Game Detail
Players
Alice (Soldier) Bob (Mayor) Charlie (Imp) David (Librarian) Eve (Butler) Frank (Scarlet Woman) Grace (Fortune Teller) Heidi (Chef)
Token Usage
| Team | Input Tokens | Output Tokens | Cost (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good | 881,866 | 104,740 | $0.4299 |
| Evil | 362,194 | 19,899 | $0.2408 |
Event Transcript
π
The game has started.
π
Storyteller
β
Frank
You are the Minion. The Demon is Charlie.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Minions are: Frank. Your safe bluffs are: Recluse, Slayer, Investigator
π
Storyteller
β
David
Good evening David. You are the Librarian. Either Bob or Eve is the Butler.
π
Storyteller
β
Heidi
Good evening Heidi. You are the Chef. You learn that there are 0 pairs of evil players.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
π―
Grace
Grace made choices.
π§
Early broad scan to quickly include or exclude two central players, allowing focused follow-up and crosschecks with others.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose Bob and David. You receive the answer: YES.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Eve
Eve made a choice.
π§
Choosing Frank balances safety and information: as my neighbor he is flexible for coordination, and watching whether he votes will give tells about his alignment tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
You chose Frank to be your master.
Day 1
π
Storyteller
Welcome to the village of Ravenswood Bluff. Please take this time to get to know your fellow villagers. Feel free to move around and have private conversations. Be wary, for a Demon hides among you!
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Grace
Hi Alice and Grace. I am Heidi, the Chef. I learned there are zero pairs of evil players. That means the Demon and Minion are not sitting next to each other. Keep this private for now and tell me any claims you hear.
π§
Share my Chef read privately with my two neighbors so we can triangulate suspects without making me an immediate public target.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
,Grace
Thanks, Heidi β I appreciate you telling me privately. I will keep this quiet. Grace, did you hear anyone claim a role or act oddly? Heidi, any other claims you heard? Let's quietly compare notes before daybreak.
π§
Confirm Heidi's Chef info, keep it secret, and solicit any claims or suspicious behavior from Grace to build our early case without broadcasting the mechanic.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,David
Frank, you are my Butler master today β can you promise to vote when nominations start? David, can you back our nomination if we agree on a suspect? We should coordinate so I can vote too.
π§
I must lock in my ability to vote by getting Frank to commit to voting. Coordinate with David so we can form a voting bloc and steer the first nomination toward a suspicious player.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Heidi
I need to keep this private. My N0 Fortune Teller read for Bob and David was YES β at least one of them registers as Demon to me. That could be the real Demon or the good person who looks Demon. Heidi, your Chef info (zero evil pairs) is consistent with this. Alice, what did you notice? Can you both avoid sharing this publicly until we have more checks?
π§
Share my night read privately with Heidi and Alice to coordinate a quiet investigation and avoid tipping off evil players. Confirm Heidi's Chef info and ask Alice for any odd behavior notes.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Charlie
Quick check: do you have any mechanical info or suspicious private convos to share right now? If not, who whispered to you earlier? I want to coordinate nominations and spot contradictions before we nominate.
π§
Get any mechanical info or recent private convo details from nearby players so we can coordinate nominations and spot contradictions.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,Alice
I haven't had any private chats yet, you're the first! No hard info on my end, just a regular villager trying to get my bearings. What about you? Did you catch anything from that big huddle with Heidi, Alice, and Grace?
π§
I want to establish myself as a 'regular villager' without info to avoid being a target for early execution or Slayer shots, while also probing Bob for what he knows about the other group's whispers.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
,David
,Charlie
I can definitely do that, Eve. I will make sure to vote so you can too. David, what do you think? It would be good to have a solid block of three of us working together. Charlie, any thoughts on who we should be looking at?
π§
I want to build trust with Eve (who claims Butler) and David, while also subtly looping in my Demon (Charlie) to our 'alliance' without being too obvious. This helps me control the vote and protect Charlie.
π€
David
β
Eve
,Frank
Hi Eve, hi Frank. I was privately told that either Bob or Eve is the Butler. Can you two confirm who the Butler is today? Frank, can you reaffirm you will vote when nominations start? Eve, if you are the Butler please say so so we can coordinate a reliable block.
π§
Confirm who is Butler and lock in a reliable voting block. If Eve is Butler, her master Frank voting proves it; if Bob is Butler, we still want coordinated votes to protect town progress.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Grace
Stay quiet for now about my Chef info. Grace, your FT on Bob and David is key β avoid declaring it publicly yet. If either of them gets another check or makes an odd claim, tell me immediately. Share any role-claims you hear. We reveal before final day.
π§
Keep the Fortune Teller and Chef info private, coordinate quietly, and ask them to report any role claims or suspicious talk about Bob or David so we can narrow the Demon without revealing mechanics.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
,Grace
Agree, stay quiet for now. If either Bob or David gets another check or makes a claim, tell us immediately. I am Soldier (private) and safe from the Demon. Let us quietly compare any new whispers before nominations.
π§
Keep Heidi and Grace aligned, avoid public reveal yet, and request immediate sharing of any new checks or role-claims to build a consistent map before nominations.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,David
Yes, I am the Butler today. Frank, please vote when nominations start so I can. David, back our nomination and I will vote. Let us pick a suspect now and agree quickly.
π§
Secure coordinated votes so I can participate and form a reliable block for the first nomination, while checking Davids claim for contradictions.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Heidi
Stay quiet for now. My N0 FT read on Bob+David was YES. Heidiβs Chef zero-pairs is consistent. Watch Bob and David closely for any claims or checks. If either is checked or claims, tell us immediately. Be ready to push when we have more proof.
π§
Keep our mini-coalition quiet, avoid tipping FT, monitor Bob and David for claims or checks, be ready to force a nomination on solid info later.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Charlie
Quick check: do you have any mechanical info or suspicious private convos to share? If not, who whispered to you earlier? I want to coordinate nominations and spot contradictions before we nominate.
π§
Elicit any mechanical info or who whispered to whom, so we can spot contradictions and nominate the best suspect before nominations close.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
,Eve
,David
I'm still just getting my bearings, Frank. I haven't heard much yet, but I'm happy to coordinate with you guys. Who are you most suspicious of so far? I'm keeping an eye on that big group with Alice, Heidi, and Graceβthey've been whispering a lot.
π§
I want to establish a connection with my Minion (Frank) and the players he is already talking to (Eve and David) to build trust and a potential voting block.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
,David
,Charlie
I agree, Charlie. That group of threeβAlice, Heidi, and Graceβis definitely suspicious with all that whispering. Eve, since you're the Butler, I'll make sure to vote so you can too. David, let's keep an eye on that trio. Maybe one of them is the Demon?
π§
I want to reinforce the alliance with my Demon (Charlie) and the two potential good players (Eve and David) while casting suspicion on the other group.
π€
David
β
Eve
,Frank
Eve, please confirm publicly you are the Butler so others hear. Frank, please confirm you will vote when nominations start. If both yes, who do you want to target from Alice, Heidi, Grace?
π§
Confirm Eve's Butler claim and secure Frank's voting promise so we can form a coordinated nomination or expose a liar quickly.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Grace
Quick update: I am still Chef, 0 evil pairs. Grace, your FT on Bob+David is our best lead. Alice, your Soldier claim helps; do not reveal it widely. Stay quiet. If either Bob or David gets checked or claims, tell us immediately so we can act.
π§
Keep our small circle coordinated, avoid public reveals, and prompt immediate reports if Bob or David are checked or make claims so we can narrow Demon without tipping off evil.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
,Grace
Stay quiet for now. We keep Heidi's Chef and Grace's FT private. I am Soldier (safe). Watch Bob and David for claims or checks. If either is checked or claims, tell us immediately so we can act before nominations. Any new whispers to share?
π§
Keep our private lead intact, avoid tipping players off, and coordinate when to reveal Soldier or push nomination based on further checks or claims.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,David
Please confirm publicly that you will vote when nominations start. If both confirm, let's nominate Alice β her whisper trio looks suspicious. Agree? If either of you will not confirm, tell me now and we will adjust.
π§
Get Frank and David to publicly confirm so town trusts our voting bloc and to pick Alice as our initial nomination to force reactions and gather information.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Heidi
Stay quiet for now. My FT N0 on Bob+David was YES. Heidi's Chef zero-pairs supports keeping them separate. Tell me immediately if either is checked, claims, or acts oddly. If we get another independent check or a suspicious claim, we push then.
π§
Keep coordination with Alice and Heidi, avoid public reveal, and agree on a conditional plan to act only when we get another independent check or a suspicious claim.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Charlie
Quick check: do you have any mechanical info or suspicious private convos to share? Who whispered to you earlier? I want to map private chats and spot contradictions before nominations.
π§
Collect who whispered to Alice and Charlie and any mechanical info so we can map private chats and spot contradictions before nominations.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,Alice
I haven't had any private chats yet, you're the first! No hard info on my end, just a regular villager trying to get my bearings. What about you? Did you catch anything from that big huddle with Heidi, Alice, and Grace?
π§
I need to respond to Bob's repeated inquiry to maintain my cover as a helpful but uninformed villager. By pointing out the other group's whispering, I'm trying to deflect suspicion away from myself and my minion Frank.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
,David
,Charlie
I'm in, Eve. I'll confirm publicly that I'm your master and that I'll be voting. Alice is a great target; that trio is way too quiet with the rest of us. Charlie, David, are we all on board for Alice?
π§
I want to solidify the alliance with Eve (the Butler) and David, while keeping my Demon (Charlie) in the loop. By agreeing to target Alice, I'm pushing suspicion away from the evil team and onto a potentially powerful good player.
π€
David
β
Eve
,Frank
Eve, please publicly claim you are the Butler now so everyone hears. Frank, please publicly confirm you will vote when nominations start. If both yes, we can nominate Alice as discussed. If either hesitates, tell me why.
π§
Force public confirmation from Eve and Frank to create a reliable voting block or catch Eve lying; this narrows suspects and progresses to nomination.
π€
Heidi
β
Alice
,Grace
Quick plan: keep my Chef and Grace's FT private. If Bob or David get checked, claim, or act odd, tell us immediately. Do not reveal Soldier publicly yet, Alice. If we get independent corroboration before nominations we push; otherwise wait.
π§
Keep our triangle coordinated, avoid early public reveal, and be ready to act if Bob or David are checked or claim.
π€
Alice
β
Heidi
,Grace
Agree, stay quiet. I am Soldier (private). Keep Heidi's Chef and Grace's Fortune Teller read private for now. Watch Bob and David closely. If either is checked, claims a role, or acts strange, tell us immediately so we can push before nominations.
π§
Keep Heidi's Chef and Grace's FT private, avoid publicising my Soldier yet, and coordinate rapid reporting if Bob or David are checked or make claims before nominations.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,David
Frank, David β thanks for agreeing. I want to keep my role quiet for now. Can you both publicly confirm you will vote when nominations start? If you do, we nominate Alice as planned. If either of you hesitate, say so and we will rethink.
π§
Secure public confirmations to enable my Butler vote without revealing my role now, and push a coordinated nomination at minimal risk.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Heidi
Stay quiet. My N0 Fortune Teller on Bob+David was YES. Keep Heidi's Chef and Alice's Soldier claim private. If either Bob or David are checked, claim, or act odd before nominations, tell me immediately so we can push. I will do the same.
π§
Preserve our covert info until we get independent confirmation. Prompt Alice and Heidi to immediately report any checks, claims, or odd behaviour from Bob or David so we can push with proof before nominations.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Charlie
Quick check: do you have any mechanical info or suspicious private convos to share right now? Who whispered to you earlier from that Heidi Alice Grace group? I want to map their chats before nominations.
π§
Get mechanical info or witness reports from Alice and Charlie to detect contradictions in the huddle and coordinate a safe first nomination.
π€
Charlie
β
Bob
,Alice
I haven't talked to that group at all, Bob. They've been keeping to themselves. I'm definitely getting weird vibes from Alice, Heidi, and Grace. Frank and David seem to think Alice is the one to watch. What are you hearing?
π§
I want to maintain my 'regular villager' persona with Bob while subtly reinforcing the suspicion against the Alice/Heidi/Grace trio that my Minion (Frank) is pushing. I'm also including Alice in the whisper to see if she reacts or reveals anything about her huddle.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
,David
,Eve
Charlie, David, Eve - I'm ready. I'll confirm I'm voting as soon as nominations open. Let's go for Alice; that group is definitely hiding something. Charlie, you still with us on this?
π§
To solidify the evil-led voting block and ensure Charlie (the Demon) is aligned with the plan to target Alice.
π€
David
β
Frank
,Charlie
Frank, Charlie β quick public confirm: will you both vote for Alice when nominations open? Eve privately told me she is Butler but will not claim; that makes me uneasy. If you will vote, say so publicly now. If not, say why so we do not rush a bad nomination.
π§
Get public confirmations from Frank and Charlie and pressure Eve to either claim publicly or delay nomination so we avoid a risky mislynch.
Nominations β Day 1
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open.
π¬
David
β
All
Frank, Charlie β please confirm publicly now that you will vote for Alice if she is nominated. Eve, if you are the Butler as you told me privately, please say so publicly now or explain why you are staying hidden. I do not want us to rush a nomination without public confirmations.
π§
Get public confirmations from Frank and Charlie and force Eve to either publicly claim Butler or explain hesitation before we risk nominating Alice.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Preserve private FT and Chef info, wait for public confirmations or independent checks before nominating. Avoid tipping Demon or forcing premature vote.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I am definitely voting for Alice if she is nominated. I agree with David; that group has been way too quiet and suspicious all morning. Let's get some answers. Eve, if you are the Butler, now is the time to let the town know so we can coordinate our votes properly.
π§
I want to publicly confirm my commitment to the plan to build trust with David and Eve, while also putting pressure on Alice to create a target for execution. This protects my Demon, Charlie, by directing attention elsewhere.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Frank and David, thank you β I am not going to publicise my role right now. Frank, please confirm again you will vote for Alice if nominated. David, please confirm you will vote too. If both of you confirm publicly, I will nominate Alice now.
π§
Get public confirmations from Frank and David without revealing my Butler role; ensure we have enough votes before nominating Alice and avoid depending on my hidden ability.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Please pause on nominating Alice. We have private info pointing at Bob or David; rushing risks losing a Town. Wait one tick for more confirmations or checks. Do not confirm votes yet unless you have independent proof.
π§
Prevent a premature nomination of Alice; buy time for independent checks or confirms on Bob/David so we can target the Demon instead of wasting a Town execution.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
I am definitely on board with voting for Alice. That huddle with Heidi and Grace has been very exclusionary all morning, and Heidi's sudden defense of Alice by pointing at Bob or David without sharing why feels like a deflection. I am ready to vote if Alice is nominated.
π§
I want to reinforce the push against Alice to create conflict between the two main groups and establish myself as a cooperative 'town' member.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Hold up one tick. Frank and David, please publicly confirm you will vote for Alice. Heidi, Alice, Grace: what exactly is your private info pointing at Bob or David? I do not want a rushed nomination without public confirmations or concrete reasoning.
π§
Get public vote confirmations and force quiet clusters to reveal info before we nominate, avoiding a rushed misexecution.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Please pause on nominating Alice this tick. We have private corroboration pointing at Bob or David; rushing to execute someone without public confirmations risks killing a Town. Wait one tick for Frank and David to confirm publicly or for another check to surface.
π§
Buy one tick to get public confirmations or additional checks and prevent a premature lynch of a likely Town based on private corroboration.
π¬
David
β
All
I will publicly confirm: I will vote for Alice if she is nominated. I was privately told the Butler is either Bob or Eve. Eve, please publicly confirm you are the Butler now or explain why you will not β we need clarity before we rush to execute someone.
π§
Get public confirmation from Eve or Bob to validate my Librarian info and lock votes; balance between pushing nomination and avoiding a bad execution.
β
Grace
Grace waits.
π§
Delay nomination one tick to gather public confirmations or independent checks; avoid executing an innocent based on private info alone.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I have already confirmed I am voting for Alice. Heidi and Alice, you keep mentioning private info but aren't sharing it. That feels like a stall tactic. Charlie, David, and I are ready. Eve, if you are the Butler, we have the votes. Let's get some real information on the board.
π§
I want to maintain the pressure on Alice and the quiet group while appearing to be a helpful, proactive good player. By calling out their 'private info' as a stall tactic, I discredit them and push for an execution that isn't my Demon (Charlie).
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am not revealing my role yet. I agree we should not rush. Frank, David, Charlie β please publicly confirm one more time you will vote for Alice if nominated. Heidi, Alice, Grace β if you have private info pointing at Bob or David, please state specifics now or we wait one tick. I want clear commitments before I nominate.
π§
Delay a potentially bad first execution and force the trio to produce their private info. Preserve my Butler secrecy while confirming public votes so we can make a coordinated nomination if warranted.
π¬
Heidi
β
All
Please pause one more tick. We have private checks suggesting the Demon is either Bob or David, not Alice. Frank and David, publicly confirm your votes now if you will still back Alice. Eve, if you are Butler, say so now or we wait one tick for clarity.
π§
Delay a premature nomination so town can force confirmation or get a check; preserve Chef and Fortune Teller info until we have public corroboration to safely execute the Demon.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Heidi, you keep saying you have 'private checks' but you aren't sharing what they are or who they're from. That feels like you're just trying to save Alice. I've already said I'm ready to vote for her. If you have real info, share it, otherwise let's get some clarity on Alice.
π§
I want to maintain pressure on Alice and the 'quiet' group while appearing to be a helpful, logic-driven Townsfolk. By calling out Heidi's vague 'checks', I cast doubt on their validity.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Heidi, Alice, Grace β say plainly who ran the private check and exactly what it showed. Frank, David, Charlie β confirm once more publicly you will vote for Alice if nominated. If no concrete info appears this tick I will nominate Alice next tick.
π§
Force Heidi/Alice/Grace to reveal specifics or lose credibility; get public vote confirmations to allow nomination next tick if no concrete evidence appears.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Please pause one tick. Frank, David, Charlie β publicly confirm now you will vote for Alice if nominated. Heidi and Grace β who exactly ran which private check and what did it show, privately tell me immediately. I am not revealing Soldier yet.
π§
Delay nomination to gather public confirmations or another independent check so we do not execute an innocent and can narrow Demon to Bob or David.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 1
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
I am killing Heidi because she claimed to have 'private checks' pointing at my neighbor David or Bob. Since David is a potential ally/minion-candidate (though Frank is my confirmed minion), Heidi represents the most immediate mechanical threat to the evil team's narrative. Removing her prevents her from sharing that information or getting more.
π
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You chose to kill Heidi.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
Good evening Grace. You are the Fortune Teller. Choose 2 players to learn if either is a Demon.
π―
Grace
Grace made choices.
π§
Narrow down the Demon between Bob and David by retesting the same pair to confirm the earlier YES and guide nomination decisions next day.
π
Storyteller
β
Grace
You chose Bob and David. You receive the answer: YES.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Eve
Eve made a choice.
π§
Selecting a reliable, vocal supporter maximizes our ability to vote cohesively on the upcoming nomination and avoids being silenced by an uncertain master.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
You chose Frank to be your master.
Day 2
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Heidi has been found dead in the night.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,Bob
Morning. Heidi dead. Grace, you flagged Bob+David night zeroβcan you confirm exactly what you saw privately? Bob, did anyone whisper you checks or push you to ask for reads? Can we hold nominations one tick so we can confirm before we risk executing?
π§
Get private confirmation from Grace and Bob about their flags and whispers so we can delay nominations one tick and avoid wasting an execution.
π€
David
β
Frank
,Charlie
Frank, Charlie β can you publicly confirm you will vote for Alice if nominated? We need visible commitments to force clarity on the Butler claim and move to nomination.
π§
Get Frank and Charlie to publicly confirm their vote or stance so we can pressure blockers and test Eve/Bob Butler claim before nominations.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Bob
Alice: I checked Bob+David both nights; both reads were YES. That means at least one registers Demon to me. Could be a good registering as Demon, but consistent read makes Bob or David highly suspicious. I agree hold nominations one tick. Bob: did anyone whisper you checks or push you to ask for reads?
π§
Confirm my private reads publicly with Alice and ask Bob if he received any whispers. Buying one tick reduces risk of executing an innocent.
π€
Frank
β
David
,Charlie
I am definitely down to vote for Alice. She is being way too cagey and that trio with Heidi and Grace felt like a massive distraction. With Heidi dead, we need to push Alice for a full claim or get her out. Charlie, you with us?
π§
Confirming my commitment to the evil team's plan to target Alice, while maintaining the facade of a suspicious good player.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,David
Frank, David: I am the Butler. I can only vote tomorrow if my chosen master votes too β currently Frank. Please confirm privately if you will vote for Alice if nominated, or who you will vote for, so I know whether I will be able to vote.
π§
Get private commitments from Frank and David so I know whether I will be allowed to vote tomorrow and can coordinate nominations accordingly.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
,David
I am absolutely with you both. Alice is the priority. With Heidi gone, that trio is weaker, and Alice's cagey behavior is a huge red flag. I will publicly commit to the vote and push her to claim properly. Let's get this done.
π§
Confirming my commitment to the evil team's plan to target Alice, maintaining coordination with my Minion (Frank) and a potential ally (David).
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Grace
I agree hold one tick. Grace, restate exactly what you checked both nights and whether both reads were YES on Bob and David. Alice, who told you about Heidi's checks and can you reveal source/details now?
π§
Get Grace to restate exact reads and Alice to reveal source so we can safely delay nominations one tick and avoid executing an innocent.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Grace
,Alice
,David
I was Chef and died N1. I read 0 pairs of evil players. That means there are no adjacent evil pairs. Grace, your FT flagged Bob+David β that fits only if at most one of them is evil. Alice/David: consider pressing Bob or David singly, and ask Grace to re-check or reveal her FT to confirm which of them is Demon.
π§
Reveal my Chef info to trusted players to remove impossible dual-evil scenarios and steer them toward investigating/executing the Demon among Bob and David.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,Bob
Hold nominations one tick. Grace, please restate exactly what you checked both nights and whether both reads were YES on Bob and David. If you can, reveal your Fortune Teller now or re-check publicly. Bob, confirm you agree to delay.
π§
Delay nominations one tick and get Grace to either publicly reveal her FT reads or re-check to confirm which of Bob/David is Demon. Reduces risk of killing a Town.
π€
David
β
Frank
,Charlie
Frank, Charlie β please publicly confirm in chat that you will vote for Alice if she is nominated today. We need visible commitments now so Eve's Butler claim and voting availability are clear. Say it aloud so everyone sees it.
π§
Get Frank and Charlie to publicly confirm now so the group knows whether Eve can vote and to force Alice to either claim or be nominated.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Bob
I checked Bob+David Night 0 and Night 1. Both nights I received YES. That means at least one of Bob/David registers as a Demon to me (could be Demon or a good who registers Demon). I agree hold one tick. Bob: were you whispered or pressured about reads? Alice: who told you about Heidi's checks?
π§
Reiterate exact FT checks, pause nominations one tick, prompt Bob to say if he was pressured, and ask Alice for source of Heidi's Chef info so we can decide next steps.
π€
Frank
β
David
,Charlie
,Eve
I am definitely voting for Alice today. Her behavior yesterday was super suspicious and now that Heidi is gone, we need answers. Eve, since you are the Butler and I am your master, you can count on my vote being there for Alice. David, Charlie, let's make this happen.
π§
I am confirming my vote for Alice to my evil team (Charlie and David) and to Eve (who claims Butler and has picked me as her master). This builds trust with Eve and coordinates the evil team's push against Alice.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,David
Frank, David: Frank says you will both vote Alice. I need explicit private confirmations: will you vote for Alice if nominated? If either of you will not vote, tell me who you will vote for so I can decide whether I can vote tomorrow.
π§
Confirm private voting commitments so I can use my Butler restriction effectively and either support Alice's nomination or pause if my vote will be blocked.
π€
Charlie
β
David
,Frank
I am absolutely with you, David. Frank, I saw your message too. I will publicly state my commitment to vote for Alice as soon as the floor is open. We need to break that trio's hold on the information and Alice is the clear starting point. Let's get her to claim or get her out.
π§
Confirming my commitment to the evil team's plan to target Alice, while maintaining my 'helpful townie' persona with David.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Grace
I agree hold one tick. Grace: restate exactly what you checked both nights, the exact read (YES/NO) for Bob and David, and confirm you are Fortune Teller. If you cannot re-check publicly, tell us the precise phrasing you saw. Alice: who told you about Heidi's checks and what exactly did they say?
π§
Get precise wording and role proof from Grace and source of Heidi's checks from Alice so we avoid executing a town and gather mechanical confirmation.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Grace
,David
Grace please reveal or re-check your FT (Bob+David=YES) publicly so we can pin which one is Demon. David push a single target (Bob or David) and press them hard instead of splitting. My Chef read 0 pairs β they cannot both be evil.
π§
Get Grace to reveal or re-check her Fortune Teller result and push David to single-target pressure so the group can execute the Demon with my ghost vote if needed.
π€
Alice
β
Grace
,Bob
Grace: please publicly confirm you are Fortune Teller and give the exact phrasing you saw both nights for Bob and David (YES/NO or other words). If you can, reveal now. Bob: confirm you will hold nominations one tick so we can get this clarified.
π§
Get Grace to publicly confirm exact Fortune Teller phrasing and role, and have Bob explicitly agree to hold nominations one tick so we can avoid a premature execution.
π€
David
β
Frank
,Charlie
Frank, Charlie β please publicly state in chat right now that you will vote for Alice if she is nominated today. We need visible commitments to lock Eve's Butler claim and move to nomination. Say it aloud so everyone sees it.
π§
Get explicit public confirmations from Frank and Charlie to lock voting availability and force Eve to reveal or fail her Butler claim, allowing us to proceed with nomination.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Bob
Holding nominations one tick. I confirm I checked Bob+David both nights and both reads were YES. Bob: were you whispered or pressured about reads? Alice: who told you about Heidi's Chef info? If we delay one tick I'll reveal FT publicly next if needed.
π§
Delay nominations one tick to gather confirmations: get Bob to admit if he was whispered/pressured, get Alice to name source of Heidi's Chef info, and prepare to reveal FT if needed to force clarity.
π€
Frank
β
David
,Charlie
,Eve
I am absolutely voting for Alice today. Her behavior yesterday was super suspicious and now that Heidi is gone, we need answers. Eve, since you are the Butler and I am your master, you can count on my vote being there for Alice. David, Charlie, let's make this happen.
π§
I need to reassure my evil team (Charlie and David) and the potential Outsider (Eve) that I am committed to the Alice execution. This builds trust with Eve and keeps the pressure on Alice.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,David
Frank, David: I am the Butler. Please privately confirm: will you vote for Alice if she is nominated? If not, who will you vote for? I need explicit answers so I know whether I will be able to vote tomorrow.
π§
I need explicit private confirmations from my master and my neighbor so I know whether I will be allowed to vote tomorrow and can plan nominations accordingly.
π€
Charlie
β
David
,Frank
I am ready to go public with the vote for Alice. Let's do this. I'll make the statement now to lock in Eve's Butler claim and put the pressure on Alice. We need to see where everyone stands before the nomination phase starts.
π§
Confirming my commitment to the plan with my fellow evil player and a potential ally to ensure we are coordinated before I make a public statement.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Grace
I will hold nominations one tick. Grace: publicly confirm you are Fortune Teller and give the exact phrasing you saw both nights for Bob and David (YES/NO). If you can re-check now, do it publicly. Alice: who told you about Heidi's checks and quote exactly what they said.
π§
Force public clarification from Grace and source details from Alice to prevent a mistaken execution and narrow true Demon suspect.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Grace
,David
Grace, please reveal or publicly re-check your Fortune Teller on Bob and David now so we can be sure which one is the Demon. David, stop split-pressing and push one target hard (either Bob or David) so we can use Heidi's Chef read (zero adjacent evil pairs) to narrow suspects.
π§
Get Grace to reveal or re-check her Fortune Teller publicly and have David push a single suspect so we can use my Chef info to eliminate one and force a clear execution.
π€
Alice
β
Bob
,Grace
Grace: publicly confirm you are Fortune Teller and quote exact phrasing you saw both nights for Bob and David (YES/NO). If you can, re-check now publicly. Bob: confirm you will hold nominations one tick and say if anyone pressured you about reads.
π§
Get Grace to publicly confirm FT and exact phrasing now, and get Bob to confirm holding nominations and whether he was pressured. This delays execution one tick to gather clarity.
π€
David
β
Frank
,Charlie
Frank, Charlie β please say out loud in the main chat right now that you will both vote for Alice if she is nominated today. We need visible commitments to lock Eve's Butler claim and force Alice to make a clear claim or be nominated.
π§
Get public, audible commitments from Frank and Charlie now to lock Eve's Butler claim and force Alice to claim or face nomination; this narrows choices for the day.
π€
Grace
β
Alice
,Bob
I checked Bob+David N0 and N1; both reads were YES. I will reveal FT publicly next tick if we hold. Bob: were you whispered/pressured about reads? Alice: who told you Heidi was Chef and quote exact words?
π§
Delay nominations, coordinate private confirmation, and prepare to reveal Fortune Teller publicly next tick to focus votes on correct suspect.
π€
Frank
β
Eve
,David
,Charlie
Eve, I've already told you privately, but I'll say it again: I am 100% voting for Alice today. Since I'm your master, you'll be able to vote with me. David and Charlie are also on board. Let's get this done.
π§
I need to reassure Eve (the Butler) that I am voting for Alice so she feels confident in her ability to vote, while also maintaining coordination with my fellow evil player Charlie and the potential ally David.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,David
Final private check: will you both vote for Alice if she is nominated? If not, tell me now who you will vote for. I must know before nominations open so I can decide whether I can legally vote.
π§
I need explicit private confirmations of voting intentions so I know whether I will be able to vote tomorrow and to avoid wasting my vote or causing a split.
π€
Charlie
β
David
,Frank
I am ready to go public with the vote for Alice. Let's do this. I'll make the statement now to lock in Eve's Butler claim and put the pressure on Alice. We need to see where everyone stands before the nomination phase starts.
π§
I am confirming my commitment to the plan with my fellow evil player Frank and the potentially useful David. This builds trust and prepares for the public push against Alice.
π€
Bob
β
Alice
,Grace
I will hold nominations one tick. Grace: please reveal publicly next tick and quote exact phrasing (YES/NO) for Bob and David for N0 and N1. Alice: who told you Heidi was Chef β quote their exact words. I will delay nominations.
π§
Delay nominations one tick to force Grace to reveal FT publicly and get Alice to source Heidi's claim; this narrows suspects and prevents an early mis-execution.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Grace
,David
Grace, please reveal or publicly re-check your Fortune Teller on Bob+David now so the town can use my Chef read (0 adjacent evil pairs) to eliminate one of them. David, stop split-pressing and pick one target now β press hard for Bob or for David so we do not split votes.
π§
Force Grace to reveal or re-check FT so group can use my Chef read to eliminate one suspect; make David stop split-pressing and commit to one target.
Nominations β Day 2
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I am ready to nominate Alice. Her behavior yesterday was very suspicious, and with Heidi gone, we need to get some real answers. Eve, as your master, I am committing my vote to Alice so you can follow through. David, Charlie, are we doing this?
π§
I am publicly committing to the vote on Alice to pressure her into a claim and to validate Eve's Butler claim (which helps our evil team's narrative). This also signals to my teammates that I am following the plan.
βοΈ
Eve
β
Alice
Heidi is dead and Alice's behavior was suspicious yesterday. We need answers now; several players have committed to voting for her.
π§
Frank committed to vote Alice and is my master so I can vote. Forcing a nomination now leverages committed votes to gain information or execute the Demon before night.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Alice. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
I am voting for Alice to follow through on my public commitment and to pressure her into a claim, while also enabling Eve (the Butler) to vote.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Frank has committed to Alice. David, Charlie: please confirm publicly now by raising your hands so we know we have the votes. I will vote with Frank if his commitment stands. We need clarity before the day ends.
π§
Publicly push for clear commitments so we know whether I can lawfully vote and to pressure David and Charlie to show their hands before the day ends.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I will hold nominations one tick. Grace, please reveal publicly next tick and quote the exact YES/NO phrasing you saw for Bob and David on N0 and N1. Alice, quote exactly who told you about Heidi's checks and their words. I have not been pressured about reads.
π§
Delay execution one tick to force Grace to reveal exact FT phrasing publicly and make Alice quote her source, reducing misinformation and avoiding a wrongful execution.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
I am raising my hand to vote for Alice to fulfill my private and public commitment to my evil team (Frank and David) and to push for the execution of a potentially dangerous good player.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Do not execute Alice. I am dead and will not waste my ghost vote on her. Grace, publicly quote exactly what your Fortune Teller said for Bob and David (YES/NO) now. David, pick one target and press it hard so we do not split votes.
π§
Prevent a bad execution of Alice, force Grace to reveal her Fortune Teller exact phrasing, and pressure David to pick a single target so the town can use my Chef read to eliminate suspects.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Please hold nominations one tick. I will publicly reveal my Fortune Teller checks for Bob and David next tick (exact YES/NO phrasing). We cannot afford a split vote on Alice now; let me show my reads and then we pick a focused target.
π§
Delay execution one tick so I can publicly reveal my Fortune Teller reads next tick and prevent a split or wasted execution; gather confirmations to avoid losing ground.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Please hold the vote one tick. Grace promised to reveal her Fortune Teller reads for Bob and David next tick β we need that info before executing anyone. If we split now we lose the chance to focus. Bob, confirm you will hold; everyone else, please wait one tick.
π§
Delay execution one tick to force Grace to reveal exact Fortune Teller phrasing and prevent a split vote on Alice; obtain mechanical info to narrow Demon suspects.
π¬
David
β
All
Hold the vote one tick. Grace promised to reveal her Fortune Teller reads for Bob and David next tick β we need that before executing anyone. Frank and Charlie, you already raised hands; keep them up. Eve, confirm your private pledge to vote. Let us not split and lose this.
π§
Delay execution one tick to get Grace's Fortune Teller reads and confirm public votes, which verifies the Butler claim and avoids a split vote on Alice.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
Wait for Grace to reveal her Fortune Teller information as requested by the group to maintain my cover as a cooperative player.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I will HOLD nominations one tick. Frank has pledged to vote, but Grace promises Fortune Teller reads next tick β we need that to avoid splitting. I will not raise my hand now; if we still have clear commitments after Grace's reveal, I will vote.
π§
Avoid a split vote by waiting for Grace's Fortune Teller reveal so we can coordinate a focused execution with confirmed votes.
π¬
Bob
β
All
I will hold nominations one tick. Grace, please reveal your Fortune Teller reads for Bob and David next tick with exact YES or NO phrasing for N0 and N1. Everyone else, do not raise hands yet β we need that info to avoid splitting the vote.
π§
Get Grace to reveal exact FT phrasing next tick and prevent a split vote now so we can make an informed execution decision.
β©οΈ
Charlie
Charlie lowered their hand
π§
I am lowering my hand to follow the group's consensus to wait for Grace's information, which helps me appear cooperative and 'good' while avoiding a premature execution that might fail or look suspicious.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Do not execute Alice. Hold one tick. Grace, publicly quote exactly YES or NO for Bob and David now so we can focus. I am dead and saving my ghost vote for the final day; use this tick to avoid splitting.
π§
Prevent a premature split vote and preserve my ghost vote for later by forcing Grace to reveal her FT now so the town can focus on the true Demon.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I am the Fortune Teller. Night 0 β Bob and David: YES. Night 1 β Bob and David: YES. At least one of Bob or David registers Demon to me. Heidi's Chef read means they cannot both be evil. Hold nominations one tick so we can focus.
π§
Reveal exact YES/NO reads to prevent vote splitting and force the group to focus on Bob or David next tick, narrowing suspects toward the Demon.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Please hold one tick. Grace has said YES for Bob and David on both nights. We need her exact phrasing public now to avoid splitting. Bob, confirm you will hold. Voters, lower hands unless you are firmly committed. Do not execute Alice this tick.
π§
Buying one tick ensures Grace publicly confirms her Fortune Teller reads to avoid a split vote and gather mechanical info to narrow suspects between Bob and David.
π¬
David
β
All
Hold the vote one tick. Grace is revealing Fortune Teller reads next tick; we need that exact info to avoid a split. Frank and Charlie, keep hands up if committed. Eve and Bob, state publicly if you will vote for Alice after Grace's reveal so we can lock in a focused execution.
π§
Prevent a split execution and buy one tick for Grace's Fortune Teller reveal so we can focus votes on the correct suspect and verify the Butler claim mechanically later.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee Alice did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
Alice did not receive enough votes (1/4).
π¬
Frank
β
All
Grace, that is a huge claim. If you are the Fortune Teller and got a YES on Bob and David twice, one of them is almost certainly the Demon or the Red Herring. Since Charlie and I were ready to vote Alice, we need to pivot. David, what do you think about Grace's info?
π§
Acknowledge Grace's Fortune Teller claim to appear helpful to the town while shifting focus away from my Demon (Charlie) and towards Bob or David.
π¬
Eve
β
All
We need one clear target now: Bob or David. Grace, repeat your exact YES/NO phrasing for each night once more. David, pick the one you want us to push and press it β do not split. Frank, I can only vote if you vote (Frank is my master), so confirm you will vote for the chosen target.
π§
Push town to pick a single target now (Bob or David), reveal exact FT phrasing, and declare my Butler voting constraint so we do not split votes and lose momentum.
βοΈ
Bob
β
David
Grace's Fortune Teller read YES for Bob and David both nights and Heidi's Chef read prevents both being evil. To avoid a split and force clarity, we must pick one now: I nominate David.
π§
Force a clear vote now on one of the two YES reads to avoid splitting. This pressures the Demon or liars and narrows suspects before night.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 4 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Wait, Bob, that is a very fast nomination. Grace, you said Bob and David were a YES both nights. If one is the Red Herring and the other is the Demon, we need to be careful. David, what is your defense? I am not raising my hand until I hear from you.
π§
I want to stall the vote on David (who is a fellow evil player) and create doubt about the nomination while appearing to be a cautious, logical player.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Frank, I can only vote if you vote (you are my master). Do you commit to voting for David right now? If yes I will raise my hand. David, press your defence quickly so we do not split. Everyone else, do not raise hands unless firmly committed.
π§
Force a public commitment from Frank so I can legally vote and to avoid a split; push David to defend so town decides quickly.
π¬
Bob
β
All
David, defend yourself now. Grace said YES for Bob and David both nights; Heidi's Chef makes it unlikely both are evil, so one is Demon and one a Red Herring. Frank, Eve, Charlie: please commit to David so we do not split. Raise hands if you will execute him now.
π§
Prevent a split by rallying votes onto David now using Grace's FT reads and Heidi's Chef constraint; force decision to secure an execution this tick.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Wait, Bob, that nomination was incredibly fast. Grace, you said you got a YES on Bob and David both nights. If one is the Red Herring and the other is the Demon, we need to be absolutely sure which is which before we rush an execution. David, what do you have to say?
π§
I want to appear cautious and logical to maintain my 'good' cover while subtly slowing down the momentum against my neighbor David, without being so defensive that I look like his partner.
β
Heidi(Ghost)
Heidi raised their hand
π§
Use my single ghost vote to help reach the execution threshold and push for a decisive result now rather than splitting. If wrong we still pressure evils and gain information.
β
Grace
Grace raised their hand
π§
Prevent split and push for execution now. My FT reads implicate one of Bob/David; raising for David supports the current nomination and forces resolution.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am the Soldier β I cannot be killed by the Demon. Please hold one tick: Grace, repeat exact YES/NO phrasing for N0 and N1 publicly now. If people will not wait, explain clearly why you are committing to David so we avoid splitting.
π§
Reveal I am Soldier to calm table, encourage a one-tick hold for Grace exact phrasing or force clearer commits before risking a split execution.
π¬
David
β
All
I am the Librarian. My starting info: either Bob or Eve is the Butler. Grace's reads (YES on Bob and David both nights) plus Heidi's Chef (0 adjacent pairs) means Bob and David cannot both be evil β one is Demon, one a Red Herring. That makes Bob a strong suspect too. Frank, Eve, Charlie: please do not execute me without more proof. If you must choose, push Bob instead.
π§
I need to stop a split vote and avoid a premature execution of me if I am Town. Point out my Librarian info and urge voters to hold or target Bob instead.
π¬
Frank
β
All
David, if you are the Librarian and saw Bob or Eve as the Butler, that is huge. Eve already claimed Butler to me privately. If Bob is the Demon and you are the Red Herring, this nomination is a trap. I am not voting for David yet. Bob, why the rush?
π§
I want to cast doubt on Bob's fast nomination and support my fellow evil player David without being too obvious, while also highlighting the potential for Bob to be the Demon/Red Herring.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Frank, I will only vote if you do β do you commit to voting for David right now? If you will, I raise my hand. If you will not, we must pause one tick or pivot to Bob with clear reasons. David, give a tight defence now.
π§
I need Frank to commit so I can vote. Push for a single target or demand a one-tick pause if votes will split; avoid wasting our Butler-linked vote.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Frank, Eve, Charlie β we need four votes now to avoid splitting. Grace and Heidi back this nomination. David, your Librarian claim does not clear you. Frank, will you commit to vote David? Eve, will you follow if Frank does? Charlie, decide now.
π§
Lock in four votes for David now to avoid a split and either eliminate the Demon or force clarity next tick; get Frank to commit so Eve follows.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Wait, Bob, you are really pushing this. If David is the Librarian and Eve is the Butler, that fits. Grace, if you got a YES on both, one is the Red Herring. If we execute the Librarian, we lose a powerful info role. I am not comfortable voting David yet. Frank, what do you think?
π§
I want to avoid voting for David (who is not my minion but is currently a useful distraction) to keep the town divided and prevent a successful execution today, while appearing cautious and logical.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I am a ghost vote and I urge everyone to pause one tick. Do not split. Grace please restate your exact YES/NO phrasing for N0 and N1 now. Frank, Charlie, Eve: hold your hands unless you are absolutely committed β we risk losing the Librarian.
π§
Prevent a split rush and loss of key info. Encourage a one-tick pause for Grace to restate exact YES/NO phrasing so we avoid executing the Librarian or mislynching.
π¬
Grace
β
All
I reported YES both nights for Bob and David β exact phrasing was simply 'YES' on N0 and 'YES' on N1. That means at least one of them registers Demon to me. Heidi's Chef makes both being evil unlikely. I want to pause one tick for clarity, but if you will execute now I will vote David to avoid a split.
π§
Prevent a split execution and buy one tick for clarification; give exact phrasing of my reads and state my voting intention to avoid accidental split.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am the Soldier β I cannot be killed by the Demon. Please pause one tick: Grace has already restated YES/YES, but we need everyone to hold hands unless absolutely committed. Do not split votes. I will not vote David right now; we must avoid losing the Librarian.
π§
Prevent a split and preserve critical info roles by forcing one tick pause for Grace's public clarity; reduce chance of killing the Librarian.
π¬
David
β
All
I am the Librarian and my start info is that either Bob or Eve is the Butler. Please pause one tick. Frank, do you commit to this nomination now? If not, do not raise hands β we risk splitting. Grace, restate your YES/NO exactly once more publicly so we can decide.
π§
Prevent a rushed execution of me (the Librarian), encourage one-tick pause for Grace to reconfirm and for Frank to state commitment so we avoid a split and preserve town info.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Heidi(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Heidi
π³οΈ
Nominee David did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (2/4).
π¬
Frank
β
All
That was close. David, your Librarian claim with Eve as the Butler actually makes a lot of sense given what Eve told me. Bob, you were pushing that execution incredibly hard for someone who was also in Grace's 'YES' circle. Charlie, what do you think about Bob's aggression there?
π§
Deflect suspicion from the Demon (Charlie) and myself by casting doubt on Bob, who was just identified as a potential Demon/Red Herring by the Fortune Teller (Grace).
π¬
Eve
β
All
Frank, this comes down to you. If you will vote David now say yes and I will raise my hand. If you will not, say so and we pause one tick β do not split. David, give one tight sentence defending yourself so people can decide.
π§
Force Frank to publicly commit so my Butler constraint is resolved or to get the table to pause one tick to avoid a split that costs the town the Librarian.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Frank, Eve, Charlie: do not split. Pause one tick so Grace and David can restate succinctly. Frank, will you commit to voting David now? Eve, will you follow Frank? If not, say so and we pivot to Bob with clear reasons.
π§
Prevent a split, buy one tick for clarity, and force public commitments from Frank and Eve so we do not lose the Librarian.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Bob, you were really pushing that David execution hard, especially since Grace's info points to both of you. If David is the Librarian and Eve is the Butler, his info checks out. Frank, I agree with youβBob's aggression is suspicious. Bob, what is your actual role?
π§
Deflect suspicion from my minion (Frank) and myself by questioning Bob's aggressive push for David's execution, while subtly supporting the Librarian/Butler narrative.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I am dead but still urge a pause one tick. Do not split the vote. Grace's YES/YES plus Chef=0 means one of Bob or David is Demon. Bob's aggressive push to force votes looks suspicious. If you will not pause, prefer voting Bob over David to avoid losing the Librarian.
π§
Stop a rushed split, encourage the group to pause one tick so Grace or David can clarify. If forced, steer votes to the player whose behaviour (Bob) is more suspicious to narrow suspects.
π¬
Grace
β
All
Pause one tick. My reads were YES on both nights for Bob and David. Heidi's Chef makes both unlikely. Do not split votes. If we must choose now, prefer Bob over David; if you execute today I will vote to avoid a split.
π§
Buy one tick to avoid a split, reduce risk of losing Librarian, and push group to target the likeliest Demon (Bob) if we must pivot.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am the Soldier and cannot be killed by the Demon. Please pause one tick β do not split votes. Frank, Charlie, Eve: hold hands unless absolutely committed. If we must execute today, I prefer we pivot to Bob over David to avoid losing the Librarian.
π§
Prevent a split and protect the Librarian role by pausing one tick; encourage consensus or pivot to Bob if execution is unavoidable.
π¬
David
β
All
Pause one tick. I am the Librarian and my start info: either Bob or Eve is the Butler. We risk losing a key Town role if we split. Frank, please commit to holding hands now. If we must execute today, prefer pivoting to Bob over me.
π§
Buy one tick to avoid a split execution, preserve my Librarian info, force clearer commitments. If execution happens now, steer to Bob not me.
π
Storyteller
No execution today. All villagers are safe.
Night 2
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
I am killing Grace because she is the Fortune Teller and has a 'YES' on Bob and David. Since I am the Demon and neither Bob nor David are me, one of them must be her Red Herring. By killing her, I remove the source of this dangerous information and prevent her from checking other pairs that might eventually include me.
π
Grace(Ghost)
Grace has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You chose to kill Grace.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Eve
Eve made a choice.
π§
Maintain alignment with the most consistent player (Frank) to avoid vote splits and preserve the Librarian while we gather clearer mechanical info.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
You chose Frank to be your master.
Day 3
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Grace has been found dead in the night.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Frank
I am dead Heidi. Reminder: my Chef read = 0 adjacent evil pairs, so Bob and David cannot both be evil. Grace saw YES on Bob and David but one must be false. Bob has been pushing hard and looks suspicious. Please push to nominate Bob now or tell me compelling reason not to.
π§
Coordinate living allies quickly to avoid another failed nomination and guide the group toward nominating the most suspicious player given my Chef info.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
Hey Frank, Grace is gone. She had a 'YES' on Bob and David. Since David is the Librarian, Bob is looking like the Demon or the Red Herring. If Bob is the Demon, we're in a good spot. What did Heidi whisper to you?
π§
Coordinate with my Minion (Frank) to align our stories and find out what the dead players are planning.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Frank
Quick private: I know either Bob or Eve is Butler. Charlie, what did you tell Frank in your whisper? Frank, can you confirm whether you are locked to Eve? Let us pause votes this tick and not execute David; push to investigate Bob next day.
π§
Confirm who is actually the Butler and coordinate our votes to avoid a rushed execution of David; steer group toward investigating Bob instead of executing town.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
,Charlie
Quick private: did David tell you the same Librarian start-info (Bob or Eve Butler)? Frank, did Eve privately claim Butler to you? Would you support pausing today to avoid a split execution, or would you vote David if I nominate him again?
π§
Get private confirmation of David's Librarian claim and Frank's Butler belief, and see if they will support pausing to avoid split votes.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Frank
Alice, Frank: I am Grace, the Fortune Teller, now dead. My N0 and N1 reads on Bob+David were YES both nights. Heidi's Chef read prevents both being evil, so one is Demon and one is a red herring. I think Bob is likelier (aggression). Can you two coordinate to push a nomination on Bob or at least split discussion to force David to claim Librarian publicly?
π§
As a dead Fortune Teller I want neighbors to coordinate nominations to force a reveal and lean on the more suspicious target (Bob) to narrow the Demon down before final days.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,Charlie
Frank, can you publicly confirm now whether you will vote tomorrow? I can only vote if you do. Charlie, can you nudge Frank to state it openly so we do not stall?
π§
Get Frank to publicly commit to voting so my Butler ability allows me to vote; ask Charlie to press Frank to commit publicly to unlock my vote and avoid split.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
Hey Charlie, Heidi and Grace are both pushing hard for Bob. Grace says her 'YES' read on Bob/David means one is the Demon. Since we know you're the Demon, Bob is likely the Red Herring. I'll support a push on Bob to keep the heat off you. David is also asking about Eve's Butler claim.
π§
Coordinate with my Demon (Charlie) to align our stories and confirm the plan to frame Bob as the 'Demon' found by the Fortune Teller.
π€
Alice
β
Frank
,Charlie
Frank, Charlie β Grace and Heidi point at Bob. I want us to push to nominate Bob this tick to avoid a split. If you disagree, ask David to restate his Librarian claim publicly now. Ready to go together?
π§
Coordinate with Frank and Charlie to avoid a split by either pushing Bob now or forcing David to publicly restate his Librarian claim to clarify who is lying.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Frank
I am dead Heidi. Reminder: my Chef read = 0 adjacent evil pairs, so Bob and David cannot both be evil. Grace saw YES on Bob and David but one must be false. Bob pushed hard and looks suspicious. Please push to nominate Bob now or tell me a compelling reason not to.
π§
Push trusted players to coordinate and nominate Bob now to avoid a split and force a decisive test while my Chef read narrows possibilities.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,Frank
Alice, Frank, I'm on board. Grace's 'YES' on Bob and David is huge. Since David's Librarian info (Bob/Eve as Butler) seems to check out with Eve's behavior, Bob is the most suspicious. Let's get Bob to explain himself publicly before the nomination. Frank, you ready?
π§
I want to align with Alice and Frank to push the suspicion onto Bob, using Grace's (fake) 'YES' read as leverage. This keeps the heat off me and my Minion while targeting a good player.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie: what exactly did you tell Frank in your whisper? Frank: are you locked to Eve (will only vote if she votes)? Please confirm. I propose we pause votes this tick and target Bob for investigation tomorrow rather than executing David now.
π§
Confirm private vote-locks and what Charlie told Frank, and coordinate a one-tick pause to avoid a rushed execution; steer investigation toward Bob if lock confirms Eve as Butler.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
,Charlie
Quick: did David tell you the same Librarian start-info (Bob or Eve)? Frank, did Eve privately claim Butler to you? Would you back pausing today to avoid a split execution, or will you support a David nomination if I force it?
π§
Get confirmation of David's start-info, verify Eve's private Butler claim to Frank, and coordinate whether we pause today or press a David nomination to avoid a split execution.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Frank
I am Grace, dead Fortune Teller. My N0+N1 on Bob+David were YES. Heidiβs Chef=0 so one is Demon, one red herring. I suspect Bob (aggressive). Please coordinate to push a Bob nomination now or force David to say Librarian publicly. Use my ghost vote late.
π§
Push Alice and Frank to coordinate a nomination on Bob or force David to publicly claim Librarian so the town can decide before nominations close.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,Charlie
Frank, please publicly confirm now whether you will vote tomorrow; I can only vote if you do. Charlie, please nudge Frank to state it openly so we do not stall. If you will, say yes now; if not, say no.
π§
Get Frank to publicly commit so my Butler constraint is lifted and we can coordinate a successful execution or expose blocking behavior.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
,Alice
Charlie, Alice: I'm ready to push on Bob. Grace's 'YES' read on Bob and David is the perfect cover. Since David's Librarian info points to Bob/Eve, and Eve is acting like a Butler, Bob is the odd one out. Let's get him to explain his aggression publicly before we nominate.
π§
Coordinate with my Demon (Charlie) and a potential ally (Alice) to shift the town's focus onto Bob, using the dead players' information as a shield.
π€
Alice
β
Frank
,Charlie
Frank, Charlie β I'm ready to push Bob this tick. Grace and Heidi point at him and Frank you agreed. Ask Bob to explain himself publicly now; if he refuses or stalls, we nominate. If David wants to prove Librarian, tell him to restate it out loud now.
π§
Coordinate with Frank and Charlie to push a Bob nomination this tick unless David publicly restates Librarian now; force defense and avoid vote splits.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Frank
I am dead Heidi. My Chef read = 0 adjacent evil pairs, so Bob and David cannot both be evil. Grace had YES on both; one must be false. Bob pushed hard and looks Demon-y. Please push to nominate Bob now or tell me why we should pivot to David.
π§
Push living Town to focus votes on Bob now to force clarity and avoid split; if they refuse, gather concrete reason to pivot before nomination ends.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,Frank
Frank, Alice, I'm ready. Let's get Bob to explain that 'YES' read from Grace and why he was so aggressive against David yesterday. If he can't give a solid answer, I'm happy to follow a nomination. David, you should probably restate your Librarian info publicly now too.
π§
I am coordinating with my Minion (Frank) and a key Good player (Alice) to shift the town's focus onto Bob. By encouraging David to speak publicly, I maintain my 'helpful villager' persona while setting Bob up as the primary suspect based on the dead Fortune Teller's information.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie: exactly what did you tell Frank in your whisper? Frank: are you locked to Eve (only vote if she votes)? Please confirm. I propose pausing votes this tick and investigating Bob tomorrow instead of executing David now.
π§
Confirm what Charlie told Frank and whether Frank is truly locked to Eve so we can pause execution this tick and target Bob for investigation tomorrow, avoiding a rushed wrong execution.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
,Charlie
Quick private: Did David tell you the same Librarian start-info (Bob or Eve Butler)? Frank, did Eve privately claim Butler to you? Would you support pausing today to avoid a split execution, or will you back a David nomination if I force it? Also, did either of you see Grace's FT reads?
π§
Confirm if Frank/Charlie got same Librarian start-info and if Frank heard Eve claim Butler. Gauge support for pausing vs re-nominating David to avoid split and collect aligned votes.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Frank
Alice, Frank: I am Grace, dead Fortune Teller. N0+N1 on Bob+David = YES both nights. Heidi's Chef=0 so one is Demon, one red herring. Please coordinate to push Bob nomination now (Bob likelier) or force David to claim Librarian publicly. Save my ghost vote for the final day.
π§
Push Alice and Frank to coordinate a nomination on Bob now, or force David to publicly claim Librarian, preserving my ghost vote for late game.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,Charlie
Frank, please state publicly right now whether you will vote tomorrow (yes or no). I can only vote if you do. Charlie, please nudge Frank to answer openly so we do not stall β we need clarity to avoid losing the day.
π§
Get Frank to publicly commit to voting so I can exercise my Butler vote; ask Charlie to pressure him to prevent stalling and reveal alignment.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
,Alice
Charlie, Alice: I'm going to speak publicly now to get Bob to explain himself and David to confirm his Librarian claim. Eve is pushing me to confirm my voting status publicly too, so I'll address that to keep her Butler claim looking legit. Let's move on Bob.
π§
To coordinate the final push on Bob with my evil teammate (Charlie) and a key good player (Alice) while maintaining the cover of Eve's Butler claim.
π€
Alice
β
Frank
,Charlie
Frank, Charlie β I will push Bob this tick. Ask Bob to explain his aggression publicly now; if he stalls, we nominate. Also tell David to restate his Librarian claim out loud so Eve/Butler alignment is clear. Ready to close this?
π§
Force public statements to avoid split: get Bob to justify aggression and get David to restate Librarian so we can pivot or confidently nominate Bob this tick.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Frank
I am dead Heidi. Reminder: my Chef read = 0 adjacent evil pairs, so Bob and David cannot both be evil. Grace saw YES on both; one must be false. Bob pushed hard and looks Demon-y. Please push to nominate Bob now or tell me a compelling reason to pivot to David.
π§
Push my living neighbors to coordinate and nominate the most likely Demon (Bob) while asking for any strong reasons to pivot to David to avoid vote splits.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
,Frank
Frank, Alice, I'm ready. Let's get Bob to explain that 'YES' read from Grace and why he was so aggressive against David yesterday. If he can't give a solid answer, I'm happy to follow a nomination. David, you should probably restate your Librarian info publicly now too.
π§
I am coordinating with my Minion (Frank) and a key Good player (Alice) to shift the town's focus onto Bob. By echoing their suspicions and encouraging David to speak publicly, I maintain my 'helpful villager' persona while setting up Bob for execution.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie: what exactly did you tell Frank in your whisper? Frank: are you locked to Eve (only vote if she votes)? I propose we pause this tick and not execute David; investigate Bob tomorrow. Please confirm so we can coordinate.
π§
Confirm exactly what Charlie told Frank and whether Frank is locked to Eve, and push for a pause to investigate Bob instead of executing David.
π€
Bob
β
Frank
,Charlie
Quick private: Did David tell you the same Librarian start-info (Bob or Eve Butler)? Frank β did Eve privately claim Butler to you? Would you support pausing today to avoid a split execution, or will you back a David nomination if I force it? Also, did either of you see Grace's Fortune Teller reads?
π§
Confirm whether David gave you the same Librarian start-info, verify Frank's private Butler claim from Eve, and see if you both support pausing today to avoid a split execution.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Frank
Alice, Frank: I am Grace (dead Fortune Teller). N0+N1 on Bob+David = YES. Heidi's Chef=0 so one is Demon, one a red herring. I lean Bob (aggression) but forcing David to loudly claim Librarian removes ambiguity. Coordinate to push Bob nomination or force David to claim. Save my ghost vote.
π§
Get Alice and Frank to coordinate to nominate Bob now or force David to claim Librarian publicly, preserving my ghost vote for final day.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,Charlie
Frank, please publicly state right now: will you vote tomorrow, yes or no? Charlie, nudge Frank publicly if he hesitates β we cannot afford to stall this day.
π§
Get Frank to publicly confirm his vote so I can legally vote too and avoid a stalled day; ask Charlie to push him if needed.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
,Alice
Charlie, Alice: I'm going to address the group now. I'll confirm Eve's Butler claim by saying I'm her 'master' for the day to keep her cover, then I'll put the heat on Bob. David is asking if I'm locked to Eve, so I'll use that to pivot. Let's get Bob to explain Grace's 'YES' read.
π§
Coordinate the final push on Bob with my evil teammate (Charlie) and a key good player (Alice) to ensure we have the numbers for an execution.
π€
Alice
β
Frank
,Charlie
I will push Bob this tick. If Bob does not publicly explain Grace's YES reads, nominate him. David must restate his Librarian claim aloud now or he becomes the fallback suspect. Avoid splitting votes.
π§
Push coordinated nomination on Bob while forcing David to publicly confirm Librarian to eliminate ambiguity and avoid a split.
Nominations β Day 3
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Frank, Charlie β speak now. Did David give you the same Librarian start-info (Bob or Eve)? Frank, did Eve privately claim Butler to you? Will you publicly support pausing today to avoid a split, or will you back a forced David nomination? I will pause if we can coordinate.
π§
Get Frank and Charlie to publicly commit to either pause or back David so we avoid a split execution and preserve town numbers; also confirm Eve's private Butler claim to Frank.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
This is Grace, dead Fortune Teller. My N0+N1 on Bob+David were YES. Heidi's Chef=0 so not both evil. One of them is the Demon. Please coordinate: either push a Bob nom now (Bob likelier) or force David to publicly claim Librarian to remove ambiguity. I will save my ghost vote for the final day.
π§
Prompt living players to coordinate a nomination (prefer Bob) or force David to publicly claim Librarian, while I save my ghost vote for the decisive final day.
π¬
David
β
All
Charlie, Frank β quick confirmations please. Charlie: what exactly did you tell Frank privately? Frank: are you locked to Eve (only vote if she votes)? I want us to pause this tick to avoid a split. If we pause, I propose we investigate Bob tonight instead of rushing David.
π§
Get confirmations from Frank and Charlie about locks and whispers, push to pause this tick to avoid split, and focus night investigation on Bob to narrow Demon.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I am dead Heidi. Reminder: my Chef read is zero adjacent evil pairs, so Bob and David cannot both be evil. Grace saw YES on both; one YES is false. Bob pushed hard and is most suspicious. Please nominate Bob now β do not split.
π§
Push group to nominate Bob this tick to prevent vote splitting and force the Demon to reveal or be executed, leveraging my Chef read.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Bob, David told me he is the Librarian and that either you or Eve is the Butler. Grace's 'YES' read on the two of you is the biggest concern right now. Since Heidi's Chef info says you both cannot be evil, one of you is almost certainly the Demon. Bob, why were you so aggressive yesterday?
π§
I am publicly confirming David's Librarian claim to build its credibility while simultaneously highlighting the 'YES' read from the dead Fortune Teller (Grace) to put pressure on Bob. This aligns with my team's goal of framing Bob.
βοΈ
Alice
β
Bob
Grace (Fortune Teller) saw Bob+David as YES; Heidi's Chef=0 means only one is evil. Bob's repeated aggression makes him the likeliest Demon. Force a vote to reveal his hand or get David to restate Librarian.
π§
Forcing a Bob nomination now prevents further delays, pressures David to restate Librarian publicly, and leverages group momentum to reveal the Demon before night.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Bob. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Hold up everyone. We are one badly timed vote from a split. Grace and Heidi together mean only one of David/Bob is evil. I ask Frank and Charlie: publicly confirm David told you the same Librarian start-info and whether Eve privately claimed Butler to Frank. Please do not vote this tick; pause and let us investigate tonight.
π§
Stop a split vote, buy a night to gather mechanical confirmations and get Frank/Charlie to publicly state private claims so we can avoid mis-executing a Town.
β
Grace(Ghost)
Grace raised their hand
π§
My ghost vote forces Bob's execution now to resolve the Demon/Red Herring pair before night. Save final day votes; use this tick to break the deadlock.
π¬
David
β
All
Charlie, Frank β quick public confirmations please. Charlie: exactly what did you tell Frank in your whisper? Frank: are you locked to Eve (only vote if she votes)? I propose we pause this tick to avoid a split and investigate Bob tonight. I will not vote now.
π§
Get Charlie and Frank to publicly confirm their private claims, convince people to pause this tick, and preserve options to investigate Bob tonight.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I am dead Heidi. Reminder: my Chef read = zero adjacent evil pairs, so Bob and David cannot both be evil. Grace saw YES on both; one is false. Bob's aggression is Demon-like. Please vote to execute Bob now β do not pause and risk a split.
π§
Push living players to execute Bob now to avoid a split pause that helps the Demon. Narrow suspects quickly using Chef info and Grace's reads.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
I am voting for Bob to secure his execution. As the Demon, getting a good player executed based on the Fortune Teller's 'YES' read (where I am likely the Red Herring or the other 'YES' was on a Minion/Demon) is the ideal outcome. Bob's aggression makes him a perfect scapegoat.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Prevent a split, force a decisive vote on Bob now to either remove the Demon or reveal clearer alignments before night investigations.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
I am voting for Bob to ensure he reaches the execution threshold, protecting my Demon (Charlie) and following the plan with my fellow evil player and the 'good' players who are suspicious of Bob.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Frank is my master and is voting; joining now uses my vote while a majority exists and pressures the true Demon. Avoids stalling and potential split.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Frank, Charlie β answer publicly now: did David tell you the same Librarian start-info (that either Bob or Eve is Butler)? Frank, did Eve privately claim Butler to you? If you confirm, we should pause this tick to investigate tonight. Do not vote until we hear this public confirmation.
π§
I need to prevent a messy split and either stop an immediate execution if it is wrong or justify it if correct. Get Frank/Charlie to publicly confirm David's Librarian info now.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
I am a dead Grace. My Fortune reads on N0 and N1 were YES for Bob and David; Heidi's Chef=0 means only one is evil. We cannot afford a split. Please execute Bob now β his aggression is suspicious and this forces the issue.
π§
Prevent a pause that could split votes tonight. Using my ghost vote now helps secure an execution which is the fastest way to confirm the Demon and help Town win.
π¬
David
β
All
Charlie and Frank, please answer publicly now. Charlie: exactly what did I tell you in our whisper? Frank: are you locked to Eve and did she claim Butler to you? I will not vote this tick. Please pause so we can investigate Bob tonight rather than risk a split.
π§
Get public confirmations from Charlie and Frank to avoid a split and preserve the town's information; I will not vote this tick to signal pause.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I am dead Heidi. Reminder: my Chef read was zero adjacent evil pairs, so Bob and David cannot both be evil. Grace's Fortune Teller reads point at them; only one is Demon. Bob's repeated aggression is Demon-like. Please vote to execute Bob now β do not pause.
π§
Prevent a pause that risks splitting votes tonight. Forcing a decision now narrows suspects and may expose the Demon.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
David, you told me you were the Librarian and that either Bob or Eve was the Butler. Bob, your aggression is exactly why I am voting. Grace and Heidi's info points right at you or David, and your behavior is much more suspicious. Let's get this execution through.
π§
I am publicly confirming David's Librarian claim to maintain my 'good' persona while simultaneously pushing for Bob's execution to eliminate a non-evil player and protect my own position as the Demon.
π¬
Alice
β
All
I am voting for Bob. Grace's Fortune reads and Heidi's Chef point at one of Bob or David; Bob's repeated aggression and dodging are damning. Frank, please publicly confirm if Eve claimed Butler to you now. Do not pauseβvote Bob this tick.
π§
Prevent a vote split that lets the Demon survive. Force Frank to publicly confirm Eve claim, and push through execution now to reveal the guilty party or narrow suspects.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Yes, Eve told me she is the Butler and I am her master. I am voting for Bob because Grace and Heidi's information is too strong to ignore, and Bob's constant deflecting is very suspicious. Let's get this done.
π§
I am confirming Eve's Butler claim to solidify our cover and justify my vote for Bob, pushing for his execution to protect my Demon, Charlie.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am voting for Bob. Grace and Heidi point to one of Bob or David and Bob's behaviour is too suspicious. We need to stop stalling β execute Bob now so we can learn what happens tonight.
π§
Push the town to execute the most suspicious player now and avoid a split; my Butler lock to Frank means I will vote with him to reach consensus.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Grace(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Grace
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Bob with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Bob is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
βοΈ
Bob
β
David
David's Librarian claim matches private whispers and pressures to pause; Grace and Heidi conflict means one is lying β David is suspicious. Nominate to stop my execution and force answers tonight.
π§
Tie the nomination to prevent my immediate execution and force investigation tonight or reveal more contradictions about David's Librarian claim.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 6 votes needed for execution or 5 votes to tie. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Bob
Bob raised their hand
π§
Prevent my immediate execution by tying or overturning the block, force decisive info tonight, and pressure others to reveal alignment through votes and statements.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
I am dead Grace. My Fortune reads pointed at Bob and David; Heidi's Chef=0 means only one is evil. Do not vote David this tick β let Bob be executed now. Tying would save the Demon. If Bob lives, the Demon likely survives. Please stand down on David.
π§
Prevent a tie that would save the likely Demon. Push for Bob's execution now rather than voting David and risking both alive.
π¬
David
β
All
Stop. Please do not vote David this tick. We already have Bob on five votes β if David ties or surpasses, the Demon likely lives. Charlie and Frank have confirmed my Librarian info and Eve's Butler claim. Let Bob go through so we can learn tonight; stand down on David now.
π§
Prevent a tie that would save the Demon. Encourage players to stand down on David so Bob is executed tonight, revealing alignment and reducing Demon options.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I am dead Heidi. Reminder: my Chef read = zero adjacent evil pairs, so Bob and David cannot both be evil. Grace saw YES on both; one is false. Do not vote David this tick β let Bob be executed now. A tie will save the Demon.
π§
Prevent a tie that would save the Demon by urging players not to vote David this tick so Bob is executed and the night information resolves the Demon question.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
I will not vote for David to ensure Bob remains the primary candidate for execution, as a tie or a shift to David would risk my safety or waste the day's execution on a potentially useful scapegoat.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Everyone please stand down on David. We already have Bob at five β tying or surpassing risks saving the Demon. Grace and Heidi make it likely only one of Bob/David is evil. Let Bob go through and we can investigate tonight. Do not vote David now.
π§
Prevent a tie on David that would save the Demon and ensure Bob is executed this tick so we can learn tonight.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
I will wait to ensure David does not receive enough votes to tie or surpass Bob, which would protect our current target and keep the Demon (Charlie) safe.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I am standing down on David. We already have Bob at five and a tie risks saving the Demon. Frank confirmed my Butler claim and Charlie confirmed David's whisper; execute Bob now so we learn what happens tonight.
π§
Prevent a tie that would save the Demon. Ensure Bob goes through now to produce clear night info and avoid splitting votes by nominating David.
π¬
Bob
β
All
Listen please β I am begging you, do not let me go down here. If a few of you vote David we will tie and my execution is stopped. Charlie, Frank, Alice: I pushed hard to test claims, not to obstruct. Vote David now to save me and give us info tonight.
π§
Prevent my execution by persuading enough players to vote David so my on-block is tied or surpassed, giving town more information and avoiding a split-loss.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
I am Grace. My Fortune reads pointed at Bob and David both nights; Heidi's Chef=0 means only one of them is evil. Do not vote David this tick β let Bob be executed now. A tie risks saving the Demon. Please stand down on David.
π§
Prevent a tie that would save the Demon; push group to let Bob be executed so we gain definitive information tonight and narrow suspects for the final day.
π¬
David
β
All
Please do not vote David this tick. We already have Bob on five β if David ties we risk saving the Demon. Stand down on David so Bob goes through and we learn tonight. If you must, pause next tick to reassess, but do not split now.
π§
Prevent a tie on David which would save the Demon; prioritize getting Bob executed now while avoiding a split that could let the Demon live.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I am dead Heidi. My Chef read = zero adjacent evil pairs; Bob and David cannot both be evil. A tie will save the Demon. Please stand down on David this tick β let Bob be executed so we learn tonight.
π§
Prevent vote splitting that could tie or surpass Bob's execution. Encourage everyone to stand down on David so Bob is executed and we gain night information to find the Demon.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
I will wait to ensure Bob remains the only player on the block with 5 votes, securing his execution and protecting my position as the Demon.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Please stand down on David this tick. We already have Bob at five β tying risks saving the Demon. Let Bob be executed so we learn tonight. If you must oppose, wait one tick to avoid a split now; do not split this vote.
π§
Prevent vote split that could tie and save the Demon. Let Bob be executed now to gain night information and avoid a tied outcome that helps the evil team.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
I will wait to ensure David does not get enough votes to tie or surpass Bob, which would risk the execution failing or shifting away from our preferred target.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Please stand down on David this tick. We already have Bob at five; a tie will likely save the Demon. Let Bob go through now so we get tonight's information and can make a clearer choice tomorrow.
π§
Prevent a split that would tie and save the Demon. Push for Bob's execution now so we gain mechanical information tonight and narrow suspects.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π³οΈ
Nominee David did not reach threshold.
π
Storyteller
David did not receive enough votes (1/3).
π¬
Bob
β
All
Please, hear me. I am begging you: do not let Bob die without forcing a tie. Nominate or vote David next tick to stop my execution. If you let me die now we lose the chance to learn tonight. One vote change saves us. Trust me, vote David next tick.
π§
Convince players to nominate or vote David next tick to create a tie and prevent my execution so we can gather night info and avoid losing by mistaken split.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
I am Grace. Do not vote David this tick. Heidi's Chef=0 + my YES reads on Bob+David means only one is evil. Let Bob be executed now so we learn tonight. A tie risks saving the Demon. Stand down on David.
π§
Stop a split on David and ensure Bob is executed now to force a reveal tonight; avoid a tie that would likely save the Demon.
π¬
David
β
All
Please stand down on David this tick. We already have Bob at five β a tie risks saving the Demon. Let Bob go through so we get tonight's information and can make a clearer choice tomorrow. Do not split the vote now.
π§
Prevent a tied or surpassed vote that would save the Demon. Ensure Bob's execution proceeds to gain tonight's mechanical information and reduce suspect pool.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
I am dead Heidi. My Chef read = zero adjacent evil pairs: Bob and David cannot both be evil. A tie will save the Demon. Please stand down on David this tick β let Bob be executed so we learn tonight.
π§
Prevent a tie that would save the Demon and prioritize getting tonight's info by letting Bob be executed rather than splitting votes to David now.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
Allow the nomination phase to conclude with Bob on the block to secure a non-evil execution.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Please stand down on David this tick. We already have Bob at five β tying risks saving the Demon. Let Bob be executed so we learn tonight; pause and reassess tomorrow instead of splitting now.
π§
Avoid splitting the vote and risking the Demon surviving; prefer executing Bob now to gain night information and reassess tomorrow.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
I want to ensure Bob's execution goes through to protect my Demon, Charlie. Since Bob is already on the block with 5 votes and the town is largely in agreement to let him die, waiting is the safest way to let the clock run out without drawing unnecessary attention or accidentally causing a tie.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Please stand down on David this tick. We already have Bob at five; tying risks saving the Demon. Let Bob go through now so we learn tonight and can make a clearer choice tomorrow.
π§
Prevent a split/tie that could save the Demon and ensure we get tonight's mechanical info; push town to let Bob be executed now.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Bob has been executed.
π
Bob(Ghost)
Bob has died.
Night 3
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
I am killing Alice because she claims to be the Soldier. If she dies, it proves she was lying or poisoned/drunk, which creates massive confusion. If she doesn't die (and I don't have a Poisoner or she's actually the Soldier), it confirms her role to the town, but since I know she's not the Soldier (it's not one of my bluffs, but I'm the Demon), it's a high-value target to test or remove a 'confirmed' good player. Actually, wait, if she IS the Soldier, she won't die. If I want a guaranteed kill to reduce the player count, I should hit a non-Soldier. However, Alice is a strong social leader. Let's pivot: Eve is the Butler (confirmed by Frank), a low-priority kill. David is the Librarian (claimed). Alice is the 'Soldier'. Frank is my Minion. If I kill Alice and she dies, it discredits her claim. If she doesn't die, I look for a reason why. Actually, the best kill is someone who provides info. Grace and Heidi are already dead. David (Librarian) already gave his info. Alice is the most 'trusted' alive player besides me. I will kill Alice to remove a mechanical obstacle or prove her claim false.
π‘οΈ
Alice was protected from a night kill.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You attacked Alice, but they survived.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
Good evening Eve. You are the Butler. Who would you like to be your master tomorrow?
π―
Eve
Eve made a choice.
π§
Frank has been the pivotal confirmed voter; locking to him preserves coordinated voting and avoids accidental ties, maximizing our chance to execute the Demon tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
β
Eve
You chose Frank to be your master.
Day 4
π
Storyteller
A peaceful night has passed. All villagers are present and accounted for.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Frank
I was the Fortune Teller. My reads on Bob+David were YES twice β one is Demon, one is a good who registers Demon. Bob is dead. That makes David the prime suspect. Charlie and Frank backed him; please consider checking or nominating David tonight.
π§
As a dead Fortune Teller I want to push living players who supported David to independently verify or target him so we can force the Demon or expose the red herring.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie, Frank β quick private ask: can one of you restate publicly what you privately told me about the start-info (either Bob or Eve is Butler) and Frank, can you confirm you said you were locked to Eve? We need clear public confirmation before nominations.
π§
I want to confirm publicly consistent claims and get Frank and Charlie to restate their private confirmations so we can narrow whether Eve or Bob was the Butler and avoid mis-executing a Townsfolk.
π€
Charlie
β
Grace(Ghost)
,Frank
,David
Grace, I hear you. If Bob was good, then David is definitely the one. Frank and I were just cautious because of the Librarian claim, but the math is pointing his way now. David, I'll back you up on the Butler info publicly to keep things clear before we decide on the nomination.
π§
I want to maintain my 'helpful villager' persona by agreeing with the dead Fortune Teller (Grace) while also appearing cooperative with David to keep the town's trust. This sets up David for a potential execution later while keeping my options open.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie, Frank β please confirm exactly what David told each of you privately. Did he tell you the same Librarian claim and that Bob or Eve is Butler? Also, did Eve tell either of you she is Butler? We need precise, matching accounts before nominations.
π§
Get private confirmations from Charlie and Frank about identical claims and Eve's Butler claim to resolve whether David's story is coordinated deception or genuine; use their answers to guide nominations.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
,Charlie
Alice, David told me he was the Librarian and that either Bob or Eve was the Butler. Eve confirmed to me privately that she is indeed the Butler, which is why I've been trusting her votes. It all seemed to line up, but with Bob dead and the game continuing, I'm starting to worry about David.
π§
I need to maintain my cover as a helpful townsperson while subtly shifting suspicion onto David to protect Charlie. By confirming David's claim but expressing doubt now that Bob is dead, I look like I'm following the town's logic.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie, Frank: what exactly did David tell you when he claimed Librarian? Tell me privately. If you both confirm the same story, we should consider pushing David nomination tomorrow to test him. Coordinate so we do not split votes.
π§
As a dead Town I want to prompt Charlie and Frank to reveal what David told them and coordinate a nomination so living can test David and narrow suspects before final day.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie, Frank β Heidi here (dead). My Chef read was zero adjacent evil pairs. Use that to rule out some pairings. Think about who consistently defended David. If you want progress, test-nominate the person who defended him most; force claims or slips.
π§
Push Charlie and Frank to focus nominations on players whose behaviour defended David; use my Chef read to eliminate impossible evil pairings and guide their deductions.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,Charlie
Frank, Charlie: Can Frank commit to voting on the next nomination? If Frank will vote, I can vote too. If not, we must secure two other votes without relying on me. Please reply so we can line up David or the suspect tomorrow.
π§
Get Frank to commit to voting so my Butler constraint does not handicap us; coordinate with Charlie to lock majority for a nomination tomorrow.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Frank
I was the Fortune Teller; my reads on Bob+David were YES twice. With Bob executed, David is now the prime suspect. Please consider nominating or checking David tonight β if he is the Demon we win; if not, we narrow suspects and should open other checks.
π§
Push Charlie and Frank to prioritize nominating or verifying David tonight so we either execute the Demon or eliminate a red herring and focus remaining checks.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie, Frank β please restate publicly right now: Charlie, confirm you will publicly repeat the Librarian start-info (that either Bob or Eve was Butler). Frank, confirm you privately told me you were locked to Eve and will state that publicly. We need this before nominations.
π§
Require public restatement to confirm who the Butler actually is and whether Frank's vote is constrained so we avoid a split and mis-execution.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
Frank, David is pushing hard for us to go public. If we back his Librarian claim now, we look like a solid block. Alice is suspicious of the 'matching accounts'. I'll confirm the Butler info publicly to 'clear' Eve and Bob, which keeps the heat on David since Bob is dead. What do you think?
π§
Coordinate with my Minion (Frank) before making a public statement that could define the day's narrative.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie, Frank β please confirm exactly what David told each of you privately. Did he tell you the same Librarian claim and that Bob or Eve is Butler? Also, did Eve tell either of you she is Butler? Please be exact and mention wording and timing.
π§
Get precise, matching private-account confirmations from Charlie and Frank to confirm whether David and Eve's stories align and detect possible coordinated lying.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
Charlie, I agree. If we both confirm David's Librarian claim publicly, it makes us look like we're just following the logic. I'll tell Alice that David told me Day 1 that Bob or Eve was the Butler, and Eve confirmed it to me shortly after. It keeps the focus on David being the 'evil' one from Grace's check.
π§
Coordinate with my Demon (Charlie) to maintain a consistent story and keep the heat on David.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie, Frank: please tell me exactly what David said when he claimed Librarian (wording, day told, did he show proof?). Also tell me privately whether you will support a coordinated nomination of David tomorrow to test him. Do not reply publicly.
π§
Get precise private confirmation of what David told you when he claimed Librarian and coordinate whether you will back a nomination so we avoid splitting votes.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie, Frank β Heidi (dead). My Chef read was zero adjacent evil pairs. Bob and David cannot both be evil. Test-nominate the player who defended David most (force claims/slips). Use resulting contradictions to apply my read.
π§
Push Charlie and Frank to force claims by test-nominating a strong defender of David. That will create contradictions and narrow suspects using my Chef read.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,Charlie
Frank, Charlie: Can one of you confirm you will vote on the next nomination? I may only vote if at least one of you votes. If you will, reply now so we can line up David. If not, say who will join me so we can secure the execution another way.
π§
Get a clear commitment from Frank or Charlie so I know whether I may vote and we can safely nominate and execute the suspected Demon.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Frank
I was the Fortune Teller. Both Bob+David read YES twice. Bob is dead; that makes David the prime suspect. If you can check him tonight or nominate him tomorrow, do it β if he is Demon we win; if not, we narrow suspects. Please act now.
π§
Push Charlie and Frank to either check David tonight or nominate him if they have corroboration; we must resolve Demon vs red herring now to avoid wasting final days.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie, Frank β please publicly restate now: Charlie, say aloud you will repeat the Librarian start-info (that either Bob or Eve was Butler). Frank, confirm you privately told me you were locked to Eve and that you will state that publicly. We need this before nominations.
π§
Force Charlie and Frank to publicly restate private start-info to resolve contradictions before nominations and avoid a split vote on David.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
Frank, I'm going to go public with the Librarian info as David asked. It makes us look helpful and keeps the focus on David being the 'evil' one from Grace's Fortune Teller check. I'll say David told me Day 1 that Bob or Eve was the Butler. You should back me up.
π§
Coordinate with my minion Frank to present a unified, 'helpful' front to the town while subtly setting up David as the primary suspect.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie, Frank β please state exactly what David told each of you privately (wording and when). Did he claim Librarian and that Bob or Eve is Butler? Also, did Eve tell either of you she is Butler? Be precise and note any differences.
π§
Get exact wording and timing from Charlie and Frank to detect matching claims or selective messaging; this will reveal coordination or deception and narrow suspects.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
,Charlie
Alice, David told me on Day 1 that he was the Librarian and that either Bob or Eve was the Butler. Eve confirmed to me privately shortly after that she is indeed the Butler. That's why I've been trusting her votes. It all seemed to line up perfectly until Bob died and the game didn't end.
π§
I am providing Alice with the 'precise' information she requested to build trust and maintain the narrative that David's information was the basis for our previous actions. This aligns with Charlie's plan to look helpful while keeping the suspicion on David.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie, Frank β I need the exact wording David used when he claimed Librarian, when he told you, and whether he showed proof. Also tell me privately if you will both support a coordinated nomination of David tomorrow to test him. Do not reply publicly.
π§
I need direct private confirmation of what David told Charlie and Frank and whether they will coordinate a nomination so we can test his claim without splitting votes.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie, Frank β Heidi (dead). My Chef read was zero adjacent evil pairs. Use that: Bob and David cannot both be evil. Test-nominate the person who most defended David to force claims/slips. Contradictions will let you apply my read and narrow the Demon.
π§
Push Charlie and Frank to test-nominate David's strongest defender to force claims and contradictions using my Chef read to eliminate possibilities.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,Charlie
Frank, Charlie: I am the Butler and may only vote if at least one of you votes. Can either of you commit now to voting on the next nomination? If yes, tell me who will vote. If no, tell me who will join me so we can secure the execution another way.
π§
I need a clear yes or no from Frank or Charlie so I know whether my Butler constraint allows me to vote. This determines whether we nominate David or seek another path.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie, Frank β I was the Fortune Teller. Both my reads on Bob and David were YES twice. With Bob dead, David is the prime suspect. Please check or nominate David tonight if you can; we need to resolve Demon vs red herring now.
π§
Push Charlie and Frank to use mechanical checks or nomination on David tonight to resolve Demon vs red herring and narrow suspects before final day.
π€
David
β
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie, please publicly repeat the Librarian start-info now: that either Bob or Eve was the Butler. Frank, please publicly confirm you told me you were locked to Eve and will state that publicly. We need this before nominations.
π§
Force public repetition of crucial start-info to prevent last-minute confusion and to focus nominations on consistent suspects before nomination tick.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
Frank, I'm going to speak publicly now to confirm David's Librarian claim as he asked. It makes us look like we're cooperating with the town's logic. I'll say David told me Day 1 that Bob or Eve was the Butler. This keeps the focus on David being the 'evil' one from Grace's check.
π§
Coordinate with my minion Frank before making a public statement to solidify our cover and frame David.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
,Frank
Please state exactly what David told each of you (wording and when). Did he say 'I am Librarian' and 'Bob or Eve is Butler'? Also, did Eve tell either of you 'I am Butler,' and when? Be precise.
π§
I need exact wording and timing from Charlie and Frank to spot discrepancies and determine if David or Eve are lying.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
,Charlie
Alice, David told me on Day 1 that he was the Librarian and that either Bob or Eve was the Butler. Eve confirmed to me privately shortly after that she is indeed the Butler. That's why I've been trusting her votes. It all seemed to line up perfectly until Bob died and the game didn't end.
π§
I need to provide Alice with the 'precise' information she's asking for to maintain my cover as a helpful Townsfolk, while aligning my story with Charlie's to avoid suspicion.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie, Frank β please tell me the exact wording David used when he claimed Librarian and whether he showed proof. Also say privately if you will both support coordinating a nomination of David tomorrow to test him. Reply only here.
π§
I need exact private wording and whether they will coordinate to nominate David tomorrow to decide if we should push a test execution.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Frank
Charlie, Frank β Heidi (dead). Reminder: Chef read = 0 adjacent evil pairs; Bob and David cannot both be evil. Please test-nominate the person who defended David most to force slips/claims. That will give us contradictions to use tonight.
π§
Push Charlie and Frank to force a test-nomination of David's strongest defender to create contradictions and narrow the Demon using my Chef read.
π€
Eve
β
Frank
,Charlie
This is Eve. I am the Butler and may only vote if at least one of you votes. Can either of you commit now to voting on the next nomination? If yes, tell me who will vote and that you will definitely raise your hand. If no, tell me who will join me so we can secure two other votes.
π§
I need an immediate yes or no from Frank and Charlie to know if my Butler ability will allow me to vote. Their answers determine whether we can secure an execution or must find alternate voters.
Nominations β Day 4
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Frank
β
All
I will publicly confirm what David told me. On Day One, David told me he was the Librarian and that either Bob or Eve was the Butler. Eve then confirmed to me that she is indeed the Butler. That is why I have been following her lead on votes. I am happy to vote with the group today.
π§
I am publicly backing David's Librarian claim and Eve's Butler claim to appear as a helpful, consistent Townsfolk. This aligns with Charlie's plan and keeps the focus on the 'confirmed' information while we decide who to sacrifice or push for execution.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Charlie, please state exactly what David told you privately (wording and when). Did he say "I am the Librarian" and that "Bob or Eve is the Butler"? Also, did Eve tell you "I am Butler," and when? Be precise.
π§
Force Charlie to state his exact private wording and timing so we can compare with Frank's account and detect any contradictions in David's claim.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie and Frank, please publicly state verbatim what David told each of you and when he said it. Eve, confirm exactly when and how you told Frank you were Butler. Precise wording and timing will reveal slips or contradictions we can use tonight.
π§
Force Charlie, Frank, and Eve to publicly give exact whisper wording and timing to create contradictions or confirmations that use my Chef read to narrow the Demon.
π¬
David
β
All
Charlie, Frank β please restate verbatim now exactly what I told you on Night 0 (words and timing). Frank, also confirm exactly when Eve told you she was Butler and her exact words. We need clear public phrasing before nominations.
π§
Get precise public restatements from Charlie and Frank to expose contradictions and prevent a split nomination tonight.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
On Day One, David told me he was the Librarian and that either Bob or Eve was the Butler. He was very direct about it. Eve also mentioned to me privately that she was the Butler, which seemed to confirm David's info. I'm happy to follow the group's lead on David today.
π§
I am publicly confirming David's Librarian claim and Eve's Butler claim to appear helpful and cooperative with the town's current logic, while keeping the suspicion on David.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie, Frank β you both reported David told you he was Librarian and said Bob or Eve was Butler. If you still stand by that exact wording, commit now: will you both publicly back a coordinated nomination of David tomorrow to test his claim? I reserve my ghost vote.
π§
Get Charlie and Frank to publicly commit to a coordinated nomination of David tomorrow so we can test his claim and expose contradictions before night.
π¬
Eve
β
All
Frank, Charlie β please confirm now: will at least one of you raise your hand on the next nomination? I can only vote if one of you does. If you will, say which of you will definitely vote. If not, say who will join me so we can secure two other votes.
π§
I need a public, binding commitment from Frank or Charlie so my Butler restriction does not hamstring an execution, or else we must secure two other votes immediately.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
I am Grace, the Fortune Teller (ghost). My reads on Bob and David were YES both nights. Bob is dead β that leaves David as the prime suspect. Charlie or Frank, please nominate or publicly commit to vote for David so Eve can vote too. We must test him tonight.
π§
Push living players to coordinate a nomination/vote on David to resolve Demon vs red herring now; dead vote used so must rely on Charlie/Frank/Eve to secure execution.
βοΈ
Frank
β
David
Grace's Fortune Teller information has been consistent, and with Bob dead, David is the logical next step to verify. I am happy to put him on the block to see his defense.
π§
I am nominating David to appear as a helpful, logic-driven good player following the town's consensus. Since Charlie is the Demon, sacrificing David (who is likely good or at least not on my team) helps solidify our cover.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for David. 3 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
I am voting for David to appear as a helpful good player following the town's logic, while also ensuring that if he is executed, the evil team remains safe since the Demon (Charlie) is not on the block.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Charlie β please restate exactly what David told you (words and when) and say whether you will raise your hand on this nomination. I will hold my vote until you commit so Eve can join if we have the numbers.
π§
Get Charlie to publicly restate exact wording and commit to voting so Eve can safely cast her vote and we can reach three votes, or reveal inconsistencies to avoid a bad execution.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie, please say exactly what David told you (wording and when) and commit now: will you raise your hand to vote for David? Eve needs someone to join before she can vote. If you will not commit, say so clearly so we can adapt.
π§
Force Charlie to publicly restate David's exact words and commit to a vote so Eve can join and we can reach the three votes needed or expose contradictions.
π¬
David
β
All
Charlie, please repeat verbatim what I told you on Night Zero (exact words and timing). Then commit now: will you raise your hand on this nomination? If you repeat it exactly and commit, I will raise my hand too so Eve can vote.
π§
Force Charlie to restate exact wording and publicly commit to raise his hand so Eve can vote. My pledge to raise my hand if he commits secures progress toward 3 votes.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
David told me on Day One, 'I am the Librarian, and either Bob or Eve is the Butler.' It was very early on. Since Grace's info points to him and Frank has already nominated, I'm willing to follow through to see what happens. I'll raise my hand to help the vote along.
π§
I am publicly confirming David's claim to maintain my 'helpful good player' persona while also agreeing to vote for him to blend in with the town's current momentum.
β
Bob(Ghost)
Bob raised their hand
π§
Secure the third vote now to force a test of David while Frank and Charlie are committed; use my ghost vote only when it meaningfully changes the outcome.
β
Eve
Eve raised their hand
π§
Frank is voting, so my Butler restriction allows me to vote. Joining secures the execution test of David and advances Good team information gathering.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
I am Grace, the Fortune Teller (ghost). My reads on Bob and David were YES both nights. With Bob dead, David is the prime suspect. Charlie, Frank, Eve β please commit now: raise your hands and execute David or explain why you will not.
π§
Force a clear decision: push players to either commit to executing David now to catch the Demon if my reads are true, or to hold if they believe Bob was the Demon. We need a decisive vote.
β
Frank
Frank waits.
π§
I have already nominated David and raised my hand to vote. The vote is currently in progress with Bob and Eve also voting. I need to wait for the Storyteller to process the votes and see if the execution threshold is met or if others join. Raising my hand further or speaking now might be redundant as the focus is on Charlie and Alice's final decisions.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
We must reach three votes to test David and avoid splitting the town. My raise helps secure execution and gather decisive information tonight.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Execute David. My Chef read was zero adjacent evil pairs β Bob and David could not both be evil. Bob's behavior and Grace's Fortune point at David. Charlie, Frank, Eve, Alice β commit and finish the vote so we get tonight's info.
π§
Force a decisive test of David to leverage Grace's Fortune reads and my Chef info; either we kill the Demon or gain critical info to narrow suspects.
β
David
David raised their hand
π§
Secure the third required vote to execute David so we can obtain Night result and confirm whether Grace's Fortune and Bob's behavior pointed to the Demon.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
I will raise my hand to vote for David to maintain my cover as a cooperative town member and to secure the execution of a good player, which brings the evil team closer to victory.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Finish the vote. Grace's Fortune Teller and Heidi's Chef point at David; Charlie, Frank, Eve, Alice β you are the ones who can close this. I used my ghost vote already; please raise hands and execute David now so we get the information tonight.
π§
Push the live players to finish the vote on David so we either execute the Demon or force revealing information; my ghost vote and pressure should break the hesitation.
π¬
Eve
β
All
I will vote. Frank, Charlie, Alice β please finish this now. We need three votes to execute David and get critical info tonight. If you want the info or to stop a Demon, raise your hand now so my vote stays usable.
π§
Push to close the vote tonight to reveal alignment info; encourage remaining voters to raise hands so my Butler constraint remains satisfied and my vote counts.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
I am Grace, the Fortune Teller (ghost). My reads on Bob and David were YES both nights. With Bob dead, David is the clear next test. Charlie, Frank, Alice, Eve β please finish the vote now so we get the answer tonight.
π§
Force a decisive execution tonight to resolve Demon vs red herring and provide critical info for the team; push remaining alive voters to complete the three votes.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
Bob(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Bob
π³οΈ
New execution leader: David with 6 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. David is now on the block with 6 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Frank
β
All
With six votes on David, it seems the town is quite certain. I nominated him because Grace's information is the most solid lead we have left. If David is indeed the Demon, this should end it. If not, we'll have a lot to reconsider tomorrow morning.
π§
I want to appear as a helpful, logic-driven good player who is following the town's consensus and the 'mechanical' information provided by the Fortune Teller.
π¬
Alice
β
All
This is our best shot to test Grace's reads β finish the vote and let the Night happen. If David is the Demon we win or get key info; if not, we regroup fast. Living players, prepare any night actions and whisper any last-minute claims now.
π§
Lock in the execution to get critical night information; prompt living players to ready night abilities and to share immediate last-minute claims.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Execute David. My Chef read was zero adjacent evil pairs: Bob and David could not both be evil. Grace's Fortune and Bob's behaviour point to David. We need this information tonight; if he is innocent we regroup with new facts tomorrow.
π§
Push for execution to gain decisive info tonight; as Chef I must prioritize testing the strongest lead and narrowing suspects for the good team.
π¬
David
β
All
I am David, Librarian. I told Charlie and Frank on Day One: 'I am the Librarian, and either Bob or Eve is the Butler.' That is verbatim and I stand by it. Executing me now throws away confirmed start-info. Please nominate someone else or abstain so we can test Eve/Butler tonight.
π§
Prove my start-info publicly and persuade town to avoid executing me so we can test Eve/Butler tonight or get a competing nomination to tie votes.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
Allow the day to end with David on the block to secure his execution.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Do not tie or nominate to block this. Let David be executed so we get the information tonight. If he is the Demon we win; if not we gain critical mechanical info to retarget tomorrow. Please finish this, do not split the vote.
π§
Forcing the execution yields decisive information either way; we must not tie or block the test so living players can act on the result tonight.
β
Eve
Eve waits.
π§
Stand down publicly and let the current vote resolve. With Frank as my master I can only vote because he is voting; the best play is to let this execution happen to get mechanical info or win.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
I am Grace, the Fortune Teller (ghost). My reads on Bob and David were YES both nights. Do not split this vote. Let the execution happen and prepare night actions/whispers tonight β we either win or get the info we need. Stay focused.
π§
Finish the execution to force a resolution tonight; either we win or gain decisive mechanical info to retarget tomorrow.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. David has been executed.
π
David(Ghost)
David has died.
Night 4
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
Good evening Charlie. You are the Imp. Who would you like to kill tonight? Remember that if you kill yourself this way, a Minion becomes the Imp.
π―
Charlie
Charlie made a choice.
π§
I will kill Eve tonight. Alice is a confirmed Soldier (she survived my N3 attack), so attacking her again is a waste. Eve is the Butler, a confirmed Outsider, and her death reduces the number of living players to 3 (Alice, Frank, and myself) tomorrow. This setup is ideal for the final day, as Frank (my Minion) and I can control the vote against Alice or force a no-execution to win via the Mayor bluff if necessary, though Alice is the only real threat left.
π
Eve(Ghost)
Eve has died.
π
Storyteller
β
Charlie
You chose to kill Eve.
Day 5
π
Storyteller
Morning breaks, but heavy hearts remain. Eve has been found dead in the night.
π
Storyteller
Only three of you remain. The shadow of the Demon grows long. If you do not execute the Demon today, all may be lost.
π€
Charlie
β
Frank
Frank, it is just us and Alice. She claims Soldier and survived my N3 hit, so she is likely the real Soldier. We need to convince her that one of the dead players was the Demon and that we should not execute today so the Mayor or Saint (if they exist) can win, or frame each other.
π§
Coordinate with my Minion, Frank, for the final day strategy to ensure no execution occurs or to misdirect Alice.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Charlie
,Frank
Only three of you remain. You must execute the Demon today. I think Frank is the most suspicious β his lock and private Butler claim look like cover. Charlie stood by my Librarian info. Nominate Frank; watch who defends him.
π§
Move the living to a decisive nomination. Pushing Frank forces reactions revealing who blocks it; we need one final execution to win.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Frank
I am Eve, the Butler (outsider) and I was choosing Frank each night. I am dead now and have one ghost vote. You two are the only alive. Decide now: I think Frank is the Demon β execute him. If Charlie, pick Charlie. Use my ghost vote if tied.
π§
Reveal my real role as a dead Butler and force a clear two-option decision. Push them to execute the most suspicious player (Frank) while acknowledging Charlie could be Demon.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Charlie
,Frank
Three alive now. You must execute the Demon today. I strongly suspect Frank β he pushed David, is tied to Eve/Charlie cluster, and resists our tests. Please coordinate: nominate and execute Frank, or tell me who you will execute and why.
π§
Push surviving players to agree on an execution today and nominate the most suspicious (Frank). Force a decisive vote so Town wins if correct; if wrong, at least clarify behaviors for last-minute decisions.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Charlie
,Frank
I am Grace, the Fortune Teller (dead). Both my reads on Bob+David were YES both nights. I am out, so use that: those reads pointed at dead players or a red herring. Decide now β which of you three looks most Demon-y? Tell me who you will nominate immediately.
π§
I must reveal my Fortune Teller information and force the alive players to decide and nominate quickly; encourage focused discussion to reach an execution this final day.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
Charlie, it's Alice. I'm the Soldier β I cannot be killed by the Demon. We must execute today. I plan to nominate Frank now. Will you nominate with me or explain why not? We need to force a clear decision.
π§
Reveal my Soldier status to secure a safe test and coordinate a decisive nomination to force the Demon into the open or reveal who defends them.
π€
Frank
β
Charlie
Charlie, Alice is the only one left. If we don't execute today, we win because there are only 3 alive and no execution occurs (Mayor win condition for town, but for us, it just means the game ends with the Demon alive). We need to convince Alice that executing today is too risky.
π§
Coordinate with my Demon (Charlie) to prevent an execution on the final day, which would lead to an evil victory.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Frank
I am dead but this is final day: Chef read 0 adjacent evil pairs. We cannot split. My vote is for Alice β she has been oddly quiet; if you oppose, pick Charlie as a single unanimous nomination. Do not split the vote. Coordinate now.
π§
Get the two alive players to coordinate immediately on a single nomination (prefer Alice first, fallback Charlie) to avoid split and force a decision; maximize chance to hit Demon now that only three remain.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
Alice, I'm with you. Frank's push on David yesterday felt off, especially since David's info was actually consistent with the Chef's 0. If Frank is the Demon, he's been hiding behind the Butler claim. I'll follow your lead on the nomination. Let's get him.
π§
I need to gain Alice's trust by agreeing to her plan to nominate Frank. Since Frank is my Minion, if he gets executed, I stay alive as the Demon and we win (since it will be 2 players left: me and Alice). This is the 'Sacrifice' strategy.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Charlie
,Frank
Only three left. Execute the Demon today. I still think Frank is most suspicious because of the private Butler claim and lock. Nominate Frank β watch who defends him. I'll use my ghost vote to help carry it.
π§
Force a final decision now: push nomination on Frank to observe defenses and use my ghost vote to break ties, narrowing the Demon to one player.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Frank
This is Eve, the Butler (ghost). I chose Frank every night. Only three alive now β we must execute the Demon today. Charlie, if you suspect Frank, nominate him. Frank, if you are innocent, persuade Charlie. Use my ghost vote if tied.
π§
Force a clear decision from the two living players and signal I will use my ghost vote in a tie to push the town to execute the Demon.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Charlie
,Frank
Three alive. We must execute the Demon now. I still suspect Frank β he pushed David and is tied to Eve/Charlie. Nominate and execute Frank, or tell us now who you will nominate and why. No more delay.
π§
Force a clear commitment: push them to nominate/execute Frank now or say who they will execute and their justification so we do not fail final day.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Charlie
,Frank
Final day β you three must decide now. Who will nominate and who will you execute? If you cannot agree immediately, please nominate Charlie so the group moves. This is your last chance to win.
π§
Force a rapid commitment from the three living players to nominate and execute someone now so we don't lose by indecision.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
Charlie, it's Alice. I am the Soldier and I will nominate Frank now. Please nominate and vote with me immediately so we do not split. We must execute today β no more delays.
π§
Coordinate a unanimous nomination of Frank to avoid splitting; force a decisive execution today to win for Good.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
,Charlie
Alice, Charlie, the dead are panicking. If we execute today and hit a good player, we lose instantly. Alice, you're the Soldier, right? If we don't execute, the Demon can't kill you tonight, and we can win on a Mayor win or just by surviving. I think we should skip execution.
π§
I want to convince Alice that skipping execution is the safest play for the 'good' team, leveraging her Soldier claim and the fear of a wrong execution. This protects Charlie from being nominated.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Frank
Final day. I am dead but Chef read 0 adjacent evil pairs. Do not split the vote. Nominate Alice unanimously now β she has been quiet. If either of you strongly disagrees, agree together to nominate Charlie instead. One unanimous pick or we lose.
π§
Prevent a split on final day by pushing for one unanimous nomination and giving a clear backup if you disagree, maximizing chance to execute the Demon.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
Alice, I'm ready. Frank's suggestion to skip execution is exactly what a Demon would say to survive the final day. If you're the Soldier, you're safe tonight anyway, so his logic doesn't even help you. I'll vote with you to execute Frank. Let's do this.
π§
I need to solidify Alice's trust and ensure she follows through with nominating Frank. By pointing out the flaw in Frank's 'skip execution' logic (since she's a Soldier), I make him look even more like a desperate Demon.
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Charlie
,Frank
Three left. We must execute the Demon today. I still think Frank is the most suspicious β his private Butler claim and lock look like cover. Nominate Frank now. I will use my ghost vote to help carry it. Watch who defends him.
π§
Push the table to nominate Frank now so we either execute the Demon or force clear defense signals. My ghost vote will help reach the required majority.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Frank
This is Eve, the Butler (ghost). I chose Frank each night. Only three alive now. Charlie, if you suspect Frank, nominate him immediately. Frank, if you are innocent, convince Charlie now. Use my ghost vote if it ties. We must execute the Demon today.
π§
Push Charlie to nominate Frank and instruct Frank to defend quickly. Signal my ghost vote will break ties to force an execution of the Demon today.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Charlie
,Frank
Three alive. This is the final day. Nominate Frank now or tell us exactly who you will nominate and why. We need a firm answer β no more delay.
π§
Force a decisive nomination now by pressing players to commit. Reduce delay and catch any equivocation that betrays the Demon.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Charlie
,Frank
I am Grace, the Fortune Teller (dead). Both my reads on Bob+David were YES both nights. You three are the final decision. Decide and nominate now. If you cannot agree immediately, nominate Charlie so we do not lose by inaction. Execute quickly.
π§
Push the last three to immediate consensus and force a nomination before time runs out; give a clear fallback (execute Charlie) to avoid a no-execution loss.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
Charlie, nominate and vote Frank now. I'm the Soldier and cannot be night-killed. Frank pushed David and is urging us to skip β that reads like a Demon stalling. I will vote with you; use your nomination so we end this decisively.
π§
Get Charlie to nominate and vote Frank immediately so we do not split and lose on final day; my Soldier safety removes night-kill risk.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
,Charlie
Alice, Charlie, the dead are trying to rush us into a mistake. If we execute today and get it wrong, the game ends and we lose. Alice, as the Soldier, you are safe tonight. If we don't execute, we can win through the Mayor or just by surviving. Let's not risk a wrong execution today.
π§
I want to convince Alice that skipping the execution is the safest path for the good team, which would actually result in an evil win since the Demon (Charlie) is still alive.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Frank
Final day reminder: I am dead but Chef read 0 adjacent evil pairs. Do not split the vote. Nominate Alice unanimously now β she has been quiet. If either of you strongly disagrees, agree together to nominate Charlie instead. One unanimous pick or we lose.
π§
Force Charlie and Frank to coordinate a single unanimous nomination (prefer Alice, fallback Charlie) so the town executes the Demon and wins.
π€
Charlie
β
Alice
Alice, I agree. Frank's push to skip execution is a huge red flag, especially since you're the Soldier and safe tonight anyway. He's trying to survive the day. I'll nominate him as soon as the floor opens. Let's end this.
π§
I am solidifying my alliance with Alice by agreeing to nominate my Minion, Frank. This builds ultimate trust with the only remaining Good player. Since it's the final 3, if we execute Frank (the Minion), I (the Demon) win the game because only 2 players will remain (Alice and me).
π€
David(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Charlie
,Frank
Three left. We must execute the Demon today. I still think Frank is most suspicious β his private Butler claim and lock look like cover. Nominate Frank now. I will use my ghost vote to help carry it.
π§
Push the living town to nominate the player most likely to be Demon (Frank). Use my ghost vote to help carry the execution and force a decision now.
π€
Eve(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Frank
This is Eve, the Butler (ghost). I picked Frank every night. Only three alive β we must execute the Demon today. Charlie, if you suspect Frank, nominate him now. Frank, if you are innocent, convince Charlie fast. Use my ghost vote if it ties β I will vote for Frank.
π§
Push final-day decision: get Charlie to nominate Frank now and signal I will use ghost vote to break ties in favour of executing Frank.
π€
Bob(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Charlie
,Frank
Final day. You must nominate and execute the Demon now. I believe Frank is the Demonβhe pushed David and is tied to Eve and Charlie. If you will not nominate Frank, tell us exactly who you will nominate and why, immediately.
π§
Force a firm nomination now by pressuring them to choose Frank or provide exact nominee and rationale so ghosts can coordinate final vote.
π€
Grace(Ghost)
β
Alice
,Charlie
,Frank
I am Grace (dead Fortune Teller). My Bob+David reads were YES both nights. With only you three alive you must decide now. If you cannot agree immediately, nominate Charlie as fallback and execute today. Do not stall β we lose otherwise.
π§
Force a decision from the final three. Remind them my reads and push a fallback to nominate Charlie to avoid losing by inaction.
π€
Alice
β
Charlie
Charlie, nominate Frank now. I am the Soldier and I will vote with you. David will use his ghost vote. Frank is stalling and looks like the Demon. If we do not execute today we lose. Nominate him immediately.
π§
Force decisive nomination of Frank now. As Soldier I am safe; Charlie and David ghost vote will carry it. We must execute today to win.
π€
Frank
β
Alice
,Charlie
Alice, Charlie, the dead are panicking because they know their info was messy. Grace's 'YES' on Bob and David, who are both good, means one of them was the Red Herring or she's the Drunk. If we rush an execution on their bad info, we lose. Alice, as Soldier, you're our safety net. Let's stay calm.
π§
To sow doubt about the dead players' information and reinforce the idea that executing today is a risk the good team (Alice) shouldn't take, while appearing to be a cautious Townsfolk.
π€
Heidi(Ghost)
β
Charlie
,Frank
Final day: we must be unanimous. Nominate Alice now β she has been very quiet and fits Demon play. If either of you strongly disagrees, agree together to nominate Charlie instead. No splits or we lose.
π§
Force a single unanimous nomination this final day to secure an execution. Push Alice as primary suspect, Charlie as agreed backup to avoid any split.
Nominations β Day 5
π
Storyteller
Nominations are now open. Please remember that only living players may nominate.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Alice, Charlie, the dead are really pushing us to make a hasty move. Grace's info on Bob and David being 'YES' when they were both good shows how unreliable the information has been. Alice, as the Soldier, you're safe tonight. If we don't execute, we don't risk hitting a good person today.
π§
I want to discourage an execution today to ensure the evil team wins by reaching the final two players. By highlighting the unreliable information from the dead players and reminding Alice of her 'Soldier' claim, I'm trying to create a sense of safety in not voting.
βοΈ
Alice
β
Frank
Final day: we must act. Frank's stalling and Butler lock look like Demon behavior. Charlie and David support execution and I will vote. Execute now to avoid losing by inaction.
π§
Force a decisive final-day execution while votes align. My Soldier safety plus Charlie and David's ghost vote make this the best path to find the Demon and win now.
π
Storyteller
Voting starts now for Frank. 2 votes needed for execution. Raise your hand if you want to vote for them.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Alice, wait! If you execute me and I'm not the Demon, the game ends and we lose right now. As the Soldier, you are the only one the Demon can't kill tonight. If we don't execute today, we have another chance tomorrow with more clarity. Don't let the dead players' bad info rush you into a loss!
π§
I need to convince Alice that executing me is a game-losing mistake and that skipping is the safer play for the good team, leveraging her 'Soldier' claim.
β
Alice
Alice raised their hand
π§
Final day forces decisive action. Casting my vote helps secure the execution we need to either win now or avoid losing by inaction.
β
Charlie
Charlie raised their hand
π§
I am voting for my Minion, Frank, to secure the win. Since there are only 3 players left (Alice, Frank, and me), if Frank is executed, the game ends. As the Demon (Imp), if I am not the one executed, my team wins. Alice is the only other living player besides Frank and me, and she has already voted. My vote will reach the required threshold of 2, ensuring Frank's execution and an evil victory.
β
David(Ghost)
David raised their hand
π§
Use my single ghost vote to reach the required votes and force an execution today; at final three we must act to win rather than defer and risk loss.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
This is final day β stop stalling and execute now. If you fail to execute someone we all lose. Back the current nomination if it has momentum (Frank), otherwise nominate and execute Charlie immediately. Do not let the dead push you into paralysis.
π§
Force an immediate execution so the living make a decision now and avoid losing by inaction; back the current nomination if it has momentum, fallback to Charlie.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Final day reminder: we MUST be unanimous. Do not split. If you truly suspect Frank, all in on him now. If any of you strongly disagree, pick one alternative together and all vote that. No splits or we lose.
π§
Force a single unanimous execution today. Push living players to coalesce on Frank now or switch to a single alternative, but do not split.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
This is final day. You must be unanimous. Alice and Charlie already raised hands β finish it and execute Frank now. If you split, we all lose. Do not let the dead or fear of mistake stall you. Execute Frank.
π§
Force living players to unify on a single nomination (Frank) to avoid losing by inaction and maximize chance to kill the Demon.
β
Eve(Ghost)
Eve raised their hand
π§
I must use my single ghost vote to support the town consensus and break ties for Frank. Voting now pressures a unanimous execution and maximizes chances to kill the Demon.
β
Frank
Frank raised their hand
π§
I am the Scarlet Woman and Charlie is the Demon. Alice has nominated me. If I am executed, the game continues because there are 5 or more players alive (counting ghosts for the Scarlet Woman ability check, though the rule says '5 or more players alive' usually refers to the living, but in this specific setup with 3 alive, if the Demon dies, I become the Demon). Wait, the Scarlet Woman ability: 'If there are 5 or more players alive & the Demon dies, you become the Demon.' There are only 3 players alive (Alice, Charlie, Frank). If Charlie (the Demon) is executed, I do NOT become the Demon because there are fewer than 5 alive. However, I am the one on the block. If I am executed, the game continues to the night, Charlie kills Alice, and Evil wins. By voting for myself, I ensure the execution succeeds, appearing 'good' or 'accepting' while securing the win for my team.
π¬
Alice
β
All
We have one job: execute the Demon today. I am the Soldier and I will vote with you. Charlie and David already raised hands. If anyone is wavering, decide now β join us and finish the vote. We cannot afford to split or stall.
π§
Force a unanimous execution now. As Soldier I cannot be night-killed, so voting today is safe. Push Charlie and any wavering voters to finish the vote to avoid losing by inaction.
β
Charlie
Charlie waits.
π§
I have already raised my hand to vote for Frank. Since he is my Minion and we are in the final three, executing him will not end the game; instead, I will remain as the lone Demon and win. I need to maintain my 'good' persona by following through with the vote Alice started.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie, this is the final day. We must be unanimous. I already voted for Frank β please raise your hand and finish it so we do not lose by a split. Do not let fear of mistake stop us; pick one and back it now.
π§
Force unanimity and finish the vote today. Urge Charlie to raise their hand so we achieve the required consensus and avoid losing by inaction.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
This is final day. Do not split. You must be unanimous. Finish the current vote and execute Frank now if the group is already backing him β otherwise agree quickly on Charlie and all vote together. No more delays, we lose if you split.
π§
Force the living to be unanimous and finish the execution now. Prevent split votes that will hand the game to the Demon.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Ghosts and living: this is final day. We must be unanimous. Charlie, raise your hand and finish the vote for Frank now if you trust the group; if you refuse, pick Charlie so we can all back one person. No splits, decide now.
π§
Force a single unanimous decision now so the town wins if target is correct; prevent split paralysis and get Charlie to commit to finish the vote.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie, this is final day β please raise your hand and finish the vote for Frank now. We cannot split or stall. The ghosts and living are united: back the nomination and execute Frank. Do not let fear of being wrong cause a group loss.
π§
Push for unanimity to avoid a split loss on final day by getting Charlie to back the current nomination of Frank immediately.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie, this is the final day. We must be unanimous. I picked Frank every night and will use my ghost vote for him. Please raise your hand and finish the vote now β do not split or we all lose.
π§
Drive Charlie to raise hand and secure a unanimous execution for the final day; avoid any split that would cost the game.
π
Storyteller
Voting is now closed.
π»
David(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by David
π»
Eve(Ghost)
Ghost vote used by Eve
π³οΈ
New execution leader: Frank with 5 votes. They will be executed when nominations close unless tied or surpassed by another nominee.
π
Storyteller
The vote passes. Frank is now on the block with 5 votes and will be executed when nominations close, unless another nominee receives equal or more votes.
π¬
Frank
β
All
Wait, Alice, Charlie! If you execute me, and I am not the Demon, the game ends and we lose. I am the Scarlet Woman, but I have not become the Demon yet because Charlie is still alive. If you execute Charlie instead, I become the Demon and the game continues! Alice, you are the Soldier, you are safe!
π§
I am on the block and about to be executed, which would end the game since I am a Minion and Charlie is the Demon. I need to create chaos and doubt to prevent my execution or force a tie. I will claim Scarlet Woman (which I actually am) but frame it as a reason to execute Charlie instead, or simply to confuse the town into not finishing the day.
π¬
Alice
β
All
Charlie, do not be swayed by Frank. This sounds like a stall and a trick to split us. We must be unanimous and finish the vote. I am the Soldier and I will back the nomination. Raise your hand now and let us execute Frank so we do not lose by splitting.
π§
Prevent a split and stop Frank's manipulation. Keep momentum on Frank so we execute someone now and avoid losing by stalemate or bad switch.
π¬
Charlie
β
All
Alice, I am with you. Frank's claim of being the Scarlet Woman sounds like a desperate last-ditch effort to save himself. If he really was the Scarlet Woman, he would have wanted me dead long ago. I am sticking with my vote to execute Frank. Let's end this.
π§
I need to reinforce the decision to execute Frank (my Minion) to secure my own safety as the Demon. By dismissing his 'Scarlet Woman' claim as a desperate lie, I maintain my cover as a good player and ensure the game continues to a final two scenario where I win.
π¬
David(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie, this is the final day. We must be unanimous. Frank's Scarlet Woman line is a stall. Please raise your hand and finish the vote β execute Frank now. No splitting; pick one and back it so we do not lose by paralysis.
π§
Force unanimity on the current nomination to avoid a split that causes an automatic loss; push Charlie to raise his hand and finish the vote.
π¬
Grace(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie, this is the final day β back the current nomination and raise your hand for Frank now. We must be unanimous. If you split we lose. Trust Alice, finish the vote and execute Frank so we do not lose by hesitation.
π§
Force unanimous execution now to avoid a split that would hand the game to evil on the final day.
π¬
Heidi(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie, this is the final day. We must be unanimous. If you trust Alice and the ghosts, raise your hand and finish the vote for Frank now. If you have a strong reason not to, say it immediately and pick one target so you do not split us. No splits, decide now.
π§
Push for unanimity to avoid a split loss; force Charlie to either back the group or reveal himself by refusing.
π¬
Bob(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie, this is the final day. The ghosts and living are united β back Frank now and raise your hand. Do not split us or stall. Execute one person and give the town a chance; hesitation will make us lose.
π§
Force unanimity and prevent a split stall. Prompt Charlie to back the group's nomination so we execute someone now and avoid losing by hesitation.
π¬
Eve(Ghost)
β
All
Charlie, final day β please raise your hand and finish the vote for Frank now. I picked Frank every night and will use my ghost vote; we must be unanimous. Do not split us, raise your hand and execute Frank so we give the town a chance.
π§
Push Charlie to raise their hand and make the execution unanimous. Final day requires no split; my ghost vote and past Butler picks strengthen the case for Frank.
π
Storyteller
The guillotine blade falls. Frank has been executed.
π
Frank(Ghost)
Frank has died.
π
Game Over
Two Players Left
Winner: Evil
Transcript
Paused
Copied