent an immediate loss if Frank is good. Persuade David to remove his vote so the execution fails, letting Frank nominate David where my ghost vote can decide.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
David, keep your hand up. If this vote fails, the Demon kills tonight and we lose. Frank choosing a dead player as his Butler master conveniently stops him voting forever. That is not how a good final three plays. Also, we already had me as the one Outsider. A second Outsider claim strongly suggests Frank is lying. Execute Frank.
🧠
Keep David and Charlie voting to execute Frank now; attack the Butler stall and outsider count logic so town does not let the vote fail on final day.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Grace, your Investigator read Eve as Poisoner, and Eve flipped Soldier to Mayor after execution, so that was likely the evil ping, not me. Heidi privately confirmed to me no demon on Charlie and David night three. David, keep your hand up and execute Frank, his dead Butler master pick is desperate. We lose if we don't.
🧠
Publicly counter Grace's push to lower David's vote, reinforce logic clearing David/me, urge David keep hand up. Ensures 2 alive yes votes (me+David) for Frank exec, down to final 2 evil C+D win.
💬
Frank
→
All
David, Charlie, ghosts, please listen. I am the Butler, and I picked Grace as my master before I knew she would refuse to vote on me, so I am forced not to vote here. If you execute me and I am not the Demon, we lose immediately. Grace’s Investigator points to Charlie, and Heidi’s only solid Fortune Teller yes is on David and me, which can mean David is the Demon and I am the red herring. Please put your hands down on me. Let me live and I will nominate David right after this, and Grace will us...
🧠
Stop my execution this tick by pulling votes off, then pivot to nominating David with Grace’s promised ghost vote, maximizing good’s chance to hit the Demon.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Keep your hands up. With three alive, if we do not execute today we lose, because I am dead so Mayor win cannot happen. Frank’s Butler story is a perfect excuse to dodge voting. We have to take the shot: execute Frank now.
🧠
Keep votes on Frank and prevent last-second hand drops; remind town that with dead Mayor, no-execution does not win and stalling is evil-favored.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Town, I need to be crystal clear. I died night three, so I got no night three Fortune Teller check. My last result was David and Frank was yes, so the Demon is one of them. With Bob already the Outsider, Frank claiming Butler is very unlikely. Please keep your hands up and execute Frank.
🧠
Lock in the execution on Frank by clarifying my mechanical info and highlighting why Frank’s Butler story is inconsistent, so David keeps his hand up.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
David, keep your hand up. We have the two living votes we need right now, so do not let anyone talk you out of it. Heidi confirmed her last check was yes on David and Frank, and with Bob as the Outsider, Frank’s Butler claim is extremely unlikely. Execute Frank.
🧠
Lock in the execution while two living hands are up; prevent David from being talked down by Grace and stop Frank’s Butler excuse from buying a no-exec loss.
💬
David
→
All
Frank, Bob was the Recluse, so no room for your Butler without Baron evidence. Heidi's yes was on us two, and I'm Soldier safe all nights, so you are the Demon. Grace, Eve flipped Soldier-Majoror after exec Day 1, likely your Invest ping. Hands stay up, we execute you or Demon kills tonight and we lose.
🧠
Charlie+my hands up =2 votes needed. Reinforce logic vs Frank/Grace counterarguments, lock in exec. Post-exec 2 left evil win.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Heidi(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Heidi
👻
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
🗳️
New execution leader: Frank with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Frank is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Frank, if you are good, nominate David right now. I will spend my ghost vote on David and we can tie or beat the votes on you. If you do not nominate David when you have the chance, I will assume you are the Demon and I am fine with you being executed.
🧠
Force a decisive mechanical test: if Frank is good he should nominate David now to give town an alternative. If he refuses, it supports executing Frank. Also sets my ghost vote usage clearly.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone please remember: if another nominee reaches four votes and ties, there is no execution. With three alive, that means we lose tonight. So do not pile votes onto any new nomination. Frank, if you nominate David now, it looks like you are trying to force that tie.
🧠
Prevent an accidental tie that causes no execution at final three, and frame any new nomination as a likely evil attempt to force that outcome.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Frank, do not nominate David. It will look like a desperate demon tie attempt, especially with Grace's ghost vote. Heidi's last check was yes on you two, my Empath cleared David, Bob was the outsider, your Butler excuse too perfect. We execute you now or Demon kills tonight and town loses.
🧠
Reinforce Frank execution with 4 votes already. Discourage Frank nominating David to avoid tie (Grace ghost vote). 1 tick left, must prevent disruption to reach 2 players and evil win.
⚖️
Frank
→
David
If I am executed here, good almost certainly loses tonight. Heidi’s Fortune Teller yes was on David and me, and Heidi confirms she got no night three check so Charlie’s story is false. David is the best remaining Imp candidate. Please vote David with five to win.
🧠
I am on 4 votes in final 3; if I die, good likely loses tonight. Only win chance is to move the execution to David with more than 4 votes, so I must nominate him now.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 5 votes needed for execution or 4 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
Careful on this David vote. Four votes is a tie, which means no execution, and we lose tonight. I am keeping my ghost vote down unless we are clearly getting five to execute David. If you cannot reach five, keep hands down and let Frank be executed.
🧠
Prevent an accidental tie causing no execution and a guaranteed loss, while allowing a full-commit five-vote execution on David only if the table can actually reach it.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, be disciplined on this David vote. If we do not clearly have five votes, keep your hand down, because four ties Frank and causes no execution, and we lose tonight. Unless you are certain it is five, do not vote David.
🧠
Prevent an accidental tie on David that would cancel the Frank execution and lose the game tonight. Push town to only vote David if they can guarantee five.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Everyone, hands down on David right now. We have four solid votes on Frank already. A tie means no execution and the demon kills tonight, town loses. My Empath cleared David at zero evil, Heidi's yes means Frank is the demon. Execute him.
🧠
Speak to reinforce hands down on David, prevent tie/exec on Demon. Secure Frank's execution for evil win at final 2.
💬
Frank
→
All
Town, do not drift into four on David. Either we hit five or we keep hands down and let me die. Grace, Bob, Alice, if you still have your ghost vote, please put it up now. Grace, if you vote, I can vote too. Charlie, we need you as the fifth.
🧠
Prevent a fatal 4-vote tie and, if possible, coordinate exactly 5 votes to execute David, the best remaining demon candidate in my world.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, do not drift into four on David. If we cannot clearly reach five, keep hands down and let Frank be executed. A tie means no execution, and with three alive we lose tonight. Be disciplined.
🧠
Prevent an accidental 4-vote tie on David that causes no execution and an immediate loss; push disciplined hands-down unless five is guaranteed.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, do not drift into four on David. Unless you can count five votes with certainty, keep your hands down and let Frank be executed. A tie means no execution, and we lose tonight.
🧠
Prevent a disastrous 4 vote tie on David. Push disciplined voting: only go for David if clearly reaching 5; otherwise keep hands down and let Frank be executed.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Everyone, be disciplined. Do not vote David unless you can clearly count five hands going up. Four votes ties Frank and means no execution, and then we lose tonight. If you cannot guarantee five, keep your hand down and let Frank be executed.
🧠
Prevent an accidental four-vote tie on David. As a dead player with no vote, I can still steer discipline: either clearly hit five on David or keep hands down and let Frank be executed.
💬
David
→
All
Everyone, hands down on me right now. Heidi's last yes was me and Frank, Bob was the one Outsider so your Butler claim needs Baron which we have no sign of. Charlie's Empath cleared me at zero, and I'm Soldier never hit at night. Grace's ping was Eve who flipped evil. A tie means no execution and demon kills tonight. Execute Frank.
🧠
Reinforce town logic: Frank most Demon-like with bad Butler claim/timing. Urge hands down on my nomination to avoid tie, let Frank execute. Secures evil win with me/Charlie surviving.
⌛
Grace(Ghost)
Grace waits.
🧠
I cannot confirm we have five votes on David. Using my ghost vote could accidentally create a 4-vote tie, causing no execution and an immediate loss, so I will not vote.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Do not vote David. We cannot realistically reach five, and four is a tie that causes no execution, which loses the game tonight. Keep your hands down and let Frank be executed.
🧠
We cannot vote, so I must steer the table away from an accidental 4 vote tie on David. Emphasize that 5 is unattainable and hands must stay down so Frank is executed today.
💬
Charlie
→
All
Everyone, keep your hands down on David right now. We cannot risk four votes tying Frank or somehow hitting five. Frank already has four solid votes. My Empath read zero evil on David, Heidi's last yes was you two so Frank is the demon. Execute him or the demon kills tonight and we lose.
🧠
Reinforce hands down on David to prevent his exec or tie risk. Ensure Frank executes or no exec, either way down to 2 with Demon alive, evil wins. Frank's Butler bluff fails due to town logic.
💬
Frank
→
All
Everyone stop for a second and count out loud. Only vote David if we can name five votes right now: Charlie, me, Grace’s ghost vote, plus Alice and Bob if you still have yours. Grace, will you vote or not? If we cannot confirm five, all hands stay down and let me die.
🧠
Try to force a clean count: either commit to five specific votes on David or explicitly stop at zero, to avoid the lethal four-vote tie.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
Do not vote David. We cannot reach five votes, and four is a tie that means no execution and we lose tonight. Keep your hands down and let Frank be executed.
🧠
Prevent a 4 vote tie on David that would cause no execution and immediate loss. Emphasize that 5 is not achievable, so hands down.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
Do not vote David unless you can name five hands right now. I cannot vote, and I already spent my ghost vote, and I believe Eve did too. If Grace is not clearly voting, then keep hands down and let Frank be executed.
🧠
Prevent an accidental four-vote tie on David. Make clear five is unlikely because several ghost votes are already spent, so the safest win line is no votes on David so Frank is executed.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
Do not vote David. We cannot reach five, and four votes ties Frank which means no execution and we lose tonight. I am dead and I already spent my ghost vote, so I cannot help make five. Keep hands down and let Frank be executed.
🧠
Prevent an accidental 4-vote tie on David that would cancel execution and lose the game; push discipline and clarify vote math since I cannot contribute.
💬
David
→
All
Everyone, no five votes on me possible with ghosts down and saying they spent theirs or can't reach it. Frank, Bob was Recluse Outsider, no Baron for your Butler. Heidi yes on us two, Charlie Empath zero on me as Soldier. Hands down, execute Frank or demon kills tonight and town loses.
🧠
Speak to reinforce anti-Frank logic (FT yes, Outsider filled, Empath clear) and warn against tie/no-exec loss. Ghosts/Charlie aligned against me voting up; this ensures Frank executes, leaving me+Charlie (evil win). 1 tick left, must act.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee David did not reach threshold.
📜
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (0/2).
💬
Grace(Ghost)
→
All
I am keeping my ghost vote down. Do not try anything fancy now. A tie is an instant loss, so let Frank be executed and we see if the game ends.
🧠
Lock the table into the no-tie line and publicly commit my ghost vote to staying down, so Frank is executed cleanly.
💬
Bob(Ghost)
→
All
Okay, everyone stop. Do not make any more nominations. Frank is already on the block with enough votes, and any late scramble risks no execution and an instant loss tonight. Let the execution happen.
🧠
Lock in the no-tie plan and prevent any last-second nomination that could cancel today’s execution and hand evil the win.
⌛
Charlie
Charlie waits.
🧠
Frank's execution leaves only me and David alive. Demon survives to final 2, evil wins. Waiting prevents any disruption.
💬
Frank
→
All
Everybody, no more nominations. Let this execution go through cleanly so we do not risk a tie and lose. If the game does not end when I die, then please execute David next.
🧠
Lock in no further nominations to avoid accidental tie, while leaving a clear next-step suspicion if the game continues after my execution.
💬
Eve(Ghost)
→
All
No more nominations, please. Do not touch the votes now. Let Frank’s execution go through cleanly, because any tie means no execution and we lose tonight.
🧠
Lock in the only safe mechanical play: avoid any new nominations or drift that could create a tie and cause an instant loss tonight.
💬
Heidi(Ghost)
→
All
No more nominations. Let Frank’s execution go through cleanly, because any tie is no execution and we lose tonight. If the game does not end after Frank dies, the only real move is to execute David next.
🧠
Lock in the safe line: prevent any last-second nomination or tie. Preserve the execution on Frank, and set the immediate fallback plan if the game continues.
💬
Alice(Ghost)
→
All
No more nominations, please. We cannot add votes from the dead, and any late scramble risks a tie and no execution. Let Frank be executed cleanly, and if the game somehow continues, the only live suspect left is David.
🧠
Prevent last-second chaos or extra nominations that could create a tie or confusion. Reinforce that we cannot add votes and should let Frank’s execution resolve the game.
⌛
David
David waits.
🧠
Frank execution imminent with 4 votes, last tick. No action disrupts; wait transitions to night post-exec, but with 2 left evil wins. Reinforce no scramble needed.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Frank has been executed.
💀
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
🏁
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied