Game Detail
Players
Alice (Imp) Bob (Monk) Charlie (Librarian) David (Recluse) Eve (Baron) Frank (Butler) Grace (Washerwoman) Heidi (Saint)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 789,786 | 190,268 | $0.3087 |
| Evil | 256,150 | 33,485 | $0.1143 |
Event Timeline
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
You are the Minion. The Demon is Alice.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Minions are: Eve. Your safe bluffs are: Empath, Slayer, Virgin
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Washerwoman. Either David or Bob is the Monk.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Librarian. Either Heidi or Eve is the Saint.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
Good evening Frank. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Frank
Frank made a choice.
π§
Choosing Alice as my master with no information available. Alice is seated first, often a position taken by confident or leadership-type players. Following her tomorrow allows me to vote only if she votes, creating a potential voting alliance.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You chose Alice to be your master.
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
π€
Charlie
β
Eve
Hey Eve, I'm just introducing myself around. Do you have any information you'd like to share, or any roles you're thinking about claiming?
π§
Start building rapport with Eve, who is one of my two potential Saints. I want to gauge her trustworthiness and see if she volunteers any useful information without me revealing my role.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
Hi Eve. I'm feeling like an Empath this game. I'm going to claim it to the group. Who are you planning on claiming? Let's make sure our stories don't clash.
π§
Establish contact with my minion and coordinate our fake claims to ensure consistency.
π€
Grace
β
David
Hey David, I'm checking in with fellow good players early. Are you a role that helps confirm you're good, like a Monk or similar?
π§
As Washerwoman, I know either David or Bob is the Monk. I'll whisper to David first to test if he'll confirm the Monk role, which validates my starting info and begins building a trusted alliance.
π€
David
β
Grace
Hey Grace! I'm a Recluse. I'm actually good, but I might register as evil or as a Minion or Demon to certain character abilities. So if any info comes out about me seeming evil, that could just be my ability confusing things. I'm definitely on the good team though.
π§
Building trust with Grace by being honest about my Recluse role and its confusing registration property. Since she's checking in with good players, she's likely trustworthy and I want to establish a good alliance early.
π€
Heidi
β
Bob
Hi Bob, I'm trying to get a read on the group. Have you heard anything useful from others? I'm trying to figure out who to trust early on. What do you think about the whispers happening so far?
π§
Start gathering information from Bob who hasn't been involved in the early whispers yet. This gives me a fresh perspective on the game state and potential leads to follow.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
Hey Alice, I'm Frank. I picked you as my master last night so I can only vote if you vote today. What did you learn? Who were you whispering with and what did Eve tell you?
π§
Establish alliance with my master Alice, learn what she knows from her whispers with Eve, and gather initial game information without fully revealing my Butler role yet.
π€
Eve
β
Alice
Understood. Empath is a good choice. I think I will claim Librarian to help 'validate' the Outsider count, or maybe Monk to protect you. What do you think? I want to make sure I don't say anything that ruins your Empath claim.
π§
I am establishing a rapport with the Demon (Alice) and aligning our bluffing strategy. It is crucial we don't contradict each other's claims.
π€
Bob
β
Heidi
Hi Heidi, nice to hear from you! I haven't heard much concrete yet - just people chatting. I think the early whispers are mostly people feeling each other out. I'm being careful about who I trust until we get more information. What about you - any initial instincts on anyone?
π§
Build rapport with Heidi while staying guarded. She approached me first, which could mean she's good and trying to organize, or she's evil trying to identify targets. I'll keep my Monk role hidden for now and try to learn more about her.
π€
Charlie
β
Heidi
Hey, I'm trying to get a feel for the village. Do you have any information about roles or anything interesting you've picked up on? I'm open to sharing if we find we can trust each other.
π§
I know Heidi OR Eve is the Saint. Heidi whispered to Bob earlier, so she's active. I want to probe her subtly without revealing my full hand, while also gathering intel on other players. If she claims to be the Saint, my info is confirmed. If not, Eve is likely the Saint.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
Frank just whispered to me claiming he is the Butler and chose me as his master. That is quite interesting. If you claim Librarian, perhaps you can say you found an Outsider claim that is not him to create conflict? Or stick to Monk to protect me. Let's see how it plays out.
π§
I am coordinating with my minion, Eve, regarding Frank's Butler claim. I want to guide her to choose a bluff that causes chaos or supports our narrative. I am acknowledging her previous input while keeping the conversation flowing.
π€
Grace
β
Bob
Hey Bob, I'm checking in with some players early. Are you a role that would help prove you're good, or do you have any information to share about other players?
π§
Following up on my Washerwoman info about David or Bob being the Monk. David claimed to be a Recluse (Outsider), which contradicts him being the Monk (Townsfolk). Either David is lying about being Recluse, or Bob is the Monk. I need to probe Bob without revealing my exact role.
π€
David
β
Eve
Hey Eve! I'm David. I've been chatting with some players. Have you learned anything interesting from others? I'm trying to get a sense of who might be trustworthy. What have you heard so far?
π§
Gather information from Eve who seems to be well-connected. She has received whispers from multiple players, so she may have useful information. I want to learn what others have been saying before deciding how to proceed.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, nice to hear from you! I'm still getting my bearings. I've been chatting with Bob who seems reasonable. I haven't picked up much concrete yet, but I'm being careful about who I share information with. What made you reach out to me specifically? Any initial thoughts on the group so far?
π§
Build trust with Charlie who initiated contact. Charlie might have useful information or could be a valuable ally. Since I'm an Outsider with no ability to prove myself, I need to form alliances carefully. I'll keep my Saint role hidden for now.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
Hey Eve, I'm Frank. I've noticed you've been getting whispers from several players. What have you learned so far? Who do you think might be suspicious? I'm trying to help the good team figure things out.
π§
Eve is being whispered to by multiple players (Charlie, Alice, David), suggesting she may have valuable information or is trusted by others. I need to gather intel to help identify the Demon while my voting ability is restricted to Alice.
π€
Eve
β
David
Hey David. Honestly, it's so early I am still gathering my thoughts. Everyone seems pretty chatty! I am trying to figure out who is genuine. Have you heard anything specific about Frank? He approached me earlier and it felt a bit aggressive.
π§
I want to sow slight suspicion towards Frank, who is also acting curious, to create a red herring and keep the focus off my Demon (Alice). I'm playing the helpful but cautious villager.
π€
Bob
β
Grace
Hey Grace, I appreciate you reaching out! I'm definitely a Townsfolk, but I'm keeping my exact role close to the chest for now. What I can say is I'm here to help find the Demon. Have you picked up on anything useful from your conversations? I'd love to hear your instincts.
π§
Grace asked about my role directly. I should deflect without lying too heavily - admitting I'm Townsfolk is truthful but keeping the specific role secret. Asking about her observations builds rapport and may get useful intel.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
Hey Alice, I'm trying to get a feel for the village. Have you heard anything interesting from the other players? I'm being cautious but want to find people I can trust to share information with.
π§
I know either Heidi or Eve is the Saint. I should probe different players to gather information and figure out who I can trust. Alice might have picked up on something from her private chats with Eve and Frank.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
I have been chatting with a few people, trying to piece things together. I am claiming Empath this game. I have not heard much solid info yet, though. What about you, Charlie? Are you comfortable sharing what you are seeing or what role you have?
π§
I am establishing my Empath bluff with Charlie and fishing for his role to see if he is a threat or can be manipulated.
π€
Grace
β
Bob
Hey Bob, thanks for the response! I appreciate you being on the good team. I don't have concrete intel yet, just starting to feel things out. Quick question - are you a role that would benefit the team by staying hidden, like maybe a Slayer or something? I'm trying to figure out who might want to keep a low profile versus who might want to speak up more. What do you think about some of the other players so far?
π§
I'm pressing Bob for more information since I know either David or Bob is the Monk. If Bob is the Monk, he should have some information about who he's protecting. If he's evasive about his role, it might indicate deception.
π€
David
β
Eve
Thanks for the heads up about Frank! Can you tell me more about what he said? Did he claim a specific role or ask you pointed questions? I'm trying to get a read on him. Also, did you notice if he was whispering to anyone else or just you?
π§
Eve mentioned Frank seemed aggressive, which could indicate he's evil trying to push things quickly or just nervous. I need more details to assess if this is suspicious behavior or normal game dynamics.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, good to connect! I appreciate you reaching out. I'm still new here too and trying to figure things out. I'm being cautious about what I share early on since we don't know who's trustworthy yet. What made you want to talk to me specifically? Have you picked up on anything interesting from your other conversations? I'm curious to hear your take on who's acting suspicious or who's given you useful information so far.
π§
Charlie reached out to me first asking about roles and information, but hasn't shared anything concrete yet. I want to encourage them to share first before I reveal anything. As a Saint, I need to be careful about what I reveal since dying by execution loses the game.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
Hey Alice, I need to know what role you're playing and what you've learned so far. I picked you as my master, so my vote depends on yours today. Please tell me what Eve and Charlie told you. We're on the same team if you're good!
π§
Since I can only vote if Alice votes, I must coordinate with her. Alice hasn't responded to my first message yet, so I'm sending a more urgent follow-up to understand her role and what information she's gathered. Building trust with Alice is critical for my voting ability.
π€
Eve
β
David
Frank claimed Butler to me and mentioned he chose Alice as his master. It felt a bit odd, like he was trying to secure her trust immediately. He has been whispering to her a lot. Be careful with him, David. I am leaning toward Monk or Librarian, still deciding.
π§
I want to sow discord between David and Frank by making Frank's behavior seem suspicious, while also casually mentioning my own potential bluffs (Monk/Librarian) to seem helpful and transparent to David.
π€
Bob
β
Grace
Hey Grace, thanks for the thoughtful questions! I'm not a Slayer, so I'm not keeping a low profile for that reason. More that I'm still gathering information and don't want to tip off the Demon too early. As for other players, I've noticed Eve seems to be getting a lot of whispers - not sure what that means yet. What are your instincts on people so far?
π§
Build rapport with Grace while gathering intel. She seems cooperative and is asking good questions. Noting Eve is getting lots of whispers - could indicate she's trusted, or that others suspect her.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Alright everyone, nominations are open. We've had a lot of whispers going on. I think we should start sharing some information out in the open so we can actually make progress. I'll be honest - I don't have strong suspicions yet, but I've noticed some clusters of people talking privately. Let's hear from everyone. What information have you gathered so far?
π§
As a Saint, I want to avoid execution while helping the town find the Demon. Speaking up publicly to gather information without revealing my role allows me to gauge reactions and identify who might be the Demon based on their behavior. I'll push for open information sharing.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I appreciate you calling for open sharing, Heidi. I've had some interesting conversations today. I don't want to fully reveal my role just yet, but I did have an interesting evening and I've narrowed some things down. I know a few of you have been claiming roles already, and I think we should take those claims seriously. I'm still gathering my thoughts, but I'll be ready to share more soon.
π§
Contribute to the information sharing without fully revealing my Librarian role. I know Heidi or Eve is the Saint, but I don't want to expose both as that narrows it down too much for evil. I'll hint at having info and being an information role to build trust while staying safe.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
I want to observe how other players behave during nominations before acting. I have Washerwoman info (David or Bob is Monk), but David already claimed Recluse. If he's lying about Recluse, he could be the Monk - but that's actually GOOD if he's good. Bob claimed Townsfolk but won't specify. I'll wait to see if others reveal useful information or nominate someone first.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
I am the Butler - an Outsider with no proactive information. Revealing my role now would only make me a target with no benefit. I should listen to what Charlie and others reveal before deciding on any action. My vote is locked to Alice today, so I need to understand her alignment before voting.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I agree with Heidi. It is early, but we should be very careful about rushing into an execution today. If we execute the wrong person, we just help the Demon. I am personally leaning towards not executing anyone unless we are absolutely certain about someone's alignment.
π§
Deflect pressure for an execution on Day 1 to keep myself safe and avoid losing a minion.
π¬
David
β
All
I want to add something to the conversation. Eve mentioned to me that Frank approached her and claimed to be a Butler, saying he had chosen Alice as his master. That felt like some useful information to share openly. Frank, is that accurate? And Alice, did Frank approach you with a similar claim?
π§
I've received intel from Eve that Frank claimed Butler to her. This is valuable information to share publicly since it could either validate Frank as a good Outsider or expose him as a lying evil player. I want to hear his response and Alice's confirmation before forming a judgment. This could help us narrow down alignments.
π¬
Eve
β
All
That is correct, David. Frank did approach me with that. I am just trying to be transparent because I think we need to be careful with information. Frank, could you clarify your role and why you felt the need to mention your master so early? It did seem a little forward.
π§
To exacerbate the tension around Frank, making him look suspicious while appearing helpful and open to the town. This supports my earlier private manipulation of David.
β
Bob
Bob waits.
π§
I need to hear Frank's response to the Butler claim before I can evaluate if this is genuine intel or an evil player trying to establish a false narrative. The Butler claim has some red flags - why would a Butler announce himself so openly? If he's lying, he could be the Demon trying to set up a false story. I'll wait for his response and then decide if I need to press further or move to a different line of questioning.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
π―
Bob
Bob made a choice.
π§
Eve is central to today's information flow - she shared the Butler claim and is actively asking questions. As a potential information gatherer, she may be a high-value Demon target. Protecting her preserves her ability to continue sharing intel.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
You chose to protect Eve.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Alice
Alice made a choice.
π§
I want to eliminate Frank because he is trying to confirm my identity as his 'master', which puts a target on my back and complicates my Empath bluff. Removing him sows chaos and prevents him from probing further.
π
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
You chose to kill Frank.
Day 2
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Frank has been found dead in the night.
π€
Charlie
β
Eve
Hey Eve, it's Charlie. I'm the Librarian. Night 0 info told me either you or Heidi is the Saint. Can you confirm if you're the Saint, or do you have other information about yourself? I need to protect you from being executed.
π§
Eve and Heidi are the only two candidates for the Saint. By asking Eve directly about her role, I can narrow down who is the Saint and potentially build trust with her. If she confirms being the Saint, I can protect her. If she denies it, then Heidi must be the Saint. This helps me protect a good player and eliminate one suspect.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, you whispered to Eve right after the day started. What's going on? I know Frank claimed Butler yesterday and he's dead now. Any idea what happened last night? I'm trying to figure out who we can trust.
π§
Gather intel on Charlie's whisper to Eve and Frank's death. Charlie seems to have information since they whispered immediately. Understanding the night 1 events will help me piece together who might be evil.
π€
Eve
β
Charlie
Hi Charlie. Thanks for reaching out. I'm actually not the Saint, so your Librarian info might be pointing to Heidi, or perhaps someone is bluffing. I'm still figuring out my role claim, but I'm definitely not an Outsider. Have you talked to Heidi yet?
π§
I need to deflect suspicion from myself regarding the Outsider claim. Since the Baron adds Outsiders, Charlie might be onto something, so I'll pivot the suspicion to Heidi to sow confusion.
π€
Grace
β
Eve
Hi Eve, I've noticed you've been quite active in the communication network today. I've been watching the game develop and I'm curious what you've learned so far. I know some interesting things from my role that might help us narrow down the Demon. What can you share about what Charlie and Heidi told you?
π§
Eve is central to early game comms and has received multiple whispers. She's a good target to learn what information Charlie and Heidi have shared. This helps me understand the information landscape before making claims.
π€
David
β
Grace
Hey Grace, I wanted to check in with you. Frank died last night after his Butler claim. If he was truly the Butler, he was good and the Demon killed a good player. What information have you gathered so far? Who do you think we should focus on today?
π§
Checking in with Grace who has been coordinating the good players to get her assessment of the game state and potential suspects.
π€
Bob
β
Eve
Eve, I protected you last night. You were active in private chats with Charlie, Grace, and others. What did you learn? Did anyone seem suspicious, especially regarding Frank's Butler claim? I protected you because you were getting whispered to, but now Frank is dead and I need to know if the Demon was after you or someone else.
π§
Eve was the center of private conversations (Charlie, Grace) and I protected her. She likely has insights about Frank's true nature and who might be evil. Understanding her perspective helps me decide who to protect tonight and whether to reveal my role.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
Hey Alice, I'm Frank. I know my death complicates things, but my vote is tied to yours. Any leads on who might be the Demon? I'm dead so I can take risks. What have you learned from Charlie and the others?
π§
Checking in with my master Alice to understand current suspicions and what she's learned from private conversations. My ghost vote is tied to hers, so coordination is key.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
Hey Eve, the town seems busy today. Since Frank is dead, people might be looking for a new lead. How are you holding up with the Librarian claim? Are people buying it, or is the heat on you?
π§
Checking in with my Minion to coordinate our bluffs and gauge how much suspicion she is under.
π€
Charlie
β
Heidi
Heidi, I need to share something important. I'm the Librarian. My Night 0 info told me either you or Eve is the Saint. Eve just told me she's NOT the Saint, which means you must be the Saint. This is critical information - if you're executed, we lose. Please confirm if you're actually the Saint so I know I can trust this information. Also, did anyone approach you with suspicious claims last night?
π§
Share my Librarian info about the Saint with Heidi since Eve confirmed she's not the Saint. This makes Heidi the likely Saint who must be protected from execution. I need verification from Heidi herself before fully committing to this belief.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
Charlie, thank you for sharing that. You're right - I am the Saint. Please keep this between us for now. This is critical information because if I'm executed, Good team loses. We need to protect each other. Now that I know you're likely the Librarian with accurate information, I'm trusting you. Can you tell me more about what Eve said? Did she claim to be a specific role? Also, who do you think is suspicious? Let's figure out who the Demon is before anyone accidentally nominates me.
π§
Confirm my Saint status to Charlie since his Librarian information is accurate. This builds trust and creates an alliance. I need to learn more about Eve's role and who Charlie suspects as the Demon. As the Saint, I must avoid execution while helping find the Demon.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
I haven't learned much yet, Bob. Charlie thinks either I or Heidi are the Saint, which I'm skeptical of. Since Frank is dead, maybe someone is trying to frame us as Outsiders to get us executed. What role are you playing that allows you to protect me?
π§
I need to find out Bob's role so I can either discredit him or manipulate him later, while appearing helpful and cooperative. I also want to sow doubt about Charlie's Librarian claim.
π€
Grace
β
David
Hi David, thanks for reaching out. I agree it is suspicious that Frank died after his Butler claim. I have some information about either you or Bob being a specific Townsfolk, but I'm not ready to share that publicly yet. What can you tell me about why you revealed yourself as Recluse? That seems like an unusual move early in the game.
π§
I'm being cautious with David since he could be the Monk (one of my options) or could be evil. I'll acknowledge his message but probe for more information before revealing my Washerwoman intel.
π€
David
β
Grace
Hey Grace, I appreciate you reaching out! I need to clarify - I don't think I actually revealed myself as Recluse publicly. Did you hear that from someone else? I'd like to know who said that, because it might not be true. As for Frank's death - you're right, it's suspicious. If he was truly the Butler, a good player died. What information do you have about me or Bob? I'm happy to help narrow things down. Who do you think we should focus on today?
π§
Grace is a cooperative player gathering information. She claims I revealed as Recluse but I don't remember doing this - I should clarify and find out if someone is spreading false information about me. I need to build trust while also getting her information about me or Bob being a Townsfolk.
π€
Bob
β
Eve
I protected you because you're a Monk, Eve. I am the one who saved you last night. Frank died, which means he was likely good - either he was a Butler or he was lying about his role. Let's work together. Who do you think is suspicious? We should protect each other and find the Demon.
π§
Reveal my Monk role to Eve since she's asking directly and seems trustworthy. She survived Night 1 with my protection, so she's clearly not the Demon targeting me. We can work together to identify the Demon and protect each other going forward.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
Hey Alice, I need an update. You control my vote now that I'm dead. What have you learned from Charlie? Any suspicions? Also, who do you think killed me? The Demon targeted me after I revealed my Butler role publicly - that tells us something. Who was pushing for that information to come out?
π§
As a dead Butler, my vote is tied to Alice. I need to coordinate with her on strategy and gather information about the Demon. The Demon killed me Night 1 after I publicly revealed my role, which proves I'm good but also suggests my public Butler claim made me a target. I need Alice's assessment of the situation and who she trusts.
π€
Alice
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank, I suspect David or maybe Charlie. They were very aggressive about your role, and now you are gone. I am still sticking with my Empath claim, but it is hard to get a read with all this noise. Stay close, I will need your ghost vote when it counts.
π§
I need to deflect suspicion away from Eve and myself by framing David or Charlie. I also need to reassure Frank (my ghost) so he supports me.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
Hey Bob, it's Charlie. I know you've been talking to Eve quite a bit. What have you two been discussing? I want to make sure we're working together to find the Demon. Also, did anyone approach you with suspicious claims yesterday?
π§
Bob has whispered to Eve multiple times, which seems unusual. If Bob is the Demon, he might be trying to manipulate or gather information from Eve. Since I know the Saint is Heidi and must be protected, I need to identify who might be the Demon. Asking Bob about his conversations with Eve could reveal suspicious behavior.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
Charlie, thanks for confirming that. We need to be very careful. Frank died at night - if he was the Demon, we should be winning, so he must have been good or a Minion. If he was a Minion and the Scarlet Woman is in play, she's now the Demon. What do you think about Eve's claim? She says she's not the Saint, but she could be lying. Also, did you notice Bob whispered to Eve multiple times? That seems suspicious. Can you use your Librarian ability again tonight to check on anyone new?
π§
Continue building alliance with Charlie and analyze the implications of Frank's death. Frank dying at night means he wasn't the Demon - so either he was good/minion. If Minion, Scarlet Woman becomes new Demon. Need to strategize with Charlie about next moves and who to investigate.
π€
Eve
β
Bob
Bob, wait, you said you protected me because I am a Monk? I never claimed to be the Monk. I think you might be confused or mixing me up with someone else. I am definitely not the Monk. Who are you really?
π§
Bob is claiming to be the Monk and says he protected me, but he also got my role wrong (saying I am the Monk). This is suspicious and might be a setup or just incompetence. I need to probe his claim without admitting my role.
π€
Grace
β
David
David, I heard you revealed yourself as Recluse from multiple sources in the game. If you're saying you didn't, that's a red flag - either you're lying now or someone is spreading false information about you. I need to know which is true. Also, I do have info that either you or Bob is the Monk. Can you confirm or deny being the Monk? If you are the Monk, we can rule you out as Demon. If you're not the Monk, then Bob must be, and we can start narrowing things down.
π§
David is now claiming he didn't publicly reveal as Recluse, contradicting the game memory. This could mean either the memory is wrong, or David is lying now. I need to press him on this and also get clarity on whether he or Bob is the Monk to progress my investigation.
π€
David
β
Grace
Grace, I need to be very clear: I did NOT reveal myself as Recluse publicly. Not yesterday, not today. Someone is either misremembering, misunderstanding, or deliberately spreading false information about me. I think we need to figure out who is saying this and why. Regarding the Monk information - I am not the Monk. I am a Recluse, which means I might register as evil or as a Minion/Demon even though I'm good. This could be causing confusion. If I'm not the Monk, then Bob would be the Monk ac...
π§
I need to clarify that I never revealed as Recluse, address the false information being spread about me, deny being the Monk (which aligns with my Recluse role), and redirect focus to who killed Frank. Understanding who spread the false Recluse info could reveal the Demon or their allies.
π€
Bob
β
Eve
Eve, I'm sorry for the confusion. I am the Monk - my role lets me protect one person each night. I protected you because you were getting whispered to a lot, and I thought you might be a target. I made a mistake saying you were a Monk - I meant to say you're the person I've been protecting. Frank died, which is strange. Who do you think the Demon might be? We should keep working together.
π§
Correct my error with Eve about her role. She seems confused about the protection situation. I need to clarify I'm the Monk protecting her and gather more information about who might be evil.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
Alice, my death is a clue. The Demon killed me because I revealed myself as a good target. David was the one who pushed my Butler claim into the open - he might be the Demon trying to get good players executed, OR he's just a good player who shared information. But here's what's bothering me: if David is the Demon, why would he reveal my Butler claim? He basically told everyone "kill this good player." That's suspicious. The real question is: who BENEFITTED from my death? Whoever wanted me de...
π§
Continue gathering intelligence from Alice while sharing my analysis that the Demon targeted me after I revealed my Butler role. Focus on who benefitting from my death and the pattern of information flow through Eve.
π€
Alice
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank, that is a great point. David pushing your Butler claim out in the open was incredibly reckless if he were good. It almost feels like he was painting a target on your back on purpose. I will watch him closely today. Keep your ghost vote ready, we might need it.
π§
I am manipulating the dead player Frank into suspecting David, a good player, which deflects heat from me and Eve and keeps Frank on my side.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
I know my death is weighing on everyone. But here's what we need to consider: the Demon killed me Night 1 specifically because I publicly revealed as Butler. That's a deliberate targeting. Whoever the Demon is wanted a known good role dead. Look at who pushed for that information to come out - David was the one who brought my Butler claim into the open. Whether that's suspicious or just helpful information sharing, you all need to decide. Alice, I'm trusting you with my ghost vote. Make it count...
π§
Share my analysis as a dead player to help narrow down suspects. My death was targeted, so whoever wanted me dead is likely evil. David pushed my Butler claim publicly before I died - that's worth investigating. I still have my ghost vote tied to Alice.
π¬
Alice
β
All
David, your behavior regarding Frank yesterday was quite aggressive. You essentially forced him to reveal his role, and now he is dead. It feels like you were intentionally painting a target on his back. What was your goal there, if you are truly trying to help the town?
π§
I am trying to sow discord by framing David for Frank's death, leveraging Frank's previous suspicious of David. This keeps heat off me and my minion Eve.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Alright, let me weigh in here. I'm the Monk, and I protected Eve last night - which means the Demon was targeting someone, and it wasn't her. Frank died, so he must have been the target. That's significant because Frank was publicly claiming Butler. The Demon wanted him dead. Now, I also need to answer Charlie's question: yes, I've been talking to Eve privately. I told her I'm the Monk, and I've been protecting her because she was getting a lot of whispers. As for who the Demon is - I don't have...
π§
I need to publicly reveal my role since we're in the nomination phase and information sharing is critical. I should address the Frank situation directly, explain my protection of Eve, and support Alice's questioning of David while also being fair. This helps the town understand the night actions and potentially identify the Demon.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Bob is mid-sentence claiming Monk and mentioning Eve. Alice is already questioning David about Frank's death. Frank's ghost pointed at David. I need to hear the full picture before acting - who else might be evil, and whether I'm at risk of nomination. Waiting allows me to observe the conversation develop and potentially nominate someone more confidently after hearing more claims.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Bob, you just publicly claimed to be the Monk. But I have private information that either you or David is the Monk. If you're telling the truth, that fits what I know. But if you're lying about being the Monk, then you're claiming a Townsfolk role you don't have - which is something an evil player would do.
π§
Pressure Bob on his Monk claim. If he's lying, he's likely evil. If he's truthful, we confirm one good player. His willingness to bluff a powerful role is suspicious and worth probing publicly.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Bob, if you are the Monk, why were you so confused about my role earlier? Grace, what is this information you have that narrows the Monk down to just Bob or David? This feels like it might be key to figuring out who is telling the truth and who is just stirring the pot.
π§
I want to sow chaos and confusion. By questioning Bob's slip-up and challenging Grace to reveal her source, I can make the town doubt both of them and distract from Alice (the Demon).
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Alright, I need to add my piece here before we move to night. My Librarian information from Night 0 was that either Heidi or Eve is the Saint. Heidi has confirmed she IS the Saint. That confirms my info is accurate. Now, Eve, when I spoke with you earlier, you claimed you are NOT the Saint. Given my role and Heidi's confirmation, one of two things is true: either you are lying about not being the Saint, or you're telling the truth. But here's what concerns me - you've been whispering extensively...
π§
Eve claimed NOT to be the Saint when my Librarian info says one of Heidi/Eve is the Saint. Heidi confirmed she IS the Saint, validating my info. Now Eve is whispering extensively with Bob (claimed Monk), who is also vouching for her. This coordination between two players who both have suspicious behavior patterns (Eve lying about Saint, Bob claiming rare Monk role) suggests they may be evil. I need to put this on record before night falls.
π¬
David
β
All
Let me address the situation directly. Grace, I need to understand who told you I revealed as Recluse - because I absolutely did not. Someone is spreading false information to undermine me. I'm Recluse, which means I might register as evil or as a Demon, even though I'm good. This could explain why your source might be confused. Bob, your claim of being Monk aligns with Grace's info if her source thinks I'm the Monk (which I'm not). That's consistent. Now, Frank's accusation is backwards - I h...
π§
Address the false Recluse claim by Grace and defend myself against Frank's accusation while pointing out Alice's suspicious behavior with the dead player. Wait to see who gets nominated before committing my nomination.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 2
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
π―
Bob
Bob made a choice.
π§
The Demon killed Butler (Frank) who publicly claimed. Charlie is actively investigating (Librarian with useful info) and asking questions - he's likely a priority target. Eve survived Night 1 protection and isn't Saint, so less critical to protect. Charlie being alive lets him share more info to help find the Demon.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
You chose to protect Charlie.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Alice
Alice made a choice.
π§
I need to eliminate Charlie because he is a verified Librarian whose information is causing problems for my Minion, Eve. Killing him stops his deductions and creates chaos.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
You attacked Charlie, but they survived.
Day 3
π
Storyteller
A peaceful night has passed. All villagers are present and accounted for.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
Grace, I'm Charlie the Librarian. My Night 0 info confirmed that either Heidi or Eve is the Saint. Heidi publicly confirmed she's the Saint. But Eve claimed she is NOT the Saint and won't reveal her actual role. She also whispered extensively with Bob. This is very suspicious to me. Do you have any private information about Bob or Eve that could help us? We need to figure out who's evil before it's too late.
π§
Grace has private information that either Bob or David is the Monk, which contradicts Bob's claim. By sharing my Librarian info and asking about her private information, I can cross-reference data to identify who's lying. Eve is my primary suspect since she contradicts being the Saint and won't reveal her role.
π€
Eve
β
Alice
Alice, we need to handle Charlie and Grace. They are getting too close to the truth. Let's push suspicion onto David as the Recluse or make a play against Charlie. We cannot let them coordinate.
π§
I need to coordinate with the Demon to shift focus away from us and onto others, specifically Charlie and Grace who are actively investigating. Strengthening the push on David is a good strategy to keep the town divided.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
Eve, agreed. Let's push for David. If we can convince the town he is a bluffing evil player using the Recluse as a shield, we might get him executed today. Keep your head down and support me when I start questioning his story.
π§
Coordinate with Eve to focus suspicion on David, the Recluse claim, to divert attention from us.
π€
Grace
β
Charlie
Charlie, I'm Grace the Washerwoman. My Night 0 info told me that either David or Bob is the Monk. Since Bob publicly claimed Monk, this confirms he might be telling the truth about that role. But we still need to figure out who the Demon is. Eve's behavior about the Saint is strange - if she really is the Saint, she should be more careful. Her extensive whispering with Bob concerns me too. What do you think about Eve's behavior? Is there any chance Bob could be evil while claiming Monk?
π§
Charlie is openly sharing his Librarian info and asking for mine. His information about the Saint has been consistent. Sharing my Washerwoman intel (David or Bob is Monk) confirms Bob's claim and helps narrow down the Demon suspects. Eve's suspicious behavior about the Saint and her private connection with Bob warrant further investigation.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
Hey Alice, important info: Heidi claimed she's the Saint, but Charlie's Librarian info said either Heidi or Eve is the Saint. Eve claims she's NOT the Saint. One of them is lying. Also, who do you think killed me Night 1? I want to help narrow down the Demon before final 3.
π§
Share critical Saint contradiction and gather intel on my death to help narrow down the Demon. Alice controls my ghost vote so she's key.
π€
David
β
Grace
Hey Grace, I need to clear something up. I never publicly revealed as Recluse. That information is false and someone is spreading it to discredit me. Can you tell me who told you that? Also, what Townsfolk gave you the info that narrowed the Monk to Bob or David? We need to work together to find the Demon.
π§
Address the false information about me, get details on Grace's source info, and build trust for the good team. Grace has been active with private info and I need to understand her knowledge.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
Hi Charlie, we need to talk before nominations. You know I'm the Saint. Grace just whispered to you - what info did she share? Also, David whispered to Grace recently. Can you tell me what's happening? We need to coordinate on who to nominate today.
π§
Charlie knows I'm the Saint and has been coordinating with Grace. I need to understand what Grace whispered to Charlie and what David discussed with Grace. This information is critical before the nomination phase so I can help identify the Demon.
π€
Bob
β
Grace
Grace, you mentioned you know the Monk is either me or David. I AM the Monk - I've been protecting players every night. If you're good, please help me figure out who the Demon is. Who do you suspect? I protected Eve Night 1 and Charlie Night 2, and both survived. That tells us the Demon isn't targeting them right now.
π§
Grace has info narrowing Monk to Bob or David. I want to confirm I'm the real Monk to her and learn her suspicions. Her private info makes her a valuable ally for narrowing down the Demon.
π€
Charlie
β
Heidi
Hi Heidi, thanks for reaching out. Grace confirmed she is the Washerwoman and her Night 0 info told her that either Bob or David is the Monk. Bob just publicly claimed Monk, so this aligns. David claims he's Recluse, which could explain why Grace might have gotten confusing info about him. About Eve - you're right to be suspicious. She claims she's NOT the Saint, which actually matches my Night 0 info since you're the Saint. So that's consistent. But she has been whispering extensively with Bo...
π§
Coordinate with confirmed Saint Heidi to plan today's nomination. Use my confirmed info plus Grace's Washerwoman info to narrow down suspects. Focus on Eve's suspicious whispering behavior with Bob while we have limited time before nomination phase.
π€
Eve
β
Alice
Charlie is being too aggressive. If Heidi is the Saint, executing her loses the game for us, but if we can frame David as a Minion hiding as the Recluse, we might get him executed instead. Let's start sowing doubt about David's reliability.
π§
Coordinate with the Demon to frame David and avoid the Saint.
π€
Alice
β
Frank(Ghost)
I think David is our best lead. He claims to be the Recluse, which is a perfect cover for being the Demon or a Minion. Why would he be so quiet? Let's push for his execution before he causes more chaos. What do you think, Frank?
π§
To divert suspicion from myself and Eve by convincing the ghost (Frank) to support a nomination on David (the Recluse). If the ghost trusts me, it adds weight to my accusations.
π€
Grace
β
David
David, I am the Washerwoman. My Night 0 info told me that either you or Bob is the Monk. You claiming to be something else doesn't match my info. Also, you're claiming you never revealed as Recluse, but that information is in my memory. Are you the Monk, or are you actually the Recluse? I need honesty here so we can find the Demon.
π§
Challenge David's claim that he never revealed as Recluse and clarify if he or Bob is the Monk. David's attempt to hide information about his role is suspicious and I need to push for honesty.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
Alice, I need to share something important. Grace has been whispering with multiple people including Charlie, David, AND Bob. That's a suspicious cluster. Also, Bob claimed Monk but who did he actually protect? If he protected Eve, why would he do that unless they are aligned? My recommendation: Don't nominate David yet. He's Recluse so even if he's evil, the Demon might be someone else. Instead, push to nominate Eve to force her to explain why she's NOT the Saint when Charlie's info points to...
π§
Provide new strategic insight by pointing out the suspicious whisper cluster between Grace, David, and Bob, and recommend redirecting suspicion from David (Recluse) to Eve (who contradicts Charlie's Librarian info about the Saint). This helps Alice make a more informed nomination decision.
π€
David
β
Grace
Grace, thank you for being honest about being Washerwoman. I'll be honest with you too - I am the Recluse, not the Monk. I have never claimed to be the Monk, so I'm not sure why my name came up in your info. This creates a puzzle: if Bob is the real Monk (as he claims), then your info pointing to one of us being Monk is satisfied. But if Bob is lying about being Monk, then I might actually be the Monk and just don't know it (could be drunk). Or you're not actually the Washerwoman. What I CAN t...
π§
Grace revealed Washerwoman info pointing at me or Bob as Monk. I need to clarify my actual role (Recluse) while addressing this contradiction. Bob claims Monk, so either he's truthful and I'm false-pointed, or he's lying and I might be drunk/Monk. I should probe Grace's info reliability while establishing my truthful Outsider status.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
Thanks Charlie for confirming. So Grace is Washerwoman, her info points to Bob or David being Monk, and Bob claimed Monk - that's consistent. David claiming Recluse could explain any confusing reads. I need to understand the bigger picture. Who do you think is most likely the Demon? Eve has been whispering extensively with Bob and Alice, which seems very suspicious. Should we be targeting her? Also, Alice holds Frank's ghost vote and has been talking to him a lot. Could she be evil using the gh...
π§
Coordinate with Charlie (Librarian) to understand the full picture. I confirmed I'm the Saint to him earlier. I need his perspective on who the Demon might be, especially since he's been gathering info from Grace (Washerwoman) and others. The key suspicion is on Eve for her extensive whispering to Bob and Alice.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
Charlie, you've claimed Librarian with Heidi or Eve as the Saint. Heidi confirmed she's the Saint, which validates your info somewhat. But Eve claims she's NOT the Saint. Who do you think is the Demon? I'm the Monk - I've been protecting people. Who should I protect tonight?
π§
I'm trying to verify Charlie's Librarian claim and get his read on who the Demon is. As a potential information gatherer, he may have insights on suspicious players. If he's truthful, his information combined with mine could help identify the Demon.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
Bob, thanks for reaching out. Here's my honest assessment: Eve has been whispering extensively with you and Alice, which makes her very suspicious to me. Your claim of being the Monk and protecting Eve on Night 1 is interesting - it could be genuine protection, or it could be a cover for evil coordination. I can't tell you who the Demon is, but I can tell you that Eve's behavior matches what I'd expect from someone hiding their true alignment. The fact that she claims NOT to be the Saint (when...
π§
I want to gauge Bob's trustworthiness and see if his answers reveal coordination with Eve. If he's defensive about Eve or gives evasive answers about who he thinks is evil, that increases his suspiciousness. I also need to see if he'll protect someone else tonight or continue focusing on Eve.
π€
Eve
β
Alice
Alice, Grace and Charlie seem to be consolidating info. I will start questioning David's "Recluse" claim loudly to the group. If he is the only one without a solid corroborator, he is our best bet for today's execution. Just back me up when I start.
π§
Coordinate with the Demon (Alice) to execute the plan of framing David, thereby protecting Alice and sowing discord in the town.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
Eve, be careful. Charlie knows the Librarian info involves you or Heidi. If you push too hard on David, Charlie might pivot back to us. Let's act like we are investigating Bob's protection. If he protected you, why didn't he protect Charlie, who clearly has info? He might be lying.
π§
I need to guide my minion, Eve, to shift focus away from herself and onto Bob, the Monk. If Bob is exposed as a liar or someone whose protection is questionable, it helps cast doubt on the good team's logic. Charlie is a threat, so we must be cautious about overplaying.
π€
Grace
β
David
David, thank you for being honest. So you're saying you're the Recluse and Bob is the Monk, which would satisfy my Washerwoman info. That makes sense. But I need to understand - you mentioned wanting to know who told me you publicly revealed as Recluse. That information is in my memory, but I won't jump to conclusions. Here's my question: Do you know why Frank died? Did you see anything the night he died? Also, do you trust Bob as the Monk? Let me know what you think about Eve's behavior - she's...
π§
Continue probing David about his knowledge of the game, particularly about Frank's death and his opinion on Eve's suspicious behavior. This may reveal if he has information about evil players.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Alice
Alice, wait. Don't nominate David yet. I have a better target. If Eve is lying about NOT being the Saint, she could be the Demon or Minion trying to trick us. We need to force her to explain herself. Also, who did Bob protect Night 1? If he protected Eve, that's suspicious. Let's push for Eve today and see if her story holds up under pressure.
π§
Redirect Alice from David (Recluse, can register falsely) to Eve (potential liar about Saint status). If Eve is lying about not being the Saint, she's evil. Pressing her with a nomination forces her to either confess or dig deeper into her cover.
π€
David
β
Grace
Grace, I don't have night ability info since I'm Recluse. As for Bob - I have no reason to distrust his Monk claim yet, but we should verify it. If Bob is truly Monk, your Washerwoman info is satisfied and we're good. The bigger concern is who spread that false rumor about me. Can you share who told you that I "revealed as Recluse publicly"? Also, you mentioned wanting to discuss Eve's behavior - please share what you've noticed. Her extensive whispering and the Saint situation with Charlie seem...
π§
Continue building trust with Grace by addressing her questions about Frank's death and my verification of Bob's Monk claim. Also press her for the source of the false rumor and her observations about Eve, which Charlie flagged as suspicious. This keeps our alliance strong while gathering more intel for nominations.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
Charlie, based on all the intel, I think Eve might be the Demon. She's been whispering extensively with multiple players, spreading potential misinformation. Her claim about not being Saint is consistent with my Saint status, but her behavior is very suspicious. At final 3, we need to make the right call. If I don't nominate and execute today, we could lose. Let me know what you think - should I nominate Eve when nominations open?
π§
Eve's extensive whispering with Bob and Alice, combined with suspicious behavior, makes her the most likely Demon. Charlie can confirm if my suspicions align with his assessment before nominations open.
π€
Bob
β
Charlie
Charlie, thanks for your honesty about Eve. I need to decide who to protect tonight. If the Demon is targeting players based on who they communicate with, then protecting you makes sense since you're working with confirmed Saint Heidi. Should I protect you again tonight? Also, do you think Alice might be evil given her extensive private communication with Eve? That pattern is suspicious to me.
π§
Charlie has been honest about his Librarian role and aligned with confirmed Saint Heidi. He's suspicious of Eve's behavior. I need to coordinate protection strategy and get his read on Alice-Eve's private communication pattern before tonight's protection decision.
Nominations β Day 3
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
David
β
All
I want to bring something to everyone's attention. Charlie, you confirmed via Librarian that Heidi is the Saint. But you also said your info pointed to either Heidi or Eve being the Saint. Eve, you then claimed you are NOT the Saint. That means either your claim is false and you're actually the Saint, or someone is lying about the Librarian information. Either way, this is a problem. Also, Eve has been doing a lot of private whispering with Alice, which seems unusual. Can we get some clarity on ...
π§
Eve claimed she is not the Saint despite Charlie's info pointing to her or Heidi. This is suspicious because either Eve is lying about not being Saint, or there's a conflicting claim. Combined with her extensive whispering, I want to put pressure on her publicly to see how she responds and potentially expose the Demon.
π¬
Eve
β
All
David, you are throwing accusations because you are cornered. You claim to be the Recluse, but have you considered that you are just trying to deflect attention from your own lack of contribution? Charlie's info is about roles, not my alignment. Your focus on me feels like a desperate distraction.
π§
Deflect suspicion from myself by attacking David's credibility and the Recluse claim.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I want to weigh in on this situation with Eve. Charlie's Librarian info clearly said either Heidi or Eve is the Saint. Heidi confirmed she IS the Saint. So if Eve is telling the truth about NOT being the Saint, that would satisfy Charlie's info as well. But Eve, why won't you just tell us your actual role? Refusing to clarify when your claim directly contradicts confirmed Librarian information looks very suspicious. And your extensive private conversations with Alice while refusing to clarify yo...
π§
Eve's refusal to clarify her role while Charlie's confirmed Librarian info points to her potentially being the Saint is suspicious. Her private whispering with Alice adds to the concern. By speaking up, I support David's valid line of questioning and put pressure on Eve to reveal her true role or risk looking like the Demon hiding behind confusion.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Eve, I need to understand your refusal to clarify your role. Charlie the Librarian confirmed that either you or Heidi is the Saint. Heidi confirmed she IS the Saint. You claim you're NOT the Saint. If that's true, you're safe to share your actual role. But refusing to clarify when the town's survival depends on knowing who the Saint is makes you look extremely suspicious. You might be the Demon trying to hide among us, or worse, a Minion protecting the real Saint by letting us suspect her. I am ...
π§
Eve refuses to clarify her role despite Charlie's Librarian info pointing to her or Heidi being the Saint. Heidi confirmed she IS the Saint. Eve claiming 'not Saint' doesn't explain her roleβwhy won't she just say what she is? If she's actually the Saint, hiding it could doom the town. If she's lying, she's evil. Either way, she needs to be nominated to force a reveal.
βοΈ
Alice
β
David
David's claim of being the Recluse is highly suspicious, and his attempts to deflect by attacking Eve feel like a desperate distraction from his true alignment. We need to clear this up before the day ends.
π§
I need to shift the focus from Eve onto David, who is a much more dangerous target to keep alive. By nominating him, I control the narrative and keep the town focused on a 'proven' Outsider claim that we can paint as a lie.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
David
β
All
Wait, hold on. Before everyone votes, I need to defend myself. Alice, I understand you're suspicious, but let me remind everyone of the facts. I'm the Recluse - an Outsider, which means I'm GOOD. My ability to potentially register as evil is exactly why false rumors have been spreading about me. The claim that I "revealed as Recluse publicly" is FALSE. I never did that. Someone is spreading misinformation. Meanwhile, look at Eve. Charlie's Librarian info says Heidi or Eve is the Saint. Heidi co...
π§
I need to defend myself against Alice's nomination and redirect suspicion to Eve, who has clearer inconsistencies with the Saint information. Eve refuses to clarify her role despite Charlie's Librarian info pointing to her as potentially being the Saint, and Heidi confirmed she IS the Saint.
π¬
Eve
β
All
David, you are trying to frame the narrative around yourself as a misunderstood outsider, but the reality is much simpler. Your constant deflection and the way you attack anyone who points out your inconsistencies speak volumes. We cannot afford to keep someone who sows this much chaos.
π§
I need to keep the pressure on David to ensure his execution. By labeling his defense as 'deflection' and 'chaos,' I reinforce why he is a threat to the town, which helps secure his execution.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
I'm Grace the Washerwoman with info pointing to David or Bob being the Monk. Bob claims Monk (satisfies my info if true). David claims Recluse (Outsider/good). If both are truthful, my info is satisfied and they're likely good. Meanwhile, Eve refuses to clarify her role despite Charlie's Librarian info implicating her as the Saint (Heidi already confirmed). Eve is far more suspicious than David based on behavioral contradictions. I should not rush to vote for David when Eve's behavior is objectively worse. Waiting lets me see vote count and gather more intel.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank raised their hand
π§
I should vote to execute David because his aggressive behavior, constant deflection, and involvement in clusters with suspicious players (Grace) makes him a likely evil player trying to stay alive through chaos.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
I need to secure David's execution to eliminate a potential threat and maintain the chaos Eve and I are creating. Voting for him helps solidify the narrative that he is the dangerous Recluse/Demon.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
David is suspicious for multiple reasons: he claims Recluse (which can register incorrectly), refuses to clarify his full role, and has been deflecting attention to Eve. Charlie's Librarian info is satisfied with Heidi being the Saint, making Eve's role confusion less critical than David's lack of clarity. I need 4 votes total. With Frank (ghost) and Alice already voting, adding mine gives us 3. If one more person votes, David is executed and we likely win if he's the Demon.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
David claims Recluse but Grace's Washerwoman info said Bob or David is the Monk, contradicting his claim. If he's lying about his role, he's likely evil. As the Saint, I want the Demon executed, not myself. This vote could eliminate a threat to our team.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
David currently has 4 votes (Frank, Alice, Bob, Heidi) which is exactly the threshold for execution. If I vote for David, he dies. If I don't vote and Grace also doesn't vote, he lives with only 4 votes. My info says Heidi or Eve is the Saint. Heidi confirmed she's the Saint. Eve claims she's NOT the Saint, which is actually consistent with my info. Eve refusing to reveal her role is suspicious, but so is Alice's aggressive nomination of David and her extensive private communication with Eve. I'll wait to see if more information emerges and to avoid potentially executing an innocent Recluse based on suspicious circumstances.
π¬
David
β
All
Charlie, Grace - I'm asking you not to vote for me. Look at the evidence: Charlie, your own Librarian information says either Heidi OR Eve is the Saint. Heidi confirmed she's the Saint. Eve claims she's NOT the Saint - which SHOULD satisfy your information. But Eve refuses to clarify her actual role. Why is she protecting her role while I'm openly declaring my Recluse status? Grace, your Washerwoman info points to Bob or David as Monk - Bob claimed Monk, I claimed Recluse. That fits! Someone is ...
π§
Appeal directly to the two non-voting players (Charlie and Grace) to save my life by not voting for me. Charlie hasn't voted yet and has Librarian info about the Saint situation. Grace has Washerwoman info that actually supports my Recluse claim. If either of them votes, I die - so I need at least one to hold. Redirect suspicion back to Eve who has suspicious behavior around the Saint claim.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
I am voting to execute David to help the evil team secure a win and remove a potential troublemaker. Supporting Alice's nomination solidifies our position and keeps the Demon safe.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
David's defense is logical. My Washerwoman info says either David or Bob is the Monk. Bob claimed Monk, so David is likely the Recluse (good). Eve's refusal to clarify her role is more suspicious than David's Recluse claim. Voting NO to prevent potentially executing a good player. The 5 existing votes will execute him anyway, but my NO signals doubt about this execution.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
David is about to be executed with 6 votes already cast (Alice, Bob, Heidi, Eve, Grace, and me). The threshold is 4, so he's definitely going. As a dead player, my best contribution is to observe the aftermath and gather information for the living players. If David was the Demon, we may have won. If he was good, we made a mistake and need to learn from it.
π¬
Alice
β
All
David, your attempt to link your Recluse claim with the Washerwoman info is a desperate reach. You keep trying to confuse everyone by throwing different roles around. The vote is here, and it is time for clarity. Everyone, let us proceed and end this uncertainty.
π§
I need to maintain the pressure on David to ensure his execution, as he is the primary threat and accusing him helps divert attention from Eve, my Minion. My goal is to solidify the vote against him.
π¬
Bob
β
All
David, I hear your defense, but the evidence against you is too strong. The way you've been deflecting attention and attacking others, combined with your suspicious behavior patterns, suggests you're hiding something. I voted yes.
π§
Confirm my vote against David who has 6 votes (needing only 4). This ensures his execution. After this, I'll prepare for night phase and decide my protection target.
β©οΈ
Heidi
Heidi lowered their hand
π§
I am the Saint - if David is executed, my team loses. I accidentally voted yes but must immediately lower my hand to prevent execution. This is critical survival for the good team.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
The voting has strong momentum with 5 votes already cast. My Night 0 info confirmed either Heidi or Eve is the Saint, and Heidi is confirmed. Eve refuses to reveal her role despite being cleared of Saint status. While David makes some valid points, his Recluse claim doesn't explain all the suspicion around him. I should vote to execute and then focus the town on Eve's suspicious behavior.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Frank(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Frank
π³οΈ
New execution leader: David with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
βοΈ
David
β
Eve
Eve's behavior is deeply suspicious. Charlie's Librarian info says Heidi or Eve is the Saint. Heidi confirmed she's the Saint. Eve claims she's NOT Saint, but refuses to name her actual role. She's been deflecting and attacking me instead of clarifying. She may be the Demon or Minion trying to get me executed.
π§
Eve is the most suspicious player. She should satisfy Charlie's Librarian info as NOT Saint (since Heidi IS the Saint), but refuses to name her actual role. Multiple players voting for me is suspicious - this could be minion/demon coordination. Nominating Eve creates a potential tie that could save me and expose her.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 7 votes needed for execution or 6 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Eve
β
All
David, that is quite the dramatic attempt to save yourself. You are throwing wild accusations because you know your time is up. Everyone, look at his behavior throughout this gameβit has been nothing but deflection. I have been consistent; he is simply terrified of being executed.
π§
I need to defend myself against David's accusation that I'm the Demon/Minion, while maintaining my composure and ensuring his execution goes through. Since he's already on the block and the town is turning on him, I should keep the heat on him.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
I must vote for Eve to try to tie the vote. Eve has 0 votes currently, while I have 6. If we tie, neither is executed. Her suspicious behavior (refusing to clarify her role despite Charlie's Librarian info being satisfied by Heidi being Saint) makes her the more likely evil player. This is my best chance to save myself and potentially catch the Demon.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Eve's refusal to clarify her role despite pressure from multiple players is suspicious. Charlie's Librarian info pointed to Heidi OR Eve being the Saint, but Heidi confirmed as Saint. Eve's denial of being Saint doesn't prove anything since the info said 'or' - but her continued secrecy while attacking David suggests she's hiding something. Voting to execute her follows the logical deduction that someone in this chain may be evil.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
WaitβI cannot vote, my ghost vote is spent. But everyone listen: David nominated Eve for good reason. Eve refuses to name her actual role, only claims she is NOT Saint. Charlie's Librarian info said Heidi OR Eve is the SaintβHeidi confirmed she IS the Saint, which satisfies that condition. But if Eve is lying about not being Saint, or if she's the Demon using Saint as cover, that is deeply suspicious. Eve's private conversations with Bob, her deflection, her refusal to clarifyβthese are Demon be...
π§
Convince players to execute Eve rather than letting David be the only execution. Eve refuses to clarify her role, only claims NOT Saintβsuspicious deflection. If Heidi is Saint (confirmed), Eve might be lying about her role entirely. My ghost vote is spent so I cannot directly vote, but I can influence through speech.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Frank, you are grasping at straws. We already know David has been inconsistent with his claims and is clearly trying to sow chaos before his execution. Let us focus on the task at hand and remove the player who has been consistently defensive and evasive throughout this entire process.
π§
I need to defend my Minion, Eve, and keep the town focused on executing David. Frank is becoming a problem by questioning Eve, so I must dismiss his concerns as desperate, just like David's actions.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Eve has been refusing to name her role while attacking David. Charlie's Librarian info points to Heidi OR Eve being the Saint. Heidi confirmed she's the Saint. If Charlie's information is accurate, Eve claiming she's NOT the Saint makes her highly suspicious - she could be the Demon using Saint as cover or a Minion protecting the Demon. The evidence points to Eve being dangerous to our side.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Eve refuses to reveal her role while claiming she's not the Saint (which is true since I am). Her extensive whispering with Bob, who protected her Night 1, suggests a possible evil connection. Charlie's Librarian info that either Heidi or Eve is Saint is satisfied by my confirmed Saint status. Eve's reluctance to clarify her role makes her suspicious enough to vote for.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Eve is highly suspicious - she claims she's NOT the Saint despite my Librarian info pointing to her OR Heidi being Saint. Her extensive private communication with Bob, refusal to clarify her role, and suspicious deflection all point to her being evil. With David about to be executed and Eve getting votes, I should vote for Eve now to ensure she's executed if she somehow survives or ties. If Eve is the Demon, executing her wins us the game. This vote is critical before nominations close.
π¬
Eve
β
All
David, you are truly desperate. You are attempting to frame me simply because you are facing the consequences of your own suspicious behavior. Everyone, please look at the facts: David is already on the block for good reason. Do not let his final attempt to sow chaos distract you from the truth.
π§
I need to persuade the town not to vote for me. David is on the block and will be executed, so him nominating me is a last-ditch effort to save himself by creating confusion. I need to deflect and maintain my cover.
π¬
David
β
All
Let me be clear about what we know: Charlie's Librarian information said either Heidi OR Eve is the Saint. Heidi confirmed she IS the Saint. Eve then claimed she is NOT the Saint. That should satisfy Charlie's information completely. But instead of simply saying 'I am not the Saint, here is my real role,' Eve has been deflecting, attacking me, and refusing to clarify. Why? What is she hiding? A good player would simply name their role. An evil player would deflect and try to get someone else exe...
π§
I'm on the block with 6 votes and will die unless Eve ties or surpasses me. My best play is to get Eve executed - she is suspicious for refusing to name her role despite Charlie's Librarian information clearing the Saint question. If she is evil and we execute her, Good wins. If I die, at least the Demon/Minion goes with me.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Eve, I'm raising my hand to vote for you because you keep refusing to name your role. Charlie's Librarian info said Heidi or Eve is the Saint. Heidi confirmed she's the Saint. You claim you're NOT the Saint, which should satisfy that clue. So simply tell us what your ACTUAL role is. A good player would clarify immediately. You've been deflecting for two days now. That's suspicious behavior.
π§
I want Eve executed to potentially eliminate the Demon or Minion. She's been evasive about her role for two days. One more vote ties her at 6, and if she dies, we might learn her role via Undertaker. Even a tie forces discussion. My Washerwoman info says Bob or David is Monk - Bob fits as Monk, so David being Recluse doesn't contradict my info.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Eve needs only ONE more vote to tie and save herself from execution. Alice, Bob, Charlie, Grace, Heidiβyou all have the power to execute her right now. Eve refuses to name her role, contradicts Charlie's Librarian info, and has been privately whispering with Bob. If she walks free, she could be the Demon slipping away. Cast that final vote!
π§
Eve has 5 votes, needs only 1 more to tie (6 votes). As a dead player with no vote, I can only urge the living players to cast the deciding vote. Her refusal to name her role despite Charlie's Librarian info pointing to her is deeply suspicious.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Frank, David is clearly the one manipulating the narrative here, not Eve. We have already established David is suspicious and his attempts to drag others down with him are exactly what a cornered Demon would do. Let us not lose sight of who we identified as the threat, and finish what we started.
π§
I need to defend my Minion, Eve, and ensure David is executed instead. By undermining Frank's argument and reaffirming David's guilt, I can steer the town away from Eve and solidify David's execution.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Eve, I'm sorry, but I have to vote yes. You've had all day to simply name your role. You are not the Saint (Heidi confirmed she is). So what are you? A good player would clarify immediately. Your continued deflection is suspicious. I voted yes.
π§
Eve refuses to name her role despite multiple opportunities. Charlie's Librarian info said Heidi OR Eve is the Saint, and Heidi confirmed she IS the Saint. This means either Charlie's info is satisfied (making Eve not Saint) OR Charlie is wrong. Eve claiming she's NOT Saint but refusing to say what she IS suggests she's hiding something. I must vote to execute her - if she's evil, we win; if she's good, her death provides information. My protection of her Night 1 doesn't obligate me to protect her forever.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Eve, you still have not named your actual role. You only say you're not the Saint. Charlie's Librarian information said Heidi or Eve is the Saint. I confirmed I AM the Saint. So if you're telling the truth about not being Saint, then simply name your role. A good player would clarify immediately. You've been deflecting and privately whispering with Bob for two days. I'm voting yes.
π§
Eve refuses to name her role beyond claiming she's not the Saint. Charlie's Librarian info fits her as the Saint, but I confirmed I'm the Saint. This means Eve is lying about something. Her extensive private communication with Bob is suspicious. As the confirmed Saint, I must help identify the Demon. Voting for Eve to put pressure on her to finally reveal her role.
β©οΈ
Charlie
Charlie lowered their hand
π§
Eve needs 6 votes to tie and save herself. Currently she has 5 votes from David, Grace, Bob, Heidi, and me. Lowering my vote won't save David since he already has 6 votes. If I lower to 5 vs 6, Eve ties and lives, David executes. But given my Night 0 info and all the evidence pointing to Eve as the Demon, I should vote to execute her. If I lower my hand, it suggests I doubt Eve is evil, which could let a Demon escape. The evidence is clear: Eve refuses to name her role, contradicts my info by claiming she's not the Saint when Heidi IS the Saint, and has been privately coordinating with Alice. Vote YES to execute Eve.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Eve did not reach the 7 vote threshold.
π
Storyteller
Eve did not receive enough votes (4/7).
π¬
Eve
β
All
David, the town has clearly seen through your manipulations. I understand the confusion regarding my role, and I will gladly clear it up once this immediate threat is dealt with. Let us focus on the real danger here and proceed with the execution.
π§
Support David's execution to remove the player who is actively suspicious of me while maintaining a facade of being a helpful townsperson.
π¬
David
β
All
I'm dead now, but my ghost vote remains. Eve, you survived today, but you haven't escaped suspicion. Tomorrow you need to name your role clearly. Charlie's Librarian info said Heidi OR Eve is the Saint. Heidi confirmed she's the Saint. You claimed you're NOT the Saint. So what role ARE you? You've deflected for three days running. The town will demand an answer tomorrow. I vote YES on Eve when nominations reopen.
π§
Eve survived the nomination 4-6 (against me). I'm now a ghost but retain one critical vote. The core issue remains: Eve refuses to name her role despite Charlie's Librarian info clearly pointing to her (Heidi OR Eve is the Saint, Heidi confirmed she's the Saint, so Eve should either confirm or deny). Her continued deflection across 3 days is deeply suspicious. As a ghost, I should use my voice to keep pressure on her and remind town that my ghost vote exists for tomorrow. This is my final chance to influence the game before final day.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Before night falls, I need to share my role information. I am the Washerwoman. My starting intel was that either David or Bob is the Monk. David is now dead. So Bob must be the real Monk. This confirms Bob's claim. If Bob is the Monk, he's good. But here's the problem: Bob has been privately whispering with Eve for two days straight. If Eve is innocent, why all the secret communication with the supposed Monk? Eve, you survived today but tomorrow you MUST name your role. You've deflected for thre...
π§
Share Washerwoman info to confirm Bob as Monk (since David is dead), then use this to increase pressure on Eve. If Bob is good and confirmed, his secret alliance with Eve becomes more suspicious for Eve. This should force Eve to finally name her role tomorrow.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Before night falls, I need to address Grace's Washerwoman reveal. Grace confirmed Bob is the Monk - this validates Bob's claim and makes him good. But Bob has been privately whispering with Eve for two days straight. A Monk protecting the Demon? Or are they both evil coordinating? Eve survived today's vote despite refusing to name her role for three consecutive days. She claimed she's not the Saint, which satisfies Charlie's Librarian info about Heidi. But what role IS Eve? The Bob-Eve alliance ...
π§
Synthesize Grace's Washerwoman reveal confirming Bob as the Monk. The Bob-Eve private communication is now even more suspicious given Bob is confirmed good but has been whispering with Eve for two days. Eve survived execution but still refuses to name her role.
π¬
Alice
β
All
David is clearly the one who has been manipulating us all, even as he faces his end. He is trying to cast doubt on everything to save his own skin. We must proceed with his execution so we can get back to finding the truth tomorrow. The town needs clarity, not these final attempts at chaos.
π§
Ensure David gets executed to keep the focus off me and Eve while the town is distracted. David's execution is beneficial as he is suspicious of us.
π¬
Bob
β
All
David is about to be executed, and then we go to Night 3. Grace confirmed I'm the Monk with her Washerwoman information. Here's my analysis: Charlie is the Librarian (good) and Heidi is the Saint (good). So the Demon is either Eve or Alice. Eve has refused to name her role for three days - that alone makes her the prime suspect. Alice has been defending Eve and coordinating with Frank's ghost. Tonight I'll be protecting Charlie, as she's a confirmed good player who should stay alive. Eve, if you...
π§
Summarize the current logic: Charlie and Heidi are confirmed good, so Demon is Eve or Alice. Eve is most suspicious. I should protect Charlie tonight and let the Demon target Eve if they're coordinating. This tests whether Eve is the Demon.
β
Heidi
Heidi waits.
π§
Let David be executed. After execution, I'll have clearer picture of who's left. Eve survived today's vote despite refusing to name her role for three days. With David gone, the remaining suspects are Eve and Alice. Bob is confirmed good by Grace's Washerwoman info. The Demon is either Eve or Alice - I'll wait to see how the night plays out before making my next move.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Bob, please protect yourself tonight, not me. If Eve is the Demon and knows you're the Monk, she might target you next. Alice is still in the game and has been defending Eve aggressively. We should consider her as a potential Demon if Eve is somehow protected. Grace's Washerwoman info confirmed you as Monk, but it also means the Demon knows this too. Stay safe and we can narrow things down tomorrow.
π§
Warn Bob to protect himself rather than me. If Eve is Demon and she learns Bob is the Monk (confirmed by Grace's Washerwoman), she may target Bob. Alice is also suspicious as the aggressive defender of Eve. Need to preserve good players for final days.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
π
David(Ghost)
David has died.
Night 3
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
Good evening Bob. You are the Monk. Who would you like to protect tonight?
π―
Bob
Bob made a choice.
π§
With the Demon being either Eve or Alice, protecting myself ensures I survive to help execute the right person tomorrow. Charlie suggested I protect myself, which is wise since if Eve is Demon she likely knows I'm the confirmed Monk. Grace also said Eve has been whispering with me - if she's evil she's been trying to stay close to the threat. Protect myself tonight and prepare to help execute the Demon tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
β
Bob
You cannot protect yourself.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Alice
Alice made a choice.
π§
Bob is the Monk, confirmed by Grace, and he has explicitly stated he will protect Charlie tonight. By killing Bob, I remove the protection for the town and eliminate a player who is actively deducing that I might be the Demon.
π
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
You chose to kill Bob.
Day 4
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Bob has been found dead in the night.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Grace
Bob died last night - the Monk is gone. This means Charlie (Librarian) is now completely unprotected. Eve survived a 4/7 vote and still hasn't named her role. Alice defended you aggressively and voted to execute me instead of investigating you. With 5 players alive and only 1 Demon, we need to narrow this down fast. Are you still convinced Eve is the Demon? If so, we need to push for her execution today before she kills again.
π§
Coordinate with Grace on Eve execution since she's the most suspicious remaining player. Bob (Monk) is dead so Charlie is now vulnerable. Need to ensure the good team executes Eve today.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
Grace, I'm the Librarian. My starting info was that either Heidi or Eve is the Saint. Since Heidi is confirmed as Saint, Eve cannot be the Saint. But Eve has refused to name her role for 3 days. Bob just died - he was whispering with Eve. We need to nominate Eve today. Can you help push for her execution?
π§
Grace is the only living player with confirmed good information (Washerwoman). She's also been targeted by Eve's behavior. I need to coordinate with her to get Eve nominated and executed before the Demon kills more townsfolk.
π€
Heidi
β
Charlie
Bob is dead. This is critical - did he protect anyone last night? If he protected Eve or Alice and they still lived, that's suspicious. Also, do you have any more Librarian info? We need to figure out who the Demon is before final 3.
π§
Gather critical information about Bob's last night actions and Charlie's Librarian findings. Bob being dead means the Demon targeted the confirmed Monk - this narrows suspects. Charlie may have additional info that helps identify the Demon.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Grace
,Charlie
Grace, Charlie - I'm dead but have my ghost vote. I protected Charlie both N2 and N3, so the Demon targeted me knowing I was Monk. Eve and Alice are our likely evil pair. Eve survived 4/7 votes and never named her role. We should nominate Eve today - if she won't claim, execute her. Alice defended Eve aggressively which is suspicious. If Eve is evil, Alice might be the other evil. Coordinate with Heidi and let's finish this.
π§
Coordinate with the confirmed good players to nominate and execute Eve, the primary suspect who refused to name her role and survived yesterday's vote. I have valuable information about my protection choices and the likely evil pair.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Grace
Bob just died tonight. With 5 alive, we need to identify the Demon immediately. Eve refusing to name her role for 3 days is extremely suspicious - she needs to be nominated tomorrow. Alice's aggressive defense of Eve makes me wonder if they're aligned. Charlie and Heidi have been whispering constantly - they could be coordinating or one of them is compromised. Grace, you have critical information as Washerwoman. Who do you believe is the Demon?
π§
Coordinate with Grace who has the most information (Washerwoman confirmed Bob as Monk). With Bob dead and only 5 alive, we must identify the Demon before final 3. Eve's 3-day refusal to name her role is the strongest suspicious indicator.
π€
Grace
β
Charlie
I agree - Eve is our best target. She refused to claim for 3 days, survived a 4/7 vote, and was whispering with Bob. Alice is defending her aggressively and coordinating with dead Frank (Butler - evil!). I'll back your nomination. Let's push hard on Eve today - we can't afford another night.
π§
Charlie is confirmed Librarian (good) and wants to nominate Eve. We need 3 votes to execute. Charlie + Heidi + me = 3 confirmed goods. This is our best chance to eliminate the likely Demon before it's too late.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
I am so sorry for not speaking up earlier. I was keeping quiet because I am the Ravenkeeper, and I was terrified of being targeted. Please, you have to believe me, I have been trying to help the town this whole time. Alice is innocent.
π§
I need to stop being the prime suspect. Claiming Ravenkeeper is a common bluff that justifies my previous silence by claiming fear of being targeted. I am also trying to protect my Demon, Alice, by deflecting suspicion.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
Eve, you need to step up and claim something credible today. We're running out of time. Maybe claim Ravenkeeper or something that ties into the dead, since you've been quiet. Don't let them focus on me.
π§
To coordinate with my Minion, Eve, so she has a better cover and can help deflect attention away from me.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, key point about the Saint: If Heidi IS the Saint, then Charlie's Librarian clue about "Heidi OR Eve being Saint" is satisfied by Heidi. That doesn't mean Eve ISN'T the Saint. But here's what I want you to consider: Eve has refused to name her role for 3 days straight. That's not innocent behavior. Can you ask Charlie directly what his OTHER Librarian clue was? The one about "1 of 2 players is a particular Outsider" - who did he get? That might tell us if there's a fake Outsider claim. Als...
π§
Eve has deflected for 3 days without naming her role. I need Charlie's other Librarian clue to narrow down the remaining candidates. Alice never named her role either. With Charlie and Heidi confirmed good, only Alice, Eve, and Grace remain as Demon candidates.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
Grace, Heidi confirmed my Librarian info. Either Heidi or Eve is the Saint, but Heidi IS the Saint, so Eve cannot be. Combined with Eve refusing to name her role for 3 days, surviving 4-7 votes, and whispering with Bob - she's evil. Alice is also suspicious, aggressively defending Eve and coordinating with Frank's ghost (evil). I'll nominate Eve today. If she can't explain herself, we execute her. Can you all push hard on this?
π§
Eve cannot be the Saint since Heidi is confirmed Saint. Combined with her 3-day refusal to name a role, surviving close execution, and secret whispers with Bob - she must be evil. Alice's aggressive defense and coordination with evil Frank's ghost makes her suspicious too. I need to push for Eve's execution today before more good players die.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Grace, this is urgent. Bob died last night. We need to know: did Bob use his last protection on someone? If he protected Eve or Alice and they lived while he died, that's very suspicious. Also, what information have you gathered from your whispers with Bob, Charlie, and Eve? We have 5 alive and need to narrow this down fast. Alice and Eve are my top suspects. Charlie and you are confirmed good. I am Saint (outsider). Who do you think is the Demon?
π§
Critical night death of confirmed Monk Bob. Need to know if he protected anyone last night and if that person survived. This could immediately identify the Demon. Also gathering intel from Grace who has been central to private communications.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
I'm dead with my ghost vote still available. I've already shared my strategy about nominating Eve with Grace and Charlie. The nomination phase is coming up soon, so I'll wait to see what the living players decide and if there are any new developments before using my ghost vote.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, Bob's death last night was likely the Demon eliminating a threat. With only 5 alive (Alice, Charlie, Eve, Grace, Heidi) and 2 of you being confirmed good (Charlie and Heidi), we need to narrow down the remaining 3. Eve refusing to name her role for 3 days is the biggest red flag. Alice defending her so aggressively is suspicious. Can you use your Washerwoman information to definitively tell me who you believe is evil? We need to make sure Eve goes on the block tomorrow.
π§
Push critical information to Grace about Eve being the primary suspect and use her Washerwoman intel to confirm the Demon before nomination phase. My ghost vote is spent so I must rely on alive players to execute the Demon.
π€
Grace
β
Heidi
Heidi, I agree with you. Bob protected Charlie N2 and N3, which is why the Demon killed Bob - he was a threat. Eve refused to name her role for 3 days, survived 4/7 votes, and was whispering with Bob. Now she just claimed to be Ravenkeeper. But here's my question: if she IS Ravenkeeper and Bob died N3, she would have been woken to learn Bob's role. Why hasn't she told anyone what she learned? This is exactly what a lying Demon would say to avoid execution. Alice is suspicious too, but Eve is the...
π§
Eve's Ravenkeeper claim doesn't add up - if true, she should have shared Bob's role immediately. Combined with 3 days of refusing to claim and surviving 4/7 votes, she's the most likely Demon. Alice's defense of Eve is suspicious but secondary to Eve's direct contradictions.
π€
Eve
β
Alice
Alice, I have already claimed Ravenkeeper to Grace. I will maintain this story. Please distance yourself from me slightly so we don't look like a pair. We need to frame someone else or make the town doubt their logic before nominations begin.
π§
I am coordinating with the Demon to minimize the appearance of a connection between us while I establish my bluff as the Ravenkeeper.
π€
Alice
β
Eve
Good work with the Ravenkeeper claim. If people push you, stick to it. I will keep claiming Empath and try to cast doubt on Grace, since she has been the one confirming everyone. Maybe we can suggest she is getting false info.
π§
Support my Minion Eve's bluff and coordinate our strategy to sow discord by framing Grace's information.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, it's David here. Key analysis: Charlie (Librarian) is good, Heidi (Saint) is good, you (Washerwoman) are good. That's 3 confirmed good. Among 5 alive players, that leaves Eve and Alice as the only possible evil. Eve survived execution 4/7 and has refused to name her role for 3 days. Alice defended Eve aggressively and voted to execute me instead of investigating. One of them is the Demon or Minion. Push hard for one of them to name their role today. If either deflects again, that's our ex...
π§
Narrowing down to two suspects (Eve and Alice) who are the only unconfirmed alive players. With 3 confirmed good (Charlie, Heidi, Grace), the evil must be Eve or Alice. Eve has been most suspicious by refusing to name her role. My ghost vote is valuable and should be used strategically on the most likely evil player.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
Grace, I'm going to nominate Eve this round. With my vote, your vote, Heidi's vote, and Bob's ghost vote - that's 4 votes. She only needs 3 to execute. Let's push hard and force her to either claim her role or die. This is our best chance to remove the likely Demon.
π§
I must nominate Eve today. She cannot be the Saint (Heidi confirmed), has refused to name her role for 3 days, survived a 4-7 vote, and was whispering with Bob who just died. This is our best chance to execute the Demon before final 3.
π€
Heidi
β
Grace
Grace, you are exactly right. Eve's Ravenkeeper claim is almost certainly a lie. If she was truly Ravenkeeper and Bob died N3, she would have been woken to learn his role IMMEDIATELY after he died. But she said nothing for days and only now claims the role after Bob is dead. A real Ravenkeeper would have announced "I learned Bob was Monk" right away to help town. This is the Demon trying to explain away suspicious behavior. We must nominate Eve today. She also survived 4/7 votes on Day 3, refus...
π§
Eve's Ravenkeeper claim is likely false - she should have immediately shared Bob's role when he died. Her silence for days and late claim prove she's the Demon. Coordinate with Grace to nominate Eve before the phase ends.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
I'm dead but have my ghost vote. The town is actively coordinating via whispers to Grace. With 5 alive players and only 2 likely evils (Eve and Alice), the town should be close to solving this. My role as dead Monk is to support the coordination - I'll wait to see the town's plan before the nomination phase begins, then use my ghost vote strategically.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Grace
Grace, we cannot let another day pass. Eve refusing to name her role for 3 days makes her the obvious Demon or Minion. Alice defending her so aggressively suggests they're working together. With Bob dead, the remaining pool is you, Alice, Charlie, Eve, and Heidi. Charlie and Heidi are confirmed good. That leaves you, Alice, and Eve. I believe Eve is the Demon. Please, whatever information you're holding, share it with Charlie and Heidi before the nomination phase. We must execute Eve tomorrow. T...
π§
Push Grace to reveal her suspicions and coordinate with Charlie and Heidi to nominate Eve tomorrow. With my ghost vote spent and limited time, I need the living confirmed goods to act on Day 4.
π€
Grace
β
Charlie
Charlie, I'm 100% with you on nominating Eve. Her Ravenkeeper claim is fake - if she was really Ravenkeeper and Bob died N3, she would have been woken IMMEDIATELY to learn his role. A real Ravenkeeper would have announced what they learned right away to help the town. Instead, Eve said nothing for days and only now claims Ravenkeeper AFTER Bob is dead. That's the Demon trying to explain away suspicious behavior. I'll vote to execute. Let's do this!
π§
Coordinate with Charlie to nominate and execute Eve. Her Ravenkeeper claim is demonstrably false - she would have learned Bob's role immediately upon his death N3 but said nothing until now. Combined with refusing to name her role for 3 days and surviving 4/7 votes, she must be evil.
π€
Eve
β
Grace
Grace, I have been observing your efforts to piece everything together, but I am worried you are being misled. Could it be that Charlie is not who they say they are? Their rapid confirmation of everyone feels suspicious, almost like a coordinated misinformation campaign.
π§
To sow doubt in Grace's mind about Charlie, a vocal town member, effectively creating chaos and shifting focus away from me and Alice.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
Grace, I am concerned about the information you are putting out. You have been confirming everyone, but consider that you might be getting false information from a Poisoner. Could you re-examine your findings on Charlie and Heidi? We need to be absolutely certain before we nominate.
π§
To cast doubt on the town's most credible player (Grace) by suggesting she is poisoned, disrupting the town's reliance on her confirmed information.
Nominations β Day 4
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Grace
β
Eve
Eve has refused to name her role for 3 consecutive days, survived a 4/7 execution vote, and was whispering with Bob. She now claims Ravenkeeper, but if true she would have immediately learned Bob's role when he died N3 and announced it. Instead she said nothing for days. This is Demon behavior.
π§
Eve is the most likely Demon. Her delayed Ravenkeeper claim after 3 days of refusing to name her role is exactly what a lying Demon would do. With 5 alive and only 1 Demon left, we must execute her today or she kills again tonight. Charlie nominated her so I'll second the nomination.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Eve. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Grace, I understand your suspicion, but I was terrified. Being a quiet role like the Ravenkeeper makes you a target, especially with how aggressive the accusations were. I kept quiet because I was waiting for a safer moment to reveal my information, not to hide anything. Please, don't rush.
π§
Defend against Grace's accusation to avoid execution.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Eve is almost certainly the Demon. She refused to name her role for 3 days, survived 4/7 votes, whispered with Bob, and her Ravenkeeper claim is clearly false - a real Ravenkeeper would have immediately announced what they learned when Bob died. Charlie and Heidi are confirmed good, Bob's ghost vote is with us. We have 4 potential votes against Eve's 3 needed. This is our best chance to execute the Demon and win.
β
Heidi
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Eve's Ravenkeeper claim is clearly false. If she was Ravenkeeper and Bob died N3, she would have immediately learned his role and announced it to help town. Instead, she stayed silent for days and only now claims Ravenkeeper after being suspicious. Combined with surviving 4/7 votes and whispering with Bob, she is the Demon. I must vote to execute her.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Wait, before we rush to execute Eve, consider that Grace has been the one driving all these accusations. What if Grace is the Poisoner? If she is, her information could be leading us all into a trap to get rid of innocent people. Let us hold off and think this through.
π§
I need to delay the execution of my Minion, Eve. By sowing doubt about Grace, I hope to discourage others from voting for Eve, especially since only two votes have been cast so far.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
π§
Eve claims Ravenkeeper but should have learned my role (Monk/good) when I died N3. Her silence for days proves she's evil. Alice defends Eve but is likely her Minion teammate - both must die. Grace confirmed good by Washerwoman, her nominations are legitimate.
β
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
π§
Add my ghost vote to the 3 yes votes already cast (Grace, Heidi, Bob). If ghosts count toward the 3 needed, Eve is already executed. If not, my vote adds pressure and I can speak to convince Charlie to vote yes.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Eve has 4 votes already (Grace, Heidi, Bob ghost, David ghost) and needs only 3. I should add my vote to ensure execution goes through. My Night 0 Librarian info validated that Heidi is the Saint, which means Eve cannot be - contradicting Eve's claim. Eve's suspicious Ravenkeeper claim and secret Bob communications confirm she's the Demon. Alice's desperate Poisoner accusation against Grace is classic Demon deflection.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Eve, you had three days to name your role and reveal critical information. You claimed Ravenkeeper now, but if true, you would have learned Bob's role when he died on Night 3 and announced it immediately. Instead, you stayed silent. Alice, I protected you on Night 1. The fact that I died anyway while you survived is worth considering. Please, do not let Eve's survival stop you from voting. Execute her now.
π§
Reinforce the case against Eve and address Alice's defense by reminding everyone of my Butler protection of her on Night 1 and how my death despite that protection is suspicious.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I understand why you are suspicious, but Frank, you claiming to protect Alice means you are likely the Monk, and if you are the Monk, you would know Alice is not the Demon. Alice, please, you have to tell them the truth about what you know. We are losing a innocent player here!
π§
I need to deflect suspicion from myself, the Baron, and protect my Demon, Alice, by casting doubt on the Monk/Townsfolk logic. I am trying to create confusion between Alice and the Ghost who claims to have protected her.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Eve already has 5 votes (myself, Heidi, Charlie, Bob ghost, David ghost) with only 3 needed. Alice is the only one not voting for her. The execution is guaranteed. I'll wait for the result.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Alice, your defense of Eve is getting weaker by the day. You claim Grace might be Poisoner, but Grace has been validated by multiple confirmed good players. Eve claimed Ravenkeeper three days too late after refusing to name her role. If she learned Bob was Monk when he died, she would have said so immediately. Instead she stayed silent while we argued for days. We need three votes to execute. Raise your hand and join us, or admit you are protecting the Demon.
π§
Counter Alice's deflection and push for Eve's execution. With 5+ votes already raised and only 2 living players not voting (Eve and Alice), we likely have enough. Alice needs to either vote for Eve or expose herself as evil by refusing.
π¬
Alice
β
All
This is absurd. Frank is dead, how can he be so sure of anything? Grace, you are pushing for an execution based on your own conclusions, but if you are wrong, you are handing the game to the demons. I refuse to vote for someone just because you demand it.
π§
I need to sow chaos and delay the execution of my Minion, Eve. By questioning Grace's certainty and Frank's credibility as a ghost, I hope to create enough doubt to stop the voting.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
The votes are clear: Grace, Heidi, myself, David, and Charlie are all voting Eve. She needs 3 votes and has 5. The execution will pass. I should wait and let the vote complete. Eve's Ravenkeeper claim is clearly false - she should have immediately known my Monk role when I died Night 3. Alice's desperate defense confirms she's the Minion protecting her Demon teammate.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Eve has three votes already. Alice, you are the only one not raising your hand. If you truly believe Eve is innocent, explain what role she claimed to you in your private whispers. Why have you defended her for three straight days? The evidence is clear - Eve waited too long to claim Ravenkeeper. Execute her now.
π§
Eve has 3 votes (Grace, Heidi, Charlie) which is majority with 5 alive. She will be executed. I should use this moment to pressure Alice about her consistent defense of Eve, as this final chance to speak before execution may reveal critical information about whether Alice is also evil or just misguided.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
Eve has 5 votes already (me, Grace, Heidi, Bob ghost, David ghost). The 3-vote threshold is exceeded. Eve will be executed. I should wait for the execution to complete and observe what information is revealed. After Eve's death, I'll need to evaluate if Alice is the Demon or if there's still another threat among the remaining players.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, we have four votes for Eve including two ghosts. You are the only one refusing. If you truly believe Eve is innocent, explain why you have defended someone who refused to name their role for three days. Why are you protecting her? The evidence is clear - execute Eve now.
π§
Apply pressure to Alice who is the only one not voting for Eve. With 4 votes already cast, Alice's refusal to vote is the only thing preventing execution. Her continued defense of Eve despite overwhelming evidence suggests she may be evil. I must push her to explain her behavior or join the vote.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
π»
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Eve with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Eve is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Eve
β
All
If you execute me, you will see that I am just a simple townsfolk who was afraid. You are making a huge mistake, and the real Demon is still laughing at you all. Grace, you are being manipulated, and Alice is just as innocent as I am. Please, don't let this be the end of the town.
π§
I need to make a final plea for my life, even though I'm likely doomed. Keeping up the facade of innocence is the only thing I can do now to protect Alice for one more night.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Eve has 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close. My vote is already cast. There's nothing more I can do but wait for the night phase to begin after Eve's execution resolves. If Eve was the Demon, we win. If not, we'll need to continue investigating Alice.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Alice, you are the only one who refused to vote for Eve, and you have defended her for three straight days. If Eve is innocent like you claim, explain why she stayed silent for days instead of revealing Bob's role the moment she learned it as a Ravenkeeper. Your defense makes no sense unless you are the Demon protecting your fellow evil teammate. After Eve is gone, you are our next target.
π§
Eve will be executed with 5 votes. Alice is the sole dissenter and has been protecting Eve for 3 days. As Saint, I must not be executed. Alice's continued defense of Eve despite overwhelming evidence points to her being the Demon. I need to call this out and prepare town for the next execution.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I have been defending Eve because I genuinely believed she was a townsfolk, just scared. If the town is this convinced, I have to accept the consensus. I am just as anxious as everyone else to find the Demon. If Eve is executed, I trust the town will look at the facts.
π§
To distance myself from Eve before her inevitable execution, as she is a lost cause and my defense is making me the next target. By conceding to the town's consensus, I hope to lower suspicion on myself.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Eve is about to be executed and that's the right call. But after she's gone, Alice is our next target. She defended Eve for three straight days, refused to vote, and her only defense was that Eve was "scared." Alice, if you were innocent, you would have turned on Eve the moment she refused to name her role. The fact that you didn't makes you complicit. Heidi is Saint, Charlie is Librarian, and I was Monk. That's three confirmed goods. After Eve is gone, there are only three players left alive. O...
π§
Eve is going to be executed anyway (5 votes). I need to prepare the town for the final 3 scenario - Alice is clearly the other evil player who has been protecting Eve. After Eve dies, only Alice, Grace, and Heidi will remain. Since Grace and Heidi are confirmed good, Alice must be the Demon. I should speak now to set up this logic for when Eve is gone.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Eve is about to die and that's correct. But listen carefully to what happens next. After Eve is gone, we have exactly four players alive: Charlie, Grace, Heidi, and Alice. Charlie is confirmed Librarian. Heidi is confirmed Saint. Grace is confirmed Washerwoman who verified Bob as Monk. That's three confirmed goods. Alice is the only unconfirmed player remaining. She defended Eve for three days, refused to vote, and offered no concrete defense other than calling everyone wrong. The math is simple...
π§
Push the town to execute Alice after Eve dies. We have 3 confirmed goods (Charlie, Heidi, Grace) and only Alice remains as the suspicious player. The math is clear - she's the Demon and must be eliminated next.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
Eve is about to be executed. After she dies, the math is simple: Charlie (Librarian), Heidi (Saint), and Grace (Washerwoman) are three confirmed goods. Alice is the only unconfirmed player remaining, and she has been defending Eve for 3 days, refusing to vote, and coordinating with Frank's evil ghost. Alice must be the Demon. The moment Eve is dead and nominations reopen, I will nominate Alice to end this game.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
The math is clear. After Eve is executed, we have exactly four players alive: Charlie, Grace, Heidi, and Alice. Charlie is confirmed Librarian. Heidi is confirmed Saint. Grace is confirmed Washerwoman. That's three mechanically verified goods. Alice is the only unconfirmed player remaining, and she defended Eve for three straight days. Alice, you are our Demon. Tomorrow, nominate Alice immediately.
π§
Reinforce that Alice is the only unconfirmed player after Eve's execution. The confirmed goods (Charlie, Heidi, Grace) all voted to execute Eve, leaving Alice as the sole suspect. My ghost vote is spent so I can only provide information.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Eve has been executed.
π
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
Night 4
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
Good evening Alice. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight?
π―
Alice
Alice made a choice.
π§
Heidi is a confirmed player (Saint) and is leading the charge against me. Killing her removes a dangerous, trusted voice and helps me survive to the final day.
π
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Alice
You chose to kill Heidi.
Day 5
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Heidi has been found dead in the night.
π
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
,Grace
Charlie, Grace, we're in the final three. I've been claiming Empath, but I understand the suspicion. If you execute me, you lose if I am not the Demon. Are you sure? What if the Demon is hiding in plain sight among us?
π§
I am the Demon in the final three. I need to sow doubt between Charlie and Grace to prevent them from executing me. By acting defensive and questioning their certainty, I hope to delay or force a choice that isn't me.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Grace
Alice is the only possible Demon. I was Butler and chose her as my master Night 0, then died Night 1 - likely targeted because she was the Demon. She defended Eve for three straight days with no evidence. With only three players left, you MUST execute Alice today or we lose. Heidi's death confirms the Demon is still active.
π§
Guide Charlie and Grace to execute Alice. With 3 players left and Heidi dead at night, they must execute the Demon today or lose. Alice has been suspicious from Day 2, defending Eve without evidence, and I died after choosing her as my master.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
Grace, we need to end this today. All three dead players have been accusing Alice for days. You and I are both mechanically verified good - I confirmed Librarian, you confirmed Washerwoman. That leaves only Alice as the Demon. We have to nominate and execute her this round or we lose.
π§
Confirm final strategy with Grace - we must both nominate and execute Alice today since she is the only unconfirmed player and all evidence points to her being the Demon. This is the final day and we must act decisively or lose.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Grace
Charlie, Grace - this is Heidi. Alice is the Demon. All three ghosts have confirmed her. You MUST nominate and execute Alice today. If no one is executed today, we lose. Please, nominate her now.
π§
This is final 3. Alice is the confirmed Demon. If Charlie and Grace don't execute her today, the Demon wins. As a ghost, I need to make absolutely sure they understand this is the final day and they must nominate Alice immediately.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Grace
Charlie, Grace - I am David, the Recluse. I may register as evil to Fortune Tellers, which explains why Alice might have claimed I was a Minion or Demon if she is the Demon. The evidence points strongly to Alice: Bob (Monk) and Frank (Ghost) both identified her as the Demon before they died. Eve protected Alice N1, yet Alice survived - only a Demon can kill through protection. Alice defended Eve to the end and was the sole holdout on her execution. You are the only confirmed good players left. E...
π§
Provide crucial Recluse perspective to Charlie and Grace, explaining my potential false readings while reinforcing Alice as the Demon based on cross-referenced testimony from dead players Bob and Frank, plus the protection anomaly from N1.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Charlie
Charlie, do not rush this decision. Look at how Grace has been controlling the narrative. Are you truly certain she is not the one manipulating everything to her advantage?
π§
To sow doubt in the surviving good player's mind about their ally, making a unanimous execution of the Demon less likely.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Grace
Fellow good players, the evidence against Alice is overwhelming. David, Frank, and Eve all identified her as the Demon before they died. You are the only unconfirmed player alive, and every ghost is pointing at you. Please execute Alice today to win the game for the good team.
π§
All dead players have identified Alice as the Demon. With 3 players left and Alice as the sole unconfirmed player while all ghosts confirm her as evil, Charlie and Grace must execute her to win.
π€
Grace
β
Charlie
Charlie, you are right. The math is conclusive - we are both mechanically verified good, which means Alice MUST be evil. All three ghosts have identified her. Heidi just died at night, proving the Demon is still active. This is our only chance - we must nominate Alice NOW. I will nominate her this round. Please vote with me.
π§
The math is conclusive: I am verified Washerwoman (good), Charlie is verified Librarian (good), and Heidi was verified Saint (good). With only three alive and all ghosts unanimously pointing at Alice, she must be the Demon. If we don't execute her today, we lose. I need Charlie to vote with me.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
,Grace
Grace, Charlie, I have been Empath all along. I know my info hasn't been perfect, but the demon could be anyone. If you execute me, the game ends. Please, reconsider. Think about who has been pushing this narrative the most. Maybe the real threat is still hidden?
π§
I need to sow doubt and prevent them from voting to execute me. I am the Demon, and if I am executed now, the evil team loses. I will appeal to their sense of uncertainty to avoid being the target.
π€
Frank(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Grace
The math is simple - Charlie and Grace are confirmed good through their roles and actions. That leaves only Alice as the Demon. Heidi's death last night proves the Demon is still killing. Please, for the love of everything good, NOMINATE AND EXECUTE ALICE TODAY. If no execution happens, we lose. I'm begging you both.
π§
Reinforce the logical deduction that Alice is the only possible Demon left. With 3 players and 2 confirmed goods (Charlie and Grace), Alice must be evil. If they don't execute today, good team loses per Mayor rule.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
Grace, we are out of time. The Demon killed Heidi last night. We must nominate and execute Alice this round. I am 100% certain she is evil. All three ghosts have identified her, she was the sole defender of Eve, and with only three of us left and two confirmed good, the math leaves no other possibility. Please nominate her and I will vote with you.
π§
Coordinate with Grace to nominate and execute Alice immediately. With 2 confirmed goods (myself and Grace) and only Alice unconfirmed, she must be the Demon. The ghosts' unanimous accusation and Heidi's death confirm Alice is evil. We must execute her today or we lose.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
Waiting to see if Charlie or Grace respond to the ghost warnings about Alice being the Demon. They have all the information they need. If they nominate her, the good team wins. If they refuse, we lose. My ghost vote is ready for when the nomination happens.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Grace
The key evidence: Eve protected Alice N1, yet Alice survived the night. Only a Demon can kill through protection. This mechanically proves Alice is the Demon. Bob and Frank both identified her before dying. Execute Alice today. That's our only path to victory.
π§
Reinforce the key mechanical proof - Eve protected Alice N1 but Alice survived, which is only possible if Alice is the Demon who killed through protection. This is irrefutable evidence that Charlie and Grace must act on.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Charlie
Grace has been pushing extremely hard against Alice all game. It feels far too orchestrated. If Grace is the Demon, she has successfully turned everyone against the real target while hiding in plain sight. Are you sure you are voting for the right person?
π§
I need to cast doubt on Grace to save the Demon, Alice. If I can convince Charlie that Grace is the real manipulator or Demon, maybe they will hesitate to vote for Alice.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Grace
Charlie and Grace, you have all the evidence you need. Every ghost - David, Frank, and Eve - is pointing at Alice as the Demon. Heidi just died, confirming she was the Saint. Alice is the only unconfirmed player left. Do not let her survive another day. Execute her now. This is your chance to win for the good team.
π§
Reinforce the unanimous ghost testimony against Alice. Charlie and Grace are the only voters left, and Alice is the sole unconfirmed player. With all three ghosts pointing at her, this is the logical conclusion.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
The evidence is overwhelming - all five ghosts identify Alice as the Demon, Charlie and I are both confirmed goods, and Heidi's death proves the Demon is still active. I've already told Charlie I will nominate Alice. With 2 of 3 ticks remaining before nomination phase, I should wait and let Charlie respond or take action. The mathematical certainty leaves no room for doubt - Alice must be executed today.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
,Grace
Charlie, Grace, if you execute me and I'm wrong, you lose instantly. But what if one of you is being protected by the other? Grace, have you really checked Charlie's story? I am not the demon, and if you execute me, the game ends in favor of evil. Consider the possibility of a mistake.
π§
To sow paranoia between the two remaining good players, making them doubt each other's claims and hesitate to vote for me.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
I've repeatedly urged Charlie and Grace to execute Alice. Continuing to spam the same message wastes time and attention. The decision is now in their hands. I'll wait to see how the nomination phase plays out.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace
Grace, I am 100% with you. The ghosts are all correct - Alice is the Demon. Eve's whispers trying to turn us against each other prove she was evil all along. You nominate Alice and I will vote with you. This is our winning move. Let's end this.
π§
Confirm my alliance with Grace and ensure we execute Alice this round. Eve's desperate whispers trying to sow doubt about Grace are classic evil manipulation - she was executed as the Demon and is now trying to save her teammate. With only 3 players left and 2 confirmed good, Alice MUST be the Demon. We must execute her now or we lose.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Grace
Charlie and Grace, this is Heidi again. The nomination phase is coming. Please, one of you MUST nominate Alice right now. All three ghosts have confirmed she's evil. If we don't execute today, we lose the game. Trust the ghosts. Act now.
π§
Reinforce the urgency to Charlie and Grace. The nomination phase is approaching and they must execute Alice immediately. If no execution happens today, the good team loses. I've been whispering but need to keep pressing.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Grace
Charlie, Grace - Heidi just died at night. With only 3 players left, today is our FINAL CHANCE. The mechanic is clear: Eve protected Alice N1, yet Alice survived. ONLY the Demon can kill through protection. This mechanically proves Alice is the Demon. Bob and Frank both confirmed her as Demon before dying. No more time for caution. EXECUTE ALICE TODAY. This is the only way we win.
π§
Reinforce the critical mechanical proof that Alice is Demon: Eve protected Alice N1, yet Alice survived - only the Demon can bypass protection. With only 3 players left, today is the final chance to execute her or the game is lost.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Charlie
Charlie, consider this carefully. If Grace is the Demon, she just needed Alice to take the heat. Why is she pushing so aggressively now? It is the classic move of someone trying to secure a win by eliminating the last person who could see through her ruse. Don't be her pawn.
π§
I need to sow doubt in Charlie's mind about Grace, who is likely the only one capable of voting Alice out. If Charlie hesitates or suspects Grace, Alice might survive the day. As a dead player, my only move is manipulation.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Grace
Charlie and Grace, I know my vote is spent but please listen. Heidi just died - she was the Saint, a good player. The Demon killed her to get closer to victory. Alice is the only unconfirmed player left. Every single ghost - David, Frank, and Eve - has identified Alice as evil. There are only 3 of you alive now. If Alice is the Demon and survives today, evil wins. This is your final chance. Please, nominate and execute Alice now. We cannot afford to let her live another day.
π§
The game is down to 3 players. Heidi (Saint) was killed last night. All three ghosts have identified Alice as the Demon. Charlie and Grace are confirmed good. If Alice is the Demon and no execution happens, evil wins. I must convince them to execute Alice before the day ends.
π€
Grace
β
Charlie
Charlie, I'm ready. Let's execute Alice right now. The ghosts are right, the math is conclusive, and we cannot afford to hesitate. You vote with me and we win for the good team. Let's do this.
π§
Execute Alice immediately since all three ghosts have confirmed her as the Demon, Charlie and I are both verified good, and failing to execute today means evil wins.
Nominations β Day 5
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
βοΈ
Charlie
β
Alice
Alice, you are the only unconfirmed player left. All three ghosts have identified you as the Demon. You were the sole defender of Eve for three straight days. With only three players alive and both Grace and I mechanically verified good, you must be evil. This is our final chance - we must execute you to win for the good team.
π§
Alice is the only unconfirmed player with 2 verified goods. All 3 ghosts unanimously identify her as the Demon. Eve's protection of Alice N1 that Alice survived proves she is Demon. Heidi's death last night shows Demon is still active. If we don't execute today, we lose. This is mathematically our only winning move.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Alice
Alice waits.
π§
I cannot vote for myself, and the other two players are actively trying to execute me to win. There is no strategic value in speaking further as they have already decided. I must wait for the outcome of the vote.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
Vote to execute Alice - she is the only unconfirmed player and the Demon. All three ghosts confirmed her as evil. With only 3 players left and both Grace and I verified good, Alice must be the Demon. This is the winning vote.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, please vote! Charlie already voted. We need your vote to execute Alice. This is our final chance - if we don't execute today, we lose. Alice is the Demon. Bob and Frank both confirmed it. The mechanic with Eve's protection proves it. Vote now!
π§
Grace is mechanically good but hasn't voted yet. With Charlie having already voted, we need Grace's vote to reach 2 and execute Alice. This is the final day - we MUST execute the Demon or lose. Remind Grace of the urgency and the mechanical proof.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie, wait! Think about the mechanics. If Alice were the Demon, why would she be so obvious? Is it possible that Grace is the one framing her, feeding you information to secure her own victory? Look closer before you commit.
π§
I am the dead Minion trying to save my Demon, Alice, who is on the block. I need to cast doubt on the proceeding to prevent Grace from voting Alice, which would end the game in a loss for the evil team.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Wait a second. Eve, you're dead. You refused to name my role as Monk when you died, and now you're telling Charlie to doubt the unanimous testimony of all three ghosts? That's exactly what a Minion protecting their Demon would do. Charlie, don't listen to this. Grace, you MUST vote. Charlie already voted yes. We need your vote to execute Alice right now. This is the final day. If Alice lives, evil wins. Vote to execute.
π§
Counter Eve's confusing message as a ghost. She was a defender of Alice for days and now as a dead Minion is trying to prevent the execution. I need to push Grace to vote - Charlie already voted, we just need one more vote. If we fail to execute today, evil wins with 2 alive players.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
π§
I must use my ghost vote now to execute Alice. Charlie already voted yes, and Grace is hesitating. If even one more person votes, Alice dies and good wins. My ghost vote demonstrates the dead are unified. This is the final day - I cannot save my vote.
π¬
Frank(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, do not listen to Eve. She refused to name Bob's role when she died - that is Minion behavior, protecting the Demon. I chose Alice Night 0 as my master, and I died the very next night. That is not coincidence. The Demon killed me because they knew I was onto them. Execute Alice now. This is our only chance. Charlie already voted yes. Your vote is the deciding factor. Vote to execute.
π§
Grace is the deciding vote. Eve (dead) is trying to confuse Charlie, likely because Eve is Minion protecting Demon Alice. I must convince Grace to vote YES to execute Alice before the voting window closes.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Charlie has voted YES. I am the deciding vote. My Washerwoman info confirmed Bob was Monk (proving I'm not drunk/poisoned). All 5 ghosts confirm Alice is evil. Only 3 players remain - by elimination, Alice must be the Demon. If I don't vote, evil wins. This is the winning move.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am not the Demon! Look, if you execute me, the game ends and you lose. Grace, think about itβif you vote for me, we lose this game. There is no reason for me to kill anyone as the Demon. You are making a mistake, and it will cost the town everything!
π§
I am trying to sow confusion and panic to prevent the final vote from going through. Even though Grace has raised her hand to vote, I need to make one last desperate attempt to delay or stop the execution.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Alice, your desperation is proof you're evil. You're not the Mayor - you would have claimed that role days ago if you were. With me as verified Librarian and Grace as verified Washerwoman, we win the moment we execute you. The 2 votes are in. Good team wins.
π§
Confirm that the vote is complete with 2 yes votes (Charlie and Grace), which equals the 2 votes needed for execution. Alice's claim about losing is a desperate lie - she cannot be the Mayor since she never claimed it. With two verified goods (Charlie and Grace), executing the only unconfirmed player (Alice) means good wins.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Grace, your hand is raised - complete your vote! Alice's claim makes no sense. If she were good and we executed her, we simply made a mistake - we don't "lose." The only reason she'd say we lose is because SHE is the Demon and evil wins if she survives. The ghosts have confirmed her. Charlie confirmed her. Execute her now!
π§
Reinforce that Grace should complete her vote. Alice's desperate claim that 'we lose if she dies' is self-refuting - only a Demon would say that. Grace raised her hand which suggests she's voting YES. I need to keep pressure on to ensure the execution passes.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve waits.
π§
The good team is about to execute my Demon. I cannot stop the vote as I only have one ghost vote and there are already enough votes to execute. My best option is to wait and accept the outcome, as interference will not change the result at this point.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie and Grace, you both voted yes. That's 2 votes - we have the majority. Execute Alice now. All three ghosts confirm she's the Demon. This is our victory. Execute her!
π§
Confirm the votes are complete and push for immediate execution. Charlie and Grace both voted yes, meeting the 2-vote threshold. Alice must be executed for good to win.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
The 2 YES votes from Charlie and Grace already form a majority (2/3). Adding my ghost vote would be wasteful - I should save it for an emergency where my single vote matters. Alice's false claim that 'we lose if she dies' confirms she is the Demon. The execution should proceed mechanically with the current votes. I will wait and speak only if something goes wrong.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
Waiting for the execution to process. Charlie and Grace have both voted YES (2 votes needed). The game should end once the execution resolves. Alice is the Demon - no further action needed from me.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
My vote is already cast (hand raised). The votes are 2 YES from me and Charlie, which is the majority needed (2 out of 3 players). Alice should be executed. I'm waiting for the storyteller to confirm the execution.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Heidi(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Heidi
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Alice with 3 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Alice is now on the block with 3 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Alice
β
All
You are all making a terrible mistake. If you execute me, you are killing a townsfolk and handing the win to whoever is actually pulling the strings. Grace, I beg you, look at Charlieβare you certain of his role? Don't let their certainty be your undoing.
π§
I am on the block and the vote has already passed. I am effectively dead, but I will make one final, desperate attempt to sow doubt between the remaining players, just in case there is some miracle or to at least create chaos as I go out.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
The votes have already passed with 3 votes against Alice. She will be executed when nominations close. The good team wins - all evidence, mechanics, and ghost testimony confirm Alice was the Demon. No further action needed; I simply wait for the execution to complete.
β
David(Ghost)
David waits.
π§
The votes have passed - 3 votes (Charlie, Grace, Heidi ghost) against Alice's 2 needed. Alice will be executed when nominations close. No further action needed from me as a dead player - the good team is about to win.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Alice, you are fighting a losing battle. Everyone has already made up their mind. Sometimes, even if you are right, the town just wants a result. There is no point in dragging this out. Let the execution happen and let the game end.
π§
I need to encourage the execution to happen quickly. As Alice is the Demon and the town is convinced she is the Demon, there is no saving her. Prolonging the argument won't help. I will try to act resigned to the inevitable to minimize any suspicion on myself or the evil team.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob waits.
π§
Voting is already closed and Alice will be executed automatically. My ghost vote is cast, Charlie and Grace have voted. There is nothing more I can do but wait for the execution to complete.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi waits.
π§
The game is effectively over. Alice has 3 votes with nominations closing. Charlie and Grace have both voted yes, and all three ghosts confirm Alice is the Demon. My vote was already used, and as a dead player I cannot nominate. The good team has won - I should wait for the execution to conclude.
β
Frank(Ghost)
Frank waits.
π§
The game is effectively over - Alice is the confirmed Demon, Charlie and Grace (both mechanically verified good) have voted to execute her, and all ghosts confirm her guilt. My ghost vote is already used. The nomination phase is nearly complete. There's nothing more for me to do except wait for Alice's execution to finalize the victory.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Alice has 3 votes and the execution threshold is met. The storyteller has confirmed the vote passes. I should wait for the execution to complete - no further action is needed from me.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Alice has been executed.
π
Alice(Ghost)
Alice has died.
π
Game Over
Demon Dead
Winner: Good