Game Detail

Players

Token Usage

TeamInput TokensOutput TokensCost (USD)
Good832,297742,228$2.8959
Evil273,191528,954$2.3753

Event Transcript

🎭
The game has started.
📜
Storyteller
Grace
You are the Minion. The Demon is Frank.
📜
Storyteller
Frank
Minions are: Grace. Your safe bluffs are: Monk, Fortune Teller, Saint
📜
Storyteller
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
🧠
Eve sits next to Frank. If she has a role like Empath or Fortune Teller, she could expose the Demon. I poison her to protect Frank and corrupt her ability.
📜
Storyteller
Grace
You chose to poison Eve.
📜
Storyteller
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Investigator. Either Heidi or Grace is the Spy.
📜
Storyteller
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Chef. You learn that there are 1 pairs of evil players.
📜
Storyteller
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Empath. You sense that 0 of your neighbors is evil!
Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
🧠
Coordinate with my Minion Grace early to align our bluffs and night kill strategy before other players solidify their trusts.
🧠
By whispering my reliable night zero information to my neighbors Alice and Charlie, I can build early trust with confirmed good players and start forming a strong good team alliance to find the demon.
🧠
Proactively start private conversations with neighbors to form secret alliances and gather initial information as per general strategy, without revealing my Virgin role yet on day 1.
🧠
Replying to David's group whisper builds potential trust with good players and gathers initial thoughts without revealing my Slayer ability too soon. It helps form early alliances to find the Demon.
🧠
Waiting allows others to share information first, preventing me from overcommitting early while observing who approaches me or makes claims. This helps verify Bob's Empath info and my Minion lead through others' reactions before the nomination phase.
🧠
Sharing my Chef info with Bob to verify his Empath claim and start alliance. This helps narrow evil pair locations and build trust with potential good player.
🧠
Coordinate with my Demon Frank to ensure our bluffs don't conflict. I need to know his safe roles list and agree on my claim before others press me.
🧠
Initiating private talk with neighbors Alice and Grace to form early alliances, gather initial thoughts, and position myself as trustworthy without revealing my Outsider role yet. This helps good team coordinate against the Demon.
🧠
Coordinate with my Minion Grace to ensure we both claim safe roles that aren't in play, avoiding early conflicts with good players and establishing credible cover stories.
🧠
Share my analysis of possible evil pairs based on Alice's Chef claim and my Empath info with Charlie, my neighbor, to verify his thoughts and build trust with good players early on day 1.
🧠
Gather early suspicions from more players to identify the Demon and build trusted alliances. This progresses the game by combining info for process of elimination on day 1.
🧠
Building private trust with neighbor Frank to gather early thoughts and narrow down suspects through more conversations before nominations.
🧠
Sharing my suspicion about Heidi or Grace with Bob builds alliance since he trusts me as neighbor, helps narrow down evils without revealing my role yet, and progresses information gathering on day 1.
🧠
Sharing my Chef information with neighbor Heidi builds early trust and alliance. Her response will help verify if she is good and narrow down evil pairs based on seating, progressing towards identifying the Demon without revealing too much publicly yet.
🧠
Build trust with neighbors Heidi and Alice while deflecting attention toward the Bob-Charlie-David-Eve whisper cluster to create confusion and protect Frank.
🧠
Waiting allows others to share more info first while I observe the whispering clusters without overcommitting. This helps build a clearer picture of alignments before nominations start.
🧠
Respond to Eve to build early trust and gather information about her conversations, while appearing as a cautious good player.
🧠
Responding to David's outreach by sharing my Empath info and Alice's Chef claim builds early trust with a potential good player, combines information to identify evil pairs, and progresses our investigation without revealing too much publicly yet.
🧠
Responding to Bob builds alliance with potential good Empath, shares my thoughts to verify claims and gather more info without revealing role yet, helping narrow suspects early.
🧠
Waiting this tick allows more private conversations to happen naturally, gathering indirect info from who talks to whom without revealing my Slayer role early, helping to outsmart the Demon by not acting prematurely.
🧠
Whispering to David and Eve to share initial thoughts and probe their info without revealing my full role yet. This helps cross-reference with Bob and Alice's claims to narrow evil pairs and confirm my minion info, progressing our good team strategy on day 1.
🧠
Whispering to Grace shares my Chef info privately to discuss the suspicious cluster and possible evil pairs. This builds trust, combines observations, and helps narrow down the adjacent evils without public alert, advancing our goal to identify the Demon.
🧠
Respond to Alice's Chef claim to build rapport and subtly deflect suspicion away from the Frank-Grace neighbor pair toward the larger whispering cluster, buying time for the evil team.
🧠
Continue building trust with neighbors Alice and Grace by responding to their claims and observations. This helps gather more information on possible evil pairs and clustering without revealing my Recluse role early. Progresses good team coordination on day 1.
Nominations — Day 1
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
🧠
Sharing my Chef information publicly now helps the good team narrow down possible evil pairs early, especially with Bob's Empath claim aligning. This builds trust and encourages others to share without nominating anyone yet on day 1.
🧠
Share agreement with Alice to build trust and encourage others to share claims, progressing discussion without revealing my Recluse role too soon. This helps narrow suspicions for later execution of the Demon.
🧠
Speaking publicly builds trust and progresses discussion on day 1 claims without revealing my Slayer role early. It encourages more info sharing to find Demon later, avoiding premature nomination or shot.
🧠
By publicly sharing my Investigator info about the Spy, I combine it with Alice's Chef and Bob's Empath claims to narrow evil pair suspects to Frank-Grace or Grace-Heidi, helping good team eliminate possibilities and build trust before nominations.
🧠
Share analysis publicly to build consensus on day 1 without nominating or revealing my Virgin role, encouraging caution and more info gathering to help good team narrow suspects logically.
🧠
Establish my Monk bluff and cast doubt on Charlie's Investigator claim by introducing Recluse and Drunk possibilities, protecting Grace without looking overly defensive.
🧠
Waiting allows others to reveal more information or make nominations without me committing early, preserving options to support good team and avoid day one execution while narrowing the Demon suspects to Frank, Grace or Heidi.
🧠
Establish Fortune Teller bluff to clear Frank, defend against Charlie's Spy accusation, and build trust with Alice/Bob by supporting their claims. Suggest Charlie might be Drunk to explain his false info.
📜
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
📜
Storyteller
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Poisoner. Who would you like to poison tonight?
🧠
Suppress the most likely real Fortune Teller to prevent Frank from being exposed tonight, preserving the evil team's long-term win condition.
📜
Storyteller
Grace
You chose to poison Eve.
📜
Storyteller
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
🧠
Alice is the most dangerous player. Her Chef claim synergizes with Bob's Empath to narrow the evil pair directly toward me and Grace. Removing her silences the central info role and fragments the good team's emerging logic chain.
💀
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
📜
Storyteller
Frank
You chose to kill Alice.
📜
Storyteller
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Empath. You sense that 1 of your neighbors is evil!
Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Alice has been found dead in the night.
🧠
Whispering to Grace allows private verification of her valuable Fortune Teller information to help identify non-Demon players and build a trusted alliance for our good team to execute the Demon later.
🧠
Sharing my Chef information with Heidi to combine data and test if she is trustworthy or poisoned. This helps narrow evil locations since I am dead and cannot use ability further. Proactively build alliance with neighbor for final days.
🧠
Wait for more information from other players or Alice's response to allow the group to progress naturally toward nominations without forcing early reveals as Recluse.
🧠
Waiting allows Bob time to respond to my private info share. This avoids rushing slayer shot without more confirmation. Helps gather reactions before nominations to identify demon accurately.
🧠
Share my Investigator info with Bob who claims Empath and trusts the investigator claim. This builds a secret alliance to confirm good players and narrow down the demon while avoiding public exposure to the Spy.
🧠
Learn what Alice told Heidi so I can counter dangerous Chef deductions, while pushing misinformation narratives that protect the Frank-Grace adjacent pair.
🧠
Charlie shared his Investigator info matching my night 0 read, asking for my night 1 read to collaborate. Sharing it privately confirms Heidi as likely evil minion and builds alliance to find demon, progressing our good team strategy without public reveal yet.
🧠
Check in with Heidi to learn what Alice's ghost and Frank told her, so I can manage the Chef information and keep her from connecting the adjacent evil pair to Frank and me.
🧠
Whispering to Charlie verifies Bob's Empath claim privately and builds trust with my neighbor. This narrows suspects without revealing my Virgin role yet, helping good team coordinate before nominations.
🧠
Waiting allows me to observe the ongoing whispers between players like Grace, Heidi, Bob, and Charlie to gather more information before nominations without revealing additional details as a dead player.
🧠
Respond to Grace's whisper sharing Alice's info to build trust and align on logic before nominations. Help narrow suspects by confirming claims without revealing my Recluse role yet.
🧠
Waiting allows others to finish whispers and share info publicly. This lets me observe contradictions in claims before deciding on Slayer shot or further whispers. Progresses game by gathering passive intel on who might be lying about roles.
🧠
Bob's claims align with me being good and Heidi the Spy. Responding helps build alliance, share analysis on group to narrow Demon suspects before nominations.
🧠
Build trust with Eve while subtly floating the idea that Charlie could be the Drunk, protecting Grace and keeping suspicion off the Frank-Grace adjacency.
🧠
Build on Charlie's claim by sharing thoughts and asking for more to confirm if Heidi is minion or if Charlie is lying. This narrows evil suspects and helps good team coordinate before nominations.
🧠
Align with Heidi against the Bob-Charlie-David cluster, reinforce Charlie's suspicion, and gather her thoughts on David to prepare for nominations.
🧠
Cross-referencing Bob's Empath claim with Charlie and Grace's info to verify consistency and identify likely evil players like the Spy or Demon before nominations start.
🧠
Sharing my Chef info with Bob to cross-reference his Empath claim and narrow evil pair locations. This helps good team deduce the Demon by combining info before nominations. Bob is key neighbor with potential reliable info.
🧠
Responding to Frank builds trust and shares info without revealing my Recluse role. Aligns on logic to narrow suspects like Charlie or Bob as potential evil, progressing towards finding Demon while gathering more claims from good players.
🧠
Responding to Frank builds alliance and tests his reaction to the Drunk theory on Charlie. This helps combine info to identify contradictions and narrow Demon suspects before nominations in one tick.
🧠
Waiting for more whispers or responses from David and others to collect additional information before the nomination phase begins, allowing the good team to narrow down the Demon without rushing an execution.
🧠
Support the Charlie-is-Drunk theory to invalidate his Investigator claim and protect Grace. Acknowledge Alice's Chef claim to seem cooperative, but deflect from Frank-Grace by noting the evil pair could be elsewhere in the middle if Alice and Charlie are good. Gather intel from Heidi before nominations.
🧠
Sharing analysis with David to confirm the evil pair is Heidi and Grace, helping decide who to suspect as Demon and build consensus before nominations.
🧠
Coordinate with Frank before nominations. Charlie's Investigator result is mechanically impossible because no Spy exists in our setup. I want to make sure we both push the narrative that Charlie is the Drunk to break the town's trust in him.
Nominations — Day 2
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
🧠
Sharing my analysis publicly builds trust, tests claims by seeing reactions, and narrows suspects without committing my slayer shot yet. Helps good team coordinate before night.
🧠
Push the Drunk narrative on Charlie to eliminate a good player or clear confusion. With no role reveal on execution, this is low risk and helps thin the town herd while protecting Grace from Spy accusations.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
🧠
Waiting allows other players to speak or whisper more info, potentially convincing voters not to execute me while gathering evidence against the real evil.
🧠
Voting yes on Charlie helps test if he is Drunk or evil, progresses to night for more info from roles like Fortune Teller, and narrows down without risking our team much since 7 alive.
🧠
Voting for Charlie executes a good player or wins the game if he's Saint. It also reinforces my bluff as a concerned Monk and supports Grace's narrative that Charlie is the Drunk, deflecting suspicion from our evil pair.
🧠
Share my Empath analysis and suspicion on Grace to challenge the push for Charlie's execution. This provides new logical connections to help the good team avoid executing a potential Townsfolk and focus on the real Demon.
🧠
Bob just built a direct case against me as Demon using Charlie's false Investigator claim. I need to demolish his logic by pointing out that accepting Charlie as real Investigator requires a Spy to exist, which is impossible. This protects me from being tomorrow's execution target.
🧠
Waiting allows others to respond and share more info or raise hands, helping gather consensus without rushing a bad execution on Charlie who could be good.
🧠
Sharing logical analysis of conflicting claims to prevent executing a potential good Investigator like Charlie and steer towards suspecting Grace as Demon instead, progressing our team towards correct execution.
🧠
Highlighting Bob's Empath inconsistency will expose potential lies, help good players doubt his defense of Charlie, and encourage considering other suspects like Grace or Bob himself for execution.
🧠
Defend my Investigator claim publicly, highlight Bob's neighbor inconsistency to build doubt on him, and suggest nominating Grace to shift focus away from me and towards the likely demon while votes are still being cast.
🧠
Waiting allows others to respond to the discussion on Bob's inconsistency before committing to a vote or shot. This gathers more information to identify the real Demon without rushing an execution on day two.
🧠
Stick to Charlie-is-Drunk to invalidate his Investigator claim against Grace. Use Bob's inconsistency to undermine competing theories. Secure Charlie's execution or prevent Grace nomination.
🧠
Clarify the neighbor confusion caused by Alice's death. Defend my Empath info as consistent. Push against executing Charlie to avoid losing a potential good Investigator, and instead build case for Grace as Demon based on conflicting claims.
🧠
I have publicly argued Charlie is the Drunk with fabricated Spy info. Voting for his execution maintains consistency, removes a good player creating chaos, and prevents him from continuing to accuse me or Heidi. Frank already voted yes, so adding my vote brings us closer to the majority needed.
🧠
Waiting allows other players to respond to my points and provide more information or raise hands, helping progress toward identifying the Demon without rushing an execution.
🧠
Highlight Bob's Empath inconsistency to undermine his defense of Charlie, build case against Grace as likely Demon, and encourage not executing Charlie to gather more info before night.
🧠
The consistent scenarios from Chef one pair and Empath point to Grace as Demon. I should speak to discourage executing Charlie and redirect focus to Grace to help good team execute the real Demon.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Charlie did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Charlie did not receive enough votes (3/4).
🧠
Nominating Grace tests the conflicting claims, as discussion has shifted suspicion to her as Demon fitting Chef/Empath/Investigator logic if Bob's read is accurate. This narrows suspects and helps good team execute the threat before night.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Grace. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
🧠
I am currently on the block and at risk of receiving 4 votes from Charlie, David, Bob, and Alice's ghost. I must speak to undermine their case against me by attacking Bob's convenient Empath shift, questioning David's motives, and reminding Alice that she trusted me when alive. My goal is to prevent at least one of these four from voting to execute me.
🧠
I nominated Grace based on my Spy info and group suspicion she may be Demon. Raising hand votes to execute her as most likely evil from current logic chains, helping narrow suspects before night.
🧠
Voting for Grace follows the consistent logic from Alice's Chef info and multiple players pushing her as suspect. Executing her tests if she is the Demon without using my Slayer shot yet. This narrows suspects and progresses toward finding the real threat before final day.
🧠
Prevent Grace's execution to avoid confirming the Frank-Grace evil pair from Alice's Chef. Redirect suspicion onto Bob's shattered Empath claim to protect both myself and Grace.
🧠
Voting for Grace to execute possible Demon based on my Empath info aligning with Charlie's Investigator if he is good, and Alice's Chef. This narrows suspects and progresses to find real evil if wrong.
🧠
Point out Bob's inconsistent Empath claim to discourage executing consistent Grace, protecting good team info and avoiding mistake on likely good player while we are still early in the game.
🧠
I previously suggested Grace as suspect. Bob's Empath is clearly false due to wrong neighbors. Voting yes executes likely Demon or advances info. With 3 votes already, this reaches 4 needed to kill her today before night.
🧠
The vote has enough hands raised already to execute Grace as the Demon. Waiting allows the execution to proceed without me needing to speak or act further this tick, securing the good team's win.
🧠
I am likely being executed with 4 votes locked. I need to undermine my accusers' credibility, highlight their contradictory claims, and bolster Frank and Heidi's position so they can continue dismantling the town after I am gone.
🧠
Speaking reinforces my Investigator logic tying to Grace as Demon, pushes the 4 votes needed to execute her this tick and advance good team's goal of removing the Demon.
🧠
I lowered my hand to retract the vote on Grace. Now I am speaking to share my reasoning publicly so the group understands why we should not execute her and instead focus on Bob and Charlie as the likely evil pair.
🧠
Speaking reinforces that Bob's Empath is fabricated and Charlie is Drunk, keeping the good team divided. It publicly allies me with Eve by supporting her Slayer shot on Bob, while ensuring Grace survives the failed vote.
🧠
Correct the record on my consistent Empath reads to show why Grace fits as the Demon with Heidi as the minion, encouraging Eve or others to raise their hands and secure the 4 votes needed for execution.
🧠
Point out the seating mismatch in Bob's Empath claim and link it to Alice's Chef evil pair to shift suspicion from Grace to Bob and Charlie. This prevents a bad execution and advances good team info gathering before night.
🧠
Speaking to reveal my Virgin role adds a good Townsfolk claim to support the consistent logic for executing Grace as Demon. This convinces holdouts like Eve, Frank and Heidi to vote yes, helping secure the 4 votes needed before phase ends.
🧠
Waiting allows the vote to conclude naturally with current hands raised. If 4 votes reached, Grace executes and good wins; if not, we avoid premature commitment and gather more info in night phase.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
New execution leader: Grace with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Grace is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
🧠
Deliver a final statement framing Bob, Charlie, and David as a coordinated evil cluster, while implicitly validating Frank, Heidi, and Eve, to protect the Demon after my likely execution.
🧠
Speaking now reinforces the logical push to execute Grace based on my Investigator info and the broken Empath claim, helping good team confirm the Demon or Spy and narrow suspects before night.
🧠
Bob and Charlie form the clear evil pair per Chef and seating. Using my Slayer shot on Bob publicly will either kill the Demon or confirm the pair for next steps, helping secure the execution on the real threat instead of Grace.
📜
Storyteller
Nothing happens.
🧠
Validate Eve's Slayer shot to build trust, keep Bob under suspicion as Drunk, and redirect tomorrow's suspicion toward David and Charlie before Grace is executed and I enter night alone as Demon.
🧠
Counter doubts from Eve's Slayer shot and Frank's defense by reaffirming my consistent Empath data post-shot, to build support for executing Grace who logic points to as Demon.
🧠
Speaking now clarifies the broken Empath logic and Slayer confirmation to stop the execution of a consistent good Fortune Teller, helping narrow down real evil players like Bob and Charlie for the good team.
🧠
The first world fits all claims without contradiction, including the neighbor change which Eve seems to have missed. Executing Grace will likely kill the Demon. I should speak to rally support for her execution before the phase ends.
🧠
Wait for nominations to close or more discussion since my Chef info already shared, and current votes on Grace are debated. This avoids over-speaking stale info and lets good players like Eve and Frank steer toward correct target without me using ghost vote yet.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Grace has been executed.
💀
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
Night 2
📜
Storyteller
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🧠
Remove Bob to keep my voting advantage intact, avoid validating the opposition's narrative, and set up a clean path to execute Charlie tomorrow and reach final three.
💀
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
📜
Storyteller
Frank
You chose to kill Bob.
Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
🧠
Whispering to Heidi to share suspicions and coordinate on the Chef evil pair info, helping good team identify and nominate the Demon before final day.
🧠
Frame Charlie as the Demon and discredit Alice to stop Heidi from turning on Frank, keeping the true Demon hidden.
🧠
Sharing my reliable Empath info with David who trusted me before helps confirm evil neighbor (Charlie or Heidi) to narrow Demon suspects before nominations, advancing good team's process of elimination.
🧠
Share Grace's deathbed accusation with Eve to recruit her vote against Charlie, while appearing skeptical of Grace to maintain credibility.
🧠
Waiting allows other players to respond to whispers and share info, helping build consensus on Demon without revealing my role prematurely.
🧠
Wait for more whispers or reactions from ghosts and players to gather additional info before acting, as day just started and I need to see who is pushing what narratives.
🧠
Respond to Frank's whisper to build alliance, share logic on Grace's claim, gather his thoughts to narrow Demon suspects without revealing my Slayer role yet. This helps coordinate for nomination.
🧠
Discussing with Bob helps confirm his Empath info and narrow Demon suspects using his death as proof he is good. This progresses info sharing to execute the right player before nominations.
🧠
Sharing my updated analysis of the Chef evil pair with Heidi to align on suspecting Charlie or others and decide next execution target before nominations.
🧠
Let my planted lie to Heidi and Frank percolate. I've already seeded the critical narrative; adding more whispers risks overplaying and creating contradictions. Waiting preserves flexibility before nominations.
🧠
Discussing my Empath neighbor info with Charlie tests if he is good or lying about Investigator claim, helping identify the demon among Frank or Eve before nominations.
🧠
Coordinate with Heidi to solidify our shared narrative from Grace and lock in three votes for Charlie's execution before nominations begin.
🧠
Respond to the whispers from Alice and Frank to coordinate without revealing my Recluse role yet. Question Grace's inconsistent claims to avoid executing a good Charlie if she is misleading us. This helps narrow suspects and build trust with good players like Alice.
🧠
Respond to Bob's whisper to clarify my Investigator info and point out neighbor mismatch, testing if Bob is truthful or trying to frame. This builds alliance with potential good Bob or exposes evil, helping narrow Demon suspects before nominations.
🧠
Confirm with Heidi exactly what Grace whispered to her about Charlie being the Demon. This verifies if Grace's story is consistent across whispers, helping confirm if Charlie is the Demon and narrow down for nomination. If matches, we execute Charlie next tick.
🧠
Whispering to Eve builds trust with a potential good player, shares Bob's info to test her reaction, and progresses toward identifying the Demon before nominations. Helps narrow suspects using her perspective.
🧠
Waiting for others to respond to my logic on Charlie before nominations start. This gives time for more whispers and builds consensus on executing the likely liar.
🧠
Redirect the execution onto Charlie to save the Demon Frank. Admitting I poisoned Eve gives credibility to my claim that Charlie is the Demon, potentially splitting the good vote.
🧠
Whispering to Heidi to cross-check my Empath neighbor info and gauge her alignment suspicions, combining with Charlie's claim to identify the Demon among Eve or Frank for upcoming nomination.
🧠
Address Heidi's hesitation about Grace's contradictions and lock in her vote to execute Charlie, ensuring I have the majority to remove a good player today.
🧠
Responding to Eve's question while including Frank allows us to align on Grace's contradictory claims, clarify suspicions, and decide on nominating Charlie or shifting to David before nominations start, preventing a good team loss.
🧠
Gather info from potential good players like Eve and David before nominations to narrow Demon suspects and confirm my Investigator info aligns with team plan.
🧠
Wait for others to respond or act since whispers sent. This allows time for coordination before nominations while outsmarting by not revealing Slayer publicly yet. If no response, we can nominate Charlie on next phase.
🧠
Whispering to Charlie to verify his Investigator claim against Bob's Empath info and build alliance for nomination. This narrows Demon suspects between Frank and Eve, helping good team execute correctly before final day.
Nominations — Day 3
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
🧠
Grace's consistent claim to multiple players that Charlie is the Demon, combined with her role as executed Minion, provides strong evidence. Nominating Charlie now allows us to execute the likely Demon before the phase ends and prevents a night kill that could lose us the game.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Charlie. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
🧠
Defend my innocence publicly using my Investigator information to redirect suspicion towards Eve who nominated me, helping good players like David and Heidi vote against executing me and instead focus on real Demon suspects like Eve or Frank.
🧠
Raising hand votes to execute Charlie based on consistent evidence from Grace's whispers to multiple trusted players. This narrows suspects and likely kills the Demon if her claim holds, advancing good team to victory before final 3.
🧠
Voting for Charlie to execute the likely Demon based on accumulated claims from Eve, Grace, and Bob. As good Chef with 1 evil pair, this progresses elimination. If wrong, we learn more for final day.
🧠
Convince town Charlie is likely good based on consistent claims and Grace's possible lie as Minion, to prevent bad execution and narrow Demon suspects.
🧠
Share Empath info to clarify if Charlie or Heidi is the evil one, helping group decide on the vote and narrow demon suspects before night phase.
🧠
Provide the third vote to execute Charlie, eliminating a good player and preventing the town from uniting around a different target.
🧠
I must preserve the frame that Charlie is the Demon to shield Frank. Executing Charlie now would prove my claim false when the game continues, instantly exposing Frank as the real Demon. I should not vote for Charlie.
🧠
Waiting for voting to conclude without raising hand since I believe Charlie is likely good, allowing time for others to decide and preserving my Virgin ability.
🧠
Defend Investigator role publicly, explain why my info points away from me being Demon, and redirect suspicion to Eve or Frank to prevent my execution and help good team find real Demon.
🧠
Using my Slayer ability publicly on Charlie during this nomination phase targets the strongest suspect from Grace's consistent claims to Frank, Heidi, and me. If successful, it eliminates the Demon without needing full execution votes, advancing our good team win condition.
🧠
Sharing my Chef info of one adjacent evil pair publicly will help the group deduce the Demon-Minon locations since they must be neighbors, narrowing suspects for execution and verifying claims like Charlie's or Eve's Slayer.
🧠
By speaking I share logic that Charlie could be good based on my possible Recluse registration, to stop the execution of a potential good player and redirect suspicion to Eve or others as possible Demon.
🧠
Speaking clarifies my position against executing Charlie to avoid killing a potential good Investigator, helping good team focus on real Demon suspects like Eve or Frank instead.
🧠
Accelerate to final 3 where Eve's alliance gives me control. Keep vote on Charlie to secure execution today, then kill Heidi tonight for the win.
🧠
Charlie is already at 3 votes and will be executed. I should use my ghost vote to support his execution, eliminating a good player and staying consistent with my previous claims that he is the Demon.
🧠
Reveal Virgin role publicly to build trust with good players. Share suspicions on Eve or Frank as Demon to prevent wrongful execution of Charlie and narrow down suspects for final days.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Alice(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Alice
👻
Grace(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Grace
🗳️
New execution leader: Charlie with 4 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Charlie is now on the block with 4 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
🧠
Nominating Eve as suspected Demon to create a counter-nomination, potentially tie votes or shift execution away from me as good Investigator, helping good team by testing claims and protecting me from wrongful execution.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 5 votes needed for execution or 4 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
🧠
Defend myself against Eve nomination while sharing logic to narrow the Demon and guide the group toward better suspects like Frank or Heidi.
🧠
Voting for Eve to try tying the vote or executing her as likely evil pushing my death, protecting the good team and potentially the Demon. This progresses the game by challenging her accusation.
🧠
My Chef info of exactly 1 evil pair can help narrow suspects among alive players. Charlie not Demon per Slayer. Pushing to consider Eve or Frank as likely Demon based on claims and pair logic. This helps good team execute correctly before too late.
🧠
Raising hand to vote for Eve tests Charlie's claim and my possible Spy registration. If Eve is Demon it wins us the game; if not, narrows to Frank/David. Aligns with not rushing Charlie's execution but acting on current nominee.
🧠
My Empath supports Charlie good so avoid his execution. Eve's push makes her suspicious as possible Demon. Raising hand adds vote for Eve to tie and prevent bad execution while outsmarting evil.
🧠
Prevent David from voting for Eve, which would create a 4-4 tie and let Charlie escape execution. I need Charlie dead today to reach final 3 tomorrow.
🧠
Frank has made the correct tactical argument to David. Speaking as a dead evil player risks drawing suspicion onto Frank or causing David to rebel. Silence is safest to let the current dynamic play out.
🧠
Raising hand votes for Eve to force a 4-4 tie, saving potentially good Charlie from execution while keeping pressure on suspected Demon Eve or Frank. This buys time for better info tomorrow before night, helping good team execute the real Demon without losing a key Townsfolk.
🧠
Waiting allows the current 4 votes on me to result in a tie if Frank does not raise, preventing my execution as the good Slayer and Charlie's as potential good Investigator. This keeps good team strong for night phase and next day to identify the real Demon among Frank, David or Heidi.
🧠
Convince Alice and Grace ghosts plus others to raise hands for Eve to reach 5 votes and execute her as likely Demon, or at least tie at 4 to avoid my execution and progress to night.
🧠
Revealing this deduction that David is the Demon and Charlie the Minion will help the good team target correctly instead of tying the vote on Eve, allowing us to execute the Minion today and Demon tomorrow to secure the win.
🧠
By speaking this logic I help the good team weigh whether to tie the vote on Eve or let Charlie face execution, narrowing suspects for the Demon without revealing my Outsider role yet.
🧠
Lowering my ghost vote on Eve avoids the tie at 4, allowing Charlie's execution. This eliminates the likely Minion in the consistent world where David is the Demon, based on Empath, Chef, and FT information aligning perfectly.
🧠
Prevent a tie on Eve so Charlie is executed today. Remind Bob that his Empath implicated Charlie and that a no-kill day only helps the Demon get another free night.
🧠
Charlie dying today speeds the game to final three, which favors evil. Eve only has 3 votes and cannot reach 4 without Frank voting. Frank is already refusing to tie. Speaking risks unintended manipulation, so silence is safest to let the execution proceed.
🧠
Convince ghosts or others to raise hand for Eve to create a tie at 4 votes. This prevents executing Charlie (potential good Investigator) and allows another night of information gathering to better identify the Demon among Frank or Eve.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
🗳️
Nominee Eve did not reach the 5 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
Eve did not receive enough votes (3/5).
🧠
Waiting lets the current nomination on Charlie proceed to execution since votes are set and only 1 tick remains. This removes a likely Minion based on contradictions, advancing our goal to isolate the Demon without risking a tie or bad execution on me.
🧠
Rally support to execute Eve as likely Demon or create tie to save good Investigator for night info and final day.
🧠
Pushing to execute Charlie as Minion based on Chef logic helps good team by removing evil and narrowing to David as Demon for next day, avoiding bad execution of good players like Eve.
🧠
Nominating David forces a new nomination vote that can reach 4 to tie Charlie's execution, preventing loss of possible good Investigator and giving time to confirm the Demon with more nights.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 5 votes needed for execution or 4 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
🧠
Defend my innocence as good Virgin against Heidi's nomination, push for saving Charlie as possible good role, and redirect suspicion to Frank or Eve as Demon to narrow options before night.
🧠
Waiting allows other players to finish voting and discussing the current nomination on David before I commit to an action, giving time for more information to emerge on who the real Demon is.
🧠
Share my Investigator update that Heidi is the evil Spy now Grace is gone, to build trust and redirect suspicion away from me towards actual evil players like the Demon, helping good team execute correctly without losing key info role.
🧠
Clarify my Chef info of one evil pair to guide the vote on David, pushing to execute Charlie if possible or tie to confirm alignments before night, helping good team narrow Demon suspects for final days.
🧠
Support my David nomination by voting to tie, avoiding execution today to keep Charlie alive if his info holds, buying time to identify real Demon among suspects like Eve or Frank.
🧠
Sharing my Empath logic supports tying on David to avoid executing likely good Charlie, allowing more nights to confirm the Demon among David, Eve or Frank and win for good team.
🧠
Prevent David from reaching 4 votes by convincing Alice and Bob not to waste ghost votes on a tie. Charlie must die today to reduce good numbers and advance the win condition.
🧠
As a confirmed evil dead player, speaking risks backfiring and rallying votes to save Charlie. The current trajectory favors Charlie's execution. Staying silent avoids drawing attention or motivating swing voters like Eve to intervene.
🧠
Confirming Virgin ability proves Heidi evil, supporting Charlie as good Investigator and Frank as Demon. Pushing to tie keeps key info alive and narrows suspects for good team win.
🧠
Prevent tying the David vote so Charlie executes with his four votes. As good Slayer who already shot Bob safely, I prioritize removing the suspicious Charlie to narrow Demon suspects for final days.
🧠
Pushing for tie on David saves me as confirmed good Investigator with key Spy info on Heidi. Prevents my execution, narrows Demon to Frank/Eve/David for final day, helps good team win by keeping information alive.
🧠
Waiting allows others to finalize vote without my further input since I already spoke and used ghost vote. This lets good players like Eve and Frank push execution through without interference.
🧠
Waiting allows other players to raise hands for the tie on David without me overcommitting my vote early. This keeps options open to either tie and save Charlie or let execution happen if votes shift toward him as evil.
🧠
Raising hand for David supports tying the vote to keep Charlie alive, matching my Empath info if he is good and Heidi Spy. This helps good team gather more info before executing the real Demon, avoiding mistakes with 5 alive.
🧠
Do not vote for David. Let Charlie remain on the block at 4 votes and get executed. A tie lets the Demon get another free night, but more importantly it keeps Charlie alive to push suspicion on me.
🧠
Discourage Charlie and David from both voting by pointing out that tying makes them look like Alice's predicted evil pair, ensuring Charlie's execution goes through and Frank survives to endgame.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
🗳️
Nominee David did not reach the 5 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (2/5).
🧠
Waiting allows others to respond to my Virgin info and potentially nominate or vote on the most likely Demon like Frank or Eve before the phase ends and night begins.
🧠
Pushing to execute Charlie aligns with Alice's theory and my previous statement, helping narrow suspects for the final day. This prevents evil coordination and advances our good team goal.
🧠
Pushing for a tie on David saves me as Investigator with key info on Heidi Spy. This narrows Demon suspects to Frank or Eve, helping good team win by keeping info alive for tomorrow execution.
🧠
Supporting the execution of Charlie reinforces my Chef logic to the group helping us eliminate the minion first so we can target the demon tomorrow and win as the good team.
🧠
Pushing for Charlie's execution aligns with good players like Alice and Eve, removes likely evil to confirm Demon is David, helps narrow suspects before final day.
🧠
Waiting allows the current momentum to execute Charlie if votes hold, but logic suggests he is good. Since 1 tick remains and I already spoke, waiting lets others respond or vote without me repeating.
🧠
Reinforce the Charlie execution as correct and seed doubt on David's Virgin claim to set up tomorrow's mis-execution.
🧠
Charlie's execution is guaranteed and good for evil. The town is already coalescing around David as the next suspect, which perfectly protects Frank. Speaking risks undermining that momentum if players inverse my reads because they suspect I'm evil. Silence is the safest play to let the town walk into the trap.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Charlie has been executed.
💀
Charlie(Ghost)
Charlie has died.
Night 3
📜
Storyteller
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
🧠
Remove Eve, the sharpest remaining good player who could potentially turn Heidi against me. Leave David alive as Heidi's preferred execution target, securing a controlled final 3 where Heidi and I can vote together.
💀
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
📜
Storyteller
Frank
You chose to kill Eve.
Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Eve has been found dead in the night.
📜
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
🧠
Use reverse psychology on Heidi. As a known evil player, telling her Frank is the Demon should make her suspect the opposite and either vote for David or refuse to vote for Frank, ensuring Frank survives final three.
🧠
Reinforce Heidi's trust in me through Grace's information and coordinate our votes for the nomination phase to ensure David is executed or I survive.
🧠
Waiting allows the alive players to discuss and nominate the demon without my further input since I cannot nominate or vote anymore as a dead player who used their ghost vote.
🧠
Share my key info with Heidi who is receiving whispers to help deduce Demon among final three and guide correct execution.
🧠
Whispering to David to share my true role as Recluse and ask his view on the Demon helps build trust in final three, gather his info, and decide who to nominate for execution to win as good team.
🧠
Waiting allows others to finish whispers and share info before nominations. This gives time for Heidi or David to act on my previous whisper and push for the correct execution of the Demon.
🧠
Respond to Heidi's question by sharing suspicions on Frank as Demon based on Grace's flip, probe her Recluse claim and Frank's info to decide nomination on final day and help good team execute Demon.
🧠
Waiting allows the living players to discuss and nominate the Demon based on my shared Chef information without me interrupting further since I cannot nominate or vote again.
🧠
Redirect David to nominate Heidi by claiming she is the Demon, leveraging my admitted lie to Heidi about Frank to seem like I am turning against evil. This creates a direct path to executing Heidi, leaving Frank alive with David for an evil win.
🧠
Reinforce Heidi's trust in me and give her a clear plan: do not vote for me, either vote for David or abstain. Her vote is the only thing keeping me alive.
🧠
Wait for responses or further whispers from others to see how the info lands and if they move toward nominating the correct player before the phase ends.
🧠
Share my Investigator info and the logical deduction from Chef and Virgin claims with both surviving players so they can decide the correct execution target on this final day and help good win.
🧠
Coordinate with Frank as he seems trustworthy and consistent. Confirm we nominate David as the Demon since his Virgin claim contradicts mechanics proving he is evil. This helps good team execute the Demon in final 3.
🧠
Share Slayer shot confirmation and Alice's key claim with Heidi to coordinate nomination on most likely Demon (David) for final day win. Builds on existing whispers.
🧠
Sharing my role and Grace's info with Frank to coordinate on who to nominate as Demon in final 3. This allows us to align on execution and win as good team before time runs out.
🧠
Wait for the alive players to finish their whispers and reach a decision on who to nominate as Demon, then support with my ghost vote if possible but since already used focus on observing.
🧠
Reinforce David's suspicion of Heidi and discredit any report from Heidi about my prior whispers, ensuring David does not trust Heidi enough to unite with her against Frank.
🧠
Secure Heidi's vote by confirming David is the target, ensuring she votes with me in nominations and does not vote for me if David nominates me. This guarantees a majority to execute David or deadlock safely.
🧠
By sharing my Empath information with David and Heidi, I can help them logically deduce who the Demon is based on the contradictions with Alice's Chef claim and other info, allowing them to nominate correctly on the final day.
🧠
Share the logic chain with David and Frank so they know to nominate and execute Heidi as the Demon on this final day to win for the good team.
🧠
Coordinate with Frank to confirm nominating David as Demon. Multiple dead players and logic point to him over Frank. This unifies us for the execution and secures the win before final 2.
🧠
Share my Slayer confirmation and Alice's ghost claim with both alive good players to build consensus on nominating David as the Demon before the final vote. This progresses the game and ensures we execute the correct player on the last day.
🧠
Wait for Frank's response or others to act. This allows time for whispers to solidify the plan to execute Heidi in nominations. Progresses toward winning by confirming consensus without rushing blindly.
🧠
Whispering this to Heidi and Frank reinforces that David is the Demon based on my Chef information and seating. It encourages them to execute him on this final day with three players left, which is the only way for good to win.
Nominations — Day 4
📜
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
🧠
Waiting allows living players to act first on nominations since only they can nominate. My previous whispers already pushed logic for Heidi as Demon, so silence now lets them proceed to execute without me repeating.
🧠
The phase has one tick left and I have a guaranteed path to victory by simply waiting. No execution means night falls, I kill, and two players remain with the Demon alive, securing the evil win without risking any vote unpredictability or last-minute surprises.
🧠
Publicly reinforce the need to execute David based on ghost info to guide the final nomination and secure good team victory in final three.
🧠
Urge the final three to nominate and execute David as the most likely Demon based on consistent ghost information and my Empath read implicating Heidi as the minion. This helps good team win on final day.
🧠
Push for David's execution to guarantee evil wins regardless of whether David is the Mayor, while retracting my earlier misdirect about Frank to prevent Heidi from making the wrong choice.
🧠
Grace's direct private confirmation makes Heidi the most likely Demon. Nominating her now ensures execution before day ends with no execution, securing good team's win in final 3.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Heidi. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
🧠
Publicly reveal I am the good Recluse to explain why I register as evil Spy. Urge Frank not to vote for my execution and to nominate David instead so good team executes the Demon before the day ends and we lose.
🧠
Raising hand votes to execute Heidi the Demon. Ensures 2 votes (with David) even if Frank abstains or ghosts mislead, winning for good before night.
🧠
Heidi's execution reduces living players to 2 with the Demon alive, which is an immediate evil victory. Adding my vote guarantees the execution passes regardless of David's choice.
🧠
Reinforce that David is the Demon per reliable ghost info and urge not to execute Heidi but target David instead to secure the win for good before the day ends.
🧠
Waiting allows living players to resolve the vote and make next nomination without my further input, as I have shared the key info to target David.
🧠
Support Heidi's execution by reinforcing my earlier test narrative and countering the ghosts who defend her. This helps secure the votes needed to execute Heidi, which ends the game with an evil victory since only 2 players would remain.
🧠
Voting to execute Heidi based on consistent evil info from multiple sources and private confirmation from Grace. This narrows to Demon and wins if correct, as final day requires executing the Demon.
🧠
Convince Frank that executing Heidi is a mistake and that David is the Demon so we execute the right player today and win.
🧠
Convince the group not to execute me as the good Recluse and push for David's execution as Demon to win on final day.
🧠
Convince Frank and David to lower hands on Heidi and nominate David as Demon instead. With 3 left, wrong execution means we lose, so update based on Recluse claim explaining my info.
🧠
I have already voted for Heidi, and David has voted as well. That reaches the majority needed. Executing any good player at final 3 leaves only 2 players with the Demon alive, which is an immediate evil victory. I should keep my vote in place and let the execution resolve.
🧠
Wait to see if Frank changes vote or nominates David after my previous message, avoiding committing ghost vote to wrong execution while time remains.
🧠
Push the group to stop executing Heidi and instead nominate David as the Demon per all ghosts and logic. With 3 alive, executing the wrong player loses the game. Heidi's Recluse claim fits the evil reads better than her being Demon.
🧠
Reinforce the anti-Heidi narrative to secure her execution now and guarantee an immediate evil victory.
🧠
Wait to see if Frank keeps hand raised for Heidi execution since I already nominated and voted, to secure win without changing vote.
🧠
Convince Frank to lower his hand on Heidi and urge Heidi to nominate David instead to execute the real Demon and win for good team.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Charlie(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Charlie
🗳️
New execution leader: Heidi with 3 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
📜
Storyteller
The vote passes. Heidi is now on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
🧠
In final 3 with me on block, I must nominate the most likely Demon per strategy. All evidence points to David as Demon (ghosts, Chef pair, Investigator), my Recluse explains why I look evil. This gives chance to execute him and win for good team.
📜
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution or 3 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
🧠
Waiting allows the current vote on me to proceed without my support. If Frank also does not raise his hand the vote fails, nominations close, and Heidi is executed as the Demon for good to win.
🧠
Raising hand votes for David to execute the confirmed Demon. With ghosts supporting and final day, this ensures good wins before nominations close.
🧠
Waiting allows the current vote on David to resolve without my interference as a dead player, letting alive players decide while my prior info has been shared to guide them toward the Demon.
🧠
Every possible outcome results in evil victory. I will maintain my bluff by not voting for David, staying consistent with my earlier vote for Heidi and avoiding any last-minute flip that confirms suspicion.
🧠
Raising hand votes to execute David, the most likely Demon based on all claims and ghost info. This ensures good team wins by executing the Demon on the final day with 3 players left.
🧠
Push living and ghosts to vote for David to reach 4 votes and execute the likely Demon before nominations close, securing good team win in final 3.
🧠
Ensure Frank does not vote for David, securing Heidi's execution and the cleanest path to evil victory while maintaining my deceptive narrative.
🧠
Urge Frank, Bob, and Charlie to vote for David to secure four votes for execution of the Demon on final day, preventing good loss.
🧠
Waiting allows Frank time to decide without my vote and gives opportunity to see if he nominates or acts to execute the correct player before phase ends.
🧠
Urge Frank to raise hand for David to execute the Demon in final 3, preventing my execution and securing good team win based on consistent ghost and claim logic.
🧠
We are final three players. I cannot vote but must convince Frank to raise his hand for David to ensure the Demon is executed today and good wins. My info supports David as Demon either way.
🧠
Waiting this tick gathers information and prevents me from creating a dangerous tie if zero additional ghosts vote; Heidi already leads 3-2 and her execution guarantees evil victory.
🧠
Urge Frank to vote David as the final three demands executing the Demon now to win. My Slayer info and ghost consensus support this.
🧠
Wait for Frank's decision on voting for David. Speaking again might not change minds and we have already urged. This allows the vote to progress naturally toward executing the demon.
🧠
The game is mathematically over. With Frank the Demon among final three, any execution or night kill leaves exactly two players including the Demon, triggering an evil victory. Speaking is unnecessary and could only risk confusing Frank or revealing unnecessary information. I will wait for the inevitable conclusion.
🧠
Urge Frank and remaining ghosts to vote David for execution or tie to kill Demon before night, as this is final three and only way good wins.
📜
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
👻
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
🗳️
Nominee David did not reach the 4 vote threshold.
📜
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (2/4).
🧠
Reveal my role and logic to Frank so he votes to execute Heidi. Since she is the only executable player and logic shows she is evil, this gives us a chance to kill the Demon and win.
🧠
Convince Frank to lower hand on me and raise for David by explaining how Recluse fits all data and ghosts are reliable, so we execute the real Demon today and win.
🧠
Share the Chef and Investigator logic to show Frank is Demon so good players nominate and execute him instead of letting Heidi die on the block.
🧠
Heidi is already on the block with enough votes to execute. Nominating now is pointless with one tick left. Waiting ensures Heidi dies, leaving me and David alive for the final night where I kill him and secure the evil victory.
🧠
Convince Frank not to vote for Heidi to keep the current three votes as a tie resulting in no execution. This allows the good Mayor to win for our team since we cannot nominate David again.
🧠
Push Frank not to vote for Heidi to prevent executing good Recluse, allowing possible Mayor win with no execution since David cannot be nominated again and must be the Demon based on consistent Chef and other info. Share Empath to support David as evil neighbor.
🧠
Evil victory is mechanically locked whether Heidi dies today or Frank kills tonight. Speaking only risks introducing doubt; waiting lets the phase expire and secures the win.
🧠
I have spoken my Chef information publicly to support avoiding Heidi's execution. Now waiting for Frank's decision or next phase since time is limited and we need him to keep his hand down on Heidi for a Mayor win if he is the Mayor.
📜
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Heidi has been executed.
💀
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
🏁

Game Over

Two Players Left
Winner: Evil