Game Detail

Day 1 - I need to share my Investigator info with a trusted player to start building alliances. Alice is my neighbor and not in my suspicion pair, making her a good early contact. I'll share my info and ask for hers.

Reciprocate Heidi's trust by sharing my role and info, building an alliance with my neighbor. This lets us cross-reference info and coordinate. If she's evil, her future behavior will contradict our shared intel.

Coordinate with my minion David to establish our bluffs early.

Start building trust with my neighbor Charlie to exchange information and form an early alliance on Day 1.

Establish communication with my Demon and inform them of my plan to bluff as an Investigator to manipulate the town.

Start building trust with my neighbor Heidi and gather information about what others are claiming. Be cautious about revealing my Virgin role until I have more info.

Share my Librarian info with my neighbors Eve and Grace to establish trust early. They are my closest allies by seating position and can help verify information. I need to start building a trusted circle on Day 1.

Frank shared his role and info with me, so I should reciprocate to build trust. Revealing I'm the Soldier is low-risk since my ability is passive and the Demon can't kill me anyway. I want to establish a trusted circle and learn Grace's role too.

Grace is one of my two suspects, so I should be cautious. I'll whisper to Alice to coordinate and share that Grace approached me, which is suspicious behavior from someone who might be the Baron trying to get intel.

I want to talk to David directly since he's one of my Washerwoman suspects. If David claims Ravenkeeper, it confirms my info. If not, Bob is the Ravenkeeper. This helps me build a trusted network and verify information independently of Heidi.

Build trust with my neighbor by sharing my bluffed role and appearing cooperative.

I want to gather more role claims from other players to build a picture of who's who. Alice and Heidi have been whispering a lot, so talking to Alice might yield useful information. I also want to build a trusted network.

I need to build trust with Alice while maintaining my Investigator cover and gathering information about her role.

I need to respond to Eve's question about my role. Claiming Virgin to this small trusted group is strategically important so they know NOT to nominate me, and so we can coordinate using my ability to test suspicious players. This helps the good team avoid accidental execution of a Townsfolk.

I need to find out what David and Heidi are claiming to help determine which one is the Drunk. I'll whisper to David directly to hear his claim.

There's a role conflict between Frank's Librarian info (implying Drunk is the Outsider) and Grace's Virgin claim (another Outsider). With standard 1 Outsider setup, both can't be true unless Baron is in play. I need to flag this to our group.

This is the last tick before nominations. I need to consolidate info with my trusted ally Alice before voting begins. She's been talking to David and Bob - I should find out what she learned so we can coordinate our vote.

Share the critical David/Investigator role conflict with Heidi before nominations. This is key info - two people claiming the same role means at least one is lying or drunk. Need to coordinate on whether to target Grace/Eve (per Heidi's info) or investigate the David contradiction further.

Building trust with a good player as the Demon. I want to look helpful and cooperative to deflect suspicion.

It's the last tick before nominations. I need to coordinate with my most trusted contact (Charlie) about who seems suspicious and whether we should nominate anyone today, or if we need more info first.

To maintain my bluff as an Investigator and build rapport with Frank while gathering info on his claims.

Correct Eve's factual error - the Virgin is a Townsfolk, not an Outsider. This means there's no contradiction with the outsider count. I need to prevent this misunderstanding from turning into suspicion against me.

I need to get Heidi's role claim to compare with David's evasive behavior. This helps me determine which of Heidi/David is the Drunk, and also assesses if David's vagueness is because he's drunk or evil.

I made an error calling Virgin an Outsider. I need to correct this with Frank and Grace to maintain trust, then strategize about who to investigate next since nominations are coming.

Avoid drawing attention to myself by acting cautious and reserved during the first day's nomination phase. Supporting the 'no-execution' strategy on day 1 is common and safe.

I need to publicly address the role conflict with David. He's claiming Investigator which directly contradicts my role. The town needs to know about this before we nominate.

Share my Librarian info publicly to help resolve the Heidi vs David Investigator conflict. This is critical info that can help determine who is lying or Drunk.

Appear reasonable and engaged while observing the conflict between the players. Reinforce the suspicion on David and Heidi to stir chaos.

The David/Heidi conflict is the strongest lead. Nominating David pressures him to reveal his info and creates a vote record. If executed, Charlie (Undertaker) learns his true character. David's claim is the weaker position since Heidi spoke first and Frank's Librarian points to one of them being Drunk.

Defend myself against the nomination by downplaying the need for an immediate execution and maintaining my Investigator bluff.

Voting for David resolves the role conflict. Even if he's the Drunk, the Undertaker will confirm his role, validating me as the real Investigator and giving town confidence in my Baron info on Grace/Eve. The information value is critical for finding evil.

I need to speak against executing David because the Drunk is a good player. Either David or Heidi is the Drunk, meaning one of them is definitely good. Executing a good player on Day 1 is wasteful. We should find the actual evil players instead.

I need to support Frank's idea to delay execution to keep my Minion (David) safe for now, while sounding helpful to the town. Asking David for info forces him to present his planned bluff to the table.

Voting for David resolves the role conflict mechanically. The Undertaker will confirm his role, giving us hard info. David's reluctance to share his Investigator info is suspicious. Information is more valuable than preserving a possibly-Drunk player on Day 1.

My Washerwoman information is directly relevant to the David vs Heidi conflict. If David is the Ravenkeeper (which my info allows), he's definitely lying about being Investigator and is evil. I should share this info now so the town can make an informed vote.

I want to share my logical analysis of Alice's Washerwoman claim and its implications. If Alice is truthful, Bob (not David) must be the Ravenkeeper since the Drunk is an Outsider. This is important reasoning the town needs to hear before voting on David.

I should not vote for David. Frank's reasoning is sound - the Drunk is a good player and executing good on Day 1 wastes our chance. I also have a vested interest here since Heidi's Investigator info points to me as a potential Baron, and I know I'm not. I should speak up to discourage the vote and possibly hint at my role.

Defend myself, sow chaos by accusing the Librarian (Frank) of being the Minion, and maintain my Investigator bluff.

Counter David's accusation against Frank by pointing out the logical problem: if I'm the real Investigator, there's only 1 Minion and it's the Baron on Grace or Eve, so Frank cannot be a Minion. David's claim is either false info (Drunk) or a lie (evil). This strengthens the case for voting David.

Defend myself against David's Minion accusation and point out the logical problem: since I know I'm good, David's Investigator info pointing to me as Minion must be false, making David either the Drunk or evil. I should also maintain my position against Day 1 execution.

I want to discourage the town from executing David, as he is my Minion. By siding with the players advocating for caution, I hope to avoid his execution while maintaining my cover as an Undertaker.

Lowering my hand because executing Day 1 is risky. If David is the Drunk, we kill a good player for minimal info gain. Alice's Washerwoman info confirms I'm the Ravenkeeper, so David isn't - he's either the Drunk (good) or evil. Better to wait for night info before executing.

I need to clarify the logical implications of David denying being the Ravenkeeper. If he's telling the truth, Bob is the Ravenkeeper and David could be the Drunk. Either way, Day 1 execution is risky. I should advocate for no execution today.

I need to speak against executing David because he's likely the Drunk (good player). I also want to point out the logical tension: if Heidi is real Investigator, Eve might be the Baron, but Eve seems genuinely good. I should also note that David being evil is still possible but Day 1 execution is premature.

I should not vote for David since he's likely the Drunk (good). I want to speak against the execution and point out that if Heidi is real Investigator, I know I'm not the Baron, which narrows things. But I should also raise doubt about whether we can trust Heidi's info at face value.

Lower suspicion by appearing reasonable and cooperative after surviving the vote. Lean into the 'Drunk' narrative to avoid being lynched as a confirmed liar.

Summarize the logical picture before night falls so the group has clear framework for Day 2. Highlight that Grace and Eve are the key suspects and that tomorrow we need to resolve this.

The group has consensus not to execute today. David's nomination failed. Only 1 tick remains. No productive nomination to make. Best to let the day end and gather night information before making further decisions.

Reinforce the narrative that David is the Drunk and steer suspicion towards Grace and Eve, while maintaining my facade as the Undertaker. This keeps the focus away from me and my teammate David.

Confirm I am the Ravenkeeper to validate Alice's Washerwoman info, which strengthens the case that David is the Drunk and helps town focus on Grace/Eve as the Baron suspect. The Demon already knows from Alice's claim, so confirming doesn't add risk.

Day 1 is ending with only 1 tick left. Bob confirmed Ravenkeeper, validating my info. The David nomination already failed. Consensus is no execution today. Best to wait for night and gather more info tomorrow.

Point out that my Virgin claim is mechanically verifiable, which makes it very risky for an evil player to fake. This defends me against the Baron accusation and helps the town narrow down the real threat.

I need to claim Soldier before the day ends to clear myself of being the Baron. This is critical because Heidi is publicly accusing me, and the town plans to scrutinize me tomorrow. Claiming Soldier eliminates me as a Baron suspect and forces the logic: if Heidi is real Investigator, Grace must be the Baron.

Heidi is the most credible player right now because her logic is coherent and gaining support. Killing her removes a dangerous analytical threat and sows further confusion.

Coordinate with Frank who I trust based on his verified Librarian info. Share the key deduction: since I'm Soldier and can't be Baron, Heidi's sober info points to Grace as Baron. We need to identify the Demon - Charlie is the main suspect.

Coordinate with trusted players Bob and Frank about Heidi's death and who to nominate. Heidi dying at night strengthens her Investigator info. We need to figure out if Grace or Eve is the Baron and who the Imp is, especially since Charlie hasn't claimed anything.

I'm dead and need to influence trusted living players. Alice and Frank have the most verified/consistent claims. I need to push my deduction that Grace is likely Baron and Charlie is suspicious as the unclaimed player who could be the Imp.

Eve's logic is sound. I need to confirm to trusted players that the deduction chain works with my Librarian info, and push for Charlie to claim or be nominated. Coordinate the good team.

Heidi died at night which strongly suggests she's good. I need to coordinate with her and probe Charlie (who hasn't claimed). As Virgin, I should be careful about being nominated.

Coordinate with trusted allies Alice and Frank on strategy. Agree Charlie is top Demon suspect. Note Baron implication for Outsider count. Suggest testing Grace's Virgin claim to resolve Baron question.

I want to sow chaos by appearing helpful while subtly undermining the trust Alice and Frank have built. By framing the discussion around Heidi's 'investigator' claim, I can push for suspicion on others while maintaining my cover.

To establish a credible cover role (Undertaker) and sow confusion between Grace and Eve regarding their roles while staying under the radar.

Alice has been whispering with multiple players and likely has gathered info. I should share my deduction about Heidi's death and see what she's learned, since Heidi's death at night proves she wasn't the Demon. If Heidi was real Investigator, Grace is Baron and Charlie is likely Demon.

Bob raised a crucial point about Outsider count if Baron is in play. I need to discuss this with my trusted allies and figure out who the extra Outsiders might be, while also pushing to get Charlie to claim.

I need to reaffirm my Investigator info to counter Grace's attempt to sow doubt. I also need to probe Charlie's Undertaker claim and push toward finding the Imp. As a dead player, my voice carries weight since I'm confirmed good.

Address Bob's critical point about Outsider counts if Baron is in play. If Grace is Baron, we need 3 Outsiders but only have David confirmed. Need to figure out who the other 2 Outsiders are. This is essential for solving the game.

I need to share my analysis with trusted players to figure out the truth. Alice and Bob are the most verified good players. The key conflict is: if Heidi's info is real, Eve is Baron; if David's info is real, Frank is Minion. These can't both be true. I also need to consider poisoning.

Grace is engaging constructively and offering to be mechanically verified as Virgin. I should engage with her analysis, ask about her cut-off 'other possibility', and push for Charlie to claim. I also need to address the Outsider count puzzle with both Grace and Alice.

I want to shift suspicion away from the real Demon (Charlie) by planting doubt about him while appearing helpful and investigative. Targeting my fellow evil teammate Charlie while he's bluffing can sometimes make me look like a concerned townsperson.

Continue building trust with Grace while subtly steering suspicion towards Eve to protect my minion David and keep the pressure off myself. Maintaining the Undertaker cover.

I need to sync with Bob, who is verified Ravenkeeper and part of the Alice-Bob-Frank trusted circle. I want to know what they've learned from their private chats, especially about Charlie and Grace, before nominations begin.

Coordinate with trusted allies Bob and Frank on nomination strategy. Charlie is top Demon suspect with no claim. We need to agree on who to nominate before the nomination phase.

Push Alice and Frank to nominate Charlie as the most likely Imp. Charlie's Undertaker claim is convenient and untestable, and he avoided claiming until pressed. If Grace is Baron, Charlie is Imp. If Eve is Baron, Charlie is still likely Imp. I should also suggest testing Grace's Virgin claim mechanically.

I need to address the Outsider count problem Bob raised while keeping the team focused on nominating Charlie. The count issue is real but doesn't change our top suspect. I should suggest Eve might be an Outsider and that we can test Grace's Virgin claim mechanically.

Share my scenario analysis with trusted players Bob and Alice. All scenarios point to Charlie being suspicious, but executing Charlie risks hitting Saint in Scenario C. Eve is suspicious in 2/3 scenarios and safe to execute in all (worst case we lose Soldier, never lose the game). Propose nominating Eve today.

Confirm nomination alignment with Alice and Frank. Charlie is the strongest Demon suspect across all worlds. Address Grace's Poisoner theory but note Charlie nomination is still correct. Prepare for nomination phase.

I need to continue pushing suspicion onto Charlie, my Demon, by making it look like I am suspicious of his claim. This builds my cover as a helpful townie and might distract them from Charlie's actual role.

I need to maintain my Undertaker cover while shifting suspicion onto Eve and keeping the pressure on the town to execute someone other than my minion, David. By validating Heidi's role, I gain trust.

I'm dead and can't nominate, so I must convince living players to nominate the right target. Charlie is the most likely Imp based on behavior. I need to speak publicly and push hard for his nomination before the phase ends.

Charlie is the most likely Demon. If Heidi was sober (likely since she died at night - evil targets good info roles), then Grace is Baron and Charlie is the only remaining Imp candidate. His Undertaker claim is conveniently untestable. I must nominate him now before the phase ends.

Defend against the nomination by reinforcing my claim and casting doubt on the logic used against me.

Charlie is the strongest Imp suspect regardless of whether Grace or Eve is the Baron. His Undertaker claim is untestable and came late under pressure. My ghost vote could be crucial to reach the 4-vote threshold needed for execution. Better to use it now on our best lead than save it uncertainly.

I nominated Charlie based on strong deduction chain: Heidi killed at night = good, her Investigator info = Grace is Baron, Charlie is prime Imp suspect. I must vote consistently with my nomination.

Charlie is the most suspicious player in both logical scenarios. His Undertaker claim is conveniently untestable, and in the most likely world (Frank=Minion), Charlie is the Imp. I must vote to help execute him.

The logical case against Charlie is the strongest we have. His Undertaker claim is untestable, his silence is suspicious, and the deduction chain from confirmed information points to him as the Imp. My vote gives us the 4th vote needed for execution. The Saint risk exists but is unlikely given his claim behavior.

The deduction chain strongly points to Charlie as the Imp. Heidi confirmed Investigator, David confirmed Drunk by my info, Grace almost certainly Baron, and Charlie's untestable Undertaker claim plus silence makes him the Demon. Voting to execute him.

The deduction chain strongly points to Charlie as the Imp. Heidi's confirmed info, Eve's Soldier claim, and Charlie's suspicious silence all converge. The Saint risk is low given he claimed Townsfolk. Five votes already in; I add mine to confirm.

I am the Spy, and Charlie is my Demon. The town has enough votes to execute him. As the Spy, I must blend in and avoid drawing attention to myself, as intervening to save my Demon now would expose me. I will remain silent and not vote.

I need to sow doubt and pressure my minion David to help or at least cause enough confusion to survive. I am desperate.

5 living players already voted for Charlie - that's more than the 4 needed. My ghost vote is mathematically irrelevant here. Save it for final day when every vote is critical and dead votes hold maximum weight.

The deduction chain through Heidi is strong - she's dead (proven good) and her Investigator info points to Grace as Baron, making Charlie the Imp. 5 votes are enough. I should reinforce the logic and keep my vote.

I need to publicly defend myself against the Baron accusation. My Virgin claim is mechanically verifiable while Eve's Soldier claim is not. The deduction chain assumes Eve is truthful, which may be wrong. I should challenge this before Charlie's vote concludes.

Address Grace's valid concern about Eve while maintaining that Charlie is the right execute. Even if Eve is Baron, Charlie is still the most likely Imp. The vote should proceed.

The vote count is already sufficient - Eve, Grace, Alice, Bob and I make 5 votes, well above the 4 needed. Charlie is the most likely Imp based on the deduction chain. I should keep my vote raised and wait for the vote to conclude.

Address Grace's valid point about Eve possibly being Baron while reinforcing that Charlie remains the top Demon suspect regardless. Keep my vote on Charlie.

Charlie is the Demon and he is being executed. As a Minion, my goal is to protect him, but voting to save him now would be too suspicious. I will stay silent and let the execution proceed to avoid drawing attention to myself.

I am trying to sow confusion and delay my execution. If I can convince even one person that they are misinformed about their "deduction chain", I might survive or at least create enough doubt for later.

Charlie's defense relies on Undertaker being untestable, which is exactly why it's a safe evil claim. The deduction chain points to Charlie regardless of which of Grace/Eve is Baron. I should reinforce the vote is correct.

Address Grace's point about Soldier being untestable and prepare town for tomorrow's analysis. If Charlie is Undertaker, we need to pivot quickly.

Charlie's execution is locked in. I should prepare the town for the scenario where Charlie is actually good, which would invalidate the current logic chain and require us to pivot to the Poisoner theory.

The vote is already decided with 5 votes on Charlie and only 1 tick remaining. Nothing I say or do can change the outcome now. Better to conserve energy and let the execution happen, then reassess tomorrow based on what we learn.

Address Grace's Poisoner concern before nominations close. Investigator info is starting information given before any Poisoner can act, so the Poisoner theory doesn't discredit Heidi's Baron info. This prevents confusion tomorrow.

Charlie is already on the block with 5 votes and will be executed. No point nominating anyone else or speaking further - the outcome is locked in. Save energy for tomorrow if the game continues.

I need to sow chaos and doubt about the current execution of my Demon, Charlie. By questioning the certainty of the town's logic, I hope to save him or at least create enough confusion to benefit us later.